Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on...
Transcript of Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on...
![Page 1: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Impacts of Post-Combustion pCO2 Capture on Plant Performance –
A Case StudyA Case Study 12th Meeting of the International
Post-Combustion CO Capture Network
Chris van DrielAnindo Dey
Post-Combustion CO2 Capture Network
Anindo DeyDavid Cameron
30 S t b 200930 September 2009
![Page 2: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Presentation Overview
• Acknowledgements• Existing Plant Performance• Existing Plant Performance • Modeling Integration and Methodology• Boiler Improvements/Upgradesp pg• Steam Turbine Improvements/Upgrades• Process Implications
C t f R ti St– Cost of Regeneration Steam– Heat Recovery– Flue Gas Water Consumptionue Gas ate Co su pt o
• Risk Assessment• Conclusion
![Page 3: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Acknowledgements
This presentation is based on work that Stantec carried out in pconjunction with the SaskPower Clean Coal Team.
Potential performance improvements described herein are only those that have been analyzed using a generic CO capture system and indicative unit performanceanalyzed using a generic CO2 capture system and indicative unit performance.
All design improvements are still under consideration.
![Page 4: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Existing Plant Performance Boundary Dam Power StationBoundary Dam Power Station
• Boundary Dam located in Saskatchewan, CanadaB d D C i f Si U it• Boundary Dam Comprises of Six Units
• Current CCS demonstration work focused on Unit 3– Pulverized Coal BoilerPulverized Coal Boiler– 150 MWe Gross Tandem-Compound HIP-LP Steam Turbine
Courtesy of SaskPower
![Page 5: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Existing Plant PerformanceBoiler and Turbine PlantBoiler and Turbine Plant
• Steam Generator:P l eri ed Coal Balanced draft Tangentiall fired Unit– Pulverized Coal, Balanced draft, Tangentially fired Unit
– Tubular PA Heater, Rotary SA Heater– Design MCR Rating – 1050 mlb/hr, 1000 ºF/1000 ºF
• Steam Turbine:– GE Tandem-Compound HIP-LP
Six Feedwater Heaters (incl 1 DA)– Six Feedwater Heaters (incl. 1 DA)
HP IP LP
![Page 6: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Modeling Integration and MethodologySoftware
• Software Packages - GateCycleTM and ProMax®
G t C l (GE E )
Software
• GateCycle (GE Energy):– Power Island Modeling
• Boiler & Steam Turbine– CO2 Capture
• Flue Gas & Simplified Capture Systems– CO2 CompressionCO2 Compression
• Compressors w/ Simplified Dehydration
• ProMax (BR&E):CO2 C t– CO2 Capture
• Flue Gas & Capture Systems – CO2 Compression
• Compressors w/ Detailed Dehydration
![Page 7: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Modeling Integration and Methodology(con’t)(con t)
M t d lli i t• Most modelling is system specific, completed in smaller auxiliary models. Steam Flue Gas
SteamGenerator
y• Overall plant performance
and integration with master model
Turbine System
MasterModel
model.• Both software packages
can interface can through
FG Pre-Treatment
CO2
CO2Capture
gExcel. Comp.
![Page 8: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Modeling Integration and MethodologyCO2 Capture System Modelling AssumptionsCO2 Capture System Modelling Assumptions
CO2 Capture Plant Modeling Assumptions:Monoethanolamine 30 Wt% Base Case– Monoethanolamine 30 Wt% - Base Case
– Saturated gas from DCC supplied to absorber– Absorber outlet stream vented to atmosphere– Reflux drum outlet stream to compression plant
• CO2 Compression Unit Modeling Assumptions:CO2 Compression Unit Modeling Assumptions:– Six (6) stages of wet, two (2) stages of dry compression– Dehydration/Dryer Unit– Approx. 2500 psia at pipeline
![Page 9: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Boiler Improvements/UpgradesObjectivesObjectives
• Overall objectives:– Increase Steam/Electrical Generation– Minimize Air Heater Leakage
Li it d t iti f it i d• Limited opportunities for capacity increases due to existing structure.Possibility to increase steam conditions• Possibility to increase steam conditions
• Alter air heater arrangement and design –accommodate heat recoveryaccommodate heat recovery
![Page 10: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Boiler Improvements/Upgrades(con’t)(con t)
• Limited opportunities for capacity increases due t i ti t tto existing structure.– Optimization of increased number of tubes spacingnumber of tubes, spacing, and sizing in SH/RH and Econ– Air heater performance
ECAir heater performance
upgrades and new potentialarrangements
SH/RH
PAHg– Potential efficiency improvement of ~ 0.3 – 4.5 Pts SAH
![Page 11: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Boiler Improvements/Upgrades(con’t)(con t)
• Possibility to increase steam conditions – Pressure:
• No opportunity to increase existing pressure operation [1800 psig (12.5 MPa)] [ p g ( )]
– Temperature: • Opportunity exists to increase existing temperature
operation from 1000 ºF (538 ºC)operation from 1000 F (538 C) • Potential new operating temperature for main and reheat
steam of 1050 ºF (566 ºC)B il ffi i i l ti l t t h d• Boiler efficiency remains relatively constant, enhanced T-G performance and unit heat rate
![Page 12: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Boiler Improvements/Upgrades(con’t)(con t)
• Alter air heater arrangement and design –d t h taccommodate heat recovery
– Air preheating upstream of air heaters delivers increased efficiency potential 0 3 - 1 % Pt increaseincreased efficiency, potential 0.3 - 1 % Pt increase.
80 ºF80 250 ºFPA IN
SA IN
80 ºF
80 ºF
80 - 250 ºF
80 - 250 ºF
![Page 13: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Steam Turbine Improvements/UpgradesObjectivesObjectives
• Overall objectives:– Increased Power Generation / Efficiency– Minimize Cycle Impact of Regeneration Steam
E i ti ST G i b ild d b• Existing ST-G requires rebuild and can be re-designed to accommodate new regen extractionPossibility to increase steam conditions >1000ºF• Possibility to increase steam conditions >1000ºF
• Possibility to employ condensate preheating from heat recoveryfrom heat recovery
![Page 14: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Steam Turbine Improvements/Upgrades(con’t)(con t)
• Existing ST-G requires rebuild and can be re-d i d t d t t tidesigned to accommodate new regen extraction– Improve stage efficiencies and heat rate over existing
Potential use of uncontrolled extraction to limit losses– Potential use of uncontrolled extraction to limit lossesSTEAM TO PROCESS
EXISTING 1000 ºF / 1000 ºF
HP IP LPPOTENTIAL GROSS OUTPUT INCREASE
OF 3 - 4 %
![Page 15: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Steam Turbine Improvements/Upgrades(con’t)(con t)
• Possibility to increase steam conditions >1000ºF– Opportunity exists to operating temperature for main
and reheat steam from 1000 ºF (538 ºC) to 1050 ºF(566 ºC)(566 C)
STEAM TO PROCESS
POTENTIAL 1050 ºF / 1050 ºF
HP IP LPPOTENTIAL GROSS OUTPUT INCREASE
OF 0 5 - 1%OF 0.5 1%
![Page 16: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Steam Turbine Improvements/Upgrades(con’t)(con t)
• Possibility to employ condensate preheating f h t (HP & LP)from heat recovery (HP & LP)
HP100% >1% >2% >3%
HP > 5% >1 5% >2 5%50% >.5% >1.5% >2.5%
HP0% BASE >1% >2%
HP IP LP
LP0%
LP50%
LP100%
LP PREHEATHP PREHEAT Potential % Increase in Gross GenerationPotential % Increase in Gross Generation
![Page 17: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Process ImplicationsOverviewOverview
• Regeneration Steam• Heat Recovery• Flue Gas Water Consumption• Condenser Off-loading• Booster Fan
![Page 18: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Process ImplicationsCost of Regeneration SteamCost of Regeneration Steam
• Regeneration Steam Impacted by:Req ired press re and heat d t at reboiler + line losses– Required pressure and heat duty at reboiler, + line losses
– ‘Cost of Steam’ kWe per lb/hr or MBtu(MWth)
Gross GenerationImpact (kW / MBtu/hr)
Increasing Process Steam
Pressure
Condensate Return Temperature
![Page 19: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Process ImplicationsCost of Regeneration Steam (con’t)Cost of Regeneration Steam (con t)
• Regeneration Steam Impacted by:Partial Load Performance Red ced P/T Q alit– Partial Load Performance – Reduced P/T Quality
Process Steam Pressure
Process SteamTemperature%
MCR
% MCR
Process Steam Extraction Flow
![Page 20: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Process ImplicationsHeat RecoveryHeat Recovery
• Heat Recovery– Flue Gas Coolers
ABSORBERINLET
DCCSO2REMOVAL
FGC
ID FANESPBOILER
A/H OUTLETDCC
– CO2 Capture and CompressionREFLUX
CONDENSER STAGECONDENSER
CWSTRIPPER
COMPRESSIONINLET
STAGEINLET
CWTYPICAL INTERSTAGE COOLER
STAGEOUTLET
![Page 21: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Process ImplicationsHeat Recovery (con’t)Heat Recovery (con t)
• Heat Recovery - Sources and SinksTotal Heat Duty (HOT)
Temperature
Total Heat Duty (COLD)
HPCP LPCP SA PA RH
Heat Rejection Required
![Page 22: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Process ImplicationsFlue Gas Water ConsumptionFlue Gas Water Consumption
• Water Consumption DCCSO2REMOVAL
DCC
100% Saturation Curve
FGC
Humidity
Curve
y(lb H20 /
lb Dry Gas)
FG INFGD
DCC
FG IN
FG OUTFGC
Temperature
![Page 23: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Process ImplicationsOtherOther
• Condenser Off-loading– During process extraction, condenser heat duty is
reduced significantly (~ 25 – 45%)• Booster Fans• Booster Fans
– Required to reuse existing ID fan, maximize use of existing infrastructure.g
![Page 24: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Risk AssessmentOverviewOverview
• Prior experience in amine systems
• Bowtie Analysis
• Hazard Identification (HAZID)
• Preliminary Hazard & Operability studies (HAZOP)
• Sensitivity Studies
![Page 25: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Risk AssessmentBow-tie AnalysisBow tie Analysis
• Can be applied to assess performance risk of a first-of-its kind technologyits-kind technology
• Bow-tie diagram – Event (or hazards) shown as knot in the middle, threats on the ( )
left; consequences on the right
• Identifies threats and control measures in engineering design for mitigation of threatsdesign for mitigation of threats
• List the control measures for mitigation of potential consequences during commissioning/operational stage
• Assess impact on project capital cost, project schedule and operating costs
![Page 26: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Risk AssessmentBow-tie DiagramBow tie Diagram
EVENT
THREAT CONSEQUENCETHREAT CONSEQUENCE
![Page 27: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Risk AssessmentBow-tie Diagram - Threat IdentificationBow tie Diagram Threat Identification (Left side of the knot)
• Identify the hazards or the undesirable EVENTS• Suggest Controls to mitigate the hazards or undesirable events• Identify new threats for the suggested controls• Identify new threats for the suggested controls• Suggest Controls for the threats
![Page 28: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Risk AssessmentBow-tie Diagram - Consequence IdentificationBow tie Diagram Consequence Identification(Right side of the knot)
• A consequence occurs if the hazard is breached and nohazard is breached and no action is taken to recover from the issue
• Suggest controls to the ggconsequences arising out of the undesirable events or hazardsC b• Consequences can be customized to reflect the need of the exercise
• Develop Risk Matrix for:Develop Risk Matrix for:– People, Assets, Environment,
Unplanned Outage– Construction / Commissioning
Phase– Operational Phase
![Page 29: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Conclusion
• With the large heating, cooling, and power demands of a CO2capture and compression system, system integration andcapture and compression system, system integration and optimization is paramount.
• Modelling plant systems facilitates integration, along with identification and qualification of opportunities.identification and qualification of opportunities.
• A combination of boiler and turbine improvements, coupled with heat recovery, have the potential to increase plant efficiency by over 10%. Initial projections placed the net generation at capture at 10010%. Initial projections placed the net generation at capture at 100 MWe, current projections are at 115 – 120 MWe.
• Increased heat recovery can improve cycle efficiency and also reduce water consumptioneduce ate co su pt o
• Increased integration represents increased risks, which require proper threat and consequence identification for mitigation.
![Page 30: Impacts of Post-Combustion CO2 Capture on Plant ... cap/S-7 Stantec prn_cgv... · 2 Capture on Plant Performance – A Case StudyA Case Study ... GateCycleTM and ProMax ... • ProMax](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022011802/5b4286e07f8b9afd3b8b5291/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Questions
Chris van Driel, P.Eng., M.Sc.E. – Heat and Mass BalanceAnindo Dey, P.Eng., MASc(Engg.), MBA – CO2 Capture and Compression
David Cameron, P.Eng., Senior Principal – Project Executivechris.vandriel / anindo.dey / david.cameron / @stantec.com
30 September 2009