Innovative Remedial Approaches to Accelerated Site …e2s2.ndia.org/schedule/Documents/2012...
Transcript of Innovative Remedial Approaches to Accelerated Site …e2s2.ndia.org/schedule/Documents/2012...
Innovative Remedial
Approaches to
Accelerated Site Closure Karen Hohe Suchomel, PG
Rula A. Deeb, PhD, BCEEM
Scott T. Potter, PhD, PE
Suthan S. Suthersan, PhD, PE
ARCADIS/Malcolm Pirnie
May 24, 2012
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Performance
Based
Remediation: A Platform for
Innovation and
Accelerated Site
Closure
• Reese Air Force Base, TX
– Innovation: Directed Groundwater
Recirculation (DGR)
• Fort Gordon, GA
– Innovation: Green Remediation
• Lake City Army Ammunition Plant, MO
– Innovation: Regulatory plan for schedule
acceleration
• Sierra Army Depot, CA
– Innovation: cost-effective management
of MMRP impacts
Project Overview
Innovation Driver….TECHNICAL
• Reese AFB operated between 1941 and 1997 (BRAC closure): aircraft maintenance, vehicle maintenance, aircraft and equipment fueling, fire training, and solid waste disposal
• Performance objective: Fence to fence closure of all known and unknown environmental sites
• Contract administered by the USACE, Tulsa District
• Period of performance: 2004 – 2014
• Contract value: ~$43.5M
Technical Challenges
• 3-mile TCE plume in a sole source aquifer for surrounding community
– Restoration to MCLs – Groundwater drives the local
economy (potable use, farming, commercial, light industrial)
– Dozens of private wells and irrigation wells
– Extensive well network for site remediation (671 monitoring wells, 50 extraction wells, 60 injection wells)
• Aquifer heterogeneities
• Result: “Final” remedy operating for 5 years and still no OPS
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Technical
Approach
• Revise the Conceptual Site Model
– Detected high permeability layers that
control migration direction
• Using the new CSM as a foundation
for remedy design
– Modify current system to demonstrate
OPS
• Pump and treat required to avoid ROD
modification
– Optimize current system to accelerate
mass removal
– Stop plume growth
Use of Optimization Tools
Innovative software
(MODALL), an add-on
to MODFLOW, was
used to optimize
remedy
900 gpm
300 gpm
Setting the stage to
optimizing remedy
approved in the ROD
300 gpm
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Reese
Summary
• Overall Project – Site Closure (SC) for 7 soil sites within 4
years of start
– Remediation (to MCLs) of groundwater plumes at Southwest Landfill and POL Area
• Tower Plume – OPS designation
– TCE below 5 ppb, entering 3 year monitoring period for closure
– Plume shrinkage from 800 acres (2004) to 12 acres (July 2011) at an average rate of 2-3 acres/week
– Savings: ~$25M
– Schedule: Acceleration by 12 years
Project Overview
Innovation Driver….TECHNICAL
• Period of performance: 9/2001– 10/2015, with contract value of $19.5M
• Performance objectives: Close 26 SWMUs
– Landfills, former maintenance shops, waste
storage and disposal areas, drainage
structures, groundwater plumes
– Contaminants: Hydrocarbons, pesticides,
mercury, chlorinated solvents
• Key technical challenge: SWMU 9
– TCE plume with concentrations >1,000 ppb
– Plume is discharging to the adjacent stream
– Stream data demonstrate that surface water
concentrations are ND
– No identified receptors; remote location
– Groundwater concentrations are attenuating
Technical Challenges
Remedy Objectives
• Address the Georgia Environmental Protection Division guidelines to have an active remedy
• Result in minimal site impacts to protect an endangered species (Red Cockaded Woodpecker)
• Needs to be low maintenance because of the remoteness of the site and there is no access to power or utilities
• Meet GA stream water quality standards (32 ppb)
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
The Result:
Artesian
Treatment
Vessels
(ATVs)
Sustainability by design
• ARCADIS balanced the overall treatment objectives and the ecosystem considerations to develop a sustainable, cost-effective remediation strategy with the collaboration with all stakeholders involved –The ATV
– Remedy takes advantage of ambient artesian conditions that cause impacted groundwater to flow through the ATVs, removing all VOCs
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Fort Gordon
Summary
• Developed and implemented an innovative “green” remedy that uses natural artesian conditions, does not require an external energy source and needs very little maintenance
– Operating continuously at 8.5 gpm (100% uptime)
– GAC life-cycle is 5 to 7 years
– Removes approximately 5.1 lbs of TCE/year
– Will reduce life cycle CO2 emissions by an 60 tons (analysis using ARCADIS BalancE3® Tool to compare alternatives)
• Improved relationship between the Army and GAEPD
Project Overview
Innovation Driver….SCHEDULE
• Active ongoing mission-critical CERCLA site with 4 OUs and 33 AOCs
• Nature and extent of contamination
– Abandoned disposal pits, sumps, firing
ranges, old lagoons and dumps, closed
RCRA lagoons, burning grounds
– Large chlorinated solvent plumes with
NAPLs and mixed liquid wastes
– Impacts to a prolific drinking water
aquifer
• Contract objective: RIP/RC/NFA by 2007
• Period of performance: 2003 – 2012; contract value: ~$52.5M
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Performance
Based
Contract
Drives
Schedule
• Multiple teams mobilized from across the country
• Numerous meetings with regulators
– Obtain buy in for combined reports
– Present concept for site-wide groundwater approach
– Present findings before they were included in a draft report
– Address questions/concerns before they had a chance to slow progress
• Community Meetings – Introduce technical concepts
Technical Approach
Innovative approaches to rapidly treat two NAPL source areas
• NECOU: Zero-valent iron (ZVI)/clay soil mixing treatment, with enhanced reductive dechlorination and MNA
– Reduced mass flux from
the source by decreasing
effective hydraulic conductivity
– Passive technology, limiting
life-cycle costs and net
environmental impact
– Destroys chlorinated ethenes, providing permanent treatment
• Area 18: In-situ bioremediation in DNAPL source zone
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Green
Remediation
• Seven mobile solar-powered systems to recover NAPL
• Phytoremediation used to manage hydraulics related to underperforming PRB
• Reuse of extracted groundwater for elements of final remedy
• Minimizing waste generation (e.g., on-site soil treatment, passive groundwater sampling devices)
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Lake City
AAP
Summary
• Met aggressive cost and schedule goals (RIP/RC/NFA within 4 years) under challenging regulatory constraints
– NFA designations at 25 AOCs
• Implemented comprehensive groundwater strategy
• Five-year review (2011) determined remedy is protective of human health and environment
• Estimated savings: $20M
• Winner: 2011 AAEE (American Association of Environmental Engineers) Excellence in Environmental Engineering Award, Design Category
Project Overview
Innovation Driver….COST and REGULATORY
• Performance objective: Achieve RC for 8 MMRP Sites
– Area with numerous white phosphorus
(WP) rounds
– Possible UXO in debris piles
– Metals exceedances in shallow soil
samples
– Elevated arsenic levels in site
groundwater wells
• Period of performance: January 2010 through December 2012
• Costs for anticipated remediation :
– $12M – characterization through RC
– >$100M – estimates for MEC removal
remedies
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Regulatory
Interaction
• Relationship developed over 7 years of executing remediation at IRP sites
• Numerous meetings and site visit with regulators. Agreements included:
– Appropriateness of LUCs – remove sites from active Army and public use
– Scope to ensure protectiveness
– Accelerated schedule
• Agreements allowed execution of RA work during RI field work to accelerate schedule and minimize mobilization costs
Technical Approach
• Complete RI to address regulatory concerns about UXO/MEC and MC
– 100% surface sweeps for MEC
characterization
– Focused media sampling • Soil sampling to assess exposure risk
and risk of leaching to groundwater • Subsurface soil sampling
adjacent/beneath buried trenches • Installed 2 new monitoring wells • GW evaluation
• Complete RA field work during RI to meet time constraint
– BIP MEC encountered
– Fence repair/installation and warning
sign installation
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Sierra Army
Depot
Summary
• Regulatory agency concurred with NFA recommendation for one site and had only one comment on the 7 Sites Draft RI/FS Report
• In August 2011, regulatory agency concurred with the selected LUCs remedy for the 7 other sites
• On track to achieve RC in 3Q2012 (within two years of contract award) with completion of a 7 Sites ROD
• Total contract value: $6.9M – order of magnitude savings
Environment, Energy Security & Sustainability Symposium & Exhibition
Overall
Conclusion:
Necessity
Drives
Innovation
• Performance-based remediation is a
platform for developing innovative
approaches to accelerate closure
and meet contract objectives
– Contractor accountability
• Lessons-learned process is therefore
critical
– at ARCADIS, captured by our Technical
Knowledge and Innovation (TKI) group.
• Performance-based contracting
maintains the focus on closing sites
and minimizing life-cycle costs
34
Imagine the result
QUESTIONS???
Karen Hohe Suchomel Associate Vice President, Guaranteed Outcomes Contact Info: [email protected]