CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro...
Transcript of CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro...
![Page 1: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory
Masahiro Nakashima
(The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU)
With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU)
COSMO/CosPa 2010
![Page 2: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
COSMO/CosPa 2010 2/21
Introduction Two Big Mysteries of Cosmology
→ Dark Energy & Dark Matter
Modification of Gravity = Adding the extra degree of freedom
The Mysteries of Gravity = Modification of Gravity at long-distance scale?
scalar : F(R)-gravity, Galileon theory… tensor : massive gravity, bi-gravity theory… vector : ???
Einstein-Aether Theory!
![Page 3: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Action = Einstein-Hilbert + Fixed Norm Vector Fieldwith a Lorentz Violating VEV. [Jacobson and Mattingly (1999)]
Stability Analysis of Perturbation [Armendariz-Picon et al. (2010)]
** : correspondence with Horava-Lifshitz gravity.
Einstein-Aether Theory
What is the observational consequence of this new transversevector degree?
CMB B-mode Polarization!
scalar sector : tensor sector :vector sector :
COSMO/CosPa 2010 3/21
![Page 4: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
CMB B-mode PolarizationB-mode is the curl-like component of CMB polarization.
Now, so many projects are attempting to detect the CMB B-modepolarization exciting era for B-mode physics!
Possible origin of B-mode Polarization
Vector modes are more efficient to produce B-mode polarization than tensor modes. [Hu and White (1997)]
difficult for usual vector models to make a definite prediction.
Tensor : Primordial Gravitational Waves (PGW) Vector : Source models such as cosmic strings or other defects
** In GR without sources, vector mode only decays…
Aether Field Perturbation can be generated in a same way as PGW during inflation and the subsequent evolution is clearly understood!
COSMO/CosPa 2010 4/21
![Page 5: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Our Works
Formulate the linear perturbation of the vector mode in Einstein Aether theory using the covariant formalism.
Derive the initial condition in the early Radiation Dominated stage considering the ordinary matter and Aether.
Calculate the CMB B-mode Power spectrum due to the vectormode numerically using modified CAMB code
Understand the shape of the spectrum in an analytic way.
COSMO/CosPa 2010 5/21
![Page 6: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Basic Quantities for Aether Field
Energy-Momentum Tensor :
Equation of motion for Aether Field :
Fixed Norm Constraint :
Einstein equation :
Useful Parameter Definition
COSMO/CosPa 2010 6/21
![Page 7: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Background Cosmology
Flat FRW Background :
Friedman equations :
Effect of Aether can be incorporated intothe cosmological Gravitational Constant (G.C.).
Note that the fundamental G.C. , which appears in the analysis of perturbations, is different from the G.C. of the background cosmology.
** The G.C. that the local experiment measures is
Constraint from BBN :
[ Carroll and Lim (2004) ]
COSMO/CosPa 2010 7/21
![Page 8: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Second order action without matter
During inflation , we have the positive frequency solution,
Defining the dimensionless power spectrum as ,
we can derive
Primordial Spectrum of Aether Vector Perturbation
Vector Perturbation for Aether Field
** The amplitude and tilt depends on the details of the inflation ( for dS inflation).
[ Armendariz-Picon et al. (2010) ]
COSMO/CosPa 2010 8/21
![Page 9: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Fundamental observer : ( )
Projection tensor :
Covariant Formalism
1+3 Decomposition using
10 Fundamental Variables
Projective Covariant Derivative
Energy-Momentum Tensor
Covariant Derivative of 4-velocity
Decomposition of Weyl Tensor
* Hawking (1966), Olsen (1976), …+
** In Background FRW universe, only have non-vanishing values.
Merits- Gauge invariant- Non-linear effect- CAMB !
COSMO/CosPa 2010 9/21
![Page 10: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Basic Equations From Ricci identities and contracted Bianchi identities using
Einstein equation, we obtain the following equations.
Constraint eqs.
Conservation of Energy-Momentum Tensor
Evolution eqs.
** In the above equations, we have dropped the higher order terms (left only the linear quantity around the flat FRW universe).
COSMO/CosPa 2010 10/21
![Page 11: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Numerical Result from Modified CAMB
It is possible for vector BB to surpass the tensor BB respecting the existing observational constraint from the TT amplitude.
COSMO/CosPa 2010 14/21
![Page 12: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Analytic Approach -1-Photon Multipole Equations in covariant formalism
Integral Solution for B-mode Polarization
Note that , it is important to know at the recombination epoch.
Tight-Coupling Expansion
COSMO/CosPa 2010 15/21
![Page 13: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Evolution of Variables
Aether vs Scale-factorin normal plot
Aether vs Scale-factorin log plot
tracks the evolution of
Super-Horizon Sub-Horizon
COSMO/CosPa 2010 17/21
![Page 14: CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory...CMB Polarization in Einstein-Aether Theory Masahiro Nakashima (The Univ. of Tokyo, RESCEU) With Tsutomu Kobayashi (RESCEU) COSMO/CosPa](https://reader035.fdocument.pub/reader035/viewer/2022062611/612919688dfed9606d6fc75a/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Summary and DiscussionWe have computed the power spectrum of CMB B-mode
Polarization in the Einstein-Aether Theory.
To do that, we have employed the covariant formalism and derived the regular initial conditions.
The shape of the spectrum is clearly understood in an analytic way using tight-coupling expansion.
More quantitative argument for whether the spectrum can be observed or not and the search for the consistent parameter range considering other experiments will be future works.
Are there any cosmological Aether effects? (e.g. Weak Lensing?)
COSMO/CosPa 2010 21/21