8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
1/43
Nos. 14-556, 14-562, 14-571 & 14-574
WILSON-EPES PRINTINGCO., INC. – (202) 789-0096 – W ASHINGTON, D. C. 20002
IN THE
#$%&%'() $*')+'*,%'-./*%0' *1*%2'
————
J AMES OBERGEFELL, ET AL., AND BRITTANI HENRY , ET AL.,
PETITIONERS,
v.
RICHARD HODGES, DIRECTOR, OHIO DEPARTMENT OFHEALTH, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
————
V ALERIA T ANCO, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
WILLIAM EDWARD “BILL” H ASLAM, GOVERNOR OFTENNESSEE, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
———— A PRIL DEBOER, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
RICK SNYDER, GOVERNOR OF MICHIGAN, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
————
GREGORY BOURKE, ET AL., AND TIMOTHY LOVE, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
STEVE BESHEAR, GOVERNOR OF K ENTUCKY , ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
————
On Writs of Certiorari to theUnited States Court of Appeals
for the Sixth Circuit
————
BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE MAE KUYKENDALL,DAVID UPHAM AND MICHAEL WORLEYIN SUPPORT OF NEITHER PARTY ANDURGING AFFIRMANCE ON QUESTION 1
————
MICHAEL T. WORLEY
272 Wymount TerraceProvo, UT 84604(818) [email protected]
M AE K UYKENDALL
Counsel of RecordMichigan State University648 N. Shaw Lane Rm 366East Lansing, MI 48824(517) [email protected]
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
2/43
!
!"#$%&'( *+#$#(%#,
#$!% &'!() *++'(%%(% ,$( -.(%,!/01 2/(% ,$( 3/.'4
,((0,$ 56(0+6(0, '(-.!'( * %,*,( ,/ 7!8(0%( * 6*'4
'!*9( &(,:((0 ,:/ ;(/;7( /) ,$( %*6( %( &(4
8*.%( !"#$# +!%*9'(( /0 ,$( %(8/0+ -.(%,!/01 2/(%
,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0, '(-.!'( * %,*,( ,/ '(8/94
0!?( * 6*''!*9( &(,:((0 ,:/ ;(/;7( /) ,$( %*6( %(<
:$(0 ,$(!' 6*''!*9( :*% 7*:).77> 7!8(0%(+ *0+ ;('4
)/'6(+ /.,4/)4%,*,(=
!"#$# 0/,( &(7/: ,$(!' @*'!/.% ;/%!,!/0% /0 ,$(
%(8/0+ -.(%,!/0A
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
3/43
!!
%-./# '0 1'(%#(%$
B*9(
CDEF#GHI BJEFEI#E2 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA !
#5KLE H3 5D#MHJG#GEF AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA !@
GI#EJEF#F H3 !%&'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA N
F#5#EOEI# AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA P
5JQDOEI# AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA R
GA #$!% S/.', *@/!+% (U:!,$ )(:
(
%,*,( )*6!7> 7*: 8*%(% :/.7+ $*@( ,/ &(8/6(
)(+('*7 !%%.(% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA NZ
5A I.6('/.% )(+('*7 8/.', 8*%(% :/.7+
'(%.7, )'/6 * 7!8(0%!09 +(8!%!/0 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA NR
KA 5% [.+9( F.,,/0 0/,(+Y * 7!8(0%!09
+(8!%!/0 :/.7+ +'*6*,!8*77> (
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
4/43
!!!
SA ()*#+, *. /#0,#+#1 *0+ /,$(' '!9$,4,/4
6*''> 8*%(% +!+ 0/, '(-.!'( :$/7(%*7(8$*09(% ,/ %,*,( 7*:A AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA P]
GGGA "#$% (
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
5/43
!@
%-./# '0 -"%2'+&%$
*345678
S*%(%
!210 *. 3"#45Y
R]V 3A]+ N^R bZ,$ S!'A P\NNc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PT
!2)64#*7 ')8697 *. :1;< =#09Y
N]] FAS, PZZP bP\N]c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA NT
!+>7+;01+24 *. ?#$5102@YZ\^ DAFA R`V bNVVPc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA N\
:)22#7 *. ')++7$4#$84Y
^\N DAFA ]TN bNVTNc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA NN
:)@4#$ *. 3$517A70Y
TR\ 3A]+ ]ZP bP\N^c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA N]
:0)B+ *. :85"1+Y
V^T 3AF.;;AP+ NNT\ b2A D,*$ P\N]c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA N`
'10+7@ *. 35792)+Y
]NN IAdAP+ T^T bO!8$A NV`Nc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA ̀
'#4< )A :)70+7 *. C9)07@Y
ZPN DAFA Z\T bNVVTc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA P\
')99#+@ *. D10>70 D7#,54@Y
Z\] DAFA NNZ bNVVPc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA ]
'01#, *. :)07+Y^PV DAFA NV\ bNVTRc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA NV
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
6/43
@
E7:)70 *. 3+ *. D122)$>Y
P\N DAFA ZRP bNV\Rc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA V
J7+20#$> *. 35)7"1>7Y V\ FAdA]+ ZRR
b#(00A P\\Pc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA ̀
(1B07+$7 *. K7L1@Y
Z]V DAFA ZZ` bP\\]c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA NN
()A4)+ *. 37$F< )A E764. )A '5#9207+ M C1"#9
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
7/43
@!
%#$5179 D. *. =70192 E.O
^VN DAFA NN\ bNV`Vc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PT
%8065< *. ?1"@7
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
8/43
@!!
R5)97 R)"7+F@ D71945 *. (1$>7
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
9/43
@!!!
DAFA S/0%,A 56(0+A aG_ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA N\
3(+('*7 *0+ F,*,( L(9!%7*,!/0
S*7!)/'0!* 5%%(6&7> K!77 `^V bP\\Zc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PR
S*7!)/'0!* F(0*,( K!77 PT^ bP\N]c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PR
MA[A J(%A NT\Y RN,$ S/09A bNVN\c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PP
MA[A J(%A PTVY ZR,$ S/09A bNV\\c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PP
FA[A J(%A P`Y `\,$ S/09A bNV^Tc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PP
H,$(' 5.,$/'!,!(%
5%%/8!*,(+ B'(%%Y Q*> 6*''!*9(1 I/',$ S*'/7!0*
/))!8!*7 '(%!90% bH8,A NRY P\N^c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA P`
K(>/0+ F*6(4F(< O*''!*9(1 5 I(: F,'*,(9!8 _!%!/0
3/' 577 H.' 3*6!7!(% *0+ J(7*,!/0%$!;% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA N^
S/6;7*!0,Y D7+270@)+ *. K#667$1+)7 ')8+4
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
10/43
!<
2ESL5J5#GHI H3 GI2EBEI2EISE bNTTRc AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA NP
E+:*'+ F,(!0Y I1@4 1+2 I07@7+4 I0)6)@72
!"7+2"7+4@ 4) 457 S+#472 34147@ ')+@4#484#)+
?7,102#+, %100#1,7 Z G%%.(% !0 L(9*7 F8$/7*'%$!;
N bP\\^c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PP
Q//97( F8$/7*' %(*'8$(%Y K(%, !0,('(%,% /) ,$( 8$!7+ AA V
Q//97( F8$/7*' %(*'8$(%Y B'(%.6;,!/0 /) B*,('0!,> PT
O*( g.>X(0+*77Y ! R1< G84 )A 457 31"7V37L
%100#1,7 %7@@Y #$( I(: e/'X #!6(% bO*> P^Y
P\NPcY B*9( 5]N AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA ̂
F,(@(0 QA S*7*&'(%! *0+ Q(00* F!0(7A K57 =1<
%100#1,7 '1@7@ 1+2 C727019 Q80#@2#$4#)+W G+ R5<
K57 E)"7@4#$ ?7914#)+@ HL$764#)+ 4) C727019
Q80#@2#$4#)+ #@ !0$51#$ 1+2 35)892 ;7 G*7008972
bI/',$:(%,('0 B.&7!8 L*: J(%(*'8$ B*;(' I/A N^4
Z\ P\N^c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA N^
#'*0%8'!;, /) H'*7 5'9.6(0,Y S+#472 34147@ *.
R#+2@)0Y N]] FAS, PRTZ bP\N]c AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PN
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
11/43
N
&(%#+#$%$ '0 !"#$# %
!"#$# *'( 7(9*7 %8$/7*'% :$/ &(7!(@( ,$*, ,$(
3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0, +/(% 0/, '(-.!'( %,*,(% ,/ 7!4
8(0%( %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9(A !"#$# +!%*9'(( /0 ,$( *04
%:(' ,/ ,$( %(8/0+ -.(%,!/0 '(9*'+!09 '(8/90!,!/0 /)
/.,4/)4%,*,( 6*''!*9(% *0+ 8!,( ,$(!' @*'!/.% ;/%!,!/0%
&(7/: *0+ !0 ,$( *;;(0+! *7%/ +!%*9'(( /0
:$(,$(' %,*,(%Y *8,!09 ,$'/.9$ *0> /'9*0 /) ,$( 9/@4
('06(0, %,'.8,.'(Y %$/.7+ 7(9*7!?( ,$( 7!8(0%!09 /)
%*6(4%(< 6*''!*9(A !"#$# )!7( ,/9(,$(' ,/ $!9$7!9$,
X(> !%%.(% ,$*, :!77 /88.' %$/.7+ ,$!% S/.', '.7( ,$*,
,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0, '(-.!'(% %,*,(% ,/ !%%.(
7!8(0%(% ,/ ,:/ ;(/;7( /) ,$( %*6( %( 8/0,'!&.,!/0 !0,(0+(+ ,/ ).0+ !,%
;'(;*'*,!/0 /' %.&6!%%!/0A I/ (+.8*,!/0*7 !0%,!,.,!/0 $*% (04
+/'%(+ /' )!0*08(+ ,$!% &'!()A 577 ;*',!(% $*@( 8/0%(0,(+ ,/ ,$(
)!7!09 /) ,$!% &'!()A #$( B(,!,!/0('% !0 *77 )/.' 8*%(% 8/0%(0,(+ ,/
,$!% &'!() *0+ * 7(,,(' 0/,!09 8/0%(0, !% /0 )!7( :!,$ ,$( S7('XA
K7*0X(, 8/0%(0, )'/6 '(%;/0+(0,% !0 *77 )/.' 8*%(% !% 0/,(+ !0
8/66.0!8*,!/0% /0 )!7( :!,$ ,$( S7('XA
P G0%,!,.,!/0*7 *))!7!*,!/0% /) !"#$# *'( )/' !+(0,!)!8*,!/0 /07>A
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
12/43
P
$%-%#9#(%
5% ,$!% S/.', %,*,(+ !0 S+#472 34147@ *. R#+2%)0Y
i#$( +()!0!,!/0 /) 6*''!*9( !% ,$( )/.0+*,!/0 /) ,$(
F,*,(W% &'/*+(' *.,$/'!,> ,/ '(9.7*,( ,$( %.&j(8, /)
+/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% :!,$ '(%;(8, ,/ ,$( kl;m'/,(8,!/0 /)
/))%;'!09Y ;'/;(',> !0,('(%,%Y *0+ ,$( (0)/'8(6(0, /)
6*'!,*7 '(%;/0%!&!7!,!(%AW n N]] FAS, PRTZY PRVN bP\N]c
b8!,!09 R#99#1"@ *. N)045 '10)9#+1Y ]NT DAFA P`TY PV`
bNV^PccA #$!% &'/*+ *.,$/'!,> !% *, ,$( $(*', /) :$>
7!8(0%!09 6*''!*9(% )/' %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(% !% 0/, * +.,>
!6;/%(+ &> ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0,A d('( %.8$
7!8(0%!09 ,/ !087.+( %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(%Y ,$(%( 8$*09(%,/ ,$( 8/0+!,!/0% /) 6*''!*9( :/.7+ +'*6*,!8*77> !64
;*8, ,$( il;m'/,(8,!/0 /) /))%;'!09Y ;'/;(',> !0,('(%,%Y
*0+ ,$( (0)/'8(6(0, /) 6*'!,*7 '(%;/0%!&!7!,!(%An 5%
,$( /;;/%!,(4%(< 0*,.'( /) 6*''!*9( :*% $!%,/'!8*77>
i(%%(0,!*7 ,/ ,$( @('> +()!0!,!/0 /) ,$*, ,('6Yn 0.6('4
/.% %,*,( 7*:% :('( &*%(+ /0 %.8$ * i'/7( *0+ ).084
,!/0An R#+2@)0Y N]] FAS,A *, PR`VA
#$!% +/(% 0/, 6(*0 ,$*, ,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0%
( 7*:Y ;'(87.+(% ,$( S/.', )'/6 '.7!09 $('(A
#$!% S/.', ;'(@!/.%7> $*% '.7(+ .08/0%,!,.,!/0*7
7*:% !6;/%!09 8(',*!0 '(%,'!8,!/0% /0 6*''!*9(A 377Y
7.,. ()*#+, *. /#0,#+#1Y ]`` DAFA N bNVRTc b%,'!X!09
+/:0 &'/*+ 7*: )/'&!++!09 !0,('4'*8!*7 6*''!*9(cA
!"#$# '(*+!7> 8/08(+( ,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% ( %,*,( 7*: -.(%4
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
13/43
]
,!/0%A 5 '.7!09 /) ,$!% 0*,.'( :/.7+ /@(',!6( ('/+(
,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% (A
d$> +/ +(7(,('!/.% 8/0%(-.(08(% /) * $/7+!09 '(4
-.!'!09 7!8(0%!09 /) %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9(% *))(8, ,$( !04
,(';'(,*,!/0 /) ,$( 8/0,(0, /) ,$( 3/.',((0,$
56(0+6(0,= #$!% S/.', '(*7!?(% ,$*, ,$( +/8,'!0(% /)
,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0,Y !) 0/, 8$(8X(+Y :/.7+
.;%(, ,$( &*7*08( /) )(+('*7!%6A
5% S$!() [.%,!8( J/&(',% $*% 0/,(+ !0 * 8*%( '(4
9*'+!09 *0 !0@!,*,!/0 ,/ )!0+ * 0(: ).0+*6(0,*7 '!9$,
!0 ,$( *'(* /) ;/%,48/0@!8,!/0 '(7!()Y i5% * 9(0('*7
6*,,('Y ,$( S/.', $*% *7:*>% &((0 '(7.8,*0, ,/ (!09 ,$( &'/*+
;*'*6(,('% /) ,$( 2.( B'/8(%% S7*.%(A #$('(
!% 0/ '(*%/0 ,/ 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7!?( ,$( !%%.( !0
,$!% :*>An &2. *, P]NPA
F.8$ !% ,$( 8*%( $('(A d$(,$(' 7!8(0%!09 :('( ,/&( 6*0+*,(+ .0+(' ,$( (-.*7 ;'/,(8,!/0 87*.%( /' ,$(
+.( ;'/8(%% 87*.%(Y ,$( 0((+(+ !0%,!,.,!/0*7 9.!+(4
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
14/43
̂
;/%,% )/' '(%;/0%!&7( +(8!%!/06*X!09 !0 ,$!% *'(* *'(
i%8*'8( *0+ /;(04(0+(+An 5 7!8(0%!09 '.7!09 :/.7+ +/( :$*, ,$!% S/.', :*% '(7.8,*0, ,/ +/ !0 G@V
;)0+7 *0+ /,$(' 8*%(%p,*X( )*6!7> 7*: ;'('/9*,!@(%
i/., /) ,$( $*0+% /) 7(9!%7*,.'(% *0+ %,*,( 8/.',%n *0+
i,.'0 l,$(6m /@(' ,/ )(+('*7 8/.',%An
G) ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0, 6*0+*,(% 6*''!*9(
7!8(0%!09 )/' %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(%Y )(+('*7 8/.',% :/.7+
*%%.6( &'/*+ *.,$/'!,> /@(' %,*,( )*6!7> 7*:A I(:7>
)(+('*7!?(+ +!%;.,(% :/.7+ /88.' )/' *0 .0;'(+!8,*&7(
;('!/+ /) ,!6(A #$(%( .0;'(+!8,*&7( &., ;'/&*&7( ()4
)(8,% %$/: ,$*, !, !% +!))!8.7, )/' &'/*+Y %:((;!096*0+*,(% %.8$ *% ,$( ;'/;/%(+ 7!8(0%!09 '.7!09 ,/ 8/4
(
;/7!8!(% /0 6*''!*9( 6.%, &( '(@!%(+ &> ,$( %,*,(%
,$(6%(7@(% !) ,$(> 8$//%( ,/ 9!@( 7!8(0%(% ,/ %*6(4%(<
8/.;7(%A #$( /,$(' /;,!/0 !% ,$!%1 :$*, :*% )/'6('7>
&*%(+ !0 %,*,( 8/.', '.7!09% *0+ %,*,( )*6!7> 7*: :!77
&( +'*%,!8*77> 6/+!)!(+ &> )(+('*7 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7 *0+
%,*,.,/'> 7*:A O*0+*,(+ 7!8(0%!09 :/.7+ %!90!)> )(+4
('*7 8/0,'/7 /) i+!))('(08(% *8'/%% %,*,(% !0 *'(*% 7!X(
+!@/'8(Y 8$!7+ 8.%,/+> *0+ !0$('!,*08(An: 5% [.+9(
F.,,/0 0/,(+Y %.8$ * '.7!09 :/.7+ 7(*@( ,$( %,*,(%
:!,$ i7!,,7( *.,$/'!,>n ,/ '(%/7@( i+(&*,(% *&/., $/:
,/ +()!0( 6*''!*9( b*0+ ,$( &(0()!,% *0+ &.'+(0% ,$*,
8/6( :!,$ !,cAn E7:)70 *. 3+ 7*:A
] 377 O*( g.>X(0+*77Y ! R1< G84 )A 457 31"7V37L %100#1,7
%7@@Y #$( I(: e/'X #!6(% bO*> P^Y P\NPcY B*9( 5]NY *@*!7*&7(*,1 $,,;1qq:::A0>,!6(%A8/6qP\NPq\ZqP^q/;!0!/0q*4:*>4/.,4/)4,$(4
%*6(4%(
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
15/43
Z
E '(9*'+!09 6*''!*9( 7*:A 3(+('*7 8/.',%
$*@( 0/ !0%,!,.,!/0*7 )'*6(:/'X )/' *++'(%%!09 %.8$
8*%(%A #$( F! /.,4/)4
%,*,( '(8/90!,!/0 *0+ :!77 '(%;(8, 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7
0/'6%A !"#$8@ D;$*6 &(7!(@(% 0/ 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7
;'/@!%!/0 %;(*X% ,/ ,$( !%%.( /) %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9(A
!"#$8@ d/'7(> &(7!(@(% ,$*, !0,('%,*,( ,'*@(7 *0+
@4107 27$#@#@ :/.7+ -.!8X7> &7.' ,$( +!%,!08,!/0% &(4
,:((0 7!8(0%!09 *0+ '(8/90!,!/0 *0+ &'/*+(0 ,$(
%8/;( /) ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0,A !"#$# )!7( ,/4
9(,$(' ,/ (6;$*%!?( ,$( )/'(%((*&7( ;'/&7(6% !) ,$!%
S/.', '(@('%(% ,$( F!
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
16/43
R
-+;"9#(%
&< %=>7 1?@AB 3C?>D7 5EF?@GD>G4 ?G B=5
H53G>G4 ?I H3AA>345 >G A5J3B>?G B? 3 KA?3D
3GD D5B3>J5D 75B ?I 7B3B5LA54@J3B5D J3M7
3GD N?@AB A@J>G47<
#$/.%*0+% /) )*6!7!(% ,.'0 ,/ %,*,( 8/.',% (@('>
>(*' ,/ +(*7 :!,$ 6*0> )*6!7> 7!)( !%%.(%A E*8$ %,*,(
8/.', +(*7% :!,$ 8/6;7(< !%%.(% (%%(0,!*77> )/'(!90 ,/
)(+('*7 8/.',%A #$(%( %,*,( 8/.',% *'( 0/, :(77 @('%(+
!0 )(+('*7 8/.',%r j.'!%;'.+(08( /0 (-.*7!,> *0+ +.(;'/8(%%A G0%,(*+Y ,$(> )/8.% /0 ;'*8,!8*7 !%%.(% %.8$
*% (-.!,>Y 8.%,/+>Y *0+ )*6!7> )!0*08(%A #$( '.7!09%
&> ,$(%( 8/.',% *'( '(%;/0%!@( ,/ ;'*8,!8*7 !%%.(% *0+
%,*,( 8/+(%A #$(%( )*6!7!(% *7%/ ,.'0 ,/ %,*,( 7(9!%7*4
,/'% ,/ 8/''(8, )7*:% !0 ,$( 7*:% ,$*, %,*,( 8/.',% !04
,(';'(,A
3(+('*7 7*:% *0+ 8/.', '.7!09% +!))(' %!90!)!8*0,7>
)'/6 %,*,( 7*:% *0+ 8/.', '.7!09% :!,$ '(%;(8, ,/ )*64
!7> 7*:A #$(%( +!))('(08(% +(6/0%,'*,( ,$*, ,$( 3/.'4
,((0,$ 56(0+6(0, +/(% 0/, '(-.!'( ,$( 7!8(0%!09 /)6*''!*9(% )/' %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(%A #$( 8/6;7(< ())(8,%
/) * 8/0,'*'> $/7+!09 /0 %,*,( 7*: :/.7+ &( &'/*+ *0+
)*'4'(*8$!09A #$!% !% &(8*.%( * '.7!09 6*0+*,!09 7!4
8(0%!09 8/.7+ %;(*X ,/ ,$( $)+2#4#)+@ )/' 6*''!*9(Y
&., 0(!,$(' %.8$ * '.7!09 0/' *0> ;'(@!/.% '.7!09 &>
,$!% S/.', 8/0%,'.8,% ,$( #+@4#484#)+19 A01"7B)0> /)
6*''!*9( 7*:A 5 8/0+!,!/0 %;(*X% ,/ :$/ 9(,% 6*'4
'!(+s ,$( )'*6(:/'X %;(*X% ,/ ,$( &(0()!,% *0+ &.'4
+(0% ,$*, 8/6( :!,$ 6*''!*9(A 377 E7:)70 *. 3+ ,$( %.&j(8, /) +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% :!,$
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
17/43
T
'(%;(8, ,/ ,$( kl;m'/,(8,!/0 /) /))%;'!09Y ;'/;(',> !04
,('(%,%Y *0+ ,$( (0)/'8(6(0, /) 6*'!,*7 '(%;/0%!&!7!4,!(%AW n N]] FAS, PRTZY PRVN bP\N]c b8!,!09 R#99#1"@ *.
N)045 '10)9#+1Y ]NT DAFA P`TY PV` bNV^PccA #$!% S/.',
$*% 0(@(' %*!+ !0 *0> +(9'(( /) %;(8!)!8!,> *0>,$!09
*&/., $/: %,*,(% %$/.7+ *+6!0!%,(' 6*''!*9( 7*:%A
d('( !, ,/ *,,(6;, %.8$Y ,$!% @/!+ !0 j.'!%;'.+(08(
:/.7+ $*@( ,/ &( )!77(+ &> * %!90!)!8*0, @/7.6( /)
:/'X &> )(+('*7 8/.',%A 5% 8/.;7(% ;'(%(0, 0/@(7 +!%4
;.,(% )/' 8/.',% ,/ '(%/7@( .0+(' )(+('*7 j.'!%+!8,!/0Y
,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% ( +(%,*&!7!?!09
,/ ,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% (7 N375 >7 3K?@B 3G >G7B>B@B>?G 37 M5JJ 37
>GD>C>D@3J7<
E*8$ %,*,( $*% 6*0> 7*:% '(9*'+!09 6*''!*9( *0+
)*6!7> 7!)(A #$(%( 6*0> 8/6;7(< '(-.!'(6(0,% %$/:
,$*, %,*,( 9/@('06(0,% *'( !0,(0%(7> !0@/7@(+ !0
6*''!*9( *% *0 !0%,!,.,!/0A M!%,/'!8*77>Y %/8!(,!(%$*@( 0/, @!(:(+ 6*''!*9( *% &*%(+ /0 ,$( 7/@( ,$*, !%
%$*'(+ &> [/$0 *0+ F*77>Y /' 2/0*7+ *0+ L/.!%(Y /'
#>7(' *0+ 500*&(77(A d$!7( 8.7,.'*77> 6*''!*9( $*%
&(8/6( 7!0X(+ :!,$ '/6*0,!8 7/@(Y (*8$ %,*,( $*%
0.6('/.% '(%,'!8,!/0% /0 6*''!*9( ,$*, $*@( 7!,,7( ,/
+/ :!,$ 7/@(A 577 %,*,(% $*@( (
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
18/43
̀
7> :!77 $*@( * $*'+(' ,!6( !0 6*0> %,*,(% (0+!09
,$(!' 6*''!*9( ,$*0 %,*',!09 !,U:$(,$(' /' 0/, 8$!74+'(0 *'( !0@/7@(+AZ
E*8$ %,*,( '(9.7*,(% 6*''!*9( &/,$ ,/ ;'(%('@(
,$( *.,/0/6> /) ,$( )*6!7> *0+ ,/ ;'/@!+( %*)(9.*'+%
)/' :$(0 ,$( )*6!7> %,'.8,.'( )*!7%A #$( %,*,(% $*@(
+(@(7/;(+ %,'.8,.'(% )/'(!90 ,/ ,$!% S/.',A #$(%( !04
87.+(1 ,$( i&(%, !0,('(%,% /) ,$( 8$!7+n %,*0+*'+YR
:*!,!09 ;('!/+% ,/ 6/+('*,( ;*%%!/0%YT *0+ *+/;,!/0
*0+ )/%,(' 8*'( ;'/8(+.'(%A`
3.',$('Y (*8$ %,*,( $*% %,'/09 ;/7!8!(% (!,$(' )*4
@/'!09 /' +!%)*@/'!09 '(8/90!,!/0 /) 6*'!,*7 '!9$,% !0
0/046*'!,*7 '(7*,!/0%$!;%AV #$(%( 7*:% *'( &*%(+ !0
&*8X9'/.0+ *%%.6;,!/0% *&/., )*!'0(%% +('!@(+ )'/6
,$( +(;(0+(08!(% *0+ ( ,$(
#(00A S/+( 500A hh ]R4N4N\N4 ]R4T4Z\] b%*6(cA Q!@(0 ,$( 8/64
;7( /) &/,$ ,$(%( 8/+(% *0+ ,$( 8*%(% !0,(';'(,!09 ,$(6Y
!"#$# 8*0 /07> )/'(,(77 * %6*77 %*6;7!09 /) ).,.'( )(+('*7 !%%.(%
'*!%(+ &> * 7!8(0%!09 +(8!%!/0A
Z 377Y 7.,.Y O!8$A S/6;A L*: 500A hh ZZPAN 74 @7U. b8'!,('!* )/'
+!@/'8(cA
R 377Y 7.,.Y J7+20#$> *. 35)7"1>7Y V\ FAdA]+ ZRRY ZRT
b#(00A P\\Pc b(@*7.*,!09 :$*, !% !0 ,$( i8$!7+r% &(%, !0,('(%,%ncA
T 377Y 7.,.Y g>A J(@A F,*,A 500A h ^\]A\^^ b,$!',> +*> :*!,!09 ;(4
'!/+ )/' +!@/'8( :$(0 8$!7+'(0 *'( !0@/7@(+cA
` 377Y 7.,.Y H$!/ J(@A S/+( hh ]N\TA\N 74 @7UA
V ')"6107 %10*#+ *. %10*#+Y ZZT BAP+ N\R bS*7A NVTRc b)*@/'!09
'(8/90!,!/0 /) 0/046*'!,*7 '(7*,!/0%$!;%c B#45 '10+7@ *. 3579V2)+Y ]NN IAdAP+ T^T bO!8$A NV`Nc b+!%)*@/'!09 '(8/90!,!/0 /)
0/046*'!,*7 '(7*,!/0%$!;%cA
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
19/43
V
%,*,(% 8*00/, &( X0/:0A M/:(@('Y !, !% 8(',*!0 ,$*,
;*',!(% :!77 %((X )(+('*7 9.!+*08( /0 ,$( '(*8$ /) ,$((-.*7!,> *0+ +.( ;'/8(%% ;'!08!;7(% !0 )*6!7> 7*:A
F,*,(% +/ *0+ :!77 %(( 6*''!*9( *% )*' 6/'( 8/64
;7!8*,(+ ,$*0 6.,.*7 8/6;*%%!/0Y *))(8,!/0 *0+ '/4
6*0,!8 7/@(A F,*,(% '/.,!0(7> *++'(%% *%;(8,% /) 6*'4
'!*9( 0/ 7(%% !6;/',*0, ,$*0 ,$( '/6*0,!8 !+(*7Y *%4
;(8,% ,'*+!,!/0*77> X(;, *:*> )'/6 )(+('*7 8/.', &>
*+$('(08( ,/ ,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% (7B?A>N3JJOPM>B= I5M 5EN5FL
B>?G7P75B B=5 K?@GD3A>57 A543AD>G4 >G7B>L
B@B>?G3J 5II5NB7 ?I H3AA>345 >G B=5>A 7B3B5<
R#+2@)0 *0+ 0.6('/.% /,$(' 8*%(% $*@( ( * 6*,4
,(' )/' %,*,(%A &+ 07 :8008@ N]R DAFA Z`RY ZV]pZV^
bN`V\cA S/09'(%% !% ( +!%;.,(%A #$( ;$'*%(
il&m(%, !0,('(%,% /) ,$( 8$!7+n *;;(*'% /@(' ,:(0,> %(@(0 ,$/.4
%*0+ ,!6(% !0 * +*,*&*%( /) F,*,( 8/.', /;!0!/0% *0+ .0+(' 7#,54
58+2072 !0 * ;*'*77(7 +*,*&*%( /) )(+('*7 8/.', /;!0!/0%A 377
Q//97( F8$/7*' %(*'8$(%Y K(%, !0,('(%,% /) ,$( 8$!7+Y
$,,;1qq&!,A7>qKGS$!7+%,*,( *0+ $,,;1qq&!,A7>qKGS$!7+3(+('*7 bL*%,
@!%!,(+ 3(&A P]Y P\NZcA
NN 377 DAFA S/0%,A 56(0+A a bi#$( ;/:('% 0/, +(7(9*,(+ ,/ ,$(
D0!,(+ F,*,(% &> ,$( S/0%,!,.,!/0Y 0/' ;'/$!&!,(+ &> !, ,/ ,$(
F,*,(%Y *'( '(%('@(+ ,/ ,$( F,*,(% '(%;(8,!@(7>Y /' ,/ ,$( ;(/4;7(Ancs N14. C72+. )A &+276. :8@#+7@@ *. 37;79#8@O N]P FAS,A PZRRY
PZTT bP\NPc bJ/&(',%Y [Ac biG0 /.' )(+('*7 %>%,(6Y ,$( I*,!/0*7
http://bit.ly/BIChildstatehttp://bit.ly/BIChildstatehttp://bit.ly/BIChildFederalhttp://bit.ly/BIChildFederalhttp://bit.ly/BIChildFederalhttp://bit.ly/BIChildstate
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
20/43
N\
8/.',% *'( ;'(@(0,(+ )'/6 '.7!09 /0 +/6(%,!8 6*,,('%
,$'/.9$ ,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% (7+V;01+24 *. ?#$5102@O Z\^ DAFA R`VY RVT4T\^ bNVVPc b$!%4
,/'!8*7 &*8X9'/.0+ /) ,$( ( ;'(@!/.%7> (%,*&7!%$(+
%,*0+*'+% )/' (-.*7 ;'/,(8,!/0 *0+ +.( ;'/8(%% ,/ *
:$/7( &'*08$ /) 7*:A #$( B(,!,!/0('% ,$.% *%X ,$*,
,$( S/.', *8, :!,$/., * ,$(/'>U* 479)@ U( 8/0,'/7 /@(' *+j.%,!09 )/' +!))('(08(% *6/09
+!))('(0, ,>;(% /) 8/.;7(% 6.%, '(6*!0 :!,$ %,*,(%A
H,$(':!%(Y :$*, :/'X% )/' O*%%*8$.%(,,% 6*> &(
)/'8(+ .;/0 S*7!)/'0!* /' @!8( @('%*A F,*,( )*6!7>
7*: !0@/7@(% * 8/6;7(< !0,('*8,!/0 &(,:((0 %,*,(
Q/@('06(0, ;/%%(%%(% /07> 7!6!,(+ ;/:('%s ,$( F,*,(% *0+ ,$(
;(/;7( '(,*!0 ,$( '(6*!0+('ncA
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
21/43
NN
8/.',%W *+j.+!8*,!/0 /) 0(: ;'/&7(6% *0+ '(%;/0%!@(
7*:6*X!09 &> %,*,( 7(9!%7*,.'(%A
1< %=>7 1?@ABQ7 FA5N5D5GB J3NR7 3 I?@GD3B>?G
B? 7F53R B? H3AA>345 37 3G >G7B>B@B>?G<
5% B(,!,!/0('% 87*!6Y ,$!% S/.', $*% ;'(@!/.%7> +(4
)!0(+ 6*''!*9( !0 * :*> ,$*, (6;$*%!?(% !0+!@!+.*7
'!9$,%A 377Y 7.,.Y =0#@B)92 *. ')++7$4#$84Y ]`N DAFA
^TV bNVRZc b'!9$, /) 6*''!(+ 8/.;7(% ,/ .%( 8/0,'*4
8(;,!/0cY (1B07+$7 *. K7L1@, Z]V DAFA ZZ` bP\\]c
b'!9$, /) *+.7, 8/.;7(% ,/ * %(cs I91++72
I107+45))2 *. E1+A)045, ^P` DAFA ZP bNVTRc b%,*,(
6*> 0/, '(-.!'( 8/0%(0, /) * $.%&*0+ )/' * :!)(W%
*&/',!/0cs I91++72 I107+45))2 *. '1@7 0/, '(-.!'( * :!)( ,/ 0/,!)> $('
$.%&*0+ /) ;7*00(+ *&/',!/0cs T1;9)$># *. ?7251#9,
^]^ DAFA ZT^ bNVT`c b$/7+!09 .08/0%,!,.,!/0*7 * 7*:
8/0+!,!/0!09 ,$( 6*''!*9( /) * 0/08.%,/+!*7 ;*'(0, /0
$!% ;*>6(0, /) 8$!7+ %.;;/',cA #$(%( 8*%(% *77 8/08('0!0+!@!+.*7 '!9$,%A
3/' ( !0%,!4,.,!/0*7 ,$(/'> /) 6*''!*9( 7*: *0+ +/ 0/, 8/0,*!0 *0
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
22/43
NP
*))!'6*,!@( j.'!%;'.+(08( /) 6*''!*9(A #$(> %;(*X
!0%,(*+ ,/ ,$( '/7(% /) (-.*7!,> *0+ +.( ;'/8(%%A
G, !% 8/66/0 %(0%( ,$*, +.( ;'/8(%% *0+ (-.*7
;'/,(8,!/0 8*%(% :/.7+ 8/0,*!0 7*09.*9( &*%(+ !0
+!90!,> *0+ (-.*7!,>A 577 56('!8*0% /) *77 *9(% %.'(7>
+(%('@( ,$( '!9$,% ;'/6!%(+ ,/ ,$(6 %!08( /.' )/.0+4
!09Y !087.+!09 ,$/%( /) 7!)(Y 7!&(',> *0+ ,$( ;.'%.!, /)
$*;;!0(%%A #$/%( '!9$,%Y ,$/.9$Y 8*0 /07> &( %(8.'(+
.;/0 * i)/.0+*,!/0 /0 %.8$ ;'!08!;7(% *0+ /'9*0!?!09
!,% ;/:('% !0 %.8$ )/'6Y *% ,/ ,$(6 %$*77 %((6 6/%,
7!X(7> ,/ ())(8, ,$(!' F*)(,> *0+ M*;;!0(%%An
2ESL5J5#GHI H3 GI2EBEI2EISE bNTTRcA
#$( ;'!08!;7(% .0+('7>!09 ,$( i)/.0+*,!/0n /) )*64
!7> 7*:U;'/,(8,!/0 /) 6(0Y :/6(0 *0+ 8$!7+'(0U
$*@( &((0 ( !0 %,*,( $*0+% %!08( ,$( )/.0+4
!09A #$( 7!0X &(,:((0 '!9$,% *0+ ,$(!' )/.0+*,!/0*7
i;'!08!;7(%n *0+ /'9*0!?!09 i;/:('%n !% (%%(0,!*7A G0
)*6!7> 7*:Y ,$(%( ;'!08!;7(% *0+ ;/:('% *'( 87/%(7>
7!0X(+ ,/ ,$( %,*,(W% &'/*+ *.,$/'!,> ,/ '(9.7*,( 6*'4
'!*9(A 377 R#+2@)0Y N]] DAFA *, PRVNA #/ 6*0!;.7*,(
,$( )/.0+*,!/0 :!,$/., *++'(%%!09 ,$( !0%,!,.,!/0*7
;'!08!;7(% *0+ ;/:('% !0@/7@(+ !% !0@!,!09 +!%%/0*08(AG0 8/0,'*%,Y 7(*@!09 %,*,(% '(%;/0%!&7( ,/ %$*;( )*6!7>
7*: !0 7!9$, /) ,$( )7.< !0 )*6!7> )/'6% !% 6/%, 7!X(7>
,/ ;'/6/,( %/.0+ ;/7!8!(% '(%;/0%!@( ,/ ,$( 0((+% /)
56('!8*0 )*6!7!(% /@(' ,!6(A 377 K0)L79 *. =01+*#997Y
Z]\ DAFA ZT bP\\\c b;7.'*7!,> /;!0!/0c b'(8/90!?!09
0(: 8/6;7( i8$*09!09 '(*7!,!(% /) ,$(
56('!8*0 )*6!7>ncA
F/6( 8*%(% !0 ,$!% S/.',W% j.'!%;'.+(08( +/ *'9.4
*&7> %;(*X ,/ ,$( !0%,!,.,!/0*7 *%;(8,% /) 6*''!*9(A
377Y 7.,.Y %71Y PRP DAFA ]V\Y ]VV bNVP]cb+.( ;'/8(%% !087.+(% '!9$, i,/ 6*''>Y (%,*&7!%$ *
$/6( *0+ &'!09 .; 8$!7+'(0ncA #/ ,$( ( +/Y
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
23/43
N]
,$/%( !0%,!,.,!/0*7 *%;(8,% *'( 7*'9(7> !0 8/0)7!8, :!,$
'(@('%!09 ,$( F!
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
24/43
N^
,$( S/.', 6.%, *))!'6 ,$( F! )!77
:!,$ 0((+(+ %,'.8,.'( *0+ '.7(%A 3.',$('Y ,$( ,//7%0((+(+ ,/ %$*;( !0%,!,.,!/0*7 6*''!*9( 7*: *'( 0/,
)/.0+ !0 ,$!% 8/.',W% ;'(8(+(0,A !"#$# '(%;(8,).77>
%.&6!, ,$*, *0 ('/%!/0 /) ,$( +/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% (/0+ F*6(4F(< O*''!*9(1 5 I(: F,'*,(9!8 _!%!/03/' 577 H.' 3*6!7!(% *0+ J(7*,!/0%$!;%Y $,,;1qq&(>/0+6*''!*9(
A/'9A
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
25/43
NZ
,!/0 /) :$> %,*,(% *'( !0@/7@(+ !0 6*''!*9( 8/6( )'/6
%,*,( 7*:A #$( 8/6;7(< 7(@(7 /) &(0()!,% 9!@(0 (*8$/;;/%!,(4%(< 8/.;7( +(6/0%,'*,(% ,$*, '*,$(' ,$*0
6/@!09 &(>/0+ 6*''!*9(Y %/8!(,> %$/.7+ .'9( %,*,(%
,/ %,'(09,$(0 !,A 5 '.7!09 &> ,$!% S/.', (6;$*%!?!09
%,*,( '!9$,% :!77 $(7; %,'(09,$(0 ,$( !0%,!,.,!/0 /)
6*''!*9( !0 ,$( %,*,(%A
&&< 0?A B=5 0?@AB55GB= -H5GDH5GB B? A5S@>A5
7B3B57 B? J>N5G75 73H5L75E H3AA>345T H3GO
7B3B5 I3H>JO J3M N3757 M?@JD =3C5 B? K5L
N?H5 I5D5A3J >77@57<
d$*, !% ,$( !6;/',*08( ,/ ,$!% 8*%( /) ,$( )*8, ,$*,
,$!% S/.',W% ;'(8(+(0, +/(% 0/, %;(*X ,/ ,$( !0%,!,.4
,!/0*7 *%;(8,% /) 6*''!*9(= 5 '.7!09 '(@('%!09 ,$(
F! (
!087.+(% ,$( *&/',!/0 +(8!%!/0Y &., u 6.%, &( 8/0%!+4
('(+ *9*!0%, !6;/',*0, %,*,( !0,('(%,% !0 '(9.7*,!/0An
^N\ DAFA NN]Y NZ^ bNVT]cA 5% I91++72 I107+45))2 *.
'1@7< ).',$(' (
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
26/43
NR
S/.', 9'*0,(+ ;*', /) * '(-.(%, ,/ 7!), * %,*> /) * 7/:4
(' 8/.',W% +(8!%!/0A R5)97 R)"7+F@ D71945 *. (1$>7 /'+(' :!,$ '(%;(8, ,/
87!0!8% !0 ,:/ #(
:!,$ '(%;(8, ,/ /,$(' ;*',% /) #(
!087.+(% /,$(' 8/6;7(< !%%.(% :!,$ 0/ 87(*' %/7.,!/0A
#$( E-.*7 B'/,(8,!/0 87*.%( /' 2.( B'/8(%% S7*.%(
:/.7+ $*@( * 6.8$4( ,$( :/'+% /) S$!() [.%,!8( J/&(',% !0 G@V
;)0+7 ,/ ,$!% 8*%(Y il(m%,*&7!%$!09 * )'((%,*0+!09 '!9$,
,/ l/&,*!0 * %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( 7!8(0%(m :/.7+ )/'8(
l,$( S/.',m ,/ *8, *% ;/7!8>6*X('%Y *0+ /.' %.&%,*04
,!@(4+.(4;'/8(%% l*0+ (-.*7 ;'/,(8,!/0m '.7(6*X!09
*.,$/'!,> :/.7+ u $*@( ,/ 8/@(' u* 6>'!*+ /) /,$('!%%.(%An E#@40#$4 !44)0+7N5G7>G4 D5N>7>?G<
d$*, *'( ,$( 8/0%(-.(08(% ,/ %,*,( 7*: /) * +(8!4
%!/0 6*0+*,!09 7!8(0%!09= G) ,$( 7*09.*9( /) +.( ;'/4
8(%% *0+ (-.*7!,> 8/6;(7% 7!8(0%!09 %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(%Y
,$( 7*09.*9( *7%/ 8*77% !0,/ -.(%,!/0 0.6('/.% 9(04
+('4&*%(+ )*6!7> 7*:%A O*0> -.(%,!/0% /) )*6!7> 7*:
:/.7+ &( +!))!8.7, ,/ +(8!+( :!,$/., +!'(8, %,*,( 7(9!%47*,!@( !0@/7@(6(0,A G0 (*8$ 8*%(Y $/:(@('Y * ;*',>
)*!7!09 ,/ 9*!0 * )*@/'*&7( /.,8/6( !0 %,*,( 8/.',% /'
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
27/43
NT
,$( +(6/8'*,!8 ;'/8(%% 8/.7+ )!7( !0 )(+('*7 8/.', *74
7(9!09 * @!/7*,!/0 /) $!% /' $(' (-.*7 ;'/,(8,!/0 /' +.(;'/8(%% '!9$,%A
#$(%( -.(%,!/0% *'( 6*0>A #$(> !087.+(1
G% * 8$!7+ %.;;/', '.7!09 ,/ &( ,$( %*6( *)4
,(' * %*6(4%(< +!@/'8( :$(,$(' /' 0/, ,$(
0/048.%,/+!*7 ;*'(0, !% * &!/7/9!8*7 ;*'(0,=
377 g>A J(@A F,*,A 500A h ^\]APNP bRc b'()('4
'!09 ,/ 8$!7+'(0 i&/'0 /) ,$( '(7*,!/0%$!;ncA
G% ,$( ;'(%.6;,!/0 /) ;*,('0!,> %,!77 @*7!+ !)
* 8$!7+ !% &/'0 ,/ * :/6*0 6*''!(+ ,/ *04/,$(' :/6*0 /' +/(% * &!/7/9!8*7 )*4
,$('q%;/.%( $*@( 6/'( '!9$,% %!08( ,$(
%*6(4%(< :!)( 8*00/, &( * &!/7/9!8*7 '(7*4
,!/0= 377 O!8$A S/6;A L*: 500A h
T\\APNN^bNc b*cA NR
2/ ,:/ )*,$('% $*@( * 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7 '!9$,
,/ (;!8*77> )*@/'(+
&!/7/9!8*7 ;*'(0,% !0 8.%,/+> +!%;.,(%A i#$(%( ;'/,(8,!/0% *'(
8/0%/0*0, :!,$ ,$( ;'!08!;7(Y '(8/90!?(+ !0 l,$!% S/.',W%m 8*%(%Y
,$*, ,$( &!/7/9!8*7 &/0+ &(,:((0 ;*'(0, *0+ 8$!7+ !% 6(*0!094
).7An !2)64#*7 ')8697 *. :1;< =#09Y N]] FAS, PZZPY PZTZ bP\N]c
bF/,/6*>/' [AY +!%%(0,!09cA #*X(0 /0 !,% )*8(Y ,$!% ;'(8(+(0,
8/0)7!8,% :!,$ %/6( '.7!09% +!%8.%%(+ !0 B*', GGGY #+A01A #$!%
S/.', 6*> 0((+ ,/ /@(''.7( ,$( &!/7/9!8*7 &/0+ )*@/'!,!%6 )/.0+!0 !,% ;'(8(+(0, !) (-.*7 ;'/,(8,!/0 /' +.( ;'/8(%% '!9$,% (
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
28/43
N`
5),(' * +!@/'8(Y !% !, !0 ,$( &(%, !0,('(%, /) *
8$!7+ )/' * 8$!7+ ,/ $*@( @!%!,*,!/0 '!9$,% )/'* 0/04&!/7/9!8*7 %*6(4%(< ;*'(0,= 5'( ;*4
'(0,*7 '!9$,% /) ,$( ;'(8!%( %*6( :(!9$, )/'
)/'6(' %;/.%(% !''(%;(8,!@( /) &!/7/9!8*7 '(4
7*,!/0=
G0 %/6( 8*%(% 0/, %,*,( 7*: &., /,$(' )(+('*7 *0+
%,*,( 8/.',% 6*> 8'(*,( ,$(%( %/',% /) 8/0)7!8,%A 3/'
( !0,(';'(,(+
(1B07+$7 ,/ '(-.!'( * 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7 '!9$, ,/ ;/7>9*4
6/.% 8/$*&!,*,!/0A 377 :0)B+ *. :85"1+Y V^T
3AF.;;AP+ NNT\Y NNV^Y NNV`4NP\PY NPPP4PZ b2A D,*$P\N]c 166719 2)$>7472 F(;A PZY P\N^ b'(7>!09 *, 7(09,$
/0 (1B07+$7cA d$!7( ,$( #(0,$ S!'8.!, /' ,$!% S/.',
6*> /@(''.7( ,$*, 8*%( *, * ).,.'( +*,(Y *0*7/9/.%
8*%(% &*%(+ /0 ,$( 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7!?!09 /) 7!8(0%!09 *'(
(*%> ,/ )/'(%((ANT
NT !"#$# *%%.6( *0> '.7!09 &> ,$!% S/.', '(-.!'!09 7!8(0%!09 )/'
B(,!,!/0('% :!77 &( :!,$/., *0> !0,(0, ,/ %!90*7 ,$*, ,$( 3/.'4
,((0,$ 56(0+6(0, '(-.!'(% F,*,(% ,/ !%%.( ;/7>*6/'/.% 6*'4
'!*9( 7!8(0%(%A
I/0(,$(7(%%Y ,$( '(*%/0 ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0, +/(%0W, '(4
-.!'( !%%.!09 ;/7>*6/'/.% 6*''!*9( 7!8(0%(% 7*'9(7> '(7!(% /0
,$( 8/6;/0(0,% /) 6*''!*9( %(, !0 F,*,( 7*:A I.6('/.% F,*,(
7*:% '(7> /0 ,$( ,:/4;('%/0 +()!0!,!/0 /) 6*''!*9( j.%, *% ,$(>
'(7> /0 ,$( /;;/%!,(4%(< +()!0!,!/0 /) 6*''!*9(A 3/' ( :/'X !) * :/6*0 $*+
,:/ $.%&*0+%= 377Y 7.,.Y O!8$A S/6;A L*: 500A h T\\APNN^bNc
b*cA
B'(8(+(0, %(, &> ,$!% 8*%( 6.%, @*7!+*,( ,$( F,*,(W% '/7( !0 +(4
,('6!0!09 ,$( ;.';/%(% )/' 7*:% *&/., 6*''!*9(A H,$(':!%(Y ,$(
7/9!8 /) (-.*7!,> /' +!90!,> :!77 %(, ,$( )(+('*7 8/.',% /0 * 8/.'%(
,/ $(*'!09 *0+ +(8!+!09 +(6*0+% )/' *0 !0+!@!+.*7 '!9$, ,/ 6.74,!;7( 6*''!*9( 7!8(0%(% b;/7>9*6>c *0+ ,/ 7!8(0%(% 8'(*,!09 *
9'/.; /) !0+!@!+.*7% :$/ 8/0%,!,.,( /0( 6*''!*9( b;/7>*6/'>cA
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
29/43
NV
#$(%( ;'(+!8,*&7( ;'/&7(6%U%/6( '//,(+ !0 +!))!4
8.7, ;.&7!8 ;/7!8> 8/08('0%U8/.7+ *77 &( %/7@(+ &> *8*'().7 7(9!%7*,.'( /' %,*,( 8/.',s 0/0( 8*0 &( ())!4
8!(0,7> /' (@(0 )*!'7> %/7@(+ &> ,$( 3/.',((0,$
56(0+6(0,W% 8*77 ,/ (-.*7!,>A H0( 8/.7+ (*%!7> *',!84
.7*,( ;/%%!&7( %/7.,!/0% ,/ ,$(%( -.(%,!/0%Y &., %.8$
*0%:('% *'( 7!X(7> ,/ &( %.&j(8, ,/ '(*%/0*&7( +!%*4
9'((6(0,A d!,$/., %.;;/',!@( %,*,( 7*:Y ;('%/0% 7(4
9!,!6*,(7> %((X!09 @!0+!8*,!/0 *'( 7!X(7> ,/ )!7( .0+('
)(+('*7 j.'!%+!8,!/0 ,/ /&,*!0 '(7!() !0%,(*+ /) .%!09
%,*,( 8/.',% *0+ ,$( +(6/8'*,!8 ;'/8(%%A
#$(%( +!%;.,(% 6*> 0/, %/7(7> &( &'/.9$, &>%*6(4%(< 8/.;7(%A 5% )*6!7> 7*: j.'!%;'.+(08( &(4
9!0% ,/ +(@(7/; !0 )(+('*7 8/.',%Y /;;/%!,(4%(< ;*',4
0('% 6*> :(77 )!7( !0 ,$( j.'!%+!8,!/0U%,*,( /' )(+('4
*7U 6/%, )*@/'*&7( ,/ ,$(6A 5% il,m$('( !% /07> /0(
E-.*7 B'/,(8,!/0 S7*.%(Yn ,$( %*6( ;'!08!;7(% ,$*,
)(+('*7 8/.',% *;;7> ,/ %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(% '(9*'+!09
+/6(%,!8 6*,,('% :/.7+ $*@( ,/ *;;7> ,/ /;;/%!,(4%(<
8/.;7(%A '01#, *. :)07+Y ^PV DAFA NV\Y PNN bNVTRc
bF,(@(0%Y [AY 8/08.''!09cA
#$(%( ;'/&7(6% %$/.7+ &( '(%/7@(+ !0 ,$( %,*,(%A 5% ,$!% S/.', (0*6!8% /) %,*,( 9/@('06(0, !0 ,$( )(+('*7
%>%,(6 *'( ,/ *77/: ,$( )/'6*,!/0 /) 8/0%(0%.% '(4
%;(8,!09 ,$( :*> ,$( 6(6&('% /) * +!%8'(,( 8/66.0!4
L/09%,*0+!09 7*:% *0+ ;('%(8.,!/0 *9*!0%, *+.7,('> *0+ ;/7>94
*6> :/.7+ 6*X( %.8$ 8$*77(09(% )/'(%((*&7( .0+(' (-.*7 ;'/4
,(8,!/0 ,$(/'!(%Y !087.+!09 *0!6.%Y *% :(77 *% +.( ;'/8(%% ,$(/4
'!(%A #$!% 8/.', :/.7+ '(-.!'( * ,$(/'> /) 6*''!*9( *% *0 (0,!,>
*0+ 0/, * 9'/.; /) !0+!@!+.*7% (
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
30/43
P\
,> ,'(*, (*8$ /,$(' !0 ,$(!' +*!7> 8/0,*8, *0+ 8/0%,*0,
!0,('*8,!/0 :!,$ (*8$ /,$('An N]] DAFA *, PRVP bP\N]cA
.< -7 U@D45 $@BB?G G?B5DT 3 J>N5G7>G4 D5N>L
7>?G M?@JD DA3H3B>N3JJO 5EF3GD $5NB>?G
0>C5 ?I B=5 0?@AB55GB= -H5GDH5GB<
H0( :*> )(+('*7 7*: :/.7+ 8*''> !08'(*%(+ j.'!%4
+!8,!/0 /@(' )*6!7> 6*,,('% :/.7+ &( !0 ,$( ( '!9$, ;'/,(8,(+
&> ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0,A 377 '#4< )A :)70+7 *.
C9)07@Y ZPN DAFA Z\TY ZNV bNVVTcA S/09'(%% 8*00/,
i8$*09l(m :$*, ,$( '!9$, !%Yn &2.Y &., !, 8*0 (0)/'8(
;'((
6(0,A #$(%( '!9$,% 6.%, &( 8/09'.(0, *0+ ;'/;/'4
,!/0*,( ,/ ,$( !0j.'> *% +(,('6!0(+ &> ,$!% S/.',A
K7++7@@77 *. (1+7Y Z^N DAFA *, ZP\ bP\\^cA G) ,$!%
S/.', '.7(% %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(% 6.%, &( *77/:(+ ,/ '(4
8(!@( 6*''!*9( 7!8(0%(%Y S/09'(%% :/.7+ $*@( ,$(
'!9$, ,/ (0)/'8( bNc '(6(+!*7 6(*%.'(%Y bPc ;'(@(0,*4
,!@( 6(*%.'(%Y *0+ b]c ;'((
%.8$ 7!8(0%!09A
I/ 6*,,(' $/: 0*''/: S/09'(%%W% F(8,!/0 3!@(
;/:(' !%Y * 7!8(0%!09 '.7!09 :!77 (
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
31/43
PN
6/,$(' :/.7+ 9(, 7(%% 8$!7+ %.;;/', ,$*0 !) %$( +!4
@/'8(+ ,$( )*,$(' /) ,$( 8$!7+ (@(0 !) ,$( )(6*7(%;/.%( :*% ;'(%(0, *, ,$( 8$!7+W% &!',$A S/.7+ S/04
9'(%% ;*%% * 7*: '(-.!'!09 %,*,(% ,/ ,'(*, * 0/04
&!/7/9!8*7 %*6(4%(< ;*'(0, ,$( %*6( *% * &!/7/9!8*7
/;;/%!,(4%(< ;*'(0,= F.'(7> ,$( *0%:(' :/.7+ &( >(%1
!) %,*,( *8,!/0 +!))('(0,!*,!09 %*6(4%(< *0+ /;;/%!,(4
%(< ;*'(0,% !% !0@*7!+ .0+(' ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+4
6(0,Y S/09'(%%W% *8,!/0 ,/ ;'(@(0, *0+ '(6(+> %.8$
+!))('(0,!*,!/0 :/.7+ &( 8/09'.(0, *0+ ;'/;/',!/0*,(
,/ ,$!% S/.',W% +(,('6!0*,!/0 /) ,$( 3/.',((0,$
56(0+6(0, '!9$,%AF.8$ *8,!/0 :/.7+ *7%/ '(+.8( ,$( %8/;( /) ,$(
+/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% (Y ,$( ;'(4
%.6;,!/0 /) ;*,('0!,> *0+ /,$(' 6*,,('%Y )(+('*7
8/.',% 6.%, !0,(';'(, %.8$ 7*:% '(9*'+7(%% /) ,$( +/4
6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% ( !0+!%;.,*&7(A 5,
/'*7 *'9.6(0, !0 S+#472 34147@ *. R#+2@)0Y ,$( D0!,4
(+ F,*,(% ,//X ,$( ;/%!,!/0 ,$*, )(+('*7 *8,!/0% (;/,$(,!8*7 *&/.,
7*: ( ,/ &(
+!%;.,(+ &> ,$( ;*',!(% /' /,$(' !"#$# !0 ,$!% 8*%(A
#$!% 0(:)/.0+ F(8,!/0 3!@( ;/:(' :/.7+ &( *0
(0/'6/.% $!%,/'!8*7 *0/6*7>A 5% [.+9( F.,,/0 %,*,4
(+1 iM/: /++ ,$*, /0( &'*08$ /) ,$( I*,!/0*7 Q/@4
('06(0, bS/09'(%%c :/.7+ &( '(;'!6*0+(+ )/' (0,('4
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
32/43
PP
!09 ,$( )'*> !0 P\N] *0+ ,:/ &'*08$(% /) ,$( %*6(
Q/@('06(0, b,$( S/.', *0+ S/09'(%%c :/.7+ ,*X(8/0,'/7 /) ,$( !%%.( * %$/', ,!6( 7*,('An E7:)70 *.
3+ 7*: %!08(
/.' )/.0+!09A #$( '*+!8*7 !6;7!8*,!/0% /) * +!'(8, )/'4
*> !0,/ %,*,( 6*''!*9( 7*:% %$/.7+ &( 87(*' &()/'( ,$(
S/.', ,*X(% %.8$ * )*,().7 %,(;A
G0 ,$( ,:(0,!(,$ 8(0,.'>Y ,$( ;'/;/%*7 ,/ 6*X(
6*''!*9( 7*: .0!)/'6 *% * )(+('*7 ).08,!/0 :*% '(4 j(8,(+ '(;(*,(+7>A 377 E+:*'+ F,(!0Y I1@4 1+2 I07V
@7+4 I0)6)@72 !"7+2"7+4@ 4) 457 S+#472 34147@ ')+V
@4#484#)+ ?7,102#+, %100#1,7 Z G%%.(% !0 L(9*7
F8$/7*'%$!; N bP\\^c b8*,*7/9!09 '(j(8,!/0%cAN` !"#$#
.'9( ,$( S/.', ,/ 8/0%!+(' ,$( !6;7!8*,!/0% /) *:*'+4
!09 %(8,!/0 Z ;/:('% /@(' 6*''!*9( ,/ S/09'(%% *0+
*:*'+!09 )*6!7> 7*: j.'!%+!8,!/0Y '(4(09!0(('(+ *%
3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0, (-.*7!,> /' +.( ;'/8(%%Y ,/
,$( )(+('*7 8/.',%A
N` 3/' ( *00.76(0, /) 6*''!*9( /' &> +!@/'8(Ancs MA[A J(%A NT\Y
RN,$ S/09A bNVN\c biS/09'(%% !% ).',$(' (6;/:('(+ ,/ 6*X(
7*:% '(%;(8,!09 A A A 6*''!*9(Y +!@/'8(Y *0+ *7!6/0>Y :$!8$ 7*:%
%$*77 &( /) * 9(0('*7 0*,.'( *0+ .0!)/'6 !0 /;('*,!/0 ,$'/.9$4
/., ,$( D0!,(+ F,*,(%ns MA[A J(%A PTVY ZR,$ S/09A bNV\\c biS/049'(%% %$*77 $*@( ;/:(' ,/ (0*8, .0!)/'6 7*:% /0 ,$( %.&j(8, /)
6*''!*9( *0+ +!@/'8(AncA
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
33/43
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
34/43
P^
,$( ;'('(-.!%!,( /) 9(0+(' +!@('%!,> %;(*X% ,/ ,$(
@('> i'/7( *0+ ).08,!/0n /) 6*''!*9( !0 %,*,( 7*:A 377R#+2@)0Y N]] FAS,A *, PR`VA
3/' (Y *0+ 7!X(7> 0(@('Y ,.'0 /0
'*8( *7/0( .0+(' %,*,( 7*:A #$(> )'(-.(0,7> ,.'0Y
$/:(@('Y /0 &/,$ 9(0+(' *0+ &!/7/9!8*7 '(7*,!/0%$!;U
,:/ *,,'!&.,(% ).0+*6(0,*77> 8$*09(+ &> *0 (-.*7!,>
/' +.( ;'/8(%% '.7!09 6*0+*,!09 7!8(0%!09A L!X(:!%(Y'(%,'!8,!/0% /0 8/0+!,!/0% )/' 6*''!*9( '(6/@(+ &>
8/0%,!,.,!/0*7 '(*%/0!09Y %.8$ *% &(!09 !08*'8('*,(+
/' 0/, ;*>!09 8$!7+ %.;;/',Y ,>;!8*77> +/ 0/, '*!%(
%.8$ 8/6;7(< ;'/&7(6%A 377Y 7.,. K80+70 *. 31A97# *. ?7251#9Y
^]^ DAFA ZT^ bNVT`c b8$!7+ %.;;/',cA
&&&< *37B 5EF5A>5GN5 5E5HFJ>I>57 F?B5GB>3J >7L
7@57<
E
)(+('*7 8*%(% !0 %,*,(% :$('( )(+('*7 8/.',% $*@(
6*0+*,(+ ,$( 7!8(0%!09 /) %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( %$/:
87(*'7> ,$( ('/%!/0 /) ,$( )(+('*7!%6 $!%,/'!8*77> ;'(4
%(0, !0 %,*,( 7*:A
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
35/43
PZ
-< #EF5A>5GN5 >G 7B3B57 B=3B 4A3GB H3AA>345
J>N5G757 B? 73H5L75E N?@FJ57 B=A?@4= 7B3B5N?@AB7 ?A B=5 D5H?NA3B>N FA?N577<
d$(0 %,*,( 7(9!%7*,.'(% *0+ 8/.',% *'( ,$( %/7(
6(8$*0!%6 )/' 6/+!)>!09 7!8(0%!09 '(-.!'(6(0,%Y !64
;7(6(0,*,!/0 /) %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( $*;;(0% /0 ,$(
%,*,( 7(@(7A d$(0 %,*,( 7*:% /' 8/0%,!,.,!/0% '(-.!'(
%*6(4%(< 6*''!*9(Y ,$( '(7*,!/0%$!; &(,:((0 ,$(
%,*,(% *0+ ,$( 0*,!/0*7 9/@('06(0, !% .0,/.8$(+A
F.8$ 7*:% *'( 8/0%!%,(0, :!,$ i,$( )/.0+*,!/0 /) ,$(
F,*,(r% &'/*+(' *.,$/'!,> ,/ '(9.7*,( ,$( %.&j(8, /)
+/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0%An 377 R#+2@)0Y N]] DAFA *, PRVNA 5
%,*,( 7*: 0(@(' 8*0 +!8,*,( ,$( %8/;( /) )(+('*7 '!9$,%
/) (-.*7!,>A F,*,(% ,$*, (0*8, %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( (Y '*,$(' ,$*0 $*'6Y )(+('*7!%6A
G0 ,$(%( %,*,(%Y ,$( 8/08('0% 6(0,!/0(+ !0 ;*', GGY
@8601Y *'( &(!09 ;7*>(+ /., !0 %,*,( j.'!%+!8,!/0%Y '*4
,$(' ,$*0 )(+('*7A 3/' ( +/(% 0/, *;;7> ,/ %*6(4%(< 8/.;7(%A 377 P.% *.
:.'. 1+2 Q.3.Y I/A N]TRN4N] bIAeA 3*6A S,A O/0'/(S,>A P\N^cAP\ #$( G/:* F.;'(6( S/.', $*% '.7(+ !0 *
8/0)7!8,!09 :*>A 377 =104+70 *. &)B1 E76104"7+4 )A
I8;9#$ D71945Y `]\ IAdAP+ P]Z bG/:* P\N]cA #$(%(
+(8!%!/0% 6*,8$ ,'*+!,!/0% /) )(+('*7!%6 !0 )*6!7> ;/74
!8> 8/0%!+('*,!/0% &(8*.%( ,$(> *'( ,*X!09 ;7*8( !0
%,*,( 8/.', .0+(' %,*,( 7*:Y '*,$(' ,$*0 &(!09 +(8!+4
(+ &*%(+ /0 )(+('*7 8/0%,!,.,!/0*7 7*:A 5 0*,!/0*7 +(4
8!%!/0 6*0+*,!09 7!8(0%!09 :/.7+ /;(0 .; *@(0.(% )/'
)(+('*7 8/.',% ,/ :(!9$ !0 /0 ,$(%( !%%.(%A F$/.7+ *
P\ #$( ,(7*:>('A0>7jA8/6q*+9!)%q+(8!%!/0%N^qNNNPN^X/$/.,A;+)A
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
36/43
PR
)*6!7> 7*: -.(%,!/0 ,$*, !% ,>;!8*77> *0*7>?(+ *0+
*0%:('(+ &> %,*,( 7(9!%7*,/'%Y j.+9(%Y *0+ 7/8*7 7*:4>('%Y &(8/6( * )(+('*7 -.(%,!/0=
.< #EF5A>5GN5 >G 7B3B57 B=3B J>N5G75 73H5L75E
N?@FJ57 K5N3@75 ?I I5D5A3J N?@AB D5N>L
7>?G7<
D0,!7 @('> '(8(0,7>Y ,$( /07> %,*,( ,/ $*@( 7!8(0%(+
%*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( *% * '(%.7, /) * )(+('*7 S/.', /'4
+(' :*% S*7!)/'0!*A S*7!)/'0!* !% .0!-.( *6/09 ,$(
F,*,(% !0 ,$*, ,$( 7(9!%7*,.'( /) S*7!)/'0!* :*% !0 )*4
@/' /) %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( :$!7( ,$( ;(/;7( /) S*7!)/'40!* :('( /;;/%(+APN K(8*.%( /) ,$!% 6!0+%(,Y S*7!)/'4
0!*W% 7(9!%7*,.'( $*% 6*+( *+j.%,6(0,% ,/ !,% 6*'4
'!*9( *0+ )*6!7> ;/7!8!(% ,$*, /,$(' F,*,( 7(9!%7*,.'(%
:/.7+ 0/, 6*X(A 3/' ( ,$( ;'/&7(6% /) :$(,$(' ,$( &!/7/9!4
8*7 ;*'(0, /' ,$( %*6(4%(< %;/.%( $*% 9'(*,(' ;*'(04
,*7 '!9$,%APP
H,$(' %,*,(% :!77 $*@( +!))('!09 @!(:%A O*0>
%,*,(% %(( &!/7/9> *% i(%%(0,!*7n ,/ +(,('6!0!09 :$/%(
0*6( *;;(*'% *% * ;*'(0, /0 * &!',$ 8(',!)!8*,(A 'A.R#+2@)0Y N]] FAS,A *, PR`VA O*0> %,*,(% :!77 ,$.% '(4
%!%, *0> ())/', ,/ 8$*09( %.8$ '(-.!'(6(0,%A 3/' !04
%,*08(Y G0+!*0* 7*: '()7(8,% ,$( !0%,!,.,!/0*7 7!0X &(4
,:((0 &!/7/9!8*7 ;*'(0,!09 *0+ ,$( 0*6(% /) ,$( ;*'4
(0,% /0 ,$( &!',$ 8(',!)!8*,(A 3/77/:!09 ,$( F(@(0,$
PN ')"6107 S*7!)/'0!* 5%%(6&7> K!77 `^V bP\\Zc b;'/;/%(+ &!77 ,/
7(9*7!?( %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9(cY *@*!7*&7( *, $,,;1qq&!,A7>qS55K`^V
B#45 S*7A S/0%,AY 5',A GY hTAZA biB'/;/%!,!/0 `nc b+(6/8'*,!8 ;'/4
8(%% >!(7+!09 * 8/0,'*'> '(%.7, ,$'(( >(*'% 7*,('cA
PP 377 S*7!)/'0!* F(0*,( K!77 PT^ bP\N]cY *@*!7*&7( *,
$,,;1qq&!,A7>qS5FKPT^A
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
37/43
PT
S!'8.!,W% '.7!09 6*0+*,!09 %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( 7!8(0%4
!09Y * 8*%( $*% &((0 7/+9(+ *77(9!09 ,$*, G0+!*0*W%+()!0!,!/0 /) &(!09 i&/'0 !0 :(+7/8Xn *0+ i;'(%.6;4
,!/0 /) ;*,('0!,>n *'( .08/0%,!,.,!/0*7A 377 S/64
;7*!0,Y D7+270@)+ *. K#667$1+)7 ')8+4 *0+ *%4*;;7!(+cA #$!% 8*%( $*%
*'!%(0 +(%;!,( ,$( )*8, ,$*, )(+('*7 8/.',% $*@( *74
6/%, 0(@(' '.7(+ /0 ;'(%.6;,!/0% /) ;*,('0!,>AP]
G,%((6% 87(*' ,$*, '.7!09 /0 ,$!% 8*%( B)892 0*''/: ,$(
+/6(%,!8 '(7*,!/0% ( !6;*8, 6(0
;'(@!/.%7> ;'/,(8,(+ &> ,$( ;'(%.6;,!/0 /) ;*,('0!,>A
G0 *++!,!/0 ,/ ,$(%( 6*0> 0/@(7 -.(%,!/0%Y /,$('
8*%(% !0@/7@!09 %!6!7*' !%%.(% :!77 0((+ ,/ &( '(4
7!,!9*,(+A 377Y 7.,.Y !210 *. 3"#45Y R]V 3A]+ N^R bZ,$
S!'A P\NNc b.;$/7+!09 L/.!%!*0*W% *+/;,!/0 *0+ &!',$
8(',!)!8*,( 7*:%cs ()A4)+ *. 37$F< )A E764. )A '5#9207+ M
C1"#9 &( /@(''.7(+A 377 K0)L79 *.
=01+*#997Y Z]\ DAFA *, R`pRV b;7.'*7!,> /;!0!/0c b0/,4
P] G0 /0( +*,*&*%(Y /07> A#A4 $,,;1qq&!,A7>qB/B3(+('*7 *0+
$,,;1qq&!,A7>qB/BF,*,( b7*%, @!%!,(+ 3(&'.*'> P]Y P\NZcA #$( ,:/
6/%, '(8(0, '.7!09% &> ,$!% S/.', *++'(%%!09 ,$!% !%%.( >!(7+(+
7!6!,(+ ;'(8(+(0, +.( ,/ +!@('%( @!(:;/!0,% /0 * %(0%!,!@( !%%.(AK0)L79 *. =01+*#997Y Z]\ DAFA *, R`pRV b0/ 6*j/'!,> /;!0!/0cs %#V
$5179 D. *. =70192 E.O ^VN DAFA NN\ bNV`Vc b0/ 6*j/'!,> /;!0!/0cA
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
38/43
P`
!09 ;'(%.6;,!/0 /) ;*,('0!,> !% &*%(+ /0 ,$( ;*'(0,W%
i0*,.'*7 &/0+%ncA
#$(%( ())(8,% *'( (@(0 6/'( %,'!X!09 :$(0 ,$( !%4
%.( /) 8/0%8!(0,!/.% /&j(8,!/0% !% 8/0%!+('(+A F/6(
%,*,( 8/.', j.+9(% $*@( 8$/%(0 ,/ '(%!90 '*,$(' ,$*0
/))!8!*,( /@(' %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9(%AP^ F!6!7*'7>Y 6*0>
7(9!%7*,/'% :!77 %!6;7> )((7 ,$*, !, @!/7*,(% ,$(!' 8/04
%8!(08( ,/ @/,( )/' &!77% ,$*, :/.7+ !6;7!8!,7> *88(;,
%*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( *% ,$( 7*: /) ,$( 7*0+A K(8*.%( /)
,$(!' %!08('( &(7!()%Y ,$(!' %,*,( 7*: :!77 '()7(8, ,$(
!0%,!,.,!/0*7 6*04:/6*0 +()!0!,!/0 /) 6*''!*9(Y (@(0
*% ,$(> !%%.( %*6(4%(< 6*''!*9( 7!8(0%(%A #$(%( 8/04
%8!(0,!/.% /&j(8,!/0% /07> (0%.'( ,$*, ,$(%( 8/0)7!8,%
:!77 *''!@( !0 3(+('*7 S/.',A 5 +!'(8, '.7!09 %,*,!09
,$*, %,*,( 6*''!*9( 7*: '(-.!'(% 7!8(0%!09 /) %*6(4
%(< 6*''!*9( :/.7+ 8*.%( )(+('*7 %.;('@!%!/0 /) %,*,(
6*''!*9( 7*:A
&V< !1*2* B3R5 G? F?7>B>?G ?G B=5 75N?GD S@57L
B>?G FA575GB5D<
!"#$# ,*X( 0/ ;/%!,!/0 /0 ,$( !0,('%,*,( '(8/90!4
,!/0 -.(%,!/0 !0 ,$!% 8*%(APZ
!"#$8@ g.>X(0+*77 )((7% ,$*, ,$( '(8/90!,!/0 +(4
8!%!/0 :/.7+ '(,.'0 )*6!7> 7*: ;'!08!;7(% ,/ %,*,(
8/.',% ,/ *;;7> ,$( +(8!%!/0 /) '(8/90!,!/0 :!,$ 6!0!4
6*7 /' 0/ /@('%!9$, &> )(+('*7 8/.',%A F$( &(7!(@(%
%,*,( 8/.',% :!77 8'(*,!@(7> 6*!0,*!0 ,$( 8.''(0, '(7*4
,!/0%$!; &(,:((0 )(+('*7 7*: *0+ %,*,( )*6!7> 7*: !04
P^ 377 5%%/8!*,(+ B'(%%Y Q*> 6*''!*9(1 I/',$ S*'/7!0* /))!8!*7
'(%!90% bH8,A NRY P\N^cY *@*!7*&7( *,1 $,,;1qq&!,A7>qIS[.+9(%A
PZ #$( 5;;(0+!< ;'/@!+(% 6/'( +(,*!7 '(9*'+!09 $/: !"#$# +!%*4
9'(( !0 '(9*'+% ,/ ,$( %(8/0+ -.(%,!/0A
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
39/43
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
40/43
]\
1'(1/"$&'(
#$( +(8!%!/0 &(7/: %$/.7+ &( *))!'6(+ :!,$ '(4
%;(8, ,/ C.(%,!/0 NA !"#$# 8/77(8,!@(7> ,*X( 0/ ;/%!4
,!/0 :!,$ '(%;(8, ,/ C.(%,!/0 PA
J(%;(8,).77> %.&6!,,(+A
OGSM5EL #A dHJLEe O 5E g DegEI25LL
PTP d>6/.0, #(''*8( ')8+@79 )A ?7$)02
B'/@/Y D# `^R\^ O!8$!9*0 F,*,( D0!@('%!,>
b`N`c R]R4`NR\ R^` IA F$*: L*0( J6 ]RR
E*%, L*0%!09Y OG ^``P^
ZNT4^]P4R`V^
X.>X(0+Nv7*:A6%.A(+.
3(&'.*'> PTY P\NZ
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
41/43
N*
-**#(,&WX -9&1& $%-%#9#(%$ '0
&(%#+#$%
O*( g.>X(0+*77Y B'/)(%%/' /) L*:Y O!8$!9*0
F,*,( D0!@('%!,>Y $*% ;.&7!%$(+ ( /0 &/,$
,$( 7!8(0%!09 *0+ '(8/90!,!/0 !%%.(%AP` F$( %.99(%,(+
!0 ,$( NVV\% ,$*, !6;/%!09 * '(%,'!8,(+ 6(*0!09 /0
,$( :/'+ &> !0%(',!09 * 7(9!%7*,!@( i+()!0(+ ,('6n !0
%,*,( 8/+(% :*% *',!)!8!*7A #$( ,.'0 ,/ * +()!0!,!/0*7
6(,$/+ 8/0%,!,.,(+ * 8/08(%%!/0 ,$*, 6*''!*9( $*%
,*X(0 /0 * 6/'( !087.%!@( 6(*0!09 ,$*0 !,% ,'*+!4
,!/0*7 &!0*'> .0+('%,*0+!09A F$( $*% 0/0(,$(7(%%
*'9.(+ ,$*, * 6/'( +>0*6!8 )(+('*7!%6 8/.7+ &(0()!,
,$( !0%,!,.,!/0 /) 6*''!*9( &> (08/.'*9!09 %,*,(% ,/
;'/@!+( 6/'( 8/0@(0!(0, 6*''!*9( *88(%% )/' *77 8/.4
;7(% *0+Y ;/,(0,!*77>Y %.&%,*0,!@( @*'!*,!/0% ,$*, *+4
j.%, ,/ 8/.;7( 0((+% *0+ ;.&7!8 @*7.(%A F$( %.99(%,%
,$*, 6*''!*9( *.,$/'!?*,!/0 *% *0 !0!,!*7 6*,,(' 0((+
0/, &( 9'/.0+(+ !0 ,$( 8/!08!+(08( /) 9(/9'*;$> :!,$
j.'!%+!8,!/0*7 7!0(%A #$*, !%Y %,*,(% 6*> *.,$/'!?(
6*''!*9( )/' ;('%/0% :$/ +/ 0/, '(%!+( !0 ,$(!' j.'!%4
+!8,!/0 *0+ +/ 0/, ,'*@(7 ,/ !,A
5, ,$( %*6( ,!6(Y *% %,*,(% *88/66/+*,( +!%,*0,
8/.;7(%Y (*8$ j.'!%+!8,!/0 :/.7+ '(,*!0 7*:6*X!09
*.,$/'!,> /@(' ,$( 0/'6*,!@( %$*;( /) 6*''!*9( 7*:
;.'%.*0, ,/ ,$( @*7.(% *0+ !+(*% /) ,$( j.'!%+!8,!/0A
g.>X(0+*77 $*% ,$.% 8/087.+(+ ,$*, 6*''!*9( 7*:
:/.7+ &(0()!, !) !, :('( 6/+('0!?(+ &(,,(' ,/ *++'(%%
,$( 0((+% /) * 6/&!7( %/8!(,>A E*8$ %,*,( 8/.7+ ;'/4
P` F((Y (A9AY O*( g.>X(0+*77Y E-.*7!,> 3(+('*7!%61 5 F/7.,!/0 ,/
,$( O*''!*9( d*'%Y NZ DA B(00A [A S/0%,A LA ]TTs 5+*6 S*04+(.& *0+ O*( g.>X(0+*77Y O/+('0!?!09 O*''!*9(Y ^^ DA O!8$A
[A L*: J()/'6 T]Z bP\N\cA
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
42/43
P*
@!+( 6/'( /' 7(%% )7(
6*''!*9( 7!8(0%!09 7*: !% )(7, ,/ 8/0,'!&.,( ,/ 6*'4
'!*9( 7*:A #$( S/.',W% (X(0+*77 $*% ;'/;/%(+ ,$*, ,$( '!9$, /) %,*,(%
,/ )*%$!/0 ,$(!' /:0 6*''!*9( 7*:Y *0+ ,/ !0,(9'*,( *
%$*'(+ 0/'6 /) )*!'0(%% !0,/ ,$( 7*:Y &( j/!0(+ ,/ *0
/&7!9*,!/0 ,/ '(8/90!?( 7(9*7 6*''!*9(% /) 8/.;7(% /),$( %*6( %(X(0+*77 $*% *'9.(+ ,$*, %,*,(% :!77
&( *&7( ,/ )*%$!/0Y ,$'/.9$ ,$( 8/66/0 7*: :/'X /)
j.+9(%Y %,*,( 7*: '(%;(8,).7 /) (-.*7!,>Y *0+ 8/0%!+('4
*,( /) ,$( 7(9*7 %,*,.%Y '!9$,%Y *0+ !0,('(%,% /) 8/.;7(%
:$/%( '(7*,!/0%$!; !% (0)/7+(+ !0,/ ,$( /&7!9*,!/0%
*0+ +!90!,> /) ,$( 6*'!,*7 *%%/8!*,!/0A D07!X( %/6(
/0 ,$( 7(), %!+( /) ,$( ;/7!,!8*7 %;(8,'.6Y *0+ (@(0
%/6( /0 ,$( '!9$,Y :$/ *'9.( )/' ,$( :!,$+'*:*7 /)
,$( %,*,( )'/6 %;/0%/'!09 6*''!*9(Y g.>X(0+*77 '(4
9*'+% 6*''!*9( *% * 8'!,!8*7 !0%,!,.,!/0 /) %/8!(,> ,$*,
%,*,( !0@/7@(6(0, %.;;/',%A F$( '(9*'+% ,$( '(,(04
,!/0 &> !0+!@!+.*7 %,*,(% /) ,$( ;'!6*'> 8/0,'/7 /@('
&.!7+!09 ,$( 7(9*7 )'*6(:/'X *0+ %/8!*7 '/7( /) 6*'4
'!*9( *% ,$( 6/%, ;'.+(0, ;*,$ ,/ %,'(09,$(0!09 6*'4
'!*9( /0 * &*%!% /) (-.*7 '!9$,% *0+ '(%;(8, )/' *77
8/.;7(%A
2*@!+ JA D;$*6Y B$A2AY [A2A !% 5%%/8!*,( B'/)(%4
%/' /) B/7!,!8% *, ,$( D0!@('%!,> /) 2*77*%Y :$('( $(
,(*8$(% 9'*+.*,( *0+ .0+('9'*+.*,( 8/.'%(% !0 8/04
%,!,.,!/0*7 7*: *0+ 56('!8*0 ;/7!,!8*7 ,$/.9$,A M(
$*% '(%(*'8$(+ *0+ ;.&7!%$(+ ( !0 ,$( $!%4
,/'> /) ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0,A M!% ;.&7!%$(+
8/9/2019 Kuykendall, et al., Amicus Brief
43/43
]*
:/'X !087.+(% * '(8(0, %,.+> /0 !0,(''*8!*7 6*''!*9(
*0+ ,$( /'!9!0*7 .0+('%,*0+!09 /) ,$*, 56(0+6(0,APV
O!8$*(7 d/'7(> !% *0 *,,/'0(>A M!% :/'X /0 ,$!%
S/.',W% '(7!9!/.% )'((+/6 *0+ )*6!7> ;/7!8> 8*%(% $*%
*;;(*'(+ !0 ,$( H ;!9(/0$/7(+
*% !''(7(@*0, /' !''*,!/0*7A #$!% !% 7*'9(7> &(8*.%( ,$(
!0%,!,.,!/0*7 *%;(8,% /) 6*''!*9( *'( (*%!7> !90/'(+ /'
6!%8$*'*8,('!?(+ !0 ,$( ;.&7!8 %-.*'(A d/'7(> '(4
9*'+% 6*''!*9( *% * 8'!,!8*7 !0%,!,.,!/0 /) %/8!(,> ,$*,
%,*,( !0@/7@(6(0, %.;;/',%A d$!7( ,$( (0@!'/06(0,
!0 %/6( %,*,(% $*% 8$*09(+ ,$( !0%,!,.,!/0*7 %!90!)!4
8*08( /) 6*''!*9(Y /,$(' %,*,(% $*@( &((0 %.88(%%).7
!0 8'(*,!09 *0 (0@!'/06(0, %.;;/',!@( /) 6*''!*9(
&(,:((0 * 6*0 *0+ * :/6*0A d/'7(> j/!0% ,$!% &'!()
,/ $(7; (!09 ,$( 3/.',((0,$ 56(0+6(0, ,/ %,*,( 6*''!*9( 7*: !0 (0@!'/06(0,%
,$*, %.;;/', 6*''!*9( &(,:((0 * 6*0 *0+ * :/6*0A
M( !% 9'*,().7 )/' ,$( )*8, ,$*, ,$/%( :$/ +!%*9'((
(@(0 /0 +!))!8.7, !%%.(% %.8$ *% ,$!% 8*0 %,!77 )!0+
8/66/0 9'/.0+Y *% ,$( %!90('% /) ,$!% &'!() $*@(
+/0(A
PV
2*@!+ JA D;$*6Y &+47001$#19 %100#1,7 1+2 457 G0#,#+19 S+V270@41+2#+, )A 457 C)80477+45 !"7+2"7+4Y ^P M*%,!09% S/0%,A
LA CA PN] bP\NZcA