Radiate Not Write, Might ETcrose/papers/midnight.pdf · Radiate Christopher Rose 1 and Gre gory...
Transcript of Radiate Not Write, Might ETcrose/papers/midnight.pdf · Radiate Christopher Rose 1 and Gre gory...
ETMightWrite,NotRadiate
ChristopherRose1andGregoryWright2
1WINLAB
RutgersUniversity
Piscataway,NewJersey08854USA
2AntiopeAssociates
18ClayStreet
FairHaven,NewJersey07704USA
December16,2004
WriteNotRadiate1
Atruckfilledwithstoragemedia,drivenacrosstown,isaveryreliable
highbitratechannel.
–Comm.TheoryCollectiveSubconscious
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate2
TenYearsofWirelessResearch
SpectrumManagement
Interferencehurts,sodealwithit!
Delaytolerance
–Transmitwhenchannelgood!
Mobility
–Isnotanathemaithelps!
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate3
GOPOSTAL!Radiointerferenceisbad
–Mutualinterferenceisanetworkkiller
Mobilityisgood
–Canoftentoleratedelay
–Channelespeciallygoodwhennearby
Storagedensityisincreasing
–FasterthanMoore!
ForgetRadio!Writemessagedown!Tossittorecipient!
Completelyridiculous!!(right?)
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate4
Nope,NotRidiculousNYC/BostonMatterTransportEnergy
–200milesat20milespergallon
–12108Joulespergallon
–100kgDVDs:25105bits/joule
EquivalentRadiationEnergy
–Satellite:5660bits/joule
(35104kmuplink,D2propagation,1m2dish)
–Terrestrial(320km,D4propagation):MUCHlowerefficiency
Butadhoccomparisonsareunsatisfying
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate5
ALittleAnalyticRigor
R2
π
0D
apertures
0Dr
τ=D/c+T
T
radiated message
D/c 0
Mass Transport
Radiation
mass delivered
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate6
InformationDensity,ρ
HowAboutBlackHoles?
SchwarzschildRadius:r2GMc215X1027M
Infocontentgoesaseventhorizonsurfacearea:1072r2bits
ρ151045rbits/kg
Microhole(1µmradius):151039bits/kg
Donut-holesizedhole(1cmradius):151043bits/kg
Aweebitimpractical(andantisocial)
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate7
EmpiricalMassInformationDensitiesI
VoyagerSpacecraft:106bits/kg
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate8
EmpiricalMassInformationDensitiesII20lbpaper@1000dpi:21010bits/kg
DVD:31012bits/kg
MagneticStoragewithFeO2:21017bits/kg
OpticalLithographywithSiO2:3851018bits/kg
E-beamLithographywithSiO2:1541021bits/kg
STMwithXeonNi:1741022bits/kg
RNA:361024bits/kg
LiBe:751025bits/kg
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate9
MinimumTransportEnergy,E
Justtheinitialkineticenergy:
E
12
mv2
.
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate10
MinimumTransportEnergy,E
Justtheinitialkineticenergy:
E
12
mv2
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate11
InscribedMatterEnergyRequirementsMessagesizeB,massinformationdensityρ
Ew
12
Bρ
v212
Bρ
cδ
2
10 101010100110864
solar escape
earth escapem
ilky way escape
jetliner
brisk walk
δ
light speed
Artillery:addsafactorof2toenergy
Escape:smallpenaltyifv2escapevelocity
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate12
RadiationEnergyRequirementsEnergycapture
νD
AG
4πD2
BitsalaShannon:
BTCTWlog2PGA
4πD2
N0W
1
ErPT,
ErBN04πD2
AGTWB
2B
TW1
LargeTW:
ErBN04πD2
AGln2
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate13
RadiationtoTransportEnergyRatio
ΩEr
Ew
NormalizedApertureA2Rλ
NormalizedDistanceDD2R
ΩρN0
c2
8π2
DA
2
2ln2δ2
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate14
IsotropicRadiationvs.TerrestrialArtillery
ρ31024,R5cm,Temperature300K
10-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
10-5
Fraction of Lightspeed10
0
102
104
106
108
1010
Ω
D=10mD=100mD=1000mD=10000m
walking
running
jetlinerAside:250secondsbetweenNYCandBostonballistically
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate15
ChiptoChipLaserLinks
D=10cm
2R=10um
300KIR
Laser
Delay:δ109
Wavelength:λ1µm
Magneticstorage:Ω104
STMinscription:Ω5108
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate16
Interstellar
(ρ1022,δ103,Temperature3K)
102
104
106
108
1010
1012
1014
1016
1018
1020
1022
D (normalized distance)
100
104
108
1012
1016
1020
A
(norm
alized ap
erture)
Arecibo@10GHz10m Optical (500nm)1m Xray (0.1nm)Earth@10GHz
Ω
1
10-6
106
1012
1018
1024
1030
10kLY,Arecibo-Arecibo:Ω51015
–Radiation/Matter:(2megatonblast)/(Shelve5lbsugarbag)
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate17
Voyager
109bitpayload
900kgmass
Catapultlaunch:about800joules/bit
BreakevenDistance:2000lightyears
Asides:
–RocketLaunch:distanceup9.
–Use3DVDs(insteadofgolddisc):distancedown10
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate18
ThePhysicsHasSpoken
Matterisstunninglymoreefficientforawiderangeofdistancesandmethodsof
radiatedcommunications.
Butwhatabout...
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate19
MatterandRadiationPenalties
Radiation
–ImpermanenceandRepetition
Matter
–Broadcast
–InscriptionEnergy
–DecelerationAtTarget
–Preservation
–Advertisement
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate20
MatterPersists–RadiationVanishes
messageradiated
messageradiated
messageradiated
birthlife
time
radiatedmessage
mass packet
CivilizationBirthRate:α1109peryear
CivilizationExtinctionRate:β1106peryear
Successcriterion0Φ1
Howmanyradiatedrepetitions?
–Φ0992105
–Φ099992107
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate21
IsRadiationBetterforBroadcast?
Radiationilluminatesmanymatterpenalty
MilkyWaystellardensity28102stars(LY)3
Sphericalgalaxy,isotropicradiation,Arecibo-Arecibo
–R104LY:1131011stars(butΩ1028)
–R106LY:1131017stars(butΩ1032)
No,inscribedmatterstillwins!
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate22
InscriptionEnergy/Speed
MatterInscription/ReadoutEnergyandTime
–Canbereversibleandabitrarilyfast(R.Landauer)
Empiricalenergycalc:
–60000ATP/secondfor20minutes:4639KbaseofE-coli
–81020JperATPmolecule
–621019Jbit1.
–Eatearthescape:1681017Jbit1.
Constructionenergyprobablynotaproblem
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate23
ParkingthePackage
Assumeexhaustbraking
Energypenalty(excessmass):ec
δgIsp
IspSpecificImpulse
–Chemical:102
–NuclearElectric:104
–Fusion:106
Isp20000,δ1000penalty46
δ100orIsp2000penalty44106
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate24
CosmicInsultsInsults:
–Highenergyparticlebombardment
–Heating(diffusion)
–Iontracks,dislocations,subatomiccascades
Shielding:
–10millionyearsat10%bacteriaviability:3mradiusrock
(3gcm3density)
–34106penalty
CleverComposition,CodingandCorrection?
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate25
OverallImplication
ETmightwritenotradiate
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate26
SolarSpaceisBIG
MessageAdvertisement?
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate27
BigRock?
Somewhatantisocial
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate28
OddRock?
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate29
SeededComet?
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate30
ActiveProbe?
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate31
LifeBoat?
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate32
CONCLUSIONS
IfDelayAcceptable
Inscribedmattermessagingisefficient
–FedExandNetflix
MightevenfinesseGupta-KumaradhocnetsNproblem
–littledatamissiles
Chip-to-chipormote-to-motecommunication
–smartdusttossinginscribeddust
Shouldstartlookingforextraterrestrialartifacts
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar
WriteNotRadiate33
LearnMore
Nature431,pp.47–49,September2,2004WebSite:http://www.winlab.rutgers.edu/crose/cgi-bin/cosmic19.html
C.RoseWINLABMidnightSeminar