Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
Transcript of Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 1/16
Alice ZapataP.A.D.
Río Negro
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 2/16
DEBATE
• Debate starts when two people have a
different opinion about the same idea.
• There are three types:
1) Value : X is better than Y
2) Policy : X should do Y
3) Fact : X is/was/will be true
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 3/16
Debate Terms
• Opinion is called the Proposition or
Resolution.
• .
• Negative Team.
• Judges.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 4/16
Reasons
• Everyone has opinions and these opinions
are based on REASONS.
•
1) Must logically support the opinion
2) Must be specific and state the idea clearly
3) Must be convincing to a majority of
people
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 5/16
• You also need:
- Manner
- Gestures
-
- Posture
- Voice
- Humor
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 6/16
Supporting your opinion
• EVIDENCE – is the concrete foundation.
• It can be in the form of: -
- an example
- statistics- the opinion of an expert
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 7/16
Debate Application:
Case Study
• Finding evidence to support your reasons
requires researching a variety of sources
includin :
- magazines
- books
- journals
- Internet, etc.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 8/16
Debate Focus:
Case Study
• Researching supports:
- Choose one set of opposite opinions
- Look for information in ma azine, news a ers,
books, on the internet or interview experts.
- Find at least 3 different reasons.
- Write Reason – Support sheets
• Remember : Include your sources.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 9/16
Organizing your opinion
• Our presentation must be organized in asystematic way.
• FIRST AFFIRMATIVE CONSTRUCTIVESPEECH or 1AC.
• It has three parts:
- Introduction.- Affirmative Points.
- Conclusion.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 10/16
Refuting Explanations
• Here we say why the opposing team’s pointis either not true or not important.
• Then we have in mind HOW to say therefutation.
• There are five steps: - signpost.
- rephrase.- negation & why.
- rationale.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 11/16
Debate Application:
Tennis Table• Round 1
– Teacher gives a resolution to the
Affirmative Team. - ey ave m nutes to:
brainstorm, make reasons and support.
- Write them and pass them to the
Negative Team.-The Negative Team has 3 minutes
to think about possible resolutions.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 12/16
• Round 2
- similar to round 1 but the Negative Team
without preparation has to answer.
• Round 3
- Both teams work without preparation.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 13/16
Challenging Supports:
Organizing your refutation
• The 1NC (First Negative Constructive) has
5 parts:
-
- Refutation
-Transition
- Negative Points
- Conclusion
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 14/16
Debating an Opinion
• REBUTTAL SPEECHES – they are used to
summarize the debate and wh our side
has won.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 15/16
How to Judge a Debate?
• Relax and follow your feelings.
• Compare the two teams in three areas:
- MATTER : refers to team’s lo ic andreasoning.
- MANNER : refers to team’s speaking style.
- METHOD : refers to team’s organization.
• Flow the debate (take notes).
• Fill in a judging form.
8/14/2019 Alice Zapata P.a.D. Río Negro
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/alice-zapata-pad-rio-negro 16/16
• Give points in a scale of 1 to 10.
• Give honest feedback. • on t ust say t ey won. xp a n y.