Television and Newspaper Which is the most effective advertising medium for your business? Presented...

Television and Newspaper

Which is the most effective advertising

medium for your business?

Presented by: KSL-TV Research

Newspaper Task Force

• Local Account Executives– 2 Account Executives assigned to work with Research Department

– One Quarter to complete project

– National/Local Trends

Newspaper Task Force• Focus:

–In-house computer software/research:

–Stowell, Scarborough, Qualitap

–External research: TVB, NAA, Starch, Belden

–Speaker (Former NP Account Executive)

Newspaper Task Force• Focus:

–Newspaper Websites–Rate Information–Newspaper Ads–Newspaper Terminology

Internet Sites• Research Sites

–www.tvb.orgwww.naa.org

–www.org/national/index.html–www.org/retail/index.html–[email protected]–tvadvertising.com–Local Newspaper Web Sites

Newspaper Task Force

• Project Finalization–Trainer Guide–Sales One Sheets–Sales Training

Newspaper Facts• Pros

–History–Visual–Ad Variety–In Depth–Tracking

• Cons–Passive–Decreased Market

Penetration –Browsers, Not

Readers–Readers Don’t See

Ads–Coupon Usage is

Declining–Ad Clutter

Source: RAB Media Facts 12/10/97

Newspaper Trends

• The percentage of Americans reading weekday newspapers has dropped from 67% in 1977 to 51% in 1997

Source: The report, “Consumer Media Usage’. Produced for the Newspaper Association of America (NAA) and the American Society of Newspaper Editors (ASNE) by Clark, Martire and Bartolomeo.”

Newspaper Trends

• The decline has spanned every income and educational level


Newspaper Trends

• Weekday newspapers reach approximately 6 out of 10 American Adults

• Sunday editions reach 7 out of 10 American Adults


Read59%

Do Not Read41%

Newspaper Trends

U.S. Daily/Sunday/Weekend Newspaper Reading Audience

1996 Avg Adult Daily Readership

Source: NAA Facts About Newspapers, 1997; A18+ Total Population

Read69%

Do Not Read31%1996 Avg Adult

Sunday/Weekend Readership

U.S. Daily/Sun/Weekend Newspaper Reading Audience

Source: WR Simmons & Associates, 1970-19977; Simmons Market Research Bureau, Inc. 1980-1994; Scarborough Reports-Top 50 Markets, 1995-1996

Year Weekday Sun/Weekend1970 78% 72%1980 67% 67%1985 64% 65%1990 62% 67%1995 64% 73%1996 59% 69%

%chg. ‘70-’96 -24% -5.3%

Salt Lake Tribune/Deseret News Historical Trend

Source: Audit Bureau of Circulation’s 6 month report ending 9/30/98

Metro HH Gross Circ. Adv. Cost Year %chg %chg %chg

1993 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%

1994 1.6% 1.0% 0.0%

1995 4.1% 2.0% 8.0%

1996 6.3% 3.0% 8.0%

1997 8.7% 4.2% 13.2%

1998 11.3% 2.9% 17.7%

Salt Lake City Newspaper Reading Audience

Read61%

Do Not Read39%

39% of the Adults 18+ in the Salt Lake Market Do not Read

the Daily Newspaper!

Source: Stowell, 1997

The Salt Lake Market is Spending Less Time with the

Daily Paper

16.1

14.515.6

27.4

2423.9

6.98.1

9.410.2

10

7.15.3

5.84.1

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

<15' 16-30' 31-45' 46-60' 60'+

1989 1995 1997

Source: Stowell, 1989, 1995, 1997

15.6

21.9

44.4

18.1

7.3

16

34

42.7

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

<30' 30'+

A18-24

A25-34

A35-54

A55+

Percentage of Adults in the Salt Lake Market Who Read

the Daily Paper

Source: Scarborough, Feb’98-Jan’99

26

4641 46

5452

38

49

42.7 57

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Men Women

Sports Entertainment Comics Business/Finance Classifieds

Persons 18+ NOT Noting Ads in Specific Sections of the

Newspaper (%)

Source: Starch Database, 6000+ Interviews September 1995-Adnorms

4240 42

38 36 36

62

7260 42.7 57 58

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Men Women

Confectionary Soaps Pet Food/Pet Care

HH Products/Cleansers Soft Drinks Toiletries

Noting of Grocery Ads (%)


6365

66

74

56

58

60

62

64

66

68

70

72

74

1st Quarter 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter

Do Adults Pay Attention to Newspaper Ads?


% of People Not Noting Ads

Salt Lake Market


Newspaper Reader Demographic Profile

Source: Scarborough, Feb’98-Jan’99

Market• 50.1% Male• 49.9% Female• A25-54: 60.6%• HHI: $50k-$74,999k

19.7%• 66.1% Married• 20.5% Coll. Degr.+• 73.7% Own Home

Market• 52.6% Male• 47.4% Female• Avg Age: 42.2• Avg HHI: $54,973

• 66.7% Married• 36.2% Coll. Degr.+• 78.1% Own Home

Salt Lake Market


• 52.3% Male• 47.7% Female• Avg Age: 42.1• Avg HHI: $53,367• 69.3% Married• 34.4% Coll. Deg.+• 76.3% Own Home

Read <15’ Read 16’-30’• 52.6% Male• 47.4% Female• Avg Age: 38.4• Avg HHI: $58,820• 64.7% Married• 42.3% Coll. Deg.+• 75.6% Own Home

Newspaper Reader Demographic Profile




Read 46-60’Read 31’-45’

Salt Lake MarketNewspaper Reader Demographic Profile

Do Adults Pay Attention to Newspaper Inserts?

No51.9%

Yes48.1%

Are your advertising dollars working most effectively for

your business?


4-5 Hrs5-6 Hrs

6-7 Hrs 6-7 Hrs

7+ Hrs

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8 1950's

1960's

1970's

1980's

1990's

Television Viewership is on the Rise

Source: TVB Nielsen Media Research NTI Annual Averages

52%

11%

26%

11%

Television Magazines Newspapers Radio

Which Advertising Medium is Most Authoritative

Among Adults?

Source: TVB and the MEDIACENTER,1998

80%

4%8%

8%


Which Advertising Medium is Most Influential Among Adults?


77%

7%5%

11%


Which Advertising Medium is Most Exciting Among Adults?


40%

14%

34%

12%


Which Advertising Medium is Most Believable Among Adults?


Adults Spend More Time With Television Each Day


TV NP Radio Mag.

A25-54 213’ 27’ 137’ 16’

$50-<$75k 192’ 25’ 103’ 20’

College Grad+ 166’ 36’ 115’ 22’

Prof/Tech/Mgr/ 159’ 3’ 139’ 16’ Prop

Time Spent Yesterday in Minutes with Major Media

Television Reaches More Adults Than Any Other Medium


TV NP Radio Mag.

A25-54 89 58 77 36

$50-<$75k 87 59 76 45

College Grad+ 85 67 79 41

Prof/Tech/Mgr/ 87 66 79 37 Prop

Reached Yesterday By Major Media (%)

Time Spent Yesterday with Major Media (Minutes)


22'36'

115' 166'

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

Magazines Newspapers Radio Television

College Graduate+

Reached Yesterday by Major Media (%)


41%

67%79%

85%

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Magazines Newspapers Radio Television

College Graduate+

Summary• Utilize Research Sources• Involve Your Account

Executives–Bonus from management for increase in sales

–Get AE input: They know their clients

• Change clients mind set• Media Mix with newspaper

Television and Newspaper Which is the most effective advertising medium for your business? Presented...

Documents

Transcript of Television and Newspaper Which is the most effective advertising medium for your business? Presented...