7/26/2019 macasaet

1/3

[G. R. No. 156747. February 23, 2005]

ALLEN A. MACASAET, NC!LAS ". #$%AN!, %R., a&' ALFE L!REN(!, )e*+*+o&er, -.

TE /E!/LE !F TE /L//NES a&' %!SELT! TRNA, re)o&'e&*.

FACTS

Ta* o& or abou* *e 13* 'ay o %uy, 16 +& #ueo& C+*y, /++))+&e, *e a+'

aue' ALFE L!REN(!, ou8&+*, ALLEN MACASAET, )ub+er, NC!LAS #$%AN!

%R., 8a&a9+&9 e'+*or, R!GER :. /ARA%ES, e'+*or, re)e*+-ey o Aba&*e a &e;)a)er

o 9e&era +rua*+o& +& *e /++))+&e, a&' %!RAN CASTLL!, o&)+r+&9,

o&e'era*+&9 *o9e*er a&' 8u*uay e)+&9 o&e a&o*er, ;+* e-+'e&* +&*e&* o

e TRNA a.=.a. T!T!

TRNA *o )ub+ a*re', '+o&or, '+re'+* a&' o&*e8)* a&' r+'+ue, '+', *e&

a&' *ere ;+uy, u&a;uy a&' eo&+ouy a&' 8a++ouy ;r+*e, )ub+, e

7/26/2019 macasaet

2/3

pa ba, dahil sa kakulitan mo% )ilit mo kaming binubuyo na sabihin kay Tito Al"e na

tulungan ka rin tulad ng tulong na ibinibigay ni Tito Al"e na pag#aalaga sa amin.

)ero hate na hate ka nga ni Tito Al"e dahil sa masamang ugali, natatandaan mo pa

ba yun $aya tiyak ko na imbento mo lang ang lahat ng pinagsasabi mo para

makaganti ka kay Tito Al"e, ani Jordan sa mga nag#interbyu sa kanyang legitimate

writers.

Hindi na siguro namin kailangan pang dagdagan ang mga sinabi ng sinasabi ni Toto

Trinidad na mga barkada niya at kapwa niya kuno !iberty Boys%*

*ereby )ub+y +8)u*+&9 a r+8e, -+e or 'ee*, rea or +8a9+&ary or a& a*,

o8++o&, o&'+*+o&, *a*u or +ru8*a&e a&' au+&9 +& -+e; o *e+r )ub+a*+o&,

'+re'+* a&' o&*e8)* u)o& *e )ero& o a+' %!SELT! MAGALLANES TRNA

a.=.a. %!E> TRNA a.=.a. T!T! TRNA, *o + 'a8a9e a&' )re@u'+e.

!& 12 Se)*e8ber 17, )e*+*+o&er e' a Mo*+o& *o +8+ *e +be ae o& *e

9rou&' *a* *e *r+a our* '+' &o* a-e @ur+'+*+o& o-er *e oBe&e ar9e'.

Aor'+&9 *o )e*+*+o&er, a *e +&or8a*+o& '+oe *a* *e re+'e&e o )r+-a*e

re)o&'e&* ;a +& Mar+=+&a, *e RTC o #ueo& C+*y '+' &o* a-e @ur+'+*+o& o-er

*e ae )urua&* *o Ar*+e 360 o *e Re-+e' /e&a Co'e, *o ;+*

Te r+8+&a a&' +-+ a*+o& or 'a8a9e +& ae o ;r+**e& 'ea8a*+o& a

)ro-+'e' or +& *+ a)*er, a be e' +8u*a&eouy or e)ara*ey ;+* *e

Cour* o F+r* &*a&e o *e )ro-+&e or +*y ;ere *e +beou ar*+e + )r+&*e'

a&' r* )ub+e' or ;ere a&y o *e oBe&'e' )ar*+e a*uay re+'e a* *e *+8e

o *e o88++o& o *e oBe&e

& + !))o+*+o& *o *e Mo*+o& *o +8+ 'a*e' 23 Se)*e8ber 17,[] *e )ub+

)roeu*or ar9ue' *a* *e RTC, #ueo& C+*y, a' @ur+'+*+o& o-er *e ae. e

8a+&*a+&e' *a* 'ur+&9 *e *+8e 8a*er+a *o *+ ae, )r+-a*e re)o&'e&* )r+-a*e

o8)a+&a&* beo;D ;a a re+'e&* o bo* 2 Ma*+&o S*. or&er Mau8a&ay S*.,

S+=a*u&a "+a9e, #ueo& C+*y a&' are& S*., /a+)ara&, S*o. N+o, Mar+=+&a, Me*ro

Ma&+a, a o;& +& + Re)yAH'a-+* o 11 !*ober 16 e' 'ur+&9 *e

)re+8+&ary +&-e*+9a*+o& o *e ae.

SS$E F TE RTC !F #$E(!N CT> AS %$RSCT!N

R$LNG

& r+8+&a a*+o&, +* + a u&'a8e&*a rue *a* -e&ue + @ur+'+*+o&a. Tu, *e)ae ;ere *e r+8e ;a o88+**e' 'e*er8+&e &o* o&y *e -e&ue o *e a*+o&

bu* + a& ee&*+a ee8e&* o @ur+'+*+o&.[35] & *e ae o $y -. Cour* o A))ea

a&' /eo)e o *e /++))+&e,[36] *+ Cour* a' *e oa+o& *o e

7/26/2019 macasaet

3/3

+&9re'+e&* *oo= )ae ;+*+& *e *err+*or+a @ur+'+*+o& o *e our*. Terr+*or+a

@ur+'+*+o& +& r+8+&a ae + *e *err+*ory ;ere *e our* a @ur+'+*+o& *o *a=e

o9&+a&e or *o *ry *e oBe&e ae9e'y o88+**e' *ere+& by *e aue'. Tu,

+* a&&o* *a=e @ur+'+*+o& o-er a )ero& ar9e' ;+* a& oBe&e ae9e'y

o88+**e' ou*+'e o *a* +8+*e' *err+*ory. Fur*er8ore, *e @ur+'+*+o& o a our*

o-er *e r+8+&a ae + 'e*er8+&e' by *e ae9a*+o& +& *e o8)a+&* or+&or8a*+o&. A&' o&e +* + o o;&, *e our* 8ay -a+'y *a=e o9&+a&e o *e

ae. o;e-er, + *e e-+'e&e a''ue' 'ur+&9 *e *r+a o; *a* *e oBe&e ;a

o88+**e' o8e;ere ee, *e our* ou' '+8+ *e a*+o& or ;a&* o

@ur+'+*+o&.[37]

& *e ae a* bar, )r+-a*e re)o&'e&* ;a a )r+-a*e +*+e& a* *e *+8e o *e

)ub+a*+o& o *e ae9e' +beou ar*+e, e&e, e ou' o&y e + +be u+* +&

*e C+*y o Ma&+a ;ere Aba&*e ;a r* )ub+e' or +& *e )ro-+&e or +*y ;ere

e a*uay re+'e' a* *e *+8e *e )ur)or*e' +beou ar*+e ;a )r+&*e'.

A )erua, o;e-er, o *e +&or8a*+o& +&-o-e' +& *+ ae ea+y re-ea *a* *eae9a*+o& o&*a+&e' *ere+& are u**ery +&uH+e&* *o -e* @ur+'+*+o& o& *e RTC

o #ueo& C+*y. !*er *a& )eru&*or+y *a*+&9 #ueo& C+*y a* *e be9+&&+&9 o *e

+&or8a*+o&, *e a+*a&* +*y )roeu*or ;o )re)are' *e +&or8a*+o& '+' &o*

bo*er *o +&'+a*e ;e*er *e @ur+'+*+o& o RTC #ueo& C+*y ;a +&-o=e' e+*er

beaue Aba&*e ;a )r+&*e' +& *a* )ae or )r+-a*e re)o&'e&* ;a a re+'e&* o

a+' +*y a* *e *+8e *e a+8e' +beou ar*+e a8e ou*. A *ee 8a**er 'ea

;+* *e u&'a8e&*a +ue o *e our* @ur+'+*+o&, Ar*+e 360 o *e Re-+e'

/e&a Co'e, a a8e&'e', 8a&'a*e *a* e+*er o&e o *ee *a*e8e&* 8u* be

ae9e' +& *e +&or8a*+o& +*e a&' *e abe&e o bo* ro8 *e -ery ae o *e

+&or8a*+o& re&'er *e a**er a*ay 'ee*+-e. Sa'y or )r+-a*e re)o&'e&*, *e

+&or8a*+o& e' beore *e *r+a our* a ;ay or* o *+ reIu+re8e&*. Te

a+*a&* +*y )roeu*or a+ure *o )ro)ery ay *e ba+ or +&-o=+&9 *e

@ur+'+*+o& o *e RTC, #ueo& C+*y, eBe*+-ey 'e&+e' a+' our* o *e )o;er *o

*a=e o9&+a&e o *+ ae. ENCE N! %$RSCT!N.