7© 9 n,,~ , zzzd adaeel...~Taitahassee j 'FL 32599- 1050 ANTonio WRI?)D > Ds C># I 040¥2 7 7 b...
Transcript of 7© 9 n,,~ , zzzd adaeel...~Taitahassee j 'FL 32599- 1050 ANTonio WRI?)D > Ds C># I 040¥2 7 7 b...
-
FILEDJOHN A. T OM A SIN0
Tri E FIanroa suraeme coaer28H NAR 28 P 1: 5tr
CLERK. SUPREME COUR T
hN7aN To vwtBb BY
V. PeT ITIortea. CRse no,:
hCa (#óe go.', 1Di¥ ~ 03 3
STATE «F TLoaron by . case no , 9 8 - 4 s av crd
SP oudenT.ON
HAR 2 4 2014
Tu s u r URIsp1671onR2 BRIEF
SeeKVNG ReMlew TRom The %sr Durar Ds C># I�040¥2 7 7 b
Flonida ärare psiuou7© 9 n,,~ , zzzd adaeelRa>road ,yi at oz c
-
e le o F Cou7en7 5
Table or cila)ions , ,. ., n o , pp , 171 - E
072TemeNT OF 7})e Code exc|Tac7J ... , pp. 1 - z
60mme nY aF 'f/Ze /192 Gumeu7 - , o , pp . 3
RR60men7 , n , , , , , s .99 . - 9
Con c jus >ou , s , , , ., , rp , )o
CenTirica,e ciF 6envice .. .. , .P3 .so
-
ne1E oy OTa71on3
£asts_
CARhada! -v, 67aTe, 76 so. Sc) 8583 36 7/d-
S/328 (Fla. Zon) . . P -7
Han v . 47ave , 477 4)) 2 So,768 Tld
C s l)14 6 LóV977 V
- , , , . pp. s
Hut|409 V�042P9|melt , 46 �042Ö l 7 ) 3 23
(19 8 ¥) , . . . . . . . pp , BLevi>> V. Cauf , 51g u.s . 343 > 355 > M 4.c} . 217'f
9ÀV Å||e Ñù)|$ôak Co. V* JH077)eY
�042CT.2 , 63 L�042ÍÀ )Ed
Suced mavo , G é ho�0422 d 865 , 26 9 ( ria.1953
6 TaTe v. J encen , 751 Joe 2c y 7, y8 (F/a.1979
int Flonida 67ag v. 8 » J ,E ., 5 30 36.a J 28c (7,,,
U»S. N . Pe7eie , dio F. 3d 709 (11Th cia, zooz
wdG61 4 . 37a7e , 153 so. 2 d 571, 573 (yja ,
- - - . .. 99.5,gGE 6DWAseDS 4 s sTà7e , 3g ff
7 case no.: lbl3 - 297+ , ,
o 030 (bM3) > Í d' R" A"® P
o ó3o (d)(2)(A)(iv) e e ., -. �042-. -FA-3
-
Con47;yafzo^e
[2R7/c 0 V 3 (b)(3) * FE�0421 )
TR7uT�254
T|9. ST27. 7¶ . ol ., , ·· - - ~ - P2�0425
-
1 or lo
TaTemeis7 sF Case ano Facvs
1. On denuenzt 16 Th i ?ot¥ , Pe7171ones Toawaaded
2 n E16h|een (is) Patie PeTi13on Toa wai1 oy HabeasConpas wi}}i ¥xnisir (a) ttne le> nerencia aryixed
d>Rech t To The Fiasy D> s riuct counr o r nee atsay o> a6 Juni s di c ri on pans van r r o Aaricle v , §+(hun op The FloniÍa cons}ila}ion i and reale
9. Odo ( b )( a> >Fle. R.ape.y . Peri rionen sowehr
1mmeaÍI a re t�254efea6e Taum uit la wfa l 1mpr is onmear
ß@6ed ou The Tsvel count lacic of Sul dec7 marren
Jaaiidic fio,« ro hcah, dereamne , ääd ad Ja Jicare
e mà77eh i 7Jene bY Ren aÎeßl N G ÍÌ>e du c G men | Eri7ened
2. 08 Yebtwent 03 , 20iN i The ÍÍns7 Dcn Is&zsed an
ORden diaechin& Perr7>vuea 70 show cause w/Am
TeH(io) 815 vt|Y1 S2WCYaoNá 4 valÍ NOT be impobe
OÓ a/ M47 PeTiYiUNeR i )H C hÝHiG 2 ERO i iT/oM ÑÓPinbr
ÜN1 la VBF 9Pfeals CA PeTiYious cbattencius Tlie
aÁGmeN7 ONÍ b6N7CNCe lH ÖUVa| CoCrNTY CIR GuiT
CoenT Cade ug..- 1t -7773-cr -o02/8oz -exxx -ne.
3. au TebtwenY |}Th > 2001 > Peririonea Tomaaded
f&YllioHeR6 keNON C7) P&6e Reðp?unde To fÅod
Canbe ondea ,skaias OAv sancrious skvail nor
he rmpased,
-
2 oF 10
ON Mdach 1 2 Th , 2 o 24 , The Fiab7 D>67tu c1 evunr
O F R9Pepi I66 ue c| 3 a Y¥paes 5 ed an il Òusec7 conFbcr
0 F The áupzern e COVRf C N 4 2me- QueG/cw of
law hv waare« Ofixion dumusius peririon haunir ei aden cuneas , au/ oiso zuaed nencueaDR o inec| Cva7// c r y Lewirren opuscw fäoLL søc
fafW/e /0/20'Je ÄÍ/Nr3 MNÁn 7F/e/ dy a mem jen
ix Goad sbuoline op Me 7A,u/p æn (see sa ¿,, on
AP/exdiK )
-
3 of to
(NA/DBlut or TAe Rizó er?reur
7Áe év/e 765 ae'a ) BeFone YMis Hopea a J}e
Cowz7 /5 7ÁW DNcne 7/oHany ÁundJ aÚ c rhcrnor rha cuan, may de euescued t»hen a
rapieae/ as/ a½ed caum/ aurrw opiaaAas /een Asa4aed. �060cas», may øs e
-
0 F l 0
I ., f1,6%GUYnCNT
fun4vauT To fler!Cl* 8 (hA®) °
T|6,i lcla cons hi faht on > Thi s Hancaable c o uwY
}2a s hi s cae-nou ent Jais i cTi o n T© Ñ° 1e
9 de ci 6 i o N 6 F 9 ÁS.Tald CourVT ©7 AM�254G|
-fha| egynejsiv an/} Álaech11 conFlicY
d Óe cis ) on OF 7|2e Oymme e o�5237
aisriucr Count 67 flereel
8 s E , 540 Ss. zel 2 g g (7|a. 1923
F/a, R , Rep., p . 9 , 0 3 o (a M Z ) ( Al f v1
Heae , )¾nT2 unen ConTe
16ml b 6 i NG T|Je peri nonJuusdc c
C oppcss ) 5 vgi hin The Élácaert one Y
OF T)3e 'Flanida 30paeme C°°ª¹
QuÓ Ótnecr conFlier 0F The 4°P
The é 2me aecr °!!'"!
oa i~ prconvimou riwricus )( see raiea æ""
ar ep.2-2)
-
5 oF 10
ORlÎ2 40pgerne Cod127 Âa5 YcrNG Â81
Ybe Gnea7 wyv7 oy 7tafeas conpas 16 2 wruT
°F R16 kT ó bTài n ab le LLN Ýcn ourt CON
4 all meu dbo CÍeim Á de ah'ldw Fu/IV
Int/piu6cNe/ S6enys t' -/Áent wt// . > !) '"^
To &/ Jole/y TÅe /e&d// h/ af 1Áe /
Im/1n/JoNmen/. Jee JNee| V �042/??ªY'° i
865 , 3 69 (7/a . / 1s3 ) /�254e/tec'^' N 7
as 7fe gasis 7¿,e fonnot'ic kus' (see agend di
Pp. 1-2 )
7"Áene is 2 siusanlio|w"' 07 Tb" 6"?
case ep paxen v. 47are > 4"fn2
The deasua ¼ The Plaida sopae
J N Baxen is Based CN ÑellTi o
67 Habeas conpas bei ns dumissed as tvia ° '*e
upw 4ee g,ue gevie,» oy a J'a}cment SH 4e"T°"
7has Aven,y a Thar , } &cTiv a eJ
foár Convicryog Ite|)e7 pytoce Åme ,
À°w e en > 4need 9. mayo , supna , a!!a©s Per' 7"*'
OR NVfLIT OF |4ebeas conpas To e Éle
Solett The Jecali,1 op rhe periTic,eens
bl5 Nowenab|e count can Redoive The
c nea+e J f y 3he y,aar d i s rni cr eunt of
-
é o lo
}{e Two eCI67 ON3 S/le 19D2elodct �042
eYt Y) owen écra6 h h ho be 1sninea dl e he lY
Títum uN làvaFal Irn?106 ON me"7
/ac/& of fu j jecÍ s77871°A A
te/ c ocrizr, ¾n ze)ÁtcÁ ca×
7~/me �042
Í}]e Xpsy D, c.se - 6F 7/ento 9 GH 6eV
leen /J beve CeNJ/J yt'gy 71/ y , elÁ a 9 C 9
Áe [7szte/ ce ciar] /a cice/ scid Jec r aa tre"
o,itj oÓc y op can /e s�2542/6e|27 ONv'
)pggy v. 57e7e , 953 30, 2 d 579 ) S¹
2cot ) 3 ¢t.s . y , peTee , 31 o T. ad 709
15Mille ?c NB6|1xille Ret MaÍ ¢©*
uns. o it9, o5z , 29 s.cf . 42 > 53 L
Nd// v - 47a7e, g 7 7 só .
t'tbus Lovey7 v. Love77, 93
( Fla. I n1)) ; and wunen EEK
J S 7/a 4 L .. Weekly D 2 2 3 / > DI674u7 C36e N0 - am 3
Of IHead Ti lec| 0 cTo beR 2 3 >
RthÍlN �540IM W2qSY , 6TaTe , SofRd
permonea con¼ends -}fgf pun6vaur re FJa.s1er-49.o
-
7 of /0
ÓU/MeM ! Covn on GNt/ J ¡ce siegy
/baer on 4 any c�523a/ /adse ;raa a e
°F Aefees cenpas and sí,ws hy swida
N/ /ekce pyn fp J/e cause 7; je//eve /Á&/ Áe
°n &Íe i s addire/ y//bu / /swn/ salb
Ne caml dasáce, a Jad e y a sud
Art a ,,ia/e dei, écou/ Me æ/
cd/ 862/ug/ -,Sje ,oegsop ,,, &Ávse
c v de as,»car/ u & /s,xe / ax/
mea dia /ciy henne an
-
8 oy 10
/ N ena ÁÍe [vt/W 91 f/ZeV/GUS IV o C /N e
/EeV/ecò TÁe d e con ol gy/n/c/ coun/ of ns'r e 9/
GAÍ'7/0 CVN7//c/ IJsue 826e) en /Y:) Áof /NG
ÓÁe Actb 3, B5o -//me /imi appiy |0 C D'mJCA /NG e g d'ao/g,yppg4/ g9y yo,/ cpy;o
2 3 GAt ene ç/ 0 CocWl/ t.-///]ps/ Jesus cbc toy ,
('"A e even , ÑeJcr/ve of 2NofÅen (ÁeHeMGe
CONc /u o syg g / ggy |ac/c of fun/J ÁcÁ/°'v
TÁe 4 o a d sec,, alive,/ 7g, c,xcai/ c a
Un/J Í/ c / oM 6ee ) cpada Jai v 4TaTe> 15
258 , 36 flg . L , weexts S6 28 ( Fla- 7°10
eTITI cdeR CcnuieHÉJ Thaf Y e fRieR CeR7/Tle
cewi j c g ,n, a d dao re penrio ens
C) R CamÜenceá i ~Tbt3
esolve This mar7en Baded
isc| dinecy &crNFhc7 Á /
H , RM vmen7
ORdU 2HT To flgyjc} 33 0 y 7 e
CONJT1TuTt on , TH1 s lionong |e c ourtT > 1
7 J cneT1oH 2ny JuniJ À> cTlon °F
al 2 supteme cou,tr fecause The Ex;nes>ed 2nd
R e LT Con F |t cT O F Tbe s opaeme C ourtr on The S 2me
-
9 of to
aes un VF Ácò Áas Áex GNek p' dsi/Áu op/w/ox
Ín//wf/x6 42xc f/onj cry /Áe //e k"A V ¿OAoÁ'
¾/Me da 'Je ÑÍÁNóJ tuV|eJ 5 V Ñ '''""'
/At doo/ JÁso/øs op /Áe ,Flox/ ? 82'E>l' "6 3 ò7
SAWcess 7.5/ do., 2of y7, 98 (Fh./97Ò( NdGUIA'
nró'' 77/za//rnev/o!e /ver/ce GN GN Off°
/mÁ Áe?ïv/2e /4eev'enÁNG ÍS./ Í/ Á69"É Ñ°
wzÁÁeA /9772 c/c J cist Áls osz Áen ccwvic /v
Addaøex c, faá Na/ caer/u / rxa '"
S/JeNcen olo e s yoy coa foizin D jew/S
M..t. 8 95 , 3 gg , //G S - c l. 2 / 7 4 l/996 )
Ñ68 C S. St y, 5a3 , jag ss c}. alw
6 upreme cenirc7 h a s e }e J }}zal pst) su"e!'
óx3|| /a/powe/ ,g/cr/v/ To peÁ! b/ ''
Ñ/2 Ae|/leJ S cry ~,7½esp 0/2/eV 9 N Ce 3 >
Ác2Jond ÁÍe A/gf/ e7 ßcce.>3 76 TÁe '
EX Mi8/1 CA) , 27 pp , 2 )
eT1T)ottedt ConTen0 J ~Íb27 lb Con! I
ebe i cory phc7 , Tun e!² > fell I °
2 |acM op TaiaI coun7 e'Y mª¹
C|aim }hal can be Raised al ent T)" '
¶£3 sg. Ñ 571, 57 3 (Fle�042( ll yk c a. Zoo .
u,$. v. peren o 310 F-8 7°9
-
1O of )o
OMCÍUJ/VN
79//J //UNG/29 f CVcMY < UV/Í 6ddef Ý ÑscAPY/0HBftY
U?z// c oy ~fo /feJg/Ve fk/J fpc ¿7/ |egg/ fg3(¿e on
/20//Cf GcteJ;Í/ oN .
_Cf/tT/7/cn7e or seavíce
f //cize 9/ Cesz Á pçi 2 1/zae o78/ ccuuzec7
CV/p çt cry 7Áss /couj // c //ex?/' 8/t/e7 Á23 'N''
/~o 7~Áe /uzaese //J /e/ o dizÁ/eJ ON Á /
Sine a o Bond ; ,
Trenne y' 6ewen p is 077/ce
o 2 > The cajnro I
al19baSSee i FL 3239c;
e3Dec u//z/ So mi//er|
''s/ doÁnæ rWsxd'
N N/O l'e/srs?.
[]oni22 4727e PR/6°N
78/9 nw- 2237h 5 'zed
2)Fonc|,TL 3202 d
-
1 oT 1
MAR 2 4 20M THE Y L onIon SupnTN
RE E 0 RT
. BYv, Case no.
D C A CA5e No.
l·T , CRSe >ro .
P NBIX
óU9NT 70 7)a. g, epp, p , go 220 (d')( 7 3 Pe7)Tronero
The Farrowme accoon
�042OXHiÂ17 (R) CoHTonrned Cop4 of planch 12 , 2014
PI R5Y Clo7RI CY Cconf of RPeepi Of'>t'ON Co n s1 s y i y g
) P&Ge MITh E%pReh5ed wairrew opinion
c n ,he becn cF Tni pace £6ual ine ïwo m paces .
-
IN THF, DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALFIRST DISTRICT, STATE OF FLORIDA
ANTONIO WARD, NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TOFILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND
Petitioner, DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED
v. CASE NO. 1D14-0313
STATE OF FLORIDA,
Respondent.
Opinion filed March 12, 2014.
Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus -- Original Jurisdiction.
Antonio Ward, pro se, Petitioner.
Pamela Jo Bondi, Attorney General, Tallahassee, for Respondent.
PER CURIAM.
This petition for writ ofhabeas corpus seeks review of a judgment and sentence
in Duval County Circuit Court case number 98-4802-CF D. The petition is dismissed.
-
See Baker v. State, 878 So. 2d 1236 (Fla. 2004)(reiterating that habeas corpus cannot
be used to litigate issues that could have been or were raised on direct appeal or in
postconviction motions).
Due to petitioner's apparent abuse of the legal process by his repeated pro se
filings attacking his conviction and sentence, this court issued an order directing
petitioner to show cause why he should not be prohibited from future pro se filings.
State v. Spencer, 751 So. 2d 47, 48 (Fla. 1999) (requiring that courts "first provide
notice and an opportunity to respond before preventing [a] litigant from bringing
further attacks on his or her conviction and sentence."). Petitioner's response to the
show cause order does not provide a legal basis to prohibit the imposition ofsanctions.
As such, because petitioner's continued and repeated attacks on his conviction
and sentence have become an abuse of the legal process, we hold that he is barred from
future pro se filings in this court concerning Duval County Circuit Court case number
98-4802-CFD. The Clerk of the Court is directed not to accept any future filings
concerning this case unless they are filed by a member in good standing ofThe Florida
Bar. Petitioner is warned that any filings which violate the terms of this opinion may
result in a referral to the appropriate institution for disciplinary procedures as provided
in section 944.279, Florida Statutes. See Fla. R. App. P. 9.410.
LEWIS, C.J., WOLF and ROBERTS, JJ., CONCUR.
. ·2