BẠCH THỊ HƯƠNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUẬT KINH DOANH QUỐC TẾ (1)
Transcript of BẠCH THỊ HƯƠNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUẬT KINH DOANH QUỐC TẾ (1)
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
1/81
TRNG I HC NGOI THNG
KHOA QUN TRKINH DOANH
---------***---------
KHA LUN TT NGHIP
Chuyn ngnh: Lut kinh doanh quc t
HY HP NG TRONG TRNG HP HNG HAKHNG PH HP THEO CNG C VIN
NM 1980 VHP NG MUA BN HNG HA
QUC T
Hv tn sinh vin: Bch ThHng Giang
M sinh vin: 0852020007
Lp: Anh 2 Khi 1 QT
Kha: 47
Ngi hng dn khoa hc: TS. Nguyn Minh Hng
H Ni, thng 05 nm2012
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
2/81
MC LC
LI NI U ....................................................................................................... i
CHNG 1: TNG QUAN V HP NG MUA BN HNG HAQUC T V CH TI HY HP NG TRONG TRNG HP
HNG HA KHNG PH HP THEO CNG C VIN NM 1980 V
HP NG MUA BN HNG HA QUC T............................................ 1
1.1. Khi qut chung v Cng c Vin nm 1980 v hp ng mua bn
hng ho quc t................................................................................................... 1
1.1.1. Gii thiu Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng ho
quc t(CISG) ....................................................................................................... 1
1.1.2. Hp ng mua bn hng ho quc ttheo CISG................................ 4
1.2. Khi qut chung vchti huhp ng trong hp ng mua bn hng
ha quc t ............................................................................................................ 5
1.2.1. iu kin p dng ch ti hu hp ng trong hp ng mua bn
hng ha quc t..................................................................................................... 5
1.2.2. Hu quphp l ca vic huhp ng ........................................... 11
1.3. Khi qut chung vtnh ph hp vi hp ng ca hng ho............... 12
1.3.1. Tnh ph hp ca hng ho ............................................................... 12
1.3.2. Trch nhim ca ngi bn vvic hng ho khng ph hp vi hp
ng 16
1.3.3. Quyn khi phc tnh ph hp ca hng ha vi hp ng ca ngi
bn trc hn giao hng ....................................................................................... 19
1.3.4. Kim tra cht lng hng ho v khiu ni trong trng hp hngho khng ph hp vi hp ng ........................................................................ 19
CHNG 2: HY HP NG TRONG TRNG HP HNG HA
KHNG PH HP THEO CNG C VIN NM 1980 VHP NG
MUA BN HNG HA QUC T ................................................................ 21
2.1. Cc trng hp dn n vic p dng chti huhp ng do hng ho
khng ph hp theo Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng
ho quc t .......................................................................................................... 21
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
3/81
2.1.1. Cc trng hp hng ho khng ph hp cu thnh vi phm cbn. .. 21
2.1.2. Trng hp khng th khi phc tnh ph hp ca hng ha trong
khong thi gian m ngi mua gia hn thm hoc thi hn m ngi bn
yu cu ngi mua gia hn thm. ........................................................................ 312.2. Mt s gii hn v quyn hu hp ng ca ngi mua do hng ho
khng ph hp vi hp ng ............................................................................ 34
2.2.1. Trng hp ngi mua khng khiu ni hoc khng kp thi khiu
ni vskhng ph hp ca hng ha. ............................................................... 34
2.2.2. Trng hp ngi mua mt quyn huhp ng do khng thng bo
kp thi. ................................................................................................................ 40
2.2.3. Khnng ngi bn gim gi hng hoc sa cha hng ho hoc giao
hng thay th ........................................................................................................ 42
CHNG 3: GII PHP NHM HN CHVIC HY HP NG DO
HNG HA KHNG PH HP THEO CNG C VIN NM 1980 V
HP NG MUA BN HNG HA QUC T V BI HC KINH
NGHIM I VI VIT NAM ...................................................................... 46
3.1. nh gi cc quy nh v thc tin huhp ng do hng ho khng
ph hp theo Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng ho quc
t...........................................................................................................................46
3.1.1. nh gi cc quy nh lin quan n hu hp ng do hng ho
khng ph hp theo CISG.................................................................................... 46
3.1.2. nh gi thc tin huhp ng do hng ho khng ph hp theo
CISG..................................................................................................................... 48
3.2. Gii php nhm hn ch vic hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ngdn n huhp ng theo CISG .................................................................... 51
3.2.1. Cc bn tha thun cthvtnh ph hp ca hng ho v khnng
p dng chti huhp ng .............................................................................. 51
3.2.2. Sdng hp l cc gii hn vhuhp ng do hng ho khng ph
hp vi hp ng theo CISG ............................................................................... 52
3.2.3. To iu kin thit lp giao dch mi gia cc bn trn c s hp
ng c bhu ................................................................................................. 54
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
4/81
3.2.4. Kt hp p dng cc thi quen, tp qun thng mi, cc quy phm
tphp quc ttrong cc giao dch mua bn hng ho quc t .......................... 54
3.2.5. Bsung cc quy nh mi vcc vn php l mi pht sinh ...... 56
3.3. Bi hc kinh nghim i vi Vit Nam ..................................................... 563.3.1. Bi hc kinh nghim cho cc doanh nghip Vit Nam..................... 57
3.3.2. Kin nghhon thin thm cc quy nh php lut ca Vit Nam v
vn hy hp ng trong trng hp hng ha khng ph hp dn n hy hp
ng ..................................................................................................................... 61
KT LUN ......................................................................................................... 65
DANH MC TI LIU THAM KHO.......................................................... 67
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
5/81
1
DANH MC VIT TT
Tvit tt Ting Anh Ting Vit
CISG, Cng cVin nm 1980,
Cng c
Convention on Contracts for theInternational Sale of Goods
Cng c Vin nm 1980v hp ng mua bn
hng ha quc t
UCC Uniform Commercial Code Blut thng mi thng
nht Hoa K
PECL Principles of European on
contract law
B nguyn tc Chu u
vhp ng
UNCITRAL United Nations Commission on
International Trade Law
y ban ca Lin Hp
Quc vLut thng mi
quc t
ICC International Chamber of
Commerce
Phng thng mi quc t
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
6/81
i
LI NI U
1. Tnh cp thit ca tiSau 25 nm mca thtrng v 5 nm gia nhp tchc Thng mi th
gii, hot ng kinh t i ngoi ca Vit Nam trong nng ct l ngoithng tin b r rt. Th trng c rng m ti hn 150 nn kinh t thnh
vin. Cc hp ng xut nhp khu gia cc thng nhn Vit Nam v cc
thng nhn nc ngoi cng nhiu hn vs lng v ln hn vgi trhp
ng. c bit, lnh vc xut nhp khu hng ho c bc tng trng vt
bc v tr thnh mt trong nhng ngnh ch cht ca cc hot ng ngoi
thng ni chung.
Vi tnh hnh mua bn hng ho quc tdin ra nhn nhp nhvy, tnh
cht v quy m ca cc giao dch ny ngy cng a dng v phc tp. Do vy,
khi m khong cch kinh t, k thut v vn ho vn cha c xo b hon
ton, rt nhiu cc thng nhn Vit Nam gp phi cc trng hp vi phm dn
n huhp ng gy thit hi ln v quan trng nht l khin cho mc ch khi
giao kt hp ng lc ban u khng c thc hin. Mt trong nhng nguyn
nhn phbin dn n huhp ng chnh l do hng ho khng ph hp vihp ng.
Vy thno l hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ng? Trng hp no
hng ho khng ph hp vi ng c thdn n huhp ng? Php lut hp
ng ca Vit Nam vn cha c nhng quy nh c th r rng v trng hp
ny. Tuy nhin, nhng ngun lut khc nhBlut thng mi thng nht Hoa
K, chth44/99/EC ca Nghvin chu u1, Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp
ng mua bn hng ho quc tu c nhng quy nh lin quan, c bit lCng c Vin nm 1980 - ngun lut iu chnh phn ln cc hp ng mua
bn hng ho quc ttrn thgii. Chnh v vy, ngi vit chn Cng c
Vin nm 1980 nhm lm r thm vn trn v chn ti: Huhp ng
trong trng hp hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ng theo Cng c Vin
1iu 2, chth44/99/EC vmua bn hng ho v cc bin php m bo. Xem ti
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:31999L0044:EN:NOT.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
7/81
ii
nm 1980 v hp ng mua bn hng ho quc t lm ti kho lun tt
nghip ca mnh.
2. Mc ch nghin cuBng vic chn ti Huhp ng trong trng hp hng ho khng
ph hp theo Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng ho quc
t lm ti kho lun tt nghip, ngi vit s lm r trng hp hu hp
ng do hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ng trong khun khcc giao dch p
dng Cng c Vin 1980 trn mt l lun v thc tin. T ngi vit a ra
nhng gii php nhm hn ch trng hp ny v bi hc kinh nghim i vi
cc doanh nghip Vit Nam khi tham gia quan hmua bn hng ho quc t.
3. i tng v phm vi nghin cu: i tng nghin cu:
i tng nghin cu ca kho lun tt nghip ny l cc quy nh ca
Cng c Vin 1980 vhuhp ng trong trng hp hng ho khng ph hp
vi hp ng v cc tranh chp c th trong thc tin c lin quan n vn
ny.
Phm vi nghin cu:Phm vi nghin cu ca kho lun l cc trng hp hu hp ng do
hng ho khng ph hp ca cc giao dch mua bn hng ho quc t trong
khun khCng c Vin 1980.
Vmt thi gian: Cc tranh chp din ra tkhi Cng c Vin nm 1980
vhp ng mua bn hng ha quc tc hiu lc cho n nay.
V mt ni dung: Hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ng gm c hai
dng: Khng ph hp vmt thc t (sai lch so vi hp ng) v khng phhp vmt php l (sai lch so vi cc chng tngoi hp ng). Trong kho
lun tt nghip ny xin php chphn tch cc trng hp hng ho khng ph
hp vmt thc t.
4. Phng php nghin cu:Kho lun sdng phng php nghin cu tng hp, phn tch, so snh
nh gi cc thng tin sliu thu thp c c lin quan n trng hp hu
hp ng do hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ng theo Cng c Vin 1980.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
8/81
iii
Ngoi ra phng php cng sdng mt sphng php nghin cu lut hc
nhphng php so snh lut hc, phng php bnh lun n l.
5. Kt cu ca ti:Ngoi li ni u, kt lun v danh mc tham kho, ni dung kho lun
c chia lm 3 chng:
- Chng 1: Tng quan vHp ng mua bn hng ho quc tv Chti
hu hp ng trong trng hp hng ho khng ph hp theo cng c Vin
nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn quc t.
- Chng 2: Huhp ng trong trng hp hng ho khng ph hp theo
Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn quc t.
- Chng 3: Gii php nhm hn chvic huhp ng do hng ho khng
ph hp theo Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn quc tv bi hc
kinh nghim i vi cc doanh nghip Vit Nam.
Em xin gi li cm n chn thnh n TS. Nguyn Minh Hng ngi
trc tip hng dn, chbo v tn tnh gip em trong sut qu trnh lm kha
lun. Em cng by tsbit n i vi tp thging vin trng i hc Ngoi
thng tn tnh dy dv trang bcho em nhng kin thc qu bu trong thi
gian hc tp v nghin cu ti trng.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
9/81
1
CHNG 1: TNG QUAN VHP NG MUA BN HNG HA
QUC TV CHTI HY HP NG TRONG TRNG HP
HNG HA KHNG PH HP THEO CNG C VIN NM
1980 VHP NG MUA BN HNG HA QUC T1.1. Khi qut chung v Cng c Vin nm 1980 v hp ng mua bn
hng ho quc t
1.1.1. Gii thiu Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng
ho quc t(CISG)
Cng c Vin 1980 ca Lin Hp Quc vhp ng mua bn hng
ha quc t(vit tt theo ting Anh l CISG - Convention on Contracts for the
International Sale of Goods) c son tho bi y ban ca Lin Hp Quc v
Lut thng mi quc t(UNCITRAL) l kt quca mt nlc hng ti vic
thng nht ngun lut p dng cho hp ng mua bn hng ho quc t.
c c thng qua ti Vin (o) ngy 11 thng 04 nm 1980 ti Hi
nghca y ban ca Lin hp quc vLut thng mi quc t, sau hn 30 nm
CISG tr thnh Cng c c p dng rng ri nht trong scc iu c
quc ta phng vmua bn hng ha quc t. Cho n hin nay, c tnhCng c Vin nm 1980 iu chnh hn ba phn t thng mi hng ha
trn ton thgii. Tnh n thi im thng 2 nm 2012, c gn 80 quc gia
tham gia Cng c.2
Cng c Vin 1980 ca Lin Hp Quc vhp ng mua bn hng ha
quc tbao gm cc ni dung chnh sau:
Phn 1: Phm vi p dng v cc quy nh chung (iu 1 13)
Phn ny bao gm cc quy nh vnhng trng hp Cng c c p
dng (iu 1 6) cng nhnhng quy nh din gii vtuyn b, xsv vic
p dng tp qun thng mi ca cc bn. ng thi cng nu ra nhng vn
lin quan hnh thc hp ng.
Phn 2: Hnh thnh hp ng (trnh t, thtc k kt hp ng) (iu 14-
24)
2Tnh n ngy 01/01/2012 theo website ca Uncitral, xem ti http://www.uncitral.org/
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
10/81
2
Trong phn ny, Cng c Vin cp n cc vn php l t ra
trong qu trnh giao kt hp ng. CISG nh ngha cho hng, phn bit cho
hng vi li mi cho hng v chra cc c im ca mt cho hng. ng thi
Cng c cng quy nh vhiu lc ca cho hng, thu hi v hy bcho hng.Song song vi cho hng, Cng c cng c quy nh tng i chi tit v r
rng vchp nhn cho hng v cc kha cnh php l lin quan bao gm: ni
dung chp nhn cho hng; hiu lc ca chp nhn v iu kin cu thnh hp
ng cng vi cho hng; thi hn chp nhn v chp nhn mun, ko di thi
hn chp nhn; thu hi chp nhn; thi im hp ng c hiu lc.
Phn 3: Mua bn hng ha (iu 25 - 88)
Phn 3 bao gm cc vn php l lin quan n thc hin hp ng mua
bn hng ha quc tv c xem l phn chnh ca Cng c Vin nm 1980.
Phn Mua bn hng ha bao gm cc chng:
Chng I: Nhng quy nh chung
Chng II: Ngha vca ngi bn
Chng III: Ngha vca ngi mua
Chng IV: Chuyn ri ro
Chng V: Cc iu khon chung v ngha v ca ngi bn v ngi
mua.
Chng I bao gm nhng quy nh chung vcc phm tr khc nhau nh
cch xc nh vi phm cbn, thng bo hy hp ng, vin dn thng tin
Cc phm tr ny c tc dng trong vic to csthc hin hay lm r hn mt
sni dung cc chng sau.
Trng tm ca phn 3 nm cc quy nh vngha vca ngi bn vngi mua trong chng II v chng III. Vngha vca ngi bn, Cng c
quy nh rt r ngha vgiao hng v chuyn giao chng t, c bit l ngha v
m bo tnh ph hp ca hng ha c giao (vmt thc tcng nhvmt
php l). Song song vi ngi bn, ngi mua cng phi m bo thc hin
nhng ngha vchnh ca mnh, bao gm thanh ton v nhn hng.
Cng c Vin khng c chng ring dnh cho vi phm hp ng v cc
ch ti do vi phm hp ng. Nhng ni dung ny cng c cp trong cc
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
11/81
3
chng II, III v V. Theo , nhng ch ti khi xy ra vi phm hp ng bao
gm buc thc hin ng hp ng, i bi thng thit hi, hy hp ng.
ng thi, CISG cng quy nh thm nhng bin php khc nhgim gi hng,
gia hn thi hn thc hin ngha v. Nhng bin php ny khng mang tnh chti, trng pht m li to iu kin cho cc bn, c bit l bn vi phm tip tc
hon thnh cc ngha v, thc hin hp ng.
Cng c Vin cng tch ring vn chuyn ri ro thnh chng IV ca
phn III. Theo , ty thuc vo tng trng hp v giai on cth, ri ro c
quy nh thuc vbn no. y l csxc nh phm trch nhim v ngha
vca cc bn c bit trong trng hp c xy ra vi phm hp ng.
Chng V ca Phn 3 quy nh vvn tm ngng thc hin ngha v
hp ng, vi phm trc hp ng, vic p dng cc bin php php l trong
trng hp giao hng tng phn, hy hp ng khi cha n thi hn thc hin
ngha v. c bit chng V cn nhng quy nh cthvchti bi thng
thit hi mt trong nhng bin php c p dng ph bin nht trong cc
tranh chp thuc khun khCISG. Ngoi ra, cc vn vcn cmin trch,
hu qudo hy hp ng, bo qun hng ha khi xy ra vi phm cng c
cp n.
Phn 4: Cc quy nh cui cng (iu 89 - 101)
Phn ny bao gm cc vn mang tnh thtc nhthi im Cng c
c hiu lc, hiu lc ca Cng c so vi hiu lc ca cc ngun lut khc, th
tc gia nhp hay tbCng c i vi cc quc gia v cc vn khc.
Nhvy, sau hn 20 nm c hiu lc, cng vi cc quy nh c nh
gi l hin i, mm do v linh hot, Cng c Vin nm 1980 v hp ngmua bn hng ha quc tc nh gi l mt trong nhng cng c thng
nht vlut tthnh cng nht. c Lin Hp Quc bo trson tho v thc
thi, CISG to ra c s tin cy tpha cc quc gia (trong qu trnh son
tho) m cn nhn c stin tng tng o doanh nghip (trong qu trnh
thc thi). S thnh cng ca Cng c Vin 1980 c khng nh trong thc
tin vi hn 2500 v tranh chp c Ta n v trng ti cc nc/quc t
gii quyt c lin quan n vic p dng v din gii Cng c Vin 1980 c
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
12/81
4
bo co. Khng chcc nc thnh vin m cc quc gia cha phi l thnh vin
vn p dng Cng c, hoc do cc bn trong hp ng la chn Cng c Vin
1980 nhl lut p dng cho hp ng, hoc do cc ta n, trng ti dn chiu
n gii quyt tranh chp. Nhiu doanh nghip ti cc quc gia cha phi lthnh vin CISG tnguyn p dng CISG cho cc giao dch thng mi quc
tca mnh, bi v hthy c nhng u vit ca CISG so vi lut quc gia.
1.1.2. Hp ng mua bn hng ho quc ttheo CISG
Cng c Vin nm 1980 vHp ng mua bn hng ha quc tkhng
c iu khon no nu ra nh ngha php l cthcho hp ng mua bn hng
ha quc t. Tuy nhin, thng qua iu 31 v 53 ca Cng c, ta c thkt lun
mt hp ng mua bn hng ha c hnh thnh trong trng hp ngi bn
c quy nh thc hin ngha vgiao hng (v chng t) v ngi mua c
quy nh thc hin ngha v thanh ton. Cng c cng a ra tiu ch xc
nh xem loi hng ha nhthno thuc phm vi iu chnh ca Cng c (t
iu 2 n iu 6 Cng c).
Ngoi ra, xc nh tnh cht quc t (international character) cho hp
ng, iu 1 ca Cng c c nu: Cng c ny p dng cho cc hp ng
mua bn hng ha gia cc bn c tr s thng mi ti cc Quc gia khc
nhau. Nhvy, Cng c Vin a xem trsthng mi l tiu ch xc
nh hp ng k kt gia cc bn c phi l hp ng mua bn hng ha quc t
hay khng. Trong trng hp c nhiu trs thng mi, bn giao dch c th
chn ra trsc mi lin quan cht chnht ti hp ng. Trong trng hp hai
bn khng c trsthng mi th sly ni ctr thng xuyn lm tiu ch
xc nh tnh cht quc tca hp ng (iu 10 CISG).Tuy nhin, trong trng hp cc bn khng chng minh c tr s
thng mi ca mnh mt cch chnh thc nhti khon 2 iu 1 Vic xc nhn
c cc bn c trsthng mi ti cc quc gia khc nhau khng c chp
nhn nu vic xc nhn ny khng xut pht thp ng, tcc giao dch vn
c gia cc bn hoc tcc thng tin c trao i gia cc bn trc hoc vo
thi im k hp ng. V dmt trong cc bn giao dch khng chng minh
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
13/81
5
mnh l i l hp php ca mt bn c trsthng mi khc th hp ng k
kt gia hai bn khng c xem l hp ng mua bn hng ha quc t.
Ngoi ra Cng c Vin khng ly cc yu t mang tnh quc tch
(nationality), quy ch dn s (civil character) v quy ch thng mi(commercial character) lm tiu ch xc nh hp ng mua bn hng ha quc
t. iu 1 khon 3 c nu: Quc tch cng nhtcch dn shoc thng mi
ca cc bn hoc tnh cht dn shay thng mi ca hp ng khng c xt
ti khi xc nh phm vi p dng ca Cng c ny.
1.2. Khi qut chung vchti huhp ng trong hp ng mua bn hng
ha quc t
Lut Thng mi 2005 ca Vit Nam quy nh hy hp ng l vic hy
bhon ton hoc mt phn hp ng (iu 312): Hy bhon ton l vic bi
bton bvic thc hin tt ccc ngha vhp ng i vi ton bhp ng;
tng t: hy bmt phn hp ng l vic bi bthc hin mt phn ngha v
hp ng, cc phn cn li trong hp ng vn c hiu lc. B lut thng nht
thng mi thng nht Hoa Kquy nh khc hn khi phn thnh hai thut ng
ring bit cho 2 trng hp ca hy hp ng (hy hp ng do hai bn tha
thun trc, hy hp ng do mt bn gy ra vi phm). Tuy nhin, bn cht ca
hy hp ng trong UCC vn l vic hai bn sgii thot cho nhau tt cmi
ngha vca hp ng, trnhng ngha vpht sinh sau khi hy hp ng v t
gii quyt tranh chp (iu 2 106 khon 3, 4 UCC).
Bn cnh , theo tinh thn ca hu ht php lut cc nc, khi xy ra vi
phm hp ng, bn bvi phm cha p dng chti ny ngay m p dng cc
chti khc (bt buc thc hin ngha ng ngha v, pht vi phm, bi thngthit hi). Trong trng hp vic p dng cc ch ti khc khng khc phc
c tnh trng vi phm, chti hy hp ng mi c p dng. Vic p dng
chti hy hp ng phi m bo nhng iu kin vni dung v hnh thc.
1.2.1. iu kin p dng chti huhp ng trong hp ng mua
bn hng ha quc t
1.2.1.1.iu kin vni dung
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
14/81
6
Php lut cc nc khc nhau th c cch quy nh khc nhau v cc
trng hp c p dng chti hy hp ng.
Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005 li quy nh: Trcc trng hp min
trch quy nh ti iu 294 ca Lut ny, chti hy bhp ng c p dngtrong cc trng hp sau y:
a. Xy ra hnh vi vi phm m cc bn tha thun l iu kin hy
bhp ng;
b. Mt bn vi phm cbn ngha vhp ng.
CISG li c quy nh ring cho tng bn vcc trng hp c p dng
ch ti hy hp ng. Theo , iu 49 khon 1 Cng c quy nh i vi
trng hp ngi mua: Ngi mua c thtuyn bhy hp ng:
a. Nu vic ngi bn khng thc hin mt ngha vno ca hpht
sinh thp ng hay tCng c ny cu thnh mt vi phm cbn hp ng;
hoc
b. Trong trng hp khng giao hng, nu ngi bn khng giao hng
trong thi gian c ngi mua gia hn thm cho hchiu theo khon 1 iu
47 hoc nu ngi bn tuyn b s khng giao hng trong thi gian c gia
hn ny.
Song song, iu 64 khon 1 cng quy nh v quyn hy hp ng ca
ngi bn: Ngi bn c thtuyn bhy hp ng:
a. Nu skin ngi mua khng thc hin ngha vno ca h theo
hp ng hay Cng c cu thnh mt svi phm cbn hp ng; hoc
b. Nu ngi mua khng thc hin ngha vtrtin hoc nhn hng trong
thi hn bsung m ngi bn chp nhn cho hchiu theo khon 1 iu 63 haynu htuyn bskhng lm vic trong thi hn y.
Thi hn gia hn thm c ni ti y l mt thi gian hp l c
mt bn chp nhn thm bn cn li c thhon thnh ngha vca mnh.
Nhvy, chti hy hp ng c thc p dng trong cc trng hp
sau: do hai bn tha thun trong hp ng; do c xy ra vi phm gy ra thit hi
nghim trng; do bn vi phm khng thkhc phc c thit hi trong thi hn
c gia hn thm.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
15/81
7
Trng hp cc bn tha thun trc vtrng hp hy hp ng
Vic p dng chti ny c thc quy nh ngay trong iu khon ca
hp ng bn cnh nhng quy nh trong php lut vcc tnh trng vi phm c
thdn n c thp dng c chti hy hp ng nh1.2.1.1. iu 312khon 4 im a Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005 c quy nh: chti hy hp
ng cng c p dng nu c tha thun ngay trong hp ng. Trn thc
t, c nhng trng hp vi phm hp ng cha n mc nghim trng dn
n hy hp ng, nhng v l mt trng hp m hai bn tha thun trong
hp ng nn dn n chti hy vn c p dng. Tng t, iu 2-106 khon
3 UCC cng quy nh vtrng hp ny ny.
Trng hp xy ra vi phm gy ra thit hi nghim trng
C th thy cc ngun Lut u c im chung l ch ti hy hp ng
c p dng trong trng hp xy ra vi phm nghim trng. Tuy nhin, mi
ngun lut c cch din gii khc nhau vvi phm nghim trng. Trong trng
hp ca B lut thng mi thng nht Hoa Kcng nhBnguyn tc Chu
u vhp ng, mt bn c quyn hy hp ng khi bn kia c svi phm cc
iu khon ch yu. Trong khi lut Cng ha Php s dng thut ng viphm chyu lm c s cho vic p dng ch ti hy. Trong , cCng
c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng ha quc tv Lut Thng mi
Vit Nam c s gp g trong vic s dng thut ng vi phm c bn
(fundamental breach).
lm r hn v trng hp vi phm nghim trng dn n hy hp
ng, kha lun ny sphn tch nhng vn lin quan n vi phm cbn bao
gm khi nim v cch xc nh vi phm cbn.- Khi nim vi phm cbn
Rt nhiu chuyn gia cng nhcc nh kinh doanh nh gi thut ngvi
phm c bn rt m h v kh p dng. ng thi, mi ngun lut cng c
cch quy nh khc nhau cho khi nim ny.
Lut Thng mi Vit Nam nm 2005 nh ngha ti iu 13 khon 3: Vi
phm cbn l svi phm hp ng ca mt bn gy thit hi cho bn kia n
mc lm cho bn kia khng t c mc ch giao kt. Vi khi nim ny,
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
16/81
8
CISG li quy nh tng i cthhn ti iu 25: Mt svi phm hp ng
do mt bn gy ra l vi phm cbn nu svi phm lm cho bn kia bthit
hi m ngi b thit hi, trong mt chng mc ng k bmt ci m h c
quyn chi trn cshp ng, trphi bn vi phm khng tin liu c huqu v mt ngi c l tr minh mn cng s khng tin liu c nu h
cng vo hon cnh tng t.
Nhvy, c th thy cLut Thng mi Vit Nam ln CISG u nhn
nhn vi phm cbn tgc hu quca vi phm thay v quy nh cthv
hnh vi vi phm. Vbn cht, vi phm cbn l mt svi phm hp ng. l
vic vi phm bt kmt ngha v c hai bn tha thun trong hp ng
hoc pht sinh thp ng hay quy nh ca ngun lut p dng cho hp ng.
Tuy nhin, nu Lut Thng mi Vit Nam nm 2005 ch cp n hu qu
lm cho mt bn khng t c mc ch giao kt th Cng c Vin nm
1980 c thha hu qu l bn bvi phm bmt quyn chi trn cs
hp ng trong chng mc ng kv bn vi phm lng trc c thit hi
.
Chnh cch quy nh c vmh nhtrn mra mt phm tr rng
ln bao gm nhng quy nh php lut c lin quan n vi phm cbn v thc
tin m vic xc nh vi phm c bn tr thnh vn chnh. Khi nim vi
phm c bn tr thnh trung tm trong nhiu tranh chp ca ca cc giao
dch mua bn hng ha quc t. Vic nh gi khng ng tnh c bn
(fundamentality) ca vi phm c th dn n vic xc nh nhm v quyn v
ngha vca cc bn, do lm mt i tnh cng bng cho cc phn quyt v gy
ra nhng thit hi khng ng c. Chnh v vy, vic xc nh vi phm cbncn phi da vo nhng tiu ch nht nh.
- Tiu ch xc nh vi phm cbn
Mc d cch nh ngha c thkhc nhau, vn trng tm ca vic xc
nh vi phm cbn chnh l tnh nghim trng ca thit hi. y l tiu ch
u tin nh gi tnh cbn ca vi phm.
Ti iu 25 Cng c Vin, thut ng ng k (substianlly) c s
dng din gii mc thit hi m bn b vi phm gp phi hay mc
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
17/81
9
nhng li ch m bn bvi phm khng t c do hnh vi vi phm.3Phn mt
i ny cng ln th thit hi cng nghim trng v do bn vi phm cng db
xem l gy ra vi phm cbn cho hp ng. Thng thng, nhng li ch bmt
i ny c th hin qua vic cc bn khng thc hin c mc ch m hmong mun khi k kt hp ng. V d, nu ngi bn giao hng km cht
lng khin ngi mua khng thtiu thshng ha trn thtrng nh
nh ban u; nu ngi mua vi phm ngha vthanh ton, ngi bn khng th
c c s tin nh mong mun phc vnhng khoch t ra. y
chnh l im gp ggia CISG v Lut Thng mi Vit Nam nm 2005.
Ngoi ra, tnh nghim trng ca thit hi cng c thc nh gi thng
qua khnng khc phc hu qu. Hu qudo vi phm cbn gy ra khng nht
thit l khng khc phc c. Tuy nhin c thvic khc phc sgy ra chi ph
qu ln hay nhng ph tn v l cho cc bn.
Bn cnh vic nh gi tnh nghim trng ca thit hi, tnh tit vi phm
cng l mt tiu ch xc nh vi phm c bn. Vi phm cbn khng nht
thit l vi phm mt ngha vchyu hay mt ngha vcbn ca hp ng.
Vic vi phm bt kngha vno, d l ngha vph, nhng mang y cc
tiu ch nu ti iu 25 th u c coi l vi phm cbn. V dnhngi mua
vi phm ngha vbo mt hng ha Do , nu chxem xt hu quv kh
nng khc phc hu qum khng xem xt tnh tit vi phm c thsdn n
vic nh gi khng ng n tnh cht cbn.
Ngoi ra, mt trong nhng tiu ch CISG a ra xc nh vi phm c
bn chnh l vic bn vi phm phi lng trc c nhng hu quca vi phm
hay cn gi l tnh c thdon c (foreseeability). Theo iu 25 CISG,nu bn vi phm khng thc bit hay tin liu c mnh svi phm ngha
vv gy ra thit hi nghim trng cho bn cn li th vi phm skhng c
xem l vi phm cbn (theo Perovic 2004).
3Xem Explanatory Note by the UNCITRAL Secretariat on the United Nations
Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, on 29, c tihttp://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/text/p23.html
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
18/81
10
Trng hp bn vi phm khng thkhc phc thit hi trong thi hn gia
hn thm
Cc ngun lut cho php khi xy ra vi phm, bn vi phm c php thc
hin cc bin php nhm khc phc cc thit hi gy ra. Hay ni cch khcy l vic buc bn vi phm phi thc hin ng hp ng nhm mc ch ti
a ha li ch nhn c ca cc bn tvic thc hin hp ng thnh cng. Cc
bin php ny khng lm mt i quyn i bi thng thit hi ca bn b vi
phm.
c bit, bn vi phm sc gia hn thm thi gian tin hnh cc
bin php ny. Cng c Vin nm 1980 quy nh vgia hn thm thi gian
loi trcc thiu st trong thc hin ngha v ti iu 47 khon 1 (gia hn cho
ngi bn) v iu 63 khon 1 (gia hn cho ngi mua). Bnguyn tc Chu u
vhp ng cng a ra quy nh tng tti iu 8:106 khon 1.
Tuy nhin, vic khc phc cc tn tht gy trong thi gian c gia hn
thm gy ra ph tn qu ln hoc nhng chm trkhng ng c cho cc bn, ch
ti hy hp ng sbp dng. Tng t, nu vt qua thi hn m bn vi
phm vn cha tin hnh thnh cng bin php no, hp ng cng stng b
hy.
1.2.1.2.iu kin vhnh thc
Ngoi cc iu kin vni dung, vic p dng chti hy hp ng cng
yu cu vic p ng iu kin vhnh thc.
Trc khi p dng ch ti hy hp ng cc bn cn tuyn b hy hp
ng. CCng c Vin nm 1980 ln Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005 u c
quan im chung v vic bn b vi phm phi thng bo v tuyn b hy hpng ca mnh n cc bn lin quan. Theo , Lut Thng mi Vit Nam
quy nh ti iu 315: Bn tm ngng thc hin hp ng, nh ch thc hin
hp ng hoc hy b hp ng phi thng bo cho bn kia bit v vic tm
ngng hp ng... Tng tiu 26 CISG cng nu r: Mt li tuyn b v
vic hy hp ng chc hiu lc nu c thng bo cho bn kia bit. Bn cnh
, CISG cng a ra thi hn tuyn b, nu ngi mua khng tin hnh thng bo
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
19/81
11
cho ngi bn bit trong thi hn ny, ngi mua sbmt quyn hy hp ng
(iu 49 khon 2).
C mt im ng ch l tuyn bhy hp ng ngay ckhi cha c
hnh vi vi phm hp ng. Cng c Vin nm 1980 cho php p dng ch tihy hp ng bt klc no tsau khi k hp ng m khng cn chvic thc
hin hp ng hoc hnh vi vi phm v tn tht c hay cha.4Hay ni cch
khc csca vic hy hp ng l da trn nng lc thc txt xem bn kia
c ththc hin c hp ng hay khng; hoc c thda trn tuyn bca h
vvic khng thi hnh cc ngha vhp ng. Do , trong trng hp cha c
cc chng cchng minh vi phm v tn tht, tnh hp php ca vic tuyn b
hy hp ng skhng c m bo. Chnh v vy, bn tuyn bhy hp ng
phi lm ng tc thng bo vquyt nh ca h. Nu trong trng hp bn
i tc khng thchng minh c khnng thc hin ngha vca mnh, bn
c nh tuyn bhy hp ng c thtuyn bhy m khng sbkhiu ni.
Vvn ny, Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005 khng c quy nh vtrng
hp cho php p dng chti trc khi xy ra tn tht.
1.2.2. Hu quphp l ca vic huhp ng
Hy hp ng c xem l chti nng nht trong cc chti v n dn
n hu quphp l rt nng ncho cc bn. Tuy rng cc ngun lut quy nh
vcc trng hp p dng chti hy hp ng khng ging nhau, hu ht cc
ngun lut c quan im ging nhau vcc hu quphp l. l:
Thnht, khi p dng chti hy hp ng, hai bn sgii thot cho nhau
tt cmi ngha vca hp ng (trnhng ngha vpht sinh sau khi hy hp
ng v tgii quyt tranh chp). iu 314 khon 1 Lut Thng mi 2005 caVit Nam quy nh: sau khi hy bhp ng, hp ng khng c hiu lc t
thi im giao kt, cc bn khng phi tip tc thc hin cc ngha v tha
thun trong hp ng, tr tha thun vcc quyn v ngha vsau khi hy b
hp ng v v gii quyt tranh chp. Cng c Vin 1980 cng thng nht
quan im ny.
4Xem iu 72 khon 1 Cng c Vin.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
20/81
12
Hu quphp l thhai l vic cc bn phi hon trnhng g nhn
c tbn kia trong qu trnh thc hin hp ng hay cc bn c quyn i li
li ch do vic thc hin phn ngha vca mnh theo hp ng. Nu cc bn
u c ngha vhon trth phi thc hin ngha vhon trng thi. Trnghp khng thhon trli ch nhn c th phi hon trbng tin.
Hu quphp l tip theo l vic bn bvi phm c bi thng thit hi
gy ra do bn vi phm hoc np pht nu hp ng c quy nh. Mc d cn
nhiu mu thun vvic p dng hnh thc pht vi phm, cc ngun lut u c
chung quan im vvic chp nhn hnh thc bi thng thit hi. ngha ca
nhng quy nh ny l nhm bo vquyn li cho bn bvi phm c bit l cc
li ch vti sn v loi trkhnng bn vi phm li dng hy hp ng trn
trnh cc trch nhim ca mnh.
1.3. Khi qut chung vtnh ph hp vi hp ng ca hng ho
1.3.1. Tnh ph hp ca hng ho
Php lut cc nc quy nh tng i ging nhau vkhi nim tnh ph
hp vi hp ng ca hng ha (conformity of goods). Theo , cc nc u
c quan im hng ha ph hp vi hp ng khng ch gii hn vnhng
quy nh trong hp ng m cn phi ph hp vi nhng quy nh ca php lut.
Chth44/99/EC ca Nghvin chu u a ra nhng tiu ch to nn tnh ph
hp ca hng ha ti iu 2 khon 2:
Hng ha c coi l ph hp vi hp ng nu:
a. p ng cc m tca ngi bn v c cc tnh cht ca hng mu m
ngi bn cung cp cho ngi mua trc ;
b. ph hp cho bt kmc ch cthno m ngi mua mong mun tc hoc ngi bn cho bit vo thi im giao kt hp ng hoc ngi
bn chp nhn;
c. ph hp vi mc ch s dng thng thng ca cc hng ha cng
chng loi;
d. Cc phm cht v c tnh thhin nhhng ha cng loi thng c
v p ng yu cu hp l ca ngi mua, da trn tnh cht cbn ca hng
ha v tnh n bt cthng bo cng khai no vcc c im cthca hng
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
21/81
13
ha c ngi bn, ngi sn xut hoc i din ca ha ra, c bit qua
cc qung co hoc nhn hiu.
Tng t, CISG cng quy nh ti khon 1,2 iu 35:
1. Ngi bn phi giao hng ng s lng, phm cht v m t nhquy nh trong hp ng, v ng bao b hay ng gi nhhp ng yu cu.
2. Trnhng trng hp cc bn c tha thun khc, hng ha bcoi l
khng ph hp vi hp ng nu:
a. Hng ha khng thch hp cho cc mc ch sdng m cc hng ha
cng loi vn thng p ng.
b. Hng khng thch hp cho bt kmc ch cthno m ngi bn
c bit mt cch r rng hoc ng vo lc giao kt hp ng, tr trng
hp nu cn cvo cc hon cnh cthc ththy rng ngi mua khng
tnh n nng lc hay snh gi ca ngi bn hoc nu i vi hlm nh
thl khng hp l.
c. Hng khng c cc tnh cht ca hng mu m ngi bn cung cp
cho ngi mua.
d. Hng khng c ng phong b theo cch thng thng cho nhng
hng cng loi hoc, nu khng c cch thng thng, th bng cch thch hp
gign v bo vhng ho .
Tng t, Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005 v Blut Thng mi thng
nht Hoa K cng c nhng quy nh tng t nh ch th 44/99/EC v Cng
c Vin nm 1980.5
Nhvy, trc tin, c ththy ngha vm bo hay giao hng ph hp
vi hp ng l ngha vca ngi bn. ng thi, hng ha ph hp vi hpng cng phi p ng nhng tiu ch nht nh.
1.3.1.1. Hng ha ph hp vi slng, phm cht v m tnhhp
ng
Ngi bn phi p ng tiu ch vslng hng ha. Thng thng, do
tnh cht phong ph v phc tp v tnh cht hng ha cng nh qung ng
vn chuyn hng trong cc giao dch mang tnh quc tny, hai bn thng quy
5iu 39 Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
22/81
14
nh mt mc xp xhoc c thm dung sai vs lng hng. Theo , ngi
bn c php giao hng vi slng nm trong mc xp xhay dung sai ny.
Trong trng hp p dng mc xp x, ngi bn phi cn phi tnh ton cn
trng cung cp mt slng hp l. Vic cung cp thiu hay tha qu nhiuso vi mc xp xc thbxem l vi phm ngha vgiao hng ng slng v
gy ra cc ph tn khng ng c cho cc bn (v d: chi ph lu kho, chi ph vn
chuyn).
Bn cnh tiu ch vslng, tiu ch vphm cht hng ha cng phi
c m bo. V kha cnh ny, phm cht c hiu theo ngha rt rng,
khng nht thit gii hn nhng c im mang tnh k thut hay phm cht
quy cch ca hng ha. V d: trong mt vi trng hp, hng ha khng ng
ngun gc xut xnhhp ng yu cu cng c thbxem l khng ph hp.
Ngoi ra, giao hng vi phm cht tng t, d l phm cht tt hn cng cha
c khng nh l khng vi phm hp ng.
Hng ha c giao ti thiu phi p ng y v chnh xc cc c
im mang tnh cht m t trong hp ng (V d: mu sc, kch c) Phng
Thng mi Cng nghip chra rng trong trng hp hng ha khng c hoc
kh xc nh cc quy chun vphm cht, ngi bn c ngha vcung cp hng
ha ph hp vi mc ch v m t.
1.3.1.2. Hng ha c bao b, c ng gi v c bo qun theo hp
ng
Mt trong cc tiu ch xc nh tnh ph hp ca hng ha theo hp ng
chnh l tnh trng bao b, ng gi hay bo qun ca hng ha. Trng hp bao
b, cch ng gi hay bo qun hng ha khng ging nhquy nh trong hpng hoc theo cch thng thng hoc thch hp m hng ha cng loi c
ng gi v bo qun, hng ha c thbnghi ngkhng m bo cht lng
nhngi mua yu cu v c thdn n vic kt lun ngi mua vi phm ngha
vca mnh.
1.3.1.3. Hng ha phi ph hp vi mc ch sdng
Bn cnh cc tiu ch trn, Cng c Vin nm 1980, BLut Thng
mi Thng nht v chth44/99/EC u cp n tnh ph hp vi mc ch s
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
23/81
15
dng xc nh tnh ph hp ca hng ha. Theo , hng ha s b xem l
khng ph hp nu khng thch hp cho cc mc ch s dng m hng ha
cng loi vn thng p ng [1]; hoc khng ph hp vi bt cmc ch s
dng cthno m ngi bn c bit mt cch r rng hay ng vo thiim giao kt hp ng [2].
Vi trng hp [1], tnh thch hp vi mc ch sdng y c nh
gi thng qua suy ngh thng thng ngi mua v ngi bn vcng nng s
dng ca hng ha.6Thng thng, tnh ph hp vi mc ch sdng thng
c xc nh theo cc tiu chun ca nc ngi bn. Do , trn thc tgiao
dch, ngi mua nn thng bo vi ngi bn vnhng yu cu c bit hoc
nhng gii hn ca nc ngi mua. V tt nht l tiu chun c thm nc
ngi mua ra vtnh ph hp vi mc ch sdng ca hng ha.
Vi trng hp [2], tnh thch hp vi mc ch sdng cthc hiu
l mc ch ca ngi mua khi nhp khu loi hng ha ny.7V dhng ha c
thnhm mc ch bn li thu li nhun hoc tr thnh nguyn, nhin liu u
vo cho qu trnh sn xut Tiu ch ny c dng trong trng hp ngi
mua mua hng nhm mc ch sdng cth. Hay ni cch khc, nu ngi bn
bit r nh ca ngi mua, ngi mua thng da vo knng v sphn
on ca ngi bn c c loi hng ha p ng c mc ch sdng
(theo Hubber & Mullis 2007).
1.3.1.4. Hng ha c tnh cht ca hng mu
Ngi bn cng c trch nhim giao hng ha c cc tnh cht ca hng
mu. Theo , UCC quy nh ti im c, khon 1 iu 2-313 nhsau: Nu
tha thun c hnh thnh c phn da trn bt khng mu hay m hnh no,tt chng ha c giao phi m bo ph hp vi hng mu v m hnh .
Tng t, i vi CISG, ngi bn cng bxem l giao hng khng ph hp nu
hng ha khng c cc tnh cht ca hng mu.8 ngha ca iu khon ny l
6Fit for ordinary use
7Fit for particular purposes8Xem iu 35 khon 2 im c Cng c Vin
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
24/81
16
thay v quy nh trong hp ng cc c im, phm cht ca hng ha, ngi
bn trin khai mt ngha vthay thm tv nhn din hng ha.
1.3.2. Trch nhim ca ngi bn vvic hng ho khng ph hp
vi hp ngTrch nhim ca ngi bn vvic hng ha khng ph hp vi hp ng
c thc hiu l ngi bn vi phm mt trong cc tiu ch xc nh tnh
ph hp ca hng ha nhphn 1.3.1 v hnh vi vi phm ny c th gy ra
thit hi nht nh cho ngi mua.
Bn cnh , cc ngun lut cng quy nh trong trng hp no ngi
bn phi chu trch nhim vvic hng ha khng ph hp vi hp ng v cc
chti c thc p dng nu xy ra trng hp .
1.3.2.1. Phm vi trch nhim ngi bn phi chu v vic hng ha
khng ph hp
iu 36 Cng c Vin nm 1980 quy nh:
1. Ngi bn chu trch nhim chiu theo hp ng v Cng c ny, v
mi skhng ph hp no ca hng ha tn ti vo lc chuyn giao quyn ri ro
sang ngi mua, ngay ckhi skhng ph hp ca hng ha chc pht hin
sau .
2. Ngi bn cng chu trch nhim vmi skhng ph hp ca hng
ha xy ra sau thi im ni im trn v l hu quca vic ngi bn vi
phm bt cmt ngha vno ca mnh, k c vic khng th hon ton m
bo rng trong mt thi hn no , hng ha vn thch hp cho mc ch s
dng thng thng hay mc ch cthhoc vn duy tr c nhng tnh cht
hay c tnh quy nh.Tng t, khon 2, khon 3 iu 40 Lut Thng mi 2005 ca Vit Nam
cng cp n vn ny:
2. Trtrng hp quy nh ti khon 1 iu ny, trong thi hn khiu ni
theo quy nh ca Lut ny, bn bn phi chu trch nhim v bt k khim
khuyt ca hng ha c trc ri ro cho bn mua, k c trng hp khim
khuyt c pht hin sau thi im chuyn ri ro.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
25/81
17
3. Bn bn phi chu trch nhim vkhim khuyt ca hng ha pht sinh
sau thi im chuyn ri ro nu khim khuyt do bn bn vi phm hp ng.
Nhvy, cCISG v Lut Thng mi Vit Nam u sdng thi im
chuyn giao ri ro hng ha lm cn cxc nh phm vi m ngi bn phichu trch nhim nu hng ha khng ph hp vi hp ng. Theo , phm vi
chu trch nhim ca ngi bn c quy nh nhsau:
Th nht, ngi bn phi m bo tnh ph hp ca hng ha ti thi
im chuyn giao ri ro. C ngha l ti thi im ny, hng ha phi tnh trng
hon ho, ph hp vi yu cu v mong mun ca ngi mua. Ni cch khc,
ngi bn sphi chu trch nhim nu c bt ckhim khuyt no c pht
hin ti thi im ny.
Thhai, trn thc t, c nhng khim khuyt hay bt ph hp chc
pht hin sau khi ri ro c chuyn cho ngi mua, c bit chpht sinh
trong qu trnh sdng. Vi trng hp ny ngi bn phi chu trch nhim vi
bt ckhim khuyt no ca hng ha pht sinh hoc l hu quca vic bn
bn vi phm hp ng [1]; hoc trong thi hn m ngi bn m bo rng
hng ha ph hp vi mc ch sdng thng thng hay mc ch cthhoc
vn duy tr c nhng tnh cht hay c tnh quy nh [2].
y, ngi bn sphi chu trch nhim nu nhng khim khuyt ny l
do ngi bn vi phm mt trong cc ngha vtrc thi im chuyn giao ri ro
(trng hp [1]). Ngha vc thhiu l ngha vm bo hng ha ph hp
vi hp ng nhmc 1.3.1 nhng cng c thl bt kngha vno khc. V
dtrng hp ngi bn c chnh thu tu v ngi bn thu tu ca mt
cng ty khng m bo nng lc chuyn ch. Trong qu trnh vn chuyn, hngha bhhi do hng tu khng nng lc. Nhvy, ngi bn vn phi chu
trch nhim vi khim khuyt ca hng ha trong trng hp ny mc d ngi
bn khng trc tip vi phm.
i vi trng hp [2], ngi bn phi chu trch nhim vskhng ph
hp nu khim khuyt pht sinh trong thi hn m ngi bn m bo rng
hng ha ph hp vi mc ch sdng thng thng hay mc ch cthhoc
vn duy tr c nhng tnh cht hay c tnh quy nh. m bo ny c thl
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
26/81
18
mt m bo r rng hoc mt m bo ng . i vi Cng c Vin nm
1980, vic thc hin m bo ny cng c xem l mt ngha v. Do trng
hp [2] c xem l trng hp [1] v c din gii l ngi bn vi phm ngha
vtrn.Nh vy, trong phm vi phn tch trn, ngi bn phi chu trch
nhim vi hng ha khng ph hp vi hp ng. Tuy nhin, cng c trng
hp ngi bn c thot khi trch nhim ny. Theo , ngi bn c min
trch trong trng hp ti thi im giao kt, ngi mua mt cch hp l bit
c skhng ph hp vi hp ng ca hng ha. Vvn cCng c Vin
v Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005 u c quan im tng ng.9
1.3.2.2. Cc chti p dng trong trng hp hng ha khng ph hp
vi hp ng
Sau khi xc nh c trch nhim ca ngi bn trong vic hng ha
khng ph hp hp ng, ngi bn c thphi chu cc chti sau:
Ngi bn phi khi phc tnh ph hp vi hp ng ca hng hng bng
cch sa cha phn hng ha bkhim khuyt hoc giao hng thay thv mi chi
ph sa cha hay giao hng do ngi bn chu. iu ny c th dn n vic
ngi bn phi giao hng thnh tng phn hoc giao hng chm.
Ngi bn c thphi chp nhn gim gi hng ty vo khim khuyt
ca hng ha.
Ngi bn phi chu khon pht vi phm trong trng hp ng c quy
nh vpht vi phm.
Ngi bn phi bi thng thit hi nu skhng ph hp ca hng ha
gy ra cc thit hi cho ngi mua.Hp ng c thbhy nu hp ng c quy nh hoc svi phm ca
ngi bn c xem l vi phm nghim trng dn n hy hp ng (vi phm c
bn, vi phm chyu)
Ty thuc vo tnh hnh thc t, ngi bn sphi chu mt chti cth
hoc cc chti kt hp vi nhau.
9iu 35 khon 3 CISG, iu 40 khon 1 Lut Thng mi Vit Nam 2005
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
27/81
19
1.3.3. Quyn khi phc tnh ph hp ca hng ha vi hp ng ca
ngi bn trc hn giao hng
phn 1.3.2.2 c nhc n bin php khi phc tnh ph hp ca hng
ha nhmt ngha vca ngi bn nu hng ha khng ph hp vi hp ng.Tuy nhin, cc ngun lut cng cp n bin php ny nhmt quyn ca
ngi bn v quyn ny chc p dng nu hng cha n hn phi giao.
Tht vy, iu 8 104 ca bnguyn tc chu u vHp ng quy nh
trong trng hp nu mt bn khng c khnng thc hin c mt ngha v
nh tha thun trong hp ng, trc thi hn ngha vc thc hin bn
ny c tha ra nghthc hin mt ngha vthay th. Ngha vny c thl
ngha vm bo hng ha ph hp vi hp ng. Tng t, iu 37 Cng c
Vin nm 1980 cng cp n vic sa cha phn hng khng ph hp, giao
hng thiu hoc giao hng thay thnu hng ha c giao trc hn.
Tuy nhin, ngi bn chc s dng quyn ny nu c sng
ca ngi bn. V quyn ny cng khng loi trngha vchu pht vi phm hay
bi thng thit hi ca ngi mua trphi c tha thun khc.
1.3.4. Kim tra cht lng hng ho v khiu ni trong trng hp
hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ng
xc nh xem ngi bn c thc svi phm ngha vgiao hng ph
hp vi hp ng hay khng, ngi mua cn thc hin vic kim tra cht lng
hng ha hay cn gi l gim nh hng ha. Vic kim tra cht lng hng ha
v pht hin khim khuyt s tr thnh c s ngi mua khiu ni vhng
ha khng ph hp vi hp ng.
1.3.4.1. Kim tra cht lng hng haVic kim tra cht lng hng ha c thdo chnh ngi mua hoc mt
bn thba m nhn. Bn thba c th l cquan chuyn trch vgim nh
cht lng hng ha do cc bn tha thun thu hoc l ngi tiu dng cui
cng trong trng hp hng ha c bn li. Cch thc gim nh hng ha
cng ty thuc vo loi hng, cc c tnh ca hng, slng, bao b ng gi
cng nhni thc hin gim nh.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
28/81
20
Ngoi ra, vic kim tra hng ha phi c thc hin trong mt thi hn
ph hp v ty thuc theo tnh hung cth. Thi hn ph hp y c hiu
l thi hn hp l v khng chm trtrnh vic hng ha bhhi, tn tht
sau khi hng c giao. Ty theo tnh hung cthc ngha l ty vo thi imsm nht m ngi mua c khnng tip cn c vi hng thc hin gim
nh cht lng. Vvn ny, Cng c Vin cp n hai trng hp
c bit: a im ca hng bi trong qu trnh vn chuyn (redirection) hoc
hng c ngi mua gi i tip (redispatch) trong trng hp ngi mua khng
c khnng kim tra v ngi bn bit hoc c thlng trc c sthay
thi .10
1.3.4.2. Khiu ni trong trng hp hng ha khng ph hp vi hp
ng
Sau khi pht hin ra skhng ph hp trong hng ha, ngi mua c th
tin hnh khiu ni vi ngi bn. y ng thi l c s ngi mua tin
hnh cc bin php xl vi phm c bit l chti hy hp ng.
Khiu ni v tnh ph hp ca hng ha phi y cc ni dung (bn cht
khim khuyt, m tkhim khuyt, yu cu ca ngi mua) v m bo c gi
n ngi bn trong thi hn hp l. Thi hn hp l c nhn mnh bt u tlc
m ngi bn nhn bit hoc ng lphi nhn bit c khim khuyt v c
di ty thuc vo cc yu tnhtha thun vm bo cht lng ca cc bn,
quy nh ca php lut tng nc iu 39 CISG, iu 2-607 UCC hay iu 47 Lut
Thng mi Vit Nam 2005 u thng nht v quan im ny.
10iu 38 Cng c Vin.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
29/81
21
CHNG 2: HY HP NG TRONG TRNG HP HNG HA
KHNG PH HP THEO CNG C VIN NM 1980 V HP
NG MUA BN HNG HA QUC T
Qua cc nghin cu chng 1, c ththy khng phi trng hp hngha khng ph hp no cng c thdn n hy hp ng. Mi ngun lut cng
c cc quy nh ring vvn ny. Kha lun ny slm r vtrng hp hu
hp ng do hng ho khng ph hp vi hp ng trong khun khcc giao
dch p dng Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng ha quc t.
Theo Cng c Vin nm 1980, i vi trng hp hng ha khng ph
hp vi hp ng dn n hy hp ng, vi phm thuc v trch nhim ca
ngi bn v quyn hy hp ng thuc vngi mua v ngi mua chc th
thc hin quyn ny khi svi phm ca ngi bn cu thnh mt vi phm cbn
hoc ngi bn khng thkhi phc sph hp ca hng ha trong thi hn
c ngi mua gia hn thm.
2.1. Cc trng hp dn n vic p dng chti huhp ng do hng ho
khng ph hp theo Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng
ho quc t2.1.1. Cc trng hp hng ho khng ph hp cu thnh vi phm c
bn
2.1.1.1. Hng ho khng ph hp vslng, phm cht v m t.
Theo iu 35 khon 1 im a, ngi bn buc phi m bo giao hng
ng slng, phm cht v m ttrong hp ng. Nhvy, vic cung cp hng
ha khng ng slng, phm cht v m ttrong hp ng n mt gii hn
no sbxem l vi phm cbn v do ngi mua c quyn hy hp
ng. Nhvy, vn t ra l lm sao xc nh vi phm nghim trng
n mc l vi phm cbn hay cha?
Trng hp hng ha khng ph hp vslng
Trc ht, v y l mt vi phm mang tnh hnh thc, skhng ph hp
c chia thnh hai dng: giao hng thiu (quantity shortage/shortfall) v giao
hng tha (quantity surplus/excess)
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
30/81
22
i vi trng hp giao hng thiu, vi phm ny thng bxem l giao
hng chm hoc khng giao hng ty theo tnh hung cthv thng khng b
xem l mt vi phm cbn. Bn cnh , CISG quy nh cc bin php xl
thay v p dng ngay chti hy hp ng.i vi trng hp hng ha bgiao tha, theo tinh thn Cng c Vin
nm 1980 vi phm ny cng khng bxem l vi phm cbn. V theo lthng
hng ha vn ph hp vi cc tiu ch khc (trong c tnh tiu thc), do
vn tn ti khnng ngi mua bn li phn hng tha cho bn thba. Tuy
nhin, l do ny khng lm mt i quyn ca ngi mua c quy nh ti iu
51 khon 2 CISG: l ngi mua c thchp nhn hay tchi s lng ph
tri. Trong trng hp ngi mua chp nhn ton b hoc mt phn s lng
phtri, ngi mua phi trthm stin tng ng vi phn hng 11. Trong
trng hp ngi mua khng chp nhn, vic tchi khng nht thit l vic t
chi phn hng tha ti ni nhn hng. Da trn nguyn tc thin ch quy nh ti
iu 7 v nguyn tc p dng tp qun, thi quen thng mi theo iu 9 Cng
c, phn hng tha c thc ngi mua gi li v bo qun mt cch ph
hp trc khi hai bn c bin php xl khc. Nu v l do m bo ng gi
hoc chng tph hp, ngi mua khng thtchi v khng mun/khng th
bo qun phn hng tha, ngi mua c thtchi ton bshng c giao.
Tuy nhin, v y khng phi l mt vi phm cbn, ngi mua vn khng c
quyn hy hp ng.
Nh vy, ni chung giao hng nhm s lng khng b xem l mt vi
phm cbn v thng skhng bp dng chti hy hp ng.
Trng hp hng ha khng ph hp v phm cht v m t trong hpng
iu 35 khon 1 Cng c Vin nm 1980 v hp ng mua bn hng
ha quc tquy nh ngi mua c ngha vphi giao hng ph hp vi phm
cht v m t trong hp ng. Trong trng hp hng c giao b khim
khuyt, y s l cs tnh ton liu ngi bn c vi phm cbn dn n
ngi mua c quyn hy hp ng. Hay hiu cch khc, skhng ph hp v
11Xem li iu 52 khon 2 Cng c Vin.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
31/81
23
phm cht v m t c nghim trng hoc gy hu qunghim trng n mc
cu thnh mt vi phm cbn khng?
Hy xem xt n lsau y:
Mt cng ty ca Vit Nam k hp ng nhp khu l hng gm 10 xeti qua sdng vi mt cng ty Hn Quc. Hp ng c k vo ngy 5
thng 5 nm 1996. Hp ng quy nh xe phi l xe ti gc v vic kim tra
phm cht do ngi bn tin hnh cng i. Tuy nhin, khi nhn hng vo ngy
2 thng 7 nm 1996, ngi mua pht hin thy c du hiu khim khuyt xe v
nghi ngy l cc xe chkhch c tho bghngi. Do ngi mua
cho thc hin gim nh v nhn c kt lun cc xe u l xe chkhch t7
n 12 ch v c l trn sn xe. Ngi mua gi khiu ni cho ngi bn
nhng ngi bn khng a ra nghsa cha hoc giao hng thay th. Nh
vy, trong trng hp ny theo iu 35 khon 1 CISG ngi bn Hn Quc vi
phm ngha vgiao hng ph hp vi phm cht v m ttrong hp ng.
Vn y l vi phm ca ngi bn liu l vi phm cbn? C mt
sim cbn cn lu nhsau:
Thnht, ngi bn giao mt loi hng khc hn vi chng loi m
ngi mua yu cu v hng ha ny chc chn khng p ng smong mun
ca ngi mua vbt ckha cnh g (yu cu cht lng, mc ch sdng).
Tuy nhin, ngi bn vn tin hnh kim tra phm cht v tin hng giao hng
m khng gp trngi g mc d skhng ph hp tn ti ton bhng ha v
d dng pht hin bi mt thng. Do vy, c du hiu bt thng trong qu
trnh cp giy kim tra phm cht. Nhvy, c thkt lun c ngi bn c
hnh vi vi phm v chnh hnh vi vi phm dn n vic ngi mua nhnc nhng hng ha khim khuyt vi hp ng. C thngay tu ngi bn
khng c khnng hoc khng c nh giao hng ph hp vi hp ng.
Th hai, khi ngi bn khiu ni vi ngi mua v s khng ph hp,
ngi mua khng a ra nghsa cha hoc giao hng thay th. Do , c
thsuy lun ngi bn khng c khnng hoc khng c nh khi phc s
ph hp ca hng ha.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
32/81
24
Tcc im trn, ta c thkt lun ngi bn khng c khnng thc
hin hp ng v do ngi mua khng th thu c bt c li ch no m
ngi mua mong mun vo lc k hp ng. Do , vi phm ca ngi bn l vi
phm cbn. V trong trng hp ny ngi mua c quyn p dng ch tihy hp ng.
Nhvy, n l trn skhim khuyt ca hng cu thnh mt vi
phm c bn v tr thnh c s p dng ch ti hy hp ng. Tuy nhin,
khng phi bao giskhng ph hp ca hng ha vphm cht v m ttheo
hp ng cng cu thnh mt vi phm cbn. Nu skhng ph hp chdin ra
mt phm vi khng ng k v ngi bn vn c kh nng sa cha khim
khuyt cng nhkhc phc hu qumt cch hp l th vi phm ca ngi bn
cha n mc bxem l vi phm cbn. Bn cnh , cng c nhng trng hp
khim khuyt v phm cht v m t xut hin do qu trnh vn chuyn, bc
d hoc l li n t, vic xc nh vi phm c bn cng tr nn kh khn.
Chnh v vy, khng phi bao gingi mua cng c quyn hy hp ng trong
trng hp hng ha khng ph hp vi phm cht v m ttheo hp ng.
2.1.1.2. Hng ho khng ph hp vbao b, ng gi v bo qun
Vvn ny, Cng c Vin nm 1980 quy nh hng ha c giao
phi m bo vbao b, ng gi v bo qun nh quy nh trong hp ng12
hoc theo cch thng thng hoc thch hp m hng ha cng loi c ng
gi v bo qun13nu hp ng khng c quy nh g. Tuy nhin, khng ging
nhcc tiu ch vphm cht v m t, skhng ph hp vbao b, ng gi
hoc bo qun hu nhkhng a ra mt khng nh chc chn vvic hng ha
c khim khuyt v khim khuyt (nu c) c nghim trng hay khng. Do ,nu chda trn khim khuyt vbao b, ng gi hoc bo qun th khng th
khng nh c ngi bn gy ra vi phm cbn hay cha. Mun xc nh
c tnh nghim trng ca thit hi, cc bn cn tin hnh nhng kim tra trc
tip v chuyn su hn vtnh trng thc tca hng trong mt thi gian hp l.
12iu 35 khon 1 Cng c Vin13iu 35 khon 2 im d Cng c Vin
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
33/81
25
Tuy nhin, n lCISG ghi nhn nhng trng hp m khim khuyt bao
b, ng gi hay bo qun hng ha c thl vi phm cbn v dn n ngi
mua c quyn hy hp ng.
Nu khim khuyt bao b, ng gi hay bo qun sgy ra hu qutrctip v chc chn cho hng. V dnhit bo qun khng thch hp khin hng
ha bbin cht, xe t nguyn chic bva p dn n bin dng hhi nhiu
ch. Nu nhng khim khuyt nghim trng v hu nh khng c kh
nng khc phc, ngi mua hon ton c quyn hy hp ng.
ng thi, nhng khim khuyt ny xy ra l do mt hnh vi vi phm ca
ngi bn (cung cp bao b, ng gi hay bo qun khng ng cch, thu tu
khng m bo cht lng dn n hng bhhi, tn tht trong qu trnh vn
chuyn), ngi bn sbxem l gy ra vi phm cbn do ngi mua c th
hy hp ng.
Ngoi ra, trong trng hp hng ha c mua vbn li ngay lp tc,
ngi mua phi m bo hng ha tnh trng hon ho ti thiu phn bao b,
ng gi hay bo qun c thbn li cho bn khc. Hay ni cch khc nu
hng ha khng ph hp vbao b, ng gi hay bo qun, hng ha sbxem l
khng ph hp vi mc ch sdng ca ngi mua. Trng hp ny sc
phn tch mc 2.1.1.3 tip sau.
2.1.1.3. Hng ho khng ph hp vi mc ch sdng
Theo tinh thn ca Cng c Vin nm 1980 cng nhchth44/99/EC,
tnh ph hp vi mc ch sdng c xem l mt trong nhng tiu ch ngm
hiu v cht lng hng ha. Do , yu tny sc p dng trong trng
hp cc quy nh vslng, phm cht, m tv ng gi, bo qun khng choc khng r rng. Hay hiu cch khc, khi hng ha c giao c khim
khuyt nhng khng c quy nh cthtrong hp ng, cc bn sda vo mc
hng khng ph hp vi mc ch s dng xc nh xem vi phm ca
ngi bn c phi l vi phm cbn hay cha.
Nh phn tch mc 1.3.1.3 ca kha lun ny, skhng ph hp vi
mc ch sdng c hiu l khng thch hp cho cc mc ch sdng m
hng ha cng loi (cng m t) vn thng p ng (fit for ordinary use); hoc
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
34/81
26
khng ph hp vi bt cmc ch sdng c thno m ngi bn c
bit mt cch r rng hay ng vo thi im giao kt hp ng (fit for
particular purposes). Theo , CISG quy nh:
2. Trnhng trng hp cc bn c tha thun khc, hng ha bcoi lkhng ph hp vi hp ng nu:
a. Hng ha khng thch hp cho cc mc ch sdng m cc hng ha
cng loi vn thng p ng.
b. Hng khng thch hp cho bt kmc ch cthno m ngi bn
trc tip hoc gin tip bit c vo lc giao kt hp ng, trtrng hp nu
cn cvo cc hon cnh cthc ththy rng ngi mua khng tnh n
nng lc hay snh gi ca ngi bn hoc nu i vi h lm nh th l
khng hp l.
Trng hp hng ha khng thch hp cho cc mc ch sdng m cc
hng ha cng loi vn thng p ng theo im a khon 2 iu 35.
trng hp ny, bi v cht lng hng ha c so snh vi cht lng
ca hng ha cng loi/m t. Theo , vn t ra y l cht lng hng
ha c nh gi da theo tiu chun v cht lng hng ha cng loi ca
nc ngi bn hay nc ngi mua? Trong cc vvic thuc khun khCng
c, cquan gii quyt tranh chp thng ly cc tiu chun hoc cc quy nh
ca nc ngi bn vhng ha cng loi xem xt liu hng ha c giao
ph hp hay cha.
Mt tranh chp xy ra gia ngi bn Chu u v ngi mua M
vhp ng mua bn xng dnh cho t, a im giao l Rotterdam H Lan.
Loi xng tlu c sdng chu u l loi xng pha ch trong khi xngc sdng Mli l loi khng ch. V th, ngi bn giao hng l xng
c pha ch tri vi hiu bit v mong mun ca ngi mua l loi xng khng ch
(mc d khng c quy nh c thno trong hp ng vvic xng c ch hay
khng ch). Do , y, p dng iu 35 khon 2 im a CISG v tiu chun
hng ha nc ngi mua, hng vn bxem l khng ph hp vi mc ch s
dng thng thng ca hng ha cng loi. Tuy nhin, v tlu thtrng chu
u vn sdng xng pha ch v a im giao hng li l mt ni thuc chu u
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
35/81
27
nn ngi bn c xem l khng c iu kin bit hoc suy on nhu cu
chnh xc ca ngi mua. Do y ngi bn khng bxem l gy ra vi
phm cbn.
Mt vn khc c t ra khi p dng iu 35 khon 2 im a l liumc cht lng no mi c chp nhn. Nhiu nh nghin cu Cng c
cho rng iu 35 khon 2 im a c hiu hng ha c giao phi c cht
lng trung bnh xt trn mt bng cc hng ha cng m t. Ngoi ra, cng c
mt s kin cho rng hng ha c giao c thl hng ha p ng cc yu t
phm cht mc ti thiu min vn p ng mc ch sdng ca ngi mua.
Tuy nhin, ni chung ta n hay trng ti snh gi tnh ph hp vi mc ch
sdng ca hng cng loi da trn mong mun hoc hiu bit ca mt ngi
thng thng a vngi mua i vi cng nng ca loi hng . Theo ,
nu cht lng hng ha c giao hon ton khc xa vi mc cht lng m
ngi mua mong mun v do lm mt i nhng li ch m ngi mua chi
theo iu 25 CISG, ngi bn c thbxem l gy ra vi phm cbn.
Mt tranh chp lin quan n vn tng pht sinh gia ngi bn H
Lan v ngi mua o vmt hng c ng lnh.14Sau khi xem xt mu do bn
H Lan cung cp, ngi mua k hp ng v giao hng cho ngi sdng
Latvia. Tuy nhin, ngi sdng pht hin c thuc ma nh bt nm trc
v Latvia c quy nh cm nhp c nh bt trn 6 thng nn ngi sdng
trli ton bshng cho ngi mua. Trong trng hp ny, ngi bn bkt
lun vi phm ngha vgiao hng ph hp theo iu 35 khon 2 im a. Mc
d th trng H Lan vn tn ti c ng lnh tma nh bt nm trc ln
nm nay, cquan gii quyt tranh chp y l ta n o lp lun rng ivi mt ngi mua hoc ngi sdng thng thng c ng lnh thng c
hiu l c thuc ma nh bt ngay trong nm . Do , nu bqua cc tnh tit
khc, ngi bn bxem gy ra vi phm cbn dn n ngi mua c thp dng
chti hy hp ng.
14Tranh chp s447 (20030227) tihttp://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/030227a3.html
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
36/81
28
Trng hp hng ha khng ph hp vi bt cmc ch sdng cth
no m ngi bn c bit mt cch r rng hay ng vo thi im giao
kt hp ng theo iu 35 khon 2 im b
Tiu ch ti im b khon 2 iu 35 thng c p dng trong cc trnghp: hng ha c bit, c o v khng phbin trn thtrng; hng ha m
ngi mua thng thng khng c hiu bit hoc khng c cung cp r rng
cc tiu ch vphm cht, m t Tuy nhin ngi bn phi c ngi mua
thhin mt cch r rng hoc ng v nh sdng loi hng ha v do
hng c chn l da trn shiu bit hoc phn on mt cch hp l ca
ngi mua. V d: i vi cc hng ha c thit kring, cu to phc tp, hm
lng khoa hc kthut cao Trong trng hp ngi bn bit n mc ch
s dng c th ca ngi mua v c ngi mua tin tng cung cp hng,
ngi bn sb coi l gy ra vi phm nu giao hng khng ph hp. Nu tnh
cht vi phm nghim trng, vi phm sbxem l vi phm cbn v hp
ng c thsbhy.
V dnhtranh chp din ra gia ngi mua Thy Sv ngi bn
vhp ng mua bn b tr chi dnh cho trem lp t trong cng vin gii
tr.15B tr chi c dnh s cho bn thba thu. Su ngy sau khi hng
c giao, ngi mua tuyn bhy hp ng v hai l do: thnht, slng v
lp rp cc tr chi khng ging nhtha thun trong hp ng; thhai, hng c
du hiu khng m bo an ton (khng c giy chng nhn an ton, c b
long)
Trong trng hp ny, sau khi tin hnh gim nh, c quan gii quyt
tranh chp y l mt ta n Thy S kt lun: thnht, hng ha cgiao khng ph hp vi tha thun trong hp ng (theo iu 35 khon 2 im
a); thhai, hng ha c giao khng m bo an ton do dn n khng m
bo ph hp vi mc ch sdng cthca ngi mua (theo iu 35 khon 2
im b). Kt lun theo im b c gii thch bi v hng ha c tiu dng v
mc ch thng mi v c sdng ti ni cng cng, tnh m bo an ton
15Tranh chp sOA.2000.459 (20070419) tihttp://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/070419s1.html
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
37/81
29
c xem l mt tha thun ngm hiu ca hai bn vcht lng. V bn cnh
, btr chi lp t trong cng vin gii tr ca ngi bn cng khng p ng
cc quy nh php lut vm bo an ton ca nc ngi mua16. Chnh vi phm
lin quan n tnh an ton ca tr chi ny khin cho ngi mua khng ththc hin c mc ch thng mi ca mnh - y l thu li nhun tvic
cho bn thba thu. Tnh trng ny khin ngi mua mt i mt cch ng k
cc li ch m hmong mun thu c trn cshp ng. Do , vi phm ca
ngi bn c kt lun l vi phm cbn v ngi mua c quyn hy hp
ng.
Slin quan gia im a v im b ca khon 2 iu 35 Cng c Vin
iu 35 khon 2 im b c xem l mt smrng so vi im a trong
vic bo vnhng li ch m ngi mua nhn c tvic giao kt v thc hin
hp ng. CISG gii thch rng mc d hng ha vn thch hp cho mc ch ca
cc loi hng ha thng dng, hng ha vn c khnng khng ph hp vi
mc ch s dng c th ca ngi mua. Do , khi xem xt vi phm, ta n
hoc trng ti thng u tin p dng im b (ph hp vi mc ch sdng c
th) so vi im a (ph hp vi mc ch sdng ca hng cng loi). V d:
Mt ngi mua mun mua thc n cho mt loi ch cnh qu him v kn n.
Ngi mua tin tng nh ngi bn cung cp loi thc n ph hp. Tuy
nhin, loi thc n ngi bn giao li gy hi cho loi ch mc d loi thc n
ny c dng bnh thng cho hu ht nhng loi ch cnh khc. Nu p dng
khon a, ngi bn skhng bxem l gy ra vi phm v do khng phi chu
bt ctrch nhim no. Tuy nhin, bi v ngi mua tin tng vo khnng
v hiu bit ca ngi bn trong vic cung cp loi thc n ph hp, do ngibn b giao hng khng ph hp theo im b khon 2 iu 35.
S lin quan gia tnh ph hp iu 35 khon 2 im a, b v iu 35
khon 1
iu 35 khon 2 ni chung v im a,b ni ring thng c dng trong
trng hp khi hp ng khng c quy nh r rng v phm cht, m t hay
16Lut lin bang vm bo an ton trong lp t v thit bkthut ca Thy S(Federal Law of 19 March 1976 on the safety of technical installations and equipments)
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
38/81
30
ng gi, bo qun hng ha. Tuy nhin, cng c trng hp hng ha c giao
p ng cc tiu ch vmc ch sdng theo khon 2 im a,b nhng khng
ph hp vi quy cch hoc m ttrong hp ng theo khon 1. y, hng ha
c hiu l hng thay thkhc chng loi (aliud). Vy th liu ngi bn c bxem l vi phm ngha v giao hng ng m t trong hp ng khng? Vi
trng hp ny, CISG thin vquan im d cung cp hay c khnng cung cp
hng thay thnhng khc chng loi, ngi bn vn bxem l vi phm ngha v
hoc khng khnng thc hin ngha v[Nagy 2007, trang 12, on 2]
2.1.1.4. Hng ho khng c cc tnh cht ca hng mu
iu 35 khon 2 im c Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng hng ha
mua bn quc tquy nh:Trnhng trng hp cc bn c tha thun khc,
hng ha b coi l khng ph hp vi hp ng nu: Hng khng c cc tnh
cht ca hng mu m ngi bn cung cp cho ngi mua.Ngi bn sb
xem l vi phm nu giao hng khng c cc tnh cht ca hng mu m ngi
bn cung cp cho ngi mua trc . Trong trng hp hng ha c giao
khc bit ng kvi hng mu v gy ra thit hi nghim trng cho ngi mua,
ngi bn bxem l gy ra vi phm cbn v do ngi mua c quyn hy
hp ng.
Mt trong nhng n lin hnh trong trng hp ny l tranh chp gia
cng ty Rotorex ca Mv cng ty Delchi ca vhp ng mua bn my nn
kh.17 Nhng my ny sc s dng sn xut my iu ha khng kh.
Trc khi thc hin hp ng, ngi bn Rotorex gi cho ngi mua Delchi
mt my nn mu km theo mt bn thng sk thut. Tuy vy, sau khi hng
c giao, ngi mua pht hin 93% my nn kh c khnng lm lnh thp hnv tiu thnng lng nhiu hn so vi mu v so vi thng sk thut. Sau
nhng n lc khng thnh cng ca ngi mua khc phc cc li k thut
ny, ngi mua yu cu ngi bn giao hng thay th. Ngi bn tchi. Ngi
mua tuyn bhy hp ng v i ngi bn bi thng thit hi.
17Tranh chp s88-CV-1078 19940909 xem tihttp://cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/940909u1.html
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
39/81
31
Ta n xc nh hnh ng hy hp ng ca ngi mua l hp l.
y, my nn kh khng ph hp vi quy cch do cng sut lm mt thp v tiu
thnhiu nng lng. M cng sut lm mt v khnng tiu thnng lng l
nhng yu t c bn to nn gi tr ca mt chic my nn kh. Vi phm nykhin cho ngi mua khng thc hin c mc ch ca mnh l sn xut ra
nhng chic iu ho t tiu chun, tiu thc trn th trng. Do n
c coi l mt vi phm cbn theo iu 25 CISG (theo Nguyn Minh Hng
2010). y, ngi mua c quyn hy hp ng theo iu 49.
Mt vn t ra l nu hng ha c cc tnh cht ca hng mu (iu 35
khon 2 im a) nhng khng thch hp cho cc mc ch sdng thng thng
m cc hng ha cng loi vn thng p ng (iu 35 khon 2 im c) th s
xl thno? Cung cp hng mu c xem l mt tha thun vcch m t,
nhn din hng ha v c ngha phn nh cht lng cng nhmc ch s
dng thng thng ca hng ha. Tuy nhin khng phi bao gisphn nh
cng chnh xc v ph hp vi mong mun ca ngi mua. Nu ngi mua vn
tin hnh giao kt hp ng bt chp vic nhn thc c skhng tng ng
hng mu v cht lng cng nhmc ch sdng thng thng ca hng ha,
ngi bn skhng bxem l gy ra vi phm (theo im c). Ngc li, nu ngi
mua khng c khnng nhn thc c skhng tng ng , ngi bn s
phi chu trch nhim vi skhng ph hp ca hng ha (theo im a). Quay
li n lvmt hng c ng lnh phn 2.1.1.3, chi tit c thuc ma nh bt
nm trc khng c ngi bn tit l cho ngi mua. Do , mc d c
ng lnh c giao p ng tiu ch l c cc tnh cht ca hng mu, ta n
da trn skhng ph hp vi mc ch sdng thng thng theo iu 35khon 2 im b v kt lun ngi bn gy ra vi phm.
2.1.2. Trng hp khng thkhi phc tnh ph hp ca hng ha
trong khong thi gian m ngi mua gia hn thm hoc thi hn m
ngi bn yu cu ngi mua gia hn thm.
Tnh ph hp ca hng ha c thc khi phc bng cch sa cha cc
h tn, khim khuyt hoc giao hng thay th. Cc bin php khi phc ny
khng lm mt i cc quyn khc ca ngi mua nhpht bi thng thit hi
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
40/81
32
v chc p dng nu khng gy ra cc chi ph hay chm trv l cho cc
bn.
Cc bin php khi phc ny c tin hnh trong mt thi hn m ngi
bn c ngi mua gia hn thm theo iu 47 khon 1. CISG c quy nh vitng bin php nhsau:
- Quyn ca ngi mua: iu 46 khon 2, 3 cho php ngi mua yu cu
ngi bn phi loi tr s khng ph hp (sa cha khim khuyt) hoc giao
hng thay thnu skhng ph hp to thnh mt svi phm cbn hp
ng. Vic yu cu sa cha hay thay thphi c gi i cng mt lc vi vic
thng bo skhng ph hp chiu theo iu 39 hoc trong mt thi hn hp l
sau .
- Quyn ca ngi bn: iu 48 a ra bin php loi tr cc thiu st
trong thc hin ngha v(bao gm cvic khi phc tnh ph hp ca hng ha)
nhmt quyn ca ngi bn. Tuy nhin, quyn ny chc p dng khi ngi
mua ng .
1. Vi iu kin tun thquy nh ca iu 49, ngi bn c th, ngay c
sau khi ht thi hn giao hng, loi trmi thiu st trong vic thc hin ngha
vca mnh, ph tn do ngi bn chu, vi iu kin l iu khng ko theo
mt schm trv l v khng gy ra cho ngi mua nhng trngi phi l hay
skhng chc chn vvic ngi bn hon trcc ph tn m ngi mua gnh
chu. Tuy nhin, ngi mua vn c quyn i bi thng thit hi chiu theo
Cng c ny.
2. Nu ngi bn yu cu ngi mua cho bit l ngi mua c chp nhn
vic loi trthiu st ni trn ca ngi bn hay khng v nu ngi mua khngp ng yu cu ny ca ngi bn trong mt thi hn hp l, th ngi bn c
thloi trthiu st trong phm vi thi hn m ngi bn ghi trong n
yu cu. Ngi mua khng th, trc khi ht thi hn y, sdng bt cbin
php bo hphp l no khng thch hp cho vic thi hnh ngha vca ngi
bn.
ng thi, iu 51 khon 1 cng cho php ngi bn giao hng thay th
trong trng hp mt phn hng ha khng ph hp vi hp ng.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
41/81
33
1. Nu ngi bn chgiao mt phn hng ha hoc nu chmt phn
hng ha giao ph hp vi hp ng th cc iu 46 n 50 sc p dng
i vi phn hng ha thiu hoc phn hng khng ph hp vi hp ng.
2. Ngi mua chc tuyn bhy bton bhp ng, nu vic khngthc hin hp ng hoc mt phn hng giao khng ph hp vi hp ng cu
thnh mt svi phm cbn hp ng.
Cn lu , CISG quy nh khi phn hng khng ph hp cu thnh mt vi
phm cbn th ngi mua c php la chn gia tuyn bhy (theo iu 51
khon 1) hoc yu cu giao hng thay th(theo iu 46 khon 2, 3).
Mc d CISG cho php thc hin cc bin php khi phc tnh ph hp
ca hng ha. Tuy nhin trn thc t, c thngi bn hon ton khng kh
nng khi phc sph hp hng ha hoc nu khi phc sgy ra nhng ph tn
v l hoc schm trkhng ng c cho cc bn. Do , khng phi bao gi
ngi bn cng m bo giao hng ph hp vi hp ng trong thi hn gia hn
thm ti iu 47. Trong trng hp ny, ngi bn sbxem l gy ra vi phm
c bn v ngi mua c php p dng ch ti hy hp ng theo iu 49
khon 1, iu 51 khon 2 v trong mt thi hn hp l theo iu 49 khon 2 im
b(ii) v (iii).18
Hy xt tranh chp sau thy r hn vic p dng hy hp ng do
ngi mua khng khnng thc hin cc bin php khi phc tnh ph hp
ca hng ha: Mt ngi bn c v ngi mua tin hnh mua bn phn mm.19
Tuy nhin, CD-Rom m ngi bn cung cp khng c y cc m un s
dng phn mm. Ngi mua khiu ni vskhng ph hp ca hng ha vi
ngi bn. Tuy nhin ngi bn vn khng thcung cp c cc m un cnthit bi v ngi mua chcn mt loi m un c bit sdng phn mm
ny ti o v loi m un ny vn cha c to ra. Ta n kt lun ngi
bn c gy ra vi phm cbn do ngi bn khng khnng khi phc tnh
ph hp ca hng ha dn n lm mt i nhng li ch m ngi mua mong
18Xem gii thch vthi hn thng bo hy hp ng ti mc 2.2.2 kha lun ny
19Xem tranh chp s5 Ob 45/05m (20050621) tihttp://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=1047&step=Abstract
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
42/81
34
mun c c. Do , trong trng hp ny, ngi mua c p dng quyn hy
hp ng theo iu 49 khon 1.
2.2. Mt sgii hn vquyn huhp ng ca ngi mua do hng ho
khng ph hp vi hp ngKhi nghi nghng ha c du hiu khng ph hp, ngi mua phi tin
hnh cc bin php kp thi xc nh xem ngi bn c gy ra vi phm khng
v dn n ngi mua c quyn p dng cc bin php theo iu 45, trong
c chti hy hp ng. Theo , Cng c Vin nm 1980 quy nh vtrch
nhim ca ngi mua khi pht hin hng ha c du hiu khng ph hp vi hp
ng. Khng thc hin hoc thc hin khng kp thi cc trch nhim ny sdn
n vic ngi mua bmt quyn hy hp ng.
2.2.1. Trng hp ngi mua khng khiu ni hoc khng kp thi
khiu ni vskhng ph hp ca hng ha.
Khi pht hin ra hng ha khng ph hp, ngi mua phi tin hnh thng
bo hay khiu ni vskhng ph hp ca hp ng n ngi bn. Vic khiu
ni kp thi s tr thnh csngi mua sdng cc quyn ca mnh theo
iu 45 Cng c. Tuy nhin, khiu ni hp l v hp php, ngi mua phi
m bo cskhiu ni l bin bn gim nh chng nhn hng ha khng ph
hp, cung cp y nhng chi tit v s khng ph hp ca hng cng nh
nhng yu cu khc ng cch v kp thi. Nu khng m bo c cskhiu
ni, ni dung v hnh thc khiu ni cng nhthi hn khiu ni, ngi mua s
mt i quyn hy hp ng ca mnh trong trng hp hng ha khng ph hp
cu thnh mt vi phm cbn.
2.2.1.1. Cskhiu ni bin bn gim nh cht lng hng haTrc ht, vic kim tra hng ha phi c thc hin ng cch thc v
m bo tnh khch quan.
Nhvy, vn thnht cn cn ch trng y l cch thc kim tra.
Cch thc kim tra hng ha phthuc vo nhiu yu tnhloi hng, slng,
tnh trng bao gi Trng hp bin bn gim nh c lp bi mt bn khng
trnh chuyn mn hoc kthut, csvt cht tin hnh cc bin php
kim tra thch hp vi hng, bin bn gim nh smt i tnh chnh xc v do
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
43/81
35
khng th tr thnh cshp php ngi mua tin hnh khiu ni hoc
bng chng c quan gii quyt tranh chp xc nh tnh ph hp ca hng
ha.
Xt tranh chp din ra gia ngi bn c trs v ngi mua c trsH Lan vhp ng mua bn pho mt.20Mt thi gian ngn sau khi hng
c giao, ngi mua gi khiu ni cho ngi bn vskhng ph hp ca ph
mt vi hp ng. Tuy nhin, ngi mua khng chdn thm vni dung khim
khuyt cthy l pho mt bnhim khun. Ngi bn yu cu ngi mua
thanh ton tin hng cn ngi mua H Lan yu cu phi gim tin hng do hng
khng ph hp vi hp ng. Cquan gii quyt tranh chp l mt ta n ca H
Lan pht hin ngi mua chkim tra cht lng ph mt bng cch kho st
bng mt thng. Ta n cho rng l do hng c giao trng thi ng lnh l
khng c s cho vic ngi mua khng thc hin cc kim tra chuyn su
hn. V ng l ngi mua phi thc hin r ng mt vi mu tin hnh
kim tra. ng thi, ngi mua khng chng minh c ngi bn bit hoc
khng thkhng bit n vic pho mt bnhim khun vo lc ng lnh ph
mt. Do , yu cu ca ngi mua bbc bv ngi mua phi thc hin thanh
ton y cho ngi bn.
Ngoi ra bin bn gim nh cng phi m bo tnh khch quan. Trong
trng hp nu bin bn gim nh c du hiu khng khch quan trong nh gi
ca bn gim nh, bin bn gim nh kh tr thnh c sngi mua tin
hnh khiu ni v c bit l bng chng ng tin cy cquan gii quyt tranh
chp xc nh hng ha c ph hp hay khng. Do c yu t ch ca con ngi,
vic chng minh skhng khch quan ca bin bn gim nh kh khn hn sovi chng minh cch thc kim tra khng ph hp.
Thhai, vic kim tra cht lng hng ha phi c tin hnh trong mt
thi hn hp l. iu 38 khon 1 Cng c Vin nm 1980 quy nh: Ngi
mua phi kim tra hng ha hoc bo m c skim tra hng ha trong mt
thi hn ngn nht m thc tc thlm c tu tnh hung c th. Nh
20Tranh chp s900336 (19911219) xem tihttp://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=34&step=Abstract
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
44/81
36
gii thch ti mc 1.3.4.1, vic kim tra cht lng phi thc hin trong mt thi
hn ph hp y c hiu l thi hn hp l v khng chm trtrnh vic
hng ha bhhi, tn tht sau khi hng c giao, hoc ti thi im sm nht
ngi mua c kh nng tip cn c vi hng thc hin gim nh chtlng. Theo , Cng c Vin quy nh cc thi im c xem l thi im
hp l ngi mua tin hnh kim tra: ngay khi nhn c hng i vi hp
ng c chuyn ch (vic chuyn ch do bn th ba tin hnh)21; ngay ti a
im n mi sau khi hng bi trong qu trnh vn chuyn (redirection) hoc
hng c ngi mua gi i tip (redispatch) trong trng hp ngi mua khng
c khnng kim tra v ngi bn bit hoc c thlng trc c sthay
thi .22 Do , i vi nhng hng ha c hn s dng ngn v d b nh
hng bi cc yu t l ha bn ngoi nh lng thc, thc phm, nu ngi
mua khng tin hnh kim tra cht lng hng ha trong mt thi hn hp l,
bin bn gim nh ca ngi mua skh c thtrthnh cn cngi bn
khiu ni hoc cquan gii quyt tranh chp xc nh sph hp ca hng ha.
Xt tranh chp din ra gia ngi mua c v ngi bn Php v hp
ng mua bn cnh ca. Ca c sn xut hng lot. Hai thng sau khi chuyn
hng cui cng c giao, ngi mua khiu ni vi ngi bn vvic hng c
khim khuyt. Tuy nhin ngi bn khng chp nhn v cho rng qu thi hn
khiu ni. Sau , ngi bn khi kin ngi mua v khng thanh ton tin
hng.
Cquan gii quyt tranh chp l mt ta n ca c pht hin ngi
mua tin hnh vic kim tra phm cht hng ha qu mun. Ta n gii thch
rng mc d ngi mua bn li sca, ngi mua vn khng c min khitrch nhim kim tra cht lng ca trphi ngi mua l mt trung gian thun
ty hoc hng c giao thng cho ngi tiu dng cui cng. Do ngi bn
khng thbit trc hoc suy on c ngi mua sbn li shng , ngi
mua khng c min tr trch nhim theo iu 38 khon 3 Cng c Vin.
Ngoi ra, vic ca c bc li khng thl l do khin ngi mua khng thc
21iu 38 khon 2 Cng c Vin22iu 38 khon 3 Cng c Vin
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
45/81
37
hin vic gim nh cht lng hng ha. Chcn mmt sca mu l ngi
mua c thxc nh c vic hng ha c bli do vic sn xut hay khng. Do
, vic tin hnh gim nh bxem l qu thi gian hp l v v vy ko theo
vic khiu ni qu mun dn n ngi mua bmt i quyn hy hp ng theoiu 49 khon 1.
2.2.1.2. Hnh thc v ni dung khiu ni
Tuy rng Cng c Vin nm 1980 vhp ng mua bn hng ha quc
t khng quy nh c thngi mua phi thng bo v s khng ph hp ca
hng ha thng qua phng tin no, bao gm nhng ni dung g. Tuy nhin,
nhiu nh nghin cu cng nhcquan gii quyt tranh chp a ra nhng lu
quan trng cho ngi mua vvic khiu ni.
Vhnh thc khiu ni, iu 27 CISG quy nh: Trphi trong Phn II
ca Cng c ny c quy nh g khc, trong trng hp mt thng bo, mt yu
cu hay mt thng tin khc c gi bi mt bn ca hp ng chiu theo
Cng c ny v bng mt phng tin thch hp vi hon cnh, th mt s
chm tr hoc lm ln trong vic chuyn giao thng tin hoc vic thng tin
khng n ngi nhn cng skhng lm bn mt quyn vin dn cc thng
tin ca mnh. Do , khiu ni ca ngi mua sc bo n ngi mua bng
bt c phng tin no thch hp vi hon cnh, c th l vn bn hoc bng
ming. Cc hc givCISG cho rng ti thiu phng tin phi l phng
tin m cc bn giao dch u sdng. ng thi, ngi mua phi m bo ch
dn c chnh xc ngy thng v ngi m mnh lin lc. Trong v tranh
chp vhp ng mua bn giy23, ta n cho rng, khiu ni qua in thoi ch
c chp nhn nu ngi mua chng minh c mnh lin lc vi ai vo lcno v khiu ni nhng ni dung g Bn cnh , ngi bn v ngi mua c
thttha thun vhnh thc khiu ni.
Vni dung khiu ni, mt khiu ni y phi nu c cc chi tit
lin quan khim khuyt nh tn, bn cht. Trong trng hp ngi mua khng
xc nh c y l loi khim khuyt g, ti thiu ngi mua cng phi m t
23Tranh chp s3/13 O 3/94 (19940713) tihttp://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=49&step=Abstract
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
46/81
38
c cc c im m khim khuyt thhin ra bn ngoi (symptoms). Ngi
mua nn sdng bin bn gim nh nhmt bng chng chng t s khng
ph hp ca hng. Bn cnh vic ch r khim khuyt, cc chuyn gia CISG
cng cho rng ngi bn nn chng a ra cc bin php c th x lkhim khuyt nhyu cu sa cha, yu cu giao hng thay th... Cc ni
dung trn khng c nu cthr rng slm mt i tnh hp l cho khiu ni,
ng thi kh trthnh mt bng chng chnh xc v ng tin cy gp phn
bo vquyn ca ngi bn theo iu 45. Quay li tranh chp vhp ng mua
bn pho mt ti mc 2.2.1.124, ni dung ca khiu ni khng r rng v cth
tr thnh du hiu u tin thhin ngi mua khng thc hin ngha vkim
tra cht lng hng ha v do dn n nhng bt li ca ngi mua khi phn
quyt c ban hnh.
2.2.1.3. Thi hn khiu ni
Cng c Vin nm 1980 quy nh hai trng hp khin ngi bn mt
quyn khiu ni ti iu 39:
1. Ngi mua bmt quyn khiu ni v vic hng ha khng ph hp
hp ng nu ngi mua khng thng bo cho ngi bn vskhng ph hp
trong mt thi hn hp l ktlc ngi mua pht hin hoc ng lra
phi pht hin ra skhng ph hp.
2. Trong mi trng hp, ngi mua bmt quyn khiu ni vvic hng
khng ph hp vi hp ng nu hkhng thng bo cho ngi bn bit vvic
chm nht trong thi hn 2 nm k tngy hng ha thc sc giao
cho ngi mua trphi thi hn ny tri ngc vi thi hn bo hnh quy nh
trong hp ng. trng hp ti khon 1, thi hn khiu ni c tnh bt u t lc
ngi mua pht hin ra hoc ng lphi pht hin c skhng ph hp.
Thi hn ra ti khon ny c slin quan mt thit ti thi hn kim tra cht
lng hng ha c quy nh ti iu 38 CISG. Theo tinh thn Cng c, vic
kim tra cht lng hay cha khng c tnh quyt nh vquyn khiu ni ca
24 Xem li tranh chp vPh mt ti mc 2.2.1.1, trang 39
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
47/81
39
ngi mua nhng l cscho vic tnh ton thi hn khiu ni. Thi hn khiu
ni c xc nh da trn thi im bt u v di ca thi hn.
Vthi im bt u tnh thi hn, c hai trng hp nhsau: Thnht,
nu hng ha biu hin khim khuyt ngay ti thi im giao hng, thi hnkhiu ni sc tnh tthi im ng lngi mua phi thc hin vic kim
tra cht lng hng ha nu ngi mua tin hnh mun hoc khng tin hnh;
nu ngi mua tin hnh kim tra cht lng trong mt hp l, thi hn khiu
ni sc tnh tthi im . Thhai, khim khuyt ca hng ha l li n t
hoc khng thc pht hin qua vic kim tra cht lng nhti iu 38, thi
hn khiu ni sc bt u tthi im ng lngi bn phi pht hin ra
khim khuyt ( v d: sau mt thi gian lu kho, sdng)
Vdi thi hn, cc chuyn gia cng nhcquan gii quyt tranh chp
u ng rng di ny phthuc vo nhiu yu tnhc im hng ha
(hng tiu ththeo ma, hng ha dhng), mc ch ca ngi mua i vi
hng v khnng ngi bn bit c mc ch . Theo , vi tng vvic th
s c mt di thi hn khiu ni ring. V d tranh chp lin quan n hp
ng mua bn phn mm in n gia ngi bn c v ngi mua o25, cquan
gii quyt tranh chp l mt ta n ca c cho rng thi hn hp l khiu ni
vskhng ph hp ca hng ha l mt ngy sau khi nhn c hng (do li
phn mm c thpht hin c ngay khi mi ci t v sdng) Nhiu ta n
hoc trng ti thng s dng thi hn trung bnh l 1 thng lm thi hn
khiu ni. Trong mt tranh chp khc lin quan n my sn xut giy26, ta n
li cho rng vic khiu ni tin hnh trong vng 1 thng tsau khi kim tra cht
lng my l hp l v do ngi mua khng bmt i cc quyn yu cu camnh. Trong mt tranh chp khc cng lin quan n my mc27, ngi mua
25Tranh chp s2 Ob 48/02a (20030227 ) tihttp://cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/961204g1.html26Tranh chp sVIII ZR 287/98 (19991103) tihttp://cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/991103g1.html
27Tranh chp s5 U 195/94 (19950821) tihttp://cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/950821g1.html
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
48/81
40
vt qua thi hn 1 thng v dn n khng thc hin c cc quyn ti iu
45.
Xt trng hp tip theo ti khon 2 iu 39, khon ny thng c p
dng cho cc khim khuyt tim n chpht sinh sau mt thi gian di c sdng. Bn cnh , khon 2 iu 39 cng c ngha nhmt sbo vngi
bn trc cc khiu ni gi n qu lu ktngy hng c giao. Thi hn ny
c tnh tngy ngi bn thc snhn c hng. Trong trng hp a im
nhn hng b thay i nhiu 38 khon 3, thi hn sc bt u t ngy
hng n a im mi.
Gii hn thi hn khiu ni ph thuc vo thi hn bo m trong hp
ng cng nhphp lut ca tng nc, c bit l nhng nc tham gia Cng
c ca Lin hip quc vthi hiu trong mua bn hng ha quc tnm 197428.
Theo , nu thi hn 2 nm c thbrt ngn hoc ko di ty theo quy nh
ca hp ng hoc php lut tng nc.Thi hn khiu ni ti khon 2 sc
p dng nu trong hp ng khng nhc g n thi hn bo m (guaranty
period CISG trnh sdng tbo hnh warranty) v thi hn 2 nm ny
khng phi l gii hn thi hn khiu ni.
2.2.2. Trng hp ngi mua mt quyn huhp ng do khng
thng bo kp thi.
Ngoi vic p ng cc iu kin ni dung nh phn tch ti 2.1, ngi
mua cn phi m bo mnh thng bo hy hp ng trong mt thi hn hp
l. Cng c a ra mt thi hn chung cho nhng trng hp hy hp ng
m khng phi do giao hng chm iu 49 khon 2 im b. Theo , thi hn
thng bo hy hp ng trng hp hng ha khng ph hp cng p dng theoquy nh ny. CISG a ra cc thi hn nhsau:
2. Tuy nhin trong trng hp nu ngi bn giao hng th ngi mua
smt quyn hy hp ng nu ngi mua khng tuyn bhy hp ng:
28Ting Anh l Convention on the Limitation Period in the International Sale of Goods.
Cng c c k kt vo thng 6 nm 1974 v sa i vo nm 1980 ph hp viCISG.
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
49/81
41
b. i vi cc trng hp vi phm khc trng hp giao hng chm tr,
trong mt thi hn hp l:
i. Ktlc ngi mua bit hay ng lphi bit vsvi phm ;
ii. Sau khi ht mi thi hn m ngi mua gia hn thm cho ngibn chiu theo khon 1 iu 47 hoc sau khi ngi bn tuyn brng hs
khng thc hin ngha v ca mnh trong thi hn c gia hn thm ;
hoc
iii. Sau khi ht mi thi hn bsung m ngi bn yu cu chiu
theo khon 2 iu 48 hay sau khi ngi mua tuyn bl hkhng chp nhn
cho ngi bn thc hin ngha v.
im b(i) ch ra rng ngi mua phi tuyn b k t lc ngi mua
bit hay ng lphi bit vsvi phm . Trong trng hp vi phm l v
tnh ph hp ca hng ha, phi phn bit gia thi hn hy hp ng v thi
hn khiu ni theo iu 39 ca hng ha. Theo , thi hn khiu ni ti iu 39
khon 1 bt u tkhi ngi bn pht hin ra hoc ng lpht hin ra khim
khuyt ca hng ha. V thi hn thng bo hy hp ng theo iu 49 khon 2
im b(i) c tnh tthi im m skhng ph hp ca hng ha nghim
trng n mc cu thnh mt vi phm cbn hoc khng thkhi phc c.
ng thi, im b(ii) v (iii) chra rng ngi mua c quyn tuyn b
hy hp ng trong trng hp ngi bn khng c khnng khi phc tnh ph
hp ca hng ha trong thi hn m ngi mua gia hn thm (theo khon 1 iu
47) hoc thi hn m ngi bn yu cu ngi mua gia hn thm (theo iu 48);
hoc vic khi phc gy ra nhng ph tn hoc chm trkhng ng c cho
cc bn. Thi hn ny thng c bt u tlc thi hn gia hn thm ca ccbin php sa cha chm dt.
Cng nhcc quy nh khc, thi hn thng bo hy hp ng ti iu
49 khon 2 im b c xc nh ty vo tng v vic c th. Trong mt v
tranh chp lin quan n hp ng mua bn my mc phc vcng nghip ti
chti nha gia ngi mua Ecuado v ngi bn Italy.29Sau khi pht hin c
29Tranh chp ngy 13/12/2011 tihttp://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=927&step=Abstract
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
50/81
42
my c khim khuyt, ngi mua yu cu ngi bn sa cha. Sau mt vi
ln sa cha, my vn khng th s dng c. 5 tun sau ln sa cha cui
cng, ngi mua tuyn b hy hp ng. Ta n cho rng vic ngi mua
tuyn bhy hp ng sau 5 tun ktngy sa cha my cui cng l vn nmtrong thi hn ph hp theo iu 49 khon 2 im b(ii). Do , ngi mua c
p dng chti hy hp ng cng cc bin php lin quan.
Tuy nhin, trong mt tranh chp khc gia ngi bn H Lan v ngi
mua c vhp ng mua bn chn dt acrylic.30Sau khi hng c giao, ngi
mua pht hin thiu mt 5 cun chn v bo vi ngi bn nhng khng thng
bo c th l loi chn kiu no. Do , ngi bn giao nhm thm 5 cun
chn loi khc. 8 tun sau , ngi bn tuyn bhy hp ng mc d ngi
bn nghgiao li hng ph hp. Trong trng hp ny, cquan gii quyt
tranh chp l ta n ca c cho rng ngi bn mt quyn tuyn bhy hp
ng theo iu 49 khon 2 im b(i). Ta n gii thch rng, thi gian 8 tun thc
hin cc hnh ng hp l i n quyt nh hy hp ng (xem xt, thng
lng gia 2 bn, xin tvn php l) l qu di. V bn cnh , ngi bn
nghc giao hng thay th. Do vy, ngi mua bmt quyn hy hp ng.
2.2.3. Khnng ngi bn gim gi hng hoc sa cha hng ho
hoc giao hng thay th
Chti hy hp ng c xem l bin php p dng cui cng trong mi
trng hp vi phm kcvi phm vgiao hng khng ph hp vi hp ng.
Do , trc khi quyt nh xem ngi mua c quyn p dng chti hy hp
ng hay khng, ta n v trng ti vn thng u tin xem xt cc bin php c
tnh phc hi khc. Cc bin php ny thc cht l vic bt buc ngi bn honthnh cc ngha v. Mc ch ca nhng bin php ny l m bo hp ng vn
c thc hin trn csmt i mt schi ph chi nht nh. Cc bin php
ny bao gm: khi phc tnh ph hp ca hng ha v gim gi hng.
2.2.3.1. Bin php khi phc tnh ph hp ca hng ha
30Tranh chp s2 U 31/96 (19970131) tihttp://cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/970131g1.html
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIANG- A2QTKD-K47-LUT KINH DOANH QUC T (1)
51/81
43
L bin php mang tnh phnh chti hy hp ng, nu tnh ph hp
ca hng ha cn c thkhi phc m khng khin cc bn phi chu cc ph tn
hoc chm trkhng ng c, ngi mua smt i quyn p dng ch ti hy
hp ng. khc phc cc khim khuyt ngi bn c thsa cha phn hngha khng ph hp hoc giao hng thay th.
Nhmc 2.1.2 phn tch, cc bin php ny c CISG nu ra di
dng quyn ca cc bn. Tuy nhin, trn thc t, cc ni dung ny mang tnh
gnh nng cho c2 bn. Theo , trong trng hp pht hin hng ha khng
ph hp vi hp ng, ngi bn c thchng a ra li nghkhc phc
cc khim khuyt cng nhnghngi mua gia hn thm mt thi gian hp l
ngi bn thc hin cc bin php khc phc. Bn cnh , ngi mua cng
phi to chi cho ngi bn thc hin vic khi phc tnh ph hp cng nh
gia hn thm thi gian hp l ngi bn hon thnh ngha vca mnh.
Trn thc tc rt nhiu tranh chp m ngi mua bmt quyn hy
hp ng do cquan gii quyt tranh chp pht hin ra ngi mua khng to
iu kin cho ngi bn p dng cc bin php mang tnh phc hi. Xt tranh
chp vhp ng mua bn vi dt gia ngi mua v ngi bn c.31Sau
khi hng c giao, ngi mua khiu ni vi khng m bo tnh ph hp nh
tha thun. Vi khng slng v khng ng csn xut vy v o.
Ngi bn gi mu vi mi v hi thm thng tin vquy cch sn xut vy v
o. Tuy nhin ngi mua tchi khng cung cp thm thng tin. Theo , c
quan gii quyt tranh chp l ta n ca c cho rng ngi mua khng c
quyn hy hp ng theo iu 49 khon 2 im b(ii) v (iii). Ta n gii thch
rng ngi mua khng to iu kin cho ngi bn thc hin cc quyn tiiu 48 cng nhkhng gia hn thm thi gian ngi bn phc hi tnh ph
hp ca hng ha theo iu 47.
2.2.3.2. Khnng gim gi hng
Ngoi trhy hp ng, gim gi hng c xem l bin php cui cng
v chp dng khi ngi bn khng ththc hin c vic khi phc tnh ph
31Tranh chp s6 O 107/98 (19980924) tihttp://cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/980924g1.html
-
7/22/2019 BCH TH HNG GIAN