[G OKTCZBF BKDGSF - talmudha-igud.org.il VI/forty...frgfmf \giv[p sgikk qkkrtc \zibfg |7~ \kcf kpkc...
Transcript of [G OKTCZBF BKDGSF - talmudha-igud.org.il VI/forty...frgfmf \giv[p sgikk qkkrtc \zibfg |7~ \kcf kpkc...
FSGDKBFBZCTKOG[\KKO{’VKZG\DKRGSZ’)PET"B(
>P[RF<
FCKBGNVRKGPNKI\INFGV\TPG{PCZLTNFPNKIGVGJZB\FV\,[FV\JVNF
NG.HFFMNN:MN[FGBTKYZGTPGJVNF{PCZLTNFTKYZGVGJZB\FJVNF.
>DPZB<
.1GPKBKMBPKEKEFGKPNKITKYZGV\JVNF? B.BGYKP\B[N
BPGZBKCCNNFNMF
[CP[RFFPDCKNF
B\FFNMFNEDK
FMKRZ\
.2BPZZCBIBCZKFEZCTGKZBBPZZCB[K:CBGMNKVKZG\DRGSZ[RG.
.3BPZZCFCZCZIRF:MKFGFBHNKRQC\ZKFEZCKKGIRQNPKMNVKZG\DRGSZ,MK
FGKRQCKPBF{PRYJKRQNKFNMNIEGIET[ZFT[ZF,GMKFGKRQCKT[ZF{
PRYJKRQNKFMNIEGIEPBFPBF,GMNPBFPKRKKFGFGFPIHKYNFGXRBCZ
\N\BSBGKGBMKNNFGGP[\CTENBJTKOHKGRB.
C.PT[KOCBPGZBK
BZWK[ZBNGEDK
FMKRZ\,GPT[KO
RGSVKOCBPGZBKBZW
K[ZBN
.4HKGRBSNYBET\L?BNBBKPB:PHGRB.
.5ZCKBCFGBMKNTEEFGF[ZKYNKFEGECBPBVG\KF;GZCBPKGZCBSKFGGBMNK
TEER\GZPHKKFG.ZCK[PTGQCQNYK[FGFBMKNTEEPZKE,GBPZNFGZCKKGIRQ
NECKR[KBF,GFGFP[EZNKFZCKKFGEFR[KBFCBNG[KBC\ZKFGPKK\KNKF
NCK\KF.
.6MKB\BZCEKPK,BPZ:TKZBI\FK\FNGNKRBKFPNLCFZFPNL,[FKG
PGXKBKOPPRF[[KOZCGBSVNKJZK\NYGXXK\BRKOPTZC[C\NTZC[C\.
.7MKB\BZCKQ,BPZ:BKNQBIEFKFNGNKRBKFPNLCFZFPNL,[FKGPGZKEKO
PPRGBZCTKOSBFDGHNG\P[NG[CZKMG\CIE[.
.8MKB\BZCKKXIY,BPZ:TKZBI\FK\FCBZWK[ZBNGDGVRK\[PF,[FKGCF
[PRKOHGDG\BIKOMFRKOR[GBKON[PRKOHGDG\BIKG\MFRG\.
.9GCEYGZCRQPSGZBGTERFZETB,GNBB[MIGCZPCR\KFEZCISEBEFGGRSKCQ
NZPKCZIPBGNPZTGYCBCZIPB,GBUTNDCEBKRFKFGGMFR\B{BKRFGNB
FGGMFRK.
.10BPZZC:MNSTGEF[BKQCFPNI>RGSIBIZGRMGQ:"PNKI"<BKRFSTGEF. D.[\KPKPZG\
CTRKKQFSTGEF
.11BPZZCKIKKBCZBCBBPZZCKKGIRQ:MNSTGEF[BKQCF[ZKU>RGSIBIZ
GRMGQ:"[ZU"<BKRFSTGEF.
615
PSGZ\F\NPGE
~1=2|GPKBKMBPKEK...CBGMNK...[RG.F[GGKZG[NPKCZMG\GH,KT"E.~3=4|BPZZCFCZCZIRF...
GP[\CTENBJTOHKGRB...BKPBPHGRB.CCNKTKZGCKQNT"B;F[GGKZG[NPKTKZGCKQDB,MT"E;REZKOG
B,NJT"D;RHKZGJ,RFT"D;CZB[K\ZCFVZ[FXE,SKPQC.~6=8|F[GGKZG[NPK\TRK\EF,SJT"B;
BKMFZCFVZ[FC,SKPQC.
Z["K
PNKIMNECZPNGI.DPZB.VKZG\DRGSZVKZG\BZWKOMRZ\I[GCKOPQFV\.HKGRBP[PTPKEKECZ
BMKNF.PHGRBECZFSGTE.E[ZKYEGECBPBVG\KF[FHCGCPINKYPPXIG,P\GLXFN\VRKOC[ZG
PINKY.TEEPZKEET\GPJZV\.CBNG[KBGMNGSKCRKBEO.SVNKJZK\SVNKOPNBKOI\KMG\EDI\GL,
[YGZKOJGRKR"B.NYGXXK\BRKONPBMNVGTNKO[YGXXKO\BRKO,GFKGPZGCKOTE[MNBNGXZKMKQNFO
NPBMN.CZKMG\YGCKKB"[CNT"H.P[N[CZKMG\CIE[[N[VTPKOCIE[PGZKEKOPPRGML.[PRKO
HGDG\BIKO[RKO[RKOBIKOFKGMGNO,GMQR[G\KFO.[ZKU\C[KNNI[K[CGPZY,MPG:[GZVFIKF.
616PSM\CZMG\{VZYMKXEPCZMKQ
PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF
P[R\RG,CZMG\GH,PRGSI\MVZJGMNN.\IKNFRYCT[CZM\"[FMN"TNPNKI{EDPNGI{
VGJZ\PCZMFB\FV\FRBMN\TPG,GBIZMLRYCTFMNN:MN[FGBTKYZGTPGJVNF,PCZL
TNFTKYZGVGJZB\FJVNF.FBPGZBKO\FGTNML[EDPNGIRI[CNTKYZCKISNV\
FPGD[\TPG~1|,GZCB[KFTPKEB\P[R\RGC"VKZG\DKRGSZ"~2|.ZGCO[NFVZ[RKOGFIGYZKO
MMGNOFCKRG["VKZG\DKRGSZ"FOV+ZG\BKNQP\GYKOCPKGIEPBHGZDKRGSZ,BHGZFMKRZ\.BLPQ
FFY[ZRZBFCZGZ[FMGGRFFKBNV+ZG\KODKRGSZ,EFKKRGFEDKO[CKOMKRZ\.FEDKOFNNG,
[RBMNGCKQFK\ZMCG[KOCPNI,R\VSGMYNKNKOCPKGIENTKMGN,GNMQRFDGNBMNOCMPGKG\
DEGNG\CPKGIE,KISK\NV\[NKGG\FBG\O.PSKCFHGRI[C\FV\FPGTJ\FRBMN\KIEB\O
JVNFNFO.FMPG\FBDE\K\[RFDGNBMGNPQFEDKOFNNGRKMZ\P\GLFPT[KOCZCKKGIRQ
GC\NPKEKGFPGCBKOCVKSYBG\~3=5|.BDCFEKGQCEDPNGIFPFGGFTKYZSTGEFCBZWK[ZBN
PGCB\PSGZ\PKPKFCK\TNTKZBI\CKPKKRBKFPNL[FKK\FPYXFNYGXXKF\BRKO
[C\GMFMPG\DEGNF[NJZK\{SGD[NEDPNGI{NXGZLSTGEG\KFOCP[LF[CGT~6|.
PSGZ\HGFKBINYP\KBGZF[VT[CBZWK[ZBNNVRKFIGZCQFBGVKKRKNBDEG\FIGZCQ,GFKB
PGCB\CSGDKBKIETO[\KPSGZG\EGPG\[FGCBGNCCNMPGFTNKEKFRIG\K,BI\CTRKKQ
ZKCGKFDGHNG\[[KP[GNYZCRG\FKGNEG\CKPKFCK\~7|GFBIZ\CTRKKQKKIGSP[VIG\FMFGRF
~8|.PSGZG\BNGR[\PZGDOCYGCWBDEG\FIGZCQ[CKZG[NPK\TRK\EF,SJT"BGCBKMFZCF
VZ[FC,SKPQC.CPYCKNG\FNNGREGQNFNQ,CTKGRKFVKZG[.
CSGUFSGDKBPGCBG\[\KPKPZG\RGSVG\FPKGISG\NZCGZCKKGIRQ,CF\BPF,GNVKFQMN
STGEF[BKQCFPNI{BGPNKI,NVKDKZS\M\CKFKEVKZRXFGPKRMQ~10|{G[ZKU{BG[ZU,
NVKDKZS\M\CKFKEVKZRXFGPKRMQ~11|,BGNK[ZUFCNSO,EFKKRG[PQBVZSPGQNFZIF{
BKRFSTGEF.
F\RB[NP[R\RGRYJCEGDPF[NPNKIGV\NZCG\B:BUTNVK[V\RI[C\CEZLMNNTKYZ,
GFKBVGJZ\MNPKQBGMNKQ,M[FKBPGD[\TOEDPNGIFKBRI[C\NJVNFP[GO[\VYKEF
BKRGBNBNRJZNB\FPNKIG\[CED.CZOBPGZBKBZWK[ZBNGBPGZBKCCNNBVSYGMQFNMF
NPT[F,BNBRFDGNCZLTNFV\C\IKN\FSTGEFGNVJGZB\MNFPBMNKOFPGD[KOTO
FV\{MGNNEDPNGI{[R\VSGMNV\QBGMVZVZ\NV\.FQCKZG[NPKFQCCCNKRBNXGBVGB
NVZ[B\FP[RFTNEZLFBGYKP\B,MBKNGFKBTGSY\CPRFDKBMKNFF[GRKOPQFRGZPF:
CCCNFTPKEGB\FP[RFCVZG\KODKRGSZFBDE\KKOCYNKNG\O,[PFOBMNGMPGKG\DEGNG\
CPKGIEGFVMGB\FV\[FGD[FNXEONJVNF.CKZG[NPKFSCKZG[FRGZPG\F[\RGNVKFHPQ
GFPYGO:BPROBPGZBKBZWK[ZBNNBZBGCEDPNGITKYZNTGP\FV\FPGD[\NXEF,BCN
CKPKYEOR\VSFEDFPNGIMTKYZCPYGPG\PSGKPKONTGP\FV\.FGBFEKQN[RKPBMNKO
BIZKO[CPYGPG\PSGKPKOTEKKQTG[KOBG\OTKYZNTGP\FV\:FVKZGZ{VZGS\NIO[K[
FPI[KCKOBG\FTKYZNTGP\FMKMZF[NPF[NXEF,GPCZMKO"FPGXKB"EGGYBTNKFGNBTN
FV\F[NPF,GF[YKHPK{P[YFIZKUFT[GKP\CNKQ1
[NXEGBMNGV\MEKNFYFG\B\
F[VT\FBNMGFGNGFIZKVG\,MVK[RFGDCKPKRGNBMGNPKRKMKSRKQTO[\KK\P[YBG\
IZKVKO.GHFN[GQFKZG[NPK,CZMG\GH,KT"E:
ZCK[PGBNCZRIPQC[OZCKKGR\Q:P\RK\BTE[NBNPEGSTGE\PNMKOGCPYGO[TG[K’
B\FPNKITKYZ,BCNCPYGO[BKQTG[KQB\FPNKITKYZNBC~E|B.
ZCKKZPKFC[OZC:VK\BGVZGZ,BG’TNFVKZGZCPYGO[TG[KQB\FVKZGZTKYZ,BCNCPYG’
[BKQTG[KQB\FVKZGZTKYZNBC~E|B.
1SGD[NKKQFT[GK\CNKQCPYGOTRCKOPGVKTVTOBI\BXNVNKRKGS)KE,111(CMKRGKscyzinon.ZBGFTZ\TPRGBNNTUBXN
S. Krauss, Griechische und Lateinische Lehnwoerter im Talmud, Midrasch und Targum, v. 2, p. 583)NTKN,SGDKBC
FTZF52(,TZL"[YKHPK".
617 FSGDKBFBZCTKOG[\KKO:’VKZG\DKRGSZ’)PET"B(
ZCKSKPGQC[OZCK[PTGQCQNYK[:[YKHPKGVK\B,BGPZTNF[YKHPKCPYGO[TG[KQB\
F[YKHPKTKYZ,BCNCPYGO[BKQTG[KQB\F[YKHPKTKYZNBC~E|B.
NDCK"VK\BGVZGZ",FKZG[NPK\GNFB\YCKT\FTKYZGFJVNCPRFDFPYGO,GBMQZBKRG
PINGYG\\RBKOGBPGZBKOMKXENRFGDM[FCKBGNVRKGV\K\KQG[NPKQ{[FZKFKG[RFDG
NDPGZB\FNIOFVZGSNVRK[V\IGMKMZIE[F,GFKG[RFDGNMCEB\PTPEFSTGEFCMKMZ
IE[FDOM[R[BZGNFOV\K\KV\PSTGEFYGEP\.2
BUCTRKKQF[YKHPKRK\QN[TZ[FKG
[[\G[YKHPKC[T\FBZGIF,MKKQ,GFKG[ZBGC[\KK\F[YKHPKPTPETXPBK[NGGFCBMKN\
V\.SCKZBVGB[FBPGZBKO\NGB\FTRKKQCPRFDFPYGO.
CZOCY[ZNPBMNKOFPGHMZKOCP[R\RG,"PNKI\IKNFGV\TPG",PXBRGRKSGI[GRFCPYX\
CPKPZB[CKZG[NPK.ZC[PGBNCZRIPQC[OZCKKGR\QBKRGP\KKISNPRFDKPYGOCNCE,BNB
DONPRFDKO[F[\RGTOFHPQ:"P\RK\BTE[NBNPEGSTGE\PNMKOGCPYGO[TG[K’B\
FPNKITKYZ".FGGFBGPZ:CKPKRGBKQPK[TG[FB\FPNKITKYZ,BCNVTO,CJZONPEG
STGE\PNMKO,FKGPYGPG\[CFOT[GB\FPNKITKYZ.NVKHFK[FCENCKQFRBPZCKZG[NPK
NRBPZCCCNK.CCCNKFTPKEGB\FP[RFCVZG\DKRGSZ,GBNGRBMNGNVKFPSGZG\FPGCBG\
CVKSYBG\~3=5|CKPKFBPGZBKOEGGYB.NVKFKZG[NPK,NTGP\HB\,CKPKFBPGZBKOMCZVSYG
PNCZLTNFPNKI,[MQP[R\RGBKRFBNB"TE[NBNPEGSTGE\PNMKO".
[BGNNKCZPQVKZ[B\FCKJGK"TE[NBNPEGSTGE\PNMKO"MENFNQ:
MNGPZCZB[GRF,M[FKGTRKKO,NBBMNGNVRKFSTGEFGNBIZKFBNBPNGIKQDZKEB)TKKQ
YKEG[KQS"GB’,GFPVZ[KOVKZ[G[OPNGI{T[C[[PGPNGI(,BCNBI"MM[NPEG
STGE\PNMKO,MNGPZSTGE\T[KZKO,MCZVYTFI[KCG\FPNKIKOMPP[KMKO[N\BG\
FBMKNFGF[\KF,GCPYGPOCBGMNPKRKP\KYFGMKSRKQ.3
CZO,K[MPFY[KKOCVKZG[HF:
.1NBCZGZCBKHGV\TGSY\FP[RF"FCKBGNVRKGPNKI\IKNFGV\TPG"NVKNKCZPQ.BOV\
HGFKBFV\[NCXKT\FV\,GFPNKIFGCBNVRKGMEKNFP[KLB\\BGG\FBMKNF
GF[\KKF,PEGTFV\JVNFNPNKI?PFCKQHFNCKQPTPEFVZVZBG\[NVRKFPHGQMDGQMN
PKRKP\KYFGMKSRKQ,FYGCTKOBPROCZMFNTXPOBCNBKROVGJZKOB\FV\PCZM\F?
.2BOFCKBGNVRKGPNKI\IKNFGV\TPGMEKNFVKDB\JTOFPNI,GZYBIZMLFCKBGB\
FV\FI[GCFNXGZL"CXKT\FV\",BHKPFVKZG[FCKJGK"CPYGO[TG[KOB\FPNKI
TKYZ"?FZKV[GJFGB[CRSKCG\BNGFPNKIFGBTKYZ,BIZ\NBFKGPCKBKOV\RGSV\
NBIZBMKN\FPNKIGFV\[TPG.
.3CKQMLGCKQML,FBGYKP\BBKRRFCZGZFMNXGZMF.PEGTVD\GYVF[NFNMFHGNBIZ
[NPEGSTGE\PNMKO?DOBOMCZNBFKGZDKNKONBMGNPNKINVRKFV\,BOFCKBGNVRKG
PNKI\IKNFGV\TPGCPYGOP\BCQBIZ,FFNMFXZKMFNFKG\\NGKFC[BNFBO
PEGCZCPYGO[TG[KOV\TKYZBGCPYGO[TG[KOPNKITKYZ,MPGC[\KFPKPZG\
FRGSVG\CKZG[NPK,CTRKKQFVKZGZGF[YKHPKFPGD[KOTOFV\!
NMQRZBFNVZ[B\FPYGZG\CFKVGLVKZG[G[NNKCZPQ:EDPNGIMP\BCQBVKKQEGGYBB\
STGE\FPNMKO,MNGPZSTGEF[NT[KZKO,[N\YGV\FBPGZBKO.STGEFHGFKBSTGEFTO
"PRG\"PSGEZG\:)B(FVZVZBG\[NVRKFPHGQ{MDGQEDPNGI,)C(FV\GVZVZBG\KF,G)D(FPRF
2ZBGNTKN,NJT"C)SGDKBMB,"CGXT"(,GFEKGQCSGDKBFFKB,PEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF:VKZG[KFZB[GRKOGFY[KKO
CSGDKB",GPEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF:FXTFIE[FCVKZG[FSGDKB",GFPGCBG\PQF\GSV\BGFKZG[NPK[O.N[KJ\
FKZG[NPKPCZMKOFQTNV\K\KQFQTNV\[NPF"FPGXKB",BLTEKKQXZKLNYCGTTNBKHFPFONCZL.NVKZCMBQ,FECZ
\NGKCPRFDFPYGO:CPYGO[CEZLMNNVGZSKOTNFVZGSFNVRK[VG\IKOMKMZIE[F{FVZGSFTKYZ,GCPYGO[PMCEKO
B\FSTGEFCV\[NPF{F[NPFTKYZ.
3[’NKCZPQ,\GSV\BMV[GJF,INYB,HZTKO)NTKN,SGDKBCFTZF3(,TP’.65
618PSM\CZMG\{VZYMKXEPCZMKQ
FBIZGRF,FVZVZBG\[NBIZFPHGQ.C\RBKOMBNF,K[NCZLTNFPNKIGNIHGZGNCZLTN
FV\,[MQDOBOFV\PVKDFCVGTNB\JTOFPNKIFKBDOP[P[\MPHGQ[TNKGYGCTKO
STGEF,FTKYZ[NFPRFFTKYZK\."TE[NBNPEGSTGE\PNMKO"NBFYVKEGTNSEZHF,
GRZBF[CZDKNFDK[GB\MNFBGMNCC\BI\,GCMNHB\V\IGB\FSTGEFNBCCXKT\FV\
BNBCPNKI.NVTPKOBUFDK[GB\FV\NVRKFEDFPNGI,BMNGB\FEDFPNGIGZYBIZML
BMNGPQFV\.MLTGNFP\KBGZFSTGEFBXNB\RKBGS,FIMPKOCP[\F,SVZD,STGEF
[F\ZI[FNVKFPSGVZCZGPB,BLP[\\VKFFKGEGCZKKGGRK\PQFPHZI:BIEPQFSGTEKO
CKY[NIO)108f-109a(,FCKBGNVRKFOMKMZG\NIOGTPQPBMNKOZCKOPSGDKO[GRKO)109b(,
EKCZGTNFNIO)109b-116a(,FINKJGSGUSGUNBMGN,IKNYGNPSGCKOEDPNGI)116a(,EKCZGTN
EDKOPNGIKO)116a-120b(,BMNGEDPNGI)116b(,FP[KMGNECZTNEDKOPNGIKO)116b-121e(,PF
[TGZZBXNOXPB)120b-c(,CKY[GPKO)121e(,EKCZGTN[\KK\PKO)121e-125fd(\GLMEK[\KK\
PKO)125d(,GZYBIZMLBMNGNIOGPKRK\ZDKPB)126a(.
EGGYBCRSKCG\BNG,CSTGEG\NNBPRG\RVZEG\[RFDGNVRK[NPEGSTGE\PNMKO,F\Y[G
NFINKJBOFEDFPNGITKYZ,GFCZMFTNFEDFPNGICZB[FSTGEFEKRFMCZM\FV\
GCXKT\F,GFKBFCZMFFVGJZ\B\FV\GFVZVZBG\FBIZG\,BG[PBFV\TKYZ,GBGMNKO
B\FEDFPNGINVRKFV\MEKNTGZZB\F\BGGFNV\GVZVZBG\KF,BUBOFDK[GB\FV\
TPFGNBNBIZKF.NVKZCKKGR\Q,FTRKKQ\NGKCEZL[CF\GVSKOB\FEDFPNGICPYGO.
CZONBIZ[NPEGSTGE\PNMKOFINGNFDK[B\FEDFPNGINVRKFV\,GM[FDK[GNBIZPMQ
B\FV\,FKFCZGZ[JYSCXKT\FV\PIKKCCZMFPKGIE\[N"FPGXKB"MEKNFGXKBB\
FV\GVZVZBG\KF.MLPVGZ[C\GSV\BCZMG\EKE:
PNKIGVZGSF,PCZLTNFPNKIGVGJZB\FVZGSF.Z’IRKRFCQDPNKBNBG’PNKIFCB
C\IKNFNVRKFPHGQ,GV\FCBFTOFPNKINBIZFPHGQJTGRFCZMFNVRKFGNBIZKF.
\RBYPBTGSYCPK[BGMNPNKIGVZGSF[NBCPSDZ\STGEF.EKRGMPK[BMNPNKIC\IKN\
FSTGEF"TE[NBNPEGSTGE\PNMKO"NVKZCKKGR\Q.BLZ’IRKRBCQDPNKBN,MPGFBPGZBZCK
KGR\QNBIZKGCKZG[NPK,PSCKZ[CSTGEFTOPRG\{STGE\PNMKOCN[GQFKZG[NPK{K[
NCZLCZMFZB[GRFGBIZGRFTNFPNKI,GNCZL[GCTN"FPHGQ"C[T\CXKT\FV\.
CCCNNBFKGPGETKON[KRGKHFCPCRFFSTGEFGCPTPEG[NFEDFPNGI.NTGP\HB\,FO
FMKZGPSGZ\[NVKFBMNZCKKGIRQMPG\DEGNF[NEDPNGIGNBZBFCGPHGQ~3|.PSGZ\HG
FDKTFBNKRGCRKSGIYEGOKG\ZC[NG[FPYGPG\CKZG[NPK)TKZGCKQDB,MT"E;REZKOGB,NJ
T"D;RHKZGJ,RFT"D(GCCZB[K\ZCFVZ[FXE,SKPQC.GHFN[GQFPEZ[CCZB[K\ZCF:"Z’
KGIRQMEFGFBMKNBNKJKQFGFBP’NBBMNK\PHGQKGPBEKQ".MVK[FZBFNKCZPQ,4
BNKJKQ
EKKDCMKRZ\TNDCK[JZ[NNKZFBI\
4NKCZPQ,[O.
619 FSGDKBFBZCTKOG[\KKO:’VKZG\DKRGSZ’)PET"B(
FKKRGhalites,~EDKO|PNGIKO.ZCFCZCZIRFFSCKZ[ZCKKGIRQNB[CTPQFEDKOFYNKNKO
FNNGBUM[BMNPFOMPGKG\DEGNG\CPKGIE.NVKHFFKFPYGONVZ[[FOJVNKONV\
FRBMN\T]PO,BLFCCNK,CTYCG\FP[RF,PVZ[NFVL:PMKGGQ[EDKFMKRZ\FRBMNKO
PNGIKOFOYNKNKOPBGENTKMGN,GCSTGEFBGMNKOPFOMPG\DEGNFPBGEKISK\NV\,FO
RI[CKOMTKYZFSTGEFNTGP\FV\.5
FZB[GRKOVKZ[G["VKZG\DKRGSZ"FOVZG\FBKNQFDENKOCBHGZFMKRZ\.PYX\OVKZ[GBPRO
["VKZG\DKRGSZ"FOF"PNKI"[CP[RF,BLFOFCKRG[PEGCZCVZG\P\GYKOCPKGIE[BMNG
BG\OCPNIMEKNFVKDB\P\KYG\O.6
ZCRGIRRBN,7
GCTYCG\KGCTNKF\GSVG\,8
F\Y[GN\BZ
NTXPOVZG\BKNQFRBMNKOCPNI,GFOFCKRGBNRMGQ[FPKNF"PNKI"CP[RFMV[GJF
VKZG[FEDPNGI.NMQFOVKZ[G[PIP\P\KYG\O[NVZG\FBKNQ[CCYT\DKRGSZBMNG
NBIZKFOEDPNGI,GTOFEDFPNGIBMNGV\MEKNFVKDB\JTOFPNI.MQVKZ[NKCZPQ:
NET\GFPT[KO[CKZG[NPKGCCCNKP[NKPKOHFB\HF,GZCKKGIRQBMNVZG\DKRGSZ,MPSGVZ
CCCNK,GBIZMLPNKI)"BNKJKQ"(TOFV\,MN[GQFP[RF,GBIZMNHFBPZ[NBJTOPHGQ.9
BLFVKZG[KOFNNGEIGYKO.PQFFYCNFCKQ"BNKJKQ")"EDKOPNGIKO"(N"VKZG\DKRGSZ"
C\KBGZKPT[FZCKKGIRQ[CKZG[NPKGCCCNKTGNFCCKZGZ[FKKRGFL.MVK[FCKJGK"V+ZG\KO"
CKPKRGVKZG[GSGDKO[GRKO[NKXGZKOIKKOFDENKOCKO,MLDOCN[GQFCCNK"VKZG\DKRGSZ"
VKZG[OEDKFMKRZ\.10
FBGYKP\B"CBGMNKVKZG\DKRGSZ"[CCCNKCBFNFCIKQCKQFEDKO
FPNGIKOFYNKNKO[RBMNGCMPGKG\DEGNG\CBZWK[ZBNNCKQFEDKOFPNGIKO[BPGZBKCCN
TXPORFDGNBMGNCMPGKG\YJRG\,GFOJVNKONV\.
NBIZFEKGQCVZG\DKRGSZPGCB\BDEFBZW-K[ZBNK\RGSV\[PPRFTGNF[CBZWK[ZBN
\VSGB\FEDFPNGIMTKYZFSTGEF~6|:
MKB\BZCEKPK,BPZ:TKZBI\FK\FNGNKRBKFPNLCFZFPNL,[FKGPGXKBKOPPRF
[[KOZCGBSVNKJZK\NYGXXK\BRKOPTZC[C\NTZC[C\.
5BGYKP\BHGNP[RFPGY[K\CPYX\,[MQ,MBPGZ,BOZCKKGIRQBKRG\GVSB\FEDKOFPNGIKOMPHGQ,GEBK[BKQNZBG\CFO
TKYZFSTGEF,GBEZCF,FV\FP[CKTFFKBFTKYZ!BLCCCNNB\VSGMNNB\FEDFPNGIMTKYZNTGP\FV\,GEKFKFNFO
NPXGBBDEFBZW-K[ZBNK\FTGSY\CMPGKG\DEGNG\[NEDPNGIFRBMNG\CSTGEFBI\MEKNYCGT[P[R\RGTGSY\
CPXKBG\VNBK\HG,GBKQRGFDKOMQCCCN.ZBGKNXKKQ[K[NRGTEGKG\T\KYG\PBGE,PKPKFCK\,CTRKKQFCZMFTNFV\
FRBMN\TOEDKFMKRZ\.[[VTPKOPSGVZCBGGRDNKGRKOSKVGZ"RSFMKMZG\GFEDKO"[CGIKNYK[GPTJNIOGPTJEDKOCKQ
FPGRKOZTCKO,GFBGMNFSVKYNMGNO.CMNBIEPQFSKVGZKOFNNGPXBRGCZMFZB[GRF,BLFCZMFTNFEDKOBUVTOBKRF
VGJZ\B\FV\.CPZYGSIG=IPCZLK[GTNFMKMZG\GPXGGFN\NPKEKGNINYBG\QCKQFZTCKO,GBIZMLPCZLTNFEDKO
GPXGGFNINYBG\O.C[BZF\KBGZKO[NFPT[F{P\KKEKJ=M;P\KJGNG=NH;PZYGSGPB=PD;NGYSJJH=KHGKGIRQG
KB=KC{K[GPCZLTNFV\GVGJZB\FEDKOBGPCZLTN[RKFOMBIEGPINYBG\OMBIE,PCNK[KXGKQTNBKHFPFOCKZL.
6ZBG\NPKEZCRGKGRF,TNB\Z)EVKFZK"UNCT"B(,E"FCBGMNKVKZG\DKRGSZ;IKEG[KFZB"F,CZMG\PET"B,E"FP\RK’
FCKBGNG;IKEG[KFZKJC"B[O,E"FCBGMNKVKZG\DKRGSZ.BV[Z[PYX\FZB[GRKOFNNG\VSGB\FVZG\FNNGMEDKO,BL
FOBKROPXKKRKOHB\CPVGZ[.
7ZCRGIRRBNCZMG\PET"B,E"FCBGMNKVKZG\DRGSZ.ZBGTZGL,TZL"SVN";\GSVG\Z"K[KZNKBGQG\GSVG\FZB"[TNB\Z,
E"FCVKZG\DKRGSZ.
8\GSVG\CZMG\PET"B,E"FCBGMNK.
9NKCZPQ)NTKN,FTZF3(,TP’.65
10VZG\DKRGSZPGHMZKOZYCCCNK,MBQGC[RKPYGPG\RGSVKO.BU[\BGZJK\BV[ZNVZ[["VKZG\DKRGSZ"FOVZG\FBKNQ[N
CYT\DKRGSZ[NKEFMKRZ\,GNBVZG\FKO[NFMKRZ\TXPF,BU[RKFBHMGZKOFRGSVKOP\VZ[KOFKJCP\GLFRIF
[PEGCZCEDKOEGGYB:)B(CCCNKVSIKOIT"CRBPZ:"BPZZCKBCKQCZZCBEBBPZZCKKXIY:PVRKPFBKQVKZG\DKRGSZ
CKZG[NKO{MEK[NBKFGTGNKZDNKOBGPZKO:BNPNBNBTNKRGBNBNBMGNVKZG\DKRGSZCKZG[NKO{EKKRG,RPXB\TNKKF
[NBN[PF.MKGXBCGBPZZCKEGS\BKCZCKKRBK:PVRKPFBKQIPKJCZKBCKZG[NKO{MEK[NBKFGTGNKZDNKOBGPZKO:
BNPNBNBTNKRGBNBNZIGWCIPKJCZKB{EKKRG,GRPXB\TNKKF[NBN[PF".M[O[IPKJCZKBBKQBVKNGMKGXBCFO
CKZG[NKO,MLRZBFNVZ[[VZG\DKRGSZBKQBVKNGMKGXBCFOCKZG[NKO:BKQCKZG[NKOIPKO\\-YZYTKKOMNN,GBKQ
CKZG[NKOEDKOMNN.)C(CCCNKPDKNFGT"BRBPZ:"MKRZ\HGDKRGSZ,GNPFRYZB[PFMKRZ\?EP\KYKVKZBMYNBEMKRZK".
FDPZBPVZ[\B\[OFTKZ"MRZ\"[CKFG[TKJNF,BLFKBGEBKKGET\[MKRZ\/DKRGSZFODOF[PG\[NFKO[FTKZ
[GMR\TN[V\G,GPQFS\OFVZG\FP\GYKOPBVKKRKONBB\FTKZBNBB\FKO.
620PSM\CZMG\{VZYMKXEPCZMKQ
GMKGXBCHFPKPZ\ZCFPGCB\CVKSYB~10|.MVK[FTKZCTNEYEGYKSGVZKO,K[NFTEKUB\
DKZS\M\CKFKEVKZRXFGPKRMQ:"BPZZC:MNSTGEF[BKQCFPNKIBKRFSTGEF".BPRORZBF
[ZCF\MGGQNI[KCG\FVZVZ\[NVRKFPHGQ,GBKQCECZKGZBKF[FPNKIFGBTKYZCSTGEF,BL
CTNFDPZBZBFCECZKZC{MPGCPKPZB[NZCEKPKCTRKKQYXC\O[NYGXXKF\BRKO{
PYX\ZBKF[FPNKIP[P[TKYZFSTGEF.BNB[MNHFCBZWK[ZBN;CCCNPCZMKOTN
FV\GVGJZKOB\FPNKI.
TKGRKVKZG[
~3|BPZZCFCZCZIRF:MKFGFBHNKRQC\ZKFEZCKKGIRQNPKMN
VKZG\DRGSZ,MKFGKRQCKPBF{PRYJKRQNKFNMNIEGIET[ZF
T[ZF,GMKFGKRQCKT[ZF{PRYJKRQNKFMNIEGIEPBFPBF,
GMNPBFPKRKKFGFGFPIHKYNFGXRBCZ\N\BSBGKGBMKNNFG
GP[\CTENBJTKOHKGRB.
NVKZG[RGNTKN,CPEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF",PEGCZMBQCEDKO.ZCKKGIRQFKFBGMN
STGEF[NBNUEDKOPNGIKODEGNKO[RNYIGTNKEKT[ZFTEPBF\NPKEKO[R[BGKIE
T[ZFSNKODEGNKO[N[NG[SBFMNBIEPNBKOPQFEDKOFNNG.TOFEDKOFNNGFKFBGMN
DOV\,CKQMEKNFVKDB\JTOFPNIGCKQP[GO[NNBFV\NB[CT,MVK[PVGZ[CPT[F,
GBUTNVKMQFEDKORI[CKOTKYZPIP\FMPG\.
~4|HKGRBSNYBET\L?BNBBKPB:PHGRB.
ZBGNTKN,FEKGQCSGDKBD,"KKQ",PEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF:’HKKQ’G’STKE’",[OFZBKRGTN
SPLSGDKBHGGBIZG\[FVGTNHG"Q[KP[C\YGV\FBPGZBKOCPGCQ"P[CKT",BLC\YGV\
TZKM\FSGDKG\GCKPKFDBGRKOFGBIENN[P[CPGCQHFGFGSCNMNPBMN[K[NGTZL\HGR\K
MN[FGB,NPTJPKOGPNI.11
~5|ZCKBCFGBMKNTEEFGF[ZKYNKFEGECBPBVG\KF;GZCBPKGZC
BSKFGGBMNKTEER\GZPHKKFG.ZCK[PTGQCQNYK[FGFBMKNTE
EPZKE,GBPZNFGZCKKGIRQNECKR[KBF,GFGFP[EZNKFZCK
KFGEFR[KBFCBNG[KBC\ZKFGPKK\KNKFNCK\KF.
HNKN\"VKZG\DKRGSZ"DZPFBXNZCKBCFGNFHT\K\Z,TEMEKML[HCGCFINKYTNPXIG,
GBXNZCKBPKGZCKBSKNR[KZ\F[TZ.ZK[NYK[RTEZ12
CTYCG\FHNKNF,TE[RBNWZCKKGIRQ
NCY[PQFR[KBN[NGICN[KOBIZKGMEKNB\ZBG\GGNFCKBGFCK\F.DOP\KBGZKOBNG
P[\PTYX\[PEGCZCHNKN\EDKO[PRKOGNBV+ZG\FBKNQ.
11NTKN,FEKGQCSGDKBD,"KKQ",PEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF:’HKKQ’G’STKE’",GZBGCFTZF20[OFSCZBV[ZKN[KRGKSPRJKHF,
GP’CRGCKW,\NPGEFBKDGE:PBKP\KYGZKQB\[PT)NTKN,SGDKBBFTZF5(,TP’584=.585
12FVKZG[FPKNGNK[NF[GZ[PZ"ECBZPK\HFFNP[PTGFTCZK,N[GQPZK,BLFGBP[P[DON[GQCZKIF;ZBG,NP[N,
CCCNKIGNKQYNJT"B.
621 FSGDKBFBZCTKOG[\KKO:’VKZG\DKRGSZ’)PET"B(
~6|MKB\BZCEKPK,BPZ:TKZBI\FK\FNGNKRBKFPNLCFZFPNL,
[FKGPGXKBKOPPRF[[KOZCGBSVNKJZK\NYGXXK\BRKOPTZC
[C\NTZC[C\.
MVK[PGMIPQFPYCKNG\CKZG[NPK\TRK\EF,SJT"B,GBKMFZCFVZ[FC,SKPQC,PSGZ\HG
G[\KFPSGZG\FCBG\[FGCBGKIETPFCSGDKB~7=8|KSGEQCYGCWBDEG\FIGZCQ.FPSGZ\
CTRKKQFPHGQ[SGVYNYGXXKF\BRKO,GHG[CVKSYB~7|NFNQCTRKKQFDGHNG\,[KP[GCYGCW
FPYGZKMEKNFEDKOB\F[VTCBZWK[ZBNCKPKFCK\[BCETOFIGZCQ.MBQPGCB\
FPSGZ\CTRKKQSVNKFJZK\MEKNFGMKI[CBZWK[ZBN\VSGNVTPKOB\FPNKIMTKYZ
FSTGEF,GBDCPSGZ\HGPGCBG\FBIZG\.RCKBB\FPYCKNG\HGNXEHG:
KZG[NPK\TRK\BKMFZCFVZ[FCCCNKCZMG\PET"B
FNBB\FBNFKOHRI\RG.
[RKBZHKOFKGCFZFP[IF,
C\I\BIEPFQFKGPGMZKQ
BZCTIRGKG\JFGZG\GFBIE
FKGPGXKBKQPPRGBZCTK’SBF
DGHNG’CMNIE[GIE[.GPFQFKG
PSVKYKQ?YKRKONMNK[Z’.
[RKBZHKOFKGCFZFP[IF,
G\I\BIEPFOFKGBZCTKO
IRGKG\[NPGMZKJFZG\,G\I\
F[RKFKFPGXKBP’SBKQ[N
DGHNG\CMNIE[GIE[,GPFQ
FKGPCKBKQNMNK[ZBN
NYKRKFQ.
MKB\BZCEKPK,BPZ:TKZ
BI\FK\FNGNKRBKFPNLCFZ
FPNL,[FKGPGXKBKOPPRF
[[KOZCGBSVNKJZK\
NYGXXK\BRKOPTZC[C\
NTZC[C\.
JGZ[PTGQFGFPVKY\N\
PBGGQEDZCKQEPZYGTNYKKJB
MNTZGC\[GCB...
T[Z\BNVKOTKKZG\FKGCFZ
FPNL,GNZ’BNTHZCQIZSGO
FKGBNUPFO,GMRDEQFKGNG
BNUSVKRG\CKO.
T[Z\BNVKOTKKZG\FKGCFZ
FPNL,GNZCKBNTHZCQIZSGO
BNUPMGNO,GMRDEQBNUSVKRG\
CKOGMGNFOIZCG...
JGZ[PTGQFGFPVKY\N\
PBFDZCKQ~EPZYGTKQ|CMN
TZGCBNBKNKQYKKJB...
MKB\BZCKQ,BPZ:BKNQBIE
FKFNGNKRBKFPNLCFZFPNL,
[FKGPGZKEKOPPRGBZCTKO
SBFDGHNG\P[NG[CZKMG\
CIE[.
BPZZCKKGIRQ:[PGRKOHGDKO
BIKOMFRKORK[BGN[PGRKO
HGDG\BIKG\MFRG\CNKNFBIE
CFEBDGVRB,IGWPBIKOCNB
BIKG\PBIKG\CNBBIKOIGW
PNGKOIGWPK[ZBN...
B"ZKGIRQ:[PGRKOHGDKOMFRKO
BIKO,R[BGN[PGRKOHGDG\
BIKG\MFRG\,CNKNFBIE
CFEBDGVRB,IGWPBIKOCNK
BIKG\,GIGWPBIKG\CNK
BIKO,GIGWPNGKOGK[ZBNKO.
MKB\BZCKKXIY,BPZ:TKZ
BI\FK\FCBZWK[ZBN
GDGVRK\[PF,[FKGCF[PRKO
HGDG\BIKOMFRKOR[GBKO
N[PRKOHGDG\BIKG\MFRG\.
CPYCKNFCKZG[NPK\TRK\EF,SJT"B,N\KBGZPHGQYGXXKF\BRKOPSGVZ:"JGZ[PTGQFGF
PVKY\N\PBGGQEDZCKQEPZYGTNYKKJBMNTZGC\[GCB",GMKGXBCHFCBKMFZCF.13
FIGYZKO
RINYGCHKFGKFPEGKY[N"FZFPNL",PYGOFPT[FNVKZCEKPKCCCNK,BLFGBRPXBMRZBF
PXVGQNKZG[NKO,CBKHGZXVGQKFGEF/CRKPKQBGF[GPZGQ.14
K[FPHFKOB\"JGZ[PTGQ"
13ZBGBKMFZCF,PFE’[’CGCZ,GKNRF\ZR"J,TP’106,GFDFG\CFTZFYC[O.
14PF[GGBFCKQP[RF[CKTK\JDG\GSV\B[CKTK\HKTGNF[FZFPNLP[\ZTPCK\BNTEDKEZF[NYKSZKQ,[BG\FPHFKO
TOIEZF[NKPKRG.ZBG[’YNKKQ,BZWKFGEF,\NBCKC\ZX"J,TP’245;[’NKCZPQ,\GSV\BMV[GJF,INYC,HZTKO)NTKN,
SGDKBBFTZF30(,TP’575,E"FTE[KMNFPCK\BNGPKDGZEF[NYKSZKGQ,GXKGRKO[O;K’[IZ,"FZFPNL{NV\ZGRF[N
IKEF",XKGQSF)\["S(,TP’275=.306BLZBGDOH’SVZBK,"FZFPNL{TEKKQIKEF",PIYZKKFGEFG[GPZGQKJ)\["T(,TP’
69=82,FPVYVYCFXNC\FR\GRKO[CP[RFTOBNG[C\GSV\B,GPTEKUB\FHKFGK[NFZFPNLTOXVGQKFGEF.
622PSM\CZMG\{VZYMKXEPCZMKQ
[CKZG[NPKGBKMFZCFTOCK\Z,FFZ[N[PTGQCZMGMCB.15
CZOBKQXGZLNFRKIHFG\CKQ
FPYGPG\.MVK[PGMIPQFJCNBG\ENTKN,[PG\FPYGPG\[RY[ZGCPYGZNPSGZG\CTRKKQ
FPHGQ[NYGXXKF\BRKOGFDGHNG\NYRKOFGPZGC[O"FZFPNL",[BNKGRY[ZFPSGZ\BIZ\,
CTRKKQT[Z\BNVKOFTKKZG\,FRPXB\CPYCKNG\GNBFGCBFCCCNK.MKGXBCHFPXBRG[[\K
FPSGZG\[CCCNKVKSYBG\~6=7|RY[ZGCKRBKFPNLEGGYB.RZBF[FGSV\PGJKCFPNMG\
CCCNKRGTEFNFDEKNB\\IG[\FBCEQCTYCG\FIGZCQ,NBPGZ:NBHGCNCE[IZCFBZW
K[ZBNG[VTFFMNMNK,BNBBUPNMG\K[ZBNIZCF.CBZWK[ZBN,NTGP\HB\,FCKRG
[PNMG\CK\I[PGRBKBCEF[RKOZCG\NVRKIGZCQFCK\GIGZCQCK\Z[BNKFORY[ZG
FPSGZG\FNNG.
ZCKR\QCTNFTZGLVKZ["DZCKQEPZYGT"{"YVKVG\[NV\G\KNIO",16
EFKKRGSNKO[N
V\K\KNIO,BCNVKZG[HFPGY[FPMPFSKCG\:)B("DZC"FGBMEFP[P[CEZLMNNNFIHY\
RGHNKO;17
)C(Y[FNFCKQPEGTKRYGJPBQEFGBCPKNFFPGY[K\"PZYGT"NV\K\KNIOM[K[
PKNKOZCG\FP[P[G\CSVZG\IH"NNPG[DHF;)D(FBJKPGNGDKF[FXKTIRGLYGFGJN"PZYGT"
HF,TNVKFKGGRK\mergia,I\KMF,VZGSF,18
BKRFRZBK\,[MQBKQPYGONBG\TK"QCPKNFHG.
FXT\[NPFCGCZNFDKF"PZYB"GNVZ[FN[GQKKQIK,19
BUFKBBKRFRZBK\,[MQFPKNF
"PZYB"P[P[\ZYCCCNK,GPGXBFMRZBFPQFBMEK\.20
TNMNVRKO,ZCEKPKFRIG\BFCKQ[PEGCZCSGD[NEDPNGI,GNMQFINKUB\FPKNFFNB
PGMZ\"PZYGT"C"JZK\",\TZGC\FEDKOFMCG[KOFPGMZ\PQFP[RF)TCGEFHZFCG=H(.GBMQ
RZBF[PZYGTFKKRGJZK\:FZKPEGCZCPR\PHGQ[CGTK\[SGVYFCME,GBONB[RBPZCMN
HB\[PEGCZCKKQ,FET\RG\R\[PEGCZCJZK\BGCMKGXBCF.GFRFPXBRGCP[RFTCGEFHZF
FCIRFCKQ"JZK\JZGVF")CG(,[CFRJZVGFEDKONMEKRGHNSPKL,NCKQ"JZK\[BKRFJZGVF"
)CH(,[CFXGZ\FEDKOTEKKQRKMZ\.PMKGGQ[F[GZ[KOZY"TGJZ"UP[P[KO[RKFON[GQ
FMBF,RZBF["PZYGT"VKZG[GJZK\JZGVF,\TZGC\CIG[F[NEDKOMCG[KO.PHGQPNGIHF
FKFRGINBISGQ,GNMQ[KP[PHGQHFNVKFPSGZ\NFBMN\YKKJ~K|B,EFKKRGYGXXK\BRKO,21
CKPKKRBKFPNL.FPSGZ\RGTEFN\BZB\F[VTCKPKOFFO,FCBNKEKCKJGKFQCZKCGKYGXXK
F\BRKO,FP[YUPQFS\O[VT[N\BRKO,FQC[VTFPHGQ[SGVYNFOTNKEK\G[CKFZBIE
BGKK[GCBIE.
~7|MKB\BZCKQ,BPZ:BKNQBIEFKFNGNKRBKFPNLCFZFPNL,
[FKGPGZKEKOPPRGBZCTKOSBFDGHNG\P[NG[CZKMG\CIE[.
CPYCKNFCBKMFZCFVZ[FC,SKPQC:
[RKBZHKOFKGCFZFP[IF,G\I\BIEPFOFKGBZCTKOIRGKG\[NPGMZKJFZG\,G\I\
F[RKFKFPGXKBP’SBKQ[NDGHNG\CMNIE[GIE[,GPFQFKGPCKBKQNMNK[ZBNNYKRKFQ.
GMKGXBCHFCKZG[NPK\TRK\.CPYGZG\FBZW-K[ZBNKKOK[FCENDEGNCKQPSGZ\HGNYGEP\F
CTRKKQBSVY\FPHGQNYKKJKB,YGXXKF\BRKO:[ODOCKZG[NPKGCPEZ[,MPGCCCNK,FED[
FKFTNF[VTFMNMNK,BCNC\KBGZFDGHNG\CPYGZG\FBZW-K[ZBNKKOFED[FGBTN
FVTKNG\FE\K\CPYE[:FMGFRKOGFTOCKZG[NKOFYVKEGTNJFZG\GREZ[GNIRGKG\[N
15ZBGYNKKQ,[O;CGCZ)NTKN,FTZF13(,TP’106,FTZFYC.
16TZL"DZC3",GZBGDOTZL"ZYT3".GZBGXKGRKOCTZGLF[NONFNQ,FTZF.18
17ZBGM. Sokoloff, A Dictionary of Jewish Palestinian Aramaic, p. 135)NTKN,SGDKBKFTZF21(,TZL"DZC".
18I’YGFGJ,FTZGLF[NO)NTKN,SGDKBFFTZF27(,MZLC,TP’348=349,TZL"DZC3";[O,MZLH,TP’303,TZL"ZYT3".
19CGCZ)NTKN,FTZF13(,TP’106FTZFYC.
20ZBGFTZ\TPRGBNNTUBXNYZGKS)NTKN,FTZF1(,TP’353,TZL"PZYB";M. Sokoloff, A Dictionary of Jewish
Babylonian Aramaic, p. 711)NTKN,SGDKBDFTZF3(,TZL"PZY",FPVZ[[PEGCZCKKQPHGDEGGYB.
21ZBGNKCZPQ,\GSV\BMV[GJF,INYD,PGTE)NTKN,SGDKBNDFTZF18(,TP’345,E"FFZGTKQGFYKKXKQ.
623 FSGDKBFBZCTKOG[\KKO:’VKZG\DKRGSZ’)PET"B(
PGMZKJFZG\,GR[G\K[ZBNFCKBGYZCRG\FKGNE\NBIZMNNKEFGRHYYGNDGHNG\ZCKON[O
ML.CPKPZ\ZCKQ[CCCNK,NTGP\HB\,TGXCFPSGZ\HGPIE[CZGIFPSGZ\CTRKKQBSVY\
FJZK\NYGXXKF\BRKO,GRKJNFPPRFMNFF\KKISG\NYGE[KOGNPYE[.CPYGOFZFP[IF,
FZFHK\KOCKZG[NKO,PGYPFPSGZ\HGMYGEP\FCCCNKCFZFPNL;[RKFBZHKOFVMGNBZH
BIE,GNBF\KKISGMNNNBZH[P\I\KGPMZGJFZG\;GBUFBZHF[RK,[\I\KGPMZGCPYGZ
DGHNG\NXGZLYKRKFKGNEG\,FVLNBKNQVGZF[CTRVKGYKRRGFDGHNKOTXPOGBNG[KP[GPQ
FS\OPBMNIGNKQ,[MQFZFPNLBKRGRPXBCBHGZFPYE[.22
FZG[OPECZKZCKQCCCNKFGB
[PKPZBHG,MPGFPKPZBFYGEP\,CBFN\BZB\F[VTCBZWK[ZBNNVRKFIGZCQ,GNBG
EGGYBB\FVTKNG\[CPYE[.
CPYCKNG\FBZW-K[ZBNKG\BKQHMZN"[NG[CZKMG\".PGJKCHFRGSUCCCNKMEKNXKKQB\
F[VT,[MQP[RFCCBC\ZBFDPHMKZFCZKMFZB[GRF[NKGRKO,GCCCNKCKXFKT"CPGHMZG\
CZKMFZB[GRFGCZKMF[RKKF,GNMQ"[NG[CZKMG\"R\VSG\MP[FG[NPTNFPQFJCT.
~8=9|MKB\BZCKKXIY,BPZ:TKZBI\FK\FCBZWK[ZBNGDGVRK\
[PF,[FKGCF[PRKOHGDG\BIKOMFRKOR[GBKON[PRKOHGDG\
BIKG\MFRG\.GCEYGZCRQPSGZBGTERFZETB,GNBB[MIGCZ
PCR\KFEZCISEBEFGGRSKCQNZPKCZIPBGNPZTGYCBCZ
IPB,GBUTNDCEBKRFKFGGMFR\B{BKRFGNBFGGMFRK.
BU\KBGZHF[NFMGFRKOFR[GBKONMGFRG\CDGVRBPGVKTCPYCKNG\FBZW-K[ZBNKG\.GHF
N[GQFKZG[NPK\TRK\EF,SJT"B:
BPZZCKKGIRQ:[PGRKOHGDKOBIKOMFRKORK[BGN[PGRKOHGDG\BIKG\MFRG\CNKNFBIE
CFEBDGVRB,IGWPBIKOCNBBIKG\,PBIKG\CNBBIKO,IGWPNGKO,IGWPK[ZBN...
CKPKFCK\RK[BGCRG\MGFQNMGFRKOEGGYB,GHGFKK\FFRGZPFDONBIZFIGZCQ,MVK[PGMI
PMPFPYGZG\.23
CZO,PFFK\ZGQ[CRK[GBKBIKONBIKG\EGGYB?PXCHFRKEGQZCG\CSVZG\
IH"N,BLEGGYBCTYCG\FCTKG\FFNM\KG\FTNGNG\NFS\TUPPXCHF.24
KK\MRGMPFFSCZKONPGJKCHF:
.1FFSCZFIKGCK:PQFCCNKRKMZ[BPGZBKCCN\VSGB\RK[GBKFBIKOGFBIKG\MTRKKQ
IKGCK{SPPQRGSU[NJGFZFKKIGS,MPGTXOFRK[GBKO[NMGFRKONCRG\P[VIG\
MFGRF,[FZKIKV[G\GVTFEGPFCCCNGRBNXGNFS\VYCRK[GBKCRG\ZCISEBNCRK
IPB.GBMQ,TEKBN[ZPZGBIZKO\KBZGCVZGJZGJB\FPDPFCICZFFKFGEK\FMNNK\{
NBGEGGYBCIGDKFMFGRF{NF\I\QTEMPF[BV[ZC\GLFP[VIF,PCNKNIJGBCDKNGK
TZKG\.25
EGPF[RK[GBKHGDBIKONHGDBIKG\PFGGKOBUFOPTKQV[ZFCKQFPDPF
FBREGDPK\NBKSGZKTZKG\:BIKO[FODODKSKOGBIKG\[FQDODKSG\K[CKRKFOYZCF
P[VI\K\"PEGPF",[BKQCFBKSGZFNM\K.
.2FFSCZFRKJZNK:BI\FPJZG\[NRK[GBKQC\GLFP[VIFFKK\FN[PGZTNJGFZ
FKKIGS.26
DOBONBRZBFCRK[GBKBIKONBIKG\IKYGKNRK[GBKQC\GLFP[VIF,MVK
[FGXTCFSCZFIKGCKENTKN,RK\QNVZ[B\F\GVTFTNZYTI[KCG\FKKIGS:RGI
NP[VIF[MCZIKHZFBIZP[VIFBIZ\PKGIS\EKFGIK\RFNFCQBIENISGL
22BUFPKNF"CZKMF"P[P[\N\KBGZTGVG\[NIGNKQEGGYBCP[RFCCBC\ZBFDGCCCNKCKXFKT"C.
23ZBGXKGRKOGEKGQBXNT’[ZPZ,HMZGRYCFCZBO,KZG[NKO\[S"E,TP’164=.166K[BGPZKO[FFNMFFMK\\K\CKPKFCK\
BSZFTNMGFRKOGMGFRG\NFKR[BPIGWNMFGRF;ZBGFEKGQBXN[ZPZ,[O,TP’165FTZF.24
24ZBG,NP[N,P[RFKCPG\VZYDMGNG,GMQP[RFKCPG\KDH,KEE.
25[ZPZ)NTKN,FTZF23(,TP’158=169,GCKCNKGDZVKFTRVFCFTZG\[O.
26[ZPZ,[O,TP’166,GXKGRKOCFTZF29[O.
624PSM\CZMG\{VZYMKXEPCZMKQ
PTXPFPBPXKORGSVKOCMKGGQFHFGNI\QNFDOB\CRKFFBIZKO.BUNVKFSCZHF
FF\VTNG\[NBPGZBKCCNFKBCPYGO:BPRORGINT[G\MQ,BLREKZFGB[FECZ
PS\KKTCKEKFP[VIG\CCCN,GNMQF\VTNGPML[F\GVTFFKK\FMNMLRVGXFCDGVRB.
.3FFSCZF[NKNK:BPGZBKCCNBPROFCKRG[BURK[GBKBIKONBIKG\CDGVRB,MPG
RK[GBKOC\GLFMFGRF,FOTRKKQIKGCK,G[PJZ\F\KBGZ[CBDEFFGBN\BZB\FIKGCK
[CICZFFBZW-K[ZBNK\NVRKFIGZCQ,MVK[FSKVGZKOFYGEPKOCBGN\BZB\FIKGC
[CMNMNFFBZW-K[ZBNK\NVRKFIGZCQ.27
BLCPYGPG\BIZKOCSVZG\IH"NP\GBZKO
MBPGZY[KKOFNM\KKO[TNGNKONF\TGZZCTYCG\RK[GBKQMBNF,GPQFPYCKNFFBZW-
K[ZBNK\[CKZG[NPKGCBKMFZCFTGNFBGGKZFBIZ\:RK[GBKQBNGF\ZI[GMGNOCNKNF
BIE,BGNKCDNNFCFNF[FPKJGFIGZCQGFPNIPG\TNFP[VIG\CKFGEF.BV[Z,BOMQ,
[RK[GBKFBIKONBIKG\FOEGDPFN[KEGMKOCFGNKO[RTZMGCBGVQMPTJ[ZKZG\KCKQ
P[VIG\FMFGRFCDGVRB,TNMNXZF[NB\CGB.
~10=11|BPZZC:MNSTGEF[BKQCFPNIBKRFSTGEF.BPZZCKIKKBCZ
BCBBPZZCKKGIRQ:MNSTGEF[BKQCF[ZKUBKRFSTGEF.
MBPGZ,K[NFTEKUB\DKZS\YJTFDRKHFJTS ENA 2068.33,M"KPKRMQGM"KVKZRXFCPKPZ\
ZC~10|:"PNKI".PKPZ\ZCFPYGZK\NBTSYFC[BN\TKYZGJVN{ZCFEDK[B\FTGCEF
[STGEG\ZBGKG\N[PQMGNNG\PNKIMVZVZ\NVRKPHGQ,GNBZYPRFTKYZK\,GMVK[BGPZZCK
[PGBNCZRIPQC[OZCKKGR\QCKZG[NPKCZMG\GH,KT"E,FPGCBNTKN,"P\RK\BTE[NB
NPEGSTGE\PNMKO",[FZKCSTGE\PNMKOPGD[FPNKIMPRFCVRKTXPFTGENVRKCXKT\
FV\.
BDCFPKPZB[NZCPGCB\PKPZBEGPF[NZCKIKKBCZBCBC[OZCKKGIRQTNFI[KCG\
[NF"[ZKU"CSTGEF~11|.Z["KVKZ[[FGBPZY[[G\KOCPXKXF,TNSPLF[KPG[CVGTN
[Z"UCP[RFTCGEFHZFCF:"MFQ[ET\GKVF[GZVGIKF",CPGCQPXKX\INCK[KZG\PYKC\
FTDN,BLVKZG[HFZIGY,GCMNNPV\KTFECZ[PZMKCPZMHKCSTGEFBKRGPGMZNRGP[GO
PYGZBIZ,GFPKNFFKBKIKEBK\CSVZG\IH"N.NMQDOMBQK[NFTEKUB\DKZS\YJTFDRKHF
JTS ENA 2068.33,"SZU",BGDKZS\M"KPKRMQGM"KVKZRXF,"[ZU",FP\GTE\DOCTZGL.
ZCKR\QCTNFTZGLVKZ[:"[ZU[PVKDB\FPBMN[CPTKO",28
GPECZKGP[\PT[[\G[ZU
HFNZVGBFNBIZFBMKNF.CZORZBF[FBPGZBKONBFKGBGPZKOTNMDGQHF"MNSTGEF[BKQ
CF[ZUBKRFSTGEF".
[PQFBVZSPGQ,FPMGRFCNGTHK\CNSO,RYZBCN[GQFPYZBXZK,G"FXZKBKRGBNB[ZUFRGJU
PTXKFYJU"NVKECZKZCQ[PTGQCQDPNKBN,29
EFKKRG[ZUFKGXBPDHTTWFBVZSPGQ.30
C\ZDGOF[CTKOGCGGNDJFP\GZDP\FPKNFXZKretineG-resina,CF\BPF,GFPKNKOFNNG
VKZG[Q"[ZU"S\O.31
RZBF[BUCTCZK\[KP[FFPKNF"[ZU"CKJGKRZEUN[PQBVZSPGQ.
NTKNZBKRG[[PQFBVZSPGQ[KP[CTKQNSKM\FKEKKOGFZIFC\GOFSTGEF,32
GNVTPKOBU
C\GZPGDPZTNDCKDINKOCSKGOFSTGEG\FPVGBZG\CKG\ZCBZWK[ZBN.NMQRZBF[ECZK
27GBONEKKY,FZKZY\KBGZFPHGQ[NYGXXKF\BRKOCPYGZG\FBZW-K[ZBNKKORGTENPJZFHG.M[O[CCCNKVKZ[GPIE[B\
\KBGZFDGHNG\[CFZFP[IFM\KBGZ[N[VT)ZBGNTKN,TKGRKFVKZG[NVKSYB~7|(,MLVKZ[GPIE[NVKFXTFHGB\
FPSGZ\CTRKKQDGVRB[RGTEFCPYGZG\FBZW-K[ZBNKKON\BZB\\NBG\FIGZCQ,M\KBGZIKGCK[NFBKEKNKFFICZ\K\
[[ZZFCBZWK[ZBNNVRKFIGZCQ.
28ZBGI’YGFGJ,FTZGLF[NO)NTKN,SGDKBFFTZF27(,MZLI,TP’169=170,TZL"[ZU4".
29CCNKMZK\G\GT"B;F[GGKZG[NPKKGPBEF,PBT"E.
30ZBGNTKN,FEKGQCSGDKBNJ,"C[PKO",PEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF:BVZSPGQGFES";K’VNKYS,TXKC[PKOKTZGRGK)NTKN,
SGDKBNJFTZF16(,TP’37=.43
31ZBG\ZDGPKOBNGNCZB[K\NHMF,PDKB,KZPKFGIMC,PGKB,RBI,KIHYBNMHKH.
32ZBGNTKN,FEKGQCSGDKBNJ,"C[PKO",PEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF:BVZSPGQGFES",G[O,PEGZ"PFNLFSGDKBG\GNEG\KF:
FPGDPZ".
625 FSGDKBFBZCTKOG[\KKO:’VKZG\DKRGSZ’)PET"B(