IBC v. Wal-Mart - Complaint

7/28/2019 IBC v. Wal-Mart - Complaint

1/22

Case 2:13-cv-00139-WCO Document 1 Filed 06/26/13 Page 1 of 11

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTFOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIAGAINESVILLE, DIVISON

INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS )CORPORATION, INC., )

)Plaintiff ))

v. ) CVNo.)WAL-MART STORES, INC., )AMAZON.COM, and )ONWARD MANUFACTURING )COMPANY LIMITED, ))Defendants ))

COMPLAINT

Comes now International Business Corporation (IBC), through theundersigned attorneys, and states for its complaint against Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.(Wal-Mart), Amazon.com (Amazon), and Onward Manufacturing CompanyLimited (Onward), as follows:

PRELIMINARY STATEMENT1. IBC brings claims against Defendants for Defendants infringement of a

patent owned by IBC in violation of35 U.S.C. 271. Accordingly, IBCseeks, among other relief, a permanent injunction to prevent Defendantfrom importing, making, using, offering to sell, and selling within the

1

2:13-cv-139-WCO


2/22


United States any products that infringe ffiC's patent under 35 U.S.C 283; damages in the form ofDefendants' profits under 35 U.S.C. 289;and, the reasonable attorney's fees and costs incurred in prosecuting thisaction, including prejudgment interest.

THE PARTIES

2. Plaintiff IBC is a Georgia corporation having a principal place ofbusiness at 5705 Commerce Blvd., Alpharetta, Georgia.

3. Upon information and belief, Defendant Walmart IS a Delawarecorporation, having a principal place of business 702 SW 8th StreetBentonville, AR 72716-0520 and having a place of business in thisdistrict at 400 Shallowford Road NW, Gainesville, GA 30504

4. Upon information and belief, Defendant Amazon is a DelawareCorporation, having a principal place of business at 1200 12th AvenueSouth, Suite 1200, Seattle, Washington, 98144

5. Upon information and belief, Defendant Onward is a foreignCorporation, having a principal place of business at 585 Kumpf Drive,Waterloo, Ontario, Canada N2V 1K3 .

2


3/22


4/22


selling of the same accused product and questions of fact common to alldefendants will arise in the action.

FACTS COMMON TO ALL COUNTS11. The allegations of Paragraphs 1 to 10 are incorporated by reference and

re-alleged as if fully set forth herein.12. IBC is the owner ofU.S. PatentNo. D648,174 S (the "Patent") a copy of

which is attached as Exhibit A;13. The Patent is directed to a unique ornamental design for a Barbeque Grill

Rack.14. Upon information and belief, Walmart has offered to sell, sold or

imported barbeque grill racks that incorporate the invention claimed anddescribed in the Patent in the United States and in the Northern DistrictofGeorgia including through one or more stores located in Gainesville,Georgia.

15. Upon information and belief, Amazon has offered to sell, sold orimported barbeque grill racks that incorporate the invention claimed anddescribed in the Patent in the United States and in the Northern DistrictofGeorgia.

16. Upon information and belief, the accused barbeque grill racks sold byDefendants Wal-Mart and Amazon were sold or otherwise supplied to

4


5/22


them by Defendant Onward in the United States or imported into theUnited States by Onward.

17. Defendant Onward offers for sale grill products and accessories under theGrillpro mark in the United States via its website and the websites ofothers.

18 . Upon further information and belief, without permission or license fromIBC, Defendants have offered and are offering to sell, have distributedand are distributing, have sold and are selling, or have imported and areimporting barbeque grill racks that incorporate the invention claimed anddescribed in the Patent in the United States.

19. Alternatively, upon information and belief, Defendants offer and areoffering to sell, have distributed and are distributing, and have sold or areselling the Accused Products having applied thereto the patented design,or a colorable imitation thereof, to customers throughout the UnitedStates, including customers in the Northern District of Georgia, throughWal-Mart Stores, on the Wal-Mart website, through Amazon. andthrough various other websites.

20. Examples of the Accused Products offered for sale, distributed, and soldby Defendants in the United States are the "Backyard Grill Chicken Legand Wing Rack" sold by Wal-Mart as shown in Exhibit B and the

5


6/22


"GrillPro 41551 Non-Stick Wing Rack with Chrome Legs" sold onAmazon.com as shown in Exhibit C.

Count 1- Direct Infringement ofUS Patent No. D648,174 S21. The allegations set forth in paragraphs 1 through 19 are incorporated by

reference and re-alleged as if fully set forth herein.

22. On November 11, 2011, US Patent No. D648,174 S for a "Barbeque GrillRack" was duly and legally issued. The '174 Patent has been at all timessince the date of issuance, valid and enforceable. A true and correct copyof the' 174 Patent is attached as Exhibit A.

23. IBC is the owner by assignment of all right, title and interest in and to the'174 Patent, including all right to recover for any and all pastinfringement thereof.

24. Upon information and belief, without permission or license from IBC,each of the Defendants have offered to sell, manufactured or imported,distributed, or sold the Accused Products to customers in the United

States.25. The Accused Products incorporate the inventions claimed and described

in the ' 174 Patent.

6


7/22


26. Defendants each have sold, sells or exposes for sale the AccusedProducts as an article of manufacture to which the patented design or

colorable imitation has been applied.27. By offering to sell, manufacturing or importing, distributing, or selling

the Accused Products in the United States, Defendants are each directlyinfringing the claims of the '174 Patent.

28. Upon information and belief, the acts of the Defendants complained ofherein have been committed intentionally and willfully, with knowledgeofiBC ' s rights in the' 174 Patent.

29. Upon information and belief, Defendants will not cease such tortious actsunless enjoined by this Court.

30. Defendants ' acts of direct infringement have and will continue to damageIBC, and IBC has no adequate remedy at law.

Count II - Induced Infringement ofUS Patent No. D648,174S

31. The allegations set forth in paragraphs 1 through 3 0 are incorporated byreference and re-alleged as if fully set forth herein.

7


8/22


32. Upon information and belief, Defendant Onward, with specific intent, hasactively induced others to infringe the' 174 Patent, including WaJ-Martand Amazon, and has thus infringed the' 174 Patent under 35 U.S. C. 271(b).

33. Upon information and belief, the acts of the Defendant Onwardcomplained ofherein have been committed intentionally and willfully,with knowledge ofiBC's rights in the ' 174 Patent. Upon information andbelief, the acts of the Defendant complained ofherein have beencommitted intentionally and willfully, with knowledge ofiBC's rights inthe ' 174 Patent.

34. Upon information and belief, Defendant Onward will not cease suchtortious acts unless enjoined by this Court.

35. Defendant Onward's acts of induced infringement have and will continueto damage IBC, and IBC has no adequate remedy at law.

DEMAND FOR JURY TRIALPlaintiff IBC hereby demands a trial by jury of all issues so triable.WHEREFORE, IBC prays that judgment on all claims of the Complaint

be entered for IBC and against Defendants;WHEREFORE, IBC also prays for the following:(a) that pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 289, Defendants be ordered to pay to IBC

8


9/22


10/22


deem just and proper.Dated: June 26, 2013.

Robert J. VealGeorgia Bar No. [email protected] Intellectual Propety, LLC11555 Medlock Bridge RoadSuite 100Johns Creek, GA 3 0097Tel: (678) 653-4758Fax: (678) 597-1101

10


11/22


CERTIFICATE OF COUNSELPursuant to Local Rule 5.1, counsel for Plaintiff certifies that the font andpoint size, TimesNew Roman 14 point, used in this document, comply with LocalRule 5.1.

Veal Intellectual Property, LLC/s/ Robert J. VealRobert J. VealVeal Intellectual Property, LLC11555 Medlock Bridge RoadSuite 100Johns Creek, GA 30097Tel: (678) 653-4758Fax: (678) [email protected]

11


12/22

JS44 (Rev. 1/13 NDGA) CIVIL COVER SHEETThe JS44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replace nor supplement the filing and service of pleadings or other papers as required by law, except as

provided by local rules of court. This form is required for the use of the Clerk of Court for the purpose of initiating the civil docket record. (SEE INSTRUCTIONS ATTACHED)

I. (a) PLAINTIFF(S) DEFENDANT(S)

(b)COUNTY OF RESIDENCE OF FIRST LISTED COUNTY OF RESIDENCE OF FIRST LISTED

PLAINTIFF DEFENDANT

(EXCEPT IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES) (IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES ONLY)

NOTE: IN LAND CONDEMNATION CASES, USE THE LOCATION OF THE TRACT OF

LAND INVOLVED

(c) ATTORNEYS (FIRM NAME, ADDRESS, TELEPHONE NUMBER, AND ATTORNEYS (IF KNOWN) E-MAIL ADDRESS)

II. BASIS OF JURISDICTION III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES(PLACE AN X IN ONE BOX ONLY) (PLACE AN X IN ONE BOX FOR PLAINTIFF AND ONE BOX FOR DEFENDANT)

(FOR DIVERSITY CASES ONLY)

PLF DEF PLF DEF

1 U.S. GOVERNMENT 3 FEDERAL QUESTION 1 1 CITIZEN OF THIS STATE 4 4 INCORPORATED OR PRINCIPAL

PLAINTIFF (U.S. GOVERNMENT NOT A PARTY) PLACE OF BUSINESS IN THIS STATE

2 U.S. GOVERNMENT 4 DIVERSITY 2 2 CITIZEN OF ANOTHER STATE 5 5 INCORPORATED AND PRINCIPAL

DEFENDANT (INDICATE CITIZENSHIP OF PARTIES PLACE OF BUSINESS IN ANOTHER

IN ITEM III) STATE

3 3 CITIZEN OR SUBJECT OF A

FOREIGN COUNTRY 6 6 FOREIGN NATION

IV. ORIGIN (PLACE AN X IN ONE BOX ONLY) TRANSFERRED FROM APPEAL TO DISTRICT JUDGE

1 ORIGINAL 2 REMOVED FROM 3 REMANDED FROM 4 REINSTATED OR 5 ANOTHER DISTRICT 6 MULTIDISTRICT 7 FROM MAGISTRATE JUDGE

PROCEEDING STATE COURT APPELLATE COURT REOPENED (Specify District) LITIGATION JUDGMENT

V. CAUSE OF ACTION (CITE THE U.S. CIVIL STATUTE UNDER WHICH YOU ARE FILING AND WRITE A BRIEF STATEMENT OF CAUSE - DO NOT CITE

JURISDICTIONAL STATUTES UNLESS DIVERSITY)

(IF COMPLEX, CHECK REASON BELOW)

1. Unusually large number of parties. 6. Problems locating or preserving evidence

2. Unusually large number of claims or defenses. 7. Pending parallel investigations or actions by government.

3. Factual issues are exceptionally complex 8. Multiple use of experts.

4. Greater than normal volume of evidence. 9. Need for discovery outside United States boundaries.

5. Extended discovery period is needed. 10. Existence of highly technical issues and proof.

CONTINUED ON REVERSEFOR OFFICE USE ONLY

RECEIPT # AMOUNT $ APPLYING IFP MAG. JUDGE (IFP)

JUDGE MAG. JUDGE NATURE OF SUIT CAUSE OF ACTION _

(Referral)

International Business Corportation Onward Manufacturing Company, Limited,Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., and Amazon.com, Inc.

Forsyth

Robert J. VealVeal Intellectual Property, LLC11555 Medlock Bridge Road, Suite 100Johns Creek, GA [email protected]

2:13-cv-139-WCO

s

Patent Infringement Under 35 USC 271, Infringement of a Design Patent

s

Forsyth

Case 2:13-cv-00139-WCO Document 1-1 Filed 06/26/13 Page 1 of 2


13/22

VI. NATURE OF SUIT (PLACE AN X IN ONE BOX ONLY)

CONTRACT - "0" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK150 RECOVERY OF OVERPAYMENT &

ENFORCEMENT OF JUDGMENT152 RECOVERY OF DEFAULTED STUDENT

LOANS (Excl. Veterans)153 RECOVERY OF OVERPAYMENT OF

VETERAN'S BENEFITS

CONTRACT - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK

110 INSURANCE120 MARINE

130 MILLER ACT140 NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENT151 MEDICARE ACT160 STOCKHOLDERS' SUITS

190 OTHER CONTRACT195 CONTRACT PRODUCT LIABILITY

196 FRANCHISE

REAL PROPERTY - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK

210 LAND CONDEMNATION220 FORECLOSURE230 RENT LEASE & EJECTMENT240 TORTS TO LAND245 TORT PRODUCT LIABILITY

290 ALL OTHER REAL PROPERTY

TORTS - PERSONAL INJURY - "4" MONTHS

DISCOVERY TRACK

310 AIRPLANE315 AIRPLANE PRODUCT LIABILITY320 ASSAULT, LIBEL & SLANDER330 FEDERAL EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY340 MARINE

345 MARINE PRODUCT LIABILITY350 MOTOR VEHICLE355 MOTOR VEHICLE PRODUCT LIABILITY360 OTHER PERSONAL INJURY362 PERSONAL INJURY - MEDICAL

MALPRACTICE

365 PERSONAL INJURY - PRODUCT LIABILITY367 PERSONAL INJURY - HEALTH CARE/

PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCT LIABILITY368 ASBESTOS PERSONAL INJURY PRODUCT

LIABILITY

TORTS - PERSONAL PROPERTY - "4" MONTHS

DISCOVERY TRACK370 OTHER FRAUD371 TRUTH IN LENDING380 OTHER PERSONAL PROPERTY DAMAGE385 PROPERTY DAMAGE PRODUCT LIABILITY

BANKRUPTCY - "0" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK

422 APPEAL 28 USC 158423 WITHDRAWAL 28 USC 157

CIVIL RIGHTS - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK

441 VOTING442 EMPLOYMENT

443 HOUSING/ ACCOMMODATIONS444 WELFARE440 OTHER CIVIL RIGHTS445 AMERICANS with DISABILITIES - Employment446 AMERICANS with DISABILITIES - Other448 EDUCATION

IMMIGRATION - "0" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK462 NATURALIZATION APPLICATION465 OTHER IMMIGRATION ACTIONS

PRISONER PETITIONS - "0" MONTHS DISCOVERYTRACK463 HABEAS CORPUS- Alien Detainee510 MOTIONS TO VACATE SENTENCE530 HABEAS CORPUS

535 HABEAS CORPUS DEATH PENALTY540 MANDAMUS & OTHER550 CIVIL RIGHTS - Filed Pro se555 PRISON CONDITION(S) - Filed Pro se560 CIVIL DETAINEE: CONDITIONS OF

CONFINEMENT

PRISONER PETITIONS - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK550 CIVIL RIGHTS - Filed by Counsel555 PRISON CONDITION(S) - Filed by Counsel

FORFEITURE/PENALTY - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK625 DRUG RELATED SEIZURE OF PROPERTY

21 USC 881

690 OTHER

LABOR - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK710 FAIR LABOR STANDARDS ACT720 LABOR/MGMT. RELATIONS740 RAILWAY LABOR ACT751 FAMILY and MEDICAL LEAVE ACT790 OTHER LABOR LITIGATION791 EMPL. RET. INC. SECURITY ACT

PROPERTY RIGHTS - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK820 COPYRIGHTS840 TRADEMARK

PROPERTY RIGHTS - "8" MONTHS DISCOVERY TRACK830 PATENT

SOCIAL SECURITY - "0" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK861 HIA (1395ff)

862 BLACK LUNG (923)863 DIWC (405(g))863 DIWW (405(g))864 SSID TITLE XVI865 RSI (405(g))

FEDERAL TAX SUITS - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK870 TAXES (U.S. Plaintiff or Defendant)871 IRS - THIRD PARTY 26 USC 7609

OTHER STATUTES - "4" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK375 FALSE CLAIMS ACT400 STATE REAPPORTIONMENT

430 BANKS AND BANKING450 COMMERCE/ICC RATES/ETC.460 DEPORTATION470 RACKETEER INFLUENCED AND CORRUPT

ORGANIZATIONS480 CONSUMER CREDIT

490 CABLE/SATELLITE TV891 AGRICULTURAL ACTS893 ENVIRONMENTAL MATTERS895 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT950 CONSTITUTIONALITY OF STATE STATUTES890 OTHER STATUTORY ACTIONS

899 ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES ACT /REVIEW OR APPEAL OF AGENCY DECISION

OTHER STATUTES - "8" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK410 ANTITRUST850 SECURITIES / COMMODITIES / EXCHANGE

OTHER STATUTES - 0" MONTHS DISCOVERY

TRACK896 ARBITRATION

(Confirm / Vacate / Order / Modify)

* PLEASE NOTE DISCOVERYTRACK FOR EACH CASE TYPE.SEE LOCAL RULE 26.3

VII. REQUESTED IN COMPLAINT:

CHECK IF CLASS ACTION UNDER F.R.Civ.P. 23 DEMAND $_____________________________

JURY DEMAND YES NO (CHECK YES ONLY IF DEMANDED IN COMPLAINT)

VIII. RELATED/REFILED CASE(S) IF ANY JUDGE_______________________________ DOCKET NO._______________________

CIVIL CASES ARE DEEMED RELATED IF THE PENDING CASE INVOLVES: (CHECK APPROPRIATE BOX)

1. PROPERTY INCLUDED IN AN EARLIER NUMBERED PENDING SUIT.

2. SAME ISSUE OF FACT OR ARISES OUT OF THE SAME EVENT OR TRANSACTION INCLUDED IN AN EARLIER NUMBERED PENDING SUIT.

3. VALIDITY OR INFRINGEMENT OF THE SAME PATENT, COPYRIGHT OR TRADEMARK INCLUDED IN AN EARLIER NUMBERED PENDING SUIT.

4. APPEALS ARISING OUT OF THE SAME BANKRUPTCY CASE AND ANY CASE RELATED THERETO WHICH HAVE BEEN DECIDED BY THE SAME

BANKRUPTCY JUDGE.

5. REPETITIVE CASES FILED BY PRO SE LITIGANTS.

6. COMPANION OR RELATED CASE TO CASE(S) BEING SIMULTANEOUSLY FILED (INCLUDE ABBREVIATED STYLE OF OTHER CASE(S)):

7. EITHER SAME OR ALL OF THE PARTIES AND ISSUES IN THIS CASE WERE PREVIOUSLY INVOLVED IN CASE NO. , WHICH WAS

DISMISSED. This case IS IS NOT (check one box) SUBSTANTIALLY THE SAME CASE.

SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD DATE

s

26 June 2013/s/Robert J. Veal



14/22


EXHIBITA


15/22


I IIII 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111c12) United States Design Patent

Lu

(54) BARBEQUE GRILL RACK(75) Inventor: James Lu, Alpharelta, GA (US)(73) Assignee: International Business Corporation,Alpharetta, GA (US)(**) Term: 14 Years(21) Appl. No.: 29/373,678(22) Filed: May 10, 2011(51 ) LOC (9) Cl. ............................................... ... 07-02(52) U.S. Cl.. ........ ................................. D7/409; 07/354(58) Field of Classification Search ................... 06/462,

(56)

06/513, 566; 07/323, 329- 332, 337,339,07/346-347,350.1- 350.4, 354-363,391,07/393,395, 402, 409,538,542, 587,667;

99/324- 325,331- 332,337- 340,369,403-418,99/425-426,444, 450; 119/161, 166; 126/25 A,126/41 R, 275 R, 380.1 , 390.1; 206/501- 505,206/507- 508; 211141.2, 57.1 , 74, 85.4, 106,211/181.1; 219/400,405,435-442 , 620- 624,2191725, 730-735; 220/485, 491, 573.1- 573.5,2201759, 912; 248194; 312/266; 422/300;426/438 , 441 , 523

See application file for complete search history.References Cited

U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS1,514,375 A 1111924 Crimmel ......................... 2111741,947,932 A 211934 Fante ........................... 211 /85.401 62,925 S 4/195 1 Berkowitz ..................... 06/4622,956,686 A 10/1960 Garey ............................. 2111743,131 ,011 A 4/1964 Rittenberry ................... 3 12/2663,2 14 ,031 A 10/1965 McCauley ................... 21 1/41.23,532,225 A 10/ 1970 Reed .......................... 2 ll/1 8 l. l

USOOD648174S

(IO) Patent No.: us 0648,174 s** Nov. 8, 201145) Date of Patent:

3,858,835 A 3,955,682 A *4,350 ,253 A *4,572,379 A *4,830,197 A *0314,487 s *5,433,930 A *0365,481 s ..0390,056 s *0401 ,461 s *5,840,261 A *6,827,006 B I *7,281,469 Bt *7,469 ,792 Bl *7,520,397 B1 *0623,015 s *7,828,160 B2 +2005/0269277 t\1 2007/0205171 A1 ** cited by examiner

1/1975 Baren ............................. 248/945/1976 Baren ............... .............. 2111749/1 982 Ru steberg ....................... 211174211986 Wallo ........................... 21l157 .15/1989 Wallo ........................... 211157 .1211991 Bajek et al. .... .... ..... . .... 06 /5667/1995 Taschner ....................... 422/3001211995 McKeon ........................ 06 /5 132/1998 Pujals, Jr ....................... 06 /566

I !11998 Laga .. .. .... ...... .. .. . .... ...... 06 /5661111 998 Monch .......................... 422/3001212004 0 'Amato et al ............... 99/42610/2007 Barbouret at. .. ............... 9914261212008 Lin ................................. 2111744/2009 Segale .. .. .... ............ ...... 2 11/1069/2010 O'Arnatoeta l .............. 07 /409ll/2010 Lin ............................ 2 ll/18l.l1212005 Su .............. ..................... 211174912007 Iwata ......................... 2 11/181.1

Primary Examiner- Riel")' Pharo(74) Attorney, Agent, or Finn - Rodgers & Rodgers(57) CLAIMTheornamentaldesign fora barbeque grill rack,as shown ru1ddescribed.

DESCRIPTIONFlG. 1 is a perspective view ofa barbeque gri II rack showingmy new design;FlG. 2 is a top plan view thercoJ;FlG. 3 is a front elevational view thereof, the rear being thesame in appearance;FlG. 4 is a bottom plan view thereof; and,FlG. 5 is a left-side elevationa1 view thereof, the right sidebeing the same in appearance.

I Claim, 2 Drawing Sheets


16/22


U.S. Patent Nov. 8, 2011 Sheet 1 of2 US D648,174 S

FIG. I

FIG.2


17/22


U.S. Patent Nov. 8, 2011 Sheet 2 of2 US D648,174 S

FIG.3

FICJ.4

FIG.5


18/22


EXHIBITB


19/22

Case 2:13-cv-00139-WCO Document 1-3 Filed 06/26/13 Page 2 of 2ackyard Grill Chicken Leg And Wing Rack: Grills & Outdoor Cooking: Walmart.com Page 1of 1

WalmartS.,..,.,._,-,_ Uo. tbootUBackyard Grill Chicken Leg And Wing RackSe the f1st to wnte a reVIew

Shop at Waimart

In stores only Limitt!d stock m your o c a l . ~ ~ J ! ' i . ~ ? ' ! J ! I _ t ; store.F111d m anotherstoreSfl;), th.s r:;,;(l'l r 00060197015:,0 t."t ... rr-n: ~ ~ o . ; Q t ~ : r J I ; .C: ~ t ' i ot__ n .. , ;'Ciof

" t ~ r

Item Descriptior:The Backyard Grill ChiCken Leg And Wing Rack is porcela in-coated for easy dean up.Backyard Gr ill Chicken le g An d Wing Rack: Por celamcoated ror easy dean up Stamless steel ~ l o d e l ' l T7131550

Specifications

Walmart i'Jo.

Sponso red Links (:1:. "" ' ' )

http://www.walmart.com/ip/Backyard-Grill-Chicken-Leg-And-Wing-Rack/23565887

To p of Page

6113 /2013


20/22


21/22

Case 2:13-cv-00139-WCO Document 1-4 Filed 06/26/13 Page 2 of 3mazon.com: GrillPro 41551 Non-Stick Wing Rack with Chrome Legs: Patio, Lawn & G .. Page 1of3

Shop byDepartment

Your Amazon com Today's Deals Gift Cards Sell HelpSearch Pallo. t.a.vn & Garden Go Hello. Sogn inYo ur Account JoonPr ime 0 Cart

Patio, Lawn & Garden Best seuers sarogs & Deals Grdls & Outdoor Cook1ng PatiO Fumrture Outdoor Decor Gardening Mowers & Landscap.ng Too1s Home Improvement

GriiiPro 41551 Non-Stick Wing Rack withChrome Legs~Be the first ro review this 1tem or

WishList

~ 5.i.Q.QjQ. to turn on l CIIck. ordering.Pnce: $11.29 & FREE Shipping on orders ove r $25.

DetailsUsually ships within 1 to 2 months.Ships from and so ld by Amazon.com. Gift-wrap availabl e.

Non-sticl< coated wire wing rack with folding legs Best way to roast chiclhipping: This Item Is also available fo r shipping to select countries outside th e U.S.

http://www.amazon.com/dp/BOOATQR35U/ref=asc_df_BOOATQR35U2562480?smid=AT... 6/21/2013


22/22

Case 2:13-cv-00139-WCO Document 1-4 Filed 06/26/13 Page 3 of 3mazon.com: GrillPro 41551 Non-Stick Wing Rack with Chrome Legs: Patio, Lawn & G .. Page 2 of3

Origin: USAASIN: BOOATQR35UItem model number: 41551Average Customer Re v iew: Be the first to review this itemAmazon Best Sellers Rank: # 9,321 in Patio, Lawn & Garden (See Top 100 ln Patio, Law n &Garde_n )Did we miss any relevant features for this product? Tell us what we missed.Would you li ke to uodate product info, give feedback on images , o r tel l us about a lower price?

Product DescriptionGriiiPro's non -stick wing rack is a convenient non-stick coated wire wing rack with folding legs, the best way to roast chicken legs and wings on the grillwithout the hassle of flipping turning or sticking. For wings and drumsticks.

Product Ad s from External Websites (what's tho. ?)

Man-Law MAN-VlOStainless Steel BBQWing Rack$17.99+ $8.00 Est. sh ipp ing

Man -Law MAN-HY3Stainless Steel HotDog Griller$24.99+ $8.00 Est. s hipping

ShoppersChoice.(:g.m,. ShoooersChoice.com.LLC LLC

Se e a problem with these advertisements? -,!_t_ _ ?:'9!'!

Customer ReviewsThere are no c:ustomer reviews yet.

Detroit Red WingsBBQ Grill Mat$39.95+ $9.95 Est. shippingFox Sports Gear

5 star4 star3 star2 star

Share your thoughts w1th other customersWrite a customer review

i star

Customer Questions & AnswersBe the first to ask a question that you have.

l_ ----------Typical questions asked about products:- Is this gnil easy to Clean?- Arb the cushions 1n lh1s patio set comfortable?- Is th1s lawn mower easy to maneuver?

Bayou Classic Leg &Wing Rack WithFolding Legs (0. 71lbs)$9.89

Sponsored Content

Man-Law MAN-VSStainless Steel GrillTopper$27.99+ ss.oo es t. shiPPino+ $7.99 Est.. shipping ShoppersChoice.com.

Great American Soicc LLC(& ,

J Ask

Page 1 of 3

Advertise here

IBC v. Wal-Mart - Complaint

Documents

Transcript of IBC v. Wal-Mart - Complaint