University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+-...

37
0 1 x y y z

Transcript of University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+-...

Page 1: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � ��������� ����������� ���� ��� ����� � ������� ����� � �!�#"����%$ �

&('!)+*-,/.�01'2,43�56)�7+'�*-89'!)

01

x

y

y

z

:<;>=>?A@2BC; DFEG?A;>HJIKE�BJLNMNOGP�QSRUT2VXWGDF=>;YT6RUZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F`aH�bcMNd!egfh=i?AE�jk;YB�lmM�M�d!no/p ]\DFEGBJBC;>V�]^HC]\EGDFHYeqRUrFBYnsltM�M�PNu

bwvx`yWG]\Z/z|{!}!~��q�m�������N�����N��n���;>jsz+{!���N�������-���������m�����N�������N�q�N��{!}!~�h;YrqWGB�?A`a;YDN?�EGI��xD2IKE�B�`�WX?C]\E�D���;>=�_FDFE�Z^E�[G��eg�|;Y=�_FD2]\=tWXZ��UDF]�V�;YB�HC]�?x��EGI��h;>DF`yWGBC�

 �@F]^Z\TF]^DF[S¡GL�L2eq��¢�v�OGP�£G£¤:s�!D2[�jN��ek�h;YDF`yWGB��kn

Page 2: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

l

Page 3: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

O

�����������

�J_F]\H�DFEX?A;�]\H W�HC_FE�B�? ]\DN?AB�E!TF@2=>?A]^E�D ?AE  �]\DFWGB��#�h;>=Y]^HC]\EGD#�h] WG[�BCWG`aHYnS��?�rFBCEmV�]\TF;>H�HCE�`a;�jqWG=���v[�BCEG@FDFT ��DFE ��Z\;>TF[�; WXDFT�TF;YH�=YB�]\jk;YH6?C_F;%=YEGBC; WGZ^[�E�B�]^?A_2`yH>n p E�BC;%T2;>?�WX]\Z\H(=tWXD�j�; IKE�@FDFT�]^D �B���WGDN?�� H�E�BC]^[�]\DFWGZ<rqWGrk;YBhEGD��;>TF@F=>;YT fhBCTF;>BC;YT# �]\DqWGB�� �h;>=Y]^HC]\EGD �h] WX[�BAWG`aH��  �B��!P����+WGDFT ?A_2;HC@FB�V�;i� rqWXr�;>B��  �B��!MNO�� n�R�B�;Y=Y;>DN?+;���?C;YDFH�]\E�D¤=YWGZ\Z^;YT� �E�E�Z\;YWGD b��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D¤�h] WG[�BCWG`aH<]\H�TF;YH�=YB�]\jk;YT]\D�� R��UMNd��/n�J_F]\HSDFEX?A;�]\H�W B�;>V�]\H�]\E�D EGI�WGD ;tWXBCZ\]^;YB V�;YB�HC]^E�D IKB�E�` I4WGZ\ZUlmM�M�� o jqWGHC;>T�EGD VG;YB�HC]\EGDFHSIKBCE�`

lmM�MNQ�WGDFT�lmM�MGL�u n��J_F;¤`yW���E�BTF]! �;YB�;YDF=>;YH�WGB�;¤WGHIKE�Z\Z^E ��HYz�"�]\BCH�?AZ���e#�Jf� ����hHhWXBC; DFE � V�]^;$��;YTWGH�DFE�TF;>HJEGI|E�DF;�[�Z^E�jqWGZk[�BAWXrF_%��]^?C_�E�DF;�&'�!;YT(E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[ ?CE�BC;$(F;Y=>?�H�?�WX?C;iv�EGI v�?C_F;ivxWGB�?�EGI|;$)a=Y]^;YDN? ���� rqWG=��-WG[�;>HYn1�J_F;yWGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F`aH�_FWmVG;�jk;Y;>D�=�_qWGD2[�;YT o WGDFT HC]^`yrFZ^]!&q;>Tgu?CE B�;$(q;>=>? ?A_F]^H�I4WX=>?tn* ;Y=>E�DFTFZ���eXWJrFBCE�EGI!EGI2?C_F;c=tWGDFEGDF]\=>]^?x�hZ^;Y`a`�W�_FWGH�j�;>;YD¤WXTFTF;YT n��J_F]^BCTFZ���e9?A_F;cH�;Y=>?C]\E�D2H|r2BC;YH�;YDN?A]^DF[?A_F;�WGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F`aH�_qWtV�;�jk;Y;>D�=YE�`arFZ\;i?A;>Z^�SB�;YH�?CBC@F=i?A@FB�;YTsn+"w]^DqWGZ\Z���e�?C_F;�rFB�E���;Y=i?JrFB�E�r�EGHAWGZk_qWGH�j�;>;YDBC;iV!]^HC;>Tsn

, +-/.1032546�8719:�8; ��./<>=

�J_qWGDF��H�?AE�?A_F;�H�?A@FTF;>DN?AH�EGD(?C_F;�=>E�@FB�HC;YHEGI�I4WGZ\Z+ltM�MGLFesltM�MNQ!eqWXDFT ltM�M��¤IKE�B�_F;YZ^rF]\D2[a`a;�TF;>jF@F[WGDFT ]^`yrFB�EmV�;1?A_2;�DFEG?A;>HYn%�J_FWGDF��H�WXBC;�WGZ^HCE TF@2;�?CE?��WGD2H@��]\H�=�_F;YZ/e p E�B�?C;YD �UZ^BC]^� *BA BC;>DFHC;>DseCU]^;YZ\H p WGBC;i?C?C] eBD A B�[�;YD * ?AWG@FDFH�?ABC@2rse2¢�]^` * �-WG�¤:|WXBCHC;>DseB�U;>DFBC]^��U@2Z\[NW�WXBCTseNWXDFTaVXWGB�]\E�@2H+r�;>E�rFZ^;E�D�?A_F;��xDN?A;>BCDF;i?E��_2EaIKE�@2DFT(?x��rkE�HWGDFT(HC@F[G[�;YH�?A;YT ]\`arFBCEmVG;Y`a;YDN?AH>n

Page 4: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

¡

Page 5: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

������������� L

� 0 .%<>��./<>=

� �������������������� �"!#!#$%����! &

' ()�*�,+-���/.��*�,+0! 1

2 3$4�5�6�87:9;�"<=$�!#$%�>�:9;$��6?*� ��+0! @

A BC���D!FE8�,GD<HE $4�5?I����JLKM���D$���GD���NE8$4�5?PORQS 39;9;! �"TLFn^l UWV�n n�n n�n�n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n lmQLFn O XZY5[]\�^ n n�n�n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n lmdLFn ¡ _S`�`*\ba n n�n�n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n ltMLFn L c3d*e f�g�[]hif n�n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n OX£LFn Q j>k6f�lnm�Y5o5f�e>_Soia�j>k6fwe*_S\�\6j>k6f n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n OGOLFn � ji[]pq`*\"[]r=a n�n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n OGQLFn d b��2]^H�?C;YDN?A]\WGZDsh@qWGDN?A] &q=tWX?C]\E�D�WXDFT * @FjFH�?C]^?C@2?A]^E�D n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n OGQ

T tu+-���%�v+P�v��E $4�5?wE x5�yORQS 39;9z�*�{��� �NE $%����! '>1

& �|����+-���%�v!3�*}~��� �*�����"+ !u���%��$4�5?I��$]E x:ORQS 39;9;! '>1�2n^l �J_F;�P�sh@F;>;YDFHrFB�E�jFZ\;>` n n�n n�n�n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n OGd�2n O ��E�BCB�;Y=i?ADF;>HCH�EXI{��E�` jF]\DqW-?A]\EGDqWGZ���]^BC=>@F]^?CH n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n OXM�2n ¡ b{��@2]^VXWGZ\;>DF=Y;�EGI���E�`¤j2]\DqWX?C]\E�DFWGZ���]^BC=Y@2]^?AH n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n OXM

1 �Z���,$]��<��NE8$�������$]E x�O�Q� 39�9;! 2��d!n^l ¢�DF]\[�_N?CH�?CE�@FBhn n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n n n�n n�n n n n n n�n n�n n n�n n�n�n n�n ¡G¡

@ �Z� �v�u�"<HE=�n����ORQS 39;9��q�6<,�v�6?*� 2*T

OR��}����,�"�D<��"! 2*&

Page 6: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

������������� Q

Page 7: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � �n���5���q� ����� � 6 �b���q �

� � 0/0 46� �. ���������8=>=��$0@.�=

�J_F;¤=>Z WGH�HC]\=YWGZ|=tWGZ^=Y@FZ^@FHUIKE�B�TF;tWGZ^]\DF[ ��]^?C_���������� �"!$#%�'&)(¤=YE�DFH�]\H�?AHhEGI+*-,.,"#/&0!$12�"!$��34!657#/&)(98;:0<=:?>@>@>^e?A_F;�=>E�DFH�?AWGDN?AHA�����B&al WGDFTDCE!$#F(.& £2eF?A_2; EGr�;>BAWX?CE�BCHJEGI�G),"1?H���1IGJ��3K,"1ML�eON$3/(�H���1IGJ��3K,"12P�eQ1I&KR6!$�43K,"1S eT3VUXWY#%3KG0!$�43K,"1[Z ecWGDFT\573V]^3VUXWY#%3KG0!$��3K,"1`_ ��_F]\=�_ ?CE�[�;>?C_F;YB�IKE�BC` ?A_F;� �E!E�Z^;tWGD�;��!rFBC;>HCH�]\E�DFH>n* E�`a;>?C]\`a;YH�?A_F;VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�WXBC;�=YWGZ\Z^;YTDWY�),)WB,.(J3V�43K,"1Y!$#'�"!$��34!657#/&)(hE�B�WY�a,)WB,.(J3V��3K,"1Y!$#'#/&J�4�b&J�a( WXDFT�?A_2; �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2H�WGB�;�?A_F;>D ��DFE ��D WXHcd�a,)WB,.(J3V�43K,"1Y!$#=e;,0R$3KGin

"gEGBC`yWGZ\Z���e� �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFBC;>HCH�]\E�DFHUWGB�; [G;YDF;>BAWX?C;YT�IKBCE�` ?A_F;�IKE�Z^Z\E ��]\DF[ [�BAWG`a`yWGBYzf z�zhg 8jiX£ki�lDi S f i f L f i f P f i f Z f i f _ f :

��_F;YB�;�8 BCWGDF[�;>H<E9VG;YB|WJHC;i?�EXI2 �E!E�Z^;tWGDhVXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YH>n<�J_F]\H<]^H<=tWGZ^Z\;>Th?A_F;T!65J(J�4�l!�GJ�'(Jm"1B�n!?o�EGI! �E!EGZ\;tWXD;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2HYnc�J_F;h=>E�DF=YB�;>?C;�H���DN?�W��1]\DF=>Z\@FTF;>H�rqWXBC;YDN?C_F;YH�;YHJ?AE¤H�E�Z^VG;hWG` jF]\[�@2]^?A]^;YH>n p EGBC;YEmVG;YBYegWXHW =>E�`y`aE�D =YE�DNV�;>DN?A]\EGD ]^?�]\H�WGHCH�@F`y;>T�?A_FWX? ?C_F;�E�rk;YBCWX?AEGBCH j2]\DFT WX=Y=YEGBCTF]^DF[ ?CE ?A_2;Y]\B�BC;>Z WX?C]^V�;rFBC]^E�BC]�?x��n+�J_2; r2BC]\EGBC]^?C]\;>HJWGBC;Xe'��]^?C_�?A_F;�_F]^[�_F;YH�?�&qBCH�?tz S eYLJeYP�eB_�e'Z n �;YDF=>;GeqIKE�BJ; �FWX`yrFZ^;

S 8qpQLr8'stPu8'vwZx8By+g oCo�o S 8qpCuQLr8'siuQPz8'viu{Z|8By}>R  �E!E�Z^;tWGD�;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D��]�?A_ VGWXBC] WXjFZ\;>HO8qpJ:?>7>?>7:08B~TF;>DFEG?C;YHwIKE�B�;tWG=�_¤WGHCH�]\[�DF`a;YDN?wEGIF?AB�@2?A_�VGWXZ\@F;>H?AE1?C_F;¤VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�]�?AHC;>Z^I�W�?AB�@2?A_ VXWGZ^@F;SWG=>=YE�B�TF]\DF[1?CE1?A_F;SH�?�WGD2TqWGBCT ?CBC@2?C_#?AWGjFZ^;YHYe HC;Y; &q[G@FBC;�l�n����������!"()(J3@R$1BU�&J1B��(�WGBC;%��B�]^?C?C;YD WGHSH�;u��@F;>DF=Y;>H�EGI�WGHCH�]\[�D2`y;>D�?CHSEGI�VXWGZ\@F;>H ?AE VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH>e�;Gn [Fn^e� £��"8qp�:tl���8's?:�£6�"8'v7:tl��"8By � ��_F]\=�_�WXHCHC]^[�DFHJ£ ?AE�8qp�WGDFT�8'vme lh?AE�8's�WGDFTk8By9n+� ]^?C_�?A_2]\H�rFWGB�?C]\=Y@2Z WGB?AB�@2?A_�WXHCHC]^[�DF`a;YDN?�?C_F;hWXj�EmV�;�;��!rFBC;>HCH�]\E�D�_qWXH�VXWGZ\@F; l�eB��_F;YB�;tWGH � £6�"8qpJ:Yl��"8's?:�£��"8'v?:�£6��8By ����]^;YZ\T2H£2n

S£ ll £

L £ l£ £ £l £ l

P £ l£ £ ll l l

Z £ l£ l ll £ l

_ £ l£ l £l £ l

"w]^[�@FB�;¤l�zc��B�@2?A_�?�WXjFZ\;>HYn

�J_F; HC;i?�EGIh?CBC@2?C_ VXWGZ\@F;>H�]^HyEGI ?C;YD T2;YDFEG?C;YT[��g �-£�:tl���n ��I8��; &'� WGD E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[ EGI�?A_2;VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�EXI�W6 �E!EGZ\;tWXD%;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D f ��;�=tWGD%V�]\;�� f WXH¤TF;$&FDF]\DF[#W6IK@2DF=>?C]\E�D�IKB�E�`�� ~ ?AE����_F;YB�;�� ]^H�?C_F;�D�@F`¤jk;YB�EGI�VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YH>n CUEG?C]\=Y;Xe<?A_qWX?�?C_F;�rqWGB�?C]\=>@FZ WGB�E�BCTF;>BC]^DF[�=�_FE�HC;>D�IKE�B�?A_2;VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�]\H ;YHCH�;YDN?A]\WGZ�IKEGB3��_qW-?�IK@FD2=>?A]^E�D%]^H�TF;�&qDF;>Tsnw��E�D2HC]\T2;YB�IKEGB�; �FWX`yrFZ^;a?C_F;�; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�D8uZ <�nc��I���; =�_FE!EGHC;�?A_F; E�BCT2;YBC]^DF[�8 ��<�?C_F;YD(?A_F]^H�]\H�?A_2;�IK@2DF=>?C]\E�D�� o 8;:0<Fu�g\8zZ <keF?ABC@2; ]�I?A_F; &qB�H�?�WXBC[�@F`a;YDN?U]\`arFZ\]^;YH�?C_F; H�;Y=YEGDFTse j2@2?h]�I���; =�_FE�E�HC;�?A_F;�E�BCTF;>BC]^DF[�<r��8 ?A_F;>D ]^?U]\H�?A_2;IK@FDF=i?A]\EGDM� o <Y:08�u�g�8�Z <ke ?AB�@F;S]^Ic?A_2;SHC;Y=>E�DFT WGB�[�@F`a;YDN?�]\`arFZ\]^;YH�?A_F;&FBCH�?Yn�� _F;>D���;�Z W-?A;YB=YE�D2HC]\T2;YB�=YEG`yrqWX=>?�B�;YrFB�;YHC;>DN?�WX?C]\E�DFH�EGI� �E�E�Z^;tWGD ; �2r2BC;YH�HC]^E�DFHYe�H�@F=�_ VXWGB�] WGj2Z\; EGBCTF;>BC]\D2[�H�rFZ Wt�6W=YB�@F=Y]\WGZsBCEGZ\;Gn����E# �E�E�Z^;tWGD%; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�DFH f WGDFT f^� WGBC;1HCWG]\T ?AE jk;1;u��@qWXZ�]^IJ?C_F;>� ��]\;>Z\T�?C_F;1HAWX`y;�?CBC@2?C_

VXWGZ\@F;�IKE�B�WGZ\Z�?AB�@2?A_ WGH�HC]\[GDF`y;>DN?AHYn R  �E!EGZ\;tWXD ;��!rFBC;>HCH�]\E�D ]\H�W��K!$� �^,"#/,0R$m ]�Ic]^?h��]\;>Z\TFHh?CBC@F;SIKE�BWGZ\Zk?AB�@2?A_ WGHCH�]\[�D2`y;>D�?CH7�q]�?J]\HX(7!$�43/(��d!657#/&�]^I�]^?��!]^;YZ^TFH�?AB�@F;�IKE�B�WX?Z\;YWGH�?�E�D2;�?CBC@2?C_(WGHCH�]\[�DF`a;YDN?Yn�|�����,<=$4!F�-�B��� * _FE � _FE � WGZ\Z�E�rk;YBCWX?AE�B�H�=YWGD jk;6;YD2=YE�TF;YT @FH�]\DF[ E�DFZ^� S WGDFT�P�n �UHC; ?A_F]^H?AE WGBC[G@F;S?A_qWX?�WGDN�  �E�E�Z^;tWGD#;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGD%=tWGD j�; ��B�]^?C?C;YD @FHC]^DF[ EGDFZ^�MP�etL�e|VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH>e�WXDFT SWGrFrFZ^]\;>T1?AESVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>HYn

Page 8: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���+��r�-��� �+��y d

�|�����,<=$4!F�-�B� ' R�B�[�@F;1?A_FWX? f WGDFT f^� WGBC;�;F��@qWGZ�]�IWGDFT E�DFZ���]�I f _ f^� ]^HSW ?�WG@2?CE�Z\EG[G��n#�xHS]^?r�EGHCHC]^jFZ\;U?AEaHAWt�%��_F;i?A_F;>B f ]\HJHAW-?A]\H &gWGjFZ^;hIKBCE�` ?A_F;�I4WG=i?�?A_qWX? S f ]\H�WS?�WG@2?CE�Z\EG[G���� � 0 � ; �4 0 � ; =

R  �E!E�Z^;tWGDa;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGD�]\H ]\D��3/(�H�� 1IGJ�43V�$&� �,"��U !$#��},"��U����� �����]�Is]�?�=>E�DFH�]\H�?CH�EGI�W TF]\H ��@FDF=i?A]\EGDEGI�=YE�D���@2DF=>?C]\E�DFH�EGI|VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YHJWGD2T DF;>[NWX?C]\E�DFHJEXI�VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH>e2] n ;Gn�eF]�Iw]�?J]\HJEGI�?A_F;�IKE�B�`

o f pp L f ps L�������L f p��� uQP�������P o f�� p L f��s L �����?L f���"! u o lmu��_F;YB�;�;tWG=�_ f$# % ]\HJ;>]^?A_2;YBW¤VGWXBC] WXjFZ\;X8 # % E�B�WaD2;Y[NWX?C]\E�D�EXI+WSVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\; S 8 # % n�R�D(;��2WG`arFZ^;�]\H

o 8�L S <2uQP o S 8DLu<Fu��_F]\=�_�]^HJW��;>Z\Z vx��DFE ��D1IK@FDF=i?A]\EGD�EGI;8 WGD2Tz< o ��_2]\=�_�E�DF;&�-u n�R�`yEGBC;�H�@F=Y=>]\DF=i?rFBC;>HC;YDN?AWX?A]^E�D�EGIo l9u�]^H�?AE ��BC]�?A;�]�?�@FHC]^DF[�]\DFTF; �!;YT VG;YB�HC]\EGDFH�EGI�L�WGDFT�PJz

�'#)( p*+ �-,.% ( p f # %0/1 >

* ]\`a]\Z\WGBCZ���e�W�2d,"1?H���1IGJ��3V�$&� A,"��U !$#3�},"��U4��25 ���� ]^H�WGD ; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�D ?C_qWX?�=YWGD jk;8��BC]�?C?A;>D(WGH�.#)( p*+ �-,'% ( p f # %0/1

��_F;YB�;�;YWG=�_ f$# % ]\H ;Y]^?C_F;YB�W VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;�E�B W(DF;Y[�WX?A;>T�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;Xn���? ]^H�D2EG?¤TF] )a=Y@FZ�?�?CE6rFB�E9VG;�?A_2;IKE�Z\Z^E ��]\DF[�rFBCE�rkE�H�]^?A]^E�Dsz�Z� �*�{��!#$]E $���� �76 1Bm�*-,.,"#/&0!$1�&loEWY�a&)()(J3K,"1u3/( &)87��!$#Y�b,�!$1�&loEWY�a&)()(J3K,"1r3V1 25 ��[!$1YN !$1 &loEWY�a&)(J](J3K,"1�3V19�� ��;:�xD%[�;>DF;YBCWGZ e�]^?�]\H _FWGBCT�?CE TF;i?A;YB�`y]^DF;:��_F;>?C_F;YB�W  �E!EGZ\;tWXD�;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGD ]^H�HCWX?A]^H &gWXjFZ\;Xn �J_F]^H¤]\H`�WXTF;�rFBC;>=Y]^HC;�jN��W�I4WX`yE�@2H�?A_F;>E�BC;>` TF@F;�?AE���E�E��?� ��E!ENd!l6�/z< x5����� �"+ ��= BZ���*�5> ? !$�43/(��d!6573V#%3V��mz,bCX*-,.,"#/&0!$1�&loEWY�a&)()(J3K,"1�(-3/(@ cd]0G),"UXWY#/&J�^&A:o "qE�B BC;YWGTF;YB�H�@FD2I4WX`y]^Z\] WXB>��]^?A_y?A_F;UDFEG?A]^E�D1EGI CCBwvx=YEG`yrFZ^;>?C;YDF;>HCH�?C_F;UIKE�Z^Z\E ��]\D2[�H�_FE�B�?�HC@F`a`�WXB��EGI�?A_F;�r2BAWG[�`yWX?C]\=�=>E�DFH�;u��@F;YD2=Y;YH�HC@')a=Y;>HYnDB�BCEGjFZ\;>`yH ?C_qWX?aWGB�; C�Bwvx=>E�`arFZ\;i?A;1=YWGD j�;�H�E�Z^VG;YTjN�#WGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F`aHU?C_qWX? BC@FD ]\D ; �!r�E�D2;YDN?A]\WGZ�?A]\`a;GnCUE(r�E�Z���DFE�`a] WGZ�?A]^`y;SWXZ\[�E�B�]^?C_F`yH�WGBC;���DFE ��D?AE ;��!]\H�?�IKE�ByWGDN� EGIh?A_2;1C�Bwv�=YE�`arFZ\;i?A;(rFBCEGjFZ\;>`yHaWGDFT ]^?a]\HaV�;YB�� @2DFZ\]^�G;YZ��%?A_FWX?1rkE�Z^��DFEG`y]\WGZ?A]^`y;�WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F`aH H�_FE�@FZ^T ]\DFT2;Y;YT ; �2]^H�?aWGZ�?A_FEG@F[�_%DFEGj�E�T2� _qWGH¤��;i?�j�;>;YD WGjFZ^;�?AE r2BCEmV�;�?A_2;Y]\BDFE�D!v�;��!]\H�?A;>DF=Y;Xn u

��E!E�� � HU?C_F;YE�B�;Y` ;>VG;YD _FE�Z^TFH���_F;YD B�;YH�?CBC]^=>?A;>T6?AEy;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2H�]\Dw��CE"�n#"qE�B��8CE"wH�HCWX?A]^H &2vWGjF]^Z\]^?x�a]^HT2;Y=Y]^TqWGjFZ^;�]\D�rkE�Z^��DFE�`a] WXZ�?A]^`y;�jF@2?�IKE�B�8C "wH�?C_F;�?�WG@2?CE�Z\EG[G��=�_2;Y=��(]\HJ_qWGB�T o =YEXv C�B=YE�`arFZ^;>?A;tuinhRUZ^?C_FE�@F[�_ HAWX?C]\H &gWGjF]^Z\]^?x��]^H�;YWGH�� IKE�Bh�8CE"wHhWGD2T ?�WG@2?CE�Z\EG[G�(=�_F;Y=�� ;tWGH��6IKE�Bq��C "wH>e

Page 9: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � � � �X���� ���t� ��b�~���-�^����T��� P

?A_F]^H�TFE�;YH�DFEG?J_F;>Z\r�@FH�HC]\D2=Y;h?A_2;h=YE�DNVG;YBCH�]\E�D�jk;>? ��;Y;>D ��CE"wHJWGDFT��8CE"wH�]^H�;��!rkE�DF;>D�?C] WGZsWGH�?A_2;IKE�Z\Z^E ��]\DF[�;��2WG`arFZ\;�H�_FE ��HYn

��E�DFHC]^TF;YBJ?C_F;�IKE�Z\Z^E���]^DF[���CE" EmV�;>BJ?A_F;�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YH 8 p� :?>7>?>l8 ~ � :08 pp :?>?>7>7:08 ~ p zo 8 p� Pr8

pp uQL o 8 s� Pr8s p uQL�������L o 8 ~ � Pu8 ~ p uI>

�J_F;�=>E�BCB�;YH�r�E�D2TF]\DF[h�8C " ]^HwWTF]\H ��@FDF=i?A]\EGD���_F]^=�_¤_qWGH�WTF]\H ��@FDF=i?wIKE�B|;tWG=�_SEXIF?A_F;d�kv�TF]\[�]�?�jF]\DFWGB��D�@F`¤jk;YBCH�IKBCE�` £�£�£+>?>?>�£�£�£ ?AE�l�l�l�>?>7>>l�lGl ?C_F;�� � ?A_�TF]^[�]^? B�;YrFB�;YHC;>DN?A]\D2[yW¤=�_2E�]\=>;hEGI|;Y]�?A_F;>Bd8 % �o IKE�B�£�u�E�Bw8 % p o IKE�B�l9u z o 8 p� Lu8 s� L �����.Lu8 ~� Bp� Lu8 ~ � u P

o 8 p� Lu8 s� L �����.Lu8 ~� Bp� Lu8 ~ p u Pnnno 8 pp Lu8 s p L �����.Lu8 ~� Bpp Lu8 ~ � u Po 8 pp Lz8 s p L �����?Lr8 ~� Bpp Lu8 ~ p uI>

� _F;YB�;tWGH ?A_F;�E�BC]^[�]\DqWXZF;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D�_FWGH�H�]��Y;UrFBCEGr�E�B�?A]^E�DqWGZF?CE�� ?C_F;h�8CE" _qWXH�HC]��Y;UrFBCE�rkE�B�?A]\EGDqWGZ?AED�<O ~ n�J_F;�DF; ��?SHC;>=>?A]^E�D�]^DN?ABCE�TF@F=>;YH W6DFE�B�`�WGZ+IKEGBC` ?A_qW-? _qWXH `aE�BC;aTF;YH�]\BCWGjFZ\;arFB�E�r�;>B�?C]\;YH�?A_FWGD

�8C "wH�WXDFT ��CE"wHYnc�xD(rqWGB�?A]\=>@FZ WXBYe!?C_F;YB�; WGBC;�;$)a=>]\;YDN?UWGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F`aH�IKEGBT2;>?A;>BC`a]\DF]^DF[¤?A_2; HCWX?A]^H &2vWGjF]^Z\]^?x�yWGD2T(?AWG@2?AEGZ\E�[G����@F;YH�?A]^E�DFHYn�|�����,<=$4!F� 'q��� �h;YH�=YBC]^j�;¤W1r�E�Z���DFE�`a] WGZ<?A]^`y;¤WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` IKE�BhT2;>?A;>BC`a]\DF]^DF[ ��_F;i?A_F;>B W��8C " ]\HHAWX?C]\H &gWGjFZ^;Gn�|�����,<=$4!F� 'q� ' �h;YH�=YBC]^j�;�W1rkE�Z��!D2E�`y]\WGZ�?A]\`a;¤WXZ\[�E�B�]^?C_F` IKE�BhTF;i?A;YB�`y]^DF]\D2[%��_F;>?C_F;YB W;��C " ]\HW¤?�WG@2?CE�Z\EG[G��n�|�����,<=$4!F� 'q� 2�� ]�V�;�WSrFB�E!EGI�EGI�rFBCEGr�E�H�]^?C]\E�D l�n�|�����,<=$4!F� 'q� A b��2r2Z WG]^Dy_FE � ��E�E�� � Hc?A_2;YE�B�;Y` ]\`arFZ\]^;YH+?C_qWX?�=�_F;Y=���]\D2[¤]\D!v�;u��@F]�VGWXZ\;YD2=Y;�j�;i? ��;>;YD �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2HU]^H�C�Bwvx_qWXBCTsn�|�����,<=$4!F� 'q� T b��2r2Z WG]^D _FE ��?C_F;Z��@F;>H�?C]\E�D EXI+?�WG@!?AE�Z^E�[G��WXDFT HAW-?A]\H &gWGjF]^Z\]�?x�1=tWXD6jk;�TF;>=Y]^TF;YT ]�I��; WGB�;�[�]^VG;YD(WGD WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` IKE�BJ=�_F;>=���]^DF[�;F��@F]^VXWGZ^;YDF=>; jk;>? ��;Y;>D  �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGDFHYn

� � �6.1���� � �8T��=��$0@. � �6� 9 ���; =

:<;>?+8�� < � :0<�p�j�;�?C_F;D3 C�]^���B&J1B]0&J#F(.&hE�r�;>BAWX?CE�BJTF;�&qDF;YT jN�8��x< � :0<�p g o 89L�< � uQP o S 8�Lr<�p�u

_F;YD2=Y;Ge f � f � : f p�]\H�?AB�@F;a]^I f WGDFT f � WXBC;S?AB�@F;yEGB ]�I f ]\H�I4WGZ^HC;aWGDFT f p�]^Hh?ABC@2;Gny� ;a=tWGZ^Z f ?A_2;�b&)(J�w&loEWY�a&)()(J3K,"1qnwRUZ\Z�E�r�;>BAWX?CE�BCH�=tWGD�;tWXHC]\Z���jk;h; �2r2BC;YH�HC;>T @FHC]^DF[SE�DFZ��y?C_F;h]�I v�?A_2;YD!v�;YZ\H�;hE�rk;YBCWX?AE�BWGDFT ?A_2;S=YE�DFH�?�WGDN?CH £�WGD2T�l�n p E�B�;YEmV�;>BYe�?A_F]^H�=tWGD#jk;aT2E�DF;S]\D H�@F=�_%W%��Wt� ?A_qW-? WGZ\Z|?A;YH�?AH WGB�;r�;>B�IKE�B�`y;>T6E�D2Z^�(E�D o @FD!vxD2;Y[NWX?C;YTguJVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�WXDFT6VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YHE!=>=Y@FBh]^D6DFE�EG?A_F;>B�rFZ\WG=Y;>HYn8�;YDF=>;?A_F;yE�rk;YBAW-?AE�B�[�]^VG;YH¤B�]\HC;a?AE W D2;$� ��]\DFT%EXI�DFE�BC`yWGZcIKE�BC`(n1"qE�B ;��2WG`arFZ^;Ge S 8 ]\H o 8�� £ :tl9u�e8k_ <y]^H 8�� o <�� l�:A£NuJ: o <�� £�:tl9u n * ]^DF=Y;hVXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH�`¤@FH�?�E�DFZ^�yE�=Y=Y@2B�]\D�?C;YH�?AHJ?A_F;h �E!EGZ\;tWXD;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�Du8 ]^HJBC;>rFBC;>HC;YDN?C;YT#WGHw8�� l�:�£�n

Page 10: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � � � �X���� ���t� ��b�~���-�^����T��� M

RUD��VC�]^���B&J1B]0&J#F(.&9 �,"��U !$#��O,"�JU ���� �����]\H(W  �E�E�Z^;tWGD ;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGD jF@F]^Z^?�;YDN?C]\BC;>Z^�IKB�E�` ?A_2;U]�I v�?A_2;YD!v�;YZ\H�;�E�r�;>BAWX?CE�B�WGDFTy?C_F;�=>E�DFH�?�WGDN?AH�£ WGD2T6l�H�@F=�_1?A_FWX?�WXZ\ZF?A;>H�?CH�WGB�;rk;YB�IKE�BC`a;YT�E�D2Z^�1EGD(VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH>n

��I ��;�jN� f � £6��8 ��T2;YDFEG?C;?C_F;U �E!EGZ\;tWXDy; �2r2BC;YH�HC]^E�D1E�j2?AWG]\D2;YTaj���B�;YrFZ\WG=Y]^DF[ 8%��]^?C_�£ ]\D f ?A_2;YD]^?J]^HJDFEG?_qWGB�T�?AE�HC;>; ?C_qWX?�?A_F;�IKE�Z^Z\E ��]\D2[ ;u��@F]�VXWGZ\;>DF=Y;�_FE�Z^TFHYz

f g 8�� f � l��"8 �n: f � £6��8 ��> o OGu�J_F]\H�]\H ��DFE ��D�WGH�?C_F; ? ��!$1B1I,"1�&loEW�!$1�(J3K,"1�EGI f ��]^?C_�B�;YHCrk;Y=i?�?AE�8�n��J_F]\H�HC]\`arFZ^;;F��@qWX?A]^E�D1_qWXHW�Z\EG?�EGI�@FH�;>IK@FZ WGrFr2Z\]\=YWX?A]^E�DFH>n¤�J_F; &qBCH�? ]^Hh?AE�[�;>DF;YBCWX?A;yWGD#� C " IKBCE�` WGDN�#;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D f n���I f=YE�DN?AWG]\DFH�DFE¤VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�]�?�]^H�;Y]�?A_F;>B�;u��@F]�VGWXZ\;YDN?�?CES£¤E�BhlE��_F]\=�_�]\H�WGD1� C "�ngf�?A_F;>B ��]\H�; ��;hIKE�BC`?A_F; * _FWGDFDFE�D(;��!rqWXDFHC]^E�D EXI f ��]�?A_�BC;>HCrk;Y=i?U?CEyE�D2; EXI�?C_F; VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YHd8 ]\D f nc�J_�@FHUH�]\DF=>; f � £6�"8 �WGDFT f � l��"8 �<jkEG?A_�=>E�DN?�WG]^D�E�DF;�Z\;>HCH�VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;U?C_qWGD f e ��;�=YWGD�BC;Y=>@FBCH�]^VG;YZ^� &qDFT�� C "wH�IKEGBJj�EG?C_�EGI?A_F;>HC;��q=tWGZ^Z ?A_F;>` f � WXDFT f pin RUD�� C " IKE�B f ]^HJDFE � HC]^`yr2Z^�

8�� f pJ: f � >

��;�_qWtVG; r2BCEmV�;>Tsz�Z� �*�{��!#$]E $����:' 6 1BmD*X,.,"#/&0!$1M&loEWY�a&)()(J3K,"1�3/(9&)87��3V�"!$#/&J1B�d�^,�!$1�&loEWY�a&)()(J3K,"1�3V1�� C� :�|����+P��%�-� ��EGDFHC]^TF;YBh?C_F;S �E�E�Z\;YWGD ; �2r2BC;YH�HC]^E�D f g o 8qp�_ <�p�u}L o 8's-_ <�s uin ��I ��;&FDFT WGD� C " EGI f jN�%HC;>Z\;>=>?A]^DF[ ]\D EGBCTF;>B¤?A_F;1VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YHA8qpJ:a<�p�:l8's?:a<$sSEGD ��_2]\=�_ ?AE rk;YB�IKE�BC` * _qWGDFD2E�D;��!rqWGD2HC]\EGDFHYe ��;�[G;>?J?A_2; ; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�DFH

f g 8qp � f p�: f �f � g <�p � £�: f � �f p g <�p � f p^pJ:�£f � � g 8's � f � � pJ: f � � �f p^p g 8's � f p^p^pJ: f p^p �f � � � g <$s � £�:Ylf � � p g <$s � l�:A£f p^p � g <$s � £�:Ylf p^p^p g <$s � l�:A£

"w]\[G@FBC;�O¤H�_FE ��HU?A_2; ; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�D WGHWS?CBC;>;Gn * @F=�_ W�?CBC;Y;�]^H�WGZ\H�ES=tWGZ^Z\;YT(WrN�&)GJ3/(J3K,"1��4�a&)&A:��R Z\EX?�EGI�?C_F;h;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGDFHWGBC;h;YWGHC]^Z^�yHC;>;YD�?AESjk;h]\T2;YDN?A]^=tWGZ/e!H�ES]^?�]^H�?C;Y`ar2?A]^DF[ ?AES]^TF;YDN?C]^I ��?A_F;>` n"qE�B ; �FWX`yrFZ^;Ge+]^DFH�?C;tWGT EXI f p^p � ��;�=tWGD @FH�; f � � � WGDFT ]\D2H�?A;YWGT EGI f p^p^p���;�=YWGD @FH�; f � � pin ��I���;HC@Fj2H�?A]�?A@2?C; f � � � IKE�B f p^p � ]\D#?A_F;aBC]^[�_N?�vx_FWGDFT HC]\T2;yEGI f p^p WGDFT�WGZ\H�E f � � p�IKEGB f p^p^pie ��;y]\D#I4WG=>?�HC;>;?A_qW-? f � � WGD2T f p^pJWGBC;�]^TF;YDN?A]^=tWGZ/eFWGD2T ]^D f p+��; =YWGD(BC;Yr2Z WG=>; f p^p+��]^?C_ f � � n��IE��; ]^D%I4WG=>?a]^TF;YDN?A]�I � !$#V#U;u��@qWGZJH�@Fjk;��!rFBC;>HCH�]\E�DFH ��;�;>DFT�@2r ��]�?A_ ��_qWX?a]\HS��DFE ��D WGH�W573V1Y!$��mjN�&)GJ3/(J3K,"1 N$34!.R$�0!$U o W�* ���Uu n+��?�]^H�DFE Z^E�DF[�;>BaW#?CBC;Y;(EGI� �E�E�Z\;YWGD�; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�DFHyjF@2?yWTF]\B�;Y=i?A;YT(WG=i��=YZ\]^=�[�BAWGr2_ o �R � uin

Page 11: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � � � �X���� ���t� ��b�~���-�^����T��� lt£

���

� � � � �

���

���

�� ��

� �� ��

���

���

�� ��

"w]\[G@FBC; O!zR TF;Y=>]\H�]\E�D6?CBC;>;¤IKE�B o 8qp+_ < p�uOL o 8'sX_ <$s u n���WGHC_F;>T Z\]^DF;YHUTF;YDFEX?A;SZ\E ��v�jFBAWGD2=�_F;YH>eHCE�Z^]\T�Z^]\DF;>H�_F]\[G_!vxjFBCWGDF=�_F;>HYn

R�rFrFZ���]\DF[S?A_2]\HJ]\T2;tWSEGI�HC_qWGB�]\DF[2e f =YWGD�DFE ��j�;���B�]^?�?A;YD WGH>zf g 8qp � f p�: f �f � g <�p � £�: f � �f p g <�p � f � � :�£f � � g 8's � f � � pJ: f � � �f � � � g <$s � £�:Ylf � � p g <$s � l�:A£

bcWG=�_�HC@Fjk;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGD =YWGD�j�;UV!]^;$��;YT(WGH ?A_F;�DFE�TF;UEGI�W [�BAWXrF_sn * @F=�_(W D2E!TF;�]\H�;>]^?C_F;YB-�^&J��U�3V1Y!$#]\D¤?C_F;J=tWGH�;�EGI�?C_F;�=YE�D2H�?�WXD�?CH £ WXDFT�l�eNE�B+1I,"1B]^�^&J�JU�3V1Y!$# n|R DFE�D�v�?A;>BC`a]\DqWXZ2DFE�TF;J_qWGHcW�Z^E���v�;YTF[G;=YE�B�BC;>HCrkE�DFTF]^DF[�?CE�?A_2;U;>Z\HC; vxrqWXB�?�WGDFT�W _F]\[�_�vx;YT2[�;�=YE�B�BC;YH�r�EGDFTF]\D2[�?AE ?A_F;?A_F;>D!vxrFWGB�?Yn * ;Y; &q[�@FB�;¡2n�CEG?A]^=Y;Ge�?A_qWX? ?A_F;1D�@F` j�;>B¤EGI�DFE�TF;YH _qWGH¤TF;>=YB�;tWGH�;YT IKBCE�` M6]^D�?A_F;�TF;Y=>]\HC]^E�D�?CBC;Y;y?AE�� ]^D?A_F;( ����¤nw��?�]\H�DFEG?�_qWXBCT ?AE ]\`yWG[�]\D2;y?A_FWX?�]^IU;tWG=�_�EGI?A_F;�?A;>BC`a]\DqWXZ�DFE�TF;YH ��;YBC;(EG?C_F;YB�jF]^[TF;Y=>]\H�]\E�D�?CBC;>;YHJ?A_F;�HAWtV�]\DF[�H���E�@FZ^T�j�;�T2BAWG`yWX?A]^=Gn * ]\DF=>;���;�_FWmVG;�=�_FE�HC;>D(?CES=YE�D2HC]\H�?A;>D�?CZ^��HC;YZ^;Y=i?VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�]\D1?C_F;�HAWG`a;�E�B�TF;YBJ]^D�?C_F;�BC;>=Y@FB�HC]^VG;�=tWGZ^Z\H�TF@2BC]\D2[�?C_F;�=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?C]\E�D�EGI|?A_2; � CE" EGI f e?A_F;�VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH�E�=Y=Y@2B]^D(?C_F; HAWG`a;�E�BCTF;>BC]^DF[�H�E�D WGZ\Z<rqW-?A_FH�IKBCE�` ?A_F; BCE�EG?�EGI�?A_F;� ����¤nq�xD�?A_F]^HHC]�?A@qWX?C]\E�Da?A_F;�j2]\DqWGB���T2;Y=Y]^HC]^E�D�TF] WX[�BAWG` ]^H�HAWG]^T�?AESjk;�,"�lN�&J�a&0N o WGD�d* ���Uuin "w]\[G@FBC;�¡¤HC_FE ��HW ���� ?A_qW-?U]^H�WGZ\H�E�WGD6f� ����¤n

"w]\[�@2BC;6L H�_FE ��H1IKE�@FB�f� ����hH>n * E�`a; EGI�?C_F; ?A;>H�?AH o ;Gn [Fn�eEGD�8's(]^D �iu1WGBC;6BC;YT2@FDFTqWGDN?YeHC]^DF=Y;�j�EG?C_6?A_2;¤Z\E ��v�WGDFT _F]^[�_!v�jFBAWGD2=�_ Z\;YWGT6?AEy?A_F;�HAWG`a; DFE�TF;Xn * @F=�_ @FD2DF;Y=>;YHCHCWGB��6?A;YH�?AH�=YWGDj�;�BC;Y`aEmV�;>Tsz1WGDN��BC;>IK;>BC;>DF=Y;�?AE ?C_F;1B�;YTF@FD2TqWGDN?aDFE!T2;1]\H¤H�]\`arFZ^�#B�;YrFZ\WG=Y;>T j��%W BC;iIK;YBC;>DF=Y;1?CE

Page 12: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � � � �X���� ���t� ��b�~���-�^����T��� lGl

��� ���

� � � �

���

� �

� �

"w]\[G@FBC;�¡!z R  �����IKE�B o 8qp�_ <�p�uQL o 8's _ <$s u+��]�?A_(E�BCTF;>BC]^DF[�8qpw��< pw� 8'sX��<�stn :�E ��v�;YTF[�;>HWGBC;�T2BAW���D6WXHT2EG?C?C;YT(Z\]\D2;YH�WGDFT(_F]^[�_!vx;>TF[�;>H�WGH�HCE�Z^]\T�Z\]^DF;YH>n

� �

� �

� �

���

��

� �

��

�� �

"w]\[G@FBC;JLFz�"qE�@FB�f� ����hHYzwWNu+R�D�f� ���� IKE�B�l�n+jqu�RUDFEG?C_F;YB�f� �����IKE�BJl ��]^?C_a? ��E B�;YTF@FD2TqWGDN??A;>H�?AH>n =tu * WG`a;SWGH � ��]^?A_ EGDF;¤EGIc?A_2;SBC;YT2@FDFTqWGDN?�?A;>H�?CH�BC;Y`aEmV�;>Tsn Tgu�RUD f� ���� IKE�B 8qptP�8'v��]^?C_(EGDF;�BC;YT2@FDFTqWGDN?�?A;>H�?Yn

Page 13: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � � � �X���� ���t� ��b�~���-�^����T��� lmO

� �

��� ������ � � �

"w]\[G@FBC;�Q!zS�J_F;�E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[6WGDFT B�;YTF@F=>;YTFD2;YHCH�=>E�DFTF]�?A]\EGDFH�EXI �Jf� ����hHYn6:�;iI ?tz�� WGB�] WGjFZ^;YH `¤@FH�?j�;u,"�lN�&J�)&0NGn p ]\T2TFZ\;XzECE!T2;YHh`¤@2H�?hjk;k��1B3$87�'&in �]^[�_N?tzfhDFZ���1I,"1B]^�a&0N$��1YN6!$1B�w�^&)(J��(�H�_FE�@FZ^T jk;rFBC;>HC;>D�?Yn

]^?CHH�@FjFDFE�TF;XnU��IcWXZ\Z<]\T2;YDN?A]^=tWGZ<DFE�TF;>HhWGB�;�H�_qWGBC;>T WGDFT WGZ\Z<B�;YTF@FD2TqWGDN?�?C;YH�?CHhWGB�; ;>Z\]\`a]\DFWX?A;>Tse2?A_2;f� ���� ]\H�HAWG]^T�?CEhj�;X�)&0N$�BG)&0N o WXD�� d* ���uin��Jf� ����hH�_qWtV�;JHCEG`y; V�;YB��¤=>E�DNV�;YD2]\;YDN?crFB�E�rk;YB�?C]\;>H=Y;>D�?C;YB�;YTSWGB�E�@FDFT�?A_2;G0!$1I,"1B3KGJ3V�4mX#/&JU�U !j�;>Z\E ��n o f�I ?A;YD ��_F;>D rk;YE�rFZ^;cHCrk;tWG��WGjkE�@2?� ����hHs?C_F;>�BC;YWGZ\Z���`a;tWGD�� � ����hHYn u ��EaHC@F`a`yWGBC]��Y;Gz

R *�3V1Y!$��m ��&)GJ3/(J3K,"1�� 34!.R$�l!$U4��* ��� ��]\H�W�BCE�EG?C;YTseFT2]\BC;>=>?C;YT WG=>��=YZ^]\=�[�BCWGrF_/��]^?C_ E�D2; EGB�? ��Ea?A;YB�`y]^DqWGZ�DFE!T2;YH�EGI�E�@2?�v�TF;Y[GBC;Y; �>;YBCEaZ WXj�;>Z\;YT�£�E�B�l�eFWGDFT W H�;>?JEXIsVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;DFE�TF;YH��EGI<E�@2?�vxTF;>[�BC;>;�? ��EFn��J_F;�? ��ESE�@2?C[�E�]\D2[�;>TF[�;YHWGB�;S[�]^VG;YD#jN�6? ��E(IK@2DF=>?C]\E�DFH�#/, � o �u�WGDFTj��3@R"� o �uin o �xD#rF]^=>?C@FBC;>HYes?A_2;YHC;WGB�;UH�_FE ��D�WGH TFEG?�?A;YT�WGDFTyHCE�Z^]\T�Z\]^DF;YH>e�B�;YH�r�;>=>?A]�V�;>Z^��n u¤R�VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;�"!$� o �u]^HUWXHCHCE�=Y]\WX?A;>T/��]^?A_�;YWG=�_ VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;�DFE�TF;Xn

R  ���� ]\H w�0N�&J�a&0N o f� �����u�]�IJE�D WGZ^Z�rqWX?C_FH ?A_2BCE�@F[G_�?A_F;�[�BAWGr2_ ?A_2;�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>HBC;>HCrk;Y=>?1W [G]^V�;>D Z\]^DF;tWXBSE�BCTF;>B 8qp�� 8'sM� ����� � 8B~!n R�D o f�u� ���� ]\H���&0N$�'G)&0No � o f�u� �����u�]^I o G��D$��iGD�"�5�v!u! ucD2E ? ��E TF]^H�?C]\DF=i?�D2E!TF;>H��WGDFT��¤_qWtV�;?A_F;�HCWG`y;JVXWGB�] WGjFZ^;DqWX`y; WGDFT�Z^E���v�WXDFT _2]\[�_!v�HC@F=>=Y;>HCHCEGBYeq] n ;Gn�e�"!$� o �u�g �"!$� o �2u�:?#/, � o u�g #/, � o �!uJ:E��3@R"� o u�g ��3@R"� o �2u�]^`yr2Z\]\;>H�kg��':WGD2T

o �D����� � �"J�GD�DJD����E�E#�v!bE ! uJDFEyVXWGB�] WGjFZ^;�DFE!T2;� _qWXH�]\T2;YDN?A]^=tWGZ�Z\E ��v�WGDFT_F]^[�_!v�HC@F=>=Y;YH�HCE�B>eg] n ;Gn�e

#/, � o u��g ��3@R"� o �uI>�J_F;�E�BCT2;YBC]^DF[aWGDFT(BC;>TF@F=Y;>TFDF;>HCH�=>E�DFTF]�?A]^E�DFH�WGB�;�HC_FE ��D6]^D/&q[�@FB�; Q�n

�Jf� ����hH�_qWtV�; H�E�`a; ]^DN?A;YB�;YH�?A]\D2[yrFB�E�rk;YB�?C]\;>HYn��J_2;>�(rFBCEmV�]\T2;�=>E�`yrFWG=>?BC;>rFBC;>HC;>D�?AWX?A]^E�DFHEGI �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2HYekWGDFT�?A_F;>BC;�WGBC;�;�)a=Y]\;>DN?hWGZ^[�E�B�]^?A_2`yH IKE�BJr�;>B�IKE�B�`y]^DF[SWGZ^Zs��]\DFT2HEXIwZ^E�[�]\=YWGZE�rk;YBAW-?A]\EGDFHSE�D �Jf� ����hHYn �J_F;>��WGB�;(WGZ\Z�jFWGHC;>T E�D ?A_F;(=YB�@F=Y]\WGZ�I4WG=>?�?C_qWX?�IKE�BaWGDN� IK@FDF=i?A]\EGD� z�� ~ � � ?C_F;YB�;�]^H9&lo !�GJ��#%mu,"1I&�� d* ��� �)&^WY�a&)(.&J1B�43V1�R�3V�/n��J_F]\H`y;YWGDFH>ek]^D rFWGB�?C]\=Y@2Z WGB>e2?A_qW-??A_F;>BC;�]\H�&lo !�GJ�4#%m�,"1I&@�Jf� ���� IKE�Bh?A_2;a=>E�DFH�?�WGDN? ?ABC@2; o WGDFT =YE�D2H�?�WXD�?�I4WGZ^HC;tuUIK@FDF=>?C]\E�D#E�D � ~ z?A_F;h?C;YB�`y]^DqWGZ D2E!TF;Sl o WGDFT(£S]\D�=YWGHC;�EGI|I4WGZ\H�;mu n �U;YD2=Y;Geq]�?J]\HJrkE�H�HC]\j2Z\;�?CEz�b&)(J�{3V1�G),"1�(J�K!$1B�{�43VU�&�t�B&J���B&J�!$1�� d* ��� 3/(9G),"1�(J�K!$1B��#%mD�4���'&�,"��CE!$#F(.&in o �;>=tWGZ^Z�?A_FWX?JIKE�B� �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGDFHJ?A_F]^HrFBCEGjFZ\;>` ]\H�CCBwvx=YEG`yrFZ^;>?C;Gn u

Page 14: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � � � �X���� ���t� ��b�~���-�^����T��� lt¡

��E�`yWG�G;+?C_F]\H<=>Z WG]^`�`aE�B�;�rFBC;>=Y]\H�;���;c`¤@FH�?�HAWt����_qW-? ��;c`a;tWGD�IKE�B<WXD���f� ���� ?CE�BC;Yr2BC;YH�;YDN?WhIK@FDF=>?C]\E�D n>"w]^BCH�?Ye�]^?c]^H���@F]^?C;�;tWGH��¤?AE�HC;>;U_2E�� ?A_2;D2E!TF;>H �EGI WGD �Jf� ���� ]\DFT2@F=>?C]^V�;>Z^� TF;$&qD2;YH �E�E�Z\;YWGD%;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGDFH f � z�R ?A;YB�`y]^DqWGZ DFE�TF;�]\H�W  �E�E�Z^;tWGD =>E�DFH�?AWGDN?tn%R D2E�D!v�?C;YB�`y]^DqWGZ DFE!T2;`�WXBC�G;>T@��]�?A_D8�]\H WGD�]�I v�?C_F;YD!v�;YZ^HC;�;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D@��_F;YB�;U?A_2;U=>E�DFTF]�?A]\EGDy]^H�8�WGDFTy?C_F;U? ��E j2BAWGDF=�_2;YHWGBC;h?C_F;  �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2H�[�]�V�;YD�jN��?A_2; Z^E ��v E�BJ_F]\[G_!vxH�E�DseFB�;YHCrk;Y=i?A]�V�;YZ��kz

f � g £f p g lf � g �"!$� o �u � f���� ����� �� : f� �� �� �� : ]^I ]\HW¤VGWXBC] WXjFZ\;hD2E!TF;Xn

p E�B�;YEmV�;>BYe�]^I 8qp � 8'sz� �����{� 8B~ ]\H ?A_F;aVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;aE�B�TF;YB�]\DF[ EGIJ?A_F; �Jf� ����¤e ��;1WGHCH�E!=>] WX?C;��]^?C_�;tWX=�_ DFE!T2;�%?A_F;yIK@FDF=>?C]\E�D � � ?A_qW-?¤`yWGrFH o �7p�: �)s.:?>?>?>E: �a~Nu���� ~ ?AE6?C_F;�?AB�@2?A_ VGWXZ\@F;aEGIf � � �7p0�"8qp): �)sJ�"8's.:?>?>?>E: �a~6��8B~��/n+��;�=YWGD D2E�� H�?AWX?A;�?A_2; �X;>�(Z\;>`y`yW2z� �"+0+P�:� = BZ���5�>�D$�<=$%E 7��%�v+-+-� >�},"��!$1Bm�C�� 1IGJ�43K,"1�� z$� ~ � � �V�B&J�a&�3/(�&lo !�GJ��#%mu,"1I& � d* ��� ��3V�V���"!$�J34!657#/&�,"�lN�&J��3V1�R�8qp��8's � ������� 8B~u(J�'G)�r�V��!$�t� � g\� o 8qpJ:?>7>?>7:08B~�uA:�Z� ���*} � �J_F;1rFB�E!EGI�]^H�jN��]\DFTF@2=>?A]^E�D�EGD�?A_F;�D�@2`¤j�;>B EGIWXBC[�@F`a;YDN?CH EGI ��n "qE�B���g £ ?C_F;YB�;WGBC; E�DFZ���? ��E� �E!E�Z^;tWGD(IK@FDF=i?A]\EGDFHYek?A_F;�=YE�DFH�?�WGDN?CZ^��I4WGZ\H�;¤WGD2T =YE�D2H�?�WXD�?CZ^��?AB�@F;�IK@2DF=>?C]\E�DFH>n�RUD���Jf� ���� =YE�DN?AWG]\DF]^DF[�WX? Z\;YWGH�?�EGDF;�DFE�D!v ?A;YB�`y]^DqWGZ�DFE!T2;a]^H�DFE�D!v�=YE�D2H�?�WXD�?Yn o � _N���-u �J_F;YB�;>IKE�B�;?A_F;>BC;�]\HJ; �2WG=>?CZ^��E�D2;���f� �����IKEGBJ;tWG=�_ EGI�?C_F;YH�;Gzc?A_F;�?C;YBC`a]\DFWGZ\H�£yWGD2T lGnR�HCH�@F`a;�DFE � ?C_qWX?��;�_qWtV�;�r2BCEmV�;>D ?C_F;1Z\;>`y`yW(IKEGB¤WGZ^Z IK@FD2=>?A]^E�DFH¤EXI � WGBC[�@2`y;>D�?CHYn � ;

rFBCE�=Y;>;YTa?AE H�_FE � ]^?cIKE�B�WGZ\ZFIK@2DF=>?C]\E�DFH EGIQ���%l�WGB�[�@F`a;YDN?AH>nc:<;>?w�#z�� ~��=p � � j�;�WGDN�a �E!EGZ\;tWXDIK@FDF=i?A]\EGD1EGI;��� l�WGB�[�@F`a;YDN?AH>nc�h;$&qD2;�?A_F;U? ��E¤IK@FD2=>?A]^E�DFHw� � WGDFTr��p EGI;� WXBC[�@F`a;YDN?CH�jN�@&'�!]^DF[?A_F;8&qB�H�?UWGB�[�@F`a;YDN?�EGI�� ?CEa£aB�;YHCrk;Y=i?A]�V�;YZ�� l�z

��� o 8's.:?>?>?>E:08B~��=p�u�g � o �.:08's.:7>?>?>7:l8B~��=p�u�IKE�B ������no * EG`y;i?A]\`a;YH+� � WGDFT��6p�WGBC;�=YWGZ\Z^;YT1?C_F;D1I&KR6!$��3V�$& WXDFTkWB,.(J3V��3V�$&9G),"]hCE!�GJ�^,"�a( EGI��1��]�?A_�BC;>HCrk;Y=i??CE8qp n u��J_F;>HC;�IK@FDF=i?A]\EGDFH�HAWX?C]\H�I �y?A_F;�IKE�Z^Z\E ��]\D2[¤;u��@qWX?C]\E�D z

� o 8qpJ:?>?>?>E:08B~�u[g 8qp � �6p o 8's.:?>?>?>E:08B~�uJ:�� � o 8's.:?>7>?>7:08B~�uI> o ¡�u* ]\D2=Y;r� � WGDFT ��p ?AWG�G;�E�DFZ�����WGB�[�@F`a;YDN?AH��;6WXHCHC@2`y;�jN� ]\D2TF@F=>?C]\E�D%?C_qWX?S?C_F;YB�; WXBC;�@FDF] ��@2;�Jf� �����DFE�TF;YH � WXDFT Qp+��]^?C_�� ��� g � � WGDFT�� � � g �6p n�J_F;YB�;�WGBC;? ��E =tWGH�;YH�?CE =YEGDFHC]^TF;YB>n���I � g�qp�?C_F;YDz� � � g\� � � WGD2Tu� � g � � � g � � � g ��p�g��n �U;>DF=Y;� � g qp�]\H�WGD �Jf� ���� IKE�B���n���?�]\H�WGZ\H�E ?A_2;�E�DFZ��?�Jf� ���� IKEGB9� HC]\D2=Y;aTF@F;y?CE?A_F;�E�BCT2;YBC]^DF[Fek]^I}8qp]\HhW-?hWGZ^Z�rFBC;>HC;YDN?�]^D ?A_2;�Jf� ���� B�E!EX?A;YT WX? �e'8qp���EG@FZ\T D2;Y;YT ?CE�jk; ?A_2;BCE�EG?�DFE�TF;Gn��UE ��;iV�;>BYes]�I���g � � ?A_2;YD2� � g � � � £6�"8qp �qg � �� �� �� WXDFT ��pdg � � � l��"8qp �qg � ��������� �� n* ]\D2=Y; � � g � � � g � � � g\�6p�jN��WGHCH�@F`ar2?A]^E�Dse!?C_F;�Z\E ��v WXDFT�_F]\[�_�vxHCEGD1EGI ��E�@FZ^T�j�;h?C_F;�HAWG`a;Ge`�WX��]^DF[¤?A_2;���f� �����V�]^E�Z WX?C;�?A_2; B�;YTF@2=Y;YT2DF;YH�Hh=YE�D2TF]^?C]\E�D�EGI�DFE�D�vxBC;>TF@FDFTFWGDN?U?C;YH�?CHYn��I � �g qpJ?C_F;YD2� � � �g � � � j��(?A_2; ]\D2TF@F=>?C]\E�D _N�!rkEG?C_F;YH�]\H o @FHC]^DF[y?C_F; DFWG`y;>H 8's.:?>7>?>7:08B~��=p]\D rFZ WX=Y;�EGIw8qpJ:?>7>?>E:l8B~�uiny��;�?�WG�X;��?CE6jk;a?C_F;aDFE!T2; ��]�?A_[�"!$� o u g 8qp ed#/, � o �u g � e+WXDFT��3@R"� o �u g qp e�]/n ;Xn^e-� � g 8qp � � � � :�� � � ��_2]\=�_�]\H1B�;YTF@F=>;YTsn  �� WGHCH�@F`yr!?A]\EGD � � � g ��p

WGDFT � � � g�� � ?C_F;YB�;>IKE�B�; @FH�]\DF[ o ¡Nu���;([�;i?k� � g ��n * @FrFrkE�HC;�?C_qWX?���]^HSHCE�`a;�EG?A_F;>B�DFE!T2;��]^?C_��! �g �|n ��Z\;YWGBCZ���e��" y` @FH�?ST2;Yrk;YDFT E�Dj8qpiew] n ;Gn�e��! � £��"8qp � �g �! � l��"8qp � o EG?C_F;YB ��]\HC;1WGZ\H�E

Page 15: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � � � �X���� ���t� ��b�~���-�^����T��� lYL

� � g �! � £6�"8qp �+g �! �� l��"8qp �+g �6pie�W6=>E�DN?ABCWGTF]\=i?A]^E�Dguin �h@F;a?AE6?C_F;1E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[(?A_F]^H `a;tWGDFH ?A_qW-?�"!$� o �!u9g 8qp9g��"!$� o �uin p EGBC;YEmVG;YBYecIKBCEG` �" zg ��]^?�IKE�Z\Z^E���H�?A_FWX? � � �� � g � � g � ��� WXDFT� �������� � g ��p�g � � � e'��_F]^=�_(jN�y?A_F;h]^DFTF@F=i?A]^E�D1_N��r�EG?C_F;YH�]\H�]\`arFZ^]\;YH�?C_qWX?#/, � o �2u�g � g #/, � o uWGDFT���3@R"� o �!u�g�qp�g ��3@R"� o �uin>"gB�E�` ?A_F;�BC;YT2@F=Y;>TFDF;YH�HUr2BCE�rk;YB�?x��EGI�@2DF] ��@F;>DF;YH�HJ]^?�IKEGZ\Z\E ��Hc?A_qW-?zg �kn �R�D ]\`a`y;>TF] WX?C;¤=YEGDFHC;F��@2;YDF=>;�]\H�?A_F;aIKE�Z\Z^E ��]\DF[Fn * ]^DF=Y;�?A_2;y?A;>BC`a]\DqWXZ�l�]^H�WXD �Jf� ���� IKE�B WGZ\ZVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;�E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[GH¤]^? ]\H�?C_F;1E�D2Z^� �Jf� ���� ?A_FWX?¤]^H¤=YE�D2H�?�WXD�?CZ^� ?AB�@F;Gn * E ]^D%E�B�TF;YB ?AE =�_F;>=����_F;>?C_F;YB¤WGD �Jf� ���� ]^H�=>E�DFH�?�WGDN?AZ�� ?CBC@F;y]^?�HC@')a=>;YH¤?AE =�_F;Y=�� ��_F;>?C_F;YB¤]�? ]^H ?C_F;�?C;YBC`a]\DFWGZJl��_F]\=�_ ]^HSTF;$&qD2]^?A;>Z^��W =YE�DFH�?�WGDN?�?A]^`y;�E�r�;>BAWX?C]\E�D n * ]^`y]^Z WGB�Z^�Ge��Jf� ����hH¤?C_qWX?aWGB�;�=YE�D2H�?�WXD�?CZ^�I4WGZ\H�;�`¤@FH�?ajk; ]^TF;YDN?C]\=tWXZ�?AE#?A_F;�?A;>BC`a]\DqWGZ�£2n �xD I4WG=>?Ye�?AE TF;>?C;YB�`y]^DF;/��_F;>?C_F;YBa? ��E� �E!EGZ\;tWXDIK@FDF=i?A]\EGDFH WGBC;¤?C_F;yHCWG`a;Ge�]^?�H�@')a=Y;YH ?AE(=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>? ?A_2;Y]\B ��f� ����hH o ]\D ?A_2;aHCWG`a;a[GBAWGrF_qu�WXDFT=�_F;Y=��%��_2;>?A_2;YB�?A_F;�BC;>HC@FZ�?A]^DF[�DFE!T2;YHWGBC;�?C_F;�HAWG`a; �

�J_F;UEGBCTF;>BC]\D2[ EXI VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YH�=�_FE�H�;YD ��_2;YD�=>E�DFH�?ABC@2=>?A]^DF[¤WXD �Jf� ���� _qWGH W�[�BC;YWX? ]\`arqWG=i?cE�D?A_F;SH�]��>;¤EGIc?A_F;:��f� ����¤n ��I ��;�=>E�DFHC]^TF;YB�WX[NWG]\D ?A_F;S; �2r2BC;YH�HC]^E�D o 8qp�_ < p�utL o 8'sX_ <$s uhWXDFT=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?¤WGD ��f� ���� @FH�]\DF[(?A_F;aE�BCT2;YBC]^DF[�8qp9� 8'sk� < p�� <$s ?A_F; �Jf� ���� =>E�DFH�]\H�?CH EGI�MDFE�TF;YH o &F[�@FBC;3�Nu�WXDFT D2EG? �SDFE!T2;YHUWGH�IKE�B�?A_2; EGBCTF;>BC]\D2[D8qpw�[< pw�`8'sX��<�s o &q[�@FB�; ¡Nuin

£�

��� ���

� � � � � � � �

� �� �

� �

"w]\[G@FBC; �2z<�J_2; �Jf� ���� IKE�B o 8qp�_ < p�u�L o 8'sd_ <�s u ��]^?C_ VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;+E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[�8qpw� 8's ��< pd��<$stn

�|�����,<=$4!F� 2q��� * _FE � _FE � ?AE�; �!rFBC;>HCH�WGZ\Z|E�rk;YBAW-?AE�B�HhIKBCE�` ?A_F;S]�I v�?C_F;YD!v�;YZ^HC;¤E�rk;YBCWX?AEGB�WGDFT ?A_2;=YE�D2H�?�WXD�?CH£yWGD2T lGn�|�����,<=$4!F� 2q� ' �hBAW�� ?C_F; ��f� ����hHIKE�B o 8qp{_ <�p�u;L o 8's+_ <$s u;L o 8'v+_ <$v u���]^?C_ E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[GH8qpw� 8's �[8'vT��< p �[<$sT�[<$vUWGDFTz8qpw��<�pd�[8'sT��<$sT� 8'v �[<�vtn

Page 16: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n lmQ

�|�����,<=$4!F� 2q� 2 �hBAW�� ?A_F;:�Jf� ����hHhIKEGB o 8qpT_ <�p�utP o 8's_ <$s�uE��]^?A_#E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[GH-8qpA� 8's��<�pd��<�s�WXDFT 8qp ��< pw�`8'sX�[<�stn��E�� TFE�;YHc]^?c=>E�`yrFWGBC;���]�?A_S?A_F;�; �FWX`yrFZ^;J]\D &q[�@2BC;YH ¡ WGDFT � � �WGH�;YTSE�D ?C_F;�; �FWX`yrFZ^;YH|��E�@S_qWtVG;JHC;Y;>D�HCEhI4WGB>e���_qWX?wVGWXBC] WXjFZ\;cE�B�TF;YB�]\DF[ ��E�@FZ^T ��EG@SBC;Y=>E�`a`y;>DFTIKE�Bc=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?C]\DF[¤W�HC`yWGZ^Z �Jf� �����IKE�B o 8qp�_ < p�u�L o 8's{_ <�s u�L o 8'v{_ <�v u�L �����0L o 8 � _ < � u)��|�����,<=$4!F� 2q� A � ]�V�;�WGD�;��2WG`arFZ\;UEGI|W H�;u��@F;YD2=Y; EGI �Jf� ����hH�B~�:�£�� � ��_F]^=�_�]\DFTF@2=Y;YH�;��!r�E-vDF;YDN?C] WGZ^Z^��jF]^[�[�;YB TF;>=Y]\H�]\E�Dy?ABC;>;YH>n ��n ;Gn�eF]�I B~ _qWXH�HC]��Y;�� o �suc?C_F;YD1?C_F;hTF;>=Y]\H�]\E�Dy?ABC;>;hHC_2E�@FZ\T�_FWmVG;HC]��Y;�� o O ~ uin�|�����,<=$4!F� 2q� T ��E�DFH�?ABC@2=>?�WGD �Jf� ���� EXIw`yW��!]\`¤@2` H�]��Y;�EmV�;>B�HC] �1VGWXBC] WXjFZ\;>HYn

� � 0 .�= <��� <���.19 �.�7 � �. �7���46��<���.19 �� � � � =

�xD�?A_2;1rFBC;iV�]\E�@FH HC;Y=i?A]^E�D ��;1HAW�� _FE � ?AE =>E�DFH�?CBC@F=i?aWGD f� ���� IKB�E�` W  �E�E�Z\;YWGD�; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�DjN��WaH�]\`arFZ\;�BC;Y=>@FBCH�]^VG;�rFB�E!=>;YTF@2BC;Gn �J_F; ��@F;YH�?A]\EGD6WGB�]\H�;YH�DFE � _FE ��T2E:��; =YE�DFH�?AB�@F=>?�Wz�)&0N$�BG)&0Nf� ���� ��fhDF; ��Wm� ]^Hh?AE &qBCH�? =>E�DFH�?CBC@F=i?¤WXD%f� ���� WGDFT ?A_F;>D�rFB�E!=>;Y;YT jN�#BC;YT2@F=Y]^DF[ ]�?tn�R�D�vEG?A_2;YBa`yE�B�;(WGrFrk;tWGZ^]\DF[ WGrFr2BCENWG=�_ e ��_F]\=�_ ��;(IKE�Z\Z^E � _F;>BC;XeJ]\HS?AE BC;YT2@F=Y;(?A_F;6f� ���� TF@2BC]\D2[=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?C]\E�D n��ETF;YH�=YB�]\jk; _2E���?A_F]^H|]^H<TFE�DF; ��; ��]^Z\ZGD2;Y;YT WGD ;��!rFZ\]^=Y]�?�BC;Yr2BC;YH�;YDN?�W-?A]\EGD�EGI �Jf� ����hHYn CE!TF;>H

��]\Z^ZGjk;�B�;YrFB�;YHC;>DN?A;YT¤WGH�D�@F` j�;>BCH�£�:tl�: O�:?>?>?>���]^?A_�£�WGDFTyl�B�;YHC;>B�VG;YT IKE�B<?C_F;�?A;YB�`y]^DqWGZ�D2E!TF;>HYn��J_F;VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>HU]^D6?A_2; E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[�8qp-�\8's�� �����q� 8B~1WGBC;�BC;>rFBC;>HC;YDN?C;YT j�� ?A_F;>]\BU]\DFTF]^=Y;>H l�: O�:?>?>?>J:a�wn�J_F;1��f� ���� ]\HaH�?CE�BC;>T ]\D W ?�WXjFZ\;�� z ��� o �l:��^:��gu:��_F]^=�_ `�WXrFH�W DFE�TF; ?CE�]^?CHa?C_FBC;>;WX?C?CBC]^jF@2?A;>H�"!$� o �u{g �CeQ#/, � o �u�g��xegWGDFT ��3@R"� o �u{g��<n+"w]^[�@FBC; dSHC_2E���H�?A_2;�B�;YrFB�;YHC;>DN?�WX?C]\E�D(EGI?A_F;3�Jf� ���� IKB�E�` &q[G@FBC; ¡ o ��]^?C_�?A_F;�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;hDqWG`a;YHJ=�_qWXDF[�;YT(?AE�8qp+�`8'sX�`8'vX� 8By>u n

����� � �xD�E�BCTF;>BJ?AE�;YDFH�@FBC; ?A_qW-?J?A_F;�f� �����j�;>]\DF[�=>E�DFH�?CBC@F=i?A;>T ]\HJB�;YTF@F=>;YTseg]�?J]\H�DF;>=Y;YH�HAWGB���?AE�TF;>?C;YB v`y]^DF;UIKB�E�` W ?ABC]^rFZ\; o �l:��^:��gu+��_F;>?C_F;YBJ?A_2;YBC;�; �!]\H�?CH�W¤DFE�TF;� ��]�?A_ �"!$� o �u�g �l:?#/, � o �u�g��xeqWXDFT��3@R"� o �u�g��sn�"qE�Bw?C_F]\H+r2@FBCrkE�HC; ��;WGHCH�@F`y;�?C_F;JrFB�;YHC;>DF=Y;EGI W�?�WGj2Z\;"! z o �l:��^:��gu�� y`�WGr2rF]\DF[?AB�]\rFZ^;YH o �0:��^:��guwEGIkVXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;�]\D2TF]\=>;YH���e!WXDFT�DFE!T2;YH�^:���?CE�DFE!T2;YH �nw�J_F;J?AWGjFZ\;#! ]\H+?A_2;%$�]\DNV�;>BCH�;'&EGI ?C_F;U?AWGjFZ^;(� e�] n ;Gn�eNIKE�B VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;JDFE�TF;YH��e)� o u�g o �l:��^:��guie�]^I<WXDFT�E�D2Z^��]^I e*! o �0:��^:��gu�g |nw�J_F;E�rk;YBAW-?A]\EGDFH�DF;>;YTF;>T6E�D�?A_F;�? ��Ea?AWGjFZ^;YHWGBC;Xz

��z ��� o �l:��^:��gu3V1B3V� o ��u ]\DF]�?A]\WGZ\]��Y;(� ?AE�=>E�DN?�WG]^D(EGDFZ^�1£aWXDFT l,+ !6N6N o ��: �0:-�b:��ku WGZ\Z^E!=YWX?A;�WaD2;$� D2E!TF; ��]^?A_(WX?�?AB�]\jF@2?C;YH o �0:��^:��gu�"!$� o u�:?#/, � o �u�:E��3@R"� o �u Z\E�E���@Fr�?A_F; WX?�?AB�]\jF@2?C;YHJEGI 6]^D.�

! z o �0:��^:��gu� � 3V1B3V� o ! u ]\DF]�?A]\WGZ\]��Y;/! ?CE�j�;�;Y`ar2?x��#+ U�&JU 5J&J� o !�: �l:��^:��gu =�_F;Y=���]�I o �0:��^:��gu�]\HJ]^D0!,+ #/,.,21"�.W o !r: �0:-�b:��ku &qDFT3! o �l:��^:��gu3V1�(.&J��� o !r: �0:��^:��q: �u `�WX�G; o �l:��^:��gu�`�WGr�?CE� ]\D0!

Page 17: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n l��

2 3

4

5 6

7

8By 8By

8's

8'v

8qp

£ l

8's

� z .�� o �l:��^:��gu �"!$� #/, � ��3@R"�£ Ql QO L l £¡ L £ lL ¡ O ¡Q O L £� O £ Ld l Q �

"w]\[G@FBC;�d�z ��;Yr2BC;YH�;YDN?A]^DF[ WGD ��f� ���� ��]�?A_ E�BCT2;YBC]^DF[ 8qpr� 8's�� 8'v � 8By9n �J_2; D�@F`¤jk;YB�H]\DFH�]\TF;a?A_F;1VG;YB�?A]\=>;YH�WGB�;�?A_2;�]\TF;>D�?C]^?C]\;YH�@FHC;>T ]\D%?A_2;1BC;>rFBC;>HC;YDN?AWX?A]^E�Dsn �J_F;�D�@F`¤jk;YBCH�£ WXDFT lWGBC;�B�;YHC;>B�VG;YT6IKE�BJ?C_F; ?C;YB�`y]^DqWGZ D2E!TF;>HYn��J_F;�D�@F` j�;>BCHU?CES?A_F; BC]^[�_N?�EGIw?C_F; ��f� ���� H�_FE ��HU?A_2;]\DFT2;�� EGI+?C_F;�VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH�]\D(?A_F; E�BCTF;>BC]^DF[Fn��J_F;¤=>E�DFH�?AWGDN?AH�WXBC;�WGHCH�]\[�DF;>T WGD ]^DFTF; � ��_2]\=�_ ]^HU?A_2;D�@F`¤jk;YBwEXIFVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�]^D�?C_F;�E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[�rFZ\@FH|E�DF; o _F;>BC;�L ��lTg Q�uin��J_F]\H�`�WX�G;YH�HCE�`a;�H�@FjFH�;u��@F;YDN?WGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F`aH�;YWGHC]^;YB�?CEar2BC;YH�;YDN?tn �J_F; Z\E ��v WGD2T(_2]\[�_!v &q;YZ^TFH�WGB�;�@FD�@FHC;>T IKE�B�?C_F;h?A;>BC`a]\DqWGZ�DFE�TF;YH>n

UWV+� ��:-! � o �0:��^:��gul�z $%} �Qg�� E8xD�"��� �=E G5� � �O!z �"��!u� $%} U�&JU 5J&J� o !�: �0:��^:��gu E x5�"�¡2z � �=E G5�,� #/,.,21"��W o !�: �l:��^:��guLFz �"��!u� ,+ !6N6N o ��: �0:-�b:��kuQ!z 3V1�(.&J��� o !r: �0:��^:��q: �u�2z � �=E G5�,�

"w]^[�@FBC;�P!z��J_F; IK@2DF=>?C]\E�D)pqV+� ��:�! � o �0:��^:��guin

Page 18: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n lmd

X Y5[]\"^ � ��:�! � o f ul�z } GD�D<HE $���� � Y5[]\"^�� o f : ��uTgO!z $%} ����� E x5�v�¡2z $%} f ]^H�I4WGZ\H�; E x5�v�0� �=E G5�,� £ �"��!u��� �=E G5�,� lLFz �"��!u� � � + � Y5[]\�^�� o f � £6��8 % �K: �!��l9uQ!z �6p + � YD[]\�^�� o f � l.�"8 % ��: �!��l9u�2z � �=E G5�,� pqV o �0: � � : �6p�ud!z �"�DJ � Y5[]\�^ �P2zM2z � �=E G5� � � Y5[]\�^ � o f :tlmu"w]^[�@FB�;6M2z6R�Z\[GE�BC]�?A_F` IKEGByjF@2]\Z\T2]\DF[ WGD ��f� ���� IKBCE�` W� �E!EGZ\;tWXD�; �2r2BC;YH�HC]^E�D f@FH�]\DF[�?C_F;SE�BCT2;YBC]^DF[k8qpA� 8's9� �����;� 8B~2n �xD W1=tWXZ\Z � Y5[]\"^�� o f : ��uie �J]\H�?C_F;�Z\E ��;YH�?]^DFTF;��6?A_qW-? WGDN�6VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^; EGI f =tWGD#_qWtVG;Gn¤�J_�@FH8��_F;>D ?C_F;¤?A;>H�? ��� � H�@F=Y=>;Y;>TFHYe f=>E�DN?�WG]^DFH�DFEaVXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YH�WGDFT�`¤@FH�?Ujk;�;Y]�?A_F;>BJ=YE�DFH�?�WGDN?CZ^�1I4WGZ^HC;�E�BJ?CBC@F;Xn

��;�H�_qWGZ^ZNWGHCH�@F`a;c?C_qWX?|WGZ^ZG?A_2;YHC;cE�rk;YBCWX?A]^E�DFH<=YWGD�jk;�rk;YB�IKEGBC`a;YT�]\DkG),"1�(J�K!$1B�=�43VU�&ie�� o lmuin * ;Y=i?A]^E�DQ ��]\Z\Z�HC_FE ��_2E�� HC@F=�_6WSZ\E � =>E�`arFZ\; �2]�?x�1=YWGD jk; WG=�_F]^;>V�;>Tsn�J_F; IK@FDF=>?C]\E�D pqV � ��:�! � o �0:��^:��gu o H�;Y;�&q[�@2BC; PNu�HC;YWGBC=�_2;YH ?C_F; ?�WXjFZ\; ! IKE�B�W DFE�TF;1��]^?C_

VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\; ]\DFTF; � �WGDFT#Z\E ��vAe|_2]\[�_!v�jFBAWXDF=�_F;YH��^:���WXDFT B�;>?C@FBCDFH W�`�W-?A=�_F]^DF[�DFE!T2;S]^I�E�DF;�;��!]\H�?AH>nf�?A_F;>B ��]\H�;¤]^?�=YB�;tWX?C;YH�W1DF;�� DFE�TF; �es]^DFHC;>B�?CHh]^?�]\DN?AE�! WXDFT BC;i?A@FB�DFHh?A_F;S]^TF;YDN?C]^?x� EGIc]^?Yn��J_F;BC@FD2DF]\DF[¤?C]\`a;�EGI�pqV�]\H�� o lmu TF@F;h?CE¤?A_F;�WXHCHC@2`yr2?C]\E�D2H�E�D�?A_F;�jFWGHC]^=hE�rk;YBAW-?A]\EGDFH�E�D.� WGDFT�!�n�J_F; f� ���� ]\H�;YDFH�@FBC;>T(?CESj�;hB�;YTF@2=Y;YT(]^I�D2E!TF;>H�WGBC;�E�DFZ^�y=YB�;tWX?C;YT�?A_2BCE�@F[G_1?A_F;�@FH�;�EGI~p|V nc�xDTF;YH�=YB�]\jF]^DF[SpqV�WGD2T1HC@Fj2HC;u��@F;>DN?hWGZ^[�E�B�]^?A_2`yH>e���;h`yWG�X;h@FHC;�EGI<?A_F;�DFEG?�W-?A]\EGD�� ��:�! �k?AE¤]^DFTF]\=YWX?A;?A_qW-?~pqV#TF;Yrk;YDFT2HJE�D�?A_2;h[�Z\EGjqWGZgTqWX?AW H�?CBC@F=i?A@FB�;YH#� WGDFT.! e!jF@!?���;�Z\;tWtVG;hE�@2?�?A_F;�WXBC[�@F`a;YDN?CH��_F;YD(]\DNVGE���]\DF[�]^?WXHrFWGB�?�EGI�EG?C_F;YBWGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F`aHYn

����� � �����

�J_F;�=YEGDFH�?CBC@F=i?A]\EGD�EGIUWGD �Jf� ���� IKB�E�` W [�]�V�;>D� �E!E�Z^;tWGD ; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�D f rFB�E!=>;Y;>TFHaWGHS]\D ?A_2;=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?C]\E�D EGIgWXD�]�I v�?A_2;YD!v�;YZ\H�;cDFE�BC`yWGZ�IKE�B�` o � CE"�u<]\D HC;Y=i?A]^E�DSO!n|R�D�E�BCT2;YBC]^DF[EGI2?C_F; VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YH8qpw� ������� 8B~U]\H &'�!;YTsn+�UHC]^DF[U?C_F; * _qWGDFDFEGD¤;��!rqWGD2HC]\EGD f g�8qp � f � l���8qp �K: f � £6�"8qp �/e�WDFE�TF;�IKE�B f]\H<=>E�DFH�?CBC@F=i?A;>T¤jN� W�=tWXZ\ZG?CEqpqVce�WXI ?C;YB<?A_2;�DFE�TF;>H|IKE�B f � £6�"8qp ��WGD2T f � l��"8qp ��_qWtV�; jk;Y;YD�=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?C;YTjN� BC;Y=>@FBCH�]\E�D n �J_F; WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` ]\H�HC_FE ��D ]^D &F[�@FBC; M2n��J_F; =YWGZ\Z � Y5[]\"^�� o f : ��u�=>E�DFH�?CBC@F=i?AH�WGD�Jf� �����IKEGB�W� �E!EGZ\;tWXDy; �2r2BC;YH�HC]^E�D f ��]^?C_yVXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YHc]\Dr�.8 % :08 % �=pJ:7>?>?>7:l8B~ ��n+��?�TFE�;YH�HCE¤jN� &qBCH�?BC;>=Y@FB�HC]^VG;YZ�� =YEGDFH�?CBC@F=i?A]\D2[ �Jf� ����hH�� � WXDFT � pIKE�B f � £��"8 % ��WXDFT f � l.�"8 % �+]^D Z\]^DF;YH�L�WGDFT Q!e<WXDFT?A_F;>Dyr2BCE�=Y;Y;>TF]\D2[ ?CE3&qD2Ta?C_F;�]\TF;>D�?C]^?x�SEXI ?A_2;D2E!TF;JIKE�B f ]\D�Z\]^DF; �2n�CEG?A]^=Y;J?A_FWX?c]^I � � WGDFT�� p+WGB�;]\TF;>DN?A]\=YWGZ e�E�B ]^I ?A_F;>BC;�WGZ^BC;YWGT2�a]\H�W DFE�TF;E��]�?A_�?C_F;�HCWG`a; �Ce � � WXDFT��6pie!DFE DF;$��DFE�TF;�]^H�=>BC;tW-?A;YT nR�DS;��2WG`arFZ^;�EGIg@FH�]\DF[ � Y5[]\�^�?CE�=YE�`arF@2?C;JWGD:�Jf� ���� ]^HwH�_FE ��Da]^D &q[�@2BC;�lm£2n��J_F;�B�@FDFDF]^DF[?A]^`y;hEXI � Y5[]\�^�]\HJjFWGTsnc��?�]\HJ;YWGH���?CEaH�;Y;�?A_FWX?JIKE�B�W¤VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;�E�BCTF;>BC]^DF[ ��]^?A_u� VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH�?C_F;YB�;��]\Z^ZsWGZ ��Wt��H�j�;�[�;>DF;YBCWX?A;>T E�D�?A_2; EGBCTF;>BJEGI�O ~ =tWGZ^Z\Hhn

Page 19: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n ltP

����������� ������ �

����� ����� ������������� � ���� �

��� � ����� � ���� �

��� � � � !��� � �#"$��� � �%�& ��� � �'"$

��� � �%�� � �(�*)� ��� � � � � �(�*)���� � �%�&+� � �#)� ��� � � � !� � �*)�

������� � ��� � �#"&

���,�-� � � �(�*)�

���,�-�%�&!��� � �#"$

���,���%�� � � �*)����,�-�%�&!� �.�*)�

���,�/� � � � �*)�

0 1

2

3

4

5

3

6

�� � �

� � � ���

0 1 2�

3 4 5

� �

� �

� �

��

� �

��

� �

�� ���

� �

��

� �

"w]\[G@FBC;�lm£2z��HC]\D2[ � Y5[]\�^ E�D1?C_F;�;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D o 8qp�_ 8'siu=P�8'vmn o WNu��J_F;h?CBC;Y;�EGI|=tWGZ^Z\H�?CE � Y5[]\�^cno jgu��J_F;��Jf� ���� W-I ?A;YB|?A_F;�=tWGZ^Z � YD[]\�^�� o�o £ _ £�u"P�8'v.:�¡Nuin o =tu�RUI ?C;YB|?A_F;�=YWGZ\Z � Y5[]\�^�� o�o £ _ l9u�P8'v?:�¡Nu n o Tgu RUI ?C;YB<?A_2;�=tWGZ^Z � Y5[]\�^ � oCo £A_ 8'siuaP�8'v�: O�uin o ;musRUI ?C;YBs?A_2; =YWGZ\Z^H � Y5[]\�^�� o�o lT_ £Nu0P�8'v�:�¡NuWGDFT � Y5[]\�^ � oCo l�_ l9u�P�8'v.:�¡Nu n o I�uhRI ?A;YB�?A_2;y=YWGZ\Z � Y5[]\"^�� oCo l _ 8'siu�P 8'v.:�O�uin o [�u��J_F; &qDqWGZBC;>HC@FZ�?tn

Page 20: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n ltM

��� � ����� ���

_S`*`*\ba � ��:�! � o�� : Qpa: 's ul�z 3V1B3V� o�� uO!z¡2z } GD��<HE $%��� kD`*` o qp�: 's u�gLFz $%} ��o Qp): 's�u��g &JUXWY�4m E x5�v�0� �=E G5�,� ��o qp�: 's uQ!z �"��!u�R$%} Qp �j�-£�:Yl$� ����J 's �j�-£�:tl�� E x5�"� ��+ ��|o Qp): 's�u�2z �"��!u�R$%} �"!$� o qp�u�g��"!$� o 's�u E x5�"�d!z ��+ pqV o �"!$� o qp�uJ: k�`*` o #/, � o qp�uJ:7#/, � o 's u�uJ: kD`*` o ��3@R"� o qp�u�:E��3@R"� o 's uCu�uP �"��!u�R$%} �"!$� o qp�u � �"!$� o 's�u E x5�"�M ��+ pqV o �"!$� o qp�uJ: k�`*` o #/, � o qp�uJ: YsAuJ: kD`*` o ��3@R"� o qp�u�: 's�u�ulm£!z �"��!u� o� �"!$� o qp�u � �"!$� o 's u ul�lGz ��+ pqV o �"!$� o 's uJ: k�`*` o Qp):?#/, � o 's u�uJ: kD`*` o qp�:J��3@R"� o YsAuCu�ul9O�z �yo qp�: 'sAu + �lm¡!z � �=E G5� � �ltL2z �"��J kD`*`l9Q�zl �!z � ��E8GD�,� kD`*` o qp�: 's u

"w]\[�@2BC;Sl�l�z��J_2;�WXZ\[�E�B�]^?C_F` kD`*`*\ba � ��:-! � o�� : qp): 's�u n

R�Z\Z<?C_F;¤jF]^DqWGB��  �E�E�Z^;tWGD E�r�;>BAWX?CE�BCHUE�D��Jf� ����hH�WGBC;�]\`arFZ\;>`y;>DN?A;YT jN� ?C_F;¤HAWX`y;�[�;YDF;>BAWGZWGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F` kD`*`*\ba o��� : qp�: 's�u�?C_qWX?�IKE�B+? ��E��Jf� ����hH+=YEG`yrF@!?A;YH�?C_F;��Jf� ���� IKE�B+?A_2;� �E!EGZ\;tWXD;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D f � � � f ��� nc�J_F;�=>E�DFH�?ABC@2=>?A]^E�D�EGIk�`*`*\ba ]\H�jFWGHC;>T E�D�?C_F; * _qWGD2DFE�D�;��!rqWGD2HC]\EGD o O�uiz

f g 8�� f � l��"8 �n: f � £6��8 ��>fhjFHC;>B�V�;�?A_FWX?JIKE�B�WGZ^Z< �E�E�Z\;YWGD�E�rk;YBAW-?AE�B�H�,)Wy?A_2;�IKEGZ\Z\E ��]^DF[¤_FE�Z^TFHYz

o 8�� f pJ: f s u ���o 8�� f � p : f � s u[g 8�� f p �� f � p : f s � f � s o LNu��I'��;�H�?�WGB�?�IKBCE�` ?C_F; BCE�EG?�EGI2?C_F;c? ��E �Jf� ����hH ��;�=tWGD =YEGDFH�?CBC@F=i?w?A_2;+��f� ���� EGI!?A_F; BC;>HC@FZ�?|j��BC;>=Y@FB�HC]^VG;YZ��y=>E�DFH�?ABC@2=>?A]^DF[ ?C_F;�Z^E���v+WGDFTy?A_F;U_F]\[�_�vxjFBCWGDF=�_F;>H�WGDFTy?A_F;>D�IKE�BC` ?C_F;�DF;�� BCE�EG? IKBCE�`?A_F;>HC;Xn�RU[NWG]\D e�?AE�;>DFHC@2BC;S?A_qW-?h?A_F;SB�;YH�@FZ^?�]^HhBC;>TF@F=>;YTse ��;�=YBC;YWX?A;¤?C_F;¤DFE�TF;¤?C_FBCE�@2[�_#W1=tWGZ^Z|?CEpqV n p E�B�;YEmV�;>BYeg?AEaWtV�E�]^T6WXD ; �2rkE�DF;>DN?A] WXZ|j2Z\E ��vx@Fr�EGIwBC;>=Y@FB�HC]^VG;�=YWGZ\Z^HYe;N$m"1Y!$U�3KG+WY�a,0R$�l!$U�U�3V1�R]\HJ@FH�;YTsnc�J_F;�WGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F` ]^HJHC_FE ��D6]^D/&q[�@FB�;alGl�n���!DFWG`y]^=hrFB�E�[�BAWX`y`a]\DF[ ]\HJ]\`arFZ^;Y`a;YDN?A;>T�@FHC]^DF[aW�?AWGjFZ\;�EGI+B�;YHC@2Z^?AH � ncbcWG=�_ ;>DN?AB�� o �0:���u�]\H

;Y]�?A_F;>B�&JUXWY��m E�Bh=YEGD�?AWG]\D2Hh?A_F;S;YWGBCZ^]\;YBU=YE�`arF@2?C;YT#BC;>HC@FZ�?�EGI kD`�` o �0:���uin �J_F;aWGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F` TF]^H�?C]\D!v[�@F]^HC_F;>H jk;>? ��;Y;>D�IKE�@FB�T2]! �;YBC;>DN?�=YWGHC;>HYe|?A_F; &qB�H�? EGI ?A_F;>` _qWGDFTFZ^;YH�?A_2;aH�]^?C@qWX?A]^E�D1��_F;>BC;aj�EG?C_WGBC[G@F`y;>DN?AH�WGB�;¤?A;YB�`y]^DqWGZ|DFE�TF;YH>e�?C_F;SBC;>`�WX]\DF]^DF[�?A_2BC;Y;�_qWXDFTFZ\;�?A_F;�HC]�?A@qW-?A]\EGDFH ��_F;>BC;aWX?�Z^;tWGH�?E�DF;�WGB�[�@F`a;YDN?]\H�W¤VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;hDFE�TF;Gn��I+jkEG?A_ qpJWGD2T 's�WXBC;�?A;>BC`a]\DqWGZ/eFW�DF;$� �^&J��U�3V1Y!$#Q1I,7N�& ]\HJ=>E�`yr2@2?A;>T6_qWtV�]\DF[�?A_2; VXWGZ^@F;�EGI

,)W�WGr2rFZ\]^;YTS?AE�?A_F;�? ��E�?AB�@2?A_aVXWGZ\@F;>HYn o �;>=tWGZ^Z eG?C_qWX? ?A;>BC`a]\DqWGZ2DFE!T2;U£�]\HcB�;YrFB�;YHC;>DN?A;YT�jN�yW�DFE!T2;��]^?C_(]^TF;YDN?C]^?x��£�WGD2T H�]\`a]\Z WXBCZ^�SIKEGB�l�n u

Page 21: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n OX£

��IWX?¤Z^;tWGH�?SE�DF;yEGI qp�WGDFT 's�WGB�;�DFE�D�v�?A;>BC`a]\DqWXZ e ��;�rFB�E!=>;Y;>T WG=Y=>E�BCTF]^DF[6?CE6?A_F;yVGWXBC] WXjFZ\;]\DFT2;���n ��I�?A_F; DFE�TF;YH(_qWtV�;#?A_F; HAWX`y;#]\D2TF;���eh?A_2; ? ��E Z^E���v�jFBAWXDF=�_F;YH WGB�; rqWX]\BC;>T�WGDFT kD`*`BC;>=Y@FB�HC]^VG;YZ��y=>E�`arF@2?A;>T�E�Da?A_F;>` n * ]\`a]\Z\WGBCZ�� IKEGB ?C_F;U_2]\[�_!v�jFBAWXDF=�_F;YH>n��J_F]\H =YEGBCBC;>HCrkE�DFTFH�;��2WG=>?CZ^�?AE�?C_F;J=tWXHC;JHC_2E���Da]\D ;u��@qWX?C]\E�D o L�uin���Ik?C_F;>� _qWtV�;�TF] ;>BC;YDN?�]^DFTF]^=Y;YH>e ��;JrFBCE�=Y;>;YT�jN�¤rqWG]^BC]^DF[�?A_2;DFE�TF; ��]^?C_ Z\E ��;YH�? ]^DFTF;�� ��]^?C_ ?A_F;SZ^E ��vWGDFT#_F]^[�_!vxj2BAWGDF=�_2;YH�EGIc?A_2;SEG?A_F;>BYn �J_F]\H�=>E�BCB�;YH�r�E�D2TFH?AES?A_2; ;F��@qWX?A]^E�D

o 8 % � f p�: f siuA,)W f g 8 % � f pA,)W f : f sD,)W f o QGu��_F]\=�_ _2E�Z\TFH IKE�B¤WXZ\Z f n * ]\D2=Y; ��;�_qWtV�;1?AWG�G;>D%?A_F;1]^DFTF; �%EGIJ?C_F;1?A;>BC`a]\DqWXZ\H�?AE jk;1E�D2;1Z WGB�[�;YB?A_qWXD�?A_F;�]\DFTF; �1EXI|?C_F;hDFEGD!v�?C;YBC`a]\DFWGZ\H>e�?C_F;hZ\WGH�?�? ��ES=YWGHC;>HYeQ�"!$� o qp�uw� �"!$� o 's u WGDFT �"!$� o qp�u ��"!$� o 's uie!?�WG�X; WG=>=YE�@2D�?EGI|?A_2; H�]^?C@qWX?A]^E�DFH���_F;>BC; E�DF;�EGI�?A_F;�DFE�TF;>H]^H�W¤?A;YB�`y]^DqWGZ/n

"w]\[�@2BC;�l9O�HC_FE ��HJWGDy;��2WG`arFZ\;�EGI<WGrFrFZ��!]^DF[�?A_F;�WGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F` E�Da? ��E¤H�`�WGZ^Z �Jf� ����hHYn�CUEG?C]\=>;_FE � rqWX]\BCHJEXIwDFE�TF;>H�IKB�E�` ?C_F;�? ��E �Jf� ����hH�WGB�;�=YE�`¤j2]\DF;>T6WGD2T(=>E�`arF@2?A;>Tsn��E�WXDqWGZ^� �>;�?A_2;¤=YE�`arFZ^;��!]^?x��EGI�kD`*`*\ba ��;¤Z\;i?�i �i!TF;>DFEG?A;�?A_F;�D�@2`¤j�;>BhEGI�D2E!TF;>H�?A_FWX?h=YWGD

j�;�BC;tWX=�_F;YT IKBCEG` ]^D�?A_F; ��f� ����¤n�RUHCHC@2`y;�?C_qWX? � =tWXD j�;1]^`yr2Z\;Y`a;YDN?C;YT ��]�?A_%=>E�DFH�?AWGDN?Z\E�E���@Fr%WXDFT%]\D2HC;YB�?A]^E�D ?C]\`a;YHYn o * ;Y;1H�;Y=i?A]\EGD Q�IKE�B�TF;>?AWG]\Z^H�EGD�_FE � ?AE6WG=�_F]\;iV�;�?C_F]\H>n u��h@F;y?CE?A_F;T2��DqWG`a]\=�rFB�E�[�BCWG`y`a]\D2[�WX?�`aE�H�?�i Qp7i.i 's�iX=tWXZ\Z\H�?CEC_S`*`*\ba%WXBC;[�;YDF;>BAWX?C;YTsncbcWG=�_�=tWGZ^Zg?AWG�G;>H=YE�D2H�?�WXD�?�?C]\`a;Gn+�J_F;�?AEX?�WGZsB�@FDFDF]^DF[S?A]^`y;h]^H�?A_F;>BC;iIKE�BC; � o i qp?i.i 's�i u n

��� � ��������� � �

�J_F; DF;���?UE�r�;>BAWX?C]\E�D ��;�=>E�DFHC]^TF;YB]\HJ?C_F;��a&)(J�4��3KGJ��3K,"1#EGI+W@�Jf� ���� �n��J_qW-?�]^HYeq[�]�V�;YD6W�?CBC@2?C_WGHCH�]\[�D2`y;>D�?Ye�IKEGB�;��2WG`arFZ^; � £6�"8'v?:tl.�"8��.:tl��"8� � eB��; ��WGDN?�?CE¤=YE�`arF@2?C;�?A_2;8�Jf� ���� IKE�B f � @FDFTF;>B?A_F]^HcBC;YH�?AB�]\=>?C]\E�D eN] n ;Gn�eB&qD2Ty?A_2; �Jf� ���� IKE�B f � � £��"8'v?:tl���8��?:tl��"8� � n�RUH�WGDa;��2WG`arFZ^;U=>E�DFHC]^TF;YBc?A_2;�Jf� ���� EGI &F[�@FBC;alm£ o [�u o B�;Yrk;tWX?C;YT j�;>Z\E � ?CEa?C_F;�Z^;>I ?�u�BC;Yr2BC;YH�;YDN?A]^DF[y?C_F;� �E!EGZ\;tWXD(; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�Do 8qpu_ 8'siuwP 8'vmn �;>H�?AB�]\=i?A]\D2[�]^?@��]^?C_ BC;>HCrk;Y=>?�?AE�?C_F;6?AB�@2?A_ WXHCHC]^[�DF`a;YDN??� £6�"8's ���]\;>Z\TFH�WGD�Jf� ���� IKEGB o S 8qp�P28'viu n ��?�]\H�=YE�DFH�?AB�@F=>?C;YT jN��B�;YrFZ\WG=Y]^DF[(;tWG=�_ E�=Y=>@FBCB�;YDF=>;1EGI�W6D2E!TF;:��]^?C_Z WGjk;YZY8's�jN��]�?AHJZ\;iI ?�jFBAWXDF=�_(��]^;YZ\T2]\DF[¤?C_F;3�Jf� ���� W-?J?A_F;�BC]^[�_N?tz

01

x1

x2 x2

x3

01

x1

x3

�J_F;�WGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F` WX[NWG]\D6@FHC;>HCp|V�?AE�;YD2HC@FB�;�?C_qWX?�?C_F;SBC;>HC@FZ�?A]\D2[�f� ���� ]\HhB�;YTF@2=Y;YT n "w]\[G@FBC;1lt¡HC_FE ��H+?C_F;JWGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F` ]\D ?C_F;J=tWGH�; ��_F;>BC;JE�DFZ�� HC]\D2[�Z\;i?AE�D ?CBC@2?C_�WGHCH�]\[�D2`y;>D�?CH o � �J�"8 # � e����j�-£�:tl$�XuWGBC;#WXZ\Z\E ��;YTsn �xDN?A@F]�?A]^VG;YZ���e�]^D =YE�`arF@2?C]\DF[�g�d*e8f�g�[]hif o ;:���: �iu@��;#HC;tWXBC=�_ IKEGB�WGZ\Z�DFE!T2;YH%��]^?C_�"!$� g � WXDFT BC;>rFZ WG=>;y?C_F;Y` j�� ?A_F;>]\B�Z\E ��v�E�B�_F]\[G_!vxH�E�D%TF;>r�;>DFTF]\D2[ E�D��mn * ]\DF=>;�?A_2]\H `a]\[G_�?IKE�BC=>;�DFE!T2;YHWGjkE9VG; ?C_F; r�E�]^DN?�EGIwB�;YrFZ\WG=Y;>`y;>D(?CEyjk;Y=>E�`a; ;F��@qWGZ eq]�?�]\H�IKE�Z^Z\E ��;YT�jN�(WaB�;YTF@F=i?A]^E�Do ?C_FBCE�@2[�_(?C_F; =YWGZ\Z^H�?AERpqVwu n��h@F; ?CEy?C_F; ? ��E1B�;Y=Y@2BCHC]�V�;�=tWGZ^Z\H�]\D(Z\]^DF; ¡2eq?A_F;�WGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F` _qWGHUWGD;��!rkE�DF;YDN?C] WGZsB�@FDFDF]^DF[¤?A]^`y;Xe2H�;Y;�;��!;YB�=Y]^HC; LFn d�IKEGBJWGD�]\`arFBCEmVG;Y`a;YDN?J?A_qW-?�BC;YT2@F=Y;>H�?C_F]\H�?CE�Z\]\D2;tWGB?A]^`y;Xn

Page 22: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n O�l

� �� �

���

���

��� �

�� � � � �

� �� �

� �

� �

���

�� �� �� ��

��

�� ��

��

����� � ���

� ���

� � �

� � �

��� �

� � �

� � �

� ���

� � �

� � �

� � �

� ��� ��

� � �

� ���

�����

� � �

��� � �� � ���

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

! "

"w]\[G@FBC;al9O!zJRUD ;��2WG`arFZ\; EGI WGrFr2Z^��]\DF[a?A_F;¤WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` kD`*`*\ba IKE�B�=>E�`yr2@2?A]^DF[y?C_F; =>E�D���@FDF=i?A]^E�DEGI�?A_2; ? ��E ��f� ����hHhHC_FE ��D WX?U?A_F; ?CE�r Z\;iI ?tnh�J_2;¤BC;>HC@FZ�?�]\HUHC_FE ��D ?AE1?C_F;¤BC]^[�_N?tn� �;YZ\E � ?A_2;?AB�;Y; EGIcWGB�[�@F`a;YDN?AH�?AEa?A_F;�BC;Y=>@FBCH�]^VG; =tWXZ\Z\H�EGI�kD`*`sn���WGHC_F;>T6DFE�TF;>H�]\D2TF]\=YWX?A;�?A_FWX?U?C_F;�VXWGZ^@F;�EGI?A_F;DFE�TF;�_FWGH�rFB�;>V�]\EG@FHCZ���j�;>;YD1=>E�`yr2@2?A;>T�WGDFTy]\H DFEG?�BC;Y=>E�`arF@2?A;>T1TF@F;?AE ?A_F;U@FHC;UEGI<T2��DqWG`a]\=rFBCEG[�BAWG`a`a]\DF[Fn��J_F;�HCE�Z^]\Ta;YZ\Z^]\rFH�;YH HC_FE � =YWGZ\Z^H ?C_qWX? &qDF]\H�_F;YH�j��yW =YWGZ\Zq?CE3pqV���]^?A_y?A_F;VGWXBC] WXjFZ\;]\DFT2;���]^DFTF]^=tWX?C;YT�jN��?A_F;�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YH�?CE�?C_F;�BC]^[�_N?�EGI�?C_F;�?AB�;Y;Gn

Page 23: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n OGO

c3d*e8f�g�[]hif�� ��:�! � o ;:���: �>u gl�z } GD��<HE $%��� �a&)( o �u+gO!z $�} �"!$� o �u � � E8xD�"�-� �=E G5� � ¡2z �v��!u��$�} �"!$� o �u � � E8xD�"�0� �=E GD�,� p|V o �"!$� o �u�:?�a&)( o #/, � o u�uJ:?�a&)( o ��3@R"� o �uCuCuLFz �v��!u� o�� �"!$� o �u�g � � u $%} �+g £ E x5�"�0�,�=E G5�,� �a&)( o #/, � o u�uQ!z �v��!u� o�� �"!$� o �u�g ��: ��g l � u � �=E G5�,� �a&)( o ��3@R"� o �uCu�2z �"��J �a&)(d!z � ��E8GD�,� �a&)( o �u"w]^[�@FB�;�lm¡2z��J_F;�WXZ\[�E�B�]^?C_F` g�d*e8f�g�[]hif>� ��:�! � o ;:���: �>u ��_F]\=�_S=>E�`arF@2?A;>H�WGD ��f� ����IKE�B f � � ����� � n

����� ��� ��� �� �� � � ����� �� � ������� �

�xD(?C_F]\HHC;>=>?C]\E�D ��;�=YE�D2HC]\T2;YBE�r�;>BAWX?C]\E�D2H�?CEy; �2WG`y]^DF;�?A_F; HC;i?�EXI+HAW-?A]\H�I ��]\DF[�?AB�@2?A_6WGHCH�]\[�DF`a;YDN?CHEGI�WyDFE!T2;��nJR ?CBC@2?C_ WGH�HC]^[�DF`a;YDN?��1HCWX?A]^H &q;>HhWaDFE!T2; ]^I f � ������=tWXD j�; ;>VXWGZ^@qWX?C;YT ?CE6l�@FHC]^DF[?A_F;¤?CBC@2?C_ ?�WGj2Z\;YH�EXI ?C_F;� �E�E�Z\;YWGD E�rk;YBCWX?AEGBCHYn "qE�BC`yWGZ\Z���eq?A_2;SHAWX?C]\H�I ��]^DF[1?AB�@2?A_ WGH�HC]\[GDF`y;>DN?AH�]\H?A_F;�H�;>?(7!$� o �uiz

(7!$� o �u�g ��� ����� � ��������� � ����� i f � ������]\H�?CBC@F;�� :��_F;YB�;D��� � ��������� � ����� T2;YDFEG?C;YH ?A_F;aHC;i? EGI�WGZ\Z+?CBC@2?C_�WXHCHC]^[�DF`a;YDN?AH�IKE�B�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YH��.8qp�:?>?>7>7:08B~���e�]/n ;Xn^eIK@FDF=i?A]\EGDFH IKBCEG` �.8qpJ:?>?>7>E:08B~ ��?AE ?A_F;1?CBC@2?C_ VGWXZ\@F;>H�� g �-£�:tl$��n �J_F;/&qB�H�?aWGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F`(e j>k6f �lnm�YDo�fwec=>E�`yr2@2?A;>H ?A_F;�H�]��>;1EGI(7!$� o �uie�HC;>;%&q[�@FB�; ltLFn#�J_F;�WGZ^[�E�B�]^?A_2` ;��!rFZ\EG]^?AH�?A_F;�IKEGZ\Z\E ��v]\DF[ I4WG=>?Yn ��I ]\H¤W DFE!T2; ��]^?C_%VGWXBC] WXjFZ\;a]\DFT2;��[�"!$� o u�?A_F;>D ? ��E#HC;i?AHSEGI�?CBC@2?C_ WGHCH�]\[�DF`a;YDN?CH=tWGD `�WG�X;�� � ?CBC@F;Xn �J_F; &qB�H�? H�;>?#_qWXHj�"!$� ;F��@qWGZ�?CE £2e�?A_F; EG?A_2;YB _qWXH��"!$� ;F��@qWGZ�?CEl�n "gEGB¤?A_F; &qBCH�?�H�;>?Ye�?A_F;�D�@F`¤jk;YBa]\HSIKE�@2DFT�jN� &qD2TF]\DF[#?A_2; D�@F`¤jk;YBaEGI?AB�@2?A_ WGHCH�]\[�DF`a;YDN?CHG),"� 1B� o #/, � o �uCu1`�WX��]^DF[�#/, � o �u�?CBC@F;Xn R�Z\ZhVXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YH�jk;>? ��;Y;>D �"!$� o u�WGD2T �"!$� o #/, � o �u�u�]^D?A_F; EGBCTF;>BC]\D2[ =tWGD jk; =�_FE�H�;YD WXBCjF]�?ABAWXBC]\Z���e�?C_F;YB�;>IKE�B�;#]\D ?C_F;#=tWGH�; EGI �"!$� �j�;>]\DF[ £!e�W%?AEX?�WGZEGIcO"!�#�$ � �� �� ��� � !�#�$ � ��� Bp G),"� 1B� o #/, � o u�u�HAWX?C]\H�I ��]^DF[y?CBC@2?C_ WGH�HC]\[GDF`y;>DN?AH�; �!]\H�?CHYn��|E1j�; ;$)a=>]\;YDN?YeT2��DqWG`a]\=hr2BCE�[�BCWG`a`y]^DF[¤HC_2E�@FZ\T�jk; WGrFrFZ^]\;YT�]^D jikNf�lnm�YDo�f o HC;>;�; �!;YBC=>]\H�;�LFn�lm£Nu n�J_F;yD2;���?�WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` _�oia�j>k6f ]\D�&q[�@FB�;�l9Q &qDFTFH�W�HAWX?C]\H�I ��]^DF[�?ABC@!?A_ WGHCH�]\[�DF`a;YDN?Yn * E�`a;

]\B�BC;YZ^;>VXWGDN?�VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YHUrFBC;>HC;>D�? ]^D6?A_F;SEGBCTF;>BC]\D2[�`y]^[�_N?�DFEX? WGrFrk;tWGBh]^D6?A_2;SBC;YH�@FZ^?�WGDFT ?A_F;i� =YWGDj�;hWGHCH�]\[�DF;>T(WGDN��VXWGZ\@2; ��_qWX?CHCE�;>V�;>BYn _So�a�j>k6f HC]^`yr2Z^�:&qDFTFHW¤rqW-?A_�Z\;YWGTF]\D2[ ?AE�l�jN��WSTF;>r2?A_�v&qBCH�?c?ABAWtVG;YBCHCWGZ e�rFB�;>IK;>BC]\D2[�H�E�`y;���_qWX?�WGB�jF]^?CBAWGB�]\Z^� Z^E���v�;YTF[G;YH E9VG;YB _F]\[G_!vx;>TF[�;YH>n+��? ]\H�rqWXB�?A]^=Y@FZ\WGBCZ��HC]^`yrFZ^;�TF@F;U?CE ?A_2;�E�jFH�;YB�VGW-?A]\EGDy?A_FWX?X3 C!D1I,7N�& 3/(X1I,"���V�B&�^&J�JU�3V1Y!$#�%'&�3V�}��!"( !$�t#/&0!"(J� ,"1I&{W�!$�V�#/&0!6N$3V1�R �^,)( : �J_F; BC@2DFDF]\D2[�?C]\`a;h]\HJ=>Z\;YWGBCZ��1Z\]^DF;tWXB�]\D�?A_2; B�;YH�@FZ^?Yn

_�\�\Nj>k6f#]\D/&q[�@FB�;�l � &qDFTFHUWGZ^Z HAW-?A]\H�I ��]\DF[S?AB�@2?A_�v WGH�HC]\[GDF`y;>DN?AHJZ\;YWtV!]^DF[�E�@2?�]^BCBC;>Z\;iVGWXD�?JVXWGB�]�vWGjFZ^;YHcIKBCE�` ?C_F;hE�B�TF;YB�]\DF[Fn_S\"\Nj>k6f o �u &qDFT2HJWGZ\ZqrFWX?A_FH IKBCE�` W DFE!T2; 1?AE ?A_F;U?A;YB�`y]^DqWGZ<l�nw�J_F;BC@FD2DF]\DF[�?A]^`y;�]^H�Z\]\D2;tWGBJ]^D(?C_F;�HC]��>;�EXIw?A_2;�B�;YHC@2Z^?U`¤@FZ^?C]\rFZ^]\;>T ��]^?C_(?C_F; ?C]\`a;h?AEyWGTFT(?A_F; HC]^DF[�Z\;WGHCH�]\[�D2`y;>D�?CH�� 8 !�#�$ � �� �� £��kWGDFT1� 8 !*#+$ � �� �� l6�k]\D�IKBCE�DN?�EGI<W Z\]^H�?cEGI @Fr�?AEA�(;YZ\;>`y;>DN?AHYn �E ��;iV�;YB>e?A_F;�B�;YHC@2Z^?�=tWXD jk;�;��!r�EGDF;YDN?A]\WGZ\Z���Z\WGBC[G;�]\D i �i e!HCE�?A_F;�B�@FDFDF]^DF[S?A]\`a;h]^H�?A_F;�rkE!E�B � o O-, � , �<u n

Page 24: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n OX¡

j>k6f�l mY5o�f�� � � o �ul�z } GD�D<HE $���� G),"��1B� o �uO!z $%} zg £ E x5�"� �a&)(+ £¡2z �"��!u� $%} zg l E x5�"� �a&)(+ lLFz �"��!u� �a&)(+ O !�#�$ � �� �� �� � !*#+$ � �� Bp G),"� 1B� o #/, � o �uCu

� O !*#�$ � ��������� ��� � !�#�$ � �� Bp G),"��1B� o ��3@R"� o �uCuQ!z � �=E G5�,� �)&)(�2z �"�DJ G),"� 1B�d!zP2z � �=E G5� � O !�#�$ � �� Bp G),"� 1B� o �u"w]^[�@FB�; ltLFzyR�D WGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F` IKE�B TF;>?C;YBC`a]\D2]\DF[6?C_F;�D�@F`¤jk;YBSEGI�VXWGZ^]\T�?CBC@2?C_�WXHCHC]^[�D!v`a;YDN?AH>n �;>=tWGZ^Z eN?A_qW-?�?A_F;,$�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;U]^DFTF;�� &z�"!$� EGI|£¤WGD2T l�]\Da?A_F;8��f� ���� BC;Yr2BC;ivH�;YDN?�WX?C]\E�Da]\H�� �#l ��_F;>Dy?A_2;EGBCTF;>BC]\D2[�=YE�DN?�WX]\DFH���VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YH o D�@2`¤j�;>BC;>T lJ?A_2BCE�@F[G_�suinc�J_F]\H�`a;tWGD2H�?A_qWX?A�"!$� o £Nu�WGDFTM�"!$� o l9u�WGZ!��Wt��H[G]^V�;>H�� ��l�n

_Soia�jikNf o �ul�z $%} zg £ E x5�"� b�BCBCEGBO!z �"��!u� $%} zg l E x5�"�0� ��E8GD�,� � �¡2z �"��!u� $%} #/, � o �u�g £ E x5�"�0�,�=E G5�,� � 8 !�#�$ � �� �� l�: _�oia�j>k6f o ��3@R"� o u�u �LFz �"��!u��� �=E G5�,� � 8 !*#+$ � �� �� £�: _Soia�jikNf o #/, � o u�u �"w]^[�@FB�;�l9Q!z#RUD WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` IKE�ByBC;i?A@FB�DF]\DF[%W%HAWX?C]\H�I ��]^DF[ ?CBC@2?C_!v WGH�HC]^[�DF`a;YDN?tn �J_2;VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH�WGB�;�WGHCH�@F`a;YT ?CE�j�;8qp�:?>7>?>7:08B~�EGBCTF;>BC;YT(]\D�?C_F]\H���Wt��n

_S\�\NjikNf o �ul�z $%} zg £ E x5�"�0� ��E8GD�,� ���

O!z �"��!u� $%} zg l E x5�"�0� ��E8GD�,� � � � �¡2z �"��!u��� �=E G5�,�LFz � WGTFT � 8 !*#+$ � �� �� £��<]^D�IKB�E�DN?�EGIwWGZ\ZQ!z ?CBC@2?C_!v WXHCHC]^[�DF`a;YDN?AH�]^D)_S\�\Nj>k6f o #/, � o �uCuJ:�2z WXTFT � 8 !�#�$ � �� �� l6�<]\D�IKB�E�DN?UEXI+WGZ^Zd!z ?CBC@2?C_!v WXHCHC]^[�DF`a;YDN?AH�]^D)_S\�\Nj>k6f o ��3@R"� o �u�u �"w]^[�@FB�;yl �!z�R�D WXZ\[�E�B�]^?C_F` ��_F]^=�_ BC;i?A@FB�DFHhWGZ^Z�HAWX?C]\H�I ��]^DF[y?CBC@2?C_!v WGH�HC]^[�DF`a;YDN?AH>n�J_2;VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YHSWXBC;�WGH�HC@F`a;YT ?AE#jk;k8qpJ:?>?>?> 8B~#E�BCTF;>BC;>T ]^D ?A_F]^H��Wt��n%� ;�@FHC; � ����� � ?CETF;>DFEG?C;�HC;F��@2;YDF=>;YHcEGIF?CBC@2?C_SWGHCH�]\[�D2`y;>D�?CHYn��xD¤rqWGB�?A]\=>@FZ WXBYe ��� ]^H|?C_F;�;>`yr2?x� H�;u��@F;YD2=Y;EGI<?CBC@2?C_�WGHCH�]\[�D2`y;>D�?CHYe2WGDFT � � � � ]^H�?C_F;hHC;F��@F;YDF=>;�=YE�DFH�]\H�?A]\D2[¤EGI<?A_2;hHC]^DF[�Z\;U;Y`ar2?x�?CBC@2?C_6WGH�HC]^[�DF`a;YDN?tn

Page 25: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n O-L

ji[]pq`*\�[]r�a o � : �ul�z } GD�D<HE $���� (J3VU o � : �uO!z $%} � g £ E x5�"�0� ��E8GD�,� £¡2z �"��!u� $%} ��l E x5�v�P�,�=E G5�,� LFz �"��!u� $%} � g l E x5�"�Q!z � �=E G5�,� pqV o �"!$� o �uJ:E(J3VU o � :?#/, � o �u�uJ:E(J3VU o � :E��3@R"� o �uCu�u�2z �"��!u� $%} �"!$� o � u�g �"!$� o �u E x5�v�d!z $%} #/, � o � u�g £ E x5�"�0�,�=E G5�,� (J3VU o ��3@R"� o � u�:E��3@R"� o �uCuP2z �"��!u� $%} ��3@R"� o � u�g £ E x5�v�0� �=E G5�,� (J3VU o #/, � o � u�:?#/, � o u�uM2z �"��!u��� �=E G5�,� pqV o �"!$� o �uJ:lm£!z (J3VU o #/, � o � u�:?#/, � o �u�uJ:l�lGz (J3VU o ��3@R"� o � uJ:J��3@R"� o �uCuCul9O�z �"��!u� $%} �"!$� o � u � �"!$� o �u E x5�v�lm¡!z � �=E G5�,� pqV o �"!$� o � uJ:E(J3VU o #/, � o � uJ: u�:E(J3VU o ��3@R"� o � uJ: �u�ultL2z �"��!u�l9Q�z � �=E G5�,� pqV o �"!$� o �uJ:E(J3VU o � :?#/, � o �u�uJ:E(J3VU o � :E��3@R"� o �uCu�ul �!z �"�DJ (J3VUl9d�zlmP!z � �=E G5� � (J3VU o � : �u"w]^[�@FB�;yl9d�zJR�D#WGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F` o TF@2; ?AE;��EG@FTF;YB�?�;>?hWGZ � ��  p P�M��+u�IKE�BUHC]\`arFZ^]^I ��]\DF[�WXD�Jf� ���� ��?A_qW-? ��; EGDFZ^��=YWGBC;�WGjkE�@2?E�D(?A_F; TFE�`yWG]\D � n�����DqWX`y]^=�rFBCE�[GBAWG`a`y]^DF[H�_FE�@FZ^T jk; WGrFrFZ^]\;YT1?CE�]\`arFBCEmV�;�;�)y=>]\;>DF=>� o ;��!;YB�=Y]\H�;�LFn^lmO�u

Page 26: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n OGQ

p|V o �l: � : qp�u � o l9uX Y5[]\�^ o f u � o O ~ u_S`*`*\ba o��� : qp): Ys�u � o i qp?i.i Ys"i uc3d*e8f�g�[]hif o ;:���: �iu � o i �i u * ;Y;�DFEX?A;j>k6fDlnmY5o�f o u � o i �i u * ;Y;�DFEX?A;_Soia�j>k6f o �u � o i i u g � �=<���� f o �uie}i i�g � o i �i u_S\�\Nj>k6f o �u � o i �'i �<u � g � � ����� f o �uie�i �Yi�g � o O-, � , uji[]pq`*\�[]r�a o � : u � o i � i/i �i u * ;Y;�DFEX?A;CEG?A;Xz��J_F;>HC;�BC@2DFDF]\D2[1?A]\`a;YHUE�DFZ�� _2E�Z\TFH�]^IcT2��DqWG`a]\= rFBCE�[GBAWG`a`y]^DF[a]\H@2HC;YT o ; �2;>BC=>]\HC;>HUL2n d!e2LFn^lt£2eqWGDFT(LFn�l9O�u n

�wWXjFZ\;hlGz|� E�BCH�?�v�=tWGH�;JBC@FDFD2]\DF[h?C]\`a;YH�IKEGBw?A_F;���f� ���� E�r�;>BAWX?C]\E�D2HYnw�J_2;JBC@FDFD2]\DF[h?C]\`a;YH+WXBC;�?A_2;;��!rk;Y=>?C;YT#BC@2DFDF]\D2[1?A]\`a;YHUHC]^DF=Y; ?C_F;>� WGBC;¤WGZ\Z�jqWGH�;YT#E�D#W1_qWXHC_!v ?�WGjFZ^;���]�?A_ ; �2rk;Y=i?A;>T =>E�DFH�?AWGDN??A]^`y;hH�;tWGB�=�_ WGD2T(]^DFHC;>B�?C]\E�D�E�rk;YBCWX?A]^E�DFHYn

����� � � � � ������J_F; &FDqWGZUWGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` =YWGZ\Z^;YT j�[]p|`�\�[]r=a ]^HyH�_FE ��D ]\D &q[�@FB�;�l9d!n �J_F; WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F` ]^H�@FH�;YT ?CEHC]^`yrFZ^]^I �aWGD ��f� ���� j���?AB���]^DF[¤?AESB�;Y`aE9VG;�DFE�TF;YH>n �J_2; H�]\`arFZ\] &q=tW-?A]\EGDy]^H�jqWGH�;YT�E�D(W¤TFE�`yWG]\D� EGIU]\DN?C;YBC;>H�?Yn �J_F; ��f� ���� �]\HSH�@FrFrkE�HC;>T�?AE#jk;�EGI�]^DN?A;YB�;YH�?yEGDFZ^��E�D ?ABC@!?A_�WGHCH�]\[�DF`a;YDN?CH?A_qW-?SWGZ^HCE HCWX?A]^H�I � � n o �J_F]^H¤E!=>=Y@FB�H��_F;YD @FH�]\DF[1�Jf� ����hH�IKE�B C?,"�JU !$#��$&J��3 �wG0!$�43K,"1qn * ;Y=i?A]^E�Dd�HC_FE ��H�_FE � ?AE�TFE1IKE�B�`�WXZ|VG;YBC] &q=tW-?A]\EGD1��]^?A_?��f� ����hHYe j2@2?�=YE�DN?AWG]\DFH�DFE�;��2WG`arFZ\;�EGI @FHC]^DF[ji[]pq`*\"[]r=a n u��E j�;arFBC;>=Y]^HC;Ge�[�]^VG;YD � WGDFT �e�ji[]pq`*\"[]r=a &qD2TFH¤WGD2EG?A_F;>B ��f� ���� � e�?x��rF]\=YWGZ\Z�� HC`yWGZ\Z^;YB

?A_qWXD �ewH�@F=�_�?A_FWX? f� L f � g f� L f ��� n(��? TFE�;YH HCE jN�#?AB��!]^DF[ ?CE6]^TF;YDN?A]�I �#HCE�D2HYe�WGD2T ?A_2;YBC;>jN�`�WX��]^DF[SHCEG`y;�DFE�TF;>HB�;YTF@2DFTqWGDN?tn R `yEGBC;�TF;i?�WG]^Z\;YT�WXDqWGZ^��H�]\HJ]\HJZ^;>I ?J?CE�?C_F;�BC;YWGTF;YB>n�J_F;�BC@FD2DF]\DF[¤?C]\`a;UEXI|?C_F;�WGZ^[�E�BC]�?A_F`aHcEGI�?A_F;�rFBC;iV!]^E�@FHJH�;Y=>?C]\E�D2HJ]\H�H�@F`a`�WGB�]��>;YT1]^D1?�WGjFZ^; l�n

����� ����� ����� � � � ����� �� � � ��� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � �� _F;YD WXrFrFZ^��]^DF[��Jf� ����hH�EGI ?A;>D &lo�3/(J�b&J1B�434!$# 87��!$1B�43 �wG0!$��3K,"1�WGDFT G),"UXWB,.(J3V�43K,"1�]^H @FH�;YTsn b���v]\H�?A;YDN?C] WGZq��@qWXD�?C]!&q=YWX?A]^E�D ]\H1?C_F;  �E!EGZ\;tWXD E�r�;>BAWX?C]\E�D�� 8;> f n �J_2; `a;tWGD2]\DF[ EGI WGD�;��!]\H�?A;>D�?C] WGZ��@qWGDN?A] &q=tWX?C]\E�D�EXI+Wa �E�E�Z\;YWGD1VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;�]\HJ[�]�V�;YD(jN�1?A_2;�IKEGZ\Z\E ��]^DF[¤;u��@qW-?A]\EGDsz

� 8;> f g f � £6�"8 � P f � l��"8 ��> o ��ufhD ��f� ����hH ; �!]\H�?C;YDN?A]\WGZ���@qWGDN?C]!&q=YWX?A]^E�D#=tWGD#?A_F;>BC;iIKE�BC;aj�;�]^`yrFZ^;Y`a;YDN?A;>T @FHC]^DF[�? ��E =tWGZ^Z\H�?CEc3d*e f�g�[]hif WGDFT(W�HC]\D2[�Z\;h=YWGZ\Z�?AES_S`�`*\ba n2d,"UXWB,.(J3V��3K,"1 ]\H ?A_F;%�Jf� ���� E�rk;YBCWX?A]^E�D�rk;YB�IKE�BC`a]\DF[(?A_F;y;u��@F]�VGWXZ\;YDN? EGI�HC@Fj2H�?A]�?A@2?C]\E�D�E�D �E�E�Z\;YWGD�; �!rFBC;>HCHC]^E�Dsncf�I ?C;YD ?C_F;�DFEX?�WX?C]\E�D f � f^� �"8 �2]^H�@2HC;YT�?AEhTF;>HC=>BC]\jk;�?C_F;�B�;YH�@FZ^?�EGIgHC@2jFH�?C]^?A@!?A]\D2[WGZ\ZsIKB�;Y; E!=>=Y@FB�BC;>DF=Y;>HhEGI�8 ]^D f jN� f^� n o R�D E!=>=Y@FB�BC;YD2=Y;¤EGI+WaVXWGB�] WGjFZ^;�]\HJIKBC;>; ]^Iw]^?]\H�DFEX?E��]�?A_F]^D?A_F;�H�=YE�rk; EXI�W ��@FWGDN?A]!&F;YBYn u p �|E�rk;YB�IKE�BC` ?A_F]^HaH�@FjFH�?A]^?C@2?A]^E�D E�D ��f� ����hH��; E�jFHC;>B�VG; ?A_2;�������! �"$#&%('*)(),+& .-/�10�2/�3�4�5-7618!2/�90��;:<".=�+*>?"$+A@!2�B�BC�5-/0&D<"E .-/�! .".=��5"FG>H�30A@40A@5"EI5=A-9D5B�".JK+*-�LMLN=A""POQ2/=A�R2�D!B3"S+

-/LUTWVCDX".���5YKDX-/85�!F4D�Z[618!2/�90��;:<".=�+*-�LUT]\

Page 27: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���~�|5�}�� � �O� � � �q��� ���|� �b���}�Q�|�O� � � � � � �n O��

IKE�Z\Z^E ��]\DF[�;u��@qWX?C]\E�Dse ��_2]\=�_(_FE�Z\T2HJ]^I f =>E�DN?�WG]^DFH�DFE���@FWGDN?A]!&F;YBCH>zf � f � �"8 � g f � f � � l$:�£6�"8 ��g f � � f � l.�"8 �K: f � £6��8 �K> o dGu

* ]\DF=>; o f � � f � l.�"8 �K: f � £6��8 � u�g o f � L f � l��"8 � u'P o S f � L f � £6��8 � u ��;h=YWGD�=YE�`arF@2?C;�?A_2]\H+��]�?A_�? ��EWGrFrFZ^]\=YWX?A]^E�DFH+EGI�g�d*e f�g�[]hif�WGDFT�?A_FB�;Y;UWGrFrFZ^]\=tW-?A]\EGDFH+EGI�k�`*`*\ba o ��]^?C_a?C_F;UEGr�;>BAWX?CE�BCHdL�e o S u L ePcuin �UE ��;>VG;YBYekjN��;YH�HC;>D�?C] WGZ^Z^��[�;YDF;>BAWGZ^]��>]\DF[3kD`*`*\ba�?CESE�rk;YBAW-?AE�B�H�,)W ��]�?A_�?A_FB�;Y; WGB�[�@F`a;YDN?AH���;=tWGD�TFEajk;>?C?C;YB o H�;Y;�;��!;>BC=Y]^HC; LFn�lm¡Nuin

��� � � � � � ��|�����,<=$4!F�)A;��� ��E�DFH�?ABC@2=>?�?C_F;��f� ���� IKE�B S 8qpOL o 8's+_ S 8'v>u���]^?A_(E�B�TF;YB�]\DF[ 8qpT��8's� 8'v@FHC]^DF[S?A_F; WGZ^[�E�B�]^?A_2` X Y5[]\�^�]\D/&q[�@FB�; M2n�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;� ' * _FE ��?A_F;hB�;YrFB�;YH�;YDN?�WX?C]\E�D�EXI|?C_F;8�Jf� ���� EXI &q[�@FB�;8�¤]\D�?C_F;hH�?x�!Z^;�EGI &q[�@2BC;�d!n�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;� 2 * @F[�[G;YH�?WXD(]^`yr2BCEmV�;>`y;>D�?~XZY5[]\�^{l mo � o f uJEGI~X Y5[]\"^?��_F]\=�_�[�;>DF;YBCWX?A;>HEGDFZ^��WZ\]^DF;tWGB D�@F`¤jk;YBSEGI�=YWGZ\Z^H�IKE�B¤ �E!EGZ\;tWXD%;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2H f ?C_qWX?�WGB�;1=YEGD���@FDF=i?A]\EGDFH¤EGI�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;YH¤WXDFTDF;Y[�WX?A]^E�DFHJEGI|VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>HYn�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;� A ��E�DFH�?ABC@2=>?�?C_F;1��f� ����hHaIKE�B�8�WGD2T 8 Z < @FHC]^DF[ ��_FWX?A;iV�;YB�E�BCTF;>BC]^DF[ �GE�@��WXD�?Yn ��E�`yr2@2?A;�?A_2; T2]\H ��@2DF=>?C]\E�D�EGI|?A_F;�? ��E ��f� ����hHJ@FHC]^DF[Sk�`*`*\ba n�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;� T ��E�DFH�?ABC@2=>?h?C_F; �Jf� ����hH�IKE�B S o 8qp}L�8'viuUWGD2T�8's�L�8'v�@FH�]\DF[ � Y5[]\"^ ��]^?C_6?A_2;E�BCT2;YBC]^DF[98qp+�`8'sX�[8'vYn��HC; kD`*`�\ a%?AE &qDFT�?A_2;���f� ���� IKE�B S o 8qp;Lr8'v�uQP o 8'stLr8'v u n�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;� & �xHs?A_F;>BC; WGDN�h;>HCH�;YDN?A]\WGZNTF]! �;YB�;YDF=>;�]\D�B�@FDFDF]^DF[�?A]^`y;+jk;>? ��;Y;>D�&qD2TF]\DF[ g�d*e8f�g�[]hif o �.:tl�:A£NuWGDFT)g�d*e8f�g�[]hif o �.:a�t:�£�u+��_F;YD(?A_F;�VXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;hE�BCT2;YBC]^DF[�]\Hw8qp �[8'sT� ������� 8B~ ��|�����,<=$4!F�)A;� 1 �UH�; T!�!DFWG`y]^=�rFBCEG[�BAWG`a`a]\DF[ ?CE�]\`arFBCEmV�;h?C_F;�BC@FD2DF]\DF[S?C]\`a;�EGI{c3d*e8f�g�[]hif�n�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;� @�� ;>DF;YBCWGZ\]^HC;�g�d*e8f�g�[]hif ?AEWGBCj2]^?ABCWGB���?CBC@2?C_�WXHCHC]^[�DF`a;YDN?AH � 8 % � g � % � e 8 % � g � % � e@>?>?> e 8 % � g� % � �/n���?`y]^[�_N?Jjk; =>E�DNV�;>DF]\;>D�??AEaWGH�HC@F`a;�?A_qW-?T8 % � �`8 % � � ������� 8 % � n�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;��� * @F[�[G;YH�?wWUH�@FjFH�?�WGDN?A]\WGZ\Z��hjk;>?�?A;YB ��Wm� EGI2jF@F]^Z\TF]^DF[ �Jf� ����hH<IKE�B o Z WXBC[�;tus �E!EGZ\;tWXD;��!rFB�;YHCH�]\E�D2H?C_qWGD � Y5[]\�^cn�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;����� ��_qWGDF[�;�j>k6f�l mY5o�f�HC@F=�_ ?A_qWX?T2��DqWX`y]^= r2BCE�[�BCWG`a`y]^DF[S]\H�@FH�;YTsn��E�� T2E!;>H?A_F]^HJ=�_qWGDF[G;�?C_F;�BC@FD2DF]\DF[S?C]\`a;���|�����,<=$4!F�)A;���*� b>�!rFZ\WG]\D/��_N��T2��DqWG`a]\=�rFBCE�[GBAWG`a`y]^DF[¤TFE�;YH�DFEX?�_F;YZ^r ]^D(]^`yr2BCEmV�]\DF[ ?C_F;�BC@FD�vDF]\D2[¤?A]\`a;�EGI~_S\�\Nj>k6fwn�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;���"' �x`yrFB�EmV�;�?A_F;�;�)y=>]\;>DF=>��EGI ji[]pq`*\�[]r�a ��]�?A_(T2��DqWG`a]\=�rFB�E�[�BAWX`y`a]\DF[2n�|�����,<=$4!F�)A;���"2 ��B�]^?A;�?A_2;�WGZ^[�E�B�]^?A_2` lnm�pq`*me d o qp):08;: Ys�u�IKE�B�=YEG`yrF@!?A]\D2[(?C_F;%�Jf� ���� EGIqp$� 's���8 ��;$)a=Y]^;YDN?AZ�� WGZ^E�DF[%?C_F; Z\]^DF;YH1EXI�kD`*`*\bacn "w]^BCH�?1[�;YDF;>BAWGZ^]��>;wkD`�`*\ba ?AE E�rk;YBCWX?AE�B�H�,)W��]^?C_ ?A_2BC;Y; WGBC[G@F`y;>DN?AH o WGHUIKEGBU; �FWX`yrFZ^; ?C_F; ]�I v�?C_F;YD!v�;YZ^HC;�E�rk;YBAW-?AE�BAuiek@2?A]^Z\]��>]\DF[SEGDF=Y; WG[NWG]^D ?A_2;* _qWGD2DFE�D(;��!rqWGDFH�]\E�D n �J_2;YD(@FHC; ;u��@qWX?C]\E�D d ?AE:��BC]�?A;h?C_F; WGZ\[�EGBC]^?C_F`(n

Page 28: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� �"�����D� �y���3�O� � � ���|�� � � � � �+���{��|�O�b���q OGd

� � ; ��4$�8; �8.%<���.19 <��1� � � � � 0 � ��� �3<��60 .�=

�J_F;YB�;SWGB�; `yWGDN� =�_2E�]\=>;YHU?C_qWX?�_qWtV�; ?CE1j�; ?�WG�X;YD ]^D6]\`arFZ^;Y`a;YDN?A]^DF[S?A_F; ��f� ���� E�rk;YBAW-?A]\EGDFHYn�J_F;YB�;1]\H DFE EGj�V�]^E�@FH jk;YH�?��Wm� EGIJT2E�]\DF[ ]^?Yn �J_F]^H H�;Y=>?C]\E�D�[�]^VG;YH _2]\DN?AH IKE�B�H�E�`a;�BC;YWGHCEGDqWGjFZ^;HCE�Z^@2?A]^E�DFH>n

"w]\B�H�?te�?A_2;�DFE!T2;�?�WGj2Z\;/��]^HJWGD�WGB�BAWt��WGHJHC_FE ��D�]\D@&q[�@FB�;�d!n��J_F;�E�D2Z^�arFBCEGjFZ\;>` ]^H�?A_FWX?�?A_2;HC]��Y;�EGI�?C_F;�WXBCBAWt� ]^H�DFEG?���D2E���D�@FDN?A]\Z+?C_F;�IK@FZ\Zc ���� _qWGH j�;>;YD =YE�DFH�?AB�@F=>?C;YTsn�b�]^?C_F;YB�W/&'�!;YT@FrFrk;YB¤jkE�@FD2T =YE�@FZ^T%jk;�WGHCH�@F`a;YTse�E�B EG?A_F;>B�?CBC]\=���HS`¤@2H�?¤jk;�WGr2rFZ\]^;YT o IKE�B ; �FWX`yrFZ^; N$m"1Y!$U�3KG!$���0!$m.(3� ��: �UMG£2e�H�;Y=Xn�lmP!n L � uin��J_F;�?AWGjFZ^; ! =YE�@2Z\T(j�; ]\`arFZ\;>`y;>DN?A;YT WGHUWy_qWXHC_!v ?�WGjFZ^;�@FHC]^DF[yIKE�B]\DFH�?�WGD2=Y;h?A_2; _FWGHC_(IK@FDF=>?C]\E�D

� o �l: ��£�: �gl9u�g W�!$3V� o �0: W�!$3V� o ��£�: �gl9uCu `yE�T����_F;YB�;�W�!$3V�J]\H�W�rqWG]^BC]^DF[aIK@2DF=>?C]\E�D(?A_qWX?�`�WXrFH�rqWX]\BCHEGIcDqW-?A@FBCWGZ�D�@F` j�;>BCH�?CE�DqWX?C@FBAWXZ�D�@F`¤jk;YB�HWGDFT� ]^H�WSrFBC]^`y;Xn f�D2; =�_2E�]\=>;�IKEGB�?A_F;�rqWG]^BC]^DF[ IK@FDF=i?A]^E�D�]\H

W�!$3V� o �0:��!u�g o �!� ��u o �!� � ��l9uO � �

��_F]\=�_ ]^H�W jF] ��;>=>?A]^E�Dse WGDFT ?C_F;YB�;>IKE�B�; $�r�;>B�IK;>=>?-&2z�]^?SrFB�E!T2@F=Y;>HaD2E =>E�Z\Z^]\H�]\E�DFH>n#R�H�@FHC@FWGZ ��]^?C__qWGH�_!v�?AWGjFZ\;>H���;1_qWtV�;1?CE TF;>=Y]\T2;1E�D�?C_F;1HC]��Y;�WXH¤W6rFB�]\`a;� n?�E ��;iV�;YB>ecHC]\D2=Y;�?C_F;1HC]��Y;1EXI ![�BCE ��H�T2��DqWG`a]\=YWGZ\Z��1]�?�=tWGD(j�; _qWGB�T(?CE &FDFT W�[�E�E!T�=�_FE�]^=Y;�IKE�B�� nJfhDF; HCEGZ\@2?C]\E�D/��E�@FZ\T(jk;�?CE?�WG�X;�� V�;YB�� Z WXBC[�;Xe IKE�Bh; �FWX`yrFZ^; � g l9Q-LNPNQGP��G¡ o ��_F]^=�_#]\HU?C_F;�lm£�£G£�£�£�£'� ?A_6rFBC]^`y;¤D�@F` j�;>B�uieWGDFT�?A_2;YD�?�WG�X; WGHJ?C_F;�_qWGHC_2]\DF[SIK@FDF=i?A]^E�D

��� o �0: ��£�: �gl9utg�� o �0: �!£ : �gl9u�`aE!T O �@FHC]^DF[¤W ?�WGjFZ^;�EGI�H�]��>;�O � n * ?�WXB�?A]^DF[�IKB�E�` HCE�`a;hB�;tWGH�E�DqWGjFZ^;�H�`�WGZ^ZqVGWXZ\@F;EGI�� ��;�=YE�@2Z\T1]^DF=YB�;tWGH�;?A_F;y?�WGjFZ^;@��_F;>D ]^? =YE�DN?�WX]\DFH�O � ;YZ^;Y`a;YDN?AH j���WGTFT2]\DF[ EGDF;�?AE���e�=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?aW DF;$� ?�WGj2Z\;1WXDFTBC;>_qWGHC_�WGZ\Z�;>Z\;>`y;>D�?CH�]^DN?AE ?C_F]\H�DF;�� ?�WGj2Z\;Gn o R�[�WG]\Dse|HC;>;yIKE�B�; �FWX`yrFZ^;1� ��: �UMG£!ewH�;Y=Xn�lmP!n L �cIKE�BTF;>?AWG]\Z^HYn u "qE�B HC@F=�_�W T2��DqWG`a]\=_qWGHC_�v�?�WXjFZ\;�?A_F;�WG`aE�B�?C]��Y;>TseN;��!rk;Y=i?A;YT�=>E�H�?�EGI<;tWX=�_1E�rk;YBAW-?A]\EGD�]\HH�?C]\Z\Z � o l9uin�J_F; ?AWGjFZ^; � @2HC;YT6]\D)_�`*`*\ba =>E�@FZ^T jk;�]^`yr2Z\;Y`a;YDN?C;YT(WGHWa? ��EXvxT2]\`a;YDFH�]\E�DqWXZ<WGBCBCWt��n��E ��v

;>VG;YBYeJ]�?�?A@FB�DFHyEG@2?y?CE�jk;(VG;YB�� H�rqWGBCH�;YZ�� @FHC;>T�� ;>HCrk;Y=Y]\WGZ\Z�� ]^IE��; HC@F=>=Y;>;YT ]\D [�;i?C?A]^DF[ HC`yWGZ\Z�Jf� ����hH��6WGD2T ]�?h]^Hhj�;i?C?C;YBh?AE�@2HC;aW1_qWGH�_!v�?AWGjFZ\;�IKE�Bh]^?Yn��J_2;S_qWGHC_2]\DF[�IK@FDF=i?A]^E�D @FHC;>T#=YE�@FZ^Tj�;�� o �!£ : �gl9u�g � �A� o ��£�: �gl9u�`aE!T�� WGDFT WGH�IKE�B(! W�T!�!DFWG`y]^=�_qWGH�_!v�?AWGjFZ\;�=>E�@FZ^T(jk;�@FHC;>Tsn

� ��� � ; ��46�8= 0 � ����0��4$�8; =�0 4��r�6.19 2��$<�� � � � � =

�J_F]\H6HC;Y=i?A]^E�D ��]\Z\Z TF;>HC=YB�]\jk;%VXWGBC]^E�@FH ; �FWX`yrFZ^;YH EXIyr2BCE�jFZ^;Y`aH6?A_FWX? =tWXD�j�; H�E�Z^VG;YT ��]^?C_ WGD�Jf� ����UvxrFWG=��-WG[�;Gn �J_F;#;��2WG`arFZ\;>H�WGBC; 1I,"��=�_FE�HC;>D ?CE ]\Z\Z^@FH�?CBAWX?C; ��_F;>D �Jf� ����hH1WGBC; ?A_2;j�;>H�?=�_FE�]^=Y;XeqjF@2?HC]^`yrFZ���=�_2E�HC;>D ?AE�]^Z\Z\@2H�?ABCWX?A;U?A_F;�HC=>E�rk; EXIwrkEG?A;>DN?A] WXZ<WGrFrFZ^]\=YWX?A]^E�DFHYn

�(��� ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � � R =>Z WGH�HC]^=tWGZ<=�_F;>HCH vxjkENWGBCT r2BCE�jFZ^;Y` ]^H�?C_F; ��87�B&)&J1�(�WY�),$57#/&JUSz �xH�]�?r�E�H�HC]^jFZ\;�?AEarFZ WX=Y;�P���@F;Y;>DFHE�D Wy=�_F;>HCH�jkENWGB�T6H�Ea?C_qWX?UDFE���@F;>;YD =YWGD6jk;�=YWGr2?C@FBC;>T6jN� WGDFEG?C_F;YB ��@F;Y;>D � �|E�jk;�WajF]^?`aE�BC;

Page 29: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���X�@�����5� -� ���� � � �5�;����+���t� � ��� �u��� q� � � �n OXP

[�;YD2;YBAWXZ ��;�=YE�@FZ^T�WGH��y?A_2;q��@F;YH�?A]\EGD1IKE�B�WGB�jF]^?CBAWGB���� z��xHJ]^?�r�EGHCHC]^jFZ\;?AE¤r2Z WG=>;�� ��@F;Y;>DFH�HAWXIK;>Z^�E�D(W���� =�_F;>HCHj�E�WGBCT ���EaHCE�Z�V�;�?A_2; r2BCE�jFZ^;Y` @FHC]^DF[ �Jf� ����hH���; `¤@FH�?;YDF=>E!TF;�]�?�@FHC]^DF[a �E!EGZ\;tWXD1VGWXBC] WXjFZ\;>HYn+� ;

TFE�?A_F]^HUjN�(]\DN?AB�E!T2@F=Y]^DF[aWaVXWGBC]\WGjFZ^;hIKE�B�;tWG=�_ rkE�H�]^?A]^E�D�E�D ?C_F; j�ENWXBCTsn�� ; DFWG`y;�?C_F; VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YHWGH�8 % # :Yl�� �l:�� ��� ��_F;YB�; �w]^H ?C_F;�B�E � WGDFT �¤]^H ?C_F;�=>E�Z\@2`yDsn�R�VXWGB�] WGj2Z\; ��]\Z^Zqj�; l�]�I<WZ��@F;>;YD]\HJrFZ\WG=Y;>T�E�D(?C_F;�=YE�B�BC;>HCrkE�DFTF]^DF[�r�E�H�]^?C]\E�Dsn

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

�J_F;¤=tWXr2?A@FB�]\DF[yBC@FZ^;YHIKE�B���@F;>;YDFH�B�;u��@F]^BC; ?C_qWX?UDFE1EG?C_F;YB���@2;Y;YD#=YWGD jk; rkE�HC]�?A]\EGDF;YT E�D6?A_2;HAWG`a;�BCE ��ek=YE�Z^@F`yD eqE�BWGDN� EXIw?A_2;�TF]\WG[�E�DFWGZ\H>n��J_F]^H ��; =YWGD6; �2r2BC;YH�H�WGHU �E�E�Z\;YWGD�;��!rFBC;>HCH�]\E�DFH>z"qE�BJWGZ^Z �0:��qe

8 % # Z .p� � �� � ���( # S 8 % �8 % # Z .p� � �� � � �( % S 8 � #8 % # Z .p� � �� � p� # � � % �� � � �( % S 8 ��� # � � %8 % # Z .p� � �� � p� # � % � �� � � �( % S 8 ��� # � % �p E�B�;YEmV�;>BYeq?A_F;>BC;�`¤@FH�?j�; W3��@F;Y;>D6]\D�;YWG=�_ B�E ��z+"qE�B�WXZ\Z ��e8 % pQPr8 % stP �����?Pr8 % �

�wWX��]^DF[¤?A_2; =>E�D���@FD2=>?A]^E�D�EGIwWGZ\Zk?A_F; WGjkEmV�;�BC;F��@2]\BC;>`y;>DN?AHYe ��; [�;>?WSrFB�;YTF]^=tWX?C; ? ,"#�� o��8su�?CBC@F;�W-?;��2WG=i?AZ^��?A_F;�=YEGD'&q[�@FBCWX?A]^E�DFH�?C_qWX?WGB�; H�E�Z\@!?A]\EGDFH�?AES?C_F;��z��@F;>;YDFHrFBCEGjFZ\;>` n�|�����,<=$4!F� &q����= @��SG5�"�"�D!�� � �����%�v+D> � BC]�?A; W rFB�E�[�BAWX` ?C_qWX? =YWGD &qD2T WGD �Jf� ���� IKE�B? ,"#�� o��8 u ��_F;>D [�]�V�;>D�� WXH�]\DFrF@!?tn p WG�G; W%?�WXjFZ\; EXI ?C_F; D�@F`¤jk;YB�EGI H�E�Z\@2?C]\E�D2H�?AE%?C_F;����@F;Y;>DFHUr2BCE�jFZ^;Y` IKE�B�� g l�: O :A¡�:AL�: Q�: ��: d :AP�:?>?>?>�� _2;YD ?C_F;YB�;�]\H�WSHCE�Z^@2?A]^E�Dse![�]^VG; EGDF;Gn

Page 30: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���X�@�����5� -� ���� � � �5�;����+���t� � ��� �u��� q� � � �n OXM

��� *

��� *

� �

�����

"w]^[�@FBC;SltP2z�R IK@FZ\Z v WGT2TF;YB

�(��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � ����� � � � � � �

R C�� #V#%] !6N6N�&J��?AWG�G;>H WGH(WGB�[�@F`a;YDN?AH�? ��E jF]�?AHz8�WGD2T < WGD2T WGD�]\DF=>E�`a]\DF[ =YWGBCB�� jF]^?�� % n ��?rFBCE�TF@F=>;YH�WGH EG@2?ArF@!? W(HC@F` jF]�?� �WGDFT�WGD�E�@!?A[�E�]^DF[�=tWGB�B�� jF]�?����Yn��J_F;�B�;u��@F]\B�;Y`a;YDN?�]\H�?A_qW-?O ��� �� -g�8 �M< ��� % e2]^D1EG?C_F;YB ��E�B�TFH�����]\H ?A_F;h`aE�H�?�HC]^[�DF] &q=tWGDN?�jF]^?�EGI<?A_2;hHC@F` EGIQ8;:a<ke2WXDFT� % egWGDFT� �?C_F;�Z^;tWGH�?�HC]^[�DF]!&F=tWGDN?�jF]�?tn��J_F; BC;F��@2]\BC;>`y;>DN?U=YWGD6jk;8��BC]�?C?A;>D�TFE ��D WGHW¤?�WGj2Z\;�IKE�B����WGDFT6Wy?�WGj2Z\;�IKE�B� ¤]^D ?A;>BC`aH�EGIwVGWXZ\@F;>H�EGI�8;:0<�e�WGDFT�� % nE"qBCE�` H�@F=�_#Wy?AWGjFZ\; ]^?U]\H;tWXH��(?AE@��B�]^?C;TFE ��D6W��8CE" IKEGB����WGDFT� �nR�? ?C_F;�DFEGBC`yWGZ�Z\;iV�;YZ EGI�WXjFH�?CBAWG=i?A]\EGD W�=>E�`¤jF]^DqWX?C]\E�DqWXZh=Y]^BC=Y@2]^?(]\H(DFEG?C_F]\DF[ ;YZ^HC; ?A_qWGD W

 �E�E�Z\;YWGD ;��!rFB�;YH�HC]\EGDsn ��?�=tWXD�jk; BC;>rFBC;>HC;>D�?C;YT�WXH�WGD �Jf� ����¤e�@2HC]\D2[�XZY5[]\�^ ?AE =>E�DFH�?CBC@F=i??A_F;�?CBC]^V�]\WGZ ��f� ����hH�IKEGB�?A_F;�]\D2rF@2?AH�WXDFT @2HC]\D2[yWS=YWGZ\Z ?CES_�`*`*\ba%IKEGBJ;tWG=�_([NWX?C;Gn�|�����,<=$4!F� &q� ' "w]\D2T �8CE"wHJIKE�B����WGD2T� �n �c;>BC]�I �1?A_qW-??C_F; =Y]\B�=Y@F]�?�]\D/&q[�@2BC;almPa]^`yr2Z\;Y`a;YDN?CHJWE�DF;�jF]�?JIK@FZ\Z v WGT2TF;YB�@2HC]\D2[�?C_F;3�Jf� ����UvxrFWG=��-WG[�;�WGDFT�?C_F; �8C "wH>n

�(� � ��� ��� ��� � � � � � � � ��� � � ����� � � � � � �

R�H�WXj�EmV�;+��;J=YWGDS=YE�D2H�?AB�@F=>?�WGD:�Jf� ���� IKBCEG` WU=YE�`¤j2]\DqWX?C]\E�DFWGZ�=Y]\B�=Y@F]�?+WXDFTS@FHC;�?C_F; �Jf� ����hH?AE�HC_2E�� rFBCEGr�;>B�?A]^;YH>n+"qE�BJ]^DFH�?AWGDF=>;GeF?A_2; ;F��@F]^VXWGZ^;YDF=>; ��]�?A_�EG?C_F;YBJ=>]\BC=>@F]^?CHYn�|�����,<=$4!F� &q� 2 �c;YB�]^I �¤?C_qWX?c?A_F;J? ��E =>]\BC=>@F]^?CHc]\D &q[�@FB�;�ltM�WGB�; 1I,"��;u��@F]^VXWGZ^;YDN? @FHC]^DF[3�Jf� ����hHYn"w]\D2T�WGD ]^DFrF@2?J?C_qWX?�B�;>?A@2BCDFHTF]! �;YB�;YDN?E�@2?CrF@2?AH�]^D�?C_F;�? ��Ea=Y]^BC=>@F]^?CHYn

Page 31: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���X�@�����5� -� ���� � � �5�;����+���t� � ��� �u��� q� � � �n ¡G£

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

) � *

) � *

"w]\[G@FBC;¤ltM2z�����Ey=Y]^BC=Y@2]^?AHJ@2HC;YT(]\D�; �2;>BC=>]\HC;��2n ¡

Page 32: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ����T���}�b�t�|�O�b�~� � �u��� � � � �n ¡!l

� �� �

�-�� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

"w]\[G@FBC;hOG£2z p ]^Z\DF;>B6� H * =�_F;>TF@FZ^;YB���]^?C_�LS=>��=YZ^;YB�HYnc�J_F;h?AEG�G;YD�]^H�rqWGH�HC;YT(=YZ^E!=�� ��]^HC;�IKB�E�` �?p ?AE ��s?AE ��v?CE �)y�WGDFT(jqWG=���?CE �?p� � �8������ �3<��60 . 2��$<�� � � � � =

fhDF;JEGIk?A_F;J`yW���E�B+@2HC;YH EGI �Jf� ����hH+]^H�]\D-C?,"��U !$#��$&J��3 �wG0!$��3K,"1qn��xDSIKE�BC`yWGZ!VG;YB�]!&q=YWX?A]^E�DaW�`aE�TF;YZEGI�W H���H�?A;>`� ]^H�[�]�V�;YDy?AE�[�;i?A_F;>B ��]^?C_1HCEG`y;UrFBCE�rk;YB�?A]^;YH� HC@2rFr�EGHC;YT1?CE¤_FE�Z^T�IKE�Bc?A_F;�H���H�?C;Y`(n�J_F;J?�WGH��¤]\H�?AE�TF;>?C;YB�`y]^DF;���_F;>?C_F;YB ]\D2TF;Y;>T�� HAW-?A]\H�I � �nw�J_F;UWGrFr2BCENWG=�_ ��;?AWG�G;Xe�]\D��_F]^=�_ ��;HC_qWXZ\Z @2HC; WGD(WGZ\[GE�BC]�?A_F` ?AE�WXDFH ��;YB�?A_F;�HCWX?A]^H�I4WG=i?A]^E�D�rFBCEGjFZ\;>` e!]\H�EGI ?C;YD�=tWXZ\Z\;>T U�,7N�&J#OG)�B&)G�1"3V1�RGn��;aHC_qWXZ\Z�Z\E�E��6WX?�W(=>E�DF=YB�;>?C;�;��2WG`arFZ^;a=YWGZ\Z^;YT���3V#%1I&J��� ( ? G)�B&0N$��#/&J� o ?AWG�G;>D IKB�E�` p ]^Z\DF;>B6� H

j�E�E�� � p ]\Z\P�M�� uin �J_F;�`aE!TF;>Z�=>E�DFHC]^H�?CHSEGI�� GJm GJ#/&J�a(iec=YEGDFDF;Y=i?A;>T�]^D W BC]^DF[Fe+?A_FWX?S=YE-vxE�rk;YBCWX?A;>HE�D H�?AWGB�?C]\DF[#WGD2T T2;>?A;>=>?C]\DF[#?A;>BC`a]\DqWX?C]\E�D EGI � ?AWGHC��HS?A_FWX?aWGBC;�D2EG?SIK@FB�?C_F;YB�TF;>HC=>BC]\jk;YT n �J_F;HC=�_F;>TF@FZ^;YB�`¤@FH�?�`yWG�G; H�@FBC; ?C_qWX?y?A_F; � ?AWGHC��H�WGB�; WGZ ��Wt��H1H�?AWGB�?C;YT ]\D E�BCTF;>B1jF@2?�?A_F;i� WGB�;WGZ\Z^E ��;>T(?CEa?C;YBC`a]\DFWX?A;�]^D6WGDN�(E�B�TF;YB>n��J_F]\H�]^HUE�D2;�EGI�?A_F; rFB�E�r�;>B�?C]\;YH�?A_FWX?_qWGH�?AEaj�; HC_FE ��D6?CE_FE�Z^T IKE�B�?A_F;�`aE!TF;>Z n¤�J_2;y=i�!=>Z\;>BCH�?AB��6?AE�IK@FZ!&FZ\Z�?C_F]\H�jN�#rqWXHCHC]^DF[ W�?CE��G;>Dsz�?A_F;�_FE�Z^TF;YB�EXI�?A_2;?AE��X;YD(]\H�?C_F;�E�DFZ^��rFBCE�=Y;>HCHUWGZ\Z^E ��;>T�?CE�H�?�WXB�?]^?CH�?�WGH��knR�Z\Z =>��=YZ^;YBCHWGB�;�HC]\`a]\Z\WGB ;��!=Y;>r2?U?C_qWX?E�DF;�EGI|?A_2;Y` _qWXH�?C_F;�?AE��X;YD ]\D1?A_2; ]^DF]^?C] WGZkH�?AWX?A;Xnc�J_F;

=>��=YZ^;YB�H�GJm G % esl�� � ��� WXBC;�TF;>HC=YB�]\jk;YT�]\D1W¤H�?�W-?A;iv�jqWGH�;YT�I4WGHC_F]^E�D�WGHJH�`�WXZ\Zg?ABAWXDFHC]�?A]\EGD1H���H�?C;Y`aHEmV�;YB�?C_F;� �E�E�Z^;tWGDaVGWXBC] WXjFZ\;>H f % :�� % eqWGDFT � % n��J_2;hVGWXBC] WXjFZ\; f % ]\HUl���_F;YD�?AWGHC� ��]\H�BC@FDFD2]\DF[SWXDFT�£��_F;YD6]^?]\H�?A;>BC`a]\DqWX?C;YTq� � % ]^H�l���_F;>D =>��=YZ^;YB � _qWGH�Wa?CE��G;>Dse £aEG?A_2;YB ��]^HC;�� � % ]^H�l3��_F;YD =i��=YZ\;>B����lS_qWGH�rF@!?�TFE ��D ?A_F;¤?CE��G;>D WXDFT#=>��=YZ^;YB ��DFEX?h��;i?�r2]\=��G;>T#]^?�@Fr n �;YDF=>;yW1=i��=YZ\;>BhH�?AWGB�?CH�W?�WGH��¤jN��=�_qWGDF[G]\DF[ f % IKBCE�` £�?CEyl�e�WXDFTyT2;>?A;>=>?CH�]^?CH+?A;>BC`a]\DqWX?C]\E�D��_2;YD f % ]^HcWG[NWG]^Da=�_FWGDF[�;>T�jqWG=��?AEa£��kWGDFT(]^?�r2]\=���HU@2r ?A_2;�?CE��G;>D6jN��=�_qWGD2[�]\DF[ � % IKB�E�` l�?AEy£yWXDFT r2@2?AH]^?�TFE ��D j���=�_FWGDF[�]^DF[� % �=p�IKB�E�` £¤?AE�l�n��J_2;�jk;Y_qWtV�]\EG@FB�EGIw=i��=YZ\;>B � ]^HJTF;YH�=YB�]\jk;YT(j���? ��Ea?ABAWXDFHC]�?A]\EGDFHYz

$�} � % g l L f % g £ E x5�v� f % : � % :�� % ��� l�:�£�:Yl$�} � % g l E x5�v� � � %������ � � �=pJ:�� % ��� l�:�£

�J_F;a`y;YWGDF]\D2[(EXI�W�?CBAWGD2HC]^?C]\E�D $ $%} G),"1YN$3V��3K,"1 E xD�"� !"()(J3@R$1BU�&J1B� & ]^H�?A_qWX?Ye�]�I�?C_F; G),"1YN$3V��3K,"1 ]\H?AB�@F;S]\D H�E�`y;SH�?�WX?C;Ge<?A_2;YD ?A_F;�H��!H�?A;>` =tWGD#;>VGE�Z^VG;S?AE�W�DF;$� H�?AWX?A;Srk;YB�IKE�BC`a]\DF[y?A_F; o rFWGBAWGZ^Z\;>Z u!"()(J3@R$1BU�&J1B�/n �;YDF=>;Ge]^Ih?C_F; H���H�?A;Y` ]\Hy]\D W H�?�W-?A; ��_2;YBC; � % ]^H6l WXDFT f % ]^H1£ ?C_F;YD ��; =YWGDHC]^`¤@FZ^?AWGDF;>E�@FHCZ���H�;>? f % ?AE�l�e � % ?AEy£�WGDFT � % ?CE lGn

Page 33: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ����T���}�b�t�|�O�b�~� � �u��� � � � �n ¡�O

�J_F;J?ABAWXDFHC]�?A]\EGDFH�WGB�;;>DF=YE�TF;>TyjN��W�HC]^DF[�Z^;JrFBC;>TF]\=YWX?A;JEmV�;>B ?C_F;�VXWGZ\@2;JEGI�?C_F;JVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H+jk;>IKE�B�;?A_F;y?ABAWXDFHC]�?A]\EGDFH o ?A_F; WY�)&J]K(J�K!$�^&Cu�WGDFT%?C_F;�VXWGZ^@F;YH WXI ?A;>B ?A_F;y?ABAWXDFHC]�?A]\EGD o ?C_F;�WB,.(J�4]K(J�n!$�^&Cuin6�J_F;VXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�]\Da?A_F;rFBC; vxH�?�WX?C;hWGB�;?C_F; f % :�� % : � % :tl�� ���� ��_2]\=�_@��;�H�_qWGZ^Zk=>E�Z\Z^;Y=i?A]^VG;YZ��SBC;iIK;YBc?AE¤WXH�8 WGD2T(]^D�?A_F;�rkE�H�?�vxH�?AWX?A; f^�% :�� �% : � �% :tl�� �� � e ��_F]^=�_ ��;�H�_qWGZ^ZsBC;iIK;YBJ?AEyWGH �8 � n bcWG=�_ ?CBAWGD2HC]^?C]\E�D]\H�WGD�WX?AEG`y]^=SWG=>?C]\E�D#?A_FWX? ;��!=YZ^@FTF;YH WGDN�#EG?A_2;YB WG=>?C]\E�D ny�J_F;>BC;iIKE�BC;y]\D ?A_F;a;YD2=YE�TF]\DF[ ��;yH�_qWGZ\ZEGI ?A;>D�_qWtV�;�?AE�HCWm�y?A_qW-?W¤Z\EG?�EGI�VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YH�WGBC;�@2DF=�_qWGDF[G;YTsncR�H�HC@F`a;�?A_qW-?[� ]^HJW¤HC@Fj2HC;>?EGI|?A_2;@FDFrFB�]\`a;YT1VXWGB�] WGjFZ^;YH �8�n+� ;�HC_qWGZ^Zs@FH�; WSrFB�;YTF]^=tWX?C;�� 1IG)��!$1�R�&0N � EmV�;YB �8;: �8 � ��_F]^=�_ ;>DFHC@FB�;YH�?A_qW-?WGZ\ZkVXWGBC]\WGjFZ\;>H�]\D � WGBC;�@FDF=�_FWGDF[�;>Tsn���?]^HJTF;$&qD2;YT WXH�IKEGZ\Z\E ��H>z

��1IG)��!$1�R�&0N � g�� ��� .��� �8ug�8 � >

��?(]\H�HCZ^]\[�_N?CZ^� `aE�B�; =YE�DNV�;>DF]\;>DN?6?AE @FH�; ?C_F;#rFBC;>TF]\=YWX?A;[!"()(J3@R$1I&0N � � g � 1IG)��!$1�R�&0N��� � � ��_2]\=�_;��!rFB�;YHCH�?C_qWX?�;>V�;>B��yVGWXBC] WXjFZ\;A1I,"��]^D � � ]^H�@FD2=�_qWGDF[�;>Tsnc��;U=tWGD�DFE ��TF;�&qDF; % e�?C_F;�?CBAWGDFH�]^?C]\E�DFHEGI�=>��=YZ^;YB �cE9VG;YBJ?A_2;�VXWGB�] WGj2Z\;YH �8}: �8 � WXH�IKEGZ\Z\E ��H>z

% g�� ��� o � % L S f % L f^�% L S � �% L � �% L�!"()(J3@R$1I&0N �� �� � � � � � � � uP o � % L � � � %��� � � � �=p L S � �% L�!"()(J3@R$1I&0N �� �� � �� ������� � � � � � u�J_F;6H�]\[�DFWGZ\Z^]\DF[#EGIh?C;YB�`y]^DqWX?A]^E�D EGIh?�WXHC� �Ce�jN� =�_qWGDF[�]^DF[ f % IKBCE�` l ?CE £ rk;YB�IKE�BC`a;YT j�� ?A_2;;YDNV�]\B�E�DF`a;YDN?�]\H�`aE!TF;>Z\;>T�j�� � ?CBAWGDFH�]^?C]\E�DFH�� % :� � ����"!

� % g�� ��� f % L S f �% Lj!"()(J3@R$1I&0N � � � � :# �%$'& #)(*(,+.-'/1032'#�0 &34 -'(,+50*+.67-'( $%} f % g8 E8xD�"� f % !hg:9%;+C 6=<?> 4 0 4 -A@B/7+5CD#)-E(,0 4 03#?032'#?(,@F(G03#)HJI 4 -$ # &,K 6 & HL67-'#M6 K 0*2'#N0 &34 -'(*+�03+.6D-'( K�& 67HL6D-'#O6 K 032'# %�P (Q6 & 032'# � %RP (S>%+ ; # ; > 4DT5TU$ 6D(*(*+5V T #W0 &34 -'(,+50*+.67-'(4D& #�/D+5C7#S-XV@B0*2'# $'& #SY'+.I 4 03# �Z!

� g�� �[� �pqP �����?P O~+P\�-p;P�������PX�+~+>] -X0*2'#^+5-'+50*+ 4DT (G0 4 0*#Z<Q# 4 (,(*_'H1#`0*2 4 0 4DT.T 0 4 (*aA( 4b& #Z(,036 $'$ #SYc>d-�6eIS@FI T # & 2 4 ( 4 036DaD#)- 4 -'Yf67- T @$'Tg4 I)# ih �?p,j 2 4 ( 4 0367ab#)- ;Ok #)-�I)#^0*2'#l+.-�+503+ 4DT (G0 4 0*#^I 4 -fVm#`In2 4D&*4 IS0*# & + � #SYfV@X0*2'# $'& #)Y'+5I 4 0*#^o6=C7# & 0*2'#?_'- $'& +.H1#)YpC 4D& + 4 V T #S( �8 /D+5C7#S-XV@ !

o g�� �[� S �f L S���L �?p;L S ��stL �����.L S � ��>

hqk # & # S 4D$'$�T +.#SYp036 4 C7#SIS0*6 & �f Hr# 4 -'(N032'#ZI)67-ts,_'-'IS0*+.67-X6 K S 4b$'$'T +5#)Yp0361# 4 In2fI)6F6 & Y�+.- 4 0*# f % ;ujv 2'# $'& #SY'+.I 4 03#S(NY'#)(,I & +5V'+.-�/ewE+ T -�# & P (yx%In2'#SY'_ T # &M4D& #?(*_�HrH 4D& + � #SYp+.-pzU/7_ & #`{ 7;

| +5032�+.-B032�+.(W(*#�03_ $ <}#ZI)6D_ T Yi(,0 4D& 0 4 (*aA+.-'/ 4~T 6D0�6 K�� _'#S(,0*+.67-'( ;}� 6 & #�� 4 H $�T #D> 7;M��4 -"<}#~zU-�Y 4p$'& #SY'+.I 4 03#1��6tCD# & 032'#�_'- $'& +5Hr#SY�C 4D& + 4 V T #)(OIn2 4D&34 IS03# & + � +.-�/E#�� 4 IS0 T @�032�#(G0 4 0*#)(N032 4 0NI 4 -EVm# & # 4 In2'#SY K�& 6DH�o%�\��+5(WI 4DT5T #SYi0*2'#?(*#�0y6 K �a&0!�G)��!657#/&-(J�K!$�b&)(�;

{ ;Nk 6t<�H 4 -@ & # 4 In2 4 V T #Z(G0 4 0*#)( 4D& #?0*2'# & #=�� ;W] (M+50�0*2'#?I 4 (,#Z0*2 4 0N+5- 4bT.Td& # 4 In2 4 V T #?(G0 4 0*#)(M67- T @e67-'#�036DaD#)-E+.( $�& #)(,#)-0��� ;W] (N0 4 (,a f % 4DT < 4 @F(M6D- T @e(,0 4b& 03#SY 4�K 03# & f % Bp �

Page 34: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � ����������� ������ � ��� � ����� � ��� �D�

������� �!��"�#%$ � & � ���(' ��� �*) & ),+�.-�-/0"!��#%$ � � & � ��� ������� �!��"�#%$ ��� � �21 & � ��� h �315476�891 4:8 +1 476 � +1 4 � +1 4 �.-�-/0"!��#%$ �� � � � � � � j; h �<1 4 � +1 �� � � �>= 476� +1 4 �.-�-/0"!��#%$ � �� �����@? � � � j��1 & � ��� 891 4A6�8 +1 4 �.-�-/0"!��#%$ � �� & � ��� B=9CD1EC5F 21 ; ��1o & � ��� 6 G82476 GH 4AIJ=K476*I3LM4ONJNJNJ4A6*IF

� +./D_ & #`{ 7! wX+ T -'# & P (�x%In2�#)Y'_ T # &O4 (yY�#)(*I & +5Vm#SYfV@E0*2'#`0 &34 -�(*+50*+.67- $'& #)Y'+5I 4 0*#QP 4 -'YX0*2'#`+5-'+50*+ 4DTSR(,0 4 03# $'& #)Y'+5I 4 0*#�o ;

T ;�U 6F#)(QwX+ T -'# & P (}xFIn2'#)Y'_ T # &Q$ 6D(*(*#S(*( 4 Y'# 4 Y T 6%Ina%� ]n; # ; >F+.( 032'# & # 4Z& # 4 In2 4 V T #N(G0 4 0*#y+5-�<N2�+.In2-'6�0 &*4 -'(,+503+567-'(�I 4 -EVm#�0 4 aD#)-U�

v 6 4 -'(,<Q# & 0*2'#)(,# � _�#)(,0*+.67-�(l<}#Bz & (,0~2 4 CD#B036�IS67H $ _�03#p� ;�] -0*_'+50*+5C7# T @D> �JH^_'(,0~V #e0*2'#B(*#�06 K (G0 4 0*#)(O0*2 4 0�#S+50*2'# & ( 4 03+5( K @Eo hq4D& #^+5-'+50*+ 4DTgj 6 & <N+�032'+5- 4 z'-'+50*#^-A_'HlV # & 6 K P80 &34 -�(*+50*+.67-�(yI 4 -Vm# & # 4 In2�#)Y K�& 67H o ; v 2�+.(W(*_�/7/7#)(G0 4 -i+503# &34 0*+5CD# 4DT /D6 & +�032'H K 6 & IS67H $ _�03+5-'/�� 4 ( 4 -i+.-'I & # 4 (*+.-�/In2 4 +5-X6 K 4D$'$'& 6=�%+5H 4 0*+.67-�(N�WVJXn� = XZYZY�Y�Xn�W[.XZYZYZY xA03# $]\ 6 K 032'# 4DT /76 & +50*2'H zU-'Yf(G0 4 0*#)(y0*2 4 0N<N+50*2T #S(*( 032 4 - \ 0 &*4 -'(*+�03+567-'( I 4 -eVm# & # 4 In2'#)Y K�& 67H o ; k #S-'I)#b>�<}#M0 4 ab#�� V & 9 0*2'#OIS67-'(,0 4 -0 T @ K 4bT (*#$'& #SY'+.I 4 03# 4 -'YiI)67H $ _�0*#?� [�^ = 4 (�032'#?Y'+5(�s,_'-�IS03+567-p6 K o 4 -�Yi0*2'#?(*#�0y6 K (G0 4 0*#)(W<N2'+5In2 K�& 67H�67-�#0 &*4 -'(*+�03+567-B6 K P�I 4 -XV # & # 4 In2'#)Y K�& 67H � [ ; � +5/7_ & #�{7{�+ T.T _'(,0 &34 0*#)(Q0*2'#?I)67H $ _�0 4 03+567-p6 K � ;

k 6=<�Y'6~<Q#`IS67H $ _�03#�0*2'+.(�<N+�032`_�a�b U�U (n� | #?(G0 4D& 0M<N+�032p032�#c_da�b U�U � & 9 ;fe 0 4 -A@$ 6D+.-0 +.-~0*2'#NI)67H $ _�0 4 03+567-l032'#M-'#��%0 4D$�$'& 6��%+.H 4 03+567-~+.( IS67H $ _�03#SYrV@l0*2'#NY'+.( s,_'-'I�03+.6D-16 K o 4 -'YP I)67H $ 6D(*#)Yp<N+�032e0*2'# $'& #�CF+.67_'( 4b$'$'& 6��%+.H 4 0*+.67-r� + ; | # 4D& #�Y�67-'#O<N2'#S-p032'#�IS_ &*& #)-0 4 -'Yp032�#$'& #�CF+.67_'( 4D$�$'& 6��%+.H 4 03+567-'(QI)67+5-'I)+5Y'# !gih,jlkKmlj�n�oDh p�q>r�j<rlhtsAh otX%P�X G) X G),+ j 7! �vu 9

{ ! wyxDz*xD{ |� ! � + u �� ! �vu o ; h~} G) Y P 4 � j�� G)>� G) +��T ! ���>|y��� � + & �� ! wyx�|y�2w�� �

����� ��������� �<� � ��� �� (,+.-'/E032'#r( 4 H1#e#S-'I)6FY'+.-�/\6 KN4 In2'#)(,(~Vm6 4b& Y 4 (^+.- (*#SIS03+567- � ;� > T #S0,03+5-'/ ) 1�� & Y�#)-'6D0*#e032�#$'& #S(*#S-'I)#�6 K 4�� -'+5/720 4 0 $ 67(,+50*+.67- h�� X9� j <Q#OI 4 -e(,6 T CD#y6b032'# &Q$'& 67V T #)H1( ;�| #yI 4 -e#S-'I)6FY'#yHr6=C7#S(6 KN47� -'+5/720 4 (^0 &*4 -'(*+�03+567-'( ;X� 6 & # 4 In2 $ 67(*+�03+567-c>� \Hr6=CD#)( 4D& # $ 67(*(,+.V T #e+ K 032'#�@ (G0 4 @ 67- 032�#Vm6 4D& Y ;�e¡� -'+./D2A0 4 0 h�� X9� j I 4 -BVm#yHr6=CD#)Ye0*6 4 -@r67-'#O6 K h��D¢ X9� ¢ { j X h��D¢ {5X9� ¢ tj}4 (,(*_'H1+.-�/032'#�@ 4D& #lC 4 I 4 -0 4 -'Y�<N+50*2'+.-f0*2'#�Vm6 4D& Y�V 67_'-'Y 4b& @ ;�� 6 &?4bT.T�� X9� 4 -'Y \ X�£Q<N+�032 ¥¤¦\ X§£ ¤©¨4 -'Y h~\ X�£ j�ª¬«%h��­¢: X9� ¢ { j X h��­¢ {�X9� ¢ =j3®A!

¯°1±��² [§³ &W´¶µ0· ) 1±�M476 ) [ ² ³ 476 ) +1±� 4 ) + [§³ 4 ¸¹ 1»º¼² ��º¾½À¿Áy ¹ 1E² �ýIJ ¹ [ ² ³ ½EÅ )1�º���º & ) +1»º���º Y

Page 35: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � ����������� ��������]��������������� � � �

Full state space

� ������

���

�� � �

����� _����Z{7{�� x%a��! #"%$�&('�")&+*-,�./ #0� � &+12&('� 3$��4�3�)0("%$50(6�7���8� #0� #�!89 �!1�")��:; 3$��� #�30(1�8 � � &+1�8<0(��� �+��= �)1�0(8< #$��4,����)> � "?0� 3��PA@ G) X G),+CB �

PA@ G) X G) + B &W´¶µS· B=9CD1E² ��² [ ² ³ C5F�² ¹ [ ² ³ ½ ÁJ ¹ 1ED>=9² �3D<L�½ ² ¹ 1CD<L%² ��D>=À½Eů°1±��² [§³

FHGlxDwJI��LK x�MONQPSR3T`���VUXW>|ZY[K |]\­��w+^X| � � 3�_0`,��3& � �#0(*a #&�83&+7 = �b 3$��_'V&+7c7�&ed � 1 � ,/�3&+6�7��)*f.�8 � 1 � #$�� _�a�b U�U R ,50("%gJ0 � ���ihj8 � 4,X&+838 � 6�7��k'V&+�i0 � 1 �c� $l ):m,O&+8 � � &+1��!>n0� o 3$��-7c&]dp�!�47c�!'q i"!&+�31��!�i 3&=r� 8 � s0(7c7t,O&+8 � � &+1�8<&(1u0(1 ¨wv]¨ 6X&Z0(��>��x@jy /Ä�5z|{ � &(*},�.� #� � 3�)�#0J ��= �)7[~_0(7�7t #$��i,X&+8 � � &(1�8� #$50J "?0(126X�4�3�?0�"%$��)>�6l~_ 3$�� � 1 �c� $Z )� B�� ��~ � �'V&+� = 0(� � &+.�8 ¨ �FHGlxDwJI��LK x�MON�� | $Z~2>�&��!8< #$��i0(7 � &+� � #$�* gih,jlkKmlj�n�oDh p�q>r�j<rlhts 0(7�dp0?~�8< 3�)�3* � 1�0� #���FHGlxDwJI��LK x�MON�� hj1� 3$ � 8s�����)��" � 83�od���8�$50(7�7md�&+��gbd � #$fw � 7�1��)�!��8yx�"%$/�)>�.�7��)�s'V&+� ¨ & � �<h| � 8�6l~'Q0(��6O�p 3$��p*-&+8� �")&(1 = �)1 � �)1Z � #&H83&+7 = �� 3$������/�!�3" � 83�p6l~o.�8 � 1 � 0�1 � *-,�7c�!*}�!1Z %0� � &+14&('X0(1 _�a�b U�U,50("%gJ0 � ���

{O^���� 1/>2 3$��4�3�)0("%$50(6�7��48� %0J #�)8s0(8s0(1`_�a�b U�U �A�� ^���� 1�>_ #$��41l.�*A6X�)��&('��3�)0("%$50(6/7c�48� #0� #�!8)�I�^ x�$�&]d� 3$50� � 1}0�7c7/���?0("%$�0(6�7c�<8� %0� 3�)8�0� �*-&+8� �&+1��� #&(g(�)1 � 8�,/�3�)8��)1Z �&+1-0(1Z~k&('X #$��

,�7c0(")�!$�&+7�>��)��8 IZ= XZY�YZY�X IF 6Z~`'V&+�3*�.�7�0� � 1 � 0�8�. � #0(6�7c�k,/�3&+,X�)�� j~���0(1�>n,��3& = � 3$50� M��� ���

Page 36: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� � �W���.�������,W����������� � Q������� �@T ^ x�$/&ed #$�0� � 1b0(7c7X�3�)0("%$50(6�7���8� #0� #�!8Mw � 7�1��)�!��8�x�"%$��)>/.�7c�!�<"?0(1�0(7[d�0?~r8�,X�)��'V&(�3* 0

3�#0(1�8 � � &+1 : � � �(�[: � �>/&��!8s1/&( �,O&(8383�!838H0 $�#%��$��� J��� �FHGlxDwJI��LK x�MON��8� &+*-,�7c� #�H 3$��40(6X& = �4�����)��" � 8��46l~b83$�&]d � 1 � 3$50� < 3$�� %0(8�gl8 0��3�40(7[d�0?~r8<8� #0(�� 3�)>� 1_8�� � .��)1/")���@Xn{5XZYZYZYX ¨ X��@X�{dYZYZYFHGlxDwJI��LK x�MON�� | � � 3��0-,��3& � �#0(* 3$50� �+��= �)1 0�1 ¨ 0�8 � 1/,�./ ")&+*-,�./ 3�)8 3$��i�3�?0�"%$50(6�7���8� #0� #�!8&('�� � 7�1��)�!��8Ex�"%$/�)>�.�7��)�2d � 3$ ¨ " ~�"!7c�!�38)� � $��n,��3& � �#0(* 83$�&(.�7c> d�� � #��&+./ _ 3$���1l.�*A6X�)�2&('�3�)0("%$50(6�7��o8� %0� 3�)8�@Q.�8 � 1 �`q�j r������ �lr B ��_s./1� #$/�o,���& � �30(* 'V&+� ¨ & {5X � X � X�  X!�#" XZYZY�Y$���)0(83.���� #$�����.�1�1 � 1 � � *-�)8�0�1�>}>/�#0?d 0 � �#0�,�$}8�$�&]d � 1 � #$/�s*-�?0�83.����)*-�)1Z #8�0(8�04'V./1�"! � &+1�&(' ¨ � | $50J � 8� 3$��i0(8�~r*-,/ #&( � " ��.�1�1 � 1 � � *-� &('�~+&(.���,��3& � �#0(*e�

% &('*),+.-�/10325476 8:9:;=<>< &@?�/BAC?EDF-

� $ � 8�,��3&HG��)"! � *-,�7c�!*}�!1l 38�0�83*}0(7c7;,50�"%g�0 � � &('�_�a�b U�U R &+,X�)�#0J � &(1�8)� � $��H'V.�7�7;,50("%gJ0 � � 8�$�&+.�7�>")&+1Z #0 � 1_ #$/�4'V&(7c7c&]d � 1 � &+,X�)�30� � &+1�8)�I����Ä| @KJ Bhj1 � � 0(7 ��L � 3$��4,50("%gJ0 � ��� � 83�J = 0(� � 0(6�7��)8<1l.�*A6X�)���)>M�i 3$��3&+. � $NJ��Ocw.���>| @QP BR � � 1Z �0H���),����)83�!1Z %0� � &+1A&�'5 #$�� _�a�b U�U &+1� 3$��p8� %0(1/>50(�3>�&+./ #,/./ ?� � 83� 'V.�7�'V&(��>��!6�. �+�(� 1 � �SUT @ � X�£9X H B_��! 3.��31� #$��<1l.�*�6O�!�*P &('O0�1�&r>���d � 3$WV �YX @QP B & � X �� [Z @QP B & £9X ��/0".� @QP B & H � � $ � 8�")&+.�7�>6X��0(14�]\ � 8� � 1 � 1�&r>��(:J&+� 0<1�� d�7�~ "!�3�)0� #�!>o1�&r>���� � $������)>�.�"!�)>�1/�)838�&('l #$���_da�b U�U 8�$�&+.�7�>

1�&� 6X� =r� &+7c0� #�!> �^i����� @ 8 B_ &+1/8� #��.�"! p0(1 _�a�b U�U 'V�3&+* 0�bp&�&(7c�?0�1k�]\�,��3�!838 � &+1 �a`�&(.-"!&+.�7�>-���)8� #� � "! �~+&(.��38��)7�'O #&� #$/�

�b\/,/�3�)8�8 � &+1�8 ) &+� 6 ) &+�dc51 � #��"!&+1[G�.�1/"! � &+1�8�&('� #$��!83��� @fe $l~�g Bh z�z��fi @ �j XkP = XlP L B_ &+1/8� #��.�"! s #$/�c_da�b U�U ���)83./7� � 1 � 'V�3&(*�0(,�,�7[~ � 1 � �j &+1mP = 0(1/>nP L �o¥xrK |Jw.�QI!| @KP2X9�@X�p B_��)8� #� � "! � #$/�c_da�b U�U Pu0(")"!&+�3> � 1 � #&� #$/�4 3�3./ 3$�0(838 �c� 1�*-�)1Z � p �y) � � �q {5|Yro\>���>| @QP B_��! 3.��31b 3$�� 1l.�*A6X�)��&�'m�)7c�!*}�!1Z #8 � 1 #$��H83�! -��(z @QP B ��@ � 83�40o j~r,X�H #$�0� <"?0�1b")&+1Z #0 � 1 = �)��~7c0(� � ��1l.�*�6O�!�38�83.�"%$u0(8ds5&Z0� � 1 � ,X& � 1l �1l.�*�6O�!�38)� Bh �ti q { | @QP B_��! 3.��31�0-830� � 8�'q~ � 1 � #�3.� #$�0(838 �c� 1�*-�)1Z <'V&+�dPu �Cv3wYx �,�ay{z � �hj*},/7c�)*-�)1Z < 3$��i #0(6�7��)8�P 0(1�>n| d � #$2 #$/� � ��&+,X�)�30� � &+1�8<7 � 8� 3�)> � 1283�!"! � &+1n}��da 1� #&+,�&('� 3$��)8��� *-,�7c�!*}�!1Z p #$/�i&(,O�!�#0� � &+1�83~ �.� r @QJ B :���� �f�lr @KP B :�0(1�>����p@ � X�£9X H B �

Page 37: University of Texas at Austinisil/cs389L/bdd.pdf · 2015-02-02 · L 0.%./= "!#!#$% ! & ' () * ,+- /. * ,+0! 1 2 3$4 5 6 87:9; " :9;$ 6?* +0! @ A BC

� ���M������� �M� � �!�u �Cv3wYx �,�ay{z ���_ &+1Z � 1r./� � *-,�7��)*-�)1Z %0� � &+1x&('� 3$��u,�0("%gJ0 � � 6Z~ 0(>�> � 1 � 3$��u&+,X�)�30� � &+1�8�� �.�Äo�� @ 8 B 0(1/>�� p o�� @ �j XkP = XkP L B �u �Cv3wYx �,�ay{z �� ��� 1 � 83$b~(&+.�� � *-,�7��)*-�)1Z %0� � &+1 &('� 3$��4,50("%gJ0 � �46Z~�0(>�> � 1 � gihtsyr � ����r @KP2X9�@Xkp B : q>j<r��C�a�.�lr @KP B :0(1�>�� ���fq>j<r @KP B �8 -�� -C'*-C6 /1-��

�±eH9���� � 9 �!1�� � g _s� � ' e 1�>��)��83�!1 0�1�> 9 �!1�� � g 9 .�7 � 0+0(��> � b�&�&+7��?0(1��]\�,����)8�8 � &(1n> � 0 � �30(*-8)��hj1� Xk J��#�#%$!/Ä��".-�� �.Z #]� ! z �#" �,�,� �Y��$&%'%(%*),+.- j$ J-/Ä�/-: .�10. %"!/~�c/Ä�32� .- j­�rz9#]X4)K�/~#����# :,50 � �)8� @ 65 �  /:�e 0(�3830]d4: R &+7�0�1�> :,7(.�1/�98 � 5:7(.�7�~#8W� �;��� ��h=<'<(< _ &(*},�.� #�)�?>�&r" � �! j~(�

� b���~5  � � _s0(1�>50(7,<<�5bp��~+0(1Z ?�A@��#0(,/$ R 650�83�)>}0(7 � &+� � #$�*-8�'V&+�fbp&r&+7c�)0(1k'V.�1�" � &(1}*}0(1 � ,�.�7�0J � &(1 �$�%'%'%B� XÃ�!� -���� z�/ .� -, .�C2� .- j­�rz�#]X§- :, �@ _ R �@T B � � �;� 5 � � �+:t� �   � �

� b���~ � 8 � _s0(1�>50(7;<��yb���~Z0�1l )�D>r~r*A6X&+7 � "*bp&r&+7c�)0(14* 0(1 � ,�.�7c0� � &+1 d � #$4&+��>��)���)>i6 � 150���~ R >��!" � 8 � &(1> � 0 � �#0�*}8!� "92FE 2� .- jHGrz�/�IDJ),G X VLK +J- :,8 };@ � B �M8 � � 5 � �J /:N>��),� #�)*�6O�!�� �;� 8��

� _ b �A  � � a 7 �[=�� �)� _ &(.�>��)�� ?: _ $�� � 8� � 0(1Obp�)�� #$�� ?:�0(1�>O7(�?0(1 _ $�� � 8� #&(,�$�� �u0(>����(�P��)� � c5"?0J � &(1&('�8�~r1�"%$/�3&+1�&(.�8 8��RQl.��!1l � 0(7t* 0("%$ � 1��!8<650(83�!>2&+1_8�~r*A6X&+7 � " �]\��!")./ � &+1 ��hj1�7/�,> � 'Q0�g � 8):�)> � #&(�): "�G�z .-S(z�/UTOV K X/ WXTYS(z�/ .IZE K z\[$ R].-^!� [X9_�/�I,/qz K );zUS(z K ),+J- z K -�-R` � Xk aT K�K ]!/�IDJ.- := &(7c.�*-�C} " � &(' 0cbd2e) :5,50 � �)8 �@��T 5 � � � �N>�,�� � 1 � �!� R P��)�37c0 � :�� �   � �

� _Xf _ � " � � $�&+*}0(8 9 � _ &+��*}�!1 : _ $50(��7c�)8?<<� f � � 8��)��83&+1 :O0(1�>`_�&+150(7�> f �t_ ��= �!8� )� $�I5zKXk R]LG,T z�/ .Iz g" �hJ{ [X/qz�[D-�- � ��"i@4�30]d Rj9 � 7c7 :�� �;� "/�

� _ &r& � � � >O� e � _ &r&+g;� � $���")&+*-,�7c�b\ � j~ &�'� 3$��)&+���)* R ,���& =�� 1 � ,��3&r")�!>�.����)8)�lhj1 � X� aT K�K ]!/�IDJ.-B =!�z�[ K�j[�/fXk]l"�ImImGNSY�A"92FE ),+.- j$ J-/�G/- .I z�[ K �j[ K [Xn+ =!�2� .- jHGrzÀ/�IDJ :m,50 � �)8 � T ��5�� T  /:o � d `�&+��g;: � ��� �+� e 838�&�" � 0� � &+1b'V&(� _ &+*},/./ � 1 � �u0("%$ � 1��)��~+�

� � � 7   � � _�&+6 � 1n� � 7c1��!�)� 2� .-d-dGDI,/UTYS(z�/ .IpSLIH]12� .I�T�G{X]X K I�T�+ � R �3�!1l � "!� 9 0(7c7L: � �   � �