tion,

Co•• rul

accolllpU.h

00\ln801,

(198R),

at t 19At log

rocOIQmondGd

h.;r yonto

takon into acco\ant

....' ._. --.._1~_~

aublllto that .ft

,holf yoon.

long ter'" trottbumt

in.toneD.

1

fl

~,1 I

IN 'iUB CIRCUIT CO\IRT rOR T1Ui nl).-TIt J\lUICSk.l. CUtCtlJ1' ~ , OF rt,ORIOA,:IIH AltD ron 'lINJ.l.l.M~ C'O\lltT\' ,

!'J !'

, 8T~"f\ OF ,(pnIOA \

V. 'j)

DENNIS b. COHR .A '

.; 2' (\ '/ 3 3 '/1 u._.... __ ... /".:-.'

.. ,~ ,~ . ,:. . ~~ .' ,\

I) . '

; ~ OIlIlfPNft.. llIlQUL.O" .CQUIA~.•. JlIKQ .UUlt , .,.:

or....u'._.uL8U"QB..t~_Q.I..AJ).OlnMO .PI " ..I,V" " , t'~:U ....

~

­ l1L'.I1ttAOla ! ,"t>J ~" ~§ .l" •

'1 ." trrobY dubJlitd tlh'o l!u~"'()l'nn(hlJl for thp (:oUn.'9'~ 'flC010

in O(lnnoe~llon with gUnhHl(;'I'IQ. In f\n~tht:ll':Uw~ of tho lJQ,ltlA unclet'lV" I

1n9 tho s~~tC\ncinq Guidgl1,,~n. ,. 9;2) .00\ ~, ,,~(~ .• rlorlc13 Ot.nt\)t,~9 :1

l~ if' l\J>proprint-:)A to l.n(or_ thld CO\lttipf tha. t$.)(',~t~fW~ or 1""

factors "'h 1\,h "'" (" fIImt. " clov,,,,~ 1',l1.dQ",,lt ft. u" q f n)~ ""\~

oontono Inq t;l\nfJ~ of fO\J; I\hd ()nq~ht~ 1 f· \ n f I ,,: 8ti~., lHH~,;' Incnt~o<nt l~l. ' 0 I tI"nU nq rl't" 0 vII \ ell ''''0'.Tllo \KI

lncln<1~ Hr. Corr~3'O nlHtnAbSllly to n~IH.bl'ltA'".. ~

tho ,oubnt.nntlnliilkftlU10«) t.hAl n~hl1~ll)J~t:A\.'O'\ "lll b~A\JC" ~.

~nd th~ dCJtoncJat\t' II qctnutuq l'Q1IIIOtit ... i1J\'1 GtrQflg l.lIHi 11'0 ,'U) "

comploto' ....uU, ltutton.

p~rlodpr 'ncate'OfAllon or no ~(lt'9 tho\t\ tvo And Of\~" ~.

rollovod lIoY l'rolXlllon vlth 'M ••Ielf'" \>rovloh,n fo,'

nnd vh~th. l'eliUtut'on lJ1~p'{Jt'(}I;rl-4t9I"Jf1 thlli R· I

MoraovQr, any lIont~nl"JCt In e;cctutlj ,'( t.h~ loY find ot th.· .

. '\

:

~. ").

I

..

I

.... ­

"­~I'

'l

~ ~

(.

.

r.~I i

) , /~

.....

If , -.

•• .~I"," ,·

I .i

Tha t i1~t" q ~ v ~ mJ I" ~p. t. () t hp 'nf' nn.:l t lon ('J' tlt' AIJ~ I npt. MI-. !

) ~.

Corron ~y tha StAtn AI'''' n«t " 'HHlI"Cp. tlf t::<)I\t pnt I%~. HI'" ('<"In'c.;Ii' l~

Ch41'qod with flvo count" oJ 111';\1,,1 U\l~(f (~(~U1~\tt~'(U~,,,p'V"f!>en "l'l't(1X\'" ..n

'mntoly Octob@I' ')(', ",UH. AnI' ()t:tobDI" ;~. \,-PJ;1t"'" ViolAtlon ('f

Chaptor 012.cH", riot'ldA f.tAt\ltpP, Thl'O\lI.lHl\,t \~P nllU'A(I Or bl)th

,tho floa'leln I\.n'o 'nv('l~t Irlttl ll)n Alld thD P"'\PDt'\ID~' "\i~"hy hy ttl",

stato "ttol~:"ay'" orrleg. W1'OI\I:)(I"\"\(1 VA~ n~""lSt· ,1~t\,p(l f"'(" (;QVf!I'qc.J

~ {

\1P . tt0 t 0 ~ 1y h np Hr. COl" .. Q'~ c ()~, l ~ q r ~ ,. ~ (,1 f \) 1 l)t \II' t h ,,'v p g t 1fJ A t i I\fJ

!i

author 1t 1tH~l by, opcHll flq h' A l'p~ordp. hq 'n rAC' vo hlf\ton '1..,· n~p \f~f\e;ll 1

""yfro. tho ~~orldA lll\l" ~P"Ot1,.,tiot\ ,,, of \'~.~" i.

OctobGr 20, 199), ·Hr, Cor J

t·'

~ a vo 1'J'll31· l 1Y Ailf'lk C:' .~f\·{lctt (}3 '~J\ ,,' t I' tt\~

~! prODGCutora It d n 1q,,~(' t t:h\~ c;uu~, ~ n~ \'3flIHr,'.l\y . .,.fll1 I;O~.ll~to.l~· ~, I.

. ,

... 'I dotal1Qd t\ i A cr1mlnol ~OI~,hJ(,;l &\ ,,(1 h i ~ tl~p' I' q t. It); t;I t\J 11 r~tit: i tu"

tlon. ~1 ; i ~

In otni1cll'lq Ull to th~Jl~n('ln~J ch"r'rlq~ vlt!, At~~3(lr"p'. l.nRlAt.~I'(~f:l

on ,1.,tklnq r;o'otltutlon COT hla nlfHhl@dCi, Hr, CtU'f~~ ha~ fl~~fHl9tl'ate~i '~

hi. r81ftOr8~ fOl- tha br~3c', or tr\'iat "lnlt·@(l uJ)Otl hl~ ~ll~f\l~ lly '.\ls '.

:":. .".

actions. Hr. Co..ro~'C$ r~"·ot~g ·lft corrOl)(~rAt.'?d l)y ·.qr,lal 11~·31th.

.~'. :~ .~: . counaolol' Sar"h R. tl ..fttU;~Y, td.n.',vlt.h "ho" h~t~fj'~(ijh '1n tUHtt."

.:-, ."

•1"

Iftctnt .. ihca appro)(hsatolv ,JtU1\lary ot 19"2. "coJt t>( KR. ,fitA~l~y-g • ,R". I

Qurrlculu. vit3A 1~ GttAchftd hQr~ta 3. t~h'bll ~~: th~ ~"th~ht'citv

of tho Datandllnt'. fQaotaA h~tl MC!n ,-all't.l(=Jll.ly (1()':\lJl't'9hlQ:l.1 by l)t f

G.ra~d R. RoVtloldB, Ph.O., who,. (~l.lnicAl OY31\)~l!t..()n tJt Ht.' CorrOli . \.

'r.veala not only that thfttpefend8ntlo Ittwpor i.n.t~r: ''9 tJ~m.tt\§ 't~"f)l'Rtl :~.~. - .. :

bUt that hi" abllitv lei 'ccol'pll~h vletl .. r~At·.Jt'ttlt)n ~1_.1 ~111V 8 I'" •• ' ,

i·

(.

"','

'0:. i­f:;" ~.

, ;,

G.,.

. ,'. .;' . . -.: .'.:_. ~ . ~." _.: •.. ~." ;. - : -:.; . t~

8lqniflcnnt~nd th~I'npp\lt h.' rnlp '" h\A .. ~h~lq 1 it~t \(\ll.Qff'H·t.

Rayl'0 1(tA' .. ti A \J Jl Q \ A :t t t ~ ("1\ (J <1 h p ...0' .\ :\ ~ r:. 'I h i 1, ,t •\1 .,

0\1 r i nq .~l I II ') 0 )' P A I' ("" tip 1>11 ~ A ~ 111 l\ ,., \ C \ I \lJ a" r.~~ n P.)' I" 'h., r. t 0\ t Q

o C Flo .. I cI ~. Hr. Cor 1 Q.'\ f1.,~' IH1.) ., I P P\I' l\' \n" ;\ n" Ib1t II \ Q 1'co ct • ., :\ P ;\

h 1qhJ Y cOl~pn t. P IH J' ....\1., \' \I'~np r \ n 'he riP I I' "f Q ~I~}" l' 1:",,, \"'J ;\f\<1Q

~of

r . 1nva 0 t rnant C" 0 \ I/";C' I In') . r" h 1,. p.. • P n "l\ I 1 I r.,. H ,.' ( , .• 'I 1- P ~ h ~. p I"p P "

i j

mnrr Ipcl for )', 't'pi'll-n '0 hi Q ,'" I I dhe',"l PVC10t hC1~f; t, .hHl)' Ct" r"'~.

Toqft t h(u' t hoy h;\ Vp ,., I ft (1" t '00 " h i I '11 on, eh r \ Q' ""JU~.~ T 1"'\<1 C ,\r. p:\ And

Colby Corr~:\.

H~. J f

which vl11 :pnnblp h'~ t"(~ n:\lo

t:)( ftcut 1v g 0 r f 1C P I' 0 r .. I 1\ ~ 'H' \~ I r C).: \1 P: t n (' '. I ~Ir II I I) :\ " l\ ,ts n,t Hf .

t

•• Corrttn • A prob 1qr.eA . :\I\C) '/;~~ • nnnC3t. hC) 1~A a , l''" al"t~. Of) 'n C?J1".) 1 (l-" t. "0I

Dofon<Innt 't.o n~"l'kgt. t hC' c#r!l):\n)· i p Q~1"vi ("C'P ua \ f\~J h' s:a C'~t fltf::' f" ~f,n"'t"J

f)oxportlgg. r t

tho corpotn to chack 1nt' n(.~r(}\.'"t.. ,,~ v l 11 Fl~ r ~" Or ",11 ~y A.\(l Or. ,

Roynoldn, H,". HcGovRn vl11 h.q pr~A~t\t :\t t"h~ "~"'.~tl~:'n... Jlc~tln~ ,"cj ,,\

I>or".onttlly "tt.~,.t t.n hf" c:01l~ltna,,'' t.<l fir. C-':~]'~'"'' ~,,;(t t;C:J aJlrlt.. ~@tg

~Jq\loationn or· conagrnn or tho Co.\,rl. i

Hr. 'Corra" h",* 3190 ho.~n orr~rCJfl tho OJllH,t{un-tty t,Ll vb':k '11th

~~y;~..)~:~::~ .. . ,.ceo

, . :', . .:?:.:=.1~~ti'::ti~;fiJ .. .:...;.c";; ~- >....

, . .. .' .~ 1)

hovoxor. hOJll""" to dcw()t,~ " P\ll\lltAnt\Al ~t.,rt lm,j"f hi" lfl\~N'I.~ to

• • ·1

.,Y lot 1. raot Wtl\Jt ion. .j

j

noc",aui, t·h~ C(l\srl v, \:) hc:Ji\1 r r"n t hC' n\'Il~"O\,j~ l "~l 'v i cl\J~) fj V)ll' ,f t) ,I .­

wlllh to nJ\Ct1tk on HI', ("(\I'~~A'P l"ph~\f ;\t 'ho t' rt~ C~ r q~t\t. C:S"(~ 't\~J • ! i

ru r t h tH' .@ 1nbo I' 1\ t 1() 1\ 1n t 0 ;l h cs 1\" t \J" I' ;H\CI I' !Ii ( 1'''( \{\f )4 r. ('<.n' t cs l\ • P

8upport natvork '1I\I\AC~t,\~t;t"n' thp ,,,;~I~h\t;tin \n 1'(\t\tP!l(( ;&PJr.<ll, ..ncluIl . . '!

1\ COlllp ~ 1n t lon (' f 1pt t P. I'll f 1'(\1\ HI', C m'l p" 'fa P\I' ')l.ll , tJr ~ 1\3 Fl b~t;"\

RUbmlt't@d uncleu' PPJ14u·"tcs ("(wAr, ",'"ultflnp o\lAl)' W"~'!th'~ "¢'''(~1·3tl(hu., "

Horo p'·AAA' ''l(1 1R t .\() ,,~p{l ,() P 1il'"t:) H1". Cnt' .. ~~' Q .Q' t· \J.,t IQt' ,., ll\~ (: J.

contoxt or 'rhft In" Aft it. l~ar':\'''f:I te.) ~J-)~'ll(·:\' '()'\\{If ttl" ~~f,t~f\.~l,,'"

'"

Q\11tlo11ngg.i:{ rll~ (11~c\IRA'I)" v',l(~l, f(l11nv~ ,~. th,., .. ~rC)t·p. '.".~nd@,l

to <}1 va th ~~ C.O\lrt "n cn:p \ l C.·"t l dtl or t ha C'~~P 1 :\,w f~(HH:~I"t\\t,,-~ "'IHM' ·i

.1tlgntlnq :-jclrC\JIlAt"'l(~~A _.~"r'·#lnt. (l4!~l~rt\.. '·.., r1"()",.IJlC -:J\J'd~' ,.·,.A..., '.\

~I 1 ..

II r·I

~~ In nn or fOl"t to nt~"~~V~ a· tJr41;J t.~.. (l~fJl·q~ .(;~l"~ 1~t ~"{~'Y atl(l.

.. 'I falrn@t\o in th" rumt@fH;sn" .lJ'(H:OA9 t.hl' oll'lhn" t,

..ontenclnq (J\lldftpno~ \lO~~ 'Jl.~~~1tpM.~d In lh~ (.;\11 (,r ~"J1~ 1:19f.1L ;' \

.~

:. '1 '

) •101, .. 1~ . R Cr 1*' .•". ,,~~;. A r t_ 1(·.\1·1 At q.l'] l'\ t.Jlq. /. t. J;.t; t;)p.~ .,t. ()f ~"t r Ili')[:iPt[

~,.

4'auation o~ thQ gU'd~l'nqOl

.. ~ , ..

JThCl ptJrpotl" -or "C!'lt~no 1nrl q\J ltlCJ 11 "@~ if) t.{) ~~t Ab·ll ~l\ ft un I',r'ora Ret of atatttJArdl tt> (j\J Idf) t.hfl _Of'lon~.'n9 'ti{l~e in tho .onlQ',CO {1.·pl.l(jn~.3klntl "rocfl"". T1\;; (f\•.Itle I t n~R ~ roproo.nt' A .ynt"~.lfl Of ~jrt.l\t· .Qn~~il~~'~hq ')~Alt.'.-lcjeB

,- . thro,~qhout tho at8.t~o, s"ntflIlU.. I.f19 flU It1~ 11 he_ .8f @ l·ntofl.~l"J to 01 ' ..lnatO un"arl'~ntf!d VAt 1at Ion In t .... 8f.ttlt@ttOI-ttq proe••• by tad\)dlntj thQ faUb·jeotlvlt.y l . In\i~'-J)tAtlng ilp-Go'l flo of tonlo ... r.t,,':@tl Bm1 Ofr@tlll~t iOWt~. t.'~tll}.I1 cf It@l' J.3 antJ 1n dotlni.n9 thoir "013t'V4 l_pntt3nCtl I~.n ~·"4 ~~'lt9·h-~~ in-t) dCloJnloh. "1.'

, . ': , ~ ..

Rul. J.10l(b). rltt.R.Ctl.,P. g"Gl)l~t) nJ_ana.Jl,.,,~\...Jita~t.l MH go.~d

~;~.: ­ -512 '(rlao 1990) (Q.\lo..tt!n~ ~n.t.fLt!YJt."_Q.(_'t1ltlna1.~~l(:~~~!JX4L.L~,tfit..,-ntt:.'.'";; . >}l.. '.',: .. :",

-,t -.. ­

~~i-· ~:~:. -'~ }~~~ ..

t<.~

-, l·. ...

~'... r * ;. ~ . ~~'.:. .. ".;;.~' ~ ~... .. .-: ..-: .. w ". ... ,"'•• - .... ': • ,!'''''"~.I~~'d~:j~~ L

.f

.. , f'

"'~Hl\ilted

1989,);

of ,

• ~'I .

"n\}..

.. • ·r 1rnL.G.\l1.d.el1.n~DJ, '" ~ ~{\. )~l n.II, 1'1. r,) I r 1A . \<>1I1II.t . ,

tho 9Uldal1r~" 'H~ not \ntt~IH"~d h' ~l.ln'n~\o "ullc:,' A I ,t"l~H'rp.t.hH' in !

thG .ontone ~hcJ. prOCCHHI , "~OI\(J U\O Alloc',nCA")" p..l\Ut~i~tp.il " .. 'tH"~ .1 t.~

I P

plaa Of:'hOdldt' in the! q"id~l\"~p '9 tho tonet thA? . I

. Wh\ It'} 'hft 9~mta"~\f\cl (J\)\dollncHl At"P <1c'''':~'I..JI\P<' \.' tIt'f)

u,,~ '\lC'('~ ,,, thn RQ"tq,hc~ncJ i)~~lAln" ~t\iJ ~tp~, ,t '"U~hll"cJ °to ""\lfp '"d\c'~l cJ\~c .. ~t lon, c10J'Art\tl'e~ ftl l' th" JH'p.~

numpt.l VC! rumtC?'nc;o9 ""t.:"h 1 'f:iholl \ f\ th~ lJ\I l(l~ I (- .(,)~ ph~) 1 bp I\rtlr:u13t.fSl1 In ''' .. It \nQ "nil "0)(1,,s vh~" f'fH'~~.~'~tH.,~ra Of' f M:tofn rp."l!Ion~hly '\lAt \ r.,. t h~ AC~IJl.·:"":\t' I~n \)lJ: ta I t 'qAt' oh

ror tha Au"te!nco. Thp. I (,)VI;t 1 ~'r Jlrl'W'r n,,1I~IH1Q;\")' to ,",pt Ah 1 hah B dftpl\rt\lr~ fro:) A ~~nt.'ml·O Im()PI th~ (J\ lhl~\ ll\p[t \" • preponderanoe or the eVldenae. "

Rula ).'101011)("), n",n,l."r\~.l·.~ thQ 11\J\f'plll\aA~l,p('Hil":\llrl'l'Q­~'I

vido for dg~nrtun~ "'hnll thar;, ~nd~t "'·lrnmqt."tH"~~ 01' f;\C\"'I'R th,H

rOlUlon;\hly !

\1\1£1t lry MJ 'fl·" .... '" "HJ ..". I\\t "l~t ''''J tha PQl\tOtll'O" ria: " .

R, Cr hL I'., :11 • 101 (cl) ( \ \ ). i

I ' ,t''~!" 'dt.ho\lc~h th~' f .. :\nen~:! of 'h~ <ll1iflqlit\ap v~tt:l ,·~t·af."l tH'''' to

~ plneo llt.\lt.ntlonn 0/\ t.h~ ~.M·torp. J'rop~rlY ("(m~'I~I'ar) in ~"hl~l'Qf\, 'j or .<JIlr. VA tl on of .' .Antft ,);.. tho 'I" I dft 1 I nAR .In ,M'".. In ,-". I'f nv ,,,"

thot "(r)onRon" fol' flQv'A~lln(, frc")'~ th'.? q"'d~11tla,, ph~l) hrH: l"olu(1eJ: .,',

faotoro ro13tluq to I'flort.hrr p ptR "'Uhou' r:otWlr.ti\lntl ()t" \.hq "H:at~f\f,

offGn80A '-Of \

hAVA n{lJ ')'~on O~tht.3'n~d," ..,,1 __ ' :~

• ).101(d) 0:'" r13.ft.Cr''''.'', t'l'~ cO"~'f$,~hH' V;U~ r:<\l'g"\ll t"l ~t\,h",u"

lnto, hO"'Q\/or. th~t lI(o)ther r30t.(H'£*. con~lRt"",l qfH) f\M In .::mltJ..l~l

vi~h tho atot••Ant of '''''jl'O"0 • ",y·l,.. ".na I dot"" t<' IIUII,.·,1 by thA .'

.............. :Ill ,_~.~ • .., ...... ;,~.'h ..,.. t.

'Priol' to tho 11)911 A.uHHln.(!nl,*. t.h~ f*l:\ndlil,l4'<t( Pl'l"Q[ tot dop~rturlt Ito. thg 9uld(tl1f1l!H~ 'VaR ·c.~3r 1U":~1 totWIrttHfirJ;' ·.s.Yl~ d*noti. tn ~Un-Y..L...D..t.~tJ", 54~ no.~d iH trlB, 1st u.e.A. thO Firdt Circuit Court. or App.gl}l lhHil3ltr@" Hu! eoft~tit\itiol1!tlity ot. t"o roduetlon in tho ot3n(lAfd or proor lQ ~.. Jlr~~"t),~jP.tAtl(;~ evldonc.o. . ~ .

. ! ~! .~

,,:,

L ~; , \

I I

(". ~I'

1:

~ ~

(.

•

" l: ~.r

If

... ---- ..... , .. _._~-.... ""'.--""--"~"""-'-"-"'~------...

etl1 {:

c"'AU \ 1;\ P~ ('" IInt IS '* «(') (\ )) '\ ~

(190"0 AIlU'uH\l'pntn). ;:

It 1" ~qA 1n"t. to.h \ A rl~i'DaV(')"~ t,h~l t h~ r 1{,,, if'tA '~.~(Ir' 9 h~\:"~ I"., e;t '\

I

grnl~p 1 i nCJ t,~) (1\1 r i tl~ t he) I'~ r t\rt~ t ~ .. P (l r .,

l

tone 1nq . flop Stale. v. 111~'h.le.l:. .. A 11 r:n. ;,,,, ~,;, <.t \.:\. \t.) 11(.) (not' 1\'-'

thnto n 1nc~ t.he? l all llP'U!ll\t <'\ t \ on (l r u,p IJ\ll dp 1 'ncsp •.~hP (\ va .1 ~ ~{ r l("t

,co\Jrtn hnd eo,,~ to ctlAJHH.:\ta \~(')n.:h'R\(lI\A (lVCI' vhtfhor~" \1'~n\'I'~l

r 0 t\ .0" r 0 ,. (l~ 1):1 l' t \& r A 'n .. (" 1P " .. :\ n() (" {, f' '.' \ 1\ (. , h f J -, ~)~ T" ~ ~ t ~ " ,~ "p ,V f:' "

"tho.o which hap csl;lPl'llpd III the ":\00 l~v \Q th<\t~ nit h'Rt ion c)f 01 1 ;,

roc0 am00(1 a c[ n@ " t. .., r, (" ~ 1~ '" ~ I' t i\" t e,1 v I, c;a f\ t r (ll' ~ 'J b ric t)" II f ,. ~;.\ ~ (~t\ ~ ,

tho doron(OI~ll I)og~n no (u't "1"0 t '\1 ~~t '(l ntl(O \~')'. n~~ r~.'" ~)iap,'lg ;.{

5t.At.Q..._V'~~.:;'1h.a, '; H. [:0. 1 (1 "n (rll). 1? A It) ((lQ f ~fl(l~ t\' ' Q C' <",,1m:' 1~ \tV",

"" ,lin tllolnt(\('~ lnc1dpl\', th~Jtc;) 'p n(~· r'Jt,\a ..'~ th1"e;t:lt tel Qfl(·\~t';) l U~.~~~

,~

;

~.~.:: ~J...Q.t..bjtQ, ~)(. no ..}tl l';(. ~i·lA. 111 n.(".~. \'"nn) (pibm'j rUlt..'V~"Oh \0 r·

~ rahAbl11 tnt 10n nnd ~)(ca 11 ~" t. I't' o~..." h 11't 't' (l r .. qhMi .1 \t at \ <Jtl :\,' fs *311d " f.

baool1 r01· <lo,,',v,'\ ,-(1 tlft1,n ,- ,- (1'r~); 3 ta t-Q. _Y. ,l\.e'ga~l. ~. " r;().',l \;l Of) (t 1 it , , ffi

". ~d 0, C. A. 19')0) C(IAf'~ndAt,fl (1 \(1 ~,ot COf'~t' t \ltq :\' tot,t~~t t.·l) ~()·t~lQ'.,V r··rl ~~ \ ,

"I';

~ .... I,whero ttlO P;\,~t lC\J 11\'" l" r~'\Jnt1tAt'(~c:)Q of t'l~ ('I' ll\p ~no I 'f)f3t.RC\ t:',i;!

1ova 1 0 f t h1) 'db f cmdtt nt. '" II'" It ..,.. ~()r RICH Jp~ It ill ij),): .'Pl.'JL'i..•..$I.:~t.t ~ , e

h44180,2<1 lO'11, iO'ln (rl:t. 1?1)(~V1d~~~~ or f'~R01·"~ h-~ytH'o.P~1·.1V '0'

bo confllf.lftt"o(1 In alllqAtlon of ft~''lt"net:l).

r~nht\p(l b4J<M.\UU! t~JlAh It H,3U on ho l,lei 'h1~ ):~.,. tp, I 'niUt U1Y ",

lIoclCttlctA' pr.ot.Qtltlon IHI"lnrtt. cl'hHnAl rt:l(~lrH\'&~, " ,.'~rQh(jtlnt'~ .~. - t ('

aMonablllty to ffthobUltet.loh hi 3*\-on"1 t.h'" .(l~t.. .I"'9.Q,'MlllY a'",lhm..

Iated r03g0n. tor (tOYnv"ttt (1oY i ~t.l()fl ft01l A f ~C(}1l.~~~IQ-d itqhl9fiC~.

~

1110 tlor hln Suptt!l'Ift court rtalint ly ..-.phAtiI' #.~.;) 1\,,:'~~ lQt)Or:l.~n(~~ of

. .

" . ~ ~ . ....~...

1;~ ... ~:::

• 1,," ~

': '.";', ~ ~~ ~:':~~~ "J' . . Ii

t •

, . J '* . :·1:I. ~., .­~j~~;..~c:~., "'~

\i I "eJ

to. rQhAhl 1 Hl\tjann ~" the:! rr~~\tC'''t \Y~(.~HC'd 'hH'lt*'on.

O'.r,tln.....Y_" ..•s.tate, ~()b !lo. 1d I~ ~ n (r lol'. 1t;J9 0). tn. Itt1,\,n. th~ \. r';\)

1\ldqo d~p ..\l"t"d (rol!S the:! (U'C'AUftpt tv,. 9csi,tp'\l"'\fJ ~:~"'JP .,r "P.tV€\~"

throQ "nd 01'\'n-h31f ;\",1 ro'lIr """I otlp-h"lr YP:\IP ,U"';\f'·PtOllt.lo'l ;\n{\ . ",

}It. ~\

one yonr of lia'ol'nt lnn, C1HnlJ nilt~ela V. Glate, t',(),; rhl.;>(} .. \ (rln. ,i 1••" . I J ~ 1

1987),' tho ~rl"\ '\Il!'lP At~\Pfa{lPcI lIPt'ri"'h ~ ro'P 1\:\" I r~.j t. y t e' t'" P n t n..,,,t , '"I ) i

no avldanc4:!<l b)' hlA v()h"'lf~ry PIlT'ollnpnt In. '''·1' I n'. ~·"'I"'''"

Uet',rl0, 'H.n Hn, )C' ;'\t ')) I. l!

. f: OnAo(1 on:-. ,~:-.rr(lV r""til,,,.nf n.ilthera. thIS !!'er~t:'Il}lA"'H'\ CO\lt·\' .~

or Apl')(~nl lqnorCld t.h" trlnl "IIIIJt"" rt",1\neJ with '!PQ:H cl to ;\tIoP.fHl~

bill t Y t.o n~tlt1 hi 1 it 0\ Ion ""I' r p ..·eH AP(} , rCln,,~ "~~ AC' 1",1)' 01' t hp j I

8ubatnncC1 n~mAP 'HlllCH~t.A of Ua:.r.lH!,ra. t.hp ,1lpl,r\C"t, nnll'( d~t~I"I.""~(1 I.

thAt lnto)(l'~=:-.tl()f1 nr ~\Ih"~:\I\';c:l :\"\,~e can Ius c:l~~1" :,,,,1 cf",wlnr.nflf" '"

,!

roAoon Cor ~ov~vnrd

cnAO In n.a,J:~~t,f), thq fl~(p.'i~l"nt. I" lnt,()lCif~3t.~" nt .thl" t th~ U,*" e"'-e, }

I'

~1'~, WAll COllII' 1ttCld. • {"

~ Dac.H\un~ thq lhH.lond 0 lA~lr lcH. Court of "PilAt' 1~'~ At r '('l 1h':p.r~lJ'q .. ·1 hUon of DU~J:a conflICI~" vlth tMt of atho' 'I~t. Id COut':., tho

suprQllo court Accapt~d )\J~l~dkt'on tfl ha.!'r the J~;HIC. 'hi.,t~J..n. S(jO

. t

:: ','1 ~ "

So.2d nt 921. ni()nlflc~,it&y, tllp court 9t.~t~(1 ~,HhO\Il. hC;l~lt~t,hjn U·

i te un", 111i~ n(,nenn to ho) el th3l ~\,b&t3h~q 3b\J~q (~3n only v'Ut'8'l~ :f

._...;t:=-'_.-........:..... ·~I." ....;..

.'

, ,

!. ~:-~ ; .'/t:: ": ~

. , .~.. :.~.~. :" i-·I~\~i euL, \, .. :. ·,:, ~;

.'W.: .

7

4

lllal

ant1. t.llt! .

tll' "itt

eij{i• j~

dopa.ft\,ro l n ')'

t hOlla eft gO~ 1.' wh i eh t-h4'1' ~ l A 1\" 'tll'3 ,tI,_ J\pf\t. ~ \ It,~ '- l"~

tho crimI' \ ~ 'COlSJ:l it t ~d . Jn )«H~.l\ I\<Jv \t h t h~ \JU' ,~f~ 1 \ "p.~ ''''<hH'')'' t'tt;J

wh' \·h ~l\J 1(1 J'l)rn \ t ,1()vnvA "tl rlcf,\;\ ,:. t \)1 ~ 'n aVPI' \' • :'. ,

enaCt of drug A 1coho 1 "~'d \ ct ion, tt"V~"'DI, '~~rtllt uron . \.hp. 't' I ~)01'

1udgo ' fJ r l,,(Iln(J of <'t-\Iq "tll'\ct l('l' cO"'llPc' wlt~lK; ;.\"~t\a"\ '·.t).. t()

j-.t:"rohRbll}tat.lo'l, . t.hp ('O\lrt

rbI' pm'pOAtH\ or (~U, rhd ",,;tf2 d~'l;"" t U.- ~9 • • }/.. ~ el'" r d.f'·· dnnt I II D\JllRtnflca "l.)\a~~ ~\,pt. ,~ C.·(\f\p '(l~,"o(l tJ}.J~~"f.?" vitl\ tll" 0 r I'a r "l!"!UJ nnI)' 1 1t.)' -t 0 ,. es f,., l",' 1 , t. ~ t \ n 1\. . . . t W 1~ Jl'" I ,1 tho t d\)bnOta n(~C! n t)\.f:'~ • At. And' nIl ., 1()"Q, . (~:\ nl'\'~l'. \ \IA t i r \' ;\ dQpart~tr@. Tl'ftr~ ~\,q.t ~ 1,*'.l l"a p\ f \ ",.1 \ ".~ 1'~~.~(1 "I-'(.)t, C:(la"

pot.ontMA\JllAtt\nllal ~"l<1P"(.~~ t.J\at 'r tll~ fl~rq'i\(l#tnt.' ~ A~n·

toJ'C 0 ;.~ a r ~ lJu~~ (I 1nor (1 ~ .. t () t1~.r n 1 t. 'r ~ "t '"An' f () .. t. tl~ {'ftpon(l~"11Y, lhaa·C} l R ~ t'~3"on~lll D Jl(lPP' 1"·\ 't. '" t t\~\ ~'.rll, t l' e " t m* nt 1 ,,1 1 1 he (UH~(: ~ 12tH \J'1 .

• j

110J:1:10, 560;?!]O.2C) nt·,

.. . , thnt fphnl)L 1" At.lc)l' vi' 1 '>4 ~\JC!(+t.'f!,* .'\J I) .

(:

ta, Ilorl·"" n cnBO, tIt. Cf,)~ltt. (~()'lcJu{l"'ll t.llA': '-Jl~ ~\ll(l~t,.~g '139 , j. ~

~ "J r,

suf f Ie lont to A\JPCl'0r t. th~' ..@d\)~(!d A~t\t~fU~t1, • Th~. r at;t. that. Itlt!£l'. n

had ftbDt"l~luS froll (h',a<jA for it Jl4Sl'Io(') or tloCJ. ro)hlVh"-,t1.h lnp,liH . ­

porlod or ~l\tf\tftl·Y tr@~t.qnl v#.\!' fJ.C1te"·~t.l' J:i\.. ffirlC?"'- ~"'fl@tl-l"'g tj( tJ'e

potent1"l tor r@I,,,Illlltiit'on. lJ.~1;.tln, 141A n·f) ~/l ~t ~)',

.. furth~r b~linq t.ie{ln'~l!ot:~'~\@ 'hh~trOittf.\ont \1313 gQ\lflhlVap. fO\ltV-J .

eonolu.lon. UI..t.t.ln, ~(,O 60. ;Z~1 "t ~2:r. .~.. , { Ao 1n IlJtxAn, Hr. Corroft' fJ f\·.~~f\,,')i 11 t Y l<) ·1t@A\.,,~~~t

.\ .: Itrongth ot hid <Jo." I t.-ent, to" t@hab"lll tAt l(lO ~f '\ ~viICJ~'l-efl(l

voluntary ..ubldth,lon to counlllJJ InfJ pt hn t.o t.h~~ '!n-r.'!?l~tiur; 'ot ·UU~

1 . . . f

:r:~;· .~': ....: 01 2 •

. . .'.. .

i~,i~'~'~':7cj;;~ ·J.t i, ;, ". .;,:~ ;:.; "\i • :..'-8:.-_.

~ . 1~: .

.} :•'~l ·

criminal ~ n,t hy hlR cnnt· Il\uo,' {~)=-l't 'ft'l~~' "'f'

thG~"PY t.hl~O"tlh t h~ l'l'pgt·tnt (,:\~". tiPP ,,1 "(' rl aBtel. t. 1 (\ !~n. )(1 At . ~

574 (dC'lr(lrH~~"lt·II vo l\1nt ",;~, Ia \1 h'tl \ pg 1 (\Il h\ ,"'\lllllp p, fl'J pr 1,'1r ,~, 9~f"·

tanclnq .,,,.Ii w, \1 lnclnnAn i,n I'\~rt \c '5\~t" 1 n t r":t'l n.".,t '~1 f~\Jr~n ~f·p ! t-

COt' : 4) n .." 1 1 n t. t p p t t n h I q (' 0 J' n \ t n p r, t t" , " II t I 1\ \I jl tIP" t ,tp.1\ t f' 1\f :) R

10 nq nu np C CUl ~ :\ r )' t 0 I'll"< . oJ" l' 1 , ~ h (. (\ 'tIl\ 1~ t a f' P h ~ l' I ~l t :\ t ItH'

" ~ t hO\HJh t hn t 1(11' llt:l !illPI nna ('Olll t j'.I pa .. I f\ .' ~ ~i~~' ,te t p, 13 lilac) tiM,(.

o Xptn' t t c:)Sl t \ \IIOIlY lla flO t ,\n e P f:llQ" I)" t" 1Q \I .'lH', t ~ (ll""~ I,.. ,) "f Ol n'a 1\:\ '\ ill·

t Y tor ~ h n b I 1 It :\ tinn. IIer 1 1:11. ~, (, n !~ () . ; II :\ t .~)). t ~ 'p C"') rt "p ~H) f\n t

r a 1y 0 )( C 1 \IT l v pI}' 0 n HI. C () IrQ I'l • R t:t c:>l r · j'.I co I v \ I\IJ t t;' pI e P .,. n t It t jon p , "

!

nn 0)( t ft nd ~ # p g r 1()(1 C) r t 1na I !i~ I" :\1, 1\1· ., 11 1I))' v \ 1 1 ~ .. , P R t t f) t h «3 , 1~ f @.., .. . ~ 1

, J'

lthn t rgh ~ h.\ 1 1t. A" \btl c:., n l~.f,t rl ,.~ 1\111) I \ ~ h :" v \ t h l" tl r'l., I mac-I' t h·... ~ VY.: 0".

Raynoldn wl11 tgll t.hg Cc'\llJlrt '.h~t Hr. C·O .... D;l lQ ~\nt. ('tnl, c"~l*H·hH\C-· f·

, . • I i

1nq roact IV~ c)@llt:ClPfq or~ of c 1 \ n I COl I Q "J" I r '~r\(·e. 1'\lt. t h~t hI:?

<f o\lf farn f ron A IlorAonn 11 ~y (" pt"lr(l a r . n~~od UllQ", (3:£' aht1' \'~ J\A)'''.~.',O''''

, .• .. • I \I

;

r r"loqlc4\ 1 tnnt lnfJ n"f.1 Qvn f\lnt ion n1', "~i·'lo)r'Ja v L , l Ol\l"~ , h~" w'lth t,

U· lonq-torC!' .. trant.llt\nt. "I'~ Cor"~A viII .~ ~hl~ t.r, n~~'.\;~ Jllc;t r~~()v­

. ~

Qry." ..

:n::::::::tc~C:ll:ll(::3""l:csOl .1A rQ;u1l1y i\7,i.c>nrlhlc t~' n~h~h' &Hl\Utfrr ""

::. t·

Althouqh lLor.IJ..n dg~lt. w1th llrufj ",Mklloh. ~ t;utt.or h-6t tl-1'@R9'll » '

1n tho CliSO 8t .bar, th~ (~t)\lrtl' of t.hl0 C*l~'·.~ ~~··~.o f'~r-«)l",n'~~ .t.hAt. a

If.1

., ' ..

.~ .

1uotlfy ml,,1Ql\t.l()n of AP,~tQncp vl\~t\ ("('\ar~lpc' vltt," anct\3hlllt'v ".i' , r.hllbl11t~t~on. 5.nlth v. :'~_la~e, 0;1) !In .•h1 o;n (rl4i. '.1 ('.eA. '·.HUq: ·

s.t.a~o....Y_t. ,1)(e1Yes. H, 1 !hl. ,}:~l • ~ 1 1.1 (l, C , A I '.11'" I; ·(1 r. ~"'Alef rl ". h'"

Y...._A.l~~.~ll"e.t. ")') \ :~o. J<1 \ <lJ Q (r 1~, ,(\ P. C . 11, '1'j~~) (It \ At 1n"J\\1' ~,\, nCJ

\ i

tlielYo 8 0 n CJ t" O\J ntl t:' t. h:\ t :\ n p" :t." , 1 \ t \' 't' t r (2 ~ t It C) n '.:: ~j J2 r\c,t es41,a \ ... :\ 1~ n'

to Bhow l nq i\ '* t: r onr-l not I ... ", Lon r ,'.' ,ph:\ t\ \ 1 \ t l\ \ \ (~\-l t h ~~al$_ ..\;",f

Ilte.l.Y.eQ, " (, 1 li (l • ) (1 " f) l (r 1:\, 1 r1 ('l, C . A . 1 .) n~,). r f\ I , tl g' :\ Uf.· ~ • 'h~

\ll)on g)(pnrt~': av '(l~ncp 'hnt t he (lOr~l\(l;'\n' QU( rClc·41 (rC\:I J'(\Jit T1·:t\)ft~t; lc­

St rODR n1Rihrfl~ r wh leh w:\ a :\ ftc n:\ h' a , <) UP=- t "PH t by fh,,~ 'Itn:\ t· ~cl

O\ltrQI\(:l, pt(){lri\nR. Tl,~ ("'~l\lt't \f;\A P~l'Q\I~"c(l fUI'iJ,o" ..-(\tlc~r·t'IJ\q th~ , )

:! do f ondll n t • A pot q n t 1", f t)r.;~,.r o'Sh:t h \,1 \ t ~ t ~"n h}' \ he "1:-r R t. \ nl\",,; n e; .~'lf~'.l(.I"' (I-om rn1D11y, fr 'anilA :\.\(1 'rnlll(.) .... Q .. ~. tn 'h~ ,ng~Ant t.'3~~, t.ho fi\f.~t_

, 'n ' thnt Hr. CQrrft3 hn" th" 0rrc,nvhtl.!n,nq AUN'lot't I)f .'\R f~.Il~'. frh!tHtn

an(1 potan t lAl ca'v 1oyq r A (1... «lI~ u.,· ctlh" n-CC31!! h'" ~iot..:Sf,t i A t. tn· l~~lf!()"~ -) h

Cully rahnb,lll t"ltu1. rJ~~ 1pI: tc"" r4"bn it t cHI' 'JWW" Ae$}.. ra' ~ .!O\,l~f:

Tl1Cl ~)(Q.l~YRQ ('~C, 9 'on va ~ A\II~~~f·J'I~"t.1Y r~~ \ t, ~~.1 v, t t\ :tl'l1r()'(A 1 lty

tho 8tlcon(f plntr let Court ot AllP~A I l" ~ (;t\A~ • n \Ill \ch tl,~ ·clpf~f\.~13hl

raco 1vad R n 1t 1qll tOfl "9"\ eflc~ ror ':(lnV' (~t 'nh~ 0" 1 ~ Cf}\.J',l 9 ()f

I' 8endinfJ thraatonlnq lQt~Qr" Mid tour '~{)\JJ\t:" or t~f~3l~hi;\~ h#U. to

II pUbllc, lIftrVftht b;ttt~d upon thq t.nAI C~)\JI.t,'~ n,fVlI."~ t,h\\t hi,*

aotion. ""ora ..()t'v3t~d I)"f '~t, ~.trA1\~ q~l)'~"(}n;\\ {()h(l't.'I.I)n'".•

aaltb. 5)2 so.2d At ~). I n Af r 'l~'" nq lhC!! ·f.ltilfnXtl'''.' (l~I)At tu."\!, '~h~

.~ 'The atJo of t..h~ dot 'ant ,,~U ~180 bqttn ·h~·l·,.) to ~ ~ ·• .ltlq"t.. .lnq

fao·tor whon, by vlrt'lo () age, t.hlQ (iJlr4·r..~J~nt I~ ... t)()/)f!') (!~~n<Jle:i8te fof rClhablll·tatl()n. j).l,At..,t...· .•~~ltOI.' ..ll4; ~~~ t$-9,ll.1 4~. (rIA. ~th D·.el-A; 19a8).

iO.

t'. t-.· '. _..'r:'. ." - _ *

____~v - ~.. ~ .- - . . ..__r_ ------..---.~~-....

• It . · \ .

l~ It

d~,Dtrlct ~~O\.rt (.)l)"orv,,('~tl\l\t the) ~V't'Of\(i" (~~'''C4:t1 tl'"'J -t.h~ ~1~fOtl(1"1\l·p

'. ~~. UiO'i<Jho~otiOnl\tbl' lnt~llp.(~h~Al IH"t~ )u12tHl,," ""("'l\thHl' P.\'P.t\ 'j

j:! it ntoPJ)@~ "hort of chu~qf\l!Jt":\Uf\q \.H.·onl'C2t.C3tlC D

',\.

'. ~ ntntad by~}t"Q (llAt'-let ~(\\.rt:

i '.~ 1)1' in,,;u\Jty. J.d, Aft ; ','

Slta' th f A I'Hln' Rhp~nt ~. \ R . . . 'n \'0 tJ;\\)rJf)ff'\), . ~\tf'll

a3t t.C'llin All h' n d~n~ll"·o\)P"~~(.l, t t\1) l' t\fl' J,~" ,Nt <'f r~(: I,d' •o

v 1A~, the ..~t \11' 1 h",l~" r'o,,~, rtn(' t. h~ l'H.,~,P'" \ , t \' ttlA t I" P b~I\"vlolt vt\g inf l\1pnr",l ,'\' r~ ..t(~rA ''(It. l't 'tip))' v\t..l'\I' " 'A cOt,t i· C) 1 . . ~

~ froq\JO.lt 1~ clt.C:'(l 'n P\IJlJlt\I" (l( <1ov:"v~.. (l c.l"'l ..~rt\a."'t;t ip :t fl~r~n(lat\t. f p

~i

{Jaf\\) 1no I'~~or rJ~ • rOl' CC'"P t l t u t h)l\:t \ t Q;l AO"~. 1 ;\c}c 0 r t "'n01 PP c"l\I~ot

con8tlt.ut~ n .vnl1cl "~AA(ln f<.l" ~'" lJ,J)v:tr,l flql'~rt~\,Jl'~ rt(l~ t-'l~ 'J\Jl(l~-, ., .

11noo. Ih"~rt r~ 1t "~=ot'g~; on '-h~ l~:\n llf t hp IJ""fr;~v,~"t- i§-:l,Y. hov~V~t·. ... .

proparly l)(t co"O'c_1~1·~(1 .,,* n l1it. 'f'~" Itv(J r~(7t.'.)r. "~~ta.te .. Y.~. Ji.A.J;J\$l. ~2~ \i' ..

SO.~d at ~1: l~QPe:__ -v._~.. '-u~r,-e. HI r~o.':c) ;It_ IO·F(·(~lhV .-::o'Wit'lch,rl

ovldunco of t'o~orOQ tsny tOIHHIJr,y b~ cot"llcl,?,''''t' ,,, *,lth'3t.lc);\ ot tho

8ontQnco): f.tt_Q._t.t~-y_... _UPl(ft~,il. 'j'11 00. }cl 10.09 (n:J. ) "t U. C,... A, · \ 9',)l.) ,..; r~r.

"', 1 n tt,o 1nn t. ftnt ~'"a~, H,·. (~o .. r@A vi 11 Al~q:,lij' ~l~ I""t: onilll V of III @

\

I • ". .~i

~UI flHH){ of hh

t)r. Neynoida'• <'

b)· tho ltu:it 'l\onv:{,r \:1·~.Attln~' ~@nl!\l

~lll ~h~r~ ~llh l~.

t-r.;tfQi,\'A tt~'tngnl

In Ul~rttpy ~,~ :r"uttt Und~l'l'Vlflfl

t.

Dol.ly on tha 1)9f~ndaflt~'A PO If ~ftfl1'V' n'1 tupt hH)~•. 'I

rOlllor.o. Hr. Corr'-n'g ~jr-o"·-l)rrJe ,,, etJrrC)l)(lt·~':~·J;· tty '.'

: ~ . ••plrlca 1 f Ind lnfJ" ft8 vo U IU~, .! ;~.. ~: w· ~.

hoslth counnolor. SAfah br~dloy. H~. br~dl~y

Court tho btoal( th·rourlh vhl(.~h o<obtted 1ft"".

"hon 'ho wa•. tlnally ttblo ~o rovt:t-.tl

Ji " . .,r..~

~t • J '."., ,:~

, I •

• .,~.-_. "..: ..-_._-:-._-----_.__.•.._'_._._~'~

.. , , .

.~

Ii ~

c r 1.1 ~31 ellA '·C}Q" f (l~' '1,,1 eh Ill' n<.'v r" ,:~ A "~,, t ~ "(~ l nu . 0.,1)1' '\Of,.J .. ."

tho n~f'"nd"n\ "h \ P to ht;hJ \" '- n,'~ .. \ ¥ It h "ta n.m\'(ltl U "nt 0\11 H I· ',"

1: "n(1 t'oJ!\or~a . wh 'eh h:\lt, \1 hPl' ~ t. n f \11' p , \i~ i IJh~d ~f4.: hP.o1 v, \ \' ,},~on h' n .

:~.. I

:! ,.

I ~ '; / II t i·

o 1C:l v 'ncJ vo hlllt "l' , 1Y ;.. III U nr~\ll t:*h",,1 h' A \ l ," Al~r 'n l't ~.~t. h'p. 1BY •

Hr, Con''''n P01UUH1 n(l r \It. \11 r P. t h ,. P 3 t 'n A C)(~ , p.' ),', :~r. C (t .. t,.,3 ~'\'Wf=(.!'"

ntnn, .hovovp.r, t.hA of U\p (~rfaI\PP \{h~f'h ha hO\p <:·W~·:l:ll'th:Hl -l"\PUl'lmIPt\A.AR

ftnd ack now 1Ad(,p.~ t h:\ l n pP. t '1....1 0 f \ Ill":\ f' c a, ~, '(t;' ~ ~ f" t. I Iv., • 1Hl{:onl"

Inqly, thn ('c,fg"t'~ {1(lPR rH'·,! A~O~ ttl ~v()'{I. l,,('1:\.'·'~c;l'·;'t'. \"fl. 'l~'.h@t.

it i" g\Jll~lt.t:q(l t.t,,,t n fl'a,·~~ .. t\.I'P ~pnt.c"I"a in t.1)o t~"Q~ of tV(\ at\{l !.i ".'

ono-hn 1r Y·~~ 1'"0 l A ",lrt' OJ'll' , t't t ~ \In,l~l~ t'hp c l r (:,.".~ t A t\(::p~ "'t r 'h' 9 C;\Ae. I

Horcrovor. ;l:lnv. "'P"t.QIH;~ '" C'JiI~~t$j:I of ,. hAt vh' dl 'Q .. a.(~\.~At~tl \to\! ld .j

oorvo no ,:~gn:tl)lo Jl\ll'llO~~ nt'h~,' t.Jl~n t,(.l J.t.~~p )~f\ ~)(~iiJ\l~ ()f tf\i.a ; . } ,

dofandant. .I.:

:~.! •

Wh 11 fJ ., b9VgrQ ~@I't. ~n(~q (~~n Jl~nd ~ tl . 1\l~ 1) I q ft~~ PAqq t 4' :.:. doolcrty "'han t\Ch'l~.hl@t~J In ·tetl~ prolHH' c;(Jfltp.d, ~.lAt~n(!~ oft.hq

:: '..~:

co.po111 O<J n 1t,! 'fa t l "<1 r +Ic t. or't' 'n ttl q .,~ AP. #\ t. b=t r Coun~ ~ 1 ·~q;\ \ j",-t " i . 1, h

8uch l\~t 10n. \

a.an3bl Q ~,o rol1ot) 11 ,tnt' on :\f"1 At.. ri)"q ly ~..t' v~t..f?{l tC:l Ach i e\i~ ~.'I! ,'; , .

co.plQ.Qn~3~Y flO,,11) of t.()t..Bl i~ql13tlll't.3tlt}f\ ~hd cf~nI119l~ Vietl. " . c.J .

r ••tltutlofl, Thct OUb~t&tntlBl llk~llhO{)fl thM. lIl.b~f~h&13f\t. Will 1>9 ~ ;~.~ .. '.-':... "

8ucca•• 'ul i'\ hid gffotth to A(1c'oi.qllllj}) toh~l")l~:· '.101i 18 ',llijst:rtt~~l··.... ,.'. :'. -.' "='t" • • r :~:< .

@d by hiD, (IOnulno rcu~or.e A",ft by Ills' Alt<H\il c~O~)tJ~;4"l to V.tthtl­.~f:":

• I

'''7' .

pa.tlon in tt ttGfttJ\ont tJI}';Ilnll._ b·ott, ttl'. t~)rr@~'~ t.r·~ftll''''(j MiJf\t··A.i

hoalth oounoo lor. '~1. ~~Yd1t.1O!J ~ At. ~DAf8h .nf3d.i ey. 3fitlevt) ru;,u.l n~-: .Ut '.

aera'ld RtJynOlt.lta; 89t9@ tbal • 'lrl~on t~t_ Itl ~MC··1a9 of {h-at ·Pt~I·@dri ' ­~

.;

I

• to.'t.frr ".: f'

l • V

.,

f\

.....

. by tho dafCHHH1 w(.l\lhl, at.;· ~~l ,llt:\l")' ancl, At '"'nAt e\)'.~~t ..nt."n\'

~ hn.po I', t ha ult, n:\\ Q IJo~:l c\ f r CSh3 h t 1I t ..~ t 'I'''. 'f) WH t:1U: rotH:.;. IlJ\d", r \ h~ IliH \ 1nil a,' " II e\l",I:I' II ",'eoy ., f t h 'Ill (':\ '*". t. h p

Oof~ndl\nt 1~'nY"A t IMt t h I ~ {"()\In v, 11 nHcsr'111~' "'\I\~ ',ItI'· O\Q '''Ii' l.".

oy to bi) p~l''9antad 0\ t t h., ho", 1 1") I"''' tl e'VoJlho t "£ I OJ Q 1. :\",I hllp(\~" f:

(\ lD 1t 1q:\ t o,\11~ nn\ .me tI 0 f hw "nd c.'n" - h .. l( r Q of)' a In,'a 1'('",·:\t , f'n ,.1

roll o"'Qd b~ pr 0"<1 \ 10" w l..~ h t h" RppC If I C J't (lV II! ~."" r "1 I (\nc,J _ h:a" n .

o 'i) . ~ c1 n)' ct r ~l \' ft f! t"~ r. \ (OJ '.J , •

~,'" ~•. ; .# ". 0". I ) .' ;

'\·, .....~1~h )~\, \., r-i\(l(~l' ]I

t~ i,A';Q,' .A. "tr~., Ii,' 'Ii·ito11'J-Jir,c.....­0 ••

0')~ R :t (1 A It n, J.Il 1 \". J~. A . ,•J' <7 u,', t t glt.. ,. '=" ~ , !;\Ilt~ r (" 1~ ;\ .. V i\ t p r. ~., 0 l' , (1 A

'I P" l () t" '(l~ n:\ I' ., (1 . (l ., R , ~ fl 1 (All) 4'J",ofJu~

:[

~, f, .~

·.f . ~, lr:{ t' t

I, f:~' .iI

~: :. r

.:#­

~~...f'.

'

f'·'·'\

.' ,i~Jlt,X\t¥i'}f~:"i: ·,,·,S .". i ttff "±ris' '0

• " . i' .~ I

'I"

\ ': .­

' .. ; C-"lflCAI.I, ...01... e.•'I.CI

I In:R~)'i Cf:RT'nV th~t a tnH~ ar~l {lOII'At't (~n.i." nr. t.he. f,)r~q()l"Q haa baan ffu·ni.h"d. by h,,'HI. ttl Rl1t\tffT I.nflt1. j:tlQtH.Hi. -"llftSlitant Stato AtlQJi1'UY. f) 100 \ 44tr,,\ AVQn\lR "o.. t.h., C\O;\r'-·~t ~r., r,l,c;'1# Ida ,.t.,,,. on thlo -~~-,1~L dOly or Hovr(;t.t\bcll'. lQ01, (. f "~"" ' ..

I • .( I ( I " , ,~~j\I.I' ~~j ~/{~~ ~;'~_,._ ......

Q

!lh:nrn ,.. '''"' tin( . , 'I'

11 ).

)1 l~ t,

J.!

J.4

i:

. "~Ik: . .~ . " .

:. ....•.,~ :. '. .

• ',r:l' e

" " " .' ~. .. . ~~

•

...~

-fl ~ :

H UC\l(l'l\iU\( (oh\l\('1 ChMlt'\ n. Ad.lit. t .\,~. Hr. ~~ Mr. Arthur E. if\dmlr\' ~ :~Ir~. [)()n)tl\)··,~I. ,.\llll\lr(' ,: al" ~Ir. Rt)tlCrt I'. ~"')Rl(' ~..~ Mr~. I!t'th !J<>)"th (~P ~tr. \"111 \\. lk~'~' 7) rr'll(lrl\~'~ \\'. (~i~"'~>', F\<l lii rt' 8) ~15. '\'lll,\ 1\. ('i~r'\Ol\

Q

9) ~Ir .•\,\(1 ~'r \, l\('u t)('ll ("'ar \flll

10) ~ 1r. (),(k I).l i1c~ I

11) ..\I\x~rt J. I:crr·aro. Sr. 12) ~trs. Ide' ~t. rt'rra.:{) l.J) ~tr. Ntc tlol~, \ rrrr~, rf) '.\ 1·$) ~tr. lC{ll\. J='Jtlt'" f:

"1..) ~ ,... I\.r t.llll r I). II ,1.1 (~ 1 ) ~ts, '11,(! Ill'.1 'ti I'.R11' ''-1111"'1\ 1;) Captain Richardt. Holly 1~ ), Ell" I), 11~111f'll, {).ll.S. 1,')) ~·fr. Ita'11\C)·I.l. 11\1\\ .

It)) ~Ii. 1.~\llc s. ~;l)'lor 2'·) ~1,r. Jotll1 (J., ~~.""I\C)· l2) ~frs,; S\JC S. KI*~k.1lt~f·

2.J) K)' M. I(och. M~qulr{'. 1~I) Da\'ld J\. ttl' 4~lk. If..\(l utrt' 25) ~tr. IICI(!r ~. lero~

lfl) f\1r. alic" ~f r\ ' J, ~fi(~ 11 acl R·l~.II11fl'l(J .• rl 27) f\lr., 1)111111' J. ()"er~ \:. {:

I

28) ~fJ·. Sln.ntaf' :~. Slll.itll. }­

j

29) ~Is. Syl\'I~\ ("). StCllllC.'l~()I\ ~. r0) ~tr. Jolln 1~tll1P\()t\

•

.': 1) ~bf t:>orolJl)t It ry.'ht t)1~ 2) ~lr. tfllf)'lmS ~f. \Vallcr~ 3.3) ~tr. nrld ~lt" Ray \Vcbllef 34) David ~,. 2'~~lt()(kl. O,t),s.

.- ,Ii' 'J

.~ ~ .. ! , '"

'." t