감사원 세월호 감사 자료

15

description

감사원 세월호 침몰사고 감사 중간결과

Transcript of 감사원 세월호 감사 자료

  • - -

    2014. 7. 8.

    .

  • .

    .

    1.

    2.

    3.

    .

  • - 1 -

    .

    () (4. 16.)

    - , ,

    ,

    () (* )

    () '14. 5. 14. 5. 30. (1 13), 6. 9. 6. 20. (2 10)

    ,

    ,

    * , (4. 16.4. 19.)

    () 7. 9.() 10:00

    ()

  • - 2 -

    .

    1.

    , , ,

    *()() ()()

    (8) , () (-)

    *

    25%

    * 3/ ( *, )

    -

    *

    , (24.326.9%), '11. 9

    ( ) ( )

    804 3,981 24.3%( ) 750 3,000 26.9%( )

    * ()

    () ,

    54, 981 (*5. 27. )

    - , ('12. 9'13. 2) (921)

    (3,794) (24.2%) ,

    '13. 3

  • - 3 -

    '13. 1

    ()

    1)

    - 100

    ,

    ( ) , 63

    ( ) 5 () 37

    - ,

    -

    *

    ,

    (1,5131,077) ('13. 2)

    : 305(54 5.65) 162(54 3) ( )

    * - ( ) 6

    , 2)(11.7> 10.6) 3)(10.5> 10)

    , ( 4 )

    ,

    (D-), 66 58

    1) :

    2) ( ) : 26m/s ()

    3) ( ) : (30) 10

  • - 4 -

    3

    4 '13. 2. 15.(), () ,

    - '13. 2. 16.()18.()

    , , ,

    2. 19.() 9 ()

    , 14

    '13. 2. 12.

    ,

    - (),

    (3,963)( 148)

    ( 3,794, 97) ( 16951 )

    - 12 3

    '13. 2. 25. (5. 23. )

    ()

    ( ) () , ,

  • - 5 -

    -

    2,142()185,

    3 657150

    , 118 ('14. 14) 56

    -

    (*, 18 20 )

    12 30

    ,

    ( )

    - ,

    ( ) ,

    ( )

    - , (97) 88 185

    ,

    -

    4)

    , '02

    ,

    4) 46

  • - 6 -

    2.

    (08:4808:58) , ,

    ,

    (200 ) 1

    1 ,

    - , 123(100)

    ,

    (123) 09:16 11:19 (OSC)

    - 9( 13) ,

    VTS 82

    (, ) , 18

    - (08:48) 08:50

    ,

    16 09:06

    * 08:55 VTS

    08:50 , 5

    2 2

    ( 18:00 09:00) 1 2

    * , VTS CCTV

  • - 7 -

    (08:5809:30(123 ))

    ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    (* )

    * ()-()-(),

    - , ,

    (08:5509:27, 32)

    (123) 09:03 ,

    (VHF CH16) 2 (09:2628)

    () 09:10 2

    ( * 7)

    (VTS) 09:0709:37 30

    ()

    - (122) 09:04

    ,

    ( 122) 45

    ,

    ,

    (*, 122 )

  • - 8 -

    - 09:24 VTS

    , ( )

    ,

    () 08:58 , , ,

    (B511 ) ,

    300

    - 122

    () ,

    (122) (100m ) 513()

    09:13 , ( 12:19 ) 513 (09:20 ) 11:10 ( ) , 09:35

    , 10:25 ( 11:28 ) 10:45

    ( ) ,

    - () 08:58 VTS 09:10

    - () 08:52 ,

    09:13 (1)

    * ,

    () (10:0305) (10:11), 10:37

  • - 9 -

    (90%) (09:3010:28)

    ,

    (123) ,

    - , 09:30

    ,

    (123) 09:35 400m

    , ,

    - 09:49(62 ) 1 ,

    (* )

    -

    (123) 09:30 , 09:37

    ,

    - 09:43 TRS

    -

    ,

    09:48 12 ,

    * 09:50 7

  • - 10 -

    () ,(* 09:37, 09:43)

    - (123, ) ,

    ,

    () 09:37 123

    123

    () 09:47 123

    ()

    3009

    *

    * 3009 ,

    - (09:53)

    () 10:17(100 ) ,

    (- ) 15

    -

    ( 3 )

    ( ) 4('10'13) (* 57%)

    * (A) (2)

    - -- 44 7

    ( 3 ) ,

  • - 11 -

    3.

    () ,

    ,

    * : () - () - ()

    ,

    () ( , ) (1 , 6)

    - ,

    () 477, 61,8(11:00) () 476, 34,19(11:30)

    - (14:00,

    368 16:30, 164),

    190 190 , 13:12

    , 14:00 368

    - (13:55) , (14:25)

    * , 13:17

    () , 09:45 , (, 10:0010:37)

    ()

    () 09:40 , 11:06

    () 11:31

  • - 12 -

    () 08:55 (09:33), 6

    ( ) 123(09:43, 10:46) 23

    , ( 5, 14:39)

    ( ) 6 160 ,

    , ( 6, 16:33)

    () , ,

    ,

    11:01 ( ), ( )

    - (38),

    4. 18. 11

    () , 12:30

    () '13. 8 ( ),

    ( 2 )

    () ,

    ()

    ,

    () '14. 2 (),

  • - 13 -

    .

    () , ,

    ,

    () : , ,

    40 ( )

    ,

    ( 5),

    () , , ,

    ,

    ,

    ,