中国最早的国家

32
中国最早的国家:长期轨迹方法 作者:Gideon Shelach • Yitzhak Jaffe 邮箱:[email protected] [email protected] 原文链接: http://download.springer.com/static/pdf/757/art%253A10.1007%252 Fs10814-014-9074-8.pdf?auth66=1412767860_0094b0ffcd9a95f45809 ee7dc82035a7&ext=.pdf 译者: Leek、杜小逗、小马、小玉、Ici、香菇、Sharon、公无渡河 校对编辑:公无渡河 声明:原文是开放版权的文章,译文也欢迎大家阅读转载,但望读者 们尊重原作者和译者的成果,转载请注明出处(原文和译文)。

description

中国最早的国家

Transcript of 中国最早的国家

  • Gideon Shelach Yitzhak Jaffe

    [email protected]

    [email protected]

    http://download.springer.com/static/pdf/757/art%253A10.1007%252

    Fs10814-014-9074-8.pdf?auth66=1412767860_0094b0ffcd9a95f45809

    ee7dc82035a7&ext=.pdf

    LeekIciSharon

  • 1

    2500

    2 1600

    Falkenhausen 1993

    Liu 2009, p.220

    4 3 e.g., Shao 2000; Zhang 2000

    2 e.g., Bagley 1999

    e.g., Liu 2004; Liu and Chen 2003; Zhongguo 2003

    1Neoevolutionism 2Regional state

  • c. 145-85 BC 30

    400

    Watson 1993

    1046-221 BC

    841

    Watson 1993 2000

    20

    Chang 1981; Liu and Chen 2012 20 50

    1959

    20 60

    Allan 1984, 1991; Keightley 1983; Linduff 1998; Liu and Xu 2007; Thorp 1991

    1996

    2070

    1600 1600 1046

    Lee 2002; Li 2002; Shaughnessy 2009

    1900 - 1550

    e.g., Xu 2009

    1

    300 18,000-30,000 phases II and III; Liu

    2006, p. 1832

    Liu and Chen 2003, following the denition by Wright 19773

  • 500 Liu 2004, pp.

    2322344

    Zhongguo 2003

    I II 9600 4200

    5

    Liang and Sun 2004; Liu and Xu 20076

    Zhongguo 1999

    Flannery

    1998, pp. 2236

    Thorp1991

    Peterson and Drennan 2011; see further below

    2012

    Service1975

    Fried1960

    Flannery 1972; Wright 1977

    20

    80

    Wolf 1982(Paynter 1989)

    (Trigger 1998)

    (Bernbeck 2008,

    p. 537)

    ( Hodder 1982; Johnson 2004; Miller and Tilley 1984; Stahl

    1993)

    Abram

    A. Smith (2003)

    Campbell2009

    Campbell

    Joyce2010

  • Feinman1998

    Stein

    2001

    (Earle 1997; Stein 1998; M. E. Smith 2004)

    (Blanton et al. 1996; Claessen and Oosten 1996; DeMarrais et al. 1996)

    (Crumley 1995; Levy 1999)

    (Dobres and Robb 2000; Johnson 1989; Joyce et al. 2001)

    , Nichols and Charlton 1997; M. L.

    Smith 2003; Yoffee 2005)

    Baines and Yoffee1998

  • (Drennan

    et al. 2012; Earle 2011; Peregrine 2001).

    Pauketat2007

    Pauketat

    Pauketat

    Gledhill(1988, pp. 34)

    7000

    e.g., Liu and Chen 2012; Peterson and Shelach 2010, 201

    2; Shelach and Teng 2013

  • ( 1 1 2)

    1.2.3.4 5.6.

    7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.15

    16.17.18.19

  • 0.428.12

    106

    Liu2004, pp. 138142; Underhill 2002, pp. 104113

    40

    50

    300

    219

    Qiao 2007, 2.3

    46 76

    Chifeng, 2011

    BC

    3500

    3300-2500

    3500-3000

    3500-3000

    4300-2600

    4500-3000

    3000

    2800-2300

    3000-1900

    3000-1900

    2600-1900

    3000-2200

    2500

    2500-2300

    2300-2000

    2000

  • BC

    3500

    3300-2100

    3300-2600

    4000-3000

    4000-3000

    3000

    3000-2000

    3000-2000

    -

    3000-2000

    2500

    2600-1900

    2700-1700

    2000

    10

    3-5 2.5 Liu2004pp.93-94

    8

    c.2800BC, 35-50 4

    5 27 16m

    Peterson and Shelach 2010

    3000-1900BC19001550 BC16001300 BC

    13001050 BC1400-1300BC

  • 2500

    27 47.3

    463 2005.4 Underhill et al. 2008,pp.68

    500

    1500 (Guojia 2007)

    Guojia 2006

    Liu et al. 2003,p. 88

    20

    30-50(Guojia 2006, 2007; Liu

    2004) 1500-2000 km2

    (Liu 2004, pp. 104105; Underhill et al. 2008)

    1 10

    280

    (He 2013; Ren 1998; Zhongguo et al. 2005)

    (Zhongguo et al. 2004, 2007)

    1400 m2

    ( 2) II FJT1

  • 3 (Liu and Chen 2012, p. 221)

    4 (He 2013) 54

    3 100 23 10 99

    (He 2013)

    1000 87%

    12.7%

    1.3% 3 2.5 2

    2

  • (Chang 1986, pp. 276277; Liu 2004, pp. 135137; Zhongguo 2010, pp. 572574)

    400 3

    2012

    272.5 367.5 (Underhill et al. 2008, pp. 68)

    (Underhill 2002)

    50

    2 2 4.4 2.5

    Chang 1986, pp. 273276; Liu 2004, pp. 104105

    30

    10

    Beijing and Henan 2007

    Henan 2002;

    Liu 2004, pp. 104105

    Flad and

    Chen 2013; Zhongguo 20103300-2600BC

    2600-1900BC 45

    91 163 169 Pei 2004

    100 50 4-5 6 Hubei et al. 2003

    3

  • Underhill 2002

    Zhongguo 2010, p. 571

    Zhongguo 2010,

    pp. 673691

    3000

    2200

    1800Stanley et al. 1999; Yu et al. 2000; Zhongguo 2010, p. 692

    (Underhill et al. 2008; Zhongmei 2012)

    (Chifeng 2011)

    2000

    Liu 2004, pp. 110111

    1700

    Zhongguo 2003, pp. 566, 838

    2100

    2000 Beijing and Henan 2007,

    pp. 780781 2000

    100

    Zhang et al. 2007

    18 Zhang et al. 2007

  • 2000

    Liu et al. 2003

    I 100

    1900 1800 Liu an Xu 2007 1750 1700

    Zhang et al. 2007 II IV 300

    1800 1550 1700 1530

    Liu and Xu 2007; Zhang et al. 2007 3

    gongcheng

    zhongguo 2003 II III

    11 IV 2 4

    300 9600 7

  • I II

    9600 4200

    I 3625

    3011 5 II 226

    Liu and Xu 2007; Zhongguo 1999, pp.

    140159; 2003, pp. 6568

    II 5.24.25 6

    Zhongguo 1999, p. 157

    I

  • 0 20

    300

    Liang and Sun 2004

    Zhongguo 2003, pp. 114115

    17

    17

    15 Liang and Sun

    2004

    Liu and Xu 2007)

    2000

    14 III

    1610 1550

    1530 1600 Zhang et al. 2007;

    Zhongguo 2003, pp. 659663 6

    7 17 -25 9

    300 1500

    8 200

    Liu and Chen2003, pp. 87101; Yuan and Zeng 2004

  • 6

    100 2000

    3000

    9

    Du 2006

    3.75

    3.4

    23 55 40

    2

    Zhongguo2003, pp. 242246

  • 7

    Henan 2001; Yuan and Zeng 2004

    100 86.4

    28 500

  • 8

    8Henan 2001, pp. 307383

    Henan2001, pp. 384425

  • 9

    e.g., Liu and Chen 2003,

    pp. 127145

    30 Zhongguo 2003, p. 295

    875 466

    1600

    107 192 12

    Zhongguo 2003, pp. 300303

  • Kantner 2008

    (c.1050771 BC)

    478221 BC

    supraregional state

    M. L. Smith 2005

    7.55 Shen et al. 1999, pp. 258259

    ( Shelach 2011)

    11300 1500

    292000

    39673

    26

  • 40000

    5298

    18000 30000

    Liu 2004pp.299,

    10%-16% 13992000

    184370

    35 4.5

    1600

    e.g.,

    Liu and Chen 2003Lamberg-Karlovsky 2008, p.

    xviii; Peterson and Drennan 2011

    50 1500-2000

    500 100 150

    Liu 2004, pp. 232234;Liu and Chen

    2003

    Zhongguo 2003pp

    phases I and IIXu Yan 2009

    200

    70

  • Bagley 1999,

    pp. 156157

    2008

    3Argaric culture

    -

    Chapman 2008, pp. 159160

    Trigger1998,

    2003

    /

    3Argaric culture 1700 - 1000 El Argar: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Argar

  • Shelach 2004; Tong 1995

    2006

    Feinman1995 Blanton et al.19964

    Liu and Chen 2006, pp. 162-168

    Feinman

    2010Peterson2006

    4processualism 1960 Dual-processual exclusionarycorporate

  • Peterson

    //

    /

    478-221 BC221-208 BC

    206 BC-AD 220

    Yates 19975Segmentary stateKeightley 2000Trigger 1999

    Maisels 1990,20101989

    Drennan et al.2012

    Gary Feinman Linda Nicholas

    5Segmentary stateD.N.Keightley