i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R...

32
: 189 …………… : - / / / . - - /

Transcript of i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R...

Page 1: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

:189

…………… :-

/

/

/

.

--

/

Page 2: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

190 :

19481966

19841998

*****

19791988

195519901990

198119691950

Page 3: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:191

1-

. .

..

1 . .

. .

.

2-:

.

,.

!!??alia inter .

.

.

1

1998187.

Page 4: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

192 :

.

.

..

3-14

786 .

.

:

.

4-

2 .26" ."

21272)1()3(4)1 (26

2)2 (2318)3 (2812427)1 (14

231979219891966 .1949

3279)1 (75)1 (197712/1949

)(2)1 (4)1 (197712/1949).(

Page 5: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:193

324 .20)1 (

21)1 (""."

""3 .

.

14)1 (""4

.

.

..

:14)1 (

.:

..."

114"5.

:

. .

3694/1996)3/1999 (

A/55/40)(979810-6.45) (1966"

"21)1 (""21)1 (

67)1 (.5468/1991. .)20/1993 (

A/49/40)(1879-4.

Page 6: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

194 :

314)1 (26 .6 .

6)1 (7.

.

.

.

.

5- :

.14)2 (" ."7)1)( (

8)2 (6)2 (11)1 (

" ... ."

20)3 (21)3 (

66)1 (.

*****

13:

6202/1986 .)28/1988 (

A/44/40198-19910-110-12.7Eur. Court HR, Airey Case v Irland, judgment of 9 October 1979, Series, A, No. 32, pp. 11-16, paras. 20-28.

Page 7: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:195

" . .

."8.

:14)2 (

.

.""9 .

14)2 (.

:14)2 ("

"10.

:14)2 (

." ""

"11 ." "

"12 . .

."""13.

*****

" "7)1)( (

813)14(1247.9770/1997)20/2000 (

A/55/40)(1768-3.10577/1994 .)6/1997 (

A/53/40)(438-8.11591/1994 .)9/1998 (

A/53/40)(618-3.12.13.

Page 8: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

196 :

.26.14

*****

6)2 ("1 "

".15

" .""

."16

:

""17 .

. .6)2 (

" ."

"."18

:6)2" (" "

""26

14ACHPR, International Pen and Others (on behalf of Ken Savo-Wiva Jr. and Civil Liberties Organisation) v. Nigeria,

Communication Nos. 137/944, 139/94, 154/96 and 161/9731/199894-96 :html.97-161_96-154_94-139_94-137/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu/umn.1www://http.

15Eur. Court HR, Case of Allenet de Ribemunt v. France, judgment of 10 February 1995, Series A, No. 308, p. 16 para. 35; emphasis added.

16.171636.181741.

Page 9: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:197

."19

6)2 (

.20

"" "6)1 ()3 (""21 ." "

" ."

""22.

.

""23 .6)2 ( :

" ""

."24

.25

..

19Eur. Court HR, Case of Leutscher v. the Netherlands, judgment of 26 march 1996, Reports 1996-II, p. 436, para. 29.20Eur. Court HR, Minelli case v. Switzerland, judgment of 25 March 1983, Series A, No. 62, p. 18, para. 38.21.221940.2343214.2443631.25.

Page 10: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

198 :

6-

.

. .

.

6-1

17118 .

.17)1 ("

."11" :

"...8" "

" ,,,

."

.

6-1-1

." "

8--" "

Page 11: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:199

8)2 (" "26.

" "

" """""278)2" (

"28 ."

"8)1 ("29 ."

."

"

"30.

"."31

.

." "

""32 ."

"" "

""33 .

26Eur. Court HR, Huvig Case v. France, judgment of 24 April 1990, Series A, No. 176-B, p. 52,

para. 25.2752-5526-29.285429.29Eur. Court HR, Malone Case v the United Kingdom, judgment of 2 August 1984, Series A, No.

82, p. 32, para. 67.30.316833.32Eur. Court HR, Huvig Case v. France, judgment of 24 April 1990, Series A, No. 176-B, p.56-57, para. 35.335634.

Page 12: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

200 :

""34 .

8.

8

" "8)2 (.35

1991"

"""368"

."37

"

"38 ."

"39 . "

"" ."

""."40

34.35Eur. Court HR, Malone Case v the United Kingdom, judgment of 2 August 1984, Series A, No. 82 and Eur. Court HR,

Kruslin Case v. France, judgment of 24 April 1990, Series A, No. 176-B. in the case of Klass and Others8Eur. Court HR, Case of Klass and Others, judgment of 6 September 1976, Series A, No. 28..

36Eur. Court HR, Case of Lampert v. France, judgment of 24 August 1988, Reports 1998-V, p. 2240, para. 28 .

37224239.3822358-10223614.39224029.402241-224238-40.

Page 13: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:201

--

.

6-1-2

..

-8

.8)2 (

""41

" "" ."" "

.

.

"" " "

" "42.

" "" "

)1 (")2" ( ")3 (

""43 ."

."44

"

41Eur. Court HR, Case of Chappel v. the United Kingdom, judgment of 30 March 1989, Series A, No. 15-A, p. 21, para.

51.425624.432560.44.

Page 14: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

202 :

"."458.

6-1-3

, .

8 .

""46 . .

" "" ...

..."47 ."

"... "" "" "

848.

.

. .

. .

.49

.50

" ""

...] [""

452766.46Eur. Court HR, Case of Pfefer and Plankl v. Austria, judgment of 25 February 1992, Series A, No. 227, p. 18, para. 47.474719.481948.49Eur. Court HR, Case of Schonenberg and Durmaz, judgment of 20 June 1988, Series. A, No. 137, p.8-9, paras 8-9.5091011.

Page 15: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:203

"51 ." "

.:

"" "" ... ."

... .

.

"52.

" ""

."

"

6 ... .."53

8

.6-4.

.

6-2

)7

511325.5213-1428.531429.

Page 16: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

204 :

45)2 (3

""4 .(

)10)1 (5)2 ( .(

54.

55 .55)1)( ("

."

55 .

.

.1.

.51979

" :

"1990:

"16-

."

541984

19851987.554)2 (27)2 (

15)2 (2)2 (5.

Page 17: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:205

54)1)( ("

"55)1)( (.

71985"

56.

.

.

.

.

6-3

14)3)( (-"

."6)3)( (8)2)( ("

. .

""57 .10

"."

566

.57ACHPR, Media Rights Agenda (on behalf of Niran Maloulu), v. Nigeria, Communication No. 224/98

23/-7/200043:html.98-224/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://http.

Page 18: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

206 :

.14

"

1021111213

."

" "42) (

" ""."

*****

14)3)(" (

"" ""58 .:

" .

3) ("59.

"

"60

14)3)( (" "9)2 (9)3 (

"61 ." ...

"" "9)2 (62.

5813)14(1248

.59.60561/1993 .)8/1997(

A/52/40) (1519-2.61702/1996 .)18/1997(

A/52/40) (2325-9.62253/1987 .)8/1991(

A/46/402478-5.

Page 19: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:207

.

14)3)( (

.""63.

14)3)( (

64.

.14")

(""

14 "14)3)( (

"65.

" ."" "

" ... ""

"66 ."

.14)3)(()()() )67.

*****

63561/1993 .)8/1997(

A/52/40)(1519-2.64R.14/63.)28/1981(

A/37/401202011916-2.6516/1977 .)25/1983(

A/38/4013814-114-2.6614-2.67.

Page 20: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

208 :

8)2)( (" "

2/19946/ "68.

*****

6)3)( (" "

" ".69

6)3)( (

. ."

][]6)3)( [(

."70

.

.

6-4

.)14)3)( (7)1)( (

6)3)( ((8)2)( ("

") .(

.

68I-A Court HR, Castillo Petruzzi et al. case v. Peru, judgment of May 30, 1999, Series C, No. 52, p. 202, paras. 141-142 read in

conjunction with p. 201, para. 138.69Eur. Court. HR, Case of Steel and Others v. the United Kingdom, judgment of 23 September 1998, Reports 1998-VII, p. 2741,

para. 85.70Eur. Court HR, Case of Brozicek v. Italy, judgment of 19 December 1989, Series A, No. 167, p. 18, para. 41.

Page 21: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:209

931955

"

. .

."

18

"1- .

2-.

3-

.

4-.

5-

.

15" ."

207"71.

42)(‘1 ‘ .67) (

" ""

."67) ("

7114011.

Page 22: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

210 :

."65.

*****

14)3 (72

73.

.

*****

7)1)( ("

."74.

*****

" "

93)73 (5:

"

. .

.

"75.

72

R.2/8 . .)3/1980 (A/35/4011816R.1/6

. .)29/1980 (13116.73R.7/28 .)29/1980(

A/36/4011916.74

ACHPR, Media Rights Agenda (on behalf of Niran Malaolu) v. Nigeria, Communication No. 224/98

23/-6/200055-56 :http://www1.umn.edu/humanrts/africa/comcases/224-98.html.

75Eur. Court HR, Case of S. v. Switzerland, judgment of 28 November 1991, Series A, No. 220, p. 15, para. 48; emphasis added.

Page 23: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:211

"

"6)3)( (" .

"76.

. .6)3)( (

. .

" ".

6)3)( ("

"" ."" "

" " .""."77

.

14 .6

6)3("

"78 .6)3)( (

"."79

:

764816.7749.78Eur. Court HR, Case of John Murray v. the United Kingdom, judgment of 8 February 1996, Reports 1996-I, p. 54, para. 62.79.

Page 24: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

212 :

"63-

.6

. .

."80

:

15" "1987)

"81 .) (1988 .

..." . ...

. .

82.

"6 ""

--6."83

.

.

80545563.815564.8266.83.

Page 25: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:213

6-5/

14)3)( (" ."8)2)( (

" "8)3 (" ."

.

.16

.84

55)1)( (20)4)( (21)4)( (

.

*****

14)3)( (" ."

"."85

.

*****

.42)(‘3 ‘

55)2)( ( .:

84166-2.85139/1983 .)17/1985(

A/40/40202109-2201 .159/1983 .)27/1987(

A/43/4010190.

Page 26: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

214 :

"

6 ... .

6"86.

) (19893" "1988

. .

"" "."87

.

" ," "

"

"."88

" ""

""

." """89 .

" ... ."

"

."90

86Eur. Court HR, Case of John Murray v. the United Kingdom, judgment of 8 February 1996, Reports 1996-I, p. 49, para. 45;

emphasis added.873820.884946.8947.90.

Page 27: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:215

)( ..."6

."91

" ."" "

"."92

"

."93

/ .

*****

:55)2)( (

"") .(

.:

55)2)( (" "

"

.

91495047.925151.93.

Page 28: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

216 :

6-6

.207"

."94

23:

"1-

.

2-1."

43"

"43 .)43‘4‘.(

.

6-7

14)3)( ("

."8)2)( (" "6)3)( (

" ."7)1 ("

."2021

14") "20)4)((

21)4)( .((

9414011.

Page 29: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:217

.

*****

"

951314""

."96

"""

."97

" "

"14)3)((98 .

.

"

""""" ""99.

" ""

"100 ." " ""

"" "

95349/1989 .)27/1992(

A/47/403158-4702/1996 .)18/1997(A/52/402325-10.

961249.97.98528/1993 .)2/1997(

A/52/40)(2610-299349/1989 .)27/1992(

A/47/403158-4.1003113-4.

Page 30: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

218 :

)(""101"

" "102 .

14)3)( ( ..

14)3)( ( .

14)3)( ( .

." "

.

""103 .

""104 ."

"""105 .14)3) ( (.106

.

:14)3)( ( ."

."

1013153168-4.102702/1996 .)18/

1997(A/52/402325-10.103282/1988 .)31/1993(

A/48/40)(3510-4104.105.106.

Page 31: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

:219

107 .14)3)( (14)3)( (108.

109

14)3)( (" """110

14)3)( (" "

.111

.

"."112

:/14)3)(" (

" ."

" "" ""

."14)3)( (113.

"

10749/1979 .)24/1983(

A/38/4014817-314919.108676/1996 . . .)30/1998(

A/53/40)(1617-8.109R.13/566 .)29/

1981 (A/36/401881143/1979 . .)21/1983 (A/38/40

19614R.17/70 .)1/1982(A/37/40177-17812.

110115/1982 .)1/1985(A/40/4017817.

111176/1984 .)/1987(A/43/40(20716.

11220714011.113158/1983 . .)26/1984(

A/40/402115-5.

Page 32: i e S j R¾ n } R …………… ¾ R G h ^ R : W e S u W S a | ~ a R W S a R …hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL6ar.pdf · 2006. 6. 18. · Y U c T O c [ T -¿ T I j ` T : Y g U w

- :-

220 :

"114 .

14)2 (14)3)( .(

.115

*****

8)2)( ("

."" ""

."116

.

.

7-

.

.

.

.

.

114526/1993 . .)2/1997(A/52/40)(1814-1.

115451/1991 . .)15/1994(A/49/40)(1549-5.

116I-A Court HR, Castillo Petruzzi et al. case v. Peru, judgment of May 30, 1999, Series C, No. 52, p. 202, para. 141.