1. 11 1 2008 3 99 () * , () ** An International Comparative Study of Intellectual Property Education in Graduate school of Engineering Kim, Joon Ho * and Hong, Jin Hwan ** Abstract As industrial society has changed to knowledge-based society, the needs for the intellectual property education in the engineering school is emphasized. Therefore graduate engineering school in USA, Europe, and Japan has strengthened intellectual property education. The curriculum has expanded from intellectual property introduction to business development using patent technology, valuation of intellectual property, intellectual property strategy and management. However, the intellectual property education in engineering school in Korea is in early stage. This study has surveyed the intellectual property education in major engineering school in USA, Europe and Japan, and compared it with the education in Korean engineering school. Finally, some recommendations are provided based on this study. Keywords: Intellectual Property, Intellectual Property Education, Engineering education . 1990 . , . (Nonaka, 1991). . , (intellectual propert y)1) , (Pike, 2001). , . (Alikhan, 2004). , (Bader, 2006). 1) , (industrial property) , (intellectual property) . intellectual property , industrial property , , .

2. , (Kim, Joon Ho, Hong, Jin Hwan) 100 (Jennewein, 2005). (Jungahns, 2006). , . (Razgaitis, 2003). , , . (Miele, 2000). 3(, , ) . . . 3 , . . (National Academy of Engineering) (Committee on Engineering Education) 2020 (The Engineer of 2020), 2020 (Educating The Engineer of 2020) 2020 (NAE, 2004; NAE, 2005). 2020 (Strong analytical skills), (Practical ingenuity), (Creativity), , (Communication competencies: oral, written and cultural communication), , (business, management, and leadership skills), (high ethical standards and professionalism), , (Agility, resilience, flexibility) . , , , 1 . , MBA . , , 2 4 , , . , , . EC 2000 (Lisbon) , 2020 2004 11 (EC, 2004). , , . 3. 11 1 2008 3 101 , , (bottom-up) . . (UK-SPEC)2) (Chartered Engineer)3) (EC UK, 2005). , . 2025 , . (Innovation)25 . . , (Obi, 2007). 1895 , 1942 . 1950 MIT Robert Rines Inventions and Patents . 1973 (Franklin Law Center) , 1995 , 2001 . , . 1963 . 1980 , 1997 ETH . 2002 2003 90 , 2005 . , , 30 120 3 18 . 3 2 , 7 5 . , 4 , , . < 1> 30 3 3 6 0 18 2 5 4 () 21(70%) 5(17%) 11(37%) 4(13%) 2) UK Standard for Professional Engineering Competence 3) (5~10) 4. , (Kim, Joon Ho, Hong, Jin Hwan) 102 < 2> Massachusetts Institute of Technology , , Invention and Patents, Development of Inventions and Creative Ideas, Ethics and the Law on the Electronic Frontier , Sloan Patents, Copyrights, and the Law of Intellectual Property University of California-Berkeley Intellectual Property Law for the Information Industries University of Illinois-Urbana Champaign Engineering Law, Patent Law and Related Topics Ethical & Professional Issues in CS , Master of Science (M.C.S.)/Juris Doctor (J.D.) IP 12 credit Carnegie Mellon University Patents and Inventions California Institute of Technology Law and Technology University of Southern California (Viterbi) Juris Doctor/Political Science Patent Law Cornell University (NY) / Patents, Plants, and Profits: Intellectual Property Management for Scientists and Entrepreneurs . , . , , , , . MIT , , Invention and Patents, Development of Inventions and Creative Ideas, Ethics and the Law on the Electronic Frontier , Caltech Law and Technology . , TLO (Technology License Office) . (Engineering Entrepreneurship) (Entre- preneurial Business Basics) , MOT(Management of Tech- nology) (IP) , . (Master of Project Management) (Master of Engineering Management) . (Master of Engi- neering Management) , (Intellectual Property, Business Law, and Entrepreneurship) . MIT 1950 . MIT . MIT Entre- preneur Club IAP(Independent Activities Period) IP Strategy 5. 11 1 2008 3 103 < 3> MIT Inventions and Patents The Origin and Development of the American Patent System The Role of the Patent Office and the Courts Basic Patent Laws The Rights, Obligations, and Problems of Inventors Other Intellectual Property: Copyrights, Trade Secrets, Trademarks Intellectual Property Project: Research Topics Student Presentation of Final Projects The Origin and Development of the American Patent System The Role of the Patent Office and the Courts The Patent Law Patents in Action (The History of the Basic Telephone Patent The Rights, Obligations, and Problems of Inventors (Employee-Employer Relations) The Future of American Patents The Modernization of Patent Systems Court Modernization for Aiding the Patent System and the Law, in General A Formula for Economic Decline Intellectual Property Issues Associated with the Emerging Fields of Nanotechnology, Nanobiotechnology Patents Software Intellectual Property, Copyright Infringement Due To Online File Sharing, Death of a Cracker - The Failure of the DMCA and How Digital Copyright Can Be Saved, Conceal or Perish? An Overview of Trade Security and the Software Industry, The Software Protection Debate, Copyright Infringement in Music and an Alternative to Piracy Patent Strategies and the Progress of Science and Useful Arts, Athletic Performance Enhancing Inventions; the Conflicting Interests of Inventors, Spectators, Athletes and Companies, Improving Upon the Current Patent System, Effects of Patent Policies on Innovation, Defending Open Science from Patent Infringement (What Does the Future Hold for University Research?), Proposal for Fostering Commercialization of Patents, The Difficulty of Protecting Design Life Patents: The Reason, the Ramifications, the Proposed Reversal, Prospects for Drug Accessibility and Economic Growth as Indian Pharmaceuticals Enter the Product Patent Era, Prescription Drug Re-Importation, Brazil's Generic Drug Manufacturing Success and the Policies That Permitted It, Human Cloning and the United States Patent Office The Developing World and the Role of Information and Communication Technologies, Software Piracy in Developing Countries - A Mounting Problem and Proposed Solutions, Intellectual Property Protection and China, Strategies for Moving U.S. Business Into China, A Comparison Study of the United States Patent System and the System of the Former Soviet Union and Current Russia, A Global Patent System - From Fantasy to Functional, A Medical Patent System for Global Warfare . MIT Robert Rines, Jeseph G. Hadzima Aberson, Jeffrey A. Meldman . MIT Robert Rines 80 , , . 2002 . Robert Rines (Inve- ntion and Patents) < 3> . 6. , (Kim, Joon Ho, Hong, Jin Hwan) 104 < 4> Chalmers University of Technology () joint Center for Intellectual Property Studies (CIP): 2005 IP , Business Design Program , . Ethics and Intellectual property ( 2) ETHZ- Swiss Federal Institutue of Technology Zurich () Master in Advanced studies in Intellectual Property(EIPIN* member) , IP . ETH transfer KUL-Katholieke University Leuven () master in electrical engineering, computer sciences, chemical technology, material knowledge, energy, master in nanosciences and nanotechnology IP management ( Janssens Maria-Christima_ , Ballon Gabriel Luc), Bio-engineer in cell, chemistry, agronomy, environment technology IP management Tech.Univ. Munich () master of law in intellectual property(MIPLC) (interdisiplinary ) Uppsala University () MS in Applied Biotechnology entrepreneurship and IP law , Management, organisation and leadership . 1~10 ETH Zurich , Chalmers . , , , . < 4> .4) ETH 1996 1997 . , 2005 4 (MAS IP: Master of Advanced Studies in Intellectual Property) .5) ETH MAS IP . EPO6) 2/3 , 1/3 ( 2/3 ), , , (, , ) .7) , , 100 . , 3 , , . Business Design Program ICM (Intellectual Capital Manage- 4) III 1963 Bastian Forestier CEIPI(Centre d'Etudes Internationales de la Proprit Industrielle) . CEIPI 30 28 . , . 1980 Queen Mary , Oxford, Cambridge , . Munish . 5) MAS , 1 (2 ) . Bologna Reform . 6) European Patent Office 7) EIPIN , , (2), (2) . 7. 11 1 2008 3 105 < 5> ETH (MAS IP) 1 Structure 10 6 2 7 9 (1 day: CHF 400; 2 days: CHF 700) ( 5~6 ) ~ Team play (3~5 ) , , 4 research report 50 , interactive , , , , (, , ) Introduction to Law and Basic IP Issues Course (Introduction to Law, Basic IP Issues) EPC Patent Prosecution (Patentability, Patent Searching with Practical Exercises, EPC Procedure, EPC Claim Drafting , EPC Communication, EPC Opposition) Patent Protection & Litigation in Europe Course (Common Law and Civil Law Compared, Patent Rights, Patent Infringement Comparative Patent Issues Course (Patents in the US, Patent Claims: US and EPC, PCT) Copyright, Trademarks & Industrial Design (Basics of EU and US Copyright, Copyright & Trademarks, Trademarks & Design) < 6> (CIP) ICM CIP 1 EU 2007 2 (Bologna Process) , IP ( ) CSE . . 2006 , Business Plan , capitalist . negotiation , , , ) , GIBBS CSE biotech . 2 Biotech 3 , , , 4 1 . Asset 1, feedback, IP . 8. , (Kim, Joon Ho, Hong, Jin Hwan) 106 < 7> 120 , , , . , , / 3 . IP , , Advance , R&D . . /, , , 13 28 . . , life science , A, B 3 . . , , (MIP) , , , 4 . , , , , , , , . , , , MOT . , , MOT , 2 . Management Technology 1 ment), GIBBS (Gtenburg International Bioscience Business School), CSE(Chalmers School of En- terprise) . ( ), () ( ) , . , , . , , / 3 , IP , , Advanced , R&D . /, , , . (life science) . A, B 3 , . , , . (MIP) 9. 11 1 2008 3 107 < 8> National Innovation System , , , , , , , 4 , , , , , , , , , . , , , . < 7> . , 2003 8) . 2003 , 8,000 . 2006 (TMI-Technology Management for Inno- vation) , . , , , . , , , . , , , . National Innovation System , , , . , . . 14, 17, 20 3 51 . , , , , 6 5 . , . , , , , < 9> .9) , , , , 6 , , 8) , , . 9) 10. , (Kim, Joon Ho, Hong, Jin Hwan) 108 < 9> (4.26) (MIT: Robert Rines) (3.48) , (ETH: Herbert Laederach) (2.76) , (: ) (1.76) (3.96) (MIT: , Caltech: ) (3.42) (ETH: , Chalmers: , , ) (2.78) (: , , TLO, ) (2.10) , (4.12) , (Kellogg: ,MIT: ,Duke:,, ) (3.48) entrepreneurship (Bournemouth: , Chalmers: ) (2.80) ( ) (: - , , ) (1.98) ( ) (: , KAIST: ) (4.10) , , () (3.64) , ( ), () (2.68) , , ( ) ( , , ) (1.90) , , ( ) ( , , ) (3.88) (MIT: ) (3.34) [Chalmers : CIP(Center for Intellectual Property Studies) ] (2.52) , (, : , ) (1.72) (3.92) , (3.84) ETH 80 (2/3 , ) (2.48) , (: 2008 - 10) (1.72) (: 118 , ) . 6 , , , . 3.84 3.92 , [ 1] . , , 11. 11 1 2008 3 109 [ 1] , . 100 , 87, 66, 46 . , . . , . . , , . . 6 , 4.17 3.52 2.78 1.97 . . MIT 1950 Robert Rines , Caltech . 4.17 . ETH , Chalmers . 12 (Scientific Enterprise) ,10) . (Bournemouth) Ruth Soetendorp Jim Roach , UTS Bill Childs Rob McLaughlan . ( Higher Education Academy) (Engineering Subject Centre) . 3.52 . . , , , , , , IP , , , , , , , . 2.78 . , KAIST , , .11) 10) , . 11) 4 . , , , . , , 12. , (Kim, Joon Ho, Hong, Jin Hwan) 110 [ 2] SWOT (), () , , 12), 13), 14), , . , 3 , , , . , 5 . , . . [ 2] . V. , , , , 6 , . 6 , . . . 12) , , , , . 13) , , , , , . 14) , , , . 13. 11 1 2008 3 111 < 10> 1 2 , 3 , , , 4 5 6 , . , , . , 15) . . , ETH CEIPI 90~100 . , CEIPI . Prune . , , . 16) < 8> , a) b)() c) (pool) . , , . 3, 4 , 16 , . 15) 1996 , 2000 16) 14. , (Kim, Joon Ho, Hong, Jin Hwan) 112 , , . 08 1 , . , () , . . T3 (Teaching The Teachers) , , . , . () . , 17) . , . , . Pool . . ETH Zurich , , , CEIPI . , , . Pool , , . , . , , , . 1990 , , (Technology Licensing Organization) , . 4 2005 26 5 . , . . . 17) 8 15. 11 1 2008 3 113 , . . , , 3 , , , . , 3 . : , , Alikhan, Shahid and Raghunath Mashelkar (2004), Intellectual Property and Competitive Strategies in the 21st Century, Kluwer Law International Bader Martin A (2006), Intellectual Property Management in R&D Collaborations: The Case of the Service Industry Sector, Physica-Verlag, 184-198 EC (2004), Manufacture A Vision for 2020: Report of the High Level Group Engineering Council UK (2005), Chartered Engi- neer and Incorporated Engineer Standard Jennewein, Klaus (2005), Intellectual Property Management: The Role of Technology-Brands in the Appropriation of Technological Inno- vation, Physica-Verlag 367-384 Junghans, Claas and Adam Levy (2006), Intellectual Property Management: A Guide for Scientists, Engineers, Financiers, and Managers, Wiley- VCH Miele, Anthony (2000), Patent Strategy: A Manager's Guide to Profiting from Patent Portfolios, John Wiley & Son NAE (2004) Visions of Engineering in the New Century, National Academy of Engineering, The National Academies Press, Washington, DC NAE (2005) Adapting Engineering Education to the New Century, National Academy of Engineering, The National academies Press, Washington, DC Nonaka, Ikujiro (1991) The Knowledge-Creating Company, Harvard Business Review November- December 96-104 Obi, Toshio (2007), Innovation Japan, Asia Innovation Forum 2007 Pike, Christoper (2001), Virutal Monopoly, Nicolas Brealey Publishing, London Razgaitis, Richard (2003), Valuation and Pricing of Technology-Based Intellectual Property, John Wiley & Son :