8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 1/44
WACANA HAK ASASIWACANA HAK ASASI
MANUSIAMANUSIA
Islam & Human RightsIslam & Human Rights inin thethe
Federal Constitution of Federal Constitution of
MalaysiaMalaysia
Ibnu Ramlee al-TayyibeeIbnu Ramlee al-Tayyibee
2 April 2006 / 3 Rabiulawal2 April 2006 / 3 Rabiulawal
1427H1427H
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 2/44
OUTLINES OF DISCUSSIONOUTLINES OF DISCUSSION1. The Supremacy of the
Constitution
2. Position of Islam
3. Fundamental Liberties
4. ISA, OSA, AUKU
5. Related Issues
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 3/44
SUPREMACY OFSUPREMACY OF
CONSTITUTIONCONSTITUTION
This constitution is the Supreme
law of the Federation and any lawpassed after Merdeka Day which isinconsistent with this Constitution shall,to the extent of the inconsistency, be
void.(Article 4)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 4/44
Historical BackgroundHistorical BackgroundUndang-Undang Melaka
Undang-Undang Kedah (1650 M)
Undang-Undang 99 Perak
Batu Bersurat Terengganu (1303M)
Undang-Undang Pahang (1600M) ( Prof. Ahmad, Jurnal Hukum 1997, p.119-137.(
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 5/44
THE POSITION OF ISLAMTHE POSITION OF ISLAM
Religion of the Federation (Article3)
Conference of Rulers (Article 38)Subject matter of federal and
State laws (Article 74, 9th Schedule
– State List, List for States Of Sabah And Sarawak
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 6/44
IslamIslam
Kes Che Omar bin Che Soh v PP[1988]
Kes Meor Atiqulrahman & Others vFatimah & Others. [2005]MLJ 375
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 7/44
The constitutionality of Shariah CourtThe constitutionality of Shariah Court
In all States:
By virtue of:
Article 74
Ninth Schedule;Item 1 of the State List.(ListII)
In Federal Territories:
Ninth Schedule; Item 6(e) of the Federal List.(List I)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 8/44
Article 121(1)(A)Article 121(1)(A)
The courts referred to in
clause (1) shall have no jurisdiction in respect of
any matter within the
jurisdiction of the Syariahcourts.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 9/44
FUNDAMENTAL LIBERTIESFUNDAMENTAL LIBERTIES
The right to life and liberty (Article 5)
The prohibition of slavery and forcedlabour (Article 6)
The protection against retrospectivecriminal laws and repeated trials (Article 7)
Equality before the law (Article 8)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 10/44
Continued:Continued:
The prohibition against banishment andfreedom of movement (Article 9)
The freedom of speech, assembly and
association (Article 10)The freedom of religion (Article 11)
The rights in respect of education (Article 12)
The right to property (Article 13)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 11/44
3. PREVENTIVE LAWS3. PREVENTIVE LAWS
PROVISIONS OF FEDERALCONSTITUTION – A.149
SAFEGUARDS UNDER THE
CONSTITUTION – A.151
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 12/44
Purpose of Preventive LawsPurpose of Preventive Laws
Article 149Article 149 WHEREAS action has been taken and further actionis threatened by a substantial body of persons bothinside and outside Malaysia -
(1) to cause, and to cause a substantial
number of citizens to fear, organised violenceagainst persons and property; and
(2) to procure the alteration, otherwise than by
lawful means, of the lawful Government of Malaysiaby law established;
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 13/44
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 14/44
Definition of Terrorism (S.2Definition of Terrorism (S.2
ISA)ISA)“terrorist” means any person who -
(a) by the use of any firearm, explosive or ammunitionacts in a manner prejudicial to the public safety or to themaintenance of public order or incites to violence or
counsels disobedience to the law or to any lawful order;(b) carries or has in his possession or under his controlany firearm, ammunition or explosive without lawfulauthority therefore; or
(c) demands, collects or receives any supplies for theuse of any person who intends or is about to act, or hasrecently acted, in a manner prejudicial to public safety orthe maintenance of public order
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 15/44
Categories of Cases under ISACategories of Cases under ISA
Criminal CasesCriminal Cases
Preventive CasesPreventive Cases
- Power to order detention or restriction- Power to order detention or restriction
of persons (S.8) – “…Minister isof persons (S.8) – “…Minister is
satisfied that the detention of anysatisfied that the detention of anyperson is necessary…person is necessary…
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 16/44
POWERS OF ARRESTSPOWERS OF ARRESTS
Section 72. Seizability andSection 72. Seizability and
bailability of offences.bailability of offences.
Section 73. Power to detainSection 73. Power to detain
suspected persons.suspected persons.
Section 11Section 11
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 17/44
LEGAL PROCESSLEGAL PROCESS
(1) Representation (S.11)(1) Representation (S.11)
(2) Review (S.13)(2) Review (S.13)
(3) Judicial Review (A.5)(3) Judicial Review (A.5)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 18/44
HABEAS CORPUS HABEAS CORPUS
PROCEDURES IN MAKING APROCEDURES IN MAKING A
COMPLAINTCOMPLAINT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODECRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
(REVISED 1999) (ACT 593)(REVISED 1999) (ACT 593)
S.365-374S.365-374
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 19/44
EXTRAORDINARY POWERS OFEXTRAORDINARY POWERS OF
ISAISA Curability of Detention OrderCurability of Detention Order
Restriction on Judicial ReviewRestriction on Judicial Review
Different Approaches of Judicial ReviewDifferent Approaches of Judicial Review
Retrospective Effect of Amendments toRetrospective Effect of Amendments to
ISAISA
Legality of Usage of Lethal Weapons inLegality of Usage of Lethal Weapons in
Effecting ArrestEffecting Arrest Overwhelming Powers of RegulationsOverwhelming Powers of Regulations
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 20/44
Cadangan SuruhanjayaCadangan Suruhanjaya
Tertakluk kepada Seksyen 8 dantindakan tersebut adalah prejudis
kepada keselamatan M’sia. Tempoh penahanan tidak lebih dari
30 hari.Hak dilawati oleh keluarga dan
peguam tidak lewat daripada 7 haridari tarikh ditangkap.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 21/44
ISA v. ISLAMISA v. ISLAM
BERCANGGAH DENGAN PRINSIPASAS KEADILAN
DAKWAAN TIDAK DIBUKTIKAN DIMAHKAMAH TERBUKA. TIADA HAK UNTUK MEMBELA DIRI PENAHANAN MESTI BERSEBAB
DENGAN ALASAN YANG KUAT DANDIBUKTIKAN.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 22/44
ISA v IslamISA v Islam
TEMPOH PENAHANAN YANG LAMA? MEMBUKA PINTU KEBATILAN,
MENGUNDANG KEZALIMAN MELANGGARI NILAI AKHLAK ISLAM MEMBERI KESAN/AKIBAT YANG
TIDAK SEPATUTNYA TERHADAP TERTUDUH
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 23/44
AUKU 1971AUKU 1971Section 15
No person, while he is a student of
the U, shall be a member of,associate with, any society,
political party, any organisation,body or group …whether or not it
is established under any law, inthe U or outside the U
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 24/44
……except as may be provided byexcept as may be provided by
or under the Constitution, or or under the Constitution, or except as may be approved inexcept as may be approved in
advance in writing by theadvance in writing by the VCVC..
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 25/44
Section 15(3)Section 15(3)
No person, while he is astudent of the U, shall express
or do anything which may beconstrued as expressingsupport, sympathy or
opposition to any politicalparty
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 26/44
OSAOSA
AKTA RAHSIA RASMI
KES EZAM
KES IRENE FERNANDEZ
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 27/44
POLICE ACT 1967POLICE ACT 1967
27. Power to regulateassemblies, meetings and
processions.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 28/44
Cadangan SuruhanjayaCadangan Suruhanjaya
Sek. 27 mesti menghayati semangatPerkara 10 (2)(3) Perlembagaan.
Sek. 27(2) meletakkan beban yangberat kepada penganjur untuk meyakiniKPD agar perhimpunan tidakmendatangkan mudarat…
Takrifan “keselamatan” terlalu umumdan boleh/seringkali dimanupulasikan.
(lihat ms. 338-341)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 29/44
POLICE ACTPOLICE ACT
These sections to be abolished.These sections to be abolished.
27A. Power to stop certain activities whichtake place other than in a public place.
27B. Use of force in dispersing or arresting
persons pursuant to section 27 or 27A
“…any police officer or any other person actingin aid of a police officer may do all thingsnecessary for dispersing them and for
arresting them or any of them pursuant tosection 27(6) or 27A(5),”
( Laporan Suruhanjaya ms. 354)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 30/44
Perlembagaan Mengapaperluhad?
Hak-hak Had-had
The right to life and liberty (Article 5)
The prohibition of slavery andforced labour (Article 6)
The protection againstretrospective criminal lawsand repeated trials (Article 7)
Equality before the law (Article8)
The prohibition against
banishment and freedom of movement (Article 9)
The freedom of speech,assembly and association (Article 10)
The freedom of religion
(Article 11)The rights in respect of
Perkara 10 (2), (4)
Perkara 149
Akta Polis 1967
Akta PersatuanAkta Keselamatan
Dalam Negeri 1960(ISA)
Akta Rahsia Rasmi1972 (OSA)
Akta Hasutan 1948
Akta Universiti & KolejUniversiti 1971(AUKU)
Akta Penerbitan danPercetakan 1984
etc
etc
Keharmoniankaum
Keselamatannegara
(menurut Kerajaan)
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 31/44
Apa kata Prof Undang-undangApa kata Prof Undang-undang "Absolute freedom does not exist in any country, but restrictions must be reasonable.
Just because the Constitution gives Parliament the power to make or amend laws as itdeems fit, it does not mean the laws or amendments are constitutional if they violate thespirit of the Constitution," Assoc Prof Dr Azmi Sharom from UM said.
"Many of these laws go far beyond the constitutionally permissible restrictions. Ourlegislature behave as if they are supreme and are not restrained by the Constitution,"Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM) legal advisor Prof Dr Shad Saleem Faruqi said.
The law professors said the problem also lies in the reluctance of courts to examine andchallenge these unconstitutional laws.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 32/44
Apa kata Prof Undang-undangApa kata Prof Undang-undang
"The courts may not be able to challenge Parliament's power tomake laws but they can challenge the reasonable-ness andconstitutionality of these laws," Azmi argued.
"Democracy requires consultations before decisions are made and
policies framed. The existence of alternative sources of informationand centres of power such as NGOs are crucial,” Shad said.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 33/44
Related IssuesRelated Issues
Freedom of Religion & Apostasy
Equality & Gender discrimination
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 34/44
Perkara 11Perkara 11“ Tiap-tiap orang adalah berhak
menganut dan mengamalkanugamanya dan tertakluk pada fasal (4),
mengembangkan agamanya”
“(4) State law and federal law may
control or restrict the propagation of any religious doctrine or belief amongpersons professing the religion of Islam.”
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 35/44
Isu Murtad;Isu Murtad; ““mereka” nak:mereka” nak:Kuasa menentukan status agama
seseorang yang sudah Islam ialah
Mahkamah Sivil.Mahkamah Syariah tiada bidang kuasa.
Peruntukan mengenai hukuman tidakSah.
Mahkamah Syariah- unconstitutional!
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 36/44
StrategiStrategi “Mereka”“Mereka”IFD – IRC – ICMAda satu suruhanjaya agama yang
menanggani isu-isu membabitkanketidakpuasan hal-hal keagamaantermasuk yg. Melibatkan murtad.
AlhamduliLah, usaha ini GAGAL.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 37/44
Strategi ke-2,”mereka”:Strategi ke-2,”mereka”:
Pinda Perkara121(1)(A) !
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 38/44
Article 121(1)(A)Article 121(1)(A)
The courts referred to in
clause (1) shall have no jurisdiction in respect of
any matter within the
jurisdiction of the Syariahcourts.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 39/44
Prof. Ahmad Ibrahim:Prof. Ahmad Ibrahim:
One important effect of the
amendment is to avoid for thefuture any conflict betweenthe decisions of the Syariah
courts and Civil courts,…
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 40/44
Pertahankan 121(1)(A)Pertahankan 121(1)(A)121(1A) Tak perlu dipindaPeruntukan lain yang perlu dipinda
eg. Jadual 9 Senarai I&IISek. 51 LRAEnakmen Kawalan Penyebaran
Agama lainSeragamkan Enakmen Murtad eg.
Negeri Sembilan.
T ki iT ki i A l i k t kA l i k t k
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 41/44
TerkiniTerkini…Apa lagi kata mereka……Apa lagi kata mereka… KUALA LUMPUR , Mar 14 (IPS) - Moderate Muslims and non-Muslims,
fearful of incursions by Islamic 'Shariah' law into their private space,have launched a movement to rediscover Malaysia's secular
constitution and restore it as the country's supreme law. In a nationwidecampaign they will persuade Malaysians to endorse a memorandum worded inguarded English that ''reaffirms the supremacy of the constitution''.
The campaign is being organised by the Bar Council and 'Article 11' -- acoalition of 14 non-governmental organisations, named after theconstitutional provision that upholds fundamental rights for allMalaysians ''regardless of religion, race, descent, place of birth or
gender''. Significant is the participation of 'Sisters in Islam', a leading Muslimfeminist group.
Together, the campaigners demand that the Malaysian government and the judiciary uphold the supremacy of the constitution; ensure governancein accordance with the constitution; demand that the governmentreaffirm that Malaysia is not a theocratic state and urge thegovernment to recognise the independence of the judiciary.
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 42/44
Dan lagi…Dan lagi…
''We want to reaffirm the supremacy of the secular constitutionbecause there is a danger Malaysia is being turned into an Islamicstate in a silent and insidious manner,'' said lawyer Malik Imtiaz Sarvar,an outspoken defender of secularism, civil law and democratic rights.
''The minds of politicians, judges and civil servants have becomeclouded as they see themselves as Muslims first and citizenssecond,'' said Malik. ''The moderate Muslim majority is silent and we
want to awaken them with our campaign.''
''Malaysia is not an Islamic state, Malaysia is a secular state and theconstitution is the supreme law of the land,'' said Imtiaz, a keycampaigner for secular rights.[NOTA: Tidak ada satu perkataan ‘sekular’ pun dalam Perlembagaan]
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 43/44
Isu diskriminasi WanitaIsu diskriminasi Wanita::Hakim wanita
Kesaksian wanita
Harta Pesaka
Harta Sepencarian
Poligami
Fasakh
8/14/2019 Wacana Ham 2 - Dr Zulfakar
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/wacana-ham-2-dr-zulfakar 44/44
Sekian.Sekian.
Terima Kasih.Terima Kasih.
........ ق اعوا فيى أ عك رسوله الؤمونWassalam
Top Related