Planejamento de Pesquisa - Uma Introdução

8

description

Planejamento de Pesquisa - Uma Introdução

Transcript of Planejamento de Pesquisa - Uma Introdução

  • !

    "#$%&!'()(*+(!,-./+0.1+/23!*+!4+56785.9!71.!8/2:3*7;3/>+-35!*+!"7/.!

    ,"%$=B%C=$DE!F=!,='G#H'%!

    #C%!H$DIEF#JKE!

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

  • Z[!

    %!I=)H'KE!F=!"HD=I%D#I% LECE!,%ID=!H$D=QI%$D=!FE!,IEL=''E!F= \EIC#"%JKE!FE!,IEP"=C%!

    =1]3:.! .! 8143:2^/>8.! 4:81+8:.! *+55+! 2_48>3! 5+! :+`8:.&! .678&! a! :+-.;31! 3! 4-./+0.1+/23! *+! 71.!4+56785.!+&!1.85!+54+>8`8>.1+/2+&!>31!.!`3:17-.;3!+!43*+&!43:!+-.!1+51.&!>3/528278:!71!2:.].-O3!*+!4+56785.!R].52.!:+V+:!35!>:82U:835!.43/2.*35!4.:.!>.:.>2+:8Y.:!71.!4+56785.!+!A.:./28:!67+!+-+5! 5+0.1!.28/A8*35S(!,3:!+55.5! :.Yc+5&!3! 2+d23!.! 5+A78:!/83/.:.:.>2+:b528>.5(!#1.!:+V857:+!:+>74+:.:!.!+V3-7;3/>+8235!+/`.28Y.:e!.54+>235!178235!*8`+:+/2+5!*.67+-+5!>3/2+14-.*35!+1!71!2:.].-O3!*+!:+V85313!3]0+28V3&!43:!+d+14-3&!`.18-8.:8Y.:!3!4+56785.*3:!>31!3!67+!0e!`38!8/V+528A.*3!53]:+!71!*+2+:18/.*3!4:3]-+1.!*+!8/2+:+55+(!,3:!372:3! -.*3!M!+!+52.!U!.!67+52.*.! M!*8`+:+/2+5!4+553.5!.4:+5+/2.1!+528-35!*8V+:535!*+! 3:A./8Y.;+55.:8.1+/2+!.`+2.:!.!57.!67.-8*.*+(!,3:!+d+14-3&!.-A7/5! .723:+5! 8/8>8.1! 5+75! 2:.].-O35! .4:+5+/2./*3! 3! 4:3]-+1.! +! 35! 3]0+28V35! *.! :+V858.:!>31!71.!8/2:3*7;3143/*3!3! 4:3]-+1.! >70.! `3:17-.;+::.! 3! 2:.].-O3(!=1]3:.! >.*.! -+823:! 4355.! 4:+`+:8:! 71!37! 372:3! +528-3&! /313!*85>728M-35!+1!2+:135!*+!>+:23!37!+::.*3(!=/2:+2./23&!:+5A7.:*.*.5!.5!-8]+:*.*+5!*3!.723:!/3!67+!*8Y!:+54+823!.!+528-3&!+!:+54+82.*35!35!>3/*8>83/./2+5!*35!3]0+28V35!67+!+-+!4:34c+&!Oe!67+!5+!:+>3/O+>+:!67+!71.!:+V85313!67.-67+:!2:.].-O3!+5>:823&!U!71.!4+;.!*+528/.*.!a!*8V7-A.;317/8>.;313!2.-&!+52e!570+82.!.!71!1b/813!*+!>:82U:835!+!/3:1.5(!,3:!+55.5!:.Yc+5!`38!67+!.723:+5!>313!=>3!R ?ghS&!'+V+:8/3!R ?@iS!+!'.-V.*3:!R ?@ S&!43:!+d+14-3&!*+>8*8:.1!47]-8>.:!5+75!-8V:35!>31!`7/;.1+/2+!*8*e28>.(!=1]3:.! 3! >3/07/23! *+! 3]:.5! .>81.! >82.*.5! :+T/.! 3! 67+! *+!1.85! 8143:2./2+! +! T28-! 5+! 2+/O.! 4.:.! *8Y+:! .! :+54+823! *3!2:.].-O3!13/3A:e`8>3&!>3/58*+:+8!:+-+V./2+! :+231.:!.!67+52313!:+.-8Y.:!13/3A:. 8`.5&!2+:13!67+!435578!71.!>3/32.;:82U:83!1.85!`.>8-1+/2+!8*+/28`8>eV+-!*.!8/2+/;84.85!-.>7/.5&!3/*+!5+!+/>3/2:.1!35!4:8/>84.85!+/2:.V+5!2+_:8>35!+k37!1+23*3-_A8>35(!=/2:+!.5!1782.5!:.Yc+5!67+!23:/.1!8143:2./2+5!+527*35!>31!+55+!3]0+28V3&!*+V+M5+!-+1]:.:!67+!+-+5!>3/52827+1!71.!+d>+-+/2+!`3/2+!*+!.27.-8Y.;3/*+/5.1!35!43/235! 8143:2./2+5!*3!4:3]-+1.!+1!67+528.!/+>+55e:835!4.:.!57.!+-.]3:.;3!:+>31+/*.*3!4.:.!8/8>8./2+5(!

    I+V85.!

    $.]+&!.678&!*85>755./>+!*3!2+:13!j2+_:8>3j(!%!+d4:+5531!3!8/27823!*+!34lM-.!a!:+V85.!RV+:!.!5+A78:S(!#1.!:+V85.&!+1!A+:.-&!2+1!3!3]0+28V3!*+!>8:>7/5>:+V+:!71!*.*3!4:3]-+1.!*+!4+56785.!*+/2:3!*+!71!67.*:3!*+!:+`+:N/>8.!2+_:8>3!67+!4:+2+/*+!+d4-8>eM-3(!%!8143:2^/>8.!*+55.!>8:>7/5>:8;3/23:/35!*+4+/*+/*3!*3!2843!*+!4:3]-+1.!+1!+527*3&!*.!2+3:8.!+1!67+52314:318553!>31!.!2+3:8.!*.67+-+!67+! 07-A.!3! 2:.].-O3!37!1+513!*.!57.!>3/>+4;+!O.V+:!43/235!+54+>b`8>35!.!*85>728:!67+!8/*+4+/*+1!*35!4.:^1+2:35!>82.*35!.>81.(!F385!*+-+5!5.*35!.!5+A78:(!E!4:3]-+1.!+1!+527*3!U!A+:.*3!43:!71.!2+3:8.(!$+52+!>.53!+54+>b`8>3&!3!4:3]-+1.!2+1!3:8A+1!/71!67.*:3!2+_:8>3!67+!-O+! *e&! 574352.1+/2+&! >3+:N/>8.&! >3/5852N/>8.! +! V.-8*.*+(! %-U1! *8553&! *+V+! +54+>8`8>.:! >3/*8;c+5! *+2+:18/./2+5! *3!`+/l1+/3! +! V.:8eV+85! >31!.-2.! 4:3].]8-8*.*+! *+!.`+2eM-3(! ,3:! 23*.5! +55.5! :.Yc+5&! 23:/.M5+! 8/.*1855bV+-! 67+! 3! +527*3!4:+5>8/*.!*+!71.!:+V858:>7/5>:+V.!3!`+/l1+/3!/3!^1]823!*.!2+3:8.(!=d+14-3!*+!4:3]-+1.5!*+55.!>.2+A3:8.!53/>+8235! >313! 8*+3-3A8.&! :+4:+5+/2.;8.-&! .4:+/*8Y.A+1! 58A/8`8>.28V.&! +678-8]:.;313*.;(!=! Oe! 71! >.53! 4.:28>7-.:! *+55.! >-.55+! 67+! >314+/5.! :+55.-2.:9! 3! 4:3]-+1.!*+! 4+56785.! U! .! 4:_4:8.!2+3:8.(!D:.2.M5+&!.678&!*.!4+56785.!67+!4:3>7:.!./.-85.:!4:34:8+*.*+5!*.!2+3:8.!+1!67+!3!4+56785.*3:!+52e!8/2+:+55.*3&!+1!V+Y!*+!+14:+AeM-.!>313!5752+/2e>7-3!*3!4:3]-+1.!.!5+:!+527*.*3(!F+13!R ?g S&!/3!L.4(!h!Rh(nS&!`.Y!71!-+V./2.1+/23

  • Z !

    *+!4:3]-+1.5!*+55+!2843&!+/`.28Y./*3!.!8143:2^/>8.!*+!67+!35!4:_4:835!4+56785.*3:+5!4.55+1!.!.55718M-35&!+1!V+Y!*+!:+-+AeM-35!a!./e-85+!*35!`8-_53`35!.4+/.5(!E! 4:3]-+1.! /7-.:&! 1.5! 43*+! 5+:! *+:8V.*3! *+! Ve:8.5! 2+3:8.5&! 37! 43:! +-.5!+d4-8>.*3(!D+:135!>313!1328V.;.;-.27:.!/.!8*+/28*.*+!*+!+54+>8`8>.;7/5>:8;.! 4:32+A+:e! 3! 4+56785.*3:! *.5! >:b28>.5! 67+! 43*+:8.1! 5+:! `+82.5! 43:! .67+-+5! 67+!+54+:.V.1! 67+! *+2+:18/.*.! V.:8eV+-! `355+! .V.-8.*.! 5+A7/*3! 4.:^1+2:35! 67+! /3-O8*35(! ,3:! +d+14-3&!+1]3:.!P:7/+:!+!,8.A+2!2+/O.1M5+!3>74.*3!*+!.54+>235!5+1+-O./2+5!*3!*+5+/V3-V81+/23!>3A/828V3&!5+14:+!O37V+!+/2:+!.1]35! 71.! *8V+:AN/>8.! 2+_:8>.9! .! 8143:2^/>8.! *.! +d4-8>.;7/*.*.!43:!71.!+d4-8>.;314.2bV+-&!P:7/+:!>3/58*+:.V.!.5!*7.5!:+54352.5!>313!8/*+4+/*+/2+5(!

    I+V85.!

    #1.!*.5! `7/;c+5!1.85! 8143:2./2+5!*+55+! 2843!*+!:+V85.;313!3!4:3]-+1.!+1!67+528.-1+/2+! *3! 43/23! *+! V852.! 1+23*3-_A8>3(! %-U1! *+! `3:/+>+:! *.*35! :+57-2./2+5! *.5! 4+56785.5!./.-85.*.5&!+55.5!:+V85c+5!53139!M67.85!35!4:3>+*81+/235!/3:1.-1+/2+!+14:+A.*35!/3!+527*3!*+55+!4:3]-+1.o!M67+!`.23:+5!VN1!.`+2./*3!35!:+57-2.*35o!G7+!4:34352.5!2N1!58*3!`+82.5!4.:.!+d4-8>eM-35!37!4.:.!>3/2:3-eM-35o!M!67+!4:3>+*81+/235!VN1!5+/*3!+14:+A.*35!4.:.!./.-85.:!35!:+57-2.*35o!M!Oe!:+-.235!*+!1./72+/;8-82.*3! 4+-3! >3/`:3/23! >31! 3! 4:3]-+1.! *+!4+56785.(! ,3:! +d+14-3&! 43*+! 5+:! `7/*.1+/2.-! *+5>3]:8:&! 43:! 1+83! *.! :+V85+55e:8.5! 4.:.!+527*.:! 3! 4:3]-+1.! 43*+1! 5+:! 3]28*.5! 2./23! 43:! 1+83! *+! 67+5283/e:835! 67./23! *+! +/2:+V852.5(! E! 2+143! +! 3! >7523!+/V3-V8*35!/+55+!T-2813!4:3>+*81+/23!43*+1!+52.:!.-U1!*.67+-+5!*8543/bV+85!.3!4+56785.*3:(!

    I+V85.!

    I+V85c+5!O852_:8>.5!5

  • ZZ!

    :+-.;8.;83/.-!*+!,_5MQ:.*7.;.;.53&!.4+/.5!2:.].-O35!+1!=*7>.;.;+5!8/!=*7>.283/(!=*7>.283/.-!I+537:>+5(!H/`3:1.283/!L+/2+:!M=IHL(!r.5O8/A23/!FL(!M!'71e:835!*+!,+:8_*8>35!+1!,58>3-3A8.(!#',&!H/5282723!*+!,58>3-3A8.(!'+>;.!+!F3>71+/2.;O3-3A8>.-!%]52:.>25(!DO+!%1+:8>./!,5W>O3-3A8>.-!%553>8.283/(!

    I+ +`:N/>8.5!>82.*.5!+1!.:28A35!0e!+/>3/2:.*35(!L.*.!4+56785.*3:!:+.-8Y.!5+7!4:_4:83!-+V./2.1+/23!*.!-82+:.27:.!+!`.Y!:+`+:N/>8.!.35!.:28A35!728-8Y.*35!/3!2:.].-O3(!C+513!67+!71!.:28A3!+/>3/2:.*3!.>.]+!/3/57-2.:!57.5!:+`+:N/>8.5(!%!1+-O3:!`3/2+!*+55+!2843&!3]V8.1+/2+&!5N!+528V+:!8/2+:+55.*3!/.!-82+:.27:.!*35!T-28135!i!./35! R8523! *+V+! 5+:! 1+/>83/.*3S! 53]:+! 3! 2:+8/.1+/23! *+! 4:3`+553:+5! *+! !3! A:.7&! *+! >-.55+5! +54+>8.85! *.5! +5>3-.5!4T]-8>.5!*+!'3!*35!.-7/35&!V3>N!*+V+:e!+/V8.:!>313!4.-.V:.5M>O.V+!.5!+d4:+55c+5!+1!/+A:823&!.>81.(!G7.-67+:!318557523S(!E72:.5!.-2+:/.28V.5( s!4355bV+-!R+1]3:.!+d2:+1.1+/2+!814:3VeV+-S!67+&!.4_5!4+:>3::+:!35!>.18/O35!8/*8>.*35!.>81.&!V3>N!/3/58A.!+/>3/2:.:!-82+:.27:.!.*+67.*.!.3!5+7!4:3]-+1.&!37!4+-3!1+/35!71.!67./28*.*+!*+!.:28A35!57`8>8+/2+!4.:.!71.!]3.!:+V85.53&!Oe!4+-3!1+/35!2:N5!>.18/O35!/+55.:8.1+/2+!+d>-7*+/2+5(! (!L3/57-2.5!.!+54+>8.-852.5!/.!e:+.( L31!:+-.;.]+!71!.-+:2.(!#1!+54+>8.-852.!R67+!43*+:8.!5+:!5+7!4:3`+553:S!4:3V.V+-1+/2+!+52.:e!1.85!*8543/bV+-!4.:.!71.!>3/V+:5.!*3!2843!j2:3>.!*+!8*U8.5!+/2:+!4+56785.*3:+5j!*3!67+!4.:.!71.!>3/V+:5.!*3!2843!j.07*+M1+j(!s!].52./2+!*+5.A:.*eV+-!.::./0.:!2+143!4.:.!71!+/>3/2:3!>31!71.!4+553.!67+! 4+*+! .-A3! +! *+5>3]:8:! 67+! +-.! /3/V+:5.&! /+1! 2+/237! +/>3/2:.:! 53-7;31! 35! 1+835!O.]827.85(!$+55.!-8/O.&!3!1.85!`:+6m+/2+!U!3!.-7/3!>31+;.:!*8Y+/*3!67+!/3/2:37!-82+:.27:.!4.:.!3!5+7!4:3]-+1.!67./*3&!*+!>.]+;.!+!/.!O3:.&!U!4355bV+-!>82.:!71.!5U:8+!*+!.:28A3!+/>3/2:eV+85!/35!4+:8_*8>35!1.85!>317/5(!,3:2./23!5+!V3>N!28V+:!*+!.4+-.:!4.:.!+55.!`3/2+&!4+-3!1+/35!4:+4.:+M5+!]+1!4.:.!.!>3/V+:5.&!3!67+!58A/8`8>.!+5A32.:!.5! `3/2+5!O.]827.85(!Z(!%/.-3A8.5(!=52.! /:8.:!17823(!R%-8e5&!5+!V3>N!/8.! *+! 4+56785.&! :+`-82.! 5+! V.-+! .! 4+/.! 8/58528:! /3! 4:3]-+1.tS! #1.! 43558]8-8*.*+! *8543/bV+-! U!>31+;.:! .!.14-8.:! 37! .-2+:.:! 57.5! 4.-.V:.5M>O.V+! +! 4.55.:! 4.:.! 4:3]-+1.5! 5+1+-O./2+5! 37! e:+.5! >3::+-.2.5(! ,3:!+d+14-3&!5+!V3>N!4:+2+/*+!+527*.:!71!4:3]-+1.!:+-.28V3!.!*+`8>8+/2+5!1+/2.85!8/52827>83/.-8Y.*35!+!/3/2:.!-82+:.27:.!.!:+54+823&!2.-V+Y!V.-O.!.!4+/.!>3/57-2.:!-82+:.27:.!53]:+!>:+>O+5!37!372:3!2843!*+!8/528278;./2+5&! 1.5! U! 4355bV+-! 67+! V3>N! +/>3/2:+!8/`3:1.;c+5! 67+! 3! 4:+4.:+1! 1+-O3:! 4.:.! +/`:+/2.:! 3! 4:3]-+1.(! F.! 1+51.! `3:1.&! 5+! V3>N! /3/2:.! /.!-82+:.27:.!*+!,58>3-3A8.!37!=*7>.;235!*+!>3143:2.1+/23!V+:].-!+1!67+!V3>N!+52e! 8/2+:+55.*3&! >3/58*+:+! .-A71.5! 8/>7:5c+5! 4+-.! "8/Amb528>.! +! 4+-.! %/2:343-3A8.! R67+&! .-8e5&! V3>N! *+V+:8.!>3/57-2.:!*+!23*3!13*3tS(!h( '+!/.*.!*8553!`38!`:72b`+:3!+!5+!V3>N!>3/28/7.:!*+>8*8*3!.!+527*.:!3!4:3]-+1.&!V3>N!+52.:e!.723:8Y.*3!.!*854+/5.:!71.!:+V85-.1.:!.!8/+d852N/>8.!*+52.(!%!57.!4+56785.!.55718:e!71!>.:e2+:!+18/+/2+1+/2+!+d4-3:.2_:83(! =/2:+2./23&! -+1]:+M5+! *+! 67+&! 5+! V3>N! U! 71! .-7/3! *+! 4_5MA:.*7.;3/V+/>8*.!*+!67+&!*+!`.23&!.!-82+:.27:.!/3!V3>N!+52.:e!>3::+/*3!5+!75.:!5+7!4:30+23!4.:.!4-+82+.:!71.!]3-5.!37!`8/./>8.1+/23(!

    %2U!3/*+!: +2:3>+*+: !/3!2+143o!

    %! 1+/35! 67+! 5+! 2:.2+! *+! 71.! :+V85.&! +1! 67+! 3! >:82U:83! *+V+:8.! 5+:! 3!131+/23! *+! .4.:+>81+/23! *3!>3/>+823!37!4:3]-+1.!67+!5+!67+:!+527*.:&!

    @!L33:*+/.*3:8.!*+!L.4.>82.;

  • Zh!

    U!67.5+!814355bV+-!:+543/*+:!.!+55.!4+:A7/2.(!s!4355bV+-&!>3/27*3&!-./;.:!1:82U:835!.7d8-8.:+5(!\:+6mN/>8.!*+!4+56785.5!/.!e:+.(!'+!.!-82+:.27:.!`3:!.]7/*./2+&!>31!47]-8>.;c+5!:+A7-.:+5&!U!4355bV+-!67+!3!1.2+:8.-!*35!T-28135!n!37!i!./35!5+0.!57`8>8+/2+!4.:.!>3143:!71!67.*:3!*+!:+`+:N/>8.!4.:.!3!4:3]-+1.(!Xe!*7.5!574358;c+5!43:!2:e5!*+55.!.`8:1.;313!.5!47]-8>.;c+5!53:43:.*35!a!-82+:.27:.!1.85!:+>+/2+(!=1!5+A7/*3!-7A.:&!574c+M5+!67+!:+57-2.*35!1.85!./28A35!/3:43:.*35!:+4:+5+/2+1!4355bV+85!j]+>35!5+1!5.b*.j&!43:!8523!.]./*3/.*35(!$3V.1+/2+&!+52+5!43*+1!5+:!>:82U:835!.7d8-8.:+5&!1.5!57.!.4-8>.;3/2:.4352.!.!4+>7-8.:8*.*+5!*.!e:+.(!'_!>313! +d+14-3&! .-A71.5! e:+.5! *+! 4+56785.! 43*+1! +d8A8:! .! >3/57-2.! *+! *3>71+/235! ./28A35! .8/*.! +1! V8A3:&!8/*+4+/*+/2+1+/2+!*3!V3-71+!*+!-82+:.27:.!/.!e:+.(!F8543/8]8-8*.*+! *+! .:28A35! *+! :+V85+/2+1+/2+&! +*823:+5! *+! 4+:8_*8>35! R4:8/>84.-1+/2+!/3:2+M.1+:8>./35S!>35271.V.1!+/>31+/*.:!.:28A35!*+!:+V858.-852.5!*.!e:+.(!=1!A+:.-&!.!>.*.!i!./35!5.b.!71.!/3V.!:+V85.1M/.5!+1!4.:2+5&!71.!*+-.5! 5+/*3!.! :+V85.4827-3!U!71.!:+V85:823!43:!+54+>8.-852.(!%!*8543/8]8-8*.*+!*+55.5!:+V85c+5!+!3!.>+553! .! +-.5&! /.! e:+.! *+! 8/2+:+55+&! :+*7Y+1! >3/58*+:.V+-1+/2+! .! /+>+558*.*+! *+! :+2:3>+553! /3! 2+143! +1! ]75>.! *+!-82+:.27:.(! %5! 4:_4:8.5! :+V85c+5! 8/*8>.:7-.:1+/2+! 8143:2./2+5&! *+! `3:1.! 67+! ].52.:e!>.18/O.:!.!4.:28:!*+-+5(!

    L313!8/8>8.: !3!-+V./2.1+/23!]8]-83A:e`8>3!

    #1!*35!57]4:3*7235!*.!.28V8*.*+!>3/52./2+!*+!71!4+56785.*3:!+1!71.!1+51.!e:+.!U!.!`.18-8.:8*.*+!67+!.*678:+!>31!8/528278;c+5&! 4+56785.*3:+5! +! 4+:8_*8>35! .553>8.*35! a! e:+.(!E7! 5+0.&! +-+! 4.55.! .! *85>:818/.:!1.2+:8.-! 432+/>8.-1+/2+!:+-+V./2+!4+-3!/31+!*3!.723:&!*.!57.!8/528278;3!/3!67.-!3!.:28A3!`38!47]-8>.*3(!%2U!67+!V3>N!>O+A7+!-e&!3!5+7!1+-O3:!43/23!*+!4.:28*.!.8/*.!U!.!>3/57-2.!*8:+2.!.35!.:28A35&! `8>Oe:835!*+!]8]-832+>.5&! 571e:835!*+!47]-8>.;c+5! +!]./>35!*+!2+5+5!+!*855+:2.;c+5(!L3/27*3&!Oe!*7.5!>385.5!67+!V3>N!43*+!`.Y+:!4.:.!`.>8-82.:!+55.!2.:+`.(!"+V./2.1+/23!8/8>8.-!*+!4.-.V:.5M>O.V+(!L31!+55+!-+V./2.1+/23!V3>N!43*+:e!4:3>+*+:!a!>3/57-2.!a5!`3/2+5!>31!.-A71!>:82U:83! *+! 5+-+;+*81+/23! 4:+5574c+! 67+! 35! .723:+5! 8/2827-+1! 5+75! 2:.].-O35! *.!1./+8:.!1.85!*+5>:828V.!4355bV+-&!3!67+!/+1!5+14:+!U!V+:*.*+tS!,:3>+*+:! a! >3/57-2.! /.! 5+A78/2+! 3:*+19! Db27-3! MI+5713! M"+827:.! *3! 2+d23(! '+! 3! 2b27-3&! *+! .-A71.! `3:1.&! 57A+:8:!8/2+:+55+!4.:.!3!5+7!2:.].-O3&!V.-+!.!4+/.!-+:!3!:+5713(!L31!+55.!-+827:.&!5+:e!4355bV+-!*+>8*8:!5+!>314+/5.!37!/8.!*+!2_48>35!*+/2:3!*3!2+1.!+!*.5!8/`3:1.;c+5!.!5+:+1!3`+:+>8*.5!*+/2:3!*+!>.*.!2_48>3(!E7!5+0.&!2:.2.M5+!*+!3:A./8Y.:!71.!58/345+!.14-8.*.!*3!2+d23&!./2+5!*+!+-+!5+:!+5>:823!R5+14:+!U!4355bV+-!:+`3:17-eM-.!4352+:83:1+/2+S(!=/2:+2./23&!3!67+!U!1+-O3:!*3!43/23!*+!V852.!-_A8>3!/+1!5+14:+!>3::+543/*+!.35!+528-35!4+553.85(!,.:.!.-A71.5!4+553.5&!4.:+>+!4:+`+:bV+-!5+/2.:!+!8:!+5>:+V+/*3(!E!4:3>+553!U&!5+1!*TV8*.&!1.85!4+/353!+!1.85!>752353&!/.!1+*8*.!+1!67+!3!2+d23!`8/.-!5.8!>313!:+57-2.*3! *+! 2+/2.28V.5! +! +::35&! >31! 1782.5! 4eA8/.5! 03A.*.5! `3:.! +! 372:.5! 2./2.5! jA7.:*.*.5j! 4.:.! 71! +V+/27.-!.4:3V+82.1+/23!`727:3!R=>3&! ?gh&!`.-.!+1!1./2+:!71!`8>Oe:83!*+!j8*U8.5jS(!G7.-67+:!67+!5+0.!3!4:3>+*81+/23!.*32.*3&!3!57>+553!*3!2+d23!`8/.-&!+1!2+:135!*+!>317/8>.;.4.Y! *+! +/>3/2:.:! 3! `83! >3/*723:! *3! 2:.].-O3(! ,3:! +52.! :.Y3/V+/8+/2+! 67+! 3! 2+d23!.4:+5+/2+! 57]2b27-35! 67+! 8/*867+1!3! 67+! 5+:e! 2:.2.*3! +1! >.*.! 57]*8V85:+V+:!5+1!71!4-./3!4:UV83&!+52+!43*+:e!5+:!`+823!.4_5!.!>3/>-753/V+/8+/2+ :+55.-2.:!71!.54+>23!>3171!+1!2+d235!+5>:8235!5+1!4-./+0.1+/23(!s!4:3VeV+-!67+!3!8/*8Vb*73!67+!4:+`+:+!+5>:+V+:!5+1!71!4-./3!4:UV83!+52+0.!a!+54+:.!*3!`++*].>u!*.678-3!67+!0e!+52e!4:3*7Y8*3!4.:.!>3/28/7.:!4:3*7Y8/*3&!*+!2.-!`3:1.!67+!>+:2.5!./e-85+5!*N+1!j*8>.5j!*+!>313!4:355+A78:(!L313!>3/5+6mN/>8.&!U!`:+6m+/2+!67+!3!:+57-2.*3!`8/.-!5+0.!71.!-3/A.!5+6mN/>8.!*+!./e-85+5!67+!/O.1!+!/3!67.-!3!`8/.-!2+1!437>.!37!/+/O71.!:+-.;31!3!8/b>83(!I+231.:!3!2+d23!+!3:A./8YeM-3!+1!2_48>35!U!71.!`3:1.!*+!.V.-8.:!+55.!5+6mN/>8.(!=&!5+!+-35!*+55.!5+6mN/>8.!4.:+>+:+1!/.]+:! /35! 2_48>35! -+V./2.*35! 37! :+58528:+1! a! 8/>-7535&! U! ]31! :+4+/5.:! 5+! .5! 8/`3:1.;c+5! 5+*81+/23!8143:2./2+!4.:.!1+-O3:!>3/2:3-.:!.!.*+67.;3/5+6m+/2+1+/2+&!4.:.!1.83:!>314:++/58.!*+!j.]+:27:.j!+!j`+>O.1+/23j!4.:.!>.*.!2_48>3(!=1!372:.5!4.-.V:.5&!./7/>8.:!*8:+2.1+/2+!3!67+!5U!4:+2+/*+!`.Y+:!/.67+-+!2_48>3!+!>3/>-78:!*8Y+/*3!3!67+!+54+:.!67+!3!-+823:!2+/O.!+d2:.b*3!*+-+(!E!07-A.1+/23!T-2813!*+55.!.*+67.;+:2.1+/2+!>.]+:e!.3!-+823:(!

    %*+67.;.!

    L313! 0e! V8:37! :328/.! /+52+! 2:.].-O3&! /82.! .! +52+! :+54+823(! =/2:+2./23&! U! `e>8-! *85>728:! 43/235! 67+!23:/.1!71!2:.].-O3!8/.*+67.*3!*3!43/23!*+!V852.!*35!82+/5!.678!./.-85.*35(!Be!5+!`.-37!*.!8143:2^/>8.!*+!+d4-8>.:!35

  • Zn!

    3]0+28V35! *.! :+V85-78:! j.]+:27:.5j! +! j`+>O35j! +1! >.*.! 57]*8V85235! 1328V.>83/.85! *35!2:+8/.1+/235! *3! 4:3`+553:j(! G7.-67+:! .:28A3! :+`+:+/2+! .3! 2+1.! 43*+:e! 5+:! 8/>-7b*3! /3! 2+d23! *3! 57]2b27-3&! 1.5! +55.!>314.28]8-8*.*+!/8+/2+!4.:.!A.:./28:!67+!3!4:3*723!`8/.-!5+0.!]31(!D31+M5+!>313!+d+14-3!3!5+A78/2+!2:+>O3!R`8>2b>83S!*+!71.!:+V85.9!v! +!w! R ?g[S! +527*.:.1! 35! +`+8235! *3! `++*].>u! 81+*8.23! +! >3/>-7b:.1! 67+! 4:3 +`553:+5! 67+! 3! :+>+]+1! -3A3! .4_5! 3!2:+8/3&!*8.:8.1+/2+&!5.+1M5+!1+-O3:!67+!.67+-+5!67+!5_!:+>+]+1!`++*].>u!.3! 8`/.-!*.!5+1./.(!x!R ?@?S!*+13/52:37!67+!.!4.:28>84.;3-O.!*35!2+d235!.!5+:+1!728-8Y.*35!/3!2:+8/.1+/23!.71+/2.!57.!1328V.;84.:!*+-+(!%!+!D! R ?g S! :+>31+/*.1!67+!3! 2:+8/.1+/23!5+0.! +`823!*7:./2+!.!4:_4:8.! 5827.;235!1328V.>83/.85(!%!814:+553-.A+1!/.!67.-!5+!57>+*+1!:+57135!*+!2+d235!-8*35(!s!4355bV+-!67+!8553!*+>3::.!*.!.75N/>8.!*+!8/`3:1.;8+/2+!4.:.!A+:.:!71.!*85>7553/5852+/2+!*35!Ve:835!+-+1+/235!1328V.>83/.85!+/V3-V8*35!/3!2:+8/3!*+!4:3`+553:+5!R3!67+!U!67.5+!814355bV+-!>31!:+-.;.53& :+52.:8.1!.3!.723:!4+-3!1+/35!*7.5!43558]8-8*.*+59!M!17*.:!3!57]2b27-3&!67+!4:31+2+!1.85!*3!67+!3!67+!5+!2+1!4.:.!3`+:+>+:&!+k37!M! 4:++/>O+:.5! j-.>7/.5j! >31! >3/58*+:.;c+5! 4:_4:8.5! +! +14:+A.:! .437>.! -82+:.27:.! +/>3/2:.*.! >313! 71.! +54U>8+! *+!5743:2+!2+/2.28V3(!%5!8/`3:1.;c+5!58.o!$31!+55.5!3]5+:V.;c+5&!*+`+/*+:!67+!>.*.!.:28A3!+14:+A.*3!/.!:+V85314-+2.1+/2+(!E!-+823:&!>3/O+>+/*3!.!:+`+:N/>8.!*3!.:28A3&!43*+:e!>3/57-2.M-3!+!*+>8*8:!5+!2+1!8/2+:+55+!+1!8/`3:1.;c+5!.*8>83/.85(!E!67+!5+!+/`.28Y.!.678!U!3!`.23!*+!67+!.!5+-+;314c+1!.!:+V8531!8/`3:1.;c+5!*+!.-A71.!`3:1.!07-A.*.5!:+-+V./2+5!4.:.!3!2+1.!67+!+52e!5+/*3!./.-85.*3&!+!>.]+!.3!.723:!*+13/52:.:!8553(!#1.!A:./*+!67./28*.*+!*+!.:28A35!-8*35!+!:+5718*35!*7:./2+!3!-+V./2.1+/23!*+!-82+:.27:.!5+14:+!.>.].!`3:.!*3!2+d23!`8/.-!R43:!1.85!8::82./2+!+!*+53-.*3:!67+!8553!4.:+;.S!5814-+51+/2+!43:67+!/3/5+A7+!:+*8A8:(!=1]3:.!3!2:+>O3!75.*3!>313!8-752:.;2b>83!+!2+/O.!58*3!.4:+5+/2.*3!`3:.!*+!>3/2+d23&!5+:V+!4.:.!+d+14-8`8>.:!372:3!4:3]-+1.!`:+6m+/2+!+1!:+V85.1! .5! 4358;c+5! 2+_:8>.5! +! .5! *+>85c+5!1+23*3-_A8>.5(!F+55+! 43/23! *+! V852.&!/3! +d+14-3! .>81.&! .!1+/35! 67+! 5+! 4:+2+/*.&!/3! 4:3A:.1.!*+! 2:+8/.1+/23! +1!67+5275523!1328V.>83/.-(!Rs!]31!-+1]:.:!67+!3!1.2+:8.-!-8*3!+!/31!372:3!3]0+28V3S(!=55.5!>3/58*+:.;c+5!*+:23!5+/28*3&!1.85!5U:83(!D:.2.M5+!*+!71.! 2+/*N/>8.&! /3/58*+:.:! /3! 4-./+0.1+/23! *.! 4+56785.! 43/235! 8143:2./2+5! 67+! .! 4:_4:8.! -82+:.27:.!>82.*.!+!./.-85.*.!/.!:+V85.28V.!4.:.!3!`.23(!s!]+1!V+:*.*+!67+!Oe!.-A3!.8/*.!483:9!U!V+:!.67+-+! 1+513! 43/23! *+5>3/58*+:.*3! 5+:! :+231.*3! /.! *85>755313! j4355bV+-j! +d4-8>.;O3!*3!+d+14-3!R%!+!D&! ?g S&!+1]3:.!>3/2+/O.!3!1+513!4:3]-+1.!0e!./.-85.*3!+1!:+-.;23!67+!1+:+>+!*85>755.53!+1!67+5231+/*.;8.!*+!*.*35!+54+>b`8>35!67+!.!5752+/2+1&!5_!Oe!71.!>8:>7/52^/>8.!67+!07528`867+!.!1./72+/;8.9!%!+!D!531!V.52.!+d4+:8N/>8.!/.!e:+.&!*+!13*3!67+!V.-+!.!4+/.!>3::+:!3!:85>3!*3!j.:A71+/23!*.!.723:8*.*+j(!\3:.!*+55.!>8:>7/52^/>8.&!.!>82.;+! 8/T28-9!37!Oe!*.*35!67+!.! 5752+/2+1&!+!+-+5!*+V+1!5+:!.4:+5+/2.*35&!37!.!:+>31+/*.;b`8>3j!/.!e:+.&!+!/8.!2+::.:!+55+!2_48>3&!*+V+M5+!1+/>83/.:!71.!67+528.-1+/2+!4.:.!71!4_5M!A:.*7./*3!/.!O3:.!*.!*+`+5.S(!$3!131+/23!+1!67+!*.*35!5.5!58.!M375+!:+543/5.]8-8Y.!4+-.!57.!*+`+5.(!=55.!4358;:+5>+/2.!71!/3V3!.54+>23!.3!67+!5+!V+1!*85>728/*3!.!:+54+823!*+55+!2_48>3(!%-U1!*+!*+V+:!]75>.:!71.!4358;.!`:+/2+!a5!4358;c+5!+!*.*35!.4:+5+/2.*35(!%`8/.-&!+-+!-+7!23*3!3!1.2+:8.-!+!*+>8*87!3!67+!+!43:!67+!8/>-78:(!

    \3/2+5!4: 81e: 8.5!V+: 575!`3/2+5!5+>7/*e: 8.5

  • Zi!

    E5! Ve:835! 2+d235! >82.*35! /.5! :+`+:N/>8.5! *85>72+1(! .! 67+527/*e:8.5! *+! `3:1.! ].52./2+!>314-+2.!RV+:!+54+>8.-1+/2+!=>3&(! ?gh&!>.4(!hS(!%678!5+:84.85!67+!4+:182+1!4:355+A78:!>31!.!*85>755313!`38! +5>:823! +! 814:+553! 4+-3! .723:(!Xe! V.:8.;c+5! /3! 67+! 5+! .>+82.! >313!4:81e:83&!*+4+/*+/*3!*3!3]0+28V3!67+!5+!2+1(!'+!5+!4:+2+/*+!`.Y+:!71.!:+>3/52:7;.!*.!3]:.!*+!71!.723:!37!*.!+V3-7;3/58*+:.:!>313!4:81e:8.5!.5!`3/2+5!3:8A8/.85&!/.!-b/A7.!+1!67+!`3:.1!+5>:82.5f!71.! 2:.*7;3/528278:e! 71.! `3/2+! 5+>7/*e:8.(! G7./*3! 3! 67+! 8/2+:+55.! U! 3! >3/O+>81+/23!4:3*7Y8*3!.!:+54+823!*+!71!*+2+:18/.*3!`+/l1+/3&!/O+A.!.!5+:!`7/*.1+/2.-!5+!3!67+!5+!-N!U!3!.:28A3!3:8A8/.-!37!71.!:+M+*8;82.;728V+-1+/2+!71.!`3/2+!5+>7/*e:8.!+!Oe!437>.5!>8:>7/52^/>8.5!67+!.!07528`867+1(!Be!`38!*85>728*3!.678!67+!>.*.!.723:!5+-+>83/.!4.:.!3!2+d23!*.!:+V85+553! a! ]8]-83A:.`8.! 8/2+:/.>83/.-! +52e! .67U1! *3! *+5+0eV+-(! F.! 1+51.! `3:1.&! *+2+:18/.*35!*3>71+/235!43*+1!5+:!.>+55bV+85!.4+/.5!8/!-3>3&!3!67+!43*+!*8`8>7-2.:!57.!-+827:.(!=1!>3/*8;c+5!>313!+52.5&!71!.723:!43*+!5+:!.723:8Y.*3!.!:+>3::+:!.!`3/2+5!5+>7/*e:8.5(!C.5!.4+/.5!+1!>3/*8;c+5!>313!+52.5t!

    L82.;c+5!*8: +2.5!

    #1.!>82.;:8;.5&!+55.!2:./5>:8;.!3!-+823:!+1!>3/2.23!*8:+23!>31!3!2+d23!3:8A8/.-&!./2+5!*+!5+!./.-85eM!-3(!F.!1+51.!`3:1.&!+1!*+2+:18/.*35!131+/235!*+!71.!:+V85+:!T28-! 2:./5>:+V+:!71.!*.*.!4.55.A+1!R71!>.53!2b48>3!U!.!>82.;+:23!>3/2+d23!*.!3]:.!*+!71.!.723:f!1.5!8553!U!.4+/.5!71!+d+14-3S(!G7.-67+:!67+!5+0.!.!:.Y8*.!`.Y+:!71.!>82.;82.;8:>7/52^/>8.5&!.5!>82.;c+5!*8:+2.5!*+V+:8.1!5+:!+V82.*.5(!s! +V8*+/2+! 67+! .!.723:8.! *+! 71!*.*3! >3/O+>81+/23! 728-8Y.*3! *+V+! 5+:!1+/>83/.*.&!1.5! .! +55+! :+54+823! V.-+! .! 4+/.!./.-85.:!*385!43/235!+54+>b`8>35(!M! '+! -+135! +1! 71! *+2+:18/.*3! .:28A3! .5! >3/58*+:.;c+5! *+! 71! .723:! 53]:+! .54+>235! *+! /3553! 4:_4:83! 4:3]-+1.&! +!*+>8*8135! 8/>-7bMH.5! /3! 2+d23! `8/.-&! /+55e:83! `.Y+:! 71.! >82.;313! `3:1.! *+! :+>3/O+>+:! .!.723:8.(!s!57`8>8+/2+!4.:.`:.5+.:!.!./e-85+!R>31!3!*+V8*3!>78*.*3S!+!1+/>83/.:!3!/31+!*3!.723:!+!.!*.2.!*.!47]-8>.;3139!'+A7/*3!v!R ?@[S&!37!>3-3>.:!/3!`8/.-!*.!4.:e`:.5+9!Rv&! ?@[S(!M!F+V+!O.V+:!71!1b/813!*+!]31M5+/53!/.!5+-+;8*+!>82.:!*8:+2.1+/2+(!$82.:!*8:+2.1+/2+!71!.723:!67+!.`8:137!67+!jU!/+>+55e:83!67+!5+!`.;.1!1.85!4+56785.5!53]:+!=*7>.;3-3A8.!2+1!.8/*.!178235!>.1435!.!+d4-3:.:j(!E! `+>O.1+/23!1.85! 8143:2./2+!4.:.!+52+! 2+d23!U!.!N/`.5+!/.! 8143:2^/>8.!*.5!:+V85c+5!*+! -82+:.27:.(!G7+:!>313!4+;.!`7/*.1+/2.-!/.!*+`8/8;313!71! 2:.].-O3M53-3!*+!4+56785.&!71.!:+V853/528278!71!4.553!*+>858V3!4.:.!67+1!67+:!67+!4:+2+/*.!+/2:.:!+1!71.!e:+.!*+!4+56785.(!%-U1!*.!>3/2:8]78;81+/23&!71.!:+V853/528278!71!:+54+823!.3! 2:.].-O3!*+!372:35!4+56785.!*3:+5!+!71!>314:318553!>31!.!>:b28>.!>3/2b/7.!.3!4:3*723!*+52+5!+&!43:2./23&!>31!3!.4:813:.1+/23!*.!>8N/>8.(

  • Zq!

    I=\=Iy$LH%'!PHP"HEQIz\HL%'!

    P%LXI%LX&!%(B(!H/2:3*7;3-_A8>.(!'84./2+(!'.>83/.-(! 'O!1+2O3*5!8/!53>8.-!:+-.283/5(!$3V.!w3:u&!I3-2&!I8/+O.:2!./*!r8/523/&!8/>(&! ?i (!}=I"H$Q=I&!\($( C+23*3-3A8.!*.!4+56785.!+1!>8N/>8.5!53>8.85(!'.;.9!+-.]3:.;8+/2b 8`>35(! ,3:23!%-+A:+&!"8V:.:8.!'7-8/.!=*823:.&! ?@ (!'=)=IH$E&! %(B(! C+23*3-3A8.! *3! 2:.].-O3! >8+/2b 8`>3(! '/8>.5!*.!,3/28`b>8.!#/8V+:58*.*+!L.2_-8>.!*+!'7-.*3! .3! ,:3A:.1.! *+! ,_5! Q:.*7.;3-3A8.! *.! =*7>.;