b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy...

74

Transcript of b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy...

Page 1: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

������������� �������������� ������� ����������! #"%$&�'� �(� �)�*,+ � �!�.-/�0��� $ + �� �213���� ���4 + � 5

6/78:9<;>=?;A@CB�D EGFHF�IKJML

N%OQPROTSUPWVRXZY\[^]`_�a�bcYTYTXedMXMSgfihjY\]`_chk]�S�l�XebMmndco\]qpsr?tMtMtWuNvOQPROTS�wvbMmxhzy{ai]?m|bMY\o\_�]}f�~G� P/hj]?h|X��._�o��cXZm|�no�h 7 S�l�mnXeX�_�� 6 b`m|b�S�wGa p�rKt`tMtWu

Pg� 6 [:o�h|h|XZ�:hzb�hzy�X��.XZVU]?mnhz[�XZ_chibM� �!YTXZ��h|m|o\�Z]`YH�!_�dcoT_�XZXem|o\_�d]`_��{a�bc[�V���h|XZm�Pg�eoTXZ_��eX

oT_�VU]Kmxhzo�]`Y(����Y��UY\YT[�X�_ch�bM�'hzy�XGmnX��W��oTmnXZ[�X�_chz���>bMm�hjy�X���XedMmnXeXGbM��{]K�xh|Xem�bM��Pg�eoTXZ_���X

]?h�hzy�X��f�P�Pgf.ai����P��!���.P:��w�Pg�%���%�v�%� ��¡¢�%��ai��w��G£'��l.¤

PWXeV�h|X�[ 6 Xem�rKtMtM¥�¦ ��]`�n�|]`�kyW���xXehnhz���s_��xhzo�hj��h|XGbM�'�'X��ky�_�bMYTbMd 7 rKtMtM¥�O�f�YTYHmzo�dcychj��mnX��xXemn�MX��O

f���hzy�bMm�O§O�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�.XeVU]Kmxhj[¨X�_chib`�©�!YTXZ��h|m|o\�Z]`Yª�!_�dMo\_�XeXZm|o\_�d¨]`_��{a�bc[�V���h|XZm�Pg�eoTXZ_��eX

PWXZV�h|XZ[ 6 XZm%«gS(rKtMtM¥

a�Xemnhzo���X�� 6W7 O�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZOeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZOP/h|XeV�y�]`_�oTX&PWXZ_�X�¬

­�mzoT_��Zo�VU]`YH®�XZ�nX�]Km|�kyqf��n�xb��eo�]?h|X��y�XZ�no\�.Pg��VRXemx��oT�xbMm

f��e��XZV�h|XZ� 6/7 OeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OZO�OeOeOeO�OZO�OeO�OfvmnhzyW��mvPg[:o�hzy

a�y�]`o�m|[^]`_SW�.XZVU]?mnhz[�XZ_chk]KYa�bc[:[�o�hnh|XZX%bc_¯l�mz]`����]?h|X�P/hz����XZ_/hz�

Page 2: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf
Page 3: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

������������� ������������������������� �!�"����#%$'&(� �)�*���!�,+.-/�0���'12�3����&4-5 �)�

6 �!��#��"7"-��)8

6/7f�YTo\�eo�]��}ORN bWb:9ZXem

;=< > ?A@CB!BEDGF�BIHJBEK DML�DON PRQ!BI?SDGT2BUHWV�X�YZDG[GBIQI@Z[OPRY:X�T \]@CT DODGQI@CT \PRT F_^�H]?AN <�BIDOQ5;=[O@CDOT [GD

H]T_;=DGN�BEDG?`>aDGQ5b=c�dRe]eRf�c @ZT�N�PWQ!BE@ZPRYaVg<�YCh�YCYZ?ADOTiBjHRV BEK�DQIDGk2< @ZQ!DO?ADOTiBElUVgH]QjBEK�DMF�DO\]Q!DOD4HRV

m PRl�BEDOQUHRVn;=[G@ZDOT�[OD

oqp 8r������s K @Cl�BEK DGlI@ClnlIDGDOt2lnBEH�@C?SN�QIHvu]D"H]< Qn< T�F DOQ!l!BwPWT F @ZT�\/HRV�BEK D�DGxaDO[GBIlnHRV�N Q!H]lIHrF @C[jPRT F`BIDO?ANaHRQEPRYuWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T lyH]TzP{l!NaDGDO[wKzQIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T|l!}rl�BEDO?~>i}�PW[Ok2< @ZQ!@ZT \�P�BEPR\]\]DGF�[OH]Q!N < l�HRV'T�PWBI< QEPRYDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY'l!NaDGDO[wK�DOYC@Z[O@�BEDGF�@ZT�Kr<�?�PRTr��[OHR?SN <=BEDOQ�@ZTiBEDGQEPR[�BE@ZHRT�PRT F�F�DGu]DGYZH]N�@ZT \�P3Q!H]> < l�BlID�B_HWV(VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl�BEHzkr< PRTiBE@CV�}�PR[OH]<�l!BE@C[{[OH]Q!QIDOYZPWBEDGl�HRV`DG?SHRBI@ZH]T����VgHr[O< l%�U@CYZY�>*D�\R@Cu]DGTBEH`VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYal!NaDGDO[wK_l!@ZT [GD�BEK D4PW[O[O<�QEPR[�}%< lI@CT \5�!< l�B�BEK @Cl�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l!BEPWBED4K�PWl>*DODOTJVgH]<�T F`BEH/F H4P�>*DGB!BEDGQ*�!H]>�PWB�F�@ZlI[GQI@C?S@CT�PWBE@CT \U>aD�B���DGDOTADO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY=PRT FJT�H]T=��DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYlIN*DODG[wK|���O��c�PRT F�VgQI< l�BEQEP�BE@ZHRT�PRYZl!HAYCD�PRF�ljBEHSPRT�< T N YCD�PRlIPRTiB5D��=NaDGQI@ZDGT [OD4VgH]QjBIK D4< lIDGQO�

s K QIDGD4[OH]Q!NaH]QIPJPRQID�< lIDGF�BIHJ@ZTiu]DGl!BI@Z\iPWBID�N Q!H]NaDGQ!BI@ZDOl�HWV)DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY*lIN*DODG[wK_PRT�F�@CF DOTiBI@CV�}VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl�BEH%>*DJ< l!DOF{F < Q!@ZT \%[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]T�PWT F�QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T_BEPRlIt2lO� s ��H�HRV�BIK D`[OHRQIN*H]QEP�c�� �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤ PRT F¦¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF:c*[OHRT lI@Cl!B'HRVn<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlUBEK PWB'H=[G[O< QUT�PWBI< QEPWYZYC}�F < Q!@ZT \AP�QIH]<�BI@ZT DBwPWlIt�� s K D�¥�@ZT \R< @Zl�BE@Z[SL/PWBEP�^�H]T l!H]Q!BI@Z< ?§[OHRQIN*H]QEP_HWVU¨�Q!H]lIHrF�}�PRT F�X�?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY";=N*DODG[wK:cQIDGN QIDGlIDGT2BI@ZT \�BIK D¦BIK @ZQ!F�[OHRQIN < lGcU@ZlA[OH]?AN QI@ClIDGF�HRV/<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOl%l!NaH]tWDOT�>i}�PR[GBIH]QIlG�ª©�HRBIKDOYC@Z[G@CBEDGF�PRT F�T H]T=�«DOYC@Z[O@�BEDGF¬lIN*DODG[wK�PRQID/<�lIDOF�BEH�N Q!H­ur@CF DMPA[GH]?SN PRQEPWBI@CuRD�l!BI< F�}�HRV®DO?AHRBE@CH]T:�

¯ l!@ZT \�N�PRQIPRYZYCDOY®<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGl(PRl�BIK D�>�PRl!@Zl4HRV�H]< Q4@ZTiuRDOl!BI@Z\iP�BE@ZHRT:c�PRT°PRT�PWYC}rlI@Cl/HRV�l!NaDGDO[wKuWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T l'[�PR<�lIDOF{>i}¦DO?AHRBE@CH]T¦��PRl�N*DOQ�VgH]QI?ADOF�< l!@ZT \�lIN*DO[GBIQIH]\RQEPR?Al�PRT�F�N QIH]l!H=F=}2�«>�PRl!DOFBEHrH]YClO�°;=@±��N Q!H]lIHrF @C[�VgD�PWBI< QIDGl`��DGQID%N Q!H]N*H]lIDGF�BIH�>aD�\]H=HrF�F @ClI[GQI@Z?A@ZT PWBEH]Q!lyHWV5DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYlIN*DODG[wK:� ¯ l!@ZT \5F�PWBEP5[OHRYZYZDG[GBIDOFyVgQ!H]?.P5Q!D�PRY±��YC@CVgDnl![ODOT PRQI@CH cRBEK�D"[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]TMD��=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiBnF D��BEDGQI?A@ZT DGFABIK�PWB�P�u]DOQIPR\]D'N @CBI[wKS��PRl"BIK D'>aDGl!B�PWB�F�@ZlI[GQI@C?S@CT�PWBE@CT \�>*DGB��"DODGT%DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY l�BwPWBIDOlGc�UK @CYZD/?SP��=@Z?`< ?�N @�BE[wK��jPRlU>*DOl�B'VgHRQ�F @Zl![OQI@C?S@CT�PWBI@ZH]TSlI< [G[ODOl!l�< l!@ZT \APR[�BEDOF�F�PWBEP��

² < ?SPRT=�«YZ@Cl!BEDGT DOQUl�BE< F @CDOl5PRQIDMN Q!DOlIDGTiBEDOF�BIH�PRl!lIDGlIl�BIK D(YZPR>aDGYZ@CT \J?SD�BEK HrF�< lIDGF�VgH]Q�BwPR\W�\]@CT \%BEK D�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOlOc�PRT F{BEH�?SPRtRD�[OHR?SN�PWQI@Zl!H]T l/>*DGB��"DODGT�K2< ?�PWT3PRT�F�[GH]?��N <�BIDOQMDO?AHRBE@CH]T�QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T:�A³�@CT�PRYCYC}]c:P�[GH]?SN PRQI@ClIH]T{HRV�QIDOl!< YCBIl/VgQIH]?�>*HRBIK°BIK DSQ!D�PRY�PWT FPR[�BEDOF¦F�PWBEPAl!< N N*H]Q!BIl5H]<�Q'Ki}rN*HRBEK DGlI@Cl'BIK�PWB'QIDGlI< Y�BEl'QIDON*H]Q�BEDOF�H]T_PR[GBIDOF�F�PWBwP�?SPv}¬>aDM?S@Cl��YZDOPRF @CT \JlI@CT [OD4T H]Tr��DOYC@Z[G@CBEDGF%DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYalIN*DODG[wK_@Zl�?AH]Q!D/lI< >�BIYZDMPRT F�K�PWQIF DGQUBIHSF�DGBEDG[GBO�

s K DGlI@Zl�;=< N*DOQ�ur@ZlIHRQO´�;rBIDON K�PWT @ZDy;=DGT DGxs @CBIYZDW´n¨�QI@ZT�[O@ZN PRY�µUDOlIDOPRQI[wK¦��l!lIHr[O@�P�BED

Page 4: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf
Page 5: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� ��������� �����4�� �'���5

³�@CQIl!BOc��U?`<�l!B�BIK�PRT t�?(} ² DOPvuRDOT Y�}�³�PWBIK DOQ'VgH]Q�>�QI@ZT�\]@ZT \S?SDMBEH�BIK @Zl5NaHR@ZTiB�@CT_?(}¦YZ@�VgDR��«B@Zl�>*DO[OPR< l!DMHWV®}RH]<%BEK�PWB�"PR? PRT F�BEK�PWB���K�P�u]D4>*DODGT¦> YCDOl!lIDOF�BEH�\]Q!Hv�ªPRT�F�?SPWBI< QID/F <�QI@ZT�\?(}�D��=NaDGQI@ZDGT [ODSPWB m � s � ��H]<°F DOl!DOQ�u]D¬PWYZYnN QIPR@Zl!DAPRT F°K H]T H]QG� s K PRT t�}]HR<°VgH]Q4< l!@ZT \�BEK�DVgH]YCYZHv�U@ZT \(NaDGH]N YZD4PWl'@CT l!BIQI< ?ADOTiBIl'@CT�K DOYCN @ZT \J?AD/T�P�ur@Z\iP�BED�BEK�@ZlUN QIHr[ODGlIlG´

m }4BEK DGlI@Cl�PRF=u=@ClIH]QGc�������������������� ������� �!�:�"H]< YZFyYZ@CtRD�BEH'D��=N Q!DOlIl�?(}4K D�PWQ!BIVgDGYCB)BEK PRT t2lBEH/}RH]<SVgH]Q�>*DO@CT \/lI<�[wK%P���H]T�F DOQ�Vg< Y*PRF�ur@Zl!H]Q�PRT FA?SDGTiBEH]QG� s K Q!H]< \]K HR<�B�BEK @Cl�Q!DOl!D�PRQ![wK:c�PWT FPJT2< ?`>*DOQUHRV®H]> l!BEPR[OYCDOl�BEK PWB'lI< Q�V PR[ODGF:c }]H]<¦l!BI@ZYZYaD��=< F DGF_N�P�BE@ZDGT [ODMPRT�F¦[GH]?SN PRlIl!@ZH]T:�

m }�BEK DGlI@Cl¬PRF�ur@ClIH]QGc#"$�&%'���)(�(��*�����+���)�,�JK�PRF�BIK D¦VgH]Q�BE< T PWBED�H]N N*H]Q!BI< T @�B�}|BEH3K PvuRDB��"H�PRF�ur@Zl!H]QIl�BIH%\]@CuRD(?AD`\]< @CF�PRT [GD`PRT�F�lI< \]\RDOl!BI@ZH]T�l�H]T�K Hv�.BEH�PRN�N QIHiPW[wK�BEK @Cl�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wKN Q!H]> YZDG?¦� m @Z[wK DGYZYZDWc-�A��HR< YZF�YZ@CtRD�BEH|BIK�PRT t�}RH]< VgHRQ¬}]H]< Q�?ADOTiBEHRQIlIK�@ZN:c5l!BEQ!DOl!lI@ZT�\ BEK�D@Z?AN*H]Q!BEPRT [OD�HRV�F�H=[G< ?SDGTiBwPWBI@ZH]T:c PRT F�K DOYCN @ZT \J?AD/K2< TiB�F�H­�UT�> < \RlO�

m }zH/.A[OD�?�P�BEDOlGc�X�QIT�@ZDRc ² PRTcjPRT F�¥)PR< QEP��!�`PW? ?SHRl!BSPRN N Q!DO[G@�PWBI@Cu]D�HRV�PRYZY�HWV�BEK�DY�PW< \]K l�PRT�FAH0.S[GDUH]<�BE@CT \]lG��X�QIT @CDRc]BIK�PRT t(}RH]<�VgH]Q�}]HR< Q�F @Zl![O< l!lI@ZHRT l�H]T�F @ZD�B�PRT F�T2<�BEQ!@CBE@CH]T:�s K�PRT�t¬}]H]< ² PRT�VgH]QUPRT l���DGQI@ZT�\�?(}%@CT [ODGlIlIPRTiB�k2< DOl�BE@CH]T l5PRT F�>aDG@ZT \SPA\RQID�P�B5Q!DOl!H]< QI[GDMVgHRQ\]D�BIBE@CT \yBIK @ZT�\]l�BIHy�"H]QIt�� s K�PWT tS\RH=HrF T DGlIl"VgHRQ�¥)PR< QIPM�UK H`PRYC��P�}=l"[�PR?ADUBEK Q!H]< \]K��U@�BEK�PRTPRN N�QIH]N Q!@�PWBID/lIHr[O@ZPRYH]<=BE@ZT�\SP�V�BEDOQjBIH=H�?SPRTi}%F�P�}rlUHRV��!<�l!BU��HRQIt��

s K D5;�¥ ;`\]QIH]<�N)�qX�u]DGQ!}RH]T D'@ZT`BEK�D';�¥ ;J\RQIH]< N�F DGlIDGQ!u]DGl"BIK�PRT t2lO��;=NaDG[O@�h�[�PRYCYC}Rc1� �"H]< YCFYZ@CtRD`BIH�BIK�PRT t�^�K�PRH32�PRT�\�VgHRQ/K DOQ4@ZTiuWPRYC<�PR> YCD`PRl!lI@Zl�BwPRT�[ODAH]T{H]QI\iPWT @54G@ZT \¬?y}�BEK DGlI@ClyPWT FN*DOQ!VgHRQI?A@ZT \MD��=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiBElOc PRT F¬K DGQjD��=N*DOQ�BE@Zl!D�@ZTSBEK D/PWQID�PyHRV)N QIHRlIHrF�}]���5YZlIH�crBIH s6�² P/4GDOTVgH]Q�K @Zl�K DGYZN��U@�BEKSBIK D�DG?SHWBE@ZHRTS[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]TSPRT FSQIDO[GH]\]T @�BE@CH]TSD��=NaDGQI@Z?ADOTiBIljPRT FSVgH]Q"@CF D�PWlH]T%Q!DON*H]Q!BI@ZT \`BIK D/QIDGlI< Y�BElO� s H 6 H=D�¨�H]YC@CVgQIHRT @ c2VgH]QjK @CljK DGYZN¬�U@CBIK%F�PWBEP`[OH]YCYZDO[�BE@CH]T%PRT F%BIQEPRT=�lI[GQI@CN�BE@CH]T:� 6 HRT7��@ c�84PRQIDGT:crPRT F m @ZT�VgH]Q�>*DO@CT \yQ!DON*H]lI@�BEH]Q!@ZDGl�HRV@CT�VgH]Q!?�PWBI@ZH]T(H]TSD�u]DGQ!}2BEK @CT \VgQIHR? < T F DGQIl!BEPRT F @CT \(BIK D:9 ;=<�;?> ¤ l!}rl!BIDO?0BIHyh�T�F @ZT \MBEK D'>*DOl!B�QIDGl!BwPW< QEPRTiBIlO�@�n��HR< YZF�PRYZl!HYZ@CtRD�BEH�BEK PRT tyPRYZYrHRV�BEK D�N QIDGlIDOTiB"PRT FJl!DGuRDOQEPWY�N�PRl!Bn?SDG?`>aDGQIlnHWVa;�¥ ;`VgHRQ�?SPRt2@ZT \'BEK @Cln\]QIHR< NP`Vg< T:c�YCD�PRQ!T @ZT \JDGTiu=@CQIH]T�?SDGT2B5PRT�F�VgH]Qj}RH]< QUDOT�[OH]< QIPR\]DG?SDGT2B'@CT�h T @Zl!K @ZT \JBIK @ZljBIK DOl!@ZlO�

s H�BEK DBA/QEPWF <�PWBID¦X�F < [OPWBE@CH]T�VgH]Q m @CT H]QI@�BE@CDOlDCEA/X mBF ^�H]T l!H]Q!BI@Z< ?G�,2�H]Q!F lS[OPRT T HWBD��=N Q!DOl!lAK�H­� BIQI< Y�}3\]QIPWBED�Vg< YH�yPW?§BIH�K�P�u]D%>*DODGT�h�T�PRT [GDOF�>i}3}RH]<|F < Q!@ZT \�?y}�h�Q!l!B`B��"H}]DOPRQIlMPWB m � s �I��H]< Q�h�T PRT [O@ZPRYnPWT F{DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY lI< N�NaH]Q�BMPRYZYCHv��DGF�?SD(BIK DJH]N N*H]Q�BE< T @�B�}¦BIH

Page 6: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

F D�u]DOYCH]N�BEK D/l!tr@CYZYCljPRT F�[GH]T�h�F DGT [ODMT DGDOF DGF�BIHA\RDGB�BEK�QIH]< \RK�?y}�N Q!H]\]QIPR?¦��;=NaDG[O@ZPRYBEK PRT t2lBEH�³�H]Q!DOl�BE@ZT�D�©�YZPRtRDWc=�UK H�>*DOYZ@CDGuRDOF%@ZT�?(}�\RHiPRYZl�PRT F%?SPR\]@C[�PRYCYC}(VgHR< T F%?AH]T DG}A�UK DGT�BIK DOQ!D��PRl5T�H]T DR�

s H ¯ T @�u]DGQIlI@�B�}�VgQI@CDOT F l �!�A�U@ZYZY�PRYC��P�}=l�K�P�u]D3Pzl!NaDG[O@ZPRY/N Y�PW[OD{@ZT�?(}�K DOPRQ!B�VgH]Q%BEK�Dl!BEPWx{@ZT%BIK D A4QIPRF <�PWBIDy;rBE< F�DOTiBEl�� .S[GDR� s K�PRT t¬}RH]<�L�DOPRT¦^�H]YZ>*DOQ�B�c�L�DOPRT¦;rBwPWBIH]T:c�L�DOPRT^�K�PRQ!YZDGlOc2©�Q!@Z?SP�cRX�F:c A/DOH]Q!\]D�PRT F ² D�PWBIK DOQnVgH]Q®BEK Dj�"H]QIF�l�HWVaDGT [OHR< QEPR\RDO?ADOTiB�crPRF�ur@C[ODRc2PWT FHr[O[�PWlI@ZHRT�PRY:[wK�PWl!BE@ClI@CT \�lIH�BEK�PWB�"[OH]< YCF%h�T @Zl!K¦<�N�BIK @ZlUF DG\]QIDGDR�H���"H]< YCF_PRYClIH�YZ@CtRD�BIH�BIK�PRT tBEK�D��'^ m X \]QIHR< N3VgH]Q4}]H]<�Q`K DOYCN��U@�BEK�BIQIH]<�> YZDGlIK HrHRBE@CT \�N QIH]>�YZDO?AlyPRT F3VgH]QyN QIHvur@ZF�@ZT \¦Pl!BIQI< [�BE< Q!D�VgH]Q�[OH]?AN YCDGBE@CT \M\]HiPRYClO� ��T¬PRF F @�BE@ZHRT:c��n��H]<�YZF�YC@ZtWD'BIH(BEK�PWT t�X�Q!@Z[5©��2VgH]Q"K�@Zl�YCHvu]DRclI<�N NaHRQ!B�c�PWT F�VgHRQ�lIK�PRQ!@ZT \�K @CljBEDGl!BE@C?SHRT2}�lIH�BEK�P�B��[OHR< YZF�>*DOYZ@CDGuRDR�

s H|?y}�[wK2< Q![wK�V PR?A@ZY�}1� s K�PRT�t�}]H]<�BIH|PRYZY'HRV/BIK D�lEPR@CTiBElOcUDGlIN*DO[O@ZPRYZY�} PWB%©�YC< D ² @ZYCY c�UK H%N QIP�}]DOF�VgHRQ�?AD`PRT F_DOT [GH]< QEPW\]DOF�?AD(F <�QI@ZT�\SBEK�@Zl5BI@Z?ADR�'�5V�BIDOQ�\RH]@ZT \ABEK Q!H]< \]K_?�PRTi}l!BIH]QI?AlOc �"T Hv� QIDG[OH]\]T�@54OD�BIK�PWBU?(}�>�PWB!BEYZDGlUPRQID�lIN @CQI@CBI<�PRYaH]T DOlG�@���U@CYZYaVgHRQIDGuRDOQ�>*D/@ZT F�DO>�BIDOFBEH�D�u]DOQ�}]H]T�Dy�UK HAN QEP�}RDOF¦VgHRQ�?SD��UK DGT ���jPRl!T�� B�@CT�PAN*H]lI@�BE@CH]T�BEHAN QIPv}�VgH]Q�?(}rlIDGYCV �

s H�?(}_> @ZH]YCH]\]@C[�PRY)V PR?A@ZYC}1�,����HR< YZF°YZ@CtRD(BIH�BIK�PRT t_?(}�?AH]? VgHRQ/lEPR[GQI@Ch [O@ZT�\�l!H�?`< [wKlIH�BEK PWB�"[GH]< YCF�K PvuRDy?AH]Q!DR��X�u]DGT¦�U@CBIK%}]H]< QUk2< @CDGBUF @ClIN*H]lI@�BE@ZHRT:c �"lIDOD4l!HS?`<�[wK¦HRV }]HR<¦@CT?ADR����PR? ?SHRl!B'\]QEP�BEDGVg<�Y)VgHRQUBIK DMkr< PRYZ@�BE@ZDGl�HRV�F @CYZ@C\]DOT [GD4PRT F¦QIDOl!@ZYC@ZDOT�[OD/BEK�P�B'}RH]<_@CT l!BI@ZYCYZDOF@ZTA?ADUBIK QIHR< \]KS}RH]< Q�D���PR?AN YZDW� ��PR? PWYZlIHM\]QIPWBED�Vg< Y BEHM?(}APR< TiBIlOc�\RQEPRT Ti}Rc=F�PWF:crPRT F�l!@Zl�BEDOQ!l�UK HA[OH]T�l!BwPWT2BIYC}%DGT [OHR< QEPR\RDOF�?SD4F < Q!@ZT \`BIK @ZlUQ!DOlIDOPRQI[wK�

s H�VgQI@CDOT F�l ��¥�@ClIK�P�c 6 PR?S@�c�;=K�PWT F�P�c�³�QIDGF:c�PRT F�BEK�DM?ADO?(>aDGQIlUHRV�©#Ay;r�(c �"BIK�PRT t A/HrFVgH]Q ² @Zl�BE@C?S@CT \4@ZT%PRYCYZHv�U@ZT�\yH]<�Q�N�PWBIK l�BIH`[OQ!H]lIlG��X"PW[wK%HRV�}]H]<%K PRljF D�h�T @CBIDOY�}�PWF F DOF¬BIH`?(}YZ@�VgDR�

��[GH]T [OYC< F D/>i}%\]@�ur@ZT \`BIK�PRT t2l�BEH�?(}¬¥)HRQIF�PRT F¦;�P�ur@ZH]QGc 6 DOl!< l5^�K QI@Cl!BO� ² D/@ZljBIQI< Y�}�BEK�DPR<�BIK H]Q�PWT F`h�T @ClIK DGQ�HRV*?(}yV PW@CBEK����BEK PRT ty}RH]<JVgH]QnYCH­ur@CT \�?ADjlIH4?`<�[wK3C�F DGlIN @�BED�K Hv� ?�PRTi}BE@C?SDGl@��V PRYZY�lIK H]Q�B F BEK�P�B"}RH]<�\iP�uRD5}]HR< Q"YC@CVgDjVgH]Q�?ADR� s K�QIH]< \RK H]<�B�BEK @Cl"D��=NaDGQI@ZDGT [ODWc �®[OH]< YCFVgDODGY�}]HR< Q/N QIDGlIDGT [ODW� �5N QIP�}_BEK PWB/?(}_D��=NaDGQI@CDOT [GD��U@CYZY >aD�P�BIDOl�BwPR?ADOTiB/BEH%HWBEK DGQIl/HRV�}]HR< QP���DGlIH]?ADMNaHv�"DOQO�

s K @Cl�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK`��PRl�l!< N N*H]Q!BIDOFJ>i}yL'��µ'¨a��< T�F DOQ®[OH]TiBEQIPR[GB�T2< ?`>*DOQ��5©�^ ² ��eidRe]e]e]d=cW?AH]T=�@CBIH]QIDGFABIK QIHR< \]K�BEK D'L�DON PRQ!BI?SDGT2B�HRVaBEK D��TiBEDGQI@ZHRQOc���PWBI@ZH]T PRY�©�< l!@ZT DGlIl�^�DOTiBEDGQOc=��[Ok2< @ClI@�BE@ZHRT;=DGQ!ur@Z[GDOl5L�@Cur@Zl!@ZH]T:c=³�H]Q!B ² <�PR[wK2< [OP�c�����

Page 7: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

������������� ����������������������������������� �!���"�#����#$%�����&���'�(���&��)+*,�-�����./��0

132547698�:;=<�:>4-?�;

Page 8: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

Page 9: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� �����������

� � ���� �������%/����� � ����]��� ©jPR[wt2\]Q!H]< T F �M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� ����]� d ¨�QIDGur@CH]< l#23HRQIt �y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� � �

�]� d=�C� µUDOl!D�PRQ![wK_�5N N QIH]PR[wK DOlz�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� dRe�]� d=� d L/P�BwP�^�H]YCYZDO[�BE@CH]T s DG[wK T @Ckr<�DOl �M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� d=��]� d=� f L�@ClI[G< lIl!@ZH]T �4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� d]d

�]� f ��>r�!DO[�BE@CuRD �y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� dRf�]��� ��<�BEYC@ZT D5�y�M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� d��

� � � �@�! ��" ���I����("$���������#� (��%$'& �%�d=��� ^�H]QIN*H]QIP �M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� d)(

d=���]�C� m DOQI[G< Q!}�L/P�BwPq�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� d*�d=���]� d ¥�Hr[wt2K DODGF�L/PWBEP �M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� d �

d=���]� f ¥)L4^�¨�QIH]l!H=F�}¦^�HRQIN < lM�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� d)+d=���]�,� ^�HRQIN < lU¨�QIHRNaDGQ!BE@CDOl'�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f]ed=���]� b s QEPWT lI[GQI@ZN=BE@ZHRT l��y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f��

d=� d ¨�QIH]l!H=F�} �M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f��d=� d=�C� ¨�@�BE[wK¦L�DGBEDG[GBI@ZH]T �M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f]f

d=� f m DGBIK HrF l��M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� fibd=��� ;r}rl!BIDO? �y�M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f*(d=� b s PWlIt2l��M�y�M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f*(

d=� b=�C� ³�DOPWBE< Q!D/Xn�=BIQEPR[�BE@CH]T �M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f*(d=� b=� d X�uWPRYC<�PWBE@CH]T��4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f!�

d=�,( ;=< ?A?�PWQ!} �y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f!�- . ��� (�&�/ �0/1�%2����@���)% �43 �5 ��� ����� �6/7�#��� ��� � "�� � �0� � -%8

f���� 9�@ClI<�PRYI��T lIN*DO[�BE@ZHRT �4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� �ief����]�C� ¥�@CT \]< @Cl!BE@C[���T PRYC}rlI@Cl0�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� � �f����]� d ;rNaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPRN K @C[/��T�PRY�}rlI@Zl �M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� �iff����]� f ¨�Q!H]lIHrF @Z[/�5T�PRY�}=l!@Zl��y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� �:�f����]�,� ³�DOPWBE< Q!D/Xn�=BIQEPR[�BE@CH]T �M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b=�f����]� b 9�Hv�"DOY±��YZD�u]DGY)³�DOPWBE<�QIDOl �M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b=�f����]�;( ¯ BIBIDOQEPWT [OD���YZD�u]DGY®³�DOPWBE< Q!DOl��M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b]b

f�� d ^�Y�PRl!lI@�h�[�PWBI@ZH]T%Xn�=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiBEl �M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b)(f�� d=�C� X�?AHRBE@CH]T�^�Y�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRT �y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b)(

+

Page 10: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

f�� d=� d s QEPW@ZT @CT \�PRT F s DOl!BI@ZT \�^�H]T F�@CBE@CH]T l'�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b*�f�� d=� f µUDOl!< YCBIl��M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b*�

f�� f µ �4^�¨�YZHWBEljVgH]Q��5[GBEDGF_L/P�BwP �M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b)+f���� ;=< ?A?�PWQ!} �y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (��

� � ��" �����@�0/ �������! ��� � ����� / � -� ��� Xn��N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBwPWY);=DGBI< N|�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (]f� � d µ'DGlI< Y�BEly�y�M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (ib

� � � ��%1(��6/ �0� � ���

b=��� ³�<�BE< Q!D�23HRQIt_�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� ( �

. � �% '� �6/� 0�����5 � ����� � � 8 ��� (����%$' 0� � � & � �

�ve

Page 11: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � � ��� � ����� �

�G�w� ;=N*DO[GBIQIH]\RQEPR?AljHRV)BEK�QIDOD4<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOl��U@CBIK¬BEK D/lIPR?AD/YZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[5[GH]TiBEDOTiB'> <�BF @CxaDOQ!DOTiB�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY:l�BwPWBIDOl�VgH]QUBEK�D(N K QIPRlID��VgDO> Q!<�PRQ�}�B��"DOTiB�}_lI@��rBIK �¬lIN*HW�tRDGT°>i}_PSVgDO?SPRYCD(lIN*D�PWtRDOQG� s K D`F @�xDGQIDOT�[ODOl/@CT_BEK�D`T DO<=BEQEPWY�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD3C P FPRT F�BIK D�K�@Z\]K Y�}`VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF%<�BIBIDOQIPRT [OD C�[ F lI<�N N YC}�Py\RQID�P�B�F DOPRYHWV�@ZT�VgHRQI?SP��BE@CH]T:� s K D�VgQI< l�BEQEP�BEDOFA<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD'@CYZYC< l!BIQEPWBIDOlnPWTA@CT [OQ!D�PRl!DU@ZTJDOT�DOQI\W}APRT FJBEK DF < QIPWBE@CH]T%HRV u]Hv��DGYZl5PRT F�@ZTiBEDGQIT�PWY�N�PR< l!DOlO���y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� � +

d­�w� Xn� PW?SN YCD�F @�PRYCH]\]< D`VgQ!H]?�BEK�D�¥�Hr[wtrK�DODOF|[GH]QIN�< lO� s K @ClyF�@�PRYCH]\]< DJ@CT [OYC< F DOlQIDGNaDOPWB°<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGl�BEK PWB���DGQID Y�PWBIDOQ�< l!DOF BIH @CTiu]DOl�BE@C\iPWBEDzPR[GH]< l�BE@Z[zPRT�FN QIHRlIHrF @Z[/[G< DOl'@ZT%DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYl!NaDGDO[wK:� �y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f]e

d­��d C P F ��P�u]DGVgHRQI?�c�C�> F �U@CF D��«>�PRT F lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?�c-C�[ F T�PRQ!QIHv�j��> PRT FzlIN*DO[GBIQIHW�\]QEPW? @ZTAYZH]\]PRQI@�BEK ?A@Z[�VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}Al![�PRYCD'�U@�BEKAN @CBI[wKSD��=BIQEPR[�BEDGF¬< lI@CT \(^�¨"LU�(cC�F F N K�H]T DGBI@Z[zPRYC@Z\]T ?ADOTiBOc`PRT F C�D F �"H]Q!F PRYC@Z\]T�?SDGT2B_VgH]Q�BEK D�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD�����������C N QIH]T�H]< T [GDOF��W?��j\���F ��V�� F ��!#"%$#& �'�AlIN*H]tRDGT_>i}�P`VgDO?SPRYZD/l!NaDOPRtRDGQO��f)�

d­� f ³�< T F�PR?ADOTiBEPRY�VgQIDGk2< DOT [�}A[OH]TiBEHR< QIl�HRVBIK DU<�BIBIDOQIPRT [OD�)( " � "+* �4lIN*H]tRDGTSBIK QIDGDBE@C?SDGlOc)lIDGkr<�DOTiBE@ZPRYZY�}�>i}°P¦?SPRYZDJl!NaDOPRtRDGQO� s K D,��-.��HRV%)( " � "+* ��>aDG\]@ZT lyPWBPR>*H]<�B'e�� d`lIDO[GH]T F lG� �M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� fib

f��w� ;=N*DO[GBIQIH]\RQEPR?Al(HRV�BIK D¬<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD/!l![OQEP�BE[wK|BEK�P�B0�_VgH]QyF @CxaDOQ!DOTiBJDG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYl!BEPWBEDGlJlIN*H]tRDGT >i}|P_VgDG?�PWYZD�l!NaDOPRtRDGQ�@ZT3BIK D�¥�H=[wt2K DGDOFz[OH]Q!N < lO�3©�DO[OPR< l!DlIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR? C > F ��PRl/P�Q!DON*D�PWB�HRVC P F ca�U@�BEK_BIK D(lIPR?SDyYZ@CT \]< @Cl!BE@C[4[OH]TiBEDGTiB> <�B�F�@CxaDOQI@CT \`DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�l!BwP�BEDOlGc�BEK�@Zl�PRYCYZHv�"DOF�PRT�PRT PRYC}rlI@Cl�HRV)uWPRQ!@�PWBI@ZH]T l�@ZTN QIHRlIHrF @Z[�VgDOPWBE< Q!DOlU[�PW< lIDGF_>i}%DO?AHRBI@ZH]T:� �4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� �*�

f���d ;=N*DO[GBIQIH]\RQEPR?Al�@CYZYZ<�l!BEQIPWBE@CT \AF @CxaDOQ!DOT [GDOl/>*DGB��"DODOT�P�T HRQI?SPRY®N�QIH]T2< T [G@�PWBI@ZH]TC P F PRT F4Ki}=N*DOQIPRQ!BI@Z[G< Y�PWBIDOF/N Q!H]T2< T [G@�PWBI@ZH]T7C > F HRV2BEK Dn�"H]Q!F1!T�DG��PRQIt��2�{;=N*DO[��BEQ!H]\]QEPW? C�[ F lIK Hv�Ul"PMT HRQI?SPRY�N Q!H]T2< T [G@�PWBI@ZH]T�HRVaBEK D��"H]QIF3!T D���}]H]Q!t4�(PRT�F@Zl�N Q!DOl!DOTiBEDGF_VgH]Q�[OHR?SN�PWQI@Zl!H]T:�q�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� �!(

f�� f C P F ��P�u]DGVgHRQI?�c�C�> F �U@CF D��«>�PRT F lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?�c-C�[ F T�PRQ!QIHv�j��> PRT FzlIN*DO[GBIQIHW�\]QEPW? @ZT(YCH]\iPRQ!@CBIK ?S@C[®VgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}`l![�PRYCD��U@�BEKyD��rBEQIPR[GBIDOFJN @�BE[wK:c C�F F lI?AH=HRBIK DOFN @CBI[wK_[GH]TiBEH]< QGc C D F DGT DOQ!\R}]c C V F N�K H]T D�BE@Z[(PRYZ@C\]T ?ADOTiB�c�PWT F C�\ F �"H]QIF�PWYZ@Z\RT=�?SDGTiB�VgH]QjBEK D4<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD165)7 * �8�97+:;�<:=�8���2���4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� �:�

f�� � ³�< T F�PR?ADOTiBEPRY�VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}�[OHRT2BIH]< Q!l`HRVjBIK DS<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[OD/+�<> $?$#@A" 5CBEDGF "+*0$ �lIN*H]tRDGT�BIK QIDGD�BE@C?SDGl¬>i}�P�VgDO?SPRYZD¦lIN*D�PRtWDOQG� s K D�VgQI< l�BEQIPWBEDGF�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODRc<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODOf�c�@Zl�l!@Z\]T�@Ch�[OPRTiBEYC}�YZH]T�\]DOQ�BIK�PRT�BEK D4N Q!DGur@ZHR< lU<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGlO���y�M�M� � �

�]�

Page 12: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

f���b s ��HMlIDGN�PRQIPWBED'lID�BEl�HRVaVg<�T F�PR?ADOTiBwPWY VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}A[GH]TiBEH]< Q!l�VgHRQnBEK DU<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD�B��"H_H]T D�h uRD¬lI@±� ��@ZT°BEK DS¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF�[GH]QIN�< lO� s K DGQIDS��PRlyT H_H]>�lIDOQ�uWPR> YZDN�PWB!BEDOQ!T¬VgH]Q"BIK D�Vg< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRY�VgQIDGk2< DOT [�}%HRV P(VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF%DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY*l�BwPWBIDR���T [GH]TiBEH]<�Q C�P F c'BEK D{l!NaDOPRtRDGQ¦F HrDOl�T HWB¦K�D�P�ur@ZYC}�QIDGYC}�H]T ��� BEH�D���N�QIDOl!lVgQI< l�BEQIPWBE@CH]T:� s K D%l!NaDOPRtRDGQ�@ZT,C > F YZHv�"DOQ!lJK @ZlMVg< T F�PR?ADOTiBEPRY"VgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}|BEHD��=N Q!DOlIlUVgQI<�l!BEQIPWBE@CH]T:�{�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� bRe

f�� ( ³�H]< Qnl!DON�PRQIPWBED�l!DGBIl�HWVaVg< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRYrVgQIDGkr<�DOT [�}�[OH]TiBEHR< QIl�VgH]Q�BIK D�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD�B��"HSBEK�H]< lEPWT F¦BIDOT �A@ZT�BEK Dy¥)L4^�[GH]QIN <�lO� ¯ T YZ@CtRD/BEK DMQIDOPRY�F�PWBEP�c�BEK DGQIDM@ZlPSl!@Z\]T @�h�[�PWT2B5F @�xDGQIDOT�[OD(@CT�BIK DyVgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�PWT F�T DG<�BEQIPRY®DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY:l�BwPWBIDOlOc�U@CBIK�BIK DMVgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF¦l!BwP�BEDM< lI<�PWYZYC}¬>aDG@ZT \AK @Z\RK DOQG�U^�H]TiBEH]<�QIl C P F c�C > F c*PRT�FC�F F PRYClIH4lIK�H­��BIK�PWB�BEK�D'<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[OD'F < QEP�BE@ZHRTS@CT [OQ!D�PRl!DOl�VgH]Q�VgQI< l�BEQEP�BEDOFADO?AHW�BE@CH]T:���M�y�M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b]d

f�� � s ��HMlIDGN�PRQIPWBED'lID�BEl�HRVaVg<�T F�PR?ADOTiBwPWY VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}A[GH]TiBEH]< Q!l�VgHRQnBEK DU<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD!DO@C\]KiB4K2< T F Q!DOF�H]T�D)��@ZT{BEK DS¥)L4^ [OHRQIN < lG�%^�H]TiBIH]< QIl�C P F PWT F C > F lIK Hv�PRT_D��rBEQIDG?SDyF @CxaDOQ!DOT [GD(@CT ��� >aD�B���DGDOT{T DG<�BEQIPRY�PWT F¦VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYl!BEPWBEDGlO���y�M�y�M�M�y�4�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� bRf

f�� � ��YZYC< l!BIQEPWBI@ZH]TSHRV)BEK D�uRH­�"DOY±��YCDGu]DGY:N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[5VgD�PWBI< QIDGlO� s K D4N QIHRlIHrF @Z['VgD�PWBI< QIDGlBEK�P�B�PRQID_K @Z\]K�YZ@Z\RK2BIDOF�PWQID C!� F ?�P­��@C?`< ? N @�BE[wK:c C«d F PvuRDOQIPR\]D{N @CBI[wK:c C f FN @CBI[wK�lIYZHRNaDWc�PRT F C � F uRHv��DGY®F <�QEPWBI@ZH]T:�J�M�4�y�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b��

f�� + µ �4^ [O<�Q!u]D°VgH]Q%BEK D�¥)L4^ F�PWBEP�� s K�@Zl�[O< Q�u]D���PRl�N QIHrF < [GDOFª>i}�BIK QIDGD@ZT F�@Cur@ZF < PRY N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[UVgD�P�BE< Q!DOljPWT F�>i}SPMVg< YCY�� BEQEPW@ZT DGFJ?SHrF DOY�<�lI@ZT�\yBEK�D�>*DOl!BB���HAF @ClI[OQ!@Z?A@ZT�P�BE@ZT�\yVgD�P�BE< Q!DOlU?�P­� N�@CBE[wK¦PRT F�P�ur\ DOT DGQI\R}R� �M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (��

�W�w� ��TiBEDOQ�V PR[OD/VgH]Q ² < ?SPRT=� ¥�@Cl!BEDGT DOQ�Xn�=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiB�� �M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� ()�

�­d

Page 13: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � � ��� � ��� � �

d=��� ¥�@Zl!B�HRV�[OHRQIN*H]QEP�<�lIDOF�F <�QI@ZT�\�BEK @Cl�Q!DOlIDOPRQI[wK� s K D �� �¡:¢£)¡2¤ PRT�F�¥)Hr[wt2K DODGF[OH]Q!NaHRQEPy�"DOQ!D/?�PRT2<�PWYZYC}`[OQIDOPWBEDGF�PRT F¬<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOlj�"DOQ!D�BwPR\]\RDOF%>i}¬PylI@ZT�\]YZD@ZT F�@Cur@ZF < PRYaVgH]QjBIK DMPRN N Q!H]N Q!@�PWBID�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYal!BEPWBEDW�S�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� f��

d=� d ¨�K H]T D�BE@Z[¦Y�PR>*DOYClAVgHRQ���?ADOQ!@Z[OPRT�X�T \]YC@Zl!K:� s K D �@� �@��(M[OH]YC< ?ST YZ@Cl!BElABEK DY�PR>*DOYCly<�lIDOF�@CTz;�¥ ;ac®�U@�BEK�BEK�D¬[OH]Q!QIDGlIN*H]T F @CT \ ��¨� YZPR>*DOY�@ZT|N�PRQ!DOTiBEK�DOlIDGl�UK DOT¬BIK DG}AF @�xDGQO� s K�D .�� � . �@���5[OH]YC< ?ATSYC@Zl!BIl�BIK D�DGk2< @CuWPRYCDOTiBjYZPR>aDGYZl�@ZTBEK D4��µ'¨a��>*DGB'�/; ^�� ��N K�H]T DGBI@Z[MPRYCN K�PR>*DGBO�§�M�M�y�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� fid

f���� Xn� PW?SN YCD¦HWVMP°VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF�F @�PWYZH]\]<�D�@CT BIK D��  �¡¢£)¡r¤ @C\]KiB�BEQIP�u]DOY5F HW�?�PW@ZT:� s K�@Zl`F @ZPRYZHR\]< DA@ZT [GYZ< F DGl`YZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[JVgD�PWBI< QIDGl`BEK�P�B`��DGQID%K DGYZN�Vg<�Y�@ZTF DGBIDOQ!?S@CT @ZT \JN�QIH]?A@Zl!@ZT \(VgDOPWBE<�QIDOl�VgH]Q�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT%[OY�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRT:�J�4�y�M�y�M�M� �if

f�� d Xn� PW?SN YCD¬HRV'D��rBIQEPR[�BEDOF�u]Hv�"DOY±��YZD�u]DGY�VgD�PWBI< QIDGlJVgH]QJP_u]Hv�"DOY�l!DO\]?ADOTiBA@ZT|PWT<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODW� s K DGlID�N�PRQ�BE@C[O< YZPRQ5uWPRYC< DOl/PWQID(VgH]Q5BEK D`VgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}�[GH]TiBEH]< Q/N�YZHRB@ZT�³�@C\]< QID�f�� � � µUHv� d|[OH]Q!QIDGlIN*H]T F l�BEH|BEK�D°K�@Z\]K YC@Z\]KiBIDOF�u]Hv�"DOY�c��UK DOQ!D[OH]YC< ?AT l/�]c�d=c f�c�PRT F¦bJQIDON�QIDOl!DOTiB'BEK D/uWPRYZ<�DOlUHRV BEK D4@ZYCYZ< l�BEQIPWBEDGF�VgD�PWBI< QIDGlO� b]b

f�� f ¨�DGQ!VgH]Q!?�PRT�[OD�QIDGlI< Y�BEl�@ZTJ[GQIH]l!l�uRPWYZ@ZF PWBE@CH]T(D���N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBEl�VgH]Q�¥�Hr[wt2K DODGFSF�P�BwP����T YC}Jb4HRV*BEK�DM�vd4l!NaDOPRtRDGQIl���DGQID�Q!DON*H]Q!BIDOFAlI@CT [OD�BEK�D'Q!DO?SPR@ZT�@ZT \ ��lIN*D�PWtRDOQ!lK�PRF%VgDG�"DOQUBEK PRT���e���HRV BEK�DO@ZQjBIHRBwPWY:<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl�PWl'DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY � �y�M�y�M�M� b �

f���� ¨�DGQ!VgH]Q!?�PRT�[OD�Q!DOlI<�YCBEl�H]T�[OQ!H]lIl¬uWPRYC@ZF�PWBI@ZH]TzD��=N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBEl¬VgH]Q�PR[GBIDOF�F�P�BwP����u]DOQIPRYZY�c"BIK DOl!D_QIDGlI< Y�BEl�PRQID�[OH]T�lI@Zl�BEDGT2BS�U@CBIK HRBIK DOQSN < > YC@Zl!K DOF QIDOl!< YCBIlSHRTDO?AHRBE@CH]T:� s K�D4VgDG?�PWYZD�l!NaDOPRtRDGQIl�PWQID/\]\ cW�!\�c ?St�c�PWT F¦?A?��0�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� b)+

� ��� µ'DGlI< Y�BEl�VgQIHR? \]Q!H]< N{�yHWV�K2< ?SPRT=�«YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQjl�BE< F=}]�ª�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (ib� � d µ'DGlI< Y�BEl�VgQIHR? \]Q!H]< N¦d�HWV�K2< ?SPRT=�«YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQjl�BE< F=}]�ª�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (ib� � f µ'DGlI< Y�BEl�VgQIHR? \]Q!H]< N�fAHWV�K2< ?SPRT=�«YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQjl�BE< F=}]�ª�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (*(� ��� µ'DGlI< Y�BEl�VgQIHR? \]Q!H]< N �SHWV�K2< ?SPRT=�«YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQjl�BE< F=}]�ª�M�y�M�M�y�M�4�y�M�y�M�M� (*(

�vf

Page 14: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

���

Page 15: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � ��� ��� �

� ��� ��� � � � � ���

s K D4lI<�[O[ODGlIl'HRV®PJlIN*DODO[wK�QIDG[OH]\RT @54GDOQ�F DGNaDGT F l'?�PR@CT YC}�HRT�B��"HJV PR[GBIH]QIl ��PR[G[O< QIPR[G}%PRT F�QIHW�> < l�BET DGlIlG� s K�PWB�@ZlOc*@ZT¦H]QIF�DOQ5BIH¬N*DOQ!VgHRQI? PRT�@CTiBEDOT�F DOF�BEPRlIt�cl!NaDGDO[wK�Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T�l!}rl�BEDO?Al?`< l�B�>*D�PW> YZDUBEH(PR[wK @ZD�u]D5YZHv��DOQ!QIH]Q�QEP�BEDOl�PRT FABEK DGT¬?�PW@ZTiBwPR@CTJBEK DG?�<�T F DOQ�uWPRQ!}r@ZT�\([OHRT F @��BE@CH]T lG� ² Hv�"DGuRDOQOc2uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T l®PR?AH]T \�l!NaDOPRtRDGQIl�HRV�BEDGTJNaH]l!D�N QIHR> YZDG?Sl VgH]QnlIN*DODG[wKSQ!DO[GH]\]T @ 4ODOQ!lPRT F�?SPRtRD/@�BUF @ .A[O<�YCB�BEH�?SPR@ZTiBEPR@ZT¬YCHv� DGQIQIHRQ'QIPWBEDGlO�9�PRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T l�@ZT�PRT¬@CT F @Cur@CF <�PRY � l�l!NaDOPRt2@ZT \`l�B�}rYZD�PWT F¬DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�l!BwP�BED�?SP�}SPRYZl!HyF DG\]QEPWF D

QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T�N*DOQ�VgH]QI?SPRT [GDR�MXn� PW\]\]DOQIPWBEDGF{N QIH]T2< T�[O@�P�BE@ZHRT�HRV�lIN*DO[G@Ch�[JN K�H]T DOl4H]Q�l!}rYZYZPR> YZDGlOcPRYClIH�trT�H­�UT3PRlMK2}rN*DOQIPRQ!BI@Z[O<�Y�PWBI@ZH]T:c)K�PWly>*DODGT�P%BEH]N @C[�HRVjl�BE< F�}�PRl4@�ByQ!DOYZPWBEDGl4BIH_DG?SHRBI@ZH]T���O� � ��V�BIDOT�< l!DOQ!l`�UK H{PRQID�T HRB`<�T F DOQ!l!BIH=HrF|>i}|P_F @ZPRYZHR\]< DAl!}rl!BIDO? BIDOT F�BIH�Ki}=N*DOQIPRQ!BI@Z[��< YZPWBEDy?S@ClIQIDG[OH]\RT @54GDOF_�"H]QIF�l/H]Q�N K QIPRlIDGlOc�< l!<�PRYCYC}�YZDOPRF @ZT�\SBEH¬Vg<�Q!BEK�DOQ�?A@Zl!QIDO[GH]\]T @�BE@CH]T_PWT FVgQI<�l!BEQIPWBE@CH]T:�

��T|H]QIF�DOQyBIH�> < @CYZF�F @�PRYCH]\]< DAl!}rl�BEDO?Al`BEK PWBJPRQ!D�Q!H]> < l�B`BEH�l!NaDOPRt2@ZT \_l!B�}rYZD�uWPRQ!@�PWBI@ZH]T�lOcQIDGlIDOPRQI[wK{H]T�l!NaDGDO[wK�PRT F�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT_>*DO[OHR?SDGl/PRT�@C?SN*H]Q!BEPRTiB5BIH]N @C[yHRV�l�BE< F=}]�:2q@CBIK¦BEK�D`@ZT=�VgH]Q!?�PWBI@ZH]T�\]YCD�PRT�DOFSVgQ!H]? QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK%H]TSDO?AHRBE@CH]T:ciF @ZPRYZHR\]< DUl!}rl!BIDO?Al�[GH]< YZF�PRlIl!@Zl�B"VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF< l!DOQIl�>i}`HWxDGQI@ZT�\/P/QIDOl!NaHRT lIDjBIK�PWB�\]< @CF DOl®BEK D�< l!DOQnBIH/lIN*D�PRtyT DO<�BIQEPRYCYC}ylIH�BIK�PWB�BEK�DjF DOl!@ZQ!DOFBwPWlIt4[�PRT(>aD�PW[wK @ZD�u]DOFc]lI< \R\]DOl�BE@ZT�\/PRTJPRY�BEDGQIT�PWBI@CuRD"?AH=F�D�VgH]Q DOTiBIDOQI@CT \�F�P�BwP�cWH]Q®BIQEPRT l�VgDOQ!QI@ZT�\BEK�DA<�lIDOQ/BIH¦P%K2< ?SPRT{H]N*DOQEP�BEH]QG� s K D�Y�PWB!BEDGQ���HR< YZF{>*DAD��rBEQIDG?SDGYC}�PRF�uWPRTiBwPR\RDOH]< l/�U@�BEK @CT[�PWYZY�[GDOTiBEDGQIl��UK DOQ!D'P4l�}rl!BEDG? � l�QIDOl!NaHRT lIDU[OHR< YZF�?AD�PRT`BIK DUF @CxaDOQ!DOT [GD�>aD�B���DGDOT�?SPR@CT2BEPR@ZT�@ZT \PRT F�YZHRlI@ZT�\�P�[G< l!BIH]?ADOQO�

s K @Zl�BIK DOl!@Zl��U@CYZY�@CF DOTiBI@CV�}¦[wK�PRQEPW[GBEDGQI@Cl!BE@C[Ol�HWV�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY®l!NaDGDO[wK�PRT F{N Q!H]NaHRlID�P¬lID�B4HRV

�­b

Page 16: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl5VgHRQ5?SP��=@Z?`<�? F @Zl![OQI@C?S@CT�PR> @CYZ@�B�}]c=�U@�BEK�BEK Dy\]HiPRY)HRV�@CT [OHRQIN*H]QEPWBI@ZT \JBIK DOl!D(VgD�PWBI< QIDGl@ZTiBIH_P�F @�PRYCH]\]< DJl�}rl!BEDG?¦� s K�@ZlMH]>r�!DO[�BE@�u]DS�U@CYZYn>*DAN < QIl!< DOF|>i}�ur@Zl!<�PRYCYC}�@CT lIN*DO[�BE@ZT�\¦DG?SHW�BE@CH]T�PRY*lIN*DODG[wK¦<�lI@ZT�\JlIN*DO[GBIQIH]\RQEPR?Al�PRT F%N�QIH]l!H=F�}i�«>�PRlIDGF%BEHrH]YZlGc=[GH]?SN�<�BE@CT \`?AD�PRl!< QIDG?SDGT2BIlVgH]Q�H]> l!DOQ!uRDOF%N Ki}rlI@C[�PRY�VgD�P�BE< Q!DOlOc�PRT FAh�T�PRYCYC}�QI<�T T @ZT�\y[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]TAD��=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiBEl�<=BE@ZYC@54G@ZT \BEK�DOlID4VgD�P�BE< Q!DOlO�

X�?SHRBI@ZH]TS[�PRT%>*D�[GH]?S?(< T @Z[OPWBEDGFSBIK QIH]<�\]K�u]DGQI>�PWY�PRT F¬T�H]T=�«uRDOQ!>�PRY:[G< DOlG� ¯ lI@CT \(u]DGQI>�PWY[O<�DOlOc=[ODGQ!BwPW@ZTS�"H]Q!F�[wK H]@C[ODGl�lI<�[wK%PRl !>aHRQIDOF �(H]Q �VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBI@ZT \8�M?SPv}�>*D'< lIDGF�BEHM@ZT F�@Z[�P�BED'PlIN*D�PWtRDOQ � l"DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l!BwP�BEDR���5H]T=� u]DGQI>�PRY�[GH]?S?(< T @Z[OPWBE@CH]TJ?SPv}`@ZT [GYZ< F D�V PR[G@�PRY�D��=N QIDGlIl!@ZH]T lGc>*H=F�}{\RDOl!BI< QIDGlOc�PRT F3[wK PRT \]DGl(@ZT°N Q!H]lIHrF�}��U@CBIK @ZT°PRT�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODW��³�H]Q/D���PR?AN YZDWc�PW[OH]< l�BE@C[VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl(l!< [wK�PRlyP¦l!@Z\]K�H]Q(PWT3@ZT�[OQIDOPRlIDS@ZT{BEK DABEHRBEPRY�DOT�DOQI\W}3HRVjPRT�<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD�?SP�}°PRYZl!HlI<�\]\]DOl�B`BEK PWBJP_l!NaDOPRtRDGQJ@Zly>aH]Q!DOF|H]QMVgQI< l�BEQIPWBEDGF:cn�U@CBIK H]<�BMBEK D�D��=N YZ@C[O@�B(l!DO?SPRTiBE@Z[Gl`>*DO@ZT�\< l!DOF:�

s K DOQ!D`PRQ!D4lIDGuRDOQIPRY®[wK PRYZYCDOT \]DGlU@ZTiu]H]Y�u]DGF_@ZT�F D�u]DOYCH]N @CT \Sl�}rl!BEDG?SlUBEHAQIDG[OH]\RT @54GDyDG?SHRBI@ZH]T@ZT�lIN*DODO[wK� ��T D�[wK PRYZYCDOT \]D�BEK�P�B¬HRV�BIDOTqPRQ!@ZlIDGl�@Cl�h�T F @CT \|PRT�PR[O[G< QEPWBID�F DOl![OQ!@ZN�BI@ZH]T�PWT FPRT T�HRBwPWBI@ZH]T�VgH]Q4BEK�DSD���N�QIDOl!lIDGF|DO?AHRBE@CH]T:�¬³�H]Q4D�� PW?SN YCDRc H]T DA@ZT F�@Cur@ZF < PRYn?SPv}{F�DOlI[GQI@C>aDSPN*DOQI[GDO@�u]DOF DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY"l!BEPWBED�PRl`VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBI@ZH]T|�UK @CYZD�PRT HWBEK DGQJ?�P�}|[wK HrH]l!D�BIH{F DOl![OQI@C>aD�BEK�DlEPW?SDJDG?SHRBI@ZH]T�PRl/@ZQ!QI@CBEPWBE@CH]T:� 2qK�@ZYZD(>aHRBIK�Y�PR>*DOYCl�?SPv}¦@ZT�F @Z[OPWBED`F�@ZlIN�YZD�PWlI< Q!DJHRV�BEK DJ< l!DOQGcBEK�DOlID_F @CxaDOQ!DOT [GDOl¬?SPRtRD¦k2<�PRTiBE@�V�}=@CT \°DO?AHRBE@CH]TzuRDOQ�}�F @ .S[G< YCBO����[GQIH]l!l¬@ZTiBEDGQIF @ClI[G@ZN YC@ZT�PRQ�}F H]?SPR@CT lOciK Hv��DO?AHRBE@CH]T�@Zl�[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQ!@54ODGFSuWPRQ!@ZDOl�\]Q!D�PWBIYC}R����T�HRBEK DGQ�[wK�PRYZYCDOT \RD'@ClnBEK DU[GH]YZYCDO[��BE@CH]T%HRV DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYal!NaDGDO[wK:��µ'DOPRY��«YZ@CVgDUl![ODOT PRQI@CH]lOc �UK @C[wK�PRQID/@CF D�PRY*VgH]Q�[OHRYZYZDG[GBI@ZT \`DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYF�PWBEP�c�PRQ!DMHWV�BEDOT¦F @ .A[G< YCB�BIHS?AH]T @�BEH]QGc PRT F¦H]T D4@Zl�V PR[GDOF��U@CBEK�BEK�D4BEPRlIt%HWVnlI[GQIDGDOT @CT \�YZPRQI\]Dk2<�PRTiBE@�BE@CDOl�HRVa[OH]YCYZDG[GBEDGFJF�PWBEP/VgHRQnBEK H]l!D�VgDG� <�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGl�BIK�PWB�PRQ!D�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYCYC}4[wK�PRQ!\]DOF��³�@��T�PRYCYC}RciPWV�BEDGQ�PRTSD��=N QIDGlIlIDGF¬DO?AHRBI@ZH]TJ@Cl�F�DO[OHrF DGFA�U@�BEK @CTSPWTS<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDRc2BEK DUF @ZPRYZHR\]< Djl�}=l�BEDG??`< l�BJ>*D%PR> YCD�BEH�@CT2BIDO\]QIPWBEDS@ZT�VgHRQI?SPWBE@CH]T3PW>aH]<=B`BEK D�< lIDGQ � lADG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�l!BEPWBED%PWT FzPRF��!< l�BPR[G[OH]Q!F @ZT \RYC}]�

��TSBIK D5Q!DO?SPR@ZT�F DOQ�HRVaBEK @Cl�[wK PRN�BEDGQOc�PRTSHvuRDOQ!ur@CDG�qHRVDO?AHRBE@CH]T�QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK�PRT FAF�PWBEPM[GH]YZYCDO[��BE@CH]T(BIDO[wK T @Ck2< DOln�U@CYZYr>aDjN�QIDOl!DOTiBEDGF:��;=DG[GBE@CH]T%�]����[OHvu]DGQIl�N Q!H]lIHrF�}`PRT FJ\]@�u]DOl�lIH]?AD�l�BwPWBI@Zl!BI@Z[GlH]T�BIK D�Q!DO[GH]\]T @�BE@ZHRTSN*DOQ�VgH]QI?SPRT [GD�HRV�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�lIN*DODG[wK�@ZTSBIK D �5 *¡¢£)¡r¤ [OHRQIN < lG��;=DO[�BE@CH]T�]� dSN Q!DOlIDGTiBEl/N Q!DGur@ZH]<�l5�"H]QIt�BEK�P�B�K�PRl�>aDGDOT�F H]T�D(H]T�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRT F_F DOl![OQI@C>aDGl�BEDG[wK T @Ckr<�DOlBEK PWB/PRQ!D(DG?SN YCHv}]DOF¦BEH�[GH]YZYCDO[�B�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�F�PWBEP���;rDO[GBI@ZH]T3�]� fAF DGBEPR@ZYCl'BIK D(BIK DOl!@Zl�HR>r�!DO[�BE@CuRD

� (

Page 17: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

VgH]YCYZHv��DGF�>2}%PRT¦HR<�BEYC@ZT D�HWV®BIK D4[wK�PRN�BIDOQIl'HRV BEK @CljBEK DGlI@Cl'@CT¦;=DO[�BE@ZHRT��]��� �

����� � ������4���� + � �

¨�QIH]l!H=F=}{@Zl4\]DOT�DOQEPWYZYC}¦BEK HR< \]KiB(HWV�PRl4BEK DAH]Q!\iPRT @ 4�PWBI@ZH]T�PWY�l!BIQI< [�BE< Q!DSHWV�PRT�<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODW� ��TK2< ?SPRT=��K2< ?SPRT�[OH]?A?`< T�@Z[�P�BE@ZHRT:c�VgQIHR? PSYC@Zl!BIDOT DGQ � lUNaH]@CTiB5HWV�ur@ZD��4caN Q!H]lIHrF�}�@Cl5PWlIlIHr[O@ZPWBEDGF�U@CBIK¬BEK D4N*DOQ![ODON=BE@ZHRT%HRVnP`l!NaDOPRtRDGQ � l5@CTiBEDOTiBI@ZH]T%>�PWlIDOF�H]T�PR[GH]< l�BE@Z[4PWlIN*DO[GBIlUHRV lIN*DODO[wKc*@�� DW�CcF < QIPWBE@CH]T:c�N�PR<�lIDOlGc�Vg<�T F�PR?ADOTiBwPWY�VgQIDGkr<�DOT [�} C ��� F c�PRT F PR?SN�YZ@CBI< F DW� s K�D�l!NaDOPRt2@ZT \{l�B�}=YCDPRT F_DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l�BwPWBID(HRV�PWT�@ZT F�@Cur@ZF < PRY�[�PRT�PRYZl!H¬PWxaDO[�B�BEK�D(N Q!H]lIHrF�}¦HRV�PRT�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODR�-��TBEK�D�[OHRT2BID��rB�HRV�PR<�BEHR?�PWBI@Z[�lIN*DODG[wK�QIDO[GH]\]T @�BE@CH]T:c­BEK D"DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYil�BwPWBID�HRV�P'< lIDGQnlI@C\]T @�h�[�PRTiBIYC}PWxaDO[�BEl4BEK D�N Q!H]lIHrF�}��UK @C[wK3@ZT�BI< QIT�PRYZl!H_P�xDG[GBEl4BEK�DAQ!DO[GH]\]T @�BE@ZHRT°N*DOQ�VgH]QI?SPRT [GDR� ��T°V PW[GB�cVgH]QUP`VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF¦DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYl�BwPWBIDRc BIK D4DGxaDO[GB5@Zl�HWV�BEDOT�N*DOQ�VgH]QI?SPRT [GDMF�DO\]QIPRF�PWBI@ZH]T:�

s K @Zl�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK%@Cl�[GH]T�h�T�DOF�BIHy@CT2uRDOl�BE@Z\]PWBE@CT \MBIK D'@ZT�VgH]Q!?�P�BE@ZHRT(�U@CBIK @ZT�BEK D'lIN*DODG[wK%lI@C\]T�PRYBEK PWB/[OHRQIQIDGlIN*H]T F l/BIH%DO?AHRBE@CH]T:��� l�BE< F�}_HRV�BEK D�PW[OH]< l�BE@C[`[OH]Q!QIDGY�PWBIDOl/PRT�F�[wK�PRT \]DGl4@ZT�BEK�DN Q!H]lIHrF @Z['N�PRQIPR?ADGBEDGQIl"@Zl�N QIDGlIDOTiBIDOF�PRljPM?SDOPRT l"HRV�[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQ!@54O@CT \(DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�lIN*DODG[wK:�H�«B�@Cl�"DOYZY®t2T Hv�UT°BIK�PWB4PRT�@CT F @�u=@CF <�PRY)D���K�@Z> @�BE@ZT�\�VgQI< l�BEQIPWBE@CH]T�PRY�BEDOQ!l�K @Cl�H]Q�K�DOQ�l!NaDOPRt2@ZT \%l�B�}=YCD@ZT¬Py�jP�}ABEK�P�Bj[�PWT%K�P�u]D4PRF�uRDOQ!lID/DGxaDO[�BEl�H]T�lIN*DODO[wK�Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]Tcrl!< > l!DOk2< DOTiBIYC}%YCD�PRF @CT \yBIHVg< Q�BEK DGQ�VgQI< l�BEQIPWBE@CH]T|� d)+�caf]e�c �:�­����� ur@C[O@ZHR< l5[�}r[OYZD(DOT l!< DOlGc®PWT F�T DG@CBEK�DOQ5BIK D`< l!DOQ�T�H]Q�BEK�Dl!}rl�BEDO? [OPRT�[�PRQ!Q!}%H]<=B'BIK D4F DOl!@ZQ!DOF�BwPRl!t*�

³�H]QjD���PR?AN YCDRc N Q!DOYC@Z?A@ZT�PRQ�}�D��=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiBElUH]T �  �¡:¢£)¡2¤ l!< \]\]DGl!BUBEK�P�BjBEK D4Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]TN*DOQ!VgHRQI?SPRT [OD4F DG\]QEPWF DOlUVgQIH]?,�­b ��BIH�PRYC?SHRl!B'f]f�� VgH]QUT DO<�BIQEPRY PRT�F�VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF_DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYl!BEPWBEDGl%QIDGlIN*DO[GBI@CuRDOYC}R� s K�PWB�@Cl%PRYC?SH]l�B%P��­dWe�� @CT [OQ!D�PRl!D�@ZT��"H]QIFqDGQIQIHRQ¬QEPWBID��UK DOTqBEK�DDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�l!BEPWBED%HWV5BIK D�< lIDGQA[wK PRT \]DGlAVgQ!H]? T DG<�BEQIPRYjBEH�VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF:� ;=@C?S@CY�PRQ!YC}]c)BEK�DOQID�@ClP (!� � @ZT [GQID�PWlID%�UK DOTz[OHR?SN�PWQI@ZT�\�BEK D�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY"l�BwPWBID�HWV�T DG<�BEQIPRY�PRT�F K�PWN Ni}|lIN*DODG[wK:�s K DJF DG\]QEPWF�PWBE@CH]T�HRV�BEK�DJQIDO[GH]\]T @�BE@CH]T�N*DOQ!VgHRQI?SPRT [ODyVgH]Q�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY l!NaDGDO[wK:c)�UK D�BEK DGQyPWl/PQIDGlI< Y�BAHRV�P�N YCD�PRlIPRTiBAH]QJ< T N YCD�PRlIPRTiBAD��=NaDGQI@CDOT [GD¦>i}|BEK�D�<�lIDOQGc�[OPR< lIDGl�l!DOQI@CH]< l�N Q!H]> YZDG?SlVgH]Q4BEK D�lIN*DODO[wK|Q!DO[GH]\]T @ 4ODOQG� s K @ClyBIK DOl!@ZlOc®BEK DGT:cnlIDGDOt2l`BEH_F H_BEK�DSVgH]YCYZHv�U@ZT \�´�C�� F D���N�YZH]Q!DBEK�H]lID�N Q!H]N*DOQ!BI@ZDGlOciN Q!@Z?SPRQI@CYC}/N Q!H]lIHrF @C[Rc]BEK PWB�?SPv}y>*D�< lID�Vg< Y�@ZTJF D�BEDG[GBE@CT \/DO?AHRBI@ZH]T:c]PRT F3C«d F@ZTiuRDOl!BI@Z\iP�BEDMPR[OHR< l!BI@Z[4[OH]Q!QIDGY�PWBIDOl'HRV�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�BIK�PWB'@ZT < DOT�[ODMlIN*DODO[wK_F DO\]QIPRF�PWBI@ZH]T� ��F DOPRYZY�}]cF D�u]DOYCH]N @CT \�P3l!}rl�BEDO? BEK�PWB�[�PRTqF D�BEDG[GB¬BIK D�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYUl�BwPWBID�HRVMP�< l!DOQ%PRT�FqPRF��!< l�B%@CBIl

���

Page 18: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

>*DOK�P�ur@ZH]QUPW[O[OHRQIF @CT \]YC}��U@CYZY@CT F @CQIDO[�BEY�}�YCD�PRF¬BIHJ>aD�BIBEDGQUQIDO[GH]\]T @�BE@CH]T¬>i}%[wK�PRT�\]@ZT \`BIK D/< l!DOQ � l>*DOK�P�ur@ZH]QUPWT F¦Q!DOF <�[O@ZT�\AVgQ!< l!BIQEPWBI@ZH]T:�

³�@Z\R< QIDJ�G�E�/F @Zl!N Y�P�}rl�BEK D4l!NaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?Sl�HWV®BIK QIDGDM<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlU�U@CBIK%BEK D4lEPW?SD4YZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[[OHRT2BIDOTiBy> <�ByF @CxaDOQ!DOTiBMDO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY®l!BwP�BEDOlMlIN*H]tWDOT�[GH]T lIDG[O<�BI@CuRDOYC}°>i}°P¬VgDO?SPRYZDJ<�lIDOQM@ZT{BEK�D�  �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤ F�H]?�PW@ZT:� s K D�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDJlIN*H]tRDGT�@ClG�VgDO>�QI<�PRQ�}_B��"DOTiB�}°lI@±�=BIK � � s K D�lIN*DO[�BEQIH��\]QIPR?SlylIK Hv�0PRT|@CT [OQ!D�PRl!D¬@ZT°VgQI< l�BEQEP�BE@ZHRT:c��U@CBIK,C P F >*DO@ZT�\_BEK D�T H]T=�«DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDPRT F!C [ F Q!DON Q!DOlIDGTiBE@ZT�\{BIK D%?AH]l!B`VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF|<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDR� s K D%lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?§VgH]Q(BIK D¬T H]Tr�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY=<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD�lIK Hv�Ul�BEK PWB�BEK D�H­uRDOQIPRYZY DGT DOQ!\R}J@Cln?`< [wK�YZDGlIl�BIK�PRTJBEK PWB�HRV�BEK�D�K @Z\]K�YC}VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF�<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODW� s K DOQ!D¦PWYZlIH{PWN NaDOPRQIl`BIH{>aD�P�YCDOT \RBIK DOT�@ZT \�HRV'BEK�D¬u]Hv��DGYZlAPRlJBEK�DDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�l!BwP�BED�[wK�PWT \]DOlG����ljl!K Hv�UT%@ZTSBIK D�YZPRl!B"lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?�c2BEK DGQID�@CljPRYClIH`PyT HRBE@C[ODOPR> YZD@ZT�[OQIDOPRlID�@ZT¬BEK�D�N�PR< l!D/F < QIPWBE@CH]T�VgH]Q�BEK D�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODW�@�«B�@ZljK�H]NaDGF¬BEK�P�BjBEK DGlID�ur@��lI< PRYZY�}JH]> l!DOQ!uWPR>�YZD�[wK PRT \]DGl��U@CBIK @ZTAQIDGNaD�BE@CBI@CuRD5<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOl��U@�BEKSF @CxaDOQ!DOTiB�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�l!BEPWBEDGl�U@ZYCY:PR@CF�@ZT�[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQI@ 4O@CT \APRT F�DGuRDOTiBE<�PWYZYC}¬F DGBIDO[GBI@ZT \ADO?AHRBI@ZH]T¬�U@�BEK @CT%lIN*DODO[wK_lI@Z\RT�PRYZlG�

��T`HRBIK DOQ®YZ@CBIDOQIPWBE< Q!DRcvBEK�D�QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]TyPR[O[G< QEPW[G}MHRV�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYiF�PWBEP5@Zl T HRBIDOF(BIH�>*D�PW>aH]<=B�Re��,HRT|P�u]DOQIPR\]D{� f]frc�f)���"�UK�@ZYZDSPRT3PR[O[G< QEPR[�}3HWVUPR>*H]<�B (]e���@ZlyPR[wK @CDGu]DGF�VgH]QyPR<�BEHR?�PWBI@Z[[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T|>�PRl!DOFzH]T|N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[%?AHrF DOYCl�� �]e���� 2qK @ZYCD¬?`< [wKzHRV'BEK D%YC@CBIDOQEP�BE< Q!D%PR[O[GDON�BIlBEK�D¬QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T|PR[G[O< QIPR[G}�BEH�>*D¬>*DGB��"DODOT (]e�� �Re��,VgH]Q`DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�lIN*DODG[wK:c�BIK DOQ!D�PRQID�T Hl!BEPRT F�PWQIF�[OH]Q!NaH]QIP�c ?SPRt2@ZT \J@�BUF @ .A[G< YCBjBIHS[GH]?AN�PRQID/Q!DOl!< YCBIl5PW[OQIHRlIlUD��=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiBElO�

����� � �����v��� + 5�� ���@�

m < [wKAHRV�BEK�DjQIDGlID�PWQI[wK�BEK�PWB�K PRln>*DODOTAF H]T�DjH]T�DO?AHRBE@CH]T(Q!DO[GH]\]T @�BE@ZHRT`K�PRl�>*DODGTA@CT`BEK Djh DOYZF�lHRV�N�l!}r[wK H]YCH]\R}�PRT F�YZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[OlO�¬µ'DGlID�PWQI[wK�H]T°BEK DS@ZTiBEDG\]QEP�BE@ZHRT�HRV�N QIHRlIHrF�}�PRT F�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T@ZTiBIHS?AH]QIDMlIHRN K @Zl�BE@C[�PWBIDOF_K2< ?SPRT=�«[OH]?AN <�BIDOQ'l!}rl!BIDO?Al�K�PWl�H]T Y�}�H=[G[O< Q!QIDGF_�U@CBIK @ZT�BEK DyN�PRl�BVgDG� }RD�PRQ!lO� 2qK�@ZYZD�?`< [wK�HRV/BEK D¦[O< Q!QIDGT2B¬QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK�K�PRl%PW[wtrT�H­�UYCDOF \RDOF�BEK�D_@Z?AN*H]Q!BEPRT [ODBEK PWBJN Q!H]lIHrF @Z[Gl(N YZP�}3@CT�F DGBIDO[�BE@ZT�\�DO?AHRBE@CH]T:c®BIK DOQ!D¬F HrDOlJT HWBJPRN N*D�PWQ(BEH�>*D%PRTi}3\]DOT DGQEPRY[OHRT lIDGT lI< lUH]T¬�UK�@Z[wK¬VgD�P�BE< Q!DOlj?SP�}S>*D�\]HrHrF¬N QIDGF @Z[�BEH]Q!l�HRV DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�l!BEPWBEDWc�PRT F¬�UK D�BEK DGQHRBIK DOQ�VgD�P�BE< Q!DOlUT HRB�B�}rN @C[�PRYCYC}%PWlIlIHr[O@ZPWBEDGF%�U@CBEK�N Q!H]lIHrF�}�?SP�}%PRYClIH�N Y�P�}¬P�Q!H]YZDW�

� �

Page 19: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

����� �����

���

³�@C\]< QID¦�G�w�R´¬;=N*DO[�BEQ!H]\]QEPW?Sl`HWV'BIK QIDGD%<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl`�U@CBIK�BEK D%lIPR?SD�YZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[A[GH]TiBEDGT2BA> <=BF @�xDGQIDOTiB'DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYl!BEPWBEDGl�VgH]Q�BEK D4N K QIPRlID �VgDG> QI< PRQ!}¬B��"DOTiB�}¦lI@±�=BIK ��lIN*H]tRDGT_>i}�P`VgDO?SPRYZDlIN*D�PWtRDOQG� s K D/F @CxaDOQ!DOT [GDOl�@CT�BEK D�T DO<�BIQEPRYa<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGC P F PWT F�BEK�D/K @Z\]K�YC}JVgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF%<�BIBIDOQ �PRT [GD3C�[ F lI< N N�YC}{P¬\]Q!D�PWB4F�D�PRYnHWV"@CT�VgH]Q!?�PWBI@ZH]T� s K DJVgQI< l�BEQEP�BEDOF{<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD�@ZYZYC< l!BIQEPWBIDOl�PRT@ZT�[OQIDOPRlID4@CT�DGT DOQ!\R}�PRT�F�BIK D4F < QEP�BE@ZHRT�HWV®uRH­�"DOYCl�PWT F¦@CTiBEDOQ!T�PRY:N PR< lIDGlO�

� +

Page 20: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

��������� � �)8��)�����*� o &/&/�������a���)8

¨�QID�u=@CH]< l�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wKª@CTiBEH�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY5lIN*DODG[wK VgHr[O< l!DOl�H]T DG@CBIK DOQ�QIDG[OH]\RT @54G@ZT \|DG?SHRBI@ZH]T�HRQD��=N Q!DOl!lI@ZT�\/DO?AHRBE@CH]T(PWT F`K�PRl�>aDGDOT`< T�F DOQ�BwPRtWDOTJ�U@CBIK(F @�xDGQI@ZT�\�?AHRBE@�u]DOlG�n;rH]?SD"QIDGlID�PWQI[wK DGQIlBwPWtRD4BEK DMlIHr[O@ZPRY�lI[G@ZDOT�[ODyPRN N Q!HiPR[wK¦�UK�DOQIDG>i}_>�PWlI@Z[4K2< ?SPRT�T DODGF l�PRQ!DyD���PR?S@CT DOF¦PRT F�BEK�DOTl!}rl�BEDO?Al'PRQID�F DGuRDOYZHRNaDGF�BIHJK DOYCN%?SDGDGBjBIK H]l!D/T DODGF ly� d=c5+W��� ��BIK DOQ!l�@ZTiu]DGl!BI@Z\iPWBID/DO?AHRBE@CH]TSBIHDOF�< [�PWBID�< lIDGQIl4HRV"P¬l!}rl!BIDO?�>i}�N�QIHvur@ZF @CT \�VgDODGF >�PR[wt�HRQ�?S@CQIQ!H]QI@CT \ABIK DO@CQ�N Q!DOlIDGTiB(DG?SHRBI@ZH]TPRT F�N Q!H­ur@CF @ZT \JF�DGur@Z[GDOlUBEH�K DOYCN¦<�lIDOQ!l5[GY�PRl!lI@�V�}¬lI<�QIQIHR< T F @CT \�DO?AHRBE@CH]T lv� brc*dr�G���

µ'DGlIDOPRQI[wK DGQIl/P�B5BIK D m � s.m DOF @ZP�¥)PR>¦K�P�u]D(D��=N YZH]Q!DOF¦lIDGuRDOQIPRY�l�}=l�BEDG?Sl'BEK�PWB5QIDG[OH]\RT @54GDPRT F|Q!DOl!NaH]T�F�BIH�DO?AHRBE@CH]T|PRT�F|K DOYCN�BEK D%< l!DOQJ@CT [OQ!D�PRl!D¬lIDGYCV�� P���PRQIDGT DOl!l�HRV'K @Zl`DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYl!BEPWBED�� fibrcnf!�v� � s K D ² ��¥ +]e]e]e¦[OH]?AN <�BIDOQ(��PRl`[GQID�P�BEDOFzPRl`PRT�PWxaDO[GBI@CuRD¬[OH]?AN <�BIDOQJPWT FK�PRl'PR>�@ZYZ@�BE@CDOl�BIK�PWBU@ZT < DOT�[ODyPRT¦@CT F @�u=@CF <�PRY � l�DO?AHRBE@CH]T lO� ��BEK�DOQUl!}rl!BIDO?Al5BIK�PWB��"DOQIDyF DGuRDOY±�H]N*DOF���DGQID(F�DOlI@C\]T DGF¦BEHAK DGYZN�[wK @ZYCF QIDGT_PRT�F�PRQ!DM<�lIDOF¦VgH]QUDOF < [OPWBE@CH]T�PRY)PWT F_DGT2BIDOQ�BwPR@CT ?SDGTiBN < Q!NaHRlIDOlG�

² H]Y 4�PRN=VgDOY5PRT F�K�@Zl�[GH]YZYCD�PR\R< DOlSPRQID�F H]@CT \��"H]Q!tzBIK�PWBAVgH=[G< lIDGl¬H]T�BIK D_[GH]\]T @�BE@CuRD_PWT FN Ki}rlI@C[�PRY"PRlIN*DO[�BElMHRV�Q!DO[OHR\]T @54G@ZT \�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T ��� � ��� s H¦@CT2uRDOl�BE@Z\]PWBED�BEK DAN Ki}rlI@C[�PRY"PRlIN*DO[�BElMHRVDO?AHRBI@ZH]T:cvBIK D"HR> lIDGQ!u]DGF`DO?AHRBI@ZH]T4@Zl)H]>=BwPR@CT DOFM>i}yQ!DO[GH]QIF @CT \'lIN*DODO[wKcRV PR[O@ZPRYiD��=N Q!DOl!lI@ZHRT lOciPWT FBEK�QIH]< \RK�lIDOT�lIH]Q!lM@CT�[OH]TiBEPR[GB/�U@�BEK{P¬N*DOQIl!H]T:� s K D�©jP�}]DGly¨®H]@ZTiB/?SPR[wK @CT D�� � �G��@Cl/PRT HWBEK DGQD���PR?AN YCD(HRV�D�uRPWYZ<�PWBI@ZT \�P�< l!DOQ � l/DO?AHRBI@ZH]T¦< lI@CT \¬lIDGT lIHRQIlO� s K @Cl�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK{@Zl�>�PRlIDGF�H]T�BEK�DKi}rNaHRBIK DOl!@Zl�BEK�P�BS<�lIDOQ!lS@CTiBEDOQIPR[GB�ur@�P{P{?SHR< lID%BEH°PRN�N YC}|D��=[ODOl!l�N Q!DOl!lI< Q!D¦�UK DGT�F @ .S[G< YCBDGuRDOTiBElAPRQ!D�DGT [OH]<�T2BIDOQ!DOF:��X�@Z\RK2B(N QIDGlIl!< QID%l!DOT l!H]QIl�PRQ!D�?AH]< TiBEDGF|H]T|P_[GH]?AN <�BEDGQ(?AH]< l!DPRT F�?AD�PWlI< Q!DO?ADOTiBEl�PRQ!D�BwPRtWDOT�VgQIHR? H]T�D�HRV4B���H�F @Cl!BI@ZT [�B¬QIDG\]@ZHRT lOcU�U@CBIK�H]QS�U@�BEK H]<=B�P< lIPR> @ZYC@CB�}3> < \ � s K @ZlAQIDGlIDOPRQI[wK�@ClJDOT [GH]< QIPR\]@ZT�\3PRT�F DG?SN K PRlI@ 4ODOl�BEK PWBAKr<�?�PRTzDO?AHRBI@ZH]T l@Z?AN�PR[�B�DGuRDOT¦lI@Z?AN YCD�[OH]?A?AH]T%BwPRl!trlG�

L�@CxaDOQ!DOTiBAQIDOl!D�PRQ![wK�PRN N�QIHiPR[wK�DOl�VgH]Q�QIDO[GH]\]T @ 4O@CT \{DO?AHRBE@CH]TzPRQID�PRYClIH°PR[O[GH]?AN�PRT @CDOFz>2}F @�xDGQIDOTiBU[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]T¬?AHrF DOYClO�n� [GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]T¬?AHrF DOY*BEK�PWBj< lIDGl'l!NaDG[O@�h�[/VgD�PWBI< QIDGljVgQIH]?BEK�DSl!NaDGDO[wK�l!@Z\]T�PWYnBEH�QIDO[GH]\]T @ 4OD�BEK DA< l!DOQ � l(DG?SHWBE@ZHRT°@Cl4T DODGF DOF�@�VjPWT2}°?AD�PRT�@ZT \RVg<�Yn[wK�PRQ �PR[�BEDOQ!@54OPWBE@CH]T|@ZlJBEH{>*D�H]>�BwPW@ZT DGF:�z³�HRQ`BEK @ClAN�QIH��!DG[GB�c"H]T Y�}�B���H{BwPWQI\]D�BSDG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�l�BwPWBIDOlGcVgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF�PRT F¬T�H]T=��DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY=C�T�DO<�BIQEPRY F c2��DGQID�< l!DOF¬VgH]Q�BEK D5N < Q!NaH]l!D�HRV)DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�[wK�PRQ �PR[�BEDOQ!@54OPWBE@CH]T:� s K�DOlID�B��"HJl!BEPWBEDGl��"DOQID�[wK H]lIDGT�lI@ZT�[OD5BIK DG}�PRQ!D�HRV�\RQID�P�BEDOl�B�QIDGYZD�uRPWT [OD'BEH`H]<�Q

dRe

Page 21: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

@ZTiBIDOT F DGF_PWN N YZ@C[�PWBI@ZH]T�

��������� 6 ���� ���"#I#�� � �!�"���A� �*�/�/���5-��)8

µUDO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T�QEPWBIDOlJPWQID�K�D�P�ur@ZYC}�F DGNaDGT F DOTiB�H]T�BIK D�BIDO[wK T @Ck2< DOlJ< l!DOF�@ZT3F�PWBwP¦[OH]YCYZDO[�BE@CH]T:�¨�QID�u=@CH]< l��"H]Q!t_K�PRl�>aDGDOT�F H]T�D`N QI@C?�PWQI@ZY�}¬< l!@ZT \�DOYZ@C[O@�BEDOF¦DO?AHRBE@CH]T l5lI@ZT�[OD`F�P�BwP�[GH]YZYCDO[GBI@ZH]THRV�QID�PWY���YC@CVgD�l![ODGT�PRQI@CH]l'@Zl'HRV�BEDGT¦u]DGQ!}�F @ .S[G< YCBUBIHS?AH]T @�BEH]QUPRT�F�PR[Gkr<�@ZQIDW����l5PAQ!DOl!< YCBOca?AH]QID[OQ!D�PWBI@CuRD'BIDO[wK T @Ck2< DOl�VgHRQ�l!@Z?`<�Y�PWBI@ZT \/PWT F�[GH]YZYCDO[GBI@ZT \/DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY F�P�BwP4K�P�u]D�>*DODGT¬DO?AN YCH­}RDOF:�

� � �@�! ����� %1� � . %/� �' �/

s K D4?AH]l!B�[GH]?A?SH]TSBEDO[wK�T @Zk2< D/VgH]Qj[GH]YZYCDO[�BE@ZT�\`F�PWBEP(VgH]QjDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYal�BE< F @CDOl�@Clj< lI@CT \AP`[OH]Tr�BEQ!H]YZYCDOF�\]Q!H]< N_HWVnD��=N*DOQ!@ZDOT�[ODOF{PW[GBEHRQIlUBEHAlI@Z?(< Y�PWBID4PSl!NaDG[O@Ch [yDG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�l!BEPWBEDW� s K D(lIPR?ADlIDGTiBEDOT�[OD�PWT FJBEDOl�B�[OH]T F�@CBE@CH]T l�PWQIDU\]DOT�DOQEPWYZYC}y< l!DOFSBIH4?S@CT @Z?A@54GD"T HRT=��DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYruWPRQ!@�PWBI@ZH]T�lO�¯ l!@ZT \yD��=N*DOQI@CDOT [GDOF�PR[�BEH]Q!l�HRV�BIDOT�N�QIHrF < [ODGl�BEK�D�\]Q!D�PWBIDOl!B�PR?SHR< TiB�HRV:DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�F�P�BwP(l!@ZT [GDBEK�D/H]T YC}SYZ@C?S@�BwPWBI@ZH]T�@CT2uRH]YCuRDOl�BEK�D4PR[GBIH]Q � lUPR> @CYZ@CB�}JBIH�?S@C?S@C[5PJN�PWQ!BE@C[O< YZPRQ�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�l!BEPWBEDW�s K @ClnBEDO[wK�T @Zk2< DWc=PWYCBEK�H]< \]K`@CF D�PWY=VgH]Q�PWQID�PWl�HRV*QIDOl!D�PRQ![wKS@CTJlIN*DODG[wK�l!}rTiBEK�DOlI@ClOc2@Zl�T HRB�H]N�BI@Z?SPRYVgH]Qnl!NaDGDO[wKAQIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T:c��UK DOQ!DUBIDOl�BE@ZT�\/[OH]T F�@CBE@CH]T l®< lI<�PWYZYC}y@ZT�[OYZ<�F DjT�PWBI< QEPWY�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T l BEK�P�BPRQ!D�D��=K @C> @CBIDOF�F�@CxaDOQIDGTiBEYC}{>i}�F @CxaDOQ!DOTiB`l!NaDOPRtRDGQIl�PRT�F3BEK�P�BJPRQ!D�YZ@CtRDGYC}�BEH¦>aDS?`< [wK|?AH]QIDlI<�>�BEYCDR�

� �����5 ���� �%2����

s K D 2q@ 4�PRQ!F=��HRV�� ��4 C+2 � � F lI[GDOT�PWQI@ZH{PWN NaDOPRQIlyBEH�>*D�P_\]HrH=F|[GH]?SN�QIH]?A@Zl!DS>*DGB��"DODGT BEK�DP�uWPR@ZYZPR> @ZYC@CB�}(HRV)F�PWBEPJPRT F�P`QIDOPRY��«YZ@�VgD'l!DGB!BE@ZT�\ � ��T%BEK @Cl�F�P�BwP`[OHRYZYZDG[GBI@ZH]TABEDO[wK�T @Zk2< DWc�< lIDGQIlUPRQ!DN Q!DOlI<�?�PR>�YC}AT�PR@�u]D� =BEK�PWB�@ZlGcrBIK DG}¬PRQID5< T�P��jPWQID�BEK PWB�BIK DG}�PRQID�T HRBj[GH]?A?`< T @C[�PWBI@ZT \4�U@CBIK%PQIDOPRY�[OH]?AN <�BIDOQ�l!}rl!BIDO?�� s }rN @C[�PRYCYC}Rc�2 � �¦D��=N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBEl�VgQIDGkr<�DOTiBEY�}SQ!D �!DG[GB"H]Q"?A@Zl!QIDG[OH]\]T�@54OD< l!DOQ4<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl4@ZT�H]Q!F DOQ�BIH%DGuRH]tRDSP¬N�PRQ�BE@Z[G< Y�PWQ�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY®l�BwPWBIDR�J^�HRT lIDGkr<�DOTiBEY�}]c=2 � �

D��=N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBEl"[�PRTS>aD5P4uWPRYC<�PR> YCD�BEHrH]Y VgH]Q�DGuWPRYC<�PWBE@CT \4NaDG[O< YC@�PRQ!@CBI@ZDOl�PWT F�F DGlI@C\]T l�@ZT�K2< ?SPRT=�[OHR?SN <=BEDOQUF @ZPRYZHR\]< D�l�}rl!BEDG?Sl(���­d����

d=�

Page 22: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� ����( � (+��2E� �I��� ������$ /

s K Dj\RHiPRYrHRV�BEK D"N QIDG[ODGF @ZT \�BIDO[wK T�@Zk2< DOl�@Cl�< Y�BE@C?�PWBIDOY�}�BEH�?SHrF DOY @A$#* ��� � lIN*DODG[wK�HRV*P�K2< ?SPRT>*DO@ZT�\¬@ZT�PSQID�PWY���YC@CVgD4lID�BIBI@ZT \ �/�5l�l!BEPWBEDGF�D�PRQ!YZ@CDOQOc*BEK DGQIDJPWQID`F @ .A[O< Y�BE@ZDGl�@CT�PR[Gkr<�@ZQI@CT \¬YZPRQI\]DPR?AH]< TiBElMHRV�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYnF�P�BwP¦@CT�Q!D�PRY±��YC@CVgD`l![ODOT PRQI@CH]lO��©"}°l��U@CBE[wK�@ZT \�BEH_F�@CxaDOQIDGTiB`PRN�N YZ@C[�P��BE@CH]T lGc�BEK D�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l�BwPWBID%PRl(�"DOYCY�PRlyBEK D�BEPRQI\RDGBEDGF�< l!DOQIlJ?SP�}°[wK�PRT \]DW�{³�H]QyD���PR?SN�YZDRc?AH]T @CBIH]QI@CT \�P¦<�lIDOQ � lyDO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l�BwPWBIDSF�< QI@CT \¦BIK DS?A@ZF�F YZDJHRVjQI< l!K�K H]< Q4�"H]< YZF�[OH]T�[ODO@�ui�PR> Y�}J>*D5?`<�[wK�F @�xDGQIDOTiB�BEK�PWT�?AH]T @CBIH]QI@CT \4P4lI< >r�!DG[GB � ljDG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY l�BwPWBID5F <�QI@ZT�\(PM> @ZQ�BEK F�P�}N�PRQ�B�}]�

��������� 6 ��8��)-�8�8��!�"�

��Y�BEK HR< \]K�QIDGlID�PWQI[wK DGQIl�K PvuRDU>aDG\]< T�BEHMl!BE<�F�}`BEK�D'D�xDG[GBIl�BIK�PWB�DO?AHRBI@ZH]TJK�PWl�HRTSQ!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]TN*DOQ!VgHRQI?SPRT [ODWc=?(< [wK%HRV�BEK�D�N < > YC@Zl!K DOF¬Q!DOl!< YCBIl�K�P�u]D/>*DODGT%H]>�BEPR@ZT DGF�< l!@ZT \(DOYZ@C[O@�BEDOFSlIN*DODG[wK:�2qK @CYZD�BIK DUQIDOl!< YCBIl�\]@CuRD'l!H]?AD�@ZF DOP4HWVaBIK Dj��HRQIt`BEK PWB�l!BI@ZYZY=T DODGF l�BEH4>aDUF HRT DU@ZTJBEK @Clnh�DOYCF:ci@CB@ZlUPWYZlIH�?A@Zl!YZD�PWF @ZT \ylI@CT [OD4T H]Tr��DOYC@Z[G@CBEDGF%DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYalIN*DODG[wK_@Zl�?AH]Q!D/lI< >�BIYZDMPRT F�K�PWl'@�BEl�Hv�UT[wK�PRYCYZDGT \]DOlG��³�H]QnD�� PW?SN YCDRc2PRTAPR[�BEH]Q�N*H]Q�BEQEP�}r@ZT�\yP�VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY=l!BEPWBED��U@ZYCY�< l!<�PRYCYC}D���PR\R\]DOQIPWBEDMBEK D(Vg<�T F�PR?ADOTiBwPWY)VgQ!DOk2< DGT [G}�PRT F�DGT DOQ!\R}_HWV�K @Zl5lIN*DODG[wK°l!H�BEK PWB5BIK D`DG?SHRBI@ZH]TN Q!DOlIDGTiB�@Zl�H]>iur@ZH]< lGc�> <=B�@CT¬PyQ!D�PRY±��YC@CVgD�lI[GDOT�PWQI@ZH(Py< l!DOQj?SP�}�>aDG[OH]?AD�l!HyVgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�BIK�PWB"K DYZHv�"DOQ!l"K @Cl�Vg<�T F�PR?ADOTiBwPWY VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}�PRl�@CVaK D'@Zl�>aH]Q!DOFAH]Q�DGu]DGT¬Y�PW< \]K lG���5Hv��BIK D5DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYl!BEPWBED�BEK PWB)@Zl)N Q!DOlIDGTiBn>*DO[OHR?SDGl®K�PWQIF DGQ)BIH5F�DGBEDG[GB®>aDG[�PR<�lID"BIK D�D��=N Q!DOlIl!DOFJDG?SHRBI@ZH]T4@Cl�lI@Z?A@ZYZPRQBEHJBIK D4DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYal!BwP�BEDOl'HRV®>aHRQIDOF�H]? H]QUDGY�PWBI@ZH]T:�

s DG[wK T @Ckr<�DOl�PWYZlIHJuWPRQ�}¬?SPRt2@ZT \J@�BUF @ .A[O<�YCB�BEH�[GH]?SN PRQID/[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]T�PRT�F¦Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]TQIDGlI< Y�BElG�n��l�}]D�B�ciBEK DGQID5PRQIDUT H4l�BwPRT F PRQIFS[OH]Q!NaH]QIP/< lIDGFSVgH]Q�DG?SHRBI@ZH]TJQ!DOl!D�PRQ![wK:��µ'DGlID�PWQI[wK DGQIlK�P�u]D/<�lIDOF�[GH]QIN*H]QEP(BIK�PWBjuWPRQ�}SVgQ!H]? ?SHvur@ZD�lIDO\R?SDGT2BIljBEH`T�H]T=��N�QIHRVgDGlIlI@CH]T�PRYPR[GBIH]QIlGc�l!< [wK_PWll!BI< F DGT2BIlOc BIHJNaDGQ!VgH]Q!?�[GY�PRl!lI@�h�[�PWBI@ZH]T¬PRT F%QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]TSD��=NaDGQI@C?SDGT2BIlO��©�DG[�PR<�lID4[OH]Q!NaHRQEP(< l!DF @�xDGQIDOTiB4u]Hr[�PW> < Y�PWQI@ZDGl4PRT F°l!}rl!BIDO?Aly<�lIDAF @CxaDOQ!DOTiBMY�PRT \R<�PR\]DJ?AH=F�DOYZlGc�QIDGlI< Y�BElMPRQID�T HWB(PWlD�PWlI@ZY�}¬[GH]?SN PRQEPR>�YZDR�

��YClIH c:?(< [wK�?SHRQIDJPWB!BEDGT2BI@ZH]T_K�PRl/>*DODOT�\R@Cu]DGT�BEH¬F D�u]DGYZH]N @CT \%K2< ?SPRT=��[GH]?AN <�BEDGQ�@ZTiBIDOQ��V PR[GDOlJBEK�P�B�D��=N QIDGlIlADO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRlJH]N�NaH]l!DOF�BEH{F D�u]DOYCH]N @CT \{l!}rl!BIDO?Al�BIK�PWB�F D�BEDG[GBADO?AHRBE@CH]T:�µUDOlIDOPRQI[wK�H]T%l�}rT2BIK DOl!@ZlUHRV)DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�lIN*DODO[wK�@Zl�PRT HRBIK DOQ"BEH]N @C[�HRV)@CTiBEDOQ!DOl�B�VgH]Q�l!@Z?A@ZY�PWQ�QID�P­�

d]d

Page 23: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

lIHRT l�BEHSBEK�PWB�HRV�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T¦QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T:� s K D`@CTiBEDO\RQEPWBI@ZH]T�HRV�N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[y@ZT�VgHRQI?SPWBE@CH]T�H]T_BEK�DVgQIHRT2B���DGT F_PWT F¦> PR[wt]��DOT�F_HRV BEK D4l!NaH]tWDOT�YZPRT \]< PR\]D�l�}=l�BEDG? �U@CYZY:K�H]NaD�Vg< YZY�}�YCD�PRF%BIHS[GH]Tiu]DOQ �lEP�BE@ZHRT�PRY:l�}=l�BEDG?SlUBEK�P�B'PRQID4?AH]QID�T PWBE< QIPRY �

s K DOl!D`F @�xDGQIDOT�[ODOl�@ZT_F PWBwPA[OH]YCYZDO[�BE@CH]T:c BEDG[wK T @Ckr<�DOlOca[OH]Q!NaHRQEP�PWT F�QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T�l!}rl�BEDO?AlK�P�u]DS?�PWF DS<�T F DOQ!l!BEPRT F @CT \�PRT�F3[OHR?SN�PWQI@ZT�\�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT°[GY�PRl!lI@�h�[�PWBI@ZH]T�PRT F�QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T{QID��lI<�YCBEl�F�@ .A[O< Y�B���³�H]Q"BEK DGlID4QIDOPRlIH]T�lOc BEK�DOQID/@Cljl!BI@ZYCYPJ\]Q!D�PWB�F�D�PRYBIHJ>aD4PW[O[OHR?SN YC@Zl!K DOF¬�U@�BEK @CTDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PRT�F¦N Q!H]lIHrF�}%Q!DOl!D�PRQ![wK:�

����� ����� � ��� ���

s K D�HR>r�!DO[�BE@CuRD/HRV�BEK�@Zl"BIK DOl!@Zlj@Cl"BIHJPR[Ok2< @CQID/PMBwPR\]\RDOF%[OHRQIN < l�HRV)T�PWBI< QEPRY*DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY*l!NaDGDO[wKDOYC@Z[G@CBEDGF_@CT�Kr<�?�PRTr��[OHR?SN <=BEDOQ5@ZTiBEDGQEPR[�BE@CH]T:cF�DGu]DGYZH]N{P¬Q!H]> < l�B/lID�B4HRV�VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl�BEH%k2<�PWT2BI@CV�}PR[GH]< l!BI@Z[5[OH]Q!QIDOYZPWBEDGl�HRV)DG?SHWBE@ZHRT:c2?�PR@CT YC}(VgQI< l�BEQEP�BE@ZHRT:c�PWT F¬BEHy@Z?AN QIHvu]D5H]< Q"< T F DGQIl!BEPRT F @CT \HRV�BIK DJDGxaDO[�BEl/HRV�N Q!H]lIHrF @C[`PRT F�BIDO?ANaHRQEPRY)uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T l'H]T�BEK D(lIN*DODO[wK°QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T¦l!}rl!BIDO?��s H�PR[O[GH]?SN�YZ@Zl!KSBIK @Zlj\RHiPRY ciBIK D�BEK DGlI@CljN QIDGlIDGT2BIl'P([OH]?AN�PRQIPWBE@�u]D5l!BE<�F�}¬HRV l�BwPWBI@Zl!BI@Z[OPRYaQ!DOl!< YCBIlPRT F�K2< ?SPRT�YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQ�l�BE< F @CDOlG�

s K D�Vg< T F�PR?ADOTiBEPRYnVgQIDGkr<�DOT [�}�K PRl4>aDGDOT°QIDO[GH]\]T @ 4ODGF3PRlMPRT°@Z?AN*H]Q!BEPRTiB�VgD�PWBI< QID�@CT°F�@Zl��PR?`>�@Z\]<�P�BE@ZT�\�>*DGB��"DODOTSDO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYrl!BEPWBEDGlO�n¨�@�BE[wK�F DGBIDO[�BE@ZHRTA@Cl�DOl!lIDOTiBI@�PRY�VgHRQnBEK D�[GH]?SN�YZDGBI@ZH]THRVnBIK D(BIK DOl!@Zl�\RHiPRYZlG� s K�DOQID`PRQIDylIDGuRDOQIPRY�[wK�PWYZYZDGT \]DGl�PRl!lIHr[O@�P�BEDOF¦�U@CBEK_D��rBEQIPR[GBI@ZT \SN @CBI[wK�@ZT=�VgH]Q!?�PWBI@ZH]T¦< lI@CT \�N @CBI[wK�F DGBIDO[�BE@ZHRT�PWYZ\]H]Q!@CBIK ?SlG� s H�PRF�F QIDGlIl/BEK DGlID�[wK�PRYCYZDGT \]DOlGc:BEK @Cl�BEK�DOlI@Cl< l!DOlJP_[GH]TiBE@CTr<�H]< l`N @�BE[wK�F�DGBEDG[GBI@ZH]T|PWYZ\]H]Q!@CBIK ? BIK�PWB(��PRl`F�DGu]DGYZH]N*DOF��U@�BEK @CT°BIK D�;=N*H]tWDOT¥)PRT \]< PR\]DJ;2}=l�BEDG?Sl�\RQIH]< N|� �!+�� � s K D`?SPR@ZT�[OH]TiBIQI@Z>�<�BE@CH]T l�HWVnBEK @Cl5BIK DOl!@Zl�PWQIDJPAF @ZQ!DO[GB�QID��lI<�YCB4HRV"< lI@CT \%BEK D�N @�BE[wK°F DGBIDO[�BE@ZHRT3PRYC\]H]Q!@CBEK�? BIH�[OQIDOPWBEDJuRH­�"DOY±��YCDGu]DGY�PRT F°<�BIBIDOQEPWT [OD���YZD�u]DGYVgD�P�BE< Q!DOl"VgHRQ�@CTiu]DOl�BE@C\iPWBE@CH]T:� ² Hv��D�u]DGQOc l!@ZT [GD�PRTS@ZT=�«F DON=BEK�F�@ZlI[G< lIl!@ZH]TSH]T�N�@CBE[wKAF D�BEDO[�BE@CH]T�@ClPRT HWBEK DGQ�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK�BIH]N @Z[Wc*BIK @ZlUBEK�DOlI@Cl5�U@CYZY�H]T Y�}�N QIDGlIDGT2B4Q!DOYCDGuWPRTiB�F�DGBwPW@ZYZl'HRVnBIK D`PWYZ\]H]Q!@CBIK ?BEK PWB'PRQID4T DG[ODGlIlEPWQ!}�VgH]Q�< T F�DOQIl�BwPRT�F @ZT \�BEK�DM?ADGBIK HrF H]YZHR\R}�<�lIDOF�VgH]QjBEK�@Zl�N Q!H��!DO[�B��

dRf

Page 24: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

����� � + � )�)���

s K D5QIDO?SPR@CT F DOQ�HRVaBEK DUBEK�DOlI@Cl"@Cl"HRQI\iPRT�@54ODGFS@CTiBEH4h u]D5[wK�PRN�BIDOQIl�PRT F�PRT¬PRN�NaDGT F @��a��^�K PRN�BEDGQd�[OHvu]DGQIl®BIK D�D��=NaDGQI@C?SDGT2BEPRY2?SD�BEK HrF H]YCH]\R}R� s K D�?ADGBIK H=F�H]YZH]\W}�@Cl F�DOlI@C\]T DGFyBEH'?A@ZT @C?S@ 4ODnPWT2}uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T l��U@�BEK @CTJBEK DUlIN*DODG[wK¬lI@C\]T�PRY�[�PR< l!DOF¬>i}JF�@CxaDOQIDGT [ODGl�@CTAl!NaDOPRtRDGQIlGc�\]DGT F DOQGcrPRT FAY�PRT=�\]<�PW\]DjN Q!H]T2< T [O@ZPWBE@CH]TJT HRB�PRlIl!H=[G@�PWBIDOFJF @CQIDO[�BEY�}y�U@�BEK`BEK�D�D��=N QIDGlIl!DOF�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT:� s K�DjBwPRl!trlnBIH>*D'N*DOQ�VgH]QI?ADOFAPRQ!D�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [OD���YCDGu]DGY�DO?AHRBE@CH]T`[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T�PRT FAQIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T:� s K DU[OHRQIN*H]QEP�cN @�BE[wK�BEQEPW[wtr@CT \JBEHrH]YZlGc PRT�F¦Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T%l�}rl!BEDG? PRQID4PRYClIH�N Q!DOlIDGTiBEDOF_@ZT¬BEK�@ZlU[wK�PRN�BIDOQG�

^�K�PRN�BIDOQ/fA[OHvu]DGQIl�BIK D(N Q!DOYC@Z?A@ZT�PRQ�}¬F�P�BwP�PWT�PRYC}rl!@ZlO�#2�D(@CF DOTiBE@�h�DOF_P�lI@C\]T @�h�[�PRTiB5T2< ?��>*DOQ/HRV�lI@�BE<�P�BE@ZHRT l5�UK DGQID�< l!DOQIl4Q!DON*D�PWBIDOF�PRT�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [OD�?`<�YCBE@CN YZD4BE@C?SDGl�PRT�F°l!DOk2< DGT2BI@�PRYCYC}>*DO[�PW< lID�HRV�N*DOQ!lI@Zl�BEDGT2BMQ!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T¦DOQ!QIH]QG� 2�D`F DG[O@ZF�DOF�BEH%D���N�YZH]@�B�BEK DGlIDJQ!DON*D�PWBIDOF{<�BIBIDOQ �PRT [GDOl�BIH¬lIDGQ!uRD�PRl�BEK�D(>�PRl!@Zl�VgHRQ5< T�F DOQ!l!BwPWT F @ZT�\�PR[OH]<�l!BE@C[([GH]QIQ!DOY�P�BEDOl5HRV�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T¦>aDG[�PR< l!DBEK�DG}%VgH]Q!? PRT�@ZF DOPRY:[GH]T F @�BE@ZHRT%HRVnN�PWQEPRYCYZDOYa<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl5@CT%BEDOQ!?Sl�HWVnlIN*D�PWtRDOQ5PRT F�YZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[[OHRT2BIDOTiB�caF @CxaDOQ!@ZT \�H]T�YC}�@ZT�BEK�D(N Q!DOlI<�?SDGF�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYl!BwP�BEDMN QIHvu]HRtRDOF{>i}�QIDGNaDOPWBEDGF�QIDG[OH]\��T @�BE@ZHRT�V PR@ZYC< QIDW� �5TqH­uRDOQ�u=@CDG�,HRVyBIK D{PR[GH]< l!BI@Z[�VgDOPWBE< Q!DOl�< l!DOF�F < QI@CT \�BEK�D�D��=NaDGQI@C?SDGT2BIl�U@ZYCY�PRYClIH�>aD�N Q!DOl!DOTiBEDGF:�¬X�?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�[wK PRQEPR[�BEDGQI@Zl�BE@C[Ol4HRV�BIK D�lIN*DODG[wK�lI@C\]T�PRY�PWQID�D���PR?A@ZT DGF< l!@ZT \�l!NaDG[GBIQIH]\]QIPR?AlOc�\]QIPRN K @C[�PRY�BEHrH]YClOc�PRT�F�µ �4^ [O< Q�u]DGlO� s QEPR@CT @ZT \�PRT F�[OY�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRTBEDG[wK T @Ckr<�DOl�PWQIDyPRYZl!HAN�QIDOl!DOTiBEDGF:� s K DGlID(D��=NaDGQI@Z?ADOTiBIl�PRQ!DMPRT�PRY�} 4GDOF�BEHA>aD�BIBEDGQ5<�T F DOQ!l!BEPRT F�UK @C[wK¦N�PWQEPR?ADGBIDOQIl'PRQ!D/?SHRl!BU[OHRQIQIDGY�PWBIDOF%�U@CBIK¦DG?SHWBE@ZHRT:�

^�K�PRN�BIDOQ �_N Q!DOlIDGTiBEl`BEK�D�K2< ?SPRT=��YC@Zl�BEDOT�DOQ4l!BI< F @ZDGlO� s K D¬F�DOlI@C\]T�PWT F3@CT2BIDOQ�V PR[ODSHRVjBEK�DK2< ?SPRT%YZ@Cl!BEDGT DOQ"l!BI< F�}¬�U@CYZY*>aD�N�QIDOl!DOTiBEDGF_PWT F�PRT�PRY�})4ODOF�"µUDOl!< YCBIl�PRQ!D�N QIDGlIDGT2BIDOF�VgH]Qj[GH]?��N�PRQ!@Zl!H]T��U@�BEK3BIK D�l�BwPWBI@Zl!BI@Z[OPRY�QIDGlI< Y�BEl(VgH]Q4BEK�D¬PR[�BEDOF�PRT F�Q!D�PRY�F�PWBEP�� s K�DOlID�D��=NaDGQI@C?SDGT2BIlPRQ!DJPRT�PRY�})4ODOF�BIH%>aD�BIBEDGQ�< T F�DOQIl�BwPRT�F°BIK DJ[wK�PRYCYZDOT�\]DOl/PWlIlIHr[O@ZPWBEDGF��U@CBIK�F DGBIDO[GBI@ZT \�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T@ZT�l!NaH]tWDOT¦Y�PRT \R<�PR\]D�l�}rl!BEDG?SlG�

^�K�PRN�BIDOQ�bSlI< ?A?SPRQI@ 4ODOl�BIK DyBIK DOl!@Zl�PWT F_l!< \]\]DGl!BE@CH]T l'VgH]Q'Vg<=BE< Q!Dy�"H]QIt�H]T�BEK @Cl5N Q!H��!DO[�BPRQ!DMF�@ZlI[G< lIl!DOF:� s K DMPRN N*DOT�F @���@CT [OYC< F DGl'lIPR?AN YZD�HR<�BEN <=B'VgQ!H]?0BIK D4[OH]Q!NaHRQEP��

d��

Page 25: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � ��� ��� �

� � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � ���

2q@CBIK @ZT�Kr<�?�PRTr��K2< ?SPRT�[OH]?A?`< T�@Z[�P�BE@ZHRT lOc�Q!DO[OHR\]T @54G@ZT \|DG?SHWBE@ZHRT l�@Cl%P|[OQI@�BE@C[�PRY'lIt2@ZYCY'VgHRQQIDOPRlIHRT @ZT \°BEK Q!H]< \]K�YZ@CVgD��«BIK QIDOPWBEDGT @ZT \{l!@CBE< PWBE@CH]T lOc�@ZTiBEDG\]QEPWBI@ZT \°@ZTiBIH3lIHr[O@ZPRYUDOTiur@ZQ!H]T ?ADOTiBElGcPRT Fql!< [O[GDOlIl�Vg< YZY�}�[OHR?S?`<�T @Z[OPWBE@CT \�P|F DGlI@ZQ!DOFq\]HiPWY5BEK PWB%lIK�H]< YZFq>*D{PR[wK @CDGu]DGF:� ��u]DGQEPRYCY cK2< ?SPRT l�PRQID�uRDOQ!}q\RH=HrFqPWB�F DGBIDO[�BE@ZT�\zBIK D{N QIDGlIDOT�[OD3HWV(DG?SHRBI@ZH]Tc�PRY�BEK HR< \]K�[OYZPRlIl!@CV�}r@ZT�\BEK�D¬lIN*DO[G@Ch�[%DG?SHRBI@ZH]T�N QIHvuRDOlJ?AH]QIDSF @ .A[O<�YCB��D2qK @ZYCD�YZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[�DGur@ZF�DOT [GD%?�P�}°@ZT < DOT [GDP�N*DOQIl!H]T�� l%F DO[G@Zl!@ZH]T�VgHRQ¬lIDGYZDO[�BE@CT \|P�N�PRQ�BE@C[O< YZPRQSDG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYUl!BEPWBEDWc5K2< ?SPRT l%PWQID�PR>�YZD¦BIHN*DOQI[GDO@�u]D4DOYC@Z[O@�BEDGF¬DO?AHRBE@CH]T�V PR@CQIY�}�PW[O[O<�QEPWBIDOYC}�>�PRl!DOF�?SDGQIDOY�}�HRT�BIK D/N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[�[O< DGl'N�QIDOl!DOTiB@ZT°P%lIN*DODG[wK�lI@C\]T�PRY�� fid­� � ¯ l!@ZT \%BIK @Zl4t2T Hv�UYZDGF \]DSPRlMP%VgHR< T F�PWBI@ZH]T�VgH]Q/HR< Q4QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK:c)BEK @ClBEK�DOlI@Cl"@CF DOTiBI@Ch�DGl"N Q!H]lIHrF @C['VgDOPWBE< Q!DOl�PRT F�@CTiu]DOl�BE@C\iPWBEDGl"K�H­��uWPRQ!@�PWBI@ZH]T�l�@ZT�BEK DGlID�N PRQEPR?ADGBIDOQ!lPWxaDO[�B'BIK D4NaDGQ!VgH]Q!?�PWT [OD/HRV�PJlIN*DODG[wK�QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T%l!}rl�BEDO?��

s K D_\RHiPRYjHRV5BEK @ClJBEK DGlI@ZlA[�PWT�H]T Y�}|>*D¦PW[wK @ZD�u]DOF�@CV'BEK DGQID¦PRQID�lIH]?AD�@ZF DGTiBE@Ch�PR> YZD�PWT FQIDGYZ@ZPR> YZD¦PR[GH]< l!BI@Z[¦[OH]Q!QIDOYZPWBEDGl¬HRV4DG?SHRBI@ZH]T DO?`>*DOF�F DOF��U@CBIK @ZTzBEK D�l!@Z\]T PRY5[wK PRQEPR[�BEDGQI@Zl�BE@C[OlO�s K @Cl5BEK�DOlI@Cl�F DGlI@C\]T l�PWT_D��=N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBwPRY ?ADGBEK�H=F�BEK�PWB5< l!DOl�N�PWQEPRYCYZDOY�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOl5BEH¬PWT�PRYC})4GDPRT F%@CF DOTiBI@CV�}SPR[OHR< l!BI@Z[�PWT F%N QIHRlIHrF @Z[5[O< DGljHRV)DO?AHRBI@ZH]T:� s K DOl!D/N�PRQEPWYZYZDGY�<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGl�[OH]T l!@Zl�BHRV @ � BE< N�YZD'QIDON*DGBI@CBI@ZH]T l�BEK PWB�PRQ!D�l�BEQI<�[GBE<�QIDOF%DGlIl!DOTiBE@ZPRYZY�}ABIK D�lIPR?AD�YZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[�PWYZYC}M> <=B�F @CxaDOQ@ZT¬BIK DO@CQ�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY*l!BEPWBEDW� s K @Zlj��P�}]c*PRT�H]N�BI@Z?SPRYa[GH]?AN�PRQI@ClIH]T%[OPRT�>aD4?SPRF D�>*DGB��"DODGT_BEK�DN�PRQIPRYZYCDOYa<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGl5>i}%@ClIH]YZPWBE@CT \(BEK�DMD��=N QIDGlIlIDGF�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYl!BEPWBEDW�

¨nPRQIPRYZYCDOY/<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOl��U@CBEK�@ZT�P N�PWQ!BE@C[O< YZPRQ @ �«BI< N YCD�\]QIH]<�NªPRQ!D°l!NaHRtRDOT >2}qBIK D�lIPR?ADlIN*D�PWtRDOQG�|;=N*D�PWtRDOQJF�DON*DOT F DGT [G}�DGYZ@C?S@CT�PWBEDGl(PWT2}°uWPRQI@ZPR> @CYZ@CB�}�@ZT|N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[SN QIHRNaDGQ!BE@CDOl`F�< DBEH|l!NaDOPRtRDGQ%uRPWQI@�P�BE@ZHRT lO� ¯ l!@ZT \�BIK D�QIDGlI< Y�BEl¬VgH]<�T F�F < Q!@ZT \�BIK D�F�PWBEP|PRT�PRY�}=l!@ZlGc5DG?SHRBI@ZH]T

d]b

Page 26: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]TSPRT F¬Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T�BwPWlIt2l�[OPRT¬>*D�N*DOQ!VgHRQI?ADOF:� s K�D�DO?AHRBI@ZH]TA[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T�PWT FQIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]TJBwPWlIt2l"<�lIDUBEK D�� £®������� C)E;=N*DODO[wK ¯ T F�DOQIl�BwPRT�F @ZT \y>i} m PR[wK @CT D�P�B m � s � F � b=�O�QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T%l�}=l�BEDG? F�DGu]DGYZH]N*DOF��U@CBIK @ZT%BIK Dy;=NaHRtRDOT¦¥)PRT \]< PR\]Dy;r}rl!BIDO?Al C ;�¥ ; F \]QIHR< N:�

s K D�Q!DO?SPR@ZT�F DOQ4HRV"BEK @ClM[wK PRN�BEDGQy�U@CYZYn[GH­uRDOQMBEK DA[OH]Q!NaHRQEP�PRT F3\RDOT DGQEPRY�?ADGBEK�H=F lM< l!DOF@ZT�BIK @Zl¬Q!DOl!D�PRQ![wK:�0��>�QI@ZD�V(F�@ZlI[G< lIl!@ZH]TqHRVMBEK�D°N�@CBE[wKqF D�BEDG[GBE@CH]T�PRYZ\RH]QI@�BEK ?~�U@ZYCY�PRYClIH�>*DN Q!DOlIDGTiBEDOF��;=DO[�BE@ZHRT�d=�C�{N Q!DOl!DOTiBEl�BEK D�[GH]QIN*H]QIP|PRT F�F�PWBEP|[OH]YCYZDO[�BE@CH]T BIDO[wK T @Ck2< DOlG� s K DDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY5[GH]QIN*H]QEP�PRQ!D�N QI@C?�PWQI@ZY�}�[OH]T=h�\]< Q!DOF VgQ!H]? BIK D{¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF�� " ��� :=� ( $ >��F�PWBEPPRY�BEK H]<�\]K�BEK D �� �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤� F�P�BwP¬�jPWly< l!DOF°BEH%u]DGQI@CV�}{l�BwPWBI@Zl�BE@Z[OPRY®h T F @ZT�\]lMPRT F°@ZTiu]DGl!BE@C\iPWBIDYZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[JVgD�PWBI< QIDGl`HRV'DO?AHRBI@ZH]T:c�PRT F�BIK D%¥�@ZT \R< @Zl�BE@Z[SL/PWBEP�^�H]T l!H]Q!BI@Z< ? C ¥)L4^ F [GH]QIN*H]QIPHRV)¨�QIHRlIHrF�}%PRT�F¬X�?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYa;=NaDGDO[wK���DGQID/< l!DOF�PRl�Py[OH]?AN�PRQ!@ZlIHRT¬>aD�B���DGDOT�< T DGYZ@C[O@CBIDOF%PWT FDOYC@Z[G@CBEDGF%lIN*DODG[wK:�

©�DO[OPR< l!D¦H]<�Q`QIDGlID�PWQI[wK�<�lIDOl�Q!DON*D�PWBIDOF�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGlABIH{PRT�PRY�})4OD%DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY"l!NaDGDO[wK:c�PRT< T F�DOQIl�BwPRT�F @ZT \3HRV�BEK�D¦D�xDG[GBEl�HRV/N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[�uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T lJH]T lIN*DODG[wK��U@ZYZY�>*D_<�lIDGVg<�Y5@CT�F D��BEDGQI?A@ZT @CT \%QIDGYZ@ZPR> YZD`VgDOPWBE<�QIDOlG��;=DG[GBE@CH]T3d=� d�N QIDGlIDGT2BIl`P�\]DOT DGQEPRY�Hvu]DGQ!ur@ZD�� HRVjN�QIH]l!H=F�}°PWT FP�F @Zl![O< l!lI@ZHRT3HRV"BEK DA?SHRl!BMQIDG[OH]\]T�@54ODGF3N Q!H]lIHrF @C[�VgDOPWBE<�QIDOly@Zl4\]@�u]DOT� s K DAN @CBI[wK3F D�BEDO[�BE@CH]TPRYC\]H]QI@�BEK ? @ClUPRYZl!HAN�QIDOl!DOTiBEDGF:�

;=DO[�BE@CH]T°d=� f�[OHvu]DGQIl�BIK D`?ADGBEK�H=F l�< lIDGF�BEH¬D�xDG[GBE@�u]DGYC}�PWT�PRYC})4GDyBEK�D`DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY)[wK�PWQEPR[��BEDGQI@Cl!BE@C[OlG��� F�@ZlI[G< lIl!@ZH]T�HRV BEK�DyPWT�PRYC}rl!@ZlOc�[OY�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRT%D��=NaDGQI@C?SDGT2BIlOc�PRT�F�K2< ?SPRT�YZ@Cl!BEDGT DOQl!BI< F @CDOl��U@ZYCY�>*DJ\]@CuRDOT:�`;=DO[�BE@CH]T�d=�,�%N�QIDOl!DOTiBEl4BEK�DJl!}rl!BIDO?�< l!DOF°F < QI@CT \¬BEK�DJ[OY�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRTPRT F_QIDO[GH]\]T @�BE@CH]T¦BEPRlIt2lOc:PRT F�lIDG[GBI@ZH]T{dr� bS[GHvu]DOQ!l�BEK DyBwPRl!trl5BEH¬>*D(N*DOQ�VgH]QI?ADOF�F�< QI@CT \¬[OYZPRl��lI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRT:��³�@CT�PRYZY�}]crlIDG[GBE@CH]T_d=�;(J\]@�u]DGl5PJl!< ?S?SPRQ�}¬HRV BEK D4[wK�PWN�BEDGQO�

� ��� �0����$&�����

s K D4[OHRYZYZDG[GBI@ZH]TSHRV�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�lIN*DODG[wK¦VgH]Qj>�< @ZYCF @ZT \yBEK D/[GH]QIN*H]QEP(��PRlUPJlI<�> l!BEPRTiBE@�PWY:N�PRQ�B�HRVBEK�@ZlUBEK DGlI@ZlG���< Q5l!BE<�F�}_Q!DOYC@ZDOF�H]T_B��"H%[OHRQIN*H]QEP�c�[wK HRlIDOT{N Q!@Z?SPRQI@CYC}SH]T_BIK D(>�PWlI@Zl'BEK�P�B�BEK�DDO?AHRBI@ZH]TM< T F DGQn@ZTiuRDOl!BI@Z\iP�BE@ZHRTM��PRlnT HWBn@ZTiBIDOTiBE@CH]T�PRYCYC}�DGYZ@C[O@CBIDOF:� s K D�[OH]Q!NaH]QIP'�"DOQ!Dj[OH]YCYZDG[GBEDGF

�� ����������������������� �!� ��" #$� �&%�'��(�(� ) �*��+��-,/. 0��+ �*�-1�� � ����� +2+�'�� ��'��-� �*,3� +�'3����4�65�� �67 �����4������,3� �-,�5 �8+4� ���4� �*+��-�6, � �*, �9� :;�6��,3� ��+ ���<���<� �*1 =>� �3���?+4�(�<@ �8,���1-�3� �-,�5'A+B+4�/CED�DF=G=G=H. 561-� ���*1��B������4�8+I"*. �6�45ADF7J�81?�?+ �6�B"3D��B" �I+4�<7K�&D*�I'��8�9D*�B�� �B' ��� ��=H. '�+47

L( �����������J�*:H'A�37 �*, M ����7K��� +��(�N� � �618��56���!�O�-, �QP3�-56'A+R�4�(���<�4� ��+4�8��,S� ��7 �*�-,T� �(�6�(18�����!�U�-,T+�'��WV #XV56�4�6�3�/.

d)(

Page 27: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

VgQIHR? Q!D�PRY±��YC@CVgD/lI[GDOT�PWQI@ZHRl�BEK�P�B�T�PWBI< QEPWYZYC}¬DOYZ@C[O@�BEDOF¦DO?AHRBE@CH]T¦VgQ!H]? BEK Dy< lIDGQO�M^�H]T�lIDOk2< DGTiBEYC}RcBEK�Dy[GH]QIN*H]QEP�PRQ!D4@ZTiuWPRYZ<�PW> YZD/@CT�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT%QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK:��L�< Q!@ZT \JBIK DyYZPWBIBIDOQ�N�PWQ!B'HRV�BIK @ZljBIK DOl!@ZlGcBEK�D¦¥)L4^ [OH]Q!NaH]QIP�HRV�¨�QIHRlIHrF�}�PRT FzX�?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYU;=N*DODG[wK �"DOQ!D¦< l!DOFzBEH°[OH]?AN�PRQ!D�Q!DOl!< YCBIl>*DGB��"DODOT�<�T DOYC@Z[O@�BEDGF¦PWT F�PR[�BEDGF_lIN*DODG[wK:� s K DyPR?SHR< TiB5HWV�F�PWBEPSPRT�F_DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOl< l!DOF_F�< QI@CT \JBEK @Cl�QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK_@Cl�lI< ?A?�PWQI@54GDOF�@ZT s PR> YCDyd=�C�R�

L/PWBwPJ[GH]YZYCDO[GBI@ZH]Tc=@CT�\RDOT DGQEPRY�c @Zl�T H�DOPRl!}%BEPRlIt��@��T%BEK DMPRQ!D�PJHRV®DO?AHRBE@CH]T%QIDGlID�PWQI[wK:c�F�PWBEP[OHRYZYZDG[GBI@ZH]T¦@Zl�D�u]DGT°?AH]Q!D(Y�PW>aH]Q!@ZH]<�l5>*DO[OPR< lID`BIK @Zl'BEH]N�@Z[(HWV"l�BE< F=}�@Zl5QIDGY�PWBI@Cu]DGYC}�T D��4c�HRV�BEDGTYZDOP�u=@CT \�BEK D�F�P�BwPU[OH]YCYZDO[�BE@CH]T�BEK D�l!H]YZD�QIDGlIN*H]T l!@Z> @CYZ@CB�}5HRVrBEK D�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK DGQOcWDOlIN*DO[G@�PRYCYC}�@CV�P'l�BE< F�}HRV"DO?AHRBE@CH]T{N QIHrF < [GDOF°@ZT{QIDOPRY��«YZ@�VgD(lI@�BE<�P�BE@ZHRT l/@Zl4F DGlI@ZQ!DOF:� s K DAY�PW>aDGYZ@ZT�\¬HRV�P%l!DOTiBEDGT [OD%PWlDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY @Cl�P�l!< >r�!DG[GBE@�u]DJN Q!H=[GDOl!lOc)PRT F�@Cl�T HWB�[OHRT lI@Cl!BEDGTiBMPR?SHRT \�F @�xDGQIDGT2B�YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQ!lOc:PWl�U@ZYCY>*DO[GH]?SD4D�u=@CF DOTiB'@ZT%BIK D4[wK�PRN�BIDOQ'H]T�YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQ�l�BE< F @CDOlG�

s K @ZlSBEK DGlI@ZlSVgH=[G< lIDGl¬N QI@C?�PWQI@ZY�}�H]T�F @CxaDOQ!DOTiBE@ZPWBE@CT \3>*DGB��"DODGTqVgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOFqPRT�F�T DO<�BIQEPRYDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY:l!BEPWBEDGl�>*DO[�PW< lID`<�T F DOQ!l!BEPRT F @CT \SBIK DOl!D(B���HSl!BEPWBEDGl5�"H]< YZF_PRQI\R<�PR> Y�}�YZD�PWF�BIH�F D��lI@C\]T @CT \�>*DGB!BEDGQ¬lIN*H]tRDGT�F @�PWYZH]\]<�D�l�}rl!BEDG?SlG� ³�QI< l�BEQIPWBE@CH]T�@Cl�PRT�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l�BwPWBID_BEK�P�B�@ClPRYClIH¬HRV�@CT2BIDOQ!DOl!B/BIH%[OH]?A?ADOQI[G@�PRY)[GH]?SN PRT @ZDGl�>*DO[�PW< lID�HRV�BEK�D`@ZT��!<�QI@ZHR< l5BIK QIDOPWB/BEK�P�B/YZH]l!@ZT \PJ[O< l�BEH]?ADOQ�N*H]l!DOl��UK DOT�?A@ZlIQ!DO[GH]\]T @�BE@ZHRT�Hr[O[O<�QIl�QIDGNaDOPWBEDGF YC}R��³�Hr[O<�lI@ZT�\JH]T�[wK�PRQEPW[GBEDGQI@ 4O@ZT�\BEK�D`PR[GH]< l!BI@Z[yPRT F�N�QIH]l!H=F @C[yN�QIH]N*DOQ�BE@ZDGl5HWVnVgQI< l�BEQIPWBEDGF�lIN*DODG[wK{�U@CYZY:BIK DOT�K�H]NaD�Vg< YZY�}%YZDOPRF¦BIH@ZT�lI@Z\RK2BIl�PR>*H]<�BjBIK D/F @ .S[G< YCBI@ZDGl�PRT F�@Zl!lI< DGljBEK�P�BUlIK H]<�YZF%>*D4PRF F Q!DOlIl!DOF��UK DOT�F DOPRYZ@CT \(�U@CBIKDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYlIN*DODG[wK:�

��������� � �)���)-���� 6 ����

s K D�h�QIl�B�[GH]QIN�< l ��PRl [OH]T�l!BEQ!< [GBIDOF(VgQ!H]? �� �¡¢£)¡r¤ cRPWT(PRN�N YZ@C[�PWBI@ZH]T/>�PWlIDOFyH]T4BEK D�9 ;=<�;=> ¤PRQ![wK @CBIDO[GBI< QIDy� �2b­��c2F DGuRDOYCH]NaDGFA�U@�BEK @CT`BEK D';=¥®;J\]Q!H]< N:c]BIK�PWB�PRYCYZHv�Ul�< l!DOQ!l�BIHyPWQIQEPWT \]D�PR@CQIYC@ZT D @C\]KiBElUPRT F�N Q!@Z[GD�@CBI@ZT DGQEPRQ!@ZDOlG� ��T�?�PWT2}S[�PWlIDOlGc�BEK D/< l!DOQ!lU�"DOQ!DMPR[GBI<�PRYZY�}SBIQ!}r@ZT�\`BEH�PRQ!QEPRT \RDP�QIDOPRY @C\]KiBJ@CBI@ZT DGQEPRQ�} �K�H­�"DGuRDOQGc"BEK�DOQID%�"DOQ!D%H=[G[�PRl!@ZH]T l`�UK�DOQID%<�lIDOQ!lJ��DGQID�T HRBJ?SPRt2@ZT�\QIDOPRY�BEQEP�uRDOYjN YZPRT lG��^�H]T l!DOk2< DGT2BIYC}Rc�BIK DSVgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}|HRV�VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlJ@CT3BEK�D�F�PWBEP��PRl5YCHv��DGQjBEK�PRT�@CB���H]<�YZF�K�P�u]DM>aDGDOT�@ZT�PRT�PR[GBI<�PRY @C\]KiBUQIDGlIDOQ�uWPWBE@CH]T¦l![ODGT�PRQI@CH �

L/PWBwP`[GH]YZYCDO[�BE@ZHRT��jPWl5F HRT D/Hvu]DOQ�BIK D/BEDOYCDON K�H]T D4PRT F¦PRYCYF�PWBEP(��DGQIDMlEPR?AN YCDOF�PWB � t ² 4W���N�N QIH��=@Z?SPWBEDGYC}_d]d=c e]e]eS<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGl/lIN�PRT�T @ZT \�P�BI@Z?AD�� VgQEPR?AD4HRV"PR>aHR<�B�H]T�D`}]D�PWQ���DGQID�YZ@Cl��BEDGT DOF|BIH�[�PRQ!DGVg< YCYC}{VgH]Q(@CF DOTiBI@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T3HRV'H]T�D¬HRV�BEK�QIDOD%DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�l!BEPWBEDGlO´�T�DO<�BIQEPRY�cnVgQI< l �

d*�

Page 28: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

BEQIPWBEDGF:c�PRT F�K�PWN Ni}]�U�]c,(!����<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl���DGQIDMY�PR>*DOYCDOF�PRl�VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF:c�f � PRlUK�PWN Ni}]c�PRT F�BEK�DQIDG?�PW@ZT @CT \�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGlSYZPR>*DOYZDGFzPRl�T DO<�BIQEPRY��q�­dRe{lIDOl!lI@CH]T l���DGQID�@ZF DGT2BI@Ch�DGF�PWlSK�P�ur@ZT�\�P�BYZDOPRl!BMH]T�DS<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDABIK�PWB4��PRlyVgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF:c6��l!DOlIl!@ZH]T�l(PRlMK�P�ur@ZT \¦PWBMYZDOPRl!BMH]T�DS<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDBEK PWB�D��=N QIDGlIl!DOljlIPWBE@Cl!V PR[�BE@ZHRT:c2PRT FSfMl!DOl!lI@ZHRT l��"DOQ!D�@CF DOTiBE@�h�DOFSPRl�P4?S@±��DGF�lIDOl!lI@CH]T:cr?SDOPRT @ZT�\BEK�DOQID4@ClUPWB'YZD�PWl!BUH]T D/VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODMPRT F�H]T D4K�PWN Ni}%<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODW�

� Tr<�?`>aDGQ4HRV�@CTiBEDOQ!DOl�BE@ZT�\�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOl4BEK PWB/��DGQIDA@ZF DGTiBE@Ch DOF°@ZT�BEK�D �5 *¡¢£)¡r¤ [GH]QIN�< lN Q!H­ur@CF DOF`uWPRYC<�PR> YCD"@CT lI@C\]KiBn@ZTiBIH�DGuRDOTiBEl�lI<�QIQIHR< T F @CT \/< lIDGQ�VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBE@CH]T:��³�HRQ®D�� PW?SN YCDRc]l!H]?AD< l!DOQIlM[wK HrH]lID�BEH�D���N�QIDOl!lyBIK DO@CQMDG?SHWBE@ZHRT�N QIDGF H]?A@ZT�PRTiBIYC}¦< lI@CT \¦YC@ZT \R< @Zl�BE@Z[y[O< DGlOc®>2}�< lI@CT \l!�"D�PWQj��H]Q!F lOc�T DO\iP�BE@CuRD�[OHRT l!BIQI< [�BEH]Q!lOc�PRT F¬BIDOQ!?S@CT�PWBE@CH]TA[OH]?A?�PWT F lOc2�UK @CYZD�HWBEK DGQIl�?AH=F @�V�}BEK�DAN�QIH]l!H=F @C[`VgD�PWBI< QIDGlO�723DAPRYClIH�H]> l!DOQ�u]DOF�BEK�PWB4Q!DO[GH]\]T @�BE@ZHRT�DOQIQ!H]Q4N QIHR?SN�BIDOF{QIDGNaD�BE@�BE@ZHRTHRV5@ZT�VgHRQI?SPWBE@CH]T:� ��T P�VgDG� [OPRlIDGlOc�BIK D�QIDGNaDOPWBA<�BIBIDOQEPWT [OD��jPWlSl!NaH]tWDOT T D�PRQ!YC}�BIK D�lEPR?AD� K Hv�"DGu]DGQOc�?SPRTi}�< l!DOQ!l'DG?SN�K�PRlI@ 4ODGF�?A@Zl!QIDG[OH]\]T�@54ODGF¬��HRQIF l�H]QjPRYCBIDOQIDGF¬BEK D/l�BEQ!< [GBI< QID4HRV)BEK�D<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDR��©�}�?SPRt2@ZT�\_< l!D�HRV�BIK @ZlM@ZT�VgHRQI?SPWBE@CH]T:c���DA��DGQID�PR>�YZD�BEH_k2<�PWYZ@CBEPWBE@�u]DGYC}{PRl!lIDGlIlBEK�DMD�xDG[GBUBEK PWB'DO?AHRBE@CH]T%K�PRlUH]T�QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T:�

��������� � �'���'���)��� 6 ����

s K D�l!DO[GH]T F%[OHRQIN < l"�jPRl�[OH]T l�BEQ!< [GBIDOF¬VgQIHR?0¥�Hr[wt2K DODGF%F�PWBwPM�U@CBEK�@ZT¬PMY�PR>*H]QIPWBEH]Q�}JlI@C?`< YZPWB!�@ZT�\�>*DO@ZT�\�PR>*HiPRQ!FyBEK�D � " � � :=� ( $ >�� s K�D�� " � � :=� ( $ >�@Zl®P�YZ@C?S@�BEDGFM?AH]> @CYZ@�B�}�N YZPWBIVgHRQI? < l!DOFBEH/Q!DOl!D�PRQ![wKSPWT FJBEDOl�B�PRF�uWPRT�[ODOFJBIDO[wK T HRYZH]\]@CDOl�VgHRQnlI< Q�V PR[OD�l!K @ZN�ln@ZT(BIK DUPRQ!D�PRlnHWVaN�QIH]N <�YZlI@CH]T:cPR<�BIH]?SPWBE@CH]T:c lID�P­��tRDGDON @CT \{PR> @CYZ@�BE@ZDGlOc PRT F|Q!DOF <�[ODOF�QIPRF�PRQylI@Z\RT�PWBE<�QIDR� s K D�BIDOl!B`[OQEP�V�B(��PRlF D�u]DOYCH]N*DOF�<�T F DOQAP�[OHR?`> @ZT�DOFzN QIH]\RQEPR? >2}|BIK D���F�uWPRT�[ODOF�µ'DGlIDOPRQI[wK ¨�Q!H��!DO[�BElA��\]DGT [G}C���µ'¨a� F c�BIK D �5P�ur}RcUPRT F�¥�Hr[wt2K DODGF m PRQ!BI@ZT m @Zl!lI@CYZDOlSPRT F�;=N�PR[GD�^�H]?AN�PRTi}R� s K�D � " �� :=� ( $ >qN Q!H]\]QEPW? >*DO\iPWT|@ZT�BEK�D�� + � e � lO�{�5lJN�PRQ!B`HRV'@CBEl(N < QIN*H]l!D¬BEH�D��=N YCH]QID%l�BEQIPWBEDG\]@ZDGlVgH]Q�Q!DOF < [GDOF¦?�PRT�T @ZT \`PR<�BEHR?�PWBI@ZH]Tc P`BwPRl!t�l![ODOT PRQI@CHA��PRlUF DGuRDOYCH]NaDGF�BIH�?SH]T�@CBEHRQ�?`< Y�BE@CN YZDDGuRDOTiBEl¬VgQ!H]?~�U@CBIK @ZT lIDGuRDOQIPRY�F H]?SPR@CT l�PWT F�K H]N*DGVg<�YZYC}�DGT [OHR< QEPR\RD�?`< Y�BE@�� BwPRl!t2@ZT \ � ��Q!@Z\W�@ZT PRYZY�}]c"P3[OH]Q!N < l���PRlS[OH]T l�BEQ!< [GBIDOF�VgQIH]? PW[GBE< PRY5l!NaDGDO[wK�PR>*HiPRQ!F BEK�D � " � � :=� ( $ > l!K @ZN:�² Hv�"DGuRDOQOc�>aDG[�PR< l!D'BIK D'lIN*DODO[wKS�jPRl�QIDG[OH]Q!F DOF�H]TABIK D'lIK @CN�� l�@ZTiBIDOQI[GH]? ?A@Z[GQIH]N K�H]T DOlGc2?�PRTi}HRV®BEK D4�jP�uRDGVgH]Q!?SlU��DGQIDyT H]@Zl�}]c�BEK�DOQID�VgH]QIDM?SPRt2@ZT \�@CB�uRDOQ�}¦F�@ .A[O< Y�BUBEHAH]>�BwPW@ZT�PRT¦PR[O[G< QEPWBIDN @�BE[wK%D��rBIQEPR[�BE@ZHRT:�n��lUPyQIDOl!< YCBOc P`[GH]QIN <�l��jPWljVgH]QI?ADOF¬<�lI@ZT�\(BEK D�¥)Hr[wt2K DODGF¦YZPR>�F PWBwP`l!@ZT [GDBEK�D/\]HiPRY*HRV)BEK @Cl"BEPRlItA�jPRljBIK D/lEPW?SD/PWl�BEK D/F PWBwP([GH]YZYCDO[�BEDOF�PW>aHiPWQIF�BIK D � " �S� :=� ( $ >{l!K @ZN:�

d �

Page 29: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

s K D�¥�Hr[wt2K DODGF¬[OH]Q!N < l��jPWl�[OHRYZYZDG[GBIDOF�VgQIH]? �vd4l!NaDOPRtRDGQIlOc=DOYCDGu]DGT¬?SPRYZDUPRT�FSH]T�D'VgDG?�PRYCDRc[OHvuRDOQI@CT \�H]T�D���?ADOQ!@Z[OPRT(X�T \]YC@Zl!K(F @ZPRYZDG[GB�� X�PR[wKJlIN*D�PWtRDOQ®�jPRl�@ZT�VgH]Q!?SDGFMBIH�[�PWQIQ!}MH]<=B�P'BEPRlItlI[GDOT�PWQI@ZHylI@C?S@CY�PRQ BEH4�UK�PWB"K D5HRQ"l!K D5?SP�}�D��=N*DOQI@CDOT [GD�PR>*HiPRQ!FABIK D � " � � :=� ( $ >¦lIK�@ZN:��;=PR?��N YCD5BwPWlIt2l�@ZT [GYZ< F�DOF¬Q!DON*H]Q!BI@ZT \MBEK D�F�DOYZ@�u]DGQ!}ABE@Z?AD5PRT F¬k2<�PRTiBI@CB�}SHRV)lI< N�N YZ@CDOlOc=QIDGNaH]Q�BE@CT \(BEK�Dl!BEPWBE<�l�HRV�DGkr<�@ZN ?ADOTiB4PRT�F�QIH]<=BE@ZT�D(?SPR@ZTiBEDGT�PRT [GDRcaPRT F_uRDOQ!@CV�}r@ZT \�< lIDGQ�@ZT�VgHRQI?SPWBE@CH]T:��X�PR[wKlIN*D�PWtRDOQ/l!NaHRtRDJPR>*H]<�B/dRe]e�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOl�VgHRQ�PSBIHRBwPRY)HRV�PWYZ?AH]l!B�d=c��ie]eS<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlG� ��V�BIK DOl!Dd=c f*+id�<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOlGcnd)( � ��DGQID�Y�PR>*DOYCDOF{PRl/Q!DON*D�PWB4<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlG��µ'DGNaDOPWB4<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOlOc lIN*H]tWDOT[OHRT lIDG[O<�BI@Cu]DGYC}�>i}zPRT�@ZT�F @Cur@ZF�<�PRY�l!NaDOPRtRDGQOc�PWQID�Y�PR>*DOYCDOF��U@�BEKzPRT PRN N Q!H]N QI@ZPWBED%DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYl!BEPWBEDyHRV�DG@CBEK�DOQUVgQI< l�BEQEP�BEDOF_H]Q5T�DO<�BIQEPRY�caPWT F_\]Q!H]< N*DOF�>i}�BEK�DO@ZQ'YZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[�[GH]TiBEDOTiBO���VnBEK�DQIDGNaDOPWB'<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGlOc)�­d��J�"DOQ!DyYZPR>aDGYZDGF�PRl�VgQI< l�BEQEP�BEDOF�

��T{D���PR?AN YCD`lI[GDOT�PRQ!@ZH¬B�}rN @C[�PRYCYC}�[�PRQ!QI@CDOF�H]<�B�H]T�BEK D ¢ �3��� ¢ C�N Q!H]T H]< T�[ODOF �Wl��Zl ���rt � Fl!}rl�BEDO? @Zl)l!K Hv�UT`@ZT(³�@Z\]<�QID�d­�E�]� s K�D ¢ ����� ¢ QIDG[OH]\]T�@54ODGQ ��PRl®[OH]T�h \]< QIDGF(VgQIHR? BEK DJ� £®�������l!}rl�BEDO?��

��������� � 6 � ������8�� � ���3�"��&4-�8

s K DMh�T�PRY [OH]Q!N < l'�jPRl5[OH]?AN @CYZDOF�>i}�BEK D(¥ L4^ PRT F_[GH]T l!@Zl!BIDOF�HWV�lIN*DODG[wK�QID�PWF�>i}_PA\]QIHR< NHRV`PR[GBIH]QIl�@ZT�uWPRQI@CH]< l�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�l!BEPWBEDGlO� ¯ T YZ@CtRD�BEK D{HRBIK DOQ�B��"H�[OHRQIN*H]QEP�c5BEK @Cl�[GH]QIN�< l��PRl'PRYZQ!D�PRF�}SBwPR\R\]DOF%�U@CBIK�PRT_PWN N QIHRN QI@ZPWBED�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRT F%BEQIPRT lI[GQI@CN�BE@CH]T:c ?SPRt2@ZT \`BIK D/F�PWBEP[OHRYZYZDG[GBI@ZH]T%Q!DOY�P�BE@CuRDOY�}�k2< @C[wt%PRT F�N�PR@CT YZDGlIlO�

s K D/¥)L4^ [GH]QIN <�l"��PRl�[GH]YZYCDO[GBIDOFAVgQIH]? �4lIN*D�PRtWDOQIl"�U@CBEK¦���(F�@CxaDOQI@CT \4DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l�BwPWBIDOlG�¯ B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOln�"DOQ!D�lIDO?SPRTiBE@C[�PRYCYC}4T DG<�BEQIPRY�@CT(BEK PWB�BIK DG}([OH]T l!@Zl�BEDOFJHWV�H]T YC}y?AH]TiBEK l�PRT FJF�PWBIDOlGcPRl5@ZT���� �����������������������a� s K DyDO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l�BwPWBIDOl�HRV�BEK D(¥ L4^�[OH]Q!N < l�@CT [OYC< F DGF_N�PRT�@Z[RcPRT=�=@CDGB�}]c=>aHRQIDOF�H]?¦crF @ClI\]< l�B�c=DOY�P�BEDOFc PRT F�T DO<�BIQEPRYalIN*DODG[wK:�j;r@ZT [GD�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOljVgH]Q�BEK D/¥�Hr[wt]�K DGDOF{[OH]Q!N < l��"DOQ!DJlIDGN�PRQEP�BEDOF�HRT YC}�@ZTiBIH�B���H%DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY)l!BEPWBEDGlOcBIK D`DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY l�BwPWBIDOl�VgHRQBEK�Dy¥)L4^q[OH]Q!N < lU��DGQIDyPRYZl!HAl!DON�PWQEPWBIDOF_@CTiBEHJB���HAF @Cl!BE@CT [GBUDG?SHWBE@ZHRT l�>i}�[OH]YCY�PRN l!@ZT \(lI@Z?A@ZYZPRQDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�l!BEPWBEDGl(PWT F3DGYZ@Z?A@ZT PWBE@CT \�HRBIK DOQ!lO��³�HRQ/D���PR?AN YZDWc)BIK DADO?AHRBE@CH]T l�������� ����! ���"��������� �# %$�"�&��'������� ��PRT F%�("*)��+�,�����°��DGQID¬[GH]YZYZPRN lIDGF3@CT2BIH¦BIK D�\]DGT DOQIPRY�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l�BwPWBID- � .��������(� ��� �'DO<�BIQEPRYa<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl���DGQID4PRYCQID�PWF�}SBEPR\]\]DGF�PRljl!< [wK_PWT F¬��DGQID4lI@C?SN�YC}APRF F�DOFBEHJBIK D4[OH]Q!N < l5PRT F�Y�PR>*DOYCDOF%�U@CBIK�PRT�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYal!BwP�BED4HRV/�,���������&=�

d)+

Page 30: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

¢ ����� ¢�� � : B 5 B 5 7 5 5 $ 7�� @A$ > $�� "+* �8� B $#@ � � � $#!#"+*£ �  �¡�� ¢ ����� ¢ ��� � � � � � ;?9 �� � �  ¢ ����� ¢�� � �����2� ��!#" �<: B 5 B 5 7�565 $ 7 $#!#"+*£ �  �¡�� � � ;������ ¤ � � ¡� *¢  � �® °¡ ;�� � � ¡� �� £)  � �¢ ����� ¢�� � $ � "+* � * " � (���� $ * " 7 " B !#" � ��> ��B<� B @ � � *0" 7 " ( "+@ 7 "���$#!#"+*¢ ����� ¢�� �8� � "+@ �<B $#@ � � � "+* � ��� $#& ��5��9�8� & 5 &�� ( �8� " � $#* � * �8� 5 * " �)& " 5��!� ( " � "+* @A$ > �£ �  �¡�� ; " ��¡)� ; � � �  ¢ ����� ¢�� � �����2� ��!#" �#�0�47%$ � $ � $#& * * " �)& " 5��!�'&.> ��B<�<B @ � � * " 7 " ( "+@ 7 "��,$#!#"+*)(¢ ����� ¢�� & � "+* �+* � ��� * � $ � * ( "+@ �#B @A" > �8� "+* � " � � "+* �8� & * " B 5-,/.10 (£ �  �¡�� ��; ¤ ; 9 ; � �¢ ����� ¢�� & � "+* �+* � ��� * � $ � * ( "+@ �#B @A" > �8� "+* � " � � "+* �8� & * " B 5-,/.10 (£ �  �¡�� 23� ; ��� � ��  4X��¡� �� ; � � �)  ;��  �¡ � ¡�  ��� £)¡� £ �  �¡�� 23� ; ��� � ��  4X��¡� �� ; � � �)  ;��  �¡ � ¡�  ��� £)¡� ¢ ����� ¢�� 5 B * " ����B @ : " � ( "+*6� * " 565 &=* " B 58790 (£ �  �¡�� �   �:� �'¤ ;=<  *¡ �¢ ����� ¢�� ; ( $#@�< � &=@ ( "+* 5��9� @ (=� $#&=* B @ � "+@ �<B $#@�(¢ ����� ¢�� 5 B * " ����B @ : " � ( "+*6� * " 565 &=* " B 58790 (£ �  �¡�� � ¤® ¢ ����� ¢�� > $ $ (��%� "@? $ "A(¢ ����� ¢�� � �����2� ��!#" �#�0�47%$ � $ � $#& * * " �)& " 5��!�'&.> ��B<�<B @ � � * " 7 " ( "+@ 7 "��,$#!#"+*

³�@C\]< QID�d­�w�R´°Xn��PR?AN YZD_F @�PRYCH]\]< D�VgQIHR? BIK D�¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF�[OH]Q!N < lG� s K @Cl¬F @ZPRYZH]\R< D¦@CT [OYC< F DGlQIDGNaDOPWB`<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOl`BIK�PWBy��DGQID¬YZPWBEDGQy< l!DOF|BEH¦@ZTiu]DGl!BI@Z\iPWBID¬PR[GH]< l�BE@Z[¬PRT F�N Q!H]lIHrF @C[S[G< DOlJ@CTDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYlIN*DODG[wK:�

�������CB ������&4-�8 �°����&`�)������ 8

m H]l�BJHRVjBIK D��"H]QIt°@ZT°BEK @ClyBIK DOl!@Zl(��PRl`F HRT D¬H]T3BIK D¬¥�Hr[wt2K DODGFzYZPR>3[GH]QIN�< lO��³�H]QMBEK DSQID��?SPR@ZT F�DOQ�HWV�BIK @Zl'BEK DGlI@ClOc�QID�VgDOQ!DOT [GD�BIH%PRTi}�F PWBwP¬H]Q�QIDOl!< YCBIl�lIK�H]< YZF�>*D�PRl!lI< ?ADOF�BIH%>aD(VgHRQBEK�Dy¥�Hr[wt2K DODGF_[OHRQIN < l'< T YCDOl!l'D��=N YZ@C[O@CBIYC}ST HRBIDOF�HRBEK DGQ!�U@ClIDR�

X�PR[wK <�BIBIDOQIPRT [OD�@ZT�BEK D�[OH]Q!N < l_��PRl_\R@Cu]DGT �­d�N QIH]N*DOQ�BE@CDOl¦BIH�PR@CF @CT @ZF�DOTiBE@�h�[�PWBI@ZH]TPRT F�PRT�PRY�}=l!@ZlG� s K D(VgH]YCYZHv�U@ZT�\SN Q!H]N*DOQ!BI@ZDGl5�"DOQIDJ<�lIDOF´ ��� �# ED���F(� - "��) - � & � %�AG(����H�� �# ��������� �# %$��&�& � �# &���������� "�������+�,��& "�������"������IG��/J# "�������"������IG��/J# ������� - �($��!

���IG,����! � )�"���� "��(��& �������� °PWT F $�"������,�+��� "�"9Fa� s K D°N QIHRNaDGQ!B�}�F DGlI[GQI@ZN=BE@ZHRT l�PRYZH]T�\�U@CBIK3PWT�D�� PW?SN YCDJHRV�BEK DA[OH]Q!N < lMH]<�BIN <�B4VgH]Q�BEK�DSYC@Zl!BIDOF{N Q!H]NaDGQ!BI@ZDOl4[OPRT�>*DJVgH]< T F°@ZT{BEK�DPRN N*DOT�F @��a�

f]e

Page 31: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� �' '�6� / � � ����( � " � ����� ��� (�� �¡:¢£)¡2¤ d]d=c d=�­d �]c;(*���¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF �]c;�Rf*+ �R�­d¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF�¥)PR> d=c f*+id �vd��¥)L4^ d=c f!� � �]c,��� +

s PR> YZDSd=���]´(¥)@Cl!BMHRV�[OH]Q!NaH]QIP�<�lIDOF3F < QI@CT \�BEK @ClMQ!DOl!D�PRQ![wK:� s K D �� �¡¢£)¡r¤ PRT F�¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF[OHRQIN*H]QEP(�"DOQ!Dy?SPRT2<�PRYCYC}A[OQ!D�PWBIDOF�PRT F�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOlU��DGQID/BwPR\R\]DOF�>i}�P`lI@CT \]YCD�@ZT F�@Cur@ZF < PRY*VgHRQBEK�DyPWN N QIHRN QI@ZPWBED/DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYl�BwPWBIDR�

��������� �S������8=�����!&� �!�"��8

Xn�=[ODON=BSVgH]QyBEK D�¥)L4^ [OH]Q!N < lOc�BEK D¬BIQEPRT�lI[OQ!@ZN�BI@ZH]T�l(VgH]Q�PRYCY�[OHRQIN*H]QEP_�"DOQ!D�DGTiBEDOQ!DOF ?�PRT2<=�PRYCYC}¦PWV�BEDGQ�YZ@Cl!BIDOT @CT \�BEH%DOPR[wK°<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODW�(��YCY®�"H]QIF�l�BEK�PWB/�"DOQ!D�H]> lIDGQ!uRDOF°@ZT�BEK�DJQIDO[GH]QIF�DOF<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD���DGQIDABEQEPWT lI[GQI@Z>*DOF��U@CBEK°BEK D�PRN N Q!H]N Q!@�PWBIDSN K�H]T DGBI@Z[�BEQIPRT lI[GQI@CN�BE@CH]T�BIH�PRYCYZDGur@ZPWBED@Zl!lI< DGl'PRlIl!H=[G@�PWBIDOF%�U@CBIK�HR<�B!�«HRV��«uRH=[OPR> < YZPRQ!}��"H]QIF lG��³�H]Q�@ZT l�BwPRT [GDRc�l!H]?SD�HRV®BIK D/<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOl[OHRT2BEPR@ZT�DOF��"H]Q!F l(l!< [wK|PRl�!?AH]QIH]T �_PRT�F3l!�"D�PWQy�"H]QIF lG� ¯ BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl(l!< [wK|PRl4BEK DGlID��"DOQ!DBEQIPRT l![OQI@C>aDGF¦l!HABIK�PWB'PJN K HRT DGBI@Z[MPRT F���HRQIF¦PRYZ@C\]T ?ADOTiBj[GH]< YZF�>*D/H]>�BwPW@ZT DGF¦PWT F�BIK D4<�BIBIDOQ �PRT [GDj[OHR< YZF`>*Dj< l!DOF�@ZTyBEK @Cl�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK:c2l!@ZT [GD���D�T�DODOF�DOFJBEH�?SPRtWDj< lID�HWV*PRYZYrHRV�BEK�DjF�PWBEP5BEK�P�B�"DOQID(P�uRPW@ZY�PW> YZDW� s PR> YCDyd=� dJYZ@Cl!BIljBEK DyPR[OHR< l!BI@Z[��«N K H]T�DGBE@C[4l!}r?`>*H]YZlU< l!DOF_�U@�BEK�BEK DG@ZQU��µU¨�U�>*DGBUl!}r?`>*H]YClOc�PRT�F%D���PR?AN YZD/Q!DGVgDOQ!DOT [GD4D��=N QIDGlIl!@ZH]T l5PRQ!D�N QIHvur@ZF�DOF�PRlUPJQID�VgDOQIDGT [OD4\]<�@ZF D�VgHRQ?SPRTi}%HRV BEK D4l!}r?`>*H]YCl�< lIDGF_@ZT�[wK�PWN�BEDGQ5f=�

� ��� � ����5��3���

¨�QIH]l!H=F=}(N Q!Hvu=@CF DOlnPRF F @�BE@ZHRT�PRY2@ZT�VgHRQI?SPWBE@CH]TMPR>aHR<�B�BIK Dj?AD�PRT @CT \�HRQ�DOT�[OHrF DOF�?ADOlIlIPR\]DjHWV*PRT<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDRc)�UK DOQ!D�PRlMYZ@CT \]< @Cl!BE@C[([G< DOlMN QIHvur@ZF�DA@CT�VgH]Q!?�PWBI@ZH]T_PR>*H]<�B4BEK D�YC@CBEDGQEPRY®[OH]TiBIDOTiB�� ��T\]DGT DOQIPRY c N�QIH]l!H=F�}�QID�VgDOQIl�BIH�BIK D/[OHR?SN YCD��¬H]QI\iPWT @54OPWBE@CH]T�HRV®N Ki}rlI@C[�PRY�c N K H]T�DGBE@C[/DGxaDO[�BEl�BEK�P�BPRQ!DA<�lIDOF�BEH�D��=N QIDGlIlJP�BIBE@�BE< F�D�PRT F3DG?SN�K�PRlI@Cl4@ZT°Kr<�?�PRT°[OHR?S?`<�T @Z[OPWBE@CH]T:�7��T F DGDOF:c®>aHRBIKB�}rNaDGl�HRV:@ZT�VgH]Q!?�P�BE@ZHRT:cRYC@ZT \]<�@Zl!BI@Z[�PWT F�N Q!H]lIHrF @C[Rc2[OH]TiBIQI@Z>�<�BEDUBEHMBEK D'[OH]Q!QIDG[GB"< T F DGQIl!BEPRT F @CT \PRT F�l!< [O[GDOl!l!Vg< Y4[OHR?S?`<�T @Z[OPWBE@CH]T HWVMP�?SDGlIlEPW\]DR�.¨�QI@CH]QSBIH�F DGBIDOQ!?S@CT @ZT \°BEK D�F�@CxaDOQIDGT [ODGl>*DGB��"DODOTqDG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY'PRT F�T HRT=��DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�lIN*DODG[wK:c'BIK D�N Q!H]lIHrF @C[¦VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl¬HRV�BEK D�l!NaDGDO[wKlI@C\]T�PRY=?`< l�B�>aD�[OPRN�BI< QIDGF�VgHRQ�PRT�PRY�}rlI@ZlG� s K @ClnBEK DGlI@ClnVgH=[G< lIDGl�H]TJ@ZTiu]DGl!BI@Z\iPWBI@ZT \�BIK DjN Q!H]lIHrF @C[

f��

Page 32: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

�@� �@��( .�� � . �@��� � � � " ��(�� �H� �@�)( .�� � . �@��� � � �5" ��(+�3 ��� �)(0/ ��� � ��� ���I����� ��$ /@���C�@�� F ��J > "6" B <�� D > $ $ B� �+� > BgB �< � B $ $ BD � C D �+F � J > ��BgB - � � > B * F ��� > " B ��� C ��� F � J > BgBED� ��� > �]B � C� � F "IJ > $ �� ��� > $ > � � ��D > $#& B ��" > $#& �#:2B � �� �i>aHR<�B� ��� > & B � �� F DG> BgBH � "9D > $ �]B � ���� > <�B!B "+*� �� > $ $ t� (��0�=��/ �H��� ���0� /� D >"P�} Q�C

9F � * Pv}

}BC � F J �]PR[wKiB Y & � P�}Y � ��& >*HRBIB � "

� � / ��(0/? ) �AH � ?�� � ) >*HRBIB $ �T � @ HrH @ T�� ��� > <�B!B $#@� ��� l!@ @ � � � ����� 23PRlIK B @ �RBIH]T� � �� �U@ @ @ DGQ� �&%1� ��� ��� /l � 5GD�P 4 ! F�H]T D"l C

‘F �*� 5C:rD "47C

“F ! � ?AD�P=5G< Q!D

V - �W@ZT u F ! PRT# ��� �<:r@ZT $ � � �<:=DGTK ��� :=P�}��� � � /N G � D�P > % ��DODB � ��D�P F � (2P�}t H $�DG} \ � �iPR@ZTN'& G�$�& N*H � l >'& %�$�& >*H ��lB & ��$�& N*H � l F(& �,$�& N*H (ilt�& H�$�& N*H 7%$�l \ & �,$�& >*H4�]l) * > < ����H]T � �+ ?`< ( (]}. � �+%1� ��� /"[7C

¢F $*� 7+:rH]tWD ", C £ F - � .�H]tWD

s PR> YZD¦d=� d=´%¨�K H]T�DGBE@C[¦YZPR>*DOYZlyVgH]Q���?ADOQI@C[�PRT�X�T \]YC@Zl!K:� s K D �H� �@��(4[OHRYZ< ?AT|YZ@Cl!BEl`BIK D�Y�P��>*DOYZl'< l!DOF�@ZT�;�¥ ;ac��U@CBEK�BEK Dy[OH]Q!QIDGlIN*H]T F @CT \ ��¨� Y�PR>*DOY�@CT_N�PWQIDOTiBIK DOl!DOl��UK DGT�BEK D�}¦F�@CxaDOQO�s K D .�� � . �@���J[OH]YC< ?AT�YZ@Cl!BEl5BEK DJDGkr<�@CuWPRYZDGTiB/Y�PR>*DOYCl�@CT�BEK DJ��µ'¨a��>*DGB4�/;�^�� �'N K H]T D�BE@C[PRYCN K�PR>*DGBO�

fid

Page 33: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

N Q!H]NaDGQ!BI@ZDOlyHRV�BEK�D¬lIN*DODG[wKzl!@Z\]T PRY"@CT�BIK D¬K H]N*D�BIK�PWB(BIK DOl!D¬N Q!H]NaDGQ!BI@ZDOly�U@ZYZY�F @ClEPR?(> @Z\]< PWBED>*DGB��"DODOT_DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYaPRT F�T H]T=�«DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRYalIN*DODG[wK:�

��[G[OH]Q!F @ZT \�BIH�?�PWT2}�QIDGlIDOPRQI[wKzl!BI< F @ZDGlOc�BEK�DOQID�PWQID�BIK QIDGD%N Ki}=l!@Z[OPRY c�N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[AVgD�PWBI< QIDGlBEK PWB�PRQ!D�?SHRl!B¬<�lIDGVg<�Y�@ZT�F D�BEDG[GBE@CT \|DO?AHRBI@ZH]T)��Vg< T F�PW?SDGT2BEPRY�VgQIDGkr<�DOT [�}]c�F�< QEPWBI@ZH]Tc5PWT FDOT�DOQI\W}:���ve crd*�rcrbReW��� s K D'NaDGQI[ODGN�BE< PRY*VgHRQI? HRVaBEK DGlID'N QIHRlIHrF @Z[�VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl"PRQID'N @CBI[wK:c2lIN*D�PRt2@CT \QEP�BEDRc=PRT FSYZH]<�F T DOl!lOcrQIDGlIN*DO[GBI@CuRDOYC}R� s K @Zl�QIDGlID�PWQI[wK%< l!DOljPWT F�?SPRtRDGl�Q!DGVgDOQ!DOT [GD�BEH4BEK�D�N Ki}rlI@±�[�PWY�VgDOPWBE<�QIDOl�@ZT�l!BEDOPRFAHRVBIK DO@CQ�N*DOQ![ODGN�BE<�PWYa[GH]< TiBEDGQIN�PRQ�BEl">aDG[�PR< l!D'BIK D'N Ki}=l!@Z[OPRY*VgDOPWBE<�QIDOl"PRQ!D?AD�PRl!< QEPR>�YZD/N�PRQIPR?ADGBEDGQIlG�

��F F�@CBE@CH]T�PRYCYC}Rc=BEK�D4Vg<�T F�PR?ADOTiBwPWY:VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}�K�PWl5>*DODGT_QIDG[OH]\RT @54GDOF¦PRl�BEK DM?SHRl!BU@Z?AN*H]Q��BwPWT2B5N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[4VgD�P�BE< Q!D(@ZT¦F @Zl�BE@CT \]< @ClIK @CT \�>aD�B���DGDOT�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�l!BwP�BEDOl`� �]fW� �5^�H]T�lIDOk2< DGTiBEYC}RcF D�BEDO[�BE@CT \%BEK D`Vg< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRY®VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}�BIK DOT°>*DO[OHR?SDGl4PRT{DOlIl!DOTiBE@ZPRY�l!BIDON{@ZT�BIK DAPRT�PRY�}rlI@ZlHRV�N�QIH]l!H=F�}¦PRT�F_DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�@ZT�lIN*DODG[wK°l!@Z\]T PRYZlG� ��T Dy��P�}�BIH¬PR[G[OH]?AN YC@ZlIK�BEK�@Zl'@Zl'>2}�< l!@ZT \�PN @�BE[wK�F DGBIDO[GBI@ZH]T�PRYC\]H]Q!@CBEK�?¦�

��������� �3�� �*� 6 �: �)� �!�"�

s K @Cl"BEK�DOlI@Cl�< l!DOl�PM[OH]TiBI@ZT2< H]< l�N @CBI[wK�F D�BEDO[�BE@CH]T%PRYC\]H]QI@�BEK ? C«^�¨�LU� F cr�UK @Z[wKS�jPRl"F DOl!@Z\]T�DOFlIN*DO[G@Ch�[OPRYZY�}%VgH]Q'N QIH]l!H=F�@Z[M?SHrF DOYC@ZT \APRN�N YZ@C[�PWBI@ZH]T l�VgH]QUBEDGYZDGN K H]T Dyk2<�PRYZ@�B�}�lIN*DODG[wK)� �*+i��� s K DN @�BE[wK`DGl!BE@C?�P�BE@ZHRTy?ADGBIK H=Fy@Zl >�PRl!DOFJH]T(BIK D�K PRQI?AH]T @C["?SPWBE[wK�@ZT \�PRN N Q!HiPR[wK���� (W��cW�UK @C[wK`< l!DOlBEK�D5Q!DOY�P�BE@ZHRT lIK @CNSHWV:K�PRQ!?SHRT @Z[Gl�>*DO@CT \MlIN�PR[GDOF�P4[OH]T�l!BwPWT2B�F @Zl�BwPRT�[OD5VgQ!H]? BIK D5Vg< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRYH]T�P�YCH]\�VgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}Jl![�PRYCDRciPRT�F�P�F�}rT�PR?A@Z["N QIH]\RQEPR?A?S@CT \'lID�PWQI[wKJBEDG[wK T @Zk2< DW� s K D�F�}rT�PR?A@Z[N Q!H]\]QEPW?S?A@ZT \�lID�PWQI[wK(h�T�F l�PUN @�BE[wKyuWPRYC< DnVgH]Q)DGuRDOQ�}MVgQIPR?ADRc�@ZT [GYZ< F @CT \�< Tiu]HR@Z[ODGF`QIDG\]@ZHRT lO����TH]< Q�QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK:crP�lIDG\]?SDGTiBwPWBI@ZH]TJHRV�BIK Dj�jP�uRDGVgH]Q!? ��PRl�H]>�BwPW@ZT DGF`< lI@CT \4P�lIN*DODG[wK�Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]Tl!}rl�BEDO?�c*PRT F�N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[�VgDOPWBE<�QIDOlUVgQIHR?0BEK�D4uRHv��DGY®l!DO\]?ADOTiBEl'PRQ!DMPRT�PRY�} 4GDOF:�

³�@Z\R< QID4dv��d(lIK�H­�UlUBEK�D ��� [OH]TiBIH]< Q�Hvu]DGQIY�PW@ZF�H]T�PJlIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?�VgH]QUPRT%<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD/VgQIH]?BEK�D¬¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF�[OHRQIN < lG�_�5l(lIK�H­�UT|@CT�BIK D�h�\]<�QIDRc®BEK DAVg< T F�PR?ADOTiBEPRY�VgQ!DOk2< DGT [G}3@ZlMlI@Z\RT @CV��@Z[OPRTiBEY�}���DOPRtRDGQyBIK�PRT{BEK DAK�PRQ!?SH]T�@Z[OlMPRT�F�?SP�}�ur@ZlI< PRYZY�}�F @ClEPRN N*D�PWQMl!H¦BIK�PWByPRT�PR[O[G< QEPWBIDN @�BE[wK{DOl�BE@Z?SPWBI@ZH]T�F DGNaDGT F lMH]T{N QIHRNaDGQM<=BE@ZYC@54OPWBE@CH]T_HRV�BEK�DAK�@Z\]K DGQ�K�PRQ!?SHRT @Z[Gl���� s H¦>*DGB!BEDGQPRl!lIDOl!l�BEK�D¦N @�BE[wKzBEQEPW[wtRDOQGc�@CBIlAHR<�BEN <=B�@ClAF�H]< > YCDOF�l!H�BIK�PWBS@CB�lIK�H]< YZF [OH]@CT [O@CF D%�U@CBIK BEK�D

��� '�� = � �*% :;��,3� �67K�<,A+ �619���G� �3�H+�� �R'��-56' M � �6�4���318+��(� �-, +�'��H+4�<1-�<�3'��6,��H' �6,3������+(.

f]f

Page 34: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

³�@C\]< QIDMdv��d=´C P F ��P�u]D�VgH]QI?�c�C�> F �U@ZF�D���> PRT F_l!NaDG[GBIQIH]\]QIPR?�c=C�[ F T�PWQIQIHv�j�«>�PRT F�lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?@ZT�YCH]\iPRQ!@CBEK�?S@C['VgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}�lI[OPRYZD/�U@CBIK¦N�@CBE[wK�D��=BIQEPR[�BEDGF�< lI@CT \S^�¨�L'�yc�C F F N K H]T�DGBE@C[MPRYZ@C\]T=�?ADOTiB�c�PWT F!C�D F �"H]QIF�PRYC@Z\]T�?SDGT2BMVgH]Q4BEK D�<�BIBIDOQEPWT [OD/C�������2� C N QIH]T�H]< T [GDOF �W? �j\ �5F ��V�� F��!#" $#& �E�AlIN*H]tWDOT_>i}�P`VgDO?SPRYCD�lIN*D�PRtWDOQG�

lIDG[OH]T�F�K�PRQ!?SH]T�@Z[R� s K DOQ!DGVgH]Q!DRc�PWYZY�N @�BE[wK3DGl!BI@Z?SPWBE@CH]T l/?`< l�Byh QIl!B(>aDAK�PRY�u]DGF�VgH]QyPRT�PRY�}rlI@ZlN < Q!NaHRlIDOlG����YZl!H c�T�HRBE@C[OD5BIK�PWBjBIK D�[wK HRlIDOT ��� N PWBEK%F <�QI@ZT�\`< Tiu]H]@C[ODGF�Q!DO\]@CH]T l�PRT F¬VgQI@C[�PWBI@ZH]T@Zl"QEPRT�F H]?�PRT F¬l![�PWB!BEDGQIDOF� s K�DOlID/uWPRYC< DOl�PRQID5T HRBj?AD�PWT @ZT \WVg< Y c2> <�BjPRQID�P(QID DO[�BE@CH]T%HRV�BEK�DV PR[�B�BEK�PWBUBIK DMPRYZ\]HRQI@CBIK ?�PRYC��P�}rl'N�QIH]N*H]lIDGl�P`uWPRYC< D�VgH]Q ��� �

¯ l!@ZT \_BIK @Zl4ur@Zl!<�PRY�QIDON�QIDOl!DOTiBwP�BE@ZHRT�PRl`P�\]< @ZF�DRc�[wK PRT \]DGl`@ZT°BEK D¬N�QIH]l!H=F @C[SN PRQEPR?ADGBIDOQ!l�U@CBIK @ZT¦PSQ!DON*D�PWB @ �«BI< N YZDM[OHR< YZF�>aDyH]> l!DOQ!uRDOF{@ZT�@CBE@ZPRYZY�}SPRT F¦BIK DOT_Y�PWBIDOQ'kr< PRTiBE@CBEPWBE@�u]DGYC}�PRT=�PRY�} 4GDOF < lI@CT \ l�BwPWBI@Zl�BE@Z[OPRY/PRT PRYC}rlI@ClO� ��T [OD{BEK D°N @�BE[wK�DOl!BI@Z?SPWBE@CH]T���PRl¦F�DGBEDGQI?A@ZT DGF:c�BEK�DD��rBIQEPR[�BEDOF�N @�BE[wK�uWPRYC< DOlJPWYZYZHv�"DOF�N�@CBE[wK|[GH]TiBEH]<�QIl`BEH_>aD¬N�YZHRB!BEDOF3lIH�BEK�P�BJPRTi}�F�@CxaDOQIDGT [ODGl�U@CBIK @ZT%Q!DON*D�PWB'l!DGBElU�"DOQIDMDO?AN K�PWlI@54GDOF:�

³�H]Q5D���PR?SN�YZDRc*@ZT�³�@Z\]<�QID(d­� f�c�BIK DyVg< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRY)VgQIDGk2< DOT [�}_VgH]Q'BEK Dy<�BIBIDOQIPRT [OD�)( " � "+* �lIN*H]tWDOT¬H]TABEK Q!DOD'F @CxaDOQ!DOTiB"@ZT l�BwPRT [GDOlGc=DOPR[wK¬[OHRT lIDG[O<�BI@Cu]DGYC}�VgH]YCYZHv�U@ZT \�BIK D'HRBEK DGQOc2@Zl�N YCHRBIBIDOF:�s K DGlID�BEK Q!DOD�<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODGl VgH]Q!?ªPjBEQ!@ZN YCDnQIDGNaDOPWB lID�B�� s K�D�h QIl!B <�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD"K PRl PUK�@Z\]K DGQ�Hvu]DOQIPRYZYVg< T F PR?SDGTiBwPRY*VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}�P�BjBEK D/HRT lID�BUHRV)BEK D �#- �(@CT )( " � "+* � C e�� d(lIDG[OH]T�F lU@ZT¬BEK�D�h�\]< Q!D F �³�< Q!BIK DOQ!?SHRQIDRc2BEK�D�h�QIl�Bj<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDRc��UK�@Z[wK%@Zl"PRYClIH`F DGlI@C\]T�PWBIDOF%PRl"BEK D5T DO<�BIQEPRYa<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODWc�@Cl

f)�

Page 35: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

lIK�H]Q!BIDOQUBEK�PRT�BEK DM?AH]QID/VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF_<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOl5H]Q�BEK DM<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl�@C?S?ADOF @ZPWBEDGYC}AVgH]YZYCHv�U@ZT \@CBO� s K @Clj��H]<�YZF�@ZT F�@Z[�P�BED�BIK�PWB�BEK�DOQID/@ClUPJF DO[GQID�PWlID4@ZT¬BIK D4lIN*D�PRt2@ZT�\AQIPWBED�PRl�BEK D/<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD@Zl�Q!DON*D�PWBIDOF:�@��T�?SHRQID/lID�u]DGQID([OPRlIDGlUHRV®uRHv��DGY®H]Q�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[OD4YZDGT \RBEK�DOT @CT \ c�BIK D4< lIDGQ'?SP�}%>*DKi}rNaDGQEPRQ�BE@Z[G< Y�P�BE@ZT�\`��H]Q!F lOc��UK @C[wK��"H]< YCF�[ODOQ�BwPR@CT YC}�YZDOPRF%BEH�NaDGQ!VgH]Q!?�PWT [OD/F DG\]QEPWF�PWBE@CH]T:�

³�@C\]< QIDSd­��f�´`³�< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRY�VgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}�[GH]TiBEH]<�QIl(HWVjBEK DS<�BIBIDOQIPRT [OD )( " � "+* �¦l!NaHRtRDOT�BIK QIDGDBE@C?SDGlOc�lIDGkr<�DOTiBE@ZPRYZY�}/>i}MP'?SPRYZD�l!NaDOPRtRDGQO� s K�D ��-.�UHWV )( " � "+* �'>aDG\]@ZT l PWB®PR>*H]<�B®e�� d�lIDO[GH]T F lG�

� ��� � � ����3�G5

¯ l!@ZT \yBEK D/N�PWQEPRYCYZDOY�<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOlUPRl"BEK D�> PRlI@Cl�VgH]Q"BIK @Zl�QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK:c�lID�u]DGQEPRY:?ADGBIK HrF l��"DOQID/<=BE@��YZ@ 4ODGF¦BEH�PRT�PRY�})4ODyBIK D`PW[OH]< l�BE@C[(PRT�F�N QIHRlIHrF @Z[M[O< DGl�VgH]Q'DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l!NaDGDO[wK:��³�@ZQ!l!B�c*PSur@ClI<�PRY@ZT�lIN*DO[GBI@ZH]T�HRV)BEK D���P�u]DGVgHRQI?0��PRlUF H]T�D�BEHJ@CF DOTiBE@�V�}AlIN*DO[O@�h�[�VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl�HRV DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY*l!NaDGDO[wK>i}�[GH]?SN PRQI@CT \_F @�xDGQIDGT2B`N�PRQEPWYZYZDGY�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGlJ�U@CBEK3F @CxaDOQ!@ZT \¦DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l!BEPWBEDGlO��;=DG[OH]T FcP¦l�BwPWBI@Zl�BE@Z[OPRY�PRT�PWYC}rlI@Cl4��PRl`N*DOQ�VgH]QI?ADOF°< l!@ZT \�BEK DAVgD�PWBI< QIDGlyBEK PWBy�"DOQ!DSur@Zl!<�PRYCYC}�H]>�lIDOQ�u]DGF:��5D��rB�c)[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T�D��=N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBEl/�"DOQID�[GH]T F < [�BEDGF°BIH¬BEDOl�BMK Hv� �"DOYCYnH]< Q4PRYC\]H]Q!@CBEK�? F�@Zl��[OQ!@Z?A@ZT�P�BEDOFA>*DGB��"DODOT%BIK D�DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRY�PRT F�T H]T=�«DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l!NaDGDO[wK%< l!@ZT \(BIK D�D��rBEQEPW[GBEDGF¬VgD�P��

fib

Page 36: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

BE<�QIDOlG�M³�@ZT�PWYZYC}Rc�P¬K2< ?�PWT�YZ@Cl!BEDGT DOQ5l!BI< F�}_��PRl/[GH]T F < [�BEDGF{BIH%PRl!lIDOl!l/BEK D`Q!DOYC@�PR> @CYZ@�B�}¬HRV�BEK�DDO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY'YZPR>*DOYZlSPRT F�BIH�N Q!H­ur@CF D�P3[GH]?SN PRQI@ClIH]TzBEH3BIK D�[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T�Q!DOl!< YCBIlO� s K DGlID?ADGBEK�H=F lj�U@CYZY:>*D/F DGlI[OQ!@Z>*DOF¦@ZT�?SHRQID/F D�BwPR@CY:@ZT�^�K�PWN�BEDGQ�f��

� ��� " �v5W�� �

s K D�[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]T�PWT F�QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T�BEPRlIt2l�PRQ!D�[OH]T=h�\]< Q!DOFq< lI@CT \�BEK�D � £®������� l!}rl!BIDO?��� £ ������� @Zl%PWTqPR<�BEHR?�PWBI@Z[�lIN*DODG[wK Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T�l!}rl!BIDO? BIK�PWB%<�BI@ZYC@54ODGl¬PR[GH]< l�BE@Z[_?SHrF DOYClOcY�PWT \]<�PR\RD�?SHrF DGYZlOc5PRT FqN Q!H]T2< T [G@�PWBI@ZH]Tq?AH=F DGYZl�BIH�F DGBIDOQI?A@ZT�D�BEK D�>*DOl�B¦Ki}rN*HRBEK DGlI@Cl�VgHRQP�lIN*H]tWDOTz<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODW� ¯ T YZ@CtRD¬?SPRTi}3HWV'BIK D%[O<�QIQIDGTiB�lIN*DODO[wKzQIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T�l�}rl!BEDG?Sl`�UK�@Z[wK< l!D`K @ZF�F DOT m PRQItWHvu_?AH=F�DOYZlGc�BEK D � £ ��� ��� l!}rl!BIDO? @Zl'lIDO\R?SDGT2B���>�PWlIDOF aBEK PWB�@ClOc�@CB'VgH=[G< lIDGlH]T¦N K H]T D�BE@C[(lIDG\]?ADOTiB�>*H]< T F PRQI@CDOl�[GH]QIQ!DOl!NaH]T�F @ZT \ABEHSlIN*DO[O@�h�[JPR[GH]< l�BE@Z[MDGuRDOTiBEl�BIH�D��=BIQEPR[�BVgD�P�BE< Q!DOlO�

� ��� � �!5 ��5

³�H]Q�BIK DJ[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T{PRT F{QIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T_BEPRlIt2lGc ?AH]l�B4HRV�BEK D`VgDOPWBE< Q!DOl/�"DOQID�[wK�PWQEPR[�BEDOQ!@54GDOF@ZT�@CBE@ZPRYZY�}��U@CBIK Q!DOl!NaDG[GB�BEH�BEK D�uRH­�"DOYCl¦@CT�BEK D{l!@Z\]T�PWY � X�?AHRBE@CH]T�[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T�@ZTiu]HRYCu]DGlF D�BEDOQ!?S@CT @ZT�\¦BEK�D%DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�N Q!H]NaDGQ!BI@ZDOlM�U@CBIK @ZT3BIK D¬<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDRc�@ZT|N PRQ!BI@Z[O<�Y�PRQ4BEK DSu]Hv��DGYlIDG\]?ADOTiBElGcR\]@�u]DOT/BIK D�lI@Z\RT�PRYiPRT�FyN K�H]T DGBI@Z[�PRYC@Z\]T ?ADOTiBIlO� ^�Y�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRT:c��UK @Z[wK(PRYZl!H�@ZTiu]HRYCu]DGlPR[GH]< l!BI@Z[`?AHrF DOYC@ZT \SPRT F_VgDOPWBE<�QID`D��=BIQEPR[�BE@CH]T:c:@Cl�F DOPRYCB5�U@CBEK_F < QI@CT \�BIK D(BEQIPR@ZT�@ZT \SN K�PRl!D`HRVBEK�D`D��=N*DOQI@C?SDGTiB��4X�?SHRBI@ZH]T¦QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T_[GH]T l!@Zl!BIl�HRV�F D�BEDOQ!?S@CT @ZT�\SBEK�D`DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY)l�BwPWBID`HRVPRT`<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[OD�>i}(<=BE@ZYC@54G@ZT \�BEK�D�PR[OHR< l!BI@Z[j?AH=F�DOYZl®PRT FJ[GH]?`> @CT @ZT�\5[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]TyQIDOl!< YCBIlO��³�H]QBEK�@Zl�BEK�DOlI@ClOc [OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T��jPWlyP�> @CT�PRQ!}_F DO[G@Zl!@ZH]T:c)@�� DW�Cc)PRT°<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD���PRlMQIDG[OH]\]T�@54ODGF3PWlDO@�BEK DGQ�NaHRlIlIDGlIl!@ZT \SDO?AHRBE@CH]T:c=VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBI@ZH]T�@CT%H]< QU[�PRl!DRc�H]QUT HWBUNaH]l!lIDGlIlI@CT \�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT:�

��������� � �)���-����.���'������ �!�"�

s K D'N QI@C?�PWQ!}y\]HiPRY HWVaVgDOPWBE< Q!DUD��rBEQIPR[GBI@ZH]TA@ZlnBIHMF�DGBEDGQI?A@ZT D'P/lID�B�HRVVgDOPWBE< Q!DOl�BEK PWB��U@ZYZY=?�P­�r�@Z?A@54GDSBIK D%F @CxaDOQ!DOT [GDOlAPR?AH]T \�F @�xDGQIDGT2B�[GY�PRl!lIDGlO�z;=@±��N Q!H]lIHrF @C[¬VgD�PWBI< QIDGl`��DGQID�D��rBEQIPR[GBIDOFF < Q!@ZT \�BIK D�[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]TqPRT FqQ!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T BwPRl!trlG� s K DGlID°N QIH]l!H=F�@Z[_VgDOPWBE< Q!DOl%�"DOQID{@CT @��

f*(

Page 37: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

BE@ZPRYZY�}�[GH]?AN <�BEDGF_PWl'uRH­�"DOY±��YCDGu]DGY VgDOPWBE<�QIDOl5PRT F�BEK�DOT_YZPWBEDGQU?�PRT�@ZN < YZPWBEDGF¬BEHA[OH]Q!QIDGlIN*H]T F @CT \<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD���YCDGuRDOY�VgD�PWBI< QIDGlO�

s K D°lI@���VgD�PWBI< QIDGl¦@CT2uRDOl�BE@Z\]PWBEDGF�VgH]Q%?SP��=@Z?(< ? F�@ZlI[GQI@C?S@CT�PWBE@CH]T��"DOQ!D3P�u]DGQEPR\RD�N @�BE[wK:cP�u]DGQEPR\]D%DGT DOQ!\R}]c�?SP��=@Z?(< ?�N @CBI[wK:c�N @�BE[wK|?AH­uRDO?ADOTiB�c�P�uRDOQEPW\]D¬u]Hv�"DOYjF <�QEPWBI@ZH]T:cnPRT F�BEK�DF @�xDGQIDOT�[OD�>*DGB��"DODGT|BEK DS?�P��=@C?`< ?�N @�BE[wK3uWPRYC< D�@ZT°BEK DAh�QIl�BJPRT F3Y�PRl�ByuRH­�"DOYCl`@ZT{BEK�D�<�B��BEDGQEPRT�[ODR� ��V�BEK�DOlID¬VgDOPWBE<�QIDOlGc�H]T D���PRlJQIDGY�PWBIDOF3BIH�BEK D�D��rBEQ!DO?SP�HRV�BEK D�<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODWc�BIK QIDGD�"DOQID�P�uRDOQEPW\]DOlGc"PWT F�BEK D�QIDO?SPR@CT @ZT \�B���H��"DOQ!D¬VgD�PWBI< QIDGl�PRlIl!H=[G@�PWBIDOF3�U@�BEK�K�H­��BEK�D¬N @CBI[wK?AH­uRDOF{BEK Q!H]< \]K�H]<�B/BEK�DA<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODR� s K�DS[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]T�l�}=l�BEDG?�< lIDGlyYC@ZT DOPRQ�F @ClI[GQI@Z?A@ZT PWBEDPRT�PWYC}rlI@ClC ¥)L'� F BEH4F DGBIDOQ!?S@CT D��UK @Z[wK�VgD�PWBI< QIDGl">*DOl�B�F @Zl![OQI@C?S@CT�PWBIDj>aD�B���DGDOT¬DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY PWT FT H]Tr��DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOlO� s K DGlID'VgD�PWBI< QIDGl��U@CYZY >*DUF DGh�T�DOF¬@CTA?AH]Q!D'F�DGBwPW@ZY�@ZTS^�K�PWN�BEDGQ�f��

��������� ������#!-���������

s K D�DGuWPRYC<�PWBI@ZH]T/HRVrBEK�D�[GY�PRl!lI@�h�[�PWBI@ZH]T4PWT FyQ!DO[GH]\]T @�BE@ZHRT/D��=NaDGQI@C?SDGT2BIl)@Zl�>�PRl!DOFy?�PR@CT YC}'H]T4BEK�DDOQ!QIH]Q�QEPWBID4PRl�@CB�QIDOYZPWBEDGl�BEHJBIK D�BEK Q!DOl!K H]YZF¬uWPRYC< D�BIK�PWBj��PRlU[OH]?AN <�BIDOF:� s K�@ZljBEK�DOlI@CljVgH=[G< lIDGl?AH]QID�H]TM@ZF�DOTiBE@�V�}=@CT \jBEK�D"PW[OH]< l�BE@C[�[GH]QIQ!DOYZPWBEDGl�HRV�PRT4DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYR<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD�PWl HRN NaHRlIDOF4BEHUBEK�D?AH]QID�[wK�PRYCYZDGT \]@ZT�\¬BwPRl!t°HWVj@Z?AN Q!H­ur@CT \%lIN*DODG[wK|QIDO[GH]\]T @�BE@CH]T{NaDGQ!VgH]Q!?�PRT�[ODR� ��?SN�QIHvu]DG?SDGT2BIl@ZT�Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T%N*DOQ�VgH]QI?SPRT [GD��U@ZYCYK H]N*DGVg<�YZYC}�>aD/<�T F DOQ�BwPRtWDOT�@CT%BEK D/Vg<�BI< QIDW�

� ��� " + � � ��� �

��T¦BIK @ZlU[wK�PWN�BEDGQOc�BEK DMD��=N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBwPRY)?ADGBIK H=F�H]YZH]\W}�@Cl'N�QIDOl!DOTiBEDGF{PRl5PRT_PWN N QIH]PR[wK¦VgH]QU@CF DOT=�BE@�V�}r@ZT \�PRT�F�@CTiu]DOl�BE@C\iPWBE@CT \|YZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z[�PWT F N�QIH]l!H=F @C[_VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl�BEK�PWB�PWQID�[OHRQIQIDGY�PWBIDOF��U@CBIKDO?AHRBI@ZH]T:� s K QIDGD{[OH]Q!NaH]QIP�PRQID�K @C\]K YC@Z\]KiBEDGF:cU�U@CBEK�BIK DO@CQ%F�PWBEP�[GH]YZYCDO[�BE@ZHRT:c�BEQEPWT lI[GQI@ZN=BE@ZHRTBEDG[wK T @Ckr<�DOlOcnPRT F°[OH]Q!N < l(N�QIH]N*DOQ�BE@ZDGlMPRYZl!H¦>*DO@CT \�?SDGT2BI@ZH]T�DOF:�S�0\]DGT DOQIPRY�Hvu]DOQ�ur@ZDG� HWV�BEK�D[OHRT2BI@ZT2< H]<�lyN @�BE[wK{F D�BEDO[�BE@CH]T3PWYZ\]H]Q!@CBIK ?,PWT F°BIK D�[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]T{PRT F°QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T�l!}rl�BEDO?Al< l!DOF_@CT%BEK @Cl�QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK�PRQ!DMPRYZl!HJN QIDGlIDOTiBIDOF:�

f!�

Page 38: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

f �

Page 39: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � ��� ��� �

� � � � � � ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � �

��� � � � � � � �

s K DyDOY�P�BE@ZHRT¦HRV�BEK DyQIDO[GDOTiB�>�@ZQ!BIK_HRV�PS[wK @CYZF�H]Q5BIK DMVgQ!< l!BIQEPWBI@ZH]T¦HRV�D���N*DOQ!@ZDGT [O@CT \¬PA?S@ClIlIDGF @C\]KiBU[�PRT�>aD4Q!DO[OHR\]T @54GDOF��U@CBIK H]<�B�ur@Zl!<�PRY�[G< DOlG��³�H]Q�@CT l!BEPRT [ODWc�@Z?SPR\]@CT D5BIK�PWB�}]HR<¦��PRTiB'BIHBEDGYZY�P�VgQI@ZDGT F��UK H�@Zl � e]e¬?A@ZYZDGl�P���Pv}�HRV�BEK DJF DGYZ@�u]DOQ�}_HWV"}RH]< Q�h�Q!l!BE>*H]Q!T°[wK�@ZYZFc< l!@ZT \%BEK�DBEDGYZDGN K H]T D(PRlUBEK Dy?SDGF @Z< ?0VgH]Q5D��=[wK�PRT \]D(HRVn@CT�VgH]QI?SPWBI@ZH]T:� s HSNaHRQ!BEQIP�}%BEK DyD��=[O@�BEDO?ADOTiB5HRVBEK�DMHr[O[OPRlI@CH]T:c HRT D4?S@C\]KiBUlIN*D�PRt��U@�BEK¦PJK @Z\]K�DOQ�N @�BE[wK�H]QjBEK DMlIN*D�PWtr@CT \�QEPWBID4?�P�}¬@CT [OQ!D�PRl!DlIYC@Z\]KiBIYC}]�nµ'DG\iPRQIF�YZDOl!l�HRV �UK�PWB'PR[�BE<�PRYCYC}S\]HrDOl�H]T:c=BEK DGQID4@ZlUPRT�D��=BIQIDG?SDGYC}¬K�@Z\]K�[wK�PRT�[OD/BEK�P�B}]HR< QUD��=[O@�BEDO?ADOTiBU�U@ZYCY:>*D/lI< [G[ODOl!l!Vg< YCYC}�[GH]Tiu]DG}RDOF�BIH�BIK D4YZ@Cl!BEDGT DOQG�

��l�@CYZYZ<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF¬@ZTSBEK @CljlI@C?SN YCD�D�� PW?SN YCDRc=DO?AHRBE@CH]T¬[�PWT�>*D�N*DOQ![ODO@�u]DGF¦T HWB�H]T Y�}SBIK QIH]<�\]K\]DGl!BE<�QIDOl�PRT F�V PR[O@ZPRY:D���N�QIDOl!lI@CH]T lOca> <�B5PRYClIHJ�U@CBIK¦H]T�YC}¬BIK DyN�QIDOl!DOT [GD(HRVnPR< F @�BEH]Q�}%@ZT=VgH]QI?SP��BE@CH]T:��;rH(BEK D�PRN N Q!H]N Q!@�PWBID�k2< DOl�BE@CH]T�BEK�DOT%>*DO[OHR?SDGlOc� ² Hv� PRQID'��D/PW> YZD'BEH(F�DGBEDG[GBUDG?SHRBI@ZH]T�U@CBIK�HRT YC}�PR< F @C> YZDJ[GYZ< DGl�� � s K DGQID�K PRlMPRYZQ!D�PRF�}�>aDGDOT3l!H]?ADAQ!DOl!D�PRQ![wK3F H]T�DS@CT{BIK @ZlMPRQ!D�P��;=[wK Q!H=F�DOQ5PRT F�K @Zl�[GH]YZYCD�PR\]<�DOl�lIK�H­�"DOF¦BEK�PWBUBIK DMPR?`< l!DO?ADOTiB�D��=N QIDGlIlI@CH]T:c�T�PR?ADOY�}¬l!?S@CYZ@ZT�\ c@Zljur@ClI<�PRY)PWT F�PR< F @C> YZD/@CT�l!NaDGDO[wK�� �*�W� �

s K @Zl�BIK DOl!@Zl�D��=N YZH]Q!DOl�BIK H]lIDJN PRQEPR?ADGBIDOQ!l�BEK�P�B4PRYZYCHv� P¬YZ@Zl�BEDGT DOQ�BIH¬F D�BEDO[�ByP¬NaDGQI[ODG@CuRDOFDO?AHRBI@ZH]T¬@CT�PJlIN*DODO[wK�lI@C\]T�PRY�� m H]Q!D/lIN*DO[G@Ch�[OPRYZY�}]c=BIK @Zl�QIDOl!D�PRQ![wK¦�U@CYZY*<�BE@CYZ@54GD5BIK D/t2T Hv�UYZDOF�\]DHRVK Hv��K2< ?�PWT l�QIDO[GH]\]T @ 4OD'DO?AHRBE@CH]TAPRT FSPWBIBIDO?AN�B�BEHM[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQI@ 4OD'DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY=lIN*DODG[wK�VgH]Q�P[OHR?SN <=BEDOQG� s K D/\]HiPWYaHRV)BIK @Zl�BIK DOl!@Zlj@Cl�BEH(@ZF DGT2BI@CV�}SN QIHRlIHrF @Z['VgD�PWBI< QIDGlUPRT F%K Hv��BEK D�}%PWxaDO[�BBEK�DMN*DOQ![ODGN�BE@CH]T¦HWVnPJ< l!DOQ � l'DO?AHRBE@CH]T:�

f*+

Page 40: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

s K D(?ADGBIK HrF H]YZHR\R}¬F D�u]DGYZH]N*DOF_VgHRQUBIK @Zl�BIK DOl!@Zl'@ZlU< lID�Vg< Y)VgH]QU[OH]?AN�PRQ!@ZT \APRT F_PRT�PRY�})4O@ZT�\lIN*DODG[wK�uWPRQ!@�PWBI@ZH]T�l�F < D�BIHJDO?AHRBE@CH]T:� s K�D/QIDON*DGBI@CBI@ZH]T¬HWV®<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlUl�BEQI<�[GBE<�QIDOF�DOl!lIDGT2BI@�PRYCYC}@ZF�DOTiBE@C[�PRYCYC}]c >i}�[GH]T lIDG[O<�BI@CuRDOYC}�VgH]YZYCHv�U@ZT \�D�PW[wKzHWBEK DGQ`PRT F|l!NaHRtRDOT�>i}°BEK D¬lIPR?AD�lIN*D�PWtRDOQGcPRYCYZHv� [OH]?AN�PRQ!@ZlIHRT°HWV�F @�xDGQIDGT [ODGly[OPR< lIDGF3>i}�uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T l�@CT�N QIHRlIHrF @Z[JVgD�P�BE< Q!DOl4H]T Y�}]�A³�QID��k2< DOTiBIYC}]cjBIK DOl!D�N Q!H]lIHrF @Z[�uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T l�[OHRQIQIDGlIN*H]T F�BIH|P�[wK PRT \]D¦@ZT�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�l!BEPWBEDW� �5TPRT�PWYC}rlI@Cl�HRV�BIK DOl!DJQIDON*D�P�B/<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODGl/lIDGQ!u]DGlMPRl�BEK�D`>�PRl!@Zl�HWV"<�T F DOQ!l!BEPRT F @CT \�PRT F�D�u]DGT2BI<=�PRYCYC}S[wK�PRQEPW[GBEDGQI@ 4O@ZT�\ADG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRYl!NaDGDO[wK:�

s K D'QIDO?SPR@CT F DOQ�HRVaBIK @Zl�[wK PRN�BEDGQ��U@ZYZY=[OHvu]DGQ�BIK D�uWPRQI@CH]< l�?ADGBEK�H=F l�DG?SN�YZHv}]DGFABIHM@CF DOTiBI@CV�}D��rBIQEPR[�BwPR> YCD5VgDOPWBE< Q!DOl�BEH`>*D�< l!DOF%F <�QI@ZT�\yBEK�D�[OYZPRlIl!@Ch�[OPWBE@CH]TSPRT F¬Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]TAD��=N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBElG�� F @ClI[G< lIl!@ZH]T�HRV�BIK D`QIDGlI< Y�BEl�VgH]Q'BEK DGlIDJD���N*DOQ!@Z?ADOTiBEl��U@CYZY PRYClIH¬>*DJN QIDGlIDGT2BIDOF:�`;=DO[�BE@CH]T�f����[OHvuRDOQIljBIK D/PRT PRYC}rlI@Cl"BIDO[wK T @Ck2< DOljBIK�PWB��"DOQ!D/< lIDGF�F < QI@CT \yur@ClI<�PRYa@ZT l!NaDG[GBI@ZH]T¬HWV�BEK D5F�PWBwP=���F @ClI[O<�lIlI@CH]T%HRV�BIK D�lIN*DO[�BEQ!H]\]QEPW?Sl�PRT F%N Q!H]lIHrF�}i��>�PWlIDOF¬BIH=HRYZlOc=PRl��"DOYCYPWl�BEK D�lIDGBjHRV�VgD�PWBI< QIDGl[wK H]l!DOT�VgH]Q�?�P­��@C?`< ?�F @Zl![OQ!@Z?A@ZT�PWBI@ZH]TS@ZlUN Q!DOlIDGTiBEDOF�

;=DO[�BE@CH]T�f=� d/\]@CuRDOl�PRTAHvu]DOQ�ur@ZDG�qHWVaBIK DU[OY�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRTAD��=NaDGQI@Z?ADOTiBIlOcrF DGBEPR@ZYC@ZT \�BIK DUBEQEPW@ZT=�@ZT�\¬PRT F�BEDGl!BE@CT \¬[GH]T F @�BE@ZHRT lU< lIDGF�VgH]Q5>*HRBIK¦BEK�D(QIDOPRY®PRT F�PR[�BEDGF�F�PWBEP�� s K D(Q!DOlI<�YCBEl5HRV�BEK�DQIDG[OH]\RT @CBI@ZH]T�BEPRlIt2lUPRQ!D/N QIDGlIDGT2BIDOF¦PRlj�"DOYZY���;=DG[GBE@CH]T�f�� f`N QIDGlIDOTiBIl5µ �M^�N YCHRBEl�VgHRQ�BEK D�PR[GBIDOFF�PWBEP�c�PRT�F�BIK D4lI< ?A?�PWQ!}¬@CT¦;=DO[�BE@ZHRT¦f=�,��[OHRT [OYC< F DOlUBEK�@Zl�[wK�PRN=BEDOQG�

� ��� � �)5 + �� ��/�G5�$&�'�������

2qK @CYZDJBEK DSN QIDGlIDGT [OD%HRVjDO?AHRBE@CH]T�?SP�}°>aDANaDGQI[GDO@CuRDOF|l!< >r�!DO[�BE@�u]DOY�}3>i}3P¦K2< ?SPRT3YC@Zl�BEDOT�DOQOcP%?SD�BEK HrF�HRV�ur@ZlI< PRYZY�}_F @ClIN YZP�}=@CT \%D��rBIQEPR[�BwPR> YCDJlIN*DODG[wK�VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl4@Zl/@C?SN*H]Q!BEPRTiB�VgH]Q5h�T F @CT \H]>r�!DG[GBI@Cu]D/?AD�PWlI< Q!DO?ADOTiBElGc�DOlIN*DO[G@�PRYCYC}�VgH]Q"Y�PWBIDOQ�<�lID/@ZT�PWT�PR<�BEHR?�PWBI@Z['DO?AHRBE@CH]T¬Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]Tl!}rl�BEDO?�� ��T D�HRV=BEK D�?AH]l!B [OHR?S?AH]T4?SDOPRT l�VgH]Q�l�BE< F�}r@CT \�l!H]< T Fy@Zl)>i}4< lI@CT \'P'l!NaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?¦�� lIN*DO[GBIQIH]\RQEPR? @ZlSP°ur@ClI<�PRYUQ!DON Q!DOlIDGTiBwPWBI@ZH]T�HWV/lIH]<�T F�BEK PWB�@ClS[GQIDOPWBEDGF�>i} F�@ZlIN�Y�P�}r@ZT \�PVgQIDGk2< DOT [�}i�«BE@C?SD4N YCHRB�HRV®@ZTiBIDOT l!@CB�}%DGT [OHrF DOF¦H]T¦P�\RQEP�}i��lI[OPRYZDW�

��T HWBEK DGQM��P�}�BEH�F @Zl!N Y�P�}¦BEK DADO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY®[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQI@Cl!BI@Z[OlGc)@ZT{N�PRQ�BE@Z[G< Y�PWQ�BEK D�N Q!H]lIHrF @C[[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQ!@Zl!BI@Z[GlOc)@ZT�BEK�DAl!NaDGDO[wK°�jP�u]D�VgH]QI? @Cl��U@CBEK�Vg< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRYnVgQ!DOk2< DGT [G}{[GH]TiBEH]< Q!lO� ��TBEK�@Zl/QIDGlIDOPRQI[wK:c)BEK�D`Vg< T F�PR?ADOTiBEPRY�VgQIDGk2< DOT [�}°[OH]TiBEHR< QIl��"DOQ!DS[GH]?SN�<�BEDGF°<�lI@ZT�\¦P%N @�BE[wK{F D��BEDG[GBI@ZH]T°PRYC\]H]QI@�BEK ? F DGlI@C\]T DOF{VgH]Q/[GH]TiBE@ZT2< HR< l4lIN*DODO[wK�S³�H]Q/F�DGBwPW@ZYZl�PR>aHR<�B/BEK @Cl4PRYZ\RH]QI@�BEK ?�c

�ie

Page 41: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

N YCD�PRl!DMQ!DGVgDGQUBIH¦� �!+�� �9�@ClI<�PRY2@CT lIN*DO[�BE@ZHRT(HRV BIK D"��P�u]D�VgH]QI?Al®��PRlnPWT(@Z?AN*H]Q!BEPRTiB®l�BEDGN`@ZTMh�T F @CT \5N�QIH]?A@Zl!@ZT \UVgD�P��

BE<�QIDOlUVgH]QjBIK D4[OY�PWlIlI@�h�[�P�BE@ZHRT¬BwPRl!t*��^�H]T l!DOk2< DGT2BIYC}RcaK2< T F�QIDOF�l�HRV®F @�PWYZH]\]<�DOlj�"DOQID4h�Q!l!B'k2<�PRY��@CBEPWBE@�u]DGYC}�PRT�PRY�})4ODOFzPRT�Fz<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOl�@CT lIN*DO[�BEDOFz< l!@ZT \�l!NaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?Sl�PWT F�N QIH]l!H=F=}2�«>�PRl!DOFBEHrH]YClj@ZT%H]Q!F DOQ�BIHAQ!DOl!H]YCuRD�BEK D4lI<�>r�!DO[�BE@CuRDyN�QIH]N*DOQ�BE@ZDGl�HRV®DO?AHRBE@CH]T%@ZTiBEHJ?AD�PWlI< QIPR> YZDWc N Ki}rlI@±�[�PWY�N QIH]N*DOQ�BE@CDOlO�

� ������� � �I��7"-/�!8r �!� o ����# �'8 ��8

L�< Q!@ZT \�BIK DJD�PWQIYC}¦l!BEPR\]DGlMHWV�BIK @Zl5BEK DGlI@ZlGc:BEK D �5 *¡¢£)¡r¤ [OH]Q!N < l/�jPWl/HRV�N QI@C?�PRQ�}�@ZTiBEDGQIDOl�B>*DO[�PW< lIDS@CB4�jPWl(H]> l!DOQ�u]DOF�BIH_K�P�uRD�>*HRBEK�YZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[JPRT F3PR[OH]<�l!BE@C[S[G< DOlMVgH]QMDO?AHRBE@CH]T:���5TD���PR?AN YCD/F @�PRYCH]\]< D�VgQ!H]?0BIK D �� �¡:¢£)¡r¤ [OH]Q!N < l�BEK�P�B'��PRl'Y�PR>*DOYCDOF�PRl�VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF¦@ClUlIK Hv�UT@ZT s PR> YCD�f����]� ¯ lI@CT \"�!< l!B�BIK D�[OHRT2BID��rB�@ZT�VgHRQI?SPWBE@CH]T:c�K H]N*DGVg< YCYC}M@CB�@Cl�V PR@CQIYC}MD�u=@CF DOTiB�BIK�PWB�BEK�D< l!DOQ'K�PRF�lIH]?AD4F @ .A[O<�YCB�}¬�U@�BEK�BEK D4F @ZPRYZH]\R< D�l!}rl�BEDO?�� ¯ NaHRT¦@CT lIN*DO[�BE@ZHRT�HWV�BEK�@ZlUF @�PWYZH]\]<�DRcP4Tr<�?`>aDGQ�HRV:@CT2BIDOQ!DOl!BI@ZT \MYZ@CT \]< @Cl!BI@Z["VgDOPWBE<�QIDOl��"DOQID5H]> l!DOQ!uRDOF:� ��T D�VgD�P�BE< Q!D'BIK�PWB��jPWl�VgH]<�T F��PRl�BEK D(< lIDJHRV�T DG\iPWBI@Cu]D([OH]T l�BEQ!< [GBIH]QIlGc�@ � DRc ��� s�� c �J�I��T�BEK @Cl�D���PR?AN YZDWcaBIK DJ< lIDGQ�< l!DOlBEK�@Zl�lIDGTiBEDOT�[OD(l�BEQ!< [GBI< QID4BEH�[wK�PRT�\]DMBIK DMPRQIQ!@CuWPRYaF DOl�BE@ZT PWBE@CH]T:�

��T HWBEK DGQMYC@ZT \R< @Zl�BE@Z[4VgD�P�BE< Q!D`BEK�PWB/��PRl4H]> l!DOQ�u]DOF�F < Q!@ZT \%l!DGu]DGQEPRY�HRV�BEK�D �� �¡:¢£)¡r¤ F @��PRYCH]\]< DGl'��PRl�Q!DON*D�PWBIDOF�Q!DOk2< DGl!BElG� s K�DOQID`PRQIDyPRYZl!HSl!DGuRDOQEPWY�D���PR?AN YCDOl'HRV�QIDGNaDOPWBEDGF�QIDGk2< DOl�BEl@ZT�BEK DylEPR?AN YCDyF @ZPRYZHR\]< DR���T�\RDOT DGQEPRY�ca@�B5��PRl�H]>�lIDOQ�u]DGF�BEK�PWB�QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T�DOQIQ!H]Q�N�QIH]?AN�BEDGFQIDGNaD�BE@�BE@ZHRT|HRV�@CT�VgH]Q!?�PWBI@ZH]T� s K DGlID�QIDON*DGBI@CBI@ZH]T lJN�QIH]?AN�BEDGF�PWTz@CTiBEDOQ!DOl�BE@ZT�\�PWN N QIH]PR[wKzVgHRQ[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQ!@54O@CT \�DG?SHWBE@ZHRT�PRY�lIN*DODG[wK:�/³�H]Q'@ZT l�BwPRT�[ODRc�BEK�D`QIDGNaD�BE@CBI@ZH]T�HRV � � ? T HRB�QID�BE< Q!T @ZT \��?AHRBE@�uRP�BEDOFJBIK D5l�BE< F=}SHWV:HRBIK DOQ�N�PRQIPRYZYCDOY <=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlG�"bReMN PRQEPRYCYZDGY�<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOl"�"DOQ!D5VgH]<�T F�@CTBEK�D �� �¡:¢£)¡r¤ [OHRQIN < lGcrPRT FJ@CB®�jPWl�HWV�BEDOT`VgHR< T F`BEK PWB�BEK D�QIDON*D�P�BEDOF�<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDOl�K�PRFAP�?AH]QIDVgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF3DG?SHRBI@ZH]T PRYnl!BEPWBEDW� m PRTi}{< l!DOQ!l(DO?AN K�PWlI@54GDOF�?S@ClIQIDG[OH]\RT @54GDOF{��H]Q!F lMH]QMPRYCBIDOQIDGFBEK�D`l!BIQI< [�BE< Q!D`HRV�BEK�D`lIDGT2BIDOT [GDR�M³�@CT�PRYZY�}]c BIK D`D���PR?AN YCD(F @ZPRYZH]\R< D4lIK Hv�Ul4P�N Q!DO?SPWBE<�QIDyBIDOQ �?A@ZT�PWBI@ZH]T¦[OH]?A?SPRT F:�4��Y�BEK HR< \]K_BIK @Zl�YC@ZT \R< @Zl�BE@Z[4VgD�P�BE< Q!DJ@Zl�< l!DGVg< Y®VgH]Q/PRT�PWYC}rlI@Cl�N < Q!NaH]l!DOlGcBEK�D/QIDOl!< YCBj< lI<�PWYZYC}SDOT�F l�@ZT¬BIK D�F @ZPRYZH]\R< D�>*DO@CT \(BEDGQI?A@ZT�P�BEDOF�PWT F¬BEK D/@CTiBEDOT�F DOF�\]HiPWY>*DO@ZT�\< T l!< [O[GDOl!l!Vg< Y�� ��BIK DOQyYZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[�VgDOPWBE<�QIDOlyBEK�PWBy��DGQID%H]>�lIDOQ�u]DGFz@CT3BEK�D �� �¡:¢£)¡2¤ [GH]QIN�< l�"DOQID`PRT�@ZT�[OQIDOPRlID(@ZT¦BIK D(VgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}�HWV�[OH]Q!QIDO[�BE@CH]T�[OHR?S?SPRT F lGcal���DOPRQ��"H]QIF�lOcuRH=[OPR> < YZPRQ!}@ZT�F @Z[OPWBE@CT \5@CQIQ!@CBwP�BE@ZHRTMl!< [wKAPRl !?AH]Q!H]T ��PWT F �VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBE@CT \8� c�@ZTiBIDOQIQ!H]\iPWBI@CuRD�l!BEPWBEDG?SDGTiBElOc2PWT F

� �

Page 42: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� �  �¡�� ��  2 £ �  �¡�  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $ ����� ; < � � "+@ * $ � � � $#& � " � � $#* � * B � � �#5��G� & " 5�� & 5 "+*)(�� $ > 70� @ ; : " � �

� $#&��� �  �¡�� £�� ��� � < ����  � � � � � 2 ���)  ¢�)  ;��   � � < � 9 � � � �g¢�®  � �¡ � �

�.� � � � � � � � � ¡�  ; �   � £ <�  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � ; < � � � $ $ $%� $#* �<: " 7+: " � � " 5������ *0" >�: "+@ ; � * B�7 " � $#&=* B<�<B @A"+* � * � ( � $ ���

� * $ �� $ 5�� $#@ � $ � BE�8� ( � :=�8� ( �8� " >�B � � � $#& � " � * � !#" � B @ � �� �  �¡�� <   ��� �T��; ¤���£ �  �£�� X�! ��� � � � � ��£ �   �:  � ���  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $ ����� � * $ �� $ 5�� $#@ � $ � BE�8� $#@ � &=@ ( ��� ? &=@A" 01. (�� � @ � $#& � * $#! B ( "

�<: " � �1� * $ D#B ���8� " ( " � � * � &=*0" �<B � "%$#* ��B * � B @A"��� �  �¡�� £�� � � � £ � ; ¢ �:£ ;=<)< ¤ ����� ��� � � �.� � � �:� � � 23� ; �:  �  �¡ ¢ ���*¤

¤ � £ ��� � � � ����� � �.� � � �:� � � �   � £ < � � ¡�  ;�  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $#*C* �9� ; < � @A$ � 5 & * " >�:=�8��� $#& 5+��B ( (� �  �¡�� � 2 ;�� � � � � � � 2 ���)  < � 9 � � =¡ � � �.� � � � � � � �   � £ < � � ¡�  ;�  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $ ��� � * $ �� $ 5�� $#@ � $ � "6$#& � ( � :=�8� ( �8� " >�B � � � $#& � " � * � !#" � B @ � �� �  �¡�� £�� ;�� � ��; � � <   ��� � �¡r¤���£ �   �:  � ���  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $ ����� � * $ �� $ 5�� $#@ � $ � "6$#& � $#@ � & @ ( ��� ? & @A" 01. ( � � @ � $#& � * $#! B ( "

�<: " � �1� * $ D#B ���8� " ( " � � * � &=*0" �<B � "%$#* ��B * � B @A"��� �  �¡�� � ��  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $ ������� BE�#:4� 5 � *0$ �� $ 5�� $#@ � $ � "6$#& � ( " � � * �<B @ � � " �<> "6"+@���� .1.,��� � @ (

010 � .1. � � $#@ � & @ ( ��� ? & @A" 01. ( � @A" � $ � "+@ � � � " �#5 " (A(A(A( � : "+* " � * "@A$�@A$#@ 5�� $�� � BE�#:4�<5 ( ; :=� !#" � BE�#:4�<5 $#@ &.� "+* B�70� @ ��� " � �9�I��� $#*0" � @ &.B * � $#* � : > " 5��!��� B @ �8� � $#* " &.B * � B @A" 5 � � @ ("! @ B<� " ( ( � : ".��* 5���� BE�#:4� � " � !#" 5�8�$# �&% .���� � @ (;� *C* B !#" 5 �8�(' �&% . � � (*) $#& � *�* B !#" �<: " � $ � � $ >�B @ � ( ��� (

� �  �¡�� ��� �� ; ��� � � � 2 <�� ��9 ��� � ; ��  � < ���®  � � 2 <��:��9 � � ���)  < � 9 � ��!�¤ � £ � � ; ¡X� ; � � � �   ;����,; ¡�¡G� �   ; � � � >

�  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $#*C* �9� ; < � @A$ � 5 & * " >�:=�8��� $#& 5+��B ( (� �  �¡�� � � 2 <��:��9 � � ���) 4 < � 9 � ��  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $ ������� BE�#:4� 5 � *0$ �� $ 5�� $#@ � $ � "6$#& � ( " � � * �<B @ � � " �<> "6"+@���� .1.,��� � @ (

010 � .1. � � $#@ � & @ ( ��� ?4&=@A" 01. ( � @A" � $ � "+@ � � � " �#5 " (A(A( � : "+* " � * "@A$�@A$#@ 5�� $�� � BE�#:4�<5 ( ; :=� !#" � BE�#:4�<5 $#@ &.� "+* B�70� @ ��� " � �9�I��� $#*0" � @ &.B * � $#* � : > " 5��!��� B @ �8� � $#* " &.B * � B @A" 5 � � @ ("! @ B<� " ( ( � : ".��* 5���� BE�#:4� � " � !#" 5�8�$# �&% .���� � @ (;� *C* B !#" 5 �8�(' �&% . � � (*) $#& � *�* B !#" �<: " � $ � � $ >�B @ � ( ��� (

� �  �¡�� � � ; ¤ ��� <)< ; ¡�¡G� �   � �   �?; ¤ <�; �: �¡ �¬£ ���  *¡ � � ;��:� ;�� ¤:2 ; ¤ �� � ; ¤ ��� � � 2 �5£®¢�� � � � � ¡�  ;�� ; ��¡

�  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � � $#*C* �9� ; < � @A$ � 5 & * " >�:=�8��� $#& 5+��B ( (� �  �¡�� � � 2 ��£ ¢� � � ��   < � 9 � � � �g¢��  ��  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ � ; : " � * (3� $#& �#5 $���� $#& � ��� * " 5 ( & �C� "+* � $#& :=� !#" 5 " � " 7)� " (G�<: " � BE�#:4� 5 � $#*

� $#& * B<�<B @A"+* � * ��� ; >�B � � � " ��� � " � $ � $ $ $ &9� �<: " ��� * "A( ; 5 �<: "+* " 5 $ � " � : B @ �" � 5 " ; 70� @ ( $ � $#* � $#&��

� �  �¡�� � � ; ¤+� � ¡�  ;�� ; ��¡,�G£ �   �:  � ���

�2d

Page 43: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

�  �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤ � � $ ���9� !G� &.B * > ��� 5(� BE�#:4� 5 � * $ �� $ 5�� $#@ � $ � "6$#& � ( " � � * �<B @ �E� " �<> "6"+@��� .1. ��� � @ ( 010 � .1. � � $#@ � &=@ ( ��� ? & @A" 01. ( � @A" � $ � "+@ � � � " �#5 "(A(A( � : "+*0" � *0" @A$ @A$#@ 5�� $�� � BE�#:4�<5 ( ; :=� !#" � � BE�#:4� 7 $#@ @A" 7)�<B @ ��B @ " >) $#* $ 5 � � > & � * (�B � � " � ! B @ � �8� # � .1.���� � @ (�� *C* B ! B @ ���8��� �&% . � � (*) $#&� *�* B !#" �<: " � $ � � $ >�B @ ��( ��� � � $#& � (,�<:=�8� > $#* $ �

� �  *¡�� � � ; ¤�  �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤ � ! �E&.B * > ��� 5 � BE�#:4� '���."7�7 $#@ @A" 7)�<B @ ��� $ � $#* " � @ &.B * � BE�#:4����,GB @ " >

) $#* $ 5�� "+@ @A" (��.:=�#5 � "6"+@ � ( ( " ( � $ � $#& * B<� B @A"+* � * � ( ) $#& ( " � � * � $ 5�� $#@�8��# � .1. ��� � @ ( � *�* B !#" B @ � "6$#& � �8��� �&% . � � ( ) $#& � *�* B !#" � : " � $ � � $ >�B @ �( ��� ( � :=�8� ( �8� " >�B � � � $#& � " * " � & *C@ B @ � $#@ �

� �  *¡�� £:� ���C� � � �z¡�  �£ ¡ � � ��9�  �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤ � ; < � 5 $#*C* �9�-� & � ; (�B ( @6< � 70�8�97+:?� : " ( �8� "A( � $#& � ( � $#&E� � " �#5 " * " � " �8�.B<�

� � " �#5 "��� �  *¡�� ���C� � � �z¡�  �£ ¡ � � ��9�  �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤ � � $ ���9�=� * $ � � "6$#& � � $ $ 5�� $#@ $#@ � : &=* 5+( ��� ? & � � 0 # ( � � @ � $#& � * $#! B ( "

� : " � �1� * $ D#B ���8� " ( " � � * � &=* " � B � "%$#* ��B * � B @A"��� �  *¡�� � � � ¡ 9   � ��� � ¤� �  �¡:¢a£ ¡2¤ � � $#*�* ��� ; < � @A$ ��5 &=*0" >�:=�8� � $#& 5+��B ( (s PR> YZDAf����]´4Xn��PR?SN�YZD�HRV�P%VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF3F @ZPRYZHR\]< D`@CT{BIK D �  �¡:¢£)¡r¤ @Z\]KiB/BIQEP�u]DGY"F HR?�PR@CT:�s K @Cl'F�@�PRYCH]\]< D�@CT [OYC< F DGl�YZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[5VgD�P�BE< Q!DOlUBEK�PWB��"DOQ!D(K DGYZN�Vg<�Y:@ZT�F D�BEDOQ!?S@CT @ZT�\JN QIH]?A@Zl!@ZT \VgD�P�BE< Q!DOl�VgH]Q�DO?AHRBI@ZH]T%[GY�PRl!lI@Ch [�PWBI@ZH]T:�

uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T lj@CT¬BEK D �� �¡¢£)¡r¤ l�}=l�BEDG? [GH]?A?�PRT�F lO���T�PRF F @�BE@CH]TMBIH�h�T F�@ZT \5YZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[�VgDOPWBE<�QIDOl BEK�P�BnlI@C\]T�PRYCDOF(P�< lIDGQ���PRl�VgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF:ciPR[GH]< l �

BE@C[jVgD�PWBI< QIDGl�BEK�PWB��"DOQ!D5HR> lIDGQ!u]DGF%PRYClIH�BEHRYZFAP/lI@Z?A@ZYZPRQ l!BEHRQ!}]��;rH]?SD�HWVaBIK D'PR[OH]<�l!BE@C[jVgD�PWBI< QIDGlBEK PWBj�"DOQID4N Q!DOl!DOTiB�@CT¬BEK D �5 *¡¢£)¡r¤ F�PWBwPJPWT F%BEK DGT�YZPWBEDGQj@ZTiuRDOl!BI@Z\iP�BEDOF�@CT¬BEK D/HRBIK DOQ�[OH]Q �N*H]QEPU��DGQIDj[wK�PWT \]DOl�@ZT(Vg< T�F�PR?ADOTiBwPRYiVgQ!DOk2< DOT�[G}]c2DGT DOQ!\R}]c]Ki}rN*DOQEPWQ!BE@C[O< YZPWBE@CH]T:c�> QIDOPWBEKi}ylI@C\]K lOcPRT F%[wK PRT \]DGl'@CT%lIN*D�PRt2@CT \JQEPWBIDR��©"}�?�PWtr@CT \`< l!D/HRV >aHWBEK¬BEK�D/YZ@ZT�\]< @Zl�BE@C[�PRT�F�PR[OH]<�l!BE@C[�VgD�P��BE<�QIDOlGc��"D���DGQID4PR>�YZD5BIH`k2<�PRYC@CBwP�BE@CuRDOY�}APRlIl!DOlIljBIK D�D�xDG[GB�BEK PWBjDG?SHRBI@ZH]TSK�PRljHRT¬QIDG[OH]\]T�@CBE@CH]T:�

� ������� $'&`�)� ����7�����&4�/�!� o ����# �'8 ��8

;=N*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?AlMPRQIDAP¬B��"HW��F @C?SDGT lI@CH]T�PRY�QIDON�QIDOl!DOTiBwP�BE@ZHRT3HRV�BEK DAlIK�H]Q!B��«BE@C?SD`³�HR< QI@CDOQ�BEQIPRT l �VgH]Q!? PRT�F%N QIHvur@ZF D4PWT%DGxaDO[GBI@CuRD��jP�}�BIH�PRT�PRY�})4OD�l!@Z\]T�PWY[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQ!@Zl!BI@Z[GlO��³�@C\]< QID�f��w��lIK Hv�UllIN*DO[�BEQ!H]\]QEPW?Sl�HWV�BIK DJ<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD !lI[GQEPWBI[wK°BIK�PWB0�%l!NaHRtRDOT{>i}{P�VgDG?�PRYCD(l!NaDOPRtRDGQO� s K�D`u]DOQ �BE@C[�PRYnP��=@Zl/QIDGN QIDGlIDGT2BIlyBIK DAVgQ!DOk2< DGT [O@CDOlMHRV"BIK D�lIN*DO[�BEQEPWY�[OH]?ANaHRT DOTiBElGc BIK D�K H]Q!@54OHRT2BEPRY�P��=@ClQIDGN QIDGlIDGT2BIl�BEK�DMBI@Z?ADRc�PRT F�BEK�D(\]QIPv}¬lI[�PWYZDMQIDON�QIDOl!DOTiBEl5BEK DMQIDGY�PWBI@Cu]D4@CT2BIDOT l!@CB�}�HRV®BEK DMlIHR< T F

�if

Page 44: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

�� � ,��<� +4� �61 ����� :;�4�3�B+�� ��+4�(�

³�@C\]< QID�f­�w�]´);rNaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?Sl)HRVrBEK�D"<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD !lI[GQEPWBI[wKyBEK PWB0�UVgH]Q�F @�xDGQIDOTiB DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWYRl!BEPWBEDGllIN*H]tWDOT|>i}�P�VgDO?SPRYCDAl!NaDOPRtRDGQ`@ZT°BEK D�¥�H=[wt2K DGDOF|[OHRQIN < lG�_©"DO[�PW< lID¬l!NaDG[GBIQIH]\]QIPR? C�> F ��PRlP¬QIDGNaDOPWB4HRVC�P F c�U@�BEK�BIK DJlEPR?AD`YC@ZT \]<�@Zl!BI@Z[M[OH]TiBIDOTiB4> <�B4F @�xDGQI@CT \¬DO?AHRBI@ZH]T�PWY l�BwPWBIDOlGc:BEK @ClPRYCYZHv��DGF�PRT�PRT�PRY�}=l!@Zl�HRV uWPRQI@ZPWBE@CH]T lj@CT�N QIH]l!H=F�@Z[�VgD�P�BE< Q!DOlU[�PR<�lIDOF¦>i}�DO?AHRBE@CH]T:�

PWByP�N�PRQ!BI@Z[G< Y�PRQ�VgQ!DOk2< DGT [G}�PRT F°BE@C?SDW� ��T�\]DOT�DOQEPWY c�BEK DAF�PRQ!tRDGQMBIK DS[GH]YZHRQ�BEK DAK @Z\RK DOQ/BEK�DPR?AN YZ@�BE< F�DJHRVjBEK�D�lIN*DO[�BEQIPRY"[GH]?ANaH]T�DOTiBEl(PWByBIK�PWByVgQIDOk2< DGT [G}R� ��T3PRF F @�BE@ZHRT:c®N�YZHRBIlyHRV�4ODOQ!H[OQ!H]lIl!@ZT \�QIPWBEDWc:BEHRBEPRYnDOT�DOQI\W}]c PRT F{YZHv�j� VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}�DOT DGQI\R}{PWQIDJ@ZT�[OYZ<�F DOF°PWB/BIK D`BEH]N{HRV�BEK�DlIN*DO[�BEQ!H]\]QEPW?¦c��UK @CYZD/BEK DM�jP�uRDGVgH]Q!? @Cl5F�@ZlIN�Y�P�}]DGF�PWB'BEK Dy>aHWBIBEHR?¦� s K D(<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GD(@Cl'BIQEPRT=�lI[GQI@C>aDGF_PRl.�Wl!t�&!Q0� "[ $8��BC�=�

��T�[GH]?SN PRQI@ClIH]T|BEH{BEK�D¦T DG<�BEQIPRYUlIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?�c�BEK DGQID�@ZlAPRT�@CT [OQ!D�PRl!D�@ZT�BEHRBEPRY�DOT DGQI\R}@ZT¦BEK D`VgQ!< l!BIQEPWBIDOF�lIN*DO[�BEQ!H]\]QEPW?¦c*�UK @Z[wK{@Zl5lIDGDOT{@ZT�BIK D`F�PRQ!tRDGQ/@ZTiBEDGT lI@�B�}]� s K DOQ!DJ@Zl�PRYZl!H%PlI@C\]T @�h�[�PRTiBIYC}�YZH]T�\]DOQ5\iPRN�>*DGB��"DODOT{BEK�D`B���H%�"H]QIF l/@CT�BEK DyVgQI< l�BEQEP�BEDOF{l!NaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?¦�4�5l/PYZ@Cl!BIDOT DGQOc2PRTA@ZT [GQIDOPRlIDGF�\iPRN��"H]< YZFA>*D'N*DOQ![ODG@Cu]DGF¬PRl�P4N�PR< l!DR���5F F @CBI@ZH]T PRYZY�}]cWBIK D�u]Hv�"DOY ��� �@ZT�>*HRBEK !l![OQIPWBE[wK ��PRT F �BIK�PWB0��K�PWl'>*DODGT¦YCDOT \WBEK DGT DOF:�

L�< QI@CT \/BEK D'[OHR< QIl!D�HRVaBEK @Cl�Q!DOl!D�PRQ![wK:c PRTS@ZTiBEDGQIDGl!BE@CT \MN K DOT�H]?SDGT H]TA�jPRl�H]> l!DOQ�u]DOF¬�UK�DOT

�*�

Page 45: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDOl��"DOQ!D`QIDGNaDOPWBEDGF:�-��T¦\]DOT�DOQEPWY c�BEK DyQIDON*D�P�BEDOF_<�BIBIDOQEPWT [ODM�jPRl�YZH]T \RDOQU@ZT¦F < QEP�BE@ZHRTBEK PRT�BEK�D�H]QI@C\]@ZT PRYZY�}�lIN*H]tWDOTq<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODW� s K @Zl�H=[G[O< Q!QIDOF�>*DO[OPR< l!D�BEK D�<�lIDOQ�[OY�PWQI@Ch DOF�HRQl!BIQIDGlIlIDGFªBEK D°N�PRQ�B�HRV(BIK D�<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[OD�BIK�PWB���PRl¦?A@Zl!QIDG[OH]\]T�@54ODGF:c�< l!<�PRYCYC}�l!NaDOPRt2@ZT \z@ZT PVgQI<�l!BEQIPWBEDGF�DO?AHRBE@CH]T�PRY�l!BEPWBEDW� ��V�BEDGT�BEK @Cl`?AD�PRTiB`BIK�PWBJBEK�D¬< lIDGQ�F DO[GQID�PWlIDOFzK @Cl`lIN*D�PRt2@CT \QEP�BEDR� s K D�@CT [OQ!D�PRl!D�@CT(<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD�F < QIPWBE@CH]T4�jPRl®BEK D"QIDOl!< YCB®HRV�P'[OH]?(> @ZT�P�BE@ZHRTMHWV�PRT(@CT [OQ!D�PRl!D@ZT�@ZTiBIDOQIT PRY�N�PR< l!D(F <�QEPWBI@ZH]T¦PRT F�u]Hv��DGY®YCDOT \WBEK DGT @ZT \�� s K DGlID`D�u]DOTiBIl�[�PRT¦>aDMlIDGDOT�F�@ZQIDG[GBIYC}@ZT%h�\R< QIDMf��E�]�

��T�D��rBEQIDG?SD�[OPRlIDGlyHRV�uRH­�"DOY�YZDGT \RBIK DOT @CT \ cBIK D�< lIDGQ4H­uRDOQ � PRQ�BE@Z[G< Y�P�BEDOl��"H]Q!F lOc QIDGlI< Y�BE@ZT�\@ZT�Vg< Q!BIK DOQ�l!}rl!BIDO?,F�DO\]QIPRF�PWBI@ZH]T:��³�@Z\R< QIDyf���d�lIK Hv�Ul�BIK QIDGD`lIDGN�PRQEP�BED`l!NaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?Sl5HRV�BEK�D�"H]QIF l !T D��jPRQ!t � �3PRT F �T DG� }RH]QIt �3D��rBEQEPW[GBEDGF�VgQIH]?~<=BIBEDGQEPRT�[ODOlSlIN*H]tRDGT�>i}zBIK D_lIPR?ADlIN*D�PWtRDOQ�@ZT¦BIK D �5 *¡¢£)¡r¤ [OHRQIN < lG� s K DMBEQIPRT lI[GQI@CN�BE@CH]T¦VgH]Q�!T D��jPWQIt4��PRT F �T DG� }RH]QIt4�¬@Cl�WT2< � C � F QIt �JPRT F��WT2< � }� OQ!t �=c�QIDOl!NaDG[GBI@Cu]DGYC}R�

�jBUlIH]?AD�N*H]@CT2B�F < Q!@ZT \`BIK D�F @ZPRYZH]\R< DRc2BEK D�< lIDGQ�>aDG[OH]?ADOljl!HAPRT T Hv}]DGF%�U@CBEK¬BIK D�l�}=l�BEDG?BEK PWBMK DS>*DO\R@ZT l/BEH�Ki}rNaDGQEPRQ�BE@C[O< YZPWBEDJBEK�DA�"H]QIF�ly@CT°BIK D�QIDON*D�P�BEDOF�<�BIBIDOQIPRT [ODW� ��T{BEK DAT DO<r�BEQIPRY�lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?AlOc)BEK�DOQIDS@Zl4T H¦F @Zl�BE@ZT�\]< @Zl!K�PR> YCDJl!}rYZYZPR> YCDJH]QM�"H]Q!F3>*H]< T F�PWQ!}]� ² Hv��D�u]DOQGc@ZT�BEK DMVgQI< l�BEQIPWBEDGF_lIN*DO[�BEQ!H]\]QEPW?¦c�BEK DGQIDy@Zl5PS[OYCD�PRQ'l!}rYCY�PR> YCD4>aH]<�T F�PRQ�}_PWQIH]< T�F � ���(l!DO[OHRT F llIDGN�PRQIPWBE@CT \�BIK D¦h�Q!l!B�l!}rYZYZPR> YZD%VgQ!H]? BEK D¦Y�PRl�BAl!}rYZYZPR> YZD�@CT !T D��jPWQIt�� � ��T�[OH]?AN�PRQ!@Zl!H]TzBIHC P F c�BEK D�l!NaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?�@ZT C > F PRYZl!H�K PRl4?SH]Q!D`BEHRBEPRYnDGT DOQ!\R}]c DOl!NaDG[O@�PWYZYC}_@ZT�BEK�D���t ��PWB4BEK�DDOT�F�HRV�BEK�D��"H]Q!F:�A³�<�Q!BEK�DOQI?AH]Q!DRc:BEK�D�BIK @ZQ!F�VgH]QI?SPRTiB4@ZT�BIK DJu]Hv��DGY�P�B � � d¬l!DO[OHRT F lMK�PRlMPl!BIDODGNaDGQ"V PRYCY BEK�PRTA@ZTDC P F � 2qK DGT¬lIN*D�PWtr@CT \(T PWBE< QIPRYZY�}]c]BIK D,!P��y@CT �T DG��PRQIt4�`@Cl�N QIH]T�H]< T [GDOF��-.�=c�>�<�Bj�UK DGT �T DG��PRQIt4��@Zl�K2}rN*DOQIPRQ!BI@Z[O<�Y�PWBIDOF:crBEK DG!P��`T Hv� lIH]< T�F l�YZ@CtRD ��� �=� s K�D�VgQI< l �BEQIPWBEDGF%lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?0T Hv��QIDOl!DO?`>�YZDOljB��"H�lIDGN�PRQEP�BED��"H]QIF lj�UK�@Z[wK¬�"H]< YZF%N�QIDOl!DOTiB'F @ .A[G< YCB�}VgH]Q/BEK�D�QIDG[OH]\RT @54GDOQyPRT F�PW\]\]QEP�uWPWBI@ZH]T�VgH]Q/BEK�D�< l!DOQ(@�V�K�D�@ZTiBIDOT F DGF�H]T D��"H]QIF:c®lI< [wK�PWly@CTBEK�@Zl/[�PWlIDR� s K D�YZPRl!B/l!NaDG[GBIQIH]\]QIPR?�@Cl/N QIDGlIDOTiBIDOF�VgHRQ/[OH]?AN�PRQ!@ZlIHRT�HRV%�T DG� }]H]Q!t=�¦PRT F{BEK�DKi}rNaDGQEPRQ�BE@Z[G< Y�P�BEDOF !T�DG��PRQIt��2�

s K D4lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR? K DOYCN ljBEHJur@Zl!<�PRYZY�}AF @Zl!N Y�P�}¬K�H­� Ki}rNaDGQEPRQ�BE@Z[G< Y�P�BE@ZHRT�PRYCBIDOQIljPJ�"H]Q!F�HRQ

� � '�� ,��<� +4� �61 � +B+4�<� �*, �<������ � = �6,�+>+��R56�O:;����7 18�A� �6,�56�(18�!� +4�N,��(= �6��%N+�'3�<, � �-���� +�1-"N�6, +4�N1-��,3� �6,K��,��,��8+4�(� �*�-�418�-,��!��.�� � '3�H:;���3�B+�� ��+4�(��� +�+��<� �*,���� �����&� = �6,�+ +4� 56�R:;�4�67�1-�A� �*,�5��<1-�(�>+��K,3�<= �*�4%K:;����7�,��(= �6��%+��J1-�6,�� �6,�'�� �*+�'��4��=H.�� � '�� ������*%6�(�G���>7 �61-�*.

L�� '�� � +�+��(� �6, ���G����� =>�(181���= �6,�+4�(�N+�� 7 �6%6� � ����,�,��� +��-��,O:;�4�67 18�A� �*,�5��<1-�(�X+4� ,��<= �*�4% �6,3�N+�'�����" �I+4�<7%6�(� + '�� �6���-,�57K� � �F" ,��(=S"��6�4% �6,3�N� �3, �6181-" � �*��� ,��(= �6��%9.�� � '����X� +B+4�<� �*, �<� ��� � ����7K7K�<,A+ +4�+4'��G�B" �B+��(7 .

�2b

Page 46: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

������� 8����-:�� @�,��(� +�� �*1 ������ 8����-:�� @3:;�4�3�B+�� ��+4�(�

�� ��� 8�� 4�:�� @9,��<��+�� �*1

³�@C\]< QID'f�� d=´�;rNaDG[GBEQ!H]\]QIPR?Sl"@ZYCYZ< l�BEQEP�BE@ZT�\/F @CxaDOQ!DOT [GDOl�>*DGB��"DODGT�PyT H]Q!?�PWY*N�QIH]T2< T [G@�PWBI@ZH]TDC P FPRT F(K2}rN*DOQIPRQ!BI@Z[O<�Y�PWBIDOF`N Q!H]T2< T [G@�PWBI@ZH]T�C�> F HRV�BEK D���HRQIF !T D��jPWQIt�� ��;=N*DO[�BEQ!H]\]QEPW? C [ F lIK Hv�UlPJT H]Q!?�PRYN QIH]T2< T�[O@�P�BE@ZHRT%HRV�BIK D/��H]Q!F �T DG� }]H]Q!t=�SPRT F�@Zl�N�QIDOl!DOTiBEDGF_VgH]Q�[GH]?SN PRQI@ClIH]T:�

�!(

Page 47: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GDR� s H¦PWT°DGT QEPW\]DOF°< lIDGQOc)[OYCD�PRQ!YC}_DOT2< T [G@�PWBI@ZT \%K @Cl���HRQIF l4?SPv}_lIDGDO?�YZ@CtRDJP%\]HrHrF?ADGBEK�H=F�VgH]Q�H]>�BEPR@ZT�@ZT \�l!}rl�BEDO? Q!DO[OHR\]T @CBI@ZH]T K Hv��D�u]DGQOc:PWl5l!K Hv�UT_@ZT�h�\]<�QIDyf���d=c=BEK DMQIDGlI< Y�B@Zl�HWV�BEDOT�< T�V P�uRH]QEPR>�YZD4PRT F¦PR[�BE<�PRYCYC}S[OH]<�T2BIDOQIPR[GBIl5l�}=l�BEDG? Q!DO[GH]\]T @�BE@ZHRT:�

��T HWBEK DGQABIH=H]Y"BEK�PWBJ��PRlA<�BE@CYZ@ 4ODOF|F�< QI@CT \°BIK @ZlJQ!DOl!D�PRQ![wK�PRYZl!H�?�PWF D�< lID�HRV'BEK D�lIN*DO[��BEQ!H]\]QIPR?�PRT F3PRF F @�BE@CH]T�PRYnN�QIH]l!H=F @C[S@CT�VgH]Q!?�PWBI@ZH]T�PRlM�"DOYCY �%³®@Z\]< Q!DAf�� f�lIK Hv�Ul(P¦\]QIPRN K @C[�PRYur@ZD��U@ZT \_BIH=HRY��U@�BEK�P_l!?SHrHRBEK�DOF�Vg< T F PR?SDGTiBwPRY�VgQIDGkr<�DOT [�}|[OH]TiBIH]< Q�PRT F3DOT DGQI\R}3@ZT [GYZ< F DGFVgH]QMBEK DSlEPR?AD�<�B!BEDGQEPRT [GDRc !l![OQIPWBE[wK�BIK�PWB�c2�°PRl(l!K Hv�UT�@ZT�h \]< QID�f��w�R� s K @Cl � * � @ 5)7 * B � �<B $#@� B " >_BEHrH]Y l!K Hv�Ul"T�HRB�H]T YC}`lIN*DO[GBIQIH]\RQEPRN K�@Z[U[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQI@Cl!BI@Z[Ol�HRV*BEK�D'��P�u]DGVgHRQI? > <�B�N Q!H]lIHrF @C[[wK�PRQIPR[GBIDOQ!@Zl!BI@Z[Gl5PWlU�"DOYCY �

³�@C\]< QID4f­� f�´C P F ��P�u]D�VgH]QI?�c�C�> F �U@ZF�D���> PRT F_l!NaDG[GBIQIH]\]QIPR?�c=C�[ F T�PWQIQIHv�j�«>�PRT F�lIN*DO[�BEQIHR\]QEPR?@ZT�YZHR\iPRQI@�BEK ?A@Z[5VgQIDOk2< DGT [G}¦lI[OPRYZD4�U@CBIK¦D��rBEQEPW[GBEDGF�N @CBI[wK:c�C�F F lI?AHrHRBEK DGF_N @�BE[wK¦[OH]TiBEHR< QOc�C�D FDOT�DOQI\W}]c�CgV F N�K H]T D�BE@Z[�PWYZ@Z\RT ?SDGTiB�c�PRT F C \ F ��HRQIF PRYZ@C\]T ?ADOTiB(VgH]Q`BIK D%<�B!BEDOQIPRT [GD C5)7 * �8�97+:�<:=�8���2�

� ������� ������8�� ����� ����� �������

������������� �"!�#%$&$'��()� ()$+* �,� #%��* #-$,�.�0/1* �����,23�)* #-��4�(056���7�+�,$'�8#-49��:��;$,������:��.<=�+� �>�@?A��5%��� �+!:���#-4�B�(�B�� ()����#%$C()5D* �E()4�� $,��#-��* #-��4F*E�"��5HGI�J�K$+��2L��:�*E�M���ON"� #-$,()5QPR��S"T��+$+*E#VU��M/W�C(0* :�� �+�,PD*E���/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5X/W� �+Y":��,4�$@NZ<=()�[�\?A* �E()$@*E�+!>()4�!�()4�()5%N"],�+!^G�_`4>ab#-B�:�� �1ced`f�Pg* ���h/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5

fji

Page 48: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

/W� �+Yj:��,4�$@N /W���.*E��� :�* * �,� ()4�$,� *`<R� ��4�� ��#V? ]+�,��� � P � ���7� � �,4 SON9* ����� ()23� ���7�,( � �+�,P #%���5%�)* * �,!^G�� * *E�+�E()4�$,�,��*`<R�Z()4�! * ��� �+�L(0� � � �+�7�,(0*E�+!�:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,��< #%* ��(04��+2L�)* #-��4�()5b�*'(0* ��)/J/W� :��*E� (0*E�+!^P�< ��#-5%��*E����������*�:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�h#%��4��,:�* �E()5HG

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5120

140

160

180

200

220

240

260

280

300

320

Hz

time

fundamental frequency

utterance1utterance2utterance3

ab#%B�:�� �&ced`f�� a :�4�!�()23�,4O*'(05[/W� �+Y":��,4�$@N $,��4O*E�):�� � �)/�*E��� :A* *E�+�E()4�$,� +�<>�� @A" 5CBED F "+* �)�� �g� � �,4 *E��� �,� *E#-23�,�3SON ( /W�,2L()5-� � �g�C( � �,�+G �����Z/W��:���* �E(0* �,! :A* *E�+�E()4�$,�)P�:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�Cc�P�#%�� #%B�4�#���$C()4O* 5%NL5-��4�B)�,�D*E��()4M* ������� �@U"#-��:�� :�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,�+G

��������� ��*=4��)* #-$,�,()S�5%��!�#� 7�,� �+4�$,�6S7�@*`<=�+�,4 * ���6* ��� �+�[:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�=#%� * ����:�* * �,�E(04�$,�6!�:��E( d*E#%��4^G��[�J*E����:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�=#%�J���,�g�C(0* �,!^Pe*E��� !�:�� (0*E#%��4�*E�,4�!��J* �[#%4�$,���C()���)Gb����� * ��#-��!h:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�

#-�h� #%B�4�#���$C()4O*E5VN>5-��4�B��,��*E��(04K*E���L��� �@U"#-��:�� :�* * �,�E(04�$,�+� ()4�! ��()� $,5%�C()��<R��� ! Sg��:�4�!�()� #%�,�,G������� �+$,��4�! :�*�*E�+�E()4�$+����()� ( � 5%#-B��O*E5VN35-� <=�+�D/W:�4�!�(02L�+4j*E()5 /W���,Yj:��,4�$+N.*E��()4.*E��� �)* ���,�D*`<R�:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�,G�_`4O*E�+� �+��*E#%4�B�5VN;�+4���:�B�� PA*E��#-�R<=()�D* ����$C(0� �[< #V*E� ���+U��+�E()5 �)/ *E���[� �,�g�C(e*�B�� �):����,G

�6� <R�+U��+�,P � ��23� �7�+����5%� �@?A��� �+� ���,!K* ���,#%��/W� :��*E�E(e*E#-�)4�SjN&5-� <=�+� #%4�B *E���+#-��/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5/W� �+Yj:��,4�$@N�P�< ��#%$'� $C(0:�� �+! * ���[���7�,( � �+�D*E� ����:�4�!.23�����6!��+��� �+� ���,!M�E(0* ���,� *E��()4L/W� :��*E�E(e*E�,! G� 4 *E���&�)*E���,� ��(04�!^P��)* ���,� ���7�,( � �+� �.#%4�$,���C()���,! *E���,#-�3/W:�4�!�(02L�+4j*E()5 /W� �,Yj:��+4�$+N *E� �g���d

*E� (CN�*E���+#-��#-��� #%*E(0*E#%��4Z< #V*E�>*E���3��N"��* �,2MG _`4�/ (0$+*CPX< ��#%5-� ()4�(05%N"],#%4�B :�* * �,�E(04�$,�+�h*E��(0*h<R�,���

��� '�� � +�+��<� �*,����H��� :;����7 +�'�� # � �&%A'3�<�(� �������3�3��. � '�� ������*%��<�(@3� �&' � �<�6,/@ ��� :;�<7 �61-�*.

f��

Page 49: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

:�4��+5-#%$,#%* �,!^Pg*E���+� � <=()� 4�� 4��)* #-$+�C()S�5%� ��(e* *E�+� 4>��S����,�U��,!>/W���[* ��� /W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5J/W� �,Yj:��+4�$+N)G�6� <R�+U)�,�,Pj< ���+43:�� #-4�B !�(0*'(�$+��5-5%�,$@*E�,! /W����2 *E��������� $,�)� ��:��+PO*E���D/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5"/W� �+Y":��,4�$@NB��+4��,� ()5-5VN>#-4�$+� �C(0� �,! < ���,4 *E��� � �g�C( � �,� (0$+*E�+! #-4K( /W� :��*E� (0*E�+! �,23�)*E#%��4�()5��*'(0* �)G � /W�+<�@?�()23��5%�,�6/W����2 !�(0*E(;$,�)5-5-�+$+* �,! /W����2 *E����� �A$ � ���+�,!>()4�!������8$,�����7��� ( ()���h�����,���,4O*E�+!>* �#-5%5-:��*E� (0*E��*E��#%� ��4�!�#-4�B�G

ab#-B):�� ��c dK� ��� < �.* ��� �+�>/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'(05[/W� �+Y":��,4�$@N $,��4O*E�):�� �.�)/�* ���>:�* * �,�E(04�$,� *`<R���4�� ��U��.� # ? � /W����2 !�#� 7�,���,4O* � �g�C( � �,���L#%4K*E�����X�"$ � ���,�+!I$+��� ��:��,G�_`4 �H(��'P * ���,��� #-�hU)�,�N5-#V* * 5-�;!�#� 7�,� �+4�$,� Sg�+*`<R�,�+4I*E��� /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'(05D/W� �,Yj:��+4�$,#%�,� �)/�*E��� 4��+:�*E� ()5 ()4�! /W��:���* �E(0* �,!�,23�)* #-��4�(05D��*E(0*E�+�,G9�J�K!��@*E�,$@*;�+2L�0*E#-�)4 #%4 * ���M� �g�,�,$'�9�0/[*E��#-�3��()��* #-$+:�5 ()� ���7�,( � �+�,P���4��<R��:�5-!M4��+�,! *E� � �+5%N.��4 �)* ���,� ������� �"!�#%$�/W�C(0* :�� �+��Sg�,��#-!��+��/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'(05 /W� �+Y":��,4�$@N�G

�6� <R�+U��+�,Pg#-4.*E���12L()5%��� �g�C( � �,�+P * ���,���h#%� ( � #-B)4�#���$,()4O* !�#� 7�,���,4�$+��#-4.*E��� /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5

/W� �+Yj:��,4�$@NKSg�+*`<R�,�+4 �,23�)* #-��4�(05 ��*E(0*E�+�,G _`4�$,��4O*E�):���� S��'PX*E���3/W��:���* �E(0* �,!K�+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5 �*'(0* �� ��� < �=()4 #-4�$+� �,()� ��#-4 :�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�6!�:��E(0* #-��4^POS�:�*�*E����/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5�/W���,Yj:��,4�$+N3#-��5-� <R�,� *E��()4#-4&* ��� 4��+:�*E� ()5 :�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�,G����+4��,� ()5-5VN�P7<R� <=�):�5-!��\?��g�,$@*h(;/W� :��*E�E(e*E�,!>:����,� *E�.������:�*��)�� �g�C( � ��� 235%N < #%* �>* ��� ��N"�*E�,2MG���� ()����#%$C()5%5%N)P7*E��#-��<R��:�5-!>$+��� ���,� �g��4�! *E�M()4>#-4�$,� �,()� � #%4*E���6/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5 /W� �+Y":��,4�$@N�G�6� <=�@U��+�,P�()�R� ��� < 4.#%4��HS��'PA< #V*E� � �,()5Vd 5-#%/W� � !�(0*'(AP"* ��#-� 2;(CN4��)* �"$,$+:��,G

_`4K����!��,� * � 2L( � �3� �)2L� $,�)2L��(0� #-����4>S7�@*`<=�+�,4 * ���3()$+* �,! (04�!K���C()5 !�(e*'(�PX:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�

<R�,� �M$'�������,4 /W� ��2 *E��������� $+��� ��:��3< #V*E�F�,#V*E���+� �@?�()$@*3<R����!I$+��2 S�#%4�(0*E#%��4�� �)� � #-23#-5-()�<R��� !Ad #-4�#V*E#-()5�()4�!1<R��� !"d ��4�(05"������4��+�J* �6�+5-#-23#-4�(0*E� !�#� 7�,���,4�$+�,�b#%4 /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*E()5�/W� �+Y":��,4�$+#-�,�+Ga���� #%4���*E()4�$,�0P � #%4�$,� * ���.:�* * �,� ()4�$,� *`<=�>��4�� ��U��.� # ? � <D()�3()4�()5%N"],�+! #-4 * ����� �A$ � ���+�,!$,�)� ��:��+P�()4 (0* * �,23��*.<D(0� 2L()!���*E� ��4�! ()48:�* * �,� ()4�$,� *E��(e* $,��4O*'(0#-4��+! � : � � ()4�! �� � G_`4��*E�C(0!^P ()4.:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+��*E��(0*=$,��4O*E()#-4��+! � : � � ()4�! � � <D()��$'����� �+4M/W����2 * ��������� $,������:��+P� #%4�$,� 4�� �\?�(0$+*.2L(0*E$'�I<D()�L/W��:�4�!^G8�����&���,��:�5%* #-4�B�:�* * �,�E(04�$,�Z<=()� $'����� �+4 * �KSg� *`<R�*E����:��E(04�!M* �,4 � /W����$+��2L��()� #%� ��4^G

�6�g��43#-4�#V*E# (05"#%4�� �g�,$@*E#%��4^P�*E���,� ��()����� ��23��$,5%�C()� !�#� 7�,� �+4�$,�+��S7�@*`<=�+�,4;* ��� � �C(05�!�(0*E(1(04�!()$@*E�,! !�(e*'(�P�()�D� ��� < 4 #%4.ab#-B):�� �[ced���G �[��� ��� < 4 #%4 /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*E()57/W���,Yj:��,4�$+N.$+��4O*E��:������H$��()4�!�� !��'PX#-4&* ��� #-4�#V*E#-()5��e: � �.#%4�*E��� $+��4O*E��:�����5%�)*E� �0/ * ���3()$+* �,! !�(0*E(�P^*E��� /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5/W� �+Yj:��,4�$@N $,��4O*E�):�� �L�)/6* ��� /W� :��*E�E(e*E�,!I:�* * �,� ()4�$,�+� ()��� � #-B)4�#���$,()4O*E5VN ��#%B����,� * ��()4F*E��������)/R*E��� 4��+:�*E� ()5 :�* * �,� ()4�$,�+�,G �����35-()� B)� � ��#V/ *h#%4�/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*E()5 /W� �+Y":��,4�$@N�#%��#-4�!�#%$C(0* #%U)� �)/

f��

Page 50: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4140

160

180

200

220

240

260

280

300

320fundamental frequency

time

Hz

neutralneutralfrustratedfrustrated

���� :;�(7 �*1-� ���9� �*%��<�

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4100

110

120

130

140

150

160fundamental frequency

time

Hz

neutralneutralfrustrated

���� 7 �*1-� �B�9� �6%6�<�

ab#%B�:�� � c d ���D<R�Z� �+��()� (0*E�3� �@*E� �0/=/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5 /W���,Yj:��,4�$+N $,��4O* ��:�� �1/W����*E���L:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�� *`<R� ��4�� ��U�� ��#V?�� #%4 *E��� � �A$ � ���+�,!>$,�)� ��:��+G������+� � <=()��4��;��S�� �+��U0()S�5%� ��(e* *E�+� 4Z/W�)�6*E���/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5 /W���,Yj:��,4�$+N��)/�(./W� :��*E� (0*E�+!��+2L�)* #-��4�()5 ��*E(0*E�0G;_`4�$,��4O*E�):�� �Q(��EPJ* ��� � �g�C( � �,�!��"�,�L4��)*L���C(CU"#-5VNF� �,5VNF��4����;*E���@?A�����,� � /W��:���* �E(0* #-��4 G �����&���7�,( � �+�;#-4 �HS�� 5-� <R�,���;��#%�/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5^/W���,Yj:��,4�$+N.*E�3�@?A�����,����/W��:���* �E(0* #-��4^G

��

Page 51: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

()4>�@?�()B)B��,� (0*E�+! $'��()4�B��0G �����,���L$'��()4�B��+�h(0� � � � �\?A* � �+2L� * ��(0*1( �j:�2L()4>5-#-�*E�+4��,�[<R��:�5%!��(CU���4�� ������S�5%�,2 #-!��+4j* #%/ N"#-4�B *E����#%4j* �,4�!��,! �,23�)*E#%��4�()5g��*E(0*E�0G������ � � (0*�* ��� �,4�! �)/J*E���:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+� ()���7�,()� ��*E�3Sg�1���,!�:�$,�,!Z#-4.*E������5%�)*E�+P ()4�! *E���1:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�h!�:��E(0* #-��4 ��4�$+�1()BO()#%4#-��5%�,4�B0*E���+4��,!^G

� U��,4 #%4>$C()���,�h< ���,� �3*E���3�����)4��,�h#-4>*E���3:�* * �,� ()4�$,� <R�,� �L$,��23��5%�+*E�+5%N�!�#� 7�,� �+4O*CPX*E��#%���4�!�#-4�B���* #-5%5����+5-!^G a #-B�:���� cedi[����� < � ���R$+��4O*E��:���� /W��� *E��� :�*�*E�+�E()4�$+� � �,#-B)�j*��j:�4�!�� �+!;��4�� �/W��� *`<R� � �,��()�E(0* � � �g�C( � �,� �+G � 4�$,� ()BO(0#-4^P * ���./W:�4�!�()23�,4O*E()5=/W� �+Yj:��,4�$@NF#-4�$+� �,()� �+� < ���,4*E���L�+2L�)* #-��4�()5b�*'(0* �3$'��()4�B��+�h/W� �)2 4��,:A*E�E(05 *E� /W� :��*E�E(e*E�,! Pb()4�! * ���L:A* *E�+�E()4�$,�3!�:��E(e*E#-�)4#-4�$,� �,()� �+�6#%4.$,��4O* ��:�� ��5-�0* �Q(��EG

�6��#-4�B6� #-23#-5-()� �\?�()2L��5-�,�+P)#V* Sg�,$,()23�R(0����()���,4O* �,()� 5VN ��4h* ��(0* ()4h#-4�$+� �C(0� � #-4�/W:�4�!�()23�,4"d*'(05g/W���,Yj:��,4�$+N�P��)/ *E�+4;/W��:�4�!;#-4;�+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5�!�(0*E( � �+$,����!��,!.SON;()4 (0$+*E�)�,P�!�#-!;4��)*�()$+$,:�� (0*E�+5%N

$C(e*E�,B)��� #%],��2 :�$'�M�0/J* ��� !�(0*E( *E��(0*=<D()� $+��5-5%�,$+* �,!.#%4 ��:���$+��� ��:��,G �6� <R�+U��+�,P�<R��<R�,���1()S�5-�*E�M2L( � � :����L�)/ *E���3U0()��# ()4�$+� #-4>*E��� /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5 /W���,Yj:��+4�$+N�()4�! �������7�)� �L()����������� #-(0*E�/W�C(e*E:����,��/W������:�� $+5 ()��� #���$C(0* #-��4.�\?��g�,��#-23�,4O*E�+G

� �����CB ��� ������� ��� ������ ������R�

� #-4��,()��/W�C(0* :�� �6�@?"*E� ()$+* #-��4 $,()4 Sg�6* ����:�B��O*=�)/X()� ��4�!�#%4�B ( ���+*=�)/^U��+$+* ��� �D* ��(0*R� 7�,$+* #%U)�,5%N

$C(0��*E:����3* ��� #-4�/W�)� 2L(0*E#%��4&�����,� �+4O* !�:���#-4�BM()4 �@?A�g�,��#-23�,4O*'()5 �)S�� �+��U0(0*E#%��4>< ��#-5%� � �,!�:�$,#%4�B*E��� !�#-23�,4�� #-�)4�()5-#V*`N�GMa�����*E��#%� � �+� �,()� $'�^P <R�.!��,��#-���L*E�Z�@?"*E� ()$+* /W�,(0*E:�� �,� < ��#-$'�K/W�"$,:�� ��4!�#%� $,��#-23#-4�(e*E#-4�B ()23��4�B �+2L�)* #-��4�()5^()4�! 4��)4Ad`�+2L�)* #-��4�()57���7�+�,$'�^G

� ������� � � � � ���)� � � � � ��� ������� � �

����� U�� <R�,5 d`5-�@U��+5�/W�C(0* :�� �+�^<=�+� ��$,��23��:�* �,!1()�X()4�#%4j* �,��2L�+!�# (0* �b�*E�,��*E� <=()� !���4�!�#-4�B :�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�@d5-�@U��+5�/W�C(0* :�� �+�,G ��:���#-4�B�* ��� ()4�(05%N"� #%� ��*'(0B����)/g*E��#%� � �+� �C(0� $'�^PjU�� <R�,5Vd 5-�@U��,5 ������� �"!�#%$=/W�C(0* :�� �+�

/W��� �C(0$'�Z:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�1<R�,��� $,�)2L��:A*E�,! G ��� #-4�B3* ���h#%5-5%:���* �E(0* #-��4 #%4Mab#-B�:�� ��ced ��P�*E����������� �"!�#%$/W�C(e*E:����,��< #-5-5 Sg�3��� �+� �,4O* �,!K/W������4��3U)� <R�,5R� �+B�2L�+4O*CP < ��#-$'�K#%���C()��#-5%N&�@?"*E�+4�!��,! * � �0*E���+�� �+B�23�,4O*E� #%4�* ���;:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�)GM�����;/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5�/W� �+Yj:��,4�$@NK$+��4O*E��:�� #-�1�)/D* ���;:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�� *`<R�h* ����:�� ()4�!;4�#-4��0G �>����� ��� �*RU)� <=�+5 �0: � ��#-� /W� ��2 *E#-23� ��G ��* � �AG�� � �+$,��4�!��,P�* ���6���,$+��4�!U�� <R�,5 � � � � /W� �)2 *E#%2L� ��G�� * � ��G f � �+$,��4�!��,Pg()4�!M� �3��4^G

��

Page 52: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4100

120

140

160

180

200

220

240

260

280

300fundamental frequency

time

Hz

neutralneutralfrustrated

���� :;�(7 �*1-� ���9� �*%��<�

0 0.5 1 1.550

100

150

200

250

300

350

400fundamental frequency

timeH

z

neutralfrustratedfrustratedfrustrated

����>:;�<7 �61-� ������*%��<�

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.280

100

120

140

160

180

200

220

240

260

280fundamental frequency

time

Hz

neutralfrustratedfrustrated

���>:;�<7 �618�H������*%6�(�

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 160

80

100

120

140

160

180

200fundamental frequency

time

Hz

neutralneutralfrustrated

� � � 7 �618�H������*%6�(�

ab#%B�:�� � ced�� ��a���:�� � �,��()�E(0* � � �+* �h�0/R/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5 /W� �,Yj:��+4�$+N $+��4O*E��:���� /W����*E��� :�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�� *`<R�M* ����:�� ()4�! *E�,4 � #%4>* ��� ����� $,�)� ��:��+G ��4�5-# � � *E���3���C()5 !�(0*'(�P * ���,���L#%��(M��#-B�4�#���$C(04j*!�#� �+� �,4�$,�.#-4 * ���;/W��:���* �E(0* �,! ()4�!F4��+:�*E� ()5D�,23�)* #-��4�(05 �*'(0* �,�+P < #V*E� *E��� /W� :��*E�E(e*E�,!F�*'(0* �:���:�()5-5VN�S7�+#-4�B6��#-B)���,�+G �=��4O*E�):�� � �Q(��EP �HS��'PO()4�!��H!�� ()5-���6����� <F*E��(0* *E���R:�* * �,� ()4�$,�=!�:��E(e*E#-�)4#-4�$,� �,()� �+��/W�)�D/W� :��*E�E(e*E�,!M�,23�)* #-��4^G

Page 53: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.270

80

90

100

110

120

130

140

150

160

170fundamental frequency

time

Hz

neutralneutralfrustratedfrustrated

�� � 7 �61-� ������*%��<�

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2150

200

250

300fundamental frequency

time

Hz

neutralneutralfrustratedfrustrated

��� � :;�<7 �618� �B�9� �6%6�(�

ab#%B�:�� � c di ���D<R�Z� �+��()� (0*E�3� �@*E� �0/=/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5 /W���,Yj:��,4�$+N $,��4O* ��:�� �1/W����*E���L:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�� �+#-B��O*L�":�4�!�� �+! ��4�� �K#-4I* ��� ����� $,�)� ��:��+G �=��4O* ��:�� ���Q(�� ()4�! � S�� ����� < (04 �@?"*E���,23�!�#� �+� �,4�$,��#-4 � ��Sg�+*`<R�,�,4Z4��,:�* �E()5X(04�!M/W��:���* �E(0* �,!M�,23�)*E#%��4�()5g��*E(0*E�+�,G

)c

Page 54: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

�����h/W�):��6��� �����A!�#%$1/W�,(0*E:�� �,� *E��(0*�(0� �15 ()Sg�,5%�,!M#-4 *E��� ��B�:���� ()����� � �=2;(e?A#%2 :�2 ��#V*E$'�^P����� (CU��+�E()B�� ��#%*E$'� P��Qc ����#V*E$'��� 5%���g�)P^(04�! �Hf���U�� <R�,5 !�:��E(0* #-��4^G[����� ��#V*E$'�Ad S�()� �+!&/W�C(0* :�� �+�<R�,� �6()5%5�4�����2;()5%#-]+�,! < #V*E�3� �,���7�+$+* *E� *E����23�C(04L��#V*E$'� �)/7*E��� ������* :�* * �,� ()4�$,��#-4 * ��� � �,�g�C(e*� �+� #%�,�,G�_ *�<D()�6/W�,5%* * ��(0*[* ��#-��#-�6(L���C()5%#-�*E#-$�23�A!��,5^/W��� < ��(0*[$,��:�5%!ZSg� !��)4�� #%4&(L!�# ()5%��B�:��� �@* * #-4�B�G

�b(0S�5-� cAG��L����� < ��*E��� �@?"*E� ()$+* �,!>2L�,()� :�� �,23�,4O* �[/W���[�,()$'�>�)/ *E��� U�� <R�,5-� #%4Z*E��� :�* * �,� d()4�$+�)G������1� �+$,��4�! � � < $,����� �,���7�)4�!�� *E� *E����#-5%5-:��*E� (0*E�+!;/W�C(0* :�� �+�,G

ab#%B�:�� �Lced � � _`5-5-:���*E� (0*E#%��4 �)/�*E���LU�� <=�+5Vd 5-�+U)�,5D��� �����A!�#%$L/W�,(0*E:����,�+G������ ������� �"!�#-$3/W�C(0* :�� �+�*E��(0*�()��� ��#-B���5-#-B)�j* �,!�(0� ��� � � 2L(e?A#-2 :�2 ��#V*E$'�^P � � �6(CU��+�E()B�� ��#%*E$'� P �Qc�� ��#%*E$'�>��5-���g�)P (04�!�Hf���U�� <=�+5 !�:��E(0* #-��4 G

0f

Page 55: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

����� � ��� ��� � � � ��� � ��� ��������� ��� �������� ��������� ����� �!��" #%$%� � ������

� �Cf�G f ��� ��G c f�G � �CfOc�G � � � ��G �

� � ��G c � i ��G�� diAG � � � ��G � � ��iAG

� ���G � �Cf ��G � d���G � ��iAG � � � ��G c

�,f ��G � �ef�G i d � �AG i �CfjiAG � �0f�c�G �

� ()S�5-�[c�G � � � ?�()2L��5-���)/X�@?"*E� ()$+* �,! U)� <R�,5 d`5%�+U��+5 /W�C(e*E:����,�=/W���R(hU)� <R�,5 � �,B)2L�+4j*D#-4 (04 :�* * �,� d()4�$+�)G �����+� � ��()�*E#%$,:�5-()�DU0()5-:��+�[(0� �h/W�)��* ���1/W���,Yj:��+4�$+NZ$,��4O*E�):��[��5%�)*�#-4Zab#-B�:�� �1ced �AG'&�� <�.$,����� �,���7�)4�!���*E� *E���3��#-B)��5-#%B��O*E�,!&U)� <=�+5QP < ���,� �3$,�)5-:�234�� ��P��APJc�PJ()4�! .���,�����,���,4O* *E���U0()5-:��,���)/ *E����#-5%5-:��*E� (0*E�+!;/W�C(0* :�� �+�,G

� �����)( * � � � ������� � �)� � � � � ��� ������� � �

�����1U�� <=�+5Vd 5-�+U)�,5J/W�C(0* :�� �+�6<R�,� �1*E���+4&2L()4�#-��:�5 (0* �,! *E�L$,��23��:�* �1* ��� :�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�@d 5-�+U)�,5J$C()4"d

!�#%!�(0*E�h/W�C(0* :�� �+��/W����$,5-()� ��#���$,(0*E#%��4^G������ :�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�@d 5-�+U)�,5 /W�,(0*E:����,��<R�,���34���� 2L()5-#%],�+! < #%* �� �+� �g�,$@*.*E� B��+4�!��+�.()4�! * ��� ������*.:A* *E�+�E()4�$,��#-4 (K� �+�7�,(0*.B�����:��^G _`4 B��,4��,�E(05QP�*E��� ��� �*:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+� <D()��* ��� 23����*[4��,:�* �E()5b�)/ ()5-5X*E��� :�* * �,�E(04�$,�+� #-4&*E��� � �+�7�,(0* B�����:��^G�����#%� 4����d2L()5-#%]C(0* #-��4.<=()� !���4�� * � (0* * �,23��*[* � ()!eT�:��*�/W���[* ��� ���7�,( � �+�1!��,�g�,4�!��+4�$,#%�,���)/ * ��� ��#%* $'�U0()5-:��)G

� ��#-4�B�5%� �,23�)*E#%��4 /W�C(0* :�� �MU��,$@*E���L#-� *E���+4 $,�)4���* � :�$@*E�,! /W����2 *E���Z� �@* �)/[:�* * �,� ()4�$,�\d5-�@U��+5X/W�,(0*E:�� �,� *E��(0*6()� ��$,�)2L��:A*E�,! G=a�����*E��#-��� �+� �,()� $'�^Pg� # ?M!�#� 7�,���,4O* /W�C(0* :�� �+��< ��#-$'� <R�,���*E����:�B��O*1*E�MS7� $,�)� � �+5 (0* �,!>< #%* ���+2L�)* #-��4�<R�,���;:�* #-5-#%],�+!�#-4>*E��� *E� ()#-4�#%4�B.�����A$+�,� �+G �����+� �:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�@d`5%�+U)�,5 /W�C(0* :�� �+��()� �1()�D/W��5%5-� < � �

��G ����� ��� � �,+ ����� 2L(e?A#-2 :�2 /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'(05�/W� �+Y":��,4�$@N �)/ *E����:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+� 2;(e?A#%2L#%],�,!� U��+��* ����2;( ?�#%2 :�2 /W:�4�!�(02L�+4j*E()5 /W���,Yj:��,4�$+NM#-4 �C(0$'�MU)� <R�,5HG

�AG � ��� ��� � �,+ ������(CU��+�E()B)�[/W:�4�!�(02L�+4j*E()57/W���,Yj:��+4�$+N /W�)�R*E����:�* * �,� ()4�$,� !��,� #VU��+! /W� ��2* ��� /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*E()5 /W� �+Yj:��,4�$+#-�+�[�)/J*E��� U)� <R�,5%�,G

c�G ���� ��� � � ��� � ���- + ����� ()S�� �)5-:�* � U0()5-:��h�)/�*E��� /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'(05 /W� �+Yj:��,4�$@N&/W�����,()$'�

Page 56: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

U)� <R�,5X#%4 * ����:�* * �,� ()4�$,� <=()��$,��23��:�* �,!^P�* ���,4 (CU��+�E()B��+! * �3�)S�*'()#%4 *E��� * �)*'()5 �@?A$,:�� d��#-��4 �)/J*E��� /W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5^/W���,Yj:��+4�$+N.* ��� ��:�B�����:�* * ����:�* * �,�E(04�$,�0G

f�G � ��� ����� ����" + �����1( U)�,� ()B��1�,4��+� B)N./W����* ����:�* * �,�E(04�$,�1!��,��#%U)�,! /W����2 * ���1�,4��+� B)N #%4* ��� U�� <=�+5-�+G

AG � ��� ����� #�$%� � ���� � + ����� (CU��+�E()B�� �)/ ()5%5��)/ *E��� U)� <=�+5g!�:��E(0* #-��4�� #-4 * ��� :�* * �,�E(04�$,�0G

��G #%���� � ���!� � � � + �����D!�#� �+� �+4�$,�DSg�+*`<R�,�+4 *E���R2;(e?A#%2 :�2 /W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5j/W� �+Y":��,4�$@N

�)/J*E��� ��� ��*6()4�! 5-()��*�U)� <R�,5%�6#%4 *E����:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�)G

����� ����� � �������� ���� �������! "�$# �!�%�&�

�=5 (0� � #���$C(e*E#-�)4L�\?��g�,��#-23�,4O*E�R()���[�g�,��/W�)� 23�,! *E� (04�()5%N"]+��< ��#%$'� ������� �"!�#-$�/W�,(0*E:����,�RS7�+��*D!�#-�d$,��#-23#-4�(e*E�3S7�@*`<=�+�,4 �,23�)*E#%��4�()5 ()4�! 4���4Ad`�+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5 !�(0*E(�G������ ()4�()5%N"� #%�h/W�"$,:����,� ��4 ��#V?/W�C(e*E:����,�=#%4L< ��#%$'�.��4��6���R23������<R�,����$,��4�� #-�*E�+4j* 5%N3��S����,�U��,! #%4L*E���6/W� :���*E� (0*E�+! :�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,��)/ ��:�� $,�)� �g���E(�G

')(+*,(.- �0/ � �����R�21 ��� �����43�� �������R�

����� $+5 ()��� #���$C(0* #-��4L2L�@*E���"!;/W���=* ��#-�R��� � T��,$+*�<=()��S�(0� �,!.�)4 *E���[* �,$'��4�#-Yj:������ #%B�#-4�()5-5VN :����,!/W����$+��4 ��!��+4�$,�\d`��$,����#-4�BL#-4.*E����5A�g� � �,4��X()4�B�:�()B��65jNA�*E�+2L� �75 �85 �RB�����:��:9 ��<;HG��� #%4�B *E��#%�*E�+$'��4�#%Y":��)P�(�B����,�,!AN � �C(0� $'�;#%���7�+��/W����2L�+!L� U��+�=(05-5�* ���6$,()4�!�#%!�(0* ����� �����A!�#%$�/W�C(0* :�� �+�,G�a��C(ed*E:�� �,�R()��� * ���,4L#%* �,�E(e*E#%U)�,5VN ()!�!��,!L* � (�� #%4�B�5%���,23�)*E#%��4 /W�C(0* :�� ��U��+$+* ��� /W����2 * ���6$,()4�!�#%!�(0* �� �@*[:�4j* #-5 * ���h()!�!�#V*E#-�)4.�)/ /W�,(0*E:�� �,��4��35-��4�B��,��#%2L����� U��,� �g�,�/W��� 2L()4�$+�)G�� �3�����A!�:�$,�1(3��#-4AdB�5%� �,23�)* #-��4&��$,����� /W����( �ON"�g�)*E���+� #%�,PX( 5-#%4��C(0�[�����eT��,$@*E#-�)4ZU��+$+*E�)�1#%�6* �E()#%4��,!>()4�!�:�� �+!>* �� �+!�:�$+�3* ���L�+2L�0*E#-�)4&/W�C(0* :�� � U��+$+* ���,G � ��� ��S�(0S�#-5%#-��* #-$h�,23�)*E#%��4>� $,�)� �3#-��*E���,4K$+��23��:�*E�+!S�()���,!M��4 ( 2L(e?A#-2 :�2>=�? �<@BADC�E�F �GE�F ������S�()S�#-5-#V*`N �DH �JI��R$+5 ()��� #���$C(0* #-��4^G���:�� #%4�B *E��#%� ��� �0d

$,�+� �+P=(Z* ��� �+� ����5%!F#-� $+��2L��:�*E�+! *E�>()$'��#%�+U)� (&5%�A$,()5 2L#%4�#-2 :�2 �,� �����,G � 4��+BO(0*E#VU�� ��$,������ �+� :�5V*E��#-4 ( ��� T��,$@*E#%��43< ��#-5-�D(��g����#%*E#VU�����$,���������,��:�5%* � #%4 ()4L()$,$+�,��*E()4�$,�0P"< ���,� ��()$+$,�+��*'()4�$,�23�C()4���* ����:�* * �,�E(04�$,��#-���+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5QG

� �;()$,$+��23��5-#%� �.*E������SjT��,$+* #%U)�,�[�0/b*E��#-� ��� � T��,$+*,P7���+U)�,�E(05 �����,5%#-23#-4�()�N;�*E�+����<R�,��� $+��2 d��5%�+*E�+! * �>!��+* �,� 23#-4�� (����+*3�)/���� �����A!�#%$ /W�C(0* :�� �+� *E� :�� � !�:���#-4�B>$+5 ()��� #���$C(0* #-��4^GK5"#-23��5-�

Page 57: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

5-#%4��C(0� !�#-��$,� #%2L#%4�(0* #-��4>()4�()5%N"� #%� � ��� ���[<=()��*E���+4 :����,!K* �Z$,�)4���* � :�$@* ( �1():�� � #-()4K23�"!��,5()4�!Z��S�*'(0#-4 (L������S�()S�#%5-#%��*E#%$ �,23�)*E#%��4M� $,�)� � :�� #-4�B;����#-������� �)S�()S�#%5-#%* #-�+��()4�!Z* ��� $+��23��:�*E�+!*E��� �,������5%!^G

')(+*,(+* � ������� � ��� ����� � � � ������� 1K�R����� �����R���

I�� #%��� *E� *E� ()#-4�#-4�B �,()$'�L:A* *E�+�E()4�$,�)Pj*E����!�(0*'(�()����5-()Sg�,5-�+! ()���,#V*E���+��� �GEBE.C � A ��� F�� � �GE�E.C � A G _`4*E��#-� �\?��g�,��#-23�,4O*CP�* ����� �GE�E.C � A 5 ()Sg�,5A$,����� �+� �g��4�!�� *E��(043:A* *E�+�E()4�$,���g��� ���,� ��#-4�B1�,23�)* #-��4 (04�!()4 F�� � �GE�E.C � A 5 ()Sg�,5O* � ([4���4"d`�,23�)* #-��4�(05�:�* * �,� ()4�$,�0G � $+� �����dQU)(05-#-!�(0*E#%��4 (0����� ��()$'� <=()� :����,!*E� *E� ()#-4�()4�!>*E�+��*h��4�* ���3!�(0*'(AG;����#%�h(0����� ��()$'��<=()� $'����� �+4 � #%4�$,� *E���+� � <D(0� ( 5-#-23#%* �,!()23��:�4O*.�)/h!�(0*E(�G � :��.�\?A�7�+� #-23�,4O* � <=�+� �>�7�+��/W����2L�+! :�� #%4�B *E��� � �"$ � ���,�,! ()4�! �����

$,�)� �g���E(�G ��� #%4�B * ����� �"$ � ���,�+!9$,������:��,PD* ���M$,5 (0� � #���$C(e*E#-�)4I�\?��g�,��#-23�,4O*3<D()�L$,��4�!�:�$+* �,!:���#-4�B �AP �0fji�:�* * �,� ()4�$,�+�=���7� � �,4LSjN � ��!�#� �+� �+4j* ���7�,( � �+� �,G ��5-�@U��+4 � �g�C( � �,���R<R�,� ��:����,!L/W�)�

*E� ()#-4�#-4�B ()4�! * ����� �+2;()#%4�#-4�B � �g�C( � �,��<D()� ���+5-! ��:�* /W���D* �,�*E#-4�B�G

����� �����>$,������:��J�)/�()$+* �,! !�(0*'(D<=()�b(05-� � :����,! #%4���� !��+� *E� 2;( � � $,��23��()��#-� �)4�� S7�@*`<=�+�,44�(0* :��E(05-5%N��+5-#-$+#%* �,!�()4�!1()$@*E�+!h!�(e*'(�GX������$,5-()� ��#���$,(0*E#%��4�()4�!����,$,�)B�4�#%* #-��4 �\?A�7�+� #-23�,4O* � :�� #%4�B*E��� ����� $,�)� ��:�� $+��4���#-��* �,!3�)/ ��P ��� ��:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,��� �g� � �+4LSON3i[!�#� 7�,� �+4O*�� �g�C( � �,� �+G � � * �E()#%4*E��� ()$,$+�,��* �0� �`T��,$@*�$,5 (0� � #����,�+P^(;!�#� 7�,� �+4O* � �g�C( � �,��<=()� ���+5-!&��:A*[/W����*E�,�*E#%4�B.�C()$'�&* #-23�1* ��,4�� :����1* ��(0*�*E���1���,$+��B�4�#%],�,� �g�,�/W��� 2L()4�$+��<D()�������,!�#%$+*E�+! �)4M:�4�� �+�,4&���7�,( � �+�6!�(e*'(�G

�����=* �E()#%4�#-4�B6()4�! * �,�*E#-4�B[$,�)4�!�#%* #-��4��J<R�,��� ��� �* �g�,��/W�)� 23�,! :���#-4�B�(6$,�)2 S�#-4�(0*E#%��4h�0/g()5-5� # ?L�)/ *E���[:�* * �,�E(04�$,�\d`5-�@U��+5 /W�C(0* :�� �+�,GD(0� �,! ��4L*E�������,��:�5%* #-4�B1<=�+#-B��O*E��$,()5-$+:�5 (e*E�,!3/W���=�,()$'��)/ * ���[/W�C(e*E:����,�,PA<=��<R�,����()S�5-��*E� 2L( � � ()4 #%4�#%* # ()5 ()��� �+� � 23�,4O*��)/ * ����Sg�,��*D!�#-��$,� #%2L#%4�(0* #-4�B/W�C(e*E:����,�,G �J�3�@U0()5-:�(e*E� *E����!�#%� $+� #-23#-4�(0*E#%��4;��:�$,$+�,� �6�)/ �C()$'� :�* * �,�E(04�$,�\d`5-�@U��+5X/W�,(0*E:�� �)P��,()$'�#-4�!�#%U"#-!�:�()57/W�,(0*E:�� � <D(0� * �E()#%4��,! ���,��()� (0*E�+5%N.�)4 Sg�)*E� �)/J*E���1$+��� �g��� (�G

')(+*,( ' � � � � � ���

� ()S�5-�hc�G c;()4�!Z� ()S�5-�hc�G f;����� < * ��� ��� �,5%#-23#-4�(0��NL� �,��:�5%* �[�)/b*E���h$,5 (0� � #���$C(e*E#-�)4Z()4�!Z� �+$,��Bed4�#V*E#-�)4 * �,�*E�6/W�)� * ��� ���C()5J()4�!&()$@*E�,! !�(0*E(�P � �,���7�+$+* #%U��+5%N)G������ ���,� :�5%*E�6��S�*E()#-4��+! :�� #-4�BL*E���� �A$ � ���+�,!.!�(e*'( <D()�+P�#%4;B��+4��,� ()5QPj#-4�$,��4�$+5-:���#%U)�6Sg�,$,():�� ��*E���+� ��<D()�R� :�$'� (�5-#%2L#V*E�+!L(02L��:�4j*�)/A�,23�)*E#%��4�()50:�* * �,� ()4�$,�+�,G _`41/ ()$@*CPe()5%2L���* ��()5V/"�)/A* ����� �g�C( � �,��� ��(0!h���7� � �,4�/W�+<R�,�X*E��(04�*`<R�

�i

Page 58: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

�,23�)* #-��4�(057:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,�+G�6�6( ���,� :�5%* �)/J*E��#%�,P�* ��� *E�+��*�� �@*�/W�)�=*E���+� �1� �g�C( � �,����<=()� � �@U��,���,5VNS�#-()� �+!Z*E� <=()� !&* ��� 4��+:�*E� ()5b:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,�+PX()4�!Z* ��� ()$+$,:�� ()$+NZ�E(0* �h<=()��4��)* ()�[23�C()4�#-4�B)/W:�5QG� ()S�5-� c�G cL5-#-�*E�6��4�5%NM*E��� � �g�C( � �,����* ��(0* ��()!>()�������C?�#%2;(e*E�,5VN � ��� �)/�*E���+#-�6:�* * �,�E(04�$,�+�h(0��,23�)* #-��4�(05QG

��$'�^P�*E���.���7�,( � �+�3< #V*E� *E���M23���* /W� :��*E� (0*E�+!I:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,�+PR��(0! ()4F(0$,$,:��E()$@NF�E(0* � �)/i���G ��� P < ��#%$'� #-� $+��4���#-��* �,4O* < #%* � �)*E���,� 5%#%*E�+�E()�N>� �+� :�5V*E� ��4 �+2L�0*E#-�)4K� �+$,��B)4�#%* ��4^G�����#%��g�,��/W�)� 2L()4�$,�6�E(0* �[#%�R�*E#-5%5 4��)*RS7�@* *E�+�=*E��()4 $'��()4�$,�)P�()4�! #%�R23����*=5-# � �,5VN !�:���*E� ( $+��2 S�#%4�(ed*E#%��4 �)/ * ��� � �g�C( � �,���\?A��#-S�#V*E#%4�B �+2L�)* #-��4 ()4�!.Sg�,#-4�B *E���[��4�5%N /W�+2;()5%�[#%4;*E���[$,5 (0� � #���$C(e*E#-�)4

()4�! � �,$+��B�4�#V*E#%��4h�\?A�7�+� #-23�,4O* �,P���:�$'� *E��(e*b*E���=� 7�,$@* �)/�*E�E(0#-4�#%4�B6�)4 ��4�5VN�2;()5%�,�J()4�!h*E�,�*E#%4�B��4M( /W�,2L()5-���j:��*��7�+��/W����2;()4�$,� � #%B�4�#���$C()4O* 5%N�G

� � � �� ��� ��� � � � � � ���!$�� � � � # � ��$% � � � � � $�� � � "!�$'� � � � �0f ��� � i���G �T�B�� � � � � �)c � � ��G T�2L$ � i�� � � �Cf�� � ��G iT�� # � i�� � � �Cf�� �OiAG �� S�( � � � � � � i0f � �AG i

� ()S�5-�Mc�G c � I �,��/W�)� 2L()4�$,� ���,� :�5%*E�3#-4F$+� ����� U0()5%#-!�(e*E#-�)4 �@?A�g�,� #%2L�+4O*E� /W��� � �A$ � ���+�,! !�(0*'(�G� 4�5%N �)/ * ��� � �Z���7�,( � �+� � <=�+� �.���,�g����* �,! � #%4�$,� * ��� ���,2L()#-4�#%4�B�iZ���7�,( � �+� � ��()! /W�@<=�+�*E��()4 � ��� �)/J*E���,#-�D* �)*'(05^:�* * �,� ()4�$,�+�[(0���+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5QG

a���� *E��� � �A$ � ���+�,! $+��� ��:��,P=* ��� �+2L�0*E#-�)4 $,5 (0� � #���$C(e*E#-�)4F* �,$'��4�#-Yj:�� N"#%�,5-!��,!F*E��(0*3*E���

��� ��������� /W�,(0*E:���� <D(0� S7�+��* (0* !�#%� $+� #-23#-4�(0*E#%4�BRSg�+*`<R�,�+4 �+2L�)* #-��4�()50�*'(0* �,�+P)()4�!�� �� ���������

<=()�X� �,$+��4�!1S7�+��*,G�� �,4��+�E()5%5%N6� �g�C( � #%4�B�Pe()5%* ����:�B)�[*E���+� � /W�C(e*E:����,�X��()! *E��� ��#-B����,��* <R�,#%B��O*E�+!U0()5-:�� ��:�* �)/ ()5-57�)/ * �����@?"*E� ()$+* �,!M/W�C(0* :�� �+�,P�*E���,#-�D<R�,#%B��O*E� <=�+� �1��* #-5-57� �+5 (0* #%U��+5%NL� 2L()5-5HG

������� �,��:�5%* � /W�)��* ����()$+* �,!������F!�(0*E(h()��� B�#%U)�,43#-4 �b(0S�5-��c�G f�G �65%*E����:�B�� *E���[()$+$,:�� ()$+N�E(e*E�,��()���h4��)*�()����#-B��M()��* ����� �1�)/ *E����� �,()5 !�(0*E(�P�*E���,� �h� �+� :�5V*E��()� ��23��� � ��#-B�4�#���$,()4O*[(04�!

����� U"#%!�� ( Sg�+*�*E�+� #-4�!�#%$C(0* #-��4 �0/A��� <K�,23�)*E#%��4�()50:�* * �,� ()4�$,�+�b( �+$+*J� �+$,��B�4�#%*E#%��4��g�,�/W��� 2L()4�$+�Sg�,$C(0:�� � *E���,� ��#%�D2L�)� ���+2L�)* #-��4�()57!�(0*'(�G�a�:��*E���+� 23��� �0P�Sg�,$,():�� ��*E��#-�D!�(e*'( <=()� ��� �"!�:�$+�,!SON�()$@*E�����,Pg<=� $,()4�2;( � � ( !�#%� �+$+*�$+��23��()� #%� ��4 < #%*E�Z� �,��:�5%* �[/W� �)2 �)* ���,�65-#V*E�,� (0*E:�� �)G[�����(CU��+�E()B��;()$,$+:��E(0$+N /W��� (05-5��)/D* ���;���7�,( � �+� � #%� i��AG ��� G �����L�7�+��/W����2;()4�$,�;�)4K�C(0$'� �)/�*E���� �g�C( � �,���[#%��2L������*E��(04 � ��� Sg�+* * �,�D* ��()4M$'��()4�$+�h�g�,�/W��� 2L()4�$+�)G

Page 59: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � � �� ��� ��� � � � � � ���!$�� � � � # � ��$% � � � � � $�� � � "$,$ � � � i)i � � i���G i$+5 � ��� f � i � ��c�G cB�B � �� �Cf�c �Cf � i ��G �T�B ��� � � � � �)f �)f�G �2 / � � c)c )c i)c�G c2 � � � f � �� i AG �232 �0f � � c � �Oi �iAG f

� ()S�5-�[c�G f�� Ib�+��/W����2;(04�$,� ���,� :�5%*E�=��4 $,����� �DU0()5%#-!�(e*E#-�)43�\?A�7�+� #-23�,4O* �D/W���D()$@*E�+!.!�(0*'(AG � U)�,� d()5%5QP�* ���,��� � �+� :�5V*E��()���h$+��4�� #%��* �,4O*[< #V*E�M�)*E���+� ��:�S�5%#-� ���,!Z���,��:�5%* �6��4M�,23�)* #-��4^G ������/W�,2L()5-�� �g�C( � �,����()��� B�B�PeT�B�P�2 � P�()4�! 232 G

_ * #-�b#-4O*E�+� �,�*E#%4�B[*E� 4��)*E�=* ��(0* *E�������7�,( � �+� � < ��� ��()! * ���=<R��� �* ()$,$+:��E(0$+N � (0*E�+�,P@T�B�(04�!232 P�()� ��Sg�)*E�./W�,2L()5%��� �g�C( � �,���,G=�����1�0*E���+� *`<R� /W�,2L()5-�����7�,( � �+� �6#-4 *E���1�\?A�7�+� #-23�,4O*6()���

B�B1()4�! 2 � Gb�������,���)/ *E���+� � /W�,2L()5-�D���7�,( � �+� �R()5-��� ��(CU���*E������#-B����+��*�4j:�2 Sg�,���)/ /W��:���* �E(0* �,!:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�,G�� ��#-5%�3* ��#-�1$,�)� ��:�� $,��4O*'(0#-4��h��4�5%N (0$+*E�+! � �g�,�+$'�^P *E��#-� ��#%* :�(0*E#%��4>/W� �,Yj:��+4O*E5%N�"$,$,:�� � #-4.���C()5 d`5-#V/W�[��$,�,4�()� #%���D< ���,4Z( :�� �+��#%4O*E�,� ()$+* �D< #%* � ( !�#-()5-�)B�:����NA�*E�+2 G �[� �NA�*E�+223#-� ���,$+��B�4�#V*E#-�)41�"$,$+:�� �+P)*E���=4j:�2 Sg�,� �)/ �,23�)*E#%��4�()5O:A* *E�+�E()4�$,�,�b#-4�$+� �C(0� �,� < ��#-5%�R���,$,�)B�4�#%* #-��4�g�,��/W�)� 2L()4�$,� !��,$,���C()���,�+G

a�����*E���h()$+* �,! !�(0*'(AP�*E���1$,5-()� ��#���$,(0*E#%��4 �@?A�7�+� #%2L�+4j* N"#-�+5-!��+! * ��(0* � �� ��������� <D(0�6*E���Sg�,��*.(0* !�#%� $+� #-23#-4�(0*E#%4�B>S7�@*`<=�+�,4 ��:��L�,23�)*E#%��4�()5 ��*E(0*E�+�,G������ /W�C(0* :�� � ��� ��������� <=()�� �+$,��4�!ZSg�,��*,P�/W��5-5%� <=�+!MSON ��� �������� � G

��� �� � � �� �&��� �� �� � � ��� �26�

_ *�#%�[#%4j* �,���,��* #-4�BL*E� �\?�(02L#%4��h* ��� �,23�)* #-��4 � �,$+��B�4�#V*E#%��4Z���,� :�5%*E�6/W����* ��� ()$@*E�+!�!�(0*'(L:�� #%4�B( & �,$+�,#%U)�,� � �g�,� (0*E#%4�B �=��(0�E()$@*E�,��#-�*E#-$ � & � � � $,:��U��)G ����� & � � $,:��U���23�C()��:�� �+�;*E���

*E� ()!��\d`� MSg�+*`<R�,�,4 * ����(0$,$,�+��*'(04�$,���0/ $,����� �+$+*E5VN3#-!��+4j* #����+!;�+2L�)* #-��4�()5�:�* * �,� ()4�$,�+���H#HG �0G !��\d*E�+$+* #-��4 �E(0* � ��()4�! *E��� / ()5-���3()$,$+�,��*E()4�$,�;�)/D:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,�1*E��(0*1<R�,� �L#-4�$+��� ���,$@*E5%N&#-!��+4j* #����+!()�1�,23�)*E#%��4�()5 �H#QG �)GL/ ()5-���L(05 ()��2 �E(0* � �EG _`!��C(05-5%N)PJ<R�L<R��:�5%! <=()4O* * �Z���,�;23�����3�+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,��S7�+#-4�B $+��� ���,$+* 5%N.#%!��,4O* #����+!^P�()4�! /W�+<R�,� 4��+:�*E� ()5 :�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,��#-4�$+��� ���,$+* 5%NL#-!��+4O*E#Vd���+!Z()���+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5QG ����#-��<R��:�5%!M$+��� ���,���7��4�!M* � * ����$,:��U��1� ��#V/ *E#%4�B *E� <=()� ! *E���1:����7�+� 5-�+/ *

Page 60: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

�)/J*E������5%�)*CG

ab#-B):�� �Mced �>����� < �;*E��� & � � ��5-�)* /W��� * ���Z(0$+*E�+! !�(e*'(�G �����M* ��� �+� Sg�,�* #-4�!�#%U"#-!�:�()5/W�C(e*E:����,�L()4�! (>$,�)2 S�#-4�(0*E#%��4F�)/[* ���M* ���I*`<R�K!�#-� $+� #%2L#%4�(0*E#%4�BZ/W�,(0*E:����,�L()� �M��5%�)* * �,!^GI_ *

#-�;$,5-�,()�;/W����2 * ��� ��B�:����&*E��(e* � �� � ������� !��"�,�.��#-B�4�#���$C(04j* 5%N Sg�+* * �,� * ��()4 �� � ������� P()4�! /W:���* ���,��2L�)� �)PR!��"�,�L()�3<R�,5%5 ()5-�)4��M()�;(04jNF$+��2 S�#%4�(0* #-��4F�)/[#%* < #%* �I�0*E���+�3/W�,(0*E:����,�+G���j:��,P (05%*E����:�B�� ��� ����� ��� #%�=*E��� � �,$+��4�!MS7�+��*�/W�,(0*E:����)P�#V*�#-�R*E�"� ��#-B���5%N3$,����� �+5 (0* �,! < #%* �� �� ��������� * � Sg� �)/�/W:���* ���,� :���� * ��*E��� ��N"�*E�,2MGF�����M��N"��* �,2 #-4���*E�,()!F��� �@/W�,���3* ��(0!�!*E��� ��� ��� ��� � /W�,(0*E:�� � ()�R#%* �R���,$,�)4�!.$C()4�!�#-!�(e*E�)G ��� <=�@U��,�+P ()5%* ����:�B)� ��� ����� � � !��A�+�� #%B�4�#���$C()4O* 5%N Sg�+* * �,� *E��()4;$'��()4�$+� �7�+��/W����2;()4�$,�[SONL#%* � �,5V/ Pj#%*R#-� :�4�()S�5%�6* � /W:���* ���,�R#-23��� � U)�� U��+�=*E��� � �� � ������� /W�,(0*E:�� ��(0$+*E#%4�B (05-��4��0G ����#%�=$C(04 S7�6#-4O*E�+� �����+* �,! ()�=( �7�)� #%* #%U)�6���,� :�5%*CG����(0*1#%�,P^/W����( U��+��N>��#-23��5-� ��$,����#-4�B.23�,$'��()4�#-��2 ��4 ( � #-4�B�5-� /W�,(0*E:�� �)PX��#-B�4�#���$C(04j*����,��:�5%* �

$C(04 Sg�1()$'��#-�@U��+!Z#-4.!�#-� $+� #%2L#%4�(0*E#%4�B �+2L�0*E#-�)4.#-4M()$+* �,!M� �g�,�+$'�^G

�=���"��� #%4�BF()49�@?�()$@* ���g�,�E(e*E#-4�B �7�)#-4O* ��4 * ����$,:���U��0P6<R��$C()49�\?�()2L#%4��Z* ����� �+5 (0* #%U��$C(0��()S�#%5-#%*`N1�)/g*E����#%4�!�#VUA#%!�:�()5j/W�C(e*E:����,�,G�a�����2 * ��� ��B�:����)P�* ��� S7�+��* ���g�,�E(e*E#-4�B �7��#%4O* /W��� *E���

��� ��� ��� � ��()� ()23�+*E�+��#-��(0*�()����:�4�! ���� $,�)� � �+$+*1()$+$,�+��*'()4�$,�)G �6� #%4�B *E��� ��� � ����� �

/W�C(e*E:����)PX*E��� ��N"�*E�,2 <R��:�5%! / ()5%� �+5%N&���,$+��B�4�#%],� 4��C(0� 5%N�c ��� �)/ *E���L4��+:�*E� ()5 :�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,� (0�Sg�,#-4�B.�,23�)*E#%��4�()5HG ��� <=�@U��,�+P :�� #-4�B T�:���* *E��� � �� ��������� /W��� 2L(e?A#-2 :�2 !�#%� $+� #-23#-4�()S�#-5%#%*`N)P

<R�h$+��:�5-! ���,!�:�$+�1* ��� / ()5-����()$,$+�,��*E()4�$+�h� (0*E��* �;c ���.G

�����,��� � �+� :�5V*E�M#-4�!�#-$C(e*E#-4�B *E��(0* * ����2L(e?A#-2 :�2 ��#V*E$'�^P�(CU)�,�E(0B��K��#V*E$'�^P�()4�! (CU)�,�E(0B���,4��,� B0N ()� �MB��"�A!F!�#%� $,��#-23#-4�(e*E����� �)/��+2L�0*E#-�)4 #%� 4��)*3� :������ #%� #%4�B�P=�+� �g�,$+# ()5%5%N ��#-4�$+�M* ���,�����4�!�#-4�B��1()���3(M���,� :�5%*1�)/D:�� #-4�BZ()$@*E�+!����7�+�,$'�^G & �,$,()5-5 /W����2 �,()� 5%#-�,�[� �,$@*E#%��4��1#-4�*E��#%� *E���\d� #%�,PJ*E��(0*�* ���;�\?�$+:�� ��#-��4�S7�@*`<=�+�,4 * ���L/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'()5 /W���,Yj:��,4�$,#-�+� �)/D� �C(05R(04�! ()$@*E�+!K!�(0*E(<=()� !�� ()2;(e*E#-$,()5-5VN&!�#� �+� �+4j*,G�a�� �+Y":��,4O*E5VNK#%4 ()$@*E�,! !�(0*'(�P *E��� 23���* ���,(CUA#%5%N � �+5-#%�,!Ad :��7�)4

/W�C(e*E:����,� /W���1�@?A�����,��� #-4�B��,23�)*E#%��4�#%�1* ��(0* �)/D/W:�4�!�()2L�+4O*'()5�/W� �+Y":��,4�$@N ()4�!K�,4��+� B)N)GZ����#%�()5%� � ()B����,�,� < #%* �I�0*E���+�L5%#%*E�+�E()�NK<R��� � � *E��(e*;���,$,�)B�4�#-]+�.*E��� /W:�4�!�(02L�+4j*E()5D/W� �+Yj:��,4�$@N (0�*E���623����*����,5%# ()S�5%�=/W�C(e*E:�����/W����!��@*E�+$+*E#%4�B1�,23�)*E#%��4^G �6� <=�@U��+�,P�* ����/W:�4�!�()23�,4O*'(05�/W� �,Yj:��+4�$+N)P� �g�,$+#���$,()5-5VN�* ���.2L(e?A#-2 :�2 ��#V*E$'�^P�#%� :�4�/W���*E:�4�(e*E�,5VNK4��)*3(&B��"�A! !�#%� $+� #-23#-4�(0*E����/W��� ���C()5!�(0*E(�G

� �

Page 61: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 10

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

false acceptance rate

corr

ect a

ccep

tanc

e ra

te

max pitchavg pitchavg energymax pitch and avg energy

ab#%B�:�� ��ced � � & � � $+:���U)�[/W����*E��� �����I!�(0*E(�G ����#%�=$,:���U��6<D()�R��� �"!�:�$+�,!.SON *E�����,�6#-4�!�#VU"#-!Ad:�()5b��� �����A!�#-$ /W�C(e*E:����,�1()4�!>SON>( /W:�5-5 d * �E()#%4��,!&23�"!��,5 :�� #%4�B.*E��� Sg�,��*�*`<R� !�#-��$,� #%2L#%4�(0* #-4�B/W�C(e*E:����,� 2;( ? ��#%*E$'� ()4�!M(CU"B �,4��+� B)N)G

���� ��� # # � ��

����#%�M$'��()��*E�+� !��,� $+� #%S7�+� *E���>U0()��#-��:��M23�+* ���"!��.*E��(0* <R�,�����+2L��5%� N��,!8#-4 *E��#-�.*E���+� #%� * �#-!��,4O*E#V/ N ��� �)� �"!�#-$./W�C(e*E:����,�L/W�)�3�+2L�0*E#-�)4 $+5 ()��� #���$C(0* #-��4I()4�!I� �+$,��B�4�#%*E#%��4^G �6��#-4�B�� �,�g�C(e*:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,� (0��* ���3S�()� #%���)/D��:��1#%4OU��,�*E#%BO(0*E#%��4^PX()4K()4�()5VN"� #-� �0/D� �g�,�+$'�KU0()� #-(0*E#%��4���!�:��3* �

�,23�)* #-��4F<D(0�;�g�,��/W�)� 23�,! :�� #-4�BK!�#-()5-��B):��,� *E�K$C()��* :�� � 5-#%4�B�:�#%��*E#%$ #-4A/W��� 2L(0*E#%��4^P � �g�,$@*E� �edB�� ()2L�6*E� #-5%5-:��*E�E(e*E� $'��(04�B��,��#%4>* ��� �,4��,� B0N>��� :�* * �,� ()4�$,� !�:��E(0* #-��4^PX(04�!>��� �����A!ANjd S�()���,!*E�"��5%� * � �,23����()��#-]+�6*E����$'��()4�B)�,��#-43/W:�4�!�(02L�+4j*E()57/W���,Yj:��+4�$+N ()4�! !�:��E(0* #-��4^G � !�#-��$,:���� #%��4#-�[B�#%U)�,4>��4>��� < * ��� �@?"*E� ()$+* �,!>/W�C(0* :�� �+��<=�+� � $'�������,4K()��<=�+5-5 (0��( !��,��$,� #%��*E#%��4>�)/ �C()$'� G����� $,5-()� ��#���$,(0*E#%��4�()4�! ���,$+��B�4�#V*E#-�)4Z*'()� � ��()� � �����,���,4O*E�+! ()4�!>���,� :�5%*E��(0� � !�#%� $+:�� ���,! (04�!�+U0()5%:�(0* �,!^G

� ��#-5%��<=��<R�,� �1� :�$,$,�+� �/W:�5 #%4 S�:�#-5%!�#-4�B ( 23�"!��,5 * ��(0*�$,�):�5-! !�#%� $,��#-23#-4�(e*E� ()$@*E�+! �+2L�0d*E#%��4�()5�()4�!34���4Ad �,23�)*E#%��4�()5"� �g�,�+$'�^PA* ���623�"!��,5�<=()� :�4�()S�5-�D*E�12L( � ��*E����� � !�#%��*E#%4�$+* #-��4�� ��4*E��� 4�(0* :��E()5J�,23�)* #-��4�(05 � �g�,�,$'� G _`4&*E��� 4��@?"* $'��()�A*E�,�+P <R� < #-5%5J���,� * ��(0*[�":�2;()4Z5-#-�*E�+4��,���

� �

Page 62: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

()���6(05-� � 4��)* ��()��* #-$+:�5 ()��5%N1$,�)4�� #%��*E�+4O*=#%4 *E���+#-�7T�:�!�B)2L�+4j* ���)/ �+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5�$+��4O*E�+4j*R�)/74�(0* :��E()5� �g�,�+$'�Z!�� (C< 4M/W����2 ���7� � �,4 !�# ()5%��B�:��[#-4O*E�+�E()$@*E#-�)4^P��@U��,4M< ���,4MB�#VU��,4 *E���h(0� B�:�(0S�5%NL�C()��#-�+�*'(0� � �)/ !�#%� $,��#-23#-4�(e*E#-4�B 23#-4�#%2;()5g��()#%� �+P�< #%* � * �����E()23� � �g�C( � �,�6()4�!M5-#%4�B�:�#%��* #-$[$+��4O*E�+4j*,G

� �

Page 63: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � ��� ����

� � ��� � ��������� �� ��� � � �����

�����3$,�����7�)�E(./W����*E��#%� *E���+� #-��<R�,� �32L()4j:�()5-5VNZ$+� �,(0*E�+!KSON � �,5VN"#-4�B ��4�(.� #-4�B�5-� #-4�!�#%U"#-!�:�()5

�H2hNA���,5V/ ��* � $,5 (0� � #V/ N6* ����()����� ������# (0* � �,23�)* #-��4�(050�*'(0* ��/W�)�^�C()$'�1:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�)G&5"#-4�$+�b*E���+� � <=()�4��M$,��5%5 ()Sg��� (0*E#%��4Z��4 ()2 S�#-B�:���:�� :�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�1��� � :�SA*E5-� !�#� �+� �+4�$,�+�1* ��(0*12;(CNZ��(CU��3S7�+�,4�g�,� $+�,#VU��,! P #%*�#%��Yj:�#V*E�1�C()�N *E�;$+��23��� �+���,4�! *E��(0* * ��#-��2L�@*E���"!M�)/ *'(0B�B�#-4�B * ��� �+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5��*E(0*E�[�)/ ()4.:�* * �,� ()4�$,� 23#-B)�j*R��(CU�� Sg�,�+4 ��� ��S�5-�,2L(0* #-$)G �[4.:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+��*E��(e*D<D(0���7�+� $,�+#%U)�,!*E�ZS7�;/W��:���* �E(0* �,! <=()� ()��� :�23�,! * �&S7�;� �Z* ��� ��:�B�����:�* *E���.(04�()5%N"��#-�,P *E���+4 5 (0* �,� :�� �,! * �!��@*E�,��2L#%4�� *E������� �����A!�#%$�/W�,(0*E:�� �,� /W���=$+5 ()��� #���$C(0* #-��4 G �6� <R�+U)�,�,P�#V/ * ���,���[<D(0�D( 23��� ��5-# � �+5%N�,23�)* #-��4�(05���*E(0*E� /W��� *E����:A* *E�+�E()4�$,�)Pj*E���,4L* ����� �,��:�5%* � /W� ��2 * ����$,5 (0� � #���$C(e*E#-�)4 �@?A�7�+� #%2L�+4j* �<R��:�5-!K4��)* Sg�.()�h� �,5%# ()S�5-�)G � �Z$,��:�4O* �,� *E��� � :�SjT��,$+* #%U"#%*`N��)/ ��4�� #-4�!�#%U"#-!�:�()5 *'()B�B)#-4�BZ()5-5:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,� ()4�! *E�;()� ���,���[*E���hYj:�()5-#V*`N.�)/ * ���1$,�����7��� (�P7(L5-#%��* �,4�#%4�B ��*E:�!�N <D()�6�7�+��/W����2L�+!

< #%* � �":�2;()4M� :�S"T��,$@*E�,G

�0��� ������� �# �!�%� � � � ��� �

� #-�*E�,4�#-4�B3�@?A�g�,� #%2L�+4O*E�6<R�,��� �g�,��/W�)� 23�,! < #V*E� �L�j:�2L()4Z��:�S"T��,$@*E�+P *E�����,�h2;()5%�1()4�! * ��� �+�/W�,2L()5%�)P�< ��� ��()!&4��)*6�����+U"#-��:�� 5%N 5%#-�*E�,4��,! * �;:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,��#%4M* ��� $+��� ��:��,G������,��� � :�S"T��,$@*E�<R�,� ��(0� � �+! *E� � (0*E��*E���[�@?A��� �+� ���,!M�,23�)*E#%��4L�0/J()4 :�*�*E�,� ()4�$+��SON;$+��2L��()� #%4�B #V*R* � *E��� ��� �*:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�Z#-4 #%* � � �,�g�C(e*;B�����:��^G a �):��L!�#� 7�,� �+4O*;���,�g�C(0*LB�� �):���� <=�+� �Z:�� �,! !�:�� #%4�B>*E��#%��@?A�g�,��#-23�,4O*CG

a�����()4ON � #%4�B�5-�=� �,�g�C(e*RB)� ��:�� Pj* ��� � :�SjT��,$+* <=()�RB)#%U��+43(1���+* �)/7#-4��*E� :�$+*E#%��4���$,�)4�$,�+� 4�#%4�B

��c

Page 64: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

*E���,#-� *'(0� � G � ��$,� �+�,4���4�()�������)*��0/ *E���1#-4O* �,��/ (0$,� #%� !�#-����5 (CN��+!&#-4 ab#%B�:�� �1f0d ��GD�D<R� :�* * �,� d()4�$+�,��(0� ����5 (CN��+! � :�$,$,�+� ��#%U��+5%N)P�< #%*E�L��4��6:�* * �,�E(04�$,�6B�:�()� ()4O*E�,�+!;*E�hS7��*E��� ��� �*D:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+��)/ * ��� ���+*,G������ ����!��,�6#-4 < ��#-$'� * ��� :A* *E�+�E()4�$,�,��()� �1��5 (CN)�,!Z<=()��� ()4�!���235%N $'����� �+4^G������� :�S"T��,$@*.#-�3()5%5-� <=�+! * �K5%#-��* �,4F*E� *E���M��()#%�3�0/ :�* * �,� ()4�$,�+� ()�32L()4ON *E#-23�,�3()�34��+�,!��+!9SjN$,5%#-$ � #-4�B *E����� C ? C = A S�:�*�*E��4^G

ab#-B�:�� � f0d � � _`4O*E�,�/ ()$,� /W��� ��:�2L()4Ad�� #%��*E�+4��,� � ?A�g�,� #%2L�+4O*CG

�6/ * �,�15-#-�*E�+4�#-4�B.* �M* ���L:A* *E�+�E()4�$,�,�+P * ���L��:�S"T��+$+* #%� *E���+4K������2L�A*E�,!>*E�M$,5%#-$ � * ��� $,��� d� �+� �g��4�!�#%4�B S�:�*�*E��4�*E��(0*�S7�+��*�!��+� $+� #-Sg�,� < ��#%$'��:A* *E�+�E()4�$,� ��� ��� ����� *E����:�B��O* <D()��23��� �����5%�,���[/W� :��*E� (0*E�+!^Gh����� � :�S"T��+$+*1#-�[()� � �,!>*E�.$+5-#-$ � � ����� �.#V/���� *E���):�B��O*�*E��(0*�*E��� ��� �*:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�&��5 (CN)�,! <=()�;23�����M/W��:���* �E(0* �,! *E��()4I* ���Z���,$,�)4�!^G � 4 * ���Z�0*E���+�;��()4�!^P�#%/[���*E����:�B��O*D* ��(0*D* ��� � �+$,��4�!M:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+��*E��(0*=<D()����5 (CN��+! <=()��23��� ��/W� :��*E� (0*E�+!^P�*E���,4 ����<=()�������2L�A*E�,!&* �.$,5%#-$ � � ��� � ��G1_ / *E��� � �g�C( � �,�=T�:�!�B)�,!�*E��(e*�*E���+� � <=()��4��.!�#%��*E#%4�B�:�#%� ��(0S�5-�!�#� �+� �,4�$,� #-4 * ��� �,23�)*E#%��4�()5 ��*E(0*E�+�3�0/6* ���.:�* * �,� ()4�$,�+�3* ��(0* <R�,���M��5 (CN��+!^PR* ���,4F���.<=()�()� � �,!M*E� � �+5-�+$+* � ��� � ��G

5A�,4�4����,#%� �+�1���C()!����+* � ()4�!>* ��� ():�!�#-�.$C(0��()S�#%5-#%* #-�+�[�)/R(����,5%5 $+��2L��:�*E�+��<=�+� � :�� �+! /W�)�

�)f

Page 65: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

$,�)4�!�:�$@*E#-4�B6*E���,� � �@?A�g�,��#-23�,4O*E�+Gb�������,�=�0/�*E��� /W��:��J5%#-�*E�X$,��4�� #-�*E�+! �)/�:�* * �,�E(04�$,�+� *E��(0* <R�,���� �+�7�,(0*E�+! < #V*E�>()5%2L�)��* �\?�(0$+*E5VNZ* ��� �E()23� 5-#%4�B�:�#%��*E#%$h$+��4O*E�+4j*,G ����� /W��:��*E�>5-#%��*CP7��� <=�@U��+�,P$,�)4�� #%��*E�+!h�0/�:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,� *E��(0* <=�+� ��/W�E()B)2L�+4j* �^*E��(e*X$,��4O*'(0#-4��+!�* �����E()23� 5-#%4�B�:�#%��* #-$J2L�+� �E(0B��()��*E��� ��� ��*�:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�)P�#%4 (04 �+5-5-#%��*E#%$C()5�/W����2 G

�����3B��O()5 �0/R* ��#-����* :�!�N&<=()��*E� �+U0()5%:�(0* �3#V/ �)*E���+��� :�S"T��+$+* � $,�):�5-!>!��@*E�,$@* $'��()4�B��+�h#%4�,23�)* #-��4�(05 ��*E(0*E� < ���+4Z:�*�*E�+�E()4�$+�,� <=�+� ��� �+�7�,(0*E�+!Z#%4M��:�$,$+�,��� #-�)4^G

�0��� � � ��� ���&�

����#%���\?A�7�+� #-23�,4O*�N"#-�,5%!��,!M� �)2L��:����+/W:�5X#-4A/W��� 2L(0*E#%��4^G a #-� �*CP�/W��� (05-5^���,�g�C(0*6B�� �):���� �@?A$,�+��*��4��0P)*E���D�,23�)*E#%��4�()5O�*'(0* �D�)/�* ���D���,�g�C(0* �b<D(0� �E()���,5VN�T�:�!�B��,!h*E��Sg�=5%�,� �b�,23�)*E#%��4�()5�* ��()4 *E���������*6:�* * �,�E(04�$,�0GD_ *�#-� $,5%�C()��/W� �)2 *E����< #-!���U0()��# ()S�#-5-#V*`N;#%4.*E���1� �+� :�5V*E� *E��(0* * ���h�+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5

$,�)4j* �,4O*.�)/ * ���,���&:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�.#-�34��)*LU��+��N $+5-�,()� 5VNF2;()4�#%/W�,�*E�+!^P ()4�! * ��#-�L2;(CN ��()�*E#-()5-5VN�@?A��5-()#-4.* ����#-4�()S�#-5-#V*`N �)/b* ������N"��* �,2 * �3!�#-� $+� #%2L#%4�(0*E�6*E�����,23�)* #-��4�(05 $,�)4j* �,4O*6()��<=�+5-5HG

� ��� � ��� � � ���!� ��� � � � ��� �� ��G �� ��G c�c ��G � ic ��G �Oi ��G � i ��G � if ��G �Oi ��G c�c � ��G � i ��G �� ��G c�c

�b()S�5-� f�G � ��& �,� :�5%*E��/W����2 B�����:�� ���)/b�j:�2L()4Ad 5-#%��*E�+4��,���*E:�!AN�G

� ��� � ��� � � ���!� ��� � � � ��� �� ��G c�c � ��G �Oic ��G �Oi � ��G c�cf ��G c�c � ��G �Oi ��G �Oi � ��G c�c

�b()S�5-� f�G � ��& �,� :�5%*E��/W����2 B�����:�� � �)/b�j:�2L()4Ad 5-#%��*E�+4��,���*E:�!AN�G

��

Page 66: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� ��� � ��� � � ���!� ��� � � � ��� �� ��G ��c � ��G � ic ��G �Oi � ��G c�cf ��G � i � ��G ��c ��G �� � ��G ��

�b()S�5-� f�G c ��& �,� :�5%*E��/W����2 B�����:��Mc �)/b�j:�2L()4Ad 5-#%��*E�+4��,���*E:�!AN�G

� ��� � ��� � � ���!� ��� � � � ��� �� ��G c�c ��G c�c ��G c�cc � ��G �� ��G ��f ��G c�c � ��G �Oi ��G �Oi � ��G c�c� ��G � i � ��G ��ci � � ��G � �� ��G c�c ��G � i ��G ��

�b()S�5-� f�G f���& �,� :�5%*E��/W����2 B�����:�� f �)/b�j:�2L()4Ad 5-#%��*E�+4��,���*E:�!AN�G

� �

Page 67: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � ��� ���� �

� � � ��� � ����� �

_`4�*E��#%�[*E���,� #%�,P <R� �@?A��5%��� �+! $'��()�E()$@*E�+� #-�*E#%$,���)/ �+2L�)* #-��4�()5 ���7�+�,$'� SON&:���#-4�B * ��� � �g�,$@*E� �edB�� ()2 (04�! ��� �)� �"!�#-$3*E�"��5-�+G������ �+�.$,�����7��� (Z<=�+� �.$+� �C(e*E�,! P �0/�< ��#-$'� *E��� �X�"$ � ���,�+! (04�!����� $+��� ��:�� <=�+� � :�� �+!I/W��� (>$+��23��()�E(e*E#%U)�.��* :�!�N Sg�+*`<R�,�+4 � �,()5�()4�! ()$@*E�+! !�(0*'(�G 5A#V?������� �"!�#-$L/W�C(0* :�� �+� <=�+� �.�@?"* �E()$@*E�,!F/W� �)2 * ��� $,�)5-5-�+$+* �,! !�(0*E(�()4�! �*E:�!�#%�,! * ��!��+* �,� 23#-4��*E���,#-���g�)* �,4O*E#-()5 *E� !�#%� $+� #-23#-4�(0*E�[()2L�)4�B /W� :��*E�E(e*E�,! ()4�!M4���4"d`�,23�)* #-��4�(057���7�+�,$'�^G

�[4h�@?A�7�+� #%2L�+4j*E()5O23�+*E���A!��)5-��B)N�<=()� !��,� #%B�4��+!h/W��� ���A*E#-2L()50$,��23��()��#-� �)41�0/�*E���R(0$,��:��*E#%$

$,�)� � �+5 (0* �,���)/R�,23�)*E#%��4^G _ *�<=()�h�)S�� �+��U��+! �C(0� 5%NZ��4>*E��(0*����7�,( � �+� �h�)/ *E�+4����,�g�C(0* �,!�<R����!�����R:�* * �,�E(04�$,�+�D< ���,4 23#-� ���,$+��B�4�#V*E#-�)43�"$,$+:�� ���,!^G������[� �,�g�+* #%* #-��4�� <=�+� � :���:�()5%5%N ��* � :�$@*E:����,!*E���&�E()23�&5%#-4�B�:�#-��* #-$,()5-5VN�PR()4�! /W� �+Yj:��,4O*E5VN (K$'��(04�B���#-4 �,23�)*E#%��4�()5���*E(0*E��(05-� �K�A$+$,:���� �,! G�=��4����,Yj:��+4j* 5%N)P^:�� #%4�B *E���+� � ��(0�E()5%5-�,5 :�* * �,�E(04�$,�+�����,5%�7�+!Z#%� ��5-(0*E��* ��� �\?���� �,��� �+! �+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5��*E(0*E�1()4�! �+5-#-23#-4�(0*E�+!;U0()� #-()S�#-5%#%* #-�,��!�:���* �3U0()��# (0* #-��4��=#-4 ���7�,( � �+�[()4�! 5%#-4�B�:�#-��* #-$6$,��4O*E�+4O*CG

HZ���*R�0/7* ����()4�()5VNA��#-� ���,5-#%�,! ��43� �g�,$@*E����B��E(0����#-$ (04�! ��� �����A!�#-$ ()4�(05%N"� #%� *E��!��+* �,��2L#%4�� (� �@*[�0/ /W�,(0*E:����,��/W��� $,5-()� ��#���$,(0*E#%��4^G _`4 ��:���#%4jU)�,�*E#-B�(0*E#%��4^P�<R�1/W�):�4�! *E��(0* ���,��:�5%* ��4���� 2L()5-5VN� �+�7�)��*E�+! #%4 �0*E���+��5%#%* �,�E(e*E:����)P�()5V*E���):�B�� �,4�$+��:�� ()B�#-4�B�P ()� �1()4M:�4����C()5%#-�*E#-$ $+��23��()� #%� ��4 /W�)�$,5-()� ��#���$,(0*E#%��4�()4�!K���,$+��B�4�#V*E#-�)4 �\?A�7�+� #-23�,4O* �h< #%* �����C()5�!�(e*'(�G._`4���()��* #-$+:�5 ()�+P *E��� /W:�4�!�( d

23�,4O*'()5A/W� �,Yj:��+4�$+N #%��( B��A�"! !�#%� $,��#-23#-4�(e*E���X/W����()$@*E�,!3� �g�,�+$'�^P"S�:�*�4��)*�4��,$,�+� � ()� #%5%N /W��� ���C()5!�(0*E(�G

������$,5-()� ��#���$,(0*E#%��4.�7�+��/W����2;(04�$,���)4 (0$+*E�+! � �g�,�,$'�M<D(0����#-B�4�#���$,()4O*E5%NLSg�+* * �,�D* ��()4.*E��(e*��4 * ��� 4�(0* :��E()57�,23�)*E#%��4�()5g:�*�*E�,� ()4�$+�,�,P���:�B�B��+��* #-4�B *E��(0* ()$@*E�,! �+2L�)* #-��4;2;(CNLS7� (04M:�4�� �\d()5%#-��* #-$ 23�"!��,5 �0/=*E��� U0()��# ()S�#-5-#V*`NM�,4�$+��:�4O*E�+� �,!K#-4>� �,()5 �,23�)*E#%��4�()5 �@?A�����,� ��#-��4 G ���3/W��:�4�!

�Oi

Page 68: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

*E��(0*�(;$+��2 S�#%4�(0*E#%��4Z�0/ *E��� 2L(e?A#-2 :�2 ��#%* $'�>()4�!>(CU��+�E()B)� �,4��+� B)NM/W�C(0* :�� �+� !�#-! *E��� Sg�,�*T���S �)/ !�#-��$,��#-23#-4�(0* #-4�BhS7�@*`<=�+�,4&�+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5^(04�! 4���4Ad`�+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5g� �g�,�,$'� G

� ��� ��� � � &��� �� ��

=�+$C():����L* ��� !�(0*'( $,�)5-5-�+$+* #-��4����,Yj:�#-���,! � :�$'� ( B)� �C(e*h!��C()5��)/ *E#%2L�0P^<=�3!�#-! 4��)*1B��@*�*E�M(�g��#-4O* < ���+� ��<=� $,��:�5-!1#-4O*E�+B��E(0* ��(��N"��*E�+2 $,��23�7�)4��,4O*X*E��� �+� �g��4�!�*E�6()4h�+2L�0*E#%U)� :�� �+�,G �64� 7�,$@*E#VU�� $+��23�7��4��,4O*�$+��:�5-! S7�DT�:��* (L��:����g����* #%U)� � �+� �g��4���� *E�L#-4�!�#%$C(0* � *E�L* ��� :�� �,��*E��(e**E���h�NA�*E�+2 :�4�!��,����*E()4�!��6������� � ���1#-� ��(CU"#-4�B !�#��3$,:�5V*`N�P ���D*E���h�NA�*E�+2 $+��:�5%! $'��(04�B���#%* �23�A!��[�)/J���7�+�E(0* #-��4L*E� ( 23��� ��!�#-� �+$+* �,!.!�#-()5-��B):��[23�A!��,5QP"���D� �+� ()4 ()5%* �,��4�(0*E#VU���23�+* ���"!*E� �+4j* �,��#-4�B *E����!�(e*'(��H�0G B�G � �+N ��()!M�������7�+5-5-�+! 2L�"!�� �EG

�����;��� �,5%#-23#-4�(0��NM#-4OU��+��* #-BO(0* #-��4>#%4j* � ���,5%# ()S�5%� /W�C(e*E:����,��/W����4�(0*E:��E()5 �+2L�)* #-��4>���,$,�)B�4�#Vd

*E#%��4 #%� !�#%� $,�):��E()B)#-4�B�G �=5-�C(0� 5%N)P 23��� �3<=��� � 4��+�,!�� * ��S7�;!���4��0G � 4��.#-� ��:�� 2L(CN�Sg� *E���!�#��L$+:�5%*`N #-4M� �,5%# ()S�5%NL�@?"*E� ()$+* #-4�B�P (0S���* �E()$@*E#-4�B�P ()4�!M4�����2;()5%#-]+#-4�B ��#%*E$'�M#-4A/W��� 2L(0*E#%��4^PA��()�d*E#%$,:�5-()� 5VN /W����*E�,5%�,������4�� Yj:�()5%#%*`N ���7�+�,$'�^GR_`4Z( ���C()5%#-��* #-$��+4OUA#%� ��4�2L�+4j*,P���4�� ������:�5%! Sg�1()S�5-�*E��$,��23��:�* �ZS�(0� �,5%#-4��M��#V*E$'�9()4�! �,4��,� B0N !�(e*'( /W����2 *E��� ��� �*;/W�@< :�* * �,�E(04�$,�+�;*E��� :�� �+�:�*�*E�,���[#%4Z(3!�# ()5%��B�:��0P ()4�! 4���� 2L()5%#-],��/W:���*E���,�[:A* *E�+�E()4�$,�,�6S�()���,!&��4M*E���+� � $+��23��:�*'(e*E#-�)4��,G�6� <R�+U)�,�,P�/W:��*E���+� $,��23��5%#-$C(e*E#-4�B / (0$+*E�)� � (0� �;* ��� :����,� �� #-4�$,5-#%4�(0* #-��4�*E�Z�7�+� ��()��� $,��4�$,�C(05*E���,#-� �+2L�)* #-��4��,P ��� �+U)�,4&*E�LS7�1:�4��+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5 #-4 *E���1/ ()$+� �)/b!�#�3$+:�5%* #-�,� !�:��h*E�;(3!��+*'(0$'�Ad23�,4O*�< #%* �M���,���7�+$+*�*E� ( � #%2 :�5 (e*E�,! *E()� � G�_ *�2;(CN;�+U��+4ZSg��<=�)��*E�O< ��#%5-�0P���4�$+�1�N"��*E�+2L�6()���()S�5%�D*E��� �+� �g��4�!L()������������# (0* �,5%N1*E��4��+BO(0* #%U����+2L�0*E#-�)4^P)*E� * �E()#%4 *E��� :����,� � * � = � A �+2L�0*E#-�)4�()5

< ���+4 *E���+N ()������(CUA#%4�B !�#�3$+:�5%* #-�,�D< #V*E� $,�)2L2 :�4�#-$,(0*E#%��4^Ga���� *E��� ()$@*E�+! !�(e*'(�P6$,��4���#-�*E�,4O*M< #%* � * ���>��S����,��U0(0* #-��4 *E��(0* 2;( ?�#%2 :�2 ��#%* $'� (04�!

(CU��+�E()B��3�,4��,� B0N�<=�+� �3#-4O*E:�#V*E#VU��,5VNZB)�A�"!>!�#-��$,� #%2L#%4�(0* ��� �6�)/=�+2L�0*E#-�)4^P^*E���+� � /W�C(0* :�� �+�1<R�,���()5%� ����*E(0*E#%��*E#%$C()5%5%Nh� ��� < 4;* �h!��1<R�,5%5QG a�:��*E���+� <R��� � 4��,�+!��R* �hSg� !���4�� *E�1S�:�#%5-! $,��4 ��!��,4�$,�#-4 *E���L�,23�)*E#%��4K��$,����#-4�BM*E�+$'��4�#-Yj:�� ()4�!K* ��� $,5-()� ��#����+�,G � 4��L<=(CN�* �&()$+$,��23��5-#%� � *E��#%�h#%�*E�K#-4OU��+��*E#%BO(0* �&()!�!�#%*E#%��4�()5�/W�,(0*E:����,�;* ��(0*;2;(CN S7�Z$,����� �,5-(0*E�+! < #%* � �+2L�)* #-��4 G _ *;<R��:�5%!()5%� �KSg�&Sg�,4�� ��$,#-()5 *E� �g�,�/W��� 2 ()!�!�#%*E#%��4�()5 $+5 ()��� #���$C(0* #-��4 �@?A�g�,� #%2L�+4O*E� ��4 �C()$'�9/W�C(e*E:����#-4�!��,�g�,4�!��,4O*E5VN ()4�!M$,��23��()��� �j:�2;(04 5%#-��* �,4��+����* :�!�#-�+��< #%*E� ���,$,�)B�4�#%* #-��4.���,��:�5%* �,G

� �

Page 69: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� � � ��� � ��� �

� � � � � � � � �� ��� � � ��� �

������/W��5%5-� < #-4�B1�\?�()2L��5-�[�):�*E��:A*�5-#%��*E� *E���[��� ���g�,�*E#%�,�=�0/ *E����� �"$ � ���,�+! $+��� ��:��,G�����#%�D#-�=()4�@?�()23��5%��/W���D*E�������7�+�,$'�Z<=(CU��+/W�)� 2 5 (0S7�+5-�,! (0���� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � ��� G

��� ���� ������� � ���� � ����� ����

� � ��!� �"�� � ��� ��� � � � � ��� � �#�!� � � � � ����$&%�� � �������� � ��� '$ �� � ��� � � � ��� ����� � �#�� � � � �!���� �)( �� � � ��� � � � � � ��$*� � �,+ � ����!� ����+ �� � ��� ��+� ���#+������ �#�� � � � ������� ( ��� � ��� � - ���.$ �� � ��� �� � � ��� ���'$ � � �� � �� � � � ���.$ �� � ��� � � � ���� ��� � � �����$/%�� 0�� �� � ��� �� �� � � ������� �1� � �� � �'$ ��� � �"�2���� � ��� ���1� �� � � �'$ ��� ���"�����3 � �� � � � �� �.$ �1�� � � ����� ��.$��1�# � � � � � �� � � �#��� �� ��$ ������� �� � � �!� ���� � �3�-��� � ��$ �1��

� !�465�$67 #98�*E#9:�4;:)/J*,<�4 � �=8�7>:834?7�* #@465A:)/J*,<#41$?:7B8�:�5�(-7B41(-5�/C:�5%5@: <A5 �

D *E()B�� *,<#41#%!�4,4O* #���$,(0*E#9:�4.5 ()S�4,57/C:7 ()4 :�* *B467 ()4�$64

� �

Page 70: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

D <=(CU4+/C:-7 2 ��5@4 � 59:A$,(0*E#9:�4 :)/J<=( U-4+/C:7�2

D 5>834,( � 4?7 � #-4�!�#VU"#-!�:�(05 :�5>467�*,<�(e*�<=(-5A7B4+$6:7�!�4,! 5B8�4C( � #%4�B :�* *B467E(04�$64

D B4+4�!�4?7 � ()!�:�5V* 2;(05@4 :7D/C4+2;(05@4 5>834,( � 4?7

D $,()5-5 #-! ��5 #-23#-5-(-7�*,: 5B465>5 #9:�4 S�:�*�#-4�$+5-:�!�4?5 5B8�4C( � 4676(-5�<�4+5-5

D 594,4�B)*B< � :�*�*,467 ()4�$?41594,4�B0*,<M#-4 5E(02 8�59465

D :7�#-B�#%4�()5 :7*,<�:)B7E(-8#<jN �M*,7E(04�5 $?7 #@8A*E#@:)4 :)/[*,<�4M:�* *B467 ()4�$64ZS34@/C:7B4 (-7�* #%/ ()$@*,53()4�! :�: U<.:7 !#5�<.467>4 7>4,2 : U4,!

D (-7*E#V/ ()$+* � 5>834+$,# (05g*E()B1/C:-7R!�4?5 #%B�4�(0* #-4�B�<A<�4+*B<�467R*,<�46:�* *B467E(04�$64?5�<�(-5R$64?7�*'(0#-4 (0$6:�:�5*E#%$4@U4,4O*B5�5 :�$ <&(-5 5 (0:�B<O*,4?7 :7�$6:�:�B<�#-4�B

D 7>468�4C(0* � #%4�!�#%$C(0*B465D<A<�4@*,<�4?76:�*�*,4?7E()4�$?4�#@5 ( 7B4?834,(0*

D 4+2 :)* #@:�4�()5 5�*E(0*,4 �6#%4�!�#-$,(0*,4?56<A<�4@*,<�4?7 :�* *B467 ()4�$64 #@5�4+2 :0*E#@:)4�()5 � /C7�:�5�*B7E(0*B4,!��A:-7[4�:�4"d4+2 :)* #@:�4�()5

D $?:�4O*'()#%4�5 :�: U ��#%4�!�#-$,(0*,4?5�#%/X*,<#41:A* *,4?7E()4�$641$6:�4O*'(0#-4�5 :�:A*�d :0/ d U:"$C(0S�:�5 (�7�N3<�:7�!�5

i��

Page 71: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

� ��� � ����� � ��� ���

9��;��� ������ &���� <������@:����� ���� 7���8#5� !�"� �#� 5�<�7���$34?7����&%'��() �&5+*B:���,- �4'�/. I 7B:5>:0(01!23$4%-5>45(%'�6*B:�78%9*:��,;(�4<*,45,<*:�9:�� :'=>%'����:?1�%'��,64@%A��(B=C7���5C*,7�%A*:�9:��B��� <!��7D%'�023,6:�7 8��6*B467�(��E%'�9:����GF�����IH E�J � C C:K FML0N<@JPO ARQ CTSAU�V �WH>�YX'Z�Z�X0�6[:'�"�4\6� 8#8��]X'Z�\_^a`6X'Z'b_Z0�

9GX<;c;� d%'�#5B4�%'��(e�f��c�� 5+, <�467>4675�;.C g,6:'��5P*���, 8�7>:'h4�9465d���8[:+,a%'� 457 :'*:�9:�� 4ji#8#7B465>5��9:����GFk���l JAm EjL =�n JPO H C�E @5JAL =�n F Apo = L]KDVqJ � F =�nqH @jo � Q0J n J-NAo [:'�"�Y^'Z0���?r�r�s0��8�8��ts6�ab9`+s�\�s6�

9u\G;; �� d%9*:������467v�_�f�!w��@5P, <�467v�6c��!x��6$34?75�0�� 5�8����� -4?75�+%'��(zy#�!{}|:'*B<��#.�� 4?5B84%-7�%A*,4v��1 5>464v +�����457 :'*:�9:���5 :-75~W%',<*,:7>55���#���a%�7�(�5v�'%'�6( <!��7D%'�;$34v�����-55�GF���fH E�J �?� JPO ApQ C�S-V�UW���9�eJGEj�$@jQ0J ?JALBV ? C C � Q = L]Kz���DJ A F�JAL � �4v��=p%-5C*a�YX'Z'Z�Z6�

9�b ;; �� d%A*������#4675�qc���x��6$34?75��x;��{��9457D%'�����]y#��{�|:'*,<����� 5�8����� �4675��%'��(��f�qw��@5P, <�467v�I.)� <�47B4v,6:����6��*:�9:�� :A=.4v7 :A*:�@:'���tF/����� C�E5�v�DJ_��F n�� OvJAm+L]K = A F�JAL @fJPO�@ ? C C � Q!� A"J'�D@ ? C C � Q A E = L @ n = �A F�JAL @ �4X'Z�Z�Z6�#8�8����?Z�s?`]��X0���

9G�<;�f�&x� ��@:+, <�4?75��.P �� 4v,v*���[4 5>:0,v�E%'���!��465C*a~�*B4a%', <������ 457 :'*��@:�� 7B45,?:�������*:�9:����#��*B<����02*,4?7:%',<*:��[-4�7 4v(��E%f%A��(��#�@7B4v�@4?5B5 4<i�8�7>465>5���[-4;*B:?1�5v�tF:HI� � HB%-5P*B467>5 � <#465��955�q d%'7}$#7���(6�4'�HI ��Y��6��4@�?r�r�r6�

9usG;¡�� .:5�, <���.Py¢7 :A*:�@:'��55~��A<4%A*��@5 83:5>5���$��@4;���e*,<�4 !56c£=C7:%A7 4<��:7P Y�tF¤����H E�J �?� JPO�ARQ CSjV�UW���9�¥JGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL¦V ? C C � Q = L]KD���DJ A F�JAL �4X'Z�Z�Z6�

9G^<;{�� d%'7 86$34v���"�>.���%9*-%'$4%�5B465 :'=�y¢7 :'*:�9:��4%'� 5�8�464v, <��tF����8H E:J �?� JPO�ApQ CdS-V�UW���9�eJGEj�$@jQ0J ?JALBV ? C C � Q = L]Kz���DJ A F�JAL �YX'Z�Z'Z6�

9u§G;c;� ���] d%'����(6�.45�����;. � <�4?7B4�(���(¨*,<#4%A���467©�-:!ª � <�4 7B:��94 :'=&,?:��_*,4ji0*����¨���!*B467>8�7B4<*:���6�457 :'*:�9:��)��� 5B8�464v, <��tF«���¬H E�J �?� JPO%ARQ C8S-V�UW���9�eJGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL­V ? C C � Q = L]KB���DJ A F�JAL �X'Z�Z�Z0�

9urG;c;�� �:-7���4v�����#55� .>� <#46:7>4v*:��,a%'�;%-8#8�7B:_%A, <�465e*,: 4v7 :A*:�@:'���tF ���®H E�J �?� JPO ARQ C¦SjV�UW����¥JGEj�$@jQ0J ? JALIV ? C C � Q = L]Kz���DJ A F�JAL �4X'Z�Z�Z6�

9��?ZG;c;�� �:?�#�@4�%'��()y#�&� :'�����E%�5C2C �:?�#�94'�¯.C g�6*B:�78%9*:��, 5C*-%A*��@5P*���,5%'��%'�4%'��1�5P�@5 :'=©*,<#4 5������4%'�%'��(;8�7>:5B:+(���, 5P�����#5 :A= 4v7 :'*��@:������;5B8�4645, <��tF)���IH E:J �?� JPO ARQ C�SAU�V �WH>���ar�r�s6�

9����;c;�+ �:?�#�94'��.�� 465P,67P��$������;*B<�4 457 :'*:�9:��4%'� 5C*-%A*B465�4ji�8�7B4?5B5B4v(¨��� 5B8�4645, <��tFB���¨H E�J �?� JPOJARQ CSjV�UW���9�¥JGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL¦V ? C C � Q = L]KD���DJ A F�JAL �4X'Z�Z�Z6�#8�8������v2:�?§6�

^0�

Page 72: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

9���X<;{�!��%-<6��$�|� ,- Y�! ��+�|� ����5B:'���+¡¢�_ <�7B4v�!$34?7�����. � ���a%-7P( :'=��T�A5P*���(��9465�2W�A<!1z%A��( <#:����GF����� LqJ�� n C:K�N C� = @C:KzV4o @BA7Cv� @ ��[-:��"�4��6��4�b����?r�r'b6��8�8��]X��A§�`6X's�s0�

9��?\G;w���� 4v����%-467C*a�2��� I :����5�����_%'��(@ ����%'��$�45����.�c 4v,6:��'�����v����� 4v7 :A*:�@:'�}���=5>834?45, <��GF¨���DH E�J �?�JPO!ARQ C�SAU�V �WH>���?r�r�s0�

9��ab ;�f�Yw��@5P, <�467v�z.P g���#:'*-%A*������@y¢7 :'*:�9:��4%'��¡W%'�6���4%'�4��%A*:%6�tF����£� C�E5�v�DJ_��F n � C ? JGEBA� ��� �� 45,A���?r�r�r0�

9����<; �������x�%'�64v��� 5q�&5�45��4<����%'��( �� I :�����=C7B:�������.�cA45,?:�������*:�@:'�),6:��0h4(�45�6,64 5�,6:-7����6�k%A��(��*B5��5>4���� 5B8�4645, < ���6(�467>5P*-%A��(����6� 5P1�5P*B457 55�GF ��� U¢JA� ? m ADC�EDV ? C C � Q = L]K � = L0NAm = N C �[:������?s6�4X'Z�Z�Z6�#8�8��4b_r�`+s_^0�

9��?sG; ����x 465B5v�¦. I¢��*:, <¦(�4<*,467P7D���4%A*��@:�� :A= 5B8�4645, < 5������4%'�955�GF �4?7���������� 4?7�7D%'�_1q~ 5�8�7P�����-4675�� 467P�E%'���q�?r�§�\0�

9���^<;¡��Ax 4v*B<�467P�����'*B:��}%A��( H��GHI,a d%'��(��9465B5v��. 50 JI I�x�� c�y#~�%A� 4<i+*B45��5P��$��94�5B8�464v, <@%'�4%'��1�5��@5%'��( 7B4v,6:����6��*:�9:��f*,:�:$�%-5B4v( :�� �©,5�����© Y�tFe����H E:J �?� JPO ARQ C�S9U�V �WH�� I <����E%'(#45�@8#<��E%6� I� ���?r�r�s0�

9��?§G;x��x :����a%-86=C4v�"�& g��w4��45�4v��� H��&� 4v��45,- �4'�>%'��(� � �)%A��$�45�"�¯.P� �_*,45�-7:%A*������ 4v7 :A*:�@:'�4%'�,5��4?5����_*B:�%k=C7:%A7 4<��:7P �=C:78(���%'�@:'����4e78%'��%'�457 45�_*5�tF ��� I 7B:+,'�':'=�*,<#4�X'Z�Z_X�� �_*:�"� �:��6=C4?7B45�6,64 :�� HI����*���7 :0(�%'�q� �_*B467P=p%A,6465v���T,<*,:�$�467�X'Z'Z_X0�

9��?rG;; ��A� ��(4%T%A��(�H����>%-5P��7}��7�%6�>.�� 465P�����������T%A��(f*,465C*:������%T,6:7>8���5�:'=�4v7 :'*��@:���%'� 5B8�4645, <��tF��� �TV l V ? E�FML0N�� C CA FML0N ���?r�r�§0�

9GX'ZG;�H��!���@4v�4%-5P*�%A��( ����w�� 5�45�6(���7 45�94675��.P �,6:���5C*:��,a%'�Y%'��%'��1�5��95�:'=35B8�45,v*B7:%'�Y%A��(z*B457 83:-7:%'�, <4%'���-465f��� 457 :'*:�9:��4%'� 5>834?45, <��GF ���­H E�J �?� JPO ARQ CDS-V�UW���9�eJGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL­V ? C C � Q = L]K���DJ A F�JAL �YXAZ�Z�Z6�

9GX0�;�}�Y���@7B5P, <��z.>� <�4%A�345,<*:��[-4*������4?75~>% 5C*:��(01 :��¨*,<#4�,6:'��5P*B7���,<*:�@:'� :'=&%'� 4v7 :'*��@:���%'����17B45%',v*���[4�*B:�1'�tF:HI� � HI%-5P*B467B5 � <�4?5��@5v�] d%'7}$�7P��(��-4'� HI �Y�����4z�?r�r�r0�

9GX�X<;�}�_¡���*�78%'���_��!x��97B5�, <!$�467P���6%A��( Hk� 5!��4?7P*,5v��. I 7B4v(���,<*:���6�%A�6*,:�7D%A*���, 5>834?45, < 7>45,6:'������2*:�9:�� 8�467C=C:7�7D%'��,?4���5P����� 8#7B:5>:0(���,�,v��465v�tF/��� H,=�? C�E ? E.CB@CvL ADC:K = A��#���}U ��� 5�45%A*�*��@4'�HB%a1eX'Z�Z'Z6�

9GX'\G;� g���� HI��*:, <�4v������ g� H 4v��45�?4655����W g� � �������E%'7 55� g� I�%-7�(#:��W�}��y 7���,- 5B:�����%'�6(��}��w4�02� ��7}�#7:%6�d.: �<4%'���-465���� 5P1+����%'$��@4#%A��(8$�:�����(�%-7P1 5C*,7B4v���'*B<�5�(��#4�*,:;�@7>7���*-%A*��@:����GF8���¨H E�J �?�JPO!ARQ C�SjV�UW���9�¥JGEj�$@jQ0J ? JALBV ? C C � Q = L]Kz���DJ A F�JAL �YXAZ�Z�Z6�

9GXAb ; ��� H :7P��1�%'78%�%'��( 5q���T�5%?��%6�«.Py¢7 :A*:�@:'� 7B4v,6:��'����*��@:��¯%A��( 5P1+�_*,<�4?5��@5 5P1�5C*,457 :��5B8�464v, <��tF����IH E�J �?� JPO ApQ CTS:�¢���¤S9U���U�V �4��6��4@�?r�r�r6�

9GX��<;�5q�����¡�� H :��v�5��,?:��4%',v,5�+%'��(�}�����x 4?7�7 465v�&.�cA:��94�:'=6���_*,:��4%9*:�@:'� 8�%A*�*B467��#5����,?:��_[4<10�����457 :'*:�9:��¦��� 5>834?45, <��GF ���)H E:J �?� JPO�SjL A n�� U¢JAL0NGE CB@ @@JPO H Q0JAL CA F � V � F CvL � CB@ ���ar�r�r6� 8�8��X'Z�Z6�j`6X'Z�Z'b6�

^�X

Page 73: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

9GX'sG;�5q�W���¡�� H :��5�v��,?:��4%',v,5��%'��(��}�W��Wx 467P7 4?55� .Py&i�8�7>465B5P�@:�� :'= 4v7 :A*:�@:'�k%A��()%A*P*:��*:��(�4*,<�7>:����< *,4v7 8�:7:%A��5B8�4645, <)[A%-7P�E%A*��@:��#55�GF ��� H E�J �?� JPO ApQ C@S9U�V ��H>��[-:��"��X0�&X'Z�Z�Z6� 8�8��\_^'\�`+\_^'§6�

9GX�^<;�5q�����¡�� H :��v�5��,?:��4%',v,5���&. 5!*:��(61 :'=����!*B:��4%A*��@:�� 8�%A*�*B467��#5���� 5>834?45, <=4ji�8�7B4?5B5������ 4v7 :'*��@:��:7@%A*P*:��*���(�4A~ 8�7>:0(6��,v*��@:�� %'��( 834?7�,?4686*��@:����GF S H�� ��L4L4m =�n>H E:J-NGE.CB@ @ � C ? JGEBA ��� I��}�y¢����(�<#:�[-45���W�?r'r�§6�

9GX'§G;�5q�����¡��&H :��5�v��,6:'�4%',5,v�#%'��( �}�����x 467P7 4?55� .Py¢7 :'*��@:��)%'��( %A*�*���*���(�4�,6:'�![-4v1-45(¤���5B8�464v, <�$!1z7 4a%'�#5�:'=�8#7B:5>:0(61'�tF _L]K��eJGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL�� A A F ARm6K C�� H C�E @5JAL =�n F Apo = L]K}���DJ'�A F�JAL @ FML�� @C�E<�p�#K =�? A7C:K@S-L A7C�E = � A F�JAL � 5�:��_*B<�:'=C45��� � 467P78%A�!1'�YX'Z�Z0���

9GX'rG;�5q�4¡�� �g[+�E%9*�*a� �@��¡ 4<[:?��� H�� HB%A,5y�%', <�4?7����]%'��(e�f������<6���;..H :+(�45������� <!1�8�467�%-7P*���,5�+2�E%A*B4.5>834?45, <@(���7P������<+�678%'�+2 ,6:'7 8��0*,467 467>7B:7 7B4?5B:����6*:�9:����GF�H E�J �?� JPO ARQ CdSAU�V �WH>�?[:�����X0��?r�r�s0�#8�8��Y§'Z6�<`0§�ZAb��

9u\�ZG;�5q�_¡�� �g[+�E%A*P*a� H�� HB%',5y�%', <#467�����%'��( �f�_¡�4v[-:����©. I 7B45(6��,v*������ <_1�8�467:%�7P*:��,5����%A*,4 5>834?45, <(���7P����� <!��78%A�02 ,?:�7 86�6*,4?7 4?7B7>:7 7B465>:����0*:�@:'���tF V ? C C � Q U¢JA�f�fm+L ��[:�����XAb����?r�r�§6� 8�8���<`6X'\0�

9u\6�;; ��$I�%-465P, <� -4�%'��( ���?w�� 5�45��(���7 4v�@4?75��. I 7B:-5B:+(���,&, <�%-7:%',<*,4?7��@5C*:��,65 :'=�457 :'*:�9:��4%'�25B8�464v, <�~7 45%-5��#7B457 45�_*B5 :'=�=R����(�%'7 4v�_*-%'��=C7B45�!��4v��,v1¤7 :?[4v7 4v�_*,55�GF ��� H E�J �?� JPO�ApQ CeSjV�UW����¥JGEj�$@jQ0J ? JALIV ? C C � Q = L]Kz���DJ A F�JAL �4X'Z�Z�Z6�

9u\_X<;� g� I 4?7B4v�@7:%z%'��(¥ g����%A*,5>:����;. 5�:�7 4T%',6:��#5P*:��,�, <4%-7�%',v*B467��95P*���,65A:'= 457 :'*��@:����GF¦���IH E�J �?�JPO!ARQ C�SAU�V �WH>� 5+1+(���4<1��Y g��5C*,7�%'����%6���?r'r�§6�

9u\�\G;�}� I 4v*B7���5><�������.Py¢7 :A*:�@:'�8��� 5B8�4645, <�~.7>45,6:'������*��@:��8%'��(¨%-8#8�����,a%A*��@:��@*,:f,5%'���],64v�!*B467>55�GF������H E�J � C C:K FML0N<@@JPO ApQ CIU¢JAL?O�C�E.CvL � CzJAL��JEBA F�� � F =�n � Cvm E =�n �!CA �>JGEj�$@ FML �>L0NGFML C C�E�FML0N ��?r�r�r0�

9u\'b ;�}� I 4v*B7���5><������¦.Py¢7 :'*:�9:�� 7B4v,6:��'����*��@:��I%'�45�_*B5���� 7B45%'���.:7P��(��GF��;���kH,=�? C�E @dO E�JA� ARQ C������S� =�nMn V4o9� ? J<@�FMm0� JAL¨VqJ � F =�nMn o�S-L A7C nMn F�N CvL A��>N CvL A @ �� m0� = L FML ApQ C � J?J ?]��XAZ�Z�Z6�

9u\_�<;c;�GI¢��,a%�7�(z%'��(z������945������.� �:�7 86�6*,4?7B5&*,<�%A* 7B4v,6:����6���64#%A��( 7B465>83:'��(f*,:���5B4?7�457 :'*:�9:���~*,<�4?:7B4<*:��,a%'��%A��( 8#7:%',<*:��,5%'����7 8�����,5%A*:�9:���55�GF0H¥� � H 45(6�E%@¡W%'$;� 4v, <BcA468�:7P*g�'\�§0�

9u\�sG;c;� I���,a%-7P(��;.P �� 4v,v*:��[4�,6:'7 8��0*:���6���tFk d%'7�$�7���(��4'� HI �~ HI� � I'7>465>55�W�?r�r_^+�9u\_^<;c;�"I¢��,5%-7�(�� . �������(������ x� T¡�~>,6:�7 8��6*B467B5z*,<4%9* 5B4v��5B4A�A7B45,?:��������64A��%A��(&7B4?5B8�:���(¬*B:

<!��78%A� 4v7 :A*:�@:'���tF����� m+� = L � F @�F�JAL = L]K@� n C � A E�JAL F � Sj� = NGFML0N � S �4_%'�!�4%-7C1¥X'Z�Z6���9u\�§G;x� I¢�@7P -4?7�%'�6( �f��¡ :+(�4?7B467v��.�G� 5�%'��(I.C* �.:�*:� 2 ,- �4v*,5��~ <�:?�)*B:�*:%'�� g*B:T%#(�4a%9=��#���5%-7�(��GF}���

H E:J �?� JPO�ARQ C��gU�V0���eJGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL� !F =�n J-NAm C = L]K H E�J<@5JaK'o � 5�4686*5�4�?r�r�r6�!8#8��4�?§6�<`Y�?§�s6�9u\�rG;�� I :'����=C7>:�����%'��( 5q� 5�4v��4v��� . ��%'��%9i+1!23���-~�%-5z%'� %-7�, <���*,4v,v*:�#7B4�=C:7 5B8�:� �45�¬(6�E%'�9:�����4

4v[A%'���4%A*:�9:����GF ��� H E�J �?� JPO�ApQ C _L]K�S-L A n�� U¢JAL?O�C�E.CvL � CBJAL � � �gU �¢ d*,<�4v��55� � 7B464v,64A�X'Z�Z�Z0�

^'\

Page 74: b`m|b S wGa p rKt`tMtWu - MIT · 6 ² p /4 gdot vgh]q k @zl k dgyzn u@ beksbik d dg?shwbe@zhrts[gy prl!li@ch [ pwbi@zh]tsprt fsqido[gh]\]t @ be@ch]tsd =nadgqi@z?adotibiljprt fsvgh]q"@cf

9�b_ZG; ��� 5]� I :����v����%'�6(� ���)%A��$�45�"��.Cy�7 :'*��@:��02 5B4v��5���*:��[-4 <!��7D%'�023,6:�7 8��6*B467>���_*,4?7P=p%',?4655�GFB���H E:J �?� JPO ApQ C�S-V�UW���9�eJGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL¦V ? C C � Q = L]Kz���DJ A F�JAL � �4v��=p%-5C*�X'Z�Z�Z6�

9�b��; �f���T���! g�!c 4<1+��:���(#55�!%'��(Dc�� I¢��,a%�7�(���.>� <�4�d%a14?5.8�:����!*&78%', <6����4d=C:7�,6:�7 8��6*B467C23��5B4?7=C7���5C*,7�%A*:�9:���(�4v*B45,<*:�@:'�e[+�E% 8�7>465>5���7>47 :���5>4'�GFk���¦H �qS �]X'Z'Z6���

9�b!X<;6I��¢cA:_%', <�� .>� 45, <������!��465@=C:7f*,<�4;8�<#:���4v*���,¨(�4?5�,67P�@86*��@:�� :'= 457 :'*��@:��4%A��5B8�464v, <��GF ���H E:J �?� JPO ApQ C�S-V�UW���9�eJGEj�$@jQ0J ? JAL¦V ? C C � Q = L]Kz���DJ A F�JAL �YX'Z�Z'Z6�

9�b_\G;�f��c�� 50, <#467B4?75�gc;� d%'��5>4'�gx���f� �)%'����$�:'*�*5�©%'��( ��� � :'��(�$�45,- Y� . � :0,5%'�g,v��465����y¢7 :'*��@:���y¢��,?:0(������¥%'��()� 4v,6:+(����6���tF ��� �¦J A F�� = A F�JAL = L]K¥�>�DJ A F�JAL �W[:������?�0�>�ar�r6���8�8�����XA\�`]�ab_§0�

9�b�b ;�H�� 50, <�7a|:�(�4?75� �}�4 ���$�467����4'�Y%'��(�H��] d%A*B<��E%�7�(��;.: d%A�¨�.4 <�4a%-7A5P7D���@4?ªaF9�b!�<;�5q� 5�45�#4v���dy#��x���7��94v1���c;��¡W%'���© g� I�%-:��)I�� 50, <�7z��(��©%A��( �������#4'� . �;%A�E%9i+1_2 �P�-~�%

7B4<=C467B4v��,64�%-7�, <���*,4v,v*:�#7B4D=C:-7,?:��_[467>5:%A*��@:���%'�.5C1�5P*,4v7 (#4v[4v�@:867 4v�!*5�tF ��� H E�J �?� JPO ARQ CSAU�V �WH>� 5+1+(��#4v1��] g�#5P*,7�%'����%6���ar�r�§6�

9�b_sG; g� 5�<��#45��(#467�7D%'���}.>� <�4;����7D��*,5 :'= 5B8�464v, < 7B4v,6:����6��*:�9:����GF)��� U¢JA�f�fm+L F � = A F�JAL @JPO ARQ C�}U�� � 5�4686*5�]X'Z�Z�Z0�6[:�����b_\6�4�#:��4r6� 8�8��Ys�\�`0s_�+�

9�b!^<;;y#� 5�<�7���$34?7����¢y#� ��%'(�4'��%'��(KI�� I 7P��,64A� .�x���7D%'�02 7D%', <�����4 8�7>:�$��9457 5>:���[+���6�¦��5������5B8�:� -4v���E%A�����4%'�-4 5C1�5P*,4v7 5�756¡85�:~+w]%A,v*,:-7B5>%A� 4v,v*������ 834?7P=C:7P78%A��,64�%'��(D��5B4?7�5:%9*:�@5C=p%',<2*:�9:����GF®H E�J �?� JPO�ApQ C #� �#H � V ? C C � Q = L]K � = Apm E =�n�� = L0NAm = N Ck�eJGEj�$@jQ0J ?]�&�?r�r_X+� 8�8��b_r�`6�9b��

9�b_§G;�H�� ��%'�� �467v�4��� g$�467P(�464v���]�� �:���%'��(��0y#� �7:%9*�*a���� �;%�7:%A=C:��9:��0¡¢��x��@7>5�, <�7D%'���0 ��Y¡�4'�5q��¡�464'��5q��{g%�7:%a1_%'��%'���;�f� I�%-8�����45������g��I 45���@:�7e���� I :�����=C7>:����"�� ���I :A*-%'7z�E%'�#:55�I�� I 7:%A$�<!���� �Wc��6(�����,- _1'� �f�856%'��(#467B5v� 5]�85�45��4<�����}� 5+*:%'����%-7�(���%'��( 5]� � <���*P*-%' �4675�.��# Tc�I� � �:�7z7}���6��,a%9*,:7(��E%'�9:��I*B7:%a[4v� 8��E%'�6������� 5P1�5P*B457 55~ � <�4e�����4eXAZ�Z�ZB(4%A*:%,6:����@4v,v*:�9:����GF����BH E:J �?� � � � � V H �¢�TU g�4 T%A��$�:7����6� 45��7D%-7P ]� 5�4686*5��XAZ�Z6����8#8����?\_^0�j`�?\_^Ab6�

9�b_rG;� g� �)%A����%'��(�5q�<5�45�#4v���&.�cA:�$��#5P* 8���*�, <;*B7:%',- !�����©=C:7�8�7B:-5B:+(���,�7 :0(#45�������©����*B45�@4?8�<�:��#45B8�464v, <��tF����IH,=�? C�E ? E CB@CvL ADC:K = A ApQ C�S:�¢���¤S9UW��V4V H>��� 5C*-%'�!$������ ���#7� -4<1��]�����4�X'Z�Z'Z6�

9G�'ZG;�5q� I�� � <���*,465P��(�4A��. 5+��7}����%A*,4v( 457 :'*��@:���5v~�%'�¨%',?:���5C*:��,�5P*:�6(61 :'=W[:'��,64�%A��( 834?7P*���7�$4%�2*:�9:���7 45%-5��#7B465v�tFk���BH E�J �?� JPO ApQ C�S9U�V �WH����?r�r�§6�#8�8��Ys�r�r?`6^'Z�\6�

9G�0�;�}������4'�W�� ���E%�5B55�W�}��� :�:+(�����4A� H�� I'<6�������@8�5g%'��(:5q� 5�45��4<����.)� <�4� ���������� 5>834?45, <7B4v,6:����6��*:�9:�� 5P1�5P*B457e~ 8�<�:���:'�@:�����,a%'��7 :+(�45�������6� %'��(£�94<i0��,5%'�;%',5,?465B5v�tF ��� H E�J �?� JPOSAUW�TV4V H>���?r�r�Z0�#8�8��4b�r�`6��X0�

9G��X<;�}�����#4@%'��( �� ���E%-5>55�¦.� �:��_[467>5:%A*��@:���%'�����_*,4?7P=p%',?465v~�%'(6[A%'��,?465;%'��(�, <4%'���@4v���465v�tF����H E:J �?� JPO ApQ C�S:���¢� �6[-:��"�4§'§6����:��Y§0�� g���6�]X'Z�Z�Z6�#8�8������?s's�`]���?§'Z6�

^Ab