£k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

21

Transcript of £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

Page 1: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

���������������� ����������������� ������������������� �������� � � !��� "#�$���

%'&)('*,+�-/.1032546*879;:=<?>A@B>ACD>�E8FHG�IKJL</@�M?C�F�N�IPOF)QSRT@�M?C�F

U�:D@WV'F?RX</@Y>ZOF[E8FH\�QSC]VL^S@W:_'`�a IZF?bc@W:dESC!efJ a)g Q6>WRhQS:

ikjml'n)o=p5\qQSCrVS^S@A:=j g ^Lj�stF?C]V'F ` i�u�\�vw98U�xy�*87h&z-/*Z&{7)|�}�~��S�K�=�'���r���K���r���B�D�8�����]����}8�

� &3�1&z�D��46*Z&'|��8�)�X�3�������L�8�6�6��D(��|��8�)�X�3�������6�����{�

  �¡('*£¢]4'¤S('�¥¦F¨§Z^SRz>Ab#F?:©>�Qmª�G�IKJL</@ a <s«FX¬ ­=QSRX®dU�:D@AVLF?RX<T@B>AJo°¯£^S<TIK@W:r±6>�QS:£G g ^ a F

stF?¬ ­DQSRX® ` s�­²lK³K³K³'n´U�µZ¶y�*K7/&z-h*Z&z7)|�·r�L¸]�]�]���K�8�����]¹6�� &3�1&z�D��46*Z&'|��X�º�r�»�»�¨¼6¼'½��º�6�6�S¼

�D(��|¾�X�º�r�»�»�¨¼6¼K¿»���8�D�zÀ

ÁÂ(L-h0X�Ã�»¿]Ä��3¼'¼6¼Å �Æ.ÈÇK�K7T�ÊÉ#-;&zËr. Å &3Ì£Í�4ÎË6&)2ÐÏ©&z-��DÄ$�3¼6¼6¼

2Ñ. Å;Å .Æ*ZÇc-;&zÒA&z-;&)*�0{&t('Ì�ÌZ&3ÌÓ%6Ô�*Z&Ñ�3ÀZÄ=�L�'�6�

� 4Õ(L����&»(L-�.Æ*ÖN�IZF#×�:F#eØC g >ACrRhF»Ù�¶ e�QS:DV'F?RX<{^6>A@YQS:Ã^8ÚhQSCD>�µ a @�F?: a F6Ä&)Ì�.Ê7/&3ÌÛÏ8ÉÛ%K()É�ÜÝ(LÏD.1*ZÇ6&3-�('*�Ì£ÞP(L-;-mÉ£ßk46�Æ�1.Æ* Å

àBá *�.ÊËK&z- Å .Ê7âÉ#4LÒ�ßk��.Æ03(LÇK4äã�-;& Å;Å Ä��L�6�D�)å

Page 2: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

� ��������� � �������������������������� !�"�����$#%�� &�'�

(*),+�-/.0+1.2+�34+658749:+�;=<4>�?�>@-A<B3DCFE,GH<B+1<B>�<B),CI7�J@>@KIG,LM+:N�>@G,3OCFL�LM+�;,CP5Q<B+&3D+R58?S<BCI>@-/.0587�T(U+�;,CF;V-,>8<W.058-A<�5YXD7D?�CF+�-,?�+Z.[583D\]CF-V<4),+_^`3D7D<�a,KF58?�+:Nb74>c.�)Ade7D),>@G,KI;e.0+ -f>g.h.058-A<ai+R58?�+kjV(=+l;f>@-nmo<�.[58-A<p56<434G,?�+l+�CI<4),+�3�qsrb)f+�74+�583D+!74CILMafKIdt-,>8<�<4),+l34CIu@)A<�?�5:<B+�u@>@34CI+�7wvx>8358-yCF-A<4+�KFKI+�?S<BG`58K0;,CF7D?�G,7D74CF>8-nq]z{-�X|a}+�58?�+�<~5:KF9�74\,N�>@-f+t?�58-�58-,;yL!G,7|<M-f+�u@>8<4CP5:<4+8TWz~m�KFK0u@CIJ8+d@>8G_<B),CI7'58-,;Zd8>@G�u@C�J@+OL�+p<4)`5:<Rq[�0Gf<'<B34GH<B)_?�58-,-,>:<wEi+s-f+�u@>8<4CP5:<4+�;ZCF-�<B),CI7�.05Rd@q�z{-Zv�5:?�<RN58;,>8af<BCI-,u!<B),CI71XD;,CIa,KF>8L65:<4CF?�\p<4+�34L�CF-f>@KF>@u:dl.0>@GfKF;t58L�>@G,-A<[<B>l?�>@-,?�+�;,CI-,ul<B>�>lL!G,?~)�<B>l<B)f+34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7|<�af),CFKI>@74>@af)�dO��vx>@3�.�),CF?~)1CF-A<4+�KFKI+�?S<BG`58K�;,CI74?�Gf7474CI>@-1CF7�-f>8<B),CI-,u�L�>@34+2<B)`58-15�ai>k.0+�37D<434G,u8u@KF+�CF-AJ@>@K�J�CF-,u&5&LMC���<BG,3D+w>8v�ai+�3D74G`587DCF>@-�Nf?�>�+�3D?�CI>@-�58-,;�-f+�u@>8<4CP5:<4CF>@-!� <4)`5:<[.2+w.058-A<<B>�?�34C�<BCF?�CF��+8q&��- <4),+l>8<B)f+�3�)`58-f;nN�.0+1;,>�Ei+�KICF+�J8+lCF- +��f?~),58-,u@+�7s>8v2CF;f+R587�T�<B)f+�74+�74+�3DJ8+1<4>?�KF5834C�v�d]583D+R5871>8vw58u@3D+�+�LM+�-�<658-,;�;,CI7B58u@3D+�+�LM+�-�<�N2<4>�<4+�7|<M<4),+�7D+�76EAdy7DG,E��D+�?S<BCI-,uU<4),+�L�<4>>@E��D+�?�<4CF>@-,7�Nf5:-,;6L�>@34+�u@+�-,+�3458KFK�d!<B>pa,3D>@LM>:<B+'5s?�>@KFKI+�?�<4CIJ8+'7D+R583D?~)6vx>@3<B)f+'<434Gf<4)nq�w-,;�<B)`5Q<CF7[.�)Ad�.2+&5:34+�),+�34+8q

�`>@3�G,7�C�<O58KFK�7D<B583D<4+�;/56vx+�.�d@+�58347p58u@>fT�.2+1.2+�3D+1E}>8<4) a,G,����KF+�;/58-,;�CF3D34CI<B5:<B+�;�EAd�<B)f+a,3D+�J:58CFKICF-,u�af),CFKI>@74>@af)�d!CF-1?�+�3D<~5:CF-�CF-A<B+�KFKF+�?�<4G`58K,?�CF34?�KF+�7�� +�-,?�>@L�a`587D74CI-,usKF5834u8+ba`583D<472>:v�<B)f+)�G,LM58-,CI<4CF+�7�N}58-A<B),3D>@a}>8KF>@u8dt5:-,; 74>�?�CI>@KF>@u:d�>8v�74?�CF+�-,?�+s� .�),+�3D+�EAd 58KIK�v�58?�<47�5834+�XD74>�?�CF58KFK�d?�>8-,7D<434G,?S<B+�;f\,N�7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?p<4),+�>@3DCF+�7w583D+sL�+�3D+�X|L&d�<B),7D\W>@3MXD-`583D3B5:<4CF>@-f74\,N`7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?&;,+�E`5:<B+�7583D+!34+�74>@K�J@+�;�EAd*X|34),+S<B>@3DCF?�\W58-,;�XD+�-,KFCI7D<BCI-,uW5:KFKFCI+�7D\,N�5:-,;�<B3DGf<B) CI7�74CILMa,K�d�CF-A<B+�347DG,E��D+�?S<BC�J@+58u@3D+�+�LM+�-�<�q�z�v�58KIK�<B)fCF7b74+�+�L�7'58-Z>kJ8+�347|<~5:<4+�L�+�-A<RN�?�>@-,74CI;,+�3b<4),+�vx>@KFKI>g.�CI-,ul587D74+�3D<BCI>@-,7�T

� ���� A¡O¢R£k¤�¥�¦�¥¨§�©Mªk«�§¬ �¡~ªk­¬¡~§¬¥�®~£k¤�¯�­¬ªk¯,ªg°¬¥¨§¬¥¨ªg±�°b¥�±W§¬ A¡p°¬®~¥¨¡�±�®B¡�°'¥�°�¥�±�±Aª1²�£�©�£�³,¡�®B§{¡�¦´ ©&«P£k®B§¬µ�£k¤�¡~¢@¥�¦A¡�±�®B¡k¶¸·�� A¡0±�£R§¬µA­|£k¤H²�ªk­D¤�¦s �£k°�£�°¬¹O£k¤�¤�ªk­±Aªg±@ºx¡B»A¥�°{§{¡�±:§�­|ªg¤¨¡2¥�±s§¬ A¡[®Bªg±�°{§{­|µ�®B§¬¥¨ªg±pªk«}°¬®~¥¨¡�±@º§¬¥¨¼�®[½@±AªS²2¤¨¡�¦A¾k¡k¶o¿À ¥�±�®B¡�§¬ A¡s°{¡~§{§¬¤¨¡�¹�¡�±:§'ªk«�£1®Bªg±:§{­¬ªS¢k¡~­|°¬©t¥�°[§¬ A¡MÁDÂRÃ8Ä~Åsªk«Æ0£R§¬µA­¬¡kÇo°�­|¡~¯�­¬¡�°{¡�±:§¬£R§¬¥¨ªg±`ȱAªk§'§¬ �¡&®Bªg±�°¬¡�É:µA¡�±�®B¡kÈ�²�¡&®~£k±_±�¡~¢k¡~­wµ�°¬¡p§¬ A¡&ªgµA§¬®Bªg¹�¡pÊ Æ0£R§¬µA­¬¡pÊ §{ªM¡B»@¯�¤�£k¥�± AªS²�£k±�¦l²Ë :©&£p®Bªg±Q§{­¬ª�¢k¡~­|°{©1 �£k° ´ ¡~¡�±�°{¡~§{§¬¤¨¡�¦`¶oÌÍ ªk­§¬ A¡[­¬¡�¤�£R§¬¥�¢8¥�°¬§[� °¬µ�®| !£k°�ªgµA­|°{¡�¤�¢k¡�°��`§¬ A¡~­¬¡b¥�°�±Aª�°{¡�±�°{¡b£R§{§¬£k®| �¡�¦1§{ª�§¬ A¡b¥�¦A¡�£�§¬ �£R§°{ªg¹�¡6°{§¬£k±�¦�£R­|¦�°pªk­ ´ ¡�¤�¥¨¡~«P°O£R­¬¡6­¬¡�£k¤�¤¨©�­|£R§¬¥¨ªg±�£k¤Ë£k°!¦�¥�°{§¬¥�±�®B§�«I­|ªg¹Î¹�¡~­|¡�¤¨©�¤¨ª@®~£k¤�¤¨©

Ï|Ð�Ñ|ÒÔÓSÑDÕ&Ö�×DØSÙ�ÙgÚRÛ�ÜQÝRÞ�߬ÜàBá}âSãäãæå ÕQçwÖx×4ØSÙg×�Ú,Û�ÜfÝ�ß{Ü&èné âpê�ëQìSãæåæí:îDì~ïðåäâ Õ:ç�ÕgÑDÑDñ ïÔâpò Ñ'ó ì ñgÑSô�õ å Ò�ç ï Ú ïðöQå ç0ç ï�ì~ï Ñ|ó[Ñ|Õ ï2å ç â�÷ Ñ|ÒÔÑDñ ì ç

Û ì Ò ï�â�ø�á}âSãäãäå ÕQçDù å Õ ï Ò â ñ ëQî¬ïðåäâ Õ ïÔâ�ì çðÑ ï�â�ø ç ïðë ñ å Ñ4ç2Ö�ÑDñ åæï Ñ4ñ òRú�ögå óbßûÑ|ó[Û ãäâ~úRå ÕQÓ ïðö ÑËÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ïðåäüRå ç ï�ì ÛgÛgÒ â�ì�î�ö Úì Õ:ñ î¬â Õ:ç ïÔå�ïÔëkï Ñ4ç ögå ç�ç ë ó[ó ì Ò ú'âSøfïÔöQì~ï�ì ÛgÛQÒ â�ìSî�ö�ýgö ÑËñ â ÑDçûÕ â�ï0þÔÿ�������������� ÑDÕQñ â ÒÔçðÑ ïðögå ç ü�å Ñ|éÚ ïðögâ�ë Ó öOì ÕÑ|Õ:ñ â Ò�ç�ÑDó[Ñ|Õ ï ç�ÑDÑ|óbç å ó[Û ãäå Ñ4ñ ò�ú2ïðö Ñ î¬â Õ ï Ñ� ï Ü��RÑ î¬â ÕQñAÚ�é ögåæã Ñ á}â�ãæãäå Õ:ç ì ÛQÛ:Ñ ì Ò�ç ïðâ�å Õ ï Ñ|Õ:ñ ïðögå ç ì çðçðÑ|Ò ïðåäâ Õ ì çì ÕËÑ|ó[Û å Ò å¸î|ìSã�î|ãäìSå ó ìSò:â�ëkï�ïÔö Ñ öQå ç ïðâ Ò ú�â�ø ç î|å ÑDÕ î Ñ�Ú åæï,å çfÛ â çÔç åäògã Ñ ïðö:ì~ï,ö Ñ å Õ ï ÑDÕQñgç å�ï ÕgÑ å�ïÔö Ñ|Ò ì ç ì Õ2Ñ|ó[Û å Ò å¸î|ìSãî¬ã¸ì�å ó Õ â Ò ì ç ì Õ â ÒÔó ì~ïÔåæü Ñ�ÛgÒ å Õ î|å Û ã Ñ â�ø Ñ|Û å ç ï ÑDó â�ãæâ Ó ú Ú ògëgï Ò ì~ïÔö Ñ|Ò ì ç ì ó0Ñ ïðögâ ñ â�ãæâ Ó å¸î|ìSãiå Õ�� ë Õ î¬ïðåäâ Õ ïÔâç âRî|åæâ�ãæâ Ó å ç ï ç â�ø ç î¬å Ñ|Õ î ÑSô0Õ ì ó[Ñ ãäú Ú ïðâsìSî{ï������ ���xïðö Ñ�Õ ì~ïÔë Ò ì�ã é â Ò ã ñ ö:ì�� ñ�� ì çðó ì�ãäã�â Ò2Õ â Õ��FÑ� å ç ï Ñ|Õ ï Ò âSã Ñå Õ ïðö Ñ î|â ÕQç ï Ò ëQî{ïÔåæâ Õ â�ø ç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïÔå�í:î! Õ â é ã ÑDñkÓ�Ñ#"gÚ â Ò å Õ â�ïÔö Ñ|Ò�é â ÒÔñQç ïÔâ$�&%('�)�*Ôþ Ö �ðò Ò ì�î+ Ñ ï "�ß�é öQì~ï Ñ ü ÑDÒûÒ âSã Ñïðö Ñ�Õ ì~ïÔë Ò ì�ã é â Ò ã ñsó ìBúpå Õ ø�ì�î{ï Û ãäìBúOå Õ ïðö Ñ î¬â Õ:ç ï Ò ëQî¬ïðåäâ Õ â�ø ç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïðåæí:î, Õ â é ã ÑDñkÓ�ÑSÜ.-&Ñ'ç ö:ì�ãäãiì ÒÔÓ ë Ñ å Õ�RÑ î{ïðåäâ ÕwÝgÜ0/ ò Ñ ãäâ é ïÔöQì~ï�ïðögå ç ì ÛQÛgÒ â�ìSî�öbå ç�ç�ÑDÒ åäâSë ç ãäú ñkÑ í:î|å ÑDÕ ï1���32bþ�54�)76()8�9):%8�bø�â Ò�ç âkî¬åäâSãäâ Ó å ç ï ç â�ø ç î¬å Ñ|Õ î ÑSÜ

;#< ì�ïðâSë Ò�Öx×DØ�Ù�ÞkÚ�ÛQÛ�ÜQØSØQÚ�/(=SÙ�ß{Ü>�RÑDÑ?� â( ~ì�ã�ì ÕQñ�@�Ò å¸î ó â Õ ï Öx×4ØSØSÙQÚ î�öQì Û�Ü�A�ß ø�â Ò ì ñkÑ ïÔì�åäã ÑDñ�ñ å ç î|ë çðç åäâ Õ�Ü

B

Page 3: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

£k®~®B¡~¯�§{¡�¦6£k°�°¬µ�®D `¶ �À ®~¥¨¡�±�®B¡M¤¨¡~¾g¥¨§¬¥�¹O£R§{¡�°s¥¨§¬°{¡�¤¨« ´ © ¤�¥�±A½@¥�±A¾�¥¨§¬°s¦�¥�°¬®Bª�¢k¡~­|¥¨¡�°O²2¥¨§¬  ¯,ªS²�¡~­�È�£t®Bªg±�±A¡�®B§¬¥¨ªg±²Ë �¥�®D ��QÅ���Å������fÅ4Ä �P±�ªk§p¹�¡~­¬¡�¤¨©�¥�±��HµA¡�±�®B¡�°��'²Ë �£R§O®Bªgµ�±Q§¬°O£k°p­¬¡�¤�¥�£ ´ ¤¨¡s½@±Aª�²Ë¤¨¡�¦A¾k¡¶~¶�¶��

��Gf<�>8vû<B),CI7[CF3D34C�<~5:<4CF>@-M?R58L�+��H>@9Q58Kðmæ7�����������! #"�$&%0a,5834>�;fd�5:3D<BCI?�KI+�58-,;�>@G,3bEi>�>@9�q('*)�5Q<B),+�3<B),58-W34+�a}+�5:<b),+�34+�5:KFK�<B),+w5834u@GfLM+�-�<47[?�>8-�<B58CF-f+�;WCI-W>@G,32E}>�>@9�58-,;�CI-W>8<B)f+�30afG,E,KFCI?R5:<4CF>@-f7,+�N.2+b74)`58KIKH<43Ddp<B>�74GfLMLM5834CI��+2>@G,3�LM58CF-&>@E��D+�?S<BCI>@-,7�<4>�<B),+[<434+�-f;,7CF--��?�CF+�-,?�+.��<BG,;,CI+�7./x>@30�H>21?�CI>@KF>8u8d�>8v3��?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?54�-,>k.�KF+�;fu@+�60KI>H>@7D+�K�d6CI-,74a,CI34+�;�E�d6<B),+tX,��<B34>8-,u87�3D>@u@3458LML�+�\fq�rb),+�74+>@E��D+�?�<4CF>@-,72583D+'+�a,CF7|<B+�LM>@KI>@u@CI?R58Kf58-,;6L�+�<4),>�;,>@KF>8u@CF?�58K:9Q<B),+�34+�vx>834+8N�.2+'.�CIKFK,-,>:<0;,CI74?�G,747Ë),+�3D+<B)f+&;,+S<~58CIKF7'>8vsXD?R5:74+!7|<BG,;,CI+�7D\,q�(*),CIKF+O.0+&;,>W-,>8<w;,+�-Adt<B)`5Q<�CF-A<4+�34+�7D<4CF-,u6.2>@3D9ZLM5RdZ),5kJ8+Ei+�+�-U;,>@-,+1CI-�<4),>@7D+M7|<BG,;,CI+�7�� a`583|<BCF?�G,KP5:34KIdt.�),+�-U<B)f+M5:Gf<B),>8347�J�CF>@KF5:<B+�;�<4),+�CI3�>k.�-=;,+;1?�KF5834+�;WL�+�<B)f>H;,>8KF>@u@CI?R58Kfa,34+�?�+�aH<B7=<[� <4),CF7Ëv�58?�<0;,>�+�7[-,>:<b58-,7|.0+�3b>@G,32>@E��D+�?S<BCI>@-,7[5:CFL�+�;W5Q<<B)f+paf34CF-f?�CFafKF+�7b>:v�<4),+>��<B3D>@-,u8734>@u@3458L�LM+:q

�wJ@+�3!<4),+WKF587D<p<B),3D+�+6d8+R583D7�N.2+�)`5RJ@+Wa`5:3D<BCI?�CIa`5:<B+�;cCF-U-�G,LM+�34>@Gf7!;,+�E,5:<B+�7!.�CI<B)=74>�?�C?1>@KI>@u@CF7|<B7�N�58-A<B),3D>@a}>8KF>@u@CI7D<47�N�a,7|dH?~)f>@KF>@u8CF7D<47�Nûa,7Dd�?~),>@58-`58K�dH7|<B7&58-,;=af),CFKI>@74>@af),+�3D7�q��wKI<4),>@G,u8)<B)f+p3D+R58?S<BCI>@-,7b.0+�34+p+S��<B3D+�L�+�K�d�;,CIJ8+�3D74+8N`.2+s),5kJ8+s3D+�ai+R5:<4+�;,K�d�L�+�<'a}+�>@a,KI+�.�),>�<4),CF-f96<B)`5Q<587D74+�3|<BCI>@-,7&>:vbv�58?�<&58Ei>@Gf<p<B),+W-,5:<BG,3458K.0>834KF;=?R58-cEi+M<434G,+cXDCF-U>@G,3p?�G,K�<BG,3D+�\ 5:-,;=d@+S<lEi+v�58KI74+1CF-�74>8LM+�>8<B)f+�3O?�G,K�<BG,3D+8qA@e(=+�)`5RJ@+MLM+S<pa}+�>@a,KF+l.�),>t7Dd�7|<B+�LM5:<4CF?R5:KFKId_?�>@-HvxG,74+�v�58?�<4758-,;�J:58KFGf+�7�N�<B3DGf<B)f7&58-f;UEi+�KICF+�vx7�N�<B),+1.0>834KF;U58-,;/>@G,3O9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+�>8v[C�<RqCBZ>@3D+�>kJ@+�3�N�.�)f+�-?~)`58KIKF+�-,u@+�;�N�<4),+�dt.�CFKIKn?�>8-,74CI7D<B+�-A<BKIdt;,+�-AdZ<4)`5:<�74G,?~) ;,CI7D<4CF-,?S<BCF>8-,7�L6589:+s7D+�-,7D+8qD�H>@L�+p.�CIKFK?�KF58CFL�<B)`5Q<.�CI<B?~)f+�725834+'587Ë34+�58K�587Ë5:<B>8LM7�NA>@3�a,34+S<B+�-f;M<B>O)`5RJ8+w-,>pCF;,+�5�.�),+�<4),+�3�<B),+FE�583D<4)CF7HG�5:<RNHE,KF>�>�;6?�CI34?�G,KP5:<4+�7[>830<B),+5I034G,7458;,+�7�3D+R58KIKId1<B>�>@91a,KP5:?�+8q0J'>8<B+�<B)`5:<0<B),+�74+�ai+�>@a,KI+�583D+>8<4),+�3|.�CF74+s34+�5874>@-,58E,KF+O3D+�74+�5834?~)f+�347�>83'Gf-,CIJ8+�347DCI<{dta,3D>8vx+�7D74>@3D7�q��wKIK�<4),CF7�CI-,;,CF?�5:<B+�7'<4),+p+S�HCF7�1<B+�-,?�+s>8v5�3B58;fCF?R5:KFKIdM34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7|<'58?R5:;,+�L�CF?>K�+�C�<Bu@+�CF7|<RN,.�),CI?~)_CF7�.2+�CF3D;nq ·�L rû>6Ei+s7DG,34+:Ni<4),+�7D+583D+�>@3B58K}7D<B5:<B+�LM+�-�<47bL65:;,+�CF-�7D+�L�CF-`5:347[>@30a,34C�J85Q<B+�;,CI74?�G,747DCF>@-nN,58-,;�>@3B5:K�7D<B5:<B+�LM+�-A<B7�G,74GM158KIKId�<B+�-f;�<4>1E}+�L�>@34+�3458;,CI?R58Ki<B)`58-�.�3DCI<4<4+�-�>@-,+�7�q2�0Gf<b<4),+�a,G,E,KICF7D),+�;�.�34C�<4<4+�-t58747D+�3|<BCF>8-,7N G,>8<4+�;tCF-�<B),+Oa,3D+�?�+�;,CI-,uMa,583B58u83B58a,)t583D+p58KF3D+R58;fd N G,CI<4+O.2+�CI34;nq ·{·

O @ ì ÒÔÕgÑDç ì ÕQñ @ ãäâRâ Ò�Öx×4ØSÙQ×SÚRÛ�Ü�/�ÞSß{Ú î|ãäì Ò åæí:îDì~ïðåäâ Õ ì ñgñgÑDñ ò�ú�ë çDÜP�Q�Ò â Õ â é åæïSR Ö�×DØSÙ�ÙgÚRÛ�Ü /�T8ARß{ÚRÑ|ó[Û öQì ç å ç å Õ ïÔö Ñ â Ò å Ó å Õ ì�ã ÜU7� â( ~ìSã Öx×DØ�Ø�V�ß{Ú � â( ~ìSã�ì ÕQñ @}Ò å¸î ó â Õ ï Öx×DØ�ØSÙ�ß{Ü2è öQâSë Ó ö ñkÑ ãæåäò ÑDÒ ì�ï Ñbç ì~ïðå ÒÔÑ2ó ìBú çðÑ|Ñ|ó ïÔâ�ò Ñ ì é ì Ò ãäå Ñ

ïÔì�î{ïÔåäî Úgé}Ñç ögâSëQã ñwç ï ÒðÑ4çðç ïÔöQì~ï�ïÔö Ñó ì�å Õ�ÒÔÑ ì ç â Õ ø�â Ò ë ç å ÕgÓ ïðögå ç ïÔâ�â�ã é ì ç ïðâ[ø�â Ò î Ñ ì0ögâ ÕgÑDç ï ñkÑ òQì�ï Ñ�é ögå¸î�öçðÑ|Ñ|ó[Ñ4ñ ògãäâkî+ Ñ4ñAÜ

W �RÑ|Ñ,� â( ~ìSã Öx×4ØSØSÙ�ß ì ÕQñ @�Ò åäî ó â Õ ï Öx×4ØSØSØ�ß{Ü�õ â Ò�ÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ï Ñ4ñ ì ÒÔÓ ë ó[ÑDÕ ï ç|Ú:ç�ÑDÑ!X ì ÓSÑ ã Öx×DØ�Ø�ÞSß{ÚZY ìSìSî+ Öx×4ØSØSÙ�ßì Õ:ñF[ åæïÔî�ö ÑDÒ�Öx×4ØSØSÙ�ß{Ü

\ �RÑ|ÑËÐ å ÕgÓ�Ò ì ç�Ö�×DØ�Ø =Sß ø�â Ò ì0î Ò åæïðå¸î|ìSã�ì Õ ìSãæú ç å ç âSø çðÑ ü Ñ|Ò ì�ã ÒðÑ î Ñ|Õ ïnï ÑDÕQñkÑDÕ î¬å ÑDç å Õ � î¬å Ñ|Õ î Ñ � ïÔë ñ å ÑDçDÜ]Dõ â Ò ì ÕOÑ� ì ó[Û ã Ñ å Õ üSâSãäüRå ÕQÓ ïðö Ñ â Ò å Ó å Õ:ç â�ø X ì~ïÔåæü ÑHQ�ó[ÑDÒ å¸î|ì Õ�Û â Û ëgã¸ì~ïðåäâ Õ:ç|ÚAçðÑ|Ñ!� â ~ì�ã,ì ÕQñ @�Ò åäî ó â Õ ï

Öx×4ØSØ�ÙgÚ�^�Û åäãäâ Ó ë Ñ4ß ì ÕQñ @ â Ó ögâ çÔç å¸ì Õ&Öx×4ØSØ�V�ß{ÜÏ`_#-sÑûÑ|ó[Û öQì ç åaR Ñ ïÔöQì~ï é�Ñ öQìBü ÑnÕ âå ñkÑ ì�öQâ éMé å ñkÑDçðÛgÒÔÑ ì ñ ïÔö ÑDçðÑ�Ñ� ï ÒÔÑ|ó[Ñ�Û â ç å�ïÔåæâ ÕQç ì ÒðÑ�Ü @ ëkï`ïðö Ñ å Ò�ó[Ñ|ÒÔÑ

Ñ� å ç ï Ñ|Õ î Ñ å ç�é�Ñ å Ò�ñ'ÑDÕ âSë Ó ö ÜÏðϬõ â Ò�Ñ� ï ÒðÑDó[Ñ ãäú é�Ñ å Ò�ñ�é�Ò åæï�ï Ñ|Õpç ïÔì�ï Ñ|ó[ÑDÕ ï ç|ÚAçðÑ|Ñ ì�ã ç âbïÔö Ñ2ñ å ç î¬ë çÔç åæâ Õ òRú < ì~ïÔâSë Ò â�ø`ïðö Ñ î|ìSë çðÑDç â�ø`ïðö Ñ

ñkÑ ì~ïðösâ�ø�ïÔö Ñ0Û öQì Ò ì�â�öcb�ì óbçðÑDçed�dËÖ < ì�ïðâSë ÒDÚ,×DØ�ØSÙ�ß ýAì ÕQñ ø�â Ò ì'î Ò åæïðå¸ê�ë ÑSÚAçðÑ|Ñ.� â( ~ì�ã,ì Õ:ñ$@�Ò å¸î ó â Õ ï Öx×4ØSØSÙQÚÕ âSï Ñ[×7/SÝ�ß{Ü

f

Page 4: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

z�v�>@-,+M+�- N G,CI34+�7!58E}>8Gf<s<4),+O�DGf7D<BC�^`?R5Q<BCF>8-,7pvx>83p<4),+�7D+W74G,3Da,34CI74CI-,uZJ�CF+S.�7�N�>8-,+6CI7sCI-�J:583DC?158E,K�d�KI+�;�<B>�<4),+UXDG,74G,58K�74Gf74ai+�?�<474\,TO<B)f+!.�34CI<4CF-,u87�>8v 4OGf),-nN��`+�d8+�3B5:E}+�-,;c58-f; )�>@3|<{d#9�<B)f+G,-,;f+�34;f+�<B+�34L�CF-`5Q<BCF>8-]>8v�<B),+�>@34CI+�7lEAdc;`5Q<~5 9Ë<B),+W<4),+�>@3|d�1{KP5:;,+�-,-f+�7471>8v'>@Ef74+�3|J:5:<BCI>@-�907D>@L�+.�34C�<BCI-,u@7Ë>8vH/x<4),+�KP5Q<B+�3,6(*C�<4<4u@+�-,7|<B+�CF-�9�<B),+WX,��<B3D>@-,u 73D>@u@3B5:LML�+�\sCF-M<4),+�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u8d1>8v�7D?�C?1+�-f?�+8q0�wvû?�>@G,3D74+:N�<4),+�KP5Q<4<B+�3b58Gf<4),>@3D7b;,>1-,>8<�G,7DG`58KFK�dWLM5898+�<4),+�L�>@7D<�3458;,CF?�58K�?�KP58CILM7Ë<B)`5Q<.2+�)`5RJ@+�),+�5834;nq0)'5:<4),+�3�NH.�)`5:<0<{dHafCF?R5:KFKId1),58a,ai+�-,7bCI72<B),5:<[<B)f+�dML6589:+�58L!EfCFu@G,>8G,70>@32?�>@-M1vxG,7D+�;t7D<~5Q<B+�L�+�-A<47'<4)`5:<'583D+�<B),+�-ZCI-�<4+�3Da,34+S<B+�;ZEAd�>8<B)f+�347�CI-Z5l3458;,CF?�58KFK�d�34+�KF5:<BC�J�CF7D<0v�5874),CI>@-nqrb),+�34+�vx>834+8N2>@G,3lu@>@58K[CF-]<4),CF71583|<BCI?�KF+M.�CFKFK2E}+W<4>�;,CF7D+�-A<~58-fu@KF+WJ:583DCF>@G,7l?�>@-fvxG,7DCF>@-f7�?�58G,7D+�;EAd v�5874)fCF>@-`5:E,KF+!CI;,+R5:7pCI- <B),+1?�>8-�<4+�L�a}>83B583|d a,),CIKF>@7D>@a,)Ad�>8v074?�CF+�-f?�+8q*)�>@G,u@),K�d�7Da}+�589�CF-,u,N>@G,3'LM58CF-�<B)f+�74CI7wCI7�<4)`5:<'<B),>874+&CI;,+R5:7�?�>@-A<~58CI-�5198+�3D-,+�K�>8v�<434Gf<4)Z<B),5:<w?�58-_Ei+&Gf-,;,+�3D7D<4>H>�;a,3D>@a}+�34K�d�.�)f+�-�<B),>874+�CI;,+R58705834+�?R583D+�vxG,KIKId1vx>@3DL!G,KP5Q<B+�; 9HE,GH<0<B)f+�-W<B)f+�dWu8CIJ@+�-,>l74Gfa,a}>83D<0<4>3B5:;,CF?�58Kn34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DLZq

��>k.2+�J@+�3�NbEi+�vx>@3D+�u@+�<D<BCF-fu�<4> .0>@3D9�N2.2+t.058-A<M<4>/5kJ8>@CF;�ai>@747DCFE,KI+�LMCI74G,-,;f+�347|<~58-f;,CF-,u8758-,;�<B>1+�LMa,),5874CI��+O74>@L�+�ai>@CF-A<B7[.�)fCF?~)nN,.2+s)f>@a}+:N�5834+�-f>@-,?�>8-�<434>kJ@+�347DCP58KðT

� 6 ��?�CF+�-,?�+2CF7�5�)�G,LM58-!+�-,;,+R5RJ8>@3�N�58-f;&KFCI98+258-Adp>8<B),+�3�)�G,LM58-&+�-,;,+�5kJ8>@3CI<ûL�+�3DCI<B7ûEi+�CF-fu74GfE��D+�?S<B+�;/<B>�3DCFu@>@3D>@G,7�7D>H?�CP58K�58-`58K�d�74CF7�qp(*)fCF?~) 34+�74+�5834?~)Ua,34>@EfKF+�L�7�?�>@G,-A<p587�CFL�ai>@3D<B58-A< 9),>k. 3D+�7D+R583D?~)ZvxG,-,;f7�5:34+�;,CI7D<B3DCFE,GH<B+�; 9f.�),>1u@+�<47�a,34+�7D<BCIu@+O58-,;tai>g.2+�3 9,.�)`5:<�3D>@KF+�7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?+S�Hai+�3|<BCF7D+1a,KP5Rd�7OCF- a,G,EfKFCF?;1{ai>@KFCI?�dt;,+�E`5:<B+�7 9�CF- .�)`5:<�vx>@3DL 74?�CF+�-�<4CI^`?l9�-,>k.�KI+�;,u@+1Ei+�?�>@LM+�7+�L&E}>�;,CF+�;lCF-l<B+�?~),-,>@KI>@u8d8NH5:-,;lvx>@3�.�),>@7D+'Ei+�-f+�^,<� 58KFK�<B),+�74+�CF7D74G,+�705:34+b7D<434>@-fu@KId!5���+�?�<4+�;EAd1a}>8KFCI<4CF?�58KÔNQ+�?�>@-,>@L�CF?b5:-,;�<4>s7D>@L�+b+S��<B+�-�<0CF;,+�>@KF>8u@CF?�58KH?�>@-,7DCF;,+�3B5:<4CF>@-,7�N�587.0+�KFK�587�EAdl<B)f+CF-A<4+�34-,58KnKF>8u@CF?'>8v�74?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?�CF- N GfCF3Dd8q�rb),+Sd�5834+�<4)�G,7bvx34G,C�<4vxG,K}74G,E��D+�?�<47'vx>@30+�L�a,CF3DCF?R5:K}7|<BG,;fdEAd�),CI7D<B>834CP5:-,7�N,7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CI7D<B7�Nfai>@KFC�<BCI?R58K�74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<B7'58-,;t+�?�>@-,>@L�CF7|<B7�q

B 6��[<p5WL�>@34+&74G,Ef<4KF+lKI+�J@+�KÔNn+SJ@+�-/<4),+l?�>@-A<4+�-A<p>8vË74?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?l;,+�E`5:<B+s� .�)`5:<�<{d�a}+�7�>8v<B)f+�>@3DCF+�7w?R58-�Ei+!?�>@-,?�+�CIJ8+�;/58-,;�+�-A<B+�3|<~58CI-,+�;�N�.�)`5:<�?�34C�<B+�3DCP5M5834+p<B>�Ei+&G,7D+�; vx>@3w;f+�?�CI;,CF-fuEi+�<{.2+�+�-=?�>@L�a}+S<BCI-,u�<B),+�>@34CI+�7�� CI7O?�>@-,7|<B3458CF-,+�;UCI-Ua,583D<pEAd <B),+�a,3D+�J:58CFKICF-,u�5Q<4<BC�<BG,;f+�7O>8vL�CF-,;nNA.�),CI?~)�CF-6<4G,34-W5834CI74+wCI-6a`5:3D<0vx3D>@L ;,+�+�a 1{7D+R5:<4+�;�),CI7D<B>834CF?�58K,v�58?S<B>@3D7�qz�<[CI72<4),+w<~5:7491>8v),CI7D<B>834CP5:-,7�58-,;�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CF7|<B7�>8v07D?�CI+�-,?�+1<4>�74>@3|<O>@Gf<RN�CI- +R58?~)/74ai+�?�CI^`?1CI-,7D<B58-,?�+:N�<B),+l3D>@KF+�7a,KF5kd8+�;�E�d X|+S��<B+�34-`58KI\=5:-,; XDCI-A<B+�3D-`58KI\�v�5:?�<B>83471CF-�;,+�<4+�3DLMCI-,CF-,u�<4),+t?�>@G,3D74+Z>8v�7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?;,+SJ@+�KI>@a,L�+�-A<Rq*J�>:<s7DG,34af34CF7DCF-,u8KId@N�7D?�CI+�-A<BCI7D<B7�<4+�-,;/<B>�7D<434+�7D7s<4),+UXDCF-A<B+�34-`5:KF\Wv�58?S<B>@3D7O.�)fCFKF+74>�?�CI>@KF>8u@CF7|<B72<4+�-,;t<B>17D<434+�747�<B),+ZXD+��H<4+�3D-`58KF\fN,CIv�>@-,K�dWEi+�?R5:G,74+p+R58?~)tu@3D>@G,a�<B+�-,;,7�<B>1)`5RJ@+s5ai>H>@3u83B587DaM>@-1<B)f+�>8<4),+�3�u@3D>@G,anm�7�?�>@-f?�+�aH<B7�qË�0GH<Ë<4),+�7D+�af34>@E,KI+�L�7Ë5834+�ai+�3Dvx+�?�<4KId158L�+�-,58E,KF+<B>1345:<BCI>@-`58K};,+�E`5Q<B+8q

f 6brb),+�3D+!CF7'-,>8<4),CF-,u1.�34>8-,u6.�CI<4)_3D+�74+�5834?~)_CF-fvx>@3DLM+�;ZEAd_5Mai>@KFC�<BCI?R58K}?�>@L�LMC�<BL�+�-A<RN�5:7KF>8-,u65:7�<B),5:<�?�>@LML�CI<4LM+�-A<�;,>H+�7w-,>:<�E,KICF-,;�<B),+s34+�74+R5:34?~),+�3w<B>WCI-,?�>8-�J8+�-,CI+�-A<wv�5:?�<B7�q�rb)�G,7�N<B)f+�34+OCI7�51KI>@-,u158-f;Z),>8-,>@3B5:E,KF+�<43B58;,C�<BCI>@-W>8v�74>�?�CI>21{ai>@KFC�<BCI?R58K`?�34CI<4C N G,+�>8v�74?�CF+�-,?�+ · ¿ NfCF-,?�KFG,; 1CF-fu_58-A<4CF3B5:?�CF7|<p?�34C�<BC N Gf+�7p>8vb58-A<4),34>@ai>@KI>@u@CF?�58K�a,7D+�G,;f>21{7D?�CF+�-,?�+W58-,;=+�G,u@+�-,CF?�7!58-,;/vx+�L�CF-,CI7D<?�3DCI<4C N G,+�7w>8v�a,7Dd�?~),>8KF>@u8d�58-,; a`5:3D<B7w>8v�LM+�;,CF?�CF-,+&58-,; E,CI>@KF>8u8d@q�rb),+�7D+l?�34C�<BC N Gf+�7w<{d�a,CI?R58KIKIdvx>@KIKF>k.Y567|<~58-,;,5834; a`5Q<4<B+�34-nT���CI347D<w>@-,+!7D),>k.�7�N�G,7DCF-,u6?�>@-AJ@+�-A<BCF>8-`58K�7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?l5834u8G,LM+�-A<B7�N.�)Ad_<4),+!34+�74+�5834?~)�CF- N Gf+�7D<4CF>@-�CI7FG�5R.2+�; �M������������� % � %� "C�������� � ��� �=� � �����8����M������������"�� ��"�9�<B),+�-nN3� ��� ��� ��� %� "���N�>@-,+!5Q<4<B+�LMaH<B7w<4>W+S�Ha,KF58CF-Z),>k.�<4),+!3D+�74+�5834?~)f+�347�m�74>�?�CF58K�a,34+{��1Ïxà�-sÑ ãæå ó å�ï�âSë Ò�ç�Ñ ãæü ÑDç ö ÑDÒðÑ ïðâ'î Ò åæïðå¸ê�ë ÑDç î�ö:ì�ãäã ÑDÕgÓ å ÕgÓ ïðö Ñ0ç ëQò ç ï�ì Õ ïðåäü Ñ î|â Õ ï ÑDÕ ï�â�ø ç î|å ÑDÕ ïðåæí:î�ïðö Ñ â Ò å ÑDç â Ò

ó[Ñ ïÔögâ ñ âSãäâ Ó ú Ü�� ïðö ÑDÒ å ó[Û â Ò ïÔì Õ ï�ïxú Û:Ñ4ç âSøfî Ò åæïðå¸ê�ë ÑDç î�öQìSãæã Ñ|ÕgÓ�Ñ ïÔö Ñ ë ç�Ñ4ç ïðâ é ögå¸î�ö ç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïðåæí:î3 Õ â é ã Ñ4ñkÓSÑ å çÛ ëkï Ö�ÑSÜ ÓQÜ å Õ ï Ñ î�ö Õ âSãäâ Ó ú ß â Ò ïðö Ñ�ç âkî¬å¸ì�ã ç ï Ò ë:î{ïðë ÒðÑ â�øfïðö Ñ�ç î|å ÑDÕ ïÔå�í8î�î|â ó[ó ë Õ å�ïxú Ü

Page 5: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

G,;,CI?�+�7 /�.�),CF?~)�LM5Rd6.2+�KFK�)`5RJ@+pE}+�+�-�G,-,?�>@-,74?�CF>@Gf7�6[KF+�;�<4),+�L <B>!J�CF>@KF5:<B+�<B),+�74+O?R58-f>@-,7�q2�wv?�>8G,347D+8N�+R58?~)W7DG,?~)6?�34C�<BC N G,+�)`5:7Ë<4>s7|<~58-,;M>@3v�58KFKf>@-MC�<B7�>k.�-6L�+�3DCI<B7 9�)`5RJHCI-,upu@>H>�;1a}>8KFCI<4CF?�58KCF-A<4+�-A<BCI>@-,7l;,>�+�7D-nm�<Mu@G`5:3B58-A<B+�+�<B)`5:<1>8-,+8m�765:-`58KId�7DCF7!.�CFKIK0?�>@-,7D<4CI<4Gf<B+�u@>�>H;y7D?�CF+�-,?�+:N0u@>�>�;74>�?�CI>@KF>8u8d >@3su@>H>�;/),CF7|<B>@3|d@qZ�0Gf<&<4),CF7su@+�-f+�3B5:KË<{.2>21{7|<B+�ay58a,a,3D>A58?~)cCI7�N�.2+M<4),CF-,9�N�7D>@G,-,; 958-,;�+�L�a,CI34CF?�58Kf7|<BG,;fCF+�7�>8v}<B),CI79�CF-,;nN�C�v}?�>@-,;,Gf?�<B+�;6.�CI<4)1;,G,+'CF-A<B+�KFKF+�?�<4G`58Kf3DCFu@>83�N@?�>@G,KF;�74)f+�;G,7D+�vxG,K�KFCIu@)A<�>@- <B)f+�7D>H?�CP58K�?�>@-,;fCI<BCI>@-,7�G,-f;,+�3O.�),CF?~)/u@>�>H; 7D?�CI+�-,?�+ /x;,+�^`-f+�;=-f>@34LM5:<BC�J@+�KId587�<4),+174+R5:34?~)Uvx>83w<B3DGf<B),7O>@3O5Q<OKF+R5:7D<p58a,af34>R�HCFLM5:<B+&<434Gf<4),7p58Ei>@Gf<�<B)f+1.2>@3DKF; 6�CI7�vx>@7D<4+�3D+�;>@3b),CI-,;,+�34+�;�q · Ì

J�>k.ON�.2+!;,>@-�m�<�.[58-A<�<4>W?�KF58CFL <B)`5:<�<B),+�74+&<4),34+�+!ai>@CF-A<B7�+S�H)`58Gf7D<�<4),+&^`+�KF;_>:vvx34G,C�<4vxG,KCF- N GfCF3Dd�vx>83�),CI7D<4>@34CF58-,7'58-,;�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CI7D<B7b>:v74?�CF+�-f?�+8N�E,Gf<w<4),+�dt?�+�3D<B58CF-fKId�;,>MKP5Rd�>@Gf<�5ME,CIu58-,;yCILMai>@3D<B58-A<l583D+R5fq=z{-V58-Ad=?R587D+8N0>8G,3l?�3DCI<BCI?�CI74L�7&>8vD� � 4 5834+�58CILM+�;c>@-,K�d]5:<13458;,CI?R58K+�afCF7D<4+�L�>@KF>8u@CF?�58K�5:-,;�LM+S<B),>�;,>@KI>@u@CF?�58Kû?�KP5:CFL�7�<B),5:<pu@>�v�583�Ei+�d@>8-,;U<4),+�58E}>kJ8+�1{L�+�-A<4CF>@-,+�;<B3DG,CF7DLM7�q

rb),CF7�a`58ai+�3�CF7�>834uA58-fCF��+�;!587ûvx>@KFKI>k.�7�T���CI347D<�>8v�5:KFKÔNg.2+0)`5RJ@+[<4>w?�KF+R5:3û<4),+[+�afCF7D<4+�L�>@KF>8u@CF?�58Ku@3D>@G,-,; /:�H+�?�<BCI>@- B 6Sq J'+S��<RN[.2+Zvx>@3DL!G,KF5:<B+�>@Gf3M>@E��D+�?�<4CF>@-f7M<B>�<B)f+ ��<434>@-,u 734>@u83B58L�LM+/:��+�?�<4CF>@- f 6Sq���-,;�^`-`5:KFKId8Ni.2+l74),58KFKûCF-,;fCF?R5Q<B+O.�)`5:<�.2+!<B),CI-,9t5834+s74>@L�+!ai>@747DCFE,KI+!583D+R587�>8v?�>8KFKP5:E}>@345:<BCI>@-6Ei+�<{.2+�+�-�74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<B7'58-,;t74>�?�CI>@KF>@u8CF7D<470>8v�74?�CF+�-,?�+C/:�H+�?�<4CF>@- � 6�q

� ����� � � ��������� ������� � ���������R�� ����� � !�����

����� ���! #"%$&��'�(*),+.-0/1"2$3"%(*46587 9� +.:1 +;/*+3:<4="%9��>/1"2?@9A��9� B��'%'�/DC��>/�0+�vx>834+�;,CF7D?�G,7D74CI-,uO74>@L�+b74+�34CF>8G,7CF7D74G,+�7ËCI-!<B),+�a,)fCFKF>874>@a,)Ad&>8vi74?�CI+�-,?�+8N�.0+�-,+�+�;1<B>�?�KF+R5:3

>@Gf<�>:vi<4),+b.[5Rdl7D>@L�+b>@KF;l3D+�;1),+�3D34CI-,u@7�q�rb),+b^`347|<�a}>@CI-A<�<B)`5Q<�74),>@GfKF;1E}+b-f>@- 1{?�>@-A<B3D>gJ8+�3D74CP5:KCF7�<4)`5:<�7D>@KFCIa,74CI74L /x<4),+1CF;,+�56<B)`5:<�<4),+�3D+1CF7�-,>:<B),CI-,u�CF-�<4),+l.0>@3DKF;�+S�H?�+�af<pL&d_74+�-f7B5:<4CF>@-,7,658-,;M3B58;fCF?R5:K`7498+�af<BCI?�CI74L /x<4)`5:<2-,>p34+�KICP58EfKF+b9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+'>8v�<4),+'.2>@3DKF;6?�58-6+SJ@+�30Ei+�>@EH<~58CI-,+�; 6?R5:-,-,>8<2E}+'34+SvxGf<B+�;nqz�<[CI7�;,>@G,Ef<DvxG,K`.�),+�<4),+�3[58-Ad@>@-,+�34+�58KFK�dlE}+�KFCI+�J@+�7Ë<4),>@7D+w;,>�?�<434CF-f+�7�� 5Q<KF+�587D<�.�),+�-!?�3D>@747DCF-,uw5�?�CI<{dO7D<434+�+�<û��E,GH<�<4),+�CI3ûCI343D+�vxGf<B58E,CFKICI<{d�CF7û-,+�J8+�3|<B),+�KF+�7D758-sCFL�a}>@3|<~58-A<a,),CIKF>@7D>@a,),CI?R58K�>@E,74+�3DJ:5:<4CF>@-nq �HCI-,?�+�<B)f+&583Du@G,L�+�-A<B7'583D+O7D<~5:-,;`583D;�58-,;tu@>�E`58?~9t5:<�KI+R587|<'<4>��GfLM+:N8.0+0-,+�+�;�-f>8<�3D+�ai+R5:<�<4),+�L�),+�34+8qFE�-fvx>@3|<BG,-,5:<B+�KId@N8L658-Adp>8v`<4),+b583Du@G,L�+�-A<B75:;,;,G,?�+�;CF- v�5RJ@>83s>8v234+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7|<OCF;,+�587p5834+:N�CF-/34+R5:KFCI<{d8N�E`58-`5:K34+�vx>834L!G,KF5:<BCI>@-,7�>:v[3B5:;,CF?�58K�749:+�af<4CF?�CF74LE,Gf<�58afa,KFCI+�;�CF-�G,-g�DG,7D<4CI^�58EfKIdW7D+�KI+�?�<4CIJ8+p.05RdH7�q · �

z{-�<B),+�7B5:LM+�.05Rd�<B),5:<�-,+R5:34KId�+�J8+�3|d@>@-,+2CF-�),CI7n>@3n)f+�3�+�J8+�3Dd�;`5RdOKICIvx+�;fCF743D+�uA5:34;,7�7D>@KFCIa,74CI74L58-,;63B58;,CI?R58K�7D98+�aH<BCF?�CF7DL 58-f;W74ai>@-A<~58-f+�>@G,7DKId658;,>@aH<B7[5�XD34+�58KFCI7D<B\p>@3&XD>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ�CF7|<B\l5:<D<BC�<BG,;,+<B>k.05834;�<B)f+�+���<B+�3D-`58K�.2>@34KI;nN�74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<B7O74ai>@-A<~58-f+�>@G,7DKId�;,>�KICF98+S.�CF7D+lCF-�<B)f+�CF3�af34>8vx+�7474CI>@-`58K.2>@349�qz{-,;,+�+�;nNf74?�CI+�-A<BCI7D<47[3B583D+�K�d1G,74+w<4),+w.2>@34;]XD34+�58KFCI7D<B\fN�Ei+�?�58G,7D+�CI<2CF7�<~589:+�-Wvx>@3Ëu@3458-A<B+�;�TÏ ; � ø}î¬â�ë Ò�ç�Ñ�Ú8é�Ñ2ñ â Õ�ù ï ó[Ñ ì Õ ïÔâ�å ó[Û ãæú�ïÔöQì~ï�ïðö Ñ )8'���� Ö â Ò�Ñ ü ÑDÕpÛgÒ å Õ î¬å Û ì�ã ß�Û ë ÒðÛ â çðÑ âSø�ïðö Ñ ögå ç ïÔâ Ò ú�â�ø

ç î¬å Ñ|Õ î Ñ å ç ïðâ�ö Ñ ã Û0é â Ò �å ÕgÓ�ç î|å ÑDÕ ïðå ç ï ç|Ü Y å ç ïÔâ Ò úâ�ø ç î|å ÑDÕ î Ñ âSòRüRåäâSë ç ãæúö:ì ç å Õ ï Ò å ÕQç åäî�ü~ì�ãäë Ñ ì ç ì�î¬â Õ ï Ò åæògëgïðåäâ Õïðâ�ïÔö Ñ ögå ç ïÔâ Ò ú�â�ø8öRë ó ì Õbç âkî|å Ñ ïxúËì ÕQñ öRë ó ì Õ ïðöQâSë Ó ö�ï Ü @ ëkï�åæï çðÑ|Ñ|óbç ïÔâ�ë ç ïðö:ì~ï�ögå ç ïÔâ Ò ú�â�ø ç î¬å Ñ|Õ î ÑSÚ�é ö ÑDÕñ â ÕgÑ�é}Ñ ãæã Ú î|ì Õ �8�0��)[ö Ñ ã Û�é â Ò �å ÕgÓ[ç î|å ÑDÕ ïðå ç ï ç|ÜÏ O Q�Õ âSïðö ÑDÒ ø�ìBü�â Ò å�ï Ñ ïÔì�î{ïðå¸î ÑDó0Û ãæâ~ú ÑDñ òRú ÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ïÔåæüRå ç ï ç å ç ïÔâ'î¬â ÕHG ì�ï Ñ ø�ì�î{ï ç ì ÕQñ âSë Ò Õ â é ã Ñ4ñkÓSÑ âSøfïÔö Ñ|ó�Ú

Õ âSï�òRú Ó åæüRå ÕgÓ ì Õ úpì ÒÔÓ ë ó0ÑDÕ ï Ú ògëkï ç å ó0Û ãæúOòRúOë ç å ÕgÓ å Õ ï Ñ|Õ ïðåäâ Õ ìSãæãäúOì ó ògå Ó ëgâ�ë ç ï Ñ|ÒÔó å Õ âSãäâ Ó ú Ü �RÑDÑ � â( ~ìSãì Õ:ñ.@}Ò å¸î ó â Õ ï Ö�×DØSØ�ÙgÚ î�ö:ì Û�Ü A�ß ø�â ÒiÑ� ì ó[Û ã Ñ4ç å Õ ïðö Ñ�é â Ò ç âSø [ ëgö Õ�Ú�@ ì ÒÔÕgÑDçJI�@ ãäâ�â ÒDÚ8< ì~ïÔâSë Ò ì ÕQñ�õ âSë ÒÔÑ R Ü

K

Page 6: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

��� ��� � � ��"Z<B),+Sd�.058-A<W<4>c;,CF7D?�>kJ@+�3 /�7D>@L�+�587Da}+�?�<B76>8v�6l),>k.h<B),+Z.0>@3DKF;�34+R5:KFKIdyCI7����w-,;�N>8vË?�>8G,347D+8Nn<B)f+�d�58;f),+�3D+!<B>W<B)f+!74>21�?R58KIKF+�;*XD?�>83434+�74ai>@-,;,+�-,?�+1<B)f+�>@3|d�>8v<434Gf<4),\ · � /ð58u@58CF-nN�5.2>@34;l<B),5:<�CF7�E,5834+�KIdsG,74+�; 6ST�C�v�74>@L�+�>8-,+b7B5Rd�7<B)`5:<�CI<CI7�<B3DG,+[<B)`5Q<�5�u@CIJ8+�-l;,CI74+R5:74+�CF7�?�58G,7D+�;EAd�5�u@CIJ8+�-�J�CF34Gf7�N�74),+1L�+R58-f7O<4)`5:<�N�CF-/58?�<4G`58K�v�5:?�<RN�<4),+1;,CF7D+R587D+�CI7�?R58Gf74+�;UEAd�<B),+lJ�CF3DG,7�q7),CFKI>@74>8a,),+�3D7�>8v�<4+�- 34+�uA583D; 74G,?~) J�CF+S.�7O587�-`58C�J@+:NnE,Gf<�.2+!.2>@G,KF; KICF9:+&<B>W7D),>k. <4)`5:<�<4),+�d583D+s5:?�<BG,58KFK�d N G,C�<B+�;,+Svx+�-,7DCFE,KI+8N,.�CI<4)nN,),>k.2+�J8+�3�Ni74>8LM+OCFL�ai>@3D<B58-A< N G`58KFC�^`?R5Q<BCF>8-,7�q

rb),+/L658CI- >@E��D+�?�<BCI>@-,7�<B>]<4),+�74?�CI+�-A<BCI7D<47�m�74ai>@-A<~58-f+�>@G,7Z5:<D<BCI<4G,;,+ ?�>@-,74CI7D<tCF- J:583DCF>@G,7<B)f+�74+�7M7D),>k.�CF-,u <4)`5:<l<B)f+�>@3DCF+�715:34+�G,-,;f+�34;f+�<B+�34L�CF-,+�;�EAd];,5:<~5fq · ' z{-�C�<B7lL�>@7D<!?�>@L�LM>8-vx>@3DL!G,KP5Q<BCF>8-nNA<B),+�G,-f;,+�3D;,+�<4+�34L�CF-,5:<BCI>@-W<B),+�74CI7b7B5Rd�7�<4)`5:<�Nfvx>@3b58-AdW^,-,CI<4+-/�>@3b+SJ@+�-ZCI-f^`-,C�<B+�674+S<�>8v�;`5:<B5fN`<B),+�34+!5:34+pCF-f^`-fCI<B+�KId6L658-Ad�L!GH<BG`58KIKId6CF-,?�>@LMa,5:<BCIE,KF+�<4),+�>@3DCF+�7'<4)`5:<�5834+_XD?�>@L-1a`5:<4CFE,KI+�\�.�CI<4) <B),>@7D+M;,5:<~5fq�rb),CI7O<4),+�7DCF7�N�C�v0-,>:<saf34>@ai+�3DKId G,-f;,+�3D7D<B>�>�; · +RN�?�58-/+R587DCFKId�KF+R5:;<B>�3B5:;,CF?�58Kn?�>8-,?�KIG,74CI>@-,7�qËrb),+s74?�CI+�-A<BCI7D<�.�),>�E}+�KFCI+�J@+�7'<4)`5:<�51;,CF7D+R587D+sCI7b?R58G,7D+�;�EAdt5lJ�CF34Gf7a,3D+�74GfL658EfKIdZ;,>H+�7�74>�>8-�<B),+!E,5874CI7�>8v�74>8LM+�X|+�J�CF;,+�-,?�+�\�>@3w7D>@LM+ XD;`5:<B58\,qc�f5Rd�CF-fuW<B)`5:<�5;,CI74+R5:74+6CI7O?R58G,7D+�;cEAdU5tJ�CI34G,7pa,34+�74G,LM58E,K�d ?�>8G,-A<B7!5:7&5VX|<B),+�>@3Dd�\ /�+8q�u,q�N�C�<sCI-AJ@>@K�J@+�7�N�CIL-1a,KICF?�C�<BK�d@N@LM58-Ad1?�>@Gf-�<4+�3|v�58?�<4G`58Ki7D<~5Q<B+�L�+�-A<47�6Sq��2Gf<RN�CIv}>@-,+'CF7258E,KI+�<4>&?�>@-AJHCI-,?�+�<B)f+w74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<<B),5:<�<B)f+�34+�5:34+[CI-f^`-,C�<B+�K�dOL65:-�ds;,CI7D<BCI-,?�<�<B),+�>@34CI+�7�<4)`5:<�5:34+[?�>@LMa,5:<BCIE,KF+�.�CI<4)!<B),>@7D+�XD;`5:<B58\,N),+W>83&74)f+WL65Rd�.2+�KFK�.2>@-,;,+�3l>@-=.�)`5:<&E`587DCF7!>@-f+6?R5:-]3B5:<4CF>@-`5:KFKId_?~),>�>@74+WEi+�<{.2+�+�-]<B),>@7D+<B)f+�>@3DCF+�7�q

z{-�>@3D;,+�3'<B>6?�KP583DCIv�dW<4),+&7DCI<4G`5:<BCI>@-nN�CI<�CF7'CFL�ai>@3D<B58-A<b<B>WG,-f;,+�3D7D<~5:-,; ),>k. <B),+sG,-,;,+�34;,+;1<B+�34L�CF-`5Q<BCF>8-W<B),+�74CF7�CI7'+�7D<B58E,KFCI74),+�;�9,<B)f+�-nN�CI<47bLM+�58-,CI-,u�58-,;tCI<B7�KICFL�CI<~5Q<BCF>8-,7�E}+�?�>@L�+OL!G,?~)?�KI+R583D+�3�q ��+�34+65834+174>8LM+�+S�f58L�a,KF+�7O>8v[),>k. G,-f;,+�3D;,+�<4+�34L�CF-,5:<BCI>@- .0>@3D9�7 9>@-,+�LM5kd�?�KP5:CFL<B),5:<RT

� rb),+Ma`587|<!;,CI;U-,>:<&+��fCI7D<�T&<B),+MG,-,C�J@+�3D74+6.0587s?�34+�5:<B+�;=^,J8+6L�CF-�Gf<B+�7&5:u@>�58KI>@-,u�.�CI<4)58KIK�<B)f+�;f>H?�G,LM+�-A<B7O58-,;U58KIK�>@G,3�L�+�L�>@3DCF+�7�34+Svx+�343DCF-,u�<4>�<4),+la`587|<pCF-�<B)f+�CF3�af34+�7D+�-A<p7D<B5:<B+:q�wK�<B+�34-`5:<4CIJ8+�KId8N,CI<[?�>@G,KI;�)`5RJ@+pE}+�+�-_?�34+�5:<B+�; ����� >83 ������� d@+�58347�58u@>fq

� rb),+07D<~5:347�;f>w-,>8<�+S�HCI7D<RTûCF-f7D<B+�58;nNQ<B),+�34+[5:34+07Da}>:<B7�>8-!5�;fCF7D<B58-A<�7D9Ads<4)`5:<�+�L�CI<�+S�f58?�<4KId<B)f+p7458L�+�74CFu8-`58KF7�5:7�<4),>@7D+O.2+O34+�?�+�C�J@+:q� �wKIK�?�34CILMCI-`58KF7b+SJ@+�3�a,Gf<�CI-��458CIK�.2+�3D+!CF-f-,>H?�+�-A<Rq���>83�+�58?~)�58KFKI+�u@+�;_?�34CFL�CF-,58KÔN`+��fafKP58CI-5R.[5Rdp58KIK:<4+�7D<4CFL�>@-Ad�EAdO5b;,+�KFCFEi+�345:<B+�;,+�7DCF34+<4>'),5834L�<B),+Ë58?�?�G,7D+�;�9@;f+�?�KF5834+�<4)`5:<û58KIK@+�J�CI;,+�-,?�+

.0587'v�5:E,34CI?R5:<4+�;�EAd�<B),+Oai>@KFCI?�+�5:-,;t<4)`5:<'58KIKn?�>8-fvx+�7D74CF>8-,7b.0+�34+p>@Ef<~5:CF-,+�;tEAd�vx>@3D?�+:q · <�wv}?�>@G,3D74+8N�5:KFK�<B),+�74+�X|<4),+�7D+�74\OLM5Rds),5kJ8+[<B>�Ei+[+�KF58Ei>@3B5:<4+�;nN:E,Gf<�<4),+[E`5:74CF?0CF;,+�5wCF7�?�KF+�583�T

u@C�J@+�-Z58-Ad�74+S<w>:v�v�58?S<B7�N8�DG,7|<wLM589:+pGfa�517D<B>83Dd@N�-,>�LM5:<4<4+�3b),>k. � � � ���:N,<B>=X458?�?�>@Gf-�<4\�vx>83<B)f+Ov�5:?�<B7b.�C�<B),>@GH<�34G,-,-fCF-,u1CF-A<4>�?�>@-A<B3458;,CF?S<BCI>@-,7�q · @Ï P�-sÑé âSëQã ñ�Õ â�ï Ñ ü Ñ|Õ î|ìSãæãAåæï�ì �xïðö Ñ â Ò ú " ý Ò ì~ïðö Ñ|Ò4Ú�é�Ñ î¬â ÕQç å ñkÑDÒ åæïûì ��*ðþ+�+)�' 6�����)�' ��)�*?54gþ?�'��þ�����&%(������� �

â�ø`ì çÔçðÑ|Ò ïðåäâ ÕQç ì�ò8âSëkï�ïÔö Ñé â Ò ã ñAÜÏ U � ø¨ï ÑDÕ îDì�ãäã Ñ4ñ ïÔö Ñ� ëQö Ñ|ó@I � ëQå ÕgÑ ïÔö ÑDç å çDÜ d�Õwé öQì~ï�ø�â�ãæãäâ é�ç|ÚRé�Ñ�é åæãäã ÒðÑ ø Ñ|Ò ïðâ � ëgå ÕgÑ�ù ç ü Ñ|Ò�ç åäâ Õ&Ö�� ëgå ÕgÑSÚ

×DØ�Ù�T�ß{ÚRé ögå¸î�öwå çnó ë:î�ö ó â ÒÔÑ�Ò ì ñ å¸î|ì�ã@ïÔöQì Õ� ëgö Ñ|ó�ù ç|ÜÏ W��`ì Ò ïðå¸î¬ëgã¸ì Ò ãäú�î¬â Õ î ÑDÒðÕ å ÕgÓ ïÔö ÑËó[Ñ ì Õ å ÕgÓ âSø`ïðö Ñ2é â ÒÔñ �Ôî¬â ó[Û ì�ïðåäògã Ñ#"gÜ �kÑ|Ñ ìSã ç â < ìSë ñ ì Õ1Öx×DØ�Ø�T ò ß ø�â Ò ì

ó â ÒÔÑñkÑ ï�ì�åäã Ñ4ñ�ñ å ç î¬ë çÔç åäâ Õ�ÜÏ \ � øiî¬â�ë ÒÔçðÑSÚ ïðögå ç ã¸ì~ïðï Ñ|Ò�ç åæïðë:ì~ïðåäâ Õ�Ú ë Õ ãäå Ñ ïÔö ÑËÛgÒÔÑ üRåäâSë ç ï é â Ú 6()4þ���âRîDî¬ë Ò ø ÒðÑ ê�ë Ñ|Õ ïðãäú Ñ|Õ â�ë Ó ö Ü @ ëkï�åæï ç

âkî|î|ë ÒðÒÔÑ|Õ î Ñ â ÒiÕ âSï ñkÑDÛ:ÑDÕQñgç â Õ ïÔö ÑûÛ ì Ò ïÔåäî|ëgã¸ì Ò îDì çðÑSÚ�é ögåäã Ñ ïðö Ñ ë ÕQñkÑ ï Ñ|Ò�ñkÑ ï Ñ|ÒÔó å Õ ì~ïðåäâ Õ ïðö Ñ4ç å ç å ç ì %�þ�'8þ�* �8�ÛgÒ å Õ î¬å Û ã Ñó[Ñ ì Õ ïnïðâbì ÛgÛ ãæú'ïðâ ����`î|ì ç�Ñ4ç|ÜÏ ] d�Õ ïÔö Ñ ø�ì ó â�ë ç�Û ì Û8Ñ|Ò å Õ&é öQåäî�ö � ëgå ÕQÑ[çðÑ ï ç ø�â Ò ïðöpïðö Ñbó â ñkÑ|ÒÔÕ ü Ñ|Ò�ç åäâ Õ â�ø�ïÔö Ñ ë ÕQñgÑ|Ò�ñkÑ ï Ñ|ÒÔó å Õ ì�ïðåäâ Õ

Page 7: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

z�<wCI7�CILMai>@3|<~58-A<[<4>634+�58KFCI��+�<B),5:<�<B),CI7�CI7�5:KFKn<B)f+�34+pCF7b<4>M<B)f+su@+�-,+�3458KH/ � G,CI-,+R58- 6�G,-f;,+�3�1;,+S<B+�3DLMCI-`5:<4CF>@-t<B),+�74CF7�qcBZ>@3D+�>kJ@+�3�Nn<4),CF7'<B),+�74CF7�N�58K�<B),>@Gfu@)�CI<�a,KF5kd8+�;�58- CILMai>@3|<~58-A<'34>@KI+&CI-<B)f+�34+SvxGf<~5:<4CF>@-M>8v�<B)f+�LM>87D<[+���<B34+�LM+�J8+�3D74CF>8-,7[>8v�KI>@u@CF?�58K�a}>874CI<4CIJ�CF7DLZNACI70-,>:<[J@+�3DdW;fC �}+�34+�-A<vx34>8L <B)f+p>8E,74+�3DJ:5:<BCI>@-�<B)`5Q<�3B58;,CI?R58K�7498+�af<BCI?�CI74L >@3b+SJ@+�-_74>8KFCFaf74CF7DL ?�58-,-,>8<�Ei+O34+SvxGf<B+�;nTË58KFK>@G,3�9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+s58Ei>@Gf<b<B)f+p.2>@34KI;ZCI7bE`587D+�;_>8-Z7D>@LM+O7D>@3D<'>8v�CF-fvx+�34+�-f?�+Ovx34>@L <B),+p>@E,7D+�3DJ8+�;<B>t<B),+�G,-,>8E,74+�3DJ@+�;nNË58-,;U-,>_7DG,?~)cCF-Hvx+�34+�-,?�+M?R58-UE}+��DG,7D<4CI^`+�;=EAd/;,+�;fG,?�<4CIJ@+6KF>@u@CI?158KF>8-,+8q��>k.2+�J8+�3�N�C�<'CF7w?�KF+�583'<4)`5:<�N}CI-_a,3458?�<4CF?�+:N�-,>8E}>�;fd�+�J8+�3w<B5898+�7�74+�34CF>8G,74K�d�74G,?~)�X|<4),+�>834CF+�74\�5:7<B)f>@74+'LM+�-A<BCF>8-,+�;�58Ei>kJ@+8NH58-Ad1L�>@34+[<4)`58-1<B),+Sdl<~589:+�7D+�34CI>@G,7DKIdl7D>@KFCIa,74CI74L >833B58;,CI?R58K`7D98+�af<BC 1?�CI74Ltq���+�<ËG,7�?�58KFKf<4),+�7D+MXD?�3458��dl<4),+�>@3DCF+�74\ ¿ L /�>8v}?�>8G,347D+8N�CI<�CI7-,>8<�+R5:7Ddl<B>O745kd1+��f58?�<4KId!.�)`5Q<CI<&LM+�58-,7&vx>83l5Z<B)f+�>@3|d=<B> Ei+W-,>8- 1{?�3B58�Sd 6�q J�>8<4+6<B)`5Q<!<B),+�74+�<B)f+�>@3DCF+�7&34+ N G,CI34+W-f>�.0>@3D9�T<B)f+�d�?�58-�E}+!vx>834L!G,KF5:<B+�;�+�-A<4CF34+�KId �����;�:���;�~q!��- <B),+l>:<B),+�3�)`58-,;�Nn<B),+l;,C���?�G,K�<�a,34>8E,KF+�LZNu@C�J@+�-Z74>@L�+p74+�<�>8v�;`5:<~5HNiCI7b<B>M^,-,;_+SJ@+�- >8-,+s-f>@- 1{?�3B58�Sd�<B),+�>@3Dd�<4)`5:<w58?�?�>@G,-A<B7'vx>@3b<B),+�LZqI0>@-,7DCF;,+�3�N�vx>@3+S�f58L�a,KI+8N�5pai>@KICF?�+0+�- N G,CI3Dd�58Ei>@Gf<Ë74>8LM+�?�3DCFL�+8TûCI<ËCF7+�587Dd1+�-,>@G,u8)M<B>pCF-AJ8+�-A<5&7|<B>@3|dM<4)`5:<�X45:?�?�>8G,-A<B70vx>@3Ë<B),+�v�58?�<474\lCF-W58- � � � ����v�5:74),CI>@- /�7D>@L�+�<BCILM+�70KF5k.bd8+�3D7[;,>��DG,7|<<B),5:<;6;9,.�)`5:<'CF7b)`5:34;tCF7[<B>1;,CI74?�>gJ8+�3�.�),>�34+R5:KFKId6?�>@L�L�CI<4<4+�;W<4),+O?�34CILM+O5:-,;�<B>�>@Ef<~5:CF-�+�J�C?1;,+�-,?�+s;,+�L�>@-,7|<B3B5Q<BCF-fu1<4)`5:<�Ei+�d8>@-,; 5134+�5874>@-,58E,KF+O;,>8G,Ef<RqH)�+ G`+�?�<BCI-,u�>@-t<4),CF7�+�KF+�L�+�-A<B583Dd+S�f58L�a,KI+[?�KF5834C�^`+�7�<4),+bL�+R58-,CI-,u�>8v�<4),+bG,-,;,+�34;,+S<B+�34L�CF-`5:<4CF>@-s<B),+�74CF7�q���+�7Da,CI<4+0<B)f+b+S�HCF7|<B+�-f?�+>8v�CI-,-�G,L�+�3B5:E,KF+�XD?�3B58�Sd1<B),+�>@34CI+�74\s?�>@-f?�+�3D-,CF-fu!58-Ad�u@CIJ8+�-M?�34CILM+:N�CI<Ë74>@L�+�<4CFL�+�7�)`58afa}+�-,70CI-a,3458?�<4CF?�+O<B),5:<�<4),+�3D+sCI7w51G,-,C N G,+s<4),+�>@3|d /�Cðqæ+:q}5�G,-,C N Gf+s7|<B>@3|d_5:E}>@GH<'.�)f>6?�>8LML�CI<D<B+�;�<B)f+?�3DCFL�+p58-,;_)f>g.F6b<B)`5Q<wCI7� �?� � ���� ��"&58-,;Z?�>@L�a`5:<4CFE,KI+�.�CI<B)t<B),+p9�-,>k.�-�v�58?�<47 9iCF-�<B)`5Q<w?�5874+:N>@-,+�.�CIKFK�745RdW<B)`5Q<b<B),+O?�3DCFL�CF-`5:K})`5:7'Ei+�+�-Z;fCF74?�>kJ@+�3D+�; /x.�CI<4)t51)fCFu@)�;,+�u@34+�+p>:v�?�>@-f^`;,+�-,?�+:N58KIE}+�CI<'-,>8<�.�CI<B)_?�+�3|<~58CI-A<{d 6�q�z�<�LM5Rd_5:KF74>M)`58a,ai+�-�<4)`5:<w-,>Wa,KF58G,74CIE,KF+O<B)f+�>@3|dZCI7�vx>@Gf-,;nN�>83<B),5:<&.2+�583D+6G,-`5:E,KF+�<B>�;,+�?�CI;,+M.�),CI?~)]>@-,+658LM>8-,u_7D+�J@+�3B58K074G,7Da}+�?�<B7lCI7&3D+R58KIKId u@GfCFKI<{diTlCI-<B)f+�74+p?R5:74+�7�N`<B),+OG,-,;f+�34;f+�<B+�34L�CF-`5Q<BCF>8-�CF7�34+�58KÔq

��� � ��+3 + � 9 " /D"%?@9�(�?�� /*:<70/1C(*),+�-cv�5:?�CF-fuZ<B)f+6a,3D>@E,KF+�LM7p?R5:G,74+�;]E�dUG,-,;f+�34;f+�<B+�34L�CF-`5Q<BCF>8-nN�>8-,+6LM5RdUEi+M<4+�L�af<B+�;

EAd�5&3458;,CI?R58K�<BG,3D-nT�(*)`5:<b58E}>8Gf<b58E,58-,;,>@-fCF-,u&<4),+�-,>:<BCF>8-6>8vwX|<434Gf<4),\l5871X|?�>@3D34+�7Da}>8-,;,+�-f?�+.�CI<4)_3D+R58KICI<{d�\,N�58-,;Z74+�+�9�CF-,u6CF-,7|<B+R5:;�58-_58KI<4+�34-,5:<BC�J@+p-,>8<BCI>@-t>8v�<B3DGf<B)`jUrb),+�3D+!583D+!5:<'KI+R587|<<{.2>s?�G,343D+�-A<BK�dlv�5874),CI>@-`58EfKF+[a,3D>@ai>@7B58KI7>8v�<4),CF79�CI-,;nT�>8-,+�CF7�<B>O;,+S^`-,+�<B3DGf<B)1<B),3D>@G,u@)�Gf<4CFKFC�<{d>@3�?�>@-AJ@+�-fCF+�-f?�+8N�<4),+�>8<B),+�3�CF7�<B>y;,+S^`-,+/CI<�<B)f34>@G,u8)�CI-A<B+�3D74G,E��D+�?�<4CIJ8+c58u@3D+�+�LM+�-�<�q rb),+a,),CIKF>@7D>@a,),+�3 )'CI?~)`583D; )�>@3|<{d�> �}+�347�+��,5:LMa,KI+�7b>8v�Ei>8<B)nT

�  �£R§s¯,¡~ªk¯�¤¨¡M¤�¥¨½k¡���µ� �±`È��0¡~­¬­|¥�¦�£t£k±�¦�� ´ ¡�¤�¥�¡~¢k¡�¥�°s§¬ �£R§s¥¨§&¥�°O¯,ªg¥�±:§¬¤¨¡�°¬°p§{ª_£k°¬½²Ë A¡~§¬ A¡~­�§¬ A¡~­¬¡2­¬¡�£k¤�¤¨©O£R­|¡0¹�ªgµ�±Q§¬£k¥�±�°�ªk­�²Ë A¡~§¬ A¡~­�¥¨§�¥�°�¹�¡~­|¡�¤¨©O®Bªg±Q¢k¡�±�¥¨¡�±Q§�«Fªk­�µ�°�§{ª§¬£k¤¨½!£ ´ ªgµ�§�¹�ªgµ�±:§¬£k¥�±�°~¶ ¿ ·

ïðö ÑDç å çDÚ ö ÑbÑ ü ÑDÕ ìSãæãäâ é�ç ögå óbçðÑ ãæønïðâ�î�öQì ÕQÓSÑ ïðö Ñbó[Ñ ì Õ å ÕgÓ�ç âSø é â Ò�ñgç ì Õ:ñ ïÔö ÑbÒ ëgã Ñ4ç â�ønãæâ Ó å¸î Ú å Õ â Ò�ñkÑ|Ò ïÔâç ögâ é ïÔöQì~ïûì Õ ú ç ïÔì�ï ÑDó0ÑDÕ ïûî|ì Õ ò Ñ ö Ñ ã ñ ï Ò ë ÑSÚ �Ôî¬â ó0Ñ�é öQì�ï ó ìBú "wÖ�� ëgå ÕgÑ�Ú�×DØ�Ù�T�߬Üà�_ ��ÒDÚ ì ç ïðö ÑÛ ö�ú ç åäî|å ç ï ìBüRå ñ���Ñ|ÒÔó å Õ î|ìSãæã ç ïðö ÑDó�Ú � ëgö ÑDó,I � ëgå ÕgÑó â ÕQç ï Ò â ç å�ïÔå Ñ4ç "wÖ��OÑ|ÒÔó å Õ�ÚA×4ØSØSÙ�ß{Üà�Ï b�â Ò ïxú Öx×DØ�ØSÙQÚ�Û�Ü�Þ(/S߬Ü��RÑ|Ñ ì�ã ç â!ïÔö Ñ î Ò å�ïÔåäê�ë Ñ4ç òRú X ì Ó�Ñ ã Öx×DØ�Ø�ÞkÚ�ÛQÛ�Ü /SÙ IkÝ�T�ß ì ÕQñ Q ãæò Ñ|Ò ï Ö�×DØSØ�Ù�ß ý

ì Õ:ñwçðÑ|Ñ3Y ìSìSî+ Öx×DØ�Ø�ÞSß ø�â Ò ì Õ�Ñ|Õ ï Ñ|Ò ïÔì�å Õ å ÕgÓ î¬â Õ ï Ò ì ç ïnò Ñ ï é�Ñ|Ñ|Õ ïÔö Ñ ï é â Ò ì ñ åäîDì�ãäãæú ñ åæ÷ Ñ|ÒÔÑ|Õ ï�� ÛgÒ ì Ó�ó ì~ïðå ç ï "Û ögåäãäâ ç â Û ögå ÑDç âSø`á Ü0�@Ü � Ñ å Ò î Ñ ì ÕQñ âSø b�â Ò ïxú Ü

Page 8: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

�  �¥�¤¨ªg°{ªk¯� A¡~­D°`ªg±�¹'©'°|¥�¦A¡ûªk«�§¬ A¡�£R­|¾gµ�¹�¡�±:§�£k±�°¬²�¡~­n§¬ �£R§nª ´�� ¡�®B§¬¥¨¢@¥¨§�©'¥�°}±Aªk§n£0¹O£R§{§{¡~­ªk«H®Bªk­¬­|¡�°{¯,ªg±�¦�¥�±A¾2§{ªbª ´�� ¡�®B§¬° ´ µA§n£b¹O£R§{§{¡~­�ªk«H¾k¡~§{§¬¥�±A¾b§{ªk¾k¡~§¬ A¡~­�²2¥¨§¬ wªk§¬ A¡~­�°¬µ ´�� ¡�®B§¬°Ê §¬ �£R§�§¬ �¡~­¬¡'¥�°±Aªk§¬ �¥�±A¾�§{ªOª ´�� ¡�®B§¬¥¨¢@¥¨§�©!¡B»A®B¡~¯�§Ë¥�±:§{¡~­|°¬µ ´�� ¡�®B§¬¥¨¢@¥¨§ð©k¶ ¿{¿

�HCILMCIKP583�J�CF+S.�7�5834+w+S�Ha,34+�747D+�;_EAd674>@L�+�>8v�<B)f+wvx>@G,-,;f+�347b>:vû<4),+c��<434>@-fu-7�3D>@u@3458LML�+'CF-W<B)f+74>�?�CI>@KF>8u8d6>:v�7D?�CF+�-,?�+:T

�� A¡6­¬¡�¤�£R§¬¥¨¢@¥�°{§~È2¤�¥¨½k¡6¡~¢k¡~­¬©kªg±A¡�¡�¤�°{¡kÈ0¥�°!µ�±�¦A¡~­&§¬ A¡�±A¡�®B¡�°¬°|¥¨§�©U§{ª�°¬ªk­¬§!ªgµA§ ´ ¡�¤�¥¨¡~«F°�È£k®~®B¡~¯�§¬¥�±A¾�°{ªg¹O¡!£k±�¦Z­|¡ � ¡�®B§¬¥�±�¾Mªk§¬ A¡~­D°~¶��Ë¡!²Ë¥�¤�¤û±�£R§¬µ�­|£k¤�¤¨©� �£S¢k¡!¯�­¬¡~«F¡~­¬¡�±�®B¡�°�£k±�¦§¬ A¡�°{¡M²Ë¥�¤�¤�§�©8¯�¥�®~£k¤�¤¨©_®Bªg¥�±�®~¥�¦A¡1²2¥¨§¬  §¬ Aªg°{¡�ªk«bªk§¬ A¡~­|°p¥�±� �¥�°O¤�ª8®~£k¤�¥�§�©k¶c�� A¡1²�ªk­|¦�°� §{­|µA¡kÇ�£k±�¦ � «P£k¤�°{¡kÇ}¯�­¬ª�¢8¥�¦�¡O§¬ A¡s¥�¦�¥¨ªg¹ ¥�±t²Ë �¥�®D �§¬ Aªg°¬¡s¡~¢R£k¤�µ�£R§¬¥¨ªg±�°'£R­¬¡s¡B»8¯�­|¡�°¬°{¡�¦`È£k±�¦l§¬ A¡b²�ªk­|¦�° � ­|£R§¬¥¨ªg±�£k¤�Ç�£k±�¦ � ¥¨­¬­|£R§¬¥�ªg±�£k¤�Ç@²Ë¥�¤�¤, �£S¢k¡'£O°¬¥�¹O¥�¤�£R­�«Pµ�±�®B§¬¥¨ªg±`¶o¿{Ì

rb),+�Ei+�7|<W.[5Rd�<B>c7D+�+_<4)`5:<�<B),+�74+ 3D+�;,+S^`-,CI<4CF>@-f7M;,>=-,>8<6.2>@3D9�CI7�<4>]58a,a,K�dy<B),+�L <4>74CILMafKF+O?�>@-f?�34+S<B+s+S�f58L�a,KF+�7�q'�`>@3�CI-,7D<B58-,?�+8NiCI<�.0>8G,KF;Z?�+�3|<~58CI-,KId�Ei+pG,74+SvxG,K�<4>6LM5898+pa}+�>@a,KI+Ei+�KFCI+�J8+[<B)`5:<�C�v}<4),+�d!;,34C�J@+b;,3DG,-,9!<B)f+�d!.�CIKFKfu8>O<4>O),+�KIK,>@3;,CI+[vx34>@L ?R58-,?�+�3�N�EfGf<�<B)`5:<.2>@G,KI;-,>8<�L6589:+&<B)f>@74+l7|<~5:<4+�L�+�-A<B7�<B3DG,+ /�5:<�KF+�587D<�>@-�58- CF-A<4G,CI<4CIJ@+sG,-,;,+�347|<~58-,;fCF-,u�>8v�<B)f+&.0>834;X|<434G,+�\ 6Sq ��CFL�CFKP5:34KId8NH>8-,?�+pG,ai>@-�5l<BCILM+:N`a}+�>@a,KF+p58u834+�+�;Z<4)`5:<'<B),+>E�583D<4)Z.0587.G`5:< /x>@3b<B)`5Q<E,KI>H>�;_.0587O7D<~5Q<BCF?:Nn+�<4?8qa6SN�58-f;�.2+l-,>k.�9�-,>k.�<B)`5Q<�<B),+Sd_.2+�34+l.�3D>@-,u,q �H>�CF-A<B+�347DG,E��D+�?S<BC�J@+58u@3D+�+�LM+�-�<';,>�+�7�-,>:<�?�>@CI-,?�CI;,+�.�CI<4)�<434Gf<4) /�58uA58CI-nNfGf-,;,+�3D7D<4>H>�;ZCI-A<BG,C�<BCIJ8+�K�d 6�q

�wv,?�>8G,347D+8N:.2+25834+ËG,74CI-,u�),+�3D+05:-sCI-�<4G,CI<4CIJ8+-,>8<BCI>@-O>8vf<434Gf<4)nN:58-,;!5b?�34CI<4CF?L�CFu@)A<�;,+�L65:-,;5�LM>@3D+sXD34CIu@>@34>8G,74\�;,+S^`-,CI<4CF>@-�q��0GH<û<4),+Ëa,34>@EfKF+�L%CF7�<B)`5Q<�58KIK@;,+S^`-,CI<4CF>@-f7�<4+�-,;p<B>�E}+�?�CI34?�G,KP583>@3�+�KF7D+!<B>�34+�KIdZ>@- vxG,-,;`5:LM+�-�<B58K�Gf-,;,+�^,-,+�;/<B+�3DLM7�<B)`5:<�>@-,+l+�C�<B),+�3�u@345874a,7�CI-A<BG,C�<BCIJ8+�K�dZ>83;,>�+�7�-,>8<�u83B587Da_5:<'5:KFKÔq��w-,;�<B3DGf<B)�v�58KFKI70-`5Q<BG,3458KFK�d6CI-�<4),+OKP5:<D<B+�3b?R5:<4+�u@>@3|d@q ¿ �

�HCF-f?�+�<B),+�74+'34+�;f+�^`-,C�<BCI>@-,7�>8v[X|<B3DGf<B),\s583D+'7D>&a`5Q<B+�-A<4KId158Ef74G,3D;nN�.�)Ad�583D+b<B),+Sd1a,34>@ai>@7D+�;74>�>8v�<4+�- ¿ � 58-,;Z.�)AdZ583D+O<4),+�d�7D>Mai>@a,GfKP583Bj 73D+�74GfL658EfKId@N,<4),+s58-,7D.2+�3�)`587b<B>�;,>�.�CI<B)�<B)f+v�58?S<p<4)`5:<�N�3B58;,CI?R58K�7498+�af<BCI?�CI74L"Ei+�CF-futCI343D+�vxGf<B58E,KF+:N�>@-,+1?R5:-=58K�.[5Rd�7O;,>@G,EH<&5:-�d�a,583D<4CF?�GfKP583<B3DGf<B)�.�C�<B),>@GH<b34G,-f-,CF-,ulCI-A<B>lKF>8u@CF?�58K}?�>@-A<B3458;,CF?S<BCI>@-nq�0GH<b<B),+�74+O34+�;,+�^`-fCI<BCI>@-,7[;f>�-f>8<b+�J8+�-74>8KIJ@+'<B),+�a,34>8E,KF+�L >8v�3B5:;,CF?�58K�7498+�af<BCI?�CI74Ltqr�589:+8N�vx>@32CI-,7D<B58-,?�+8NfGH<BCFKICI<{diTû7B5Rd�CF-,up<B)`5:<074>@L�+�1<B)fCF-,uOCF7Gf74+�vxGfK /xvx>@37D>@LM+�7Da}+�?�CI^,+�;�u@>A58K 6�CF7�58KI34+�58;fdl5:-M>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ8+'7|<~5:<4+�L�+�-A<D/�C�<�)`587<B>OEi+�,"=���`���!G,7D+�vxG,K�vx>@3<B),+';,+�?�KP5:34+�;Mu@>A58K 6�<B)`5Q<23D+�KICF+�7�CILMa,KICF?�CI<BK�dp>@-�<4),+'?�>@3D34+�7Da}>8-,;,+�-f?�+�-,>:<BCF>8->8v[<434Gf<4)nq�rb),+67458L�+634+�L65:349 CF7p+�J8+�-]L�>@34+1>@EAJ�CF>8G,7svx>@3pCF-A<4+�347DG,E��D+�?�<BC�J@+�5:u@34+�+�L�+�-A<RT&<4>7B5RdZ<B)`5:< /�>8<4),+�3,6�ai+�>@a,KI+s<4),CF-,9t74>�5:-,; 74>�CI7�58- >@E��D+�?�<4CIJ8+!7D<B5:<B+�LM+�-�<O;f+�74?�34CIE,CF-,u6a`583D<w>8v<B)f+C/x74>�?�CF58K`6Ë.2>@3DKF;�X4587bC�<�CF74\fq

�wv&?�>@G,347D+8N�ai>@74C�<BC�J@+ 583Du@G,L�+�-A<B7t583D+ 74>@L�+�<4CFL�+�7�u@C�J@+�-*<4>y74G,a,ai>@3|<Z3D+�;,+S^`-,C�<BCF>8-,7�>8v<B3DGf<B)�N�587bvx>@3bCF-,7|<~58-f?�+�<B),+�vx>@KIKF>k.�CF-fu&74>8LM+S.�)`5:<'74G,EH<BKF+O7D>@a,),CI74LtT

¶~¶�¶�§¬ A¡bªg±�¤¨©s®B­|¥¨§{¡~­|¥¨ªg±&²�¡� �£�¢k¡'«Iªk­�£R¯�¯H¤¨©8¥�±A¾'§¬ A¡[²�ªk­|¦���§{­|µA¡�¥�° � µ�°¬§¬¥¨¼�®~£R§¬¥¨ªg±!£k±�¦� µ�°{§¬¥¨¼�®~£R§¬¥¨ªg±/¥�°p£k¤¨²�£�©@°s­¬¡�¤�£R§¬¥¨¢k¡M§{ªZ£k±=£kµ�¦�¥¨¡�±�®B¡k¶ À ª_¥¨§p¥�°s£k¤�°{ª�­|¡�¤�£R§¬¥¨¢k¡�§{ªZ§¬ �£R§

àðà b�â Ò ïxú Ö�×DØSØ�ÙgÚRÛgÛ�Ü@ÞR× IQÞ8/�ß{Üà ;#@ ì ÒÔÕgÑDç ì ÕQñ @ ãäâRâ Ò�Öx×4ØSÙQ×SÚRÛ�Ü�/�ÞSß{Ü �RÑDÑ?� â( ~ì�ã�ì ÕQñ�@�Ò å¸î ó â Õ ï Öx×4ØSØ�ÙgÚ î�öQì Û�Ü A�ß ø�â Ò ì[î Ò åæïðå¸ê�ë ÑSÜà O Q ø¨ï Ñ|Ò ìSãæã ÚgÛ8Ñ â Û ã Ñé öQâ[ì ç é öQì~ï���ï Ò ëkïðö "[ó[Ñ ì ÕQç ì ÒðÑ�Õ âSï ÒðÑ ì�ãäãæú�å Õ ïðö Ñ�ç ì ó[ÑÛ â ç å�ïÔåæâ Õ ì ç ïðöQâ çðÑ�é öQâ

é â ÕQñkÑDÒ�é öQì~ï�ì Õ âkî{ïÔâ Û ë ç å ç â Ò�é ögâ�� ÑDÕ â Û öQâ Õwé ì ç|ÜàSPDõ â Ò ì ñ å ç î|ë çÔç åäâ Õ â�ø ç å ó åäãäì Ò�ÛgÒ â Û â ç ì�ã ç|Ú4ç�ÑDÑ>@}ÑDÒ ï Ò ì ÕQñ b�ë çÔç�Ñ ãæã ù ç î Ò å�ïÔåäê�ë Ñ â�øRïðö ÑiÛgÒ ì ÓSó ì~ïÔå çðó âSø - åäãäãæå¸ì ó

ì ó[ÑDç ì ÕQñ âSö Õ �Ñ|é�Ñ ú Ö b�ë çÔçðÑ ãäã ÚA×4Ø�Vg×�Ú î�öQì ÛQçDÜ�/�A ì ÕQñ / =kÚ å Õ�Û ì Ò ïðå¸î¬ëgã¸ì ÒnÛ�Ü@ÞSÞ~Ø�ß{Ü

Page 9: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

£kµ�¦�¥¨¡�±�®B¡kÇo°'¤�¥¨¾g :§¬°0Ê §¬ A¡p¯�µ�­¬¯,ªg°{¡�§¬ �£R§�°¬µ�®| t£k±Z£kµ�¦�¥¨¡�±�®B¡O²�£k±:§¬°w°{¡~­¬¢k¡�¦t£k±�¦�§¬ A¡°¬¥¨§¬µ�£R§¬¥�ªg±l¥�±!²Ë �¥�®D l¥¨§¼�±�¦�°¥¨§¬°{¡�¤¨«Ô¶o¿ '

rb),+tE}+�u@CF-f-,CF-,u >:vw<B)f+�^,347D<M74+�-A<B+�-f?�+_CI71?�>@3D34+�?S<RN2E,Gf<�CI<1;,>�+�7�-,>8<1CILMafKId=<4)`5:<l<434Gf<4)�CI7CF;f+�-A<BCI?R58K,<4>b�DG,7|<BC�^`?R5:<4CF>@-�q /Ô��-,+�LM5Rd!.0+�KFK�Ei+�345:<BCI>@-`58KIKId[�DG,7D<4CI^`+�;6CI-�Ei+�KICF+SJHCI-,uO74>@L�+�<4),CF-fu<B),5:<2<4G,34-f70>@Gf<�NH>8-6?�KI>@74+�32+��f58LMCI-`5:<4CF>@-nN@<4>&Ei+'v�5:KF74+:q ¿ + 68Bt>@34+�>gJ8+�3�NH.�)`5:<0;,>�+�7ËCI<2LM+�58-�<4>7B5Rdl<4)`5:<��DG,7|<BCI^,?R5:<4CF>@-1CF7�5:KI.05kd�7Ë34+�KP5:<4CIJ@+[<4>�<B),+�a,G,3Da}>874+�<B)`5:<258-�58Gf;,CF+�-,?�+�.[5:-�<4727D+�3|J@+�;`jrb),CI7pCI-A<B34>�;,G,?�+�7p5�74G,EH<BKF+1?�>@-fvxG,7DCF>@-/E}+S<{.0+�+�-c9�-,>k.�KI+�;,u@+�58-f;/J:58KIG,+�7�NûEAd�CILMa,KICF?�CI<BK�d�587�174GfLMCI-,u!<B)`5Q<'58KFK}9�-f>g.�KI+�;,u8+�;,+�ai+�-,;f7�>@-�7D>@LM+tX|a,G,34ai>@7D+�\,N,Cðqæ+:q,74>8LM+�-,>8- 1{?�>@u@-,C�<BCIJ8+wu@>@58KÔq�0Gf<0.�)`5:<bC�v�<B),+�XD58G,;,CI+�-,?�+�\!.058-A<B7[<B>!^,-,;�>@Gf<b)f>g. /x74>@L�+�a`583|<b>8v,6�<4),+w.2>@34KI;�34+R5:KFKId1CI7~j)�>@3D<{d�L�CFu@)A<Ë34+�a,KId1<B),5:<2<4),CF72u@>A58K�CI72G,-,5:<4<B58CF-`5:E,KF+:NH5:72<B)f+�vx>@KIKF>k.�CF-,uO7|<~5:<4+�L�+�-A<[7DG,u@u@+�7D<B7�TXD��u8>A58KûCF7�7D>@LM+S<B),CI-,u6d8>@G ?R58- 9�-,>k.�d@>@G/583D+!u@+S<4<BCI-,uW?�KF>@7D+�3w<4>,N�>@3�v�583D<4),+�3�5R.05Rd_vx34>8LZq�0Gf<�<4),+�3D+1CF7�-,>�.05kd_<B>�9�-,>k. >@G,3�;,CI7D<B58-,?�+!vx3D>@LÎ<4),+l<B3DGf<B)nN�-f>8<O+�J8+�-U.�)f+�<B)f+�3O.0+�583D+?�KI>@74+�3'<4>WCI<�<4)`58-�>@Gf3w58-f?�+�7|<B>@3D7w.2+�34+:qæ\ ¿ < �0Gf<�CI7'<4),CF7'34+�58KFK�d�74>�j ��>@LM+p>8v>8G,3�58-f?�+�7|<B>@3D7<B)f>@G,u@)A<1<B)`5Q<l<B),+ E�583D<4)y.0587-G�5:<�q ��>8-nm�<l.2+t9�-f>g. E}+S<4<4+�3~j ��34+�-�m�<1.2+Z?�KF>@7D+�3!<B>�<B)f+<B3DGf<B)�N`CF-�<B)`5Q<�34+�7Da}+�?�<w5:<�KF+�587D<~j

rb),+ZJ�CI+�.ha,3D>@a}>874+�;V),+�3D+_CF7�74>UCFL�a,KP5:G,74CIE,KF+6<4)`5:<M>@-,+tCF71vx>@34?�+�;V<4>=3D+�74>83D<�<B>=7D>@L�+XD?~)`5:34CI<B58E,KI+�\yCF-A<B+�34a,3D+�<B5:<BCI>@-nq 7�+�3D)`58a,7 )�>@3D<{d*L�+R58-f7tEAd X|<434Gf<4),\�7D>@L�+�<B)fCF-,uyKFCI98+ <B)f+vxG,-,;,58LM+�-A<~58K�a,)Ad�74CI?R58K�KP5R.�7'u@>kJ@+�34-,CI-,uM<4),+s+�-A<BCF3D+sGf-,CIJ8+�347D+8Ni>@3'58- XD58E,74>8KFGf<4+�\1<B34GH<B)_;fCF7 1?�>kJ8+�34+�;VEAd]a,Gf34+�<B),>8G,u@)A< /ð5871CI-]?�KP5:7474CI?R58K0LM+S<~58a,)Ad�74CI?�7,6�9�58-,;yC�<l;,>�+�71L65:98+�7l7D+�-,7D+t<4>Ei+�7D98+�af<BCI?R58K�58Ei>@Gf<O>8G,3O58E,CIKFCI<{d�<4>t;fCF74?�>kJ@+�3�<434Gf<4),7O>8v2<4),>@7D+�9�CI-,;,7�q1�2Gf<pCIv�<B),CI7�CF7�.�)`5Q<)�>@3D<{d L�+R5:-,7�N�<B),+�-=),+�74)f>@G,KF;/7B5Rd�7D>Z+��fafKFCF?�CI<4KId@N�345:<B)f+�3�<B)`5:-ULM589�CF-,u�7|<~5:<4+�L�+�-A<B7O<B)`5Q<58KIKF+�u8+�;,K�d=5:a,a,KId/<B>/58KIK2ai>@7D74CFEfKF+W9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+:qy��3�NË58KI<4+�3D-`5:<BC�J@+�KId@Nai+�3D)`58a,7-)�>@3|<{dc74CILMafKId.058-A<B7�<B>�3D+�C�<B+�345:<B+s<B),+!E,58-`58K�>@E,74+�3DJ:5:<4CF>@-�<4)`5:<O58KIK�7|<~5:<4+�L�+�-A<B7�>:vv�58?�<8/x+�J8+�-U58E}>8Gf<�<B)f+G�5:<4-,+�7D7�>8v<B)f+ E�583D<4) 6'?�58- E}+&?~)`58KFKI+�-,u8+�;�EAd 5M?�>@-,7DCF7|<B+�-A<�3458;,CI?R58Kû749:+�af<4CF?8qO�2Gf<�<B),5:<�CI7-,>8<'51a`583|<BCI?�G,KF5834K�dM-f+�. CI-,74CIu@)A<Rq

����� � C�+.9 5�� C��>/ (DC�?@7 '% B?@9�+� ?��� C�J@+�-&<B),+2a,34>8E,KF+�LM7û3B58CI74+�;&EAd&Gf-,;,+�3D;,+�<4+�3DLMCI-`5:<BCI>@-nN:58-,;!7DCF-,?�+03D+�;,+S^`-,CF-fuw<B3DGf<B)!KI+R58;f7

G,7�vx3D>@L E`58;s<B>w.2>@347D+8N@.�)`5Q<�74)f>@G,KF;&>@-,+0;f>�j�rb)f+�34+0CF7û-,>�58E,7|<B3458?�<�5:-,;!u@+�-,+�3458Kf5:-,7D.2+�3�<4><B)fCF7 N G,+�7D<BCI>@-nq�(U+O5834+:NfCI-W74>@L�+�7D+�-,7D+8N2XD74?�34+�+�-,+�;,\lvx34>@L 34+�58KFC�<{d /�.0+�),5kJ8+O-,>lCFL�LM+�;,CP5Q<B+58?�?�+�7D7�<B>'CI<�N:3458;,CI?R58KA7D98+�aH<BCF?�CF7DL�?�58-,-,>:<�Ei+23D+�vxGf<4+�;nN:+�<B?:q 6�q�rb),+�34+[5:34+Ë-,>�58Ef74>@KIGf<B+�KId�7D+�?�Gf34+vx>@G,-f;`5:<BCI>@-,7'>@-_.�),CI?~)_<B>ME`587D+!>@G,3'9�-,>k.�KF+�;fu@+8qDJ�+�J8+�3|<B),+�KF+�7D7�Nn.2+!58KIKû58747DG,LM+sCFL�a,KFCI?�C�<BKId<B),5:<�.0+�?R58-M>@Ef<~5:CF-174>@L�+'34+R5:74>@-`5:E,KIdl3D+�KICP58E,KI+[9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+w>:vn34+�58KFC�<{d@N�5:<ËKI+R587|<0CI-�+SJ@+�3Dd�;`5RdKFC�vx+8q ��+�<�G,7<B3|d&<4>�u@>�v�583D<4),+�3�NAa,Gf<4<4CF-,u�<4>�.0>@3D9l58KIK�<4),+�34+�7D>@G,3D?�+�7Ë>8vi>@G,3�v�5:KFKFCIE,KF+Ë58-f;1^,-,CI<4+L�CF-,;,7�T�>@E,7D+�3|J85Q<BCF>8-,7�N,+��Ha}+�34CFL�+�-A<47�N,3D+R587D>@-,CF-fu,q�w-,;�<4),+�-�KF+S<bG,7b7D+�+�),>k.�v�5830.2+p?�58-�u@>,qàSU b�â Ò ïxú Ö�×DØSØ�ÙgÚRÛ�Ü�ARß{Üà W õ â ÒûÑ� ì ó0Û ã Ñ�Ú�Y ë ó[Ñ�Öx×4ØSÙ�Ù � ×BÞ�A�Ù8�FÚQçðÑ î¬ïðåäâ Õ � ß�Ó åäü Ñ4ç ïÔö Ñ�Ñ� ì ó0Û ã Ñ âSøiì Û8Ñ|Ò�ç â Õ å Õcd�ÕQñ åäì é öQâ Ú ê�ëQå�ï Ñ

Ò ì~ïðåäâ Õ ì�ãäãæú ÚDÒÔÑ ø�ë çðÑDñ ïÔâ�ò Ñ ãäå Ñ ü Ñ ïÔöQì~ï é ì�ï Ñ|Ò î|ì Õ ò Ñ î¬â ó[Ñiç âSãäå ññ ë Ò å ÕgÓûé å Õ ï ÑDÒ�Ö�é ì�ï ÑDÒ�ç â�ãæå ñ åæí ÑDç ü ÑDÒ ú�ì�ò Ò ë Û ïÔãæúì Ò âSë ÕQñ ïðö Ñ ø ÒÔÑ|Ñ R|å ÕgÓbÛ âSå Õ ï Ú8ç âbåæø,â ÕgÑ ãäåæü ÑDç å Õ ì é ì ÒÔó î|ãæå ó ì~ï Ñ�Ú åæïûå ç å ÕQñkÑ|Ñ4ñ öQì Ò�ñ ïðâ�ò Ñ ãäå Ñ ü Ñ ïðöQì�ï é ì�ï ÑDÒî|ì Õ ø ÒðÑDÑ R ÑBß{Ü d ï ç ögâ é�ç ïÔöQì~ï Ò ì�ïðåäâ Õ ìSã8å Õ ø ÑDÒðÑDÕ î Ñ4ç ø Ò â ó ïÔö Ñ ìBü~ì�åäãäìSògã Ñ�Ñ üRå ñkÑDÕ î Ñ�ñ â Õ â�ï ÕgÑ î Ñ4çðç ì Ò åæãäúbã Ñ ì ñ ïÔâï Ò ë Ñ î¬â Õ î¬ãäë ç åæâ ÕQçDÜàS\ b�â Ò ïxú Ö�×DØSØ�ÙgÚRÛgÛ�Ü:Ý I ARß{Ü

Page 10: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

z{-�v�58?�<�N�<4),+1LM>87D<O74Gf34a,3DCF74CI-,u�<B),CI-,u,N�7D),>k.�-UEAd <B)f+�;f+�J@+�KF>@afLM+�-�<p>8v2L�>H;,+�34-�74?�CF+�-,?�+:N�CI7),>k.%v�5:3[.0+p74+�+�L <B>1Ei+p58E,KF+�<4>1u@>,q

� vx3DCF+�-f;�>8v�>@G,3D7w>@-f?�+!7458CF;nT�X|zb58LÎ5M-`58C�J@+s34+R5:KFCF7|<Rq��0Gf<wz�58;,L�CI<'<B)`5:<�9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+!CI7;,C��M?�G,KI<�qæ\�rb),CI7bCF70<4),+�34>�>8<0>8v�<B),+�a,3D>@E,KI+�Ltq34�-,>k.�CF-,ul),>k. <B),CI-,u@7[3D+R58KIKIdM5834+�CI70<B)f+�u@>A58K>8vË74?�CF+�-,?�+29�<4),CF7wu@>A58KûCF7�;fC ��?�G,K�<w<4>�34+R5:?~)nN�E,Gf<O-,>:<�CFL�a}>87474CIE,KF+*/�5:<�KF+�587D<wvx>@3�74>8LM+!a,583D<47>8v'34+�58KFC�<{dU58-,;]<B> 7D>@LM+6;,+�u@3D+�+�7�>:vw5:a,a,34>R�HCFLM5:<4CF>@- 6�q�z�v'.0+�?~)`5:-,u@+W<B)f+�u@>A58K� CIv¬N�vx>83+S�f58L�a,KI+8N}.2+l74+�+�9�CI-,7D<4+R58;�5W?�>@-,7D+�-,7DG,7w� <B)f+�- >8v�?�>@G,347D+!<B),CI-,u@7�Ei+�?�>@L�+!L!G,?~) +�5874CI+�3 9E,Gf<w587��0+�3|<B3458-,; )�G,7D74+�KIK�>@E,74+�3DJ8+�; CF-Z5174CFL�CFKF583[?�>@-A<B+S��<�Ni<4),CF7�)`587�58KIKn<B),+s58;fJ:58-A<~5:u@+�7'>8v<B)f+�v�<'>kJ@+�3�),>8-,+�7|<�<4>@CFKðq

z�<�CI7�CFL�a}>@3|<~58-A<�<4>�3D+�L�+�L!Ei+�3�<B)`5Q<�7D?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?29�-,>k.�KI+�;,u@+Ë-,+�+�;,7�-f>WX��DGf7D<BC�^`?R5Q<BCF>8-,\bvx34>@L<B)f+M>@GH<B74CI;,+8qMrb),+��DG,7D<4CI^`?�5:<BCI>@- vx>@3�<B),+1>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ@+�J:58KFCI;,CI<{dZ>8v[7D?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?�<4),+�>834CF+�7*/�CF-�<B)f+74+�-,74+�>8vnEi+�CI-,us5:<ËKF+R5:7D<258a,a,3D>R�fCIL65Q<B+b<B3DGf<B),7258Ei>@Gf<�<B)f+'.2>@34KI; 6�KFCI+�7CF-�74ai+�?�CI^`?�<B)f+�>@3D+�<BCI?R58K58-,; +�LMafCF34CI?R58Kû583Du@G,L�+�-A<B7�qp�wv�?�>@G,3D74+:N�a,),CFKI>@74>8a,),+�3D7�Nn)fCF7D<4>@34CF58-,7'>@3�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CF7|<B7�LM5kdZEi+CFL�a,3D+�747D+�;�EAd]<B),+t74G,?�?�+�7474+�7W>8v�<B),+�-`5:<4G,3B5:Kb74?�CI+�-,?�+�7 /ð587l<B)f+tKI>@u@CI?R58K2a}>@7DCI<4CIJ�CF7|<B7!.2+�34+ 658-,;/74+�+�9�<4>tGf-,;,+�3D7D<B58-,;/),>k. 74?�CF+�-f?�+l.0>8349�7�qM�0Gf<�<4),+�3D+M5:34+l<{.0>�vx34+ N G,+�-A<sLMCI7D<~5:98+�7�<4>5RJ@>@CI;nTp��-,+1CF7w<4>�<B),CI-,9_<B),5:<RN�Ei+�?�58G,74+�74>8LM+la`5:3D<BCI?�G,KF583�58?�?�>@Gf-�<Ov�58CIKF7 /�7B5Rd8Nû<4),+1KF>@u@CI?R58K 1ai>@74C�<BCIJ�CI7D<�>@-f+l>@3�<B),+87û>@a,ai+�34CF58-�>@-,+ 6SN�<B),+�-�74>@L�+�58KI<4+�34-,5:<BC�J@+l58?�?�>@Gf-�<C/x+8q�u,qn<B),+l7D>H?�CF>21),CI7D<B>834CF?�58K�>@-,+ 6 � � ��%�� �����}q��0Gf<�<4)`5:<�CI7�58-&>@EAJHCI>@G,7ûv�58KFKF58?�d 98ai+�3D)`58a,7 � �'+��HCF7D<4CF-,u�58?�?�>@G,-A<.2>@349�7�q ¿ @ rb)f+w74+�?�>@-f;nN,58-f;6L�>@34+bvxG,-,;,58LM+�-A<~58KðN�L�CF7|<~589:+�CF7<B>p<B),CI-,9&<B),5:<0>8G,3�CF-`58EfCFKFC�<{ds<4>58?�?�>@G,-A<�CF-Ou@+�-,+�3458KA<B+�3DLM7�vx>@3n<4),+Ë74G,?�?�+�7D7�>8vH74?�CF+�-f?�+Ë74>@L�+�),>k.]LM589:+�7û74?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?�9�-,>k.�KF+�;fu@+KF+�747�34+�KFCP5:E,KF+W>83MKI+�747�>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ@+:qerb)`5:<M?�>8-fvxG,74+�7W58?�?�>@Gf-�<4CF-,u=58-,; �DG,7D<4CIv�d�CF-,ufq��'v�<B+�3M58KIKÔNECF-,7|<B+�CF-M58-,; ��5:3D.�CF-�uA5RJ@+w5834u8G,LM+�-A<B7�vx>@3<B),+�CF3<B),+�>@34CI+�7�Nf58-f;M<B)f>@74+�5834u8G,LM+�-A<B7�.0+�34+�v�5:3vx34>8L Ei+�CI-,u 58KIKË+�343D>@-,+�>8G,7�q�rb),+�34+�vx>834+8N�+SJ@+�-�CIv I[5834-`5:anmæ715:-,;�7�>@afa}+�3�m�7l+�a,CI7D<B+�LM>8KF>@u@CI+�7.2+�34+1+�-�<4CF3D+�KIdZL�CF74u8G,CF;,+�;nN}<4)`5:<�.2>@G,KI;�-,>8<�Ei+�u@CI-�<B>�?�587D<O;,>8G,Ef<O>@- 3D+�KP5Q<BCIJ�C�<{dt<4),+�>83Dd�>83+�J8>@KFGH<BCF>8-nq

BZ>@3D+�>kJ@+�3�N�<4),+6G,-f;,+�3D;,+�<4+�34L�CF-,5:<BCI>@-/<4),+�7DCF7�N�v�583�vx34>8L"G,-,;,+�34L�CF-,CI-,u�74?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?6>8E��D+�?;1<BC�J�CI<{d@N�5:?�<BG,58KFK�d�LM5898+�7O<4),+174G,?�?�+�747&>:v[74?�CF+�-,?�+M58KFKû<B),+1L�>@34+l3D+�LM58349Q58EfKF+8qlz{-f;,+�+�;nN�.�)`5Q<CF7';,C��M?�G,KI<�CF7'-,>8<'<B>�^`-,;�5�7D<B>83Dd�<B)`5Q<�X|^f<B7�<4),+&;,5:<~58\fN}E,GH<�<4>6^`-,;�+SJ@+�- >@-,+�� ��� �=���������74Gf?~)=7D<4>@3Dd8q ��>k. ;,>H+�7�>@-,+l9�-,>k.�<4)`5:<�C�<�CF7�-,>8- 1{?�3B58�Sd,j*� ?�>@L&E,CF-`5Q<BCF>8-�>8vËv�58?�<4>@347�T�CI<47a,3D+�;,CI?�<BC�J@+�a}>k.2+�3�N�CI<47O+S�Ha,KP5:-`5:<B>83Dd�J:58KIG,+8NûCI<47�E,34+�58;f<B)c58-,;/74CFL�a,KICF?�C�<{d@Nn+S<B?:q J�>8<4),CF-fuZCI-<B)f+�G,-,;,+�34;,+S<B+�3DLMCI-`5:<4CF>@-=<4),+�7DCF7!<4+�KFKI7&G,7l)f>g. <B>�^,-,;]CF-,+ N G,CIJ:58KI+�-A<!<B)f+�>@3DCF+�7s.�CI<B)]7D>@L�+>@3�5:KFK�>:vË<4),+�7D+1a,34>@ai+�3|<BCI+�7�qpz{- v�58?�<�N�<B)f+�34+15:34+!J:587D<O;f>@L65:CF-,7�CF- a,)Ad�74CI?�7�N�?~),+�LMCI7D<43Dd 5:-,;E,CI>@KF>@u:d�.�),+�3D+1<4),+�3D+!CF7�5WG,-,C N G,+&-,>@- 1�?�3B5:��d_<4),+�>83Dd_<4)`5:<O5:?�?�>8G,-A<B7�vx>@3w<4),+!9�-,>k.�-�v�58?�<4758-,;W.�)f+�34+OLM58-AdW5:KI<B+�34-`5Q<BCIJ8+w<B)f+�>@3DCF+�70)`5RJ@+�Ei+�+�-�<434CF+�;�58-,;Wv�58CIKF+�;WE}+�?R58Gf74+�<B),+�CF32a,34+�;,CF?;1<BCI>@-,7Ë?�>@-A<43B58;,CI?�<4+�;�+S�Hai+�3DCFL�+�-A<B7�qz{-W<B),>@7D+w;,>8L658CI-,7�N�>@-,+�?R58-634+R5:74>@-`5:E,KId1<B)fCF-,9l<B),5:<[>@Gf3a,3D+�74+�-A<�1{;,5kd�<4),+�>@3DCF+�7�5834+p5:<�KI+R587|<'58a,a,3D>k�HCIL65:<4+�K�dM<434G,+:q Ì L

àS] �RÑ|Ñ � î Ð å ÕgÕ�Öx×4ØSØ�ÝgÚ î�ö:ì Û�Ü4ÞSß ø�â Ò ïÔö Ñ å Õ ï Ñ|ÒÔÑDç ïðå ÕgÓ�ç ë ÓSÓ�ÑDç ïðåäâ Õ ïðöQì�ï�ë ÕQñgÑ|Ò�ç ï�ì ÕQñ å ÕgÓ â�ë Ò â é�Õ Õ â é ã Ñ4ñkÓSÑ��ÛgÒ â ñ ëQî¬å ÕgÓbó[Ñ î�ö:ì Õ å ç�óbç�ç å ó0Û ãæú�ãæå ÑDç â�ëkï ç å ñkÑ ïðö Ñ ò:â�ë ÕQñ â�ø é öQì�ï�å ç ògåäâSãäâ Ó å¸î|ìSãæãäú[ø Ñ ì ç åäògã Ñ ø�â Ò âSë Ò ãäå ó åæï Ñ4ñó å Õ:ñgç|Ü;�_#- å�ïÔö�î Ñ|Ò ïÔì�å Õ î|ìBü Ñ ì�ï ç ïðâ2ò Ñ�ó ì ñkÑ ìSò:â�ëkïiïÔö Ñ�ç ïÔì�ïðë ç â�ø�ë Õ âSò çðÑ|Ò ü~ì�ògã Ñ�Ñ|Õ ïðåæïðå ÑDç å Õ ï Ò â ñ ë:î ÑDñ å Õ�Û öRú ç åäî ç

ì Õ:ñ ïÔö ÑOÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ï ÑDñWñkÑ ò:ì~ï Ñ4ç ò Ñ ï é�Ñ|ÑDÕ6ÒÔÑ ìSãæå ç ï ç ì ÕQñ å ÕQç ï Ò ë ó[Ñ|Õ ï�ì�ãäå ç ï çDÜ �kÑ|Ñ @�Ò å¸î ó â Õ ï Ö�×DØ�ØSØ�ß ø�â Ò ì ó â ÒÔÑñkÑ ïÔì�åäã ÑDñpñ å ç î¬ë çÔç åæâ Õ�Ü3X â�ï ÑSÚ ögâ é�Ñ ü Ñ|Ò4Ú ïÔöQì~ï ÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ïðåäüRå ç ï ç�ç â ó[Ñ ïÔå ó[ÑDç ï ÑDÕQñ ïðâ�ø�ì�ãäãfò:ìSî+ �â Õ å ÕQç ï Ò ë ó[Ñ|Õ ïÔìSãæå ç ïÛ â ç å�ïÔåæâ ÕQç�é ö ÑDÕ î�öQìSãæã Ñ|ÕgÓ�ÑDñAÚ ògëkï}ïðö ÑDÒðÑ å ç ì ÛgÒ â�ø�âSë ÕQñbñ åæ÷ ÑDÒðÑDÕ î Ñ ò Ñ ï é�Ñ|ÑDÕ ïðö Ñ ï é â2ì~ï�ïÔå�ïÔë ñkÑ4ç|Ü d�ÕQç ï Ò ë ó[Ñ|Õ �

���

Page 11: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

J�>k.Y<B)`5Q<�.2+!)`5RJ@+&7498+S<B?~),+�;�>@G,3�5Q<4<BC�<BG,;f+s>@-_+�a,CI7D<B+�LM>8KF>@u@CI?R58K�CF747DG,+�7�N�KI+�<�G,7�<4G,34-_<4><B)f+p?�>@-,7D+ N G,+�-f?�+�7�vx>@3b?�>@-A<4+�L�a}>@34583DdW74>�?�CF>8KF>@u@CI?R58K�7|<BG,;,CI+�7'>8v�74?�CI+�-,?�+8q

� � �1 !��� ���A����� s�����t� �F�

rb),+�3D+�+S�HCF7|<[7D+�J@+�3B58K�?�>@-A<B+�LMai>@34583Dd1J:5834CF58-A<B72>8v�34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DLZq � G,CI<4+w>8v�<4+�-nNHa}+�>@a,KI+�;,+�-AdEi+�CF-fu_34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7|<pE}+�?R58G,7D+6<B)f+�d=5834+�34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7|<sCI-=7D>@LM+M>8<B)f+�3&7D+�-,7D+6<B),58-=<B)f+6>@-,+MG,-,;,+�3?�>8-,74CI;,+�345:<BCI>@-nq �H>�CI<&CF7p-,+�?�+�7D7B583|dc<B>�u8>_>kJ@+�3!74+SJ@+�3458K[ai>@747DCFE,KI+6L�+R58-fCF-,u@7p>8vb<4),+M.2>@34;�q(U+M7D)`58KFK?�>@-,7DCF;,+�3s),+�34+M>@-,KId_<{.0>ZLM+�58-,CF-fu@7�Tp?�>@u8-,CI<4CIJ@+ /x>@3O+�a,CI7D<B+�LMCI?�6�34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DLZN�5:-,;L�+�<B)f>H;,>8KF>@u@CI?R58K�34+�KF5:<BC�J�CF74Ltqb��G,3�L65:CF-�<B),+�74CF7�CF7�<B)`5Q<w?�>@u@-,C�<BCIJ8+s3D+�KF5:<BC�JHCI74L CI7w5�a}>874CI<4CF>@-<B),5:<0-f>&74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<5/xCF-6+�CI<4),+�3<B)f+w-`5:<4G,3B5:Ki>83Ë<4),+�7D>H?�CP58K�7D?�CF+�-,?�+�7�6�74),>@GfKF;M.�CI74)6<4>s+�L!E,3458?�+:N58-,;t<B)`5Q<wL�+�<4),>H;f>@KF>@u8CF?R5:Kn34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL L65:98+�7�74+�-,74+!>8-,KId�C�v>@-,+s58;,)f+�34+�7w<B>M?�>@u8-,CI<4CIJ@+O3D+�K?15:<4CIJ�CF7DLZq

� ��� � ?��@9 " /D"��@+ :1+.'2�>/1"�0"%(*4)'>8G,u@),K�d�74ai+R589�CF-fu,N�.2+6.�CFKIKG,74+M<B),+1<B+�34L XD34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DLM\�<4>_34+Svx+�3p<B>�5:-�d/a,)fCFKF>874>@a,)Ad

<B),5:<�?�KP58CILM7b<B),5:<�<4),+&<434Gf<4)�>@3�v�58KF7DCI<{d�>8v�5M7D<~5Q<B+�L�+�-A<wCF7w3D+�KF5:<BC�J@+O<B>�58-ZCF-,;fCIJ�CF;,G,58K�>@3'<4>5l74>�?�CF58Knu@3D>@G,anq Ì ·

rb),+M^,347D<s<B),CI-,u�<B>_-f>8<BCI?�+�58Ei>@Gf<s?�>@u@-fCI<BC�J@+134+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL CF7�<4)`5:<p<B),CI7s;,>�?�<434CI-,+lvx>@KFKI>g.�7-`5:<4G,3B5:KFKId�CIvp.2+U5:?�?�+�af<_5y3458;,CI?R58K�3D+�;,+S^`-,C�<BCF>8-�>:vs<434Gf<4)nTy?�KF+�5834K�d@N�CIvO<B3DGf<B)�34+�;,G,?�+�7t<4>Gf<4CFKFC�<{d1>@32<4>lCF-A<B+�347DG,E��D+�?S<BC�J@+O58u@3D+�+�LM+�-�<�Nf<B)f+�-W<B)f+�X|<B3DGf<B)f\l>8vû5&a,3D>@a}>874CI<4CF>@-�.�CFKIK};,+�a}+�-,;>@-6<4),+�CI-,;,CIJ�CI;,G`58K�>@3�<B),+w74>�?�CP5:K}u@3D>@G,aWCI- N G,+�7D<BCI>@-nqË��-W<B)f+w>8<4),+�3[),58-,;nNHCIvn.2+�58;,>8af<[<B)f+?�Gf7D<B>8L6583|d�/�XD?�>@3D34+�74ai>@-,;,+�-,?�+�\ 6�-,>8<BCI>@-�>8vË<B3DGf<B)�N�<B),+�-U?�>@u@-,C�<BC�J@+!3D+�KP5Q<BCIJ�CI74LhCF7�a,5:<B+�-�<4KIdv�58KI74+8T�74CI-,?�+15�a,3D>@a}>874CI<4CF>@-_CF7w<434G,+!<4>W<B),+l+��H<4+�-A<p<B)`5:<�CI<�3D+ G`+�?�<B7*/x74>@L�+l587Da}+�?�<B7O>8v,6�<B)f+.05kd6<B),+�.2>@34KI;tCI7�N,C�<B7[<434Gf<4)t>83[v�58KF7DCI<{dM;,+�ai+�-,;f7�>@-�<4),+�.[5Rd�<4),+�.0>834KF;�CI7�58-,;�-,>8<�>@-�<B)f+Ei+�KFCI+�vx7b>@3b>:<B),+�3'?~),583B58?S<B+�34CF7|<BCI?�7b>8v�58-Ad�CF-,;fCIJ�CF;,G,58K�>@3bu834>@G,a�q

�HCF-f?�+s.2+!)`5RJ8+158KF3D+R58;fd�;fCF74?�G,747D+�;�34+�;,+�^,-,CI<4CF>@-,7�>8v�<434Gf<4)nN}<4),+�3D+&CF7�-,>8<wL!G,?~)_<4>�58;,;nN+S�H?�+�af<s<B)`5:<sCI<OLM589:+�7&-f>Z7D+�-,7D+6vx>@3O>@34;fCF-`583|d 74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<B7�� .�)f+�<B)f+�3s<4),+�d/7|<BG,;fd/-`5Q<BG,3D+>@3�7D>H?�CF+S<{dt� <4>Z5:;,>@af<�Nn+�J8+�-=CILMafKFCF?�CI<4KId@N�5W?�>@u@-,C�<BC�J@+!3D+�KP5Q<BCIJ�CI7D<�5Q<4<BC�<BG,;f+8qs��>83�?�>@u8-,CI<4CIJ@+34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL$58L�>@G,-A<B7&<4>�58E`58-f;,>@-,CI-,u_<B)f+Wu@>A58KË>8v'>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ@+�9�-,>k.�KI+�;,u@+6a,G,347DG,+�;�EAdc7D?�C?1+�-f?�+8q �'>g.2+�J8+�3�N�CI<�74+�+�LM7O<B),5:<O74>@L�+l),CI7D<B>834CP5:-,7�58-,;/74>�?�CI>@KF>8u@CF7|<B7�.058-A<O<B>�)`5RJ@+�CI<�E}>8<4).05kd�7�T�5:;,>@af<w5M3D+�KP5Q<BCIJ�CI7D<�5:<4<4CI<4G,;,+�.�CI<4)_34+�74ai+�?S<�<B>�<B),+s-`5:<BGf3B58K�74?�CF+�-,?�+�7�N�58-f;�58-�>8E��D+�?;1ïÔìSãæå ç ï ç`ó ìBú é ì Õ ï`ïðâ�î|ãäìSå óUÑ åæïðö ÑDÒ ïðö:ì~ï é�Ñ öQìBü ÑnÕ â é ìBú�â�ø Õ â é å ÕgÓ�é ö Ñ ïÔö Ñ|Ò �ðë Õ â�ò ç�ÑDÒ ü~ìSògã Ñ7" ïÔö Ñ â ÒðÑ ïðå¸î|ìSãÑ|Õ ïÔå�ïÔå Ñ4ç�ÒÔÑ ì�ãäãäú Ñ� å ç ï Ú â Ò ïÔöQì~ïûïðö Ñ å Ò�ó[Ñ ì Õ å ÕgÓ å ç�ñkÑ í ÕgÑDñ�ç âSã Ñ ãäúbïðö Ò â�ë Ó ö ó[Ñ ì ç ë Ò ì�òQã Ñ ê�ëQì Õ ïÔå�ïÔå Ñ4ç ý:ògëkï�ïÔögå çñ â ÑDç�Õ âSï�å ó[Û ãäúbïðöQì�ï}ïÔö Ñ ú ÒÔÑ|Ó ì Ò�ñ�ç ëQî�ö ÑDÕ ïÔå�ïÔå Ñ4ç ì ç � ç ëgò �xÑ î{ïðåäü Ñ7" å Õ ïÔö Ñ�çðÑ|Õ:ç�Ñ ïðöQì�ïnïðö Ñ å Ònó[Ñ ì Õ å ÕQÓ2é âSëgã ñò Ñ�ç å Ó�Õ åæí:î|ì Õ ïÔãæú0å ÕHG ë ÑDÕ î Ñ4ñ òRú Ñ� ï Ò ì ��ç î|å ÑDÕ ïðåæí:înø�ìSî¬ïðâ ÒÔç�Ö�ç ëQî�ö�ì ç ïðö Ñ�Û8Ñ|Ò�ç â Õ ì�ãäåæïxú2âSøAïðö Ñ å Õ:ñ åæüRå ñ ëQìSã ç î¬å Ñ|Õ��ïðå ç ï�â Ò ïðö Ñbç âRî|åäìSãfî�ö:ì Ò ìSî{ï Ñ|Ò å ç ïðå¸î ç â�øiïðö Ñ[ÓSÒ âSë Û ïðâ é ögå¸î�ö ç ö Ñ ò Ñ ãæâ ÕgÓ�ç�ß{Ü!d�ÕQñkÑ|Ñ4ñAÚ å ÕQç ï Ò ë ó[Ñ|Õ ïÔìSãæå ç ï ç�ó ìBúÒÔÑ|Ó ì ÒÔñ â�ë Ònç î|å ÑDÕ ïÔå�í8î�ïÔö Ñ â Ò å ÑDç ì çDÚ ê�ëgåæï Ñç å ó[Û ãäú Ú ïÔö Ñ�ó â ç ï ç ì�ïðå ç ø�ì�î{ïÔâ Ò ú é ìBú0ïðöQì�ï}ïÔö Ñ öRë ó ì Õ'ó å Õ:ñAÚké å�ïÔöåæï ç å Õ ö ÑDÒðÑDÕ ï�ògåäâSãäâ Ó åäîDì�ã@ãäå ó åæïÔì~ïÔåæâ ÕQçDÚ å ç îDì Û ìSògã Ñ âSøfë ÕQñkÑ|Ò�ç ïÔì Õ:ñ å ÕQÓ ïÔö Ñé â Ò ã ñAÜ

;�Ï -sÑ0é åäãæã`î¬â ÕQç å ñkÑDÒ â Õ ãæú ÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ïÔåæüRå ç�ó ì�ò8âSëgï ç ïÔì~ï Ñ|ó[Ñ|Õ ï ç âSø`ø�ìSî¬ï Ö å Ü ÑSÜ ì�ò8âSëgï é öQì�ï Ñ� å ç ï ç â Ò å ç î¬ã¸ì�å ó0Ñ4ñïðâ Ñ� å ç ï ß{Ú ì ÕQñ ã Ñ ìBü Ñ ì ç å ñkÑ�ÒðÑ ãäì�ïðåäü�å çðó ì�ò8âSëkï Ñ ïðögå¸î|ìSã�â Ò ì ÑDç ïðö Ñ ïðå¸î � ë ñkÓSó[Ñ|Õ ï ç|Ü

� �

Page 12: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

<BC�J�CF7D<-/�+�J8+�-U-`58CIJ8+l34+�58KFCI7D<;6�5:<4<4CI<BGf;,+&.�CI<4)�34+�7Da}+�?�<O<B>�<4),+174>�?�CP5:K�74?�CF+�-,?�+�7�q Ì{¿ �0Gf<O<4)`5:<�CI7CF-f?�>@-,7DCF7|<B+�-A< 9}5Qv�<B+�3'58KIKÔN,3D+�7D+R583D?~)�CF-t),CF7|<B>@3|d@N�58-f;_CF-�a`5:3D<BCI?�G,KF583bCF-�<B)f+s),CI7D<4>@3Dd�>:v�74?�CF+�-,?�+:N+�L�a,KI>gd�7�LM+S<B),>�;,7�<B)`5:<�5834+s-,>8<�3B58;fCF?R5:KFKIdW;,C �}+�3D+�-A<wvx3D>@L <B),>874+!G,7D+�; CI-Z<B)f+&-`5:<4G,3B5:K�7D?�C?1+�-f?�+�7�T27|<BG,;HdHCI-,u1;,>�?�G,L�+�-A<B7�N,;,345k.�CI-,ul<B),+�L�>@7|<b3B5:<4CF>@-,58K}CI-fvx+�3D+�-,?�+�7�N`L6589�CI-,u!CF-f;,G,?�<4CF>@-f7E`587D+�;�>@-c<B)f+�5kJ:58CIKP58EfKF+�;`5:<~5HN25:-,;]74> vx>@3|<B)nq/z�v�5:34u@G,L�+�-A<47l>8v�<B),CI7&<{d�a}+�CI-]a,)AdH7DCF?�7�>83E,CI>@KF>@u:d];,CF;�-,>8<658KFKI>k. G,76<4>c583D34C�J@+Z5:<W3D+R587D>@-`58E,K�dy34+�KFCP5:E,KF+�?�>8-,?�KIG,74CI>@-,7�N[.�),5:<63D+R587D>@-.2>@G,KF;�<4),+�3D+lE}+!<4>W<B3DG,7D<�<4),+�LÎCF-�),CI7D<4>@3DdZ>@3�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u8dfj�(*)Ad 74ai+R5:9_CF-�5W3D+R58KICF7|<�L�>H;,+58Ei>@Gf<O),CI7D<4>@34CI?R58K�?R5:<4+�u@>@3DCF+�7�N�74Gf?~)c587�4�G,),-,CF58-�a`583458;,CFu8LM7�NnCIvËCI<�CF7O58-/CFKIKFG,7DCF>@-t<B>�74ai+R589CF-y5�3D+R58KICF7|<lLM>�;,+�5:E}>@GH<l74?�CF+�-A<4CI^`?�?�>@-,?�+�af<B7 /�.�),CF?~)�583D+�CF-cv�58?S<lL!G,?~)�LM>834+Wa,3D+�?�CF74+�KId;,+S^`-,+�; 6�7DG,?~)�587�+�KF+�?S<B3D>@-,7�>@3 �5J���j

� � � � +;/DC�? ?@'2? �@"%$&��'�:1+ '2�>/D"��0"2(D4BZ+�<4),>�;,>@KF>8u@CF?�58K�34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL CF7'-,>8<�CF-_C�<B7D+�KIv5Ma,),CIKF>@7D>@a,),CI?R58K�ai>@7DCI<BCI>@-�9�CI<�CF7'3B5Q<B),+�3�Nn5:7

<B)f+!-`58L�+sCI-,;,CI?R5:<4+�7�N�5674+S<�>8vL�+�<4),>�;,>@KF>8u@CF?�58K�a,34CI-,?�CIa,KF+�7�q'rb),CF7w34+�KF5:<BC�J�CF74L CF7�5:7474>�?�CF5:<B+�;<B>�;,+SJ@+�KI>@a,L�+�-A<B7�CF-�<B),+p),CI7D<B>83Ddt58-,;Z74>�?�CI>@KF>@u:dW>8v�74?�CI+�-,?�+s<4)`5:<�E}+�uA58-t;,G,34CI-,u1<B),+ � � � � 7G,-,;f+�3[<B)f+�E`58-,-f+�3b>8v�<B)f+�74>21�?R58KIKF+�;yX,��<434>@-,u-73D>@u@3B5:LML�+�\&58-,;W.�),CI?~)t),5kJ8+�)`58;�58-�+�-,>@3�1L�>@G,7[CILMa`5:?�<[CI-6<B)f+�^`+�KI;�>8vû74>�?�CF>8KF>@u8d�>8v�7D?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?�9�-,>k.�KF+�;fu@+8/:� � 4>62587[.0+�KFK�587b>@Gf<474CF;f+<B),5:<^`+�KI; /�CF-1?�G,KI<4G,3B58Kf7D<BGf;,CF+�7�N�58-A<B),3D>@ai>@KF>@u:d@N@+S<B?8qa6Sq Ì{Ì rb),+F��<B3D>@-,u�734>@u@3458L�LM+[af34>@ai>@74+�7<B>pu@C�J@+�5s?R5:G,7B58Ki58?�?�>@Gf-�<0>8v�<4),+�58?�?�+�af<B58-,?�+�>8v�7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?�CI;,+R587�NA.�),CFKI+'3D+�LM58CF-fCF-,utXDCILMa,583 1<BCF58KF\ /�>@3tXD7|d�LML�+�<434CF?�58KF\�6�587�<4>�.�)f+�<B)f+�3O<B),+Sd�5834+!<434G,+1>@3�v�5:KF74+:N�3B5:<4CF>@-,58K�>83�CF34345:<BCI>@-`58Kðq��+�34+OCF7b)f>g. ��5kJ�CI;��0KF>�>@3[KF5kd�7�>@Gf<b<4),+Oa,34CI-,?�CIa,KF+�7[vx>@3[<B)f+p-f+�. 7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u8dM>8v�9�-f>g.�KI+�;,u8+8T

� ¶ �ð§û²�ªgµ�¤�¦ ´ ¡Ë®~£kµ�°¬£k¤�È:§¬ �£R§�¥�°~ÈQ®Bªg±�®B¡~­|±�¡�¦p²Ë¥�§¬ �§¬ A¡Ë®Bªg±�¦�¥¨§¬¥¨ªg±�°�²2 �¥�®|  ´ ­|¥�±A¾b£ ´ ªgµA§´ ¡�¤�¥¨¡~«@ªk­�°{§¬£R§{¡�°�ªk«�½@±AªS²2¤¨¡�¦A¾k¡k¶nÆ2£R§¬µA­D£k¤�¤¨©�§¬ A¡~­|¡�²Ë¥�¤�¤ ´ ¡ûªk§¬ �¡~­�§�©8¯f¡�°�ªk«�®~£kµ�°{¡�°�£R¯�£R­¬§«I­|ªg¹Y°{ª@®~¥�£k¤,ªg±A¡�°�²2 �¥�®| !²2¥�¤�¤,®Bª:ªk¯,¡~­|£R§{¡�¥�± ´ ­|¥�±�¾g¥�±A¾�£ ´ ªgµ�§ ´ ¡�¤�¥¨¡~«ð¶� ¶ �Ô§[²�ªgµ�¤�¦ ´ ¡�¥�¹O¯�£R­¬§¬¥�£k¤}²Ë¥¨§¬ 6­¬¡�°{¯,¡�®B§[§{ªl§{­|µA§¬ W£k±�¦W«P£k¤�°¬¥�§�©kÈ`­|£R§¬¥¨ªg±�£k¤�¥¨§�©Mªk­�¥¨­¬­|£�º§¬¥¨ªg±�£k¤�¥�§�©kÈ�°¬µ�®~®B¡�°|°ªk­Ë«P£k¥�¤�µA­|¡k¶���ªk§¬ �°|¥�¦A¡�°�ªk«�§¬ A¡�°{¡'¦�¥�®| Aªk§{ªg¹O¥�¡�°²Ë¥�¤�¤H­¬¡�É8µ�¥¨­¬¡[¡B»@¯�¤�£�º±�£R§¬¥¨ªg±`¶� ¶ �ð§û²�ªgµ�¤�¦ ´ ¡Ë°{©@¹O¹�¡~§{­|¥�®~£k¤�¥�±p¥�§¬°û°{§ð©8¤¨¡2ªk«,¡B»8¯�¤�£k±�£R§¬¥¨ªg±`¶��� A¡2°¬£k¹�¡Ë§ð©:¯,¡�°�ªk«`®~£kµ�°{¡²�ªgµ�¤�¦!¡B»8¯H¤�£k¥�±`ÈA°¬£S©kÈ�§{­|µA¡�£k±�¦l«F£k¤�°{¡ ´ ¡�¤�¥¨¡~«P°~¶� ¶ �Ô§²�ªgµ�¤�¦ ´ ¡[­¬¡���¡B»@¥¨¢k¡k¶ �Ô±!¯�­D¥�±�®~¥¨¯�¤�¡2¥¨§¬°¯H£R§{§{¡~­|±�°ªk«�¡B»8¯H¤�£k±�£R§¬¥¨ªg±!²�ªgµ�¤�¦l �£S¢k¡�§{ª´ ¡�£R¯�¯�¤�¥�®~£ ´ ¤¨¡2§{ªs°{ª8®~¥�ªg¤¨ªk¾k©&¥�§¬°{¡�¤¨«Ô¶ ����¤¨ª:ªk­ ����� ÈH¯�¶ ���D¶

��>k. CF7&>8-,+W<B>�Gf-,;,+�3D7D<B58-,;y<B),+W7|d�LML�+�<43Dd=58-,;]<B),+6CFL�a`583D<4CP58KICI<{dZ<B),+�74+�7Bj z{-�>834;,+�3<B>/74+�+Z<4),+�;,C ��?�GfKI<{d@N2KF+S<MGf7�^`3D7D<M?�>@-f74CF;f+�31a}+�34?�+�af<4CF>@-�CF-y+�J8+�3Dd�;`5Rd�KFC�vx+ /x.2+8m�KFKb<BG,3D-�<4>74?�CF+�-�<4CI^`?�<4),+�>834CF+�7�CF-�5lLM>8LM+�-�<�6Sq0��G,a,ai>@74+O<B)`5Q<�74+�J8+�3458K�>8v�G,7'5834+�7|<~58-,;fCF-,u1>@Gf<4;,>�>@347bCI-<B)f+�3B58CI-nN,58-f;t7D>@L�+�>@-,+w7B5Rd�7�T&XDz�<bCF7b3458CF-fCF-,up<B>�;`5Rd@q�\Urb)`5Q<�7D<~5Q<B+�L�+�-A<�+��faf34+�7D74+�7�5!Ei+�KFCI+�v�9;ðà7�RÑ|Ñ � â( ~ì�ã}ì ÕQñ @�Ò å¸î ó â Õ ï Ö�×DØ�ØSÙgÚ î�öQì Û�Ü A�ß ø�â ÒËÒðÑ ã Ñ üBì Õ ïËê�ëQâ�ï Ñ4ç ø Ò â ó [ ëQö Õ�Ú,õgÑ ú Ñ|Ò ì�ò Ñ|ÕQñ�Ú @ ì ÒÔÕgÑDçJI

@ ãæâRâ Ò ì ÕQñ�õ â�ë ÒðÑ R Ú ìSãæâ ÕgÓ2é åæïðö�ì ó â ÒÔÑñkÑ ï�ì�åäã Ñ4ñ î Ò åæïðå¸ê�ë ÑSÜ; ;7�RÑ|Ñ < ì�ë ñ ì Õ�Öx×4ØSÙg×�Úg×DØ�Ø�T ì ß{Ú(� ã Ñ RDì8 Öx×4ØSØ8A ì Úk×4ØSØ8A ò ß ì ÕQñ [ åæïÔî�ö ÑDÒ�Öx×4ØSØSÙ�ß ø�â Ò�ÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ï ÑDñ î Ò å�ïÔåäî|å çðóbç â�ø@ïðö Ñ

� ï Ò â ÕgÓ � Ò â Ó�Ò ì ó[ó0Ñ�Ü X â�ï ÑËÛ ì Ò ïÔåäî|ëgãäì Ò ãäú [ åæïÔî�ö Ñ|Ò4ù ç î Ò åæïðå¸î¬å çðó âSø`ïðö Ñ � õ â�ë Ò â Ó�ó ì ç âSø � î¬å Ñ|Õ î Ñ!� ïÔë ñ å ÑDç:"Öx×4ØSØ�ÙgÚRÛgÛ�ÜQÝ�Ù I�A =S߬ÚRé ögåäî�öwå ç ê�ëgå�ï Ñ�ç å ó åæã¸ì Ò ïÔâbâSë Ò â é�Õ î Ò å�ïÔåäê�ë Ñ�Ü

��B

Page 13: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

),>k.%5834+'.0+�<4>l+S�Ha,KP5:CF-6<4),CF7[Ei+�KICF+Sv'XD?R5:G,7B58KIKId�\�j�(=+�KFKÔN�-,>l>@-f+w<B>�;`5Rd69�-,>k.�7[<4),+�?�>@L�a,KI+�<B+;,+S<~58CIKF7w>:vË<4),+!?�58G,7B5:K�LM+�?~)`58-,CI74L�7�NnEfGf<�CI<w74+�+�L�7�>@EAJHCI>@G,7w<4)`5:<�a,583D<�>:vË<4),+!+��fafKP58-`5Q<BCF>8-CF-AJ8>@KIJ8+�7l<B),+�v�58?S<1<B)`5:<1C�<134+�58KFK�d=CI7l3B58CI-,CF-,uZ<B>�;`5Rd@qyz�vw7D>@L�+�>@-,+�7458CF;]<B),5:<1CI<1CI7l3B58CI-,CF-,u.�),+�-WCI<�CI7Ë-f>8<RN�>@-,+'L�CFu@)A<<B)fCF-,9&<4)`5:<Ë),+'CF7��D>@9�CF-fus>@3<4)`5:<Ë),+'CF7�LM+�-A<~58KIKId!;fCF7D<4G,34Ei+�; 9HE,GH<<B)f+s+��fafKP58-`5Q<BCF>8-,7'.2>@G,KI;ZEi+OJ@+�3|d�5:7Dd�LML�+�<434CI?R58KðN,;,+�ai+�-f;,CF-,uM>@-Z.�)f+�<B)f+�3wC�<'CF7�3B58CI-,CF-fu�>83-,>8<�q Ì �

��58?�+�;t.�C�<B)�<B),CI7ba,34>@EfKF+�LtN,7DG,a,ai>@3D<4+�347'>8vû<B),+>��<434>@-fuC734>8u@3B58L�L�+�?�>@GfKF;Z58;,L�CI<[.�)`5Q<.2+U745kd vx>83�>@34;,CI-`583|de9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+8N�EfGf<tL658CI-A<~58CI-e<B)`5:<tC�<�;,>�+�7t-,>8<t58a,afKIde<4>�7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+8TVCF-*<B),+/KP5:<D<B+�3�N�3D+R58KICI<{de.2>@G,KI;%a,KF5kdeKFCI<D<BKI+�>@3t-,>V3D>@KF+�CF-�?�>8-,7D<43B58CI-,CF-,uy>@Gf3Ei+�KFCI+�vx7�q Ì � ��>k.2+�J@+�3�N�<B)fCF7�?�KP58CIL KF>�>@9�7wa`583|<BCI?�G,KF5834K�d�CFL�a,KP58Gf74CFEfKF+8N`7DCF-,?�+!74?�CF+�-�<4CI^`?15:?�<BC�J�CI<{d� v�583wLM>@3D+&7D>�<4)`58- +SJ@+�3|d�;`5Rd�KFCIvx+�� CF7�74+S<OG,a /x<B)f34>@G,u8) +S�Ha}+�34CILM+�-�<47�N�+S<B?8qa6Ua,3D+�?�CF74+�KId74>M587b<B>1LM5898+cJ�5:<BGf34+OCI<474+�K�v�?�>@-,7|<B3B5:CF-�>@G,3bEi+�KICF+�vx7�5:E}>@GH<�CI<'587b7|<B34>8-,u@KId�587ba}>87474CIE,KF+:q

��+�<Rm�7�?�>@-,74CI;,+�3�N�>@-f?�+l58u@58CF-nNi5�?�>@-,?�34+S<B+l+S�f58L�a,KI+8T0(*)AdZ;,CF;_<4),+ EG,3D>@ai+R58- 7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,??�>8LML!Gf-,CI<{dyEi+�?�>@LM+_?�>@-AJ�CF-,?�+�; >8v�<4),+_<434Gf<4) >8vcJ�+S.b<B>@-fCP58- L�+�?~)`5:-,CF?�7674>8LM+S<BCFL�+tE}+;1<{.2+�+�- � � ��� 5:-,; � � K � j E�-f;,>@G,Ef<4+�;,K�dU5ZJ:5834CI+�<{d�>8vb)fCF7D<4>@34CI?R58KðN�74>�?�CF>8KF>@u@CI?R58KðN�CF;,+�>@KF>8u@CF?�58K58-,;=a}>@KICI<4CF?R5:K�v�58?�<4>@347sL!G,7|<!a,KF5kdU5ta`583D<&CF-/<B),CI7&+S�Ha,KF58-`5:<4CF>@- � >8-,+6L!Gf7D<!+��Ha,KP58CI-nN�vx>83+S�f58L�a,KI+8N:.�)Ad J�+�.b<4>@-,CF58-!L�+�?~)`58-fCF?�7�.[587�5:?�?�+�af<B+�; N G,CF?~9�KIdsCF- E�-fu@KP58-f;!E,Gf<L�>@3D+27DKF>k.�KIdCF-U�`3B58-f?�+ Ì ' � EfGf<&?�+�3|<~58CI-,KId ��� � "�a,583D<s>8v0<4),+�+S�Ha,KP5:-`5:<BCI>@- /ð58-,;=5t345:<B)f+�3pCFL�a}>@3|<~58-A<a`583|<l5:<s<B)`5Q<;6pL&G,7D<&E}+�<B)`5:<s<B),+6a,KP58-f+�<B7&58-,;c?�>@L�+�<B7&34+R5:KFKId�;f>�LM>kJ8+ /x<4> 5ZJ8+�3Dd=),CFu8);,+�u@34+�+[>8v�58afa,34>R�HCFLM5:<BCI>@-nNk<B)f>@G,u@)!-f>8<�+��f58?�<4KId 6�587�a,34+�;,CF?S<B+�;lE�d>J'+�.b<B>8-,CP58-&LM+�?~)`58-,CI?�7�q Ì +

�[<2<4),+'34CF7D9l>8vnEi+R5Q<BCF-fus5O;,+�58;6),>83474+:NHKI+�<ËG,7Ë34+�a,),3B5:74+w>8G,3�?�34C�<BC N Gf+'>:v�<B)f+��<434>@-fu 734>Z1u@3458LML�+8m�7�74>�?�CI>@KF>@u8CF?R5:K@34+�;,G,?�<4CF>@-fCF74LY5:7�5 �," � � ��%S�:�5� ��� �� � ��� � � q I0>@-,74CI;,+�3û<B),+Ëvx>@KFKI>k.�CF-,u<B)f>@G,u@)A<�1�+S�Hai+�34CILM+�-A<RT0�HGfa,a}>874+w<4)`5:<05 ��58a,KF58?�CF58-M;f+�L�>@-6.2+�34+�<B>&u8CIJ@+�G,7[5:KFK`?�>8-,?�+�CIJ:58E,KI+CF-Hvx>@34LM5:<BCI>@-158Ei>@Gf<Ë74+SJ@+�-�<4+�+�-�<4) 1{?�+�-A<BGf3Dd E-,u@KF58-,;1<B)`5:<2?�>8G,KF;�CF-M58-Adl.[5Rd�Ei+�?�58KFKI+�;�74>�?�C?1>@KI>@u@CF?�58K�>83'af7Dd�?~),>@KI>@u@CF?�58KÔTË58KIKn<B),+p?�>8- G`CF?S<B7�Ei+�<{.2+�+�- L�+�L&E}+�347�>8v�<4),+>)'>kdA5:K ��>H?�CF+�<{d8Ni58KFK<B)f+p;,5:<~5l58Ei>@Gf<�+�?�>@-f>@LMCI?�a,3D>H;,Gf?�<BCI>@-t58-,;�?�KF58747b3D+�KF5:<BCI>@-,7�NH+�<4?8q���+�<Rm�7�+�J8+�-_CI-,?�KIG,;,+�;f>H?;1G,L�+�-A<B7�<B),5:<Ë)`5RJ@+wEi+�+�-6;,+�7D<434>kd@+�;�58-,;Ma,34C�J85Q<B+b?�>8-�J8+�3D7B5:<4CF>@-,7Ë<B)`5Q<Ë.2+�3D+w-,+SJ@+�3034+�?�>@3D;,+�;�q; O �RÑ|ÑlÐ�Ò â çÔç ì ÕQñ <�Ñ üRå�ïðï Ö�×DØ�Ø8AQÚûÛgÛ�Ü =�Þ I =�Ù�ß ø�â Ò ì ç å ó åæã¸ì Ò�ñ å ç î|ë çðç åäâ Õ�Ü � ø2î|âSë Ò�ç�Ñ�Ú�Ñ ü Ñ|Õ â Ò�ñ å Õ ì Ò ú

Û8Ñ|Ò î Ñ|Û ïðåäâ Õ å ç � ç âRî|åäìSã " å Õ0ç â ó0ÑnçðÑ|ÕQçðÑSÜfõ â ÒfÑ� ì ó0Û ã Ñ�Ú å Õ â Ò�ñkÑ|Ò ïðâ ç�ÑDÑ î¬ã Ñ ì Ò ãäú Ú�ç â ó[Ñ}Û:Ñ â Û ã Ñ}ÕQÑ|ÑDñ�Ñ ú ÑDÓ ã¸ì çÔç�Ñ4çïðö:ì~ïwì ÒðÑsç âkî¬å¸ì�ãäãäú ÛgÒ â ñ ëQî ÑDñAÜ�� â ÒÔÑ ø�ë ÕQñ ì ó[Ñ|Õ ïÔìSãæãäú Ú ïÔö Ñ&ó0Ñ ì Õ å ÕgÓ âSøïðö Ñsé â ÒÔñQç ïðö Ò â�ë Ó ö é ögå¸î�ö�â ÕQÑÑ� kÛgÒÔÑDçÔçðÑDç â ÕgÑSù ç}Û:ÑDÒ î Ñ|Û ïÔåæâ ÕQç å ç ïðâ ç â ó[ÑûÑ� ï Ñ|Õ ï�å ÕHG ë Ñ|Õ î ÑDñ òRú[ïÔö Ñ�ÑDÕ ü�å Ò â Õgó[Ñ|Õ ï�å Õ�é ögåäî�ö�ïðö Ñ ú�ì ÒÔÑ ë çðÑDñAÜ� â ó0Ñ ïðå ó[ÑDç�ÒðÑ ãäì�ïðåäü�å ç ï ç å ÕQç å ç ïwïðöQì�ïwì�ãäã�ïðö Ñ úWî|ãäìSå ó å ç ïÔöQì~ï ç î¬å Ñ|Õ î Ñ å ç � ç âkî¬å¸ì�ã " å ç�ç â ó[ÑpÑ ê�ëQì�ãäãæú é�Ñ ì8 çðÑ|ÕQçðÑ ý,ògëkïËïðöQì�ï ç�ÑDÑ|óbç ïÔâOë ç ãäå9 Ñ ì�î¬â ÕQç å ñkÑDÒ ìSògã Ñ0é ì~ï Ñ|Ò å ÕQÓ8��ñ â é�Õ âSø�ïÔö Ñ � ç ú ó[ó[Ñ ï Ò ú " ïðö Ñ4ç å ç|ÜDd�ÕQñkÑDÑDñAÚé ö ÑDÕ â ÕgÑ�ç ïðë ñ å ÑDç�Û:ÑDÒ î Ñ|Û ïÔåæâ Õ[ç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïÔå�í:îDì�ãäãæú Ú ïðö Ñ|ÒÔÑ å ç`Õ â � ç ú ó[ó[Ñ ï Ò ú "QÚ å Õ ì Õ ú ó0Ñ ì Õ å ÕgÓ ø�ëgã çðÑ|ÕQçðÑSÚ ò Ñ ï é�Ñ|ÑDÕöQìSãæãäëQî¬å Õ ì�ïðåäâ Õ ì ÕQñ î¬â ÒðÒÔÑ î¬ï Û8Ñ|Ò î ÑDÛ ïðåäâ Õ�Ü Q�Õ:ñ ïðö Ñ�ñ åæ÷ ÑDÒðÑDÕ î Ñ ò Ñ ï é�Ñ|ÑDÕ ïÔö Ñ ï é â�å ç,ÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ï Ñ4ñ ïÔâ�ögâ é ïÔö Ñ�é â Ò ã ñÒÔÑ ì�ãäãäú�å çDÚgç â2ïÔöQì~ï�ïÔö Ñ ã¸ì~ï�ï Ñ|Ò å ç�Û ì Ò ïÔãæú'îDì�ë ç ì�ãäãäú ÒðÑ4ç�Û â ÕQç åäògã Ñ ø�â Ò î¬â ÒÔÒÔÑ î{ï Û8Ñ|Ò î Ñ|Û ïðåäâ ÕQçDÜ;SP7�RÑ|ÑÕ â�ï Ñ / ìSò:â~ü Ñ ø�â Ò ì ÕwÑ� kÛ ãäåäî|å�ïûì çðçðÑ|Ò ïðåäâ Õ â�øfïðögå ç ïðö ÑDç å ç òRú Y ì ÒÔÒ ú�á}â�ãæãäå ÕQç|Ü;SU7�RÑ|Ñ�Ú ø�â Ò�Ñ� ì ó[Û ã ÑSÚ�@�Ò ë ÕgÑ ï Ö�×DØSÝQ×4ß ì ÕQñ� âSògò ç ì ÕQñ ìSî¬â�ò Ö�×DØSØ =S߬Ü; W ��Ò�ó â ÒðÑsÛgÒÔÑ î¬å çðÑ ãäú ôMè ö Ñ|ÒÔÑ å ç ì�ü~ì ç ï�ò:â ñ ú�âSø Ñ� ï ÒÔÑ|ó[Ñ ãæú�î|â Õ üRå Õ î|å ÕQÓ ì ç ï Ò â Õ â ó åäîDì�ã Ñ üRå ñgÑ|Õ î Ñ å Õ

ç ë ÛgÛ â Ò ï�âSø�ïðö Ñ ò Ñ ãäå Ñ øfïðöQì�ï}ïÔö ÑÛ ã¸ì ÕgÑ ï ç ì ÕQñ î¬â ó0Ñ ï ç�ñ â ó â~ü Ñ[Ö ïÔâ0ì0ü ÑDÒ ú[ögå Ó ö ñkÑDÓSÒÔÑ|Ñ âSøfì ÛgÛgÒ â å ó ì~ïÔåæâ Õ�ÚïðöQâSë Ó ö Õ âSï Ñ� ìSî¬ïðãäú ß ì ç�ÛgÒÔÑDñ å¸î{ï ÑDñ òRú X�ÑDé ïðâ Õ åäì Õsó[Ñ î�ö:ì Õ å¸î ç ýHì ÕQñ � �!ïðögå ç ò Ñ ãäå Ñ ø�å ç î|â ÒÔÒðÑ î{ï Ú ïÔö Ñ|Õ åæï�å çïðö Ñ ø�ìSî¬ï�âSø`ïðögå ç�ó âSïðåäâ Õ1Ö ì ÕQñ�Õ â�ï ó[ÑDÒðÑ ãæú�âSë Ò ò Ñ ãäå Ñ ø�å Õ å�ï ß ïðö:ì~ïûø�â Òðóbç�Û ì Ò ïûâSø`ïðö Ñ2Ñ� kÛ ã¸ì Õ ì�ïðåäâ Õ âSø é öRúïðö Ñ'Ñ å Ó ö�ï Ñ|Ñ|Õ ïÔö � î Ñ|Õ ïðë Ò ú ^ ë Ò â Û8Ñ ì Õlç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïðåæí:î�î|â ó[ó ë Õ å�ïxú!î|ì ó[Ñ ïðâOò Ñ ãäå Ñ ü Ñ å Õ ïÔö Ñ ï Ò ëkïÔölâ�ø X�ÑDé ïðâ Õ åäì Õó[Ñ î�öQì Õ å¸î çDÜ

��f

Page 14: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

�w;f;U<B>�<B)fCF7O5�u@CFuA5:-�<4CF?l7DG,a}+�3 1Ôv�587D<p?�>8LMa,GH<B+�3O<B),5:<p?R58-/a,34>�?�+�747&58KFK�<4),CF7OCI-fvx>@34LM5:<4CF>@- 5:7L!G,?~)_587';,+�7DCF34+�;nq��0Gf<�;,>M-,>8<'CF-,?�KFG,;f+s5:-�dZ587|<B3D>@-,>@L�CF?�58Kn;`5:<B5 /x74G,?~) 5:7D4�+�afKF+�3�mæ7'>@E,7D+�3�1J:5:<BCI>@-,7,6Sq�J�>k.ON�<43Dd_<4>�XDa,3D+�;,CI?�<B\Wvx3D>@Lh<B),>@7D+l;`5:<B5M<B)`5Q<�74?�CF+�-A<4CF7D<47�.�CFKIK�58?�?�+�af<p56<B),+�>@3DdCF-1.�),CI?~)6<B),+'u@345kJ�C�<~5:<4CF>@-`5:Kfvx>@34?�+�;f+�?R5Rd�70.�C�<B)1<B),+�CF-AJ@+�3474+�7 N G`583D+w>8v}<B),+�;,CF7|<~58-f?�+8N�3B5Q<B),+�3<B),58-t<4),+OCF-AJ@+�347D+s?�G,E}+:q �'>k. ?�>8G,KF;�>@-,+O;,>�CI<~jt(*)`5:<'9�CF-f;t>:v�3D+R587D>@-,CF-fuM?�>@G,KF;�>@-f+pGf74+kjz�<�7D+�+�LM7�>8E�J�CI>@G,7�<4>WG,7'<B)`5:<�<B),CI7�3D+�7DG,KI<w74CFL�a,K�d�?R58-,-f>8<�Ei+ XD+���<B3B5:?�<B+�;,\Wvx34>8L <B),+!u8CIJ@+�-;`5:<B5fq Ì <

J�>k. 74G,a,ai>@7D+8N,EAdM?�>@-A<B34587D<�Nf<B),5:<b>@-,+'.[5:-�<47[<B>lu@C�J@+w5&?R58Gf7B58K�5:?�?�>8G,-A<b>8v�Ei+�KFCI+�v�CI-�587�1<B3D>@KF>8u8d@q�z{-�<B),CI7n?R5:74+�CI<�CI7�5:<�KI+R587|<�?�>@-f?�+�C�J:58E,KF+�<4)`5:<�>@-f+?�>@G,KI;�>@Ef<B58CF-O5ba,G,3D+�K�d�74>�?�CI>@KF>8u@CF?�58K>@3Oa,7|dH?~)f>@KF>@u8CF?R5:K25:?�?�>8G,-A<&>8v0<B),+�CF-,?�CF;,+�-,?�+�>8v074G,?~)cEi+�KICF+Svx7�N�.�CI<B)f>@Gf<p+�J8+�3&CI-AJ@>@9�CF-fuZ<B)f+u@>�>H;�+�J�CI;,+�-,?�+w7DG,a,ai>@3D<4CF-,uO<B),>874+wEi+�KICF+Svx7�� 7DCFL�a,KId&E}+�?R58G,7D+w<B)f+�34+'CF7Ë-,>p74G,?~)�+SJ�CF;,+�-,?�+:q Ì @rb),CI7&?�>8LMa`5:34CF7D>@-=Ei+�<{.2+�+�- J�+�.b<4>@-,CF58-cL�+�?~)`58-fCF?�7&58-,;]5:7D<B3D>@KF>8u8d�74),>k.�7l?�KF+R5:34KId/5Z-,+�?;1+�7D7B583|d�58-,;�?�34G,?�CP58K5:7Dd�LML�+�<43DdZCF-�<4),+1+S�Ha,KP5:-`5:<B>83DdZ74?~),+�LM+:TpCI-�<B),+l>8-,+l?R587D+8N�+�J�CI;,+�-,?�+L!G,7|<�+�-�<4+�3�CF-A<B>658-AdZ745:<BCI7Dv�58?S<B>@3|dt+S�Ha,KP5:-`5:<BCI>@-nN�CF-t<B),+s>8<B)f+�3'?R587D+!-,>8<�qFJ'>8<B+:N�>8v�?�>@G,3D74+:N<B),5:<0C�vnd@>8GW)`58a,ai+�-M<B>&Ei+�KICF+SJ@+ /�.�34>@-fu@KId 6�<B)`5:<0587|<B34>8KF>@u8d � ��.2+�KFKi74Gfa,a}>83D<B+�;WEAd6+SJ�CF;,+�-,?�+:N<B)f+�-l<B),CI7�v�58?S<B>@3 � � � � � �!a,3D+�74GfL658EfKIds+�-A<B+�3CF-A<B>�.�)`5Q<�d@>@G13D+�uA583D;1587�5w745:<BCI7Dv�58?S<B>@3|d&?�58G,7B5:K58?�?�>@G,-A<'>8v�E}+�KFCI+�v�CF-�587|<B34>8KF>@u8d8q

z{-_7DG,LMLM583|d@N�CI<'74+�+�L�7�?�KF+�583'<4)`5:<�58-_58;,+ N G`5Q<B+&?�58G,7458K�+S�Ha,KP5:-`5:<BCI>@-t>8v�),>k.Y7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?<B)f+�>@3DCF+�7'?�>8LM+O<B>�E}+s58?�?�+�aH<B+�;�.2>@G,KI;_)`5RJ8+s<B>�?�>8L!E,CF-f+�XD-,5:<BG,3458KF\�58-f; XD7D>H?�CP58KI\1v�5:?�<B>8347�N�DG,7|<�587lvx>@3!>@3D;,CF-`5:3Ddcai+�3D?�+�af<BCI>@-nqy�wv�?�>@G,3D74+:N2+��fafKP58-,CI-,u 74?�CF+�-�<4CI^`?�9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+�CF7&L!G,?~)L�>@34+�?�>@LMafKFCF?�5:<B+�;W<B)`5:-t+��Ha,KP58CI-,CF-fula}+�34?�+�af<BCI>@-nN,.�),CI?~)ZCI7b?�>@L�a,KICF?R5Q<B+�;�+�-,>@G,u8)nq

E�5834KICF+�3lCI-]<B),CI7l+�74745Rd@N[.2+ZLM58;,+�58-�58-`5:KF>@u8d=E}+S<{.0+�+�-e7D?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?�CF-AJ@+�7D<BCIuA5:<4CF>@-,715:-,;ai>@KFCI?�+l+�- N GfCF34CI+�7�q I0>@-A<BCI-�G,CF-,u�<4),CF7p58-`5:KF>@u8d8N�>@-,+1?�>@GfKF;/7B5Rd <B)`5Q<s>8-�<4>@KF>8u@CF?�58K�3D+�KP5Q<BCIJ�CI74L58L�>@G,-A<B72<B>l7B5Rd�CF-fu!<B)`5:<b<4),+�3D+�CF72-,>1>@E��D+�?S<BC�J@+�v�58?S<b>8v�<B),+�LM5:<D<B+�3058Ei>@Gf<[.�),+S<B),+�3'5!a`583 1<BCI?�G,KF583b74Gf74ai+�?�<wCF7�CF-f-,>H?�+�-A<�>@3�u@G,CFK�<{d@Nf.�)fCFKF+O+�a,CF7|<B+�L�>@KI>@u@CF?�58K�3D+�KF5:<BC�JHCI74L CF7b<B),+s587D74+�3|<BCI>@-<B),5:<&-f>_L�+�<B)f>H;/>8vb+�- N G,CF3|d�?R58-cEi+�7B58CI;/<4>_Ei+M>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ8+�KId/Ei+�<D<B+�3O<B),58-]58-,>:<B),+�3 /x+8q�u,qIN?R5:34+�vxGfKFKIdl58-`58K�dH��CF-,u�^`-fu@+�3Da,34CI-�<47ËJ8+�3D74G,7[afKP58-A<BCI-,uO+�J�CF;f+�-,?�+�6Sq!Bt+�<B)f>H;,>8KF>@u@CI?R58Kf34+�KF5:<BC�J�CF74LtN>@-_<4),+&>:<B),+�3�)`58-,;�Nn58L�>@G,-A<B7'<B>�<B3Dd�CI-,u6<B>MG,-,;,+�347|<~58-,;�),>k. <4),+!ai>@KFCI?�+8N8�DG,;fu@+!58-f;M�DG,3DdEi+�?�>8LM+�?�>8-�J�CI-,?�+�;6>8v��!m�72u@GfCFKI<�.�CI<B)f>@Gf<�+�J8+�3Ë<~589�CF-fupCI-A<B>s58?�?�>@G,-A<�<B),+�v�58?�<�<4)`5:<RN�CI-�7D>@L�+?R5:74+�7�5:<�KI+R587|<RNf<4),+�3D+sL�CFu@)A<bEi+Ou@>�>H;�+SJHCI;,+�-f?�+Ovx>@3��!m�7�u@G,CFK�<Rq

��+�<lG,7l?�>@-,7DCF;,+�3!CF-=<4),CF7sKFCIu@)A<!58-y5:7474+�3D<4CF>@-]>8vFI0>8KFKFCI-,7s58-,;�7CF-,?~)y5:E}>@GH<-ECF-,7|<B+�CI-nm�7<B)f+�>@3|d�>8v�34+�KF5:<BC�J�CI<{diT

� ¡�¤�£R§¬¥�¢8¥¨§ð©t¶~¶�¶�¥�°0£!§{­DµA§¬ W²Ë �¥�®D W®~£k¹�¡O¥�±:§{ª ´ ¡�¥�±A¾&£k°'£s­|¡�°¬µ�¤¨§[ªk«�¦�¡�®~¥�°¬¥¨ªg±�°[£ ´ ªgµA§ AªS²]²�¡�°¬ Aªgµ�¤�¦!¤�¥¨¢k¡0ªgµA­�°¬®~¥¨¡�±:§¬¥¨¼�®[¤�¥¨¢k¡�°�È@£k±�¦l AªS²]²�¡�°¬ Aªgµ�¤�¦&¤�¥�®B¡�±�®B¡[ªgµA­�°¬®~¥¨¡�±:§¬¥¨¼�®ª ´ °{¡~­¬¢R£R§¬¥¨ªg±�°��}¥¨§b²�£k°�£l§{­|µ�§¬  ´ ­¬ªgµA¾g :§�£ ´ ªgµA§ ´ ©W£R¾k­¬¡~¡�¹�¡�±:§'§{ª1£R¾k­|¡~¡s£ ´ ªgµA§�±A¡~²§¬ �¥�±A¾g°�¶ �Ô§�²�£k°û±Aªk§�£b§{­DµA§¬ �«Fªk­|®B¡�¦Oªg±sµ�° ´ ©�§¬ A¡2¥�±A¡B»@ªk­|£ ´ ¤¨¡¤¨ªk¾g¥�®�ªk«f£�°¬¡~§�ªk«`®B­|µ�®~¥�£k¤

;S\ � ø�î¬âSë ÒÔçðÑSÚ â ÕgÑ îDì Õ ì ÒÔÓ ë Ñ ïÔöQì~ïiïðö Ñ�Ò å ç�Ñ âSø ç î¬å Ñ|Õ î Ñ å ç ãäå Õ ÑDñ ïÔâ�ïðö Ñ�Ò å ç�Ñ âSø8ïÔö Ñ ò8âSë ÒÔÓSÑ âSå ç å ÑÖ ìSã�ïÔögâSë Ó öïðö Ñ îDì�ë ç ì�ã8ãæå Õ bò Ñ ï é�Ñ|ÑDÕ ïðö Ñ ï é â Ú å�ø,ì Õ ú Ú å ç ë Õ î¬ã Ñ ì Ò�ß ý�â ÕgÑûó å Ó ö�ï Ñ ü ÑDÕ ì ÒÔÓ ë Ñ ïðö:ì~ï�ì � ó[Ñ î�öQì Õ å¸î|ìSã é â Ò ã ñ �üRå ÑDé " å ç ì çÔç âkî¬å¸ì~ï ÑDñbé åæïðö'ïðö Ñ ò8âSë ÒÔÓSÑ âSå ç�Ñ ïðögâ ç|Ü @ ëkï�ïðöQì�ï Rå ÕQñ âSøHì ÒÔÓ ë ó0ÑDÕ ï é åäãæã Õ âSï Ñ� ï Ñ|ÕQñ ïðâ ñkÑ ï�ì�åäã Ñ4ñÑ|ó[Û å Ò åäîDì�ã ç ïÔì~ï Ñ|ó[Ñ|Õ ï ç ãæå Ñ ïÔö Ñ å Õ ü Ñ|Ò�ç�Ñ��Pç ê�ëQì ÒÔÑ ã¸ì éÜ;S] � ø8î|âSë Ò�ç�Ñ�Ú â ÕgÑ�ó ìBúöQìBü Ñ ì çðÑ|Û ì Ò ì�ï Ñ}é â ÒðÒ ú ô� â ÑDç ì Õ ú�â ÕgÑ ì~ï ÛgÒÔÑDçðÑ|Õ ïHöQìBü Ñ ì é}Ñ ãæã � ï ÑDç ï Ñ4ñËç âkî¬åäâSãäâ Ó å¸î|ìSã

â Ò�Û:ç úkî�ögâ�ãæâ Ó å¸î|ì�ã8ïÔö Ñ â Ò ú'ïðöQì�ï�ú�å Ñ ã ñgç ìbîDì�ë ç ì�ã�ì ÕQñwÑ� kÛ ã¸ì Õ ì�ïðâ Ò ú'ì�î|î|âSë Õ ï�â�ø ��' � ç ú ç ï ÑDó â�ø`ò Ñ ãäå Ñ ø ç|Ú:Ñ ü Ñ|Õç ë Û:ÑDÒÔç ïðåæïðåäâSë ç â ÕgÑ4ç��

� �

Page 15: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

¡B»8¯,¡~­|¥�¹�¡�±Q§¬°�¶ � � ªg¤�¤�¥�±�°�£k±�¦ � ¥�±�®| `È ���� ÈH¯�¶�� � �(U>@G,KF;f-nm�<pC�<s7D>@G,-,;=>H;,;/<B>t7B5Rd�<B)`5Q< XDC�<OCF7O<B3DG,+�<4)`5:< � CI7Ou@G,CFK�<{d�\tEfGf<&<4)`5:<O<B),CI7p<434Gf<4)XD?�58LM+ZCF-A<B>=E}+�CF-,u=587�5=3D+�74GfKI<�>8vO;f+�?�CI74CI>@-,7W5:E}>@GH<W),>k.h.0+ 7D),>@G,KI;eKFCI?�+�-,?�+Z>@G,36ai>@KICF?�+CF-AJ8+�7D<4CFuA5Q<BCF>8-,7 9:CI<�.0587�5b<B3DGf<B)sE,34>8G,u@)A<�58E}>8Gf<ûE�dp5:u@34+�+�L�+�-A<�<4>w5:u@34+�+25:E}>@GH<�-f+�.c<4),CF-,u874\�jrb),+O.�),>@KI+�<B),CI-,u1CF7ba,KF58u@G,+�;t.�C�<B)t58L!E,CIu@G,C�<BCF+�7�T ��>H+�7'>8-,+OLM+�58-�<B>�7B5RdW<B),5:< � CI7bu@G,CIKI<{d>@3�-,>8<~jtz{7�<B),CI7�LM+�34+�K�d15O?�>@-fvxGf74CF-fup.05Rd1>8vn7|<~5:<4CF-,uO<B),+�E`5:-`58K�>@E,7D+�3DJ:5:<4CF>@-1<B),5:<Ë>@G,3 �"�� �:" �CF- �&mæ7�u@G,CIKI<�5:34>@7D+�vx34>@L 5l7D>H?�CP58Knaf34>�?�+�7D7~j � L

(*),+�-/58KIK�CI7�7B5:CF;�58-,; ;f>@-,+8N�LM+S<B),>�;,>@KI>@u@CF?�58K�34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL L6589:+�7�-,>�7D+�-,7D+1G,-,KF+�747�>@-f+58;,)f+�34+�7�<4>M<B)f+&CF;f+R5l<B)`5:<'<B)f+s-`5Q<BG,3458K�74?�CI+�-,?�+�7wvx>834L 74>8LM+p9�CF-,;Z>8v�CI;,+�>@KI>@u8d�>83�3D+�KFCIu@CF>8-nN.�),CIKF+�>@Gf3b9�-f>g.�KI+�;,u8+p>:v�<4),+�74>�?�CF58K�.2>@34KI;�CF7[<B3DG,KId674?�CF+�-A<4CI^`?O58-f;t+��Ha,KP58CI-,7�/�>83[.�CFKFK}74>@L�+�1;`5RdW+��Ha,KP58CI- 6�.�)Ad6-`5:<BGf3B58K}74?�CI+�-A<BCI7D<47bE}+�KFCF+SJ@+w.�),5:<[<B)f+�dW;f>,q��0Gf<[<4),+�-�Nf.0+�),5kJ8+O5!;,CF3D+�?S<?�>8LMai+�<4CI<BCI>@-nTn(*),CI?~)&<B)f+�>@3DCF+�7�5834+2LM>@3D+07D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?8N@Cðqæ+:q8583D+[Ei+�<4<4+�3�7DG,a,ai>@3D<4+�;lEAd!+SJ�CF;,+�-,?�+:NLM5898+lL�>@34+!58?�?�G,3B5:<4+1a,34+�;,CF?S<BCF>8-,7�N�+S<B?8qäj�rb)f>@74+1>8v2a,)Ad�74CF?�7p58-,;�?~),+�L�CF7|<B3|d�58-,;�E,CI>@KF>@u:d@N>@3&<4),>@7D+W>8v'74>�?�CI>@KF>@u:d /�CF-f?�KFGf;,CF-,ut<B),+�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u8d�>8v'3D+�KFCIu@CF>8-=58-f;]>8v�v�5874),CI>@- 6Dj rb),+�58- 17D.2+�3l7D+�+�LM7s?�KF+�583&+�-,>@G,u8)nq � ·�� � ¿ rb),CF7sG,-,a,KI+R587458-A<l74C�<BG`5:<4CF>@- /xvx>83s7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CF7|<B7O>8v�7D?�CF+�-,?�+ 674>8LM+S<BCFL�+�7sKF+�58;,7s<4),+�L$<B> +�LMafKF>kdU5834u@GfLM+�-�<47&7DG,a,ai>@3D<4CF-,u�?�>@u@-,C�<BC�J@+63D+�KF5:<BC�JHCI74LtNû.�)fCF?~))`5RJ@+s<B),+�X|LM+�34CI<4\ /�vx34>@L <4),+�CI3wai>@CF-A<�>8vJ�CF+�.F6�>8v�7D<4>@a,a,CI-,u6<4),+ XD;fCF34+�?�<w?�>@L�a}+S<BC�<BCF>8-,\,T0C�v-,>l<B)f+�>@3|d�CF7b>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ8+�KIdWE}+S<4<B+�3[<B)`5:-_58-f>8<B),+�3�Nf<4),+�-ta,)Ad�74CI?�7'CF7b-,>8<�L�>@3D+�74?�CF+�-A<4CI^`?�<B),58-74>�?�CI>@KF>8u8d@q��0Gf<�NH5:7�.2+�+S�Ha,KF58CF-,+�;Maf34+�J�CI>@G,74K�d@NA?�>@u@-,C�<BCIJ8+b34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL CI7-,>8<25�JHCI+�.�<B)`5:<Ë5:-�d74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<b� -,5:<BG,3458Kn>@3b7D>H?�CP58K�� 74),>@GfKF;�.[58-A<�<B>1),>8KF;nq � ÌO _7<�Ñ ï�ë ç[Õ â�ï Ñ å Õ6Û ì çðç å ÕQÓ ïÔöQì~ïbïÔö Ñ ãäì ç ï çðÑ|Õ ï ÑDÕ î Ñ âSøûïðö Ñ ê�ëQâ�ï Ñ å ç î¬â ÒðÒÔÑ î¬ï ô ïðö Ñ�Õ âSïðåäâ Õ â�ø �ðî Ò ëQî|åäìSã

Ñ� kÛ8Ñ|Ò å ó[ÑDÕ ï "gÚké ögå¸î�ö�å ç ë ç�Ñ4ñ ò�ú ç â ó0ÑÛ ögåæãäâ ç â Û ö Ñ|Ò�ç â�ø ç î|å ÑDÕ î Ñ�ÚgÓSÒ â çÔç ãäúbâ~ü ÑDÒÔç å ó0Û ãæåæí ÑDç ïÔö Ñ î¬â ó0Û ã Ñ� 'é}Ñ òâ�øAå Õ ï Ñ|Ò ãäâRî+ Rå ÕgÓ�Ñ ü�å ñkÑDÕ î Ñ ïÔöQì~ï Ó åäü Ñ4ç�ç ë ÛgÛ â Ò ïiïðâ é�Ñ ãäã � î|â Õ í ÒÔó[ÑDñ[ç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïðåæí:î�ïÔö Ñ â Ò å ÑDçDÜ,è ö Ñ�Û öRú ç å¸î¬å ç ï ìBüRå ñ��ÑDÒðó å Õ�Ú å Õ ögå ç�Ñ� î Ñ ãæã Ñ|Õ ï�î Ò åæïðå¸ê�ë Ñ â�ø�ïÔö Ñ ìSî|î|âSë Õ ï�â�ø ÒÔÑ ã¸ì~ïÔåæüRåæïxú Ó åæü Ñ|Õ ò�úpá}â�ãæãäå Õ:ç ì ÕQñ �iå Õ î�ö Ú î¬â ÒðÒÔÑ î¬ïðãäúî¬â Õ î Ñ4ñkÑDç ïðö:ì~ï ç î|å ÑDÕ ïÔå ç ï çDù â~ü ÑDÒÔç å ó[Û ãäåæí ÑDñ ögå ç ïðâ Ò å ÑDçDÚ ì ç}ÛQÒðÑ4ç�ÑDÕ ï ÑDñ å Õ ï Ñ� ïðò8âRâ( çDÚRç â ó[Ñ ïðå ó0Ñ4ç}ñ â ó ì8 Ñ ïÔögå çÑ|ÒÔÒ â Ò�Ö���ÑDÒðó å Õ�Ú8×DØSØ V ì Úk×DØSØ V ò Úk×4ØSØ V î Úk×4ØSØRÞ�ß{Ü ��Õ ïðö Ñ âSïðö ÑDÒ öQì Õ:ñAÚSÑ� RÛ8Ñ|Ò å ó0ÑDÕ ï ç ì ÕQñ âSò çðÑ|Ò ü~ì~ïðåäâ Õ:ç|Ú ����þ�'�+)���æþ+�� ���~þ���� Ú ì ÒÔÑ å ÕQñkÑDÑDñ î Ò ëQî¬å¸ì�ã ç å Õ î Ñ ïðö ÑDÒðÑ å çfÕ â�âSïðö ÑDÒfé ìBú�ïðâ�âSòkï�ì�å Õ2ÒÔÑ ãäå¸ì�ògã Ñ Õ â é ã ÑDñkÓ�Ñ âSøQïðö Ñ�Ñ� ï Ñ|ÒÔÕ ìSãé â Ò ã ñAÜO Ϭè âOìBü�âSå ñOó å ç ë Õ:ñkÑ|Ò�ç ï�ì ÕQñ å ÕgÓ�ç|Ú ã Ñ ï�ë çÑ|ó[Û öQì ç åaR Ñ ïÔöQì~ï�ïðöQå ç�ñ â Ñ4ç�Õ â�ï ó[Ñ ì Õ ïðöQì�ï Õ ì~ïÔë Ò ìSã ç î|å ÑDÕ ïÔå ç ï ç

ì ÒÔÑ�ó â ÒÔÑ î|ã Ñ ü Ñ|Ò ïÔöQì Õ�ç âkî¬åäâSãäâ Ó å ç ï ç â Ò ögå ç ïÔâ Ò åäì ÕQçDÚ òQëkï ç å ó[Û ãäúbïðö:ì~ï�ïðö Ñ ú ñgÑ ì�ã é åæïðö Ñ ì ç å ÑDÒ�ÛgÒ â�ògã Ñ|óbç|ÜO à d�Õ ì ç å ó åæã¸ì Ò ü Ñ å Õ�Ú ïÔö Ñ î�ö:ì Û ï Ñ|Ò â�ø @ ì ÒÔÕgÑDçDÚ @ ãäâRâ Ò ì ÕQñ�Y�Ñ|ÕQÒ ú Ö�×DØSØ V�ß â Õ � ÛQÒ âRâ�øiì ÕQñOçðÑ ãæø �FÑ üRå ñkÑDÕ î Ñ7"

å çÑ|ÑDÒ åäãæúpø�ì ç î¬å Õ ì~ïÔå ÕQÓQÜ�è ö Ñ ì�ëkïÔögâ Ò�ç ï Ò úOïÔâ ÒðÑ ø�ëkï Ñ ïÔö Ñ î|ãäìSå ó ïðöQì�ï ç â ó[Ñ ò Ñ ãæå Ñ ø çDÚ ãäå Ñ / /�� A â Ò ïðö Ñ2.)#6� �� ��)8'8þ�'�� Ú ì ÒÔÑËç â'â�ò�üRåäâSë ç ïðöQì�ï�ïÔö Ñ ú ÕgÑDÑDñ�Õ âSï�ò ÑËÑ� RÛ ãäìSå ÕgÑ4ñOç âRî|åæâ�ãæâ Ó å¸î|ìSãæãäú Ü @ ëkïûïÔö Ñ å Ò ì ÒÔÓ ë ó[Ñ|Õ ï çç ögâ éÚ ì~ï ó â ç ï Ú ïÔöQì~ï0ïðögâ ç�Ñ ò Ñ ãäå Ñ ø ç ì ÒðÑ�Õ â�ïbì ç2Ñ üRå ñkÑ|Õ ïbì ç ïðö Ñ ú ó ìBú ç�ÑDÑ|ó Ö�Ñ�Ü Ó:ÜæÚ ò Ñ î|ì�ë ç�Ñ ïðö Ñ�Õ ì�ïðë ÒÔÑâ�ø�ì Ò å�ïÔö ó[Ñ ïðå¸î ç ïÔì�ï ÑDó0ÑDÕ ï ç å ç â Û8Ñ|Õ ïðâ ñ åæü Ñ|ÒÔÓSÑDÕ ï�å Õ ï ÑDÒðÛQÒðÑ ïÔì~ïÔåæâ ÕQç å Õ ïðö Ñ0Û ögåäãæâ ç â Û öRú�âSø ó ì~ïÔö Ñ|ó ì~ïÔåäî ç|Ú â Òò Ñ î|ìSë çðÑ ïðö Ñ 2.)#6� �� ��)�'8þ�'��[ì ÛgÛ ãæå ÑDç â Õ ãäúwïðâwå ñgÑ ì�ãäãäú ÛQÒðÑ î¬å ç�Ñ�ÛQÒ â Û â ç åæïðåäâ ÕQç ì Õ:ñ�Õ â�ï�ïðâ'ïðögâ ç�Ñ î¬â Õ ï�ì�å Õ å ÕgÓåäãæã �PñgÑ í ÕgÑ4ñ�é â Ò�ñgç ãäå9 Ñ ��ö Ñ ì Û "�ß{Ü @ ëkï�ïðöQì�ï�ì ÕQç�é�Ñ|Ò�ó å çÔç�Ñ4ç ïÔö Ñ â�ò�üRåäâSë ç�Û â�å Õ ïûïÔöQì~ï�ì�ãäãHöRë ó ì Õ ò Ñ å ÕgÓ�ç��ò Ñ ïÔö Ñ ú Û öRú ç å¸î¬å ç ï ç â Ò}ç âkî¬åäâSãäâ Ó å ç ï ç â ÒiÛ ãæë ó ò ÑDÒÔç�� öQìBü Ñ�Ú å Õ'ÛgÒ ìSî¬ïðå¸î Ñ�Ú�Õ â ç�ÑDÕQç åæògã Ñ ìSã�ï Ñ|ÒÔÕ ì~ïÔåæü Ñ ògëkï�ïðâ2ë çðÑì Ò åæïðö ó[Ñ ïÔåäî2ì ÕQñ ãäâ Ó åäî Ü Q�Õ:ñ ïðâ ç�ÑDÑ �ì ç âRî|åæâ�ãæâ Ó å¸î|ìSã Ñ� kÛ ã¸ì Õ ì�ïðåäâ Õ ø�â Ò�ç ëQî�ö�òQì ç å¸î Õ â�ïÔåæâ ÕQçûç ë ÒÔÑ ãäú Û ëkï ç ïðö Ñî|ì Ò ï�ò Ñ ø�â ÒÔÑ ïÔö Ñ ögâ Ò�ç�Ñ�Ü â @ ì ÒðÕQÑDç þ� �8��� ÒÔÑ ìSãæãäú0ïðögå Õ [ïÔöQì~ï�ïðö Ñ å Ò�ç âkî¬åäâSãäâ Ó å¸î|ìSãgïÔö Ñ â Ò å ÑDç ì ÒÔÑûó â ÒÔÑûÒÔÑ ãäå¸ì�ògã Ñïðö:ì Õ /� /�� A ì ÕQñ 2.)#6� �� ��)�'@þ�'�� � �RÑDÑ X ì ÓSÑ ã Ö�×DØ�Ø�Þ�ß ø�â Ò ì Õ&Ñ ã¸ì�ò8â Ò ì~ïðåäâ Õ â�ø}ïðö Ñ4ç�Ñ ì ÒðÓ ë ó[Ñ|Õ ï çDÚ ì ÕQñ��ÑDÒðó å Õ!Ö�×DØ�ØSÙ�ß ø�â Ò ì Õ â�ïÔö Ñ|Ò î Ò åæïðå¸ê�ë ÑSÜO ;Dõ â Ò î�öQì Ò åæïxú Ú:é}Ñ ö:ìBü Ñ ö ÑDÒðÑ ã Ñ ø¨ï�ì ç å ñgÑ @ ãæâRâ Ò4ù ç ø�âSë Ò ïðö ÛQÒ å Õ î¬å Û ã Ñ'Ö � ÒðÑ%GQÑ� åäüRå�ïxú "�߬Ü�d�ÕQñkÑ|Ñ4ñAÚ å�ï ç�ÑDÑ|óbç ïÔâ

ë ç ïÔöQì~ï2å�ø ç âRî|åæâ�ãæâ Ó å ç ï ç�ç ï�ì Ò ïï Ò ú�å ÕgÓ ïðâ Ñ� kÛ ã¸ì�å Õ&é öRú�ïÔö Ñ ú&ögâ�ã ñ ïðö Ñ å Ò â é�Õ ò Ñ ãæå Ñ ø çËé å�ïÔögâSëkïËïÔì8 Rå ÕgÓ å Õ ïÔâìSîDî¬â�ë Õ ïïðö ÑbÑ ü�å ñkÑDÕ î Ñ ïÔöQì~ï�ïÔögâ çðÑ ò Ñ ãäå Ñ ø ç ì ÒÔÑ�ç â ó[Ñ ögâ é ò Ñ ï�ï Ñ|Ò â Ò�ó â ÒÔÑ âSò �xÑ î{ïðåäü Ñ ïÔöQì Õ ïÔögâ çðÑ â�ø�ïðö Ñ å Ò

� K

Page 16: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

z�<lCF7sCF-A<B+�34+�7D<BCI-,u_<4>�?�>@L�a`583D+ � � 4�5:-,;]a}>87D<BL�>�;,+�3D-,CF7DLZNû.�),CF?~)y583D+6>8v�<4+�-]?�>@-fvxG,7D+�;EAdc<B)f+�CF3l>8a,a}>8-,+�-A<B7�q 7û>@7D<4LM>�;,+�34-,CI7D<B7l<4+�-,;y<B>�34+{�D+�?S<M>8E��D+�?S<BCIJ�C�<{d]+�J8+�-e5:7M5 u@>@58KÔTW+SJ�1+�3|d�<B),CI-,u�Ei+�?�>8LM+�7!;,+�ai+�-f;,+�-A<�>@-c>@-f+8m�7!74G,E��D+�?�<4CIJ8+�J�CI+�.�ai>@CF-A<RN�58-,;cL�>@3B5:KË>83l58+�7|<B),+S<BCI?J:58KFGf+�7Ë;,CF7Da,KP58?�+�?�>@u@-fCI<BC�J@+�>@-,+�7�q � G,C�<B+b<B),+'>@a,ai>@7DCI<B+�CI7�<434G,+�vx>@3�74Gfa,a}>83D<B+�3472>8v�<4),+��<B34>8-,u734>@u83B58L�LM+:N�.�),>_>8v�<B+�-]58a,ai+R583s+S��<B3458>@3D;,CF-`5:34CFK�d 74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<BCF?:T!vx>@3&+��f58LMafKF+8N��0KF>�>@3O>8v�<B+�-+�L�a,)`5:74CF��+�7Ë<B)`5:<Ë),CI7ËJ�CI+�. CI72LM5:<B+�34CF58KFCI7D<BCI?8N:-`5:<BGf3B58KICF7D<4CF?�58-f;674?�CF+�-�<4CI^`?:q�0Gf<2<B),+'L�+�<B)f>H; 1>@KI>@u@CF?�58Kn3D+�KP5Q<BCIJ�CI74L ?�>@-A<~58CI-,+�;�CI-Z<4),+ XD7|d�LML�+�<43Dd�\W58-f;*XDCFL�a`583|<BCF58KFC�<{dH\s<B),+�74+�7�� G,-fKF+�7D7CI<OCI7OCF-A<B+�34a,3D+�<B+�;=CI-/7D>t.05:<4+�34+�; 1{;f>g.�-c5�v�587D),CF>8-U5:7p<4>ZEi+�?�>@LM+lJ�CF3|<BG`5:KFKIdZ+�L�af<{dZ� G,-M1;,+�34L�CF-,+�7�<4),+Z345:<BCI>@-`58KICF7|<15874ai+�?S<W>8v�<B),+Z74>�?�CI>@KF>@u8CF?R5:K0+�-A<4+�34af34CF7D+8Nb7D>U<B),5:<6af3B58?S<BCI<4CF>@-f+�347>8v � � 4 +SJ@+�-�<4G`58KIKId�)`5RJ@+O<B>lv�58KIKnE`58?~9�>8-Z3458;,CF?�58K?1�749:+�af<4CF?R5:Kn583Du@G,L�+�-A<B7'58Ei>@Gf<'>@E��D+�?�<4CIJ�CI<{d<B),5:<�>8v�<B+�-ZKI+R58;�<4),+�L <4>1L6589:+O?�>@L�LM>8-�?R58G,7D+p.�C�<B)�<B)f+pai>@7|<BL�>H;,+�34-,CI7D<47�q

� � ��� � �R� ��������� ��� ����3�F����� �

(=+t;,>�-,>8<1.058-A<M<4>Uu8CIJ@+W<4),+tCFL�a,34+�7474CI>@-c<B),5:<1<B),+�34+Z5834+�-,>/CF-A<B+�34+�7D<BCI-,u N G,+�7|<BCF>8-,7<B>�Ei+l;,+�58KI<�.�C�<B)�EAd�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CF7|<B7�>8vË74?�CI+�-,?�+8q1��- <B)f+l?�>@-A<B34583Dd8N�<B),+�34+1583D+lKF>8<47�>8v�<B),+�LZq�0Gf<�.2+�?�>@-A<B+�-,;�<4)`5:<�<B)f+'af),CFKI>@74>@af),CF?�58Kf?�>@-fvxG,7DCF>@-,7�?�G,343D+�-A<BK�d!v�5874)fCF>@-`5:E,KF+bCI-8� � 4%?�CF34?�KF+�7),CI-,;,+�3b345:<B)f+�3b<B)`5:-tvx>@7|<B+�3�<4),+Oa}>87474CIE,CFKICI<{d�>8v�74+�34CF>8G,74K�d�7D<4G,;fd�CF-,ul<4),+�Ltq

rb),+19�CF-,; >8v N G,+�7D<BCI>@-,7�.2+�),5kJ8+lCF- L�CF-,;_34+�J8>@KIJ8+1a,34CIL6583DCFK�d�5834>8G,-,; <B),+laf34>@E,KI+�L�>8v+S�Hai+�3|<BCF7D+8q�(U+�583D+w?�>@-,7D<B58-A<BK�dM7DG,E��D+�?�<B+�;W<B>!3D+�ai>@3D<472>:v'XD+S�Hai+�3|<B\!>@afCF-,CI>@-nN�>@-W5:KFK�a}>87474CIE,KF+<B>8a,CF?�7�qy�0Gf<�7D),>@G,KI;�>8-,+�E}+�KFCF+SJ@+W<4),+�L6j �H),>@GfKF;y>@-,+�Ei+�KICF+�J8+�<B)`5:<l<4>@E`58?�?�>/CF7lE`5:;yvx>83>@-,+:mæ7�),+R5:KI<B)`jUrb)`5:<w>@KFC�J@+O>@CFK�CI7�u@>�>�; /�5:v�<B+�3w58KIK`6Dj�rb)`5Q<�-�G,?�KI+R583�a}>k.2+�3�a,KP58-A<47w583D+&745:vx+kjrb)`5:<b<4),+p58G,7|<B+�3DCI<{d�L�+R5:74G,3D+�7�>8v�<B),+Oz B_�y583D+Ou@>H>�;Wvx>@30<4),+O+�?�>@-,>@L&dfj_rb)`5Q<�-,+�.�7Da`58ai+�334+�a}>83D<B7p583D+158?�?�G,3B5Q<B+kj%rb),5:<pa,G,E,KICF?R5Q<BCF>8-,7w>@-�<B)f+=X|LM+�LM>@3|d_>:v2.05:<B+�34\ � � ?�>@-f?�+�3D-U7D>@L�+34+�58K�a,)Ad�74CI?R58K�+���+�?�<�j

(*),+�-_?�>@-fvx3D>@-A<B+�;_.�CI<4)Z+��fai+�3|<B7�Nn58-Ad�CF-f;,CIJ�CF;fG`58K�>@3�74LM58KIK�u@34>@GfaZ>8v�CF-,;,C�J�CF;,G`5:KF7[CI7�CI-5O;,C ��?�GfKI<Ë74C�<BG`5:<4CF>@-�q�rb),+�34+�CF7�-,>s.05Rdl<B>O^`-,;�<B),+�<BCILM+'58-,;1<B)f+�L�+R58-f7Ë<4>s?~),+�?~9M;fCF34+�?�<4KId+�J8+�-�5p74LM58KFKHvx3B58?S<BCF>8-�>:v�<B)f+�+��fai+�3|<B7�mf587D74+�3D<BCI>@-,7�q�w-,;�d@+�<�NfCI-�LM58-Ad1a,3458?�<4CF?R5:K`74CI<4G`5:<4CF>@-,7.2+Z)`5RJ8+Z<B>/;,+�?�CF;f+�.�)f+�<B)f+�36>83�-f>8<1<B>�<B34Gf7D<�<B),+�CF3l?�KF58CFL�7�q �'>g. 74),>@GfKF;y.0+ta,34>�?�+�+�;�jrb)`5:<wCF7�5M<B3DG,KId�CI-A<B+�3D+�7|<BCF-fuW58-,;_;,C ��?�GfKI< N Gf+�7D<4CF>@-�qw�0GH<�+�afCF7D<4+�L�CF?s58-,;�L�+�<4),>�;,>@KF>8u@CF?�58K34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL ;,>l-,>8<[),+�KIa�),+�3D+8q�(U+�.[58-A<[<4>!^`-,;�>@GH<[.�),>lCF7034CFu8)�<[58-,;W.�),>lCI72.�3D>@-,u,N`5:-,;<B),5:<w;f+�ai+�-,;,7�G,KI<4CFLM5:<B+�KId6>@-Z)f>g. <4),+O.0>@3DKF;Z34+R5:KFKIdWCF7�q J�>@3'CF7b<B)f+ N G,+�7|<BCI>@-_a`5:3D<BCI?�G,KF5834K�d-,+S.OTOvx>83�+S�f58L�a,KF+:N ��G,L�+158;,;,3D+�7D74+�;UCI<O5:KF34+�58;fd8N�58-,;/uA5RJ@+174>@L�+lu@G,CI;,+�KICF-,+�7wvx>@3�7D>@KIJ�CF-fuCI<�N�CF-]),CI7l;,CF7D?�G,7D74CF>8-�>8v'.�),+S<B),+�3�>8-,+�74),>@GfKF;yE}+�KFCI+�J@+�CI-yLMCI3B58?�KF+�7�q � � rb)f+Z5:34u@G,L�+�-A<1CI7î Ò åæïðå¸î çDÚ ïðö ÑDÕwé�Ñ�ç å ó[Û ãäú ó â~ü Ñ ø Ò â óyÑDÒðÒ â Ò ïðâbìSò ç ë ÒÔñ åæïxú Ü X â�ï Ñ ïÔöQì~ï Ú òRú�î|â Õ ï Ò ì ç ï Ú á}âSãäãäå ÕQçÖ�×DØ�Ø /kÚRÛ�Ü�×DÙSÙ�ßì ÒÔÓ ë ÑDç ïÔöQì~ï,� ç âkî¬åäâSãäâ Ó å ç ï ç âSø ç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïðåæí:î Õ â é ã ÑDñgÓSÑûé öQâ é ì Õ ïiïÔâ�í ÕQñ&Ö â Ò ö Ñ ã Û î¬â ÕQç ï Ò ëQî{ï ß`ÕgÑDé âSò �xÑ î{ï ç å Õïðö Ñ2é â Ò ã ñ�ó ë ç ï�î|â ó[Û ì Ò ï ó[ÑDÕ ï�ì�ãäå çðÑ ý8ïÔö Ñ ú ó ë ç ï Õ â�ï�ì ÛgÛ ãæú�ïÔö Ñ å Ò�ó[Ñ ïðögâ ñgç ïðâ'ïðö ÑDóbç�Ñ ãæü ÑDçDÜ "Zè öQì~ï ó â~ü Ñì�ãäãäâ é�ç ögå ó ïÔâ ÑDç î|ì Û:Ñ ø Ò â ó%çðÑ ãæø �FÒÔÑ ø�ëgïÔì~ïÔåæâ Õ�Ú ògëkï é ö�ú ç ögâSëgã ñ ì Õ ú�â ÕgÑ ì�î|î ÑDÛ ïËögå ç2Ò ëgã Ñ � �RÑ|Ñ'õQÒ å ÑDñgó ì ÕÖx×4ØSØ�Ù�ß ø�â Ò ì ó â ÒÔÑ�ñgÑ ïÔìSåæã ÑDñ�ñ å ç î¬ë çÔç åäâ Õ�ÜOSO Q�Õ�Ñ ÷ Ñ î{ï�ìSãæã Ñ|Ó�ÑDñ ãäúbø�âSë ÕQñ òRú õgÒÔÑ|Õ î�ö ç î¬å Ñ|Õ ïÔå ç ï ì�î|ê�ë Ñ4ç @}ÑDÕ ü Ñ|Õ å ç ï Ñ ïÔöQì~ï Ú åæøfï Ò ë ÑSÚgé âSëgã ñwÓ åäü Ñ ïÔö Ñ â �

ÒÔÑ ïðå¸î|ìSã ç ë ÛgÛ â Ò ï`ïðâ�ögâ ó[Ñ â Û ì~ïðöRú Ö ìBü Ñ|Õ ì ç þ�>�8��� ×DØ�ÙSÙ�᪚ �RÑDÑ � ì ñQñ â þ���8��� Öx×4ØSÙ�Ù�ß ø�â Ò ìËî Ò å�ïÔåäîDì�ãgì Õ ì�ãäú ç å çì Õ:ñAÚ ø�â Ò ì ó â ÒÔÑñkÑ ï�ì�åäã Ñ4ñ�ñ å ç î¬ë çÔç åæâ Õ�Úgç�ÑDÑ1@}Ò âkî�ö Ö�×DØ�Ø /S߬ÜO P�Y ë ó[Ñ'Ö�×DØ�ÙSÙ � ×~Þ�A�Ù8�FÚRçðÑ î{ïÔåæâ Õ � ß{Ü

���

Page 17: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

.2+�KFK 1{9�-,>k.�-nT�z�v'd@>@G�)`5RJ@+�-,+SJ@+�3M7D+�+�-�5 LMCI3B58?�KF+�d@>@G,3D74+�KIv¬N�d@>@G,31Ei+�KICF+�v�CI7lE`587D+�;�>@-yE}+;1KFCI+�J�CF-fu�7D>@L�+�>@-,+p.�),>W3D+�ai>@3D<47'<4),+&>�?�?�G,343D+�-,?�+!>8v5MLMCI3B58?�KF+8q0�0Gf<�d@>@G�9�-,>k. vx3D>@L ;,CF3D+�?S<+S�Hai+�3DCF+�-f?�+!<B),5:<�ai+�>@a,KI+!74>8LM+S<BCFL�+�7�;,+�?�+�C�J@+!<B)f+�L�74+�K�J@+�7p>83w?~),+�5:<O>8<B)f+�347�q>�H>,N�.�),+�-,+�J8+�3d@>8G�)f+R583�<4),+b34+�a}>@3|<>8v}5�L�CF3B5:?�KF+:N8C�<�CF7�58KI.05RdH7L�>@3D+[3B5:<4CF>@-,58K�<4>�E}+�KFCI+�J@+2� 5:<KF+�587D<�CF-!<B)f+58E,7D+�-,?�+s>:v�ai>k.0+�3DvxG,K�?�>@G,-A<B+�3DJ:58CIKFCF-fu!+�J�CF;f+�-,?�+�� <B)`5:<�7D>@L�+�9�CI-,;�>8vû;,+�?�+�af<4CF>@-�CI7[<~589�CF-fua,KF58?�+�345:<B),+�3b<B)`58-Z5!<B3DG,+OLMCI3B58?�KF+8q � '

r�>�u@C�J@+15�?�>8-,?�3D+�<B+�+S�f58L�a,KI+!>8vË<B),+l9�CF-f;/>:v03D+R587D>@-,CF-fuW<B)`5:<�.2+1)`5RJ@+�CF- L�CF-,;�Nn?�>@-M174CI;,+�3'<B),+&CF747DG,+!>8v<4),+�XDL�+�L�>@3|d�>8v.[5Q<B+�3D\,qp��-,+&.05Rd_<B>6L6589:+!5]X���G,L�+R58-f\�5834u8G,LM+�-A<58Ei>@Gf<'CI<47�a,KP58Gf74CFEfCFKFC�<{d�u@>H+�7'587'vx>8KFKF>k.�7�T � C�J@+�-t<B)`5Q<'<4),+O34+�74G,K�<RN�CIvû<B3DG,+8N`.2>@G,KF;ta,3D>gJ8>@98+&534+SJ@>@KIGf<BCI>@-WCI-�a,)AdH7DCF?�7�58-,;�?~),+�LMCI7D<B3|d@N`5Q<bKF+�587D<b7D>@L�+�74?�CF+�-A<4CF7D<47�5834>8G,-,;W<B)f+w.0>834KF;�7D),>@G,KI;)`5RJ@+t58-yCI-�<4+�3D+�7D< /xCF-]Ei>8<B)]7D+�-,7D+�7�>8v�<B),+�.2>@34; 6&CF-];,G,afKFCF?�5:<BCI-,uZ<4),+�34+�74G,K�<Rq BZ>@34+�>kJ@+�3�N<B)f+�+S�Ha}+�34CILM+�-�<[CI<B7D+�K�v�;,>H+�7b-,>8<�3D+ N G,CF3D+�)�G,u@+�CI-�J8+�7|<BL�+�-A<B7�q �'>g.2+�J8+�3�Ni-f>l34+�afKFCF?�5:<BCI>@-W)`5:7Ei+�+�-U?�KF58CFL�+�;nN�5Q<OKF+R5:7D<p-,>8<pEAd�a}+�>@a,KI+1<4>8<~5:KFKIdZCF-f;,+�ai+�-,;f+�-A<&>:vb�0+�-�J8+�-,CI7D<4+8q � + J'+�uA5:<4CIJ8+34+�74G,K�<B7Ë583D+bG,74G`5:KFKId&-,>8<�3D+�ai>@3D<4+�;nN�74>O7D98+�aH<BCF?�CF7DL�.�CI<B)l3D+�7Da}+�?�<Ë<B>�<B),+�>@3DCFu@CI-`58K�+S�Hai+�34CILM+�-A<Ei+�?�>8LM+�7l34+R5:74>@-`5:E,KF+ /�<B> 745kdU<B),+�KI+R587|<;6�q=�wv'?�>8G,347D+8N�.0+�583D+W),+�34+�>@-,K�d=7DG,u@u@+�7D<4CF-,u <B)f+>@Gf<4KFCI-,+�>8v�58-Z583Du@G,L�+�-A<Rq[��34+�58K�CF-AJ@+�7D<4CFuA5:<4CF>@-�.2>@G,KF;Z)`5RJ@+p<B>1^`-,;�>@GH<'.�)f+�<B)f+�3�<4),+&+�� 1ai+�34CILM+�-A<03D+R58KIKId!.0587[+�587Dd1<B>&34+�afKFCF?�5:<B+'58-f;6.�),+�<4),+�3[5:<4<4+�L�af<B705:<03D+�a,KICF?�5:<BCI>@- /�KF+�58;,CI-,up<4>-,+�uA5:<BC�J@+�34+�7DG,KI<47�6.0+�34+wCI-Mv�58?S<0LM58;,+:q�w-,;�<B)`5Q<[CF-AJ8>@KIJ8+�70?�>@-,7DCF;,+�3B5:<4CF>@-,7ËEi>8<B)M>8v�a,)Ad�74CI?�758-,;t>8v�74>�?�CI>@KF>@u:d@q

��>k.2+�J@+�3�N`>@-f+w>8v�<4),+w;,CI7D<4G,34E,CI-,u!5:74ai+�?�<47[>8ve� � 41m�70L�+�<4),>�;,>@KF>8u@CF?�58K,34+�KP5:<4CIJ�CF7DL CF7�<B)`5Q<CI<47!58;f),+�3D+�-A<B7l<B+�-,;c<B> ?�>@L!E,CI-,+W5:-]+S�f58u@u@+�3B5:<4+�;]7D98+�aH<BCF?�CF7DL <B>k.05834;f7l?�>@-AJ@+�-A<BCF>8-`58K[7D?�C?1+�-A<4CI^`?�9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+�.�CI<B) 5]3B5:<4),+�3�<4>@KF+�3B58-A< /�>@3�+SJ@+�-%v�5RJ@>@3458E,KF+ 6W5:<4<4CI<4G,;,+ <B>k.05834;,7�<B)f+a,7D+�G,;,>Z1{74?�CF+�-,?�+�7�qy�`>@3!+��,5:LMa,KI+8N��[5:34-,+�7�N2�0KF>�>@3!5:-,; ��+�-f3Ddc?�>@L�LM+�-�<!7Dd�LMa,5:<B),+S<BCI?R58KIKId>@-�),>@L�+�>8a`5:<B)AdW58-,;t587D<434>@KI>@u8d � <�N�5:-,;�u@>174>lv�583b5:7[<B>�58747D+�3|<b<B)`5:<b<4),+�;`5:<B5luA5:<B)f+�34+�;�E�d� 58G N G,+�KICF-�CF-�74G,afa}>@3|<0>:vn<B),+�587|<B34>8KF>@u@CI?R58KH<B),+�>@3Ddl<4)`5:<Ë<B),+�34+wCI7Ë5�X,B_5:347Ë+ �}+�?�<4\l5��}+�?S<BCF-fu<B)f+l;,+�7|<BCF-Ad_>8vË74ai>@3D<47�?~)`58L�a,CF>@-f7�XD?�>8G,KF;�?�>@-,?�+�CIJ:58EfKIdZ?�>@L�+&<B>�Ei+158?�?�>@L�LM>�;`5:<4+�; 5:7�5<B3DCFG,L�a,)Z>8v<B),+&74?�CI+�-A<BC�^`?&L�+�<4),>�;,\,q � @ ��75BZ+�34L�CF-�>8E,74+�3DJ@+�7�Nnvx>@KIKF>k.�CF-fu65 �'G,L�+R58-_<{d�ai+>8v�34+R5:74>@-,CI-,u,N@<4),+�;,5:<~5O>8v � 58G N G,+�KFCI-M5:34+�74>s74G,3Da,34CI74CF-fuC/�58L�>@G,-A<BCI-,u�<B>s5_XDL�CF3458?�KI+�\ 6�<B)`5Q<CI<�CI7�34+R5:74>@-`5:E,KF+�<4>6587D74G,L�+p3B5:<4),+�3b<B),5:<'74>@L�+�9�CF-,;t>8v�;f+�?�+�af<BCI>@- /�>@3�74+�KIv 1�;,+�?�+�af<4CF>@- 6[)`5:7>�?�?�Gf3434+�;nq � L �w-,>:<B),+�3'+��f58LMafKF+�CF70a,34>kJ�CF;,+�;ZEAd�<4),+�?�>@L�L�+�-A<�EAd I0>@KFKICF-,7[58-,; 7CF-,?~)�<B)`5Q<XDC�vb),>@L�+�>@a,5:<B)AdU?R58-,-f>8<!Ei+W;,+�LM>@-f7D<B345:<B+�;]+S�Hai+�34CILM+�-A<~58KIKId@N�CI<sCF7sG,ac<B>�7D?�CI+�-A<BCI7D<B7�N.�),>9�-,>k. <B)f+�34CF7D9�7'>:v�vx3D>@-A<BCF+�3b34+�74+R5:34?~)nN`<B>17D),>k.%.�)Ad@q�\ � · �0GH<b<B),CI7�58LM>8G,-A<B7b<B>174)fCIv�<BCI-,u!<B)f+E,G,3D;,+�-6>8v�+�J�CI;,+�-,?�+8TC�<2CI72Gfa6<B>&58;fJ@>�?R5Q<B+�72>8v�),>8LM+�>@a`5:<4)�dl<4> XD;f+�L�>@-,7D<43B5:<4+w+��fai+�3DCFL�+�- 1O U�Qûç Y ë ó[Ñ â�ò çðÑ|Ò ü ÑDñ�Ú åæïËå ç�Ñ ü Ñ|ÕlÒ ì~ïÔåæâ Õ ì�ã`ø�â Ò ì Õ å Õ öQìSògåæïÔì Õ ïËâSø d�ÕQñ å¸ì�ïðâ ñ å ç ò Ñ ãæå Ñ ü Ñ ïðö Ñ î¬ã¸ì�å ó ïðöQì�ï

é ì~ï ÑDÒ î|ì Õ ò Ñ î|â ó[Ñç â�ãæå ñ�ñ ë Ò å ÕgÓbé å Õ ï Ñ|Ò4ô`ç�ÑDÑ�Õ â�ï Ñ /�Þ ì�ò8â~ü ÑSÜO:W � Õ ãäå ÑSÚ ø�â Ò�Ñ� ì ó[Û ã ÑSÚ ïðö Ñ[Ñ� kÛ8Ñ|Ò å ó[ÑDÕ ï ç�ç ögâ é å ÕgÓ ïðö Ñ[Ñ� å ç ï Ñ|Õ î Ñ â�ø ç ë Û8Ñ|Ò î¬â ÕQñ ëQî¬ïðåäü�åæïxúOì~ï�ögå Ó ösï ÑDó!�

Û8Ñ|Ò ì~ïðë ÒðÑ4ç|Úké ögå¸î�ö é}ÑDÒðÑ�ÒÔÑ|Û ãäåäîDì~ï ÑDñ ì Ò âSë ÕQñ ïðö Ñé â Ò ã ñ'é åæïðögå Õ ì2ø Ñ|é_é}ÑDÑ ç|ÜO \#@ ì ÒÔÕgÑDçDÚ�@ ãæâRâ Ò ì ÕQñY�Ñ|ÕQÒ ú Ö�×DØ�Ø�VgÚ î�öQì Û�Ü V�߬ÜO ]#@ ì ÒÔÕgÑDçDÚ�@ ãæâRâ Ò ì ÕQñY�Ñ|ÕQÒ ú Ö�×DØ�Ø�VgÚRÛ�Ü�×�AQ×Bß{ÜP�_ ��Ñ|ÒÔó å Õ1Ö�×DØ�ØSÙ�᪚ �RÑDÑ ì�ã ç â @}ÑDÕQç �å�þ� ��� � Öx×4ØSØ V�ß ø�â Ò ì'î Ò å�ïÔåäîDì�ã�ì ÕQñ�ñkÑ ï�ì�åäã Ñ4ñ ø�ìSî{ïÔëQì�ã Ñ� ì ó å Õ ì~ïÔåæâ Õ â�ø

ïðö Ñ � � ì ÒÔç�Ñ ÷ Ñ î¬ï "QÜP�Ï á}âSãäãæå ÕQç ì ÕQñ ��å Õ î�ö Ö�×DØ�ØSÝgÚRÛ�Ü�×�A(ARß{Ü

� �

Page 18: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

<~5:KFKId�\p<B)`5:<0<B),+�CF30<4),+�3458aAd6.2>@349�7�E}+Sd@>@-f;�<4),+�a,KF58?�+�E}>!+���+�?�<�N`-,>8<[<4),+�>8<4),+�30.05Rd�583D>@G,-,;nqz�<OCF7�Gf-fvx>@3D<4G,-`5:<4+�K�d�+R5:7Dd�<4>�^,-,;�74CFL�CFKF583'7D<~5Q<B+�L�+�-A<47�T�vx>@3�CI-,7D<B58-,?�+:N�CF- >@-,+l>:v2<4),+l+R583DKIdEi>H>@9�7>@-/X|�wKI<4+�3D-`5:<BC�J@+�7�<B>O�0CIu��H?�CI+�-,?�+�\,NA>@-f+b?�>@G,KI;158KF3D+R58;Hd&3D+R58;nT�X�q�q�qvxGf<BG,3D+ba,34>874ai+�?�<47vx>@3'5Mu834+R5Q<wE,3D+R589A<4),34>@Gfu@)_CI-t(U+�7|<B+�3D-�74?�CF+�-,?�+&58-,;_CI-Z<4),+s>�?�?�G,KI<'7D?�CF+�-,?�+�7�>8v�<B),+&��34CF+�-A<583D+M7458CF;�<B>ZE}+�u@>�>H;nqM�w7|<B34>8KF>@u8d_.�CFKFK�5:uA58CF-�Ei+�?�>@LM+M5�34+�?�>@u@-,CI74+�;c74?�CF+�-f?�+8N�>@-,?�+6CI<p)`5:7LM58;,+'G,74+'>8v�?SdHEi+�3D-,+�<4CF?�7[58-,;M7D<B5:<BCI7D<BCI?R58K�5:-`58KId�7DCF7�q��0Gf<274G,?~)W?�KP58CILM7�v�5:KFK`>@-�<B),+';,+R5Qv�+R583D7>8v�> ��?�CF58Kn74?�CF+�-,?�+:qæ\ �{¿

rb),+�7D+�34+�L6583D9�7[583D+w74)f>H?~9�CF-fu!E,Gf<[5834+�a}+�34)`58af70-,>8<074>!7DG,34af34CF7DCF-,ufNH7DCF-,?�+�<B)f+�XD-,+�Gf<B3458K?1CI<{d�\�>:vb<B),+ ��<434>@-fu 734>@u@3458L�LM+�KF+�58;,7!C�<B7!5:;,),+�3D+�-A<B7!<4> ;,CF7D34+�uA5834;c58-Adc+�afCF7D<4+�L�>@KF>8u@CF?�58K;,CI7D<BCI-,?�<4CF>@-f7[E}+S<{.0+�+�-�7D?�CI+�-,?�+&58-f;taf74+�Gf;,>21{7D?�CI+�-,?�+8q

�wv�?�>@G,3D74+:NnE}+�KFCI+�J�CF-,u�+S�Hai+�3|<B7�CI7�-,>:<w<B)f+!7B58L�+O<B),CI-,uW587wE}+�KFCF+SJ�CF-,u�CF-ZLMCI3B58?�KF+�7>/x>@3wCI-<B)f+�a,7D+�G,;f>21{7D?�CF+�-,?�+�7�6;9`58-,;MCF-�>@34;,+�3Ë<4>pvx>834L!G,KF5:<B+�;,+�+�ai+�3Ëa,34CI-,?�CIa,KF+�7�>8vn345:<BCI>@-`58K,CI-fvx+�3D+�-,?�+CF-t34+�58K?1�KFC�vx+�74C�<BG`5:<4CF>@-f7�N`LM58-Ad�74>�?�CF>8KF>@u@CI?R58K}?�>@-f74CF;f+�3B5Q<BCF>8-,7�E}+�?�>@L�+s3D+�KI+�J:58-A<Rq���CI347|<�>:v58KIKÔNCI<2CF72CFL�a}>83D<~5:-�<�<4>&)`5RJ@+O5Q<0KI+R587|<b5&3D>@G,u@)MCF;,+�5&>8v�),>k. XD+��fai+�3|<B7D\lCF-W5su@CIJ8+�-6^`+�KF;WEi+�?�>@L�+58?�?�34+�;,CI<4+�;U58-,;�.�)`5:<OL�+�<4),>H;f7O<4),+�d�G,74+1.�CI<4),CF-�<4),+�CI3O5834+�5�>:vlXD+��Ha}+�3D<BCI74+�\,T�<B),CI7O58KFKI>g.�7>@-,+'<B>s;,CF7|<BCF-fu@G,CF7D)nN�>@-6+�a,CF7|<B+�LM>@KI>@u@CI?R58K,u834>@G,-f;,7�NHE}+S<{.0+�+�-�KFCI?�+�-f74+�;MLM+�;,CF?�58K�;,>�?�<B>8347[5:-,;+ N G`5:KFKId/),CIu@),K�d�X458?�?�34+�;,CI<4+�;,\_a,3B58?S<BC�<BCF>8-,+�3D7&>8v�5:G,3B5_3D+R58;fCF-,u,qtrb),+�-nN34>@Gfu@),KId/7Da}+�589�CF-,u,N>@-,+274),>8G,KF;sE}+�KFCF+SJ@+25 /xu@+�-�G,CI-,+�6�+S�Ha}+�3D<�.�),+�-&<4),+�3D+b583D+2>8<4),+�3�N8+ N G,58KFK�dO?�>@L�a}+S<B+�-�<�+S�Hai+�3D<47<B),5:<p)`5RJ@+�E}>8<4)=5:-UCI-�<4+�3D+�7D<&58-,;�<B)f+ML�+R58-f7O<4>Z?�>@-A<B3458;,CF?S<O<B),+�+S�Hai+�3D<sCF- N G,+�7D<BCI>@-c5:-,;;,>�-,>8<';,>M74>,q2�0Gf<'<B)`5Q<�CI-AJ@>@K�J@+�7'-�G,L�+�34>8G,7�7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CI?R58K N G,+�7|<BCF>8-,7�T ��>k. vx34+�+sCI7b<B),+O74>Z1?R5:KFKF+�;tX|vx34+�+L65:3498+S<�>8vHCF;,+�5874\Aj ��>b?�>@-A<B3458;,CI?�<B>83DdwJ�CI+�.�ai>@CF-A<B7�u8+�<û50v�58CI3n),+R5:34CF-fu�j J�>8<4),CF-fua,3D+�J@+�-A<B7b<B),+�+��HCF7D<4+�-,?�+�>8v�.�)`5:<�>8-,+�L�CFu@)A<2?R58KIK[XD;f+�L�>H?�3B5:<4CF?��nd�74+�-,98>874\,N`-`5:LM+�KId�a}+�>@a,KI+.�),>,N`.�C�<B),CI-t;f+�L�>H?�3B5:<4CF?�74>�?�CI+�<4CF+�7�N�u@+�<'),>@KI;�>8v�7D>@LM+OCI-,7D<4CI<BGH<BCF>8-`58Knai>@74C�<BCI>@-�>8v�ai>k.0+�3 /�574?�CF+�-�<4CI^`?&�D>@Gf34-`58KðNË5�3D+�7D+R583D?~)VCF-f7D<BC�<BGf<4+�6!58-f;�CILMai>@74+M<B),+�CF3!v�5RJ@>@3DCI<4+�XDKFCI-,+�\ >8v�34+�74+�5834?~)<B)f+�34+:N�KF+R5:;,CF-,u�<4>p5O;f+R58;�+�-,;�q�z{-�v�5:?�<RN�5:-�d8>@-,+�.0>8349�CF-,uOCI-M5�G,-fCIJ@+�347DCI<{dl9�-,>k.�7�<B)`5:<<4),+�3D+583D+�KF>8<470>8v�;f+�L�>H?�3B5:<4CF?��nd�74+�-,98>87�N�5:<bKI+R587|<[>@-�5!7DL65:KFK�+�-,>8G,u@)�74?�58KF+:q� L�>@7D<0CF-A<B+�34+�7|<BCI-,ua,3D>@E,KF+�LÎvx>@3O7D>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CF7|<B7 /ð58-,;/ai>@KFCI?�d�1{LM5898+�347,6�CF7�<B>�;,+�74CIu@-UCI-,7D<4CI<4Gf<BCI>@-,7w<4)`5:<OL�CF-,CILMCI��+<B)f+pKICF9:+�KFCI),>�>H;�<B)`5:<'7DG,?~)_ai+�>@afKF+�Ei+�?�>8LM+�<B>�>lai>g.2+�3|vxG,KÔq

(*),+�-t58KIK}CI707458CF;�5:-,;�;,>@-,+:Nf<B)f+�34+wCF7[-,>&-,+�+�;�vx>83[5�XD7D?�CF+�-,?�+�.0583D\!E}+S<{.0+�+�-t74?�CF+�-A<4CF7D<4758-,;/74>�?�CI>@KF>8u@CF7|<B7�q1�2>8<B)�?�>8G,KF;/a}+�3Dvx+�?�<BK�d�.2+�KFK?�>H>8a}+�3B5:<4+�>8-=5�J:5834CI+�<{d >8v2CF7D74G,+�7�qMz{-U>@Gf3J�CF+S.ON �H?�CI+�-,?�+ ��<BG,;,CI+�7�mË+�a,CF7|<B+�LM>@KI>@u@CI?R58K058-,;VL�+�<4),>�;,>@KF>8u@CF?�58K0?�>@-,?�+�CI<476583D+_5�;,C�J@+�3D74CI>@-vx34>8L <B)f+bCFL�a}>@3|<~58-A<�L65:<D<B+�347�<B),5:<L�>8<BC�J85Q<B+�;8��?�CF+�-,?�+.��<BG,;,CI+�7�CF-!<4),+[^`3D7D<�a,KF58?�+:T�-`58L�+�K�d@N<B)f+!74>�?�CF58KÔN�+�?�>@-,>@L�CF?s58-,; ai>@KICI<BCI?R58K�34>@KI+�7w>:v�74?�CI+�-,?�+l58-,;�<4+�?~),-f>@KF>@u:d@qwrû>�Ei+&74Gf34+8N}<B),>@7D+?�>8-,?�+�CI<B715:34+W-,>:<158-y58?�?�CF;f+�-A< 9Ë<B),+Sdc)`5RJ@+t5_)fCF7D<4>@3Dd8N.�),CF?~)]?�58-yCI<B7D+�K�v�E}+W7DG,E��D+�?�<B+�;�<4>74>�?�CI>@KF>8u@CF?�58K�7|<BG,;fd8q �{Ì �0Gf< �H?�CI+�-,?�+ ��<4G,;,CI+�7pa,3B58?S<BC�<BCF>8-,+�3D7s5:34+�-,>8<s>@E,KFCIu@+�; <4>_ai+�347DCF7|<&CI-5]LMCI74u@GfCF;,+�; +�a,CI7D<B+�LM>8KF>@u8d 9�<4),+�d ?�58-�u@CIJ8+ CI<�G,anNw58-,;*u@>y>@- <B>]<4),+�74+�3DCF>@Gf7�<B58749�>8v7D<4G,;fd�CF-fuU7D?�CF+�-,?�+:q 7�+�3D)`58a,7�N0vx34>8L <B)f+tai+�3D74ai+�?S<BCIJ8+Z>:vw5 vx+�. d@+�58347lvx34>8L�-,>k.ONË<4>H;,5kdim�774>Z1{?R5:KFKF+�;�X,�H?�CF+�-f?�+�(c5:3474\1.�CFKIK}<4G,34-t>@Gf<b<4>M)`5RJ8+sLM58349:+�;�74Gf?~)�5l<BG,3D-,CF-,u1ai>@CF-A<�q

Pðà�X â é â�ï Õ ú Öx×DØRÞ~ØQÚ�Û�Ü�×7=�ß{ÜP ;Dõ â Ò ì Õ å Õ ï Ñ|ÒÔÑDç ïðå ÕgÓ î|â Õ��xÑ î{ïÔë ÒðÑ�Ú4çðÑ|Ñ X ì ÕQñ ì Öx×4ØSØ�ÞkÚ|ÛgÛ�ÜBÞ~Ø IRÙ T�ß{Ü�õ â Ò ì ñ å�÷ Ñ|ÒÔÑ|Õ ï Ö ògëkï Õ â�ï�å Õ î|â ó[Û ì~ïÔåæòQã ÑBß

î¬â Õ��xÑ î¬ïðë ÒÔÑSÚ�çðÑ|Ñ�Ð�Ò â çÔç ì ÕQñ <�Ñ üRå�ïðï Öx×DØ�Ø8A:ÚDÛgÛ�Ü�Þ�AQÚ�Ù / IkÙSÙgÚ�/k×~Þ�I�/�ÝSÝ�ß{Ü @ â�ïÔö�ïÔö ÑDçðÑ î|â Õ��xÑ î{ïÔë ÒðÑ4ç�ó[ÑDÒ åæï�î|ì ÒÔÑ ø�ëQãÑ|ó[Û å Ò åäîDì�ãAå Õ ü ÑDç ïðå Ó ì�ïðåäâ Õ òRú�å Õ ï Ñ ãæã Ñ î¬ïðëQìSã�ögå ç ïÔâ Ò åäì ÕQç|Ü

� �

Page 19: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

� � ����� � ���� ��� �����F�

(=+�.2>@G,KI;ZKICF98+�<B>1<B)`58-f9 BZCF?~)f+�K � ),CF-,7�N �H),+�KFKI+�d � >@KI;,7D<4+�CF-�Nf�w-A<D<BC 4�G,a,CF58CF-,+�-nN J'>@34L��+�J�CI<D<�58-,;lrbCIL BZ58G,;,KICF-&vx>@3�L658-AdsCF-A<B+�34+�7D<BCI-,u�;,CI74?�Gf7474CI>@-,7>@-!<4),+bCF7D74G,+�7;,CF7D?�G,7D74+�;M),+�34+:q�wv�?�>@G,3D74+8N`<4),+�d�5:34+OCF-�-,>l.05kd�3D+�7Da}>@-f74CFEfKF+�vx>@3[.�)`5Q<'.2+p)`5RJ@+O.�34CI<D<B+�-nq

� ��� �R������� � ���

�wKIE}+�3D<RN BZCF?~),58+�Kðq � � ��� q�X=)'>83D<{d�<B),+�afG,E,KFCI?wa,)fCFKF>874>@a,)f+�34\fq���� � ���� �� "8/�J�>kJ@+�L!E}+�3�6�T� � � � � q

�w3D>@-,>k.�CI<4�8N ��<B58-,KI+�d@q � ����� q>�����:"�� ��" ��� � � "����� 5� ����� � � ��" � ����� �M"��Z��� � ���� ���M"�����������:"�% �iq!BtCF-,-`5:a}>@KICF7�T!E�-,C�J@+�3474C�<{d�>8v BZCF-f-,+�7D>8<~58734+�7D7�q

�[583D-,+�7�Nf�[5:343Ddl58-,; ��5RJ�CF;��0KI>H>83�q � ����� q�X=)�+�KP5Q<BCIJ�CI74LtN@3B5:<4CF>@-,58KFCI74L�58-,;1<B),+'74>�?�CI>@KF>8u8d>8vË9�-,>k.�KF+�;,u@+�\fq!z{-nT� ��%��:��� ��� �`% � � ����� "��?��%������ � � N�afanq B � � � � q>E�;fCI<B+�;�E�d B_583|<BCF- �'>@KFKICF758-,; ��<4+�J@+�- ��G,9:+�7�q0����vx>@34;nTË�0KF58?~9A.0+�KFKðq

�[583D-,+�7�N��[583D3Dd8N ��5RJ�CF; �2KF>�>@3W58-f;��8>@),- ��+�-,3Dd8q � � ��� q �����:"�� %S� � ��� � � � ��" � M"�����������:�Z��� ��:�=����� � ����� ��� �Aq!I0)fCF?R5:u@>,T�E�-fCIJ@+�347DCI<{d�>8v I0),CI?R58u@>8734+�747�q

�0+�-f749�CÔN>I0KP5:G,;,+ "�% ����� � " � � � ��!#""���%$�%�'& �,"�� � � " ��% ��� �(��"��*)(+-,.,., � � ����%�/ � � � � �:�����Aq��wL�),+�3D7D<RN Jpq10!qIT!734>8LM+S<B),+�G,7�q

�0KF>�>@3�N ��5RJHCI;nq � � � � q�� � � � ��" � M"�� ���*�����������2� � � M"����iq B43�5 +�;nqHI0),CF?�58u@>,T�E'-,CIJ8+�3D74CI<{d>8v I0),CF?�58u@>8734+�747�q

�0>@u@)f>@747DCP58-nNc7�58G,Kðq � � ��� q�X|(*),5:<Z<4),+ �H>@9Q58K�),>A5g��>@G,u@)A<t<B>y<B+R5:?~) G,7�q�\ � � " �6e�`%�"���� ��� � � � � ��" � "�� %>/���+�?�+�L!Ei+�3 ��f 6�T � � � � K qc)�+�af34CF-A<4+�; CF-�T7�98�� � ��": � �`� %D��� �#� ���.�! $ � � �����.� ��% � ���M"���� � ��%;� �2%� �<� �� � % �����:"�� ��"8N�+�;,CI<4+�;WEAdCJ�>@3D+�<D<~5 4�>�+�3|<Bu@+:NHa,a�q B�f � f�� qJ�+S.=0Ë>@3D9�T0����vx>@3D; E'-,CIJ8+�347DCI<{d 73D+�747�N � � ��� q

�034CI?�L�>@-A<RN#�8+�58-nq � � � � qlX=�H>H?�CF>@KI>@u8dW58-,;_+�a,CF7|<B+�LM>@KI>@u8d8qæ\crû>M58a,ai+R583'CF-�� ">� � "?��� %�"����� ��%��:��� ����" �M"7 �M�`��� ��� � �M�:"@q

�034>�?~)nN���+�-,34Cðq � � � B q;� � /A@ � � �M"!�CB "�$&% �=�M�������� ����,"8q��2>@34;,+�58GH�}T �m �'>@34CI��>@-�I0),CILED+�34C N Gf+8q�034Gf-,+�<�N 7CF+�343D+8q � �&f � qF6GB �� % ����� � ��%��:��� �M" �F%�IH"������:" � �M"KJ�" �3% ��� "��L& ��� � ��"D� �NMPO �C�Q�SR

���UT"�����"@q 7�583DCF7�T�sq��0KP5:-,?~)`583D;nqWVA)�+�a,3DCF-A<B+�;�E�d ��KP5:<49�CI-,+8N � +�-,+�J:5fN � � � � q1XI0>@KFKICF-,7�N ��58343|d B/q � ��� � q�X=��<~58u8+�7�CI-s<B)f+[+�L�a,CF3DCF?�58K�a,34>@u83B58L�LM+Ë>8v�3D+�KP5Q<BCIJ�CI74L�\,q �����������

� % � ���:" � ��������:"�� ��"ZY#Y`T f � � � qI0>@KFKICF-,7�N �w5:343Dd8q � � � B q / � � ������E[ � �M"��\�]� " � � �:�=��%S�:��� � ���^����� � ��%S�:��� �� �����:"�� %�� � �

���M��%S�:��"8q ��+�?�>8-,; +�;,CI<4CF>@-�.�CI<B)*5c-f+�. 5:v�<B+�3D.2>@34;nq I0),CF?�58u@>,T E�-fCIJ@+�347DCI<{d >8v I0),CI?R58u8>734+�747�q

I0>@KFKICF-,7�N ��58343|d!5:-,;!rû34+�J8>@307CF-,?~)�q � � ��f q� � "I_F�Z��" � �Z` � ��%a!b��"���� ��� " � � � � � �7� � � �� �� � %!�����:"�� ��"8q!I[58L!E,3DCF;,u8+8T!I[58L!Ef34CF;fu@+ E�-fCIJ@+�347DCI<{d 734+�747�q

��5RJ@+�-,587�N Ebqe"�%H����� � ����� qOX���G,LM58-�E`587D>@a,),CIK�;,+�u@3B5:-�GfKP5:<4CF>@-6<434CIu@u@+�3D+�;�EAd6J8+�3|d�;,CFKIGf<B+58-A<BCI74+�34G,L 5:uA58CF-f7D<�z{u�E\,qcJ5��% � �,"ed2d#dnT ����� � ��� � q

� �

Page 20: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

��>@E,E,7�Nf�2+�<4<{d��8>&rû+�+S<B+�3[58-,; B_5834u@5834+S< Iwq �@58?�>8Enq � � � K qbJ�" �3%���� � ��� % � " / � � % � ��"����J�" �3%���� ��� � � � � q�[<BKF58-A<BCF? ��CFu8),KP58-f;,7�N J'+�. �8+�347D+�diT �'G,LM58-,CI<4CF+�7 734+�7D7�q

�`34CF+�;,LM58-nN BZCF?~),58+�Kðq � � ��� q�XB��-6<B)f+�74>�?�CI>@KF>@u:dl>8v�74?�CF+�-�<4CI^`?�9�-,>k.�KF+�;fu@+�58-,;�C�<B7Ëa,),CIKF>2174>8a,),CF?�58K�58u8+�-,;`5:\,q � % � �.�K8� ��%$�K �M�`���.����� � ��� T B�f � � B � � q

� +�34u@+�-nN 4O+�-,-,+S<B)��fq � � ��� qOX4�`+�LMCI-,CF7|<?�3DCI<BC N G,+�>8vn7D?�CF+�-,?�+w58-,;1<B),+�?~)`58KIKF+�-fu@+�>8vn7D>H?�CP58K+�afCF7D<4+�L�>@KF>8u8d�\,q�z{-nT &e" � �� � ��%0 � � � ��M%�� ���% � "H� % � � ��% � �,"F��� � � � � ��" � M"8N:+�;,CI<4+�;pEAd>B_583DdBZ? I[58-,-,+Sd � +�3Du@+�-�N,a,anq B � � � � q0J'+�.=0Ë>8349�T!J�+�.�0Ë>@349 E�-,C�J@+�3D74C�<{d 734+�7D7�q

� CI-,u@34587�N;0wJ@+�7�q � � � K q X E�-y58CI3s;f+W3B58;fCF?R5:KFCF7DLM+:T8�HG,3 N G,+�K N G,+�7!<B+�-f;`58-,?�+�713 D+�?�+�-A<4+�7+�-/74>�?�CI>@KF>8u@CF+s;,+1KP5W74?�CF+�-,?�+1+�<p;,+1KF56<B+�?~)f-,>@KF>8u@CF+�\,qZ�D��%�" ���M"-�?���."�� � "��,� � "*"�� �����:"�� ��" �������������" ��Y�����T f � � � q

� 3D>@747�NM7�58G,K )Oq@5:-,;CJ'>@34LM58- ��+�J�C�<4<Rq � � � � / B 3�5 +�;�q � � ��� 6�qF8D� �� "�� � � � "�� ��%��`%S�:���#� � "�D�=� �M" � �:� 6 " �;%F� ��� �`%��� � � ���,"�� � �3�`%� �����:"�� ��"��s�[58KI<4CFL�>@34+:TW�8>@),-,7��'>@a,9�CF-,7#E'-,CIJ8+�3D74CI<{d734+�747�q

�w5@5:?~9iN!��G,7B58-�q � � � � qeX|(U+Wa,3B5:u@L65Q<BCF7|<B71q�q�q�TC7�+�CI34?�+�58-,; )�>@3|<{d=CI-=?�>8-�J8+�3D7B5:<4CF>@-,\fq � �;%S� � � �P� ">���:" ���� �� / � 6�T ��� � � � � q3)�+�a,3DCF-A<B+�;�CF- �w5@5:?~9 � � ��� NH?~)`58af<4+�3 B q

�w5@5:?~9iN ��G,7B58-�q � � ��� qb� � � � � " ��% � ���c�Z ��� ���:��� ��% "?� ���M"�����%�"���� � � ��� �M�:��� � ��"K! � � � � ���I0),CI?R58u@>fT�E�-,C�J@+�3D74C�<{d�>8v I0),CF?�58u@>8734+�7D7�q

��G,L�+8N ��5RJHCI;nq � ����� V � ��� � Xðq � � ! ��� � ���� / ��� ��"���� ��� 8 � � � ��� ���M"�� ��%:� �������}q�wL�),+�347D<�N Jsq 0lq�T!7�3D>@L�+�<B)f+�G,7�q

4�CI<B?~)f+�3�N � � ��� q�XD� 7KF+�5'vx>@3 �H?�CI+�-,?�+ ��<4G,;,CI+�74\fq�z{-nT ��8>� � ��"�: � �`� %e���-�#� ���.�F! $ � � ����� � ��% � ���M"���� � ��%G� �Z% � ��� �� � %>�����:"�� ��"8Nb+�;,C�<B+�;VE�d J�>834+�<D<~5 4O>�+�3|<Bu@+:Nba,anq f B � K�� q J'+�.0Ë>@3D9iT2����vx>@34; E'-,CIJ8+�347DCI<{d 734+�747�q

��5:<B>@Gf3�N`�03DG,-,>,q � ��� � q �����:"�� ��"����D��%S�:���#� 8>� � % �e& �Z�`��� � �����:"�� %�� ��%�>� ���N! ����� "�"�� �%����� � �� �������:"�% �iq!I[5:L!E,34CI;,u@+:N B_587D7B58?~)�G,7D+�<4<47�T ��583DJ:583D; E�-,C�J@+�3D74C�<{d 734+�7D7�q

��5:<B>@Gf3�N��03DG,-,>,q � � ��� q_X�)�58L�7��+�7�z4z�+�7|<�1�CFK�L�>@3|<�;,+lKP5�<BG,Ei+�3D?�G,KI>@74+Rjk\fq 6���� "�� � "��,� � "d���� /:B_5:34?~) 6�T � � � � K q3�H+�+s58KF7D>!<B),+O+�343B5Q<~5�d���� /��waf34CFK 6ST � K 5:-,; d�� � /SB_5Rd 6ST � q

��58G,;`58-�N ��58343|d@q � � ��� q�X|rb),+la,74+�G,;,>21�74?�CF+�-f?�+l>8v�7D?�CF+�-,?�+RjR\ �M�`��� ��� � ��� ���>% � " ����������������:"�� ��" � Y2Y`T � � f � � ��� q

��58G,;`58-�N �û5:343Dd8q � � ��� 5fq-�����:"�� ��"8� �����."��?��%������ � � q I0),CI?R58u@>fT�E�-fCIJ@+�347DCI<{d�>:v I0),CI?R58u8>734+�747�q

��58G,;`58-�N ��583D3Dd@q � � ��� Enq=X ��+�L&d�7|<BCIv�d�CI-,u�G,-,;,+�34;,+S<B+�3DLMCI-`5:<4CF>@-,\fq�� �� � " ���Z%:� � % � ���:" ��� %� "7 �M�`��� ��� � ��� ���5�����:"�� ��"ZY���T B�� � � B � � q

B_58;,;f>k�}NK�8>@)f-nN<�@58L�+�7*)�5:-,;,C'58-,;�(c58K�<B+�31(Yq ��<4+�.0583D<�q � ����� q X�� ��CFu8) 1{;,CIKFGf<4CF>@-�m+S�Hai+�3DCFL�+�-A<B7'5l;,+�KIG,74CI>@-,\,q�J5��% � �,"ed2d���T B � � � B ��� q

BZ? � CF-f-nNeI0>@KFCI-nq � � �&f q� �,� ��" � � ��� �M�`��� ��� � ���U� � "e6e� � �`%� ��������� � �����q1����vx>@34;nT�0KF58?~9A.0+�KFKÔq

BZ+�3DLMCI-nN Jpq ��5RJ�CF;nq � � ��� 5fqtX|(*),5:<Rm�7�.�34>@-fuW.�CI<B)Z<B),CI7�74G,7|<~58CI-,CF-fuWL&d�<B)�jR\ ��� ���:� � #����� ��� � / f 6c/:BZ5834?~) 6�T � � � ��f q

BZ+�3DLMCI-nN&Jpq ��5kJ�CI;nq � � ��� EnqwXDrb),+ � >8KF+�L�CF��5:<BCI>@-�>8vf34+�KF5:<BC�J�CI<{d�\,q ��� ���:� �> #����� ��� � / � 6/���a,34CIK`6�T � � � � f q

B��

Page 21: £k®~®B¡~¯ §{¡ ¦6£k° °¬µ ®D - physics.nyu.edu #9, *) B;,+ + a f · ¿ M % "C = M " %-

BZ+�3DLMCI-nNMJsq ��5RJ�CF;nq � � ��� ?8qOX,��>H?�CF>@KI>@u@CF7|<B7�N874?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<2?�>@-A<BCI-�Gf+�;,+�E`5:<4+w58Ei>@Gf<Ë7D?�CF+�-A<BCI^,?a,3D>H?�+�747D\,q ��� ���:� � ����� � � � / � 6c/ �8G,KId 6ST � � � � K N ��� q

BZ+�3DLMCI-nN Jpq ��5RJ�CF;nq � � � � q X,�H>�?�CI>@KF>8u@CF7|<B7�NË74?�CF+�-�<4CF7|<Wa,CI?~9�5Q<M<4),34+�58;,76>:vO5834u8G,LM+�-A<58Ei>@Gf<�7D?�CF+�-,?�+�\,q ��� ���:� � ����� � � � / � 6c/ �@58-�G`583Dd 6�T � B � � K q

BZ+�3DLMCI-nN�Jpq ��5RJHCI;nq � � ��� qwXDrb),+b7D?�CF+�-,?�+�>8vi7D?�CF+�-,?�+:T�� a,)Ad�74CI?�CI7D<�34+�58;,7��[5:34-,+�7�N��0KF>�>@358-,; ��+�-,3Dd�\,q ����������� � % � ���:" � ��������:"�� ��" � �nT ���&f � � B2f q

Jw58u8+�KÔNfrb),>@LM587�q � � � � q � "76�����% ` ������q!J�+S. 0Ë>@349�TË����vx>@34; E�-fCIJ@+�347DCI<{d 734+�747�qJw58-f;`5fN.BZ+�+�3B5Hq � � � � q XDrb),+ ��?�CF+�-,?�+t(c5:3476CI-Vz{-,;fCP58\,q 5� � ��"�� %����e/ � 6 /�(*CF-A<B+�3�6ST

� � � �&f qJ�>k.2>8<B-Ad@N �'+�KFu@5fq � � � � q X,��?�CF+�-,?�+W58-,;]CI<47&?�34CI<4CF?�7�T134+�G`+�?S<BCF>8-,7!>@-]5:-�<4C?1�74?�CI+�-,?�+�\ z{-nT

/ � � � %�"����$� �(��" � "�� % ��� %� "�����:"�� ��" ��9H+�;,C�<B+�;�E�d �sq J�>k.0>:<B-Ad�58-,; �pq )�>@74+:q ��>@34;f34+�?~)A<�T)�+�CF;f+�KÔq

� G,CF-,+:N�(*CIKFKP5:34;��Ë58- ��34LM58-nq � ����� q"XDr[.0>�;,>@u8L6587�>:v&+�LMa,CI34CI?�CF7DLM\fq z{-nT & �,� �� 6 � ��:�=���F �Z�� % ��� O �:" �ON�74+�?�>@-,;�+�;,C�<BCF>8-nN34+SJHCI74+�;nq�V���CF347|<1+�;,C�<BCI>@-nN � � K2f X.I[58L!Ef34CF;fu@+8NB_587D7B58?~)�G,7D+�<D<B7�T �w583|J85:34; E�-,C�J@+�3474C�<{d 734+�747�q

)'>83D<{d@N )'CI?~)`583D;nq � � ��� q � � % � � ���� �,� �," � ��� �M�`��� ��� � �M�:�=���F � � "�� ��� I[58L!Ef34CF;fu@+8TI[58L!Ef34CF;fu@+#E�-,C�J@+�3474C�<{d 734+�747�q

)'Gf7474+�KFKðN��0+�3|<B3458-,;nq � ����� V ^`347|<O+�;,C�<BCI>@- � � � � XÔqe8D� ��%������ ��� ` " ��%�"����� �M�`��� ��� � ����N B43�5+�;�q ��>@-f;,>@-nT � +�>@3Du@+��wKIKF+�-�� E�-A.�CF-nqKV )�+�a,3DCF-A<B+�;ZEAd )�>@Gf<BKI+�;,u8+8N ��>@-,;f>@-nN � � � � q X

�HKF+��R589�N 7û+�<B+�3�q � � � � 5fqOXDrb)f+p7D>H?�CP58K}?�>@-f7D<B3DG,?�<4CF>@-t>8vû74>�?�CF58K�?�>@-,7|<B34Gf?�<BCI>@-,CI74L�\ ����� � ����d �}T � f � � � K � q

�HKF+��R589�N 7û+�<4+�3�q � � � � E�q XD�h74+�?�>@-f;eKF>�>@9c5Q< ��5RJ�CF;��0KI>H>@3�mæ7L� � � � ��" � M" � ��� ������������ � � M"�����\,qb �M�`��� ��� � ��� ���c%� "c����������� �����:"�� ��" � � ��T f&f�� � f���� q

�H>@9Q58KðNË��KP58- �!q � � ��� q XDr�3458-,7Du@34+�7474CI-,u�<B),+�Ei>@G,-,;`5:34CF+�7�T�rû>k.[583D;V5�<43B58-,7|vx>@34LM5:<4CIJ@+),+�34L�+�-,+�Gf<BCI?�7�>8v N G,58-A<BG,L u@345RJHC�<{d�\,q �����������H #"�$&% ����� � �}T B � � � B K B q

�H>@9Q58KðNû��KP58-�q � � ��� q=X|(*)`5:<O<4),+ �����������F #"�$&%�5���58CI3�;,>�+�7s58-,;/;,>H+�7s-f>8<pa,34>kJ@+�\,qWz{-nT� 8�� � ��"^: � �`� %-��� �#� ���.� ! $ � � ����� � ��% � ���M"���� � ��%�� �2%� ��� �� � %������:"�� ��"@N[+�;,CI<4+�;�E�dJ�>834+�<D<~5-4�>H+�3D<4u@+8N`a,a�q � � B B q J�+�.=0Ë>@349�TË����vx>@34; E�-,C�J@+�3474C�<{d 734+�747�q

�H>@9Q58KðNs��KP58-Y58-f; �8+R58-��03DCF?�L�>@-A<Rq � � ��� q ��� % "��`��"���% � ���W� � � � ��% � ��" ��� .� ��% � ���M"���� �M�`��� ��� � � "�� ��B�� � ��" ���8�����:"�� ��"8q ��>@-,;f>@-nT8734>8^`KI+W�0>�>@9�7�q 7G,EfKFCF7D),+�;=CF-=<4),+�E�c5:-,;I[58-`5:;`5UG,-f;,+�3�<B),+t<BCI<4KF+P& ��� �M�:��� � ��"LJ�������"�����"��* � ��% � ���M"���� ��� % "��`��"���% � ��� ��Bc� � ��" ��������:"�� ��"8q J'+�. 0Ë>@349�TC7�CI?R58;f>@3 E���&q V���34CIu@CF-`5:KFKId�a,G,E,KICF74)f+�;]CF-y�`3D+�-,?~)yG,-,;f+�3!<B)f+W<BCI<4KF+� � � � ��% � ��" �5�� %�"��`��"���% � "��`��" �@q07�583DCF7�T0��;,CIKF+G�@5:?�>@EnN � � � � q1X

B �