Akademik(Yükselmelerde( Sorunlu(Dergiler( - TR Dizin |...

h"p://www.la*mes.com/science/sciencenow/la-‐sci-‐sn-‐fake-‐open-‐access-‐journal-‐paper-‐20131003,0,7008664.story#axzz2lIYkskv0

Akademik Yükselmelerde Sorunlu Dergiler

Dr. Haydar Demirel Hace"epe Üniversitesi Spor Bilimleri Fakültesi ve

Tıp Fak. Spor Hekimliği Anabilim Dalı

Christophe Vorlet/ Los Angeles Times

Türkiye adresli yayınların sayısında yıllara bağlı ar[ş: 1996-‐2012

SCImago. (2007). SJR — SCImago Journal & Country Rank. Retrieved November 22, 2013, from hEp://www.scimagojr.com

Türkiye’nin makale sayısı açısından dünya sıralamasındaki yeri: 1996-‐2012

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

SCImago. (2007). SJR — SCImago Journal & Country Rank. Retrieved November 22, 2013, from hEp://www.scimagojr.com verilerine göre hesaplanmışPr

Türkiye adresli a[f almayan yayınların yüzdesi: 1996-‐2012


0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Makale başına a[f ve kendine a[f hariç a[flar: 1996-‐2012

SCImago. (2007). SJR — SCImago Journal & Country Rank. Retrieved November 22, 2013, from hEp://www.scimagojr.com

Türkiye adresli yayınlara yapılan kendine a[fların a[flara oranı: 1996-‐2012

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012


0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

İsviçre

Danimarka

Holland

a

ABD

İsveç

Finlandiya

Kanada

UK

Belçika

İsrail

Norveç

İran

Polonya

Türkiye

Hind

istan

Çin

Rusya

Ukrayna

4 9

32 34 36


Makale başı a[flarda Türkiye’nin yeri (100.000 üzeri makalesi olan 38 ülke içinde)

Türkiye’nin dünya sıralamasındaki yeri: 1996-‐2012


Makale sayısı H indeks Kendine A[f/ Toplam a[f

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Aynı ülkeden a[flarda Türkiye’nin önündeki ülkeler (aynı ülkeden a[flara göre sıralamaın ülkenin makale sayısına göre

sıralamanın önünde olduğu ülkelerin adı verilmiş*r)


8) PAKİSTAN 46*

9) UKRAYNA 38*

10) SIRBİSTAN 54*

11) TÜRKİYE 20*

1) ÇİN 2*

3) İRAN 17*

4) HİNDİSTAN 9*

5) BREZİLYA 15*

6) RUSYA 12*

*Ülkenin makale sırasındaki yeri

h"p://www.matema*kdunyasi.org/arsiv/PDF/12_02_69_75_ozturk.pdf

EEST EEST PART A EEST PART B FES SPECR EEST PART C EEST PART D

Journals

h"p://www.silascience.com/journals.aspx?id=2

VOLUMES: Volume (Issue) 28 (1), October 2011 Volume (Issue) 27 (2), July 2011 Volume (Issue) 27 (1), April 2011 Volume (Issue) 26 (2), January 2011 Volume (Issue) 26 (1), October 2010 Volume (Issue) 25 (1&2), April-‐July 2010 Volume (Issue) 24 (2), January 2010 Volume (Issue) 24 (1), October 2009 Volume (Issue) 23 (1&2), April-‐July 2009 Volume (Issue) 22 (2), January 2009

5-‐11 makale

VOLUMES: Makale sayısı Volume (Issue) 31 (3), July 2013 83 Volume (Issue) 31 (2), April 2013 79 Volume (Issue) 31 (1), Jan 2013 146 Volume (Issue) 30 (SI -‐2), Dec 2012 91 Volume (Issue) 30 (SI -‐1), Dec 2012 142 Volume (Issue) 30 (1), October 2012 80 Volume (Issue) 29 (2), July 2012 69 Volume (Issue) 29 (1), April 2012 67 Volume (Issue) 28 (2), January 2012 69

The Impact of Journal Self-‐Cita6on: The Case of Energy Educa6on Science and Technology Umut Al* ve İrem Soydal** h"p://yunus.hace"epe.edu.tr/~umutal/publica*ons/tk-‐ua-‐is-‐2012.pdf

EESET PART B: VOLUMES: Volume (Issue) 3 (4), Oct 2011 Volume (Issue) 3 (3), July 2011 Volume (Issue) 3 (1&2), Jan-‐April 2011 Volume (Issue) 2 (3&4), July-‐Oct 2010 Volume (Issue) 2 (1&2), Jan-‐April 2010 Volume (Issue) 1 (3&4), July-‐Oct 2009 Volume (Issue) 1 (1&2), January-‐April 2009 4 3/4

7 3/7

5 3/5

8 5/8

15 7/14

17 12/17

31 20/31

Makale sayısı Tek isimli / Toplam

VOLUMES: Volume (Issue) 5 (3), July 2013 Volume (Issue) 5 (2), April 2013 Volume (Issue) 5 (1), January 2013 Volume (Issue) 4 (SI-‐1), December 2012 Volume (Issue) 4 (SI -‐2), December 2012 Volume (Issue) 4 (4), October 2012 Volume (Issue) 4 (3), July 2012 Volume (Issue) 4 (2), April 2012 Volume (Issue) 4 (1), January 2012

Makale Tek isimli / Toplam

53 34/53

59 30/58

12 7/11

18 8/ 13

78 39/75

67 43/66

286 132/198

42 9/15

16 5/6

SONUÇ BÖLÜMÜNDE YER ALAN BİR CÜMLE İLE BİRLİKTE EEST KAYNAKLI 10 ATIFA YER VERİLMİŞ!

h"p://scholarlyoa.com/?s=erratum

Uydurma dergiciliğin trajikomik örneği!

On Sep 4, 2013, at 2:35 AM, <[email protected]> wrote: Dear Lakhtakia, Akhlesh， This is from Fron*ers of Engineering Mechanics Research (FEMR). It is a great honor wri*ng to you. We found a paper you published. It’s an excellent paper which is well matched with the Focus & Scope of FEMR. Title: Erratum: Theory of thin-‐film, narrowband, linear-‐polariza*on rejec*on filters with superla�ce structure (Op*cs Communica*ons (2006) 268:1 (182-‐188) DOI:10.1016/j.optcom.2006.07.006) To promote the communica*ons in the area of engineering mechanics, we are now sending our earnest invita*on for you to submit new paper to FEMR.

If you are interested in it, please submit your paper online, Website: h"p://www.academicpub.org/femr/SubmissionGuidelines.aspx If you are interested in being our reviewer, please send us your CV (including your *tle, affilia*on, department, research interests, qualifica*on, email, etc.). We appreciate the coopera*on with you and look forward you hearing from you in the near future. Sorry for any inconvenience caused. Best regards, Erica Yan Editorial Assistant Fron*ers of Engineering Mechanics Research (FEMR) The World Academic Publishing Co., Ltd Website: h"p://www.academicpub.org/femr/ Email: [email protected]

Interna*onal Journal of Medical Sciences and Health Care

USA and UK Based Research Journal

International Journal of Medical Sciences and Health Care

USA and UK Based Research Journal Calls For Papers "Volume 1,Issue 9" Last date will be on 25-Sep-2013****Calls For Editorial Board Members and Reviewers E-Mail Us [email protected])

h"p://www.ijmshc.com/category/volume-‐1-‐issue-‐5/#

PUBLICATION Volume 1, Issue 1 Volume 1, Issue 2 Volume 1, Issue 3 Volume 1, Issue 4 Volume 1, Issue 5 Volume 1, Issue 6 Volume 1, Issue 7 Volume 1, Issue 8 Volume 1, Issue 9

Volume 1, Issue 5 May 31st, 2013 | Author: admin Volume 1, Issue 5 [1] Cytogenedc Profile of de novo Acute Myeloid Leukemia Padents in Malaysia Author’s Details:John Peter-‐Kevin Sahin-‐Germany [Full Paper PDF] [Page 01-‐06]

Cytogenedc Profile of de novo Acute Myeloid Leukemia Padents in Malaysiaia Isimli makale pubmed’de başka yazarlara ait ve başka bir ergide yayımlanmış!

Volume 1, Issue 5 May 31st, 2013 | Author: admin Volume 1, Issue 5 [1] Cytogenedc Profile of de novo Acute Myeloid Leukemia Padents in Malaysia Author’s Details:John Peter-‐Kevin Sahin-‐Germany [Full Paper PDF] [Page 01-‐06] ========================================================================= [2] The Ethnobotanical, Phytochemical and Mineral Analyses of Phragmanthera Incana (Klotzsch), A Species of Mistletoe Growing on Three Plant Hosts in South-‐Western Nigeria Author’s Details:O. T. Ogunmefun-‐T. R. Fasola-‐France [Full Paper PDF] [Page 07-‐11]

International Journal of Medical Sciences and Health Care

USA and UK Based Research Journal Calls For Papers "Volume 1,Issue 9" Last date will be on 25-Sep-2013****Calls For Editorial Board Members and Reviewers E-Mail Us [email protected])

h"p://www.ijmshc.com/category/volume-‐1-‐issue-‐5/#

The Ethnobotanical, Phytochemical and Mineral Analyses of Phragmanthera Incana (Klotzsch), A Species of Mistletoe Growing on Three Plant Hosts in South-‐Western Nigeria Pubmed, yukarıdaki makalede yazar ve dergis sayısının farklı olduğunu gösteriyor!

Publishing Ethics Author Guidelines

h"p://www.ijmshc.com/guidlines/

Ethical Issues Plagiarism: If you suspect that an ar*cle is a substan*al

copy of another work, please let the editor know, ci*ng the previous work in as much detail as possible

Fraud: It is very difficult to detect the determined fraudster, but if you suspect the results in an ar*cle to be untrue, discuss it with the editor

Other ethical concerns: For medical research, has confiden*ality been maintained? Has there been a viola*on of the accepted norms in the ethical treatment of animal or human subjects? If so, then these should also be iden*fied to the editor

International Journal of Medical Sciences and Health Care Dergisi ve yayın etiği

h"p://pdos.csail.mit.edu/scigen/

Bilgisayar Bilimleri alanında otoma*k yayın üretme yazılımı! Gelinen duruma dikkat çeken yazılım bazı yazarlarca yayın amaçlı kullanılmış!

Elsevier’in Merck destekli dergisi(2002-‐2005)

2003’de Vioxx kaynaklı kalp krizinin ardından, George Jelinek tara�ndan incelenen ilk sayıda 21 makalenin 4’ü Fosamax’ı refere ederken ikinci sayıda 29 makaleden 9’u Vioxx, ve 12’si Fosamax’ı refere ediyor’

Hakem değerlendirmesinden kim korkar?

4 OCTOBER 60 2013 VOL 342 SCIENCE www.sciencemag.org, 2013

•  51 gün sonra kabül yazısı

•  Sadece kaynak vb ilgili düzeltme isteği

•  304 versiyonu dergilere gönderildi ve 157’sine kabul alındı!


h"p://www.economist.com/news/china/21586845-‐flawed-‐system-‐judging-‐research-‐leading-‐academic-‐fraud-‐looks-‐good-‐paper

h"p://www.casestudiesjournal.com

Special Offers Diamond Package: On $3000 Unlimited papers must be free of cost whole life in this subscrip4on. Golden package: On $1000 “50” papers must be published free of cost in this subscrip4on. Silver package: On $500 “15” papers must be published free of cost in this subscrip4on. -‐ See more at: h"p://www.casestudiesjournal.com/special-‐offers/#sthash.sCgh8FR8.dpuf

h"p://www.casestudiesjournal.com/special-‐offers/

h"p://scholarlyoa.com/publishers/

•  460 Yayınevi, 2500 üzerinde dergiyle listede

Beall’in Listesi

Sahte açık erişimli dergilere ilişkin bazı

ipuçları •  Yayın kuruluşu adresini ya vermez ya da

yanlış adres verir •  E-‐mail kutunuza gelen e-‐postalarla yayınevinden makale göndermeniz, editörler kurulunda yer almanız veya özel sayı editörü olmanız istenir

•  Yayınevinin web sayfasında ciddi gramer ve yazım hataları vardır.

Beall J. Medical Publishing Triage – Chronicling Predatory Open Access PublishersAnnals of Medicine and Surgery Volume 2, Issue 2 , Pages 47-‐49, 2013

Sahte açık erişimli dergilere ilişkin bazı

ipuçları •  Yayınevinin dergi listesinde çok sayıda

dergi vardır. Çoğu yeni olup, içeriğinin az oluşu dikka*nizi çeker

•  Dergiler çok geniş bir alanı kapsar. Örneğin: Journal of Medicine

•  Yayınevinin e-‐mail adresi gmail veya yahoo gibi adreslerdir.

Beall J. Medical Publishing Triage – Chronicling Predatory Open Access PublishersAnnals of Medicine and Surgery Volume 2, Issue 2 , Pages 47-‐49, 2013

Malezya Eği*m Bakanlığı tara�ndan tanınmayan yayınevleri

h"p://referencephsusm.files.wordpress.com/2013/06/four-‐4-‐publishers-‐not-‐recognized-‐by-‐malaysia-‐ministry-‐of-‐educa*on.pdf

h"p://www.matema*kdunyasi.org/arsiv/PDF/12_02_69_75_ozturk.pdf

Saygılarımla…

Akademik(Yükselmelerde( Sorunlu(Dergiler( - TR Dizin |...

Documents

Transcript of Akademik(Yükselmelerde( Sorunlu(Dergiler( - TR Dizin |...