onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri...

245

Transcript of onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri...

Page 1: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

������������� ���� ������������������������� ��� !#"$����� ���%&')( ��*�%+, -�����.� !/�102��34� �5��������687�����3 9:"; ��<���*� 34��=��>�������?6@����< AB��=�3 �C� ���������

' 34�1<������-����5�������

DFEHGJILKNMOK.PJQRI�KRI�STEHILUVTW

X�YZY8[]\_^,`badc�[fehgjilkd[]\*\,`m\onp[]^*YENq

k�r,`�c�`fs*[JtvuwY8`b\xuzy|{�}�rp`mYZg�~Luvtv��[]\pi�}�rp`mYZg��2[]a��:g�yxa�y|�]�

MOS-P]��Q�EHMO�������J���]�O���zILSTE�q��*EHGJI�QNIL�f�JMOQRI���I�STEHK��q2Q�EHGJI�UJIL�2QNILI5q��

� qm�LENq2Q�q����4G�MO�Oq�KNq2PJG WMOS�EHGJI�KR� Vm� I���E�q��

}�r,`bY gj�2[]a¢¡�rx�,~�g��T~

£ ��QR¤���QRU¦¥SJM�¤�I�QRKNM�E W§ ��� V QRMOUJ�2I�¨|©>��KRKH���ªGf�JKRILEREHK

©>� W ¨�«�¬�¬T«

Page 2: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�­l«�¬2¬T«C®�¯ �z�z��Sf�JIL� � ��¤bM�U-°���S�SJI�S V �����¦±D%�O��QNMO��GfENK.QNI�KRI�Q�¤2I�Uo±

Page 3: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

²)³h´_µw¶J·1¸*µ$¹ ���������%���� ���� ���%���������.������������� ���!º"$����� ���& ')( ����+, -�����.� !#�102��34� �5� �L�z��.67F���1349:" ; ��<���*��3¢��=��>� �����?6�����< A»��=�3 �5� �L�z�����

' 34�1<������-����5�������

¯ ���¼��Sf�JIL� � ��¤bM�U-°���S�SJI�S V �����©>� W ¨�«�¬�¬T«

D�U�¤mMOKRq2Q�½4¯ QRMO�C¾�± £ IL�O��I�Q

°�GJM�K EHGJILKNMOK �Lqv¤2I�QRK¢ENGJQNILI�EHq2PJM���K M�S:KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������b�m�J��STEH�J�ÀU W SJ���zM���KL± § G]��PbÁENI�QRKÂ��S�U¼«���QRI�UJIL¤�q�EHILUzENq�ENGJI�UJI�¤2I���q2PJ��I�STEd��SJUz��PJPJ��MO����EHM�q2S�q��o��PJG]��KRI�ÁÃKNP]���LIU�IL��q2QR�¼��ENMOq2SZ��PJPJQRqT���ªGZEHq@q2PbEHMO��MOÄLI�ENGJI����O��KNKRMO����������SJq2SJM������dQNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2S�q���$SJI���QN� W M�STEHI���QH� V ��I £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S_± § G]��P�ENI�Qz¼UJI�¤2I���q2PJK���SJU8ENI�K�EHK�ENGJI�ENGJI�q�Q W ¨

Å G�MO�OI¢MOS § G]��P�ENI�Q�«.EHG�I��zI�EHGJqmU�M�K*KR�J���LI�KRKR���J��� W ��PJPJ��MOI�U�EHq�KNIL¤�I�QN������qbU�I�� £ ����MO�ÆÁENq2SJMO��SJK�± § GJ��P�EHILQNK�Ç>��SJU È>��QRI¼UJI�¤2q�ENI�U ENq>K�EH�JUJM�I�K5q���I�S�I�QN� W QRI�UJM�KRENQNM V ��EHM�q2S_±É P�IL��M��J������� W ¨ § G]��P�ENI�Q:Ǧ��q2��P]��QRI�K�U W SJ���zM������ EN�JSJSJIL�OMOS��¦EHq>D�QNS�q2�ËÊÌU � M�Í��JKRMOq2SM�S����zqmUJIL� £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S8K W K�EHIL�¦¨¢MOSZq�QNUJILQ�EHq�UJI�EHI�QR�zM�SJI¼ENGJI�QNIL�¿��ENM�¤2IzMO��P�q�Q�ÁEH��SJ�LI�q��4EHGJI5E Å q�E W PxI�K�q��¢I�S�I�QN� W¦Î q Å ��K��¼��I��ªGJ��SJMOKR��q��¢¤mM V QH��ENMOq2SJ���,I�SJILQN� WQRI�UJM�KRENQNM V ��EHM�q2S-MOS$P�q2� W ��ENq2��MO����q2�OIL���J��I�K�±dÏÃE�M�K%�Lq2SJ�L�O�JUJILU¦ENG]��E%U W S]����MO�����_EH�JSbÁS�I��OM�SJ��M�K��2ILSJI�QN���O� W ���J�ªG�����KRENI�Q�ENG]��S-D�QRSJq2�ËÊÌU � M�Ío�JKRMOq2So± § G]��PbEHI�Q�È:K�EH�JU�MOI�K.��S

MOM�M

Page 4: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��S]��� W ENMO�����O� W KNq2��¤�� V �OI.K�EHqm�ªG]��KRENMO�%�zqmUJI��J��q�QdILSJI�QR� W U�MOKNPxI�QRKNM�q2S¼UJ��I%EHq5Sf�J�zILQNq2��KÐ ��S�U]���bÁÒÑoI�SJILQENQH��SJKRM�ENMOq2SJK.q2S>�zSJI�E Å q�QNÓ$q��4��¤2q2M�UJI�U>��QNq�KNKNM�SJ�2KL±%Ô*MOS]����� W ¨ § G]��PbÁENI�QRK�Õ���S�U8Ö��Lqw¤�I�Q�MOKRKN�JILK�QNI��O��EHILU�EHq�¤mM V QN��EHM�q2S]���pPJQNILUJMOKRKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S_±�Ï×S § G]��P�EHILQÕm¨��ØPxI�QREN�JQ V ��EHM�¤2IC�zqmUJI��_��q�Q.¤mM V QH��ENMOq2SJ���_PJQRI�UJM�KNKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S$MOK.UJIL¤�I���q2P�ILU���S�U���PbÁP��OMOILU�EHq�D�Q £ Ô�±JDÙSf�J� V I�Q.q��*MO��Pxq2QREH��STE�I�ÚbPxI�QNM��zILSTEª���_q V KNILQR¤���EHM�q2SJK.QNIL�T��QRUJMOSJ�ENGJIØD�Q £ ÔÛK W KRENI��/��QRI:QNI��Lqv¤2I�QRI�UZ��KNMOS��¦q2��Q��zqmUJI��j±�Ï×S § G]��P�ENI�QCÖ Å I�UJIL¤�I���q2P��KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�������Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ�¼��q�QN���J�O�¼��q2Q V q2�JSJUmÁÃ��QNILIØUJMOKRKNqm��M¿�ÜEHM�¤�I���q��JPJ�OM�SJ�2K1��KNMOS��q�SJ� W ���O��KNKRMO�����¢Ô|q��JQNM�I�Q��LqbI�Ý���MOILSTEHK�q���ENGJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_±�°�GJMOKC��q2QN���J�¿�-MOK5KN�J�ÞÁ�LI�KRKR���J��� W ��P�PJ�OM�I�U�EHqØKRIL¤2ILQH���,EHILKRE����KNI�KL±

M�¤

Page 5: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ß�àâáäãæå ¶]·�ç�è_é5·�¶|ê,çص�´

¤mM

Page 6: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ë ��ì�����íâ�L��<�9�� �����

î QNM�EHMOS��ZEHGJM�K-ENGJI�KRMOK Å q��J�OUïSJq�E$G]��¤2I V I�I�S�P�q�KNKNM V �OI Å M�EHGJq���E-EHGJI@GJIL�OPïq���z��S W PxI�q2P��OI�±�Ô*MOQNK�EØq������O�j¨ Ï Å q2�J�OU���MOÓ�I�ENq�EHG]��S�Óð� W ��Ub¤bM�KNq2QL¨�ñ.MO�ªÓ £ I����OILQ�¨��q�Q�EHI����ªGJMOS����zI��f�]��SfEN�J�â��I��ªG]��SJMO�LK���SJU���q2Q1��� Å � W K V I�MOS������2QNI���E�KNq��JQN�LI:q��M�UJI���K���SJUòSJI Å P�ILQNKNPxI���EHM�¤2I�KL±¼Ï.EHG]��SJÓ�ó�M��O��ô���I���P�ILQNI�Q1��q�Q1EHGJIØq2PJPxq2Q�EH�JSJM�E W ENq�Lq2�O�O� V q2QH��ENI Å M�EHG�GJM��õq2S���PJQRq � I���E��zqmUJI����OM�SJ�$¤mM V QH��ENMOq2SJ���dP�QNI�U�MOKNKRqb�LM¿��ENMOq2S q��¤���S�U�I�Q î �2���OK���q2��PJ�OIÞÚbI�K�± °�G�I�QNI�KR�J��ENK�q��,EHGJM�K Å q2QNÓzMOK�ENGJI�KN� Vf� I��LEq�� § G]��P�EHILQÕq��JEHG�MOK*ENGJI�KRMOKL±�Ï,����KNq%ENG]��SJÓ � ��¤mMOU�ñ.I�M��ªGJ�z��S5��q2Q*GJMOK,¤���QNM�q2�JK���U�¤mMO�LI�q2S�KR��M�I�SJ�LI��SJU¦q�EHGJILQ�KN� Vm� IL�LENK�±

Ï Å q2���OU����OKRq��OMOÓ�I�EHq�EHGJ��SJÓ:��Sf�J� V I�Q4q��x��QNM�I�SJUJK Å G�q5GJIL�OPxI�UØ��I��2ILE4EHG�QNq2�J��G��QH��UJ�J��EHI�KR�ªGJqbq��˽�©>��QRÓÛö��JUJM�ÓmKRI�S_¨ Å M�EHG Å GJq�� Ï Å q2QRÓ�I�UïEHGJQRq2�J�2G÷EHG�I��]QNK�EKRI���I�K�EHI�Q¼q��CñM��ªÓ|ÊøKz�m�J��STEH�J� �zIL�ªG]��SJM���K�¨.��SJUlD����OM�KNq2S?ô���� V I�S_¨ Å GJq Å ��K�� WG�q2�zI Å q�QNÓðP]��Q�EHSJILQ�ENGJI$KNI��Lq2SJUlKRI���I�K�EHI�QL±ï©¦MO�ªGJ��I�� É GJILI�G W ¨ Å GJq8G]��K V ILI�Sù���QNI��ÜE�QNqmq2���¼�ÜEHIUJ�JQNM�SJ��� WØW I���QRK�GJI�QRI�¨]��S�U Å GJqJ¨J���Oq2SJ� Å M�EHG�©>��QNÓz��SJU-ô���ENMOI� QN��Ó�I�¨ Å ��K�� W GJq2��I Å q2QRÓòPJ��QRENSJI�Q�M�SZ¯ �J�2ILSJI É GJ��ÓfGJSJqv¤mMO�ªG_ÊÌK:KREH��EHM�KREHM������4��I�Á�ªGJ��SJMO�LK¼�L�¿��KRK�±ÛÏØ����KNq@EHG]��S�Ó�� W q�EHGJILQzQRqbq��z�z��EHILK�¨�¾�ILÍ�QNI W ó���QREHq�Sl��SJU £ �ÜÁú q��JSJ� Ð I�I�¨ Å GJq$����q2SJ� Å M�ENG8©¦MO�ªG]��I��˨h�z��UJI:q��JQC��P]��Q�EH��I�STEC� Å IL�O��q��zI:PJ�O����IENqØ��q2��I�GJq2��I�EHqJ±

¤mMOM

Page 7: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ñ� � M¿��G � ILSJS W GJI���P�ILU5��I Å M�ENG�¤���QRMOq2��K,������ILENK,q���ENGJI¢¥%SJMÆÚ�q2PxI�QH�ÜEHMOS��K W KREHIL�¦¨��SJU��T��¤�Id��I��.�2QRI���E*UJI����mq��JGJIL�OP Å M�EHGCPJQNILP]��QRMOSJ�� W P]��PxI�QRK�û���SJUCEHGJM�K,ENGJI�KRMOKHüpMOSÐ ��°pILý�±]þ%M�Ó�q2�O��M � q2ÓfGJq2� W ��S��T��¤2I���I�¤�I�Q W GJI���P����J�h��Ub¤bM���I1QRI��T��QNUJM�SJ��EHGJI�KNI���QN�ªG��q�Q¼Pxq2KRENUJqb��EHq2QN���.P�q�KNM�ENMOq2S�K�¨���S�UlGJI�����KNq8�T��¤2I���I>�z��S W �JKNI����J�%ENMOPJKzq2SlGJq ÅENq�QNILKNPxq2SJU�EHq�QRIL��ILQNI�I:�LQNM�EHMO�LMOKR�zK Å GJI�S@QRIL¤mMOKRMOSJ���z��Sf�JKR��QNM�P�EHKL±�D�STEHGJq�S W ú I�Ä�ÄLM˨��PJQRq���I�KRKNq2QCMOS�ENGJI�¯4��I���EHQNM���������SJU § q2�zP���EHILQ5¯ SJ��MOSJILI�QNM�SJ� � I�P]��QREH��I�STE�q��¢EHG�Iö�I�q�QN�2MO��Ï×SJKRENM�EH�bEHI$q���°pI��ªG�SJq2�Oq�� W ¨��2�v¤�I¦��I-�@Sm��� V ILQzq���GJIL�OP�������KN�J�2��I�KRENMOq2S�Kq�S�EHGJI�Sf�J��I�QRMO�����oMO��PJ��I���I�STEª��ENMOq2S�q��pKNq��zI�q��hENGJI������2q2QNM�EHGJ��K¢PJQNILKNI�STENI�U>M�S¼EHG�I�JQNKRE.E Å qz�ªGJ��P�EHILQNKq��pEHGJM�K.ENGJI�KRMOKL±

Ï:���OKNq@EHGJ��SJÓ V q�EHG���q2QN��I�Q���SJU?���JQRQNILSfE £ IL�O�OILQ:�2QNq��JPù��I�� V I�QRK���q�Q��z��S WG�I��OPb���J����q�Sf¤�I�QRKH��ENMOq2SJKz��SJU���I�ILU V ���ªÓ�q2S�� W Å q2QRÓ|±�Ï×S�EHG�MOK�¤2ILMOS_¨dÏ�ILKNPxI���MO���O� W

Å q2�J��U��OM�Ó�I�ENqØENG]��SJÓ � q2QNq�S § q2GJILS_¨ Å M�ENG Å G�q2�æÏ¢��q2���¿� V q2QN��EHILU_±�°�GJI�QRI�KR�J��ENK�q��q��JQd�Lq2�O�O� V q2QH��ENMOq2S:�z� W:V I%��q2�JS�U¼MOS § G]��PbEHI�QdÈ�q��oEHGJM�K¢ENGJI�KRMOK�± D%�OKRq5Ï Å q2�J��U¼��MOÓ�IENq1EHG]��SJÓ É �Lq�E É G]� Å ��SJU:D%�OI�Ú:ó���QRSJILERE���q2Q�ENGJI�M�Q�GJI���P:MOS:UJI����OM�SJ� Å M�EHG:��q��zPJ�bEHI�QP�QNq V ��I���K�¨o¾�MOQRM,ÿ¢��SJMO�LI�Ó|¨oD%QNI�ILÄØ©¦qmU W ¨o��SJU�°pQNq W ¤2q�S�ÿ4qbq2QRGJMOK.��q2Q%�¼Sf�J� V I�Q%q��G�I��OPb���J�h��q2ST¤�I�QNKN��EHM�q2SJK%QNI��2��QNUJM�SJ��� W QNILKNI���QN�ªG_¨���SJU>ñq V ILQRE%����QRQNq�ERE.��q2Q.GJI���P>MOS��ILENENMOSJ�Ø� W P]��PxI�QRK%��SJU¦QRI���IL¤���STE.PJQNq��2QH����K�q2STEHqØEHG�IC��QNq2�JP Å I V KRM�ENI�±

ú MOKNQRqbIL��ó�QR�J�zILQ�UJILKNI�Q�¤2ILK¼KNPxI��LM¿���d�zILSTEHMOq�S_¨ ��q2Q�SJq�E�q2SJ� W MOK�G�I�q2SJI�q��.EHG�I�L�Oq2KRI�K�E���QNM�I�SJUJKCEHG]�ÜE�Ï��z��UJI¼U��JQNM�SJ���2QN��UJ�]��ENI¼KR�ªGJqbq��˨ V �bE:GJI����OKNq¦Eª���J��GfE��zI

¤mMOM�M

Page 8: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�f�JM�EHI.� V M�E4� V q2��E¢¾���U]��MOKR�¦± � �JQNM�SJ�1� W5W I���QNK4GJILQNI�¨TG�I�GJI���P�ILU���I��Lq2SJSJIL�LE Å M�ENG� W ����M�ENG�EHGJQRq2�J�2G-q2��QK�EH�JU W KNI�KRKNM�q2SJK��E.EHGJI £ ��QR¤���QRU £ MO���OI��j±� EHG�I�Q���QNM�I�SJU�K�Ï Å q2���OU:�OM�Ó�I¢EHq1EHGJ��SJÓ5��QNI � ��¤mMOUØñ.q2KR�¼��QRMOS_¨ î MO��� É �ªGJqbILS_¨m¾�ILÍ

¥Q V ��S_¨h¾�M��O�pó�I��ªÓ�I�QL¨p¾�q2GJS@ô�QN�J��¨hö�� W £ I�QRÄ�q2��¨h��SJU�û��¿��K�E V ��E�SJq�E��OI���KREªü%ñ�v¤mM�Uñ.qv¤mSJI�QL± ú q2�JQ���QNM�I�SJU�KNGJM�P¦UJ��QNMOS��z� W EHMO��I���E £ ��Q�¤���QNU$GJI���P�ILU¦��I��2ILEEHG�QNq2�J��G��QH��UJ�J��EHI�KR�ªGJqbq��˱

DFKRP�IL��M¿���oEHG]��SJÓ W q��$��qbILK�EHqØ� W PJ��QNILSfENK�¨]D%�O�OILS-��SJU$ñ.MOS]��±�Ï Å q2�J��U$S�q�E V I

Å G�I�QNI�Ï1��� EHqmU]� W Å M�ENGJq2��E5������EHG�Iz��U�¤mMO��I���S�U8KR�JPJPxq2QRE�EHG�I W �T��¤2I���I�±z©¦q2QRIENG]��S>��S W q2SJI5I���KNI�¨]ENGJI W G]��¤�I�GJIL�OPxI�U>Ó�I�ILP��zICq2S¦�zK�EHI���U W ��q2��QNKNICEHGJQRq2�J�2G¦� W��M���I�¨J��SJU-G]��¤�ICKRG]��QRI�U Å M�EHG-��I1EHGJI Å M�KNUJq2� EHGJI W �T��M�SJI�U�ENGJQNq2���2G�EHGJILMOQ�¤���QRMOq2�JKIÞÚbP�ILQNMOILSJ��ILK�±

Ô�M�S]����� W ¨�Ï Å ��STE�EHq �2M�¤�I��ZGJI���QREN��IL��EzEHG]��S�ÓmK�ENqZ� W KNM�KREHILQ�¨ É ��QN��G_¨ Å GJqðMOKI���KNM�� W � W�V ILKRE���QNMOILSJUùM�S�ENGJI Å GJq2�OI Å q2QN��U_¨���S�UùG]��K¼��� Å � W K V I�ILSlMOSJ�LQNILUJM V � WKR�JPJPxq2QRENM�¤�I1EHGJQRq2�J�2G$�����o� W UJM�Ý�������E�PxI�QRMOqmUJK�± D%S W q2SJI Å q2�J�OU V I��f�JM�ENI��O�J�ªÓ W ENqGJ�v¤�I��:KRM V ��MOSJ�:��MOÓ�I�GJI�QL±

MÆÚ

Page 9: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

� �����������

� � ¡�c�X� H��[]~�`mi � s*sptwy|[]��rluvy�}�a�[]~�~�gj�2[]ad¡�r,[]~�`� ��_sp[]�2`òc�`m{ËyxtÜY [� uwg�yx\*~ �Â2±� Ï×STEHQRqbU��J�LENMOq2Sï±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± «Â2± « °�GJIC¯�¤2q��O��ENMOq2S$¯ �f�]��EHM�q2SJK�±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± �

Â2± «b±� ¯�¤2q2����EHM�q2S-q��*ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S ±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±�Â�¬Â2± «b± « ¯�¤2q2����EHM�q2S-q��*ENGJI5ö�ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�ØÔ]�JSJ��EHMOq�S ±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±�Â�Ç

Â2±øÇ § GJqmq2KRMOSJ��� ±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±�Â�ÖÂ2±ÌÈ °�GJICÔ�M�QNK�ERÁ � QRUJI�Q Ð MO��M�EB±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æ«mÂÂ2± Õ D%S]��� W ENMO�����_¯�Ú����zP��OI�K/±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æ«ÜÈ

Â2± Õb±� ÂLÁ � ¯�Ú�����PJ�OI ±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æ«ÜÈÂ2± Õb± « «wÁ � ¯�Ú�����PJ�OI ±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æ«��

Â2±øÖ DÙþ�J�zILQNM������h¯�Ú�����PJ�OI ±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ç�Ç

Ú

Page 10: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Â2±�� § q2S�KREHQR�J�LENMOq2S-q�� É I���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������ î ��¤2I����JSJ��EHMOq�SJKÀ±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ç��Â2±�� § q2S����O��KNMOq�SJK.��SJU¦Ô]��EH�JQRICñILKNI���QN�ªG ±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± ÈT«

� �o`mYZgj�Ta�[]~�~�gj�2[]a��Ø^p[]\xuwg��T[buwg�yx\ �-~�g�\p�"!L\�eJ[�t�g�[]\�u�k�y|t�g$# �&% tw[]ipg�`m\�u' c�`m~��2`m\�u � s*sptwyx[J��r (�)«b±� Ï×STEHQRqbU��J�LENMOq2Sï±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± È2Ö«b± « °�GJI § öC©õ©$ILEHG�qbU ±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æÕ�««b±øÇ °�GJI § £ ©»©¦I�EHGJqmU ±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æÕÜÈ«b±ÌÈ °�GJI5ö�QH��U�MOI�STE�Á � I�KR��ILSfED%PJPJQNq2���ªG�±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æÕ��

«b±ÌÈJ±� � QNq V ��I���K Å M�ENG-ENGJI § £ ©/©¦ILENGJqmU ±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æÕ��«b±ÌÈJ± « °�GJIC¯�¤2q2����EHM�q2S$¯4�f�]�ÜEHMOq�S ±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æÕ*�

«b± Õ þ�J�zILQNM�������Ï×�zPJ��I���I�STEª�ÜEHMOq�S�q��*ENGJIC� � ¯ ±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æÕ*+«b± Õb±� � ¤2I�QN���O� É EHQR�J�LEN�JQNICq��pEHGJI�D����2q2QRM�EHG�� ±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±æÕ*+«b± Õb± « � W S]����MO��K���E%�zö�M�¤�I�S-D���EHM�q2SF±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ö�¬

«b±øÖ þ�J�zILQNM������o¯�Ú�����PJ��I�K ±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ö�Ç«b±øÖ�±� ° Å q � I���QNI�ILK%q���Ô]QNILI�UJq�� ±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ö�Ç«b±øÖ�± « É M�Ú � I��2QRI�ILKq���Ô]QNILI�UJq�� ±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ö��«b±øÖ�±øÇ � MOKR���JKRKNMOq�SÀ±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±,�mÂ

«b±�� § q2S����O��KNMOq�SJK.��SJU¦Ô]��EH�JQRICñILKNI���QN�ªG ±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±,�ÜÈ

ÚbM

Page 11: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

- c��,\,[]YZg��2[]a�k�^p\*\,`majg�\,�.5`ftÜ~�^p~ � tÜ\,y�a$/�i÷c$g10¢^p~�g�yx\2# � }5yxY sp[Jt3 g�~�yx\ùy|{4�Ø^p[]\xuw^*Y []\pi�}�a�[]~�~�gj�2[JadX�\,`ftÜ�]�65�a�y87:9¼[�uv`m~ ;=<Ç�±� Ï×STEHQRqbU��J�LENMOq2Sï±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±,�*+Ç�± « °�GJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S ±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>��Ö

Ç�± «b±� ¯ �m�J��EHM�q2S$��SJU � IL�]SJM�EHM�q2S�q�������QN���zI�EHILQNK ±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>��ÖÇ�± «b± « °�GJI�D�QRSJq2�ËÊÌU î I V ±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>���

Ç�±øÇ ©¦I�EHGJqmU$q�� § ���O�����¿��ENMOq2S ±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+2«Ç�±øÇ�±� � ¤2I�Q�¤mMOI Å ±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+2«Ç�±øÇ�± « § �¿��KRKNM������ § ���O�����¿��ENMOq2SJK�±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+�ÈÇ�±øÇ�±øÇ ?1�]��STEH�J� § ���O�L�J�¿��ENMOq2S�Kæ±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+�È

Ç�±ÌÈ ñ.I�KR�J��ENK.��SJU � MOKN�L�JKNKRMOq2S ±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+�ÖÇ�±ÌÈJ±� °�GJQNILI � IL�2QNILI�K.q���Ô]QNI�ILUJq2� ±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+�ÖÇ�±ÌÈJ± « Ô]q2�JQ � I���QNI�ILK.q���Ô]QRI�I�U�q2� ±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+��Ç�±ÌÈJ±øÇ Ô�M�¤�I � I��2QRI�ILKq�� Ô]QNILI�UJq2� ±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬bÂ

Ç�± Õ ©¦IL�ªG]��SJM�KN�äq��@?1�]��STEH���ä¯ SJI�QR� W Ô��Oq Å ±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬bÂÇ�±øÖ Ð qm������MOÄ��ÜEHMOq�S¼q��pEHGJIC¯ MO��I�SJK�Eª��ENI�K�±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬�ÈÇ�±�� § q2S����O��KNMOq�SJK.��SJU¦Ô]��EH�JQRICñILKNI���QN�ªG ±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ2Â�¬

( � \ � \,[]a��ouwgj�2[Jaja �A�_yxa eJ[Jn*a�`B��uvyh�Ür,[]~Luwg��DCFyhi,`ma�{Ëyxt@X�\,`ftw�|��c-gj~�

ÚbMOM

Page 12: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

s `ftÜ~�g�y�\Ûc-^,`¦uvyDE>^pY `ftwy�^p~GF¢[J\*i,[]^H JI�`b\,`ft>kdtÜ[J\*~�g uwg�yx\*~ �K���ÈJ±� Ï×STEHQRqbU��J�LENMOq2Sï±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ2Â�ÇÈJ± « °�GJI5©¦qmUJIL�d±C±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ2ÂvÕÈJ±øÇ ©¦q��zILSfENK.q��*ENGJI � MOK�EHQNM V ��ENMOq2S�±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂw«�¬ÈJ±ÌÈ � M�KNPxI�QNKRMOq2S-� QRq��]�OI?±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂw«mÂÈJ± Õ þ�J�zILQNM�������°*ILKRE���SJU � MOKN�L�JKNKRMOq2S$±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂw«�ÖÈJ±øÖ § q2S����O��KNMOq�SJKä±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂw«*�

) � ¡1`ftvuw^,twn*[�uvg�ex` � sps*twy|[]�Ür$uvyL.$g�nptÜ[buwg�yx\,[]aJ¡CtÜ`mipgj~�~�yh�Tg�[�uwg�y�\M9¼[�uv`m~�#� sps�a�g��2[�uwg�y�\ðuvy � t*NO5 ��-QPÕb±� Ï×STEHQRqbU��J�LENMOq2Sï±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂvÇ2«Õb± « °�GJI5©¦qmUJIL�d±C±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂvÇ��

Õb± «b±� °�GJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S ±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂvÇ��Õb± «b± « � ILENI�QN��MOS�MOSJ��ENGJICó�q2�JS�UbÁ É EH��EHILKر5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ�È2¬Õb± «b±øÇ � ILENI�QN��MOS�MOSJ��ENGJI � ��EH�2q�MOSJ� É EH��EHILKº±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ�È�ÈÕb± «b±ÌÈ § q2��PJ��EHM�SJ��EHG�I � M�KNKRqb�LM¿��ENMOq2S�ñ��ENI ±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ�È2ÖÕb± «b± Õ É I���M�ÁÃD�S]��� W EHM������o©¦qmUJI��@±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ�È��

Õb±øÇ ñ.I�KR�J��ENK.��SJU � MOKN�L�JKNKRMOq2S ±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂwÕ�¬Õb±øÇ�±� °�GJI � MOKRKNqm��M¿�ÜEHMOq�S�ñ%�ÜEHI�K$±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂwÕ�¬

ÚbMOM�M

Page 13: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Õb±øÇ�± « °�GJICñq�Eª��ENMOq2S]��� � MOK�EHQRM V ��ENMOq2S�±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂvÖ�¬Õb±øÇ�±øÇ þ%�J��I�QRMO�����_Ï×KNKR�JI�K ±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂvÖ�È

Õb±ÌÈ § q2S����O��KNMOq�SJK.��SJU¦Ô]��EH�JQRICñILKNI���QN�ªG ±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂvÖ�Ö

R c�`Tuv`ftÜYZgj\,[�uwg�yx\�y|{h��yx^*\piS T5htw`m`5c-gj~�~�yh�Tg�[�uwg e�`C}�yx^,s�a�g�\p�x~U.$g�[�}�a�[]~� ~�g��2[]aV5,yx^,tÜg�`ft$}5y_`XWZ�Tg�`m\�uw~ � ; �Ö�±� Ï×STEHQRqbU��J�LENMOq2Sï±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂY��ÇÖ�± « °�GJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S ±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂY���Ö�±øÇ °�GJIC¯ SJILQN� W Á×°�M��zI�ñ.I�P�QNI�KRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�S ±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂY�*�Ö�±ÌÈ °�GJI § q2��PJ�OM�SJ�ØÔ]q2QN�����¿�#±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ�bÂÖ�± Õ þ�J�zILQNM�������°*ILKREHK$±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ�2«Ö�±øÖ D%PJPJ�OM�����ENMOq2SzEHq � MOKRKNqm��M¿�ÜEHMOq�S�� QNqm��I�KRKNILKÛ±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ���Ö�±�� § q2S����O��KNMOq�SJKä±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ+�¬

� E¦^*Y `ftÜg��2[]aja �B��uv[Jn*a�`O!�Y8s�a�`mY `m\�uv[�uwg�yx\�y|{�uwr,` % c � CF`Tuwr,yhi ��[K�D5±�Â#� QNq�P]���T��ENMOSJ�G\ � SJI�°�MO��I É ENI�P ±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ+2«D5± «Bþ�J�zILQNM������o�4QRq2P]���2��EHM�q2S�q��2] ±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ+�ÈD5± Ç � QNq�P]���T��ENMOq2S�°�M��zI5±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ+��

� � \ � ipi*g uwg�yx\p[]aU5�g�t�~�u' J^:t�i,`ft_9�`m~�^pa u �QPKP

Ú�M�¤

Page 14: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

} E¦^*Y `ftÜg��2[]a,c-`Tuv[Jgja�~%{Ãy|t�uwr,`�.$g�nptÜ[buwg�yx\,[]a_¡CtÜ`mipgj~�~�yh�Tg�[�uwg�y�\ }5[]a��T^S a�[�uwg�yx\*~ �QP`�§ ±�»°�GJICÔ]QNILI�Á £ Ô�ó���KRMOK»±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±�«�¬�ǧ ± « �pq�EHILSfENM¿��� § q2�JPJ��MOSJ�2K�±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±�«�¬�È

c � \,�x^*a�[Jt$}5yx^,s�a�gj\,�x~ �QP`R

Úm¤

Page 15: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

a b O� �dc e bgf:h i ��

Â2±� °�GJI��]QRKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q���q2��I�STEH�J� �]I���UJK.�2I�S�I�QH�ÜEHI�U VTW EHG�Ij�Lk���SJUO�ml�z��SJM���q2�OU�q��oEHQN� � I���EHq2QRMOILK�¨ Å GJI�QRIonqp Â�rø¬�¨�stp Â�rø¬�¨8uMp Â�rø¬�¨m��SJUvxw p «b±ûj�Tü�°�G�Iy�Lkd�¼��S�M���q2��U_±�û V ü�°�GJIm�ml�¼��SJM���q2��U_±�±C±C±C±C±C± Ç�¬

Â2± « � �Oq�E_q��z\ðû|{ w�} {'~ }��������� }S������|� üo�ÜEh¤���QNMOq��JKoEHM��zILKo��q2QoENGJI4� �J�O��I�SbÁׯ UJ�zq�SJUJK£ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_±dûj�Tü��2pï¬zrø¬�±û V ü���p�¬zr�Â2±û���ü��2p�¬8r «b±%û�U|üV�2p ¬8r Ç�± Ç�Ö

Â2±øÇ � �Oq�E,q��Q\ðû�{ wX} {'~ }x�J���� � }������� � üh��q2QhENGJI�� �J���OILSbÁÒ¯ UJ��q2SJUJK £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S��q2Q���p�� MOS�EHG�I��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.��MO��M�E�± ±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ç��

Â2±ÌÈ � �Oq�E_q��z\ðû|{ w�} {'~ } ������ � } ������ � üo�ÜEh¤���QNMOq��JKoEHM��zILKo��q2QoENGJI4� �J�O��I�SbÁׯ UJ�zq�SJUJK£ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S Å M�EHG�EHG�I�ûË« }3� «2üdQRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�QNI���qv¤2ILU_±1û��TüU��p�¬zrø¬�±û V üV�2p ¬8r�Â2±û��vüV��p ¬zr «b±û�U|ü���p�¬zrøÇ�±-±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ç�+

Â2± Õ � �Oq�Edq��S\ðû�{ wX} {'~ } �������� } �������� ü4��E2�2p�¬zr ¬���q2Q¢�*q�EHI�STENM¿����KdÏ ��SJUzÏRϪ±�ûj�Tü�pq�EHILSfENM¿���oϪ±pû V ü��*q�EHI�STENM¿���_ÏRϪ±�±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± È2¬

Úb¤mM

Page 16: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Â2±øÖ � QNq V � V M��OM�E W UJILSJKNM�E W PJ�Oq�ENK-q���ENGJI@KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������ Å ��¤2I����JSJ�LENMOq2S�K�2ILSJI�QN��EHILUò��QRq2� EHGJIØIL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S�q2Sò�*q�ENI�STEHMO���OK�Ï%��SJU@ÏNϪ± ûj�Tü�°�GJI

Å ��¤2IL����SJ�LENMOq2S���q2Q��pq�EHILSTEHM¿���oϪ±hû V üd°�GJI Å ��¤2I����JSJ�LENMOq2S���q2Q��*q�ENI�SbÁENM¿����ÏNϪ±Û±C±5±C±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± È�Â

«b±� D¤2q2M�UJI�UØ��QRq2KNKRMOSJ� V ILE Å I�ILS¼KREH��EHILK4Ç�+���SJUØÈT¬���K4�1���JS��LEHM�q2S:q��Q� w ±°�GJI$����QR¤2ILK�GJILQNI���QNI-EHGJI$�f�]��STEH�J� I�S�I�QN��MOI�Kz��SJU�EHGJI$I�S�I�QN��MOI�Kq V Eª��M�SJI�U VTW U�M¿���2q�S]���OM�Ä�M�SJ��EHGJI +>ý�+ V �Oqm�ªÓ MOS8EHGJI�G]��QN��q2SJMO�ÞÁq2KR��M��O�¿�ÜEHq2Q4EHq2QR�JK V ��KRMOK�±$±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ö�Ö

«b± « D¤2q2M�UJI�UØ��QRq2KNKRMOSJ� V ILE Å I�ILS¼KREH��EHILK4Ç�+���SJUØÈT¬���K4�1���JS��LEHM�q2S:q��Q� w ±°�GJI$����QR¤2ILK�GJILQNI���QNI-EHGJI$�f�]��STEH�J� I�S�I�QN��MOI�Kz��SJU�EHGJI$I�S�I�QN��MOI�Kq V Eª��M�SJI�U VTW UJM¿���2q2S]����MOÄLMOSJ��EHG�I�+¦ý�+ V �Oqm�ªÓòM�S EHG�I�ÏÒñ%ñ EHq�QN�JKV ��KNMOKL±*±C±C±5±C±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ö��

Ç�±�Â É ���zPJ��I�EHQN� � I���EHq2Q W ��q2Q��>p�ÇØKNGJq Å M�SJ�ØD�QNS�q2�ËÊÌU � M�Í��JKNM�q2S_±±C±C±C±>��+Ç�± « Ï×���O�JK�EHQH�ÜEHMOq�Szq��_D�QNS�q2�ËÊÌU î I V K���q2Q4¤���QNM�q2�JKd��q2�JP��OMOS���KN�ªG�I���I�K.��SJU

UJIL�2QNILI�Kq��p��QNI�ILUJq2�$±8±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+�¬Ç�±øÇ § q2ST¤�I�QN��I�SJ�LI�q��*���������J�O��EHM�q2SJK���q�Q��>p�Ç�±)±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+2ÕÇ�±ÌÈ � �Oq�E�q������'�wû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|�J�Üû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p Çz��q2Q § q2�bÁ

PJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�Ϫ± ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+��

Úm¤mMOM

Page 17: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ç�± Õ � �Oq�E�q������'�wû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|�J�Üû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p Çz��q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�ÏNÏNϪ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+��

Ç�±øÖ � �Oq�E�q������'�wû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|�J�Üû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p ȼ��q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�Ϫ± ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+�+

Ç�±�� � �Oq�E�q������J©Üû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|��©�û��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p ȼ��q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�Ϫ± ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±>+�+

Ç�±�� � �Oq�E�q������'�wû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|�J�Üû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p ȼ��q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�ÏNϪ± ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬�¬

Ç�±�+ � �Oq�E�q������'�wû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|�J�Üû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p ȼ��q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�ÏNÏNϪ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬�¬

Ç�±�Âv¬Û� �Oq�E�q������'�wû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|�J�Üû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p)Õ���q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�Ϫ± ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬2«

Ç�±�Â2Â�� �Oq�E�q������J©Üû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|��©�û��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p)Õ���q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�Ϫ± ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬2«

Ç�±�Âw«l� �Oq�E�q������'ªwû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢�,¤�I�QRKN�JK��|�JªÜû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§���q2Qo�¨p)Õ���q2Q § q2�bÁPJ��MOSJ� É �ªGJI���I�Ϫ± ±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬2«

Ç�±�ÂvÇÛ� �Oq�E-q������'��« ªwû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢��¤2ILQNKN��K¬�|�J��« ªwû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§ä��q2Q � p ÕZ��q2Q§ q2��PJ�OM�SJ� É �ªGJIL�zI�ÏNϪ±/±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬�Ç

Úm¤mMOMOM

Page 18: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ç�±�Â�È÷� �Oq�E-q������'��« ªwû1�Rü����������|�� ¡���¢��¤2ILQNKN��K¬�|�J��« ªwû��Rü���£�¤��¢¥J¦¡¤�§ä��q2Q � p ÕZ��q2Q§ q2��PJ�OM�SJ� É �ªGJIL�zI�ÏNÏRϪ±�±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬�Ç

Ç�±�ÂwÕ­?1�]��STEN�J� ���LENMOq2S Î q Å M��O���JKRENQH��ENMOSJ�ðEHG�I �f�]��STEH��� ��S]���Oq2�2��Iòq��D%QNSJq2�jÊøU � M�Ío�JKRMOq2So±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬2Õ

Ç�±�ÂvÖl°pq�Eª���hSm��� V ILQ�q�����¤���MO�¿� V �OI�K�Eª��ENI�K¯®º��q2Q��qpA��¨�Õ��f�]��SfEH��¨���K�����JS��LEHM�q2S-q��*�OS°uZû § q2�JPJ��MOSJ� É �ªG�I���I5Ï�üÞ±ð±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬��

Ç�±�ÂY�l� �Oq�E%q��.ûjþ�J� V I�Qq�� D¤���MO�¿� V �OI É EH��EHILKªüG±ïÏ×ST¤�I�QNKRI:����QREHM���M�P]��EHM�q2Sñ��EHM�q���q2QG� p:��¨�Õ��m�J��STEª��¨���K�������SJ�LENMOq2S�q��%�OS°u�û § q2�JPJ��MOSJ�É �ªG�I���ICÏ�üÞ±�±C±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂv¬��

Ç�±�ÂZ� Ð,� ��É ��q2Q��²p���¨|Õ��f�]��STEª�b¨|��q�Q°uMp ¬zrø¬�Âzû § q2��PJ�OM�SJ� É �ªGJIL�zI�Ï�ü�±�Âv¬�+Ç�±�ÂZ+ Ð,� ��É ��q2Q��²p���¨|Õ��f�]��STEª�b¨|��q�Q°uMp ¬zr�Âzû § q2�JP��OMOS�� É �ªGJI���ICÏ�ü�±C±dÂv¬�+Ç�± «�¬ Ð,� ��É ��q2Q��²p���¨|Õ��f�]��STEª�b¨|��q�Q°uMp Â�rø¬$û § q2�JP��OMOS�� É �ªGJI���ICÏ�ü�±C±dÂv¬�+

ÈJ±� � MO���2QH���âKNGJq Å M�SJ��SJILE Å q2QRÓ q��.��¤�q2MOUJILUð��QRq2KNKRMOSJ�2K��2I�SJILQH��ENI�U VTW¤���Q W M�SJ�:KNq��zI�P]��QN����ILEHILQ°u,±5±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ2Â�Ö

ÈJ± « � MO���2QH��� KRGJq Å MOSJ��Pxq2KNKRM V ��I V ILG]��¤bM�q2QNK��E��S¦��¤�q2MOUJILU¦�LQNq2KRKNM�SJ�J±]±C±dÂ2ÂZ�ÈJ±øÇ § q2��P]��QRMOKRq2S¦q��¢��S]��� W ENMO�����_¤2ILQNKN��K�Sm���zILQNMO�����pUJMOKRP�ILQNKNM�q2S>P�QNq��]��I�K

UJ��I�ENqØKREHqm�ªG]��K�EHM��C��q�ENMOq2S�q2S�ENGJI�SJILE Å q2QNÓ�q�����¤2q�MOUJILU¦�LQNq2KRKNMOS��2K�±b±dÂw«��

Ú�MÆÚ

Page 19: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Õb±� ?1�]����M�EH��EHM�¤2I�MO���O�JK�EHQN��EHM�q2S�q��_ENGJI��q2�JP��OMOS�� V ILE Å I�ILS-� V q2�JSJUbÁÃKREH��EHI��S�U��.�2M�¤�I�SCI�ÚbM�Ep�ªG]��SJSJI��j±�°�GJI¢PJ��q�E,MOK,q���KNq2��I2³H´�û|µ�ü_��q2��Pxq2SJI�STEq����¦�2M�¤2I�S V q2��SJUbÁ×K�Eª��ENI�¨�KRq2��I¼q2��EN�2q2M�SJ� Å ��¤2I·¶�´¢¸jû|µ�üÞ¨ ��SJU8EHGJI�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ��¹»º�¼¾½ k|¿ ¼ ´ ¸ ´ û|µ�üÞ±�±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ�È��

Ö�±� ?1�]��STEN�J�æ¤2ILQNKR�JK�KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����o�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ�2K���q�Q�sÀp�¬zrø¬�Â2±Ù±C±C±C±C±dÂZ��ÈÖ�± « ?1�]��STEN�J�æ¤2ILQNKR�JK�KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����o�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ�2K���q�Q�sÀp�¬zr�Â2±�±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ�2ÕÖ�±øÇ ?1�]��STEN�J�æ¤2ILQNKR�JK�KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����o�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ�2K���q�Q�sÀp Â�rø¬�±�±C±C±C±C±C±dÂZ��ÖÖ�±ÌÈ ?1�]��STEN�J�æ¤2ILQNKR�JK�KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����o�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ�2K���q�Q�sÀp Âv¬zrø¬�±Ù±C±C±C±C±dÂZ���

ÚfÚ

Page 20: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

a b O� �dc Á Â>à Äg�Å

«b±� « � I��2QRI�IÞÁ×q��¿Á×Ô|QRI�ILUJq2� ¯�Ú�����PJ�OI�±�¯ SJI�QR�2MOILK�q��oKREH��EHILK�ÇX�1EHqCÈfÕ�q V ÁEH��MOSJILU VfW ¤���QNMOq��JK��zI�EHGJqmUJKL± § q2�O�J��S¦«b½U?1�]��STEH���ØÁÃ�zIL�ªG]��SJM������j±§ q2���J��S�Ç�½x+�ýÆ+ V �Oqm�ªÓUJM¿����q2S]����MOÄ��ÜEHMOq�S%M�S1EHGJI G]��QN��q2SJMO�ÞÁ×q2KR��M��O�¿�ÜEHq2QENq2QN�JK V ��KNM�K�± § q��O�J��S�ÈJ½g+�ýÇ+ V �Oqm�ªÓCUJM¿����q2S]����MOÄ��ÜEHMOq�S5M�S�EHGJI�ÏÒññV ��KNMOKL±*±C±C±5±C±5±C±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C± Ö2Õ

«b± « Ö � IL�2QNILI�Á×q��¿ÁÒÔ]QNILI�UJq2� ¯�Ú����zP��OI�± DFKN����PJ�OI1q��*ILSJI�QR�2MOILK.q��pKREª�ÜEHI�K�TÕ�ENq�«bÂ�¬�q V Eª��M�SJI�U VTW ¤���QNM�q2�JK ��ILEHG�qbUJKL± § q2���J�zSz«b½@?1�]��STEH�J�:Á��I��ªG]��SJMO�����˱ § q2���J�zS�Ç�½4Âw«�Ö%ýFÂv«�Ö V ��qb�ªÓCUJMO���2q2S]���OMOÄ���EHM�q2S�MOS5EHGJIG]��QN��q2SJMO�ÞÁ×q2KR��M��O�¿�ÜEHq2Q.EHq2QR�JK V ��KNM�K�± § q��O�J��S8È�½¼Âw«�Ö�ý�Âw«�Ö V �Oqm�ªÓUJMO���2q2SJ���OM�Ä���ENMOq2S�MOS�EHG�ICÏÒññ V ��KNMOKL±»±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±,��¬

ÚmÚbM

Page 21: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Õb±� ¯ SJILQN�2M�I�K¼q����8KN���zP��OI$q���D�Q £ Ô V q2��SJUbÁ×K�Eª��ENI�K�û�MOS?��� ½ k ü Å M�EHGQRI�KNPxI���E�EHq�EHG�I���q2QRQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ� È }ÊÉ pÀ¬¼��QNI�IÞÁ £ ÔlKREª�ÜEHI�± § q2�O���zS«b½�°�G�I����������J�O��EHILU>ILSJI�QR�2MOILK�± § q2���J��S�Ç�½�°�GJI�I�ÚbP�ILQNM��zILSfEH���pI�SbÁILQN�2M�I�K�± § q��O�J��SJK.ÈMË Õb½d°�GJI5�JQNKRE�KNI�E1q�� V q�Ú¦UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�± § q���Á�J��S?Ö�½�°�GJI¦�¼�ÜÚbM����J�»PJ��QRENMO����I�ÁÃMOSbÁ×�ÜÁ V q�ÚZILSJI�QR� W �OIL¤�I��MOS�EHGJIV ��KNMOK¢�JKRI�U���q2Q4EHGJI�]QNK�E�KRILE�q�� V q�ÚzUJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK%û�ÌOp  � ® �¼�wÚ ü�±§ q2���J��S �"Ë���½ °�GJI�KRI��Lq2SJU>KRILE.q�� V qvÚ�UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�± § q��O�J��S +�½°�GJI��¼�ÜÚbM����J� P]��Q�EHM����OIÞÁ×M�SbÁÒ�ÜÁ V q�Ú�I�SJILQN� W �OIL¤�I���MOS¼ENGJI V ��KNMOK��JKNILU��q2Q�ENGJI�KNIL��q2SJU¦KNI�E%q�� V q�Ú-UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂ�È2Ç

Õb± « � M�KNKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S QN��EHILK:��q2Q�EHGJI8ûÒÂv¬2¬2¬TüCKREª�ÜEHI�± § q��O�J��S÷Â$��M�¤2ILK:EHGJIQN��EHILK¼��q�QNQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ� ENq8EHG�I V q2�JSJUbÁÃKREH��EHI¦��q2��PJ��ENI�Ul�JKRMOSJ�8EHGJI�]QRKRE�KNILE�q�� V qvÚ UJM��zILSJKNM�q2SJK�± § q2���J�zSZ«¦�2M�¤2I�KCEHGJI¼QH��ENI�K��Lq2QNQRI�ÁKRP�q2S�UJMOSJ��ENqCENGJI V q2��SJUbÁ×K�Eª��ENI.��q2��PJ��ENI�U��JKNM�SJ��EHGJIKNIL��q2SJUzKNI�Edq��V q�Ú-UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�±�±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂwÕmÂ

Õb±øÇ � M�KNKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S QN��EHILK:��q2Q�EHGJI8ûj«�¬2¬2¬TüCKREª�ÜEHI�± § q��O�J��S÷Â$��M�¤2ILK:EHGJIQN��EHILK¼��q�QNQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ� ENq8EHG�I V q2�JSJUbÁÃKREH��EHI¦��q2��PJ��ENI�Ul�JKRMOSJ�8EHGJI�]QRKRE�KNILE�q�� V qvÚ UJM��zILSJKNM�q2SJK�± § q2���J�zSZ«¦�2M�¤2I�KCEHGJI¼QH��ENI�K��Lq2QNQRI�ÁKRP�q2S�UJMOSJ��ENqCENGJI V q2��SJUbÁ×K�Eª��ENI.��q2��PJ��ENI�U��JKNM�SJ��EHGJIKNIL��q2SJUzKNI�Edq��V q�Ú-UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�±�±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂwÕ�«

ÚfÚbMOM

Page 22: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Õb±ÌÈ � M�KNKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S QN��EHILK:��q2Q�EHGJI8ûj«bÂ2Âv¬TüCKREª�ÜEHI�± § q��O�J��S÷Â$��M�¤2ILK:EHGJIQN��EHILK¼��q�QNQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ� ENq8EHG�I V q2�JSJUbÁÃKREH��EHI¦��q2��PJ��ENI�Ul�JKRMOSJ�8EHGJI�]QRKRE�KNILE�q�� V qvÚ UJM��zILSJKNM�q2SJK�± § q2���J�zSZ«¦�2M�¤2I�KCEHGJI¼QH��ENI�K��Lq2QNQRI�ÁKRP�q2S�UJMOSJ��ENqCENGJI V q2��SJUbÁ×K�Eª��ENI.��q2��PJ��ENI�U��JKNM�SJ��EHGJIKNIL��q2SJUzKNI�Edq��V q�Ú-UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�±�±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂwÕ�Ç

Õb± Õ � M�KNKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S QN��EHILK:��q2Q�EHGJI8û�Ç2¬2¬2¬TüCKREª�ÜEHI�± § q��O�J��S÷Â$��M�¤2ILK:EHGJIQN��EHILK¼��q�QNQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ� ENq8EHG�I V q2�JSJUbÁÃKREH��EHI¦��q2��PJ��ENI�Ul�JKRMOSJ�8EHGJI�]QRKRE�KNILE�q�� V qvÚ UJM��zILSJKNM�q2SJK�± § q2���J�zSZ«¦�2M�¤2I�KCEHGJI¼QH��ENI�K��Lq2QNQRI�ÁKRP�q2S�UJMOSJ��ENqCENGJI V q2��SJUbÁ×K�Eª��ENI.��q2��PJ��ENI�U��JKNM�SJ��EHGJIKNIL��q2SJUzKNI�Edq��V q�Ú-UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�±�±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂwÕÜÈ

Õb±øÖ � M�KNKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S QN��EHILK:��q2Q�EHGJI8û�Ç�Â2Âv¬TüCKREª�ÜEHI�± § q��O�J��S÷Â$��M�¤2ILK:EHGJIQN��EHILK¼��q�QNQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ� ENq8EHG�I V q2�JSJUbÁÃKREH��EHI¦��q2��PJ��ENI�Ul�JKRMOSJ�8EHGJI�]QRKRE�KNILE�q�� V qvÚ UJM��zILSJKNM�q2SJK�± § q2���J�zSZ«¦�2M�¤2I�KCEHGJI¼QH��ENI�K��Lq2QNQRI�ÁKRP�q2S�UJMOSJ��ENqCENGJI V q2��SJUbÁ×K�Eª��ENI.��q2��PJ��ENI�U��JKNM�SJ��EHGJIKNIL��q2SJUzKNI�Edq��V q�Ú-UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�SJK�±�±�±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±�±5±C±5±C±C±5±C±5±C±C±C±C±C±dÂwÕ�Õ

ÚfÚbMOMOM

Page 23: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Í��z3 ��íæ��3¢<

°�GJI�QNI�KRI���QR�ªGØ��q2STEª��MOSJILU�MOS5EHGJM�KpENGJI�KRMOK�q�QNMO��MOS]����� W �2QNI Å q2��E*q��x�%UJILKNM�QNI�ENq V ILERÁENI�Q�JSJUJILQNK�Eª��SJU>Ï×SfENQH����q2��I������¿��Q�ÿ�M V QN��EHM�q2S]���hñ.I��O�ÜÚ���EHM�q2S_¨]q2Q.ÏÃÿ1ñC¨]��q2QKNGJq�QRE�±�ÏÃEGJ��K V I�ILS�q V KRI�Q�¤2I�U:M�S5G�MO�2GbÁÃQNILKNq2����EHM�q2S�KNPxI���EHQH�%q��JPxq2� W ��EHq��zM�� �zq2��I��L�J�OILK,ENG]��E*��PbÁPJ��QNILSfEN� W KNG]��QNP_¨ Å I�����ÁÃUJIL�]S�I�U-P�I���ÓfKCûj��E��Oq Å ILQ�QNILKNq2����EHM�q2SJKHü���QNI�MOS¼������E���QH���LEHM�q2SbÁ�ÜEHI�U:M�STEHq�ENGJq2�JKN��SJUJK�q���KR�¼���O�OILQ,P�I���ÓfK Å M�EHG�MOS��1SJ��QNQRq Å ILSJI�QR� W�V ��SJU_±�°�G�MOK*��QN����ÁENMOq2SJ��EHM�q2S5M�K�M�SJUJMO����EHM�¤2I¢q��]��q2SJ��ÁËEHMO��I U W S]����MO�LK Å M�ENGJMOSCEHGJIdP�q�� W �ÜEHq2��MO�4��q2�OIL���J��I�¨U��JQNM�SJ� Å GJM��ªG:I�SJILQN� W PJ�O����ILU�MOSTENq1��S�M�SJM�ENM¿����Ä�I�QRq�EHGmÁ×q2QRUJI�Qp¤bM V QH�ÜEHMOq�S]���TKREH��EHI Î q Å KM�STEHq�EHGJI.q�ENGJI�Q4¤mM V QN��EHM�q2S]���JK�Eª��ENI�K¢q��oENGJIP�q2� W ��ENq2��MO��±pD�S��JSJU�I�QNK�Eª��S�UJMOSJ�5q��oENGJMOKILSJI�QR� W:Î q Å M�K q��_M�SfENI�QRI�KRE¢EHq�PJG W KNM������|�ªGJIL�zM�KRENK�¨mKNMOS���I�EHGJIUJM�KREHQRM V �bEHMOq�S:q��o¤mM V QH�ÜÁENMOq2SJ����ILSJI�QR� W Å M�ENGJMOS@��Pxq2� W ��EHq��zM�����q2�OIL���J��I�G]��KC��KRENQNq2S��$I�ÍoIL�LECq2S@�ªGJIL�zM������QRI�����EHM�q2S-QH��ENI�K�±� �JQCÏÃÿ�ñÀQRI�KNI���QN�ªG �OI�Uò�JK�EHq-EHGJI�MOKRKN�JI�q��d�]SJUJM�SJ��EHGJIz��PJPJQRq2PJQRM¿��ENI�ÄLI�QRq�EHGbÁ

q�QNUJILQ V ��KNM�K���QNq�� Å GJM��ªG�ENq��zI���KN��QNI�MOSTENQH����q2�OIL���J�O��Q�¤bM V QH�ÜEHMOq�S]���¢I�SJILQN� WZÎ q Å ±ÏÃÿ1ñ)MOK1� V ��KNM�K�Á×U�I�PxI�SJUJILSTE5S�q�EHM�q2S_¨_KRMOSJ�LI:MOSò��S@��PJP�QNq2PJQRM¿��ENI V ��KRMOKL¨hS]����I�� W EHG�IILMO�2ILSJKREH��EHILK�¨oENGJI�QRI�MOK%SJq�ÏÃÿ1ñ)��E1���O�j±D)S]��EH��QH��� V ��KRMOK�¨�q V EH��MOSJILU>��QNq����L�¿��KRKNM��������I��ªGJ��SJMO�LK�¨h�Lq2SJKNM�KRENKCq��¢ENGJIØKNIL�zM����¿��KNKNM������ Å �v¤�IL���JS��LEHM�q2SJKC��q2QRQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ��EHq�EHG�IM�ST¤���QNM¿��SfE�ENq2QNM4q��dEHGJIØ���J��� �zq2��I��L�J�¿��Q%¤bM V QH�ÜEHMOq�S]��� £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_± î I�UJIL¤�I���q2P�ILU

ÚfÚ�M�¤

Page 24: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

���2QH��UJMOILSfE�Á×UJILKN�LI�STE���PJP�QNqT���ªGðûËö � D1ü�ENqz�]SJU¦EHGJI�q�P�EHM��zM�Ä�I�U V ��KNMOK%q�� M�Sf¤���QRM¿��STEENq2QNM Å M�EHG Å GJMO�ªG�EHqCQNI�P�QNI�KRI�STE.��SJI���QN� W KRI�P]��QH� V ��I £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S_±,°�GJM�K������Oq Å K�EHG�IU�ILEHILQN��MOS]�ÜEHMOq�S$q�� I�SJILQN� W KNPxI���EHQN��¨ Å M�EHGJM�S>���2M�¤�I�S�QN��SJ�2I�¨ Å M�EHG>�z���J�ªG>KN�z���O��I�QKRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO����� V ��KRMOK�ENG]��S�QNIL�f�JMOQRI�U Å M�ENG���S�MOS�M�EHMO���hÄ�ILQNq�ENGbÁ×q�QNUJILQ1QNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2Sû�KN�J�ªG>��K.G]��QR�zq2S�MO�1q2KR��M��O�¿�ÜEHq2QRKªü�±

°�GJI�ö � D��zI�EHGJqmU Å ��K�EHGJILSl�2I�S�I�QH���OMOÄLI�U�EHq8MOSJ�L�O�JUJI$��Q V M�ENQH��Q W ����SJq2SJM������QRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S�K�q���PJGJ��KNIzKNP]���LI�¨4��S�U SJq�E � �JKRE����LENMOq2SmÁÒ��SJ���OI�¤���QNMO� V ��I�K�±�ÏÃE Å ��K���OKNq�I�ÚmEHILSJUJI�U$KNq:ENG]��E��Lq2SJK�EHQN���LEHM�q2S-q��hEHG�I�KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������ Å ��¤�IL���JSJ��EHM�q2SJK��KNKRqb�LM�Á�ÜEHI�U Å M�ENG$ENGJI5q�P�EHM��zM�Ä�I�U�����SJq2S�MO����� V ��KNM�K Å ��KP�q�KNKNM V �OI�±�°�GJM�K Å q2QRÓ������O��K��JSJUJILQENGJIØ����ENI��2q�Q W q��dPJG]��KRI�ÁÃKNP]���LI¼UJI���q2QN�z��ENMOq2SJKL¨,��SJU@��q2QN��K�EHGJI:�]QRKRECE Å q$�ªG]��PbEHI�QRKq��*ENGJMOK�ENGJI�KRMOK�±

î I¼���OKNq$KNq��J�2GTE5ENq>K�EH�JU W ENGJIz��I��ªGJ��SJMOKR�ºq���ILSJI�QR� W@Î q Å V ILE Å I�I�SZENGJI�MOSbÁ¤���QRM¿��STEzEHq2QRM%M�Sù¤mM V QN��EHM�q2S]���.U W S]����MO�LK¼PJQRq V ��I���K�± É PxI��LM��]�����O� W ¨ Å I Å MOKRGJI�UlENqU�ILEHILQN��MOSJI Å GJI�EHGJILQ�U W S]����MO�����JEH�JS�SJI���MOSJ�J¨m�C�m�J��STEH�J� I�SJILQN� WØÎ q Å ��I��ªG]��SJMOKR�¦¨q�Q�D�QRSJq2�ËÊÌU � M�Í��JKNM�q2S_¨��1���¿��KNKNM�������I�SJILQN� W5Î q Å ��I��ªG]��S�MOKN�$¨ Å ��K EHGJI�P�QNMO�z��Q W �L�J��ÁP�QNM�ENK.�OI���UJMOSJ�:ENq�ENGJIC�JSJI5PxI���Ó�KNPJ��M�ENENMOSJ��K�q V KRI�QR¤�I�U�M�S¦ÏÒñ�KRP�IL�LEHQN��±�Ï×S¦��UJUJM�EHM�q2S_¨ENGJI�ÏÃÿ1ñ Å q2QRÓ Å ��K�����KNqzQNI��O��EHILU>EHq Å q2QRÓ VTW ó�QNqmq2ÓfK1�*��EHI5q�� EHG�I�¥%S�M�¤2ILQNKRM�E W q��ÿ�MOQR�2MOSJMO��¨ Å GJq Å ��K1K�EH�JU W M�SJ��EHG�I�UJI Î I���EHMOq�S�q��4��q2�OIL���J��I�KMOS>IÞÚmEHI�QRS]���p�]I���UJK�±1ÏÃE

Å ��K V IL�OMOI�¤2ILU¦EHGJ��EI�SJILQN� W EHQN��SJK���I�Q�U��JICENq Ð ��SJUJ���bÁ�ÑoILSJI�QU W S]����MO�LK�EHGJQRq2�J�2G>�ÚfÚm¤

Page 25: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

S�ILE Å q2QNÓ@q�����¤2q2M�UJI�U8��QNq�KNKNM�SJ�2K���q��J�OUò�OI���U�EHq$UJI Î IL�LENMOq2Sòq����O��QN��I�Q���q2�OIL���J��I�K�MOSIL�OIL�LEHQRMO���]IL�OUJKL±ØD UJI�KRMOQNI:ENq¦�JS�UJI�QRKREª��SJU8ENGJMOK�ILSJI�QR� W�Î q Å ��I��ªG]��SJMOKR�â�OILU@ENq$��Lq2�O�O� V q2QH��ENMOq2S Å M�EHG � q2QRq2S § q2GJILS_¨2EHG�I�SØ�1Pxq2KRE�Á×UJqm���JS�UJI�Q4ñ.MO�ªÓ £ IL�O�OILQ�¨�MOS Å GJM��ªG

Å I�UJI�¤2I���q2PxI�U$��S-��S]��� W EHM�������� W KRq2��¤�� V ��I�K�EHqm�ªG]��KRENMO�1��qmUJI��x��q2Q�ILSJI�QR� W UJM�KNPxI�QRKNMOq�SU��JI�EHq¼Sm���zILQNq2�JK Ð ��SJU]���bÁÒÑoI�SJILQ%ENQH��SJKRM�ENMOq2SJKL±�°�GJILKNI�E Å q�KN� Vf� I��LENKzû�U W S]����MO�����EN�JSJSJIL�OM�SJ��¤mKL±�D�QNS�q2�ËÊÌU � M�Ío��KNMOq�S¦��SJU Ð ��SJUJ���bÁ�ÑoILSJI�QU W S]����MO�LKªü������O�h��SJUJI�Q.EHG�I����EHIL�2q2Q W q��*I�SJILQN� W QRI�UJM�KREHQRM V �bEHMOq�S_¨J��S�U-��q�QN� § G]��P�EHILQNKÇz��SJU-Èzq��pEHG�MOK�EHG�I�KNM�K�±

Ô�M�S]����� W ¨w��SJq�EHG�I�Q,�OM�SJI q��JQRI�KRI���QR�ªG�EHG]�ÜE*ENGJI4ÏÃÿ�ñ Å q�QNÓ1EHqmq2Ó Å ��K��K�EH�JU W q���EHG�I¤mM V QH��ENMOq2SJ���*P�QNI�U�MOKNKRqb�LM¿��ENMOq2S>q��dENGJI�¤���S@UJI�Q î �2����K1��q��zPJ��I�Ú>D�Q £ Ô�±_°�G�MOK Å q2QNÓ

Å ��K1U�q2SJI�M�S>�Lq2�O�O� V q�QH��ENMOq2S Å M�ENG�� QNq��Ò±1ó�M��O�,ô��OIL�zPxI�QRI�Q%��SJU�GJM�K��2QRq2�JP_¨xGJILQNI:��E£ ��QR¤���QRU_± � �JQ���qT��� Å ��K�EHqzUJIL¤�I���q2P��z�f�]��SfEN�J� �zqmUJIL�,��q�QENGJI5P�QNI�U�MOKNKRqb�LM¿��ENMOq2SU W SJ���zM���K Å GJMO�ªG¼��q2�J��U¼PJQRI�UJM��LE¢EHGJIPJQRI�UJM�KNKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S�QH��ENI�K���SJU¼QRq�Eª��ENMOq2SJ���]UJMOK�EHQRM�ÁV ��EHM�q2S�q��]ENGJI�q���EH�2q�MOSJ� £ Ô�± î I��z��S]���2ILU�EHq%q V EH��MOS5QH��ENI�K Å G�MO�ªG Å I�QNI Å M�EHG�MOS���Sq�QNUJILQ�q��,�z���2SJM�EH�JU�Iq�Q����J�ªG V I�ENEHILQ�¨bMOS�KRq2�zI����KNI�KL¨Jq��hENGJq2KNI��zI���KN�JQRI�U�IÞÚbP�ILQNM�Á��I�STEH���O� W ± î I.����KNq��z��S]����I�U�ENqC�Lq2S��]QR� ENGJI�I�ÚbPxI�QNM��zILSTEª���Jq V KNILQR¤���EHM�q2S�EHGJ��E�EHG�IP�QNqmUJ�J�LE £ Ô@P�QNIL��ILQNILSfENM¿����� W PJQNILUJMOKRKNqm��MO��EHILK MOSTEHq�EHG�IG�MO�2GJILKRE¢��S��2�J�¿��Q��zq��zILSfEN�J�K�Eª��ENIòû � ÁÃKREª�ÜEHIvü�������ILKNKRM V ��I���q2Q�EHGJI��Lq2��PJ�OIÞÚo¨ Å GJM��ªG�MOK � p#ÂvÇb± °�GJI-�z��MOSðUJM�K�Á�LQNILP]��SJ� W>V ILE Å I�ILS@ENGJI�q�Q W ��SJU¦I�ÚbP�ILQNM��zILSfE�MOK.EHG]�ÜE1q2�JQQNq�Eª��ENMOq2S]���hUJMOK�EHQNM V ��ENMOq2SM�K����J�ªG$�zq�QNI�KNGJ��QNPJ� W PxI���Ó�I�U��ÜE � p Â�Ç:ENG]��S�EHG�ICIÞÚbP�ILQNMO��I�STEH���hUJMOK�EHQRM V ��ENMOq2So±

ÚfÚb¤mM

Page 26: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

î IC���OKRq��z��S]���2I�U�EHqØUJI�¤2IL�Oq2P¦��KRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO�����o�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ����q�QN���J�O����q2Q V q2�JSJUbÁ��QRI�ICUJMOKRKNqm��MO��EHM�¤2I���q2��PJ�OM�SJ�2K.�JKNM�SJ�¼q�SJ� W ENGJI��L�¿��KRKNM������,Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ�LqbI�Ý���MOILSTEHK�q���EHG�I£ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S_±�°�G�MOKCMOK��-P]��QRENM¿�����2I�SJILQH����MOÄ���EHM�q2S�q��¢EHGJI V q��JSJUbÁ V q2��SJU8�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ���q�QN���J�O����KNMOS��zEHG�I�Ô]q2�JQRMOI�Q��qmILÝ��LMOI�STENK1q���ENGJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S�MOS���S����LENMOq2SmÁÒ��SJ���OIIÞÚbP]��SJKRMOq2S_±¢°�GJILKNI5E Å q¼KR� Vm� IL�LEHK�����O�o�JSJUJILQ.ENGJIC����ENI��2q2Q W q��*¤bM V QH�ÜEHMOq�S]���oP�QNI�U�MOK�ÁKRqb�LM¿��ENMOq2So¨J��SJU���q2QR�æEHG�IC�O��KRE�E Å q��ªG]��P�ENI�QNK�ûËÕ:��S�U>ÖTü�q��*ENGJMOK�ENGJI�KRMOK�±

ÚfÚm¤mMOM

Page 27: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

� Î Â,ÏÐ��� i Ñ

Ò Ó Ô Õ ÖØ× Â,À�ÅÙ Ò Ï Ï i �¨Â,ÚBÎ ���

� ÄÛÂqt b ÚÇÂ�Ä Ó Î ÂqÜ� Ö·Ý Ï Â,ÚÇ�

Ô �Þc�� iàß Âá� b ���

°�G�MOK �ªG]��PbEHI�Q4PJQRI�KRI�STEHKd��� � ¯�Á V ��KRI�Uz��PJPJQRqT���ªG:EHq1�]S�UJMOSJ�C��S:q�P�EHM��¼���m����SJq2SJM������V ��KNM�K Å M�ENG Å GJMO�ªGlENqZQNILPJQNILKNILSfE$�ZS�I���QR� W MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S_±÷°�GJI>MOUJI��V I�G�MOSJU ENGJI¼��ILENGJqmUZMOK�EHq��Lq2STEHM�Sm��q2�JKN� W UJIL��q2QR�ºEHGJI�M�SJM�ENM¿��������SJq�SJMO����� V ��KNM�K�MOSKR�J�ªGz� Å � W ENG]��E ENGJI�UJILP�ILSJUJI�S���Iq��|EHGJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S5q2S�ENGJI�����SJq2SJM������bP�q2KRM�ENMOq2Sq��¢ENGJI��]SJ��� V ��KRMOK1M�K1��MOSJM��zM�Ä�I�Uo±1°�GJI��]S]��� V ��KRMOK1M�SJ��q�QNPxq2QH��ENI�K���K����J�ªG@q�� EHG�I

Â

Page 28: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�L�¿��KRKNM������mU W S]����MO�LK���K�Pxq2KRKNM V �OI�M�STEHq���S�MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S_¨v�OI���¤bM�SJ�������J�ªGKR�¼���O�OILQ�SJq2SbÁÃMOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI���q2��P�q�SJI�STE�ENG]��SZM�S8ENGJI¼M�SJM�ENM¿��� QRI�PJQRI�KNILSTEª��ENMOq2S_± î M�ENGENGJMOK.��PJPJQNq2���ªG-M�E�M�K.���OKRq:P�q2KRKNM V �OI�ENqØ��q2SJK�EHQR�J�LE.EHG�I�KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������ Å ��¤2I����JSJ��EHMOq�SJK�Lq2QNQRI�KRP�q2S�UJMOSJ�%EHq�ENGJI��]S]��������SJq2SJM������ V ��KRMOK�±*°�GJMOK�q2P�EHM��zM�Ä�ILU V ��KNMOK�MOK�Pxq�ENI�STEHMO���O� W��KNIL�����bM�S��f�]��STEH��� �����O�L�J�¿��ENMOq2S�K�¨ V q�EHG���K�� Å � W EHq���MOS�MO��MOÄ�I*EHGJIdQNI��f�JM�QNILU�KNM�Ä�I¢q��V ��KNM�K�KNILENK�¨|��S�U¦��K�� Å � W ENq:PJQNqv¤mMOUJI�P�G W KRMO�����hMOSJKRMO�2GTE VTW M�KNq2�O��EHM�SJ�5ENGJq2KRI�ILÍ�I��LENKQRI�KR�J��ENMOSJ�:��QNq��æMOSTENI��2QN� V �OI�U W S]����MO��KL±

âGãZâ ä ��� 3 �-<����.�������

É �JPJPxq2KNI Å I5��QNI1�2M�¤2ILS¦�:SJI���QN� W M�STEHI���QH� V ��I £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��SØ\ðû�å }Hs ü�¨ Å GJILQNIzû|å }Hs üQRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEHK1KRq2��IC����SJq2S�MO�����pQRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S¦q���P�G]��KNICKNPJ����I�û�SJq�ESJIL��ILKNKH��QNMO� W q2Q�ÁU�MOS]��Q W Pxq2KRM�EHM�q2S���SJU��zq��zILSfEN�J�¼ü�± î I Å MOKRG�EHq��]SJUò��S�q�EHGJILQ1����SJq2SJM������*QNI�P�QNI�ÁKRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�SZû � }H¡ ü�M�S Å G�MO�ªGO\/M�K%��K%�L�Oq2KRI5��K%Pxq2KNKRM V ��I1EHq V ILMOSJ��MOSTENI��2QN� V �OI�± � �JQ��q�ENM�¤���EHM�q2S5��q�Q�EHGJM�K MOK�E Å q���q2��U_¨f��SJU�MOK��Lq2SJSJIL�LENI�UzENq�KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������b�m�J��STEH�J� ��I�Á�ªGJ��SJMO�LK�½�Ô�MOQRKRE�q������O�j¨_��QNq2�º�-PJ�JQRI�� W Sm���zILQNMO����� PxI�QNKRP�IL�LENM�¤2I�¨��-QNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2SM�S Å GJM��ªGÀ\õM�K1��K%���Oq�KNI���K�Pxq2KNKRM V ��I5EHq V ILMOSJ�zMOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OIC�OI���UJK%ENq���S>q�P�EHM��zM�Ä�I�UKRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO����� V ��KNM�K Å M�ENG Å GJMO�ªG�ENq�PxI�Q���q2QN� �f�]��STEH��� ���������J�O��EHM�q2SJKL±�°�GJI�QRI���KRq2S��q�QCENGJMOK5MOK�EHG]��E Å I�����SZ��KNKRqb�LM¿��ENI Å M�EHG ¡ �¦�f�]��SfEN�J�»K�Eª��ENI�æ ¡ �L±-ÏÃ� Å I Å QRM�EHI

«

Page 29: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

\Zû � }H¡ ü@p�\ ºèç ¿ û ¡ ü8éê\ º k|¿ û ��}H¡ üÞ¨TEHGJILS¼M�E4M�K4���OI���Q4EHG]��EV\ º�ç ¿ MOK4UJMO���2q2SJ���]MOS:EHG�Ië æ ¡ ��ì V ��KNM�K�¨]KNqØEHGJ��E.q2SJ� W \ º k|¿ MOK.��¤���M��¿� V ��I�EHqØ�Lq2�JPJ��I1EHGJI�¤���QNM�q2�JK V ��KNMOK.K�Eª��ENI�K�±°�G�IC�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ�ØM�K��2M�¤�I�S-KNIL�zM����¿��KNKNM�������� W�VTW�í +ïî˨

� ¡4ð æ�ñ\ º k|¿ æ ¡ �2pò\ º k|¿ó ¸õô óöø÷Tùú û¡ é ¡ ð« ü û�Â�±�Âwü

Å G�I�QNIL\ º k|¿ó ¸ûô óöø÷Tùú û�üKý=ü¸l ü.M�KENGJIêü ¸ ½ ülÊþZÿ� Ô|q��JQNM�I�Q��q2��P�q�SJI�STE��ÜE_üKý=ü ¸l q��2\ º k|¿ ±D)QRI�PbÁ

QRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S$MOS Å GJM��ªG \ º k|¿ M�K.��K.KN�z���O�o��K.P�q2KRKNM V �OI Å MO���o��MOSJM��zM�Ä�I.EHGJIC��q��JPJ�OM�SJ�2KM�S:EHGJI��q2QRQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ� ë æ ¡ ��ì V ��KNMOKL¨m��SJUØEHGf�JK Å MO�O���zM�SJMO��MOÄLIdEHG�IKRMOÄLI%q��xEHG�I V ��KNMOKQRI��f�JM�QNI�U-EHqØPxI�Q���q2QN�ä�:�2M�¤2ILS¦�����O�L�J�¿��ENMOq2SzEHqØKNq2��I�UJI�KRMOQRI�U¦�����L�JQH��� W ±

É IL��q2S�UJ� W ¨]������SJq2SJM�������QNI�P�QNI�KRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�S�MOS Å GJM��ªG \ MOK���K��L�Oq2KRI���K�Pxq2KNKRM V ��I%ENqV I�M�SJ�¼M�STEHI���QH� V ��I�PJQNqv¤mMOUJILK�PJG W KNM������*MOSJKRMO�2GTE�±.ó W MOSJ�Lq2QNPxq2QH�ÜEHMOS��z��K����J�ªG>q���EHG�I�L�¿��KRKNM������ U W S]���zM���KC��KCP�q2KRKNM V �OIØMOSTENq>��SòMOSTENI��2QN� V �OI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_¨�ENGJMOKCq2P�ENMO�z�������SJq2S�MO�����pQRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S�����S�GJIL�OP$EHq�M�KNq2�O��EHI�EHG�q2KNI5���¿��KNKNM������p��S�U��f�]��STEH�J��IL�¿Á��IL�LENK�QNI�KR�J��ENMOSJ�z��QNq2��MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI�U W SJ���zM���K���QRq2� EHGJq2KRI�EHG]�ÜE�UJq�SJq�E�±�°�Gm��K�ENGJMOKQRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S>����S�M�KNq2�O��EHI�SJq�SbÁ×M�SfENI��2QN� V ��IC�f�]��SfEN�J����SJU>�L�¿��KRKNM������,ILÍ�I���EHK1KR�J�ªG��K�U W S]����MO�����%EH��SJSJI���MOSJ�Z��SJU÷D�QRSJq2�ËÊÌUÛUJM�Ío�JKRMOq2So¨QRI�KRP�IL�LEHM�¤2IL� W ±)Ô]�JQRENGJI�QR�zq2QRI�¨

Å I¼����SZ���OKNq-¤mMOKR�]���OM�Ä�I�ENGJI¼�f�]��STEN�J�#�¼��S�M���I�K�Eª��ENMOq2S�q���EHG�I¼MOSTENI��2QN� V �OI:�L�¿��KRKNM������U W SJ���zM���K�¤mM¿��EHG�I5KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����_PJQRI�KN�LQNM�P�EHM�q2S���q2Q.��q2SJK�EHQR�J�LENMOSJ�z� Å ��¤2I����JSJ�LENMOq2So½ö�M�¤�I�S�ENGJI���I�SJILQH��ENMOSJ������SJ�LENMOq2SL]û�å }H¡ ü,��QRq2��EHGJI�MOSJM�EHM¿��� V ��KRMOK�û�å }Hs ü,ENq�EHGJId�]S]���

Ç

Page 30: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

V ��KNM�KCû � }H¡ ü�¨ Å ICG]��¤2I�¨x��P$ENq�S�q2QN�z���OM�Ä���ENMOq2So¨

��åVæ ¡ ��p&æ UJI�E � l ]�Kå�� ¡ æ��ö IÞÚbP í�� ]��� î û�Â�± «2ü

Å G�I�QNICUJI�E � ö �� �'� ü M�K�EHGJI Å I�����Á×ÓfSJq Å S-ÿ¢��S-ÿ1�OIL�ªÓ�UJI�EHI�QR�zM�S]��STE�±Ï×SðEHG�I�����KRI�q��%���LENMOq2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I�¤���QRM¿� V �OI�KL¨�EHGJI¼q2P�EHM��zM�Ä�ILUZQNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2S�q��%�

S�I���QR� W M�STEHI���QH� V ��I £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��SzMOK�ENI�QN��I�U$��S-Ï×STEHQRMOSJKRMO��ñ.I�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�ñ.I�P�QNI�KRI�STEª�wÁENMOq2Sùû�ÏÒññ%ü�¨p�$ENI�QN�#�Lq2MOSJILU VTW § ��QNM�q2�OMj¨ £ IL�O�OILQ�¨*��SJUZ©¦q2�O��I�Qzû § £ ©�ü í «b¨pÇ*îj±�Ï×SÂ3+�+X�¼EHGJI W PJ� V ��MOKRGJI�U8�$PJ��P�ILQ�UJILEH��MO��MOSJ�-��S8�����2q2QNM�EHGJ� ��q2Q1ENGJIz�Lq2SJK�EHQN���LEHM�q2Sòq��KR�J�ªG8�¼QNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2S_±�°�G�I:MOUJI�� V ILGJMOS�U�EHGJI § £ © ���O�2q2QRM�ENGJ�äMOK�ENq�I���MO��MOS]��ENI���O�hEHGJI5SJq2SbÁÃQNILKNq2S]��SfE%EHILQN��K�q�� ENGJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S�¤bMO�¼��S���PJPJQRq2PJQNMO��EHIC����SJq2SJM������ENQH��S�KR��q2QR�¼��ENMOq2So±ù°�GJM�Kz����SJq2SJM�������ENQH��S�KR��q2QR�¼��ENMOq2S�M�Kzq V Eª��M�SJI�U�¤mM¿�ò�8��qbUJM��]I�U§ GJ��PJ�z��S_¨oöC��QRQNI�ENE�¨x��S�U�©¦M��O�OILQ5û § öC©�ü.��ILENGJqmU í «b¨xÇ�¨�Èïî˨ Å GJM��ªG�MOKI�KRKNI�STENM¿����� W�@þI Å EHq�SbÁÒñ��PJGJKRq2S�KN�ªGJIL�zI-EHq��]SJU�EHG�I$M�ST¤���QNM¿��SfE�EHq2QRM Å M�ENG?��UJILKNM�QNI�U�KNI�E�q�����LEHM�q2SJK���q�QØ��SJI���QR� W MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI�K W K�EHIL�¦±Z°�G�I$QRI��z��MOS�MOSJ�¦QNI�KRq2S]��STEz��SJU�SJI���Q�ÁQRI�KRq2S]��STE�ENI�QN��K:��QRIzENGJI�S�QNIÞÁ×IÞÚ�P�QNI�KRKNILU?M�S8EHG�I�SJI Å V ��KRMOKL±�ÏÃE:MOK5MO��P�q�KNKNM V �OI:ENqQRI�UJ����I�ENGJI���S��2�OICUJI�PxI�S�UJI�SJ�LI���S W ����QREHG�I�Q�¨�KNM�SJ��ICEHGJM�K Å q2�J�OU>QNI�KR�J��E%MOS$EHGJI5��q2Q�Á�z��ENMOq2S-q�� QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�ÄLq2SJI�KL¨ Å GJM��ªG>PJQRIL¤�I�STEHK����2�Oq V ���h����EHMOq�SbÁÒ��S��2�OI�UJILKN�LQNMOPbEHMOq�Sq��*ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S_±

Ï×Sz«�¬2¬bÂ�EHGJI.����EHGJq�Q�PJ� V ��MOKRGJI�U���SØ����EHILQNS]��ENM�¤�I������2q2QNM�EHGJ����q�Q��]SJUJM�SJ�1EHG�I�ÏÒñ%ñ

È

Page 31: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

V ��KNM�K í «Zî˱�°�G�I��zI�EHGJqmUZMOSTENQNqmUJ�J��ILUZMOK���� � ¯�Á V ��KRI�U���PJP�QNqT���ªG Å G�MO�ªGð��q�SfENMOSbÁ��q2�JKN� W UJI���q2QN��K�EHG�I�MOSJM�EHM¿��������EHM�q2SbÁÒ��SJ�2�OI V ��KRMOK:MOSðKR�J�ªG?� Å � W EHGJ��E:EHGJI$��S��2�OIU�I�PxI�SJUJILSJ��I�q��1EHGJI £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��SðM�Kz�Lq2STEHM�Sm��q2�JKN� W QNI�U��J��ILU_±�ÏÃE�����q2�JSTEHKØEHq ���QH��UJM�I�STERÁÃUJI�KR��ILSfE����O��q2QNM�EHGJ� MOSØEHGJI�OM��zM�E�q��_���JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q¢PxI�QREN�JQ V ��EHM�q2S_¨f��SJU Å ��KENGJI�QRIL��q2QRI������O��I�U5ENGJI�ö � Dù��ILEHG�qbU_±*Ô]q2QN�z����� W ¨�ENGJI���ILENGJqbU5UJqmI�K�S�q�E�UJM�KRENMOSJ�2��MOKNGV ILE Å I�ILS-QNI�KRq2S]��STE�¨�SJI���QN� W QRI�KRq2S]��STE�¨���SJU�S�q2SbÁ×QRI�KRq2S]��STE�ENI�QN��K�¨fEHGJ��E�M�K�¨fEHGJI%IL¤2qÜÁ����EHM�q2S-MOK.PxI�QR��q�QN��I�U>q�S$ENGJI�ILSfENMOQRI £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S Å M�ENGJq2��E%��S W EHILQN��K%S�I��2��I��LENI�U_±£ q Å I�¤2I�QL¨]EHGJI1I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S�M�K�KN�J�ªG�ENG]��E�ENGJI1��q2QNI1S�q2SbÁ×QRI�KRq2S]��STE.��ENI�QN�$¨bENGJI1��q2QNIK�EHQRq2SJ�2� W M�E�MOK.��Í�I���EHI�U VTW EHG�ICI�¤2q2����EHM�q2S_± °�Gf�JKL¨|ENGJI�SJq2SmÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��STEENI�QR�zK�q��pEHG�I£ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S���QRI�I�KRKNI�STENM¿����� W ÓfM��O�OILU�q�Í*¨JEHGJI�S�I���QR� W QRI�KRq2S]��STEEHI�QR�zK.��QNI�QNILUJ�J�LI�UKRq2��I Å G]��E�¨ Å GJMO��I�EHGJI�QRI�KRq2S]��STE4EHILQN��K4��QNI.I�KRKNILSfENM¿����� W �JS]��Í�I���EHILU_± Ï×S¼ñ.IL�Ò±�«b¨2EHG�Iö � D ��ILENGJqbU Å ��K��JKRI�U�ENqzKRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����O� W �]SJU¦EHGJICI�M��2I�ST¤����O��I�Kq��¢«b¨|ÈJ¨���SJU>ÖU�I��2QRI�I�ÁÃq��¿ÁÃ��QRI�ILUJq2� K W K�EHIL�zKL¨x��KNMOS�����QNI��ÜEH� W QNILUJ�J��ILU V ��KNMOK.KRILEHKL±

°�GJI�ö � Dl��ILENGJqmU��LMOQR���J��¤�I�STEHK4E Å q5�z��MOS:U�QH� Å V ���ªÓfK¢q���ENGJI § £ ©ä�zI�EHGJqmU_±Ô*MOQNK�E�¨xEHGJI § £ © ��ILENGJqmU�QNIL�m��MOQNILK���S@��PJQRMOq2QRM*UJIL��M�KNMOq�S@��K�EHq Å G�MO�ªG�EHILQN��K���QNIQRI�KRq2S]��STE���S�U�SJq2SbÁÃQNILKNq2S]��SfE�±�°�GJMOK%�OI���UJK%ENq���S���� V MO���JM�E W M�S¦EHG�I�����KRI�q��4SJI���Q�ÁQRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�KL±CÏÃE1��q2�J��U�G]��P�P�ILS�EHG]��E1���2M�¤�I�S>ENI�QR��M�S>EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S-���JK�E V I�Lq2SJKRMOUJILQNI�UØQRI�KNq�S]��STE¢MOS�q2QRUJI�Q�ENq��2ILE ENGJI.þ%I Å EHq2SmÁÒñ��PJGJKRq2SØKN�ªGJIL�zI�EHq��Lq2ST¤2ILQN�2I�±°�G�MOK��OI���UJK�EHq¦�$KRq2��I Å G]��E5��Q�EHM��]��MO�����L��EHq�Í��LQNM�EHI�QRMOq2So¨pKRMOSJ�LI��$SJI���QN� W QNILKNq2SJ��STE

Õ

Page 32: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ô]q2��QNMOILQ%�Lq2��P�q2S�I�STE1KRGJq2�J��U�MOS>P�QNMOS���MOP��OICKREHM��O� V I�QNILUJ�J�LI�Uò��K1�����ªG@��K�Pxq2KNKRM V ��I�¨ENGJq2�J��G�SJq�E1S�I���ILKNKN��QNM�� W ��q2��PJ�OI�EHIL� W ±�°�Gm��K�¨h�JSJ��I�KRK�EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S-G]��K�����I ÅIÞÚ����LE%q2Q.SJI���Q�Á×QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�KL¨oM�E.M�K.SJq�E����I���Q�EHGJ��E%ENGJI § £ ©/��ILENGJqmU Å M��O�_�2M�¤2I�EHG�Iq�P�EHM��zM�Ä�I�U�ENq2QN��K V ��KNM�K�±

É IL��q2S�U_¨pENGJI § £ © �zI�EHGJqmU@QNIL�m��MOQNILK�EHGJIØSf�J��I�QNM�������IL¤����O�J��EHM�q2S�q��d���J��ENMOUJMÆÁ��I�S�KNMOq�S]���|MOSTEHIL�2QH���OK�¨m��S�U¼EHGJI%Sf�J�zILQNM������|MOST¤�I�QNKRMOq2S¼q��,�5S�q2SJ�OM�SJI���Qd��SJ�2�OI�z��P���EI�¤2ILQ W M�EHILQH��ENMOq2S-K�EHI�Po±�Ô]�JQ�EHGJILQN��q2QNI�¨xI�¤2ILQ W M�EHILQH��ENMOq2S-K�EHI�P@���OKNq�QNIL�f�JMOQRI�K%ENGJI�Sf�bÁ��I�QRMO�����TKNq2����EHM�q2S�q��|�%K W K�EHIL�)q��]��MOSJI���Q,I��f�]��ENMOq2S�K�±�°�G�I�KNI�Sm���zILQNMO�����m���������J�O��EHM�q2SJKKR�Oq Å ENGJI���O��q2QNM�EHGJ� UJq Å S_± Ï×S���q2STEHQN��KRE�¨mENGJI.Sf�J�zILQNM������J�����O�L�J�¿�ÜEHMOq�SJK�QNIL�f�JMOQRI�U VTWENGJI:ö � D ��ILENGJqbU���QNIC���J�ªG�KRMO��PJ�OILQ�¨|KNq Å I V I���MOI�¤2I5ENG]��E%EHGJI�ö � D ��ILENGJqmU>MOK����KREHILQ1EHG]��S@ENGJI § £ © ��P�PJQNqT���ªGùû EHGJq��J�2G@MOS�����M�QNSJILKNK�M�E1KNG�q2�J�OU V IØ��UJUJILU�EHG]��ES�q�U�MOQNIL�LEKNPxI�ILU>�Lq2�zPJ��QNM�KNq2SJK�G]��¤2I V ILI�S>�z��UJI1ENqØU]��EHI�ü�±

� ILKNPJM�EHICM�EHK��Ub¤���SfEH���2ILK�¨|EHGJI�ö � D �zI�EHGJqmU_¨|��KUJI�KR��QRM V I�U�M�S>ñ.IL�Ò±.«m¨xM�K%��MO�:ÁM�EHILU�EHq�K W K�EHI���K4UJI�KR��QRM V � V �OI VTW ���LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��Id¤���QNMO� V ��I�K�±*Ô]�JQRENGJI�QR�zq�QNI�¨ Å GJMO��IdEHG�I��ILENGJqmU>�2ILSJI�QN��EHILK%EHG�I�QNILPJQNILKNILSfEH��EHM�q2S�q���EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S�M�S¦EHG�I5�]S]���*���LEHM�q2SbÁ��SJ�2�OI V ��KNM�K�¨hM�E�U�qbILKCS�q�E��2M�¤�I�EHGJIØqv¤2ILQH�������2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�����JSJ�LENMOq2S�].û|å }H¡ üÞ¨_EHQN��SJK�Á��q�QN��MOSJ�1��QRq2�)EHG�IM�SJM�ENM¿���oû|å }Hs ü V ��KNMOK ENqCENGJI��]S]���pû � }H¡ ü V ��KNM�K�±�°�Gf�JKL¨ Å I%�Lq2�J��U�Lq2��PJ��EHI4EHG�IdILSJI�QR� W KNPxI��LENQN�J� ��QRMOKRMOSJ�.��QNq2����S�q2PbEHMO��MOÄLI�U�MOST¤���QRM¿��STE,EHq2QR�JK V ��KNM�K�¨V ��ECSJq�ECEHGJIØ��q�QNQNILKNPxq2SJUJM�SJ�$KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������ Å ��¤2I����JSJ�LENMOq2S�K��R�OM�¤mMOSJ���¼q2SòENGJI�ÏÒñ%ñ

Ö

Page 33: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ENq2QNMj±°�GJM�K��ªG]��P�EHILQ�MOK5�¦�Lq2STEHM�Sm�J��EHM�q2S q���EHGJI Å q�QNÓòPJQNILKNI�STENI�UðMOS ñI��Ò±¦« ûj��SJUZMOS

§ GJ��P�EHILQ�«�ü�¨���SJUCM�EpG]��KpKNI�¤2I�QN���mPJ�JQNPxq2KRI�K�½*Ô�M�QNKRE�¨vEHGJI¢PJQNILKNILSfEH��EHM�q2S�q���EHG�I¢��ILENGJqmU��M�¤2ILS>M�S�ñ.IL�Ò±«�GJ��K V I�ILS��2QNI���EH� W KNM��zPJ��M��]ILU_¨|��SJU¦�2I�S�I�QH���OMOÄLI�U$EHq¼M�SJ�����JUJIC��Q V M�ÁENQH��Q W ����SJq2SJM�������QRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S�K5q���PJG]��KRIzKRP]���LI�± É I��Lq2SJUJ� W ¨*��SJUò�zq2QRI:MO��P�q�Q�ÁEH��STEH� W ¨�ENGJI���ILEHG�qbUZGJ��K V ILI�SðIÞÚbENI�SJU�I�U�EHq�M�SJ�����JUJIzENGJI�UJI�EHILQN��MOS]��ENMOq2S8q���EHG�Iqv¤�I�QH���O� �2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�$����SJ�LENMOq2S�].û|å }N¡ üÞ±z°�GJM�K�PJQNqv¤mMOUJILK��-Pxq Å I�Q����J� ¤mMOKN�J���OM�Ä���ENMOq2SENqbq�� Å GJMO�ªG8�����Oq Å K1q2SJI:ENq>����EH�]���O� W ��q�SJKRENQN�J��E5ENGJIØKNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������ Å ��¤2I����JSJ��EHMOq�SJK��KNKNqm��MO��EHILU Å M�ENG�EHGJI�q2P�EHM��zM�Ä�ILU>����SJq2SJM������ V ��KRMOK�±�°�Gf�JKL¨ Å GJMO��ICENGJI����J���p��ILENGJqmU

Å M��O� V I�U�IL¤2IL�Oq2PxI�U$MOS�ENGJMOK��ªG]��P�ENI�Q�¨JENGJI�Sf�J��I�QNM������oI�Ú�����PJ�OILK���qb�L�JK�q2S�EHG�I�qw¤�I�QÒÁ���O�4�2I�S�I�QH�ÜEHMOS��>���JSJ��EHMOq�S¬].û|å }N¡ üÞ±>D�K��zILSfENMOq2S�I�U V IL��q2QRI�¨�Sf�J��I�QRMO�����dIÞÚ����zP��OI�KU�I�����MOSJ� Å M�ENG�ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S�UJM�QNIL�LEH� W �z� W�V I.��q2�JSJU�MOSzñ.IL�Ò±4«�û�q2Q4M�S § G]��P�EHILQ«�q��pEHG�MOK�EHGJILKNM�Kªü�±

°�GJM�K��ªG]��P�ENI�Q�M�K�q2QN�2��SJMOÄLI�U-��K���q��O�Oq Å KL½�Ï×S É I���EHM�q2S�Â2± « Å I�UJILQNM�¤�I1EHGJI���I�SJILQNMO�I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S¼IL�f�]��EHM�q2SJK¢��q2QdENGJI £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��SØ��SJU¼EHG�I1qv¤2I�QN���O�x�2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�5���JS��LEHM�q2S_¨K�Eª��Q�EHM�SJ�:��QNq2�æ��S>��Q V M�EHQH��Q W ����SJq2S�MO����� V ��KRMOK5û|å }Ns üÞ±¢Ï×S É IL�LEHM�q2SòÂ2± Ç Å IC�Lq2SJKRMOUJILQENGJI�����KNI%q��,�CSJI���QR� W MOSTENI��2QN� V �OI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_¨T��SJUzq V EH��MOS�EHGJIKNPxI��LM��]����q�QN� q2�JQI�¤2q2����EHM�q2S�M�KdEHq5Eª��Ó�I�M�� Å I Å ��SfE�EHq:q2P�ENMO��MOÄLI.ENGJI�����SJq2SJM������ V ��KRMOK���KNI�U�ENq:QNI�P�QNI�ÁKRI�STE�ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S_± Ï×S É I���EHMOq�S8Â2±ÌÈ Å I5��q2SJKRMOUJILQENGJI��]QNK�ERÁ×q�QNUJILQ%��MO��M�E�q���q2�JQ

Page 34: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

� � ¯ ��P�PJQNqT���ªG_± î I$q V EH��MOS?�8��I�SJILQH����MOÄ�ILU��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q����O��KNKRMO�����.P�ILQREH��Q V ��ENMOq2SENGJI�q�Q W Å GJM��ªG?�Lq2MOS���MOU�I�K Å M�ENG�KREª��SJU]��QRU?PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��EHM�q2SZEHG�I�q2Q W MOS���S���PJP�QNq2PJQRM�Á�ÜEHIØ�OM��zM�E�¨oq V Eª��M�SJI�U VTW Eª��ÓfM�SJ�$ENGJIØIL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2SòP]��QN����ILEHILQ1EHq � ± £ q Å I�¤2I�QL¨�EHG�I��U�¤���STEª���2I:q��dq��JQ1�]QNK�ERÁÃq2QNUJILQ���q2QR���J�¿�zMOK�ENG]��E�M�E1QNI��z��M�SJK��Lq2ST¤2I�QR�2I�STEC��q2Q������*��ÁS�M�EHI1¤������JI�K�q��pENGJI�IL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S�PJ��QH����ILENI�QL¨Jq2SJ� W Pxq2KNKRM V � W UJM�¤2ILQN�2M�SJ�Ø��K.�:QNILKN�J��E.q��S�I���Q�QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��ILK5M�S�EHGJIØ��MO��M�EEHqO� ±�Ï×S É I���EHMOq�S�Â�± Õ Å I Å q2QNÓ>KNq2��IØ��S]��� W EHMO�����IÞÚ����zP��OI�KL±�Ï×S�P]��QREHM����J�O��Q�¨ Å I�KNG�q Å ENG]��E1q�SJI�ÁÃUJMO��I�SJKRMOq2SJ���p� V qv¤�I�Á V ��QNQRMOI�Q î ô�óENGJI�q�Q W MOKC��q2STEH��MOSJILU Å M�ENGJMOSòq2�JQ5� � ¯�Á V ��KRI�U���P�PJQNqT���ªG_± É I���EHMOq�SlÂ2±øÖ$EHILKRENK5EHG�I] IL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�SÛI��f�]��ENMOq2S Å M�EHG÷�ZSf�J��I�QNM������%I�Ú�����PJ�OI�± î I���q�SfENMOSf�JI�M�S É I���EHMOq�SÂ�±è� VTW ��P�PJ� W MOS���EHGJIm]�IL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S¼I��f�]��ENMOq2S�EHqØ���LEH�J���O� W �Lq2SJK�EHQN���LE%��SJU�¤mMOKR�]���OM�Ä�IKRq2��I�KNIL�zM����O��KNKRMO����� Å ��¤2IL����SJ�LENMOq2SJK.��KNKNqm��MO��EHILU Å M�ENG�q2P�ENMO��MOÄ�ILU¼����SJq2SJM������ V ��KRI�KL±Ô*MOS]����� W ¨ Å I���q2S����O��UJI�MOS É I���EHM�q2S�Â2±�� Å M�ENGÛ� KR�J�z�z��Q W q���q2�JQzQNI�KR�J��ENK���SJUl�U�MOKN�L�JKNKRMOq2S$q��p����EH��QNI�QNILKNI���QN�ªG>P��¿��SJKL±

âGã � � ( � 7����z���>� ����� 7������C� ������Ï×S�ENGJMOKdKNIL�LEHM�q2S Å I1KNG]���O�xUJI�QRM�¤2I%EHGJI V ��KNM��1IL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2SzI��f�]��ENMOq2S�K���q2QdENGJI £ ���zM���ENq�ÁS�M¿��Sj\ ��SJUCENGJI¢qw¤�I�QN���O�f�2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�����SJ�LENMOq2Sy]�±*°�GJI¢MOU�I��.MOKp��K,��q2�O��q Å KL½ î I¢KREH��QREÅ M�EHGò��SòMOSJM�EHMO���,KNILE5q��d����S�q2SJMO�������Lqbq2QRUJMOSJ��EHILK�û|å }Hs ü�¨ Å GJM��ªG8U�I�SJq�ENI���S W �2�Oq V ���

Page 35: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

QRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S¦q��*PJG]��KRI5KRP]����I�¨x��SJU$UJqzS�q�ESJI��LI�KNKN��QNM�� W QRIL��I�Q�ENqzq2QRUJMOSJ��Q W P�q2KRM�ÁENMOq2S¼��SJU���q2��I�STEH���¦¨fQNILKNPxI���EHM�¤�I�� W û�SJq2SbÁÃ�2�Oq V ���]QNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2SJK�����S�����KNq Å q2QRÓx¨��K:�Oq2SJ�@��K Å I-QNIL�¼��MOS Å I���� Å M�EHG�MOS ENGJI-QNI���MOq2Sðq��PJGJ��KNI-KNPJ����I�EHG�I W UJILKN�LQNM V I�±D%S>IÞÚJ���zPJ��I5q���EHGJM�K%M�K����LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I1¤���QNM¿� V �OILK.��q�Q���K W KRENI�� Å GJMO�ªG�����S>U�MOKNKRqb�LM�Á�ÜEHI�±�D%�LENMOq2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I�¤���QNM¿� V �OILKKRGJq2�J��U Å q2QNÓ$��K%��¤�����MOU-QNILPJQNILKNILSfEH��EHM�q2S���K%�Oq2S��¼��K

Å IØQNIL�¼��M�S Å I��O� V IL�Oq Å ��S W UJMOKRKNqm��MO��EHM�q2S>EHG�QNI�KRGJq2��U|ü�± î I:�Lq2STEHMOSf�Jq��JKN� W UJI���q2QN�ENGJMOKCK W K�EHI��#¤mM¿�$�¦KRI�QNM�I�KCq���M�S��]SJM�EHI�KRMO�z�����2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�-���JSJ�LENMOq2S�K�±�°�GJIzQNI�KR�J��E5MOKENG]��E5q2�JQC����S�q2SJMO�����4QNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2SZMOKCIL¤�q2��¤mM�SJ� Å M�EHG8ENMO��I�¨*��SJUZM�K�UJI�SJq�EHI�U VTWû � ¦ }H¡ ¦�ü���E�ENMO��Io�Þ± D�K.q2�JQ.����SJq2SJM�������P]��M�Q�IL¤2q���¤2ILK�¨]EHG�I�����SJ�LENMOq2S]���oUJILP�ILSJUJI�S���Iq��x\ q2S¼ENGJI�����SJq2S�MO�����xPJ��MOQ¢�ªG]��SJ��I�K�±4Ï×S���UJUJM�ENMOq2So¨fENGJI1qv¤2ILQH�����|�2I�SJILQH��ENMOSJ�5���JSJ��ÁENMOq2SM].û|å }H¡�� �Rü4��q2SJS�I��LENMOSJ��ENGJI�M�SJM�ENM¿���pû�å }Hs ü¢EHq5EHGJI1�L�JQNQRI�STECû � ¦ }H¡ ¦�ü¢I�¤2q2��¤2I�K��KÅ I����˱ØÏ×SòKN� V KRI���EHMOq�SùÂ2± «b±�Â2¨ Å I�UJI�QRM�¤�I�ENGJI�� � ¯��2qv¤2I�QRSJMOS��$ENGJIzI�¤2q2����EHM�q2S@q���\��I�SJILQH��ENI�U VTW ENGJMOK�P�G]��KNI¼KNP]���LI�UJIL��q�QN�z��EHM�q2S_±>Ï×SðKR� V KRI��LENMOq2S÷Â2± «b± «b¨ Å I�UJI�QRM�¤�IENGJIC� � ¯ù�2qv¤2ILQNSJM�SJ�:EHGJI�IL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S$q���]�±

ó�I���q2QNIC��q�SfENMOSf�JM�SJ�J¨]M�E.KRGJq2�J��U V I�P�q2M�STEHI�U$q2��EEHGJ��E���UJqmI�KSJq�EQNI���I�Q.EHqØEHM��zIM�S�EHGJIØq2QRUJMOS]��Q W KNI�S�KNI�¨ V ��ECMOK�QN��EHG�I�Q���UJIL��q�QN�z��EHM�q2S�q2Q�GJq2��q�ENq2P W P]��QN����ILEHILQ�±Ï×Sï�����LE�¨���q2Q�ENGJI8KRP�IL��M��]�ò��q�QN� q���q2�JQ$� � ¯�Á V ��KRI�U ��PJPJQRqT���ªG û Å GJMO�ªG Å MO��� V IP�QNI�KRI�STEHILU�MOS É IL�LENMOq2S@Â2±øÇTü�¨�M�E.�z� W¼V I�KRGJq Å S¦EHGJ��E ��G]��K��SJM�ENK�q�� í ��� n��'î l ±

+

Page 36: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

���! "�#� $&%('*),+.-0/1'(23'�45-0687:9<;>=?/#)@-A'*2B/#;>2§ q�SJKNM�UJI�Q���S���Q V M�EHQN��Q W KRILE�q��¢����SJq2SJM������p��qmq2QRUJMOS]�ÜEHI�KL±1D�E1ENMO��Im�Þ¨ Å I�ÊÌQNIØ�ÜE1K W KÒÁENI��#û � ¦ }H¡ ¦�ü�±¢D�E.EHM��zI¯�HéDC��Þ¨ Å I�ÊøQRI��ÜE%K W KREHIL�õû � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦jü�±4°�GJI�KRI���QRI���q2SbÁS�I��LENI�U VfW ��S-MOS��]S�M�EHILKNM��¼���x�2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�����JSJ��EHMOq�SGFzû � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüUp � ¦IH ¡ ¦ ý0E ¦zéC��¢�zû � ¦ }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüÞ± °�GJI�QRIL��q2QRI�¨

� ¦ ý0E ¦Sp � ¦=éJC��,K ü �zû � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü û�Â�± ÇTü

¡ ¦Hp ¡ ¦ ý0E ¦=éJC��,KML��zû � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü û�Â�±øÈfü

KRq�ENq:�]QNK�ERÁ×q�QNUJILQ�¨ Å ICq V Eª��M�S_¨

� ¦Hp � ¦ ý0E ¦ � CX�,K ü �zû � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü û�Â�± Õ2ü

¡ ¦Sp ¡ ¦ ý0E ¦QéNC��,KML��zû � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü û�Â�± ÖTü

°�G�I £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��Sò��ECEHM��zIG�2éOCX��M�K5ENGJI�QRIL��q2QRI¼QNIL�¿��ENI�U ENq>EHG�I £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S@��EENMO��Io��¤mMO��¨\ðû � ¦ ý0E ¦ }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �HéJC��Rü p \ðû � ¦ }H¡ ¦ � �Rü

p \ðû � ¦ ý0E ¦ � C��,K ü �¼û � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦zéC��,KML��zû � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü � �Rüp \ðû � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSéJC��LûPK ü \QHRKML�� �

KML�\SHTK ü ��ü û�Â�±è�2üÂ�¬

Page 37: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��SJU¦KRqJ¨ �K\�=� p�K ü \QHRK�L�� � KML�\SHRK ü � p � ë \ } �"ì û�Â�±��Tü

Å G�MO�ªG$����S V I�QRI�Á Å QRM�EREHI�S$��KL¨ �`\�=� é ë \ } �"ì p ¬ û�Â�±�+Tü

°�Gf�JKL¨�EHG�MOKhIL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S5�2ILSJI�QN��EHILK��.q2SJIÞÁ×P]��QH����ILENI�Q_������MO� W ë \ðû � }H¡�� �Rü�ì¢q�� £ ����MO�ÆÁENq2SJMO��SJK�¨ Å GJq2KNIòIL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�Sï��SJUJI�Q-EHG�I ����EHM�q2S÷q���ENGJI@MOS��]S�M�EHILKNM��¼���%�2I�S�I�QH�ÜEHMOS������SJ�LENMOq2SJK��¼û � }H¡�� �RüdMOK��2M�¤�I�S VTW ENGJI�PJQNI�¤mMOq2�JK�IL�f�]��EHM�q2Sòûj¯ �|±%û�Â2±�+TüRü�±�ÏÃE.KRGJq2�J��U���OKNq V I�P�q2M�STEHI�U�q2��E�ENG]��E�¯4�|±.ûÒÂ2±�+TüpM�K*SJq�EHGJM�SJ�1��q2QNI4EHG]��S�EHGJIdKREª�ÜEHI���I�STE�ENG]��E@\M�K�M�Sf¤���QRM¿��STE%�JSJUJILQ�EHG�I�����S�q2SJMO�����,EHQH��SJKR��q2QR�¼�ÜEHMOq�S¦M�SJUJ�J�LI�U VTW F�ûUC \V�WC�� p ¬Tü�¨

Å G�MO�ªG���q2���Oq Å K¢��QRq2� EHGJI������LE�ENG]��EXFÙMOK��5EHM��zIÞÁ×M�SJUJI�PxI�S�UJI�STE�����SJq2S�MO�����xENQH��SJK���q2Q�Á�z��ENMOq2S í «��Yîj±

Ô]q2Q Å G]�ÜE���q2�O��q Å K�MOS�EHGJM�K��ªG]��P�ENI�Q.M�E Å MO�O��PJQNqv¤�I5�Lq2ST¤2I�S�MOI�STEEHqØQNILPJQNILKNILSfEEHG�IU W SJ���zM���K�M�S@Ô|q��JQNM�I�Q1KRP]����I�±:°*q�ENGJMOK�ILSJU_¨p��KNKR�J��IØENG]��Em\BM�K�P�ILQNMOqmUJM���MOS@I����ªGY   Å M�EHGòPxI�QNM�qbU[Z@ Ã±�°�G�I�S Å I¼KRG]���O� �ªG�qbq2KRI_� ENq>����KNq V I�PxI�QNM�qbU�MO�:MOSòI����ªG Y  Å M�EHG�P�ILQNM�qbUJZ@ Ã± � I��]SJI ¹ p\Z�k]H^H^H_Z>`�¨���S�Uù�OI�EMaæUJI�S�q�EHI¦��Sl��Q V M�EHQH��Q W � ÁU�MO��I�SJKRMOq2S]��� V qvÚ�q���KRMOUJI���I�SJ��ENGJKXZ�k } r3r3r } Z>`�± °�GJILS_¨

\ðû � }H¡�� �Rü�p ¹<b#c \ c û ¡M� �Rü,� lÊþ'  cRd L û�Â2±�Âv¬Tü

Â�Â

Page 38: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Å G�I�QNI\ c û ¡M� �Rüfe:gih�C � \ðû � }H¡�� �Rü,� ½ lÊþJ  cRd L û�Â2±�Â2Âwü

��SJU¦KRMO��MO�O��QN� W ��q2Q°�¼û � }H¡�� �Rü�±°�GJI����J���oIL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S$U�q2SJI���q2��Pxq2SJI�STE�Á Å MOKRI��2M�¤�I�K�¨

¹ b1c �K\ c�Q� � lÊþ'  cRd L p Â

¹ l û bjc ¸ K ü \ c ¸k� lÊþJ  c ¸ d L HÜ«Rl � b c ¸ ¸]m ð ð � c ¸ ¸n� lÊþ'  c ¸ ¸ d L �«Rl � bjc ¸ m ð \ c ¸ � lÊþJ  c ¸ d L H b c ¸ ¸ K ü � c ¸ ¸ � lÊþ'  c ¸ ¸ d L ü û�Â2±�Âw«2ü

Å G�MO�ªG$�2M�¤�I�K�¨

b1c �K\ c�=� � lÊþJ  cRd L p «Rl �¹ bc ¸ « c ¸ ¸ í û m ð ð H^K ü \ c ¸ ü�� c ¸ ¸ � û m ð HRK ü � c ¸ ¸ ü¢\ c ¸ îo� lÊþ'  º c ¸ ý c ¸ ¸ ¿ d L

p «Rl �¹ b1cpbqc ¸ í û m ð HRK ü \ c ½ c ¸ ü�� c ¸ �ûNû m � m ð ürHTK ü � c ¸ ü�\ c ½ c ¸ îk� lÊþJ  cRd L û�Â2±�ÂvÇTü

� �JQ��Lq2��P�q2S�I�STERÁ Å MOKNI�I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S-MOK�EHG�I�QNI���q2QNI�¨�K\ c�=� p «Rl � ¹ bsc ¸ í û m ð HRK ü \ c ½ c ¸ ü¢� c ¸ � ûRû m � m ð ürHRK ü � c ¸ ü�\ c ½ c ¸ î û�Â2±�Â�Èfü

þq�EHI ENG]��EhEHG�I¢I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S�PJQNILKNILQR¤2ILK�EHG�I¢M�STEHI���QH��ENMOq2S���MO��M�EHK�q��bq2�JQhq2QRMO�2M�S]����K W KREHIL�¦±°�Gf�JK.EHG�I�ENq2Pxq2�Oq2� W q��pEHG�ICq�QNMO��MOS]���xPJG]��KNICKNP]���LI5M�K�PJQNILKNILQR¤2ILU_±

D%K5���]SJ��� SJq�ENI���q2Q1EHGJM�K�KN� V KNI���EHM�q2S_¨pM�E�KRGJq2�J��U V I:�zILSTEHMOq�SJI�U�EHGJ��E�UJI���QNI�ILKq��p��QRI�ILUJq2� ��q�Q Å GJMO�ªG&Z@ ,MOK��JSJM�ENI1����S V I1EHQRI���ENI�U-MOS-��S$����EHM�q2SbÁÒ��SJ�2�OI.��q2QR�¼����MOKR�

Âv«

Page 39: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

M�S Å GJM��ªGpZ@ "p Â�¨ Å GJMO��I¦U�I��2QRI�I�K¼q�����QNILI�UJq2� ��q2Q Å GJM��ªGtZ� Lp � GJ�v¤�I>EHG�I�MOQ�Lq2QNQRI�KRP�q2S�UJMOSJ��Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ�KN�J��K.QNI�P��¿���LI�U VfW MOSTEHIL�2QH����K�±

���! "�! $&%('*),+.-0/1'(23'�45-0687vuw7x287zy{;r-0/,28|?}B+B28~�-{/1'*2°�G�I�� V qv¤2IdENQNI���EH��I�STEpEHI����OK,�JKpGJq Å EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S1I�¤2q2��¤2ILK��JSJUJILQ*ENGJI����LEHM�q2SCq��ENGJIMOS��]S�M�EHILKNM��¼���b�2I�S�I�QH�ÜEHMOS��C���JS��LEHM�q2SJKL¨ V �bE�M�E EHI����OK4�JK¢SJq�ENGJMOSJ��q��oEHGJIIL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2Sq���].û|å }H¡�� �RüÞ¨fENGJIqw¤�I�QN���O�x�2I�S�I�QH�ÜEHMOS��C���JS��LEHM�q2Sz��QRq2�ÀEHG�I�MOS�M�EHMO���JK W K�EHIL�âû�å }Hs ü ENqû � ¦ }H¡ ¦�ü�± î I�KNG]���O�_UJI���� Å M�ENG�EHGJM�K�SJq Å ±

D�E%EHMO��I4�Þ¨�q2��Q��2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�z���JS��LEHM�q2S>M�K¯].û�å }H¡�� �Rü�¨|Eª��ÓfM�SJ�¼�JK��QNq2�/û�å }Hs ü.ENqû � ¦ }H¡ ¦�ü�±-D�E5EHMO��I"��éOC��Þ¨�q2�JQ5�2I�S�I�QH�ÜEHMOS��$���JS��LEHM�q2SZM�KL].û|å }H¡M� �@étC��Rü�¨�EH��ÓfMOSJ���K*��QNq�� û|å }Hs ü_EHq:û � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦�üÞ± î I�ÓfSJq Å EHGJ��E�û � ¦ }H¡ ¦�ü,��SJU-û � ¦ ý0E ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦jü,��QNI�Lq2SJSJIL�LENI�U VfW ��S�MOS��]S�M�EHILKNM��¼���w�2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�����JSJ��EHM�q2S � ¦1H ¡ ¦ ý0E ¦|éBCX�¢�zû � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü�±î I����JK�E%GJ�v¤�I�¨

s p �`]�Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ � �Rü�p �`]�Kå û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �HéJC��Rü û�Â2±�ÂwÕ2ü

þq Å ¨�`]�Kå û|å }N¡ ¦ � �Rü p �`]�Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦=éJC�� �K�� � û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü � �Rüp �`]�Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé � l ]� ¡ �Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH �K�� � û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C��

Â�Ç

Page 40: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

p �`]�Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé �K�� � û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH � l ]�Kå�� ¡ û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C��p �`]�Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé �K�� � û � û�å }H¡ ¦ � �Rü }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH � ��Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C��p �`]�Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé �K�� � û � û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH � ��`å û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C��p �`]�Kå û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé �K��Kå û � û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C�� û�Â2±�ÂvÖTü

°�G�ICENQH��SJK���q2QN�z��ENMOq2S V ILE Å I�I�S¦EHGJICKNIL��q2SJU>��SJU$EHGJM�QNU$�OMOS�I�K�MOS-EHG�I�� V qv¤2ICUJI�QRM�¤��ÜÁENMOq2S Å ��Kq V EH��MOSJILU VfW K Å M�EN�ªGJMOS�����QRq2�æ�Lq2�O�J��S�¤2IL�LEHq�QNK.EHqØQNq Å ¤�I���EHq2QRK�±

î IC���OKRq�GJ�v¤�I�¨�`]�Kå û|å }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �HéJC��Rü2p �`]�Kå û|å }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé � l ]�Q�#�Kå û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü#C�� û�Â2±�ÂY�2ü

��SJU¦KRqJ¨ � l ]�Q�#�Kå p �`��Kå û � û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü û�Â2±�ÂZ�Tüî IC���OKRq�GJ�v¤�I�¨

� ¦�p �`]� ¡ û|å }H¡ ¦ � �Rüp �`]� ¡ û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦QéNC�� �K�� � û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü � �Rüp �`]� ¡ û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé � l ]� ¡ l û|å }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH �`�� � û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C�� û�Â2±�ÂZ+Tü

��SJU

� ¦ ý0E ¦�p �`]� ¡ û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �SéNC��RüÂ�È

Page 41: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

p �`]� ¡ û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé � l ]�=�#� ¡ û|å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C�� û�Â2± «�¬Tü

��SJU

� ¦ ý0E ¦�p � ¦Qé �K�� ¡ û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C��p �`]� ¡ û|å }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé � l ]� ¡ l û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH �K�� � û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü,C��Hé�`�� ¡ û � ¦ }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü#C�� û�Â2± «bÂwü

��SJU¦KRqJ¨� l ]�Q�#� ¡ û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü p � l ]� ¡ l û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH �K�� � û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé�K�� ¡ û � ¦ }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rüp �K�� � û � û�å }H¡ ¦ � �Rü }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH � �� ¡ û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé�K�� ¡ û � û|å }N¡ ¦ � �Rü }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rüp �K�� � û � û�å }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RürH � �� ¡ û|å }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �RüSé�K�� ¡ û � û|å }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rüp �K�� ¡ û � û|å }N¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rü }H¡ ¦ ý0E ¦ � �Rüf������ � û�Â2± «2«2ü

� SJ�LI4���T��M�S_¨w��K Å M�EH�ªG���QNq2����q2���J��S�EHq.QNq Å ¤2IL�LEHq�QNK,�2M�¤�I�K,�JK_ENGJI I��f�]����M�E W�V I�E Å ILI�SENGJI��]QNK�E%��SJU$KNI��Lq2SJU¦�OMOS�I�K�q��pEHG�I5� V qv¤2ICUJILQNM�¤���ENMOq2So±�°�GJI�QRIL��q2QRI�¨ Å I5KRI�I�EHG]�ÜE�¨� l ]�Kå��=� p �K��`å û �`]� ¡ û�å }H¡�� �Rü }N¡M� �Rü û�Â2± «�ÇTü

ÂvÕ

Page 42: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��SJU � l ]� ¡ �=� p �`�� ¡ û �`]� ¡ û|å }H¡�� �Rü }H¡M� �Rü ������ � û�Â2± «�Èfü

KRq Å I�q V EH��MOS_¨ �`]�=� û|å }H¡�� �Rü@pò�¼û ��]� ¡ û|å }H¡M� �Rü }H¡�� �RüHéN�¼û1�Rü û�Â2± «2Õ2ü

É MOSJ�LI Å I�q2SJ� W ����QRIz� V q2�bE�û � ¦ }H¡ ¦�ü���SJUòSJq�E5� V q2��Ej]�M�EHKRI����Ò¨ Å Iz����SòUJQNq2P@EHG�I�zû��RüdENI�QR�¦¨]�2M�¤mMOSJ�:�JKL¨J�]S]����� W ¨��]�Q� pÇ�¼û �`]� ¡ }H¡�� �Rü û�Â2± «�ÖTü

âGã�� � ( ���������9 �î I Å ��SfEd��S���P�PJQNqT���ªG�ENG]��E4��MOSJM��zM�Ä�I�K,EHG�IU�I�PxI�SJUJILSJ��I%q��»\ q2S � ±�°�GJI��q2S�UJM�ÁENMOq2SCEHG]�ÜE2\ V I�MOSJU�I�PxI�SJUJILSTE q�� � MOK*I��f�JM�¤����OI�STE�ENq�EHG�I�¤���SJMOKRGJMOS���q��]ENGJI�SJq2S�Ä�I�QRqÔ]q2��QNMOILQ%�Lq2��P�q2S�I�STEHK \ c û ¡ ü�± î I�ENGJI�QRIL��q2QRI�KNILI�Ó$EHq���MOSJM��zM�Ä�I1ENGJI�UJILP�ILSJUJI�S���Iq���\âq2S � VTW �ªGJqmq2KNM�SJ�"� MOS�KR�J�ªG>� Å � W ENG]��E�ENGJIMæ \ c û ¡�� �RüZæT��QRI1��q2STENMOSf�Jq2�JKR� WU�I���QRI���KRMOSJ�Ø��q2Q.����� mJ�p ¬�±

D�EzKNq2��I-EHMO��IM�Þ¨ Å I>����S Å QRM�EHIO\ðû � }H¡�� �Rü_p \ ºèç ¿ û ¡�� �RüUéA\ º k|¿ û � }H¡�� �Rü�±°�G�I�MOUJI���MOK�ENG]��EG\ º�ç ¿ �Lq2STEª��M�SJK�ENGJI�PJMOIL��I�q��ENGJI £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��S Å GJM��ªGðMOK�q2S�� W

Â�Ö

Page 43: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

U�I�PxI�SJUJILSTE�q2S ¡ ¨]��SJUO\ º k|¿ ��q2STEH��MOSJK�ENGJI�QNI��z��M�SJUJI�QL±�°�GJILS_¨�K\�=� p ûPK ü \ º�ç ¿ éDK ü \ º k|¿ ürHTK�LU� � KML2\ º k|¿ HRK ü �

p K ü \ ºèç ¿ HRK�L��­éDK ü \ º k|¿ HRKML�� � K�L�\ º k|¿ HRK ü �p K ü \ ºèç ¿ HRK�L�� � ë \ º k|¿ } �Gì û�Â2± «��2ü

Ï×S ENGJI¼��MO��M�E�q��.�$�]QRKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q5P�ILQREH��Q V ��ENMOq2S8q2SZ��SZMOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��So¨ENGJI�QNIL�OIL¤���STE.IL�m�J��EHM�q2S¦M�K�¨

�`\�=� p�K ü \ º�ç ¿ HRKML2� û�Â2± «��Tü

Ï×S¦Ô]q2�JQRMOI�Q�KNP]���LI�¨]EHG�MOK V I���q��zILK�¨�K\�=� p Â

¹ b,c �K\ c�Q� � lÊþ'  cTd L pwK ü \ º�ç ¿ H «Rl �¹ b#c m � c � lÊþ'  cTd L û�Â2± «�+Tü

KRq �K\ c�=� p�«Rl � û m HRK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü�� c û�Â2±øÇ2¬Tü

°�G�I�S ���I� ÿ�I�� ¦ pÅ\ c � ÿ���� ¦ é \ c ������ ¦ p)«Tl � û m HWK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü�û \ c � c � \ c � c ü�±1°�GJILQNIÞÁ��q�QNI�¨fM�SzEHG�I�]QRKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q¢�OM��zM�E�¨�ENGJI���QH��UJM�I�STERÁÃUJI�KR��ILSfE�PJQNILKN�LQNMOPbEHMOq�S���q2Q4��MOSJM��zM�Ä�M�SJ�æ \ c æ l p \ c \ c } m��p ¬�MOK�ENq?KRILE � c p «Rl � û m HIK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü¢\ c ± °�GJI�S � c p� «Rl � û m HTK ü \ ºèç ¿ ü \ c ¨JKNq�MOS�EHG�I��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.��MO��M�E Å I�q V EH��MOS�ENG]��E�¨�K\ c \ c�=� p � ��l l û m HRK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü l \ c \ c û�Â2±øÇ�Âwü

ÂZ�

Page 44: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Å G�MO�ªG M�K5�L�OI���QN� W SJIL�T��EHM�¤2I�±-Ô|q�QCK�EHQRq2SJ�2ILQ5PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��EHM�q2SJKL¨pENGJMOK�MOKCSJq$�Oq2S��2I�Q�EHG�I��QH��UJM�I�STERÁÃUJI�KR��ILSfE�PJQRI�KR��QNM�P�EHM�q2S_± £ q Å IL¤2ILQ�¨¢��q2Q�SJI���QN� W MOSTENI��2QN� V �OIzK W KRENI���K¦û�EHG�Iq�SJI�K�q���MOSTEHILQNILKRE�ENq>�JK�M�S8ENGJMOK5�ªG]��P�ENI�Qªü�EHGJIzP�ILQREH��Q V ��ENMOq2S8KNGJq��J�OUZK�EHM��O� V IzKN���¿Á�J��MOILSTEH� W Å I���Ó�ENG]��EØEHG�I>� V qv¤2I¦�ªGJq2MO�LI$��q�QØ� c Å MO����KNGJQRMOSJÓZENGJIO\ c \ c } m��põ¬�±°�G�I�QNI���q2QNI�¨ Å I�Eª��Ó�I�¨

� c p�«Rl � û m HRK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü¢\ c û�Â2±øÇT«2ü

°�G�MOK.�2M�¤�I�KL¨

�¼û � }H¡ ü p ¹ b,c � c û ¡ ü,� lÊþ'  cRd L p Â

¹ «Rl � K ü \ ºèç ¿ H b1c m \ c � lÊþ'  cTd Lp «Rl �

¹ K ü \ º�ç ¿ H «Rl � KML b,c \ c � lÊþ'  cRd L

p K ü \ º�ç ¿ HRK�L�\ û�Â2±øÇ2ÇTü

KRqÀ�¼û � }H¡ ü"p�K ü \ ºèç ¿ H�K�LU\ p�K ü \ º�ç ¿ H�KML�\ º k|¿ ±8þ%q�EHI¼ENG]��E�ENGJI-Ô]q2�JQNM�I�QIÞÚbP]��SJKRMOq2S�q���� M�Sf¤�q2��¤�I�K�ENI�QN��K:q��.EHG�I���q2QN� m H�K ü \ ºèç ¿ ± D m ��q2Q Å GJMO�ªG m HK ü \ º�ç ¿ pâ¬@MOKØ���2ILSJI�QN���OM�Ä�ILU�QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI>�ÜE ¡ ±ð°�GJI-M�SfENI��2QN� V M��OM�E W q��o\ º�ç ¿ MOKU�I�KRENQNq W ILU VTW EHG�ICQRI�KRq2S]��STEEHI�QR�zK�M�S·\ º k|¿ ±� �JQ�IL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S�UJqmI�K�SJq�EØ��q2QR�¼����� W UJMOK�EHM�SJ�2�JM�KNG V I�E Å ILI�SÛQNILKNq2SJ��SJ��ILK�¨�SJI���Q�Á

QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�KL¨o��S�U¦SJq�SbÁ×QRI�KNq�S]��SJ�LI�K�±d°�GJICIL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S-MOK.UJq�SJI�q2S$ENGJICI�STEHM�QNI £ ����MO�ÆÁENq2SJMO��S Å M�EHGJq���E1��S W EHILQN��K%S�I��2��I��LENI�U_± £ q Å IL¤�I�Q�¨_ENGJIC���Oq�KNI�Q���ENI�QN� M�KENq V I�MOS��QRI�KRq2S]��STE�¨JENGJI�KN�z�����OI�Q4EHG�I���q2QRQNI�KRP�q�SJUJMOS��zÔ]q2��QNMOILQ��Lq2�zPxq2SJILSTE.q��g��¨]��SJU-KNq�EHG�I

Â3�

Page 45: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��I�KRK.ENG]��E�ENI�QN�æMOK.��Í�I���EHI�U VTW EHGJI�I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S_±Ï×S>ENGJI5�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q�OM��zM�E�¨Q\ ºèç ¿ û ¡�� �Rü�UJM�Í�I�QRK%��QRq2��\ º�ç ¿ û ¡M� ¬Tü VTW �z�Lq2QNQRI���EHMOq�S

Å G�MO�ªG�MOK���E���q2KRE%�]QNK�ERÁÃq2QNUJILQ1MOSê\ º k|¿ ±�°�GJILQNIL��q�QNI�¨oM�� Å I:�JKNI"\ ºèç ¿ û ¡�� ¬Tü.MOSJK�EHI���Uq��L\ º�ç ¿ û ¡�� �Rü�MOS÷q2�JQ-PJQRI�KN�LQNM�P�EHM�q2SÛ��q2Q-�ªGJqbq�KNMOS��6�BM�Sï¯4�|±âû�Â2±øÇ2ÇTüÞ¨ Å I8�2I�E¦�U�MOKN�LQNILP]��SJ� W q��o��E4�zq�KRE4KNIL��q2S�UbÁ×q2QRUJI�Q4M�SG\ º k|¿ ¨TKNq�EHGJ��E EHGJI�E Å q���q2QN�����¿��ENMOq2SJK���QNIIL�f�JM�¤�����I�STE1EHq��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�QL± É MOSJ�LI:q2�JQ1PJQRI�KR��QNM�P�EHM�q2S���q2Q%�ªGJqbq�KNMOS�� � Å ��K�UJI�QRM�¤2ILU��QRq2� EHGJI��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q���MO��M�E.q��4ENGJI�IL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S�q��U\ ¨ Å I:KNILI�EHG]��E1M�E1M�K1I��f�JM�¤����OILSfEENqØ�JKNIj\ º�ç ¿ û ¡M� ¬2üdq2Q°\ º�ç ¿ û ¡M� �Rü�MOS$¯ �x±�û�Â�± Ç2Ç2ü�±4Ô�M�S]���O� W ¨mq2�JQ���p ¬ £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��SM�K��JKN�J���O� W �2M�¤2I�S���K·\ðû�å }Hs ü�p \ ç û s ü éá¹zû|å }Ns üÞ¨ Å GJI�QRID\ ç MOK�ENGJI8ÄLI�QRq�EHGbÁq�QNUJILQ�¨�M�SfENI��2QN� V ��I £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_¨,��SJUƹ MOKCEHGJIzP�ILQREH��Q V ��ENMOq2So± î I¼����SZI�ÚmENQH����EENGJI m p ¬CÔ]q2�JQRMOI�Q4�Lq2�zPxq2SJILSTE�q��x¹�¨ Å QNM�ENMOSJ�j¹�û�å }Hs ü�p ¹ ç û s üzé��¹¼û�å }Hs ü�± °�GJILS\Zû � }H¡�� ¬TüÛpò\ ç û ¡ ü*é�¹ ç û ¡ üïé �¹�û ��}H¡ üÞ¨2KNq1ENG]��EU\ º�ç ¿ û ¡�� ¬Tü�p�\ ç û ¡ üïé�¹ ç û ¡ ü�¨��SJU \ º k|¿ û ��}H¡M� ¬Tü�p �¹�û � }H¡ ü�± °�GJILQNI���q2QNI�¨]SJq�EHI�ENG]��E.MOS�ENGJI��]QNK�ERÁ×q�QNUJILQ��MO��M�EdM�EM�K�IL�m��M�¤����OILSTE�EHq���KNI"\ º�ç ¿ û ¡�� ¬Tü�q2Q \ ç û ¡ üM�S>EHG�I�PJQNILKN�LQNMOPbEHMOq�S>��q2Q��ªG�qbq2KRMOSJ�M��±� SJ�LI:���T��MOS_¨|EHGJM�K���I���S�K%EHGJ��E1M�E1MOKI��f�JM�¤����OILSfE�EHq��JKRI"\ º�ç ¿ û ¡M� ¬Tü.q�Q¯\ ç û ¡ ü�±%Ï×SÅ GJ��E���q2�O��q Å K \ º�ç ¿ û ¡M� �RüÞ¨S\ º�ç ¿ û ¡M� ¬Tü�¨h��SJUt\ ç û ¡ ü Å MO�O�����O� V I:U�I�SJq�ENI�U VTW \ º�ç ¿ ¨q�Q \ º�ç ¿ û ¡ üÞ± î GJILS8QRI��f�JMOQRI�U_¨ Å I Å MO����KNPxI��LM�� W EHq Å GJMO�ªGt\ º�ç ¿ Å IØ��QNI:QRIL��ILQNQNM�SJ�J±ÿ4ILQ W q�� EHI�So¨Jq2SJI�q��pEHGJI�ENGJQNILIC�ªG�q2MO�LI�K Å MO���oQNILKN�J��E.MOS$����q2QN���J�¿��ENMOq2Szq��pEHGJIC� � ¯ K

Å G�MO�ªG$MOK���q�SJKNM�UJI�QN� V � W KNMO��PJ��I�Q�ENq�M��zP��OI���I�STEdEHG]��S-EHG�ICq�EHGJILQNK�±Â3+

Page 46: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

î I1��q�SJ�����JUJI�ENGJMOKdKNI���EHM�q2S VTW UJILQNM�¤bM�SJ�5ENGJI�� � ¯ð�2qv¤2ILQNSJM�SJ��EHGJI�IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2Szq��]�¨J��M�¤2ILS¦q��JQ�PJQNILKN�LQNMOPbEHMOq�S$��q2Q��ªG�qbq2KRMOSJ���ر î I�G]��¤�I�¨�`]�=� û|å }N¡M� �Rü�pò�¼û � û|å }N¡M� �Rü }H¡�� �Rü@pwK ü \ º�ç ¿ HRKML�\ðû � û|å }H¡M� �Rü }H¡�� �Rü�û�Â2±øÇ�Èfü

þq Å ¨ Å I�ÓmS�q Å EHGJ��E \ðû � }H¡�� �Rü pÅ\Zû|å }Hs�� ¬Tü pÞ\ðû|å } ������ û�å }H¡�� �Rü � ¬Tü�± î I:���OKNqGJ�v¤�I�¨ ��Kå p �� � H � ��Kå p �� � � l ]�Kå�� ¡ û�Â2±øÇTÕ2ü

É Å M�EH�ªG�MOSJ�:��QNq��æQNq Å EHq���q2���J�zS�¤�I���EHq2QRK%�2M�¤2ILK �� � p � ö �� ü � � �� L ¨|��SJU-KNq�¨�� � p)û � l ]� ¡ �Kå ü ½ k ��Kå û�Â2±øÇ2ÖTü

��SJU¦KRq:EHGJI�U W S]����MO�LK.q���]�MOK��2qv¤�I�QNS�I�U VTW ¨�`]�=� p �K\ º�ç ¿� ¡ Hmû � l ]� ¡ �`å ü ½ k �K\ðû|å }��J�� � � ¬2ü�Kå ������ ü û�Â2±øÇX�2ü

þq Å ¨ ��� º � «s����1��� ç ¿� � ������ ü p ���� � ������^� û|å } ���� � � ¬2ü�é ���� � ������ � û|å } ���� � � ¬2ü�H � ö �� � ö ± � SJ��I4���2��MOS_¨vK Å M�EN�ªGbÁM�SJ�:��QNq2� QNq Å ENqØ��q2���J�zS�¤�I���EHq2QRK��2M�¤2I�KL¨�K\ðû�å }������� � ¬Tü�Kå ������ ü p �K\�Kå ������ � û�å } �`]�Kå � ¬TüSé � l ]�Kå l �K\� s ������ � û|å } ��]�Kå � ¬Tü û�Â2±øÇ��Tü

þq�EHIzEHG]��E�KNMOS���I \ðû�å }Hs�� ¬TüCM�K�KNM��zP�� W q2�JQ�M�SJM�ENM¿��� £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S_¨,EHGJM�K:� � ¯Ù��q2Q] M�ST¤2q2��¤2I�KL] q2SJ� W ± î I¼UJq¦SJq�E5SJI�ILU EHG�IzI�¤2q2����EHM�q2S q���\ M�S8q2QRUJI�Q�EHq¦�2ILECEHG�II�¤2q2����EHM�q2S-q��@]�±

«�¬

Page 47: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

°�GJI�Sf�J��I�QRMO�����_IL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S�q��@]�MOK�U�I�KN�LQNM V ILU¦M�S�D�PJPxI�SJU�M�Ú�D5± É M�SJ��I1ENGJI�����KRI��q�Q���Q V M�EHQN��Q W ����S�q2SJMO������P]��MOQNK�M�K�G]��SJU��OI�UòKNM��zM��¿��QR� W ¨ Å IØUJq-SJq�EC�2M�¤�I:Sf�J�zILQNM������U�ILEª��MO�OKd��q2Q�EHGJIm\ºIL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S$M�S�EHGJM�K��ªG]��P�ENI�Q�±

âGã#� � ( � Íl��34*�*+���34<���33����� ���

Ô]QRq2� q2�JQ��ªGJq�MO��I�q���� M�S¼EHGJI�PJQNI�¤bM�q2�JK�KRI���EHMOq�S_¨JM�E¢��q2���Oq Å KdENG]��E�M�S¼EHG�I��OMO��M�E4q��p��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��EHM�q2S�q2S¦��S-MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_¨

�`\ c�=� p � ÈWl l û m HRK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü l \ c û�Â2±øÇ�+Tü

� �JQ��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q�KRq2�O�bEHMOq�S W M�I���UJK�\ c û ¡M� �Rü�pÇ\ c û ¡M� ¬2ü�I�ÚbP í � ÈWl l û m H^K ü \ º�ç ¿ ü l � î˱þq�EHI�ENG]��E ENGJI��zq�QNI�SJq�SbÁ×QRI�KNq�S]��STE¢�1EHI�QR�¦¨2ENGJI�����K�EHI�Q�ENGJI�I�ÚbPxq2SJILSfENM¿���]U�I���� W ±�Ï×SPJ��QRENMO�����¿��QL¨]QNI�KRq2S]��S���I�K1��QNICSJq�E���Í�I��LENI�U��ÜE1�����˱�ÏÃE%�z� W ���OKNq V I�SJq�ENI�U$EHG]��EEHG�I�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q%IL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S>I��f�]��ENMOq2S>���zq��JSTEHK%ENq�QN��SJSJMOS��¼EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S�EHG�QNq2�J��G�:GJI���EI��f�]��ENMOq2So±

î I:SJq Å EN�JQNS�ENq�EHGJI:I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S�q���]÷M�S�EHGJI��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q��OMO��M�E�±1°pq-ENGJMOK�I�SJU_¨

Å QRM�ENIL].û|å }H¡M� �Rü�p å&H ¡ é ��zû|å }N¡M� �RüÞ±�Ï×S Å G]��E%��q2�O��q Å K Å I�KRG]����� Å q2QRÓ$ENqz�]QRKRERÁq�QNUJILQM�S �� ��SJUO\ º k|¿ ±4°�GJILS_¨

�K\�Kå ������i� û|å } ��]�Kå � ¬Tü�p �K\�Kå û|å }H¡�� ¬Tü»é � l \� ¡ �Kå û�å }H¡�� ¬Tü � ���`å û�Â2±ÌÈT¬Tü

«mÂ

Page 48: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��SJU� l ]�Kå l �K\� s ������ � û|å } ��]�Kå � ¬Tü�p � l ���Kå l �K\� s ������ � û|å }N¡ é � ���`å � ¬Tü�p � l ���Kå l �`\� ¡ û|å }H¡�� ¬Tü û�Â2±ÌÈJÂwüþq Å ¨�\ðû�å }Hs�� ¬Tü@pò\ ºèç ¿ û s�� ¬Tü�é \ º k|¿ û�å }Hs�� ¬Tü�±,°�GJILS ���� � û|å }H¡�� ¬Tü�p ���>� �n�� � û�å }H¡�� ¬TüÞ±°pqZ�]QRKRERÁÃq2QNU�I�Q�¨ � ö �� ü � � û|å }H¡M� ¬Tü ����� � p � ö � � �n�� ü � � û|å }N¡M� ¬2ü ����� � p ¬�±ÙÔ�M�S]���O� W ¨¢EHqZ�]QRKRERÁq�QNUJILQ�¨ � ö ��� � ö � �� ü ������ � û|å }H¡�� ¬TüOp � ö ��� � ö ���f��¡ �� ü û ¡�� ¬TüÞ± É MOS���I�I����ªG÷q���EHGJILKNI�EHILQN��K���QNIILM�ENGJI�Q��]QRKRERÁÃq2QNU�I�Q.MOSO\ º k|¿ q2Q ���¨]M�S$ENGJI��]QNK�ERÁ×q�QNUJILQ%��MO��M�E Å ICEª��Ó�I�û � ö �� ü � � ü ½ k p � ±� ��EREHM�SJ�ØIL¤2ILQ W EHG�MOSJ��EHq2�2I�EHGJILQ��2M�¤�I�K.�JK.EHG]�ÜE.q2�JQ��]QRKRERÁÃq2QNU�I�Q.I��f�]��ENMOq2S-M�K�¨�V���=� p �K\ º�ç ¿� ¡ Hmû �K\ º k|¿�Kå é � l ���Kå l �`\ ºèç ¿� ¡ ü û�Â2±ÌÈf«2ü

Ï×S¦Ô]q2�JQRMOI�Q�KNP]���LI�¨]EHG�MOK V I���q��zILK�¨� �� c�=� p�«Rl � û m H^K ü \ º�ç ¿ ü¢\ º k|¿c � ÈWl l û m HRK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü l �� c û�Â2±ÌÈTÇTü

É MOSJ�LI �� c û ¡�� ¬Tü@p ¬£¢ m ¨ Å I�q V Eª��M�S_¨�� c û ¡M� �Rü�p � \ º k|¿c«Rl¢û m HRK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü û� � � ½ © þ ö º cRd ¤ ó �f��¡ � ¿ ö ¦ ü û�Â2±ÌÈ2Èfü

þq�EHICEHG]�ÜEt�� c û ¡M� �Rü p ¬���q2Q����O�,QRI�KNq�S]��STE1EHILQN��K�±%°�GJMOK1����S V I�KRI�I�S VTW �Oqmq2ÓfMOSJ��ÜECENGJI�q2QNM��2MOS]��� � � ¯���QNq�� Å GJMO�ªGòEHGJI�KNq��O��ENMOq2S@MOK�UJILQNM�¤2I�Uo¨�q2Q�I��f�JM�¤����OILSfEN� W�VTWS�q�EHM�SJ�>EHGJ��EØ�OM�� cRd ¤ ó � ��¡ �k¥ ç û� � IÞÚ�P í � ÈWl l û m HRK ü \ º�ç ¿ ü l � î ü,�Jû m HRK ü \ ºèç ¿ üGp ¬�±î I�����S Å QNM�EHI�¨

��zû|å }H¡�� �Rü�p ¹�«Rl bc§¦¨ ç \ º k|¿cm HRK ü \ ºèç ¿ û� � � ½ © þ ö º cRd ¤ ó �>��¡ � ¿ ö ¦ ü,� lÊþJ  cRd � û�Â2±ÌÈfÕ2ü

«�«

Page 49: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

°�G�MOK�KRI�QRMOI�K%MOK��q2ST¤�I�QN��I�STE�¨ V I������JKRI5EHG�I�I�ÚbPxq2SJILSfENM¿���,EHILQN� PJQRIL¤2ILSTEHK�QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��ILK��SJU�SJI���Q�QNI�KRq2S]��S���I�K�M�S>EHGJI:U�I�SJq2��MOSJ��EHq2Q��QNq2�������JKNM�SJ��EHGJI�KNI�QRMOILK1EHq�UJM�¤2I�QR�2I�±î I�����S$�OI�E �>© � ENqØ�2ILE.EHG�I��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��EHM�q2S�EHG�I�q2Q W QNI�KR�J��E�¨

��zû|å }H¡M� �Ûü@p ¹�«TlJbc§¦¨0ª \ º k|¿cm HTK ü \ º�ç ¿ � lÊþJ  cRd � û�Â2±ÌÈTÖTü

Å G�I�QNI�ENGJI�KN�J� MOK�qv¤2ILQ$���O�SJq2SbÁÃQNILKNq2S]��SfE m ±Àþ%q�EHI�¨%GJq Å I�¤2ILQ�¨�ENG]��E�EHG�I���q2SbÁ¤�I�QR�2I�SJ�LI�q��1ENGJI¦¤���QRMOq2��K¼Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ��Lq2��P�q2S�I�STEHK�EHq8ENGJI�M�Q"��© � �OMO��M�ENK�MOK�SJq�E��SJM���q2QR�¦¨ V IL������KNI�EHGJI�EHM��zI���q2SJK�Eª��STE��q2Q�EHG�ICIÞÚbP�q2S�I�STEHMO���_EHILQN� M�K�PJQNq2Pxq2Q�EHMOq�S]���ENq�ÂT�Jû m HWK ü \ ºèç ¿ ü l ±°�GJM�K1�2qmI�K%ENq¼M�S��]SJM�E W ��K m ��P�PJQNqT���ªGJI�K���QNI�KRq2S]��S���I�±�°�G�I� V qv¤2I:IL�f�]��EHM�q2S����JK�E V I:KNq2��¤2I�U���q2Q�]SJM�EHIy�Þ¨,��S�U�EHGJILS@EH��Ó�I�ENGJIL��© � ��MO��M�E�±°�G�MOK�PJQNI�¤2ILSfENK:��S W ��� V MO�2�JM�EHM�I�K1M�S ��بpKNq2��ILENGJMOSJ� Å GJM��ªG Å M��O� V IØMO�O���JKRENQH��ENI�U@MOSENGJI�SJI�ÚmEKNIL�LENMOq2S_±

î I5KRGJq2�J��U¦Pxq2M�SfEq2�bEENG]��E Å I5G]��¤�I�SJq�EUJILQNM�¤2I�U>�Ø�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.�L�¿��KRKNMO�����hPxI�Q�ÁEN�JQ V ��EHM�q2SlEHGJILq2Q W EHG]��E-M�K�SJI��LI�KRKH��QRMO� W ��q2ST¤�I�QN��I�STE�± °�GJI@KREH��SJU]��QRUï�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q��q�QN���J�O��MOKØq V EH��MOS�I�U VTW Eª��ÓfMOS��@ENGJI��V© � �OM��zM�E�q��1q2�JQ:IÞÚbPJQNILKNKNM�q2S_¨���SJUl��K����S V I��L�OI���QN� W KRI�ILS_¨�EHG�I�PJQRI�KNILSJ��I�q��hSJI���Q�Á×QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�K�����S�QNILKN�J��E�M�S���U�M�¤2ILQN�2ILSTEKRI�QRMOI�KL± £ q Å IL¤2ILQ�¨�EHG�I>��Ub¤���SfEH���2I$q��1q��JQ���q�QN���J�O��MOK:EHG]�ÜEz��q2Q��������]SJM�EHI��Þ¨�EHG�IS�I���QÒÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��ILK���QNI���ENENI�Sf�]��ENI�U VTW ENGJI�I�ÚbPxq2SJILSfENM¿���pEHILQN��MOS�KR�J�ªGò� Å � W EHG]��EENGJI�KRI�QNM�I�K�U�qbILK���q2ST¤�I�QN��I�±@°�Gf�JK�¨ EHG�MOK���ILENGJqmUZUJqmI�K�SJq�E:QNIL�m��MOQNI¼��S W �>P�QNMOq�QNM

«�Ç

Page 50: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

QRI���qv¤���� q���ENI�QN��K Å GJMO�ªG ��QNI���KRKNM��2SJI�U ��KG�RQNILKNq2SJ��STE_�J±�ñ��ENGJI�QL¨*���O��EHILQN��K��¼� WV I�MOS����O��UJI�U�M�S�EHGJI��]QRKRERÁÃq2QNU�I�Q�IÞÚ�P�QNI�KRKNM�q2S_¨x��SJU��d�¼� WzV I��ªGJq�KNI�S-EHq V I���K��¿��QN�2I��K�P�q�KNKNM V �OI Å M�ENGJq2��E���S W Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ�ENI�QN� I�Úb�LI�I�U�MOSJ��KNq��zI��L��EHq�Í �LQNM�ENI�QRMOq2S_±�Ï×SENGJMOK Å � W ¨JENGJI1SJq�SbÁ×QRI�KNq�S]��STEÔ]q2�JQNM�I�Q¢EHI�QR�zK Å MO�O�xI�KRKNILSfENM¿����� W G]��¤2I�EHG�I�MOQdKREH��SJU]��QRU�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q¢¤����O�JILK�¨ Å GJMO��IENGJI���q2QRI�SJI���QN� W QNI�KRq2S]��STE�ENI�QR�zK Å MO�O�]K�EHM��O�]G]��¤2I��CSJq2SbÁS�I��2��MO�2M V �OI¢I�ÚbPxq2SJI�STENM¿���mEHI�QR�ÀPJQRI�KNILSTE Å G�MO�ªGØÓ�ILI�PJK4EHGJI�qv¤�I�QH���O��KRI�QRMOI�K �Lq2ST¤2ILQN�2ILSfE�±°�G�I5�Lq2QNQRI�KNPxq2SJU�MOSJ�ØSJq2SmÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��STE1Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ�EHILQN��KM�S�EHGJI £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��S Å MO�O�xEHGJILSGJ�v¤�I V I�ILS�I�KNKRI�STEHMO���O� W ÓfMO���OILUðq�Í�¨ Å GJM��OI�ENGJI��zq�QNI�SJI���QN� W QNILKNq2SJ��STE�ENI�QR�zK Å M��O�GJ�v¤�I V I�ILS¦QRI�UJ����I�U¦KNq2��I Å GJ��E�¨ V �bE%S�q�E.��q2��PJ��ILEHIL� W ±

âGã « ë �����L"�� ������ï7�¬$��� ������

���!­"�#� ��®�¯ $�°±;>=³²B)17§ q�SJKNM�UJI�Q�EHG�IC����KNICq��p��QNILICP�QNq2P]���T��EHM�q2S�PxI�QREN�JQ V I�U VTW � Å I���Óx¨|��qb�����OM�Ä�I�U¼P�q�ENI�SbÁENM¿���j± � �JQ £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��SzMOKL¨

\ðû�´ }Pµ ü@p µ l«*n é6¹¼û¶´2ü û�Â2±ÌÈ �2ü

Å G�I�QNI�¹�û�´�ü�M�K5�]S�M�EHIzMOS 9 ��SJUZU�I���� W K�EHq�¬>��K·´¸© ¹m� ±�Ô]q2Q5� V qv¤�I�Á V ��QNQRMOI�QILSJI�QR�2MOILK Å I¢����S5��q2S�KREHQR�J�LE���S5���LENMOq2S����JS��LEHM�q2S�UJIL�JSJI�U5IL¤2ILQ W Å GJILQNI�MOS��Lqbq2QRUJMOSJ��EHI

«ÜÈ

Page 51: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

KRP]���LI�¨|�2M�¤�I�S VTW ¨].û�´ }¾v ü�p v g £ û� � «*n·¹�û¶´ ð ü

v l ü �ö C§´ ð û�Â2±ÌÈX�Tü

Å G�I�QNI v e µ ûU¹j�ÛüÞ± D���q2SJ���ð���¿��KNKNM������%EHQH� � I��LENq2Q W ¨ Å I8GJ�v¤�Ivº ölʧ éŹ¼û¶´2üÀp\Zû�´ }Pµ ü�p º ö»lʧ p\¼ ölʧ ¨oKNqzEHGJI5QNI�P�QNI�KRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�S�q��2\»M�S¦ENGJI��Lq2QNQRI�KNPxq2SJU�MOSJ�@û Y }Tv üK W KREHIL�äMOK.KNM��zP�� W \ðû�´ }Pµ ü@pò\ ºèç ¿ û v ü�p ¼ ölʧ ±

ó�IL������KNI ].û�´ }¾v ü1MOKCq2SJ� W U�ILEHILQN��MOSJILUZ�JP ENq>KRq2�zI>û�Pxq2KRKNM V � W ��Á×UJILP�ILSJUJILSfEªü�Lq2SJK�Eª��STE�EHILQN�$¨���O� Å I�����S÷�JSJM��m��I�� W KNPxI��LM�� W MOK µ p ���� £ p v û� �

lʧr½ º £ ¿¼ ö ü �ö ±Ï×S�EHG�I$�]QRKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�QØ�OM��zM�E�¨ Å I¦ÓfSJq Å ��QRq2�»ENGJI¦P�QNIL¤mM�q2�JKØKNIL�LEHM�q2S?ENG]��E�q2�JQ�� � ¯��ILENGJqmUl��q2ST¤�I�QN��I�K�EHqð�8KREHI���U W Á×K�Eª��ENI�± � �JQ���ILENGJqbUùKNGJq2���OUlK�EHMO���.��q2��I�����q2KNIENq-�¼KRENI���U W ÁÃKREH��EHI V I W q2SJU�EHGJI��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�QL¨ W I�E�KRENMO�O� Å I���Óf� W PxI�QREN�JQ V I�Uo¨hQNI���MO��I�±Ô]q2Q�EHG�I¼KRENQNq2S��2� W PxI�QREN�JQ V I�U ����KRI�¨ Å I�UJq2S_Ê E�ÓfSJq Å Å G]��E�q2�JQ5�zI�EHGJqmU Å M��O�4UJqJ±þIL¤�I�QRENGJI���I�KRK�¨ Å I�����S:KNG�q Å EHGJ��E���q2Q����O�b� V qv¤2I�Á V ��QRQNMOILQ�ILSJI�QR�2MOILK�¨Tq2�JQ*�zI�EHGJqmU�G]��K�:�JS�MO�f�JI�KRENI���U W ÁÃKREª�ÜEHICKNq2����EHM�q2S_¨J��SJU-MOK��2M�¤2I�S VTW EHG�I���q�QN���J�O����q2Q µ û¶´ }Tv ü��2M�¤2ILS� V qv¤2I�±�°*qzPJQNqv¤�I5EHG�MOK�¨ Å I�SJq�EHI�EHG]��EM�S¦q2S�I5UJM��zILSJKNM�q2S-EHGJICIL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S$I��f�]�ÜEHMOq�S��q�Q°] V I���q��zILK�¨ �`]�=� p vn Â

� ö �� ¼ � £ �K\�{´ ������ ¼ û�Â2±ÌÈX+Tü

É ILENENMOSJ� ���� ¦ p�¬b¨b��SJUzQRI���I�� V I�QRMOSJ��ENG]��E ��q2Q4I�S�I�QN��MOI�K¢� V qv¤2I.EHGJI V ��QNQNM�I�Q Å I%GJ�v¤�I

«�Õ

Page 52: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

v �p ¬�¨ Å I5��ILE�EHG�ICK�EHI���U W Á×K�Eª��ENI5IL�m�J��EHM�q2S_¨�K\ðû�´ } ���� £ ü�{´ ������ ¼ p�¬ û�Â2± Õ�¬Tü

þq�EHIzEHG]��E5EHGJM�K:��KRKN�J��I�K�ENG]��E � ö �� ¼ � £ �p�¬ } � ¨�KNq��zI�EHGJM�SJ�¦ENG]��E Å I Å MO���¢q�SJ� W8V I� V �OI�EHq��ªGJIL�ªÓ$q�SJ��I Å I5KNq2��¤2ICq2�JQ.I��f�]�ÜEHMOq�S_±�°�GJICKRENI���U W ÁÃKREH��EHI5I��f�]��ENMOq2S$����S V IM�STEHI���QH��ENI�Uò��E��Lq2SJKREH��STE v EHq��2M�¤2IG\ðû¶´ }*���� £ ü�p¾�zû v ü�± Ð ILENENMOSJ�5´V© ¹m� �2M�¤2ILK��K�EHG]�ÜE \ V I��Lq2�zILK º ö»lʧ p ¼ ölʧ ¨oKRq��¼û v ü p ¼ ölʧ ±�°�GJILQNI���q2QNI�¨ klʧ û �J�� £ ü l é­¹¼û¶´2ü�p¼ ölʧ�¿ ���� £ p v û� �

lʧr½ º £ ¿¼ ö ü �ö ±þq�EHI�EHGJ��E � ö �� ¼ � £ �pº¬ } � ��q2QØ������I�S�I�QN��MOI�K�� V qv¤2I-EHGJI V ��QRQNM�I�Q�¨¢KNqòq2�JQ�� � ¯

��PJPJQNq2���ªGðUJqmI�K W MOIL�OUòEHGJI���PJPJQNq�PJQNMO��EHI�KRENI���U W ÁÃKREª�ÜEHI�KNq��O��ENMOq2S_±¦ó�IL�Oq Å EHGJI V ��Q�ÁQRMOILQ�¨ Å I�����SJSJq�E���q�SJKRENQN�J��E:�¦QRI����d����EHMOq�Sò���JS��LEHM�q2S U�IL�]SJILUZ��q2Q5���O�f´m¨�KRMOSJ�LIzEHG�I��q2��I�STEH��� µ V I��Lq2�zILK:MO�z���2M�S]��Q W M�SZEHGJI��L�¿��KRKNM�������� W ��q2Q V MOUJU�I�SðQNIL�2MOq�S_±@D�E��EN�JQNS�MOSJ��Pxq2M�SfE�¨ � ö �� ¼ � £ p � ¨mKNq:MOS¼��S W I�¤2I�STE.q2��Q���ILEHG�qbU¼��q�Qd�]SJU�MOSJ��ENGJI1K�EHI���U W ÁK�Eª��ENI V QNI���ÓfKdUJq Å S V IL�Oq Å EHGJI V ��QRQNM�I�Q�±*°�Gf�JK�¨ V q�EHG���PJPJQRqT���ªGJILK¢ENq��]SJUJM�SJ�C�CQRI�������LEHM�q2S����JSJ��EHMOq�S]�P�QNI�KRI�STEHILUZMOS@EHG�MOK�KNIL�LEHM�q2SòG]��¤2I���S8IL�m�J���4QH��SJ��I�q���¤����OM�UJM�E W ¨SJ���zIL� W ¨,��q�Q������ I�SJILQN�2M�I�K5� V qw¤�I�ENGJI V ��QNQRMOI�QL± É IL�zM����O��KNKRMO�����O� W ¨_EHGJM�K��zI���SJK�EHG]��Eq��JQ� � ¯ù��PJPJQRqT���ªG>QRI��Lqw¤�I�QRK î ô�óïENGJI�q2Q W ��q2Q.� V qv¤2I�Á V ��QRQNMOILQ.I�SJILQN�2M�I�K�±�©>��M�EHQH���SJU £ I����OI�Q í Â2Â'î|U�IL¤2IL�Oq2PxI�U¼�C��ILENGJqmU�ENq5�Lq2�zP���EHI� V qv¤2I�Á V ��QRQNMOILQ4QNI Î I��LENMOq2S���qmIL�¿Á�J��MOILSTEHK�JKNM�SJ��ENGJI î ôCó Å �v¤�IL���JS��LEHM�q2SJK���K��ØUJM�KREHq�QREHILUbÁ Å ��¤2I V ��KRMOK�±d°�GJI5� V qv¤�I

«�Ö

Page 53: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

U�I�QNM�¤���EHM�q2S?KRGJq Å K�EHG]�ÜE¼EHG�MOKz��PJPJQRqT���ªGÛMOK���q�SfEH��MOS�I�U÷��K¼�8KN� V ����KNI Å M�EHGJM�Sùq2�JQ� � ¯�Á V ��KNILU>��P�PJQNqT���ªG_±

���!­"�! z®�¯ $�°±;>=³²B)17§ q�SJKNM�UJI�Q�EHG�I £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S_¨

\ðû¶À }�Á�}Pµzw�}Pµ ~�ü2p µ lw é µ l~«*n é6uI� ½Â�º w ö ý ~ ö ¿ û�Â2± ÕbÂwü

î I Å MOKNGïEHq���q2S�KREHQR�J�LE���S����LEHM�q2SÛ���JSJ��EHMOq�SA].û¶À }_Á`}¾vxw�}¾v ~�ü-M�S÷ENGJI8�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q��MO��M�E�±�ó W ENGJI5K W �z��ILENQ W q���ENGJMOKPJQRq V �OIL�¦¨ Å I�SJILI�U�q�SJ� W �Lq2SJKNM�UJI�Q v ~¯pÙ¬�± É qJ¨��ILE�ÊøK Å QRM�ENI4].û¶À }_Á`}¾v�w*}¾v ~�ü2ppÀ v�w é Á8v ~�é�zû¶À }�Á�}¾vxw�}¾v ~�ü�¨ Å G�I�QNI4� MOK�q��JQ��]QRKRERÁq�QNUJILQ���q�QNQNIL�LENMOq2S_± î I�KN� V KREHM�EH��ENI�MOSTENqzEHG�I5EHM��zIÞÁ×M�SJUJI�PxI�S�UJI�STE £ ����MO��ENq2SbÁÒ¾2����q V MIL�f�]��EHM�q2S8û £ ¾2¯dü�ENq���ILE�¨

à p \ðûÄÀ }_Á�}Tv�w é �K��0À }¾v ~2é �K�� Á üp Â

«*n û vlw é v l~ üSé v�wn

�K��0À é v ~n �`�� Á é6uI� ½Â�º w ö ý ~ ö ¿ û�Â2± Õ2«2ü

É ILE v ~°pï¬�¨ à p ¼ ö�lʧ ENq���ILE�¨ �`��0À p � uQnv�w � ½Â�º w ö ý ~ ö ¿ û�Â2± Õ�ÇTü

Å G�MO�ªG�����S V I�MOSTEHIL�2QH�ÜEHI�UðENq��2M�¤�I �¼ûÄÀ }_Á�}Tv�w�} ¬Tü"p �MÅ §¼ � � ½Â ~ ö�Æ w½�Ç � ½Â w ¸ ö C§À ð é�zû Á`}¾vxw üÞ±�þ%q Å ¨§�ÛM�K�UJI�EHI�QR�zM�SJI�U VTW ENGJI V q2�JSJUJ��Q W ��q�SJUJM�ENMOq2S�K Å G�MO�ªG Å I�MO��Pxq2KNI«��

Page 54: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

q�S>EHGJM�K�K W K�EHIL�¦±1°�G�I��]QNK�E�KNI�E�q�� V q2�JS�U]��Q W ��q�SJUJM�ENMOq2S�K Å I Å MO���,��q2SJKRMOUJILQ1MOK.EHG�IQRI��f�JM�QNI���I�STE.EHGJ��E µ ~°p ¬Ø��E"À�p � � ± î I�G]��¤2I�¨

�K�� Á p «�uQn svxw Á � ½Â ~ ö g w½�Ç � ½Â w ¸ ö C�À ð é ���� Á û�Â2± Õ�Èfü

°�G�I�Sò��E8À�p � � Å I:�2I�E µ ~jp ��È� ~ pÀ¬�¨_KRq��²p��¼û v�w üÞ± É MOSJ�LI�EHGJI £ ¾2¯�q2S�� WU�I�PxI�SJUJKCq2S@EHGJIØ��q2��I�STEH�J���]I���Uò��I�SJILQH��ENI�U VTW ]ï��SJUòSJq�ECq2SD]ïM�ENKNIL���Ò¨,� v�w ÁU�I�PxI�SJUJILSTE���q�SJKREH��STE5ENI�QN�ºM�K��JSJM��zPxq2QREH��STE�¨hKRq Å Iz����S8KRILE5M�E�ENq>¬�±�°�GJILQNIL��q�QNI�¨q�SJI��]QNK�ERÁ×q�QNUJILQKRq2�O�bEHMOq�S�MOK�¨

�"k�ûÄÀ }_Á�}Tv�w�} ¬Tü p � uKnv�w � ½Â ~ ö g w½�Ç � ½Â w ¸ ö C§À ðp � uKn

v�wWÉ s � ½Â ~ ö g�Ê Â w½�Ç � ½ ¤ ö C§Ë û�Â2± Õ2Õ2ü

D%S ����EHILQNS]��ENM�¤�I�KNq2����EHM�q2SÛMOK¼q V Eª��MOSJILU÷��QRq2� ENGJI V q��JSJU]��Q W �Lq2SJUJM�EHMOq�SlEHG]��Eµ ~ ������ w ¨ ½�Ç p �>µ ~ ������ w ¨ Ç ±»�4���J�2�2M�SJ�lM�SfENq÷q2�JQ�IÞÚ�P�QNI�KRKNM�q2S ��q2Q � �� ~ �2M�¤2I�K ��È� ~ p� l Å § ¼ ��Ì þ Á � ½Â ~ ö ��� È� ~ ¨ Å G�MO�ªG$����S V I�KRq2��¤�I�U$��q2Q ��È� ~ ��S�U¦M�SfENI��2QN��EHILU�EHq W M�I���U_¨

�zû Á`}¾vxw ü2p uQn« vxw�Í ls � ½Â ~ ö é ��¼û v�w ü û�Â2± Õ�ÖTü

D%K V IL��q2QRI�¨ Å I�UJQRq2P�ENGJI vxw Á×U�I�PxI�SJUJILSTE ��q2S�KREª��SfE�EHI�QR�¦±p°�GJIdQNI�KR�J��E�MOK*��SJq�ENGJI�Q�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.KRq2�O��ENMOq2So¨

�4lwûÄÀ }_Á�}Tv�w�} ¬Tü p � uQnv�wWÉ s � ½Â ~ ö ûPg�Ê Â w½�Ç � ½ ¤ ö CÎË � É l

« ü

«*�

Page 55: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

p � uQnv�w É s � ½Â ~ ö ûPg�Ê Â w½�Ç � ½ ¤ ö CÎË � g ç½�Ç � ½ ¤ ö CÎËxü

p � uQnv�w É s � ½Â ~ ö g Ê Â wç � ½ ¤ ö C§Ë û�Â2± Õ��2ü

Ô�M��2�JQRI�KCÂ2±�Â���¨ V PJ��q�E.EHGJI5�zq2��I�STEN�J� �]I���UJK�2I�SJILQH��ENI�U VTW �Lk.��SJU �mlv±.þq�EHIENG]��EV�Lk�PJQRqbU��J��ILK¢ENGJI.�zq2QRI�PJG W KNMO�����O� W MOSTEN�JM�ENM�¤2I��z��SJM���q2�OU�q���ENQH� � IL�LENq2QNM�I�K�¨fKRMOSJ�LIENGJI W �JQNKRE5GJI���U K�EHQH��MO�2GTE�EHq Å ��QNU ENGJI¼öC����KNKNMO��S V �J��P_¨���SJU ��QNI�q2SJ� W UJI Î IL�LENI�U��KØENGJI W ��PJPJQRqT���ªG�M�E�±ð°�G�I �4l�ENQH� � IL�LENq2QNM�I�K�¨¢MOS��Lq2STEHQH��KRE�¨���QNI�K W �z��ILENQNMO������ENqENGJI��OI�� E.��SJU-QRMO�2GTE�q��,ENGJI V �J��P_± °�GJM�K�MOK.���L��q2��PJ�OM�KNGJILU VTW MOS�M�EHMO���O� W ��SJ���OMOS��5EHG�IENQH� � IL�LENq2QNM�I�K�MOS Å ��QNU�EHq Å ��QNU?ENGJI V �J��P_±l°�GJI-EHQN� � I���EHq2QRMOI�K�����QR¤2I¦MOS���SJU�EHGJILS�L�JQR¤�I�� Å � W ��K�EHGJI W QNI����ªG¦ENGJI V �J��P_±

î I5S�q Å EN�JQNS$EHqz�Ø�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.EHQRI���EN�zILSTE��JKRMOSJ�ØEHG�I���P�PJQNqT���ªG>UJILQNM�¤�I�U>��QRq2�q��JQ�� � ¯���ILENGJqbUo± î I V I��2M�S VTW �JKNM�SJ��EHG�I�P�q�KNM�ENMOq2S¦��q2QN�����¿��ENMOq2S$q��¢q2�JQ�� � ¯M�S¦ENGJI5�]QRKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q%�OMO��M�E�¨J�2M�¤2I�S VfW ¯ �|±:û�Â�±øÈf«�ü�± î I5ÓfSJq Å ENG]��E%EHGJI5IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S¦q��� ��qbILK�ENq$�$K�EHI���U W Á×KREH��EHI�¨*KRq¦KRILEREHMOS�� � �� ¦ p ¬�¨p��S�U8PJ���J�2�2M�SJ��MOS�ENGJI:EHI�QR�zK���q2Qq��JQ�KNPxI��LM��]�CP�q�EHI�STENM¿���j¨ W MOIL�OUJKL¨

� «�sÛun � ½Â�º w ö ý ~ ö ¿ û v�w À�é v ~ Á ü�é Ân l û

� l ��0À l v lw éC« � l ��{ÀI� Á v�wYv ~Zé � l �� Á l v l~ ü�p ¬�û�Â2± Õ��Tü

D�E v ~°p�¬ Å I��2I�E � ö �� w ö p l  Š§¼ � ÀI� ½Â�º w ö ý ~ ö ¿ ± Ï×STEHIL�2QH�ÜEHMOS�����M�¤2ILK�¨�K��0À p � uKnv�w � ½Â�º w ö ý ~ ö ¿ éJ�zû Á`}¾v�w ü û�Â2± Õ�+Tü

«*+

Page 56: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

-2 -1 0 1 2x

-2

-1

0

1

2y

a

-2 -1 0 1 2x

-2

-1

0

1

2

y

b

Ô*MO�2�JQRI�Â2±�Â2½�°�GJI��]QRKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q:��q2��I�STEH�J�/�]I���UJK:�2ILSJI�QN��EHILU VTW ENGJI·�"k���SJUà�4l�z��SJM���q2�OU$q�� ENQH� � IL�LEHq�QNMOILK�¨ Å G�I�QNIyn p Â�rø¬�¨»s6p Â�r ¬b¨SuÜp Â�r ¬�¨_��SJU vxw pÀ«m±Øûj�Tü°�G�Ij�Lk��¼��S�M���q2��U_±�û V ü�°�GJIm�ml�¼��SJM���q2��U_±

ÏÃ� Å I8QNIL�m��MOQNI µ=w ������ w ¨ ½�Ç p v�w ¨1EHGJILS � �� w ������ w ¨ ½�Ç p ¬ ¿ �¼û Á�}¾vxw ü�p ¬�± � �JQQRI�KR�J��ENMOSJ�CUJM�Í�I�QRI�STEHMO���JIL�m�J��EHM�q2Sz��q2QU�FMOK ENGJI�QRIL��q2QRI%M�UJI�STEHM������JENqCENGJIq2SJIq V Eª��MOSJILU¤mMO�:ENGJI £ ¾2¯ùM�S�EHGJI��]QRKRERÁÃq2QNU�I�Q.�OM��zM�E�±

î I¦S�q Å �JKNI-EHG�I>Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ���q2QN���J�¿��ENMOq2S q��1q2��QØ�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�QL¨�� � ¯�Á V ��KNI�U?��PbÁP�QNqT���ªGo¨ VTW ��PJPJ� W M�SJ�>¯ �|± û�Â2±ÌÈfÕ2üÞ±�°�GJI�Ô]q2�JQRMOI�Q��Lq2�zPxq2SJILSTEHK�q��X� ½Â�º w ö ý ~ ö ¿ ��QNI��M�¤2ILS VTW u þ  � ½ ÷ öÏ ºÑÐ ö� ý Ð ö� ¿ ± °�GJI�QRIL��q2QRI�¨ Å ICq V EH��MOSo¨

Ç�¬

Page 57: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�zû¶À }_Á`}¾vxw�}¾v ~ � �Rü p � u«Rl l s g ǽ�Ç g ǽ�Ç CÒ w CÒ�~ I�ÚbP í � þ ö ûPÒ lw éDÒ l~ ü îÒ w ¼ �§ éDÒ�~ ¼ �§ ±û� � � ½ © þ ö ��Ó �_Ô���Õ Ó ��Ô�� � öÖ ö ¦ ü#� lÊþ'  ºÑÐ � w ý Ð � ~�¿ û�Â2±øÖ2¬Tü

î I�SJq Å KRILE v ~°p�¬�¨J�2M�¤bM�SJ�

�zû¶À }�Á�}¾vxw�} ¬ � �Rü p � uQn«�s v�w g ǽ�Ç g ǽ�Ç CÒ w CÒ�~ I�ÚbP í � þ öÂ Ò lw î�I�ÚbP í � þ öÂ Ò l~ îÒ w ±û� � � ½ © þ ö Ð ö� ¼ ö� ¦q×�§ ö ü#� lÊþ'  Ð � w � lÊþJ  Ð � ~

p � uQn«�s v�w�Í s l � ½Â ~ ö g ǽ�Ç CÒ w IÞÚ�P í � þ öÂ Ò lw îÒ w û� � � ½ © þ ö Ð ö� ¼ ö� ¦q×�§ ö ü,� lÊþJ  Ð � w

p � uQn« vxw É szl � ½Â ~ ö g ǽ�Ç CÒ w � ½ ÷ öÏ Ð ö� ûÒ � � ½ © þ ö Ð ö� ¼ ö� ¦q×�§ ö ü�±ûË«Tl � g wç � lÊþJ  Ð � w ¸ C�À ð é ÂÒ w ü

p � uKnv�w Í ls � ½Â ~ ö g wç C§À ð g ǽ�Ç CÒ w � ½ ÷ öÏ Ð ö� ûÒ � � ½ © þ ö Ð ö� ¼ ö� ¦q×�§ ö ü,� lÊþJ  Ð � w ¸ é� uQn« vxw�É szl � ½Â ~ ö g ǽ�Ç CÒ wÒ w � ½ ÷ öÏ Ð ö� ûÒ � � ½ © þ ö Ð ö� ¼ ö� ¦q×�§ ö ü ûÒÂ2± ÖbÂwü

°�G�I%KRI���q�SJU�MOSTENI��2QN���J¤���SJMOKRGJI�KL¨ V I������JKRI%EHG�IM�STEHI���QH��SJUzMOK¢��S�qbU�U����JS��LEHM�q2S�q��zÒ w ±°�G�MOK.�2M�¤�I�K.�JKL¨

�zû¶À }�Á�}¾vxw�} ¬ � �Rü p � uKnv�w Í ls � ½Â ~ ö g wç C§À ð g ǽ�Ç CÒ w � ½ ÷ öÏ Ð ö� û� � � ½ © þ ö Ð ö� ¼ ö� ¦q×�§ ö ü#� lÊþ'  Ð � w ¸p � uKnv�wØÍ ls � ½Â ~ ö g wç C§À ð g ǽ�Ç CÒ w û�IÞÚbP í � l ls Ò lw î �

I�ÚbP í � l lk�Ï ý © ¼ ö� ¦q×�§ ö Ò lw î¿ü,� lÊþ'  Ð � w ¸ÇbÂ

Page 58: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

p � uKnv�wØÍ ls � ½Â ~ ö g wç C§À ð û Í s l I�ÚbP í � szÀ ð l î �ÂÌ l4û k é�È v lw �,�*n l ü IÞÚbP í � À ð lk é�È v lw �,�*n l î¿ü û�Â2±øÖT«2ü

î I�����S V QRI���Ó�ENGJMOK.MOSTENI��2QN���,MOSTEHqØE Å q¼PJMOIL��I�KL±Ô�MOQRKRE�OI�E�ÊÌK%SJq�EHI�EHGJI���q2�O��q Å MOSJ��ªGJ��SJ�2Iq��o¤���QRM¿� V �OI�½ É I�ENENMOSJ�ØË�p É s@u¼�2M�¤2ILK�¨ Æ wç C8u Ì Âþ � ½Â Å ö p kÊ þ Æ Ê Â wç C§ËI� ½ ¤ ö ±°�G�I�QNI���q2QNI�¨

�zû¶À }_Á`}¾vxw�} ¬ � �Rü p � uQnvxw É s � ½Â ~ ö ûPgMÊ Â wç � ½ ¤ ö C§Ë � g �É �Ï ÕRÙ¶Ô ö��ÚjÛ Ö öç � ½ ¤ ö C§Ë�ü

p � uQnvxw É s � ½Â ~ ö g Ê Â w#Ü Ï �É � ÕTÙ¶Ô ö� Ï ÚjÛ Ö ö �

½ ¤ ö CÎË û�Â2±øÖ2ÇTü

Ð I�ENEHM�SJ�"�>© � ��M�¤2ILK.�JK�¨

�zû¶À }�Á�}¾vxw�} ¬Tü�p � uKnv�w É s � ½Â ~ ö g Ê Â wç � ½ ¤ ö C§Ë û�Â2±øÖ�Èfü

°�Gf�JKL¨mENGJIÔ]q2�JQNM�I�Q�KRP]���LI���P�PJQNqT���ªG W MOIL�OUJK�ENGJI°�ml4���JSJ��EHM�q2SØq V Eª��MOSJILU�P�QNIL¤mM�q2�JKN� W ±þq�EHI%EHG]��E�M�E Å ��K�SJI��LI�KNKN��Q W EHq�Eª��Ó�I�ENGJIo�>© � �OM��zM�E4q2SJ� W ��EdEHGJI�I�SJU_¨�MOS�q2QRUJI�QENq��v¤�q2MOU¦��S W ��� V MO�2��M�EHM�I�KdMOS-IL¤������]��EHM�SJ��EHG�ICM�STEHI���QH����K�±

Ç2«

Page 59: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

âGã�Ý ë Þ ��� ��34������÷7O¬$��� �����

î I�ªGJq2KNIEHqCEHI�K�EdENGJIo] IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S�Sf�J�zILQNM�������� W q�S�ENGJIE Å q�ÁÃUJMO��I�SJKRMOq2SJ���|� �J�O��I�SbÁ¯ UJ��q2SJU�K £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S í �*îj¨J�2M�¤�I�S VTW ¨

\ðûÄÀ }_Á�}Uµ=w�}Uµ ~�üUp µ lw é µ l~« é « ûø�lw À l é� l~ Á l üSéJß,À l Á l û�Â2±øÖTÕ2ü

°�G�MOK Å ��K EHGJIdE Å q�ÁÃUJMO��I�S�KNMOq�S]���mK W KRENI�� KREN�JUJM�I�U:Sf�J��I�QNM�������� W MOS�ñI��Ò±4«�MOS�ENI�K�EHMOS��ENGJIØö � D ��ILEHG�qbU_±%°�GJI�QRI�KN����EHK%EHGJILQNI Å I�QRI���q2��P]��QRI�U Å M�EHG>ENGJq2KRI�q V EH��MOSJILU�MOSñ.IL�Ò±.Ç��JKNM�SJ�ØEHGJI § £ ©õ��ILENGJqbUo± £ q Å IL¤2ILQ�¨ Å G�MO�OI�M�S>ñ.IL�Ò±«:EHGJI5IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S Å ��KU�q2SJI1q2S \âM�S¼EHG�I���q2STEHIÞÚmE.q��pq V Eª��MOSJM�SJ����KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����|�m�J��STEH�J� KRP�IL�LENQN�J�$¨JMOSENGJMOK�����KNICM�E�MOK�EHG�I5� � ¯?��q�Q°]�EHGJ��EMOK V I�MOS��ØENI�K�EHI�Uo±

î I@KNILEM� w pÐ��~àp Â2±)°�G�IÀ�Üp ¬Z����SJq2SJM�������QNI�P�QNI�KRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�S�M�K�KNM��zPJ� WENGJI�G]��QR�zq�SJMO�zq2KN�LMO�O�O��EHq�Q�����EHM�q2SbÁÒ��SJ�2�OI V ��KRMOKL¨¢U�I�SJq�ENI�U VTW û�{ w } {'~ }áà�wX}áà ~�üÞ±8°�G�I��Q V M�EHQH��Q W ������SJq2S�MO������QNI�P�QNI�KRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�S�MOK-UJILSJq�EHILU VTW û�¶ w�} ¶K~ } � wX} ��~�üÞ¨�KNq�EHG]��E] p ].û|{ w�} {'~ } � w�} �J~ � �Rü�¨ Å M�ENG à�w p ������ � ¨d��SJU à ~ p ������ � ±ð°�G�I$ENQH��SJK���q2QN�z��ENMOq2SENq�ENGJI@G]��QR�zq2S�MO��QRI�PJQRI�KNILSTEª��ENMOq2S�MOK-q V EH��MOSJILU VfW KRILEREHMOS��âÀ>p Ì ã �þ �Lq2K�«Rlx{ w ¨µzw p � Ì ã �þ KNM�S�«Tlx{ w ¨|��SJU-KRMO��MO�¿��QN� W ��q�Q Á�}Pµ ~w±¢°�G�ICQRI�KR�J��EMOKL¨\ðû|{ wX} {'~ }áà�w�}áà ~�ü p Â

«Rl û à�w é à ~vüSé ß à�w�à ~ÈWl l ûÒÂVé���q�K]ÈWlx{ w é���q�K]ÈWlx{'~2é« û���q2K]È�l¢û|{ w é6{'~�üSé��Lq2K]ÈWl¢û�{ w°� {'~vüRüNü û�Â2±øÖ2ÖTü

Ç�Ç

Page 60: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

°�G�I�q2SJ� W SJq2ST¤���SJM�KNGJM�SJ��Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ�Lq2��P�q2S�I�STEHK%��QNI·¹zûj« } ¬Tü } ¹�ûj¬ } «�ü } ¹�ûË« } «2ü�¨|��S�U¹�ûË« }3� «�ü�±4þ%q�EHI�MOS-P]��Q�EHM����J�O��Q�EHGJ��E.¹zûj« }3� «2ü�MOK.�:QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��I�±� ��ENGJIòENGJQNILI8P�QNI�KR��QRMOP�ENMOq2SJK-��q2Q-�ªGJqmq2KNM�SJ� �ب�ENGJI8KRMO��PJ�OILKRE$q2SJI@EHq?�JKNIòMOK

\ ºèç ¿ p¨\ ç p klÊþ û� } Âwü(Hxû�� wX} �J~�üÞ¨�KNq�ENG]��EäK ü \ º�ç ¿ M�K5Eª��Ó�I�SðENq V I klÊþ û� } Âwü�±¦Ï×S��UJUJM�ENMOq2So¨b��q2Q�ENGJMOK £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S¼M�E�MOK.QNI���UJMO� W ¤�I�QRM��]ILU$ENG]��E�¨

�K\�Kå ������i� û|å } ��]�Kå � ¬Tü p � ßl �`]�K{ w �`]�K{'~ û�KNM�SÈ�lx{ w é « û�KNMOS�È�l¢û|{ w é6{'~�üSé�KRMOS�ÈWl4û|{ w°� {'~vüRü }

KNMOS.ÈWlS{'~2é « û�KNM�S�ÈWl¢û�{ w éà{'~vü � KRMOS�ÈWl4û|{ w°� {'~vüRüNü ûÒÂ2±øÖX�2ü

��SJU_¨

�K\� s ������ � p «Rl û� } ÂwüHé ß

ÈWl l ûÒÂ�é���q2K]È�lx{ w é���q�K]ÈWlx{'~Ué« û��Lq2K]ÈWl¢û�{ w éà{'~vüSé���q2K]È�l¢û|{ w°� {'~�üNüNüLû �`]�K{'~ } �`]�K{ w ü û�Â2±øÖ��Tü

î I�KR� V KRENM�EN��EHI:M�SfENq�¯ �|±¼ûÒÂ2±øÇ��Tü%��SJU�EHGJILS@MOSTEHq�¯ �|±zû�Â2±øÇX�2ü�EHq��2I�E1EHG�I:� � ¯÷��q2Q]�±

î I�KNI�Eäß"p ¬zrø¬TÕb¨���SJU� w pq��~�p�+�l ±¦°�GJMOK5��q2QRQNILKNPxq2SJUJK�ENq��¦ENq2QN�JK Å M�ENGÄLI�QRq�EHGbÁÃq2QNU�I�Q�ILSJI�QR� W à p +¼��E°��pÙ¬b±°�G�I�K W KRENI���MOKSJI���QN� W M�STEHI���QH� V ��I�MOS¦ENGJMOKQRI��2M��zI í Ç*î˨ W I�E��KREN�JU W q��hEHGJI%KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM�������� W q V Eª��M�SJI�U�ILSJI�QR� W KRP�IL�LENQN�J� í «f¨JÇ*îKRGJq Å K�����I���Q�UJM�ÍoILQNI�S���I�K Å M�EHG��]QNK�ERÁÃq2QNUJILQ¼PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��EHM�q2S�EHGJILq2Q W ± î I¦ENGJI�QRIL��q2QRIENI�K�E%q��JQ� � ¯ V I W q2S�U¦EHG�I��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.��MO��M�E Å M�EHG�ENGJMOK�IÞÚJ���zPJ��I�±

Ç�È

Page 61: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

î I5KRILEo®�pF«�¬�¨K�Må:p�¬zr�Â�¨K� � p ¬zrø¬2Ç�ÈJ¨|��SJU �m��]>æ�pò+�¨ Å GJMO�ªG¦���O��q Å ILU��K�EHq�PJQRq2P]���T�ÜEHI�ENGJI.� � ¯8q2��E�EHq���EHM��zIdq���¬zrøÇ2¬2ÖØû�ENGJI���I���SJM�SJ�1q��|ENGJI�KRI�P]��QH���ØÁI�EHILQNK.MOK���M�¤2ILS�MOS�D%PJP�ILSJUJMÆÚ�D�üÞ±J°�GJI�QN��EHI�q��p�ªG]��SJ�2I�q��Û]�q�S�EHGJI��2QRMOU�QRI����ªGJILK���MOS�MO���J� �ÜE1EHGJM�K1Pxq2MOSTE�û Å GJMO�ªG Å ��K�UJILENI�QR�zM�SJI�U VTW ENQH���ªÓfMOS�� Ì �Hû���]����Q�Rü l ��q�SENGJIC�2QNM�U|ü�¨]KRq¼EHGJICIL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S Å ��K�K�EHq2P�P�ILU>GJILQNI�±ó�IL������KNI�q��JQ�� � ¯Û��P�PJQNqT���ªG>MOKq�SJ� W ENGJI��2QN��UJMOILSTERÁ×U�I�KN�LI�STE�PJQRI�KR��QNM�P�EHM�q2S�M�S¦EHG�I5�]QRKRERÁÃq2QNU�I�Q1��MO��M�E�¨b��q2Q�JSJM�ENI�PxI�Q�ÁEN�JQ V ��EHM�q2SJK�ENGJI�QRI:MOK1SJq-QRI���KRq2S�EHq-I�ÚbPxI���E�EHGJI:I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S�EHq�QRI����ªG@KRENI���U W ÁÃKREH��EHI�±î I�UJMOKR���JKRKENGJMOK�M�KNKR�JI����JQRENGJI�Q.MOS-D%PJP�ILSJUJMÆÚ-D�±

Ô�M��2�JQRI�K�Â2± «��ÜÁÃU�KNGJq Å ENGJI�QNILKN�J��EHK.q��pEHGJI�I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S$��E�EHM��zILK��2pï¬zr ¬ } ¬zr� } ¬zr «b¨��SJUÛ¬zrøÇ�±�ÏÃE¼KNGJq2���OU V I�SJq�ENI�UùENG]��E Å I@��QRI>SJq�E�PJ��q�ENENMOSJ�D]ÀMOSùENGJI�KRI��2QH��PJGJK�±ñ��ENGJI�QL¨ Å I¦PJ�Oq�E_\Zû|{ wX} {'~ } ������|� } �J������ ü�±Û°�GJILQNI���QNI-E Å qZQRI���KRq2SJK���q2Q:EHGJM�K�½�Ô�M�QNK�E�¨V I������JKRI Å I���QNI Å q2QNÓfMOS��$M�S�EHGJI Å I���Óf� W P�ILQREH��Q V I�U_¨,EHGJq��J�2G@KRENMO�O� V I W q2S�U8�]QRKRERÁq�QNUJILQ�¨�QRI��2M��zI�¨ ])QNIL�¼��MOSJKØ����MOQR� W ���Oq�KNI¦ENqòENGJI>M�UJI�STENM�E W EHQN��SJK���q2QN�z��EHM�q2S_±l°�G�II�ÍoIL�LE¼q2S \ðû�{ wX} {'~ }x������ � }S�J���� � ü�¨�GJq Å IL¤�I�Q�¨.M�KzUJQN���z��EHM���¨d��SJUùKRq M�EzM�Kz���J�ªGù��q2QNI�Lq2ST¤2ILSJMOILSfECEHq�QRI�PJQRI�KRI�STE5ENGJIØIL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S�q���]÷MOS�ENGJMOK�M�SJUJMOQRI���E1����KNG�MOq2S_± É I��Lq2SJU_¨I�¤2ILS?M��ENGJI�PxI�QREN�JQ V ��EHM�q2S Å ILQNI-KN�bÝz�LMOILSfEN� W K�EHQRq2SJ��EHq�KRMO�2SJM��]����SfEN� W UJIL��q�QN�Ð]�¨ENGJI�q2SJ� W Å � W EHqØUJILENI�QR�zM�SJI�M��pEHGJI�UJI���q2QN�z��ENMOq2S�q���]�MOK���q�QNQNIL�LEMOK�ENqØ�Oqmq2Ó¼�ÜE.M�EHKI�ÍoIL�LEq2SO\ ±

¥KNMOS���EHGJI¼��q�QN���J�O�¦UJILQNM�¤2I�U�M�SZD�PJPxI�S�UJM�ÚZó�¨�M�E�M�K�QNI���UJMO� W KNGJq Å S�EHG]�ÜE�EHG�IÇ2Õ

Page 62: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

c

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

d

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

a

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

b

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

Ô*MO�2�JQRI�Â2± «b½,� �Oq�Epq��z\ðû|{ w�} {'~ }x������ � }x������ � üh��E,¤���QNM�q2�JK_ENMO��I�K_��q2QhEHG�Id� �J���OILSbÁÒ¯ UJ��q2SJUJK£ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S_±�ûj�TüV��p�¬zrø¬�±û V ü���p�¬zr�Â2±%û���üV�2p ¬8r «b±û�U|üV�2p�¬zr Çb±

�JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q.KRq2�O��ENMOq2S�ENq�\ðû|{ wX} {'~ } ������ � } ������ � ü�MOKL¨

\Zû|{ wX} {'~ } �`]�K{ w } �`]�K{'~ ü p «Rl û�� w éà��~�üxé ß�� w ��~È�l l û�ÂVéJ� ½ © ¦ û���q2K]ÈWlS{ w é���q2K|ÈWlS{'~�üSé« û��Lq2K]ÈWl¢û�{ w°� {'~vüSéN� ½ k�çʦ �Lq2K]ÈWl¢û�{ w éà{'~vüRüNü û�Â2±øÖ�+Tü

î G�MO�OI�EHG�I�P�ILQREN�JQ V �ÜEHMOq�S�MOK%KN��Ý���M�I�STEH� W K�EHQNq�SJ�¼EHGJ��E1EHG�I�QNI���QNI��L�OI���Q�UJM�ÍoILQNILSJ��ILK

Å M�EHG��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q*P�ILQREN�JQ V �ÜEHMOq�S�EHGJILq2Q W ¨�EHG�I�P�ILQREN�JQ V �ÜEHMOq�S�MOK*KRENMO�O�fKR��Ý���MOILSTEH� W Å I���Ó

Ç�Ö

Page 63: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.3

0.7

1

Thetax

0

0.3

0.7

1

Thetay

7

10

14

H

0

0.3

0.7

1

Thetax

Ô*MO�2�JQRI-Â2± Çb½:� �Oq�E5q���\ðû�{ wX} {'~ }x�J������ }��������� ü���q2Q�EHGJI¼� �J�O��I�SbÁׯ4U��zq2S�UJK £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S��q�Q��2p�� MOS�ENGJI��]QNK�ERÁ×q�QNUJILQ��MO��M�E�±

ENG]��E ENGJI��]QNK�ERÁ×q�QNUJILQ¢QRI�KR�J��E4PJQRqv¤bM�UJI�K¢���f�]���OM�Eª��ENM�¤�I���SJUØKNIL�zM��f�]��STEHM�Eª��ENM�¤2I�P�MO�LEN�JQNIq���GJq Å EHGJI�IL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S$KRGJq2�J��U-PJQNqm��ILI�U_±

Ð ILEREHM�SJ�"�>© � ¨ Å ICKNILICENG]��E�ENGJI��Oq2SJ�ÜÁÃEHM��zI%�OM��zM�E�q��pEHG�ICI�¤2q2����EHM�q2S-�2M�¤�I�KL¨

\Zû|{ wX} {'~ } �`]�K{ w } �`]�K{'~ ü ������ ¦ ¨ Ç p «Rl û�� w éÜ�J~�ü=é ß�� w ��~ÈWl l ûÒÂ�é Â

« ��q2K|ÈWl¢û�{ w2� {'~�üNü8û�Â2±���¬Tü°�G�MOK¢MOK¢PJ�Oq�EREHILU���q2Q¢q2�JQ4KRP�IL��M��J��KNI�E�q��oP]��QN���zI�EHILQNK¢MOS�Ô*MO�2�JQRI�Â2±øÇ�± þ%q�EHI%ENG]��E4EHG�ISf�J��I�QRMO�����,IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S¦UJqbILK%M�SJUJILI�U�UJI���q2QN�d]ùM�S>KN���ªG@� Å � W EHGJ��E%ENGJI���QH��PJG�K�MOS

��

Page 64: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ô*MO�2�JQRI�K Â2± «��ÜÁÃU�IL¤2q���¤2I4EHq�Oqmq2Ó%�OMOÓ�I�EHGJI4�2QN��PJGCMOSCÔ�M��2�JQNI�Â�± Ç�± î M�ENGJq2��EhENGJI%ûË« }'� «2üQRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�¨ £ M�K�MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI���E�EHG�MOK�ILSJI�QR� W·í Ç*î˨�KNq�M�E�MOK�Pxq2KNKRM V ��I�EHq1ENQH��S�KR��q2QR� ENq��V ��KNM�KM�S Å GJMO�ªG \#q�SJ� W UJI�PxI�SJU�K�q2S û�� wX} �J~�üÞ±¢Ï×S�KREHI���U_¨|EHGJI�I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S-I��OM��zM�S]��ENI�K��K����J�ªG÷q���EHG�I�SJq2SJQRI�KNq�S]��STE V ILG]��¤mMOq2Q���K�P�q�KNKNM V �OI�¨ V ��E�EHG�I�QNILKNq2S]��SfE¦��S��2�OIU�I�PxI�SJUJILSJ��I8��QRMOKNM�SJ� ��QRq2� ENGJI�ûË« }3� «�ü�EHILQN� QRI��z��MOS�K�± Ï×S�Ô*MO�2�JQRI�K�Â�±øÈT�wÁ×U Å IP�QNI�KRI�STE4EHGJI�QNI�KR�J��ENK�q��|EHG�I�IL¤�q2�O��ENMOq2S:q�S�EHGJI £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S�q V Eª��MOSJILU VfW QNIL�zqv¤mMOSJ�ENGJI>ûË« }3� «2ü�QNILKNq2S]��SJ��I���QNq2� ENGJI�� �J���OILSbÁÒ¯ UJ��q2SJUJK�ENI�QN�$± î Iz�ªGJ��SJ�2ILU¬� � ENq¬8r ¬2Ç�Ç���SJUÜ�m��]>æ ENq�Â2Â2±�D%�O�,q�EHG�I�Q1P]��QH����ILENI�QNK1��QNI5q�EHGJILQ Å M�KNI��JS��ªG]��SJ�2ILU_±�Ï×SENGJMOKd����KRI�¨mEHGJI1I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S¼KRGJq2�J��U Î ��EREHILS�\ ¨J��SJU���K�Ô�MO�2��QNI�K%Â2±ÌÈT�ÜÁ×Uz��q2Sb�]QN�$¨mENGJMOKM�K�I�Ú�����EH� W Å G]��EG]��PJPxI�S�K�±

âGã�è � ����*��34���.������� �Ø0 ���� ������������.����é �±���102������+� ������

î I-��PJP��OMOILUZEHGJM�KØ� � ¯�Á V ��KRI�U?��PJPJQRqT���ªG�EHq���q�SJKRENQN�J��E¼q2PbEHMO��MOÄLI�UZKRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO�����

Å ��¤2I����JSJ�LENMOq2S�K���q�Q1�T���JKRKNMO��S V �J��P�Pxq�EHILSfENM¿����K�±�°�Gf�JKL¨ Å I:��q�SJKNM�UJI�QRI�Uò� £ ����MO�ÆÁENq2SJMO��S�q���ENGJI���q2QN�$¨

\ðûÄÀ }_Á`}Pµ=w�}Uµ ~�ü�p µ lw é µ l~« éBu%IÞÚbP í � ûUê�À l é?«Wë�À Á éJì Á l ü$î û�Â2±��bÂwü

��

Page 65: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

c

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

d

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

a

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

b

00.3

0.71

Thetax 00.3

0.71

Thetay7

1014H

00.3

0.71

Thetax

Ô*MO�2�JQRI�Â2±ÌÈJ½,� �Oq�Epq��z\ðû|{ w�} {'~ }x������ � }x������ � üh��E,¤���QNM�q2�JK_ENMO��I�K_��q2QhEHG�Id� �J���OILSbÁÒ¯ UJ��q2SJUJK£ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S Å M�EHG�EHG�I>ûj« }3� «2ü%QRI�KNq�S]��SJ�LIzQRI���qw¤�I�U_±$û��Tü°�op ¬zrø¬�±-û V ü��¯p ¬zr�Â2±û��vü��2pï¬zr «b±û�U|ü���p�¬zrøÇ�±

î I-��q2SJKRMOUJILQNILU�E Å q8U�M�Í�I�QNILSTEzPxq�ENI�STEHMO���OKL±ðÔ]q2QØ�*q�ENI�STEHMO����Ϫ¨ Å I�EHqmq2Ó¬u»kØp } ê¬p�ì põ } ë p ¬�±ðÔ]q2Q:�pq�EHILSTEHM¿����ÏNϪ¨ Å I�EHqmq2ÓDuKlMpõ } êÆpíì pâÇ } ë pâ«b±°�G�MOK��Lq2QNQRI�KNPxq2SJU�K�EHq�EHG�I1P�q�EHI�STENM¿���xI�ÚbP í � ûÄÀ l éZÕ Á l ü$îj¨ Å M�EHG�ENGJI%Ú W ÁÒ�ÜÚbMOK�QNq�EH��EHILU�L�Oqm�ªÓ Å MOKNI VTW ÈfÕ�î�±

°�GJIt] IL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S Å ��K�KNq2��¤2I�Ul��q�Q v�w p Â�r Õ }¾v ~Dp ¬8r ¬�¨.�Lq2QNQRI�KNPxq2SJU�MOSJ�ZENqÇ�+

Page 66: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��P]��QREHM�����I��zq��zILSfEN�J�»q��:ûÒÂ�r Õ } ¬zrø¬TüC����QØ� Å � W ��QNq2�/EHGJI-Pxq�EHILSfENM¿���j± °�Gf�JKL¨dEHG�IPJ��QRENMO����I�ILSJI�QR� W MOK�� V qv¤�I1EHGJI V ���zP�GJILMO�2GTE���q2Q V q�ENG�P�q�EHI�STENM¿����K�± î I Å q�QNÓ�ILU¦q�SENGJI�KNPJ��EHMO�����2QRMOU í � È } È�î�± í � È } È�î Å M�EHGØ��KRENI�PØKNM�Ä�I�q���¬zr «b± î I��JKRI�Uz�1�zq��zILSfEN�J�K�EHILP8KRMOÄ�IØq���¬zrø¬TÕb± É EH��QRENMOSJ�$��E�ENMO��Iy�op ¬b¨ Å I�PJQNq2PJ���T��ENI�U@q2��E�ENq·�op ¬zr «¼��q2Q�pq�EHILSTEHM¿����Ï��SJUÜ�°p ¬zr�ÂwÕ���q2Q��pq�EHILSTEHM¿����ÏNÏ�JKNM�SJ�-�¼EHM��zI5KRENI�P@q��d¬zrø¬�Â2±CÏ×S V q�ENG����KNILK�¨mEHGJI.QH�ÜEHIq��o�ªGJ��SJ�2I%q��S] q�S�ENGJI%��QNMOU Å ��Kd��E¢�OI���KRE�Õ�¬§ï KR�¼���O�OILQ ��E4EHG�I%ILSJUq��*ENGJI�IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S�EHGJ��S$��E.EHGJI V I��2M�SJSJMOS��J±

a

-20

2x -2

0

2

y1

2H

-20

2x

b

-20

2x -2

0

2

y1

2H

-20

2x

Ô*MO�2�JQRI�Â2± Õb½�� �Oq�E�q���\ðû�{ w�} {'~ }x�������� }x�J������ ü1��E �op ¬zrø¬���q2Q��*q�EHI�STENM¿����K�Ï���S�U8ÏRϪ±4ûj�Tü�pq�EHILSTEHM¿���hϪ±,û V ü��pq�EHILSfENM¿���hÏRϪ±

Ô�M��2�JQRI�K:Â2± Õ���¨ V P��Oq�Em\ðûÄÀ }_Á`} ���� w } ���� ~ ü���q2Q1ENGJI:E Å q$Pxq�EHILSfENM¿����K���E�EHG�I�K�Eª��Q�ECq��ENGJI�M�QdQRI�KRP�IL�LEHM�¤2I1I�¤2q2����EHM�q2SJKL¨ Å G�MO�OI%Ô�M��2�JQNILK.Â2± Ö���¨ V ��QNI%PJQNq V � V M��OM�E W UJI�S�KNM�E W PJ��q�EHKq�� EHGJI��Lq2QNQRI�KRP�q2S�UJMOSJ� Å ��¤2I����JSJ�LENMOq2S�K�± î GJM�ENI�QRI��2M�q2SJK1�Lq2QNQRI�KNPxq2SJU�ENq�I�S�G]��SJ�LI�UP�QNq V � V MO��M�E W UJILSJKNM�E W ¨ Å GJM��OI$U]��QNÓ�QRI��2M�q2SJK���q2QRQNI�KRP�q�SJUlEHq8UJI�PJ��ILENI�UÛPJQRq V � V M��OM�E W

È2¬

Page 67: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

U�I�SJKRM�E W ±@Ï×S V q�EHGð����KNILK�¨ EHG�I��¼�wÚ�M����J�#PJQRq V � V M��OM�E W UJI�S�KNM�E W �ªG]��SJ��I���QNq2�ºEHG�IV ���ªÓf�2QNq2��SJU$¤������JI1q��¢Â�MOKd��QNq2�æ«�¬ � Ç2¬§ï�±4þ%q�ENI�GJq Å ENGJI Å ��¤�IL���JSJ��EHM�q2SJKQNIL¤�I����KRq2��I�q��]ENGJI��JSJU�I�QN� W MOSJ�%���¿��KNKNM������mU W S]����MO�LK�±�Ô|q�Q*EHG�I�K W ���zI�EHQRMO���2���JKNKRM¿��S V �J��Pq����pq�EHILSTEHM¿����Ϫ¨��L�¿��KRKNM������4EHQN� � I���EHq2QRMOI�KØ��QNI�UJI Î I���EHILUù��QRq2�JSJUZENGJI V ���zP_±@°�Gf�JKL¨ENGJI�QRI�KNGJq��J�OU V I-��UJI�PJ��ILENMOq2Sðq��PJQRq V � V MO�OM�E W MOSZEHG�I���I�STENI�QØq��EHGJI V ���zP_¨¢��S�U��S>I�S�G]��SJ�LI���I�STE�MOS$EHGJI5QNIL�2MOq2S¦��QRq2�JSJU>ENGJI V �J��P_±.D�K1Ô*MO�2�JQRIzÂ�± Ö2�ØMO���O�JK�EHQN��EHILK�¨ENGJMOK4M�K¢IÞÚ����LEN� W Å G]�ÜE�G]��PJP�ILSJK�± D÷KRMO��MO�¿��Q�KNM�EH�]�ÜEHMOq�S�qm���L�JQNK¢MOS�Ô�M��2�JQRICÂ�± Ö V ±�°�GJMOKENMO��I�¨2G�q Å IL¤�I�QL¨bEHG�IU�MOKRENQNM V ��EHM�q2S�M�K4��SJ�2��I�U:KNq��zI Å G]��Ed���Oq�SJ�1EHGJI�U�MOQNIL�LENMOq2SØq��|EHG�IPxq�ENI�STEHMO���˨ Å GJMO�ªG$KNGJq��J�OU V ICIÞÚbP�IL�LEHILU����O��KNKRMO�����O� W ±

-4 -2 0 2 4x

-4

-2

0

2

4

y

a

-4 -2 0 2 4x

-4

-2

0

2

4

y

b

Ô*MO�2�JQRI�Â2±øÖ�½4� QNq V � V MO��M�E W UJI�S�KNM�E W P��Oq�ENK�q��pEHGJI�KNIL�zM����O��KNKRMO����� Å ��¤�IL���JSJ��EHM�q2SJK�2I�SbÁILQH��ENI�Uò��QNq2�âENGJIzI�¤2q2����EHM�q2Sòq2S �pq�EHILSTEHM¿���OKCÏ1��SJU8ÏNϪ±dûj�2ü�°�G�I Å �v¤�IL���JS��LEHM�q2S ��q2Q�pq�EHILSTEHM¿���hϪ±,û V ü�°�GJI Å ��¤2IL����SJ�LENMOq2S$��q2Q�*q�ENI�STEHMO���_ÏNϪ±

È�Â

Page 68: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

°�GJI5q2SJI���I���EN�JQNI�EHGJ��E��z� W SJq�E V I5PJG W KNM�������� W M�STEH�JM�EHM�¤�I�MOK�EHGJICK W ���zI�EHQ W q��ENGJI¢PJQNq V � V MO��M�E W UJMOK�EHQNM V ��ENMOq2S_± £ q Å IL¤�I�QL¨ Å Id�¼� W QRI������O�T��QNq2� KN� V KRI���EHMOq�S�Â2± Õb± «m¨�MOS

Å G�MO�ªG Å I��Lq2SJK�EHQN���LEHILU��]QRKRERÁÃq2QNU�I�Qp�zq2��I�STEN�J���]I���UJK,��q2QhEHGJI¢K W ���zI�EHQNM��4�T���JKRKNM¿��SV �J�zPo¨fENG]��E¢EHGJI�2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�C����SJ�LENMOq2SM]8MOK¢SJq�E¢SJIL��I�KRKH��QRMO� W ��SJMO�f�JI�± � ��Q¢��ILENGJqmUGJ��PJPxI�SJK.EHqØKNIL�OIL�LE.EHG]�ÜE�] Å GJMO�ªG$�2M�¤2I�K.QRMOKNI1ENq���K W ����ILEHQRMO�1��q2��I�STEH��� �]IL�OU_±

âGã�ð � ����������������ä����< Í$�>� ��3 � ; �������34� (

°�G�MOK1�ªG]��P�EHILQ1PJQNILKNILSfENI�U8��� � ¯�Á V ��KRI�U_¨_P�G]��KNIÞÁ×KRP]����I:U�IL��q2QR�¼��ENMOq2S>��PJPJQRqT���ªG�ENqq�P�EHM��zM�Ä�IzENGJI-����S�q2SJMO����� V ��KNMOK Å M�EHG Å GJMO�ªG�EHq@�2��q V ����� W QNILPJQNILKNILSfE¼�@SJI���QR� W MOSbÁENI��2QN� V ��I £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S_±ðódI������JKNI-EHGJM�KØ�zI�EHGJqmU�QNI�U��J��ILKzEHq8�@�2QH��U�MOI�STE�Á×UJILKN��ILSTE��PJPJQNq2���ªGð��q2Q�q2P�ENMO��MOÄLMOSJ�-EHGJI�����SJq2S�MO����� V ��KRMOK:M�S EHGJI��JQNKRE�Á×q2QRUJI�Q:��MO��M�E�¨*M�E Å ��K�����O��I�UòEHGJI�ö � D ��ILENGJqmU MOS ñI��Ò±�«m¨ Å GJILQNI�M�E Å ��K�M�SJM�ENM¿����� W ��PJPJ��MOILU8EHq>UJILENI�Q�Á��MOS�ICENGJI�ILMO�2ILSJI�SJILQN�2M�I�K1q��¢«b¨oÈ�¨o��S�U@ÖzUJIL�2QNILI�q�� ��QNILI�UJq���K W K�EHIL�zKL±1°�GJIØö � D��ILENGJqmU�MOK��Lq2��P]��EHM V �OI Å M�ENG���S W ����SJq2SJM�������QNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2S-q��pPJG]��KRI�KNP]���LI�¨|��S�U���O�Oq Å KEHGJI��Lq2SJK�EHQN���LEHM�q2S@��SJU�¤mM�KN�]����MOÄ���EHM�q2S¦q�� EHGJI�KRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO����� Å ��¤2I����JSJ��EHMOq�SJK�Lq2QNQRI�KRP�q2S�UJMOSJ�:ENq�ENGJI�q2P�EHM��zM�Ä�ILU�����S�q2SJMO����� V ��KRMOK���q2Q�ENGJI��2M�¤�I�S £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S_±

D%K Å ��KØ��I�STEHM�q2SJI�U�M�S�ENGJI�Ï×STEHQRqbUJ���LEHM�q2S_¨4EHGJI���q�ENM�¤���EHM�q2S ��q2Q5EHGJM�K Å q2QRÓZMOKU�I�QNM�¤2ILU¼��QNq2� KRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO�����]�f�]��STEH��� ��I��ªG]��SJMO�LK�± Ï×S¼��MO�2GTE¢q��_ENGJI�QRI�KR�J��ENK¢��q2Q4EHG�I

ÈT«

Page 69: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

\�IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2SzMOS�ñ.IL�Ò±¢«�û���SJU § GJ��P�EHILQ.«2üÞ¨bEHG�MOK���ILENGJqmU��¼� W�V I��JKRIL���J�_M�S¼�JS�UJI�QÒÁK�Eª��S�UJMOSJ�%¤bM V QH�ÜEHMOq�S]���TU W S]����MO�LK�M�S�Pxq2� W ��EHq2��MO�4��q2�OIL���J��I�KL±*ÏÃE��¼� W ����KNq V I��JKRIL���J���K*� Å � W ENq.��q2SJK�EHQR�J�LE*UJMOK�EHq2Q�EHILUbÁ Å ��¤2I V ��KNM�K,KNILENKp��q�QhKN���ÜENEHILQNM�SJ�%�����O�L�J�¿�ÜEHMOq�SJK�¨w��S�UG�I�SJ�LI��¼� W �]SJU-��P�PJ�OM�����ENMOq2S�MOS���I�KRq2KN�Lq2PJM��1PJG W KNMO�LK�±4ÏÃE�KRGJq2�J��U V I�SJq�EHILU�MOS¼ENGJMOKQRI��T��QNU8ENG]��E5EHGJM�K�� � ¯�Á V ��KNI�UZ��PJPJQRqT���ªGZ�Lq2STEª��M�SJK5q�EHGJILQ���ILEHG�qbUJK5��K5KN� V ����KRI�KL±Ô]q2Q�IÞÚ����zP��OI�¨%MOS÷ñ.IL�Ò± Â2Â2¨1©>��M�EHQH�ð��SJU £ I����OI�Q¼�JKNILU q2SJIÞÁ×UJM��zILSJKNM�q2S]��� î ô�ó

Å ��¤2I����JSJ�LENMOq2S�K���KC��UJM�KREHq�QREHILUbÁ Å ��¤2I V ��KRMOK1��q2Q��Lq2��PJ��EHM�SJ�-� V qv¤2I�Á V ��QRQNMOILQ�QNI Î I��ÞÁENMOq2S8��qmILÝ���M�I�STEHKL±>ÏÃE Å ��K�KNGJq Å S_¨ M�S KR� V KNIL�LENMOq2SlÂ�± Õb±�Â2¨pEHG]��E�q2�JQ5� � ¯Ù��ILENGJqmUGJ��K.���JSJM��m��I�KREHI���U W Á×K�Eª��ENI�¨ Å GJM��ªG¦IÞÚ����LEN� W �Lq2MOS���MOU�I�K Å M�EHG�EHG�I�q2SJI�ÁÃUJMO��I�S�KNMOq�S]���î ô�ó Å ��¤�IL���JSJ��EHM�q2SJK�¨|��q2Q.�����h� V qv¤2I�Á V ��QRQNMOILQ�I�SJILQN�2M�I�KL±d°�Gf�JKL¨|ENGJI5©>��M�EHQH�wÁ £ IL�O��I�Q��ILENGJqmU MOKC��q�SfEH��MOS�I�U Å M�EHGJM�SòENGJI�ö � D ��ILENGJqbUo±�Ï×S8EHG�I�MOQCP]��PxI�QL¨ ©>��M�EHQN�>��S�U£ I����OI�Q%QH��M�KNILU�EHGJI:M�KNKN��I:q��¢�2I�SJILQH����MOÄLMOSJ��EHGJILMOQ�ENI��ªGJSJM��f�JI:EHq�GJM��2GJI�Q�UJMO��I�SJKRMOq2S�K�¨��SJU�EHq-����EHMOq�SbÁÒ��S��2�OICK W KRENI���K�± � ��Q�� � ¯�Á V ��KNILUò��PJPJQRqT���ªG@MOK1IÞÚ����LEN� W ENGJMOK��2I�SbÁILQH����MOÄ���EHM�q2S_±

D�EpEHGJM�K*Pxq2M�SfE�¨ Å I¢G]��¤2I�S�q�E W ILE���PJPJ��MOI�U�ENGJI�ö � D���ILENGJqbU�EHq%����EH�]���fK W K�EHIL�zKL±°�G�I:�¼��M�S>UJM�Ý����J��E W M�S�UJI����OMOS�� Å M�ENG�¤bM V QH�ÜEHMOq�S]���,���������J�O��EHM�q2SJK.��q2Q1Pxq2� W ��EHq��zM���KM�K EHG]��EdM�E4M�Kd�L�JQNQRI�STEH� W UJM�Ý��L�J��E4EHq5q V EH��MOS����L���JQN��EHI¤bM V QH�ÜEHMOq�S]���JPxq�EHILSTEHM¿���]I�SJILQN� WKR�JQR������I�KL¨�I�¤2I�SC��q2Q_��I Å Á×��EHq�� Pxq2� W ��EHq2��MO�LK�± £ q Å IL¤�I�Q�¨�M�E Å q2�J��U V I �JKNI����J�TEHq��PJP�� WENGJIdö � Dð��ILEHG�qbU�EHq����EH�]���TK W KREHIL�zK*��EpKNq��zI4Pxq2MOSTE�±,Ï×S5��UJUJM�EHM�q2S_¨ Å GJM��OI Å I Å QRM�EHI

È2Ç

Page 70: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

M�S�EHGJI�Ï×STEHQRqbU��J�LENMOq2S�ENG]��E Å I V I���MOI�¤2I1EHG�ICö � DÙ��PJPJQRqT���ªG-MOK�KRMO�2S�M��]����STEH� W ����K�EHI�QENG]��S?PJQNI�¤bM�q2�JK�����S�q2SJMO����� V ��KRMOK�q2P�ENMO��MOÄ��ÜEHMOq�Sð���O��q2QNM�EHGJ��K-ûj�ÜE¼��I���K�E���q�QØENGJIO\I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S|üÞ¨ Å I����OKRq Å QRq�EHI�EHG]��E�MOSò����MOQRSJI�KRK�SJq�KRP�ILI�Uð�Lq2�zPJ��QNM�KNq2SJK5G]��¤2I V I�ILS�z��UJICEHq�UJ��EHI�±�°�Gm��K�¨,��SJq�EHGJILQ�Pxq�EHILSfENM¿����� W �JKRIL���J�*KREN�JU W Å q2�J��U V I�EHq��Lq2��P]��QNIENGJI5ö � DF��ILEHG�qbU Å M�ENG�EHGJI�¤���QNM�q2�JK�q�ENGJI�Q.��ILENGJqbU�K�q2S$ENGJI��¼��QNÓ�I�E�±

°pq-��q2SJ�L�O�JU�I�¨ Å IØKRGJq2�J��U8��UJU�EHG]��E £ I����OI�Q�G]��K�q�� ENI�S@�¼��UJI�EHGJI:�Lq2��P]��QNM�KNq2SV ILE Å I�ILS?ENGJI�KNILP]��QH�ÜEHQNMÆÚðQRI��2M�q2Sð�2I�S�I�QH�ÜEHI�U VTW ���Oqm������Pxq�EHILSfENM¿��� V �J��PðMOSðq2S�IU�MO��I�SJKRMOq2S@EHq$EHGJIzQNI�KRq2S]��S���I�ÄLq2SJI¼K�EHQR�J�LEN�JQNI�M�SZ�¦�*q2M�SJ����QRI¼KR�JQR�����LI�q���KRI���EHMOq�Sq����:SJI���QN� W M�STEHI���QH� V ��I £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��S í �b¨oÂ2ÂJî˱ Ï×SJU�I�I�Uo¨ £ I����OI�QdQNIL�T��QNU�K�EHGJI�� V qv¤2IÞÁV ��QNQRMOI�QCQNI Î I���EHM�q2SZPJQRq V �OIL�/��K��$PJQNq�ENq�E W P�Iz��q2QCENGJI¼��q2QRIz�Lq2�zP��OMO����EHILU8����KNI¼q��U W SJ���zM������¢EH�JS�SJI���MOSJ� V ILE Å I�ILSùM�Sf¤���QRM¿��STE5EHq2QRMd�����LMO�OM�Eª��ENI�U VfW QNI�KRq2S]��S���I-Ä�q2S�I�K�±ódI������JKNI V q�ENG�E W PxI�K5q���K W KREHIL�zKC����S V IØENQNI���EHILU Å M�EHGJM�SòENGJIØKH����I�� � ¯�Á V ��KNILU��PJPJQNq2���ªG_¨JEHG�I W ��QRI�¨JM�S-�����LE�¨J��q�QN�z���O� W I��f�JM�¤�����I�STEPJGJILSJq2��I�S]��±

È�È

Page 71: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

� Î Â,ÏÐ��� i ñ

Ý � ß b Ú ÄÛÂqt b ÚòÂ�Ä h Â���� bóò  � b ���ô b � f õ ��ö> iàb Âq��� Á � iàb±÷ Ò

ø i ÂqÙ b ���d� ÖØÔ ��tÚÇ���d� Ò Ï Ï i �dÂ,ÚBÎ

°�G�MOK��ªG]��P�EHILQØ��PJPJ��MOI�KCEHGJI�ö � DæPJGJ��KNIÞÁ×KNPJ����I-UJI���q2QN�z��EHM�q2S ��ILENGJqmUZUJIL¤�I���q2P�ILUM�S�EHGJI�PJQRIL¤mMOq2��K�ªGJ��P�EHILQENq:EHGJI�PJQRq V �OIL� q��*UJILENI�QR�zM�SJMOSJ��ENGJI�I�SJILQN� W KRP�IL�LENQH�Øq��V q2�JS�U £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��SJKL±�Ô]q2Q�KR�J�ªG8K W KREHIL�zKL¨_EHGJI�ö � DÀ�zI�EHGJqmU>�]S�UJK���S@q2P�ENMO�z���KRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO����� V ��KRMOK�q��,M�ST¤���QNM¿��SfE¢EHq�QNM Å G�MO�ªG���MOSJM��zM�Ä�I�K ENGJI���SJ���J�¿��Q¢UJILP�ILSJUJI�S���Iq���EHG�I £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S_±Z°�GJM�KzQRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2S?q���ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��SZM�K:EHI�QR�zILUù��S

ÈTÕ

Page 72: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ù ú{ûUü ýÄúAþ�ýPÿ�����þ��Rú��Wú�ÿ������Iü���þ���ú{û �WûUý �Rú û�ÏÒñ%ñ%ü�¨*��SJU M�E���M�¤2ILK�EHG�I�KN�z���O��I�K�E�Pxq2KNKRM�ÁV �OI V ��KNM�K¼q V EH��MOSJ� V �OI-��QNq�� �L�¿��KRKNM�������zIL�ªG]��SJM���KL± î I>UJI���q2SJK�EHQH�ÜEHI>ENGJI�ö � D��ILENGJqmU VTW �]QRKRE%QNILPJQNqmUJ�J�LMOSJ��QNILKN�J��EHK���QNq2� �¼«�UJIL�2QNILI�Á×q��¿ÁÃ��QNILI�UJq��äK W KRENI�� �JKNILUENq�UJIL�zq2S�KREHQN��EHIEHGJI�PJQNI�¤bM�q2�JK § ��QNMOq��OM˨ £ I����OI�QL¨m��SJU$©¦q2���OILQ�û § £ ©�ü¢MO��PJ�OIL�zILSfEH�ÜÁENMOq2S>q�� EHGJI�ÏÒñ%ñ ��PJPJQRqT���ªG_± î I�EHG�I�S��2q�q�S�EHq�KRGJq Å ENG]��E�q2��Q���ILEHG�qbU�����S V I��PJPJ�OM�I�U�ENq�GJMO�2G�I�Q�UJM��zILSJKNM�q2S]��� £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��SJKhENG]��SØPJQNI�¤mMOq2�JKR� W KREH��UJMOILU VTW ��KNMOS��M�E�EHqz¯4ó�ô)�f�]��STENMOÄ�IC�ØÖ:UJI���QNI�IÞÁ×q��¿ÁË��QNILI�UJq2�æK W KRENI��$±

��ãZâ ä ��� 3 �-<����.�������

°�G�I>KNIL�zM����O��KNKRMO�������f�]��STEHM�Ä���ENMOq2S�q��4��ÁÃUJMO��I�S�KNMOq�S]����S�q2SbÁ×KRI�P]��QH� V ��I £ ����MO��ENq2SJMÆÁ��SJK�M�K%��S�q2�OU¦��SJU¦UJM�Ý��L�J��E%PJQNq V �OIL�¦±�ódIL��q2QRI5EHG�I5UJM�KN�Lqw¤�I�Q W q���EHGJI É �ªGJQNqmUJM�SJ�2I�Q¯ �f�]��ENMOq2So¨�EHGJI�KREª��SJU]��QRU�P�QNqm��I�U��JQNI Å ��K ILKNKNILSTEHM¿���O� W Å G]��E�MOK�ÓfSJq Å S:EHqmU]� W ��K�EHG�I¯ M�SJKRENI�MOSmÁÒó�QRMO�O��q2�JM�SbÁÒô�I����OILQCûj¯4ó�ôCü��f�]��STEHM�Ä���ENMOq2S@��ILEHG�qbU_±ØÏ×S@EHGJM�K��zI�EHGJqmU_¨hq2S�I��qbq�ÓmK���q�Q�����SJq�SJMO�����_��q2�zILSTEª�L�ïk } r3r3r } �i` Å GJMO�ªG¦��QRI�MOST¤���QNMO��STEHK�q��pEHGJI £ ���zM���ENq�ÁS�M¿��S_¨xÓfSJq Å S@��K%ENGJI����LEHM�q2S¦¤���QRM¿� V �OI�KL¨o��SJU>EHG�I�S�KRILEHK%EHGJILKNI�M�Sf¤���QRM¿��STENK%IL�m�J���*ENq«Tl � û�Ì` *é Â��© ü�¨ Å G�I�QNI%EHGJI sS h��QNI%ENGJI�©>��KN�Oqv¤�MOS�UJMO�LI�K�±û�D K W K�EHIL� ��q2Q Å GJMO�ªG�KR�J�ªGM�ST¤���QNM¿��SfENK.����S V I���q2�JSJU¦IL¤�I�Q W Å GJILQNI:M�S¦PJGJ��KNI5KNP]���LI�M�K%KN��MOU-EHq V ICMOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI�± ü°�G�I £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��S\ UJILP�ILSJUJKzI�Úb�����JKNM�¤2I�� W q2S�ENGJIO� ����EHMOq�SJKG�ïk } r3r'r } �á`�¨���S�U

È2Ö

Page 73: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

KRq�EHGJIzKNIL�zM����¿��KNKNM������4ILSJI�QR�2MOILK�q���EHG�I £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��Sò��QRI¼�ªG]��QN���LENI�QRMOÄ�ILU VfW �2qmqbU�f�]��SfEN�J� Sm��� V ILQNKp¤bMO� à û�Ì�k } r3r3r } Ì�` ü2p�\Zû��ïk } r3r3r } �i`�ü�¨ Å M�EHGj�J »p�«Rl � û�Ì� ¢é Â��© ü�±¥KN�]���O� W sx »p�«b¨ Å GJMO�ªG$MOK�q V Eª��M�SJI�U���QRq2� ENGJI î ôCóÛEHG�I�q2Q W ±

Ï×S�q2SJIÞÁ×UJM��zILSJKNM�q2S_¨�ENGJMOK�PJQNqm��ILUJ�JQNI�M�K�KRENQH��M��2GTEN��q2Q Å ��QNU_±@°�GJILQNI�MOK�q2SJ� W q2S�I���LEHM�q2S�¤���QNMO� V �OI��|¨|��SJU$M�E�M�K��2M�¤�I�S VfW ¨

�Lp�� µ C§´ ûË«m±�Âwü

Å G�I�QNI�ENGJI���q2STENq2�JQ MOSTENI��2QN����UJILSJq�ENI�K4MOSTEHIL�2QH�ÜEHMOq�S�qv¤2ILQ¢q�SJI�P�ILQNM�qbU�q���ENGJI��zq�EHMOq�S_¨��SJU µ p�¹ Ì «*nòû à � ¹�û�´�üNü�MOK�EHGJIz�zq��zILSfEN�J�#q���ENGJI¼P]��QREHM�����I�±-ÏÃE�M�K5�JKR�]����� WS�q�E4P�q�KNKNM V �OIdEHq�q V EH��MOS"�Gp ��û à ü���S]��� W ENMO�����O� W ¨���SJUzM�S�EHGJI.����KNI.q��x���J��EHM�PJ�OI Å IL�O�OKENGJI�QRI5M�K.�zq2QRI1EHG]��S¦q2S�Ij�¼��q�Q.���2M�¤2ILS à ±dþ%I�¤2ILQREHG�I��OILKNKL¨ Å M�ENG$ENqbUJ� W ÊÌK%Pxq Å ILQR���J��Lq2��PJ��EHILQNKL¨JEHGJI�MO��PJ��I���I�STEª��ENMOq2Szq���ENGJMOK���ILENGJqmU$M�K�QNIL�¿��ENM�¤2IL� W KRENQH��M��2GTEN��q2Q Å ��QRU_±

°�GJM�K5KRMO��PJ�OI�KN�ªGJIL�zIØ����MO��K�MOS@GJM��2GJI�Q�UJM��zILSJKNM�q2SJKL±�°�G�IzPJQRq V ��I��âM�K1EHG]��E���q2Q���2I�S�I�QH���*SJq�SbÁ×KRI�P]��QN� V ��I £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_¨bENGJI5�L�¿��KRKNM������,��q�EHM�q2S-�¼� W ¤2ILQ W Å IL�O� V I�ªGJ��q�EHM���±Ûþq8q�EHGJILQzM�Sf¤���QRM¿��STENK�q�EHGJILQ�ENG]��S�EHGJI$I�SJILQN� W ����S V I$��q��JSJU_¨���SJUùKRqENGJI¼ILSJI�QR�2MOILK�����SJSJq�E V I¼�ªG]��QN���LENI�QRMOÄ�ILU VTW �2qbqmU8���LENMOq2SJKL± � SòEHGJIzq�EHG�I�QCG]��SJU_¨M�� EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S$MOK�KRI�P]��QH� V ��I�¨oENGJI�S�ENGJI�PJQRq V �OIL������S V I V QNq�Ó�I�SòUJq Å S@MOSTEHq��KRI�QRMOI�KØq��q2S�I�UJMO��I�SJKRMOq2SJ���dP�QNq V ��I���K�±8ó�I������JKRI-��q�Q�I����ªG�UJIL�2QNILI-q��.��QNI�ILUJq2�ENGJI�PJG]��KRI�KNP]���LI��zq�ENMOq2S�ENQH���LI�K.q2��E�:�L�Oq2KRI�U$���JQ�¤2I�EHq2Pxq2�Oq��2MO�����O� W I��f�JM�¤����OI�STE�ENq

ÈX�

Page 74: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�@��M�QN�L�OI�¨¢EHGJI¦qv¤2I�QN���O����q�ENMOq2S�q��1ENGJI Å GJq2�OI-K W K�EHIL� ��MOI�KØq2S Å G]��EzMOKØ�����O�OILUù��SM�ST¤���QNM¿��SfEdEHq2QR�JK�± °�G�ICM�ST¤���QNM¿��SfEdEHq2QRM��]���oq2�bE�EHGJI�ILSTEHMOQRI�PJG]��KRI�KNP]����Izû�q2Q���E��OI���KREENGJI�QNI���MOq2S Å M�ENGJMOS8��S W ÓfMOSJU8q���UJM�KNKRqb�LM¿��ENMOq2S@I�S�I�QN� W q���EHG�IzK W K�EHIL��üÞ±�°�GJIzENq2QNM��QNICI����ªG��ªG]��QH����EHI�QRMOÄLI�U VTW ��S�����EHM�q2S¦¤�I��LENq2Qo�_p û��ïk } r3r3r } �i` üÞ¨o��SJU>q2��Q�K W K�EHI��M�K��f�]��STEHM�Ä�I�U$MOS�ENGJI��¼��S�SJI�Q�UJILKN�LQNM V I�U>� V qw¤�I�±

ÏÃ�¢��S¦MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OI�K W K�EHI���MOKP�ILQREN�JQ V I�U_¨���SJU¦EHGJI5P�ILQREH��Q V ��ENMOq2S$MOKKN�bÝz�LMOILSfEN� W

Å I���Óx¨TENGJI�S:��q2KRE�q��|EHGJI�P�G]��KNI�KRP]���LI�MOK�K�EHMO���b�Lqv¤2I�QRI�U VTW MOST¤���QRM¿��STE�ENq2QNM í «�Öïîj±�°�GJMOKM�K�ILKNKNILSTEHM¿���O� W ENGJI���q�SfENI�STE�q�� ENGJI:ô�D�©õ°�G�I�q2QRI��$±�°�Gm��K�¨hM�E%MOK%KRENMO�O�,Pxq2KNKRM V ��I5ENq�JSJU EHG�IzKRI���MO���O��KNKRMO����� I�SJILQN�2M�I�K5�JKNM�SJ�¦ENGJI¼¯4ó�ô ��P�PJQNqT���ªG_±-°�GJI¼�Lq2�zP��OMO����EHM�q2SENG]��Ez��QRMOKNILKØMOK:EHGJI$PJQRI�KNILSJ��I¦q��1QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�Kzq2QØSJI���QÒÁ×QRI�KNq�S]��SJ�LI�K Å G�MO�ªG��OI���U�ENqENGJI���q2QN�z��ENMOq2S�QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI5ÄLq2SJILK�±4Ï×ST¤���QNM¿��SfE�ENq2QNMhK�EHM��O�oIÞÚbMOKREM�SJKNM�UJI�EHG�ICQRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LIÄLq2SJILK � G�q Å IL¤�I�QL¨*EHG�I W ��QRIØUJI�KR��QNM V ILU VTW ��KNI�ECq������LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I5¤���QNMO� V ��I�K Å GJM��ªG����SJSJq�E V I���SJ��� W EHM�������� W ��q2STENMOSf�JI�U>q2��EHKRMOUJICEHGJICÄ�q�SJI�KL±%°�Gf�JK�ENGJI�QRI�M�KS�q��Oq2S��2I�Q��S W ÓfMOSJUðq��%���Oq V ���d���LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��IzUJILKN�LQNMOPbEHMOq�SZq���EHG�I £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S?û�ENGJI���SJ���OI�KV I�M�SJ�zENGJI�����SJq2S�MO�����*�Lqbq2QRUJMOSJ��EHILKªü�±°�GJI5MOSTEHIL�2QH� V �OICQNI���MOq2SJK%q�� PJGJ��KNI�KRP]���LI:��QNIENGJI�QRIL��q2QRI8�Lqv¤2I�QRI�U VTW ����q2���OI���EHM�q2SÛq��:���LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I>¤���QNMO� V �OILK�¨%I����ªG�q�� Å GJM��ªGM�KØq2SJ� W �Oqm������� W ¤����OMOU Å M�EHGJM�Sù�@��ILQREH��MOS�QNIL�2MOq2S�q���PJG]��KRI>KRP]����I�± É ENMO�O�j¨4I����ªG?q��ENGJI-KNI�EHK¼q�����qb����������EHMOq�SJKØ�¼� WðV I-�m�J��STEHMOÄLI�U_¨���SJU VfW U�q2MOSJ�@KRq M�EØM�K:P�q�KNKNM V �OIENqZ��q�SJKRENQN�J��E�EHGJI¦���J�O�%¯4ó�ôºKNPxI��LENQN�J�$±�°�GJI>PJQNq V �OI�� Å M�ENGùEHG�MOKz��PJPJQRqT���ªGÛMOK

��

Page 75: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ENG]��E�f�]��STEH���ØÁÃ�zIL�ªG]��SJM�������� W ¨JENq2QNMhM�S$ENGJICUJM�Í�I�QRI�STE�QRI��2M�q2SJK.q���PJG]��KRI�KNPJ����I�¨�Mj±øI�±�¨KRI�P]��QH��ENI�U VTW QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��I:ÄLq2SJILK�¨,��QRI�KRENMO�O�p��q��JPJ�OILU�EHq�I����ªG@q�EHGJILQ�±zû�D%K1IL¤mM�UJI�SJ�LI��q�Q1EHGJM�K�¨hEHGJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S>����S V IØIL¤����O�J��EHILUòM�S�EHGJI�¯4ó�ôæK�Eª��ENI�K�¨*��SJU@EHG�I�q�ÍxÁU�M¿���2q�S]���hI���I���I�STEHK1��QNICSJq2SbÁˤ���SJMOKRGJMOS��fü�±.°�GJI�ILSJI�QR� W$Î q Å V I�E Å ILI�S@KN�J�ªG�ENq2QNM,MOKÓfSJq Å S$��K � W S]���zM������|°p�JSJSJIL�OMOS��J¨J��S�U�M�E���I���U�KdEHq�ENGJI V QRI���ÓfM�SJ��q��pUJIL�2I�SJILQH���LMOILKq�Q%SJI���Q�ÁÃUJI���I�SJILQH���LMOI�K�MOS-EHGJI�¯¢ó�ô ILSJI�QR�2MOILK�±°�GJI�� V qv¤2I5�zI�EHGJqmU>q�� �f�]��STEHM�Ä�MOS��ENGJI��Oqm������KNI�EHKq������LEHM�q2SJK�����M��OK�ENq:Eª��Ó�ICENGJMOK�M�SfENq������Lq2�JSTE�±

D%S@����ENI�QNSJ��EHM�¤2I5��PJPJQRqT���ªG�M�K%EHq¼QNI��z��M�S¦M�S��z�2��q V ���p����EHM�q2SbÁÒ��SJ�2�OI V ��KNMOKL¨_��S�UENq8ENQH��SJK���q2QN� ENqZ�8KRILE¼q�������EHMOq�SbÁÒ��S��2�OI�¤���QRM¿� V ��I�K Å GJM��ªGl�zM�SJMO��MOÄLI�K�ENGJI���S��2�OIU�I�PxI�SJUJILSJ��I%q��xEHGJI £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��So± É �J�ªG���QRI�PJQRI�KNILSTEª��ENMOq2SzMOK�EHILQN��I�U���S ù�ú{û�ü ýÄúAþ�ýPÿ����þ��Rú��Wú�ÿ�������Iü���þ���ú{û��Wû�ý �Rú û�ÏÒñ%ñ%ü�¨p�¦ENI�QN�#�Lq2MOSJILU VTW § ��QNM�q2�OM I�E:���j± í Ç*îj±¦°�G�I��SJ�2�J�O��Q%U�I�PxI�SJUJILSJ��I:q��¢� £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S�M�K���MOSJM��zM�Ä�I�U Å GJILS�EHGJI���SJ�2�J�O��Q.EHI�QR�zK��QNIz���O��QRI�KRq2S]��STE�ENI�QR�zK�q��dEHGJI�Ä�ILQNq�ENGbÁ×q2QRUJI�Q £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��So±:ÏÃE�M�KCM��zPxq2KRKNM V �OI�ENqQRI�UJ����I�EHGJI���S��2�J�¿��Q�UJI�PxI�SJU�I�SJ�LIC���JQ�EHGJILQ�¨]KRMOSJ�LI�ENGJI�QNILKNq2S]��SfE.ENI�QN��K��OI���U�EHq:EHG�I��q�QN�z��EHM�q2S:q��_QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�ÄLq2SJI�K Å GJM��ªG¼PJQRIL¤2ILSTE.�C���Oq V ���]���LENMOq2SmÁÒ��SJ���OI�UJILKN�LQNMOPbEHMOq�Sq��*ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S_±

î I%ENGJI�Sz�JKNI�ENGJIÏÒñ%ñlEHq�QNMx��Kd�5KNIL�zM����O��KNKRMO����� V ��KNM�K Å M�EHG Å GJMO�ªGzEHq�QRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEq��JQ £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��SCMOSØ�z��EHQRM�ÚC��q2QN�$±�ódI������JKNI���J�ªGØq��xEHGJI.�L�¿��KRKNMO������U W SJ���zM���K G]��K���OQNI���U WòV I�I�S�� V KNq2Q V ILUZMOSTENq>EHGJIzÏÒñ%ñ EHq�QNM˨*�OI��v¤mM�SJ�>q2S�� W EHGJIz�f�]��STEH�J�/EHQN��SJK�Á

�+

Page 76: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Pxq2Q�E¢����QRq2KNK¢QNILKNq2S]��SJ��IÄ�q2S�I�K�¨mM�E�MOK4P�q�KNKNM V �OI�ENq�q V Eª��MOS:EHGJI.KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO������ILSJI�QR�2MOILK��KNMOS��@�>���J�ªG�KN�z�����OI�Q V ��KRMOK�ENG]��SðQRI��f�JMOQRI�U Å M�EHG���Ä�ILQNq�ENGbÁ×q�QNUJILQ:���LENMOq2SmÁÒ��SJ���OIQRI�PJQRI�KRI�STEª��ENMOq2So±>Ô]�JQ�EHGJILQN��q2QNI�¨�PJG W KNM������dMOSJKRMO�2GTECMOKCq V EH��MOSJILU_¨�KRMOSJ�LIzENGJI¼QRI�KN����ERÁM�SJ� V ��KRMOK�MOK�U�I�QNM�¤2ILU8��QNq���EHG�I���SJUJI�QR� W MOS��$U W SJ���zM���K�q��¢EHGJIØK W K�EHIL�¦¨ Å GJMO��I�EHG�Iq�QNMO��MOS]��� V ��KNM�K�û�I�±Ì�J±¦GJ��QN��q2SJM���q�KN��M��O�O��EHq2QRKªü�M�K5q�� ENI�SZ�ªG�q2KNILSZ��q2Q5�Lq2��PJ��Eª�ÜEHMOq�S]����Lq2ST¤2ILSJMOILSJ��I�±

§ ��QRMOq2��M˨ £ I��O��I�QL¨%��SJU�©¦q2�O��I�Q�û § £ ©>ü�P�� V �OM�KNGJILU÷��Sï���O��q2QNM�EHGJ� M�SFÂZ+�+X�8ENq�Lq2SJK�EHQN���LE1ENGJI�ÏÒññ V ��KNM�K%��QNq������2M�¤�I�S £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S í Çïî˱%°�GJI�M�Q���ILEHG�qbU Å ��K1���I�SJILQH����MOÄ��ÜEHMOq�S�q��dENGJI § G]��PJ�z��S_¨*ö���QNQRILENE�¨p��SJU ©¦MO���OI�Q:û § öC©�ü í È�î4��ILENGJqbU���q2Q�JSJUJMOS���MOST¤���QNMO��STE�ENq2QNMpq��¢��SJI���QN� W KRI�P]��QH� V ��I�K W K�EHI��$± � SJI�UJQN� Å V ���ªÓ Å M�ENG>EHG�I§ £ © �zI�EHGJqmUðMOK�ENG]��E:M�E:QNIL�f�JMOQRI�KØ��PJQRMOq2QRMdÓfSJq Å �OILUJ�2I�q�� Å GJM��ªGðEHI�QR�zK:M�S EHG�I£ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S>��QNI�EHq V IØ��q2S�KNMOU�I�QNILU@QNI�KRq2S]��S���I�KL¨���SJU Å GJMO�ªGò��QRI�S_Ê E�±�°�G�I § £ ©��ILENGJqmUòENQH��SJK���q2QN��KC� Å � W EHGJI�SJq2SmÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��STE5ENI�QN��K��JKNM�SJ�¦��S M�EHI�QN��EHM�¤2I:KR�ªGJI���IENG]��E.�JPxU]��ENI�K�EHG�I1���J�O� £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S¼�ÜE.IL¤2ILQ W M�EHI�QN��EHM�q2S�K�EHI�Po± § q�Sf¤�I�QR�2I�SJ�LI�q2S�� WQRI��f�JM�QNI�KC����I Å M�ENI�QH�ÜEHMOq�SJK�¨o��SJU@EHGJI��]SJ��� £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S$��q2STEH��MOSJK�q�SJ� W EHGJIØQNILKNq�ÁSJ��STECENI�QR�zKL± £ q Å IL¤2ILQ�¨*q�� EHILS@ENGJI:EHILQN��K���QNI:SJq�E�I�Ú����LEN� W QRI�KRq2S]��STE�¨ V �bE5S�I���QR� WQRI�KRq2S]��STE�±ÙÏ×SÛPJQRMOSJ�LMOPJ��I�¨�SJI���Q�ÁÃQNILKNq2S]��SJ��ILK-��QNI>ENq V I>EHQRI���ENI�U÷�OM�Ó�I>QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�KL±¥S���q2Q�EH�JS]�ÜEHI�� W ¨¢EHGJM�K�M�K��òPxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��EHM�q2SbÁÃUJI�PxI�SJU�I�STEzENI�QR�¦¨���SJU�EHGf�JKzENGJI�QRI¦M�K���LI�Q�Eª��M�S¼��� V MO�2��M�E W M�S�ENGJIENQH��S�KNM�ENMOq2SØ��QNq��ÀQNIL�T��QNU�MOSJ�5�CENI�QN� ��K�SJq2SmÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��STEdENq

Õ�¬

Page 77: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

QRI�KRq2S]��STE�±D%SJq�EHG�I�Q4UJQH� Å V ���ªÓ Å M�EHG�ENGJI § £ ©ä�zI�EHGJqmU:MOK�ENG]��E¢��E4I����ªG�KREHILP_¨fM�E M�K SJI��LI�KÒÁ

KN��Q W ENqzI�¤����O�]�ÜEHIC�����J��ENMOUJM��zILSJKNM�q2S]���xMOSTEHIL�2QH���,��SJU-EHq�MOST¤2ILQRE��zSJq2S��OMOS�I���Q.��S��2�OI�z��P_±:°�G�I�KNI���I���EN�JQNILK�KN�Oq Å EHGJI������2q2QNM�EHGJ� UJq Å S_¨p�z��ÓfMOSJ�-M�E1UJM�Ý�������E�EHq$KREN�JU WK W KREHIL�zK Å M�ENG-�zq2QRI1EHG]��S�«�q2Q.Ç:UJIL�2QNILI�Kq�����QRI�I�U�q2�¦±

°�GJI$PJQRIL¤mMOq2��Kz�ªG]��P�EHILQzPJQRI�KRI�STEHILUÛ��S?����ENI�QNSJ��EHM�¤2I-��PJP�QNqT���ªG�EHq@�]SJU�MOSJ��EHG�IÏÒññ V ��KNM�K�¨_S]���zIL� W ¨�EHGJI�ö � D �zI�EHGJqmU_±C°�GJMOK��zI�EHGJqmU�UJqmI�K�SJq�E1QNI��f�JM�QNIØ��S W �P�QNMOq�QNM¢��KNKRMO�2S��zILSfE�q���Pxq�EHILSfENM¿���4EHILQN��K:��K5QNI�KRq2S]��STE:q�Q�SJq2SbÁÃQNILKNq2S]��SfE�±�D�E:I����ªGM�EHILQH��ENMOq2S¦KREHILP@IL¤2ILQ W EHI�QR� M�S>EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S-MOK���U � �JKRENI�U�UJILP�ILSJUJM�SJ��q2S�GJq Å�L�Oq2KRI:M�E�M�K�EHq V I�MOS��$QRI�KRq2S]��STE�±Ø°�GJIØ��ILENGJqbUo¨,��K�MO��PJ�OIL�zILSTEHI�U�M�S�EHGJM�K��ªG]��P�ENI�Q�¨M�K���K.���L���JQN��EHI���K�EHGJI § £ ©/���O�2q2QRM�ENGJ� MOS�q V Eª��M�SJMOSJ�CEHGJI�KRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO�����xI�SJILQN�2M�I�K�±ÏÃENK��z��MOSz��U�¤���STEª���2I�M�KdEHGJ��E�M�E���¤2q�MOUJKdIL¤����O�J��EHM�SJ��������EHM�UJMO��I�S�KNMOq�S]����M�STEHI���QH����Kdq2QM�ST¤2I�Q�EHM�SJ��SJq2S��OMOS�I���Q���SJ�2��I��z��PJK�± °�Gf�JKL¨ Å I V IL�OMOI�¤2I�ENG]��E�M�E�M�K����J�ªG�����K�EHILQ�EHG]��SENGJI § £ © �zI�EHGJqmU_¨,�¼��ÓmM�SJ�-M�E�Pxq2KRKNM V �OI:EHq��]SJU8ÏÒñ%ñ)ENq2QNM�MOS@GJMO��GJI�Q�UJIL�2QNILI�KCq����QRI�ILUJq2�æENG]��S$PJQNI�¤bM�q2�JKR� W K�EH�JU�MOI�Uo±

°�GJM�K4�ªG]��P�ENI�Q4MOK�q�QN�T��S�MOÄ�ILU���K���q2�O��q Å K�½,Ï×S É I��LENMOq2Sz«b± «b¨ Å I.�2M�¤�I.� V QNMOI��xQNIL¤mM�I Åq��bENGJI § ö5© ��ILEHG�qbU���q2Qo�JSJUJMOS��.ENGJI4MOST¤���QNMO��STE_EHq�QNM2q�����SJq2SbÁÃQNILKNq2S]��SfE,K W KREHIL�¦±*Ï×SÉ I��LENMOq2S¼«b±øÇ�¨ Å I%UJI�KR��QRM V IENGJI § £ ©��2ILSJI�QN���OM�Ä���ENMOq2S:q���EHGJI § öC©���ILEHG�qbU_¨ Å GJM��ªG���O�Oq Å K�q2S�I�ENq-�JSJU8ENGJIzÏÒññ)EHq�QNM q���� £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S_±�Ï×S É I���EHM�q2SZ«m±øÈJ¨ Å I Å QRM�EHI

ÕmÂ

Page 78: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

U�q Å S:ENGJI�KNPxI��LM��]����q�QN�Ùq��|EHGJI�\ IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S�IL�f�]��EHM�q2S���q2QpEHGJI�K W KREHIL�zK4q��|M�STEHI�QRI�K�EM�S EHG�MOK��ªGJ��P�EHILQ�±@Ï×S É IL�LEHM�q2S�«b± Õb¨ Å I�UJILKN��QRM V I�EHGJI¼Sm���zILQNMO�����¢MO��PJ�OIL�zILSfEH��EHM�q2Sq��5q��JQ��zI�EHGJqmU_±)Ô�MOS]���O� W ¨�MOS É IL�LENMOq2Sï«b±øÖ Å I@PJQRI�KRI�STE$q2�JQ�Sf�J��I�QNM������%QNILKN�J��EHK�±î I��]QRKRE V IL�2MOS VTW U�I���q2SJKRENQH��ENMOSJ�¼q2�JQ���ILEHG�qbU��JKRMOSJ��ENGJI:KH����I�«wÁÃUJMO��I�SJKRMOq2SJ���£ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S Å GJMO�ªG § ��QRMOq2��MI�E-���j±F�JKNILU÷ENqðUJI���q2SJK�EHQN��EHI>ENGJI § £ © ��ILENGJqmUí Ç*îj± î IzENGJI�S �2q>q2S8EHq>KRGJq Å EHG]��E5q2�JQC��ILEHG�qbUZ����S V I¼��KNI�UZENq>K�EH�JU W GJM��2GJI�QU�MO��I�SJKRMOq2S]���_K W KRENI���K%ENG]��S>P�QNIL¤mM�q2�JKN� W KREN�JUJMOILU_¨ VfW ��qbq�ÓmM�SJ����E%�¼ÖØUJMO��I�S�KNMOq�S]���IÞÚ����zP��OI�±

��ã � � ( � ����� � �%� ( �-<

°�G�I § öC© ��ILENGJqbU�MOK$��SïM�ENI�QH�ÜEHM�¤�Iò���O�2q�QNM�ENGJ� ENG]��E-�]SJU�K¦EHG�I8M�Sf¤���QRM¿��STE�ENq2QNMq��dKRq2��I £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S·\ðû|{ }�� üÞ±5ÏÃE�U�qbILK1EHGJM�K VTW �]SJUJM�SJ�-���2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�����JSJ��EHMOq�S].û�{ }T! ü�¨�ENQH��S�KR��q2QR�zM�SJ�%��QRq2�FEHGJI.����EHM�q2SbÁÒ��SJ�2�OILK�û�{ }�� ü,ENq�û�¶ }�! üÞ¨�KNq1ENG]��E2\Zû|{ }�� ü�p�\ û ! ü�¨ Å GJILQNI �\ UJILSJq�ENI�K¦ENGJIòQNI�P�QNI�KRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�S�q��"\ MOS÷EHG�I8SJI Å ���LENMOq2SmÁÒ��SJ���OI�Lqbq�QNUJM�S]��EHILK�±

î I�KREH��QRE Å M�EHGðKNq��zI�M�STEHI���QH� V ��IM�»Á�UJM��zILSJKNM�q2S]��� £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��St\ ç û � ü�¨�ENqÅ G�MO�ªG Å I¦��UJU?�òKR�¼���O��PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��ENMOq2SB¹¼û �Û} {�ü�¨ Å GJI�QRI Å I¦����S�I�ÚbP]��SJU­¹ºM�S��

Õ�«

Page 79: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ô]q2��QNMOILQ É ILQNMOILK�¤bMO��¨¹¼û|{ }�� ü�p bc�¦¨0ª ¹ c û � ü#� lÊþ'  cTd � ûË«m± «2ü

Å G�I�QNI m pÀûPÒ8k } H^H^H } Ò§` üÞ¨TMOK �1¤�I��LENq2Q4q���MOSTEHIL�2I�QRK í «��Yî˱ î I�UJq2SoÊÌE4M�SJ�����JUJI�EHG�I�Ä�I�QRq¤�I���EHq2QL¨oKNM�SJ��ICEHGJM�K%����S V I�� V KNq2Q V ILU�MOSTENqM\ ç ± É MOS���ICq2�JQP�ILQREH��Q V ��ENMOq2S¦MOKKN�z���O�j¨Å I Å QNM�EHI�].û|{ }T! ü���KU].û|{ }T! ü�p ! H�{Hé��¼û�{ }T! ü�¨ Å GJI�QRI��zû !ï} {�üUp�� c�¦¨0ª � c û ! ü,� lÊþ'  cRd � ±°�G�ICS�I Å ��S�U¦q2��U-���LENMOq2SmÁÒ��SJ���OI�¤���QRM¿� V ��I�K���QNI�QNIL�¿��ENI�U-EHqØI����ªG¦q�ENGJI�Q�¤mM¿�b¨

� p ! éDK � �zû|{ }�! ü ûË«m± ÇTü

¶ pò{�éDK��$�¼û�{ }T! ü ûË«m±øÈfü

°�G�I�QNI���q2QNI�¨H\ðû�{ }�� üVp \ðû ! é K � �¼û�{ }T! ü } {�ü�p �\ðû�{ }T! ü�± î I5����S�IÞÚ�PJ��SJU �\/MOS¦�Ô]q2��QNMOILQ É ILQNMOILK.MOS·{b¨ Å QRM�EHM�SJ�J¨

�\ðû�{ }T! ü�p b�� �\ � û ! ü,� lÊþJ  � d � ûË«m± Õ2ü

Å G�I�QNI�¨ �\ � e �\ � í ë � c ìZîÃû ! üUp g \ðû|{ }T! éJK � �zû|{ }T! üNü,� ½ lÊþJ  � d ��C { ûË«m± ÖTü

Å G�I�QNI5I����ªGê{' �M�K%M�SfENI��2QN��EHILU¦��QRq2�ä¬�ENq>Â2±�°�GJI��2q2���hq���ENGJI § öC©/��ILENGJqmU>MOK�ENqENGJI�S$�ªGJqmq2KNICq2�JQ�� c û ! ü�KNqØEHG]��E�¨

�\ � í ë � c ìZîÃû ! ü�p�¬ }H\ �p P ûË«m±è�2ü

Õ�Ç

Page 80: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

°�G�MOK.MOK�UJq�SJI��JKNM�SJ�z��þI Å ENq2SbÁÒñ��PJG�KNq2S$M�ENI�QH�ÜEHMOq�S�KN�ªGJIL�zI�¨x��E�EHGJI�ILSJU¦q�� Å GJM��ªG

Å ICG]��¤2Im\ðû|{ }�� ü�p �\ ç û ! ü�¨]��KRKN�J��MOS�� Å ICq V Eª��MOS���q�Sf¤�I�QR�2I�SJ�LI�±°�GJI V I����bE W q��xEHGJM�K �zI�EHGJqmU:MOK�ENG]��E EHG�I.���LENMOq2SJK ! q��|EHGJI��]S]����EHq2QR�JK4��QRI.�bÚ�ILU

�ÜE�EHG�I�KREH��QRE:q���EHGJI����O�2q2QRM�ENGJ� VTW ENGJI��JKRI�Q�±@ó W KRILENENMOSJ� ! p�«Tl � û \ é kl ü�¨ Å IQRI���U�MO� W q V EH��MOS�ENGJIC¯¢ó�ô)KNPxI���EHQN���äq��*ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S_±

��� � ( � ��� � � �%� ( �-<

°�G�I § ö5©»��ILENGJqmU¦����M��OK Å GJI�S�ENGJI�QRI:��QNI5QNILKNq2S]��SJ��ILK�MOS>ENGJI £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_±.ó�I�Á�����JKRI�q��]EHG�I���q2QN�z��ENMOq2SCq��|QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��I�Ä�q2SJILK MOSCEHGJI�P�G]��KNI�KNP]���LI�¨2ENGJI § öC©æQNI�P�QNI�ÁKRI�STEª�ÜEHMOq�Szq��xEHG�I £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S�M�Kd����qb�����Jq2SJI�¨m��SJUØEHGf�JK¢����SJS�q�E¢G]��SJUJ��I��f�]��STEH�J�I�ÍoIL�LENK�KN���ªG���K�U W SJ���zM������_EN�JSJSJIL�OM�SJ�J±�°�G�I § £ ©/�zI�EHGJqmU_¨]q2S$EHGJICq�EHG�I�QG]��SJU_¨QRI��z��MOS�K�MOS$�����Oq V ���_����EHMOq�SbÁÒ��S��2�OI V ��KNM�KI�¤2ILS>MOS�ENGJI5P�QNI�KRI�SJ�LI�q��*QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��ILK�±�ÏÃEU�qbILK4ENGJMOK VTW QNILUJ�J�LMOSJ��EHGJI%��SJ���J�¿��Q U�I�PxI�SJUJILSJ��I%q��oENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S:��K¢���J�ªG���KPxq2KRKNM V �OI�¨ V �bEdS�q�E��Lq2��PJ�OI�EHI�� W ¨T��I���¤mMOSJ��q2SJ� W EHG�q2KNI%��SJ�2���¿��Q�ENI�QN��K¢��q2QRQNI�KRP�q�SJUJMOS��ENqØQNI�KRq2S]��S���I�K���SJU$����EHM�¤�I�����KRE.EHILQN��K�±

î I5M��O���JKRENQH��ENI%EHG�I5��ILENGJqbU-M�S-ENGJICKNMO��PJ��I�KRE.����KNI�¨]EHG]��E.q�� �:KNM�SJ�2�OI�QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LIt ±�û�ÏÃ�! _û � ü:UJI�S�q�EHILKzEHG�I¦ÄLI�QNq�EHGbÁÃq2QNUJILQ���QRI��f�JILSJ��M�I�K¼q���EHG�I £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��S_¨�EHGJILS�8QNI�KRq2S]��S���I t ��E¼Ä�I�QRq�EHGmÁ×q2QRUJI�Q¼���LENMOq2S � ��I���SJK�EHG]�ÜE" _û � ü.H t pB¬�±�D�E Å q�Á

ÕÜÈ

Page 81: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

U�MO��I�SJKRMOq2S]����I�Ú�����PJ��IòM�K�M��# XkLû à k }áà lªütp «$ ïlÜû à k }áà lÞüÞ¨�EHG�I�S t p û� }'� «2ü�M�K-�QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI1��E1û à k }áà lÞüÞ± ü�°�G�I%EHQRMO�ªÓ:M�K4ENq V QNI���ÓØENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S�M�SfENqCE Å q�PJM�I��LI�K�±°�G�I��JQNKREPJM�I��LIC�Lq2SJKRMOKRENK.q������O��ENGJI�SJq2SbÁÃQNILKNq2S]��SfE.ENI�QN��K�¨|��SJU-�¼� W�V I�I�ÚbPJQRI�KNKRI�U��K�¨

\L¥&%vû|{ }�� ü�p b� ¦¨ º(' « º ¦¨ ç \ � û � ü,� lÊþJ  � d � ûË«m±��Tü

°�G�ICKRI��Lq2SJU>P�MOI��LI���q2SJKRMOK�EHKq��*ENGJI�QNILKNq2S]��SfE.ENI�QN��K�¨|��SJU-�¼� W�V I�I�ÚbPJQRI�KNKRI�U@��KL¨

\#%wû|{ }�� ü�p bº ¦¨ ç \ º(' û � ü#� lÊþ'  º(' d � ûË«m±�+Tü

Ï×S�ENGJI § £ ©B�zI�EHGJqmU_¨ Å IØ��P�PJ� W �¼��qbU�M��]ILU § öC©»�zI�EHGJqmU¦ENq�\L¥&%���K���q2�O��q Å K�½°�G�I1Ô]q2�JQRMOI�Q4�Lq2�zPxq2SJILSTEHK¢q��x\ MOSzENGJISJI Å ����EHM�q2SbÁÒ��SJ�2�OI�¤���QRM¿� V �OI�K¢��QRI%��M�¤2ILS VTW ¨

�\ � û ! üfe �\ � í ë � c ìZî×û ! ü�p�g \ðû ! éDK � �zû|{ }T! ü } {�û�¶ }�! üRü,� ½ lÊþ'  � d ) C�¶ ûË«b±�Âv¬Tü

î IC�JKNICEHGJI�þ%I Å ENq2SbÁ×ñ%��P�GJKNq2S>�zI�EHGJqmU$ENq¼KRq2��¤�I �\ � í ë � c ìZîÃû ! ü�pF¬ }ª\ �p µ]t }Pµ �p¬b±�D�E1I����ªG�KRENI�P¦q���EHG�I5M�EHI�QN��EHM�q2S_¨JENGJI5�z��P ¶ º ¥Z¿ pA{�éDK*�$� º ¥3¿ û�{ }T! ü�MOKMOST¤2ILQREHILU��KNMOS����ZPJQNqm��ILUJ�JQNI@UJI�¤2IL�Oq2PxI�U VTW î ��QNSJqm�ªÓl��SJUïñ��ENG í Öïî˱ °�GJI�PJQNq��2QH��� MOKK�EHq2P�P�ILU Å GJILS EHGJI�SJq2SmÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��STE�Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ���q2��P�q�SJI�STEHK5��QRI�KR�¼���O�OILQ�EHGJ��S KRq2�zIKRP�IL��M��]I�U$I�QRQNq2QL±¢°�G�ICQRI�KR�J��EH��STE £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��S¼�z� W EHG�I�S V I Å QNM�ENENI�S¦��K�¨

�\ðû�¶ }T! ü@p b º �\ º+' � lÊþ'  º+' d ) ûË«b±�Â2Âwü

Õ�Õ

Page 82: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

î IdENGJI�S:��KNI�ENGJI�QNILKN�J��EHM�SJ�%ENq2QNMb��K��%KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM������ V ��KNMOK Å M�EHG Å GJMO�ªG�ENq1��q�SJKRENQN�J��Eq��JQ5�z��ENQNM�Ú�QNILPJQNILKNI�STEH��EHM�q2S q��dEHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S_±:ÏÃ� Å I��OI�E·æ \ ��UJI�S�q�EHIz� V ��KNMOKK�Eª��ENI>�Lq2QNQRI�KNPxq2SJU�MOSJ�òEHq8ENGJI¦ENq2QN��K Å M�ENGl����EHM�q2SJK ! � p»«Rlr� û \ é kl üÞ¨�EHGJILSùEHG�IKRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO�����o�Lq2�JPJ��MOSJ�·� Y æ�ñ\Ææ \ ��M�K��2M�¤�I�S VTW ¨

ñ\�, � p�\�, ½ � û ! ,Dé ! �« ü ûË«b±�Âw«2ü

Å G�I�QNI�\�, ½ � UJI�SJq�EHI�K4EHG�I Y&�-\ Ô|q��JQNM�I�Q ��q��zPxq2SJILSfE¢q��H\ í +*îj±�°�GJM�K¢IÞÚbPJQNILKNKNM�q2SS�I��2��I��LENK4��q2STEHQRM V �bEHMOq�SJK���QNq2� EHGJI.�L�¿��KRKNMO�����O� W ��q2Q V M�UJUJILSzQRI��2M�q2S � GJq Å IL¤2ILQ�¨bM�� Å I�ÊøQRIÅ q2QRÓmM�SJ�¼M�S���QNI���MO��ICM�S Å GJM��ªG��zKRI���MO�L�¿��KRKNMO�����,��S]��� W KNM�K��M�¤2ILK1���L���JQN��EHI5QNILKN�J��EHK�¨ENGJI�S Å I%I�ÚbPxI��LE�KN�J�ªG��Lq2STEHQRM V ��ENMOq2S�K4ENq V I%KR�¼���O�,û�KNMOS���I.EHGJI�¯¢ó�ô Å ��¤2I����JSJ��EHMOq�SJKU�I���� W QN��PJMOU�� W q2��EHKRMOUJI�ENGJI����¿��KNKNM�������� W �����Oq Å ILU-QNI���MOq2S|üÞ±

Ï×SlENGJI��zq�QNI>��I�SJILQH���%����KRI�q��C���J��EHMOP��OI-QNILKNq2S]��SJ��ILK�¨%ENGJI�KRI�EHILQN��K����JK�E V IM�SJ�����JUJILU�M�STEHq4\#% MOSØq2QRUJI�Q�ENq����ªGJM�IL¤2I.�Lq2ST¤2I�QR�2I�S���I�±¢ÏÃE4�z� W ���OKRq V I�S�I���ILKNKN��Q W ENqM�SJ�����JUJISJI���Q�Á×QRI�KRq2S]��SJ�LI�K�q�QdI�¤2I�S�����KRE�ENI�QR�zK�û�M�SzEHG�I�����KNI1q��_�ªG]��q�ENMO�U W S]����MO��KHü�±

Õ�Ö

Page 83: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��ã#� � ( � � 34��<��������*+�!/����.����� ë ����3 ����� (

�.-±�#� / y{'10B)17x=3254 /!-06�-068776 998 8 7�-068':°�G�I�QNI8��QRI@E Å qù�z��M�SïU�QH� Å V ���ªÓfK¦ENq�ENGJI § £ © �zI�EHGJqmU_½�Ô�MOQRKRE�¨%EHG�IòENQNMO�ªÓùq��QRI���qv¤bM�SJ��QNILKNq2SJ��STEpENI�QR�zK_��QRq2��ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��SQN�JS�KpM�STEHq�EHQRq2� V ��I MOS1ENGJI ����KRI4q��S�I���QÒÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��ILK�± Ô]q2Q_��KREHQRq2SJ�2ILQ,P�ILQREH��Q V ��ENMOq2So¨vSJI���QÒÁ×QRI�KNq�S]��SJ�LI�K*��SJU�KNq2��ILENMO��I�KI�¤2ILSØ����KRE�ENI�QN��K�SJILI�U:EHq V I�QRI���qv¤2I�UØM�S�q2QNU�I�Q*��q�Q�EHGJI�þ%I Å ENq2SbÁ×ñ%��P�GJKNq2S:��ILENGJqmUENqØ��q2ST¤2ILQN�2I�± £ q Å I�¤2I�QL¨]EHGJILKNI�I�Úb�����JUJILU¦EHILQN��K�KNGJq��J�OU-KRENMO��� V I�QNILUJ�J��ILU���K����J�ªG��K�Pxq2KNKRM V ��I�¨�ENGJq2�J�2G SJq�E�S�I���ILKNKN��QNM�� W ��q2��PJ��ILEHIL� W ±>ó�IL������KNI�EHG�I § £ © ��ILENGJqmU����MO�OK,EHq�UJq1EHGJM�K�¨2M�E�M�K�SJq�E����OI���Q*ENG]��E M�E Å M��O�m��� Å � W K��2M�¤�I�EHG�I�q2P�EHM��¼��� £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S

Å M�EHG�����MOSJM��zM�Ä�ILU ��S��2�J�¿��Q�UJILP�ILSJUJI�S���I�± � S�� W MOSð����KNILK Å G�I�QNI�ENGJI�QRI-��QNIz��I ÅIÞÚ����LEq2Q�S�I���QÒÁ×QNILKNq2SJ��SJ��ILK�¨ Å M�ENG�EHGJI�q�EHGJILQ�EHI�QR�zK�G�MO�2GJ� W SJq2SbÁÃQNI�KRq2S]��STE�¨ Å MO�O�|EHG�I��MOS�MO��MOÄ�ILU���S��2�J�¿��Q�UJI�PxI�SJU�I�SJ�LI V I�q V Eª��MOSJILU_±

°�GJI¼KNI��Lq2SJUðUJM�KH��Ub¤���SfEH���2IØEHq$EHGJI § £ © ��ILEHG�qbU8MOK�EHG]��E���E5I����ªGðM�EHILQH��ENMOq2SK�EHILP�M�E�M�K�SJIL��I�KRKH��Q W EHq>MOST¤2ILQRE�ENGJI���SJ���OI¼�z��Pð��SJUZEHGJILSZEHq�I�¤����O�]��ENI��>���J��ENM�ÁU�MO��I�SJKRMOq2S]����MOSTENI��2QN����MOS@q2QRUJI�Q�ENq$q V Eª��M�S�EHGJIØ�JPxU]��ENI�UZÔ]q2��QNMOILQ1��q��zPxq2SJILSfENK�q��ENGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��S_± °�GJM�K-��I���EH��QNI@KN��q Å K�ENGJI § £ © ��ILENGJqmUïU�q Å So¨��¼��ÓfM�SJ�ðM�EU�M�Ý����J��E�EHq���PJP�� W ENqØK W KRENI���K Å M�EHG$�zq2QRI�EHGJ��S�«�q2QÇ:UJIL�2QNILI�Kq��*��QRI�ILUJq2�$±

°�GJI Å � W ��QRq2�JSJU����O��ENGJI�KRI�UJQN� Å V ���ªÓfK�MOKhENq���q�SfENMOSf�Jq2��KN� W U�IL��q2QR��EHGJI¢q2QNM��2MOSJ���

��

Page 84: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

���LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I�K W K�EHI��º¤mM¿�-��KNILQNM�I�K�q��dMOS��]S�M�EHILKNM��¼���p�2ILSJI�QN��EHM�SJ�����JSJ�LENMOq2S�K�±�¯4���ªGÔ]q2��QNMOILQØ��q2��P�q�SJI�STE�q��1EHGJI £ ����MO��EHq2S�M¿��SðM�Kz�Lq2STEHMOSf�Jq��JKN� W I�¤2q2��¤2ILUl��QNq2� KRq2�zIM�SJM�ENM¿���m¤����O�JI.EHq5KNq2��I.�]S]���|¤����O�JI�±�°�GJI%�zq2QRI.SJq2SbÁÃQNI�KRq2S]��STE��CEHILQN�$¨mENGJI��L�Oq2KRI�Q¢M�EM�K V QNq2���2GTE%ENqzÄLI�QNq�û Å GJILQNI5� �RQRI�KNq�S]��SJ�LIá������S�����KNqØ��I���S>�Ø����K�E%ENI�QR� EHG]��EG]��KV I��Lq2��I.���LENM�¤2I�U��JI�EHq1ENGJI.KNMOÄLI�q��|EHGJI�PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ��ENMOq2S|üÞ±�Ô]�JQ�EHGJILQN��q2QNI�¨ VTW ��¤2q2M�UJMOSJ�ENGJI.SJI�ILUzENqCM�ST¤2I�Q�E¢SJq2SJ��MOSJI���Q����JSJ��EHM�q2SJK4��SJUØEHq�I�¤����O�]��ENI����J��EHMOU�MO��I�SJKRMOq2S]���mM�STEHI�Á��QH����K�¨ Å I�����S$�2I�E�EHq�EHG�ICÏÒññ V ��KNM�K����J�ªG-����KRENI�Q�EHGJ��S Å M�EHG�ENGJI § £ ©º�zI�EHGJqmU_¨�z��ÓfMOS��zM�E�Pxq2KNKRM V ��ICENq¼K�EH�JU W GJM��2GJI�Q%UJI���QNI�I5q�� ��QNILI�UJq���K W KREHIL�zK:û��JP>ENq���pÙÖM�S�EHGJM�K��ªG]��P�ENI�Q%��SJU-P�q�KNKNM V � W GJMO��GJI�QHü�±

�.-±�! ; 687<$&%('*)#+.-{/1'(2\$=<�+8;r-0/#'*2Ô]q2Q Å G]�ÜE5��q2���Oq Å K�¨pM�E Å M��O� PJQRqw¤�I¼��q2QNIØ�Lq2ST¤2I�S�MOI�STE�ENq Å q2QNÓ@M�S ��S ���LENMOq2SmÁÒ��SJ���OIK W KREHIL�æM�S Å GJM��ªG¼EHGJI���SJ�2��I�KdQH��SJ��I��QRq2� ¬CEHq:«Rl�M�SJKRENI���U�q��,¬5EHqzÂ2±�°�GJI1���LENMOq2SJKû��ïk } r3r3r } �i` üd�Lq2QNQRI�KRP�q2S�UJMOSJ��ENq�KNq��zI1KRILE.q��,�f�]��SfEN�J� Sf�J� V I�QRKCû�Ìxk } r3r3r } Ì�`�ü���QNIENGJI�S��2M�¤�I�S VTW �J »p � û�Ì� ¢é kl ü�±*°�GJI�KRI�¤����O��I�K,��q2QpENGJI����LEHM�q2SJK*��QNI¢��q2QNI¢��q2ST¤�I�SJM�I�STE��q�Q%�f�]��STEN�J� ���������J�O��EHM�q2SJK�¨]KRMOSJ�LI Å I�U�q¼SJq�E%G]��¤2I5EHq�UJI���� Å M�ENG���S¦I�ÚmEHQN��������EHq2Qq�� «Rl�¨]��SJU¦��QNI�ENGm��K%���OQNI���U W MOS-I�KRKNI�STENM¿����� W ���m�J��STEH�J�äSf�J� V I�Q,�z��SJM�ENK�±

Ô]QNq��âEHGJI�PJQNI�¤mMOq2�JKC�ªG]��PbEHI�QL¨�EHG�I¼IL¤�q2�O�bEHMOq�S8q���\ M�S Ô]q2�JQRMOILQ�KNP]���LIz��q2QCq2�JQ

Õ*�

Page 85: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

���LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I�QNILPJQNILKNILSfEH��EHM�q2S>M�K��2M�¤�I�S VTW ¨�`\ c�=� p � bjc ¸ í û m ð HRK��$\ c ½ c ¸ ü�� c ¸ � ûNû m � m ð ürHRK*�$� c ¸ ü¢\ c ½ c ¸ î ûË«b±�ÂvÇTü

Å G�I�QNICMOS-q2��Q��zqmUJM��JI�U-����EHMOq�SbÁÒ��S��2�OI1K W KREHIL� Å I Å QNM�EHI�¨

\ðû�¶ }T! ü�p b c \ c �   cTd ) ûË«b±�Â�Èfü

��SJU¦KRMO��MO�O��QN� W ��q2Q°��±°�GJI>K W KRENI���K Å I�K�EH�JU W ��QRI>G]��QN��q2SJMO�ÞÁ×q2KR��M��O�¿�ÜEHq2Q £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��SJK Å GJM��ªG÷��QNI

PxI�Q�EH�JQ V ILU VTW KNq��zI¢��SJGJ��QN��q2SJM���EHI�QR�zKL¨�KRMOSJ�LI EHGJI4Eª��QR�2ILEpK W K�EHIL�zKpq���ENGJMOK,�ªG]��P�EHILQ��QNI���qbU�I��d¤mM V QH��ENMOq2SJ��� £ ����MO��ENq2SJMO��SJK�q��%P�q2� W ��ENq2��MO���zq2��I��L�J�OILK�±@D�K Å M�EHGZEHG�IIÞÚ����zP��OI�MOS�ENGJI5P�QNIL¤mM�q2�JK.�ªG]��P�ENI�QL¨|ENGJI�KNM��zPJ��I�K�E.PJQNILKN��QRMOP�ENMOq2S-��q2Q��ªGJqmq2KRMOSJ���ÀMOKENq¼�JKRIL\ º�ç ¿ pA\ ç p ! HZ�¨ Å GJILQNI4�÷UJI�S�q�EHILK%EHG�I5¤2IL�LENq2Q1q���G]��QN��q2SJM���ÁÃq2KN�LMO�O�O��EHq�Q��QRI��f�JILSJ��M�I�K�±¢°�GJICQNILKN�J��EHMOS��:I��f�]��ENMOq2S-MOK�ENGJI�S_¨�K\ c�=� p � bjc ¸ û m ð H'��ü í û m ð HRK*�Ê\ c ½ c ¸ ü�\ c ¸ � ûNû m � m ð ürHTK��$\ c ¸ ü�\ c ½ c ¸ î ûË«b±�ÂwÕ2ü

��ã « Þ ��� ��34������ ä � �����1� �������5������� �Ø0ï� ( � ' !B7

�!­"�#� >N%*7xy{;>)#)"?"-Ay�+8~�-0+8y{7:'�4 -{687A@O)#|�'�y�/@-06B=î I V IL�2MOS VTW �ªGJqmq2KNM�SJ��q2�JQ V ��KRMOK q����f�]��STEH��� Sm��� V ILQ¢¤�I���EHq2QRK ë æ \ ��ìf± î M�ENGØENGJMOKV ��KNM�K Å I��2ILSJI�QN��EHICq2�JQ £ ����MO��EHq2SJMO��S��z��EHQRM�Ú�¤mMO��EHG�I5KRI���MO���O��KNKRMO�����hPJQNILKN�LQNMOPbEHMOq�S

Õ*+

Page 86: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

� Y æ \¬æ \ �_p:\�, ½ � û �.B ý �.Cl üÞ¨���K:U�I�KN�LQNM V ILU?M�S�¯4�|±ïûj«b±�Âv«2ü�± î I�EHGf�JK���q�SJKRENQN�J��E�$�OM�KRE ! ' q��dEHGJI¼���LENMOq2S�K � B ý � Cl MOST¤2q2��¤2ILU MOSòq2�JQCKNIL�zM����O��KNKRMO����� �¼��ENQNMÆÚo±zÏÃE�M�K5q�SENGJMOK U�MOKN�LQNI�EHIKNILEdq��o���LENMOq2S�K�EHG]��E Å I Å M��O�]��PJPJ� W q2�JQ4�2QN��UJMOILSTERÁ×U�I�KN�LI�STE����O�2q�QNM�ENGJ�$±D�E.ENGJI5ILSJU>q���EHG�I5PJQRq2�2QN���¦¨bEHGJIm\ � û ! ' ü Å M��O�_G]��¤�I V I�I�S¦�ªG]��SJ��I�U¦ENq�ENGJI�M�Q��]S]���¤������JI�KL±>Ô]q2Q�I����ªG ! ' Å I����OKRq>K�EHq2QRI�������EHGJI¼��KNKRqb�LM¿��ENI�U ~ e Y �÷\ ±¦°�GJIz�]S]���¤������JI�Kdq���\�DLû ! ' ü¢��QNI�ENGJI�S¼PJ�¿���LI�U�M�SfENq5ENGJI�M�Q���PJP�QNq2PJQRM¿��ENI%Pxq2KRM�EHM�q2SJK¢MOS�EHGJI1KRI���M�Á�L�¿��KRKNM������ �z��EHQRM�Ú�¨hEHGJILQNI VfW �2M�¤bM�SJ�-�JKCq2�JQ��]S]��� £ ���zM���EHq�SJM¿��S>�¼��ENQNMÆÚo¨ Å GJM��ªG Å IENGJI�S$UJMO���2q2S]���OMOÄLI%ENq�U�ILEHILQN��MOSJI�ENGJI�KNI���MO�L�¿��KRKNM�������KNPxI��LENQN�J�$±

�!­"�! ¯FE±28;>=³/1~G2D;r-p; uw/@%(7x2H@t~�-{/1'*2î I�KRq2��¤�I�EHGJM�K�K W K�EHI�� q���� � ¯4K�q2SØ���2QRMOU�q��x���LEHM�q2SJK � V q2�bE�EHG�I���ILSfENQH���J���LENMOq2S ! ç ¨Å G�I�QNI5q2�JQ�2QNM�U-��q2SJKRMOK�EHK�q�� �����,���LENMOq2SJK ! c p ! ç éB�Må m ¨ Å M�EHG m p ûPÒ8k } r3r'r } Ò§` üKN��EHM�KR� W MOS�� æ�Ò8kZæ¾é­r'r3rJé æ Ò§`°æJIÇ�j�M]�æC± Ð ILE.�JK�UJILSJq�ENI1EHGJM�K�KNI�E.q��p�2QNM�U�P�q�MOSTEHK.��Ka�û ! ç } �j��]>æ1üÞ±@�m��]>æï��SJUM�Måâ��QNI�JKRI�Q�ÁÃMOSJP���E�PJ��QH����ILENI�QRK�±�D�EdEHGJI V IL�2MOS�SJMOSJ�q��%I�¤2q2����EHM�q2S_¨ Å I��]QNK�EØ��q2��PJ��ENI������dEHG�I�\ c q2S������¢ENGJI��2QNM�UZPxq2MOSTEHK�� V q���E�EHG�I���LEHM�q2S ! ç ± î I:����S_Ê E���q��zPJ�bEHIG\ c ��q2Q����O�,¤2IL�LENq2QNK m ¨_KRq Å IØ�z��Ó�I����JKNILQ�Á×M�SJPJ��E�L��EHq�ÍLKFM.åONZ±�°�Gf�JKL¨ Å Izq2SJ� W EHQN���ªÓ�EHGJq2KRI m ��q2Q Å GJMO�ªGÇæ�Ò8kZæïé r3r3rXéáæ�Ò§`�æPIKFM.åONZ±*D��O�Tq�EHGJILQg\ c ��QRIdKRILEpEHq%¬.ENGJQNq��J�2GJq2�bEpENGJI¢IL¤2q��O��ENMOq2S_±pÔ]�JQ�EHGJILQN��q2QNI�¨ÜENq

Ö�¬

Page 87: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

IL�OM��zM�S]��EHIEHQN���ªÓfMOSJ��SJI����OMO��M V ��I%����K�EENI�QR�zK Å I5M�SfENQNqmUJ�J�LI5�:QRI�KNq�S]��SJ�LI�G]�����¿Á Å M�U�EHGµ \RQ ¨,��SJU����JQRENGJI�Q�QRI�KRENQNM��LECq2�JQRKNI���¤2ILK�ENq�EHGJq2KRI m ��q�Q Å GJMO�ªG­æ m HY�4æTSÞµ \UQÀ¨

Å G�I�QNI �ùMOK�EHG�I�¤�I���EHq2Q.q��pEHGJI�ÄLI�QNq�EHGbÁÃq2QNUJILQ.G]��QN��q2SJM�����QNIL�f�JI�SJ�LMOILK�±°�GJIdMOSJM�EHMO���X\ c ��QNI¢��q2��PJ��ENI�U���S]��� W ENMO�����O� W ± î I�KREH��QRE Å M�ENG���S�MOSJM�EHMO���˨�ÄLI�QRq�EHGbÁ

q�QNUJILQ%���LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I V ��KRMOK.q��*G]��QR�zq2S�MO�1q2KR��M��O�¿�ÜEHq2QRK�± � �JQ £ ���zM���ENq2SJM¿��SzM�K�¨

\Zû.V }Hs ü�p s l« é

« ûø�lk À l k éDr3r'r�é·� l` À l ` ü8é WbX ¨ � b¥ � ýZY[Y[Y ý ¥�\ ¨ X s�º ¥ � « Y[Y[Y « ¥]\Q¿Ìxk+^iH^H^H¢Ì�`1^ À ¥ �k H^H^H,À ¥]\`

ûË«b±�ÂvÖTüî I Eª��Ó�I¢���O��q2�JQ,�¼��KNKNILKhEHq V I.Â2¨wKRMOSJ�LI¢M�S��Pxq2� W ��ENq2�zM�����q2�OIL���J��I�¨w��SJq2QR�¼����Á×��qmUJI��S]��� W KRMOK�MOST¤�q2��¤�I�K��EHQH��SJKR��q2QR�¼�ÜEHMOq�S¼EHq��:K W KRENI��äq��*�z��KNKÒÁ×KN�����OILU-��qmq2QNUJM�S]��ENI�K�MOS

Å G�MO�ªGZ���O��EHG�Iz�z��KNKRI�K V IL��q2��I$Â2±�°�GJIØEHQN��SJKR��q�QN�z��EHM�q2S�EHq$G]��QN��q2SJM���ÁÃq2KN�LMO�O�O��EHq�Q���LEHM�q2SbÁ×��SJ�2��I���qmq2QRUJMOS]�ÜEHI�K�M�K�EHGJILS����L��q2��PJ��MOKNG�I�U�¤mM¿�

À Ð pA_ � Ðl»� Ða`&bdc�e lx{ Ð f ehg Âjidkµ Ð p � _ � Ð � Ðl c�lnmoe lx{ Ð f ehg Â�pqk

r ms`utov�wstyx c w{z]|dty}Ztut&m�~st+v�tu���*l�mstu~��q�1t�`ubd�*�s��v�toz$�n�{�d��z$~�l�t&mqv�c��sc�l�ms��`&tumJv�t&��t&~~�ln�Zt&��tums`&tuc&�o�dln|�l�m����sc"z$m�� f�� åU��k z$`&`u�s��z�v�tUt&c�v�ln��z�v�t$g9��tRv�wstumF����bd�{z��qz�v�t� b$���1z$��~�}q��bdmst�v�l��*t c�v�t&��b � ��t&m��$v�w � � �P��wsl�`�w�lnc#z$�nc�bR�sc�t&� Á c���t&`uln¡{tu~�gO¢£wsl�c����bd�{z��qz�v�lnbdm¤c�v�t&�Rlnc£~st&c�`&��l�}�t&~=lnm¦¥o�s��t&ms~sl¨§"¥©g�ªb$v�t«v�wsz�v��1t!`]z$m�msb$vtu|�z$�n�{z�v�tK�� x c z�v�v�wst�}�bd�sms~sz$���¬b � b$�s���$��l�~Tg¤¢£w���c&�­��t�`]z$m�msb$v�`�w{z$ms�dt v�wst*|$z����stuc©z�v® Â

Page 88: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

v�wst�}Zb$�sms~{z$�����Zb$l�mqv�cug­¯ob���tu|$t&�&�sz$���s�$��l�~���bdlnmJv�c°l�m a f²±�ç�³�´!�¤µ æU¶�Â�k wsz�|$to}�t&tum����bd�{z��qz�v�tu~·`ubd����t&`uv��n�$�¸z$ms~�c�bUz � v�t&�¹v�wst*¡{��c�v#lnv�t&��z�v�lnbdm�c�v�tu�·�1t�bdms�n�O`ubdmqv�lnm���t����bd�{z��qz�v�lnbdm�z�vPv�wsbdc�t1�d��l�~©��bdlnmJv�c&gPªob$v�t�v�w{z�vºz � v�tu�»v�wst1c�t&`&b$ms~�lnv�t&��z�v�l�b$m!��t1bdm��n�`ubdmqv�lnm���t©�s��bd�{z$�qz�v�l�m�� bdm a f²±�ç�³�´!�¤µ æ�¶ e k gy¼1b$mJv�l�mJ�slnms� v�wsl�c�s��b�`&tuc�cu�Z��t#�dtuvv�w{z�v°z � v�t&�­v�wst ��½ � lnv�t&��z�v�lnbdm©��tb$ms�n��`&bdmqv�l�mJ�st£�s��bd�{z$�qz�v�l�m���bdm a f²±�ç�³�´!�¤µ 澶 � k �z�ms~�c�bRv�wst�v�b$v�z$�°mJ�s�#}�t&�©b � lnv�t&��z�v�l�b$msc�`&z$msmsb�v#t+§h`ut&t&~ ´!�¤µ æ g=¢£wslnc©c�`�wst&�*tz]|$bdl�~sc¹v�w�t�mstut&~ � bd�¹ln� ��bdc�lnms�¾z$��v�ln¡{`ul¿z$�º}Zbd��ms~{z$����`ubdms~slÀv�lnbdmsc¹bdm·b$�s��c���c�v�tu�¦gÁ z�v�wst&�u�­z$��bd�sms~�t]z$`�w ±Jç ��t�wsz�|$t�z¾`&bd�n�¿z$�sc�l�ms�¤}�bd�sm�~{z$���¬lnmsc�ln~st�b � ��wsln`�w�v�w�tx c� c1z$��ty�s��bd�sz$�qz�v�t&~�`ubd����t&`+v��n��z�v�t]z$`�w�v�l��*toc�v�tu��gÄÃÅ����v�w�t&���*bd��t$��c�l�m�`&to��t�bdm��n�`&z$��t=z$}�bd��v*v�wst=|�z$�n�st&c*b � v�wstRx c z�v ±�ç ��tR� z��5z�c ��t&���c�t+v�v�w�t=mJ�s�#}�t&� b �lÀv�tu��z�v�l�bdmscyz$ms~ ´!�¤µ æ v�b¤}Zt�tuÆJ�{z$� g#ÃÅb$�«z�~st&c�l���t&~¬m����#}Ztu�«b � lnv�t&��z�v�l�b$msc&�Tv�wsl�c�$ln|dtuc�v�wsty�*l�msln�#�s�Ç|�z$�n�stb � ´!�¤µ æ ��bdc�c�l�}s�nt$�J��wsl�`�w�lnms`&��t]z$c�t&c1v�wst�z����dbd��lnv�ws�  cc��Ztut&~=z$ms~"� lnmsl��*l Ä t&c�� tu� bd������t&ÆJ�sl���t&�*t&mqv�cug

® e

Page 89: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��ã�Ý ÞÉÈUÊ Ë«Ì°Í]ÎÏ©ÐÒÑ ¬ Ï#Ê ÓUÐuË«Ô � ÕX�#� ;�4 '?¯�7z|*y{7z7Ö2 '�4&}±y{7x7Ö:B'*=��t£¡{��c�v1~�t&�*bdmsc�v���z�v�t�bd�s�°� t+v�wsb�~*�sc�lnms�!v�wst׸�s���nt&m Á�Ø ~�� bdm�~sc°¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdm�l¿z$m"Ù p�Ú

x�Û µ �ÜaÝ µ �Þe Ý Âe fàß �Ü À � Ý ß �Þ Á � k Ý ß,À � Á � f ehg Â�áqk��w�t&��ta��t�c�t+v ß Ü Û ß Þ Û Â z$ms~ ß Ûãâ�äåâqæhgP¢£wsl�c­lncºv�w�t£c���c�v�t&�7c�v��s~slnt&~�}q�*¼az$��l�bd�nlt+v]g°z$��gÙèç Ú l�m"ln������c�v���z�v�lnms�¹v�wst�¼a¯�éê�*tuv�wsbh~T����wsl�`�w"lnca��wJ���1t¹c�wsz$���Gz���c�b���c�t¹lnvv�b¹l����n�sc�v���z�v�tabd�s�¸�*tuv�wsb�~��Jc�b¹v�w{z�v¸v�wst&��tolnc°z � ��z$�*t£b � ��t � tu��tums`&t � bd�¸`&bd�*�{z$��l�c�bdm�gë m¦Ãºl��$�s��t�ehg  ��t¹�dln|$t¹z�`ubdmqv�bd���£�s��b$vab � v�wslnc�¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdmsl�z$m z�v�t&mstu���dlnt&c à Ûæ ³  ⠳ ä&ä]ä�æ�â�gP¢£w�l�cºc���c�v�tu�Çw{z�c � bd�s�»c����*� t+v����©zj§�tuc&�d�$ln|�l�ms�o��lnc�t°v�b � b$�s�º�*bh~�t&c»b �b$c�`&ln����z�v�lnbdm ½ ¢a�1b�ì��nbh`&z$��í�� b�~stuc&��`ubd����t&c��Zbdm�~sl�ms�#v�b�bdc�`ul��n�¿z�v�l�bdm z$��b$ms��v�wsty§"z$m�~�*zj§�tuc&�hz$ms~*v��1bRì�msbd����z$�ní«� b�~stuc&�J`&bd����tuc���bdms~slnms�!v�b©bdc�`&ln���¿z�v�l�b$m�z$��b$ms�«v�wst��lnmst&cÁ Û ¹8À ga¢£wstu��t©lnc�c�v���bdms� ~���m{z$�*l�`]z���v��smsm�t&��lnms��}Zt+v��1tut&mRv�wstRì���b�`]z$�ní�� b�~st&cl�mv�wst¹ÆJ�{z$c�l Á lnmJv�t&�d��z$}s�nt«��t&�$l��*t�v�w{z�v�nt]z$~scav�b�z�ÆJ�{z$mqv���� Á � tu`�w{z$msln`]z$��}���t]z�î�lnms�*b �v�wst¹~st&�$t&mstu��z$`+�"l�m¤v�wst¹c��Ztu`uv����s�¾g

Ã{bd�n��b���l�ms��¼az$��l�bd�nlÅtuv£z�� gÀ����t���b�bdî�t&~¤z�vÄv�w�bdc�t�ÆJ�{z�mJv��s�ïc�v�z�v�t&c f.ð»ñ(³�ð � k c�z�v�lnc Á� ��lnms� ð»ñ Ý ð � Û p gP¢£wsl�c¸�dlÀ|dtuc¸�sc°msl�mst Á � bd�n~#~stu�dt&mstu��z�v�t�c�v�z�v�t&c¸��lÀv�w Ä tu��b$v�w Á bd��~st&�tumst&���$� Ã Û á g­¢£w�toc��hc�v�tu�òlncÄlnm*v�wstÆ��sz$c�l Á l�mqv�t&�d��z$}s��t���t&�dln� t�z�v°v�wsl�cÄt&mstu���$�$g ë �

® ç

Page 90: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��t�`ubd�smqva�s� � ��bd�7v�wsty�d��bd�sms~ Á c�v�z�v�t f â ³ â k �qv�w�t&m���ty¡{ms~ v�w{z�v�v�wstuc�tomsl�mstoc�v�z�v�tucz���t¹c�v�z�v�tucoç i v�b�óJæ#b � b$�s��c���c�v�t&�¾gô �ZbdmOlnmJv���b�~s�s`ul�ms��v�wst�z$mswsz$���*bdmsln`#`&bd���s��lnms��v�tu����v�b¤bd�s�«c���c�v�tu�¦�Gv�wst�~st Á�$t&mstu��z$`+�Ub � v�wstuc�t*c�v�z�v�t&c¹lnc�}s��b$î$t&mT�P�dlÀ|�l�ms��v�wst�ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� Á �*t&`�wsz$msl�`&z$�­tumst&���dl�tuc�nl�c�v�t&~¬l�mUv�wst c�t&`ubdms~�`ubd���s�*m¬b � ¢Pz$}s�nt�e�g  g ¢£wst&c�t�t&m�t&���$l�t&c¹��t&��t bd}�v�z$l�mstu~�}q�~�l¿z$�db$m{z$��l Ä lnms�yz����sc�v�z�v�t&c � ��bd�Av�wst��d��bd�sms~�c�v�z�v�t���*v�b�z�v�b$v�z$��b � c�lÀ§�v�tut&m*ÆJ�{z$mqv�z�g

��t"mst+§�v*~sl¿z��dbdm{z$�nl Ä t&~�bdm��n�·v�wst á¦õ5á }s��b�`�î·b � bd����msl�mst Á � bd�n~�~st&�$t&mstu��z�v�tc�v�z�v�t&c¹�sc�l�ms�¤v�w�t*wsz$���*bdmsln` Á b$c�`&ln����z�v�bd�£v�bd��l¸z�c«bd�s�«c�tu� ln`&��z$c�c�l�`]z��º}{z$c�l�cug�¢£wst���t Ác��s�nv�c�z$��t���lnc�v�tu~�l�m�v�wst�v�wsl���~�`&b$���s�*m�b � ¢Pz$}s�nt"ehg  gOªob$v�t�v�w�t�c�ln�dmsln¡s`]z$mqv�~slnc Á`u��tu�{z$ms`+��}�tuv���t&t&möv�w�t&c�t�t&mstu���dlnt&c�z$m�~�v�wst�t(§�z$`uv�c�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�°t&mstu���dlnt&cug f�÷ �t(§�z$`uv©c�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�ln`]z$�¸tumst&���dl�tuc���t�� t&z$m�v�wst�tumst&���dl�tuc©bd}hv�z$lnmst&~��sc�lnms�¦v�wst�c�z$� twsz$���*bdmsln`}sz$c�lnc��sc�t&~�v�b©bd}�v�z$l�m�v�w�tyÆJ�{z$mqv����òtumst&���dl�tuc&��}���v1��c�l�m���v�w�tyc�tu� ln`&��z$c Ác�l�`&z$�G`&bd���s��lnms�dc�l�msc�v�t&z$~¦b � v�w�t�ÆJ�{z$mqv��s�øbdmst&cug k ��t�z$�s�s�nl�t&~"bd���yù¹ú�¥A�*tuv�wsb�~v�b#v�wstuc�t«mslnmst«~stu�dt&mstu��z�v�t«c�v�z�v�tuc&�{�sc�l�ms� �*û Û�â�äåâqeh� � å Ûãâ�äåâqeh� K�M.åON Û p �ü x Q Û p ä  z$ms~ ´���µ æ Û Âji g¹¢£wst���t&c����nv�c¹z���t#�nl�c�v�t&~RlnmRv�wst � b$�s��v�wU`&bd�n�s� mb � ¢ºz�}s��tyehg  g°ªob$v�tv�w{z�v�v�wsto~sl�c�`&��tu�{z$ms`+� ��lÀv�w*v�wstot+§�z$`uvac�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�ln`]z$�{tumst&���dl�tucwsz$c�}Ztut&m¾~s��z$c�v�ln`]z$�n�n� ��t&~��s`&tu~�g

¼az$��l�bd�nlJtuv°z$��gºz���c�by�Ztu� � bd��� tu~�zyc���t&tu� b � ß Ü � ��bd�ýâ�ä ádá v�b  äþâ  v�b«�nbhbdî¹z�vºv�w�tz]|$bdl�~stu~¦`u��bdc�c�lnms��}�tuv���t&tumRc�v�z�v�tucyç á z$ms~¾óqâ�g ë m¦Ãºl��d����t!ehg  ��t!c�wsb���v�wst�c�t&�*l Á® ó

Page 91: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÿ v�z�v�t �¹é ¯yz$��� b$msl�` ÷ z$c�lnc ë�ÁÁ ÷ z$c�l�cç i á g  æ�ó p ó á g Âji çdâ i á g  æde ® âç p á g  æ idi e á g Â�p�Â2Â�p á g  ædæ pdáç á á gþç p âqæ p á gèó Â�ádá æ á gåç idi$á âódâ á gåóqe ® æ$â á gþæ$â$ódó p á gèóJedæ á�Âó  á g æ  ®d® e á gþæ á â$óJæ á gþæ  ® idióqe á g ® p æ á ó á g p óqç p e á g ® á âdâ ®ódç á g ® ádp ® p á g p æ Â�á ç á g i âqe$âdâó$ó  â�gþâ  e á ó  â�gþe i ç ® ó  â�gåâ Â�á æ póqæ  â�gþâ  çdçdâ  â�gþe i ç á$á  â�gåâ Â�á ® ó

¢Pz$}s�nt"ehg Â2½ eRú�tu�d��tut Á b � Á Ã{��tut&~sb$� Ø §�z$�*�s��t�g Ø mstu���dlnt&c�b � c�v�z�v�t&c*ç i v�bUóJæ=bd} Áv�z$l�m�t&~R}q�¾|$z���l�b$�sco�*tuv�wsb�~sc&g�¼1bd���s�*mOe ½ ���{z�mJv��s� Á �*t&`�w{z$m�l�`]z�� go¼1bd����� mUç ½�á� á }���b�`�î�~sl¿z��dbdm{z$�nl Ä z�v�lnbdm�l�m"v�w�t©w{z$��� b$msl�` Á bdc�`&l��n�¿z�v�bd�°v�bd���sco}sz$c�lnc&g¼1bd�n�s� m¾ó ½á � á }s��b�`�î�~sl�z$�dbdmsz$��l Ä z�v�l�bdm*l�m¤v�w�t ë�ÁÁ }{z�c�l�cug

® æ

Page 92: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

9.3

9.35

9.4

9.45

9.5

9.55

9.6

0.99 0.995 1 1.005 1.01

Ene

rgy

Harmonic Frequency of X Oscillator

Quantum

9 X 9 Block: Harmonic Basis

ÃPl��d�s��t�ehg Â2½ ¥o|db$l�~stu~¬`u��bdc�c�lnms�¤}Zt+v��1tut&m�c�v�z�v�t&c¹ç á z$ms~Oóqâ¤z$c«z � ��ms`uv�l�bdmUb � ß Ü g¢£w�t�`&�s��|dt&c¹wstu��t�z���t©v�wst#ÆJ�{z$mqv���� t&m�t&���$l�t&c¹z�ms~=v�w�t�t&mstu���dlnt&c�bd}hv�z$lnmst&~R}q�=~sl Áz��dbdm{z$�nl Ä l�ms�!v�wst á � á }s�nbh`�î l�m¤v�w�t!wsz$���*bdmsln` Á b$c�`&ln����z�v�bd�¸v�bd���sc�}{z�c�l�cug`u�¿z$c�c�ln`]z$�Zt&mstu���$�"`u�s��|$t&c � bd�1v�w�t¹v���b�c�v�z�v�tuc&�Åz$�nbdms�#��lnv�w¤v�wst«`u�s��|$t&cbd}�v�z�l�mstu~¾}q�~�l¿z$�db$m{z$��l Ä lnms�!v�wst á#õ¦á }���b�`�î��sc�l�ms�#v�wst«w{z$��� bdm�l�` Á bdc�`ul��n�¿z�v�bd�¸v�bd��l�z$c£bd���£}{z$c�lnc&gë m�úl��$�s��toehgþe¹��t�z$�nc�b!c�wsb��Òv�wstoc�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�{t&m�t&����� `u�s��|$t&c � b$�Äv�wstv���b#c�v�z�v�t&c&�z���bdms����lÀv�w¦v�wst!`&�s��|dt&cybd}�v�z�l�mstu~¦}q�¦z$�s�s�À��l�ms��bd�s��d��z$~sl�tumqv Á ~�t&c�`ut&mqv��*tuv�wsb�~¾v�bb$�s� Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~�t&�msl�mst Á � bd�n~¦~�t&�dtumst&��z�v�t�}{z$c�lnc f ��lnv�w¦v�w�t�c�z$� t��s��b$�d��z$�ï�{z$��z�� Át+v�tu��c�z$c�}�t � b$��t k g�ªb$v�t�v�w{z�v!v�wst*~sl�c�`&��tu�{z$ms`+�¬�s��tuc�t&mqv©l�m�úl��d����t*ehg  wsz$c�}�t&tumtu��ln� lnm{z�v�tu~�gÖ¢Pb�}Ztc�����t$�Jv�w�to� z�v�`�w*l�cÄmsb$vÄt(§sz�`uv]��}s��vÄv�w�to~slÀ�Ttu��tums`&tuc1`]z�msmsb$v�}Zt

®$®

Page 93: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

9.32

9.34

9.36

9.38

9.4

9.42

9.44

9.46

9.48

0.99 0.995 1 1.005 1.01

Ene

rgy

Harmonic Frequency of X Oscillator

Quantum

9 X 9 Block: IRR Basis

ÃPl��d�s��t�ehgþe ½ ¥o|db$l�~stu~¬`u��bdc�c�lnms�¤}Zt+v��1tut&m�c�v�z�v�t&c¹ç á z$ms~Oóqâ¤z$c«z � ��ms`uv�l�bdmUb � ß Ü g¢£w�t�`&�s��|dt&c¹wstu��t�z���t©v�wst#ÆJ�{z$mqv���� t&m�t&���$l�t&c¹z�ms~=v�w�t�t&mstu���dlnt&c�bd}hv�z$lnmst&~R}q�=~sl Áz��dbdm{z$�nl Ä l�ms�!v�wst á � á }s�nbh`�î l�m¤v�w�t ë�ÁÁ v�bd���sc�}{z�c�l�cugc�t&tumRz�v£v�wst¹��t&c�bd���hv�l�b$m¤��tu|$t&�Öb � v�wst¹�s�nb$v]g��� Õ���� ?���� ���������Ö2������������»:������t*`&bdms`u���s~�t*v�wsl�c¹c�tu`uv�l�bdm¬}q���nbhb$î�lnms�"z�v�z ® ~stu�d��tut Á b � Á � ��tut&~sb$�êt+§�z$�*�s��t�g�¥oc��lÀv�w*v�wstó Á ~�l��*t&msc�l�bdm{z��st+§�z$�*�s��t��qv�wsty¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdmsl�z$m©��ty`�wsb$c�ty�1z$caz!�dt&m�t&��z���l Ä z Áv�l�bdm¤b � v�w�t�׸�s�n��tum Á�Ø ~s�*bdms~sc1c���c�v�t&�¾gÄ��t«v�b�bdîÅ�

x Û Âe��� � ñ f"! �� Ý$# �� k Ý

® i

Page 94: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

â�äåâqæ f âhä á ç ! � ñ ! �� Ý â�ä á ó ! � ñ ! �% Ý â�ä á æ ! �� ! �% Ýâ�ä á ® ! � ñ ! �& Ý â�ä áqi ! �� ! �& Ý âhä ádp ! �% ! �& Ýâ�ä ádá ! � ñ ! �' Ý Â äåâdâ ! �� ! �' Ý Â äþâ  ! �% ! �' Ý äåâqe ! �& ! �' Ý Â äåâdç ! � ñ ! �� Ý Â äþâ$ó ! �� ! �� Ý äåâqæ ! �% ! �� Ý Â äåâ ® ! �& ! �� Ý Â äþâ i ! �' ! �� k f ehgþe$â k

��t!l�mslÀv�l¿z����n��v���l�tu~¾v�b�bd}hv�z$lnm"v�wst©t(§�z$`uvoÆJ�{z$mqv��s��z$m�~=c�tu� ln`&��z$c�c�l�`]z��Gt&mstu���dlnt&cb �v�wst�c�v�z�v�t&c1��lÀv�w¤z�v�b$v�z���b � p ÆJ�{z$mqv�z#lnm�v�wsto�sms��t&��v��s��}Ztu~¾�nl��*lnv&gÖ��w�l���toz$�s���n��l�ms�b$�s�1�*tuv�wsbh~*v�b©v�wsl�c�}{z$c�l�c���bd�s�n~�msb$v1w{z]|dt�}�t&tum"z©�s��bd}s��tu�¦�q��ty��bd�s��~�msb$vawsz�|$t}�t&tum"z$}s�ntov�b��$t&mstu��z�v�tyv�wstyt+§�z$`uv�ÆJ�{z�mJv��s��z�ms~¤c�tu� ln`&�¿z�c�c�ln`]z$�Åtumst&���dl�tuca��tuÆ���l���tu~� b$�º`&b$� �{z���l�c�bdm�gÖ¥ycP��lnv�w�v�wst�eoz$ms~#ó Á ~sl��*t&m�c�l�b$m{z$�q`]z�c�t&cu�d�1t��1bd����~#w{z]|$t£w{z$~©v�b~�l¿z$�db$m{z$��l Ä t«z�����c�v�z�v�t&cy���¾v�b�z�v�b$v�z$�Gb � c�lÀ§�v�tut&m¦Æ��sz$mqv�z*v�b �$tuvv�wst!wsl��$wst&� Á bd��~st&�z�`&`&����z$`+�¤~st&c�l���t&~�g°¢£wst«��t&c����nv�lnms��}{z$c�l�ca�1z$c£c�ln� ���n�*v�b�b#�¿z$���dt � bd�1bd�s�£`&b$� �s�hv�t&�v�b�wsz$ms~s�nt$�hz$ms~�c�b���towsz$~ v�b©��t+v���t]z�vÄv�b�z!�*bd��to� z$m{z$�$t]z$}s�nt£t+§�z$�*�s��t�gº��tv�w���c�nbhb$î$t&~�z�vºv�w�bdc�t£ÆJ�{z$mqv��s�7c�v�z�v�tuc f²ðÖñ(³�ð � ³�ð % ³�ð & ³�ð ' ³�ð � k c�z�v�l�c � ��lnms� ð»ñ Ý ð � Ý ð % Ýð & Ý ð ' Ý ð � ÛFó����dlÀ|hlnms�©��c  e ® ~stu�dt&m�t&��z�v�t«c�v�z�v�tuca��lnv�w¤z Ä tu��b$v�w Á bd��~st&�1t&mstu���$�b �)( Û i g©¼1bd�smqv�lnms� � ��b$��v�wst��d��b$�sms~ Á c�v�z�v�t�z$c�}�t � b$��t$����t��dt+v«v�w{z�vyv�wstuc�t*z$��tc�v�z�v�t&c p æ©v�b�e  â�b � bd�s�£c���c�v�tu�¦g

¢£wst!ÆJ�{z$mqv���� t&mstu���dlnt&c£�1tu��t¹v�wstum¦b$}�v�z$lnmst&~"}q�¤~sl�z$�dbdmsz$��l Ä l�m��#z$�n��c�v�z�v�tuc���® p

Page 95: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

v�bOz=v�b$v�z$�Äb � t&l��$wJv#Æ��sz$mqv�z�g¬¢£wst¤��tuc��s�Àv�c�z$��t���lnc�v�t&~�lnm�v�wst¤c�t&`&b$ms~ö`&bd�n�s� m·b �¢Pz$}s�ntOehgþeh�£��tuc���t&`+v�ln|$t&�À�dg �·tR~�bdm  v¤��lnc�v¤z����  e ® tumst&���dl�tuc&��}s��v"��z�v�wstu��bdms�À� z��t&�s��t&c�t&mqv�z�v�ln|$t�c�z$�*�s��t�g�׸��b�`&tut&~slnms�"z$c�}�t � b$��t$���1t�v�wstumU~sl¿z$�$bdm{z$�nl Ä tu~¦b$ms�n�"v�w�t e ® õz e ® }���b�`�î#b � ~st&�$t&mstu��z�v�toc�v�z�v�t&c&�J�sc�l�ms�«v�wst Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~st&�°w{z$��� b$msl�`ab$c�`&ln����z Áv�bd�av�b$��lGz$c�bd���£}{z$c�lnc&g°¢£wst¹��tuc��s�Àv�cz$��t!�$ln|dtum¦lnm�v�wst«v�wsl���~¾`ubd����� m"b � ¢ºz�}s��t!ehgþehgÃPl�m{z$�n�n�$�s�1t�z$���s��lnt&~=b$�s�y�d��z$~slnt&mqv Á ~st&c�`&t&mqv!z$�n�dbd��lnv�w��ïv�b�v�wsl�co~st&�$t&mstu��z�v�t�}{z$c�lnc&gô c�lnms� K�M+*ON Û p �qz]|dt��sc1c�b�� z$mq� ��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut&cz$ms~ � z$c�vav�t&��� cÄv�w{z�v�v�wsty���sm Áv�l��*t#�az�c��s��bdwsln}slnv�ln|dtu�n�¦c��nbj�¹g ÿ bs�G��t�c�z$`&��ln¡{`ut&~�z$`&`u�s��z$`+� � bd�«c���t&tu~�z$ms~��sc�tu~v�wst��{z���z$�*tuv�t&��c � û Û�â�äåâ$ós� � * Û�â�äþâdeh� K�M+*ON Û ós� ü x Q Û�ósä  �°z$m�~´!�¤µ-, Û9ç f ��t©~sln~¦m�b$vy� z$î�t ´!�¤µ-, c��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�¦��z$���$t�v�b���t]z$`�w¾v�wst�bd��v�l�� z$�}sz$c�lnc&�Å}Ztu`]z$��c�t�v�wst¹���sm Á v�ln� t���bd�s�n~=w{z]|$t#z$�qz�l�m"}Ztut&m¦�s��bdw�l�}slÀv�ln|$t&�À��c��nb�� k g1¢£w�t��t&c��s�nv�c�z$��t��$ln|dtum¤l�m�v�wst � bd�s��v�w¤`ubd���s�*m�b � ¢Pz$}s�nt«ehgåç�g°ªob�v�l�`utyv�wsz�v�z$�Àv�wsbd���dw���tc�l��dm�ln¡{`&z$mqv��n�"��t&~s��`&t&~Uv�wst©mJ�s�#}�t&�yb � z]|$z�l��¿z�}s��t«��t&c�b$m{z$ms`ut&c¹z$ms~ � z�c�vyv�t&��� cu�Z��tc�v�ln���G� z$m{z$�dtu~¦v�b�`&��vov�wst�l�mslÀv�l�z$��t&m�t&�����=~slnc�`u��t&�sz$ms`u� � ��b$�øz$mUz]|dtu��z$�dt©b � ehäåâ10v�b¹z$m�z]|dtu��z$�dt£b � â�äþç20¤gP¢£wsl�c¸`ubd����t&c��Zbdm�~sc­v�b¹z$m�z]|$t&��z��dt£��tu~s�s`uv�l�bdm�lnm©v�w�t£l�mslÀv�l¿z��tu����bd�£}q� p ó30�g

® á

Page 96: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÿ v�z�v�t �¹é ¯yz$��� bdm�l�` ÷ z�c�l�c ë�ÁÁ ÷ z$c�l�cp æ i g æ Âji ç p i g ® âdâ ® e i g æ$e i ædep ® i g æ�ç  ® æ i g ® e Â�ádá i g æ�ódó i ®pdi i g æ�çqæ  ó i g ® edæ�óqç i g æ�ó i æ�óp$p i g æ�óqâ i ® i g ® e ádá â i g æ$æ Â2 óp$á i g æ�ó á ® p i g ® ç i â p i g æ$æ ® á æá â i g æ ® â i ç i g ® ó p ó i i g æ ®d® e$âe�âqæ i g p$p� ç  p g Â2Â�p æ ® i g á e ® ódóe�â ® i g p$p ede$â p g  e  ⠮ i g á e p e$âe�â i i g p$p ódódó p g  e$çqæ$ç i g á e ádá óe�â p i g p$pqi e ® p g  e ® p æ i g á çqede ®e�â á i g p$pqi$p ç p g  ç Â�pdá i g á çqæ i$áe  â i g á edæ�ódó p g Â�ádádpdá i g á$p� æ p

¢Pz$}s�ntRe�g e ½ ® ú�tu�d��tut Á b � Á Ã{��tut&~sbd� Ø §�z$�*�s�nt$gÒ¥�c�z$�*�s��t¾b � t&mstu���dlnt&c�b � c�v�z�v�tucp æ"v�bUe  â¦b$}�v�z$lnmst&~�}q��|�z$��l�bd�sc!�*tuv�w�bh~scugU¼1bd�n�s�*m�e ½ ���{z$mqv��s� Á � tu`�w{z$msln`]z$��g¼1b$���s�*m¾ç ½% e ® �  e ® }���b�`�î�~sl¿z��dbdm{z$�nl Ä z�v�lnbdm�lnm"v�wst!w{z$���*bdmsln` Á bdc�`ul�����z�v�b$�°v�bd����c}sz$c�lnc&gļ1bd�n�s� m"ó ½� e ® �  e ® }s��b�`�î�~sl�z$�dbdmsz$��l Ä z�v�l�bdm*l�m¤v�w�t ë�ÁÁ }{z�c�l�cug

i â

Page 97: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��� Õ��54 ��276�8�2�29�:��;ªb$v�ln`&t�v�w{z�val�m�z$���Åbd����t(§sz�� �s�nt&cu�=<��sc�va�sc�l�ms�!v�wst�~�t&�dtumst&��z�v�t�}sz$c�lnc�b � wsz$���*bdmsln` Áb$c�`&ln����z�v�bd��v�b$��lº~�l�~Omsb$v«�$ln|dt���c¹z"�$bhb�~Rt&c�v�ln��z�v�t#b � v�wst�c�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�»t&mstu���dlnt&c&gë vy�az$c«m�t&`&tuc�c�z$���Uv�b¤~sl¿z$�$bdm{z$�nl Ä t!z$�n�Pc�v�z�v�t&c���lÀv�wslnmUz��#�s`�wU��l�~�t&��tumst&���$�R}{z�ms~v�b#~sb#c�bsg¸¥y�Àv�wsb$�s�dw�wsz$���*bdmsln`obdc�`&ln���¿z�v�bd��c�z���ty����bd}{z�}s�n��v�w�t�t]z$c�l�tuc�v£}{z�c�l�c�c�v�z�v�tucv�bU�sc�t � bd��v�wst¤��b$v�tumqv�l¿z���c©b � lnmqv�t&��t&c�v�v�bO�sc�l�m�v�wsl�c©`�w{z$��v�t&�&�Älnv©l�c#�$t&mstu��z$�n�n�·z�*l�c�v�z$î�t#v�b¦z�v�v�z$`�w�z"�*t&`�wsz$msl�c�� v�b"v�w�t*tumst&���$�?>{b�� z�c�c�b�`&l�z�v�tu~¬��lÀv�wUv�w�l�c«}{z Ác�l�cug ë m ÿ v���`�wst&}s���sîJwsb�|Uz$m�~Oé=z$��`&�sc#Ù Â â Ú �Å�sc�l�ms��z w{z$��� b$msl�` Á bdc�`&l��n�¿z�v�bd�1}sz$c�lncv�bc�v��s~h� âhäþâ Â�¶ âhä  `&�A@ ñ t&mstu���$�5c�����lnv�v�lnms�dc#lnm zO�Zb$�n�qz�v�bd�*l�`��*bd�nt&`&����t���lnv�w óqe|�ln}s��z�v�l�bdmsz$�Ö~st&�d��t&tuc!b �¸� ��t&tu~sbd�¾�Tv�w�tu�Rwsz$~Rv�b¤~sl�z$�dbdmsz$��l Ä t!z$���»c�v�z�v�tuc���lnv�wsl�mUz�mtumst&���$�U}{z�ms~Ob �  â�`&� @ ñ bd�«� b$��t$g¹¢£wst+�Ol�mq|db$î$t&~Ov�w�t�`&bdms`ut&��v¹b � z5ì�c��s��t&��t(§ Á`�wsz$ms�dtuí��*t&`�w{z$m�l�c��¾�s��wstu��t&}q�¾t&m�t&�����B>sbj��}Zt+v��1tut&mRmst&z$���À�¤~stu�dt&mstu��z�v�t©c�v�z�v�t&c&�}���v¹~sl�c�v�z$mqv��n�¾c�tu�{z$��z�v�t&~¬l�m¦v�wst�ÆJ�{z$mqv��s�êmJ�s�#}�t&��c��{z$`ut$�Öbh`u`&�s����tu~O|�l�z�t&mstu���$�>sbj�Ç}Zt+v��1tut&m�c�v�z�v�t&c¹`&�nbdc�tu�«v�b"t]z$`�w¬b$v�wst&�¹l�mUv�wst�Æ��sz$mqv��s�HmJ�s�#}�t&�¹c��{z$`&t�}s�hv��lÀv�w�z¤�¿z$���dt&�«tumst&���$�O�qz$�¬}Zt+v��1tut&m·v�wst&�¾g*¢£wsl�c¦ì�c��s�Ztu��t(§�`�wsz$ms�dtuíR� tu`�w{z$mslnc��lncyz*}{z$c�l�c Á ~st&��t&m�~st&mqv«msb�v�l�b$m��Åwsb��1t+|dt&�u�Gz$cl�c� b$c�voc�l��*�s�À�¤l��n���sc�v���z�v�t&~¾}q�¾bd�s�ye~�t&�d��t&t Á b � Á � ��t&tu~sbd�ït(§�z$� ����t$g¸¢»b�bd}�v�z$l�m�v�wst¹c�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�ln`]z$�Zt&mstu���dlnt&c�b � c�v�z�v�tucoç iv�b¦óqæh�G��lnv�w�z¤v�b$v�z$�¸t&mstu���$�¬��z$ms�dt S  �G��t�w{z�~¬v�b¦~sl�z$�dbdmsz$��l Ä t�z"�#�s`�w��¿z$���dt&�

imÂ

Page 98: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

}sz$c�lnc1b �  æ$ç�c�v�z�v�t&c1��lÀv�w¤z¹v�b$v�z$�Åt&mstu���$� ��z$m��dtyb �-C e$â�gº��t�`ubd�s��~�z$��c�b©lnmJ|$bdî$t�zì�c��s��t&��t+§h`�w{z$ms�$t&í!� tu`�w{z$mslnc�� � b$�Pv�w�l�c­tumst&���$�D>{b��¹g ë m�~st&tu~��Jc�ws��l�msîJl�m��«bd�s�­}{z�c�l�c~�l�~U�dlÀ|dt�z�c�� z$�n�P`�w{z�ms�dt�l�m=v�wst�t&m�t&���$l�t&c f v�wsbd���dwUbdms�À�=lnmRv�wst���z$c�v«b$mst�bd�yv���b~�t&`&ln��z��Z�s��z$`&tuc k ��c�b#v�w{z�v£b$mst�`&b$�s��~¤z����d�stov�w{z�vabd�s�a��t&��v��s��}{z�v�lnbdm�lnc1c��7. `ul�tumJv��n�c�v���bdms��v�b�z$�n��b�� � bd�c���`�wOz�� tu`�w{z$mslnc��¾g¯ob��1t+|dtu�&�Öz$cl�co`&��t&z$�}J�¦z$���s�n��l�m���bd�s�ù¹ú�¥ý�*tuv�wsbh~T�Tz��*bd��t©z$`u`&�s��z�v�t©t+§h�s�¿z�m{z�v�lnbdm¾l�co��w�l���t�z c��s��t&��t(§h`�w{z$ms�dt��*t&`�w Áz�msl�c���l�c���tuÆ���l���tu~ v�b�z$`u`&bd�smqv � bd��t&mstu���$�E>{b�� lnm v�w�t¦w{z����*bdmsl�`¤}sz$c�lnc&�1v�wst&��tt(§hl�c�v�c¹z�}{z$c�l�c�bd}hv�z$lnm{z$}s�nt � ��b$��v�wst��sms~stu���À�hlnms��`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�º~h�hmsz$� ln`&c�b � v�wst�c���c Áv�t&�¾�{m{z$�*t&�À��v�w�t ë�ÁÁ v�bd��l �slnm¤��wsl�`�w¾v�wst¹c����Ztu��t+§h`�w{z�ms�dt#�*t&`�w{z�msl�c�� mst&tu~=msb$v}�tl�mq|dbdî�t&~�g ô c�l�m���v�w�t ë�ÁÁ v�bd��l{��to��t&��t«z$}s�ntv�b©bd}�v�z$l�m*bd�s�Ämslnmstoc�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�tumst&���dl�tuc¸�sc�lnms�!z��#�s`�w*c�� z$���nt&�P}{z$c�lncº��wsln`�w�z$�nc�b«�nl�t&c»��lnv�wsl�m#v�wst�t&mstu���$�©��z$ms�$t£b �b$�s�¸c�tu� ln`&�¿z�c�c�ln`]z$�hc���t&`+v������¦g­¢£w�t�ì�c��s��t&��t+§h`�w{z$ms�$t&í©�*t&`�wsz$msl�c��7l�cPv�wJ�scÄz$m z$��v�l Á� z�`uv]�q`ubd�*l�ms� � ��b$�ýv�w�t � z�`uv¸v�wsz�vÄbd�s� Ä tu��b$v�w Á b$��~stu�Ä}sz$c�lncÄb � w{z����*bdmsl�` Á bdc�`&ln���¿z�v�bd��clnc£msb$v£v�wst¹bd��v�ln��z��T}{z$c�l�c�b � ë�ÁoÁ v�bd��l g

¼az$��l�bd�nl�tuv"z$��gã� z$~st¦bdmstUz$~�~slnv�l�bdm{z��£�s��b$v�l�m5v�wstul����sz$�Ztu�&��l�m ��wsl�`�wLv�wstu�z��s�s��lnt&~Rv�wst&ln�¹¼a¯�é�� t+v�wsb�~Ul�mRv�wst�`�w{z$b$v�l�`#��t&�dln� t��T��lnv�w ( Û æ$â�g�¢Pb"bd}�v�z$l�m`ubdmq|dtu���dtums`&t�b � v�wst&ln�£� t+v�wsb�~���v�wstu�"w{z�~¾v�b�z$�nc�b�lnms`&�n�s~st«v�wst � z$c�v�v�t&��� c�z���l�c�l�ms�� ��bd� v�wst!|dtu`uv�b$�GF�Û f  ³ Âjk g¢£wst ë�ÁÁ ��t&�s��t&c�t&mqv�z�v�l�bdmUb � v�wst©¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdmsl�z$m¤�az�cm�b¾�nbdms�dtu��}s�nbh`�î¾~sl¿z��dbdm{z$���Zv�wsbd�s�dwUv�wst�`&bd���s��lnms��c�v����s`+v��s��t*�1z$c«c�v�l��n�ºc�l��*�s��lÀ¡{t&~i e

Page 99: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

c�bd�*tu��w{z�v&g¸Ã{bd�ºv�wsl�c¸��t]z$c�bdm��d��t~�t&`&ln~st&~�v�b � bd���db«bd�s�¸b���m�c�v��s~���z�v ( Û�æ$â�gP¥av}�t&c�v]�Zbd�s��z����dbd��lnv�ws�ï��bd�s��~=c�l��*�s�nl � ��v�wst©`ubd�s�s�nl�ms� c�v����s`+v��s��t�z$co��t&�n� ��c�b�v�w{z�v�zc���z�����tu��}sz$c�lnc1�1b$�s��~¤}�t«��tuÆ���l���tu~�v�b�bd}hv�z$lnm�v�wst«c�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�Åc���t&`+v������¦g ë m�v�w�t`�wsz$b$v�ln`���tu�dl��*t$��wsb���tu|dtu�&�Åc�tu� ln`&��z$c�c�l�`]z���ÆJ�{z�mJv�l Ä z�v�lnbdm�msb��nbdms�dtu�abh`u`&�s��cabdms�À��b$mv�wst«l�mq|�z$��l¿z$mqv1v�bd��l f ~s�st�v�b�t&���dbh~�l�`���t&�dlnbdmscab � �sw{z�c�t«c��sz$`&t¹b � z$��t]z�c�ln�dmsln¡s`]z$mqv��À���z$���$t&�Öv�w{z$m f eIHKJL kNM¸k ��c�b�v�wsz�vºv�wst ë�ÁÁ }{z$c�l�cPl�cºm�b«��bdms�$t&�»bd��v�ln��z�� gÖ¥ymsb�v�wstu�º�az]�b � �nbhbdîJlnms�«z�v¸v�wsl�c¸lnc­v�w{z�v°c�l�ms`ut�bd�s�¸� z�v���lÀ§©l�c¸msb¹��b$ms�dt&�¸}���b�`�î©~sl�z$�dbdm{z�� f v�wsbd�s�$w��lÀv�w*z¹c�l��*�s�nln¡{tu~#`&bd���s��lnms�¹c�v����s`uv��s��t k �J�1t�w{z]|$tv�b�lnmJ|$bdî$t£v�wst�ì�c��s��t&��t+§h`�w{z$ms�$t&í�*t&`�wsz$msl�c��øl�mRbd��~st&�v�b¤z�`&`&b$�smqv � bd�ov�wst#bd}�c�t&��|dtu~¬tumst&���dl�tuc&g�¥avyv�wslncy��bdl�mqv]�Å��t� z]�¤z$c£��t&�n�G�sc�t¹w{z$��� b$msl�`«bdc�`&ln���¿z�v�bd��c&gë m¾v�wst!t&ms~T��v�wst���c�t©b � l�mq|�z$��l¿z$mqv�v�bd��lÖz$coz*c�t&�*l�`&��z$c�c�l�`&z$�G}{z$c�l�c � bd��ÆJ�{z$mqv��s�`&z$��`u�s�¿z�v�l�b$msc�lnc©�*bdc�v©�sc�t � �s�£z�v©��tu�¿z�v�ln|dtu�n�¬��b�� tumst&���$�d�¸��wstu��t�v�w�t�~���m{z$�*l�`uc©l�cÆJ�{z�c�l Á l�mqv�tu�d��z�}s��t�g ë v#lnc©lnm·v�wslnc©��t&�dln� t�v�w{z�v#v�wst ë�ÁoÁ }{z$c�l�c©lnc©t(§���t&`+v�tu~öv�bU}Zt�*bdc�vº�swq��c�ln`]z$�n�n�«�*b$v�ln|�z�v�lÀ|dtu~���z$ms~#`ubdmsc�tuÆJ�st&mqv��À�©�nt]z$~�c»v�b�zoc�l��dm�ln¡{`&z$mqv��n��c�� z$���nt&�}sz$c�lnc&�Åz$ca��t&�n�Öz$c��dln|�l�m����swq�hc�l�`&z$�Gl�msc�l��dwqv&g

i ç

Page 100: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

OQPSR TVUXW ÎÐ]ÈUÔ­Í UXW Ô Ï W?Y Z È\[¸ÈUÌ¸Ë ] Ë«ÔºËyÏ#Ì°Î)^ë mUv�wsl�c«`�w{z���v�tu�¹��t*z$�s�s�nl�tu~Rv�wst*ù¹ú¥Ç� t+v�wsb�~ � bd�y¡{ms~�l�ms�¤v�w�t ë�ÁoÁ }sz$c�lnc«b � z¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$m¦c���c�v�tu�¦g��·t�c�v�z$��v�t&~OlnmOz�w{z$���*bdmsln`�z$`+v�l�b$m Á z$m��d��t!��tu�s��tuc�t&mqv�z�v�lnbdmb � v�wsty¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdmsl�z$m��qz�ms~¤`&bdmqv�l�mJ�sbd�sc��n�*~st � bd���*t&~�b$�s�1lnmslnv�l¿z$�Åz$`+v�lnbdm Á z�ms�d��t�}{z�c�l�clnmqv�b¹z$m�bd�hv�l�� z$�J}{z$c�l�c¸b � v�bd��lhl�m#��wsln`�w�v�wst£z$m��d�s�¿z��­~st&��t&m�~st&ms`ut�b � v�wst�¯oz$� ln�nv�b Ám�l¿z$m��1z$c1�*l�msln� l Ä tu~�gÖ¢£wstyz�~�|�z$mqv�z$�dt�b � v�wst�d��z$~sl�tumqv Á ~�t&c�`ut&mqv1z$�s�s��bqz$`�w�lnc¸v�w{z�v� b$��� z$���À�¤lnvo~sb�t&c�msb�v«~sl�c�v�lnms�d�slnc�w=}�tuv���t&tumO��t&c�bdm{z$m�`&t&c!z$m�~ � z$c�vyv�t&��� cu�Tc�b�v�w{z�vz����T��b$v�t&mqv�l�z$�Tv�tu���*c�z$��t«t+|dbd�À|dtu~¦lnm¦z��sm�l � bd��� � z$c�wsl�b$m"z$ms~¾��t&~��s`&tu~=z$c��#��`�w=z$c��bdc�c�l�}���t$gº¢£wst¹¼a¯�é�� t+v�wsb�~���bdm�v�w�t�b$v�w�t&�1wsz$ms~�����tuÆ���l���tuc£z$m¤z!�s��lnbd��lÅ~stu`&lnc�l�b$mz�cav�b#��wsln`�w"v�t&��� c£z���t�v�b�}�tyv���t]z�v�t&~¾z$c£��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut&cz$ms~¤��wsln`�w¾z$��t��$bdl�ms��v�b�}Ztlnms`&b$����bd��z�v�t&~¾l�mqv�b `&��t]z�v�l�ms�*v�wst¹¡{m{z$�Öv�b$��l g ë m=v�wst!`]z�c�t©b � mst]z�� Á ��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut&cyv�wsl�c~�l�c�v�l�ms`+v�lnbdmRl�cy}s���s����tu~��Öz$ms~O~stu�Ztums~sc¹bdmRv�w�t*c�v���t&ms�$v�wOb � v�wst���t&��v��s��}{z�v�lnbdm�g ë mv�wst�`�wsz$b$v�ln`���t&�dln� t��Pt+|dt&m � z$c�v©v�t&���*c!��z]�¬mst&tu~�v�b¦}Zt*v���t&z�v�tu~öz$c©��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut&cug¥o�nv�wsbd�s�dw¬msb¾c���t&tu~·`&b$� �{z���l�c�bdmsc«��t&��t ��z�~st$�G��t�}�t&��lntu|$t�v�w{z�v!bd�s�¹�*tuv�wsbh~¬l�cz���c�b � z$c�v�t&�u�Åc�l�m�`&t���t!~sbdm  vywsz�|$t©v�b*tu|�z$�n�{z�v�t�z�mJ�¾lnmJv�t&�d��z$��c�bd��lnmJ|$t&��vov�wst#z$m��d��t� z$��g"¢£wJ�scu�¸bd�s�!� t+v�wsb�~·`&z$m�}�t��sc�t&~�v�b¦c�v��s~���wsl��dw�t&�!~sl��*t&msc�l�bdmsz$�¸c���c�v�t&�*cf �s�öv�b � Û ® z$ms~5� z���}�t¤tu|$t&m w�l��dwstu� k gö¯ob��1t+|dtu�&�a�nl�î$t�v�wst¦¼a¯�é � t+v�wsb�~��b$�s���*tuv�wsb�~��­z$c�`&�s����tumJv��n�¬l��*�s�nt&�*t&mqv�tu~��ºz�c�c���� tuc#z=c���z$�n�¸�Ztu��v��s��}{z�v�l�b$m·bdm·z

i ó

Page 101: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~�t&��l�mqv�tu�d��z�}s��t«¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$m�gr �s� � ��v��s��t!�dbqz$�Tl�c£v�b�~st+v�t&��� lnmst«v�wst!c�v����s`+v��s��t�b � v�w�t!� z�v���l�`ut&c£lnm¾v�wst ë�ÁoÁ}sz$c�lnc&g¹¢£wst��d��t]z�v�t&c�v!z�~�|�z$mqv�z$�dt©b � v�wst ë�ÁÁ ��t&�s��t&c�t&mqv�z�v�l�bdmOlncov�wsz�v«lnvyl�ms`ubd����b Á��z�v�tuc1�#��`�w¤b � v�w�ty`&��z$c�c�l�`&z$�Z�*t&`�wsz$msl�`uc1lnmJv�b�v�wstylnmJ|�z$��l¿z$mqv°v�b$��l �Jv�w�t&��tu}q��� z$îJl�ms���bdc�c�l�}���t¹v�wst!l�c�bd�¿z�v�l�bdm"b � ��t&c�l�~s�sz$�ÖÆ��sz$mqv��s��tu�Zt&`+v�cyc��s`�wOz$co~���m{z$�*l�`]z���v��smsm�t&� Álnms�sgÒ¥omL�sms~stu��c�v�z$ms~�l�ms��b � v�wst¦`&bd���s��lnms�dc*}Zt+v��1tut&mÒv�wst ë�ÁoÁ v�bd��l£��l��n����tu|$t]z$�w�bj�ãv�wst«v���msmst&�Ö`ubd�s�s�nl�ms�dc£}�t&wsz�|$t$g�¢£wsl�c�`&b$�s��~¾l�m¤v�����m¾}Zt!�sc�tu~¦v�b*��ms~st&��c�v�z$ms~��wst&msb$� tum{z¬c��s`�wLz�c���b�`]z$�nl Ä z�v�l�b$m·b � v�wst¤v��smsmstu��l�m��s�°bd��l � v�wst"��t&��v��s��}{z�v�lnbdm�l�cc��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À� c�v���bdms�s�ht&���$bh~sln`&lÀv���b�|dt&��v�wstot&mstu���$�*wq���Ztu��c���� � z$`ut«~s�stov�b#~���m{z$�*l�`&z$�v��smsmstu��lnms�sgë vÄw{z$c°}�t&tum��*t&mqv�lnbdmst&~�lnm�v�wsl�c¸`�wsz$��v�tu�Äv�w{z�vÄl�m�v�wst�Æ��sz$c�l Á l�mqv�t&�d��z$}s��t1��t&�$l��*t$�v�wst"`&bd���s��lnms�dc�}�tuv���t&t&m v�wst ë�ÁÁ v�bd��l£`&bd����tuc���bdms~öv�b¬~���m{z$�*l�`]z��1v��sm�mst&�nl�ms�Ol�mv�wst�c�t&�*l�`&��z$c�c�l�`&z$�Å��l��*lnv&g ÷ t&`&z$�sc�t�v�wsty����t&c�t&ms`ut¹b � ��tuc�bdmsz$ms`&tuc��s��t+|dt&mqv£v�wstytu��l�� Álnm{z�v�l�bdm�b � v�w�t ë�ÁÁ `&b$�s�s��lnms�dc�x`_ @7a ��lÀv�w{z$c�}Ztut&m z$���d��t&~5l�m Á t � g i v�w{z�v*lnvlncov�wst � bd����z�v�l�bdm¾b � ��tuc�bdmsz$ms`&t Ä bdmstuc�l�m=v�wst#�swsz$c�t�c��{z$`&t#��w�l�`�w � z$`ul���lÀv�z�v�t&c£v�w�tv��smsmstu��lnms�sg ë m�z=×»bdl�m�`]z$��t*c��s� � z�`&t�b � c�tu`uv�l�bdm��Öv�w�t �swsz$c�t c��{z$`ut�c��s����bd�sms~slnms�¦zwq����t&��}�bd�nl�`�¡�§ht&~¤��bdl�mqv�l�m�v�wst���t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut Ä b$msty�nbhbdîJcÄ�#�s`�w��nl�î�tv�wsty�swsz$c�t�c��{z$`ut� b$�¹v�wst*bdmst Á ~sl��*t&m�c�l�b$m{z$�¸z$}�b�|dt Á }{z$����lnt&�¹��tS>{t&`+v�l�b$m��s��bd}s�nt&� Ù i � Â2Â&Ú �»��w�l�`�w·lnc!z����l��*t�t(§sz�� �s�nt«b � ~���m{z$�*l�`]z��Tv��sm�mst&�nl�ms�sgi æ

Page 102: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

¼1��z$c�c�l�`]z����n�$��w�bj��tu|$t&�u��lnm#çyb$�º�*bd��t�~sl��*t&msc�l�bdm�c&��¥y��m�bd�  ~�ú�ln�Z�sc�l�bdm!`]z$m�`&z$�sc�ttumst&���$��v���z$msc���bd��v1}�tuv���t&tum�v�wstv�bd��l gº¥�v���z=<�t&`+v�bd���*`]z$m*v���z]|$t&�Zz$��bdm��!v�wsto¥o��msb$�  ~��t&}*l�m�v�wst£`�w{z$b$v�l�`£lnmJv�t&��c�v�ln`&tucÄ}�tuv���t&tum�v�w�t�v�bd��l��qz$ms~�� z]�©|dtu������t&�n�{}Zt�t&���db�~sl�`b�|$t&��v�wstt&mstu���$��wq���Ztu��c��s� � z$`ut$g°¢£wJ�sc&��l�m�wsl��$wst&�°~sln� tumsc�lnbdmsc&��z¹mJ�s� tu��ln`]z$�Åc�v��s~��v�b=~st+v�tu���*l�mst���wst+v�wstu��v�w�t ë�ÁÁ `&bd�s����l�m��dc!z$��t*�s��ln��z���l��À�=~��st v�b¾v��smsmstu��l�m��¦bd�v�bö¥y��m�bd�  ~�ú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdmÒl�c¤m�t&`&tuc�c�z$���$g3¢£w�t¬�$t&mstu��z$�«`ubdmsc�tumsc���c=l�c v�w{z�v"¥o��msb$�  ~ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m·l�c©c���b��ïz$ms~��nbh`&z$��l Ä t&c�ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� Á �*t&`�wsz$msl�`&z$���À� Ù i �  ç Ú g¬¥�mJ�s� tu��ln`]z$�c�v��s~h��b � v�wslncÄ��wst&msb$� tumsbdm�l�c¸c�v�l��n�h�1z$����z$mqv�tu~�}�t � bd��t£��z$îJlnms��v�wst�`u�¿z$ln�Av�w{z�v¸v�w�të�ÁÁ v�bd��lGz���t¹`&bd���s��tu~¦}q�¤~���m{z�� ln`]z$�Tv��smsmstu��lnms����lnv�w"`ut&��v�z$l�mqv��$g÷ t � bd��t�`&bdm�`&����~sl�ms���$lnvPc�tut&�*c¸z$�s����bd�s��l¿z�v�tÄv�by}s��l�tS>s�!~sl�c�`&�sc�c­v�wst���v�ln��lnv���b � v�w�të�ÁÁ z$�s����bqz$`�w*l�m*�dtumst&��z$� �Jz$m�~ v�w�to×°ú Ø ln� �s�nt&�*t&mqv�z�v�l�b$m#b � lÀv°l�m��{z$��v�ln`&�s��z$�&�Jz$cz m���� tu��l�`&z$�»� t+v�wsb�~ � bd�oÆ��sz$mqv��s� `]z$�n`&�s��z�v�lnbdmsc&g¥ � v�t&�yz$�����ZlÀvylncy�sc��{z$���À�¾t]z$c�l�t&�z�ms~ � z$c�v�t&�!v�bR��c�t¤z¾`&bdmq|dtumsl�tumqv Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~st&��}{z$c�lnc#z$m�~�c�ln� �s�À�O~sl¿z��dbdm{z$�nl Ä t�z��z$���$t#}{z$c�l�c«c�t+v]g�¢£wst*×°ú Ø �*tuv�wsbh~Olnc«`&�s�#}�t&��c�bd�*t�}q�U`&b$� �{z���l�c�bdm��G��t&ÆJ�sl���l�ms��*bd��t«c�bd�sw�l�c�v�l�`&z�v�tu~¾� z�v�wst&� z�v�ln`]z$�Tz$ms~"mJ�s�*t&��ln`]z$�T��z$`�w�l�mstu���dg

¥oc�v�wst#~�l��*t&msc�l�bdm{z���lnv���b � z�c���c�v�t&� l�ms`u��t]z�c�t&cu�Tv�w�t�}{z$c�lncyc�tuv¹��tuÆJ�sl���t&~ � bd�yz~�l���tu`uv Ä t&��b�v�w Á bd��~stu�#~sl�z$�dbdm{z���l Ä z�v�lnbdm¬`&bd�s�n~�}Zt�v�bhbU��z$���$t � bd�©v�wst¤`&bd�*�s��v�t&�#v�bwsz$ms~s�nt$g­¥oc1�*t&mqv�lnbdmst&~ l�m c��s}sc�t&`+v�l�b$m"ehg ® g e��J��t«z$�n��t&z$~���t&m�`&bd�smqv�t&��tu~�v�wslnc�����bd} Á�nt&��l�mUbd���«m���� tu��l�`&z$�Pv�t&c�v�c&g�¢£w�t ë�ÁÁ z��s�s��bdz$`�wO`]z$mOc�ln�dmslÀ¡{`]z$mqv��n�¦��t&~��s`&t�v�w�ti ®

Page 103: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

c�l Ä t¾b � v�wst"}{z$c�l�c���tuÆ���l���tu~�v�bObd}�v�z$l�m�v�w�t¾~�t&c�ln��tu~5tumst&���dl�tuc&�Äv�b¬zU�Zbdlnmqv���wst&��tv�wsl�c }{z$c�l�c�`&z$mÒt]z$c�l��À� }�t=c�v�bd��t&~Fz$ms~ ~sl¿z$�$bdm{z$�nl Ä tu~ bdm v�wstR`ubd�*�s��v�tu�&g9¢£wJ�scu���w�l���t*c��nb��1tu��v�wsz$m·~sln��tu`uv#~�l¿z$�db$m{z$��l Ä z�v�l�bdmT�Tv�wslnc©z��s�s��bdz$`�w�� z��¬}�t��sc�t � �s��z$c©zmJ�s�*t&��l�`&z$�­�*tuv�w�bh~UlnmU`]z$c�t&c¹��wst&��t�v�wst���tuÆ���l���tu~ Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~�t&�«}{z$c�l�c«c�tuv!c�l Ä t�l�cc�l��*�s�n��v�bhb#��z$���$t � bd��v�wst«`&b$� �s�hv�t&�av�b�w{z$ms~���t$g¸¢£w�t ë�ÁoÁ z$�s�s��bqz$`�w"w{z$cav�wst«z$~ Á~�lnv�lnbdm{z$�Zz$~�|�z$mqv�z$�dtyv�w{z�vav�wst«��tu~s�s`&tu~¦}sz$c�lnc£l�ca�*bd��ty�swq�hc�l�`&z$���À���*b$v�lÀ|�z�v�tu~�v�w{z�mv�wst Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~st&�}{z$c�l�c&�Åc�l�ms`ut!v�wst ë�ÁÁ }{z$c�l�c�l�ct+§�v���z$`uv�t&~ � ��bd�ïv�wst���ms~st&���n��l�m��`u�¿z$c�c�ln`]z$��~h�hmsz$� ln`&c£b � v�w�t!c���c�v�tu�¦g

i$i

Page 104: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

b c dfehgjilk m

n o p drq sKtudrv w x p p iyvzs p { | i}kE~�x ~

� k p � v���� n s�� x ~�s ��p � �

b � q e dfk�sK~ ��p ��� x d p g�x q d p �

b v�dr~�~�sKt�d�v � p i}k {ro � v ��� � d�gjil~

¢£w�l�cº`�wsz$��v�tu�­z�v�v�tu� ��v�cPv�by��tuc�bd�À|dt1v�wst1lnc�c��st1b � v�wst�m{z�v�����t1b � v�wst1â�äþâ Â{¶ â�ä  `&� @ ñ��t]z�îyc�����lnv�v�lnms�dcTb$}sc�tu��|dtu~©lnm«wsl��dw Á ��tuc�bd�n��v�lnbdm ë�Á c���t&`uv���z£b � ��bd�n�dz�v�bd�*l�`P� b$��t&`u�s��tuc&gë v¦l�c"}�t&�nl�tu|$t&~Fv�w{z�v"v�wst&c�t·c�����lnv�v�lnms�dc"z$��t�`&z$�sc�tu~�}q��~���m{z$�*l�`&z$��v��sm�mst&�nl�ms�s��z

i�p

Page 105: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÆJ�{z�mJv��s� Á �*t&`�w{z$m�l�`]z����swstumsbd�*t&msb$m���w�t&��tu}q��t&mstu���$��>sbj��c¸}�tuv���t&tum v���b¹��t&�$l�bdmscb � �sw{z�c�t Á c��{z�`&t¦z�v z¬��z�v�t"�dtumst&��z$���À���#�s`�w � z$c�v�t&��v�wsz$m �s��t&~sln`uv�t&~5}J�ö`u�¿z$c�c�ln`]z$��*t&`�wsz$msl�`uc&gU¯b��1t+|dt&�u�Äz=�Zb$c�c�ln}s��t `&��z$c�c�l�`]z��Ä�*t&`�wsz$msl�c�� � b$�!v�wst�t&m�t&�����j>{b��3l�c¥o��msb$�  ~Uú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdm��Å��wsl�`�wO`ubdmsmstu`uv�c«~�ln�Zt&��tumqv¹��t&�$l�bdmscobdmRv�w�t#t&mstu���$�RwJ����t&��c��s� Á� z�`&t"}q�öz¬��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut¦m�tuv���bd��î�îJmsb���mLz�c�v�wst"¥y��msbd�  ~��·tu}�g ô c�lnms�¬zUc�l��*�s�nt$��$tuv�swq��c�ln`]z$�n�n����t&�ntu|�z$mqv]�{¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$m��d��t!`ubd�*�{z$��t«~h�hmsz$� ln`]z$��v��sm�mst&�nl�ms����z�v�tuc��lÀv�w�¥y��m�bd�  ~�ú�lÀ�T�sc�l�bdmT�Ö��w�l�`�w�lnc�c�wsb���m�v�b=}�t��©�s`�w�c��nb��1tu��v�wsz$m�~���m{z$�*l�`&z$�v��smsmstu��lnms�sg��P�� ��W [¸Ì U�Y ÈUÎ�[­Í UXW

¥om���ms��tuc�bd�À|dt&~·Æ���t&c�v�l�bdm�l�mUv�w�t �swq��c�ln`]z$�°`�wstu� lnc�v����O`&b$� �#��mslnv��=l�c«v�wst�m{z�v��s��tb � v�wstOâ�äåâ Â#¶ â�ä  â�`u�A@ ñ �Zt&z$î c��s��lÀv�v�lnms�dc�v�w{z�v�w{z]|dtO}�t&tumÒbd}sc�tu��|$t&~Fl�mLwsln�dw Á��t&c�bd����v�l�bdm ë�Á c��Ztu`uv���zRb � ��bd�À�qz�v�bd� ln`�� bd�nt&`u�s��tuc�Ù i �  â Ú g=¢£wstuc�t�c��s��lÀv�v�lnms�dc�z$��tlnms~sln`]z�v�ln|dt1b � tumst&���$��>{b��Llnm�v�wst��sw{z�c�tc��{z$`ut�b � v�wst�� bd�nt&`u�s��t��dl�ms~��s`&tu~ }q�#��t]z$î��t&c�l�~s�{z��«z$msw{z����*bdmsl�`=`&bd�s����l�m��dc&�oz$ms~�`&b$mJv�z$l�m�lnm � bd��� z�v�l�bdm bdmÒv�wstO��b$ms� Á v�l��*t~h�hmsz$� ln`&cÄb � v�wst� bd�nt&`u�s��tuc&g r mstowq�h��b$v�wst&c�l�c1wsz$c�}�t&tum v�w{z�vÄv�wst� tu`�w{z$mslnc�� � bd�v�wsl�c1�Zt&z$î�c��s��lÀv�v�lnms�©lnca~s�st�v�b�~���m{z$�*l�`&z$�Zv��smsmstu��l�m��s��v�wsbd�s�$w¾m�b�~stu¡{m�lnv�lÀ|dt«�s��bhb �wsz$c£�dtuv}�t&tum=�dlÀ|dt&m·Ù ijÚ g

i�á

Page 106: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

×Pz$��v«b � v�wst#����bd}s�nt&��l�mRtu���s`ul�~{z�v�l�m��*v�wst#�*t&`�w{z$m�l�c���b � ë mqv���z$�*bd��tu`&�s��z$�+�yl Á}���z�v�l�bdm{z�� Á t&~�l�c�v���ln}s��v�lnbdm f ë � Á k lncov�w{z�v�lÀvylnco¡{��c�v«m�t&`&tuc�c�z$���¦v�b�~st+¡{mst�z c�tuv�b �c�v����s`uv��s��tuc#}Zt+v��1tut&m���wsln`�w·v�w�t tumst&���$�¬��t&~�l�c�v���ln}s��v�lnbdm¬bh`u`&�s��c&g ë ms~stut&~��­lÀv!��z]�}�t!z$���$�st&~"v�w{z�v���t&~�l�c�v���ln}s��v�lnbdm¤b � t&mstu���$�"lnc�z$m¦z$��v�l � z$`+v]��c�l�ms`ut¹l�m¤v�wst¹ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� Á�*t&`�wsz$msl�`&z$�atul��dtum�}sz$c�lnc*b � v�wst"c���c�v�t&�¾�1msb¬��tu~sl�c�v���l�}s��v�l�bdm·bh`u`&�s��c�z�v*z���� g�¢£wsl�c`&z$mR}�t�c�t&tumU}J�¾msb�v�l�m��*v�w{z$mUz$m¦t&ln�dt&msc�v�z�v�t�� �� £b � tumst&���$� ( b � c�bd�*t©¯oz$� ln�nv�b Ám�l¿z$mRt+|dbd�À|dtuc¹z$`&`ubd��~slnms� v�b¡� �)  ½ Û�¢ @3£¥¤ ½§¦:¨© � �) ugo¢£w���c&�G��tu~sl�c�v���l�}s��v�l�bdm¦l�cyz�}{z$c�l�c Á~�t&��t&ms~stumqvymsb�v�l�b$m�g

¥øm{z�v��s��z��£}{z$c�lnc � ��bd� ��w�l�`�wöv�b¬~stu¡{m�t¦tumst&���$�ö��tu~sl�c�v���ln}s��v�l�bdm�lnc*�$ln|dtum }q�v�wstylnmq|$z���l¿z�mJvÄv�b$��lÅb � v�w�t�¯yz�� ln�nv�b$msl¿z$mTg»¢£w�ty|�l�}s��z�v�lnbdm{z$�ůoz$� ln�nv�bdmsl¿z�msc¸b � ��bd�n� Áz�v�bd�*l�`ucGz$��t°�dlÀ|dtum�}q�¹w{z$��� b$msl�` Á bdc�`&l��n�¿z�v�bd��cÅ�s�n�sc»z$msw{z����*bdmsl�`Pv�t&��� cugº¢£wstÄz$m�w{z$� Á�*bdmsln`&lÀv�l�tucz$��t#c���z����»l�m=v�wst#��b�� ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� Á mJ�s�#}�t&�«��tu�dl��*t$�Å��wsln`�wUl�c��dtumst&��z$���À�v�wst©��t&�dln� t!�s��bd}Ztu~U}q�=t(§���t&��l��*t&mqv�z���l�c�v�cl�m ë�Á c��Ztu`uv���bdc�`ubd�q�dg¹¢£wJ�sc&�Zv�wstDª¹¥�颣w�t&bd��t&�ýz$c�c��s��tucºv�w{z�v­z$�n� b$c�v»z$�n��b � v�w�t1�sw{z�c�t Á c��{z�`&talnc»¡{�n��tu~!��lÀv�w©lnmq|$z���l¿z�mJvÖv�bd��lÙèe ® �Ge p�Ú g ÿ t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$���À�d�Zbdmst���z]�Rz$c�c�bh`ul¿z�v�t*ÆJ�{z�mJv��s� Á �*t&`�w{z$m�l�`]z��º�az]|$t � �sms` Áv�l�bdm�c»��lÀv�w©v�wstal�mq|�z$��l¿z$mqvÖv�bd��lhb � z$`uv�l�bdmsc f¬«jñ+³ ä]ä]ä ³­« M k ÛãeIHKJL f.ð»ñ ݯ® ñ±° ó ³ ä]ä]ä ³�ð M Ý® M ° ó k go¯ot&��t©v�w�t ð £ z$��t�msbdmsmstu�qz�v�ln|dt�l�mqv�tu�dt&��c&�Tz$ms~Rv�w�t ® £ z$��t�v�w�t�é=z$c���b�|¾l�m Á~�l�`&tuc&�°��wsl�`�w z$��t¾��c��{z$�n�n�·t&ÆJ�{z$�av�b·e�g�¢£wst¦c�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�1tumst&���$��c��Ztu`uv����s��l�cv�wst&m�b$}�v�z$lnmst&~�}q�·c�tuv�v�l�ms� ( f²ðÖñ+³ ä]ä]ä ³�ð M k Û x f¬«jñ(³ ä]ä&ä ³­« M k �º��w�t&��t�x ~st&m�b$v�tucp â

Page 107: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

v�wst!¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdm�l¿z$m�g¢£wst�� t+v�wsb�~`<���c�vo~st&c�`&��ln}Ztu~Rl�c£v�wst Ø l�m�c�v�tul�m Á ÷ ��ln���nbd�sl�m Á ª«t&�n�ntu� f Ø ÷ ª k ÆJ�{z$m Á

v�l Ä z�v�lnbdmO� t+v�wsb�~��Pz$ms~�v�wst���bdlnmJv!lnc¹v�w{z�v&�ºtu|$t&m � b$��mst&z$���À�Ul�mqv�t&�d��z$}s��t�c��hc�v�tu� cu�lÀv¤l�c�c�v�ln���o�Zbdc�c�ln}s��t=v�b�c�tu� ln`&�¿z�c�c�ln`]z$�n�n��¡{m�~ãz�c�tuv¾b � �db�bh~ÒÆJ�{z$mqv��s� mJ�s�#}�t&��cf.ð»ñ+³ ä&ä]ä ³�ð M k `�w{z$��z�`uv�tu��l Ä l�m���v�w�tRt&mstu���$� c���t&`+v����s�¦g ÿ ��t&`+v���b$c�`&b$�sl�c�v�c¤z�v�v�tu� ��vv�b ~�tuv�tu���*l�mst«v�wst � ��ms`uv�l�bdm{z�� � bd����b � v�wst!t&m�t&�����"~st&��t&ms~�t&ms`ut#bdm"v�wst!ÆJ�{z$mqv��s�mJ�s�©}Ztu��c�}q�¤¡sv�v�l�ms��v�w�t!c��Ztu`uv���z$�G��t]z$îJc£v�b z$m"t+§h�{z�msc�lnbdm��( f²ðÖñ(³ ä]ä]ä ³�ð M k Û (+² Ý M�

£ � ñ3³ £ ð £ Ý�£µ´ ¶¸·3£ ³ £¹¶

ð £ ð ¶ Ý �£µ´ ¶ ·3£µ´ � ·º¶ ³ £¹¶

� ð £ ð ¶ ð � Ý ä]ä]ä f çhg Âjk��w{z�v1w{z��s�Ztumsc � b$�Ä�*t&~�l��s� Á c�l Ä tu~��Zbd�À�qz�v�bd�*l�`&c¸lnc¸v�w{z�v�t&m�t&������>{b���}Zt+v��1tut&m

v�wst�v�bd��l»~stuc�v���b��hc�v�wst©�$bhb�~=ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� mJ�s�©}Ztu��c«z$m�~R��t&z$~scov�b�c��Ztu`uv���bdc�`ubd�sln`]z$�n�n���m{z$c�c�l��dmsz$}s��t"��t]z$îJcugF¢£w�t¦��t]z$îöc��s��lÀv�v�lnms�dc�z$��t¦c��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�öm{z$����b���v�w{z�v v�wstu�z���t�v�w�t!��t&c��s�nv�b � �nbdms� Á v�l��*t~���m{z$�*l�`&cu�sbdm¤v�w�t!b$��~stu�£b � v�wsbd�sc�z$ms~sc£v�b*wJ�sm�~s��tu~scb � v�wsbd�sc�z$ms~sc«b � |hln}s��z�v�l�b$m{z$�»�Ztu��l�b�~scob � v�wst#�*bd�nt&`&����t$g r mst©�Zbdc�c�ln}s��t�`&�s�n�s��lÀv�l�c�*b�~st¤� l¨§hl�ms�s�¸��wstu��tu}J�5v�w�t¾��t]z�î�c��s�nlnv�v�l�ms�$c�z$��t¤v�w�t¦��t&c����nv*b � v�wst � bd��� z�v�l�bdmb � mst+� ì�msb$��� z$��íU�*bh~�t&c&gö¢£wst"��t&�¿z�v�ln|$t"c�v���t&ms��v�w5b � v�wst"~sln�Zt&��t&mqv*�Zt&z$îJc lnc�z�*t]z�c��s��t=b � v�wst¦��t&��z�v�lÀ|dt¾`&bdmqv���l�}���v�lnbdm b � v�wst¾~slÀ�Ttu��t&mqv�ì���b�`]z$�níU� b�~stuc*v�b�v�w�tb�|$t&��z����¹ì�m�bd��� z$��í�� b�~st&cug ë mOv�wst���z$ms�d�sz$�dt#b � `u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�­�*t&`�w{z�msl�`uc&�Gbdmst���bd�s�n~c�z]� v�w{z�vav�wst���t]z$î*c��s�nlnv�v�l�m��dc�lnms~sln`]z�v�tv�w{z�vav�wsty|�l�}s��z�v�lnbdm{z$�{~h�hmsz$� ln`&ca��t&c�l�~st�b$m

pbÂ

Page 108: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

lnmq|$z���l¿z�mJvTv�bd��ld�n��l�m��£l�msc�l�~st¸��t&c�b$m{z$ms`ut Ä bdmst&c»�dtumst&��z�v�tu~�}q��v�wstįyz$�*l��Àv�bdmsl�z$m�g�¢£w�t� z$lnm��s��bd}s��tu�3��lÀv�w�v�wsl�caz$m{z$�À�hc�l�c�l�c1v�w{z�v1v�wst&c�t¹�Zt&z$î c��s��lÀv�v�l�ms�dc�z$��t��s}slnÆ���lnv�b$�sc&�z�ms~�z$��t*z$����t]z$~��Rc�t&tum�z�v!��b��ÇÆ��sz$mqv��s� mJ�s�#}�t&��c f ç=z$ms~¬b � v�t&m·�nt&c�c k g ¥av©c��s`�w�nb���ÆJ�{z$mqv����9m����#}Ztu��cÖv�wstÄz$m�w{z$���*bdmsln`&lÀv�l�tuc�l�m«v�wstÄ|�ln}s��z�v�l�bdmsz$�d¯oz$� ln�nv�bdmsl¿z�m«z$��tc��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�¹c�� z$����v�w{z�vÖv�wst°��t&c�bdm{z$m�`&t Ä bdmstucPc�wsbd�s�n~�b�`&`u�s�q�¹bdms�À�¹z£c�� z$��� � ��z$`uv�l�bdmb � v�wst�v�b$v�z$�­�sw{z�c�t Á c��{z�`&t |$bd����� t�g�¢£w���c&�ºlÀv«l�c¹ln� �s��bd}{z$}���t�v�w{z�v!l�mq|�z$��l¿z$mqv�v�bd��l��t&c�l�~slnms�Ol�m�v�wst"��t&c�b$m{z$ms`ut Ä b$mst&c*`&bd����~öc��s���Zbd��v z¬c�l��dmslÀ¡{`]z�mJv � ��z$`uv�l�bdmöb � v�w�t|�ln}s��z�v�l�bdmsz$�Ttul��dtumsc�v�z�v�tuc&g÷ �=c�ln� ln�¿z$����t&z$c�b$msl�ms���G`&�¿z�c�c�ln`]z$�»`�w{z$b$c!lnc���lnî$tu�n�¦z$��c�b"z$mUl�m�c��/.*`&lnt&mqv¹�*t&`�w{z Ám�l�c���z$`u`&bd��mJv�l�ms� � bd�v�wst©��t]z�î¾c��s��lÀv�v�l�ms�dcug£��wsl��nt�c��s`�wOz��*t&`�w{z$m�l�c�� ��bd�s�n~R}Ztt(§h�Ztu`uv�tu~�v�b~�bd� lnm{z�v�t � bd�G�¿z����dt­ÆJ�{z�mJv��s��mJ�s�#}�t&��c&��v�wst¸ÆJ�{z$c�l Á l�mqv�tu�d��z$}���t­��t&�dln� tlncÄv�wst��t&�$l��*tb � l�mqv�tu��tuc�valnm*v�wsl�cÄ�{z$��t&�ug­¢£wst���t&� z$l�m�l�ms�«�*t&`�w{z�msl�c��òz�`&`&b$�smqv�l�m��� b$�1v�wst«��t]z�î�c�����lnv�v�lnms�dc1lnc)>{b���}�tuv���t&tum¾v�wst«l�mq|�z$��l¿z$mqvav�bd��lZ��t&c�l�~slnms��bd��v�c�ln~styv�w�t��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut Ä bdmstuc&g ÷ t&`&z$�sc�t�v�w�t*c��s��lÀv�v�l�ms�dc�z$��t�lnms~sl�`&z�v�lÀ|dt�b � ��b$ms� Á v�l��*t�~h�hmsz$� Áln`&cu�Pv�w�tu�·z$��t*}Ztu��lntu|dtu~·v�b¦}Zt ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� Á �*t&`�wsz$msl�`&z$�°l�m�m{z�v�����t$�ºl gèt$gÀ�º~���m{z$�*l�`&z$�v��smsmstu��lnms�sgL¯b��1t+|dt&�u� � bd� c���c�v�tu� c*��lnv�w �*bd��t¤v�wsz$m v���b·~stu�d��tut&c�b �y� ��tut&~sb$�¦�z�msb$v�w�t&�¹v��h��t�b � ��bdm�� Á v�l��*t#`&��z$c�c�l�`]z��­v���z�msc���bd��v�}�tuv���t&t&m�lnmq|$z���l¿z�mJv¹v�bd��l°l�c¹��bdc Ác�l�}s�nt ½ ¥y��m�bd�  ~Oú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdm�g!¥y��msbd�  ~Oú�ln�Z�sc�l�bdmRb�`&`u�s��c«��wstum·z�v���z=<�tu`uv�bd���U�*b�|dtucz���bdms�RzR��t&c�bdm{z$m�`&t¤�smqv�ln�1lÀv#l�mqv�t&��c�t&`+v�c*zRc�tu`&bdms~ö��t&c�b$m{z$ms`ut$��z�v#��wsln`�w��Zbdlnmqv�lnvp e

Page 109: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�*b�|dtuc1z$�nbdms�«v�w�toc�t&`&b$ms~���tuc�bdmsz$ms`&t�g ë m��dtumst&��z$� �qv�w�to��t&c�b$m{z$ms`utoc�v�����`uv�����tyb � v�w�t¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$m � bd���*c!z¦mst+v��1b$��î·îJmsb���m�z�c�v�w�t�¥y��msbd�  ~¬�·tu}�g ë m��s��lnms`&ln�s��t��P}q�msz�|�ln�qz�v�lnms�#v�w�t�¥o��msbd�  ~¤��t&}���z�v���z=<�t&`+v�bd���¤`]z$m¦t&���dbh~�l�`]z����n��v���z]|dtu��c�t!v�wst!t&mqv�l���ttumst&���$�"wq���Ztu��c���� � z$`ut�Ù i ��e ® Ú g

ªtu|dtu��v�wst&�nt&c�cu�Ölnv�lnc�}�t&��lntu|$t&~Rv�wsz�v�~���m{z�� ln`]z$�»v��smsm�t&��lnms��~�bd� lnm{z�v�t&cy¥o��msb$�  ~ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m�� � bd�«c�tu|dtu��z$�°��t]z$c�bdmsc&g Ãºln��c�v�b � z���� �T~���m{z$�*l�`]z��ºv��sm�mst&�nl�ms�"z$�n��t&z$~��Rb�` Á`u�s��cUlnm�c���c�v�t&�*cU��lnv�w�v��1bÒ~stu�d��tut&cOb ��� ��tut&~sb$�¦�¹��wsl��nt·¥o��msbd�  ~ ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$mãl�cb$ms�n� z��Zbdc�c�ln}s��tR�*t&`�wsz$msl�c�� l�mLv�ws��tutO~st&�d��t&tuc¾b �!� ��t&tu~sbd� z$m�~Fw�l��dwstu�&g ÿ t&` Áb$ms~��G¥y��msbd�  ~¬ú�ln�Z�sc�l�bdmRwsz$c«}Ztut&m¬c�wsb���m�z$m{z$�À�Jv�l�`&z$���À�¤v�b"}�t���z�v�wst&�«c���b��¹����lnv�wz�~sln�Z�sc�lnbdm5`&b�t».*`&lnt&mqv�v�wsz�v�c�`]z$�nt&c�z�cA¢ @½¼:¾ ¿ÁÀIÂz¾ ¦Äà Š�a��wst&��t?Æ�~stumsb$v�t&c�v�w�t=��t&� Áv��s��}sz�v�lnbdm�c�v���t&ms�$v�w��¸z$m�~¡Ç ß _ lnc�îJmsb���m�z�c!v�wst���t&c�b$m{z$ms`ut�~st+v��smslnms��Ù çqæh�»ç ijÚ gÃPl�m{z$�n�n�$��c�v��s~slnt&cy}q�¤��bd�n��mstucyz�ms~=`ub Á ��bd��î�t&��cybdm=z*ÆJ�{z$mqv�l Ä tu~Rc�v�bh`�wsz$c�v�l�`!�s�s�*��*b�~st&�hb � ¥o��msb$�  ~ ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m#c��s�$�dt&c�vÄv�w{z�v°¥o��msbd�  ~�ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m���b�`]z$�nl Ä tucºÆJ�{z$mqv��s� Á�*t&`�wsz$msl�`&z$���À�UÙ Â ç���e ® �{çqe��{çdç��Åç$óh�Åç ® Ú gë vyc�wsbd����~R}�t©tu� �swsz$c�l Ä t&~Uw�t&��t�v�w{z�vo`&b$� �{z���l�c�bdmsco}Zt+v��1tut&mO~���m{z$�*l�`&z$�Gv��sm Ám�t&��lnms� z$ms~ã¥o��msb$�  ~ãú�lÀ�T�sc�l�bdmF�#�sc�v=}�t¬��z$~�t�lnmFv�wst � t+�HÆJ�{z$mqv��s� Á mJ�s�©}Ztu���t&�dln� t�g ¢£w�t���t&z$c�b$m � bd�«v�w�l�c¹l�c«v�wsz�v � b$�!c��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�Owsl��dw¬ÆJ�{z$mqv���� mJ�s�©}Ztu��c&�ÆJ�{z�mJv��s� tu�Zt&`+v�c=}�t&`ubd�*t��sm�l��*�Zbd��v�z$mqv&��c�b ¥y��m�bd�  ~ãú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m���bd�s�n~ã}�t�t(§ Á��t&`+v�tu~5v�bU~sbd�*l�m{z�v�t�z$mq��v��smsm�t&��lnms�Utu�Zt&`+v�cug�¥ymöt+§h`ut&���nt&mqv�t+§�z$�*�s�nt�b � v�wslnc#l�cp ç

Page 110: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

v�wst�c�bd�¿z���c��hc�v�tu�¦�­��wstu��t¤lÀv�lnc©}�t&�nl�tu|$t&~·v�w{z�v©¥y��m�bd�  ~�ú�lÀ�T�sc�l�bdm¬l�c���tuc���bdmsc�ln}s��t� b$�©`&tu��v�z$l�möz$c��Ztu`uv�c�b � v�wst¤c�v����s`uv��s��t¤b � v�wst"z$c�v�t&��bdl�~·}Ztu�nv#}�tuv���t&tumLé¦z$��c�z$m�~¾ ���slnv�t&�&gRúy�hmsz$� ln`]z$�°v���msmst&�nl�ms�¦l�c�msb$v�t(§���t&`+v�tu~öv�bU}Zt l��*�Zb$��v�z�mJv�l�m·t+§h�s�¿z�l�m Álnms�O��z�`&��b$c�`&b$�sl�` � t]z�v��s��t&c*b � bd��� c�bd�¿z$��c���c�v�tu�¦gL¯ob��1t+|dtu�&� � bd� ë�Á c�v��s~sl�tuc b$m��bd�À�qz�v�bd� ln`a�*bd��tu`&�s�nt&c&�dv�wst � tu�ÒÆJ�{z�mJv��s� Á mJ�s�#}�t&�°��tu�dl��*t£l�c°t(§sz�`uv��À�#v�w�to��t&�dln� t}�t&lnms�=����bd}�t&~�g ë v©l�c!t+§h�Ztu`uv�t&~�v�wsz�v#ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� t+�Ttu`uv�c#z$��t�l��*��bd��v�z$mqv � bd�!v�wst&c�tv�����t&c¤b � c��hc�v�tu� cu��z$ms~Òc�böz�`&bd�*�{z$��l�c�bdm }�tuv���t&tum�~���m{z�� ln`]z$�v��smsm�t&��lnms��z$m�~¥o��msb$�  ~¦ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m¤��z�v�t&c�l�ca�1z$����z$mqv�tu~�g

¯bj��tu|$t&�u�Zlnm¤`&bd�*�{z$��l�ms��ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� z$ms~"`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$��tumst&���$�A>{b�����z�v�tuc&��v���b*î$tu�lnc�c��st&c mst&tu~ v�b¬}Zt¾�s��bd�Ztu���À�öz$~s~s��t&c�c�t&~Tgãúln��c�v�b � z$�n� �°~sb�t&c�b$mst¦lnms`&�n�s~st Ä tu��b Á��bdlnmJvat&mstu���$�"lnmJv�b#v�wst¹`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$��`&z$��`u�s�¿z�v�l�bdm�c Ⱦ¢£w�t!����bd}s�nt&�òl�cav�wsz�v�l�m"bd��~st&�av�bwsz�|$t«z©�s��bd��t&�1c�t&�*l�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�Åc�ln�#�s�¿z�v�l�b$m�� Ä tu��b Á �Zbdlnmqv1tumst&���$���©�sc�v1}Ztv�z$î�t&m"l�mqv�bz�`&`&b$�smqv]g¾¯ob���tu|dtu�&� � bd��z"c��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�¬�¿z$���dt�m����#}Ztu�©b � |�l�}s��z�v�lnbdm{z$�¸~stu�d��tut&c�b �� ��t&tu~sbd�¾��v�wst Ä t&��b Á ��bdl�mqv£tumst&���$�¤� z���}Zt«c�b ��z$���$tyv�w{z�v�`&�¿z�c�c�ln`]z$�n�n��v�w�t«� bd�nt&`u�s��t`&z$m=~�l�c�c�bh`ul¿z�v�t$�{t+|dt&m=l�m¾lnv�c��d��bd�sms~¦c�v�z�v�t�g ÿ t&`ubdms~s�À�d�Ålnvlncm�t&`&tuc�c�z$���¾v�b*~stu|$t&�nbd�z�`u��lnv�t&��l�bdm���w�l�`�w¾`]z$m"~slnc�v�lnms�d�slnc�w¤}�tuv���t&tum=�dtum���l�mst«¥o��msbd�  ~"ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m"z$ms~"t&m Átu���$�E>{b�� ��wsln`�w lnc c�l��*�s�n��~��st¦v�b·�*bh~st"�*lÀ§hl�m��sgL¢£wslnc lnc msb�v�mstu`&tuc�c�z���l��À� zv���lÀ|hl�z$�Ö�Zb$l�mqv]��c�lnms`&t���t]z���l�c�v�ln`�c��hc�v�tu� c�wsz�|$t�c��s`�w¬z���z$���$t�~stumsc�lÀv��=b � c�v�z�v�t&cov�w{z�vlÀv£}�t&`&b$� tuco~sl§.*`&�s�Àvav�b�v���z$`�î���wsln`�w¦��t&c�b$m{z$ms`ut&coz$��t!z$`+v�ln|$t!z�vz$mq�¤�dlÀ|dt&m"v�ln� t�gp ó

Page 111: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

¢£wst©c�bd�n��v�lnbdm¦v�b�}Zb�v�wR�s��bd}s�nt&�*cyl�c�v�w�t#`&bdm�c�v����s`uv�l�bdmUb � z�c���mqv�w�tuv�ln`�¯yz$�*l�� Áv�bdmsl�z$m���wsln`�w�~sb�t&c©m�b$v#`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$���À�U~slnc�c�b�`&l�z�v�t*��lnv�w�v�w�t�l�ms`u���sc�l�bdm�b � v�wst Ä tu��b Á��bdlnmJvtumst&���$�d�Zz$ms~"��wsl�`�w¦w{z$coz$m=t&z$c�ln�n�¤`ubdmsc�v�����`uv�ln}s��t¹¥o��msbd�  ~"��t&}�����z�î�lnms��lnvz¦c�l��*�s�nt � z�v�v�t&�¹v�bR~�tuv�tu`uv�¥o��msb$�  ~�ú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdm�g ë m·v�w�l�c©�sz$�Ztu����t¤�s��tuc�tumJv�mJ� Á�*t&��l�`&z$�Gc�v��s~sl�tucybdm=z c��s`�wUz�¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$m��h��w�l�`�wRc��s�s��bd��vv�wst�`&bdm�c�t&m�c��scy|�lntu�v�w{z�v�~���m{z$�*l�`&z$�sv��sm�mst&�nl�ms�¹l�cÄ��lnî$tu�n��c�l��dmslÀ¡{`]z�mJv��n� � z$c�v�t&�°v�w{z$m ¥y��msbd�  ~ ú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdm��z�ms~"wst&ms`ut!v�wst¹��z�l�m�`&z$�sc�t¹b � v�w�t¹¡smst¹�Zt&z$î�c�����lnv�v�lnms�dc1b$}sc�tu��|dtu~=lnm ë�Á c���t&`uv���z�g¢£w�bd�s�dwO`&b$msc�v����s`+v�t&~¬}q�Rw{z�ms~��Tv�wst�¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdm�l¿z$m"�1t�����t&c�t&mqv!w{z$c¹z�mJ�s�#}�t&�yb �`�wsz$��z$`+v�tu��l�c�v�ln`&c�l�m"`&b$� �*bdm���lnv�w¤|hln}s��z�v�l�b$m{z$��¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$msc&g

¢£wslnc°`�w{z$��v�t&�Äl�c¸bd���qz$msl Ä t&~*z$c � bd�n��b���c ½ ë m ÿ t&`+v�lnbdm�çhg ey��to�s��t&c�t&mqv�v�wst¯yz$�*l�� Áv�bdmsl�z$mR��wsl�`�wO��t���ln���P�sc�t � bd�«bd���«c��s}sc�t&ÆJ�stumJv©`]z$�n`&�s��z�v�lnbdmscu�Gz$ms~Oc�w�bj�Çwsb��Çv�b`ubdmsc�v�����`uv�lnv�ca¥y��msbd�  ~���t&}�g ë m ÿ tu`uv�l�bdm¾ç�gåç©�1t«~�t&c�`u��ln}Zt«}�b$v�w�v�wst«`&��z$c�c�l�`&z$��z$m�~ÆJ�{z�mJv��s� `]z$�n`&�s��z�v�lnbdmscu��z�ms~#wsb�����t1`&b$� �{z���tÄ~���m{z$�*l�`]z��dv��smsm�t&��lnms�oz$ms~©¥o��msb$�  ~ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m ��z�v�tuc���lnv�w v�wsty��t&c����nv�c�b � v�wsty`&z$��`u�s�¿z�v�l�bdm�c&g ë m ÿ t&`+v�lnbdm�ç�gèó���t��s��t&c�t&mqvv�wst Á t&c��s�nv�caz$ms~"ú�lnc�`u�sc�c�l�bdm�g ë m ÿ t&`+v�l�b$m¤ç�gþæ!�1ty~sl�c�`&�sc�cav�wstoÆ��sz$mqv��s�ïz$m{z$�nbd�d�stb � ¥o��msbd�  ~*ú�lÀ�T�sc�l�bdm�z�c°z¹�*t&`�wsz$msl�c�� � bd�­v�wst�Æ��sz$mqv��s� tumst&���$��>{b��¹g ë m ÿ t&`+v�l�b$mçhg ® ��t«`&b$msc�ln~st&�1v�wst�lnc�c���t«b � ��b�`]z$�nl Ä z�v�lnbdm�l�m�bd���1�*bh~stu� gºÃºl�m{z����n�$�q�1t«`ubdms����~st�l�mÿ t&`uv�l�bdm�ç�g i ��lÀv�w�z¾c��s�*��z$���Ub � bd�s�¹��z�l�mO��tuc��s�Àv�c!z$ms~·z¾~slnc�`u�sc�c�l�bdm¬b �1� �hv��s��t��t&c�t]z$��`�w=�s��z$msc&g p æ

Page 112: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��P¸O É ^RË Ê Ï#Ê Í]ÐS[ UXW Í&Ï W

4Ë���Ë�NÌ Í�Î�8�Ï�Ð9�:�);ÑÏ-;�ÒÓu��ÔÕ;���Ð9�N��;Ñ����Ö\Ïz��Ï-�×�ØÐ9����Ù��tR��l��n�o��bd��î ��lnv�wLv�wst � Á ~sl��*t&msc�l�bdmsz$�y¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$m��a�dlÀ|dtumFlnm�z$`uv�l�bdm Á z$ms�$��t|�z$��l¿z$}���t&c1}J�$�x f5Ú�ñ(³ ä]ä]ä ³¸Ú M ³­«�ñ�³ ä]ä]ä ³­« M k Û�x ² f¬«�ñ+³ ä]ä]ä ³­« M k ÝÜÛÁÝ f5ÚGñ�³ ä]ä]ä ³¸Ú M ³­«�ñ(³ ä]ä]ä ³Þ« M kf çhg e k

��w�t&��tx ² f¬«jñ(³ ä]ä&ä ³­« M k Û M�

£ � ñ f ® £ « £ ¶�ß £ « �£ k f çhgþç kz�ms~

Ý f5ÚGñ�³ ä]ä]ä ³¸Ú M ³­«�ñ(³ ä]ä]ä ³Þ« M k Û �£µàº¶âá £¹¶

f¬« £ ³­« ¶ k `ubdc fãÚ £ ¶ Ú ¶ k f çhgåó k��t«v�wstum¦~�tu¡{mst��

® ��ä @ ñ Û ®"Ý e ß « ² f çhg æ k® ��ä Û ® ¶ e ß f¬« ² Ý Ç « k f çhg ® k

ß ��ä @ ñ Û ß f çhg idkß ��ä Û ¶�ß f çhg pqk

��w�t&��t ® � ß � « ² z$ms~�Ç « z$��t«c��Ztu`&ln¡st&~=`ubdmsc�v�z$mqv�cugp ®

Page 113: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

¢£wst�z$}Zb�|$t�¯yz�� ln�nv�b$msl¿z$mU��t&c�t&�#}s�nt&c©zUé¦bd��c�t Á r c�`&ln����z�v�bd�¹¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$mR��lnv�wm�bdms��lnmst]z���`&bd���s��lnms�£}Zt+v��1tut&m!v�wst¸�nbh`&z$�$�*bh~�t&c&gPÃ{bd���nb���l�ms�Äv�wslncÖz$m{z$�nbd�$�d�]��tÄ~stu¡{m�t® Û ß �j��w�t&��t ß l�cGc�bd� t°c��Ztu`&ln¡st&~!w{z$���*bdmsln` � ��tuÆJ�st&ms`+�d�qz�ms~ ß$å ß � ° ó ��æ �j��wst&��t��æ ~stumsb$v�tuc�z*~sl�c�c�b�`&l¿z�v�l�b$m¾tumst&���$�dg£��t©z���c�b*`&b$msc�ln~st&�v�ws��t&t©~�ln�Zt&��tumqv � bd��� c � bd�v�wst á £¹¶ g���t¾}�t&�$l�m�}q��~st+¡{msl�m�� á

f"«�ñ(³­« � k Û f Â!¶ ¢º@½ç�è ¦ çêé k f ©¶ ¢º@½ç¬ë ¦ çêé k g�¢£wstum¼1b$�s�s��lnms� ÿ `�wst&�*t ë l�c¹~stu¡smst&~�}q�¬c�t+v�v�l�ms� á £ì¶

f"« £ ³­« ¶ k Û áf¬« £ ³­« ¶ k l � z$ms~·b$ms�n�Ol �

� í ¶�î �JÛ Â go¼1bd�s�s�nl�ms� ÿ `�wstu� t ë�ë l�c~st+¡{mst&~U}q�¦c�t+v�v�lnms� á £¹¶f"« £ ³Þ« ¶ k Û á

f"« £ ³Þ« ¶ k l �z�ms~Rbdms�À�"l � í�� î z���t©b � ~sln�Zt&��t&mqv��sz$��lÀv��d�Ål gèt$gÀ�Zl � í Ý î l�cbh~�~�gyÃPl�m{z$�n�n�$�ż1bd�s�s�nl�ms�ÿ `�wst&�*t ë�ë�ë l�c£~st+¡{mstu~=}q�"c�t+v�v�lnms� á £¹¶f¬« £ ³­« ¶ k Û á

f¬« £ ³­« ¶ k � bd��z$���ïí�ðÛ î g¢£wst¤�*b$v�ln|�z�v�lnbdm � bd��v�wst�~�tu¡{mslÀv�lnbdm�b � v�wst á £¹¶ l�c©z$c � bd�n��b���c ½ ��t��1z$mqv#v�w�t��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut¹c�v����s`uv��s��t!b � v�w�t � ������¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$m v�b�}Zt¹t&c�c�tumJv�l¿z$�n�n� ~sl�`+v�z�v�t&~"}q��v�w�t

Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~�t&�«¯oz$� ln�nv�bdmsl¿z�m�g£¢£wJ�sc&�T��t#�1z$mqvòñÚ?ó�ôXõ x ² ����wsl�`�wU�*t]z$m�cyv�w{z�vy��tm�t&t&~ ôXõ Ý ó â�g¸¥avÄv�wstoc�z$�*tov�l��*t$�d��ty�az�mJv�v�wsto~���m{z$�*l�`ucÄv�b©}�tyc���`�w�v�w{z�vÄv�w�t« £÷ö âyz�vPz$�n�dv�l��*t&cugP¢£wJ�scu�$��t��1z$mqv ñ« £ ÛFâol � « £ Û�âhg­ªob�v�t°v�w{z�v á f¬«jñ(³­« � k c�z�v�lnc�¡{tucv�wst&c�t���t&ÆJ�sl���t&�*t&mqv�cug ë � «�ñ(³Þ« � CGC « ¼ �»v�wst&m á

f"«�ñ(³­« � k ó  �ºc�b ôXõ Ý ó â��P��wsln��tl � «�ñ bd� « � z$��t#tuÆJ�{z$�ºv�b"â��Tv�w�t&m á

f¬«�ñ+³Þ« � k Û7â���c�b � bd�yv�w�t�`&bd����t&c��Zb$ms~sl�m�� « £ ��t�$tuv ñ« £ ÛÇâhg ÷ �R`�wsb�bdc�l�ms� « ¼ c��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�Rc���z$�n�Ö`&bd�*�{z$��t&~Rv�b�v�wst#`�w{z���z$`+v�t&��l�c�v�l�`z�`uv�lnbdmsc b � bd�s� c�l��©�s�¿z�v�l�bdm�c&�1��tR`]z�mÒ��z$î�t=v�w�tR��tu�dl�bdm b � �sw{z�c�t Á c��{z�`&tU��wsbdc�t��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut�c�v����s`+v��s��t*lncy~sln`uv�z�v�tu~U}J�¦v�wst Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~�t&�«¯oz$� ln�nv�bdmsl¿z�m¦z�c«�¿z$���dt#z$cpdi

Page 114: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��bdc�c�l�}���t$g4Ë���Ë��� ø¡ù��ûúü��;���ý»þ"ÒÓÿ �����t���z]�©msb��L�sc�tv�wst Ä t&��b$v�w Á bd��~st&�įyz�� ln�nv�b$msl¿z$m¹v�b!`&b$msc�v����s`+vÄv�wst�¥y��msbd�  ~��·tu}� b$�!b$�s�¹c���c�v�t&�¾g��Gtuv�v�l�m������� ñ(³ ä&ä]ä ³ �� M ~st&m�b$v�t�v�wst*`]z�msbdmsln`]z$�­}sz$c�lnc�b �� M �Ö��tb$}�v�z$lnmUv�w{z�v « ² � Ý f Ç « ¶ « k �� ��� Ý « �� ��ä�� ñ lnc¹z f  ³ ¶CÂjk ��tuc�bdm{z�ms`&t ��l�m�t$g�¢Pb¦}Ztc��Ztu`&lÀ¡{`$� f¬« ² Ý Ç « ¶ «�³Þ« ² Ý «Å³­« ² ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« ² k l�c�z f  ³ ¶CÂjk ��t&c�bdm{z$m�`&t$g¸¢£wJ�scu�sc�v�z$��v�l�ms�z�v f"« ² Ý Ç «Å³­« ² ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« ² k �Öv�wst c���c�v�t&� `]z$m·tu|db$�n|dt �smqv�ln�­v�wst Ç « ��mslnv�c!b � z$`uv�l�bdmwsz�|$ty}�t&tum���tuc�bdmsz$mqv��n��v���z$m�c � t&����tu~�l�mqv�b��*bh~�tye�g­¥av°v�wslnc���bdl�mqv&�dv�wstc���c�v�t&� l�cÄl�mc�v�z�v�t f¬« ² ³­« ² Ý Ç «Å³­« ² ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« ² k �{z$ms~"msb��Fv�wst f"« ² ³­« ² Ý Ç « ¶ «Å³­« ² Ý «Å³­« ² ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« ² k��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut���l�m�t©w{z$c«}�t&`ubd�*t�z$`uv�ln|$t$g©¢£w�t�c���c�v�t&�H`]z�m¬m�bj�ý�s��bh`ut&t&~Uv�b�v���z�msc � tu�tumst&���$�!v�b��*bh~�t1ç���l�m#����l�m�`&l�����t°tu|$bd�n|�l�m��yv�bv�wstac�v�z�v�t f"« ² ³­« ² ³­« ² Ý Ç «Å³­« ² ³ ä]ä&ä ³­« ² k g¢£w�l�c¸t&m�t&������v���z�msc � tu� � ��bd�ý� b�~st  v�b¹�*bh~staç¹lnc°z$`&`ubd�*�s��lnc�wstu~�|�l�z�¥y��m�bd�  ~*ú�l � Á� ��c�l�b$m��{}Ztu`]z$��c�t¹v�wst¹t&m�t&�����¾v���z$m�c � t&��b�`&`u�s��c�¡{��c�voz$��bdm���v�wst¹��tuc�bdm{z�ms`&t�}Zt+v��1tut&m�*b�~st&c  z$ms~·ehg�ú�����l�m��"v�wsl�c«��t&c�bdm{z$mqv�t&mstu���$�Ov���z$msc � t&�&�Px ³Þ«�ñ Ý « � ³­« % ³ ä]ä&ä ³­« Mz���t�`ubdmsc�tu��|$t&~�g r ms`ut�Ç « �sm�lnv�c©b � z$`uv�l�bdm�wsz�|$t"}Ztut&m�v���z$msc � tu����t&~�v�bR�*b�~st"eh�v�wsty�*b�~st Â%Á �*bh~stye©z$m�~�v�wsty� b�~stye Á �*b�~st�ç!��t&c�bdm{z$m�`&t«��lnmst&cÄl�mqv�t&��c�t&`+v]�{z$m�~v�wst&m¦t&mstu���$�¤v���z$m�c � t&��`&z$m=b�`&`u�s� � ��bd���*b�~st!e�v�b �*b�~st¹ç�g�ú��s��lnms��v�wslnc��t&��l�b�~��

p$p

Page 115: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

x ³­«�ñ�³­« � Ý « % ³­« & ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« M z$��t¹`ubdmsc�tu��|$t&~�g ÷ �"~stu¡smslnv�l�bdm��hv�wslnc£�s��b�`&tuc�cl�c�msb$v�wsl�ms�b�v�wstu�Äv�w{z$m�¥o��msb$�  ~�ú�lÀ�T�sc�l�bdmT�qc�l�m�`&t�v�wstot&mstu���$��v���z$msc � t&� � ��bd�7�*b�~st  v�b!�*bh~stç�b�`&`u�s����t&~=}q�¤�*b�|�l�ms��z$�nbdms��v�w�t!��t&c�bdm{z$ms`ut!��t&}Tg

úln�d�s��toçhg  c�wsb���c1z�c�z�� �s�ntav���z=<�t&`+v�bd���*��lÀv�w � Ûãç�g¸ªb$v�t�v�w{z�v1z�v1z�mJ�*�dlÀ|dtumv�l��*t$��t&lÀv�wstu� «jñ Ý « � z$ms~ « % ��tu��z�l�m©tuc�c�t&mqv�l�z$���À�¹`&bdmsc�v�z$mqv&�dbd� «�ñ z$m�~ « � Ý « % ��t&� z$l�mtuc�c�t&mqv�l�z$���À�¦`ubdmsc�v�z$mqv]go¢£wJ�sc&�Tv�wst#c��hc�v�tu� �*bj|$t&c�lnmqv�b�~�ln�Zt&��tumqv���tuc�bdmsz$ms`&t Ä bdmstuc|�l�z�¥o��msb$�  ~¦ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m�g

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000

Act

ion

Time

Mode 1Mode 2Mode 3

úl��d����t¹ç�g Â2½ ÿ z$�*�s�ntyv���z=<�t&`+v�bd��� � bd� � Û�ç�c�wsb���l�m��*¥o��msb$�  ~¦ú�lÀ�T��c�l�b$m�g¼1bd���s��lnms� ÿ `�wstu� t ë b$ms�n��z$���nbj��c � bd�#c�tuÆJ�st&mqv�l�z$����tuc�bdm{z�mJv*tumst&���$��v���z$msc � t&�&g

¢£wsz�v�l�cu�Ätumst&���$��`&z$m b$ms�n��>{b�� � ��bd� �*bh~�t  v�bU�*bh~st¾e¦v�bO� b�~st¤ç��Äz$m�~ c�bp$á

Page 116: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

b$m�ga¼1b$�s�s��lnms� ÿ `�wstu� tuc ë�ë z$ms~ ë�ë�ë z$���nb�� � bd����t&c�b$m{z$mqvytumst&���$�¤v���z$msc � t&�}Zt+v��1tut&mz�mJ�Uv���b=�*b�~st&c¹b � bd�s��bdc�lÀv�t��{z$��lnv��$g ¢£wst*��tuc��s�Àv�lnms�"¥y��m�bd�  ~¬��t&}�c�ln������c�v���z�v�lnms�v�wst*mstuv���bd��îOb � ��tuc�bdm{z�mJv�t&m�t&�����?>{b�� �{z�v�wsc � b$�¹v�wst�|$z���l�b$�sc¹c�`�wstu� tuc©l�c¹�dlÀ|dtumlnm=ÃPl��d�s��t!ç�g e�g�ªob$v�t�v�wsz�vy¼1bd�s�s�nl�ms� ÿ `�wstu� t ë ��t&c��s�nv�colnmRz*c�l��*�s�nt«`�w{z$l�mT����wsln��t¼1b$�s�s��lnms� ÿ `�wstu� tuc ë�ë z�ms~ ë�ë�ë �s��bh~s��`&tz$m*z$`uv��{z$����t&}Tg¸¢£wsl�c­��t&} }Ztu`&bd�*t&c¸�*bd��t~�t&msc�t!��lÀv�w"l�ms`u��t&z$c�lnms� � g

1

2

3

4

5

D = 5, Coupling Scheme I1

D = 5, Coupling Schemes II,III

2

3D = 3, Coupling Schemes I-III

1 2

34

D = 4, Couplings Schemes II,III

1

2

34

5

ÃPl��d�s��t�ç�gþe ½ ë �n���sc�v���z�v�lnbdm·b � ¥o��msbd�  ~���t&}�c � bd�©|�z$��lnbd�sc#`ubd�s�s�nl�ms�=c�`�wstu� tuc�z$m�~~�t&�d��t&t&cb �»� ��tut&~sbd�¾g

¼az$��tU�#�sc�v"}Zt=v�z$î$tumFv�b�`�wsb�bdc�t Û c��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�Lc�� z$�n�oc�böv�w{z�v�v�wstUc���c�v�t&�lnc�l�m�~st&tu~FÆJ�{z�c�l Á l�mqv�tu�d��z�}s��t=z�v�v�w�tUt&mstu���$�Ò}�t&lnms��c�v��s~slnt&~�g ë � Û l�c�v�bhb���z$���$t$�

á â

Page 117: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

v�wst&mU��z$�sln~=t&m�t&������>{b�� }�t&`ubd� tuc���bdc�c�l�}s�nt!|�l¿z*msbdms��t&c�bdm{z$mqv«`�w{z�b$v�ln`©~���m{z$�*l�`uc&���w�l�`�w¤`]z�m�v�wstum"z$`&`ubd�smqv � bd��}Zb�v�w�`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$��z$ms~�ÆJ�{z�mJv��s�ïtumst&���$�X>{b��¹g�Ã{bd�Äbd�s�c�l��#���¿z�v�l�bdmscu�»��t¤c�t+v Û Ûøâ�äåâ  gR¥oc�úl��$�s��t�ç�g  c�wsb���c&�¸v�wst&��t�l�c#tuc�c�t&mqv�l�z$���À��m�bm�bdm Á ��t&c�bdm{z$mqvatumst&���$�*v���z�msc � tu� � bd�Äv�wslncÄ|�z$�n�styb � v�wsto�Ztu��v�����}{z�v�l�bdm c�v���t&m��$v�w�gÄÃ{bd�Û Ûïâ�ä  �»z¾c�l��*l��¿z��yl�m�c���t&`uv�l�bdm¬b � v�wst*`&��z$c�c�l�`]z��ºv���z=<�t&`+v�bd��l�t&c!��t+|dt&z$��c!c�bd�*t�msbdm Á��t&c�bdm{z$mqvatumst&���$�*v���z�msc � tu�&��}s��vab�|$t&��z����Åv�wslnc�lnc�c�v�l��n�{c�� z$�����Jz$ms~�¥o��msb$�  ~�ú�ln�Z�sc�l�bdm��t&� z$l�m�c�tuc�c�tumqv�l¿z����n�Ov�wst�bdms�À�¬� tu`�w{z$mslnc�� � bd��tumst&���$��>sbj�3}�tuv���t&tum5��t&c�bdm{z$ms`utÄ bdmstuc&g�¢£wst�� z$l�mR~�ln�Zt&��tums`&t�}�tuv���t&tum Û Û âhäþâ  v�b Û Û â�ä  l�c¹z�c�w�bd��v�t&mslnms�"b �v�wst�v�l��*t�c�`&z$��tuc©b�|dtu����wsln`�w·v�wst*¥y��msbd�  ~·ú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdmObh`u`&�s��c&g¾¯ob���tu|dtu�&�°z$�n��t&z$~��� b$� Û Û Â äåâ©v�w�t«~���m{z$�*l�`&c£}�t&`ubd�*t&c£`�w{z$b�v�l�`�g­��wsl��ntov�wst«��tuc�bdm{z�ms`&t¹c�v����s`+v��s��t¹b �v�wst�¯oz$�*l��nv�bdmsl�z$mUc�v�l����°~sln`uv�z�v�tuc�v�w�t�~���m{z$�*l�`uc©c�bd� t+��w{z�v&�ºv�wst �Ztu��v��s��}{z�v�l�b$m·l�cc��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À�¤c�v���bdms��v�wsz�v�msbdm Á ��tuc�bdm{z�mJvtumst&���$�Q>{b���}�t&`ubd� tuc�c�l��$msln¡{`&z$mqv]g÷ t � bd��t*`&b$ms`&�n�s~sl�m��¾v�wsl�c¹c�tu`uv�l�bdm��»lnv!c�wsbd�s�n~�}�t�z���c�b"��bdl�mqv�t&~¬bd��v!v�w{z�v¹v�wst&��tlnc!z¾��bdc�c�l�}sln��lÀv��=lnm�bd���!�*b�~st&� � bd�¹c�bd� t�b � v�wst � ��tuÆJ�st&ms`ul�tuc ß £ f.± k Û ® £ ¶ e ß £ « £v�b¤}Ztu`&bd�*t#mstu�qz�v�ln|dt�g©Ã{bd�yz��dln|$t&mR|�z$�n�st#b � � ��lÀv�lnc��Zb$c�c�ln}s��t!v�b¤`�wsb�bdc�t « ² ��Ç «c��s`�w�v�w{z�v�z$��� � ��t&ÆJ�stums`&lnt&c1��t&� z$l�m���bdc�lÀv�lÀ|dt�~s�s��l�ms�¹v�wsttu|$bd���hv�l�b$m��J`&bd����t&c��Zb$ms~sl�m��v�b�}Zb$�sms~Ò�*b$v�lnbdmÒz�v"z�����v�l��*t&cug9�·tU}�t&�dlnmL}q�L��bdl�mqv�l�ms��b$��v�v�wsz�v�� M£ � ñ « £ l�c`ubdmsc�t&��|$t&~R}q��v�wst!¯yz$�*l��Àv�bdm�l¿z$m��Jc�b c�l�ms`ut!b$�s�£�Ztu��v��s��}{z�v�l�b$m"�1z$c�`�wsbdc�t&m¦c�b�v�w{z�v« £÷ö â©z�v�z$�n�sv�l��*t&cu�Jlnv � bd���nb���c­v�w{z�v1â�� « £ �üÇ « Ý �¯« ² g¸Ã{bd�¸v�wstob�~s~ Á mJ�s�#}�t&��tu~ábÂ

Page 118: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�*b�~st&cu� ß £ f.± k `]z$m"}�t&`&b$� t�m�t&�qz�v�ln|$t�l � ® ¶ e ß f Ç « Ý f²� ¶�Âjk « ² k ��â�� ® ° e ß �Ç « Ý f²� ¶÷Âjk « ² g«Ã{bd��v�wst#t+|dtum Á mJ�s�#}�t&��t&~¬� b�~stuc&� ß £ f²± k `&z$mU}Ztu`&bd�*t#mstu�qz�v�ln|dtl � ® ¶ e ß f"« ² Ý Ç « k �Fâ�� ® ° e ß �uÇ « Ý « ² g�¢£wst&��t � bd��t$��z$c�c��s�*l�ms� � ö eh�{��t�©�sc�vow{z]|dt ® ° e ß ö Ç « Ý f�� ¶ÛÂjk « ² l�m¾bd��~st&�£v�b t&msc��s��t�}Zb$�sms~=�*b$v�l�bdm�g ô c�l�m��v�wst«|�z$���stuc£b � ® � ß lnm¤v�t&��� c£b � ß � ��æ �s�1t¹�dt+v]�

e ��æ ö ßyf Ç « Ý f²� ¶ÛÂjk « ² k f çhg áqk��P � � Ë�[K^ U�Y U��lT Ï©Ð]ÎoÈUÐuÏ [¸Í U¯Wë mOv�w�l�c¹c�tu`uv�lnbdm��G��t ~stuc�`u��l�}�t�wsb��7��t `ubd� �sz$��t�ÆJ�{z$mqv��s� z$ms~¬`&��z$c�c�l�`]z��¸t&mstu���$�>sbj�ï��z�v�t&cu�az$ms~�v�wst¤�az]��v�w�l�c�l�c#v���z$m�c��¿z�v�t&~ölnmJv�b¬zO`ubd�*�{z$��lnc�bdm�b � ~���m{z$�*l�`&z$�v��smsmstu��lnms�#|�c&gÄ¥y��m�bd�  ~¾ú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdm�g4Ë�54��NÌ �����÷�����:�! ��tö���sm bd���Uc�l��©�s�¿z�v�l�bdm�c=c�v�z$��v�l�ms� � ��bd� v�wst�v�bd���scR��lnv�wAÆJ�{z�mJv��s� mJ�s�#}�t&��cf æ ³ â ³ ä]ä]ä ³ â k g �·t¦��tuv�v�wstRz$m��d��tuc*���sm � ��bd� âOv�b�eIH­�ac�b¬v�wst¦`&bdmq|dtu��c�l�bdm � ��bd�ÆJ�{z�mJv��s� m����#}Ztu��c f²ð»ñ+³ ä]ä]ä ³�ð M k v�b�z�`uv�lnbdmsc f¬«jñ(³ ä]ä]ä ³­« M k lnc�z$`u`&bd�*�s��lnc�wstu~5|�l�z« £ Û×JL f.ð £ Ý ñ� k gy¢£wJ�scu�T��t#w{z]|dt « ² Û�JL ° eh�ÁÇ « ÛÇæ3JL gyÃ{bd��¼1bd�s�s�nl�ms� ÿ `�wstu� t ë �z�`uv�lnbdm"`]z$m¦bdms�À���dt+volnmqv�b*� b�~st&cç�z$ms~¦wsl��$wst&�a|�l¿z�¥y��msbd�  ~¾ú�ln�Z�sc�l�bdm�g­��t!��z]�á e

Page 119: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

v�wJ�sc#�s�nb$v#" « % f%$ k   ³ ä&ä]ä ³ " « M f%$ k  !}�b$v�w�`&��z$c�c�l�`]z����n�¬z�ms~�ÆJ�{z$mqv���� Á � tu`�w{z$msln`]z$�n�n�Rv�b~�tuv�tu���*l�mst�v�wst"��tu�¿z�v�ln|dt¤��z�v�tuc�b � ~h�hmsz$� ln`]z$��v��smsm�t&��lnms�Oz$ms~5¥y��msbd�  ~5ú�ln�Z�sc�l�bdm� b$��¼1b$�s�s��lnms� ÿ `�wstu� t ë g°Ã{bd� ¼1bd�s�s�nl�ms� ÿ `�wstu� tuc ë�ë z$ms~ ë�ë�ë �°z$`uv�l�bdm5`]z�m bdm��n��$tuv�l�mqv�b¾v�wst*bh~�~·mJ�s�#}�t&��t&~��*bh~�t&c�ç=z$ms~�wsl��$wst&�¹|�l¿z"¥y��m�bd�  ~�ú�lÀ�T�sc�l�bdmTg ��t� z]��v�wJ�sc��s�nb$v&" « % f'$ k   ³ " « ' f'$ k   ³ ä]ä]ä�}Zb$v�w¦`u�¿z$c�c�ln`]z$�n�n��z$ms~¾Æ��sz$mqv��s� Á �*t&`�w{z�msl�`&z$���À�v�b«~stuv�t&��� lnmstav�wst£��t&��z�v�lÀ|dt£��z�v�t&c¸b � ~h�hmsz$� ln`]z$��v��sm�mst&�nl�ms�¹z$m�~*¥o��msb$�  ~�ú�ln�Z�sc�lnbdm�g

Ã{bd�«z����»b � bd�s��c�l��#�s��z�v�lnbdmscu����t�v�b�bdî�JL Û Â � Û Û â�äþâ  � ß Û Â äþâ�� �`æ Û æhäåâ��z�ms~ « ¼ Û�âhä  gº¢£wsty`ubdms~slÀv�l�b$m*v�w{z�vÄ�1tow{z]|dt�bdm��n��}�bd�sms~ Á c�v�z�v�t� b�v�l�b$m*}�t&`ubd�*t&c&� â ö æ Ý f²� ¶�Âjk ° eh�d��wsln`�w��dln|$t&c&� � � Â2 gº¢£wJ�sc&�q��t£`]z$m����sm�`]z���`&���¿z�v�l�bdmsc»�s�#v�bÂ� ~st&�d��t&tuc£b �Ö� ��t&tu~sbd�3��lnv�w�bd��v � t&z$�ab � ~slnc�c�b�`&l�z�v�lnbdm�g»¢£wst¹`�wsbdln`&t�b � Û �az$c£c��s`�wv�w{z�v�v�wst�c���c�v�tu�ò�1z$cac��/.*`&l�tumqv��n� ÆJ�{z$c�l Á lnmqv�t&�$��z$}s�ntyz�v1v�w�t�t&mstu���dlnt&c�c�v���~sl�tu~�v�w{z�vm�bdms��tuc�bdmsz$mqv£`�w{z$b$v�l�`�~h�hmsz$� ln`&cÄ�az$c1msb$v£z�m¤l�c�c��st$g¸¢£w�l�calnc1l��n���sc�v���z�v�tu~ lnm¤Ãºl��$�s��tçhg  �Å��wstu��t�lnvo`&�nt]z$�v�w{z�v � bd��v�wslncy`�wsb$l�`&t©b � Û �Tbdms�À�¾¥y��m�bd�  ~Uú�ln�Z�sc�l�bdm¾`]z$m=��t]z�~v�bUc�ln�dmsln¡s`]z$mqv#tumst&���$����t&~slnc�v���l�}���v�lnbdm�}�tuv���t&t&m z$�n�Äv�ws��tut¤� b�~st&cugU¥yc�~slnc�`u�sc�c�t&~����tu|�lnbd�sc��À�d�d� z$îJl�m�� Û z$m�bd��~�t&�­b � � z$�dm�lnv���~st���z$���$t&�º�nt]z$~�cPv�by~���m{z$�*l�`&cºc�wsb���l�m��v�wst°¡{��c�vºc�l��dmscÖb � c�ln�dmsln¡s`]z$mqv»msbdm Á ��tuc�bdm{z�mJvPt&m�t&�����«v���z�msc � tu�&g ÷ �¹��z$îJlnms�£v�wst°v�ln� tc�v�tu�sc�c��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À��c�� z$�����$�1t���t&��tyz$}s�ntav�b�z$`&`u�s��z�v�t&�À���s��b$�{z$�qz�v�t£v�wst�v���z=<�t&`+v�bd��l�t&cb$��v¤v�böz�v�ln� t¦b � e$âdâdâ��£��wsln`�wF�1z$c"c��7. `ul�tumJv"v�b�`&bd�*�{z$��tRv�wstU`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$�«z$m�~ÆJ�{z�mJv��s� t&m�t&�����A>{b��9��z�v�t&cug á ç

Page 120: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

4Ë�54���� (¡ýNÏzÙ7Ù9�:6 Ï-ý�(�Ï-ýN6�8�ý:Ï�Ð��:��;�Ù¢»b�~st+v�t&��� lnmst�" « £ f%$ k  1`u�¿z$c�c�l�`&z$���À�d�q��t¹z�|$t&��z$�dt�bd�hv « £ f'$ k � bd�1z#c��1z$���òb � v���z=<�t&`+v�b Á��l�tuc��lÀv�wRz�`uv�lnbdmscb � v�wst©lnmslnv�l¿z$�Tv�bd����c&��}s��v�~�ln�Zt&��lnms�*l�mslÀv�l¿z��Gz$ms�d�nt&cuga�·t�`&bdmsc�l�~ Átu��tu~�lnmslnv�l¿z$�Pz$ms�d�nt#|dtu`uv�b$��c f5ÚGñ�³ ä]ä]ä ³¸Ú M k Û f eIH í ñ±°*)¦³ ä]ä]ä ³ eIH í M °*) k �G��wst&��t t&z$`�wí � Ûýâ ³ ä&ä]ä ³+) ¶ï �T�dlÀ|�l�ms� )\M l�m�lnv�l�z$��v���z=<�t&`+v�bd��l�tuc&g«¢»b�~stuv�t&��� lnmst©v�w�t#bd��v�l�� z$�) v�b¤�sc�t$����t���z$mOz � Û7ç�`]z���`&���¿z�v�l�bdm=z$ms~U�s�nb$v�v�t&~�" « % f'$ k   � bd� ) ÛÇós� p �  ® �z�ms~Oçqehg«¢£wst���t&c��s�nv�c¹z$��t#����b$v�v�t&~=l�mOúln�d�s��t�ç�gåç�g«�·t©~st&tu� tu~Ov�wst ) Û Â ® ���smc��/.*`&lnt&mqv��À��`&bdmq|dtu���dtu~¤c�b!v�w{z�vÄ��ty�sc�t&~�lÀv � bd�1z����sb � bd�s�°`]z$�n`&�s��z�v�lnbdmscu�qt+§h`&tu��v � bd�v�wst � Ûøæ¦c�l��#���¿z�v�l�bdmscug ë m�v�wslnc�`&z$c�t�� ) Û Â ® ��t&ÆJ�sl���t&~�v�bhb¦��z$mq�Ov���z=<�t&`+v�b Á��l�tuc&�T� z$îJl�m���v�wst©���smRv�l��*t��s��bdwsln}slnv�ln|dtu�n�"c���b��¹g¹Ã{bd� � Û7æh���1t#v�wst&��t � bd��t©v�b�bdî) Û p g�¥oc�úln�d�s��t!ç�gåç c�wsb���c&� � b$� ) Û p v�wst©���smRlncomsb�vyÆJ�slÀv�t©`ubdmq|dtu���dtu~��T}s�hvv�wst«`&����|dt¹lncamstu|$t&��v�wstu��t&c�co��z�v�w�t&�£c��*b�b$v�w���z$ms~¤~sb�t&c£m�b$vË>{�s`+v��{z�v�t«�d��t&z�v��À� � ��bd�v�wst ) Û Â ® bd� ) Ûãçqe#��tuc��s�Àv�cug4Ë�54��54 , 8�Ï-;)Ð�8�� (�Ï-ýN6�8�ý:Ï�Ð��:��;�Ù¢.-0/1ÆJ�{z2143����A�5/*6��s�7386ºz$�5/�b$}03�z2971�/&~�}q�&6�bd�n|:971s�.3;-�/<3;9��=/ Á ~�/&�>/*1�~�/*143 ÿ@? -s��b�~�971s�A/&�/uÆJ�{zB3;9nbA1��Ä¡{�86C3�}q��68/u�D9 ? �¿zB68689 ? z$�n�n��ÆJ�{z2143;9 Ä 9E1���38-�/=¯oz$�=9��73�bA1�9�z21GF�¢»b�~sb�3;-�976&��/ ? bA10689�~0/&�*zU}{z268976�68/H3 b � Ø ÷ ªI6C3�zB38/*6��A9À|A/*1ö}q�J3;-0/ ? bd�n�E/ ? 3;9nbA1�b � ÆJ�{z2143��s�

á ó

Page 121: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

4 Angles8 Angles

16 Angles32 Angles

ÃK9��$�s�8/¹ç0Fåç ½ ¼1bA1q|2/&���2/*1 ? /©b �L? z$� ? �s��zB3;9nbA1�6 � b$� � Û�ç0F1J�s�©}M/u�!|2/ ? 3�bd�86D�@N ð»ñ�³ ä]ä]ä ³�ð MPO+ ? bd���5/*6���bA1s~09E1s��3�bQ38-�/ z ? 389�bA1�6��@N «jñ Û�JL N ð»ñ Ýñ� O ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« M ÛVJL N ð M Ý ñ� OR F!¢.-�/ Ä /u��b238- Á b$��~�/u�S/*1�/u���$�Rb � 3;-�/�6C3�zB38/ � ðÖñ(³ ä]ä]ä ³�ð M  976«�A9n|2/*1O}q� (�² N ðÖñ+³ ä]ä]ä ³�ð MPO Û x ² N «�ñ+³ ä]ä]ä ³Þ« MTO �»z21s~U3;-�/ ? bd�s�s�79E1s�¤}>/V3��/*/V1W3���b6C3�zB38/*6��YX¡ ÄÛ�� Z ñ+³ ä&ä]ä ³ Z M  u���Y[  °Û � ðÖñ(³ ä]ä&ä ³�ð M  \9E6£�A9À|A/*1¾}q��Ù ájÚ �

"][Ë� �x�� X� °Û�x aº@ _&N ± _ Ý ± a^ O N�ç0F  â O�_-0/&�8/ ± _ÒÛ`N « � è ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« �KabO å N:JL N'Z ñ Ý ñ� O ³ ä]ä&ä ³ JL N'Z M Ý ñ� O8O ��z21�~ ± a Û`N « ä è ³ ä]ä]ä ³­« äcabO åNÄJL N ðÖñ Ý ñ� O ³ ä&ä]ä ³ JL N ð M Ý ñ� O8O Fº¥y�E6�bs��dx�e¹~�/*1sbB3;/*6<3;-�/gf ? bd�*�Zb21�/*1439E1�3;-�/oÃ{bd�s�897/&�/(§h�{z21�659�bA1¾b � x·�s�A9À|A/*1¾}q�"xJN Ú»³�± O Û � e dx�e0N ± O ¢ £ eih j F

á æ

Page 122: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��PCk ] Ë«Ô­ÈUл[­Ô�Ï W?Y l Í]ÔºÎoÈUÔ­ÔºÍ UXW

�W/£��zB1�1����D/u�89 ? z$� ? z$� ? �s�¿zi3;9�b21�6Pb21�ç��qós�qz21�~�æy~0/&�d�5/*/£b �Å� �8/V/&~sb$�m6��:6C3;/&�=6*F°ÃL9n|A/~0/&�d�5/*/*6°b �Å� �5/*/&~�bd�Ç�1z26T3;-�/£� z�§@9��©�s�n38-{zB3¸�=/&�*bd���#z21�~�389��=/ ? bA1�653���z297143;6¸�>/&� Á�=97353;/u~GF ÿ 9¨§¾~�/&�d�5/*/V6yb �­� �5/*/u~sbd����bd�s��~Q-{z]|A/#�5/&ÆJ��9n�8/&~o6�b�� z21q�#3���z=<5/ ? 3�bd�59E/V6g3�b�2/V3°�8/&z26�b21{z$}s�À� ? bA1q|2/&���2/&~ ? z$� ? �s�¿zi3;9�b21�6_N²�0689E1��&p¹z21��d�E/V6¸�M/u�Ä~0/&�d�5/*/�b ��� �8/*/u~sbd� O �38-{zB3.38-�/¹����1q3;9n�D/y��bd�s�n~Q-sz�|2/r3�z$î2/V1Q65/u|2/&��z��P�*bA143;-�6VF4Ë�'s��NÌ ø¡ù������û ���������÷Ù ������������Ò��)�ÃL9��d�s�5/"ç0Fèó�65-sb��_6�zO�s��bB3�b � " « % N $ O   ¼'tvu8wxw¬£¥¼'uCt |A/u�86���6y" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd�*¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë FZ¼1�¿zB68689 ? z$�Öz ? 3;9nbA1�>{b�� � ��bd�|3;-�/¹¡{�86C3��*bh~0/r97143�b�3;-�/r3;-�9n��~¾� b�~�/ ? z21b21s�n�¦b ?V? �s��|:9�z�¥y�81�bd�  ~OúS9n�Z��689nbA1GF©¼1�E/&z$���À�d�}38-�/�ÆJ�{z2143��s��>{b��Ç~sb$�D971{zB3;/V6~3;-0/? �¿z265689 ? z$�A/V1�/&���$��>{b��¹�26�bg38-{zB3Ö}q�¹~�/+¡�1�97389�bA1T��~h�@1sz$�D9 ? z$�B3���1�10/&�E971s�_9E6G�#� ? - � z26C3;/&�38-{z21¾¥y�51sbd�  ~"úS9n�Z��659�bA1#971q38-�9E6./(§�z$� ���E/2F

ÃK9n�d�s�5/oç@F æ�68-sb��_61z!�s�nb23°b � " « % N $ O   ¼'tvu8wxw¬£¥¼'uCt |2/&�86���6�" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd��¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë�ë�ë Fh¼1bd�s�s�79E1s� ÿ@? -�/u�D/V6 ë z21�~ ë�ë z$�8/�9�~�/V1�389 ? z$� � bd��3;-s�5/*/y~0/&�d�5/*/*6�b ��� �5/*/ Á~�bd�QF ë 1�3;-09E6 ? z265/$�\3;-0/¦ÆJ�{z2143��s� >sbj��9E6=653;9n��� � z26C3;/u�&�a}s�@3D38-�/ ? �¿z265689 ? z$��>{b��976 ? bd�*�{z$��z$}s�7/2F·¢.-09E6��8/V6��s��3*z$�s�>/]z$�56�3�bO}M/"zB3�����9 ? z$����689E1 ? /¾z26�-�9n�A-�/&��~09��=/*1 Á659�bA1sz$�P�5/*6��s�7386��_9����b65-sb��¹��971 ? �5/]z2659E1s�D3;-�/�1J�s�©}M/u�«b � ~�/&�$�8/*/V6¹b �¸� �8/V/&~sbd��68/V/&�=6

á ®

Page 123: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9��d�s�5/ç0Fåó ½ ×¸��b23Äb � " « % N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t |A/&�56���6r" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd� � Û�ç � bd�1¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë F

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

2.2

2.4

2.6

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9��d�s�5/ç0F æ ½ ׸��b23Äb � " « % N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t |A/&�56���6r" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd� � Û�ç � bd�1¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë�ë�ë FáA�

Page 124: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

3�bW/V1�-{z21 ? /q3;-�/"~��:1{z$�=9 ? z$��3���1�1�/u�E9E1��¬��zB3;/"�5/&�¿zi3;9n|2/�3�by3;-�/"¥o�81sbd�  ~ úS9n�Z��659�bA1��zB3;/BF4Ë�'s���� ����8���u�÷��������Ù�������������Ò����ÃL9��d�s�5/"ç0F ® 65-sb��_6�zO�s��bB3�b � " « % N $ O   ¼'tvu8wxw¬£¥¼'uCt |A/u�86���6y" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd�*¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë FK��1 ? /¤z$�dz29E1��P~��:1{z$�=9 ? z$�P3���1�10/&�E971s��976�~sb$�D971{z2143cF¾¢.-�/�~�976 ? �8/&�sz21 ? �}>/V3��/*/V1 ~h�@1sz$�D9 ? z$��3��01�1�/&�79E1s��z21s~�¥y�51sbd�  ~�úS9À�T�0689�b21©��zi3;/*6¸}>/ ? bd�=/*6T/+|A/*1��*bd�8/z��s�{z$�5/*143b9E1¹ÃK9n�d�s�5/¸ç0F � ���_-�9 ? -�68-�bj�_6»z£�s�nb23�b � " « & N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t |A/u�86���6\" « & N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { �� b$�g38-�/#¼1b$�s�s�E971s� ÿ@? -�/&�=/ ë F ë 1Q38-�9E6 ? zB68/$�>3;-�/u�8/&9E6_-{z$��~s�n�¾z21q� ? ��z268659 ? z$�b/*1�/u���$�>sbj��zB3z$�n�]F

ÃK9n�d�s�5/*6�ç0F�p��{ç0F á 68-�bj���s��b2386ab � " « % N $ O   ¼�tvu5w]w¬£ ¼�uCt |A/&�56���6�" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd�¼1bd� Á���E9E1�� ÿ@? -0/&�=/*6 ë�ë z21s~ ë�ë�ë ���8/V6��>/ ? 389n|2/&�n�2F ÷ / ? z$��65/�� b�~�/ó ? z21�}>/�z ?V? /*6568/u~ � ��bd��*b�~�/  |:9¿z¤bd��~09E1{z$���=�5/*6�bA1{z2143r/*1�/u���$�o3���zB1�6 � /u�¹�_9�3;-U3;-0/*68/ ? bd�s�s�79E1s�#6 ? -�/&�=/*6u��/�~�bo1sb23©��b�bdîUzB3�" « & N $ O  u�L659E1 ? /D38-�/�ÆJ�{z2143��s� z21s~ ? �¿z265689 ? z$�¸�8/V6��s��3;6©z$�8/=689n� Á9n�¿z$�u�»z21s~·~�bo1sb23!�A9À|A/ z21q��9E1 � bd����zi3;9�b21Oz26r3�bQ38-�/ �5/&��zB3;9À|A/*��zB38/*6!b � ~��:1{z$�=9 ? z$�3���1�1�/u�E971s�!|2/&�56���6a¥o�81sb$�  ~�úS9À�T��659�bA1}Fºªb23;/_3;-{zi3�971 ? bd� �sz$�8976�bA1�3�br3;-�/�¡{�5653 ? bd� Á���E9E1��Q6 ? -�/&�=/$�K38-�/�¥o�81sb$�  ~�úS9n�Z��659�bA1O��zi3;/�-sz26�}>/*/V1J689n�A1�9n¡ ? z2143��À�U�8/u~s� ? /&~��P6�b38-{zB3�~��:1{z$�=9 ? z$��3���1�10/&�E971s��976/+|A/V1¤� bd�5/�9n� ��bd�C3�z2143 � bd��3;-�/V68/ ? bd�s�s�79E1s�r6 ? -�/u�D/V6

á p

Page 125: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9��d�s�5/ç0F ® ½ ׸��b23Äb � " « % N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t |A/&�56���6r" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd� � ÛFó � bd�1¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë F

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9��d�s�5/ç0F �m½ ׸��b23Äb � " « & N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t |A/&�56���6r" « & N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd� � ÛFó � bd�1¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë Fá$á

Page 126: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9��d�s�5/ç0F�p ½ ׸��b23Äb � " « % N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t |A/&�56���6r" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd� � ÛFó � bd�1¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë�ë F

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

2.2

2.4

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9��d�s�5/ç0F áb½ ׸��b23Äb � " « % N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t |A/&�56���6r" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � � bd� � ÛFó � bd�1¼1bd�s�s�79E1s�ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë�ë�ë F â$â

Page 127: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

38-{z21 � bd�¼1bd�s���E9E1�� ÿ@? -�/&�=/ ë Fs¢.-�9E6_976.9E1 ? bA143���z26C3g3�b=38-s�8/V/¹~�/&�d�5/*/V6ob �»� �8/V/&~sb$�¦�� b$�©�_-�9 ? -J38-�/¾¼1bd�s�s�79E1s� ÿ:? -�/&�=/ ë�ë�ë �qz]|2/¾¥o�81sb$�  ~öúS9n�Z��689nbA1���zi3;/*6�38-{zB3#�/&�5/? bd�*�{z$��z�}s�E/~3�b�3;-�/¹~��:1{z$�=9 ? z$�}3���1�1�/u�E9E1��*��zB3;/V6*F4Ë�'s��54 �����)�ûu�÷��������Ù����B��������Ò��)�ÃL9��d�s�5/*6Pç0F  â ÁªÂ ^ 65-sb��ö�s��b2386Pb � " « % ´ & ´ ' N $ O   ¼�tvu5w]w¬£ ¼�uCt |A/u�86���6g" « % ´ & ´ ' N $ O  Cz]{ u ä ½ { � � bd�º¼1bd� Á���E9E1�� ÿ@? -�/u�D/ ë �T�8/V6��>/ ? 3;9n|2/&�À�AF«¥y�dz29E1�� � bd�g3;-�976 ? b$�s�s�E971s��6 ? -�/&�=/$�G38-�/#bA1��n�"�az]�z ? 3;9nbA1 ? z21Q>{b���971�3�b#�*bh~�/V6£ç��hós�{z21s~¾æ � ��bd�3� b�~�/  976�|:9¿z#¥o�81sbd�  ~�úS9n�Z��689nbA1GFúy�:1{z��D9 ? z$�T3���1�1�/u�E9E1��Q976�~sb$�D971{z2143!bA1 ? /�z$�qz2971��!3;-sb$�s�A-�6�bd�D/+�_-{zB3��E/V686�6�b � bd��*b�~�/Äç0FP�S1 ? /az$�qzB9E1���z26L9E6�/u|:9�~�/V1 ? /u~�9E1©ÃK9��$�s�8/V6ºç0F  ç��  ós�i9E1 ? �8/&z268971s�_3;-�/�~�/*1�65973��b � 38-�/y�/&}¤�_9738-¾¼1bd�s�s�79E1s� ÿ@? -�/&�=/*6 ë�ë zB1s~ ë�ë�ë �$�8/]zi3��n�D6����s�s�8/V6865/*6_3;-�/ ? �¿z265689 ? z$�z ? 3;9nbA1Q>{b����5/&�¿zi3;9n|2/S3�b�3;-0/!ÆJ�{zB1�3��s�øz ? 3;9�b21A>{b���F��PR� � Ë«Î�^RÏ W Í]ÔºÊ U��m� ÈRÏ W [­ÈUÊ Ñ W Ë«ÌP��� Z Ð U��ÃL9E�A���5/�ç@F  æ�68-sb��_6��o���nb23�b � 3;-�/ Æ����2143;��� � ? 389�bA1�>{b�� � bA��¼1bA�0���E971�� ÿ@? -0/*�=/ë F°¢.-�/Q�8/V68����3;6��B�8/ � bA���y3;-��5/*/Q¡�/*�A�5/*/¦b �y� �5/*/*¡�bA� 6��:6538/*��F�ªb23;/�3;-��i3D�_-�97�E/9�3S976S¡��:1��2�=9 ? �2��38��1�1�/V�E971���3;-��i3��E/*�2¡�6~3�b�/*1�/V�8�$�\>{b�� � ��bA���*b:¡�/  971�3�b��*b@¡�/ç@¢T1�/V£2/*�C3;-�/V�E/*656�973 ? �21J65/*/*1�38-��B3�38-�/�Æ����B1�38���¤� ? 3;9nbA1j>sb �¦¥.bA�7��b��_6&�o���B353;/*�51

 â Â

Page 128: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9E�A���5/Äç0F  ⠽ ×��nb23»b2¥�" « % N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t £2/*�568��6_" « % N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � ¥.bA��§ïÛ�æ_¥.bA�º¼1bA�����79E1��ÿ:? -�/*�=/ ë F

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9E�A���5/Äç0F Â�Â2½ ×��nb23»b2¥�" « & N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t £2/*�568��6_" « & N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � ¥.bA��§ïÛ�æ_¥.bA�º¼1bA�����79E1��ÿ:? -�/*�=/ ë F

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

2.2

2.4

2.6

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9E�A���5/Äç0F  ^ ½ ×��nb23»b2¥�" « ' N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t £2/*�568��6_" « ' N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � ¥.bA��§ïÛ�æ_¥.bA�º¼1bA�����79E1��ÿ:? -�/*�=/ ë F â ^

Page 129: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9E�A���5/�ç0F Â ç ½ ×P�nb23£b2¥�" « % ´ ' N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t £A/V�865��6�" « % ´ ' N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � ¥.bA�\§òÛãæ&¥.bA��¼1bA� Á�0�E9E10� ÿ@? -�/*�=/ ë�ë F

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

1.3

1.4

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

QuantumClassical

ÃL9E�A���5/�ç0F Â ó ½ ×P�nb23£b2¥�" « % ´ ' N $ O   ¼'t�u5w]w"£¥¼'u5t £A/V�865��6�" « % ´ ' N $ O  5z]{ u ä ½ { � ¥.bA�\§òÛãæ&¥.bA��¼1bA� Á�0�E9E10� ÿ@? -�/*�=/ ë�ë�ë F

 â$ç

Page 130: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

38-��B3#976�¥.bA�5���2�7�7¨J38-�/U6;�2�=/U�26�38-�/ ? �E�268659 ? �2�S� ? 3;9nbA1�>{b���Fm©.-���6V¢�� ? 389�bA1�ª��86C3>sb �_6=¥'��bA�«�*b:¡�/  9E143�bW�*b@¡0/ ^ ¢.�21�¡�3;-�/V1¬¥'��bA� � b:¡�/ ^ 3�b­�*b@¡�/¾ç0F®©.-0/�5/c�26�bA1¯¥.bA��3;-09E6#9E6�38-��B3q�*b�£@971��°�2�nbA1��J� ? �E�268659 ? �2�S�8/V6�bA1��21 ? / ? b2�8�8/V68��bA1�¡�6#3�b�*b�£:9E1��Q�2��b21����Q¡�/V�A/*1�/V�;�B38/��D�21�9�¥.bA�E¡Ub2¥�653;�B3;/V6©Æ����2143;�0� Á �D/ ? -��21�9 ? �2�7�7¨AFD©.-�9E665���A�A/V65386�3;-��B3�38-�/ ? �±�B68689 ? �2�b�5/*6�b21��21 ? /�6538�8� ? 3;���5/©b2¥K3;-�/&²~�2�=9E��3�bA109±�21#�A9�£A/V6��59E68/3�by�Òì�Æ����21438��� ³��81sbA�x´�¡�úS97µM��689nbA1sí��B��bA1��Q3;-�/�¡0/*�A/V1�/*�8�B3;/#�D�21�9�¥.bA�E¡¬b2¥g653;�B3;/V6¡0/Vª�1�/V¡�¶�¨&3;-�/��8/*6�bA1��21 ? /\�/*¶GFP©.-�/\� ? 389�bA1D>sb ��9E6L¡���/�3�b�¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? �2�:38��1�1�/V�E971���¢¶0�03g1�/V£2/*�538-�/*�7/*656~9E6\38-�/�·����2143;���¸�B1��2��b2�A��/�b2¥L³~�51sbA�x´�¡¾úS97µM��659�bA1GF��P+¹ º�Uq»_¼�½*¾*¿�¼ [ ¾ UXW U�� [K^�À Á ¾ ��À WU [ ¼ [KÀ Âë 1U38-�9E6�65/ ? 389�bA1U�/�¶��897/»>�¨o¡�9E6 ? ��656�38-�/�9E6568��/�b2¥</V9E�A/V1�653;�B3;/���b ? �B�E9 Ä �B3;9nbA1#¥.bA�«bA���²��2�=9E�73�bA1�9E�21GFÄÃW/�¶>/*�A971®¶4¨Å9E1438��b:¡�� ? 971��J��·����21438973�¨A¢î�1sb��_1Æ�26�3;-�/ ë 1�£2/*�568/×L�2�5389 ? 9E���B389�bA1QÇg�B3;9nbUN ë ×�Ç O ¢>3;-��B3S����b�£:9E¡�/V6����=/c�265���8/�¥.b2��3;-0/�/HÈ:3;/V143�3�b��_-�9 ? -�B1U/*9E�2/*1�6C3+�B38/�9E6~¡0/*��b ? �B�E9 Ä /*¡GF�©.-0/ ë ×�ÇÊÉ�N ³ � ³ O b2¥�21U9E10973;9E�2�!653;�B3;/ � ³  ~9E6S�A9�£A/V1¶4¨2¢

ÉDN ³ � ³ O Û �E9E�Ë0Ì_Í ÂûÅΠ˲ �Ï" ³ � ¢ @3£iÐÑ!Ò ¦:¨© � ³  I� Ó8Ô $ N�ç0F Â2 O©.-���6V¢L38-�/ ëÖÕ Ç×�=/c�265���8/V6�3;-�/�3;97�D/��c£2/*�;�B�A/*¡W����bA¶��2¶�9E�7973�¨¦b2¥.�����c£A/*��� ? î2/H3��8/ Á38���8109E1���3�b�9�3;6�971�97389±�2��653+�i3;/2F�©.-�/��*bA�8/�/*�5�db@¡09 ? 38-�/o6C¨:653;/V�Q¢_3;-0/o��b21��A/*��3;-0/

 â�ó

Page 131: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

0 500 1000 1500 2000

Act

ion

Time

Mode 1Mode 2Mode 3

Ø 9E�A���5/�ç0F Â æ ½ �S���2143;��� � ? 389�bA1 >sb � 9E�7�E��6C3;�;�i3;9E10��38-�/J·����2143;��� �21��2�nbA�A��/�b2¥³��81sb2�]´v¡¦úS9�µ}�0689�b21GF

 âdæ

Page 132: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

���c£A/V��� ? î2/H3.68�>/*10¡�6��c���c¨�¥'��bA�n3;-�/_9E10973;9E�2�:653+�i3;/2¢:�210¡�38-���6<38-�/_68�D�2�E�7/*��3;-�/ ëÖÕ ÇrFÇg�21�¡�bA� éo�B38�89ÏÈy©.-�/&b2�5¨¬NxÇoéQ© O ���8/V¡�9 ? 3;6&�21 ëÖÕ Ç7b2¥ %Ù � Ó ¢b�_-�/*�5/ ) ¡�/*1�b23;/V638-�/_1�����¶>/*�°b2¥M�c£2�B9E�±�B¶��E/653+�i3;/*6��_9738-�9E1��B1=/V1�/*�5�2¨�9E1438/*�5£B�2�0¡�/Vª�10/*¡=¶�¨�38-�/ Ø /*�8�=9ù«bA�7¡�/*1DÇg�0�E/_¡�/ ? �c¨=�_97¡03;-}F ë ¥}38-�/g���c£A/V��� ? î2/H3_6;�2�=���7/*6�3;-�/g68���5��bA�01�¡�9E10�&��-��268/ Á65��� ? / ? bA�=���7/V3;/V�7¨#�01�97¥.bA�5�D��¨A¢�38-�/*1�38-�/ ëÖÕ ÇÚ9E6 ñÙ Fg©.-:�06*¢}971Q38-�/��E�2�8�A/ ) �79E�=973*¢ÇoéQ©¯���5/*¡�9 ? 3;63;-��B3\�2¶�bA�03  ° ç©b2¥!38-�/S�c£B�29E�E�2¶��7/g�0-��268/ Á 65��� ? /�976�68�2�D�0�E/*¡�¶�¨=3;-0/971�97389±�2�>653;�B3;/BF

³�1Q/V·:�097£B�2�E/V143_¡�/Vª�10973;9nbA1"b2¥�3;-�/ ëÖÕ ÇÛ9E6.�A9�£A/V1Q¶4¨A¢É�N ³ � ³ OPÜ � ä # N ð � ³ O Ó N�ç0F  ^ O

�_-0/*�8/ # N ð � ³ O ¡�/V1sb23;/V6�3;-�/Q����b2¶��2¶�97�E973�¨J38-��B3D3;-�/ Ä /*��b23;- Á bA�8¡0/*��6C3+�B38/ � ³  D976�9E1/V9E�A/V1�653;�B3;/�� ð  VF.©.-�/&� bA�5/�¡�/*�nb ? �2�E9 Ä /*¡q3;-0/&/V9E�A/V1�653;�B3;/V6*¢Ý3;-�/V1o3;-�/r�*bA�8/&�D�A9�£A/V1Ä /*��b23;- Á bA�8¡0/*�P653;�B3;/.976T68-��2�8/V¡��2�*bA1��2653T38-�/./*97�A/*1�6C3+�B38/*6VFT©.-���6*¢�3;-�/ ëÖÕ Ç¬�0��b�£:9E¡�/V6� ? bA14£A/*109E/*143~�D/*�268���5/S¥.bA�\3;-0/r/RÈ:3;/*143yb2¥K/V9E�A/V1�653;�B3;/�¡0/*��b ? �B�E9 Ä �B3;9nbA1GFØ bA��Þ1bA�����79E1�� ÿ@? -0/*�=/ ë ¢�9E1 ? �8/c�B689E10� Û ? �B��68/V6�3;-�/ ëÖÕ Ç®3�b�/RÈ0-09E¶�9�3��r��b ? �2�79 Ä � Á389�bA1Q3�bq¡�/*�nb ? �2�E9 Ä �B389�bA1q3;�8�21�65973;9nbA1U�2��bA��1�¡ Û Ü Â F Ø 9E�A�0�8/#ç@F Â�ß 65-sb��_6r�q�0��b23yb2¥38-�/S1�����¶>/*�1b2¥��c£2�B9E�±�B¶��E/_653;�B3;/V6 ) ¥.bA���21qp�¡�/V�A�8/V/«b2¥!¥'�8/V/*¡sb2�|�5��1��_9738-#�&3�bB3+�2�bB¥�æg·����2143;�0FT©.-�/1:�0��¶M/V�ºb2¥���£B�297�±�2¶0�E/P653;�B3;/V6K�5/*�D�29E1�6b¥��297�8�7¨ ? bA10653+�B1�3P�B3T�B��bA��10¡� â0¢>�21�¡Q38-�/*1�¥'��bA�¸�B��bA��10¡ Û Ü âhä Â_à÷ äåâ=9�3��01�¡�/*�5�db:/*6S��¥��29E�5�7¨�68-��2�5�o971 ? �5/c�265/

 â ß

Page 133: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

-12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4

Num

ber o

f Ava

ilabl

e S

tate

s (N

)

Ln (Lambda)Ø 9E�A���5/�ç0F Â�ß�½ ©»b23+�B�P1:�0��¶M/V�¹b2¥\�c£B�297�±�2¶��7/�6C3+�B38/*6 ) ¥.bA��§ Ü p@¢ºæ�·����2143;�0¢��26r�¥'�01 ? 389�bA1"b2¥L�E1 Û NxÞ1bA�����79E1�� ÿ@? -0/*�=/ ë O F

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

-12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4

N*I

PR

Ln (Lambda)Ø 9E�A���5/�ç@F  �m½ Õ ��b23�b2¥rN�á�����¶>/*��b2¥_³�£B�297�±�2¶0�E/ ÿ 3;�B3;/V6 O õ ë 14£A/*�568/ Õ �2�5389 ? 97���B389�bA1Çg�B389�b�¥.bA�_§ Ü p0¢{æ�·����B1�3;�0¢>�26_��¥'��1 ? 389�bA1"b2¥L�E1 Û N]Þ1bA���0�E9E10� ÿ:? -�/*�=/ ë O F

 â �

Page 134: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

3�b��2���0��bcÈ@9E�D�B3;/V�7¨*ó � â0FK³Û����bB31b2¥ ) õ « É ü �A9�£A/*1#971 Ø 97�A���8/oç0F  � ���2�8�2�E�7/*�76�38-�9E638�;�2106897389�bA1}F ) õ « É ü �8/V���2971�6./*6568/V1�389±�2�7�7¨ ? bA1�6C3+�2143��B3g�897�A-43g�2��b2��1�¡#3;-�/rÇoéQ©�0�8/*¡09 ? 389�bA1�bB¥Tç@FT©.-�/_/*97�A/*1�6C3+�B38/*6��2�5/.¡�/*�nb ? �2�E9 Ä /V¡��2��b21��S3;-�/.¡0/*�A/V1�/*�8�B3;/ ? -��2971�b2¥6C3+�B38/*6L�7¨:9E1��~�2��b21��g38-�/�³��81sb2�]´v¡&ÃW/*¶�¥.bA�b3;-09E6 ? bA�����79E1��g6 ? -0/*�=/2FT³���bA��10¡ Û Ü â�ä  ¢38-�/�1�����¶>/*�«b2¥��c£2�B9E�±�B¶��E/&653+�i3;/*6�971 ? �5/c�265/*6r¡��;�2�D�B389 ? �B�E�7¨2¢M¶0�03�3;-�/ ëÖÕ Ç`�8/V���B9E1�6/V6865/*143;9E�2�E��¨���1 ? -��210�A/*¡G¢4971�¡�9 ? �B389E1��.3;-��B3K38-�/�/V9E�A/V1�653;�B3;/V6T�2�5/�¶>/ ? b2�D971����nb ? �2�E9 Ä /V¡GF²b���/H£A/*�V¢G�26 Û 9E6_9E1 ? �8/*�268/V¡o¶>/V¨$bA1�¡  ¢�38-�/r£B�2�7��/¹b2¥ ) õ « É ü ��1�¡�/V�8�db:/*6�����b Á? �2�E9 Ä �B389�bA1D3�b�¡�/V��b ? �2�79 Ä �i3;9�b21D3;�8�21�65973;9nbA1GFT©.-0/r/V9E�A/V1�653;�B3;/V6_68���5/c�2¡q3�b�/*�5�db:¡�9 ? �2�E��¨68�2�=���E/�38-�/��±�2�5�A/*�~68/V3¹bB¥�6C3+�B38/*6r�c£2�B9E�±�B¶��E/B¢G�21�¡ ? bA1�68/V·���/*143;��¨ ) õ « É ü ¡���bA�063�b=��£B�2�7��/�68�79E�A-438�7¨D�±�2�5�A/*�\38-��21q���8/V¡�9 ? 3;/V¡o¶4¨qÇoéQ©�FØ 97�A���5/*6Uç0F  p Á ^ â�65-sb��¤���nb23;6¦b2¥�3;-�/­��b ? �2�r¡�/*1068973�¨ãb2¥=653;�B3;/V6�Nx�Öú�� ÿ O ¥.bA�Û Ü â�äåâ ÂAâ âhä ÂAâ� äþâ@¢ ? bA�5�8/*65�Zb21�¡�9E10��3�b�38-�/�3;-��5/*/=�8/*�29E�=/*6�¡�/*6 ? �59E¶>/*¡W�2¶Zb�£2/2F Ø bA�Û Ü âhäþâ  3;-0/Q6C3;�8� ? 3;�0�8/�9E6�1sb23D�;�210¡sbA��¢<�_-�9 ? -¬�5/»>�/ ? 3;6=3;-�/�6538�8� ? 3;���5/¦bB¥~3;-0/³��81sb2�]´v¡�ÃW/*¶q¥.bA��bA��� ? b2�����E971���6 ? -�/V�D/BF Ø bA� Û Ü â�ä  �/�65/*/�3;-��i3g38-�/&�»ú�� ÿ 9E665���2�568/*�V¢}971�¡�9 ? �B3;971���3;-�/�bA1�65/V3�bB¥P��b ? �2�79 Ä �B3;9nbA1GF Ø 9E1��B�E�7¨2¢0¥.bA� Û Ü Â äåâ=3;-0/�65¨:6C3;/*�976 ? �E�268659 ? �B�E�7¨ ? -��$bB3;9 ? ¢��21�¡q3;-09E6.9E6.�5/»>�/ ? 38/*¡o971#3;-�/ ? b2�8�8/V68��bA1�¡�971��D�»ú�� ÿ FØ bA�QÞ1bA���0�E9E10� ÿ:? -�/*�=/*6 ë�ë �210¡ ë�ë�ë ¢\3;-�/�/*97�A/*10653+�i3;/*6�-��c£A/­��38/*1�¡�/V1 ? ¨¯3�b�nb ? �2�E9 Ä /B¢�971�¡�/V�M/V1�¡�/*143�bB¥ Û FQá�/H£A/V�53;-0/*�E/V686V¢�38-�/�1�����¶M/V�#b2¥£b ?*? ����9E/V¡�653;�B3;/V6�9E138-�/~·����B689 Á 9E143;/V�A�;�B¶��E/_�8/V�A9E�=/_9E6</*6568/*14389±�2�7�7¨�9E10¡�/*�>/*1�¡0/*143£b2¥ Û F<�S1��7¨�¥.b2� Û Ü â&9E6

 â2p

Page 135: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

6.7 6.71 6.72 6.73 6.74 6.75 6.76 6.77 6.78 6.79 6.8

Pro

babi

lity

EnergyØ 97�A���8/¹ç@F  p ½ �»ú�� ÿ ¥.bA�_§ Ü p0¢{æ�·����B1�3;�0¢�¥.bA� Û Ü âhäþâ  NxÞ1bA�����79E1�� ÿ@? -0/*�=/ ë O F

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

6.5 6.55 6.6 6.65 6.7 6.75 6.8 6.85 6.9 6.95 7

Pro

babi

lity

EnergyØ 97�A���8/�ç0F Â]á�½ �Öú�� ÿ ¥.bA�_§ Ü p@¢Åæ�·����B1�3;�0¢�¥.bA� Û Ü â�ä  NxÞ1bA�����79E1�� ÿ@? -0/*�=/ ë O F

0

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

0.03

0.035

0.04

0.045

4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Pro

babi

lity

EnergyØ 97�A���8/�ç0F ^ â ½ �Öú�� ÿ ¥.bA�_§ Ü p@¢Åæ�·����B1�3;�0¢�¥.bA� Û Ü Â äþâ�NxÞ1bA�����79E1�� ÿ@? -0/*�=/ ë O F â á

Page 136: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

38-�/ ëÖÕ Çã/HÈ0� ? 3;��¨  F ë 1 ? �8/*�268971�� Û ¶4¨Q�21��2�5¶�9738�;�2�59E��¨�68�D�2�7��Æ ? �2�068/*6�3;-�/ ëÖÕ ÇÚ3�b¡0��bA�D¡��;�2�D�B389 ? �B�E�7¨2¢A9E10¡�9 ? �B3;971���6�bA�=/g9E1�9�3;9±�B��¡�/*�nb ? �2�E9 Ä �B389�bA1©b £2/*�<3;-�/����21097¥.bA�7¡�b2¥¡0/*�A/V1�/*�8�B3;/ Ä /V��b238- Á bA�5¡�/*�.6C3+�B38/*6VF��PSR TVUXWU»g½cäUÂT¾ UXWUÂå¼�W?Y Z�ä [ äUæ À ]�À  À ¼�æ�» ^

©.-09E6 ? -��2�038/*��6C3;��¡09E/*¡D³~�51sbA�]´v¡�úS9�µ}�0689�b21=�8�B3;/V6��B1�¡ ? bA�D���2�8/V¡D3;-0/*�×3�br¡0¨:1��2�=9 Á? �2��3;��1�10/*�E971��S�8�B3;/V6K��659E1������8/*�E�B3;9�£A/V�7¨�6897�D�0�E/2¢i¨A/H3P��-4¨:689 ? �2�E��¨r� b23897£B�B38/*¡G¢B²~�2�=9E� Á3�bA1�9E�21S�_9738-&�.�5/c�2¡�97�7¨ ? bA10653;�5� ? 389E¶��7/P³~�51sbA�]´v¡�í/V¶GF ë 1&�A/V1�/*�8�2�4973}�\�26b¡�/H3;/V�8�=9E1�/V¡38-��B3g¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? �2�G3;�01�1�/*�79E1��=9E6_659E�A1�9�ª ? �B1�38�7¨�¥��B653;/V�g38-��21Q³~�81�bA�]´v¡=úS9�µ}�0689�b21GF©.-0/b21��7¨W����<�bA��/HÈ ? /*�0389�bA1J3�bU38-�9E6����26=��3;-��5/*/#¡�/V�A�8/V/"b2¥_¥'�8/*/V¡sbA�¤�5��1°��68971���3;-0/38-�9E�5¡ ? bA���0�E9E10��6 ? -�/V�D/BF\çT£A/V1Q¥.bA�.3;-09E6.�8�01G¢�-sb���/H£A/V�*¢M38-�/�¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? �2�}3;�01�1�/*�79E1�����26.6C3;9E�7�M¡�bA�D971��2143cFKè�1q�214¨ ? �B68/2¢�38-�/S�5/*68�0�73;6.65���A�A/V653.38-��B3\�_9�3;-#-�97�A-�/*�¡�/*�2�8/*/V6bB¥>¥'�5/*/V¡sbA�`�B1�¡=�21�9E1 ? �8/*�268971��A�7¨r¡�/V1�68/_³��81sbA�x´�¡�ÃW/*¶}¢A3;-�/.³��81sbA�x´�¡�úS9�µ}�0689�b21��\�B665�������5/*6568/*¡Q�_973;-��8/V68�>/ ? 3g3�b=38-�/�¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? �2�M38��1�1�/V�E9E10��F

©.-�/��8/V68����3;6�971=38-�9E6 ? -��2�@3;/*�68���0�ZbA�C3�38-�/ ? �±�297�m3;-��B3�9�3<9E6<¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? �B��3;��1�10/*� Á971���¢��21�¡�1sb23r³��81sbA�x´�¡�úS97µM��659�bA1G¢M�_-�9 ? -W9E6�3;-�/=���59E�=/ ? ���7���89�3S¥.bA��3;-�/�ª�1�/=��b�� Á/V1�/*�5�2¨J�>/c�2éW68���797353;9E10�A6©bA¶068/*�C£A/V¡¬9E1JèÖÇê68�>/ ? 3;�;�Ob2¥g�=/*¡�97��� Á 689 Ä /*¡­�ZbA��¨4�B3�bA�=9 ?�*bA�7/ ? �0�E/*6VFPï-�9E�7/«bA���g� b:¡�/*�}¡sb@/V6�1�b23g6;�2�=���E/S38-�/r/*143;97�8/����2�8�2�D/H3;/V�g65��� ? /r¥.bA�

Â2Âcë

Page 137: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

¡0/V3;/V�8�=9E1�971����_-�/V38-�/*�ybA�_1sb23�¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? �B�G3;��1�10/*�E971��=9E6.¥��26538/*�g3;-��21Q³~�51sbA�]´v¡¦úS97¥ Á¥'�0689�b21G¢:38-�9E6�97697�D��bA68659E¶��7/\3�b&¡sb�9E1D�214¨=/V£2/*143cF�è�1#�2¡0¡�97389�bA1G¢A¥'�@3;���5/~�8/V68/*�2� ? -��_97�E�10/*/*¡�3�by¡�/H3;/*�5�D971�/#3;-�/q��bA�E/V6�3;-��B3 ? �±�265689 ? �2� ? -���bA6=�21�¡�� b:¡�/#�=9�È@9E1��U�0�±�c¨J9E1£:97¶��;�B389�bA1��2�M/V1�/*�5�2¨A>{b��Û�B3_��b��Æ·����2143;���å1�����¶M/V�86*F�³�6.¡�9E6 ? ��6568/*¡Q9E1�38-�/�è�1�38��b Á¡0� ? 389�bA1G¢�38-�/*65/��D/ ? -��21�9768�=6~�B�8/r¶M/V�E9E/H£A/V¡o3�bD¶M/r��1�97�D��bA�53;�2143c¢�¶��@3S973_��bA���7¡�¶M/�068/V¥'�0��3�b_¡�9E�5/ ? 38�7¨�3;/*6C3L38-�9E6b�B6868�0�D�0389�bA1��_9�3;-r1:�0��¶M/V�89 ? �2�4�B1�¡&/H£A/V1�/HÈ@�>/*�897�D/V143+�2�6C3;��¡09E/*6VFÃW/��2�76�b�¡0/V3;/V�8�=9E1�/V¡Q38-��B3~38-�/�·����B1�38���ì� ? 3;9nbA1�>sb �_6S� ?*? bA�8¡�971��D3�b�3;-0/���1 Á

¡0/*�8��¨:9E1����5/*6�b21��21 ? /r6C3;�5� ? 38���8/¹b2¥b3;-0/�²~�2�=9E��3�bA1�9E�21G¢��A9�£@971����59E68/S3�b����D/ ? -��21�9768��_-09 ? -��/ ? �2�E�4·����21438���ʳ��81sb2�]´v¡#úS97µM��659�bA1GFb©.-�/·����2143;���n� ? 3;9nbA1 >{b����2�nbA1��.3;-0/¡0/*�A/V1�/*�8�B3;/����21097¥.bA�7¡�b2¥G6C3+�B38/*6<9E6�¡���/g3�br¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? �B��3;��1�10/*�E971���¢4¶��@338-�/�¡@¨@1��2� Á9 ? 6.976.68� ? -o38-��B3_9�3 ? bA�5�8/V68��bA1�¡�6_3�bD�21q³~�51sbA�]´v¡¾úS97µM��689nbA1 Á �E9EéB/~/V1�/*�5�2¨�3;�8�21�6C¥'/*�*FØ 971��2�7�7¨A¢��/��B¡�¡��8/V6865/*¡U3;-�/&9E6568��/�b2¥P��b ? �B�E9 Ä �B3;9nbA1�971=bA����� b:¡�/V�]¢Ý�21�¡o68-sb��/*¡38-��B3��_-�9E�7/�Þ1bA���0�E9E10� ÿ@? -�/V�D/V6�è8èg�21�¡Uè5è8è.����b@¡0� ? /��nb ? �2�E9 Ä /V¡o/*97�A/*10653+�i3;/*6V¢bÞ1bA� Á�0�E9E10� ÿ@? -�/*�=/�è�/RÈ0-09E¶�9�3;6_����b ? �2�79 Ä �i3;9�b21=3�bD¡�/V��b ? �2�79 Ä �B3;9nbA1D38�;�21�6597389�bA1GF

Â2Â�Â

Page 138: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

b c dfehgjilk í

� p � p drv o g�sKtudrvzv o î � vbïVdñð v i

î g � tÜc dr~�g�sKt � � iyv �Ë� k � p i}k {fo

n sK~�e i}kE~js ��p n x i g � ò x q ilk � x ~

ó d p � drx ôQõ i p i}k w k�d p ~js g�s ��p ~

©.-09E6 ? -��2�@3;/*���0�8/*65/*143;6D��6897�D�0�E/�6C3�b ? -��26C3;9 ? �*b:¡�/*�<¥.bA��/*10/*�8�B¨J¡�9E65�M/V�8659�bA1J¡��0/3�b°1:�0�D/V��bA��6Q�b�21�¡��B� ÁCö /V1�/*��38�;�21�6597389�bA1�6VF`í/ ? bA1�6897¡�/*���°²~�B�D97�73�b21�9±�21��_9738-��¡0/*�>/*1�¡�/V1 ? /¾bA1°��659E1��A�7/����B�;�2�=/V38/*� Û ¢P�_-sbA65/#/*1�/V�8�2¨J�7/V£2/*�E6&¥.bA�8�÷�o��/V¶öb2¥

Â2Â ^

Page 139: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

38�;�=<5/ ? 3�bA�897/*6r�26 Û 9E6S£B�2�59E/*¡}F�ÃW/D�26865���D/�38-��B3�3;-�/V�8/=�2�5/=�5/*659E¡����B�P�M/V�53;�0�8¶��B3897£2/38/*�5�D6.971�3;-�/�²��2�D97�73�bA1�9±�B1=�_-�9 ? - ? �2��65/�9E143;/V�868/ ? 389�bA1�6�b2¥�/V1�/*�5�2¨#�E/H£A/V� ? ���C£A/V6g3�b¶>/ ? bA�=/P1��2�8��b����c£db29E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA65689E10�A6*F�©.-�/�/*1�/V�8�2¨S�4�2��¶M/H3���/V/*1&68� ?V? /*65689�£A/\�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡? ��bA6568971��A6�9E6��26865���D/V¡ ? bA1�6C3+�2143c¢�21�¡J¥'���C3;-�/V�8�*bA�8/D3;-�/#-sb2����9E10�U����bA¶��2¶�9E�7973�¨�9E6�B6868�0�D/V¡Æ3�b�¶>/y� ? bA10653+�B1�3 #|øúù ë0â�Â*û F`³~6568���=9E10�J653�b ? -��26C3;9 ? ¡@¨@1��2�D9 ? 6V¢��/38-�/*15bA¶03;�29E1°�B1��B1��2�7¨�389 ? �B�E�7¨y6�bA�7£B�2¶0�E/��*b@¡0/*�¥.b2��3;-�/q¡�9768�>/*�8659�bA1J�0��b2ª��7/2F�©.-0/�0��b2ª��7/Q976�¥.bA��1�¡�3�b­¶>/��4�2��65689±�B1G¢��_9738-Å�21�/*1�/V�8�2¨�¡��597¥%3=����bA�Zb2�53;9nbA1��2�3�b¬ü @ èëý @ ü Fè�1y���B�53;9 ? ���E�2�*¢Ý3;-0/�/*1�/V�8�2¨U¡0�897¥%3~9E6~¥.b2��1�¡�3�b#¶>/�9E10¡�/*�>/*1�¡0/*143!b2¥�3;-�/�1�����¶M/V�«b2¥�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA65689E10�A6*F_©.-�/&653+�B1�¡��2�5¡o¡�/H£@9E�B3;9nbA1¾b2¥K38-�/��4�B��68659±�21q¨:9E/*�7¡�6��D¡�9�µ}��659�bA1? b@/S. ? 9E/V143��0��bA��bA�5389�bA1��2�>3�b üý @ ü ¢09E1 ? b21�38�;�26C3_3�b�3;-�/�¶�9E�268/V¡q�;�21�¡�bA� Á �\�B�Eé=�8/*65���73bB¥ # N ÂLà # O FK©.-�976��D/*�21�6�3;-��B3<�B6 #�þ  ¢A3;-�/��b�21�¡��2� ÁCö /*10/*��¡�9E65�M/V�8659�bA1�¶>/ ? b2�D/V69710ª�1�9�3;/B¢0�_-�9E�7/~3;-0/r¶09±�265/*¡ Á �;�21�¡�bA�ñ���2�EéD¡�9E65�M/V�8689nbA1q¶M/ ? bA�=/*6 Ä /*��b0Fk P�� ��W [ æzU�YUäU» [ ¾ UXW

©.-0/S/*1�/V�8�2¨��E/H£A/*�761b2¥b���2�;�2�=/V38/*� Á ¡�/V�M/V1�¡�/*143_²��2�=9E�73�bA1�9E�21�6<�2�8/ob2¥%3;/V1 ? -��2�8� ? 38/*� Á9 Ä /V¡o¶4¨q3;-�/&���8/V68/*1 ? /�b2¥��c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA65689E10�A6*Fg³~1o��£$bA9E¡0/*¡ ? ��bA65689E10��b ?V? ���56��_-�/V13���bU/*10/*�8�B¨­�7/V£A/V�E6�¶>/ ? bA�=/�¡�/V�A/*1�/V�;�B38/q�26���¥'��1 ? 389�bA1·b2¥.3;-�/����2�;�B�D/H3;/*�r¶>/*9E10�£B�2�59E/V¡GF°è�1�6538/c�2¡ b2¥S¶>/*971��y/HÈ0� ? 38�7¨J¡0/*�A/V1�/*�8�B3;/B¢\�8/V689E¡0���2�.·����2143;�0� Á �D/ ? -��21�9 ? �2�

Â2Âcÿ

Page 140: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

? bA�����79E1��26��E/c�B¡�3�b­�y¶��8/*�2é�9E1��¬b2¥�3;-�/�¡�/*�21�/*�8� ? ¨2FÅè�¥~38-�/Q���2�;�2�=/V38/*��9E6�£B�2�59E/V¡65��b��_�7¨�/*1sb2���A-G¢�38-�/*1q3;-�/r�2¡09±�2¶��i3;9 ? 3;-�/ubA�8/V���A���B�;�2143;/V/*6_3;-��i3g��6C3+�B38/����8/V���2�8/V¡971��21�/V9E�A/V1�653;�B3;/�b2¥�3;-0/\9E1�9�3;9E�2�4²~�B�D97�73�b21�9±�21��_97�E��� b�£2/\�2�nbA1���38-�/\/V1�/*�5�2¨ ? bA143�bA�0�? bA�8�5/*65�ZbA10¡�9E1��Q3�bo38-�/�/*97�A/*10653+�i3;/�bB¥.3;-�/�£B�2�C¨:9E1��U²��2�=9E�73�bA1�9E�21GFqá�/*�2���c£$bA9E¡�/V¡? ��bA6568971��A6*¢�-sb��/V£A/V�*¢�3;-�/����2�8�2�=/V3;/V������6C3&¶>/�£B�2�897/*¡y/V£2/*1��*bA�8/�65��b��_�7¨Q¥.bA�S3;-0/�B¡�9±�2¶��B3;9 ? 3;-�/ubA�8/V�ñ3�b�-sb2�E¡GFPè�¥L3;-�/����2�8�2�=/V3;/V�.9E6\£B�2�59E/*¡q6�bA�D/H�_-��B3_¥��26C3;/*�V¢�3;-�/V1/V1�/*�5�2¨r3;�;�B1�65¥'/V� ? �B1#b ?V? ���L¶M/H3���/V/*1�38-�/\�2¡=<8� ? /V1�3T653+�i3;/*6Pb2¥�38-�/.�c£dbA97¡�/*¡ ? ��b26868971���F©.-09E63�¨:�>/yb2¥G¡�9±�2¶��B3;9 ? /V1�/*�5�2¨�3;�8�21�65¥'/V��976é�1sb��_1q�26����b�21�¡��B� ÁCö /V1�/*��3;�8�21�689�3;9nbA1GF

è�1 ? -�/V�D97653;�C¨A¢B�b�21�¡��2� ÁCö /*10/*�}38�;�21�6597389�bA1�6G�2�8/¸b2¥%38/*1��5/*68��bA1�659E¶��7/T¥.bA�}38-�/P¶��8/*�2é Á¡�b �_1=b2¥K38-�/���bA�81 Á �S���M/V1�-�/V9E�=/*�g�2������bcÈ097���i3;9�b21��068/*¡Q3�bD�21��2��¨ Ä /&1�� ? �E/*�2���*b Á389�bA1}FK©.-�976���-�/V1sbA�=/*1sb21#9E6�3;/*�5�D/V¡�68�0�5¥�� ? /~-sbA�0��9E1��&9E1=3;-�/ ? -0/*�=9 ? �B�>�79738/*�;�i3;���5/2¢�B1�¡��2�7��b��_6.¥.bA�.3;�8�21�689�3;9nbA1�6_¶M/H3���/V/*1UbA10/��1b2�81 Á ���0�M/V1�-�/*97�D/V�_/*�E/ ? 38��bA1�9 ? �Zb238/*1 Á389±�2�/*1�/V�8�2¨�68���C¥�� ? /#3�b��21�b23;-�/V�*F��@�0�5¥�� ? /#-sbA����971�� ? �21°���E�c¨J� ? �5� ? 9E�2�\��b2�E/#9E1? -0/*�=9 ? �B���5/c� ? 3;9�b21¬¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? 6*F Ø bA�D/RÈ0�2�D�0�E/2¢�¡�9E656�b ? 9±�i3;9�b21 ? �21Lb ?*? �0�D�_-�/V1¯��b�210¡��2� ÁÖö /*1�/V��38�;�2106897389�bA1�976<�D�2¡�/.¥'��bA�×��¶ZbA�01�¡D6C3+�B38/ob21 bA10/���b23;/V143;9±�B��/*1�/V�8�2¨65���5¥�� ? /�3�b��21q��1�¶�bA��1�¡q6C3+�B38/«b2¥L38-�/�6;�B�D/S/V1�/*�5�2¨¤bA1��21�b23;-�/V�.�ZbB3;/*14389±�2�M/*1�/V�8�2¨65���5¥�� ? /2F

©.-�/������8��bA65/�b2¥\38-�9E6 ? -��2�038/*�&9E6�3�b��B1��2�7¨ Ä /D3;-0/�/*10/*�8�B¨­65���8/*�2¡�9E10�Q�_-�/V1°�²��2�=9E�73�bA1�9E�21U9E6 ? �2�5�89E/V¡­3;-0��bA���2-�1����D/V��bA�06��c£dbA97¡�/*¡ ? ��bA6568971��A6*Foè�1����2�C3;9 ? ���±�B�*¢

Â2Â��

Page 141: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�/ ? b21�6897¡�/*�����*b@¡�/V� ? bA1�659E65389E1��«bB¥}�B1D�B�8¶�9�3+�2�59E�7¨S�±�2�5�A/\1�/H3��1bA�5é#b2¥>/*10/*�8�B¨��E/H£A/*�76*¢�_9�3;-����8/V�A���E�2�b���B3838/*�51©b2¥Ý�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA65689E10�A6*FTè�3L9E6��26568���=/*¡&3;-��B3�3;-0/�����bA¶��2¶�97�E9�3�¨¥.b2�.���b�21�¡��2� ÁCö /*10/*� <5���=�#9E6 # FTí/��26568���=/�653�b ? -��265389 ? ¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? 6*¢0�21�¡q¡�/V£2/*�nbA����8/ ? ���5689�£A/�¥.bA�8���0�±��¥.bA� ? b2�D���@3;9E10��38-�/�¡�9E65�M/V�8659�bA1�����bBª��E/��26g��¥'��1 ? 3;9�b21¦b2¥�3;-0/1�����¶M/V�£b2¥T�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��b26868971��A6VF�ÃW/S3;-0/*1��db�bA1�3�b�bA¶03;�29E1q�B1Q�B1��2�7¨�389 ? �B�>¥.bA�5�|3�b? -��2�;� ? 3;/V�89 Ä /�3;-�976.¡�9E65�M/V�8689nbA1q����bBª��E/BF

è�1�¥��297�81�/V686V¢A973K68-sbA�0�E¡�¶>/\��bA9E143;/V¡#bA�03L3;-��i3��~6897�D97�±�2�!�*b:¡�/*�@�21�¡�6�bA�E�0389�bA1r�\�B6b2¶03+�2971�/*¡W9E1 Â����� ¶4¨­²��2�8�=9E1W�21�¡ Õ �89 ? /UN�Çg/H¥ÖF ÿ p O Fqág/V£A/V�538-�/*�7/*686V¢°bA���r�8/*65���73���26_¡�/V�897£2/*¡Q9E1�¡�/V�M/V1�¡�/V1�38�7¨q�B1�¡Q�0689E10�=65�E97�A-43;�7¨D¡�9�µ}/V�8/*143_3;/ ? -�1�97·:�0/*6*¢Ý6�b=�/r¥'/V�7338-��B3_9�3_9E6.65389E�7�}9E1438/*�8/V65389E1��=�21�¡Q�2���0��bA���59±�B38/S¥.bA�\3;-09E6\3;-0/*68976*Fk P¸O É ^�À � U�Y À ½ÃW/=-��c£A/#�q68/H3#b2¥\�2¡�9±�B¶��B3;9 ? /*1�/V�8�2¨��7/V£A/V� ? ���5£2/*6VFqÃW/��B6868�0�D/�3;-��i3&38-�/D�0��bA¶ Á�B¶�9E�7973�¨U¥.bA���U�b�210¡��2� ÁÖö /*1�/V��¡�9±�B¶��B3;9 ? <5���=�J�B3��21°�c£dbA97¡�/*¡ ? ��bA68659E1��U976 # FUÃW/�D�c¨�3;-0/*1®�265é�3;-�/q¥.bA�7��b��_9E1�� ½ ³~6865���=9E1��W��6C¨:653;/V� 976�3+�2éB/*1¬���2653 ) �c£$bA9E¡�/V¡? ��bA6568971��A6*¢��_-��B3&9E6�3;-�/=����bA¶��2¶�97�E9�3�¨Rb2¥����2é�971���y���4�\�B�8¡��*b�£A/*6­Èʳ~1W���4�\�B�8¡N'¡sb��_14�\�2�5¡ O �*b�£A/�9E6�bA1�/q971��_-�9 ? -�38-�/ ? -��21��A/Q9E1°/*10/*�8�B¨�¥'��bA�ÉbA10/Q�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡? ��bA6568971���3�b�38-�/�1�/RÈ:3�9E6~��bA65973;9�£A/�N�1�/V�4�B3;9�£A/ O F Ø 97�A���8/ � F  9E�7�E��6C3;�;�i3;/*6g3;-�/�/*1�/V�8�2¨

Â2Â��

Page 142: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�7/V£2/*�����B353;/V�81D�/��2�8/ ? bA1�6897¡�/*�59E1��0FT³ ? -��2�8�2/*¡����2�5389 ? �7/abA1D�r�59E1��S�_9�3;-D����1�97¥.b2�8��D�2�A10/V3;9 ? ª�/V�E¡öbA�897/*143;/V¡°�M/V�8�>/*1�¡�9 ? ���E�2��3�by38-�/q�8971��U�A/*10/*�;�i3;/*6=�U·����2�7973+�i3;97£2/*��¨659E�=9E�E�2��/*1�/V�8�2¨W�E/H£A/V�����B353;/V�81��_-�/V1�3;-�/��D�2�A10/V3;9 ? ª�/*�E¡­653;�5/*1��B3;-J¶>/ ? b2�D/V6&3;-0/£B�2�59±�2¶0�E/S���B�;�2�=/V38/*�*F

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

0 1 2 3 4 5

E

LambdaØ 9E�A���5/ � F Â�½� 9E�2�A�8�2�Û68-�b �_971��~10/V3���bA�8é!b2¥Ý�c£db29E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA68659E1��A6L�A/*10/*�;�i3;/*¡�¶�¨�£B�2�C¨ Á971���6�bA�=/����2�8�2�=/V3;/V� Û FÃW/�1sb��×38���81­3�bQ38-�/�6�bA�E�0389�bA1¬b2¥£b2�����*b@¡0/*��N Ø 97�A���5/ � F ^ ���c¨�¶M/D�o��65/V¥'���

£:9768���2��3�bhb2��¥.bA�P¥.bA�E�nb �_971��S3;-0/��B�8�A���=/*143 O ½ ÃW/_¶M/V�A9E1D�B3�21D��£$bA9E¡0/*¡ ? ��bA6568971����210¡38�;�c£A/V�865/ ) 971D65� ?*? /*65689�b21GFPí/g¡�/Vª�1�/�É��TN� â ) O 3�b&¶>/_3;-�/�����bA¶��2¶�9E�7973�¨©b2¥G-��c£:9E10�����4���2�8¡��*b £2/*�=/*143;6_9�¥��/�9E1�9�3;9E�2�E��¨�653;�2�53�bA1#38-�/�-�9E�2-�/*���B��b��/*�_�2¡�9E�2¶��B3.�B3\3;-0/

Â2Âcß

Page 143: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA68659E1��0FQáb23;/=3;-��i3&�/#�2�5/��26568���=9E10�o653�b ? -��265389 ? ¡@¨@1��2�D9 ? 6V¢L3;-��B3�976*¢�/r1�/*�A�7/ ? 3.3;-�/�/VµM/ ? 3ybB¥K��-��268/�9E1438/*�5¥'/V�8/V1 ? /!bA1#3;-�/�¡�9768�>/*�5689�b21��0��b2ª��7/2F

Stay on adiabat with probability 1-p

Make diabatic jump with probability p

Ø 9E�2���8/ � F ^ ½� 9E�2�A�;�B�ê65-sb��_9E1��=��bA68659E¶��7/�¶M/V-��c£@9nbA�86g�B3g�B1o�c£db29E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA65689E10��F�hb0¢L65������bA68/=��/D653+�B�53�bA1�38-�/=-�9E�A-0/*�r�2¡�9E�2¶��B3*FDÃW/ ? �21­/V973;-0/*��653;��¨¬bA1y3;-0/

�B¡�9±�2¶��B3D�_9�3;-�����bA¶��2¶�9E�7973�¨ Â�à # ¢£bA�=��/ ? �21®-sbA��3�b­38-�/o�nb �/*���2¡�9E�2¶��B3=�_9738-�0��bA¶��B¶�9E�7973�¨ # F�è�¥g��/q6C3+�c¨�bA1�38-�/��2¡�9±�B¶��B3c¢T38-�/*15bA����/*1�/V�8�2¨°971 ? �5/c�265/*6=�26��/-0/c�2¡o3�bD38-�/�1�/RÈ:3��c£dbA97¡�/*¡ ? ��bA6568971���¢>6�bD38-��B3~1sb��ã��/#b21��7¨q-��c£2/�3�bD���2éB/� à÷Â

�*bA�5/=�0�����2�5¡J� b�£A/V6*FQ�S���r65¨:6538/*� 9E6�3;-���6�bA1W38-�/��nb �/*�&�2¡�9E�2¶��B3&�B3�38-�/�1�/RÈ:3�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA6568971���¢��21�¡�-�/*�5/���/=-��c£A/�3�bq�D�2é2/� à� ���4���2�8¡W� b�£2/*6�9E1 ) à�Â

6C3;/V��6*¢>�_973;-o�=3�b23+�2�!�0��bA¶��B¶�9E�7973�¨¤b2¥TÉ @ N� à÷ÂAâ ) à÷ O F��@9E1 ? /�3;-�/&����bA¶��2¶�9E�7973�¨�b2¥Â2Â��

Page 144: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

971�97389±�2�7�7¨�653;��¨:971����B3K38-�/�ª��5653��c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA68659E1��S���26 Â>à # ¢2�/.-��c£A/_� ? bA143;�59E¶��0389�bA1bB¥.N Âgà # O É @ N� àÛÂAâ ) àÛ O 3�b=É � N� â ) O F

�hbJ1�b ��68�0���Zb268/�3;-��B3c¢g653;�2�5389E1��J�i3�3;-�/o-�9E�A-0/*�#�2¡09±�2¶��i3c¢\�/¯<5���D�Å3�b­3;-0/�nb���/V���2¡�9E�2¶��B3=�_9738-Å����bA¶��2¶�97�E9�3�¨ # F�©.-0/*1ÒbA���D/*1�/V�8�2¨�¡�/ ? �8/*�268/V6��26D�/�-�/*�2¡3�bD38-�/�1�/RÈ@3S�c£dbA97¡�/*¡ ? ��bA65689E10��¢}�B1�¡�6�bD��/��5/*�D�29E1¦bA1��D-�9E�A-0/*� Á /*1�/V�8�2¨Q�2¡09±�2¶��i3cF�:9E1 ? /=�/D6C3;97�E�T-��c£2/D3�b��D�2é2/�y�0�����2�5¡�� b�£2/*6*¢�3;-�/ ? b21�38�897¶��03;9nbA1y3�bQÉ � N� â ) O¥'��bA�|38-�9E6.��bA65689E¶09E�E9�3�¨�976 # É � N� â ) àÛ O ¢��210¡Q6�b=�/¹bA¶03+�B9E1#3;-��i3c¢

É � N� â ) O�Ü # É � N� â ) àl O�� N Â_à # O É @ N� àùÂAâ ) àÛ O N � F  OÃW/�1sb�� ? bA�=���E/H3;/�38-�/���9 ? 3;�0�8/�¶4¨#�26568���=9E10����/�6C3+�2�C3_�B3\38-�/���b��/*�.�2¡09±�2¶��i3cF

ÃW/ ? �21\<5���D�W�_973;-J�0��bA¶��B¶�9E�7973�¨ # ¢P6�b�3;-��B3#bA����/V1�/*�5�2¨�971 ? �5/c�265/*6�3�bQ3;-�/#1�/RÈ:3�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA6568971���¢:�21�¡=6�b��/��5/*�D�29E1�bA1D����b��/*��/*1�/V�8�2¨=�B¡�9±�2¶��B3cFL©.-:�06<38-�/ ? bA1 Á38�897¶��03;9nbA1�3�b�É @ N� â ) O ¥'��bA�ã3;-�976K��bA68659E¶�97�E9�3�¨�9E6 # É @ N� à�ÂAâ ) à� O FT³��73;/V�81��i3;97£2/*��¨A¢�_9�3;-��0��bA¶��B¶�9E�7973�¨ Â>à # ��/.6C3+�c¨�bA1�3;-�/���b���/V�T/*10/*�8�B¨��2¡09±�2¶��i3c¢26�bS3;-��i3­bA���K/*1�/V�8�2¨¡0/ ? �5/c�265/*6��26P��/_-�/*�2¡=3�br38-�/_1�/HÈ:3�c£dbA97¡�/*¡ ? ��bA68659E1��0FKí/g�2�5/.3;-���6ÄbA1�3;-�/_-�97�A-�/*�/V1�/*�5�2¨��2¡�9E�2¶��B3=�i3=38-�/q1�/HÈ:3��c£dbA97¡�/*¡ ? ��b26868971���¢�21�¡���/�65389E�E�-��c£A/�3�b����2éB/��0�����2�5¡��*b £2/*6V¢06�b�3;-0/�����bA¶��2¶09E�E9�3�¨&¥'��bA�m38-�9E6���bA68659E¶�97�E973�¨&9E6�N ÂLà # O É � N� â ) à� O ¢�297£:9E1����06*¢

É @ N� â ) O�Ü N Â_à # O É � N� â ) àÛ O�� # É @ N� àùÂAâ ) àÛ O N � F ^ OÂ2 p

Page 145: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

è�3&9E6�/c�B65¨y3�b�/*6C3+�2¶��79E65-W3;-0/=¥.bA�7��b��_9E10�#9E¡�/V1�3897389E/*6 ½ É � N ë@â ) O�Ü É @ N ) â ) O�Ü# Ù ¢��21�¡¯É � N ) â ) O�Ü É @ N ë0â ) O�Ü N Â�à # O # Ù @ ý F Ø ��b2� 38-�9E6��21�¡®¥'��bA� bA����5/ ? ���8659�bA1y¥.bA�8�����±�26S¥.b2�&É��°�/D�29E�I3�bQ65-sb��`3;-��B3&É @ N� â ) O�Ü É � N ) à â ) O ¢ë ��Æ� ) F Ø bA� ) Ü Â 3;-�976�9E6�bA¶4£:9�b2��68��¨­3;�5��/2F���b�65������bA68/q9�3�9E6�38�8��/�¥.bA�) FS©.-�/V1y¥.b2� ) �  973~9E6 ? /*�C3+�2971��7¨#38�8��/�¥.b2�� Ü ë0â ) �  FS³�6865���D/&3;-�/V1�3;-��B3 ���� ) F�©.-�/V1Q�/&-��c£2/2¢É @ N� â ) �  OúÜ N Â.à # O É � N� â ) O�� # É @ N� àÛÂ2â ) O

Ü N Â.à # O É @ N ) à â ) O�� # É � N ) � Â_à â ) OÜ # É � N ) � Â_à â ) O�� N Â_à # O É @ N ) � Â_à àlÂAâ ) OÜ É � N ) � Âgà â ) �  O N � F ÿ O

�B1�¡Q6�b�bA��� ? �E�29E�ê9E6.����b�£A/*¡}F©.-�/V�8/H¥.bA�8/B¢Ý�/ ? �21q�_�89�3;/B¢É � N� â ) O�Ü # É � N� â ) àl O�� N Â_à # O É � N ) à â ) àÛ O N � F � O

Þ1b2��¶�9E10/*¡y�_973;-�É � N ë0â ) O�Ü # Ù ¢�É � N ) â ) O�Ü N Â�à # O # Ù @ ý ¢K�210¡­É @ N� â ) O�ÜÉ � N ) à â ) O ¢���/ ? �21q/H£2�B�E���B38/�É��PN� â ) O ¥.b2�_�2�E� â ) F

Â2Â!�

Page 146: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

k P � � U#" À W [ ÂrU�� [z^�À l÷¾c [ æ<¾�$Uä [ ¾ UXW

ÃW/�68-��B�E�}1�b �ãbA¶03;�29E1q���8/ ? ���5689�£A/r�8/*�E�B3;9nbA1�¥.bA�\ª�1�¡�9E10��3;-�/��*bA�D/V143;6£b2¥»bA���_¡�976 Á38�897¶��03;9nbA1�É � N� â ) O N�659E1 ? /�É @ ? �21=¶M/�bA¶03;�29E10/*¡�¥'��bA�mÉ � ¶4¨�3;-�/.38�;�21�6C¥.bA�8�D�B389�bA1 þ ) à M¢2�/\1�/V/*¡�bA10�7¨ ? bA10689E¡0/*�ºb21�/1b2¥03;-�/.É Á ¥'�01 ? 389�bA1�6 O Fb©.-�/\Z 38- �*bA�D/V143c¢Z C ë ¢�976.¡�/Vª�1�/*¡�£@9E�0¢

"% �   Ù Ü Ù�� � ² � É � N� â ) O N � F � O�S���.�5/ ? ���86597£A/r�8/V�±�B389�bA1#976£bA¶03;�29E1�/V¡#£@9E�0¢"� �   Ù Ü Ù @ ý��­� ý � É � N� â ) O�� ) � N Â_à # O # Ù @ ý

Ü ) � N Â_à # O # Ù @ ý � Ù @ ý�� � ý N� � # É � N� â ) àÛ O&� � N Â_à # O É � N ) à â ) àÛ O5OÜ ) � N Â_à # O # Ù @ ý � # "% �   Ù @ ý � N Â_à # O('Ù @ ý��­� ý N� à ) � ) O � É � N ) à â ) àÛ OÜ ) � N Â_à # O # Ù @ ý � # "% �   Ù @ ý� N Â_à # O Ù @ ý�� � ý É � N ) à â ) àl O �� t � ²

) Z+*-, N à5 O t N ) à O t ) � @:tÜ ) � N Â_à # O # Ù @ ý � # "% �   Ù @ ý � N Â_à # O N �� t � ý

) Z * , N à5 O t ) � @:t "� t   Ù @ ý� Ù @ ý�� � ý ) � É � N ) à â ) àÛ O8O

Ü ) � N Â_à # O # Ù @ ý � # "% �   Ù @ ý � N Â_à # O N �� t � ý) Z * , N à5 O t ) � @:t "� t   Ù @ ý

 ^ ë

Page 147: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

� ) � N Â_à # Ù @ ý O8OÜ # "% �   Ù @ ý � N Â_à # O N àCÂ O � "% �   Ù @ ý � N Â_à # O � @ ý�

t � ý) Z+* , N à5Â O t ) � @:t "� t   Ù @ ý� ) � N Â_à # O

Ü N # � N àCÂ O � N Â_à # O5O "% �   Ù @ ý � N Â_à # O Ù @ ý�t � ý

) Z * , N à5 O t ) � @:t "% t   Ù @ ý� ) � N Â_à # O N � F ß O�B1�¡Q6�b�¢0�/&65/*/�3;-��i3c¢"� �   Ù Ü N # � N à5 O � N ÂAà # O5O "% �   Ù @ ý � N ÂAà # O � @ ý�

t � ý) Z * , N àCÂ O t ) � @:t "% t   Ù @ ý � ) � N ÂAà # ON � F � O

k PCk l÷¾cÂ/. À æ�ÂT¾ UXW 0mæzU21�½ À�S���~�db4�2���_9E�E�!3�b#¡�/V38/*�8�=9E10/�3;-�/�¡09E6538�897¶��03;9nbA1o�0��b2ª��7/&¥.bA��3;-�/�1�/H3�¡�9768���E� ? /V�D/V1�33 å ^ à ) ¢�-��c£:9E10��6C3+�2�C3;/V¡ bA1°3;-�/q�nb �/*�=�2¡09±�2¶��i3cF4�¨�38-�/oÞ�/*143;�8�2�_�!9E�=973©.-0/&bA�5/*��¢03;-�/~¡�9E6C3;�897¶��0389�bA1�bB¥ 3 ¶M/ ? bA�=/*6.�4�B��68659±�21#971�3;-�/��79E�=973°b2¥��E�2�8�A/ ) F�©»b? bA�=���E/H3;/*��¨ ? -��2�;� ? 3;/V�89 Ä /.3;-�976T�4�2�068689E�21G¢A�/.-��c£A/.3�b ? bA�=���03;/\38-�/.�=/c�21�" 3   â �210¡6C3+�210¡��2�8¡�¡�/H£@9E�B3;9nbA165TF�©.-�976_�_97�E�>ª��86C3��5/*·���97�8/���6.3�b ? b2�D���@3;/D"%9  Ù �21�¡­"% Ó   Ù F

�hbQ��/#¶>/*�A971­¶4¨W68/V353;971���Z Ü Â 9E1W38-�/��5/*�±�i3;9�b21�bA¶@3+�2971�/*¡�971­3;-0/����5/V£:9�bA�06 ^ Â

Page 148: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

65/ ? 3;9�b21GF�©.-�9E6.�A9�£A/V6*¢"�9  Ù Ü N ^87 àÛ O "�9  Ù @ ý � ) N Â_à 7 O N � F�p O

Ø bA�K�±�2�5�A/ ) �/.68-��B�E�0�D�2éB/\3;-�/_�26568���=�0389�bA1�38-��B3g"%/  Ù 976P�21��21��B�7¨�3;9 ? �2��¥'��1 ? 3;9�b21bB¥ 7 ¢�6�bD38-��B3.�/ ? �21o/RÈ0���21�¡o9�3_9E1���©K�c¨:��b2�g65/*�59E/*6��2¶�bA�03 7 Ü ýÓ F Õ �7���A�A971���9E143�bb2�����5/ ? �0�8689�£A/o¥.b2�8�����E�0¢��/�9E�=�=/*¡�9E�B3;/V�7¨�b2¶03+�2971�38-��B3#�i3 7 Ü ýÓ ¢r"�9  Ù Ü Ù Ó F 9�µ}/V�8/V1�389±�B389E1��S�_9�3;-=�8/V68�>/ ? 33�b 7 �A9�£A/V6:9�;=<?>A@9 ü Ü ^ "%9  Ù @ ý � N ^B7 à@ O 9�;=<?>C@-D è9 ü à ) F�:��¶�65389738�03;971�� 7 Ü ýÓ �A9�£A/*6&"%/ FE Ù N ýÓ OPÜ ^ Ù @ ýÓ à ) Ü àC F

Þ1bA14389E1���9E10��3;-�976~����b ? /*656*¢G�/��A/V3 9 ë ;G<?>C@9 ü ë Ü � 9�;=<?>C@-D è9 ü � N ^87 à÷ O 9 ë ;G<?>C@-D è9 ü ë F��¨�5/*�>/c�B38/*¡���¨#¡�9�µ}/V�8/*14389±�B389E1���¢:��/¹bA¶@3+�2971q¥.b2� ) ö ^ 38-��B3c¢

Ô ä "�9  ÙÔ 7 ä Ü ^ 3 Ô ä @ ý "�9  Ù @ ýÔ 7 ä @ ý � N ^87 àÛ O Ô ä "%/  Ù @ ýÔ 7 ä N � F � O©.-0/*�8/H¥.bA�8/B¢L"%9 BH ä�IÙ N ýÓ O�Ü ^ 3 "%/ BH ä @ ý IÙ @ ý N ýÓ O F<áob���¢�¥'��bA� "%/ BH ý IÙ N ýÓ O�Ü à5 ��/r-��c£A/B¢

"%9 BH ä�IÙ N Â^ O�Ü à ^ ä @ ý 3�J â 3 ö ^ N � F Â�ë Oáb23;/�38-��B3.3;-09E6.¥.bA�8�����±���B�E6�b���bA�8é�6_¥.bA� 3 Ü Â F�©.-�/V�8/V¥.b2�8/2¢Ý971�3;-�/r�±�2�5�A/ ) �E97�D9�3�/!bA¶03+�B9E1�3;-��B3c¢

"%9  Ù N 7 OúÜ ) ^ à ÍKä�L ý ^ ä @ ý N 7 à Â^ O äÜ ) ^ à Â^ ÍKä�L ý N ^87 àl O ä

 ^2^

Page 149: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ü ) ^ à Â^ ^87 àÛÂ^ à ^87Ü Â^ N ) à 7 à ýÓÂ_à 7 O N � F Â2Â O

©.-�976D976�3;-�/��=/c�21°£B�2�E��/¤bB¥S���4���2�8¡Å�*b�£A/V6D-��c£:9E10�W6C3+�2�C3;/*¡5bA1�3;-�/q-�97�A-�/*��B¡�9±�2¶��B3cF�©.-���6*¢Ý3;-0/&�=/c�21#£B�2�7��/¹b2¥T¡sb��_14���2�8¡��*b�£A/V6�976r" ) à 9  Ü ) à "%9  ÜýÓ N ) � ü @ èëý @ ü O FT©.-�976\9E6/HÈ0� ? 3;�7¨=3;-0/~�=/c�21�£B�2�7��/ybB¥b���4�\�2�5¡q� b�£A/V6\-��c£:9E1���653+�B�53;/V¡b21&3;-0/���b��/*�L�2¡�9E�2¶��B3*F�©.-0/*�8/H¥.bA�8/B¢Ý" 3   Ü " ^ à )   Ü ^ "�9  à ) Ü ) � ü @ èëý @ ü à ) Üü @ èëý @ ü ¢��B1�¡Q6�b=�/ ? �21q�_�89�3;/B¢�9E1�3;-0/r�79E�=973�b2¥L�±�2�5�A/ ) ¢�38-��B3c¢

" 3   Ü 7 à ýÓÂ_à 7 N � F  ^ O�@/H38389E1���Z Ü ^ 971"bA���.�8/ ? ���5689nbA1Q�5/*�E�B3;9nbA1#�A97£2/*6V¢"%:Ó¸  Ù Ü N 7 � Â_à 7 O "�@ÓS  Ù @ ý � N Â_à 7 O N àC O N ^ O ) "%9  Ù @ ý � ) ÓiN Â_à 7 O

Ü "%:Ó¸  Ù @ ý à ^ ) N Â_à 7 O "%9  Ù @ ý � ) ÓiN Âgà 7 O N � F Â�ÿ O�S1 ? /.�2�4�2971G¢ ¥.bA� ) �±�2�5�A/P��/\65-��2�7�0�26568���=/38-��B3."% Ó   Ù 9E6L�21��B1��2�7¨�389 ? ¥'��1 ? 3;9�b21

bB¥ 7 F�³\3 7 Ü ýÓ ��/#-���£2/�"% Ó   Ù Ü "% Ó   Ù @ ý à ) "%9  Ù @ ý � ýÓ ) Ó Ü "% Ó   Ù @ ý àÙ H Ù @ ý IÓ � ýÓ ) Ó Ü Ù Ó � "% Ó   Ù @ ý FP©.-�/V�8/H¥.bA�8/B¢b"% Ó   Ù Ü ýÓ N ) � ) à� �NM�M�M8�  OPÜÙ H Ù � ý IO F 9�µ}/V�8/*14389±�B389E1����_9�3;-q�8/V68�>/ ? 3�3�b 7 �A9�£A/*6V¢Ô>"% Ó   ÙÔ 7 Ü Ô>"% Ó   Ù @ ýÔ 7 � ^ ) "%/  Ù @ ý à ^ ) N Â_à 7 O Ô>"%/  Ù @ ýÔ 7 à ) Ó N � F Â!� O

 ^ ÿ

Page 150: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÃW/T3;-0/*1¹bA¶03;�29E1="% Ó   E Ù N ýÓ O�Ü "% Ó   E Ù @ ý N ýÓ OP� ^ ) Ù @ ýÓ à ^ ) ýÓ N àC O à ) Ó Ü "% Ó   E Ù @ ý N ýÓ OP�) Ó à ) � ) à ) Ó Ü "% Ó   E Ù @ ý N ýÓ O F°©.-�/*�5/V¥.bA�5/2¢S"% Ó   E Ù N ýÓ O=Ü "% Ó   E ý N ýÓ O F°áb ��¢"� Ó   ý N 7 O�Ü Â_à 7 ¢Ý�210¡�6�b�"� Ó   E ý N ýÓ OPÜ à5 F 9�µ}/V�8/*14389±�B389E1����2�4�B9E1¯�A97£2/*6V¢ 9 ë ;=< ë > @9 ü ë Ü 9 ë ;G< ë >C@-D è9 ü ë � � ) 9�;G<?>C@-D è9 ü à ^ ) N ÂDà7 O 9 ë ;G<�>A@QD è9 ü ë FÞ1bA143;971:�09E1���9E1�38-�9E6.���c¨A¢��/&65/*/�3;-��B3.¥.b2� 3 ö ^ ¢Ô ä "% Ó   ÙÔ 7 ä Ü Ô ä "% Ó   Ù @ ýÔ 7 ä � ^ 3 ) Ô ä @ ý "%9  Ù @ ýÔ 7 ä @ ý à ^ ) N Â_à 7 O Ô ä "%9  Ù @ ýÔ 7 ä N � F ÂR� O

©.-0/*�8/H¥.bA�8/&�B3 7 Ü ýÓ ��/��A/H3c¢"% Ó  BH ä!IÙ N Â^ OúÜ "% Ó  BH ä!IÙ @ ý N Â^ O�� ^ 3 ) N à ^ ä @ Ó N 3 àù O J O à ) N à ^ ä @ ý 3�J O

Ü "%:ÓS BH ä!IÙ @ ý N Â^ O à ^ ä @ ý 3�J ) � ^ ä @ ý 3�J )Ü "%:ÓS BH ä!IÙ @ ý N Â^ O N � F Â�ß O

áb���¢�¥'��bA� "% Ó   ý N 7 O�Ü Â�à 7 ��/=-��c£A/=3;-��i3�"� Ó   H ä�Iý N 7 O�Ü ë ¥.b2� 3 ö ^ ¢L�B1�¡­6�b"� Ó   H ä�IÙ N ýÓ O�Ü ë ¥.bA� 3 ö ^ F�©.-���6_3;-�/�©L�c¨@�nbA�./HÈ@���B1�689nbA1�¥.b2�r"% Ó   Ù 976*¢

"%@ÓS  Ù N 7 OPÜ ) N ) �  O� à N 7 à Â^ O N � F  � O©.-�976S9E6�"% Ó   Ù ¥.bA�S���4���2�8¡y�*b�£A/*6�6C3+�2�C3;971���bA1�38-�/�-�97�A-�/*�S�2¡�9±�B¶��B3cF Ø b2��3;-0/

¡�b �_14���2�8¡Q� b�£2/*6g653+�B�53;971����B3_3;-0/r-09E�A-�/V�_�2¡�9E�2¶��B3*¢@�/&�nbhbAéD�B3";N ) à O Ó¸  Ü ) Ó à ^ ) "%9  � "%:ÓS 

 ^ �

Page 151: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ü ) Ó à ^ ) Â^ N ) à 7 à ýÓÂ_à 7 O � ) Ó� � ) � à N 7 à Â^ OÜ ) Ó à ) Ó � ) 7 à ýÓÂ_à 7 � ) Ó� � ) � à N 7 à Â^ OÜ ) �#N � 7 à ^Â_à 7 �  O�� ) Ó� à N 7 à Â^ OÜ ) � ÿ 7 àÛÂ

Â_à 7 � ) Ó� à N 7 à Â^ O N � F  p O©.-09E6_9E6r"% Ó   Ù ¥.bA�.���4���2�8¡��*b £2/*6g653;�2�5389E1���bA1#3;-0/r�nb���/V���B¡�9±�2¶��B3cFT©.-0/*�8/H¥.bA�8/B¢" 3 Ó¸  Ü ";N ^ à ) O ÓS  Ü � "%@Ó¸  àS� ) "%9  � ) Ó

Ü ) ÿ 7 àÛÂÂ_à 7 � ) Ó à N � 7 à ^ O à ^ ) N ) � 7 à ýÓÂgà 7 O�� ) Ó

Ü ) ÿ 7 àÛÂÂ_à 7 � ) Ó à N � 7 à ^ O à ^ ) Ó à ^ ) 7 à ýÓÂ_à 7 � ) Ó

Ü ) ÿ 7 àÛÂ_à ^87 � ÂÂ_à 7 à N � 7 à ^ O

Ü ) 7Â_à 7 à N � 7 à ^ O N � F Â�� O

�B1�¡#6�b�¢:¥.bA�1b2���UT��2��68659±�21�����b2ª��E/2¢:��/��2/V3\38-��B3(5 Ó Ü ) üý @ ü à N � 7 à ^ O à NÖü @ èëý @ ü O Ó FØ bA�.�E�2�8�2/ ) ¢�38-�9E6_¶>/ ? b2�D/V6*¢5 ÜWV ) 7

Â_à 7 N � F ^ ë O©.-�/r/*·����i3;9�b21q¥.b2�£bA���XTr�B��68659±�21q9E6\38-�/*�5/V¥.bA�5/2¢

É Ù N 3 O�Ü ^5�Y ^[Z /HÈ@��N à N 3 à " 3   O Ó^ 5 Ó O N � F ^  O ^ �

Page 152: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

©.-0/S¥�� ? 3�bA�ab2¥ ^ 9E6�9E1 ? �E��¡�/V¡#68971 ? /~�/r�2�8/��1bA�5é�9E1����_9�3;-q������bA¶��2¶�97�E9�3�¨�-�/*�5/2¢�1sb23�D����bA¶��2¶�9E�7973�¨q¡�/V1�689�3�¨A¢!�B1�¡y�26�o�5��1�6~¥'��bA� ë 3�b ) ¢ 3 �5��1�6S¥'��bA� à ) 3�b ) 9E16C3;/V��6obB¥ ^ Fk PR� \¤ä]" À æ�¾c»g¼�½ É À  [ ¼�W?Y l ¾cÂT»gäUÂTÂT¾ UXW

©»b­¡0/*�*bA1�6538�;�B38/¦b2����¥.bA�8���0�±�0¢���/Q�;�21��W1����=/*�59 ? �2�\3;/V653=�_973;- ) Ü �2ë2ë �210¡7 Ü ë_^=�`� F�©.-�/��8/V68����3;6��2�5/�����bB383;/V¡U9E1 Ø 97�A���5/ � F ÿ F�áobB3;/�3;-��B3«bA�����A�2��68659±�21Uª�3�D�B3 ? -�/*6g3;-�/r/HÈ0� ? 3S�8/V68����3~�>/*�C¥'/ ? 3;�7¨2F_è�3�38���81�6obA�03g3;-��i3�38-��B3g3;-�/r�4�2��65689E�21Qª�3�9E6�0�8/V353�¨��db�b@¡�/H£A/*1D�_-�/*1���/g653;�2�53�3�br65/*/���¡�9±�2¶��B3;9 ? 68��97é2/��B3 3 Ü ) F Ø b2����65���B�E�65��9EéB/P3;-�/P�4�B��68659±�21�-����A6G38-�/�¶���b4�B¡����2�53ÖbB¥:38-�/�¡�9E6C3;�59E¶��0389�bA1~�8/c�B6�bA1��B¶��7¨g��/V�E�xF Ø bA����E�2�8�2/�65��9EéB/2¢�¡�/H£@9E�B3;9nbA1�6��2�8/S�*bA�5/~6897�A1�9�ª ? �2143*¢0¶��03\6�b���� ? -"b2¥!38-�/�����bA¶��2¶�97�E9�3�¨976g�2�E�5/c�2¡0¨ ? �E��6C3;/V�8/*¡��B3 ) 3;-��B3�38-�/r¡�9E6 ? �8/V���21 ? ¨�¶M/H3���/V/*1�3;-0/��4�2�068689E�21Qª03S�210¡38-�/g¶���b4�B¡����2�C3Äb2¥}38-�/~����b2ª��7/g976�1sb23<3;-��B3<1sbB3;9 ? /c�2¶0�E/2FKè�1��214¨�/V£2/*143c¢@¥.bA�Pª�1�9738/ )38-�/��4�B��68659±�21oª03S9E6�/HÈ@�>/ ? 38/*¡y3�b�¶0�8/c�BéQ¡sb��_1�¥.bA� 7 68�_a ? 9E/V1�38�7¨ ? ��b268/&3�b  FS©.-0/�0�8/*65/*1 ? /£b2¥>�~¡�9E�2¶��B389 ? 68��97é2/\�5/*1�¡0/*�86¸b2���T�21��2�7¨�3;9 ? 9�3�¨r�26865���D�@3;9�b21�9E1 ? bA�8�5/ ? 3c¢4�210¡9�3<9E6�3;-�976�B6868�0�D�0389�bA1=3;-��i3<���26��68/V¡�3�br¡�/*�597£A/g3;-�/����2�8�2�D/H3;/V�86�¥.bA�°bA���<�4�2��65689±�B1�0��b2ª��7/2FP²b���/H£A/*�V¢@¥.bA�<��ª0È@/*¡ 7 ¢@¶4¨��D�2é�9E1�� ) 68�ba ? 97/*143;��¨��±�2�5�A/2¢4�/ ? �21��2/V3�89E¡bB¥L38-�/�¡�9±�2¶��B3;9 ? 68��97é2/r�21�¡��8/ ? b�£A/V�g38-�/��4�2��65689E�21Q�0��b2ª��7/2F

 ^ ß

Page 153: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

0.005

0.006

0.007

0.008

0.009

-600 -400 -200 0 200 400 600

Pro

babi

lity

n

Gaussian FitExact

Ø 9E�A���5/ � F ÿ�½ Þ1bA�=���2�8976�bA1©b2¥M�21��2��¨:389 ? �2�:£2/*�568��6�1����=/*�89 ? �2�@¡�9E65�M/V�8659�bA1�����b2ª��7/*6T¡��0/3�b�653�b ? -��26C3;9 ? �*b2389�bA1¤bA1#38-�/�1�/V3���bA�8é¤bB¥T�c£db29E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA65689E10�A6*F

è�3�68-sbA�0�E¡��B�E6�bQ¶M/D1sb238/*¡­38-��B3#b2���&6C3�b ? -��26C3;9 ? � b:¡�/V�<976&1�b23�38-�/�68�2�D/D�26��659E�=���E/K�;�21�¡�bA�����2�EéS�*b:¡�/*�xF�©.-0/�5/c�26�bA1r¥.b2�b38-�9E6!976!3;-��B3b971�3;-�/ ? �265/�bB¥��_�;�210¡sbA����2�7é>¢�38-�/r����bA¶��2¶�9E�7973�¨=¥.bA�g�21����4�\�2�5¡#c5���=�q9E6g�2�7���c¨:6~��ª0È@/*¡ 7 ø�ù ë0â�Â*û Fè�1q3;-0/? �268/b2¥G���B1�¡��2� ÁÖö /*1�/V��¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? 6V¢43;-�/g-sbA���09E1��r����b2¶��2¶�97�E973�¨ 7 ? bA�5�8/*65�Zb21�¡�63�b��B1�0�����2�5¡dc5���=�¤bA1���¨�97¥b�/�653+�B�53bA1#3;-�/��nb �/*�_�B¡�9±�2¶��B3cFTè�¥��/&-��B���M/V1�3�b�653+�c¨¤b2138-�/��nb �/*���2¡�9±�B¶��B3c¢�3;-�/V1��B3�38-�/�1�/RÈ@3=�c£$bA9E¡�/V¡ ? ��bA68659E1��o�/q�2�5/�bA1­38-�/�-�97�A-�/*��B¡�9±�2¶��B3c¢@�21�¡#6�b�3;-�/S-�bA����971�������b2¶��2¶�97�E973�¨ 7 ? bA�5�8/*65�Zb21�¡�6\3�b���¡�b �_14���2�8¡�c5���=�GF©»b����Bé2/S/H£A/*�C¨�3;-�971�� ? bA1 ? �8/H3;/B¢�¥.bA�38-�/S�;�B1�¡sbA� Á ���2�Eé��_9�3;-#���0��bA¶��B¶�9E�7973�¨�¥.bA�

 ^ �

Page 154: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�B1��0�����2�5¡o-sbA�¾b2¥ 7 ¢��/r-���£2/2¢" 3   Ü N ^87 àl O ) N � F ^A^ O

�B1�¡G¢5 Ü ^_e 7 N Â_à 7 O ) N � F ^ ÿ O

áb23;/�38-��B3 ? bA�D���2�8/V¡�3�bU3;-�/#�8�21�¡sb2� Á �\�2�7éy� b:¡�/*�x¢K3;-0/#1�/V3=�b�21�¡��2� ÁCö /V1�/*�/V1�/*�5�2¨�¡��89�¥%3_9E6g�8/V�±�B3897£A/V�7¨�9E1�65/*1�65973;9�£A/�3�b�3;-�/&-sbA���09E1��=����b2¶��2¶�97�E973�¨2F�è�1o¥�� ? 3*¢Ý973_9E6971�¡�/V�M/V1�¡�/*143�bB¥ ) ¢K�_-�97�E/�3;-�/D�;�210¡sbA� Á ���2�EéU/V1�/*�5�2¨­¡0�897¥%3&6 ? �2�E/V6��79E1�/*�2�8��¨��_9738-) FP©.-�9E6<9E6�¶>/ ? �2��68/obA1 ? /S��3;�;��c5/ ? 3�bA�5¨=6C3+�c¨:61bA1��21��2¡09±�2¶��i3�9E1�6C3;/c�B¡�b2¥}-sbA����971���¢38-�/�¶�9±�B6S¥.bA��� b�£:9E1��#971����A9�£A/V1W¡�97�8/ ? 3;9nbA1U65�_9�3 ? -�/V6&3�bq38-�/*bA����bA689�3;/�¡�97�8/ ? 3;9nbA1GF©.-09E6_6;�2�=/�65�_9�3 ? -�971��D/Hµ}/ ? 3~�2�E6�b=� ?*? bA��143;6_¥.bA�\3;-0/&/V1�-��21 ? /*¡Q/*1�/V�8�2¨q¡�9768�>/*�5689�b21971�38-�/��b�210¡��2� ÁÖö /*1�/V�&�*b@¡0/*�<�26!bA����bA68/V¡­3�b�3;-�/D�;�21�¡�bA� Á �\�B�Eé��*b@¡0/*�]F�è�1W3;-0/�8�21�¡sb2� Á �\�2�7é ? �268/B¢f5 þ ë �26 7 þ  ¢��_-09E�E/.971�3;-�/g�b�21�¡��B� ÁCö /V1�/*� ? �B68/2¢f5 þ g Fk�h+¹ TVUXWU»g½cäUÂT¾ UXWUÂ�S����b�21�¡��B� ÁCö /V1�/*��3;�8�21�689�3;9nbA1�6�� b:¡�/V�>976�����bA¶��2¶��7¨�38-�/~659E�=���E/V653ÄbA1�/ ? b2���E¡ ? bA1 Á6C3;�5� ? 3r¥.bA��3;-�/�3�¨:�M/*b2¥�/*1�/V�8�2¨y65���8/*�2¡�9E10���/��2�5/ ? bA1�659E¡�/V�8971���F=è�1­�A/V1�/*�8�2�]¢!3;-0/-�bA����971��W�0��bA¶��B¶�9E�7973�¨�976�1sb23 ? bA1�6C3+�2143*¢.�21�¡�·:���2143;��� 9E1438/*�5¥'/V�8/V1 ? /Q/VµM/ ? 386 ? �21

 ^ p

Page 155: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

? -��21��A/q3;-�/q¡�9768�>/*�5689�b21��0��b2ª��7/�¥'��bA�÷�_-��B3��1b2���E¡�¶M/q/RÈ0�>/ ? 3;/V¡¬97¥g3;-0/�¡@¨@1��2� Á9 ? 6#���26�38�8����¨®653�b ? -��265389 ? Fñ²ob��/V£A/V�*¢�97¥r3;-0/W6C¨@6C3;/V� 976q9E�=�D/V�868/V¡¯9E1Ä��¶��i3;-G¢38-�/*1#¡0/ ? b2-�/*�5/*1 ? / ? �21�¡0/*6538��b�¨��214¨�·����21438���|97143;/*�C¥'/*�5/*1 ? /S/VµM/ ? 3;6*¢0�E/c�B¡�9E1��&¶�� ? é3�bo/V6868/V143;9±�B�E�7¨y6C3�b ? -��26C3;9 ? ¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? 6*F Ø ���538-�/*�5� b2�8/2¢b�_-�97�E/=� ? bA1�653;�2143�-sb2����9E10��0��bA¶��B¶�9E�7973�¨�976�1sb23<�A/*10/*�89 ? ¢���/�¶M/V�E97/V£A/.38-��B3<3;-�/g68���5/c�2¡09E1����_-�9 ? -�bA���<�21��2��¨�3;9 ? �2��*b:¡�/*����8/V¡�9 ? 3;6�9E6��2/*1�/V�89 ? F�©.-��B3�976*¢<�26�38-�/#����b2¶��2¶�97�E973�¨y¥.bA���y¡09±�2¶��i3;9 ? c5���=��B������bA� ? -�/*6  ¢038-�/�1�/V3g/V1�/*�5�2¨q¡��89�¥%3_�21�¡�68�0�8/c�B¡�9E1���971 ? �5/c�265/*6��26.��/V�E�]F

 ^ �

Page 156: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

b c dfehgjilk i

� j i}k�g�x kJð dyg�sbïÓi � e e k � dft c g �

| sKð k�d�g�s ��p d�v j k¡il� sK~�~ � tòs�dyg�s ��p

� d�gjil~ � � e e vzsKt�d�g�s ��p g � � k4k �

©.-09E6 ? -��2�038/*�b���5/*68/V143;6T�.�>/*�C3;���5¶��B3;9�£A/��*b@¡�/V�2¥.bA�G38-�/P£@97¶��;�i3;9�b21��2�2�0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1¡@¨@1��2�D9 ? 6�b2¥K9E1�/V�53g�4�26_-4¨:¡���bA�2/*1�-��B�E9E¡0/=NxÇ_�4²�l O ? bA�=���E/RÈ0/V6*F©.-�/����5/*¡�97686�b ? 9±� Á389�bA1q976.� b:¡�/*�7�E/V¡q�26g� Ø /*�5�D9�T¹bA�7¡�/*1�Ç_���E/=N Ø TrÇ O ����b ? /V686_¥'��bA���=¶�bA��1�¡ Á 653;�B3;/�5/*659E¡�971���bA1���3��1b Á ���2�8�2�=/V3;/V�.�ZbB3;/*14389±�2�M/*1�/V�8�2¨#65���5¥�� ? /DN Õ çm� O bA¶03;�29E1�/V¡#¶4¨q�c£ Á/V�;�2�29E1��«b�£A/V�P3;-�/_²Ul®£@97¶��;�i3;9�b21��2�:653+�i3;/£b2¥M9E143;/V�8/V653c¢A3�br��65/*�59E/*6¸bB¥Zb21�/ Á ���2�;�B�D/H3;/*�

Â�ÿ2ë

Page 157: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

/RÈ@973 ? -��21�1�/V�E6©b2¶03+�2971�/*¡­¶�¨W�c£A/V�;�2�29E1��Rb�£2/*��38-�/�²Ul���b�£:9E¶0�;�B389�bA1��B�P653+�i3;/�b2¥\9E1 Á38/*�5/*653*F�©.-�976�� b:¡�/*�9E6��B�����E97/*¡�3�bU³~�;² Ø ¢K¥.bA�&�_-�9 ? -��U-�9E�2-J·:���2�E9�3�¨��2¶°971�97389�b97143;/*�8� ? 389�bA1U��b238/*143;9E�2�K976���£B�297�±�2¶0�E/2F�è�1y���2�C3;9 ? ���E�2�*¢}�/�¥.b ? ��6«bA1U3;-0/#n þ n à�Â

38�;�2106897389�bA1r¥.bA�K38-�/\¶�bA��1�¡�6C3+�B38/*6gN ÂcëAëAë O ¢ÝN ^ ë2ëAë O ¢�N ^ Â�Â�ë O ¢�N ÿAë2ëAë O �B1�¡�N ÿ�Â�Â�ë O FbÃW/? bA10ª��5�×3;-�/�/HÈ@�M/V�897�D/V1�3;�2��bA¶�68/V�5£B�B389�bA1=3;-��B3<3;-0/S����b:¡�� ? 3\² Ø 3;/V1�¡�6<3�b ? bA�D/b2µ�i3r38-�/=-�9E�A-0/*653�� ?V? /*656897¶��E/ î�Á 653;�B3;/B¢��_-09 ? -�976 î Ü Â�ÿ ¥.bA��3;-�976r6C¨:653;/V�QF#©.-09E6r9E1 Á¡09 ? �i3;/*6_��6C3;��bA1��=�21��A�0�±�2���21�9E6�b23;��bA�4¨�971�3;-�/�³��;² Ø 971�38/*�8� ? 389�bA1���b238/*143;9E�2�M�_-�9 ? -? bA�����7/*6���b�� Á cP�B1�¡�-�9E�A- Á cT² Ø 653;�B3;/V6*FP©.-�/_¶��B689 ? �=/ ? -��B1�9E65�Ê¥.bA�T38-�9E6P-�97�A- Á cT�0�8/V¥ Á/V�8/V1 ? /r9E6_¡�/H3;/*�5�D971�/*¡q3�b�¶>/�3;-�/r68���0���8/V68689nbA1=bB¥K3;-0/r�nb�� Á c\/HÈ@973 ? -��2101�/*�76��B�89E659E1��¥'��bA�ñ-09E�A-���¨*bA6 ? 9E�E�E�B3�b2�5¨=��b�� Á c1bA�@3;�dbA971������c£A/V¥'�01 ? 389�bA1�6VFÃW/��2�E6�b�bA¶�65/*�5£2/*¡�3;-��B338-�/�3+�B9E�E6�b2¥_3;-�/#¶�bA��10¡ Á 6C3+�B38/��\�c£A/H¥'��1 ? 3;9�b21�6*¢9E1�3;-0/#9E1�1�/V���\�B�E���5/*�A9nbA1�b2¥_3;-0/97143;/*�8� ? 389�bA1=��b23;/V1�389±�2�x¢��4�c£A/~38-�/~�D�29E1 ? b21�38�897¶��03;9nbA1�3�b�38-�/~���5/*¡�97686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1=�;�B38/2¢971�¡�9 ? �B389E1��\38-��B3�3;-�/�£:9E¶��8�B3;9nbA1��2�A�0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1�����b ? /*656L976�¡0��/3�bg38��1�1�/V�E9E10�~�210¡976L38-�/*�5/V¥.bA�5/.�~�����5/*��¨�·����21438���m/Hµ}/ ? 3cFK©.-�/ ? �B� ? �0�±�B389�bA1�6L�2�76�b ? bA10ª��5�n38-�/\6538��bA10�n Á ¡�/*�>/*1�¡0/*1 ? /#b2¥K38-�/��0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1q�8�B3;/V6*¢M�26g�/*�7���26�38-�/&6C3+�2¶09E�E9 Ä �B389�bA1¤bB¥K3;-0/? bA�=���E/RÈ�3;-��B3¹b ?V? ���S�_-0/*1�/*1�/V�8�2¨y976S���±� ? /*¡y971�3�b#3;-�/�² Ø ¶>/*10¡�9E1��q�*b@¡0/2F Ø bA�38-�/�N Â�ëAë2ë O �21�¡�N ^ Â2Âcë O 653+�i3;/*6V¢���/�bA¶03+�B9E1q�;�B38/*6_��/V�E�b¶>/*��b�� Â2â+ßAëAë 65/ ?po ý ¢��_-�9 ? -976 ? bA1�68976538/*143\�_9738-�3;-0/�bA¶�65/*�5£B�B389�bA1�¶�¨rqQ97�E�E/V� ù �2ß ¢ �A� û 38-��B3�38-�/~£:9E¶0�;�B389�bA1��B�>�0�8/ Á¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1o�;�B38/*6r�2�8/�3�bhbq65��b��Ê3�bq¶M/��=/c�265���8/V¡GF�©.-�/QN ^ ë2ëAë O 6C3+�B38/=¡�b@/V6r�297£A/

Â�ÿbÂ

Page 158: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�q�=/c�265���;�2¶0�E/��;�B38/2¢��_973;-W� ? bA�=���038/*¡­¡0/ ? �c¨�9E143�b�38-�/ î Ü Â�ÿ /RÈ@973 ? -��21�10/*�Äb2¥Â���â+ëAëAë 65/ ? o ý F©.-�/�N ÿAëAë2ë O 653+�i3;/r�A97£2/*6�� ? bA�8�5/*68��bA1�¡09E1��D�;�B38/!bB¥ ^ ëAë@â+ëAëAë 65/ ? o ý ¢971U�db�b@¡U�B�A�8/V/*�=/*143��_9738-�3;-�/�b�£A/V�;�2�7�K¡�97686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1��8�B3;/©b2¥ ^ �2ë0â+ë2ëAë 68/ ? o ý F&©.-0/N ÿ�Â2Â�ë O �;�i3;/�976�68�nb���/V�*¢P�_9738-J�o£B�2�E��/ b2¥  ^ â+ë2ëAë 68/ ?po ý FUï-�9E�7/=38-�9E6��;�B38/�68/V/*�=66�bA�=/V�_-��B3_65���B�E�]¢��A9�£A/V1q38-��B3\38-�/��E9�¥'/V389E�=/bB¥�38-�/=N ÿbÂ2Â�ë O 653+�i3;/S���26.�D/*�268�0�8/*¡#3�bb21��7¨q¶>/&3��_9 ? /��B6��nbA1����B6�3;-��B3ybB¥T3;-�/�N ÿAë2ëAë O 653;�B3;/B¢M3;-09E6g�;�B38/��21�¡o�2�E�ÖbA�0���8�B3;/V6�B�8/��_9738-�9E1q�21"bA�5¡�/*��b2¥L�D�2�A1�9�3;��¡�/«bB¥L38-�/��D/*�268���5/*¡��;�B38/*6VF�6h�� � srtPævuxwUäU»UtT¾�u#s©.-0/S6538��¡0¨*b2¥!3;-0/�£:9E¶��8�B3;9nbA1��2���0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1*b2¥G£B�21D¡�/*�Ã��A�B�E6<�21�¡�-4¨:¡���bA�A/*1fy¶�bA1�¡0/*¡ ? bA�=���E/RÈ0/V6�-��B6&¶>/*/V1J�21�� ? 3;9�£A/�ª�/*�7¡·b2¥�/HÈ@�>/*�897�D/V143+�2�<�21�¡�3;-�/ubA�8/H3;9 ? �2��5/*65/c�2� ? -Æ¥.bA�D3;-�/U���B653#3��/*143�¨Åª�£2/y¨2/c�2�56*F��~9E¶��8�B3;9nbA1��2�_���5/*¡�97686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1G¢_�B6q��=/ ? -��21�9E65�Û¥.bA� ? bA14£A/V�5389E1��g£@97¶��;�i3;9�b21��2�A/V1�/*�5�2¨r9E143�bg3;�;�B1�68�E�B3;9nbA1��2�2�21�¡���b23+�i3;9�b21��2�/V1�/*�5�2¨A¢��D�c¨®���E��¨®�21Ä97�D��bA�C3+�2143#��bA�E/U971Æ�5/*�E�iÈ0�B3;9nbA1¯¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? 6#971Ä�A�268/V6o�210¡�79E·���97¡�6*¢@6�bD���0��bA�>/*�_��1�¡0/*�86C3+�210¡�9E1��*b2¥L973_976.9E�=�ZbA�C3+�2143*F

�hb2�D/¸b2¥:3;-0/P� bA6C3b/HÈ:3;/V1�689�£A/V�7¨�6538��¡�97/*¡ ? bA�=���7/HÈ@/*6��2�5/T3;-�/�9E10/*�53G�4�26b-4¨@¡0��bA�A/V1-��2�E97¡�/ ? bA�=���E/RÈ0/V6�N�Çg�4²Ul O F@©.-�/V68/��2�5/~3;-0/~6897�D�0�E/*6C3 ? bA�D�0�E/HÈ@/V6�_-�9 ? - ? �21�-���£2/¶�b238-�£:9E¶��8�B3;9nbA1D3�b���b23;�B3;9nbA1��B1�¡�£:9E¶��8�B3;9nbA1D3�b�3;�8�21�68�E�B3;9nbA1�/V1�/*�5�2¨=3;�;�B1�65¥'/V�*F Ø ���Fy

Â�ÿ ^

Page 159: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

38-�/*�5� b2�8/2¢�38-�/�-4¨@¡0��bA�A/V1o-��B�E9E¡0/ ? bA�=���7/HÈ@/*6_-��c£A/�3;-0/r97143;/*�5/*6C3;9E10�=�0��bA�>/*�C3�¨#3;-��B338-�/V¨­3;/*10¡°3�bU���8/V¡�9E656�b ? 9E�B3;/��_9�3;-�3;-0/#���iÈ@97�����÷�2�E�nb ���2¶��7/���b23+�B389�bA1��2�/V1�/*�5�2¨AF©.-09E6_9E6_¡���/�3�b�3;-0/&�5/*�±�i3;97£2/*��¨��±�B�8�A/���b23+�B389�bA1��2� ? bA1�653;�2143;6ob2¥K38-�/r²�lÊ¡�9±�B3�bA�=9 ? 6V¢971 ? b21�38�;�26C3�3�b�38-�/qÇg�pl Ó ? b2�D���7/HÈ@/*6V¢P�_-�9 ? -J3;/V1�¡J3�bU���5/*¡�97686�b ? 9±�B38/��_9738-J-�9E�A-38�;�21068�±�i3;9�b21��2�./*10/*�8�B¨ ù �4ÿBû FÆ©.-�9E6D���B3838/*�51Å9E6D� ? �E�268659 ? /HÈ0�2�=���E/¾b2¥�38-�/�çT�_9E10��*bA�=/*143;�0�ì�4�2���±�c� ù �bÂVû ¢L�_-09 ? -­¶��2689 ? �2�7�7¨�6C3+�B38/*6�3;-��i3�/V1�/*�5�2¨y9E1�6�bA�=/=9E1�9�3;9±�B�¡�bA1sbA�<653;�B3;/g9E6�3;�8�21�65¥'/V�8�5/*¡����5/V¥'/V�8/*14389±�2�7�7¨�3�br38-�/�ª�1��2�>� ?*? /*�03�bA��6C3+�B38/�N.bA�6C3+�B38/*6 O�_9�3;-¬38-�/o�7/c�26C3�1sb:¡��2� ? -��2�8� ? 38/*�VFÛ©.-�9E6D���Bé2/*6�68/*1068/U68971 ? /Q-�9E�2-��7¨öbA6 ? 97�E�±�i3�bA�C¨���c£A/H¥'��1 ? 389�bA106�38/*1�¡y3�b#-���£2/��E97353;�7/ ? bA�����79E1����_9�3;-U3;-0/�9E1�9�3;9±�B��6C3+�B38/2F&³~1y/*·���9�£zy�B�E/*143�¥.bA�5�����E�B3;9nbA1=b2¥<3;-09E6S���59E1 ? 9E���7/�9E6�3;-��B3�/V1�/*�5�2¨]{{b��_6�9E143�b�38-�/�653;�B3;/��_-�9 ? -�=9E109E�=9 Ä /V6\3;-�/�� bA�=/*1438����3;�8�21�65¥'/V�*FS©.-0/�²�lm¡�9±�B3�bA�=9 ? 6_-��c£2/��8/*�E�B3;9�£A/V�7¨q�±�B�8�A/��b23+�i3;9�b21��2�</*1�/V�8�2¨J�A�2��6*¢�6�b��=9E109E�=9 Ä 971��#3;-�/#1�b@¡��B� ? -��2�8� ? 38/*��b2¥_3;-0/¤bA�03;�$bA9E1�����c£A/V6.�D/*�21�6<���±� ? 9E1���3;-0/~/HÈ ? /*686./V1�/*�5�2¨D9E143�b&��b23;�B3;9nbA1GF�©.-�/|l Ó ¡�9±�B3�bA�=9 ? 6P-���£2/��� ? -­65���2�7�E/V����b23;�B3;9nbA1��2�P/V1�/*�5�2¨��4�2��6V¢K6�bQ�D971�9E�=9 Ä 9E1��=3;-�/D1sb:¡��2� ? -��2�8� ? 38/*��b2¥38-�/¹bA�038�dbA9E10���\�c£A/V6~�=/c�2106g�0�±� ? 9E1���38-�/�/HÈ ? /V686~/V1�/*�5�2¨#971�3�b�3;�;�B1�68�E�B3;9nbA1GF

³�1sb23;-0/*�K¥'/*�B3;���5/1b2¥�38-�/\Ç_�4²Ul ? b2�D���7/HÈ@/*6K9E6b3;-��B3L3;-�/V9E�L���8/V¡�9E656�b ? 9±�i3;9�b21&�8�B3;/V6�B�8/S���B�53;9 ? ���E�2�8��¨�68�nb�� ù ��� ¢ ���iû ¢0�D�2é�9E10��973¡�9Aa ? ���733�b�� ?V? ���8�B3;/V�7¨ ? bA�=���038/~3;-0/*9E��8�B3;/V6*FSè�1y�B1�/c�2�5�7¨q3;-0/&bA�5/V3;9 ? �2��6538��¡0¨2¢!²��0386�bA1 ù �`�Bû �B353;/*�=�038/*¡o3�b ? �2� ? ���E�B3;/�3;-0/£:97¶��;�B389�bA1��2��0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1­�;�B38/*6�b2¥g³~�8²SÞ��\¥.bA��n Ñ�} t Ü Â ¶�bA��10¡_y�6C3+�B38/*6*¢�¶��@3

Â�ÿ2ÿ

Page 160: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

-09E6��5/*65���7386D�/*�8/UbBµ�¶4¨¬�B3��7/c�26C3�3���b�bA�8¡0/*�86�b2¥����B�A1�9738��¡�/ ù � p û FÄè�1¯�21sb238-�/*�/*�2�8��¨�6C3;��¡0¨2¢0²��2�E¶>/*�5653;�2¡03 ù � p û �*b@¡�/V�E�7/*¡�3;-0/�N�² Ø O Ó ¡09E�=/*���26<�21DÇg�A² Ø ? bA�=���7/HÈ971öbA�8¡�/V��3�b ? �B� ? �0�±�B38/�3;-�/#���5/*¡�97686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1J�8�B3;/V6*F�²ob��/V£A/V�*¢\9�3�9E6�é�1sb��_1�3;-��B3? bA�=���E/RÈ0/V6T�_9738-�-�9E�A-0/*�T¡�/V�A�8/V/*6Äb2¥Ý¥'�8/V/*¡sbA��¢A65� ? -��26K³~�P~R² Ø ¢ÝN�² Ø O Ó ¢��21�¡�á Ó ² Ø ¢-���£2/Q�0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1°�8�B3;/V6��_-09 ? -Å�B�8/#3�¨:��9 ? �2�E��¨�68/H£A/V�;�2�bA�8¡0/*�86�b2¥~���B�A1�9738��¡�/¥��B653;/V��3;-��21�3;-�/SÇg�4² Ø ? b2�D���7/HÈ@/*6 ù ����û ¢06�b�9�3\9E61sb23 ? �E/*�2�38-��B3\�*b:¡�/*�7�E9E10��N�² Ø O Ó�B6��B1QÇ_�4² Ø ? bA�=���E/RÈ#9E6_� ?*? �0�;�B38/2F

�S1�/Ub2¥�38-�/U� b2653 ? bA�D�*bA1���¨�653;�0¡�9E/V¡ÄÇ_�4²Ul ? bA�=���7/HÈ@/*6#976�³~�8² Ø F\³��;² ض�bA��10¡_y�6C3+�B38/*6P-��c£A/_¶>/*/V1D6C¨@1438-�/*659 Ä /V¡�����3�b ù �4ßiû n Ñ�� Ü � ¢2�_-�97�E/\�0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1�8�B3;/V6�-��c£A/�¶M/V/*1°6538��¡�9E/V¡­¥.bA� ù ��� ¢ �4ß ¢ �A� û n Ñ�� Ü Â�à¯ÿ F�©.-�/��0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1�8�B3;/V6�68-sb��¦�#6538��bA10�Q¡�/V�M/V1�¡�/V1 ? / bA1�n Ñ�� F Ø �0�53;-0/*�8�*bA�5/2¢!3;-�/�¶�bA��1�¡fy�653;�B3;/V6¹b2¥³��;² Ø �2�8/~689E�21�97ª ? �2143;��¨�653+�B¶�9E�79 Ä /V¡D�_-�/V1q/*1�/V�8�2¨D9E6���±� ? /*¡�97143�b�38-�/�² Ø ¶M/V1�¡�9E10��*b:¡�/2FU©.-�/6n Ñ�� Ü Â �8�B3;/V6��/*�8/#3�bhb�65��b��INF� ÂAâ+ßAëAë 6 o ý O 3�bU¶>/�bA¶068/*�C£A/V¡¬9E1�=/c�B68���5/*�=/*143;6&¶�¨�qQ97�E�7/*� ù �2ßBû F��hbA�=/ b2¥3;-�/�n Ñ�� Ü ^ �;�B38/*6r��/V�8/��=/c�B68���8�2¶��E/ù �A�iû ¢�38-sbA���A-�3;-�/Q�;�B38/*6���/V�8/�6C3;97�E��3�bhbW68��b���¥.b2�D�y£B�2�E��/q3�bW¶M/Q�265689E�21�/*¡GF Ø bA�n Ñ�� Ü ÿ 38-�/��8�B3;/V6S�2�5/&65�ba ? 97/*143;��¨Q-09E�A-�3�b ? �2� ? ���±�i3;/&�D��bB3+�B389�bA1��B�!¡�9E6C3;�897¶��0389�bA1¥.b2�\3;-�/����5/*¡�97686�b ? 9E�B3;9nbA1 ù ���2û F

©.-�/Sª��8653g�i383;/V�D�@3�3�b��*b:¡�/*�Ý3;-�/��0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1 b2¥�³~�8² Ø £:9±��� ? bA�=���E/H3;/*��¨�B¶�9E1�9�3;9nbr�*b:¡�/*�Ý�\�B6\¡sbA1�/~9E1�Ç_/V¥ÖF �Aÿ ¶4¨r��� ? -�� ? -�/V1�é$b�¢��:38/*���B1sb�£M¢QT��59E�dbA�5/*1�é�b�¢

Â�ÿp�

Page 161: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�B1�¡oág/*���0é:-09E1GF���� ? -�� ? -�/*1�é�b#/V3��2�xF<�*b:¡�/*�G38-�/����8/V¡�9E656�b ? 9±�i3;9�b21��0��b ? /*656��0689E10���68/V�D9�y�/*�=��97�89 ? �2�\³��;² ØÊÕ ç�� b2¶03+�2971�/*¡���68971��­38-�/o¡�9E�B3�b2�D9 ? 6Fy�9E1_y�� b2�E/ ? ���E/D�2�_y�0��b4� ? -}F�ï-�9E�7/�3;-�/V9E���2���0��b4� ? - ? b210ª��8�=/*¡U38-�/�����bA�>/*1068973�¨Rb2¥38-�/=² Ø 3�b ? bA�D/bBµQ��b23+�i3;9�b21��2�E��¨�-�b23��0�ZbA1����8/V¡�9E656�b ? 9±�i3;9�b21G¢��21�¡�38-�/g653+�B¶�9E�79 Ä �i3;9�b21�b2¥G3;-0/~¶�bA��1�¡_y6C3+�B38/*6��_-�/*1W/*1�/V�8�2¨�976r�0�±� ? /*¡�9E143�b�² Ø ¶>/*1�¡�971���¢»b23;-0/*��¥'/c�B38���8/V6�bB¥�3;-0/=�*b:¡�/*�¡09E¡o1�b23��2�2�8/*/r��/V�E���_973;-Q/HÈ@�>/*�897�D/V143cF Ø 97�86C3yb2¥P�2�E�x¢>/RÈ@�M/V�89E�=/*143;�2�E��¨q973�-��26~¶>/*/V1b2¶�68/V�5£A/V¡o3;-��B3�38-�/���b23;�B3;9nbA1��2�}¡�9E6C3;�897¶��0389�bA1"b2¥L����b:¡�� ? 3S² Ø ¡0/ ? �c¨:6S�*bA�8/«b2�g�7/*656/RÈ@�ZbA10/*143;9E�2�E��¨�¥'��bA�¤38-�/o-09E�A-�/V653�� ?*? /*65689E¶0�E/�c�y�653;�B3;/B¢��_-�9 ? -Å9E6 î Ü Âcÿ ¥.bA�*bA���6C¨:653;/V�Q¢>�_-�9E�7/�Ç_/V¥ÖF �4ÿ ���8/V¡�9 ? 3;/V¡y�D¶�97� b:¡��2�!¡�976538�89E¶0�03;9nbA1GFU�@/ ? bA10¡��7¨2¢M3;-0/ ? b2�dy�0�03;/V¡­�E9�¥'/V389E�=/*6~�/*�5/��A/V1�/*�8�2�E��¨y�21¬bA�8¡�/V��bB¥\�D�2�A1�9�3;��¡�/�3�bhb���b���F Ø 9E1��B�E�7¨2¢}3;-0/�nb���/V653S/V1�/*�5�2¨Q¶ZbA�01�¡_y�6C3+�B38/&¥.bA��n Ü ÿ bB¥�³~�;² Ø 976����5/*¡�9 ? 38/*¡�3�bD-��c£A/��D-�9E�A-0/*653� ?*? /V68659E¶��7/�/HÈ@9�3 ? -��B1�1�/*� ? bA�5�8/V68��bA1�¡�971��Q3�b î Ü Â ^ Fq©.-���6*¢�Ç_/V¥ÖF �4ÿ ���8/V¡�9 ? 3;6��65��¡�¡�/V1G¢\659E�A1�9�ª ? �B1�3�¡0��bA�°9E1J38-�/q���8/V¡�9E656�b ? 9±�i3;9�b21J�;�B38/�¥'��bA��n Ü ^ 3�b�n Ü ÿ ¢�5/*65���7389E1���¥'��bA�å3;-�/ ? ��bA659E1�� b2¥�3;-�/ î Ü Â�ÿ ? -��B1�1�/*�xF�çKÈ0�>/*�59E�=/*143+�B�E�7¨2¢ î Ü Â�ÿ 9E6é�1sb��_1�3�b��8/V���2971¤bA�>/*1Q�2�E�>3;-�/�����¨#38-���b2���A-�n Ü � F /V68��9�3;/q3;-�/V9E�=¡�/Vª ? 9E/V1 ? 97/*6*¢\38-�/��8/ ? /*143���bA�8é°¶4¨���� ? -�� ? -�/*1�é�bJ/V3��2�]F�¢\�210¡38-�/#/c�B�8�7¨���bA�8éW¶�¨�²��0386�bA1��210¡�²��2�E¶>/*�5653;�2¡03�N��21�¡�b238-�/*�56*¢<68/*/qÇ_/V¥'6VF O �2�8/q�B�E�97�D��bA�C3+�2143c¢P¶>/ ? �2��65/�38-�/V¨J97�E�7��6538�;�B38/D3;-0/�¡09Aa ? ����3�¨J9E1 ? bA�=���03;971���3;-0/��8�B3;/V6�b2¥38-�/DÇg�4²Ul ? bA�=���E/RÈ@/*6*F�©.-�/D65��b��_1�/V686©bB¥�3;-0/D�8�B3;/V6&�D�2é2/V6&9�3r1�/ ? /*6868�2�5¨�3�b���65/

Â�ÿ��

Page 162: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�y�8/V�±�B3897£2/*�7¨­-�9E�2-�·����2�7973�¨��2¶¬971�97389�b���b23;/V143;9±�B�]¢<9E1öbA�8¡0/*��3�b¬bA¶03+�B9E1°�8/*�26�bA1��2¶��E/�B�A�8/V/*�=/*143��_9738-J/HÈ@�>/*�897�D/V143cFy©.-�9E6&�\�26�659E�=���7¨y1�b23��c£B�29E�E�2¶��E/=�B3�3;-�/�389E�=/D3�b²g�03;6�bA1G¢Ý²��2�E¶>/*�5653+�B¡03c¢sb2�./V£A/V1�3�b#��� ? -�� ? -0/*1�é�b�/V3g�2�xF�²��0386�bA1q-��B6g659E1 ? /�¡�/V£2/*�Cyb2�M/V¡��21D� ?V? ���8�B3;/��2¶=9E1�9�3;9�b~�Zb238/*143;9E�2��¥.bA��³~�8² Ø ù �Bëiû N'38-�/�² ß N � ¢ ÿ ¢ ^ O �ZbB3;/*14389±�2� O ¢�_-09 ? -�9E6./*6568/V1�389±�2�7�7¨��=65/*�897/*6�b2¥�3��1b[y����2�8�2�=/V3;/V�*¢�n Ñ�� y�¡�/V�M/V1�¡�/*143��ZbB3;/*14389±�2�76*F

�S1�/�b2¥M��6�Nãª�F=T�F�²&F O ¢4�A/V1�/*�8�B3;/V¡���-�97�A-�·����2�7973�¨��B¶=971�97389�bS��b238/*143;9E�2�@¥.bA�P³��;² Ø�0689E10�o3;-�/#Þ.Þ�� N�© O �=/V38-sb@¡��21�¡J¶��2659E6&68/V386�¡�/V£2/*�nbA�M/V¡°¶�¨ ��1�1�971����B1�¡ ? bpy��bA�5é2/*�56 ù � ^ ¢ �Bÿ ¢ �p�iû N��o� b2�8/=¡�/V3;�29E�7/*¡�¡�976 ? ��68659�bA1 ? �21�¶>/�¥.bA��1�¡­9E1JÇ_/V¥ÖF �`� O F©.-09E6q�ZbB3;/*14389±�2�S/V1�/*�5�2¨¯68�0�5¥�� ? /ÅN Õ çm� O 976�1�b23��c£A/*�8�2�A/V¡ãb�£A/V��38-�/U£@97¶��;�i3;9�b21��2�6C3+�B38/*6¸b2¥M² Ø ¢2¶��@3P9E6T�8�B3;-0/*�P�~38-��8/V/8y�¡09E�=/*1�659�bA1��B�@��b23;/V143;9±�B�0�A9�£A/*1�971�3;/V�8�=6¸b2¥�3;-0/6C3+�210¡��2�8¡#�A� ? bA¶�9 ? b�bA�8¡09E1��B38/*6Pb2¥Ý³~�8² Ø Fi©.-�/.�����5�Zb268/ab2¥�38-�9E6L6538��¡0¨�976L3�bS¡�/V£2/*�nbA����*b:¡�/*��¥.b2��3;-�/#�0�8/*¡09E686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1·b2¥SÇ_�4²Ul ? bA�=���7/HÈ@/*6��_-�9 ? -G¢<9E1 ? b21[c5��1 ? 3;9�b21�_9�3;-�38-�/��2¶q9E1�9�3;9nb�³~�8² Ø ��b23;/V143;9±�B�}����b £:97¡�/*¡q¶4¨�ª�FGT�F�²&¢ ? �21q·����2�E9�3+�B3897£2/*�7¨D�210¡·����B1�38973;�B3;9�£A/*��¨����8/V¡�9 ? 3.�r1:�0��¶M/V�ab2¥!éB/V¨=¥'/c�B38���8/V6ab2¥G38-�/S³��;² Ø ���8/V¡�9E656�b ? 9E�B3;9nbA1GF

©.-�/����5/*¡�97686�b ? 9±�B389�bA1U976S� b:¡�/V�E�E/V¡U�26�� Ø /*�5�D9/T¹bA�7¡�/*1yÇ_���7/qN Ø T�Ç O ����b ? /*656¥'��bA�|��¶�bA��10¡_y�6C3+�B38/��8/*659E¡�971��#bA1�� Õ çm�#�_9�3;-�38-�/�³~�8² Ø £B�21#¡�/*�\í�A�2�76\6538�8/H3 ? -�B1�¡�² Ø ��b23;�B3;9nbA1��26&38-�/�65��b��`£B�2�59±�2¶��7/*6V¢�3�b=bA�038�dbA971��Q�0��b:¡�� ? 3&653;�B3;/V6��8/V6897¡�9E1��b21 Õ çm�M´�6&�_973;-�3;-�/=³~�8² Ø 653;�5/V3 ? -°�26r38-�/�b21��7¨y65��b��`£B�2�89E�2¶��7/2F�©.-�976��B������bA� ? -9714£dbA��£A/*6=��¡�9E�2¶��B389 ? 68/*���2�;�B389�bA1�bB¥�38-�/�¥��2653=² Ø £:9E¶��8�B3;9nbA1­¥'��b2�÷3;-0/¤b23;-�/V� ? bpy

Â�ÿ2ß

Page 163: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

b2�8¡�971��B3;/V6«b2¥<3;-�/�³~�8² Ø ? b2�D���7/HÈMF�©.-�/��8�B3;/V6&�B�8/�68�_a ? 9E/V1�38�7¨U65��b��`6�b��26�3�bq¶M/971�¡�9 ? �B3897£A/�b2¥S���5/*�E�B3;9�£A/*��¨W�/c�BéJ9E143;/V�;� ? 3;9�b21J�Zb238/*143;9E�2�]F�©.-���6*¢\���M/V�53;�0�8¶��B3897£2/6 ? -�/*�=/2¢�9xF�/BF Ø TrÇ�¢@65-sbA���7¡q¶M/S38-�/�����b2�M/V�.�2������b4� ? -#3�b�38-�9E6�����bA¶0�E/*��FTè�3_65-sbA���7¡¶>/./*�=��-��B689 Ä /*¡�-�/V�8/.3;-��i3T3;-�976P� b:¡�/V�09E6P1�b23P�8/V6538�89 ? 3;/V¡=3�b�³~�;² Ø ¢A¶��@3��;�B38-�/*���214¨Ç_�4²Ul ? bA�=���E/RÈ�¥.bA�\�_-09 ? -Q��38-��8/V/8y�¡09E�=/*1�659�bA1��B� Õ çm��9E6_�c£B�297�±�2¶��7/2F38-�9E6 ? -��2�03;/V��9E6obA�8�4�B1�9 Ä /*¡U�26�¥.bA�E�nb �_6��_è�1��:/ ? 389�bA1 � F ^ �/�¡�/V6 ? �59E¶>/�9E1o¡�/V3;�29E�

b2����·����2143;���«�*b:¡�/*��¥.b2��3;-�/q���5/*¡�97686�b ? 9E�B3;9nbA1J¡0¨:1��2�=9 ? 6�b2¥S³��;² Ø FTè�1N�@/ ? 3;9�b21� F ÿ �/����8/V68/V1�3�38-�/��8/V68����3;6��B1�¡U¡�9E6 ? ��65689nbA1GF�í/��21��2��¨ Ä /�3;-0/��8/*65���7386�bA¶03;�29E10/*¡G¢? bA�=���2�8971���3;-�/V�å�_973;-q�_-��B3�9E6gé�1sb��_1�/HÈ@�>/*�59E�=/*143+�2�7�7¨2¢Ý�21�¡��B�E6�bD�2¡�¡0�8/*656~6�bA�D/1����=/*�59 ? �2�.9E6568��/V6�9E14£$bA�7£2/*¡¬971 ? bA�=���03;971��y3;-�/����8/V¡�9E656�b ? 9E�B3;9nbA1°�;�B38/*6*F Ø 9E1��B�E�7¨2¢�/ ? bA1 ? �7��¡�/&9E1]�:/ ? 389�bA1 � F � �_9738-U�D65���D�D�2�C¨"b2¥°bA���g���B9E1��8/*65���7386��21�¡o¡�9E6 ? ��656¥'�@3;���5/r�5/*65/c�2� ? -GF�6hB� É�� À � uxw À ½³��E� ? �2� ? ���±�B389�bA106S��/V�8/�¡sb21�/D971­��¡�9E�=/*10689�b21��E/V686�65¨:6538/*� b2¥.��10973;6��_9738-­���8/H¥'/*�Fy/V1 ? /~���26561b2¥  �0F���Fv�G¢0�&�8/V¥'/V�8/V1 ? /S�7/*1��B3;-�b2¥ Â��³&¢��21�¡����8/H¥'/*�8/V1 ? /��\�c£A/V1�����¶>/*�bB¥ ÂAâ+ë2ëAë ? � o ý Fx�@�0¶�68/ ? 3;9nbA1 ^ F  ���8/V68/V1�386�3;-0/�²��2�D97�73�bA1�9±�B1��db�£A/V�81�971��Q38-�/D¡@¨zy1��2�D9 ? 6�b2¥G3;-0/S³~�8² Ø ? b2�D���7/HÈMF��@�0¶�68/ ? 3;9nbA1 ^ F ^ ���5/*68/V143;6.3;-�/~¡�9±�2¶��B3;9 ? �B������bA� ? -

Â�ÿA�

Page 164: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�068/*¡q3�b ? bA�=���03;/�3;-�/�¶�bA��1�¡fy�653;�B3;/V6£b2¥�9E143;/V�8/V653_9E1�38-�9E6 ? -��2�038/*�*F��@�0¶�68/ ? 3;9nbA1 ^ F ÿ�0�8/*65/*143;6S38-�/��=/V38-sb:¡Q3�b�¡�/V38/*�8�=9E10/r38-�/©bA�@3;�dbA971��=653+�i3;/*6VF��@�0¶�68/ ? 3;9nbA1 ^ F � �A9�£A/V638-�/ Ø T�Ç�¥.bA�8�����±��¥.bA��3;-�/����5/*¡�97686�b ? 9E�B3;9nbA1��;�B38/*6=9E143�b�3;-�/q£B�2�89nbA��6=/HÈ@973 ? -��21fy10/*�E6VF Ø 971��2�7�7¨A¢��@��¶�65/ ? 389�bA1 ^ F � ���5/*68/V143;6��q68/V�D9�yÖ�21��2�7¨�3;9 ? �2���0��b4� ? -�3�b�/V£B�2�7���B3;/38-�/ Ø T�Ǭ¥.bA�5�����±����659E1��r3;-�/_ï9E�21�/*��3;�8�21�65¥.b2�8��FK©.-�/������8��bA65/ob2¥}3;-�976�B������bA� ? -976�3�bU65�������7/*�=/*143�3;-�/q¡�97�8/ ? 3 ? �2� ? ���E�B3;9nbA1�6V¢T9E1öbA�5¡�/*��3�b ? 9E� ? ����£2/*143=1����D/V�89 ? �2�¡09Aa ? ����3;97/*6�2686�b ? 9±�B38/*¡��_9738-�/HÈ:38�;� ? 3;9E10��68�nb �¯�8�B3;/V6�¥'��b2�ê-09E�A-���¨�bA6 ? 9E�7�±�B3�bA�5¨�97143;/8y�2�;�2�76*F�(�%���NÌ ø¡ù���� Ï����Ný¡ b¢¤£���¥�£ÃW/�¡�/Vª�1�/�¦y3�b�¡�/V1sb23;/&���8/*¡0� ? /V¡����B686*¢Ý�B1�¡Q65/V3X¦¨§ Ü ¦ Ñ�� ¢Ý�21�¡�¦�© Ü ¦&ª_§ Ñ�� FÃW/q68-��B�E�\1�/V�A�E/ ? 3�38-�/"b £2/*�8�2�E�.��b23+�B389�bA1��2��*b2389�bA1�b2¥g3;-0/ ? bA�=���E/RÈM¢6�by38-��B3��/? �21q�1bA�5éq9E1��=¶�b:¡0¨`y�ª0È@/*¡ ? b�bA�8¡09E1��B38/��iÈ@9E6VF Ø 971��2�7�7¨A¢@¶4¨q�����7389E����¨:9E1��#b2���.�\�c£A/By¥'�01 ? 389�bA1�6.¶4¨�«�¬:¢0�_-�/V�8/:«®­°¯p±«�¯�¢�¬²­³¯ ±¬Q¯�¢sbA���g²~�B�D97�73�b21�9±�21D¶M/ ? bA�=/*6V¢´µ Ü ´7 Ó ©^ ¦�© � ´7 Ó§^ ¦¨§ ��¶ N·¬ O à ¸¹ Ó^ ¦�§P¬ Ó N Â

659E1Uº�»» º N'68971Uº »» º O��Â

659E1 Ó º » Ó»�¼ Ó O��N½ N·« â ¬ â º ON � F  O

�_-0/*�8/ ¶ N·¬ O ¡�/*1b¾23;/V6_38-�/r² Ø 9E143;/V�;� ? 3;9A¾A1#��¾B3;/*14389±�2�x¢��21�¡ ½ N·« â ¬ â º O 976\3;-�/�9E1438/*�Fy� ? 3;9A¾A1q¶M/H3���/V/*1Q³~�g�21�¡�² Ø F

Â�ÿ p

Page 165: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

á�¾23;/�38-��B3~689E1 ? /2¿vÀ�­ à�Á ¸¹� j ? ¾A�=���038/*6~�_9�3;-o38-�/�³~�8² Ø ²��2�=9E�73P¾A1�9E�21G¢��/10/*/*¡]¾21��7¨#��¾A�8�C¨��B¶�¾A�@3 ? ¾A�����79E1��A6��2�#¾A1��A6C3~97¡�/*14389 ? �B��Z N�² Ø ¶M/V1�¡�9E10� O 6C3+�B38/*6*F©.-���6V¢Ý�2�E� ? �B� ? �0�±�B389+¾A1�6<9E1D3;-�976 ? -��2�@3;/*�_�B�8/ ? �2�8�59E/*¡6¾2�03_�B3 ? ¾A1�6C3+�2143_ZU¢0�_-09 ? -#9E6¡09 ? 3;�B3;/V¡o¶4¨#3;-0/�¶Ã¾A��1�¡_y�653;�B3;/ľ2¥T97143;/*�5/*6C3cF.©.-�/&¶�¾A�01�¡_y�6C3+�B38/*6��2�8/ ? -��2�8� ? 38/*�59 Ä /V¡�B6SNÅnpÆ4Z 3 O ¢4�_-�/*�5/|n�976P3;-�/�² Ø £:9E¶��8�B3;9A¾A1��2�@·:���2143;���¦1�����¶>/*�V¢Æ ? ¾A�8�5/*65��¾A10¡�63P¾Ç Ó ¥Å¾A�.² Ø 9E1�3;-0/��E9E�=973m¾2¥�9710ª�1�9�3;/~³��;² Ø ¶�¾A10¡�¡09E653;�21 ? /2¢�Z ? ¾A�5�8/V68�þA1�¡�6\3P¾�¿vÀ�¢�B1�¡ 3 976\3;-�/�£:9E¶0�;�B389+¾A1��B�}·����2143;�0�å1:�0��¶M/V�.¥Å¾A�\3;-�/�³�� M�M�M ² Ø 6538�8/V3 ? -GF©.-�/o�2¶�9E1�9�3;9+¾U�þ238/*143;9E�2�]¢ ½ N·« â ¬ â º O ¢��\�B6D�A/V1�/*�8�B3;/V¡È¾A1��W�A�59E¡J�_9738-N« Ü

^ ^G�@â ^ ^ �:â ^ ^É�0â+ÿb^�ÂAâ+ÿb^�ÿ0âHÿb^=�@â+ÿb^��@â+ÿ_^=�0âP��^�Â2â���^�ÿ0â���^=�@âB�_^�ë0âB�f^G�@â;ßb^�ë@â+ßb^=�@â;�f^�ë0â p ^�ë@â?�b^�ë0â�Â�ëb^�ë ¢¬ Ü ëb^�ß0â+ë_^ �bÂ���0â+ëb^ p �@â;ëb^=�bÂ�ß p â+ë_^=�Aÿ ^ ß0âëb^=�2ß� p â+ë_^=��� p â�Â�^�ëAÿ ^ ��â�Â�^�ë2ßAÿ`�A�@â�Â�^�ë� p Â�ß0âÂ^ ^ â�Â�^�ÿb p ë4�@â�Â�^É�0â�Â�^=�@â�Â�^�ß0â�Â�^�� ¢<�2�7�g971 �³�¢_�B1�¡Êº Ü ëËSàÀ p ë�Ë 9E1 Â��Ë 9E1438/*�5£B�2�76*F©.-0/Q/V1�/*�5�A9E/V6=�/*�5/Q�A9�£A/V1�971���10973;6d¾2¥ ? � o ý ¢¶��03���/ ? ¾A14£2/*�538/*¡¬38-�/q��¾B3;/*14389±�2�¡��B3+��3�¾d¾A�0�.¡�9E�=/*1�659+¾A10�E/*656 ? ¾f¾A�8¡09E1��B38/*6VFP³ã¡�/V3;�29E�7/*¡q¡�9E6 ? ��65689A¾A1x¾A1�38-�/ ? �2� ? ���E�[y389+¾A1̾2¥P3;-�/&¥'�8/*/ByÖ² Ø ¶��2659E6��210¡�3;-�/�/H£B�2�E���i3;9+¾21̾2¥P38-�/��þ23;/V1�389±�2� ? ¾2�����E971��A6����c¨¶>/�¥Å¾A��1�¡q971�³����>/*1�¡�9ÏÈQÞ~F

Â�ÿ�

Page 166: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�(�%���%� Í��� b� Î-�°�F£��F£�Ï� �Ð��WÑ4¢�Ò�£�ÓXÔzÕ� �¥� b� ÖØ ¾A�D�+¾�� �P¾×;�p×�ØA¾�Ù��2�g·����Ù`×;�0� Ù�����¶ÃÚ*�PÛdÆ�¢g¶�¾p×�ÜÊ«ú�Ù�¡Ýº��2�ÞÚ]Û8�A¾ �¸£B�2�Þر�2¶��AÚ�Û�UØC×�Ü��ÞÚ�Û5��Ú�ß�×�×�¾�¬_à�©�Ü���ÛV¢&×�Ü�Ú��A¾��(yAcg¶Ã¾A��Ù�¡fy¡ÛÞ×;�p×�Ú�Û�¾2¥�³~�8² Ø�á ×�Ü�Ú�¾�Ù��7¨�¾�ÙbÚ�ÛS��Ú�B�PÚÌØAÙ`×�Ú*�ÞÚ�ÛF×�Ú*¡�ØAÙ�¥Å¾A�d×�ÜbØ+Û�ÛF×;��¡@¨�â=�PÚ�ÛÞØE¡�Ú�¾�Ù®��×���¾py����2�;�B��Ú8×�Ú*� Õ çm�N¾A¶b×+�pØ+Ù�ÚV¡¶4¨W�c£�ÚV�;�2��ØAÙ��̾�£Ú*�:×PÜ�Ú�£_Ø7¶��;�[×�Ø+¾Ù��2�T·����Ù`×8���ãÛF×+�p×PÚ�¾B¥�Ø+Ù`×�ÚV�PÚ�ÛÞ×!à#©�¾o¡bÚ�×�ÚV�8�#Ø+Ù�Ú×PÜ�Ú�¶Ã¾A��Ù�¡_y%ÛÞ×;�p×�Ú�ÛS¥Å¾A�S�#��Ø�£�Ú�Ù�£fØ7¶��;�p×PØ+¾�Ù��2�L·����pÙz×8���äÙ�����¶�ÚV��n>¢M�¤Ú����Þ¾_ß�Ú�ÚV¡­�ۥž2�E�+¾��UÛ��KÃ�Ú��_�ÞØA×�Ú�×PÜ�Ú�¥'���E�}³~�;² Ø ²��2�#ØE�A×P¾�Ù�ØE�Ù��pÛ*¢

´µ Ü ´7 Ó ©å ¦�© � ´µ Ñ�� á ¬ â º�â ��½ á « â ¬ â ºâ á � à å â©�ÜbÚSÚ�Ø7��Ú�Ù�ÛF×+�p×PÚ�Ûo�2�PÚ�ÚHÈ@���Ù�¡bÚ*¡æØ+ÙÝ×�Ü�ÚW���P¾:¡���ß8×�¶��ÛÞØ+Û�¯ 3�ç ¯ n â Æ ç ¢S�UÜ�ÚV�PÚè¯ n â Æ ç¡bÚ�Ù�¾×PÚ6×�Ü�Ú�¥'�ÞÚ�Ú8y�² Ø ����£Ú8y]¥'��Ù�ß�×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ*¢�UÜbØE�+Ú�¯ 3�ç ¡�Ú�Ù�¾×PÚ�Û2×�Ü�Úq���B�Þ×�ØAß*�AÚ8y¡ØAÙ_yÖ�Ry�¶Ã¾�ÈÛF×+�p×PÚ�Û~¥Å¾2��« ø®ù ¿ ý â ¿ Ó û ¢Ý�UÜ�Ú*�ÞÚ ù ¿ ý â ¿ Ó û Ø+Û~����ÛPÚV�Fy%Û8�ÃÚ�ß�Ø�ªQÚ*¡]ØAÙ`×�Ú*�C£B�2��àg©�Ü�Ú�Ú�Ù�Ú*��y�Ø+Ú�ÛU¾2¥�×�Ü�Ú�ÛPÚ:ÛÞ×+�[×�Ú�Û��2�ÞÚ:é�ê ÜìëíBî�ï î ê îÓ%ð!ñ`ò î ¢-óUÜbÚ�ôPÚ:¿�­�¿ Ó à ¿ ý à�©�Ü�ØAÛ�ØAÛ�õö�÷#ØA×P×PÚ�ö�ø�¨õpÙ#ùbÙfùbÛPùQõø-ß?Ü�¾Ø+ß�Ú�¾pú}¶QõpÛPØ+Û�àP²X¾�ó�Ú�ûÚ�ô�ü:¶ÃÚ�ß!õpù�ÛPÚ�¾�ù�ôvýþ×�Ú�Ù`×�ØþõpøböQõp×�õ�Ø+Ûv¾�Ù�øCÿ���ØCû�Ú�Ù¾�ûÚ�ô�õ�ø+ØA÷�ØC×�Ú�ö#ô�õpÙ���Úü_ó¤Ú�ó¤õÙ`×�Ú�ö6×P¾=¶ÃÚ�õ2¶bø+Ú|×P¾�úž�ôPß�Ú�×�Ü�Ú�¶Ã¾�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û(×�¾�ûpõÙ_yØAÛPÜ�¾�ùb×�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú#×�Ü�ØAÛ�ôPõÙ���Ú#×�¾Ì÷�õ2épÚ�×�ÜbÚ�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôPØAß!õømØ+Ù`×PÚ���ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û²ÚHÈbõß8×!à���Ü�Ú#×?õØAø+Û¾pú�×PÜ�Ú�¶�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�ÛUõpôPÚ�ÛPù_a�ß�Ø+Ú�Ùz×PøAÿ�ÛP÷�õø+ø�¾�ùb×�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�×PÜ�Ú�ô�õpÙ���Ú�¾ú�ýþ×�Ú�Ùz×PØþõø�öQõp×�õ×PÜQõp×:×�Ü�ØAÛ�Ø+Û:õ�ûpõøAØ+öSõpÛPÛPùb÷�ýb×PØ+¾�Ù¨àQÃ�Ú�ôPÚ�Ú�÷#ý�ÜQõÛÞØ Ä Ú�×�ÜQõ[×�� ö�¾fÚ�Û�Ùb¾×�Ù�Ú�Ú�öS×P¾¶ÃÚ�ÚHÈ_ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÛPøAÿrÛPýÃÚ�ß�Ø�ªQÚ�ö¨üQÛPØ+Ùbß�Ú�ó¤Ú�¾Ù�øAÿ�ß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ô�ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û(õp÷�¾�Ù���ÛÞ×�ØAö�Ú�Ù`×PØ+ß!õpø��

Â!�Aë

Page 167: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�à��ÜbÚ:÷�õp×�ôÞØ�È�Ú�øAÚ�÷#Ú�Ù`×�Û�õôÞÚ�×�Ü�Ú�Ù��ØCû�Ú�Ùq¶`ÿ�ü� 3 E ¯ � n E â Æ E ¯ ´µ ¯ n â Æ ç ¯ 3�ç Ü á é�ê � é ����â��8ê�ê������������������ � � 3 E ¯ � n E â Æ E ¯ ½ á « â ¬ â º�âR¯ n â Æ ç ¯ 3&çá � à ÿ âØ ¾�ôX×�Ü�Ú�¶Ã¾�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú2øCÿfØ+Ù��r¾Ù�×PÜ�Ú Õ çm��ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�öbØ+Ù��6×�¾xõ���ØCû�Ú�Ù�û_Ø7¶�ô�õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõø·zùQõpÙz×Pù�÷ Ùzù�÷�¶�Ú�ô�n-ü�ó¤ÚÌ×�õ2éÚÌn E Ü n-üUõÙ�ö�ÛP¾S×PÜ�ÚÌ÷�õp×PôPØ�È�Ú�ø+Ú�÷�Ú�Ùz×PÛr¾�ÙN×PÜ�Ø+ÛÕ çm��õpôPÚ���ØAûÚ�Ùo¶`ÿü á éUê � é�����â��8ê�ê���������� � � 3 E ¯ � n â Æ E ¯ ½ á « â ¬ â º�â�¯ n â Æ ç ¯ 3�ç à���Ü�Ú:ß�¾�ù_yýbø+Ø+Ù���Û � 3 E ¯ � n â Æ E ¯ ½ á « â ¬ â º�â�¯ n â Æ ç ¯ 3�ç õôPÚ�Ú�ûpõøAùQõp×�Ú�ö�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß!õpø+øAÿ�¶`ÿ�ùbÛPØ+Ù���õ²ø+Ø+ÙbÚ!õôØAÙ`×�Ú�ôÞý�¾øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�×P¾ � n â Æ E ¯ ½ á « â ¬ â ºâR¯ n â Æ ç ØAÙ�«�àÃ�Ú�×�Ü�Ú�Ù�öbØþõ���¾ÙQõø+Ø Ä ÚÄØ+Ù�×PÜ�Ø+ÛS¶�õÛPØAÛ�×�¾6¾A¶b×�õØ+Ù�×PÜ�Ú�¶Ã¾�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û²óUØC×�Ü�ØAÙÌ×�ÜbÚ

� ÈbÚ�ö_y¡n�ÛPù�¶bÛPýQõß�Úà�³ �ØAû�Ú�ÙJ¶�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú6Ø+Û�ÚHÈ_ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÛÞØE¶�øAÚxõÛ"! ê$# �&% ê'�`¯ 3&ç ¯ n â Æ ç Ü! � ! ê % ê'��¯ 3&ç ¯ n â Æ ç à_á�¾�ó²ü ! ê % ê(��¯ 3�ç ö�Ú�ÛÞß�ôÞØE¶ÃÚ�Û�õdó(õ!ûÚ8y%úÅùbÙ�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù�)�� á «²â8üÃÛP¾#×�ÜQõp×¾ù�ô.¶�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú²÷�õ!ÿ�¶�Ú�óUôPØC×P×PÚ�Ù�õÛ�ü*! � )�� á «²âR¯ n â Æ ç à��Ü�ØAÛ�÷�Ú8×�Ü�¾fö�ØAÛvÙ�¾×�×�ÜbÚXÛF×?õÙ�ö�õôPö��¤¾�ôÞÙ_y�+�ý�ýÃÚ�Ù�ÜbÚ�Ø+÷#Ú�ô�õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü�úž�ô � Ù�ö�Ø+Ù��

×PÜ�Ú-,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�óUÜ�Ú�Ù�« â ºÌõôPÚrÛÞø+¾�ó�ûpõôPØ+õ�,�ø+Ú�Û:ß�¾�÷#ýQõôPÚ�öS×�¾]¬fàyÇXõ[×�Ü�Ú�ô�ü/ó�Ú÷�õ2épÚ�õxö�Øþõ.,Qõp×�ØAßdÛPÚ�ý�õô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù ¾ú�×�Ü�Ú#ú·õÛÞ×0/ Ø ûfØ1,�ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù�ß�¾f¾�ôPö�ØAÙQõp×PÚ#¬6úÅôÞ¾�÷ä×�ÜbÚÛÞø+¾�ó ûpõôÞØþõ�,bø+Ú�Û�« â º_à2��Ü�Ú2��Ú�¾�÷�Ú8×�ôFÿ]¾úm×�Ü�Údý�ôÞ¾3,�ø+Ú�÷ Ø+Û�ó�Ú�øAøCy%ÛPù�ØC×�Ú�ö�×P¾�ÛÞù�ß?ÜSõpÙõpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü&à4��ÜbÚ¤ôPÚ�õÛP¾Ù:úž�ô�×�ÜbØ+Û�Ø+Û�×�ÜQõ[×�×PÜ�Ú65Xô(/ Ø ,�ØAÙ�ö�ØAÙ��XÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿľú87 ÂcëAë ß�÷ o ýØAÛ�ÛÞ÷�õpø+ø�ß�¾÷�ýQõpôPÚ�ö�×�¾ ×�Ü�Ú/ Ø ûfØ�,�ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù�õø�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�ÛPý�õß�ØAÙ���¾ú97 ÿAëAëAë ß�÷ o ý à

Â!��Â

Page 168: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��Üzù�Û�üQ×�Ü�Ú95|ô�/ Ø Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ô�õß8×�ØA¾�Ù6¾�Ù�øCÿ�ó�Ú!õ2ézøAÿxöbØ+ÛÞ×P¾�ôÞ×PÛ(×�Ü�Ú�ú·õÛF×:/ Ø ûfØ1,�ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù&àØ ¾�ô�×PÜ�ÚÌ« ß�¾f¾�ôÞö�Ø+ÙQõ[×�Ú6ýQõôF×�ØAß�ø+ÚBy¡ØAÙ_y�õ[y;,�¾cÈ�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ümó¤Ú�ù�ÛPÚ�ö�סó�¾�ÛÞÚ�×�Û#¾ú<,�¾cÈöbØ+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�Û|õÙ�ö=,QõÛÞØ+Û�ÛÞÚ�ײÛÞØ Ä Ú�Û�úž�ô|×PÜ�Ú>,�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�ß�õø+ß�ù�øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ�à�è¡Ù]×�Ü�Ú � ôPÛF×ÛÞÚ�×�ü�ó�Ú�÷�õpö�ÚÄ×PÜ�Ú�öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�ÛXõÙ�ö,QõÛPØAÛ|ÛÞÚ�×�ÛÞØ Ä Ú�õÛXÛP÷�õø+ø õÛXý�¾ÛPÛPØ�,�ø+Ú²óUØA×PÜ�¾�ùb×õ$?¨Ú�ß�×�ØAÙ�� ×�Ü�Ú�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�¾úÄ×�Ü�Ú�ö�Ú�ÛPØAôPÚ�ö@,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�ÚpàA��Ü�Ø+Û6ó¤õÛxö�¾�Ù�Ú�ÛP¾�õÛ6×P¾Ú�ø+ØA÷�ØAÙQõp×�Ú#õÙ`ÿ�ôPÚ�ÛPØ+öbùQõø¤ÛÞ÷�õpø+ø�¾�ÛPß�Ø+øAøþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ÛÄõp×:×�Ü�Ú�ó(õ!û�ÚBy%úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù ×?õØAø+Û�àoè¡ÙS×�ÜbÚÛÞÚ�ß�¾�Ù�öSÛÞÚ�×!ü�ó¤Ú�ù�ÛPÚ�ö øþõô���Ú�ô9,þ�È�ö�ØA÷�Ú�Ù�ÛPØA¾�Ù�Û�üB,�ù_×�ù�ÛÞÚ�ö�×PÜ�Ú�ÛÞ÷�õpø+ø+Ú�ÛÞ×�,QõÛÞØ+ÛÄÛPÚ8×ýþ�ÛÞÛPØ1,bø+Ú2×�¾C��Ú�×Ä×�Ü�Ú#Û�õp÷�Ú#Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���ØAÚ�Û:õÛ�ØAÙ ×PÜ�Ú � ôPÛF×�ÛPÚ8×!à�ÃÊÜ�ØAø+Ú2×�ÜbÚ#סó�¾�ÛPÚ8×�Û:¾ú,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�õý�ýÃÚ!õô¤Ø+ö�Ú�Ùz×PØ+ß�õø�ü_ôPÚ�ÛÞØ+ö�ù�õø&¾�ÛÞß�Ø+øAøþõp×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ¤õpפ×�Ü�Ú�×?õpØ+ø+Û�¾ú ×�Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚ�ß�¾�Ù�öÛÞÚ�×|ß�¾�ù�øAö�ø+Ú�õö�×P¾�ö�ØD?¨Ú�ôPÚ�Ùz×|ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�à_Ã�Ú�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PÚ�öÌ×PÜ�Ú�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙôPõp×�Ú�Û�ù�ÛÞØ+Ù��C,�¾p×�ÜSÛÞÚ�×�Û�¾ú ,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ü/ØAÙ�¾�ôÞö�Ú�ôÄ×�¾�ö�Ú8×�Ú�ôP÷#Ø+Ù�Úd×�Ü�Ú�Ùzù�÷�Ú�ôPØAß!õøÛF×?õ�,bØ+ø+ØCסÿ�¾pú�×PÜ�Ú � ÙQõø õÙbÛÞó�Ú�ôPÛ�à

è¡ÙE��õ�,bø+Ú � à  ó�Ú�ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×�×�Ü�Úxß!õpø+ß�ùbøþõp×PÚ�ö4Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���ØAÚ�Ûdúž�ô2×�Ü�Ú á Â�ëAëAë âBü á å ëAëAë â8üá å Â2Â�ë â8ü á ÿAë2ëAë â8üÃõÙbö á ÿbÂ2Â�ë âF,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�à:��Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚ2õôPÚÄ×�Ü�Ú�,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û|óUÜ�¾�ÛÞÚýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ô�õp×PÚ�Û¤ó�Ú�ß�¾Ù�ÛPØAö�Ú�ô�ØAÙ�×�Ü�ØAÛ¤ß?ÜQõpýb×�Ú�ô�àPÃ�Ú�õø+ÛÞ¾�ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÚ�Ùz×U×PÜ�Ú�ÚHÈ_ýÃÚ�ô�yØA÷�Ú�Ù`×?õøAøAÿd÷#Ú!õÛÞù�ôPÚ�ö�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���Ø+Ú�Û�ü�óUÜ�ØAß?Ü�õpôPÚ²õøAÛP¾>��ØCû�Ú�ÙxØAÙQÇUÚ�ú�à ÿ àPè¡Ù�õpö�ö�ØA×PØ+¾�Ù¨ü_ó�Ú�ØAû�Úm×�Ü�Ú6,�¾cÈ�ö�Ø+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛ�õÙbö>,QõÛPØAÛ�ÛÞÚ�×vÛÞØ Ä Ú¤ù�ÛPÚ�ö�×�¾�¾3,_×?õØAÙ:×�ÜbÚ�ÛPÚ�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���Ø+Ú�Û�àPá�¾×�Ú×PÜQõp×mß�¾ÙzûÚ�ô���Ú�Ù�ß�Ú�Ø+Ûvú·õØAôPøAÿ:ô�õpý�Ø+ö&üzôÞÚ�Gzù�Ø+ôÞØ+Ù��ÄÙ�¾Ä÷�¾ôPÚ�×�ÜQõpÙ �4ë ,QõÛÞØ+Û�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�à���Ü�Ø+ÛØAÛ�×�¾H,ÃÚ6ÚHÈ_ýÃÚ�ß8×�Ú�ö¨ü¤ÛPØAÙ�ß�Úr×PÜ�Ú�5|ô�/ Ø ØAÙz×PÚ�ôPõß�×PØ+¾�Ù ØAÛ�ú·õØ+ôÞøAÿ]ó�Ú!õ2é á õÛ2ß�¾�÷�ý�õôPÚ�ö

Â!� å

Page 169: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�f×?õp×PÚ 5<,Qè¡ÙbØA×�ØA¾ çKÈ_ýÃÚ�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ù`× I ýJBK ê I ýJBL�M á ý I ÓJBK ê I ÓJBL�M á Óá Â�ëAëAë â y ��� à ��� y Â�Â2 à ÿ`� å àON � à ß å � å à ß ß à ë ÿ`�á å ëAëAë â y Â�ë Nbà ß2ß y  å�å à ß� å àON � àQP å � å à ß ß à ë �4ëá å Â2Â�ë â y ÿ N_à ëAß y �4ß à ÿ`� å àON � àON å � å à ß ß à ë ÿAëá ÿAëAëAë â y Â2 NbàQN � y Âcÿ`� à � P å à � � à � å ë å à ß ß à ë ÿAëá ÿ�Â2Â�ë â y � å àQN ß y � å à Â�ÿ å àON � àQP Â�ë å à ß ß à ë ÂR�

��õ�,�øAÚ � à  �Lç�ÙbÚ�ô��Ø+Ú�Ûv¾pú¨õ�ÛPõ÷#ý�ø+Ú(¾pú&5Xô(/ Ø ,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û á Ø+Ù2ß�÷ o ý â�óUØC×�Ü2ôÞÚ�ÛPýÃÚ�ß8××P¾ ×�Ü�Ú]ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�öbØ+Ù��4n â Æ Ü ë úÅôPÚ�Ú8y�/ Ø ÛÞ×?õ[×�Úà×Þ¤¾�ø+ù�÷#Ù å �R��ÜbÚ ß�õø+ß�ù�øþõ[×�Ú�öÚ�Ù�Ú�ô���Ø+Ú�Û�à�Þ¤¾�ø+ù�÷#Ù ÿ �S��Ü�Ú2ÚHÈ_ýÃÚ�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ù`×?õø/Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���Ø+Ú�Û�à�Þ¤¾�ø+ù�÷#Ù�Û �UT°� �V��ÜbÚ � ôPÛF×ÛÞÚ�×2¾pú�,�¾cÈ�ö�Ø+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛ�àoÞ¤¾�ø+ù�÷#Ù ß �>��ÜbÚ6÷�õiÈ_ØA÷�ù�÷ ýQõôF×�ØAß�ø+ÚBy¡ØAÙ_y�õ[y;,�¾cÈ�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿøAÚ�ûÚ�øvØ+Ù�×PÜ�Ú2,QõÛÞØ+Û�ù�ÛÞÚ�ö�úž�ô�×�Ü�Ú � ôPÛÞ×ÄÛÞÚ�׾ú,�¾cÈ�öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�Û á 3 Ü ÂSàXW ÷�õiÈ â8àÞ¤¾ø+ù�÷#ÙYP T Nb�4��Ü�ÚUÛÞÚ�ß�¾Ù�örÛPÚ8×m¾ú�,þcÈ#ö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾Ù�Û�àTÞ¤¾�ø+ù�÷#Ù � �B��Ü�ÚX÷�õiÈ_Ø+÷�ù�÷ý�õôÞ×PØ+ß�øAÚ8y%Ø+Ù_y¡õ[yZ,þcÈ�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�øAÚ�ûÚ�ø�Ø+Ù�×PÜ�ÚH,QõÛÞØ+Û6ù�ÛÞÚ�ö�úžô�×�Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚ�ß�¾Ù�öèÛÞÚ�×�¾ú�,�¾cÈöbØ+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�Û�à

Â!�Aÿ

Page 170: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

óUØC×�Ü6×�ÜbÚ0/ Ø ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø âBà��Ü�ÚUõ.��ôPÚ�Ú�÷#Ú�Ù`×[,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ùd×�ÜbÚ�¾�ôFÿ2õÙ�ö�ÚHÈ_ý�Ú�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ùz×/Ø+Û�ú·õØAôPøCÿ9��¾_¾fö]\�Üb¾Ró�Ú�ûÚ�ô�übõÛ

óUØC×�ÜÄ×�Ü�ÚmúÅôPÚ�ÚBy�/ Ø ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�üó�Ú¤ù�ÛÞÚ¤×�ÜbÚ¤ÚHÈ_ýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õøzûpõø+ùbÚ�Û úž�ô�×PÜ�Ú¤Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���Ø+Ú�Û�ØAÙ:×�ÜbÚöbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ÛXØ+Ù�×�ÜbØ+Û�ß?ÜQõpýb×�Ú�ô�à���Ü�Ú2ôÞÚ!õÛÞ¾�Ù�Û�úž�ô|×PÜ�Ø+Û�õôPÚ2ö�ØAÛPß�ù�ÛPÛÞÚ�öØAÙ6×�Ü�Ú&Þ¤¾�Ù�ß�ø+ù�ÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛUõÙ�ö�Ø+ÙU5|ý�ýÃÚ�Ùbö�Ø�ÈQÞ|à  ¾�Ù6×�Ü�Ú�úÅôPÚ�Ú8yZ/ Ø ,QõÛPØAÛ�à�(�%���_^ Í��� b� Î-�°�F£��F£�Ï� �Ð��A`NÒX bÏ�¢��F£�Ï Õ� b¥� �� Ö��¾�ö�Ú8×�Ú�ôP÷#Ø+Ù�Ú�×�Ü�ÚXö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ú�ö�ó(õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù6ß�¾�ôÞôPÚ�ÛÞý�¾Ù�ö�Ø+Ù���×�¾�ýbôP¾fö�ù�ß�× / Ø Ú�azyØC×�ØAÙ���óUØA×PÜÌÚ�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿ�é�ØAÙx×PÜ�ÚÄÛÞ×?õ[×�Úx¯ n â Æ ç ü�ó�Ú�õ!û�Ú�ô�õ��Ú:×�ÜbÚb/Xõ÷�ØAøA×P¾�Ù�ØþõpÙr¾�û�Ú�ôU×�ÜbÚÛF×?õp×PÚ ¯ n â Æ ç ¾ú|ØAÙ`×�Ú�ôÞÚ�ÛF×!ü�×PÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ�,`ÿ�¾3,b×�õØ+Ù�ØAÙ���õ Õ ç��4ö�Ú�ýÃÚ�Ùbö�Ø+Ù�� ¾�Ù�øCÿS¾�Ù�«�ü¤¾ÙóUÜbØ+ß?Ü4ó¤Ú�ß!õÙ�ß�¾�ÙbÛÞ×�ôÞù�ß�×#×�ÜbÚ�¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù��]ó¤õ�ûÚà Ø ¾ôd×PÜ�ÚxÜ�Ø1�Ü_yAc�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ü�×PÜ�Ú�ôP¾py×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿR�`õpý�Û2õôÞÚ�¾�ÙS×PÜ�Úr¾�ôÞö�Ú�ô�¾pú �2ëAë ß�÷ o ý ü/óUÜ�ØAø+Ú�×PÜ�Ú�×Pô�õÙ�ÛÞøþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�õøÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿc�`õý�Û�õôPÚ�¾�Ù�×PÜ�Ú�¾ôPö�Ú�ô:¾ú�õ�úÅÚ�ó Â�ëed Ûľú�ß�÷ o ý àU��Üzù�Û�ü�õp×�ÜbØ1��Ü_yCc�üB,þ×Pܬ�õÙ�ö ºrõôÞÚ�ú·õÛÞ×|ûõpôPØþõ.,�ø+Ú�Û�ü¨ÛÞ¾6×�ÜQõp×|×�Ü�ØAÛ�õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü�Ø+Û|Úfabõß�×PøAÿ�×�Ü�Ú2ß�ôPù�ö�Úd��¾�ôPÙ_y+�ý�ýÃÚ�ÙbÜ�Ú�ØA÷�Ú�ô�õýbý�ôP¾ga_Ø+÷�õp×�ØA¾�Ù&à]h�Ú�Ú�a_ý�Ú�ß�×vÙ�Ú���ø+Ø���Ø1,bø+Ú/÷#ØDa_Ø+Ù��Uõ÷�¾Ù���ÛÞ×�×�ÜbÚ�Ü�Ø���Ü_yc�ß?ÜQõpÙ�Ù�Ú�øAÛ�ü`ÛÞ¾�×�ÜQõp×�×�Ü�Ú(öbÚ�ß!õ!ÿ�ô�õp×PÚ�ÛvØ+Ù`×P¾|×�Ü�Ú�÷ õpôPÚ(Ú�GfùbØAûpõø+Ú�Ù`×/×�¾�×PÜ�Ú(ö�Ú�ß!õ!ÿ�ôPõp×�Ú�ÛØAÙ`×�¾�×PÜ�Ú�ß�¾ôPôPÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ���ý�ôÞ¾_öbù�ß�×�/ Ø ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�à Ø ¾�ô�×PÜ�Ú�øA¾Ró�Ú�ô/Æ#ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�üb¾�Ù�øAÿ#¬ÄØ+Û¤õú·õpÛÞ×�ûpõôPØ+õ�,�øAÚübÛÞ¾2×�ÜQõp×�×PÜ�Ø+ÛUõpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü�ÙbÚ���øAÚ�ß�×PÛU÷�ØiabØAÙ��2õ÷#¾�Ù��ÛÞ×�×�ÜbÚ�ø+¾�ó(yAc¤ß?ÜQõÙfy

Â!��

Page 171: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÙbÚ�ø+Û�àj��Üzù�Û�ü�óUÜ�ØAø+Ú�×PÜ�Ú6ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û�×P¾�×PÜ�Ú�ÛÞÚxß?ÜQõÙ�Ù�Ú�ø+Û#õôÞÚrÛPùba#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×PøAÿ ÛÞ÷�õøAø¤ÛÞ¾×PÜQõp×:×�Ü�ÚröbÚ�ß!õ!ÿ�ô�õp×PÚ�Û�ØAÙz×P¾�×PÜ�Ú�÷ãõôPÚk��ØAûÚ�ÙR,`ÿ õpÙ Ø T�l�õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü&üvØAÙ`×�Ú�ôÞß?ÜQõÙ_yÙbÚ�øm÷�ØiabØAÙ��x÷�õBéÚ�Û²×�ÜbÚ�ÛPÚ�ö�Ú�ß�õ�ÿ ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ö�ØD?¨Ú�ôPÚ�Ù`×ÄúÅôP¾�÷ ×PÜ�Ú�öbÚ�ß!õ!ÿ ô�õ[×�Ú�Û:Ø+Ù`×�¾x×�ÜbÚß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù���ý�ôP¾fö�ù�ß8× / Ø ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û�à�áXÚ8û�Ú�ôF×�Ü�Ú�ø+Ú�ÛPÛ�üQÛÞØ+Ù�ß�Ú|ó�Ú�Úfa_ýÃÚ�ß�פ×�Ü�ÚXý�ôP¾fö�ù�ß8×/ Ø ×�¾",�Ú²ôP¾p×?õp×PØ+¾�ÙQõpø+øAÿdÜb¾×!ü�×PÜ�Ú²ö�Ú�ß�õ�ÿxôPõp×�Ú�ÛXØAÙ`×�¾2×�Ü�Ú²øA¾Ró(yCc¤ß?ÜQõÙ�Ù�Ú�ø+Û�ÛPÜ�¾ù�ø+öm,�ÚÙbÚ���øAØ1��Ø�,�ø+ÚpüvôPÚ�Ùbö�Ú�ôÞØ+Ù�� Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPß?ÜQõpÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�÷#ØDa_Ø+Ù��]ØAôPôÞÚ�ø+Ú8ûpõÙ`×!àn��Üzù�Û�ü(×PÜ�Ø+Ûd÷#Ú�×�Üb¾_ö4Ø+ÛöbØ+ôPÚ�ß�×PøAÿ õý�ýbø+Ø+ß�õ�,�øAÚ2¾�Ù�øAÿ]×P¾�×PÜ�Úkl��o/Ul³ß�¾�÷�ýbø+Úfa_Ú�Û�à Ø ¾�ô�×�Ü�Úkl:�l Ó ß�¾�÷�ýbø+Úfa_Ú�Û×PÜ�Ú�ö�Ú�ß�õ�ÿ#ôPõp×�Ú�Û¤õôÞÚXýbôPÚ�öb¾�÷�ØAÙQõÙ`×�øCÿ�ØAÙz×P¾Ä×PÜ�Ú�ø+¾�ó(yAcvß?ÜQõÙ�Ù�Ú�ø+Û�ü_ÛÞ¾�ß?ÜQõÙbÙ�Ú�øÃ÷�Øia_Ø+Ù��ÙbÚ�Ú�öbÛ(×�¾>,ÃÚX×?õBéÚ�ÙxØAÙz×P¾2õß�ß�¾�ù�Ù`×UØAÙ�¾�ôÞö�Ú�ô¤×P¾2ý�ôP¾ý�Ú�ôPøAÿ#ö�Ú8×�Ú�ôP÷#Ø+Ù�Ú�×�Ü�Ú�ôÞ¾×?õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõøöbØ+ÛÞ×PôPØ�,�ùb×�ØA¾�Ù&à��Ü�Úľ�Ù�ÚBy¡ýQõpô�õ÷#Ú�×PÚ�ô�/|õp÷�ØAøA×�¾Ù�ØþõÙY,�Ú�ß�¾�÷#Ú�Û�ü´µ © Ü à ¸¹ Óå ¦�© Ô ÓÔf« Ó ��½ ��� á «²â � é ��� á � à � â

óUÜbÚ�ôPÚ ½ ��� á «²âr­ � n â Æ&¯ ½ ¯ n â Æ ç àp��¾ ¾3,b×�õØ+Ù�õ�ÛP¾�øAùb×�ØA¾�Ùpq á «²â�¾ú|Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�é#ü�ó�ÚÙzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�õø+øCÿ�ØAÙz×PÚ���ôPõp×�Ú�×PÜ�Ú�úž�ø+øA¾�óUØ+Ù���ý�õØ+ôÞÛ�¾ú�Ú�GzùQõp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û��

Ô�qÔz« Ü@r á � à � âÔ rÔz« Ü à å ¦�©¸¹ Ó á é à é���� à ½ ��� á «²âPâ�q á � à ß â

��Ü�Ú²¾�ÙbøAÿ�Ø+ÛPÛÞù�Ú�Ü�Ú�ôPÚ�Ø+Û�¾�,b×?õØAÙ�Ø+Ù���õ�ÛPÚ8×�¾ú�Ø+Ù�ØC×�ØþõpøÃß�¾�Ù�ö�ØC×�ØA¾�Ù�Û�à4��Ü�Ú�ý�¾p×�Ú�Ù`×PØþõøö�õp×?õ#¾�Ù�øAÿU�¾_Ú�ÛXúÅôP¾÷ìÛP¾�÷#Ú�« JsK ê�t ë ×P¾rÛP¾÷�Ú:« JBL�M üÃÛP¾�ó�Ú�¾�ÙbøAÿ � Ù�ö�×�Ü�Ú:¾�ùb×Þy

Â!�`�

Page 172: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�¾�Ø+Ù��dó¤õ�ûÚ�Û�¾�û�Ú�ôX×PÜ�Ø+Û�ô�õÙ���Úà Ø ¾�ôUÛPØA÷�ý�øAØ+ß�ØAסÿ�übÛPÚ�× ½ ��� á «²â ÜW½ �_� á « JBK ê`â�úžô|« øù ë0â « JBK ê û üzóUØC×�Ü2×�ÜbÚ�ÛF×�ØAý�ù�øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�×�ÜQõ[×Fqr÷�ùbÛÞ×�ûpõÙ�Ø+ÛÞÜ#õp×m« Ü ë à4��Ü�ÚUûpõÙ�Ø+ÛÞÜ�Ø+Ù���¾úq�õpפ« Ü ë Ø+Û�õß�ß�¾�÷#ý�ø+ØAÛPÜ�Ú�öY,`ÿ�õÛPÛÞù�÷#Ø+Ù���õ:ÜQõôÞö�ó¤õø+øÃõpפ« Ü ë á ×�Ü�ÚXö�Ø�?�Ú�ôÞÚ�Ù�ß�ÚØAÛUÙ�Ú���øAØ1��Ø�,�ø+ÚXØAú�« ØAÛ�ÛÞØ+÷#ý�øAÿ�õøAø+¾�ó¤Ú�ö�×P¾2��¾#×P¾ à g õpÙ�ö ½ ��� á «²â Ü�½ ��� á « JsK ê`â¤úž�ô« ø á à g â « JsK ê û âBà[��Ü�Ú�ØAÙ�ØA×PØþõø�ß�¾�Ù�ö�ØC×�ØA¾�Ù�Û�õôPÚX¾3,b×?õpØ+Ù�Ú�ök,`ÿ�ÛÞ¾�øAûfØAÙ��:úž�ô6q�ØAÙ�×�ÜbÚôPõÙ���Ú ù ë0â « JsK ê û àr�_Ú�×Þ×�Ø+Ù���q á « JsK êzâ Ü Â ü�ß�¾�÷�,�ØAÙ�Ú�ö óUØA×�Ü�×�ÜbÚ�ôÞÚ�Gzù�Ø+ôÞÚ�÷#Ú�Ù`×Ä×�ÜQõp×q á ë â Ü ë ü�Ø+Û�ÛÞùba#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×X×P¾#öbÚ�×�Ú�ôP÷#Ø+Ù�Ú r á « JBK ê`â Ü q-E á « JBK ê`â8à5�ú ×�Ú�ômó¤Ú|¾3,b×?õpØ+Ùd×�Ü�ÚXÛP¾�øAùb×�ØA¾�Ù#×P¾�¾�ù�ômÛÞÿfÛF×�Ú�÷°¾ús+ ç d Û�ü_ó�Ú|Ù�Ú�Ú�ör×P¾�Ù�¾�ôÞ÷�õpøCy

Ø Ä Ú|×PÜ�Ú|ó¤õ!û�Ú�úÅùbÙ�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù�ÛP¾�×PÜQõp×(×PÜ�Ú�¾�ùb×���¾�Ø+Ù���ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ÜQõ!û�Ú�×�ÜbÚu� á é à é E â�Ù�¾�ôÞ÷�õpøCyØ Ä õp×PØ+¾�ÙÌß�¾�Ù`û�Ú�Ù`×�Ø+¾Ù&à���Ü�ØAÛ�ôPÚ�Gzù�ØAôPÚ�Û²×PÜQõp×�×PÜ�Ú�ó(õ!ûÚ�úÅù�Ù�ß8×�ØA¾�Ù�Ü�õ�ûÚ#õÙ�¾�ÛPß�Ø+ø+ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ùõp÷�ý�øAØA×Pù�ö�Ú�¾ú á Ó Jï î ëí î HQv o vxw�y I â3z{ ØAÙr×�Ü�Ú²ø+õô���Ú²«Wø+ØA÷�ØC×!à�(�%���}| ~�¢¤����ÒX ��Þ£�Ï  QÐ��æÍè�FÖ_Öb¢�� �F¥� ���¢¤£���¥� ����ÜbÚÄöbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù6ôPõp×�Ú²ØAÛ�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PÚ�ö�ù�ÛPØAÙ��"�-Ú�ôP÷#Ø d ÛUT�¾�ø+ö�Ú�Ùml�ù�øAÚà��Q¾�ôUõ>,þ�ù�Ù�ö_yúÅôÞÚ�Úxö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙSý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛÞÛ�ØAÙ4óUÜbØ+ß?Ü4×�Ü�Úx¾�ùb×���¾�ØAÙ��]ß�¾�Ù`×PØ+Ùzù�ù�÷�ÛF×?õp×PÚ�ÛdÜQõ!û�Úx×�ÜbÚ� á é���é E â²Ù�¾ôP÷�õø+Ø Ä õp×PØ+¾�Ù&üÃ×�Ü�ÚY��T�l úžôP÷�ù�ø+õ���ØAûÚ�Û:õ�ö�Ú�ß!õ!ÿ ô�õp×PÚdØ+Ù`×�¾�õC��ØCû�Ú�ÙÚ�a_ØA×Uß?ÜQõÙbÙ�Ú�ø ¾ú�ü

��� å[Z¸¹ ¯ � ¼ � ¯´µ ¯ ¼ � ç ¯ � á � à�P�â

Â!�3�

Page 173: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

óUÜbÚ�ôPÚx¯ ¼ � ç ö�Ú�Ùb¾×�Ú�Û�×PÜ�Ú9,�¾�ùbÙ�ö�ÛF×?õp×PÚüÃõÙ�ö4¯ ¼ � ç ö�Ú�Ù�¾×�Ú�Û�×PÜ�Ú9��ØAûÚ�Ù�Úfa_ØA×Uß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù��ÄÛÞ×�õp×�ÚUóUØA×PÜ�Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿ�Ú�Gfù�õøÃ×P¾:×PÜ�ÚS,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿ�à[��Ü�ÚSépÚ�ÿdúÅÚ!õ[×�ù�ôÞÚ×P¾dÙ�¾×�Ú²Ü�Ú�ôPÚ²Ø+Û(×PÜQõp×U×�ÜbÚÄýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù6ØAÛ(úÅôP¾�÷³õ>,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ²¾3,b×?õpØ+Ù�Ú�öxúÅôÞ¾�÷õm/|õp÷�ØAøA×�¾Ù�ØþõÙ�óUØA×�Ü�סó�¾ÌÛPøA¾�ó ûpõôPØ+õ�,�øAÚ�Û�ü�×P¾�¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ��xÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û:¾3,_×?õØAÙ�Ú�ö�úÅôP¾�÷ õ/Xõ÷#Ø+øA×P¾�Ù�Ø+õÙ#óUØC×�Ü6¾�ÙbÚ�ÛPø+¾�óÝûpõôPØ+õ�,�ø+Úpà���Ú�û�Ú�ôÞ×PÜ�Ú�øAÚ�ÛPÛ�üÃ×PÜ�Ú9��T�lÝô�õp×PÚ�Ø+Û¤¾3,b×?õpØ+Ù�Ú�ö,`ÿ ØAÙ�ÛPÚ�ôÞ×PØ+Ù���×PÜ�ÚrúÅù�ø+ø6/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�ÙbØþõÙ ´µ ,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�Ù�×PÜ�Ú�,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�ÚxõÙbö�õH��ØCû�Ú�Ù¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù���ÛÞ×?õ[×�Úà���Ü�Ú�,QõÛÞØ+ß�ØAö�Ú!õ Ø+Û#×�ÜQõp×rõøA×PÜ�¾�ù��Ü�×�ÜbÚ�,�¾ù�Ù�öÊõÙ�öN¾�ùb×(�¾�Ø+Ù��ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�õôPÚY��Ú�Ù�Ú�ô�õp×PÚ�ö�úÅôÞ¾�÷ ö�ØD?¨Ú�ôPÚ�Ù`×�/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�Ù�Ø+õÙ�Û�ü&×�Ü�Ú8ÿ�øAØ+Úd¾�Ù�ÛPù�ôFú·õß�Ú�Û�óUØA×PÜöbØ�?�Ú�ôPÚ�Ù`×�úÅôÞÚ�Ú8yZ/S� ûfØ1,�ôPõp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø<Gfù�õÙ`×�ù�÷ Ùzù�÷�,ÃÚ�ôÞÛ�üÄõÙ�öÝÛP¾�×�Ü�Ú ¾�Ù�øCÿÈ×�Ú�ôP÷ Ø+Ù×PÜ�Ú>/Xõ÷�ØAøA×P¾�Ù�ØþõpÙ�óUÜ�ØAß?Ü]ß�¾�ùbý�ø+Ú�Û|×�Ü�Ú>,þ�ù�Ùbö�õÙ�ö]¾�ùb×���¾�ØAÙ���ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�Ø+ÛX×�Ü�Ú�5Xô(/<�ØAÙ`×�Ú�ôPõß�×PØ+¾�Ù ½ á «���¬��?ºâ8à��Ü�Ú6,�¾�ùbÙ�ö�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Ø+Ûs��ØAûÚ�Ù�,`ÿ�! � )]� á «²â�¯ n8�¡Æ ç üõÙ�ö�ÛÞØ+Ù�ß�Ú�ó�Ú(ø+¾f¾Aé²õp×�n þ nB� Â

×Pô�õÙbÛPØA×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ�üb×PÜ�Ú:¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù��2ÛF×?õp×PÚ:ØAÛ ��ØAûÚ�Ùm,zÿ ¼ ��� á «²â�¯ n0�  �¡Æ E ç à[h�Ú:Ú8ûpõø+ùQõ[×�Ú�×�ÜbÚß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���Ø+Ù`×PÚ���ôPõø�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�õø+øCÿ�ü�,`ÿ�ù�ÛÞØ+Ù��Ìø+Ø+ÙbÚ!õô²Ø+Ù`×PÚ�ôPýþ�ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�¾�Ù ¼ ���Åü�)]�RüvõÙbö½ H � o ý I ��� � �Rü(óUÜ�Ú�ôPÚ ½ H � o ý I ��� � � á «²â�­ � nm�  �¡Æ E ¯ ½ ¯ n*�%Æ ç à���Ü�ÚH,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�ó�Ú�ôÞÚÚ8ûpõø+ùQõ[×�Ú�ö�¾�Ù]õ  � ëAëAë y¡ýþ�Ø+Ù`×UÚ�GzùQõpø+øAÿxÛÞýQõß�Ú�öH��ôÞØ+ö�úÅôÞ¾�÷ « � å ^G� � Â�ëb^�ë �5:ü&õÙbö×PÜ�Ú�¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù���ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ó¤Ú�ôPÚrÚ8ûpõø+ùQõ[×�Ú�ö�¾�Ù õ �AëAë � ë2ëAë y¡ýþ�ØAÙzײÚ�GzùQõø+øCÿ�ÛPýQõpß�Ú�ö��ôPØ+öúÅôÞ¾�÷ « � å ^=� � Â�ë_^�ë®�5�à65�GzùQõøAØA×�õp×�ØCû�Ú�Ø+øAø+ù�ÛF×�ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù6¾ú�×PÜ�Ú�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��2,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ù�õ,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ:õpÙ�ö�õ"��ØCû�Ú�Ù�Ú�a_ØA×�ß?ÜQõÙ�ÙbÚ�ø Ø+Û ��ØCû�Ú�Ù�ØAÙU��Ø1��ùbôPÚ � à  à

Â!� P

Page 174: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5R

Bound StateOutgoing State

Potential

��Ø1��ù�ôÞÚ � à  ����ùQõpø+ØA×�õp×�ØCû�Ú�Ø+ø+øAù�ÛÞ×Pô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù ¾ú�×�Ü�Ú6ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�ÙÈõH,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�ÚõpÙ�ö õU�ØAû�Ú�Ù�Ú�a_ØAײß?ÜQõÙbÙ�Ú�ø�à>��Ü�Údý�ø+¾×²ØAÛ�¾ú�ÛP¾�÷#Ú>)]� á «²â|ß�¾�÷#ý�¾�ÙbÚ�Ù`׾ú(õ���ØCû�Ú�Ù,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚüQÛP¾÷�Ú�¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ���ó¤õ�ûÚ ¼ ��� á «²âBü-õÙ�öx×�Ü�Ú²ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù�� ½ H � o ý I ������� á «²âBà�(�%���%� Õ������%Ô��Ý£�¥����� �����¥��"� ¢UÓ��s�5XÛvó¤Ú�ÛPÜQõpø+ø�ÛÞÚ�Ú�Ø+Ù2×�Ü�Ú<lUÚ�ÛPùbøA×�ÛmõÙbö ØAÛPß�ùbÛPÛPØA¾�Ù&ü�×PÜ�ÚUÜ�Ø1��ÜbøAÿ�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õp×�¾�ôFÿľ�ùb×(�¾�Ø+Ù��ó¤õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß�×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ(÷�õ.�Ú|ØC×mö�ØAa#ß�ùbøA×m×�¾�õpß�ß�ùbô�õp×PÚ�øAÿdß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�×�Ü�ÚXø+¾�ó�Ú�ô�ÆdýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�ØCyõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ô�õ[×�Ú�Û�à���Ü�Ú�ôÞÚ�ÛPùbøA×/¾púÃ×PÜ�Ø+Û�Ø+Û�×�ÜQõp×�×�Ü�Ú(Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�Û/ý�ôPÚ8û�Ú�Ùz×�ùbÛ�úÅôP¾�÷WÚfaf×Pô�õß8×�Ø+Ù��×PÜ�ÚÄôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø&öbØ+ÛÞ×PôPØ�,�ùb×�ØA¾�Ù6ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAß�×�Ú�ö,`ÿx×�Ü�ÚÄ÷#¾_ö�Ú�ø�à��%×�ó¤¾�ùbø+öm,�ÚÄö�Ú�ÛÞØ+ôPõ�,�ø+Ú�×P¾ÛÞù�ý�ý�øAÚ�÷#Ú�Ù`×X¾�ù�ô�ß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û(óUØA×PÜÌõpÙ�¾×�ÜbÚ�ô�Ø+Ù`×�Ú���ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù6×PÚ�ß?Ü�Ù�Ø�Gzù�Ú:óUÜ�ØAß?ÜÌ÷#¾�ôPÚú·õpØA×�Ü_úÅù�ø+øCÿ�ôPÚ�ý�ôP¾fö�ù�ß�Ú�Û�×PÜ�Ú�ôÞ¾×?õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõø/ö�ØAÛÞ×PôPØ1,bùb×�ØA¾�Ù&à���¾�×�ÜbØ+Û�Ú�Ù�ö&ü�ó�Úk,ÃÚ��Ø+Ùj,`ÿ

Â!� N

Page 175: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

öbÚ � Ù�ØAÙ��]¯ )s�_��� ç ûfØþõ � «�¯ )B����� ç � )B����� á «²â � ! � )]� á «²â ½ H � o ý I ��� � � á «²â8à���Ü�Ú�Ù¨ü� ¼ � ¯

´µ ¯ ¼ � ç ���"�o �c  « ¼ ��� á «²â�)s�_��� á «²â � � ¼ ����¯ )s�_��� ç á � àQN`âóUÜbÚ�ôPÚ ¼ � � á «²â � )B��� � á «²â ��¡ úž�ô(« ø�¢U£�ù « JsK ê���« J4L�M û à[��Ü�Ú9��T�lÊô�õp×PÚ|ØAÙz×P¾�×�ÜbÚ¯ n��  �%Æ E ç ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø_ØAÛ&×�Ü�Ú�Ùb��ØCû�Ú�Ù0,`ÿ � ïëí ¯ � ¼ ���¡¯ )B����� ç ¯ � àBh�Ú�ß!õÙ:Ú�øAØ+÷#Ø+ÙQõp×PÚ�×PÜ�Ú�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õ[y×P¾�ôÞÿ�ÙQõp×Pù�ôPÚU¾úÃ×�Ü�ÚU¾�û�Ú�ôPø+õýdØ+Ù`×�Ú���ô�õø�,zÿ2õý�ý�øCÿ_ØAÙ���×�ÜbÚ�hÊØ���Ù�Ú�ô/×�ô�õpÙ�ÛÞúž�ôÞ÷ ×P¾�,þ×PÜ)s����� á «²â�õÙ�ö ¼ ��� á «²âBàd�¤ôPØAÚ�{�ÿü ×PÜ�Ú�hÊØ1�Ù�Ú�ô�×Pô�õÙ�ÛFúž�ôP÷äß�¾�Ù`û�Ú�ôÞ×PÛ�õró¤õ�ûÚ�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù) á «²â�Ø+Ù`×�¾6õ�סó�¾py%ö�Ø+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�õø�ýbÜQõÛPÚBy¡ÛÞýQõß�Údö�ØAÛÞ×PôPØ1,bùb×�ØA¾�Ù�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�ÙH¤¦¥§# ¨ á «�� 7 ©¨â8à�%×�ØAÛ ��ØAûÚ�ÙU,`ÿ�ü

¤¦¥§# ¨ á «�� 7 ©&â � Âå[Z ¸¹ �"�o �  x© ) á « � © â ¸) á «@� © âbÚ�abý á � å Á 7 © © £ ¸¹ â á � à � â��ÜbÚ0��T9lèô�õ[×�Ú²÷�õ!ÿ�×�Ü�Ú�ÙC,ÃÚ�óUôPØA×Þ×�Ú�ÙÌõÛ�ü

�H� ª� Z � �Y�o � �Y�o �   «   7 ©*¤¦¥§# ¨ w1y � á «�� 7 ©&â�¤¦¥§# « y � á «�� 7 ©¨â á � à  ¡ â5(× � ôPÛF×b�øþõÙ�ß�Úü�ØA×Ä÷�õ�ÿ õpý�ý�Ú�õô�×�ÜQõ[×:ó�Ú d û�ÚrÛÞØ+÷#ý�øAÿÌß�¾�÷#ý�øAØ+ß!õ[×�Ú�ö]×PÜ�Ú�ýbôP¾3,_y

øAÚ�÷¬,`ÿÌØAÙz×PôP¾fö�ù�ß�Ø+Ù���סó�¾xØ+Ù`×�Ú���ô�õ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ûpõôPØ+õ�,�øAÚ�Û�ü�Ø+Ù�ÛF×�Ú�õö]¾ú¨cÞù�ÛF×�¾�Ù�Úpà0/�¾�ó¤Ú8û�Ú�ô�ü,ÃÚ�ß�õù�ÛÞÚ ¼ ��� á «²âXØ+Û�×�Ü�Ú�Ú�Ø1��Ú�Ù�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú2¾pú�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�é³¾úv×�ÜbÚ2¾�Ù�Ú8y%ö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾ÙQõøs/|õ÷#Ø+ø�y×P¾�Ù�Ø+õÙ&ü µ ����� á «�� 7 ©&â � 7 � ©å ¦�© �N½ ����� á «²â � é������ á � à Â2 â

Â!���

Page 176: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

×P¾�ø+¾�ó�Ú�ÛÞ×Fy¡¾�ôÞö�Ú�ô�ØAÙ ¸¹ ØC×�ß!õpÙ�,ÃÚvÛPÜb¾RóUÙ²×�Ü�õp×­¤¦¥§# « y � á «�� 7 ©¨â � ýO ï ëí � á éY� µ ����� á «�� 7 ©�âPâ8ü×PÜQõp×�Ø+Û�üx¤¦¥§# « y � ØAÛ�ÛÞØ+÷#ý�øAÿ�ý�ôP¾�ýþ�ôF×�Ø+¾ÙQõøb×P¾:×�ÜbÚ|ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õøQ÷�ØAß�ôÞ¾_ß�õÙ�¾�Ù�ØAß!õøbö�Ø+ÛF×�ôPØ�,�ù_y×PØ+¾�Ù¨àB��Üzù�Û�üz×PÜ�Ú(¾�ÛÞß�ØAø+øþõ[×�¾�ôFÿ�ÙQõp×Pù�ôPÚ(¾púÃ×PÜ�Ú(¾�û�Ú�ôPø+õý2Ø+Ù`×�Ú���ô�õpø_ÜQõpÛ�,�Ú�Ú�Ù2Ú�ø+Ø+÷#Ø+Ù�õp×�Ú�ö&à�Qù�ôF×�Ü�Ú�ôP÷#¾�ôPÚpü[×PÜ�Ú¤ØAÙ�ØA×PØþõøÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú¤öbØ+ÛÞ×PôPØ�,�ùb×�ØA¾�Ù9)B����� á «²â�÷�õ�ÿ�,ÃÚ�ôÞÚ!õÛÞ¾�ÙQõ�,bøAÿ:õý�ý�ôÞ¾gafyØA÷�õ[×�Ú�ö²óUØA×PÜ�õ:�`õù�ÛÞÛPØ+õÙ&üÛÞ¾X×PÜQõp×�ØA×�Û­hÊØ���Ù�Ú�ô ×�ôPõÙ�ÛFúž�ôP÷�ØAÛ�ØC×�ÛPÚ�øAúbõ<�`õpù�ÛPÛÞØþõÙ&àB��Ü�Ø+ÛôÞÚ�ÛÞù�øA×PÛ�Ø+ÙxõÙxØ+Ù`×PÚ���ôPõø�×PÜQõp×�ß�õÙU,�Ú�ôÞÚ!õö�ØAøAÿ�Ú�ûpõøAùQõp×�Ú�ö6ù�ÛPØAÙ���qC5[��/S®mqC5[� ��¯65:à��Ü�Ú�õ�,þRûÚ�õýbý�ôP¾`õpß?Ü�×�¾#×�Ü�ØAÛXý�õôÞ×PØ+ß�ùbøþõô�ÛFÿ_ÛF×�Ú�÷ ó¤õÛ|öbÚ�û�Ú�ø+¾�ýÃÚ�ö�Ø+Ùl�Ú8ú�à �� à

��ÜbØ+Û�ôPÚ8úÅÚ�ôÞÚ�Ù�ß�Ú¤õøAÛP¾�ß�¾�Ù`×?õØAÙ�Û õF��¾f¾_ö�ôÞÚ�ûfØ+Ú8óS¾úz×�ÜbÚ�hÊØ���Ù�Ú�ô¨×�ôPõÙ�ÛÞúžôP÷�úžôP÷�õø+ØAÛP÷�à°6h'± ²´³uµ�¶H·�t�µ¬¸�s]w ¹»ºgµ4¼<¶Hµ�µ4º�u#s�(�_^U��½ ¾SÐ���Íè�FÖ_Öb¢�� ��¥� Q��¢¤£���¥� b��Ö��ÜbÚV��T�lÈýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù#ô�õ[×�Ú�Û�ó�Ú�ôPÚ|ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PÚ�ö�úžôm×PÜ�Ú á  ¡3¡3¡ âf� á å ¡3¡3¡ â�� á å Â2 ¡ â��áÀ¿3¡3¡3¡ â�õÙ�ö á�¿ Â2 ¡ â�ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û�àk�(ó�¾ÌÛÞÚ�×�Û:¾ú(ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ó¤Ú�ôPÚ�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�ö&ü�ß�¾�ôÞôPÚ�ÛÞý�¾Ù�ö�Ø+Ù��×P¾Ä×PÜ�Ú�סó¤¾:ÛPÚ8×�Ûm¾ú],þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�¾�,b×?õØAÙ�Ú�ö¨à4��Ü�Ú�ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Û�õôPÚUý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×�Ú�ö�Ø+Ù"��õ�,bø+Ú�ÛÁ à å y � àh�Ú0,ÃÚ��Ø+ÙU,`ÿxÙ�¾×�ØAÙ���×�Ü�õp×�¾�Ù�øAÿ�×�Ü�ÚXÆ �  ¿ ôPõp×�Ú�ÛXõpôPÚ²ôPÚ�øþõp×PØAû�Ú�øAÿ�ÛÞ×?õ.,�ø+Úpà��ÜbÚ

ôPõp×�Ú�Û6ÛPÜ�¾�ó ÛÞØ1��ÙbØ � ß�õÙ`×6ö�Ø+ÛÞß�ôÞÚ�ýQõÙbß�Ø+Ú�ÛU,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�Ù�×PÜ�Ú�סó�¾�ÛÞÚ�×�Ûx¾ú0,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û Á ¡

Page 177: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

 ôÞ¾_öbù�ß�×SÃf×�õp×�Ú Ä�Ú�ß�õ�ÿml�õp×PÚ Â á Û oÆÅ â Ä�Ú�ß!õ!ÿUl�õp×PÚ å á Û oÆŠ⯠¡ �  ¿ ç Â^Q� P>Ç Â ¡ � Â^Q� P>Ç Â ¡ �¯ ¡ �  å ç N ^QÈ Á Ç Â ¡�É Â^� ¿ Ç Â ¡ ů ¡ � Â2 ç Â^Q�3� Ç Â ¡ É Â^ Á È Ç Â ¡ ɯ ¡ �  ¡ ç Â^ ¡�Ê Ç Â ¡ Å Â^�Â Ê Ç Â ¡ ů ¡ � È ç N ^ ¡ Â Ç Â ¡ � Ê ^ ¡ Â Ç Â ¡ �¯ ¡ �'N ç å ^ ¡ È Ç Â ¡ � Ê ^ ¡ Â Ç Â ¡ ů ¡ ��P ç Â^Q� N2Ç Â ¡ Å Á ^Q��Â Ç Â ¡ ů ¡ � � ç å ^ ¿ P>Ç Â ¡ � ¿ ^�ÂªÈ Ç Â ¡ �¯ ¡ � Á ç Â^ Ê È Ç Â ¡ ~ Â^ å ¿ Ç Â ¡ ~¯ ¡ � Ê ç �_^Q� Ê Ç Â ¡ ~ Á ^ ¿3¡ Ç Â ¡ ~¯ ¡ � ¿ ç Ê ^�Â Ê Ç Â ¡ O ¿ ^ å ¿ Ç Â ¡ O¯ ¡ � å ç Â^ Êo¡ Ç Â ¡�Ë Â^ å È Ç Â ¡�˯ ¡ �  ç Â^ N ¿ Ç Â ¡�Ë å ^ ¡�Ê Ç Â ¡�˯ ¡ � ¡ ç Á ^Q� å Ç Â ¡ O Á ^�ÂªÈ Ç Â ¡ O

��õ�,�øAÚ Á à å �6Ä�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�úžô�×PÜ�Ú á  ¡3¡3¡ â(ÛF×?õp×PÚà<¯¤¾�ø+ùb÷�Ù Â ��ØCû�Ú�ÛX×�ÜbÚ:ôPõp×�Ú�Ûß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��Ä×�¾�×PÜ�ÚS,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ|ß�¾÷�ý�ù_×�Ú�ö�ù�ÛPØAÙ���×PÜ�Ú � ôÞÛÞפÛPÚ�פ¾ú­,þga�öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù_yÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛ�௤¾�øAù�÷�Ù å ��ØCû�Ú�Û(×�Ü�Ú�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù���×P¾2×�Ü�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�öùbÛPØ+Ù��d×PÜ�Ú²ÛPÚ�ß�¾�Ù�ö�ÛPÚ8×X¾pú4,þgaxö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾Ù�Û�à Á Â

Page 178: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

 ôÞ¾_öbù�ß�×SÃf×�õp×�Ú Ä�Ú�ß�õ�ÿml�õp×PÚ Â á Û oÆÅ â Ä�Ú�ß!õ!ÿUl�õp×PÚ å á Û oÆŠ⯠ �  ¿ ç Â^ ¿ È Ç Â ¡ O Â^ ¿ È Ç Â ¡ O¯  �  å ç N ^ ¡ � Ç Â ¡ Å P ^� P>Ç Â ¡ ů  � Â2 ç Â^ ¿�Ê Ç Â ¡ ~ Â^ å È Ç Â ¡ ~¯  �  ¡ ç ¿ ^ ¡3¡ Ç Â ¡ ~ å ^ Á � Ç Â ¡ ~¯  � È ç Â^�Â2Â Ç Â ¡ � Ê ^ P å Ç Â ¡ ů  �'N ç P ^ P � Ç Â ¡ Å N ^ å N2Ç Â ¡ ɯ  ��P ç P ^ Á � Ç Â ¡ � Â^�ÂªÈ Ç Â ¡ ~¯  � � ç Â^ ¡ N2Ç Â ¡ ~ Â^ å ¿ Ç Â ¡ �¯  � Á ç å ^Q� Á Ç Â ¡ � Ê ^ Á � Ç Â ¡ �¯  � Ê ç å ^ Ê P>Ç Â ¡ ~ Á ^ Á�å Ç Â ¡ �¯  � ¿ ç È_^ Á Â Ç Â ¡ ~ Â^ Ê Â Ç Â ¡ O¯  � å ç Â^� ¿ Ç Â ¡ O Â^ N ¡ Ç Â ¡ O¯  �  ç Ê ^ Á P>Ç Â ¡ O ¿ ^ Ê3Ê Ç Â ¡ O¯  � ¡ ç P ^QÈ P>Ç Â ¡ O N ^ P å Ç Â ¡ O

��õ�,�øAÚ Á à ¿ �6Ä�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�úžô�×PÜ�Ú á å ¡3¡3¡ â(ÛF×?õp×PÚà<¯¤¾�ø+ùb÷�Ù Â ��ØCû�Ú�ÛX×�ÜbÚ:ôPõp×�Ú�Ûß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��Ä×�¾�×PÜ�ÚS,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ|ß�¾÷�ý�ù_×�Ú�ö�ù�ÛPØAÙ���×PÜ�Ú � ôÞÛÞפÛPÚ�פ¾ú­,þga�öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù_yÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛ�௤¾�øAù�÷�Ù å ��ØCû�Ú�Û(×�Ü�Ú�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù���×P¾2×�Ü�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�öùbÛPØ+Ù��d×PÜ�Ú²ÛPÚ�ß�¾�Ù�ö�ÛPÚ8×X¾pú4,þgaxö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾Ù�Û�à Áå

Page 179: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

 ôÞ¾_öbù�ß�×SÃf×�õp×�Ú Ä�Ú�ß�õ�ÿml�õp×PÚ Â á Û oÆÅ â Ä�Ú�ß!õ!ÿUl�õp×PÚ å á Û oÆŠ⯠ �  ¿ ç �_^ å Ê Ç Â ¡ Å �_^ ¿ Â Ç Â ¡ ů  �  å ç P ^ ¡ Á Ç Â ¡ Å È_^ ¿ Á Ç Â ¡ ů  � Â2 ç P ^ N ¿ Ç Â ¡ � �_^ ¡ P>Ç Â ¡ �¯  �  ¡ ç ¿ ^ Ê å Ç Â ¡ Å È_^ ¿ N2Ç Â ¡�ɯ  � È ç Á ^Q� Á Ç Â ¡ � ¿ ^QÈ N2Ç Â ¡ �¯  �'N ç N ^ å ¡ Ç Â ¡ Å Â^ ¡ P>Ç Â ¡ �¯  ��P ç ¿ ^Q��Â Ç Â ¡ Å ¿ ^� P>Ç Â ¡�ɯ  � � ç Ê ^ Ê P>Ç Â ¡ Å ¿ ^ Á Â Ç Â ¡ o �¯  � Á ç Èb^ Ê Á Ç Â ¡ oÆÅ �_^QÈ Á Ç Â ¡ ů  � Ê ç ¿ ^ N ¿ Ç Â ¡ ~ ¿ ^ P Ê Ç Â ¡ ~¯  � ¿ ç Ê ^Q��Â Ç Â ¡ � Ê ^� N2Ç Â ¡ �¯  � å ç ¿ ^QÈ�Â Ç Â ¡ ~ å ^ P Ê Ç Â ¡ ~¯  �  ç Â^�Â2Â Ç Â ¡ O Â^ å Â Ç Â ¡ O

��õ�,�øAÚ Á à Ê �6Ä�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�úžô�×PÜ�Ú á å Â2 ¡ â(ÛF×?õp×PÚà<¯¤¾�ø+ùb÷�Ù Â ��ØCû�Ú�ÛX×�ÜbÚ:ôPõp×�Ú�Ûß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��Ä×�¾�×PÜ�ÚS,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ|ß�¾÷�ý�ù_×�Ú�ö�ù�ÛPØAÙ���×PÜ�Ú � ôÞÛÞפÛPÚ�פ¾ú­,þga�öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù_yÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛ�௤¾�øAù�÷�Ù å ��ØCû�Ú�Û(×�Ü�Ú�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù���×P¾2×�Ü�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�öùbÛPØ+Ù��d×PÜ�Ú²ÛPÚ�ß�¾�Ù�ö�ÛPÚ8×X¾pú4,þgaxö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾Ù�Û�à Á ¿

Page 180: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

 ôÞ¾_öbù�ß�×SÃf×�õp×�Ú Ä�Ú�ß�õ�ÿml�õp×PÚ Â á Û oÆÅ â Ä�Ú�ß!õ!ÿUl�õp×PÚ å á Û oÆŠ⯠å �  ¿ ç Â^QÈ3È Ç Â ¡�Ë Â^QÈ N2Ç Â ¡�˯ å �  å ç Ê ^ ¿ Â Ç Â ¡ ~ ¿ ^ N å Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å � Â2 ç å ^ Á Ê Ç Â ¡ ~ Ê ^ å Ê Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å �  ¡ ç å ^�ª� Ç Â ¡ O Â^ P å Ç Â ¡ O¯ å � È ç å ^ Á Ê Ç Â ¡ O Â^ Á � Ç Â ¡ O¯ å �'N ç Â^ å ¡ Ç Â ¡ O Â^ å N2Ç Â ¡ O¯ å ��P ç È_^ P Â Ç Â ¡ ~ È_^� ¡ Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å � � ç Ê ^ P Â Ç Â ¡ � P ^ ¡�Ê Ç Â ¡ �¯ å � Á ç Á ^Q� ¡ Ç Â ¡ ~ å ^ Á Â Ç Â ¡ ů å � Ê ç Â^ ¡ P>Ç Â ¡ O È_^� ¡ Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å � ¿ ç Á ^ Êo¿ Ç Â ¡ O å ^QÈ å Ç Â ¡ O¯ å � å ç Â^ ¿ N2Ç Â ¡�Ë Â^ å Ê Ç Â ¡�˯ å �  ç �_^ P � Ç Â ¡ O Â^QÈ å Ç Â ¡�˯ å � ¡ ç Ê ^ ¡ È Ç Â ¡ O å ^�ª� Ç Â ¡ O

��õ�,�øAÚ Á à Á �6Ä�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�úžô�×PÜ�Ú áÀ¿3¡3¡3¡ â(ÛF×?õp×PÚà<¯¤¾�ø+ùb÷�Ù Â ��ØCû�Ú�ÛX×�ÜbÚ:ôPõp×�Ú�Ûß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��Ä×�¾�×PÜ�ÚS,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ|ß�¾÷�ý�ù_×�Ú�ö�ù�ÛPØAÙ���×PÜ�Ú � ôÞÛÞפÛPÚ�פ¾ú­,þga�öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù_yÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛ�௤¾�øAù�÷�Ù å ��ØCû�Ú�Û(×�Ü�Ú�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù���×P¾2×�Ü�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�öùbÛPØ+Ù��d×PÜ�Ú²ÛPÚ�ß�¾�Ù�ö�ÛPÚ8×X¾pú4,þgaxö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾Ù�Û�à Á Ê

Page 181: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

 ôÞ¾_öbù�ß�×SÃf×�õp×�Ú Ä�Ú�ß�õ�ÿml�õp×PÚ Â á Û oÆÅ â Ä�Ú�ß!õ!ÿUl�õp×PÚ å á Û oÆŠ⯠å �  ¿ ç Â^ å Â Ç Â ¡ O Â^ å Ê Ç Â ¡ O¯ å �  å ç Â^ Ê N2Ç Â ¡ � Ê ^ P å Ç Â ¡ �¯ å � Â2 ç Â^ N ¿ Ç Â ¡ ~ Â^Q� å Ç Â ¡ �¯ å �  ¡ ç ¿ ^ NoP>Ç Â ¡ ~ å ^ ¡�Ê Ç Â ¡ O¯ å � È ç Â^ ¡ N2Ç Â ¡ ~ Â^�Â Ê Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å �'N ç �_^ Ê Á Ç Â ¡ � P ^ Á3Á Ç Â ¡ ů å ��P ç å ^ Á Ê Ç Â ¡�É �_^ N ¿ Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å � � ç ¿ ^ ¿3¿ Ç Â ¡�É �_^Q� Á Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å � Á ç Á ^ Á È Ç Â ¡ � Ê ^ å È Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å � Ê ç Ê ^ N å Ç Â ¡ � �_^ N å Ç Â ¡ ~¯ å � ¿ ç ¿ ^� N2Ç Â ¡ O Ê ^ P Â Ç Â ¡ O¯ å � å ç å ^ å È Ç Â ¡ O ¿ ^Q��Â Ç Â ¡ O¯ å �  ç Á ^ ¡ � Ç Â ¡ ~ �_^ å ¿ Ç Â ¡ ~

��õ�,�øAÚ Á à � �6Ä�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�úžô�×PÜ�Ú áÀ¿ Â2 ¡ â(ÛF×?õp×PÚà<¯¤¾�ø+ùb÷�Ù Â ��ØCû�Ú�ÛX×�ÜbÚ:ôPõp×�Ú�Ûß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��Ä×�¾�×PÜ�ÚS,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ|ß�¾÷�ý�ù_×�Ú�ö�ù�ÛPØAÙ���×PÜ�Ú � ôÞÛÞפÛPÚ�פ¾ú­,þga�öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù_yÛÞØ+¾�ÙbÛ�௤¾�øAù�÷�Ù å ��ØCû�Ú�Û(×�Ü�Ú�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù���×P¾2×�Ü�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�öùbÛPØ+Ù��d×PÜ�Ú²ÛPÚ�ß�¾�Ù�ö�ÛPÚ8×X¾pú4,þgaxö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾Ù�Û�à Á�Á

Page 182: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

õpø+ôPÚ�õöbÿ�õp×(Æ �  å à<h�Ú:óUØAø+ø ö�Ø+ÛÞß�ù�ÛÞÛ�×�Ü�Ú:ôPÚ�õÛP¾�ÙbÛ|úž�ôX×PÜ�Ø+ÛXøþõp×PÚ�ô�Ø+ÙÌ×PÜ�Ø+ÛXÛPÚ�ß�×�ØA¾�Ù&àh�Ú6ÛPÜb¾�ù�ø+ö4Ù�¾p×�Úr×�Ü�õp×2¾�ù�ô2ÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿf×PØ+ß#÷�¾fö�Ú�ø(ù�ÛPØAÙ���×�ÜbÚ-hÊØ1��Ù�Ú�ô�×�ôPõÙ�ÛÞúžôP÷öbÚ!õøAÛUóUØC×�Üx×�Ü�ØAÛUý�ôP¾3,bø+Ú�÷ Gzù�ØC×�Ú�ó�Ú�ø+ø�àh�Ú²óUØ+ø+ø&õø+ÛÞ¾�ôÞÚ�×�ùbôPÙ�×P¾#×PÜ�Ø+ÛUø+õp×�Ú�ô�üÆ,�ùb×Uúž�ôÙb¾Ró°ó¤Ú�ÛPÜb¾�ù�ø+ö4Ù�¾p×�Ú6×�ÜQõ[×�ØC×2Ø+Ùbö�Ø+ß�õp×�Ú�Û�×�ÜQõp×2×PÜ�Ú�ô�õp×PÚ�Ûdö�ôP¾ý�¾.?�ÛPÜQõpôPý�øCÿSóUØA×PÜöbÚ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞØ+Ù��²ÆQü_ÛP¾�×�Ü�õp×(Ú�ÛPÛPÚ�Ù`×�Øþõpø+øAÿ�õøAø�¾pú�×�Ü�Ú�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù#¾fß�ß�ùbôPÛ(ØAÙz×P¾�×�ÜbÚ�Æ �  ¿ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�à@��Ü�Ú�Úfa_ýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õø�ö�ØAÛÞ×�ôÞØ1,�ù_×�Ø+¾Ù�ØAÛ�ß�¾�Ù�ÛPØAö�Ú�ôPõ�,�øCÿE,bôP¾`õöbÚ�ô�à  ¾ÛPÛPØ�,�ø+ÚôÞÚ!õÛÞ¾�Ù�Ûdúž�ô2×�Ü�ØAÛdö�Ø+ÛÞß�ôPÚ�ýQõÙ�ß8ÿ4óUØ+ø+ø6,�Ú�ö�Ø+ÛÞß�ù�ÛÞÛPÚ�ö&àÌ�Q¾�ô2Ù�¾�ó²ü(Ü�¾�ó�Ú�û�Ú�ô�ü�ó�Ú�óUØAø+øúžfß�ùbÛ¤¾�Ù�×PÜ�Ú(Æ �  ¿ ôPõp×�Ú�Û�úž�ô�×�ÜbÚ|ûpõôPØA¾�ù�Û,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_yvÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�übÛPØAÙ�ß�Ú�ó¤ÚS,�Ú�ø+Ø+Ú8û�Ú�×�ÜQõp××PÜ�Ú�ÛÞÚ�õpôPÚ�×�ÜbÚľÙ�øAÿ�¾�Ù�Ú�ÛU×�Ü�õp×�õôPÚ²ÛÞØ1��Ù�Ø � ß!õpÙz×�à��Ü�Ú²ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù6ôPõp×�Ú�úÅôÞ¾�÷�×PÜ�Ú á  ¡�¡3¡ â�ÛF×?õp×PÚ�×�¾2×�Ü�Úr¯ ¡ �  ¿ ç Úfa_ØA×�ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø

ó¤õÛ6ö�Ú8×�Ú�ôP÷#Ø+Ù�Ú�öN×�¾R,ÃÚ=7  P ¡ Û oÆÅ àÎÍ�ÛPØAÙ��S¾�ù�ô�ÛPÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿz×�Ø+ß�hÊØ���Ù�Ú�ô#×�ôPõÙ�ÛFyúžôP÷ õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü&ü ó¤Úd¾3,b×�õØ+ÙbÚ�ö�õxß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��xôPõp×�Úd¾ú  � Á P ¡ Û oÆÅ à"Ϥ¾×PÜ�×PÜ�Ú�ÛÞÚôPõp×�Ú�ÛÄõôPÚ2,ÃÚ�ø+¾�ó  � � ¡�¡ Û oÆÅ ü�óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü Ø+Û�ß�ù�ôPôÞÚ�Ù`×�øCÿ õôP¾�ùbÙ�ö]×�Ü�Ú#ø+¾�ó�Ú�ô�ø+ØA÷�ØC×|úž�ô²õpÙÚ�a_ý�Ú�ôPØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×�õø+øCÿr÷#Ú!õÛÞù�ô�õ�,bø+Ú�ô�õ[×�Úà��Üzù�Û�ü-ó�Ú:ÜQõ!ûÚ�÷�õÙQõ���Ú�ö6×�¾#ß�¾�Ù � ôP÷ ×�ÜbÚÄÚ�azyýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õpø�¾3,bÛPÚ�ôFûpõp×�ØA¾�Ù�×�Ü�õp×(×�ÜbÚ á  ¡�¡3¡ âmýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ô�õp×PÚ�Ø+Ûm×�¾f¾�ÛPøA¾�óÝ×P¾>,�Ú÷#Ú!õpÛPù�ôÞÚ�öUÐ Á �.Ñ à���¾×�Úm×�ÜQõp×�Ú�ûÚ�Ù2×�Üb¾�ù���ÜÄ×�Ü�Ú�Úfabõß�×võÙ�ö�ÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy�õpÙQõøAÿz×PØ+ßvôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Û�ö�ØAúþyúÅÚ�ô�,`ÿ2õ|ú·õß8×�¾�ô�¾ú-×�Ú�Ù2ØAÙ�×�Ü�ØAÛ�ß�õÛPÚpüz×PÜ�Ú�ÿ�õôPÚ¤Úfa_ý�Ú�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ùz×�õø+øCÿÄÚ�Gzù�ØAûpõøAÚ�Ù`×!ü�,�Ú�ß!õù�ÛÞÚõpø+ø�¾�ÙbÚXß�õÙ�ÛPõ�ÿ�õp×�×PÜ�Ø+Û�ýþ�Ø+Ù`×�õ�,þ�ùb×�×�Ü�Ú á  ¡3¡3¡ â/ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Ø+Ûv×PÜQõp×mØA×PÛmýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙôPõp×�Ú�ØAÛUø+Ú�ÛÞÛ(×�ÜQõpÙ Â � � ¡3¡ Û oÆÅ à

 Á �

Page 183: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�Q¾�ô�×PÜ�Ú á å ¡3¡3¡ â²ÛÞ×�õp×�Úpü�ó�ÚU��Ú�×2õÌû_Ø�,�ô�õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõø�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙSô�õ[×�ÚrØAÙz×P¾Ì×�ÜbÚ¯  �  ¿ ç ß?ÜQõÙ�Ù�Ú�ø²¾ú>7 Â Ê � ¡3¡3¡ Û oÆÅ üXóUÜ�ØAß?Ü�ØAÛ6÷�Ú�õÛPùbô�õ�,�øAÚàA��Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy�õpÙQõøAÿz×PØ+ßûpõøAù�Ú6Ø+Û Âª� � ¡3¡3¡ Û oÆÅ àE�¡Ùbö�Ú�Ú�ö&ü¤×�ÜbÚ á å ¡3¡3¡ â�ö�Ú�ß�õ�ÿ4ôPõp×�ÚxÜQõpÛ",ÃÚ�Ú�Ù�÷#Ú!õpÛPù�ôÞÚ�öX,`ÿq�Ø+ø+øAÚ�ô9Ð Á P Ñ üÃõøC×�Ü�¾�ù���ÜxõÙ�õß�×PùQõø�Ùzù�÷�,ÃÚ�ô�ó¤õÛXÙb¾×:��ØAûÚ�Ù&à��Ü�Ú�ôÞÚ�úž�ôÞÚüÃõøAø¨ó¤Ú²ß�õÙÛPõ!ÿ]õ�,þ�ùb×X×�Ü�Ú á å ¡3¡3¡ âUÛF×?õp×PÚ2õp×|×PÜ�Ø+Û|ý�¾�ØAÙ`×|ØAÛ|×�ÜQõ[×�¾�ù�ôXÙzù�÷�Ú�ôPØAß�Û�õôÞÚ�ß�¾Ù�ÛPØAÛÞ×�Ú�Ù`×óUØC×�Ü6×�ÜbÚ²ú·õpß�×U×�ÜQõ[×�×�Ü�ØAÛ�ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú²ÜQõÛ�õ2÷�Ú�õÛPùbô�õ�,�øAÚ�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù6ô�õp×PÚà�Q¾�ô�×PÜ�Ú á å Â2 ¡ â²ÛÞ×�õp×�Úpü�ó�ÚU��Ú�×2õÌû_Ø�,�ô�õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõø�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙSô�õ[×�ÚrØAÙz×P¾Ì×�ÜbÚ

¯  �  ¿ ç ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�¾ú�7 � ¡ Û oÆÅ ü�óUÜbØ+ß?Ü�ØAÛ:÷�ù�ß?Ü�×P¾_¾�ÛP÷�õø+ø�×�¾,ÃÚ#÷�Ú�õÛPù�ôÞÚ�ö&à���ÜbÚÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿf×PØ+ß2ûpõø+ùbÚrØ+Û Â � ¡ P ¡ Û oÆÅ àc5<�`õØAÙ&ü�óUÜ�ØAø+Ú�×PÜ�Ú�סó�¾ ôPõp×�Ú�ÛdõôPÚ�¾�?Ò,`ÿ õpÙ¾ôPö�Ú�ôv¾úÃ÷�õ��Ù�ØA×Pù�ö�Úü[×�Ü�Ú8ÿdõôÞÚF,�¾p×�ÜdÚfa_ýÃÚ�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ù`×?õøAøAÿÄÚ�Gzù�ØCûõpø+Ú�Ù`×�ü`ÛPØ+Ùbß�Ú(×�ÜbÚ�ÿ�,þ×PÜýbôPÚ�öbØ+ß�×�×PÜQõp×�×PÜ�Úvý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ô�õp×PÚvØ+Û¨×P¾_¾�ÛÞø+¾�ó ×�¾�,�Úv÷#Ú!õpÛPù�ôÞÚ�ö&àB�¡Ù�ö�Ú�Ú�ö&ü[ØA×�ÜQõpÛ,ÃÚ�Ú�Ù�¾3,�ÛÞÚ�ôFû�Ú�ö�Ú�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õpø+øAÿ-,zÿ�q�ØAø+ø+Ú�ô(×�ÜQõ[×|×�ÜbÚ á å Â2 ¡ â(ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ú�Û×P¾_¾dÛÞø+¾�óUøAÿ�×�¾dÜQõ!û�Ú:õ2÷�Ú�õÛPù�ôPõ�,�øAÚ�ô�õp×PÚàh�Ú�ß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�Ú�ö�×�ÜbÚ�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ùrô�õp×PÚ�¾ú ×�ÜbÚ á�¿3¡�¡3¡ âmÛF×?õp×PÚ�Ø+Ù`×�¾�×PÜ�Ú�¯ å �  ¿ ç

Ú�a_ØA×�ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø:×�¾E,�ÚR7 å ¡3¡ � ¡3¡3¡ Û oÆÅ üÄõÛ�ß�¾�÷#ýQõôÞÚ�öÝóUØA×�Ü�×�Ü�Ú�Úfa_ý�Ú�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ùz×�õø+øCÿ÷#Ú!õpÛPù�ôÞÚ�ö�ûpõøAù�Úx¾ú Â å ¡ � ¡3¡�¡ Û oÆÅ àÒ��Ü�Ú�ß�¾ôPôPÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ���ÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿf×PØ+ßrôÞÚ�ÛÞù�øA×#Ø+ÛÂg� ¡ � ¡3¡�¡ Û oÆÅ à�+�ù�ô�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PÚ�ö�ô�õp×PÚ:ØAÛU×PÜzù�ÛXó�Ú�øAø óUØC×�Ü�ØAÙ�×PÜ�Ú�¾ôPö�Ú�ôX¾ú�÷�õ.��Ù�ØA×Pù�ö�Ú¾pú�×PÜ�Ú²÷�Ú�õÛPù�ôÞÚ�ö�ô�õp×PÚà��ØAÙQõøAøAÿ�ü�×�Ü�ÚdûfØ1,�ôPõp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù]ô�õp×PÚ#¾pú¤×�ÜbÚ áÀ¿ Â2 ¡ â�ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú#Ø+Ù`×�¾6×�ÜbÚ

 Á P

Page 184: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

¯ å �  ¿ ç Úfa_ØA×�ß?ÜQõÙ�Ù�Ú�ø¤ó¤õÛdß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�Ú�ö�×�¾H,ÃÚm7  å � ¡�¡3¡ Û oÆÅ àc��Ü�Ú6ÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy�õpÙQõøAÿz×PØ+ßûpõøAù�Ú�ó¤õÛ2Px� � ¡3¡ Û oÆÅ à���Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚrûpõø+ù�Ú�Û�ü/óUÜ�ØAø+ÚdóUØA×PÜ�Ø+Ù�õÙ ¾�ôPöbÚ�ô�¾púU÷�õ��Ù�ØA×Pù�ö�Ú#¾ú×PÜ�ÚU÷�Ú�õÛPùbôPÚ�ö#ô�õ[×�ÚüzÛÞÚ�Ú�÷ ÛÞ¾�÷#Ú�óUÜQõp×møA¾Ró²üo�ØAû�Ú�Ù#×PÜQõp×�×�ÜbÚ áÀ¿ Â2 ¡ â�ø+ØCúÅÚ�×�ØA÷�Ú�Ø+Ûv¾�ÙbøAÿסóUØAß�ÚdõÛ�øA¾�Ù��xõÛ�×PÜ�Ú á�¿�¡3¡3¡ âXøAØAúÅÚ8×�Ø+÷#ÚkÐ Ê3Ê Ñ à0h�Ú2ö�¾Ù d ײÜ�õ�ûÚ#õÙ�Úfa_ý�øþõpÙQõp×�ØA¾�ÙÌúž�ô×PÜ�Ø+Û�ö�Ø+ÛÞß�ôÞÚ�ýQõÙbß�ÿ�übÛPØ+Ùbß�Ú|×PÜ�Ú|Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�Û¤ÛPÚ�Ú�÷°ú·õØAôPøCÿ2ß�øAÚ!õô�ß�ùb×�à+�ÙbÚ�ý�¾ÛPÛPØ�,�Ø+øAØAסÿ2¾Ù×PÜ�Ú(ß�¾�÷�ýbùb×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù�õøzÛPØ+öbÚ¤ÜQõÛ�×�¾�ö�¾|óUØC×�Ü�×PÜ�Ú¤ú·õß8×/×�Ü�õp×�×PÜ�Ú¤ó¤õ�ûÚ�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù2×?õØAø+Û�õôPÚ×PÜ�Ú2÷�õØ+Ù�ß�¾�Ù`×�ôÞØ1,�ùb×P¾�ôPÛ�×P¾r×�Ü�Ú2ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙÌô�õp×PÚ�Û�àb��Ü�Ø+Û|×PÚ�Ù�öbÛ²×P¾6÷�õ.�Ú�×�ÜbÚôPõp×�Ú�Û²ÛP¾�÷#Ú�óUÜQõ[ײÛPÚ�ÙbÛPØA×PØAûÚd×P¾6×�Ü�Ú2ÛÞÜQõýÃÚ#¾pú�×PÜ�Ú2,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�à#T²ØCû�Ú�Ù]×PÜQõpײ¾�ù�ô,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��Ø+Ú�ÛÄסÿfý�Ø+ß�õø+øCÿ�ÜQõ!û�ÚrÚ�ôPôP¾ôPÛ�¾�Ù ×�Ü�Ú�¾�ôPö�Ú�ô�¾ú  ¡ �  Á3Ó ü�×PÜ�Ú�ôÞÚß�¾�ù�øAöÔ,�Ú�ÛÞùba#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×xÚ�ôÞôP¾�ôÞÛxõp×r×�ÜbÚÌ×?õØAø+Û#×�¾SÛÞØ1��Ù�Ø � ß!õpÙz×PøAÿNõ.?�Ú�ß�×�×�Ü�Ú�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�öôPõp×�Ú�Û�à5XÙ�¾×�ÜbÚ�ô�ôPÚ!õpÛP¾�ÙÌúžôU×PÜ�ÚÄø+¾�ó áÀ¿ Â2 ¡ â(ôPõp×�ÚÄ÷�õ!ÿ6øAØ+Ú²Ø+Ùx×�ÜbÚ�õ�,�Ø+Ù�ØC×�ØA¾�ý�¾p×�Ú�Ù`×PØþõø

ØC×�ÛÞÚ�øAú�àBh�Ú²ö�ØAÛÞ×�¾ôÞ×�Ú�ö6×�Ü�Ú Â ®Ã�õß�ß�¾�ôÞö�Ø+Ù��d×P¾2×�Ü�Ú²Ú�GzùQõ[×�Ø+¾Ù ½ êgÕÀÖ á «���¬��?ºâ � ½ Õ�×�Øá  Ø@�pâ á ½ �;Ù 9 á «��P¬$��º�â6� ½ Õ_×�â8ü�óUÜbÚ�ôPÚ ½ Õ�× � � å ¡ å ^OÈ å N2ß�÷ oÆÅ ØAÛÄ×PÜ�Ú�ûpõøAù�Ú#¾ú(×�ÜbÚ ®Ã�õp×�×�ÜbÚ#Ú�Gzù�Ø+øAØ1,�ôÞØ+ù�÷ 5Xô(/S��ß�¾�Ù � ��ùbô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù&ü&õÙ�öc��Ø+Û²õröbØ+øþõ[×�Ø+¾ÙÌýQõôPõ÷#Ú�×�Ú�ô�à�Q¾�ôF� ��¡ ^� ó¤Ú�úž�ùbÙ�ö6×�ÜQõp×�×PÜ�ÚUÆ �  ¿ ô�õp×PÚ�Û�Ø+Ùbß�ôPÚ�õÛPÚ�öU,zÿ6õ2ú·õpß�×�¾ô(¾ú å úž�ô¤×�ÜbÚáÀ¿ Â2 ¡ â�ÛF×?õp×PÚüQõÙbö-,`ÿ6õ�,þ�ùb× Á ¡ Ó úž�ô�×PÜ�Ú áÀ¿3¡3¡3¡ âvÛÞ×�õp×�Úpà�-¾ô6� ��¡ ^ å üz×�ÜbÚ�Æ �  ¿ôPõp×�Ú�Ø+Ù�ß�ôPÚ�õÛPÚ�ö�,zÿ�õÙ�¾p×�Ü�Ú�ô�ú·õß�×P¾�ôľú å úž�ôÄ×�Ü�Ú áÀ¿ Â2 ¡ â²ÛF×?õp×PÚü�õÙ�öj,zÿ ¿3¿ Ó úž�ô×PÜ�Ú á�¿3¡3¡�¡ â¤ÛÞ×�õp×�ÚpàF�Q¾�ô:� � � ¡ ^� üQ×�ÜbÚXÆ �  ¿ ôPõp×�Ú�Û�úž�ô�,þ×�Ü á�¿ Â2 ¡ â(õÙbö á�¿�¡3¡3¡ â

 Á N

Page 185: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

öbôP¾�ý�ýÃÚ�öY,`ÿ�õ²ú·õß�×P¾�ôm¾ú å ü_õÙ�ö#×�Ü�Ú�Ùrõ���õØ+Ù",`ÿ�õpÙ�¾×�ÜbÚ�ô�ú·õß�×P¾�ô�¾pú å úžô§� � � ¡ ^ å à5 ú·õpß�×�¾ô2¾ú å ¾ô Ê ØAÙ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞÚ6Ø+Ù4¾�ù�ô2ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�ö Æ �  ¿ ô�õp×PÚ�,�ôPØAÙ���Û�×PÜ�Úrûpõø+ù�Úùbý�×�¾ å Ê � ¡3¡3¡ Û oÆÅ ¾�ô Ê N�� ¡3¡�¡ Û oÆÅ ü�óUÜbØ+ß?Ü�Ø+Û�õpø+ôPÚ�õöbÿ�Ø+Ù]÷�ù�ß?ÜH,�Ú8×P×PÚ�ô²õ���ôÞÚ�Ú�÷�Ú�Ùz×óUØC×�Ü�Ú�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×!à��X¾p×�Ú�×�Ü�õp×r×�ÜbÚ]ö�Ø+ÛF×�¾�ôF×�Ø+¾ÙÈØ+ÛrôÞÚ�ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú�øCÿ�ÛP÷�õø+øXõôP¾ù�Ù�öÈ×�ÜbÚÚ�Gzù�Ø+øAØ1,�ôÞØ+ù�÷Ú5Xô(/<��ß�¾�Ù � ��ù�ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù&ü_õÙ�örÛÞ¾�¾�Ù�øCÿY,ÃÚ�ß�¾�÷#Ú�Û�õýbý�ôPÚ�ß�Øþõ.,�ø+ÚUóUÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ|×�ÜbÚ5Xô(/<��ý�¾p×�Ú�Ù`×PØþõø8,ÃÚ�ß�¾÷�Ú�Û(øþõô���Úüz×�Ü�õp×(ØAÛ�üzúž�ô¤ÛÞ÷�õøAø-«�à[��Ü�Ø+Û�ÛPù�����Ú�ÛF×�Û(×�Ü�õpפ×PÜ�Ú�ôÞÚß�¾�ù�øAöH,�Ú�Ú�ôPôÞ¾�ôPÛ²õp×|ÛP÷�õø+ø�« Ø+Ù�×PÜ�Ú2õ�,]ØAÙ�ØA×PØ+¾  ®ÃÌ×�ÜQõ[×�ó¤¾ù�ø+ö�õß�ß�¾�ùbÙz×�úžôX×�ÜbÚôPõp×�Ú�öbØ+ÛPß�ôPÚ�ýQõÙ�ß�Ø+Ú�Û/óUØC×�ÜdÚfa_ýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×!à�¯¤Ú�ôÞ×�õØ+ÙbøAÿÄ×�Ü�Ú�õ�,þ�û�Ú�ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�ÛvØAÙ�ö�Ø+ß�õp×�Ú�×�ÜQõp××PÜ�Ø+Û�ôÞÚ�Gzù�ØAôPÚ�ÛUúÅù�ôF×�Ü�Ú�ô�Ø+Ù`û�Ú�ÛÞ×�Ø��`õp×PØ+¾�Ù&à�(ó�¾6úÅÚ!õp×Pù�ôPÚ�Û�¾ú�Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPÚ�ÛÞ×ÄõôÞÚ:×�ÜbÚ2ÛÞ×�ôÞ¾�Ù��6n�y¡öbÚ�ýÃÚ�Ù�ö�Ú�Ù�ß�Ú2¾púm×PÜ�Ú�ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõ[y

×PØ+¾�ÙxôPõp×�Ú�Û�ü-õÙ�öx×�ÜbÚÄÛF×?õ�,bØ+ø+Ø Ä ØAÙ���Ú�?�Ú�ß8×X×PÜQõp×�¾fß�ß�ùbôPÛ�óUÜ�Ú�ÙC�äØAÛ�ØAÙ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞÚ�öxúÅôP¾�÷ ¡×P¾  à[��Ü�Ú � ôÞÛÞ×�úÅÚ�õp×�ù�ôÞÚ�ß!õÙU,ÃÚ�Úfa_ý�ø+õØ+Ù�Ú�ö�,`ÿrÙ�¾×PØ+Ù���×PÜQõp×UõpÛ�n�ØAÛ(Ø+Ù�ß�ôPÚ�õÛPÚ�ö&üb×�ÜbÚõ!ûÚ�ô�õ.��Ú�/S�@,�¾Ù�öSø+Ú�Ù��×PÜ�Ø+Ùbß�ôPÚ�õÛPÚ�Û�üvõpÙ�öSÛP¾�×�Ü�Úk/S�èÚ�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+Ú�Ù�ß�Ú�Û�÷�¾ôPÚ#¾ú(×�ÜbÚõpÙ�ÜQõôÞ÷�¾�ÙbØ+ß�ØCסÿr¾ú�×�Ü�Ú05|ô(/<��ØAÙ`×�Ú�ôPõß�×PØ+¾�Ù¨à ��Ü�Ú�ôÞÚ�ÛPùbøA×XØ+Û�õÙÌØAÙ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞÚ�ö�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��×P¾6×�Ü�Ú2¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ��6ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ü�õÙ�ö ß�¾Ù�ÛPÚ�GfùbÚ�Ù`×�øCÿ õ6ú·õpÛÞ×�Ú�ô�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù]ô�õp×PÚà���ÜbÚÚf?¨Ú�ß�×|Ø+ÛUö�ô�õp÷�õp×PØ+ßp���ÜbÚ á�¿�¡3¡3¡ â(ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ùxô�õp×PÚ²Ø+Û å � ¿ ¾�ôPöbÚ�ôPÛX¾ú/÷�õ���ÙbØCy×Pù�ö�ÚÄøþõô���Ú�ô�×PÜQõÙ�×PÜ�Ú á  ¡3¡�¡ â(ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ôPõp×�Ú á öbÚ�ýÃÚ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ���¾Ù�óUÜ�Ú8×�Ü�Ú�ô|¾�ÙbÚùbÛPÚ�Û�×PÜ�Ú6Úfabõß8×d¾�ô�ÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿf×PØ+ß á  ¡�¡3¡ âÄôÞÚ�ÛÞù�øA×?â8àH�¡Ù�ö�Ú�Ú�ö&ü§Û�ø+Ú�÷�ýÃÚ�ôÞÚ�ô�õpÙ�ö ß�¾pyó�¾�ô��Ú�ôÞÛUÜQõ!û�Ú²õô���ù�Ú�ör×PÜQõp×Uõ�n O ýþ�ó¤Ú�ô�øþõ!óÊö�Ú�ÛÞß�ôÞØ1,ÃÚ�Û(×�ÜbÚ�ýQõp×P×PÚ�ôÞÙ6¾ú�×�Ü�Ú á n ¡3¡3¡ â

 Á È

Page 186: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù6ôPõp×�Ú�Û0Ð Ê3Ê Ñ à��Ü�ÚÄÛPÚ�ß�¾�Ùbö�úÅÚ�õp×�ù�ôÞÚ²ß!õÙU,ÃÚÄÚ�a_ý�øþõØAÙ�Ú�öU,`ÿ6Ù�¾p×�Ø+Ù��d×PÜQõp×UØAÙ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞØ+Ù��>� úÅôP¾�÷ ¡

×P¾  ý�ø+õß�Ú�Û/ÛP¾�÷#Ú¤¾púQ×�Ü�Ú�/<�ÌôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ØAÙ`×�¾|×PÜ�Ú(ý�ø+õÙ�Ú¤ýÃÚ�ôÞý�Ú�Ù�ö�ØAß�ù�ø+õô�×P¾�×�Ü�ÚF5Xô(/<�ûpõÙ]öbÚ�ôVh�õ�õø+ÛXû�Ú�ß8×�¾�ô豫�à���Ü�Ø+Û�ôÞÚ�ö�ùbß�Ú�Û�×PÜ�Ú2Úfaf×�Ú�Ù`×Ä×P¾róUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü]×PÜ�Ú2/S�ÈÛPõ÷�ýbø+Ú�Û×PÜ�Ú�õÙ�ØAÛP¾×PôP¾�ý`ÿ2¾ú�×�Ü�Ú�5Xô(/S��Ø+Ù`×PÚ�ô�õpß�×�ØA¾�ÙdØ+Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú(×PÜ�Ú�ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õøbó�Ú�øAø�à4��Üzù�Û�ü_óUÜ�ØAø+Ú×PÜ�Ø+Û²ôÞÚ�ÛPùbøA×�ÛÄØ+Ù�×�ÜbÚY� �  ,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Ûb,ÃÚ�ØAÙ���÷�¾�ôÞÚ�ó¤Ú�õ��zøAÿc,þ�ù�Ù�ö ×�ÜQõÙ�×�ÜbÚ� �Ü¡ ,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�ü ×�ÜbÚ�Ø+ô�øAØAúÅÚ8×�Ø+÷#Ú�Û|õôPÚdß�¾�Ù�ÛPØAö�Ú�ôPõ�,�øCÿ]ø+¾�Ù���Ú�ô�à>��Ü�Ø+Û²õß�ß�¾�ùbÙz×PÛúžô¤×�Ü�Ú á å ¡3¡�¡ â�ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ôPõp×�ÚS,�Ú�Ø+Ù��2÷#Ú!õÛÞù�ô�õ.,�ø+Úpü�,�ùb×�×PÜ�Ú�ß�¾�÷�ýbùb×�Ú�ö�ôPõp×�Úúžô á å Â2 ¡ â4,�Ú�Ø+Ù���×P¾_¾²ÛPøA¾�ó�×P¾0,ÃÚU÷�Ú�õÛPù�ôPõ�,�øAÚà45XÛ�Ù�¾×�Ú�ö�õ.,�¾�û�Úpü_¾ù�ô�ß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û÷�õ!ÿc,�Úr¾�ûÚ�ôPÚ�ÛÞ×PØ+÷�õp×�ØAÙ��Ì×�ÜbØ+Û�Úf?¨Ú�ß�×!üvÛÞØ+Ù�ß�Ú�×�ÜbÚ6ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PÚ�ö ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ôPõp×�Ú¾pú/×�Ü�Ú á�¿�¡3¡3¡ â(ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú:Ø+Û�õý�ýbôP¾ga_Ø+÷�õp×�Ú�øAÿ å ¡ ×�ØA÷�Ú�Û�ø+õô��Ú�ô�×�ÜQõpÙ�×�Ü�õp×|¾pú�×�ÜbÚ á�¿ Â2 ¡ âÛF×?õp×PÚà�(�_^U�%� ¾SÐ��Ý��¢v b¥� Q��¢¤£�¥��rÍè�FÖz �Î-��Þ�ÒX ��F¢�£5XÛ�÷#Ú�Ù`×PØ+¾�Ù�Ú�öNý�ôÞÚ�ûfØ+¾ù�ÛPøCÿ�ü¤ó�ÚÌÚ�Ù�ß�¾�ùbÙz×PÚ�ôÞÚ�ö�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôPØAß!õø�öbØAa#ß�ù�øC×�ØAÚ�Ûdß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PØ+Ù��×PÜ�Ú�ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙxôPõp×�Ú�Û�õøAôPÚ!õpöbÿ6úž�ô�Æ �  å à���Ü�ØAÛ�óUØAø+ø­,ÃÚ�õöbö�ôPÚ�ÛPÛPÚ�ö]ÛPÜ�¾ôÞ×�øCÿ�ü,bùb×�úž�ô�Ùb¾Ró�ó�Ú6ÛPÜ�¾ù�ø+ö Ù�¾p×�Ú�×PÜQõp×�×PÜ�Ú6ÛPÚ�÷�Ø�y�õÙQõpøAÿz×�ØAß�õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü�,QõÛÞÚ�ö4¾�ÙS×�ÜbÚhÊØ���Ù�Ú�ô�×Pô�õÙ�ÛFúž�ôP÷ ö�ØAö®Ù�¾×�Ú�Ùbß�¾�ù�Ù`×PÚ�ô�õÙ`ÿÝÛPù�ß?ÜæÙzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß!õpøÄöbØAa#ß�ù�øC×�ØAÚ�Û�à¬��¾

ª� ¡

Page 187: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�Ú�×2õpÙSØ+ö�Ú�õ�¾ú¤óUÜQõp×�¾ù�ô�ß�¾�÷�ýbùb×�Ú�öSôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõøvöbØ+ÛÞ×PôPØ�,�ùb×�ØA¾�Ù ÛPÜ�¾�ùbø+öSøA¾_¾3�Ìø+Ø1�pÚüó�Úrß�¾�÷�ýbùb×�Ú�öS×�Ü�ÚrýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ô�õp×PÚ�Û�úžô:×�ÜbÚ á�¿3¡�¡3¡ âu,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚrØ+Ù`×P¾�×�ÜbÚ¯ n � å �¡Æ �  å � Â2 �  ¡ � È Úfa_ØA×#ß?ÜQõpÙ�Ù�Ú�øAÛ�àÌ��Ü�Ú�ÛPÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿz×�Ø+ß�ôPÚ�ÛÞù�øA×PÛ�õpôPÚ �Ú�å�Á Û oÆÅ � ¡ ^� å Û oÆÅ � ¡ ^ ¡�¡  Á Û oÆÅ � ¡ ^ ¡�¡3¡ ÂªÈ Û oÆÅ ôÞÚ�ÛÞý�Ú�ß�×�ØCû�Ú�øAÿ�àß5ìÛPØA÷�ØAøþõô²ýQõp×Þ×�Ú�ôPÙ ó(õpÛ¾�,b×?õØAÙ�Ú�ö6óUØC×�Üx×�Ü�Ú²¾×PÜ�Ú�ôUÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ü-óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü�ýÃÚ�ôPÛÞØ+ÛF×�ÛXõø+øÃ×�Ü�Ú²ó(õ!ÿxö�¾�óUÙ�×�¾2×�Ü�ÚÄø+¾�ó(yCcß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø+Û�à�T�ØAû�Ú�Ù]×�ÜQõpײ×PÜ�ÚdÛPÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿz×�Ø+ß�õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?ÜcGzùQõÙ`×�ØC×?õp×PØAû�Ú�øAÿÌôPÚ�ýbôP¾fö�ù�ß�Ú�Û×PÜ�ÚdÆ �  ¿ ôPõp×�Ú�Û�üvó�Úm,ÃÚ�øAØ+Ú8û�Úr×�Ü�õp×�×�ÜbØ+Û2Ø+Û�ÛÞ×�ôÞ¾�Ù���Ú�ûfØAö�Ú�Ù�ß�Ú6×�ÜQõp×dÙzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�õø+øCÿÚ�ÛPÛÞÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø+øCÿ#õø+øQ¾ú¨×�Ü�ÚXý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�¾fß�ß�ù�ôPÛ�Ø+Ù`×�¾Ä×�Ü�Ú¤Æ �  ¿ ß?ÜQõÙ�ÙbÚ�ø�ü_õÙ�ö�×�ÜQõp××PÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ¤ØAÛ�õUÛPÜQõpôPý&ü�ß�¾�Ù`×�ØAÙfùb¾�ù�Û�öbÚ�ß!õ!ÿÄØ+ÙÄ×�Ü�Úmý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙÄô�õp×PÚ�Û óUØA×�Ü:ö�Ú�ß�ôPÚ�õÛPØAÙ��ÆQà�%×XØ+ÛUýþ�ÛPÛÞØ1,�øAÚ²×PÜQõp×�×�Ü�Ú9hÊØ1�Ù�Ú�ô�yZ,QõÛÞÚ�öÌõý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?ÜÌÛÞ¾�÷#Ú�óUÜQõp×Xù�Ù�öbÚ�ôPÚ�ÛÞ×PØ+÷�õp×�Ú�Û

×PÜ�Ú2Æ �  å õÙ�öSøA¾�ó¤Ú�ô�ô�õp×PÚ�Û�àH��Ü�Úr÷�õØ+Ù�ß�¾�Ù`×�ôÞØ1,�ù_×�Ø+¾Ù�×�¾�×�Ü�ÚrýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙôPõp×�ÚXß�¾�÷#Ú�ÛmúÅôP¾�÷ ×PÜ�Ú|ØAÙ�Ù�Ú�ôm×?õØAøQôPÚ���Ø+¾�Ù�¾ú�×�ÜbÚS,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�à[��Ü�ØAÛ¤Ø+Û�ö�ù�Ú�×�¾�סó�¾ú·õpß�×�¾ôPÛ��4��Ø+ôÞÛÞ×�üz×PÜ�ÚUØ+Ù`×�Ú�ô�õß8×�ØA¾�Ù�ýþ×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø�,ÃÚ�ß�¾÷�Ú�Û�ø+õô���Ú�ØAÙ#×PÜ�ÚUØ+Ù�ÙbÚ�ôv×?õØAøQôPÚ���Ø+¾�ÙóUÜbÚ�ôPÚU«�ØAÛ�ÛP÷�õøAø�àBÃ_Ú�ß�¾�Ù�ö&ü�úžô/«�ÛP÷�õø+øAÚ�ô ×�ÜQõpÙ�×�Ü�Ú(ß�øþõÛÞÛPØAß!õøfØ+Ù�ÙbÚ�ô�×Pù�ôPÙ�ØAÙ���ýþ�Ø+Ù`×¾púf×PÜ�Ú�¾�ùb×���¾�Ø+Ù��(ß?ÜQõÙ�ÙbÚ�ø+Û�ü[×PÜ�Úv¾�ùb×���¾�ØAÙ��(ó(õ!ûÚ�úÅù�Ù�ß8×�ØA¾�Ù�Û�õôPÚvÙb¾�øA¾�Ù���Ú�ô&¾�ÛÞß�Ø+øAøþõp×P¾�ôÞÿüÛÞ¾�×�ÜQõ[×(×�Ü�Ú�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��:óUØA×�Ür×PÜ�ÚV,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�öb¾_Ú�Û(Ù�¾× �Ú�×Uß!õpÙ�ß�Ú�ø+ø+Ú�ö&à���Ü�Ú²øA¾Ró�Ú�ôÆQüz×�Ü�Ú|ÛP÷�õø+øAÚ�ôm«®ôPÚ�GfùbØ+ôPÚ�ö�×�¾b,�ÚXØ+Ù�×PÜ�Ú|ß�øþõÛÞÛPØAß!õøAøAÿ�úž�ô�,�Ø+öbö�Ú�ÙrôÞÚ���ØA¾�Ù&üfõÙ�ö�Ü�Ú�Ù�ß�Ú×PÜ�ÚÄÛP÷�õø+øAÚ�ô¤×PÜ�Ú:ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��d×?õpØ+ø+Û�¾pú�×�ÜbÚ0,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�à§5|ø+ôÞÚ!õö_ÿrúž�ômÆ �  å ü

ª�bÂ

Page 188: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

×PÜ�Ú2Ø+÷#ýþ�ôÞ×�õÙ`×|ØAÙz×PÚ���ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù�ôÞÚ���ØA¾�Ù�Ø+Û|ÛPùba#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×�øCÿ�ö�Ú�Ú�ý Ø+ÙÌ×PÜ�Ú2Ø+ÙbÙ�Ú�ô|×�õØ+ø�ôPÚ���Ø+¾�Ù×PÜQõp×�×PÜ�Ú�ôPÚ�ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú�øAÿ�ôPõý�ØAö�øAÿXö�Ú�ß�õ!ÿ_ØAÙ��:�`õù�ÛÞÛPØþõpÙ � × ß�¾�ù�øAö:ù�Ùbö�Ú�ôÞÚ�ÛÞ×PØ+÷�õp×�Ú/×PÜ�Úvûpõø+ù�Ú¾pú�×�Ü�Ú�ØAÙ�ØA×PØþõøbÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�ö�ØAÛÞ×PôPØ1,bùb×�ØA¾�Ù&à4��ÜbÚ�ý�ôP¾3,bø+Ú�÷ óUØC×�Ürß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ß�×PØ+Ù��:×�Ü�ØAÛ¤Ø+Ûm×�ÜQõ[פ×�ÜbÚ×�õØ+øAÛ�õpôPÚ�õøAôPÚ�õöbÿ:ÛPùba#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×�øCÿ�ÛÞ÷�õpø+øz×�ÜQõp×�×�Ü�Ú�öbØ+ÛPß�ôPÚ�ýQõÙ�ß8ÿ�Ø+Û�Ù�¾×/ûÚ�ôFÿ2Ù�¾×PØ+ß�Ú�õ�,�øAÚà��ÜbØ+Û¤ØAÛ�Ùb¾×(ýQõpôÞ×�ØAß�ù�ø+õôv×�¾�×PÜ�Ú<hÊØ���Ù�Ú�ô¤õýbý�ôP¾`õpß?Ü&ü�,�ù_×(ô�õ[×�Ü�Ú�ô¤ôPÚ8{QÚ�ß8×�Û�¾�ÙbÚ|ÛP¾ù�ôPß�Ú¾pú|ö�ØCa#ß�ù�øCסÿSØ+Ù ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�ØAÙ��]ø+¾�ó�Ú�ô²Æ ô�õp×PÚ�Û��U��Ü�ÚxøA¾Ró�Ú�ô²Æ ô�õp×PÚ�Û2��Ú8×2×�Ü�Ú�Ø+ô�÷�õØ+Ùß�¾�Ù`×�ôÞØ1,�ùb×PØ+¾�Ù]úÅôÞ¾�÷�×PÜ�Ú2ú·õô�×?õØAø�ôPÚ���Ø+¾Ù�Û²¾ú�×PÜ�Ú2,�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û�àY��ÜbÚ#×�õØ+øAÛ�õôPÚdÛÞ¾ÛÞ÷�õpø+ø�Ü�Ú�ôPÚU×�ÜQõ[×m×PÜ�Ú�ôÞÚUØ+Û�ÛPØ���Ù�Ø � ß!õÙ`×�ù�Ù�ß�Ú�ôF×?õØAÙzסÿ�õÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�Ú�ö#óUØC×�Ü2×�Ü�Ú�÷�üz÷�õ��zØ+Ù��×PÜ�ÚUß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PÚ�ö�ô�õp×PÚ�Û�ù�Ù�ôÞÚ�ø+Ø+õ�,�øAÚàs5|Ù�¾×PÜ�Ú�ôm÷�õRcÞ¾�ô/ö�ØCa#ß�ù�øCסÿ2Ø+Ù`û�¾øAûfØ+Ù��²¾�ÛÞß�ØAø+øþõ[×�¾�ôFÿØAÙ`×�Ú��ô�õøAÛ(Ø+Û�ö�ØAÛPß�ù�ÛPÛÞÚ�ö�ØAÙx×PÜ�Ú²Ù�Úfaf×�ÛPù�,�ÛPÚ�ß�×�ØA¾�Ù&à�¡ÙÊõÙ`ÿ�Ú�ûÚ�Ù`×!üX¾�ù�ô�÷#¾fö�Ú�ø�ÛPù�ß�ß�Ú�ÛPÛÞúÅùbø+øAÿNß!õý_×�ù�ôÞÚ�Û�×PÜ�Ú�Úfa_ýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õøX¾3,�ÛÞÚ�ôFy

ûpõp×PØ+¾�Ù4×�Ü�õp×�×PÜ�Ú5Xô(/S�Wß�¾�÷#ý�øAÚfa�ý�ôÞÚ�úÅÚ�ôÞÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø+øCÿ ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�Ú�Û�ØAÙz×P¾�×PÜ�ÚÌÜ�Ø���Ü_yÚ�ÛÞײõpß�ß�Ú�ÛPÛÞØ1,�øAÚ2ôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø ß?ÜQõÙbÙ�Ú�ø�àu��Ü�Ú2÷�õpØ+ÙÌöbØ+ÛPß�ôPÚ�ýQõÙ�ß8ÿÌóUØA×PÜ�Úfa_ýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×�Ø+Û×PÜQõp׾�ù�ôÄôP¾p×?õp×PØ+¾�ÙQõpø/ö�Ø+ÛF×�ôÞØ1,�ùb×PØ+¾�Ù]ØAÛ²ß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ô�õ�,bøAÿ�ÛPÜ�õôPýÃÚ�ô²×�ÜQõpÙ ×PÜQõp×:¾3,�ÛPÚ�ôÞûÚ�öÚ�a_ý�Ú�ôPØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×�õø+øCÿ�à +�Ù�ÚÄýþ�ÛPÛÞØ1,�øAÚ:ÛÞ¾�ù�ôPß�Ú�¾ú�×�Ü�ØAÛXöbØ+ÛPß�ôPÚ�ýQõÙ�ß8ÿ�ØAÛX¾ù�ôXÙbÚ���øAÚ�ß�×�¾ú/Ø+Ù_y×PÚ�ôÞß?ÜQõÙ�Ù�Ú�øUß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù���õp×dÜ�Ø1�Ü_yAc�àß��ÜfùbÛ�ü(ØC×2ß�¾�ùbø+ön,�Ú6×PÜQõp×2×�ÜbÚ�Æ �  ¿ ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�øÛÞÚ�ôFû�Ú�ÛXõÛ�õ��`õp×PÚ�ó¤õ!ÿ6úž�ô ��T�l�ö�Ú�ß�õ�ÿrØ+Ù`×�¾�×PÜ�Ú²ø+¾�ó¤Ú�ô�Æ�ß?ÜQõpÙ�Ù�Ú�øAÛ�à���¾�ß?Ü�Ú�ß'�r×�Ü�ØAÛ�üó�Úrß�¾�÷�ýbùb×�Ú�ö�×�Ü�Ú�Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPß?ÜQõÙbÙ�Ú�ø�ß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù���Û:úž�ô²×�ÜbÚ�ûpõôPØA¾�ù�Û�,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�àHϤÚ8yß�õù�ÛÞÚ|ó¤Ú²õpôPÚ|öbÚ!õøAØ+Ù��ÄóUØA×�Ü-� á éÒ��é E â�Ù�¾�ôÞ÷�õøAØ Ä õp×�ØA¾�ÙdØ+Ù�×PÜ�Ú�¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ���ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø+Û�ü

ª� å

Page 189: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

×PÜ�Ú�ØAÙ`×�Ú�ôÞß?ÜQõÙ�ÙbÚ�ø�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Û|õôÞÚ�ö�ØA÷�Ú�Ù�ÛPØA¾�Ù�øAÚ�ÛPÛ�à���¾�ù�ÛPÚ2õ#ÛPýÃÚ�ß�Ø � ß�ß�õÛPÚpü�úž�ôU×�ÜbÚáÀ¿3¡3¡3¡ âÄÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�×�Ü�Ú2Æ �  ¿ £ Æ �  å ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Ìó¤õÛ27 ¡ ^ ¡3¡ � à=Ã_ØAÙ�ß�Ú�×PÜ�Ú6ôPÚ�ø+Ú8ûõpÙz×ý�õô�õ÷#Ú�×PÚ�ô�úž�ôV��T9lWØAÛ�¯ ½ ¯ � õÛ|¾�ý�ýþ�ÛPÚ�ö�×P¾�¯ ½ ¯Gü¨ó�Ú���Ú8×�×�Ü�õp×�×�ÜbÚ�ô�õp×PÚ�ØAÙz×P¾�×�ÜbÚÆ �  å ß?ÜQõÙ�ÙbÚ�ø(ÛÞÜ�¾�ù�øAöR,�Ú�¾�ÙS×�Ü�Ú�¾�ôPö�Ú�ô�¾ú ¡ ^ ¡3¡ � � Ç å ¡3¡ � ¡3¡�¡ Û oÆÅ � P ^ å Û oÆÅ üóUÜbÚ�ôPÚ å ¡3¡ � ¡3¡�¡ Û oÆÅ Ø+Û¤×PÜ�Ú�ô�õ[×�Ú�ØAÙz×P¾�×�Ü�Ú(Æ �  ¿ ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�à�5|ÛUõ�ß�¾�÷�ý�õôPØAÛP¾�Ù&üz×�ÜbÚÆ �  £ Æ ��¡ ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Äó(õpÛ�7 ¡ ^� P_à���Ü�ØAÛ6��ØCû�Ú�Û(õ�¯ ½ ¯ � óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü6ØAÛ6N ¡3¡ ×PØ+÷#Ú�Ûmøþõô���Ú�ô×PÜQõÙ2×�Ü�õp×vúž�ô/×�ÜbÚ�Æ �  ¿ £ Æ �  å ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��bàB5ÊÛPØA÷�ØAøþõô ýQõ[×P×�Ú�ôPÙdó(õpÛm¾�,�ÛPÚ�ôÞû�Ú�ö�úž�ô×PÜ�Úd¾×�ÜbÚ�ô�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ü�ÛP¾xó¤Úd¾3,_×?õØAÙ�×PÜQõpײØAÙz×PÚ�ôÞß?ÜQõÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�ß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù��xõý�ýÃÚ!õôÞÛ�×�¾m��ØAûÚdõÙbÚ���øAØ1��Ø�,�ø+Ú�ß�¾�Ù`×PôPØ1,bùb×�ØA¾�Ùr×�¾2×�ÜbÚÄôPõp×�Ú�ÛUõp×UÜ�Ø���Ü_yAc�à45(×XøA¾�ó(yAc¤Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPß?ÜQõpÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��,ÃÚ�ß�¾�÷#Ú�ÛUÛPØ���Ù�Ø � ß!õÙ`×!üe,�ùb×�Ø+Û¤ù�Ù�Ø+÷#ýþ�ôÞ×�õÙ`×�ÛPØAÙ�ß�Ú�×PÜ�Ú²ø+¾�ó(yAc¤ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙrôPõp×�Ú�ÛõpôPÚ²Ù�Ú��ø+Ø1�Ø1,�øAÚà��Ü�Ú�Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPý�ø+õ!ÿ]¾ú¤×PÜ�ôPÚ�Ú�ú·õß8×�¾�ôÞÛ²ôPÚ�ÛÞù�øA×PÛ�ØAÙ�õxôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõøAøAÿ�Ü�¾×:ý�ôÞ¾_ö�ùbß�×b/S�¤à

��Ø+ôPÛF×m¾ú õøAø�ü�×�ÜbÚX÷#¾�ôPÚ�Úfa_ß�Ú�ÛPÛ�û_Ø�,�ô�õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõøQÚ�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿ�ØAÛ�ýbøþõß�Ú�ö�ØAÙ`×�¾²×�ô�õpÙ�ÛPø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù&ü�×�ÜbÚ÷#¾�ôÞÚX¾�ÛÞß�ØAø+øþõ[×�¾�ôFÿ�×�ÜbÚ|ß�¾ôPôPÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ���¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù��²ó(õ!ûÚà��Ü�Ø+ÛmôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Û¤ØAÙrõÄÛPù�ý�ýbôPÚ�Û�yÛÞØ+¾�Ùx¾ú�×�Ü�Ú²ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù6ôPõp×�Ú�ÛXõpÛ�¾Ù�Ú0�¾_Ú�Û(úÅôP¾�÷ ÜbØ1��Ü_yCc�×�¾#ø+¾�ó(yAc�à+|ú/ß�¾�ù�ôÞÛPÚüýbøþõß�Ø+Ù��6Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�Ø+Ù`×�¾xôÞ¾×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù]ôÞÚ�ÛÞù�øA×PÛÄØAÙ õÙ�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õp×�¾�ôFÿ�õpÙ���ù�ø+õô�ß�¾÷�ýþ�Ù�Ú�Ùzײ×P¾×PÜ�Ú]¾�ùb×���¾�ØAÙ���ó¤õ�ûÚ�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù&àÚ��ÜbØ+Ûró�¾�ù�ø+ö�Ü�õ�ûÚ õ ×PÚ�Ù�öbÚ�Ù�ß8ÿÈ×�¾ ÛÞù�ý�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÛx×�ÜbÚÜbØ1��Ü_yCc�ô�õp×PÚ�Û�ôÞÚ�øþõ[×�ØAûÚ�×�¾�×PÜ�Ú�ø+¾�ó(yAc¤ôPõp×�Ú�Û�à�/X¾�ó�Ú�ûÚ�ô�ü-×�ÜbÚ�ø+Ø1�Üz×PÙ�Ú�ÛÞÛ�¾úB/à��ØAûÚ�Û�/<�õdôPÚ�øþõp×PØAûÚ�øAÿrøþõô���Ú²ôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø&ß�¾�Ù�ÛF×?õÙ`×!üÃÛP¾d×�Ü�õp×XúžôXõ"��ØAûÚ�Ù�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿüÃ×PÜ�Ú�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õ[y

ª� ¿

Page 190: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

×P¾�ôÞÿrß?ÜQõô�õpß�×�Ú�ôU¾ú�×PÜ�Ú²¾�ùb×���¾�Ø+Ù���ó(õ!û�ÚÄØ+Û�÷#Ø+ÙbØ+÷#Ø Ä Ú�ö-,`ÿ6ý�ø+õß�ØAÙ���×�Ü�Ú²Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿxØ+Ù`×�¾ôÞ¾×?õ[×�Ø+¾Ù&à���Ø+Ù�õø+øCÿ�ü�×�ÜbÚb5|ô�/S��Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ô�õß8×�Ø+¾ÙÌýþ×�Ú�Ùz×PØþõø ÜQõpÛ�õ�ÛF×�ôÞ¾�Ù��6º�õÙ�Ø+ÛÞ¾×�ôÞ¾�ý`ÿ�üóUÜbØ+ß?Ü�÷#¾�Ù�¾×P¾�Ù�ØAß!õøAøAÿ�Ø+Ù�ß�ôPÚ!õpÛPÚ�Û�óUØA×PÜ�¯ ¬S��¬�Õ_×p¯=à �¡Ù�ö�Ú�Ú�ö&ü¨õ�ý�øA¾×�¾ú ½ õÛ�õdúÅù�Ù�ß8y×PØ+¾�ÙN¾ú:º�ôPÚ8û�Ú!õpø+Ú�öÝõSÛÞÜQõôPýbøAÿ�ý�Ú�õ��Ú�ö��`õpù�ÛPÛÞØþõÙÊõ�,þ�ùb×rº � ¡ Ë àÎ��Ü�Ø+Ûxõpø+ø+¾�óUÛúžôÄÚf?¨Ú�ß�×PØAû�Ú#ß�¾ù�ý�ø+ØAÙ��U,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�ÙS×PÜ�Údø+¾�ó(yAc�ß�¾�÷#ý�¾Ù�Ú�Ù`×�Û²¾ú�×�Ü�Ú",þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ÛÄ×P¾×PÜ�Ú�ÜbØ1��Ü_yCc�¾�ùb×���¾�ØAÙ���ó¤õ!û�Ú�Û�àVhÊÜ�Ø+øAÚÄ×PÜ�Ú�øA¾Ró(yCc(ápø+¾�ó(yCc�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���Û|õôPÚ:ÛPØ���Ù�Ø � ß!õÙ`×�øCÿÛF×�ôÞ¾�Ù���Ú�ô�üQ×�Ü�Ú:õÙ�ØAÛP¾×PôP¾�ý`ÿ6÷�õ��pÚ�ÛU×�Ü�ÚÄø+¾�ó(yAc(á[Ü�Ø1��ÜfyAc¤ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���ÛUÛPùba#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×PøAÿxÛÞ×PôP¾�Ù��×PÜQõp×�üÃß�¾�÷�,�ØAÙ�Ú�ö�óUØA×PÜ�×�ÜbÚ:ý�ôÞÚ�ûfØ+¾ù�ÛXסó�¾rÚ�?�Ú�ß8×�ÛXÛPù�ý�ýbôPÚ�ÛÞÛPØAÙ���×�ÜbÚ�ø+¾�ó(yCcUß?ÜQõÙbÙ�Ú�øAÛôÞÚ�ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú�×�¾2×PÜ�Ú²Ü�Ø1��ÜfyAc¤¾�Ù�Ú�Û�ü-ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�ÛUØ+ÙxõdôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõøAøAÿdÜ�¾p×Uý�ôP¾fö�ù�ß8×S/<�¤à�(�_^U�_^ âæÒ���� Î-����¥��"ã`ÖbÖ�Ò�� Öh�Úd÷�õ!ÿÌÙ�¾×�Ú2×PÜQõp×�×�ÜbÚdסó�¾ÌÛÞÚ�×PÛ:¾ú�ô�õ[×�Ú�Û9��ØCû�Ú�Ù ØAÙ=��õ�,bø+Ú�Û Á à å y � õø+ôÞÚ!õöbÿ�ÛPÜ�¾�óÛÞØ1��ÙbØ � ß�õÙ`×|ö�ØAÛPß�ôPÚ�ý�õÙ�ß�ØAÚ�Û|õp×(Æ �  å ü-Ø+Ù�ÛP¾�÷#ÚÄß!õÛÞÚ�ö�ØD?¨Ú�ôPØ+Ù��Y,`ÿ å � ¿ ¾�ôPö�Ú�ôPÛX¾ú÷�õ���ÙbØA×�ùbö�Ú J ��ÜbØ+Û�ß�õÙj,ÃÚ�Ú�a_ý�øþõØAÙ�Ú�ö ú·õØ+ôÞøAÿÌÛPØ+÷#ý�øCÿ��05|ÛÄó¤ÚY��¾�×P¾Ìø+¾�ó�Ú�ôXÆQü�×�ÜbÚ¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù��xÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ÜQõ!ûÚr÷�¾ôPÚ2×�ôPõÙ�ÛPø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿü/÷�õ.�fØAÙ��6×�Ü�Ú�÷ ÷�¾�ôÞÚ�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õ[y×P¾�ôÞÿàS�Qù�ôF×�Ü�Ú�ôP÷#¾�ôPÚpüQ×�Ü�Ú á ¬��?º�âUß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���ÛUúÅôP¾�÷ ×PÜ�Ú�øA¾Ró(yCc�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾÷�ý�ôÞØ+ÛÞØ+Ù��2×�ÜbÚ,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�ÛX×P¾#×PÜ�Ú�¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù��dÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û|ØAÙ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞÚb,`ÿ�ÛPÚ�ûÚ�ôPõø�¾�ôÞö�Ú�ôÞÛX¾púv÷�õ.��Ù�ØA×Pù�ö�ÚõpÛ�ó�Ú:öbôP¾�ý�×�¾#ø+¾�ó¤Ú�ô¤ÆQà§��Ü�Ú�ôÞÚ�ÛPùbøA×�Ø+ÛU×�ÜQõ[×|õpÛ�ó�Ú0�¾#×P¾�ø+¾�ó�Ú�ômÆQüQ×�Ü�ÚÄÙzù�÷�Ú�ôPØAß!õø

ª� Ê

Page 191: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ØAÙ`×�Ú��ô�õp×PØ+¾�ÙxØ+Ù`û¾�øAûÚ�Û�õpö�ö�Ø+Ù���ø+õô���Ú�ô�õÙ�öÌø+õô��Ú�ôUÙzù�÷�,ÃÚ�ôPÛX¾úv÷#¾�ôPÚ²ôPõý�Ø+öbøAÿrûpõôFÿzyØAÙ��ÌÛÞØ1��Ù¨àhÊÜ�Ø+øAÚ#ó�ÚrÚ�abýÃÚ�ß8×2×�Ü�Ú�¾�ÛPß�Ø+ø+ø+õp×�¾ôÞÿ]ÙQõ[×�ù�ôÞÚr¾ú�×�ÜbÚr¾�ùb×���¾�Ø+Ù���ó¤õ!û�Ú�Û2×P¾Ú�ÛPÛÞÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø+øCÿC�zØAø+ø�×�Ü�Ú�ß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù��rõp×�øA¾�ó¤Ú�ô(ÆQü¨×�ÜbÚ�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôPØAß!õø�ý�ôPÚ�ß�ØAÛPØ+¾Ù̾�Ù�×PÜ�Ú�ß�¾÷dyýbùb×�Ú�ô�ØAÛvØ+Ù�ÛÞùba#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×�×P¾Äß�õÙ�ß�Ú�ø-¾�ùb×�×�ÜbÚ|õöbö�ØA×PØ+¾�Ù�Û/õÙ�ö�ÛÞù�,b×Pô�õß8×�Ø+¾Ù�Û�¾ú�×PÜ�Ú�øþõô���Ú�ôß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Û�×�¾X×�Ü�Ú(Ú�af×�Ú�Ù`×�ôÞÚ�Gzù�Ø+ôÞÚ�ö2×�¾S��ØAûÚ�õÙ2õß�ß�ù�ôPõp×�Ú¤ôPÚ�ÛÞù�øA×�úž�ô�×PÜ�Ú(Ø+Ù`×PÚ���ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù&à�Q¾�ô(×PÜ�ÚÄÜ�Ø1��ÜbÚ�ômÆ�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�üQ×�ÜbÚ:ØAÙz×PÚ���ôPõø&ØAÛ�øAÚ�ÛÞÛ�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õp×�¾�ôFÿ�üQõpÙ�ö�×PÜ�Ú²ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û�õôPÚ÷�ù�ß?Ü�ÛP÷�õøAø+Ú�ô�üQÛP¾�×PÜ�Ú�õpö�ö�ØA×PØ+¾�ÙbÛXõpÙ�ö�ÛPù�,b×�ôPõß�×PØ+¾�Ù�ÛXö�¾�Ùb¾×�Ù�Ú�Ú�öÌ×P¾k,ÃÚ�õÛXÚfabõß8×õpÛ�úž�ô�×PÜ�Úrø+¾�ó�Ú�ô�Æ�Ø+Ù ¾ôPö�Ú�ô�×�¾H��Ú8×dõÙ4õß�ß�ù�ôPõp×�Ú�ô�õp×PÚà=��Ü�Ø+Û2Ú�a_ý�øþõØAÙ�Û:óUÜ`ÿ Ùb¾÷�õp×Þ×�Ú�ô²óUÜQõp×�×�Ü�Ú�Æ �  ¿ ôPõp×�Ú�Ø+Û²úž�ô�õøAøv×�Ü�Ú-,þ�ù�ÙböSÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ü/×�ÜbÚrø+¾�ó�Ú�ô�Æ]ôPõp×�Ú�Û×PÚ�Ù�ö]×P¾:cÞù�÷�ý]×P¾rûõpø+ù�Ú�Û�¾�Ù]×�Ü�Ú2¾ôPö�Ú�ô�¾ú  ¡ ~ �  ¡ Ë Û oÆÅ à��¡Ù�¾�ù�ô�ö�ØA÷�Ú�Ù�ÛPØA¾�Ù�ø+Ú�ÛPÛÛFÿfÛÞ×�Ú�÷³¾ú&ù�Ù�ØA×PÛ�üf×�Ü�ØAÛ�ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�öbÛ¤×�¾2õ:ô�õp×PÚ|¾�Ù#×�Ü�Ú�¾ôPö�Ú�ô¤¾ú  ¡ oÆÅZÅ �  ¡ oxä à[��ÜbÚÙzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�õø¨ý�ôÞÚ�ß�Ø+ÛPØA¾�Ùxõ!ûpõØ+ø+õ�,�ø+ÚX¾�Ù6¾�ù�ô�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�ô�ß!õÙx¾�ÙbøAÿ�ß!õÙ�ß�Ú�ø�¾�ù_×(×�Ü�Ú²øA¾Ró�Ú�ôÆ#ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ��2×�Ú�ôÞ÷�Û(×P¾2×�Ü�ØAÛ�øAÚ�ûÚ�ø�à�¡Ùßl�Ú8ú�à Êo¿ Ϥù�ß?Ü�õß?Ü�Ú�Ù��¾�Ú8×Äõø�à:¾3,b×?õpØ+Ù�Ú�ö�õ6ôÞ¾×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù�õø�öbØ+ÛÞ×PôPØ�,�ùb×�ØA¾�ÙÌóUÜ�ØAß?Ü

Ü�õö2õ<,bØ+÷#¾_öQõpø`ß?ÜQõô�õpß�×�Ú�ô�à���ÜbÚ�Ø+ô�ß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û��`õ!û�Ú6,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ¤øAØAúÅÚ�×PØ+÷#Ú�Û&óUÜ�ØAß?Üó�Ú�ôÞÚ:סÿfý�ØAß!õøAøAÿ6õpÙ�¾�ôÞö�Ú�ôU¾ú�÷�õ.��Ù�ØA×Pù�ö�Ú�×P¾_¾#ø+¾�ó²à�h�Ú9,ÃÚ�ø+ØAÚ�ûÚÄ×PÜQõp×U×�Ü�ØAÛ�,�Ø+÷#¾_ö�õøöbØ+ÛÞ×PôPØ�,�ùb×�ØA¾�Ù&ü�õÛ�ó�Ú�øAø�õÛ�×PÜ�Úxø+¾�ó�ø+ØAúÅÚ8×�ØA÷�Ú�Û�ü/ØAÛdõp×dø+Ú�õÛÞ×2ý�õôÞ×PøAÿSöbù�Úr×�¾]×�ÜbÚ�Ùzù_y÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�õø Ø+ÛPÛÞù�Ú�Û|ö�Ú�ÛÞß�ôPØ�,�Ú�ö�Ü�Ú�ôÞÚàV5XÛ�ß!õÙH,ÃÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ú�Ù ØAÙ��õ�,�øAÚ�Û å õRy¡Úü-×�ÜbÚ�Ùzù�÷�Ú�ôPØAß!õøØAÙ`×�Ú��ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù�Û9��ØCû�Ú#õC,bØ+÷#¾_öQõpø/ö�Ø+ÛF×�ôÞØ1,�ùb×PØ+¾�Ù¨ü õÙ�ö�ÛÞØ1��ÙbØ � ß�õÙ`×�øAÿ�¾RûÚ�ôÞÚ�ÛÞ×PØ+÷�õp×�Úd×�ÜbÚ

ª� Á

Page 192: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

øA¾�ó(yAc�ô�õ[×�Ú�Û�ü�ÛP¾�×PÜQõp×(×PÜ�Ú�×�¾p×?õø�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ô�õ[×�Ú�ÛUõpôPÚ�õÙ6¾ôPö�Ú�ô(¾ú�÷�õ.��Ù�ØA×Pù�ö�Ú¾ô�÷�¾�ôÞÚ�øþõô���Ú�ô�×�ÜQõÙx×�Üb¾�ÛPÚ²÷#Ú!õÛÞù�ôPÚ�ö�Ú�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õpø+øAÿà°6h�å æ°u#sH¼:·g¶Hµ�º�u#sHµ ¸�s]w çm¶Ìt[¶Hè[³ ²´³uµ4³S¸�è�¼¤���ÜbØ+Û�ß?ÜQõý_×�Ú�ô²ö�Ú8û�Ú�ø+¾�ýÃÚ�ö�õr÷�¾fö�Ú�ø�úž�ô�×�Ü�Ú�ûfØ�,�ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù�õø�ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ö_ÿ_Ù�õ÷dyØAß�Û�¾ú§l��o/�l ß�¾�÷#ý�ø+Ú�a_Ú�ÛÄõÛ²õÙ=��T9l ö�Ú�ß!õ!ÿ�úÅôP¾÷ õ-,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú2ôÞÚ�ÛPØAö�Ø+Ù��6¾�Ù õסó�¾py%ýQõô�õp÷�Ú8×�Ú�ô  ®Ã�×�¾dõ�ÛÞÚ�ôÞØ+Ú�Û�¾pú�¾Ù�Ú8y%ýQõô�õp÷�Ú8×�Ú�ô¤Úfa_ØA×�ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø+Û�àÍ�ÛPØ+Ù��dõ�Ü�Ø1��ÜGzùQõpø+ØAסÿ õ.,�Ø+ÙbØA×�ØA¾U5|ô(/<�  ®Ã�ü�ó�Úrõpý�ý�ø+ØAÚ�ö ×�Ü�ØAÛ:÷#¾_öbÚ�øv×�¾�×�Ü�ÚY5|ô(/<��ß�¾�÷�ýbø+Úfa�à��ÜbØ+Û�÷�¾fö�Ú�ø��`õ!ûÚ�ô�õ[×�Ú�ÛUúž�ôU×�Ü�Ú á  ¡3¡3¡ â�õÙ�ö á å Â� ¡ â(ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�ÛX×�Ü�õp×Xó�Ú�ôÞÚ�ß�¾Ù�ÛPØAÛÞ×�Ú�Ù`×óUØC×�Ü�×�Ü�Ú�¾3,�ÛÞÚ�ôÞûpõp×PØ+¾�Ù�×�Ü�õp×�ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�¾ú¤×�Ü�Ú�ÛPÚk,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�ÛÄØ+Û²×�¾f¾�ÛÞø+¾�ó×P¾0,ÃÚ�ß�ù�ôÞôPÚ�Ù`×PøAÿ#÷�Ú�õÛPùbôPÚ�ö¨à[��Ü�Ú|ß�¾�÷�ýbùb×�Ú�ö�ô�õ[×�Ú�úž�ô�×�Ü�Ú á å ¡�¡3¡ â/ÛÞ×�õp×�ÚUó(õpÛ�úž�ù�Ùbö×P¾k,ÃÚ:ß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ÛÞ×PÚ�Ù`×�óUØC×�ÜÌØC×�Û�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙU,�Ú�Ø+Ù���¾3,�ÛPÚ�ôÞûpõ�,�øAÚü-×�Ü�¾ù���ÜÌÙb¾6õß�×PùQõøÚ�a_ý�Ú�ôPØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×�õø/ûpõø+ù�ÚdÜQõpÛ0,ÃÚ�Ú�Ùj��ØCû�Ú�Ù ×�¾�öQõp×PÚà��Q¾�ô�×PÜ�Ú áÀ¿3¡3¡3¡ â|ÛÞ×?õ[×�Úü�×�Ü�Ú#ß�¾÷dyýbùb×�Ú�öxÆ �  ¿ ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ôPõp×�Ú:¾ú å ¡3¡ � ¡3¡3¡ Û oÆÅ Ø+Û�Ø+Ù���¾f¾fö�õ���ôÞÚ�Ú�÷�Ú�Ùz×XóUØA×PÜ×PÜ�Ú6¾�û�Ú�ô�õøAø¤ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙSôPõp×�Úr¾pú å�Á ¡ � ¡3¡�¡ Û oÆÅ àc�¡Ù�ö�Ú�Ú�ö&üm¾úU×�Ü�Ú � û�ÚU,þ�ù�Ù�ö_yÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û/ß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ôPÚ�ödØAÙ�×�Ü�ØAÛ�ýQõpý�Ú�ô�ü×PÜ�Ú(¾�Ù�øCÿÄý�ôP¾3,bø+Ú�÷�õp×PØ+ßmÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú(ØAÛ�×�ÜbÚ á�¿ Â� ¡ â�ÛÞ×?õ[×�ÚüóUÜb¾�ÛPÚ2ß�¾�÷�ýbùb×�Ú�ö]ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ô�õp×PÚ�Ø+Ù`×P¾�×�Ü�Ú²Æ �  ¿ ß?ÜQõÙbÙ�Ú�ø/¾pú  å � ¡3¡3¡ Û oÆÅØAÛ�ÛP¾�÷#Ú�óUÜ�õp×�øA¾�ó²ü&×�Ü�¾�ù���Ü�ÛF×�ØAø+ø�óUØC×�Ü�ØAÙ�õpÙ�¾�ôÞö�Ú�ô²¾ú�÷�õ���Ù�ØC×�ù�ö�Ú2¾pú¤Ú�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×!à

ª���

Page 193: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��ù�÷#Ú�ôPØAß!õøQ×PÚ�ÛÞ×PÛ¤óUØA×PÜrõ�öbØ+ÛÞ×P¾�ôÞ×PÚ�ö�ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø-ÛPù�����Ú�ÛF×(×�ÜQõ[×�×PÜ�Ø+Û�ô�õp×PÚXö�ØAÛPß�ôPÚ�ý�õÙ�ß�ÿ÷�õ!ÿÌÜ�õ�ûÚ�Ùb¾×�Ü�ØAÙ���×P¾�öb¾xóUØC×�Ü]¾�ùbô|×�Ü�Ú�¾�ôPÚ8×�ØAß!õøvõpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü]×�¾6×�Ü�Ú2ýbôP¾3,�øAÚ�÷�ü�,�ù_×ôPõp×�ÜbÚ�ô�÷�õ!ÿU,ÃÚ:ö�ùbÚ:×�¾�Ú�ôÞôP¾�ôÞÛXØAÙ�×PÜ�Ú�õ�,�Ø+Ù�ØC×�ØA¾  ®Ã�úžô<5Xô(/S��üQØ+ÙÌý�õôÞ×PØ+ß�ùbøþõôUõp×ÛÞ÷�õpø+ø&«�àhÊÜ�ØAø+Ú�¾�ù�ô�õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü#ó(õÛ¤Ù�¾×¤õ:ý�ù�ôÞÚ�õ�,�Ø+Ù�ØC×�ØA¾Ä¾Ù�ÚüfØ+Ù#×�ÜQõp×mó�Ú�õö[cÞùbÛÞ×�Ú�ö�×�ÜbÚ

úÅôÞÚ�ÚBy�/S� õpÙ�öU,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ²Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���ØAÚ�Û(×�¾�×PÜ�Ú²Úfa_ýÃÚ�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ù`×?õøAøAÿ#ß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�Ú�ö6¾�Ù�Ú�Û á ÛPÚ�Ú5Xý�ýÃÚ�Ù�ö�Øia=5�à  âBü&ó¤ÚdÛPÜb¾�ù�ø+ö�Ù�¾p×�Ú�×�Ü�õp×ÄõrúÅù�ø+øvõ., ØAÙ�ØA×PØ+¾�õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü�ó¤¾�ùbø+ö�Ù�Ú�ûÚ�ô�y×PÜ�Ú�øAÚ�ÛÞÛ�ÜQõ!û�Ú-�ØAû�Ú�ÙSÛPØA÷�ØAøþõô�ôÞÚ�ÛÞù�øA×PÛ�×�¾�×�Ü�Úr¾Ù�Ú�Û:¾3,b×?õpØ+Ù�Ú�öSØ+Ù ×�Ü�ØAÛ�ß?ÜQõý_×�Ú�ô�à���¾ØAø+øAù�ÛÞ×Pô�õp×PÚüùbÛPØ+Ù��²õö[cÞù�ÛF×�Ú�ö2úÅôÞÚ�Ú8yZ/S�]õÙbö",þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ(Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���ØAÚ�Û[�`õ!ûÚUõ²ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�ØCyõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ôPõp×�ÚUúÅôP¾�÷ ×PÜ�Ú áÀ¿3¡3¡3¡ â/×P¾:×PÜ�Ú�¯ n � å �¡Æ �  ¿ ç Ú�a_ØA×(ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�¾ú å ¡3¡ � ¡�¡3¡ Û oÆÅ üóUØC×�Ü4õÌýbôP¾fö�ù�ß�×>/S�è×�ôPõÙ�ÛÞøþõp×PØ+¾�ÙQõpømÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿS¾púSN3P2ß�÷ oÆÅ àH5 ý�ù�ôÞÚxõ�, Ø+Ù�ØC×�ØA¾�ß�õøCyß�ù�øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù&ü�óUØC×�ÜSÙb¾ÌýQõôPõ÷#Ú�×�Ú�ôPÛ�õö[cÞù�ÛF×�Ú�ö¨ü[�`õ!û�Ú6õ�ß�¾�ôÞôPÚ�ÛÞý�¾Ù�ö�Ø+Ù���ö�Ú�ß�õ!ÿ�ôPõp×�Ú�¾úÂg� ¡ � ¡3¡�¡ Û oÆÅ õÙ�ö�õ2×Pô�õÙbÛPøþõ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõø¨Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ6¾ú Á Ê ß�÷ oÆÅ à+�ù�ô�÷#¾fö�Ú�ø�ÛPùbß�ß�Ú�ÛPÛFúÅù�ø+øCÿSý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAß�×�Û:×�Ü�ÚrÛF×�ôÞ¾�Ù���n�y¡öbÚ�ýÃÚ�Ù�ö�Ú�Ù�ß�Ú6¾pú�×�Ü�ÚrýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛFy

ÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ôPõp×�Ú�Û�ü�õÛÄó�Ú�øAø�õÛ²×�Ü�Ú#ÛÞ×�õ�,�Ø+øAØ Ä õp×�ØA¾�Ù�¾ú�×�Ü�Ú",�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û²×�Ü�õp׾_ß�ß�ù�ôÞÛóUÜbÚ�Ù]Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿ�ØAÛXýbøþõß�Ú�ö�ØAÙz×P¾k/<�X,ÃÚ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ���ü-Ø�à ÚàCü-óUÜ�Ú�ÙH� ØAÛXØAÙ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞÚ�ö�úÅôÞ¾�÷ ¡ ×P¾Â à�¯¤¾�÷�,�ØAÙ�Ú�ö�óUØA×�Ü�×�Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚ�÷#ØCy¡õÙQõøCÿf×PØ+ß�ôÞÚ�ÛPùbøA×�Û�übó�Ú�õø+ÛÞ¾�÷�õÙQõ��Ú�ö�×P¾�ß�¾Ù � ôP÷�×�ÜbÚÚ�a_ý�Ú�ôPØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×�õø¤¾3,bÛPÚ�ôFûpõp×�ØA¾�ÙS×�ÜQõ[×2×�Ü�ÚrýbôP¾fö�ù�ß�×"/<�è×�Ú�Ù�ö�Û2×�¾]ß�¾�÷�Ú�¾�?NóUØC×�ÜS×�ÜbÚÜbØ1��Ü�Ú�ÛÞײõpß�ß�Ú�ÛPÛÞØ1,�øAÚ²Æ-ü�óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü]ó¤õÛ�Æ �  ¿ úž�ô|×PÜ�Ú�,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ôPÚ�ö&àb5XÛ

ª� P

Page 194: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

÷#Ú�Ù`×PØ+¾�Ù�Ú�ö�Ø+Ù:×�Ü�Ú(ýbôPÚ�ûfØA¾�ù�Û/ÛÞÚ�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù¨ü�×�Ü�ØAÛ�ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Û�úÅôÞ¾�÷�×�Ü�Ú�ØAÙ`×�Ú�ôÞý�øþõ!ÿľúQ×PÜ�ôPÚ�Ú¤ú·õß8y×P¾�ôPÛ�� á  â���Ü�ÚXôÞÚ�ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú�øCÿ2øþõpô���Ú�ôÞ¾×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù�õøbß�¾�Ù�ÛÞ×�õÙ`×(¾ú�/S��à á å â�5ÝÛÞ×�ôÞ¾�Ù��:õÙ���ùbøþõôõpÙ�Ø+ÛÞ¾×�ôÞ¾�ý`ÿ�Ø+Ù�×�Ü�Ú"5|ô�/S��ØAÙ`×�Ú�ôPõß�×PØ+¾�Ù�ýþ×�Ú�Ù`×�Øþõpø á ×�ÜbÚk�`õùbÛPÛPØ+õÙ Ø+Ù�º�÷#Ú�Ù`×�ØA¾�Ù�Ú�öØAÙ2×�Ü�Ú�ý�ôPÚ8ûfØ+¾�ù�ÛmÛPÚ�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù-âBà á�¿ â�/�Ø1��ÜbøAÿ�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õp×�¾�ôFÿ�øA¾�ó(yAc/¾�ùb×(�¾�Ø+Ù���ó¤õ!û�Ú�Û�ü�õÛmß�¾÷dyý�õôPÚ�ö#×P¾:Ü�Ø���Ü_yCcv¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ���ó¤õ�ûÚ�Û�ü_óUÜ�ØAß?Ü�ÛPùbý�ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÛm×�Ü�Ú�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù2ô�õp×PÚ�ÛmØ+Ù`×�¾×PÜ�Ú�ø+¾�ó(yCc(ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø+ÛUõÛ�ß�¾�÷�ý�õôPÚ�öx×P¾�×�Ü�Ú�ÜbØ1��Ü_yCc�¾�Ù�Ú�Û�à[h�Ú�ÛÞÜ�¾�ù�øAöxÙ�¾×�Ú�×PÜQõp×(×PÜ�Ø+ÛÚ�a_ý�øþõÙ�õp×�ØA¾�ÙrØ+Û¤Ù�¾×U¾�ôÞØ1��ØAÙQõø�ü`Ü�õ�ûfØAÙ��>,�Ú�Ú�Ù�Ù�¾×PÚ�ö&übúžô(Ø+Ù�ÛF×?õÙbß�ÚübØ+ÙUlUÚ�ú�à  à�/�¾Ró(yÚ8û�Ú�ô�ü�ó�Ú�úÅÚ�øA×(ØA×(ÛÞÜ�¾�ù�øAö�,�Ú�ôÞÚ�ÛF×?õp×PÚ�öxÜ�Ú�ôÞÚü�ÛÞØ+Ù�ß�Ú�ØA×�ØAÛ(õ�ß�¾�Ù�ß�øAù�ÛPØA¾�ÙróUÜ�ØAß?Üxúžø+ø+¾�óUÛúÅôÞ¾�÷ ¾�ù�ô|ØAÙ`û�Ú�ÛF×�Ø��`õp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û�àu�¡Ù�ú·õß�×�ü�õÛ�ö�ØAÛPß�ù�ÛPÛÞÚ�ö Ø+ÙÌ×PÜ�Ú��¡Ù`×�ôÞ¾_ö�ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù&ü&ØC×|ß�õÙ=,�Úõpô���ù�Ú�öS×�ÜQõ[×�×�ÜbØ+Û�Ú�a_ý�øþõÙ�õp×�ØA¾�ÙSØ+Û�õß�×PùQõøAøAÿ�ö�ù�Úr×P¾H®/óUØ+Ù�� á ù�ýS×P¾�ÛP¾�÷#Úrö�Ú8×?õØAø+Ûý�õôÞ×PØ+ß�ùbøþõô¤×P¾2×�Ü�ØAÛ�ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷�â8à��Ü�Ú]÷�õØAÙNö�ØAÛPß�ôÞÚ�ýQõpÙ�ß�ÿX,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�Ùݾ�ù�ô�÷#¾fö�Ú�øXõÙ�ö�Ú�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×6ØAÛ�×�Ü�õp×6¾�ù�ô

÷#¾fö�Ú�ø�ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAß�×PÛ�Ú�ÛPÛÞÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø+øCÿxõø+ø¨¾ú�×PÜ�Ú:ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ùr×P¾�¾fß�ß�ù�ô�Ø+Ù`×�¾2×�ÜbÚ|Æ �  ¿ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�à��ÜbÚrÛPÚ�÷�Ø�y�õÙQõpøAÿz×�ØAß#ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×?õ[×�Ø+¾Ù�Û0�ØAû�Ú�õÌÛPÜ�õôPý&ü�÷�¾�ôÞÚ�¾�ôÄø+Ú�ÛPÛ�Ú�a_ý�¾pyÙbÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õøQö�Ú�ß�õ!ÿ�ØAÙ#×PÜ�Ú�ô�õp×PÚ�Û�óUØA×�Ü#ö�Ú�ß�ôPÚ�õÛPØAÙ���ÆQà[®4a_ýÃÚ�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ù`×?õøAøAÿ�×PÜ�Ú�ö�Ø+ÛF×�ôPØ�,�ùb×PØ+¾�ÙØAÛ(ß�¾Ù�ÛPØAö�Ú�ôPõ�,�øAÿk,�ôP¾�õö�Ú�ô�übóUØA×PÜ6ÛPØ���Ù�Ø � ß!õÙ`×�ý�ôÞ¾3,Qõ�,bØ+ø+ØCסÿ#Ø+Ùr×�ÜbÚUÆ � È �  ¿ ô�õÙ���Úà��ÜbÚ2Úfa_ý�Ú�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ùz×�õø�öbÚ�ß!õ!ÿ]ØAÛ�õøAÛP¾rÚ�ÛPÛPÚ�Ù`×�Øþõpø+øAÿ�Úfa_ýþ�Ù�Ú�Ùz×PØþõø�ü¨óUØA×PÜ�õ�ÛPøAØ1��Ü`×�Ú�a_ß�Ú�ýfy×PØ+¾�Ù�úž�ôd×�Ü�Ú á�¿ Â2 ¡ â�ÛÞ×?õ[×�Úü(óUÜbØ+ß?Ü�ÛPÜb¾RóUÛrõ�ÛPøAØ1��Ü`×PøAÿ ø+õô���Ú�ô�Æ �  å ôPõp×�Ú�×�ÜQõpÙ×PÜ�Ú�Æ �  ¿ ô�õ[×�ÚàS+�ù�ô|ß�ù�ôPôÞÚ�Ù`×�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß!õpø�Ú8û_ØAö�Ú�Ùbß�Ú�ÛÞù��3��Ú�ÛÞ×�ÛX×�ÜQõp×|Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPß?ÜQõpÙ�Ù�Ú�ø

ª� N

Page 195: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

÷#ØDa_ØAÙ���ÜQõpÛ²õxÙbÚ���øAØ1��Ø�,�ø+Ú²Ú�?�Ú�ß8׾�Ù�×�Ü�Ú2ôÞ¾×?õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõø�ö�Ø+ÛF×�ôPØ�,�ùb×PØ+¾�Ù&ü�ÛP¾r×PÜQõp×Äõp×�×PÜ�Ø+Ûýþ�ØAÙz×�ó¤Ú6ö�¾Ù d ×dÜ�õ�ûÚ�õ���¾_¾fö Úfa_ý�ø+õÙQõp×PØ+¾�Ù�úž�ô�×�ÜbÚ�ÛPÚxö�ØAÛPß�ôPÚ�ý�õÙ�ß�ØAÚ�Û�àR5 Ü�Ø���Ü�Ú�ôøAÚ�ûÚ�ø�¾púv×�Ü�Ú�¾�ôÞÿ�÷�õ�ÿm,ÃÚ�ôPÚ�Gzù�Ø+ôÞÚ�ö�×�¾�ý�ôP¾�ýÃÚ�ôÞøAÿ�õöbö�ôPÚ�ÛPÛ�×�ÜbØ+Û|ÛÞØA×PùQõp×�ØA¾�Ù&ü-Ú�ØC×�Ü�Ú�ô�Ø+Ù×PÜ�Ú2ß�¾÷�ý�ù_×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù]¾ú�×PÜ�Ú>,�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û�ü ¾�ô�Ø+Ù�×PÜ�Ú2¾�ùb×���¾�Ø+Ù��rß?ÜQõÙ�ÙbÚ�ø+Û�ü ¾�ôu,�¾p×�Ü&à��ÜbÚ�ÛPØA÷�ýbø+Ø+ß�ØAסÿ�¾ú(¾ù�ô:ß�ù�ôPôÞÚ�Ù`×�÷#¾fö�Ú�øv÷�õ��Ú�Û:ØC×:õ�ß�¾ÙzûÚ�Ù�ØAÚ�Ù`×�ÛÞý�ôPØAÙ��3,þ`õôÞö úž�ô÷#¾�ôÞÚ�ß�¾÷�ý�øAØ+ß�õp×�Ú�ö&ü&õÙbö]Ü�¾�ýÃÚ�úÅù�øAøAÿ�÷�¾ôPÚ2õß�ß�ù�ôPõp×�Úpü õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü�Ú�Û�à�h�Ú�øAÚ!õ!û�Ú�×PÜ�Ø+Ûúžô(úÅùb×�ù�ôÞÚ�ó¤¾�ô��-à5XÛ�÷�Ú�Ùz×PØ+¾�ÙbÚ�ö]ý�ôÞÚ�ûfØ+¾�ùbÛPøAÿü&ØA×�÷�õ!ÿÌõø+ÛÞ¾-,�Ú2ÙbÚ�ß�Ú�ÛPÛPõôÞÿ�×P¾6¾3,b×�õØ+Ù]õ6÷#¾�ôPÚ�õß8y

ß�ù�ô�õ[×�Úxõ�, ØAÙ�ØA×PØ+¾  ®Ã�à��%×�ÛPÜ�¾�ùbø+ön,�Ú�ôPÚ8y%Ú�÷#ý�ÜQõÛÞØ Ä Ú�ö ×�ÜQõ[×�×�Ü�Ú6ÛÞø+¾�óUÙ�Ú�ÛPÛ2¾úU×�ÜbÚýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ô�õp×PÚ�Û2÷�õ��Úr×PÜ�Ú�ØAô�Ùzù�÷�Ú�ôPØAß!õø�Ú�ûpõø+ù�õp×�ØA¾�ÙSö�ØCa�ß�ù�øA×�àß��ÜbØ+Û�ØAÛ�Ú�Û�yýÃÚ�ß�ØþõøAøAÿ�×�ôPùbÚ�úž�ôd×�ÜbÚ�øA¾Ró�Ú�ô:ÆSô�õ[×�Ú�Û�ü¤óUÜ�Ú�ôPÚ�×PÜ�Ú�ØAôdÛPø+¾�óUÙ�Ú�ÛPÛrß�¾�÷#ý�ø+ØAß!õp×PÚ�Û�×�ÜbÚ�Ø+ôõpß�ß�ùbô�õp×PÚ�Ú�ûpõøAùQõp×PØ+¾�Ùxö�ù�ÚÄ×�¾�¾�ÛPß�Ø+ø+ø+õp×�¾ôÞÿ6ØAÙz×PÚ���ôPõø+Û�àF��Üzù�Û�ü&õøA×PÜ�¾�ù���Üx×�ÜbÚ�ß�ùbôPôPÚ�Ù`×õ.,rØ+Ù�ØC×�ØA¾�5Xô(/<�  ®§Ã�ØAÛ¤¾ú ôÞÚ�ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú�øCÿdÜ�Ø1�ÜkGzùQõøAØAסÿ�üfØAפØ+ÛmÙ�¾×¤ß�ø+Ú�õô�×PÜQõp×�ó¤Ú�ß�¾�ù�øAöÜ�õ�ûÚ:¾�,b×?õØAÙ�Ú�öx÷�ùbß?ÜC,ÃÚ�×Þ×�Ú�ôUôÞÚ�ÛPùbøA×�Û�óUØC×�ÜxØA×Uù�ÛÞØ+Ù��#õ2Ü�Ø���Ü�Ú�ô�øAÚ�ûÚ�ø ¾ú�×�Ü�Ú�¾�ôÞÿà+�Ù�×�Ü�Ú�Ú�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õpø�ÛPØAö�Úü�ó¤Ú ÛPÜ�¾ù�ø+öÊÙ�¾×PÚ�×�ÜQõ[×x¾�Ù�Ú�¾úÄù�Û á hæàOÛ2àGâ�ÜQõpÛ

ôÞÚ!õÛÞ¾�ÙÌ×P¾-,�Ú�ø+ØAÚ�û�Ú²×�Ü�õp×|×PÜ�Ú�ß�ù�ôPôÞÚ�Ù`×�÷#Ú!õÛÞù�ôPÚ�÷�Ú�Ùz×PÛ|¾�Ù�×�Ü�Ú:n �é¿ ,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û¾pú&5Xô(/<��÷�õ!ÿ�¾�ûÚ�ôPÚ�ÛÞ×PØ+÷�õp×�Ú(×PÜ�Ú�ø+¾�ó�Ú�ô Ʋý�¾�ýbù�øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ�às��Ü�Ø+ÛvØAÛ�×�Ü�Ú�ôPÚ8úž�ôPÚ�õÙ2ØAÛPÛPùbÚóUÜbØ+ß?Ü�÷�õ!ÿ2õøAÛP¾ÄôPÚ�GfùbØ+ôPÚ�úÅù�ôF×�Ü�Ú�ô�Úfa_ý�Ú�ôPØA÷�Ú�Ùz×�õøQØ+Ù`ûÚ�ÛÞ×PØ1�`õ[×�Ø+¾Ù&à4�%×mß�¾ù�ø+ödû�Ú�ôÞÿdó¤Ú�ø+øÜ�õý�ýÃÚ�ÙÈ×�Ü�õp×r×�ÜbÚÌ×�ôÞù�Ú�ôP¾p×?õp×PØ+¾�ÙQõpø�ö�Ø+ÛF×�ôPØ�,�ùb×PØ+¾�Ù�Û#ú·õø+øUÛÞ¾�÷�Ú8óUÜ�Ú�ôÞÚH,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�Ù�×�ÜbÚ

ª��È

Page 196: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ß�ù�ôPôÞÚ�Ù`×�×�Ü�Ú�¾�ôPÚ8×�Ø+ß�õø�õÙbö�Ú�abýÃÚ�ôÞØ+÷#Ú�Ù`×?õpø&ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Û�àh�Ú|ÛÞÜ�¾�ù�øAörõøAÛP¾�ôÞÚ�ÛF×?õp×PÚ|Ü�Ú�ôPÚX×PÜQõp×�×�Ü�Ú�÷�õpØ+Ù#ß�¾�Ù`×�ôÞØ1,�ù_×�Ø+¾Ù�×�¾Ä×�Ü�Ú<,�¾ù�Ù�ö_y�úÅôPÚ�Ú

ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���ØAÛ/Ø+Ù2×PÜ�Ú�Ø+Ù�ÙbÚ�ô/ó¤õø+ø�ôÞÚ���ØA¾�Ù2¾ú-×�ÜbÚ:5Xô(/<��ýþ×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø�üõp×v×�Ü�Ú�,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú×�õØ+øAÛ�à���Ü�ØAÛ/÷�Ú�õÙ�Û�×�ÜQõp×�×�Ü�Ú6,�ù�ø1�²¾úQ×PÜ�Ú6,þ�ù�Ùbö_y%úÅôÞÚ�Ú(ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��XØ+Û�ØAÙ:×PÜ�Ú(ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø+øCÿúžô�,�ØAö�ö�Ú�Ù6ôÞÚ���ØA¾�Ù&ü_ÛP¾�×�Ü�õp×(×�ÜbÚ�ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�ý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛPÛUØAÛ(ö�ù�Ú�×P¾�×�ù�ÙbÙ�Ú�øAØ+Ù��dõÙböØAÛ�×�Ü�Ú�ôPÚ�úžôPÚ�õ�ý�ù�ôÞÚ�øCÿHGzùQõÙ`×�ù�÷ Úf?¨Ú�ß�×!àm¯¤ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õøvÛPØA÷�ù�øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù�Û|óUØ+øAø�ú·õØAø/×�¾x×?õ��pÚ×PÜ�ÚrØAÙ�Ù�Ú�ôÄó(õpø+ø¤ôÞÚ���ØA¾�Ù�¾pú�×�Ü�Ú-5Xô(/<�®ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õømØ+Ù`×�¾Ìõß�ß�¾�ù�Ù`×!ümõÙ�ö ÛÞ¾�óUØ+øAø�ØAû�ÚýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù6ôPõp×�Ú�Û�óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü�õôPÚ�×P¾_¾2øA¾Ró²à+�ù�ô/ß�ù�ôPôÞÚ�Ù`×�÷#¾_ö�Ú�ø_ß�õÙ>,ÃÚ(ù�ÛPÚ�ö2×�¾�ÛF×�ù�öbÿ�¾×�ÜbÚ�ô[l��o/�lÈß�¾�÷#ý�ø+Ú�a_Ú�Û�üý�ôP¾�ûfØ+ö�Ú�ö

×PÜQõp×xõpÙ�õ�,�Ø+ÙbØA×�ØA¾�ýþ×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õøXß�õÙÔ,ÃÚ�¾3,b×�õØ+Ù�Ú�öÈúž�ô�×PÜ�¾�ÛÞÚàÎ�¡Ù�ýQõôF×�Ø+ß�ù�øþõpô�ü(¾�ÙbÚß�¾�÷#ý�ø+Ú�a]¾ú�Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPÚ�ÛÞ×:Ø+Û9Û�ô(/<�¤ü¨óUÜ�¾�ÛÞÚ�ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù]Ú8û�Ú�Ù õpײn.ê � ��¿ ØAÛ²×P¾_¾ÛÞø+¾�ó�×�¾H,ÃÚ�÷#Ú!õpÛPù�ôÞÚ�ö&àn+�Ù�Ú6ýþ�ÛÞÛPØ1,bø+ÚrÚ�abýbøþõÙQõ[×�Ø+¾ÙSúž�ô�×�ÜbØ+Û2Ø+Û:×�ÜQõp×2×PÜ�ÚUÛ�ô(/<�ØAÙ`×�Ú�ôPõß�×PØ+¾�Ù�ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õøbØAÛ�ÛÞØ1��Ù � ß!õÙ`×�øCÿ�ÛF×�ôP¾Ù���Ú�ô�×�ÜQõÙ2×PÜ�ÚF5|ô�/S��ØAÙz×PÚ�ôPõß�×PØ+¾�Ù&àB��Ü�Ø+Ûß�¾�ù�øAö�ôPÚ�ÛÞù�øA×rØ+ÙÊõR,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú]Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿÈÛÞùba#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×�øAÿNø+¾�ó ×�¾4ß�øA¾�ÛPÚ�×�Ü�ÚxÆ �  ¿ß?Ü�õÙ�Ù�Ú�ø�üQø+Ú�õö�ØAÙ���×�¾#õdÛPÜQõôÞý�öbôP¾�ýxØ+Ù6×PÜ�Ú²ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù6ô�õp×PÚ�Û�à�Qùb×Pù�ôPÚ�ôPÚ�ÛPÚ!õpôPß?Ü�ý�ø+õÙ�ÛdØ+Ù`û�¾øAû�Ú�Úfaf×�Ú�Ù�ö�ØAÙ���¾�ùbô�÷#¾_öbÚ�ø(×�¾�ÛÞ×Pù�öbÿ�¾×�ÜbÚ�ôdûõpÙ

öbÚ�ôUhSõ�õpø+Ûxß�¾�÷#ý�øAÚfa_Ú�Û�ü�ÛPù�ß?Ü�õpÛ�¯ +Xy�/<�¤ü�� � /<�¤ü á /<�vâ � ü²õÙ�ö�5XôP~'/<�¤à���Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚß�¾�÷#ý�ø+Ú�abÚ�Û�ÜQõ!û�Ú2ýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ô�õp×PÚ�Û�óUÜ�ØAß?Ü�õôPÚ�ÛPÚ�ûÚ�ôPõø/¾�ôÞö�Ú�ôÞÛ�¾ú�÷�õ.��Ù�ØA×Pù�ö�Úø+õô��Ú�ôU×�ÜQõÙ�×�Ü�¾�ÛÞÚ�¾ú�5Xô(/S��ü¨õÙbö�ØA×Xó¤¾�ùbø+ö�,ÃÚ�ØAÙz×PÚ�ôÞÚ�ÛÞ×PØ+Ù���×�¾rÛÞÚ�Ú�ØCú/×�Ü�ØAÛ|ß�õÙH,�Ú

 P ¡

Page 197: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ß�¾�Ù � ôÞ÷�Ú�ö�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�õø+øCÿ�àR5XøA×�Üb¾�ù���Ü ×�ÜbÚ�ÛPÚ�ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷#Û�õpôPÚxß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõøAøAÿ�÷#¾�ôPÚöbØAa#ß�ù�øC×(×�¾�ó�¾�ô���óUØA×PÜm,ÃÚ�ß�õù�ÛÞÚ²×PÜ�Ú�ÿ�ÜQõ!û�ÚÄ÷�¾ôPÚ�ö�Ú���ôPÚ�Ú�ÛU¾ú úÅôPÚ�Ú�ö�¾÷�ü�ØC×�÷�õ�ÿk,�Úýþ�ÛÞÛPØ1,bø+Ú�×P¾ ÷#¾�ôÞÚxõß�ß�ù�ô�õp×PÚ�øCÿSÚfaf×Pô�õß8×#×PÜ�Ú6ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù ô�õ[×�Ú�Û>,ÃÚ�ß�õù�ÛÞÚ�×PÜ�Ú�ÿõpôPÚ�÷�ù�ß?Ü6øþõpô���Ú�ô�à���Ø+ÙQõøAøAÿüó¤Ú|Ü�¾�ýÃÚ�×P¾�ö�Ú�ûÚ�øA¾�ý�×�ÜbÚ<hÊØ1�Ù�Ú�ô�õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü6õpÙ�ö�ÛÞÚ�Ú�ØCúØC×�Ø+Ûvýþ�ÛPÛÞØ1,�øAÚ(×�¾�,�ôPØAÙ��²ØA×vØAÙ`×�¾9GzùQõÙ`×�ØC×?õp×PØAû�Ú�õ��ôPÚ�Ú�÷�Ú�Ù`×móUØC×�Ü2×�ÜbÚXÙzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß�Ûvúž�ô�õpø+ø×PÜ�Ú>,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�ß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ôPÚ�ö&à�ϤÚ�ß!õùbÛPÚ2×�Ü�Ú�hÊØ���Ù�Ú�ôFyZ,�õÛPÚ�ö�õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü�ö�¾fÚ�Û�Ù�¾×ÛÞù�?�Ú�ôvúÅôP¾�÷æ×�ÜbÚ�ÛPõ÷#Ú�Ùfùb÷�Ú�ôPØ+ß�õøbØAÙ�ÛÞ×�õ�,�ØAø+ØA×PØ+Ú�Û�×PÜQõp×�ö�ØAôPÚ�ß8×vØ+Ù`×PÚ���ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù2ö�¾fÚ�Û�ü`ÛÞù�ß?ÜõpÙ�õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü�ß�¾�ù�øAö�ôÞÚ�ý�ø+õß�Ú�×PÜ�Ú²ö�Ø+ôÞÚ�ß8×UØ+Ù`×�Ú���ô�õp×PØ+¾�ÙrõÛ�õd÷#Ú�×PÜ�¾förúž�ô�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PØ+Ù��×PÜ�ÚÌýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ô�õ[×�Ú�Û�à���Ü�ÚmhÊØ1��ÙbÚ�ôFy;,QõÛÞÚ�ö�õýbý�ôP¾`õpß?ÜÈÜQõÛ#×�Ü�Ú]õpö�ö�ØA×PØ+¾�Ù�õøõpöbûpõÙ`×?õ���ÚÄ×�ÜQõ[×�ØA×Xý�ôÞ¾RûfØAö�Ú�Û�ýbÜzÿfÛÞØ+ß!õpø�Ø+ÙbÛPØ1�Üz×�ü&,`ÿC��ØAûfØAÙ��rõ�ýbÜQõÛPÚBy¡ÛÞýQõß�Ú2ýbØ+ß�×Pù�ôPÚ¾pú�×PÜ�Ú²ý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�Ø+¾Ù6ý�ôP¾fß�Ú�ÛPÛ�à

 P Â

Page 198: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ë ì íïîñðßò�ó ô

õ ò�ðßò�ópö ÷[ø íAð�÷Bùúø ù¬û ü ùúý ø þ ÿ � óRòÎòõ ÷����Hù��à÷4íAð�÷��úò ë ùúý î [÷[ø �� � ÷4í

ë 4í ���j÷��@í� � ùúý óp÷Bòéó ë ù»ò�� ��÷BòÚø´ð����ÜbØ+Û�ß?ÜQõýb×PÚ�ômý�ôPÚ�ÛPÚ�Ùz×PÛ(õÙ�õý�ýbôP¾`õß?Ü#×�¾²ß�¾÷�ý�ù_×�ÚUß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û[,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ùk,�¾�ùbÙ�örõÙböùbÙx,þ�ù�Ùbö�ó¤õ�ûÚ�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù�Û�ù�ÛPØAÙ��:¾Ù�øAÿ2ß�øþõÛÞÛPØAß!õøÆ�Q¾�ùbôPØ+Ú�ôvß�¾fÚ��#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×�Û�¾úÃ×�Ü�Ú</|õ÷#Ø+ø�y×P¾�Ù�Ø+õÙ&à���Ü�Ø+Û|õý�ý�ôÞ¾`õß?Ü]ØAÛ|õÙÌÚfaf×�Ú�Ù�ÛPØA¾�Ù]¾ú/×PÜ�Ú:ó�Ú�øAøCyZ�zÙ�¾�óUÙÌ×PÚ�ß?Ü�ÙbØ1Gzù�Ú2¾úvùbÛPØ+Ù���Q¾�ùbôPØ+Ú�ô&ß�¾fÚ��#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×PÛ�ØAÙ�×�Ü�Úmõß8×�Ø+¾Ù_y�õÙ���ø+Ú�ôPÚ�ýbôPÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õ[×�Ø+¾ÙÄ×P¾�ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Ú�,þ�ù�Ù�öfy¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú×P¾u,�¾ù�Ù�ö_y%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�ß�¾ù�ý�ø+ØAÙ���Û�àsh�Ú�ö�Ú�ûÚ�øA¾�ý2×�Ü�ÚUõÙ�õø+¾3�¾�ù�Û�,þ�ù�Ù�öfy%úÅôPÚ�Ú�õý�ýbôP¾`õß?Ü2úž�ô

 P å

Page 199: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

¾Ù�Ú8y%ö�Ø+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�õøx/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�Ù�Ø+õÙ�Û õÙbö2ö�Ú�÷#¾�Ù�ÛF×�ô�õ[×�Ú¤ØC×�úž�ô�ÛPÚ8û�Ú�ôPõø�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Xý�¾×PÚ�Ù_y×PØþõøAÛ�à���ÜbÚ��Ú�Ù�Ú�ô�õøAØ Ä õ[×�Ø+¾Ùr×�¾dÜ�Ø1�Ü�Ú�ô�ö�ØA÷�Ú�Ù�ÛPØA¾�Ù�Û(ØAÛ�õø+ÛÞ¾2ö�Ø+ÛÞß�ù�ÛÞÛPÚ�ö¨à����� � srt[èvuxwH¶H¼Ut�º�u#sI�Ú8× µ á ¼ ����â�ö�Ú�Ù�¾×�ÚÌõ�� ö�Ú��ôPÚ�ÚBy¡¾úþy�úÅôPÚ�Ú�ö�¾�÷ /Xõ÷#Ø+øA×P¾�Ù�Ø+õÙSÚfa_ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÛPÚ�öÊØAÙ�ÛÞ¾�÷�Úõpß�×�ØA¾�Ù_y¡õÙ���øAÚk,QõÛÞØ+Û á ¼ ����â8ü ¼ � Ð ¡ � Â�Ñ � àR��Ü�Úm®�ÏFÛäÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß!õpø6GzùQõÙ`×�Ø Ä õp×PØ+¾�Ù÷#Ú�×PÜ�¾fö�õÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PÚ�Û�õ�ó¤õ!û�Ú�úÅùbÙ�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù�óUØA×PÜ�×�Ü�¾�ÛÞÚdõß�×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ!� �ìá#" Å �%$&$&$�� " � â|ÛPõp×�ØAÛFyú ÿfØAÙ�� " K � å(' ¸¹ á*) K Ø�+ K £ Ê â8üzóUÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ�Ú!õpß?Ü ) K ØAÛ¤õ:Ù�¾�Ù�Ù�Ú��`õp×PØAû�ÚXØ+Ù`×�Ú���Ú�ô�übõpÙ�ö�×�ÜbÚ,+ KöbÚ�Ù�¾×PÚ�×�Ü�Ú:qÌõÛÞø+¾�û6ØAÙ�ö�Ø+ß�Ú�Û�à�ÍXÛPù�õø+øCÿ-+ K � å à��Ü�Ú�ÛPÚ(ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õø�ó¤õ�ûÚ�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù�Û/÷�õ!ÿ9,�Úmß?ÜQõôPõß�×PÚ�ôÞØ Ä Ú�ö�,`ÿ²×�Ü�Ú�Ø+ô�GzùQõÙ`×�ù�÷

Ùzù�÷b,�Ú�ôPÛ á#) Å �.$&$&$�� ) � âBü-õÙ�öU��ØCû�Ú�ôPØAÛPÚ�×�¾#õ>,QõÛÞØ+Û�ÛÞÚ�×0/Q¯ ) Å �&$&$&$�� ) � ç21 óUÜbØ+ß?Ü�÷�õ!ÿ,ÃÚ6ù�ÛÞÚ�ö�Ø+Ù�GzùQõÙ`×�ùb÷�ß!õøAß�ù�ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û�àß��Ü�Úxß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ù�סó�¾�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õøó¤õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß�×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ#¯ 3 ç � ¯ ) Å �&$&$%$�� ) � ç õÙ�ö ¯54 ç � ¯ � Å �&$&$%$��(� � ç ØAÛ ��ØAûÚ�Ùm,zÿ=Ð È.Ñ ü

� 4�¯ ´µ ¯ 3 ç ��µ76 o98 á � 6 Ø:� 8å â á � à  â"%6 ü " 8 ö�Ú�Ùb¾×�Ú�×�ÜbÚ²õß�×PØ+¾�ÙrûÚ�ß�×P¾�ôPÛ�ß�¾ôPôPÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ���×�¾2×PÜ�ÚuGzùQõÙ`×�ù�÷ìÙzù�÷b,�Ú�ôPÛ;4Nü3�ü-ôPÚ�ÛPýÃÚ�ß�×PØAûÚ�øAÿü¨õpÙ�ö µ=<bá ��â�öbÚ�Ù�¾×PÚ�Û�×�Ü�Ú?>j�Q¾�ù�ôÞØ+Ú�ô�ß�¾�÷#ý�¾�ÙbÚ�Ù`×|¾pú µ Ú�ûpõø+ù�õp×�Ú�ö

 P ¿

Page 200: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

õ[×;�püQö�Ú � Ù�Ú�ö�ûfØþõ�×PÜ�Ú²Úfa_ýQõÙ�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù¨üµ á ¼ ����â ��@ < µ=<bá#" âBAg� ï K <(C « á � à å â

��ÜbØ+Û|ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õø ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���úž�ôÞ÷�ù�ø+õ�Ø+Û�ó¤Ú�ø+ø�yZ�zÙ�¾�óUÙ&ü&õpÙ�ö]ÜQõÛXý�ôP¾�û�Ú�Ù�ù�ÛPÚ8úÅù�ø/Ø+ÙÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õøvõýbý�ôP¾`õpß?Ü�Ú�Û²×�¾x×�Ü�Ú2GzùQõÙ`×Pù�÷ öbÿfÙQõ÷#Ø+ß�Û²¾ú§,þ�ù�Ù�ö ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷#Û�Ð Â ü å ü¿ ü8P_ü È$Ñ àhÊÜQõ[×�õ.,�¾�ù_ײö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Øþõ[×�ØAûÚ�ý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛPÛÞÚ�Û�DÝ��Ü�õpײØ+Û�üs�ØAû�Ú�Ù õU,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�õpÙ�ö õ

ß�¾�Ù`×�ØAÙfùbù�÷�ÛÞ×�õp×�ÚvóUÜ�ØAß?Ü�õôÞÚ,þ×PÜÄÚ�Ø1��Ú�Ù�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�¾púbÛÞ¾�÷�Ú Ä Ú�ôP¾p×�Ü_y%¾�ôPö�Ú�ôs/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�Ù�Ø+õÙµ É üzõpÙ�ödõ�ý�Ú�ôÞ×Pù�ô�,Qõ[×�Ø+¾Ù ½ ü`Ø+Û�ØA×/ýþ�ÛÞÛPØ1,bø+Ú¤×P¾�Úfa_ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÛv×�ÜbÚ ½ y¡ØAÙ�ö�ù�ß�Ú�ödö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØCû�Úß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��2,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ù�×�Ü�ڲסó¤¾�Ø+Ùx×�Ú�ôP÷#ÛX¾ú�×�Ü�ÚÄß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø��Q¾�ù�ôPØAÚ�ô�ß�¾_Ú2��ß�Ø+Ú�Ùz×PÛ|¾ú ½ DÃfù�ß?Ürõ�úž�ôÞ÷�ù�øþõ|ó�¾�ù�øAöY,ÃÚUù�ÛPÚ8úÅù�øQúž�ôvÚfaf×PÚ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ��ÄÛPÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØAß!õøQõpÙQõøAÿfÛÞÚ�Û�,QõÛÞÚ�ö�¾Ùß�øþõÛÞÛPØAß!õø¦�Q¾�ù�ôÞØ+Ú�ô�ß�¾_Ú2�#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×�Û�×P¾|ý�ôÞ¾3,�øAÚ�÷#Û�ØAÙ`û�¾�øCû_ØAÙ��:,�¾�Ùböb,�ôÞÚ!õ��zØ+Ù�� á û_Ø�,�ô�õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõøýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�Ø+Û�¾�Ù�Ú0��¾f¾_ö�Úfabõ÷#ý�ø+Ú!â8à:ϤÚ�ß!õù�ÛÞÚ�ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß!õpø�ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ¾pú�×�Ü�Ú/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�ÙbØþõÙ�,QõpÛPÚ�öN¾�ÙÈß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø:�-¾ù�ôPØAÚ�ôdß�¾fÚ��#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×�Ûk��ôPÚ8ó ¾�ùb×�¾ú�×�ÜbÚ®�ÏFÛ ÷�Ú8×�Ü�¾fö&üv×�ÜbÚ�ÛPÚ�õý�ýbôP¾`õß?ÜbÚ�ÛdôPÚ�GfùbØ+ôPÚ�öNõpÙ�õpß�×�ØA¾�Ù_y¡õÙ���øAÚ�ôPÚ�ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÚ�Ùz×�õp×�ØA¾�Ù�¾ú×PÜ�Ú"/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�ÙbØþõÙ&ü�õÙ�ö�ó�Ú�ôPÚd×�ÜbÚ�ôPÚ8úž�ôPÚ#ø+ØA÷�ØC×�Ú�ö�×�¾m,þ�ù�Ù�ö_y;,�¾ù�Ù�ö�ý�ôP¾fß�Ú�ÛPÛÞÚ�Û�àY�¡Ùõpö�ö�ØA×PØ+¾�Ù¨üb×�Ü�Ú²×�ôPõö�ØC×�Ø+¾ÙQõø�úžfß�ùbÛ�óUØC×�Ü�ØAÙx×PÜ�Ø+Û�õôÞÚ!õ#¾ú/ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø&÷#Ú�×�Üb¾_ö�ÛUÜQõpÛ,ÃÚ�Ú�Ù�¾�Ù�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�ÛPýÃÚ�ß8×�ô�õ_ü�ÛÞ¾�×�ÜbÚ�ôPÚdÜQõpÛÄÙb¾×�,�Ú�Ú�ÙSõx÷�õFEÞ¾�ô�ØA÷�ýÃÚ�×Pù�Û�×�¾�ö�Ú�ûÚ�øA¾�ýõpÙ�õpÙQõø+¾���¾�ù�Û�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø�úž�ôÞ÷�ù�ø+õ�úž�ô�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú�ý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛÞÛPÚ�Û�à

 P Ê

Page 201: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

�Q¾�ôrùbÙx,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ù�Ù¦,þ�ù�Ù�ö�ý�ôP¾fß�Ú�ÛPÛÞÚ�Û�ü�qÌõØA×Pô�õ õÙbö�/�Ú�øAø+Ú�ôHÐ Â2Â�Ñ ö�Ú�ûÚ�øA¾�ý�Ú�öèõpÙõpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü-,QõÛÞÚ�öx¾�Ù�×PÜ�Ú|ùbÛPÚ�¾ú­h@Û9Ï�ó¤õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß�×PØ+¾�ÙbÛUõÛ(õ�öbØ+ÛÞ×P¾�ôÞ×PÚ�ö_y�ó(õ!ûÚu,QõÛPØAÛ�àÃfý�Ú�ß�Ø � ß!õøAøAÿ�ü�×�Ü�Ú8ÿ]ß�¾�ÙbÛPØ+öbÚ�ôPÚ�ö ×PÜ�Údý�ôP¾�,�ø+Ú�÷ä¾ú�õ�,þ�û�Ú8y;,QõôÞôPØ+Ú�ô�ôPÚ8{QÚ�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù�ØAÙ]¾�Ù�Ú8yöbØ+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù&übõÙ�öxÛPÜb¾Ró�Ú�ö�×�ÜQõ[×�×�Ü�Ú�ù�ÛÞÚ²¾ú ×�Ü�Úuh@Û9ÏÈó(õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù�Û�ó�¾�ô��Ú�ö�ó¤Ú�ø+øõ[×(Ú�ÛÞÛPÚ�Ùz×PØþõøAøAÿ�õøAø�õ.,�¾�û�ÚByZ,QõpôPôPØAÚ�ô�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���ØAÚ�Û�õÛ(õ�ö�Ø+ÛF×�¾�ôF×�Ú�ö_y%ó¤õ!û�Úu,QõÛÞØ+Û�Ø+Ù�×PÜ�Ú � ôÞÛÞ×Þy¾ôPö�Ú�ô�Ϥ¾�ôÞÙ õý�ýbôP¾ga_Ø+÷�õp×�ØA¾�Ù&à�hÊÜ�Ø+øAÚ#×PÜ�Ú�ØAô:ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���úž�ôP÷�ù�øþõ6ó(õpÛ�Ù�¾×b��ØAûÚ�Ù Ø+Ù×PÚ�ôÞ÷�Û#¾ú�ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õø:�Q¾�ù�ôPØAÚ�ôdß�¾fÚ��#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×PÛr¾ú�×PÜ�Ú/Xõ÷#Ø+øA×P¾�Ù�Ø+õÙ&ü�ØA×#Ø+Û#ýþ�ÛPÛÞØ1,�øAÚ�×P¾ÛÞÜ�¾�óæ×�ÜQõp×�ü-Ø+Ù�õ#ÛPùG�#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×PøAÿ�ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø�øAØ+÷#ØA×�üb×�Ü�Ú:ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ��#úžôP÷�ù�ø+õ2÷�õ!ÿm,�Ú�ØAû�Ú�Ù�ØAÙ6ÛPù�ß?ÜÌõdúžôP÷�à�¡Ù�×PÜ�Ú�ØAô|ýQõýÃÚ�ô�ü qÌõØC×�ôPõ�õÙ�ö=/�Ú�øAø+Ú�ô�ö�ØAÛPß�ùbÛPÛPÚ�ö]×�Ü�Ú�ØAö�Ú!õ�¾ú�¾3,b×�õØ+Ù�ØAÙ��rõY��Ú�Ù_y

Ú�ô�õø�÷#Ú�×�Üb¾_ö�×�¾ õÛÞÛPØ���Ù�õ�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø GzùQõÙ`×�ù�÷ ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ��ß,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�ÙÝõÙ`ÿ�סó�¾ß�¾�Ù`×�¾�ùbôPÛ�ØAÙNý�Ü�õÛPÚBy¡ÛPý�õß�Úpà��¡ÙÈýQõpôÞ×�ØAß�ù�ø+õô�ü�ÛPù�ß?ÜÊõ�úž�ôP÷�ù�øþõ]ó¤¾ù�ø+ö�Ø+Ù�ß�ø+ù�ö�Úx×�ÜbÚõ.,�Ø+øAØAסÿ�×P¾�ß�¾�÷�ýbùb×�Ú�ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�Ùró¤õ�ûÚ�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù�Û(ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��:×�¾b,þ�ù�ÙböõpÙ�ö�ùbÙx,þ�ù�Ùbö�ý�Ü�õÛPÚBy¡ÛPý�õß�ÚÄß�¾�Ù`×P¾�ù�ôPÛ�à��Ü�Ú�ö�ØH�#ß�ùbøAסÿ�Ø+Ùß��Ú�ÙbÚ�ô�õpø+Ø Ä Ø+Ù��6×PÜ�Úk,þ�ù�Ù�öfyZ,þ�ù�Ù�öSß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��xúž�ôÞ÷�ù�øþõr×P¾�×�ÜbÚ

,þ�ù�Ùbö_y%úÅôÞÚ�Ú�ß!õpÛPÚUØ+Û�×PÜQõp×/×PÜ�Ú�ôÞÚUØ+Ûvõ�ÛPùbö�ö�Ú�Ù#ß?ÜQõÙ���Ú�Ø+Ù�×PÜ�Ú�×�¾�ýþ�ø+¾��ÿľú-×�Ü�Ú�ý�Ü�õÛPÚByÛÞýQõß�Ú�Ø+Ù���¾�ØAÙ���úÅôÞ¾�÷�×PÜ�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öxôPÚ���Ø+÷#ÚX×P¾�×�Ü�Ú�ùbÙx,þ�ù�Ùbö�ôÞÚ���ØA÷�Úpà��¡Ù6×�Ü�Úu,þ�ù�ÙböôÞÚ���ØA÷�Ú ØA×ÌØ+Û�ý�¾�ÛÞÛPØ�,�ø+Ú�×�¾�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø+øCÿÈß?ÜQõôPõß�×PÚ�ôÞØ Ä ÚS×PÜ�Ú�ó¤õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß�×PØ+¾�ÙbÛc,`ÿGzùQõpÙz×Pù�÷ Ùfùb÷�,�Ú�ôPÛ�ß�¾�ôÞôPÚ�ÛÞý�¾Ù�ö�Ø+Ù���×�¾�ö�Ú � ÙbØA×�Ú�ûpõø+ù�Ú�Û�¾pú�×�Ü�Ú�ß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø�õß8×�ØA¾�Ù&ü

 P Á

Page 202: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

óUÜbØ+ø+Ú�ØAÙ#×PÜ�Ú�ù�Ù¦,�¾�ùbÙ�ö�ôÞÚ���ØA÷�Ú(×PÜ�Ø+Û�Ø+ÛvÙb¾×¤ýþ�ÛÞÛPØ1,bø+ÚàB��Üzù�Û�ü_ØA×�Ø+Û�Ù�¾p×�ØA÷�÷#Ú�öbØþõp×PÚ�øAÿ¾�,zûfØA¾�ù�ÛUØ+Ù6óUÜQõp×Uß�õÙ�¾�ÙbØ+ß!õpø­,QõÛPØAÛ(×�¾"�Q¾�ù�ôÞØ+Ú�ô�Ú�a_ýQõÙ�öx×�Ü�Ú�/Xõ÷�ØAøA×P¾�Ù�ØþõpÙ&à��Ü�ØAÛ¤ß?ÜQõpýb×�Ú�ô¤ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×�ÛUõ:ÛÞù�ß�ß�Ú�ÛÞÛÞúÅù�ø�õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü�×�¾:×�Ü�ØAÛ�ý�ôÞ¾3,�øAÚ�÷�à[Ã_ýÃÚ�ß�Ø � ß�õø+øCÿ�ü

ó�Ú�Úfaf×�Ú�Ù�ö:×PÜ�Ú�,�¾ù�Ù�ö_y;,�¾�ùbÙ�öÄúžôP÷�ù�ø+õ�×�¾�×PÜ�Ú�,�¾�ùbÙ�ö_y%úÅôÞÚ�Ú�ß!õpÛPÚvúž�ô��#y%ö�Ø+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�õøÛÞÚ�ýQõpô�õ�,�øAÚ�ÛFÿfÛÞ×�Ú�÷�Û�üóUÜ�Ú�ôPÚ¤×PÜ�Ú�ýþ×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø`úž�ô Ú!õß?Ü�öbÚ���ôÞÚ�Ú¤¾pú�úÅôPÚ�Ú�ö�¾�÷�Ü�õÛ/õ�ôPÚ�ýbù�øCyÛÞØAûÚ(Ø+Ù�ÙbÚ�ô�ó¤õøAø�üpõÙ�ö2ÛPùbý�ý�¾ôÞ×�Û4,�¾×PÜ�,þ�ù�Ù�ö2õpÙ�ö2ù�Ù¦,�¾ù�Ù�ö2ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�à���ÜbØ+Û/õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü×PÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ�úž�ôÞÚ|ØAÙ�ß�øAù�ö�Ú�Û�÷�¾ÛÞ×(ß?ÜbÚ�÷#Ø+ß!õpø+øAÿ�Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôPÚ�ÛF×�ØAÙ���ÛFÿ_ÛF×�Ú�÷�Û�ü�ÛPØAÙ�ß�Ú�ß?ÜbÚ�÷#Ø+ß!õpø*,þ�Ù�öbÛõpôPÚ²¾ú ×�Ú�Ùxö�Ú�ÛÞß�ôPØ�,Qõ�,�øAÚ�óUØA×�ÜxÛÞù�ß?ÜÌýþ×�Ú�Ù`×�Øþõpø+Û á Úà ��àv×�Ü�Ú:q�¾�ôÞÛPÚ²ýþ×�Ú�Ùz×PØþõøþâ8à��Ü�ØAÛXß?Ü�õýb×�Ú�ô|ØAÛ�¾ô��`õÙbØ Ä Ú�öÌõpÛ�úž�øAø+¾�óUÛ����¡Ù�Ã_Ú�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù � à å üQó�Ú�ö�Ú8û�Ú�øA¾�ý�×PÜ�Úľ�Ù�Ú8y

öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�ÙQõpø�ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷ óUÜ�ØAß?Ü�ó�Ú óUØAø+ø�ß�¾�Ù�ÛPØAö�Ú�ô�à h�Úß�¾�¾ÙèØ+Ù�Ã_Ú�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù � à ¿ ×P¾ß�¾�Ù�ÛF×�ôPùbß�×#×�Ü�ÚxÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß!õpøF,�¾ù�Ù�ö�õÙ�ö4ù�Ù¦,�¾ù�Ù�öNÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�ü�õÙ�ö4Ø+ÙEÃ_Ú�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù � à Êó�Ú]ö�Ú�ôPØAûÚ�×�Ü�Ú]ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õøUß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ��R,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�ÙÊ×�ÜbÚ�÷�àÎh�Ú�×�Ú�ÛÞ×x¾�ùbô�úž�ôP÷�ù�øþõóUØC×�Ü�ÛP¾�÷#Ú�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôÞØ+ß!õpø�Ú�abõ÷�ýbø+Ú�ÛXØ+Ù�Ã_Ú�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù � à Á à:h�Ú�öbØ+ÛPß�ù�ÛPÛ|Ü�¾�óW×PÜ�Ú�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��úžôP÷�ù�ø+õ�÷�õ!ÿU,ÃÚ9��Ú�Ù�Ú�ô�õøAØ Ä Ú�ö�õÙ�ö�õý�ý�øAØ+Ú�öx×�¾#ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù6ý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛPÛÞÚ�ÛXØ+ÙÃ_Ú�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù� à � à���Ø+ÙQõøAøAÿüfó�Ú:ýbôPÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×X¾�ù�ô�ß�¾Ù�ß�øAù�ÛPØA¾�Ù�ÛUØ+ÙCÃ_Ú�ß�×�ØA¾�Ù � àQP_à

 P �

Page 203: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

���B� I���³ J ¸LK ºg·8t/u#sHº�¸�s¯¤¾Ù�ÛPØAö�Ú�ô�×�ÜbÚľÙ�Ú8y%ö�Ø+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�õø]/Xõ÷�ØAøA×P¾�Ù�ØþõpÙ&ü

µ É á#M �ONÃâ � N �å � Ø ½ á#M â á � à ¿ âh�Ú²õÛÞÛPù�÷#Ú�×�ÜQõ[× ½ ÜQõÛ¤×PÜ�Ú�úž�øAø+¾�óUØ+Ù��:ý�ôP¾ý�Ú�ôÞ×�ØAÚ�Û�� á  â�øAØ+÷�×QP o � ½ á*M â �SR à á å âøAØ+÷�×QP � ½ á*M â � ½ É à á�¿ â ½ õp×P×�õØ+ÙbÛÄØC×�Û9��øA¾3,Qõø/÷#Ø+ÙbØ+÷�ù�÷�õp×:ÛP¾�÷#Ú M JsK ê�ü�õÙ�ö Ø+Û÷#¾�Ù�¾p×�¾�Ù�Ú�öbÚ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞØ+Ù��dúž�ô M � M JsK ê#õÙ�ö�÷�¾Ù�¾×�¾Ù�Ú�Ø+Ù�ß�ôPÚ�õÛPØAÙ���úž�ô M t M JBK ê�à��Ü�Úrq�¾�ôÞÛPÚ�¾ÛPß�ØAø+ø+õp×�¾�ô á ½ á*M â � � á  �TA oVU M â � â�Ø+ÛÄõC�¾_¾fö�Ú�abõ÷�ýbø+Úd¾ú(ÛÞù�ß?Ü

õ�ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷�àHÃ_ùbß?Ü4õ�/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�ÙbØþõÙ�õöb÷�ØC×�Û9,�¾ù�Ù�öSÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�ù�ý�×�¾Ì×PÜ�Ú�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�ÙÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ ½ É übõÙ�ör¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ���ÛF×?õp×PÚ�ÛUõ�,þ�û�Ú ½ É à�ϤÚ�ø+¾�ó ½ É ü_ó�Ú�÷�õ!ÿ�õÛPÛÞù�÷#Ú|×�ÜQõ[פ×�ÜbÚ,þ�ù�Ùbö_y¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û²õôÞÚ>��ØAûÚ�Ù=,`ÿHGzùQõÙ`×�ù�÷äÙfùb÷�,�Ú�ôPÛ=/ ) 1 ü�ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛÞý�¾�Ùbö�Ø+Ù��6×P¾xõß�×PØ+¾�Ù�Û" ê � å(' ¸¹ á#) Ø Å� â8ü_õß�ß�¾�ôPöbØ+Ù��²×�¾�h@Û�Ï�×�Ü�Ú�¾�ôÞÿ#Ø+Ù�¾�Ù�Ú�ö�Ø+÷#Ú�ÙbÛPØ+¾Ù&à45<,�¾�û�Ú ½ É üz×�ÜbÚ/Xõ÷#Ø+øA×P¾�Ù�Ø+õÙrõöb÷�ØC×�Û(¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ��2ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�úžôUõø+ø�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô���ØAÚ�Û�éAt ½ É àÃ_ùbý�ý�¾ÛPÚdó¤Ú#õö�ö õxý�Ú�ôÞ×Pù�ô�,Qõ[×�ØAûÚ2ý�¾p×�Ú�Ù`×PØþõø ½LW ÅYX á#M âXóUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü ß!õpÙ ØAÙ�ö�ù�ß�Údß�¾�ù_y

ýbø+Ø+Ù���Û>,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�ÙN×PÜ�ÚxÚ�Ø���Ú�Ù�ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�àÒ+�ù�ô2��¾`õpø(Ø+Û2×�¾]óUôÞØA×�Úxö�¾�óUÙ�õ ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õøÚ�a_ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÛPØA¾�Ù�úž�ô � é�¯ ´½=W ÅYX ¯ ) ç ü-óUÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ̯ é ç ö�Ú�Ù�¾×PÚ�Û�õÙ̾�ùb×(�¾�Ø+Ù��#ÛÞ×�õp×�Úpü&õÙböN¯ ) ç ö�Ú8yÙb¾×�Ú�Û2õ,þ�ù�Ù�ö ÛF×?õp×PÚà���¾]ö�¾Ì×PÜ�Ø+Û�ü�ó¤Ú6÷�ù�ÛÞ× � ôPÛÞ×:óUôPØC×�Úrö�¾�óUÙ4õÌÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õøÚ�a_ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÛPØA¾�Ù�úžô(×�Ü�Ú9,þ�ù�Ù�ö�õÙ�öxù�Ù¦,þ�ù�Ù�ö�ó(õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù�Û�à

 P�P

Page 204: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

���'± I���³ Z®s�³uè\[=]_^`Iܺ%K ³ ²´³,aHè[³uµB³�srt�¸:t�º�u#s5ÊôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�ÙdóUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü#Ø+ÛvØAö�Ú!õpø+øAÿ:ÛPùbØA×�Ú�ö2×�¾²×�Ü�Ú:/|õp÷�ØAøA×�¾Ù�ØþõÙ µ É ØAÛ/×�Ü�ÚUÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ`y×PØ+÷#ÚÌôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù&à �¡ÙÊ×PÜ�Ø+Û6ß�õÙ�¾�ÙbØ+ß!õpøS,QõÛÞØ+Û�ü�×PÜ�Ú�ß!õÙ�¾Ù�Ø+ß�õø|÷#¾�÷#Ú�Ù`×�ù�÷ Ø+Û�ØAû�Ú�Ù=,zÿ�×�Ü�Ú2Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ]é � µ É á#M �ONÃâBü�õÙ�ö]×�ÜbÚ2ß!õÙ�¾Ù�Ø+ß�õø�ýþ�ÛPØC×�ØA¾�Ù�Ø+ÛX×�Ü�Ú�×Pô�õÙbÛPØA××PØ+÷#ÚXúÅôÞ¾�÷°×PÜ�Ú�Ø+Ù�ÙbÚ�ô(×�ùbôPÙ�ØAÙ��2ý�¾Ø+Ù`×Uõp×�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿxé ×P¾ á#M �ONÃâ8à[�%ú ó�Ú²ö�Ú � ÙbÚ0b á é�â�×P¾,ÃÚ2×�Ü�Ú2×PØ+÷#Ú�ØA×�×�õ��Ú�Û�õ6×�ôPõFEÞÚ�ß8×�¾�ôFÿ�×�¾m��¾6úÅôP¾�÷ ×�Ü�ÚdØAÙ�Ù�Ú�ô�×Pù�ôPÙ�ØAÙ��xý�¾Ø+Ù`×�×�¾6×�ÜbÚ¾ùb×�Ú�ôU×Pù�ôPÙbØ+Ù��2ýþ�Ø+Ù`×�õp×UÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�é�ü_×�Ü�Ú�Ù�õÙ`ÿ6ýþ�Ø+Ù`×U¾�Ù6×PÜ�Ú µ É á#M �ONÃâ � é ý�Ü�õÛPÚByÛÞýQõß�Ú�ß�¾�Ù`×�¾�ù�ôx÷�õ!ÿÒ,ÃÚ ùbÙ�Ø1Gzù�Ú�øAÿÈß?Ü�õô�õß8×�Ú�ôPØ Ä Ú�ö�,zÿÈÛP¾�÷#Úcb � Ð �db á é�âf�Bb á é�â Ñ àÏ�Ú�ß!õpù�ÛPÚ áOe b��?é�â�ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×�Û�ÛÞ¾�÷�Ú á*M � e NÃâBü ØA×�úž�øAø+¾�óUÛ�×�ÜQõ[ײØ+Ù]×�Ü�ÚdÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ`y%×�ØA÷�ÚôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù�¾ú ½ W ÅYX á*M â�ó�Ú:Ü�õ�ûÚ ½ W ÅYX á b��?é�â � ½ W ÅYX á �db���é�â8à��Ü�ÚC��Ú�ÙbÚ�ô�õ[×�Ø+Ù�� úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù4úÅôP¾�÷ ×PÜ�Ú á#M �ONÃâ�ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷ ×�¾�×�ÜbÚ á b��?é�â2ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷ Ø+Û

�ØAû�Ú�Ù�ûfØ+õbü f á#M �?é�â � � ××hg W v X N á*M(i �?é�â   MFi á � à Ê âóUÜbÚ�ôPÚ M o á é�âvö�Ú�Ùb¾×�Ú�Û¤×�Ü�Ú|Ø+Ù�Ù�Ú�ôm×Pù�ôPÙbØ+Ù��:ý�¾�ØAÙ`×(õpפÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�é#ü�õÙ�ö?Nrö�Ú�Ù�¾×�Ú�Û¤×�ÜbÚ÷#¾�÷#Ú�Ù`×�ùb÷�ü���ØCû�Ú�Ùß,`ÿ-N á#M �?é�â ��j å � á éà� ½ á#M âPâ?à-��Ü�Ú�ß�¾�Ù`û�Ú�ôPÛPØA¾�Ù�úÅôÞ¾�÷ä×�ÜbÚá*M �YNÃâ�×�¾2×�ÜbÚ á b��?é�â¤ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù�÷�õ!ÿk,�Ú²¾3,b×�õØ+ÙbÚ�ö6úÅôP¾�÷�×�Ü�Ú²Ú�Gfù�õp×�ØA¾�Ù�Û0Ð å P Ñ ü

N á#M �?é�â � »f» M á*M ��é�â á � à Á â

 P.N

Page 205: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

b á#M �?é�â � »f

» éá*M ��é�â á � à � â

�%×d÷�õ!ÿj,ÃÚ6ÛPØA÷�ý�øCÿ ÛPÜ�¾�óUÙ4×�ÜQõp×kb á#M �?é�â:ØAÛ�×�ÜbÚr×�Ø+÷#Ú�ØC×�×�õ��Ú�Ûdúžô2õ�ýQõôF×�Ø+ß�ø+ÚÛF×?õôF×�ØAÙ���õ[×�×PÜ�ÚÌØAÙ�Ù�Ú�ôd×�ùbôPÙ�ØAÙ���ýþ�Ø+Ù`×�õp×�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿNé ×�¾�ôÞÚ!õß?Ü�×�Ü�Ú�ý�¾�ØAÙ`× M àÔ�¡Ùß�¾�Ù`×�ôPõÛÞ×�×P¾�×PÜ�Ú á ¼ � " â²ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù¨ü�×�Ü�Ú á b��?é�â²ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù ß�õÙR,ÃÚrù�ÛPÚ�ö×P¾�ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×V,þ×�Ü�×�Ü�Ú0,�¾�ùbÙ�ö�õÙböÌù�Ù¦,þ�ù�Ù�ö�Ú�Ø1��Ú�ÙbúÅù�Ù�ß8×�ØA¾�Ù�ÛU¾ú µ É à ��Ü�Ú�h@Û9Ïó¤õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß�×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ|õôÞÚ²ôPÚ!õpø õÙ�öx÷�õ!ÿ�,ÃÚ9��ØAûÚ�ÙU,`ÿ�ü) v á#M â �Sl2á é�ânm oooooo » �

f» M » é oooooo á Ú�abýsÐ Á

f á*M �?é�â £ ¸¹ Ñ Ø�Úfa_ýsÐ � Áf á#M �?é�â £ ¸¹ Ñ â á � à�P�â

óUÜbÚ�ôPÚ l2á é�â2Ø+ÛdÛP¾�÷#Ú�Ù�¾�ôP÷�õøAØ Ä õ[×�Ø+¾ÙSß�¾�ÙbÛÞ×?õpÙz×#óUÜ�ØAß?Ü�ó�ÚÌÙ�¾�ó ö�Ú8×�Ú�ôÞ÷�ØAÙ�ÚàE�¡ÙôÞÚ!õøAØAסÿü&×�Ü�ØAÛ²úžôP÷�ù�ø+õk,�ôÞÚ!õ��zÛÄö�¾�óUÙ�Ù�Ú�õô�×�Ü�Úd×�ù�ôÞÙ�Ø+Ù���ýþ�ØAÙz×PÛ�à"/X¾�ó�Ú�ûÚ�ô�ü�Ø+Ù]×�ÜbÚÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õø¨øAØ+÷#ØA×�ó�ÚÄóUØAø+ø�õÛPÛÞù�÷�Ú á õÛ(óUØA×PÜx×PÜ�ÚÄõÙQõøA¾3��¾�ùbÛ(ö�Ú�ôÞØAûpõp×PØ+¾�Ù�Û�úž�ô¤×�ÜbÚß�õÛPÚ�¾pú�õß�×PØ+¾�Ù9p¡õÙ���øAÚXôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�ÙbÛ?â�×�Ü�õp×�¾�Ù�øCÿ#ß�¾�Ù`×�ôÞØ1,�ù_×�Ø+¾Ù�Û¤úÅôP¾÷�×PÜ�Ú�ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØqpß�õø+øCÿrõpø+ø+¾�ó�Ú�öxôPÚ���Ø+¾Ù�õpôPÚ�Ø+÷#ýþ�ôÞ×�õÙ`×!übØAÙ6óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü�ß!õÛÞÚ�×�Ü�ÚÄõ�,þ�û�Ú²úž�ôP÷�ùbøþõ�Ü�¾�øAö�Û�à�%ú�é r ½ É ü�×�Ü�Ú�ÙNé � é á#) â � µ É á*" ê�â8ü�õÙ�ö ó¤Ú6ó¤õÙ`×�×PÜ�Ú6Ù�¾�ôÞ÷�õpø+Ø Ä õp×�ØA¾�Ù

� ) i ¯ ) ç � �8ê�ê���àRhÊØC×�Ü�¾ùb×2ø+¾ÛPÛ2¾ú<��Ú�ÙbÚ�ô�õpø+ØAסÿ�ó¤Úx÷�õ!ÿ õÛÞÛPù�÷#Ú6×�ÜQõp×#é�êsr éUê���à��Üzù�Û�üQó¤Úľ3,b×�õØ+Ù&ü�Bê�ê � 7°¯ l ê ¸l ê � ¯ � ×utv× gv   MFi oooooo » �

f» M i » é oooooo á A K WxwyW × � # v v � X o wyW × � # v v XHXqz ëí Ø:A o K WxwyW × � # v v � Xþo w{W × � # v v XHXqz ëí âá � àQN`â

 P È

Page 206: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÛÞØ+Ù�ß�Ú�ó�ÚrõôÞÚ�Ù�Ú���ø+Ú�ß�×PØ+Ù��x×�Ü�Ú�ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß!õpø+øAÿÌúž�ô�,�ØAö�ö�Ú�Ù�ôPÚ���Ø+¾Ù&àU�X¾×PÚ�×PÜQõp×Äó¤Ú6õpø+ÛP¾ÙbÚ���øAÚ�ß�×�×�ÜbÚm×PÚ�ôP÷#Û Ø+Ù`û�¾øAûfØ+Ù��

f á#M i ��éUê�â�Ø f á*M i �?éUê � â8às�¡Ù:×�ÜbÚ�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø`ø+ØA÷�ØCרó�ÚõpÛPÛPùb÷�Ú�×�ÜQõ[× ¸¹ ØAÛ�ÛÞ÷�õpø+ø�ü�ÛÞ¾X×PÜ�Ú¤ß�¾�ôPôÞÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�öbØ+Ù���Úfa_ýþ�Ù�Ú�Ù`×PØþõøAÛ�¾�ÛÞß�ØAø+øþõ[×�ÚvÛPù9��ß�Ø+Ú�Ùz×PøAÿôPõý�ØAö�øAÿ�×�ÜQõp×�×�ÜbÚ:ØAÙz×PÚ���ôPõø+ÛUõpôPÚÄÚ�ÛPÛÞÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø+øCÿ ¡ à Ïmÿ6×�Ü�ÚÄÛ�õ÷#ÚÄõô��ù�÷�Ú�Ù`×!üQó¤Ú:Ù�Ú�Ú�ö¾Ù�øAÿ�ß�¾�ÙbÛPØ+öbÚ�ô

f á#M i �?é�ê��+âF� f á*M i �?é�ê`â:úž�ô�éUê��<7 é�ê�àch�Ú6×PÜfùbÛ#÷�õ��pÚxõ�ø+Ø+ÙbÚ!õôõpý�ý�ôP¾ga_Ø+÷�õp×PØ+¾�Ù6õ.,�¾�ù_×�éUêbüb×�¾2��Ú8×!ü�Bê�ê��87°¯ l êï � � × tv× gv   M i oooooo » �

f» M i » é oooooo á A K}|B~|B� oooooo � v W v v � o v v XHz ëí ØsA o Kh|B~|B� oooooo � v W v v � o v v Xqz ëí âá � à È â

��¾�ó²ü�ù�ÛPØAÙ��-b �  w v ü&ó�Ú2��Ú�×�×PÜQõp×   b � ¯  î wÂ × Â v ¯   M õp×�ß�¾Ù�ÛÞ×�õÙ`×�é#à>Ã_ØAÙ�ß�Ú�ó�Ú#õôPÚß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ôPØ+Ù���×�ÜbÚ�×�ù�ôÞÙ�Ø+Ù��Ìýþ�Ø+Ù`×�Û�õp×�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�éUê_ü�×�ÜbÚ�Ù ß?ÜQõÙ���Ø+Ù���ûpõôPØ+õ�,�ø+Ú�ÛÄúÅôÞ¾�÷á*M �YNÃâ�×�¾ á b���é�â6��ØCû�Ú�Û�ü�8ê�ê�� � ¯ l êï � á �7� vÉ   b i A K W v v � o v v X � � z ëí Ø �7� vÉ   b i A o K W v v � o v v X � � z ëí â� ¯ l êï � � � vo � v   b i A K W v v � o v v X � � z ëí á � à  ¡ â

��¾�ó²üQÛPØ+Ùbß�Ú�ó�Ú:õpôPÚ�Ø+Ùr×PÜ�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öxôPÚ���Ø+÷#ÚübéUê � é á*" ê�â8übóUÜ�Ú�ôPÚ " ê � å(' ¸¹ á*) Ø Å� âØAÛm×PÜ�Ú�õpß�×�ØA¾�Ù&à�5(פÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�é�êbü_¾�ô�Ú�Gzù�ØAûpõøAÚ�Ù`×�øCÿ�ü_õp×(õpß�×�ØA¾�Ù " êbüzó�Ú�ÜQõ!û�Ú ¼ �S�&á#" â�bBüóUÜbÚ�ôPÚ �&á*" â�­�� v��� à�5S�`õpØ+Ù&ü�ÛÞØ+Ù�ß�ÚÄéUê � 7®éUê_ü�ó�Úľ�,b×?õØAÙ&ü

�8ê�ê�� � ¯ l ê�¯ ��&á#" ê`â � zîo zî   ¼ Ag� ï K W ê o ê � X N ¡

Page 207: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

� ¯ l ê�¯ ��&á#" ê`â �8ê�ê�� á � à Â2 âÛÞ¾#ó�Ú²¾3,b×�õØ+Ù l ê ��j �&á*" ê`âBà��Ü�ØAÛ�×?õ.�Ú�Û�ß!õôÞÚ¤¾úQ×PÜ�Ú6,þ�ù�Ù�ö2ÛF×?õp×PÚ¤Ù�¾ôP÷�õø+Ø Ä õp×PØ+¾�Ù&à]�-¾ô�×�ÜbÚ¤¾�ùb×���¾�ØAÙ��|ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�ü

ó�Ú2ó(õpÙz× � é i ¯ é ç � � á éé�Èé i â8à�h�Ú2ß�õÙ úžø+ø+¾�óWõrÛÞØ+÷#Ø+øþõpôXý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ö�ùbôPÚ#õÛ²õ�,þ�û�ÚüôÞÚ�÷#Ú�÷�,ÃÚ�ôÞØ+Ù���×PÜQõp×�Ø+Ùr×PÜ�Ú²ù�Ù¦,�¾ù�Ù�öÌôÞÚ���ØA÷�Úpü9b¤ß!õÙm��¾2×�¾ R ü���ØCûfØ+Ù���ü

� á éà� é i â � ¯ l2á é�âR¯ � �Y�o �   bhA K W v � o v X � z ëí� åF' ¸¹ ¯ l�á é�âR¯ �(� á éà�4é i â á � à  å â�ØAûfØ+Ù��bü l2á é�â � Å� � ï ëí-à����å I���³ æ��Y¶caH·�º&��[ ç��"è�K ¶H·�¸h�Ú�Ù�¾�óWóUØ+ÛÞÜ�×�¾rÚ8ûõpø+ùQõp×PÚ:×PÜ�Ú2ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù�� � é�¯ ´½ W ÅYX ¯ ) ç ,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ù�×�ÜbÚ,þ�ù�ÙböNÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�¯ ) ç õÙbö�×�ÜbÚ̾�ùb×���¾�ØAÙ���ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú4¯ é ç àÌ�-¾ø+ø+¾�óUØAÙ���×�Ü�Ú�ö�Ú�ôPØAûpõp×PØ+¾�Ù úž�ô×PÜ�Úb,þ�ù�Ùbö9pZ,þ�ù�Ù�ö�ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û�üQó�Ú�õÛÞÛPù�÷#Ú:×PÜQõp×|éÚ7WéUê_à:¯¤¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ô�ü�×PÜ�Ú�Ù¨ü�ÛÞ¾�÷�ÚÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿÌé J � Ð é�ê���é Ñ àSh�Ú:ß!õÙ�×PÜ�Ú�Ù�óUôÞØA×PÚ

f á#M �?é�â�� f á#M �?é�ê`â 7  w v oooooo v�� á éé�é�ê�â8à��Ü�Ú�Ù6ó¤Ú�ØAÙ`×�Ú��ô�õp×PÚXúÅôP¾÷ M o á é J â�×P¾ M��/á é J âBü_óUÜ�Ú�ôPÚ M��vá é J â�÷�õ�ÿdûÚ�ôÞÿ�ó¤Ú�ø+ø

 N Â

Page 208: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

,ÃÚ R ØCú�é J t ½ É à[��Ü�ÚÄÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß!õpø¨ß�¾ù�ý�ø+ØAÙ��2Ø+Û(×PÜ�Ú�Ù¨ü� é�¯ ´½ W ÅYX ¯ ) ç � m �&á*" ê�âå(' ¸¹ � × t W v � X

×Bg W v�� X   MFi ½ W ÅYX á*M(i â oooooo á » �f

» M i » é oooooo v � â oooooo Çá A K |B~|B� oooooo � � W v o v v Xqz ëí Ø:A o K |B~|}� oooooo � � W v o v v Xqz ëí â� m �&á*" ê�âå(' ¸¹ � � W v � X

É   b ½ W ÅYX á b��?é J â á A K W v o v v X � z ëí ØsA o K W v o v v X � z ëí â� m �&á*" ê�âå(' ¸¹ � � W v � Xo � W v�� X   b ½ W ÅYX á b��?é J âhA o K W v o v v X � z ëí� m �&á*" ê�âå(' ¸¹��½ W ÅYX� g � vî ���� á é J â á � à  ¿ â

óUÜbÚ�ôPÚ �½ W ÅYX� á é�âX­�� � W v Xo � W v X   b ½ W ÅYX á b��?é�âhA o � ï K � � à���Üzù�Û�ü�ó�ÚdÜQõ!û�Ú#ö�Ú�ûÚ�ø+¾ý�Ú�ö�õÙ]Ú�aVpýbôPÚ�ÛÞÛPØA¾�ÙSúž�ô�×PÜ�Ú�,�¾ù�Ù�ö9p�úÅôPÚ�Ú�ß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù���Ø+Ù�×PÚ�ôÞ÷�Û�¾pú�×PÜ�Ú��Q¾�ù�ôÞØ+Ú�ô�ß�¾fÚ��#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×PÛ2¾ú½LW ÅYX ØAÙ6×�Ü�Ú²Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿVp�×�ØA÷�Úu,QõpÛPØ+Û�à����° � ¶cK ³uè�ºg¼:¸b·TIp³Vµ��[µh�Úv×�Ú�ÛÞ×�Ú�ö�¾�ùbô�ß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù��(úž�ôP÷�ùbøþõ(Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôPØAß!õøAøAÿ�úž�ô&×�ÜbÚ Ä Ú�ôÞ¾×�Ü9p%¾�ôPöbÚ�ô�/|õp÷�ØAøA×�¾Ù�ØþõÙ¨üµ É á#M �ONÃâ � N �å ¦ Øs� á  ��A oVU × â�� á � à Â Ê âùbÛPØ+Ù�� ½ W ÅYX á#M â � A o�  × î à µ É ÜQõpÛ�õ Ä Ú�ôP¾×PÜ9p¡¾�ôÞö�Ú�ô²ÜQõpôP÷#¾�Ù�Ø+ß�úÅôÞÚ�Gzù�Ú�Ù�ß�ÿc¡ É ��ØCû�Ú�Ù,`ÿ Å� ¦¢¡ �É � �¤£ � àÝh�Ú�×P¾_¾���¦ �  $ ¡ ü¥¡ É �  $ ¡ ü¦� �  ¡ $ ¡ õÙbö ¸¹ �  $ ¡ à��ÜbØ+Û>/Xõ÷�ØAøA×P¾�Ù�ØþõpÙ]ÛPù�ý�ýþ�ôF×�Û å ¡ ,þ�ù�ÙböSÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�üvóUØA×PÜSÚ�Ù�Ú�ô���ØAÚ�Û��ØAû�Ú�ÙR,`ÿ�ümé�ê �á*) Ø Å� â ¸¹ ¡ É á  � W ê � zî X ëí�§F¨© � âBü�óUÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ )m��¡ �  � å �&$&$&$f� ÂªÈ à

 N å

Page 209: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��Ø���ù�ôÞÚ�Û � à  p Ê ý�øA¾×�×�ÜbÚmß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Û­,�Ú8סó¤Ú�Ú�Ù2õøAø×�ÜbÚ,þ�ù�Ùbö9p¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û ×�¾U×�Ü�Ú�¾�ùb×���¾�pØAÙ���ÛF×?õp×PÚXóUØC×�ÜrÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿré � Â� $ ¡ üfúž�ôª+ ��¡ $ ¡  ü ¡ $  ü  $ ¡ ü�õÙ�ö  ¡ $ ¡ ü_ôÞÚ�ÛÞý�Ú�ß�×�ØCû�Ú�øAÿ�à��ÜbôPÚ�Úxûpõø+ùbÚ�Û2¾ú|é J ó¤Ú�ôPÚ�ù�ÛPÚ�ö.«Ìé J � éUê_üm×PÜ�ÚxÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿS¾úX×PÜ�ÚU,�¾ù�Ù�ö9p%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Úüé J � é#üb×�ÜbÚ�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�¾ú ×�Ü�Ú�¾ùb×(��¾Ø+Ù��:ÛÞ×?õ[×�Úü�õÙ�ö�é J � v v � v� üb×PÜ�Ú�Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿ6÷�ØAö9pó¤õ!ÿk,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ùr×�Ü�Ú�סó¤¾�ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û�à[�%×(ÛÞÜ�¾�ù�øAök,ÃÚXÙ�¾p×�Ú�ö�×�Ü�Ú�×�Ü�Ú|õ�,�ÛP¾ø+ùb×PÚ�ûpõøAù�ÚU¾ú&×�ÜbÚß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���Ø+Û0,�Ú�Ø+Ù���ý�ø+¾×Þ×�Ú�ö&ü�úž�ô²×¡ó¤¾]ôÞÚ!õÛÞ¾�Ù�Û�à=��Ø+ôÞÛÞ×!ü�×�Ü�ØAÛ�õ!û�¾Ø+ö�Û2õpÙzÿ�õ÷�,bØ1��ù�جp×PØ+Ú�Û¤õÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�Ú�ö�óUØA×PÜ�ö�ØD?¨Ú�ôPÚ�Ùbß�Ú�Û¤Ø+Ùdó(õ!û�Ú8úÅù�Ù�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù6ÛPØ1�Ù&à�Ã_Ú�ß�¾�Ù�ö¨üb×�Ü�Ú<,�¾ù�Ù�ö9p�úÅôPÚ�ÚöbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØAûÚ�öbÿfÙQõ÷#Ø+ß�Û�Ø+Û���Ú�Ù�Ú�ôPõø+øCÿ6õ"�QÚ�ôP÷#Ø®­�¾�ø+ö�Ú�ÙlUù�øAÚ á �®­�lXâ(ö�Ú�ß�õ!ÿ�¾ùb×�¾úõH,þ�ù�Ù�ö4ÛF×?õp×PÚ6Ø+Ù`×�¾�õ]÷�õÙ�ØAúžø+ö�¾pú|¾�ù_×(��¾�ØAÙ���ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û2óUØA×PÜ�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ ß�ø+¾�ÛÞÚr×�¾�×�ÜbÚ,þ�ù�Ùbö9p¡ÛF×?õp×PÚrÚ�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿàH��Üzù�Û�üv×�ÜbÚrôPÚ�ø+Ú�ûpõÙ`×2ý�õô�õ÷#Ú�×PÚ�ô:Ø+Û:×PÜ�Ú6õ�,bÛP¾�øAùb×�Ú#ûõpø+ù�Ú�¾ú×PÜ�Ú²ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ��2Û�GzùQõôÞÚ�ö&ü-ÛÞ¾#×PÜ�Ú²ÛPØ1�Ù�õpÙ�öÌõpÙzÿrý�ÜQõÛÞÚ²ú·õpß�×�¾ôPÛ�õôPÚ²ù�ÙbØ+÷#ý�¾�ôF×?õÙ`×�àh�Ú�÷�õ�ÿ#Ù�¾p×�ÚXúžô¤õøAøQúž�ù�ô6�ô�õý�ÜbÛ�ü_×PÜQõp×�übõÛm×�Ü�ÚSGfù�õÙ`×�ù�÷�Ùzù�÷�,ÃÚ�ô(ØAÙ�ß�ôÞÚ!õÛÞÚ�Û�ü

×PÜ�Ú#ÛPÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØAß!õø/ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Û²õø+ø/ß�¾�Ù`û�Ú�ô���Ú�¾�Ù ×PÜ�Ú"Gfù�õÙ`×�ù�÷ ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×!ü�óUÜ�ØAß?Ü�Ø+Û�×P¾,ÃÚ²Úfa_ýÃÚ�ß�×PÚ�ö&ü�ÛPØAÙ�ß�Ú:õp×�Ü�Ø1�Ü�Ú�ô�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿx×�Ü�ÚÄÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø&õý�ý�ôÞ¾ªa_ØA÷�õp×PØ+¾�Ù¨ü�õÛUó¤Ú�ø+øõpÛr×�Ü�Ú�ø+ØAÙ�Ú!õpôPØ Ä õp×�ØA¾�ÙN¾pú:×PÜ�ÚH��Ú�ÙbÚ�ô�õ[×�Ø+Ù��4úÅùbÙ�ß�×PØ+¾�Ù

fü<,ÃÚ�ß�¾�÷#Ú]÷�¾�ôÞÚ�õß�ß�ù�ô�õ[×�Úà

��Ú�ûÚ�ôÞ×PÜ�Ú�øAÚ�ÛÞÛ�übó�ÚX÷�õ!ÿ2Ù�¾×PÚ�×PÜQõp×mß�Ú�ôÞ×�õØ+Ù#ß?Ü�¾�ØAß�Ú�Û�úž�ômé J õôPÚ:,�Ú8×P×PÚ�ô�×�ÜQõÙ#¾×PÜ�Ú�ôÞÛöbÚ�ýÃÚ�Ù�ö�ØAÙ��x¾�Ù�×�ÜbÚ#ýþ×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø�à��Q¾�ô,+ �Ú¡ $ ¡  ü&×�ÜbÚdé J � éï��ôPõý�Ü á%¯ Ã�¯é�QôPÚ�Ú%°zâØAÛ6GzùQõÙ`×PØA×?õ[×�ØAûÚ|¾�û�Ú�ô¤×�ÜbÚ�Ú�Ù`×�ØAôPÚXô�õÙ��Ú|¾ú�,þ�ù�Ù�ö�p¡ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û�à[��Ü�Ú�é J � v v � v� ��ô�õýbÜá�¯ Ã�¯ìq�ØAö�ö�øAÚ%°zâd¾�Ù�øAÿn,ÃÚ�ß�¾�÷#Ú�Û-GzùQõÙ`×PØA×?õ[×�ØAûÚ�úž�ôY,�¾ù�Ù�ö9p%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û�óUØA×�ÜEGzùQõÙ`×�ù�÷

 N ¿

Page 210: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

0.03

0.035

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

|Cou

plin

g|

Quantum Number

QuantumSC Bound

SC FreeSC Middle

��Ø1��ùbôPÚ � à  «��ùQõÙ`×Pù�÷ û�Ú�ôPÛPùbÛXÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø&ß�¾ù�ý�ø+ØAÙ���Û¤úžô;+ �@¡ $ ¡  àÙzù�÷b,�Ú�ôPÛ�õôP¾ù�Ù�ö  ¡ ¾�ôUÜ�Ø1��ÜbÚ�ô�à[��ÜbÚ:é J � é�ê>��ôPõý�Ü á%¯ Ã�¯@Ϥ¾�ù�Ùbö±°zâ�×?õ.�Ú�ÛU×�ÜbÚøA¾�Ù���Ú�ÛÞ×�×P¾",ÃÚ�ß�¾�÷#Ú�GzùQõpÙz×PØA×�õp×�ØCû�Úü�õp×Xõ2GzùQõpÙz×Pù�÷ìÙzù�÷�,ÃÚ�ôU¾ú ª� à�Q¾�ô²+ ��¡ $  ü�õpø+ø���ôPõý�Ü�ÛÄôPÚ�÷�õpØ+Ù�ú·õØAôPøAÿCGzùQõÙ`×�ØC×?õp×PØAûÚü�Úfa_ß�Ú�ýb×:úžô:é J � éUê

úžô ) � Ð ¡ � Ê Ñ àY��Ü�Ú",ÃÚ�ÛÞ× � ×ÄØAÛ²úžô:é J � v v � v� ü�óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü�Ø+Û�Ú�ÛÞÛPÚ�Ùz×PØþõøAøAÿ]ØAÙ�ö�ØAÛÞ×�ØAÙ9p�ù�Ø+ÛÞÜQõ�,�øAÚ�úÅôP¾�÷�×�Ü�Ú9GzùQõÙ`×�ùb÷ìôPÚ�ÛÞù�øA×�à5�ÛÞØ+÷#Ø+øþõpô�ýQõ[×P×�Ú�ôPÙxýÃÚ�ôPÛÞØ+ÛF×�Û�úž�ô;+ �  $ ¡ ü_×�Ü�¾�ù���Ü6×�Ü�ØAÛ(×�Ø+÷#Ú|×PÜ�Ú ¯ Ã�¯@Ϥ¾�ù�Ù�öG°

õpÙ�ö ¯ Ã�¯ �QôÞÚ�Ú%°H�ô�õý�ÜbÛd×�õ��ÚxÛÞ¾�÷�Ú8óUÜQõp×døA¾�Ù���Ú�ô�×�¾=,ÃÚ�ß�¾÷�Ú�GzùQõÙ`×PØA×?õ[×�ØAûÚr×�ÜQõpÙýbôPÚ�ûfØA¾�ù�ÛPøCÿ�à[��Ú�ûÚ�ôÞ×PÜ�Ú�øAÚ�ÛÞÛ�ü_×PÜ�Ú ¯ Ã�¯Nq�Ø+ö�ö�øAÚ%°9��ôPõý�Ü#ôPÚ�÷�õØAÙ�Û[GzùQõÙ`×�ØC×?õp×PØAû�Ú(úžô�õpø+øGzùQõpÙz×Pù�÷ìÙzù�÷�,ÃÚ�ôÞÛ�à

 N Ê

Page 211: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

0.07

0.08

0.09

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

|Cou

plin

g|

Quantum Number

QuantumSC Bound

SC FreeSC Middle

��Ø1�ù�ôPÚ � à å «��ùQõÙ`×Pù�÷³û�Ú�ôPÛÞù�Û|ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø¨ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���Û(úžô;+ ��¡ $  à��ØAÙQõøAøAÿ�üÃúž�ô²+ �  ¡ $ ¡ ü&ó¤Ú#ÛPÚ�Ú2×�ÜQõp×:õøAø�×PÜ�ôPÚ�Ú�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø4��ôPõý�Ü�Û9,ÃÚ�ß�¾�÷�Ú

GzùQõpÙz×PØA×�õp×�ØCû�Ú²õôÞ¾�ù�Ù�ö )C� Á ü�×�Üb¾�ù���Üx¾�Ù�ß�Ú�õ.�`õØ+Ù6ØC×�õý�ýÃÚ!õôÞÛ�×�ÜQõp×�×PÜ�Ú ¯ Ã�¯èq�Ø+ö9pöbø+Ú%°2��ôPõý�ÜxØ+Û�÷#¾�ôÞÚ²õß�ß�ù�ô�õp×PÚ�×�ÜQõÙx×�ÜbÚÄôÞÚ�ÛF×!à��Ü�Ú�ôPÚ�õôPÚ6ÛÞÚ�ûÚ�ô�õpø�ý�õp×P×PÚ�ôPÙbÛd×P¾�Ù�¾×�ÚxÜ�Ú�ôPÚpàn��Ø+ôÞÛÞ×d¾úXõøAø�üv¾ú�×�Ü�Ú6×PÜ�ôPÚ�Ú�ýbôPÚ2p

ÛÞß�ôÞØ+ýb×PØ+¾�Ù�Û²úž�ô²ß?Ü�¾f¾�ÛPØAÙ���é J ü�×�ÜbÚ�ß?Ü�¾Ø+ß�Ú�é J � v v � v� ó(õÛÄ×�Ü�Ú#÷#¾�ÛÞ×�õß�ß�ù�ô�õ[×�ÚüóUØC×�Ü ×�Ü�Ú#Ù�¾×�õ�,�ø+Ú#Úfa_ß�Ú�ýb×PØ+¾�Ù úž�ôk+ � ¡ $ ¡  ü úž�ô²óUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü�é J � éìó(õpÛ:×�ÜbÚ�÷#¾�ÛÞ×õpß�ß�ùbô�õp×PÚàcϤ¾×PÜ ôPÚ�ÛÞù�øA×PÛdõôPÚ�Ú!õÛFÿ�×�¾]Ú�a_ý�øþõØAÙ&àH�¡Ù���Ú�Ù�Ú�ôPõø�üvù�ÛÞØ+Ù���é J � v v � v�ÛÞÜ�¾�ù�øAö�,ÃÚ�÷#¾�ôPÚ:õß�ß�ù�ô�õ[×�Ú:×PÜQõÙ�ùbÛPØ+Ù��6é J � é�ê�¾ô|é#ü�,ÃÚ�ß!õpù�ÛPÚ�×PÜ�Ú�Ú�a_ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÛPØA¾�Ùf á*M �?é�â*� f á#M �?éUêâ �  w v á#M �?é J â á ép�Ìé�ê�â�ØAÛ¤õß�ß�ù�ôPõp×�ÚU×�¾Ä×�Ü�ØAôPö9p%¾�ôPöbÚ�ô�Ø+Ù�éE��éUê

 N Á

Page 212: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

0.07

0.08

0.09

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

|Cou

plin

g|

Quantum Number

QuantumSC Bound

SC FreeSC Middle

��Ø1�ù�ôPÚ � à ¿ «��ùQõÙ`×Pù�÷³û�Ú�ôPÛÞù�Û|ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø¨ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���Û(úžô;+ �  $ ¡ àúžôvé J � v v � v� ü3,�ù_×�¾�Ù�øAÿ:õß�ß�ù�ôPõp×�Ú(×P¾�ÛPÚ�ß�¾�Ù�ö�p¡¾�ôÞö�Ú�ôvØAÙ2éc�#é�ê�úž�ôvé J � é�êe�?é�à�¡Ùr×PÜ�Ú|ß�õÛPÚ�¾pú®+ ��¡ $ ¡  üfÜ�¾�ó¤Ú8û�Ú�ô�ü�×�Ü�Ú|ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õøÃØ+ÛmÛPùG�#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×�øCÿ�ÛÞý�ôPÚ�õöx¾�ùb×�×�ÜQõp×ùbÛPØ+Ù��6é J � é�ê�� v � v v� ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Û|ØAÙ�Ø+Ù`×PÚ���ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù�¾�ûÚ�ô|×P¾_¾�ÙQõôPôÞ¾�óWõ�ô�õÙ���Ú:úž�ôU×�ÜbÚøA¾�ó¤Ú�ô<GzùQõÙ`×Pù�÷ Ùfùb÷�,�Ú�ôPÛ�×�¾rõpß�ß�ùbô�õp×PÚ�øAÿxß�õýb×Pù�ôPÚ:õø+ø&×PÜ�Ú�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��bàFϤÚ�ß!õù�ÛÞÚ:úž�ôé J � éä×�Ü�ÚxØAÙz×PÚ���ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù ô�õpÙ���Ú6Ø+Û2ØAÙ � Ù�ØC×�ÚpümØC×2ß!õpýb×�ù�ôÞÚ�Û2×�ÜbÚxóUÜb¾�ø+Ú6ýþ×�Ú�Ù`×�Øþõpø�üøAÚ!õöbØ+Ù���×P¾�õ2÷#¾�ôPÚ²õpß�ß�ùbô�õp×PÚ:Ú�abýbôPÚ�ÛÞÛPØA¾�Ù�úžô(×�Ü�Ú²ß�¾ù�ý�ø+ØAÙ���à��ØAÙQõøAøAÿ�ü�óUÜbØ+ø+ÚÄ×�Ü�Ú:ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��"��ô�õpý�Ü�Û|úž�ô³+ ��¡ $ ¡  � ¡ $  �  $ ¡ ,ÃÚ2p

ß�¾�÷#Ú�Ú�ÛÞÛPÚ�Ùz×PØþõøAøAÿ Ø+Ùbö�Ø+ÛF×�Ø+Ù���ù�Ø+ÛÞÜQõ�,�øAÚ2úÅôP¾�÷ ×�ÜbÚkGzùQõÙ`×�ùb÷ ôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Û�úžô:×�ÜbÚ�Ü�Ø���Ü�Ú�ôGzùQõpÙz×Pù�÷ Ùfùb÷�,�Ú�ôPÛ�ü&õ�ÛÞ÷�õpø+ø ö�Ø+ÛÞß�ôÞÚ�ýQõÙbß�ÿ�ý�Ú�ôPÛPØAÛÞ×PÛXúž�ô³+ �  ¡ $ ¡ õøAø&×�Ü�Ú�ó¤õ!ÿ�ù�ý

 N �

Page 213: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

|Cou

plin

g|

Quantum Number

QuantumSC Bound

SC FreeSC Middle

��Ø1��ùbôPÚ � à Ê «��ùQõÙ`×Pù�÷ û�Ú�ôPÛPùbÛXÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø&ß�¾ù�ý�ø+ØAÙ���Û¤úžô;+ �  ¡ $ ¡ à×P¾ )C� ÂgÈ à���Ü�ÚXôPÚ!õpÛP¾�Ù�úžô�×PÜ�Ø+ÛmØ+Û�×�Ü�õp×�×PÜ�Ú�ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õøÃõp×�×�Ü�ØAÛ�ýþ�ØAÙz×mØAÛ�ÛÞ¾�ÙQõôÞôP¾�ó×PÜQõp× ×�ÜbÚ�Úf?¨Ú�ß�×�ØCû�Ú�Ø+Ù`×�Ú���ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù²ôPõÙ���Úvúž�ô�×�ÜbÚ�ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù���Ø+Û�ú·õØAôPøAÿ|ÙQõôÞôP¾�ó²à4/�¾�ó¤Ú8û�Ú�ô�üÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õø/õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü�Ú�Û�õôPÚ2Ú�a_ý�Ú�ß�×�Ú�ö�×�¾m,ÃÚ�õpß�ß�ùbô�õp×PÚ#ØAÙ�ôPÚ��Ø+÷#Ú�Û�óUÜ�Ú�ôPÚ ¸¹ Ø+ÛÛÞ÷�õpø+ø�üz¾�ô¤Ú�Gzù�ØAûpõøAÚ�Ù`×�øCÿ�üfóUÜ�Ú�Ùx×�Ü�Ú�ß?Ü�õô�õß8×�Ú�ôPØ+ÛF×�ØAß|ó(õ!ûÚ�ø+Ú�Ù��×PÜ�ØAÛ(ÛPÜb¾�ôÞ×Uß�¾�÷�ý�õôPÚ�ö×P¾|×�ÜbÚ¤ø+Ú�Ù��×PÜ�ÛPß�õø+Ú�Û/¾úQ×�ÜbÚ¤ý�ôÞ¾3,�ø+Ú�÷�às�¡Ù�×PÜ�Ø+Û�ß!õÛÞÚü�×�ÜbÚ(ý�¾p×�Ú�Ù`×PØþõøzØ+Û�ÛP¾�ÛÞÜQõôÞý�×�ÜQõp××PÜ�Ú#Ú�?�Ú�ß�×PØAûÚ�ô�õpÙ���Ú#¾ú(×�ÜbÚ�ýþ×�Ú�Ù`×�ØþõpømØAÛ²¾�Ù�×PÜ�Ú�¾�ôÞö�Ú�ôľú(õ�ó¤õ�ûÚ�øAÚ�Ù��×PÜ ¾�ô²ø+Ú�ÛPÛ�üøAÚ!õöbØ+Ù��|×P¾�¾3,�ÛÞÚ�ôÞûpõ�,bø+Ú á ×PÜ�¾�ù��Ü2ÛP÷�õø+øþâ�ö�ØAÛPß�ôÞÚ�ýQõpÙ�ß�ØAÚ�Û[,ÃÚ�סó�Ú�Ú�Ù#×�Ü�Ú GzùQõpÙz×Pù�÷ õÙböÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õø¨ôÞÚ�ÛÞù�øA×�à

 N3P

Page 214: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

����� ´µacaH·�ºg¼:¸²�[º%�¶� �·� ¹»ºgµ�µ��U¼<º�¸²�[º%�¶� ¸ è\�U¼�³uµ�µ4³VµhÊÜbØ+ø+Ú�×�Ü�Ú[,þ�ù�Ù�ö�p%úÅôPÚ�ÚvÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õøRúž�ôÞ÷�ù�øþõmó(õÛ ö�Ú8û�Ú�ø+¾�ýÃÚ�ö�úž�ô&¾Ù�Ú2p%ö�Ø+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�õøÛFÿfÛÞ×�Ú�÷�Û�ü�×�Ü�Ú>��Ú�Ù�Ú�ôPõø+Ø Ä õp×PØ+¾�Ù�×�¾6ÛÞÚ�ýQõôPõ�,�øAÚ�ÛÞÿfÛÞ×PÚ�÷#Û²Ø+Û�ØA÷�÷#Ú�ö�Ø+õp×�Úpà9Ã_ýÃÚ�ß�Ø � ß�õø+øCÿ�ü�ØAû�Ú�ÙÌõ7�ìö�Ú���ôPÚ�Ú2p¡¾pú p%úÅôPÚ�Ú�ö�¾÷ /|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�ÙbØþõÙ&ü

µ É á#M Å �%$&$&$�� M � �ON Å �&$&$&$f�ON � â � �@ K¬¹ Å á N �Kå ¦ K Ø ½ K á#M K âPâ á � à  Á âóUÜbØ+ß?ܲý�ôP¾fö�ù�ß�Ú�Û�õÙ²Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿVp�×�ØA÷�Ú/ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù²¾úfý�Ü�õÛPÚnp¡ÛPý�õß�Ú��ØAûÚ�Ù9,`ÿ á b Å �&$&$&$��b � �?é Å �%$&$&$f�?é � â8ü|×PÜ�Ú�Ù@��ØAûÚ�ÙÝÛP¾�÷#Ú�ý�¾p×�Ú�Ù`×PØþõø ½LW ÅYX á#M Å �&$&$&$�� M � âró�Ú ¾3,b×?õpØ+ÙÈ×�ÜbÚÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õø¨ôÞÚ�ÛÞù�øA×�ü� é Å �&$&$&$Pé � ¯ ´½ W ÅYX ¯ ) Å �&$%$&$�� ) � ç � á åF' ¸¹ â o�º î j » �K¬¹ Å �¨á#" ê%¼�â �½ W ÅYX½ g ½F¾î ���� á#¿,6 â á � à ª� â

óUÜbÚ�ôPÚ ¿ ­ á é Å �&$&$&$��?é � â8ü ¿ 8 ­ á éUê z �&$&$%$��?é�ê º âBüQõÙ�ö ¿,6 ­ á é J z �&$&$&$f�?é J º âBà�Q¾�ôXÙ�¾�Ù9p%ÛPÚ�ý�õô�õ�,bø+Ú�ÛFÿfÛÞ×�Ú�÷�Û�ü&×�Ü�Ú:úž�ôP÷�ùbøþõdØ+Û|ØAÙ�ý�ôÞØ+Ù�ß�Ø+ý�øAÚ²×PÜ�Ú�ÛPõ÷�Úpü&õÛ|ø+¾�Ù��

õpÛ�ØA×XØ+ÛXý�¾�ÛÞÛPØ�,�ø+ÚÄ×�¾ � Ùbö]õrß!õÙb¾�Ù�Ø+ß�õø�ôPÚ�ýbôPÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õ[×�Ø+¾Ù]¾úv×�Ü�Ú:ý�ÜQõÛÞÚ2ÛPýQõpß�Ú�óUÜ�ØAß?Üß�õÙ�,ÃÚ�ù�ÛPÚ�öx×P¾�ß�¾Ù�ÛÞ×PôPù�ß8×�×PÜ�Ú�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø&,�õÛPØAÛ¤úÅù�Ù�ß8×�Ø+¾Ù�Û(Ø+Ùk,�¾×PÜr×�Ü�Úu,þ�ù�ÙböõpÙ�ö�ùbÙx,þ�ù�Ùbö�ôÞÚ���ØA÷�Ú�Û�à+�ù�ô�¾�Ù�Únp¡ö�ØA÷�Ú�Ù�ÛPØA¾�ÙQõø`ß�¾�ù�ý�øAØ+Ù��Uúž�ôP÷�ù�øþõbü[õÛ óUôPØC×P×PÚ�Ù&üpö�¾_Ú�Û�Ùb¾×�Ú�a_ý�ø+ØAß�ØA×PøAÿu�ØAû�Ú

×PÜ�Ú�,�¾�ùbÙ�ö9p%úÅôÞÚ�ÚÄß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ��2úž�ô�õ#ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØAû�Ú²ý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛÞÛ�ü*,�Ú�ß!õù�ÛÞÚ:×PÜ�ÚÄúžôP÷�ù�ø+õ2ß�¾�ù9pýbø+Ú�Û:סó¤¾]ÛF×?õp×PÚ�Û�¾ú�ö�ØD?¨Ú�ôPØAÙ��ÌÚ�Ù�Ú�ô���Ø+Ú�Û�àH5|Û�÷�Ú�Ùz×PØ+¾�ÙbÚ�öSý�ôÞÚ�ûfØ+¾ù�ÛPøCÿ�üvö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú

 N�N

Page 215: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ýbôP¾fß�Ú�ÛÞÛPÚ�ۤסÿfý�Ø+ß�õø+øCÿ�Ø+Ù`û¾�øAûÚ|õ��QÚ�ôP÷#ØÀ­�¾�ø+ö�Ú�ÙklUù�øAÚ�öbÚ�ß!õ!ÿdúÅôP¾÷ õ�,þ�ù�Ùbö9p¡ÛF×?õp×PÚ�×P¾õpÙrù�Ù¦,�¾ù�Ù�ö9p%ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�¾ú Ú�GzùQõø¨Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ�à�/�¾�ó¤Ú8û�Ú�ô�ü�×�¾�ØAø+øAù�ÛÞ×Pô�õp×PÚ�Üb¾RóÊ×PÜ�Ú�ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�ø+õÛPÛÞØqpß�õø�,þ�ù�Ùbö9p%úÅôÞÚ�Ú|úž�ôÞ÷�ù�ø+õ:÷�õ�ÿY,ÃÚ�õý�ý�øAØ+Ú�ö�×�¾�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù¨üfß�¾�Ù�ÛÞØ+ö�Ú�ô(×�Ü�Ú�ÛÞØ+÷#ý�ø+Ú�ÛÞ×ß�õÛPÚU¾ú�õ|סó�¾�p¡öbØ+÷#Ú�Ù�ÛÞØ+¾�ÙQõpøbö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØCû�Ú(ýbôP¾fß�Ú�ÛÞÛvúÅôP¾�÷WÛP¾�÷#Ú ,þ�ù�Ù�ödÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�¯ Á ç ¯ é�ê ç×P¾ÌõpÙ�ù�Ù¦,þ�ù�Ù�ö�ÛÞ×�õp×�Ú]¯ Á2� Â ç ¯ é ç à2��Ü�Ø+Û²ý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛPÛÄß�¾ôPôPÚ�ÛPýþ�Ù�ö�ÛÄ×�¾�õrû_Ø�,�ô�õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõøýbôPÚ�öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ý�ôP¾fß�Ú�ÛPÛ�ü&óUÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ#¾Ù�Ú�GzùQõÙ`×�ùb÷ä¾ú�ûfØ1,�ôPõp×�ØA¾�Ù á ×�Ü�Úk°yÁV°rÛÞ×�õp×�Ú�Û?â|Ø+Û×Pô�õÙbÛÞúÅÚ�ôÞôPÚ�öÈ×�¾ õ�×�ô�õpÙ�ÛPø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø�ö�Ú���ôPÚ�Ú�¾ú�úÅôÞÚ�Ú�öb¾�÷�ü(óUØC×�ÜÈÛÞùG�#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×6Ú�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿ�×P¾ß�õù�ÛÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù&àß�%ú|ó�Ú�õÛPÛÞù�÷�Úx×�Ü�õp×2,�¾ù�Ù�ö�ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�ÛdÜQõ!ûÚ�×PÜ�Úm�8ê�ê���Ù�¾�ôÞ÷�õpøqpØ Ä õp×PØ+¾�Ù¨ü¤õÙböNù�Ù¦,þ�ù�Ù�ö�ÛÞ×?õ[×�Ú�Û�ÜQõ!û�Ú�×�Ü�ÚC� á é ��é i â�Ù�¾ôP÷�õø+Ø Ä õp×PØ+¾�Ù&ü/×PÜ�Ú�ÙNØAú ½öbÚ�Ù�¾×PÚ�Û²×�Ü�ÚdýÃÚ�ôF×�ù�ô�,Qõp×�ØA¾�Ù]ø+Ú�õö�ØAÙ��r×�¾xö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù&ü¨×PÜ�Ú�Ù�×�ÜbÚ#öbØ+ÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØAûÚ2ß�¾�ù9pýbø+Ø+Ù��2Ø+Û ��ØCû�Ú�Ù�ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß!õpø+øAÿ2,`ÿü

� Á0�  �?é�¯ ´½ ¯ Á8�?éUê ç � m �¨á#" ê�âå(' ¸¹ �½ W oÆÅ # � g � vî ���� X á å(' ¸¹ Á*��é J â á � à  P�â/�Ú�ôÞÚ �½ ö�Ú�Ù�¾p×�Ú�Û�×�Ü�Ú§�Q¾�ù�ôÞØ+Ú�ô�Ú�a_ýQõÙ�ÛÞØ+¾�Ù�¾pú ½ ü[óUÜ�Ú�ôÞÚ�×PÜ�ÚmûfØ�,�ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù�õø�ß�¾f¾�ôÞö�Ø+ÙQõ[×�Ú�ÛõpôPÚ Úfa_ýQõÙ�öbÚ�ö®ØAÙèõß8×�ØA¾�Ù9p�õpÙ���ø+Ú�ûpõôÞØþõ�,bø+Ú�Û�ü�õÙbö�×�ÜbÚ ×Pô�õÙ�ÛÞøþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�õø�ß�¾f¾�ôÞö�Ø+ÙQõ[×�Ú�ÛõpôPÚ6Úfa_ýQõpÙ�ö�Ú�öNØ+Ù4õÙ�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ{p�×�Ø+÷#ÚrôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛPÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù&à �&á*" ê`â�ö�Ú�Ù�¾p×�Ú�Ûd×�ÜbÚ Ä Ú�ôÞ¾×�Ü9p¾ôPö�Ú�ô úÅôÞÚ�Gzù�Ú�Ù�ß�ÿ²úž�ô&×PÜ�Úv×�ô�õpÙ�ÛPø+õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõøp÷�¾×PØ+¾�Ù|Ø+Ù�×�Ü�Ú�,þ�ù�Ù�ö�p¡ÛÞ×�õp×�ÚvóUØC×�Ü9GzùQõÙ`×�ù�÷Ùzù�÷b,�Ú�ô ) à��Ü�ÚXסÿ_ýÃÚ�¾ú�ûfØ�,�ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù�õøQý�ôPÚ�ö�Ø+ÛÞÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù�ý�ôÞ¾_ß�Ú�ÛÞÛ(ö�Ú�ÛÞß�ôÞØ1,ÃÚ�öxõ�,þ�û�Ú�ØAÛ§�zÙ�¾�óUÙ

 N È

Page 216: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

õpÛ ¯ �Âp%ÛPÜQõpý�Ú�ö±°�ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù&üpõÛ�ØA×�ö�¾_Ú�Û�Ùb¾×/ØAÙ�ß�øAù�ö�Ú�ôP¾×�õp×�ØA¾�ÙQõø`Úf?¨Ú�ß�×PÛ�à���Üzù�Û�üóUÜ�õp×vó¤ÚUÜQõ!ûÚ�ýbôPÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×�Ú�ö�ØAÛ�õ�ÛPØA÷�ý�øAØ � ß�õp×�ØA¾�Ùľú-×�Ü�Ú(×PôPù�Ú�ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ö_ÿ_Ù�õ÷7pØAß�Û�à[�XÚ8û�Ú�ôF×�Ü�Ú�ø+Ú�ÛPÛ�ü�×PÜ�Ú|ýbù�ôPýþ�ÛPÚ|Ø+Û�×�¾���ØCû�ÚXõ�ß�¾Ù�ß�ôÞÚ�×�Ú|Úfabõ÷#ý�ø+Úpü_ØAø+ø+ùbÛÞ×�ôPõp×�ØAÙ���Ü�¾�ó×PÜ�Ú�,�¾�ùbÙ�ö9p%úÅôÞÚ�ÚÄÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø¨ß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù��dúžôP÷�ù�ø+õ2÷�õ!ÿU,ÃÚ:õpý�ý�ø+ØAÚ�öx×�¾�õß�×PùQõø ÛÞÿfÛ�p×PÚ�÷#Û�à���2à æ��¶�H¼:·g¶Hµ�º%�¶�Hµ��ÜbØ+Û�ß?Ü�õýb×�Ú�ô�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×�Ú�ö�õ�ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø�õpý�ý�ôP¾�õß?Ü�úž�ôÄß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×PØ+Ù��x×�ÜbÚk,þ�ù�Ù�ö9púÅôÞÚ�Ú�ß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù���Û�úžô�¾�Ù�Únp¡ö�ØA÷�Ú�Ù�ÛPØA¾�ÙQõø`ÛFÿfÛÞ×�Ú�÷�ÛvùbÛPØ+Ù��|ß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß�õø��Q¾�ùbôPØ+Ú�ô�ß�¾_Ú2�#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×�Û�à��ÜbÚrôPÚ�ÛPù�øC×�Ø+Û�õ�ýQõpôÞ×�Ø+õø���Ú�ÙbÚ�ô�õpø+Ø Ä õp×�ØA¾�Ù ¾ú�×�Ü�Ú#úž�ôP÷�ù�øþõ6úž�ôb,þ�ù�Ùbö9pZ,þ�ù�Ù�ö�ß�¾�ù9pýbø+Ø+Ù���Û�à���ÜbÚ0�pÚ�ÿxö�ØD?¨Ú�ôPÚ�Ùbß�ÚÄØ+Û(×�Ü�õp×�óUÜ�Ø+øAÚ�×�Ü�Ú9,þ�ù�Ù�ö�pZ,þ�ù�Ù�ö�ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û�õôÞÚ9��Ú�Ù9pÚ�ô�õøAøAÿE��ØAûÚ�Ù�õÛm�Q¾�ù�ôPØAÚ�ôrß�¾_Ú2�#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×�ÛxúÅôP¾�÷ õÙèõpß�×�ØA¾�Ù9p¡õÙ���øAÚÌôPÚ�ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÚ�Ùz×�õp×�ØA¾�Ùݾú×PÜ�ÚY/|õ÷#Ø+øC×�¾�Ù�Ø+õÙ&ü�Ø+Ù�×�Ü�Ú2,þ�ù�Ù�ö9p�úÅôPÚ�Ú�ß�õÛPÚd×�Ü�ÚY�Q¾�ù�ôÞØ+Ú�ô�ß�¾_Ú2�#ß�Ø+Ú�Ù`×�Û�ß�¾�÷#ÚdúÅôÞ¾�÷õpÙ�Ú�Ù�Ú�ô��ÿ{p�×�Ø+÷#Ú�ôÞÚ�ý�ôÞÚ�ÛÞÚ�Ù`×?õp×PØ+¾�Ù�¾úv×PÜ�Ú>/Xõ÷�ØAøA×P¾�Ù�ØþõpÙ&à<Ã_ù�ß?Ü õ�ôPÚ�ý�ôPÚ�ÛPÚ�Ùz×�õp×�ØA¾�Ù]Ø+ÛûpõøAØ+ö�Ø+Ù-,þ×�Ür×PÜ�Úu,þ�ù�Ù�öxõÙbö6ù�Ù¦,�¾�ùbÙ�öxôPÚ��Ø+÷#Ú�Û�üf×�Ü�¾ù���Ür×�ÜbÚ�ô�õÙ���Ú�¾ú ×�ÜbÚ|×�ØA÷�ÚûpõôÞØþõ�,bø+Ú�Ø+ÛmÚ�ÙbÚ�ô��pÿVp%ö�Ú�ýÃÚ�Ùbö�Ú�Ù`× á Ø+Ù#ß�¾�Ù`×�ôPõÛÞ×�×�¾�õß�×PØ+¾�Ù9p¡õÙ���øAÚ¤ûpõôPØ+õ�,�øAÚ�Û�ü`úž�ôvóUÜ�ØAß?Ü×PÜ�Ú#ô�õÙ��Ú#¾pú¤×�ÜbÚ�õÙ���ø+Ú�ûpõôÞØþõ�,�øAÚ2Ø+ÛÄõÙ Ø+Ù`×�Ú�ôÞûpõø�¾ú�ø+Ú�Ù��×�Ü Â âBà-�Xùb÷�Ú�ôPØ+ß�õø/×�Ú�ÛÞ×PÛúžô�ÛPÚ�ûÚ�ôPõø ý�¾×PÚ�Ù`×�Ø+õø+Û�ß�¾�Ù � ôÞ÷�Ú�ö6×�Ü�Ú²ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�ø+õÛPÛÞØ+ß!õpø¨úž�ôP÷�ù�øþõbà

ÂªÈ ¡

Page 217: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

��Ü�Ú2,þ�ù�Ù�ö�p%úÅôPÚ�Ú2ÛPÚ�÷�ØAß�øþõpÛPÛPØAß!õø�ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���úž�ôÞ÷�ù�øþõ�ß�¾�ù�øAö]ý�ôP¾�ûÚ#ùbÛPÚ�úÅùbøvØ+Ù�õÙ9põpøAÿ Ä ØAÙ���ö�ØAÛPÛÞ¾_ß�Øþõp×PØ+¾�Ù�ý�ôP¾fß�Ú�ÛPÛÞÚ�Û²ÛPù�ß?Ü�õpÛ|×�Ü�Ú:û_Ø�,�ô�õ[×�Ø+¾ÙQõø�ý�ôÞÚ�ö�ØAÛPÛP¾fß�Ø+õp×�ØA¾�Ù̾púvûõpÙöbÚ�ô6h�õ�õøAÛ¤ß�¾÷�ý�øAÚfa_Ú�Û�à�ϤÚ�ß�õù�ÛÞÚ�×�Ü�Ú�ÛÞÚ�÷#Ø+ß�øþõÛÞÛPØ+ß�õøÃß�¾�ù�ýbø+Ø+Ù���Û¤õpôPÚ�¾3,_×?õØAÙ�Ú�ö�úÅôÞ¾�÷�Q¾�ùbôPØ+Ú�ô�ß�¾fÚ��#ß�ØAÚ�Ù`×�Ûľú¤õ�ß�øþõÛÞÛPØAß!õø�/Xõ÷�ØAøA×P¾�Ù�ØþõpÙ&üÃ×PÜ�Ú�ÿ õpôPÚdØ+Ùc��Ú�ÙbÚ�ô�õpøvÚ!õÛÞØ+Ú�ô�×P¾ß�¾�÷#ý�ùb×�Úx×�Ü�õÙ�×PÜ�ÚCGzùQõpÙz×Pù�÷ ß�¾�ùbý�ø+ØAÙ���Û�ümóUÜ�Ø+ß?Ü�ó¤¾�ùbø+öNôÞÚ�Gzù�ØAôPÚx×�Ü�Ú�Ùzù�÷�Ú�ôPØAß!õøØAÙ`×�Ú��ô�õp×PØ+¾�Ù6¾ú�ó¤õ�ûÚ�úÅù�Ùbß�×�ØA¾�Ù�Û�à

ªÈbÂ

Page 218: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ä î î òÚø þ ÷ÆÅ ÄÇ ý ö òéóp÷��@í�\ÆÈ É ðjí�Ê BòË ö î Bò ö ò ø´ðjíAð�÷Bùúø ù¬û ð�ì ò Ì õ Äò�ð�ì ù þ

´ ��� ¸ è��¶a�¸?["¸²�[º&��[ Í ÎÏ��³ Iܺ&K ³ Ð_��³,a�¡Ù4×�ÜbØ+Û2ÛPÚ�ß�×PØÒÑ�Ù&ümó¤Ú�ö�Ú�ÛPß�ôÞØ1,ÃÚxܱÑ�ó ó¤Ú�Ùzù�÷#Ú�ôPØAß!õøAøAÿ Ø+Ù`×PÚ���ôPõp×�Ú6×�ÜbÚ Â Äu® ú*Ñô7ÓÔ õ�Õ2ý�ôBÖ%Õ}Ö�×{Ø�Ö�ösÙÒ×p¯ÂÚQõpýGØ�Ö�ô¤Û�Ü?Ñy×±Ö-Ø�ÙA÷ÝÖÝÕBØ}Ö�ý4ú*ÑyÞBߤõ�ÞPö`àR�·ÙHÞ}ÕBØLÑú�õpø+ø�ü·ÙHØ=ÕBÚ±Ñ�ù�øAö,ÀÖ¤×GÑ�Ø�Ö�ö�Ø�ÚQõ�ØkÕ}ÙH×±á%֤ߪÖ6õ�ÞBÖ¤á�Ñy×±Õ}ÙAö±Ö%ÞBÙÒ×���õø+ø\Ø�Ö�ÞP÷¶ÕkÑúâØ}Ú±Ö�ú*Ñ�ÞP÷ã>�ä�å7æuÓ É�ç ߪÖè Þ}Ö;Õ}ÙHéLê±ëHØ è ×±Ö�Ñyê±Õ}ëqìkÖ2íyÑyëqí�ÙÒ×±î0ïÀÑ�Ø�Ö�×VØ}Ù è ë9Ø�Ö%ÞBéÝÕ�á�ÑyÞ}ÞBÖ%Õ}ïÀÑy×±ðGÙÒ×±î0Ø�Ñ0Þ}Ö�Õ}Ñy× è ×±á%Ö�Õ è ×Gð

ÂªÈ Û

Page 219: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ñ è ÕBØ7Ø�Ö�Þ}é¶Õ%à:òâÚ�êGÕ ç Ø}Ú±Ö%ÞBÖóÙHÕ è í è Þ}ÙHÖ�ØuìôÑ ñ Ø}ÙÒé¶Ö-Õ}á è ëÒÖ%Õ¶ÙÒ×�ÑyêGÞ¶Õhì�ÕBØ�Ö�é ç Õ}ÑõØ�Ú è ØÕhØ�Ùqö`×±Ö�Õ}Õ,÷ÀÖ%á�ÑyéÝÖ�Õ è ï±ÞBÑy÷±ëHÖ%éøà0ù!×±ÖLß è ì è Þ}ÑyêG×±ðúØ�ÚGÙÒÕ!ÙHÕ³Ø�Ñ-Ö�éÝïGëÒÑ�ì è ×cÙÒé¶ï±ëÒÙHá%ÙqØÙH×{Ø�Ö%î�Þ è Ø}ÙÒÑy×LÕBá�Ú±Ö%é¶ÖâØ�Ñ è á�ÚGÙÒÖ�í�Ö;ÕBØ è ÷±ÙÒëHÙHØuì ç ÷±êGØ\ߪÖ;Ú è íyÖ è ð±ÙHö¢Ö%ÞBÖ%×{Ø�é¶Ö�Ø�ÚGÑ9ðLß;Ú±ÙHá�ÚØ è ��Ö�Õ è ðGí è ×{Ø è îyÖ,Ñ ñ Ø�ÚGÖ ñ è á�ØâØ�Ú è Ø;Ñyê±Þ;ïÀÖ%ÞBØ}ê±Þ}÷ è Ø�ÙHÑy×-ÙÒÕ;Õ}é è ëHëOàòâÚ±Ö³ûüÞ}ÕhØBpuÑ�Þ}ð±Ö�Þ è ïGï±Þ}Ñga9ÙÒé è Ø�ÙHÑy×=Ø�Ñ?Ñyê±ÞÂÖ2íyÑyëHêGØ�ÙHÑy׶Ö%ýVê è Ø}ÙÒÑy×¶ß è ÕÂÕ}Ú±Ñ�ß;פØ}ÑL÷¢Öþ ê vþ � � � Ô 3¶ä�å¶æ�Ó É Ü � ÓLÿ ç îyÙHí�ÙH×±îkÓLÿ Ô �$�}beØ�� Ü � ÓLÿ Ô �$�}bBÜhA o W 8 C � � ê ¨ X���� à\òâÚ±Ö�Þ}Ö ñ Ñ�Þ}Ö çñ Ñ�ÞâÕ}é è ëÒë��øߪֲé è ì¤ß;ÞBÙHØ}Ö ç ÓLÿ Ô �.�}b]Ø�üÜ �

� � @<��¹� Ð Ô >�ä(å¶æQÓ 8po < Ô �$�}bBÜBÜBÓ � Ô �.�BbBÜ4�Ô}Ô 3�ô>�Ü·ä(å¶æ�Ó � Ô �$�}bBÜ}ÜhÓ 8po < Ô �.�}bBÜ Ñ ÇÔ >�ä(å¶æ�Ó É ÜhA o WHW <(C � � ê ¨ X�� � WHW 8po < X C � � ê ¨ X��uX�� Ô�� à  ÜÕBÑÝÙH×{Ø�Ö%î�Þ è Ø}ÙÒ×±î�� ñ Þ}Ñ�é ¡ Ø�Ѷ��� îyÙHí�Ö%Õ çÓLÿ Ô �$�}b�Øs���¦Ü � ÓLÿ Ô �$�}bBÜB� @<��¹� Ô Â �ôA o WqW <(C � � ê ¨ X �u� WqW 8po < X C � � ê ¨ X � X ��� Ü Ô >�ä(å¶æuÓ É ÜFÇÔ >øä(å7æuÓ 8po < Ô �.�BbBÜ}ÜBÓ � Ô �$�}bBÜ4� Ô}Ô 3�ô>�Ü·ä(å7æuÓ � Ô �$�}bBÜBÜBÓ 8po < Ô �$�}bBÜÔ >óäFå7æ�Ó É Ü � Ø ÔBÔ 3�ô>�Ü·ä(å7æ�Ó É Ü � Ô�� à ÛyÜù ñ á%Ñyê±ÞBÕ}Ö ç Ù ñ +�� Ô >óä(å7æ�Ó É Ü � Ø Ô}Ô 3��ô>�Ü�ä�å7æuÓ É Ü � ÙÒÕâØ�Ñ�ÑÝá�ëÒÑyÕBÖ,Ø�Ñ ¡ ç Ø�Ú±Ö�×óØ�ÚGÖá�Ñyé¶ï±êGØ�Ö�Þ?ß;ÙHëÒë\îyÙqíyÖ è�� Ñ è Ø}ÙÒ×±îóÖfa9á%Ö�ïGØ�ÙHÑy×�Ö�Þ}Þ}Ñ�ÞkÙ ñ ßÂÖÝØ�ÞBìõØ}Ñ�Ö�í è ëHê è Ø�Ö Å¡o Õ g�� º � ðGÙÒÞ}Ö�á�Ø}ëHìyà-h�Ö7Ø�ÚVê±ÕkÖ2í è ëÒê è Ø�Ö7Ø�Ú±ÙHÕ²Ø}Ö%Þ}é è Õ ñ ÑyëHëÒÑ�ß;Õ%«9h ÖÝð±Ö�û±×±Ö�! � +���� ç è ×Gð

ÂªÈ ¿

Page 220: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÞBÖ�ß;ÞBÙHØ�Ö¶Ñyê±Þ²Öfa9ï±ÞBÖ%ÕBÕ}ÙÒÑ�× è Õk�"� Å¡o Õ g$#% à-h Ö¶Ø�Ú±Ö�×�Ö�í è ëHê è Ø�Ö Å¡o Õ g$#% í�Ù è ÙHØ}Õ0ò è ì�ëÒÑyÞÖ�a9ï è ×±ÕBÙÒÑy× ç î�ÙHíyÖ�×ó÷{ì'& �ÿ ¹ É W o % X vW ÿ � ÅYX)( àϪì Ö+*9ï è ×±ðGÙÒ×±îôØ�ÚGÖ�Ö,*9ï¢Ñy×GÖ%×{Ø�Ù è ë,ÑyêGØ-Ø}Ñ�û±Þ}ÕBØhpuÑyÞBð±Ö%Þ ç ߪÖõÕ}Ö%ÖcØ}Ú è Ø-Ø�ÚGÙÒÕ è ï9pïGÞ}Ñ è á�Ú7ÞBÖ%ð±ê±á�Ö%Õ�Ø�Ñ!Ø}Ú±Ö;ÑyÞ}ð±ÙH× è ÞhìkÑy×GÖ2puÕhØ�Ö�ï¶Ö,*9ï±ëÒÙHá%ÙHØ[®�êGëÒÖ%Þ·éÝÖ2Ø�Ú±Ñ�ð ñ ÑyÞ�Õ}ê9�Ýá�ÙÒÖ�×VØ}ëHìÕBé è ëÒëÀ���²à.-³Ñ�ߪÖ�íyÖ�Þ ç Ø}Ú±Ö è ÷ÀÑ�íyÖ,é¶Ö�Ø�ÚGÑ9ð_ÙHÕ¥Õ}êGï¢Ö�Þ}ÙÒÑ�ÞªØ�Ñkê±Õ}ÙH×±î è ×_Ö,*GïGëÒÙÒá�ÙHØF®�êGëÒÖ%Þé¶Ö�Ø}Ú±Ñ�ð=Õ}ÙÒ×Gá%֥ߪÖdá è ×7×±Ñ�ß Ø è ��Öâë è Þ}îyÖ�Þ·Ø�ÙHéÝÖªÕBØ}Ö%ï±Õ�é¶ÑyÞ}Ö è ï±ï±Þ}Ñ�ï±Þ}Ù è Ø�ÖÂØ}Ñ,Ø�Ú±ÖâÕBëÒÑ�ßØ}Ö%ÞBéÝÕ è ÞBÙÒÕBÙÒ×±î ñ ÞBÑyé ÞBÖ%Õ}Ñ�× è ×±á�Ö%Õ ÑyÞ\×±Ö è ÞhpuÞBÖ%ÕBÑy× è ×±á�Ö%Õ�à òâÚGÖ%Õ}Ödë è Þ}îyÖ�Þ·Ø�ÙHéÝÖ¥ÕhØ�Ö�ï±ÕªðGÑ×GÑ�Ø!ëHÖ è ðøØ�Ñ_×Vê±é¶Ö%ÞBÙÒá è ë®ÙH×±ÕBØ è ÷±ÙHëÒÙHØuì ç Õ}ÙH×±á%ÖkØ}Ú±Öké¶ÑyÞBÖk×±Ñy×�puÞ}Ö�Õ}Ñy× è ×{ئØ�Ö�Þ}é¶Õ Ô á%ÑyÞBÞ}Ö2pÕBï¢Ñ�×±ð±ÙÒ×Gî7Ø}Ñ=Ø�Ú±Ö,ÕBÚ±ÑyÞBØ}Ö%ÞâØ�ÙHéÝÖ¦Õ}á è ëÒÖ%ÕâÞBÖ%ýVê±ÙHÞ}ÙÒ×Gî¶ÕBé è ëÒëÒÖ�ÞªØ}ÙÒé¶Ö!ÕBØ}Ö%ï±ÕâØ�Ñ7é è ÙÒ×{Ø è ÙÒ×ÕhØ è ÷GÙÒëÒÙqØuì�ÙH×:Ø}Ú±ÖúÖ,*GïGëÒÙÒá�ÙHØ"®\ê±ëHÖ%Þ¶Õ}á�Ú±Ö�éÝÖ&Ü è ÞBÖ è ØBØ�Ö�×VØ}ê è Ø}Ö%ð ÷{ì�Ø�Ú±ÖøÖ+*9ïÀÑy×±Ö�×VØ}Ù è ëñ è á�Ø�Ñ�Þ%à6�u× ñ è á2Ø ç Õ}ÙH×±á%Ö0ßÂÖ0ß è ×{سØ}Ñk�VÙÒëHë.Ñ�öcØ�ÚGÖ?×±Ñ�×9puÞBÖ%Õ}Ñ�× è ×{سØ}Ö%ÞBéÝÕ;ÙÒ× è ×{ì�á è Õ}Ö çØ}Ú±Ö%ÞBÖâÙÒÕ è ×=ÑyïGØ�ÙHéLê±é�Ø�ÙHéÝÖªÕBØ�Ö�ï=ß;Ú±ÙÒá�Ú2�VÙÒëHëÒÕ·Ñ�ö¤Ø�ÚGÖâ×±Ñy×9pQÞ}Ö%ÕBÑy× è ×{Ø\Ø}Ö%Þ}é¶Õ è Õ�ékê±á�Úè ÕdïÀÑyÕBÕ}ÙÒ÷GëÒÖ!ß;ÙHØ}Ú±ÑyêGØ;Õ è á%ÞBÙHûüá�ÙÒ×±î è á%á%êGÞ è á2ìyà

´ �,/ �ñ¶cK ³Vèº�¼:¸b·T¸ è\�¶a�¸k[2¸?��º%�¶� �1032

� ñ Ó ÙÒÕdîyÙHí�Ö%× è × è ëHìVØ}ÙÒá è ëÒëHì ç Ø�Ú±Ö�×úØ�ÚGÖkð±Ö�Þ}ÙHí è Ø}ÙHí�Ö%Õ¦Ñ ñ Óµá è × è ëÒÕBѤ÷ÀÖkð±Ö2Ø�Ö�Þ}é¶ÙÒ×±Ö�ðè × è ëHìVØ}ÙÒá è ëÒëHì�à¥òâÚ±Ö�Þ}Ö ñ Ñ�Þ}Ö ç ÙHسá è ×ú÷¢Ö?Õ}Ö%Ö�× ñ Þ}Ñy鬮\ýVÕ%à Ô Â à ¿�4 Ü è ×±ð Ô Â à ¿65 Ü¥Ø�Ú è ØdØ�ÚGÖ×Vê±é¶Ö%ÞBÙÒá è ë³ïGÞ}Ñyï è î è Ø�ÙHÑy× Ñ ñ f Ñ�×±ëHì:Þ}Ö�ýVê±ÙÒÞBÖ%Õ¤Ø}Ú±Ö�×Vê±é¶Ö%Þ}ÙHá è ëdÖ�í è ëHê è Ø}ÙÒÑy×:Ñ ñ Ø�ÚGÖÂªÈ Ê

Page 221: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ï è ÞBØ}Ù è ë¢ð±Ö%ÞBÙHí è Ø�ÙqíyÖ�ÕdÑ ñ f à\òâÚ±ÙHÕdÙHÕâð±Ñy×±Ö0ê±ÕBÙÒ×±î7á�Ö%×{Ø�Ö�Þ}Ö%ðúð±ÙHö¢Ö%ÞBÖ%×±á�Ö%Õ%à� ØÆØ}ÙÒé¶Ö·b �@¡ ç f ÙHÕÆÕ}ÙÒé¶ï±ëqìdØ}Ú±Ö\ÙÒðGÖ%×{Ø�ÙqØuì¦Ø�Þ è ×±Õ ñ ÑyÞ}é è Ø�ÙHÑy× ç Õ}ÑâØ�Ú è Ø f Ô�7 �98": ¡ Ü �

7 ä�8¶à�òâÚVê±Õ ç f ÙHÕ_×±Ñ�Ø-ïÀÖ%ÞBÙÒÑ�ð±ÙÒáóÙÒ× Ö è á�Ú M<; ß;ÙqØ�ÚTïÀÖ%Þ}ÙHÑ9ð>= ; à�Ä!Ö2ûü×±Öõ3@? �Ô ) Å = Å �&$%$&$�� ) � = � Ü ç è ×Gð�×±Ñ�Ø}Ö ç Ú±Ñ�ߪÖ�íyÖ�Þ ç Ø�Ú è Ø f ÔA7 Ø 3B?��98": ¡ Ü � 8�ä¢3B?@Øf Ô�7 �98": ¡ Ü2à"C Ö¶á%ë è ÙÒéÏØ�Ú è Ø?Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕ²ï±Þ}Ñ�ï¢Ö�ÞBØuìõÙÒÕ0ï±ÞBÖ%ÕBÖ%ÞBí�Ö%ð�÷{ìõØ�Ú±Ö¶Ö�í�ÑyëÒêGØ}ÙÒÑy×`à�C�ÖÕBÚ è ëHë è ÕBÕ}ê±é¶Ö?Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕ ñ ÑyÞ³ß;Ú è Ø ñ ÑyëHëÒÑ�ß;Õ ç è ×±ðóØ�Ú±Ö�×cï±Þ}Ñ�íyÖkÙHØ è ئØ}Ú±ÖLÖ%×GðcÑ ñ Ø�ÚGÙÒÕ¦ÕBÖ%ánpØ}ÙÒÑy×`à\òâÚ�êGÕ ç è ëHØ}Ú±Ñyê±îyÚ f ÙÒÕ;×±Ñ�ØdïÀÖ%Þ}ÙHÑ9ðGÙÒá!ÙH×�Ø}Ú±Ö M<;ED Õ ç ߪֲÕBØ�ÙHëÒë.×GÖ%Ö%ðóÑy×±ëqì¤Ø�Þ è á'� fñ Ñ�Þ 7 ÙH× è �¶pQð±ÙÒé¶Ö%×GÕ}ÙÒÑ�× è ëÀ÷¢ÑF*�Ñ ñ Õ}ÙHð±Ö0ëÒÖ�×±î�Ø�ÚGÕG= Å �%$&$&$��9= � àòâÚ±Ö 7 puî�Þ}ÙÒð0ÙHÕ�îyÙqíyÖ�×k÷{ì=/ Ô ) Å = Å £<HJI $&$%$ I ) � = � £�H ÜLK )�;NM�¡ I $%$&$ IOHQP  1 ç î�ÙHí�ÙÒ×±îH � îyÞ}ÙHð_ï¢Ñ�ÙÒ×{Ø�Õ�àRC Ö!Ø}Þ è á'� è ëÒë�8 Ñy× è îyÞBÙÒð_Ñ ñ á è ×±Ñy×±ÙHá è ë¢éÝÑ�éÝÖ�×VØ è=è ÷ÀÑyêGØâÕBÑyéÝÖá�Ö%×{Ø�Þ è ë,é¶ÑyéÝÖ�×{Ø�ê±é 8 É%ç ß;Ú±Ö�Þ}ÖõÑyê±Þ-î�Þ}ÙÒð á%Ñy×±ÕBÙÒÕhØ�Õ�Ñ ñ è ëÒë³á è ×GÑy×±ÙÒá è ë¦é¶Ñyé¶Ö%×{Ø è8 <SM 8 É Øc��Tc> ç ß;ÙqØ�Ú¤> M ÔAU Å I $&$&$ I U � Ü\Õ è Ø}ÙÒÕ ñ ì9ÙH×±îJK U Å K�Ø�$&$%$(ØVK U � KXWZY²� f

[ à\ Ö2Ø¥ê±Õªð±Ö%×±Ñ�Ø�Ö¦Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕªÕ}Ö�ØÂ÷{ì^] Ô 8 É I Y?� f

[ Ünà�Ã9ÙH×±á%Ö³Ñyê±ÞÂÖ2íyÑyëHêGØ�ÙHÑyפÙH×{íyÑyëqíyÖ%Õ è ûüÞBÕBØBpðGÖ%Þ}Ùqí è Ø�ÙqíyÖ²ÙÒ×'8�Ñ ñ f ç ߪÖká è ×±×±Ñ�ئá�ÑyéÝïGêGØ�Ö þ wþ � è سØ}Ú±Ök÷ÀÑyê±×±ð è ÞBì�Ñ ñ Ø�Ú±Ö_80pQîyÞ}ÙHð.àòâÚGÖÝÞBÖ%Õ}êGëHزÙÒÕ,Ø�Ú è Ø,ßÂÖ¶á è × Ñy×±ëqì�ï±ÞBÑyï è î è Ø�Ö7Ñy×�] Ô 8 É I Y²� f[ P Â Ü ç Õ}Ñ�Ø�Ú è Ø è ØÖ è á�Ú�ÙqØ�Ö%Þ è Ø�ÙHÑy×õØ�Ú±Ö¶í è ëÒê±Ö¶Ñ ñ Y²� f

[ ÕBÚ±Þ}ÙH×�`VÕk÷{ì  à�òâÚ±ÙÒÕ?á%ÑyëHë è ï±ÕBÙÒ×±î�÷ÀÑyê±×±ð è ÞBìé¶Ö�Ø}Ú±Ñ�ðóÙHÕdðGÖ%Õ}á�Þ}ÙH÷¢Ö�ð�ÙÒ× ñ ê±ÞBØ}Ú±Ö%Þdð±Ö2Ø è ÙHëÆÙÒ×JadÖ ñ àâÛ ç Õ}ÙH×±á%Ö²ÙHØ è ëHÕ}Ñ è Þ}ÙHÕ}Ö�Õd× è Ø�ê±Þ è ëÒëqìÙH×ôØ�Ú±Ö�×Vê±é¶Ö%Þ}ÙHá è ëÂÙÒé¶ï±ëÒÖ�éÝÖ�×VØ è Ø�ÙHÑy× Ñ ñ Ø}Ú±ÖøÓ Ö2íyÑyëHêGØ�ÙHÑy×.àôòâÚ±Ö è ÷±ÕBÖ%×±á�ÖóÑ ñ è ×{ì÷ÀÑyê±×Gð è ÞBì7á�Ñy×±ð±ÙqØ�ÙHÑy× ñ ÑyÞ\Ø�Ú±Öb80pQîyÞ}ÙHð7ÙÒÕ�ð±ê±Ö;Ø�Ñ0Ø�Ú±Ö ñ è á2Ø Ø}Ú è Ø Ø�Ú±Ö�Þ}Ö è Þ}ÖdÕ}ÙHéÝïGëHìL×GÑÂªÈ Á

Page 222: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ïGÚVì�ÕBÙÒá è ëÒëHìÝ× è Ø}ê±Þ è ë`÷ÀÑyê±×±ð è ÞBìÝá%Ñy×±ðGÙHØ�ÙHÑy×±Õ Ø�Ñ=ÙÒé¶ïÀÑyÕ}Ö�à�òâÚ±ÙÒÕâÙHÕÂÙH×-á%Ñy×{Ø�Þ è ÕBØÂØ�ÑLØ�ÚGÖÚGÖ è ØÂÖ%ýVê è Ø}ÙÒÑy× ç ñ ÑyÞªÖ+* è é¶ï±ëÒÖ ç ß;Ú±Ö�Þ}Ö¦ûc*GÙH×±îkØ}Ú±Ö³Ø}Ö%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ è Ø}ê±Þ}Ö è ØÂØ}Ú±Ö¦÷ÀÑyê±×±ð è ÞBì¶ÙÒÕïGÚVì�ÕBÙÒá è ëÒëHìLÞ}Ö è ëÒÙ Ä Ö%ð¶÷{ìÝÙHéÝé¶Ö%ÞBÕ}ÙH×±î!Ø�Ú±ÖdÕBì�ÕhØ�Ö%é�ÙÒ× è á%Ñy×±ÕhØ è ×{تØ�Ö%é¶ïÀÖ%Þ è Ø�ê±ÞBÖ³÷ è Ø�Ú.àù!×±á�Ö þ wþ � Ú è Õ¦÷ÀÖ%Ö�×cÖ�í è ëÒê è Ø�Ö�ð�Ñy× è ëÒë�ï¢Ñ�Õ}Õ}ÙH÷±ëÒÖ²îyÞBÙÒðúïÀÑyÙH×VØ}Õ ç Ø�Ú±Ö?ï±Þ}Ñ�ï è î è Ø}ÙÒÑy×÷{ì=ÕBÑyé¶Ö¥Ø�ÙÒé¶Ö¥ÕhØ�Ö%ïÝ��� ÙÒÕ\ð±Ñy×GÖâê±Õ}ÙH×±î,Ø�Ú±Öbde*9ï±ëÒÙHá%ÙHØfd�êGëÒÖ%Þ\é¶Ö�Ø}Ú±Ñ�ð ç ß;Ú±ÙÒá�Ú¶é¶Ö è ×±ÕØ}Ú è ØâߪÖ?ÕBÖ�Ø f ÔA7 I 8 � :}b]Øs���¦Ü M f ÔA7 I 8 � :}bBÜ­Ø:��� þ wþ � Ô�7 I 8 � :}bBÜnàg ÙH× è ëHëHì ç ÕBê±ï±ïÀÑyÕ}Ö�ᦙ è Þ}Ö�á%Ñy×GÕ}ÙÒðGÖ%Þ}ÙH×±î è Õhì�ÕBØ�Ö�é ß;ÙHØ}Úsê±×V÷ÀÑyê±×±ð:ð±Ö�îyÞ}Ö�Ö%Õ¶Ñ ññ ÞBÖ%Ö�ð±Ñyé ç Ø�Ú è Ø ÙHÕ ç Õ}Ñ�éÝÖ;Ñ ñ Ø�Ú±Öb= ;NMih à�òâÚ±Ö%׶ßÂÖ;Ø�Þ è áO`kØ�ÚGÑyÕ}Ö M<; � / M+; É eó)kj K )�M

h I $&$&$ IOH ; 1 à � Ø²Ö è á�Ú�Ø}ÙÒé¶Ö=ÕBØ�Ö�ï ç ßÂÖ¶á è ×�Ñy×±ëqì�á�ÑyéÝïGêGØ�Ö þ wþ � ê±ïõØ�Ñ )QM H ; P  çÕBÑ�Ø�Ú è Ø è ñ Ø�Ö�Þ¤Ö è á�ÚTØ�ÙÒé¶ÖøÕBØ�Ö�ïTßÂÖcÕBÚ±Þ}ÙH×�`sÑ�ê±Þ_Õ}Ö2Ø-Ñ ñ M<; ÷Vìsð±Ö�á%Þ}Ö è Õ}ÙH×±î H ; ÷{ìÑ�×±Ö�àRC Ú±ÙHëÒÖ³ÙÒפØ}Ú±ÙÒÕªá è ÕBÖ,ÙHØ¥é è ì¶÷¢Ö!ïÀÑyÕBÕ}ÙÒ÷GëÒÖ³Ø}Ñ=ÙÒé¶ï¢Ñ�Õ}Ö¦é¶ÑyÞBÖ¦× è Ø}ê±Þ è ë¢÷ÀÑyê±×±ð è ÞBìá�Ñy×±ð±ÙqØ�ÙHÑy×±Õ¥Ñy×�Ø�ÚGÖ²Õhì�ÕBØ�Ö�é ç ÙH×�ï±Þ è á2Ø�ÙHá%Ö0ÙHØâÙHÕâ×Vê±éÝÖ�Þ}ÙHá è ëHëHìÝéÝÑyÕhØ;ÕBØ è ÷±ëÒÖ!Ø}Ñ7Ú è íyÖ èñ ÞBÖ%Ö0÷ÀÑyê±×±ð è ÞBì ç è ÕdÙHÕâð±Ñy×±Ö,ß;ÙqØ�Ú-Ø�Ú±ÖS8,puîyÞBÙÒð.àC�Ö-ß;ÙÒëÒëÂ×±Ñ�ß ï±ÞBÑFí�ÖøØ}Ú è Ø f ÔA7 Ø�3B? I 8":}bBÜ M 8�ä�3@?XØ f ÔA7 I 8�:BbBÜ2à�ò®Ñ�ðGÑØ}Ú±ÙÒÕ ç ßÂÖ7é è `�ÖLØ}Ú±Ö1`�Ö2ì è Õ}ÕBê±éÝï9Ø�ÙÒÑ�×�Ø�Ú è Ø,Ø}Ú±Ö7×Vê±éÝÖ�Þ}ÙHá è ë�ï±Þ}Ñyï è î è Ø}ÙÒÑy×cÑyê9Ø�ëÒÙH×±Ö%ðè ÷¢Ñ�íyÖ¤á%Ñy×{íyÖ�Þ}îyÖ�Õ=Ø�ÑúØ}Ú±Ö¤Ö,* è á�Ø7Õ}Ñ�ëÒêGØ}ÙÒÑy×�Ñ ñ Ø�ÚGÖ Â Äld�ÙH× Ø�ÚGÖ_ëÒÙHéÝÙqØ0Ñ ñ Ø�ÚGÖ¤Ø�ÙHéÝÖè ×±ð Õ}ï è Ø�Ù è ë³ÕhØ�Ö�ï±Õ è ï±ï±ÞBÑ è á�Ú±ÙH×±î h àÎÃ9ïÀÖ%á%Ùqûüá è ëÒëHì ç îyÙqíyÖ%×TÕBÑyé¶ÖóØ�ÙHéÝÖ�� m h Ø}Ñß;ÚGÙÒá�ÚTßÂÖcß;ÙHÕ}Ú Ø�Ñôï±ÞBÑyï è î è Ø�Ö�Ø�ÚGÖ Â Äld ç ߪÖõð±ÙHí�ÙHð±Ö�Ø�Ú±Ö�Ø}ÙÒé¶Ö�îyÞBÙÒðTÙÒ×{Ø}ÑôÕBØ�Ö�ïÕBÙ Ä Ö%Õ,Ñ ñ ëÒÖ�×±î�Ø}Úõ��� M �Gn H ç ß;Ú±Ö�Þ}Ö H ÙÒÕ è ×cÙÒ×{Ø�Ö�îyÖ%Þ³Ø�Ú è ئßÂÖ7ëÒÖ2Ø!îyÑ_Ø}Ñ R à � Ø

ªÈpo

Page 223: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÕBÑyé¶Ö 7 I 8 ç ߪÖâá%Ñy×±ÕhØ�ÞBê±á�Ø f ÔA7 I 8�:BbBÜ®÷{ìLá�Ñy×±ÕBØ}Þ}ê±á2Ø�ÙH×±î f ÿ Ô�7 I 8kÜf� f ÔA7 I 8": ) ���¦Ü çß;ÚGÖ%Þ}Ö )Mqh I $&$%$ IOH ç è ×±ð ñ ÑyÞ!b � Ð h I � Ñ ßªÖ¶ðGÖ�ûü×±Ö f ÔA7 I 8�:}bBܳØ}Ñ�÷¢ÖLØ}Ú±Ö7ëÒÙÒ×GÖ è ÞÙH×{Ø�Ö%ÞBï¢Ñ�ë è Ø}ÙÒÑy×õÑ ñ Ô f É ÔA7 I 8LÜ I $&$&$ I f r ÔA7 I 8kÜ}Ü,Ñy×ÒÐ h I � Ñ à�sÂëÒÖ è Þ}ëHì ç Ù ñ ߪÖ_á è × Õ}Ú±Ñ�ßØ}Ú è Ø f ÿ ÔA7 Ø 3@? I 8kÜ M 8 ä�3B?pØ f ÿ ÔA7 I 8LÜ ç Ø�Ú±Ö�×�÷Vì�ÙÒ×{Ø�Ö�Þ}ïÀÑyë è Ø}ÙÒÑy×�Ñyê±ÞLá�ë è ÙHéÚGÑyëÒð±ÕutÀb � Ð h I � Ñ àeC�Ö0ï±Þ}Ñ�í�Ö²Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕâ÷{ì�ÙÒ×Gð±ê±á�Ø}ÙÒÑy×`àϪìúð±Ö�û±×±ÙHØ}ÙÒÑy× ç f ÿ Ô�7 ØT3B? I 8kÜ M 8�äy3@?jØ f ÿ ÔA7 I 8LÜ ñ Ñ�Þ )vMwh ç Õ}Ñ è Õ}ÕBê±é¶ÖØ}Ú±Ö7Þ}Ö�Õ}ê±ëqØ?ÚGÑyëÒð±Õ ñ Ñ�Þ²ÕBÑyé¶Ö )yxzh à7ò�Ñøï±ÞBÑFí�Ö¶Ø}Ú è زÙHØ0ÚGÑyëÒð±Õ ñ Ñ�Þ ) Ø Â ç ߪֶé è ì×GÑ�Ø�Ö,Ø�Ú è Ø çf ÿ � Å ÔA7 Øs3@? I 8kÜ M

f ÿ ÔA7 Øs3@? I 8LÜ]Ø f b Ô�7 Ø:3B? I 8": ) �"�!Üh���

M 8�äF3@?=Ø f ÿ ÔA7 I 8LÜ�Ø f b Ô�7 Øs3@? I 8": ) ���¦ÜB��� Ô�� à ¿ Ü

{ Ñ�ß ç ñ ÞBÑyé f ÿ Ô�7 Ø 3@? I 8kÜ M 8 ä¢3B?@Ø f ÿ ÔA7 I 8LÜ_ßÂÖôÑ�÷GØ è ÙH× Ø}Ú è Ø þ wþ+| Ô�7 Ø3@? I 8�: ) ���¦Ü M 3@?pØ þ wþ,| ÔA7 I 8": ) ���¦Ü ç Õ}ÑcØ}Ú±Ö-ï¢Ö�Þ}ÙHÑ9ð±ÙHá%ÙqØuìõÑ ñ Y Ø�Ú±Ö�×�ÙÒé¶ï±ëÒÙHÖ%ÕØ}Ú è Ø þ wþ � ÔA7 Øs3@? I 8�: ) ���¦Ü M þ wþ � ÔA7 I 8": ) ���¦Ü2à�òâÚ±Ö�×}d\ý à Ô�� à ¿ Ü¥÷ÀÖ%á%Ñ�éÝÖ�Õ çf ÿ � Å ÔA7 Øs3@? I 8LÜ M 8�äF3@?HØ f ÿ Ô�7 I 8kÜ­Ø f b Ô�7 I 8": ) �"�!Üh���

M 8�äF3@?HØ f ÿ � Å ÔA7 I 8LÜ Ô�� à Ê ÜØ}Ú±Ö%ÞBÖ%÷{ì�á%Ñ�éÝï±ëHÖ�Ø}ÙÒ×±îLØ}Ú±Ö0ÙÒ×±ð±êGá�Ø�ÙHÑy×-ÕBØ}Ö%ï ç è ×Gðóï±ÞBÑ�í9ÙH×±î7Ñyê±Þâá�ë è ÙHéóà

ÂªÈ 4

Page 224: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

´ �O~ ¸ è��¶a}�?["�²�[º%�¶� IAº&K �

a;Ö%á è ëÒë ñ Þ}Ñyé�d�ý à Ô Â à ¿6h ܪØ�Ú è ØâØ}Ú±Ö,ûüÞ}ÕhØBpQÑyÞ}ð±Ö�Þ;Ö+*9ï±Þ}Ö�Õ}ÕBÙÒÑy× ñ ÑyÞ¥Ø�Ú±Ö0Ö2íyÑyëHêGØ�ÙHÑy×-Ñ ñ ÓÙH× g Ñ�ê±Þ}ÙHÖ%Þ¥ÕBï è á%Ö²ÙÒÕ ç Ó < b M Û '�� Ô >�ä(å | Ó W É X Ü�Y < Ô�� à Á Ü

òâÚGÙÒÕdÖ%ýVê è Ø}ÙÒÑy×øß è ÕdØ�Ú±Ö�×úê±ÕBÖ%ðúØ}ѤÑy÷9Ø è ÙH×�Ø}Ú±Ökî�Þ è ð±ÙHÖ%×{ØBpQð±Ö%ÕBá%Ö�×Vئï±Þ}Ö�Õ}á�Þ}ÙÒï9Ø�ÙÒÑ�× ñ ÑyÞá�ÚGÑ9ÑyÕBÙÒ×±î�YÏÙÒ×�Ø}Ú±Ö_ûüÞ}ÕhØBpQÑyÞ}ð±Ö�ÞLëÒÙHéÝÙqØ&à g ÑyÞ?ßÂÖ è ` ïÀÖ%ÞhØ�ê±ÞB÷ è Ø�ÙHÑy×±Õ ç Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕkï±Þ}Ö�Õ}á%ÞBÙÒï9pØ}ÙÒÑyפױÑ=ëÒÑy×GîyÖ%Þ¥á�ÑyÙÒ×Gá%ÙÒðGÖ%ÕÂß;ÙqØ�Ú¤Ø}Ú±Ö,îyÞ è ð±ÙÒÖ�×VØhpuð±Ö�Õ}á�Ö%×{Ø è ï±ï±ÞBÑ è á�Ú ç ÷GêGØâÕ}ÚGÑyê±ëÒð-ÕhØ�ÙHëÒëÕBÚ±Þ}ÙH×�`_Ø�ÚGÖ²×GÑy× Ä Ö�Þ}Ñ g Ñ�ê±Þ}ÙHÖ%Þâá%Ñ�éÝïÀÑy×±Ö�×VØ}Õ³Ñ ñ Ó à òâÚ±ÙÒÕâß;ÙHëÒë.Ñ�á%á�ê±Þ è Õ³ëHÑy×±î è ÕâØ�ÚGÖÞBÙÒîyÚ{سÕ}ÙHð±Ö?Ñ ñ d\ýÀà Ô�� à Á Ü Ô Ñ�Þ�d\ý à Ô Â à ¿6h Ü}Ü¥ÙHÕ³ÕBêG�¶á%ÙÒÖ�×{Ø�ëHìóð±Ñyé¶ÙÒ× è ×{سá�Ñyé¶ï è Þ}Ö�ðóØ}ÑØ}Ú±Ö7Þ}Ö�é è ÙH×±ÙÒ×Gî¤Ø�Ö�Þ}é¶Õ,ÙÒ×cØ�Ú±Ö ñ ê±ëHë  Äld ñ ÑyÞ0Ó�à { Ñ�Ø}Ö7Ø}Ú±Ö%×õØ�Ú è Ø ñ ÑyÞ,Þ}Ö�Õ}Ñy× è ×±á%Ö�Õè ×±ð�×GÖ è Þ�puÞ}Ö�Õ}Ñy× è ×±á%Ö�Õ²Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕ,á�Ñy×±ð±ÙqØ�ÙHÑy×cð±Ñ�Ö%Õ0×±Ñ�زڱÑyëHð.à1-³Ñ�ߪÖ�í�Ö%Þ ç ñ ÑyÞ,Õ}ê9�Ýá�ÙÒÖ�×VØ}ëHì×GÑy×9puÞBÖ%ÕBÑy× è ×{ØkØ}Ö%ÞBéÝÕ²Ø�Ú±ÙHÕ?á�Ñy×±ð±ÙqØ�ÙÒÑ�× ð±Ñ�Ö%Õ?Ú±ÑyëÒð`àøòâÚVê±Õ ç ÙÒ× î�Ö%×±Ö�Þ è ë ç ñ ÑyÞ è ᦙ è `ïÀÖ%ÞhØ�ê±ÞB÷ è Ø}ÙÒÑy× ç Ñyê±Þ  Äld·pu÷ è ÕBÖ%ð è ï±ï±ÞBÑ è á�Ú ÕhØ è ÞhØ�Õ¶ÑyêGØÝ÷{ì�ð±Ö%á�Þ}Ö è Õ}ÙÒ×Gî�Ø�ÚGÖóé¶ÑyÞ}Ö×GÑy×9puÞBÖ%ÕBÑy× è ×{ØâØ�Ö�Þ}é¶ÕâÑ ñ Ó à�òâÚ±Ö��LpQð±Ö%ïÀÖ%×±ðGÖ%×±á�Ö?Ñ ñ Ó ÕBØ è ÞBØ}Õâð±Ö%á�Þ}Ö è Õ}ÙH×±î ç è ×±ð�ÕBÑØ}Ú±Ö0Þ è Ø}Ö0Ñ ñ á�Ú è ×±îyÖ²Ñ ñ f ð±Ö%á�Þ}Ö è Õ}Ö�Õ è ÕâߪÖ%ëÒë è Õ;Ø}Ú±Ö0Ö�í�ÑyëÒêGØ}ÙÒÑy×�ï±ÞBÑ9á�Ö%Ö�ð±Õ%àud�íyÖ%×{Ø}ê9pè ëÒëHì ç Ø�ÚGÖ¶ÕBêG�¶á%ÙHÖ%×{Ø�ëqìc×±Ñy×9pQÞ}Ö�Õ}Ñy× è ×VØ0Ø}Ö%Þ}é¶Õ,Ñ ñ Ó è Þ}Ö=ÞBÖ%ð±ê±á�Ö%ð�Ø�Ñ è ï¢ÑyÙH×{Ø,ß;Ú±Ö%ÞBÖÚGÙÒîyÚ±Ö�ÞhpQÑyÞ}ð±Ö�Þ.Ø�Ö�Þ}é¶ÕÆ÷¢Ö�á%Ñyé¶Ö�ÙÒé¶ï¢ÑyÞhØ è ×{Ø ç Õ}Ñ;Ø�Ú è Ø�Ñyê±ÞÆûüÞ}ÕhØBpQÑyÞ}ð±Ö�Þ�îyÞ è ðGÙÒÖ%×{Øhpuð±Ö�Õ}á%Ö�×{ØïGÞ}Ö%ÕBá%ÞBÙÒïGØ}ÙÒÑy× ñ ÑyÞâá�ÚGÑ9ÑyÕBÙÒ×±î1Y ß;ÙÒëÒëÀ×±Ñ7ëÒÑ�×±îyÖ%ÞªßÂÑyÞ�`¤Ø�Ñ=ÞBÖ%ð±êGá%Ö,Ø�Ú±Ö��LpQð±Ö%ïÀÖ%×Gð±Ö%×±á�ÖÂªÈ 5

Page 225: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ñ ñ Ó à!òâÚ±Ö=Þ è Ø�Ö?Ñ ñ á�Ú è ×±î�Ö=Ñ ñ f Ø�Ú±Ö�×�÷ÀÖ%î�ÙÒ×±ÕdØ�Ñ_ÙH×±á%ÞBÖ è ÕBÖ è ñ Ø�Ö�Þ¦Ø�ÚGÙÒÕ¦ïÀÑyÙH×VØ ç è ×GðÖ2íyÖ�×VØ}ê è ëHëHìkØ}Ú±Ö Â Äld�÷ÀÖ%á�Ñyé¶Ö%Õ\×Vê±é¶Ö%Þ}ÙHá è ëHëHì²ê±×±ÕhØ è ÷GëÒÖ�à�ϪìkØ}Þ è áO`VÙÒ×Gî j � Ô fn bBÜ��<�Ñ�פØ�Ú±Ö¦îyÞ}ÙHð ç ÙHتÙÒÕÂïÀÑyÕBÕ}ÙÒ÷GëÒÖ;Ø�ÑLÕhØ�Ñyï_Ø}Ú±Ö¦Ö2íyÑyëHêGØ�ÙHÑyפß;Ú±Ö�Þ}Ö¦Ø}Ú±Ö!Þ è Ø�Ö¦Ñ ñ á�Ú è ×±î�Ö!Ñ ñ f

ÞBÖ è á�ÚGÖ%Õ0ÙHØ}Õ,éÝÙH×±ÙÒéLêGé ç è ×±ðõá�Ñy×±Õ}Ö�ýVê±Ö%×{Ø�ëqìcß;Ú±Ö%ÞBÖ=Ø�Ú±Ö=á è ×±Ñy×±ÙHá è ë�÷ è ÕBÙÒÕ,Ú è Õ,÷ÀÖ%Ö�×Ñ�ïGØ�ÙHéÝÙ Ä Ö%ð`àªòâÚ±ÖkÓ Ö2íyÑyëHêGØ�ÙHÑy×øÙÒÕ è ëÒÕBѶØ}Ö%Þ}é¶ÙÒ× è Ø�Ö�ðøêGÕ}ÙÒ×Gî è × è × è ëHÑyîyÑyê±Õâá�Þ}ÙqØ�Ö%ÞBÙÒÑy×Ø}Ñ=Ø�Ú±Ö0Ñy×±Ö0ê±ÕBÖ%ð ñ ÑyÞ f àù ñ á%Ñ�ê±Þ}ÕBÖ ç Ø}Ú±Ö³ßªÖ è `�Ö%Þ¥Ø}Ú±Ö¦ïÀÖ%ÞhØ�ê±ÞB÷ è Ø}ÙÒÑy× ç Ø}Ú±Ö¦á�ëÒÑyÕBÖ%Þ è îyÙHí�Ö%×_>úéLê±ÕBØÂ÷¢ÖdØ�Ñ èÞBÖ%ÕBÑy× è ×±á�Ö ñ ÑyÞÂÑyêGÞâá�Ú±ÑyÙÒá�Ö!Ñ ñ Y Ø}Ñ=×±Ñ7ëÒÑy×GîyÖ%Þ ßÂÑyÞ�`ÝØ}Ñ=Þ}Ö%ðGê±á%Ö,Ø�ÚGÖ,á%ÑyÞBÞ}Ö%ÕBï¢Ñ�×±ð±ÙÒ×GîÓ < à g êGØ}Ú±Ö%ÞBéÝÑ�Þ}Ö ç Ø}Ú±Ö¤ßªÖ è `�Ö%Þ7Ø�Ú±Ö¤ï¢Ö�ÞBØ�êGÞ}÷ è Ø}ÙÒÑy× ç Ø�Ú±Ö-ëHÑy×±îyÖ�ÞkÙHØLÙÒÕkïÀÑyÕBÕ}ÙÒ÷GëÒÖ¤Ø}ÑïGÞ}Ñyï è î è Ø�ÖdØ�Ú±Ö Â Äld�÷ÀÖ ñ ÑyÞBÖ j � Ô fn bBÜ � �ªÞ}Ö è á�Ú±Ö�ÕâÙHØ�ÕªéÝÙH×±ÙÒékê±é ç è ×±ð_Ø�Ú±Ö¦á%ëÒÑ�Õ}Ö%ÞØ}Ú±ÙÒÕ,é¶ÙÒ×GÙÒéLê±é ß;ÙHëÒë�á%ÑyÞBÞ}Ö%ÕBï¢Ñ�×±ð�Ø}Ñ è ÕBØ�Ö è ðGì{puÕhØ è Ø}Ö�à��QØ,ߪÑyê±ëHðc÷¢Ö7ÙÒ×{Ø}Ö%Þ}Ö�ÕBØ}ÙÒ×±î_Ø}ÑðGÖ�íyÖ�ëÒÑyï è ÕBÙÒé¶ï±ëÒÖÝá%ÞBÙHØ�Ö�Þ}ÙHÑy×�Ø}ÑcÖ%ÕBØ}ÙÒé è Ø�Ö è ØLß;Ú è ØLØ�ÙHéÝÖ¶Ø�Ú±ÙHÕké¶ÙÒ×±ÙHéLê±é Ñ�á%á%êGÞ}Õ çè ×±ðóÚGÑFß ñ è Þ è ß è ì-Ø}Ú±Ö0ÕBì�ÕBØ}Ö%é�ÙÒÕ ñ ÞBÑyé ÕhØ�Ö è ðGì{puÕBØ è Ø�Ö è Ø;Ø}Ú±Ö0éÝÙH×±ÙÒéLêGéóà

ªÈ�È

Page 226: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ä î î òÚø þ ÷ÆÅ ü

Ä ø Ä þ þ ÷­ð�÷Bùúø í � ÷4ó��Cð�ÿJ� ónþ ò�ó

� ò �jý ­ð�u×øØ�Ú±ÙHÕ;Õ}Ö%á2Ø�ÙHÑy×óߪÖkð±Ö�Þ}ÙqíyÖ0Ø�Ú±Ö0ûüÞ}ÕhØBpQÑyÞ}ð±Ö�Þ³ÞBÖ%ÕBê±ëHØ ñ ÑyÞ³Ó ÔA7 I þ wþ+� : h Ü2à g Ñ�ëÒëÒÑ�ß;ÙH×±îkØ�ÚGÖïGÞ}Ñ�á%Ö%ðGê±Þ}ÖóÙÒ×ysÂÚ è ïGØ�Ö�Þ Â ç ßÂÖøß;Þ}ÙHØ}Ö f

M 7 ä 8w� �Y ÔA7 I 8":}bBÜnà>C Ö è ëÒÕBÑ�ß;ÞBÙHØ�ÖÓ ÔA7 I9� : h Ü M Ó W�� X Ô � : h Üe� Ó W�� X Ô�7 I9� : h Ü2à"�dÕ}ÙÒ×Gî � M þ wþ,� M 8�� å � �Y Ô�7 I 8":}bBÜ çߪֲîyÖ�ØâØ}Ñ7û±Þ}ÕBØhpuÑyÞBð±Ö%ÞâØ}Ú è Ø çÓ ÔA7 I9� : h Ü M Ó W�� X Ô 8�: h Ü��ôå | Ó W�� X Ô 8�: h Ü.ä&å � �Y ÔA7 I 8�:}bBÜ���Ó W�� X ÔA7 I 8": h Ü ÔA� à  Üg ÑyÞ�ÕBÙÒé¶ï±ëÒÙHá%ÙHØuì ç ᦙ è ÕBÕ}ê±é¶ÖdØ}Ú è Ø�Y�ß è Õªá�Ú±ÑyÕBÖ%×_ê±ÕBÙÒ×±îkÓ W�� X Ô 8LÜ M Ó W�� X Ô 8": h Ünà � Õé¶Ö%×{Ø}ÙÒÑy×±Ö�ð�÷¢Ö ñ ÑyÞ}Ö ç ÙÒ×-Ø�Ú±Ö,ûüÞBÕBØhpuÑyÞBð±Ö%Þ;ëÒÙHéÝÙqØ è ëÒë¢Ø}Ú±Þ}Ö�Ö?ïGÞ}Ö%ÕBá%ÞBÙÒïGØ}ÙÒÑy×±Õ ñ Ñ�Þâá�Ú±Ñ9Ñ�Õ}ÙÒ×Gî

Û hph

Page 227: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Y è ÞBÖúÖ%ýVê±Ùqí è ëÒÖ�×VØ%ài�dÕ}ÙH×±î�Ø}Ú±Ö�Ñ�Ø}Ú±Ö%Þ¶ØußÂÑ�ïGÞ}Ö%ÕBá%ÞBÙÒïGØ}ÙÒÑy×±Õ¶ß;ÙÒëHëdëHÖ è ð:Ø�Ñ è ؤé¶ÑyÕBØÕBÖ%á�Ñy×±ð9pQÑyÞ}ð±Ö�Þ³á�ÑyÞ}ÞBÖ%á2Ø�ÙÒÑ�×±ÕâÙÒ×�Ñyê±Þ¥û±× è ëÆÞ}Ö�Õ}ê±ëqØ&à g Þ}Ñyé�d\ýÀà Ô Â à����yܪßÂÖ0îyÖ2Ø;Ø�Ú è Ø çå | Ó W�� X ä(å � �Y Ô�7 I 8":}bBÜ M P

Â� @<��¹ � Ó W�� X< Ô Â P A o ©E� � W <FC �k  ¡.¢ ¨�£ X � � ÜhA � � ;x<FC �

M P Ó W�� X � Â� @<��¹ � Ó W�� X< A o ©E� � W <FC �k X¡ ¢ ¨�£ X � � A � � ;x<(C �ÔA� à ÛyÜ

è ×±ðóÕBÑ=ßÂÖ²Ñy÷GØ è ÙÒ× çÓ Ô�7 I

f 7 ÔA7 I 8�:}bBÜ,: h Ü M Ó W�� X Ô 8": h ÜN� Â

� @<��¹ � Ó W�� X< Ô 8�: h ÜBA o ©E� � W <(C �k  ¡ ¢ ¨�£ X�� � A � � ;x<FC �ÔA� à�¤{Ü

Û h Â

Page 228: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ä î î òÚø þ ÷ÆÅ ¥

Ç ý ö ¦3§p÷��©¨� õ ¦iª«¨ ÷\�� û�ù¬§ ªv­ ¦

� ÷·Ê §v¨zª�÷Bùúø ¨� ® §¯¦�þ ÷����=ù��à÷e¨wª�÷Bùúø

¥ ¨����ý e¨zª�÷Bùúø ��u×�Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕ � ï±ïÀÖ%×±ðGÙ�* ç ߪÖ=ï±Þ}Ö�Õ}Ö%×{زÕ}Ñ�éÝÖ?×�êGéÝÖ�Þ}ÙÒá è ë·ðGÖ�Ø è ÙÒëÒÕ ñ ÑyÞ³Ø}Ú±Ö=á è ëÒá%êGë è Ø}ÙÒÑy×±ÕdÙÒ×sÂÚ è ïGØ�Ö�Þu�9à�òâÚ±Ö�Õ}Ödá è ëHá%ê±ë è Ø�ÙHÑy×±Õ�ߪÖ%ÞBÖ³×GÑ�Ø�Þ}Ö�î è Þ}ðGÖ%ð è Õ\Õ}êG�¶á�ÙÒÖ%×{Ø}ëHì=ÙH×VØ}Ö%ÞBÖ%ÕBØ}ÙÒ×±î,Ø}Ñ÷ÀÖ0ÙÒ×±á�ëÒê±ðGÖ%ðøÙÒ×�Ø�Ú±Ö0é è ÙÒ×�÷ÀÑ9ðGì_Ñ ñ Ø}Ú±Ö?á�Ú è ïGØ�Ö�Þ%àªòâÚ±Ö�ì è ÞBÖ²ÙH×±á%ëHê±ð±Ö�ðóÚ±Ö�Þ}Ö0Ø�Ñ è ÙÒðÙH×{Ø�Ö%ÞBÖ%ÕhØ�Ö%ð:Þ}Ö�Õ}Ö è Þ}á�Ú±Ö�Þ}Õ¶ÙÒ×ôÞBÖ%ï±ÞBÑ9ð±êGá%ÙÒ×GîcÑyê±Þ=Þ}Ö�Õ}ê±ëqØ�Õ è ×Gð:ïÀÑyÕBÕ}ÙÒ÷GëHì�Þ}Ö�û±×±ÙÒ×±î è ×GðÖ,*�Ø�Ö%×Gð±ÙÒ×±î7Ø�ÚGÖ²ïGÞ}Ö%ðGÙÒÕ}ÕBÑ9á�Ù è Ø}ÙÒÑy×-é¶Ñ�ð±Ö%ëYà

Û h Û

Page 229: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

° ��� I��}� ±'²f�³�³^¢J ± ´µ��¶R·F¶

òâÚGÖkÞ}Ñ�í�ÙÒ÷GÞ è Ø}ÙÒÑy× è ëÆÕBØ è Ø�Ö%Õ³Ñ ñ - g ߪÖ%Þ}ÖkÑy÷GØ è ÙÒ×±Ö�ðú÷{ì è Õ}ÕBê±éÝÙH×±î è qóÑyÞBÕ}ÖkÙH×{Ø�Ö%Þ è á2pØ}ÙÒÑy×õïÀÑ�Ø�Ö�×{Ø�Ù è ë ç ß;ÙHØ}Ú è îyÞBÑyê±×±ð9pQÕBØ è Ø�Ö¶Ú è ÞBéÝÑy×GÙÒá ñ Þ}Ö�ýVê±Ö%×±á2ìc¡ M �  ¤ 5 $�¤{ÛLá%é o � çè ×±ð è ð±ÙÒÕBÕ}Ñ�á%Ù è Ø�ÙHÑy× Ö�×±Ö%ÞBî�ì�Ñ ñ � M � 4 I o Û 5 á�é o � à¸C�Ö_Ñy÷GØ è ÙÒ×GÖ%ðôÑyê±Þ ñ Þ}Ö%Önp�- gÖ�ÙÒîyÖ�× ñ ê±×±á2Ø�ÙHÑy×±Õ ñ ÑyÞâÁ Mih P � ç6¹ Mºh P  �Gà�òâÚ±Ö0Ö%ýVê±ÙHëÒÙÒ÷GÞ}ÙÒêGé�÷ÀÑy×±ð�ëHÖ%×±î�Ø}Ú¼»F½�¾ÂÑ ñ- g ÙÒÕ è ëÒÕBѳ`V×±Ñ�ß;× è ×±ð=ÙÒÕ�Ö%ýVê è ëGØ}Ñ h $�¿ Â$o 5�À� à·òâÚ±Ö è á2Ø�ê è ë ñ Þ}Ö�Ö2pE- g Ö�×±Ö%ÞBîyÙÒÖ�Õ�ð±ÙHö¢Ö%ÞÕBëÒÙHîyÚ{Ø�ëHì ñ Þ}Ñyé Ø}Ú±ÑyÕBÖÝÑy÷9Ø è ÙH×±Ö%ð�ê±Õ}ÙH×±îóØ}Ú±Ö�qóÑyÞ}ÕBÖ¤ïÀÑ�Ø�Ö�×{Ø�Ù è ë è ï±ï±ÞBÑ$*9ÙHé è Ø}ÙÒÑy×`à � ×Ö,*9á%Ö%ëHëÒÖ�×Vسû±Ø ç è á�á%ê±Þ è Ø�Ö²Ø�Ѷß;ÙHØ�ÚGÙÒ× Â á�é o � ç ÙHÕ³îyÙqíyÖ�×ú÷{ì�Ø�Ú±ÖÂÁ!ê±×±Ú è é�Ö,*9ï±Þ}Ö�Õ}Õ}ÙHÑy×à o hÅÄ ç

ÆÈÇ�É M Ô�Ê ��� Ô Ál� ÂÛ Ü�� Ê � � Ô Ál� ÂÛ Ü � � ÊÌË � Ô Á³� ÂÛ Ü Ë Ü��Ô�Ê �Í� � Ê �E� Ô Á³� ÂÛ Ü�� Ê � � Ô Á³� ÂÛ Ü � Ü ¹ Ô ¹ �  Ü��Ô�Ê � � � Ê � � Ô Á³� ÂÛ Ü�� Ê �E� Ô Á³� ÂÛ Ü � Ü Ô ¹ Ô ¹ �  Ü}Ü � Ô s¦à  Üß;ÚGÖ%Þ}Ö Ê ��� M �  ¤ 5 $�¤{Û I Ê � � M P 5 ¿9$ 565 I Ê�Ë � Mºh $�¿ h I Ê �Í� M Û h $�¿6�6� 4 I Ê �E� M P h $ 4 ¿ 5 I Ê � � Mh $ h Â Û 4 I Ê � � Mµh $ h6h Û Â �  I Ê � � M P o $ 5¼Î  h o Ï I Ê �E� M Û9$ 5¼Î  h o Ð ç è ëÒë�ÙH×õê±×±ÙHØ}Õ0Ñ ñá�é o � à

� Ö�á è êGÕ}Ö;Ø�Ú±Ö;á%Ñ�Þ}Þ}Ö�á�Ø}ÙÒÑy×±Õ�Ø}Ñ,Ø�Ú±Ö ñ ÞBÖ%Ö2pE- g Ö%×GÖ%Þ}î�ÙÒÖ%Õ�á�ÑyéÝïGêGØ�Ö�ð7ß;ÙqØ�Ú=Ø�ÚGÖ|qøÑyÞ}ÕBÖïÀÑ�Ø}Ö%×{Ø�Ù è ë è Þ}ÖøÕ}é è ëÒë Ô è ØÝéÝÑyÕhØ è ñ Ö�ß ïÀÖ%ÞBá%Ö�×VØ�Ü ç ߪÖúð±Ö�á%ÙÒðGÖ%ð Ø}Ú è ضØ�Ú±Ö ñ Þ}Ö%Önp�- gÖ�ÙÒîyÖ�× ñ ê±×±á2Ø�ÙHÑy×±ÕÂá�Ñyé¶ï±êGØ�Ö�ð ñ Þ}Ñ�é�Ø}Ú±Ö�qøÑyÞ}ÕBÖ!ï¢Ñ�Ø�Ö%×{Ø}Ù è ëüߪÖ%Þ}Ö¦Õ}êG�¶á%ÙHÖ%×{Ø�ëqì è á%á%êGÞ è Ø}ÖÛ h ¤

Page 230: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ñ Ñ�Þ�Ø}Ú±ÖÂá è ëÒá�ê±ë è Ø�ÙÒÑ�×±ÕÆÙÒ×ÂsÂÚ è ïGØ}Ö%ÞR�9àR-dÑFߪÖ�í�Ö%Þ ç Õ}ÙÒ×Gá%Ö è Ú±ÙHîyÚ±ëHì è á%á�ê±Þ è Ø}ÖªÖ,*9ï±Þ}Ö�Õ}Õ}ÙHÑy×ñ Ñ�Þ0Ø}Ú±Ö ñ Þ}Ö%Önp�- g Õ}ïÀÖ%á2Ø�ÞBê±éãÙÒÕ è í è ÙÒë è ÷±ëÒÖ ç ßÂÖ¶ð±Ö%á�ÙÒð±Ö�ð Ø�Ñøê±ÕBÖ¤ÙHØ,Ø}Ñúá�ÑyéÝïGêGØ�Ö=Ø�ÚGÖñ ÞBÖ%Önp�- g Ö�×±Ö%ÞBîyÙÒÖ�ÕdÑ�×±á%Ö0Ñyê±ÞXqóÑ�Þ}Õ}Ö0ïÀÑ�Ø�Ö�×{Ø�Ù è ë.á è ëHá%ê±ë è Ø�ÙHÑy×±Õ¥á�Ñy×{íyÖ�Þ}îyÖ�ð.à° �,/ ¸ �7�e�,�_�f·��ÂÑ ° �"ÒcaÓÑF·&��["¶

ò®ÑkðGÖ�Ø�Ö�Þ}é¶ÙÒ×±ÖâØ}Ú±Ö³ÞBÖ%ï±ÞBÖ%ÕBÖ%×{Ø è Ø}ÙÒÑy× è Ø è î�ÙHíyÖ�×^Ô Ñ ñ � Ô Ô I » IOÕ Ü�ÙH׶Ø}Ú±Ö ñ ÞBÖ%Önp�- g ÷ è pÕBÙÒÕ ç ߪÖ�ÕBØ è ÞBØ�÷{ì!ß;ÞBÙHØ�ÙH×±î¥Ø�ÚGÖ ñ Þ}Ö%Önp�- g ÕhØ è Ø}Ö%ÕÈK Á I ¹ � è Õ@& ��Ö Ç � K U �×K ¹ I9Ø � ç ß;Ú±Ö�Þ}Ö;/ÙK U � 1è Þ}Ö;Ø�Ú±ÖdÚ è ÞBéÝÑy×GÙÒá2pQÑyÕ}á�ÙÒëHë è Ø}ÑyÞ�Ö�ÙÒîyÖ�× ñ ê±×±á2Ø�ÙHÑy×±Õ á%ÑyÞBÞ}Ö%ÕBï¢Ñ�×±ð±ÙÒ×Gî²Ø}Ñ?Ø�ÚGÖ³îyÞBÑyê±×±ð�puÕBØ è Ø�ÖÚ è Þ}é¶Ñy×±ÙHá ñ Þ}Ö�ý�êGÖ%×±á2ì�Ñ ñ Ø}Ú±ÖÄqóÑyÞBÕ}Ö²ï¢Ñ�Ø�Ö%×{Ø}Ù è ëYà·òâÚ±Ö�×óØ�ÚGÖ,á%Ñyê±ïGëÒÙÒ×Gî � Á i I ¹ i K � K Á I ¹ �ÙHÕ�îyÙHí�Ö%פ÷{ìÚ& �+Û �ÍÜ Ö Ç Üx�ÍÜ Ö Ç � � ¹ i I9Ø K � U i K � K U �LK ¹ I9Ø ��à·òâÚ±ÙÒÕ ï±Þ}Ñ�í�Ö%ð¤Ø}Ñ?÷ÀÖ è á%Ñy×{í�Ö%×±ÙHÖ%×{Øß è ìóØ}Ѥá�ÑyéÝïGêGØ�Ö²Ø�Ú±Ö?á%Ñyê±ïGëÒÙÒ×GîyÕ ç Õ}ÙH×±á%Ö?Ú è ÞBéÝÑy×GÙÒá2pQÑyÕ}á�ÙÒëHë è Ø}ÑyÞÂÖ�ÙÒîyÖ�×±ÕBØ è Ø�Ö�Õ è ÞBÖkÞ}Ö�ëqpè Ø�ÙHí�Ö%ëqì_Ö è ÕBì-Ø�Ñ7Ú è ×±ð±ëÒÖ�àC�Ö�á%Ñy×{íyÖ�ÞBØ}Ö%ð ñ ÞBÑyéµØ}Ú±Ö�»�Þ}Ö�ï±Þ}Ö�Õ}Ö%×{Ø è Ø�ÙHÑy×sÑ ñ Ø}Ú±Ö'- g ÷¢Ñy×Gð:ëHÖ%×±î�Ø�ÚôØ�ÑcØ�ÚGÖ

Ý M » P »F½�¾=ÞBÖ%ï±ÞBÖ%Õ}Ö�×{Ø è Ø}ÙÒÑy×�ÙÒ×�Ø}Ö%ÞBéÝÕ=Ñ ñ Ö%ýVê±ÙHëÒÙH÷±Þ}ÙHê±é ð±ÙÒÕBï±ë è á%Ö%é¶Ö%×{Ø%à�C�Ö è ëÒÕ}Ñá�Ñy×{íyÖ�ÞBØ�Ö�ð ñ Þ}Ñ�é�Ø�ÚGÖ è ×±îyëÒÖ Õ Ø}Ñ�Þ}��á%ÑyÕ Õ_P  à�C�Ö¶×GÖ+*�زé è ðGÖLØ�Ú±Ö7Ö+*9ï è ×±Õ}ÙHÑy×� Ô Ô I » IOÕ Ü M &Jßáà ß Ô Ô I Ý Ü�Þ ß à�â9ÙÒ×Gá%Ö0ßÂÖLÚ è í�Ö Â ¤¶ð è Ø è ï¢Ñ�ÙÒ×{Ø�Õ ñ ÑyÞbÞ ñ Ñ�Þ³Ö è á�ÚÓÔ I »ï è ÙÒÞ ç ßÂÖ0é è `�Ö0ÑyêGÞ¥û±ØdÑyêGØâØ�Ñ Â Û Ø}Ú ÑyÞ}ðGÖ%Þ%à�òâÚ±Ö�× ç

� ¹ i I9Ø K � K ¹ I9Ø � M @ß à ß Ô Ô I Ý Ü � ¹ i I9Ø K Þ ß K ¹ IÍØ � Ô s¦à ÛyÜÛ h �

Page 231: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

è ×±ðóÕBÑ ç� U i K � ¹ i I9Ø K � K ¹ IÍØ �×K U � M @

ß� U i K à ß Ô Ô I Ý Ü$K U � � ¹ i I9Ø K Þ ß K ¹ I9Ø � Ô s¦à�¤{Ü

òâÚ±Ö�Ö�í è ëHê è Ø�ÙHÑy× Ñ ñ � ¹ i I9Ø K Þ ß K ¹ IÍØ �øÙÒÕ�ïÀÖ%Þ ñ ÑyÞ}é¶Ö%ð è × è ëqìVØ�ÙÒá è ëÒëqì Ô ß;ÙHØ}ÚSÕBÑyéÝÖÚGÖ%ëÒï ñ Þ}Ñ�é q � òG-�dmq � òÈ�ãs � Ü2à�òâÚ±ÖÝÖ2í è ëÒê è Ø�ÙÒÑ�×�Ñ ñ � U i K à ß Ô Ô I Ý Ü$K U �,ÙÒÕ0ð±Ñ�×±ÖÝ×Vê9pé¶Ö%ÞBÙÒá è ëÒëqì ç ê±ÕBÙÒ×±îóëÒÙÒ×GÖ è Þ0ÙÒ×{Ø}Ö%Þ}ïÀÑyë è Ø�ÙHÑy×cÑy× à ß Ô Ô I Ý Ü,ÙÒ× Ý à^C Ú±ÙÒëHÖ=ßÂÖ_á�Ñyê±ëHð�Ñy×GëHìïÀÖ%Þ ñ ÑyÞ}éãØ�ÚGÖ_ÙÒ×{Ø�Ö�îyÞ è Ø�ÙÒÑ�× Ñ�íyÖ�Þ è ûü×±ÙHØ}Ö Ý Þ è ×GîyÖ ñ ÑyÞ²ß;Ú±ÙÒá�Ú�ïÀÑ�Ø�Ö�×VØ}Ù è ë ð è Ø è ß è Õè í è ÙHë è ÷±ëHÖ ç ßÂÖ?ï±Þ}Ö�Õ}ê±é¶Ö²Ø}Ú è Ø;Ø�ÚGÖ²ß è íyÖ ñ êG×±á�Ø}ÙÒÑy×±Õ¦ð±Ö%á è ìøÕBêG�¶á%ÙÒÖ�×{Ø�ëHì�Þ è ï±ÙHð±ëHì¤ÑyêGØBpÕBÙÒð±Ö,Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕâÞ è ×±îyÖ!Ø}Ú è ØdÕ}ê±á�Ú è ×�ÙÒ×{Ø�Ö�îyÞ è Ø�ÙÒÑ�×_ì9ÙHÖ%ëHð±Õ è á%á�ê±Þ è Ø�Ö²Þ}Ö%ÕBê±ëHØ}Õ%à

Û h �

Page 232: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ä ä ä ¦wå æ çÆÅ è

Ä å éëê ìe¨�§ ¥ íîê ä ìfçfå éðï

�u× Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕ � ï±ïÀÖ%×±ðGÙ�* ç ßÂÖcÕBÚ è ëÒë³Õ}Ú±Ñ�ß�Ú±Ñ�ß ßÂÖcá�ÑyéÝïGêGØ�Ö�á�Ñyê±ï±ëHÙÒ×±î�Õ¤Ñ ñ Ø�ÚGÖ ñ ÑyÞ}é ç� ¹�ñ I9Ø K Þ ÿ K ¹ I9Ø � ç ß;Ú±Ö%ÞBÖ_Þ�� á%ÑyÕ ÕlP>ò àfC�Ö,ÕBØ è ÞBØd÷{ì-ß;Þ}ÙqØ�ÙÒ×Gî ç

� ÕcI ¼ K ¹ I9Ø � M ÊSóÉ Ô ÕcI ¼ ÜM Ô P_ò Ü ÉÛ É ¹Ùô õöö÷ Û ¹ � ò

�ÅøÔ ¹ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ P¯Ø Ü ôúù ; óBû òÕ}ÙÒ× ó Õ

ü É,ý óü Ô á%ÑyÕ Õ Ü É,ý ó Ô Õ}ÙÒ× Õ Ü � ÉÔ ÁLà ò Ü

� Õ³Ö,*GïGë è ÙH×±Ö%ðøÙÒ×JsÂÚ è ï9Ø�Ö%Þ�� ç ÑyêGÞdïÀÑ�Ø}Ö%×{Ø�Ù è ë.ð±Ñ�Ö%Õd×±Ñ�ØdÙÒ×Gð±ê±á%Ö,Ø}Þ è ×±ÕBÙHØ}ÙÒÑy×±Õâ÷ÀÖ+þØuߪÖ%Ö�×SðGÙHö¢Ö%Þ}Ö�×{Ø Ø ÕBØ è Ø�Ö%Õ�à�òâÚ�êGÕ ç ߪÖcá è × ñ ÑyÞ}îyÖ2Ø è ÷ÀÑyêGØÝØ�Ú±Ö ù; óeû Ø�Ö%ÞBé ç è ×Gð

Û h o

Page 233: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

ÞBÖ%Ö,*GïGÞ}Ö%ÕBÕ¦ÑyêGÞâÖ%ýVê è Ø}ÙÒÑy×øÙÒ×-Ø�Ö�Þ}é¶ÕâÑ ñ Þ¢à\òâÚ±ÙHÕ;îyÙHí�Ö%Õ;ê±Õ çÿ óÉ Ô Þ±Ü M òÛ É ¹Ùô õöö÷ Û ¹ � ò

�pøÔ ¹ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ PvØ Ü ô òÔ P Þ Ô Þl�sÛyÜ}Ü�� � ü É,ý ó

ü Þ ÉOý óÔ Þ Ô Þ�� ÛyÜBÜ É Ô ÁLà ÛyÜ

a;Ö%é¶Ö%ék÷¢Ö�Þ}ÙÒ×Gî¦Ø�Ú è Ø�Ø�Ú±ÖâÙH×{Ø�Ö%î�Þ è Ø}ÙÒÑy×LÑ ñ ¼ ñ Þ}Ñyé h Ø�ѲÛ×ø�ÕBÙÒé¶ï±ëHì²ï±ÞBÑ9ð±êGá%Ö%Õ è ñ è á2Ø�ÑyÞÑ ñ Û×ø ç ßÂÖ²Ñy÷GØ è ÙÒ×_Ø}Ú è Ø ç� ¹ ñ I9Ø K Þ ÿ K ¹ I9Ø � M òÛ É � É Ü � � ¹Ìô ¹ ñ ô � Ô Û ¹ � ò Ü Ô Û ¹ ñ � ò Ü õöö÷ Ô ¹ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ PvØ Ü ô Ô ¹ ñ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ ñ P¯Ø Ü ô Î� �ý �

ü Þ Þ ÿÔ P Þ Ô Þl�sÛyÜ}Ü ó ü ÉOý óü Þ É,ý ó

Ô Þ Ô Þl�sÛyÜ}Ü É ü É Ü ý óü Þ É Ü ý óÔ Þ Ô Þ�� ÛyÜBÜ É ÜÔ ÁLà�¤{Ü

C�Ö è ï±ï±ëHìõØ}Ú±Ö¤á�Ú è ×±îyÖ_Ñ ñ í è ÞBÙ è ÷GëÒÖ1Þ M P Û�� ç ß;Ú±ÙHá�Ú è ñ Ø�Ö�ÞkÕBÑyéÝÖ¶Þ}Ö�Õ}ÚVê��¶ÙÒ×GîcÑ ñïÀÑ�ßÂÖ�Þ}ÕdÑ ñ Û ç Þ}Ö�Õ}ê±ëqØ�Õ;ÙÒ×-Ø}Ú±Ö0Ö%ýVê è Ø}ÙÒÑy× ç� ¹ ñ I9Ø K Þ ÿ K ¹ I9Ø � M Ô P_ò Ü ÿ Û ÿ

¹Ùô ¹ ñ ô� Ô Û ¹ � ò Ü Ô Û ¹ ñ � ò Ü õöö÷ Ô ¹ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ PvØ Ü ô Ô ¹ ñ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ ñ P¯Ø Ü ô Î� �

�ü �� ÿ ý ó Ô òbP �`Ü ý ó ü É,ý ó

ü � ÉOý ó Ô � Ô òÈP �¢Ü}Ü É ü É Ü ý óü � É Ü ý ó Ô � Ô òGP �¢Ü}Ü É ÜÔ ÁLà �VÜ

{ ÑFß ç Ô !�� à Ü É M &É ���� É �� ! à É,ý ç Õ}Ñ�! É Ô !�� à Ü É M &

É ���� É �� ! É � à É,ý ç è ×GðÚGÖ%×±á�Ö ç

ü É,ý óü ! ÉOý ó

Ô ! Ô !�� à Ü}Ü É MÉ����� ¹ U�� Ô ¹ � U Ü`ä�ä�ä Ô�U � Ø � ò Ü�! � ó à É,ý

Û h64

Page 234: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

M ! ó àÉ É���

�� ¹ U�� Ô ¹ � U Ü ôÔ�U � Ø Ü ô Ô ¹ PvØ Ü ôÔ ¹ PvØ Ü ô ! à ý

M ! ó àÉ Ô ¹ PvØ Ü ô É���

�� ¹ U�� � ¹ � U

¹ PvØ � !àý Ô ÁLà��yÜ

Á!Ö2ûü×±Ö³Þ M ! � à Ô Ø}Ú±ÙÒÕ Þ7ÕBÚ±Ñyê±ëHð-÷¢Ö!êG×±ð±Ö%ÞBÕBØ}Ñ9Ñ�ð è Õ¥ð±ÙHÕBØ}ÙÒ×±á2Ø ñ Þ}Ñyé Ø}Ú±Ö³Þ¶ð±Ö�ûü×GÖ%ðè Õdá�ÑyÕ Õ³Pyò Ünà\òâÚ±Ö%× çü É,ý óü ! É,ý ó

Ô ! Ô !1� à ÜBÜ É M ü É,ý óü Þ É,ý ó

Ô Þ Ô Þ P à Ü}Ü ÉM Þ ó¦Ô P ò Ü É à É Ô ¹ PvØ Ü ô É���

�� ¹ U � � ¹ � U

¹ P¯Ø � Þ Ô P_ò Ü à ý

M Ô P_ò Ü É à É Ô ¹ P¯Ø Ü ô Ô !�� à Ü ó É����� ¹ U�� � ¹ � U

¹ PvØ � ÎÔ P_ò Ü à ý Ô !�� à Ü Ô ÁLà o ÜòâÚGÖ²ÕBê±é�ÙÒÕ��BêGÕBØ çÉ����� ¹ U�� � ¹ � U

¹ P«Ø � Ô P_ò Ü à ý � Ü � �� UU ñ � ! Ü à ý Ü M

É����� ¹ U�� � ¹ � U

¹ P¯Ø � Ô P ò Ü Î� Ü � �� UU ñ � ! Ü à ý Ü

MÉ� Ü � � !

Ü à ý Ü ÎÉ���� Ü � UU ñ � � ¹ U�� � ¹ � U¹ PvØ � Ô P ò Ü

MÉ����!àý Î

É� Ü �� � U ñU�� � ¹U ñ � � ¹ � U ñ¹ PvØ � Ô P ò Ü Ü

Û hp5

Page 235: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ô ÁLà 4 Ü{ ÑFß ç Ü � É Ü � M

Ü ((�� Ü ý �� ( É ( Ü (�� ÉOý Ü � ( M É (

(�� É,ý �� ( � É,ý �� (� ÉOý Ü � (�� Ü ý �� ( M É � É,ý É,ý Ü � ç Õ}Ñ�ߪÖî�Ö�Ø ç & É ��� É � ! à ý & É Ü �� É,ý É,ý Ü � É � ÜÉOý ó

� Ô P_ò Ü Ü àÂòâÚGÙÒÕdÚ è Õ è ÞBÑ9Ñ�Ø;Ñ ñ éLê±ëqØ�ÙHï±ëÒÙHá%ÙHØuìØ è ØÈ! Mºh ç Õ}Ñ7Ø�ÚGÙÒÕâÙÒÕ��BêGÕBØ ç

É���ó� ¹ U � ! à ý �ÉOý

� Ü � �� ¹ P U¹ P U P U ñ � � ¹ � U � U ñ

¹ PvØ � Ô P ò Ü � Ü M! ó à

ý óÉOý ó���

�� ¹U � Ø � !

àý É,ý ý ó� Ü � �

� ¹ P U Pvع P U PvØ P U ñ � � ¹ � U � U ñ � Ø

¹ PvØ � Ô P_ò Ü � Ü � ó M

Ô P_ò Ü ó ! ó à ý ó ÉOý ó����� ¹U � Ø � Ô P ò Ü ! à ý ÉOý ý ó� Ü � �

� ¹ P U P«ØU ñ � � ¹ � Ø � U � U ñ¹ PvØ � Ô P_ò Ü ÜÔ ÁLà 5 Ü

Á!Ö2ûü×±Ö U ñ ñ M ¹ PvصP U P U ñ ç Õ}Ñ U ñ M ¹ PvصP U P U ñ ñ ç îyÙHí�ÙH×±î çÔ P_ò Ü ó ! ó à ý ó ÉOý ó����� ¹U � Ø � Ô P ò Ü ! à ý Î

É,ý ó ý� Ü Ü � �� ¹ P¯ØµP U¹ P¯Ø�P U P U ñ ñ � � Û ¹ P U ñ ñ

¹ PvØ � Ô P ò Ü É,ý ó ý ý Ü Ü M! ó à

ý ó!Ô P ò Ü É É,ý ó����� ¹U � Ø � !

àý ÉOý ó ý � Ü � �

� ¹ PvصP UU ñ � � Û ¹ P U ñ

¹ PvØ � Ô P_ò Ü Ü Ô ÁLà�¿{ÜC�Ö,Ø�ÚVê±ÕdÑy÷GØ è ÙÒ× ç

ü É,ý óü ! ÉOý ó

Ô ! Ô !�� à Ü}Ü É M àÉ,ý ó¦Ô ¹ P¯Ø Ü ô ! ó0Ô !�� à Ü ó É,ý ó���

�� ¹U � Ø � ! à ý ÎÉ,ý ó ý

� Ü � �� ¹ PvØ P U

U ñ � � Û ¹ P U ñ¹ P¯Ø � Ô P ò Ü Ü Ô ÁLà ò h Ü

Û h ¿

Page 236: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

òâÚ±Ö�Þ}Ö ñ ÑyÞ}Ö ç Ø}Ú±Ö0á%ÑyêGï±ëÒÙH×±î=÷¢Ö�á%Ñyé¶Ö%Õ çõöö÷ Ô ¹ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ P«Ø Ü ô Ô ¹ ñ � Ø Ü ôÔ ¹ ñ P¯Ø Ü ô Ô P ò Ü ÿ Û ÿ

¹Ùô ¹ ñ ô� Ô Û ¹ � ò Ü Ô Û ¹ ñ � ò Ü Ô P ò Ü ó � É � É Ü Î� �

�ü �� ÿ Ô P ò Ü É � ó¦Ô ¹ P«Ø Ü ô ÉOý ó���

�� ¹U � Ø � ! à ý ÙÉ,ý ó ý

� Ü � �� ¹ P¯ØµP U

U ñ � � Û ¹ P U ñ¹ PvØ � Ô P ò Ü Ü Î

� ó!Ô P_ò Ü É Ü Ô ¹ ñ P¯Ø Ü ô É Ü� Ü Ü � �� ¹ ñU ñ ñ � � ¹ ñ � U ñ ñ

¹ ñ PvØ � � Ü Ü Ô P ò Ü Ü Ü M

Ô P_ò Ü ÿ Û ÿ¹Ìô ¹ ñ ô

� Ô Û ¹ � ò Ü Ô Û ¹ ñ � ò Ü Ô ¹ � Ø Ü ô Ô ¹ P¯Ø Ü ô Ô ¹ ñ � Ø Ü ô Ô ¹ ñ P¯Ø Ü ô Î� ��ü � É,ý ó���

�� ¹U � Ø � Ô P_ò Ü ÙÉOý ó ý � Ü � �

� ¹ P«Ø�P UU ñ � � Û ¹ P U ñ

¹ P¯Ø � Ô P ò Ü Ü ÎÉ Ü� Ü Ü � �

� ¹ ñU ñ ñ � � ¹ ñ � U ñ ñ¹ ñ PvØ � Ô P ò Ü Ü Ü � � Ü Ü � ó � ÿ Ô ÁLà ò6ò Ü

è ×±ðóÕBÑ7ÙÒ×{Ø�Ö�îyÞ è Ø}ÙÒ×±î=Ö2íyÖ�ÞBìVØ�Ú±ÙH×±î¤Ñ�êGØ;îyÙHí�Ö%Õ;ê±ÕâØ�Ú è Ø ç� ¹ ñ I9Ø K Þ ÿ K ¹ I9Ø � M Ô P_ò Ü ÿ Û ÿ

¹Ùô ¹ ñ ô� Ô Û ¹ � ò Ü Ô Û ¹ ñ � ò Ü Ô ¹ � Ø Ü ô Ô ¹ PvØ Ü ô Ô ¹ ñ � Ø Ü ô Ô ¹ ñ PvØ Ü ô ÎÉOý ó���

�� ¹U � Ø � Ô P ò Ü É,ý ó ý � Ü � �

� ¹ P¯Ø�P UU ñ � � Û ¹ P U ñ

¹ P¯Ø � Ô P_ò Ü Ü ÎÉ Ü� Ü Ü � �

� ¹6ñU ñ ñ � � ¹6ñ � U ñ ñ¹ ñ PvØ � Ô P_ò Ü Ü ÜU � U ñ ñ � Ø �! �� ò

Ô ÁLà ò ÛyÜC ÚGÙÒëÒÖ=á�ê±éL÷ÀÖ%ÞBÕ}Ñyé¶Ö ç Ø�Ú±ÙHÕ,Ö%ýVê è Ø}ÙÒÑy×�ÙÒÕ0ÞBÖ è ð±ÙHëHìúÖ�í è ëÒê è Ø�Ö�ð�êGÕ}ÙÒ×Gî#" � òG- d�" � ò�þ�ãs � à

Û ò h

Page 237: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

$ ç·Ê ìfçBí¬é¬§v¨ ä ­ Èà ò Ä dâà�ò è ×G×±Ö%×V÷ è êGé ç&% �(' ÁldRþ � è ÕBÖ%ð � ï±ï±Þ}Ñ è á�ÚLØ�ÑSsÂë è Õ}ÕBÙÒá è ë ' Ú è Õ}Ö+þ�â9ï è á�ÖÈÁ!Ö+þñ Ñ�Þ}é è Ø�ÙHÑy×±Õ�) ç ' Ú{ì9Õ�à�adÖ2í¢à�d Ô Õ}á�ÚGÖ%ð±ê±ëHÖ%ðúØ}Ñ è ï±ïÀÖ è ÞâÙH×+*�êG×±Ö ç Û h6h ÛyÜ2àÃ Û Ä dâàüò è ×±×±Ö�×V÷ è ê±é è ×±ð'dâà,*Gà�-dÖ%ëHëÒÖ%Þ ç *Gà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà �.-�/10 ç Û 5ph ¤ Ô Û hph ò Ü2àà ¤ Ä "�àGs è Þ}ÙHÑyëÒÙ ç dâà2*Gà -³Ö%ëHëÒÖ�Þ ç è ×±ð43=à � à5"óÑ�ëÒëÒÖ�Þ ç *Gà sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à -�/16 ç 5 � o �Ô ò ¿6¿ 4 Ü2àà � Ä âÀàRsÂÚ è ï±é è × ç � à�s¦à�7 è ÞBÞ}Ö2Ø}Ø ç è ×±ð�C�à�-²à�"øÙÒëÒëHÖ%Þ ç *GàesÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à 6�8 ç � h ÛÔ ò ¿ 4 o Ü2àà � Ä ùLà � Þ}Ñ�ð±ÙÒÖ�Þ ç ' à â9á�ÚGë è îyÚGÖ%áO` ç è ×±ð�ÁLàN�³ëÒëHéÝÑ ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à a;Ö�íÀà \ Ö�ØBØ&à:9<; ç h o � ò h òÔ Û h6h ò Ü2àà o Ä a0à \ à�C è ÞB×±Ñ9áO` è ×±ðJa²à�ÁLàÙa;êGØ�Ú ç ' Ú{ì�Õ}ÙHá è>= 6@? ç ò Ô ò ¿ 5�4 Ü2àà 4×Ä dâà,*Gà�-³Ö%ëHëÒÖ�Þ ç *Gà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�sÂÚ±Ö�éóàBAA ç Û o Û6� Ô ò ¿6¿��yÜnàÛ òpò

Page 238: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

à 5ÅÄ a0à � à ' êGëÒëÒÖ�× è ×Gð � à�a0àpd\ð±é¶Ñy×±ð±Õ ç *Gà ' ÚVì�Õ�à � " è Ø�Ú.àC7,Ö%×.à -D8 ç \ � 464 Ô ò ¿ 5 ò Ü2àà ¿ Ä s¦àB* è öFEù è ×±ð ' à � Þ}ê±é¶Ö%Þ ç *GàÌsÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à19 = ç Ûp¤6¤ h Ô ò ¿ 5 �yÜ,:Ùs¦àB* è öGEù ç:HJIKHJL à99 ç 4 o h ¤ Ô ò ¿ 565 Üà ò hÅÄ � à � àcâ�Ø�ê±á�ÚGÖ%÷±ÞBê�`VÚ±Ñ�í è ×±ðÚa²à � à�" è Þ}á�ê±Õ ç *Gà sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�A9 ç o h �6� Ô ò ¿6¿6¤yÜ2àà ò6ò Ä { à ò,à1" è ÙHØ�Þ è=è ×±ðJdâà2*GàÌ-dÖ%ëÒëHÖ%Þ ç ' ÚVì�Õ�à�a;Ö�íÀà � à 0@8 ç � 4 o ¤ Ô ò ¿p¿ o Ü2àà ò Û Ä "�à3 è�è Õ è ë è ÙÒ×GÖ%× è ×±ð+*Gà � ÙH×±×±Ö�ì ç ' ÚVì�Õ�à�a;Ö�íÀà \ Ö�ØBØ&à<;�M ç Ûp¤ 464 Ô ò ¿6¿p�{Ü2àà ò ¤ Ä ÁLà,"�à \ Ö%ÙqØ�×±Ö�Þ è ×±ð ' à,77à�C�Ñyëqì9×GÖ%Õ ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�a;Ö�íÀà \ Ö�Ø}Ø%à<;�A ç �p� Ô ò ¿6¿ 4 Ü2àà ò � Ä � àÌa è é è á�Ú è ×±ð±Þ è × è ×±ð+3=à,77à�3 è ì ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à:AA ç ¤ o �Å¿ Ô ò ¿6¿p¤{Ü2àà ò � Ä dâà \ à�â9ÙÒ÷ÀÖ%ÞhØG�Í�Í� ç *Gà�sÂÚGÖ%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à199 ç ��¤ 4p5 Ô ò ¿ 565 Ü2àà ò o Ä dâà \ à�â9ÙÒ÷ÀÖ%ÞhØG�Í�Í� è ×±ð � à � àB"óá$sÂÑ�ì ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à -�/B0 ç � o ¿ Ô ò ¿6¿ o Ü2àà ò 4×Ä a0à�d;à�CTì è Ø}Ø ç � ðGíÀà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à:;�M ç ÛŤ ò Ô ò ¿ 5 ¿{Ü2àà ò 5ÅÄ a0à�d;àFCTì è Ø}Ø ç s¦à$�uêG×±î ç è ×±ð_s¦à \ Ö ñ ÑyÞBÖ%ÕBØ}ÙÒÖ�Þ ç *Gà×sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�àN; 0 ç ¤p�X� 5 Ô ò ¿6¿{Û�Ü+:; 0 ç ¤p� 4p4 Ô ò ¿6¿{Û�Ü2àà ò ¿ Ä âÀà2"�à \ Ö%ðGÖ%Þ}é è × è ×±ðJa0à � àB" è Þ}á�ê±Õ ç *Gà�sÂÚGÖ%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à199 ç o ¤ ò Û Ô ò ¿ 565 Ünà

Û ò Û

Page 239: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

Ã Û hÅÄ âÀà2"�à \ Ö�ð±Ö%ÞBé è × ç â¢à,*Gà�3,ÙHï±ï¢Ö�×±ÕBØ}Ö%ÙH× ç è ×Gð¼a²à � à�" è ÞBá%ê±Õ ç sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à \ Ö�ØBØ&à-D816 ç 4 Ô ò ¿ 5p5 Ü2àÃ Û ò Ä a0à ò,à \ è ßâØ�Ñy× è ×±ðO"�à�â¢à�sÂÚ±ÙHëÒð ç "óÑ�ëOà ' Ú{ì9Õ�àPM1; ç ò 4 ¿6¿ Ô ò ¿ 4 ¿{Ü+: 8B8 ç 4ph ¿Ô ò ¿ 5 ò Ü2àà ÛyÛ Ä "�à2*Gà�Á è í�ÙÒÕ è ×±ð'dâà,*Gà�-dÖ%ëHëÒÖ%Þ ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à:; 0 ç ÛÅ� o Ô ò ¿ 5 ò Ü2àà Ûp¤ Ä ÁLà g è ÞBÖ%ëHëHì è ×±ðøò,àÌ� Ä Ö%Þ ç *Gà�sÂÚGÖ%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à<9 0 ç ¤ h65 Ô ò ¿ 5 o Ünàà ÛÅ� Ä � à2"�à`ù Ä ÑyÞ}ÙHÑ=ð±Ö � ëÒé¶Ö%ÙHð è ç *Gà ' ÚVì�Õ�àksÂÚ±Ö�éóàB99 ç o ò ¤6¿ Ô ò ¿ 5 �VÜ2àà Û6� Ä C�à�-?à1"óÙHëÒëHÖ%Þ ç � ð9í¢à�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à = 0 ç o ¿ Ô ò ¿ 4 �VÜ2àÃ Û o Ä d\ðGß è ÞBðøù!ØBØ&à�Q�R�S�TVU HXWZY\[]W SC^ H`_ SCa@b [ Udcfed^GU�s è éL÷GÞ}ÙÒðGîyÖ��d×±ÙHí�Ö%ÞBÕ}ÙHØuì ' Þ}Ö�Õ}Õ ç

{ Ö�ßhg Ñ�ÞÍ` ç { g ç ò ¿6¿6¤GàÃ Û 4×Ä -dÖ%ÞB÷¢Ö�ÞBØi7,ÑyëHð±ÕBØ}Ö%ÙÒ×`à@QjakS]U�U H`_ SCaClme _ R�S W@H`_ UKn\Û WBLpo LDq � ð±ðGÙÒÕ}Ñ�×_C�Ö%Õ}ëHÖ�ì ç a;Ö è ðcþÙH×±î ç " � ç ò ¿ 5ph àÃ Û 5ÅÄPr à���à � Þ}×±Ñ�ëÒð.àsltSCcXR@ed^uSCc H`_ SCaslvedcXR@T L UwTyxzQjakS]U�U H`_ SCa{lme _ R�S W@H`_ UKn�Û WBL(o LDq

â�ï±Þ}ÙH×±îyÖ%Þ�þ r Ö�Þ}ë è î ç { Ö�ßhg ÑyÞ�` ç { g ç ò ¿ 5 ¿Gà

Û ò ¤

Page 240: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

à Ûp¿ Ä * è éÝÖ�Õ dâà � è ìVûüÖ�ëÒð.àt|~}�S W cJ}�^ o�� T]a�}�c H T W n�� W��dW cJ��T L } _ c H T W cyT�� H ^>ed�Y ef�@e WBL e W cF|~}�S W c�}�^�lve _ R�S W@H`_ U2à�*C�yڱׯC ÙHëÒÖ�ìv�¬â���×±Õ ç �u×±á�à ç { Ö�ß�g��yÞÍ` ç{ g ç ò ¿p¿6¿Gà

à ¤ hÅÄ " è ÞBØ}ÙÒ×qs¦àG70ê9Ø Ä ß;ÙHëÒëHÖ%Þ%àZQ�R�S�TVU HXW QjakS]U�U H`_ SCa�S WBL |~}�S W cJ}�^ lve _ R�S W@H`_ U2àâ�ï±Þ}ÙH×±îyÖ%Þ�þ r Ö�Þ}ë è î ç { Ö�ßhg��yÞ�` ç { g ç ò ¿6¿ h à

à ¤ ò Ä C�à�-?à ' Þ}Ö%ÕBÕ ç âÀà � àGò®Ö%ê�`��yëÒÕ�`Vì ç C�à ò,à r Ö�ØBØ�Ö�Þ}ëÒÙH×±î ç � à ' à g ë è ×±×±Ö%Þhìyà@��}�^>ed� H`_ SCa� e _dH �@e�U HXW Qin�Û WBL o LDq s è éL÷±ÞBÙÒð±î�Öu�d×±ÙHí�Ö%ÞBÕ}ÙHØuì ' Þ}Ö�Õ}Õ ç { Ö2ßwg��yÞÍ` ç { g ç ò ¿p¿{Û9àà ¤{Û Ä � à2*Gà \ ÙHá�ÚVØ}Ö%×V÷ÀÖ%Þ}î è ×±ð � à,"�à � Õhß è ×±Ù ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�adÖ2íÀàÌd;à 0 ; ç �p¤{Ûp� Ô ò ¿6¿ 5 Ü2àà ¤6¤ Ä 7=àÌ- è ëÒëÒÖ�Þ ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à \ Ö�ØBØ&à � = // ç ¤p� Ô ò ¿6¿6�yÜ2àà ¤p� Ä *Gà±íC�y×t"øÙÒëÒá Ä Ö2ß;ÕÍ`VÙ ç 7=à�-²à g àÙÁ!ÙÒÖ�Þ}áO`VÕ}Ö�× è ×±ðøò,àÌ� Ä Ö%Þ ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�a;Ö�íÀà \ Ö2Ø}Ø%à<; 6 çÛ 5 ¿ h Ô ò ¿p¿ o Ü2àà ¤�� Ä 7=àüòâÕ è ê±Þ è ×±ð+*GàáC è ×±î ç ' Ú{ì9Õ�à�adÖ2í¢àÌdâà 0�8 ç � o � 4 Ô ò ¿6¿ o Ünàà ¤ o Ä *GàLÁ!Ö \ ê±á è ç � à,*Gà \ ÙÒá�Ú{Ø�Ö�×�÷ÀÖ%ÞBî è ×±ð�âÀàLadêGö1� ç ' ÚVì�Õ�àÅa;Ö�íÀà×dâà 0�- ç Û 5�4p4 Ô ò ¿6¿���Ü2àà ¤ 4×Ä ÁLà � àÌ- è Þ}é¶ÙÒ× ç ' Ú{ì9Õ�à�adÖ2í¢à � à 06 ç ÛŤ{Û Ô ò ¿6¿ 4 Ü2àà ¤ 5ÅÄ ÁLà � àÌ- è Þ}é¶ÙÒ× è ×±ð ' à { à ' Þ}ÙHá%Ö ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�adÖ2íÀà � à 8 A ç ò ¿6¤6¤ Ô ò ¿6¿p�VÜnà

Û ò �

Page 241: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

à ¤6¿ Ä C�àÌ- è Þ}ÕBÚ è ß è Þ}ð±Ú è × è ×±ð+7=à�â¢à � î è Þhß è ë ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�adÖ2í¢à � à 00 ç Û ò o � Ô ò ¿6¿ 4 Ünàà � hÅÄ�� à�sÂÚ è ��ì9ê è × è ×±ð�-²à { è ` è ékê±Þ è ç *GàÌsÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à -�/B6 ç Û6�p¿p¿ Ô ò ¿6¿ 4 Ü2àà � ò Ä a0àÌ-³êGÖ%÷±×±Ö�Þ è ×±ð'a²àB7,Þ è Ú è é ç ' ÚVì�Õ�à�a;Ö�íÀà � à 0 M ç � 5�4Åh Ô ò ¿6¿ o Ü2àà �VÛ Ä ÁLà�C è *9é è × ç � ×±×.à ' Ú{ì9Õ�à = M 6 ç Û h � Ô ò ¿6¿p�VÜnàà ��¤ Ä � à � à � êGá�Ú è á�Ú±Ö�×�`C� ç { à g à�â�Ø}Ö%ï è ×���í ç � à \ àG7,Þ}ÙÒîC�yÞ}Ö�×�`C� ç è ×±ð � à r à { Ö+þékê�`VÚ±ÙÒ× ç *Gà�sÂÚGÖ%éøà ' ÚVì�Õ�à --- ç ÛÅ� 4ph Ô ò ¿6¿6¿{Ünàà �6� Ä s¦à�s¦àfsÂÚVê è ×±î ç â¢à { à®òâÕ è ×Gî ç C�à�30ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö�Þ ç è ×±ðv-?à�s¦àesÂÚ è ×±î ç *GàRsÂÚ±Ö�éóà' Ú{ì�Õ%à -�/ A ç 565 ¤ o Ô ò ¿p¿ 5 Ü2àà �X� Ä s¦à�s¦àXsÂÚVê è ×Gî ç 3=à2*GàÅ-³ÙHîyîyÙH×±Õ ç -?à�s¦à g ê ç è ×±ðÂC�àC30ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö�Þ ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' ÚVì�Õ�à-- = ç 4ph ÛyÛ Ô Û h6h6h Ünàà � o Ä s¦à�s¦à�sÂÚVê è ×±î è ×±ð�C�à3,ëÒÖ%é¶ïÀÖ%Þ}Ö�Þ ç *GàÙsÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' ÚVì�Õ�à -- M ç � ò6ò o Ô Û h6h6h Ünàà � 4×Ä s¦à�s¦àfsÂÚVê è ×±î ç â¢à { à®òâÕ è ×Gî ç C�à�30ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö�Þ ç è ×±ðv-?à�s¦àesÂÚ è ×±î ç *GàRsÂÚ±Ö�éóà' Ú{ì�Õ%à -�/ A ç � 5 � Ô ò ¿6¿ 5 Ü2àà � 5ÅÄ { à�- è ëÒ÷ÀÖ%ÞBÕBØ è ðGØ ç ' à � Þ}Ö�á�Ú±ÙÒî�× è á ç *Gà � à � Ö%ÕBß;ÙHáO` ç è ×±ðZ"�àÙâ9Ú è ï±ÙÒÞ�� ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà' Ú{ì�Õ%à<9 8 ç ò 4ph Ô ò ¿ 5 o Ü2à

Û ò �

Page 242: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

à ��¿ Ä *Gà,"�à�-³ê9Ø�Õ���× ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à19 - ç Ûp¤6� 4 Ô ò ¿ 5 ¤{Ü2àà � hÅÄ *Gà,"�à�-³ê9Ø�Õ���× ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à1A 6 ç o 4 �yÛ Ô ò ¿p¿{ÛyÜ2àà � ò Ä 7=à�d;àÌd�ß;ÙH×±î ç *GàÌsÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�; - ç ¤ ò ��¤ Ô ò ¿ 4 ¿{Üà �yÛ Ä ÁLà�dâà�Cw���y× è ×±ðøò,à�-?àÌÁ!ê±×±×GÙÒ×±î ç *�Þ%à ç *GàÌsÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à:A9 ç ò ¤6� 5 Ô ò ¿6¿p¤{Ü2àà �p¤ Ä ò,à�-?à�Á!ê±×G×±ÙÒ×±î ç *�Þ%à ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à1A / ç ò h6h�4 Ô ò ¿ 5 ¿{Ü2àà �Å� Ä a0à � ài3,Ö%×±ð è ëÒë ç ò,à�-²à.Á!ê±×±×±ÙH×±î ç *�Þ%à ç è ×±ð a²à,*Gàf- è Þ}Þ}ÙHÕ��y× ç *GàfsÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' ÚVì�Õ�àA 6 ç o 4 ¿ o Ô ò ¿6¿{Û�Ü2àà �6� Ä a0à r às30ÞBÖ%é¶Õ ç { às" è ÞÍ`C��í�ÙÒá ç � à � à � ê±á�Ú è á�Ú±Ö�×�`C� ç è ×±ð â¢à { �yÞBð±Ú��yëHé ç *Gà

sÂÚGÖ%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à --D8 ç ò ÛÅ��¿ Ô Û h6h ò Ünàà � o Ä a0à�d;às"óÙHëÒëHÖ%Þ ç ÙÒ×ObcJ�d} _ cJ}���e�S WBLzY\[]W SC^ H`_ U�Tyx4�+e�S]�]a [�� T]} WBL lmT]a�e _ }�akSC�Q�T]^��Ba�e���e�U ç Ö%ð±ÙqØ�Ö�ðó÷{ì � àcC Ö�÷¢Ö�Þ Ô adÖ�ÙÒð±Ö�ë ç Á���Þ}ð±ÞBÖ%á�Ú{Ø ç ò ¿ 5�4 Ü ç ï.à ò ¤ ò àà � 4×Ä ' à � à � ë���áO` è ×Gð�a0à�dâà"øÙÒëÒëHÖ%Þ ç sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à \ Ö�Ø}Ø%à == 6 ç ¤ ò 4 Ô ò ¿6¿p�{Ü2àà � 5ÅÄ \ à ù!ê±ð±Öf� è ×±Õ ç 3=à { è êGØ è ç è ×GðVa0à�dâài"øÙÒëÒëHÖ%Þ ç *Gà.sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à -�/B0 ç ò h � ò hÔ ò ¿6¿ o Ü2àà �p¿ Ä � à�â9Ö%îyÖ2í è ×±ðJdâà2*GàÌ-dÖ%ëÒëHÖ%Þ ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à -- = ç � hph � Ô Û h6hph Ü2à

Û ò o

Page 243: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

à o hÅÄ *Gà \ àÌÁ!ê±×±Ú è é ç ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�a;Ö�íÀà 8�- ç 4 ò ¤ Ô ò ¿6¤yÛyÜ2àà o ò Ä *Gà � à � Ö%ÕBß;ÙHáO` è ×±ð�*GàB*C�yÞBØ}×±Ö%Þ ç � ðGíÀà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à 8 ; ç ¤ o ¤ Ô ò ¿ 5 ò Ü2àà o Û Ä { àÌ- è ëH÷¢Ö�Þ}ÕhØ è ðGØ ç â¢àÙâ9Ö%ÞB× è ç ùLàÙa{�y×±á%Ö�Þ�� ç è ×±ð 3=à�s¦à* è ×±ð è ç *GàÌsÂÚGÖ%éøà ' ÚVì�Õ�àA1; ç ¤p� ò Ô ò ¿6¿{ÛyÜnàà o ¤ Ä 7=à ò,à g Þ è Õ}Ö�Þ è ×±ð � à�â¢à ' ÙÒ×±Ö ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à19 0 ç Û6� h Û Ô ò ¿ 5 o Ü2àà o � Ä -²à�s¦àNsÂÚ è ×Gî ç g à2"�à ò è � ç C�à130ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö�Þ ç s¦à�-³Ö è ëÒÖ2ì ç è ×±ðt*Gà,"�à�-³êGØ}Õ��y× ç *Gà

sÂÚGÖ%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à<AA ç ¿6¤6¤ 4 Ô ò ¿6¿6¤{Ünàà o � Ä -²à�s¦à�sÂÚ è ×±î è ×±ð¼C�à30ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö�Þ ç sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à \ Ö�ØBØ&àBA9 ç ÛÅ��¿ 4 Ô ò ¿6¿6¤{Ünàà o6o Ä s¦à�s¦à�sÂÚ�ê è ×±î ç âÀà { à òâÕ è ×±î ç C�à�3,ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö%Þ ç è ×GðV-²à�s¦àusÂÚ è ×Gî ç *Gà ' ÚVì�Õ�à

sÂÚGÖ%éøà � à -�/¡- ç o 4ph Û Ô ò ¿6¿ 4 Ünàà o 4×Ä âÀà { àüòâÕ è ×±î ç s¦à�s¦à�sÂÚVê è ×Gî ç a²à@"��yëÒë èyè îyÚ è ÷ è ÷ è ç C�à3,ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö%Þ ç è ×GðJ-²à�s¦à

sÂÚ è ×±î ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à -�/10 ç �6¤ 5 � Ô ò ¿p¿ o Ü2àà o 5ÅÄ dâà,*Gà � �yÚ è á ç "�à�ÁLà�" è Þ}Õ}Ú è ëÒë ç è ×±ð¸a0à�dâà¡"óÙHëÒëHÖ%Þ ç *Gà sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à�A 6 ç o6o 5 òÔ ò ¿6¿{Û�Ü2àà o ¿ Ä s¦à � à ò èyè Ø¢�BÖ%Õ è ×±ðJâ¢à�a²à \ Ö£�y×±Ö ç *Gà�sÂÚGÖ%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à19A ç ¤ h Û Ô ò ¿ 565 Ünà

Û ò 4

Page 244: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

à 4phÅÄ � à�âÀà ' ÙÒ×±Ö ç *Gà<"��yëYà�â9ï¢Ö�á�Ø}Þ��yÕBá�à�9 = I ��¤6� Ô ò ¿ 56h Ü+: � à�â¢à ' ÙÒ×±Ö ç *GàNsÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' ÚVì�Õ�à-�/¡- ç ¤p�6�6� Ô ò ¿6¿p�VÜnàà 4 ò Ä s¦à�s¦àfsÂÚVê è ×±î ç â¢à { à®òâÕ è ×Gî ç C�à�30ëHÖ%é¶ï¢Ö�Þ}Ö�Þ ç è ×±ðv-?à�s¦àesÂÚ è ×±î ç *GàRsÂÚ±Ö�éóà' Ú{ì�Õ%à -�/ A ç � 5 � Ô ò ¿6¿ 5 Ü2àà 4 Û Ä g à2"�àüò è � è ×±ð¼C�à3,ëÒÖ�éÝïÀÖ%ÞBÖ%Þ ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à -�/¡- ç ò6ò Ûp¿ Ô ò ¿6¿p�{Ü2àà 4 ¤ Ä ÁLà ò,à � ×Gð±Ö%ÞBÕ}Ö%× ç â¢àkÁ è í�ÙHÕ ç è ×±ð¸ÁLà,*Gà { Ö�Õ}÷±ÙqØ}Ø ç *Gà�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à -�/B0 ç �6� 565Ô ò ¿6¿ o Ü2àà 4 � Ä ÁLà,*Gà { Ö�Õ}÷±ÙqØ}Ø ç g è Þ è ð è ì^Á!ÙÒÕ}á�ê±Õ}Õ�àBA1; ç ò Ô ò ¿6¿p�VÜnàà 4 � Ä ò,à�í è ×u"��yê±ÞBÙ ` è ×±ð=ò,à�-?à�Á!êG×±×±ÙÒ×Gî ç *�Þ�à ç *Gà6sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à -�/ ; ç ÛÅ�X� ò Ô ò ¿6¿ 4 Ü2àà 4 o Ä s¦à,"�à \ ��í�Öy����ì ç "�à�ÁLà_â9á�ÚVê±ðGÖ%Þ ç è ×±ð ÁLà2*Gà { Ö�Õ}÷±ÙqØ}Ø ç sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à \ Ö�ØBØ&à- = ; I ¤ 4 � Ô ò ¿ 5 o Ü+:�*Gà�sÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' ÚVì�Õ�à<9 0 ç � 5 ¿ h Ô ò ¿ 5 o Ü2àà 464×Ä�� à�â¢à�-³ê è ×Gî ç 3=à C�à5*�ê±áO`VÕ ç è ×±ðZa0à�dâà~"óÙÒëHëÒÖ%Þ ç *GàÈsÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' ÚVì�Õ�à¤9 0 ç o ¿ h �Ô ò ¿ 5 o Ü2àà 4p5ÅÄ s¦à,"�à \ ��íyÖy����ì è ×Gð�ÁLà,*Gà { Ö�Õ}÷±ÙqØ}Ø ç *GàÌsÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' Ú{ì9Õ�à:A - ç Û 4 ¿ h Ô ò ¿ 5 ¿{Ü2à

Û ò 5

Page 245: onp[]^*Yprojects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hellergroup/files/manny_tannenbaum_thesis.pdf · s u¼« qri ujil¤ q ehiluzenq engji uji ¤2i q2pj i sted sjuz pjpj mo ehm q2s q o pjg] kri

à 4 ¿ Ä � à¡"óá<�uëÒÞ���ì è ×±ð�ÁLà,*Gà { Ö%Õ}÷GÙHØ}Ø ç sÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à \ Ö2Ø}Ø&à - 9<; ç Û ò � Ô ò ¿6¿ ò Ü,:¡*Gà ò,àg è ÞBÞ}Ö�ëÒë ç *�Þ�à ç ùLàGâ9×±Ö�Ú ç � à{"óá��uëHÞ���ì ç � à�dâà{30×GÙÒîyÚ{Ø ç è ×GðºÁLà,*Gà { Ö%Õ}÷GÙHØ}Ø ç *GàsÂÚGÖ%éøà ' Ú{ì�Õ%à<A1; ç 4 ¿ o 4 Ô ò ¿6¿{ÛyÜnà

à 56hÅÄ s¦à,"�à \ ��íyÖf���Fì ç *Gà2"�àÌ-dêGØ�Õ��y× ç è ×GðJÁLà,*Gà { Ö%Õ}÷GÙHØ}Ø ç *GàÌsÂÚ±Ö�éóà ' Ú{ì�Õ%àBA1; ç 56h6h ¿Ô ò ¿6¿{Û�Ü2àà 5 ò Ä � àÌd\Þ}×±Ö�ÕBØ�Ù è ×Gð#*Gà,"�àÌ-³ê9Ø�Õ���× ç ' ÚVì�Õ�àNa;Ö�íÀà � à 0�- ç Ûp¤p¿ Ô ò ¿6¿���Ü2àà 5 Û Ä \ àdù!ê±ð±Öf� è ×±Õ ç ÁLàdù,ëHÕ��y× ç è ×±ðºa0à�dâà¤"óÙHëÒëÒÖ�Þ ç *GàbsÂÚ±Ö%éøà ' ÚVì�Õ�à -�/B0 ç 5 � ò �Ô ò ¿6¿ o Ü2àà 5 ¤ Ä "�à�ÁLà.â�á�Ú�êGð±Ö%Þ ç s¦à,"�à \ �Fí�Öy����ì ç a0à \ è Õ}á£�yë è ç è ×±ðQÁLà2*Gà { Ö%ÕB÷±ÙHØBØ ç *GàfsÂÚ±Ö�éóà' Ú{ì�Õ%à<AA ç �6¤p� o Ô ò ¿6¿6¤{Ünàà 5 � Ä *Gà \ à]"óáF- è ëÒÖ�à�lvT]a�e _ }�akSC�¥bN�@e _ cJ��TVU _ T�� [ à ' ÞBÖ%×{Ø�ÙHá%Ö+þE- è ëHë ç �dï±ï¢Ö�Þ@â è ð±ðGëÒÖ.a;ÙHíyÖ�Þ ç

{ * ç ò ¿6¿6¿9àà 5 � Ä *Gà,*Gà'â è `Vê±Þ è ÙOà lmT L ed� W |~}�S W cJ}�^ lve _ R�S W@H`_ UKn � e � H UVe L o LDq à � ð±ð±ÙHÕ��y×cþ

C�Ö%ÕBëÒÖ2ì ç adÖ è ð±ÙH×±î ç " � ç ò ¿6¿p�Gà

Û ò ¿