Isla Melville & Ian McNeill - Symposium_Final
-
Upload
miasto-przemyslowe -
Category
Documents
-
view
222 -
download
1
description
Transcript of Isla Melville & Ian McNeill - Symposium_Final
T H E A L T E R N A T I V E SY
MP
OS
IU
MR e c i p r o c i t y
E m p o w e r m e n t
D e m o c r a c y
URBAN STRATEGY | MARCH STAGE IIISLA MELVILLE & IAN MCNEILL
T H E
A L T E R N A T I V E
RED
ECIPROCITY [the practice of exchanging things with others for mutual benefit]
ENVIRONMENTAL NEED BUSINESS NEED SOCIAL NEED
“For every action, there will be an equal and opposite reaction”
“...cooperative rather than competitive...”
Lack of physical interactions in space
Unproductive vs Productive Ursus(north-west vs south)
Mutual exchange and physical interactions (work centres)
Mutual exchange and barter - nonmonetary forms of exchange
Non-capital market within a capitalist environment
Move towards a polyopoly market as opposed to current oligopoly
Mutual growth and expansion
Global need for sustainable technologies
Industrial ecology need for industrial symbiosis
Poland’s energy situation a need for change ?
European policy pressure on Poland
T H E
A L T E R N A T I V E
RED
MPOWERMENT [the subordination of economic power to social power]
POLISH HISTORY CURRENT SOCIAL HUMAN VOICE
Strong history of empowerment and fighting social injustices
Solidarity Movement
Orange Alternative
High Unemployment “The big sleep and its clients” graffiti
Job security and poor pay Online blogs/informal newspaper uprising against social constraints
Graduate Unemployment Graduate Unemployment
Increased Poverty rate Increased Poverty rate
Increased wage gap and class divisions
Increased wage gap and class divisions
T H E
A L T E R N A T I V E
D EMOCRACY
RE
DEMOCRATIC POLAND? SOCIAL EQUALITY CLAIMING TERRITORY
[...all people have broadly equal access to the means to participate meaningfully in decisions about things which affect their lives]
Capitalist society - those with wealth have power
Ursus site - existing industries have little say about the future of the site
Equal weight between individuals and companies on site
Sense of belonging
Money is equal to knowledge, equal power
Physical participation in matters on site
CURRENT FABRIC
CURRENT WORKING
EMPTY OPEN SPACE NATURE TAKES OVER DERELICT BUILDINGS
BLANK FACADES DERELICT BUILDINGS
[working with and determining the strategy]
Strategy adds to existing systemsOwnership AssociationStarting point
Claiming Territory (formal and informal)Opportunity
Non-human actorsBuild upon
UsedStarting point
Vertical VoidsBlank canvas for play
UnusedShelter and structure in placeOpportunity for informal
CELTIC OWNERSHIP
NO INFORMAL PRESENCE ONE FORMAL ACTIVITY OCCUPIES SITE ONE FORMAL ACTIVITY PRESENCE OPENS INFORMAL ACTIVITY OPPORTUNITY
MORE FORMAL ACTIVITY PRESENCE FEEDS MORE INFORMAL ACTIVITY OPPORTUNITY
FULL RED OCCUPATION THE FORMAL ACTIVITY PERMEATES BEYOND URSUS DISTRICT
If the tidal spread of Celtic ownership can be stemmed, and a strong enough bond ,reinforced by Industrial symbiosis, can be utilised to start working at claiming land back off the developer, and put it too productive use.
Occupation and multi-ownership/claiming of territory
INSECURITIES NEGATIVE IMAGE MONO-OWNERSHIP
MATERIAL FLOW ANALYSIS
ON-SITE POTENTIAL ACTIVITIES ANALYSIS
OPPORTUNITIES FOR ON-SITE SYNERGIES
ON-SITE SYNERGY FLY ASH REUSEUse of fly ash from power plantUse in Water TreatmentUse within building products (concrete, asphalt, etc)
ON-SITE SYNERGY REUSE OF ALUMINIUM WASTEWaste aluminium from industries (el-box, etc) may circulate aluminium waste back to Asmet
ON-SITE SYNERGY PAPER RECYCLINGWaste paper from offices and packaging materials could be recycled into paper reused by Raphael Printers
ON-SITE SYNERGY REUSE OF WASTE PAINTUse of “clean” waste paint for graffiti / street art
EXISTING ON-SITE CONNECTIONS
INDUSTRIAL WASTE
MUNICIPAL WASTE
GAPS IN THE SYSTEMS OPPORTUNITIES
CURRENT ACTIVITIES OFF-SITE
OPPORTUNITIES FOR SITE-DISTRICT SYNERGIES
ON-SITE CONNECTIONS TO AGRICULTURAL ACTIVITIESCleaning of Water Run-off
Use of Treated and Tested Sewage Sludge on Agricultural Crops
ON-SITE CONNECTIONS TO COMPUTER COMPANIESConnection between on-site computer part making and outside
small computer businesses
MATERIAL FLOW ANALYSIS
OPPORTUNITIES TO CONNECT WITH SURROUNDING AREA
SCENARIO A-B-C
WATER ENERGY WASTE
BIOPOLYEMER PRODUCTION PLANT
BIOSOLIDS TESTING
AGRICULTURAL USE
METHANE GASEMERGENCY WATER
WATER PURIFICATION
= WATER = OPPORTUNITY = ACTIVITY FOOTPRINT= WASTE
SUBSTITUTION
INTERCHANGEABLE FOR LIKE INDUSTRIES
FUTURE RESILIENCE CYCLICAL SYSTEMS
COMPANY A
COMPANY B
NEW ACTIVITY
COMPANY C
ENERGETYKA URSUS
NEW ACTIVITY
OPTION B
OPTION C
OPTION D
NEW ACTIVITY
OPTION B
OPTION C
INPUT NATIONAL/GLOBAL/REGIONAL SUPPLY(MATCHING POTENTIAL)
OUTPUTGOODS/INFORMATION/DSERVICES/LABOUR(MATCHING POTENTIAL)
OPTION B OPTION C
CHIPBOARD ANALOGY
DETERMINED BY INFRASTRUCTURE
SUBSTITUTIONS
COLLECTIVE WORKING FOR SAME GOAL
CONSTRUCTIVE
CONNECTIONS TO OTHER “POST-INDUSTRIAL” SITES
SUBSTITUTION
CHIPBOARD ANALOGY LINKS TO OTHER SITES COLLECTIVE WORKING
WHO?
WHY?
WHAT?
BENEFITS?
FORMAL ACTIVITIES
Formal Industries/Businesses - Capital backing
Mutual benefit / growth / expansion
Formal static buildings
Investment on site
Required to the system (allows for substitution)
Collaboration and Innovation
High capital
Security, and future buying of Celtic land
Fit the gaps/opportunities identified
Polyopoly
Owned land (formal/legal claiming of territory)
Industrial symbiosis - environmental
Static
Respond to EU pressure
Examples - opportunities booklet
Formal occupation, support informal
WHO?
WHY?
WHAT?
BENEFITS?
INFORMAL ACTIVITIES
Unemployed, graduates, job insecure, etc
Stepping Stone
Informal transient structures - temporary
Frontline in occupation for security
Without capital
“Free” platform - barter exchange
Progressive over time
Physical human interaction transforming place
Transient population
Equality
On Celtic owned land, and others
Human element
Individuals/Collectives/Informal Businesses
Collaborative/Productive Atmosphere
Parasitic
Social change
PAPER MILL EXAMPLE
COM
PUTE
R FA
CTO
RY
WAS
TE P
AINT
RAPH
AEL
PRIN
TERS
PRIN
TING
PRE
SS
PAPE
R M
ILL
WEB
SITE
DES
IGNE
RIN
DEPE
NDEN
T NE
WSP
APER
ARTI
STS’
STU
DIO W
ASTE
PAP
ER D
EPO
T
PAPE
R CR
AFTS
WAS
TE P
APER
COM
PUTE
R CO
MPA
NIES
SCRA
P PA
PER
REUS
E
WAS
TE P
APER
OFF
ICES
: WAS
TE P
APER
DULU
X: W
ASTE
PAI
NT
CRAF
T SH
OP
COM
PUTE
R CO
MPA
NIES
EL-B
OX:
CO
MPU
TER
CASI
NG
BIO
POLY
MER
PRO
DUCT
ION:
CO
MPU
TER
CASI
NG