Master-Brain Drain of

259
 ) (  Brain drain of Arab causes and con sequences  )  Iraq model (  ~ 1 ~ 

description

Arab

Transcript of Master-Brain Drain of

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 1/259

 

)(

 Brain drain of Arab causes and consequences

 ) Iraq model ( 

 

~ 1~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 2/259

 

2009

~ 2~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 3/259

 

.  .

 :

 . . :

~ 3~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 4/259

 

.

......................................... :

 

.

/ ......../ ...... :2009.

~ 4~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 5/259

 

.

:

:

/ ......... / ....... :2009.

~ 5~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 6/259

 

( .......................... ))  (, .

 /....../.....:2009.

:

 

....................................

....................

......................

....................................

....................

........................

................................

....

.................

...

....................

....

....................................

....................

........................

~ 6~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 7/259

 

""

 .

 :

..............................

 :..............................

 

:

~ 7~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 8/259

 .

 

.

 ""

).(

 .

~ 8~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 9/259

 

)( 

. .

 

.

 . 

.

~ 9~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 10/259

~ 10~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 11/259

INTRODUCTION...............................................................................................................14

~ 11~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 12/259

 

1  ..................................................... 53

 2  ................................................................59

 3  ................................61 4)10( .......................................... 65

 5  ......................................................................................68

 6  ...................................................................73

  7  .........................................................................77

 8 1990 2003 ................................................... 79

 9 2000. ...........................88

 10  ............................................................... 97

 11  ........................................................................101

 12  .........................................114

 13  ...............................................................116

 14  ............................................................118

 15 2003/2004 .............................. 121

 16  ............................................................. 127

 17 1996 ........................130

 18  .....................130

 19  ...................................... 132

 20  ......................................................135

 21)1982 – 2003.( ...............141

 22  .....................142

 23)1990 – 2001.( ) ( ......................143

 24. .........................147

 25. .................................. 148

 26. .......................................................158

 27. ...............................166

  28  ........................................................ 170

 29  ..................................................................174

  30  ........................................................ 175

~ 12~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 13/259

 31  .........185

 32  .............................................................187

 33  ............................................................188

 34  ................................................190

 35 2006 – 2007 ................................................................... 192

 36)1995 – 1996.( 203

 37)95/96( ...............203

 38  ..................................................................204

 39  .........................208

 40  ...............................................216

 41  ............................................ 221

~ 13~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 14/259

Brain drain of Arab causes and consequences(Iraq model)

Introduction

The wealth of nations cannot be used without the best use of human, as creatures of God, whogave him the functions of learning, analysis and conclusion, and inference. That man cannot

 be used and the functions of fungal elements without prior knowledge of the hypotheses andthe results came here it was great interest in human resources to create innovative and creativeminds.

Human resources play a key role in the communities of the paper during the continuous flowof knowledge production, which in turn reflected the high rates of development in all fieldscovered by the humanitarian aspects of economic, social, political and cultural. Without suchcare, which must be attached to the benefit of human resource investments is to talk about theevolution of human societies is a non-sense.

We have sought the advanced countries in the world today in the way of control and influenceover the vast areas of the developing world. Is not direct military influence as in the periods of colonialism, but it was the direct influence of the will of peoples to gain a more indirectlythrough government-specific way or the other, where the convergence of interests in common

denominators. These kinds of colonialism always need the knowledge and technicalexcellence.

In order to ensure their working knowledge and technical excellence, it still worked on therevitalization of all the means that would enable them to upgrade their creativity by attractingqualified scientists from different parts of the ground using all means and ways to accomplishthis goal. This was reflected in the adoption of the policy of major media and propaganda inorder to attract creative people into the society and from different countries of the world,whether developing or developed.

The strength of the economy today, measured the quality of human resources, efficiency andgood use. Hence, the concept of human resource development is floating on the surface andattracts attention. The human resource is one of the most important factors of economic andsocial progress. The Human resources are equipped, as the tools used by society to evaluatethe course of economic development and put them in the right direction

Human presence in the thinker and the world society is a factor of strength and an important pillar in the economic construction and the knowledge of his country. And to maintain thiselement of loss, damage and destruction is a matter of urgency, and must use all necessarymeans to maintain it and that causes the absence of decreasing the size of the skill of the

~ 14~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 15/259

knowledge society, which leads to a sharp decline in the degree of development of society andthus the gradual loss of political independence and moral integrity.

That the economic resources that abound in the developing world, including the Arabcountries is a large and diverse in terms of quantity and quality of that region was still thestatus of polarization of the colonial world that was and is still on the resources and economic

wealth, which constitute the basic motivation for the further economic development in their countries.

Bear the burden the new world order not to attract plenty of qualified scientists is no doubtwhich of the perceived interests of human beings on the other side of the world as a humanentities deserve to live up to the levels enjoyed by the developed world. In spite of conferences and symposia held under the guise of eliminating the disparities between the richand the poor world, but that these seminars and studies to the unending nothing compared tothe size and breadth of the gap between worlds, a result of the policies of the newglobalization in the exploitation of the wealth of peoples and harnessed for the benefit of their economies without having to worry about the size of the damage caused by the levelseducation and services within those communities that are the poorest.

This study is another effort by serious attempts to extrapolate these signs of migration, presentation and analysis of the causes and identify effective means to reduce the brain drainand the drain of scientific societies, which were abandoned or intentionally left behindwithout have a great deal of failure and retreat in the areas of science and research knowledge.As well as there are a large accumulations in the size of the gap of knowledge and technicalseparation between the developed and developing countries. From here we have found that it

is appropriate to research in this crucial aspect, study and analyze the reality of the damage being inflicted on the result of developing our societies to increase the number of migration of skills and the Arab people to abroad where it is supposed to perform their duty to their communities and develop the capacities of their economies and thus help to raise standards of social welfare and production of their art, which is later than others in the progress and

 prosperity.

~ 15~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 16/259

 .

 

.

 

.

 .

 

. .

 .

 

.

 

.

 

.

 .

~ 16~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 17/259

 .

 " 

"

 "  ."

 . 

).( 

.

 

.

 

~ 17~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 18/259

 . .

 

.

 

 

.

 

) ( .

 .

 ) (.

 

. .

~ 18~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 19/259

 

.

 

. :

 .

 .

 .

 

.

 

.

~ 19~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 20/259

 

,.

 )(

 

.

 

.

 

).(

 

:

 

.

 , , )(

 .

~ 20~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 21/259

 

2003.  

.

 

.

 .

 

.

~ 21~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 22/259

 

).( 

.

 .

 .

 :

 :

 

−)(

~ 22~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 23/259

 :

 −

−)(

− 

~ 23~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 24/259

~ 24~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 25/259

~ 25~ 

:)(

 

) (

−) (

 :)(

 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 26/259

~ 26~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 27/259

~ 27~ 

:

 −

 −.

−.

−.

.−.

−.

−.

 .

 .

−.

 .

.

−.

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 28/259

~ 28~ 

:

 

 

 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 29/259

 

 

) (

 

 −

 

:−

~ 29~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 30/259

 

~ 30~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 31/259

 

.. 

:

1..

2.. .

 :

1..

2."" 

)( 

.

3. 

.

~ 31~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 32/259

4. .

5. 

).1.(

" "

 . . 

.

 

. .

 

) .2.(

).( .

 .

 

~ 32~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 33/259

 .

 

.

 

),.( 

. ).3.(

." "

 

." -

 -).4.(

~ 33~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 34/259

 .

 

:

 

19501975  4,3%

. .

 

"

."  . 

. .

 

"" 1976

 

. .

 

. .

~ 34~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 35/259

 .

 

.

 

).5.(

.

 1 " 

)."6.(

:

•.

•.

1

 ..,2006

~ 35~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 36/259

•.

•.

•.

•) .7.(

.

 

. . .

 

.

 

2015 

.

 ) (

 .

 

~ 36~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 37/259

 .

 .

 .

 . )(

 .

 :

•.

•.

•.

•.

•.

•).(

•).(

.•

 .(

•.

•).(

•.

•.

•.

•.

 .

 

~ 37~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 38/259

 

.

 

.

 

.

 

. ) :8.(

)( )(

).( 

. .

 .:

 

. :

1.).(

2..

3..

~ 38~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 39/259

4..

 

.:

1.).(

2..

3. 

)/.(

 )(

 )(. 

.)(

 .)

 (30%. 

:

1.) ..(

2. .

3. .

4..

~ 39~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 40/259

5. 

.. )(

 

.).(

 .

 : 

)200600( )600(

 .

 

)600()3000 (.

 

)3000. (

 200197640%

 15.%

 )1000(40%  20.%

 

0. 

) .(

~ 40~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 41/259

 

.

 

..:

1.

 ),.( 

. :

1. .

2.).(

3..

4.)() .(

2.

 . 

..

 

)( 

~ 41~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 42/259

 . :

1..

2..

3. .

4. .

 ), ,,(

 

. ),,.(

 

..

 .

:1.

 .

2. )(

 .

3.

 )).(9.(

~ 42~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 43/259

 

)( 

)(. "

 " .

 2 " "

 ""." " 

.

 ""

 ."" )(

 .

 ""

2 )Theodore W. Schultz()301902(1979

 .1924  ..

~ 43~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 44/259

 "" 

."

 

. /"

 ."

 "

 . 

."

 )( 

.( ) "

 "" 

" .

 )(

).( 3 

)10.(

.

3 Amartya Kumar Sen,H3H H1933HHH

HHH

1998HHHHHHHHH

.  .

~ 44~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 45/259

 

.

 . 

.

 

." ")Pouel Streeten, means and Ends(

.

 

:

•.

•.

•.

 . 

).11.(

~ 45~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 46/259

 . 

:

 .

. "

 "" 

, )"12.(

. "."

 .

1. .

2. .

 

.

 

~ 46~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 47/259

 

1990. 4

 /1986" 

." . 

.

 

. .

 

. :

1.. 

.

2.

3.) .13.(

, , ,.

 

:

1..

2.

 .

~ 47~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 48/259

3. .

 

. .

 U 4 .

 ).14.(

)15.(

.

 

. ).(

 

.

 

) .16.(

4 ) ( – –.

 .  .

~ 48~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 49/259

 

.

 .  . .. 

).17.(

.

 

. .

 .

 1.)(

 )( 

)( 

.

 

.

 

~ 49~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 50/259

 . 

:

1.

 .

2. 

.

3. ) .18.(

2.

 

. .

 .

 .

)( 

) .19.(

)( .

 

~ 50~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 51/259

 :

1(.

2(.

3(.

4(.

5(.

6( .

7(.

8(.

9(.

 

.)(

 

. .

 

).20(

3.

 . :

1.) .(

2.).(

 

~ 51~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 52/259

)(. 

.  

.

 

.

 . .

 

.

 .

 .

 )( .

 

)( .

 

~ 52~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 53/259

 .

 .

 

).( )

 () .21.(

.

 . 

. 1993–2003 :

 1

: – –20065

5 )2005.(

~ 53~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 54/259

~ 54~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 55/259

 185 

)15–24(

~ 55~ 

1993 2003

 3129

 2221

 1921

 1217

 1315

 915

89

 57

 1715

 1214

0 20 40

1993

2003

 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 56/259

. .115 19901,22004.64

 2015).22.(

.

 

) .23.(

:

1.

 

. .

2.)(

 :

1..

2..

3..

4..

~ 56~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 57/259

 

.

 

. :

1( )()

.(

2(

 

.

3( .

4(.

5( 

.

6( .

 , , )( 

.

 .

 , .

 . . 

, ),.(

~ 57~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 58/259

 

..

 

.:

 60 )1999-2004.(

 20%. 

40%16 .10%5%15%21%4%24%39%42%38.%

6 . 

1999  2004 

39%)24.(

80%20% . 

)1–5.(

6

 ,),( , -2006,Hwww.uis.unesco.orgH.

~ 58~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 60/259

 

.) 2002(

 

:1.

 

.

2. 

.

3..

 :

1..

2. ..

3.

.4.,)25.(

86,6%)1,51,3 .(

 )12–24 (

 . 

~ 60~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 61/259

 .)26.(

.

 

2007 

) .()40(

 

.

 )

 .( 

:

 3

:2005,.

 

)(

 195519951965

~ 61~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 62/259

 

)(

195519951985

 10

196520101979

197020152022

 10

197520352028

199520402028

 

201020452040

201820452040

 )3(, ).(

 )( ).(

 ).(

 .

 

. 1990,

2005. , , )( 20.%)(

 60%199032%

 2000. 851000421000.

~ 62~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 63/259

 .

~ 63~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 64/259

 

.) (

 2020. )6.( 1950,1990)2,5

 .(1990 2020)27.(

1

56,7

12,89,39,7

6,2 5,3

58,2

18,58,9

6,34,2 3,7

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

 

1990 2020

. .

 20078 )3,3

 (2030

 )5.(220  19002.842000..93

 80.

 200020301.36 2.64294742394

8

 2007.  :Hhttp://www.unfpa.org/swp/H

~ 64~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 65/259

 609.80 2030.

 .

 

. ) .28.(

. )(

 

.

 )( .

 

.

 

2030. 

.

 4)10(

~ 65~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 66/259

 

1990

 

2000

 

2010

 

2030

33364250

33384456

68727578

 71767986

 76808287

70707273

 2

:2006–

~ 66~ 

0

10

20

3040

50

60

70

80

90

 

1990

 

2000

 

2010

 

2030

 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 67/259

 )4(20002030)18,14(

 )6,10,7,3(

) :18+14) – (6+10+7+3=(42–26=61.

)29.(

. )( . :

.•

 .

•.

•..

•.

 

. .

 

. .

 . .

 

U F9FU :

9 ,,)14 –16 – (6 –2005.

~ 67~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 68/259

1(

 .

 . )(

 . .

2(

 

.

3(

 

.

4(

 .

5(

 

)30.(

.

  )820(20002002:

 5

: Global Empliyment trends 820, january 2003 p.850.

~ 68~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 69/259

 2000

 2002

 3,84,2

 3,24,5

 6,06,5

 6,16,9

 9,79,9

 17,918,0

 13,714,4

 )(

13,513,5

 :

1( .

2( ,.

3( 

.

4( .

5( 

.

~ 69~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 70/259

6(.

 

.

 

, .

 

. .:1.

 

.

2.

 

. .

 )  ( 

.,,.

 

~ 70~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 71/259

 . :

1.

 

. .

2.

 .

 

. )(

 .

3.

 

.. 

.

4. 

36) .31.(

~ 71~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 72/259

 . .

 .

 . )(

 .

 

. " ""

 " :

1..

 .

2.

 .

3.

 .

4.

 80% ).32.(

, , , ) .(

 :

•, , ), () .33.(

 

.  .

~ 72~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 73/259

 8   0  

 9   6  

 5  7  

 8   6  

7  7  

7   9  

7   3  

 9  1  

7   0  

 8   0  

 5   9  

 6   6  

 3  1  

 3  7  

4  4  

 5  2  

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700

 

44 52

31 37

59 66

70 80

73 91

77 79

57 86

 

6

 :1992.

 :

 .

 .

 . 

. .

 :

1(.

2(.

~ 73~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 74/259

3(.

4( 

.

5( .

 .

 

.

 

.

 

.

 .

 100.

).(  

) .34.(

~ 74~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 75/259

. .

 

)1,8()200 (2015.

 )1,9. (

 

41% 2015) .35.(

.70% .

 

).36.(

. .

 

, .

 

. .

 28%

 .

 

~ 75~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 76/259

 

20%) .37.(

~ 76~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 77/259

 

70,7

59,357,8

54,649,2

44,7 40,837 36 33,2

25

0

 )( .

 .

 . . )(.

 .

 .

 50

 . .

 7

:2005..

~ 77~ 

70,749,236,0

59,344,733,2

 57,840,825,054,637,0

 3

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 78/259

 

. .

 .

 )(. 

.

 ) (

 .

 

. .

 )( 

.2005 )()

40%(.. 

. .

 

.

 .

~ 78~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 79/259

 

.

 

. .

 

. , )(20% 20%..

 ) .38.(

10 20%44%.

 98% ..

 819902003

19902003

 18%25%

 13%17%

 8%9%

 6%8%

~ 79~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 80/259

19902003

 5%7%

 5%6%

 )15–59.(

 )(

 .16

 )1960 –1990( 

19.)(35 .16

 .

~ 80~ 

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

1990 2003

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 81/259

 

20% 86%.20%

1,3) %39.(

199038.61.

2177  2236.

 500 5%

)(416.

 

2015

 :1.

.

2.800.

3.47.

 

:

1(.

2(.

3(.

4(.

~ 81~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 82/259

5( 

.

6( .

7( .

8( .

~ 82~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 83/259

 

)(

~ 83~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 84/259

 

)(

 

)(

 

)( 

.

 600.–300.

.. 

)500–700(.300.500..

 

.

 . 

.

 )80(.

 

).40.(

~ 84~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 85/259

 .

 

.

 .

 .

 .

 .

 . 

.

 

.  – –

)41.(

~ 85~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 86/259

 10 " 

."

 

.:

 

.•

 .

 .

 

) .42.(

( ) 1981

 ).43.(

)(

 

10

 « » .

~ 86~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 87/259

.

 )(

 . 

) .44.(

).45.()( 11 

( )" 1.8

 ." 

18 

.

 . )(

 . .

 

.

 

"" "Brain Drain."

11 .

~ 87~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 88/259

 

.

 

)(200 3%. 

.

 

. :

 :

 . 

. :

 )(.( ) 

.1960-1987850

 )46.(2000:

 9 2000.

:Adams, Jr,Docquier and Marfouk cited by Richard H Migration,Remittances and development: The critical Nexus in the Middle East and

North Africa, Un, Beriut,2006,p.9.

~ 88~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 89/259

 

8

 

9–12

 

13

76,79,214,1100

18,322,658,9100

17,0024,558,6100

34,826,638,6100

14,727,657,6100

16,428,055,6100

11,920,267,8100

30,425,144,5100

22,923,054,1100

70,616,512,9100

21,915,462,7100

15,215,269,6100

13,422,064,6100

31,024,744,3100

73,012,114,9100

 16,815,867,3100

 15,829,155,0100

~ 89~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 90/259

 

8

 

9–12

 

13

 

33,731,934,5100

 ( )

 

2000  

) .47.(

:)(,,2000.

 ,

 . 

, .10%

 6%).48.(

).49.(

~ 90~ 

50

2315

0

20

4060

 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 91/259

 

" 12

 8."

 96 

6576

 . 5

.

 )( 

.

 

.. 

.

 .

 .

~ 91~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 92/259

 .

 

.

 

:

 200.

 450.

•5.4% .

700,600.318

 4500.

•75%,. ,

2000.

•20 ).50.(

~ 92~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 93/259

 

)(

 

. .

 

.

 

.  

.

 

.

~ 93~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 94/259

 

. .

 

. :

1..

 

. .

 . 

1991–1998 735067%23%

 ,.

2..

 2003

 1785%  .20042006 

3200 10%32)51.(

3..

 

.

~ 94~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 95/259

 

.

 

.)52.(

)( 

.

 

:

1..

2. .

 . 

. 12 

. " "

 "2006 "136 130.

 1,2 850.

12 19892001 859%116.%

 ..2001 .

 2.5.9661.3

~ 95~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 96/259

 : ""China: TheNext Science Superpower 

 20202050. 

20102.2.%

 24)23( 1215.)53.(

3. 

.

4. 

.

 .

 20041520.% 20036.2%

 12,2.%3.% 201025

 60% .

 2005 .70

 3%7%

 )54.(

~ 96~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 97/259

 .

 250

 .80% 50%2005. 

.

 10

 

6.98.8%4.615.1%

6.98.8%

2.5410.6%

2.5310%

1.925.7%

1.3935.1%

1.15.6%

70025.6%

252%

60015.4%

3301%

28510%

2437.9%

21926.6%

2053.3%

15520.7%

~ 97~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 98/259

 

900.7%

200.5%

101.1%

: 13-27/2008-20//1429

 

. :1.

 .

 

.

2. 

.

3.. 

.

4.

 

.

5.,, .

13 ): (

 :www.annabaa.orghttp://www.annabaa.org/nbanews/70/005.htm

~ 98~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 99/259

 

1.:

 

.  .

 ) .55.(

.

 

.

 2004 ""

 500)56.(

2.:

 .

 

~ 99~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 100/259

 . 

.  .

 

19604,615,7199434.

25% 70) %57.(

. :

 -

 .:

 .

•.

 .

~ 100~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 101/259

•. .

 -

 

-:•

 .

 .

 .

 .

 

.  ,, ,.

 

)58.(

2007 

14 .

 4.

 11

~ 101~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 102/259

 1995 –2005

 152,80080%

 38,20020%

 191100%

 . .

 

1000.) =152,800,000*1000= (

1528,000,000,00. .

 ).(

 .

 .

 . :

•5.

•.

•,)59.(

~ 102~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 103/259

 

)( .

 "" . :

 -:

 

.:

1.. 

.2..

 

 –)(

 .

 

)()60.(

~ 103~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 104/259

 )61.(

:

1(

 .2(

 ).(

3( 

.

 )( 

. .

 

. .

 .

 

.

 

"–" 

1970–1975. 

)62.(

, )

 .(

.:

~ 104~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 105/259

1. .

 .

2.

 .

3. 

.

4.

 

.

5. .

 .

6.

 .

7. 

.

8. 

)( .

 

.

~ 105~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 106/259

 

:1.

 .

2. 

. ,

 " 1963. 1967)"63.(

2005. 

.

3..

4. .

5. 

.

~ 106~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 107/259

~ 107~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 108/259

 

~ 108~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 109/259

 

.

 

" " 

""  

. .

 . .

 "" 

.

~ 109~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 110/259

 .

 . " "1792-1750". "

 .

 "" " ".

 

" "" "" " . " "

 1968  :

•)102(1974 .

•)118(1974 .

 . . ) .64.(

1280.

 1908192319271936 .1956

 1958 19686

 .2006/2007 )25()18(.

~ 110~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 111/259

 

1970 .

 .

 1991

 .

 126 33 

.5.

 . 

.

 4

 56.2

338. .

 . "

.".

 

.

 

12 .

 ,( ),,,,,, ,,.

~ 111~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 112/259

 

""

 .

 

2003. 

. .

 

45.6837720012002)

 (7600619911992. )45(

 7%580566.)65.(2000 5.7.%

4-5 

1.0014.

14

 1.00  1.00.

~ 112~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 113/259

 200015.8% 0.99." "15 .

2003 /2004627 

94%60%)(16.

 . 34%.)66.(

15 –. 2003/2004–.

16 .30%

 30% 

.)2003/2004– .(

~ 113~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 114/259

 12 17

 /

 

- -

 

- -

 

- -

 

- -

47461732080

 31256918130

29290223040

26233219221

1313101016221

 /

2363511021230

 / 145450137430

 / 229290322031

24204712131

38317718670

17

 :,,  2005.

~ 114~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 115/259

 /

 

- -

 

- -

 

- -

 

- -

18171013051

343310131290

31292521050

1212015330

25250022021

 28262017191

1313005251

545041523781

1311208320

353230161351

282620101350

627588397937172969

 2003–2004 90.966

 90% 

. :

~ 115~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 116/259

 1318

 

0.0480.0452857.60327

 0.0420.0363323.0129

0.0620.0581493.27522

0.0330.0282612.991110.0620.0597291150716

0.0410.0382283.46715

0.0370.0352803.55713

0.0510.0461623.46915

0.0610.0561923.64619

0.0570.0572773.31512

0.0360.030571.28723

0.0350.0311762.15312

 0.0320.0272692.97111

0.0230.020881.09312

18 :2003–2004,, –2005.

~ 116~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 117/259

0.0650.0563937.02518

0.0870.0851542.49516

0.1120.1055009.44519

0.0650.0616046.81811

5.85690.96616

 

1:271:9.

 

) .67.(

:

 200020014.031.34655.94%

 44.06.%11709 190650.

2000 109.6%1999–2000

 200080.9%

83.8%92.9%2000. 0.82%

.616 .400.000

 17.0%

~ 117~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 118/259

 2000.19 2000.

 2003/2004.

 14 20

 

430.2541.02

 180.8570.96

139.2401.00

218.7550.91

1.018.7810.98

225.6211.02

236.5390.94

127.8690.99

163.2471.02

134.6870.89

80.0150.86

133.3540.82

 229.8150.94

19 –. 2003/2004–.

20

 :2003–2004,,  –2005

~ 118~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 119/259

 

98.7550.79

305.5411.06

165.3562.16

219.4780.98

225.4450.81

4.334.6090.98

 0.982000 . 4.334.609

 2003/2004 2000

 . 23%

 

. .

 . 

.

 .

 .

 :

•.

~ 119~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 120/259

•.

•.

•.

•.•.

 200025% 25%

 50% .

 . 

)(.

 .

 200020011.291.3091.063.842)

61.2%39.8(%227.467) 57.1%42.9(%. 224%600315197119721023842

 19901991.106384220002001.

 200038.3%0.62

 

69.5%59.9% 77.5.%

 

. 1.03 

~ 120~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 121/259

 .2003/2004. 21.

 15 2003/200422

21 –. 2003/2004.

22

 :2003–2004,,  –2005.

~ 121~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 122/259

~ 122~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 123/259

~ 123~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 124/259

~ 124~ 

111.4090.31

 57.3680.36

48.4120.41

79.4830.40

455.0570.51

64.4810.34

72.6590.34

38.5090.34

50.0080.37

41.1480.32

16.1090.21

41.6110.30

 73.7360.36

27.2430.26

106.2780.43

60.2970.92

97.4640.51

129.9160.55

1.571.2880.42

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 125/259

 42% 2000

 2000. .

 5.78%12741319961997227467

 20002001. .1997

 

. 38.3%

 1999200047%19901991. 1999200034.4%

 22.4% 2000200124.8%

21.7%.

 .

 . 

.:

•.

 2003.

 12042000200110976.4043

 2001200224%19961997.. 

~ 125~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 126/259

 .

 .

 

23 2006.

2003/20049%

 5%23% .

 

78% 24 2003/2004.

 2000200173989 6284011149.

 99%)5001000()540.(

 .

23 .200531%37%36%45%2007 .! 2007

 "", ,

.

24 ––68"."

 2003/2004– .

~ 126~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 127/259

 .

 .

 

.

 

. .

 .  )10(%. 2000200165750

 618613889 12449719911992

 50%. 78.4%38.3%

 37.8%278236.

 1625

 /

4613.606

5000542

4511.989

 158

25

 :2003–2004,,  –2005.

~ 127~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 128/259

 /

17863.707

 1204 2000200110976.

40432001200224%19961997.

 .1978

 15 45

.15 4548%19789.19%1987

 . .19941995

 

.1995121718884)700017 .

 71%45.%»

«1535»«1015

 . 

)19901991()19981999( 9432388 1124.

~ 128~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 129/259

 

.

 

1280. .19

)3(9)(38)11.( 20012002

 31799329729220701 14743131671576.

 4 56.

2338..

 . ..

 

.

 

12 .( )

 .

 

. 1.4

% 2.28%63.39%.

 1996. :

~ 129~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 130/259

 171996

 

707304470983605543204205221015220

80965015496049583546244429

230909348105757312043112855

446819149780279242157652

1254227371220250659087131

4270826851684752653495217016

29383585250273468865

793502600484914034928

243706414861529089

367701747778578680

1343857522299955702226244808

295201469121329418150

 

:

 18

~ 130~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 131/259

 

6.96%4.40%82.35%4.25%2.02%

33.12%063.39%2.02%1.04%

20.45%0.8%71.82%5.78%1.08%

7.74%0.33%86.84%4.84%0.73%

5.84%0.23%91.09%2.27%0.090%

19.67%1.23%77.63%1.22%0.22%

22.71%074.45%2.43%0.4%

:

•1996 "" 

.

 

.

 

.

~ 131~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 132/259

 2004 

)1995 –1996( 26 :

 19

 

),,(

 )(

 )(

906,61079,9001,191

157,7358,0002,270

75.8216.4002.855

36.562.7001.717

81.9251.3003.067

172.6186.8001.082

4.243.10010.351

24.7279.70011.313

4.875.90015.701

26

 ""2004.. -

~ 132~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 133/259

 

),,(

 )(

 )(

7.557.4007.620

231.42.283.0009.868

14.4126.1008.731

224.2484.6002.161

65.7135.5002.055

254.6372.2001.462

93.3180.0001.930

107.766.900621

~ 133~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 134/259

 

),,(

 )(

 )(

110.756.500511

1.81.800978

9.18.900974

4.62.400517

 .

 .:

~ 134~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 135/259

 20 27

 1950197319932003

3257181211313619

0005051201214014

000101581381018

0000331782911

101303404505

000000202202

27 : 2004.

~ 135~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 136/259

 1950197319932003

000101101123

000000101112

000101101101

000404707808

000000101257

1013031301326026

0002021101114014

1013031301313114

~ 136~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 137/259

 1950197319932003

10120260681422

0002021601627128

0001014267815

000000101101

000000101101

000101101123

~ 137~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 138/259

 

:

 

" ." 

28 ..:

 

.

 .

• .

 .

 

.

28

 5500  .141998.

~ 138~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 139/259

 

:

 

. 29 ) .68.(

 

.

 .

 

.)69.(

 .

 

)7350(:

29 " ".."."

 . " ".

 . "")50%.()30%(

( ). .

 ." "

 .

~ 139~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 140/259

 .

 .

 2004 86%5% ."" 30 "

 60074%" 21%

24%.)70.(

 . 

. .

 .

 2007:

•( ) 

.

 

. 2007

30 .

~ 140~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 141/259

 

2007 .)71.(

 , , 

2003. 1982

 2003. 31 1982–2003:

 21)

1982 –2003(.

19824730199315204

19834212199412937

19843488199518672

19853185199627139

19863157199743187

19872003199841516

31 ""

 1996"" .

~ 141~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 142/259

19882350199936560

19893901200047184

199013473200150763

199111629200251005

199217658200324700

 22 

)1980-1989) / (1990-1999(

 1980-19891990-1999

6002220

7506050

901510

 _ 560

1010

~ 142~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 143/259

 1980-19891990-1999

 _ 850

 _ 1290

200010690

784025200

4005530

5602210

20850

394055050

 21309710

53011250

5606450

 _ 1490

67036430

465013700

 24750191040

 23)1990 –2001().(

~ 143~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 144/259

 

1990-1,11331,4-3,8----

1991-1,218428,032,94,0-20,0--

1992-1,250111,427,75,4-19,92,84,7

1993-645,04,924,035,5-20,03,19,3

1994-613,02,718,036,36,720,03,614,4

1995-595,53,313,033,97,31,74,218,0

1996-579,23,09,726,88,22,04,720,6

1997-570,80,75,721,18,01,65,125,4

1998-530,61,05,419,46,61,76,022,319998,8510,00,65,43,46,01,86,419,4

20009,8386,00,65,21,85,81,29,519,3

200110,0386,00,65,11,76,00,312,019,1

 

) .72.(

 

~ 144~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 145/259

 .

 . 

.

 . 

.

 1280.

 .19)3(9)(38)11

.(20012002

31799329729220701 14743131671576.

 .1959 

.

 1419581956 1967

 1974.

 81414/10/1987 

)40100( 

.

 

.)19632003(

 .

 1970 

..

~ 145~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 146/259

 

) .73.(

2003 

)(. 

--) .(

 85% 

2000153 532 4469160

 .

 . 

). (

 32) .74.(

.

 .  .

32 --2004 152004)Dr. John

Agresto("" 

.( )

~ 146~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 147/259

 24 33.

2351606944

1161103434

37472710589

 34 

:1.95%5%.

2. 74%

 .

3.62%4%

 1% 17%.

4. " " 59%

 ""13% 6%6% 

2%.

5.

 57%14%11%6%5%  4% 1) . %75.(

. .

33 :–822007.

34 

~ 147~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 148/259

 .

 ) .

76.(

)77.(25

.

 

1023

 373

 282

 345

 1525

 1328

 10327

 774

~ 148~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 149/259

 55500

 92

 

. .

 ) .78.(

( ) 

. :

 .

 .

•.

•) (.

 

.

 

.

 

.

~ 149~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 150/259

 19682003

 )(

 .

 

..

 1970 

.. 

. .

 .

 :

−( ):

.•

 .

 .

−( ) :

 .

 

.

 

~ 150~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 151/259

 .

 .

 

( ) .

 . 

.

 " "

. . 

. .

 .

 ) .79.(

, " ,," ",,. " 

.

~ 151~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 152/259

 80% 200340%

 40%1990.

 

. 230. 182.

 

2006172 )3000. (

 300.200680%

 35 

.

 

"" 

35 5%. 

2000 .

 

4001002003.

~ 152~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 153/259

 

.

1(

 3.4

 ).(

 3800166

 .661  24

 . .)80.(

2(

 38.3%

 )19992000(47%  )19901991.( 

200 650 .

 .

3(

 )2000–2001( 65750618613889 124497

 )19911992(50% 78.4.%

 38.3%37.8% )1991–2001.(

 278236. )66317(

)2005–2006.(50%)19911992(

~ 153~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 154/259

 18.2% 74%23.7% 1.5%0.8% 9.9%)73579(

.

 )4966()2005–2006(8.9%

 85% 13.8%0.8% 0.4%

 6.4% )4669(.

 )20904(

)2005-2006(25.2.%  67.9.% 29.2%0.8%

 2.1% 44.1) .%

81.(

4(

 .

 

42/32005 36 .

 . 1/620062/6

.15%25%.

 

50%2002 

36 .

 ( ) .:

 ..

~ 154~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 155/259

 .

.

 

50%. 

. )1000(

 37 

.

5(

 38 

37

 41. "

 ."( ))(

 .

38 « » » .«»

 .«- 

.  .

~ 155~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 156/259

 

.

6(

 

. 39 "

 ". 

.   –

).82.(

40 ) .83.(

7(

 

. ""

 .

8(

39 . ./2006.

40 « »192007.

 2004. 4001002003.

~ 156~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 157/259

 41 

.

 60

 )( .

 

70%. 

2003 

2003 

)9(15% ) .84.(

.  .

 

41 ""

 .

 27  20.

~ 157~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 158/259

 . .

 

.

 2004 

).85.(

2007)7.5(

 )7.5(-: 26 42.

 

1453.33

42 :2007

~ 158~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 159/259

 

2113.33%

35107.16%

42102.95%

52002.81%

61502.11%

1502.11%

81201.69%

97098%

1

0

 5577%

11

 5070%

12

 5070%

~ 159~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 160/259

 

13 

5070%

14

 4056%

15

 3042%

16 3042%

17

 2028%

18

 1014%

19

 1014%

20

 57%

21

 507%

 ).86.(

9(

 2007 

~ 160~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 161/259

 

:

 

.

 

28200543 9739.1082007

 44.

 .

 2007

43 ( ) )(97

%.»«»

 

«»94%. .«

44 »«

.» .

 . 34.

~ 161~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 162/259

 

) .87.(

~ 162~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 163/259

 

2003 . 

.

 19913600  166. 12. 

3.4 ).(

 3800166) .88.(

5500. 

.

 19974372. 

~ 163~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 164/259

 .661 

24. 

.

 

.

 1990.

 .1989 75) %

 70(%1991  20%1987.

 5%1989 3.8.%)6-23(53.%

 83%861310334. 7004500.

1980. 

. 9569219901316581999.)89.(

~ 164~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 165/259

 .

 :

 

. 200650

 . 6.1%3.1%

 .

 

199967% 92.5%

 199719981298567 19981999.

 19971998 12206126394

.51328613 1000. 

62.% . 19901995 )8917(19901991)3,328,212()8035(

19941995)3,277,387(. )19992000()3,634,095(. 

.

 198919901999

2000.

 27 45.46

45 :. ","".

46 –,2001.

~ 165~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 166/259

  –-

  –-

  –-

1989/

1990

59673335772442

1990/9156326390782898

1991/9293750486053260

1992/9367706527314085

1993/9471705493743803

1994/9586412584654079

1995/9689531530564969

1996/9775217511255316

1997/9872598425645131

1998/9970185376075746

1999/200071092379767098

 

. 47 

1999/2000)484()3098(. "

 .

47

 . .,".2003.

~ 166~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 167/259

 " " 

.)90.(

.

 .

 2,43,7 178.%

 :

 . .

 .

 ).91.(

)7-19(1987)442349(91,7%8,3. %1990

 

).92.(

~ 167~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 168/259

 "

 1999/2000)484()3098" (.

 

." "  

. "

 )93.(

)83.1(%2006)MICS-3()3.6(%2005

 )86.2(%.2004)86.6(%)88.5(%2001

 )80.3(%2000, 1997)90.5(%

1997 .

 28 48

199

7

199

8

199

9

200

0

200

1

200

2

200

4

200

5

200

6

 90.5

83.5

84.3

80.3

88.5…

86.6

86.2

83.1

 36%

 3,1.% . .

 . 

48

 , :,,  ,,12132007.

~ 168~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 169/259

 . 

. .

 

.  1992/199359,5% 52,2%

 . 1997/

199868%62%.

 49 .

 

)( 

:

 .

 .

•.

 .

.

 

.

 .

49 /2001.

~ 169~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 170/259

 

.

 .

 

.  .

 .

 

2008 50. :

•"" 

. 51.

 " " " "

 ".".

50 ..

 1Z16631.

51 )1192(16/9/1978".")1225(10/9/1981"

."  .

~ 170~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 171/259

 .

 " "

 .

•" " 

.

•" " " "

 .""  .

 .

•.

 .

 " " .

 

.)94.(

80.%

~ 171~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 172/259

 

.

 .  

. .

 

.

 

. 52 

/1990.

. )95.(

52

 . .

~ 172~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 173/259

 )25(%1997)20(%1991.

 19882006:

 2953 

1988

46.9%

199

3

50.2%

1002

61.7%

2005

 43.8%

1990. 1520%.

 .

 . .

 

1993 .1993.

 1990/1991.

 350019907611993) .96.(

53 :12132007.

~ 173~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 174/259

 90%90.

 . 

.

 1999.

 30

 

96.859 199

0 9.8 947.974 199

1

 16.4 1576.194

1994

 19.7 1910.30

8

199

8

 

.2002-2001

45% 

. . 

) .97(

)(

 .

~ 174~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 175/259

 .

 

. 18%45) .%98.(

. 7

 

"".

 " "90%

. 3001991.

 1991

 1500199090%

7 416

 250.1991

 70% 1.5.

 2002 .126

 2533

 68

~ 175~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 176/259

 3125 84.

 250300 

.

 "" "

 "- 30054 

" " .

 

.

 

. "

 """

. " "

 

)( ""2002 

.

54 "."

~ 176~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 177/259

 "

".""" .

 

. 55) .99.(

200222.6% 19901998. 

2000 83.8%61%

1970 .

 

0.58119800.7511990 76

 0.5811998 126174 47139( )110

 111 /2003.

2003)2.2(   –).100.(

55 89,24:

 89 –"."

 24 –""  15."

~ 177~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 178/259

~ 178~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 179/259

 

~ 179~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 180/259

 

.

 . 

.

 "

 ." 56 "

 . ."

 

. . 

.

 

.

 

.

56 

~ 180~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 181/259

 . 

.

 

.

 ..57 

:

 =XX.

 =.

 = .

 ).101.(

"."

 

2003. .

 

2003. 2002""58 ")( "

 : ."

57 " .- "- .

58 "".

~ 181~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 182/259

 --15" ""59."

 "60 """1993 

." "

 199019991215

 2% 112

 14 . 

)1441( 

.

 52 

:" 

." 

.

 .

 .

500 

"" .""

 

59 2003.

60 .

~ 182~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 183/259

 " .

 

.

~ 183~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 184/259

 

.

 . 42464195731000 74. %258971965).102.(

"" 2003.).

103.(

31 61

19824730199518672

19834212199627139

19843488199743187

19853185199841516

19863157199936560

19872003200047184

19882350200150763

19893901200251005

199013473200324700

61 : 16- -2007.

~ 184~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 185/259

199111629200410883

199217658200513613

199315204200622155

1994129372007

 

)( 

. , ),(:

 32

 

1982473017%

1983421215.5%

1984348812.9%

1985318511.6%

1986315711.6%

198720037.4%

198823508.6%

1989390114.4%

~ 185~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 186/259

 

27026100%

33

 

1990134733.4%

1991116293%

1992176584.5%

1993152043.9%

1994129373.3%

1995186724.8%

1996271397%

19974318711%

19984151610.7%

1999365609.4%

20004718412%

20015076313%

20025100513%

386927100%

34

~ 186~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 187/259

 

20032470034.6%

20041088315.25%

20051361319%

20062215531%

2007

71351

 

2004. 2001.

 .

 

: 16- /2007.

~ 187~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 188/259

 2006–2007 37 

62.

 35 2006–200763

 20062007

219504396765917

 147181777332491

64061331419720

75881103518623

9886797317859

8830890217232

360853698977

284218084650

 21.100

 " "

 )104.(

)COMPETE

AMERICA( 

62 20062007

 37.:http://www.unhcr.org/statistics/STATISTICS/47daae862.pdf 

63 .-–2007.

~ 188~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 189/259

 H-IB64 

.

 

31 ","

 450 

.735019911998.

 4.2

 1991-1995)105.(:

1.

 .3,3%19772%1990-1995

 5%1,4%1977-1997. 6500007%

 1990-199532%.  3,80%1977 2,97%2004

 2,1%)106.(

2.

 

:

•.

•.

64 

..  202007.

~ 189~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 190/259

 .

 

. .

 .

 ) (

 . )450(

 (.  

1998 )47.4(%1995

 )33.4(%)16.6% )

.

3.

 . 65 

.

 .

 

65 .

~ 190~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 191/259

 . 

-- .)107.(

4. 

.:

 .

 .

 .

 

.

 .

 

"."

 . 

.

 )( 336. 

.

 1004.

~ 191~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 192/259

5.

 

""66.

 " 

.  -- 

. 67

 

.

 

45,000 

1989140,000..68 

1750066 

..

67 .

68 , 

.

 .

~ 192~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 193/259

 75004550,45 11253452,45

 .304. % ""

 

)15-20 ()108.(

150 

.

 

.

 

.

 " 

.

 

~ 193~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 194/259

 

.

 ) (

 

––. 

.

 " 

"  .

 "," 

.

 

.

 

.

 

~ 194~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 195/259

 

.

 

.

 

.

 

.

 

) .(

 

~ 195~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 196/259

 

.

 

. . 

.:

 :

 

. . .

 

. :

 = ×

 =×.

 

. =×

 =×

 =+

 = +

~ 196~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 197/259

 

)( .:

•:

 =×.

 =×

 =+ +

 = ++

• :

 =×.

 =×

 =+

 ++ .

 = +++.

 

:

 )(

 .:

 =× .

 =×

~ 197~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 198/259

 =+ ++

 +.

 =++++.

−:

 :

4.

6.

 5.

:

 =×.

 =×

 =+ ++

 + +.

 =+++++.

 

:

−:

 =× .

 =×.

 =+ ++

 + ++ .

 =++++++.

~ 198~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 199/259

−:

 =× .

 =×.

 =+ ++

 + ++ +.

 =+++++++ .

 

.69 2004

 )1995 –1996(:

 36 

)1995 –

1996.(

 

80965015496049583546244429

 70.

 37 )95/96(

69 21

70

 21  .

~ 199~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 200/259

 

), ,(

 )(

 )(

157,7358,0002,270*71

 .

 

.  .

 

:

 38

 

) (

--

 7506

 ) (1750*72

371 )/, ,.(

 . ,

 =5500=7500 .

72 )( ... 35006 

33

 =1750  .

~ 200~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 201/259

 

)(17503

 1135732

 )(

2270)4,5,6= (5 74

 )(55003

 )(75005

 .

 75

.

73 4,2270 ÷2=1135.

74 )4( )6()5

.(5)(.

75 .

~ 201~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 202/259

 

. .

 .

 . .

 

.

 

.  

76 "."

 .

76 "–."

 :

http://www.ao-academy.org/wesima_articles/aou_articles-20050613-97.html

~ 202~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 203/259

 :

 :

)17500.(

)7500.(

)25000.(

 39

 

375500

 150150

 ) (

300300

 150150

 1515

 150150 530

 

120120

 30150

 4454 .

~ 203~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 204/259

 

11541589

:" –"

 .

 

:

 ) =× + (+ .

 :

 :

 

. .

 :

 .

 

. .

 .

 175005 

~ 204~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 205/259

 734:

 = ××

 = ( )1154×12=13848  .

 ) =13848×5×17500= (1211700000

 = ( )1589×12=19068 .

 ) =19068×7×7500= (1001070000

 

:

 =× ×=5500×3×17500=288750000 .

 

:

 =××=7500×5×7500=281250000

 :

 

"." 

.. 

.

 .

~ 205~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 206/259

 :

1.

 

. .

 .

 .

 . 

. :

 )} =×× (5×4×12{

.6 5.

.

2.

 

.

 )( :

~ 206~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 207/259

 

7 .)5(

)7. (

)) = ( ××+ (

 + +.

 =)1211700000() +17500×5500×3+ (})17500×750×6) + (17500×1750×3) + (17500×1750×3(

77) +17500×2270×5) + {(5500×3×17500) + (0(78=2250,325,000.

 

)) = ( ××+ (

 + +.

 ) =1001070000+ (})7500×750×6) + (7500×1750×3() +7500×1750×3(79) +7500×2270×5) + {(5500×3×7500

) + (7500×5×7500) + (0(80=1603695000.

77 )17500×750×6) + (17500×1750×3) + (17500×1750×3) + (17500×2270×5(17500.

78 .

79 )7500×750×6) + (7500×1750×3) + (7500×1750×3) + (7500×2270×5(7500.

80 .

~ 207~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 208/259

 

. . 

" "

 .

 

.  

"" 

.

 

.175007500

 .4550.451125 3452.45 304.5%

 .

 

. :

~ 208~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 209/259

1.)(

 ,,

 

.

 =.

2.)(

 

:

 =× .

 81 "

 "

 ))(109.(} =

 +– {.

 :

 ) =÷ × (100.

81 

" ."

 ""–

."  .

~ 209~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 210/259

 

. 82

: 40

 25

–83.

 150300

 30 ,50

900

1200

 25 175007500

 25. :

 

=.

 :

 =300+900=1200 } =+

 – {.

 )} =17500×5500×3) + (7500×5×7500={(570,000,000.

82 .

83 .

~ 210~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 211/259

 25000:

=8 30 =240 84.

 ) =240×5×4×12= (57600

 . 25000=57600×25000=1440000000 .

 ) =570+1440– (1200=810.

 ) =÷(×100.

) =810÷1200× (100=67,5.%

67.5%)(

 25000 .

 .

 

:

84 .

~ 211~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 212/259

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

25000

25000

810

1200

3853

 

1

 ..

 

.

 

.

 

~ 212~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 213/259

 . 

.:

1.

 

.

 

.

 

).110.(

. ":

 " 

) .

111(

.

~ 213~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 214/259

 

.

2.

 

.

 

.

 

" "

 . 

.

3.

 

.

~ 214~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 215/259

 

.

 

. :

 =–)×.(

 )} =× × (.{

 41

 =–)×.(

 )} =× × (.{

=0,=,

>0

<0

~ 215~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 216/259

 .

 .

 

.

 

.4.

 

. .

 .

 

.

5.

 .

 .

 

.

~ 216~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 217/259

6.

 

.

7.

 

. .

 . 

., ,. 

.

 .

 .

8.

 

.

9.

 

.

~ 217~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 218/259

 .

 .

 

:

.

.

 .

 .

 .

 .

.

) .112.(

~ 218~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 219/259

 

~ 219~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 220/259

 

.

 .

 ,. 

:

1. .

2. 

) ().( 

.

3.

 .

~ 220~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 221/259

4., , , , ).(

5. 

.

6. 

.7.

 .

 :

 .

 .•

 .

 .

 .

 .8.

 

.

~ 221~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 222/259

9. 

:

•.

•.

•.

 .

 .

10. 

.

11..

~ 222~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 223/259

 

)(

 

:

 

.

 . 

.

 

.

 . 

.

•,

 .

~ 223~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 224/259

 

.

 . 

.

 . .

 .

 

.

 )(  .

 

.

 

.

 

.

~ 224~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 225/259

 ,

 

.

 .

~ 225~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 226/259

 :

1. )(

 

.

2. .

3. 

.

4. 

.

5.

 .

6. 

.

7.

 . 

.

8. ,

 .

~ 226~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 227/259

 .

 

..

 4. 

.

 

~ 227~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 228/259

 

.

 

.

 

. :

1.

 .

 .), , ,( .

 .

 

)(. 

. )/( 

)(

 .

~ 228~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 229/259

 .) (:

 

:

 

:

 :

 

~ 229~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 230/259

 

).( 

. :

 

.

•. 

. .

 

.

~ 230~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 231/259

•)( )( . ) (

 .

 )(

 )

 .(

 

)()( 

)(.

 

.

2. 

).( .

 

.

3..

~ 231~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 232/259

4. .

5. . 

. .

 . 

.

6. 

.

7. 

)(

 )(.  )(

 

~ 232~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 233/259

 )( ).(

 

.

 

.

 

2006 

.

 

.

 

.:

~ 233~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 234/259

 . 

.

 

.

 

.

 .

 .

 . .

 .

 

.

 ( ) .

•.

~ 234~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 235/259

 .

 .

 .

 .

 .

• .

 .

 .

 .

 .

~ 235~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 236/259

 

.:

 

" ."

 

2003. .

 .

 

.

 .

 

.

•"" 

~ 236~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 237/259

 

.

 

.

 

.

 

.

~ 237~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 238/259

 :

1., , ,,–

-,2000.

2., ,),(,2002.

3., ,,,–,2004.

4.,,),( ,,–,2007.

5., ,),( ,,

 ,2003.

6.,,)( ,

,2008.

7., ,, / –4 22/2006." "

8.,47–73,.

9.,.

10., , ) ,(), (29,

,2006.

11., ,), , , ,,1994.

12., ,),( , –.

13.,,,

 ,14,2004.

~ 238~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 239/259

14.,,.

15., ,, , ),( ,,1992.

16., –,.

 ,,, .

17.,,.

18., ,, , ),(1176,2-8-2007.

19., ,,,, –,11-3-2005.

20., ,,.

21., ,, )

 ,( –,2002.

22.) ,2005,(–2006.

23., ,, ,,15

–8–2007.24.,)

 ,(, -2006,HU www.uis.unesco.org UH.

25.,,2002.

26.2007,,, ,2006.

27., ,,, 

-GCP/SYR/006/ITA, –,2003.

28.,, , –

,2007,:HU www.unfpa.org/ UH 

29.2007,.

~ 239~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 240/259

30., , .

 ,) , ,14–16– (6–2005.

31., ,, ) , ,19–23( –2005.

32., ,,, ,1990.

33.,, 1997,13-173.

34.2007,,,96.

35.,  –,292004.

36.,, ) ,

23–28– (6–2003. ,

37.2005,,,2005.

38.2005,.

39., ,.

40.,,,,1972.

41., ,––,–––23–10–2007.

42., ,, ,,

 10426–11-2004.43., ,,)

260,(. - ,

44., ,.

45.,,, ,. ,

~ 240~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 241/259

46.,,, :

http://www.doroob.com/ , 22 – 3 – 2007.

47.), (,2000.

48.,,,,152– 155,,2000.

49.,,,, ,,4–8/

1985.

50., , , ––2005.

51.,,,, 1024,18--2006.

52.,,:,,,2131,17-4-2007.

53.,,:,,,10286,26––2007.

54.,,,,

 ,8,,/2005.

55.,,..,, ,9792,19––2005.

56.,,,, ,,24–1–2006.

57.,,.

58.,,  ,–,2000.

59.,2007,15––2007.

60.,,, ,–,2004.

61.,, ,,

 ,2,2007.

~ 241~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 242/259

62.,,–,

 .

63.,,.

64.),(,11–4-2008 .65., ,),(,156,

,11–3–2008.

66. 2003/2004,2005

 .

67.2003–2004,

 ,– 2005.

68., ,,,14– –2006.

69., , .

70., ,600,000, 3"2/5 –2006"

, –.

71., ,, , –,2–10–2007.

72.,941,,30–8–2004.

73., ,.

74., ,,,   –,8– –2007.

75.,,, ,http://www.al-

 jalili.com/CONTENT/Public/Doc1/IraqiAcademics_60611.pdf ,,14– –2007.

76.,, –, , 2137,22–12–2007.

~ 242~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 243/259

77., ,,,2007.

78., ,)12,( , –,13–8–2007.

79., ,.80.,,.

81.2003 –2004, , –2005.

82.,," ,"27/2007.

83.,, ,5–9–2007.

84.,, –, 

,2007.

85.,,, , ,3102004.

86.,2007  .

87., ,.

88.,– –) –,(

 ,7–12–2004.

89.1991,.

90.,,,,.

91., 

1995.

92.,/2001.

~ 243~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 244/259

93.,,, ,,12132007.

94.1975.

95.,.

96.,. ,

97.,, 

""30/1/2008,.

98., ,, ,

 17182008  ,

99.,,,242000.

100.,, ,,1830

2005,, .

101.,,, ,––––,17–

6–2007.

102., ,-,1980.

103. 16- -2007.

104.-

 ,138-10–2006.105.24–-

2006.

106.,,.

107.,: ,.4––2008.

108.,,,,

 , –.

~ 244~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 245/259

109.,,.

110.,,, 34,20–4–2007.

111.,,,

 ,10–6–2007, –.112.,.

~ 245~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 246/259

 

Conway, G.R., and Barbier, E.B., 1990. After the Green Revolution:

Sustainable Agriculture for Development . London: Earthscan: pp. 16- 26.

~ 246~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 247/259

•) ,2005(

  –2006.•,)

 ,(, -2006,HU www.uis.unesco.org UH.

•2002.

•2007)( 2006.

  –2007.

•1997 .

•2007 

96.

•, –, –,29- 2004.

•, ,

 )23–28– ( –2003. ,

•2005 2005.

•), (,2000.

•,2007,15––2007.

 2003/2004,2005 .

•"",172007.

~ 247~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 248/259

•2007.

•2006 .

•/2001.

~ 248~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 249/259

 

.:

 

1996/1997 

. :

 = ×

 =×=0×2=0.

 =×=244429×750×6=1099,930,500

. =+

 

= + =0+1099930500.

 :

 =×.

 =×=244429×1750×3=1,283,252,250 .

 =+ +

 = ++=0+1099930500+1283252250=2,383,182,750.

 :

 =×.

~ 249~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 250/259

 =×=244429×1750×3=1,283,252,250 .

 =+ ++

 . = +++=0+1099930500+1283252250+

1283252250=3666435000

 

.

 =×=80965×1135×2=183790550

 =+)+ ()

 + ( )+(.

 =×

 =++++.

 =0) +80965×750) + (80965×1750) + (80965×1750+ (183790550=386364980

 :

 =×.

 =×=154960×2270×5=1788796000

. =

+)+ ( )+ ( )

 +(.

 =++++=0) +154960×750×6() +154960×1750×3) + (154960×1750×3+ (1788796000=

4113196000.

~ 250~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 251/259

 :

 :

 =× .

 =× ×=5500×3×4958=81807000

 =+)+(

 )+ () + ( )

(85 +)+ ( .

 =++++++.

 =0) +4985×750×6) + (4985×1750×3) + (4985×1750×3) + (4985×2270×5(

) + ×(86+81807000=213161750.

 :

 =× .

 =××=7500×5×3546=132975000

 =+ )+(

 )+ () + ()

+()+ (  )+ (.

 =+++++++.

85 

. -.

86 .

~ 251~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 252/259

 =0) +3546×6×750) + (3546×3×1750) + (3546×3×1750) + (×

(87) +3546×5×2270) + (3546×3×5500+ (132975000=284921100.

 

:

 

8096515496049583546244429

 /3863649

8041131960

002131617

502849211

0049976438

30

 

)( 

.""  .

87 .

~ 252~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 253/259

 

~ 253~ 

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 254/259

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 255/259

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 256/259

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 257/259

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 258/259

7/16/2019 Master-Brain Drain of

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/master-brain-drain-of 259/259