University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al...

64

Transcript of University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al...

Page 1: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

���������������� �������������������������������� ��!#"$ &%'�(")�����������*%+����,�����-(!���./���01�2��"3%+��4��6587

9;:=<�>@?BAC?EDGFB>@?B>@HJIK>$L

MJN

�PO#��.Q,�RS����"

TVU M�W AXIYIY>@L�IKZ1IY<�>'[\FY]^L U ]_IY> Ta` <�ZVZcbZ^d#IK<�>e HfAXgc>$FY?BAXI N Z^dihj]^?B?K] ` < U ?B>$IBIK?�9 W <�>$FY?kIEAXHml2]^FBIYAn]^b�d U bXo�bCb W >@HJI

Z^d#IK<�>\FY>$p U ACFB> W >@HJIK?=dqZcFrIY<�>\L�>@scFB>@>tZ^d

u&�#.v ������w*7�� �������������&x�")��� ����y��"3�����{z|�(4��! ����x}�#�(���#����������

9}l�FBACb�~_�c�J�

� bC> ` IKFBA ` ]^b]^H�L3��Z W l U IY>@F � H�scAXH�>@>$FYACHfs

Page 2: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

`� ��Zcl N FBACsc<JI MJN 9}��]^?B<�[|Za>$b�~^�c�c�

9EbCb��ACs^<)IY?���>$?Y>$FBgc>$L

Page 3: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

���������������� �������������������������������� ��!#"$ &%'�(")�����������*%+����,�����-(!���./���01�2��"3%+��4��6587

9;:=<�>@?BAC?EDGFB>@?B>@HJIK>$L

MJN

�PO#��.Q,�RS����"

9}lfl�FYZvgc>$L�]^?=IYZP?kI N bC>']^H�L ` ZcHJIY>@HJI MJN��

�}��hj]^HfA��\FBAC?B<�H2]f����<�]^ACF

� ?YFY]^>@b��|ZcFB>@H���h�> W�M >@F

��?K] M ]P9EH�L�FY]^?Eh3ZcFYA�IK�_��h3> W�M >@F

T >$?Y< U�� ����>@? U ����>@l2]^FkI W >@HJI��E>@]^L� bC> ` IYFYA ` ]^b]^HfLj��Z W l U IK>@F � H�scAXH�>@>$FYAXH�s

Page 4: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

:�Z W+N l2]^FY>$HJIK?

Page 5: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

�+��O(������")���#�i4���� .

��� Z U bXLSbXAC�^>rIYZ'>��al�FY>$?Y? W'N L�>$>@l8]_l�l�FY> ` AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD�FYZ^d��G�}�Vh3]^H�A��|FYAC?B<�H2]\]^H�LSD�FYZ^d��

� ���|ZcFB>@H8dqZcF�IK<�>$ACF ` ZcH�?kI�]^HJI�>$H ` Z U FK]^sc> W >$HJI���? U l�l�ZcFBI�]_H�L�s U AXL2]^H ` >�L U FBACH�s+IY<�> ` Z U FY?B>

Z^d W+N h T � � ]^bX?YZ � AC?B<�IYZ�IY<2]^H���D�FBZ^d����\FBAC?B<�H2]�dqZcF1<�AX?Pl�]_IKAX>@H ` >�AXH�]^H�? � >@FBACH�s W+N

H U W >@FYZ U ?�p U >@?BIYACZcH � ��� Z U bCL�]^bX?YZ1bCAX�^>�IYZ IY<2]^H��8DGFBZ^d��¡�}��9+��h�ZcFYA�IK��dqZcF=FB>$gVAC> � ACH�s W+N

IK<f>@?YAX?G]^H�L dqZcFi?B<2]^FYAXH�s�g_]^b U ] M bC>�ACH�?BACsc<JIK?$� ��� Z U bCL bCAX�^>�IYZ\>¢�al�FY>$?Y? W+N s^FK]_IYAXI U L�>�IKZt£ Tf¤

dqZcF�IK<f>E? U l�l�ZcFBIYACH�s\IK<�AX? � ZcFB��� � ] W scFY]_IK>¢d U b�IKZ\¥�A§¦Y] N ]^H�L8�\] W >@?B<PdqZ^F¡<�>$bCl�AXH�s W >�Z U I

]_I W ]_H N Z `@` ]^?YAXZcH�?$� �r� Z U bXL�]^bX?YZPbCAX�^>\IKZSIY<2]^H�� W+N dqFBAC>$H�L�?�]�I e W ]^?B?�dqZ^F W ]^�)ACH�s W+N

?BIK] N � ZcH�L�>$FBd U b¨�G©#]_?BIKb N � ��� Z U bCL�bCAX�^>�IKZ+IY<2]^H�� W+N l2]^FY>$HJIK?�]^H�Lm��> MJN ]^H�A�dqZcF�IY<�>@AXF�bCZvg^>

]^H�L�? U l�lyZ^FBI�IK<�FBZ U sc<fZ U I W+N ?kI�] N <�>$FY>_�

g

Page 6: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

�Pª .v ����y

���������������� �������������������������������� ��!#"$ &%'�(")�����������*%+����,�����-(!���./���

01���#"3%+��4���5/7

�S����"¬«f­2­�®

�PO#��.Q,�RS����"

���#.v �n �!� ��*�(w¬%'��� ,#����"V���#¯�°�±t�#��#���#.8² ���#�#!´³ ���Cµ����.Q�n y¯�°i�����#�n�

u·¶n7i¶�x�¶nz ¶�x�°(³ ���Cµ����.��n �¯¸�(w�u&�#.Q.v���,�!�.��2 � �. �P4�,����.v

��ACFB> ` IY>@L MJN�� D�FBZ^dq>@?B?YZcF}�}��hj]^H�A��|FBAC?Y<fH2]

� W�M >@L�L�>$Lj? N ?kIK> W ?EZ^d�IK>$H3<2]�g^>'?B>$gc>$FY>'lyZ � >@FE]^H�Lj>$H�>@FBs N ` Z^H�?BIYFK]^AXH)IY?@�¡� N H2] W A ` gcZ^bXIB¹

]^sc>/? ` ]_bCACHfs�AC?+] W > ` <2]^H�AX? WºMJN � <�A ` <�>$H�>@FBs N ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH W ] N*M >8FB>@L U�` >@L��*��¥ T

AC? M ]^?Y>$L*ZcH¬IK<�>1d»] ` I\IK<2]_I ` l U�¼ ?'l�Z � >$F'AX?|p U ]^L�FY]_IKA ` ]^bXb N FY>@bC]_IK>$L�IYZ�gcZcb�I�]^sc>_� � <�ACbX>�AXIY?

?Yl�>@>$L¸AC?8bXACH�>@]^FYb N FY>@bC]_IK>$L�� � H�IK<�AX? � ZcFY� � >½A W lfbC> W >@HJI8]*L N H2] W A ` g^ZcbXIK]^sc>3? ` ]_bCACHfs

M ]^?B>@L3? ` <�>$L U bC>$FEAXHm>v��Zc?�Zcl�>@FK]�IKACHfsP? N ?BIK> W F U H�HfACH�s ZcHm¥GZcbXIK]^sc> TV` ]^bC] M bC> � HJIY>@b¾�? ` ]^bX>

� ZJ]_FYLS]^H�LP?Y<�Z � <�Z � >$H�>@FBs N U ?Y]^sc> ` ]^H M >�FB>@L U�` >@L � <fACbC>=?kIKAXbCb W >@>¢IKACHfst<�]^FYLPFY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >

L�>@]^L�bCAXH�>@?$�

� W�M >$L�L�>$L{? N ?kIK> W ?3]^FY>½Z_d�IK>@H¸? U M ¦B> ` IK>$L{IKZ�d»] U bXIK?�L U >�IKZ6<2]^FB?Y<�>@HJgVACFBZcH W >@HJI�]^b

` Z^H�L�AXIYACZcHf?@�=À*>'L�>@? ` FBA M >�]Sl�Z � >$F|] � ]_FY>'d»] U bXI�IKZcbX>@FY]^HJI}? ` <�>@L U bCACHfs8]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W dqZcFEFB>�]^b

IKA W >G? N ?kIK> W ]^H�L'?YA W U bn]�IK>GAXI#IKZEL�> W ZcH�?kIKFK]�IK>GIK<2]_I(FY>$bCAn] M ACbXAXI N Z^d�]E? N ?BIK> W ` ]^H M >¡IYFK]^L�>$L

dqZcFrIY<�>\lyZ � >@F ` ZcH�? U W lfIKAXZcH��

��<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s�AX?i] W > ` <�]^H�AC? W dqZcF�lfFYZvgVACL�AXH�sEd»] U bXI#IKZcbX>@FK]_H ` >�IKZ}IY<�>�? N ?kIK> W � � H'IK<�AX?

]^l�lfFYZJ] ` < �)]_I�>�] ` < ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJI��cIY<�>=? N ?BIY> W ?kI�]_IY>rAC?(?K]�gc>$L/]^HfL � <�>@HP]}d»] U b�IiAX?(L�>¢IK> ` IK>$L��

IK<f>P? N ?BIK> W AC?|FB>@?BIK]^FBIY>@L�dqFYZ W IK<�> W Zc?BI\FB> ` >$HJI ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJI��1À*> <2]�g^>SA W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L¬]

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sPbCA M FK]_F N dqZcF=FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >�]_l�l�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHf?rACHm�¡IYbCAXH U � �

gVA

Page 7: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

%��#ª ")�Á��w*z\�(� ��� .

D�]^sc>

��� O(������")�����i4}��� .àÂ�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ� g

�#ª .v ����y ÄÂ� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â� gVA

Å���.v ´5Pw¬%��#ª ")��.ÃÂ�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â� A��

Å���.v ´5Pw¬�����i!����.Æ Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â� �

z\,�#2 ���

Ç ¶m��È %+0�5PÉ/³/z\%'�$5PÈ Â Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â�  ÊÊ � Ê Ë gc>$FBgVAC> � ����� ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� ÊÊ �Ì~ ��ZcHJIYFYA M U IKAXZcHÍ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� ÎÊ �ÏÎ Ë U IYbCACHf>|Z^d(:=<f>@?YAX?������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Î

« ¶m%+xtz|² ÈP�$z��PÅб\�Pz\Ñ/RS0�5P³ È ÉÒÂ�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â� �~a� Ê � N H2] W A ` ¥GZ^bXI�]_sc> Ta` ]^bCAXH�sÓ������ ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� �~a�Ì~ ¤ ] U b�I�:�Z^bC>@FY]^H ` >·�������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ô~a�ÏÎ ©AXIY>@FY]_I U FB> TaU Fkgc> N ������ ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Õ

Ö ¶8×S5PÅ %��PRSxØ7#z��PÅ���È/RÙ�PÅ�R�5 01��%+² u ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â;Ê �Îf� Ê h3ZVL�>$bC?�]^H�L�:�>$F W ACH�Z^bCZcs N �������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê �

Îf� Ê � Ê :(]^?B�mh3ZVL�>@b����� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê �Îf� Ê �Ì~ D�Z � >$F�h�ZaL�>$b(��� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� ÊcÊ

Îf�Ì~ � N ` bXA `'Ta` <�>$L U bXACH�s ������ ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� ÊcÊÎf�ÏÎ 9EbCscZcFBAXIY< W ��� ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê ~

Îf�ÏÎf� Ê Ë g^>@FB<�>�]^Lf?������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê ÎÎf�ÛÚ � W l�bC> W >$HJI�]_IYACZcHm��>¢I�]^AXbC?Ü�������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê Ú

Îf�ÛÚ�� Ê �}]^FBL � ]_FY>tD�bn]_IBdqZcF W ���� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê ÚÎf�ÛÚ��Ì~ T Z^d�I � ]^FY>\9}F ` <�AXIY> ` I U FB>Ý� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê �Îf�ÛÚ��ÏÎ � W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H8Z^d � � ¤ AXH�>���Zc?����������� ����������� ���������� ��� ÊvÞÎf�ÛÚ��ÛÚ ¥GZcbXIK]^sc> Ta` ]^bCAXH�s ]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W AXH�>���Zc?=��������� ����������� ���������� ��� ÊvÞÎf�ÛÚ��Ì� ��>$? U b�IK?P���������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~^�

gaAXA

Page 8: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

à ¶m� ��³ Å�%|á�%15PÅ�x�0��PÈ %Ø×S5PÅ�%¡�PRSxÜ7�z|²Px}É/³ Å���È/RÙ�PÅ=R�5P01��%+² u  ~^ÎÚ�� Ê h3ZVL�>$b�]_H�Lm:�>$F W ACH�ZcbXZcs N �������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~_Ú

Ú�� Ê � Ê ¤ ] U bXI�]_H�L���> ` Zvgc>$F N h3ZVL�>@b ������ ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~_ÚÚ��Ì~ 9EbCscZcFBAXIY< W ��� ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~c�Ú��ÏÎ ��>@? U bXIY?´������� ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~c�

® ¶m��u´��Å¡x�u´x�È %��E%+�$5PÈâ5 �ãz\² xtz|Ñ8�t5P��È %+��È/RÝ��ÈÒ0�%15871ÂÂ� Â�Â�Â� ~ Þ�a� Ê � HJIKFBZaL U�` IYACZcH ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~ Þ�a�Ì~ e ?K]^sc>{�������� ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎ Ê�a�ÏÎ � W l�bC> W >$HJI�]_IYACZcH�L�>¢I�]^AXbC?'���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎ Ê

�a�ÏÎf� Ê DGFBZcscFY] W ��Z U H)IY>@F�9}L�¦ U ?BI W >@HJI�� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎJ~�a�ÏÎf�Ì~ T I�] ` � T >@s W >@HJI(����������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎJ~�a�ÏÎf�ÏÎ ��>$scAC?kIK>@FB?��������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎcÎ

�a�ÛÚ :#FK]^Hf?Bdq>@F�Z^di��<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIY>@L T I�]_IY>½���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎ^Ú�a�Ì� ��> ` ZQg^>@F N lfFYZ ` >@?B?´������ ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎ^Ú�a�Ïå � �aly>$FYA W >$H)IK]^bFY>$? U b�IK?�]^H�L3]^H2]_b N ?YAX?*������ ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎJ��a�ÌÔ ©A W AXIK]_IKAXZcH�?Á� ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���äÎcå

æ ¶jz+5PÈ/z|Å�³/7 �$5PÈ/7��SÈ Éç��³ %+³ 01xÍÉ/��01xtz|%+�$5PÈ/7¸Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â� ÎJÔ

01��wf�����������.  ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â� Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â�  ΠÞ��¶Á�P����4}�")��4���� a�f ���(���(w3���(!���%��#.QO(.)è� a�#.QO(.Q�2 ��8�n ,6É'¯(���#4�����×1�("$ yá��i��7 � �#"V������%+,���2�#�����&� z\��.| Â�ÂÂ�Â�Â� ÂÂ�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â�ÂÂ� Â�Â�ÂÂ�Â�  Ú)~

±P¶{��4��")��4���� a�� ����(���(w�×��("@ V��i�fá�� "V����O�.��y��")�����¸.Q�(wa y�|�#���Â�Â�Â� Â�Â�Â� �^Î

gVACAXA

Page 9: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Å���.v &��w¬%��#ª ")��.

:�] M bC> D(]_sc>

Îf� Ê éêQëíì�î�ïvðKñ¿òcófð�ð�ô8ò^ð�ìõì�öø÷JïQù � ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê �

Ú�� Ê éêQëíì�î�ïvð}ú�ð�ûvð�ëøù ����������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~^å

Ú��Ì~ ò^ücùõìõð�ý;óaî�þkîvý|ð�ìõð�þkù ������ ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~^å

A��

Page 10: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

š��.Q ���w������i!����.

¤ AXs U FY> D(]_sc>

Îf� Ê ÿiöøþ����)öíì��röøî�ïvþkîvý�� �������� ���������� ���������� ���������� ����������� ���������� ��� Ê Ú

Îf�Ì~ � ý|óVî�KìGê��'êQ÷ ì� Jð������8ð�÷)ð�þ�ïvü��KêQ÷Vù��)ý|ó)ì�öøêQ÷�� ������� ����������� ���������� ���ß~ Ê

Îf�ÏÎ � ý|óVî�KìGê ì� Jð�÷��)ý���ð�þ�êyì�îvù��cùGêQ÷ ì� Jð������/ð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü��KêQ÷)ù��)ý|ó)ì�öíêQ÷�� ������ ���ß~c~

Îf�ÛÚ � ý|óVî�KìGê�÷��)ý���ð�þ�ê�ì�îvù��cùGêQ÷1ì� )ð������8ð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü��KêQ÷)ù��Vý|ó)ì�öíêQ÷�� � ���������� ���ß~c~

Ú�� Ê � ý|óaî�KìEê�ö�÷! Vî�ì�öíêQ÷"Cî�Kìõêvþ|êQ÷#nîvöøë$�Jþ�ðtó)þ�ê�Vî%�Vö�ëøöíì»ü8îv÷)ô½ÿ�&('�) ùEð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü*�KêQ÷Jñù��Vý|ó)ì�öíêQ÷�Cêvþ,+�êvþBùõì-��îvùõð�ì�î�þkïvð�ì.�Jì�öøë�ö0/�î�ì�öíêQ÷�ê�12�43 ����� ����������� ���������� ���ß~cÔ

Ú��Ì~ � ý|óaî�KìEê�ö�÷! Vî�ì�öíêQ÷"Cî�Kìõêvþ|êQ÷#nîvöøë$�Jþ�ðtó)þ�ê�Vî%�Vö�ëøöíì»ü8îv÷)ô½ÿ�&('�) ùEð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü*�KêQ÷Jñù��Vý|ó)ì�öíêQ÷�Cêvþ,+�êvþBùõì-��îvùõð�ì�î�þkïvð�ì.�Jì�öøë�ö0/�î�ì�öíêQ÷�ê�12�65 ����� ����������� ���������� ���ß~cÔ

Ú��ÏÎ � ý|óVî�KìGê��� )ð7���^ófêQö�÷�ì�öø÷)ï|ê¢ûvð�þ� Jð�îvôVù�êQ÷�nîvöøë$�)þ�ðró)þ�ê�Vî%�Vö�ëøöíì»ü ���� ���������� ���ß~^Õ

Ú��ÛÚ � ý|óVî�KìGê8nîvöøë$�Jþ�ðró)þkê�Vî%�Vöøëøöøì»ü\êQ÷Sÿ9&('�ð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü��KêQ÷)ù��)ý\ó)ì�öíêQ÷�� �� ���������� ���ß~^Õ

Page 11: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

z ,&�&� ��*� Ç

��ÈP%'015 É/³/z\%'�$5PÈ

Ê � Ê Ë g^>@FkgaAX> �

9}H´> W�M >@L�L�>$L�? N ?BIY> W ` ]^H M >jLf>$o2H�>$L�]^?8]�? N ?BIY> W IY<2]_I/AC?P> W�M >@L�Lf>@L � AXIY<�ACH&]

scA�gc>@H*]^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH�]^H�L � ZcFB�V?'>@HJIKAXFY>$b N ACH¬IK<f> ` Z^H)IY>¢�VI�Z_drIK<2]�I�]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH�� ¥�AXFBI U ]^bCb N

]^bXb�]^l�l�bXAn]^H ` >@?1IK<�]_I/<�]vg^>�]¬L�ACs^AXI�]_brACHJIK>$FBd»] ` >;: � ]_I ` <�>$?@� W A ` FBZ � ]�gc>$?@�r¥E�r��?@� ` ]^FY?<:U ?B>+> W+M >$L�L�>@L½? N ?BIK> W ?$� T Z W >t> W�M >@LfL�>@L�? N ?BIK> W ?}ACH ` b U L�>']^H3Zcly>$FK]_IYACH�sS? N ?BIY> W � M U I

?YZ W >�]^FB>�?BZ�? W ]_bCbr]_H�L�?Bly> ` AC]^bCAX�@>@L�IY<2]_I IK<�>m>$H)IYACFB>�bXZcscA `8` ]^H M >3A W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L6]^?P]

?YAXH�scbX>|l�FYZcs^FK] W �

� W�M >$L�L�>$L�? N ?kIK> W ?']^FY>1Z_d�IK>@H M ]_IBIK>$F N ¹õL�FBAXg^>@H¬? N ?BIY> W ?tIY<2]_I\<2]�g^>S?kIKFYAXH�sc>$H)I\l�Z � >$F

]^H�L�=_ZcF�>@H�>$FYs N ` Z^H�?BIYFK]^AXH)IY?@� � �f] W l�bC>$?¡AXH ` b U L�>E]'H�>¢I � ZcFB�SZ_d W A ` FBZc?Y>$H�?YZcFB?¡Lf>@l�bXZ N >@L�AXH] M ]�IYIKbX>$o2>$bCL�dqZcF}? U FBg^>@ACbXbn]^H ` >+Z^F}]/?Bl2] ` >1? N ?BIY> W FB>@b N AXH�s/Z^H�?YZcbC]^FE]^H�L M ]�IYIK>$F N lyZ � >@F$�

T AXH ` >�IK<�>}]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H � AXbCb�d»]^AXb�A�d�IK<f>@ACF�> W+M >$L�L�>@L�? N ?BIK> W d»]^AXbC?$�)d»] U bXI�IKZcbX>@FY]^H ` >�AC?¡Z^d�IK>$H

A W l�ZcFBIK]^HJI�� � Ht]^L�L�A�IKAXZcH�IKZ�]^bXb_IY<�AC?$��> W�M >@L�L�>$L'? N ?BIK> W ?�Z^d�IY>@H\F U H'FB>�]^bø¹ IKA W >�]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?

IK<�]_I1FY>$p U ACFB> W >$>$IKAXH�s ` FYAXIYA ` ]^b�IK]^?Y��L�>�]_L�bCAXH�>@?$� T Z�IY<�>@?B>m? N ?BIY> W ?1sc>@H�>$FK]^bXb N <2]�gc>�IK<f>

dqZcbXbCZ � ACH�s+�^> N Lf>@?YAXscH ` ZcH�?kIKFY]^ACHJIK? �

Ê �¡D�>@FkdqZcF W ]^H ` >

~a�¡D�Z � >$F ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH

Îf� ¤ ] U bXIrIYZcbC>$FK]^H ` >

9}H�> W�M >@LfL�>@L�? N ?BIY> W IY<2]_Im<2]^?m<�AXsc<�l�>@FBdqZ^F W ]^H ` >?>»]^H�L�=�ZcF8d»] U b�IB¹ IYZcbC>$FK]^H ` >@ FY>�¹p U ACFB> W >@HJIK? � ACbCb�Z M gVACZ U ?Yb N <2]_?�<�ACs^<�>@FElyZ � >@F ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH�]^H�L�gVA ` >+gc>$FY?K]a� � H½FB> ` >@HJI

N >@]^FY?'IK<�> IKFY]^L�>@ZBA M >$I � >@>$H6lyZ � >@F ` ZcH�? U W laIKACZ^HÁ]^H�L�ly>$FBdqZcF W ]_H ` >P<2]^?'sJ]^ACHf>@L W U�` <

Ê

Page 12: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

]_IBIK>@HJIYACZcH�]_H�L W ]_H N ?YZ^l�<�AC?kIKA ` ]_IY>@L�l�Z � >@F W ]^H2]_sc> W >@HJIr? ` <�> W >@?=<�]vg^> M >$>@H�l�FBZclyZ^?Y>@L �

]^A W AXH�s�IKZ�FB>@L U�` >¡Zvg^>@FK]_bCbJ>@Hf>@FYs N ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcH�� � <�AXbC>�?BIYACbXbJ] ` <�AX>$gVACH�s�scZVZVL|ly>$FBdqZcF W ]^H ` >^�

D�Z � >@F ` ]^H M > W ]^H2]_sc>@L MJN U ?BACH�s�g_]^FYAXZ U ?|<2]_FYL � ]^FY>_�#o�F W � ]^FY>_�#]^H�L¬? N ?BIY> W ?YZ_d�I � ]^FB>

d»] ` ACbCA�IKAX>@?rAXHj]^H3>@H�>$FYs N ¹ >DC ` AX>@HJI W ]^H�H�>$F � <fACbC> ` ZcHJIKACH U AXH�sSIYZ W >@>¢IEIY<�> ` Z W l U I�]�IKACZ^H2]^bH�>$>@L�?GZ^d�IK<f> U ?Y>$F@��D#Z � >@F ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH ` ]^H M >=FB>@L Uf` >@L MJN ?B< U IYIKAXH�s\L�Z � H ACL�bX> U H�A�IK?iZ^F

MJN l U IYIYACH�sPIK<�>'l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F}ACHJIYZ/ACLfbC>=�?YbC>$>@l W ZVL�> � <�>@H�IY<�>@FB>+AC?�H�Z � ZcFB��� � H�l�FBACH ` ACl�bX>^�

IK<fAC?+AX?'g^>@F N ?YA W l�bX>PIYZ�A W l�bX> W >@HJI M U I�L�Z½HfZ^I1] `$` Z U H)I1dqZ^FtIY<�>/d»] ` I�IK<2]�I1]^H N L�>$gVA ` >

� <�A ` <�AC? `$U FYFB>@HJIKb N AXL�bC> W ] N�M >/FY>$p U ACFB>@L6]_I�]^H N AXH�?BIK]^HJI1ACH�IK<�>/d U I U FB>^�¬� U >PIKZ�IK<f>

Z^d�IY>@H�? U M ?BIK]^HJIKAC]^b(Zvgc>$FY<�>@]^L�?\]^?B?YZ ` AC]_IK>$L�ACH M FYACHfscACH�s IK<f>�ACL�bX> U H�AXIY? M ] ` ��ZcH�bXACH�>_��IY<�>@?B>

? ` <f> W >@?8H�Z_I8]^b � ] N ?8]_l�l�FYZ^l�FYAC]_IK>mdqZcF FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >�? N ?kIK> W ?@��9}HfZ^IK<�>$F8]^b�IK>$FYH2]_IYAXg^>�AX?PIYZ

F U H¬]8? N ?BIY> W U HfL�>@F�g_]^FBAn] M bX>'?Bly>$>@L�]^H�L�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�L U FYACHfs8AXIY?�Zcl�>@FK]�IKACZ^H���:=<�AX?|? ` <�> W >_�

M > ` ] U ?Y>1Z^dGA�IK?EbCZ � >$F�Zvgc>$FY<�>@]^L�?@��scA�gc>$? W U�` < M >$IBIK>@F}ly>$FBdqZcF W ]^H ` >^�|:=<f> W ]_ACH3dqZ `@U ?�Z^d

IK<fAC?rIK<f>@?YAX?�AC?rIKZPA W l�bX> W >@HJI=]^HfL3?kI U L N ? U�` <�]1? N ?kIK> W �

:=<�> W ]Q¦BZcFYA�I N Z^d W ZVL�>@FBHa¹õL�] N�W A ` FBZcl�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcFY? U ?Y>½L�AXscAXIK]^bE�=h Ë T´` ACF `@U A�IK?$�E]_H�L

IK<f>@ACF\>$H�>@FBs N ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcH¬AC?\l�FBZclyZ^FBIKAXZcH2]^b#IKZmIK<�>P?Yp U ]_FY>PZ^d�IY<�> ` ZcFB>S? U l�l�b N gcZcb�I�]^sc>

� <�AXbC>EIY<�>�L�>$bn] N AC?¡bCACHf>�]^FBb N l�FBZclyZ^FBIKAXZcH2]^b�IYZ�IK<�>E? U lfl�b N gcZcb�I�]^s^>^� � H�Z^IY<�>@F � ZcFBL�?@�fAXdIK<f>

` Z^FY>Eg^ZcbXIK]^sc>�AC?�FY>$L U�` >$L8IKZ'<2]^bXd��JIY<�>}>$H�>@FBs N ` ZcH�? U W >$L MJN IY<�>}lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcF � ACbXb2FY>@L U�` >}IYZ

ZcH�>�dqZ U FBIY<�Z^d#AXIK?�ZcFYAXscACH2]_b�g_]^b U > M U I�IK<�> ` l U ?Bly>$>@LE>»Z^F=L�>@bC] N @ � AXbCb M >|FB>@L Uf` >@LmIKZ1Z^H�b N<2]^b�d��i:=<�>|l�FBZ ` >@?B?=Z^d#] ` IYAXg^>@b N ]^L�¦ U ?BIKAXH�s+IY<�> ` l U�¼ ? ` ZcFY>EgcZcb�I�]^sc>}]^H�L�?Bly>$>@LmACH�FB>@?Yl�ZcH�?B>

IKZ1IY<�>GF U�` I U ]_IYACZcH�?�AXH�A�IK? U IYACbXAC��]�IKACZ^H/AC?=�)H�Z � Hj]^?�� N H�] W A ` ¥GZcb�I�]^sc> Ta` ]^bXACH�s">»��¥ T @¢�� N H2] W A ` ¥GZcbXIK]^sc> Ta` ]^bXACH�s�<2]^?8> W >$FYsc>$L�]^?�]�lyZ � >@FBd U b W > ` <2]^HfAC? W dqZcFSFY>@L U�` AXH�s

IK<f>Á>@H�>$FYs N ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcH;L U FBACH�s&? N ?BIY> W Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXZcHIH ÊKJ �ºh3]^H N `@U FYFY>$HJI¬> W�M >@L�Lf>@L

l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcFY?�? Uf` <·]^?8IY<�> � H)IY>@b�¾}? ` ]_bC>LH Ê � J �}]^H�L¸:#FK]^H�? W >¢I�]���F U ?YZV>MH Ê å J ]_bCbCZ � IY<�>@AXF

Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�s�gcZcb�I�]^s^>�IKZ M > ` <2]_H�sc>@L3L N H2] W A ` ]^bCb N �

¤ ] U bXIPIKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` > ` ]_H M >j]^L�L�>$L´IKZ�]Á? N ?kIK> W ACH&L�ANAy>@FB>@HJI � ] N ?$� :=<�>jIKFY]^L�A�IKACZ^H2]^b

]^l�lfFYZJ] ` <{AC? � ¹PIKZ�F U H{IK<f>�?Y] W >�]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH�ZcH{]^H�Z_IK<�>$F3?B>$I3Z^d�<2]_FYL � ]^FY>_�Ø:=<�AC?mAX?

gc>$F N ?YA W l�bX>�]^l�lfFYZJ] ` < M U I�FY>$p U ACFY>$?rL�Z U M bC>�FB>@?BZ U F ` >@?�]^H�L�Z M gVAXZ U ?Yb N AX?¡I � A ` >\]^?rl�Z � >$F

~

Page 13: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

` Z^H�? U W ACHfsS]_?�F U H�H�AXH�s ZcH�b N ZcH�> ` Zcl N ��9}H�Z^IY<�>@F�]^lfl�FYZJ] ` <jAC?rIY<�> ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s_¹ M ]^?B>@L

]^l�lfFYZJ] ` < � � H/IK<�AX?r]^lfl�FYZJ] ` <���]_I¡>�] ` < ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJI��aIK<�>E? N ?BIY> W ?kI�]_IY>�AC?�?K]�g^>@L�]^H�L � <f>@H

]1d»] U bXI�AX?�L�>$IY> ` IY>@L���IK<f>'? N ?kIK> W AX?�FY>@?kI�]^FkIK>$L3dqFYZ W IK<�> W Zc?BI�FY> ` >$H)I ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)I@�=:=<�>@FB>

AC?¡] ` Zc?BIr]^?Y?BZ ` An]_IY>@L � A�IK< ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s�� � <fA ` <8AXH ` b U L�>@?¡?K]�gVACH�s'IK<�>El�FYZ ` >$?Y?r?kI�]_IY>EIKZ+]

?Y> `@U FB>�L�>$gVA ` >^�(À¸A�IK<�Z U I ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sf�)]}d»] U bXI � ACbXbaFB>@p U ACFB>=FY>$?BI�]_FBIKAXH�s\]^H ]BAy> ` IK>$L IK]^?Y�dqFYZ W IK<�> M >$scACHfH�ACH�sf�=��<�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sSIK<�>$FY>$dqZ^FY>t<2]^?EIY<�>tlyZ^IY>@HJIKAC]^b�IKZSFY>$L U�` >'>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH

IKA W >_� � HmIK<�AX?rIK<�>$?YAC?$� � >tbCZVZc�S]_I�IK<�>\A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H/Z^d ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�sPACHmL�>¢I�]^AXb¿�

Ê �Ì~ ��ZcHJIKFYA M U IYACZcH

:=<�AC?'IK<�>$?YAC?+L�>@? ` FYA M >$?�IK<�>�A W lfbC> W >@HJIK]_IKAXZcH¬L�>$IK]^ACbX?+Z^d�]½�=¥ T M ]_?Y>@L�l�Z � >$F ] � ]^FB>

��>�]^bø¹ IKA W >�Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�s1? N ?BIY> W ?<>»�(: Ë T @¢�f:=<�AC?rIY<�>@?BAC?�]^bC?BZ1l�FY>$?Y>$H)IY?EIY<�>|A W l�bC> W >$HJI�]_IYACZcHZ^d ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s M ]_?Y>@L½d»] U bXI}IYZcbC>$FK]^H ` >�AXH¬�(: Ë T � :=<�>1d»] U bXI}IYZcbC>$FK]^H ` >�l�FBZvgaAXL�>@L¬AXH½]

? N ?kIK> W ` ]_H�]^bC?BZ M >PIYFK]^Lf>@L*dqZcFtl�Z � >@F ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcHÁ]_H�L � >/bCZVZc�½]�I'IY<�AC?\IKFY]^L�>@ZBA&AXH

L�>¢I�]^AXb¿�:=<�> W ]^AXH ` ZcHJIYFYA M U IKAXZcH�? W ]^L�>|ACH8IY<�AC?=IY<�>@?BAC? ` ]^H M >|? U WPW ]_FYAC�$>@L�]^?=dqZcbXbCZ � ? �

Ê � � W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H�Z^di]1bXZ � l�Z � >@F�FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >EZcly>$FK]_IYACH�s1? N ?BIK> W �G:=<�AX?�ACH ` b U L�>$? �

O � W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H1Z^d]\L N H2] W A ` g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�? ` ]^bCAXH�s M ]^?Y>$L/? ` <�>@L U bC>@F�ACHS]^HS�(: Ë TO 9�l�FYZVZ^dn¹õZ_dn¹ ` Z^H ` >$lfI<2]^FBL � ]^FY>�l�FBZ^IKZ_I N l�> U ?YAXH�s�� Ë : T\` Z W lyZcHf>@HJIK?�IYZ=L�> W ZcHa¹

?BIKFY]_IK>|IY<�>|dq>�]^?BA M AXbCAXI N Z^d�IK<�>$?Y>|IK> ` <�H�AXp U >@?@�

~a� � W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H�Z^d ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�sSbXA M FY]^FYAX>@?¡ACH�]^H3�(: Ë T

Îf� T A W U bn]_IY>3]�bCZ � l�Z � >@FSd»] U bXIPIKZ^bC>@FY]^HJI/? ` <�>@L U bCAXH�s�]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W � AXIK<�L N H2] W A ` FY>�¹

?YZ U F ` >tFY> ` bn] W ]_IYACZcH U ?YAXH�sP��¥ T �

Ê �ÏÎ Ë U IKbCAXH�>�Z^d(:=<�>@?BAC?

:=<�>�FB>@?BI�Z^d�IK<�AX?�IY<�>@?BAC?�AX?}ZcFBsJ]^H�AX�@>$LjACH3IK<�>tdqZcbCbXZ � AXH�s W ]^HfH�>@F$� T > ` IYACZcH¬~Pl�FYZvgVACL�>$?

IK> ` <�H�A ` ]^b M ] ` �)scFBZ U H�L/ZcH/l�Z � >$Fr] � ]_FY> ` Z W l U IYACH�s��)L N H2] W A ` g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�? ` ]^bCAXH�st]^H�LPd»] U bXI

Î

Page 14: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

IKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` >6]^bCZcHfs � AXIY<ß]´bXAXIY>@FK]�I U FB>Á? U Fkgc> N � T > ` IKAXZcHäδL�>@? ` FBA M >@?�]´gcZcb�I�]^sc>*? ` ]_bCACHfs

]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W �@A�IK?A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H}ACHt]^Ht�(: Ë T ]^H�LtFY>$? U b�IK?$� T > ` IYACZcHtÎ�]^bC?BZ�l�FYZvgVACL�>$?#] M FYAC>¢d

L�>$? ` FBAClfIYACZcH1Z_d2IK<�>=<2]_FYL � ]^FY>�l�FYZ^IYZ^I N ly>rIY<2]_I � >=<2]�gc> U ?Y>@L1dqZcF(Z U Fi>$H�>@FBs N ¹�] � ]_FY>=�^>$FYH�>$b

FY>$bn]_IY>@L6>¢�al�>@FBA W >@HJIK?$� T > ` IKAXZcH6Ú½L�>@? ` FYA M >$?P]¬l�Z � >$FP] � ]^FB>md»] U bXI�IYZcbC>$FK]^HJI1? ` <�>@L U bCAXH�s

]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W ]^H�L+IY<�>r?YA W U bC]_IKAXZcH\FY>@? U bXIY?iZ^d2IY<�AC?(]^bCscZ^FYAXIY< W � T > ` IKAXZcHP��l�FBZvgaAXL�>@?�IK<�>rLf>$I�]_ACbC?

Z^d�]_H�A W l�bC> W >$HJI�]_IYACZcH\Z^d ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfs�ACH+]^H1�(: Ë T ��:=<�AC? � ZcFB� ` ZcH ` b U Lf>@? � A�IK<1] M FYAC>¢d

L�AX? `@U ?Y?YAXZcH�ACH T > ` IKAXZcH�åf�

Ú

Page 15: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

z ,&�&� ��*� «

%'xtz\² È �$z|�PÅß±t� z\Ñ/RS015 ³PÈ É

Ë ly>$FK]_IYACH�s'? N ?BIY> W ?P> Ë T @ W ]_H2]^sc>E]^bCb�IY<�>}lfFYZ ` >@?B?Y>$?=ACH8] ` Z W l U IY>@F�? N ?BIY> W ]^H�L ` ]^H

IK< U ?\l�bC] N ]^H¬A W l�ZcFBIK]^HJI�FYZ^bC>�AXH�FB>@L Uf` ACHfsmIY<�>1l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF ¼ ?t>@H�>$FYs N ` ZcH�? U W laIKACZ^H�� � I\AX?

IK<f>�FY>$?Yl�ZcH�?BA M AXbCAXI N Z^d2IK<�>¡? ` <�>$L U bX>@Fil�FB>@?B>@HJIGACH�?BACL�>GIK<f> Ë T IKZE? ` <�>$L U bX>=L�ANAy>@FB>@HJI(IK]^?Y�)?iAXH? Uf` <�] � ] N IK<2]�I�]_bCbfIY<�>�FY>�]_b�¹ IYA W > ` ZcH�?BIYFK]^AXHJIK?¡]^FY>�?K]�IKAC?ko2>@L � T ACH ` >=I�]^?B�V?¡]^FB>E]_?Y?YZ ` AC]_IK>$L

� AXIY<1FY>$?YZ U F ` >$?�<�]vgVAXH�s|?Yl�> ` AXo ` >$H�>@FBs N1W ZaL�>$bC?$�_IK<f>=? ` <�>$L U bC>$F ` ]^H1>��flfbCZcA�IiIK<�AX?iACHadqZcF W ]�¹

IKAXZcH IKZtFY>@L U�` >EF U Ha¹¿IKA W >�>@Hf>@FYs N ` ZcH�? U W lfIKAXZcH�� ¤ ZcFG>¢�f] W l�bX>^�)FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >�IK]^?Y�)?�HfZcF W ]^bCb N

L�Z|H�Z_IGF U H�IYZ�IK<�>$ACF � ZcFY?kIB¹ ` ]^?B>�>��a> `@U IKACZ^H IYA W >^�J]_H�L�IK<�AX?(IKA W > ` ]^H M >=FY> ` bn]_A W >@L�L U FYACHfs

IK<f>8>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH��½:=<�> W ]^AXHÁ]^A W Z^d�IK<�AX?'IK<f>@?YAX?�AC?tIKZ�A W lfbC> W >@HJI+]j? ` <f>@L U bX>@F�IY<2]_I ` ]^H

>¢�al�bXZcAXIrF U Ha¹¿IKA W >�AXHfdqZcF W ]_IYACZcHSIKZ FY>$L U�` >\IK<f>tZvg^>@FK]_bCbl�Z � >@F ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcHmZ^d(] ? N ?BIY> W �

:=<�>*FB>@?kIjZ^d'IK<�AX?3?B> ` IKACZ^HÃAC?mZcFBsJ]^H�AX�@>$LÃ]^?mdqZcbXbCZ � ?@� � H{IY<�>�Hf>¢�VI�? U M ?Y> ` IYACZcH�� � >

l�FB>@?Y>$HJI}IK<f> ` ZcH ` >@lfI M >$<�ACHfL�IY<�><QPRBSUT�V�WYX"ZU[]\0^_T`�aPb�XcT�\0WdS�`e>»��¥ T @¢�aÀ*>']^bC?BZ l�FY>$?Y>@HJI}]

? U M ?Y> ` IKAXZcHjZ^Hmd»] U bXIrIYZcbC>$FK]^H ` >|dqZcbCbXZ � >$L M)N ]1FB>@bC>¢g_]^HJIEbXAXIY>@FK]�I U FB>�? U Fkgc> N �

~a� Ê � N H�] W A ` ¥GZcb�I�]^sc> TV` ]^bXACH�s

h3Zc?kI W ZaL�>$FYH�L2] N�W A ` FYZclfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcFB? U ?B>/L�AXscAXIK]^bG�=h Ë T*` ACF `$U AXIY?@��]^H�L*IY<�>@AXF'l�Z � >$F

` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcH ` ]^H M > W ZVL�>@bX>@L1] `@`@U FK]_IY>@b N � AXIY<1?YA W l�bX>�>$p U ]_IKAXZcH�?@�i�=h Ë T�` ACF `@U A�IK?i<�]vg^>

M Z^IK<½L N H2] W A ` ]^H�L¬?kI�]_IYA ` l�Z � >$F ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcH��t� N H2] W A ` lyZ � >@F|AC? ` ZcH�? U W >@L½L U >�IYZ

IK<f>j? � A�I ` <�AXH�s*Z_d�sJ]_IY>@?/]^H�L&AX?S?kIKAXbCb=FY>$?Yl�ZcH�?BA M bX>�dqZcFS]�bC]^FYs^>�l�>@F ` >$H)IK]^sc>3Z^d�IK<f>�IYZ^I�]^b

l�Z � >@F1LfAC?Y?BACl2]�IK>@L�AXH6�=h Ë TÁ` AXF `@U AXIK?$�G]^bXIY<�Z U s^<Á?BIK]_IKA ` lyZ � >@F ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH � � <�A ` <�AX?

L U >8IYZjIK<f>�bC>�]_�_]_sc> `$U FYFB>@HJI M >¢I � >$>@H6IK<�>/lyZ � >@F1? U l�l�b N ]^H�L�scFBZ U H�L ��AC?+>��aly> ` IK>$L�IYZ

ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>tACH�IY<�>td U I U FB>^��:=<f>'L N H2] W A ` l�Z � >$F ` ZcH�? U W laIKACZ^H3Z^di]/�=h Ë Tm` AXF `@U AXI ` ]_H M >

FY>$l�FY>$?Y>$H)IY>@L½]_?�H ÊKJ ��

Page 16: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

f(gdhji�k�lnmpo�qsrBtvuPwxyx9z >¨~a� Ê @� <�>$FY>mpo AX?�IY<�> ` AXF `@U AXI=Z U IKl U I�bXZJ]^L ` ]_l2] ` A�I�]^H ` >^�q�r]t AX?rIK<�>\H U W�M >@F�Z^d�? � A�I ` <�>$?El�>@F ` bCZ ` � ` N ` bC>^�z AC?rIY<�> ` bCZ ` �/dqFB>@p U >@H ` N �

:=<�> ` ACF `@U A�I=L�>$bn] N �2L�>$H�Z^IY>@L M)N"{ ��Z M > N ?�IK<�>|dqZcbXbCZ � ACHfs�>@p U ]_IYACZcHEH Ê å J{ l mpo�u xyx| > u xyx~} u�� @�� >¨~a� ~�@

� <�>$FY>u xyx AX?rIK<�>'�rD e ` ZcFB>t? U l�l�b N gcZ^bXI�]_sc>| AX?�] ` ZcH�?kI�]^HJIEL�>@l�>@HfL�ACH�s ZcHmIK<f>tlfFYZ ` >@?B?}]_H�LmsJ]_IK>\?BAC�@>u�� AX?�IY<�>|IK<�FB>@?B<�ZcbCL�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>� g^]_FYAC>$? M >$I � >@>$H Ê ]^H�L6~�� � l ~�dqZcFtbCZcHfs_¹ ` <2]_H�H�>@b�L�>¢gaA ` >$? � <�A ` <*<2]�gc>8H�Z3gc>@bXZ ` AXI N

?K]�I U FY]_IKAXZcH��

� p U ]_IKAXZcH½~a� Ê ?Y<�Z � ?}IY<2]_I ` bCZ ` �8dqFY>$p U >@H ` N FB>@L Uf` IKAXZcHjbXACH�>@]^FYb N Lf> ` FB>�]^?B>@?�IY<�>'l�Z � >$F

` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcHt]^H�L|g^ZcbXIK]^sc>iFB>@L U�` IKAXZcH'FB>@L Uf` >@?#AXI�p U ]^L�FK]�IKA ` ]^bCb N � � p U ]_IYACZcH'~a�Ì~�?Y<�Z � ?�IK<2]�I{ AC?|AXHJgc>@FB?Yb N l�FYZcl�ZcFkIKACZ^H2]^b�IYZ u xyx >qdqZcF|L�>¢gVA ` >$? � A�IK< � l ~2@}?BZ3L�> ` FB>�]^?BACH�s�IK<�> ? U l�l�b NgcZ^bXI�]_sc>/AXH ` FB>�]^?B>@?�IK<f> ` AXF `@U AXI'L�>@bC] N �¬� U >SIYZjIK<f>8ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>$L�Lf>@bn] N �(IK<�> ` ACF `@U A�IK? ` Z U bXL

H�Z^I M >1L�FBAXg^>@H�]_I�IY<�>1?K] W >+dqFB>@p U >@H ` N z � <�>$H�IY<�>1? U lfl�b N gcZcb�I�]^sc> u xyx AX?�L�> ` FY>@]^?Y>$L��

��bC>@]^FYb N IY<�>@FB> AC?\]8d U H�L2] W >$H)IK]^b(IYFK]^L�>$Z�A M >$I � >@>$H*Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�s�?Yl�>@>$L�>»Z^F�ly>$FBdqZcF W ]_H ` >%@]^H�L�? U l�l�b N gcZcb�I�]^sc>�>qZcF=l�Z � >@F ` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcH�@��

¤ ZcFi<2]^FBL FY>�]_b�¹ IYA W >¡? N ?BIK> W ?$� � <f>@FY> W >@>¢IKACHfs|L�>�]^LfbCACHf>@?iAX?igc>@F N ` FBAXIYA ` ]_b¿�_IY<�AC?�IKFK]_L�>@Z�AAC?Pl2]^FkIKA `@U bC]^FYb N U ?B>$d U b¨����>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >/IK]^?Y�)?8]_FY>�H�ZcF W ]^bXb N ` <�]^FK] ` IK>$FYAC�$>@L MJN IK<f>@ACF � ZcFY?kI

` ]_?Y>t>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH3IYA W > � <�A ` < ` ]^H M > M Z U H�L�>$L � A�IK<�FY>�]_?YZcH2] M bC> ` >$FBIK]^ACHJI N � AXIY<�IK<�>t<�>@bXl

Z^d�?kI�]_IYAC?BIYA ` ]^b�]_H2]^b N ?BAC?�]_H�L�l�FYZ_o2bCAXH�s��j:=<f>@?Y>8IK]^?Y�)? ]^FB>8H�ZcF W ]_bCb N ly>$FYACZVL�A ` � A�IK<*IY<�>@AXF

å

Page 17: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

l�>@FYAXZaL M >@ACHfs+�)H�Z � H8ACH/]^Lfg_]^H ` >^� TaUf` <�]'l�FBACZcFBA��VHfZ � bX>@L�s^>�] M Z U I�IK<�> � ZcFY�)bCZc]^L W ]^�^>$?

l�Z � >@F W ]^H2]^sc> W >$HJIrIK> ` <�H�ACp U >$?}>¢gc>@H W Z^FY>|?YAXscH�A�o ` ]^HJI=dqZcFrIY<�>@?B>'? N ?BIK> W ?$�h3ZVL�>@FBH�L2] N lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcFB?\? U�` <*]^?�IK<�> � HJIY>@bi¾�? ` ]^bX>^��:#FK]^H�? W >¢I�]���F U ?YZV>S]_bCbCZ � IY<�>@AXF

Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�sS?Bly>$>@L�IYZ M >+]^LQ¦ U ?BIY>@L½ZcH�IK<�>�F N ��:=<�>$?Y>1l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcFY?EL�Z8H�Z_I ` Z W >t>@p U AXl�l�>@L� AXIY<�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>1? ` ]^bXACH�s ` ]_l2] M AXbCAXIYAC>$?|]^H�L W U ?kI M >S] U s W >@HJIK>$L � A�IK<�<2]^FBL � ]_FY> M bCZ ` �)?\IYZ

L N H2] W A ` ]^bCb N ` <2]_H�sc>�IK<�>E? U l�lfb N gcZ^bXI�]_sc>^�)?Y>$> ¤ AXs U FB> Ê �i:=<�>@?B>}<2]_FYL � ]^FY> M bCZ ` �)?¡?B<�Z U bXL

]^bX?YZ=<2]�gc>G?BZ^d�I � ]_FY>GACHJIK>$FBd»] ` >@?IK<�]_I ` ]_H M >�l�FBZQgVAXL�>@L\IKZrIY<�> Ë T IYZrd»] ` AXbCAXIK]_IK>#>@Hf>@FYs N ] � ]^FB>

FY>$?YZ U F ` > W ]_H2]^sc> W >$H)I@� � H�IK<�>tH�>¢�VI ` <2]^lfIY>@F@� � >+L�> W ZcHf?BIKFY]_IK>\Z U FEA W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H8Z^d

�=¥ T ACHm]^H�Z�A�¹ IK<f>¢¹õ?B<�>@b�d(lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcF$�~a�Ì~ ¤ ] U bXI=:#ZcbX>@FK]_H ` >

: � ZmIK> ` <�H�AXp U >@?|dqZcF�l�FBZvgaAXL�ACHfs/d»] U b�I�IKZcbX>@FY]^H ` >+ACH�FB>�]^b(IYA W >+? N ?kIK> W ?t]^FB> M ]^?Y>$L¬ZcH

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s#H Ê � J ]^HfL3l�FBA W ]^F N ]^H�L�sc<�Z^?BI ` ZclfAC>@?�H Ê Î J �� H&IK<f> ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s�¹ M ]^?B>@L¸]^lfl�FYZJ] ` <���]_I/>@] ` < ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)I@�=IK<�>3? N ?BIY> W ?kI�]_IY>jAX?

?K]�g^>@L�]^H�L � <f>@H�]3d»] U b�ItAC?+Lf>$IK> ` IY>@L���IK<f>8? N ?BIY> W AC?tFY>@?kI�]^FkIK>$LÁdqFYZ W IK<f> W Z^?BI�FB> ` >@HJI

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)I@��:=<�>@FB>�AC?�] ` Zc?BI�]^?B?YZ ` AC]_IK>$L � AXIK< ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s�� � <�A ` < AXH ` b U L�>@?(?K]�gVACH�s|IK<f>

l�FBZ ` >@?Y?�?BIK]_IK>\IKZS] ?Y> `$U FY>'l�bn] ` >^�GÀ¸AXIY<�Z U I ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s���>$g^>@H½] M FYAX>$d�IKFK]_H�?YAX>@HJI�d»] U bXI

W ] N FY>@p U AXFY> U ?\IKZ3]�FB>@?kI�]^FkItIY<�> I�]^?B��dqFYZ W IY<�> M >$scACHfH�ACH�sf�/��<f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s�IY<�>@FB>$dqZcFB>

<2]^?=IY<�>\lyZ^IY>@HJIKAC]^b IYZPFB>@L Uf` >t>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH�IYA W >^�� HjIK<f>�l�FYA W ]_F N ]^HfL�sc<�Zc?kI ` Zcl�AC>$? M ]_?Y>@L¬]_l�l�FYZc] ` <�� s^<�Zc?BI ` ZclfAC>@?}]^FY>'> W�M >@LfL�>@L½AXH

IK<f>S? ` <�>@L U bC>8]_bCZcH�s � A�IK<¬IK<�>Pl�FBA W ]^F N ` Zcl�AX>@?$�/9Ísc<�Zc?kI+AX?t] M ] ` � U l ` Z^l N � � <�A ` <*bXAC>@?

L�ZcF W ]_H)I U HJIKAXb�AXI+AC?+] ` IYAXg_]_IK>$L*IKZ�IK]^�^>8IY<�>8l�bC] ` >SZ^dE] ` Z^FYFY>$?Yl�ZcH�L�AXH�s½l�FBA W ]^F N � <�Zc?B>

l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF1<2]^?'d»]^ACbX>@L�� � H ` ]^?Y>�Z_d�d»]_ACb U FY>^�#IK<�> � <fZcbC>/]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H*AC?'?BIK]^FBIY>@L�dqFYZ W IK<f>

M >@scAXH�H�ACHfs��� Z^IY<mIY<�>|] M Zvgc>�¹ W >@HJIKAXZcH�>@L�IY> ` <�H�AXp U >@?=dqZcFrlfFYZvgVACL�AXH�s�d»] U b�I�IKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` >�FY>$p U ACFY>|?BZ W >

?YbC] ` � IKZ M >�FY>$?Y>@Fkgc>$LjACHSIK<�>�? ` <�>@L U bC>|IKZ W >$>$I=L�>@]^L�bXACH�>$?rACH/IY<�>�>¢gc>@HJI�Z^d�d»] U b�IK?¡?BIKFBAC�)ACHfs

IK<f>�? N ?kIK> W �Ä�EZ � >$g^>@F@�tACH�IK<�> ` Z WSW ZcH ` ]^?B>*Z^d+H�Z�d»] U bXIK?m<�A�IYIYACH�s�IK<f>*? N ?kIK> W IK<f>

? ` <f>@L U bX>@F ` ]^H�FY> ` bC]^A W IK<�AX?=?YbC] ` � MJN F U HfH�ACH�s1IY<�> ���! ]_I�] bCZ � >@F=?Yl�>@>$L��

Ô

Page 18: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

~a�ÏÎ ©�A�IK>$FK]_I U FY> TaU FBgc> N

��¥ T <2]^?1FY> ` >$H)IYb N ]_IYIYFK] ` IK>@L�]�bC]^FYsc> M ZVL N Z^d�FY>@?B>�]^F ` <�H Ê ¹ Ú J ��:=<�> W ]^ACH W Z^IYAXg_]�¹

IKAXZcH M >@<�AXH�L½IK<�AX?|ACH ` FY>�]_?YACHfsm]_IYIY>@HJIKAXZcH½AC?�IY<�>1bCA W A�I�]_IYACZcH�ZcH M ]_IBIK>@F N bXAXdq>�AXH½> W�M >@L�Lf>@L

? N ?kIK> W ?@� � > ` ] U ?Y>1Z_diIK<�>+ACH ` FY>�]_?YACHfs/l�Zcl U bC]^FYA�I N Z^dG�=¥ T � W ]_H N > W�M >$L�L�>$L�lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcFB?

? Uf` <m]^?¡IY<�> � HJIK>$b�¾}? ` ]^bC><H Ê � J �a]^H�LS:�FY]^H�? W >$IK]1��F U ?YZV>�H Ê å J ]^FY>EH�Z � >@p U AXl�ly>$L � AXIY</IK<f>

] M AXbCA�I N IYZ�L N H2] W A ` ]^bCb N ? ` ]^bX>+IK<f>@ACF|Z^ly>$FK]_IYACH�s/g^ZcbXIK]^sc>_�'9Æ?kI U L N Z^d�l�>@FBACZVL�A ` FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >

I�]_?Y�)?@� � <�A ` < ` ]^H ` ZcHf? U W >�>@Hf>@FYs N ]_I/lyZc?B?YA M b N g_]^F N AXH�sÁFK]�IK>@?$�EAX?/l�FB>@?B>@HJIK>$L{AXH�HÏ~ ÊKJ �9 M >@H ` < W ]^FB�½? U A�IK> ]^H�L¬?BA W U bC]_IKAXZcH�>$H)gVAXFYZcH W >@HJI\dqZcF}g^ZcbXIK]^sc>1? ` ]^bXACH�s�AX?|l�FY>$?Y>@HJIY>@LÁAXHHÛ~c~ J �´� N H2] W A ` gcZ^bXI�]_sc>¢¹ ? ` <�>$L U bCAXH�s�]^bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W ?+dqZcF1of�a>@LV¹õl�FBACZcFBAXI N IK]^?Y�6? N ?kIK> W ? � >@FB>

l�FB>@?Y>$HJIK>@L�ACH�HÛÎ^� J ����Z W l�AXbC>$Fk¹�]_?Y?YAX?BIY>@L8�=¥ T AC?�?kI U LfAC>@L�AXH�H§ÚcÚ J �i9·H U W�M >@FrZ_d�bCZ � ¹õl�Z � >$F

? N ?kIK> W ¹õbX>$g^>@b�L�>@?BACscH�IK> ` <fH�ACp U >$?8<2]�gc> M >$>@H´L�>¢gc>$bCZcl�>@L�� � LfbC>md U H ` IYACZcHf? U HfAXIK? ` ]_H M >

l�Z � >@FB>@L�L�Z � H�HÛ~_Ú J ]_H�L6l�FY>$L�A ` IKAXg^>¢¹ ?Y< U IKLfZ � HV¹ M ]^?B>@L�lyZ � >@F ZclfIYA W AC��]�IKACZ^H�IK> ` <�H�AXp U >@?

]^FB>'l�FB>@?B>@HJIK>$L½ACHEHÏ~^� J ��:=<�>@?B> W >$IK<fZaL�?E]^FB>'L�>$?YAXscH�>@L�dqZcF�? N ?BIY> W ? � A�IK<3]Pof�a>@L3gcZcb�I�]^sc>? U l�l�b N ��9}H�]_bXIK>$FYH2]�IKAXg^>P]^l�l�FBZJ] ` <*IYZ3?Y]vg^>8>@Hf>@FYs N AX? M ]^?Y>$LÁZcH*L N H�] W A ` lyZ � >@F W ]^Ha¹

]^sc> W >$HJI�>»�|D�h�@¢��AXH � <fA ` <�IY<�>mZcl�>@FK]�IKACHfs�? N ?BIK> W > Ë T @�AC? FY>$?Yl�ZcH�?BA M bX>8dqZcF FY>@L U�` AXH�s? N ?kIK> W lyZ � >@F ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH ���|D�h � ]^? W ]_L�>+l�Zc?Y?BA M bX>'bC]^FYs^>@b N L U >+IKZSIK<�>�9ELfg_]^H ` >@L

��ZcHfo�s U FK]�IKACZ^H ]^H�LPD�Z � >@F � HJIK>@Fkd»] ` >s>q9��rD � @�HÛ~^å J �i9��rD � ]_bCbCZ � ?�<2]^FYL � ]^FB>�lyZ � >@F�?BIK]_IK>$?IKZ M > ` ZcHJIKFBZcbCbX>@L M)N IY<�> Ë T IK<fFYZ U s^<�? N ?BIY> W ` ]^bXbC?$�y>�A > ` IKA�gc>$b N IKFY]^H�?Bdq>$FYFBACH�s/IY<�>+l�Z � >$FFY>$L U�` IKACZ^HÁFY>$?Yl�ZcH�?YA M ACbXAXI N dqFBZ W IK<f>8<2]^FBL � ]_FY>~> � �kË T @\IYZ3IY<�>8?YZ_d�I � ]^FB>~> Ë T @¢�(h3Zc?BI+Z^dIK<f> ��¥ T FY>@?B>�]^F ` <�AX? M ]^?B>@L¬ZcH¬?YA W U bC]_IKAXZcH�?E]^H�L½H�Z^I W U�` <¬A W l�bC> W >$HJI�]_IYACZcH � Z^FY��<2]_?

M >@>@H�FB>@l�ZcFBIY>@L���h�ZcFY>�FB> ` >@HJIKb N �2]+?Bly> `@U bC]_IKA�gc>E? ` <�> W >|<2]_? M >$>@H�l�FBZcl�Zc?Y>$L�ACH~HÛ~cÔ J ��:=<�AX?? ` <f> W >t<�]^? M >$>@H�A W l�bC> W >$HJIK>@L/ACH8IK<f>t>���Zc?=Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�s1? N ?BIY> W HÛ~^Õ J F U H�HfACH�s ZcHm] � HJIK>$b¾�? ` ]^bX>¢¹ M ]^?Y>$L M ZJ]^FYL ��:=<�AC?S? ` <�> W >3AC?P?Yl�> `@U bn]_IYAXgc>B�}A�I/]_bCbCZ � ? l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF/?Bly>$>@L´IYZ M >

FY>$L U�` >@L�ACH�]^HJIYA ` AXl2]_IYACZcH�Z^dtFY>@L U�` >$L{>��f> `@U IYACZcH�IYA W >^��]^H�L�L�ZV>@?�HfZ^I�s U ]_FK]^HJIK>$>�IK<2]�I

L�>@]^L�bCAXH�>@? � ACbXb M >�?Y]_IKAX?Bo2>$L�� � H?H Îc� J � � ]^FYbXAC>$?BI}��>�]^L�bXACH�> ¤ AXFY?BI�> � � ¤ @�]^H�L½��]_IK>�h3ZcH�Z�¹

IKZ^H�A ` >»�}h�@ M ]^?Y>$L/�=¥ T ]^bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W ?(<2]�g^> M >@>$H/L�>¢gc>$bCZcl�>@LS]^H�L <2]�gc> M >@>@HPA W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$LÕ

Page 19: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

ZcH8IY<�>\©ACH U �/Zcly>$FK]_IYACH�s+? N ?BIY> W F U H�H�ACHfs�ZcH�]^H�9|h3� 9rIY<�bCZ^H M ]^?Y>$LmH�Z^IK> M ZVZc����:=<�>$?Y>

IK> ` <�H�AXp U >@?�]^FB>GA W l�bC> W >$H)IY>@Lt]^?�©ACH U �t�^>$FYH�>$b W ZVL U bC>$?@�_]^H�LtL�Z}HfZ^I#s U ]^FY]^HJIK>@>¡FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >

M >@<2]�gVACZcF$��9&��¥ T ]^bXscZcFBAXIK< WÃM ]^?B>@L�Z^H � � ¤ ]_bCscZcFBAXIY< W AX?�]_bC?YZEA W l�bC> W >$HJIK>@L\AXH��(:=bXACH U �H§Ú)~ J �}:=<�AX? � ZcFY�3]^?Y? U W >@?}IY<2]_I|]_bCbI�]^?B�)?�<2]�gc>+IY<�>�?Y] W >tl�>@FYAXZaL � ]^FB>+H�Z^Ha¹õl�FB>@> W lfIYA M bX>^�]^H�L3]^bXbyI�]_?Y�)?EF U HmIKZ1IK<�>$ACF � ZcFY?kI ` ]^?B>'>��f> `@U IYACZcHmIKA W >_�

:=<�>@FB>Á<2]^? M >$>@H;]�bCZ^I�Z^d�FY>@?B>�]^F ` < FY>@l�ZcFkIK>@L{ZcH ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfs��Ó��<f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s

bCA M FK]_FYAC>$?G? U�` <m]^?r©�A M ` �)lfI@�2��ZcHfL�ZcF@�a]^H�L ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s�A W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L8]^?�]+�^>$FYH�>$b W ZVLa¹

U bX>j? Uf` <¸]^?/>$l ` �)lfIm]_H�L ` FY]^�nH Þ � Ê �f� ÊcÊ � Ê ~a� Ê Î J F U H´ZcH´?B>$gc>$FK]^bEgc>@FB?YAXZcH�?8Z^d e H�Aø� �

hj]^H N FY>@?B>�]^F ` <�>@FB?�HÛ�a�Ïåf�ÌÔa�ÌÕ J ]^bX?YZ¬]^LfL�FY>$?Y? ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s¬AXH�]�FY>@]^b¡IYA W >/? N ?kIK> W ��:=<�>

] ` I U ]^b'A W l�bC> W >$HJI�]_IYACZcH�Z^d ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s¸ACHÃFY>�]_b'IKA W >�Zcl�>@FK]�IKACHfs´? N ?BIY> W ?¬<2]^?�H�Z_I

N >¢I M >@>$H&FB>@l�ZcFBIY>@L´]_H�L�HfZ*l U M bCA ` b N ]vg_]^AXbn] M bC>/FB>�]^b=IYA W >�Zcly>$FK]_IYACH�s¬? N ?kIK> W ? U l�l�ZcFBIY?

]^H N ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfs W > ` <2]_H�AC? W ��IYZ�Z U F|�)H�Z � bC>@Lfsc>^� Ë U F W ]^ACH¬]^A W � ]^?|IKZmL�>¢gc>$bCZcl�]

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s/? ` <�> W >'ACH3] � ACLf>@b N ] `@` >$lfIK>$L½]^H�L3dqFY>@>$b N ]�g_]^ACbC] M bX>�FY>@]^b#IYA W >|Zcl�>@FK]�IKACHfs

? N ?kIK> W �

:=<�>@FB>'AX?�]^bC?BZ g^>@F N bXAXIBIKbC> � Z^FY��FY>$lyZ^FBIK>$LjZcHmIK<f>tl�Z � >$F}]_H�L3>$H�>@FBs N ]^?Bly> ` IK?EZ^d#d»] U bXI

IKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` >^� � H�H Ê Õ J � e H�?Y]^b�>$I/]^b¿���¡lfFYZcl�Zc?Y>$L´]^H�>@H�>$FYs N ¹õ] � ]^FB>�]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcHa¹ bC>$g^>@b�d»] U bXI

IKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` >�? ` <�> W >^� � <�>$FY>^�V?Y> ` ZcHfL2]^F N ` Zcl�AX>@?�]^FY> U ?B>@LPdqZcFid»] U b�I�IKZcbX>@FK]_H ` >=AXHPLfAC?BIYFYA M U IK>$L

FY>@]^b(IYA W >�? N ?BIY> W ?@� � H�]^H�Z^IY<�>@F\]�IYIK> W laI���]^H¬>@Hf>@FYs N ¹õ] � ]^FB> ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACH�A�IKH�sm? ` <f> W > dqZ^F

> W+M >$L�L�>@L3? N ?BIY> W ?}AX?�lfFY>@?B>@HJIK>$L?H Ê�ÞBJ ��:=<�AX? � ZcFY��AX? M ]^?Y>$LjZcH�IK<�>t]^?B? U W lfIYACZcHmIK<2]�I}]�I

W Zc?BI��jd»] U bXIK?}Z `$`@U F|AXHjIK<�> ? N ?kIK> W ��AXI�L�Za>$?YH ¼ I ` Z^H�?YAXL�>@F|l�FBZ M ] M ACbCAX?BIYA ` d»]^ACb U FY> W ZVL�>@bX?@�:=<�>�]BAy> ` IK?�Z^d�L N H2] W A ` FY>$?YZ U F ` >�FY> ` bC] W ]�IKACZ^H�]^H�L1?Bbn] ` �'FY> ` bn] W ]_IYACZcH'ZcH1FY>$bCAC] M ACbXAXI N ]_H�L>@Hf>@FYs N <2]�g^>|]^bC?BZ'HfZ^I M >@>$H�]^L�L�FB>@?B?Y>@L8��IK<�>$?Y> ` ]^H8bC>@]^LSIYZ+?BACscH�A�o ` ]_H)I¡l�Z � >@F�?K]�gVACH�sc?$� � HZ U F � ZcFB� � >t]^L�LfFY>@?B?}]_bCb IY<�>@?B>'AX?Y? U >@?�?YA W U bXIK]^H�>$Z U ?Yb N �

Þ

Page 20: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

z ,&�&� ��*� Ö

×P5PÅ�%�� RSxÜ7�z|�PÅ¡��È8RÓ�PÅ�R�5P01��%'²Pu

��>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >GI�]^?B�)?�H�ZcF W ]^bXb N L�Z|H�Z_I�F U H�IYZ�IK<�>$ACF � ZcFB?BI ` ]_?Y>=>¢�a> `@U IYACZcH1IKA W >$?�]^H�L�IY< U ?

bC>@]�gc>P?YZ W > ?Ybn] ` ��ACH¬IK<�>$ACF|>��f> `@U IYACZcH�L U FBACH�smF U H�IKA W >_�P� U HfH�ACH�s�IY<�> � �! ]_I']�bXZ � >$F

?Yl�>@>$L ` ]^H�FY> ` bn]^A W IY<�AC?=?Bbn] ` ��� � H�IK<�AX? ` <2]^lfIY>@F$� � >tL�>@? ` FBA M >\IY<�>|A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcHSZ^d(]^H

]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W H ÊKJ � � <�A ` <*]_bCbCZ � ?|L N H2] W A ` FY>@?BZ U F ` >PFY> ` bn] W ]_IYACZcH � <�AXbC>1s U ]^FK]^HJIY>@>@AXH�s�IK<2]�I

H�Z L�>@]^L�bCAXH�>@? � AXbCb M > W AX?Y?B>@L��

Îf� Ê h3ZaLf>@bC?�]^HfL�:#>@F W AXH�ZcbXZcs N

Îf� Ê � Ê :�]^?B��h3ZaLf>@b

9 I N l�A ` ]^bGFY>@]^bGIKA W >1I�]^?B� W ZVL�>@b ` ZcH�?YAX?BIY?+Z^d=l�>@FBACZVL�A ` FB>�]^bGIKA W >1I�]_?Y�)? � <�>$FY>8>@] ` <

I�]_?Y�8AX? W ZVL�>@bX>@L MJN���U� � D#>@FBACZVL3Z^d(]�I�]^?B�e�Y��<� � ��>$bn]_IYAXgc>|Lf>�]^L�bXACH�>|Z_di]�I�]_?Y�e��> l��U� @����ms�P��� � À�ZcFY?kI ` ]^?B>t>��a> `@U IKACZ^H�IYA W >|Z^di]�IK]^?Y�e� U HfL�>@F=d»] U b�I=dqFY>$> ` ZcH�L�A�IKAXZcH�?@�� �P��� � 9 ` I U ]_b>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH�IYA W >�Z^d(]�I�]^?B�;� U H�L�>$F�d»] U bXIrdqFB>@> ` ZcHfL�AXIYACZcH�?$�9}bXb(IK<�>1IK]^?Y�)?t]^FY> AXH�L�>@l�>@HfL�>@HJItA¿�Û>^�1H�Z�IK]^?Y��Lf>@l�>@H�L�?tZcH½IK<f>PZ U IKl U I'Z_dr]^H N Z_IK<�>$F

I�]_?Y�)?@�G9}bX?YZ��JIK]^?Y�)? W U ?BIrF U H/IYZ ` Z W l�bX>$IKAXZcH ACHSZcFYL�>$F¡IYZ�sc>$I�]^H NSM >$H�>$o�I¡dqFYZ W IY<�> W A¿�Û>^�

IK<f> N ]^FB>\H�Z^I � H ` FY>�]_?Y>@L���> � ]^FBL�dqZ^F � H ` FB>�]^?B>@L T >$FBgVA ` >�> � � � T @�I�]^?B�V?sH Ê Ú J �� �P��� AC?�]^?B? U W >@L�IKZSg_]^F N U H�A�dqZcF W b N ACHmIK<�>tFK]_H�sc>�H4��� ��m����U� � ��ms�P���NJ �����;]� Ê ��9E?E] ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>$?@��IY<�>|I�]^?B� ¼ ?�>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH�IYA W > M > ` Z W >@? W ZcFY>}L�>$IY>@F W ACHfAC?BIYA ` �

Ê �

Page 21: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Îf� Ê �Ì~ D#Z � >$F�h3ZVL�>$b

:=<�>+lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcF ` ]^H3Zcly>$FK]_IY>�]_I�I � Z/gcZcb�I�]^s^>tbX>$g^>@bC? ����� ]^HfL � o > ������� o @¢� �B� ]_H�L� o ]^FY>�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>@?t]_I � <fA ` <¬IK<�> l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF ` ]^H¬L�Z U ?Y>¢d U b ` Z W l U IK]_IKAXZcH��':=<�>S?BbCZ � L�Z � H

d»] ` IKZcF MJN � <�A ` <jIK<f>+l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF�AX?E?BbCZ � >$F�]_IEgcZcb�I�]^s^> � FB>@bn]�IKAXg^>tIYZ � <�>$H¬]_I�gcZcb�I�]^sc> ���AC? �  ¢¡¤£¢¥§¦�£¢¥�¨ > � @ l � > �B� } � � @ w�B� >»Îf� Ê @� <�>$FY> � � AC?�IK<�>¡IK<�FB>@?Y<fZcbCL+g^ZcbXIK]^sc>¡]^H�L � g_]^FYAX>@? M >¢I � >$>@H Ê ]^HfL ~a��À�>r]_?Y? U W >$L � läÊc Î

dqZcF�]^bXb�Z U F=>��aly>$FYA W >@HJIY?@�À*>\L�>¢o2H�>\ZcH�> U HfAXI�Z^d#>¢�a> `@U IYACZcH3]^?=IK<�> ` Z W l U I�]_IYACZcH/ly>$FBdqZcF W >$L MJN IY<�>\l�FYZ ` >$?Y?BZcF

]_I �B� AXH U H�A�I�IKA W >_�¬�E>@H ` >^��ZcH�> U H�AXI�Z^d�>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH � ACbCbGI�]_�^>  ¡¤£]¥�¦�£¢¥�¨ >qg�@ U H�AXIY?�Z^dIKA W >�]_I�gcZ^bXI�]_sc> � ��:=<�>EFK]_IYACZtZ^d>$H�>@FBs N ` ZcH�? U W >$L8l�>@F ` N ` bC> MJN ]tl�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^Fr]_I¡gcZcb�I�]^sc>g�FB>@bn]�IKAXg^>�IKZ1IK<�]_I�]_I�gcZcb�I�]^s^> ��� AX?

� ¨�©%ª¢«�¬ ª �2­�� £ ®�©%ª ¯�¬�¯D¡¤© > � @ l±° ����P² w >»Îf� ~�@À*>*<2]�gc>ÁI�]_�^>@H;AXHJIKZ�] `$` Z U H)I½IY<�> ` Zc?BI¬]_?Y?YZ ` AC]_IK>$L � AXIY<ÃgcZ^bXI�]_sc>*? ` ]^bXACH�s�ACH·Z U F

A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcH ��À�>�o2H�L´]_H U l�ly>$F M Z U H�L�Z^H�IY<�>@?B>�Zvg^>@FY<f>�]^L�?SACH6?Y> ` IYACZcH�Îf�ÏÎ�]_H�L

] `$` Z U HJIY>@L dqZcF(IK<fAC? ` Zc?BI MJN1W >@FBscACHfs}AXIiACHJIKZ}IY<�> � ZcFY?kIB¹ ` ]^?Y>�l�FBZ^o2bX>rACHfdqZ^F W ]_IKAXZcH'Z_d�IK]^?Y�)?$�

Îf�Ì~ � N ` bCA `+TV` <�>@L U bCACHfs

¤ ZcF >�] ` <´l�>@FBACZVL�A ` dqFY] W >^� � <fA ` <&AX?1IK<�>3©>�]^?kI���Z WPW ZcH´h U bXIYACl�bX>³>¨©#�=h�@1Z^d�IK<f>l�>@FYAXZaLf?PZ_d\]^bCbrIY<�>3IK]^?Y�)?SACH6IK<�>3? N ?BIY> W ��]^bCbrIK]^?Y�)?8]_FY>�FY>@bX>�]^?B>@L�]�IPIY<�> M >@s^ACH�H�AXH�s¬Z^d

IK<f>/dqFK] W >8]_H�L W U ?kI+o2H�AX?Y< MJN IY<�>8>$H�L�Z^d=IK<f> `@U FBFY>$H)I1dqFY] W >^�jÀ�>�]^?B? U W >/IK<�]_I�IK<f>

I�]_?Y�)?|<2]�gc> ]/lfFY>@Lf>$o2H�>$L�>��a> `@U IKACZ^H½ZcFYL�>$F@�t�|> N IKZ/IY<�> ]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W AC?�]/d U H ` IYACZcH���´v>¤­µ@¢�� <�A ` <{<2]_?�IY<�>¬l�FYZcl�>@FkI N IK<2]�ImAXdtIK<�>�] W Z U HJI�Z^d U Hfo2H�AX?Y<�>$L � ZcFY�¸]�I�IKA W >�I�AC?�H�Z_I

scFB>�]_IY>@F}IY<2]^H�´v>¤­µ@�� IK<f>@FY>+AC?}>$H�Z U s^<½l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YAXH�s ` ]_l2] ` A�I N IYZ W >@>$I�]^bCb#L�>@]^L�bCAXH�>@? U H�L�>$F

IK<f>�? ` <�>@L U bCAXH�s+]_bCscZcFBAXIY< W AX? M >$ACH�s U ?B>@L�� � HPZ^IK<f>@F � Z^FYL�?$�¶´v>¤­µ@iAX?¡]|? U C ` AC>$HJI ` ZcH�L�A�IKACZ^HdqZcF=? ` <�>@L U bn] M AXbCA�I N �

ÊcÊ

Page 22: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Îf�ÏÎ 9}bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W

:=<�>�]^bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W ` ZcH�?YAX?BIY?1Z^d�I � Z¬l�<2]_?Y>@?$� � H�IK<�>�ZB·SAXH�>8l�<�]^?Y>_� � <�A ` <6AC?�>��f> `@U IY>@L

M >$dqZcFB>PIY<�>S? N ?BIK> W AC?'] ` I U ]^bCb N U ?B>@L�� � >SZ M IK]^ACH½IK<f>Pd U H ` IKAXZcH�´v>d­µ@|Zvg^>@F'IY<�>PL U FK]�IKACZ^HZ^d#IK<�>|dqFY] W >_� � HmIK<�>\ZcH�bXACH�>}l�<2]^?B>^� � <�>@HmIK<f>t? N ?BIK> W AC?=Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�s�� � >\?Y>¢IEIY<�>|gcZcb�I�]^sc>

bC>¢gc>$b�IKZ�s U ]^FK]_H)IY>@>+IY<2]_I�IY<�> U Hao2H�AC?B<�>@L � ZcFY� � ACbXb�Hf>$gc>$F|>¢� ` >$>@L¸´v>¤­µ@}]_IEIKA W >tI��|:=<�AX?]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W ]_b � ] N ?�?B>$IY?�IK<�>ÁlfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcF�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�IKZ � o{� <�>$H;IK<�> U Hfo2H�AX?Y<�>$L � ZcFB�{AX?

s U ]_FK]^HJIK>$>@L�IKZ M > M >@bXZ � ´v>¤­µ@���]^H�L �B� Z^IY<�>@F � AC?Y>_��:=<f>�ZB·SAXH�>/lf<2]^?Y>mAX? ` ]_FYFYAX>@L�Z U I

ACH�IK<�>PdqZcbCbXZ � ACH�s � ] N ��©>¢I�¹ M >SIY<�> � ZcFY?kIB¹ ` ]^?B> U IYACbCAX��]_IYACZcH½Z_drIK<�>Sl�FYZ ` >$?Y?BZcF1]_I'<�ACs^<

gcZ^bXI�]_sc>E>»A¿�Û>^���¡IY<�> U IKAXbCAC�@]_IKAXZcHÁA�d}>¢gc>@F N I�]^?B��FK]^H�IKZ�AXIK?1À´� � :Ü]^H�L � ]^?SF U H&]_IP<�ACs^<

gcZ^bXI�]_sc>@��Ð��Z^H�?BIYF U�` I���dqZcF8>�] ` <¸IK]^?Y� ��� ] ` ZcFBFY>@?BlyZ^H�L�ACHfs�ACH�F�]�IK>@L´IK]^?Y� �»º� � A�IK<´IK<f>

?K] W >Ely>$FYACZVL8]_? �U� M U I � <�Zc?B>�>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH8IKA W >�AX?¡L�>¢IK>$F W ACH�AX?BIKA ` ]_H�L8AC?�>@p U ]_byIKZ½¼¾ IKA W >@?IK<f>SÀ´� � :ÍZ^d ��� ��:=<�>/?B>$I�Z_drI�]^?B�)?@� �»º.lÀ¿e�»º¼ � �»ºw � �»ºÁ �X���X�����X� ��ºÂ�à �(<�]^? U IYACbXAC��]�IKACZ^H Ê

MJN ` ZcH�?BIYF U�` IKAXZcH���£EZ � � U ?Y>8IY<�> � � ¤ ? ` <f>@L U bXACH�s¬]_bCscZcFBAXIY< W IKZ½? ` <�>@L U bC>�AXI@�³´v>¤­µ@'AX?IK<f> U Hfo2H�AX?Y<�>$L � ZcFY����] `$` ZcFBL�ACH�s�IYZ1IK<�AX?=? ` <�>$L U bC>_��Z^d�IK]^?Y�)? `@U FBFY>$H)IYb N ] � ]^AXIYACH�s1?B>@FkgaA ` >_�

��>$o�H�> MJN IK<f>�Z�·PACH�> I�]^?B�8>�I7@'IY<�>8I�]^?B��>qAXd�]^H N @+F U HfH�ACH�s¬]�I�IKA W >�­ U H�L�>@F�IY<�>�Z�·PACHf>? ` <f>@L U bX>^�

:=<�>tZcH�bCAXH�>�l�<�]^?Y>\AC?=>$p U ]^bCb N >@]^? N IYZSLf>@? ` FYA M >_� � � ¤ AC? U ?Y>@L�<�>$FY>t]^? � >$bCb¨�iÀ¸<�>@H3]

I�]_?Y� ?BIK]^FBIY?�>¢�a> `@U IYACH�s�>qZcF�FY>@?kI�]^FkIK?�dqZ^bCbCZ � AXH�st]'l�FB>@> W lfIYACZcH�@��JIK<�> � ZcFB?BI ` ]^?B> U Hfo2HfAC?Y<f>@L� ZcFY��AC? ` <�> ` �_>@LÁ]_H�L ` Z W l2]_FY>@L � AXIK<~´�>d­µ@¢� � d�]�IP´v>¤­µ@��yIK<f>+I�]^?B�3AX?}F U H½]_I ��� U HJIKACb#AXI

AC? ` Z W l�bC>¢IK>$L½ZcF�l�FB>@> W lfIY>@L MJN ]^H�Z^IY<�>@FEI�]^?B��� � d M >@bXZ � ´v>d­µ@¢� � > L�>$IY>@F W ACHf>+IK<�>1Hf>¢�VIIKA W >;Ä � <�>@H´IY<�> � ZcFB?BIk¹ ` ]_?Y> U Hao2H�AC?B<�>@L � ZcFB� � ACbCb=>$p U ]^b»ÄÅ>¤­µ@���:=<�> ���! AX?SF U H´]�I� o U H)IYACbG>@A�IK<�>$F�Ä*AC?\FY>@] ` <�>$L�ZcF|IK<�>PI�]^?B��<�]^? ` Z W l�bC>¢IK>@L�ZcF M >$>@HÁlfFY>@> W laIK>@L �mÀ¸<f>@H

]½I�]^?B�ÁAC? ` Z W lfbC>$IY>@L�ZcF1l�FB>@> W lfIY>@L�� � >�FY> ` ]^b `@U bC]_IK>8IY<�> � ZcFB?BIk¹ ` ]_?Y> U Hfo2H�AX?Y<�>$L � ZcFY�

ACH�IY<�>3? N ?BIK> W � � d}IY<�>�I�]^?B��AC? l�FY>$> W lfIK>$L��¡IY<�>@H ` ]^b `@U bC]_IKAXH�s�IK<f> U Hfo2H�AX?Y<�>$L � ZcFY��AX?

?BIYFK]^AXsc<JIYdqZcF � ]_FYL��i:=<f>}] W Z U HJIGZ^d � Z^FY�1L�ZcHf>E?BACH ` >�IY<�>�bn]^?kI�IYA W >rIK<�>=IK]^?Y� � ]^?�FY>@? U W >@L

ZcF¡>¢�a> `$U IK>$L3AX?�? U M IKFY] ` IY>@L�dqFYZ W IY<�> U Hfo�H�AC?B<�>@L � ZcFY�PACH/IY<�>�? N ?kIK> W IKZ+sc>$IrIY<�> `$U FYFB>@HJI

U Hfo�H�AC?B<�>@L � ZcFY��ACH*IY<�>8? N ?kIK> W � ��U I1A�d=IK<�>SI�]^?B��AX?�Zvgc>@F$��IK<�> � ZcFB?BIB¹ ` ]^?B> U Hfo2HfAC?Y<f>@L

Ê ~

Page 23: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

� ZcFY�3AC? ` ]^b `$U bn]_IY>@L�Lf>@l�>@H�L�AXH�s U l�ZcH�IK<f>�dqZcbCbXZ � AXH�s ` ZcH�LfAXIKAXZcH�? � � dGIK<f>1L�>�]^LfbCACHf>+Z^dGIK<f>

H�>��aI�IK]^?Y�8AX?=scFY>@]_IK>$FrIK<2]_H�IY<�>\L�>�]^LfbCACHf>�Z^d#IK<�AX?rI�]^?B��> ¦ U ?kI�o2H�AC?B<�>@L�@rIY<�>@H+¦ U ?kI�? U M IYFK] ` IIK<f> ] ` I U ]^b(>��a> `@U IKACZ^H¬IYA W >;>qFY> W ]^AXH�ACH�s!@�Z^dGIY<�>�I�]^?B�3dqFBZ W IY<�> U Hao2H�AC?B<�>@L � ZcFY��IKZ�sc>¢I

IK<f> `$U FYFB>@HJI U Hfo2HfAC?Y<f>@L � ZcFB��ACH½IK<f>1? N ?BIY> W � � d�IK<f>PLf>�]^L�bXACH�>1Z_d¡IY<�>1H�>¢�VItI�]^?B��AC?|bX>@?B?

IK<�]^HÁIK<�>/L�>�]^LfbCACHf>/Z^d=IY<�>/I�]_?Y�8¦ U ?BI�o�H�AC?B<�>@L��iIY<�>@H6sc>$H�>@FY]_IK>8]^H�Z^IY<�>@F�lf?Y> U L�Z�I�]^?B�*AXH

IK<f>E? N ?kIK> W � A�IK<SIY<�>�?K] W >El�>@FBACZVL/]_?�IY<2]_I¡Z^d IY<�>EIK]^?Y�E¦ U ?kI�o2HfAC?Y<f>@L~>q?K] N ��� @¢�)>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcHIKA W > l���ms�P��� ¹j� m����U� ��]_H�LSIY<�>}?Y] W >EL�>�]_L�bCAXH�>}]_?�IY<2]_IrZ_d ��� ��:=<�AC?�l�?B> U L�Z�IK]^?Y� AX?bCAX�^>�]^H N Z^IK<f>@FGI�]^?B���a>¢� ` >$lfIrIY<2]_I�IK<�> ` l U AC?�ACL�bX> � <fACbC>�>��f> `@U IYACH�s+AXI��(©>$I¡ZcH�bCAXH�>¢¹¿I�]^?B��>qI7@L�>$H�Z^IK>�IY<�>�I�]_?Y�3IY<2]_I|AX?�F U H�H�ACHfs U H�L�>$F�IK<�>1ZcHfbCACHf>+? ` <f>@L U bX>P]_I�IKA W >tI��\9rIt]^H N IYA W >^�

I���IY<�>ml�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F � ACbCb M >�F U H�H�AXH�s¬]_I bXZ � g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�>¢� ` >@lfI � <�>$H&]^H N Z_d�IY<�>�dqZcbCbXZ � ACH�s

` Z^H�L�AXIYACZcHf?=AC?=?K]�IKAC?ko2>@L �

Ê ��Z�·PAXH�> IK]^?Y��>qI�@ l ZcH�bXACH�> I�]_?Y��>qI�@¢�~a�·:=<f> � Z^FY?BIk¹ ` ]^?Y> U Hao2H�AC?B<�>@L � ZcFY� U H�Lf>@F/IY<�>�ZcH�bXACH�>3]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W AX?S>$p U ]^b}IYZÆ´v>¤­µ@¢�� d\]^H N Z^d�IY<�>@?B> ` ZcH�L�A�IKACZ^H�?P]^FY>�?K]_IYAC?ko2>@L��rIY<�>�l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F/F U H�?8]_IS<�AXsc<�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>_��:=<�>

] M Zvgc>¢¹ W >$HJIKACZ^H�>@L3]^bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W s U ]_FK]^HJIK>$>@?�IK<2]�I�H�Z1I�]^?B� � ACbCb W AX?Y?=A�IK?=L�>@]^L�bCAXH�>^�

Îf�ÏÎf� Ê Ë g^>@FY<f>�]^L�?

¥GZcbXIK]^sc>�¹ ` bXZ ` �P? ` ]^bCAXH�s1L�> ` AC?BACZcHmAX?rI�]^�_>@H�]�I=IK<�>|dqZcbXbCZ � ACH�s+lyZcAXHJIK? �

Ê �GÀ¸<�>@Hj]1IK]^?Y�/AC?=l�FB>@> W lfIY>@LjZ^F ` Z W l�bC>¢IK>$L��

~a�GÀ¸<�>@H�IK<�>\Z�·PACHf> `@U Fkgc>tACHJIK>$FY?Y> ` IY?�IY<�>\ZcH�bCAXH�> `$U FBg^>^�:=<�>�ZQg^>@FB<�>�]^L8]^?Y?BZ ` An]_IY>@L � AXIY<PIY<�AC?G]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W ` ]^H M > M Z U H�L�>@L MJN IK<�>=d»] ` IGIK<2]_I � >

�)H�Z � IK<�>\I�]_?Y��]^FYFBAXg_]^b�>$lyZ ` <�?$��9EbCbXZ � AXH�s1dqZcF=IK<�>\d»] ` IEIY<2]_I}]P? ` ]^bXACH�sS] ` IYACZcH W ] N <�]vg^>

IKZ M >|I�]^�_>@H�]_I=IY<�>�gc>$F N�M >@scAXH�H�AXH�s1Z^d�IK<�>|>��a> `@U IKACZ^H3ZcF�]�IrIK<�>|AXHJIK>@FB?Y> ` IKAXZcHmlyZ^ACHJI��VIK<�AX?

M Z U H�L�AC?=scA�gc>$H MJN Ç l ¨ >dÈ xyÉ r�Ê È-� ¨ ­ ©%ª� ©¯ ­c@� <�>$FY>\IK<�>|dqZcbXbCZ � ACH�s+H�Z^I�]�IKACZ^H�AC? U ?B>@L �

Ê Î

Page 24: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

¨ £ U W�M >$F�Z^d(AXHJIK>@FB?Y> ` IKAXZcH�lyZcAXHJIK?�]^H�L�IK]^?Y� ` Z W lfbC>$IYACZcHf?rl�b U ? ÊÈ xyÉ r Ë gc>$FY<�>@]^LjZ^d(�=¥ T ] ` IYACZcHÈ � ÂDË$ÌÎÍ k Ì g Ë Ë gc>$FY<�>@]^LjZ^d ` ]_b `@U bn]_IYACH�s1AXH)IY>@FB?Y> ` IKAXZcHmlyZcAXHJI

Îf�ÛÚ � W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^Hm��>$I�]_ACbC?

Îf�ÛÚ�� Ê �E]^FYL � ]^FB>tDGbC]_IYdqZ^F W

À*>tA W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L�Z U F�l�FYZ^IYZ^I N ly>t? N ?kIK> W ZcH�9�� ��� H�scACHf>@>@FBACH�s ¼ ? � HJIK>$b#¾}? ` ]_bC> � ���

M ZJ]^FYL �+:=<�>1¾�? ` ]^bX>1l�bn]�IYdqZcF W ? U l�l�ZcFBIY?\H�ACH�>�dqFB>@p U >$H ` N bX>$gc>$bC?|FY]^H�scAXH�s/dqFYZ W ~^�c�mh�<��

IKZSÔ^Î^ÎSh�<��eH Ê Ô J �¡�r©�� ��IY<�>\ACH�l U I�FY>$dq>$FY>$H ` > ` bXZ ` �/dqZ^F � H)IY>@b¾�? ` ]^bX>\l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F@��] `@` >@lfIY?]^H½AXH�l U I ` bCZ ` �mdqFY>@p U >$H ` N Z^d�ÎcÎ/IKZ8åcåmh3<��_�'D�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF U ?B>@?\]^H½AXH)IY>@FBH2]^biDG©�©�IKZ8bXZ ` �

IKZ IK<f>'AXH�l U I ` bXZ ` �m]_H�L W U bXIYACl�bXAC>@?¡IK<�>\dqFY>$p U >@H ` NjMJN ]1g^]_FYAn] M bC> W U bXIKAXl�bCAX>@F§> ` <2]^HfsJ] M bX>IK<fFYZ U s^<j?YZ_d�I � ]^FB>@=IKZ/lfFYZVL U�` >']S<fACsc<a¹ ?Yl�>@>$L ` Z^FY> ` bCZ ` �³>¿�=�r©���@¢��:=<�AX?EscA�gc>$?}?YZ_d�I � ]^FB>IK<f>S] M ACbXAXI N IKZ ` <2]^Hfsc>PIY<�>1dqFY>$p U >@H ` N � AXIK<fZ U I\<2]�gVACH�s�IYZ�FB>@?B>$ItIK<�> ` Z^FY>^� � HJIY>@b�¾�? ` ]^bX>

]^bX?YZ�? U l�l�ZcFkIK?tbCZ � gcZ^bXI�]_sc> Zcly>$FK]_IYACZcH � A�IK<Á] ` Z^FY>P? U l�lfb N ]^?tbCZ � ]^?'�f� Þ �8¥���9rI+>@] ` <

gcZ^bXI�]_sc>=bC>¢gc>@b¨�cIK<�>$FY>�AC?i] W ]��aA W U W ` bCZ ` �'dqFB>@p U >@H ` N >¿�=�r©���@¢�cIY<�Z U sc< ` ZcFY> ` ]^HSZ^ly>$FK]_IY>]_I#bCZ � >@F�dqFY>$p U >@H ` AC>@?#AXdfL�>@?BACFB>@L�� � H)IY>@bJ¾�? ` ]^bX>r�rD e ¼ ? ` ZcFB>¡Z^HtIY<�AC? M Zc]^FYL\AC?�l�Z � >$FY>@L'dqFYZ W

Ê �Ì�t¥�� ` FB>�]_IY>@L MJN ]�? � AXI ` <fACH�s�FB>@s U bn]_IYZcFG>»©a: Ê Ô^åcÔ2@¢����Z � >¢gc>@F$��IK<�AX? ` ]^H M > ` <2]^H�sc>$L M)Ng_]^F N AXH�st]�?YACHfscbC>=FB>@?YAX?BIK]^H ` >�AXH ]\FY]^H�sc>rdqFBZ W Ê � ~�¥�IYZ Ê �ÌÕ�¥�� � N U ?YAXH�s\9�� � >@H�scAXH�>@>$FYAXH�s ¼ ?

� ��� M Zc]^FYL � > � >@FB>P] M bC>�IYZ�sc>$I|dqFB>@p U >$H ` N ¹ g^ZcbXIK]^sc>P? ` ]^bn] M bC>�l�bC]_IYdqZ^F W � AXIY< W ACHfA W ]^b

` <2]^Hfsc>@?�ACH�IK<f> ` ACF `@U A�I��

LT1767−ADJ

3.3 VR64

FB 10 1.5 V to CPU Core

Quad Analog Switch

VHp 34401AMultimeter

ADJ

¤ AXs U FY>\Îa� Ê � ÿiöíþ����)öøì��röøî�ïvþBîvý��Ê Ú

Page 25: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

¥GZcb�I�]^sc> �rD e dqFY>@p~>¿h3<��%@Ê �Ì~ ÚJ�^�Ê �Ì� Ô^Î^Î

:(] M bC>\Îf� Ê � éêQëíì�î�ïvðKñ¿òcófð�ð�ô8ò^ð�ìõì�öø÷JïQù�

� d1dq>@>$L M ] ` �{FY>@?BAC?kI�]^H ` >Ï>¨��å^Ú�@�AC?3?Y<�Z^FBI ` ACF `@U A�IK>@L � Ê � ��¥ºL�FYZ^l�?3IYZ Ê �Ì~�¥�� T Z´AXH

l�FBACH ` ACl�bX>^��A�d � >�l�bn] ` >�]�? � A�I ` <;] ` FYZ^?Y?jIY<�AC?�FY>$?YAC?kI�]^H ` >^� U l�ZcH·? � AXI ` <�ACH�s�AXI Ë £ � >

� ACbXbrsc>¢I8]�? U l�lfb N gcZ^bXI�]_sc>mZ^d Ê �Ì~¬¥ ]^HfL&? � A�I ` <�AXH�s*A�I Ë ¤(¤ � AXbCb=l�FBZaL U�` > Ê �Ì�½¥+��9E?

?Y<fZ � H3ACHmo2s U FB>tÎf� Ê ��IK<�>tlyZ � >@F�FY>$s U bn]�IKZcF ` ACF `$U AXI�Z_d(IK<f> M ZJ]^FBL3AX? W ZVL�AXo�>@L MJN l�bn] ` ACH�s

]^H·h�h�Ô_ÚJ�}��ÚJ�cåcån>»p U ]^L·]^H2]^bXZcs�? � AXI ` <�@3] ` FYZc?B?�IY<�>�dq>$>@L M ] ` �{FB>@?BAC?BIK]^H ` >*Z^d1l�Z � >$F

FY>$s U bC]_IKZcF$� :=<�AC?8? � AXI ` <{AX? ` ZcHJIYFYZcbXbC>@L�IK<�FBZ U sc<´IY<�>��r�Jh�~Ál�ZcFBI@� MJN ` ZcH�H�> ` IYACH�s�IK<f>

�(: T bXACH�>'Z^dGIK<�>�?B>@FBAn]^b�lyZcFkI¢>¨� Ë hj~2@�IKZ8IY<�> ` Z^H)IYFYZcb�l�ACH?>ql�ACH Ê Î!@EZ^d�IY<�AC?}? � AXI ` <��t:=<�>�(: T bXACH�>tAC?E>@A�IK<�>$F�]_I Ê �1¥ÆZcFE]_IE¹��P¥���À�> � FYA�IK>']Sg_]^b U >tIKZ���: T bCAXH�>'? U�` <½IK<2]�I}IK<f>

? � A�I ` <¬AC?}ACH�IK<f> Ë £ß?BI�]�IK> � <�>$H Ê �Ì~S¥GZcb�IK?�AX?�FY>$p U ACFY>$L���]^H�L Ë ¤i¤ Z_IK<�>$F � AC?B>^�tÀ*> U ?B>

]8L�AXZaL�>+]^H�L Ê �/�\Z^< W FB>@?BAC?BIYZcF}IYZ ` bXACljIY<�>+gcZ^bXI�]_sc>'IYZm�S¥ÆAXd�IY<�>�AXH�l U I}scZa>$?}IKZ/¹��P¥��

e ?BACH�sPIK<�AX? ` ACF `$U AXI@��]SIKZ^IK]^b�Z^d¡~ g^ZcbXIK]^sc>t?Y>¢IYIKAXH�sc? Ê � ~1¥Æ]^H�L Ê � �1¥Æ]^FB> W ]^L�>']�g^]_ACbn] M bC>

IKZ1IY<�>\�^>@FBH�>@b¨�

¥GZcbXIK]^sc>�¹ ` bXZ ` ��? ` ]^bCAXH�s�Zvg^>@FY<f>�]^L�?SACH ` b U Lf>�IY<�>3lf<2]^?Y>�¹õbXZ ` �_>@L´bXZaZclÐ>»D�©�©(@1? N H ` <�FBZ_¹H�AX��]_IYACZcH�IKA W >+Z_d¡~^�c�c� ` l U½` N ` bC>@?\]_H�L�� M ]_?Y>@L½Z^H?HÛÎcÎ J �]_l�l�FYZ��aA W ]_IY>@b N Úc�ÒÑ�?Y> ` ZcHfL�?|Z^dgcZ^bXI�]_sc>8?BIK] M AXbCAC�@]_IKAXZcH½IKA W >_�½ÚJ��Ñ�?Y> ` ZcHfL�?1AC?+IY<�>/IYA W >SI�]_�^>@H MJN g^ZcbXIK]^sc>SFY>@s U bn]_IYZcF'IYZ

l�FBZaL Uf` >E]\?kI�] M bC>=gcZcb�I�]^s^>�]^H�LPL U FYAXH�s|IK<�AX?�IKA W >rl�>@FBACZVL IY<�>�l�FYZ ` >$?Y?BZcF ` ZcHJIKAXH U >@?GIKZtF U H��

]^b M >$AXI�]_I�]1bXZ � >@F�?Bly>$>@L��

:=<�>�?Yl�>@>$L;gcZcb�I�]^sc> ` Z W+M ACH2]�IKACZ^H�?�IY<2]_I � >�<2]�g^> U ?Y>$L dqZ^FjZ U Fj>¢�aly>$FYA W >$H)IY?½]^FB>

? U WSW ]^FYAX�@>$L�ACHm:(] M bC>tÎf� Ê �

Îf�ÛÚ��Ì~ T Z^d�I � ]_FY>\9}F ` <�AXIY> ` I U FY>

À*>/A W l�bC> W >$H)IY>@L�Z U F+g^ZcbXIK]^sc>/? ` ]^bXACH�sj]^bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W AXH�IK<f> � W�M >$L�L�>$L&��Z^Hfo2s U FY] M bX>

Ë ly>$FK]_IYACH�s ? N ?kIK> W >q>v��Zc?Ó@¢��>���Zc?}AX?�]P<�AXsc<�b N ` Z^Hfo2s U FY] M bX>tFB>�]^bIYA W >|Zcly>$FK]_IYACH�s ? N ?kIK> WÊ �

Page 26: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

HÛ~^� J � � gc>$F N > W+M >$L�L�>@L¸? N ?kIK> W <2]^?�H�>$>@L�?�Z^dtAXIY?8Z � H��Íh3Zc?kIm> W�M >@LfL�>@L�Zcl�>@FK]�IKACHfs

? N ?kIK> W ?�IKZVL2] N lfFYZvgVACL�> W ZcFY>�d U H ` IKACZ^H2]^bCA�I N IK<2]_H IY<�>=] ` I U ]_b�FY>$p U ACFY> W >$HJIK?�Z^d�ACHfL�AXgVACL U ]^b

]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?$� :=<�AX?j>��aIYFK]&d U H ` IKAXZcH2]^bXAXI N AXH)IYFYZVL U�` >@? U HfH�>@>$L�>@L ` Z W l�bX>¢�aAXI N AXH)IYZ&IK<f>

?YZ_d�I � ]^FB>^��>���Zc?¡lfFYZvgVACL�>$?�IY<�> ` ZcHJIKFBZcb�IKZ\IK<�>�L�>¢gc>$bCZcl�>@FGIKZtFY> W Zvgc>�? Uf` <Sd U H ` IKAXZcH2]^bXAXI N ]_?

AC?�HfZ^IGH�>@>$L�>@L � � IG<2]^? W Z^FY>�IY<2]^H/~^�c� ` Z^Hfo2s U FY]_IKAXZcH1l�ZcACHJIK?�> � <�A ` < ` ]_H M > ` <�Zc?B>@H U ?YAXH�s] ` ZcHfo�s U FK]�IKACZ^HmIYZaZ^bd@r]^H�L ` ]_H M > U ?Y>@L3dqZcF=o2H�>¢¹ scFK]_ACH�>$L3? ` ]^bC] M ACbXAXI N ��>v��Zc? ` ]^H3l�FYZvgVACLf>

IK<f> M ]^?YA ` d U H ` IYACZcH2]_bCAXI N Z^dr]^H��(: Ë T � A�IK< W > W ZcF N dqZaZ^IYl�FYAXHJI|ACH½IK>$H�?\IKZm< U H�L�FB>@L�?tZ^d

� � N IK>$?@��:=<�> ` ZcFB>\d U H ` IYACZcH2]_bCAXIYAC>$?�l�FBZQgVAXL�>@L MJN >v��Zc?�]^FB> �

O �}]^FBL � ]_FY>�9 M ?kIKFK] ` IKAXZcH´©�] N >$F�>»�E9}©Ô@ ¹ � ISlfFYZvgVACL�>$?/]¬?YZ^d�I � ]^FB>jbn] N >@F1IK<2]�I/scA�gc>$?

sc>@H�>$FK]^b�] `@` >$?Y?�IKZ <2]^FBL � ]_FY>^�

O �\>$FYH�>$b�¹ � IrACH ` b U L�>$?rACHJIY>@FYF U lfI�]_H�L�>¢� ` >$lfIKAXZcHm<2]^H�LfbCACHfs��VIY<�FY>@]^Lm]^H�L�? N H ` <�FYZ^H�AC�@]�¹

IKACZ^H�? U l�l�ZcFBI@��] ` <�ZcA ` >\Z^d(? ` <�>@L U bC>$FY?@��IKA W >$FY?$� ` Z U HJIK>@FB?}]_H�Lj]_bn]^F W ?$�

O � T Ë �{]_H�L W ]_IY<�bCA M FK]^FBAC>@?

O ��>$gVA ` >tLfFYAXg^>@FB?k¹ � I�ACH ` b U Lf>@?�?BIK]^H�L2]^FBL3?B>@FBAn]^b¨�f>$IY<�>@FBH�>$I@� ¤ bn]^?B<�� Ë hÝ]^HfL�Z_IK<�>$FY?@�

O [t£ e Lf> M U s^sc>@F�>¿[\� � @(? U l�lyZ^FBI�¥ � I¡lfFYZvgVACL�>$?�IK]^FYsc>¢I�?YZ^d�I � ]^FY>�dqZcF ` Z WSW U H�A ` ]_IB¹

ACH�s � AXIY<�]S[\� � <�Zc?kI��

� Z^IY<1>v��Zc?G]_H�L1IK<�>=]_l�l�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH'F U H1AXH1? U l�>@FkgVAC?YZ^F W ZVL�>_�(:=<�>$FY>�AC?�H�Z|L�AXgVAX?YACZ^H M >¢I � >$>@H

U ?B>@Fi]_H�L��^>$FYH�>$b W ZaLf>@?#ACH+>���Zc?@� � I(AX?#IY<�>�FB>@?Yl�ZcH�?BA M AXbCA�I N Z^d�IY<�>r]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH\L�>¢gc>@bXZcl�>@F�IYZ

I�]_�^>�lfFYZcl�>@F ` ]^FB> � <fACbC> � FBAXIKAXH�s�]^H+> W�M >@L�L�>$L1]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH��Q]^?�]�?YACHfscbC>GA W l�FBZcly>$F�lyZcAXHJIK>@F

] `$` >@?B? ` ]^H � ACl�>1Z U I|IK<f> � <fZcbC>1? N ?kIK> W � � H W ]_H N Zcl�>@FK]�IKACHfs�? N ?BIY> W ?@�#ACHJIK>$FYF U lfIK?t]^FB>

L�AX?K] M bX>@L8L U FYAXH�s+IK<f>�>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH�Z^d�? ` <�>@L U bC>@FB? M U IrIY<�AC?¡AC?¡H�Z^I�IY<�> ` ]^?Y> � A�IK<8>���Zc?@�G:=<�AX?

�^>$>@l�?|AXHJIK>@FBF U laI�bn]�IK>@H ` N bCZ � ��:=<�>�>v��Z^?��^>$FYH�>$biA W l�bC> W >$HJIK?=I � Z�?kI�]_IYA ` l�FYAXZcFYA�I NmM ]^?B>@L

l�FB>@> W lfIYAXgc>\? ` <�>@L U bC>@FB? �

Ê ��h U bXIYACbX>$gc>$b�Õ U > U > Ta` <�>$L U bX>@F � :=<�AC?�? ` <�>@L U bC>$F\]^bCbXZ � ?�IK<�>+>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH½Z^d W U b�IKAXl�bC>

IK<�FB>�]^L�? ]�I1>�] ` <�Z^d�A�IK?�l�FBACZcFBAXI N bC>¢gc>$bC?@��D�FYAXZcFYA�I N bX>$g^>@bC? ` ]^H M > ` ZcHfo�s U FY>$L�dqFYZ W

Ê å

Page 27: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ê IYZjÎJ~V� ` ZcFYFB>@?BlyZcHfL�ACH�s�IKZ�l�FYAXZcFYA�I N H U W�M >@FB?+�E>»<fACsc<�>$?BItl�FBACZcFBAXI N @EIKZ3Î Ê >»bXZ � >@?kIl�FYAXZcFYA�I N @��(:=<�AX?�? ` <�>@L U bC>@Fr]^bCbXZ � ?GIK<f>}l�FB>@> W lfIYACZcHSZ^d�]+bXZ � >@F�¹õl�FBACZcFBAXI N IY<�FY>@]^L MJN ]<�ACsc<f>@Fk¹ l�FYAXZcFYA�I N IK<�FB>�]^L3]^H�LmAXI=]^bC?BZP? U l�l�ZcFBIY?=IKA W >�?BbCA ` ACH�s � AXIK<fACHm]1l�FYAXZcFYA�I N bX>$g^>@b¿�

~a� � AXI W ]^l Ta` <�>$L U bC>$F � :=<�AX?r? ` <�>$L U bX>@F�]^bXbCZ � ?�IY<�>�>��f> `@U IYACZcHmZ^dIY<�FY>@]^L�?=]�I W U b�IKAXl�bC>

l�FYAXZcFYA�I N bC>¢gc>$bC? M U IPH�Z¬I � Z�IK<�FB>�]^Lf? ` ]^H�<�]vg^>�IY<�>�?K] W >ml�FYAXZcFYA�I N bX>$gc>$b¿� � IS]^bC?BZ

A W l�bC> W >$H)IY?8l�FB>@> W lfIYAXgc>½? ` <�>@L U bCAXH�s��EIY<�Z U s^<¸IYA W >�?YbXA ` ACH�sÁAX?�ACFBFY>@bX>$g_]^HJI�AXH´IK<�AX?

? ` <�>$L U bC>$F@�

:=<�> `@U FYFY>$HJIKb N ]vg_]^AXbn] M bC>}>���Zc?�? ` <�>$L U bX>@FY?�L�ZcH ¼ I�<2]�gc>|IY<�>\H�Z^IKAXZcH�Z^d�ly>$FYAXZaL�?�]_H�LmL�>�]^LV¹

bCAXH�>@?$��]^H�L�]^bXb(Z^d�IK<�> W ]^FB>�of�a>@La¹ l�FYAXZcFYA�I N ¹ M ]^?B>@L¬? ` <�>$L U bX>@FY?$�1À*> <2]�gc> A W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L¬]

L N H2] W A ` ¹õl�FBACZcFBAXI N ¹ M ]^?Y>$L½? ` <�>$L U bC>$F'AXH¬>v��Zc?$�/:=<�AX?t? ` <�>@L U bC>$F'AX? M ]^?Y>$L*ZcH¬IK<f> � ]^FBbCAX>@?BI

��>�]_L�bCAXH�> ¤ AXFY?kI�> � � ¤ @�l�ZcbXA ` N HÛ~ ÊKJ ��D�FYAXZcFYA�IKAC>$?(]_FY>rIK<f>@FY>¢dqZcFY>�]_?Y?YAXscH�>$LS]�IGF U H1IKA W > M ]^?B>@LZcH�IK<f>\IK]^?Y�)? ¼ Lf>�]^L�bXACH�>$?@�

:=<�> M AXI W ]^l\? ` <f>@L U bX>@F�AC?�]�?kI�]_IYA ` ¹ l�FYAXZcFYA�I N ¹ M ]^?B>@L\l�FB>@> W lfIYAXgc>�? ` <f>@L U bX>@F$� � I(? U l�l�ZcFBIY?

U l�IKZ8Îc~1IK]^?Y�)?v>qZcF=IK<�FB>�]^L�?Ó@�AXH�IY<�>+? N ?kIK> W �=:=<�>+]^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH � FYAXIY>@F�]_I�IK<�> M >@scAXH�H�ACHfs]^?B?YACs^H�?�]\lfFYACZ^FYAXI N IKZt]|IK<�FB>�]^L � <�A ` <PAC?�FB>$IK]^ACH�>$L�� U H ` <2]_H�sc>@L �VdqZcFiIY<�>=IK<�FB>�]^L ¼ ?�bCA�dq>$IKA W >_�

£EZ\I � Z'IK<fFY>�]_L�? ` ]^HP<2]�gc>EIY<�>�?K] W >�l�FYAXZcFYA�I N ��:=<�>El�>@FBACZVL�A ` H2]_I U FY>�Z^d FB>�]^b�IYA W >rI�]^?B�)?¡AX?

` ]_lfI U FB>@L M)N ]1L�>$bn] N d U H ` IKAXZcH � <�A ` <�l U IY?�IY<�>|I�]^?B��ACH�]�Ö!×2Ø�ØBÙ�?BI�]�IK>|dqZcF�] IYA W >�>@p U ]_bIKZ A�IK?=l�>@FYAXZaL �

:=<�>�g_]^FYAXZ U ?�?kIK>@lf?�AXH)g^ZcbXg^>@L\ACH|IY<�>�>v��Zc?��_>@FYHf>@bJdqFYZ W IK<fFY>�]_L ` FY>�]�IKACZ^H�IKZ�AXIY?�>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH

]^FB> �

OLÚBÛ�Ü Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á ÚBß Ø�à Ý Ø�â�ã � :=<�AX?�d U H ` IYACZcHmAC? U ?B>@L3ACH�>v��Zc?�IKZ ` FB>�]_IY>+]1I�]^?B��� � HmIK<�AX?� >|l�FBZvgaAXL�>�IK<f>�l�FYAXZcFYA�I N ]_I � <�A ` <�IK<�>}IK]^?Y� � ACbXb M >�F U H��fl�ZcACHJIY>@F�IYZ+IK<�> ` ZaLf>}IK<2]�I

� ACbCb M >m>��f> `@U IY>@L�]_H�L6lyZcAXHJIK>@F�IYZ¬?BI�] ` �6]^H�L6H2] W >�Z^d�IK<�>�IK<fFY>�]_L���9}?P]½FY>$? U b�I

Z^dEIY<�AC?�d U H ` IYACZcH�]�IK<�FB>�]^L6AX? ` FY>@]_IK>$L&]_H�L�AX?�FY>$scAC?kIK>$FY>@L�ACH�IY<�>�? N ?BIY> W � AXIY<�AXIY?

l�FYAXZcFYA�I N � � H�A�IKAC]^bCb N �)IK<�FB>�]^L�AC? ` FY>�]�IK>@L�ACH�IY<�>\?YbC>$>@l�?BIK]_IK>_��]^H�L�AC?=?BIK]^FBIY>@L MJNy�

Ê Ô

Page 28: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

OLÚBÛ�Ü Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á ß Ø�Öä!å�Ø�â�ã � :=<�AC?�d U H ` IYACZcH/FY>@? U W >@?=]+?BbC>$>@l�AXH�s'IY<�FY>@]^L�� e l�ZcH ` ]^bCbXACH�sIK<�AX?rd U H ` IYACZcHmIK<f>tHf> � b N ` FY>@]_IK>$L�IY<�FY>@]^L�?BI�]_FBIK?�F U H�H�AXH�s��

OLÚBÛ�Ü Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á æ¶à¶ç Ý â�ã � :=<�AX?�d U H ` IKACZ^H/I�]^�_>@?�]~èkL�>@bC] N�é g_]^b U >�]^?�AXIK?�]^FYs U W >$HJI���]_H�LAC?\l�FYZvgVACLf>@L�IYZml U I+]mIY<�FY>@]^L�AXH�IYZm?YbC>$>@l W ZVL�>�dqZcFt]m?Yl�> ` A�o2>@L*] W Z U HJItZ^d¡IYA W >^�

:=<�AC?td U H ` IYACZcH�AC?t]^bX?YZ U ?Y>@L*ACH*>���Zc?'IYZjA W l�bX> W >@HJI\l�>@FYAXZaLfA ` FY>@]^b�IKA W >1I�]^?B�)?@��9

ly>$FYACZVL�A ` I�]^?B� ` ]^bXbC?iIK<fAC?�d U H ` IKACZ^H � A�IK<PL�>@bC] N >@p U ]^b2IKZtAXIY?Gly>$FYACZVL�� � HPIY<�AC?�d U H ` IKAXZcH

]1IYA W >@FrAXHJIK>@FBF U laI�AC?r?B>$I�dqZcF�]+IKA W >}>@p U ]^b�IYZ IY<�> `@U FYFY>$HJI�IYA W >�l�b U ?rIK<�>|l�>@FBACZVL�Z^d

IK<�>+IK]^?Y�j]^H�LjIY<�>@H½IY<�>�? ` <f>@L U bX>@F|AX? ` ]_bCbC>$L3IYZ�? ` <�>$L U bC> ]_H�Z^IK<f>@F�<�AXsc<�>$?BIB¹ l�FYAXZcFYA�I N

F U H2] M bC>|I�]_?Y�8AXHmIY<�>\? N ?BIY> W �

: � Z W Z^?BI�A W l�ZcFBIK]^HJIrL2]_IK]1?BIKF U�` I U FY>$? U ?B>@L3ACH8IK<f> � AXI W ]^l�? ` <�>@L U bC>@FE]^FB> �

Ê ��F U H�p U > U >

~a�iIY<�FY>@]^L I�] M bC>

F U Hfp U > U >mAC?+]�ÎJ~Q¹ M AXItg_]^b U > � <�A ` <6?BIKZ^FY>@?'IK<�>8?kI�]_I U ?�>»] ` IYAXgc>/ZcF+?BbC>@>$l�ACHfs�@tZ^d�>@] ` <IK<fFY>�]_LÃACH¸IK<f>�? N ?kIK> W �\]^FBFK]^Hfsc>@L M ]^?B>@L·ZcH¸IK<f>@ACFml�FBACZcFBAXI N bX>$g^>@b¿� T Z�F U H�p U > U > � AXbCb

ACHfL�A ` ]_IK>_� MJN IK<�>¬g_]^b U >½?BIKZ^FY>@LÃ]_I3]�l2]^FBIYA `$U bn]^F M AXIml�Zc?YA�IKACZ^H�� � <f>$IK<f>@F�]�I�]_?Y��� � AXIY<

l�FBACZcFBAXI N ` ZcFBFY>@?BlyZ^H�L�ACHfs6IYZ�IK<2]_I M AXI�l�Zc?YA�IKAXZcH���AC?m] ` IKA�gc>½ZcF�H�Z_ImACH´IK<f>�? N ?BIK> W � ¤ ZcF

>¢�f] W l�bX>8]^H�] ` IKA�gc>PI�]^?B� � A�IK<*lfFYACZ^FYAXI N Ô�FY>@? U bXIY?+AXH Ê ]_I M AXI+lyZ^?YAXIYACZcH*Ô3AXH*F U H�p U > U >_�

:=<�>�? ` <�>$L U bX>@F¡o�FY?BI¡? ` ]^H�?GIK<�FBZ U sc< IK<fAC?GF U Hfp U > U >�dqFYZ W ��>»A¨�Ï>_�(<�AXsc<�>$?BI¡l�FYAXZcFYA�I N @�IYZ|o2H�LIK<f>E<�AXsc<�>$?BI�l�FYAXZcFYA�I N ] ` IKA�gc>�I�]^?B�1ACH1IK<�>�? N ?kIK> W ]^H�L IK<f>@H U ?Y>@?�IK<�AX?GH U W�M >$F�]_?¡]_H/ACHfL�>¢�

IKZ�IY<�>1IK<�FB>�]^L IK] M bC>+L2]_I�]�?kIKF Uf` I U FY> IKZmL�>$IY>@F W AXH�>�IK<�> ` ZcFYFB>@?Yl�ZcH�LfACH�smIK<�FB>�]^L¬l�ZcACHJIY>@F@�

IK<fFY>�]_L I�] M bX>jAX?8]^H¸]^FBFK] N Z_d|IK<�FB>�]^L¸l�ZcACHJIK>$FY? � A�IK<�Îc~*>@HJIKFBAC>@?$� Ë H ` >�IK<f>½? ` <�>$L U bC>$F

L�AX? ` Zvg^>@FY?\IK<f>P<fACsc<�>$?BI\l�FBACZcFBAXI N ] ` IYAXg^>�I�]^?B��ACH½IK<f>1? N ?BIY> W ��A�I U ?Y>$?tIY<2]_I\l�FBACZcFBAXI N g_]^b U >

IKZ AXH�L�>¢��ACHJIKZ1IK<f>\IY<�FY>@]^L IK] M bC>�IYZ sc>$I�IK<f>\IY<�FY>@]^L�lyZcAXHJIK>@F�]_H�L�IY<�>@H�? ` <f>@L U bX>@?�AXI@�

:=<�> M AXI W ]_l1? ` <�>$L U bC>$FG? U l�l�ZcFkIK?Gl�FY>�¹õ> W lfIYACZcH � � d�IK<�> `@U FYFY>$HJIKb N F U HfH�ACH�s|IK]^?Y��AX?�Z^dy]

bCZ � >@FrlfFYACZ^FYAXI N IY<2]^H8IY<�>}I�]_?Y� IK<2]_I#¦ U ?BI�]_FYFYA�gc>$L�ACH/IY<�>�? N ?kIK> W �fIY<�>�? ` <f>@L U bX>@F=l�FB>@> W lfIY?

AXI�]_H�Lm? ` <�>$L U bC>$?EIY<�AC?=H�> � b N ¹�]_FYFYA�gc>$L�IK]^?Y���G:=<�AC?�AX?�]^bCFB>�]^L N ? U lflyZcFkIK>$L3AXH�>���Zc?@�

Ê Õ

Page 29: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Îf�ÛÚ��ÏÎ � W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcH�Z_d � � ¤ ACHm>v��Z^?

:=<�>}IK]^?Y�P?BIYF U�` I U FB>�ACHS>v��Zc?r�_>@FBH�>@byAC? W ZVL�AXo2>$LSIYZ+<2]�gc>EIK<�>|]_L�L�AXIYACZcH�]^b2l2]^FY] W >¢IK>$FY? �

O À�� � :

O D�>@FBACZVL

O ��>�]^L�bXACH�>

£E> � 9}D � ?P]^FB> M >@ACHfs½A W l�bC> W >$H)IY>@LÁAXH � � ¤ IKZ ` FB>�]_IY>m]^H�L�F U H�]jI�]^?B� U ?BACH�s½IK<f>

� � ¤ lyZcbXA ` N �

OLÚBÛ�Ü Ø2á�ê Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á Ú]ß Ø�à Ý Øjâ�ã � :=<�AX?�d U H ` IYACZcH|AX?�FY>$?Yl�ZcH�?BA M bX>idqZcF ` FB>�]_IYACH�srIY<�>iIK<fFY>�]_L ¼ ?L2]_I�]=?kIKF `$U IKFB>�ACH�?BACL�>iIY<�>��^>$FYH�>$b)]^H�L\AC? L�ANAy>@FB>@HJIdqFYZ W IK<�>G]_bCFY>@]^L N >¢�aAC?kIKAXH�s ` N s IK<fFY>�]_L ` FB>�]_IY>

ACH�] � ] N IK<�]_I�AXIrIK]^�^>$?}D#>@FYAXZaL �fÀ�� � : ]^?=A�IK?=AXH�l U I�l2]^FY] W >$IK>$F@�

OLÚBÛ�Ü Ø2á�ê Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á æ�à¶ç Ý âDã � :=<�AX?¡d U H ` IKAXZcH/l U IK?�IK<�> `@U FBFY>@HJIrIK]^?Y� AXH)IYZ+?BbC>@>$l W ZaL�>dqZcF\]8L U FY]_IKAXZcH½>@p U ]^biIYZ�AXIY?�ly>$FYAXZaL�� � H½IK<�AX?}d U H ` IKACZ^H � > U l�L2]_IY> IY<�>1l�FBACZcFBAXI N Z^d

]^bCb�] ` IKA�gc>�I�]^?B�V? M ]^?B>@L8Z^HPIY<�>@AXF�FB>@?Bly> ` IKA�gc>EL�>�]^LfbCACHf>@?¡]^H�L IK<�>$H ` ]^bXbfIK<f>E? ` <�>@L U bC>@F$�

À*>¬<2]�g^>�A W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L � � ¤ ? ` <�>@L U bC>@F�ZcH¸IKZcl�Z^d � AXI W ]_l�? ` <�>$L U bC>$F@�ãÀ¸<�>@H{]

I�]_?Y� ` Z W l�bC>¢IK>$?}>¢�a> `@U IYACZcH�� ` ]^bXb#IYZ/IK<�>+H2]_IKA�gc> � AXI W ]^l3? ` <�>$L U bC>$F\]^FY> ` ]^laI U FB>@L MJN Z U F

� � ¤ ? ` <�>$L U bX>@F@� � <�A ` <�o2FB?BI W ZaL�A�o2>@?�IK<�>}l�FYAXZcFYA�IKAC>$?¡Z_d�AXH�L�A�gaAXL U ]^b2IK]^?Y�)? M ]^?B>@LmZcH8IY<�>@AXF

FY>$?Yl�> ` IKAXg^>'Lf>�]^L�bXACH�>$?�]^H�LmIK<�>$H ` ]^bCbyIK<�> � A�I W ]^l�? ` <�>$L U bX>@F@�

Îf�ÛÚ��ÛÚ ¥GZ^bXI�]_sc> Ta` ]^bCAXH�s ]^bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W ACHm>v��Z^?

À*>�o2FY?kI½F U H·IY<�> � � ¤ ]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W IKZ´sc>$H�>@FY]_IK>�IK<�>ÁZB·SAXH�> `$U FBg^> M ]^?B>@L ZcH·IK<f>

ACH�F�]_IK>$L�À´� � :ÆZ^d=L�AëA >$FY>@HJItI�]^?B�)?@��:=<�> � � ¤ ? ` <f>@L U bX>@F'ACH�>v��Zc?'<2]^? M >@>$H W ZaLfAXo2>$L

ACH¬] � ] N IK<2]_I\A�I�o2FB?BI ` ]^b `@U bC]_IK>$?�IK<�>1Z^H�bCAXH�>�bCZc]^L M ]^?B>@L�ZcH�À´� � : Z^d�L�AëA >$FY>@HJI\I�]_?Y�)?]^H�L½IY<�>@H U l�L2]_IY>@?\AXI\] `@` Z^FYL�AXH�scb N � <�>$H�>$g^>@F']�IK]^?Y�3AC?|L�Z^H�>1ZcF|l�FB>¢¹õ> W laIK>@L �'À�>P<�]vg^>

]^bX?YZ�A W l�bC> W >$H)IY>@L�]j�=¥ T IK<fFY>�]_L�IK<�]_I ` Z W l2]^FY>$?'ZB·SAXH�>P]^H�L�ZcH�bCAXH�>1bCZc]^L�IYZ�o�H�L*IK<f>

ÊvÞ

Page 30: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

]^l�lfFYZcl�FBAn]_IY> ���! ?Yl�>@>@L&?Y>$IBIKAXH�sc?@� � d|IY<�>�ZcH�bCAXH�> `@U Fkgc>3AC? M >$bCZ � IK<f>jZ�·PACHf> `$U FBg^>�AXI

L�>¢IK>@F W AXH�>@?\IK<f>SAXH)IY>@FB?Y> ` IKAXZcH�l�ZcAXH)ItZ^d¡IK<�>PZ�·PACHf>S]_H�L*ZcHfbCACHf> `@U Fkgc>@?�]^H�L ` <�]^H�sc>$?'IK<f>

?Y>¢IYIYACH�s\]^?�FB>@p U AXFY>@LP]^HfL IY<�>@H ?BbC>@>$l�?�IKAXbCbJIK<2]�IGACHJIK>$FY?Y> ` IYACZcH1l�ZcACHJI�AX?iFY>@] ` <�>$L�� � gc>@F N IKA W >

]'IK]^?Y� AC?¡L�ZcH�>EZcF�lfFY>¢¹ > W lfIK>$L��)IK<�>�? ` <�>@L U bC>$FrFY> ` ]^b `@U bC]_IK>$?�ZcH�bXACH�>�]^HfL8Z�·PACH�>EbCZJ]_L�?�]_H�L� ]^�^>$? U ljIY<�>��=¥ T IK<�FB>�]^L���:�]^?Y�)?|]_FY>tA W l�bC> W >$H)IY>@L3]^?�dqZcFEbXZaZ^l�?�ACHmIK<�>'?K] W > � ] N ]_?

ACHEHÛ~ J �¡9El�ly>$H�L�Aø��9ä<�]^?�IY<�> ` ZVL�>tZ^d(Z U F�A W l�bC> W >$H)IK]_IKAXZcH��i9El�l�>@H�L�Aø� � Lf>@? ` FYA M >$?EZ U F

A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcHSZ^d�9�D � ? � <fA ` <�ACHJIK>$FBd»] ` >@? � AXIY<�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>¢¹ ` bXZ ` �P? ` ]^bCAXH�s1<2]^FBL � ]_FY>^�

Îf�ÛÚ��Ì� ��>@? U bXIY?

:=<�>/>��aly>$FYA W >@HJIK]^b¡?B>$I U l*dqZcF\IK<�>$?Y>SFY>@? U bXIY?+AX?+]^?\dqZcbXbCZ � ?@��:=<�>S>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH*IYA W >@?\Z^d

]^bXb�IY<�>}I�]_?Y�)?�]^FY>E?Yl�> ` AXo2>$L�AXH/IK>$F W ?rZ^dIY<�>�<�AXsc<a¹ g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�?Y>¢IYIKAXH�s���:=<�>EI�]^?B�/l�>@FYAXZaLf?r]^FB>

` <�Zc?B>@H�FK]^H�LfZ W b N IYZ M > ACHJIK>$sc>@FB? M >$I � >@>$H6~^�c�m]^HfL Ê ~_�c� W ?$�1¥GZcbXIK]^sc>¢¹ ?Yl�>@>$L�?B>$IYIYACH�s^?

dqZcF=Z U F=>¢�aly>$FYA W >$H)IY?}]_FY>|? U WSW ]^FYAX�@>$L�AXHm:(] M bC>\Îf� Ê �

:=<�>1l2]^FY] W >$IK>$FY?EZ^d�A W lyZcFkI�]^H ` >']^FY>+IY<�> � ZcFY?kIB¹ ` ]^?B>1l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F U IKAXbCAX��]_IYACZcH��8ì(í�� IK<f>H U W�M >@FGZ^dyI�]^?B�V?$�f]_H�LPIY<�>�g^]_b U >=Z^d��;>qIY<�>�] ` I U ]^b2>��f> `@U IYACZcHSAC? U HfAXdqZcF W b N L�AX?BIYFYA M U IK>$LSAXHIK<f>rFK]^Hfsc>PHî�#� ��m���� � ��m����»J @�� � H�>$FYs N ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcH1AC?�>¢�al�FB>@?Y?B>@L/]^?�]�l�>@F ` >@HJI�]_sc>Z^dIY<�> ` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcH8A�d�IK<f>�l�FYZ ` >$?Y?BZcF � ]_?rF U Hm]�I=<�ACs^<SgcZ^bXI�]_sc>}L U FYACHfs�>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH�Z^d�IK<f>

I�]_?Y�)?@�

:=<�>�A W l2] ` I�Z^d8�+ZcH1IK<�> ` l U�¼ ?¡>$H�>@FBs N ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH1dqZcF�LfANAy>@FY>$HJI � ZcFB?BIk¹ ` ]_?Y> U IKAXbCAC�@]�¹IKAXZcH�?�AC?E?Y<�Z � H½ACH ¤ ACs U FY>'Îf� ~V�E9E?G��L�> ` FY>�]_?Y>@?$��IK<�>'g^]_FYAn]_H ` >tACH�IK<�>�>��a> `@U IKACZ^H�IKA W >\Z^d

I�]_?Y�)?}AXH ` FB>�]^?B>@?@��:=<�AC? W >�]^H�?�IK<�]_I�IK<�>']PlfFYACZ^FYA�AXHfdqZcF W ]_IYACZcH � >'<�]vg^>�] M Z U I�IY<�>tIK]^?Y�)? ¼

>¢�a> `@U IYACZcHÁIYA W >@?tL�> ` FY>�]_?Y>@?$� ¤ ZcF�] � ZcFB?BI ` ]^?Y> U IKACbXAC�@]_IKAXZcH½Z^d��  �j]^H�L*bC>@?B?@�(IY<�>8>$H)IYACFB>

� ZcFY�)bCZc]^L ` ]^H U ? U ]^bCb N8M >|F U H3]_I�bCZ � gcZcb�I�]^s^>^�2]^HfL3?BZPIY<�>\>@H�>$FYs N ` ZcH�? U W laIKACZ^H�AX?=ÚJ�!ïZ^d�IY<�>+<�AXsc<a¹¿gcZcb�I�]^sc> ` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcH�� ¤ ZcFE] � Z^FY?BI ` ]^?B> U IKAXbCAX��]_IYACZcHmZ^dG�  å8]_H�L W ZcFY>_�yIK<f>

g_]^b U >+Z^d¡] M >@scAXH�?EIYZ W ]^�_>1]^H½A W l2] ` IEZcH½>@H�>$FYs N ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcH�� ¤ ZcF�]S? W ]^bCb�g_]^b U >'Z^d�2� >��f> `@U IYACZcH3IKA W >@?�Z^diIK]^?Y�)?|]_FY> W ZcFB>tg_]^FBAn] M bX>^� � <�A ` < W >�]^H�?�IK<2]�Iv>qdqZ^F}]PscAXg^>@H � ZcFY?kI

` ]_?Y> U IYACbCAX��]_IYACZcH�@�IY<�>r? N ?kIK> W <2]^? W ZcFY>�F U Ha¹¿IKA W >�?YbC] ` ��]^HfL W U ?BIGF U H ]_IG]�bXZ � >$FigcZcb�I�]^sc>

~^�

Page 31: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

dqZcFEbCZcH�s^>@F@��9}?���ACH ` FY>�]_?Y>@?�]^H�LjIY<�>�>¢�a> `@U IYACZcH�IYA W >@?�L�Z8H�Z^IEg_]^F N ]^? W U�` <¬]^H N3W ZcFB>^�

IK<f>t? N ?BIK> W <2]^?�bC>@?B?�F U Ha¹¿IKA W >�?Bbn] ` �m]_H�L3F U H3]_I�<�ACs^<�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�dqZcF=bXZcH�sc>$F@��]^H�LmIK< U ?�IK<f>

>@Hf>@FYs N ` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcH�AXH ` FB>�]^?B>@?@��À¸<�>@H�IY<�> � Z^FY?BI ` ]^?Y> U IYACbXAC��]�IKACZ^H�AX?1�  Õ�ZcF1� ÂÏÞ ��IK<f>

dqFK] ` IKAXZcH�Z^d�IKA W >�IY<�>j? N ?kIK> W <2]^?PIKZ�F U H&]_I/<fACsc<�gcZcb�I�]^sc>�ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>$?8]^HfL&IK<�>3>@H�>$FYs N

` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcHmscZV>@? U l��

number of tasks =6

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Ene

rgy

cons

umpt

ion

(per

cent

)

a

worst case cpu util=0.6worst case cpu util=0.7worst case cpu util=0.8worst case cpu util=0.9

¤ AXs U FY>�Îf� ~V��� ý|óaî�Kì�ê��'êQ÷1ì� Jð§�����8ð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü<�KêQ÷)ù��)ý\ó)ì�öíêQ÷��:=<�>tA W l2] ` IrZ^d�IY<�>\H U W�M >@F�Z^d#I�]^?B�V?�ZcHmIK<�>\? N ?kIK> W >@H�>$FYs N AX?=L U >|IKZ IK<�>|d»] ` I=IK<2]�I

]^?�IK<f>�H U W+M >$F¡Z^d�I�]_?Y�)?¡AXH1IK<�>�? N ?kIK> W AXH ` FB>�]^?B>@?GdqZcFG]ts^AXgc>$HSbXZJ]^L��_IK<�>�? N ?BIY> W <2]_? W ZcFY>

Zcl�l�ZcFkI U H�A�IKAX>@?�IKZ W ZcFY> >�A > ` IKA�gc>$b N >��flfbCZcA�I|IK<�>P?YbC] ` ��� ¤ ZcF|>���] W l�bX>1AXd�IK<�>P? N ?kIK> W <2]_?

ZcH�b N ~'I�]^?B�V?$�fIK<f>�? N ?BIY> W � AXbCb�<2]�gc>|bX>@?B?rZcl�l�ZcFBI U H�A�I N IYZ U ?Y>EdqZcFr]^HfZ^IK<�>$F�I�]_?Y� IK<�>|?Bbn] ` �

FY>$bC>@]^?Y>$L MJN ]^H >@]^FYb N ` Z W l�bX>$IYACZcH�� � HPsc>@H�>$FK]^b¨�cIK<�>�<�AXsc<�>$FiIK<�>rg_]^b U >=Z^dyH U W�M >$FGZ^dyIK]^?Y�)?$�

IK<f>SscFB>�]_IY>@F\AC?|IY<�>/]_Lfg_]^HJI�]^sc>$Z U ?tA W l2] ` I\Z^d�? W ]_bCb(g_]^b U >@?tZ^d�]f�/:=<�AX?\AC?\ACbXb U ?kIKFK]�IK>@L¬AXH

¤ AXs U FY>PÎf�ÏÎ � <f>@FY>PdqZcFt]3? W ]^bXbig_]^b U >1g_]^b U >SZ_d��2�i]3å�¹ IK]^?Y�½? N ?kIK> W l�>@FkdqZcF W ?'HfZ^IKA ` > M b N

M >$IYIY>@F�IY<�>@H�? N ?BIY> W ? � AXIK<�]½? W ]^bXbC>@F'H U W�M >@F1Z^d�I�]^?B�)?@� M U I IK<�AX?�sJ]^l6H2]_FYFYZ � ?P]^? � >

W ZQg^>|IKZP]P<fACsc<�>$Frg_]^b U >|Z_d��2��]^?=?B<�Z � HjACH ¤ AXs U FB>\Îf�ÏÚ

~ Ê

Page 32: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

a=0.25

Worst Case CPU Util

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

no. of tasks=6no. of tasks=4no. of tasks=2

Ene

rgy

cons

umpt

ion

(per

cent

)

¤ ACs U FB>|Îf�ÏÎf��� ý|óVî�Kì�ê�ì� Jð�÷��)ý���ð�þ�êyì�îvù��cùGêQ÷ ì� Jð������/ð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü��KêQ÷)ù��)ý|ó)ì�öíêQ÷��

a=0.75

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

no. of tasks=6no. of tasks=4no. of tasks=2

Worst Case CPU Util

Ene

rgy

cons

umpt

ion

(per

cent

)

¤ ACs U FY>\Îf�ÛÚ���� ý\óVî�KìGê�÷B�)ý���ð�þ�ê�ì�îvù��^ù�êQ÷1ì� Jð������/ð�÷)ð�þ�ïvü��KêQ÷)ù��)ý|óVì�öíêQ÷��~c~

Page 33: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

z ,&�&� ��*� à

�y��³ Å�%\á�% 5PÅ¡x�0��PÈ %Ü×P5PÅ�%�� RSxÜ7�z\² x�ÉS³PÅ¡��È/R�SÅ=R�5P01��%+² u

� W�M >$L�L�>$L{? N ?kIK> W ?3]^FY>½Z_d�IK>@H¸? U M ¦B> ` IK>$L{IKZ�d»] U bXIK?�L U >�IKZ6<2]^FB?Y<�>@HJgVACFBZcH W >@HJI�]^b

` Z^H�L�AXIYACZcHf?@�*:=<f>@?Y>�? N ?kIK> W ?S]^FY>m]^bX?YZ ` Z^H�?BIYFK]^AXH�>@L MJN ?Y>¢gc>$FY>jl�Z � >$FP]^H�LL=�ZcF1>@H�>$FYs N

bCA W A�IK?$� � �f] W l�bC>$?EAXH ` b U L�>t?Yl2] ` >+? N ?kIK> W ?EFY>@b N ACH�sPZcHj?BZcbn]_FE]_H�L M ]_IBIK>$F N l�Z � >@FE? U lfl�b N �

]^H�L+?Y>�] M ZcFBH�>=? N ?kIK> W ? � ZcFY�)AXH�s|Z�A/]}bCA W A�IK>@L M ]�IYIK>$F N ? U lfl�b N � � H+IK<fAC?(l�]^ly>$F@� � >=?BI U L N ]IKFY]^L�>$Z�A M >$I � >@>@H'FY>$bCAn] M ACbXAXI N ]^HfLt>$H�>@FBs N dqZcF�]^H\> W�M >@L�Lf>@Lt? N ?BIY> W ` Z^H�?YAX?BIKAXH�s=Z^d W U b�IKAXl�bC>

FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >�I�]^?B�V?$�

� N H2] W A ` ¥GZcbXIK]^sc> Ta` ]^bXACH�s�<2]^?8> W >$FYsc>$L�]^?�]�lyZ � >@FBd U b W > ` <2]^HfAC? W dqZcFSFY>@L U�` AXH�s

IK<f>j>@Hf>@FYs N ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH�L U FBACH�s�? N ?BIY> W Zcly>$FK]_IYACZcH ��9}H�L W ]^H N `@U FBFY>$H)I8> W�M >@L�Lf>@L

l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcFY?\bXAC�^> � H)IY>@b(¾}? ` ]^bC>_�:�FY]^H�? W >$IK]m��F U ?BZa>P]^bXbCZ � IK<f>@ACF}Zcly>$FK]_IYACH�sSgcZcb�I�]^sc>'IKZ M >

` <2]^Hfsc>@L L N H2] W A ` ]^bCb N � T AXH ` >=]�FB>@L Uf` IKAXZcH�AXH�gcZcb�I�]^sc>¡bC>@]^L�?(IYZ|]�L�FYZ^l1ACH�l�FBZ ` >@?B?YZcF�?Bly>$>@L

]^H�L IK< U ?GAXH ` FB>�]^?B>�AXH1IK<�>�>¢�a> `@U IYACZcHPIKA W >^�c]\H U W+M >$F�Z_d IK> ` <�H�AXp U >@?�<2]�gc> M >$>@HPl�FYZcl�Zc?B>@L

IKZ >��flfbCZcA�I=IK<�AX?rIKFK]_L�>@Z�A����>@]^brIKA W >8IK]^?Y�)?S]^FY>�IYA W > ` ZcH�?kIKFY]^ACH�>$L���A¨�Ï>_��IK<�>�I�]_?Y�)?S<�]vg^>�]½of�a>@L�L�>�]^LfbCACHf> M)N

� <�A ` <jIK<�> N <�]vg^>'IYZ/o2H�AX?Y<j>��a> `@U IKACZ^H��}9rIE>�] ` < ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJI�� IY<�>+? N ?BIK> W ?kI�]_IY>+AX?E?Y]vg^>@L

]^H�L � <f>@Hm]'d»] U bXIrAX?�L�>¢IK> ` IK>$L��fIY<�>�? N ?kIK> W AC?¡FY>@?kI�]^FkIK>$LmdqFBZ W IK<�> W Zc?kIrFB> ` >$HJI�]�g^]_ACbn] M bC>

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)I@�*:=<�>$FY>�AX?1] ` Zc?kIP]^?Y?BZ ` An]_IY>@L � A�IK< ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sf� � <fA ` <6ACH ` b U Lf>@?�?Y]vgVAXH�s

IK<f>�lfFYZ ` >@?B? ?BI�]�IK>�IKZ�]½?Y> `@U FB>3L�>¢gVA ` >_�ÁÀ¸AXIY<�Z U I ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfs���]�d»] U bXI ` ]^H�bX>�]^LÁIYZ

FY>$?BIK]^FBI�Z^d�I�]_?Y�1dqFYZ W IY<�> M >@scAXH�H�AXH�s�����<f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s�FY>$L U�` >@?rFB>¢¹ ` Z W l U I�]�IKACZ^HPIYA W >�L U >

IKZ1d»] U bXIK?$�

��>@]^bEIYA W >�IK]^?Y�)?�H�Z^F W ]^bCb N L�Z�H�Z^I/F U H´IYZÁIK<�>$ACF � ZcFB?BI ` ]^?Y>½>��a> `@U IKACZ^H´IKA W >�]_H�L

IK<fAC?=IKA W > ` ]^H M >tFY> ` bn]^A W >$L�L U FBACH�s IK<�>\F U H3IYA W > � H�IY<�AC? ` <2]^laIK>@F � >'IKF N IKZP?BI U L N IK<f>

~^Î

Page 34: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

>DAy> ` I=Z^dL N H�] W A ` FB>@?BZ U F ` >�FY> ` bC] W ]�IKACZ^H��JL N H2] W A ` lyZ � >@F W ]^H2]_sc> W >@HJI U ?YAXH�s�L N H2] W A `gcZ^bXI�]_sc>\? ` ]_bCACHfs/]^HfL3d»] U b�I=IKZcbX>@FY]^H ` > U ?BACH�s ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s8Z^H3>$H�>@FBs N ��:=<�>$H � >t>¢�VIY>@H�L

IK<fAC?GIKZ+?kI U L N IY<�>�IKFK]_L�>@Z�A M >$I � >@>$H�>$H�>@FBs N ]^H�LPIK<�>�FY>$bCAn] M ACbXAXI N ]^FYAX?YACHfs M > ` ] U ?B>�Z^d?Bbn] ` �FY> ` bC] W ]�IKACZ^H���:#ZSIY<�> M >@?kI�Z^d�Z U FE�)H�Z � bX>@L�sc>_��IY<�AC?�AC?�IK<f>'o2FB?BI � ZcFB��IY<2]_I}]^L�L�FB>@?B?Y>@?�]^bCb

IK<f>@?Y>tAC?B? U >$?�?YA W U bXIK]^H�>@Z U ?Yb N �

� d � >½F U H¸]*l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF�ACH&bCZ � gcZcb�I�]^sc>�dqZcF8]ÁbXZcH�sc>$FSIYA W >^� � >�<2]�gc>¬bC>$?Y?/IYA W >�IYZ

F U H·IK<�>�bCZc?kI ` Z W l U I�]_IYACZcH�� M U I¬]_I3IK<�>�?K] W >�IYA W >�IY<�>Á>@Hf>@FYs N ?Y]vgVAXH�sc?½]^FB>*<�AXsc<�>$F

?YZ¬IK<f>@FY>�AC?P]½IKFY]^L�>@ZBA(��:=<�AC? ` <2]^laIK>@FP?BI U L�AX>@? IK<�AX? IYFK]^Lf>@Z�A���9E?/]½o2FB?BIP?BIY>@l � >3IYF N

IKZ3>¢�VIK>$H�LÁIK<f>/L N H2] W A ` FY>$?YZ U F ` >/FY> ` bn] W ]_IYACZcH½IKZj]�d»] U bXItIKZcbX>@FK]_H)It? N ?kIK> W dqZcFt>@H�>$FYs N

FY>$L U�` IKACZ^H{]_H�L�IK<�>$H � >¬L�Z�IK<�>¬?YbC] ` �´FB> ` bC] W ]_IKAXZcH�IYZ�?kI U L N IK<�AX?8IKFY]^L�>@ZBA(�Æ� U FYACHfs

H�ZcF W ]_byZcl�>@FY]_IKAXZcH�� � >|L�Z L N H2] W A ` FY>$?YZ U F ` >\FB> ` bC] W ]_IKAXZcH8]^HfL � >t]^bX?YZ�>��flfbCZcA�Ir?YbC] ` �SIYZ

` Z^H�?Y>$FBgc>�>@Hf>@FYs N ? U�` < IK<2]�I�I�]^?B�V? ` ]_H W >@>¢I�IK<�>$ACF�L�>@]^L�bXACH�>=]_H�L L U FYAXH�st]�d»]^ACb U FY>_� � >EF U H

IK<f>E? N ?kIK> W ]_I W ]��aA W U W ?Yl�>@>$L/IKZt>¢�a> `@U IY>}IK<�>�bCZ^?BI ` Z W l U I�]_IYACZcH��#À*>E]^bX?YZtL�AC? `@U ?B?¡IK<f>

A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcHSAC?B? U >$?EFB>@bn]�IK>@L�IYZS]_bCscZcFBAXIY< W lfFY>@?B>@HJIK>$L�<�>$FY>^�

Ú�� Ê h3ZaLf>@b�]^H�L�:#>@F W ACHfZcbCZcs N

:=<�AC?�]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W AX?�]^Hm>¢�VIK>$H�?YAXZcHmIKZ IK<�>�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>|? ` ]^bCAXH�s ]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W L�>$? ` FBA M >@L�ACH�IK<f>

l�FB>$gVACZ U ?�?B> ` IKACZ^H���À*> U ?B>\IY<�>|I�]^?B��]^H�L�l�Z � >@F W ZaL�>$b�L�>$? ` FBA M >@L�ACH ` <2]^laIK>@F�Îf�

Ú�� Ê � Ê ¤ ] U bXI�]^HfLj��> ` ZQg^>@F N h3ZaLf>@b

À*>¬]_?Y? U W >½]ÁFB>�]^b�IKA W >3? N ?BIY> W IY<2]_I�AX?/? U M ¦B> ` IK>@L�IKZ*IYFK]^Hf?YAC>$HJI�d»] U bXIY? � A�IK<´IK<f>

dqZcbXbCZ � ACH�s ` <2]^FY] ` IY>@FYAX?BIYA ` ? � ¤ ]^ACb U FY>$?/Z `@`$U F8IK<�>½? N ?BIK> W ]^?m]�D�Z^AC?Y?BZcH¸l�FYZ ` >$?Y? � AXIY<¸]

of�a>@Lmd»]^AXb U FB>}FK]�IK>^�G:=<�>\bXAXdq>$IYA W >EZ_d(]�IYFK]^H�?BAC>$H)I=d»] U bXI=AX?=>¢�al�ZcH�>@HJIYAn]^bXb N L�AC?kIKFYA M U IY>@L � AXIY<

]�l2]^FY] W >$IK>$F<Ñi�½À�>m]^?Y? U W >m]�FB>�]^bø¹ IYA W >P? N ?BIK> W IK<2]�I�I�]^�_>@? ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIK?S]^H�L�?BIYZcFY>$?

IK<f> W ACH{]6?Y> `$U FY>�l�bn] ` >^�ã:=<�>�ACHJIK>$Fk¹ ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIjAXHJIK>@Fkg_]^b�dqZcF�]^bCbEI�]^?B�V?�AC?�IY<�>�?Y] W >

]^H�L � >8]^?Y? U W > IK<�]_I ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIK?1]_FY>/HfZ^I ` ZcFYF U lfIY>@L��m:=<�> ` Zc?kI1]^?B?YZ ` An]�IK>@L � AXIY<�IK<f>

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sPAC?�]_?Y? U W >$L3?Y] W >|dqZcF�]_bCbyIY<�> ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIY?@�

~_Ú

Page 35: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ú��Ì~ 9}bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W

:=<�AC?¡]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W ]^b � ] N ?¡?B>$IY?¡IK<f>El�FBZ ` >@?B?YZcF�gcZcb�I�]^sc>=IYZ � o1� <�>@HPIK<�> U Hfo2HfAC?Y<f>@L � ZcFY�AC?=s U ]^FK]_H)IY>@>$L�IYZ M > M >$bCZ ��ð >¤­µ@r]_H�L3HfZPd»] U bXI=<�A�IK?rIY<�>\? N ?BIY> W �y]_H�L ��� Z^IY<�>@F � AC?B>^�

e Hfo�H�AC?B<�>@L � ZcFY�6AXH�IK<f>3? N ?kIK> W AC? ` ]_b `@U bn]_IY>@L�ACH�IY<�>j?Y] W > � ] N ]^?PL�>$? ` FBA M >@L�AXH

T > ` IKAXZcH�Îf�Ì~a�*9rIP]^H N IYA W >^��­���IK<f>�lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcF � AXbCb M >�F U H�H�AXH�s�]_I1bCZ � gcZcb�I�]^s^>8>¢� ` >$lfI

� <�>$H�]^H N Z^d#IK<f>\dqZ^bCbCZ � AXH�s ` Z^H�L�AXIYACZcHf?=AC?=?K]�IKAC?ko2>@L �

Ê ]f��ZB·SAXH�> IK]^?Y��>�I7@ l ZcHfbCACHf> IK]^?Y��>qI�@Ê M �iIY<�> � Z^FY?BI ` ]_?Y> U Hfo2HfAC?Y<f>@L � ZcFB� U H�L�>$F�IY<�>\ZcH�bXACH�>|]_bCscZcFBAXIY< W AC?=>@p U ]_b�IYZ ð >d­µ@¢�~a��9;d»] U b�I=<�A�IK?rIK<f>t? N ?BIK> W �

À¸<�>@H�IK<�>m? N ?kIK> W AC?1Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�s¬ACH6H�ZcF W ]^b W ZVL�>³>qH�Z�d»] U bXIY?�ACH�IK<f>�? N ?BIK> W @���IK<f>] M Zvgc>¢¹ W >$HJIKACZ^H�>@L*]^bCscZ^FYAXIY< W s U ]^FK]_H)IY>@>$?'IK<�]_I+HfZ3I�]_?Y� � ACbXb W AX?Y?\AXIY?'L�>@]^L�bXACH�>_� � H*IK<f>

>$g^>@HJIrZ_d d»]^AXb U FB>^�JZ U F�]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W ]^LfZclfIK?¡]\ly>$?Y?YA W AX?BIYA ` ]^l�lfFYZJ] ` </]^H�LPIKFYAX>@?�IKZtFY>$L U�` >EIK<f>

` <2]^H ` >@?tZ^d W AC?Y?BACH�sSIK<�>1L�>@]^L�bXACH�> M)N ?Y>$IBIKAXH�s8IK<�>�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>+IYZ ��� dqZcF�FY>$?BItZ^dGIK<f>�dqFK] W >^�

:=<�> ` <2]^H ` >�Z^d W AC?B?YAXH�s|]|L�>�]_L�bCAXH�>rAC?�s^ZQg^>@FBH�>@L M)N IK<�>=IKA W AXH�s}Z_dyd»] U bXIG]^FBFYA�g^]_b¿�_IYFK]^Hf?YAC>$HJI

bCA�dq>$IYA W >�]^H�L�IYFK]^L�>$Z�A½d»] ` IKZcF$�

Ú��ÏÎ ��>$? U b�IK?

:=<�>m>¢�al�>@FYA W >$HJI�]^br?B>$I U l�dqZcF1Z U F�?BA W U bn]_IYACZcH�?'AC?1]_?�dqZcbCbXZ � ?$�¬9}bCb¡>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH6IKA W >@?

]^FB>t?Bly> ` A�o2>@L3ACH�IK>$F W ?�Z_d(<�AXsc<�gcZcb�I�]^s^>']_H�Lj]_FY>\ACH W ACbCbXAC?B> ` Z^H�L�?@�(:=<�>tIK]^?Y��l�>@FBACZVL�?�]^FB>

` <�Zc?B>@H8FY]^H�L�Z W b N dqFBZ W IK<fAC?G?Y>¢I¡Z_d g_]^b U >@?GÚJ�f�V�^�a�aÕ^�f� Ê �c�f�a~^�^�f�(:=<�>�FY>@]^?YZ^H M >@<�AXH�L IK<�AX?

]^l�lfFYZJ] ` </AC?GIKZ+bXA W AXIiIY<�>�©>@]^?BI=��Z WSW ZcH/h U b�IKAClfbC>s>¨©#�=h�@�IKZ�] W ]_H2]^sc>@] M bC>=g_]^b U >}]_H�LIK< U ?GIKZ\?Bly>$>@L U l IK<f>�?BA W U bn]_IYACZcH�F U H�?$��:=<�>ElfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcFG<2]_? M >@>$H W ZaLf>@bC>$L M ]^?Y>$L/ZcH IK<f>

IK> ` <�H�ZcbXZcs N U ?Y>@LmdqZcF=IK<f> � HJIY>@b�¾�? ` ]^bX>\l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F@�G:=<�>tl2]^FK] W >¢IK>@FB?rg_]^b U >$? U ?Y>$L�]^FB> �

:=<�>1l2]^FY] W >$IK>$FY?EZ^d�A W lyZcFkI�]^H ` >']^FY>+IY<�> � ZcFY?kIB¹ ` ]^?B>1l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F U IKAXbCAX��]_IYACZcH��8ì(í�� IK<f>]�gc>$FK]^sc>�l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F U IKAXbCAX��]_IYACZcH���ìÔñ�ò^��IK<�>�H U W�M >$F(Z^d2IK]^?Y�)?$� ¨ �_IY<�>�g_]^b U >¡Z_dU���_d»]^ACb U FY>GFK]�IK>^�FY> ` Zvgc>$F N IKA W >_� ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s ` Z^?BI��)IKFY]^L�>$Z�Amd»] ` IYZcF@� � H�>$FYs N ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcHSAC?G>¢�al�FB>@?B?Y>@L

~c�

Page 36: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

¥GZcbXIK]^sc> g_]^b U >��� Ê �ÌÔc�� o Ê �Ï�c�� � �f�Ì~^�

:(] M bC>|Ú�� Ê � éêQëíì�î�ïvð}ú�ð�ûvð�ëøù�

D(]_FK] W >$IY>@F g_]^b U >d»]^AXb U FB>}FK]�IK> Ê � Ê ��ó�ô7= W ?Y> `` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s ` Z^?BI �a� � W ?Y> `H�Z���Z_d�IK]^�)? Ú

:�] M bC>|Úf� ~a� ò^ücùõìõð�ý;óVî�þkîvý\ð�ìõð�þkù�

]^?\]8l�>@F ` >@HJIK]^sc>1Z^dGIK<f> ` ZcH�? U W lfIKAXZcH�AXdGIY<�>�l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF � ]_?|F U H�]_I|<fACsc<jg^ZcbXIK]^sc> � <f>@H

>¢�a> `@U IYACH�s IK<�> � ZcFY�)bXZJ]^L��

¤ ACFB?BI ` ZcH�?BACL�>$F(IK<f>r>DAy> ` IGZ^d�IK<�>�IY<�>rAXH�F�]_IYACZcHtd»] ` IYZcFiZcH+d»]_ACb U FY>�l�FYZ M ] M ACbXAXI N �^?Y<fZ � H AXH¤ AXs U FY>�Ú�� Ê �i:�] M bX>EÚf� ~\? U WPW ]_FYAC�$>@?�IK<f>Eg_]^b U >@?�Z^dL�AëA >$FY>@HJI¡l2]^FY] W >¢IK>$FY?@�(9}? � >}AXH ` FB>�]^?B>IK<f>�AXH�F�]_IYACZcH1d»] ` IKZcF$� � > ` Z^H�? U W > W ZcFB>=Z^d�IK<�>E]�g^]_ACbn] M bC>¡?Ybn] ` �1ACH1IK<�>�? ` <�>@L U bC>�]_H�LPIY< U ?ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>PIK<�>Pd»]^ACb U FY> l�FBZ M ] M ACbCA�I N � ��U I�]_I'IK<�>S?K] W > IKA W > � >S?K]�gc> W ZcFB>S>$H�>@FBs N �3:=<�>

scFB>�]_IY>@F1IK<�>�FY> ` Zvgc>$F N IKA W >_��IY<�>mscFY>@]_IK>$F/]^FB>�IK<�> ` <2]^H ` >@?PIKZ W AX?Y?P]�Lf>�]^L�bXACH�>mL U FYACHfs

FY> ` Zvgc>$F N ]^HfL IY< U ?�IK<�>�s^FY>�]�IK>@F�IY<�>Ád»]^AXb U FB>*l�FBZ M ] M AXbCA�I N �Ý��> ` Zvgc>$F N IYA W >@?�<�]vg^>6H�Z

W >�]^? U FK] M bC>�A W l2] ` I1ZcH6IK<�>m>$H�>@FBs N `@U FBgc>_� M > ` ] U ?Y>md»]^ACb U FY>/AC? ]�gc>$F N FK]_FY>�>$g^>@HJI�]_H�L

IK< U ?GIK<f>�>$H�>@FBs N H U W�M >@FB?�]^FB>�L�Z W ACH2]_IY>@L MJN IK<f>EH�Z�¹ d»]^AXb U FB> ` ]_?Y>^� � H ¤ AXs U FY>=Úf� ~a�V]^bXbfIK<f>

l2]^FY] W >$IK>$FY?�]^FB>|�^>@laIEIY<�>\?K] W >\]^H�L~ì(í½AC?=AXH ` FB>�]^?B>@L��

� H ¤ ACs U FB>1Ú��ÏÎf� � >PL�> W ZcH�?kIKFY]_IK> IK<�> >�A > ` I'Z^d ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s ` Zc?BItZcH¬d»]^ACb U FY>+l�FYZ M ¹

] M AXbCA�I N � <�>@H6L N H2] W A ` FY>$?YZ U F ` >$? ]^FY>SFY> ` bn]_A W >@L U ?YACHfs½��¥ T � � HfAXIKAC]^bCb N ]^? � >8AXH ` FB>�]^?B>

IK<f> ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIKAXH�s�ACHJIK>$FBg_]^b¿�yIK<�>�d»]^AXb U FB>+l�FBZ M ] M ACbCA�I N L�> ` FY>�]_?Y>@? M > ` ] U ?Y>PAXI|FB>@L Uf` >@?\IK<f>

H U W�M >@F8Z_d ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIK?�AXH&IK<f>j? N ?kIK> W ]^H�L´<�>$H ` >½FB>@L Uf` >@?8IY<�>�>��f> `@U IYACZcH´IYA W >j]_H�L

IK< U ?mAXH ` FB>�]^?B>@?8IK<f>½?Ybn] ` ��IKZ6FB> ` Zvg^>@F�dqFYZ W d»]^AXb U FB>@?@� ��U I8AXd � >½�_>@>$lÃACH ` FY>@]^?YAXH�sÁIK<f>

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�smAXH)IY>@Fkg^]_b¿��IK<�>�d»]^AXb U FB>'lfFYZ M ] M ACbXAXI N ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>$? M > ` ] U ?B> W Z^FY> ` Z W l U I�]�IKACZ^H

~^å

Page 37: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

target_util=0.6

Energy

1e−05

1.5e−05

2e−05

2.5e−05

3e−05

3.5e−05

4e−05

4.5e−05

5e−05

5.5e−05

6e−05

0.82 0.84 0.86 0.88 0.9 0.92 0.94 0.96 0.9860

65

70

75

80

Ene

rgy

Failu

re P

rob.

recovery time=10recovery time=7.5

recovery time=5

inflation factor

¤ AXs U FY>&Ú�� Ê � � ý|óaî�Kì3êPö�÷! Vî�ì�öíêQ÷õCî�Kìõêvþ½êQ÷nnîvöøë$�Jþ�ð�ó)þ�ê�Vî%�Vö�ëøöíì»ü�îv÷)ô;ÿ�&Ô'�) ùjð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü�KêQ÷)ù��Vý|ó)ì�öíêQ÷<Cêvþ,+(êvþkùõì-��îvùõð�ì�î�þ�ïvð�ì.�Jì�ö�ëøö0/�î�ì�öíêQ÷+êy12�43target_util=0.7

Energy

1e−05

2e−05

3e−05

4e−05

5e−05

6e−05

7e−05

8e−05

9e−05

0.0001

0.91 0.92 0.93 0.94 0.95 0.96 0.97 0.9860

65

70

75

80

Ene

rgy

Failu

re P

rob.

recovery time=10recovery time=7.5

recovery time=5

inflation factor

¤ AXs U FY>&Ú�� ~V� � ý|óaî�Kì3êPö�÷! Vî�ì�öíêQ÷õCî�Kìõêvþ½êQ÷nnîvöøë$�Jþ�ð�ó)þ�ê�Vî%�Vö�ëøöíì»ü�îv÷)ô;ÿ�&Ô'�) ùjð�÷Jð�þ�ïvü�KêQ÷)ù��Vý|ó)ì�öíêQ÷<Cêvþ,+(êvþkùõì-��îvùõð�ì�î�þ�ïvð�ì.�Jì�ö�ëøö0/�î�ì�öíêQ÷+êy12�65AC?=bXZc?BI U lyZcH�d»]^AXb U FB>^�

� H ¤ ACs U FY>EÚ��ÏÚf�ad»]^AXb U FB>}l�FBZ M ] M AXbCA�I N AC?�lfbCZ^IBIK>@Lm]_sJ]^ACHf?BIr>$H�>@FBs N �adqZcF�L�AëA >$FY>$H)I=g_]^b U >@?¡Z^dIK<f> ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�sjAXH)IY>@Fkg^]_b¿� T N ?BIY> W <2]^?tå�I�]^?B�)?@� À*>PZ M IK]^ACH�IY<�>Pd»]_ACb U FY>�l�FBZ M ] M ACbCA�I N

]^H�L�>$H�>@FBs N ` ZcH�? U W >$L MJN g_]^F N AXH�sjIK<f> ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s¬ACHJIY>@FBg_]^b¨�½��ANAy>@FB>@HJI `$U FBg^>@?P]^FB>~cÔ

Page 38: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

0.0026

0.0027

0.0028

0.0029

0.003

0.0031

0.0032

0.0033

0.0034

0.0035

6 8 10 12 14

Failu

re P

rob.

Checkpointing Interval

checkpointing cost=1.00checkpointing cost=1.25checkpointing cost=1.50

¤ AXs U FY>|Úf�ÌÎf��� ý|óaî�KìGê8�µ Jð7���^ó�êQöø÷_ì�öø÷Jï\ê$ûvð�þ� Jð�îvô)ù�êQ÷�Cîvö�ë$�Jþ�ðró)þ�ê�aî%�Vöøëøöíì¨ül�bXZ^IYIY>@L6dqZcF L�ANAy>@FB>@HJI/AXH�F�]_IYACZcH �&:=<�AX? `$U FBg^>3IK>$bCb U ? IK<f>jH U W�M >@FPZ^d ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIK?�]_H�L

] W Z U HJI�Z^dtAXH�F�]_IYACZcH´Hf>@>@Lf>@L¸IKZ6l�FYZvgVACLf>�IK<�>½ZclaIKA W ]^b�FY>$bCAn] M ACbXAXI N dqZcF8]ÁscAXg^>@H¸>@H�>$FYs N

M U Lfsc>$I@�

7e−06

7.5e−06

8e−06

8.5e−06

9e−06

9.5e−06

1e−05

70 72 74 76 78 80

failu

re p

roba

bilit

y

Energy

inflation=.93

inflation=.98inflation=.97inflation=.96inflation=.95inflation=.94

inflation=.92

¤ ACs U FY>�Ú��ÛÚ���� ý|óVî�Kì�ê�Cîvö�ë$�Jþ�ð�ó)þ�ê�Vî%�aöøëøöíì¨ü\êQ÷/ÿ�&Ô'�ð�÷)ð�þ�ïvü��KêQ÷Vù��)ý|ó)ì�öøêQ÷��~^Õ

Page 39: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

z ,&�&� ��*� ®

��u&��Å�x�u&x�È %��}%'�$5PÈâ5P�ãz|² xtz\Ñ8�\5P��È %+��È/RÝ��È0�%1587

�a� Ê � H)IYFYZVL U�` IKACZ^H

��<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s3ACHJgcZcb�gc>$?'?kIKZcFBACH�s�IK<f>S?kI�]_IY>SZ^d�]ml�FYZ ` >$?Y?�]�I+]_H N l�ZcAXH)I\Z_d�IKA W > ]_H�L

FY>$?BIK]^FBIYACH�sjdqFBZ W IK<2]�I1lyZ^ACHJI+AXH*IK<f>8>$g^>@HJIPZ^d�]3d»] U b�I�� ¤ ZcFtbCZ^H�s_¹õF U H�H�AXH�s�]_l�l�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHf?@�

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s3]^bXbCZ � ? U ?B>@FB?tIYZ�bCA W AXI�IK<f> ] W Z U HJI\Z^d�bCZc?kI ` Z W l U IK]_IKAXZcH U l�ZcH�]8d»]^ACb U FY>

� AXIY<�Z U I'<2]�gVACH�smIKZ3FY>$F U H*IY<�>P>@HJIKAXFY>S]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H�� � H*]3<2]^FBLa¹õFB>�]^bø¹ IYA W >�? N ?BIY> W � <�>@FB>

]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?¡<2]�gc>']+of�a>@LjLf>�]^L�bXACH�>�]^H�L W AX?Y?BACH�s�IY<�Zc?Y>\L�>@]^L�bXACH�>$? ` ]^H M > ` ]_IK]^?BIYFYZcl�<fA ` �

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s ` ]_H M >\>DAy> ` IYAXg^>@b N U ?Y>$L��:=<�> W ]^ACH´s^ZJ]^b}Z_dtIY<�AC? � ZcFB��IYZ�A W l�bC> W >$H)I ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s�AXH¸]*dqFY>@>$b N ]�g^]_ACbn] M bC>

]^H�L � ACLf>@b N U ?Y>$L½�(: Ë T ����<�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfsSAX?�]^bCFB>�]^L N ]vg_]^bXAn] M bC>EdqZ^F e H�Aø� M ]^?B>@L Ë T >»bXAC�^>©ACH U �¶@öH Þ � Ê Î J �i©ACH U �'AX?�dqFY>$>^�c> W�M >@L�L2] M bC>�]^H�L�AX?i] M bX>�IYZ�l�>@FBdqZ^F W >DC ` AX>@HJIKb N � A�IK<'? W ]^bCb��9|h M ]^?B>@L ` Z W l U IK>$F�? N ?BIY> W ?@�t�EZ � >$g^>@F@�#©ACH U �jAC?EH�Z^I�]8<2]^FYLjFY>�]_b�¹ IYA W > Ë T ��©ACH U �

U ?B>@?�LfAC?K] M bCAXH�s\Z^dACHJIY>@FYF U lfIY?�dqZcFGl�FBZvgaAXL�ACHfs'? N H ` <�FYZcHfAC��]�IKACZ^H/ACHf?YACLf>�IY<�>E�_>@FBH�>@b � <�ACbX>�>��)¹

> `$U IKAXH�s ` FYAXIYA ` ]^b)?Y> ` IKAXZcH�� � <fA ` < ` Z W l�FBZ W AC?Y>$?#IY<�>r? N ?kIK> W ? ¼ ] M AXbCA�I N IKZ�lfFYZ W lfIKb N FY>$?Yl�ZcH�L

IKZS>¢�VIK>$FYH2]_b�>¢gc>@HJIY?\]^H�L M FBACH�s^? U H�l�FY>$L�A ` I�] M ACbCA�I N ACH3ACHJIK>$FYF U lfIEL�AC?Bl2]_I ` <jbn]_IY>@H ` N � Ë IK<�>$F

?Y<fZcFBI ` Z W ACH�s^?�ACH{©�AXH U ��dqFYZ W IK<�>�<2]^FBL{FB>�]^bø¹ IYA W >�ly>$FY?Bly> ` IKA�gc>�ACH ` b U L�>�IYA W >¢¹ ?Y<2]^FBACH�s>»HfZcF W ]^bCb N Ê � W ?B> ` @G? ` <�>@L U bCACHfs��agVACFkI U ]_b W > W ZcF N ? N ?BIY> W IKA W AXH�s U H�l�FB>@L�A ` I�] M ACbXAXI N �)]_H�L

bn] ` ��Z^d�<�AXsc<a¹ scFK]^H U bC]^FYA�I N IKA W >$FY?@��À�>�<2]�gc>mA W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfs�AXH�FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >

©ACH U �~>¨�¡IYbCAXH U ��@�H Ê Ú J �G�¡IKbXACH U �SL�>�]_bC? � A�IK<�]_bCb�IK<�>�?B<�ZcFkI ` Z W AXH�sc?�Z^d#©ACH U �8]^H�L�l�FB>@?Y>$HJIK?©ACH U �+]^?�]E<2]^FYL+FY>�]_b�¹ IYA W > Ë T � � H1��IKbCAXH U �y�_IKZ}FY> W Zvgc>�IY<�> U Hfl�FY>$L�A ` I�] M AXbCA�I N ACH�AXHJIK>@FBF U laI

L�AX?Yl2]_I ` <¬bn]_IY>@H ` N ��]�bn] N >$F|Z^d�> W U bn]_IYACZcH�?BZ^d�I � ]^FY> AC?}l�bn] ` >@L M >$I � >@>@H�IK<�> ©AXH U �½�^>$FYH�>$b

]^H�L�IY<�>�AXH)IY>@FBF U lfI ` ZcHJIKFBZcbCbX>@FE<2]^FYL � ]^FB>^� � H�IK<fAC? � ] N ]^bXb#IY<�>�<2]^FBL � ]^FY>1AXH)IY>@FBF U lfIY?|]^FB>

~ Þ

Page 40: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

` ] U sc<JI M)N IK<�>�> W U bn]_IYZcF@�#:=<�AX?�> W U bC]_IKZcF ` <�> ` �)? � <f>$IK<f>@F¡©�AXH U � ACHJIY>@FYF U lfIY?G]^FY>�>@H�] M bC>$L

ZcFPL�AC?Y] M bX>@L�� � d|>$H2] M bX>@L��¡IK<�>j©�AXH U ��ACHJIK>$FYF U lfIS<2]^H�L�bX>@FPAC?PACHJgcZ^�^>@L�A WSW >@LfAn]_IY>@b N � � d��

©ACH U �¸AXHJIK>@FBF U laIK?�]^FY>½LfAC?K] M bC>$L��EIY<�>¬<2]^H�L�bX>@F�AX?�H�Z^I�ACHJgcZ^�^>@L � � H�?kIK>@]^L��|] M A�ImAC?�?Y>¢I

ACHÁIY<�>/g_]^FBAn] M bX>SIY<2]_I1<�Z^bCL�?+IY<�>�ACHadqZcF W ]_IKAXZcH�] M Z U I ]^bXb¡l�>@H�LfACH�s¬ACHJIY>@FYF U lfIY?1]^H�L6bn]�IK>@F

� <�>$H{©AXH U �&FB>¢¹ >@H2] M bC>@?/ACHJIK>$FYF U lfIK?$��IY<�>�<2]_H�L�bC>$FY?SZ^dt]^bCb=IY<�>�l�>@H�L�AXH�sÁAXH)IY>@FBF U lfIY?�]^FB>

>¢�a> `@U IY>@L��{:=<�>@?B>�?YA W U bn]�IK>@L�ACHJIY>@FYF U lfIY?8]^FB>j]^bX?YZ��)H�Z � H¸]^?S?BZ^d�I8AXHJIK>@FBF U laIK?@� � H�IK<�AX?

� ] N �2�¡IYbCACH U �SF U H�?=©ACH U �8]^?rZ^H�>�Z^d�A�IK?¡IY<�FY>@]^L�?$�iÀ¸<�>@H�IK<f>@FY>}AC?�HfZ1FY>�]_b�¹ IYA W >rIK<�FB>�]^L8IYZ

? ` <f>@L U bX>^��IK<�>+�¡IKbXACH U ��? ` <f>@L U bX>@F�? ` <�>@L U bC>$?|©ACH U �y� T ACH ` >�©ACH U ��<�]^?}H�ZSL�ACFB> ` I ` Z^H)IYFYZcb

Zvgc>$F�IK<�>}ACHJIK>$FYF U lfI ` ZcHJIKFYZ^bCbC>$F@�VAXI¡L�ZV>@?rH�Z_IrACH�F U >@H ` >�l�FBZ ` >@?B?YACHfs�Z^d�FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >=AXH)IY>@FBF U lfIY?IK<�]_I�L�Z3H�Z^I+l2]^?Y?'IK<�FBZ U sc<*IY<�>/> W U bC]_IKZcF$���¡IKbXACH U ��]^bX?YZ U ?Y>@?+L�AC?Y] M bCAXH�s�ZcH*AXH)IY>@FBF U lfIY?

ACHf?YACLf>�AXIY? ` FBAXIKA ` ]^bE?Y> ` IKAXZcH�� M U I��¡IYbCAXH U ��ACHJIY>@FYF U lfIY?m]^FY>�d»]^?kIm]^H�L¸l�FBZ ` >@?B?YACHfs�AX?��^>$lfI

W ACH�A W ]^b�ACHf?YACLf>¡��IKbCAXH U �\ACHJIY>@FYF U lfI�?Y>$FBgVA ` >¡FBZ U IKAXH�>@?$�i� U >�IYZEIK<fAC?@�QIK<f>¡AXH)IY>@FBF U lfI#L�AX?Yl2]�I ` <

bn]�IK>@H ` N ` ]^H M > M Z U H�L�>@L � A�IK<�FY>�]_?YZcH2] M bC> ` >@FkI�]^AXHJI N � � HÁ�¡IKbXACH U �y� M > ` ] U ?Y>SIK<�>PIKA W >@F

` <�AXl3AX?=l U I�ACH�IK<f>'AXH)IY>@FBF U lfIk¹õZcHV¹ IK>$F W ACH2]_b�¹ ` Z U HJI W ZVL�>^��]_H�AXHJIK>@FBF U laI ` ]^H M >\? ` <f>@L U bX>@L

� AXIY<6]^l�l�FBZ��fA W ]�IK>@b N Ê W A ` FBZc?Y> ` ZcH�L�lfFY> ` AC?BACZcH�� � H�IY<�AC? � ] N IY<�>8H�>$>@L�dqZcF1]�l�>@FBACZVL�A `

IKA W >$FGACHJIK>$FYF U lfIrAX?¡FB> W ZQg^>@L�]_H�L/IK<f> z\�}³ AX?¡AXHJIK>@FBF U laIK>@L/ZcH�b N � <f>@H�H�>$>@L�>$L���D�>@FBACZVL�A `

ACHJIY>@FYF U lfIY?|]^FY>'?YA W U bn]�IK>@L�dqZcF�©AXH U � U ?BACH�s/?YZ^d�I}ACHJIK>$FYF U lfIK?$�|�¡IKbXACH U �3F U H�?|]^bXb���:�¹ I�]_?Y�)?

ACH�IK<�>½�_>@FYHf>@b|]^LfL�FY>$?Y?m?Yl2] ` >^� � N F U HfH�ACH�sÁ]^bCb�IK<�>�IK]^?Y�)?�AXH�]Á?YAXH�scbC>j]^L�L�FB>@?B?�?Yl2] ` >

Zvgc>$FY<�>@]^L�?�FY>$bn]_IY>@L8IKZ�gVAXFBI U ]^b W > W ZcF N ]^FB>�FY>$L U�` >@L�� � > ` ] U ?B>\IY<�>��_>@FYHf>@b�]^L�LfFY>@?B?�?Yl2] ` >

AC? U ?Y>$L��JZvgc>@FB<�>�]_L�?�]^?Y?BZ ` An]_IY>@L � AXIY<1l�FYZ_IK> ` IKAXZcH1bC>¢gc>@b ` <2]^H�s^>@?�]^FY>r]^bC?BZ�>@bXA W ACH2]_IY>@L���:�]^?Y�

? � A�I ` <�AXH�stAC?�]^bC?BZ\>�]^?BAC>@FGA�d�]^bXbfI�]_?Y�)?¡F U HPACHPZcH�>�]^L�L�FB>@?B?¡?Bl2] ` > M > ` ] U ?Y>E] ` ZcHJIK>¢�VI¡? � A�I ` <

FY>$p U ACFB>@? l U ?B<�ACH�s�]^bXb¡IK<f>�FB>@scAX?BIY>@FY? ZcH�IY<�>m?BI�] ` ��]^H�L ` <2]^H�s^ACH�s½IK<f>�?kI�] ` �*lyZcAXHJIK>@F�IYZ

l�ZcACHJI�IYZ¬IY<�>mH�> � ?BIK] ` ������:=bCACH U �*IK< U ?1o�IY? M >@?kI1dqZcF1<2]^FBL6FY>�]_b�¹ IYA W >/? N ?kIK> W ? � <�>@FB>

l�FB>@L�A ` I�] M ACbXAXI N AC?=Z^d W Z^?BI�A W l�ZcFBIK]^H ` >_�

:�Z U ?Y> ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s|AXH1�¡IYbCACH U �S�cZ^H�b NtW ACH�ZcF ` <2]^Hfsc>@?G]^FB>rH�>$>@L�>$LPAXH+IK<f>=�(:�¹ IK]^?Y�)?$�

e l�ZcHSl�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F�d»]^AXb U FB>^�cIY<�>}]_l�l�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH ` ]^H M >�FY>@?kI�]^FkIK>$L � AXIY<PIY<�> ` Z WPW ]_H�LSbXACH�>pF2]^sZcH/IY<�>}lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcF¡ZcH � <�A ` <8AXIY?¡?kI�]_IY>}AX?¡?Y]vg^>@L���]^H�L/IY<�>}l�FBZcscFY] W � ACbCb M >}FB>@?kI�]^FkIK>@LSdqFYZ W

Îc�

Page 41: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

IK<f> W Zc?kI|FY> ` >$H)IYb N ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIK>$L*?kI�]_IY>^�1� U FYFY>$HJIKb N AXI}<2]^? M >@>@H¬A W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L½ZcH � HJIK>$b

]^F ` <�AXIY> ` I U FY>_��IK<�Z U sc<�>¢�VIK>$H�L�ACHfsSA�I=IKZ Z^IK<f>@F�]^F ` <fAXIK> ` I U FY>$?�?B<�Z U bXL M >|?BIYFK]^AXsc<JIYdqZcF � ]_FYL��

�a�Ì~ e ?K]_sc>

:�Z�]^L�L ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfs�? U lflyZcFkI�AXHÁ�¡IYbCACH U ��]_l�l�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHf?@��IK<�>Sl�FYZcs^FK] WPW >$F\<2]^?'IYZ

]^L�L3ZcH�>'bCACHf>�IKZ/AXH ` b U L�>\IK<�> ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)I�<�>�]^Lf>@FEo�bC>tACHmIK<�>+]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H�?YZ U F ` >to2bC>_��dqZ^F

>¢�f] W l�bX> �÷ çø Ú ×¢ä�á�Øúù�ù ß!Ý × Ú¢û Ù ÝöüYÞ.ý�ý:=<�>@HmIK<f> U ?Y>$F�<�]^?rIKZ1L�>¢IK>$F W ACH�>|]1? U AXIK] M bC>El�bn] ` > � <�>$FY>\<�>=�?Y<�> � ]^HJIK?=IKZ�IK]^�^>|IK<f>

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)I�]^H�L3]^bC?BZS<�]^?�IYZ/]_bCbCZ ` ]�IK>�?BZ W >\?B<2]^FY>$L W > W ZcF N �¡:=<fZ U sc<�IK<�> U ?Y>$FELfZa>$?YH ¼ I

<2]�gc>mIKZ W ZaL�A�d N IY<�>3]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H ` ZVL�>m<�>�]�gVACb N �¡<�>=_?B<�>�<2]^?1IKZ8¦ U ?BIPl�bC] ` >�]�d U H ` IKAXZcHß!Ý × ÚÞ Ø Ú¢û ê¶þ ß ß Ø Ú þ]ÿ�Ø ß�Û â�ã¬ACHÁIY<�> M >$scACHfH�ACH�s½Z_dEIY<�>~Ö Ý à ß!Ý ß þ¢ä Ý ç%ø¶ØjâDã¬A¨�Ï>_�ÁACH�IK<f>

M >@scAXH�H�ACHfs/Z^diIY<�>1]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH ` ZVL�>1]_H�L�<2]^?�IKZ8lfbn] ` >�]Pd U H ` IYACZcH ß!Ý × Ú¢û Ù Ý Þ Ø ß Øjâ�ã/]�IIK<f>}l�ZcACHJI � <f>@FY>}<�>=_?B<�> � ]^HJIK?rIYZ'I�]_�^>}IY<�> ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IrACH/IY<�>�]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH�� � Hm�(:=bXACH U �]^H�]_l�l�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH¬AX?+]^H*Z M ¦B> ` I+o2bX>/]_H�LÁAC?tbCZc]^L�>@L�ACHJIKZ�IK<�>S�^>$FYH�>$b=]^L�L�FB>@?B?�?Yl2] ` >8AXH�IK<f>

dqZcbXbCZ � ACH�s � ] Ny� ç%øUÖ%å�þBá ß!Ý × àBÙ�Ù�×�ç Ú à Ý ç2þ]ø ü þ � H8ZcFBL�>@F¡IKZ+F U H8IK<f>��¡IYbCACH U �/]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHL U FBACH�s¬FB> ` Zvg^>@F N IY<�> U ?Y>$FP<�]^?1IKZ¬scAXg^>�] ` Z WPW ]^HfL�bXACH�>8]^FYs U W >$H)I � A�IK<�IK<f> W ZVL U bC>

bCZc]^L�>@F � ç%ø�Ö%åUþBá ß!Ý × àBÙ�ÙU×�ç Ú à Ý ç2þ¢ø ü þ��c�

�a�ÏÎ � W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H�L�>$IK]^ACbX?

�¡IKbXACH U ��]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H�? ¼ ?BI�]�IK>\ACH ` b U Lf>@? �

Ê ����ZVL�> T >@s W >$H)I

~a� T IK] ` � T >$s W >$HJI

Îf�G��>@scAX?BIY>@FY?À¸<�>@H¸]*�¡IKbXACH U �&]^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH6AC?/bXZJ]^L�>$L U ?BACH�s�]��^>@FBH�>@b W ZVL U bX>�bXZJ]^L�>$F@�=A�IK? ` ZaLf>

sc>¢IK?�]_IBI�] ` <�>$L�IYZ1IK<�>|�_>@FYHf>@b ` ZVL�>\?Y>$s W >@HJI�FYAXsc<JI M >$bCZ � AXI��(:=<�> ` ZVL�>|?Y>$s W >$HJIEZ_d�?Y] W >

]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�ZcH´L�AëA >$FY>@HJI W ] ` <fACH�> ` ]^H�<2]�g^>�L�ANAy>@FB>@HJI³>�gaAXFBI U ]^bd@1]^LfL�FY>$?Y?Y>$?@� ¤ ZcF IK<�AX?

FY>@]^?YZ^H��VIY<�>}lfFYZcscFY] W ` Z U HJIK>@F¡ZcH/Z^H�> W ] ` <�AXH�>�H�>@>$L8H�Z^I¡lyZ^ACHJIGIKZ'IY<�>}?Y] W >EAXH�?BIYF U�` IKACZ^H

Î Ê

Page 42: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

ZcH�]_H�Z^IK<f>@F W ] ` <�AXH�> dqZcFtIY<�>8?Y] W >S]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�� T Z � > W U ?BI+<2]�gc>8?BZ W > W > ` <2]^H�AX? W

IKZ�]^LQ¦ U ?BI1IY<�>�l�FYZ^scFK] W ` Z U H)IY>@FP] `$` ZcFBL�ACH�s�IYZ½IK<�>�H�> � ` ZaL�>�?B>@s W >@HJIS]^L�LfFY>@?B?Y>$?@� � H

�¡IYbCACH U � W > W ZcF N ?Yl2] ` >}dqZcFGIK<�>E?BIK] ` �SAX?r]^bXbCZ ` ]_IY>@L U ?BACH�s�� W ]^bCbXZ ` ]_H�L/IK<f> M ]^?B>|]^L�LfFY>@?B?

Z^d�IK<f>=?BI�] ` �+AC?�IK<�>=FB>$I U FYH1g_]^b U >�Z^d�� W ]^bXbCZ ` ��:=<�AC?(A W l�bCAX>@?�IK<2]_I(IK<�>�]^LfL�FY>$?Y?GZ^d�IK<�>=?kI�] ` �

?Y>$s W >@HJI � ACbXb M >rL�AëA >$FY>$H)I(dqZcF(IK<f>r?K] W >=]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHtZcH1L�AëA >$FY>@HJI W ] ` <�AXH�>@?$�(:=< U ?$�)IY<�>@FB>W U ?kI M >\?YZ W > W > ` <2]^H�AX? W IYZ W ]^�^>\IK<f>+]^LfL�FY>$?Y?}Z_d(IK<f>t?kI�] ` �m?B>@s W >@HJI�IK<�>t?K] W >|dqZcF�]

l2]^FkIKA `@U bC]^F=]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�] ` FYZc?B?=IK<�> W ] ` <�ACHf>@?@�G9EH�Z^IK<f>@F�l�FYZ M bC> W AC?rIY<2]_I � > ` ]^H�H�Z^I U ?B>

?Y>¢I»¦ W l/]_H�LSbXZcH�s�¦ W l1AXHP�¡IKbXACH U �1IYZt?Y]�gc>EIY<�>�FY>@s^AC?BIY>@F ` ZcHJIK>¢�VI@� T Z+]^b�IK>$FYH2]_IYAXg^>rd U H ` IYACZcHf?

<2]�gc>\IKZ M >\A W l�bC> W >$H)IY>@L��� H½Z U FEA W l�bC> W >$H)IK]_IKAXZcH � >�<�]vg^>�I�]^�_>@H ` ]_FY>�Z^d�IY<�>1] M Zvgc>�¹ W >@HJIKAXZcH�>@Ljl�FYZ M bC> W ?EIYZ

A W l�bX> W >@HJI ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sPACH��¡IYbCAXH U �8AXHmIY<�>|dqZcbCbXZ � ACH�s � ] N��

�a�ÏÎf� Ê D�FBZcscFK] W ��Z U HJIY>@F�9}L�¦ U ?kI W >@HJI

� d�IK<�>\]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHSAC?rF U H�H�AXH�s1ACH8IY<�>�H�ZcF W ]_b W ZaL�>_� � >¡¦ U ?BI�?kIKZcFB>|AXIY?rD��{]_I=]+of�a>@L

l�ZcACHJI->q?K] N D�� Ê @¢�Û:=<�>@H � <�ACbX>(I�]_�VAXH�s=IK<�> ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJI � >�?BIKZ^FY>iIK<f>�lfFYZcscFY] W ` Z U HJIK>$FdqFYZ W

� <�>$FY> � >\<2]�gc>\IKZPFY>$?BIK]^FBI=IY<�>t]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H�>¨D��=~2@rL U FBACH�s FB> ` Zvg^>@F N ]^HfL � > ` ]^b `@U bC]_IK>� �  c® lÐf�m ~ } f�m ÊÀ¸<�>@H8IY<�>�?Y] W >}]^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcHSAX?¡F U H�H�AXH�s�AXH/IK<�>EFY> ` Zvgc>$F N�W ZaLf>EZcH/?YZ W >}Z^IY<�>@F�H�ZaLf>

AXI�]_sJ]^ACH ` ]^b `$U bn]�IK>@?�IY<�>�D¡�Ä]_ImIK<�>¬?Y] W >½of�a>$LÃl�ZcACHJI�]^H�L¸IK<f>@H¸IK<�>�] ` I U ]^b\D��G>qdqZ^FFY>$?BIK]^FBIYACH�s�@�AX? ` ]^b `@U bC]_IK>$L U ?YAXH�sfsm ~ lnf�mPÊ-Ê?�����,f

� H'IY<�AC? � ] N � > � >@FY>�] M bX>�IYZE?BZcbXg^>¡IK<f>¡l�FBZ M bX> W Z^dfL�ANAy>@FB>@HJI(lfFYZcscFY] W ` Z U HJIK>@FB?i] ` FYZc?B?

W ] ` <�ACHf>@?@�

�a�ÏÎf�Ì~ T I�] ` � T >$s W >@HJI

9}? W >$H)IYACZcHf>@L�] M Zvgc>_�aIK<f>}?BIK] ` �S]^H�L/dqFY] W >�l�ZcACHJIK>$FY? W ] NPM >}L�AëA >$FY>@HJI¡dqZcF�IY<�>}?Y] W >]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�ZcH´L�AëA >$FY>@HJI W ] ` <�AXH�>@?$� T ZÁAXH´Z U F ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s�? ` <�> W >^� � >j?K]�gc>½IK<f>

L�AëA >$FY>@H ` >�Z^daIY<�>�?BI�] ` �\]^H�L\dqFK] W >GlyZcAXHJIK>@FB? � AXIK<\FB>@?Yl�> ` I(IYZ�IY<�>�?BI�] ` � M ]^?Y>¡]^H�L\IK<f>@H�]_L�LÎJ~

Page 43: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

IK<f>@?Y>\L�AX?Yl�bC] ` > W >$HJIK?rAXH8IK<�> M ]^?Y>\]^LfL�FY>$?Y?�Z^d�IK<�>|?kI�] ` �/]^bCbXZ ` ]_IK>$L/IKZ�IY<�>|]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHSZcH

IK<f>}Z^IY<�>@F¡H�ZaLf>EIKZ+sc>$I�IK<�>}FYACs^<)I�g_]^b U >^�i:=<�AX?@�V<�Z � >¢gc>$F@�2L�ZV>@?¡H�Z^I � ZcFB�PdqZcF¡]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?

� AXIY</]_FYFK] N ?@��:=<f>}?BIK]^FBI¡]^LfL�FY>$?Y?�Z_d�]^HS]^FYFY] N AX?�]_I�?YZ W >EbXZ ` ]_IKAXZcH1ACH IK<f>E?kI�] ` �P]^H�L W U ?kI

M > ` <�]^H�sc>$Lj] `$` ZcFBL�ACHfs IYZPIY<�>\H�> � ]^L�L�FB>@?B?E?Bl2] ` >_� � <�A ` <�AC?=L�AëC `@U b�I=IKZ A W l�bC> W >$HJI��9¸lyZc?B?YA M bC>�?YZ^b U IYACZcH1Z^dyIK<�>�] M Zvgc>�l�FYZ M bC> W AC?�IKZt]^bXbCZ ` ]_IY>�IK<f>E?Y] W >�]^LfL�FY>$?Y?�?Yl2] ` >�IYZ

IK<f>�?kI�] ` �1?B>@s W >@HJI�Z^d�IK<�>��¡IYbCAXH U � ]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH1] ` FYZc?B? W ] ` <�AXH�>@?$���EZ � >$g^>@F�LfZcACH�s|?BZ'AX?G]

L�AëC `$U bXIIK]^?Y�}l2]^FBIYA `$U bn]^FBb N � <�>@H û å�à�×�×�þ Ú AC? U ?B>@L'dqZ^F W > W ZcF N ]^bXbCZ ` ]_IYACZcH ��9 M F U IY>¢¹¿dqZcF ` >

?YZ^b U IYACZcH8AX?¡IYZ W ZVL�AXd N IY<�>|>¢�aAX?BIKAXH�s û å�à�×�×�þ Ú dqZcF�IK<�AX?rl U FBlyZ^?Y>^�G:=<�>|�_>@FBH�>@b dqZ^F W > W Z^F N]^bXbCZ ` ]_IYACZcHj]^bC?BZ U ?Y>@? û å�à�×�×�þ Ú ]^H�L½IK< U ? W ZaL�A�d N ACH�s8A�I ` ]_H�AXH)IYFYZVL U�` > U H�l�FY>$L�A ` I�] M ACbCA�I N

ACH�IY<�>\? N ?BIY> W � Ë U F�?YZ^b U IYACZcH�AX?rd»]^ACFBb N ?YA W l�bX>^� � I�AC? M ]^?Y>$LjZcH�IK<f> ` ZcH ` >@lfIEZ^d�FY>@?B>@FkgaAXH�s

?YZ W > W > W ZcF N ]_I M ZaZ^I|IYA W >1]^H�L½IY<�>@H U ?YAXH�s�AXI�dqZcF|?kI�] ` �¬]_bCbCZ ` ]�IKACZ^HjACHf?BIK>@]^L¬Z^d U ?YAXH�sû å�à�×�×�þ Ú âDã)�3:=<�AC? ` ZcH ` >@laI�AC? � ACLf>@b N U ?Y>@L*ACHÁ��IKbCAXH U �½dqZcF']^bCbXZ ` ]_IKAXH�s�?Y<�]^FY>$L W > W Z^F N

dqZcF ` Z WSW U H�A ` ]_IKAXZcH M >$I � >@>$H�]P�¡IKbXACH U �8]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H�]^H�L3] U ?Y>$F�?Bl2] ` >+]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH�]_H�L

AC?8IK]^�^>$H{dqFBZ W IY<�>@FB>^�ã:=<�>¬l�FYZ M bC> W � AXIK<�IY<�AC?�?BZcb U IYACZcH�AX?8IK<2]�I3A�Ims U ]^FY]^HJIK>$>@?�IK<2]�I

IK<f>½l�< N ?BA ` ]^b|]^L�LfFY>@?B? � ACbCb M >jIK<�>½?Y] W > M U I�IY<�>�gVACFBI U ]^b}]^L�L�FB>@?Y?8IY<2]_I � >¬sc>$I�]_d�IK>$F

FY> W ]_l�l�ACHfs/H�>$>@L½H�Z^I M >tIK<�>�?Y] W >�] ` FYZc?B? W ] ` <�ACH�>$?@� �¡U I}IY<�AC?EL�Za>$?�H�Z^I}FY>$?BIKFBA ` I U ?�AXH

]^H N � ] NjM > ` ] U ?B>1]^H N L�ANAy>@FB>@H ` >�ACH�IK<�>1]_L�L�FY>$?Y?B>@? ` ]_H M >�]^L�¦ U ?kIK>@L ��]^?�IK<2]_I}L�ANAy>@FB>@H ` >� ACbXb FB> W ]^ACH8IY<�>\?K] W >t]^?�bCZcH�s ]_?�IY<�>\�^>$FYH�>$b#FB> W ]^ACHf?rIK<�>\?K] W >_�

�a�ÏÎf�ÏÎ ��>@s^AC?BIY>@FB?

Ö�Ø Ý�� å�Ù3]^H�L~×�þ]ø Ü�� å�Ù�]_FY> � ACLf>@b N U ?Y>$LjbCA M FK]_F N ` ]^bXbC?�dqZcF=?kIKZcFBACH�s FB>@scAX?BIK>$F ` ZcHJIK>��VI}AXH

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s�H Þ � Ê � J M U I U HadqZcFBI U H2]_IY>@b N ��IKbCAXH U ��L�ZV>@?tH�Z^I�? U l�l�ZcFBItIK<f> W �mÀ�>/<�]vg^>

L�>¢o2H�>@L*Z U FtZ � H�d U H ` IKACZ^H�? ß!Ý × Ö�à�ÿ�Ø ß Ø Ü ç!Ö Ý Ø ß ÖÅâ�ã�]^HfL ß!Ý × ß Ø�Ö Ý þ ß Ø ß Ø Ü ç!Ö Ý Ø ß ÖÅâ�ãdqZcF=IK<fAC?�l U FBlyZc?B>^� ß!Ý × Ö�à�ÿ�Ø ß Ø Ü ç!Ö Ý Ø ß ÖÅâ�ã/?kIKZcFB>@?�IK<�>\g_]^b U >@?�ACH�FY>$scAC?kIK>@FB?EZ^H�IY<�>'?kI�] ` �L U FBACH�s ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)I�]^H�L ß!Ý × ß Ø�Ö Ý þ ß Ø ß Ø Ü ç!Ö Ý Ø ß ÖÅâ�ã*l�Zcl�? IK<f> W Z U IPdqFYZ W IY<�>j?kI�] ` �

L U FBACH�s FB> ` Zvg^>@F N �

ÎcÎ

Page 44: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

�a�ÛÚ :�FY]^H�?Bdq>$FEZ_d���<�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIK>@L T I�]�IK>

� H�Z^FYL�>$F\IYZ�IKFK]_H�?Bdq>$FtIY<�> ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIK>$L*?kI�]_IY>^��IK<�> >@HJIYACFY> l�FBZ ` >@?B?'?kI�]_IY>PHf>@>@Lf>@L�dqZ^F

FY>$?BIK]^FBI@�AC?}o2FB?BI � FBAXIBIK>@H¬AXH)IYZ8?Y<�]^FY>$L W > W ZcF N ]^HfL¬IY<�AC?}?Y<2]^FB>@L W > W ZcF N AC?}bCACHf�^>@L�IYZm]

©ACH U �3]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH8F U H�H�AXH�sS]^?}] ?Y>$FBg^>@F � <fA ` <jAX?�FY>@?BlyZ^H�?YA M bC>|IKZ IKFY]^H�?kdq>@F�AXI=IKZS]^H�Z_IK<�>$F

©ACH U ��]^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH'F U H�H�AXH�s|]^?(] ` bXAC>$H)I(ZcH1?YZ W >¡Z^IK<�>$F W ] ` <�AXH�>^��:=<�AC? ` bCAX>@HJI�]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH

IK<f>@H � FBAXIY>@?�IK<�AX?G?BI�]�IK>�ACHS]t?B<2]^FB>@L W > W ZcF N FY>$scACZ^H�� � <�A ` <SAC?G]^bX?YZtbCAXH��^>$L IYZtIY<�>E�¡IKbXACH U �

]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH��

�a�� ��> ` Zvgc>$F N l�FYZ ` >$?Y?

:=<�> W ]^AXH�]^A W Z_d ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfsjAC?|IYZ3FB> ` Z^H�?BIYF U�` I+IK<f>SFB> ` Zvg^>@F N l�ZcACHJI@� � H ` <�> ` �c¹

l�ZcACHJIKAXH�s��fIY<�>tFY> ` Zvgc>@F N l�ZcAXH)I�AXH ` b U L�>@? ` FY>�]�IKACHfsPIY<�>'lfFYZ ` >@?B?�]^HfLjFY>$?BIYZcFYAXH�sSL�]_I�] ?BIK]_IK>_�

l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF�?BI�]�IK>�H ÊDJ�� <�A ` <�ACHJg^ZcbXg^>@?=IK<�>|dqZcbXbCZ � ACHfs�?BIY>@l�? �Ê �¡DGFBZ ` >@?B? ` FY>@]_IKAXZcH/AX?�A W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L MJN ACHJgcZ^�VAXH�s+IY<�> ` <�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIK>@Lml�FBZcscFY] W � AXIK</]

?Yl�> ` AC]^b ` Z WSW ]^H�LjbCACHf>�]^FBs U W >@HJI|dqZcF�FB> ` Zvg^>@F N ��:=<�AX?|FY>@?kIKZcFB>@?�IY<�> ` ZVL�>1?Y>$s W >@HJI

Z^d+IY<�>¬l�FYZ ` >$?Y? ¼ ?j?kI�]_IY>�]^H�L M >$scACH�?m>��f> `@U IYACZcH � :=<�>�]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�AXIY?Y>$bXdtL�>$IY> ` IK?

IK<�>m]^FBs U W >@HJI�dqZcF'FY> ` Zvgc>$F N AXH ß�Ý × Ú¢Þ Ø Ú¢û ê¶þ ß ß Ø Ú þ]ÿ�Ø ß�Û â�ã¬]^H�LÁIY<�>@H ` ]^bCbX?'IK<f>

FY> ` Zvgc>@F N FYZ U IYACH�>$?@�

~a��:=<�>�FY> ` Zvgc>$F N FYZ U IYACH�>EFY>@]^L�?¡IY<�> ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJI=dqFYZ W IY<�>�?B<2]^FY>$L W > W Z^F N ]^H�L/FY> ` FY>�¹

]_IK>$?�IY<�>\l�FYZ ` >$?Y? ¼ ?E?BI�] ` ��?Y>@s W >$H)I@�

Îf�¡DGFBZ ` >@?B?YZcF�?BIK]_IK>tFY>$?BIKZ^FK]_IYACZcHmFY>$p U ACFB>@?=IK<�>tl�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF�FY>@s^AC?BIY>@FB?@�2ACH ` b U L�ACH�s�IY<�>tl�FYZ_¹

scFK] W ` Z U HJIY>@Fr]_H�LS?kI�] ` � l�ZcACHJIY>@FY?�IYZ M >EFB>@?kIKZcFB>@LSIYZtIY<�>@AXF�g^]_b U >$? � <f>@HSIY<�> ` <�> ` �c¹

lyZcAXHJI � ]_?rI�]^�_>@H�� � HmZ U FrA W lfbC> W >@HJIK]_IKAXZcH�� � >\]_FY> U ?BACH�s ß!Ý × Ö�à�ÿ�Ø ß Ø Ü ç!Ö Ý Ø ß ÖÅâ�ãIKZ¸?BIYZcFY>ÁIY<�>�l�FYZ ` >$?Y?BZcF¬?BI�]�IK>6]^H�L ß!Ý × ß Ø�Ö Ý þ ß Ø ß Ø Ü ç!Ö Ý Ø ß ÖÅâ�ã´IKZ¸FY>$?BIYZcFY>�IK<f>

l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F�?kI�]_IY>^�º�E>@H ` >^�'IK<�>�FB> ` Zvg^>@F N FBZ U IYACH�>ÁHf>$gc>$F¬FY>$I U FYHf?�]_H�L;>¢�a> `$U IKAXZcH

` ZcHJIKAXH U >@?E]^?�AXd#AXI�AX?=FY>¢I U FBH�ACH�s1dqFBZ W ß!Ý × Ú¢û Ù Ý Þ Ø ß Øjâ�ãV�Î^Ú

Page 45: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

:=<�>�? N ?BIY> W ¼ ?3?BI�]�IK>L>qof�a>$L·FY>$?YZ U F ` >$?�@�? U�` <·]_?mIY<�>�?Y<2]^FB>@L W > W ZcF N � ¤ � ¤ Ë ��]_H�L

?YZ ` �^>¢IK?\AC? U H�FB>@?BIYZcFK] M bC>'ACH�Z U F}A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcH�]^?}AC?�]_bC?YZSIK<�> ` ]^?B> � AXIK<jZ^IK<�>$F}A W l�bX>¢¹

W >@HJI�]_IYACZcHf?=Z^d ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s��

�a�Ïå � �al�>@FBA W >@HJI�]^bFB>@? U bXIY?E]_H�L�]^H2]^b N ?BAC?

:�Z8g_]^bXACL2]�IK>+Z U F�A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcH � � > <2]�gc>�IY>@?BIY>@L�AXI}ZcH¬]8H U W�M >@F|Z^d¡]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?

� AXIY<�Z U I\>$H ` Z U HJIK>@FBACH�s3]^H N lfFYZ M bX> W ?|L U FBACH�s�FB> ` Zvg^>@F N �S:=<f>@?Y>P>¢�al�>@FBA W >@HJIK? � >@FY> l�>@F�¹

dqZcF W >$L'ZcH+]^H � HJIY>@baD�>@HJIYA U W �Y� W ] ` <�AXH�>GF U HfH�ACH�s}�¡IKbXACH U �|g^>@FB?YACZ^H1Îf�Ï�EF U H�H�ACHfsEZcHtIK<�> W �

9 IYZ^I�]^b�Z^d Ê �3FY>�]_L�ACH�s^? � >@FY>8IK]^�^>$H�]^H�LÁIK<f>@H6]�gc>$FK]^sc>$L�� � >@bXZ �Æ� >m]^FB>8?Y<fZ � AXH�s�IK<f>

FY>$? U b�IK?=dqZcF=?BZ W >\]_l�l�bCA ` ]_IYACZcHf? �

Ê ��hj]_IKFBA�� T p U ]^FB> � :=<�AC?�AC?=]�?kIKFK]_ACsc<JIYdqZ^F � ]^FYL W ]_IKFBA�� W U bXIKAXl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH �#9EH Ê �c�s� Ê �^�

W ]_IYFYAø�jAX?�ACHfAXIKAC]^bCAX�@>$L U ?YACHfsm]8FK]^H�LfZ W H U W�M >@F|s^>@H�>$FK]_IYZcF|]^H�L�IY<�>@H¬A�IK?�?Bp U ]^FY>1AX?

` ]^b `@U bC]_IK>$L3]_H�L3?kIKZcFB>@L�ACH�]^H�Z_IK<�>$F Ê �c�v� Ê �c� W ]_IKFBA��y�

� �a> `@U IYACZcH�IKA W > � A�IK<�Z U I ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIKAXH�s l ~ Þ�� Ô^Î Ê� Î^åc�+H�?9}l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH/?BAC�@> � AXIY<�Z U I ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s">¨]_d�IY>@F¡bCZJ]^LfACH�s']^?r�_>@FYHf>@b W ZaL U bC>%@ l�Ê ~^�c�M)N IY>@?

T I�] ` � T AC�@> l�Ê �c� � ���<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJI�I�]^�_>@H�]�I�FYZ ��l åc�� �a> `@U IYACZcH�IKA W > � A�IK< ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s l Îc� � �^ÕcÎ � ÚJÕcÕ�H�?9}l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?YAX�@> � AXIY< ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJIKAXH�s l Î^ÚJ�c� MJN IK>$?:=A W >|?Yl�>@HJI}AXH ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�sSFYZ U IYACH�>$? l Õf�Ì~cÔa� Ê Îcå�H�?e l�ZcH3FB>@?kI�]^FkIKACHfsPA�I=ZcH3]^H�Z^IY<�>@F=HfZaL�> �

:=A W >|?Yl�>@HJI}AXH�FY> ` Zvgc>$F N FYZ U IKACHf>@? l�Ê �Ïå^Ú)~V�ÌÕcÕ^��H�?~a� � H�?Y>$FBIKAXZcH T ZcFBI � :=<fAC?\AC?\]m?BIK]^H�L2]^FBL*?BZcFBIYACH�s�]^bXscZcFYA�IK< W ��9EH*]^FBFK] N Z^d�?YAX�@> Ê �c�c�^�

� ]^?�FK]_H�L�Z W b N ACH�A�IKAC]^bCAX�@>@L/]^H�LmIK<�>$H3A�I � ]^?E?BZcFBIY>@L U ?YAXH�s � H�?Y>$FBIYACZcH T ZcFkI��

� �a> `@U IYACZcH�IKA W > � A�IK<�Z U I ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIKAXH�s l�Ê ~a�Ï�cåf� Þ �c�a�Ì�J~_��H�?ÎJ�

Page 46: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

9}l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?YAX�@> � A�IK<�Z U I ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�sE>¨]�d�IK>@F}bCZJ]^LfACH�s�]_?|�^>@FBH�>@b W ZVL U bC>%@ l Õc�c�M)N IY>@?

T I�] ` � T AC�@> l åc�c� ���<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIE<2]^? M >$>@HmI�]^�_>@H � <�>@Hj]^FYFY] N ACH�Lf>¢� � ]^? l åc�^�c� �� �a> `@U IYACZcH�IKA W > � A�IK< ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s l�Ê ~V�Ì�JÔV�ÏÚJ�c�a�Ì�^�c��H�?9}l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?YAX�@> � AXIK< ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sn>¨]�d�IK>@FmbXZJ]^L�AXH�s6]^?��^>@FBH�>@b W ZaL U bC>%@ l Îc�c�c�M)N IY>@?

:=A W >|?Yl�>@HJI}AXH ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�sSFYZ U IYACH�>$? l Ú��Ïå Þ �ÏÎ Ê ~+H�?Ë H�FY>$?BIK]^FBIYACH�s AXIrZcHj]_H�Z^IK<f>@F�H�ZVL�> �

:=A W >|?Yl�>@HJI}AXH�FY> ` Zvgc>$F N FYZ U IKACHf>@? l Õf�ÛÚJåf�ÏÕ Ê å�Hf?T Z=IK<�>iIYZ^I�]_b^>¢�a> `@U IYACZcHtZvgc>@FB<�>�]_L'Zvgc>$FY<�>@]^L+l�>@F ` <f> ` �)lyZ^ACHJI�dqZcF W ]_IKFBA�� W U bXIYACl�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH

AC?i~a�ÌÔ2ï;]^H�L�dqZcF�ACH�?B>@FBIYACZcH'?YZcFkI�AC?¡�Ì�_Ú�ï8�(:=<�AX?(L�AëA >$FY>@H ` >=AC? M > ` ] U ?Y>rAXH�?Y>$FBIKAXZcH�?BZcFBI(AC?�g^>@F N` Z W l U I�]_IYACZcH�AXHJIK>@Hf?YAXg^>�]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H1]^H�LP]^bX?YZ�IK<f>=?BI�] ` �1?YAC�$>=H�>@>$L�>@L dqZcFiIY<�AC?G]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH

AC?+? W ]^bCbX>@F ` Z W l2]^FB>@L*IYZ W ]_IYFYAø� W U bXIYACl�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H��m:=<�>�ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>8AXH�?YAX�@>8Z^dE]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH

` ZVL�>+]^l�l�>�]^FB?EIKZ M >'bn]^FBsc> M U I}IY<�AC?E]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcHmAC?E]S? W ]^bXb#]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H3]_H�L3IY<�>�?YAX�@>tZ^d

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s ` ZaLf>�AC?}oa�f>$L½?YZ � A�IK< M AXscsc>@F}]^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?@�2IY<�>�ACH ` FY>@]^?Y>+ACH�?BAC�@> � ACbCb M >

ACHf?YACs^H�AXo ` ]^HJI��

�a�ÌÔ ©�A W A�I�]_IYACZcHf?

Ê ����<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIKAXH�s ` ]^H M >|L�ZcH�>|AXH�å�à¶ç%ø-â�ã�ZcH�b N ?YAXH ` >|A�d#L�ZcH�>|AXH�?YZ W >�d U H ` IKACZ^H��fIK<f>FY>$I U FYHP]^LfL�FY>$?Y?GZ^d�IK<2]�Iid U H ` IKACZ^H��c?K]�g^>@LPZcH�IK<�>=?kI�] ` ���)H�>$>@L�?�IKZ M > ` <2]^Hfsc>@L�� � <fA ` <

AC?=L�AëC `$U bXI=IYZ A W l�bC> W >$H)IrACH�IK<�> ` ]^?Y>\Z^d�FY> `@U FB?YAXg^>td U H ` IYACZcH�?$�~a�¡£EZSd U H ` IYACZcH�lyZ^ACHJIK>$FY?�]^FY>']^bXbCZ � >$LmACHmIK<�>']^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcH���]_?�d U H ` IKAXZcH�lyZcAXHJIK>@FB?E<�]vg^>

]^L�L�FB>@?Y?B>@?\Z^diIY<�> ` ZaL�>'?Y>$s W >$HJI�� � <�A ` <½]^FB>�L�ANAy>@FB>@HJI�Z^H�L�ANAy>@FB>@HJI W ] ` <�AXH�>@?$�}À�>

H�>@>$LmIYZ W ZVL�A�d N IY<�> W IKZ1l�ZcAXH)I¡IKZ�IY<�> ` ZcFBFY> ` I=bXZ ` ]_IKAXZcH��(:=<fAC? ` ]^H�H�Z^I M >�sc>$H�>@FY]^b�¹

AC�@>$Lj]_H�L � ACbCb W ]^�_>|Z U F�A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]_IYACZcH/]^l�l�bXA ` ]_IKAXZcHa¹õ?Bly> ` A�o ` �

Îcå

Page 47: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

z ,&�&� ��*� æ

z+5 È8z|Å�³/7 �$5PÈ/7��PÈPÉÙ��³ %+³ 01xãÉ/��01xtz|%+�$5PÈ/7

� H+IK<fAC?�IY<�>@?BAC? � >r<�]vg^>=bCZVZc�^>$L�]_I�IK<�>¡l�FYZ M bC> W ?#Z^d�l�Z � >@F�¹�] � ]^FY>r? ` <�>@L U bCAXH�s|]^H�L'd»] U bXI

IKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` >PdqZcF\FB>�]^bø¹ IKA W >+? N ?BIY> W ?@� À*>8<�]vg^>8]^bX?YZ�?YA W U bn]�IK>@L�]�bCZ � l�Z � >$F'd»] U b�I\IKZcbX>@FK]_H)I

? N ?kIK> W ]^H�L�?BI U L�AX>@L8g_]^FYAXZ U ?�IKFK]_L�>@Z�Ay? M >$I � >@>$H3FB>@bCAC] M AXbCAXI N ]^H�L8>$H�>@FBs N ` ZcH�? U W laIKACZ^H8Z^d]1? N ?BIY> W �

À*>'<2]�gc>�A W lfbC> W >@HJIY>@L3]SL N H2] W A ` gcZ^bXI�]_sc>'? ` ]^bXACH�s M ]^?B>@L½? ` <�>@L U bC>@F}ACH�>v��Zc?$�}:=<�AX?

? ` <f>@L U bX>@FrlfFYZvgVACL�>$?r] � ] N IYZ ` bC]^A W F U Ha¹¿IKA W >�?YbC] ` � ACHPIK<�>E? N ?BIY> W � A�IK<�Z U I W AC?B?YAXH�s+]_H N

<2]^FBL¬L�>�]^LfbCACHf>1]^H�L ` ]^H M > U ?B>@L�]^?\]^H½>�A > ` IKA�gc> ?YZ^b U IYACZcHjdqZ^F�lyZ � >@F ` Z^H�?BIYFK]^AXH�>@L¬<2]^FBL

FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >�? N ?BIY> W dqZcF�>^�ÛsP?B>�] M ZcFBH�>\? N ?BIY> W ?@�GÀ*>|<2]�g^> W ZVL�AXo2>$Lm]^H � HJIK>@by¾�? ` ]^bC> M ZJ]^FBL

dqZcF��=¥ T IKZ1g_]^bCAXL2]_IY>�Z U F�]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W �À*>}<2]�gc>|L�> W ZcHf?BIKFY]_IK>$L�IK<2]_I¡IK<�>Ed»] U bXI¡IKZcbX>@FY]^H ` >EZ^d�]+? N ?kIK> W ` ]^H M >}IKFY]^L�>$L�Z�A3dqZ^F

>@Hf>@FYs N ` ZcHf? U W lfIKAXZcH��#:=<�AC?#]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W AX?�]^H\>¢�VIK>$H�?YAXZcH'IYZ�Z U F�gcZ^bXI�]_sc>�? ` ]^bCAXH�s�]^bCs^ZcFYA�IK< W �

À�>tFB>@L Uf` >|IK<�>\l�Z � >$F ` ZcH�? U W lfIYACZcH�L U FYAXH�s H�ZcF W ]^b ` ZcH�LfAXIKAXZcH�? MJN F U H�H�AXH�s1IK<�> ` l U AXH

bCZ � >@F�?Yl�>@>$L³> ` bC]^A W ACHfs M Z_IK</F U Ha¹¿IKA W >�]^H�LS?BI�]�IKA ` ?YbC] ` ��@�]_H�L/IKF N IKZ'FY>@L U�` >�IK<�> ` <2]^H ` >@?Z^d W AX?Y?YAXH�s�IK<�>SL�>�]_L�bCAXH�>@? MJN F U H�HfACH�smIK<�>Pl�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcF�]�I'<fACsc<�>$?BI'?Yl�>@>$LÁACH�]^H*>¢gc>$H)I+Z^d

d»]^AXb U FB>^��À*>�<2]�gc>3]^bX?YZ�l�FY>$?Y>@HJIY>@L´?BA W U bC]_IKAXZcH�FY>$? U b�IK?1dqZcF1IK<f>�IYFK]^L�>$Z�A M >$I � >@>@H�d»] U bXI

IKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` >�]^H�L&>@H�>$FYs N �ÃÀ*>3<2]�gc>½]_bC?YZ�L�AC? `@U ?B?Y>$L¸IY<�>�A W l�bX> W >@HJI�]�IKACZ^H�AC?Y? U >@?/FY>@bC]_IK>$L

� AXIY<�IK<�AX?�]^bCscZ^FYAXIY< W �À*>S<2]�gc>/]^bC?BZ3A W l�bX> W >@HJIK>$L�] ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�sjbCA M FK]^F N FBIYb ` �)lfItdqZcF'�¡IKbXACH U ��]^lfl�bCA ` ]�¹

IKAXZcH�?}IY<2]_I\l�FBZvgaAXL�>�d»] U b�I}IYZcbC>$FK]^H ` >�dqZcF�FB>�]^b#IKA W >1]^lfl�bCA ` ]_IYACZcH�?$� � I|AC?�g^>@F N >�]^? N IKZ U ?B>

]^H�L'<2]^?#gc>@F N bXZ � Zvgc>@FB<�>�]_L ]^?Y?BZ ` An]_IY>@L � A�IK<'AXI��À�>�<2]�g^>rL�>@? ` FBA M >@L+g_]^FBACZ U ?�l�FBZ M bX> W ?�AXH

A W l�bX> W >@HJIKAXH�s ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIKAXH�s1ACH/]^H��(: Ë T ]^HfL8<�Z �¸� >�<�]vg^>�Zvgc>$F ` Z W >}IY<�> W �i¥�]^FBACZ U ?

bCA W A�I�]_IYACZcHf?GIYZSZ U F=A W l�bC> W >$HJI�]_IYACZcH/]^FY>t]^bX?YZ L�>@? ` FBA M >@L��

ÎJÔ

Page 48: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

:=<�>@FB>�]^FB>m?Y>$g^>@FY]^bELfACFY> ` IYACZcH�?1AXH � <fA ` <6d U I U FB> � ZcFB� ` ]^H�scZ�� Ë H�>3Z_d}IK<f> W AC?�IYZ

ACH ` ZcFBlyZcFY]_IK> ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s¬]_H�L6��¥ T ACHÁ]j? N ?BIY> W ]_H�L*IK<f>@H�?BI U L N g^]_FYACZ U ?'IYFK]^L�>$Z�Ay?M >$I � >@>@H¸FB>@bCAC] M AXbCAXI N ]^H�L&>@H�>$FYs N ` Z^H�? U W lfIYACZcH&dqFBZ W ]�lfFK] ` IKA ` ]^b�lyZcAXHJI/Z^d}gaAX> � � � W ¹

l�bX> W >@HJIKAXH�s ` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s½dqZcF�] W U bXIYAXIY<�FY>@]^L�>@LÁ]^l�l�bXA ` ]�IKACZ^H*ACH6]_H6�(: Ë T AX?1]^H�Z_IK<�>$F

]�gc>$H U >+Z^d�FY>$?Y>�]_F ` <��

À*>|<�]vg^>'A W lfbC> W >@HJIY>@L�]1? N ?kIK> W IK<2]_I�<�]^?rI � Z gcZ^bXI�]_sc>@?=bX>$gc>$b]^H�L ` ]^H M > W ZaLfAXo2>$L

dqZcF W U bXIYACl�bX>�g^ZcbXIK]^sc>�¹õ?Yl�>@>$Lm?Y>$IBIKAXH�sc?@��9EH�Z^IY<�>@FrLfACFY> ` IYACZcH8Z_d�FB>@?B>�]^F ` <3AX?¡IKZ1A W lfbC> W >@HJI�]

�=¥ T M ]^?Y>$L3? ` <�>@L U bC>$F�dqZcF � � � T I�]^?B�V?E]^H�L�IK]^?Y�)? � AXIK<ml�FB> ` >@L�>$H ` N scFK]_l�<�?@�

Ë gc>@FY]^bCb¨� � >½<2]�gc>�L�> W ZcHf?BIKFY]_IK>$L�IK<�>½>$H�>@FBs N ?K]�gVACHfsc?m] ` <�AX>$gc>$L MJN AXH ` Z^FYl�ZcFK]_IYACH�s

L N H2] W A ` gcZcb�I�]^sc>E? ` ]^bCAXH�s�ZcHm]^H ` Z WSW >@F ` AC]^b W A ` FYZ^l�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F=]^H�L U ?BACH�s ]�l�Z � >$F�] � ]^FB>

> W+M >$L�L�>@L Ë T � Ë U Fr��¥ T ¹õ>$H2] M bX>@Lm? N ?BIY> W > Ë T ]^H�Lm<2]^FBL � ]_FY>@ � <f>@H U ?Y>$LmdqZ^Fr> W�M >@LV¹L�>$L´]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?$� ` ]^H�bC>�]_L6IYZ�?BACscHfAXo ` ]^HJI >@H�>$FYs N ?Y]vgVAXH�sc?@��À*>m<2]�g^>�]^bX?YZ¬l�FY>$?Y>$H)IY>@L

` <�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IYACH�s�bCA M FK]_F N IK<2]_I ` ]^H M >¬bXACH��_>@L � AXIY<{]_H�FB>�]^b�IYA W >½]^l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�dqZ^F8d»] U bXI

IKZ^bC>@FY]^H ` >|l U FYl�Zc?B>@?@�

ÎcÕ

Page 49: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

01��wf�����������.H ÊKJ �}�2h��f�\FBAC?B<�H2]�]^HfL�¡]^H�Ha¹õ�}]^Hfs1©>@>^��è�¥GZcbXIK]^sc>¢¹���bCZ ` �c¹ Ta` ]^bCAXH�s\9}L2]^laIKAXg^> Ta` <�>$L U bø¹ACH�sP:�> ` <�H�AXp U >@?}dqZcF�©Z � D�Z � >@F�AXH��}]^FBL���>�]^b�:=A W > T N ?BIY> W ?@� é ��������� acT�\����ÅWdVÒa��a�X���S8[]\ [c`�R�T�S������ �U\0WYXcT�^ÎWY[]S�!Gb�R]V"��[#!�W%$�V1��hj] N ~^�c�^�f��l�l�� Ê �^å¢: Ê åc�a�HÛ~ J 1� T <�AXH��V�1�)��<�ZcA¨�a]_H�LS:|� T ]^� U FK]^A¨�PèYD#Z � >@F¡ZclfIYA W AC��]�IKACZ^H�?�Z_d�FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >¡> W�M >@L�Lf>@L? N ?BIY> W ?�ZcHÍg_]^FYAC] M bX>´?Yl�>@>$L l�FBZ ` >@?Y?BZcFY?$� é &�' [X)( � S�^*(,+.[]S�-.(/+.[]V"��$�^�a ' �0��W0��a1�Q<a�!�Wë`�S2��l�l���Î^åJ�Q¹�Î^åcÕf��2 U H�>+~^�c�c�f�H Î J è � H�>$FYs N >DC ` AX>@HJI�of�a>@LV¹õl�FBACZcFBAXI N ? ` <�>$L U bCAXH�sÁdqZcFSFY>�]_b�¹ IYA W >m? N ?BIY> W ?�Z^H´g^]_FYAn] M bC>?Yl�>@>@L�lfFYZ ` >@?B?YZcFB?@� é &�' [X)(�Q<a�!�Wë`�S3�"$�^�[]V�T�^ÎWY[]S4+.[]S�-%a ' a�S8X�a¢��l�l ��ÕJ~_Õ�¹�ÕcÎ^Îf�52 U H�>~^�c� Ê �H§Ú J :|� � ?Y<fAC<2]^FY]f��]^H�L��t��¡]^? U�U FY]f� èk¥GZ^bXI�]_sc>3? ` <�>@L U bCAXH�s�l�FYZ M bC> W dqZ^F/L N H2] W A ` ]^bCb Ng^]_FYAn] M bC>½gcZ^bXI�]_sc>*l�FBZ ` >@?B?YZcFB?@� é &�' [X)( � S�^6(�b�R]V"�7(98([;: & [;:öa '<� \ a�X�^ ' []S�WYX�!½T�S��Q<a�!�Wë`�S�!¢� ÊvÞ^Þ Õf��l�l � ÊvÞ Ô:f~_�J~a�HÛ� J �}�#h���|FYAX?Y<�H2]a���t]_H�s3[ � T <�ACH��~è Ë H TV` <�>@L U bCACHfs�:�]^?B�V? � AXIY<�]*Õ U A ` ����> ` ZQg^>@F NdqFYZ W ¤ ]^AXb U FB>^� é,������� � ' T�S�!)(,[]S=+.[]V"��$�^�a ' !¢��¥GZ^b¿�2��¹õÎJ�a�2£ Ë ���a��hj] N ÊvÞ Õ^åf�H å J �\FBAC?B<�H2]|�=h�� T ACH�s^<�9�����èY��>@bCAC] M AXbCAXI N Z^dy��<�> ` �Vl�ZcAXH)IY>@LP��>�]^bø¹õ:=A W > T N ?BIK> W ? U ?YAXH�s:=A W >\��>$L U H�L2]_H ` N � é3������� � ' T�S�!)(,[]S � a�\0W T >KWd\0Wd^ÎR�� T >$l�� ÊvÞcÞ Îa��l�l��2Ú)~^Ô:VÚJÎJ�V�HÛÔ J T ��À �� � ]_��� � �?2f����<�ZcAG]^HfL � �Ì�1��|A W �~èk9}H Ë lfIKA W ]^b ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�sm?BIYFK]_IY>@s NdqZcF|FY>@]^biIKA W > ` ZcHJIKFBZcbi? N ?kIK> W U HfL�>@F|IKFY]^H�?BAC>@HJI\d»] U b�IK?$� é@������� � ' T�S�!)( � a�\0W T >KWd\0Wd^ R_�T >@l��y~^�^� Ê �ag^Zcb¿���_�f��l�l���~ Þ Î�¹�Î^� Ê �H Õ J �t]_H�s½[1� T <�ACH �(:#>@ACHV¹��E?BAn]^Hfs�©ACH��?1�Ï�'��©>@>_�Ïè Ë lfIKA W ]_bG��<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s�Z_d���>@]^b�¹:=A W >|:(]^?B�)?@� é3������� � ' T�S�!)(,[]S=+.[]V"��$�^�a ' !¢�a¥GZcb¿����¹õÎcåf�2£ Ë � ÊcÊ �2£�ZQg�� ÊvÞ^Þ Ôa�H ÞBJ 2f�fD�bn]_H�����h�� � > ` ����[ �V�|ACHfsc?YbX> N ����è�©�A M ` �)lfI � :#FK]^H�?Bl2]^FB>@HJI���<�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfs U H�L�>$Fe H�Aø� � é D�FYACH ` >$IYZcH e H�A�gc>@FB?YA�I N�é �H Ê � J À¸ACbCbXAn] W �t�y��AC>¢IK>$F@�?2c] W >$? � ��© U W l�l/2^F$��èB9 e ?Y>@F�¹õbX>$gc>$b���<�> ` �)lyZcAXHJIKACHfsm©�A M FK]_F NdqZcF|D Ë T � ¾Í:=<�FY>@]^L�?tD�FYZcs^FK] W ?@� e H�A�gc>@FB?YA�I N Z^d¡�|>@HJI Uf` � N � é ��XcT ��a�V�WYX &A' a�!�! � S8X�BC aD:FE�[ '�G B C E#� ÊvÞ^Þ Ôa�H ÊcÊKJ h3A ` <2]_>@bi©A�IK�@�_Z � ��:�ZVL�L½:�]^H�H�>$H M ] U W �H2^A W � ]_?YH�> N ��]^H�L�h�ACFYZ^H½©AXgVH N �*èK��<f> ` �c¹lyZcAXHJIj]_H�L W ACscFY]_IKAXZcH�Z^d U H�A��¸lfFYZ ` >@?B?Y>$?�ACH�IK<�> ` ZcHfL�ZcF�L�AC?kIKFYA M U IY>@LÃlfFYZ ` >@?B?YAXH�s? N ?BIY> W � é ��a�X���S�WYXcT�\ � aI��[ ' ^KJL�M7N#B�O(S�W%P�a ' !�Wd^ R�[Q-SR;WT!X�[]S�!�WdSU�*V~T ��WT![]S +.[]V"��$�^�a 'b�X�WYa�S8X�a¢��9}l�FBACb Ê�ÞcÞ Ôa�

Î Þ

Page 50: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

H Ê ~ J}� L U ]^FYLfZ8D�ACH�<f>@ACFBZ���èB:�F U b N ¹ :�FY]^H�?Yl�]^FY>$H)I|��<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�sPZ^d�D�]^FK]_bCbC>$b9}l�lfbCA ` ]_IKAXZcH�?>qÀ�ZcFY�)ACHfsS��FY]_d�I7@�� éXW a1��a ' T�\5OÅS�W%P�a ' !�Wd^ R"[Q- � WY[���aZY�T�S8a�W ' [,O W[� Y�(H Ê Î J � U ]m�@<�Z^H�s�]^HfLX2c]^?BZcHÁ£�AC>$<��X�½èK�r��9�� � ©AXH U ����<�> ` �)l�ZcACHJI�=^��>$?BIK]^FBI+9}?t]3�|>$FYH�>$bh3ZaL U bC>_� é �Ua�X���S�WYXcT�\ � aI��[ ' ^%B\��aI��T ' ^ VÒa�S�^�[Q-*X�[]V"��$�^�a ' !X�WYa�S8X�a�B]+.[]\�$�V]>KW T^OÅS�W%�P�a ' !�Wd^ R��H Ê Ú J :=<�>+��:�¹�©ACH U � Ë l�>@FY]_IKAXH�s T N ?BIY> W �_��^ ^��7`ba a�:c:c:�( -�!�V�\ëT >D!)( X�[]V"ayX�[]V�V�$�S�Wd^ Rda7(H Ê � J 2c] N ]^HJI�]{� �\��> N �P��ZcH2]_bCL ¤ �|:#Z � ?YbC> N �S�}�'h��\�|FYAX?Y<�H2]a� ]^H�LÐhj]^<�>$?Y<Í[|ACFB�_]_F@�è � C ` AC>$H)I Ë Ha¹õ©�AXH�>�D�FYZ ` >$?Y?YZ^F TV` <�>@L U bCACHfstdqZcFG]t��bC]^?Y?GZ^d � � � T > � H ` FB>�]^?BACH�s'��> � ]_FYL� AXIK< � H ` FB>�]^?BACH�s T >@FBgVA ` >^� @¢� é=� acT�\����ÅWdVÒae��T;! G !)(Nb �;f V � � �5� +jb�� ÊvÞcÞ Îf�_l�l��^~ Ê Ô:a~c~^Õf�H Ê å J :�FY]^H�? W >$IK]/��Z^FYl�ZcFK]_IYACZcH �f<JIYIYl � =�= �=�=� �ÛIYFK]^Hf? W >$I�]a� ` Z W =V�H Ê Ô J <)IBIKl � =2= �=�=� �ÛACHJIY>@b¿� ` Z W =_Lf>@?YAXscH�=_AXHJIK>@bø�a? ` ]_bC>=V�H Ê Õ J 9�� � � HfscACH�>$>@FBACH�s � H ` � � �E� FB>$dq>$FY>@H ` > l�bn]_IBdqZcF W �<)IBIKl � =2= �=�=� �Ï]^L�AX>@H�s^ACH�>$>@FYAXH�s�� ` Z W =_l�FBZaL U�` IY? � ���'�Û<JI W bH ÊvÞBJ ©�A U ���}��©����2]^H�L3©�] N bC]^H�L��g2f��À ����è Ta` <f>@L U bXACH�sP]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W ?�dqZcF W U b�IKAClfFYZcscFY] WPW AXH�sACHm<2]^FBL3FB>�]^bø¹ IKA W >E>@HJgVACFBZcH W >@HJI�� é Y�(?�h+iVkj�l#BAJ/�g2c]^H � ÊvÞcÞ Îf�fl�l��2ÚJå¢:Vå Ê �HÛ~^� J�Ë ? W ]_H T � e H�?K]^b¨� � ?YFY]^>@b|�|ZcFB>@H��E�}��h3]^H�A��|FBAC?Y<fH2]f��� èB:#Z � ]_FYL�? � H�>$FYs N ¹õ9 � ]_FY>T Z^d�I � ]^FY>�¹ � ]^?B>@L ¤ ] U bXI1:#ZcbX>@FK]_H ` >�AXH���>�]_b�¹õ:=A W > T N ?BIY> W ?@� é &�' [X)( � S�^�a ' SUT�^ WY[]SUT�\b�RBV"��[#!�W%$�V []Sm8Å[;: & [;:öa '�� \ a�X�^ ' []S�WYX�!�T�S��~Q<a�!�Wë`�S2� � T ©�D � � ¼ �c~a�Ï9 U s U ?kI�~_�c�J~a�l�l�� Ê ~_Ú¢: Ê ~ Þ �HÛ~ ÊKJ 1�\n <2]^H�s;]_H�LÆ�'�+��<2]^�)FY] M ]^FkI N � è � H�>@FBs N ¹�] � ]^FY>�]_L2]^lfIYAXgc> ` <�> ` �)l�ZcACHJIYACH�s;AXH> W�M >@L�Lf>@L�FY>�]_b(IKA W >'? N ?BIY> W ?@� éo&A' [X)(9Q<a�!�Wë`�S�!Z�"$�^�[]V�T�^ÎWY[]S½T�S��3�Ua�!�^�WdS � $ ' [���a+.[]S�-%a ' a�S8X�a¢��~^�c�cÎa��l�l�� ÞfÊ Õ¢: Þ ~^Îa�HÛ~c~ J �'��9 N L�ACH �J�t�^h3>$bC<�> W �^���ch3Z^?Y?Y>_�)]^H�L1D#�ch��_9EbXg_]^FY>$�^�PèB��>$IK>$F W ACH�AXH�s�ZclfIYA W ]^b)l�FYZ_¹` >@?B?YZcF�?Yl�>@>$L�?�dqZcF=ly>$FYAXZaL�A ` FB>�]^bø¹ IKA W >�I�]^?B�)? � A�IK<mL�AëA >$FY>@HJI�l�Z � >@F ` <2]_FK] ` IK>@FBAC?kIKA ` ?@� é� $ ' []V�WYX ' [p+.[]S�-%a ' a�S8X�as[]S � acT�\����ÅWdVÒa§b�R#!�^�a�V\!¢��~^�^� Ê �HÛ~^Î J :|�=D�>$FYACHfs��E:|� ��U FYL �}]^HfL{�\� � FYZVL�>@FB?Y>@H � èk:=<�>¬?YA W U bn]_IYACZcH�]^H�L¸>¢g^]_b U ]_IYACZcH�Z^dL N H2] W A ` gcZcb�I�]^s^>t? ` ]^bXACH�sP]^bXscZcFBAXIK< W ?$� éq� S�^�a ' SUT�^ÎWY[]SUT�\�b�R]V"��[#!�W%$�Vú[]Sr8Å[;:c� & [;:öa '� \ a�X�^ ' []S�WYX�!sT�S���Q<a�!�Wë`�S2� ÊvÞcÞ Õf�fl�l���Ô^å¢:VÕ Ê �HÛ~_Ú J 9+�'��<2]^H�LfFK]^��]^?Y]^H ]^HfL �\� � FYZVL�>@FB?YZcH � èY©Z � D�Z � >@FÁ��AXscAXIK]^b1�=h Ë T ��>@?YAXscH���\b U � >$F�9 ` ]^Lf> W A ` D U M bXAC?Y<f>@FY?$��£EZcF � >$bCb¨��h39+� Ê�ÞcÞ �a� éHÛ~c� J �}�J� � ]^H�s']^H�L 9+�J��¹��'�_À U ���PèB9�lfFY>@LfA ` IYAXg^>=? N ?BIY> W ?Y< U IYL�Z � H W >$IY<�ZVL dqZ^Fi>@H�>$FYs N?K]�gVACH�sEZ^d�>¢gc>@HJIk¹õL�FBAXgc>$H ` Z W l U I�]_IYACZcH�� éq&A' [X)( � S�^Î\s(?+.[]S�-.(?+.[]V"��$�^�a ' �0��W0��a1��Q<a�!�Wë`�S2�ÊvÞcÞ Ôa�fl�l���~^Õ¢:VÎJ~a�HÛ~^å J h�� � � T FYAXg_]^?kI�]�g_]f�c9'�JD��)��<�]^H�L�FY]^��]^?K]^HP]^HfLS�\�_À � � FYZVL�>@FB?YZcH � ������� � ' T�S�(öZ78(b �b�Rt!�^�a�V\!¢��gcZcb¨��Ú���lfl��2Ú)~Q¹ Ú)�a� Ê�ÞcÞ åf���

ÚJ�

Page 51: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

HÛ~cÔ J 9}Lfg_]^H ` >���Z^Hfo2s U FY]_IKAXZcH3]^H�L3D�Z � >$F � HJIK>$FBd»] ` >e>q9��rD � @¢�vèB<JIBIKl � =2= �=�=� �Ï] ` lfA¿�ÛACHfdqZ�= é(HÛ~^Õ J ¥��a�E]^s^< U H2]_IK<�]^H��aD�� T l2]^H�Z^?r]^H�L�h�� � � T FYAXg_]^?kI�]�g_]f���PèB9}L�]^lfIKA�gc>ElyZ � >@Fk¹¿o2L�>$bCAXI N AXH>@H�>$FYs N ¹�] � ]^FY>P> W+M >$L�L�>@L�? N ?kIK> W ?@� éo&A' [X)(9Q�a�!�Wë`�Su�"$�^�[]V�T�^ WY[]Sv+.[]S�-.(C��~^�^� Ê �l�l��Ê �cå�¹ ÊcÊ �a�HÛ~ ÞBJ :=<�> > W�M >@LfL�>@L ��ZcHfo2s U FK] M bC> Zcl�>@FY]_IKAXH�s ? N ?kIK> W >»>���Zc?�@��è �=�=� �ÏFB>@L�<�]_I�� ` Z W =_> W�M >$L�L�>$L�=�IK> ` <�H�ZcbXZcscAX>@?�=�> ` Z^? é (H Îc� J D(]^L W ]^H2] M <2]^H'D�ACbCbC]^A_]^H�L'�t]_H�sE[ � T <fACH����GèY��>�]_b�¹ IYA W >(L N H2] W A ` gcZcb�I�]^sc>�? ` ]^bXACH�srdqZ^FbCZ � lyZ � >@F�> W�M >@LfL�>@L�Zcl�>@FK]�IKACHfs�? N ?BIY> W ?@� é Jw2^%���h+iV b�RBV"��[#!�W%$�V []S=xi��a ' T�^ WdS�`b�Rt!�^�a�V\! &A' WdS8X�Wy�U\ a�!¢� Ë ` IKZ M >$F}~_�c� Ê ��lfl���Õ Þ ¹ Ê �J~a�H Î ÊKJ 1�§¹��'��©>$>+]^HfL½�}�yh����|FYAX?Y<�H2]a��èk¥GZcb�I�]^s^>¢¹ ` bCZ ` �S? ` ]^bXACH�s1dqZcF�bXZ � >@H�>$FYs N ` ZcH�? U W lV¹IKACZ^H�AXH�of�a>@La¹ l�FYAXZcFYA�I N FY>@]^b�¹¿IKA W >j> W�M >@L�L�>$LÃ? N ?kIK> W ?$� é � acT�\����ÅWdVÒa#b�Rt!�^�a�V\!¢�EIYZ]^l�l�>�]^F$�H ÎJ~ J ��FYAC?kIKAC]^H�Z|D#>@FY>$ACFY]f�c¥�A§¦Y] N ��]^sc< U H2]_IY<2]^H�� T <2]^bn] M [ U lfI�]f�)��]Q¦B>$?Y<S[ U lfI�]f�c]^H�LShj]^H�AT FYA�g^]_?BI�]�g_]f� èB9 T Z^d�I � ]^FY>j9}F ` <fAXIK> ` I U FY>jdqZ^F ��U AXbCL�AXH�s�D�Z � >$F�9 � ]^FY>���>@]^bE:=A W >Ë l�>@FY]_IKAXH�s T N ?BIY> W ?@� é ��a�X���S�WYXcT�\ � aI��[ ' ^{z�l;j �1l�|��2h3]^F ` < Ê Ú���~^�^�J~/�H ÎcÎ J T ]^H�L�>$>@ljD(]^L W ]^H2] M <2]^H�� &A' W%P]T�^�a�X�[]V�V�$�S�WYXcT�^ WY[]S2�

Ú Ê

Page 52: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

��*�*�&����} �

�P�´��4��")��4}��� V�� �������(w¬����!#�&%��#.�O�.)è( a�#.QO(.Q�2 ���n �,´É'¯(���#4����Á×��("@ V��i��7 � �#")�����{%',�����#��������z|�(.

~.���t�������)�����t�������U�v� �?�U�q�i���r�g���,�6���H���#�U�)�������#�U�)���)� ���0���i�t���)�����#�����\�e�i�0��0�9�u�D�H���t�H� �t��� �#�U�)�q�)� �h�U���¡���e�)�U�q�¢�U�\���¤£¦¥g§�¨©�Z�e���ª�I�������t�0���=���?« ���)�¬� �D�#�­�#���t�¬���#���5�#�U�)�®�0�i�.���U�i����_�������H«�����« ���H� �t�H�;�¬�U� ��t�����#�g�"�e�i�0�5�I���i���t�����<�0�{�i�%¯��¬�#°�������6�t��� �#�t�U���%�t�0���H�U�����?« �t�H�;�¬�U� ��t�����#�r�0�3�<±h� �=�t�H��� �%�\�#�­�g���\²´³eµ¶�o�U���·9µK¸�~#¹]º»�g�?� ���U�)�¢�U�{�U�p���H�[�?�{���­�t�U�q� �#�¬�;�5�U���r�i�­���_���{���ª�#� µ¶ºª¼¡�)�½�H���i���0�¬��0�q�[�����q� �#���<�0�i���0�H�\�t�H���U³e���K¾®���;�H���¿��º]À<Ár�\�H�t�¬�U�S�0�q�i�0���q�����#�_���H�¶Â����%�#�­«g�����U�0�0��«S���;�����q�<�­�i�v�%�t����g�t�r�I���i���#�0���H�U���%�d�¡��� �H� Ã��H���v��� �?ÂH� ���t��«g�t�U���

Ä�Å�Æ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬÆ�ƬÆ�ƬÆ�ƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬÆ

Ç ä Ý�Þ þ ß â7Ö�ãiÈ Ç û à�Ö ÞÊÉ þ2Ø�×Ë à Ý Ø�È<Ì¬Í Ä Ì¬Í ÄΠ̬ÌÏ

ƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬƬÆ�ƬÆ�ƬÆ�ƬÆ�ƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�Æ�ƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬƬÆ�ƬƬƬÆ�ƬÆ�Å Ä

÷ ç%ø Ú ×¢ä�á�ØÑÐ ÚBÛ�Ü Ä û Ø ß ø¶Ø�× Ä û àBÙ�ç üYÞ­Ò÷ ç%ø Ú ×¢ä�á�ØÑÐ�Ö Ý á�ç2þ üYÞ­Ò÷ ç%ø Ú ×¢ä�á�ØÑÐ]å�à Ý!ÞpüÎÞUÒ÷ ç%ø Ú ×¢ä�á�ØÑÐ�Ö Ý á¶×�ç�Ó üÎÞ­Ò÷ á�Ø!ê�ç%ø¶Ø¤Ô�Õ�Ö�× Ø¬Ù�Ú¬Û Ü�Ú�Ý Ç�Þß�Þ Ï

Ú)~

Page 53: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ä�Å ÖÙ¶à Ú ØÐà�×�×�þ Ú à Ý ç2þ¢ø ê¶þ ßÐû Ø ß ø¶Ø�×�þtÓ � Ø Ú¢Ý Ö�à~ê¶þ ß ÿ�à ß ç2þ¢äUÖ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ö�ç%øÝ!Þ Ø�Ö Û Ö Ý Ø]å Å ÄÄ�Åmá ØÏæUç2×�×õà�×]æ�à Û Ö äUÖ�Ø^Ô�Õ�Ö�× Ø�Ù�Ú¬ÛÜ�ÚÝ Ç�Þ�ß�ÞÊâ ��æ Þ ç2×2Ø�à�×�×�þ Ú à Ý ç%ø Ü ÖÙ¶à Ú Ø�àç%ø þ ß á�Ø ßõÝ þ Ú]ß Ø�à Ý Ø ÖÙ¶à Ú Øõê�þ ß Ë�ã Þ Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á ç%ø Ý!Þ Ø Ö Û Ö Ý Ø]å Å ÄÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�Ö[äIÔ�Õ�Ö�× Ø�Ù�Ú¬ÛÜ�ÚÝ Ç�Þ�ß�Þ@â ��å�æ Ä�Å Ç ×�×�þ Ú à Ý ç%ø Ü ÖÙ�à Ú Øê¶þ ßÐÝ!Þ�ß Ø�à2á þtÓ � Ø Ú¢Ý Ö Å ÄÚÞ à ß Ö Ý à Ú¢û ä6ÔÕ�Ö�× Ø¬Ù­Ú¬ÛÜ�Ú�Ý Ç�Þ�ß�Þçâ �#åAä6Ï�̬Í�èå�æ Ä�Å Ç ×�×�þ Ú à Ý ç%ø Ü Ö¢Ù¶à Ú ØÐê¶þ ßÖ Ý à Ú¢û Ö Å Ä

Ú]Û�Ü Ú Þ àBø�á�×2Ø¬Ú Ý Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á Ç àÆÖ�çKå�Ù�×2Ø�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á¬×�à�Ö�çKå�Ù�×2Ø�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�écàÖ�çKå�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á Ë à�á!ÿ�ÖÚ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�æÄ�Å Ý þ Ü ØBø¶Ø ß à Ý Ø Ç éØ¬Ý Öä Ú¢Þ�Ý�Þ à Ý ç Ý ÿ¶à ß çBØ�Ö ä�ø8ç¢ê ß þå�× Û Ó¶Ø Ý æ�Ø�ØBø à Å#á éØ�ÝàBø�á á éØ�Ý Å Äá¶þ¢ä�Ó�×2Ø�à�ê�Ì üIë�ì æá¶þ¢ä�Ó�×2ØÏä�ø�ç¢ê�äd�tÌå�ê�í¬Ì ü ��àqÌ ü Î àuÌ üIî à/Ì ü Ï�à<Ì üQì àuÌ ü è�à/Ì üIë à<Ì üQï à<Ì ü Í�à3� ü ̬ðcæÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�ØBø Ý�ß�Û Ú Ý á!ÿ�Ö�Ú�Ù ß þ Ü�ß à]å�æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�ØBø Ý�ß�Û Ú Ý Ö�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]åH��æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�ØBø Ý�ß�Û Ú Ý Ö�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]å Î æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�ØBø Ý�ß�Û Ú Ý Ö�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]å î æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�ØBø Ý�ß�Û Ú Ý Ö�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]å­Ï�æ

ÚJÎ

Page 54: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�Ú Ý Ú ×�ç#Ó�×�þ Ú¢û æÿ�þ�ç]á Ú]Û�Ü ÚBäUÖ�Ø ß Ú�Ö Ý à ß!Ý â�ÿ�þ�ç¢á�ãí ç%ø Ý çHæÄ�Å ê�ç ß Ö Ý Ö�Ø Ý�Ý ç%ø Ü Ú Ù�ä ý ÖnÖÙ¶Ø�Ø!á Ý þ?å�à ñ ë¬î�î Ö Þ�ò.ü Ö�þ Ú ä ß�ß ØBø Ý Ö�Ø Ý�Ý ç%ø Ü Öà ß Ø�È ë¬î¬î Ö Þ�ò à¡� üQì ã àpÓ¶Ø�×�þ]æ�à ß Ø Ý!Þ Øçó%ø Ý Ø�×õà�Ö�Ö�Ø]å�Ó�× Û ç%øUÖ Ý�ß ä Ú¢Ý ç2þ¢øUÖ Ý þ�Ö�Ø ÝÚ Ù�ä ý Ö�ÖÙ¶Ø�Ø2á Ý þ ë¬î¬î Ö Þ�ò ŬÄÚ¬Ú�à¶Ö%åUÚ¬ÚjâtôdÖ­Û ã Ù7�?à ÷ Í�ôBãHæÚ¬Ú�à¶Ö%åUÚ¬ÚjâtôdÖ�éÙ�Ù��#Ï�à/Ì�à®Ù���à Ú è�à Ú Ì�à<Ì7ôBãHæÙ ß çø Ý ê9â#ô.Ø!ø Ý Ø ß ç%ø ÜIÚBÛ�Ü ÚBäUÖ2Ø ß Ú�Ö Ý à ß!Ý â�ãõê2ä�ø Ú¢Ý ç2þ¢øgõ¢ø�ôBãHæÚ]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Øñ�Ú�ç%ø�ç Ý â©ö Ú ×�ç�ÓU×�þ Ú¢û ã�æ

Ä�Å Ý Þ Ø Þ ç Ü2Þ Ø¶Ö Ý Ù ß ç2þ ß ç Ý�ÛnÝ!Þ�ß Ø�à2á ç!Ö Ë�ã Þ Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á Å ÄÄ�Å ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�Ø2á�ê�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú ÚBß Ø�à Ý Ø�â�Ù ß ç!þ ß ç Ý�Û à Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á ý Ö ß þ¢ä Ý ç%ø¶Ø�à~á�à Ý à�à Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á ý Öø¶à]å�Ø�à Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á ý Ö ß þ¢ä Ý ç%ø¶Ø�à¸Ö Ý à Ú¢û Ù�þ�ç%ø Ý Ø ß à¸Ö Ý à Ú]û Ö�ç ò Ø�à Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á ý Ö Þ à�ø�á¶×2Ø�àÙ�þ�çø Ý Ø ßnÝ þ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á ý Ö�á�à Ý à�Ö Ý�ß ä Ú¢Ý ä ß Ø�à<÷¬Ø�Ù�ó½Û Ë à á é جÝUã Å ÄÚ]Û�Ü Ú�Ø!á�ê�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú Ú]ß Ø�à Ý Øjâ)��à Ú þå�ÙU×2Øñ�ÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß àBå�à�â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý ã½Ìcà

ôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2á ˬã Þ ô�àÐâ�ÿ�þ�ç¢á Å ãõÖ Ý à Ú¢û ä¿Ìå�à<Ï�̬ͬècàö Ú þå�ÙU×2Øñ�Ú Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á�à/ö Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�Ö�äQÌå�àSÌcà<̶ã�æ

ÚcÚ

Page 55: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ú]Û�Ü Ú�Ø!á�ê�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú Ú]ß Ø�à Ý Øjâ Î àLÖ�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]åH��à�â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý ãç�?àôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2á Ç ô�àÐâ�ÿ�þ�ç¢á Å ãõÖ Ý à Ú¢û äD��å�à<Ï�̬ͬècàö�Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á Ç à,ö Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�Ú�Ö[äd�#å�à î ̬Ì�à/è¬Ì�ãHæ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú�Ø!á�ê�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú Ú]ß Ø�à Ý Øjâ î àLÖ�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]å Î à�â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý ã Î àôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2áÑ×�ô�àÐâ�ÿ�þ�ç¢á Å ãõÖ Ý à Ú¢û ä Î å�à<Ï�̬ͬècàö�Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á¬×�à,ö Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�Ú�Ö[ä Î å�àuÏ�̬Ì�à<Ï�Ì�ãHæ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú�Ø!á�ê�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú Ú]ß Ø�à Ý Øjâ¿Ï�àLÖ�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]å î à�â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý ã î àôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2áøé7ô�àÐâ�ÿ�þ�ç¢á Å ãõÖ Ý à Ú¢û ä î å�à<Ï�̬ͬècàö�Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�écà,ö Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�Ú�Ö[ä î å�à ì ̬Ì�à3�tÌ�̶ãHæ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú�Ø!á�ê�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú Ú]ß Ø�à Ý Øjâ ì àLÖ�çKå�ÙU×2جÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]å­Ï�à�â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý ã�Ï�àôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2á Ë ô�àÐâ�ÿ�þ�ç¢á Å ãõÖ Ý à Ú¢û äIϬå�à<Ï�̬ͬècàö�Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á Ë à,ö Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�Ú�Ö[ä6Ï�å�à,è¬Ì¬Ì�à/è¬Ì�ãHæ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú ß Ø�Öä�å�Øjâ�á!ÿUÖ�Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�ã�æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú ß Ø�Öä�å�Øjâ7Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á Ç ã�æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú ß Ø�Öä�å�Øjâ7Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á¬×�ã�æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú ß Ø�Öä�å�Øjâ7Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�é�ã�æÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý�Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú ß Ø�Öä�å�Øjâ7Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2Ø¬Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á Ë ã�æ

ð

Ú)�

Page 56: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ä�Å Ý!Þ ç!Ö�ç!ÖÏà Ú þ�á�Øõæ Þ ç ÚÞ�ß ä�ø�Ö�çø�à Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á ŬÄ

ÿ�þ�ç]á Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2جÚ�Ù ß þ Ü�ß à]å?�8â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý á�à Ý à¶ãí ç%ø Ý å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Øùê â�ç%ø Ý ãMá�à Ý à�æä�øUÖ�ç Ü ø¶Ø2á ç%ø Ý çHà � à"ø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û ÖiæÄ�Å Ý Þ ç!Ö�ç!Ö Ý þ Ü Ø�ø¶Ø ß à Ý Ø�à Ú¢Ý ä¶à�×õØ ñ�Ø Ú ä Ý ç2þ¢ø Ý çKå�Øcà"ä�ø�ç¢ê¶þ ß åU× Û ÿ�à ß çBØ�ÖÓ¶Ø Ý æ�Ø�ØBø à Å#á éØ¬Ý àBø�á á éØ¬Ý Å Äø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�ê âcà â â)� Æ à¶ã Å ä�ø8ç¢êAä ß à�ø�á9â�ã¤ú»�tÌ å�ã Å è¬ÌcæÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ô.×�Ø Ü ç%ø�ø�çø Ü Ø2á�ê�Øñ�Ø Ú ä Ý ç2þ]øAæ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�á�à Ý à ç!Ö�ú�á­õ¢øHô7à�å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ãHæê¶þ ß â�æ¬æ7ãví

Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�Ú�×�þ Ú]û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æ=íÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2áÊú�á ç!Ö ß ä�ø�ø8ç%ø Ü õ¢ø�ô�àYå�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ã�æð Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�ÚBä�ø�×�þ Ú¢û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æê¶þ ß â � ê�Ìcæ � ÐBø�ä�å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�æ � â¬â ã

Ä�Å à�ê¶þ ß ×�þ�þ¢Ù�æUç Ý!Þ ø�ä!å�Ó�Ø ß þBê ç Ý Ø ß à Ý ç2þ¢ø�ê Î î ̬̬ͬÌ�Ì Ú þ¢ø�Öä!å�Ø�Önþ¢ø�Ø Ý ç Ú¢ûà Ýøë¬î¬î Ö Þ�ò Å Äê¶þ ß â�ç;ê�Ì�æ�ç^Ð Î î ͬÌ�̬̬Ì�æ7ç â¬â ãæ

ÚJå

Page 57: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ä�Å Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�Ú2á�Ø�×!à Û ç!Ö ß ØBÙ�×!à Ú Ø2á�æUç Ý!Þ ÚBÛ�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú2æ�à¶ç Ýöü Ý Þ ç!Ö�ê2ä�ø Ú¢Ý ç2þ¢øÙ�ä Ý à Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á ç%ø Ö!×2Ø�ØBÙ Ö Ý à Ý Øcà#êUç%ø�á�ÖÐþ¢ä Ý ç Ý ÖLø¶Øñ Ý à ß�ß çÿ�à�×[à Ú à�×�×Ö ÚÞ Ø2á2ä�×2Ø ß�Ý þ�à2á � äUÖ Ý�Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ö ý Ù ß ç2þ ß ç Ý çBØ�Ö Ó¶à¶Ö�Ø2á þ¢ø Ý�Þ Ø¶ç ß á�Ø�à!á¶×�ç%ø¶Ø¶ÖÏà�ø�áÖ ÚÞ Ø2á2ä�×2ØÏø¶Ø ñ ÝnÞ ç Ü2Þ Ø¶Ö Ý Ù ß ç2þ ß ç Ý�ÛnÝ!Þ�ß Ø�à2á Å ÄÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�Ú�æ�à¶ç Ý â�ãHæ

ðð

ÿ�þ�ç]á Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2جÚ�Ù ß þ Ü�ß à]å Î â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý á�à Ý à¶ãí

ç%ø Ý å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Øùê â�ç%ø Ý ãMá�à Ý à�æä�øUÖ�ç Ü ø¶Ø2á ç%ø Ý çHà � à"ø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Öiæø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�ê âcà â â)� Æ à¶ã Å ä�ø8ç¢êAä ß à�ø�á9â�ã¤ú»�tÌ å�ã Å Ï�ÌcæÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ô.×�Ø Ü ç%ø�ø�çø Ü Ø2á�ê�Øñ�Ø Ú ä Ý ç2þ]øAæ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�á�à Ý à ç!Ö�ú�á­õ¢øHô7à�å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ãHæê¶þ ß â�æ¬æ7ãvíÚ]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�Ú�×�þ Ú]û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æ=íÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2áÊú�á ç!Ö ß ä�ø�ø8ç%ø Ü õ¢ø�ô�àYå�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ã�æ

ð Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�ÚBä�ø�×�þ Ú¢û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æê¶þ ß â � ê�Ìcæ � ÐBø�ä�å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�æ � â¬â ãê¶þ ß â�ç;ê�Ì�æ�ç^Ð Î î ͬÌ�̬̬Ì�æ7ç â¬â ãÚ)Ô

Page 58: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

æ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�æ�à�ç Ý â�ãHæð

ð

ÿ�þ�ç]á Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2جÚ�Ù ß þ Ü�ß à]å î â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý á�à Ý à¶ãí ç%ø Ý å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Øùê â�ç%ø Ý ãMá�à Ý à�æä�øUÖ�ç Ü ø¶Ø2á ç%ø Ý çHà � à"ø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Öiæø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�ê âcà â â)� Æ à¶ã Å ä�ø8ç¢êAä ß à�ø�á9â�ã¤ú»�tÌ å�ã Å �tÌcæÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ô.×�Ø Ü ç%ø�ø�çø Ü Ø2á�ê�Øñ�Ø Ú ä Ý ç2þ]øAæ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�á�à Ý à ç!Ö�ú�á­õ¢øHô7à�å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ãHæê¶þ ß â�æ¬æ7ãví

Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�Ú�×�þ Ú]û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æ=íÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2áÊú�á ç!Ö ß ä�ø�ø8ç%ø Ü õ¢øHô�à_å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ãHæð Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�ÚBä�ø�×�þ Ú¢û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æê¶þ ß â � ê�Ìcæ � ÐBø�ä�å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�æ � â¬â ãê¶þ ß â�ç;ê�Ì�æ�ç^Ð Î î ͬÌ�̬̬Ì�æ7ç â¬â ã

æ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�æ�à�ç Ý â�ãHæð

ÚJÕ

Page 59: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

ð

ÿ�þ�ç]á Ö�ç%å�Ù�×2جÚ�Ù ß þ Ü�ß à]å�Ï9â ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�à2á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý á�à Ý à¶ãí ç%ø Ý å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Øùê â�ç%ø Ý ãMá�à Ý à�æä�øUÖ�ç Ü ø¶Ø2á ç%ø Ý çHà � à"ø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö´æ

ø�ä!å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�ê âcà â â)� Æ à¶ã Å ä�ø8ç¢êAä ß à�ø�á9â�ã¤ú»�tÌ å�ã Å ì ÌcæÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ô.×�Ø Ü ç%ø�ø�çø Ü Ø2á�ê�Øñ�Ø Ú ä Ý ç2þ]øAæ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�á�à Ý à ç!Ö�ú�á­õ¢øHô7à�å�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ãHæê¶þ ß â�æ¬æ7ãvíÚ]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�Ú�×�þ Ú]û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æ=íÙ ß ç%ø Ý ê9â#ôDÝ Þ�ß Ø�à2áÊú�á ç!Ö ß ä�ø�ø8ç%ø Ü õ¢ø�ô�àYå�Ø�Ö�Ö�à Ü Ø¶ã�æ

ð Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�ÚBä�ø�×�þ Ú¢û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æê¶þ ß â � ê�Ìcæ � ÐBø�ä�å�Ó¶Ø ß Ú�þBê�Ú Ý ç Ú¢û Ö�æ � â¬â ãê¶þ ß â�ç;ê�Ì�æ�ç^Ð Î î ͬÌ�̬̬Ì�æ7ç â¬â ãæ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú�æ�à�ç Ý â�ãHæð

ð

ÿ�þ�ç]áÐá!ÿUÖ�ÚBÙ ß þ Ü�ß à]å.â Ú]Û�Ü Ú�à!á�á ß æ�þ ß á�Ú Ý å�Ø¶Ö Ü Ú�à¶ãÚ Þ

Page 60: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

í ç%ø Ý å�Ø�Ö Ü ê�â�ç%ø Ý ãLå�Ø�Ö Ü Ú�à�æÿ�þ�×!à Ý ç2×2ØÏä�ø�Ö�ç Ü ø¶Ø!á ç%ø Ý ñ�à�þ�ê�ê¶×�ç%ø�جÚ�×�þ2à!á�à¸þ¢ø�×�çø¶Ø¬Ú�×�þ!à2á�æä�øUÖ�ç Ü ø¶Ø2á ç%ø Ý Ý Ø]å�Ù�ê�Ì�æñ�ê�Ìcæ

Ä�Å çø�ç Ý çBà�×�þ¢ø�×�ç%ø�Ø¬Ú Ú ä ß ÿ�جÚ�Ö!×�þ¢Ù¶Ø�æ�ç2×�×�Ó¶Ø�Ö2Ø Ý à¶Öø�XÓ¶Ø Ú àBä�Ö�Ø ç%ø�ç Ý à�×Ö�Ø Ý�Ý ç%ø Ü Öõà ß Ø ë¬î�î Ö Þ�ò à¡� üQì ç ü Ø ü ç!Ö Þ ç Ü2Þ ÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø Å ÄÙ ß çø Ý ê9â#ô)×�Ø Ü ç%ø�ø�ç%ø Ü Ë¬ã Þ Ý Þ�ß Ø�à!á ý ÖõØñ�Ø Ú ä Ý ç2þ¢ø�æ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!áná�à Ý à ç!Ö�ú�á­õ¢øHô�àå�Ø�Ö Ü ãHæÄ�Å Ý�Þ Ø�Ö�ØÐê2ä�ø Ú¢Ý ç2þ¢ø�æ�ç2×�×�ç%ø�ç Ý ç�à�×�ç ò Ø þ�ê�ê¶×�ç%ø�Ø Ú ä ß ÿ�Ø�àBø�á þ¢ø�×�ç%ø¶Ø Ú ä ß ÿ�Ø Å ÄÚ]Û�Ü Ú¶ç%ø�ç Ý Ú�þBê�ê¶×�ç%ø¶Ø¬Ú Ú ä ß ÿ�ØjâDãHæÚ]Û�Ü Ú¶ç%ø�ç Ý Ú�þ¢ø�×�çø¶Ø¬Ú Ú ä ß ÿ�Øjâ�ã�ææ Þ ç!×2Øjâ)�2ã�íÄ�Åmá Þ ØBø�Ø�ÿ�Ø ß æ�Ø�Ö Ý à ß�Ý Ö Ë¬ã Þ Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à!á�à�ê�ç ß Ö Ý�Ý!Þ ç%ø Ü Ö�ç!Ö Ý þ Ü Ø Ý þ]ø�×�ç%ø¶Ø�àBø�áþBê�ê�×�ç%ø¶Ø�×�þ2à!á�àBø�á Ú þå�Ù¶à ß Ø Ý�Þ Ø]å Å ÄþBê�ê�×�ç%ø¶Ø¬Ú�×�þ2à2á�ê Ú]Û�Ü Ú2êUç%ø�á�Ú�þ�ê�ê�×�çø¶Ø�Ú�×�þ!à2á9âDã�æþ¢ø�×�ç%ø¶Ø¬Ú�×�þ2à2á�ê ÚBÛ�Ü Ú2ê�çø�á�Ú�þ¢øU×�çø¶Ø�Ú�×�þ2à!á,â�ãHæ

Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�Ú�×�þ Ú]û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æ=í

Ù ß çø Ý ê9â#ô]þBê�ê¶×�çø¶Ø¬Ú�×�þ!à2á ç�Ö[Ȫú!ä�àBø�á þ¢øU×�ç%ø¶Ø�×�þ2à2á ç!Ö�Ȫú2ä�õ¢øHô�àEþBê�ê�×�ç%ø¶Ø¬Ú�×�þ2à2á�àþ¢ø�×�ç%ø¶Ø¬Ú�×�þ2à2á�ãHæ�^�

Page 61: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

ð Ú]Û�Ü Ú]å�ä Ý Ø ñ�ÚBä�ø�×�þ Ú¢û â¿ö Ú ×�ç�Ó�×�þ Ú]û ã�æç¢ê9â7þBê�ê¶×�çø¶Ø¬Ú�×�þ!à2á�Ð ê�þ]ø�×�ç%ø¶Ø�Ú�×�þ2à!á�ã�íÄ�Å ÚBÛ�Ü Ú�þ¢øU×�ç%ø¶Ø¬Ú Ú ä ß ÿ�Ø�Ú�Ö!×�þ¢Ù�Ø ß Ø Ý ä ß ø Ý�ß ä¶Ø�ç]êõæ�ØÐà ß Ø�à ÝõÞ ç Ü2Þ ÿ�þ�×!à Ý�Ü Ø�Ø�×�Ö2Øê�à�×�Ö�Ø Å Äç¢ê9âgû Ú]Û�Ü Ú�þ¢ø�×�ç%ø�Ø¬Ú Ú ä ß ÿ�جÚ�Ö!×�þ¢Ù�ØjâDã�ã�íÄ�Å Ú]Û�Ü Ú!á¶þÚ2á!ÿUÖ ÚÞ ø¶à Ü Ø�Ö Ý!Þ Ø Ú Ù�ä ý Ö�ÖÙ�Ø�Ø2á Æ ÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø Ö�Ø Ý�Ý çø Ü Ö Å ÄÚ]Û�Ü Ú2á¶þÚ2á�ÿ�ÖÅâ�ãHæ Ä�Å ÚÞ à�ø Ü Ø Ý!Þ ØÏÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø ÖÙ¶Ø�Ø!áÖ�Ø Ý�Ý ç%ø Ü Ö Ý þ4� üQì ã à�ø�á ë�î¬î Ö Þ�òöü Å ÄÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú2á�Ø�×2à Û â)�;̬̬̬̬Ì�ãHæ Ä¬Ä Ö!×2Ø�ØBÙ�ê¶þ ß Ø�ÿ¶Ø ßðØ�×�Ö2جíÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú2á�Ø�×2à Û â)�;̬̬̬̬Ì�ãHæ Ä¬Ä Ö!×2Ø�ØBÙ�ê¶þ ß Ø�ÿ¶Ø ßððØ�×�Ö2جíç¢ê9â Ú]Û�Ü Ú�þ]ø�×�ç%ø¶Ø�Ú Ú ä ß ÿ¶Ø¬Ú�Ö!×�þ]Ù¶Ø�â�ã�ã½íñ�ê ÚBÛ�Ü Ú2ê�çø�á�Ú¶ç%ø Ý Ø ß Ö�Ø Ú¢Ý ç2þ¢øUÚBÙUþ�çø Ý â�ã�æ

� Ê

Page 62: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ý Ø]å�Ù�êùñ Æ Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ú ä ß�ß ØBø Ý Ú Ý çKå�Øjâ�ãHæÄ¬Ä Ù ß ç%ø Ý ê,â#ôBç%ø Ý Ø ß Ö�Ø Ú]Ý ç2þ¢ø Ù�þ�ç%ø Ý ç�Ö[Ȫú!ägõ¢øHô�à Ý ØBå�Ù�ãHæÚ]Û�Ü Ú2á¶þÚ2á�ÿ�ÖÅâ�ãHæ Ä�Å ÚÞ à�ø Ü Ø Ý!Þ ØÏÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø ÖÙ¶Ø�Ø!áÖ�Ø Ý�Ý ç%ø Ü Ö Ý þ4� ü Î ã à�ø�á¤Ï�Ì¬Ì Ö Þ�ò.ü Å ÄÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú2á�Ø�×2à Û â�â Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ý ç Ú]û Ú Ú þ]ä�ø Ý Ú Ý ã Ý Ø]å�Ù8ã�æð

Ø�×�Ö2جíÄ�Å ÚBÛ�Ü Ú2ê�çø�á�Ú¶ç%ø Ý Ø ß Ö�Ø Ú¢Ý ç2þ¢øUÚBÙUþ�çø Ý ß Ø Ý ä ß øUÖ Ý!Þ Ø Ý çKå�Øõæ Þ Ø�ø þBê�ê¶×�ç%ø¶Ø Ú ä ß ÿ�Ø�àBø�áþ¢ø�×�ç%ø¶Ø Ú ä ß ÿ¶Ø�æUç!×�×�ç%ø Ý Ø ß Ö�Ø Ú¢Ý Å¬Äñ�ê ÚBÛ�Ü Ú2ê�çø�á�Ú¶ç%ø Ý Ø ß Ö�Ø Ú¢Ý ç2þ¢øUÚBÙUþ�çø Ý â�ã�æÝ Ø]å�Ù�ê ñ Æ Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ú ä ß�ß ØBø Ý Ú Ý çKå�ØjâDãHæÄ¬Ä Ù ß ç%ø Ý ê,â#ôBç%ø Ý Ø ß Ö�Ø Ú]Ý ç2þ¢ø Ù�þ�ç%ø Ý ç�Ö[Ȫú!ägõ¢øHô�à Ý ØBå�Ù�ãHæÚ]Û�Ü Ú Ý!Þ�ß Ø�à2á�Ú2á�Ø�×2à Û â�â Ú]Û�Ü Ú Ý ç Ú]û Ú Ú þ]ä�ø Ý Ú Ý ã Ý Ø]å�Ù8ã�æððð

ð

�c~

Page 63: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

�Ù*��Á�&����} ±

��4��")��4����� V�� �������(w�×1��"@ V��i�fá���")����O{.Q� �#")�����.Q�(wV �|�#��

~)�¢�t�����5�.�����#�0����ü�±h�Z�­�t�9�i�t���)�����t�0�H« �#���e���S�[�����q�����#���t�������g�?�I�����t�0���®��� �?ÂH��0�i���0�H�9·"��±h�¬�{� ±h���;�9µ¶ºª¼3���;�������i���¬�_±������;�ª�i�t��Â?���H���5�U�r�0���#�¬�t�6�U��¶�#��À9�����#��«��°³\�0���;�3����­���0��«q�����½�?±h���;�g�

ÿ�þ�ç]áùé Û�Ü Ú Þ ÚÞ Ø2á2ä�×2Ø ß È¬È_á¶þ Ú2á!ÿ�ÖÅâDãí

éý É Ú�٬ج÷�ÛÙ¬Ý�ÚÜ�Õ­Ô�éÝ�ó½Û Ô9â�ãHæä�øUÖ�ç Ü ø¶Ø2á ÚÞ à ß Å Ú þå Î æÚ þå Î êÀâ�ä�øUÖ�ç Ü ø¶Ø2á ÚÞ à ß Å ã½Ìñ î �;̬̬̬̬ÌcæÄ¬Ä Ì ñ î �t̬Ì�Ì¬Ì¬Ì ç!Ö?å�àBÙ�Ù�Ø2á Ý þ�Ù�Ý Þ ×�ç%ø¶ØÄ�Å Ç Ý�ß ä¶Øõÿ�à�×¢ä¶Ø�þBê Þ ç Ü2Þ Ú�Ö!×�þ¢Ù�Ø ç%ø�á�ç Ú à Ý Ø�ÖÐàç� üQì ã Æ ë¬î¬î Ö Þ�òÖ�Ø Ý�Ý ç%ø Ü àBø�á�àÏê�à�×�Ö�ØÏÿ�à�×¢ä�Ø çø�á�ç Ú¢Ý à�Ø�Ö4� ü Î ã Æ Ï�Ì¬Ì½Ö Þ�òÖ�Ø Ý�Ý ç%ø Ü Å Ä

ç¢ê9â Þ ç Ü2Þ Ú¶Ö!×�þ¢Ù¶Ø�ãíÄ�ŬÅ�ŬŬŬŬÅ�Å¬Å Þ ç Ü2Þ�Ý þn×�þ]ænÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø ÚÞ àBø Ü Ø Å¬Å¬Å�ŬŬŬŬÅ�ŬŠÄÄ�Å Ú þBá�ØÐê¶þ ß ÖÙ¶Ø�Ø!á Ú¢Þ àBø Ü Ø Å ÄÚ¬Ú�à¶Ö%åUÚ¬ÚjâtôdÖ­Û ã Ù7�?à ÷ Ï�ôBãHæÚ¬Ú�à¶Ö%åUÚ¬ÚjâtôdÖ�éÙ�Ù��#Ï�à/Ì�à®Ù���à Ú è�à Ú Ì�à<Ì7ôBãHæ

�^Î

Page 64: University of Massachusetts Amherst · 2014. 2. 3. · +O( ") # i4 . Z U bXLSbXAC ^>rIYZ'> al FY>$?Y? W'N L >$>@l8]_l l FY> AC]_IKAXZcH1IKZtD FYZ^d G } Vh3]^H A

Ä�Å Ú þBá�ØÐê¶þ ß ÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø Ö¢æUç ÝUÚÞ ç%ø Ü Å ÄÅ â Ú þå Î â ÏUã;ê�Ìñ�Ì�à�æ Ä¬Ä ÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø ÚÞ àBø Ü Ø Ý þÊ� ü Î ãÞ ç Ü!Þ Ú�Ö!×�þ]Ù¶Ø ê�Ì�æðØ�×�Ö2ØíÄ�ŬÅ�ŬŬŬŬÅ�ŬŠ×�þ]æ Ý þ Þ ç Ü2Þ ÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø ÚÞ àBø Ü Ø Å¬Å¬Å�ŬŬŬŬÅ�ŬŠÄÚ¬Ú�à¶Ö%åUÚ¬ÚjâtôdÖ­Û ã Ù7�?à ÷ Í�ôBãHæÚ¬Ú�à¶Ö%åUÚ¬ÚjâtôdÖ�éÙ�Ù��#Ï�à/Ì�à®Ù���à Ú è�à Ú Ì�à<Ì7ôBãHæÅ â Ú þå Î â ÏUã;ê�Ìñ�Ì ï æ Ä¬Ä ÿ�þ�× Ý à Ü Ø Ú¢Þ àBø Ü Ø Ý þÊ� üQì ãÞ ç Ü!Þ Ú�Ö!×�þ]Ù¶Ø ê���æð

éý É Ú�٬ج÷�ÛÙ¬Ý�Ú�Ù¬Ø�ÝÕ�Ù�Ô9âDãHæð

�_Ú