An Evaluation of Small-Scale Freshwater Rural Aquaculture ...
178
AN EVALUATION OF SMALL-SCALE FRESHWATER RURAL AQUACULTURE DEVELOPMENT FOR POVERTY REDUCTION OPERATIONS EVALUATION DEPARTMENT
Transcript of An Evaluation of Small-Scale Freshwater Rural Aquaculture ...
-
! "#!
! !! $
%& !'!!(!!!
)*+,-./0.//1
2 * +,.-3
2!"
4 556662
-
! "#
$%&'$%&( #)'*+*() $%&
*+*,-&-./, #0
123+%4)&'(563'(578 8955*:4$'&(.+'(&;'.($5'.(6.'$65*(87*;9568
$%&) ,
,$
+)*%78*%9%7)
-
!"#"$ !##%!"' !()$#!*+ ,+"+-###%!"
"! #.-"/#%#, + "!"+012+-%$# !0#"/0. + "!2 $#"+0#$3#%-""-+,"+-#4
# "+-#$.#-"15!$!$.+!#- "16
!"#!$%& %" $$#"$7
- !$.-&!8-,#$$#$5+",$95
'%%()%#'*&+)%!,-.)/!0*
%#- "!8$($29%%-%- "#!#$$.#$8! !0#,/!8122%#- "!8#*+-#!"$22
%%1
9./'%2')/!0-&
' ,(8-+!027, !$!$.+- #-"1:;-#$/< "#-*+ ,+"+-#1$"#&$:9-#$/< "#-$/ -(#"$:4&%1!":5'+%%-""-#$/< "#-*+ ,+"+-###%!":5 .#8+ -0!8-#$/< "#-*+ ,+"+-#:7#$$!$# -!#03 1$"# ,/"/#-39
)%#+3#-11' ,(8-+!033#"/0$ !0+-,#$35'%/1$, # "+-#$."/# $#"+01-# 35$/ -&!8#,/!81 !0 ! 8#!"36#/0$$#"$37 -(#"$ !0 -(#"!88#!"$42!,+$!$43
+))%(4-55' ,(8-+!044#"/0$ !0+-,#$45$/ -&%#- "! !0 ! 8#!"45-.#.& =, #$/ --$5;
-
./)/!0$ 1' ,(8-+!053$"-154-0+,"! !0!$+&%"!55-,#$> -8!$> $","1> !0 -&!,$56,,#$$!8!%+"$.- % -&!86;,,#$$!8+%%-"#-,#$64 -(#"!8 % 65#$$!$# -!#07;
)%$#+"&*' ,(8-+!079'%/1$, / - ,"#-$",$72,#,!&, !0!$""+"! #-$%#,"#$7:
#,/!81 !0 ! 8#!"74-.#. % --$;;
- !$.-&!8-,#$$#$;9 "+- #$+-,#$ ! 8#!";3!-!!";4$/?+ "1;5-$$ !0%!8"- "#8#$;6+",$;6!,+$!$;6
$#)%+6$-7' ,(8-+!0;'%/1$, / - ,"#-$",$,#,!&, !0!$""+"! ""-+"#$9
#,/!81 !0 ! 8#!"2-.#$. % 8# !0+-$#-1 --$5
- !$.-&!8-,#$$#$7 "+- #$+-,#$ ! 8#!"92!-!!"9:$/?+ "194-$$ !0%!8"- "#8#$94+",$94!,+$!$95
./'%2')/!0$*8' ,(8-+!096$"-, ##%!"2;'%/1$, # "+-#$2
#,/!81 !0 ! 8#!"2,,#$$!8 -(#"$22
/##$.#-!!"!*+ ,+"+-#"#!$!2:&&+!"1=' $#0+- *+ ,+"+-###%!"23##%!",1.-& =, #-#$/< "#-*+ ,+"+-#24 .#8+ -0$.--#$/< "#-*+ ,+"+-#25#$$!$# -!#026 1$"'#!#.""/#-27
,%$9'%2'))%:$;' ,(8-+!0:##%!".%%-%- "##,/!81::"#!$!.%%-%- "##,/!813;!$""+"! $$+#$39#$$!$# -!#032
'$$$" !,#!*+ ,+"+-#339+$"- "#! !, -&'+08#". -%1,+"+-#!' !8 0#$/4;2+$"- "#! !, -&'+08#"$. % -&!8!"/#/%%!#$4
-
$%& $%&&$6 &$6%+1"$ %+1"
*$%"% %"%?@
-
$%&'$%&(
#)'(#)'(#'(A
'*+*()$%&@
-
!"
#$%##&%$ %
'&()*%
#+$,-+./0-/12345-+1 67'7 #7
'###8#93:';#
35#8'.'-)5'.'*:'; /9#
3-:'28)'2*)* )*)* :'2+-:
-
#9
8 '2
)*8
>)*##>)*89##>)*9>)*39
'2
9
#/
'2
771$$%044 % 40 % $%7=% 1 7 %4 0 7
-
/#'27'###
##9E#9##
3##
9
B 7)*
8
9#7
8> )*
>)*
>)*3)*D
>)*8#
>)*D
#
3EBE
3#
-
83E-8EE#)*)*>)*#8
>)*>)*D
3#8
-
B#82)*-)*3)#*3-?8
38)*>)*#>)*>)*#
3EBE#8?$$&
3)*
> )*D #37
#
$?D)*3$$
$$
##)7*
)* .&17#8 672#17#?? "C'2E'-7
)?C*3#2$$
#
F
#
6
: $'2
5)
#
)%%",$%0#7777$C4"#$%
7 0 $ 0 $734%%%$$$4220%3 $ %3)% %$%4733"2(2#5343$%43%%77$4507,--D%%074$4%/13%$+ ,--D % +3 ,--D % %77 )%.$%373% $ $ $ % +3,--?
- %5 .+; ": D,9'K2L- %5$MN774D0#
N> 0- %5.+;
6 %.-% 2% 1 !.+- %5;":D9'K2L- %5 $ MD- 774 '406#)%7=$74630-----774 ? 0 D )% *.) 0 *.) % 7C (70 $ /% %77 )% FO'%99$4$%7$
-
'27- :
?$$
9#38#-
#8EBE)* .!##
-#888
)270N# 1 % 7= $3 7 37431373$7
!"
-
3EBE
)*D8-#
>
>
>#-8
G#
8#
-
)%$$4%0'%)%$%>,O%6
48 E8
)
*)
*8
#
E8
7
5#
'#7172#9
##
>>
)3*3#2B96#8##:.9
38#
:-83.G
-
'
)*3
8
29
/
#
39#
.9#88
3)??*#8
#'
98
'9
88# F8
8 #8#
3 .2#8
>@D)3?*39
8
-
)5;*
# 8#-1727
@:#9#88
B##9#
:-
3&-
32-
8F##8>:9 .G
-
#
8'##.##)3!*39##
E #8998#
:#29
#8)?C*5
17 )!$% *
'
-6#
#8
6#
.G
-
#
:9G83#8+3#8+##
=8
3#
2-38#
+#:
/
8
##
#.2
J
#8:#
#7
##
#/
# J
#
J
B#
:##
2
###
8##3#
&
E0)D%%0".1*%*
-
2#9#-
###35;
##
G#
-
2>
##
/17##
/.#
17
##;(%
"@DJ#2
#
3
#6
-
'
#-/.G
-
#)3@*:-7
3
)*6.G
-
$?
7
3#8A ("?@)38@$$$"@$$$*'9? 2
/-#
.G
#J 8
###8
/##
'# F##
#7
'
)3D(* -
;8
#38
3 8838 8+'G838
8#
38#'#
G83#8
3
#85##2&-3&45&,##,+
'&()*+
= % >+B
% % %
1 %! $$.A0 -A8' -$A0$ $7A-0 7A.-8 ---A0$0
&! ! $'A70 -8A-78 A7' "8A80 -A-7" $0A88-
!!
"#$%%&'"('$)'*)+
./:!7$7$%7773$ 0 ?%3 M?,N ",D---#I% $",B# $ "B# 0 "B# $ ">B# $!%"?B#
($73 %%77%%3 I % 03 7 730./:!06B$%%$$%$
:)%%777$74)373$7$%"-KL- >A-7%# $ 6A>% 7 7 3 .,--, %47
-
#
'9&3&"&&-
3EBE7
3
8
888#8
29?
6688:8#
/837:938#8:868)*##>)*##
>)*#
#
8>)*D##
8>)*
#
8#
>)*#;8
3-
#8#38
#
3+ @$"($% J
#8:#88
/28
H8
-?-N-,- $4$ % $& 7%7 $$7473$%
-
*+,"+
#:#
###
:8/.+##
H
:#8#4#2
8#F#8
-
67
-8
68-,
68-8.
/2#883
8##8
6
2
9# 3:.# 2
8#8
E3##88
3#8#8$%7$77,--,$,,D>%41?,$%
2%7%7072702403733$%$0303%%$
43D---A>---$3$7>%%3%)D--I3$%3$0
. ,--, % % >D- 74 - 9%%29%%4703$7%4=3$$%
;%>--$3$7%$%9 $% 1 0%
-
#'H:9
533#
.B3
9.3I
I3'C
#8F##
B9
53
B
?$%!$%
'
38
5
;
#
8 3
:92##-#&2I 2 #
.$
%
$
-
:
3
172
#3
)* # >(%
#)3C*:###
5)*#8 %7
/-#
8;#8988E>#8
#8
8/#3
#8### J 9 6#
H
F8
B#
!"
3EBE#:93
#"DN#
'%0 %0 $ % 3 74 0"$777%4#%$73)%7 7 7 7 7 7 7
-
J
8
3
8
:
-
#332:')2:'*#879 #3
2:'88
#
L
/2:'
8B2:'
3 -.#
#G8#
-
3
'
7'
-
35:-
#/?$$
-
#
-
I :.9I88#
-
#- 3
8;:
E
3##85
#
F'..-#
F
8:982
388.
J
#
8
3 # /2##!D8)8*H?$$$ ($" $%
/#
:#
@$$$$?$$?&C%+
E-3#&(8&:5/-'
I# I#>
$((8C" (8 "C!@%
/3
##6?$#
)% D /4 43"043#$03%%7717G4%$%7%%%3%07H(70$7$1$%03 $%%%%770)%37$% / $ / $ (70 % "%7II$I$IIII7#77$%707$7=7$% )% * $ (70 %9377% /7 % 27 . "%7II$I /(I--DIED6,IED6,--);#)%%4301377%%77
,--D.27%(70&/(
//377%%$4$$$3%!)%%!344%$%7$%7%%07774$$3%!704
E / ,--D (4 $ % % "/ ;(#2%%/C(7
"# /6>---,---
)%4777$7%4 7 7 % %775 7 7 74$%/:!2%) . % $% 3 40$% $% 7 "3 7# 0 $3%%%%777
-
#?C$$$?$$$
B "#? D8 :#C$"$%3#&& 853:##88F#>953&"@D8
;#'#AC$$ ?$$?2/8#AD?$$?J!$$$$$
@
$$$$$D
? H .#
-#&D2
E 2#
#3
+3
-
3
-
2#8
#
86
8
9'8398
8
9#
-
9#.9#
:
-
3#
'27##7H3
38#77H)*D
89#7
8)*
9#)*D
=8
:91G82##8,
9
#
N %5 - %5.+;
(
/-'2
8
G2C" )?NO*663# ( C@%
'
#
86
8
##3#98+
-
N %5 0 - %5;
D%5 % - %5%;
%5 0- %5%;
-%5 % - %5# ;
6%5 0- %5# ;
#'298
8+#
8
-#/:96#
#89###
/27)C@*
C " #8#837#
#)*9)*
)*83#
)
*8799'2
7/
7)?C*
23
#9
#
B9-8) $" *
#
#
E) "(*
-8
#98 : #
-
8395
#
'79
#
7
'29/5-EG83
#9##'297
##>#
37#
88 7#89#
8/2)?C*#9## #8/8#
78'
###7.#
-# # 8 8#
#
/'2-#
#
6# 9 8
#8
3# #
3/7EG8) !"* #
8) *
###$# /##9#73
7
'
3
7##
G
#
B9'278
'
-
2%/+E%N>1">+2+0%5-+;
,--D,3%5;
3EBE9 ##29#
'28
#* " )"" " *.97# ##8#8-7
#8
-
)* 2#)*8##8#+"!/ 0
* 1#.+*'
)*
)*+
)*9#
#* # 1 " # &2J
#8E
'
)* 9
##
>
)* ##)8#*
)* #)
*#8>
)*
7
## 8 + 1 " % #.0
1E
'
+E#89 /
8++H+#H68
#*'( '( " #.0 % " E
#7'
8
83
)*
)* +
8>)* 8>)*
>
)*
#
#* &'(' 8
-
# " 03
-
-
! "#$%&!'()*)+" & #!#"),'--*.,/%012+++
'+,3'(4!"52+++ .+67+,
8
& #9 0#0 !0: "
2;4!"2++27*++++!;),"-*+++!(,")*++++!;;,"*-++++!2.,":2
0:
'2;7++ '-7. *.'+++2+++7(+5!5"2((+531?
!$&>1"080&!0&@80&"0:
! ! "##$
%&'(&(()%%'%(%''% *+, -. /01' ' 2% ( ' ( '2 ( '
3000
45%'
300045%'
62 63003&%%%' ' 7 8 ' 9( % :-";3.53$#+
-
8A*
$
8!" A '-7+
#?0&@80&
080
!0 80" BC&0!&0"30: &
A
/
A!@%:"
1
!" D!"D!"48
E
A1
! "
&%"#,#%300
-
38'--*5-.
()',
()*, #
!"**.,!'--26'--7"!" ;+,!'--+6'--."!"(;,*-,!'--7" @!.(,">!"3
!+2"
5
&
((,
!+26+*"
!"$
&
@%:
@;(,
!+*6'"D
#AA'62F2*,A
&2
'.,
62( 2 2 ' ! ' 3"33;;2 2 2( 2'3"%222
K ( 45 %'
A %% 22 22''22%
'B2
-
8 G )+++++2++27+,
2+, &0: !" 2;,2++' !"@!":
!"A
!"!"
H
22%7E2L-.-).%-%.M2 % & ( 2 -%%. % 2 - . 2-.=2%'2(2-.%2-*.
A & 300
-
:'--*
0$
& D/*++++6)++++5G
*++4 2++++D'+6'*5'6245#26(5!I**5
&
$ #
J&
A
?
I0
C9AI:A
/
62 '%%2 (%60,0+"00-@$+/.$+/2'2'%%
&% (2 ' "BB
%'%!(%'2
2 ' 2 % % 2 %2(
3,0000 ' ' % 2%2'B''%A 2 2 301 ' 22''%%2''/0%;2'3,00''
2%'6"$0'%62''2'0
-
0?
>JJ GA #
&.;+''+ 82++2
&
F2'@ % ' 2 ' /00+*00D%; %'
' 'A 2 ' 6"0+"/;%''2'((
''%'2F6/0;%
-
2+++++!"
K %$ 8'--7277*''7'++
@ HA
G 8
8
A 0: A
A
8##
#
?$
#A@
!" #?!
"EI BA
&
@%:A
76;8?"+,&
(%$%57'6%-76.H2 %5 8 F E-8.
C? 3003 7 &2 % 2 ' %7! &B!4(2>>2 % 7 "*- !" ./0(58=2"$*+":$
C"##,%%&%( 7% 5%87&222A2%'C72(3*+3,2"##,4%
6(22AB'88 E % % ' C (8 ' ! (2 % (
7C%22
60"0+0"/ 2 '%% -@ $+/D. '%%'6030+03/(%
-
AG
A!>B#"
>B#
:>B#
>B#
0
E
&
&9
8
8
2 ( %(
% '''((%
!
-
&&
/*+,
2(
&E
3(+++++7+++++245$23
;4$
! " &0 '-)+??
?
1
?
!" 0&0?!'-776'--)"?
8'(-7224 HJ
4"#***$*3'% 4
-9
-
?
A&'26;25&2++2'+++++53A*+,
8
2++++5
?.++0: &
27+++
A'--(6'--.'7+
! "
?!"
1$0D!" D!"4
A0: @%:A
?1G
A
# !"?
?
A@%:A
?9?
!"
D!"A
D!"
$ %! $A
!"'-*(@ !"'-)(0G#@ &
%4=8''2%5-.(%2-.%2-.2 % % 2 4=8":1'230003,1%@2%
4"##/$$%%
' ) 5$
%% *'% 4 -9 "
-
.+4 $(+K
2-,
$'7,K &!*(,"!(.,"
>
#&0
98! 98"!%8 "'--(1 # 98%8 I 98%8 %8 %8
&0& 8
&&0
&2++;
!
/ ! " !"
D!"
88
D
I
&
&
A
!"D!"
E"##/7(%'67E&2-)%.2--%.8@4'647'6%%
C2) & 9%' "##3728G'62&%7)*$1!$89(
6///,BC5'%:7%!*'N:0000022("$4"##
-
A#
1
0: /
I
#
! ' $ !
3?';4!#8#D
'+"0
A
( ' =#8# 2+9AA
5 @
)
'
@J
A
!I&GG1" E
%
)' !
8
3003 72 ' & ' & !7$,$";(
%%*++++H:#0:2, J;3 7'*6'+55:*++++
2*+++6;++++
@
)..)+57)I
AA :'',
2*2;.
&2+,&
**-;#/!*+,"!((,"
!(+,"!;-,"
!""#
!*"
3/
!-+,"?!.7,"!27,"!2(,"#='4!2),"2!*),";6(!'.,"$
K6&
06 &)!-7,"!-2,"!72,"!*',"!;(,"!2;,"
!2,"I
!'++,"!--,"/!--,"!7),"
!(.,"!2*,"!'2,"
!."
&
*
, ( ) $*++&
/ -&
+-84 0
(-. #-1 %$3-3)6* %/- $>1 ;-84 :-84 5:9 *2( 2:( $3-?4 $3-3 $86.-. "3-;9- %+*+& &- 3-@
-
!"!"!"
!"!"!"!"
!"
!7',"!*)," !(',"2, !).,"!22,"!2,"$!)-,"52',@
D !(*,"!;(,"!'),"!(,"
.&
$
!
"!" &'+ GG2*6(+=7
*42.6'+
&$IA.4(-I!-"
!("
!;"!'"
J2J.2I)262+&?@6 ()4 '- 2)4
=-7,2,
-#./0 12"2)$*++&
=$%&+
. /
.& % %% % +) %# $" "& "" %0 5) % & 0
% #:6(2
$
''%'(%F%'22''
-
;*6(*8
0.(5
')+5D
'++++62++++
&2$?!."!("I
/
.# '+
2+++6*+++
;26(*
=*'+
:I$ A(6'+*2
!'+4"!-"!)"
!2":'*;?I-4
$
()4)'(6';4$6K
#:
GGE
'+++62+++!';.+"2-*6*2+'+++0';.62)* ?=
26'+, &
! '+ $2*6(+=2*4A;6*[email protected]
D#
;
*2;6'+
:6KI
:'62.6776'2,0
!
-
'*+62.+?
=!."!("@
/ ')*4A
$.*+2-;!
-
C?%$&0
!&0"'-776'--)
.+67+,
$ '2;7++
('''%E %'22'2
&'
-
!"'-7.7*++++2++2: 7+, 8G 3
C?220 !0: "'-776'--)&0#&01?
C?0%$2*2.7- ';4'+*'))(( 2*(+++'--..',
:7',A'!"82+++C?
;))'
';+7- C?
$&>1?
!$&>1"080& #? %A0: &%$
'++I;!?@C"
%$ 8
0:
K6&2++;
$
8
I
A&
A A
4=8 > 300 "##3000+4300
-
&AA
I 8!
"
8
'+6'*5;6*5F.6'+53
?
&K;
&
C?
@
#
': '++-7!-7,"2,!":'',),$!7),"
!(7,"!4'"
- - '(';+5!2"
A:'),*!"?
!*7,"*6)!2*,"76'+ $
3/4 (2/($*++&
+- 1$%&
-4 05&-. $0;)4 -. ";)4 - ,+
./5)3/4$2//&
8
& #%8( %%$1 %#&4 %$5= "0"
) ""0$& 550
%$( "%
/ $"
7C%22300
-
!.2,"'*,22,
',4-6'2
(@!-7,"A!7),"!77,"
!'*,"!*-," #--,'++,-',22,2',*,
'! (2,;(,E!.,"!'*,"
!;,"&A&!7,"2,
& C?(2,&)(,D!2.,"8
*,.),26;27,(
1 %
;'5%$;;52++' &
A?
!;"82++2;-!"-*++5*(++5
+-
$!)+,"@
!2'& !.-,"
(,9@!-+,"
!7-,"D'',
5()3/4
: 8
6(
;
;14 1 %$"A5
;
;&14 1 #A
=(%
'@3/';/*0%;'2$#/%;' 300$1%*3%1 #3- /- 3-3 :9
'// 3/4 $*++&
( 1 $%&
3-7 53-.(4
1) #$3-8 3 3-()
,(
-
&*!"!"
!"
!"!"
?
!-+,"D1
I&*
-
1)'++2--);*!"')(.+!;;7("!2*;7" !2+++"!*++"
H1'+)2++'2;,1!%01" @2++'
-
#1'-)2
G
'-)+:!" I 1A=
& #1
1A
1
10
= LM?DGEA1
G09!"D1 1
G09
'-7+2+@1$
8G E&9$!8GE&9$"$?
6228
8 6%& -866&. ' 22 '8!-8.8!& -8&. ' & 9@ ?( -&9?. 84(2 & -84&. 6
2%''22'!22F2
30 % B % '% (222B
%'%(22%'F%'%'2%'%2(''!2B''''%22' ! ' 2@ ' % ' 2('%'%'2%2222-C
"##*H':LM.2(2%'%2'
B'%'%(2( 2 ' 8&;&9? B' '%
-%'
'@.(22%
((%'2'('%%'2E
2'
K2A'C"###$*3 ("###;30%5%=''''8%=%@'?"032
&
9
622 "#,# "% "< "% 7 * $976%3",2
7%'!2'B'
B2 22?2 ' P(((%''%B'H2' (%H 22 ( ( 25='
6 92@ 3003! '4(' ' 88''R%5F2'?2'P(227$*34(&9 (4A%'?5&7%2#*+"0#
6%' 2 ' 222 "#,0(%)>2&2"#,,C72('625277%%!*3%)622
6%>97)*$1 "/23/#+3::6%'-(-(%%222>6%>2>2&2%)"#,: 2 ( ' F( C7% &-% -9. 22*3"1%"*53$#+3/,
-
1 '-7+&0!&0" $
1
'-7'2++'
A
10&D
2+'+D
?A
2+'+1 2*++++!'22+++2++2"
3%/1?
'-7*62++'1)-,.,
7*,77,
! 2"
82++'
-'2,'+..'7 12++'1*';! 3003 6 2 ' E('22627'300
-
(7(,!*'*-*";'2,!;;2-)"2++'
A1
!EI3"0EI3 1
8888H
#
% I
)+67+,
;.5'--; @981$& +..5!'-)-6'-77"'.'5!'-7-6'--)"'((*,0!
2(-,! " '2*, G
'-7*62++'1;('.517;,5!2*" '-7*2++'1(*()5.-,3
327,(;,2++'! ;"
((,.-,')8'--)62++'5!1(*("!1.;("!1;7*"& 1.+- 1)'* 1*2+
+!"'-7*62++'1'';5 82++'1';)5
'-7+
8 F2 (% 2 2 % -$"*$;%.%3!"##
-
I'--)62++'',),
$ '--)62++'
E
0
+*6+.'+,
*6.,
'2(+--
'+,'2(, 8
1
8
E? &
!22(" !'';"!'+)"
'+,'';,
1 %
2++2(*!5"'*75 #'
8 F25 4 3000 6 2 ' %2('2*3%1%$-"+3.5"0#+"3:>&"##"224 'E% & 225%&7;7E2
-
GEA12;*+++2D!'+NO'+.67"1*7+++!2;
5"&12';+++5 1'2'+++5
#
2; !"
#A=A!5"
!" #'','7, 2+++4 %/2++262++(A
#/ '62
:-6'24$
8
A
&9! &9"
2++;'+2=-++'2+ &9
>26; &9
%%
&9 % ? &9
622'8!-8. ' @ - ' 2. %'28'%%@%'@%4 3000 '' ' 62 =2 22*3% 1%$-"+3.5
-
& &9%P
1G85 8GEAE
0 &9@1
!%8 "%8 %8 !'("
# /
A!"!#9"-*6'++, &9I#9 G
EAE!1"
#9=(*,.2,#9 &9%>%# &
#3
#
1G& 1 &91++*6+'+1#9
#$
I
9%
% (8C6O&9822(%'''2%C
222( %
''
2@ % ' C 262-C6.722' 2 ' 2 % F2 4
6C262-C6.(2'C7868G C# 6 8 -C6 3003 O&9.(2%'8C63000-C7868.8&(8&B8674&-%%22'7
4(2&'&.
622'%''6' % 'F B 2 8%F''''% 2 IF (J 2 -6. 6''%'(@
(222?('A?%8&;&9?"##"+"##$IKK%J%I%2J-C6.'(KK F F ( (2KK((22C6(%(FB'% 2 ' ' C6 (2%6C62
( %(
2( 2&9@F(0"0+0"/2'%%@33'%%'03/0
-
$?@>?1E 8G#I
?
A
@1 #
?
A#9/
& :
E
E%1++'6++21
&8
A
'.GEAE)2,)-,
!"
!" 9
! G9"
G9A
&
9A& I1:$
4( 2%2B2 &9@ 2 ' ( 2B2 222'(22
2'%G'6''2('B22%%%B'2262%B%B&9@
8F2&9@%'9@-%7R.(%2'2'%'%''22
4%"##*+300"''2'2
-
2+6;+,
2++;1';+++6')+++5)+6-+,
J1 &
?
$?1
'--*();,!)++++"!'(7+++"
EA!7),"$H'+,;,
2*=!"2++;1'*62;5
0(6.,8!;+6(7,"
!2*6((,"
# #
A8
A 3
&A
#?8
1
( ': AGEAAA
ADA(,A1;+6(+*+E!"G
I
A
&@2"##*!88@'22"*-"!
-
GEA
AGEAA
A
A 02+++62++'!*',"A!2;24"1
A
!(*6+6+"!'.62+6+"!2'6+6+"A5@1C!D'(6'(6'(" 8'--)62++' A'++,),*),+-,@1C
8A(+6**,'-7*62++'I
2++'.)6).,A
! ("1A1AA0ADA82++;*+A=1**'1;'.1(..1())@1C
A '-7.
3AA!"IA&A
I
A &
&A
58AI1
*#I B8
%'@2'2%F' %
6%23+
-
8GEA1'++++62*+++5
E
&
9
8 81
I
#
*/
5E>
@
!"8
8$5I
#
-
3 &27++++A
0 !0 %!#I
&? 8
$82*62++,
A
!"/ B
D8
A8
B/
!"
0:
1%
/ AI
$
3 ?A
Q9G%G!QB>0&@G:9"/'2,;, %
2% ' ' ! 2(K2"###'"0
?9C(
&'"##"2''% %(
2%((;2%''%''
-
QB>0&@G:99-7,
QB>0&@G:9 1/
>:22. :8G'--.
G9888
3! & $
%
&9 JJI
! &9
&
=!"
D!" D!"48
+- A 8 E$>
I
##B
6
2'P?4&=''%32262&%"
-
$?!
"
EA3
>
I/# A
*1
!'"JJ
I#
G2;
8GEA!"?
;+6'*+48
EG(31+*6'+ L?M?
GEA
E!*"
0
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
()
*
-
E*,3#G.
GEA#
/A
3&/ %(*.
&!)"1
=5
#
8 3GEA126*5 1A 7!'"+*6'+4!7"
'++&(+8G
EA(6*I GEA
& 8GEA1*5
9
1'+6'*5&
+-%!1@>? 1.*++++1'*/!?"
!"3/0$$1(+++6
?22' A 2' E '(8%BF
%%2'
6P?4&=2%% 2(% -"*0000;;2 . ' ' %% 2%'F2
622( %&9@ (('22/+"012%
A ' 2 2 ' F 22 ; 2( 2 '6 ' 2 '& 9@ % 2 9% @ &(% 2( & 9@ = (% %
-
*+++9 !"017+62*+
' G &A
103
)+,0*+,'--)2+,2++(
. %' 815 ? '-7'62++'
&&A
:
#
#&
1 !"/
. !#
1
1
@ A
I
E
6'''2%%22"#,"
2'''2(%(2'(&300"** '61 ! !6$1 % '2%A2'6225AA8'2
>4(2 '&! 2252(2222'8=;&%&!4(2 P@&22-72.
-
#
*,-H
18 IE%G'--'!9&
)'.+" 8
& $A&'--)!9&7(;*"A
G'--7!9&
7**+"
&9
8AI
! &9$G"@ &9$G
8A &9$G
68&' "##,2( ' B' ' % ' ' ( '(-8=.28&8='%' 2 2 % 2''%-8="#:.2( ' ( ' ! -8= "#*.@ ' 2 2 2 -8= 30/. 22
' ! 2 -8= 3"$. '
!-8=3"/.%'(%-8=3"*.''%2-8=3",.%2%%2' 8=3"/ 22 22 ' ''% ' ' 2'9%@%%'
-
?1 GEA
$
=!"D!"A
D!"2(7J'2(!"D!"
#=!"D!"
D !"
AD!" A
1@>?1';K62;&2++;G
EA &9! &9" $&: 0
(''&9@%'22'2
62'%;2'22%-''%%.%2'@8B2' % 2 ' "D ' 2 %H '
2''
-
GEA9888&@>?1R1'-*+ $A !"@!"'-)+
#
1GEA!1@>?"
'-7+@';7)(!"'-7*.*-.72++2GEA)*,7),
%&
GEA2';..!"82++2'),1/8';),/
(+*!" 8A
GEA1/#$R
!$1" !S'.,"G
8
!"A $$
'
GEA?
19!-*)-D'++++NO"(+#1
!"D!"4D!"!"D!"@!"$GEA
!2*"LM!'2"LM*LM
GEA=&1@>?
-(;++&
;'(7*G1!*+(+"GEA8G
&GEA2!"'GEALM 8
LM
6 % ' %2(-'!2%.'-BB!'@%( 6 2 B ' % %' ''' 2 -% / % (2.H 2 2 B ' % %'''' 2 2 -%2 ( 2. 8 !( ( B!'%2'22'2%'''F'('%'/1"1-2T00/2T00".
73003'222%2$
-
R &
;*+++42++& +;'
'+62.+52+++GEAA'+++
1 A& &9/
2++2';(,
()(*1@>?
#!)-,2',"E 1 G$#E#&
GEA
$!7'('4 NO"I0
!
A"
GEA2+++1';7(;!=
946
3003+ *A2%"%$?"$@*3$777(S@(E5&9@?(*/2
6 ' % 2'&9@3003:/00
& 300
-
2.,!'--*62+++"
2',1
(22;(+$!*+(,"!(-.,"2+++'*6*-*-,+6'(;*,.+.,E-*,$!7),"
!-.,"&).,
!"8G
EA'--;!"27
G!'2("5!)7"$2)'.:!')*7"!*'"
' .4 . !5 '2('2(
:
%
!'" *2,D
'.5' %82++2
;2%A*!2++"2'6;'82++;7*,
'6(!
)"
;&A*6.
! ":A:'+, !)67"A
8%=%@-8=.' ?300", # 62' 2 ' "##
-
!U++*"
2++;!*":;+2.
D
+, % !.),"2++2&
!(;,"#!;7,"?
!"
!2'"
%)*
#'-7+GEA#B
!GE#B" &G! &G"?@ G !@ G" &9 GEA 8
A/
&
A#
LM8
6% ( % (2 ' %2('2-C786.2'4
6 /3*#BC5: 7%% ! * '
N$*/000 22( , "#,, 4 22 ' C786 % 6 ///,BC5'% : 7%! *?':7!*@' N:00000 22( "$4 "##
-
2*6;+!"-*6'++,!#9"
#9-7, I #9
&
B
3#BC &G5GE#B'--'6'--( %
'(2 GEA*;1(*@>?:'+++++* 82++;%?2+6(+@ GGEA
-.
%+
' .
?
!)',"
:!;',"!2+,"
) .
!*),"#!'.,"D
!-,"D!.,"D!(,"D!(,"D!2,"D!2,"
. @ !-.,"2++2 !)2,"!>
% >8=;&;A =C25I 2222%-%2.F'''2%2'27('%2 F ' ' 2 ' !J 5A =%@ -A =. "### 8 ' 7 '!-!$JJ8(C(//2
C&4(=8"##$:1 1 !" $S@(E22H8!&&9@?(?'%?('A?%%2'62(2?('A2E'2KK'
(525;;'%
6'2'%% &9@33*+$//'%%2(2%%'*0000'%%2-(
.'2-2'/01%2'"001@':/00.6
'
'%%&9@$/$+#"0
5886%&8
*
7 23
*
-
"A A22!'-"
(& 1.,!;+6;*"#
!A')'("
81
!)+,"@>?8@>?K5 &5#!
I3$&"
A='+++2;,D '+++6*+++(;,D *++'6'++++;(,1 +*+'*62+
.6)4 &9-6'*!"(674!A ")'672,$ !.2,"#9
A &9
#9 &9#9 &9%>
1+'+
&9%>!.(,"%#!27,"%!7," :
!-',"
:
I
!*+,"!(*,"&
?
!.7,"!"1@>?!)-,*7,":!2),"
A!2,": ''';
!;',"!.2," J
)2,
JE?
$!-2,"A).,A
A!"!22,"&!2,"
8
62(E2%-
-
AA
G
!)2,"1A#A
!'+,"
2, . ) $,&!*2,"
!(7,"
10 0 0 5%)777!" 2++21.*.);(!2"1(2(*>
1(2';(.=)2,D'',D),D.,DA(, 12;*;771*)7.-
!1*..'-J'+7*+*"
/+*)+,82++212-(--J))*2(17*+67-2:(+()
;-,/#-',
!*,"!(,"9
9..,
.+,2',.,';,
6 / =!"!77,"D!"A!);,"D!"!)2,"D!"!.*,"D!" !"!"!*(,"@A
$
=*-,'*,
D'.,'+,
$!*2,"
&2+,
=!"4 !(;,"D!"
!-,"D!"!(,"D
6'%22%'22('/"$3"##,+300382'"/ "*32%( 2 '
-
!"
!(,"D!"!2," ',8@>?@
GEA
$&;2,$&$ 1@>?!*+,';,"1
!;;,"!;+,"!2+,"!2+,"
@:
/$!..,"
.'$
@>?1!7.,"E7,(,2,1@>?
!'*,2,"@!)-,"!'.,"!;,"!2,"
A*!;"!()" @
;+& !2*';"&;-,
8!)(,"
-$!7-,":!(.,"=!2',"!'2,"!'2,":5# !;.,"
' ( % %B 2'%'F22'%#3'B'
(2 :
74 / 87 .
;( A #A A
A# 5A" A
3(-1 $A$ A0 A
-
@>?
$!72,"=!"&.',!2;,"!2+,"!.,"!.,"5!*,"
$GEA
!A"A$!7+,"
I !'7,"!'(,"!22,"!2-,"!'-,"
*#& :+*
2!" +) !'2,"'6*4#81'++++62*+++
1'+,
'#$!7-,"# !;,"1
:!'7,"!7,"5!;,"!',"
I'-,!"
!"!'+,"$&$!*','-,"
!.),"
!2),"
!;,"!;,"@=!2',"!(.,"5!*,"#1
&
$!72,"
! "
!.*,"!(;,"!.,"!2,"'6.2 &G5GE#B
$!72,"I!'7,"
!(;,"/2.,/!';,"/!';,"!';,"/
8B2''03+"38%B2'%
-
A
/ $
!7*," !(),"!.7,"
,'
@!-(,"I !A"!)(,*-,"!72,.;,"&I
!)),*7,"5!);,*2,"?!)',*.," !;-,')," :
?
!);,(-,"!.;,*(,"!.;,*(,"
'
!..,"
&;(,!*',"5!2+,"
1'+62+ *6'+,($
!*),"D
!12-27-1'27+++"1'++++622++++
%**,122,@>?!;-," 1&2-,.,:
5
..,-,3'+,
9
*,$!;',2.,"
@!1-+2;1.;*'"&!*(,"
2',26.
,$-
!7-,"D
$!)),"
8
''%'
8('(22
-
!
"
G&!*2,"
D!;2,"@!'.,"
?&2*,
:!'+,"@27,'*,
!.
(6):2( #;(,()(*;7)2 ''4JA
;((*
);++4 9 2(+++ 1@>?
G12+++6;+++8'+,#1;+++4
'*62+,
1'*+62*+'+4
!5"!"#
& !;',"
?!2;,"?!;,":?
*
-
!)
&9$
G! &9$G"1 &9$G &9$G*DD
&9$G &9$GGEA &9$G
A1
E?A
A : &9?
EA
1
8
!"
A A
""
)
G
!" &9
G
GEA
& GEA
GE#B! &GG "@ G5 &9 82++2
8& ' 42 '%H42 ' 7 9C(
H B '% ! 2% HH %(
%@2 8& ' ' %@ %(
%@ %(
(2 2( 42 '%8(="#:'3000: 7%% "*$1P@&22542'%
6*28&5:E22%'!'"%(E''2%'%
%@ >300
-
%8 8
1 #GGE#BGEA182++;
GEA
!(-,"!;*,"!;+,"!2),"8!;+,"!'+,"
+
:1
D
G'--7!9&N9&O7**+"
&:9&7**+
? !"
9 G
EA
& ;++0>@9HE
E G
% , GEA!"A0 &G5GE#B1$?1GEAA
&
(5-. =2 3003 * ) * %(2&5 8=2
( % 2 ,$
-
A
GEA A
E
3
8
(A!"
GEA D 5
$
!1"
#
GEA8!"I !"!
"1
8GEA
!;',"
!2(,"!(,"&
5
E
*,& 5
(
>@V#:!>@#:"1'-726'-7;'--+6'--2'--)6'--7>@#:
6
'%2%"/+302!( "/0000+300000 2 % @ @"3002!%"00
(E&"##:"&*3'% #!!(?5?('A&'4(2
A ' % % 2 2
% ' 2 7
% %%22*/1''%'&CC&"##,6225(V!$
="##,5"#+3$-7 ' 6% % 6H 7 '
!?( ' % ?. 2%
'%'222
7/'!2"%'2"/+302 " % ' ' % ( %25&CC&"##,-'$*.6 '-. ' 2U6%67"##$7
(672(%A? '' ' 2 2 AG"##$A 9 &' )%"
-
8K'--'$1R1? 1GEA81!"'++++
&
#
GEA
18@
81 &9J'--7 GJ1 1
8 @
GEA
:7,$
!7-,"
GEA 2(3
:
''2%-'
-
8';,!.-,"A!2,"
&
A
!((,"!;),"
!2(,"
E '2 =
!(',"!2),"!'-,":
!(+," !27,"!'(,"!.(,"!(*,"&?
A
!.-,(',"!(2,2+,"@!'7,'+,"E!
"
&
* =
8
!(',"!;*,"!'+,"8*
!;),"
*4&
@*
@*
5
*
GEA!"4!"D!"
6''B'(-'%-+""0+++L#M+.'3B
.!''('2 5 6 &% 3000=''B'(
!$&",-".5$/+,,(
6''B'(2'("%'$%'2'2 '22"'(='22'%'3+
-
D!"!5"D!"
!"D!"
D!"4
D!"4A
E%
?
*
*1
!"
G
EA&/
GEA
5
&E
?
-
$1 E1
A
$
&'++7'&E#@E11
-7,K6&2++;9
E#
#
# $ &9$G!$ &9$G"8 &9$
G!8 &9$G" 5
#
('2%'2' 96 %'22'2
6'8!%& -8&. 8 & ' 22 -2,//0.62% '
'!22( 6 8& '% 2 ' 2(2%''! 2 8& 22% /B
2'(22H'' %( '% ' % 28&2(''G%@;2( %(
%@ %(
(22(42'%6'8&2(% ( % %(%'2
-
E'-)+E
1/ &EE E24!"8!"
!'-).E)+++!")!"G@!E? 8E1/8
E&E@!"
1';'-)'--*2''7-2+++
E
%-*
E2.+++8
!"
2((++'2+!"2+2.$
:226;*!G"8.(+++6.7+++!.NO".+6.*!"'7+4!.NO"&
&;)
4"#,# 4 %*$)
" '% 4 (8"#*#"#,,4 22 (2 '' 2 2%#0000B9%%9% 300" 6 '( &B84(25&2(('96227$6"#1';-+)2*+.,'--(1-2;+*:1);*-(1''(7-(&
*+,27,2', E
-.,'2,
A1 10&J &9! &9"51?7?.
)+5
E@
81@-+.9
1&$!1&$"
$ &9$G
6'6)227')% % -25;;2(%(2;(2;!
;.%@'% I2 2J6 '6) 2 % ' 96 % 2%2(("###-:% " ! ) -' : LM. '
%%%@' %(66"##"!1!5%
R'6)=@8
% "###! )# )%2 -&2$"':LM.'2%3/+
-
8 &9$G:
5 # *6.:(6*(&;+,;6(4;;,0(-,'62&7;,-;,2++2K!(;,"&!)(,"K
D&
!7.,"!7;,"
!*),"A;6(4
!" @*6.4
@
AAA/
&
A#
LM
8
!"2'6273
-*6'++,!#9"#9-7,##9
I
#9 A#9(*,#9@#91+'+6+'*
&
!%$"B
3#BC
8'@2%'26@' % '8F2 I@3$J '-(%00$/+00#:%-%.I@33J'-0"3#+0"$/ %. 0"/ 03/ 2( 3000 I@ "*J'%%-0$:,+"300%.I@"$J'%%-"
-
&G! &G"GEA#B
!GE#B"'--'6'--( % !
=55"
&E(2,E&
19$/!"?;7, A
?
!7+,"
E26;
'*6;*A
K6$&6K(762'++!"2.'' -',
';'2!A;7"!A;2"&!--,"1AA'+,;2,
AIA@))(67';4 *-,$!.',":'',#9
$
E
!-(,"!*;,"!;;,"!2*,"#
!.',"!7,"!),"@=!.*,"!(*,"!;-,"!7*,"!.',"
!*',"1
!-+,"!)(,"!)2,"!*.,"
$!72,"
*4
:*.,:!'',"
!*,"!;,"
G!22,"!22,"%/
!2',"!'*,"!.,"!(,"!;,"
C&4(=8"##$:1 1 !( " $(S@(E2258!&&9@?(H ? %5 ' %?('A
222'9 2E% %22'2 '2'&''9=2(2'226'22&2(%'% 2%(%' 2 2 ' -@
-
%
#'-7+1 5
8
-2,)2,%#!%#"(2,:@!'-,"!'7,"
82++2
!;',"%$!27,"%#!'7,"GI!.;,)2,"
%+
E'.+''--;'+*.)'---.7(;2++2
=!-,"!-',"&9 E ='*624D'
2E
$'+'+.6)
'*
#
/
)'6).A'(!.*,"')!2+,"#*76.;, !*.,"
!;-,"
6% ( % (2 ' %2('2-C786.2'4
-6./3*#BC5: 7%%!*'N$*/00022(,"#,,422'C786%6///,BC5'%:7%!*?':7!*@'N:0000022("$4"##
-
!'-" !'+" A2#!(),"KI3!$&" !$K"
*6.!.',";6(4
G
!(-,"!;+,"!2',"
&
!'++,"
!)+,"!2-,"
?!*+,"!'7,"!'2,"
!*,"!*,"I
J!7+,"!.',"J?#!*',"
?:
!-;,"!7-,"!72," !)(,"
!)(,"A!2;,"
!'7,"$ !-*,"
!-2,"!*+,"
?
!.-,"
*!7,"#!2-,"L?M1
!'-," !),"
!2*,"
=!;;,"
!;+," !'*,"
!'(,"!7,"!(,"&!2,"
E"!" 1
!)(,"?
I
)
'+'+.6'+;.&!-7*,"
&-'.
+>
6''(2%%
6 2 ' '' 2 7226%''%('%%A'%'B(%
%2'!8'%'R"#,/ '"!9568% 2 2 & '8%6$0+,01''962%"##/%2'%%3000
'
*% 22%-'2.'%2 6 ! ' 2% ( '' ' % '%2'27"##*2 2 ' ' 9 6 2 2 2 % 8 ( 2'2"###2' 2 ! % 5 &% "##* 2 4& 7!*3# % "7%%!*3( 8@ 7 K5 % %%%(2:*"+:,0
62222''&F(!2%''
-
+*,'+, 12-+++1*7+++ 1'+)+++12'(+++ !)-,"!'7,"!2,"!',"&
1;++++'*,
1'++++6;++++82++2(','2(-,;6.#I
?
2+++1*)-1;274:1.+2;.=!(),"D!(+,"D!.,"DA!(,"D!;,"
1;-*2*1';')*82++2(;,'422),;('*,*.)
E!.*,"!.(,"!;(,"
!'62,"$!)*,"I(*7A.$!).,"
EA!22,"!2," ;);-7
!-;,")2,=!2',"!'7,":!*,"!;,"!;,"!2,"!',"!',"!',"?DA
@!.;,"!'.,"!;.,"!2),"
(-,'-,=
6
6(%
2 %2 ' % '%3:#3:+
-
$
EG1AE*6'+,'+,'2++62(++
#
EJ
?ID &
E&+*+2)#!2(,"G !2),"!2*,"!),"#
/!7,"
?77,&
:
!2+,"!'+,"?
!-2,"!-;,"E$-7,
#
E$!)),"
1'+,';,
!.+," !*.," !(7,"!*2,"
!'*,"!'+,"!*,"!;,"!;,"
!2,"
A!',"#
/$
&.+,(),
#1G:
&9$G//&D;*,
8!77,"
92%(
'%-. ;
E 6 '22G2''
%2F%'2
' ' % "00+":0H ''222''
-
$
;-',-7,G!(,"$!7*,7-,"
$
$!)),"!(),"? .(,*',@!(',;(,"!2+,'+,"A!;',"&!)),"!'(,"
!"$!)*,)7,"!7(,7;,"!7(,.(,"!-(,7*,"!-.,-;,"
EI=.(,!"!"
!;*,"
A
'*62++, '6;+
&.*,
!'*,"
82++2!)(,"
!.,"!.,":'+,
!2,"!(,"!(," 9
2,
2++2!.2,"!';,"!'+,"&!.,"
!*,"!',"9
E
$-
$
& F2(2%(@
F% 'B %
% 2'/05/0:05$0,0530'('''-2.('27B2('F'F(( '2'822 ''2(
(F
%IBJ6B
! ' ' %'%
'222%822
-
G8
G$
9
$!)-," 3$!*;,"'-,#
!(7," !2+,"
!)," A$
?$$
0
!(;,"!2;," !;(,"1A7
AIA$
!)
EG
8
&9
E
A
&9$G//8 &9$G1 &9$GE&
A 1G 2++;8 &9$G &9$G/
19
7
6 2 ( 2%2'H2%%2
7% ' '2%26 22'2'"+3'2%-(%/00+"000%.-,.'"0'2%-"00%.
6 % 8 6 %8%&2F6
-
E1&$
1&$E
1&$
E /# !E%B"
!.
8?ED'AE
2++;
12+++
1';7#!2',":
?!'.,"!'2,"!'',"
""
)
#!2;,"!'',"8A
%
Q9G%G!QB>0&@G:9"EE%B'2,
2)2#)/(2/>.!"/
/ - 4- ;
&(&6*, %%0 "(-94#0$(%%. 84 $# %- 4((*62*/ " @6 -)9) )= "# 9(-)-%:) ;9)%)6&(86 ;4$6( G"96 /7*1 %# ) . " 4. 84 5 %- 4( - 7!6+
+ +'6
62( 2 %
!2'%6
'('%2(9%
6 %(
' 2 % '2(%(
'%2
-
;, &98 &9
18#
3
0
$
&
+
:1
G'--7N9&!9&"7**+O &:9&7**+
E%B? !"
&2+E
$ G
&
(-. =2 3003 * ) * %2&5 8=2
( % 5 2 ,$%3003*3$ P@& 225 )(=(-22.6(%' ' ' "#,*22&
2 ' 9C?
8 F2B -300". % "##* '''%(
2'2B 2 '2 ' 6 (
%(=2(%'''%2'%26I%(
%-42'%842'(.'%%(
'%''%96JB6300"*%):%57%%-* !)< 2"3
-
:
&9&
# &: E/8'--- &9''7+E
$
/ 8'-)*'27- &:@''78'--.HE1@81LM
019E;''-2)*'--.!)NO"$
/
#!#"
1G2+++
1&$E%B&?E?8$1!.NO2-"
/ !)NO"
/
19$
E
0J
&4( 3003 7 " *# 7%, 3003;""%5B'8&8=%=''''-.8 22 2'2E '' ' 7 2 '2 ''3/+
-
'/""
E
$ /LM!.NO"A#!.NO"
!" $
0
E
E !" !"
: #!"?
E#'--) J2A
%'('"/-%''%(5%''(.:$1'%,"1'22'(6 2 "##
-
=!
"
!"?
!)7,"
!)',"!*-,"!;',"$$!2-,"K!2.,"
(
>@V#:!>@#:"1'-726'-7;'--+6'--2'--)6'--7>@#:
G?E
!-"$1E
#
1 &99&@7**+!'--7 G"11
8
8@
!@"1EE$$
?!"@88E/$
@
E
E !$
E!.NO"G!.(,"
?
!7.,"1!;+,"!27,"
6"##*+"##,=('96'3+
-
$$
G
!-.,"!7',"
!;7,":
8E!-7,"
8'2!2++262++;"?
=
!)*,"!(*,"!(',"!;-,"!2+,"? !*',"!(+,"!'7,"
!-,"!.,"?!;,"
>
9
G*
I @$
@ *4@
=
*@
/@
G
*?@
6''B'(L'%-+""0+++-#.+.'3+
M!''('2B%%56&%3000=''B'(
!$&",-".5$/+,,
6 B2 ' & "##*(%8&%'&B&%56&)%E722-1%
-
E
=
G*9
*4
*8
!"
%
$
J
I
E
GE
E
8
3:
E
-
J%
=%%%W!W"%!"
I$#&0% =LX
#XXM
>'--76'---2774!"-+, ;;7 @ )+6-+,
2++';;*0 !0: " H;6*@I
8#&
42'A300
-
(++ 2+++ ?G1%E 1!@ " B !B "CC! "C!H "G!G1 "1!$ "
+"@ ?;+,'),2,!''"1G!',"8?!N'ONO+(,"@
@?0:
$,
2+++275;*5!'" ! '+" 11G
2=A
:=(-+@'--+('.5
E 5 $
E?A
#
G
&80: $@& @ !(!"!"$
D
?30:
3000'62!7* % ' "3% 230005&
)2 & "##* %+ *% " %%%" , ! 6 2 3*;"##* %5 7 84(42'8
%22%(
'&6'%%'2!2&%B%'
(-K2%(4( 9 "##* 6 8% ' C6,!7)*$1+30-&9K%K"##:6%'228% ' 62 *3#3*-$.5$"0+$"#.
! 73003:A'%*"' !%%542'8-76.
-
0
8 $:A$
11D
3$
!"4
D!"AD!"D!"4D!"
D!"
!2"
G!"88?!"9
1A8
= *#!
/=(;(= +++4*6(
. @(66 ;( &4 C ' 6 6 &( 6 (6
/( C / 9
26(&- %"A5 0A00 %"A$ "#A$ "0A A%" %0A# "%A0$ %5A# "5A% "%A#%
6 $A $$A K #A #5A A" $A" #%A%$ "A0 K A0%8( A% K K "%A$$ %0A# %A#$ "A# "A "A K "A/ #A$ #A"5 A%% "%A% "A# %#A$% "A%$ "A "5A55 "$A "0A#
)@4 #A" "A0# %"A"% "A ""A0 %A%" %0A5# %A0 "A#5 %#A%5 "$A5== A A K K K "A$ $A"# K K K K1 "A0 %A %A %A5 "A$0 A%0 %A %A" "A%" "A "A"$
66
= $$A0 A K %$A" K $A %A K $A K "#A%#
=2
-
K6#
H !"E*+,#E
3D 9
DD (+6*+,3A1J
J$>
&>
/*+,.+,
(+,'.,2(,9
9
%
A%
A %
A
0: 8
3A
#
2'2@3+
-
/A
0: AA
/A 1
I
&:8
%
//8:2++2A
0: > B0&
>A B AG
G
0:
H 101!'2"
!"
D!"4 A
D!"
0
&'--)
:
# 1!E1"I9I1$G#? '--2
E1?;?2+++0
2"##:!F((56"*-"HG/(
2&"##/7%"1%!%542'8
7 2 8 F4( ='' ' 8 72 8 %%4( '4=8 %@ (( 2
%%%%'F2E66%4( 2 ' % 2
%@% %''%!'(2%28 %
8=*/2(%8(% ' 84(2& '8=''
6%F(@%(
'6B!F2('4=86B('''H('
2( ( 6 ' B ' '
%2E2'42'%F'%6666'
&%!6'%
'''%'2
-
@%@>#01!@>#01"?@>#01A@>#01
!"!@>#01*'-726'-7."D!"!@>#01.'-7)6'--'"D!"
!@>#01)'--26'--."D!"
!@>#017'--)62++'"
/@ 1
!"D!"D!"4
G !"4 D!"D!"
@ 1
?
&@0: &8
%A
&: 2++'&:?0: &1 &:
8
&:
= 1/ ( =) (2/ =4 =>=/2+++
4- 3 4- . /1( &6 (( +
6( @D
$ % "0% $ 0 $ %$#$ $% $& " $5 "0 %"
$ %"# "# %"/ % "%$ 05% $ %"
2
-
&:
G &!'-()"I!
" #E*4&9809 0>
%A
? &
@%
G
3E %I% &:GG
9
!"
7& A A G#
0'--)&->&'--.
% 8
55!" 0: &&G!&&G"&0G!&0G"@ 85
)K3000A2&%&'62K3000!":2/
-
A
A & IJAJ
)' ! 8
&
>
I !"A
#
3
G@@?
8
E8@
0: ?
0: '-;+
$A
'-*+
/I@'-.+
"## 9 7)*$1 8G( 2 "
-
? A8
@
0: A
/
3
% :3
?#? %
0:
@H 101
I
A
H 101
#80G&&8
0:
$ D
@
8
=!" D !"
D !"
D!"9
&&A
8
0:
AB
2-&.'2%%2'-"#," * ! %'
0: 080!0 80"BC
&8@ '--2&:1
6 2 ' 84(2 6%6'
' 42 ' 8 ' 6 7
B646%%'!=%'7'6%22'
2
% "##$ ( ' 8 ! 65C'6%!1) $53#*+" 7 % %6 "% "% )%576
(4"#,,&2%B(%& !5676!=(*3*
-
GE1/09H@ &
&:1
?0: &:1&@
!"/A! A"&
@A&
#
@'-&:1'(A'-772+++@()-2-!"!77;,"5!-;,"!2(,"D
&0:
-+(;'--+I !"'--+
0: !
"
$
$!"3
0: !-"
0: #@@'-(2@IE#0: 9?&@
'-*+ &:A! &:"B@$A
!"
'-*+
' ' ' = 2 '% ' 48742'7
4(2&2 % 4 7
4(2H 2' 2E'='48742?
42 ' 8 -4=8. 300
-
A 3?H 101? 0:
@!@
#
@'.77*(2+72+++ $C1'.+62++&
8AK6:& '+++4 '7++4
D ?A=
76-,D'+,D7+, 8
0?D$D
3&:1'-77
B1
0: &:1
@;+
2);4!" '-.'';' '--*@)'2'G $
@A
%(&"##36&(7")&1
?$&" )&1 .
F * 2 "+$0 %5%
6)% 8 4(2 E B2(22B'2 I(% '2J -( 2.722E"#*,E
('4=82!
='' 3000 F/// %5 ='' 6 22':0#
4 (97
B646%%
4( & 9 > "### %6*3 , !< %A!%5!!%%7'6%
76"#*,,#*'%%6$)"52%57'6%%
(3%(%2%'%
''E%2''72%'2
> ( 4 300" ' 7%%B! 8% 65'>&(*6 $'%""-3.5/0+:
-
!'+,"7+,
@
G>
$G:$>>
&
&'--)!'."ID
;!';"@
5
8&! '"
1)*
9&8!A"!*"#
#
94( 7
B6"#,*8& ' 8 ' 6*3"$053#:+
-
=@
8 A
A
3
(
7 !>?2
3
+,-.,/0
12/
304
56.*56
73 /80,
0
./0,
5600
+ 02/
+,-5
0/.,
3
93
73 .,
73
.0+#
8: . ; / .:;?3,7>!@@'>:5///+/;+5-/A8>
.0+"
.0+!
-
#
&:1'-77B1A!';"8*++4*.+;76+*+!"(;6*)4!"'';.!":.,!'"
$!26;NO"0: !';"
&E
$ A J
J A&('
26(
H$
0A&8@A
!" (.
D
G:A
ALMJ;+,$(+,
/!"!"
(
&
>@
2I
( (2/ ,-A/'59
: / ..( $%&
(( #0$ $A#(2 %%"$ A#C? % A0C9 %%# A0/) 550 #A"
( 22 '
2E''''E2
24(&922 "##$ ' ' '' '
&'62( *3"3:5#*+"0:
-
0: 0:
@C$*++2++ $
#
!"=!"!"!'"@
3A3
$G
@=
'78&:1
?!*"
&:1@A
>
!22".67!"
A.67
&
#
=
;
-. 9 4( "#,* B 6 *3 " 1% ",5"/+(:+"">"##
-
/>
/
&
(%+*
#ALM
'62
)*
B
/'72'';.'.
=
-
I9CC
&:1&
!'.">
@
&
&&G@
AG
3 '
1)"+1*
&:1A@
8 &A(
' &'24B@1#@@.
7 G@&8
26; @AA
A
&2++62*+!"A
;'2;++6*++&
&:1!;"@&:1&
A%@2
%"##/64'''7%8%6!%7+% % &% 9 (430038@'7%8@59& 6% ' B 8 7$ *3 4( & 9 ( 4A%'?5&7%2""*+"3,
-
'*
&:1
:
:&:10: 0: @
&:1&
0!H#"!-"H#
>&H#
G09
G
B0: . %
@JJ
1=
1
D&
&
8
1 =/)=$BB= &
/(
& F F4)*,). F F. F F. ( ! F
6(3(.(( ! F
6(39: ! F&M--).+?9@"9-@"
=''2%%2''(B!!22%
2 %B2 % '@ F2 ( ' : 2 2 /B 22% %' :22,%'@22%%B(''2/00%22 '2
F '2%6F''22 '% ' 2 ' ' F % ' ' 2 F2((2F'!''I%J2 2%%''B'%2222'B' 2
%%'2( % 2 % (%F2 '2":;%2 (% '%2'
-
G
0: (24'-7)'--';'
(6*
!(+"
8!;)" 2 &:1/
&:1
&:1B10: !;)"0:
'--(=B#@@1#'--.@:.
A=0H>@%:?$
0: @%:&:1
!;)"K&
.+,'72
*+,
$)+,D
3A'*,&:1A
A@&:1$7+,I
-
=**)?
5 C9%8%8 2H C9%8 CA9'5 C9%88H89%88(89(!=%?6
5 C9%8C%A&?H C9%8'%CA?%& 8@!=%?6
+ 0,
0,560
7756
0
560
77560
+
7
,7
7/
/6
71
3
-
&
&:1/@!;)"&.+++'--'6'--*3(+,2++A?'+++(7+02++++A:
250:
24;!B@1#@"
0: &:1&:1A!&8B#&80G9#1105&N;(;*O"&
0: 0: &8A0:
@>00:
'--*6'--7
&:1=$$9>'--)6'--70:
@&&:1&80: 0: '--7
B
'--7?&0 808% @0 80
&8/0 80&:1 '--+
&:1A
-
&:1#&:1#80G&?
2++'!"@0: @&:1
90: &:11&:1+(6+*?=!"D!"&&:1
/A!"/D!"D!"AA
.67 13
/
A
:
A AI
#&:1
D8@
/
& G09 8 3
-
?5
"B
(
=4
;04
2
-
3
;
1
(
;
)
&
(
L
&
*3
A
E
/
/
-;B
:
:
&
1
;1,&1
;:.
/
"
/
@;
M"%
;B
:
)
&*33
G
*3N
1
&
":
5
5#
)0
0A
0A
0A
@;
M0%
;B
:
)
&*
3G
*3N
=
&
#:
0
#
;
5A
$A$
#$A$
#
.1
&,,M
"
+
:)
*3N
N
&
"
;(
$
%?
A
A0
%A0
%
1
+,M$
5$
.
:)
&
*
3
1
'&
%",
0
0?0
0$A
A
$A
+
,M
0
@6
9
;
B
:
)D
*
NG
6-
*
3
=
&
)0
%?
%"A
A
%"A
+
,M5
$%
.
+
&
*3N
1
&
5,
0
$?
#A
A
#A
+
,M
@6
9
;
B
*
N
&
"
8
0
#?
0
"0A
A
"0A
+
,M
.
+
&
*3N
G-
-*3N
'
&
%%
;(
#?
#
A
A
A
+
,M
5*
&
&
:
)
8
B
*
KK
,
(
(
$
)
5"
%#A
A
$A
5
..
1
8
(
3
N
0
1
18+M%
.
:)
&*
N
'
&
%#
%0;
0A
#A
#A
0)
2
8H;
M""
.
:)
.
*3
'
&
#
.4
50
)0
0A
%#A
%#A
8H;
M$#$
+
.
:)
&*
3G
9
*3
'
&
0
0
%$?
A
%A
%A
/.& 6( "5$$.(8>&; /6* -&.((
-
%&&'()&*&'(,*,**
?1 ((2"/ ( 6 A % "5 %@( 5 %A 00 #"144@ 4>*6 " # 0 #1@6* 5 %
86(:) > %05" 0$"& 67!6- -!,
? (@
2( % %% 53 #5+(. ""8*. ;9 "
$"& !++ +!6++
$"& +!'6- -!7,
?
-
?1 ((2"/+@+0(/
/+ ' 4 '
H &
4-&& H %
?
& 6( 00 A %#$# "%"()9 6( # A "
6( # A " $& 6+!-++ ,!++
"? ? A
.(( A"% "% #
. 4( "# $$ # 0
. 0 "5 00 18 %#$# "%"
1@6* 5 "0$"& 8,!8- 86!,87
? (@3 %.;9
$"& ,++ ,+$"& 8,!-8- 86!7'7
?
-
?1 ((2"/B=
/+ ' 4 '
H &
4-&& H %
?
!" #
$%& #
' % ' ( ' &)
* ( + ( # #, &&
- & (&& '$ + # . &&" / %0& 1$%%
/ 23-% %
!"#1 4 - &, *&' 0 $3' 5! &
$%&6 % & # #*%$& '",( &
' ()
* $+%5( &572 5( 8&&576
!"#"$ $# %!###'( $) &*$ +',-.,/"0##12*#!*3!$)#!*#*, "$#!$"$"#*
'/$"#1/)$)#14$#,"
4 5*$)##& , ** 6
$"##&&% &( ,*-*%7%
-
ForewordExecutive SummaryThe EvaluationIntroductionRationale, Purpose, and Method of EvaluationUnderstanding Poverty and VulnerabilityAnalyzing Capital Assets and Transforming ProcessesSummary of Key Findings from Case StudiesLessons from ADB Operations in Freshwater AquacultureRecommendations
The Case StudiesOverview of Small-scale Freshwater Aquaculture in BangladeshFarming Carps in Leased Ponds by Groups in Chandpur, BangladeshLivelihood Profiles of Fish Farmers in Kishoreganu, BangladeshOverview of Freshwater Aquaculture of Tilapia in the PhilippinesFarming Tilapia in Ponds in Central Luzon,Philippines Tilapia Cage Farming in Lake Taal, Batangas, PhilippinesOverview of Small-scale Freshwater Aquaculture in ThailandDevelopment of Technology and Extension for Small-scale Fish Farms in Northeastern Thailand
Appendixes
