Dr. Johann Sollgruber

1

Ljubljana, 12-13 October 2009

Homologues Group Meeting

Slovenia, October 2009

Republika SlovenijaEuropean Union

Cohesion policy and state aid 18th ANNUAL MEETING OF EUROPEAN FINANCIAL CONTROL AUTHORITIES OF STRUCTURAL FUNDS,

“THE HOMOLOGUES GROUP”Ljubljana, 12-13 October, 2009

Dr. Johann SollgruberDr. Johann Sollgruber

2





OverviewOverview1. CONTENT2. SF-2007-20133. Standard clause4. Cohesion Policy and State aid-links5. Horizontal framework6. Regional state aid7. Recovery&Temporary state aid

framework

3





ComplianceCompliance

Under Article 9 (2) of the Council General Regulation for the Structural Funds EC (1083) 2006, operations financed by the Funds shall comply with the provisions of the Treaty and of acts adopted under them. The Commission and the Member States shall ensure that assistance from the Funds and the Member States be consistent with the activities, policies and priorities of the Community.

4





Standard clause in Operational Standard clause in Operational ProgrammesProgrammes

Any aid granted under an operational programme must comply with the State aid rules that are in force.

5





Cohesion policy and State aid-linksCohesion policy and State aid-links

• The concept of less and better targeted aid and aid for regions most in need and the objective of Cohesion policy are similar.

• Both policies focus on Lisbon oriented targets.• Both policies, Cohesion and Competition

responded to the Crisis-recovery package - see later

• Acceleration of programme implementation

6





List of aid schemesList of aid schemes

Article 37 SF REG indent i) Chapter II,

Programming content, Section 1 “to include an indicative list of the proposed aid schemes, under Article 87 of the Treaty, which are expected to be submitted within the programming period for Commission approval.”

7





Cohesion policy and State aid-linksCohesion policy and State aid-links

• The fact that Article 55 (6) [modified] of the General Regulation governing the Structural Funds 2006/1063 refers to state aid and to the provisions of Article 87 (1) EC-Treaty proves how close both policies act together.

• Either financing gap analysis or maximum allowed state aid intensities

8





Cohesion policy and State aid-linksCohesion policy and State aid-linksThe 5 years' minimum period to keep an aided investment alsostems from state aid rules ( "relocation in the context ofregional development“). In essence it requires a MemberState to recover any co-funded state aids where a project isterminated within five years after its completion (three years forSMEs). This Member States then informs all other MemberStates and the Commission of the recovery and as aconsequence no other Member State will grant EU funding tothe same undertaking.

9





State aid principles-Treaty State aid principles-Treaty provisionsprovisions

The basic substantive rules on the control of State aid in the EU are set out in Article 87 of the EC Treaty. This article provides that State aids are in principle incompatible with the common market. The principle of incompatibility covers measures that meet all the criteria listed in Article 87(1), i.e. they: a) involve a transfer of State resources; b) entail an economic advantage for undertakings; c) distort competition by selectively[1] favouring certain beneficiaries; and d) produce an effect on intra-Community trade. [1] Selectivity could be with respect of the type of firms (e.g. SMEs), their location (e.g. a specific region) or their sector of activity. In the extreme, aid could be addressed at one specific firm.

10





StateState aid principles-Treaty aid principles-Treaty provisionsprovisions

• In the context of Structural Funds operations, the most relevant exemption clauses are those of Article 87(3)(a) and 87(3)(c) of the Treaty:

• Article 87(3)(a) states that the Commission may consider compatible “aid to promote the economic development of areas where the standard of living is abnormally low or where there is serious underemployment;

• Article 87(3)(c) states that the Commission may consider compatible “aid to facilitate the development of certain economic activities … where such aid does not adversely affect trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest”.

11





Regional Aid guidelinesRegional Aid guidelinesRegional state aid guidelines. They give substance to the articles 87(3)(a) and 87(3)(c) of the Treaty. In essence they indicate the maximum grant rates allowed for certain specifically designated regions. Under the Regional Aid Guidelines 2007-2013, Member States were invited to notify a single regional aid map for 2007-2013 covering their entire territory as soon as possible after the publication of the Guidelines. The provisions for "statistical effected regions" to be revised in 2010 and their financial envelope as well as degressive state aid intensities are similar and prove coherence between both policies.

12





Regional aid guidelinesRegional aid guidelinesRegional aid may be approved:• Article 87(3)(a) : economic cohesion at Community

level • Article 87(3)(c): national disparities• Award maxima under the Regional Aid Guidelines• Large firms-Medium-firms-Small firms• ‘a’ regions GDP per head <45% EU25 average• ‘a’ regions GDP per head <60% EU25 average • ‘a’ regions GDP per head <75% EU25 average• ‘c’ areas (general case)

13





State aid mapsState aid maps

14





Assessment of compatibility-Assessment of compatibility-a risk-a risk-based approach to State aid based approach to State aid

assessmentassessmentLarge regional aidLarge regional aid

eg risk capitaleg risk capital

RDI RDI

Specified aid categoriesSpecified aid categories

15





CompatibilityCompatibility

In broad terms, from a compliance perspective, three categories of measure can be distinguished:(i) de minimis support; (ii) measures which fit within the General GBER; and (iii) measures which require notification. This classification gives rise to important issues to be addressed at the domestic level, since each of the three groups carries different risks and responsibilities. Indeed, the lower the level of scrutiny by the Commission, the higher the administrative burden at the national and subnational levels in terms of ensuring compliance.

16





Horizontal aidHorizontal aid• Block Exemption Regulation for the following

categories have been adopted:• Environmental protection • Small and medium sized enterprises (SME) • Employment • Training• RDI• Risk capital• Those elements which do not distort competition have

been included into a « General Block exemption Regulation «OJ L 214, 9.8.2008, p. 3–47

17





Services of general economic Services of general economic interestinterest

• Difficult area but highly relevant for Cohesion policy:• Services of general economic interest• The Decision specifies the conditions under which

compensation to companies for the provision of SGEI is compatible with state aid rules and does not have to be notified to the Commission in advance.

• Conditions: a clearly defined public service mandate;no over-compensation;compensation of less than €30 million per year per undertaking; and annual turnover of less than €100 million per undertaking. no limits for amount of compensation:for hospitals, social housing; air and sea transport to islands; airports and ports.

18





The economicThe economic downturn-recovery downturn-recovery measuresmeasures

• Temporary State aid framework (December 2008): The consolidated version including the February 2009 amendments is “Temporary Community framework for State aid measures to support access to finance in the current financial and economic crisis (OJ No C 83/1 of 7 April 2009)”.

• This framework allows for a “compatible limited aid amount” of 500 000 € to be paid in the years 2008-2010. In the light of the financial and economic crisis it can exceptionally be paid to firms that fall under the definition of “firms in difficulties” . But all measures apply only to firms which were not in difficulty on 1 July 2008

19





The economic downturn-recovery The economic downturn-recovery measures-Temporary state aid measures-Temporary state aid

frameworkframework• Cohesion policy and firms in difficulties• While rescue and restructuring aid by Member States is therefore allowed under restrictive

conditions it has never been a priority under Cohesion Policy. This is for several reasons:

– The priority of Cohesion policy has been on promoting innovation, business start up and developing the capacity for entrepreneurship that can contribute to productivity gains in the medium and long term;

– The added value of EU investment in rescue and restructuring is highly dubious because of the difficulties of choosing which companies to rescue and restructure. The risk is that such measures would not be well targeted but used too widely with modest, low or zero medium term impact.

– There is a high risk of wasting public resources softening the impact of the closure of uncompetitive companies (often due to over capacity or unproductive work practices) rather than allowing market forces work.

20





Rescue aidRescue aid

The fact that state aid measures are allowed in a particular field does not automatically imply that such measures are priorities for Cohesion Policy.

21





Credit squeezeCredit squeeze This framework allows for a “compatible limited aid amount” of 500 000 € to

be paid in the years 2008-2010. In the light of the financial and economic crisis it can exceptionally be paid to firms that fall under the definition of “firms in difficulties”

Financial crisis is affecting the real economy (businesses and jobs).

High risk aversion on the part of banks → credit squeeze.

All companies are affected and especially SMEs.

Negative impact at short-medium term for EU companies and at long term on EU investments.

THEREFORE →Need for additional State aid measures but they have to be well

targeted.

22





Objective of the Communication on Objective of the Communication on temporary state aidtemporary state aid frameworkframework

Part of « European Economic Recovery Plan ».

of 26 November 2008-COM(2008) 800 final To facilitate companies’ access to finance, thereby:

Ensuring continuity in their activities. Encouraging companies to continue investing in

the future, in particular in a sustainable growth economy.

23





Main principles of the Main principles of the CommunicationCommunication

Recall the existing aid instruments. +

Propose additional aid measures → Based on Art. 87(3)(b) → Limited in time (31.12.2010)

Applicable to all sectors, SMEs and large companies.

Recall the existing aid instruments. +

Propose additional aid measures → Based on Art. 87(3)(b) → Limited in time (31.12.2010)

Applicable to all sectors, SMEs and large companies.

24





MeasuresMeasures

Aid in the form of subsidised interest rate

Aid for the production of green products

Other measures-Risk Capital

Temporary derogation of risk capital guidelines.

Simplification of the requirements to use the "escape clause" contained in the export credit Communication.

Compatible limited amount of aid

Aid in the form of guarantees

25





CompatibleCompatible limited amount of aidlimited amount of aidNot an increase of de minimis threshold →

New aid of EUR 500 000 per undertaking

Aid may be granted until 31.12. 2010.

Prior to the granting, MS shall verify that any possible de minimis aid received + the new aid will not exceed the threshold of EUR 500 000 during the period 1.01.2008- 31.12. 2010.

26





Compatible limited amount of aidCompatible limited amount of aid Only applicable to aid schemes.

Firms active in the fisheries sector and in some agricultural activities are not eligible.

(But applicable to the transport sector)

Excluded: export aid or aid favouring domestic products.

The measure only applies to firms which were not in difficulty on 1 July 2008.

27





Aid in the form of guaranteesAid in the form of guarantees

Reduction of the annual guarantee premium to be paid during a period of two years following the granting of the guarantee in relation to both investment and working capital loans. [max. 90% of the loan]

Loan must not exceed the total annual wage bill of the beneficiary for 2008.

For companies created after 1.01.2008 → the estimated amount for the first two years in operation.

Guarantee premium is calculated in accordance with the safe-harbour provisions of the ‘Notice on guarantees’.

28





Aid in the form of guaranteesAid in the form of guarantees

Reduction of up to: 25% for SMEs 15% for large companies

This reduction can also be applied for new guarantees granted on the basis of methodologies already accepted by a Commission decision.


29





Interest aid for the production of Interest aid for the production of green productsgreen products

Interest rate reduction for investment loans. Loans should be granted before 31.12.2010.For financing of new products which significatly

improve environmental protection.

Starting point to calculate the aid is the reference rate of the beneficiary calculated in accordance with the « subsidised interest rate » methodology. Then, reduction of up to:

25% for large companies 50% for SMEs

30





Interest aid for the production of Interest aid for the production of green productsgreen products

Reduction applied for a period of two years following the granting of the loan.


31





CumulationCumulation De minimis + compatible limited amount of aid → max. EUR 500 000 for the period of 1.01.08 –

31.12.2010.

De minimis + rest of the measures contained in the Communication →

de minimis granted after 1.01.08 shall be deducted from the aid granted.

Temporary aid measures can be cumulated with other compatible aid provided that the maximum aid intensities are respected.

32





Notification requirementsNotification requirementsNew measures should be notified

The Commission will ensure swift adoption of decisions

33





• Merci !

• Gracias!

• Thank you !

• Vielen Dank !

Dr. Johann Sollgruber

Documents

Transcript of Dr. Johann Sollgruber