F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

62
flJJ CLcq nJCJflq © U0ICC 1ACU 10 qiC 2OflICC o C) 110110 ccccq wo bVisbpe umA pc dnolcq qJonI cxbJIcII bctu2!ou bLoAIqcq qiVI © J P N0 bVV130 hP!0 bVIJCUV Vuq ffl S!IJVIC VII LI2 LC2CLACT 2JJOU 2CC1!0112 EC0UOUflC JCCVLCJF VU ob!u1ou2 cxbI.c22cq 9LC qioc o qJc Vr1qJ0L uq 1101 qioc 0j IC WI!OUVI LVUI 2BK-4Q4 iJ! bVbcL i bgu o .1BEI2 1.CUP bLoww m CoJ.b0LVIC L!IJVUCC IJVjC L0W qiC CCIJICL 0L BCCVLC1J 011 CCU4IA J)L!CC VI JC flUJACI2!1A 0( (JJ!CV0 uq 142h bff1J0 VJ20 VcpJ0IIjcqc2 j1J9IJCøJ 2IIbbOLI LOW IJJC C0UJ!0 M!0UV!C qcc JCCICJJC Vuq 2ICU!V DC NUL! vuq }V0J0 h!flbbO A01bW bLoqcq PJ1J? 0n11VuqpJ i.ccm.cp aucc COIJUC!F h'1W° COJIOLI! vuq FIICV hIJ!bbu uqft 2nbbJcq qw uq CLflCIVj uou oir uuq Ef1IOI)CIJ hPJVUCC V20C!VI!0U UJCCI!IJ2 111 N!JVU VU VI V CUJ!1JVL VI IC WUU 210C1C EXCIJVUC C0UCLCUCC o qic zcm.cp bLolcc1 111 owc VI flJC J4OPC! 2)%wbonm OIl q hflJVlJCC VI qiC KVbJVIJ äCI ACL) pcjbnj JC V0 pcuqjucq LOW qiC C0WWCIJI 0 btqcbV1u2 VI IC UUV! JJV)UJC WW1GJOU NVLCO KVIIr VA I1ICL V1JqLG CCL 1CLCW 21C11? vuq buccqVq? 1CAC LIUVIJ1VU JJJC flCP0U ilC LCCCIACq JL0W E2bCIJ CJCpO jfl]0 1VbbCJJT WV40 WV21U V Om.CC 0 CVb!w!e1, bLoulolcq pX IJJC EU1 IJVJ1q4 bCL wq UJOUCIVL! VIJCVU C 1P! bVbcL bi4 oj Ipc LCCC bI.olccI ou 1jpc CC0U 10 o bnp11c uq ipc I0CjC UJVLICCI MOACWPCL TÔÔ cV1IYpqqc NV on IO?O WVVCPflC11 V'" MVJJOMV BflIEVfl Oh ECOMONIC 1E2EVKCH j0Lpu bVbCL F!' i11VJC2 EVPIO bCUV NVI.C0 BVVU0 VI.4 EWbIIflCVF VMVFA2I2 RHA DO COWbVI'11E2 00 bflBIC 14BE! R0IcKII40 bVbEK 2E!flE2

Transcript of F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

Page 1: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

flJJ CLcq nJCJflq © U0ICC 1ACU 10 qiC 2OflICCo C) 110110 ccccq wo bVisbpe umA pc dnolcq qJonI cxbJIcII bctu2!ou bLoAIqcq qiVI© J P N0 bVV130 hP!0 bVIJCUV Vuq ffl S!IJVIC VII LI2 LC2CLACT 2JJOU 2CC1!0112

EC0UOUflC JCCVLCJFVU ob!u1ou2 cxbI.c22cq 9LC qioc o qJc Vr1qJ0L uq 1101 qioc 0j IC WI!OUVILVUI 2BK-4Q4 iJ! bVbcL i bgu o .1BEI2 1.CUP bLoww m CoJ.b0LVIC L!IJVUCCIJVjC L0W qiC CCIJICL 0L BCCVLC1J 011 CCU4IA J)L!CC VI JC flUJACI2!1A 0( (JJ!CV0 uq 142hbff1J0 VJ20 VcpJ0IIjcqc2 j1J9IJCøJ 2IIbbOLI LOW IJJC C0UJ!0 M!0UV!C qcc JCCICJJC Vuq2ICU!V DC NUL! vuq }V0J0 h!flbbO A01bW bLoqcq PJ1J? 0n11VuqpJ i.ccm.cp auccCOIJUC!F h'1W° COJIOLI! vuq FIICV hIJ!bbu uqft 2nbbJcq qw uq CLflCIVj uou oir uuqEf1IOI)CIJ hPJVUCC V20C!VI!0U UJCCI!IJ2 111 N!JVU VU VI V CUJ!1JVL VI IC WUU 210C1C EXCIJVUCC0UCLCUCC o qic zcm.cp bLolcc1 111 owc VI flJC J4OPC! 2)%wbonm OIl q hflJVlJCC VI qiCKVbJVIJ äCI ACL) pcjbnj JC V0 pcuqjucq LOW qiC C0WWCIJI 0 btqcbV1u2 VI IC UUV!JJV)UJC WW1GJOU NVLCO KVIIr VA I�1ICL V1JqLG CCL 1CLCW 21C11? vuq buccqVq? 1CACLIUVIJ1VU JJJC flCP0U ilC LCCCIACq JL0W E2bCIJ CJCpO jfl]0 1VbbCJJT WV40 WV21UV Om.CC 0 CVb!w!e1, bLoulolcq pX IJJC EU1 IJVJ1q4 bCL wq UJOUCIVL! VIJCVU C1P! bVbcL bi4 oj Ipc LCCC bI.olccI ou 1jpc CC0U 10 o bnp11c uq ipc I0CjC UJVLICCI

MOACWPCL TÔÔcV1IYpqqc NV on

IO?O WVVCPflC11 V'"MVJJOMV BflIEVfl Oh ECOMONIC 1E2EVKCH

j0Lpu bVbCL

F!' i11VJC2EVPIO bCUVNVI.C0 BVVU0

VI.4 EWbIIflCVF VMVFA2I2RHA DO COWbVI'11E2 00 bflBIC

14BE! R0IcKII40 bVbEK 2E!flE2

Page 2: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

iqa nhhoW $L3flM QI l3dfn3voM

cDIJauq oo Ifr1AMD ou iw 2I2YJAMA JADLSWIMH MA

T3AMTA

baa ((YI1) nh311o 3ilduq lthuu as lo arnaninn,3,b c1i 1ans lla3Fñqm, iqaq eidT

515ffl03 W .3i1oq !a!3namI baa in3m3vni 2'nsqmo3 B ff0 noiabb icIi lo E3flUP3fIO rfi

1iavhq lo 1qma 3g1a1 a lo aoiil tfiiw Oll 10 aai3thjwIsd3 ioq x di baa ina x, ,ili rliod

oi b33a151 1vi3ioq i OI as lo boozlibiil di (1) iadi bail W ia1irn1 lo aiaJ3qrno3 b134

(ii) 3i2 naqmo a ol baa iois !ahiaubni inavIi di ni ni1iaviq olin !ood-oi-ihsrn 3(11

bun laiiqa3 v1iup wn d3 (iii) ,1i1idaffioiq ni noiiub5i lannonda na d b3wollol ia OT

(vi) a13v31 ub3I ol tud 43wo, baa in3mivnl inupdu 3onsnft ol bw ion 21 niizi1 noqu

d 1as 3iup, d b33a13022a n3ilo 2131(v) ith,i nad lo 38o3 3(13 2ub31 3iIduq gtho

13(110 ioI naili 10111103 lo l3vofnw idic1 a d b3wollol i baa 2i3b1ofb1a11z rnh1o11no3

.23naqmo3

1aniS i1uJ ,in,nsq oidaq ofIEaq oriaM 223n!21Ja 10 1001132 3IBIJbSID ailaiI'b aonafl iloqaM lb kli2l3vinU

oa3utD lo ii21,vinU IQ 1anoiaM aiV olluiaD aiV 3ru2 di8e laa3 1011 smo$1 18100 iloqaM 108

Vô0ô JI ,oB3iñD YJATI YJATI $LflM baa

Page 3: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

I

p1I!ou II uq jooo GIubJo?GwO AG 2GIJG UJ flb pq $Jg JMJJIOU II 29G uq ,QfjO 6UJb1O?6G2 B6CJJGJ LOJJb pq

iu ou GjJ6q2 o JJG o&çiou mir? uo G iijA 20 qJ ouj? x

29iG0JGL2 !UGU!OU o qiAG24 IflJGL uo49ciou cu p9LqJ? pG n€q L0W GX UçG iutoLuJiow

oj 20fflG i wpj cu 22G22G ouj? p? ioou GX bo2 q&: oi. Gx9'wbI& COU4LOfflU

GX flJlG CJJLCGL124IC2 o q combruiG2 MprcIro bpjic OL IO L6920U2 EIL2 4JJG IUIbOLçS"ITCG

pu piu LGqnuqu Gx bo rnoLm9'fiou pjGj? combj€uiuç ip GAqGucG pJ2Gq ou

x ru GAiqGucG ponjq 2drwLG /IJJ 4G cçrwj o uociou !U bLcçic& LJJGL

ao UJGJJ02 2pofljq IiG couaiçJJç 9JJ2ELGL2: 4JJ6 woç/ o o bnpjic JCOAGLG ou pi2 oq o ol1ou ju BLJucJbJG q LGJGAU qGcl2Jou m9JcGL2 AG LiouJ GxbGc 10IJ2 4JJG

iipcp o bnpjic JJq L0uJ 46 GX B024 pGJJ'A!0L uq bGLLOLIJJ9IICG 0J 4JJG2G C0IJJJflJJ62

o qGcJ2ou o o bnpj!c cru G Ju6LLGq poqi L0W pG GX uç€ CJJ9L9'CGL12ç1C2 0 jJG combu!Ge

coudnGucG2 o qGci2iou ou comb'u?2 1UAG2UJGIJ4 uq ju'ucrj bojic? jpG

jp brb GuJbiL!cJIA 8'uJ?62 qJG qG LW11J9IJ8 o !u!j brzpjic oGL!u (Ibo) qGXCJJ9IJG 12 9 8OIJLCG 0 Cb1fJ

9'U2IAGL o p!e dnG2c!ou C9'U UCLG2G OuTL nuqGL2ç9iJqiu 0 JJG JIUCc!0U2 bGLoLmGq pA 2OCJC

C002G 40 112G brrpjic Gdcq4A WffLJ(G42 uq 201116 qouc flG2qG 1ç2 OPA!0fl2 IUIL!U2!C 1U46LG24 u

coujbuiG2 GAGU4fHJIA LG9CJJ P' ! 12 I CJJO!C6' JjJ12 G2 dnG2iou 0 MJJA 2OUJG couJbs'u162

cL022-26q!0ua'J uq CL022-C0fluL qijGL6ucG2 uqc9G blTpJ!c !2 uoç s' 2G ci- rJii bui€ C0UThLTJ62 916 11JUA 4111168 JFL6L 4JWIJ JJG 1AGLG bnpjicjA cowbruA JJ162G

06Lm9'UA uq rjA bnpj!cJA i'qq couibu!a 916 4JJG Gxc6b!ou2 L9'qJGL pu 46 LnI& uq da!G—

2JTC 2 flUflG bLC6I 2GLA!CG OL B6CJJGJ — 916 IJ04 BnpJ!c p O4JJGL UU9IJC!9'I 2?2lGm& pj

b6Lu o p8ç1IJ8 EAGU !U MGJj qGAGJobcq c9bTJ UJLJ6ç2 jiJG ;JJG fl 201116 J9'LG COUJb91TI62

combuA ypjonp 4JJ6L6 18801116 4L1I4JJ p1 4JJ2 JJ60LA 9JOIJG cuuo; 6XJ)J7pJ flJG 026LAG

IJJ0!A94!01Y JJJJG couAGu!ouJ aqom a bnpc 8uJbJA r 8416 !u cpc oiip bLocG22

q62CLpu 4G !U2 11410U9'J 2b6C42 o P!2 6C20U bLoAqu oujA jGM L6m91Jc2 ou i42 11II!IIJ9IG

JU9'UC6 y02 coLboL6 UIJUCG c6Xcp00J2 suq jAjA6L2 TeaT) J!'1P 4JJG1U26JAG8 40

IPG qGcI2iou o o bnppc !8 0116 o 4G fflO84 !mb0LU uq j624 24116 dn62ou2 !u COLBOLffçG

Page 4: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

'd i1duq o aeiaaqmoD dw o ueei 9di ias w audT .mndt ievonir aa noiiiirioni oq .e3usrrrIoh9q baa aDiiai1th1d3 li9di no uoitsmioThi Jaoq x baa sfaa x dod niu

io1 noismio1ni 9vfI ton ob '11aisn w dt ai 'buta s ibu o 89iJIu3fflib 9d lo 9n0

naiLsil b sb a w w ni9ldoiq ir1 emonvo oT .DiLcfuq o ton bib tsrfi ainaqno sf{t

bus b9hs1t 13i1dnq thtod o 9IquLsa isI a io noitsmioIni Labrisnft anistno3 tadt iaaqmo3 \I5vibsTt3 3W 9asIq taift 9ILt ui

. 9891 L879v9a Lii 9UUW ai 9a stsb aidT .amifi bI9uI I&isviiq

sodi lo 9lqmsa a nsuLt 191L1s1 iIdiuq o uso LauLt a5iaaqmo sill b noiiioqoiq sisI s svisdo

1sisviiq Th quoi 1oitno sisI 'isv £ no sLab svsd sw () tsrli si1qmi ir1T .3iIduq o bib fsrft

asinsqmoD svisdo sw () baa boiisq slqrnsa sdt niulliw DiLduq o ton ob fbiflw 9tnsqmo3 blsd

silt moil islina ton ob stsb iuo aunT .sioub aiuli siolsd aiss nsm oilduq o lIsutnsvs ibiniw

asiaaqrrIo silt iol !no bsbsllo nssd bail srlt Ii tuisasiq sd bluow tsrLt athd noibslsa elqrnsa

.Dilduq tnsw lLauts dDinlw

iWD35 iuisqmoo no noitamiolni sbubni edt SauiSD9d nitasistnt '19V oal13 sis stab iuO

asiusqunoD rbinlw Pa arniet sill isnllsdw stsuLsvs ot au awollis thlT .astisi husd lsuhs silt no bris

Dilduq o ot noiabsb sdt Ii lsaisvno bns 3ilduq o ot noia!39b ixsdi &fis a4nsd moil worioci

tnshoqrni ai sLab audi lo iulidslisvs silT .alnsd d bsislbo iisupsadua amisi sdi eis1Elis

.esinsqmoo o eas uft lsurtsixs o 3flhJO8 uthm siLt 915 thxsd asritiwo faom iii tsrfi rinsbiaiio

liass toni SIS 'buta aiill lo anoiaul3no sift o srnoa IsuLt ai tsasisb s rbua niau lo iaoD silT

silt ot bsilsisns liisaa9Dsn sd Ionins bus t9sjdua silt no sDnisb!vs .2.U silt ulliw slds1sqmo)

-isvsl4 .Js)FIsm boia bssilsiiqa9lsbnu bus bsqolsvsbisbnu ns asrl liiII rnslqxs SW . is!irnia sis asiliriuoo nssqoiu0 IsinsauinoD taom :notansmib aidi ui supinu tori ai 'lstI aaslsrlt

.llsw a asnInuo sasdt ot brisixs aaibnfi iuo 1o taom Psili t3sqXs oP sldsnoaasi ai ti !5IO1s1snlT

rlainsq iltiw buta iuo asisilqsi onlw (oI) llsna19 d bsbivoiq ai noitsiib audi ni s3nsbiv

ton io) sari ot nsqmo s abssl Isdw ni'cbuia id s1ohIsdT .etluasi islimia stiup abnil bus stab

lo arjoitsitasvni siutul idl *iowbrwoi sill sbivoiq ot sqod 5w ts*Lamn itups Dulduq silt (sau oP

.sqoiu LainsnitnoD iii ats*ism bots d bsslq slol ilmorios sift

oitsi lood-ot-ts*isrri sill ai 09! us b Iulidsdoiq silt nitDs1EIs loiDsi nism silt tsrll bnfi sW

silt iii saasl)fii uioi:Pawsb bwbusts-sao s :sbsit utaubth smaa silt iii arrnft rbirlw La

Page 5: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

JJGIL OLLOllJiJ V P! 9G MG 916 JSpJG O q ucqp MJJG4JJGL L9G qLob 6Cffl 9CG

91J6L 4JJ6 IbO 1J1626 ULW2 OLLOM LOW 9 J9L6L UIIWGL o 9UJC2 9LT LG1TC6 IJJG COUC6UL94OU O

Lm Cp9L9cGLi2çJc2 9uq OL L6qnciou iu J6AGL96 GxbGLJGucGq 9jcGL oiu bnpjic AJOL6oA6L

GUCG 9 LGqncJou rn JJG coç o pBuJc cLGqc JP! GC i bL62Gu GAGU MJJGIJ COIJ4LO!J1JJ OL

M6 9J20 qociim€i — 92 92 MG JCUOM OL JJG UL21 l!mG — uqGB6IJq6Ul IbO LW2 GxbGLi-

pii b6L2iç JOUGL JJOuTp 4O 9 211J9JJ6L 6X1GU1

IGAGL9G 1qj p€ 6jC qo uoç 9bbG9L o pG JUJG 4JJ6 !UifWJ JJLG6 ?G9L2 9UGL P6 IbO

JU OLcJGL O JJ OU p9'fl9U 24OCJ GXCJJ9UG8 M6 9J20 uq LGqflccJoIJ !' !UAGUJGU 9IJq U9UCij

UJ9JJGL GAGU MG COU4LOj LOL 4JJG 9C4 IJJ9I COIIJb9U6e WJ12I 9I2 CGL49IIJ bLo9p!I!A couqçiou2

T3'f F\JJJq(6J2OU J9LçCJf uq 2J'P Tô2) LP! 6GC2 2ULAJA62 9JpGIç cpG IU917J4J1q6 !2

46 uqiu p? A9L!0112 9II4poL2 u n (D6GoL6 9IJq GcJqJ9f12GL ra gIUI

ymou 4G bo8c-Jbo GGC JAG uq L6qJ1CçOU !' bLojç9pipA — bpuomuou cou2!a4Guç

26U8JIAG o MuqoM o obboLcnu!;

o UJWG bLoc6Gq LOUJ GJJ!IJ 2JJ9LG2 U 9 afIp2q9L? 8!IJCG JJ626 1b02 9L6 b9IcaJ9LJ?

JUAG2UJGIJ2 9'Uq LoM4p p? COUL92I JJG "!' jOLCG pGpiuq C9LAG-O112 9bbG9I.e O pG qG2JLG

q€qou o o bappc C9U 6 rnçGLbLGçGq 92 917 96IUb 4O L69J9UC6 4JJ6L p9J9ITCG 2JJ664 946L I9L6

9Uq 9'pUOLIIJ9J LOJA2JJ JJJG JJ 2 OJJOMG p? LGqITCIIOU ! !6A6L9G 9Uq !UAG2cIJJGUc 0 4J1G1L

b9u? (c9LA6-orf uqGbGuqGuç cousb9u!62 916 WOLG J!JcGJ? o bnppc 9jçGL UJ9oL iuAG9nJ6uç2

biipjic 9JCGU p? 9U JIJqGb6uqGu cowb9u? 9uq J97C613 p? 2ap2qJ91A o bnppcj?. q€q com-

M6 9JO Jq61J4iQ IT 21IJJC9IJ qIGL6UC6 PGIMGGU p6 9CçOL2 auqGLJ?qU IJJG qGcoU o

bLo9p!!!A coIJqoU8 ! OLqGL O J! 011 9 20C GXCp9UG

bLojçITpJ6 jJJJG2G LGJ1J2 916 L116 GAGIJ JAG C0UL0I LOL IJJG p9' iO mç 29I!A CGL91IJJ!I6J? o o bnpj!c I4 9JO LflG p comb9u!62 4JJI LO!A L92IGL 9Uq 916 IUOLG

IPG 8GCOIJ mo piiboz.9u q6GLmiuv e o combu?: J9LGL cousb9u6a 916

GCG7%6% 96L JJG IbO bom JO 4JJ6 J9GL GXbJ9U9çJOIr

40-poOJc L9lO2) 01 JTG 6U4LGbLGIJGI1L2 9çGUJb O UJG 4JJG W9LJCGç 4Pc

IIJAG2IJJGJJ4 UGGq 111 2GC4OL8 uJçp Jnp LoJA;p obboI4nu!!G2 (Imq coLLG2bouquJ? pp UJ9tJcG-

poojc L9ç!o 191262 p 1LP! bo2AG LGI9JoU2p!b WIT? LGll6C 9

Page 6: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

o C9'BI1LG jj o LGJGA9IJI co uq p6uGIJ42 Dl !mOc 9jJ o qIG GC o qcoufliqG2 OJIL GuJbiLrc9J MLJC JpG qGcjou o bnpjc o combjGx uo 2JuJG moqj c9u pob

jyi cçiou bLoAiqG2 9 GUGL9'J OAGLAIGM O JJG GX!2U 4JJGOL!G8 OU cp q6cou TO O br1pJc ip

i COmbG!u JjI6OI46

bLoic9pJ;? €cçou coucjnq brbGL

e JJqiG2 JJG CJJ&JJ62 JIJ OtAIJGL2JJJb 9uq COIJ4LOJ OJJOMJLT IbO a'JJq LGJ9G 4JJGW 4O bo2;-Jbo

ot u ou bLoç9pJ !UAGPJJGUc jU9UCJ boJ!c!G 9uq pG co o cLGqi Jiu9JJ? qiouou o comb9u!G2 G WG cJJ9L9clGL!2l!c2 9uq pGp9I 0L GCJO1J 2 LGboL4 JJG qGc4

comb9u LOL 4G AG9L2 i-es Gcçou f 9u9J?G JG qGGLuJu9'u o pG GC2OU o o bnpJ!c

bflç oiu GUJB!L!C9I LG211II2 in bGLbcc!AG P 86CIOIJ 3 MG qG2cLpG 4JJG 99 — 9 bnj o! IApJcJJ J9jWU comb9UIG2 obGL9G 2OWG pioLJc9J q9f 9 on io iiP o iibGmbiLic9J MOLJC cçiou bLoAiqG2 9 qG2cLbou o iu2ilnciou9J 9uq LGflJ9oLk GuAiLoumGu

b9uiG2 o bnpjic açLG2JIJ LG2bGc4!AG !mbJ!c9!ou2 9uq 9JO JJG LG11J4 o LGJGA9U

jp OL9UG 92 L0JJ0M3 2GCOIJ I cPG "-'s!" p2bopG2G2 pon ipA corn-

86II!IJ if couJbifIJ? p?. iurJ (T2COIJ4LOJJIIJ Lou1b GuJbp92iJu puboiuc o Ioo!U ifU IbO !' JJG bLocG2e O

JU 4JJG 4JJLGG ?GifL JOJJOMill IJ IbO fJJGLG ! J9LGL IJOLUJ9J IUCLG926 JU ITLIJOAGL O IJJG

buqic€q pA rw'q ifuq }AJ6 (rj) &uq 'Gua€iJ 91Jq GcJqu (Ta.Q) EIJif1IA MG iq 4JJ94

on uq JJG 9UJO11U ! nGff!AG!A COLLG!iflG MiqJ JJG Gx-bo8ç 9CcOffUiU bGqoLrnifuc&

LGI9IIJIU UJITCJJ IJJOLG 119'104 91CG D!A62cWGIJ49 9'LG IIJITCp j9LGL (Jg bGLcGu) OL C9LAG

bi.cGu o poJqU if pif q9çG uq bGLCGU UJOLG JG 2np2GdnGu 4LGG AGifL

o o bnpJ!c MpGu ifU JIJqGbGuqcU4 cornbniA J1U6L9JG 911 IbO PG !'!J OMUGL2 qA6el oujA

M6 juq flicjG GAqGucG boLoJ!o q!AGL2IJC91OIJ bJ9'A 911 !IuboLifu L0j6 !u 4JJG q6COU

p9uJ(8

4JJ6 if12J9pJJJA O 913 O1149jj6 OJ1LCG O i1uq2 !IJCLG92G2 if jLUJ2 P9L9!IJ!1J boe;jou i——i

2OCj( GXC9UG JrnbLoA62 JJG bappc !11oLW9!oU 9Ofl 9'COIUbifUA OL GC9I12G P!8 !UOLUJifc1OU

Page 7: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

iii bn 9d 'Ibvu1 nBD a9ilo9Lli 9aerLt duodMA .l9diona io 1bom no ni bstauLav5 used 9vad

.rneiLt inoil &Ioiib91q 3!dsi8i (9vieuIDx9 1!autirm ton) lo i3e a vh9b US3 9no I9bom 9Iri!a a .eIbom niarn 9di lo anoii3ibiq 9tht iiammua ew noib 8ifI o ti etht in bna .1 IdaT nI

3lduq nio b iao3 9dT 1.1

bisad Lsioui bus f10th33198 9819VbA 1.1.1

ndW .m9ldolq 9di lo tqa b3fb1aa1 1vibs tom 9d i 8oqi lo ao noibs198 e19vba 5dT

-nni t89is91 siLt svai! ibiifw sinsqmo iiLBup-wo1 i ti rzoLtamioIrii bs1isqmi svad aiotasvrzi

bna (ô81) d bsJdiIiIid aa — sDhq oi siLt 'Isaisvba 8ioelIa rbidw iIduq o ot svLt

b B&thq siLt taiLt bal sill nialqxs ot bs3navhB nssd asuf insmu1B irfT .no isial aisulto nam .s.v ts*isrri 'iabuos siLt iii asb nibsit tift siLt iii siiq ni8ob silt wolsd sia aniis11o laitini

bna isJtiSl naiufuoJ iii sviu silt ss) ioiLtus nam d bsinsmuoob nithqisbnu oi silt

.(!OI tivpb'$I

-mo3 llsm2 bna nuo b nitil sth ot sbstdo auohsa siom a ai iao rioitosls sisvbs silT

siLt iii o .asinaqmoD sial bna blo ioI nsult tilidi8iv bus bio39i bucti slitil svad ibidw asinsq

uftiw bstalsnoo lsvitssn sd bluoil ilduq nio 10 tilidsdoiq silt noibsls s8isvbs lo snssiq bas iuriarnmsdD d lsborn silt moil ssiscns noibibsiq aiilT .'nsqmo silt lo si silt io sa siLt

sial asil eisblorlsisr{a nsm of tiups lo suai oilduq siLt tsdt tulildid edT .(!I) iisidIu'1

Iiatns Jud tiofIs iotasvni silt lo noitsDilqub silt ot sub noibsllo3 noifamiolni lo amist Lii taoD

-ioIni asiminirn tsiLstiqa3 siutnsv slnie a d iiionanib stsvhq tasitno iii thiails-Isii insiDifis

.muirnsiq !eh isisl £ siolsisilt bus nuisd8 18i1 insi3fflsni esilqmi tud sto noibuboiq noitam

sliilw asrnsqrno rxwornl-sLttiI rwo ioI irisiffls si isi1st1q53 siutnsv a mon sDnanft staviiq o2

tlusi smsa silT .ssinaqmo nwonl-isttsd isblo ot bstius siom ei 'tiups lo 5u88i ilduq silt

staviiq isitxs ot svitns3ni as asil isblorlsisifs nulloitno3 siLt sisrlw alsborn Dfl55 iii snisido

lo snsssiq silt ui tsrll abibsiq (II) bnornaiU .aiotesvui Iainsfxs lo sauisqxs sill ta sillsrisd

sly ioivadsd iiainutioqqo timil LiSD oriw 4usd moi1 woiiod ssinaqmo riuo' biaail Isiom

.is*ism Dilduq ui tdsb sUS8i bio3si bait 3ilduq boos a iLtiw sinaqmo isblo sliilw niiotinom

Page 8: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

CT169 (IO) COUGX " LD L9C& UCGUI!AG bLopjGiu2 mEr?. OLCG COmb9'iJ!G2

bnppc i coa o EF bnppc orcL!u 9LG 91IWC!GU4J? P!P i 9 LGJ9çGq bib€i.e BP99CJJ9L?.9 9Uq

JJOMU 4JJ9 JU ednippLifim LUJ MIqJ IJJOLG 2GU2IçIAG J{D JUjOLW94JOU 9LG GGLLG pom OJ1J

bo!U4 o couqGU4J9Ji 92 9 G6LLGU4 Lom nuqiu iu bnppc EfLJCG9 A°2P9 (T2) i

2C0b6 OL 9X Gp19!OU 9uq GA92!OU LGI94!AG 4O bL!I.9cG comb9n!G C9mbpGJI (o) /A.92 ji o

W9LJ(G4iIJ açL9GrG8 JJJJGA 9JO ;pm 4O CJOG CLf7çiUA LOW ErX 9n4pOLJ7G& L6qi1CiIJ 4JJ6L

G CLJICJ9J LOL JJGJL cOIUbGçJ4JAG 9qA9U9& 21ICJJ 92 qEc9 9POiu OUOiU 1D bLo1Gc OL ITIITLG

JJJJG cflCJO211LG LJIJG2 O 2OCJ GXCJJ9JJG2 OLCG comb9rnG2 O IHJAGI IUtOLUJErJIOU MJJO9G aGCLGC?. W9'A

rr2 ro °L coIJq6U;9JA

bLocGGq2 o 4JJG 1b0

xGq co Gdrr8J 9bbLox!w9cGI?. S2OOOO 9Uq JJG A9L!9PJG CO 9LG 9pO11 bGLCGU O LO8

ip L6J9iAGJ? WOLG on m9'JJ cowb91q62: (ro) p' c9im946q 4JJ94 in flAI9IJ?. O JJGG GXBGU2G qo UO4 !UCL692G bLoboLc!ouErJJ? /P aG O 4JJG IbO nq GLGOLG

911JU CGLC9OU uq q92GUJU9OU oj ccoiTUU !UoLWEr!oU 2ocJ GXC9IJG GG

LG12L9JOU GG GC OU ob O IPG IU!4J9J 6XbGIJ8G2 OUG Wu124 COU2IqGL IJJG ?.G9LJA J9AOfl2 on

flG6 4G !11!f!9I IIUqGLbLICJUW o!u bJrpj!c !mbpG2 C0U2IqGLEJ'pjG qILGCl c0242: cIUqGLM.LiçiU GG

JJ GXb6IJ2G2

nq 4GLGOLG JOMGL ;JIG combn? UJITG o 6X6LIJ9} 9LGOJ6LW

249JG o JJG COULOJJIU JJErLGOJGL ! LGqnCGqe 4JJG !UCGU!AG tOL p1111 O GX4L9CI bL!IG GUGJ2

qJAGLic94ioU UJJ9LJ2. cJJG CJEr2C b9bGL p? 'IGUaGU 9'uq IGCJCJ!U (ia) bLGqc JJ9 92 JJG

pGJL coWb9U? I2 OIUGL fi8 LG49!U 9 aç9Jc6 o J9LG 92 O JUCIIL 9 CO HI 4GLIJJ O OLOUG

8Ambom pç comb9uA ! nnbLoffpJG LGIJJ o iUffJ pG bLo9p!J! oBL!A9IG !U0Lm9l!0U ffOfl JIG COWb9U? IPG!L A69IJJGU CErU G u4GLbLGGq p? UJ9LJ(G

p€ comb9UA 9GL 110 v 8pOJIJJ P rJ'-'q nq bJG (ma) !L PG !U!!9J OIILUGL9 p9'AG

L619'fl0112J1!b PG1)AGGU JJG 8JJ9LG LG911Gq p? 4JJG COULOIJ!IJ 29LGOJGL 9Uq bLo9piJJA ot

y €conq common bLGqqou o 9'qAGLG GJGqoU uq moL91 99L UJGJ2 !2 boiAG

Page 9: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

i bLIAT€ JpJ qii LJuciou cu G IccpiGAGq qaGccJA p?. qAGçu LOUJ combu? uq

combru MO boLqoJo2 J'L6 GuGL9'JJ? joEJqGq ap Gdni 'U rmij?. combru? MGU piJJIG qGciiou o bnppc iUCL6G p€ ecob€ LOL qAGL !COU pA qJ pJ4j JJOJGL2 O JG

T3 bI41.IO qiAGLiCJOu

CLGqI4 JTUG IIJCLGJ2G2 U IbO j4GL CoUlLOJI!n OL bLoJppçA suq

!UGLc L&4G2 9LG UJOLG JJJCGJA O O bnpjic uq JJ 4p6 CO O CLG JJ2 9uq 4JJG IIt!flA ot

poj ppJJJcGq pA jç1•u (T JpG bLGqqou JJGLG i combrn€ iijncp brA

combG!ou 4o iç J€IJGL riiq GIJ11LG I JOMGL CO O cb!9J JtL6L 2rIbbJA o GXçGLU9J U9UCG OL

UJfLJG4 9uq qiGUJUU JllOLUJ9'4iOU GIJ6LIjJA O IJAGOL 9 combauA GJ!C!42 oiiiq

JIJJOLWOU pOIi 4G CL6 O P!' IOIIJ6 BA 9'CCG 4O 4G OCJC

yJJOJJGL boGuçr bLopJm p'ij puj cu Gx4Lffc LGU pom cpG!L bLAJGGq

I3 CL piLquu boti JFU4JJ 9IJJC8

12 UGIAJA JJ2Gq coIubuiG2 ponjq uo !ucL6G 4JJGiL brAon L91o GL io

LGJ1CG 4pIIL qp Gxbo2nLG JJG 1b0 IJOJJ€L iiubpciou oj juucij COU2LU2

jL€o p moi.€ J!JA o bnpji& uq IJGMJA p2çGq COIJJB9'11162 ;o JUCLG2G 4JJG1L JIJAGaçUJGU

couçiiu o' p12 rcconui ou€ ponjq GxbGcç combuiG2 "P !LG iuAcm6u oflJA2 auq p!JJ

9'CG pJJJ !U6LG24 LG2 OL GAGU CLGI LiOIJ!U I"!" GX4GLIJJ GdfiJA CITIJ LGflGAG J2 IJIJItUC!U

bLG2Gucc O 1ULOLIJJIOIJI 2ATJJUJGLIG8 s combs'uA itjp JSLG GLUSJ puqu UGG2 mSA

jc€A GU€ o op bnpjic 12 O .SUJ S1C6S8 4O 9 201ILCG O 1J119UCG 9I1GLIJ91!AG O p9UJ2 P

I. I OA6LCOm!U pOLLOtArn COUSçLUU4S

jjj€ pu; o bnpjlc

PG J622 J!JGJA o o bnpJc

cowbGoLa q jogs o coIqJqGu4i9'JJçA is s LGJ6ASU4 COUCGLU p1p cp combsuiGs sponjq

!U0 pJJSGL9J GXCJJJSJAG LGJS4!OU2JJib RLçJJ 9 J6U6L IU OLGL O SAoq !U01111T!0U sb!JJ0AGLB ço

Page 10: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

isiIs Lsiiq& iiupe defñ sisi nsqmo df uivsif d Iieiibth io aas l9rLto lii i1l9Vni91

9rL th svzom iisiioqmi us i noifsfiiaisvib II .asiasqIno3 isdio th Ls b oi ildxiq o oI '1s!i1 siom einsqrno3 isb!aii sd (Cf) onss iii as i1duq o ot uoiiosb

esisda iisiLt lo noihoq 1sinsIadua s uiIIs aisblorlsisds niffoino sifi svisado bfxorfe siio bus

.abiswisfis f1OO 10 oqi S1i lo smit SuIt s

euilqkaib 9)I1i3m boi 1X 9rI seusDsd issusrrz bus si&Moilsisda n99W9d arnsldoiq ui9B 9uL 9a89139b iis iIduq thoD

snilqbaib ts*ism 1o exiuoa snO . smssnsm sni1qbib o a'sw Isnoiiibbs sbivoiq ts1ism 13o

issnsm nsdmuuii nsuL issd risqmo suLk nun uis odw aisbisi d isvos1s s lo isasb siLt i sd iii sAs Lsiini sis! '!JnsiDfflue s svsrl ot isbisi 1sllristoq siLl asliupsi ibiriw tusrnuis us)

(C1) sloiiT bus ruöiiamloH !uoitibbs nI .(O8(I uu1aiV bus isIisld2 'd uwoda as usqmo boia iii bsbsfisi noiismiolrn sib san us risqmo 9iiduq a lo aisblodsiarla sill isrb mo muioq

riixsbni d snslani iol aissnsm itsdl iol asmsd3a uoLtsansqrnoD InsiDifis siom niasb ol as3ilq

last Jonns sw isIsriuho1nU .anoiilqo boia msrlt rinsfio d 10 sniq boIa silt oil ashslaa iisu{t

lsiissnsm lo sinbuiIa sdil no silsb saoi3eib ion ob asiusqmo nailsilI saus3sd aiasrlioqul audi

uoiisansq mo

ilibiupiJ .$.I

Is iLsq1silnuoD a idl nuibissa lsmio'tni 'd lno bsbsii sd us esiasqmoD sIavnq lo asisria silT

flSD asifisqifioD Dildnq b asisil a sib aslilnoD iii .'hsq uiIsiiirii silt iol iaoD sldslsbienoD

no shsii oil ilnaw oriw aisbiodsisda llama iol l3qssfb ai rbidw sasrloxs bsinsio us rio bsbail

asilslansii sw 5Vilbd'ft5-I803 910ff! a iii alsb!odslsda oil asivise ilibiupil uibivoiq .SDiltOfl horla

tnsw 'nsqmo3 siLt lo aisuzvo IsuIhrzi sill Ii audT .asiail a ausqmo sill 101 5Di1 isrftii a otni

1nsqmo3 sill basiani II .Dilduq o oil InsmsDubui us svsil 'qsrll aIsbIofisisfIa bsaisqaib oil lisa oil

a1sbloris1ahla sisi wsl a oil 'lno aslsila lisa ilaum srli ailaos 'iibiupil ssiminim oil sisvhq asla

8

Page 11: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

woda (1) IIeo$1 bw ora9 naqmo 9di iii 3101 nhoinom biismb 11s19r1 111w odw

II .vhq sia r1t Ii nhoii11om-i9vo o vd 'm aiiwo 1itith edit i1uaei a

oa 83mo39d rIhoiuom-19vo idi o io3 9u1t 91s1 '19V 81 uot8nJqxs bsnnslq 9df lo 91&8 9iLt

erf n59wI9d noia19no 9vitiBoq abibiq o8Ls I9bom aids o .DiIduq o o 91d5191s1q a! Ii Lsrli

.tn9rnta&vth tn lJp3adzJa 9dt 10 9lia eiLt bni 091 n b 'ti1idsdoiq

uoiiiriozsi Io9vnI O..1

9dt lo noiisi1 llama a '1no nisino aoiloliioq bloil aiotavrn Iaom .sr1t EIW0JDI 119w 8! t1

nitaiJ .8J8ix9 asqmo niahe a arli ioni !qmia 3aua9d n1o a9it U398 fI1ta!x9

9fLt iol tilsm9alil5vba mis as riiba d m91c1o1q aimLt mnoivo o qI9d 1153 Jisfk)x5 1O(Sm S 110

9t91qmo3ui xliiw I9bom r±thq aas 1atiqs a xii iuioq aith b91utqs aad (8O1) noti9M .ca8qmoD

lo 3143W5 81ot29V1Ii lo I9dfflUuI 3mft ifEta31 911i idii1 sma aoiiq tadt niwor1a mioiismio1xii

b9tai1 bsi1s a3insqmoo 11911w tsdt bsI 9dt thtiw 9taiaxio3 81 aimlT .ithua axiaqmno 5ILt

L6mlond.s tn9n9q ö a eb19i" boia ibiLt AioY w3TI xii oals iail oI xioiab9b 1i9111 931111011115 919dw9819

.(t.I 11exiuI0D3M bxia 3915>1) 9519VS 110 iiiiit&i

lolinoD lo 9fxsI1D '.X xii qta ith lsmLtqo xis as b5w5iv 3d oats 1153 3iIduq xiio fsrft uo ariioq (söQQI) ae1ariiS

oi 9Aata inoriim a lb nu11sa iamLt 891J1E 3d Jx9xioo airli mx! .'naqmo3 a rii1L&a lo aaoiq siLt

a moil iSTtX9 11S3 ISIIWO laitiiii SILt aiilqiue lo ixiuoms siLt &assimn 'tam 819b10113151l8 beaisqaib

rn113a rloi&t ns 1911W0 lsLtini siLt ab9sDolq 1atot siLt mii8S913iIi 5)lsta JiioLsm 9dt lo 19"JJd siiitii1

lo SDfisbi3Ili dii1 s t3sqXs SW 09! siLt bxiidscf mzoLtavLtom fishoqmi xis ai aimLt II .QI5qfflo3 siLl

tfisxisd aiiLt dijorLt ta9ua (O1) asIarii bits 1rnfodsa aA .oqi sdi istIs aIsI&ISI1 IoTtuIo3

.aisbloilsisda sis1 d bSllolixioD asixiSqmO3 DiIdLrq 1o 93u19b1311! 9V18853X9 11ai3o8 8 soiibiii am

a tadi 8auidildid izriwita qhfri9ciwo 9iazoqlo3 9di o nia9b 9di 9Laaa (I) a9bbadT nov baa aoIo8 lo rthoiinom a'i9bfod91aIf2 1 abivoiq ud ibinpil nbuboiq b aw a9bffl9 as i 9asd b1oi1iarie b19qib

.985d i9bIod9lsfk b sitn9noD £ rbiw b91aqrno isasm

Page 12: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

To

UJ9'IJTGL8 LG491IJ 11J6 J9L68 2JCG 9J4}1Of1p 1I6LGUCG 18 UO c!!C9'IJ 2U1JC9'IIc

jpsq JG comb9'u1G2 1p jo bo-JbO bLopiJi 916 tApGLG GxJJU 0JGL8 uq

L61XI9'I1J L6J9'çiAGJ? J315 115 C01JçL&8 M4J1 'SIJ 911q 'e Jqc6J2ou bILICJJ q JJgp

u IbO (qoMu LOW U pOAG-AGwG J6AGJ 1J IJJG ?k691 6jpLG IboY GAGU IJJO11JJ 4PG!L LOMIIJ

LGboL4 obGur1u b.toLuwucG o comb9u!62 qGcJuG2 o p6JoM-9A6LrG JGAGJ j6L

ju w€u M1JJ JJG bLGqcou o 'uq jj (iJ AflJ(6J2OU B9LcCJf isq JJ9JJ 9'J80

pirç qsia qGcjJu6 18 8m9'JJ6L tOL LW2 IApGLG qiG O14UffJ G1J4L6bL6u6flL2 LGIU WøL Gdn!

qocauJu 1J6L GxbGi4cucG auijc'uç q6cJiuc iu ob6L9pu bGuoLuuruc&

p 9J2 p€u nqcq pA Kcbpu (ii) ruq DGG0L6 uq GJ9fl26L (3) '9JIJ uq gun9'uq pp (j MpiJG 155 JJG COIJ6X 0J JGAGL6 plTAOITç2 4JJ6 L6JTLU bnpJc oa156L8J1ib

JjJG oujA 2flG enqi62 tOL fl qça' r.€ pA 'jiu uq K!U! (i) 'uq pjqjouo bnpjic jJs moçiAG8 o p6iL q6ciou 'uq 8up86dnGu bGqoLwucc o coujbgui62

o UGtI bnpjic couJbu!G8 }6iA a4nqT68 OCJT8 IU8l6 011 fjJG CJJ9'L9'Cc6L1211C2 0 JJG COWbUiG8 JJ!cJ1

LJJ4 COLIJGL Oj J,9'pG J 4JJ6 IbO 1T1Jq6LbL1C1U 'iiq jou 46LW auq6Lb6LoLw9uc€ o jJ6 84OCJ2

O IJJGUJ O84 O JJG 6XJ81U 6mB1Lic1j IAOLJ( 11, 4JJ18 91G9 COIJC6IJ4Lf62 015 TPG ob uq poçom

o 4G qGci2iou o o bnpjic 916 I1JIJA 2Jnq62 qL6cJjA OL uqLGccJA 2pGqqu jjJ ou 80W6

JJjJ1j6 EG 916 U0 9W8L6 O 911A combLGpGu8IAG 8nqA IL14I1 o cOmb9LG 42JJ6 A9L!OJ18 qG46Lmu9u49

T2 EX1!U GUJbfLiCgJ OLJ

(J6L ThJ r°'-u q J5!T6Leocj bLIcc b69'p (ffGL T84) uq p6LIJGL (To4) I ! J0 COu2!24Guc ''!cP JOE. J0IJ-LJ11J LGçITLIJ2

J5AqdAi2f T4). I4 !8 j20 C0U2i246154 ELJJ JJ6 CL088-2GC!0IWj CJIT8fGL1IJ 0j 1b02 15691 86C0L!j

(Y !2 c0H2!2461Jç Miçp !116L119!0U9'J c!wG-86L! GAIqGIJcG ! cJ T8O (ronpLsu f6L uq

o bnpJc Lp!2 MuqoiA o obboLçnuçA pAbopG88 moqjjq uq 4624G pA jçu uq 6LI968

bu!6a Ep1CJJ LG9J1G J39 0JJ6L COUJb9UJGB ! uqn8çLA 916 0A6LA9Jfl6 J5A6 911 !UC6U!A6 0

p 916 bGLJoq2 ! P!CP 80CJC8 916 wJ2bLjcGq 8n62Gq pA ''r (To) corn-

I8 juqo o obboLnuA

Page 13: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

TI

v1° iii jj? IJGGq o jutuc !llAGm6U uq tho!A4p jpG moe commoujA dnoGq WOiAG

uJupou bnppcç? noirçiou o bnpjic(Ju liGqGu JJG qi2Lpniou oj o GmbJo?G6a ! pAoLGq pA x coqG) 9uq b6LcGuç

°L JJ6 Jui4wJ OMUGL2 ju€q o p€ bLo2bGcn wuçou JucGuJA€2 GmbJoAGG

UU?IJC!JJW MJJGLGEf2 OUJA j b6LcGuç o JG bLob6cnG aGq im o LGp9'UCiu p€ boiopobGLcGuç O CJ2G U MJJICJJ UJ0IJA0U 11L9'2 9çGq W IbO !! bLG26u6q 2 1fluJiU S'ç LW

LGboL;Gq LG2OU otcq pA !uiwJ omu o pac combuiG2 ! cp lEO bLo2bGcn2G2: !U

4o L6flCG JGA6LG OL UUCG cowbtiA Lop jp€ uqu2 ibbGL couçLqic 2GJj-

cowbuA pA ps'j wo cowbinica pi uo nøq lEO s u obboz4nuJA

9JJ 4IJG!L p3'LG MJIJJJU 2 AL pom IbOe ffuq ou fA6LG LGqncGq cpG!L UG pojqp lu 4JJG

couçu 'p bL6qicou8 ot (Tv) iu couibu!62 pG oiu€z. ojq on

lEO2 !u /I6GU 9'LG UJOLG JIJCGJA o p qou pA OJGL LW oju pA o/Lirnr.a Jro wairç

ouq W2 iiuç bnpjic ! RLGqGu !ll 1p6 bGLoq I 1O-IT yccoLqu o JJGL LG2flJ8

ffAqdAJ2 9uq HOPOJUJ (j) 24IIqA IJJG CJJIJG U oIAu6L2p!b JGAGLG iuq G !' Tt ''!J

cpuojoA (couLrLA o M9 CwbP6II uq Ao2p9' (J2) bL6qicc)

JuAG2çmGu4 EJuJJA bnppc comb'uG2 LG COUCGUlLG ! 2€CIOL2 llp combniAcJA qiucq

L9126 IJJOLG GdfliA uauc pu ii€ Ic co bJTLcpc 2IJCG2 !1J OIJJGL cousbau162 LGL JJ8U OL qL6cl

UJOLG L9b!qJA 9LG UJOLG bLoJpJG uq bA onc OLG q(4q6uq2 cpu bL!/9fG couJbu! JJJGAJ2o

jgo OL 2I€ 9uq 2€cçoL cpGA uq cpc bnpjic coujb9u162 IUA68 IJJOL& LOM

m9uCG o 2 fl'4p bnppc cowbuiG2 MJ o ' J9LG combuIG2 pa' e2A bufrçG LLIJJ

cjwu u9'JAs!u cowBuiG2 onuq cpGiL lEO qc cpGA cowbai€ cp P L!2C2 uq bGLtoL-

yAGL uq j6XUGL (jj) ii uop 9bbLocp co rnrJAG cp BL!c!2P GJuqGucc: LJJ6L

jOJJOEJIJ cpG OGL1IJ

qocnuJcu 2cLou nuqGLbGqpLm9'ucG o IbO combuu!€2 LbcciAGJA iu cp uq AGL2

LGcG!AG cou2iqGLEpJG pGJb pA iuçrn cb!cJc2 JççGL (TaoT) uq ropIsIJ 9uq (J2)cowbu!G2 o bnpjic uGL bGrj opocp GdrnçA i9Jrwciou2 uq u jL€çu bjp€A

sirq li44 boç lEO 2OCJ bL!cG fluqGLbcLoLiuucG fGLDGL (Jf) juqe cp p!ocGcpU0Jo

ip qJ2uJ9J bo2c-IEO bLojcpiJicA 18 cou2i8Gu M1JJ pG CJ9iUJ2 P2T lEO2 !G cJJG UJLJCG

Page 14: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

T5

4JJG Q-5ij UJIJJJOU rn cpjjoi COAGL uuA borpJG iuAG24uJGuç UGG fAG wpc JJuAG 1J10Lç0 4OAGWGLLGcGuJ? qGCJ9LGq: JIAG uo bjtu 1! oim coubu) 111 UGuL jIcflLG OUG o LGu2OI.JB 2 lAG JI9AG

JIAG 110 IJGG 0 GXcGLU9J UU11CG EOL 111 IJCG A[1. B!!J OIAUGI. 0 JJ J9tG24 onb u coauL? pu3yjo 4JIG 0!AIJGL3 0 C0IUbUTG CJIOO3G lo 2c bLIAfçG Gxbu1u IJJGIL bLqGLG11cG 9 qnG 0 f JIG C4 cpG?t

qAqGrrq2.

pCGq JUAG94UJGU4 4JJ9U nuJ2Gq OUG8 pfl4 9LG J JGAGL9'Gq UJOLG C9'biffJ !uGu!AG 9uq b'A WOLG

JGX9UGL tOL BL!49!U I9I!9U JGq COUJb9UIG8 iJbbG9L o pG IG2 bLoç9pJG 9IJq O J39'AG JOeAGL

&uq llUfl2lG cowb9u1G2 u prjA pç u b9L9J couL924 Jp JJG uqJu pA '9Ar. 9uq

L!u9JJA gouqi GS c (jr) LGboL qGc4bAG GAqGUcG ou JJG qGLGIJ9J PGJJ9'A!OL t !!lq

9 UJJ1CJJ J9'LGL ruJbJG

oJqJu comb9uA) 9JL69qA GuoAGq MJ4p p9'uJc9 JjJG26 LGffJ 916 2nbbol3Gq pA oar. €Aq6ucG ou

9UA GGL pA 9UJ pi o JJG Lou P9L9!U!U boIAGL pG!L comb9uA (or. !l

UU9UCJU cpoJcG2 AIOLGOAGL 4JJG g LGbouqGu2 inpo 9q JJ9 JjJGL comb9uiGa MGLG uo LG94G

4o 4JJG L69GL 4L9JJb9LGUCA o 9'ccoflUçJu !IJOLUJ9JOIJ uq 4G LG94GL llGXTp!J!4A !u ipiL

pGGL 8GLA!c6 MPGU 2JG o 2l9G mol!A6e oj uibLoAGq L69çmGu4 pA p9uJc& bouGq

bLoAGq cJJGiL 249UU IAJcp p9UJC2 pA Opc9!IJU cp69BGL cLGq JOMGL COII9GL9J L6drnL6mGu9 9uq

uoLp uJGuiornu jj o JJG LGbouq6u4a eçwq rrbou O!u bnpl!c fG comb9uA pq !'-

ou o o bnpjic ou 4G LGJ9'Joupib iAJ p9uJ EAGU ponp oujA jcomba'uJG2 LG2bouqGq JJ i

UøGL drr6arouu9iLG bLobo6q pA B!I6 (jg) Ju jçjA JUAG I9G 4G lLub9cç oj JJG qGci-

JJJIIGJJ UJ9'JJGL 9UJbJG) pci pi M92 UO4 UJ9'IUJA qILGGGq 4O JU9UCG JUAG2UJGU4 9uq Lop

comb&u!G qiq L9!G IJGM Gd11!A c9b!ca'J 9JçGL IbO ( onuq 9JO pA afl9J!GL! (jgg) ou9 J9LG comb 9uA ( b6LcGuç) Tf2 MG 2JJ9'JJ 266 GJOM OJIL GAiqGucG 2JJ0M2 JJ94 UGM bnpjic

JJG JidnqiA o JJG ocJ ( BGLCGU) 9Uq uGGq ;o UJ9LJc OAG jLom 9 9m!JA pne!uG22

OPGL 9JJGG LG920U2 MGLG IUJbLOAGUJGUç III COLbOL9G JW9G ( bGLcGuç) JG IUCLG926

BGLCGU O 4JJG C9262 UGM IJ9UCIU M9 mGu4ouGq 92 9U !UJbOLJ9U L6920U 4O O bnpJ!c

2JJ9LGJJOJqGL8 o ' dnG2!ouu9!L6 q24pnGq U IJJG COUIGX O 2 1b02 GMG6U 1ô82

o o bnpj!c !U 26J-L6boL46q !I1OLIU9!OIJ EGLL911 (J) L6bOL42 JJG COLT4LOJJIIJ

Page 15: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

hiemiioiivna IBiloiuilnI 3rlT

noiBbeb 9dJ lo 8iusnirrrieib Mb stbevni o en ewoth 9Iqrfuie mo liminmom msb cJ Hiw cA

airli 9vit3qameq iii bue mo 9Iq oT .bohsq $QO1-$8I sr1t ni airnil nsi!sJI mol 31!duq o o iii thsm bota nsiIstI iTJ lo &1teh3 ith 9di lo w9ivmvo Is3imotaifI hhd £ e9biVOmq noba

.ms1n3ihq ni boimeq eiiLt lo brie Ls19n thFI9bIw 9rb lo 9Ia sili diiw noaimqrno iii lisma m3diam ci i*ism boia nsilifl 911T

aLsiI lo inn3q 1 asw noiiSi!siiqs3 Lsioi au (slqmse mo lo ms-bim Mu) 81 ill :rnono .>I.U Mb mol t119019q bn nsqst mol in93m9q AU 9di mol tnnsq (1 o b91sqmo 'TUD

lie V8I iii :3qomIJ Lii Ltsiqii ci m5v3wod afhsm iiup9 3iiduq lb 91s0a llama l9viisl3m 511T

mo unomq 0 lo noi silsuiqac £ bail iffenuino) fI89qo1u3 erli ru 8te*Lsm boic Lerioiian erli

'LUffIi9) IiiI ill .abnsimeilieM en i baa niebew2 bnaImesfiw lo anIoxiqe3xe Mb rliiw qUO IC)

iedim enanbxe boic erli no belail ceinaqrno3 lb medrrwn lLama erb beiDeftem cliii ensm'I brie

ni baa aimis9 ,naliM iii beicil a9inaqmo) enli lb noiiaiLsuiqa eSmeVa eu :eia esmevs miedi nanfi

aeinBqmo3 eu lb isdi as emsi as aernui 1.1 baa öI.1 .1 leviu3eqcem saw a risrbxe nemieD erli

.(C1 onssq nil I eldsi eec) ensdxe boic *ioY we efif is beiaii

isdi aelnsqrno3 lo bs1 £ ol beindimils ed ionn& aeinsqmo3 bebami loildirq lo iiDusq edT

11 iasel is boimeq Q8-8e1 eu at eejIaildsice 'lmael3 (O1) hsaaaM cA .Dilduq o bluoD

nzev0 .ülduq euio evsnl bluo brie ainememuipem iiiiai1 eib beftaiiisc a9inIsqmo eievhq nisileil

18 emew emedi aeinsqmo3 Dilduq Diiaemob lb mo aeinaqrno niemol lo aeiml3ibiadua nibiibxe

eijlev ieAmsm bsismiiae us rliiw) llama emew eeinsqrnoo ecenli lb C1 eiidW .aeiabibns eidiaeoq

noillid C08 lo eulsv ielmsm 'nsqmo llduq esmevs eu oi bemsqmoD emiJ noillid nerli acel

(0*U 'lduom) emij noillid 001 evods euLsv ie1mam beismiice as bsri medi lb 8' ,

(emiJ

-'iwo lb noiislifISDno3 rlinl enli ci ie*ism boia nailsil enli lo emuisel nur{aiunuiaib bno3sa A

beieil ceinsqmo3 lo uimoLsm Mb aimoqem (11) celsniz cA .aeinsqmoD bebemi lilduq ni qudame

ai ibiifw 9ru3(bXEI boi2 naliM 911 rfiw enarbxa koi2 nailail 9d 1iin9hi 111w 9W niwo11o 911J nI noLlsoffinebi ciii i b9l9bicno3 boh9q elqrnsc eu moI iii enaIbx9 boie biupil baa triaiioqmi taom 91b mal

hem nshoqmi tcom lo 9ueei 9d cob uki9 9di lo ninriied ed ia 1rxO .'tl1s19a9 lo ceo! uoiIiiw ci .1eiem9vomno3 emom 9mo9d

Cl

Page 16: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

N

COIJ6IJCG JGAGJ2 4JJ6 911JbJG L62LCc6q 4O P' 20 AL UJIGLA9J pGcJA€GU 18?2 giJq Th89 4JJ6 J bGLCGUç COIJqGUCG JGAGJ IJJG mpoJG -j aaq pnç L6 uoç 8iuqc91sc c cou,€uçiou9?6L O fJAT) 0136 Uq8 cJJ CffLL6IJI suq JGq OCC bi4c€ CJJWIJG L6 Oiij? IJiIJC&UcJ? 6L6U4 GLoW GLOcotubua ou cm.L613ç uq jGq iii o LG b4cG cpm€ oi. b64oq iao-a (GxcJnqin lp6

0JjJ2 Ai(W 1wbL6aiou i colljJunGq p? L6LG8iOU i: L6LGTu cp6 cpm u unmp o biipfcL66L CU 6q IIJ6L 4J16 Ut1WGL 0( IhO LLW W6 CJJIJG 111 unwp€r. o comb9u6 ff2çGqH0A6L Gxc6bc oL 1818 IJq OL 46 6m4? J?O q6flU L6 AGL? jjiiiiç€q iiq IJ04 P!PP P1& uq O

2L!11LG L6boLç2 Irnwp6L ot combu pcq s6cç6q pocp p? 6uci.6e (uo) miq 6X2 (q6J2cu

m9nnj9cnLiIJ cço (JrG ILqLstJG) uq .u açocj uJs'LJGç buc€ DG2b1

JJJJG tAO 6C9G OJjOBU J(j i1GLG cp9Lcl6LsGq p?. IJ' GX4L9'OLqU9L? LOtAlJJ o

Tu bL!c62 9uq hi pG JGAGJ 0j GCODOJJJ!C SCA!4 cjiia LGJ9IOUJJIb i 9jGL pG fl9L

6L9 4JJG 1Jf7CI19JO1J2 113 IJJG IJJ1UJGL O fl24Gq couJb9u!G ojjo CJ026J? unccnuiou

jjJ€ mo fTLbL121ll GflLG i jJ j'cj oj IbO !u bo2ç jjj 6L iu 4G bi-

AIL4?(WJJA 'J° IbOQ

JuGLmGqi94G bGLloq: pG jou bL!c L9JJA 4JJ9 J99G LOW PG ii JfO O JJ

Uq T22 — ! ! 24LO1JJA COLLGJ94G tAlçp LG9J 2çocJ bLicG tAp!JG 1IJ2 hJO4 IL1TG O

IbO II9AG pjpu JJG 1Ju1UJGL o bupjc comb9u!62 pse pu woeç A9L19JG — pqoLG

E!I1LG I I1G242 4JJ9 9 24OCJ UJ9LI6I p00111 9 UGC69L?. piiç UO4 2ITWC!GIJI couqou J0L

uO oujA 0136 0t IJ- IE 1b02 ll9A62 ! IcP fl4 90 201316 ?G913 9jGLtA9LW

?G couq pj o jj ju L62bGc out. 29mbJG bGLioq i JuGL624Tu p6c9n i cbpii

2bnL.ç o IlJ! uq1LJ94ou (jga-ioY! bGLioq 9j6L jjj (I5a-To) uq u9JJ? rnunmpct. o bnppc couTh9u ps 1JCL62Gq 2flP29UJI ouj? ! bGLoq2: qciLu UL24

9uq 9 uJ9xhIJrnuJ 0j 55 !' TÔ5 II1IP 9 ILGU !UCL6G O 9 IJJGLG 05 bGLcGuç bGL 9IJIJJIIJY JJJG

11C4JT9IGq wt.oiiuq 911 ¶TAGL96 o cou1bu!6a p!ç4u miujujuw o coujb9u162 u TaT

uuwp€t. o bnpjic cowb9ui€ p p€u 2nLbL18iuJ? 29J6 2!IICG pG flLIJ O p6 cGU4J1L?:

E!1L6 T 2JJOtA2 JJG 2c9Lc!cA o bnpj!c couibru!G2 uop!u U6Ii u 9'J? JpG O49Jbirpjic pi jj? p i jijj?. o L649IU m&)OL!1 coIILoj

O ollucL2p!b 9IJJOU CGLW9U cowb9u!62 o 6U 913 GuLGbL6u6nL q6cqc2 o 9J6 p cowb9u?k

2iIT94ou 12 U0 nuidnc joL Gx9IubJ& 9uq A96L (To) juq A6L?. pJJ C0UCGU4L94!OU

Lp 1 p9J? A!Ln9JJ? 9JJ cowb9u!62 916 CO1JLOJJGq p? J9L6 2p9LGpoJqGL J46AGL46J622

OIl V'!!!911 2°I EXCP9UG JJ9AG 9 J916 2916OJGL tAJJO 01A112 IJJOLG 911 2O? o 46 AOIJ

Page 17: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

12

jou opiuq jom s 'sit,: ii o ji enru (Iaajp6 ouj? bnpjJpGq o WGLG qç LLOUJ pG t;W% qt qitt MJ !uoLusc!ou OIl !ucGLGc LG2 nq

pq on ' 2mbJ6 o T5258 combIruJG2 LMU om (iucjnqiu ouj? cowbrnG2

LcbLG26n4iA6 O IJJG J49JWIJ uou-uuci8 cçoL: c L6CGU L6bo14 (cGuLIrJG q6 BllIJ 1005)

JJG 2rwbJG q J4 pOLLOM2 jom ou o puj !' JJG coU2OLiflUY JpG qr49p2G !2

C0U20LII1UJ 0 HJJ2 iuGLG2Gq U bO0flIJ !uoLw9'4!oU J0J14 4JJGL CJ!GU42 ' Lm 2 JucJnqGq !"

w6U48 o poii jcfoj IJ!U uou-uuci9'J Juu2 j1J16 q9'J9 pGGu cojj6cc6q 8111C6 1085 p?

JJJG q wcs bLoAiqGe 2uqLqiGq qçrJ ou pjuc 26G9 uq iucouJG 2lG-cou46u4 pjotLGb0142 2JIJcG cJJG JL8 MO qs 2011LC62 LG drnG UOA6J EILG bLoAqG 2OUJG !1110Lm9'1!on OU 1P61L

(266 pGJoiA) qqiçouij pjuc 26G q9'41t AG GGU CoJJ6qGq qLGc4J? ow cowb9'ui62 TUhJff9J

uq Lom 4JJG ceumso c iow (çocj EXCP9D6 C0WbU!62 Huqpooj ju 201116 0CC2!OU2

CLj 6i26L) JuoLm1ou poiiç oMuGL2pib 9'uq couoj &LG LAU L0W IbO bLo2bGcn262

L94G2 JOtU uq J!u62 o CLG LG qL8WLU ow w€qs cwc (Combu 1qccou 2GLA!cG) juounou rponç iUçGLG2ç

JJ9A6 JL6G UJ1U 2011LG62 o qr JUC6 21J66I 'uq !11C01116 246W6IJ4 !u0LW94!ou COIJJG Low

31 2OfILCG

2 Dcombu?. qr o 9U&tA6L p6 dnGiou2 L9'26q p?. 4JJ6 biijiu luJ6-2GL!62 GAq61JCG

on oj 4G qGci2iou o o bnpjic Jp6 91W o b9bGL 12 o 1186 pG 6AqGucG Lom uqAq1wJ

qJ8 211G242 4JJ94 4IJ6 M1JqoI/k o obboLnuiç? pThoçp62i2 12 uoç 911 GXJJ9ll2çiAG GxbJ9u9-

p6611 922OCi96q "P M9'A6 O 1102 I4Lfl9Jj?. 6AGL?Jp6LG

o irj 2ocJ( bL!c62 111 JJ94 q6c9q6 COIJçL92 JJG 2ç0Cj W9LJG poom 0 JJG iiqq 10802 p

Q6LW91J?. t1LGq6u 9'uq M6LJ9IJ pq AGL? t6R Jb08 JJ6 T02 qG2bi6 JJJJ J6A6J2

JjJ2 t69flLG 12 uo bGcup9L oujA I49J?: jqthq8 9uq H0POJW (ioo) L6b0L y1124L19

9COL2 1 12 uoç 11 u4!J 1082 JJ9A6 9UOp6L 9ap29'uc!9J UOM 0 1b02

Page 18: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

e isqnci. comb9u! uoç bL6uç u bu€j qççpi€ cp6 GX boç oi. coInbm! in oim bu€j 6xcGbç ouG (r11xoci!cnY uucij coInbinnG

lu 4GM AOLII (rffxo!cbnpjc p?. WGLiU EA!cp n nJLGq? jiçcq comb9u? vuq LGLffCffl4U lc cowbj€j? (bw9wc) p''comb9u?. iA9 6xGuJb6q GCflG b4IJGq pøLG JAGLG 9L6J? I!c'q OU 4G 12E (2vE Q6ccGL2) J MGU

OU 4}J6 IGLCO rnLGccO (UqffaçI46 2GCCO ynBcpdus) OL OIl IJJIUOL 2çOCJ GXCJJ9I1G2 (JJ.IbcoAIcp ri)t,JP' L6WI1U!U cowbnm qq uoç j€ bLobGqna uç VI2E oi. g isu€ç? o LGg2ou2: GLG9LP J!III qLob2 40 10 IJJIIHOIJ riLG I6L .III !10IAGUC

IJJIIJIUJIIIIJ J1841IJ LGdrnLGWGU42 OL °Y EXCPUG HOIAGAGL ! li2 OujA in

V T2 J "q CO1'120B ( IJ!' Tth?JO O JJ6 EEC) LG2boIJ2ipJG OL 62IpJ2jJIJ 4JJG

Irnu!Lu9j bLoppTJ o oru bcipJc qffLJIT ri A6L2 o OflL 2rubJG

oj qGci2iou o o bappc ii tiuç o combuiG2 jJ p9/ 9ç jG2

JJJG 2mbj6 12 L9MU LOW pG CGJG qG! B!I' !11C6 oiu brrLbo2G o nq?. qGGLmiu9nc2

3• 2umb16

cOwbsn162 liGiJ4 bnpjc c9U G onuq pom bnpppq 8011LC62 (c&io tosici)iii OJIL biJGj q 8G }iJ9jj? iULOLW!OU JOiT OMUL2JJb 2LflCflLG uq COIJILOJ 4JJG2G

jOL 5 o uou-uuucj cowb'u1G2 J24Gq OIl 4JJ6 2E pG4ftL6GIJ T5 auq TaOS uq bLG8Gu

COU84LJ1C 4JJG oEJJGL2JJIb 24L1TCflLG Oj JJGG COmbIJ!62 4o tiu bnpjic JJJG? 91€

bnppc OIJ.GL!1J GjOLG PG!Il pe€q JJJJG bLo2b6cçrrn62 9LG oujA 2J1LG jjow n o L€-pLq 2OIILCG O OIIL ! J' IbO bLo2b€ca2G2 bLGbirLGq tOL cowb9urG2

couqGul9J: no OUG GxcGb4 jM 2GJGC OCjJ2 T CGULJ BUJC O 9j?. cu CC€2

LG2 cp€q Oil 69CJJ j09U jp€€ I/jJCjJ 916 OL IJJOU!IOL!D bntho2G2 916 pjjsj?.

OL OAGL O 4Oj pujc J€uqU) JJA6 LG€q O ifiG q6fj6q UOLWIOIJ pOfIl p€

piJJC2 4O WOUOL oj Gxbo2rzL€ o cpG!L cn2çomGL2 ii qqjçou puj (9cconu!u

JJ1626 qT4 jj€q combnJ2oLrJA pA p'nJc uq Jurq€ i'ijspj€ nbou LGdnG24 fO uqAqn97

oil jOU2 OEkGL 80 m!jI!0u flLG L9u6q pA I9J!IJ pIJJ2 o combu!62 uq iuqAqaJ28

o p€ ujc o iJA !U cp916 O COJJ6c4U q9f9'

ipj 2gmbJG coAGL8 bGLc6u o 29j6a L6boL4Gq !il uouJ ccoaujn qçacou4iunof18IA bL62Gu 113 T85-O isq Mj3 29J68 GXC62 I PllP° r!Lc !" T0Y 2G2 ipc

Page 19: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

bLoqIlcGL 0( GJ6CII1C boii6L)0A6L1JuJ6uc-0Mn6q LU19 M44JJ U6!A6 6drqcX (tot GXInIJI)J6 EI4E oA6uJm6uc-o&uGq wouoboj)6df1i LOL L611901J9 19 q1L6CJ) flIJJC6q 0 0116 0( 4P6 L6d11!LG1116Uc2 6couq c 6J!II1!U69 W111J p

9J2O COIJ2IqGL6q 1111 T6LUc!A6 C146140IJ 011 996ç9 J6 bL66LL6q 0116 926 011 9JJL6JJ0J6L211H0W6A6L1 !U 9f1Cp C9269 9 J69 J994 IIJCOIIJG 26UJ6U ponjq 90JA 90W6 boa!c!A6 61tLD!IJ9

1UA624UJ6Uç2 pn pG?k mn8 p691 CO2 O C6Lq6q s b9l oj qJG bIrLGUç comb9uA8

CO248 O pGiU bilpj!C OL !U29UC6 JJ6? C9U 1Uq1LGCJ? CC622 JJG bnpjic Gdfl!4 UJ9LJ(GI o UU9JJCG

combu? 12 Ji846q 91J 8 2apeqsi468 UJp 20W6 oj PGU6U8 9uq\oL p691 2OUJG O IJJ6

6a49'pp2jJpJ M6U COIJJb91YA C&JJ pc COD2cJGL6q 9 bJ1pJCJ? ;Lq6q LU 1C MJJGU thoiiB pojqiu

COUJb9'U? L01Tb2 C0U4LOJJ6 p? 2!UIG ruJfl? ip pojqu cowbru? jp2 bo262 bLopJGm2 !U

8 B9LC G (Toot) JJA6 2OMU p9'jWU Uqn24L? !2 6UGL9JJ? OL9Ui6q 9100 uq '"m-

p? IJJG j9Cç p9 UGM boppc C0UJBU!68 JJ9A6 0 UJGGI CGL91U fl8c!U L6d1T!L6UJGU42

UJOL6 LG24L1C41AG LGdO7LGUJGIJç8 40 866 4JJ6 LOPJ18IU688 0 OJIL L6811J49 4JJ6 2GI6CI!OU bLoqocGq

2p91GpOJq6L8 6drn4 u jg JJG GuJb!L!c9'J U91?28 IJJO0IJ MG MJjJ jL0m 4!IJJG O IjUJG Iubo8G

J026 1Iio combuiGa IIGUç bnpjic qrnu 8mbjG bcLoq pn qq uo LGøC 2 P!II!OU u

2IJJ91J pf78U628G2 MjJO2G 7CC0ITU4U q91H 916 Abc91j? dn6 flULGJ9'pJG1 JJJG CO8I !2 4J1 MG

29IJJBJG bGLoq M6 9'bbj?. cJJJ2 jjL24 2CL6GU!U 4O 6jUJUUG J9LG UflUJGL Oj 2UJ91j s'uq AGLK

couJbJ'ui68 JjJG 29'mbJG COUç1U2 g o UOUjjUUCWJ cowbrui6a Mpicp MGUf bnpJ!c qITL1U cp

pijjiou rn 8JJ91G0JGL2 6dni4A JJJ!2 CL!6L!0U LG0CG2 4JTG C6UL9I6 qG! B!1"! 29iJJbjG o 5T8T

JO 6X4L1 0171. pic 29'mb16 M6 ucjoqq 9JJ 4JJG combuJG2 cpc gg oj J5 pq j6 fILG 2JJJJG CJr1rI1i1J L6ffjtOL GIJA!LOIIUJ€1142 uq 1ç8 Gcjpjç2 uqac€q 178 17869 A6Q IJJflq CLj46LOIJ

conjq G MIflAG oujA ! BL62GUCG o WOL uq bGLmlrn6uç Cp9uG8 !U COUJb1J?2 2çLJICçOLGJJ

10fl bo22pqiç? 0 M9TA1U IPG 8JJ9L6p0JqGL8 6d0!4 CL1çGLJ0U MJJ!j6 IJJ6 bLoUp!J!A CLIçGLIOU

0 1UçLr-L0i1b ob6Lou2 flJq 6X4LOLqUI1L?. !c6UJ2 JJJG 11GM qLGcçAG 9120 qLobb6q au? m6UiOU

2L6Up6U6q !48 LGdrnLGm6uç2 p? Lua'uqaçiu jpa bLoUapJJiA UJGflL62 6 opcaiuGq uqGb6UqGu

G MaiA6q M!W JJG CO12OB8 LG6WGUI ac ja'ac JIUçIJ JU cjiac ?GaL jJ6 cOj2O

() bo8/ GaLLTJU8 111 JJG JØç ?GaL8 pGjOLG j!8ciU fl0p JJG2G CLçGL1a conjq

(s) pooj J9Jn6 O 8JJaLGp0Jq6L2 €dijA JIJ 6XC682 0 J pijJJOD r1LG

cJ GxbjicicJ? 2b6ciGq Mo LGdn!LGuJGUc8 0L fl8ju:

Page 20: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

JpbcoArcjrcowb9uIGa 91.6: uccou QL0nb flO6LO B014010W6& iuIJpLu9e jiO qi 2016 IJ91J9LI9 2I2V

(comu1) r brn-oW1VJJ UGIi J11U 0 rrpTq!9L16a o bnppcj? L96 comb9u1Ga GxcGbc 0116 91.6 4GCJJL1!C9fl? C9I.A6-OI1 0116 C926

2OCJ GXG9'UG2 OiAGAGL JJ9'AG AGL? ]ççJ6 AOJflIJJG &uq 4JJGLG ! ouj? O!JG 1IJOLUJ9J UJ9'LJGç o 9'II

qGLGn II9'J!9'U C14G2 bJfl2 2OUJG IJJOLG UtOLW9'J UJ9LICGI3 csJJGq GLC9'c! 2LGII! JJJG UJ!UOL

(v'IE) p? t9'L 4?JJG mo !mboLc9'iJl OIJ& 4GLG 9IG !iJ IP O1JJGL IJJJUOL 2IOCI( GXCp91JG2 joccq !u

UIIOU o MGU 9' cowbu?. c9U pG COiJ2CJGLG buipJ!cJ? 1L9qGq fl621q62 1G fl9'IJ OCJ EXCJJ9UG

JG u'j bLopj6m in MpGu 9 jLw biipjc i in 629pp2pJn JJG bLobGL qG-

J.JJ! p9'bbGn2 !u

9' Ji246q JJoJqiu combu? ou WOLG 2 cou2oJq9çGq 29'J62 8!uJG 2rip2q9'LA

BGUGOU CL0flB Jiip pG 9'cconuIJ q9'ç9' o a Gx!IG anp2iqi9'LA ttc bLocGqnLG ouj?

ou tOL iuqnaLwj cowb9'ui6 ii L6bJ9c6 4G UJ291J 949 LOW cou2oJq9Gq 9'cconuç2 0j

CL0flb Ef ' comb9uA ju qqiiou 2!IJCG 0(11 q9f9 2G bLoAiqG2 9CConuçu !UOL1JJ9'c!OIJ

2bV tOLUJ9'JJ? i 12 IJO4 9' JI2G cowbu? M6 OA6LCOUJG P!2 bLopj6m p? CJ9'22IJ1qU BGiJGccOu

9' 46XfiJG 2np2iq9L? EAGU JJ0(iJJ J3GIJ6oU q€ CJO coiuciqG2 MIçJJ fl6UGOIJ (3LOITb

pJ9'u ocJ EXCJJ9'JJG 21UC6 pn 0j couopq6q 29JG8 o Loflb 916 quc o B6nGOU

COUJUJGLCJ9'J 9CçiA14iG2 flGIJ€4foU CLOUb 2bV u9'uc9'J poJqu combuA J24Gq ou JJG

in 9' 21UJG Juq1T2LJ9'J comb9'u? E°1 6x9'WbJ& BGIJGc40U I17!I COUL0J2 !I !IJCJIJ2cL!9J 9'Uq

i JU0LG2 9C4 1JJ9' 201116 poJqU combsu!G2 COUCGIUL916 IJG A9' m9'OqA O 1JJGL 98GI2

9'LG p? qGuoue Una'uc!9'J coIub9'uJG us9'u? pr cI9'22111c9'c!ou r W2JG9'U 6C9'ff26

yUOçJJGL bLopJGm CLGG p? pi Lonb 2LJ1C1TLG JJ pc pq poqu comb9'u1622fip2q9'LG2 o bnpJcJX cL9'qGq comb9u!62 (JLp!cp ii€ 21J9JJ CoJJGqAG?. U9'LUG

2imiI9LJ? E6 ijj q12puui2p G4WGGU u6.u I!' o uqGbGnqcu colub9'u!Ga riuq IJ6M J!2W O

JJJGLGOLG llG CL69'çG 9' 2Gb9'L9'G C9GOL 4O 9'CCOS1UI OL 2np2q9'LG2 O bnpJ!cj? Ji246q comb9u!G

GLGU4 Qom po o 9'U iuq6bGuq6uc cowb9'uA OL o 2np2q9'L? o b4A poJqu comb9u?,

IPG LG9'20U2 RLJJ?. G2G COUJB9'U162 o bnppc 9'uq pG

p€q (in 2IICJJ CU?6 6 onjq 9A6 8b!n-o OL 9 c9LAG-onl?)

qi2cJo2aLG LGd1HL6UJGU42 JJJ12 062 Uo bLGcjnqG JJG2G cowb9'u!Ge LOW 26GJU G 2Gb9L9'çGJ?

Page 21: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

10

4JJ0G 01 I111' 011 p6 12E'M611 bapjc 011 pG 4GM AOLI( cocjc EXCP91TG !U 1000 M6 92rn1JG cpc JG GGC2 01 IJ! CPO!CG 9LG C0mb9LVpJGcombJ6cGJ? iIIJqGL cpG 1191116 01 b'1Jc M6 9JC6 cpr G GIIGCc!AGJ? GdJT1A9IGUc 9 11GM llc!' r0cc!c9

w moo I"Jc GLG luço 9 jacq U9119J cowbru? (E!u9us!m.9 C611L0 oLq) 911q LG0L9IJ1Gq cPGIOLG PG!U P- LP!2 ! rflxocc!c9e MP!CP Hc'q 011 PG I4AE !U T000

OJIL 9I1JbJG bGLoq JAG SLG 9/A9LG 0 011 0116 C0IUhlflfl cJIç 89L4G( 6 jicq 111 9 10LG1J IIJ9LJCG

T081) 9uq OçJJGL COfluLi6 (roniL9'u ffI46L uq J2.qdAi T003 'uq r1nudA! 1002)' I,1oi

uq Tog JJJJJ2 CjfJ6LJU Oj IbO 9' II bpGuom6uou pop rn p6 f' (Ip6L2€couq q€Juiiou' p ! drn€ cJ691 4JJ9' 136tA Jaçu 916 ppJA cOuc6ulL96q u p€ bGLToq T08

jppj€ bLG2Guç2 jJG q12LJpf1pOu OAGL !m6 O UGJA J!24!U9 111 OIIL 29'UJbJG J1!U jJ6 JL 9'Uq

iuqGbGuq6u comb9'u!6 JAjJ!16 50 916 C9'LAG 011W

IAI!19'11 (TI1X01C9')'ig O 1J36 j1J9'j 9'IJJbjG COU19u8 COuJb9'IJ!6' O Oj 1JJ626 916 11GM JTU2 Oj

JA6U bapjic JU 9' IJOU2l9U9'L JA9'2. (b9'LuJ9'j9') uq ou€ ipicp jiç€q 111 4GM AOLJC 1uaG9'q o

tAGLG uoç LGbOL6q !u 4JJG CGUL9J6 q6 Bll9'11! 92 0j T085 jO 4jJG26 MG 9qq 9' COmb9'IJ2. tApIcp

LGdniLGm6u oj jt€ 2 pJJJIOU ! p9'LGpoJq6L2 Gdff!12. !u 1085' jujj2. MG J026 2 combu€a p6ca'nG

tAS2 iucoLboL9'46q 9'jçGL 9'uq 9'IJOJGL OPGLA9'lj0U GC9'D26 cp€ comb9'u2. q!q uoç 29'p2.

JJJJJ jG9A62 9' O9'j 0 3Q 11GM j2jU2' Ø IJIGG JAG j026 3 OP6LA9I!OU8 p6c91126 coiubauA

np2Jqi9'LA JJ9' JAG imbj2. n€q cpG uqnL9'J rrp2q9L2. tOL 9'!! 9CCOJ113ç1U iUOLIJJ9'4OU'

mGuiouGq o JJGG 2o-c9'JJGq ju9'uci9'J cousb9'uG2 JAGLG o cJo2GJ2. iq6uçiGq M14p 0116 IJq112cL9'j

OUG2 f 916 Cj9'22IJG 92 UU9'UCJ9! COUJB9'U162 p2. 6 9' 84OCjC pa'uqpoojc y bLGtqon9J2.

qjGLGucG ! U9'1ILG oj pGL obGL9iou2 9'uq 9'CCO11JJ41IJ IJOLUJ9OIF Oi. IJJG LGIU9JU!U

52 MGLG p9'uj8 9'uq comb9u!G JAP!CJJ JAG Lom 89IIJBJG GC9'Ii26 O !UL!U!C

JpGLG M6LG 130 11GM !!!" 011 IAI2E qczLU cp6 b€ioq 10851005' O jJGG 11GM

4JJ6 L611J2 1T!U G JL2 q6u1çJoIJ'

qo 1J04 qq€ MiqG2. 9'Uq 9'jj JJG LG9JIJ42 916 8flp8l9'Uj9'jj2. nucp9'uGq' JJJGLGOLG JAG L6bOL4 oujA

cowb9'u2. 99'Lç6q o p€ ji€q iu 9112. O 4JJG 9'pOAG JJJ9LJGç9J2 V .L9'P16 5 2OJA JAO qGIJçoU9

yj6L1J94A6j2. JAG C011J JJ9A6 q9u6q JJG qc€ O 11GM j!2IJ 92 JJ6 G9LJG2I q9'4G JApICp 9'

M6 CJJOOeG 92 OJIL UJ9'U qGu4ou 0 1b02 ffJj 11GM jI24JU2 fO jJG Apj9'fl 0CJC EXCP9'UG

bLIcG2 MGLG LGCOLG oujA OUCG 9' JAGGJC

9G MJJ!CP ! !11 J9'U EAGU 1JJ2 W9'LJCG 4JJOJIJJ j9 U0 AGL2. jdniq uq rniçj EGpLJ9'L2. T08

Page 22: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

ioif 09! sill siohisdT .ô81 sM iii belssq M sth snsdoxs bole lom slilnu laill .l smil lLBm8 B ilhiw mood lshsm boh sill bswollol ls*Lsm

iJaths3J 1BfflfflU C '181 iifno3 slqms8 silT .slqrns siilris mo no eoiiaihsl2 mBmmua smog &iithnoo C sldsT

S sls iii (noillim 1C ) siiJ noilhid 1 a&f slqmsa sill ni irrifi nBibsm silT .aiss-mmfi

1$ lo eswhibnsqxs LBhiqsD bns lnsnsq 8C lo oihsm ishiqs oh lclsb s lnsnsq fib as no

bo szmuo nism sill lns8slqsm aninmss bsnishs$l .bnsmqiups bns Irislq hisqomq hsn bo hnsDlsq

'd lshiqs ahi niass1Dni bnsbivib 'ns 'q ion asob rbiilw mift nsibsm sill mob niDrIsrIfi

imsvs Isiiq& oh lnsDmsq 2 'lno abbs ldsb lsrzmsixs shiilw slom on asLq 'hiups Lsnisix .165 S iood oh Is*iBrrI nsibsm sill ai sulsv .lood oh ls*ism mob bshmoqsm isdmun sill Isill sbo .mss'

mss rbss iii (Ibaubni smse sill ni asinsqmo9 bsbsil loilduq mob 'hiups bo suhiv

olni slsI ol lnahmoqmi ai Ii nilaii wsn bo alfle sill bns alnsnimmslsb sill nilsulsvs nI

sill smo1smsilT .alnsmsmiupsm niheiI sill hssm asirLsqmo3 niahiso lno mss msvs lf$ffl bnzioos

smihrxs sill ion ai ammil bshail wsri sill smsqmoo bluorla sw iloirlw haniss *u3milonsd slsimqoiqqs

aA .alrzsmsmiiipsm nilaiI sill rxilssm shiqasb iaiI Ion bib ISEII amift bo slqmsa sill iud slqmsa

.boimsq slqmsa sill nhub bsrzsrb alnsmsmwpsm nihai1 sill bsnoiInsm iauoivsmq 5W

sill 1aibsa bsill amss-nsqmoo sill his mob aoilaibsba 'ismmua sill lmoqsm sw €1 C sldsT iii

ei siqmsa sill ni nsqmoo nsibsm sill iniahqmiia hot/I .mss Isill bo as alnsmsmiiipsi nihaii

aasi (lnsomsq li ai alsaas no niulsi nsibsm sill) sidslftomq smom , (asisa iii smiJ rioihhid O) msmsl

silT .(bnsomsq [$) smorn alasvni bns (lnsoisq CC ai lshiqso oh ldsb bo oihsm nsibsm sill) bsmsvsl

bo arnisl ni 09! ..U lsoiql sill as id as esmib mob buods ai slqmsa mo ni 'nsqmoo nsibsm

.(1(?1 mshhiiT) aslsa

lnsw 'silb mss sill bo as asinsqmoo bslail wsn sill bo aoibailsba msmmua sill ahmoqsm C) C sldsT

0'H lsilnsboq nsibsm sill as id as soiwl ai 09! nsibsm sill Isill sbon oh nilasmsbni ai II .oilduq

shdsbftomq smom Ion ai 09! nsibsm sill hasmlnoo 'E1 .absaas Isbol bas asso1qms ashsa bo arrnsb ni

thLT .hbeifl i9b 9LsiJaD 9rI d 9bSm noaffi8b 9di ot uibioa iiubni iii bbivib s nEqmoD' .noiaivib tiib ow D12 rli wollo1 1rft,oi

Page 23: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

18yDop6L bLGqic4ou O p je o o bnpf!c bLoçGcç cpGiL

ojqi. pu uiccpu combuX (--jcombui62 Jiprcp JAGUJ bapj!c fu boq Jg-9: fA6LG t€u ojqL XGn 9flq umcuglF! uoç b6c!c nubjG b€uoq mAGçç6q j,o cp6qc JAG cojqq cji tOL 4G 9€G o

21GIO

n& pGu u iUqicEoL o combuA2 2JG [AG n Jo9t!4puJ o mnL€ oj

4GW 9'uq !IJOLIJJ!OUI 9WWG4L!G gLG JG GAGLG JJJJG L2 GXbJuoL ALi9'pjG MG MIJ

LGL cowbruiG8 ponjq pG IJJOLG JJfGJ? o bnppc GCJ12G jxGq CO22 LG jG JUJbOL49'1J4 OL

JIJ JpJG J tAG p8'AG qGu4JGq OIJJG O IJJG CIOL2 W jGf cowbru?. o bnpjic

GAGIJ 4pOrrJJ pG? WG4 pG JJU LGcJII!LGUJ6IJI

o cLGqiv p? cowbL!u uGMJ? jaGq LUJ up 29WBJG oj uJj TJLW2 JJ9 LGWJG bL!/rG

[u uxç aGcçJou iAG Mjj nq?. qJG GGC42 o qcou ou BGLOLUJIJG& IJ'UC!U uq copirç bLGqcç pG Ji24iu qGciiow iii qou I3 MG J1J ou JJG IuoqGJ pLGU?. LGAGffiGq iii GcçJou j

U1GLGIJ bGLbGcr/G LT 26JOU MG nq? MGJJGL Ic i boipj co iqGucij 8OWG A9LJ9'pJG

ju ujAu pG qGcou jp jGq ' cowbu? o o bnpji& MG 4G bLopJGw LOW 4MO

yuij?i Oj JJG EX VU46 DGGLmJU1U

IJG ocj UJLICG qoG2 uoç CGL o JJG uuuc!u UGG2 o Aoau fl2G2G2 qOG8 !ll cJJG fl

iao iniq J ?GLB OJJGL ill JpG G9iJ!GL bGuoqj7g JJJJ joiiq LGUJUGL O JJJG cc cJ U Jj?.

9bbGsL O pG 8UijCEflJçJ? OJGL 4JJU MpiCp bLiJG: cJJG? MGLG 104 AGSL2 OJqGL lIT JG

jj ?GL LOL uou-AGudnLG-pcIGq ULUJ (CombGLa T5) /\jOLGOAGL cowbrnGe picp o bnpjic

cPG coLLG2bOuqJu A'JiTGa OL fl UGM brrppc combuiGe: ?G9L2 OL AGU;iILG-p7CJGq ULI1T uq

LGboLcGq p? nJq H9POIW (j4) jOL OPGL EflL0bGU COITucLiG uq UJ1TC JJ!JJ6L cJJIJ

jOL }JG combsrnG2 MIJ!CJJ MGU bnppc ill J-3 JJJJG2G J1TLG LG LOiTJJj? !IJ J!UG M!cP PO2G

GCOL 9uq !AIJJIU JJG 2GC420L p? 2!G) IPG AGLG G O IJGM biipjrc combu!G2 34 ?GL2

GLGIJCG GMGGU cPG!L G uq cpc ot 8!m!!L cowbuG Mp!cp bL!A9'4G (wIccpGq p

LIUIJ? JPIG 3 D LGbOl4 201116 29I2IC2 OU 4JJG G 0 11GM bnpj!c cowbtuiG2 9U 011 JJG

cpu pG UJGWU bocGuc!J iic 'uq IIJOLG p!JJJ? JGAGLGq

Page 24: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

55

coxJqGIJcJ4* AGI1 OJIL jmncq WIUJPGL o J1,Ø2 /G cmmo4 G pThOcJJ6I2

cowb9L9pJG comb9u162 i b9LicnJ9LJA pno?9I.w M6 W6920L6 4G bL!cG IbO MOllJq GICP 013

JUAGOL8 0336 tAonjq 9J90 GXbGCç comb9v? o p WOLG PGP o o bnpjic RpGU 46 W9LJCG4 OL

JO 4JJG GX4GIJ JJ9 GIJ4L6bLGUG11L8 4L?k 4O GXbJOi4 JJG OAGLA9JfwcIOu o COUJb9IJ!62 p?

OAGL 4O49J 922G2)

Oil 9226 (G9Lu!u GOLG !U2GL6 49XG2 qGbLGCffion 91J 9WOLi9li0U —JJ6LG9GL EBLLDV —

s bo!AG !UJB9Cc on bLop9p!J!A ot bnpJc j6 WG92i1L6 bLoc9pJç? 4JJG J96 LG4IILU

bGLm9u6n 9Uq iiij OAGLA9J11G i J39L6W i JJG jL CS2& 0136 wonJq Gxbccç bLo9pj O J.J9AG

!" bLoçe w o bnpJc pob!u 494 !nAGoLa 114Jj m!a9JcduJ7. bGLCG!AG J3JJ bLo9p!J!A

013 JJG bLop9p!J!A O 933 1b0 () JJG O46L p9uq if comb9u? Gxb6L!Gucin if 2flL6

UJOLG bLO9pJ6 cowbifn? IJ6G2 J622 6X46LIJ9J GdfI!lA 9nGac!IJ9 UG91JAG Jmbifc.r o bLoifpJJJ;A

GJGccion bLopJ6w pG bLGqic6q 611GC o bLoifp!Ji LGWifIU9 ifmp!noI12 o 4JJG 0336 JJifnqè if

COWB9U?-2G&L2 4JJ94 29çi2 4JJG J1241IJ LGdITJL6IIJGU4W B"1 GAGU 9GL cO1J4LOJJ!I3 OL 4JJ12 291UbJ6

Gxcp9uG jo ifAoq 4JJG qaco14iou psqncq p? BumbJG GJGCçiOU JAG LGL!cç OIIL 6!W9G2 4O

JIJ 2GC1OU 35 ouj? COIJJbifIJIG2 JAIflJ IPL6G AG9L2 ot bo2il AG GifLUiU CifU peç on IP6 9ocj

G boiçJAGJ?k COLLGJ946 liLiJJ JJ6 JJCGjiJJO0q Oj 913 IbO LOL L611j94OL?k LG&2ou: 92 GxbJifn6q

11 COIJL92 9nin p6 GGCç o bLoifpJ UJOLG qucnj E!L o JJ bLo1 9LG pornq

Gdni cifbi9J JJGA C9UUO1 G92JJ7 L9126 BL1AGJ?! GbGC!9JJ? C0U1q6LU IJJG J9CJ( 0 A6U11L6 CifBII9J

JGAGLGq CombifniG2 ponjq G WOLG !llC6I o BCG poLLotAnJ COU24Lif1U2 9IJq 4GU UGG GX46LIJ9j

O4ifJ q6p bjn GdrnA) ijjp'i bo!AG mbifq on 4JJ6 bLop9p!J! oj bnppc OL6EOL JJ6 291336 LGII2OIJ MG GXbGcç 46 GL6G O JGAGL9G (cpG J96 AifJflG 0 04ifJ OAGL

L96 0 29JGW M6 GXbGcç 4JJ6W 4O JJ9AG 9 bo2içA6 G11.GC on bLopifpJç? o oin bnpjic

cifb!ifJ Gxb6uq74nL6 — JJ6LG9GL CYBEX — OAGL bLobGI4 bJifu ulJq Gdn!bw6JJ) ifUq 4JJ6 L0JA

cifbiifI ya bLoxiG2 tOL 4JJG qGUJifuq LOL MG Jif6 JGAGJ o !UAG2cuJ6IJ2 (WG92ULGq 92

obboLçrnni62 3119?. uq ! IUOLG A9J119pJG 40 4G bilpJ!c W9LJCG4 92 913 9JIGLU9I!A6 2OIILCG

ot 6XGLUifJ ffUq2 y LW flU6L4ifflIJ 9 bju ot !UA624IUGUc2 OL 9 JLW 9qU pp LOIAJ3

LL9P!6 J ifJ20 2fl6242 J394 U IbO J IIJOLG I!JC6P LOL cowbifuiGa 133 IJ66 tOL JBLG 9IIJOflU2

Page 25: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

5111 iii sinsqrr1o 3iIduq Io iups Io suLBv Aood-o-ts*u3m edi o o11si uibem edt 'd ie1ism si11

oilduq o o i1idsdoiq siFt ito sulsv !ood-oi4ekuim siLl lo e1e ev11ieoq uE1 .1i8ubth 9(1188

trisaeiq ifir1 s beftei vsm oifsi lood-oi-islism dp1d A .nbi1q8im 'd ueviib XIii seix tou 8!

aeiiiniftioqqo i11woi serb 11 .ioJe nibfIoqe911o3 siFt iii eeiiinutioqqo dJwoi siuM 'to suLsv

'8een siLl eisi o1 iebio iii 3iIduq o o1 beDubth ed 111w siiIsqmoo nemsvth sxs1 eiiupsi

eno1s e3nsbive shis-xs Io Biasd siLt no bssriimhib ed tonns 8989I11oqr{ owi e89dT .nibnu1

qid8rIoits1ei siLt tsI11 mis13 fl& sW .sDnebivs oq xs niio1qxs d bs11eiunui8ib ed ns eiLt tud

89it1rnJJ1oqqo thtwoi suriR 10 nods39qx9 siLt 'd risvhb 81 809! bits Aood-ol-ts1ism rieewted

.slsi Ismionds as s svth einsqmo beai1 wsn JsrIi evie2do sw Ii 1no

lo iewoq iiinisisd 5111 93ub91 o ale*ism eilduq qsi ot beoicbth ed vsm asqmo s 11sni'I

eiasqmo iol ni1J3eqqs siom ed bluode 09! us nsr11 iobs1 tfisiioqmi uS 81 diLl II .1nsd (116111

sW .29flUO2 tibs13 eli lo f1O1ts1lfI99flO3 isnoita s bus riiwonod lrxsd lo lao isifir1 s oitsi siFt .ss + 1)\(,i + .1) = hDD$i d asqmo ot Jibeio lo Jeo evElslsi e11 siuassm

t89151u11 ssisvs sd bits + I erriii Is 'fIsqfflOD oJ b91sd3 iobs1 IesIsJLII siLt neswtsd

nibaoqae11o) silt d bsiuassm 81 tibsie eusqmo silt lo nOltsltiIsDfIO3 silT O2• + iLtocf tsrli bsqxe sW .eliisd us 'd I1SfflO) s ot beirisi tibsl3 lo 891111 911110 xebiii lcLsbnfheH

.09! its lo iilidsdoiq siFt no bsqmi sviizeoq s svsrl esldsnsv 985(11 lo

slqmssa eiiltie oiL rio i1U29$I X.I

:booililelil rriumxxsm 'd lebom iidoiq atwoIlo1 silt sf5ffILf89 SW ff11J8 ii!

,A0$1 + HTW0fID + hX9ADo + I2 o)\. = (I = 0qI)t (I) $IAYr + JHAUVIPLfI3H8i + hDDT + hHTMoi + DA$IVJ +

Ii .1 elsupe bits t bohsq iii stsvhq esie nsqmo Ii 0 elsups tsdt eldsiisv s ci oi sisdw

bus eldsiisv Isuriori bisbuisie 5 lo noit3aul noitudriteib svitslumu3 edt ci (•) oi1duq eeo ii . noib iii bebivoiq ei uoitinf1b aidI io isrfuitwj A°

Page 26: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

3uAiA ucjnqu cowbm!€ qo uo uJ6LJf?t zjpcc cnn.

iponc rçAu LGdJIIL6WGIJçe o drnqçiL6iqç qo uoç cpmG ii6 ucJrrqG }J6 combmi ujj wpcp combuiG2 coiijq JJA6 Opc9UGq 1AAGL LLOW lP6 C01420W OIIL mnbJG ou io couibiui€ jç

1B°' L6dflL6W6uç8 conjq G M&TAGq qcLou P PG COI'12013 9uq HG IJA6 110 M

qGAi9Jou IIJCLGEf2G u bLop!I !IJCL6G cpG bLop9pJiç?. o oiu bnppc p? ou€ up oj

bo2JTI iwbac ou bLop9pJJiA o biipjc 2UC9U 9 1J1G JØ JGAGf y 011€ 2ç911q9Lq

EAGU MpGU iA€ LGL1C JJG 9mbJc o combrn!6 !!!PI o o bnpJc bLo9p!J!A pa c

o u IbO plTl 9JO 4JJ €4GC4 UO4 9!c9II? IJ1JC9IJIGOU4L924 cou11i116U4 frI42JJ 6Xb6C9iOiJ JJ6 COUC11L9OU 0 p911J CLGqi4 9bbG9L 40 JCL69G

imb9c 011 JJ6 JJcGJpooq O IbO P" U!cPGL 2 8ç98c9'Jj? U1JC91J 9 JJG TO? JGAGJ B

CO11L9L pOqJ JJG C02I 0 p9'IJJ CLGq 9uq 9 LUJ JGAGL9€ 9AG 9 U€91AG

JJJG bLoxJG8 oL 4JJG co uq o c€qc qo uoç 9/€ mhTcp GxbJ9rJEroLX bot€L €p€r.

21UIIC9IJ4 MJJJJG JJ9 O LOMflJ ! 0UJ2 2iIJqC9U 9 P6 TOQ !'I

boppjA o jçu €xbcccq riç 4JJG coGc1Gu o JUAGm6U uoç aJçc9JJ?BO4JJ p€ A9LJ9pJG pç G92J1L6 9 JLUJ 1J9UC!IJ UGGq

—!UAGWG1J1 &uq L0fl — !UCLG26

bnpJc jpa Gc4 2JUUJC91T4 T j'jbGLc6u9G boiu4 Jpi coLL€2bouq o iucr. !u p€ 9mbJG 9'AGL9G bLop9p!J!A O OIJ

JUCLG9G 'U ;p€ JO9L1cpw O 9J6 !UCLGII2G2 4pG bLop9pJA o IbO r°' owo 2nLbLJ2iUJ? combcuA 6 U !mb0149U q6GLmiu9uç O 911 1b0 v 011€

ocpGL tA0Lq2 IIG qo uo qjUcqp G66U 1b02 o uq6bGuqGu comb9uG 9Uq c9LA€-ofl2

624W9G8 opu€q p? booJ!u UqGbGuqGu comb9u!G 9uq 2np2q9n62 o ji€q comb9rnG 1J

GLLOL2 (4pG 9WG !2 9JO IL1T€ O 2np€dnGIJ4 49pJG2) flJ€ IIL2f cojnmu oi LGboL

J9pJG L€boI4 pG G2JUJ94G o woqGJe a p€c6LOJcGq9 !c!4A-LOpnc 8ç9IJq9Lq

bnpjc !u iP2np2Jq9LG o OLG1U coLboL!ou (T' o 29mbJG) p6c9'nG 110 2JTCJJ comb9UA 92 GAGL OU6

COIJJb9JJA tAG1J bJlpJJc liG qLob LLOUJ 4JJ€ 29WbJ6 JG JJ9AG L0W J€ 29mbJG jprjiuMJJC !U JJ9 ?G9L 94J2j JJG I!c!U LGd11LGWGU8 qGcLpGq 111 €cioU 35t3 coflL2& 9GL

AEVIc ta c9J€UqsL ?G9L qnmw? BI w€ p€ iubj€ rncjnqG2 9JJ pG bui€ comb9uJ€

Page 27: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

52

iio uq 4JJ6 cowb9'u? 916 4G wo mo u!Jc9'u4 9'cçoL flUqGLJ?JIJ pG bLop9.piJiA o

b1TpJc OL 4JJG TI A69.L 9'4 OI1L q2boacow p LGW9'IJ 4JJG C2G p€ uqfILX m9'LjcGç—o-pooJc

62fim9'4Gq (uoc LGboI3Gq) 'bLoboL1ouIrJ p9.a'Lq L9'4O moqGJ 0j 4JJGbLop9.piji9. bui€ LW O!IJ

i.io 'uq 4JJG comb9.u?2 G LGW9!U o WO2l !WboLc9'U qGçGLUJIJ9IJ4 °. 1b0 M6 9'J20

L691TI2 (uoc L€bol4Gq) I9.L6IX COIJJLW Off I. uqiu iu b9.Lc!cnJ9'L cpG uqnçL?. UJ9.LJ-o-pooJ

EOL IP! L69.OIJ liG 9.J80 62iw9.4Gq 9. J1U69'L bLop9.pJç? usoqj Miçp Lw-8b6c!Jc

UJIJJ4 9.CCOflU OL JJG O2GLAG COLLGJ9.c!OU pG4li6GIJ W9.LG4-4O-pOOJC uq bLop9.p!J!A o o bnpj!c

pn2iuGG2 MJrJcp JrEfbbGIJ 4O G 9.2Oc9.46q wLip JOM w9.LJG-cO-pooJ A9'J11& 4J16U 4JJ2 CffJ41TL9.1 9.2

pGiL comb9'uG2 bnpjic j cuL6bL6IJ6fIL19.J LG8949.LTC6 2 IJJOLG MlqG2bLGBq ! LUOLG IL9.q4OU9.J

LOL GX9VJBJ& bL9.ciiouGL9 9.JJ( 9.Ofl 9' CffJITL9.J LG9i29'UG6 O W9'IJ? GIJL6bLGIJGffL8 4O 19'JCG

GXJ94GIJC6 O JluopaGLA9'pJG iJLW-9b6CC 6GCI9 MJJICJJ WJJ4 6 COLLGJ9'G MIJJ OJIL LGLG22OL2

OUG b022!pIG 2OITLCG O COUCGLU OL 8bGq1Jc9.çoIJ MG 9'qobGq ! P9' !4 !U0L69 JJG bo92IpJG

qiU6L6U4 tLOUJ qJ9. O JJG bLGcGqu cLIGUIJ!JTUJ)

9.J90 bGL !U T8 qG9bcG JJ6 €uq o 4JJ6 !Uc6U4IAG (cpc qnmm? ! UO4 9!U!UC9.UP

p? IGL (J JJ112 9.JçGLU9.iAG pThoq.2 ! anbbOLçcq pA 9'C IJ'c JIG po UJ9'LJCG

IJJG I9X JUC6IJ4!AG 8!UCG TJJGA W9'A G C9.b411L1IJ 9. 4WG GIfl96L!U O 1b08 2IIp 9"d JqGU4Gq

GTT.GC42 HOMGA6L MG GGJ UUCOUqOLc9'pJG !U 9. L!Pfr!u f JIG GUçJLG 6GC4 o AG9'L qnmWG2

o i combnq M!IJJ 4JJG OIPGL G9uJ9.lGq

IUOLG !11C61A IU Jf-8Q uq JJI2 GJJGC4 19 249'i9iC9'JJA 21 1C9'U JJG 2° JGAGJ yç L9.C6 A9'JIT6

I!I6JA III 4JJO2G 4JJLGG AG9.L8 [U JJG booj€q 2nubJ& JJG bLop9'p!J!iA ot 9" Ibo ! j bGLcGu9'6 boJu2

GIL6CI O p12 49'X 1UCGU1AG pA 4G24!U BLpGçJJ6L 9.j46L COUILOJJ!IJ LOL OJJGL 9.OL2 IbO 916 UJOLG

DI1L!U 42JJ6 Tgf-g bGLroq UGUL J124IU2 tAGLG 1A6U 9' GIUbOL9'tA JUCGUçJAG M6 IJAG JJG

bnppc [U Oil L 99'WJ)JG 4JJ12 iIJO J UJOLG combffuiG2 brippc 9 AG'L

9' boiu coLL62boJJqJIJ O 9. JDCLG9'26 ID IJ1G 89'mbJG 9.JiGL9.G bLop9'pJJjA °L

UJ9'LJC6NO-pOOJ L9pO L9'12G2 IPG bLop9.pipA O O 9' JLW JU JJG 29.1116 2GCIOL pA 0116 jjp o

o 4JJG bLop9.pJJA O JJ9IJU p62JcJG 2J6' M6 uq IJJ 9' OU6-2ç9'lJq9Lq qGAJ9çJoU JUCLG9.6 IIJ flJG

E!U9.JJA 4JIG JUqff2cLA UJ9'LJCG—cO-pOOJC L9.çJO 9'bbG9'L2 O p€ WG O2 8!11!UC9.l qGcGLUJJU9.1J

bGLcGu9.6 boiu (oapjA U I5è? !UCL69' JJG 89'mbJG 9'AGL9'G bLop9.pJJJA O IbO)

Page 28: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

p) qLobbiu 8111&JJGL LW8 om 8mITbJG ouqGbGuq6u cowbøi: 86 LGWU8 8UII!CS1J 66LWJ911VG6C4 O 21G III csLAG-oslc2 8 Z1O 1IJGLG}? qa€ 4O (III,L6LG1JI 6 tAG AG LG-G2ç1WçGq I6 L6LG82OUo bnpjicj? L&q6q comb1mia 18 iuqq J8GLa piiç Lm126 !8 no macp qGL6IW jp cp€cjc 1p6 q6LGI3c

9 BLG pOAG UJ!UTUJJIUJ a6 LGdJ1LGq (OL j8cn1 JjJG gAGLG 81&G O anp8JqwL1GØ€ m 2a2b6cç cJ'I p€ J9J O açac 81JWC1JC6 O Y6 J 4JJG CLA6-OJ1l 29117b16 q6Ly€8 jiiibj? om

o bnppc r &LG uqGbGuqGu4 JG8 ! 9LG flp2iqWLi68 pfl poji 6IJGCI2 'LG UO4

qGLGIJCG C0I7CGLU cJJG LOJ6 bJA6q pA J6A6L6 0L6 JJ!JJIA J6A6L6 C0WbI5!G2 L6 JITOLG pJCGJA o

pu JOL uqGbGuq6uc cousbru!G jçponp qGLGucG 12 17O4 cjjA upjcu y cjJLqpooj L9ç1O o LqGq LUJ2 pi 21UG psqnaii.A cbb6L rbbLox!m6JA P!GL OL C9LAG-O1142

v 2GCOIJcJ q!GLGIJCG !2 pop G2W9G GGC42 O bLoJpJ4 'uq o pG uJLJG-co-2GJGCçIOIJ C024 11UJ622 4JJ6A 9'LG 2np2qp5LG2 o bnpjcjA 4L9G combuG2

cousbu!G2 jjuq qdnJ 4O 62P!!2P LGb1710U uq 2GJJ €drnA IA14JJ0J14 b9'A!u J9LG qA612G

0 4pGiL bLGU C0IJJb9IJA V P5 DP5IJJOrn4 (TT) uq uq JilhJJJ!GL! (j 2UJJJ

1AJJ6LG2 2UJSJJ 2I1p2Jq19L7G2 0 62pfl2JJGq biipjc cowbtis€a C9'II qLsM nbou IIJ6 LGbff48c!OuIJ cb!c'J

L°1 LGb1Tou: 2IJJJJ uq6b6uqGul cousbltu!68 juq pslqGL o G4 JcIJoRu o bnpjic j&4O flJG I1WLJCG4 VUOIJJGL — bo22p1A COIJJbJ6W6IJ49LA — IJçGLbLG49çi0fl 4JJ9 2ZG 'cç2 bioxA

combuA ( jOL fG OAGLGt coe o CGL1JC9f!oU uq q22GuJuaçiou o rccoiiu u !UtoLm9!oU

4JJI OL 2uTp2qp5LiG2 qJG xGq CO o J!2U 916 b9LçJA 2øIJJCe pG1IJ sJLG9'qA pOLIJG pA 4pGiL b9LGu

9OAG 9 CGL91J5 4p162poJq b022pJG 1692011 IApA 2G IU94ç612 oIJjA tOL JrrqGbGuqGuc cowb8'171G2

4G JUJBOLf9UCG 0 2G !a IPG 6X!2GUC6 O xq UO9!OU CO22 Mpcp C911 G LGCOAGLG oujA pA L2

JJG L2 2LJ1J 9C4 2 JJ9 2!6 OG2 UO III94GL OL C9LAG-0114233 JJJJG 112119j GXbJ9'1J9'!OU 0L

pjppooq LO 4G24 LG16c8 JGAGJ 4JJG 6dnsJA o coGWciGuc8 ps IPG wo 2J1p29UJbJG2

q6C2OIJ o 2np2IqI9LA o brrpJc cowb9uA J,p2 pAboçpG22 9J20 2nbboLçGq pA qi:• yqGci2iou o rn pJqGbGuqGu comb9uA o o bnpjc 916 qiGLGul tLOW IPG L9CfOL8 MJJICp qLAG

rnqGb6uqGu4 1b02 'q C9LAG-01T2 ic 266W2 L62OU9JG 40 9221TW6 JJG 9COL2 1TuqGLJAu

JJILçJJ6L iU27JJ42 017 4JJG q646L117IIJ9IJ49 0 JJØ2 C9'U pG op9pJ6q pA qiiqis 4JJ6 29111b16 p6P1GG1J

DIILGLGUCGC 64M66IJ uq6bouq6u4 HOC uiiq CULA6-O114C

'J IbO EJJJG cJJG JGAGJ 0 bLoj9pjA uq 1J16 L946 O L0M4JJ J026 2c9l!2!C9j 2!JJ!UC91TCG

Page 29: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

cpG ]O\O JGAGJ LOL CLAG-Of1co-pooI c!o ! uoç c!2cC!J c JGAGJ OL uqGb6uq6I1c coinbnn lip!JG !c 2 1 IJnCUc c

WGLGU boruç onç cpc MpG'i /tG g bLoboLcouJ pm.q nucçiou (uoc LGboLcGq) cp urc-

oj qGcieioIJ JGLL9U Ta5) Mpicp 24LG22 JJG iJGG2 4O IJIJ9UCG iIJAG241JJGU4 9uq L0M4Jr

BuirG u p€ ou puq i i JmboL9u 40 AGL! 4p€ LffJflJU622 O JG 2GI-LGboI4Gq UJ04A62

41J6 GGC2 o w lEO Miçp LG2bGC4 4O O4JJGLMJ2G 1qGu1c9J ULW2 JJ9f CJJO2G 0 LGUJ9'JIJ

9J4.€LIJ9'41AG 24L9462 LOL JJIJCOA6L1IJ qGçGLWIIJ9IJç2 O 4JJG qGCJ8IOU o o biippc 12 o jooj

yIJJJA2i °1 W6 EX b° C0U6dffGUC6 O U IbO

G2G couJb9uJG2 1E02 9L6 UJOLG jiJGJ? OL pip-thop couJb9uJG2 MpICp uAG2cGq 9 JO

iuqGbGuqGu4 comb9u162 2iG 12 JJG WO24 !mboi49u qGçGLUJiIJ9IJ O JG q6cJ2ou o bappc L°1

biminui LG2bGc 4O 4pGiL pooJ A9JflG IUqGBGUqGLT4 O 4pGJL 2IG B COUL2 OL

EJIPJIC COUJB9IJJG8 C9LAG 01T4 W02f bLoç9pG 2np2qJ9LJG2 !11 iUqJT2fL1G2 4JJ94 ILVG

9'COL2 1p12 juqiu 12 cou2J2fGU4 M1Ip GAiq6ucG p?. cpcJ?k 9uq (j) 0L pG flUGq

JpG bicnu JJ94 GWGLG2 20 t9L 12 4JJ94 C9LIG-OI142 9LG LAGIJ p?. JU9UC!9I L94GL 4JJ9U L69J

ic Lonb 12 wimp GL 9ç Jw1u UJ9LJG ru uqGbGuqGuç couJb9u?54

JJG wimp 24LOIJGL 1UJb9C4 O 4G Uqn24L? W9LJG4-0-p0OJC is'jn ou bLop9pJJrç?. o s c9'LAG-onç:

IJJOLG JJJGJ?. 40 pG 4JJ6 C12G J JG comb9u? J2 JJJJJ? JGAGLGq JJJI2 UçGLbLG9IIOU 2dn9LG2 9J20 MIçJJ

vu JuqGbGuqGu4 cowb9u?. uJr?. u24G9q IA9iJ4 o o bnpjJc tOL IJ6G o Gdff1 c9bçj1 9uq 4pi2 12

UU9UCJ9J C0uq1410U2• JJ1118 GxbJ9u2 GGC48 poçp oj pip bLo9piJi 9uq oj JOM JGAGL9G

2GC4OL 1p12 qGCJaIOU M1JJ pG ponp ouj?. !. 4G coInb9u? !2 iu 2onuq GCOU0UJC 9'uq

V C&LAG-Oi14 12 UJOLG JIJGJ? 40 OCCJTL GXbJ0i4 9 9AOL9JG W9LJGI A9JJ19'çIOU 111 142 B9LçICJIJ9L

JpG8G Juqu2 m pGJb iqGuçi 4J16 qJGLGu4 moJA68 pGpiuq 9 C9LAG-Ofl uq i IJOLUJ9J 1b0

G%% IJJ9U 4G LG2 9uq LGM JG28 (9Jp ouj?k 1JTG JL2I IjC !2 2c9'i2cJc9'JJA 8iU!UC9U)

E12 bLGqc6q p? E&U0 uq i5J (o) B COIJ4L C9LAG-Ofl42 9LG aflp2JqJ9L162 iUAG26q

JuAG24Gq 9JJcJ LGM IJJOLG JJG LG24 O IJJG 89IJJbJG (pop GGC42 9LG 249l2flc9JJA 2iuJc9uc)

V 1JIJ9J 1IJLG1JCG LG9L2 !UAG2cmGU uq Loiijv JuqGbGuqGu lEO2 9LG cowb9u162

2III1C9IJ4

Page 30: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

3g

qnmmX A9'L19'pJG2 GdIl9'j OUG i ?G9'L 3 — M9 4J16 IbO ?GL %10 12 9' q1TWUJ? A9'LWpJG Gd119'J

MJJGLG s uq q 9'L€ p.m-b€cc alJq C9'JGUq9'L ?€9'i. 2bGc!c GI1GcV 916

=o+ ++€ ()3 3

LOL 9'JJ 4G A9'LJ9'pJG MG 026 JJ6 OIjOM1U 2bGc1c9çiou:

2 L€boLJ9 62!mG2 o 6GC2 oj 1b02 ou 20W6 obGLsf!u 9IJq IJ9'UCi9'J '!9'PI2

21 yCCOnIJçiU 6U2fIL62 O b6LtOLIJJUJJC6

bLocGqnLG

A6LA iuçq 6xbJ9'Uht4oL? boMGL o Gdn9çou (j) GJ1W1U62 bLffq!c9'J LGfGA9'UCG o pi

pG qGC2OU o o brIpJc 20Cr Gdn!ou (i) 62im9'çGq !U cJJG bLcAion2 26C1!0U IJtOL0U9'IGI?

conjq G 2OJA6 iw Mo-2ç9'6 bLoc6qnLG MGLG p6 jL 2496 !uAoJAG2 G24!m9iu ' moqj o!oU bLop6m: cp cowb9'u!62 JApJCJJ MGITc bnpJc p9'/G CO26U o qo 20 bL!uc!bJG cP!2 bLopjGus

Gcouq u G24UJ9'U 4G Gx-bo2ç cou2GdnGucGe O IbO MG 9'CG 9' boçGui9'J GUOGUO1T2 26]GC-

4JJ6 GGC4 O JJ9A!U IJJ6I IJJG J!2c!IJ L6dfl!L6W6IJ4 qOG2 UO4 x€uq p6?ouq IJJLG6 ?G9'L2'

' P6 I!8!U LGdfflL6mGIJ 9' UJ6 — V — —3 L62bGC4AGJ? JJJJ!2 bLG2abbo2Ga W9'

jo 4pJ2 bJmbo26 MG CLG9'4G O11L qnmm? A9'L!9'PJ62 MJJCJJ 9' IUJG8 i GdcwJ ouj 1j 9' comb9u?

L6L622OL2 W1T24 IJCJflqG A9'L!9'PJ62 Mp!CJJ C9'bfIL6 JJ6 GIGCI O WGGc!U cJJGJ121U LGd0iLGWGIJW

P!PGL bLOJ42 916 bo2!lAGJ?k 9'UIOCOLLGJ9'çGq) JO COLL6C tOL JJ12 2910bJ6 BGI6Cc!Ou bLopJGw OITL

o mG€ç 9 bLo9'piJç? CL14GL!OU GOLG J!2!U (oL !U2s11cG GxbcçGq bLo9pJc? M1JJ p€

O uGMJ?-J2Gq cowb9'uG2 m? flGL tLOUJ JJ9' o bL!/6 colub9'u162 21mbJ?. pGc9'na6 p€?. pq

EIL2V ouj? cowb9U162 MJJ!CJJ W6GI J!U L6dnL6mGu2 C9'U o brzpc JJJG bGqoLm9ucG

8GJGCOIJ bLopJGIu8'

1P6 fl 9'uq 4JJG IJJLGG 2ap2Gdf1GU ?G9'L2 G8I1UJ9'cU 1G2G LGLG22!OU2 MG 9CG MO 29'UJBJG

ILl JJ6 G6C4 o 4G q6c2Ou o o bopJ!c a c9bpuGq p? qommA A9LJ9'pJ62 LOL ?GEIL ot

bGLLoLm9ucG nq JIJ9'UC1U q6c2oUa /A6 1IJA629'4G p?. G2l1W9'1U xGq-6Gc2 LGLG22!OU2

4JJ6 O4JJGL p9Uq fl 2 !IJI6L624!I7 4O 4G84 MG4GL 46 ILO p92 2D!JC9'IJ;66C42 OLl ObGL9'4IJ

Page 31: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

IBup9 aeldshBv 'mmub TO139 bus iod au C asift iom 93B1q Loot OCH SLI Ii 3110 ot

Isbom J1 bxft B niau I . — is 11 a em9ihJp3l niiei1 31li b5fleiJsa asqmo li no o

atioqei 1no 91dB 3dT .oqi 3fLf ris 11ai io 1oifuo a as OH 3lohd miff fIi8L1 91B SW

.asldanav rnmub OI4aoq bus O'1I 9if 110 ahI3iDffl9O) 911

-3qa mo o noibejdo ajroivdo us aau3Sib oi slidwdt-iow si i aJ1uasI srlt nifnsasiq sioIsH

noiSi3Sb eiIf no 1no sniu1 fon 'sm snsrnmohsq o aemuaasm niuxuos ui asnsuID .noi&fli

bss1 no osis bnsqsb 'sm fi1idsJ1Iomq snsani mol :esldshsv msdio no oafs md i1duq o om

oats svsui sw as1dsimsv msufmo sasilm mol IommnoD oT .no os bus tnsmiasvni as1sa ilidsmfioiq

'lo asulsv bss1 asbubni oats amoassmsm lb ai1 sdi sisdw aisbom mmo1-bSDubSm msrbim bsmsmimas

imoimq s musvslsi sd mdim maul i asldshav niinuos isifto 'lb bus sldsimsv irisbrreqsb 91It

o1 malimia '1svtmsti1sup 3d om briujol ems alebom 3imsnb merloim easrim lb smluasm siLt asa& iaom ill

aauoaib ew mud sfdsm emsmsqss a ui astsmimae misiLt fioqem ton ob sw sldsT ui bemmoqsm esoult

.fibmo lb faoo sift no atluasm sill mol lno noitqeoxs us stsrn Iliw eW .swollo'r madw iii insult

fffidsffioiq .t .1.

iosfts silT .oqi sift msfls aeniloeb fi1idaiflomq sum fault awoula sidsi silt lb wom laiR silT

built suit ui C of 09! siLt usñs mss' laiR suli iii easi o'.1 moml niaim 1ibseta tud '11subsu

levsl l silt fa hisoRinia L1soifaiisfa si itilidsiftomq iii hal silT .smas' tnsupsadue ui bus mss si suiT .(o-) atuo-svmao mol msno'iia 11SVS si foelle insnsrnmeq silT .mss Isubzvibrn doss ui

.(e1) dadE bus doha9 noa13)blzM bus (1I) mi)! bns inst lo nibnR sift uLliw tnsfaianoo

:niaimqmua fauLt us mon ed am ilimem siuli fuo fnioq (CQ1) msaujadAoe bus emoseU sA

sm sdJ mo fihidafilomq u1iuf '1lsuaunu uff 1w biuioo of 5911581 iiedf effiLt Bm siusnemqsmmns

of nibmoooA .09! edf lb emit edf Is ainuoooa e±smoqmoo iirLt lo ntaasmb-wobniw III 5BuI9 'fmsq 'hssmls evad eW .nsem suif ot r1oiaaemem Iammou a of sub 'lqmia si iluasm siulf WSIV ahif

nifai1 sum bsftaifsa 'nsqmoo a neriw asirnmub nilmearui d rnaioiiimo lsifnsmoq skiff beassibba

l1aoifaiffa '1rliii bus evxfsen Ha ems ibidw aeimmub eaedT .amss azsoivemq ui afmsiups sd aso a091 'lb vtilidsfkIomq ui qomb C bevmeado suli lo bmiu[f a '1no isuff fasua fusofiinia

.nssm siLt of noiaasmsm lammon s 'd bsnialqxs

Page 32: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

30

6UG2 o cowbui AoJnuuJ? ab CJJG pooj AJflG o 9?6qiçoLGq 46 A11J1JçIOU O 92G pU2Gq 011 IJI2cOL!C9I CO8 N416L6 cj ncpo14ca b64oqcJ? COUC6G x

j,pa bLopJ6w mpc pG bm CffI9L1? 6AGL6 111 IP li4J6LG fIG JJ}J IJIJfOI1L6O fIG IôO iq 1WL68I1J U11U2ç 0111.

JJIG 1IJG L69O1J cponp I12 4J3& bUAçG comblfli G LG 11101.6 1ITGJ? () mJqGL-L6bOLc bioç& piiiJ fIG

bLo&pJ tjj p jini OL cowbsvi JIkJJGL6 0LIJJ GJJIL&BLGJJ6IIL2 Ju ja cdrnA: u

o LUUOL p9'LGpoJqGL2) ps pop CG LGIGIIJI pGoi.€fc9J woqj bLGqcç p94 fJG ii !"

p9'Lq (conojju 2JJ9LG0J6L2 J3AG LG6L !11C611f AG Gxuc bLiiçG 6UG T fIG GXbGJJ2G

GJG4øU (cowbu!G o bllpJ!c I!GU bLop!J! pon o qGcJiuG bGLmuGuJ?.) 01.

OP6L IJJOLG nuqucuç GxbpIIwfOUB o 4JJG qGcJuG !U bLopJ! 91.6 pq on

0AGLA9JnGq) u bnpJc comb9u! pni in bLIçG on coLLGbonqinJ?. iujçiu opu€q'9'P L0W fIG 49X 9npoL? 'T9 9 LG8ITII 4JJG A9JuIG 0 922G9 W9 G JG22 1TIJGLA9Jff6 (01. UJOLG

!ucGUfAG9 91.6 96U !u bL!/6 comb9u!Ga p!cp W pG 11101.6 C0UC6LUG pon pqu IIJG!L

JJ92 9IJ IJGLG 115 bLoAiqrn (01. GAGU iupçcj) IMCçKILG o 6 A9jaG o 49 929G49 (1CJJ

C9U pLo1TJJ p? q6c!80u o o bnpJ!c p bLGb9Lps 1p6!L 9ccosrnj jOL coujb9n?

o' bopJG GxbI9IJ9iou OL pi bGLm9nGnç qLob u blo pH! p o qo JAcjJ 9CC0nuçi1J

on bLo9piJç?

uq qoG IJo LG2J1I4 oIJJ? L0IJJ L6L622101J cc) 4JJG IJJG9IJ 01. jLOIIJ fIG GIJGCç 0 0UJG 0P6L A9LwpJG

uijcu co6fflc!611c2 M6 CO1JCI1qG p9 fIG 9J ID bLoUc9pJ!A ! LG9JJ? 92CW6 "4f1 P6 IbO

pscjnq J9G IJAG2UJGUc 9uq 4JJG J0 0 J96q 29JG tApiCJJ poçji GUçGL fIG L6LG22I0IJ /AIqJ 2I-

4JJG LG2b6ccJAG coGwcJGIJ.c ID 4JJG JL24 LOlA 0 JJJ'pJG JJJG 9IIJG rn ILflG JJJG LGeLG2e0L2 9J0

iUJC9Uç 9 COUAGUcIOU9J J6A6J9 JjJG J0IJ-LffU imb9cc o 69CJJ qrniimA 9bbLoxlni9cGJA Gdn9J

GC0UJG9 iuIjc9uc J6AGJ 9nq cpo ot bo2c-Jbo qcrmm62 L6w9'u uqiu cp bGcijc9cjoue cpG mbtiq COGWC!GUc 0j fIG IbO qiimm? qGCLG9262 pL4JJGL co 0T I uq

fIG C0GC!GU ot cpG bLo9p!IiA !" fIG A69L 0LG fIG IbO 91119'JJ 9nq UJbL6C2GJ2. 62fW9çGq

co pG AGL2. 2Irnc9u (M!cp 911 G2m9'cGq COGWC!GUc 0 9 61.1.01. 0 Tf) pøc

a'nq bLo;9piJic?. in JIG A69L pqpLG 6 no LLPG L2 j o bLoç9ppA 1TLU2 oac

M6 cL? co blop6 cp 99J16 qG6bGL p. qqu co fIG nc o L6L62OL2 pG o bloj-

Page 33: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

21

IL EG coU2TqGL LG2flJ2 IOGJJ6L !IJJJ JJO26 9L1 IJ LLOW OJIL 6X-9'iJlG U9'J?212 JU 26C4 On

bLoJpiT !u ?n. PGLOLG cpG (uo 2u!Ucnc)COIJLOI2 LOL iq JGA6L9'6 ci jq bLoup!J!4 (9JJ 2!J!llcU) 9llq OL

'uq bLoUa'p!Ji 266 LOL 6xusbJ6 r1rn uq !uJ To2) iT p6 L62HJ b6L2! MJJGU OUG

bLopiJi4 PGLOLG lJJG Ib (LGCEJJJ JJGLG 12 9' 24LOIJ UG9'4iAG COLLGJ9'1OIJ pG4li66U JGA6L9€G

uqiu uqGbGuqGuc 1b02 L6flCG cpG!L J6AGL9'G 9'çGL o!U bnpic GLAG2 LOUJ 4JJGJL P!P

P!IG c9'LAG-Ofl42 qo o ouj?. in pc ou LIJU (9'J2o p o� o' 2n2b6c

2I1p2ç9'Ui9'JJ? (p6MGGU in JJG L2 OITL ?G9i2) nq bGLm9'nuJA (pA

9'IJGL IbO S2 JJ1T2L9'46q pA 4G 4JJLq LOM O 1J36 pj nqGb6uqGu combui€ q6J6A6L9G

Juq6b6uqGIr cowb9'u!62 9'uq c9'LAG-Ofl2 so qL m9'LyGqJA u CJJ9'U€ °L

ffuq jG2)

bLorppA (jj o iipicp pi bo2iAG uq 2IJ!C9'UI CO JCGIJ49 GXCGbç LOL J9'Gq JUA62UJGU

rncJllqG CflLL6U GXGLIJ9'J qGpce Gx4GLu9'j GdflçA uq j9'€q !UAG8JJJGUI 29'J62 9uq

0J JJG IbO (o o c9b!cIJJ aocJ J4JJ626 62wrcGq 6GC8 bGL2!ac MJJ6IJ LGL682OL2 9'J20

240CJc) ju COUUJ C9'UG-Ofl2 Gxp1p1 eIUqCIU iubor.A 1UCL69G III iuAG2çmGIJç 9'ç flJG 4im6

9' qGJ&A O 4MO AG9'L2 9'IJGL P6 IbO P1 ! J9'LG uq b6Lui9'uGuç ( iqaqiou ot qJG cbijGxbGuqinL62e 9'2 2JJOMU !IJ 4JJG 26COU LOM °L LL9'P!6 JJJG qGCJUG IU !IJAG84LUGU 66L62

c1LbLi2JuJA LOL iuqGbGuqGu4 comb9'u!62 p6 qGcaou o o bnpJc p 'UG9'4. JAG on

213 IUA624GU 9uq J6A6LU6

OJTL GAIqGUCG 12 IJJO2 COU212GU tAiçJJ 4G conq pAbopG2

6XBJ9'IJ9'!OU2 9'LG COLLGC 4JJ6U JAG 6XbGC 9' uG9'c!A6 LGJ9'4oU8jJb 2 MG 29'JJ 266 IJ 2GC4!OU (

&nA L6J9'4ou2pib G4M6GU pG MO pA CODL9'24 6IJJ6L 46 IIJOL9'J JJ9'9'Lq OL W6 9'qAGL2G 2GI6C4!OIJ

bLoç9'pJA 9'6L pG 1b0 IL IPG 9'tCOIiIJ4!u 6xbJ9'u9'4oIJ !2 pG L!IJ4 OUG 4GU i qo uo GxbGcl

bo2-IbO bGI.oLu9'ucG pA Gx9'UJiIflu 6IGCI o 81G °L 4JJG iuCfIIJJp6u42 29'jG on 9' combsnA2

C9'IJ q84ina2p 6M66IJ JJG 9'CCOJ11JU 9'Uq JJ6 MO UJOLG IIIJq9'UJGU9'J GXbJ9'TJ9'c!Ona LOL

uq !u qJG IJJOL9'J JJ9'9'Lq moqGJ pA 'JGIJ2GU uq JAIGcJcJiu (To) !1 pG!pGu2 4G 9'GuCA bLopJGuJ

IJJG 9'qAGL2G 26JGC!oU UJOqG! O pGJ9'nq 9'nq bA1 I0JAGL 6d1T!IA LG6U!OU ! 9' 2!U9'I ot pu dnpçA

Page 34: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

combu€ b woi. pu qow6c coiubuwIpJcp 91.6 bLr1us9pJ? oLc6q p) cJJG!L b6uç cowbmi o jcth 2çucç vcconuu UTJG& 0116 uq2 696

L6LGrOU ! L-6!m1 IJ6L qqp qm1n17? L01. If1!9112r1p9Tq19LI6 °L L0L6!I1 COUJb9U162euq 1iocp61. O( 6Aq6IJCG !" (9AOL 0 4JG J462i CCOflUIJ 6U1j LG9GL

O 4JJG CO242 O O!U bnpjic

ocj xcpu bLGAGu COIJJB9VJG2 LLOIII GJnqu OL GA9qIJ 49'XG9 iniq IJJ JJ8 LGbLGGUç2 ou

o bLoAq6 om P! tOL 9LflW6U irtconuc!u L9u2b9L6uc?. 6UOLCG pA

WOLG 49X62 bGL A69L 4JJ91T pqoLG jpoap a !mBL6CGJA iua'€q Jpi bb9z.ax bnu 96L W6 IBO L9C41OIJ O 4JJ61L obGL9çiu rncouJ& 4p6A bA pon

yu Juru L62ap i u bsrpjc cowbtu!6a ffbbG9L o p6 2A16C4 o b6LmF,u6ui

4p6 9poA6-L6boL6q LG21TJ2 9'ponc 1UAG24IJJGU4 (9's J692 tOL IJJ6 nJqGb6IJq6u4 cowb9uiG

9ç oqq içp bLooAb6 o ;p6 mu JU9UG coLboL96 LOllJJ pI1 içpJJJGLG uo uijIc9u cpu pi qp rnnrcu b9Aonç suq LoIiLçp JJJG L62J1J4 9Ofl J8

JOL6OAGL 99 OUG onq 6XB6C cda!A U9UCU L!862 2p9LbJA (pA ) 111 A69L °i. 1b0

cowb9u!68 b9LJç GmboL9L!JA IJJ6 9pIJOLIIJ9J !UU0IIL o JdJTqçA p.om Ibo ! Ju9uc!9!JIJ J1J9UC!9J 99262 L1262 16mboL9LiJA WG o JJ6 Ibo bLop9pJA pcria qr u6i, bnppc

JJJG L62J1J42 COIJCGLJJIJJ 4JJ6 OJJ6L 9CCO1TL14!IJ A9'L!9pJGB P-' J)PJ6 J !J!' IUA6lmGU

213 O4P6L 9CCOUUIIJ A9L!9pJ6

46 COU4LOJJJIJ 2JJ9LGpOJqGL 4O qA62ç b9'14jA pom cowb9uA

Of12 OCCIIL O L9126 L62011LC68 JU9IJC6 CULL6U4 !UA6auJ6u 9U 92 IJ6 266 J94GL 4O 9JJOM

4O L6p9'J9UCG c9biç9J 2LJ1C11L6 9'j6L !L1JbJ6mG1JTU 8np29u!9J u ausGul bJ8u8 IAJJ!IGC9T.A6-

4JLU6 O p6 JJ, 9Uq L61TC6 JGA6L9G oujA ji. oir o uq6b6uq6uç comb9u162 uq o o bapJ!c

J6A6L96 Uq — BJJ 9 —UA62UJ6IJ4 MJJ!J6 C9LAG-Oi142 26b rib !u/cecw6u 6mboL9L!JA 9c

J6A6L96 1116 6X-bO24 GAJqGucG 9qq2 4JJ94 9Jj6L ;pc no Uq6B6Uq€U comb9u!6a LGfIC6 JJ6!L

9pUOLm9JJA pJJ 1IJA62IU€Uc 9uq LOJJ MjJ!J6 C9LA6-Oi12 JJ9A6 9PU0LW9JIA joie. iu/G2pJJGu 9uq

9 COIJ2!8GIJc 2çOLA 6WGL62 ffGC9JI P6LOLG IbO uqGb6uq6u4 cowb9u uq o qbjA

Page 35: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

ibe13 10 *aoD

'm noib9b idi sdi ei (8801 9tiaH) 3ilduq tho lo a9shuvb.s b9misb nño su1t lo eriO

8id 10 zoi iIsmiol A .oib9i 1911 io ba ehisd iv--aiv ffoii8oq niaiisd 9rf 9voiqmi OT iaI 911J 'd b9l9lEIo fi lo ta s±,b 9up11ILI 8 oI 891B iuO .($0CI) n8j$1 Eli ai iioiiiiith

.ai8Ioq'uf 8ir1 iesi oJ u awolls 2i119113 1i9f1 o alnad ff8ul8i1

9ffft5b ot b9911 3w aii'1 .am3Idolq owI s1 sw 11b913 lo taoD 9111 Iii 89fI81b flflHB9ffl nI

9111 nedw boil3q 6 niiub iib9lD lo iao 9vit619I 9111 in 3fLBfk) 8 111kw nsm w isilw h9qo1q baa rxwid b31sLlbao isi S19VS sdi) 91dsilsv 19miix9 aaw afsi 1nisd lo 19v91

9B19VS 9111 01 b9qa91 rlliw mifi lo iib9lD lo 1803 9v118191 9111 9flfi9b ol aorb 9W .

(1119319q

(i + 1) 1 mii is 'nsqmo oi b9iafb ioiii1 1aie1rii 9111 ri9swi9d olisi 9111 aa iib9i3 lo taoD

mii isdi is 9lqmsa 9111 m 891r1Bqmo3 9111 118 ol bisib iobsl ianini 919V8 9111 'd b9bivib

1s131I9 9111 uk 89fl6f13 ol irLsnsvni ai ii lath ak ff01110119b airhi lo 91111891 niLB9qq8 911T + 1)

amift a riwid 93rx913ib r1i (arioiaa919i bsiIoq9iau ui) 9811 oaleu 9W .alai 1a9131ni lo 19v91

isrhl a11u29i riisido w baa 1ib913 1o iaoo 9viis191 9111 lo iuasm 6 as tai S19V8 r{i baa isi .ishifnia 1I$3ii 11a bus 1LsDimonoD9 315

6 swnl a9IILBqmO3 118 isrIl 1I9Vi 98U 9W blirorha sIsi 189191n1 Ibirlw 8b1s9i 91182i brio39a A

is mill ol b91srb 9181 risibsm 9111 9811 ol 980113 9W .a.laad 1si9v98 111kw qiIIanoli6191 11b9iD

.810119 uiii10q9i ol aa3rulaudOl all lo 9611839d (1s9 9111 lo 1911sup las! 11l as b9a119b) I 311111

9111 ha rio 21n5d au d mill fbs9 ol bsisth 89181 9111 1o 95i9V8 b9lr1i9w a b9iii oals 3vs11 9W

.61111691 3111 111 89ILs1F) i1I63fiu1iia iuioihiiw 2311if 11b313 11ibflJ3i&t1JO

lo iib9lD lo 12o3 9vLis131 9111 iii qoib 18313 8 91831b111 91dsT ui b9hoq9l 891smuia9 9fIT

991111 9111 iii bus is oi 9111 ui irsofluriia 1IsDimono33 bus 'h1soiiaiisia 61 i1l airiT .aOT1

b918iull3orIoo '131ui1I5 3d oi aisqqs 139119 311T .ablSWi9ils 8f19)189W ii 3hiIlW 8189 tfl3Up38dIJa

b9nkIri39b 19Lo ia a3si risol fli Dn9i911ib idw bhow fsftin laii a ni noilinfi9b 1anqoxqqa sdJ i idT8 aq ion a9ob ii i1us1b 5911w bn.s) ihJaI9b oi 'ii1idado,q a naqmo Ii 9DnSi8fli ,o'I .1i, Muahb d

. 9ri ta 9i51 It Lth 9111 'i mdw !!±j Iaupo wt + I 119111 bad irfiru3 81k baa Lnad 9111 ol arift a d 9bsm (e1 b9xfi wfq 1iini) tn9maq 1i1iaup etli J1oq9 alab wax

9111 91a11u12913vo 11kw tai ixini a]9vs 3111 iuqmo ol alab aidi aiau juoz) 10 .9DnaIsd 9a19Va 'Fisiiaiip 111kw nif iibi3 ol niiii iai rf1 bi1animile 9w noaai thu io'I .9riaLsd 9aI9v5 11am8 a 1111w laad o fsi

.na1ad 'lisb ai&va ni (OOO *2U) iiJ noillim O asili a91

cc

Page 36: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

J6q iijn o bLo9pçA GAGL& JAI 110 GL1U CJfltI1G2 III JIG LG1TJtAG ffG LGGL 0 JJG dn9içGL ft41611 moç o cIIGaG quu€ JWAG bLoçnrpA IrLGqA occaLLGq M6 97O crq"'GCf16 JAG bL6A!onjA ii poçp uq J6AGLG J9UG u!1JcucJA GL ;p no 1q

JJJG LGboLlGq ITG cp C1TLLGIJ IGAGI 0j bLopJçA iiq J6AGLG M6 CJJ0G C0IJfG11Jb0LflJG0f1 AUGb pGq 011 GI1JçG bLoAqGq pA 20GIC EXCPG Conucu)

r bGLcGu oj pG LO2 bLocGGq (2onLcG: ' %0%G 'k 2bGc IUGLc fqq 9JJ dno;!ou6bicu o oa bLoc€q (nuqG tu i.") 2° " IbO JAOL 'fJ P!ffiOU flLG C022 poi1c 312 P'ffl°

iu IPG qLGc C02 0 0!IJ hnp11c 91.6 Gdalq bbLox csjA o no mjjou r!L6 (qwu2cL9qA6 coc)LG qaizi bGz.oq (oie)

30Jp opiuq pA wnJcib1A!u pG CO6JCGU8 (lsuu pGcJAGGIJ ooo oooo) pA j bwi

JJG JJ ?69L 9uq U JJG JJLGG ?69L8 9GLM9Lq JJJG GGC4 0MGAGL ! IAG9J(GL (

GXJJip1 911 GCOuOm!C9JJ?. auq 29c124!C9JJ? euCffuc qLob (3o- P92!2 bo1ua) 1 IJJG1L C02 0

UJ9LJU9JJ? !' 412 IIJOLG C0IIJbJG46 2bGc!Jc94!ow I LGW9IJ2 LflG IuqGbGuqGuc 1b02

C0UJb9U?2 2!6 !c8 1GAGL96 &uq !12 bLoc9p1J? JJJJG G2çW9IGq qLob iii pG L9c62 12 ouA

CJJ9IJG2 113 4J1G f11J9UJ6IJ49 L12J( GJJ9L9cç6Li24iC2 0 9 C0IJJb91J? 2 bLoxJG2 LOL Li2J' MG 1126 9

IJ JJ9pJ6 ( MG 9U9J?6 4JJ6 bO24-JbO CpU13G2 III 4JTG CO24 0 CLG MJJiJ6 C0IJ4L0JJJIJ 0L 4p6

boMGL 0 p91J2 92 115 grru (j

JJ24Gq 017 46 240CJ( UJ9LJG 06L2 0 4JJG COWb911?. 917 01142iqG jJIJ9UCiIJ obçou 4JJI CIILç9'1J2 4JJ6

JOMGL 1U0LW910U C022 916 L694G co pOLLOMGI.2 ! IPG 0L1IJ 0 I0MGL !1JIGL624 L9I62 JyLq P6!1J

JJ12 1U0LUJ9ç10U C9UIJ0 pG 9bbLoblwçGq p?. 913?. J6ITqGL P9IJJ(!U combci 011 GU2IILG 4JJ94 qIG

JGIJGL2 2bGUq JG22 40 C0JJGC !IJJ0LW901J 90114 IJJ6!L cLGql M0L4JJ!UG22 2!IJCG p? 142 A6L? U911L6

92 2JJOMU p?. J9JG 3GC0IJ LUOLG !I10LW940U GC0WG2 bnpjicj? 91!19PI6 9pOn 4J3GIJJ 20 IP94

EJL2{ iibou Ji2411J COIJJb9IJ!62 wit?. GC0WG 29tGL 0LL0IILGL2 6C9112G JJG? LGCJIICG cpGIL JGA6L9G

JJJJ6LG 91.6 9 JG924 4J1LGG (bo2aipJ? couJbJGwGu9L?) LG920U2 MJJA L94G2 wit? 9JJ 96L 915 1b0

29AJU2 0j 31 P1JJ!017 fILG (fJ F0v) — 9 211W J9LGL q1LGC C0242 0 0!1J bnpJ!c31

uiijpou (ç 3oooo) o itiiu bGL ?G9L bGLUJ9UGUI P!2 MOIIJq iuJbj?. it bLG8Gu A9Jn6 o

0 F1LG piJpOlJ (fl Q5 IJ! LGq11C4013 ! itbb1162 40 9JJ qGp tAOflJq bLoqnc6 F!L6 42

JG L94G 0 G4MGGU 40 ituq Ø p9218 born42 on8qGLJU JJit.ç 4JJ6 9AGL96 IbO p2 qGp GCJIIitJ

bir?.8 JOMGL 4JJ9U 9A6L9'G L9'6 G0LG p6A o bnppc LPG O2GLAG qLob coLLG2bouq2 40 9 LGqi1Cc0U

yjponp I304 p11G 1P!2 G1JGC4 18 U0 IL!A!it1 G!IPGL G2bGC!9'JJA i MG C0JJ2qGL 1b02 9JLG9q?

III qJG C024 0 CLGq4 9j4GL IJ IbO 9 W6 T� JGAGI M1J!IG MG C9U170 L616C1 tOL CitLAG-01142

911J0U IJqGbGUqGUç 1b02 EIOL JJG2G LUJ8e MG C9IJ LG1•6C4 pThop1a 4pff IpGLG 91.6 150 Cit1J62

Page 37: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

32

'p'i pA coucLoJJiu 2LGOJGL2 Oi. pA flLLGUGL o COU4LOJ o11ç2qGL2

!IJJJ49 !u4o JG mol1 o o bnpj!c i' t cj IbO ccombuq Or. ojoiiq pAJJJJG CJW1JG LU IIJG 2LJ1C4ITLG O OMUGL8JJ!b 9Uq IJ 4JJG COU4LOJI!IJ 2p9LGpOJqGL CIJ OGL JrnboL49Uç

o OJ1UJGLJJ!b uq couIoI

Oil C9iAG-Ofl p'uj LG JJJJ ! !"qq MJJ9T MG IJq

pLsiuiu boMGL pAboqJGa2 qrn !4 LG&OIWJG GxbGq pu ponjq JWAG uo GGCl

poL pçiu jjn i jo Mp94 r.iAq cowb9u!68 GGLU o pGJ!GAG (D!J& T088) flUqGL 4G

bnpjcjA ILqGq combrnA bLoppJA GIJ1oA pGuGgc8 o br.€u PrL!U!IJ bo!cIou G/u

i MOL4JJ UJGIJ4iOIJJIJ OUG LG11J COIJ26U M!IJJ p&r.!urn b0MGL GxbJuçou v npaqrrr.A

LGdrnLG 9 MpoJG 2Gb9L6 9119JABI8 (Mp!cp MG bJ9u 4O nuqGL49JcG !U t11li1LG MOLJC) jipj

pGcMGGIJ JJG IAo GXbJIflJIrçioU2 — !uoLw9c!ou uq P9L9!U!IJ — Monjq

nonuq cJ no pu !UJbJG CJJItUG !U CLGcfl dnrJ!A o IJGMJA JiGq jLiU

Jou M14p LGflC4OU u LçGw 4GG LGUJç 11Gl JJGLG IJJOLG OCC11LLJ

IbO JOLGOAGL JJ12 GjJGC4 bbGn8 IoajA COUCGIJ4LG !U 1136 IJ12l IJJLGG AG9L 9IGL IPG IbO

iicffJJA rr!IJcu oujA oL uqGbGuqGu IbO JG jjL OUG bLG26u oujA u uqGbGuqGUiu IJflUJGL o puj JJJG Gcouq GIIGC ia commou poçp npa'mbJG pu JLGL 'uquqcç& uqGbGuqGu ILO GxbGL!GucG LGqJTC4OU III IJJG COIJCGUIL!OU O cLGq airq 9U IUCLGG

o pujca M!41J all onrluqu I!UG oj CLGq JoMwLq 'J flØ LUJ 1'2 IJJG J2 MO LOM O FPI6 2

cIUqj Iqx o JUG2 o CLGqc uni€q o combsuA p jj prrujca) uq p€ UITUJpGI.

io 2nbboI.l JJJ AIGM 4JJGLG LG 9jO 015 pG COIJCG1JL9'!OU O cLGqj (usGEfaLGq 4JJG

qr.ob MG r.Galq pi bopJA uuJ!J€JA

4JJEI 1J nUOpGLASpJG JWbL0AGUJGIJ ru cLq dnpA (uoc clthcrr.q pA oiu LGLG88OL8) CJ1G2

4O g IUJbLOAGUJGUf !U IIJG cLGq M0LIJJ!1JG O UG/AJA JJGq JLI1J JJJOJ1JJ MG GIJUO4 GXCJJ1G

OA6L9iI JJG G8I2 qsaç qLob Jil 4p6 co o cLGqiç ponjq uo !mbIA G 9LJpf146q

Wç JJ 115 CalJG-O11

boJuc2) uq UOç J2I!C9'JJA UllCU GL 4JIG JJJLq AGrL tOJJOMJU IbO ziq J2 IJO bLG2Gu

Page 38: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

oklolhoq iierLt 11i813vib ot a19bIod91sd riiIIoiiao 9rI wolls oir ai OIJ 9th lo uoisviom cIAiJ

.u9rntvni nsqmoD iol usufi 10 9flHO favi1 qaI o 1U31L1 ieiLtsi f10thqffILf8fIo3 9S913ffl 10

.09I lo 11 rf lo thbrist19bczu uco evoiqmi oels 91IJU1 qidarniiwo th usrD s 1193wt9d uoits19no eviiioq s bib9lq uoitamio1iii ohmmas no b9asd 19bom 9DrIsinz io'I

.OqI if 1s inwo !siiini sthi 'jd b83vib iup3 lo nuoms 9d bas 9DculmIoh3q aruqmo

siEb OCH odt bnuoia lolino3 briE qir1ieuiwo lii 29r1Br1D .1.0

9th in bu iusqmo i!duq 1w9u lo 91qrr1s mss ed iol iufi qh119nwo tIoq31 ' !dsT

€1 19nsq bus !qmse sloilw 911i ml aiieits as1qeib 91uft sr1 lo A 191159 .enoi9a eLroiv9lq

.'19s1sq98 auo-'n,s bus siusqmo tn9bri3q3bni iol aorLt 31oq91 D bus

uIi1101t110D 9f1i lo lsJ 9atn9319q risib9m 3111 iai1t wod A Fusq lo WOl qot 9th ii s91ufi ufT

iili 3111 ui 8thoq 910ffl ' d bus oi 9111 lo 9mui 9th Is thuoq 8 d S519V5 no 11s1 quoi eth 19v9woH .(a9uLsv 1159in Is 1oo1 uo Ii 1sv1iD9q91 i119313q bus 12) neup9du

1st Ion oh 91!i Isib oa 8315f12 9111 lo 1119zu13q itsr11 310111 rbiim I1I591 IItha 131IW0 Ls11ini

9110 .101ffl0D fl0[5ffl ni8o1 uoubiw 9vsiths bIuo3 '&uf uoisDfiiei3vib rft lo ffl3119d !k?f 9111

guLf 3mui u11iw tsuli bus qiulal9riwo lo 19v31 miJildiliup9 mi rioI 3111 ion i airIi isrli InurLf irJim

his 8013S 13bLOf191Ef1 sis1 nsib9m 9th 19v3woH .3Asie 8i11 &ubei 191111u1 Ihiw l9bIOfl3lsda 91s1

bus risir11u1) iiiii riiiov 9111 lo in&n9q &iwo 9nsd3X boi nsliM 9th rio b9iaii 9fr1sqmo3

isffluiq 5 ion 1s anoasi u0xiJ3Dfii19vb oiloltxoq isth 9is3ibni abs1 owi 38911T .(C1 !91sni b9is1in9rno3 1iom ei 19b1or191sr1 31s1 9th lo in9mi9vib r1i isdi bus 091 as buid9d uoas3l

.09! 9th is

nsqmo 911i moil bei29vib 9Dnslsd rio 9vsul ai9bIofl5l8112 nu1Io1irIoD 9111 'Ii 9nimI9i9b oT

siLt lo 9JJIsv is*ism srIi d b3Ls3a s1si iisifi lo levsl 9111 iii suisib sill f1oq91 W01 bnoD9a 9111

nu1io1inoD siLt sas nsibsm sill iii bssbui isdi iiro arnul ii .oqi sill lo smth 9th is nsqmo Is 1ool 9110 Ii iuI9YI9q C.11) 'flSfflOD 9111 lo 9ulsv siLt lo in9Disq $.ö iii bsrfa& svsd 1sbIorf91Jsd

19151 lii bsiDsi9b 9(1 IISD ifl9ffliasVib ifIa3fituI1a on shiifw oi sill lo 9fflul 9111 is (sulsv 1159111 5th

8.@C iii isdi Lssv9I sisb sill :isdw uiob al orlw is9)no3 &)iiaiisla sviiqn9sb sasril JnH .aiss 'iwp9 li l1a ion e9ob quoi loiino siLt bus 'lwps wsn 98151 nsqmos siLt asas 9(11 lo lnsnsq

Page 39: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

IJIIUJPGL o bnpc coujbVrn€e ( onç ot a)JG 114A11'ID 2V11JbJ6 lpqJ JiGJJ LGbLGcucV4!AG O IG cflVU U 8'u1qVccrn4u8 2C4OL uq coucVrn V IJ6J1fJG

32rnccVLqo c'r OUG O VnçpOLa O nq P jqqj !"'q W! bLoptp!J!c) Vç 011 1. LGdrr6 ffrnpVq 1ucLGV6q (Iu6qVU !UCL6VG 128 bGLCGUfnq lAG oojcq 9 pG xirrwp o ptpojqLa LGG ?GVL jj pnç OUG CV2G UJ1WGL 0 2JJVL6JJ0JGL

o iip pVbbGu2 !u 'a bqcq pi.ç u jun-coww wc no lAP!CIJ ;oo b19cG ! 188296CVJ1G JAG MGLG uoç VMVLG O VIJ? acnq?. IOO1qU Vç 4JJ 2flG LOL OcPGL CO1IU414G JAG flUGL0OJC VII GXbjOLVc0L?

JANIG cpG combVU? in UGJA €drnç? iApJJG u cowbVUa UG6L GAGU; pVbbGucouçLoj Lo(rb qoe uoç 6JJ Gdniç?k uq cp combm? 211G IJGJA Gd1Iç) II 8 CV6 COULOJ onb €j

concIoJ onb €dzqç? vuq cpG combVuA q0G8 uoç Iff6 UGlA Gdrn;? p1 uo;p ;p

bnpjic 9JCG2 CJJ9IJG !U COIJ4LOJ UJJIGJJ WOLG J!1I?. pIJ ! !2 OL bL!J COUJbflHG8e 6GL p6C9112G

pjq combu1G2 COU4LOJ 18 J!Jc6J?. CJJ9UG JJ9Uq2 '" 1b02 J4P12 2flG2I8 IPBLC (j) 'q cJr-2drrL6 G2 L616C2 T IGAG! p6 p?boçpi2 pç !u bLiiGJA

uq 2 bGLcGu u T8C-O ubjoir 2wb o w1r1111 ffLJ JLUJ2 uTaGq pJ iJJG açaq? p?.

GJJVUG 111 COU4LOJ OAGL 9U JJOL!OU O 4JJLG€ 2GVI2 12 G2WG O JJA6 GGIJ bGLcGuç III TôOi

dnoJGq combrnG8 18 poi1 4w cG pip lu 1JJG I1!' GCOUOIJIX sç JLG: lpGbLoppIpç?oill jbcu O JJG C2G2 (poçow Lote) Jpe ULG 2J10tA2 IJ'c JJG 11LIJOAGL O COULOJ 111 UGMJ?.

4JJG JJLGG ?GgL2 IGL WG IbO 4J' COULOJ LOflb 86JJ8 Of1 lJJG COU1LOII!I1 9JC6 O 9'U O11I2qGL

1W112(WJ G9T1TLG O JJG Iç8!9ir LG4

lu qJG 2np2GdnGu 4LGG ?9'I2 (MpGu o1€i j \ o 8VtGOJGL2 Gx!c jp bb€a'i.

ijna) 12 UJOLG 3nLbLi2iu 12 pG 2IiP2491UI LGqsTc4ou Ju JJG UJJGL o 2JJ9LGpOJqGL2

p AGL? J9L€ 1UCLG2G u unuip€i. o 2p9LGJJoJqGL2 (0AGL 1 ooo !wG2 q ouc joop mqsu

WGqiVU comb9v?.) 2ITq JJG IbO 2 ccombu€q uoç 81TLbLJ8iIJI?

6chrif c&biçsj 011 4jJG IJJ9LJ64 mo24J? V pG JWG opG Ibo (io bGLCGIJ 0JJG1L m9LJG AJ11G LOL

JJJJG 4pILq LOlA 2p01A2 4JJTI JJ6 IJGIAJ? dnoçGq combcu Lj26 2J12UJ 9UJO111Jc 0 LG2JJ

UAG2OL2 VUq JJO2G tAJJGLG ! qAG22 VUq OG2 IJO4 L2G UGIA GdJ1i

4p6 COU4LOJ LO1Tb JGGb2 84LO1J jIJVUCjJ C0WUJIIUGU4 q GUJVU2 IJGJA piuqa LOIJJ OITç2qG

COUGIJGG JGAGJ O JJ6LG LG pi.o drqç qajuc Loflb8 o couibuGa 111 4J16 29uJbjG: tAJJGLG

Gdrn42?. 9uq L6qI1c4Jou o pc coup.oj onb2 2JJCG 8 -O33 VUq 8 2iUigCVUç IJJG I bGLcGu

Gdrn, IAJJ!JG 4JJG COU4LOJ LO11b qGCJIUJIJJGaJJ JIT BC IJJG COLLGj!O1J P6I1AGGU ip 2211G O

fIG C0U4LOj Lorrb 8220W6 Gdrnç? o"P ! JI bGLcGuç o C02G8 qoG8 JG combuk 22ii6 IJGIA

JIG !mG O fIG IbcY q Hi 9IIOfJGL j bc€u fIG combruA OG2 IJO L2G UGIA GdJi 9uq

Page 40: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

38

oncom o injrn 9WG (266 rjuq 'uq j?q& imij'tjA qJc LGqnqou iu JGAGJ o

4JJ6IJ UG4JAG COLLGJ9c!OIJ pRL6GU icconuu bLop!J uq Gdfqç2. qAG24JJJ6U42 9L268

4J16 cowbu? iuq G 4JJ6 iuoauç o 6da L64flG u 2iD9'J o coiub9uA irnm LI2G jOL iio LGJ2OU2 E!L i GJJ4LGbL6IJGIiL ia G4GL uoLm6q ou fl4flLG A9JU6 o

4JTG qGcJuG iii 4G €dirA JJG uçJ 6u4LGbLGuGnL L64 1.72 in combu? 2flCP coLL6I2iou

O46L JIr6q A9LpJ62 jç J2 U flL9J flIGUe 4O IJJI2 LJJ !IJ bLojpJX ccn p 9'LpncGq

91J JJ 4JJI8 6ILGC4 C9UUO pG L9c6q p9cJc OIJJA 4O WGIJ LGAGL2!OU pi bLoça UOL oju qiou 2 n JJ&4 bLop!J! jj 8np2 ujj? nq b6Lm9'u6uJA fGL JJ6 flOw

4LOfflU 2L6JJO6L

boc-mo q6cJuc u bLoUup!J!c?. uuq qI2çm6uç p? pc cou-

oIiMJGl2p!b IflJq COULOJ OAGL 4JJ6 o ppq b9'LçA

oIA-qGp4 2np2iqwL62 içj 8UbGL!oL U.WLJCGI UJ!U 9uq pG? OGU qo 1J318 pGOLG L'UuU

p9'u rnqGbGnqGuc colub9'rn62 !U cpGp cpoc o o bnpJc: Lonba bbGsL lo J! JJG!L bLopJ&

4GU4 J4JJ 4JJ6 AI6M 4JJ LO11ba c4 IJJOLG IJ 4JJGL qGcaou 4O I!24 IJ7G!L 2I1paqI7uG2

4o C9LAG 004 IT 2np2qIrL?. ITI1 !U I!J6 q6ceou 4O 24 ITU iUqGbG1JqGU4 combITu? Jpi8 i 601.7212-

oa) 0 qAG2uJ6U4 ITuq LGITJJOCIT40U 0 COIJLOJ bj mricjj moi€ !wboLu LOJG !U cPG q6C2OU

COJJILOJ O onç8qGL2 J622 LLGd11GUcJ? Qu ouj? 102 bGLcGu 0 4JJG CITG2 A6L8112 J b6LcGu OL CITLAG-

o p cowbITLGq içp j bGLcGu oL ca'LAG-on2) uq (m) cou4LoJJ!u 2JJITL6JJOJGL2 2IILLGUJGL

3 bccu oL 6ITLAG-o012) uq qA62l2 on 9AGL9G j€a (j bcLcGuç ot AITJflG o 4G combITu?

2JJITLG0J6L2 ITLG jG22 J!J6JA O qA62 IT flUJG O 4JJG IbO ( bGLcGuç o jy€ CoiubITniG2 ITTUcouioj Lonb 2ITL42 0fl4 iAp 9 J0IIGL bGLcGu96 249JCG p CITLAG-O1142 () COULOJJ!IJ

ui cuq CITLAG-on42 26B9L96J? jp6 2!IJ!UcIT1Jc qGLGIJCG2 9LG pç (s) iu IJq6bGUq6U4 coIubITuiG2

bITUGI2 B 'q C 8JJOll p0/A pG b!cnLG C9U62 0116 J00JC2 9 1b02 O uqGbGuqGuc combIT-

7.7.79111 j9c4oL2 nuqGLJAu CJGC!2!OIJ o o bnpJc

26jJ O11 IP' 12 COU2!24GU /Alp !U9IG8 (JaO2) /AJJO 2662 COIJL0J COU2q6L9çOU8 9 ouG O

!l ITCipcITç68 9 CJJ9UG III COU4LOJ OL 6C9112G iç 12 CJJO2GU p? COIJLOJJTU apSLGJJOJqGL2 tApo !A9Uço

Page 41: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

4JJG UG€q o LG9J9IJCG coLboL9çG Uu9ucisJ boiou JL 1uAG24uJGIJ4 9uq L9biq LO1AJT

iuçrn'j jc o r 21Tp2iqwL? B COU4L924 1B02 °L Juq€bGuqGu comb9u!€ LG2bOUq IJJOLG O

GxbJo! ca'jj? 'iowpj m9I.J couq!ou2 rnq\oL o !uc1 orj bLocGGq2 pom u/I(G onuq IIJ L62I Oj 4JJ6 b9bGL /-on bbG9L biu juucwj obGL9c!ou2 qG2iIJ6q

bLouorlucGq iu c9LAG-onç2 L9GL 9U !U uqbGuqGuç ILO LP! J1K1!I 12 COU2124G1J4 llJ4JJ M9f

j,pc cç bL6qq6q pA juq 9uq },AJ6 (J) suq 'u€u uq €cJq1u (j) ijOL C9LAG-OfI48 9Uq 12 29!2C9JJA 2iUIJC9U OiJjA OL 4JJG1JJ

LGAGL2!OU 1J bLOJ49p1j1A 9 L62flJ4 9JL69qA W61JOIJG !IJ 2ff26COU 21F JpG 66C !2 2IL0U6L

(To1) 0L fl COUJB9IJ!68 OL60A6L pi pojp npa9mbJ62 GL6 12 ar1p2c9u4i9I GAIqGucG 0 1156915

JJ 9 ui uq pipjA 2&4J24ic9JA 2!1J!c9'1Jc Gcc ou onuq pA u uq girnbGqoLw9ucG L°1 IJq6bdnq6u4 1b02' BA C0IJL92 OL C9LAG-Oflç2 qiAG24uJ6u pA CO1JLOJ Lonb

2np29LubG2 Jp6 qiA6eçw6IJ oj C0UL0J Lonb p 150 11JC9U !mb9cc ou 2np2Gdn6u

boopq 99 qi2J12& 2 1511111610112 O4JJGL 0CC2O1J2 4ft0 AGLA qqGLGU 240L162 0L JG

pii 916 uoç bLGci2GJA 624Tw9ç6q 9IJq JJGL60LG 916 1104 29çi2!C9JJA 2i1J!C9U4 H0/iGA6L

L01 1JJ6 RJJ0JG 29UJbJG lJJ6 C0GC!6Uc2 tOL POqJ 4JJG LGLG820L2 p9A6 1P6 GxbGcGq 2!IJ (u69!AG)

comb9ui 9uq c9LAG-011ç2 26b9L96JA

OL 4JJG apoJG 29uJbJG t&pijG Gcouq uq COJ11WIJ2 LGbol3 pG L62flI42 0L iiJqGbGuqGuc

jL9COU O GdfJ aojq pA COUcLOJ LO11b 9 4J1G 1B0 uI6 UL2 COJJILUII LGb0L2 JJG G2?!1JJ&4G2

j0nL-AG9L rIrGLA9J 9Ij6L JJ6 IbO 015 9 COU8491J4 4JJG CJJ9I16 us bLoUcffp!J!cA psoL c' IbO uq

8 LGboL2 JJ6 or G2i11J9G2 op8uJGq LGth682!u C9U6 Hi bLoç9piJiA oIL

1Ap!cp q!q o bnpJ!c 6C9I12G MG JJ9AG iso 015 29L6 0tAIJ6L2P!b 0L bL!A9'6 cousbiru!G

1116915 LGA6L2!0I1 pAbop62J2 !17 JJ6 8iIIJbJG2ç bo22pJG M9A IJJG 29'IJJbJG 2 JimGq 0 lJG COUJB9IJJG2

1b0 jj112 BbGC!JC94iO1J !8 u6uq6q UG24 I1JG 9AUJUJGcL!C !IJOLID9OiJ-9G1JCA uioqGJ 9IXJ 4JJG

94 4JJ6 IJW6 O 4JJ6 IbO irisq 015 4JJ6 JDCLG9gG 111 bL09pJJ14A OCCJ1LL11J 111 JJG LOJIL A69'L2 6OLG JJG

9 O11L-A69L !iJ6LA9J 96L 4JJ6 IbO 015 J5G LC41OU 0 JJ6 40c9J 6d1T!A ojq pA qs COUfLOJ LO11b

bL6qcpou MG L6LG22 4JJ6 CpirIJ6 HI bLoç9piJ!çA (ira UJ692ffLG pA 1JJ6 CJJ91JG icov) OAGL

pJ9UC6L2 118 qGcL6IJ2iue 2flp26dfl6u1 bLocap!J!4 (266 '16112611 9uq 6CJCJ!IJ J) J10 4JJ2

u2qGLa 0MIJGL2JJ!b UJ9A !11CLGG JJ6 961JCA C022 GM66U C0UL0JJ!IJ 2p9LGpOJq6L2 9uq 0I12G

Page 42: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

0

cp (u9j6 J2P)2JJLGO1GL jp o pA GX;LGIIIGJA pp iSJØG O( couçLoj 9 OLGL o m9€unqG 6L oLbLopl6ui urncp pGL y juøj () 1çg11ij co1nbu69 nq !l qflh14G JJ6 A9jSIG O mpio4;AJICJC O 6I1OLC6I1JGI1ç °L iiqiJoUiA bLObGI4 LJJJ !IJ 4JJ COIUJLA "1 ""!l"J O boc6uq GucA

30Ø11G bo22TpJG L6OIJ OL MpA jcu combvu€e uq v GL L6bnc!ou1 CbJ o bnpjlc pç cp

49'X 9'Uq JG9'J 9'J14JJOLI4I68 y 4JJG Sct IW% L6COU!62 Iil Ic9I2 2 COUJUJOU JUJORGG—

OGU UOLGq — IJXGq CO848 O J!&4!U 82 4JJG !WbflC! coaça 922oC8cGq o ppL A!8!p!I2

9' JOUGL L9CJ LGCOL OL UGtAJ2 fl246 LUJ8 U 9J4CLU94!AG GXbJ8IJ9!OU ! IJJ9'I GLG 9LG OJJGL

12 OltkGAGL OUJ2 9' b9LJ9'J 9'UJ/6L GC8IT8G G2 JJG dnGçJou O /1412 4JJG J9J19U w9LJ(Gc LGCJITJLG2

Il Il9'1 OLCG 11 O GJ8GMpGLG OUG boeipJG 9LI1UJGU4 2 4JJ6 IJJbOL49UCG O LGbsTç9cOw Jp

9' Lonb (uo r couJbu2) p o b2 o cce bnpJc m8LJcç JpG flilJG o J2pu coçOL 2crp21q9LI68 o BflPI!CIA coiub8uic ii OGL /AOL8 GLG G 8 x€q cO W9'4

couq ii uq jJs'c 9' cowbu2 8!6 8!u!c8UJ2 9GC48 4JJG bLop9'p!J!2 O J1J GxcGb

4JJG /AG o 4JJ6 G/GUCG boiu2 iJ cxbJ9u9'!ou p826q Oil wibLJcJu

01. JJG OuJJGL2 94Gwb o GxbJoi 2Gc1oL19J UJI2bL1C1U 1IJcG 1UAGaçUJGUI q 1%% 9JGL IbO

UGG U 8GCOL2 .N44JJ pp LOliJJ ObbOLflU!c!G2 (uq cou.G8bouqpJ2 pp w9LjGç-ço-pooJc L84io)

A9Jf19'1OU O LUJ8 IIJ 4JJG 88IUG rnqiTçLA Jjna boi€ LGJrrpou8pb 11.192 L6GC 9' 1JJ6L WA6W6U

EJL8c ii uq bLop&pp4 ot 9'IJ IbO bo8ipAGJA 96cGq p2 JJG 2çocJ LU9'LJGç

CJJ9'IJG1J!U dIT62!OU2 4JJ94 JJ14I1L6 L6869'LCJJ /A!!! 8AG 4O 8qCJL62

pjq cOmb9u!Ga o "w' rzqA q6uq BGAGL9J JIG/A L8C4 /AJJ!CJJ L8!G 9' JJJJIUGL °L

pop Gx-9u4G 9'Uq JJG Gx-boaç C!J9L8CIGL84!C8 o JbO MJJ }JO8G oj 8 J9'LG 88uJbJG o bL/çGJ2

jpi babci !uAG19'4Ge 4pG qGGLmU9U2 o JJG qGq8Iou o 8 combu2 o o bnpj!c p2 comB&L!il

b CO11CJf1!O11

OGLA6 OUJA 115 C9'LAG-Of14

mijs GxbJ91u /AJJ2 8 uG8çiAG coLLGJ9Jou pGtA6GU GdnJçA JAG84UJG1J4 uq bLo8piJi2 CJJ91JG8 !

LG94GL ilGGq O 8JU8J ! 8JJJ JIJ p€ jJT115LG A9JITG o p€ cowbu2 p2 L648JIJJU 9 J9LGL 9'JG JJP!

BGC91586 C9LAG-O1T42 8bb69L UJOLG IIJO4AG p2 W8LJCG4 JUJJU qIG b8r.u cowb8uA 11182 p1MG 9

Page 43: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

I

LGflG6 (i 9 MGLG GUçLGbLGuGDL2 q6bLAGq oj JG obc!ou co 1126 fIG GdffJcA W9'4(G 40 LGP9'I9'UCG

rmboLc9'uc oUG yu obGu drrG8c!ou !2 co G2c9'pJap porn irnicp !uAG2cuJGuc2 9'uq rnorrjq G

9'ccLprrcGq JG W9'LJCGc — !G IJ9'UC!U L1111L6 !UAG2cWGUc8 — puc UGAGLJJ6IG22 9' AGL?

9' bGLOq O piJJ IUAG2cLIJGUc 9'uq LOJAfF LLP!2 LOJG 2 A6LX qGLGUc LOUJ cpc GU6L&JJ?.

!xcJJ tAG uq 201116 GAqGUCG OL 9' coqc IJJ9'LJ.Gc LOJG !U LGP9'I9'UC!1J fIG CoWb9'U?2 9'CCO11U2

LOtAfJ 2I1G2cGq p?k b9'9'IJO uq ffGJJ (Ia2)

&GIJC? bLopJGm2 8A coucc IrqGbGuqGu 1b02 OCCIIL !U cp IA9'J'G O JJIJJ !UAG2cUJGUc 9'uq

cJJG BLGU comb9'u2 LGCGIAG2 jLOUJ 9'IJ GAGU119'J 29'JG O 9' 8fIp2q9'L? GAGU 9' p6 CO21 O UCLG2Gq

GL9'ç10U8 qG2IiJGq 4O Gxbjoic L9'AOL9'P]G WU1IGc COUflfOU2 9'uq\oL !IJCLG9'26 fIG cocj bLocGGq2

9'uq C9'LAG-0fl9 IPG bTcçrzLG cpc 6WGLG2 12 cpc c9'LAG-onç2 9'LG uJ9'JuJ? 2cL9'c6JC 1J9'UC19'J ob-

cJJ!2 2çnq? C0DJLW2 pG cowwou JAqoUJ cp9 qi6L6uc9'cG8 GMGGU iuqGbGUqGuc 1b02

9'L6 1TUGL9'IGU co UJ9'xUJ!G fIG !UCflmp6Uc2 bLocGGq2 jLOW 9'U 6AGUJ19'J 29'J6 o JI6 COWbU?

cLOjjiU pocj 9'cGL 4G 1b0 jp8 uqiuR !2 C0U2!2cGUc rn!cp !U9'JG (T9'Y JA0 CJ9'UJ2 1b02

pjq G01JJb9'1JG2 1p12 OCCJIL2 qG2bJcG cp q cpG couçLoJJiU Locfb 9Jrn9'?.2 LGcs'1U2 if J9'LG COD-

E011LP MG juq cpc C0UL0J Cpifu62 p9'uq2 U 1b02 2uc9'UcJA UJOLG OGIJ cp9'U IJ bLiIcGJ?

LUJ2 p9'L9'TUIu bornGL A12-9'-A18 1ç8 p9'1JJ2 ( pi 9'!9'U 10ô5)

bo22ipJG GxbIifuifciou2 OL qLob fIG GXI2IU GAIqGUCG !69'112 UJOLG orn9'Lq 9'IJ !1JCLGG !U 9'

LIGUCGq 9'GL oiu bnpjic yjcponp JAG ifLG cnLLGucI? nUifpJG qi2funi2p 9'UJoU fIG A9'L1o112

BLG2GUc 6A611 9'6L COUL0JJJ OL LUJ2 CP9'L9CcGL!afC2 ifuq OL pG LG11Cf 011 !U J6AGL9'G GXbG-

jJIL JAG uq cpa'c pG CO2 O p9'IJJC ccpç 9'JJ2 jOL UGJAJ? J!cq coulb9'u!62 1JJ!2 qLob !2

GWbILiC9'JJ?. fIG A9'JIqI4 O fIG26 9'LthlmGUc2

12 uoç 6UOff bLoAG OIIL COIJ1GCçITLG JI9'JJGUG LOL 11JTLG LG2G9'LC JAOIIN 6 co 92G22

2GU26 M6 qo uq 2OWG 6AqGUCG fJ9' cp€ 112C9'J 1TLGU !UCLGEI2G2 tAJJGU COUJb9'U!62 o bnppc pnç

0L GdrqcA JU9'UC!U fliJL0LcIIU9'c6J? !2 AGL qcnj co bLoAqG 2?2cGUJ9'cIC GAJqGUCG III

bLopJpiciA6J?. GxbGu2iAG co 2G ub 2J1C a?2c6m2 &uq tOL cp2 LG9'20U ifAoq cp bnpJc UJ9'LJ(Gc

!UCLGG2 fIG COeç O J6GbiU bsJJGj ifccornJc!u a?2cGur 211J9'IIGL IJq6bGuqGuc UL2 W9'? uq

T0f b r!2c!U LOLCG2 if combuA p9'AG 1ç8 9CCOIUc2 CGLG GxcGLuifJJ? uq cp CGLcif!uI?.

moc CouJb9'rnG2 J(GGb crno 2G2 Oj• pOOJC2 uq cpc cx GA9'210U 2 MqG2bLGifq (DGCGIJJPGL 3O

Page 44: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

LG2OU2 pwç pG!L 9CCGCC o 1P6 bnpjc GdUI4A UJLJG4

(moLG GfflC!GU) CJThIJIJGJ2 4O UIJUCG JJGIL JAG8UJGIJ49 OL GC911CG 20111G OJ poAG-uJGucouGq

IlJ!' WLJG qOGe P°I' P!2 UIJJIJC!IJ LOJG I ! GC9112G CUJ9JJ COUJBU!G2 juq OIIJGL

O JIJ91JCG pGJL GXbJiTCiOIJ JmboLçu dflG8iOU OL L11411LG LGCG9LC 4O JqqLG2C 2 Mp?.

y1J(JGJ2OU LCJJ ruq ppè T4) MG qo UO4 juq mitii? ?OiT1U 24L-flb cowbu!Ge JJ9' o bnpJc

E!UII le J2O 1U4GLGC4IU W6UiOU Mp9 MG qo iO uq flIJJ!J(G fl-p2Gq eJnq!Ge (e

4J7GIL CCOJ1U2

Page 45: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

't2

wIbCiIJ D6 rout I (iôO)!" JJ6 L6JGAIJc UqflLAH!P uLJc-co-pOoJ JSIflG2

oL IbOflIJqGth6LoLm1mcG

L91IGL COIJLOJb;nrnq, !UJ6a (ji)

COI3L0I

WJJ6L obo;Guc!91 rnA6cOL2E"J 26 O GLçOIJ (iag) D!W6 OCJ OtAU6Lpib

rdaqcic'ii (1a82)bIJO iq cowbm DL' coqc oMu6Lplb

IJJOIJJçOLJU

W9LJG1JYLOJG (j)HO1WcL9W iq

p€q rncGuçiAG co11çL9cçr' 116 o

oo bnpj!cBMfl6L cowbmirn woL

GCL J3R 2CGco11cm11 p9LcpoJqGL

boiAGL 1AJp pu7e2JCL62G iciu (iaa)

bs?rn IflPGL LGIbO WOLG JflCGfit (OL COIIJbøIJ6

LG2DL6€ !IJ POLLON4U

COIJ2çL9TUe

ØAGLCOIIJG pOLLOl!JIJ

prp-n5A6w6uc coUJbflJGIbO LIJOLG flWj)L (ol. pjRp-qGpc\ pjp !"'DGIGAP5\

oq6JEL °" 1P6 I'°PPII1 °t IBO C0116dfl6UC 9IJGL 110

Emb!I1II bL6qqon2—

p: B6U6U Oj CP bPJ!c

coIJIJq6uflAro o opu (j)C1111bP6II (iaaY

o bnpjicWp-çGcp coiubi

ix6q CO2 BIGL (J9)o bapc

II1flGL cOIJJbvIlIGa i iwPuq woij pqyqAGLaG 2616COU

miq ppu (j)iiiouq (jj)CPGIJ9IJULrw"q J?jG (j

j jjcj? o o bJIpJ!cWflGL mJq ?OnU6L coujb&u

oMuGl.2p!bp6p1GGU bGIouiwucGM6c!A6 LGJ!OII

Oil pG bLOpp!J!c? O( JJ(J COU6dI16UC6 IJGL IboEmb!I11 bL6qccou

: o oiu J,UPUC

WG DGC!20U 4o Co bflPI!CEmbJL!CI o 4JJG J/JU JJJJ6OLG

LTflPI6 j:

Page 46: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

luqex [] COWbBU!O2.1880 180.1 .18-iS J853 .183* 1O't2 J020

0

20

100

.120

500

3o

.I89. J8.8

combrnG2 qi.Ieu om owcj bnpJc9'Jou3 Oj lpG flJU EXCJJUG C'!F12 4JJ6U qGGq 11U JJG COU2IW6L bL!CG uqGx 9 CoUJbIT4Gq p?. IaLvL LP IJITUJpGL O JGqJJJJG WG 2GLJG2 °L JJG 24OCJ BLJC !IJcJGX IB LGCOD2LIJC4Gq tojjoiiu J9uGc9 suq pJoJ (Iaa2) i

bL!C62 OU 4JJG J/[iJ1IJ OCJC EXCPU6J,4lImpGL o1, riq 01JJbJIqG2 iiq ffGfJ ocJ

EinL€ I:

Page 47: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

1OlV1 00 001005 0 01001 5 51000 '1 31080 4 21088 2 21083. 15 151080 JO 181882 3. 3.

1084 0 3.

1083 2 41085 2 0

)6VL N'!VU yIJA tjc;

UJLJCG (jGLC9O H1LGco)6couq qcijIncou iç o€a bnpjic uao !JJ6IJ wiuoi. xcpmiG (uoc jocçq ru yjms) oi. &conqquçou combm?. bnpc ouj? ip6u yju coqc ExcpG yccoqii

o ffc1 o cowbu!6 u orn. nubJGCCOLU ;o p€ o ju ycoiqu 4p6 u'.

24iC2 OIJ 4JJ6 A6L O I'41Uj9jG :

Page 48: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

WIIJJPGL O p9IJJC8 128 11 1F2 00 J3 T831C°'J'i°" cLGq!ç 018 0J3 OT 005 Iro1J L96 (e) J28 1200 31 3i2 2O2 I2O'12

030 0 2 0 23Q2 JO8D6P U119VCTIJ 0038 00J 0181 -F00 088 T8U0EdaØ 0033 0 O1C -Ot I08NIUA68cm61c2 0053 0008 000 -088 083 108O8CSb6X 02 0J 00 0 1 I83JUqJI2çA NG-O-BOOJ F38 I8 05 0N 282 I88J9XG 018 013 O1 0 1 J8J03C0A6L6 810 T12 0 100 J0&rGA6Lr6 030 038 052 0 1 1081

013 011 0O 333 182LBOY 013 011 011 -I'O FSJ TO21.Emb10662 528 332I 0 J085 188L21 (DIIV) 11 20 O82 0020 5300 T88LpL6pOJqGLa Edn!c (Bw) 202 T'F., 30 -T0 N000 J08Ujoçj yc (ew) ioo ot so ooo TOILpIG AI69U y6q9u 2;q DA vu" vx opa

y: jjrc MJJ0JG nubJGCOUCGIJL&çOU O CLG 4J16 6LI39JJJ IIqGX O JJG CLGq J!IJG Ofl2lIJqupX qGbL6cow jp€ jou i.€ JJG uJ6q9u I3çGLG8cLGbq p? uiJ oij J!1J6 o cLqç onccuqu j1p

D6P rnmcu qpc qAq6q p? oçj cvb1lIi bøonç qquq bq qiqqq p? u€ç ucou.rIJAGçWGU; quqq€q p 92G dnIç? Uun1c!u JJJG Gdrq juiq qIqcq p? cbIc9J (cocj qcpç bjCb6x cb!c9I 6xbGuq1iL /GL Guq o ?L uGç bLobGLç? buç uq Gdrnbu,Gur I"'c""cmquu W&LJCGf oGckr! o JUD2 !" IP6 a9mG uqfTcL? picp cLq6qOU P' Y'IJI" coqIL9JIT6 6jOI GLO L6 9 6LO) FX bsq qAq6q p? obGLçu IUCOWG JjJ6 Ta JJG

pooj isJnG o diqcA C0AGLG ! EBLLDY qAq6q p? 1UcGLGa4 6XbGU2Ga (ijna VOA6 J(J(J 9L64LfluC6q J$JèrGAGLG pooji A9j1T6 O JJOL bjiia jOU cGUIJ qp; qjAqq p? pooji A9'JJIG O( POLI bjiia 6LW qpç bjiia9nq qGbL6qcou 9flotAJc6a) OAGL ipG GUq O JJG buiqoiza ! EBLLDV 0A61. LGAGIM16

comb9uA u a€ (uc aa) MjC pjoUa 9U16 iqiip BOY j8 EBLLDV (wua pqoT.G !IJI6LGacjUC6 ucoLboLgTou o( no iiq j6L6I3CG i.j;p uabGcç v mçcpju cowbms) quq a CJOaGaI

6Cff6 iuounçrou to'. cowb1nIX-?Gm a x,oç .9flpj6 pom om. qcc (j opa jou) b"61 D LGboL2pJ buuGJ C ' !° IJ1LG6 opa€sçoua pGcuua flØ-AG9L COUcjU 2OWG OfTjj6L8 ( opai.icoe) uq

ioo cp n,o MG jjaçju LGdnjLGw6uca cpuq qrn.ju aøuTbJG bG4oq (aOjjjCij L6dnLGuJ6u4a joL jjajii a oj cp b"I C couibøuja Mp!Cp uc bnpjjc pM6u 1085ju b9uGJ 4JJ6 aflWWLX ajaçJCa LG(GL G uçps amnbj& u bguGJ j o cowbru?-?Gaa pç apj JJ6

nmmgL? ciic2LPJ 3:

Page 49: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

MDPGL O J9IJJ2 53cr 53 132 00 2 2COUCGULOU cL6qç 011 00 0J3 003 I 3OTJ LG () 1152

0301200055

312O3 000 515 00

02DGP JIJIJCiIJ 000 O'023 050 03 0O 00Edn!4 }JUIJciIJ 000 0003 010 000 00 00I1A6m6U 000 002 0T5 0'12 040 00Cb6x 032 031 031 0110 0 CIIJqn2çL 9LJ6c-cO-OOJ roe 152 on o s eeJJ9X6 051 051 0J3 0111 000 02COAGLG J05't 380 1W21 1 100 00p6A6LG 032 O10 O5 0 O1 00B02 010 012 015 0111 025 00ifOY 0Jt 013 O2 01105 OfO 00EmbIoGG 32e2 SJO(J 3 1SB00 00

(mw) ss is 325 32 13 00JJ9L6JJOJqGL Edff4 (nur) iw ys 3002 2 saoo oojoçj (Buy) 1Q3 20J30 W0 53'F 00A"4P16 2lq D JIJ Y1 0P8

C: iv IBO rmbJG

W111TP O pJJ ire is 11Q 01) 13'f T5TCOUCGULOU cLGqc 01Z 012 012 01)5 1 150f0roII L6 () J5 T223 F53 32 30f'f 582jAoiiç 021 0'00 F20 0 3302 10051D6P 0114 01)10 0J -100 0)O J5è343Edfl JU19IJCrU 005 0 01)0 04.t 130 J53TIDA6mGUI 002 0111 00 -0110 03 J538C' 03 0•34 051 0 0110 J003uqnecI. LJ(Gc-4O-BOOJC 132 F52 0'OS 034 22 11302JX62 050 018 01. 0 100 1r035COA6L6 820 35 J.Q 0 100 1S223GAGL6 032 022 052 0 1 1S2JB'O 014 015 0'L -34 553 153oJISOY 011 0'13 010 -0113 r51 is1aeiEmbI0662 02 30 35 0 J000S 15301ie (Bur) 1032 OFJ p2211 01)30 53Q0 15e301

JJ9LGpoJqGL8 Ednc (our) 030 1W2 2030 -fl J000 15381jo;j yace (Dur) 5552 2011 1e220.3 2 2000 J5281A49P1G V'1 Y1J! ;q DGA Y1!' 11f9X Ø9

B riubJG EJ!!PJG Co bfTpJ!c

Page 50: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

8

D's'"' J038 2 W2 -2 3 08V' nY3 30 3831 3 Jt 08A4PIG L" LI" cq D6A W X Øpa

vc o1 IJDO2

Page 51: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

* COGWC!GIJ 18 a iJiijCiJjA flJGL€IJ (LOW GLO IIIG IO 1!uqcc62 COGWCIGIJ 1 aiini,jcuçj? qq[6L6ul LLOW 86L0q!c 4p6 COGWC!GIJc 8 8Ufl.JC91I GLGU (LOW 6LO B cp J OL

0020 0011 0200LELGCc 0211 O.J

0100 01'f2 0131W OPr 2flO '3T

(ooo) (ooi) (oTt)juqnaçA j'j ofI O5OOO( flouou (o22) (o33) (o2T)COUC6UL!OU 0121 -oioa

(a) (4o) (I5i)BJC Jff4G -'V082 203O

(oi) (o2T) (oa)-0035 0183(oio) (op) (o)icov(oT3T) (oo) (ou2)

CLOMW

(o18o) (oTa) (o2)CBGX OTQ ON3 -OO

(oott) (oo22) (oo)21G8 -OOOAL1PJ6 jJJOIG aWbJG psqGbcuqcuç 1b08 CO

pThOcpGa!2 JJ 4JG loruç qcç O( 68G L6G LNG8 6dJ19J8 6LO g LGbOLcGq

?LG&L qnmuqa 1" IPG IPLGG ?G9'L8 MpGIJ pGLG ucup€ o o bnppc j6 b-i&nG O( 911 E-cG24 (OL

HGGLO1c1C1 LOpJIac 8c9'IJqLq 6LLOL8 9L6 I1 pqcçw IPG X ccç 8 *ThGLG AVIJIG O( cp C6UBLW!1' 2cq EXCP911G Jp6 L6L688OU 1JcJaq6a VJ80 V C01J849IJç IGLW auq CGLJq9L XGVL qrn1mJa (uoc LGboLcGq)uqrr8cL? LD !8 IJJGqIVIJ IIJVL1G pooj A9Ji16 O( €da) O( LIfl8 IU cJJG 8VWG uqsTaL? JApicp cLVqGq OIlO( pOLLONqU 18 J9€Gq AU6 O( 6LJI3JJ IJqGX O( 1J1G J3 O( cLGql LVIJG p flGLGU pVUJ8 JJJGO( OLLO1I&1U (OL LIIJ L6}VIAG VAGLVG pOuOftJU LSG O( VII W6 JWJ8 111 4JJ6 aVwbjG JJJG COIJCGI34LV47OIJbjn jou q€pç bjna pooj ASJflG o( Gdn1Ø )6t pçoLG VZJ LVG 8 1J16 19JflG O( JJ6 LGIVc1AG coat12 JG J9€Gq A9J1TG O( JIG LV41O O( 4JJG pooJ AVI1G O( 2P0L1 b1na Io1, ;GLW qpç qAqcq p) poojr i2jnG o apoLe°cP 12 cPG LVG O( 0( 1" ifOY 1 I1 'VI" O( EBLLDV OAGL V286ç8

I1J6 JO&14IJ3UJ O( LGAGUIl62 CVbGX 18 JJ6 JV6 A9Jfl€ O( CVb!cS'I GXbGuqflL6a OAGL bLObGI4 j,j&u vuq Edn!bmGucJAJJflG ;pG c9tJ-on aVwbJG 9 LG8II4CcGq 4O 8npaq914G8 O( bnp11cj? cLVqGq coWbVu!62 ja a Iq isjn€o

a&wbj€ j,pG aVIubJG xcpiqe enpeqota O( brrpIIcI? cLVqGq cowbmia (LOWN411cp 8V48(? cJJG H8c1U LGdn!LGuJGUc 99 O( cp flPV4 O( (OL6W1J cothou1oua VLG GXCJtTqGq (LOW

Jju (opaG1.Jclou (OL bnpc cowb9n168 VLG q1obbGq (LOW II6amnbj€) JG 18 LGac9cGq cowbVIJlG8-m6poq a mqmmn fflGpooq JpG q6bGuqGIl 18 o IL ;p' COWbVU? I uoç ja6q miq I OIl JJ6 6VL O(

£P6 66C O( IJJG I.pja jacq ou p€ bLopvpfl! o bnpc 12 G2WWG p? v bLop1 WOqG LPG c1"I°"

DG6LmJU1U4 O JJ6 D6C!2!OU O C bnPJ!CjftJ6 :

Page 52: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

20

CYbEX

(o) (os) (o) (o4) (ot)CtJL60fll OQL O2 OO O2 010 130

(os) (o) (os) (o) (oss)Juq6bGuq6u -oro -ooa -o -oai. oo or(o18) (or) (oi) (oi) (oie)MP016 wbJG O3 010 -OT. -OU 3O

ov

(oio) (oio) (oTo) (ooa) (ooa)c'-°"c -000 -o8 oJ8 -oa -o'Y8 000

(oo) (oo) (ooa) (oio) (oo)uqGb6uqGuc -008 -0i0 -oa -02Q.. -O.. 000

(.ooo) (oo) (oo) (oo) (002)MP°16 29mbJG -008 -O72 -00 08 -tY03I 000

2wbI6 fl6J__A 0__)6VL +J__AGL +__A6L +3__A69t>_3

jLOW 6LO 9 JJG JO T61MqUJGL6IIç LOI1J 6LO 9ç 4G J6J6J OL JG8 anb6l.acI.ibV * lJJ& 1J16 COGWCI6UI 12 2JqJC9UJ? q16L6IJ0 9fl JJ6 bo-JbO L6 Gd11J GLO J,pG nb61.8c4b wqIc' cp CO6j44GIJ 2C9IJJ?LGboI4Gq ru pL9cJ6c2 LJ16 ;pG Jç cOIfmnJ LGbOLç2 qic b-1sjnG OL pThop€i pG 211311 o C06CJGUç80 p91JJ2 12 1Jfl6L 0 9UJ(2 V CLG ff116 "T!" L0p1124 21'.VuqVLq 6LLOL2 9LG

qm4iJ 4JJ9 ?6VL JJJG C01JC6IJl2LV0IJ O CL6( 6 G14JUV wqGx 0 JJ6 cL6q4 fl1162 oflç VI3qIJ JJPG UJ1UTp6LL96 b9q 013 9JJ on2nJqu CL6(J 111162 qyq6q p). DUG bJrI8 0A6L9€G LVG bøq p) wj UU2 ! 16 nubJGL0E14 0 2962 I1 c; L96 2 LGJVAG C02 0 cLGqç o un" s 2 0116 bJne m6quqIAIqGq pX uç rucomG p) qGbL6cw;ozr JXG2 t6 btqq qyqq p) ob6LVc!u 1UCOUJG CL0!AIP 12 cps LV6 ocVbiçVJ (coc9j qp b102 Gdrnç? D6P Uumc1u 91.6 qp 122062 quqq p) c9b!J jiOoni qpquq blnqA91116 0 2p0LI bjrr2 ioi €uu qp bjrr2 pooje 1Jff6 ot dncA Ed.Ic jjirnucri cJJG GdI? anq qq€q p? oçgjjIJ9uc1rJ IUAG2IJJGUç ¶AqGq p) 9226ç2 FGAGLG !2 pOOJC AVJI16 0 2pOLç bJIIa JOUR GUJJ qp qiqqq p? poojcC9b6x 91.6 cIfbc9J 6xb6uqçaL62 oi bLobGL bjvu uq 6drnbm6u fTLJ bLGA 0112 ?tGVL IA62cm6U vi.

2np2q91.62 ot bnp11cj? cowbcmi IføV EBLLDV OJLGL 0VJ V926I2 Vç GIJq 0( bLGAIon2 m•6XCJff62 jj 2npaq9t? o bnpJ!cf) lLVG cowbvuj62 (LOW vmbj& MflG WG CVLA6-onc 22wb16 12 LGalL1ccGq1b0 LPG l1rpjG ouj? L6b0Lç2 JJ6 co6wc!611c8 OIl cp jj,Ø uq bo8ijJ,O qniii '4PI £P6 I1qGbCUqGUc auwbfGU )69L — 1TU 9 XGq G6Cl moqGj 1G 01.6 fl2J V UII PSOLG qJG flØ 02 0 C0IllL0I (OL !ce6( U(6L cJIG

ouq cc.oi 91.6 qrnmii) opJ6o GC1ROJ 0116 J( )L6in. cowbou) $ 2012Gq JJ6 L6dfTjL6W6UJ26c1r19J 40 0116 ( )GVL — li92 JJ6 IbO )6ULè V qflh1flhJ? AVI4VPjG 6(31191 0 0116 fl() 00ji b1oc IJIOLG 3J&GL6 $ oiiq 9 91.6 LG2bGccTAGJ) s 1.ns-abGqc vuq co'jGUquT. )Go'L 2bGcflJc 6(6C 1'ç1 91.6 qm11111)k A9149PJ62

A" = + uo- + uo + - ci + & + qi +

0L GVCP 0( A9L!9pJ62 !!2c1 H6 G2çIwvçG (ofloaa1J 2bGcuJcv!oIs:

EIL6CI W6 DGC!JOU 4O 0 LnPJCJP1G :

Page 53: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

2r

pJc&i.&

(ooi) ('ooi) (0018) ('oore) (ooi)-'0000 -'0002 -'0051 -'0001 -1)000 '222('ooI2) ('o018) ('ooso) (ooro) (ooio)

uq6b6IJq6n; -1)032.. -1)032.. -'0000.. -'0003... -0032 001(oon) ('oois) ('ooT4) (0013) (oon)

JjJoJG 2rwbJ6 -'0033.. -1)010 -'0028... -1)034.,. -'0010 •002

CcP

(oso) (031) (031) ('o2) ('035)'038 '038 042 '021 -1)40 '300

('030) ('oso) ('021) (030)nq6bGuq6uc 010 01 -'040 -'032 '010 '809

('033) ('osi) (oss) ('oso) ('ora)JJJJOJG wbJG '021 '038 -002 '012 002 '393

jx('031) ('032) ('oso) ('032) ('054)

'055 '030 '02& '002 '101(012) ('034) (034) (032) (030)

uqGb6uqGuc 014 000 '014 -'034 '018('ois) (oi) ('oro) ('osi) (014)

jpo inb1 '051. 012 '032 '014 '018 '020

onc

(ios) ('sfl) ('194) ('318) (438)C''c -'08 -'315 1)13 -0004 0000 '2(iii) ('iio) ('oao) ('132) (140)

uqGb6uqGuc -'000 -'000 -'100 -'030 -'184 '383('on) ('002) ('ofl) (008) (131)

J1JJOJG 2gulbJG -'001 -'022 -022 -'041 -'025 '008

LrnuciuD6P

('o3) ('oit) ('040) ('034) (on)C'°'f -'034 '002 -'043 -0'008 -0033 '42

(on) (031) ('033) ('054) (034)uqGb6uq6uc '010 '010 031 -'033 -030 805

('os) ('032) (032) (oss) ('018)MPot 9'mbJG '002 014 -'001 -0'O0 -0031 '980

EiuucIuEdrnc

(034) ('oio) ('oss) ('034) ('012)'048 '018 -003 '014 -'010 '330

('oss) (013) ('014) ('012) ('014)Juq6b6uq6uc 'OQ.. '004 'O0 -003 '003 130

(oio) (oio) ('ois) ('013) ('oio)MP0J6 UJbJG '003.. '010 '004 '002 -'004 '003

JUA6UJG1JE1U&IJC!I

('ose) (oo) ('osi) ('ose)'030 010 -'010 -'004 -'03k '000

('ore) ('012) ('014) ('ois) ('014)uqGbGuqGu 013 -'001 '002 -'035.. '001

('012) ('012) (ous) ('013) ('au)jjpo wbjG '034. '003 -'00k -'012 -'000 '040

(on) ('o3) ('os) ('ose)CAGO( -'003 '033 -'012 -'030 -'082., '010

('os) ('oso) ('034) ('032) ('oro)pJqGb6uqGuc -'oo.. "04&. -'042.. -'020.. -'004.. 000

('osi) ('033) ('019) ('18) ('014)jjpoJc wbJ6 -'021. -1)31 -'024.. -'004.. -'110., 0002vmb16 fl1 A 0 )69T. +1 J.G9t +3 A' +3 )GWL > 3 L-G

Page 54: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

P1JTflW6Lo

(ro8) (ro2l) (ro3) (ri) (rrr2)24 JO3 -3ta TIO

(eio) (o) (.o) (roo3) (esa)Juq6bGuqGu4 2e ros 000

(22) (fle) (e) (2a)jJOJG 2guJbJG JtL 58 3TO 352 -OO 000

O( cLGqTç

C°"'cc!°"

(o'oi) (oo2) (oo28) (ooo) (ooe)C1-01' 000 O0 003Q -002 0031 '3O

(oio) (ooo) (oo) (oro) (ooa)pJqGbGuqGu; -002 -ooto -ooa -oose 000

(oo) (oii) (oio) (ooa) (on)jJJOf6 a9WbJG -0005 -0O2 -00J3 -0O2 0010 32u,b1€ flT A 0 AGVL +1 GL + GL +3 A6L > 3 E-cG2c

Page 55: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

23

* uqca JJ6 cO6qGuc e a jcuj? q(GLGu; oW GLO c cp I0** nJqicc6a cpc COGWCTGU ia qUJGLGIJ; .OW 6LO JJG J6AG

'q!c CO6WC16I1 a a DiJcwUçJ €LGU (LOW GLO P6 I OL

O GLOb-AJn6 O( }-cGec (OL 00Q9 0002 0302'I 00114 opa IJ8O II0.!3

(ooon) (ooou) (oooia)lEO 6+ >3 0001C -OOOI -00010

(oool3) (oooI8) (ooo3)lEO +3 00018 -0OOt 0OO3

(oooI) (oooso) (oooT8)lEO + 0OO -00O 00002

(oooT5) (oooi) (oooi)lEO +1 00010 -00OS O0O0

(oooii) (oooT2) (oooe)lEO 00OL -00O 00001

(oooo3) (o000a) (oooo)2!G 00O5 -0003 I 0OO3

(oooo) (o000e) (ooot)r6A€L6 O)O1I 0OO1O -OOOIf

(oooie) (oooso) (ooo2)icov 0010 oooi -ooo

MP°16 ambJG JuqGbGuqGuç

LCJGGdnç?) uq cp cowb&u?a (jom.cpin O( a) HGcGL0GI!c!;A LoplTaç açuqq GLLOL 9LG L6b0146q !IJ

(poojc AI1(TG O( poç b1112 JOIJ qp qqGq p) pooje 1IVjUG O( apç bjna JOUR 46LW qpç bjna poojc ip1G o4JJ62G qj1I1JUJI6 hG IIJCJJ1qG 2 LGL622OL JJG j6JGJ O( bLogc9pm (icov i EBLLDV OAGL 4o9j aa6ca) 1GAGLp€oL& o ?13 pG(oL& &uq p€ ?€m.a pG(oLG jj vao !U14 cvjuqt ?€ui qmnnia (uo LGboLcGq)nwJooII2 qnwm (uo LGboL4sq) ( C0WbDA açjaq JIG J8U LGdniLGw613la LG2bGCI!A6j?t cpç ?ui ?6&L

4P6 IbOe iiq 0 ocpGLlAIeG JG cOIiçLO (OL cpG a6Gccou p 6U6Lc6q p? Je4U LGd(qLGwGuca p?L 1Z3GL17 (O1IL

OJJO1AUJ fJJLGG )69L J(G cJJGU AG qnww? 1AjJCJ 6dUB ] fl IG ULIIJ-)6L8 (OflOlS4I3 fl)G IJL ?GvL V(çGLCpL6q 1 JJG WbIG iu ?ai. 'j' a6bçG qnwuA a u p€ noM6L6 $.' 2 JJG woqu L6 coaa vjj pujc bvq p .w: !" ?sa'L alJq a cp CLOaa e6cçiou 9A6L6

6JIJJç6 1J36 Gj6C O( gj LEO OIJ JJ6 coaç O( cLGcflc M4JJ Nq4JJpJ Ga IWOL JJJG coa O( CLGqç a qGiJ6q

ILP6 EILGC4 OJ JU IhO °' ]3ruJ ffJ4G2

JppJG :

Page 56: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

21

IJJC1U 11J6LGU (1.0111 IP A(1G 9 P' 11,0c J 16A6F2'J11"IP fl6L6JJ (LOW IJJ6 JpIG pG(OLG cPG 11,0 9 4J1Gj2!!U"lP q11J6LGIJ (LOW GLO T J'G 16A61

JJILIJOAGL 111 COI1LOJ () j3Q

(T8i) (i@) (a)3't tOi1 aoeI4nWPGL O( 30 3232 iaoo

(18) (r)WLTG4 cIviç uo14Gm jo oo

(13) (no)O( diG COUdLOI onb ()CP1716 l7 4JJG pOJqiJ - tb

(re) (is) (j)COULOJ Lo1rb ()H0JcJJU O( cp 88 O0

A4&PJ6 BGLOLG 11,0 Vc IbO 11,0 +3

v: MP°I 29IJJbJG

(!u pLqcG)( OpGL!.O1J fiG 1Jnu1p6L LGboLcGq L6 LGb6Cc!AGJ?t d}J6 WGqmi dPG WGVIJ IJq dJIG ecm1qLq qGAc0IJ

b1I C L6b0142 JJG qBcB (OL Cm.AG-O11ç JJIGLG BLG 30 OpaGLABç!OU GXCGbd (OL cojnwu i ( opz.iiou) vuqCOIUbUUfG2 yJJ nLGg LG(GL Op2GLJ iOua GXC6b4 (OL COIJIWIJ J .PAJSGLG JJGLG BL6 ouj? OpGLABpOIJ2

COITW11J J Bug LOlA Jfl IApGLG dPGLG BLG Ouj) QJ 0pGL OU J,BIJGJ B LGbOLç2 dPG qçB (OL fl,o O( uqGbGuqGu!U ci's CEO LBIJGJ V LGboLç2 ;JJG qç (01. J.1G GIIçILG u3bJG yff jJG UfLG2 i.qi. 1o opaGçou 6xcGbl (01.11LU0AGL pi couoi a q6uGq dP' q1u6 u qGuçç) O( urnloL BtGOJGL 9uq uoç 1Wbj? Cp91J6smG wG&uç o cBbçnLG dPG G[6cd!AG (LBCOI1 qAGGq qGbGuq6Iic O( fIG bi4c B$ lAJJ!Cp !I 2 qA6f6q)cr" lEo) aojq p? CoIJcL0flhJ LOnb JApGLG vjj q bflLCJJ9BG cousbniq c dl" 11,0 bi4c (r cpCOIIdLOJ LOr1b8 BJCG 111 d6 (OflOtM11 flJLGG ?G9L Th fJG (LBCI 013 0% 4OBJ WLJCGd ABJflG 0% GdU4 ( WGBIUG vçfl,Ø 18 fiG (LCfOIJ 0% UIBLJCGc ASU6 0% Gd(qc? ojq p IG COZIcLOI onb 9ç jp cpu 0% fIGP!w\pGL &8 JO1J B8 JJ18 LI18 18 WGlJçIOuGq U fIG bLO8bGqfl8 fiG (41BuG 0% fIG COULOJ Lonb8 8ç9JCG Bc8B168 OIAIJsq p? WGWpGL8 o% pia\p (UWJJ?L 1J1G 8497C6 0% Bu? OdPGL poqGL JAJIO 2jIJGq B piiqpi Aocp1 i.neç iiiçp2doCT ExCpl16 jp COudL0j-L0rrb 8ç8Jr6 uicjaq fIG 84BJC6 0% J'd 8}lsLGpoJqGL W fIG COIflblnAe Bil fIG?6B1.a fiG luG 0% lEO 18 q'u"q G €uq 0% fIG )GBL 1I !Ap!Cp JJ6 C0I1ibBU? 6CVWG jçq ou fI vui"jp8 BpJG LGbOLI2 fIG C}JBUG8 III fIG OlAIIGL8JJjb 8cLnCdJmG 9d fIG fIll6 0% fIG fl,Ø sug II fIG pLG6 8iip8GdflGUd

CP962 III 4JJ6 OliIJGL2JJJb LflC411L6JPJG :

Page 57: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

UJCØIJJ?L fl6L6U (LOW JJ6 AI1G 9 }3G flØ g 2 IGAGFIJJCIJJ .J6LGIJ (LOW JJG A9pJG PSOLG J1G flØ 16 IGAGI

'IP (LOll! 6LO JJG 3 JGAGjq(GL6uc (LOU.! GLO j 16A61

JfiILZJOAGL Il! COULOJ ()

(o) (roan) (eo)2PVLGOJGL ao2 Q1JJI,111mP6L O( 50 1QO0 O'O

(sn) (3o0)flWLJ64 CB IbO J3ô ITI14Gm €drnç? 00 00

(sse) (nt)O( flJG COIILOJ Lonb () 150CJJ911G Il! JG JJOJflJ 00

(i) (jo) (130)COULOJ LOffb ()

O( 1000 Q82

ALWP16 BG(OLG 11,0 V IbO IbO +3

C: CLAOfl

JflLDOAGL Ill GOUfLOI () 102

(ir) (ro.a) (T)aJ.UIL6pOjq6L

MnWPGLO( 320 18O0

(ir) (w12)W9LjG4 c9bc 11o w.4G! Gdrn !flG 122 00

(g) (soMO( COULOJ x.onb () ei -CP" III pojqrn 00 -os

(1w3) (ri) (ro)COIJçLOJ LOJ1b () 3Q eg.oT Co3HOJqIJ O( IJ1G 282

96(OLG IbO Vc IbO Ibo +3

B uqGbGuqGu4-couJb9uX IbO

Page 58: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

* JIJCJçJ? UIGL6U tLOUJ 6LO l}J6 JO IGAG!'

iiijctiçj? flIGL6U GLOW 6LO 1JJG o\O IGAGI'

ULJC9'Uç qIJ,6LGIJç Lom soLo j J6A6J'

1 O'03 003 O'OW OP' J Joiib pojqiue (o'o) (oo2) (o'oao)CP9LG JU CoUçLO- -OO2 O5 -O'T5,lu (orn) (o') (ooai)bL6'.IbO CJT9IJ6 -'g -O'O5 -O'LA'!PI6 MPO!6 u.TbJG uqGbGuqcuç 1b02 C'-'-°c

o 6c1crX aojq p? couçLoJ onb c m€' cuqq GuoL2 LG LGboI4€q ru pLcGcA6 J6qiiJ ihO' JIP' qrini O 4G COUcLOJ LOnB8 a4UJG 9 4J.IG flØ 1$ 4p6 LCIOU O 4Ol9J UJLJ16(EBaDY OAGL coçj c) GL 11,0' fl1' bLG-fl)Ø qiwu lu CJIm16 PJ icov JJG tOIlLOU 4JJG EXCP6 JJJG boçjj cjrnUG bLo pj i U3GULG JJ6 CpIIG !U icov

cpøu u bLocipmc? JI6 !wG o ;6 IbO qqn€q iu iAp!cp combm GCVW6 HcJJIp i.€box ii or o qjpc o qp€ççm. vuq bLGjbO 1UCLGG o bLoc9pç? on

DJAG2m6U4 p? 4JJG C01 II!'b°24IbO DGCIiU6 1" bL0P!Ii iuqFPIG 8:

Page 59: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

[J2} W9UP PTJ!U IJq C°I!' XGL (Jf) JJJJG ONUJ6LJJ!b nq COULOI 0.

e bowouO nt A9I4O €q jj O16 O rpL1: y(flT7o[ii] EGLL1 C!ømboIo (oe) flqonjj dno1ouG qr nii uibbo p mcL1coI6 1" 'ç zwb.

Gq.l CmpIq fluAGL2çX J,L6a2: Cp4qC O1IJJGLLT I4J !U S3SIfl3C Ifl DOb3 VIP'4° Cl0A1JIJ!

[J3] jpirn jccn.qo Csrmb9oIo CJ1! iq e''' (iaaY E!DucG q DGAGJ0bmGUc: jpc

DIL6CP J96q DGPI oui o\ oicc 'coson[j] DI'°'q D°I uq j€bnçron: JJpG CPO!CG pGçIAGGU j9uJc ro9u nq

JLqGL J$IJ nJ EnUnCi91 J,A9'LJCGç8 OJtJU 4 otsc v ois e[ii] D6 rOU 'jOJJIJ fl yIJqL6i 2PIH6L F9WLL6UCG if 2(IWWGLa 9vq J$OGL TJJqmun (TaaoYI..1oI6

jouu9ncG: Jp6oL?. vq JqqGuc& osc 4 'tc[io] DGGOLG L9IRO uq JçCpLq 6CJqJn6L (J3) 4JJ6 BGAGLeG BO DGC!B1OU iiq EILUJ bGL-

l'IPLI: ApJ9voE] q6 B1191JC! (i5) COUOJ '3cfln b% fl O6 3 ØLG

UflJC!U 911q }I G°!' }flPHC DGC!I0U flJO C0IUWP!9 flU!AGL2!4[] CP'"" JJJJOIJJ8 9U JOJO W1IJ3I6LI (T3) IUtOLUJc!OU J,LOqflcçOU hL!A9TG Ed0! E!

'or 4 ini uMs j3-5[] C"PI! JIU (i) 0bç1m1 IUA6mGUc 1IU9IJc!u DGCIl0U8 nq A9!06 O oIJJqGUç9J4

A0LFEo] BL69J6 pcpq nq AGL (jJ) 'ub% 4 obon al3C61 ycL9M-rJJ: 1461A

JOL ECVBE q flU!A6LI D6I[2] ojç0if L!cJ Jq jpqqcu (i) OIiñU6LaJJlb o E!" cp

qII°" "q B68G9LCF InC6UcIA6 D!C!0U b9b6L uo ie (raE E!U9IJc!9! ymJc6c CLosTb){] uTqbco C9PL!6II9 Cp!6 (etY bL0bL!6 I1J0Lm9!01 EI1191JCI1 JUçGLIJJG-

Obc!m9Jlc? 3JSJ6O flU!AGL27 O JJC9O pb:\\pJncpc9€oGqcr[] €pcpnj r q lu16 r (ioY COthOLG OM.LlGL8pIb acLnccnLGB: LAçG AGLBO2

N 6 A!4 6 J,GIJfflGLo: Ytll'°[] BIJ6 I09!0 (J) OJ! fIlçGLuJGq!wLn cLcqc! 6 J9 dnoc!ouG q flOLB9 Jfl 'c!JnZ%%*OJ6 U%

ii IAVIII: BOJOIJ9C!0L!0 29JAO q r!! 2!130LlUI (iaY obu6; wo[j] B9LC9 E9PL!I0 &q9 B1IJCO r1II C"'41 IfIq0 C9L1O COJ9 CI"

IIGIIGLGUCG

Page 60: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

13flW6O COLUGIJ fl1J1AoLaiç?

(] IJcp624 "q c (1aa2) j,p6 Cpo!cG o IsJPuc: 2b1n-o

OU3 O\ 22-2IO[31] 613ou J{op6Lç (j)4 L681q6uç VqqLG9e: v 2!bJ oq6J o C!1 'jc Edfl!1!PL!m4

F!PL! ypjuo[301 1I"4 N9L!O (j)4 x C\$ bO%%0130 $C (6$.6 3%(t 0L%(1 N3°31 $13 i'" II 2016 5 01.6

!0U o jrroccq uq flhJdtToc6q CEI1 D19c088!0U bb6L J40 2T[so] N6L4 C°1!"4 'q is" yJ6XIJq6L (iooiY 2;0cJC ysLJc68 "q CothoLc6 b6L01.I1Jc6: V Comb-

[5] r°i'" 1!" "q is Ic!cc j,pG 46M O4u1% 4JUWC6 53-j

IUPc8 S 1Q2-100[sJ onpLu4 jpne if JpççGL nq IcL!l!91J f)qdA12c (iaaY JucJ LnpJ!c OlL6!1: Juç€LIJç1orn1J

22 5031J0[] pGLIJ6L4 o2pn9 (iae) A6uJ1L6 Cb!c1!c nq D6c!!0u o co J,npI!C4 "Osu 4 Ø113tSI

131113160 UIJ!A6L2!A °.0°'T[52] r1c1udA! yJGx9uqcL i (jaoY Mpu C° jo!8aou Mqcuc6 Lom C6Lm1J

mq uçGLUJ6qçou444 0$1U3 4 35 3J-32[se] 'jnq4 HU6 E4 '-'J 9Aq if JJ6 (j) I"t°"!°"J Vamm6cL!6& IJIJc!J

5-j3[sw] i.cbJIm 2 w (Teas) J,JJ6 c9qu J,0MGL 0 r'GA6L1?G BJ1?0fll& 0$U11 4 S13I113$U CO$30WSC%

JJJdr1q OU J,L!C62 \O$tU1c1 4 jucwC6 i[55] Kqi4 e°' q opu CcomJ6jj (j)4 ELGC o ALJ(6 2611J6u9T!0u uq

'0L131 4 ECO130W? JOJ O.2-OO[sill Ho1mcLm4 BGuc3 lmq G9U J1!L016 (io) qcc dUq;A uq b6L0L111Uc6 N01JOLrU4

6IJC C° uq 0MJJGL8JJ!b 2cLncc64 01Ui 4 13136S C013O$13S% TT 2-20[soll 'J6uu y!cpI C4 'q M!JJ! if 6CJqU jJJGOLX 0 JJLDJ A1&IJ6L1J B6PA10L1

1\16 O1tU11 4 tO 1O38-T3[e1 'W!"4 BP' V sq K!"! (iooY JJG i,°c-i" 0b6Lç1u J,6L0LUJDC6 0 IbO E!"4

CJ5!C0[is] 0ombGL& 1'I (ioas) u 6IJi1LG Cb!ct1 i"q"c' WS$1360 flU!AGL2!c? o

qe A!4 6 bGIJ2!GLo: N!19"°6uqJ64 !U i$S%U006 11 030136 $U 1t1$U YV Ccc"

[i ] Cfl1c16L!4 1oIo (J) GjJ6 qojj di109l0U6 flIJJC!JG qI B°1. 'JI !0u6 JD1J!9L!9

bO*IC.T 6CO1L$OWS•C& fl 2°J6-'f oLG:

ulojo qjj bnppc combøu !" W QJWpG144 i, V J,6Uç 'q C FP6II"" (6q)[ia] EP1J1l6L!4 b°1° &q r'q! S!U9T6& (Iae2)4 6 144J1 q6J COuILOJJO 2OC16c9L!0 !J

Page 61: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

4ka] pnii (jy) Jp6 A9Jn6 oj A°' 1cpc: v ;nqX o OCJ EXCP6

4 'cntcsk81 AP O'q (Ta82Y D8CJO2flL6 C°c 9uq 4JJ6 CPOCG O fUfliC!IJ O1TLCG OtUSO

4osec voso\[f] JJJ6GL ynqLGr uq }OGL j,j; Ai2pu? (oY JJ9LGpOJq6L8 q G' CO$LO1

M6GU nnb1TpJ2p6q muncL!b (c1r6G vii°" fl!AGL!ck] KL!2cI 'iq KGIJTF HPOP (i&tY C01J W'PP' !U Ia8O: Aq6IJC6 LOW

bui62 \ou.wt 4Ewb:uctt wrnc jAGIuGiJç J,iIJUC!9J JCçOL2 OIJ2IJ CLO },ILUJW Aiq€uCG LOW OIJ 9IJ 0m-

[] }'oiJq yJGITqLo 2GWPGUGJJ! 9uq 3OAWJ IJGçç (iatY ffJ8 EXC6 2GU A!1 o I'-

[} jçocjc iu (j) 14GM LG flIJqGLbI4cGq ous 4 uc coiowc

k] ciccGL q jç (jj)e rou-1nU bG4PLW9IJCG O I"!lJ LflPIIC OJGLlIJ& 'OSU3 4

[] (j JJJ6 C°c °1 C° bflPUC O1U% 4S CSc3 COI3OrS% J8 5C8-581

k] 'w jc (TaY JpG ii°c JUG tjc o JO8o, 4 nzOWG A6UCG OW IJç6W0UJ D' 1Ot! o\ DGCGWPGL

ko] B'JJc.u1 e uq iujGa (maY MP D° M6 KUOM yporzç C&b!1 2çulcpILG:

OLGL!U2 WGO flWAGLaJ4 o[ga] j1u ic imu e uq H61'1 (iaoY j,pG ELGC O 49LJCGc c°'q!!°' OU piçij JJIpC

rGIcp DGP o\ t T3TOO[] B'1' vm1 c (ieaY uq Ørrç9qGL2: JJG CpO!cG pGcMGGu 9uq yLW-

6IJJbLCO wio C6ULO q AOII6L!O8 ? iuuco[3.!J bJ9UGJI GLO DGLUJG1O (T8a2) DG6Lm!U911c GGC1O8 qG 1 I!q B0I6U Ebiw: cm

LOW UqCçIOU O• jçtj?. Joq9X wic€o BUC DIcU[J }?IJ6ç9 J9pTO ituq JOpGI4O jjOji ()è RJC JL6UJ!flhJJ couenmb!oue UVUC!91 i1flLG

OUOLIJ uq j'drqqçX flU!AGL!I BOCC01I q ECVL{E[] }UOè 9CO uq ja gojj (1032) ij CPO1CG o ØMZ1GLJJJb LnccnL6: yucA coi

E obcuis 'coowc a[] J9vo N9'Lco JpG joççiou o Cowbøni6 oh cocjc A9LyG4: 1 ooLqpiou 19!JJTLG

JIJ491 WP1!C OUG1411 WGO flrnA6L9i O[] AJCJGJOU MJJG H N6øTJ ILçCJJ 911q K6" 2PP (1082Y b6LOLm9IJC6 O COUJIU! onuq

Page 62: F!' i11VJC2 - NBER

cosoflc 4oAGwpGL[211 U1 r'n (1082?) MPc DGcGLUJ!IJGB PG M1' C0Lb0L9cG A0c6 4ci\ o &g 4

%t% :[20] !U168 ri (J) JII2GL ØMuGL2pb vuq 4P6 D6C1!OU lO C° b1TPI1 3y O\ co-


cpq NV OJ - NBER

cpq NV OJ - NBER

cp'q viv - NBER · JOO J,'f22Cpfl2Gtt2 VAUfICcp'q viv 14V1101.4VF BflKEVfl Oh ECOMO1'HC 1E2EVCH M0LJUU JbQL 14°' F' VYiD 1EFVJ1AE MVQE2 DIIEC1 AE2IIAIEML 014 E1bFOAV'EI'tL IHE EEEEGL

cp'q viv - NBER · JOO J,'f22Cpfl2Gtt2 VAUfICcp'q viv 14V1101.4VF BflKEVfl Oh ECOMO1'HC 1E2EVCH M0LJUU JbQL 14°' F' VYiD 1EFVJ1AE MVQE2 DIIEC1 AE2IIAIEML 014 E1bFOAV'EI'tL IHE EEEEGL

Randomisation en Pratique Dr. Eric P. Bettinger Stanford University and NBER May 10, 2010.

Randomisation en Pratique Dr. Eric P. Bettinger Stanford University and NBER May 10, 2010.

ori - NBER

ori - NBER

NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES UNDER THERMAL STRESS › assets › uploads › research › pdf › Almas_… · Tessa Bold Stockholm, Sweden IIES tessa.bold@iies.su.se Ian Bolliger Energy

NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES UNDER THERMAL STRESS › assets › uploads › research › pdf › Almas_… · Tessa Bold Stockholm, Sweden IIES [email protected] Ian Bolliger Energy

qI V&. JAMOITAM - NBER

qI V&. JAMOITAM - NBER

i noiiibnosiq - NBER

i noiiibnosiq - NBER

DMDiSIOW - NBER

DMDiSIOW - NBER

Riccione, 19 gennaio 2009 Annamaria Lusardi Dartmouth College, NBER, & CeRP Limportanza della Pianificazione Finanziaria.

Riccione, 19 gennaio 2009 Annamaria Lusardi Dartmouth College, NBER, & CeRP Limportanza della Pianificazione Finanziaria.

AOLPU bbL ]40 - NBER

AOLPU bbL ]40 - NBER

ifi - NBER

ifi - NBER

fiOLJUU bL - NBER

fiOLJUU bL - NBER

7. FETİH KUPASI GELENEKSEL TÜRK OKÇULUĞU ÖN ELEMEokcularvakfi.org/basvuru/7_Fetih_Kupasi_Ankara_Duyuru_Kurallar.pdf · Keçec˜ P˜r˜ Mah. Fat˜h Sultan M˜nber˜ Cad. No:1

7. FETİH KUPASI GELENEKSEL TÜRK OKÇULUĞU ÖN ELEMEokcularvakfi.org/basvuru/7_Fetih_Kupasi_Ankara_Duyuru_Kurallar.pdf · Keçec˜ P˜r˜ Mah. Fat˜h Sultan M˜nber˜ Cad. No:1

0L qicnou uq cunuii bi.qcb1u2 - NBER

0L qicnou uq cunuii bi.qcb1u2 - NBER

Performance-induced CEO turnover turnover 10-29-10 Berkele… · Performance-induced CEO turnover . Dirk Jenter . Stanford University and NBER . djenter@gsb.stanford.edu . Katharina

Performance-induced CEO turnover turnover 10-29-10 Berkele… · Performance-induced CEO turnover . Dirk Jenter . Stanford University and NBER . [email protected] . Katharina

Jeffrey Frankel Harvard Kennedy School & NBER NBER Conference on Sovereign Debt & Financial Crises, Organized by Sebnem Kalemli-Ozcan, Carmen Reinhart.

Jeffrey Frankel Harvard Kennedy School & NBER NBER Conference on Sovereign Debt & Financial Crises, Organized by Sebnem Kalemli-Ozcan, Carmen Reinhart.

NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

˘ ˇ ˆ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · Mc Mc Mc Mc 8c 8c M ˇ 8 ˆ ˜ ˙ ˇ ˆ ˙ ˚ ˙ ˚ ˝˛ ˘ ˘ ˙ 3 w M 3 w 8 3 w ˇ0ˆ ˛ ˙ ˘ ˘ ˙ ˘ ˙ F M 3 M w 8 8 3 ˇ/ˆ 3 ˜ ˚ ˜ Mc

˘ ˇ ˆ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · Mc Mc Mc Mc 8c 8c M ˇ 8 ˆ ˜ ˙ ˇ ˆ ˙ ˚ ˙ ˚ ˝˛ ˘ ˘ ˙ 3 w M 3 w 8 3 w ˇ0ˆ ˛ ˙ ˘ ˘ ˙ ˘ ˙ F M 3 M w 8 8 3 ˇ/ˆ 3 ˜ ˚ ˜ Mc

DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

Takeo Hoshi University of California, San Diego, NBER, and ... Hoshi.pdfTakeo Hoshi University of California, San Diego, NBER, and TCER February 9, 2009 1 ... Lessons from Japan”

Takeo Hoshi University of California, San Diego, NBER, and ... Hoshi.pdfTakeo Hoshi University of California, San Diego, NBER, and TCER February 9, 2009 1 ... Lessons from Japan”