%±$×7 M*ñFûFÚFáG ) )Ê$×G /(Ô$×Fú Û*f 0Û oFþ N4 …...S6Û%Ê'2H >Ì >Ì >Ì %±$×7...
Transcript of %±$×7 M*ñFûFÚFáG ) )Ê$×G /(Ô$×Fú Û*f 0Û oFþ N4 …...S6Û%Ê'2H >Ì >Ì >Ì %±$×7...
特教研 B-295
独立行政法人国立特別支援教育総合研究所
······················································································· 1
·························································································· 2
································································································ 3
················································································· 4
·········································· 5 ············································· 5
····································································· 6
············································· 9
················· 10
, 2012 ··············································································· 12
········································ 141415
·································· 16 ········································ 16
····································· 17
································································ 18 ·············································· 18
········································································· 20 ··········································· 20
·············································· 21 ·············································· 21
···················································· 24
····························································· 28
····························································· 32
···················································· 36
································································ 41
······································································ 45
································································ 49
···················································· 53
················································· 56
······································································ 61 ··································································· 61
················································· 62 ·························································· 72
··································································· 80 ················································· 90
·························································· 95
···························································· 96 ················································· 96
·············································· 97 ······························································· 101
················································ 116 ···························································· 125
························································· 131
··············································· 136 ···································· 136
·································································· 137 ················································ 144
························································· 148
························································ 150 ············································· 150
···························································· 151 ························································· 158
················································ 164 ···························································· 171
············································· 182 ························································· 188
··················· 190 ····························· 190
· 192 ························································ 192
····································································· 193 ····························································································· 193
················ 194 ·································································································· 194 ·································································································· 194
··········································································· 196 ····························································································· 225
··················································· 229
····································································· 231
··················································· 233
············· 235
······················ 239
················································································································· 240
···························· 242
····································· 244
··································································································· 248
································································································ 255
1
2
方策
3
4
5
6
7
8
(12)
(12)
9
22 ()
( )
20 2008
18 200619 2007 30
10
11
, 2012
D
, 2012
3 24 658
24 37
24
53 2 5
192
151 153 177
0
50
100
150
200
250
N=648
12
8
10
4
, 19
, 12
, 3
, 1 , 6
NN
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
4
4
T T
26
T T
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
3
38
0 20 40 60 80 100
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
) ))
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
100
64
65
66
25 2
67
100
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
1 10 100
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
A B C
How many~?
How many ~ ?
How many ~ ?
How many ~ ?
93
How many
How many
4
How many3
How many
94
95
, 2010
, 2010
96
)
5-2-15-4-3
97
5-2-1
)
5-2-2
98
5-2-2
(1)
(3) (4)
99
5-2-3
8 30
(1) (2) (3) ((4) (5)
(1) (2) (3) (4)
)
100
10
5-2-3
101
5-2-4
5-2-5
5-2-5
5-2-4
5-2-5
102
5-2-6 5-2-6
5-2-4
103
104
(2)
5-2-7
105
106
10( 5-2-5)
5-2-8
107
5-2-9
5-2-9 5-2-6
108
5-2-9 5-2-9 5-2-6
5-2-65-2-6
5-2-10
5-2-11
109
110
111
112
113
25 26
114
115
25
/
5-2-13
116
:
117
2
< >
118
30
119
5-2-12
120
5-2-13 50
56
121
5-2-7
122
123
50
56
2
2
815
8
20
124
)
()
( 14)
( )
125
126
19 24
5-2-15 5-2-1
… … ×…
× × × × ×
127
5-2-16
< >
< > < >
5-2-8
5-2-8
128
( 17)
129
( )
5-2-18
12
5-2-18
< >
< >
< >
< >
< >
130
, 2010
, 2010 3-2-1 Check
5-2-9
5-2-9 —
—
131
132
, , 2014, Oct. 22.
3-2-1
133
-
134
(2010) ,
2013) -
- (2013) 19 (2014) 20
2010 2014
- - 1996 p.35
2009 pp.16-20
135
2010
136
5-3-1
25
10
137
5-3-2
5-3-1
138
5-3-4 5-3-3
139
12 ×
5-3-7
5-3-8
5-3-5 5-3-6
140
5-3-7
5-3-8
141
5-3-9
5-3-9
142
143
9:00 12:00
5-3-1
5-3-105-3-11
144
5-3-1
5-3-10 1
145
5-3-11
146
147
2010
2005
2011
20122007
2013
148
2011
452 38 43 E 2005
2013 !
2012
23 2007
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
or
4 5 6 7 9 10 11 12 1 2 3
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
4
167
168
Plan
Do
Check
Action
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
25 582
25 27 25582 83 56
721 a. b. c.
d.
6-1-1
10024
34.6% 236
65.4% 447 2435.0% 230
57.4% 378 7.6% 50
6-1-2
190
44412.2% 54 87.8%
390 2418.9% 73 81.1% 313
230 (35.0%)
236 (34.6%)
378 (57.4%)
447 (65.4%)
50 (7.6%) 0
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
24 25
73 (18.9%) 54
(12.2%)
313 (81.1%) 390
(87.8%)
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
24 25
N=658 N=683
N=386 N=444
191
21130
3420 18
6-1-3 68512.8% 88 37.5% 257
4 .6% 340
192
67315.9% 107
47.7% 321 36.4% 23440%
6-1-4
2010
( ) ()
193
25 585582
25 11 18 26 10
17
13
14 16
16
194
a. b.
c.
d.
e.
17
195
582 495 85.1
40%
70% 3.0%
6-2-2
85%12.1%
N=495
196
a.
6-2-3
20%
10%
N=420
N=421
N=465
197
b.
6-2-4
50%
10%
N=420
N=421
N=465
198
c.
6-2-5
20%
50%20%
N=420
N=421
N=465
199
10%
50%
20%10%
10
2004
a.
6-2-6
50%
10%
200
b.
6-2-7
50%
N=420
N=421
N=465
201
10%
c.
6-2-8
N=420
N=421
N=465
202
50%
10%
50%10%
10%
N=420
N=421
N=465
203
a.
6-2-9
N=420
N=421
N=465
204
40%
15%
2 3%
b.
6-2-10
40%
N=420
N=421
N=465
205
15%
c.
6-2-11
30%
20% 25%
N=420
N=421
N=465
206
207
a.
6-2-1240%
50%
N=420
N=421
N=465
208
b.
6-2-13
40%
40%
N=420
N=421
N=465
209
c.
6-2-14
35%
N=420
N=421
N=465
210
a.
6-2-1565%
N=420
N=421
N=465
211
20% b.
6-2-16
c. 6-2-17
75%
N=420
N=421
N=465
212
2=6.64,df=2,p<.05 2=11.36,df=2,p<.01
6-2-1
N=421
N=465
N=420
213
63%
29.6%90%15.9%
72.9%90%
47.7%
6-2-2
85.2%
54.2%74.4%
46 539 51 0 636 % 85.2% 54.2% 25.6% 0.0% 50.8%
8 456 148 4 616 % 14.8% 45.8% 74.4% 100.0% 49.2%
54 995 199 4 1252 % 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
214
2=6.64,df=1,p<.001
a.
6-2-1855%
30%
N=420
N=421
N=465
215
b. 6-2-19
70%
25%
6-2-3
N=420
N=421
N=465
216
46.8%
42.6%90%
70.6%6.0%
76.6%14-1 14-3
18.2%75.8%
10 6-2-20
50%90%
46.5%90%
217
25%
20%70%
10%40%
6-2-21
N=495
218
14 15 a e
a.
b.
14-1
c. 16-1
N=420 N=421 N=465
219
d. 14-1 14-3
e. 16-1 16-2
(3+4+5)/3=4
6-2-1 6-2-3
a.
q
q
q
220
b.
q q10
q q10
c.
q q q
q q
q
d.
q q10 q q q q10
q
q
221
q
q
e.
q q q q q q
q
a.
235306
3114
16 6-2-4
222
1
2
3
4
5
6
223
7
1
2
3
224
4
5
6
7
13 17
14 15
16
21
225
2000 6000
6-2-5 6-2-22
226
21
25
21
25
17.5 45.3 33.2 2.31.8
16.0 41.8 31.9 5.9 4.4
9.9 41.9 43.3 2.9 2.0
11.1 37.2 38.4 7.9 5.4
21
25
21
25
17.5 45.3 33.2 2.31.8
16.0 41.8 31.9 5.9 4.4
9.9 41.9 43.3 2.9 2.0
11.1 37.2 38.4 7.9 5.4
227
2014 25
1)
2010. 2) 21
2004.
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
7-4-1
235
236
237
7-4-212
238
239
240
241
242
243
2014
2009
244
2009
2014
245
PDCA
246
1) 26
852 26 11 20 2)
21 244 21 12 P411 3) 48
21 109 4) 25
2014 200
247
248
N2
N2
N2
N2
N2
440
188.
851.
390.
708
4018
9.55
1.14
0.77
4018
8.25
2.64
0.45
4019
6.51
5.68
0.13
4019
0.49
0.39
0.94
410
218
2.95
102
183.
1610
318
0.65
103
176.
0910
318
7.46
198
196.
219
619
2.23
199
198.
5819
920
3.17
193
187.
71
4319
7.08
4220
1.18
4320
1.17
4318
3.19
4119
7.51
383
380
385
385
377
7217
2.83
7.77
0.02
1*
7214
4.23
27.1
80.
00**
7216
3.66
12.9
20.
00**
7216
1.73
14.3
70.
00**
7216
0.44
13.0
40.
00**
269
210.
9726
821
5.9
271
213.
1427
121
1.59
265
209.
51
6320
0.25
6120
2.56
6320
7.55
6321
6.44
6220
5.28
404
401
406
406
399
2715
6.33
8.15
0.01
7*
2714
010
.39
0.01
**27
154.
947.
370.
03*
2714
9.63
7.89
0.02
*27
124.
8729
.46
0.00
**
227
198.
522
720
2.06
229
201.
6922
920
5.06
226
188.
85
149
215.
6114
620
9.27
149
213.
7114
920
9.51
145
230
403
400
405
405
398
311
196.
093.
830.
281
310
193.
24.
440.
2231
319
6.28
2.66
0.45
313
194.
774.
140.
2530
719
3.62
1.4
0.70
2323
4.22
2323
7.91
2322
7.24
2322
2.65
2320
8.76
3318
6.64
3219
5.64
3319
7.33
3320
3.64
3319
4.23
2920
9.52
2820
729
214.
7129
227.
4828
213.
71
396
393
398
398
391
240
190.
287.
320.
062
241
194.
172.
350.
5024
219
6.26
2.45
0.48
242
197.
891.
950.
5823
917
8.98
22.7
10.
00**
1423
0.93
1321
1.38
1419
614
212.
7914
211.
32
7122
1.87
7021
4.23
7120
7.32
7119
9.18
6922
5.07
7620
9.86
7520
3.49
7621
6.42
7621
5.74
7423
4.35
401
399
403
403
396
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
q
249
N2
N2
N2
N2
N2
439
190.
697.
250.
0640
232.
1410
.83
0.01
**36
229.
179.
370.
02*
4021
2.63
2.9
0.41
4017
3.6
1.92
0.59
410
118
1.18
9818
7.33
9918
4.67
9919
3.23
9519
0.96
194
197.
4619
918
8.97
193
181.
7219
718
5.06
186
178.
91
4015
2.04
4216
0.98
4116
2.46
4217
9.51
3916
9.68
374
379
369
378
360
7023
8.61
16.2
0.00
**71
236.
3916
.65
0.00
**66
230.
7715
.87
0.00
**69
252.
7923
.17
0.00
**69
236.
3219
.64
0.00
266
194.
7426
719
9.92
263
195.
7326
919
3.35
256
184.
13
5916
4.49
6216
1.92
6115
6.37
6016
5.8
5516
2.65
395
400
390
398
380
2722
3.09
5.24
0.07
2623
7.65
13.1
10.
00**
2520
7.48
6.76
0.03
*25
246.
329.
510.
01**
2423
7.79
7.73
0.02
225
204.
6222
521
0.95
222
205.
2522
720
6.03
217
192.
6
143
182.
8514
817
6.74
142
176.
7814
618
1.33
138
177.
6
395
399
389
398
379
309
201.
098.
870.
03*
308
203.
3712
.27
0.01
**30
019
8.73
14.7
0.00
**30
820
2.25
8.34
0.04
296
194.
4811
.02
0.01
2119
8.5
2319
8.39
2220
5.55
2319
8.2
2215
4.55
3217
9.45
3318
4.42
3218
1.69
3117
9.9
2917
0.45
2714
1.04
2813
3.64
2912
3.52
2914
5.05
2513
8.72
389
392
383
391
372
238
206.
978.
220.
04*
237
211.
5113
.30.
00**
234
205.
168.
290.
04*
237
206.
919.
190.
03*
227
196.
864.
120.
25
1417
2.07
1423
7.5
1319
2.04
1524
8.8
1418
5.07
7116
7.85
7117
0.69
6716
5.34
6817
7.11
6518
2.4
7019
7.66
7517
9.08
7318
4.86
7618
1.5
7117
0.68
393
397
387
396
377
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
q
250
N2
N2
N2
N2
N2
440
199.
991.
750.
6340
183.
632.
690.
4440
194.
233.
830.
2840
204.
656.
220.
1040
197.
660.
690.
88
410
918
7.49
109
186.
6311
018
3.69
110
182.
1311
019
8.46
200
203.
0919
820
0.92
201
207.
0220
120
9.35
195
193.
92
4519
4.69
4420
8.31
4520
0.42
4518
4.58
4318
4.06
394
391
396
396
388
6716
0.8
13.1
20.
00**
6713
5.38
32.4
70.
00**
6715
5.88
16.9
40.
00**
6715
4.46
18.8
80.
00**
6715
2.05
17.7
90.
00**
268
210.
1926
721
3.58
270
211.
5327
021
0.55
264
208.
04
6921
3.12
6721
6.47
6921
8.3
6922
3.53
6821
6.03
404
401
406
406
399
2515
3.04
7.88
0.02
*25
141.
089.
750.
01**
2517
3.94
2.78
0.25
2516
1.64
4.33
0.11
2511
5.62
35.8
40.
00**
227
199.
3322
720
0.42
229
201.
2722
920
4.7
226
186.
93
151
214.
1314
821
0.66
151
210.
4415
120
7.26
147
233.
09
403
400
405
405
398
303
192.
564.
880.
1830
219
1.58
4.99
0.17
299
190.
145.
120.
16
2622
426
205.
8126
203.
8726
200.
7126
201.
65
3520
1.69
3420
0.59
3519
5.47
3520
2.56
3520
6
3122
5.16
3023
3.37
3123
8.97
3124
3.16
3023
1.33
395
392
397
397
390
238
190.
987.
320.
0623
919
4.16
3.58
0.31
240
196.
886.
770.
0824
019
7.82
8.48
0.04
*23
717
6.8
30.8
0.00
**
1424
4.96
1320
1.38
1422
2.82
1424
1.21
1422
4.04
6921
1.72
6820
0.44
6918
9.38
6918
4.46
6721
6.51
8121
6.19
8021
9.34
8122
6.8
8122
5.06
7924
6.32
402
400
404
404
397
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
q
251
N2
N2
N2
N2
N2
440
201.
948.
450.
04*
4025
5.83
16.2
60.
00**
3823
6.34
9.43
0.02
*40
208.
71
0.80
3917
5.29
0.7
0.87
410
918
6.12
107
193.
1210
719
2.16
107
197.
7810
119
0.46
194
203.
3819
918
8.69
192
184.
1619
819
1.47
189
185.
39
4215
4.4
4417
7.24
4317
4.17
4419
1.68
4118
3.5
385
390
380
389
370
6624
2.7
17.2
50.
00**
6624
5.11
17.5
20.
00**
6023
7.42
15.2
20.
00**
6526
2.4
28.5
90.
00**
6524
2.5
22.4
70.
00**
264
195.
3826
619
6.91
263
194.
6126
719
3.16
253
183.
16
6616
6.8
6817
1.26
6816
4.82
6716
6.73
6216
5.94
396
400
391
399
380
2524
7.26
8.14
0.02
*24
256.
0614
.21
0.00
**22
236.
598.
620.
01**
2424
6.6
6.42
0.04
*22
240.
736.
860.
03*
225
201.
6822
620
7.91
224
202.
2622
620
2.3
217
190.
86
145
183.
7914
917
8.97
143
177.
2214
818
7.59
140
180.
69
395
399
389
398
379
301
203.
4910
.30.
02*
301
203.
9515
.64
0.00
**29
319
8.22
8.1
0.04
*30
120
4.31
9.97
0.02
*28
719
3.5
8.27
0.04
*
2415
8.71
2518
0.2
2419
3.52
2517
2.04
2516
8.04
3415
7.57
3519
7.39
3417
2.46
3317
5.18
3216
6.28
2917
4.12
3012
7.75
3114
7.27
3115
0.55
2714
6.3
388
391
382
390
371
236
206.
68.
10.
04*
236
210.
9910
.05
0.02
*23
320
5.36
10.4
30.
02*
235
204.
174.
60.
2022
519
6.05
4.8
0.19
1418
3.61
1422
8.46
1319
1.54
1523
8.7
1417
4.36
6816
5.63
6817
5.55
6515
7.98
6518
2.68
6219
4.98
7620
0.33
8018
0.9
7719
2.97
8218
9.85
7716
8.71
394
398
388
397
378
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
q
252
N2
N2
N2
N2
N2
458
226.
630.
680.
8858
227.
32.
110.
5558
219.
981.
630.
6558
241.
464.
550.
2158
238.
12.
830.
42
412
321
3.98
123
205.
1512
420
9.24
124
205.
1212
420
9.64
212
220.
1421
022
0.2
213
223.
2421
322
2.89
207
212.
98
4321
2.4
4222
1.46
4322
9.88
4321
4.58
4221
9.15
436
433
438
438
431
5716
4.82
19.6
40.
00**
5713
3.8
40.6
30.
00**
5716
8.68
16.5
30.
00**
5716
5.54
18.6
20.
00**
5716
3.84
17.8
10.
00**
303
238.
7130
223
7.22
305
236.
5130
523
5.91
299
230.
99
9222
4.51
9024
1.77
9223
4.09
9223
8.01
9123
8.7
452
449
454
454
447
2515
2.72
12.4
50.
00**
2514
3.6
14.7
30.
00**
2516
9.1
8.02
0.02
*25
152.
910
.92
0.00
**25
137.
9641
.60.
00**
254
223.
5425
422
2.56
256
224.
0525
622
8.9
252
203.
98
171
239.
0516
823
8.14
171
238.
5617
123
3.67
168
264.
19
450
447
452
452
445
308
217.
317.
580.
0630
720
8.82
110.
01**
310
216.
757.
430.
0631
021
6.92
9.53
0.02
*30
421
5.05
4.17
0.24
4324
6.29
4325
8.13
4324
4.74
4323
3.43
4320
5.95
4719
5.89
4622
6.77
4720
4.28
4720
2.91
4722
3.93
4324
9.6
4225
0.05
4325
6.49
4326
8.06
4225
0.21
441
438
443
443
436
256
212.
67.
40.
0625
621
4.23
8.49
0.04
258
217.
534.
510.
2125
821
9.71
3.22
0.36
254
197.
5433
0.00
**
2325
2.67
2321
9.8
2322
2.04
2323
3.96
2319
7.59
7922
7.67
7821
6.83
7922
4.72
7921
8.87
7725
3.71
8924
6.11
8825
4.81
8924
7.66
8924
3.45
8826
8.73
447
445
449
449
442
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
q
253
N2
N2
N2
N2
N2
458
222.
2210
.05
0.02
*58
267.
5317
.09
0.00
**55
258.
111
.38
0.01
**57
245.
087.
160.
0756
203.
772.
010.
57
412
221
0.71
121
218.
5412
021
2.75
120
221.
0911
621
6.56
207
223.
7221
020
8.86
206
205.
121
121
0.45
200
203.
5
4016
1.81
4317
9.26
4318
8.93
4218
4.74
3919
0.62
427
432
424
430
411
5726
8.77
12.7
40.
00**
5627
1.2
11.1
80.
00**
5125
6.77
8.91
0.01
**55
287.
3820
.35
0.00
**56
272.
0319
.81
0.00
**
299
221.
4230
122
0.52
298
221.
9930
122
0.45
286
209.
51
8819
6.19
9020
6.26
9119
5.29
9019
4.66
8418
8.06
444
447
440
446
426
2428
4.96
8.78
0.01
**24
277.
4811
.85
0.00
**23
250.
895.
030.
08*
2429
4.98
11.9
50.
00**
2328
5.98
11.8
70.
00**
252
223.
8825
323
1.75
251
225.
6525
322
6.55
245
213.
58
166
208.
7216
820
2.05
163
204.
2516
720
5.95
156
199.
98
442
445
437
444
424
307
225.
285.
230.
1630
622
7.4
13.7
80.
00**
299
220.
455.
40.
1430
422
6.14
6.51
0.09
291
217.
337.
950.
05*
4120
8.55
4219
0.87
4122
8.45
4321
8.71
4219
7.12
4419
9.2
4623
2.93
4619
6.07
4419
2.43
4318
5.84
4218
8.55
4216
5.48
4318
4.56
4418
6.66
3917
4.54
434
436
429
435
415
253
230.
6410
.28
0.02
*25
423
1.32
10.6
0.01
**25
222
6.18
7.93
0.05
*25
322
9.07
6.98
0.07
245
221.
775.
420.
14
2318
8.13
2325
9.13
2222
4.43
2426
0.83
2318
2.78
7718
6.25
7621
2.95
7418
2.96
7620
6.4
6920
0.78
8622
7.45
8919
1.04
8622
0.01
8920
2.28
8519
8.38
439
442
434
442
422
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
()
**1%
*5%
q
254
26
26
2626
26
26
255
256
25 26
27 3
239-8585 5 1 1
TEL 046-839-6803 FAX 046-839-6918 http://www.nise.go.jp