An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on...
Transcript of An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on...
![Page 1: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
V. Andretta 1ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar observations
Vincenzo Andretta
INAF/Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte
Naples, Italy
![Page 2: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
V. Andretta 2ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Sources
A personal assessment, with material (and help...) from several sources, for instance:
– ARENA WG6 activities;
– Aristidi et al. (2009): TGL (Turbulent Ground Layer) properties;
Plus some info from:– Arnaud et al. (2009): SBM (Sky Brightness Monitor)
results.
![Page 3: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
V. Andretta 3ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
First things first: The seeing
DIMM data (Nice group):– Long data series (2003 → present)
– Taken at various heights above ground:● 3 m (ground level)● 8 m (Concordiastro platform)● 20 m (top of one of Concordia buildings)
– Results (in short): median seeing
@ 3 m @ 8 m
2.4" 1.7" Winter
0.95" 0.57" Summer
![Page 4: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
V. Andretta 4ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
First things first: The seeing
![Page 5: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
V. Andretta 5ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
What about solar elevation?
● Elevation <40° (z>50°);
![Page 6: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
V. Andretta 6ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
What about solar elevation?
● Elevation <40° (z>50°);● Duty cycle depends primarily on the miminum
acceptable elevation:
Min elev.: 15 deg.
Cou
rtes
y: C
. Den
ker
(AIP
)
![Page 7: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
V. Andretta 7ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
What about solar elevation?
DIMM measurements:– Canopus (α Car) → Zenith → Sun
– Model: one-parameter, scale-free Kolmogorov turbulence → ε ~ cos(z)^(-3/5):
![Page 8: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
V. Andretta 8ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
What about solar elevation?
![Page 9: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
V. Andretta 9ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Mimimum acceptable altitude
![Page 10: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
V. Andretta 10ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Comparison with other sites
However: These values are of little significance if not compared with other sites.
An example: The site chosen for the ATST (Advanced Technology Solar Telescope):
Haleakala, Hawaii
– Location: 20° 42' 17" N, 156° 10' 36" W
– Elevation: 3084 m
– Lake Area: None
– Distance to ocean: 11 km
– Estimated sunshine: 2800 hrs/year
![Page 11: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
V. Andretta 11ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Comparison with other sites
Goals set for the chosen site (from the ATST Site Survey Working Group Final Report, 2004):
● Clear daytime fraction of 70%, 3000 hours annual sunshine.
● 1800 annual hours with r0 (500 nm) > 7 cm (measured at the telescope aperture),
including at least 100 continuous 2-hr periods.
● 200 annual hours with r0 (500 nm) > 12 cm (measured at the telescope aperture)
including at least 10 continuous 4-hour periods.
● Large isoplanatic angle, i.e., good atmospheric conditions at high altitudes.
● 480 annual hours with a sky brightness less than or equal to 25 ± 10 millionths at 1.1 radii at 1 micron with a radial profile equal to or steeper than R-0.8, including at least 40 continuous 4-hour periods.
● 600 annual hours with the precipitable water vapor below 5 mm, including at least 40 continuous 4-hour periods.
![Page 12: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
V. Andretta 12ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Comparison with other sites
![Page 13: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
V. Andretta 13ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Comparison with other sites
Notes:– Best seeing in winter (October – February), and in
the morning (HA: -6 – -4 hrs) → z < 25°!
– And... at 28 m above ground...
![Page 14: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
V. Andretta 14ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
More on summer DIMM data
![Page 15: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
V. Andretta 15ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
The Turbulent Ground Layer
● The bulk contribution to seeing comes from the TGL
● Estimates of the thickness of the TGL:– (Winter) ~ 20 – 30 m
– (Summer) Up to 400 m?
● Above the TGL: – 0.36'' (possibly free-atmosphere seeing)
![Page 16: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
V. Andretta 16ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
The Turbulent Ground LayerT
rinquet et al. 2008 (SP
IE)
![Page 17: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
V. Andretta 17ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
A simple model
Assume:– Free-atmosphere seeing: ε=0.36'';
– A time-varying TGL, with ε=∞, practically;
– Telescope at height h above ground; h is such that instrument is above the TGL for 70% of the time;
– Cloud coverage probability of 15%.
![Page 18: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
V. Andretta 18ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
A simple model
Results:
![Page 19: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
V. Andretta 19ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
'Seeing' is not everything
● Isoplanatic angle, θ:– Degrades much more easily than seeing (θ ~
cos(z)^(8/5));
– Thus: θ may be not that good towards the Sun, even above the TGL;
– May seriously impact perspectives for AO (Adaptive Optics) systems.
![Page 20: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
V. Andretta 20ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
'Seeing' is not everything
● Isoplanatic angle, θ:
![Page 21: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
V. Andretta 21ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Sky brightness
● Very low, if first indications from SBM measurements are confirmed;
● Compared with other sites (again: Haleakala)...
![Page 22: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
V. Andretta 22ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Sky brightness
![Page 23: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
V. Andretta 23ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Science cases (examples)
● High angular resolution:– Long duration observations (compared to the
minutes/less than 1 hour in other sites);
– High duty cycle (can be as high as 700 hrs/year for r
0>10 cm);
– Small contamination from telluric absorption● High spatial/spectral resolution 2D spectroscopy →
atmospheric small-scale dynamics
![Page 24: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
V. Andretta 24ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Science cases (examples)
● Coronal observations:– Low sky brightness;
– Good/moderate seeing (even within TGL)
– Easy access to IR● high S/N line polarimetry → coronal magnetic fields
![Page 25: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
V. Andretta 25ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
About infrastuctures
● Small-size coronagraph, no AO;– Note: competitive even on a low-height platform
(e.g.: Concordiastro platform).
● Medium-size telescope with AO;– Note: high duty cicles comparable or greater than in
other sites, but only if telescope is placed fairly high above ground (above TGL, or almost...).
![Page 26: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
V. Andretta 26ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Still to be done
● A more quantitative characterization of the TGL:– Its time dependence (height, strength of turbulence);
● Answer for instance to a question: there are two reversal of the temperature gradient every day, in summer; only one of these reversal (at about 17 o'clock local time) corresponds to an actual dip on DIMM data.
● Dependence of seeing, isoplanatic angle, etc., with time, AT SOLAR ELEVATIONS ABOVE HORIZON.
![Page 27: An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar ... · V. Andretta ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009) 1 An assessment of the potential of Dome C for solar](https://reader034.fdocument.pub/reader034/viewer/2022051802/5aea2cce7f8b9a6d4f91af15/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
V. Andretta 27ARENA Workshop: Progresses on site testing (Nice, Dec. 2009)
Still to be done
● To convince the solar community (and Polar Agencies...) that Dome C is worth the effort.
– A possible strategy: to proceed with installing a small(-ish) telescope (a coronagraph?) for science and to show off site characteristics...
● Historically: already proposed – CASTEL project: INAF/OAC, 2001, but not good enough for PNRA nor for INAF...