Hiroshi Mikitani - 新経済連盟 · What Japan lacks is not technology, but Global Business...
Transcript of Hiroshi Mikitani - 新経済連盟 · What Japan lacks is not technology, but Global Business...
Japan Again
Hiroshi Mikitani
What Japan lacks is not technology, but Global Business Management capability and Business Innovation.
We have to graduate from the moratorium-like system that protects companies’ top management with low capability and no vision, and to push ahead the renewal of the top management.
We need capital mechanism & law system that foster un-aided growth of companies through competition, and increase the efficiency of the industry through corporate restructuring and consolidation.
Sheer cash provision to particular companies and industries will cause moral hazard. Thorough deregulations should be executed for creation and optimization of the
market. We have to improve the efficiency of Japan, and fix the competitive disadvantages
imposed on Japanese companies. (including tax decrease) Japan has to get out of the present Galapagos social environment. For this, joining
TPP is a must. We should set some Key Performance Indicators to increase the competitiveness of
Japan, and create concrete action plans to achieve our target figures.
To Increase the Competitiveness of Japan
1
If we have more excellent top business managers, Japan can change
2
Apple’s stock price Top
Manager and
Stock Price
Japan can change if we can cultivate or invite excellent top business managers
Nissan’s stock price
2010 2005 2000 1995
1997 Steve Jobs becomes the CEO
2010 2005 2000 1995
1999年 Carlos Ghosn becomes the COO (CEO from ‘01)
We need a systems that allows individuals with high earning power to spend their money happily (Attract excellent top managers to Japan, and push up individual consumption)
Excellent top managers can dramatically increase corporate value
Method
3
To achieve these goals, we should set KPI for each of the 5 Factors, and make clear every individual’s responsiblility for each KPI, and carry out the structural reform
* KPI: Key Performance Indicators Indicators that quantitatively define the goal of an organization. By monitoring these numbers, one can manage the progress toward
the goal.
Source of Competitiveness of the Country: 5 Factors
Efficiency of the Country
(Low-cost Country)
Innovation Capability
Operation Capability
Global Expansion & Management
Capability
Brand Power (Excess earning
power)
× × × ×
4
Macro Economic Factors*
* Macro Economic Factors (e.g. exchange rate, interest rate) are also extremely important, but will leave it to the Counsil of Economic and Fiscal Policy (経済財政諮問会議)
To Increase the Competitiveness of the Country
Translate the 5 Factors into KPI, and clearly assign the responsibility to person concerned.
Achieve all the KPI targets within 5 years
5
Example of KPI (1)
Factor KPI Current Value
Target Value
1. Efficiency of the Country
(Low-cost Country)
Government service cost (% of GDP) 23.1% Under 20%
ROI (Return on Investment) of Public Investment (hurdle rate) Over 10%
Corporate tax 38.1% 25%
Electricity cost Decrease by 30%
2. Innovation Capability
Business start-up % 4% 10%
# of Intellectual Property acquired by Japanese companies (include qualitative improvement)
Increase by 30%
3. Operation Capability
GDP per worker 23rd in the
World Top 10 in the World
Working population YoY* -0.6%
YoY +1%
6 * Year over Year
Example of KPI (2)
Factor KPI Current Value
Target Value
4. Global Expansion & Management
Capability
Overseas sales % of Japanese companies 11.7% 15%
English Capability (average TOEFL score) 70 points 80 points
# of students studying abroad (focus on Business Schools and Engineering School)
60,000 (as of 2009)
100,000
5. Brand Power (Excess earning
power)
International Tourism Receipt Ranking in Asia Pacific region
10th 5th
# of foreign companies that moved its HQ / Asia HQ to Japan
10 cases a year
ROA (Return on Asset) of Japan 3% TBD*
7 * To Be Determined
Factor1: Efficiency of the Country (Low-cost Country) KPI
KPI
8
Item Current Value Target Value
Government service cost (% of GDP) 23.1% Under 20%
ROI of Public Investment (hurdle rate) Over 10%
Corporate tax 38.1% 25%
Electricity cost Decrease by 30%
Factor1: Efficiency of the Country (Low-cost Country) Actions to achieve the targets Fundamental and drastic Improvement of the high-cost structure of the Public Sector
Efficiency improvement utilizing IT (e.g. more online proceeding, open up government data to the public)
Reduction of civil servants, revision of the compensation system
Utilization of the Citizen Numbering System (Have to be used both by public / private sectors)
Cost Reduction of Medical Welfare service including Reform of its system Revision of the inappropriate fee system (e.g. dispensing fee system)
Introduction of IT to the Medical sector(e.g. online sales of drugs, cloud sharing of treatment information)
Aggressive hiring of foreigners
Fundamental Improvement of the high-cost structure that is imposed on Companies based in Japan Strategic tax reform
Reduction of corporate tax
Incentives for the use of capital (e.g. continue the special measures of 10% capital-gain tax)
Cost reduction of the infrastructure costs (introduction of market mechanism)
9
10
Efficiency of Government Service Japan should aim for the best-class efficiency among the developed countries
Source: UN “National Accounts Main Aggregates Database” (http://unstats.un.org/unsd/snaama/introduction.asp), OECD Statistics (http://stats.oecd.org/index.aspx? )
Government Service Cost as % of GDP (2010)
Target 20%
21.2%
UK
25.3%
US
20.3%
South Korea
20.3%
Japan
23.1%
Germany
General Government Gross Domestic Fixed Capital Formation
Government Final Consumption Expenditure
11
Corporate Tax Corporate tax rate in Japan should target the lowest level among the developed countries
Source: Ministry of Finance (As of April 2012) * In the US, there will be additional State / City tax. For New York city for example, the total corporate tax rate is 45.67%
Effective Corporate Tax Rate
Target 25%
2.533.3%
US*
35.0%
Japan (Tokyo)
38.1%
35.6
25.0%
Singapore
17.0%
UK
24.0%
South Korea
24.2%
China
25.0%
Germany (average)
29.5%
France
(Seoul) (Federal)
Special tax for disaster relief
【Ref】 Tax Issue of Global Company
• Google avoids tax using the tax heaven in Bermuda. Expert estimates its tax rate to be 2.4%.
• Amazon avoids tax outside of the US by booking its overseas revenue to its US HQ
12
Energy Cost Japan’s energy cost is high compared to other developed nations
Source: Cabinet Office’s research on 2010
Utility Cost (Indexed; Japan = 100)
Target Decrease by 30%
117
667564100
Japan UK US France Germany
78725756
100
Japan UK US France Germany
Electricity
City gas
13
Factor2: Innovation Capability KPI
14
KPI Item Current Value Target Value
Business start-up % * 4% 10%
# of Intellectual Property acquired by Japanese companies (include qualitative improvement) Increase by 30%
* Business Discontinue % = # of company shut down in the year / Total # of companies last year
Factor2: Innovation Capability Actions to achieve the targets
15
Improvements of Business Innovation and Technology Innovation
Creation of Environment that fosters Business Innovation Creation of new market through deregulation
Separation of electrical power production and distribution / retailing Allowing Treatment partially covered by the insurance Fostering the ecology / reusable energy industry (e.g. tax benefits)
Establishment of eco-system that fosters start-ups Support measures for venture investment (e.g. tax benefits) Revision of the present Act of the control of moneylending business (volume,
interest rate)
Creation of Environment that fosters Technology Innovation Support measures for R&D activities (e.g. tax benefits) Intellectual Property strategy (e.g. IP acquisition supports for companies,
promotion of mutual recognition) Acceleration of inviting foreign experts
16
Technological Capability, not utilized well
Source: WEF “Global Competitiveness Report 2012-13”
Innovation Ranking by World Economic Forum (2012)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
10
16
Switzerland Finland Israel Sweden Japan US Germany
UK
South Korea
Japan’s technology level is world top class
Japan needs to cultivate the business innovation capability that turns the good technology into good business
Japan’s high technological capability is not reflected in Japan’s industry competitiveness
Example of Japan’s Industry Competitiveness CE* Manufacturer Market cap Ranking (USD Bn)
4
8
15
16
19
22
23
162
527
Sony
Panasonic
Toshiba
Dell
HP
Fujitsu
Nokia
Samsung
Apple
* Consumer Electronics Source: Datamonitor (As of March 20th, 2012)
Sum of Japan’s top 4 is 72, which is less than half of Samsung
17
Metabolism (Renewal) in Japan, Low Japan is not good at creating new businesses, thus both the start-up % and discontinue % are low
Target 10%
Japan
Japan
US
US
UK
UK
Business Start-up %
Business Discontinue % (Year)
(Year)
Source:The SME Agency • Business Start up % = # of company started in the year / Total # of companies last year • Business Discontinue % = # of company shut down in the year / Total # of companies last year
Factor3: Operation Capability KPI
18
KPI Item Current Value Target Value
GDP per worker 23rd in the World Top 10 in the World
Working population YoY -0.6%
YoY +1%
Factor3: Operation Capability Actions to achieve the targets
Securing workforce under population decline Empowering women (e.g. more childcare, promotion of teleworking) Empowering foreigners (e.g. easing the procedure for foreigners to work
/ live in Japan)
19
Improvement of Labor Productivity Shift from middle-age courtesy to vitalization of the young
Job security for the young
Adoption of White Collar Exemption Making it flexible to move HR (e.g. easing of dismissal regulation)
Leveraging IT (e.g. tax benefits for IT investment) Awareness raising for productivity improvement
Rewarding companies that drastically improved the productivity (Deming Prize)
20
GDP per worker Japan’s GDP per worker is ranked 23rd in the world, which is very low among the developed nations
GDP per worker (USD; 2011)
43,276
44,567
45,158
47,884
51,303
52,948
55,092
56,749
65,798
68,156
-35%
Germany
Japan
South Korea
UK
Sweden
Taiwan
Belgium
Ireland
Hong Kong
US
Source: International Labour Organization(ILO)
1
25
23
21
10
5
4
3
2
Target Top 10
16
21
Working Population Working population in Japan is decreasing, which is the huge concern for Japan’s competitiveness
Historical change of Working population in Japan
Source: Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications
Target +1%
Working Population
(Mn)
YoY
66.5
67.0
67.5
66.0
0.0
2011 2010 2005 2000
65.9
68.0
-0.6% -0.3% -0.4% -0.3%
-0.9%
-0.2% -0.2% -0.1%
0.3% 0.2% 0.1%
-0.4%
22
Factor4: Global Expansion & Management Capability KPI
KPI Item Current Value Target Value
Overseas sales % of Japanese companies 11.7% 15%
English Capability (average TOEFL score) 70 points 80 points
# of students studying abroad (focus on Business Schools and Engineering School)
60,000 (as of 2009)
100,000
Factor4: Global Expansion & Management Capability Actions to achieve the targets (1/2)
Joining TPP Accelerating the introduction of IFRS Increasing the quality of Top Business Managers and Human Resource
Establishing a system that attract top talents from around the world Revision of the excessive progressive tax
To accelerate the introduction of stock-based compensation (e.g. introduction of classified stock)
Educational reform to cultivate world-class business people Enhancement of English education (adopt TOEFL for university / civil-servant exams)
Enhancement of IT education (including basic programming in the curriculum)
Cultivation of strategic thinking (establishing high-quality business schools in Japan)
Stimulate going to schools overseas (mainly for business schools and engineering schools) Incentive system to promote studying abroad (e.g. revision of the tax deduction law for
donation by individual)
23
Factor4: Global Expansion & Management Capability Actions to achieve the targets (2/2)
Creation of an environment which fosters companies’ global expansion capability, by the elimination of Galapagos regulation Terrestrial Digital Media Broadcasting (so called “Chi-degi”)
Medical
Communication network(Next Generation Network)
Radio wave
Securing the opened capital market, that brings market mechanism into corporate management Banning the extreme anti-takeover measures
Resolving the cross ownership of stock
24
25
Overseas Sales % of Japanese Companies Overseas sales % of Japanese companies peaked in 2007, and decreased since then
Overseas sales % of Japanese companies
Source: Ministry of Economy Trade and Industry, Ministry of Finance
Target 15%
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
11.7%
5%
13.0% 15%
20%
10% Non-Manufacturing
Total
0%
Manufacturing
26
Needs of Educational Reform and Stimulation of Overseas Study
We need to create the education system that cultivates world-class business people, and also to promote going to business schools abroad
Evaluation of Japan’s education system by World Economy Forum (2012)
In Japan’s education system, the quality of education related to industry competitiveness is relatively low
Source: WEF “Global Competitiveness Report 2012-13”
Higher education and training Total
Secondary education enrollment
Tertiary education enrollment
Quality of educational system
Quality of math and science education
Quality of management schools
Internet access in schools
Availability of research and training services
Extent of staff training
21
22
36
43
27
80
43
12
5
Indicator Ranking (/144)
Country 2005-
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
China 76 78 76 76 77
Hong Kong 80 80 80 81 81
South Korea 72 77 78 81 81
Japan 65 65 66 67 70
■In the past, TOEFL score was about the same between Japan and South Korea, but since Kim Young-sam started its Globalization Policy, the gap widened. Now South Korea ties with Hong Kong, where English is the official language. ■Since 1997, South Korea made English education mandatory from 3rd grade. In 2008 it started setting all-English classrooms, and also sending teachers abroad.
Average TOEFL Score of Asian Countries
■Number of students studying in the US South Korea is three times of Japan
No. of Students in US University (2011-2012) No. of students in US
university (Ref) No. of students in
domestic university South Korea 72,295 (2.18%) 3,320,000 (100%)
Japan 19,966 (0.69%) 2,890,000 (100%)
Gap of English Education against South Korea
Target 80 points
Source: South Korean Embassy
27
28
Students Studying Abroad Number of Japanese students studying abroad has been steadily decreasing since 2004
Number of Japanese students studying abroad
Source: Ministry of Education Culture Sports Science and Technology
Target 100,000
82,945
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
80,000
90,000
2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
59,923
29
30
Factor5: Brand Power (Excess earning power) KPI
KPI
Item Current Value Target Value
International Tourism receipt ranking in Asia Pacific region 10th 5th
Number of foreign companies that moved its HQ / Asia HQ to Japan
10 cases a year
ROA of Japan 3% TBD
Factor5: Brand Power (Excess earning power) Actions to achieve the targets Assignment of a Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) of the government.
Planning and Execution of a systematic approach Promotion of tradition and culture (e.g. publication of Japanese food and
traditional art) Promotion of mass amusement
Global expansion of domestic entertainment contents (revision of copyright law that propels online delivery of contents)
Elimination of limitation of foreign players in professional sports Exposure of Japanese people to globally featured events (e.g. Nobel Prize) Establishment of contents and services that attract foreign money
Increase entertainment attractiveness of big cities (e.g. Casino, easing of the Entertainment Business Act)
Medical tourism Making the Haneda Airport a hub
Pushing the attraction of HQ or Asia HQ of foreign companies (establish an organization like UK Trade & Investment)
31
32
International Tourism Receipt Japan’s tourism receipt is very poor. We need to increase our attractiveness and promote Japan to the world
Target 5th
10,966
11,044
12,304
17,518
17,990
18,259
26,256
27,686
31,443
48,464China
Australia
Hong Kong
Thailand
Malaysia
Singapore
India
South Korea
Taiwan
Japan
International Tourism Receipt of countries in the Asia Pacific region (USD Mn)
Source: UNWTO “Tourism Highlights 2012 Edition”
1
10
9
8
6
5
4
3
2
7
Case Study of Successful Japan Branding – Mongolia
14% South Korea
Russia 28% US 35%
Japan 37%
Source:Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Which county should Mongolia build relationship with going forward?
Image of Japan (top 3 answers)
Brand of Japan is well received in Mongolia because our ODA is frequently featured in News and many Mongolian Sumo wrestlers play in Japan
1. High Economy / Technology
2. Rich in Culture
3. Beautiful Nature
75.9%
27.2%
20.4%
Why do you think Japan is the country supporting Mongolia the most? (top 3 answers)
1. Often hear it in news
2. I can feel the support
3. The amount of support is huge
35.6%
32.4%
16.6%
・・・
Who is your favorite Japanese person (top 5 answers)
1. Kaiou (Sumo wrestler)
2. Takano-Hana (Sumo wrestler)
3. (Unspecified Sumo wrestler)
4. Prime Minister Koizumi
5. Takami-Sakari (Sumo wrestler)
91 votes
65 votes
34 votes
33 votes
26 votes
33
34
Average ROA
Average ROA in Japan is low compared to US and Europe
ROA of Japan, US, and Europe
Source: Cabinet Office
Target TBD
Europe
US
Japan
(Year)