4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ...

256
ﻦ ﻣﻦ ﻧﻈﺮﻳﺔ وﺣﺪة ﻣﻮﻗﻒ اﻟﺴﻌﺪﻳ اﻟﻮﺟﻮد

Transcript of 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ...

Page 1: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

الوجودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة

− ��  −

���4� �� ���5� 67!� !/!� �8�

6�9: ; <� �58 =>? @ A?

��<�B ��� �� '5�� C��D� E�"�( ����� ��F� �>�

G��"� � =�A$"� '>�">� ����� �HI

Page 2: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Page 3: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

���� #B;B,� �;�� �� ,B��� T.V,� ~?�� # , #Bf;Be�� f;�B,� ¡A�7 , #B)�e�� ���,� �$� , `BGf,�� A�f&sE� >fL,�² �f! "<! Í }��,� ,

`Bf��� ��f%7E�� ��h;E� �! "t9 Í T<G,�� K� � K , �f! �fJbt[ Í Ç�f%/e� N�C�2,� Yt9 ,N�@�� A�@i�3 ����� "�[ª�� ��[�� � ³�7� m�%J "��

,�A�7�� (�9�� Å]�� �+.�g�� 8,�E� &9 ! , 8�9.e�� ��&$DE� T��0 ,_ �D&9 , 8f%'� �$jf]� �f,i f!� , "�Aw hf%,� �tf9 Í ³f�7 �f� ,

"�.! �� Fe� UtV7 lG��� ,"�9� �/� �+�, ¸5:�3 �)�;�� TB�%,� .L�� �� S&�%,� (�! Nx� %7� , �+f,� ��.� ��2/7� �&�!� ,

�I�� �&,0�K � �, � Y�af7 �)2� OC/+ �� >]�� , m�f%J , �?tf9�� , �J�5f]� , �,�%��� , "#Bf;� uf&�j/7 OCf/+ �� �<R�� ! �)��� , �fJ�w >f�&�:� ,

�%�/�� �.5/� �)&� T<V,�� , �f%/�� uf�.� �)&� �BM�� , Of?�c �f� �/&��� 8! "#B;� NBV7 , ·�fM� #Bf;B,� �fD� 4f2%7 , >5f9<5,� (f��

&�<9�� NB , �)&�! �J#�+h7 O?�c ��� , NB�V/e� (�� , NBfV7 Of?�c ��� �/&��� 8! "#B;� , ·�� #B;B7 b �V, , #Bf;B,� �fDB[ �f&: �f� Of7

u�Le� , Y�#B;Be� Í �A�G,� ,#B;B,� S:B7 NB�?��,� >&�BC,� (��3 N�fV7 >&�E� �� Y�a,�7 >,pGe� "a� �D�[ �e� , >f�&�j7 >�Cf/� �fkBV,

� >&I�� Y�a, , Y�fcB�de� Y��w �f! >�C52� >�&�: �kB[ � �&: �� , 8�V/e�� 8&�<9�� >59<5,� ��A ! , �H >�C/� >�&�: � �� , 42%7 8cBf�de� Y�w �2&%7 B� � Y�w N� , uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �fDBV, , �f&�! tf[

#B;B,� S:B7 NB�?��,� >&�BC,� ,Í T<V,� u:� N� �$$:� >,pGfe� "af� , 8&�! 8���0 ��A �D� �.%7 l,w� , 82+.c , �+¤�%/� , (fI �fD�[

Page 4: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

tk��ª Í >&��%,� TB�%,� Í mBL,� &,�� S#�+.,� , Í t)&f$%[ Bf�! m0 >��60>&!Q,� >&��2,� TB�%,�3

�Â8__�� , .ff! �ff7 #B%Gff� �+ff,� %ff9 Bff�� , Î�ª�ff/5/,� , >2ff9 ÍBff/e�n���f� o|+ >,pGe� "a� Í 8�V/e� >9A� O , u,�fM� >&��� >2+�$� `Z�

8cB�de� #B;�� >&��e "#B;�� , �f! "#Bf;� Í #Bf;B,� �f;�� hf&�� �2V¬ ,U�C5Db� T�� �2! �,�C5D��3 ;+<�� , 2Gf,� &G,� B�� , �f7 Åf!

�+Q,� Å! �7 _ , Î�;.�� , >29 ÍB/e�n���ff� o ,f[ N0� Bf�� N� �D��ª Í 8�V/e� >9A� O|+ , ��af� m0 >,pGfe� "a� Í r2; c �D� b0#B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� >&�BC,� , �;�B,� N�� , m�%J , u�Le� #B;B,� B� , #B;B,� �a� Í "#B;� �A�G,� , "#B;� b0 #B;� <� , u?�f��� 8f! B��

A�$/!b�7 S.|V/e�3 8����� �+a� S.)�,� ,� 82+.c� �+¤�%/� tkBV, , �f�, t)&f�! u�R�

"�+%G,�"&��J =� Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� ���, ,=29 \[� �DBV,� &Gf,� �f2+.c �f� �+Q,� , �&��/,� 1�7 �� >&2|J Ë)� ,�H�7 ! �G&,3

6.! >,pGe� "a� Í "B,# m#� c t)2� O[�=�bb/9�� = , Ë/+�f2! �);B/� t)&�<[ ¦j57 ,� t­B$@ u&�� ,�D ���2� �)6.! (@ ���=�&�! =� , &?�D=�

`BI�� �C%/,� l,�G� �! ,$D�µ=�`#.f,�� NBfFe� �R�B� 3 �af� N�fV� 8����� �+a� 2! #B;B,� S:� >,pG� Í .�2,� u&�� Í �j$,� , �/&9�

" L�Q��� :8�� �!;C# � !8�N�� iw�� " 3 ��� Í �j$,� �a� ��; c� >f���� �:�$� ¾<@� > , Bfj2,� f! Ëf��

Ç�/,�:− • ��81�� ��� �j$,� A�&/�� �$9 N�&$, Y��F� ,�D�&7 T�J t[3

Page 5: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

• b�S� \]/�� ���� N�B2%7 ��; �� " �+%G,�7 �+.%/,� , ��a7� #Bf;B,� S:�" 3 ,N�fJ.�� �f/��; �f+.%/,� Í Y��f; m�E� S.f�5,�

�+%G,�7 , >&D�|,� S.�5,�� #Bf;B,� Sf:� ��af7 �+.%/,� Í Y��;�7 8�?��,� .)��� 3

• Ã�_d�� \_]/�� ���� N�Bf2%7 ��fF� " Sf:� Í �+%Gf,� ·BCfD ���D� #B;B,�" , N�J.�� �/��; Í �+%Gf,� ·BCD Í m�E� S.�5,� #B;B,� S:� ,·BC2,� "a� �D Í >&D�|,� S.�5,��3

• \��d�� \]/�� ���� N�B2%7 ��F� "� ��a� �� O�%,�� �Q,� �cB #B;B,� S:�"3

• �f�g� �����j$,� �?�/D (�� ! ��/�� �� 3 #�G,�� u&�B/,� Up9� �� �a� ,#��.,�� >+�I��3

8e�%,� 1A ���3 �DbB�� �D&9 ! (%D�� �A�7� (�9� ()�,� ]� u�M� &9 , _ �D&9 ,8%'� �$j]� �,i !�3

Page 6: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

J�� KLA� : !/!� �8� G&MN� ���5��� 6���"�

#Bf;B,� Sf:� >f+.�D �f� �+%Gf,� �cB� �B6B� Í ��Q,� O$c 7b �+%G,� >'.J ! -BcB,�– Î�ª�/5/,� �+,� %9 , Î�;.�� �+Q,��–

>R�:��� ,�+�=� ,#Bf;B,� Sf:� ��af� >f�&�j7 , �af� >f9�A# Of/V/,&' �� �B6Be��$D�B; X ,8J.�� Í �j$e� �a� ��; �� �a� !�; m�E�

�+%G,�7 �+.%/,� Í ,A�Cf/�� Bf,� t)/'.J ! -BcB,��=� , Í >f&D�|,�� #B;B,� S:� ��a7 �+.%/,� ,�7 8�?��,� .)��� 3

O�� ���2� :���5��� 6���"� : �/² �+.%J� Sh;B� >'.J .[w (/&9 S.�5,� "a� Í 8e�%,� �+aH , %9

Î�ª�/5/,� �+,� ,Î�;.�� �+Q,�� 3 >�[ Ë�� >&2|/,� ¸5, N� m0 SA���� �� 7b �a� O$c�±" �+%G,� " �+aI

8����� 8�%,� , >&�&�: >&2|J �G&, , >f$��,� 1�f7 �f� >&2|J Ë� O7 , tf[ U��+" N�.�,� " .�,�� P��, ,� " N�.%,� ".V7 ÏE .!� ��F , :p�

�+,� %G7 ���+ 8����� �+a� , .f�g��– Î�f;.�� �+Qf,� Bf�� – ���7 AB)��" �+Q,� &G,� " �fDBV, t)&f�! �+,� %9 ��, ��s c� Ð K

�+Q,� &G,� �� �29 \[�3 8��f��� �+afI >f&2|/,� "af� O%/f9� �� O?��� �� O%,� , ¸f5, Ëf2!�"

�+%G,�"G� »&�,� B� "#�ª 4F/� F , �D�B2! �,*� �&,0 �G2+ w0" >,�9A

n� o�Z�� :#� }�Df4� ]�f G#� ���^&� $�f�2�&�. R?� $�5&A G : ��W �P−��E

n� oG��. R? ��Dg� R? �D� R? ����� �K ,/.)�&� ,�m�b /XV%D? ��Lc&� E 1)�&� ms? ��D#� R.– ��&�2 ��U�:–��%5V&� "#� ~ b�? ,1s9&� "#�) ,�K��;) $D9M&�) , $�� ~�:��P�jK , R.

Page 7: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�+%G,� -</�� Í" �+.�p/e� �t�%,� 87 SAB)�� �D�[ >&2|/,� "a)���F 3

O�� ��95� :=� P�"2"� ��� �5� 6���"� :

N�f�.7 �7 .! �+,� .d� Ñ��,� �7 #B%G� �+,� %9 >�<%,� T���� B� �f$! �+,� ,5/,�Î�ª�f/ , ��.fI� ,Î�f9�.M� ,�f&�5,� ,A�f�2,� ,(�V/fe� ,

Ë�L2e� ,�Bj2,� ,Ës<$,�� F 3 �&7� (9�� �9� �� AB)�e� B� �a��OF3

H5���^: :" =)�Y��#& a�(�V&� 3���A G#� $�f�2 "0  #? ���� d3�� G&� H� ,)" ~ �&�%D&�

��D9M&�) R�D#9VD&� R�? C��0s_&�" ,"$&(V-D&�) $����:�D&�) $��-f4� R�? �s_&� ~ $&��3 " E jDn�: �jZj��HV~ :R�j03�j-&� $j��jK :�� W �uO ,R�j5&vD&� "jXj-. : �� W QP−Q� ,1s�4� :

��W ��O , HD�� H�0 ��n �I)" ��Dg� R? ����� G��. R?" $�� H:�0)) ���ujK E

n� oR�03�-&� $��K ~ ��n : �� W ��O−����m�b =�U ¥�� |�c&� $Dn�: ~ , m�� �.�-?H:�5�^. �f�? a���D�� , ����-? �5�^. H& �A �U7<" �s�4� d�n�c. ~ ��^��� " a���D�� '�I

�f�? :R�#��5&� R��-%&� +2��. /��AE

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :3�&�$�.�9&� 3 : �� W OP� ,�D,&� ����� :� W O�� – O�Q ,d���&� $�,? : WOQ� ,=m)��#& R��%5D&� C�N��: � W O�Q ,8KS&� C�3Sf : �� W O�Q – O ,

C��X&� C��)3 : �� W O� – Ou ,o&�x&� 3��&� :� W O�O−O�PE ,$�L�&� �`��5&� : W� u�K�-? �.) , W�O� – �O� ,a#9D&� ��V&� : W���−�� ,R�03�-&� $��K :� W � Q− �O� ,1s�4� : �� W �Q ,R�5&vD&� "X-. :� W u ,$�.s�z� �3�-D&� d�`�m : �P W OQ ,}�V%�&� �3�-. d�`�m : �� W ��u−��QE

n  o HD�� �A �X2 R?� ��� ��n" m�DM. " =3�N&� /#� ���) "m�-%. R? �D� "�Z�� : 33�&�$�.�9&� : ��W OO , HD�� RD�0 �&7 �-? ��U7 R9&"m�-%. " � � W OP� , �A )���)

Page 8: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

Í %G,� ,�" N�ª�/5J "��F >29 n���f� or;�.,� ��.,� !� F 3 "�$] T�+� �)&� ,� Ë/,� �/+.c Í "#B! �Bc� %G,� p�D ,��B�! �)&� 4��J�

>&,�E� >&!Q,� ,Bfj2,� (�! ¡#�$[ ,�f�5,�� -�f,�� , Ni.f�,� ¸f5:� "f+Bv� (+.V,� , >f�B%D af2� (f�#b�� NBf�%+ �+af,� 8�Gfe� S#�f%[

�&J�/V,� Í (�A�5�� , �+AB)�fe� »+��fe�� �t�%,� �� N�[ "�7� N�� >]��Ð}�2,� 87 ,t/j�= ",� >+�!.7 TB�&9 ,�/&7z7 U�5/:b��3

>f&�%,� �JZGf� Of[� 4/: �� N0 �� �D0 (@ ,Á&f%,� �f� ��f� f! ,�ª.,� �� -�5[� ,!#B�= Ð�UBfM�� >f!,�� -zf,� S�f&: ,fcA�5�=� af?�a,

1�$�,� , �$C,� Y�+.��� ,U�c 4/:�OF :

��%�&� a-5? $DMN. $N?�%&� $Dn�&� ,�K�^N& �&7) E�Z��) :�D,&� ����� : � W O�� , �`��5&�$�L�&� : W�OPE

n� o���#�&� "X-. ~ ��n :" ��b�V5: "e�kA ��: $�U�%&� ��5&� �-? ,�&A) ,=�b) , R. d���U $��I /2���" �%� " ,$��Dn �L�. ��k E �Z�� :���#�&� "X-. : � W OP

$�.s�z� ��V%��DU�: $�3�LDn ~ ��&�2 oN:<E

n� odm�-%&� ]�V5. ~ �m�b =�U ¥�� "L�. H& "n�: RD. d�� |�3�V&� �SK �U7 : ��W �Q� ,�-%&� ��52) ,HN5&� ]�V5. ~ m�-%. R? �DM. R? /�M� 1�.z� : $I3)Qu\A ,�59&�)e : �Z��

W $�L�&� �`��5&��O� ,o&�x&� 3��&� ~ }�U�c&�) :� W O�O , ��V&� ~ ��k R%2 y��p)a#9D&� : W���"K��;) E

$�� �&) H�A "LY-? �U7)��� jK F�D,&� ����� ~ �X2 R?� ag. ��D#-&� q-? ��U7 �I) :� W O�Q ,$�.�9&� 33�&�) : �� W OP� , ~ /#��M&� m�D-&� R?�)8KS&� C�3Sf : �� W ��Q ,

d���&� $�,? ~ /���%&�) : WOQ� ,R��%5D&� C�N�� ~ =m)��&�) :� W O�Q ��#N� �I) �X2 R?� R� H:m�) |�3�:E

n  o�Z�� :8KS&� C�3Sf :�� W O � ,o&�x&� 3��&� :� W O��E

Page 9: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�)$Gf[� NBf25,� ª�.:xf7 �+BR NBfff2� NBfff2��� Ï�$fff� ��#A �ff)/�D� NBff25,� ��Cff� tff��Ð N� Ç 8ffff$JNBffff2; NBffff25,� ¾#�B��f7 >f�&�� >&f9�&9 Szf� Í Ä�f! fc %Gf,� NBf[ �� (s.,� !�

T�G�� ,T��G,� Y<�%e�� ,�AE� �f� �)2Lc Ë/,� >%c.,� l�J Í , Ëf��f$�R (f�%,� �! �2|+ ¢ ��[ l,w N� b0 ��A��; ��� N�9�.� #<7= ±�Gf+AJ� =�

5&,pJ�=� 3 >f,�,� (V: N�70 %G,� Ä�! ���>f&,B�e� >f&D�d�+����F , �LGf7 Ëf/,�

>&cQf,� Ë�<9�� ¢�%,� N��7 .|[� ! ��wB5D� �­.L&9 ,N�f9�.� �f)2�3 7�.: >,�,� "a� T�V: ��� c�=��I SA��Fe� l,te� X� SZ|[ , (k0 4/:

�f�� T��,� #<7 Í >%cB� �� .|[� (I �%c� c 3 (fV: N�f70 Ä�f! tf[ >+AB&/,� S¿E� ,l2,AB&J ��p�D� Ë/,�� , �f@:� �f� f:� ! 45� b�

1�.j�, >!��0 �� N�L�G,� �a� , «B5,�� , A��,�� , �� >%9�� XcA ÍÒ � K"wB5D �)&� �G7 Ë/,� ���$,� l�J 3

Í �tf�%,� A�# ! Z$[� °�$� Z@pJ Y�w >&9�&G,� Y��ªE� N� Í l�b�±�&,pf/,�� P+Af/,�� }A,� , (;.fJ fc� ~f%7 Í lf,w ~f%7 %Gf,�

�J�5,*� , f7 AB)�e� Ës<$,� �7�/[ �&,pJ �� �s�.� 2! U�c �&:" UBfLe� ":�?�L�,� l�/7 �?�jC,� +BGJ �� �s.� 8:� :

4ff/: ��ªAE�ff7 .�ff,� Î�ff�A U�fff$D �fff� ���fffs Í �#�*fff�

n� o $D#U" ��_#�� "���,& HD92 ~ o?�V&� "U�M&� /�-: ,�&� $�-�: /�-: /K) '�,D&� ��x#%& $&)

R�^&� ~ "Z�4�" ��&�,�. " ,��&�,�. ~ 14� $&)�&� R� �#^5�� $&)�&� �SK �A �� , '�km �-?1s�z� ~ �L.�92 E�Z�� :����� ~ $�&�,D&� $&)�&� |�3�: : W�PO−�P�E

Page 10: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

T�)fff9 Ë2/7�fff]� �w0 Y�fff� U�Cff2,� ff! U�Cff2,� Y¯ffVJ E� #A�BJ �� l,w�N�B���� .?��%,� Í �?�Ce� (c�5/7 A�$� , (fR<J 2!

N�9�.� #<7 Í �/5,� ��B��3 3333333 �&f9 �f)&,��� f! .�f,� #.; ���± � N��%,� ,N�VG,� �� �)&� N�[ �� #�7��3 33333 , �f+��ª Í ��A�E� �:.L�K N�.FI� , N�&G2,� �[�2! �)&�! �FGD�,3 3333333333333"��F3 Q �1Q(RS! :

.|[ �t�! ! %G,� a�/J ,.)2,� ��A� �� #<7 �D�[ ��� ,N�9�.�� , �f�� NBff25,�� TBff�%,� 4/ff� Í �t�%,�ff7 S.ff��� (&,�ffc�� N�ff�7 �ff� �ff�A��;

Y�CCd/,�� , >f&V�� TBf�%,� >]�� , >f&�<V,� , >f&�L2e� , m0 >��f60 >&!Q,� TB�%,� , �,B]�� ��5,�[ ,>f&7.%,� TB�!� 3fD�V� >jD�f9 >f].� �

()G,�;� ()&�, �� �+� ! TB�%,� ��/² �� O)2&, %G�, 3 q+��� ;(�� Pp :

�−��.,�$! � FA�5�,�$! �7 �� �7 , �+,� �! ,˧�� ,�ª�Z�f,� ,T���� ,OF$e� ,�&�5,� ,(�V/e� ÇB]E� ,A��2,� ,�Qe� S��c Ñ�c , T��0�

#<$,� l�/7 >&%���,�3>29 ,� n ��{f� o >29 ÍBJ�n���ff� 3o Sf! �f,�)2� Y�5,*� :

" 4)/2e� �/² ¥° " , ��5,� UB]� (�! Í 1�/[ B�� , �f)2��" f?��%,� >+�%,�", � " T<V,� .��B; "� " >+�f%,� >,�9.,� " Xf6B,� (f�! Í ,

n� o�Z�� :'�xD&� ]�c&� :W�E

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :%&� 1�.w& e�9&� $�-0�c&� C�N�� /9��$���%M&� o�x&� :F �� W ��u �.) �K�-? ,$�.�9&� 33�&� : � W O – O O ,=����& $�-0�c&� C�N�� : � W Ou , C�N��

$�Lf /��I R?� $�-0�c&� : �O W �− Q ,o&�x&� 3��&� :��W O �E

Page 11: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

1�/[�" T<V,� (�! Í �c�Be� "Î�[B�f,� T�f��� �2! U�c : 1�f/[ Bf�� ��+�]B,� �2! ,�5,� u&�� T�A �� �2! Ë2�/G+ b� � � ���F3

�−#B_ � F �+,� T��D _ �7 ,�ª�.f,� ,T�f��� , >f�<%,� ,Ë%���f,� ,Î�/j/,� �+,� �L�7 Z)�,� 3 >29 �� �+.c ,�� � Kn�{{ff� o , >2f9 ÍBfJ�

n���f�o3TBf�! Sf! Í �A��f� T��0 ,>f&��%,� TBf�%,� Í ª\f�� , (f�%[uL2e� ,T<V,�� ,>V��� 3 Y�52C� S! �, ,�)2� :" ¥° A�¿E� Xf��B,

�Bff�A¼, A�BffDE� X,�ffL�"� " >,�ff9.,� ¥° Í >ff&�L2e� ff!�B�,� .ff+.� >&Gff�,�"� " A�¿E� �?�ffL, "� " Y�A�ff��� ¥° "� " ff! >&ff��: -��V,�"� " Z�C,� ����� ¥° "3

 − �$! �OF � %9 �7 ,�+,� %9Nt|f! �f7 _ �7 ,�+f,� ��&f6 ,Ë2+�h�,� ,T���� , >�<%,� ,Ë%���,�3>&��2,� TB�%,� Í �.7 ,>&��%,�� , N�[�

8$�ae� ��/+ ,>&52��� >&%���,� ��a� ,Ë/5+ tH N�[�3 >2f9 ÍBfJ n��{ f�o3

�5� �M�<: �1Q( : .|[ Sa�<J %G,� ! a�/J ,�FD �t�!� ,f� m0 �af� X;.+� %Gf,� S.)

n� oo&�x&� 3��&� :�� W O �E

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :&� 1�.w& e�9&� $�-0�c&� C�N�� /9�%�$���%M&� o�x&� :F�� W O� , C�N��=����& $�-0�c&� :�� W O −O O ,$�.�9&� 33�&� : �� W OOQ ,d���&� $�,? : WOuQ ,8KS&� C�3Sf :��W ��E

n  o��−~ HVDn�: �Z�� :/I��-&� H�3b /?4 �-&� G#� a�S&� :� W ��Q−�u , $�-0�c&� C�N��$L�f /��I R?� :�OW QO−Q� ,X�&�d�K�(&� 1� :���W �QO ,d���MD&� R%2 :��

WP��E

Page 12: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

وقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودم

− ��� −

S! TB�! Í �/���0� ,�Ja�<J .)�� ��� : �−_ ��F _ �7 _ �7 _ �7 _ �7 , �$! B7� ,�+f,� �<f! ,

�A�d$,� ,Ë52�� , ËF%,� ,T���� ,UB�%e�� UB�2e� Í u�je� w�/9E� 3 >29 �+.c ,�� Kn��{f� o , >29 ÍBJ�n���f� 3o

%���,� ��a� Í �.7>&52��� >& ,>&7.%,� TB�!� , ZG5/,�� ,uL2e�� , (�!�T<V,�3Y�5,*� S! �, , �)2�" �+f:Be� >jf]�D� �+j�e� >j6�� " Í

ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� ! #.,� 3 �−�G: � F �Gf: �f7 Å! �7 , f_ Bf7� ,�+f,� T�Gf: ,Óf�¯,� ,

�#AB&7E� ,T���� , >�<%,� ,Ë%���f,� 3 >2f9 f,�� Kn���ff� o >2f9 ÍBfJ�n���f�o ,Y�5,*� S! �, , �)2�"N�&$,�� Î�%e� Í N�2�� X&7A " 3  −Å! �OF(&��.f7� �f7 4f9B� �7 ,�Gf�� Bf7� ,�+f,� �<f! ,Ëf��.,� ,

�A�Cj;B�,� , T���� ,>�<%,� ,Ë52�� 3 >2f9 #�f: Í ,�� � Kn���ff� o , >29 ÍBJ�n���f� 3oÎ�ª�f/5/,� %Gf,� Tªb , &Gf,���+Qf,� , Àf:�

lff2, ABff&J P,�ffµ Í t­�.��ff2�3�ffJ�5,*� �ff� :"�+ff,� �<ff! >��ff9� " �"ªB2V,� 1�7 ¥�/5�� ªB�.,� ��["� " >&2+h,� #�A�� ¥° "

n� o�P−~ HVDn�: �Z�� :=(��ND#& ��#%&� :�� W ��� ,�D,&� ����� :�Q W Q−O� , $K(�

���?4�) r�5�&� :�OW � u ,o.s&� ��Y&� :�QW Q�− Q�E

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :�D,&� ����� :��W �O�−�O ,o.s&� ��Y&� :�OW ��Q−��� ,,? $�d���&� : W � – P ,8KS&� C�3Sf :�� W � �E

n  o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :�D,&� ����� :�QW � ,~�c&� a�&�&� :��W �u� ,o.s&� ��Y&� :�� W��−� ,$���D-�&� y`�Nc&� :WO� ,W�� ,R�5&vD&� "X-. :��W �uE

Page 13: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�−_ ��F f�� �+f,� fµ �7 � O�� �7 ,�+f,� P�f7 -�.f%e� ,Ë+.V,� ,Ë�ªA�BM� ,�A�d$,� ,�2c.G,� , Ë��.,� ,Ëf52�� ,LM�Ëf$& ,T���� ,>�<%,� 3 >2f9 ,�� � Kn�� ff� o >2f9 ÍBfJ�n���ff� o %Gf,� Tªb

Î�ª�/5/,� ,Î�;.�� �+Q,�� ,"Zs� �Ah�� �7� T���� �! a��� 3 �− � r/� � F �$! �7 ,Î��Q,� , >f2+� m0 >$GfD"N��° " �f� >f$+.c

>2+�" 1�B7E� 1�7 " , Ë��.,� ,ÎBLG�,� ,T���� ,Ë52�� 3 %G,� TªbÎ�ª�/5/,� ,Î�;.�� �+Q,� &G,�� 3

�)2� Y�5,*� S! �, :" �#�I� #��A0 ¥° "� " Ñ�fc ¥° ! Y��&�%J Ë2&�F�, >�&I� ¦d�� ! "#�ª"� " �c�Be� Y�&I0 ! >&��: " , Zs�

l,w 3 �Ja�<J .)�� ~%7 �b*� ,T�f�e� �af� Í (�.[a7 Ë5/[� , b �af,� XGf/+

%&' (�.[a,=� 3 =� P�"2"� ��� �� ��2��� �1Q( :

%G,� ��.+ �� �, ,m�%J � ��A ,>f%��D SZf|[ Y�5,*� , �f/[ 8f7 �f� �,BL� , SZ�] NB/�� ,��B:� , ¥�°� , Í �f$%[ Bf�! f! �f, )�JTB�%,� ,NB25,� .+.�J Í >d9�A Tc� 3

�/��� Í N��� �7� U�c: "c� �, Of;., S#f%/� �&,¹fJ ! �7 �5 S�.� �t�! �� ,N�9�.� #<7 �� , Î�ª�f/5/,� �+f,� %G7 .)/�+ , Í �f)2� T<V,� (�! , ��5,� UB]�� , N�&$,�� , "af� Í >df9�A >fV�� �f, Np7 )�J

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :o.s&� ��Y&� :�uW �Q− u�E

n� o ~ HVDn�: �Z��$���D-�&� y`�Nc&� :W�P−�� ,���Z&� �cU :��W �� ,$�L�&� �`��5&� :W�PO ,R�03�-&� $��K :��W u�P ,R�5&vD&� "X-. :�uW P�E

Page 14: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

TB�%,� , >&V�� TB�%,� ! �!<R0 �, N� ! U+ �� �)?�2@� Í�= ± , >&,�! ��c�=.?�9 Í>&��%,� NB25,� ,���+ �� "�27 +*+ ��"��F 3 Í %Gf,� �f,� fc�

4/� TB�! ,�,B]�� ��5,�� ZG5/,� (�%[ >&��D �D�[ ��B9 ,>f&��! �� , (f�%[T<V,� (�!� uL2e� , >,i (�! �� ,Bj2,� (�%[ , -�,�� ,N�&$,�� 3 �f$/[ �� ZG5/,� (�! Í" �Q²h�, -��V,� ! >&��: "/[ ��� �f�5,� (�! Í �$ :" >&52�� `��/�"� "¥�/5e�">&%���,� ��.� Í B�� ,�" ¦&fd�J ¥° �f/² Z$V,� X����">&52�� ��� Í ,��5,� UB]� Í �$/[ ��� :" ¥° f! >&f��:

�;��� �7b 4)/2e� �/² ! ˧�� �+,� �!"� " ��f[ m0 r+Bf�/,� r&�2/,� u?��:" , �fJ�5,*� ���ufL2e� Í :" T�f�Â, >&Gf�,� >,�f9.,� ¥°

Ë2+�h�,� Ë$J�V,�"� "T<fV,�� uL2e� �+a­ " , Sf&�%,� (f�! Í �f$/[ �f��T<V,�� : 1�/["]��e� "�:° c� , �f:° 4G +�� ± � fK" f]��e� ¥° " , 1�/[�" �&5G2,� ?��%,� ¥° " 1�/[� " T<fV,�� ufL2e� �+a­ " u7�Gf,� ".[w ,���>f,g� TB�! Í �$/[ :" ¥�f/5e� ¦&fd�J f! �f/de� ¥Qf,� "

f7 -.%+�" �/de� " �f7�/V, A�C/�� B�� " ¦&fd�J f! UBfLe� ¥Qf,� ¥�/5e�" f7 -�.%e�� " UBLe� " , 1�/[�" ¥�f/5� �f� �f,�|,� (Gf�,� ¥°

Ë[�VGf�, TBf�%,�" >fs<$,� (f�! Í ¾<|f,� �ff/V,� "af�� , �ff)2��" ¥° �J Î�FDh,� �+" , -�,� Í 1�/[ B�� , >/f9 .f%,� �f� �,� %G,� �5,�±

>29 Q! , 1�/[�"�#�I� #��A0 "Bj2,� (�! Í B�� 3 R:�%� :

>2f9 2c.f9 Í Î�ª�f/5/,� �+f,� %f9 T���� ÍBJ��� ��.f,� f! ff�

n� o�)�#k R?� $.�N. �Z�� : W�P�E

Page 15: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

r;�.,���F 3 � .5s ,m�%J , �, ,�/�A X9�� �&�! ³$9�� 3 �� ��95� ��� :=��/�T 6��D��� 6���"� :

Å! >�<%,� T���� B�� F Å! �7 _ �7 , Ë2&G�� , �+Q,� ,�G�� B7� ,Î�;.�� , �w�7�z9b� , Ë52�� ,�+Q,� &G,�7 AB)�e� , 2G,� &G,�7� ,

Z$V,� T���� , uL2e�� T<V,�� >V�� Í �G&?A� �Qe� ¢�! , ".�# >�<! ,T��0>&��D NB2� S! Í , �,B]�� ��5,�[ , ZG5/,�� ,>&7.%,� 3

>29 ,�� � Kn��{f� o Í" B[�J "�OF 1.c "w�7�z9� " , Í Of&c�"N�f;.;" ª�Z� Í (�%,� }A#� ,.f5�� f_ �f7 ��Ff� "��f,� �&,0 �7D , >!�5�f7 Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� T���� ,fe� N�f�7 f! "wBf5D lf2, AB&J �G7 �e (@ �Q

�<9��Ë , ª�Z� �)2�� , �/]�! m0 ��9A�" 2c.f9 " �f;�B7 TBf�&, P+A/,�� (�%,� ,ª�Z� m0 #�! AB&J �<� %7 (@3

(�%,� ��L7 "A�5�� >�B%D a2� Î�;.�� �+Q,� O�/�� c� , "�f2� -¤� "�$] Í >&7.%,� (�! BjD , 1�f/[ f! uf�! �fD0 U�f�+ 4/:± �" >f&��B,� " Í

$]"� 3

n� od�� ��3T G#� �-%&� d�0) |�3�: ~ �#Vk� ,�LMn3A) ���pA �K �s�A 3�USD&� E $&��3 �Z��d�3�VU�&� :�b�V5V&�C��L&z� R. H5I�.) } :��W uu− PQE

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :d���&� $�,? :WOP� ,o.s&� ��Y&� :�PW O u−OO� ,dm�-%&� ]�V5. :�� W�Q �K�-? �.) ,1s�z� ����m :�OW P− � ,o&�x&� 3��&� :��W �uu−�Q� , �`��5&�

$�L�&� :W� P�K�-? �.) ,1s�4� :�PW � ,R�5&vD&� "X-. :��W �� ,R�03�-&� $��K :��W � u−� Q ,$�.s�z� �3�-D&� d�`�m :��W OOO−OO�E

n  o O− �L& '�N�) "�n�: ") "�;�� " $���. '�D�A R. $��I /K) " 7�?���� ") "7�?����" $���. '�D�A R. $D�Z�"��V��� " ,"#-&� aKA R. �N#k �n�k< � � E�Z�� :���#�&� "X-. :��W ���−

��PE

Page 16: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

t�! A�] 4/: >,B�2e� TB�%,� Í �t�%,� Tªb (@=��.|[� Í 3 Ë2&%,� �2! U�c :"�Q,� ¢�! ,".�# >�<!"��F 3

`#.7 �.�J �7� �2! U�c�: " �G&?A� �Q,� ¢�! "� F3 Î�[B�,� U�c�: "���0 A�] =��f�Zs� >f&��%,� TB�%,� X&' Í ,#.f5/�=��fH ,

52C�=�)!�BD� X&' Í � ,.j$/�=��f)�&�;� �)�&c# Í ,��f�g�7 �/&f] A�fR� ,#<$,� X&' Í �J�52C7 }�2,� X5/D�� ,�f� O[ Í SAB)�� Ë�� , �fH �/fy

�t�%,� .7�[� , �)2� NB��2+� ,�)2! N�AC+� N�#.+�"�OF 3 Î�;.�� ÍBJ , � ��A , m�%J ,ª�Z� Í , >29n���f� o��# �H�3 RS!Q �1Q(:

�− >�<%,� T���� , u�je� ,>f&7.%,� TBf�! Í uce�� YbBf�%e� , �fLc�ª�.,� �+,� ,Î�/j/,� ,%G,� ÃB&� Í ".[w T�/e� 3 ~%7 &G,� �2! a��

TB�%,� , 1�/[ ! �:° �)2�"TB�%,� ¥�/5� "Ë[�VGf�, ��F 3 U��f: fc� �7�/[ �&�! }A+ N� �+Q,� &G,�">&G�,� ¥° "L2e� Í u , m0 >��f60

T<V,� (�! ,�29 \V7 �L�,� �, Aa/!�� , "af&�J f! �f,#� "�7 �%6�"�� �A�$� ,".[w Ôg� 3

n� oZ��� :o.s&� ��Y&� :�PW O QE

n� o�Z�� :~�c&� a�&�&� :��W ���E

n  o�Z�� :o&�x&� 3��&� :��W �uuE

n� o�Z�� :o&�x&� 3��&� :��W �uu ,t�N&4�) G�9&� :� W OPQE

Page 17: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�−�A�$� ��F Ë�L2e� "�� ,�ª�.,� �+,� �Lc T���� Sa�<J ��� F 3 Ëf§�� �f%,� �d&�f, �fc�Be� ¥° �+Qf,� &G,� �&�! }A# c��OF ,

ufL2e� �/[ ~%7� ,>&Gf�,� ¥Qf[�ª�.f,� �+f,� �fL�, ��F , ¥°��+� �, X,�Le�=��PF 3 T<fV,�� ufL2e� (f�! �f�L, �+Qf,� &G,� �&,0 O:A

�/j/,� �+,� �Lc �d&� �� SA��x7 , �fL�+ "�f� �A�f$� N�[� ,��afD� ,S.���,� 3

 −�+,� O[� ,_��F f�� �f7 #B_ �7 _ �7 ,Ô.7�f$,� Ëf��.,� ,T���� , >�<%,� ,,�Ë52�� �&�5 ,ÇB]E� 3>?t%$f9� SQf! X�f7 >29 ,�� � K ,

>29 ÍBJ�n���f�o3 Of|� >f&52�� �/[ ~%7 Î�;.�� �+Q,� �&�! �.c >+�I� >&��: ,>&!Q,� NB25,� �� S!���F 3

�−�+,� ¦�² �uF Å! ZM� Ï� ,Î�/j/,� �+,� �Lc �7� ,".f[w T�/e� 3[ ¥° �+Qf,� &G,� �2! a�� 1�f/"TBf�%,� ¥�f/5� " "f,�B, Ë[�VGf�,

n� o$Dn�: G#� H& aIA "& ,��f �3��. |�c&� G#� �SD#V: ���c&� ��%&� $Dn�: ~ ��D#-&� �U7 R9& ,

�9f�� 3�f� �I)H�#� SkA ��%&� �A) H�&� $���D-�&� y`�Nc&� ~ �m�b = , q-? o. �2 H�A)H:S.s: E�Z�� :$���D-�&� y`�Nc&� : WOOE

n� o�-%&� ���f ~ HVDn�: �.�N:E

n  o�Z�� :o.s&� ��Y&� :�PW O QE

n� o�Z�� :o&�x&� 3��&� :��W �uQE

n� o�Z�� :$���D-�&� y`�Nc&� : WQ E

n� oVDn�: �Z��~ H :�D,&� ����� :� W ��Q −�u� ,/I��-&� R��&� /&�& �-&� G#� a�S&� :� WPPu−P�� ,d���&� $�,? :W��O ,1s9&� (�n) :��W �Q ,8KS&� C�3Sf :�� W QO− Q�E

n� o�Z�� :$�L�&� �`��5&� : W� �E

n� oHVDn�: G#� H& �IA "&E

Page 18: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{ −

AB[ae� �+,� �Lc��F 3 �−�+,� �<! � F _ �7 _ ,A�L%,� ,�A�d$,� ,Ë�ªA�BM� , ��5�� ��

2$��D �+,� ��H »&�,� , _ �7 _ ,�A�fd$,� , �f&,0 �Gf/2J �af,��>+2$��2,� >�+.L,� 3

>29 A�L%,� �+,� �<! ÍBJn�{�f� o3 a�� (f�! Î�f;.�� �+Qf,� �2!�B�G,�� -BC/,��OF 3

N� �f� (s.f,� ! �+Q,� &G,� ÃB&� �� ()&�! �5c� �� ~%7 �b*�.|[ ��B&� ,"�f! �tf�! �! a�� �D� �/'.J Í #A� �� , �f� Of:A �fD��

S#%/� (&,�c�� SZ|[ ���]� m0 (�%,� O;� 3 R:M�<: �1Q( :

� &G,� Sa�<J .|[ �w0 �.s b �+Q, ,(�%,� 1<R "Cc� ,�f2! af�¼, ,�2� S#����� ,>f&��%,� TBf�%,� >f9�?A �f&,0 �)/D� c� b �&[ , Tf�/,� Xf�

>&��2,� TB�%,� Í >������ ,A�] 4/: ,�f, (;.fJ �f� ~f%7 U�fc t[ , ¢�f!".�# >�<!� �G&?A� �Qe� 3&G,� Sa�<J N0± ,(­.|[ ! , Í (�A��f/D��

���g� ,�c t[���dG,� T���� U��F , ZGf&,� Ah2,�f7 b0 (f�%,� �f� �2�C+ ¢()2� ,�Ja�<J ~%7 A#�Ce� ~%7 Y.[w �� ,>�c (�� ,()2�:− �−�+,� ABD �PF , A#��,�f$! �f7 u��$! �7 A#��,�$! �7 �$! �7 ��

n� o�Z�� :o.s&� ��Y&� :�PW O u ,o&�x&� 3��&� :��W �uuE

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :$�m3�&� y`��M&� : W����K�-? �.) E

n  oOu −�Z�� :$�L�&� �`��5&� :W�O� ,�Z��) :$�m3�&� y`��M&� :W��Q−�P�E

n� o�Z�� :1s9&� (�n) : W� QE

n� oo.s&� ��Y&� ~ HVDn�: :��W O��−O��E

Page 19: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

دين من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السع

− �{� −

�ff_ �ff7 ,Õ���ffL,� ,¥Bff/5,� Bff7� ,Off]E� Ë�Bffc.7E� , �ª�Z�ff,� ,Ë%���,� ,���&�5,� T�� 3 >29 ,�� � Kn��{f�o3 �tf�%,� �� S! �! (�%,� a��

�.ffV$,� �&L�,�ff$! Off|� ,Ô�A�ff5,� #Bff_ ��ff/,�� , #Bff_ UtffV,�� Ë�ªA�BM� ,�Ah�� �7�� ,�#�7�ª�Z5,� Fe�� ,Î�;.�� �+Q,�� 3 ÍBJ

>29n���f� o �−�+,� �&5! ��F ,�fD �f7 (+.V,�f$! �7 (&:.,�$! �7 _ �f7 �

� f&$! �f7 �$! ��: Ï� �7 �%9 , f_ Bf7� ,�.fV$,� �.f�,� ,Ë�.�� , ��.,�� (&�� ¯V7–}A�f� #<f7 Í X�C, (9� � F −�ª�Z�f,� ,Ë%���,�3 >29 ,� � � Kn���f� o >29 ÍBJ�n� �f�o3

 −(&��.70 �7 49B� �7 Å! �+,� �<! ,Ë��.,� ,Ëf52�� 3��f�J fc� %G,� Sa�<J Í �/'.J 3 ��af��� �+%Gf,� �Bf[A#� �+af,� �t�%,� �� B)�

t)2! 3 �−A&: �OF(&��.70 �7 �� �7 ,�G�� B7� , Ë��.,� , ËF%,� , Ëf52�� ,

Ë!��.,� , S.���,� O+hD ,"B;� X$G,�� ��/,� »&�7 -.%+� 3 Í ª�Z�f7 ,�� � K>?t%$9� 8Dt|,� >29 #�: ,t�! �! a��� (�%,� ��R Í O:A� "�! � ,

�B�e� ! ���3 Î�;.�� �+Q,� &G,� ! a�/J� , a�/J t[ ,�f+�=� , Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� !3 >29 ÍBJ n���f� o

�− ËF%,� �+,� .d� mBe� O6�5,� ¢�%,� �Ja�<J ��� , "a�/J ! ¦D

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :o.s&� ��Y&� :�uW P�−P�E

n� o�Z�� :���#�&� "X-. : W �O�E

n  o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :~�c&� a�&�&� :��W u� − u� ,o.s&� ��Y&� :�OW ��u−��Q , "X-.R�5&vD&� :��W uQE

Page 20: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{� −

"#�ª �\V��R �+Q,� &G,� ! ,U�c: " ! �.c 4fJ� (@ �+Q,� &G,� T�.,� #<7 ,&%� A�]�=� �A�25,� "�� _ mBe� }A, ,3 333333333 , N�[�

e�!=� , !Q/�=� , !A�=� , !#�]=�u��7 "��F 3 �−_ �Ja�<J ��� � FÍ�BM� 8G�� �7 �9B+ �7 _ �7 1�)� �7 ,

Ë52�� 3 >29 ,�� � Kn���f� o , >29 ÍBJ�n���f�o3�/J "�! �t�! ! a ,�+Q,� &G,� ()2� 3�J�52C� ~%7 �+Q,� &G,� �� X9 , Of|�" ¥°

¥�/5e�",� " �c�Be� ¥° "� " X,�fLe� ¥° �/&f��: ",� " S.[afJ ¥° >�&I� (�! Í ÕBL,�"3 8�]E� �2! a��� , >&7.%,�� , Î�%e�� , N�f&$,�� ,

uL2e�� ,>�&I�� 3 �− �Ja�<J ��� Å!�OF f_ �f7 (&��.f70 �f7 , �+Qf,� ,�+f,� ABfD ,

Ë2&G�� ,ËF%,� ,�ª�Z�,� ,Ë%���,� 3 >29 #�: Í ,�� � Kn���f�o3 a�� "#<7 �t�! �!3 S�.H �+Q,� &G,� �� X9 "�fc�Be� ¥° "� " ~f%7

-��V,� ��B:" �,�s� "�+��.�h,� ¥° " 3 >29 ÍBJn���f�3o R:�2��� �1Q(:��F

f|[ �+Qf,� &Gf,� Y�f5,*� Y. ,52Cf� 8GfM� f! �f7A��=� , �f)�[ S#�F/Gf� Y�52C� , >f,B$��� , AAf,�� .��B��f7 >f�&�� , �tf�%,� �f����J

UB$�,�7 , �)2� S#�5/9b�� , �)9A7 "%7 �� �B���� , Of��je� Í �)G+AJ� >&�%,� ,��B:� ¥�° �)&�! �B%6��3Î�[B�,� T���� U�c :"C� �J�52

n� o$���D-�&� y`�Nc&� : WOuE

n� o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :���N-&� "Z� : W��QE

n  o~ HVDn�: �Z�� :���N-&� "Z� : W�O�3 n� om�^. ~ H:�5�^. �Z��HVDn�: 3E

Page 21: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{  −

>%��D , Î�%e� SZ|[ ,Ê�5,E� >j6�� , f&�%/,�� �f�V/,� >�&�c"��F3 fc� Y�CfCd/,�� NB25,� ��s� Í &G,� �,� , >f&��2,� TBf�%,� Í ��Bf9 , ��

>&��%,� , >&9�&G,� Y�7�.L6b� �� (s.,� ! , >&!t/;b�� ,�­)� Ë/,� , Ë�<f9�� �Qfe� U�# �f� (&,�cE� l�J , tf[ f2! �f&,0 SA�f��� Y.f�

%G,� >'.J �! �+�� , �+¤�f%/� �D�[ tkE , >f%c.,� lf�J Pf5D Í� >&D�Ve� , <�A�� �)&� b�; Ë/,� ,(f�%,� Of;� �f� 3 (f�! Í �fJ�5,*� �f� ZGff5/,�" �+��.ff�h,� ZGff5J "� " T�ff�Â, Off+h2/,� A�BffD� ff! >&ff��: ����&$,�" , " -��V,� O?��� ! >&��: "� " m�f%J �,Bc ZG5J Í >,�9A

�2J�+i (q.29"3 �+�� (�! Í �J�5,*� ���" Ë$&L,� >]<� ! >&��: " f! >&f��:�

r&7�Ce� S�V��"3 Y�5,*e� ~%7 �,� ��5,� Í� , �)2�" ¥° ! >&��: >%+Qff,� ACff, >ff+�cB,�", � " u?�cff,� hff2[ ¥° ", � " >ff+�I� ¥°

Î�2&s.�," Ë52�� ��5,� Í �)/@<@�3 �f,� ~?�.f5,� Í� " ~?�.f� ¥° �D��FG,�"3

��5,� UB]� Í �,�" Î�ª�/5/�, r+B�/,� O?��� ! >&��: "� " f! >&f��: 2e� �/² ¥°/ �:��� �7b 4)"

>ff&7.%,�� >ffs<$,�� -�ff,�� Bffj2,� (ff�! Í �J�52Cff� �ff��" Í >,�ff9A -�,�" >&9A�5,�7 Ë�� ,� ".)/��" Z� -�7 "� " Bfj2,� Í >,�f9A " �+� Ë��=� , >&9A�5,�7 , S.)/��" Z� Bj27 � " >f2&��V,� ¥° ! >&��:"

>&f9A�5,�7 B��,� " UBfLe� f! >&f��: "� " �f/de� f! >&f��: ",

n� o�Z�� :o&�x&� 3��&� :��W �uQE

Page 22: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{� −

�" Ë[�VG�, ¥�/5e� �� �,�|,� (G�,� ¥°">s<$,� (�! Í �)/@<@� 3 >V�� Í �$/[ ��� " >V�� >+�� ¥° "� " Y�A���� ¥° ! >&��:

Y�)&$2/,��"� " 8f%,� >V� �L�,� ¥° ! >&��: "� " >fV: ¥° ��°��" 3

uL2e� Í �,��"Î�ª�f/5/�, >&Gf�,� >,�9.,� ¥° ! >&��: "� " ¥° �.HE� �/²" AB)�� B�� " Ë;Bs�G+x7 "

<fV,� (f�!� ?��%,� Í �$/[ ��� T" A�BfDE� X,�fL� ¥° f! >&f��: " 1�/V,� O]��" A�BfDE� X,�L� " �Bf�AE� �+f,� ��¯f, , >2f9 ÍBf/e�

n���f� o , Î�/j/,� �+,� �Lc �:° , >29 ÍB/e��n���f� o , �� B���+Qf,� &Gf,� ÃB&� 3 ��Bf: Sf! ¥Qf,� f! , &Gf,� >&f��: �f)2�

�+Q,� , � ��A3 �)2�� "e� ¥° �c�B" Ëf§�� �+,� �%, , �f)2��" ÕBL,� ZC2�, ?��%,� +.v ! Î�)5]E� ¥° ! >&��:" l,w Zs�

>%J�e� >%��2,� �/V,� �� 3 ����� ���2� :R� �>+��� �1Q(� !/!� �8� G&MN 6���"� :

#Bf;B,� Sf:� ��af� �f+.%J �,��2J Ë/,� A#�Ce� ��5J� , lf,w �fDp7e�:�� #B;B,� N� `.+ �a,� ��a , >f/$,� �f&� .|VJ b , Bf� m�f%J � N��

¢�%,� , m�%J � B� ¢�%,� N� `.:E�7 �� , 42%� N��" � b0 �f,0 b " " b m�%J � b0 #B;B�"3

#Bf;Be� Bf� � Npf7 ��ae� �a� �\] 45LC� T<9�� »&� -.! ��± �;B� O[ Í ;B+ �a,� #B , � #Bf;B7 #Bf;B� #Bf;B� O[�� Ò , #Bf;B7 b

Page 23: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{� −

�G5D , �, #B;� b w0 , #B;B,� tD0� ,#B;B,� 8! � O7��F3 �Dp7 >&2�� #�B; _ »&�,� 2! �5+.%J ��;�" #Bf;B,� Í #f%/,� Ëf5D ,

Y�#Bf;Be�� Y�#B;B,� >�&�: 87 �.5,� T!� , N��&f� f;B+ b �fD�� ,[ �;�� ��:� O�� ,";B� >�!�� � � K� F Z��, , ¦c�fD �V¬ .�i� , /Gf+ Z�,� �� "#B;� , f:�� #B;B,� tD0� , #Bf;B,� �f;�� Bf�� , �f7E��

ǪE� , .���,�� , �R�$,�� , "�B9 �� O[ B�"�OF3 >5G�5,� >!B9B� Í ��;" Of[ N0 UBf�+ #Bf;B,� Í ��a� #B;B,� S:�

� Bff� �� , � N� ���� Off[ Bff�3 ¢�ff%,� Bff� � N� �� , ¢�ff%,��B� �"��F 3

&�; .)�+ �a7�=� "#B;� �y ��ae� �a� N� , m�f%J , ¢�f%,� �af� Í , N�� � B� ¢�%,� �a� , m�%J , �J�w , >f/$,� �, .+��� �� b , Y�f$@0 Ëf2%+ Bf��

n� oaN-&� �I�. :�OW uu E H?�VU ~ =b���c&� R��&� 3�p R� ���-V&� �SK ag. aN� �I)"

$�#N-&� $-?34� 3�5�4� ~ $�&�-VD&� $D9M&�" , m�n�&� 8n�) =b���c&� R��&� 3�p ��� +�2" ���f4� 1�D: H�>? ,C�m�n�D&� aU) , on�: H�&�)�L#U 3�.4�" q.��,&� R. =A�&� �SK �A �U7 "h

$�L&z� ,�LU�3m� 8-^V%� /V&� ,$D92) �D#� H��& R. �� ��:A R. G#� �� , G#� "`�I ��K�&� �A)��n�&� o�Dn R. �2�) $N�NM&� ��%? �A ,m�n�&� aU �L0 ,m�n�&� H#U �A �DUE

n� o ��&� ~" dm�n�. "�K�� ��M^: �K) E

n  o "&�-.$�.s�z� $5%#5&� : W OOE

n� o$5%#5&� $����. :� W � � E�Z��) :Hj�K) m��jD& /5%#5&� "X-D&� :W�u , "X-D&�)���#p a�DX& /5%#5&� :� W P�Q ,$�?�-&� $,#&� oDXD& /5%#5&� "X-D&� :W � , $5%#0

m�n�&� d�2) :W�P−�� ,/?�-&� �95&� ~ m�n�&� d�2) :W Q�K�-? �.) ,�^V&� ~ �/DX-&� ��(�&� �?A 3�VU�&�) /-0�c&� R%2 3�VU�#& /.s�z� :W� u−� Q , ~ W�^�&�

��^V&� C�M#x^. :WO�� ,d�%�D&� $�?�-&� $����D&� :� W �Q�P , d�%�D&� $����D&�8K�SD&�) ���m4� ~ :� W ���P ,W���u−���Q ,/.s�z� ��0�-&� :W���E

Page 24: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{� −

��� S:�� Y�w , #B;B,� �a� Í ,,� �;�� B� #B;Be� N�� #B;B , ��� , #B;B,� �V¬ ���� , "h?�; �� , >�&��� ! �, #B;� <� , �.� ! 4/:� #B;B,�7 �5]� ,#Bf;� �f, N� f! <f�=�<�/Gf� = , �fJ�w A�f$/!�7 ,fV52�=�

Cd�/��=� #B;B,� �;�� �! �A�M� Í , #B;B�, .)�� �� �h; �D� ! O7 :�B,� ,#B;B,� �;��3

9 m0 �B$GD �aI� Å! �D& , �);� � T.[ , AB)�e� �+�� ¯� �D�" N�f[ �%� �� b� �"��F m�%J� �D�j$9 �Dp7 ,N�[ t[ Ng�3 � N� N�f+.+� ,

n� oVU ~ ���. R?� �5#&� �S� Hn�kA��2�V&� t� ,��Z�� :WuQ−Q E�5#? ��n) :"�� ��U , �3��:

G&�-:) , �/f aU a�I"�D2A 1�.z� ��� ,��%D&� �Z�� :��W �O� ,R�^M&� R? ���D� R� ,� W POQ ,d���K /?A R� ,/?���5&� 1�.�� ���) ,H& 3�N&� t�VU �Z�� :Wu� , ]�u F ,

3�hl� a9c. ]�f ~ =)�Mx&� 1�.z�) :���W QQ−O�� , ]�P� QF ,$�#M&� ~ "�-� /?A) :� W �� E �5#? +��M&� ~ ��n) :"H#�I �/f R9� "&) �� ��U E"HM�Mp ~ =3�_�&� 1�.z� ��� �DU :

��2�V&� t�VU :W�O�� , ]����uF ,HM�Mp ~ ���2 R?�) :��W ��−�� , ]���� F ,��U��D&�) a���?4� ~ }�Ib�X&�) :��W � −�O ,��&�)e�9&� R�%&� ~ /NL :�QW −O E

�5#? ��n) :"���; �/f R9� "&) �� ��U E" ,�5&) :" ���; �/f ��&) �� ��U " ,�5&) :" ��U �� ,an) (� ,���; �/f �) E"�5&) :"���; R9� "&) �� ��U E" ,�5&) :" R9� "&) �� ��U

�/f E"HM�Mp ~ =3�_�&� 1�.z� ��� �DU :��? t�VUy#_&� : WP�� , ]�O�Q�F , /NL��&�)e�9&� R�%&� ~ :�QW O ,3�N&�) ��YN&�) :W��� , ]�uF ,C�5^&�) ��D�4�) : ��? t�?

y#_&� :W��u ,m�NV���) :WQ�−Q ,��D�z� 8-f) :��W �O− �� , ~ ���2 R?�)HM�Mp :���W � , ]�����F ,���9&� "X-D&� ~ }��x&�) :��u , W �O , ]��Q�F ,

e�9&� R�%&� ~ /`�%�&�) :��%5V&� t�VU :�� W O�O , ]��� ��F ,3�N&� ~ /?���5&�) :WuP , ]�u�F ,$XM&� ~ $�%&� 1��I) :� W uP−u� ,|�3�V&�) $0�-D&� ~ =�%�&�) :�O W�QP ,3�hl� a9c. ]�f ~ =)�Mx&�) :���W O��−O� , ]�P�O�F , ]�P�O F ,

$-��c&� ~ =�nl�) :� W ��� , ]�O��F ,��2�V&� ~ $D�(k R?�) : WO�� , ~ "�-� �?A)

Page 25: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{� −

m�%J ,#B;B� N�[=� ¢�%,� u�� O$c , �%� #B;B� b� , Ng� B�� , �D�j$9 , m�%J� , U��� �a� ! ,�f%� �� b��F , � NBfV+ �f,� �f%� � , b �fDE

#B;B,� Í >&2&2@� , >f��Le� Sf:B,� O7 , U�hf+ b t&f�� UªE� Í #B;Be�f�:�� , "#B;� B�� , m�%J , #B;B,� �;�� , �D�j$9 ,"�B9 :� b3

!/!� �8� G&M� U�57(: ��ae� �a� (G�2+ , A�$/!b� �Gj7 , 8Gc m0 , Ë:�A ��a� , .�g��

�#�� 3��a� ��� N� m0 �7�jf]� ��af+ �a,� B)� Ë:�.,� #B;B,� S:� � , m�%J , Ëf�&��� #Bf;Be� B� , �J�f6B&� b0 Bf� �f� ¢�f%,� �af� N�� ,

�J�&�v� ,>&J�a,�3 #B;B,� N� �!�$J� `Z� �#�e� #B;B,� S:� ��a� ���� ���e� ¢�%,� �aI B� u��� F 3

�A�$/!� (&G�/,� �a� N� ¸:<D �jD� , Ë$GD , ~_ , �f&� -</�b� N�� ¸5�,� �Gj7 , Xc�B,� �Gj7 b , >�&���� , N� ! u5/� 8$�ae� <[ NE

S:�� >�&�: �A�M� Í �� , ��� , ���B9 �� b , ��� N0 �)9Ð �" � " , ��"¢�%,�" , ��" >%&$L,� " , �.f� b , Ëf�5, 8�+.f5,� 8f7 -<M�f� , b

Ë�&�: 3� � #Bf;B, Ëf5D ��afe� �a� N� ¸j�D �jD , m�f%J , �fL�7 ,

$�#M&� :�uW PQ ,���%5: ~ =�x&�) ,m�K d3�� ��%5: :�� W � ,H_�3�: ~) :�� WOu ,$�DLX&� G#� m�&� ~ /.3��&�) :W �P ,$DZ-&� ~ |�c&� �?A) :� W P�P , ]� �u EF �5#? ��n) :"�� ��U ,an) (� ,¥�-&� G#�, �/f aU a�I ��U) " ~ =�x&� ���n R?� ��� �DU

H_�3�: :��W Ou ,$DZ-&� ~ |�c&� �?A) :� W P� , ]� ��EF

n� oaN-&� �I�. :�OW uuE

n� o�Z�� :$5%#5&� $����. :� W � �−� P ,d�%�D&� $�?�-&� $����D&� :� W �Q�P ,H�K) m��D& /5%#5&� "X-D&� :W�u E

Page 26: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين من ن

− �{� −

>c�$,���F 3 � #Bf;B7 NB�?�fc (k� �!�$J� 4!#� N0� 4/: , m�f%J , �f;�� #B;B,� , :E� :�B,� , "�B9 b �a,� , ¢�f%,� �af� Í �D��fy (kBfV� ���e� , >&?h�� Y�#B;Be� "a� NB�%§� , �­�Cd�/7 S.|V/e� ,&� �J�f6B

, �&,�µ� , �J�C2�� , ()2� A�.c0 B)� , ¢�f%,� �a� Í :�B,� #B;B,� �j7 �#�e� ,�Gj�3

8Gfc m0 ()2f&7 t&f� NBGf�2� >&:�.,� #B;B,� S:� 1�j]� N0 (@ , >�&���� Xc�B,� Í S:� Ë� S:B,� "a� N� `.+ u+.� , �Gf2,�7 S.|V/� ,

Y���6��� , Y�A�$/!b�� ,\%e��ª�µ �)2! =� Y�f2Ve�7 , f! N�f[ N0� �/$,� �I #B;� b >�&��� �;� , �j&6BJ Ôp&9 �� ! , � ��� N0 , m�%J ,

ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� »&�,� >9Ae� "a� }�A !�3 P&f, �D� `.+ .�i u+.�� >��Le� S:B,� b0 >@ , Y�5/,� N�# , A�f$/!b�� (�Bf/,� O&$f9 ! 4/: ,

� m0 S.|V/� u?��: �� ���� B� �¬ � , `Bf9 (f@ t�± � , Bf� b0 P&f,� , m�%J� �D�j$9 ,8%$9 �7� >9Ae� "a� }�A !�� F3

G&M� VM& ��W(: ��a7 ��ae� �a� 4G+" #Bf;B,� S:� " , �f2! �+f�� Tf�J tf[3

��ae� �a� ! �)�� Í >j6�� >&G/,�� ,� #B;B,� N� `.J �kE f:� ,>/$,� �&� #%J b3

4G+� ,�+�=� , UBf��� ��af7 , f&�+ fc�" T�f%,�7 " , ��" UBf���

n� oaN-&� �I�. :�OW Q� ,�)�#k R?� $.�N. �Z��) :W���E

n� o�Z�� :�)�#k R?� $.�N. : W��O ,1s�z� �Z� ~ $�0�^&� : WP�O�K�-? �.) E3

Page 27: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{� −

T�%,�" , &�+ c�" u�Le�7 " , U��&�: " uf�Le� UBf��� "��F , 4Gf+ fc� #��b� O�� ��a7 , &�+ c�" T�%,�7 " , �+�=� , U��&�: " T�%,� #��b� "3 &� �7� T���� U�c>: " 1�/[ >2�J �� " (V�� ·BC� " , �� ��[�� ���

T<V,� ,=2R�7 .5[ �Dx�� �.����=� , ".��f� �f� r$c� �2R�7� , 4Gf+ �af�� S:B,� O�� ��a� , UB��� O��� , #��b� O���"� F3

��a� ¯� �, .�i ¦D Í�± �" >+#��b� "� " >f&,B��� " #Bf;B,� Sf:B7 ,U�c �&: :"2� (@ ()– >�V/e� �� �� , >5G�5/e�� , >�BC/e��− fc ��

>&)�� ��a� m0 �)2� �.� , >+#��b� ,>&,B����;UB�&� : �;B,� l,w N0 –m�%J �,Bc Í �� : �);� b0 l,�� �� O[ – Y�2?�V,� #B;� B� , �;��

"#B;� B� � , Y�f2?�V,� #Bf;� "#Bf;� NBfV&� , #Bf;B,� 8f7 hf&+ b �ff;�B,� , �ffVe� #Bff;B,�� , Ï.ff! �ff7� UBffc Bff� tff[ , 8%$ff9 �ff7����BjD�"�OF 3

!/!� �8!� J!�� 9D)�: 7�$9� �t�%,� .[w=� �&,0 O&e� m0 ��ae� �aH 8�?��,� �!# S! , �7 a�E�� ,

5,�² �DB[ �� (s.,� !=� UB�2e�� UB�%e� Ybb, , >f&q$,� Yt�Ge�� ,

n� od�^V_D&� $�5%#5&� $����D&� ~ ��n :W��� H^� �. "'�#M&� 8KS. : a`�N&� 8KSD&� �K/L&� �/f aU �>? ,d�2�) $N�N2 $-��x&�) �� �A) E"

�#k R?� '�I)C��`�9&� m�n�? '�N� R. ��� m�n�&� d�2) ��%5: ~ �) :" ~ $�.�U "��N&� C�7 �A C�h�MD&� ,�L��%M. ,�L&�N-.) ,R�3�^V&� ~ �� d�MV. ,�L& �K�Z. �L#U /K),EEEE , =A3 �K)'�#M&� aKA E"�Z�� :HV.�N. :W��O EW $5%#5&� C�M#x^D& a.�c&� "X-D&� ~ ��nO�u :"

y#xD&� '�#M&�m�n�&� d�2) �K $�D�: R?� ��� ~E"E

n� o�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W O�� ,W�QO ,�Z��) :� W ��� ,W���E

n  o�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W PE

Page 28: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

À,�� >&2&�&,� Y�A� , �f7 Ntf+��� ���,� m0 (H �: �a,� t� , Y�f$|,�� �&�! , >f���# 8��.f7 T�)f9 �f&;BJ �� (s.,� ! , �f�L$J , �f! �&Cf�J�

1�BC,�� u�� ���a�3 1�$9� S! �t�%,� .[w ,�)2�:− �− Î�;� �7 UB�,� �$9 N� , Ëc�w , T�f�� Í Ëfcz,� m0 Xf;.+ Ë5�f[

��25,���F, (f�%,�� 8f�&,� Y�f;A# f!� m0 �$:�f] #Bf�+ �af,�� , Nxf�-A�%,� , (�2! , >&�BC,� �J�6�+A Í �.�/9� �w0 , >&[B�Gf,� �fJ���µ� ,

�BGf,� S���f� �! >$&�,� T��� m0 OC&9 �+A <7 �Dx� , S���f� �f!��J�w , �/$&s� �?�2� T��� A��j/9� �! 4/: O7 , X�� T��� B�� , (�f2! ,&: >f&c�w Sf:� Í >,B�%e� S���e� S.|V,� "a� X/v � ,�f)&� .f|VJ b3

S:B,�7 AB%�,�7 u�� c NBV+ T��e� �a� ³�7 �w0 l,�G,�� ,u?���� >$&s� , "#B�&� ,&?���J=� , S.|V,� Ë5D m0 , S:�� >�&�: Y�$@0� , �f;�� Y�w Ëf� #B;B,� ,¢�%,� �a� AB] Í ÅF/e�3 �e� �a�� T� , >&�BC,� 2! ��25,� T��� Ë2!� ,��BfD�; Ë[B�Gf,� ��f25,� �f2� Ëc<�E� , >�B�ae� -�]�E� �! ��25,� B�� , Of?�wA �f! Åd/f,� 42%7 �<�E� , �)�?��57 Åj/,�� ,�&D,�7 u�%/,� �.J�� F3

n� o�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W O�O ,W�� −��O ,���W �u�K�-? �.) ,

R�9&�%&� �3��. :WQ� E

n� o/��x&� '�I :"�5�&� $5p ���0 ���5&� ,oI) '�2 G&� ]�)����) o�D&� ���0)E"�Z�� :oD#&� : W��� ,=��cN&� '�I) :"$.�.SD&� ��p)4� ��N� G&� ���5&�? 1�N&� 3�fA , EEEEEEEEE R� G�0 RD0

dm�DMD&� C�5^&� H�#� C�jL� $.�.SD&� H0�p)A E"$���cN&� $&���&� :W�� E � R� =7�?s9&� '�I)���5& :"$��c�&� C�5^&� R� $��,&� �K ,EEEE ,aLX&� /K /V&� ,"#Z&�),EEEEEE ,

H�� G�5: $D�.7 $5p aU) ,Hj#Ln HD#� 8j#,� �A G�-D? ,HjD#� H&��) ,H���5U ��9f) , �L&�g.A)" ��-V&� :W� �E

Page 29: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�#�A�� ��25,� �2�� , "A�f&/��� �fJ#�A� �J���f� �! �.e� 425+ N� 42%7E�,�%� , � S#�Ax7 4�$+� , �,�%��� , �f&�! �fk�+.; ¸:<&f� , Í �f� f!�

��[ #B;B,���F � `B9 �� (&�%J �! ��25,� �2�� , � (&�%J Í ���$,�� ,m�%J� F 3

>+Q$,� P52,� ÊB�: �! ��25,� �2���OF , Y���f6�� ¶��90 �2� �+.c� , Y���&,� ¶��90 �� , Ï UB/+ b �&j7, Ç� , Ë2�� , Ç0�± , Å!�± , Ëf2!�± � ,

Í�±��F 3 Î�;B,� ��25,� �2�� , Î��.%,� , Ë�%,� , `BGf,� S���f� �! ��25,� B��

A�&sE���PF3 Y�a,�7 �2&2%+ �a,� B� �B2,� �a�� , >,pGfe� "af� Í , A��fe��5Di �)&,0=� , #B;B,� S:B7 UB��, �$9 Ë� Ë/,�� 3�f� �Bf2,� �af�� ��f25,� Y�;A#��F ,uf�� Y�5Cf7 4�$+� �J�5]� �G5D �! 425+ N� ���D#� 3 �f2��

n� o{��&� �SK ~ /��x&� '�I :"H&�-0A ~ ��-&� ���3 ���0 �K ,&7 ~ H& �� 1��N?�E"oD#&� :W��� ,

�Z��) :A 8KSD& ��-V&�K��^V&� a : W� � ,$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W P�O , R. }�g&� {��&����5&�E

n� o�Z�� :��^V&� aKA 8KSD& ��-V&� :W� �E

n  o=7�?s9&� '�I :"��ZM&� R� G�5� �A �K ,�2 �&7 R. �/f ~ H& ��9� s0 E H�� �N%�)(��DV&�E"�Z�� :��-V&� :W� O ,�Z��) :�3�-D&� �3��� :W ��E

n� o�Z�� :oD#&� :WP� ,�U7 �. H#g.) ,�Y�A ,��2�V&� ~ H&�I b��_&� ��-� /?A R� oD#&� 82�p :" �/f aU R� ��-&� �)�k , �L�&�V. G&� ���f4� o�Dn m3)" E�Z�� :oD#&� : WPOE

n� o���5&� {���A ~ ��-V&� ~ '�I :"f4� R� $��,&� �K ���0) ��� ,��A3< ,G��. ���0 ��U �DU , H�#�1s%&� ,a�X#& H?3 G#X: R�2E"��-V&� :W� P ,�3�-D&� �3��� �Z��) :W ��E

n� o�Z�� :$���cN&� $&���&� : W�O ,$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W P�O−P�� ,�3�-D&� �3��� :W ��− �u ,�Z��) :/.s�z� ��^V&� G&� ak�. :W��Q−��� ,0�^&� $5%#5&� d>c� $�

�K3�x:) :W��P−��� ,��^V&� G#� ����A : WO�QE

Page 30: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

AB)�e� �+�� :"�7 XG+ �a,� �%9 �2[ ,�7 �$+ �a,� "�7� , "f+��H ÁL$+ Ë/,�33"��F 3

u�� Y�5] �! 425+ N� �)&�+� , u�� "#B)�7 , �f?�2�� �/$&�7 Ë�J.+ N� �� �G5D �! , � Y�5Cf7 �?��7� >f$J.e� "af� m0 , �f! 4f/: 4f25+ N� Ëf��

m�%J �J�5] S���� , �J�w >�:<�� S���7 , m�%J , >�h2e� , S#.Fe�� ,Y�a,� Í S.|[ �;BJ >5] O[ �! 3

>f&�V,�7 �[<)/9�7 �?�2� #B)� �! 425+ Np7 ��25,� �J�.� !� m0 Ë�J.+ (@u�� #B;� Í3A# !� >;A,� "a� �D�[ tD0� ��25,� Y�; , ¶��f90 �fkE >&�V,�7 >&2&2@<, ,N�/�7�G,� N�/$J.e� �H .%�J Ë/,��K � � K3 m�E� >f$J.e� Í B� w0

u?��: ¾<@ ���+; "��2� , u�� Y�w� , u�� Y�5]� , >f&D�|,� >$J.e� Í� 8/�&�: ���+ , "��2� , u�� Y�w� , �J�5] N�# , �.f|VJ �f;BJ Ëf/,�–

A�$/!� B,�+=� – �J�w Í , uf�� b0 ���f+ b >f&D�|,� >$J.e� Í� , m�f%J , <f� ���+ , "��2� 4/: , �J�w A.�J �;BJ Ë/,�� ,>&2&2@<, >�h�/Ge�3 Í (f@ tf�

u�� :�B,� b0 #B;B,�3`�.)G,� T���� U�c t[ � F :

n� o�Z�� :��^V&� aKA 8KSD& ��-V&� : W� O ,$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W P�O , +&�g&� {��&����5&� {���A R. E

H0�� /��N&� +��M&�) :"'�I �� �� :t�M&�? HV�7T �N0 ��&) /& em�� R.< , =��� /&� t�N: �.)�0� �D. /&� 82A �/c?H�#� �� ,H�2A GV2 a0���&�? /&� t�NV� =��� '�(� �.) , HV��2A �7�0H? oD%� =S&� H-D� ��U ,H? �^�� =S&� ��^?), EEEE"HM�Mp ~ =3�_�&� Hn�kA +��M&� ,

��I�&� t�VU ,o���V&� t�? , ]��P� :F W� ��E

n� o1s�z� |�f �K ,�DM. R? ����� a���D�� �?A ,/#� R? ,=3�^�4� ,=)�L&� ,~�^&� 1�.z� ,/#��M&� H�N5&� E $�� �&)�OQ�jK F , $�� ~�:)��u�jK F�L�. C�5�^. d�� H& :" R��`�%&� 'b��.

"��^V&� ~ , �L�.)" 1s9&� 17 "�&7 ��;) E

Page 31: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

f:�� �f� f:�� �f� :�B,� :� ��± � fff:�; "fff:� �fff� Offf[ w0 fff&:BJ �fff/%D �fff! ufffL2+ �fff� fffff:�B,� �fffff)�L7� >fffff+A�! "ffffff&:BJ "�ffffff+0 "ffffff&:BJ fff:E �fff/%2+ �fff� �fff%D�

�− #��b�� UB��� Ë/+.�27 (&�G/,� m0 X;.+ �7 UB�,� �$9 N� , U�c Ë/,� >&�BC,� ~%7 �H , #�Gf;� Í UBf��� Of$�J �fD�[ �w0 >f&I�� Y�a,� NE u�M� �� >5?�R , �H #��b� �� , XD�� <� , a�2&:Ò , UBf��� �a� r$C+ N� ,

#��b� �� ,��!=� Y�cB�de� X&' O�+ , b0 #Bf;B,� Í NBfV+ �, ��w w0� S:�� >�&�: , � Y�w Ë�� ,":���F3

 − #Bff;B,� Sff:B7 UBff�,� N� `.ff+ �ff� ��ff2� , �ff;� ff! T<ff9�� Í ·BCM� , �je� AB2,� S.V� �h� m0 X;.+–�� Zf|[ f2! Of|+ �a,

~ HVDn�: �Z�� :"ZV�D&� :�QW ��−�P ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� : ��u W P�O�K�-? �.) , d�US:

��5M&� :�O W ��uO−��Q� ,$#?��M&� C�N�� :� W ��− �u E 'b��. H?�VU ~ C��?4�)R��`�%&� :W�OQ

=)�L&� m�� "& �DV2)< ,m�n�&� d�2�? '�N&� C��?4� �#: R. �� HD23 , R�� y&�_&� �A)��#_D&� ,H? m�3A �D��) ,"�N&� R?� H& 3SV�� �DU ,m�Lc&� d�2) , d�K�c. R� H`��0 ~ 8�,� �>?�) e�%&�3��;4 ,oI��&� ~ dm�n�. ��; ��A � E=)�L&�) ,G&�-: �� HD23 , H:�5&v. ~ H�� ��-� �

HX�)�:) H& 3�^V��� �) 8KSD&� �S� '�N&� H:�3���) ,"LY-? R� �LVf� �DU E R�9&�%&� �3��. ~ "�N&� R?� ��� H:��?A H�n�: ~ �Z�� : W����−��� E

n� o�Z�� :� ��^V&� ~ C���3m/.s�z :W�Ou E 8�%&� �SK ag. G&� �-%&� H�� �I) ,'�I +�2 :" ~ R-.A �7� �&�%&� �>? ��#`�N&� $0�^VD&� q-? �

��#%&� ,'�p�&� $X& "Z-. @�k) ,H�0 �� aM� �D?�0 ,����U ��#� ��D&�Z&� '�N� �D� G&�-:< < ,�DX&� ~ 3��&�U ,(��D: � +�M? ,H? �MV� )A ,$����h� � +�M?,���,: �) ,��A �K '�N� �A Jp) ,

�K ��A) ,/L�&�) �.4� o5:�� S���2)B ,�c�&� R. 3�^V� ��. 8��X-&�) 8���,&� R. �LZ�) E �m�%0) ����&� R� /�;" E�p�ND&� ]�f :� W ��E

Page 32: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

u�M� �$� >&�BC,� ��–>&2&�&I� U�%5,� O�%,� S.V57 ��F3 �− �fH UBf�,� N� `.+ �� ��2�� , T<f9�� Í , >&�BCf,� .@pfJ m0 Xf;.+

#B;B,� �;�� >�&�j7 S:B,�7 8�?��,� , 8&�<9�� >59<5,� 2! , �&: �J�w 8! � #B;� Np7 �b*� Èc ,p7 (IBc X�#Bf;B,� Bf� � >�&�: N3

L&G7 � Y�w N� N�.+ >59<5,� N� �D�&7=� , &�&�:=� , �h2�=� �� >$?�� �� �! �[z,� �?�B� ,%�#=� �;�&/:b , <!� O; , �?h; m0 ��/_ �[.e� NE ,

�, NBV+ N� �B5D �a� !� , m�%J , �fJ�w ! ?�ª #B;� , ��af,� Í Bf,� ,��0 Th�&� �&�!� � NBV+ N� , m�%J ,J�w=� #Bf;� Zs �� ,#Bf;� ��=�#.fµ =�

>&��e� �!3 u�f,� ��A�/�� >&�BC,�� >59<5,� �� #B;B,� S:B7 NB�?��,�� Î�|,� , �DB[ B�� , m�%J ,#B;�=�#.µ =� >&��e� �! , S:B7 UB�,� p�D �&�!�#B;B,�� F 3

�− �H UB�,� �$9 N� ~%$,� `.+� ,�� Í T<9 , NBf[ `Bf!# m0 X;.+ � , m�%J , N�fV� O[ Í ,>]BCf² >f);� hf&j7 ¦/f² Zfs3 Xf�# �f¬

¢�%,� �a� ��h;� X&' Í �,B�: #��/!� m0 �7�j]� , UB���f7 �2! \%e� B�� T�%,� , Ö5e� , t/: ,#B;B,� S:B7 UB�,� m0�OF3

n� o�Z�� :��^V&� G#� ����A :W � E�������. ��cV%D&� R� �&vD&� �SkA �I)E

n� o�Z�� :aN-&� �I�. :�OW Q�E

n  o$�D�: R?� '�I :"$�DLX&� $�&�#2 '�I ,��&�N� R�S&� :��9. aU ~ H:�S? H�� , �&7 '�N� �DU $�3�X�&�– 3�X�&� R�%2 {��:A –$�DLX&� R. "K��;) , R. m�M:��) '�#M&�? R�#`�N&� ��vK)

�2�) ��n ,$�DLX&� m��� G#� 8#;A '�#M&� ��0 ,"LV�0�p) ,"LV.��) ,&�) /5�&�) 8#;A a�x-V"L�D#9V.) "K3�Z� G#� ,���f �)��-� � $�DLX&� a�I �DU< ,�/f aU �)��-� $�DLX&� $0�^V.) E

"�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W Qu ,� �Z��) W �QPE

Page 33: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف

− ��� −

�−9�� Í �H UB�,� p�2� N� `.+ �� ()2�� T< , ~f%7 #�f�/!� m0 X;.+ � NB[ 8�V/e� �.� , m�%J ,#B;B�=�>); Í b ��F , OCf527 P&f, ��

¢�%,� �! , OC/7 b� , O��7 b� , �A�� b� , �f2H �f&,0 A��+ b �&j7 �]�C/�� �! ��h2J �$@ �w0� ��2� b� , m�%J , N�V�� >)F7 , �)&� �+�y

���� , �&� ()2+�$+�, �2! �j$+ N� UB�%,� ~%$7 ��.,� �a� `#� , m�f%J , >�B�%e� Y�#B;Be� Í , ��#B;� u�j/e� , �DB[ `B!# m0 .�2,� (�.L6��

#B;B,� O[ B� ,%�#=� r;.f� <f7 r&;z,�f7 ()&f�! ��z!<, , Bf, t&f�8%� #B;B� Í "BC�� F 3

�−¤ Ë5G�� ��ae� �aH UB�,� X;.� N� `.+ �� ��2�� - , �f, Np� b -B�V,�� &;�Be�� ���wE� Í , >/$,� , Ëf/,� S#�fe� Í .�2,� m0 X;.+ B��

¢�%,� �)2� u�� ,82@� 8,t/:� �� .�E� B�� b w0 ? Ë� �¬: b�S�: � NBV+ N� , m�%J , ¢�%,� u�� c , "�B9 �� �� , S.+�f�� S#�f� �� �J�a, ,�2! >�C52�3 Ã�d��: N� �J�w �� ���� NBV+ , � Ë� ¢�%,� S#�� N� 42%7 ,m�f%J3 �f&�!�

� NBV+ N� ��0 , m�%J ,<[= K , "W�h;� ¢�%,� Y�#.5�� ,&�[ NBV+ N� ��0�=� , �J�&?h; ¢�%,� Y�#.5��3 � Y�w B� ¢�%,� #B;B� ��w �� �a� N�[ ��B9� ,

m�%J3 � NBV+ N� O&j/G+ �B,�c (@ ,J m�% , �J�a, S.+��� S#�� �� ¢�%,� u�� , ��

�B,�c .�i 42%7: � >f&��� Zfs ¢�f%,� >f&��� NBfVJ N� O&j/G+ , m�f%J ,

n� o�Z�� :aN-&� �I�. :�OW Q E

n� ou7�G,� ACe�3

Page 34: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

��.,� �a� �.� ! �DE l,w�– � Y�a, S.+��� ¢�%,� S#�� NBV7 O?��,� – � u�� Ë/,� S#�e� "a� Nx� , m�f%J ,BfVJ N� �f�0 Bf�Æ b ¢�f%,� �f)2� N

T! �� >@#�: , >+c NBVJ N� ��0� ,U�je� Th�+ 86.5,� <[ !�; �f�� �f� b #B;B� UBC: Th�+ �D¼� T! �� >@#�: S#�e� "a� NB[ �.� !

S#�� , �� �� b �� , "#.fJ UBf�%,� >��7� , �f�L$J� , �f&|[ ¢�f%,� NE �?�|[ �� �,*� , T�.;�� ,�� �?�f|V,� lf�J �fJ� �+� �� T�.f;E , b�� b �� O�%+3 >f+c S#�fe� "af� NB[ �.� ! ���� – Zfs (+f�,�� T%7 �B$G�– r;.�� >�! Zs �� #B;B,� Í S#�� UB�# Th�+ �D¼� , NE

(+�,� #�§x7 u�%/J b SA�/de� SA�,� , O]�j�, O&C� �DE ,�59 B�� 3 � b0 u$+ ¢ �&��7 U�E� Ut/:b� OL7 �w0� � Y�w �f� ¢�%,� S#�� NBVJ N ,

m�%J� �D�j$9 , #Bf;B,� Sf:B7 �f2! \%e� B�� , >f&2&2@� b� .f|VJ b w0 , :�� #B;B,�� , m�%J � #B;� B� ,":�3

�− #Bf;B,� Sf:� ��af� Sp�f27 UB�,� �h%+ ()�%7 , T<f9�� Í , m0Z|V,� �­�A��0� �&,0 >2G,�� 1�/V,� .��B� Ybb# S , r+�f/,� �)&� Ë/,��

Y�cB�de� O[ Np7 N�&:E� �� Z|[ Í , �)�%7 �� ,�J�w � Ë� 3 ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� ��.,� �a� O|� m0 ��w c� , f! U# c �D� 4!#� �&:

>2G,�� 1�/V,� �� S! ·BCD S:B,� Í �$�a� , Ybbf,� Of%+ �fD��K � � K �)&D�%� �� S.���,� ,m0 �BF�,� N�# �f)�+�pJ , >f,�*e� Of%5+ tf[ , �+af,� l,w ��A� �� NB�.+ , (��B!# �G: , � �+h2J ,m�%J3

Page 35: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

m�_�9 q��w ±�T��� n"' Pp: " "�f+0 b0 ��$%J b� l7A Èc� K ± K � × �� �± ±� �K � � � � �"��F ¯f� Ï.! �7�" Èc " 42%7 " (V: " , Ac �� , "Ac� � (V: Í N�[ �w0�%+ b N� $%+ #B$%� O[ N�[ "�+0 b0 $ , ¢�f%,� AB] �� #B$%e� �a� N�[ �+� ,

m�%J � B�3 m��9 q��w �!<� n"' 7d��: " b0 PfD��� �f�� �f��� �f�� ± � � � ± �� � � �K � � �N�$%&,� K K � � �"� F 3

m��9 q��w �(���:n"+ 4/: ()G5D� Í� ���g� Í ��2J�+i (q.K29 � � � �± � � �� � �K �� � �� � � � �fD� (fI 8$/K �± �� � ±K � �u��× � �"�OF3��ZG5J Í Ï.! �7� U�c : " ���g� Í ��2J�+i (q.K29 � � � � � � � �� �" �f� B� ���

l2� �.�,� " ()G5D� Í� � � � K � �" l2&! B�� ," (I 8$/+ 4/: � ±K � � � � �� ±" .��f2�, �� ," u�� �D�× � � K ± �" �JAB] lD0 �&: �� , l:�A B��,33333333 , b ¢�f%,� ABf]�

<]� �)2! u�� U��ª �V+= , >�&���7 �, >&�B,E� j�"o��F 3 m��9 q��w �(���: " �Ø � �;� (|� �B,BJ t�2+p� K � � � �± �� � � �× K �"�PF , m��9 q��w�: " (V%� B�� � �K � � �K (/2[ �� �+�� �K K � � �"��F , m��9 q��w�: "�,�� .�g�� U�E� B� ± � � ± �K � � �K � K�R�$,�� .��K � �� � K �"��F 3

m��9 q��w �(���: " �V,� �&�A w0 �&�A ��� ()�/c �Ø � �V,� (�B�/�J (�� ± � � � � K ± �� �� � � K �� �� � � � � � � �� � � �� � K �K

n� o����z� d3�� , $�l� O E~ /?�� R?� =A3 �Z��) :V5&�$�9D&� C�2� :��W O�� ,W��P ,� W �u ,WPQ� ,�OW �u ,��W ��� ,W�� , W��� E"9M&� W�^0 :W� E

n� oC��3�S&� d3�� , $�l�P� E$�l� �SK '�2 /?�� R?� =A3 �Z��) :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�� W���−���E

n  o�#^0 d3�� , $�l�POE

n� o"9M&� W�^0 : W�Q3 n� od�N�&� d3�� , $�l���P ,~ /?�� R?� =A3 �Z��) :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W ��PE

n� o���M&� d3�� , $�l�� ,~ /?�� R?� =A3 �Z��) :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�� W ��P ,� W ��uE

n� o���M&� d3�� , $�l�O ,~ $�¨& /?�� R?� ��%5: �Z��) :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W OQ� −OQ� ,"9M&� W�^0 :W�� ,W�P E

Page 36: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

4�A �Ø �� �"��F 3��ZG5J Í Ï.! �7� U�c: " u�� X� ¢�%,� Y;� Y.�D �w0 >7�|e� "aH , SZ: X6B� , B� b B� ,w0 �&�A �� �&�A , 4f�A � �V,� ,

�7 �7 t7 (/d� , �9B,� �� �.%� �&, �&� , Ëf5D 8f7 �f9� �fDx� , Bf���,Bc: " �&�A ���" , Y�$@0 87� ,�f,Bc B��: " 4f�A � �fV,� " , Bf���,Bc:�D� � �V, �D� �w0 �D� �� 3 .��f�,� Í �f2�<[ Í �f2,Bc 4f2%� �a)�

.���e�� , �2&! �D�� ,/�� X� .���e� AB] -<"� F 3 Y�+g� �� l,w Zs�3

�f$�a� >jf] f! �f)2� >f5?�L7 )�f/9� f�� �+#�:E� ���; "af� �f� �,Bc �+#�:E� , (�9� �&�! � ] , Õ�,� �+�� Í , � Ç� �C+:

" �$:� 4/: O��B2,�7 Ç0 1.�/+ �$! U�h+ ��� , �%f9 �f2[ �f/$$:� �wx� �7 XG+ �a,� ,� �7 �$+ �a,� "�7 , �H ÁL$+ Ë/,� "+� , Ëf/,� �f�;A�

�H �+,3333"�OF , (�9� �&�! � ] �,Bc� ,Õf�,� �+�� Í: " N0 � , O;� h! ,>��&�,� TB+ UB�+: Îf%J (f�� �6.� T#i �7� �+ K ,U�fc: �f+

? 8e�%,� 1A �D�� �#B!� �&[ 1A3333333"��F , �+f: �)2��: " N0 �

n� od3��'�5�4� , $�l���E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W ��� ,�Z��) : �O W P PE

n  oHX��_: 1�N: E ¡.�K �Z����Q EF~ +��M&� �SK '�2 /?�� R?� 1sU �Z��) : C�2�V5&�$�9D&� :�OW P��E

n� o"#%. J�Mp ~ +��M&� 1�D: �Z�� ,$#^&�) �&� t�VU ,q��D&� dm��� aY0 t�? : W����−���u , ]� P�QF , �U7 H.�D: ~ ��n �I)" �VD-xV�� " , �U7)" �V�N%V�� " E R?� =A3 �Z��)

~ ~�^&� /?�� :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W ��� ,� W PQ�E

Page 37: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�JAB] ! T#i u��"��F3

n� oHM�Mp ~ =3�_�&� Hn�kA +��M&� ,��S�V��� t�VU ,1s%&� ��? t�? : W���� , ]

�� � F �5#?" H:3�p G#� 1mT �� y#k " , "#%. Hn�kA)HM�Mp ~ ,$#^&�) �&� t�VU , t�?Hn�&� t�� R� /L�&� :W��O , ]����\ �� F , �5#?" 8�XV�#0 ��kA "U�2A a:�I �7�

Hn�&� ,H:3�p G#� 1mT y#k �� ��0E"~ /?�� R?� 1sU �Z��) :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W � O−� � ,� W P��E

H�0 �V#� R�VI�0 d�D� +��M&� �SK) , �#D�A �DK�V#U ~ R��KSD&� �K�n �sVk� o. ��&� �K��$D%XD&� �DK��2� ;G&�-: �m�n) $N�N2 ,+��M&� �SK �� �K�Z? �)SkA R�S&�) ,�� �� ��&�N0 ,

G&�-: ,��Y�A) ]3��n R. 8U�. "%n ,H:3�p) ��%�z� $��K G#� �K) , "K��� ��%�z� �4�K��A) C�I�#_D&� aDUA ,d�_%. H& /K) , G#� �)�� "L�9&�� C�7 (�D: "L�KS. apA ,G&�-: ,R�I�#_D&� C�)7 R� ,W�_&� �m�n�? ,dm�-V. ��0 "K) E �D�0 "L0sVk� R. ";�&� G#�)

�� G&� �)��%� ,G&�-: ,��Y�A) ]3��n R. ,H�A G#� ��N5V. "�A �� ,G&�-:) H��M�� , "%n��%�z�U ,��%�z� $��K G#�) ,��Y�A) ]3��n R. 8U�. E

e�k4�)m�n�&� d�2�? R�#`�N&� $�0�^&� ds; ,��K�� G#� +��M&� �SK �)�nA +�2 , ��#-n)m�n�&� d�2) ~ "L�KS. $Mp G#� "K��� d�D� E�� �A $&��&� Hn) ,G&�-: , H%5� �p)

')(�&�? ,$�-D&�) ,R��� H& �A) ,��) ,R��) ,R��A) ,an3) ,�M�), EEEEE|&� , �L#U �SK)1mT ��p)A ,#� �SK '�0�� d3�p G#� 1mT �A G ,1mT d3�p G#� ��) ,�K �L0 E$Ln R. �SK ,

1mT �A e�kA $Ln R.) ,1s%&� H�#� ,/^_c&� H:�7 H? m��D&� ��& , 3��&� G#X. H? m��D&� a?=�DMD&� ,$��DMD&� $N�NM&�) a.�9&� ��%�z�) ,H�0 q�5� =S&� ,s�) an , "&�� G&� �m�n)���U4� ,) ��D�4� d�Y2)C�5^&� E ����A 3�p ~ �L%5�? �L%5�& $�L&z� C�S&� G#X. �K 1m©0

r�ND&�) r�I4� q�5&�? H�� �-D&�) C��9DD&� ,e�� �) ��; "h �D0 , G&�-: �m�n) �� "h �.)m�n�&� �SK ~ �K�Z&� E

:T�. G#n) "&�-&� H�0 �� �n)A =S&� G#XD&� H�>? /.ml� �5&� ~ 1mT /?�� R?� �p) �S&H , �DU/&b4� �m�M&� ��%�z� H�>? H5p) ,=�?4� "`��&� �¡�&�) ,y#_&� yM&� �K) E

Page 38: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

1mT R� =�`�(X&� 3m�N&���� ��.4� '�I) :""��I /&bA H�� ,y`�NM&� $N�N2 /K /V&� HVN�N2 3��V��? ,

C���-V&� ')A) ,/L&z� "#-&� ~ �V�h R�� ')A) ,$�L&z� d3�^&� +�2 R. ')4� �L0 ,��0m3) H : �� H:3�p G#� 1mT y#k ��"

+��M&� �SL& H�n�: R. �gUA $��DX&�) $�%&� aKA R. $D`�&) ,H&�I ~ ��DY&� m�� G#� ���? :"H:3�p"? �7�. G#� E �� /?�x_&� '�I"��L&�"R��K�� R�D�� R�? $���U �-I) ,�� G&� ��^: �A J#^� "#0 ,an) (� ,

��& H�A G#� a�&�&� 1��N& H��M�� d3�p =S? "�/f H#gDU ��& " E1mT G&� �L-n�. ��90 ,$5x� $N#_&� A��. ~ ����U �3���A ��N#k �D�� 1mT $�37 �A G�-D&�)< ,$N#� "h ,$,Y. "h , �)3�p "h

�3�p< ,$�nA ,aDM&� d�. "V: �A G&� ,��5�A �)�&��0< ,�)�9� �A G&� �3�,p ���c��)< , '�� "V�0"L.�%nA E'�N� :�$5^&� �SK G#� HN#k R9� "& 1mT � ,�.�: �N#k �n) $N#_&� HV&)��: �. ')A H�9&< < ,

���37 ��V� H&�� E �X2 R?� �U7) ,G&�-: �� HD23 ,�SK ��; t��X&� R. �K�n)< , G#� t��X&� ��n) R. �US0

G&� ��DY&� m�� @�0" 1mT " ,1s%&� H�#� ,�� �A ,G&�-: ,/V&� H:3�p G#� 1mT y#k �DV�� C�. �A G&�) ��KA �A G&� �L�#� ,e�kA $5p G#� ��U $�X&� ~ ��U �D& H�A RZ� R. "K�V& �-0m< E

x� R. �� ��%�� R9� "& H�A R. $��K�&� G#� m�#& y�� �D?3 H�A t��X&� ��n) R. �U7 �DU5$ , �)��%�� R. �� ��%�� $5x� ��9: ,�&S& ')A �) , �.4� ')A R. y#k H�A R��0d3�^&� �SK G#� E )A

���h>:) o�x&� a-0 R. ��9� ��%�z� �A R�D��(&� R��-`��x&� G#� m�#& y�� E ���� +��M&� �SL& �A ��D#-&� �K�U7 /V&� m�&� ��n) R.)< ,"#�) H�#� �� G#p /��&� �A �K) , eA3

HLn) G#� ���� t�Y� ����< ,�Ln) H�fA R. Hn)) �Ln) �� J�I H& '�N�) E�L�0/��&� � , G#p"#�) H�#� �� ,H& '�I) :"Hn�&� 8�VX�#0 "U�2A t�� �7� , R. Hn)) �Ln) �� J�I aN� �)�Ln) H�fA ,�� ��0 ,G&�-: , H:3�p G#� 1mT y#k" Et)�YD&� ��-&� d3�p G#� =A E

G&� on�� ��DY&� �A ��n�&� �#: R.)" �� "G&�-: ,�� G#� ��DY&� m�� ��v�) ,-:G&� , ��n H�A e�kA $��)3 ~" RD2�&� d3�p G#� " G�-. ��9�0 " d3�^&� "$5^&� ,�� �A =A ,G&�-: , y#k

H:�5p q-? G#� 1mT ,"#-&� R. ,d3�N&�) ,d��M&� ,oD%&�) ,�^�&�) ,1s9&�) ,�&7 ��;) , ��)�/f �LL�c� � �� C�5p ���U E�� G&� d3�^&� $0��� ��9: )A ,G&�-: ,0������c: $ ,�#. )A ,

~ �DU" �� $I�� ") " �� ��? ") " /2)3 R. H�0 �_5� " E

Page 39: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

"#BC�� ! �)/,b# .���7 U/9� Ë/,� �+#�:E� �� ��Zs� 3 RX��::−

>+c #B;B,� S:� >5G�� , >&f6�e� (f�E� f?��! Í ��A�af; >7A�f6 , �+.7��,� >59<5,�� �tV�� ��Ai� , 2I� Í ��ae� �a� ��w �� , >G® O$c

D.c Q!=� #<&e� O$c ,�f2! Of|+ #B;B,� Í �� O[ NB[ S.V� �D�[�=� �h;�=�&I0 =�Q/2� =� (�2! ,%7�R a�� �D0 4/:=�&2+# =�&9B�R =� , S#�$%7 �BD��

>+#B;B,� ABC,� X&' ,>+.�2,� "aI >&/: >F&/2[��F 3

��9: )A" H:3�p "�L0�p�. G&� $5^&� $0��� R. ,�� �K) ,G&�-: , $��k $5p d3�^&� ��9V0�� C�5p R. ,G&�-: ,H? y�#: ,�c�&� d3�^U �%�& H��M�� ,�L�0 @�_&� �)m , �3�Vk� �. G#�

� 1�.z�=)��& E $�D%X&� "K���m G#� +��M&� �S� "L&��V��) $D%XD&� =A3 �Z�� :aM�&�) a#D&� :��

W���−��u ,$&m4� d�^�: :��W �O ,���NV&� r��A :WuO�K�-? �.) E ��U "K���m G#� $�0�^&� ds; =A3 �Z��)" 1mT "/L&� G#X. :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�

W� O−� � ,"9M&� W�^0 :W�Q ,WP� ,WP� , /?�� R?� "��9&� �T�N&� ��%5:~�^&� :��W Q ,8&�x&� $�,? :W�P� E

~ $�%&� aKA $D`A t��n �Z��) :=3�_�&� J�Mp ]�f ~ +��M&� 1s�A :�OW � − u ,=3��&� JV0 ,��S�V��� t�VU ,1s%&� ��? t�? :�OW PO ,"#%. J�Mp ]�f : t�VU

$5^&�) �&� ,t�� R� /L�&� t�?Hn�&� :W�u�� ,/9&�D&� /?�-&� R?z �T�N&� 1�92A :�� W�QP ,/���N&� ��%5: :� �W ��� ,}�U�c&� ��%5: :�PW ��P , +��M&� a9c.

�3�0 R?� H���?) :W��K�-? �.) ,���c&� +��M&� m)3) t���A ~ ���-V&�) ����&� :� WO� ,��^��� :W�Q �K�-? �.) E

n� o��L&� ��D92 8KS. �Z��~ :$&)m(. )A aN-&� ~ $&��N. $&�N. R. ��L#& �. y�NM: : WO� �.) �K�-? ,3�^-&� �#V_. ~ �`�N-&�) C�����&� :��W ����K�-? �.) , /����D&� "X-D&�

�`�N-&�) C�����#& :��W ��� ,$�?�-&� $5%#5&� |�3�: :��W O� , a�DX& /5%#5&� "X-D&����#p :� W P�Q ,D& /5%#5&� "X-D&�H�K) m�� : W�u� ,d�%�D&� $�?�-&� $����D&� :�

Page 40: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين

− ��� −

NBV,� u�� �$� , � �� �c�|$D� �� , �f&�%,� Y�af,�7 #��b� (@– �f! �� u+.R ��25,� , �D��.2,�7 4Ge�– Sf:� S.fV� O���J `� r6B+ l,w O[

2I� �tV: 2! #B;B,� , Õ�9� OV�7 #B;B,� S:� NB2$/+ �BD�[ �+a,��(­�5G�� Í ,(­<�pJ���F 3" ���\� " :�B,� �,�� , (�2! , >f�&��� Bf�

Y�#B;Be� .?�9 ! �BL2J Ë/,� >&�V,� , b0 ¢�%,� ��� "afI �.��f� OfvÒ >�&��� , �! h&/+ b�"���.7"(�B,� u+.L7 b0 � F 3

N�ffDB&,� >5ff9<� ~ff%7 ��affe� �aff� m0 U�ff� ffc tff[ , -BGff�&5,�[N��BD�G[��OF , "a&�J�"}&2�.7 "��F,

W�Q�P ,"&�-&� ���mA :W�u , W $D��N&� C�����&� ��jK�-? �.) ,e�9&� ��L&� ���mA :W��−�u ,/.s�z� ��95V&� R. /L&z� 8��X&� :W P�− PO ,$���L&� C�5%#5&� :WQ�−Q� , W� Q ,W�P� ,1s�z� ~ /5%#5&� �95&� |�3�: :Wu�−u� , ��5&�) ���m4�

8K�SD&�) :W�� ,$5%#5&� |�3�: ~ r)3m :� W ,3E

n� o�Z�� :$���L&� C�5%#5&� :W�P�E

n� o�Z�� :1s�z� ~ /5%#5&� �95&� |�3�: : Wu�E

n  o $�� ��0���%U� �&)�P��� E1 F $���. ~" �����A " R. t�N&�? " r�%0A " d��gU ��. G&� a23  #? �A G&�" $�#Np " ,$�?��X&� ��&�x�� G&� aNV�� "h , $���. ~ �NV��)" ��#�� " , $���D&� �SK G&�)

$�3�D&� $5�s0 8%V��" $�#�z� "�L& ��v. ')A �K) E $�� C�.��u�� E1 F �Z�� :d�%�D&� $�?�-&� $����D&� :��W �uQ ,}����&� �95&� o�?3 : W����K�-? �.) , |�3�:

$������&� $5%#5&� : W �− u ,$5%#5&� $����. :� W � PE

n� o $�� r���.�? �&)�P��� E1 F $���. ~" ��#�� "��&�x�� t��n ,��0���%U� ��%#�5&�? �h>: , '�I)m�n�&� d�2�? H#g. E H?�VU o�)" $-��x&� ~ "��-f < ,��j-f $5%#5&� "Z� R. ')A ��90< E C�.

$�� 8��I��P�� E1 EF �Z�� :#5&� 1s�A $����.$5% :�� W �u ,}�V%�&� �3�-. d�`�m :�PW O�� , $5%#5&� |�3�:

$������&� : W u – O� ,$5%#5&� $����. :� W � P ,}����&� �95&� o�?3 : W� �−� PE

Page 41: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

�"}BG�&� "��F , >f&�+�� >9Ae� �� (��� FPL&�c.f� -BGf�&5,�� �OF >&DB+E� >9Ae� ����F , t[ >9Ae� �7 �D�# ">&c��.,� "�PF , �f+�=�3 N� tf[

n� o $�� r�%#�. �&)����� E1 F ~" $����A " ,$�#�z� $�3�D&�? �h>:) ,�L�� o0�m) E �A G&� 8K7

���V. ��; �2�) m�n�&� ,U���?�h R E�Z�� :$������&� $5%#5&� |�3�: :WOO −O� , �95&� o�?3}����&� : W�OP−�O�E

n� o G&� $�%�" ��#�� "��&�x�� t��n ~ oN: $���. , ��%#�5&� �L%�A R. ')A �A 1�N: �I)" ��0���%U�"E

n  o $�� �x�#I�K �&)�P��� E1 F $���. ~" �%0A " ,f G#� $D��I $�N��;� $���. /K) ���T ���/?�,&� e�,^&� E d��A �D92 �I)" �x�#I�K "R.(&� R. d�0 $���D&� �SK E �3) �I)

�m��nA R. $�:��L9&� C�DLD&� ��%#�5&� E�L�0 R�b�D&� R. 3�p GV2 $D9M&�) $5%#5&�? a,Vf� E $�� C�.���P� E1 EF

')4� A��D&� R. >c� H�A m�n�&� ~ H&�I $psk , 3��&� �K)–%�&) dm�L-D&� 3��&� /K �– 3�� a? $5�x& $�L&� ,�� /K 3��&� �SK) ,a�&) 3�� ��) ,��Vf) ��p) ,"#�) t�2) ,$#I) $I�0) , S_V�

$5#V_. �3�p< E �Z�� :$5%#5&� 1s�A $����. :� W P�O ,d�%�D&� $�?�-&� $����D&� :� W �uQP , |�3�:

$������&� $5%#5&� : W��−�Q ,�&� �95&� o�?3}��� : W�Ou−�� ,$5%#5&� |�3�: ~ r)3m :WO−�8K�S.) C�.�N. $������&� $5%#5&� :WPQE

n� o $�3�D&�" $����4� " $���. G&� $�%� " $����A "e�,^&� ���T ���f G#� $-I��&� , �SK m�)3) $�3�D&�" ��&�� " ,)" ��3��D%9�A " ,)" ���D%9�A " ,)" �x�#I�K " E�Z�� : ~ r)3m

:$5%#5&� |�3� : W −O$������&� $5%#5&� |�3�: :W� −�QE

n� o$�3�N�?�& d�p�-. $�I�)�&� $�3�D&� ,�L& $�3�-.) , ��%#�5&� �L&�pA o�)" ����b "� OO�− ��� E1 EF ~ �&)" W�I " G&� a23) " ���hA "�LV5�s0 R� SkA ���K) , $�3�. H& >c�A ���K)

0 oDVX� ��U ��)3 ~ $�5%#0���-c&� H� ,R��I�)�&�? �&7 an4 ���N#0 E ~ �K��3T) $�3�D&� �SK d>c� �Z�� :$������&� $5%#5&� |�3�: : W O�K�-? �.) , $����D&�

d�%�D&� $�?�-&� :��W uuO ,$5%#5&� $����. :��W P ��K�-? �.) ,/L&z� 8��X&� :

Page 42: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Î�fDB&,� -BGf�&5,� #Bf;B,� Sf:� ��a� #��A �� , Of]E� ��fe�" 8RB���"��F , � ~&f� b0 Bf� �f� ¢�%,� N� `.+ �a,�� , m�f%J , �f9B/7

>&�V,� P52,�� U�E� O�%,� , �fJ�w �f! >f;A�d7 �Gf&, ¢�f%,� >f&��� N���I S.+����3 �� , m�%J , "2! ,f;A�� �Gf5D �! \!= ± �� �#�fe� ¢�f%,� �afH

Ë?.e�� F 3 �§A� YBV9� �&9B,� Ï�A�E� �%,� Í ��ae� �a� #��A ��� , �a,��

Y�#B;Be� O[ >&��� B� � N� SA�J `.+ , �Bfµ � N� `.�� SA�J `.+�Y�#B;Be��OF3

�� >&7A�E� >5G�5,� Í ()2�� �ªB2&$9� >|+ , �f&�|¬ (f�� �f� f%+ �a,��× � K ,��V:0 (�.|[��=��, ��F 3

T<9�� >�BC/� ~%7 2! ��ae� �a� ��A T<9�� Í� ,.V$�=� , AB] Í >$�/�� Y�A�$!� Y�A��0 , >5R�� , tf[ rL�,�� .VG,� m0 ()�%7 ��#A

W �P− �� , /5%#5&� �95&� |�3�:–k>VD&� r3��D&�) �x�3A d� :W �O ,�K�-? �.) , W u� ,�K�-? �.)E

n� o $�� R���#0A �&)� P�1 F $���. ~" ��&�?�,�& "Gx��&� �^. '�D�A R. , 8#� ~ a23 "h$�3��9��� G&� "#-&� ,���-&�) r3�0 ms? G&� �K�-?) ,�.)3 ~ �NV�� "h , $�� ~�: ��)� ��1 EF

�Z�� :$������&� $5%#5&� |�3�: : W u� �K�-? �.) ,$5%#5&� 1s�A $����. :��W ���−��uE

n� o�Z�� :$5%#5&� $����. : W� P ,}����&� �95&� ���k :W��Q�K�-? �.) E ��� R���#0At�-&� : W�O� , /5%#5&� �95&� |�3�:–d�k>VD&� r3��D&�) �x�3A : WO P�K�-? �.) ,

$5%#5&� |�3�: ~ r)3m :W� −�OE

n  o�Z�� :&� $����.$5%#5 :� W � PE

n� o�Z�� :d�%�D&� $�?�-&� $����D&� :� W �Q�P ,$5%#5&� $����. :� W � P , ~ $&��3�b������ $���%&�) C�Ks&� : WOPu�K�-? �.) E

Page 43: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�ff! ��ff;¹��ON__/�� 8__!$! Ä�M�U�ff,Bc : " � b0 >ff$�� Í �ff� "� F3 �ff,Bc� "Î�f� (f�!� �f� Î�j$9"�OF , �f,Bc�: " Î�j$f9 , Î�j$f9 , (f�!� �f�

Î�L�9 , ;B+ �tG,� Í Å|� P&, , -.f%J �AE� Í >5f] Å|� b� , �fD�B� , B� B�� �D� B��"��F , �,Bc�: "Î�f$!�� �fD� b0 �,0 b � �D� Î0 "�PF 3

TB+ Y�w >�&��� �! ¾�� ,� ¦+ N�[�UBf�+� �&/5: "1A��f,� �fD� ,1�Q,��� Ëc�G,�� ,��+�"��F , U�c� :" �� >&��[ Ë/++h+�7 �� �;.� ��� ,f:�� u�f%,�� �B�%e�� u��%,� �+�.� Y.�D (@=� , ¢�f! Í �fDE

f:�� X&�� NBV+ N� �V+ &:B/,�=�"��F3 -�.%e�f7 .f�E� �f! O�f9�

n� o���)�f R? G%�� R? 3�5�� �K ,��(� �?A ,/.�x%�&� E ��n ��U"���)�f ""#�>0 ����X. < , 1mT �DK) ���kA ��(� /?4 ��U)/#�) ,�m�Kb �m��� "L#U ����U)< < E $�0�^&� $D`A R. ��(� �?A �-�)

R�03�-&� ��x#%? 8N#�) ,d3�Lc. C�3�f�) �`�x&) '��2A) C�.�N. 82�p ��U) , C�.��U)d�K�� ,$#9c. C�3��� H�� Cm3) H�A ��; ,$DK�. C�Mxf) ,$-��c&� �K�� �&�_: E

$�� ~�: �� jK " 1�x%�? "�-��) �sh H&) $�� � E )" 1�x%? " d���U d�#? " �.�N? " R. $���I " 3�?�%�� " E �Z�� :���&)4� $�#2 :���W OO−� ,$�0�^&� C�N�� :W��−�� ,"ZV�D&� :�PW u−

Q ,����4� C��0) :� W PO� ,���&)4� C�N�� :WOQu −�� ,}��-c#& e�9&� C�N�x&� :W��−�� ,���&)4� C�.��U o.�n :� W �OO−�OP ,���#�&� "X-. :��W � �E

n� o~ �SK H:3��� �Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W ��� ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :��OW uu ,'��V��� ��(�. :� W O��E

n  o$N?�%&� �sg&� on��D&� �Z�� ,�Z��) :��#?� ���#: :WO�� ,���&)4� d�US: :��W OP� ,R��&� 1�#� ���2� :��W O�E

n� o�Z��:��#?� ���#: :WO�PE

n� oy?�%&� on�D&� ,$M5^&� �5�E

n� o���&)4� d�US: :��W O�QE

n� o$M5^&�) �(X&� �5� y?�%&� on�D&�E

Page 44: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

.V2e� �! Ë)2,�� ,U���: "� Í �jD �f! Ëk� -�.%e�7 .�� �)&� P&, >+b .V2e� , u�M� >+b� Í ��<V� , .fV2e� �! Ëk� -�.%e�7 .�� ��2� P&,�

Sf:B,� SÀ: Í"��F3¦df� �,pf9� :U�fc ? Ä.f%,� �f� : �fD� ,U�fc: U�c ? Õ.V,��: �D� ,U�c :U�c ? (��,�� ¥B�,��: �D� ,U�fc: #�f$! m�f%J

49B�� (&��.70 Zs 4G&!� , 8f%'� ()&f�! � Y�B�] ,U�fc: Of[ �fD� l�,�� 3 O;.,� �C� ,+h+ B7� U���: f7 , �A#� uf�� Í 4f2� �f� Of[

#B;B� B� �� O[ >�&�: , u�� ��V� , Í �fD� `.f+ ¦d�,� l,w 42� N0� u�� �J�w : ,�F! <�� F 3

E� l�J O|� �2! YA] �Dp7 Ë��LG$,� �! ()�%7 Aa/!� c� Í ��0 O+��c .VG,�� >��,� U�: , Bje�� >$&�,�� , `�.J b� `BL/� , �fH �/fy b� ,

>f+�V�� O&$9 ! �k� �� , >f/7�@ Zfs �fk� �� , m0 Ëf�J.+ b Ybb# �f, ��Y�6�+.,�� Y���Fe� Í ����� m0 4�JA� �� b0 �))�3 "pfL� ()�f%7�

�H �!7� ,!� m0 �$GD� �H ".5[ O7�fJ�c�� Í .f)� ���,� Í 9�� #��/�OF 3�,�j7 (�!� �� 3

#Bf;B,� Sf:� f! UJ Y�A�$! ()2� YA] �+a,� >&�BC,� ��� , Bf7�

n� oy?�%&� on�D&� :��W OQ E

n� oy?�%&� on�D&� :�� W OQPE

n  oH.sU ~ ��D#-&� =A3 �Z�� :R��&� 1�#� ���2� :��W O� ,$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� WO�O−O�� ,W��� ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :��OW uu ,'��V��� ��(�. :� W O��−O�� ,$��L�&�) $����&� :���W OP ,8KS&� C�3Sf :� W ��O ,}��-c#& e�9&� C�N�x&� :��W �� ,$g��M&� e)�V5&� :WO�� ,R����D&� t�mT :W��E

Page 45: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�&��¢U>� ��T�� G �N>�M�U , �,Bc 1�$,� �a� Í �J�A�$! .)�� ���: "u�� �D�"� F 3�!�$J� ~%7 m0 �, 1�/[ Í �,Bc�: " m0 (&:.f,� ��.f,� ��

N<� �7� N<�" �7 �;�� t�� , >&7B7.,� Ë!+ �D�� , >f&7B7.,� "��!#� .VD� , "2! X�� 8! �a� Np7 Aa/!�� ,U�c (@: � b0 �J�V,� O)� , f&,�� �D��

>,i �&��OF 3 �,Bc�:��F fffff,BfffffI� fffff&:B/,�7 �G B)ffffff9� �ffffff2! � Zffffffs

n� o/DM. R? 3�^�. R? R�%M&� �K ,+�,. �?A ,����� �?A '�N�) ,�sM&� , $�0�^&� $D`A �2A �K)

R�3�LcD&� ,����X. ��n ��U< ,/DM. HD�� , $���. R." ��jY�? "r3�0 ms? R. , ����? >c�)�%:) ,m��,? akm) ,$9D? 3)�n) ,��^V&�) �K(&� y��� �#�) , C�m�� R. $��Dn 8Mp)

���X&�U $�0�^&� ,/9D&� ��Dg� R? )�D�) ,=3��&� R�%M&� /?A) EVk� ;$�0�^&� |��c. H�0 �#$I��(&�) $I�_D&�) dS�-c&� G&� H�%�) ��5� "K�gU>0 ,HV�hA R. "L�.) , ��D#-&� $#Dn R. H#-n)

R����?�&� E $�� ����N: �&)<� ��jK F , $�� m��,? ��D#� {�Dn�) e�V5? ��5U aVI)O�QjK E ~ HVDn�: �Z�� :"���&� R?� ���L5&� :W �Q− �� ,=�x&� |�3�::� ��W ��� , H���V&�

���f��) :WOOP ,".4� t3�X: :��W ��−u ,$�0�^&� C�N�� :WO��−O�� , |�3�:m��,? :�uW �� −��� ,� ����4� C��0) W ����K�-? �.) ,|�3�V&� ~ a.�9&� :�u W� �−� Q ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :���W O�O – OP� ,'��V��� ��(�. :��W P�u−P�Q ,

$��L�&�) $����&�:� ��W �O −��� ,��(�D&� ��%& :� W O��−�OP , e�9&� C�N�x&�}��-c#& :��W ���−��Q ,1s�z� ~ $N#I C��^_f :W�O�K�-? �.) E

n� o~ H:3��� �Z�� :�sM&� 3��kA :W�� ,��5&� R�? ��5&� :W � ,R��&� 1�#� ���2� :�� WO� ,���&)4� d�US: :� W u ,W O� ,W OP , W Ou ,�DX.$�D�: R?� e)�V0 { :� W �u�E

n  o�Z�� :m��,? |�3�: :�uW � � ,$��L�&�) $����&� :���W �Ou ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :��� WO u ,��#?� ���#: :W���E

n� o�Z�� :�sM&� ����m :WQ�E

Page 46: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

B)fff9� �fff&[?BfffI� �fff&[ ?

Bffffff� Ëffffff2D� r&jffffff]� �,Bc�:��F

fffff+ ,¿ ¿ �fffff+� � Ù ±4fffff/: �×

Ëfff: Offf[ (fff�� fff! 4fff5�Ð � Ð .��ffffff��=�ffffff=2R�7 � ffffffv Ø

� OffffffffV7 �� OffffffffV,Ð Ð ÐÒ Offff); lffff&,0 �A�affff/!� N0� � � ±

fff! ¶.fff�� lfff� (fff�!�� K � �Ù � K KËÐ �Zffs �Gff, ,OffV,� >ff�' �ff+� Ð K � K

Ç0 Nw0 �A�affffff/!� tffffff�Ð �?!

�,Bc�:� F 3 �fD� `Bf�� �f�� ,`Bf�� �f� �D�� �� �

�Dfff7 �fff2��: N�fff:�A �fffjD� � � K� � � K �J�fffff7� Ë2J�fffff7� �wxfffff�K � �� �� �2J�fffffff7� �J�fffffff7� �w0�� �� �� �K

�,Bc�:�OF 3 lfffff� <fffff7 �fffffD� �fffffD�Ù �

�j$ffffffff9 lD�j$Gffffffff�K � � �ffffffff&:BJ �ffffffff&:BJ�� K

Î�&Cffffffff! lD�&Cffffffff!�� K � ËR�dfffffff90 lR�dfffffff90�� K

�.5s��.fffffffff5s lfffffffffDK K

�,Bc�:��F 3 �JBfff9�D .fff)�� �fff� N�j$fff9K � �� �

�ffffc�|,� �ffffJB�b �2ffff9 ¿� � ± .��ffff� �ffff��� Í �ffff7 (ffff@= ±� � ��

1A��fff,�� Offf[g� SABfff] � � �ffff��� �ffff2+�! ffff�, 4ffff/:K K �fff;���7 �fff;��� >fff�j�[�

n� o�Z�� :�sM&� ����m :WQu ,�sM&� 3��kA : W� �−� PE

n� o�Z�� :�sM&� ����m :Wu�E

n  o�Z�� : W H����mu�E

n� o�Z�� :H����m :WO� −O� ,�Z��) :m��,? |�3�: :�uW � Q ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :���W O PE

Page 47: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ة وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظري

− ��� −

Ë��LGf$�, ��Aaf/!� �f� O|7 �t�%,� ~%7 �, Aa/!� c� , �f2� ~%$f7 �� ,�.� T<Lf]b�� Bfje�� >�f�,� U�: Í YA] �k� ` , ¶.f� U�f: Í�

;B,� S�� >$je���F 3 8|:�$,� ~%7�� F m0 ��af+ �fD� m0 ��LGf$,� Y�A�f$! ~f%7 �f� ()�

#��b� ��a7 UB�,� ,UBf��� ��af7 UBf�,� m0 ��a+ �<�� N���OF ,� tf)�<[ �BfF7 .f�2,� U<� �� S.���,� >�&��� �V, m0 N�$�af+ tfk

#Bff;B,� Sff:B7 UBff�,� , SA�ff$%,� Í Xff9BJ UBff���� #�ff�b�7 Zff$%/,� N�� Zs b �)&� r��GJ� , (�2f� OV�f7 ��f2! ��ae� �a� O&]pJ (/+ ¢ N0�

%��� ,ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� 2! B� t[ ,".[w Ôg� 3 f9�� >�BC/� 2! #B;B,� S:� >5G�� AB)� Z[�B$7 OC/+ t&� �a� Í T<

Ë�<9�� �Qe� , �afI N�f[ f�� P,fDE�� Ë�<f9�� 1.f�e� Í ����Ë�<9�� �Qe� Í "AB�: X� ���h/+ .V$� AB�: ��ae� 3

>5Gf�5,� "afH UB�,�f7 Y.)/�� Ë/,�� SªA�$,� Y�&Cd�,� �� :y_� _G�¹/¦;1��M<U ,

n� o�Z�� :R��&� 1�#� ���2� :��W O� ,3���4� d�9c. :W�Q�K�-? �.) E

n� o�Z�� :/.s�z� ��^V&� G&� ak�. : W����K�-? �.) ,W� O�K�-? �.) , d�2) $5%#0m�n�&� :WO� ,W��P�K�-? �.) ,1s�z� ��� ~ $�0�^&� ��� '�^:�� $��Z� :W �− � ,

WO�−O� ,|�3�V&� ~ �(U�.) /?�-&� �95&� :W��P E 3�x: ��^V&� 8KS. �A H5&v. �US�)�Z�� m�n�&� d�2) �M� HX:�) r�5&� =��A G#� :W���E

n  ou7�G,� ACe�3 n� od�%. R? ����� R? �DM. �K ,����� �?A ,/%&��4� ,/���N&� ,��%#�0 ,��^V. , ��U H�� '�N�

$�#���D�z� d��m R. ,$I��(&�? "�� Em�n�&� d�2�? R�#`�N&� R. �K) E $�� ~�:�O�QjK EF

Page 48: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � { −

()2����Q;G G�M�U3e� �aH �)&� ¥�+ Ë/,� �,�Bc� ��� �f,Bc ��a: " �fD0 #B;� �� O[ ¼�=� , SAw U��|� �/�&��� �JAc� ��! �! 1h%+ P&, t[�

#B;B,� Í , l,w �� .�]� b� , \f[� b� , Í N�fV� �f2� Bf�� b l,af[ (9b� �a� È/�7 #B)�,�� AB���– � (9� �� – �f2)� "B$�R (k� B��

½�: "�;B,=�#B)�� =� , � ��f�/!� ()2V, f%$,"� F 3 ,�f,Bc�: " #Bf;� ¢�f%,� >f�' ��f%7� Í �f$�LJ ��B;� X&' ! ¢�%,� >�' �7 �B�de� u��

�/&�[� ,.��� "v=�=2&$� �"�OF3�,Bc� : " �f&�! U#� ~%$, ��%7 u�� .)�� �7"��F , �,Bc�: " �p$D� – � �� –CD =��+.%J b =� P&, �D� (�%+ S.V5,�7 N� � � K

B;B,� Í �,<; O; � b0 �� #"�PF 3 ,�,Bc�: " Bf� � Npf7 S#�)�,� N0

~ HVDn�: �Z�� :�s��&� 1s�A ��� :���W ��u ,�&��4� d�YI |�3�: :�u ,W �� , d)Sn��VND&� :W�O ,�DV#D&� $�,? :Wuu ,� |�3�:/%&��4� �95& :WO ��K�-? �.) ,1s�z� :

��W OE

n� o'�n�&� /?A R? RD2�&���� R? 1s%&���� �K ,"9M&� �?A ,/D_#&� ,/?�,D&� ,/%&��4� ,/#��fz� ,$�0�^&� ���f R. E $�� ¡U��D? H��) R� �?�,. ~�:� ��PO�jK EF H5���^: R." ��%5: �T�N&�") " G�%M&� �� ��D�A ]�f " E

~ HVDn�: �Z�� :�-&� :� W P�� ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :� W � −�� ,��(�D&� ��%& :�� W�O−�� ,C��0�&� C��0 :��W P�Q−P�� ,���X&� dT�. :�OW �� ,8KS&� C�3Sf :��W ��O ,/9D&� �L0 R?� ��5M&� d�US: a�7 : W�O ,r��VI�� d)Sn :� W ��P E �&� d�2�? '�N&� H�&� 8%� �I)�)�#k R?� m�n ,�Z�� :a`�%&� ��5f :WP� E�Z��) : 3�YM&�

t�,D&�) �&��4� ~ ~�^&� :WOO ,/%&��4� �95&� |�3�: :WOO�−OO E

n� o�Z�� :��n�? R?� G�%M&� ��D�4� ]�f :��W P�E

n  oy?�%&� on�D&� :��W ��E

n� oy?�%&� on�D&� :��W �O�E

n� oy?�%&� on�D&� :��W �QE

Page 49: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � � −

�­!� Y�#�)�,� T� Ë� 8$e� u��; � B� #B)��� ���� S#�)� O[ w0 O;�h!"��F 3

Åw G� &(���Æ � �M!U , :�;�� G��M-U , -.%+� ,�+�=� , ���# �7�7� , �f2! Of�D� b S.|V,� N� &5+ �� N��� �7�± >�&��� Í �I #B; , Of&$c �f� Ëf� tfD0�

n� oD&�y?�%&� on� :� W ��OE

n� oR�%M&� R? �D2A �K ,"��N&� �?A ,/%I R?� ,��N&� JV5? ,�K�%U) R�%&� ��5_:) E ~ a,Vf��-c&�) tm4�? H:����? ,��^V&�) ���&� G&� '�. "h ,H���:A) �)���. �g90 ,=�LD&� H�A G�m�0 ,

1�.z�? GD%:)� � � ,R�x?��D&� $&)m G#� 3�h) ,�h ~ �5� �. H�9&�m��D? H:3 E $���. aKA H#VI" 8#f " $��P�� E

t�VU H�&� 8%��" R�-DX&� d�Y2 G&� '�p�&� ~ R�#-�&� o#k " E ~ HVDn�: �Z�� :���%&� $#M&� :� W �Q�− � ,�&��4� d�YI |�3�: :W��O ,8X-D&� :

W u�− u� ,'��V��� ��(�. :��W � u ,��(�D&� ��%& :��W ��− �Q ,1s�4� :�� W��� E

�)�#k R?� m�n�&� d�2�? '�N&� H�&� 8%� RD.) ,�Z�� :a`�%&� ��5f :WP� E �95&� |�3�: �Z��)/%&��4� :WOO E

n  o��Km R? �DM. R? ���� R? "�K��?� �K� � ,��M�� �?A ,/�)4� ,/%&��4� ,/N&�D&� ,/��D&� ,dA�D&� R?�? �)�-D&� ,��Km R?�?)� � ,/9&�. H�N0 ,~ {�?+��M&�) HN5&� , "#�) |�3�V&�) ��%5V&�)

H�#� ��&�; H�0 �.�NV. 3�p GV2 1s9&�< ,��^V&� G&� '�.) E aKA $Im��b ~ ���2 R?� ��U7�&��4� E H:�5&v. R." m�f3z� ]�f " ," {�Dnz� a`�%. ~ t�VU " ," G�%M&� ��D�4� ]�f

" ," ���-&� R?� �&�XD&� R��M. ]�f " E)"��Km � � "��L&� ���c:) '��&� �%9? E ~ HVDn�: �Z�� :C��0�&�? ~��&� :��W ��� ,$#^&� t�V9& $#D9V&� :��W ��� , d)Sn

r��VI�� :��W Q� ,$����; 3��kA ~ $��2z� :��W O P−O � ,8KSD&� �����&� :�� W �O− �� ,��(�D&� ��%& :��W � � ,$�U(&� 3��&� d�Xf :��W ��O ,R�5&vD&� "X-. :��W �O�−�O� ,R�Dg&� �N-&� :�PW OO�−OO� E �)�#k R?� m�n�&� d�2�? '�N&� H�&� 8%� RD.) ,�Z�� :�)�#k R?� $.�N. :W��� , ��5f

a`�%&� :WP E

Page 50: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � � −

(�B,� , �Qf$,� �Ae� #B;B7 ¶�Q� ��#B;� N��± , �Afe� 4f5/D� �wxf� #B;B,� O&C5J ��2� �V+ ¢ >�' �Q$,� ,:�� �&G7 B� O7��F3

§��E�� G� &(���M!U , �,Bc `\V,� >&?�/,� Í ��D ����OF: �fff)&c� T�fff�e�7 Ô�B�fff] �fffI

����fff] Ç �fffk� �fff)&� )fff�� ± � � ± K m0 ;�ff9 ff:�� OCff� �ffD<[� � Ð � K

SFff9 Off[ Í X��ff7 �ff/�&�:� �fVJ ¢� ��Bf9 f] Ç N�[ ��� Offf[ ��#� Í �Zfff�, Ô<fff]

>fffffffffffffffffffffffffffff%[A Ä;) G� &(���M<U , ��ae� �aI O]*e�� P9*e� %+ B��× � K , >j��R �$/[�

n� o�Z�� :�)�#k R?� $.�N. :W���E

n� o/#� R? �f�D&� R? /#� R? �D� �K ,"��N&� �?A ,�52 �?A) ,R��&� ��f ,ap4� =�DM&� ,�^D&�d�0�&�) 3��&�) �&�D&� = ,@3�5&� R?�? 3�LcD&�) E8�mA ���f ,��^V&� y��� �#� ,

�`�^I H�0 8VU) ,m�n�&� d�2) 8KS. G#� '�: $M��p C�3��-? �L�Mf , �`�^N&� �SK R.)"$�`�V&�" ,��#%&� "Z�? d�D%D&�) , $�� �&)P�� $�� ~�:) jK ��O jK EF ~ HVDn�: �Z�� :&� C��0�& $#D9V&�$#N� :�OW Ouu−OuQ ,���X&� dT�. :��W ��−�O ,

����4� C��0) :�OW �P�−�P� ,��(�D&� ��%& :��W O��−O�Q ,���&)4� C�N�� :W���−��P ,d�K�(&� 1�X�&� :��W uu−OQ� ,1s�z� ����m :�OW �O�−�OP , R%2

d���MD&� :��W P�u E m�n�&� d�2�? '�N&� G&� H�%� RD.)�m�M:�� F 1�.z�/����,&� ���2 /?A , �M�&� ��%5: �Z��

��MD&� :�OW ��Q ,/�KS&� 1�.z� ,�Z�� :'��V��� ��(�. :�O W ��− �P , 1s�A ����s��&� :� W O�u−O�Q ,/��N�&� R��&� ��K�?) ,�Z�� :/?�� R?� ��59: G&� /�,&� H���: :W ��− �� ,m�� +�2 ,�Y�A ,8KSD&� �S� H&�N& ��5U R. ��D�A ,)$�D�: R?� 1�.z� ,�Z�� :

$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :�� W �O−�� ,a`�%D&�) a`���&� $��DX. :��W Q��K�-? �.) ,�)�#k R?� $.s-&�) ,�Z�� :a`�%&� ��5f :WP� ,HV.�N. :W��PE

n  o�Z�� :H����m :W��E

n� o�jD2A R? �DM. R? /#� R? �DM. �K ,�9? �?A ,����� �?A) ,/`�x&� ,:�M&�/D ,/%&��4� ,/��D&� ,R��&� /�MD? 8N#D&� ,~�^&� /?�� R?�? �)�-D&�) E d�#? ~ "#-&� SkA" $���. " ~

Page 51: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �   −

�7 r+�/,�7 ,e� �J�A�$! ���,Bc SAB)�: " Bf�� ��&�E� .)�� �� N�j$9 �)2&!"��F , �,Bc�: " �D0 – �D�j$f9 uf�� �� – ��&f�E� 8f! , ��&f�E�� S#�_ , ��#�: �5�/�� N0� , : OV7 #�_ B)� , Bf� b0 �� y t�

�&��4� ,/?�-&� t�,D&� G&� '�M:) "#-&� 8#x� �&��4� ��. R�? aN�:) , G&� �L�. aM:3� "h

m��,�U /.s�z� ��cD&� ,ap�D&�) ,yc.m) ,�^.) ,d�. 3)�n) �2) ,G&� aM:3�) 1)�&� ms? – ��&�2 ��U�: <–yc.m ~ 3��%V&� G^� GN&A "h , $�� ~�: ��)�OujK E $�� H:m�) ���U �I)

P��$���D? jK E���&�) ��^V&� ~ �L�&�; d��gU C�5&v. ��: ,$�9#D&� C�2�V5&� �K�LfA R. ,"9M&� W�^0) E��^V&� "#� ~ H��.b 1�N. ��U �I) ,�2�? '�N&� H�� �LVf� �I)m�n�&� d ,

m3) H�&�) 3�p H�-0 EH#n4 �)�590 8KSD&� �S� Sk4� ��D#-&� R. ��gU H�#� t�� �I) , ���K)�A�? R. ,H�0 �I�: R. ���K) E$XDk $5%#0 H�� /?�� R?� ��^: R� R�-�� R?� '�I� � E

~ HVDn�: �Z�� :$#N�&� C��0�& $#D9V&� : �OW PPP ,C��0�&�? ~��&� :��W ��O ,���� �$��3�&� :W�P� ,���X&� dT�. :��W �Q ,1s�z� |�3�: : $�� C��0) �#X.�O�−��� : WOP −OPQ ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :� OW �u−�Q ,$��L�&�) $����&� :��OW �P� ,R�Dg&� �N-&� :� W ���−�QQ ,��(�D&� ��%& :�PW O��−O�P , /?�� R?� $Dn�: R� /��D&� '�N&�–

��x_. : $I3)�O \ t E ��D#-&� R. oDn m�n�&� d�2�? '�N&� H�&� 8%� �I) ,/�KS&� 1�.z�U ,�jZ�� :'��V��� ��(�. :�O

W�PQ−��� ,�s��&� 1s�A ��� :� OW �u−�Q ,/����,&� ���2 /?A) , �M�&� ��j�%5: �Z����MD&� :�OW ��Q ,d��gU o���. ~ $�D�: R?�) ,�Z�� :e)�V5&� {�DX. :� W u� �.) �K�-? , GD%: $&��3 /K)� � "$�0�^&�) $�DLX&� {�? R. 1s�z� ~��� �D�0 $�#N�&�) $�#N-&� �XM&� ,�Y�A) ,� W O� �K�-? �.) , GD%: $&��3 /K)" "9M&� W�^0 ~ �. G#� 1��I4� m�&� "

m�n�&� d�2�? R�#`�N&� G#� m�&� $�D�: R?� �DL�0 ')��: �I �DKsU) ,/?�� R?�U ,@3�5&� R?�) ,R�-�� R?�) ,"K��;) E

�)�#k R?�) ,�Z�� :HV.�N. :W��P ,a`�%&� ��5f :WP� ,/��N�&� R��&� ��K�?) , �&A �I)H�A�? R��� ��U R. ��59:) ���59: ~ $&��3 , �K�D�" /?�� R?� ��59: G&� /�,&� H���: " �.�N: �I)

�L�&� d3�fz�E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W �PQE

Page 52: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � � −

u�� : , Y�!$e�� Y�cB�de� 4G� Í �A�G,� B)� , .f�E� �V+ ¢ B,�� r] �� l,a[ #B;B, , #Bf;B,� 8f! B)�"��F3 , �f,Bc�: " �f�[ #Bf;B,� >�&��� Í :�� , �%� �� b,3 3333 , .)� �&s b0 (@ t� , 1�s AB)�� ,

.)� (@ , 1�s (@ , .)� (@ , 1�s (@ , ��� �� �aV� , 1�/V,� �%$/J B���7� :�� `B9 Y;� �� >2G,��Ò"� F , �,Bc�: "�f�Ve� B)� Ð K�� Ve�� K �f�± ,

U�c �DE:n ��[ .�E� X;.+ �&,0�o , Y�#B;Be� 8! B)� , #B;B,� B� w0"�OF ,�,Bc�:−

b0 NBfffV,� Í P&fff�� �ffc�.J b±

#Bf;B,� 8f! Bf�� 8f%,� :�� lfffff&�7 >fffff,�: Í 4Gfffff/�± � �

ffff&$%,�7 >fff,�: Í 4fff±2VJ���F

��/ G� &(���M�U , � �a� .+.�J Í ��<[ ���f,Bc ��afe: " rf] fc

n� o"9M&� W�^0 : W���E

n� o$&sX&� t�VU : WQE

n  o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W ���E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W ��E

n� o�DM. R? �^� R? �DM. R? "�K��?� R? yM&���� �K ,�DM. �?A ,R��&� 8xI ,/��D&� ,/��I�&�� , G&� $�%�" $��I3 " R. 8��I R^2 " $���. " ,R�-�� R?�? 3�LcD&� ,G#� ��0�p ��U<

"L0�^:) $�s5&� m�Kb $N��� E �&��4� ~ "#-&� 8#x? a,Vf� ,���. R�? aN�:) ,$.�9D&� $9. G&� <sM:�. t�K "h ,�� 1�IA) ,

~�: �L�0) E $�� �&)���jK , $�� ~�:)��QjK , $�� a�I)��ujK E/�KS&� '�I :" ��gU 1sU H& $I��(&�) m�M:�� y��� G#� ��0�-&� ~" � R. jK H:�5&v. :" �3�-&� �? " ,)" $��2z� " E

~ HVDn�: �Z�� :C��0�&� C��0 :��W P��−P�u ,�-&� :�OW O � ,$��L�&�) $����&� :��O W �� ,=m3�&� R?� |�3�: :� W O��−O�P ,R�Dg&� �N-&� :�PW O �−OOP , ��%&

��(�D&� :�OW OQ ,d�K�(&� 1�X�&� :��W O − OO ED&� �SK ~ 8%� �I) G&� 3m�^m�n�&� d�2�? '�N&�) $I��(&� ,H�%� RD.) ,�Y�A ,�M�&� ��%5: ~ /����,&� ���2 �?A H? '�N&� G&� ,

Page 53: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � � −

U�E� �$G,� N� N��\,�7– �D�j$9 u�� – f! �f)�[ ��&f�E� Í #Bf;B� S:�� >,�: , Sf:�� >f,�: f! U�E� Í S#B;B� �)�[ ��&�E� �G&,� ,

#B;B� U�E� N�[ �e �D� l,w�=� ��&f�E� �f� :�� O[ Nx� �)�[ ��&�E� Í �JBc BjD ! ��$�+ ,f�E� �f� N� l,w�bBf$c U�E� �$Gf,� Of$�+ �f� ��&=

&D�:�=� , bBf$c �f�$�+ �� �)2��=.f|V/� =�3 33"��F , �f,Bc�: " �+��fc f7E� , Uª� �+���,�� ,A��f� ! UªE�� , Y�w f! A��fe�� , Sf:�� Y�af,�� ,

#B;B,� >%&$R ! ?�ª Zs :�B,�� , uf: >f+BI� Í #B;B,�� , Í uf��� �7�@ >&D�� ,|,��SA�À,�7 �2! \� YB$ , \�� >&�%,� �+���,� ��a: Nx� �G5D �! , u�� \M� B�� , "Zfs �f2! \f� >f&�%,� �+��f�,� �$@� N0� ,

�f&�� �f,� �2!� �2�� �7 "Zs�,3333333 , Bf)� �f7�|,� "#Bf;� Í N�f[ �w0�U�E� , .f�g� Bf)� #%J� O' N�[ �w0�� � K , Of��� , #f%,�� , YBf$|,��,

>�V,�� , >%;�.e�� , �+.%/,�� , >+Cf,�� , (+f�,� Bf� , �w0 (+f�,�� �f,0 �, U��+ �2!� �7 \�� , .f�g�� U�E� Bf� �f� , �f7�|,�� , (�V/fe��

-.%e� , �);� b0 l,�� �� OV� >���7�"� F 3 ,�f,Bc�: " Bf� uf��� "7� �� O[ O]�K K× , �JAB]� , �J�w� , ��%7� ��[�, �, �§ �� >); �� ,

�§ �� !� , �§ t[�"�OF 3

�)�#k R?�) ,�DL�� aN�&� 1�N: �DU ,e)�V5&� {�DX. ~ $�D�: R?�) :� W �� , R. �K��;)

o���D&� ,/��-&� 1�.z�) ,�Z�� :��DX&� �N� : $�� �m��2 ���P−�uujK ,WuP−u�E

n� o�3�-&� �? :W��uE

n� o�3�-&� �? :W uE

n  o�3�-&� �? :WOP�E

Page 54: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف

− � � −

Ã�NP2�� i�E��� &(���M�U , #Bf;B,� 8f7 �.f5+ b �fD0 >&&J �7� �2! U�c YB$|,�� , &�e�� u�Le� 87 �.5+ b� , "Zs� Ï.! �7� 2! t[ , �f� "2%�

`B9 b� Zs (@Ø � ,"B;B,� �� �;� �p7� F3 , ,� N� >&&J �7� .[w� Î�Gf�/ �&� 1.;� ��V7 .� ,(�:� �,pG�;�+� �a� =� � Y�w �� ,U�f��: (f@� ± �

? �2! �A��3 ��V7 ¦d� �%�� .�� , �f�;.7 .f�g� ��[.� ,U�f��: b ��[.J ,�2� �Dx��OF 3

�+%Gf,�7 �f+.%/,� ! �)&� �B�,� �&�,� >L&G7 Sh;B� S.V� l�/� %7��?��,� .)��� #B;B,� S:� ��a7� �7 8 , Of$c >+c S.V� �k� 8$J c�

-BCf/,�� >5Gf�5,� Sa��D \! T<9�� ���# T<9�� , ~f%7 �fH N�f� T<9�� >�BC/�� >59<� , >&�V,�7 �­�a; B$Æ ¢� , `B�J SA�J ��� O7 ,

�%�J SA�J� , N�f�$,� lf�J Í Õ�&G,� X6B,�� >&�<9�� >�&$,� �Gj7 >&�<9�� ,� .)� Ë/,��)&�2/%� ~%7 �)&3 �af� >[Bf� �f+Bc fc �fD� f&7

n� o/#� R? ����� R? /#� R? ��D�#� �K ,o�?�&� �?A ,R��&� ��5� ,=�`�-&� ,/.�9&� ,}�%D#V&� ,

~�p ,���f ,8�mA , $�� �&)� �jK , $�� ~�:�Q�yc.�? jK E dS.s: R. =���N&�) �K ��U) G#�) /?�� R?�d�2�&� ~ HVN��� E~ HVDn�: �Z�� :�-&� :�OW O� −O�O ,C��0�&� C��0 :

�� W O�O−O�� ,$��L�&�) $����&� :��OW O � ,d�K�(&� 1�X�&� :�uW Q−O� , �N���DX&� : $�� �m��2 ��uQ−�QujK ,WQP−��� ,~�c&� a�&�&� :��W O�Q ,1s��� :�O

W�O� ,���X&� dT�. :��W �� −��O E RD.)/�KS&� 1�.z� m�n�&� d�2�? '�N&�) $I��(&� G&� H�%� ,��gU R?�) ,/#��M&� m�jD-&� R?�) ,

HVDn�: ~ $N?�%&� on��D&� ~ �DU ,�Y�A) ,$�D�: R?� ,�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W���−�� ,��MD&� �M�&� ���%5: ~ /����,&� ���2 �?A) :�OW ��Q , ~ �)�#k R?�)

HV.�N. :W��P ,a`�%&� ��5f ~) :WP�E

n� o$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W ���−�� E

n  o�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W O�Q ,WO� E

Page 55: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � � −

��ae� ,<[ �)&� Ä�! Ë/,� Sz5,� Í "#��A .|[�= �+%Gf,� �f� , Bf�� b� 8+.FI� X9�/,�� ���|,� N.�,� , Ëf&_ .fV� >&�BCf,� �)&� ¾A� Ë/,� Ë��

Ï.! �7� �+,� , \[E� »&�,�7 -�.%e� Z)�,� ÍBC,� , ��f�J �af,��0 SA����5Di �&,=� , ��afe� �afI O]*e�� %�e� uj7 %+ �a,�� ,=2&%/Gf��

TB�!� -A�%� �� Ô�� �� OV7 , �?�L,� Y�A��0� , Y�f����� U�B:�� , Y<+�pfJ� ªB�A� , Y����f�� Y�5f��V�� , ��afe� �af� r&f6B/, ,

"ZG5J� ,��&]pJ� "�+�$� �! ��V,��3 �f� Zf|[ `, ��ae� �a� .)�� ,� �.5,� ��w w0 >&�BC ,¿ N�[ N� %7=� ��a+ b , b0 �7 UB�,� ! W.§ b�

()2� #�:g� ,S!�$/� >2�ª� Í� 3 Of[ Çf+ NE Î�f;.�� �+Qf,�� Î�ª�f/5/,� %Gf,� O|� X�# �a,� �a��

�B6Be� �a� Í �+�.7 t)2� :�� ,�2� >:�¤ �5cB� ŧ�Ø � K 3 �2,� u&�� Í ��Q,� N��� �a��Î�|,� �j$e� Í >&?h�� "a� Í . 3

Page 56: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � � −

=���� KLA� �&��� !/!� �8� Z ���5� [!-�

N�J.�� �j$e� �a� ���:− O�� ���2� : !/!� �8� Z ���5� [!-� :

\�( : !/!� �8� Z =� P�"2"� ��� �� [!-�:− S.V� UB: ·BC2,� ~%7 Î�ª�/5/,� �+,� %9 >�<%�, #Bf;B,� Sf:� ,

N�V7 S.|V,� �� �VJ ¢ N0� �]BCD� , �f$�a� f! >f:�¤ >f,�# �k� b0 S.V5,� "a� UB: �+�A� ,&5D �)&52+ B)�=�f%R�c =� , b�fL70 �f)�L$+�=.��f� =� ,

.|V/� #%/� #B;B,� N� `.+� , :�B7 P&,� ,%$J Y�#B;Be� N��=� l,af, S.|V/�� S#%/�3 �2! AB)�e� ¦2,�� �f&7�/[ Í �f�.[w S.V5,� "a� UB:"

]��e�" ¥°� " ]��e� " , ¥Q,� �� %G,� ¦27 Ë5/[� -B9� , f��S#�+ª� �/e� `B:3

>��%,� AB�E� �� #B;B,� �j$� Í ]��e� ¥° Í U�c :" t&f� .)/f�� c uf�Le� #Bf;B,� Bf� �f;�B,� >f�&�: N� >�BC/e�� >5G�5/e� �� X' 87 ,

VG�=��f! NBfV+ N� ªBf§ b �Dp7 =���f%� �� =� , .��f� Bf�� , >f&��� b� S#B;B� , #B;B,� X� �� , �f&[z,�� ��f&/:b� �f� l,w Í �e , N� 8f%/�

#B;� NBV+=� , ·�M� #B;B,� B� P&,� , �[.� u�Le� X� a�� N0 �DE , ��/j� ��.%e� #.µ �� , u�Le� m0 &�e� ��&/:� SA�½ ,½� �fD� SA�

#B;� O[ X5JAb u�Le� X5JA� B, , uf�Le� #Bf;B,� N� ()&f�! #A�� 8:� �A�fM� Í �f, uf�� b Åf[ TB)5� , SZf|[ #�.f�� �f,� , 4��f2/J #�fVJ b ,

�&� .|VJ b :�� �;�B,�� , Bf� #B;B7 #B;B� Úd� :�� �Dp7 �B7�;� �G5D , Y�#B;Be� Í .|V/,� tD0� ,���f6�� >Lf9�B7 Y , .f|VJ >Lf9�B7 b

Page 57: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− � � −

�­�#B;� ,#B;B� OC: N�GD�� m0 �GD �w0 �Dx� , #Bf;B� }.5,� m0� .�i , �aV�� ,�2,Bc 42%� �a� !�: #B;� �D� #B;B� �;�B,� , 4f2%���2,Bc: N�GD�� , }.5,� �� , "Zs �� , #B;� �w �D� #B;B� , �f, N� 4f2%7

�;�B,� m0 >$GD ,�2f� �! ª�z:� �a�� P&f, �f;�B,� Npf7 r+�f/,� >! #B;B7 , #B;B� O[ N�� , Y�A�w��,� #B;� 4/: , �;�� , t! � m�%J

B�! NBe��,� UB�+=�Z$[ =� , Y�#B;B,� .|V/� b0� , uf�Le� #Bf;B,� NBf[��B)5�=�&�[ =� , �A�½ ��a,� Í b0 �, u�� b , ��f&/:� �f� �Bf�BJ �f��

OR�7 T�%,� m0 ·�M� ,7 PV%,�7 .�E� O , �f6 Í b0 T�f%�, uf�� b w0 ·�M� ,&J�w T�%,� N�[ �w0 (%D=� ���%J Í �&,0 .�/5+ ·�d�, , N�f[ �w0 �f���6A�!=�<� 3 #B;B� O[ X5JAb X5JA� B, �D� �� ��.[w ��� , �;�B,� 4/: ,

�!�5JA� X2/&� , ��! �� ,$;�� NBV&�=� , >L,��� ,B;B,� Th�+ tD0� B, 1 �J�a, T%,� ��2/�� N�[ , �B2¬ B�� , ��f5JA� Th�/G+ >&�V,�7 �!�5JA� NE O7

"#�.�� ~%7 , �;�B,� B� �a,� , �f;�B,� Tª�Bf, .?�Gf[ , >f&��e� Of|� , >&�%,�� , >&�7��,�� ,l,w Zs�3O&c Nx� : -�CfJ� ��f2/�b �fJ�a, X2/+ O7

��&�27 ��,�3�2�c :27 ��f,� -�CfJ� Xf2/e� ��f&� , �f&�! �f�� 4f2%7 SpR�Be�7 ,�2,Bc O|�: Tf! #B;B,� , ���/f�b�7 b ,�f2,Bc Of|�: #Bf;B,� T�%� , >&D�|,� YbB�%e� �� u�Le� #B;B,� N� ! �tV�� u5J� c� �&[

, >+A�$/!b� AB�E�� ,N�&!E� Í �I u�� b Ë/,� 3 NBfV7 NB�?��,� 4!#� (@e� #B;B,� B� �;�B,�hf�A �tfV�� T<f[ �f� X6�B� Í N� u�L= ± �� �af� m0

42%e�; &0�w �(��: �j$,� #B;B,� B� �;�B,� , b ¶Qf7 #Bf;B,�� , �� �f&� &&�J b �a,� -�,� #B;B,� ,<f]�= , &0�_w �_(���: Zf� #Bf;B,�

~_ , #B;� T! B� tD0 �G5D Í Q,� NE , #Bf;Be� Utf[ Tf! �� , �f�

Page 58: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

,w N0 �&: �7 u?b Zs T%,� l , "2! .@*� Zs �� , m0 }�f&�,�7 #B;B,��° NBV+ c �,t[ T#�%,� ��,�=� , �J�a, b �V, ,+#*� �DBV, O7=� lf,w !

T%,� , ° b T! b �&j� ,%Lc=� , ~f_ Zf� �j$,� #B;B,�� , �_(���&0�w: O|� b� 6 �, O�%+ b #B;B,� ,U��+ �D¼� �,� ��� ABf)�� 2!

�f, XD�f¬ .�i #B;Be SB�,� Í ��G� #B;BeÒ , �fDB[ �2f6.� N0� #Bf;B,��#Bff;B�=� #Bff;B�, >&ff6�.%e� 4ff2%7 , �ff� �� �ff%Dt+ N� ABCff/+ <ff�

Y�#B;Be� ,&f� �A�f� �fe ·�M� 2!�=� �Bf6Be� Í .f�i , ��f2/�� Xf� �&� t)!t/;� , �f��Bc Í Ë2�/Gfe� Ofje� Bf� �Bf6Be�� U�f�� �f! , b�

#Bf;B�, l,w ABC/+ , �fD�7 ��f, TBf�J b w0� ± � � , ABCf/+ <f� (�f9 Bf,�Ð � �%��§ b� �$c�%+ �#B;� ,&0�w �(���: OC� b� P2; �, P&, #B;B,� ,=2&! �, �h; b �&G7 �DE� �2�w b� , �G5D ! ���J Th, b0� , T�J SA�½

fM� Í OfV,� #B;� ! �h�� #B;� �A� ,f&;A�� �f[z,� N�f[ N0= �� , Í�&2�w N�[ N0 ��a,�= �� , #B;� N�[ N0 "�h; NE�= � ± �� , #Bf;B� ��=� , Tf�J Thf, �G5D ! ��,� ,�! N�[ N0�=� , ��%� ��=� , ��f&�27 ��f,� Tf�J Th, ,

(!� NBV+ N� �§ P2�� NE�± , #B;B,� �� (!� b� , b0 �� �f� �f� w0#B;� �,�3 i�_` 4��81�� x�G =� 4f5� b , .f�E� >f+��� (�f9 Bf,�

Î�%e� "aH �;�B,�� #B;B,� �� O[ -�CJ� , Í 8/$;Bfe� �f! ��/D� b� Î�f|,� OV�,� , �fDB[ �f;B+ b #Bf;B�, ABf�E� "af� T�hf, N� �f�&���

�;�B,� ,T�h��, �­���G� 8$/J ¢��3 #B;B,� B� �;�B,� NBV7 UB�,� (@ Le� AB�p7 ()y�J Í�2+ u� ,�(�� >&��%,� YbBje� �� u�Le� #B;B,� N� ,<f�! Oje� �! ��W�2�/9� X2/+ Ë/,� AB�E� ��= , �f&� �IBCf: Xf2/+�

�A�M� �Gj7 , >&��e�� N�V���[ , N�GD�� O|� -<d7 , �! ��/G� �Dx�

Page 59: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Oje� ,Ë;A�M� Oje�7 ���&c Nx� ��&$,� O|��3 �(��� YbBf�%e� �f� �D� >&D�|,� , m�E� YbB�%e� uj�J Ë/,� �A�B%,� �� , �fH �w�y b �&: ��

�A�M� Í .�� , >&�V,�[ , >&?h��� , >&J�a,�� , >&6.%,�� , ufj�J AB�� �kE O�%,� Í �IBC: 2! ��&�E� u?��: , #B;B,� B� �� N�&!E� Í P&,� ,

>&J�a,� �� , >&6.%,� �� ,<|�= , N�GD�� N�&!E� Í tD0� , #�BGf,�� ,<|f�=3 ��('� �f� ��&f�E� Y�#Bf;� N� Bf� N�&$,� �&,0 ��GD� �� N� >);� �� .�D

>&��%,� YbBje� , >&D�|,� YbB�%e�� ,uf�Le� #Bf;B,� Í T<V,� N�[�3 �(��� �Ve�� �;�B,� m0 (G�2+ �D� ,.�/5� N�[ N0 �DE=�� �$9 m0 �V , �;�B� b0� , ¾#�f��� (+f�,� m0� ,cB$Gf� N�f[ N0 �fDE=� Z�,�f7 , ��

T%,�7 , ¾#�j� ,(+�� b0�3 �(��� >&Cd�,� Y�!B6Be� .|V/7 .|V/+ �D� , �.f!� f+ª #B;B[ ,}.f5,�� N�GfD�� #Bf;B[ >f&!B2,�� , >&Gf2���

Y�$2,�� N�B&�� #B;B[3 7�w �¸p:/Ge� Oje� B� �B6Be� �! ���Bc Í Ë2� U��� , #B;B�, l,w ABC/+ b� ,��w: UBje� O7��+ �� �2)� #�.e� , Bf��

���/�b�7 #B;B,� �&�! Oy �a,� , Å�! �2)� T�&�,�� (�9 B,�Ð K , >f&��e�� #B;B,� N�# ¸:<J , �A�%,� �! �?�2�/9� 42%� �a�� , l52+ b N�[ N0�

Å�! #B;� �!3<V,� �a� .���� Pf5D Ëf� tfD0 Y�2Ve� Y�#B;� N� T uff�Le� #Bff;B,� , Offje� m0 >��ff6��7 Y.ff|VJ ,ABff�� �Gff&,�=� S.ff|V/� �)G5Dp7 >CCj/� , �, >6�.%� , �f� .f|V/+ uf�Le� #B;B,� N� #�.e� Np[�±

�#B;Be� �� �&�! B� �]YY�!B6Be� .|V/7 >]�M� 3 �(��� UBf�� �fD� �#B;Be� !Y l&V�/,�7 ,f[u$f9 t3 uf: Í O&j/Gf+ �f¬ lf,w Xf&'� �;�B,� ,}�J� m�%J3 u�Le� #B;B,� B� �;�B,� NBV7 UB�,�� >���7�

S9�� UB]� ! Ë2$� ,f:�� �DB[ O|�=�#Bf;B� ¦d�f,�7 =��A�fM� Í

Page 60: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

� �J�a, T%,� X2/¬ , �f)&�! �<�%,� u5J� AB�� N<L$, Th�/G�� , �fDB[ Of|� ��&�E� -.!� ,[z��=��#B;Be� 87 Y , bB��= l&V�/,�7 �)&�! ,#�f%�=�

YbB�%e� Î�B@ Í , Y�2Ve� #B;B, �$� �;�B,� NB[� ,5C/�=� (�%,�f7 S�&��� S#�A��� SA�,�� , O9.,� U�9A0� , �/V,� U�hD0� , �f¬ lf,w Zs�

>%+Q,� �7 Y#A�"��F 3 �����: !/!� �8� Z =��/�T 6��D� [!-� :−

>,pGe� "a� Í .�2,� u&�j/7 .��� Tt/�� �+Q,� &G�, , >,�f9A �f,� �� #B;B,� S:� Í >]BC² , #B;B,� Í �� ,�, (;.J �! #A� t[� F3 c�

|j7 >,pGe� X$��=��&��� =� �)&� ,]BCD �, N� t[=� �f:�° ~f%7 Í `.�� �&��B:� , S.��� Y�A��0 �)&� ,� ��f5� �)�f%7 Í� �Bfs , m0 ��f/y

O�pJ T�%D0� .�D N�%�03 ! >,b,� Í �):¤�� �J�A�$! (�� #A�� -B9� J�$@0 "#BC��=�&5D �� =� , 7�§0=�$�9 �� =� , �f+�A Í T<fV,� uf�:� lf,w %7 (@

n� o�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �O −�P E

�-%&� 3�fA �I) ,G&�-: �� HD23 , H�A ~ +&�g&� +M�D&� ~ 3�^Vk�? e�kA d�. 8KSD&� �SK G&� RD� ���,? �MV� � G&�-:C��L&z� ~ �.�_&� �^ND&� ,'�I +�2 :" ���kT ���KS. ��LK)

�/f ~ H�. �%�&) m�M:�� )A '�#M&�? ��DK�� EEEEE|&� ,}�g&� :y#xD&� m�n�&� �K 8n��&� �A ,<spA H�0 d�gU � �2�) �K) , '��_&� $&(�D? /K /V&� C���-V&�) C�0��z� ~ d�g9&� �D��)

t��%&�) ,�NM&� ~ a9&� 7�$x&�_D&� y��x? � �K�ZD&� G#� 3�9V� �2�) $N , � �����&� ~ �g9V�)1�%N��� y��x? ,m�M:� �) ��LK '�#2 s0 ,$���,&�) $����h�� 1�-& , �3�k a��� �&7 ~ "L.sU)

{�c&�) aN-&� y��� R� EH�sx? G&� m�n�&� +M? ~ ���fA �I) , R. H& �D0 �� a#Y� R. R9&m�K" END&� ]�f�p� :� W ��E

n� o "I3 $�f�M&� ~ ���c&� $Dn�: 3m�^. �Z��� F ,���Z&� �cU �Z��) :��W uQ� , +�2 $5�#k /n�2 �K�D�"m�n�&� ~ $&��3 " , ��D� =�� R�? =S&� ��x_D&� ~)" d�2) ~ $&��3

m�n�&�" ,�DM. H�?� ����) $��3�5&�? ���c&� ��%&� �L5&A �I)E

Page 61: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين

− ��  −

"#BC���3 Ëf� >,pGfe� "af� Í "f�/%� A�f)�� �J�5,*� �GD� �� O%,� &,0 A��fe� #B;B,� S:� Í �/,�9Af5Di �f)=� , f+.F/,� ¥° f! >&f��:�3

���� �#� �kE >&���� �� �C27 �$2,�3 f+.F/,� ¥° f! �/&f��: Í �+Q,� &G,� U�c��F#Bf;B,� �fj$� Í :

" Sf:�� �J�w b0 Xc�B,� Í P&, �D� m0 >&�BC,� �� >!�' ��w , �f[.J b<]� �)&�= , S#%/� Y�5] �I O7 , �)2&! Ë� ,: Ë�� Í "hf2e� #B;B,� >�&�

N�V��� N�C�D Yt9� T%,� �?�B� �! �J�w : , #Bf&�7 Y�f&&�J �fI� Sh+t/� Y�#B;B� `��zJ l,w �Gj7 >+A�$/!� , #f%J lf,w �f� (�Bf/&�

Ë�&�: , #�f�� Tf! �f� "�.f[w �f� (/+ ¢ l,w N<L7 ! N��.7 (/+ ¢ t� Y�&��e� , (/+ b� ,�+�=� , f;B,� ��z�� #B , �fV¬ #Bf;� �f$|+ b Of7 ,<]�=3 Of�%,� ABfR �f! ��.f� �af� UBfc� , #f%/7 S��f� �f/��7 Nxf�

&�&�: �#%J Y�#B;Be�=� , >f�&��� Í >f5,�d/� u?�f�:� Y��w �k�� , N�#��� A�$/!b�3 (­�5f��V� m0 ��#�2/f9� NB!f+ >f,��e� l�J m0 NB$��a,�� (­������ ,B]B,� �V+ b �D�� �Jbb#� O�%,� �:�$7 �)&,0 U , B� O7

��ff2� U�hff%� , YbBff�%e� ��A#0 Í P��ff[ , Y�;Aff7 N�ff&�/e� �ff���O�%,� , UB$�� O�%,� �, )� �� Np7 NB�?��,�� , #�#.f� �f&�! )f� ��� ,

"��A� ABR b �D�� , Y����e�� Y�5��Ve� l�J N� NB!h&� , .+f�J !

n� oHD�� t�V9&� apA " 1s9&� ���X: " $�� ~�VD&�) /��x&� �DM. R? �DM. R��&� ��^�& ��� jKF ,}�L5pz� RD2�&���� R? m�DM. R��&� �Df H2�f , $�� ~�VD&�����jK F , �SK G#�)

}�n�X&� ���c&� ��%#& $�f�2 ]�c&� E"��N&� ]�c&�? ��-� }�L5pz� ]�f) , ]�c&� �D��?&� �s� $.s-#& �K ���X&�/Xf�N&� �DM. R? /#� R�� , $�� ~�VD&��u�QjK EF�Z�� : �cU

���Z&� :��W O�� – O�uE

Page 62: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�)/j] ,B+ t7 >,�*� O�%,� u�� , �f! NB2�/G� (�2! �/��7 S#�)�7 ()� lf,w U�|�� N<L7 ! N��.7 >��c0 , �f5/�+ b S.7�fV� �f�h+Bv N�f%+�× K �

�)&,0"��F 3 #B;B,� �j$� Í U�c� ,�+�=� , S#�f+ª �f! T<fV,� f2! >&���� P5D ��

>&��e� ! #B;B,�: " �a� – >,pG� UB: Ä��D �� `.; �� m0 SA��0 S#�+ª �J#�+ª T! �� >&��e� ! #B;B,�− #�.f�� �f, Å[ TB)5� #B;B,� N0 �2�c �w0 ��CJ� Y�&��e� �H >5C/� SZ|[=�&�&�: =� , TBf�,� �f/[ Í ABLGfe� Bf� tf[

()5,� �&,0 A#�$/+� ,�+�=� , f: Í >Cfd�/� >�&�: #B;B,� N0 �2�c N0 ���� �­�w ,"B;B,� �� �;B7 �)&� #%J b , �­�af7 >?�c Ë�� , �f)&,0 �.fL/+ b

<]� T!= , %Lc N�V�0 b�=� , �f;�B,� >f�&�: Ë�� , "Zfs NBf[ 4f2%��#B;B�=� lf,w m0 >]BCf² >$GD ��Z�7 T�&�,� >%2/e� >�&��� l�/, N� B� Z�,� , >&5&V,� >,B)µ >$G2,� l�J �D�[ N0� , �[�A#0 �! hF%+ T<[ l,a�

?�C$,� B,�� b0 >&,�! >$c�@ >2L57 "2! �� �BC� �+a,� .× K , �fD, �f� �BJ��� >�,�7 >���[ >V:"� F 3

>f&��e� �j$� Í >&���� P5D Í �+�A �+Q,� &G,� r6�� c� , SABCf7�#� ,U�c �&:: " NBf[ Í ¥A��f,� �f�#A�� Ëf/,� �f:�$e� "af� N� (f�!�

�;�B,� 8! #B;B,� ,?�ª ��=� �&�! ,t�V,� Ë� TBf�,� �G,� ! S.?�,� YT��e� �a� Í , b0 �)[Af+ b �f¬ �fk� u$f9 t&� �D°� c `.�� >,��� �2)��

1�$,E�� .?�C$,� �B,�� , 1�fLM� OCf�� >f�,�7 >fVj7 �BCf� �+af,�× K ,

n� o���XV&� ]�f G#� ���c&� $�f�2 : $I3)�u\AE

n� oy?�%&� on�D&� : $I3) O\ t– �\AE

Page 63: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�2)� �)�C52�� , .+.j/,� S.?�# �7 �&�� .+.�/,� SBc �7 Ë5+ �� A�7 , UBf�2�%2� u&�B/,� �7�u&�.,� ( : #B;B�, .+��� TB)5� O[ ,<|� N�GD��[= , �fDx�

#B;B,� �&,0 (�2+ ¢�� , "B;B,� �� �;B7 ,#Bf;B� �fV+ ¢ .f�E� P5D Í=� %Lc �)&�=� , �fDBV7 (fV�� �, �V+ ¢ �&,0 #B;B,� Tt�D� O�%,� ¸:<+ ¢���#B;B�=� , #Bf;B� �fDB[ Í B)� #B;B�, .+��� TB)5� OV�=�Pf5D Í .f�E�

#B;B,� B� �a,� "Zs m0 ��/_ ,#B;B� �DB[ Í ��/_ B� �� O[�=� "Zs m0 �V¬ B)� ,#B;B� �DB[ Í ��/y �� b0 �V�, 42%� b w0=� "Zs m0 , OV�

�V¬ B)� #B;B�, .+��� TB)5� , �;�B7 �Ve� �� �� b� , �� �� <� �;�B7 #B;B�, S.+��e� Y��B)5e� ,c�#B;B� �;�B,� N� N��\,�7 �$@ ,

#B;B,� 8! b0 NBV+ b B)� , �J�a7 #B;B� B� �a,� , �J�a, .+��� .�p7 b ,&?h; �;�B,� NBV+ N� �;� �e�=�&�&�: =� , t?�c= �J�a7 ,�J�a7 �2&%J NBV+� ,

�J�w ! ?�ª .�p7 bÒ , #B;B,� NBV+ N� �;� ,�+�=� , l,a[ , �f2&! B� w0 ,<��B)5� #B;B,� NBV+ =�&�[ =� #�.�� �, NBV+ N� �V+ , �J�w : Í B� O7

Ë�&�: Ë?h; , #%J N�V�0 �&� P&, , T�G�D� b� , �f! "hf2� �fJ�a7 (?�fc�6A�! �DB[=� "Z�, , uf�Le� #Bf;B,� B� �;�B,� NBV&� , �f! `.f%e� ��

"Zf�7 &&�/,� , �f&,0 Tt�fDb�� ,��.f! ABCf/+ b �af� f!� #Bf;B,� >2Ve� Y�&�t�, , m0 >]BCf² >$GfD �I N� b0 S#B;B� �kB[ 42%� P&��

�J�a7 (?��,� #B;B,� SÀ: , >5�/² "B;� ! >$G2,� l�J� , 4/� ��jD�� ,�)/&��� ! �<R�� Aa%/+3f&?h; #B;B,� N�[ N0� Å[ #B;Be�� =�f&�&�: =�3

���f� �f� 8f��je� ~f%7 ".f[w �f� ¦d�� �a��23 b�_w: b0 �f�%+ b� (�%,� Í NBd9�.,�3 �w �¸p: �fD� #Bf;B,� ¸5, �� ��a,� m0 A#�$/+ �a,�

&?h; NBV+ �&V� >[Q,� X2+ b TB)5�=�&�&�: =� , �+��=� ¸f5, �f� TB)5e�

Page 64: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

#B;B,� �7 T�c �� #B;Be� , (f)�<[ Í .)/�� t[ , b 4f2%7 ¯f5+ �f&V�? :� �)5+ !�w: 1�B�� )b�S� #B;B,� >�&�: Í T<V,� N� , t&� b

¸f5�,� UB,f� �� N��wE� �&,0 A#�$/+ ,f�B)5� NBfV+ N� ªBf§ �fDx�=�f&�[ =� 6A�!�=�+A�$/!� =� �J�w : Í ��z�b� �! X2/e� Ë�&��� l,a, , TBf)5[

�/�&�: m0 }�&�,�7 �;�B,�3 Ã�d�� )��&,0 �#*+ ��� N��\,� B� X$/e� N� , T�BcE� >2G,� ! A�)/�b� b ,T���E� �+B/73 &�# >�?��,� >��e� ! �F/+ #B;B� �DB[ Í ��/y B� �� O[=��f&L, Xf2� �fV¬ B)� "Zs m0 , N� Bf��

#B;B� �DB[ Í ��/je�=�%Lc �V¬ ";B� B� "Zs m0 =� , �DB[ Í ��/je� b#B;B�=� "Zs m0 ,"#B;� B� �a,�32+� Í ��/:� �e �D� B�� u&c# .�27 X�

"Zs �� l,w #�5/9� �� "Zs m0 �/+#B;B� ,bB�%� A�]�=f�BcB� �f, =� Í �&�! l,w , �V¬ B)� l,a[ B� �� O[� , -BfcBe� Zf�,� l,w Ë9 ��B9

";B� �� "#B;� �&�!3 ��� Í #Bf;B,� N� �;�B,� 8! #B;B,� NB[ +*+ T%,� Í�2+ �J�w : , T%,� UB$c �! Y��B)5e� %7� B�� , b "�f! �� NE

�J�a, T%,� UB$c �! X2/+ , #B;B,� >L9�B7 O7 , B� �;�B,� N� l� b� �J�a, T%,� Í�2+ �a,� ,"Zfs >L9�B7 �&��2+ �� b3 �_w �¸_p: UBf�J �w�f�

�;�B,� 8! �DB[ X� #B;B,� N� `.+ �&� , T�G�Db�� ¡hF/�, O7�c Zs�, Y�#B;Be� O[�&� ! �G$D� c , �f)&� .)�� , �f� �� �f2! Bf�� <f�

��&�E� , �)2&!� �)/�&�: B� O7 , Y�2&%J� Y�&&�/7 Y#%J� Yª�/�� tD0� >+A�$/!� , S.f|V/e� ��B�E� AB] Í "AB)�� .j$,�7 l,a, O|+� , �fD� Xf�

��� .j$,� >�&�: b0 ��2� P&,3 �w:�� T<[ �2� ��9 c ABfR �af� N�

Page 65: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

O�%,� ABR ��A� , >&5�V,� Y����e�7 b0 �&,0 O]B/+ b , Y�.��f2e� N�# >&��%,� , �, u�� �e ¯&� O[� , N<V/,� �&�!� N�%/Ge� ��"��F 3

�Zf|[ �f�/Æ b Ë)� #B;B,� S:� Í �)52] Ë/,� �/,�9A Í �]BCD ������ae� �a� .+.�J Í >�7�G,� ·BC2,� �!;� �f&: �� #B;B,� N� .+.�J �

�+Z|[ ! �C+ Å[ .�p7 P&, �A�M� Í u&�j/,� , Úd� :�� B� O7 Ë�&�: , m�%J �;�B,� #B;� B� , Í �f2&%J� �/&��� 8! m�%J "#B;� N�� �A�M� , �;�B,� �[.J Th�, l,a[ .�E� �V+ ¢ B, w0 , m�%J ,U�f_ B��3

B;B,� B� m�%J �;�B,�� �&�!� # , u�Le� #B;B,�� , �%Lc , Th�, &�J B, w0 �;�B,� �[.J �2� , m�%J ,U�_ B��3 uf�Le� #B;B,� B� m�%J u�� �&�%�

&Cd� #B;B,� NB[ X�=�&�&�: =�3 Y�#Bf;Be� .|VJ B)� ���e� .|V/,� ���� Y�#B;B,� P&,� ,>��6��� A�$/!b�7 l,w�3 X� >,�9.,� "a� >]<� �a�

� S#�+ª AB2,� �J�.7 �I O&|/,�7 #B;B,� S:� ��ae >j&6BJ >�|� , .[w�Y�+�V�� ~%7� F , >�c�2e� Í �)2� -.R m0 SA���� Ôp/93 ����� ���2� : !/!� �8� Z ���5� [!-� �� :−

�7�B�f,� uf�� ��f�D� �+%G,� ·BCD >�c�2� (/+ -B9 S.�5,� "a� Í >&�%,� ,�j/,� �&: �� �H�j]� m0 ��Ag� �h! >c#� >j] �� u , >j]�

�f­���h�� ! Tª�B�,� �J.J �&: �� �)c�9 Ë/,� O?b,� , >f&%Lc `f�� 1B�Le� ! >,b,� Í �)/&D��.7� O?b,� "a� , Í u&�j/,�f7 l,w X$J� (@

#B;B,� S:� >,pG� , �)&� u�� N�&7� ,m�%J � ��� N0

n� oy?�%&� on�D&� : $I3)��\ t– � \AE

n� o�Z�� : }�n�X&� ���c#& m�n�&� d�2) ~ $&��3���x_.EF

Page 66: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

\�(:�� [!-� �� !/!� �8� G&M� J!8 =� P�"2"� ��� : &�; .)� �,=� �Bs b� �)&� P$, b SABC7 , l� b� �)52/V+ �+A b�

, %G,� N� , m�%J � ��A , #Bf;B,� S:� S.V5, >6A�%e� T�� �A�%� ,b�µ �+ b t7= ##zf,� �� �J�A�$! Í .��2�, , .f�2,� ��f;A0 #.fµ 4f/: ��

8J.[ �6 �D� ! U+ �� �&� .��2,� Oj/&, ± � , �f� �J�A�$! �6 45�� �� ��ae� �a� Í "##.J ! U+ �� ��h/Db �&� O�p/,� �;B/G+ , ��f9 f�� ,

� ��A , ¦2,� l,w Í , f]��e� ¥° �f� �fJ#A�� �a,� , O?bf,� �f��)9�9� �� S.V5,� "a� Tq �� Tª�B�,�� 3

%G,� u�� �,Ð K �7 UB�,� �B�D >&5&[� ��ae� �a� .+BCJ Í , O]� N� 87� Ë5G�� .�D m0 "#.�� l,w , >5G�5/e� �� X' ��a� �Dp7 ¥¤ �a� O;E

>�BC/e�� , -BC/,� �B5G�� �+a,� >�BC/e� �� , Ï.! �7�[ ,8%$9 �7�� , �BDB�,�� ,(�Zs�3

Gf�5/e� ~f%7 2! S.V5,� O]� N� %G,� 87 c� m0 Xf;.J >�BCf/e�� >5 �A�$,� :BJ Í >59<5,� ��A , "#.v� , �/R�G7� , �f&[z,� �?�B� �! ,

Ë2�a,� �� Ë;A�M� �[z,� ��B9 , �DBV7 (IBc �;B� N� ()2! O�D �� , m�%J , Y��f�� S! �&J.J m0 X;.+ �j$,� ·�M� #B;B,� , Ëf������

"#B;B7 XL�,� , m�f%J ,f%7 P&f, Bf)� T�f%� b� T ,_�#�H��� Thf�� f%7 "#B;B7 , m�%J , �Dp7 XL�,� �§ , m�%J , �f� �f�Zs �f! Sh&/� >&��� �w Y�&��e� , �/$,� �&� ��hD b .�� B�� ,d��H��� �f;�B,� �f[.J ��5/D�7 XL�,� , m�%J , Ë;A�M� �[z,� ��B9 ,Ë2�a,� ��3 Í S#A�B,� Ybt/:b�� a�2&:� Ò

�B,� u:¾<@ �;; #Bf;B,� �f! S#.fµ >f&��� NBfV+ N� ��x� , >f&��� ��

Page 67: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

#B;B,� X� �� S#B;B� , #B;B,� 8! � >&��� �� , ��5Jb�7 U�_ U�E�� , "#B;B, 45D �DE , m�%J , �|,�� , X� �� S#B;B� >&��� �;�B,� NB[ B��

#B;B,� , U�_ ,�+�=� , N� Thf, S#Bf;B� >f&��� N�f[ B, �DE l,w� NBfV+ #B;B,�� >&��e� �� �BFe� B� �;�B,� , Of�%,� �Gfj7 B,� �$[.J Th�&�

t)2���F , ��:� �;�B,� N�[ N0� , ��� >&��e� ��0 �� , #Bf;B,� N�# , �� ��� #B;B,� , >&��e� N�# ,�;�B,� ��&/:� Th, , m0 >f&��e� ��&/:� SA�½

�)��� Í #B;B,� , U�E� ! ,B,� ��&/:�� �f)&� �)f6�.%, >f&�t�, #B; , Î�f|,� ! ,Of�%,� Í Bf,�� F , �A�f%,� �f� �f[z,�7 �f2! \f%e� Bf�� ��.%e�� , u: Í >&��e� m0 #B;B,� Tt�D� Nx� .�E� Ac �.� �� !�Ð K

��&/:b�� �[z,� Th�/G+ �;�B,� , Of�%,� Í B,� , >f;��� Öf/�+ Bf�� >�C52e�� >�C/e� ,>�C/e�� �?�h;� m0 �[.e� >;�: , m0 �/;�: >�C52e��

��h;E� l�/, �,*e� ,=2�w�;A�� �� =� , >;�: O[ �! "h2/+ �;�B,���OF3 Y���e� "a� Y)� c w0� , uf: Í S#A�B,� SAB[ae� Ybt/:b� �5/D��

n� o$5�s5&� ��� 8U�&� 1)(& ,m�n)) $�K�. 8n��&� ��U @�0 G#� , G&� m�n�&� 1�DY�� �A8n��&� $�K�D& $�:�7 $5p m�n�&� ��U 3��V��? �.� $�K�D&� ,$�K�D&� R. 8n��&� 8jU�: 1(#�0 ,

C�S&� /K /V&�) ,m�n�&� /K /V&�) $5^&�) , $�K�. R. ��(n m�n�&� ��U @�0 G#� �.�)<) 8n��&�H��-: ,H�#� 1(#�) ,�Y�A< ,��(nA R. 8n��&� C�7 8U�: E �L0 "K��� ���V2�� 1)(& �.A)

m�n�&� o. $�K�. 8n��&� ��U @�0 G#� ,$�K�D#& m�n�&� @)�-& �&7) , ���V2� d3)��m�n�&� G&� �LNNM:) �L��-: ~ $�K�D&� ,$�K�D#& H�)�-& m�n�&� ���V2� �SU) ,H& yNM: � 7� ,

�Y�A ,� ���E

n� o�Z�� :�p�ND&� ]�f :��W ��E

n  o�p�ND&� ��f� : W�O�E

Page 68: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ة وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظري

− ��{ −

#B;B,� X� �� S#B;B� >&��� �DB[ �.� �� �w0 �;�B,� , �.� �� �w0 �a[�� � K� #B;B,� N�# >&�� , Ëf� >f&��� NBV+ N� B�� Z�E� Ut/:b� b0 u$+ (��=

#B;B,� 8!K ,f6A�! #B;B,� NB[ A�$/!�7 b=��hf; �� >f&�t�, =� �f)2� , b� #Bf;B�, >6�.%� >&��� �, �;�B,� NB[ A�$/!�7 , (�f2! Xf2/¬ �af� Nxf�±

�[z,� ���h�/9b ,<�! B,�= , .� t[3 4f2%� f! O7 �f/&���� �f/�&�: N� �ffj7 #Bff;� ,ff6A�! �ffDB[ �ff! "hff2�=�ff6�.%� �� =� , Í U�ff�� Bff� tff[

Y�2Ve� ,#Bf;� �fDB[ 42%��=�f/j7 =� , b ¶Qf7 #Bf;B,� #.fµ Bf� �� , �f2! -�f]�E� .?�f9� Tf%,� ��f9 b ¶Q7 NB2%+� , �fD� �� , m�f%J ,

�&[.J S#�+ª b ¶° X� #B;Be� ,#Bf;B,� �fD� NBf2%+ b� ÅfV,� uf�Le� �&� �z�e� ,#B;B,� S:B7 NB�?��,� �)� �� ! 3

�fDBV7 ()2f� r+�J �&� �V+ ¢ N0� �a� >59<5,� ��A� , m�f%J , #Bf;B,�u�Le� , #Bf;B,� Sf:B7 UB�,� m0 Ö5e� , #Bf;B,� 8f7 NBfc.5+ (kBfV,

�ffj$,� ·�ffM� , ��Gff,� ¶Qff7 #Bff;B,� Bff� �aff,�� , b ¶Qff7 �� ,B,�� 1�§�� ¶Q7 b #B; , T�%,� u�Le� #B;B,� B� �a,�� , �&� �z�e� ,

¶Q7 b �2! \%e�� , ��#�5/f9� >�BCf/e�� >5G�5/e� �� .52,� l�,�� N� b0± >59<5,� �b*� �)2� �� , �/R�Gf7� (�f2! �f;�B,� f&:BJ ! (?��,�

�J�w Í �[z,� ��BD� O[ Ë527 ,�A�$/!b� �[z,� 4/: �f[z,�[ Ë2�af,� #B;B,�� >&��e� �� , ��&/:b�� T��/,b� (�2! Th�/Ge� , �a� ()2� ��a�p�

�)2e� , �j$,� ·�M� #B;B,� ! 4/: "B,hD�� , �B$�a� , �Bf/$@� N� f%7 #B;B,� B� �;�B,� >�&�: NB[ , u�Le� #B;B,� B� #B;B,� �a� NB[ m0 ,

Page 69: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�DB[ �B%2�� , m�%J ,#B;�=��� ]=� , �+�=� , Th�/Gf+ ·�fM� #Bf;B,� NE �[z,� ,�+�=� , uf�Le�� f&�e� �� , ��zf�b� �f7 �f¬ �� , TBf)5� Bf�� #B;B,� , h+t/,� �7 �¬� , >f&��e� >&]BCf�� ¦d�f/,�� 8f%/,� B�� , ��

��&/:b� Th�/G+;6A�! u�Le� #B;B,� N�[ �w0 =� f&��, , ��f&/:� SA�½���� Í &�e� u�Le� m0 , �&� �6�.%, &�e� m0 u�Le� ��&/:�� , f: f!

()!ª3 u: 8&�<9�� >59<5,� �! %G,� ���D �� N0 , ()2f! O�2,� AB)�� B�� ,

�f$[.J NBf%2+� >f); Of[ �� �;�B,� S:� N�.+ ()� , �f[z,� 4f/: Ë2�a,� �A�$/!b� ,��&/:b� >$?�� �� �&� �e3 �2&f9 �7� .[w �� Y�f&I0 Í U�E� N� �5�,�– #B;B,� �;�� Ë2%+ –>&D�� Zs �, >&��� b ��F , b �fD��

#B;B,� 1B;� �)�h�+ >&��� �, NBVJ N� rC+ , f! NBV+ N� ªB§ b �DE >f&��� ��f2� �, NBVJ 4/: �&[.J �)&� Ë/,� >5C,� , >f&��e� lf�J NBfVJ�

#B;B,� >$;�� ,Zfs 4f2%� >f&��e� l�/, NBV&� �f)/�&�: , 4f2%e� lf,w� #B;B,� 1B;� , >&�t�, 86A�! �D�[ B, #B;B,�� >&D�� NE� , �Bf�� <f�

�­�af, >f&��e� #Bf;B,� Thf�+ N� ��0 , �A�f� �f� ��f, �� , U�f_ U�E�� #B;B,� O$c #B;� >&�t�, NBV+ N� ���h�/9b , ��f&/:�7 �f2! \f%e� Bf��

n� o$�:�S&� HV�:3 +�2 R. /��-&� m�n�&� yNM: /K $��z� E

�Z�� :}�n�X#& C�5��-V&� : WOQ E G&� $�%� /K)" �� ¦" G�-.) " �� �" $I�h�&�) 1�)�&�) C��g&� m�n�&� ~ ,�/c&�? "#-&� ~) E�&� /D%: $5�s5&�) a.�9&� m�n"$��� " ,HV�K�. H��-? �K) ,��&�N�) :" �/c&� $��� �.) "aDU4� �m�n) �. ���-� ,HV�K�. �K) E ��2)" �� " �� aD-V%� �

�N0 3��kz� ~ ,'�v%&� �)m E�Z�� :/?�3�5#& �)�M&� t�VU : W��E

Page 70: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

t)&�[ , ��.%e�� �A�%,� , m0 .f�g� , U�f_ Bf�� ,�f+��=� ���h�/f9b O]��� O&C� ,U�_ B��3 Î�|,�� – >f&�t�, #B;B,�� >&D�� ��.! B�� >�!� �A�� ��,–�+� =� U�_ ,�);�&/:�� >&��e� N�V�0 ���h�/9b3

U�E� �2&9 �7� 2%�– #Bf;B,� �f;�� – �f, >f&��� b , Y�f&��e� Y��w� �2� #B;B,� �)&�! ~&5+, #B;B,� #.µ B)� , .?�f9� Tf%,� ��f9 ¶Qf7

�2! -�]�E� , T%,� ��9 ¶Q7 #B;B,� #.µ �;�B,� NB[ 42%� P&,� �&� �z�e� u�Le� #B;B,� �D� �2! -�]�E� .?�9� , #Bf;B,� 42%� ! O7

�&[z,� S#�+ª T! ¶° X� 3 #Bf;B,� Bf� �;�B,� N� �2&9 �7� �7 Ë2%+� , #B;B,� N� 42%� ![z�� �DB[ Ë2%+ <� �&[z,�� #B&�,� �! #.; N0�=� , ·�� #B;� B� O7 ,Úd� :�����F3

#Bf&�,� �f! #.Fe� #B;B,� B� �;�B,� NB[ &5J Ë/,�� �2&9 �7� SA�$! "a� u:�B�,�� , uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �fDB[ Th�/GJ Ë/,�� , Of[ #Bf;� Í �A�Gf,�

"#�.�� �� #B;B� , ·BC² #B;B7 &�e� Zs� , Sf:� ��ae Th�/Ge��#B;B,�3 Sf:B7 .��f� r+�fJ �f&� �fV+ ¢ N0� AB[afe� >59<5,� ��A�

n� o�Z�� : ��5c&�–C��L&z� :WO��−O����^V? E

�Z��) :V&�) C�3�fz� C�L���–C��L&z� "%I : W�Pu�K�-? �.) , W����K�-? �.) ,d�X�&� : W O��K�-? �.) ,$D9M&� ���� ]�f :�OW ���−��� , t�VU RD� C�g2��D&� t�VU"

t�-&� ��� �x�3A" :W�OQ−��� ,W��� ,W�u� ,$#��5&� $���D&� aKA ��3T : W�� ,C�m�n�D&� ªm��D? 8N#D&� $���D&� $���%&� t�VU:W � −�P ,/?�3�5#& "9M&� W�^0 :

WPu�K�-? �.) ,$�I�cD&� +2��D&� :��W � ��K�-? �.) ,$�L&z� �`�M^&� : Wu� ,1s9&� "#� ~ �I��D&� :W�u−�Q ,d��kS&� :W� P�K�-? �.) E�p�ND&� ]�f :��W ��E

Page 71: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

#B;B,� , �7 UB�,� m0 Ö5+ �D� b0 ,��h�/G+�3 "#Bf;�� �;�B,� >�&�: Í 8&�<9�� >59<5,� »&� ��A �a� N�[ �w0� ,

Ï.! �7� >&�BC,� »&�, Nx� , ��+� , �aI 1A��� T<[ ,Ë2!� �;�B,� NB[ u�Le� #B;B,� B� , �DE .[a,�7 Ï.! �7� �CC� tD0�– Tf�J t[ – fc

U�;� ��ae� �a� N�&7 Í U�] , #A� �&,0� A] �2�� , �f/�&�: f; c�± � >&�F/,� T�� ,�,Bc 1�$,� �a� Í SZ)�,� �J�A�$! ��: " �e m�%J � N� (�!�

�, �V+ ¢ #B;B,� u�L� �, N�[ &&�J �� XD�� &&�J , �)�[ Y�&&�/,� �, O7 , f&&�/,� u�L� B)� , f&&�J N�# f&&�J �f&�! (fVy b , >$GfD 4f2%� ()��f�

�&,0 �<R��"��F 3 U�c�: " SAB] O[ Í �&�v B� �<R�� Ð � � , �V¬ (V: O[ �,B$c� , �&: ��

#B;B,� 8! �D0"� F , #Bf;B,� B� �;�B,� >�&�: N� 42%7, #Bf;B,� �� u�Le�3U�c� :u�Le� &�+ �&[33 ,"&&�J #B;B,� Í `¿ ��"3�OF3

� N�[ �w0� , m�%J , Ï.! �7� 2! , u�Le� #B;B,� B� , Í "#B;� �A�G,� #B;B� O[ , ·BCf² fj7 "f: af�2&: O&j/Gf&� , >f+#B;� >Cfj7� >&Cd� ,t�! �7 >R�:�� O&j/GJ t[= 3

U�c :"�%,� SZ: Y�Zf�� (f�!� ËI�� 1�2�� Í -A , �f! �A�f� �fDE&&�/,�� ���3

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW �� E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW �QE

n  o� C�2�V5&�$�9D& :��W O�uE

Page 72: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�fff� fff! �fff$�,� �fffc.5J

&Cff+ �ff� Ä�ff� �Aff+ tff���F U�c� ,��+�: " "y ¢ tD0 × K � , �7 -A�%,� "A�+ ¢�Ð � K , ABCf,� Xf&' "�.f+ �DE ,

`.�� SAB] �/6A�! SABC7 ": t)�± � , �� �&�! T.dD�� , �fj2+ (�� .�E� �, , >2?�V,� ABC,�7 �/R�:0 T%, , �, >2?�V,� Zs� ,tf�! �7 �y (��= , U�c t[: Ût�! �7 NBL&y b�Ü� FnOo3

�;�B,� >�&�j7 >��%/e� ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� »&�,� ·BCD ~%7 "a� , fc� �D� m0 >:�¤ ��a+ �D� N�7 , m�%J , u�Le� #B;B,� ,"�fj7 l,w [�� ,

m�%J , ¢�%,� AB] Í , �&,�µ� �J�2&%J Ë� Ë/,�� , Zs "#�.�� >c,� �;� !� >&��2/e� ,b�µ �+ b t7= �+�A Í ##z,� �� l��, , Tª<7 "a�� #.µ 4/: �� �$�a� , �&� ³&�$,� r+�/,� �a� %7 , >5f9<5,� »&f� �f! �/��D �� -<d7

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W ��� ,a`�I H& ��-� � ���&�) , t�VU ~ ���Ub R?� i�-D&� H�%� �I)

}��^�&� ¥��k G&� J&�^&� ��#X&� , R. 8��I 8KS. �K) $�f��_&� 8KS. H�&� 8%�� =S&�)$�.�_&� 8KS. ,��^. R? r3�M&� H#`�I a�I) ,/#K�n an3 ,8#U "�� �K a�I) E�) ���&� e)�

�5#?" C�h�9: ") " �gU �N& " �5& '�? " �I�5: " ,)"¥��k " '�? "¥��k " E ~ ���&� �Z�� :=�x&� |�3�: :��W O�O ,�`�%&� agD&� :��W ��u ,J&�^&� ��#X&� :�O

W Q� ,��ZV%. R0 aU ~ ��xV%D&� :��W �O , W R�9&�%&� �3��.�P� ,"U4� �Kb :�OW � E � R?� m��.)�3�-&� e�& �LD2�(:) $�m�n�&� 3�^&� �h�9: �A ���&� R. /?� , �L�K��: 1�� 8�%?

$cK�&�) d��M&� Hh3�: , 3�^&� ~ H:���-: /K /V&� H:��#X: �2 R� �(X-& H&z� �2 G#� 3�VN� s0$�K��VD&� ��; $�m�n�&� ,d3�p ~ ��2 �D#90� � ,$p�^_. 3�p )A ,�M&� H�#� 1�_�� , m�XV?

) 3�^&�'�(� �) '�b �D�0 C�^�.) 8&��I ~ �K�h�9:E

n� oH� d3�� , $�l����E

n  o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�O W O�� E�Z��) :C�2�V5&� :��W ��O ,"9M&� W�^0 :W�u−�QE

Page 73: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

8&�<9�� , �2&9 �7� ,¢ �Dx� u�Le� #B;B,� m�%J �DBV7 ¥�+ , ¥¤ O7 ·�M� #B;B,� �DBV7 , m�%J �DBV7 UB�,� m0 ������ l,w Tªb N�V, N0�

u�Le� #B;B,�3 %Gf,� .[w �, , �f2! Of�2,� Tf�J tf[ , >�BCf/e�� >5Gf�5/e� lf�,�� N�

�fDB[ Í (q�A Y�$@� ()V�G�� 8&�<9�� >59<5,� �)2� �� ��#�5/9� , m�%J , u�Le� #B;B,� , rf6�� SABCf7 S#�5/9b� "a� m0 %G,� A��� c�

]��e� �/� Í ,U�c �&:: "%' N0 (@ =� N� �B�BJ >�BC/e�� >5G�5/e� �� u�Le� X� ·�M� #B;B,� Í , ��+� , ��&/:b�� �[z,� >$?��"��F �,B�� "

�+�=� "8&�<f9�� >59<5,� ��A ! �L! B� , �2&f9 �f7�� �A�f5,�[ , #Bf;�� >f&��� �f;�B,� >f�&�: NBfVJ N� O&j/Gf+ �Dp7 8�?��,� , Xf� ��

#B;B,� , ��&/:b�� �[z,� ���h�/9b ,<�! B,�= , .� t[3 %G,�� , �f�A m�%J � , lf�,�� ��A f! >�BCf/e�� >5G�5/e� �b*� ��A �L! , 8f7�

�a� ()V�G� �� ��#�5/9� (k� �DB[ Í ()$�a� .+.�J Í , m�f%J , #Bf;B,� u�Le� ,hf&/e� �j$,� ·�M� #B;B,� P&,� ,�B,�f��: Xf2/+ , ��f+� , N�

�;�B,� NBV+ , m�%J ,#B;�=�]�� =� , >5f9<5,� O&,# P5D ()��d/9�7 , �;�B,� >R�G7 Í , �f;�&/:�� �f$[.J ��2/��� ,�B,�f��: N�f[ Bf, , m�f%J ,

#B;�=�]�� =� T�f%,� uf�Le� #Bf;B,�� ·�M� #B;B,� �� �$[.J Th�/9b ,<�! B,�= , u�Le� X� ·�M� "#B;� a�� �w0 t&� �a� , �fJ�w m0 .f�D �w0 �� m�%J , >&|&�� "a� �� , T�%,� u�Le� #B;B,� m0 �;�&/:� Th�/9b� , �w0 t&�

f6A�! u�Le� #B;B,� \/!�=� ·�fM� "#Bf;B, ,/:� SA�½ m0 f&�e� ��f&

n� o�p�ND&� ]�f RD� �p�ND&� :��W �OE

Page 74: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

u�Le� ,#B;� O[ X5JAb u�Le� X5JA� B, �D� SA�½�±3 #Bf;B,� Bf� �f;�B,� N�.f+ ()� �a, , �f�� , ¶Qf7 uf�Le� #Bf;B,� ��

�<R�� ,ª�z:�=� uf�Le�� ·�fM� #B;B,� �� �$[.J �� ,ª�zf:��=� �f� u�Le� #B;B,� m0 �;�&/:�3

<9�� >59<5,� N� r&j] UB�D �jD�#B;� �;�B,� NB[ �B:¤ 8&�=� ]��=� , �f&� �z�fe� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �fDB[ �B5D (k� r&j]� , .f� tf[ ,

>+A�$/!b� Y�&�V,� �� u�Le� #B;B,� N0 �B,�c (k� r&j]� , u�� b Ë/,�N�&!E� Í �I��F , Tª�Bf�,� �f� T�f%,� u�Le� #B;B,� N0 �B,�c (k� r&j]�

M� #B;B�, >&;A�M� ·� ,<f��# P&,�= �f/&��� Í ,f�B�� b�=� �fI , <f� �&,0 .�/5+ , PV%,� ! .�E� O7 , #Bf;B,� m0 uf�Le� #Bf;B,� A��/�� B��·�M�� F , ·�fM� #Bf;B,� uf�j/7 b0 �f, ABf)� b� T�%�, u�� b w0 ,

�;�B,� NBV7 8�?��,� ��A �� (��.7 c %G,� N� r&j]�± � , m�f%J , Bf�,� u�Le� #B;B , m0 Öf5e� ()$�af� m0 �2,� �&;BJ X2+ b ��[ �a� N� b0

��ae� l,w3 �J�w NB[ ��2/��7 UB�,� m0 NB&�<9�� >59<5,� ��w �, , m�f%J , >f&���

#B;�� , �J�w Í >&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+ª ��2/�� 42%7 , m�%J , �f/�&�: Of7 "#B;� Ë� �/&���� ,� 42%� ! -�f,� �j$,� #B;B,� �D , ()�$f9 fc�

�.%�E� �G�� B7� T���� UB�,� �a� O|� m0 , #Bf;B,� NBf[ Xf2� �f&:

n� o�Z�� :�5c&� :C��L&z� :��W �QP�K�-? �.) E

n� o�Z�� :�p�ND&� ]�f :��W ��−� ,C�L���V&�) C�3�fz� :o?��&�) +&�g&� ��D%N&� :W��� ,W���/��x&� C�N�#-: o. , t�VU RD� C�jg2��D&� t�jVU" t�-&� ��� �x�3A " :�OQ−��� ,W��� ,W�u�E

Page 75: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف

− ��� −

�B)5�=�[z�� =� �Ve�� �;�B,� 87 , Ëf� �f/&���� �/�&�: #B;B� O[ O7 �7 ¦/de� �#B;B,� �2&%J , Y��af,� ! ?�h7 P&, #B;B,� N� `.+ B)� ,

�ff;�B,� Í b ,e� Í b� Y�ff2V , O?bff7 �ff)&�! �/ff:�� , U/ff9� ffc �;�B,� Í �!�2/�� Í �)�|7 >59<5,� , O?b,� ~%7 �)&�! ��#�ª� , �fV,

<�� >&,�� m0 4c.J b O?b# �k� `.+ �)&� .��2,�= >&D��\,� �! , Í �fk��>&7�LM�7 NBVJ �� �$�� Y�9�&c �� �$[A >�&���3

>,pGe� "a� N� u���– �f�! �f� >f&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+ª >,pG� Ë2!�– >V?�� , T<cE�� T�cE� Ybh� �� Ë�� , T�f��E�� T�)�E� Y<��� ,

�ª�.,� T���� O|� ! �G$/,� �, 4/: , �f)&� A�j� , S#�f+h7 UBf�+ SA�f/� �Ve�� �;�B,� Í >&��e� ! #B;B,� ,[z�f� #Bf;B,� NB[�=�f+B2%� =� ,

SA�J� �)&� >59<5,� ��A �2+ , �.%f�E� �G�� � ��A `.��� , SA�fJ�.?�: ��+=� , �+�A �$+ b ,u�� �;� �, m�%J � ��V+ N� P/�+��F3

� �] ��<� ^>? ��95� VM& Z _!>� 6>"S 7�� F:− b�S� º�;��: �.%�E� �G�� Ï� »&�,� ��A , �f� ��f$,� 8Gf�� Ï��

h/%e� >, , t)!�$J�� , � #B;� N� N�.+ (�� , m�%J , Bf� �V¬ O[ #B;�� �/�&�:� �J�w 8! , Y�af,� f! f?�ª �f]B7 P&,� , Ô�w TBf�� b� , ��

Y�&�t�, Tªb �A�! , �f;�B,� f! Xc�� #B;B,� ¸5, N� N�+.+ �a7 ���

n� o�Z�� :$�.s9&� ���3T) =b��&� R��&� �_0 : W���−��OE

n� o�Z�� :$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :��W Q�− Q� ,�cD&� +2��D&�$�I :��W � �−� � , R�-?34�R��&� '�pA ~ :W���−��� ,$�L&z� �`�M^&� :W�u ,�I��D&� : W�u−�Q , ]�f

�p�ND&� :��W ���K�-? �.) ,R�K��&� 1A G#� /I���&� $�f�2 :W��−�P E )(-&� ": �I)R��.s�z� $5�s5&� 8VU G&� y�� �D�0E

Page 76: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Ë�5�,� ��z�b� u+.L7 �Ve�� ,�B2%e� P&,���F3 d�� º�;��Ã�: >59<5,� ��A , �2&9 �7�� Ï�A�5,�[ , �z�f� #B;B,� N� B��

�fVe�� �f;�B,� Í �B2%� , l&V�f/,� uf+.L7 �f)&�! U�f�+� , Í �f2V, Y�a,� ! ?�ª Zs �;�B,� , Y�a�, TB�� B� <� , Tªb �A�! B� b� ,

S#B;B� >&��� �! SA�$! Y�a,� NBVJ �&j7 , #B;B,� X� >&��� �� ,l,w� %�#=� �J�w Í �[z,� T�h�, , �2�w B,� , #Bf;B,� �;�B� , (�f2! , �&Gf7

42%e� �aH , #.Fe� #B;B,� (�2! B)� , �j$,�� , b ¶Q7� , �A�%,� �� �&[.J O[ �! ,()2! O�2,� T�J t[3 \��d�� º�;���: 8�V/e� �� >&�! >5?�R ��A , S.!�f�E� �.�p/� ()2� , N� N�.+ �&: �fVe�� �f;�B,� Í �B2%� �z�� #B;B,� , UBf�� Bf�� *R�B/,�7 �)&�! , �D� t[ , (�2! ,�Ve�� �;�B,� Í >&��e� ! ?�ª 3

>,pGe� "a� Í 8&�e� ��Ai "a� , Of[ �fF:� Of?b# �.%/f9� �$�w B,� u+.� , Y�6�z!�� �!�L� �� B�Æ b �k� �D;B, , �� >f6A�%� �f�0 Ëf)�

>6B�2�3 u+.� O[ `, S! B� �� �.!� -B9� , �f� �f&�! �f� #A��� Y�6A�%�� �B�D , �!�L�� , �)f6Bs `� .)�&, , .f)�&,� ,�f+�=� ,

>&I�� Y�a,� �! �+�� Í >59<5,�� 8�V/e� ��VJ `� , �;�� �! #B;B,� , �&s B� �a,�� , �fJ�w �f2[ ��A#0 �! u?<M� hF%J , U�fc tf[�

u�M� &9; _ �D&9 ,(�9� �&�! � ] :" �� Of[ Í ��.V5J , b�

n� o��:A =�-f4� R%M&� /?A R� =A�&� �SK aN���-? R. H� ,=b��&�U ,/X�z�) ,}�b�V5V&�) ,

"K��;) ,y?�%&� ¡.�L&� on��. ~ "L�� aN�&� 1�N: �DUE

Page 77: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

� Í ��.V5J"��F 3 −b�S� k!;E�� ��L� ;(�� Pp M!U , 8f! #Bf;B,� NBf[ m0 �f�w �� (��

�fVe�� �;�B,� Í >&��e� , f! Ëf�5�,� ��zf�b� uf+.L7 UBf�� �fD��Y�#B;Be� :

�−�/Gf+ >f&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+ª N� Zfs Ëf� �f&: �f� >f&��e� NBf[ ThS#B;B� , >��%� �� , #B;B,�f7 T�f%e� -�CJ� �&�! Th�&� , f%7 lf,w�

>&��e� m0 #B;B,� Tt�D� ,%� S#B;B� >��%� >&��e� NBV/�=�3 >f[�[.,�� �%�,� >+�s Í �D� `.+ O&,,� �a� Í .��2,�� , Ë/�f�� f:p�

>�G� Zs }�&�,� ,� NB[ �B!# B�� >��%� >&��e , u?�f��� Y�f&��� w0 Tff! b� #Bff;B7 �ff]BJ b Y�ff&��� Ëff� �ff&: �ff� , ABff�E� .?�Gff[

>+A�$/!b� , >&�V,�[ , >&6.%,�� , >&Gf2��� , >f&!B2,�� , Tf%,�7 �)5f]B� >$s��� �)&,0 #B;B,� Tt�D� �.� ! ~c�2/,� Th�&, , Í �f� N� uf�� Of7

"#B;�� ��,� >&��� �A�M� 30 (@ Y�5Cf,� >f&�$7 ·Bf�2� O&,f,� �af� N ��.!E�� , S�f&�� >5Cf[ , SAf�,� , S#�A��� , N�Bf,E�� , U�Vf�E�� , T�F:E�� , l,w Zs� , O&,,� Í .[w �� �)&�! #.+ �kx� ,<|f� U�f�&�=: Bf,

Bf� �f&: �� Ë�� Y�w NB[ Th�, Ë�� >&��� ! S?�ª S�&�� >5] �D�[5] Tt�D� Zs �� B� Ë: Zs �&� �&,0 S�&�� > , S�f&�� �f&,0 ��fD� �wx�

n� o�Z�� :$�%M&� �p�ND&� :��W �PQ d�N&�? H�#� "92) HI��) H��5&A �&vD&� m3)A �I)

������A {�DXD? ,J�Mp ���-. �A) E}�#X-&� '�I �SU) E�Z�� :�5_&� �cU :��W O�� EZ��)� :���N&� q�0 :�OW � − ��E

n� o~ H&�2 C�cI��D&�) y��5&� �SK $&mA �Z�� :$�L&z� �`�M^&� :Wu� ,�I��D&� :W�u , ]�f�I��D&� :� W � ��K�-? �.) ,�p�ND&� ]�f :��W ��E

Page 78: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

S�&��7 Ëj7 P&, �a,� �&e� -�CJ� �&�! Th, , Y�af,� l�J NBVJ N� Th�&�%� >&j7 �G&,� >&:=� , .��f� ~c�f2J Bf��3 .?�f9 Í ~�2f,� #.f+ �f�|�� ��.!E�� Y�5C,� ,�Ve� �� �;�B,� Í ��B93

1−.+��� #B;B,� N�[ B, =�>&�t�, �7 >5C/� >&��e� �D�[ , >f&��e� -�CJ�� ��#B;B7 ¶�Q� ��Z�7 , Y�5Cf,�7 �5CfJ� �fe S#Bf;B� �fVJ ¢ Bf, w0

>&JB$|,� , #B;B,� Y�5C,� "a� ��� , a�2&: Th�&�Ò , #B;� >&�t�, NBV+ N� ��#B;� O$c ,#Bf;B� ��,� NB[ Th�+ t[=� 8J.f� , OfR�7 Bf�� , �fDBV,

<&C�= O]�j�, ,t[ Th�+ , ��+� , �G5D ! #B;Be� T�J , NBf[ A�f$/!�7 �I u:<,� #B;B,� 8! >&�t�, u7�G,� #B;B,� , OG�G/,� Th�+ t[ , ��f+� ,

Y�#B;B,� Í ,.+��� >&�t�, u7�G,� #B;B,� N�[ B, t&�=� uf:<,� #B;B�, ,U��+ Np7:V, >&��e�7 >?�c >5] >&�t�, u7�G,� #B;B,� N�[ B, T�&c O$c �I N�

.�i #B;� �H #B;B,� �a� , #Bf;B,� Í O&c �� .�g� #B;B,� �a� Í U��+� u7�G,� , �, >+�k b �� m0 Y�#B;B,� OG�G/J �aV�� , �af� ��f2/�� TB�%��

UB�%,� >��$7 ,%��=� >&��e� 8! #B;B,� NB[ �.� �� 7b OG�G/,� �aI ,6A�! b=� �I ,h, tD0 �DE�I >6A�! �kB[ Y�#B;B,� Í OG�G/,� T3

O&,,� �a�� , ��+� , �%�,� >+�s Í , >f&��e� 8f7 uf+.5/,� ! 42/$� �DE �A�M� Í #B;B,�� , Í SA.f�/e� >Cfd�/e� u?���� �� >&��e� NB[ A�$/!��

�A�M� , >+A�$/!b� AB�E� �� �k� u��� , >f&��%,� YbBje� ��� ,¢ tf� �I #B;� <� #B;B,� �)&,0 (�2+3 �fD� O&,f,� �af� ! �7 �z%+ �¬ N0 (@

#Bf;B�, �fIB$c rC&, ��#B;� O$c S#B;B� >&��e� NB[ �.� ! 42/$� ,.��� ~c�2J �&��; Tt�fD� m0 �f);�&/:� Xf2/�� >f&��e� #B;� �.� X� w0

��#B;� A.�/&, .�i #B;� ,0 (�f2&, .f�i #Bf;� m0 >f;�: <� #Bf;� m

Page 79: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

��#B;� %7 >&��e� ,O]�j�, O&C� B� w03 NBf[ �fJ�$@0 #�.e� N� TB�%�� #B;B,� 8! >&��e� , S#B;B� �kB[ b , Of�/2+ S#Bf;B� �fkB[ �.f� X�

S#B;Be� >&��e� "a� m0 T<V,� ,b�� �f)/&��� 8f! �f�#B;� O�= #Bf%&� ? U�*G,�3

;.�� �:A��� �c�Be� �:�] 1�;� c� `Bf!# Npf7 O&,,� �a� �! Î� "#B;� m0 ��,�7 �)��&c Í >&JB$|,� >5C,� A��/�� SA�½– lf,w #B;� ��

��,�– >+#B;� >&JB$@ >5] O[ Í NBV+ tD0 �a� Np7 >&6��,� >q$,� �%�J #B;B,� Zs , �Cf/� Bf� tf7 b0 �I T�&c b Y�5C,� �� ��Zs N� SA�½ #B;B,�7 ,#B;B,� t2&7 #B;B,� 8! B� "A.�J� �DB[ Í , #B;� m0 .�/5+ <�

�7 TB�&, �&�! T�/� ,#Bf;B� ��,� NB[ Th�, b0�=� 8J.f� , Tf�J Thf�,� �G5D ! ��,� , Th�,� , ��+� , �f, >+�k b �� m0 Y�#B;B,� Í OG�G/,� ,

Tf�J �f� f! O&,f,� �afH NB,/Ge� �6.� �� ! ,,� Tª�Bf�,� lf�/� Ëf/?�ª #B;B,� NB[ �.� ! ��B6.�=��a� ()�&,# ! >�ªb >&��e� ! 3

f;−?�ª #B;B,� N�[ B, =� .�i #B;� �, N�V, >&��e� ! , ���CfJ� ��f2/�b T%,�7 , #Bf;B,� #Bf;� m0 T<fV,� Of�2+ af�2&:�Ò , OGf�GJ �f&�! Thf�&�

4��2/+ b t&� Y�#B;B,�3 �� SABC7 O&,,� ´�C+ t7A� `. ,U��&�:?�ª #B;B,� N�[ B, =� >f&��e� f!

#B;B� N�V,=�[A��� =� #B;B,� Í Y�#B;B�, ,5,�²�=� >&��e� Í �I , �7 ��� ª�f&/�b� �7 �� Zs ��z�b� , #Bf;� #Bf;B�, NBfV+ N� Thf�&� , �afV�� ,

OG�G/&�3 �%�f,� >f+�s Í ��7�G[ O&,,� �a�� , Bf�� , ��f+� ,.f� f! 4f2/$� �

#.µ #B;� B� �&: �� #B;B,� ¦d�J=� u?���� Y�&��� �! , N� uf���

Page 80: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

A.�J b Ë/,� >&��%,� YbBje� �� ~_ �A�$/!� .�� B� �&: �� #B;B,� >+#B;B,� �)CCj7 b0 �A�M� Í �I , �f­�&���� ��&�E� u?��: Ë� Ë/,� ,

�A�fM� Í #Bf;B� OCf: #Bf;B,� >5] �)2� �� m0 (�D� �wx� �Cf/� #B;B,�7 , U��+ <� , #B;� �, NBV+ N� �2� Th�+ �Dp7 #B;B,� �a� �! a�2&:Ò

, #B;B,� �DE , �A�M� Í #B;B,� �a� A.�J c� , #Bf;B,� #B;� N� 42%7 #B;B,� �2&%7 B� ,OG�G/&, �&�! ?�ª �]B7 P&,� 3 ufj�+ �f]� OV�

�&�! ?�ª B)� "Zs , �G52, B� �]B,� �a� YB$@ �V,, f?�ª .f�E P&f, �&�! , >6A�! >�&�: O[ Í O&,,� �a� `.� b0� , Tf�,�[ , ¾�f��� ,

N�V���� , l,w Zs� ,<|� U��&�= N�V���7 �C/� �D� �Ve� Í , b �V, N�V�0 N�V�� N� U��+ , N�fV�0 �fD�V�0 N�fV��� , OGf�G/,� Thf�, b0� ,

"Zfs� ¾�f��� T�,� Í U��+ ��|�� ,f� �f)&� U�f�+ #Bf;B,� Í U�f�+ t , X�,�7 X�,�� , >f6A�%,� u?���� "a� OG�G/7 O?�c b� , Í U�f�+ �f)�|��

#B;B,�3 Ëf� >f&��e� NBf[ �f� uf+.5,� �af� �&,0 ��w t7 �B�2� O&,,� �a� N0 (@

�)&�! ?�ª �]B7 b #B;B,� ,U��&�: N�# >f&��e� �A�fM� Í A.f�/e� Of� #B;B,� ,B,� T� >&��e� N�# #B; ,~�2,� Th�+ 86.5,� <[ !�; f! ���

#B;B,� N�# >&��e� �A�M� Í u�j/e� NB[ �.� , Th�/G+ �DBV, OR�7 B)� >&��e� -�CJ� T! U�E� ;8�R�7 �+.��– Y�a,� – #B;B,�7 , O&L%J B��

��#B;B, , �;�B,� Í S:<e� b0 �7 O?�c b� ,� Í >&?�LG�BG,�� u?�f�� �)�[ ,�Ve�� �)2� �;�B,�3Î�|,� : tfD0 >f&��e� l�J N� ~�2,� Í U��+ N�

�)&�! S?�ª >&��e YA.�J , YA.�J tD0 l�J� , ��+� , Sf?�ª �H >?�c >&��e �)&�! , OG�G/,� Th�&� �aV�� , OR�7 B�� , Y�#Bf;B,� Í OGf�G/,� �aV�

Page 81: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

OR�73 � Í u�j/e� NB[ �.� ! ���� Í �.fF&� >f&��e� N�# #Bf;B,� B� �A�M ()�&,# Í "B6.� �� #B;B,� �a� ,f?�ª #Bf;B,� N�[ B, t&�=� >f&��e� f! ,

U��&�: �fV+ ¢ Nx� ? b T� .�i #B;� �, O� �A�M� Í u�j/e� #B;B,� �a� ?�ª �DBV7 NB�?��,� �&,0 ��w �� 8! B)� .�i #B;� �,=� Y�af,� f! , N��±

B;B,� 4f/: ?�ª #B;B, b �G5D B� #B;B7 #B;B� Y�a,� ! �J#�+ª X� #OG�G/,� �&� �.5+3

OG�G/&� �&� T<V,� �.F&� .�i #B;� �, N�[ N0� ,T�J t[ OR�7 B�� 3 u+.5,� �a� O?b# .)�� "a� , �fF�� m0 4fc.J b �fk�� �)5%f6 N�f7 c�

>&2&�&,� >&D��\,� , ��afe� �af� Tª�Bf, N0 O7– Ï� �f! �fJB$@ �.f� f! �.%�E� �G�� , ��$,� 8G�� Ï��– #�Gf5,� >+�s Í , �f� m0 >��f6x�

uf+.5,� �af� >f,#� UBf: NBf%R� Y�6�z!�� Y��c�2�� #�#A �� T�J , #B;B,� TB)5� NB[ (��B!# ��ae� �a� m0 �F/+ �D (�!� NBV+ N� �V+

b Ëff�5�,� ��zff�b� uff+.L7 "#�.ff�� ff! UBff���Bff2%e���F3 �ff�w ffc�

n� o/Z5#&� ��cD&� :G�-D&� m�-V�) �5#&� �MV� �A �K , �5#U" R�-&� " d�� ��-. G#� y#x� H��0 B�V.$��� ,d�p��&� R�-&�U ,$�3�X&�) ,r���X&�) ,�Dc&� W�I) ,�&7 ��;) , �5#U)" ��N&� "

�DK R�����V. R���-. G#� y#x� H��0" �Lx&� ") " q�M&� " E 1�L5D0" d�p��&� " ��; " $�3�X&� " ��;)" r���X&� ") " �Dc&� W�I " 1�L5.) " �Lx&� " ��; "q�M&� " ��cD&� �.A)

L0 =��-D&�$:)�5V. y`�N2 ~ G�-D&�) �5#&� �MV� �A � , �5#U" ��%�z� " G#� '�N. H��0 " ��b " )" )�D� "EEEEEEE1�L5D&�) G�-D&� �5�? |&� , ~ /V&� $���%�z� 1�L5. �A G�-D?" ��b " /V&� /K ~" )�D� " ~) " �9? "EEEEEE|&� E ��9� �I =��-D&� ��cD&�)" �����V. <". ��U �K) �)m �m��0A ~ $��%&�? yNMV. �5#&� 1�L5

C)�5: , 1�L5. yNMVU"$���%�z� "�m��0A ~ ,1�N: �DU E

Page 82: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين

− ��� −

[z�� �DB[ m0 S.!��E�� >,h/%e� �� 8�V/e� Z��'� >59<5,�=�+B2%� =� , ~f%7 Í >f&,�E� >+A�Àf,� �+��f�,� �� �ª�.,� T���� ��%+ N� #�[ 4/:

�$/[��F , [z�� #B;B,� NB[ A�VD0 ! Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� N0 O7=�f+B2%� =� 8f7 >5,�²� S.7�V� "#�.��Of�%,� >q$, � F 3 U�f�+ #Bf;B,� NBf[ f! O&,f,��

m0 ���Gf�D�7 >&f6��,� SA�Àf,� Y�#Bf;Be� 8f7 �B2%e� ��z�b� u+.L7 ·�d�E�� ��BDE� , �f;�B,� #B;B,�[ , �fVe� #Bf;B,�� , (+f�,�� ,

¾#���� , .�B��� , �.%,�� , ·�d�E� #B;�� , Ö�+ (&G�/,� �a��� �z�� #AB� #B;B7 ·�d�E�� ��BDE� "a� 87 �& , #Bf;B,� Bf�� b� ,

N�&!E� Í NBV,� B� �a,�3 Ë�5�,� ��z�b� u+.L7 �)&�! U��+ �D� Ac B,� Ð K �z�e� 42%e� �a� N�[ �e , N�&!E� Í NBV,� B�� b� ,f��j/�=� �f)&� , Of7

#B;B,� 42%7 u�j/e� NBV+ , N�&!E� Í NBV,� B�� ,#.�=�:�� =� , >f&�7� 42%e� �aI S.+��� `.�� AB�p7 >��j/� u?����� Y�&��e� ,a�2&: NBVJ <� ,

=��-D&� ��cD&� ��9� �I)" �99c. <"�m��0A ~ yNMV. �K +�2 R. �j5#&� 1�L5. ��U �K) ,

�L�0 C)�5V� R9& , 1�L5. yNMVU" @���&� "�m��0A ~ ," �#g&� @���U ") "�&� @��? �3") " ��DN&� @��?" " ��-&� @��?) " ,�-�Dn �L�0 yNM: ��) @���&� 1�L5.) G�-. ��0< , �SK �A ��

�-Y&�) d�c&� 8%M? �L�0 C)�5V. @���&� �K =S&� 1�L5D&� ,$��kl�) $�&)4�) , $��&)4�)�L.��) EH�0 ����&� �9cV& �99c. �9cD&� /D� �D��)< ,R. H�� G�-D&� ap4 �Z� �� H��0 a��I v���V&� ,/Z5#&� ��cD&� a��I R. H�A R� �L�0 G�-D&� C)�5: G&� �Z� ��) E

�Z�� :"#%&� }�-. R. "L�D&� ]�Y�� : Wu ,"#%&� G#� =�Yk4� ]�f :W � , $�f�2"#%&� RV. G#� =3�n��&� :WOQ−��E

n� o�Z�� :$�I�cD&� +2��D&� :��W ����K�-? �.) ,$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :��W Q� �K�-? �.) E�I��D&� �Z��) :W�� ,�I��D&� ]�f :� W � −� OE

n� o�Z�� :�p�ND&� ]�f :��W ��E

Page 83: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

S#B;B� 3 �5�,� ��z�b� u+.L7 Y�#B;Be� ! U��+ N�[ B, #B;B,� Nx� �&�!� , b

�B2%e� , �Ve�� �;�B,� Í ��B9 , NBV,�f7 �Cf/e� NBV+ N� �&�! Th�, �A�M� Í– 42%� B� �a,�� #B;B,�– �;�B,� ��0 , �Ve� �� , <[ !�

U�je� Th�+ 86.5,�; #B;B,�f7 uf�j/e� NB[ �.� ! ��� , Bf� �af,�� N�&!E� Í NBV,� , #Bf;B,� �f;�� B� , �fV¬ NBfV+ b N� Th�/Gf+ Bf)�

#B;B,� , ¢�%,� Y�#.5� B�� , �7 �C/� , ¸f5, #.fµ �f)&� #Bf;B,� w0 , b �, 42%� ,�2%� NE �A�M� Í NBV,� " , #Bf;� Y�2V�, NBV+ b N� Th�&�

, >LG59 B�� ,¢�%,� #B;B, Ë5D �DE3 8�?�f�,� ��af� >j] �2� Th�+ O7 #B;B,� S:B7 , u�j/e� #B;B,� w0– N�&!E� Í NBV,� 42%7 – #B;� B� ��� :�� #.� , #B;B,� �;�� #B;� B�� ,m�f%J �3 �.f� f! �f���

e� NB[#B;B,� �V¬ #B;B,�7 u�j/ , �2� #.� Í ���� 42%7 , Th�/Gf+ B)� #Bf;B,� 42%� P527 #B;B,� �;�� �C/+ b N� , Í NBfV,� Bf� �af,��

N�&!E� , Y�2Ve� >&�7 �C/J b N� Th�/G+ �a[�– �f)2� #.5,� l,w `B9 – #B;B,� 42%7 , #B;B,� 42%e .+��� .�� �)&� u�j/e� w0 , �.� %7 �DB[

Ëf�5�,� ��z�b� u+.L7 Y�#B;Be�� Y�&��e� ! bB��3 N� Í lf� b� � #B;B, r+¤ Ë5D �a� , m�%J ,#B;B,� �;��3

��zf�b� uf+.L7 Y�#Bf;Be� f! U�f�+ #Bf;B,� NBf[ ! O?b,� ��� Tf%,� �f�7��+ #Bf;B,� Np7 >[�: O�%,� >q7 N� �B2%e� , Tf%,� N� tfV�

�� TB)5� Y���%e� Í : , #Bf;B,� Í U�f�+ N� �;� �a[ , rCf+ 4f/:

Page 84: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Tf%,�� #B;B,� 87 O7��/,���F Y�f&��e� �fH �Cf/J t2f&: , N�f[ Bf, b0�bB�� #B;B,�= �)5f]� �f� Thf�, Ëf�5�,� ��z�b� u+.L7 Y�#B;Be� !

�f7 ��#�.�� X&' �C/+ b N� T%,�7 , �f� uf�� �f� b0 �f7 �Cf/+ b Of7�#�.�� #B;B,�7 � , N�&!E� Í NBV,� B� �a,� , NBfV,� Tf! "�2%� T%,� w0

N�&!E� Í , Y�#Bf;Be� �f! #Bf;B,� Xf�A 8f: �2� Th�&�– �)5f]� �� T%,�7– S#B;B� �k� �.� , #B;B,� �)2! X5J.+ b , .f�i 4f2%7 �fkBV,

N�&!E� Í NBV,� Zs 3 O?bf,� ��� , ��f+� , ##zf,� �.f� f! �fD� Y�f&��e� Y�&]BCf� Í Y�#B;Be�� ,− �z�f7 P&f,� >f&��e� 8! #B;B,� N� `.+ �� ��A !

�B2%�− , �)2! #B;B,� U��ª �;B+ b �)&� ##z,� �a� N� b0 , �a� X� B,� Y�&]BCM� Í ##z,� ,�B2%� �z�� �D� ! U+ �¬3 A.f�J �w0 �fD� �fD�&7 �2�h; �� �V¬ #B;� , a�2&:Ò ,7 �, O!�� r;.� #B;B , �A�M� Í NB[ �, ,

UB�%e� ! �)��J� >�%,� #B;� SA�½ ,fc<R0 l�fD <�=� "af� #Bf;B7 �$G,� �a�� >�%,� , �� >f$;�� r;.fe�� >f�%,� "a� NB[ Í �D##.J ª�B; X�

>2V¬ , �.! T� .�B; Ë� O� >2V¬ �kB[ �.� !� , �f� lf,w Zfs�CM� l�J Í ##z,� �;�� Y�&]B , >f�%7 #�f�/!b� U��ª ª�Bf; m0 >��f60

`.f�� >f�! >&]BCfd7 #�f�/!� m0 >]BC² , f! �fDB[ �f7 Thf�� f%7 >2&%� >&]BC� , `.�� >&]BC� ! �D� N�$� , #B;B7 ��&/,�� Th�� X�

>�%,� , >$;�� �kB[ Ë� >�%,� >&]BC� N� �/%+ Np[ ,>2V¬ �k� N�$�3 ��

n� o�Z�� :$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :��W Q� ,$�I�cD&� +2��D&�) :��W ��u ,�I��D&� :W�� ,

�I��D&� ]�f :� ��u −� ,W $�L&z� �`�M^&���−�uE

Page 85: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

#��/!b� �2� Z�J >�%,� >&]BCd7 , ��#B;B7 #��/!b� Z�/+ ¢� , #��/!b�� >�!�5,� >�%,� #B;B7 , �­�&]BC� �D�[ �+� , �,�: ! ��7Ò , <f7� Z�J <7

##.J� l�3 l�J 87 �B2%� �z�� #B;B,� N� ! >%R�c >,b# U+ �a�� >�!�5,� O�%,� ,[z�f� N�[ B, b0�=�f&�5, =�#Bf;B7 Thf�� uf�� �fe >f�%,�

>j;.e� ,<f]�= , >f�! #�f�/!� U��ª #.fF7 �f�#B;B7 #�f�/!b� U�hf, ��>]BC² >j;.���F3

uf+.L7 "#�.f�� f! U�f�+ #Bf;B,� NB[ `.+ �� ��A �%6 N�7 �� %7� �5�,� ��z�b� ,&�; .)� t[=� ��z�b� u+.L7 Y�#B;Be� ! UB�� �D�

�B2%e� ,� AB�E� �� NBV+ #�V+ 4/:>&q$,� >+A�À, 3 �t�%,� ~%7 U��: c�� F , .�E� �a� >��7 O;E , 1�jf]E A�af/!b�

��ae� �a� , �fH (�Ge� >&��%,� Y�A�À,� l�J T#�C+ b �&j7 �)&;BJ�± K� , u+.5,� �a� #�.� N� 8$�±– ��$,� 8G�� B7�� �.%�E� (�� , t)!�$J�� ,B;B� O[ #B;� NBV7 8�?��,� ! #B;B,� S#�+ª �.� N�# �/�&�: B� #

>�&��� "a� , >&��e� P5D (�2! #B;B,�� , Y�f&��� �A�fM� Í uf�j/e�� ��&�E� , Ë�5�,� ��z�b� u+.L7 �)&�! UB�� #B;B,��− (�#�.f� N� 8f7

�A�fM� Í #Bf;B,� Y�w� >f&��e� Y�w .+�f�J Xf2� �a� �� , .+�f�J Xf2� b8�B)5e�;� TB)5� #B;B,� TB)5�� >&��e , Of�%/,� �Gj7 ,<c�f! Nxf�= b

#B;B,� TB)5� �2&%7 B� >&��e� TB)5� N0 UB�+3 .+�f�J Í Xfc� tD0 -<M�� �A�M� Í 8J�a,� , #B;B,� Y�w� >&��e� Y�w , �.%f�E� �G�� Ï� #�.�

n� o�Z�� :$�I�cD&� +2��D&� :��W ���−��u ,�I��D&� :W��−�� ,�I��D&� ]�f :�

W��O−��P ,�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �� ,$�L&z� �`�M^&� :W��E

n� o�Z�� :�I��D&� :WP� ,�I��D&� ]�f :� W �P�−�P� ,�p�ND&� ]�f :��W ��−��E

Page 86: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�A�M� Í 8J�a,� .+��J X2� �%� ��� ,Í 8�B)5e� Í .+��/,� N�# Of�%/,� ,t/: .+��� >&��e� TB)5� w0=#B;B,� TB)5e 3 ThfFD �fjD U�f|e� O&$f9 f%�

Ë2�a,� O�%/,� �&: �� #�BG,� TB)5e #B;B,� TB)5� S.+��7 , >&�c Ë�� >&�7 , TBf)5� �f2&%7 Bf� #�BGf,� TB)5� Np7 UB�,� ! W.§ Oc�! �� ��� #B;B,� ,�<�%,� 87 �&�! u5/� .�� �a)� , �&� ��hD b� , .+��J Í ��h2,� tD0�8J�a,�;#B;B,� Y�w� >&��e� Y�w , �A�fM� Í , #Bf;B,� .+�f�+ N� 4f2%7

�A�M� Í >&��e� , `.�E� �! Sª�/¬� SA.�/� >+B� t)� OV, NBV+ �&j7 ,��h2,� Xc� �a� Ë5� 3 P5D #B;� B� �A�M� Í u�j/e� N� `.+ u+.5,� �a)�

>&��e� ,�.�� P&,=�?�ª =� �)&�! ,�H ·�M� ��#B;� �I >&��� O[�3 4f2%7 �A�fM� Í �]�e� Í ��� c #B;B,�� >&��e� N� , TBf)5e� Í �.+�f�J N0�

Ë2�a,� O�%/,� �Gj73 ABf�E� �f� #�BGf,� �&�! �] �� N� .�i 42%7� #B;B,� �&�! �] �� �2&%7 B� >&;A�M� ,�BGf,�� #B;B�, P&,� N�f/+B� #`.�E�7 ���:0 TB�J �A�M� Í N�Jh+t/�3

�f!�$J�� �.%f�E� �Gf�� Ï� ��a� u&�� Í �t�%,� ~%7 "#��� �� �a� , �)�! �� >&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+ª Í �.5,� 87 -<M� ()�%7 X;A� c�

Ë2�a,� #B;B,�7 UB�,� ! , "�5D �� , �.%f�E� �Gf�� Ïpf[ , N0 U�fc±�f��L� ¦d�f/e� #Bf;Be� ��f,� >&��� 8! Ë;A�M� Úd�,� #B;B,=� ,

��a,� Í >&��e� ! ?�ª Ë;A�M� #B;B,� N0 U�c �/$@� �����F 3 �;� �� .|[� �� .�D �&� A�a/!b�� �&;B/,� �a��;

��� ���� �A�fM� Í 8J�af,� .+�f�J Í 8f&�e� 87 ��h2,� p�2� #A N¼� Ø � ± , Y�w

n� o�Z�� :�I��D&� : WP� ,�I��D&� ]�f :� W �PP−�P�E

Page 87: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�e� >&� , #B;B,� Y�w� , >��/Gf� >f+B� t)2f� OfV, NBfV+ �f&j7 , Of� `.�E� ! #B;B,� >+B� �� ���:0 , >f&��e� >+B� �� , N� `Bf!#�

�a� Í Xc� ��h2,� , lf,w Xf2� ��A�/�� �%� ��� �.%�E� �G�� �7� N�� , >&��e� P5D #B;� �A�M� Í u�j/e� N�� , .f�D �f)&� >,pG� ,f�� <f� N� �

>&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+h7 8�?��,� , 8�V/e� AB)' (�� ,:� b� O7=� �� �<�%,� , �f� u�� tD0 �A�M� Í "#B;� u�j/e� #�BG,� #B;� NBV7 �/%+

�A�M� Í N�/��/G� N�/+B� tI 8J�w; #Bf;B,� >f+B�� #�BGf,� >f+B� �� , #�BG,� >+BH #B;B,� >+B� TB�J �&j7 , NB[� A.�J #�BG,� >&��e N�V, b0�

�A�M� Í , >f&��� �f! .f�2,� -�f7 �A�M� Í Sª�/e� >+BI�7 �2! \%e�� #B;B,� , #B;B�, N�V,� , ��+� , �A�M� Í NB[� A.�J , >+BI�7 �2! \%e��

, `.�� >+B� Ë�� , #�BG,� >+BI S.+��� , NBfV&� , af�2&:Ò , >f&�t�,– �� #�BG,�–�)&,0 #B;B,� >&��� Tt�D� O$c #B;� 3OR�7 �a�� 3 �f� f:� <f�

�aH UB�+ �<�%,�3 f! #Bf;B,� S#�f+ª m0 ���af,� uf+.5,� ��w #�.� tD0� �H #B;B,� T�&c >&��e� , ��.%e�7 �A�%,� T�&c , ��fV5Db� T%7 Th�� X�

�A�M� Í t)2&73 ��h2,� p�2� �a� P&�� , ��� t&� ,4f/: �Gf�� Ï� »&�f,� ��af� �f;B+

%$J �!�$J��=��, 3 �#�H ������: �f�� �.%f�E� �Gf�� Ï� ��ae A�a/!b�� �&;B/,� �a� N¼�

#B;B,�� >&��e� 87 Ë;A�M� h+t/,� ��5/D� ! U+ �%� , OfV, NBVJ �&j7 >��/G� >+B� t)2� , �f]�e� Í �f�#��� ! U+ b �2V, , NBfV+ �f&j7

OV, #��b� �7 �� Í u�� t)2� , #Bf;Be� ��,� B�� , >5Cf/e� >f&��e� �� #B;B,�7 , >+BI� Í #��b� �� , #B;B,� >+B�� >&��e� >+B� , h?�f�� �� �DE

Page 88: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

X� >%/µ >&;A�� >+B� #B;B�, NBV+ b Np7 Ë;A�M� h+t/,� T! NBV+ N�� � �]�e� Í >&��e� >+B� ,� NBV+ Np7 O7.�� #B;B,=�+A�$/!� =�6A�! =� >f+B)�, ��aff,� Í >ff&;A�M� , �ff&�! �cff] t&ff� N�ffj/+ b aff�2&j�Ò , .ff�� >ff&��e��

Ë;A�� ,Ë2�w .�� #B;B,� �&�! �] �����F3 d��H ������: >�7�Gf,� ���afe� 8f7 -<M� NB[ ! 42/$� �&;B/,� �a� N¼� t?�c= �f&5D �� Ë2�a,� #B;B,� Y�$@� ! , l,af[ .f�E� P&f,� , .f[w f��

Y�ff&�V,� Off�%J Í Ë2�aff,� #Bff;B,� Ëff527 8�?�ff��, ��hffD b �ffD� %Gff,� Y���%e�� Y�+�A�$/!b�� , Y�%2/e�� , �Gfj7 ~%$�, �)�%7 S.+����

TB)5e� , O�%,� Í �� UBCj7 O�%/,� NB[ Í ()!�hD tD0� , �?��f/c� Í� >��� Í YB$|,� ,7 (I �F/+ <� 87 .+��/,� Ë5D Ë2�a,� #B;B,� Ë5D #.F

ABC/,� Í >&��e�� #B;B,� , �f� TBf)5e� Zs ��:� �� TB)5e� NBV+ Np7 .�g� , �B2%e� ��z�b� Ë5D� , �z�f� Åf[ 4f2%� #B;B,� �� O�%+ Np7

Y�#B;Be� 873 uf+.5,� �af� �,B�+ �� >+�s N0 O7 , #Bf;B�, NB��f2,� (f�� Ë2�a,� ,,� N0 O�%,� Í ?�ª .�p7 P&, #B;B , �z�fe� ÅfV,� 42%e� P&,�

�&� �7�|7 ,����# ��A.�J 42%� !3<�! �z��� ?�ª �D0 NB,B�+ (� O7 = O�%/,� Í� , .f�g� �f� (f)5+ �f� Zfs ��:� �� ()5+ O�%,� N� 42%7 ,

f&�[ 4f2%� �2� �A+�=�OfV,� f! �Cf+ 3 uf+.5,� �af�� , ABf)' (f��E� S.!�� , Ë2�af,� #B;B�, ()&5D X� , �fD�&7 u$f9 �f� f! , Npf7 NB�?�fc

�B2%� �z�� #B;B,� ,=2�w >&��e� ! ?�ª��AB[afe� 42%e�7 � F , N� Xf�

n� o�Z�� ::�I��D&� ]�f G#� «�9&��%&� $�f�2 :� W �P −�POE

n� o�Z�� :�p�ND&� ]�f :��W ��E

Page 89: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ة وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظري

− ��� −

�+�A l,w -<� ! ��ae� »&� , .� t[ , #Bf;B,� Ëf527 ()%� �c�5J� X�Ë2�a,�3 �G����:,� S#�+ª T%7 U�c �� ��., �&;B/,� �a� �f� ��A� >f&��e� f! #B;B

��Ag� "af� 8f7 -<M� O%§ �J#�+h7 U�c , >5f9<5,� ��A �f)2�� ,f�<�=� &�5,=�+A�$/!� =��¤ =� , lf,w -<f� f! >f�&��� Í .�E� �V, , Of?��,� w0

>&�t�, >6A�! >5] ���.+ >&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+h7 , �H >?�c , Shf+t/� Zs �A�M� Í �)2! , �.%f�E� �f&,0 ��w �� ! >&��e� �2&%7 B� #B;B,� N� b

�%� ��� , �Ve�� �;�B,� Í ,�f;�B,� Í >59<5,��3 (­�A�f$! .��f�� �A�$/!� Ë�5, b Ë�&�: -<M� N� .%�J3

¸5, Í -</�b� m0 �.5,� 87 -<M� X;A� ()�%7�" #B;B,� " , �&: 8&2%� ! u�L+ �D� .[w ,�E� NBfV,� ! U , Y�af,� f! Î�f|,�� , �f�

NBV,� �7 #�A� >&��e� ! ?�ª #B;B,� N� m0 ��w , P5D �D� m0 ��w ���Y�a,� �7 #�A� >&��e�3

>f@<|7 �&�! #A� >&I�� �?�jC,� �:�] �2c.G,� m0 %G,� �$GD c��;����F: ����:� Í r6��� 87 ���ae� 87 -<M� N0 Ð � Of7��e� #Bf;B,� TBf)5� Í �D

NBV,� 42%� �2&%7 B�� T%�,3 �#�H��: Y�a,� TB)5� N0 , ��+� , Å[ :�� 42%� , Y��af,� 8f7 �&� �z�� ,

Y�#B;B,� 87 #B;B,� TB)5� ��z��[ ,?�ª �DBV7 �&� T<V,� #B%&�=� f! ?�h7 P&, �� >&��e�3

n� o�Z�� :�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �� E3

Page 90: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

d��H��:P5D N�GD�� Y�w Np7 UB�,� N0 Sf?�� �&� ABC/+ b �¬ �/&���� �J�w ,<��= �&�! ��F/:b� m0 ��/y N� �! , `Bf9 ��f7 Y�af,� �C+ ¢ �DE

Y�w �kB[ ,>&��� ��3 �)/�c�2�� U�E� u+.5,� >,#p7 OC/+ t&� �a� , �.%f�E� �Gf�� Bf7� (f��

��$,� 8G�� B7�� ,t)%$J ���3 6 �� (s.,� ! �D� U��+ u��� u+.5,� �a� >,#� �% , �J.J �¬ (s.,� !�

S9�� Tª�B, �� �&�! , UBf�,� m0 ()2f� f:� ��af+ ¢ �f7 8�?�f�,� N� b0 #B;B,� S:� ��a7 ,:�� #B;B,� NB[ ��#�A� b�=� , uf�� 8f! �D�� ,

m�%J� �D�j$9 , ¢�%,� 8! �� ,CD b=�y�J� =� , fj&�J� SA��0 b�=� , Of70 u����� l,w -<� ! 8����� �+a� <[ ��a� N=;� �Gf�� Bf7� �f��

>2G,� O�� >?� �� T��0 B)� �.%�E� , `I� >?� ��� , h+�f� `.f+ Bf�� ��.|VJ� Y�#B;Be� , u�� h&� `.+ t[ , m�%J , O�/Gfe� ·�fM� "#Bf;B7 Y�#B;Be� .?�9 �! ,#Bf;B,� �f;�� #Bf;� m0 #Bf;B,� T�Gf�D� `.+�

(+�,� , � B�� , m�%J , #Bf;B,� �fV¬ #B;� m0� , ¾#�f�� , �f� Bf�� � `B9 , #B;B,� �;�� , � u�� �� O[ B�� , m�%J , Tf! `.f+ �D� t[

�B�d�, u,�M� >�@�¬ , u,�fd�, �B�de� b� , �f$|+ �fD0 Of7 , m�f%J , Î�%e� Y�5] , �7 >?�c , �f&: �f� �fJ�a, S.+���TBf)5e� , Í �f, >f�ª<�

�J�w �! >V52� Zs �A�M� , B� � b �)&� U��+ b , "Zfs � b� ,f�<�=� Y�5C,� S�52, , >59<5,�[ , >,h/%e�� , (�Zs� ,#Bf;� �, �$|+ b �&V�=�

]��=� �7 , >&�t�, S.+��e� �%e� Y�5] �� #B;B,� NB[ X� , U�fj[ �I�: �%e� Y�5] >&�7 , ��&�E� (!� #B;B,� N�[ �e �V, , Y�5] >&�7 TB�J �7�

Î�%e� , >&��e�� Y�a,� P5D #B;B,� O%§ Np7 ´�G� �, N�[ t7., , "hf&� X�

Page 91: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

·�M� "#B;B7 m�%J3 �$�a� B� �a)� , � ��A , �f!�$J� ��a�� , (?�f�,�u,�M� >2+�$� ! , �B�d�, m�%J ,fM� "#Bf;B7 #Bf;B� Of[ hf&�� ·� ,

4f2%e� �aH >j��R �!�$J� �/[� �$/[� , Sf:� ��af� N� N�.f+ (f� Of7 OR�7 #B;B,� , U<f6� #�f�0 �f7 UB�,�� , lf�J m0 SA�f�Â, >f;�: b� (�2! O?�Ge� ,�­.)�, �)&,0 �h%,��3

>,h/%e� >?� �� B)� ��$,� 8G�� B7� ���� , (kBf[ �f� (s.,� ! (��� Y�5] S#�+ª NB52+ Y�a,� ! Î�%e , �f, NB/$|+ (k� b0 , m�f%J ,#Bf;�=�

]��=� , h&/�=� Y�#B;Be� .?�9 �! �7 , Y�a,� ! Y�5C,� S#�+ª �B5D tD0� ���� >H��� �! �A�$,� #�.�0 Í ()/�,�$� S�, ,%�#=� u,�fM� �&$�J O?�B�,

�B�de�7 , >fL,�de�� ��h/�b�7 UB�,� �&V� ,<�f�=,� �f! Sf:B7 UBf� #B;B,� , >,h/%e� >?� �� :� �7 O�+ ¢ �¬ �a)� , �� ()2f! UBf�2� Bf� b�

(­�D�f�� ()$/[ Í .LG� , .f5[ ��afe� �afH UBf�,� N� N�.f+ (f� Of7 �B�d�, u,�M� >2+�$� Í >2G,� O�� ��a� �! ()$�a� ��/� b U<6�

, �D�� , m�%J , Ǫ� (+c ,² Y�#B;Be� >&�7�>@#�: >cB�3 Ã�d�� k!;E�� ��L� ���� , NB&�<9�� >59<5,� (�� , #B;B,� NBV7 NB�?��,� �;�B,� Í >&��e� 8! ,?�ª=� �fVe� Í �f&�! , TBf)5� NBfV7 (IBfc Xf�

[z�� #B;B,�=�+B2%� =�Y�#B;Be� 87 � (k� m0 >��6x�– Of�2,� Tf�J tf[ ()2!– �;�B,� >R�G$7 NB,/G+ ,J m�% , �f$[.J >,�j/9�� ,<f�! Bf,�= ,

"#B;� ! >&��� S#�+ª Ë5D ! , �fj$,� #B;B,� #.µ �D�� , b ¶Qf7� ,

Page 92: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

`.�� O?b7 NB,/G+ (kx���F: �−?�ª #B;B,� N�[ B, =�<7�c ��,� NB[ Th�, �;�B,� Í >&��e� ! =<!��� = ,<7�fc �fDB[ ���= ±f6�.%� �fDBV�� =� #Bf;B�, ,� �A�f! #Bf;B,� , >f&�t�

<7�c NBVJ �;�B,�= #B;B�, ,<!�� �DB[ ����= ±&�f/�� �fDBV�� =� #Bf;B�, , �f�#B;B, >&�f/�� �f;�B,� >&�t� , �fI >f�!��� , NBf[ >,�j/f9� SA�½�J�w Zs �;�B,� #B;B, Ö/�e� ,�f2V¬ #Bf;B,� �f;�� N�V, b0�±3 tfD0�

e� m0 Of!�5,� >$GD NBV, l,w �B%2� 1B;B,�f7 UBf%5 , m0 Of7��,� >$GfD� N�V���7 UB$�e� , N�%/§ <� ,�+��=� :�B,� �! �+.@� A�] ���h�/9b

�&G$,�3 1− "#B;� N�[ B, , m�%J ,?�ª=� "#Bf;� U��ª ª�Bf; Thf�, �f/&��� ! ,

m�%J , U�_ B�� ,�;�B,� N�V�0 ���h�/9b3 T�h�,� �;� – U��ª T�hf, �� ! #B;B,� >&��e� ! �J#�+ª �.� –?�ª N�[ �w0 #B;B,� N� = ±� >f&��e� f!

�Dx� , a�2&:Ò ,5f]� #Bf;B,� NB[ A�$/!�7 >&��e� m0 .�/5+=�t?�fc = �f]Be�7 >&��e� B� �a,� , �Gf5D Í �fV¬ �,��ª Nx� l,a[ #B;B,� N�[ �w0�± ,.f�D=�

"Zs m0 �;�&/:b ,� N�[ �,��ª h§ ¢ B, w0 Z�,� �! Ë2�/G , �fD� �.5,��"Zs m0 ��/_ �]�3

f;−?�ª #B;B,� N�[ B, =� #B;B,�f7 >f&��e� T�J Th, �;�B,� Í >&��e� !

n� o�Z�� :d�X�&� :W �− u , �5c&��C��L&z� :FWO�O�K�-? �.) , C�L���V&�) C�3�fz��o?��&�) +&�g&� ��D%N&� FW����K�-? �.) ,W����K�-? �.) ,W����K�-? �.) , +2��D&�

$�I�c&� :��W � −� O , W� P−� � ,$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :�� W O��−O�� , R�-?34�R��&� '�pA ~ :W��O ,$�L&z� �`�M^&� :Wu� ,�I��D&� :W�u−�Q ,�I��D&� ]�f :

� W �OP−��� ,�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �O ,�p�ND&� ��fA :W��O−���E

Page 93: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

#B;B,� ! , ��#B;� O$c S#B;B� >&��e� NBVJ N� Th�&� ,U�_ B��3 >[�[.,�� �%�,� >+�s Í ���D;� O?b,� "a� m0 �D.�D �w0 �jD� ,�f)&��

.��D 4D#� ! 45� b �� ~c�2/,� �� , �fH a�*+ N� �F%,� O[ �F%,��>&D��.7 O?b# �k� !3 b�S� 7��8�� �UOG ��� .���� , �&Gf$,� ��f,� NBf[ Xf2� ! 42/$� �DE ,

<7�fc NBfV+ N� "B;B,� �� �p7 >/$,� �&� .|VJ b �a,�=<!�f�� ��f�, = �f, ,�R�7� >!B2¬ >&��,� "a�� > ,f&D��.7 Of&,# b w0=� �f)&�! , �f)&�! 4f27 fc�

"a� �)2� O?�G� S! >59<5,� ,�7 >&JB$@ Y�5] T�&c ��2/�� �)2��� m�f%J , Tª<,� X27 NBV+ O&,,� �a� N<L$� , f:�B,� ��f,� NB[ N<L7 X2� ��

<7�c �&G$,�=<!��� = ���, ,<7�c :�B,� NBV+ N� h?��� �� �Dx�= � ±� <!�f�= , 8/5�/² 8/$G27 , 1B;B,�7 ��:� , N�V���7 .�g�� , 8f/); �f� �V,

8/5�/² , >f); �� �F/� , `.f�� >f); �f� �fv b� , �Gf5D �,�f%e�[>jC,� >5C7 �C/&,3<7�fc ��f,� NBf[ Xf2+ b� Àf+ b 4f2%e� �a�� =

<!���=3 �2! 1�§ t[ , ��+� ,e� m0 O7��,� >$GD Np7± T�f%,� N�fV���7 UB$� , b Bf�� 1B;B,� Í�2+ ,�&��2+ �a,� ·�M� N�V�b�7 b3

f:�B,� N�f[ Bf, t&f� �&Gf$,� f:�B,� �f! �+.@� A�] T�h, `B!# ����±<7�c �&G$,�=<!��� = , >�R�7 `B!� X2/¬ �D��± , >5f9<5,� �f)&�! 4f27 c�

>��$,� (Vj7 >�R�7 O?�G� ,f;B,� �;�� NBV[ #B , m�f%J � , ACf+ ¢ ��� :�� �� b0 �2! , U�E� O�%,� B�� ,9�5,� ��ae� �a� ! ��27=3

��.,� �a� >59<5�, (�GD b �jD� ,c<R�=� , uf�� Of�� 2! X2/+ b �Dx� :�B,� �! Z|V,� AC+ N� , >+.�B��� , U�|e� O&$9 ! , >�&�: �kB[ X�

Page 94: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

>L&G7 S:�� ,�f%� ��.!E� UB$�,� h&j/�, >�! =� , ��f, N�.f@� tf)��&G7 :��3

Y�f��h�e� f! ��B$JA Ë/,� Tª�B�,� >jC7 >59<5�, (&�G/,� �.� ! (@<7�c �&G$,� :�B,� NB[ ��2/�� ��/7� (�GD b �2D� b0= = ±<!��� = , "af� O]p�

NE >6B�.� S.V5,�± #B;B,� ,?�ª �DB[ .+�J !=� , Y�a, �/�ª<� Í�2+ b �;�B,� ,<!�� �;�B,� NBV+ 4/: �&� Z@p/,� rC+ b Tª<e��= �f, , �af[�

UB$�e� l,w O%� m0 >;��� Th�/G+ 4/: UB$�e� .�pJ Ö/�+ b UB$�,���F3 ;'�½ nL�NEp Ã�d�� 7��8�� ���� , �f+�=� , -�CfJ� �.f� f! Ëf2/$� Bf��

c �� 4/� N�V���7 #B;B,� �;�B,� >&�t7 T� ,�,��ª ªB§ a�2&:�3 #B;B,� >5] U��ª ª�BF7 (&�G/,� T! 1�B���– �k�V�0 �.� ! 4/:

– �;�B,� >&��� �! , �­�af, >f&��e� �fVJ ¢ Bf, U��hf,� #B;B,� Th�+ tD0� �, >&�/�� , �J�w �! "#B;� U��ª X2/+ �� `B9 #B;B,� �;�B, 42%� b�

.�D=��J�a, 3 �a� "#B;� NBV7 (I (&�G/,� �.� ! , m�f%J ,f=2V¬� , �f2V, (�G� Zs , "#B;� u�� Í Z�,� m0 .�/5+ �� �Ve� NE , Í tfD0 T<fV,�� � Y�w , m�%J , �;�� Ǫ� #B;B7 >5C/e� , >5Cf/e� Ëf� �;�B,� Y�a� #B;B,�7 , Y�a,� X� #B;B,�� , ��#B;B7 >$;�B,� Y�a,�� ,7 P&,� �]B

4f/: �f;�B,� Y�af7 ���c �­�a7 SA.�/� >+B� �, �&�! ?�ª �V¬ �#B;� >2V¬ �kB[ `B!# Th�+ , �A�fM� Í �f�#B;� m0 S.f�/5� >f&��e� N� 42%7 ¦d�J� >+B� �I NBV/, , �f! �A�� �I .+��� �V¬ �� m0 S.�/5� �k� b

n� o~ �SK $5�s5&� a�&m �sx? ~ �Z�� :H2�f) �I��D&� :��W � P−� � ,W�OO −�O� ,

�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �O ,�p�ND&� ��fA :W���E

Page 95: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�­�w , #B;B�, >�!�� >�! >&��e� N� b�± ,�+ 4/: �k�V�0 `B!# Th , u�� O7 #B;B�, >&�/�� >&��e� N�± ,f;B� NBV+ N� Th�+ b Ö/�e��=�3 >f@ P&f��

UB�%�� >�!Ò , �;�� O!��� , >&��e� Ë� , �fV¬ UB%5�� ,#Bf;B,� Bf�3 f! #B;B,�f7 >f�%,� Tf�J BjD ! P&, "#B;� ! �;�B,� >&��� T�/�

�,B�%� , Y�a,�7 T�J B� tD0� >$J.,�� , �f]� f! >f@<|,� Tf�J O�%/[ >+#.5,� , >f+#.5,� Of$c >@<|�, #B;� b �D� TB�%��± , 8f7 �f2� .f�E� �afV�

>&��e�� #B;B,���F3 \��d�� 7��8�� ���� �f�#B;� Of$c >f&��e� #B;� T�h, �.� ! 42/$� B)�

#B;B,�7 �C/J 4/: ,?�ª #B;B,� N�[ B, t&�=��)&�! 3 .� c� �af� N<L7 �.%�E� �G�� Ï� U�E� u+.5,� >,#� ! #.,� 8: O&,,� , 8Gf�� Ï��

��$,� ,t)!�$J��3 \_��d�� k_!;E�� ��L� �����f?�ª #Bf;B,� NBf[ m0 ���af,� =� Í >f&��e� f!

�Ve�� �;�B,� ,[z�� �DB[ X�=�+B2%� =� �)&� , f! �J#�+ª ! >,#� ()��� Í >&��e� �;�B, , �Ve� Í �J#�+ª ! `.�� >,#�� , �f)&�! �B,/9� c� >,#� S%7 , �j7� Ä��D �� B�Æ b , t7 �)��%J T%, ��#�.+0 #C7 �G,�

�&� �j$,� #C7 �jD , Í #Bf;B,� NBfV7 8�?�f�,� ��A T�h�/f9� B�� b� �/&��� 8! �;�B,� , �)&�! ?�h7 P&, ,#Bf;B,� S:� ��a�3�A Bf�� �

t)!�ff$J�� ��ff$,� 8Gff�� Ï�� �.%ff�E� �Gff�� Ï� T�ff��� , ��A�>59<5,� ,�)&�! �J#�+ª `.+ �� ��A N�#3

n� oa�&�&� �SK �sx? ~ �Z�� :H2�f) �I��D&� :� W �O��K�-? �.) , $�f�2 �Z��)

�I��D&� ]�jf G#� «�j9&�j�%&� ,�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �� ,�p�ND&� ��jfA : W���−��PE

Page 96: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف

− ��� −

�f&�?�c �f� r&f�J b� r+�fJ �f&� P&f, ��.f,� �a� N� T�J t&� N�7 c�± #B;B,� S:� ��a7 , Å�%,� T�h�,� u+.L7 "#��� �2V, , Tf�J �� BjD !

�D�&7 ,�� N0 4/: ��ae� �a� �J#��x7 ¥�+ N� #�[ �ª�.,� T�� , .f[w t2&: u+.5,� �a� �)c�9 Ë/,� >,#E� ! S#A�B,� Y�6�z!b� , �f�w �f� >]��

[z�f� #B;B,� NB[ m0 ()2�=�f&�5, =� Y�#Bf;Be� 8f7 , N� �ª�.f,� .[af�±[z�� �V+ ¢ B, #B;B,�=�+B2%� =�B,�f7 (&G�/,� N�[ �e Y�#B;Be� 87 1B;

$;B� N�V����=� �Ve� �! �;�B,� ª�&/�b , #Bf;B,� TBf)5� N�[ �w0 �Dx�5�/²=� – Ë�5, �z�� �D� `.+ �� ��A ! – f:p7 #Bf;B,� NBV+ N� ª�; �

$;�� �&�B)5�=� �, ,=2V¬ .�g�7���, ,$;�� :�B,� ��,� NBV&�=�f=2V¬� � Í #B;B,���F3 8�?�f�,� Thf,� �ª�.,� N0 O7 ± ��.f,� �afH– NBfV7 8�?�f�,� ��

n� o�Z�� :$�I�cD&� +2��D&� :��W ��� E

/?�� R?�)3��V��? ��n�) m�n�&� ��U R. 8KSD&� �SK 8KS� ~�^&� < ,�kT 3��V��? ��9D.< , �N0H�VU R. d��gU o���. ~ �S� ]�p ,���� m�n�&� 8n�) $-��� G#� "`�I /5%#0 8KS. �K) ,H�� H:��#X:) H:����0 3)�p $�5�U) ,yM&�0 ,G&�-: ,H:�7 3��V��? ,C�7 �K +�2 R. , �Z�&� ��^?

0 3)�p R�H�� H:���� ,m�n�&� 8n�) ,C�S&� $��2A $�:�D? H�� �-D&� �K) ,R�-&� $��2A) ,�24� $��2A) ,a-5&�? H�� H:��#X:) H:����0 3)�p) H:�S& H�#X: ~ �Z�&� 3��V��?) , �L�� �-D&�)

�m��M&�) C��9DD&�? ,m�n�&� R9D. �K ,d�g9&� $��2A H�:�D? H�� �-D&� �K) , 8n�) �L0 �S& "��I�m�2 R9D.) E$��24� $�:�.) , C�S&�? d�g9&� $��2A $�:�. G#� $.�NV. R�-&� $��2A )A$�:�&�) ,��.(&�? � ,qM. /#N� =3��V�� 1�N: �L0 ,�� �� "h �D0� � ,G&�-: ,H:�7 R. C��9DD&�) ,

H:�7 /K a? E /?�� R?� '�I :"C��9DD&� ����A ~ yM&� m�n) �L0 HU3�� �. a90 ,�2 RD0 �K yM&� $��K +

�m�n) , C��9DD&� ����A �K H�0 3�^&� �sVk� +�2 R.)" E"9M&� W�^0 :W��O E

Page 97: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Y�f&��e� �� ��7 �A�! Zs �DB[ ¶Q7 ·�M� #B;B,� B� � >�&�: , >59<5,� ��a� B� t[– #Bf;B,� >f$;�� �f�0 Y�#Bf;Be� X&' NBVJ Np7 �

��� ,�f�� #Bf;B,� >2V¬ ��0�±3 >5f9<5,� �.f� �af,� #Bf;B,� N� �fD�&7 ± � #B;� �D� 8&�<9��± , m�%J , �fj7 #Bf;� B� ,-¤ , b ¶Qf7� ,

t?�fc NBfV+ N� Öf/�+ N� ��0 #B;� �D0 �&: �� >%&$L,� "aH #B;B,� �a)�= � � �G527 ,<�/G�= �J�a7 ,&2s=� "�B9 �� O[ �! , l,w Ö/�+ b �� , N�f[ �fDx�

l,a[ #B;� O[ NBV+ N� �;� U�E� , >f?�c NBfVJ Y�#B;Be� X&F� �)G5Dp7 ,�/G� �)�?��j7 >� , Y�2Ve� #B;� ��5/D� �&�! Th�,� , 8f! Bf��

#B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� ��a� ,f:�� #B;B,� NBV+ N� �2� Th�+ w0= �� , Bf� #B;B,� �;�� #B;� ,�J�a7 (?��,�3 NBfV+ N� #Bf;B,� �af� ~/f�+ ¢ N0� �

'�I) ,�Y�A :" H�� �– G&�-: �� =A –1�� )A m�n) R. "92 a9? C�-�. aU R�� ,t�n)) ,

��9.�) ,'�M.) ,R�-&� �&7 �K) �� "9M? �p�: R�� "h �D0� �" E$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�O W��� E

'�I) :"d�g9&� $��2A ���#x: /V&� $�L&z� ��D�4� +�2 R. �� $��2� , G�,&� +�2 R. �� $��2A)R�-&� $��2A ��D�4� R�) ���� � , �24� "�� H�#� y#x� �DKsU)" E"9M&� W�^0 :W��P E

'�I) :"�24� $��2A H& H%5� +�2 R. �� �A "#�A � ,9&� $��2A H& ���D�A +�2 R.) d�g" E$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW ��P E

yM&� R� '�I) ,G&�-:) H��M�� :"b��_&� ��-� �?A GD%D&� �K � � , C�h�MD&� ��D�A R. �&7 ��;)" E"9M&� W�^0 :W�� E '�I) :"yM&� ��; H:�S& 8n�) �m�n) R. "h �. � � ,H? 8n�) R9DD&�) ,��LZ. H�4 ,H? �K�j� �K) ,

3�V%. $�9DD&� R�-&�)�L�0 �K�Z&� �S� d ,��9.z�? �K�Z&�) 3�LZ&� �SK �^:�0 , H? H�#� "92�LZD&� R�� ,R9DD&� �K =S&� ,���� H:�S& m�n�&� 8n�) ~ R9DD&� �3���0 , 8n��&� �3���)

�D92 R9DD&� ~ H:�S& m�n�&�" E$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W P� E Hp�^� q-? �SK ,d��gU t��&� �SK ~ e�kA W�^� H&)E

Page 98: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

t?�c= �G527 ,&2s=� "�B9 �� O[ �! ,�fD0 �f&: �f� #Bf;B,� NBV+ N� �;� "Zs m0 .�/5� #B;� , "Z�7 (?�c� , OfR�7 �af�� , #Bf;� Ëf5D Th�/Gf+ w0

#B;B,� �;�� ,�fJ�a7 (?�f�,���F3 >5Cf/� >f&��� �fJ�a, NBfVJ N� �f;B� � #B;B,�7 , "#B;� 1B;�� "#B;� >&]BC� �$;�� Ë/,� Ë� , "ª�f&/���

Y�#B;Be� �� "�B9 t!3 B,� �;�� N� `.+ �� ��A N<L7 N� u���± ± #B; , m�%J � , #Bf;B,� #.µ

b ¶Q7� �j$,� , #B;�� >&��� �G&, �J�w N��± , 8f7� .���Ø Ø , �<f�%,�� Of�pJ 4D#pf7 ��.,� �a� >,�j/9� NB[A+ , Sf! �ª�.f,� T�f��� #A�� fc�

O?b# ,�)2�:− �− #.fµ b0 �f, >f&���� >f�&�: b �� �.f� Np7 )�+ O�%,� r+¤ N� ±

,�� #B;B,� U�_� OR�7 N�&!E� Í NBV , >f&��� O�%,� �.5+ N�� 7b O7� ��,� �aI >�&�:� , N�&!E� Í NBV,�� #B;B,�7 �)&�! (Vy l,w %7 (@ ,

>/$,� A.�/+ b >&��e� N�7 #B;B,�� , OC: 4/� �Dp7 >[�: O�%,� >q7 O7 #B;B,� 42%� , N�&!E� Í NBV,� B� �a,� ,� ��2� ��C: �� Ëf� >f&��

N�f&!E� Í ��C:� Y;� �kp7 �)&�! TBVje�� � � K , ��f5/D�7 Thf�� &5+ B��>&��e� N�# #B;B,� O�%J� F3

�− Å; Ëq7 #B;B,� ABCJ Np7 >59<5,� (&�GJ ± , �+.%/,� �! Ë2s , X� �/&���� #B;B,� �;�� >�&�: ��A#0 ��2/��7 ()&�GJ , �fJ�w �f2[ N� 42%7±

–��� �� �/&– Qf$�, >f�B�%� Zs , U#± , ()��z!�f7 , >f&��� S.+�f�� f!

n� o$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :��W QP��^V? E

n� o$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :��W O����^V? E

Page 99: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�;�B,� , m�%J ,"#B;B,��F3  − #B;B,� �;�� N�[ B, , -�,� #B;B,� #.µ , b ¶Q7� , Thf�� Xf�

Sf:�� >f&!BD >%&$R Y�w #B;B,� NBV7 , �fVe� �� �f;�B,� Í ��Bf9 , �Ve� ! rC+ �� �;�B,� ! rC+ N� �;� , N<L$f,� .��f� �af�� ,

�Ve�� �;�B,� 87 S���Ge� ��L7 �w0� , X2/+� ªB§� �§ t&� , �f;� `Bf9 .f�i .f�� m0 Xf;.+ t)2f&7 t&f� T�V:E� Í -</�b� �a� NBV+ N��

#B;B,� , �Ve� >&��� �! �;�B,� >&��� ª�&/�� >&]BC� B�� b� , Ëf/,���V:� t)2� O[ Í �$;��=�H >]�� t� F3 �fJ�w NB[ 1B;� l,a7 �$|� ,

m�%J , S#B;B� >&��� ,-�,� #B;B,� �G&,�3 �f/&��� f! �f;�B,� #Bf;� S#�+ª >,pG7 u�%/+ t&� �a)� %7� , Tf! ��

�f)&�! �J#�+ª , 8Gf�� Ï�� �.%f�E� �Gf�� Ï� ��A �%f6 N�f7 fc� ��$,� , t)!�$J�� , >59<5,� ��A �%6� , >,#� �%6� 8�+.5,� , �k��

>&D��\,� m0 4c.J b , >[�[A �)�%7 Í N0 O7± , >f&,�� m0 4f/: 4fc.J b ,<��=>&D��\,� �! 3

NBf[ m0 ���af,� ��afe� �af� f! >$Jze� S9�5,� Tª�B�,� �D�7 c� t[ -�f,� #Bf;B,� Bf� m�f%J � >�&�: , �fj$,� , b ¶Qf7� , �f&�! tf[

�� >59<f5,� NB&�<9 , "#B;� NB[ m0 ���a,� �� , m�f%J , �f/�&�: 8f! �J�w� ,bB�� #B;B,� NB[ X�= Ëf�5�,� ��zf�b� uf+.L7 Y�#B;Be� ! ,

�.%�E� �G�� B7� �&�! t[ , ��$,� 8G�� B7�� ,t)!�$J��3

n� o$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :��W O����^V? E

n� o$�&�-&� 8&�xD&� :��W O����^V? E

Page 100: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

8�?�f�,� Y�VGf/G� (f�� �f� �kBV, >&?h�� "a� Í T<V,� ���� tD0� S:B7 ()$�a� >j] ! �H O&,/�, #B;B,� ,f);� %+ tD0 ()$�a� N��= � K× ±�

8&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� ��ae .�i , >R�Gf7 Of&,# ()2f� ��#�5/f9� �f&: �;�B,� , �fj$,� #.fFe� #Bf;B,� �D��± , b ¶Qf7� , Of[ �f! #.fFe���A�! , �&�! �BVj&, ,l,w %7 ,Of[ f! �#�Cf,� uf�Le� #B;B,� �Dp7± #B;B� , #B;B,� 8! (�2! B)� ,Y�#B;Be� 8! B)�3

()2! %G,� ���D �� �a� , �JA�$! Y.� t[ ,>&?h�� "aH OC/+ t&�3 #B;B,� S:B7 NB�?��,� �7 lG� �� ·BCd7 ��� , �DB[ �� , m�f%J , Bf�

u�Le� #B;B,� , %G,� Nx� , m�%J � ��A ,�f&�! ()�?b# (�� ()2! O�D , �JA�$! ���J t[ , 8&�<9�� >59<5,� �� ���#�5/9� (k�� ,��:

�− �;�B,� >R�G7 , m�%J , ABCf,� �� SAB] �p7 �$[.J >,�j/9�� , Bf,� Å�%,� �[z,� 4/: , S#B;B� >&��� NBV+ N� �B%2�� , #B;B,� X� �� , Í �e

��&/:b�� �[z,� �� l,w , �fD�&7 .f� tf[± � , �af[� �fDB[ �Bf%2� , m�f%J , ·�M� #B;B,� , �[z,� >$?�� �� l,w Í �e ,#B;� �DB[ X2� �B��! c�=�

]��=�� ·�M� #B;B,�� u�Le� T�%,� #B;B,� �� �[z,� �J�w T�h�/9� , t&f�#B;� �J�w �D�[ B,=�]�� =� �f&,0 uf�Le� T�f%,� #Bf;B,� Tt�fD� ABCJ X� ,

��&/:b� �J�w T�h�/9b� , uf�Le� #Bf;B,� m0 ·�fM� #B;B,� ��&/:� �� T�%,� , �J�w �D�[ B, t&� , m�%J ,#B;�=�]�� =� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �fI �.! T�%,� , U�je� Th�+ 86.5,� <[ %� , ��&/:b� �� �[z,� ��0 , BfjD f!

NB&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� ��BJ �� , � Y�w �fD�[ Bf, t&f� , m�f%J , >f&���;��#B3 �− �;�B,� NB[ , m�%J , -�,� �j$,� #B;B,� B� ,b ¶Q7 #B;B,�� ,

Page 101: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

fc<R� �f&� f&&�J b �af,� -�,� #B;B,� ��=� , NB�?�f�,� "#�5/f9� �af��>59<5,� �! #B;B,� S:B73 -�,� �j$,� #B;B,� N� TB�%�� , ¶Q7�

u�Le� #B;B,� B� b 3  −Z� u�Le� �j$,� #B;B,� >�&�: NB[ ~_ , �;�B,�� , m�%J , Zf�

~_ ,u�Le� �j$,� #B;B,� B� �;�B,��3 �− O|� b� 6 �, O�%+ b u�Le� �j$,� #B;B,� NB[ , �;�B,�� , m�%J , SA�À,� (Vj7 TB�%� B� t[ , Off|� b� �f, f6 b , N� >fF&/2,� Nwxf�±

�;�B,� , m�%J ,�j$,� u�Le� #B;B,� B�3 �−B,� NB[ OC� b� �, P2; b �j$,� u�Le� #B; , �&G7 �DE , �h; b �, ,=2&! b�=2�w b� � , �&[z,� Th�/9b OC�� P2; �, N�[ B,� , uf�L��

��5J�7 �&� �&[.J b #B;B,�3 OCf� b� �, P2; b #B;B,� �;�� �a[� , ��5J�7 �&� �&[.J b w0 ,e� #B;B,� B� #B;B,� �;�� N� >F&/2,� Nwx�u�L3

�)%6B� Í �2! >,B�2e� �JA�$! Í %G,� �)&,0 A��� Ë/,� ()�?b# "a� , fc�Å+ t7 O?b,� "a� %G,� OL7�:−

−b�S� 7��8�� �UOG ��� Y�w N� (��Bf!# >&�fc Í ()&f�! %G,� #A �� ± � , m�%J , ·�M� #B;B,� Ë� �D�[ B, , ·�fM� "#B;� ��&/:� �2� Th�,,� m0 T�%,� u�Le� #B;B , ·�fM� #Bf;B,� �f� Y�af,� �f[.J �f2� Thf�&�

T�%,� u�Le� #B;B,�� , >fL,���� (f�� #.fµ `B!f,� "a� Np7± , �af,� w0 u�Le� #B;B,� B� �&� �.%+� .�g� m0 ��/y , #B;B,� m0 .�/5+ �a,� B)�

·�M� , �&� �.%+� , PV%,� P&,� ,T�f%,� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� N� lf,w± b �J�w Í �, A.�J , Y�f&��e� �)&,0 .�/5J �A�M� Í SA.�/� >+B� �, P&,� , Of7

>&��%,� YbBje� �� B� , Î�B|,� YbB�%e� ��� , �f� �fI #B;� b Ë/,�

Page 102: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Ë� Ë� �&: , ��#�.�� Í ��#B;� O7 , Y�&��� m0 >;�/je�� S.�/5e� Ë)�>f&?h�� �)CC: �)&� A.�/, u?����3 �af[� #Bf;B,� ��f5JA�7 �fD� (��Bf!#±

Ë?h; #B;B� O[ #B;� X5J.+ T�%,� u�Le� , �;�B,� #B;� 4/: , m�f%J , u�Le� #B;B,� ��5JA� X2/&� �a, , #Bf;B,� �f;�� NBV&� ,�f+�=� >fL,���

N<L$,� S.��� ,A�B%,� >�B�V�3 Th�+ tD0 u�Le� #B;B,� N� %G,� 87 c� ± ± �, t&� #B;B,� 1B;� �fJ�a, T%,� ��2/�� N�[ B , �Bf2¬ �f2V, , ��f+�� , N0±

�;�B,� B� �a,� "#�.�� ~%7 ��5JA� Th�/G+ >&�V,�7 u�Le� #B;B,� ��5JA�3 1Bf;� f! U+ �a,� N� #B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� �b*� `B!# N� 42%7±

#B;B� O[ X5J.+ �!�5JA� Í N� T�%,� u�Le� #B;B,�± ,;�B,� #B;� 4/:� , 1w�[ OR�7 (!ª , f! Tf%,� ��f2/�� N�f[ Bf, t&f� �af� ()�<[ rC+ w0

�, Ô�w u�Le� #Bf;B,� , �fJ�a, P&f, �f&�! T%,� ��2/�� N� u�� �V,± , Of7 �&�! �.%J �A�B%, , ��f2/�b >f$;Be� �A�Bf%,� l�J U��ª h?��� �� #B;Be� T%2&� T%,� ,&J�w "#B;� �V+ ¢ N0=� , � #B;B[ Y�2Ve , N0 �f���� ±

&J�w "#B;� N�[=� , T%,� �&�! X2/+ �Dx� #B;B,� �;�� #B;B[ , ��2/�� NE± ��: Í T%,� , m�%J , Ô�w , "#B;� N� t[ , m�%J ,Ô�w3

()&�! %G,� #A c�± � , ��+� , T%,� ��2/�� N� m0 NB$�a+ (k� �.� �w0 t&�± K± � � u�Le� #B;B,� ! �J�a, , ��&�27 ��,� -�CJ� ��2/�b , N0 U�f�+ N� Of|�± �

T! #B;B,�3 ��&�27 ��,� -�CJ� X2/e� Np7 %G,� 1�;p� ± , ��� 42%7 SpR�Be�7 �&�! ,�2,Bc O|�: T! #B;B,� , ���/�b�7 b ,�2,Bc O|� : #B;B,�

T�%�3 �5JA�7 �D� #B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� (!ª N� u���± ± Of[ X5J.+ u�Le� #B;B,� �

#B;B� , �;�B,� #B;� 4/: , >�B�V� S.��� >L,��� , .f� t[ , N� lf,w±

Page 103: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين

− ��� −

#B;B,�7 �&�! (Vy b �c<R0 �&: �� u�Le� #B;B,� , �f� �, #B;� b w0 B� �&: , -¤ �A�$/!� .�� B� O7 , �J�&?h;� "#�.�� ! X�+ (V�� tD0�

�A�M� Í ��#B;� u�j/e� ,� ~f%7 #Bf;� Tf%2+ "#�.f�� ~f%7 T�f%D�$ >&2&%,� Y�#B;B,� ,Y�#B;Be� OV, Ë2&%,� #B;B,� T%2+ �%&' �)��%D�7� ,

Y�#Bf;Be� OV, ·�M� #B;B,� X5JA� Y�#B;Be� X&' #B;� X5JA� B�� , �.!� +ª #B;� X5JA� a�2&: U��&�Ò , .V7�,3 333 �fVe� #Bf;� Xf5JA��

�;�B,��33333»,�3�V, uf�Le� #Bf;B,� X5JA� �D0 U��+ b , #Bff;B,� NE±>&��%,� YbBfje� �� �j$,� T�f%,� u�Le���F ,Î�B|,� YbB�%e� ���� F ,

n� o<sN� aMD&� R� �K���,V�� o�VD� /V&� 3�.4� ��>? $�#N-&� C��DMD&� �-%&� ���� � , o�VD�)

_&� 8%M? H�0 �L&�^2�3� ,$�K�D&�) ��9.z�U ,aMD&� R� R,V%. H��0 ��%�z� ag. �s_? ,/n3�k aMD&�? H.��I ��0 @���&� ag.)� E�Z�� :�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �P E

'�M.) C�0�p�D? �%�& /V&� 3�.4� ��>? �p�ND&� ��fA ~ /���9D&� �L0��)� � , ��p)A /K a?aMD&� R. �L& �?� '��2A) ,%�& �&7 o. /K)$�n3�_&� ��p)4� R. � E�Z�� :�p�ND&� ��fA :

W�OQE

n� oG&)4� C��N-D&� yM#: /V&� @3��-&� ��>? $���g&� C��N-D&� �-%&� ���� � , � +�2 R.�3�_&� ~ �.A �� =7�M� ,$�#9&�U ,$�`(X&�) ,$�:�S&�) ,$���-&�) , ���f4� y`�N2 yM#: 3�.A ��4aN-&� ~ �L&�^2 ��� , ��&)m�n�&� �K �/f ����4� ~ ,$�:�S&� )A ,$���-&� )A ,<sg. , ~ �D��)

��%�z� ����4� ,m��%&�) ,<sg. E�Z�� :�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �P E �3�_&� ~ �/f �� =7�M� � /V&� @3��-&� ��>? �p�ND&� ��fA ~ /���9D&� �L0��)� � , $�#9&�U

$�`(X&�))EEEEEEEE ,4 $���h ��D� �D��)G&)4� C��N-D#& $-?�: �� , yNMV&�? $U3�D&� /K)/n3�_&� ,$�n3�_&� 3�.4� ap4� ~ �3�� �. �4� ,��%�z�U ,m��%&�) , �#: �NNM: �7�0

}��g&� �SK ��3m� �L-�: C��N-D&� ,<sN� �L& 8%�:) ,�n3�k �< , �/f) /#U �K ���f �X: � 7�<��%�� �K �kT ,kT �/f) /`(n �/f �)��b �K � ,<sg. , ��b) ��%�z� �3�_&� ~ m�n�D&� �D��)

sg. E

Page 104: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

>�_ >&��! >+A�$/!� AB�� Ë� Ë)� ,Ë� �&: �� �A�M� Í �I #B;� b3 >f&?h�� "af� �! 1�;� t2&: %G,� #�;� c� , ��f+� ,Bf;B,� N� N�f&$7± #

>&D�|,� YbB�%e� �� u�Le� ,N�&!E� Í �I u�� b Ë/,� >+A�$/!b� AB�E��3 Sf:B7 8�?�f�,� Ub/f9� >6A�%� �.%� Í >59<5,� �! �a� O�D �&:

(��!� >j] ! >59<5,� T<V7 #B;B,�3 �f! Of�D fc �fDp7 ()f6A�%� ± b u�Le� #B;B,� N� &5+ �� 8&�<9�� >59<5,�± �A�fM� Í �, u�� , �fDE±

>&��%,� YbBje� �� ,>&D�|,� YbB�%e� �����F , �f;�� �fDB[ f&5+ <� #B;B,� , �A�M� Í Ë2&! u�� �, #B;B,� �;�� NE± , ·�M� "#B;� B� , .� �� ! ,�, #B;� <� u�Le� #B;B,� ���±3

>&��%,� YbBje� �� u�Le� #B;B,� NB[ >&�c� ,>&D�|,� YbB�%e� ��� , �&� �+A b �¬ , >f&q$,� ABf�E� �f� Bf� O7 , YbBfje� �f� �fDB[ �f��

Ofje� �f! �?�2�/9� ��2/�<� , �f7 TBf�J Of_ m0 .f�/5J YbBfje� NE , >&��e� ! ?�ª #B;B,�� ,?�ª N�[ ���=�t?�c NBV+ "Zs ! =�f7 3 �fD� �f��� ±>&��%,� YbBje� �� �A�M� Í �,BC: X2/+ �D¼� ,<]�: N�[ B, �DE= #B;B� N�V, �A�M� Í=� �&� ,#B;B� #B;B,� NBV+ N� X2/+�=� �A�fM� Í ,

�Z�� :�p�ND&� ��fA :W�OQ E$���g&� C��N-D&� ���-: ~ �Z��) :�I��D&� ]�f :�

W�PP ,���5&� C�2sxp� ��cU :�OW ��OP , W C�5��-V&� O� E C��)�-. �A }��g&� C��DMD&�) $�#N-&� C��DMD&� R�? ��5&�)� ��9: �I $�#N-&� C��DMD&�

m�n�&� $-�VD. ,o�VDD&� o. {��V.��U , aN-&� ~ @�-: $�3��V�� /L0 }��g&� C��N-D&� �s_?$�m�n�&� C��N-D#& E�Z�� :�p�ND&� ��fA :W�OQE

n� o �K +�2 R. m�n�&� �A �5c&� ~ ]�p ���� R?� �A /X�z� �Y-&� �U7� � �–y#xD&� m�n�&� =A − &� R.$���g&� C��N-D E

�Z�� :�I��D&� :WP� ,�Z��) :�I��D&� ]�f :� W �P�−�PPE

Page 105: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

#Bf;B,� �, �.%+ #B;B�, .+��� TB)5� �,�� �A�M� Í #B;Be� w0 , P&f,�#B;B,� �, �.%+ �G52, .+��� TB)5� #B;B�,3 �A�fM� Í #Bf;Be� ��f+��

,�� �A�M� Í #B;B,� � , #B;B�, .+��� �A�M� Í #B;B,� �, ��� , �f,�� NE #B;B,� �7 u�%J �� "�2%� #B;B,�± � � , �f�.+��J Öf/�+ ��f,�7 ��,� u�%J� ,

.+��� #B;B,� �,�� NBV&�=� #B;B�, , #Bf;B,� �f,�� #B;B,� NBV+ <� , b0�.+��� N�V,=� �G52, ,U�_ B��3�+�� =�N�[ B, #Bf;B� #Bf;B,� =� �A�fM� Í

�A�M� Í #B;� �, N�V, , "#B;�� , ��+� , #B;B� ,OG�G/,� Th�&�� B��U�_��F3

YbBf�%e� m0 S2/Gfe� YbBf�%e� �� �DE >&D�|,� YbB�%e� �� �DB[ ����± ±m�E� , >&�&�,�[ , �� �� Bf� #Bf;B� �A�fM� Í Y�#Bf;Be� Í P&, �Dx�#B;� ,� O7 N�GD0 #B;Be , }.�� , .F�� , .F:� , ��Zs� , �� Th�+ (@

#B;� �, NBV+ N� #B;Be� l,w >&,B�%� , NBfV+ >&?h�� Y�#B;Be� O�%/�b��= , �f­�w Í �fI A.f�J b Ëf/,� �A�Bf%,� lf�J Of�%J NBV+ ��%7 (@ ,

#B;B,�[ ,<|�=3 T%,� #B;B,� O|�� , >&D�|,� YbB�%e� �� B)� ,E YbBf�%e� m0 2/Gf+ �D

m�E� ,T! B� #B;B� N�&!E� Í P&,�3 1B;B,� ��|�� , N�V���� , ��ff2/�b�� , >f&��e�� , >f&�V,�� , >f&?h��� ,

>&J�a,�� , >&6.%,�� , >&G2��� , >&�C5,�� , >&!B2,�� , YbB�%e� �� �)�[>&D�|,�� F3

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W O�� – O�P ,m��D&� �cU :W�QE

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W O�P−O�� ,m��D&� �cU :W�Q−P�E

Page 106: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

:�� u�Le� #B;B,� NB[ `B!# Nwx�=��7 ¦d�, , �A�fM� Í NB[ �, , �f¬�D<L7 ! �<�%,� X&' u5J�3

−Ã�d�� &(��L ���� �f;�B,� NBV7 ��+.+ ¢ >59<5,� N� �� �D�&7 T�J �� ± uf�Le� #B;B,� �D� b ¶Q7� �j$,� #B;B,� B�± , ¶Qf7 b , Bf� �af,��

Å[ 42%� , �, #B;� b Å�! A�$/!�� ,B,� �2� ��#�A� O7 ¶Qf7 �j$,� #B; �&[z,� T! , >/$,� , �;�B,� NBV7 ()&�GJ X� , m�%J ,#B;�=�]�� =� �, �A�M� Í A.�J ,Y�#B;Be� .?�9 �! ª�/¬3 �2&9 �7� U�c: " �D0 ÇBc 42%� P&, – #Bf;B,� �;�� �� – #Bf;B,� #.fµ

�f&� �z�fe� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �fD� �f2! ?��h,� .?�9 ��9 ¶Q7 ,f[ N0 N� �/5] "a� #B;B� , ��Gf,� ¶Qf7 #.fFe� #Bf;Be� P&f, l,w Nx� , Of7

1�§�� ¶Q7 b #B;Be� , S#�f+ª b ¶° Xf� #Bf;Be� �D� U�E� Í Ë2!�± �&[.J , S#�+h,� ¶Q7 b #B;Be� B� .�g� �a��"��F3

�2&9 �7� �� r+¤ ¦D �a�� , 8&�<9�� >59<5,� »&� , 87 u+.5/,� Í,��+#B;B; b ¶Q7 #B;B,� , ¶Q7 b #B;B,�� , �f;�B,� N��± , m�f%J ,

u�Le� #B;B,� P&, ,¶Q7 b #B;B,� B� �a,��3 ·BCfD Í �y�J X� Y�f2Ve� Y��w �f! �;�B,� Y�w h+t/7 �$/[ �� SZ|[ , #Bf;B7 "ª�f&/���

�7 ·�� , �, D b �Dp7 �2� S.���,� SA���� X� , 6 b� , b� O|� , Zfs��H ¥¤ Ë/,� �+h2/,�� P+�/,� �;�� �� l,w± �� F3

n� o�Z�� : �5c&��C��L&z� :FWO��E

n� o#� �Z��'�gD&� a��� G : �5c&��C��L&z� :FWO��−O�u ,WO�Q−OP� ,WOP� ,d�X�&� :W � – O� , C�L���V&�) C�3�fz��o?��&�) +&�g&� ��D%N&� :FW�u� E/?�3�5#& �Z��) :

$���D&� $���%&� :W� −�� ,$#��5&� $���D&� ajKA ��3T :WO�−Ou ,WOQ−�OE

Page 107: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

−©��g�� �G�;��� \��d�� 7��8�� ���� , >5f9<5,� NBf[ �f� (s.f,� f%� �;�B,� NBV7 �B:¤ 8&�<9�� , m�%J ,Z�=��_ =� , Zf� #B;B,� N��±

~_��F�+� �B:¤� =� , �;�B,� N� , m�%J , f6 �, O�%+ b ,b� Of|� ,l,a[ #B;B,� N��±� F , l,a[ �B:¤�± � , �;�B,� Np7± , m�%J ,�, P2; b ,

OC� b� ,l,af[ #B;B,� N��±�OF , ��B/f9� lf,w �f� ��f+.+ ¢ (fk� b0 8J�a,� , .f�Ý, t)2� O[ >&2&!� , ª�f/e� #Bf;B,� �f;�� NBfV+ �f&j7

T�%,� u�Le� #B;B,� B� �Cd�/7 , .�� B� �a,�� Åf�! A�$/!�� Ë�! , w0 Î�%e�� Y�5C,� ~%7 Í ��z�b� , >f&J�w �fD�[ ��Bf9 , >f6A�! �� , b >f&��e�� >�&��� Í ��z�b� �;B+ , Ëf� 8J�af,� `f:0 NBfVJ �f&j7

`.�E� ,S:�� >�&�: tk��3 Í �f� >f+�s Npf7 �a� �! %G,� 1�;� c� ± .�E� ,#B;B,� -�CJ�7 (&�G/,� �.� ! Î�f%e� "aH , �f� Of[ -�CfJ�

�%e� "aH �;�B,�� #B;B,� , Y�af,�7 �f�#��� Th�/Gf+ b �2V, , b �fDE�f|,� OV�,� �� 8/$;Be� �! ��/D���F3 N�/&�fc O?bf,� "af� >�Cf_ w0

n� o�YM. ���k m�n�&� ��U ~ �Z��< < :�5c&�� C��L&z� :FWOPP ,d�X�&� :W Q ,m��D&� �cU :

W� ,���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W � − �P ,���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WO�−OPE

n� oag. �) H& �� � m�n�&� ��U ~ �Z�� :m��D&� �cU :W�O ,���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W ��− �u ,���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WOPE

n  o�a^0 �) H& ��n � m�n�&� ��U ~ �Z� :m��D&� �cU :W � ,���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W ��− �� ,���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :W�PE

n� or��N&� /V.�N. ~ ��DM. H�0 ��)4� �M&� ��9� =S&� �K yx�D&� ~ }�g&� a9c&�< , e�,^&�e�9&�) ,��9&�? H�V.�N. �sVk� Hn�V�� ��f),e�9&� $�#U) , ~ H�V.�N. �sVk�? m��D&�)

$�&�� e�k4�) $�n�. �DK��2� ��9: �>? ��9&� ,�V�A �D& ��9&� ~ ��V.�ND&� �N5:� �#0 , �&7)

Page 108: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{ −

Ï�§�� UBje� Í �/[z�� , Î�f|,� OV�f,� >f�&� Ëf� lf�J� , ��f/D� b�t)2&7��F3<|� O&c B�� =: Ë: �?�[ N�GD�� , Ë: �?�[ 9E�� , N� �/2+ O�±

? 9E� �2&%7 B� N�GD�� !%Lc=�b 3 �.[ �[B[ .�,� O&c B,� , >+.[ �[�BV,� O[� , Bf� .f�,� N� �/2+ O�±

? �[�BV,� �2&%7 ! ,%Lc=�b 3 >f��� �f&: �f� >�7�G,� ¾<|,� O?b,� "a� ! 1�B�� �a� , �f� �f��±

�&: O&C5/,� ,U��&�: ~f_ Zf� #Bf;B,� N� (�Gfe� Zfs �� �D0 ± , �f��Z� #B;B,� NB[ N�&$, �F: �� "�.[w=��_ =� >&D��\,� m0 4c.J b , �)/+�s

>&,; >&!�2/c0 �k� , T�J Zs ��.�/9� ! ��B27,� F , ��J "B±2�=� , �w0 �B,�c ��� �� �D#.;� Z� �, U��+ �� O[ Í �2��pJ Zf� �f, U�f�+ tf! Y�af,�7 Zf� B

�.%,�7 , Bf� Y�af,�7 ZfM� �Df;� ° �f, U�f�+ �� O[ Í l,a[ �2��pJ� #B;B,� , T%,� B� Y�a,�7 Q,�� , �f/+° �Df;� �&� �2��pJ �w0 �Dx� O/�,�[

T%,� �� �2�/+ �� A�$/!�7 ,° P&, �Dx�=�A#�fc N�f[ OJ��,� N0 �&: �� =� �&�! ,N0 �&: �� b�± >f%R�c �D�[ >,g� , UBf/�e� B�! N0 �&: �� b�

<7�c N�[= XL��, , ¦fd�f,� l,w �! S�f&�� U�ª� �D0 �&: �� O7 , Bf��

��9&� ~ ��V.�ND&� �N5:� �7� H�A ,R�V�&�� )A R�V�n�. ���9: �A �.�0 , ��V�� � R�V&�M&� sU G#�)�DL��? ,0 t�X�z� '�2 ~ �.>0���&�I ag. ��^� � H�� :����2 r�0 aU) ����2 ��%�� aU , aU �A�

r�0 ��%�� E��&�I ag. ��^� � H��0 8#%&� '�2 ~ �.A) :�XM? ��%�z� R. �/f � , �/f �)�XM? y���&� R. ,y���? ��%�z� R. �/f � H�A� E

�Z�� :$�Nx�D&� ����N&� ���M: :W����K�-? �.) ,�-& "#%&� ]�f=��X&� "�2�&� � :Wu� �.) �K�-?E

n� o�p�ND&� ��fA :W�OuE

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WO�E

Page 109: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Ë�! &c ,Y�Z� >+#B;B,� #Bf&�,� Ëc�7���F3 �,�|�� , ��+� , #\,� #�G�0� � �° P&, At|�,=� Y�a,�7 , At|,� m0 }�&�,�7 ° B� tD0 ,Í #\,�f� �fJ�w f:

Q7 P&, ,YbtV,� �� Ut[ B� O7 ,° A�] tD0�=� At|,� m0 }�&�,�7 , �� �);�h� G�� �D0 �&: , �H >�?<,� �­bt[ ´B�7 T! �&: �� , f&c B��

Ë�! , #B&�,� >&�7� , #\,� #B;� B�� , At|,�� ,Y�Z�� F3 �B,�c >59<5,� N0 O]����:&��� Í Q,� N0 ± #B;� T! �/ , Utf[ Tf! ��

#Bff;Be , �ff7 uff?b Zffs Tff%,� lff,w N0 �ff&: �ff�± , .@*ff� Zffs �� , N��± A�Qf7 Y�#Bf;B� Ëf� �f&: �f� �G&, Y�#B;Be� , A�° Ëf� tfD0�

�­bt[ Sc�5,� ��&�E� m0 }�&�,�7 , �­��a, b , lf�J m0 >f+#*� �kBV, O7T�!E��OF3

t7 #B;B,� N� u���± #B;� B� –��L� �DB[ �� =� – b� >+Zd7 b �]B+ b >+° , S:B7 �]B+ b t[ , S.|[ b� , Y�&�V,� .?�9 Np� �Dp� , .�� �DE

Ë�! �A�$/!� , >f/$,� �, A.�J b , "#�.f�� Í �fDB[� "A.f�J tfD0� , �af,�� >�je� >+ZM�7 �]B+ , >&$G2,� �� , >�fje� >+Qf,� �� ,>&$Gf2,� �� Ëf�

"#�.�� , �J�&?h; Ë� Ë/,� , >f+Z� NB&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� (Gfc �a� O;E Y��a,� ,%$J=� �­�&��e ,8Gc m03

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WO� ,�Z��) :d�X�&� :W u��K�-? �.) , �5c&�

�C��L&z� :FW����K�-? �.) , C�L���V&�) C�3�fz��o?��&�) +&�g&� ��D%N&� :FW�O� �.) �K�-? ,$�I�cD&� +2��D&� :� W P���K�-? �.) ,m��D&� �cU :W� , G#� }�L5pz� ]�f

���XV&� :��W � �K�-? �.) ,a�#-&� ��5f :W�u E

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W ��E

n  o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W �PE

Page 110: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ة وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظري

− ��� −

U+ ~_ Z� #B;B,� N0 >59<5,� UBc N� #B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� `B!�± ± �2&%7 #B;B,� �;�� B� u�Le� #B;B,� N� ! ,>�je� >+ZM� Í ��5J<, ,

�� 1a[ 8&�<9�� >59<5,� ! ��z� , Y��a,� >+Z� 87 NBc.5+ (� w0 , 8Gc m0 �)/+Z� NBG�+ ()� ,%$J=� Ë;A�fM� �)2&%J� ��#B;B, , h+�f��

>+BI� Í �­��w , u�Le� #Bf;B,� Í �j$,� A�$/!�7 b , #.fµ Bf� �&: �� �Gj� #B;� ,m0 �kBG�+ ()�:−

�−B;B,� �;�� >+Z� # , ~f_ Z� �D� N�.+ �a,� , >f+ZM� uf�L� �f, �)���� �It[� ,>f+Z� �/+Z� �B� P&,�3 �f;�� �fDB[ m0 Xf;.+ �af��

#B;B,� , u�Le� UtV,� �, #B;B,� �;��� , T�f/,� ��)$,�� , �fD�[ Bf, b0� u�Le� U�fV,� >$J.� �! Uh2, >&$GD �/+Z� , #Bf;B,� �;�� NBfV+ <f� ,

��� �a���F3 �− Y�2Ve� >+Z� , �fJ�a7 #Bf;B,� �f;�� `B9 �� O[ B�� , (�f2! ,

"Z�7 #B;B,� �;�� 4/j� , >f&V�5,� }B52,�� UB�%,�[ , ¢�f%,� ÇBf&�� , �­��w Í Y�2V¬ (�2! Ë� l,w Zs� , #B;B,� �;�B7 >$;�� �D�[ N0�

,B;B,� �;�B, >�je� >+ZM� �! >Lj2� >+ZM� Í �)/;A��J�a7 #3 �2&9 �7� U�c: "Z� P&, �J�a7 �Ve�� =��_ =� , �f, �f§ b �fJ�a7 �J�w NE± #B;B,� , T%,� O/� �J�a7 �J�a� , �f� P&f�� �f� �f;B7 T%,� O/:� ���

�+.7 �J�); X&'=� ¦�2,�� Q,� �� ,wxf�=� �f;�B,� b0 ~fje� ZfM� P&, �J�a7 #B;B,�"� F 3

n� o�Z�� :d�X�&� :W Q , �5c&����L&z�C :FWOPP−OP�E

n� o�Z�� :d�X�&� :W Q , �5c&��C��L&z� :FWOP�E

Page 111: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��  −

Y�2Ve� >+Z�� >�_ >+Z� �G&, "a� , T�J t[ , >&$GD �)/+Z� O7 , w0 >+Q7 >7B�� >+Z� Ë� ,�,�s �)&� ZM� �V,3 �fVe� Í �%/;� ��,�

Zf� f%+ b �D� b0 >+ZM� Y�); O[=��f_ =� , >f;A# �f! �f,�h2, lf,w� Y�a,�7 #B;B,� 1B;� ,.�/5� NBV&�=� "Zs m0 ,/D� ! U+ �¬5M� �� >f+Z

�2! >�je�3 �/$,� �&� Z� b �a,� #B;Be� ���� ,° �f�[ NBV+ �&j7=� , "° �f��+ ��Ø

"Z� ! ,+��G� "° NBV+ 4/: ��= Ø� "ZM ,�, #B;� <���F3 Z� #B;B,� NBV7 (Ib/9�7 OC/+ t&� �a�=��_ =� , NBfV7 (Ib/9� ����±

O|� b� �, 6 b #B;B,� ,7 P&�� (I (�G , ��+� ,`B!,� "a�3 − ! AB)�� 2! U��+ �,� Np7 �, 6 b #B;B,� NB[ ! �B,/9� c� ±

.f�i #Bf;Be SBf�,� Í ��Gf� �A�M� Í #B;B�Ò � K ,�f, XD�f¬� F3 �af� f%� �f, 6 b #B;B,�� , �A�fM� Í #Bf;B� �fD� �f&�! �Cf+ b w0± , ��f2/�b

;A�M� #B;B,�7 ���CJ� Ë , �f, NBfV+ �f&[ Ë;A�f� #Bf;� �, �V+ ¢���6�OF3

�Bf6Be� Í .f�i #Bf;Be �A��f� #Bf;Be >f]�M� 2! U��+ �,� N� t[±

n� o�Z�� :$�I�cD&� +2��D&� :� W P�Q−PP�E

n� o3�LDX&� ��� �Y&� ���-: ~ �Z�� : C�L���V&�) C�3�fz��o?��&�) +&�g&� ��D%N&� :FW�u� ,�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �� ,���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W �� Em�^ND&�) 3�LDX&�?

��D#9VD&�E

n  o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W �� ,m��D&� �cU :W�OE

Page 112: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�, �c�%�� K ,�7 .�g� (�+ ¢ �B6Be�7 ��:� T�c �w0 ����F3 �afH #Bf;B,�� �, 6 b A�$/!b� , �B6Be�7 u�%/+ b w0 ,fD�7 TB�/+ b ��_ NE± ± ± � , NE�±

#B;B7 P&, #B;B,� ,�B6Be�7 u�%/+ �&V�� F 3 YbB�%e� X&� �.%+ #B;B,� N� t[± , UBf�%� �f�0 Bf)� UB�%� O[ NE Ë;A�M� #B;B,� �, �.%&� Ë;A�� , #Bf;B,� �, �.%&� Ë2�w UB�%� ��

Ë2�a,��OF 3 (�Gf� Zfs Ub/f9b� �a�� , NBf,B�+ b 8f�V/e� N� lf,w±6Be�7 U�ff�� N�f7 TB�/e� Oje� �D�� �B , N�f&2%� (�f2! N��f,� Of7

:�� O_ Í t)!t/;� O&j/G+��F 3 N�f%/§ b N�+#B;� N�.�� tk� 42%7 f:�� Of_ Í :�� Ni Í , Ng� Pf5D Í �f2! t)!�f5JA� ª�f; N0� , t2f&7

#Bf;B� Zfs .f�� �f, 6 b �DB[ �.� ! #B;B,� , Í uf�j/7 P&f,� �A�M� ,�, 6 b �DB[ �.5+ 4/:3

#Bf;B7 P&f, #B;B,� NB[ A�$/!� ! (?�c Ub/9b� �a� Nwx� , Of;E�, 6 b �D� r] �a�3 A�$/!b� �aH #B;B,� N� ! O&,# �a� Í P&,� ± , ��

#B;� �DB[=���L� =� , �, #B;� b , #B;B,� �;�� B� , �f&,0 �f�w �f� f!B,� S:B7 NB�?��,� #B; , (IBfc 8&�<f9�� >59<5,� T<[ �� �+&5/G�

n� o$p�_&� ��� �Y&� ���-: ~ �Z�� : C�L���V&�) C�3�fz��o?�3�) +&�g&� ��D%N&� :FW�u� ,

�p�ND&� ]�f :��W �� ,���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W �� , G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f���XV&� :WOP E$5�s5&� $p�_&�? m�^ND&�)E

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W �� ,m��D&� �cU ,W�O , G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f���XV&� :WOPE

n  o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W �� ,m��D&� �cU ,W�O , G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f���XV&� :WOPE

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WOPE

Page 113: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

�, 6 b #B;B,� N0±3 �a� (IBc X� >59<5,� w0 , ()2f! �fJB$@ �.� ! , #B;B,� �;�� NB[ ! �BCD c , m�%J ,#B;B�=� Úfd� #B;B7 �J�a7 , "�B9 �� #B;� �! "#B;� Í h&/� , �f2! �+�,� 452� , m�f%J , (�f2! ,

42%7 �fD� , m�f%J , �f%Dt+� SBf�,� Í �+��Gf+ �� b , "�Bf9 �f� Of[ NE± UB�%� , �2! A#�]� �B�² �� , �f;�B,� �$e� ���G+ b UB�%e�� , <f�"#��+��F3

YbBf�%e� Xf&� �.f%+ #Bf;B,� NBV7 Ub/9b� ���� , N� O&j/Gf&�� 6 �, �.%+ ,bBf�%e� Xf&� �.f%+ b 6 �, �� NE± Y , b �f,� w0

.�g� ��, �.%+ , (�G� Zs Ub/9� B)� ,�+�=� , P&, >f��� �fk0 O7N��.7� O&,# �)&�!� F , 6A�! #B;B,� NB[ N� l,w= ±� U+ YbB�%e� X&�

"#�.�E �.%+ Å[ .�� �D� !± , "#�.f�� uf�j/7 NBfV+ ��B)5� u�j/� , b �J�a7 B� �DB[ ,#B;� �DB[ �&: ��=���L� =� , #B;B�=� �.f5&, �A�fM� Í �, 6 b �D� , Í �+#Bf;B� �+.f�� NBf[ >+�,� 42%� u�� Í ��.5e��

:�� ��, N�6.%+ b �A�fM� , :�� O_ Í� , Ng� P5D Í , �f¬ �af��#B;� #.µ B� �&: �� #B;B,� A�$/!� X� �, u�� b3

−���82� 8w� 53 |� b #B;B,� NB[ ! �A��f+ Y�af, U��+ O|e� Np7 �, OÒ ± >�&��� T�� Í "Zs ,�&f� t)2f� UB�%e� NBV+�=�f:�� =� , u$f9 �w0 �f&j7 ��a,� m0 ��:� , .@� O�%,� Í �2� OC:� , .�g� ��� B�� , �2� OCy ¢

U�E� �� O]��� .@E� Zs3 Y�a7 P&, #B;B,� N� TB�%�� ± , �f, O|� <� ,

n� o�Z�� : C�L���V&�) C�3�fz��o?��&�) +&�g&� ��D%N&� :FW�u�E

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WOPE

Page 114: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

Y�a,� w0 T%,� �� #B;B,�7 �C/+ �� ,��:p7 �C/+ b #B;B,����F3 O&,,� �a� N� 8$,� ���± ± �– >�7�G,� >,#E�[ – b #B;B,� NB[ S.V� ! (?�c

�A�M� Í �, u�� , N�&!E� Í �, #B;� b �A�$/!� Å[ .�� �DE , �a� O;E O|� b �D� r] , NB$�af+ NB&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� t2&7, .f� tf[ , NBf[ m0 �;�B,� #B;�– �, O|� b �DB[ X� – Y��a,� .?�9 �! ª�/¬ , "#B;� N��±

, b ¶Q7 #B;B,� m�%J �DB[ X� , �A�M� Í u�j/� , T�f%� .�pf7 P&,�#B;� �DB[ �&: �� #B;B,�[=� , #B;� �DB[ ��=�f��L� =� , ��A 8f7 �.f5�

B� �;�B,� NB[ Í 8&�<9�� >59<5,� b ¶Q7 #B;� , 8�?�f�,� ��A� uf�Le� #B;B,� N� #B;B,� S:B7± , ¶Qf7 b , �A�fM� Í uf�j/� , Bf��

� #B;� ,m�%J3 #B;B,� �;�� N� u���± , m�%J� �D�j$9 , �, O|� b , �, 6 b� , fD b�

�, , 8&�<9�� >59<5,� 2! ,�\f� �DBV,=� S#�fe� �f� , 1Bf;� NBfV,�� �J�a, "#B; , �J�w Í (?�c 42%e �� , Ë;A�f� 4f2%�� >�! �! b , Of;E

:�� Y�a,�7 #B;B,� �;�� N�[ �a�=� , Y�#B;Be� �� "Zs -<d7 , tDx� �<R�� ! S#�e� �! �\7 P&, ��#B;� , 4f2%e P&f, �f�#B;� NBV,�

�)&� (?�c , ��Zs �� O7 ,��Z�, >,B�%� Ë)�3�;�� N�[ �e� �J�a, #B;B,� Bj2,� �a� ! , S#�e� �� �\� , 42%e b �J�a, "#B;�� ,f:�� N�f[=� , tf[

�&,0 SA���� ���J ,:�� N�[ �w0�=� O|� �, �fV+ ¢ ,6 b� ,fD b� , w0S#�� Í b� �B6B� Í Pf&, B�� F3

n� o�Z�� :�`�N-&� ���X: G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W ��− �� ,���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :

WOP – O� ,m��D&� �cU :W�OE

n� o�Z�� :d�X�&� :W Q− O� , �5c&��C��L&z� :FWO�Q−OP�E

Page 115: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

−���82� 8w� 53 �, P2; b #B;B,� NB[ ! , �, OC� <� ,Np7± #B;B,� (&��5e� (!� , P2; �, NBV+ <� l,a[ N�[ ��� , �af,� �Gf2; N�V, b0�

�2� (!� ��B)5� Zs B� , �f, OCf� <f� �, P2; b ��� , Bf� OCf5,� NE ~%$,� �! P2�� #�.�� ~%$, h&e� ,>&�Cf5,� �5/D� >&G2�� �5/D� �wx�3

�&G7 #B;B,�� ,<]� �h; �, P&, ��= , �h;� NE± Thf, S#B;B� �D�[ N0 "� �G5D ! #B;B,� T�J ,�h; �.� �� NB[ ��= � � K� >f�&��� Í �hfF7 P&, �, ,

#Bf;B,� �f, �� B� "Wh; B� �a,� #B;Be� NE l,w� , #Bf;B,� A�f$/!�� >&6.%,�7 �� >&?h��7 ��0 �%� , �hf; #Bf;B,� NBV+ N� Th, >&?h��7 N�[ Nx�

�?h;K , ! #B;B,� T�J Th�&� 8/$J.7 �G5D , N� Thf, >&f6.%,�7 N�[ N0��h; �.� �a,� ��,� NBV+= � � K�6�.%� #B;B�, =�#B;B�, 3

�B�/� ��,� NBV+ N� Th, >��%� ��h;E� �D�[ N0�=� �f%�.+ tf7 , N�f[ N0 >&?h��7 T�%e� X� T%,� A�$/!� ,�B�/� ��=� �f%�.+ t7 �CJ� t7 , \f/!� N0

T�%e� X� T%,��.%,�7 ��F3 �fD� #Bf;B,� �! >&�C5,�� >&G2�� Ë5D ! Ub/9b� �a� Í ¸j�D �jD�±

#B;B,� >R�G7 S.V� ! (?�c , Y�f�B)5e� (!� �DB[ S.V� !� , �f�<[� #B;B,� ¦?�C� �� �D� (�G� Zs± , �+.f�E� <[ ! AB[ae� Ub/9b��

>&D��\,� m0 4c.+ b3� (��B!# N� l,w ± >,�j/9� m0 X;.J #B;B,� >R�G7 N± �f� Npf7 �Bf�2� u7�Gf,� Ub/f9b� Í �.f� �� ! ��h;� �, NBVJ N�± K� �

#B;B�, �.%+ �� Y��B)5e� , #Bf;B,� Pf5D b , >f&�V,�[ , >f&�B)5e�� ,

n� o�Z�� :m��D&� �cU :W � ,���XV&� G#� }�L5pz� ]�f :��W ��− ��E

Page 116: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

>&�B�%e�� , T%,�� ,Y��B)5e� �� l,w Zs m0��F , <|f� U��&�=: #Bf;B,� #B;B,� �;�� TB�%� ,#B;B,� �V¬ TB�%� ��3

�, P2; b #B;B,� N� (��B!# N� t[± ± , �, OC� <� , Y��B)5e� (!� �DBV, , �2� (!� TB)5� <� , �fVe� TBf)5� �f� f:�� O[ Np7 �&�! �z!� c±

T�%,� , TB)5e�� , TB�%e�� , Y�#Bf;B�, >����f,� Y��B)5e� �� ��.?��D�;B,� �� (!� Y��B�%e��#B� F3

��hf;� �f, �fD�[ B, �Dp7 #B;B,� >R�G7 ! (Ib/9� N� t[± ± , �fD�[ Nxf� >&?h��7 ��0 �)%� #B;B,� A�$/!�� "#B;B� , f! #Bf;B,� T�J Th�+ a�2&:�Ò

8/$J.7 �G5D ,�hf; �.f� �af,� ��f,� NBfV+ N� Thf�&� ��.%,�7 ��=� 6�.%� #B;B�,=� #B;B�, ,�%� ��h;E� �D�[ N0�>�; Tf%,� \f/!� Nxf�

�%�.7 ��,� TB�J Th, >&?h��7 , tf7 ��f,� TBf�J Thf, �.%,�f7 \f/!� N0� �%�.7 �CJ� , Y�$[.e� .?�G7 ·B�2� B)� ,<|� U��&�=: �&G7 N�B&�� , w0$[.� N�[ B,=� "Zfs �� N�Bf&: �f�0 "WhfF� , T<fV,� ��Gf+� , af�2&:Ò , m0

".�i�OF , U��+ Np7:; N�[ Nx� D�B&: "Wh=� #B;B� ��0 B)� , T�%� �� , Nx�#B;B� "Wh; N�[=� >f&?h�� A�$/!�7 ��x� , >&f6.%,� A�f$/!�7 �f�0� , �afV��

<&,# "�.[w c �� O|7 T<V,� ��G+=#B;B,� >R�G7 ! 3 L&G7 #B;B,� NBV7 (&�G/,� �.� ! �D0 (@=� , �, P2; <� , �, OC� <� ,

7�G,� Ub/9b� Nx� �� #B;B,� Í .�2,� A�$/!� ! �9�9� �� (?�c �/�.7 u #B;� B� �&: , Y�#B;Be� Í .�2,� A�$/!�7 P&,� , #Bf;B,� N� TBf�%��±

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WP�E

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WP�E

n  o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� /Xf�N&� ]�f :WP�−PuE

Page 117: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��� −

#B;� B� �&: �� ,A�.� �&,0 SA���� ��$9 t[=� , �f, #Bf;B� .�pf7 P&,�A�M� Í NB[3 �f;�� NBf[ f! �f7 #Bf;B,� S:B7 8�?���, u�%/� <�

� #B;B,� u�Le� #B;B,� B , �f;�B,� >R�fG7 NE± , �, P2; b �DB[� , <� �, OC� , 8&�<9�� >f59<f5,� 2! , uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �fDB[ �f7 42%+ b� K , .� �� ! , �7 #�.e� O7 , (�2! , ��h;� �� �J�w �[.J T! , >f&��� b �DE

�, , �, P2; <� �, >&��� b ��� , �, OC� <� ,� �fDBV7 (&�Gf/,� f%7 l,w#B;�=�]�� =� , (�2! ,ª�/¬=� Y�#B;Be� .?�9 �! , ·�M� #B;B,� �aH ,

T%7 P&, B)� , (�2! , #Bf;� Bf� �f&: �f� #B;B,� Í U��� B� t[ ,u�Le� #B;B,�7 �2! \%e�� , ��<[ N0 U��+ 4/:± ,�J�a7 #B;B,� �;�� �� ,

#B;� B� �&: �� #B;B,�� ,G7 �& , tfI P2f; <f� , tfI OCf� <f� , NBV&� , a�2&:Ò , u�Le� #B;B,� ,.�� �DB[ �&: ��=�f+A�$/!� =�&�f! =� , Bf�

�J�a7 #B;B,� �;�� , �! ·�M� "#B;B7 8&�<9�� >59<5,� 2! h&/e�Y�#B;Be� .?�93

>59<5,� T<V7 (&�G/,� �.� ! ��[ �a� , �fDB[ �� , m�f%J ,�\f�=� �f� �[z,� , �%,� �[z,� �� 4/: , OCf5,�� P2f�� �� �[z,� B� �a,� ,

(I (�G� Zs .�E� �a� N� u�� �V,± , f! Thf�+ OR�7� AB�_ >@ P&�� �;�B,� u: Í OC5,�� P2�� �� Å�%,� �[z,� �.� , m�%J , U��+ Np[

#B;B,� �;�� �+.%J Í: "�fJ�a, #B;B�, uj/G� #B;B� B� " , NBfV&�ff$[.� �ff+.%/,�=� Bff�� P2ff; �ff� " #Bff;Be� " , #Bff;B,� �w 4ff2%7 , �� #B;B,�7 �C/e� , T�%e� �.d&� , Bf�� OCf� ���" #Bf;B,� uj/Gfe�

�J�a," , �J�a, P&, "#B;� N�[ �� O[ �.d&� , "Zs �� O7 , #Bff;� B�� Y�f2Ve� ,$;�� �)2� N�f[ �� 4/:=� "Z�7 ,��af+ �f� ! >5f9<5,� �f&,0

Page 118: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{{ −

NB&�<9��3 >f&�&�: ��hf;� �f� Ë;A�M� �[z,� B� �B2e�� AB�je� (%D , Th�/Gfe�

�[.�,� ��&/:<,3 NB&�<f9�� >59<5,� "�/!� t7 #B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� lG� N� N�$� Nw0±

�;�B,� NB[ �� , m�%J , ~_ Z� , �, 6 b �D�� , O|� b� , P2; b� �, , �, OC� <� , OR�7 lG� , ()&�! ��z��� 1a[ B�� , :� ��a+ (��

"#B;� NB[ m0 8&�<9�� >59<5,� �� , m�%J , u�Le� #B;B,� B� , �&[ �fDB[ �f&: �f� ¦?�CfM� lf�/7 #Bf;B,� -�CJ� ! NB,/G+ �+a,��

L&G7=� , �, P2; <� , �, OC� b� , �f, O|� b� �, 6 b �DB[ ���, tfD0 #Bf;� b �DB[ �&: �� ¦?�CM� l�/7 �DB5C+ ,.f�� �fDB[ �f&: �f�=�

+A�$/!�=�&��! =� , �A�fM� Í �, u�� b , #B;B,� �;�� t2&7 , m�%J , u�� �, 8&�<9�� >59<5,� 2! �A�M� Í #B;�� , Bf� (�f2! �;�B,� >�&�j�

·�M� #B;B,� , Y�#B;Be� .?�9 �! ª�/e� , �f� #Bff;B,� �fDB[ �f&: b ¶Q7 , >/$,� �[z,� T! ¶Q7 �� , B� P&, �D� ! NB:�+ (k0 O7

u�Le� #Bf;B,� , ¶Q7 b #B;B,� �� ,�2&9 �7� SA�$! Y.� t[��F3 Sf:B7 8�?�f�,� >D�%/f9� UB: N�[ Y�|:�$�� Ä��D �� T�J �� Nx� %7�±

�CJ� UB: 8&�<9�� >59<5,� T<V7 #B;B,� Î�f%e� ~%$f7 #B;B,� - ,h�A ��B2� Ë/,��=� #B;B,� S:B7 NB�?�c 8&�<9�� >59<5,� N� m0 ()2� ± ,

h�A�=���ae� �a� >j] m0 ()2� 3 f! 4/: "#�G�� l,w N<L7 .)� c� 8&�<9�� >59<5,� ��A , 1af[ Sf:B,�7 NB�?�f�,� ()&f,0 �$GfD �� N��±

n� o W �Z����+M�&� R. E

Page 119: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{� −

r+¤ ,-B�V� ��z��� 3 (@ %G,� N0 , m�%J � ��A , #B;B,� ¦?�C� �� #A�� c , >59<5,� �!

8&�<9�� , Y�#Bf;Be� #f%J f! >f:�¤ U+ �� , P&f, #Bf;B,� N��± :�B7 ,�<�=� S:B,�7 NB�?��,� �!ª �e ,()&,0 "B$GD�3 O?b,� "a� ���

()2ff! %Gff,� �ff)��D Ëff/,� , Í �ff)&,0 SA�ff��� Y.ff� ffc�± � Y�ff|:�$e� �ff+�2@>�7�G,�:−

�− Ë/,� >&��%,� YbBje� �� 8&�<9�� >59<5,� 2! u�Le� #B;B,� N� ±<�! Oje� �! ��W�2�/9� X2/+= , �A�M� �Gj7 �&� �IBC: X2/+�3

�− �.ff%J Ëff/,� >&D�fff|,� YbBff�%e� �ff� (�ff2! uff�Le� #Bff;B,� N� ±m�E� YbB�%�,3

�a� N�[ �w0� (�2! u�Le� #B;B,� U�: , >f&��%,� YbBje� �� �DB[ �� >&D�|,� YbB�%e�� , u�Le� #B;B,� Nx� , uf�L� #Bf;� Bf� �f&: �� , b �A�M� Í �, #B;� , N�&!E� Í �, A.�J b� , NBfV+ "A.f�J� "#Bf;� tfD0�

"#�.�� #B;B7 , +ª #B;B[ , �.!� , .fV7� , }.f5,� #Bf;�� , #Bf;��AE� � , �tG,�� ,l,w Zs�3Y�#B;B,� .|VJ �� a�2&: 7<� �&�!� Ò3  −(G�2+ u�Le� #B;B,� N� ± ,(�2! , #B;B,� �;�� m0 ,#B;B,� �V¬� ,

¾#���� (+�,� m0�3 (�f2! Bf)� , (­�A�f$! r+�f7 , #f%/� , P&f,�:�B73

�− .f|V/+ u�Le� #B;B,� N� ± , (�f2! , Y�ff!B6Be� .f|V/7 >&Cfd�,� , >&!B2,�� , >&G2��� , >/$,� (�2! �&� -<� b �a�� , P&f, f+ª #Bf;B�

�.! #B;B7 , }.5,� #B;B7 P&, ,�AE� #Bf;B7 P&,3 333»f,�3 "af)� >&Cd�,� �­�!B6B7 Sh+t/� Y�#B;B,� ,Sf:�B7 �Gf&,� S.|V/� Ë)�3

Page 120: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{� −

h+t/,� �a[� , ��+� ,>&G2��� >&!B2,� Y�!B6Be�73 �− u�Le� #B;B,� N�± , (�2! , ()2! O�2,� T�J t[ , "#�.f�� f! UB�� ,

Y�#Bf;B,� Ëf� Ë/,� , l&V�f/,� uf+.L7 , �%�f,�� SBf�,� �f&: �f� , >+.�g�� >&,�E�� , �)�!� >+B,�E�� , �f&[ (�f2! �f,�: �a� N�[ ���

:�� NBV+=� ¦d�,�7 , -�f]�E� "aH �]B+ b ¦d�,�7 :�B,� NE±Í :�� Ni ,c#�] �DBV7 �]B+ b B)�=� l&V�/,� u+.L7 b �+Z|[ ! ,

*R�B/,� b� ,��Zs b�3 �− �J�a, #B;B,� �;�� N� ± , 8&�<9�� >59<5,� 2! , #Bf;B, �f$� B�

¢�%,� ,Y�2Ve� B� �a,��3 u�Le� #B;B,� �DB[ Í�2+ �a�� , b Bf� �a,�� �, #B;� , A�$/!� B� O7 Å�! ,.� �� !3

%G,� N0 (@ , m�%J � ��A , UBLe� �CD T�/� ÍØ � , OfL7� �f2! �/��D �a,�f�B! #B;B,� S:� ��a�=� , 8&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� ��A uf+.R �f� b

�Gj� , Å�2,�� Å�%,� .�2,� u+.L7 O7 , �f;�� N� `Bf!# N� .[w �&:± ±L$f, Th�/Gf� u�Le� #B;B,� B� #B;B,� �f;�B,� NBf[ N< , m�f%J , �f$�=

Y�2Ve� #B;B, ,5C/�=� (�%,�7 , SAf�,�� , S#�A��� , S�f&��� , U�f9A0� O9.,� , �/V,� U�hD0� ,>%+Q,� �7 Y#A� �¬ l,w Zs�3

8�?�f�,� ��a� N<L7 ! >,b,�� AB)�,� >+�s Í %G,� �� ¦2,� �a�� #B;B,� S:B7 ,%,� .�2,� N� l,w± XL�+ Å� , �&� �+A b t7 , NBV,� �aI N�±

�,��=� , 5C/�=� Ut[ OV7 ,f�h2��=� ¦f�D Of[ �f! , Y�&�f/�� �f� �fDE± #B;B,� 1B;�� >&�B,E� , S�f&�� >5Cf7 �Cf/� #B;B� B)� , (f�%,�� ,

SA�,�� , S#�A��� , UtfV,� Y�5] �� l,w Zs� , ¦f�D Of[ �f! "hf2�Ò>�i� , T%,�[ , YBe�� , O)��� , hF%,�� , "�.[��� , TBf2,�� , >f�5�,�� ,

Page 121: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{  −

N�&G2,�� , >;���� , U��h,�� ¦�2,� Yt9 �� l,w Zs� , Th�/Gf+ Ë/,��#B;B,� S:� ��a� >jC7 (&�G/,� �.� ! �H ���CJ�3

#B;B,� �;�� Np� B� �a� N�[ �w0�,? u�Le� #B;B,� �a� NBV+ �&V� !, f] �! A�$/!� B� �a,��-.,>f&��%,� YbBfje� �� �DE , YbBf�%e��

Î�B|,�,#B;B,�f7 l,af[ Ëf� �f&: �f� �f]BJ b Ë/,� , Í NBfV,� b� N�&!E�3

<�� Z@p/,�7 T%,� �]B+ �&V�=#Bf;B,� 1Bf;B7 �f]B+ N� �f! , b �aH UB�+ O�! �� >VG� 4D#� �, �� N� ���� � ±3 (&�Gf/,� �.f� f! 4f/:�

B;B,� S:B7 8�?���,N�&!E� Í NB[� A.�J �, u�Le� #B;B,� NB[ #, �fD�� ±¦d�,�7 :��,#B;B,� B� �D�� ±, #.J S9�� >&2+#� >&��! Tª�B, �2)� P&,�

��.,� �a� >j] �.� !3 ff:�� #Bff;B,� N�ff[ �wxff�=�ff%&' �<ff�%,� UBff�+ �wtff� ¦d�ff,�7 =� S.ff|V,

Y�#B;Be�,4��f2/J b #�fVJ Ë/,� ,� uf+.L7 S���fe�� }�Bf�, Ëf� Of� S:��, � #B;� Ë�� ,m�%J ,#B;B,� �;�� , #Bf;� N0 UB�+ Oc�! ���

+ª #B;� B� }.5,�,�.! #B;� B� O&5,� #B;�� , Bf� Y�f$2,� #B;�� N�B&�� #B;�,��fGf,� #Bff;� Bf� �AE� #B;�� , TBffF2,� #Bff;��

Y�Q�� #B;� B� �f[�BV,��333333? »,� !<c�! N� �/!� b= ± �aH UB�+3 #Bf;� S.f|V/e� Y�#Bf;Be�� Y�#B;B,� "a� NBV7 (&�G/,� �.� ! (@=�

:��=�,�;�B,� #B;� B� ,m�%J , S���fe� S.|V,� "a� YA] �&[ U��+ ¦d�,�7 :�� �!,�;�B,� O� ,m�%J ,"W�h;� Y�#B;Be�� O[ �,Å[ �� �,

�J�&?h; Ë��,U�je� Th�+ 86.5,� <[ !� ,0 �DE <f[ N�[ N= � #f%J Thf, #B;B,� �;��,"Zs Ë� Ë/,� �?�h;� �� �[.� OV,� NE ±, �fD� m0 >��f60

Page 122: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

وقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودم

− �{{� −

�?�h;� 87 >5,*e� >�%,� m0 OV,� ��&/:� �2� Th�+, �f;�� ��&/:� �2� Th�&� r;.e�� >�%,� m0 #B;B,�3 #Bf;� #B;B,� �;�B, NBV+ b N� �2� Th�+ t[

�J�w �&: �� O�/G�,;� tD0 Tf%2J� ;BJ Ë/,� �?�h;� Í A.�/� "#B, tf[ ¢�%,� >%&$R Ë�;#�G5,�� NBV,� ¢�! 3

f&�[ N�f[ N0 ����= Ø�>f&��%,� YbBfje� �f� �fDB[ m0 �+f�� #�f! f�� , Î�B|,� YbB�%e��,�A�M� Í �, #B;� b A�$/!b� �aH ÅV,� N� T�J c� ± ± ,

N�B[E� Í �, A.�J b�,� .�� B)� T�%,"#�.�� Í "#B;� tD0� , Ëf� Ëf/,�� NBV,� �a� Í Y�#B;Be� #B;�,Y�#B;Be�� Y�#B;B,� .|VJ �&�! Th�&� ,

�D�&7 .� t[3 � #B;� NBV+ N� Th�+ 86.5,� <[ !�,Bf�! NBe�f�,� UB�+ t! m�%J =�

Z$[=�,NBV,� �a� #B;� �2&%7 B� ,��hf;� �DB[ �&: �� =�fI Y�f&?h; �� Ò �a:�B,� #B;B,�, � B� �� OV� ,m�%J ,>f/$,� �� �f2� B�� <� , NBV,�f� ��&�� � µ,B� B�� ,Zs b 3

Y�#B;Be� S.|V7 >&6��,� O�%,�� P�� S#�)� N0±, �af� 1�f]� ��#f%J� ��ae�– #B;B,� S:� ��a� –O/�� Í ,Zf|V,� NBfV+ �f&V� , �afH�

b �a,� #F/,�� �B2/,�f:�� >f+�k� f: ! �, �cB+ #�V+=�? ! �f¬ �af� >f&D��.7 >f&�! >f7�;0 �2! >7�;��� �%�# �! #B;B,� S:B7 NB�?��,� hF!

>&���, S#�)�,� "a� X�#� >��%e� "a� O� 1�B�� Í �&�! ��Ac �� >+�s – >�7�G,� O�%,�� P�� S#�)� Ë2!�– m0 4/: 4c.J b >7B;� S%7 �B7�;� N� �

.�>+.%�,� O?b,� >$J,>&?�LG�BG,� 8��\,� m0 NBVJ �� 1.c� Ë� O7 3 �G�QS� n"' Pp�A�f$/!� Ë$GfD .f|VJ ���fe� .|V/,� "a� N� ±,�Gfj� ,

¦d�,�7 :�� #B;B,� N� 42%7±, �tGf,� m0 #Bf;B,� �af� �&f6� �wxf�

Page 123: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{� −

#B;B� OC:,.f�i #B;B� OfC: �AE� m0 �&6� �w0� , �&f6� �w0� m0�,�@ #B;B� OC: +ª,Xf7�A #Bf;B� OC: }.5,� m0 �&6� �w0� ,

:�B,� #B;B,� �a� Í .|V/J� Y�#B;Be� OC� �aV��3 ¢ f:�� #B;B,�� Y���6��� �G2,� B� .|VJ �a,� tD0� .|V/+,>f&�! >f+A�$/!� AB�� Ë�� ,

�I #B;� b3:�B,�[ �,�|� ;f7� SA�fJ NBfV+ =��f27� m0 �&f6� �w0 ,�f27�� �w0 �&7� m0 �&6�,&5:� =�"f; m0 �&f6� �w0 ± �,f��� =� �ff&�� m0 �ff&6� �w0

�f/���,=f!� ± ���&�� �7� m0 �&6� �w0 ,33»,�,¦d�,�7 :�� B)� �aV�� , J�w �DB[ �&: ��=�,Y�A�$/!b�7 .|V/� ,Y���f6��� ,Y�A�f$/!b� "af)� , SB2$,�� SB7E� Ë��,S#���� ,S#�5��� 3 33»,� Í >f&�&�: S.f|[ �f;BJ ¢ S:�B,� Y�a,� "a�,:�B,� #B;B,� �aI >$G2,�7 .�E� �a[� 3

�$/[ Í ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� 2! �&;B/,� �a� O|� `.D �jD���F3

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� ~ '�I :"�7� $p�k �� �� m�n) "h �D0 �#.>: � � , �D. m�n�&�? ��p�. aU)

$p�k $�%� �L0 �� e�� ,�K�ZD&� ~ /#XV&� 3�L�� �LN#-V. �D�� $�L&z� dm�3z�) , �K�Z. ~ =A�. ,$�%� �K) ,m�n�&�? �0�p�. '(� "& �K�Z&� ��0< ,1�-&�? �0�p�. '(� "& �LZD&�)< , �L� �7�0

�D92 �LZD&� Gx�A< /V&� y`�NM&� �#: R. �K�Z&� G#� y#x��0 $�%5�&� HN`�N2 8%M? �K�Z&� ~ ���%�� GD%� "92 1)�-D&� �LZD&� �&7 �L�#� �K< � � ,�9#0 )A< ,�9#. )A< , W�_fA R. ��U �.)

C�I�#_D&�,EEE , $�%� �L0 �� e�� m�n�. a90" EC�2�V5&� :��W �Q� E W�^5&� ~ '�I) :"%M&� H`�D�A R.) /#-&� G� ,H:�S& /#-&� �L0 ? �K �� "h �j.) R. G#� , )A

H%5�& ��#-0 ? �K �� �K �.) �7�. R� ,C�m�n�D&� R�� m�n�&� +�2 R. �K) , GD%D&�0���S& $�#-&� /K C�h�M. ,�K �� �%�&) ,$0��� �#� � /#-&� �L0 , 1�-&� �L& /V&� ����4� �4�

� R. $M`�3 �Df �. H�0 $V?�g&�� �m�n�& ,C�m�n�D&� ~ 3�^&� m��-: o. �L&�2 G#� /L0 , R�-&�){�DXD&� ~ {�DXD&� R. d�2�) ,��D�4� ~ d�g9&� m�n�0 ,8%�&� /K) ,$�.�� 3�.A /K) , C�S&� �K =S&� R�-&� �� ��&)" E"9M&� W�^0 :W�� E

Page 124: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{� −

%G,� ()2! ���D �� �a��,".[w u7�G,� ¦2,� Í U�c t2&: ��F: " #A�� 8:� ()&�!– S:B,�7 NB�?��,� �� –e� #B;B,� N� ± Í �, u�� b Å[ TB)5� u�L�A�M�,4��2/J #�VJ b SZ|[ #�.�� �,� ,f:�� #B;B� �;�B,�� , .f|VJ b �&�,�Gf5D Bf� #Bf;B7 #Bf;B� Úd� :�� �Dp7 �B7�;� , Í .f|V/,� tfD0�

Y���6�� >L9�B$� Y�#B;Be�,�­�#B;� .|VJ >L9�B7 b , �GfD �w0 �fDx� #B;B� OC: N�fGD�� m0, m0� .�i #B;B� }.5,�,�aV�� , �af� !�

�2,Bc 42%�:#B;� �D� #B;B� �;�B,� , �� }.5,� �� N�GD�� �2,Bc 42%�� #B;� �w �D� #B;B� "Zs , �;�B,� m0 >$GD �, N� 42%7±" 3

Y�#Bf;Be� .|V/, �&;B/,� �a� ! %G,� u�! c�± �, 8�?�f�,� �b*f� f2! S:B,�7,! ()2� ª�z:� �Dp7 #Bf;B,� �f;�� Ë527 r+�/,� >!�2� �, Of7 �DB[ �!,m�%J ,�� O[ #B;� ,Y�A�w�f�,� #Bf;� 4f/: 3 �f! � m�f%J B�! l,w=�Z$[ =�3

uf: #Bf;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� %G,� Th,� �a,� �a��K, Ëf5D �f2� Thf�+ �fDx� "#B;�,m�%J ,f&�[ 4f2%� �fDB[ A�$/!�7 =�f�B)5�� =�f��L� =� Í �f, #Bf;� b �M��A,�;�B,� NBV+ N� �2� Th�+ t[ ,m�%J ,�� O[ #B;� , Of[ 8f!�

>�&�:,f:�� �fDB[ A�f$/!�7 =�&Cfd� =�, �Gf2,� Í .f|V/,� NBf[ A�f$/!�7� Y���6���3

�G�QS� n"' ��~_ U�&� B� tD0� Xc�B,� Í �, >�&�: b .|V/,� �a� N� ±, ,w -<� ! �A�M� Í .�E� �V, }�B�� �7 u�%/J��� l=�, �a� 1�j]p�

�Z��) :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W �� ,�OW � ,WP P ,WP�� ,��W Q� ,

WO P,"9M&� W�^0 :W� � ,W �QE

n� o W �Z�� Q+M�&� R. E

Page 125: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{� −

Í >f�&de� SBfc #.fµ m0 Xf;.+ ¢�f%,� Í Y�#Bf;Be� .f|VJ N� N�.+ ��.,�±N�GD��,��#B;B, N�!w��� (&�G/,� �$9 Ë� Ë/,�� 3 Í X;.+ ��.,� �a��

u7�G,� ��.,� m0 �/�&�:, .f|VJ #.fµ Bf� Y�#Bf;Be� .f|VJ N� `.f+ �a,� ±Zs b Y���6��� �G2,�3[ tD0� f:�� �� 8+�.f,� >�C_ N�, �f� NE � ±

Y���f60� �GD S.|[ Ë� tD0 ¢�%,� �a� Í S.|V,� "a� N� `.+, N� TBf�%�� ±�I #B;� b >&�! >&��! Y�A�$/!� Y���6��� �G2,� "a�, "af� Np7 Èc ±

>�&d/� >�B/� S.|[ S.|V,�,>&�&�j7 �G&, ,U�&M� X2] �� Ë� tD0 3 �&,0 ��w �� �a��ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� ,��+� ,S.f|V,� "af� >f�&�� ��&�� Í ,

T����� Yb�&� #.µ �)�%F�,>�&��� ! �I #B;� b , Í ¥¤ �fD0 4f/: ± �N�GD�� Í >�&d/e� SB�,� ¥7 �]BCD ~%7, "af� �/f2J �fkB[ �&: ��

>F&/2,� ,u?���� ()&5D Í >&?�LG�BG,� ��a� ! 42@�� ¥� �D0 O7,�2V, ��� S:�� >�&�: �$@� �D� Í ()5,����F3

n� oR�K��&� {���4 H5p) ~ /?�� R?� '�I :" �3��Vk� �.A) – G&�-: �� =A – R. $�m�n�&� R�K��&�

yM&� C��g? "#-&� 1�D: R. H�x-: �D#0 �K��;) $�&�X&� R�K��&� ,"^_&� $X2 '�x?�) , R�K��&�)� �SK �L& �%�& $�&�X&�d�N& ,"j^_&� $X2 ax�: ���0 ,�N2 ��g: � �I)< , $�`�x%0�%&� R�K��&�)

d��2 �V�: , $�&�X&� R�K��&� R. Hn) R. /L&z� "#-&� ~ $�m�n�&� R�K��&� G&� t�IA /K)" E$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W ��� E

�kT o��. ~ '�I) :"$#�_V. /K �D�� $��%M. $N�N2 H�Z� ��U =S&� �� � � , �.4�) R�-&� =A3 �K���R�-&� ��Lc: �. �sk G#� H%5� ~ ,$���2)�&�) $���D%X&� e�N&� o�Dn ~ 3�� �SK)B E H#U "&�-&�0

$?�^�. ag. 3�p ~ , $�m�n�&� d�YM&�0– �K�cD&� =m�n�&� �g9V&� /?�� R?� H? /�-�) – �D�� '��_&� d�Y2 /K ,�_V.) r�%M. G&� 3�^&� R. ���: �. "%N: "ha ,a�_V. a9&�) E � �SK)

�LcD&� �SK �LfA R. �� H? a`�I EH? /.�� ��%#�5&�0 ,H? ��.�� "L#U '�N-&� $&mA t�MpA) ,H? ��&�N� � �K�Z&� aKA) ,3�^&� �SK H& C��n /V&� }�-D&�? �) "-� , �LcD&� �SK R. t�N� �)

Page 126: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{� −

�_G�QS� n"' ��Zfs b }�Bf�� ��*�f2� S.f|V,� "af� N� ±, >f�&��� Í� �A�M� Í S.|V/� Y�#B;B�� u?��: ��2� P&, Xc�B,��3

�A�M� Í Y�#B;Be� ��%D� ��%D�� }�B�� �,�ª �w0 �D� 42%7±3 fc� fe� �7� �! ��ae� �a� O|� T�J#Bf;B,� Sf:B7 8�?�f�,� �f� S�., �f&: �&� N��� �7� T<[ ��2� Y#A��, �f� S.f|V,� N� `.f+ �fD� �2! O�D �&: ±

(�B,� O&$c,�Q$,� �Ae� #B;B7 ¶�Q� ��#B;� N�� ±, �Ae� 45/D� �wx� #B;B�, O&]�5J ��2� �V+ ¢ >�' �Q$,���F3

�G�QS� n"' ��>f/$,� S.|[ >@ P&, �D� ±,� S.f|[ �f� #Bf;B,� Í `.f+ �f�Kc<R� S.|V7 �G&,=�,.|VJ O[ �! S#.µ >��L� S:� Ë� O7 , .f|V/,� 4f/: Í�6�� �A�$/!b�,Ë�f! .f�� >f�&��� Í Bf� �af,�� 3 �af� 1�jf]p� NB%2+ ��ae�,<]� =,#Bf;B,� Í .|VJ #B;� ,<�f� = �fH uf�%/J N� �f!

}�B��,/,�� (�B/,� u+.R ! N�[ B, 4/: O&d3 m0 ��afe� �a� �G2+�

$�`�x%0�%&� �� , ��&�N� "�A "L��?) ����? ��5&� �A ��;�H& $N�N2 � H#U �SK ��� , '�N� � RM�)�&S? , $N�N2 H�� '�N� a?" E$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW P P E

�� "�� ~ '�I) ,G&�-: ,R�VD&� =�N&� :"R�VD&� =�N&� EC��9DD&� q-? ~ �D& d�N&� )7 �K , )A�N#x. �L�0< ,d(-&� R. ,m����& '��N&� 1�� /K) ,� "&�� y#k d�N&� R. ��90'��_& , H�0 �LZ�&

m���4� R�? oDX&� ,R��Y&� R�? ojDX&� �DK��� o�VD� aN-&�) �M&� �4 , o�VD� � '��_&�)�&7 ���� ,$#�_VD&� d�N&� y#k ~ �� H:�I �) =�N&� ��x#� �L� �D0 ,'��_&� "&��) , t�IA H��0

yM&� G#� $&��&� ~ ,R���&�) �K�Z&�) �kl�) ')4� �K yM&� ��0 E�I "? b��_&� ��-� /?4 aR��Y&� R�? H-DX? '�I ? �� �0�� ,$�l� �SK G#: "h ,d�2�) R�� R. R9: "& ��) , �L�0 �D0 ��)

d�`�0 ,�9�: � 8%�&� ��0� ,H�%� �g9: �I �2��&� �_c&� ��0� ,��k) �D�) ��?�) < �?A ��9�0< < < � , '�jg.A)�&7 ,���; � �K �K) ,� G#� d3�^&� b�2 �D0 '��_&� �� $N�NM&" E$�9D&� C�j2�V5&� :�� WO P E�Z��) :"9M&� W�^0 :W�u�−�u E

n� o W �Z�� P+M�&� R. E

Page 127: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{{� −

8%$9 �7���F3,�2! O�2,� T�J t[ 3 S:B,�7 8�?��,� ��Ai -</�� N� u���±,T�J �� O|7 ,�ABf] -</f�� ,

Ê�5,E� #.µ Í�,%&' ()?�Ai OC_ Nx� b0� = ± � K ± ±�S���e� S.|V,� Ë527 UB�,� , #B;B,� S:B7 (&�G/,��3� >+�s NBC+.: (� �aI S.f|V,� Ëf5D ! ·.�

S:�� >�&�: b0 �A�M� Í u?���� YB$@ Ë527 >&;A�M�, #Bf;B,� Ë�� b� :�B,�3>5��Ve� `B!# `B9 �&�! O&,# �� (I P&,� 3

f?��%,� �f:�$� Í .f�2,� Af] >2Gf,� O�� >?� ~%7 N� FD �a� O;E± � ±b�� u?���� Y�$@0 Í .�2,�=, �f­B$@ .+�J ! w0 Í �fj$,�� .f�2,� �fV+

>+#��/!b� O?�Ge� Ëc�7,�)&� .�2,� O&j/G+ �)?�5/D�7� 3 Ë5G2,� T���� �b*� ���,�J&�! Í U�c �&: : " u?�f�: uf�� Of�� U�c

>/7�@ ��&�E�,�<� u�j/� �H (�%,�� =� >&?�LG�BG�, " 3 �&�! �:° Í %G,� U�c: "��&�E� u?��: "�/%D �� N0 ±,GD� �tf9E�7 �&

N�GffD�� �ff�,}.ff5,�� ,�tGff,�� ,�AE�� , Pff5D Í S#Bff;B� ABff�� .�E�"� F3

��ff&�E� Y��w ��B/f9�7 #Bff;B,� Sff:B7 8�?�f�,� �f! %Gf,� O�D �,�)�?��: Í (�2!,�Gfj� Sf:�� >f�&�: �fkB[ �&: �� , #Bf;� Ëf� #Bff;B,� �ff;��, � Bff� �� Off[ NBffV+ �ff&�!� ,m�ff%J , #Bff;� 4ff/:

�Y�A�w��,,�;�B,� NBV+ N� �2� Th�+ O7 ,m�f%J , �f]� OffV7 �Cf/� Of%��,=2G: �=fj&$c �� N�[ �,.f&� =�° �� N�[ =�3

n� oH&�I $�D�: R?� H�� aN� :�&�. t3¬ � ,�&�K ���)6 ! � ,�&7 "V�A) ,�N0 �� , "K) d�g9&�)"

�Z�� :a`�%D&�) a`���&� $��DX. :��W Q� ,$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W u�E

n� o�Z�� :$�5%�&� �`�N-&� ]�f :W�O−��E

Page 128: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�{ −

X6B� �� .|[� Í ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� �7 ¥¤ c �� �a��± �3 �,Bc Y�:B/5,� Í .[w ��: " O6�5J b �+° ".�B; �&: �� ��[ ¢�%,�

�&�,� O�%,�� S#�,� N0� ±.�Bf�� O�f� Í ��BG,� ! U�E, Y.f)� �f�� ABC,� Í b0 >�6�5e�,�fJ�.e� T�fV:� Ë�� ,-°�� �+Qf� , X&f6��

X6���"��F3.�i X6B� Í U�c� : ">$f9�2e� Í >�f6�5e� �%c� tD0 , Í b N�&!E�,N�&!E� Í >�6�5� b �DE ,&G,�� $%,� 87 P&, �DE , 1.f,� b� 1B7.e��,b� >�6�5� �B�de�� u,�M� "� F3

U�c�,��+� : " #B;B,� , �fH 4Ge� tD0 �D�[ >5] >+� �� �7 �]B+ ��� � B�3 � b0 �#Bf;� 4G� (@ �� �D� ()��� ± ± �,(f9� OfV7 4Gfe� Bf)� ±,

>5] OV7 -B]Be��� �%D OV7 YB%2e��"�OF3 U�c�: " �D0 – m�%J �;�B,� �� –2� O[ 8! �� #B;� �� (V: OV7 YB%T!,U�_� N�V�0� 1B;�� , lf,w Bf�� b0 (fVj7 �f]BJ 8f! (@ t� ± � 8%,�"��F3

(V�� ·BC� Í U�c�: " �af,� UtfV,� �f, NBfV+ �af,� B� �G52, Å%,� >f&�%,� �Gf2,�� >f+#B;B,� AB�E� X&' �7 �.�/G+, N� �fV+ b �f&j7

�)2� �%D �JB5+,.! S#B_ �D�[ ��B9 �=�<�!� =!°� =�,f�.! >f�B�a� �� =� <�!�=!°� =�, � 4Ge b0 l,w P&,� ± Ø,m�%J , >]�� "�PF3

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW �P E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW �Q E

n  o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W P�E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW ���E

n� o"9M&� W�^0 :W�QE

Page 129: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين

− �{�� −

t/:�=#B;B,� S:B7 UB�,� ! Tªb .�� �a� ,#��/!b� �a� �� ·�2� <� 3 �Z$[ �B�! NBe��,� UB�+ t! � m�%J 3

%G,� .[w �� %7�,��f+� , ��afe� �af� N� ±–��af� #Bf;B,� Sf:� , O9.,� U�9A0 N<L$, Th�/G�;:�� #B;B,� NB[ �.� X� w0 =�, (@ �� �D�� ± �

S:�� >�&�: b0,�;�B,� >�&�: Ë� ,m�%J , ? O9.,� U�9A0 Í S?�5,� t� f:�� #B;Be�� #B;B,�� ? (I�9A0 NBV&9 �e�, >,�f9.,� rCfJ �f&[�

S:�� 8! �� �&,0 O9.e�� UB9.,��,' (�� %&=�? �&,�µ� u�� Y�2&%J ! �/V,� U�hD0 Í U��� �a[�,? Uh�2J �e ± K !? Uh�2J �� !�± K � ! �f)&� �� S?�� ���

� B� OV,� N�[ �w0 (&,�%J� X?�° ��,? m�%J ! .f���E� �&;BJ NBV+ �e�Ë��B2,��,���)2+� �G5D :�B,� .�p+ N� O�%+� ,��!B/+� ��%+� , �)�B��

.+��)&;, �f�Ve�� �fJ?�� �f�� ? �f&�V/,� NBV+ �e� ? �)$�.+� �)$s.+� Ð? ��Ve� 8!± !Ï.! �7� U�c t[:−

ufff: fff$%,�� ufff: 1.fff,�K � × ? �ff�Ve� �ff� �.%ff� �ff&, �ff+± �fff&� ��afff� fff$! �fff�c N0� � � � �

�fff�V+ 4fffD� 1A �fff�c ��± Þ ���F3

>�&��� "aH Ï.! �7� ¥¤ c� ± �, NB[ �� ��Ve� B� ��Ve�± Ð, U�fc �f&: u�� �!,�D�j$9 : "��Ve� B)� Ð� ��Ve�±,U�fc �DE : .f�E� Xf;.+ �f&,0�

��[,Y�#B;Be� 8! B)� , #B;B,� B� w0 "� F3 U��+ (@,�f�+� ,? Ta,�� ¥fe� S?�f� �� ! ff!B,� S?�� ��� ? N�DBV+ �e�

? #Bf!Be� �f�� f!B/e� ��� ? &!B,��� �± ? 1�f�%,�� 1�Bf|,� Sf?�� �f��

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W ���E

Page 130: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

Y�B�E� �%7 S?�� ��� ? ��h��� 1�G���, >ff2�� #Bf;B, >;�ff�� �f�� 8f%,� �D�ff[ �w0 �f&,0 >;�ff��� �f�[ �af� S?�� t� ? �/��� �e� ? A�f2,��

S:��,:�� #Bf;B,� N�[� =�3 >&!Q,� Tª�B�,� "a� N� Í l� b±, Tª�Bf, �f� Tf�J �f� m0 >��60 >f&��!,

9�A ��ae� �a� OL$J=�,U<jDb�� #�G5,�7 �&�! (V�� 3 Í ��ae� �a� ! >$Jz� >�R�7 >&!°� >&��! Tª�B, �� %G,� "#A�� �� N0±

>&D��\,�� AB)�,� >+�s,�a� �� .|[� N�&7� Ub/9� m0 ��/� b 3 A�)�0 Nx� ±`f, -�f[ S9�� Tª�B, �� �52/V+ ��� ��ae� >�&�: (&�Gf/,� Í �<f�%,�

�D<L$73 �D N�[ T�J t� %7�=�#B;B,� S:� UB: Î�ª�/5/,� �+,� %9 ·BC2, 3

�����: !/!� �8� G&M� J!8 =��/�T 6��D� [!-� �� �+Q,� &G,� N� ¸j�D �jD,m�%J � ��A , ·BCf2,� lf�J U<f� �f�

B,� S:B7 UB�,� m0 ��a+ �2! �)/��D Ë/,�>f:�¤ #B;, �f/V+ ¢ �fD0 Of7 :�� #B;B,� N0 UB�,�7, �f� Ô�� �f� Of[ t7 �&�! Ub/9b� m0 ��w O7

O?b#� �F: 3 m0 �f$/[ ~f%7 �� X6�Be� ~%7 Í 45/[� c Î�;.�� �+Q,� N�[ ��,�

Of�%,� ABfR �Bf� ��afe� �af� N� m0 SA�f��� #.µ±, f! �f:° Í tf[ �c�Be� ,B,� �:�$� Í>��%,� AB�E� �� #B;, �f|+: f2! ��2� U�c �&:

�Ve�� �;�B,� Í >&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+h7 8�?��,� >,#� �!: " u?��: N0 ±SA�À,�7 >5,�d/� Y�#B;Be�3Sf:�� Y�w OV,� N� �� U��+ ��� ±, #f%/J

Zs b -�]�E� �Gj7, �f5/�+ b S.7�V� �D�%+ O�%,� ABL7 N�&�/e��

Page 131: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�  −

&,0 �)"��F3 Y�&I�� �:�$� Í `.�� S.� �&,0 A����,�fJ�w >f5,�² �f! T<fV,� f2! ,

m�%J,Y��a,� .?�G, , �� ˧�� �%,� �c�Be� �:�] OL7� ��2! l,w� � Y�w N0 (IBc �� �tV�� ~%7 �! O�D,m�%J , 87 �z�e� #B;B,� B�

Y�#B;Be� X&',Ë$�9 &�7 "Zs �! ª�/+� ,B�� f?�ª P&f, "#Bf;� N� = ±� �&�!, Npf7 ��.,� �aI ˧�� �%,� �d&� U�L70 ! �+Q,� &G,� ��%�

�f;�B,� >�&�: NB[ �� �2� Th�+ �e .��� ��ae� �a� N<L7,m�f%J ,.f�� =� L,�²=�Y�2Ve� X&� ,Y�A�w��,� 4/: 3O&j/G� �D�� � F3

�,�@ X6B� Í �&,0 A��� t[,I�� �:�$� Í Y�&, Ëf5D �f! �+f�� f2! � ! #��b�� UB���,m�%J , �fc�Be� �/f� Í �f%,� �d&f� .[w ��2!

.%�f+ l,w N0 UB�+� ".V2+� #��b�� UB��� Ë52+ �¬ >&�BC,� ~%7 UBc #B;B,� S:B7 UB�+ �� >+Z�,�7– �af� N0 U�c� ˧�� �%,� l,w .VDp� ±

Th�� �� �� Aa%,� ,u�%�± � ��,B�7 �+Q,� &G,� �&�! : " f�� Aaf%,� �a�� j$c=�D<L7� =� Th�� l,w �� – #�f�b�� UB���7 Th�� �� – lf�J Thf�+ w0

Oc�! �H UB�,� ! ¡z§ b Ë/,� >L,�de�, h&&� 4D#� h&¬ b� "�OF3 �+Q,� &G,� N�[ ��, UBc�,m�%J � ��A , lf�J ��ae� �a� m0 A��� c

��>�Fe� >%+¯,� Y�A��,�f, ��f�A ! UJ Ë/,�� , Í ��f; �f� >f]�� �+Z�E� 8C2,�, f! �/&f��: �� >�C5e�� >,BLe� ·BC2,� l�J N� b0 ±

Sf:� ��af7 �&�GfJ� "�f6A f! >jf6�� >f,b# UJ +.F/,� ¥°

n� o�D&� ]�f�I� :� W ��uE

n� o�I��D&� ]�f :� W �uE

n  o�I��D&� ]�f :�uW O�E

Page 132: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

#B;B,�,>!�.7� (�! �� Ô�� �� OV7 �&�! Ub/9b�� �2! �!��# O7 3 D� ��� ¥° f! �/&f��: �f� ·BCf2,� lf�J Í �f�<[ f�D� N� U��:� �+.F/,�,.�E� .�i ��c �&�! .�/9� t&� T<V,� u&�� m0 4%9� (@ ��� ± �3

O?�G� S! ¾<|,� �+Q,� &G,� ·BCD �2�J �,,Ë�� : �− ��afe� �af� �GD �D�– #Bf;B,� Sf:� Ëf2!� – �f� >f!�' m0

>&�BC,�3 �− � ()2! O�D �D� >f/$,� �f)&� �f[.J b S:�� �J�w #B;B,� NBV7 UB�,

�)2&! Ë� Y�5] �I Y�a,� "a� N��±3  − #B;B,� �;�� :�B,� #B;B,� �a� N�±,Úfd� :�� B�� , "hf2�

N�V��� Yt9� T%,� �?�B� �! 3 �− :�B,� #B;B,� �a� N�±, Y�f&&�J� �GfD �fI Sf:�B,� Y�af,� ��

�#B;Be� m0 >]BC² >+A�$/!�Y,`Bf9� A�&s� ��.��� Í Ë� Ë/,�� , .|V/� l,w �$G7 #B;B,� `��z&�=�#%/� =�,U�&�� (�� #.µ �D� X� 3

�− >f,B)µ Sf:�B,� Y�a,� "aI >+A�$/!b� Y�&&�/,�� �G2,� "a� N�±�ff)&�! �<ffRb� Aaff%/+� >ff&5&V,�, .?�Cff$,� Bff,�� b0 �)[Aff+ b�

>&,�! >$c�@ >2L57 NB]BCde� 3 �− a� N�± b >�&�: Y�#B;Be� .|V/7 Ñ��,� O�%,� ABR �B� ��ae� �

A�$/!b�7,Uh%� Í Å�%,� O&,,�� , m0 "�2f9 � tfD0 �f&,0 8$��a,� N�� Y����e�� Y�5��Ve� #.µ3

�− #B;B,� S:� ��a� >j] ! Å�%,� O&,,�7 �,b/9�, ��f; t[ SAB[ae� >&���� �� Z�E� ¦2,� Í,�,Bc B�� : " .+�f�� TBf)5� Of[

#B;B�,,3 3333 »,�"Ub/9b� �a� >�c�2� Ôp/9� 3

Page 133: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�− S:�� �kB[ X� Y�#B;Be� S.|[ �&$�J, SABf] Í "AB)�� .j$,�7 S.|V/e� ��B�E�,S:�� >�&�: b0 ��2� P&, �D� X� ±,.j$,� >�&�: Ë� 3

m�S� ���N��G 7T2! 5�p ����>!�' m0 ��ae� �a� >$GD �� >&�BCf,� �f� AB)��� r&j] .�� �a)�,()2! ~&5/G� O�2,�� ,�7�9 Y.[w t[ =� >f5?�R

T<9�� m0 �G/2+ �¬ ()2�,ÍBCf,� Ï.f! �7�f[ ,Î�Gf�/,� �f&5%,�� , �BDB�,��,(�Zs� 3�2V, , � ��A ,m�%J , m0 ��afe� �af� #�2f90 Of5s�

>59<5,� ~%7,�+� =�,T<9�� m0 NB$G/2+ �¬ ,[ 8%$9 �7�,���# �7�� , Óc �7��,(�Zs� , >5f9<5,� �f� Xf' �f&,0 A�f] fc ��ae� �a� N0 O7 N�DB&,�,()�%7 �! O�2,� T�J t[ 3

&G,� SA�$%�,m�%J � ��A ,>�&c# Zs �2)� ,%Gf,� SA�f$! t2&7 , � �f�A m�ff%J,U�ffc t2ff&: �#� : " >5Gff�5/e� �ff� Xff' 8ff7 t&ff� .)/ff�� ffc

��>�BC/e33338/); �� »,�; ���� >5Gf�5/e� m0 ��afe� �af� �GfD �fDE>�BC/e� m0 >��603

�#�H���>�BCf/e�� >5Gf�5/e�7 ()5f]� �DE ,>&�BCf,�� >5f9<5,�7 P&f,� , .��� �+Z$%/,� 87 �.5,��, Í ()��fc� ÃBf9A Tf! m0 %G,� �� SA��0 -BC/,�� >5G�5,� Ë�!,)&�! �<�# (k�� t, Ö5+ �� ()2� A] �e b0�

UB�2e� r&j]� UB�%e� r+�, ~c�2e� ��ae� �a� O|7 UB�,� m0 3 � >&�BCf,� f2! ��afe� �afH UBf�,� A�)/�� �+Q,� &G,� +.+ N� b0�

()$/[,T<9�� m0 ()2� 8$G/2e� >]�� , f! �f�<V7 8f&2%e� (f� (k�� ·BCM� �;�,� Í ()/�,�$e ��&�3

�_�#�d�� ���N_P� �/N���G� ~%$f, �+Qf,� &Gf,� #�2f9� >,pGf� Ëf�� b� J�w #B;B,� NBV7 UB�,� >&�BC,�=�.|VJ b� >/$,� �)&� �[.J b S:�� , �fI�

Page 134: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�]� u: UBc B)� �)2&! Ë� Y�5],()/?� ~%7 �! O�2,� T�J c� , ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� >]��,Bf;B,� NBf[ �f� >:�¤ l,w &5+ �� f:�� #=�, Ë�&�: .|VJ �&� P&,,~_ �A�$/!� �&� .|V/,� tD0 , �af� S:� Í ¥�+ b

>/$,� #B;B,�, Y�5f] �f� f:�B,� #Bf;B,� �af� �f&�! O/f�� �� O[ N�� ±+� Yt9�=��D�[ ,>j&$c �� >2G: ��B9 ,>&$�9 �� >+#B;� ,l,w Zs �� , tD0

:�B,� #B;B,� �a� Yt9� Y�5] Ë�3 D �� �a[� #Bf;B,� �af� NB[ (��B!# �� ()2! ���– uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �� – :��=�¦d�,�7 ,#B;B,� �;�� B�� , �� �\� "#B;� 1B;� O;E B��

N�V��� Yt9� T%,� �?�B�, �;� �� N�V���� T%,�7 �]B+ �&[� �Í ��; t[ �a�� "#B;��d��d�� ���N�� �

��G�;�� ���N�� ���0 &G,� "29� �� B�� #B;B,� �a� NB[ m0 (H��w �� ()&, `.f+ �f)$� S���fe� Y�#Bf;Be� m0 �GfD� Y�&&�J �, ¦d�,�7 :�B,�K

.|V/� #B;B,�=�,#%/� .)�+� =�,=2+�$/� �$+� �5�/² =�, Npf7 )�J >�&��� �V, >/$,� .|VJ b,U�&�� (�� B� tD0� ,�a)� ,�+� =�,�f]� uf: , UBfc Bf��

?��,� >&�BC,� .|[���ae� �aH 8�, Sf:B,�7 O?��,� ��ae�7 �2! \%e� B�� �Gf2,�� Y�A�$/!b�7 >Cd�e�,ÍBCf,� Ï.f! �f7� �f&�! tf[ , ACf,��

�BDB�,� ,��Zs� , 4/: >Cd�e� Zs >��Le� S:B,�7 UB�+ �� ��2� �V,�G2,�� Y�A�$/!b�7,-BG�&5,� 8%$9 �7� �&�! t[ , -BCfJ �C+ N�[�

7 Ï.! �7�>F® >5G�� �kp� �3 >&?h�� "a� �! �+�� 2! �2! O�2,� T�J t[ �)%6B� Í3

>f$��a,� >&�BCf,� �� >�5,� l�J �! �+�� #C7 �2� �+Q,� &G,� �V,U�E� ��.,� m0,�Gf2,�� Y�A�$/!b�7 >Cd�e� S:B,�7 8�?��,� , NBfV,

Page 135: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

.)�� UB�%,� >,b, .�g� ��.,� >�#�C�,b/9b�� �&�! U, O?b,�7 B,� >&7�LM�,>&5�V,� Y����e�� ,¯!� 3

�N_��g� ���N_��G 7T2! 5�p ���� Y�f&&�/,�� �Gf2,� "af� N0 �f,Bc Ëf�� ±�f)&�! �<Rb� Aa%/+� >&5&V,� >,B)µ S:�B,� Y�a,� "aI >+A�$/!b�, Ëf)�

�/&,B�%�� ��ae� "a� >j] Í ¥#�B�,� :� uj7 %J× K�,:�� w0 .�� ! >,���ae� �aH >,�)�� ¾ABJ UB)µ,>,�)��� ,�f+� =�, �af,� Åf�%,� O&,f,�7

&G,� �c�9,m�%J � ��A ,�&�! �7 Ub/9<, ,�/�fc�2� Ôp/9 �� ! 3 N0� #Bf;B,� Í �f�� Sf:�� Y�af, 4D� O?�G/&, Oc�%,�±, ¦d�f/7 >Cfd�/�

Ë?h;– #Bf;B,� �7 Ë2!�� –?�f�: m0 �/��f6x7 Í �fI #Bf;� b `.f�� uY�#B;B�� Y��w �)2� OCj/+ Xc�B,� , �f]BJ b� >f+#B;Be�7 �f]BJ

#B;B,�7,>��6�� "a� >�&�: t� ,u�%/,� �a� >�&�: ��� , �f��� �w0 Of�� #B;B� OC: +ª m0 �/��60 #.µ,.f�i #Bf;B� OCf: �.! m0� , m0�

·BCfde� }.f5,� B� #B;B� OC: ·BC² }.� , }.f� m0�.f�i, .f�i ·BC² }.� B� #B;B� OC:,Y�#Bf;Be� .f|V/J �afV� Of�� ,

Y�&&�/,�� �G2,�� Y���6�� "a� u+.L73 N�f[ Bf, T<V,� �a� O�%+ (%D >f&,B%5e�� >f&�!�5,�� >f&,B�%e�� >&�%,� O&$9 ! >��6��� u�%/,� �a�, ��

�f?�h;� m0 f:�B,� #B;B,� T�G�D� u+.L7,e� 8f%J uf+.L7 �� × � � ÅfV,� TBf)5#B;B�,,#B;� "A�$/!�7 =���L� =�,�J�&?h; m0 , #Bf;B,� Sf:B7 8�?��,� �V,

"a� .|V/,� AB] NB%2+,Ëf�&��� .f|V/,� �f;BJ �fkE , #f%J �f;BJ� >�&�: #B;B,�,>f�&�: #Bf;B,� >5Cf7 �Cf/� �f)2� #.f� Of[ N� 42%7 ±,

f�� Y�#Bf;Be� 8f7 #B;B,� >5] Í ��z�b� NBV+ a�2&:�Ò[�z=�f&�&�: =� +B2%�=�,��ae� �aH NB�?��,� "�7p+ �¬ �a�� , #.fµ m0 S.f|V,� "af� NB�&j&�

Page 136: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

u�Le� #B;B,� m0 >$G2,�� >��6�� u+.L7 .|V/,�, NB, b �, -.%+ b �a,�� >j?�A b� (%R b�,�<�%,� ���%+ b� , m0 �f)[�A#� &Gf,� U�f:� f�� �a,

.?�C$,� B,��,57 NB]BCde� >&,�! >$c�@ >2L, �f¬ �2Cf,� �af� Zs Np[� .[a,�7 ()C�,�<�%,� ��s� (�� ,��ae� �a� ��A#0 �! Uh%� Í 3

���0� �a,=��+Qf,� &Gf,� u&�j/, ,m�f%J � �f�A , "af� >f&5&V7 >f,�)�� Y�#Bf;B,� b Y�#Bf;Be� .|V/J �H Ë/,�� Y�&&�/,�� �G2,�� Y���6��

|V,� "aH (�%,� X;A� #Bf;B,� SÀf: m0 Y�f&&�/,�� Y���6b� u+.L7 S.Y����e�� Y�5��Ve� #.µ m0 :�B,� Úd�,�,UBf�%,� Ybb# m0 b ,

Í �2! �+�� T�J t[�L�N�� ���N��, #%/,�7 >&6�c UB�%,� Ybb# NE ".|VJ� #B;B�, Ë�&���,5]� ��ae� �a� �]� c B)� �a, =��&c# =� t2f&:

U�cO�%,� ABR �B� �D0,<f�! �&�! Ub/9b� �V+ b O%5,�7 �D� 42%7 = ±, �ff��V:E >ffy¤ >ff5,�² �,�ff² �ffDE, �c�ff9 �aff,� Åff�%,� O&,ff,�� �aff,

�, �,�² >�&��� Í B� ��ae� �a� ! �7 Ub/9<,– �,�f² �fD� Ëf2!� r+�,� O�%�,–>%7�G,� >,pGe� Í �/�c�2� Ôp/9 t[ 3

������G�N�� ���N�� u7�Gf,� �CfD Í �+Qf,� &Gf,� ��A �f, Ë)� , �fDE �a� �$�a� ! O&,,�3

&G,� U/9� �,,m�%J � ��A ,:�� Å�! O&,7 ��ae� �a� .+.�J ! , +.F/,� ¥° >&��: Í ".[w,�2! O�2,� T�J t[ , "afH O&,f,� �af� O%,�

�!�70 �� >s�&C,�,­.V� O]� �V, 8&�<9�� >59<5,� 2! A.�� �, �� ]��e� ¥° Í ()2! %G,� O�D, �Bf�%; (kBf[ �f� ()&�! �z!� 8:

�;�B,� Y�w,�G527 u�j/e� ,"�B9 t! Ë2�,� ,#B;B,� B� , NBfV+ b ¢ �fD� ± Zs NBV+ N� ªB§ b "�B9 t! Ë2�,� �G527 u�j/e� Np7 �B7�;p� #B;B,� Zs� ±

Page 137: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

#B;B,�,NE ±�A�½ #B;B,� m0 u�j/,� Í #B;B,� Zs ��&/:� ��F3 `.f�� SABC7 �V, &G,� O&,# O|7 Ë���� ��.,�$! >�<%,� U/9� c�

U�c �&: �2� >$+.c: "�2&%7 #B;B� Y�#B;Be� �$� N� l�b ±, ��0 B�� <� ±"Zs �� #B;B,� >�&�: NBV+ N�,"Zfs NBV+ N� h?�; b� ,��f&/:� SA�½

#B;B,� B� Zs m0 "#B;� Í #B;B,� ZsÒ,1B;B,� Í�2+ ��&/:b�� , 8%/� #B;B,� >�&�: NBV+ N�,��L� N�[ Nx� =�1B�Le� �$@ �� ,f=2&%/� N�[ N0� �

<��# 8%/,� NBV+ N� X2/+=�f&� ,�f;�B,� �f[z, b0� Ø, NBfV+ N� 8f%/� ±;A��=�,#B;B,� B� �� ~_ �;�B,�� , >5] 8%/,�� >6A�!"� F3

�+Q,� &G,� �� "#�5/9� c Ë���� O%,�3 SZ�a,� �7�/[ Í ÕBL,� �+,� �<! "#A�� c �a� &G,� O&,#�,"�D� , t[

�&�! "a�¹� ~%7 m0 SA���� Ôp/93 �a� &G,� O&,#�,m�%J � ��A ,�+��fc� Y��f�� S! �� �,*� , (f)5+

Å+ �� �)2�:− �−,� TB)5� N� Ø�f/� Ëf/,� Y�f�B)5e� �f� �� m0 .f�/5� Zfs #B;B, NE ±

Y��B)5e� (!� #B;B,�,}�2;E� P2; B�� , �V+ b Y��B)5e� OV� �a, 8%/J N�,>+#B;Be�7 �C/J �� ,�f)&,0 #Bf;B,� Tt�D�7 b0 , TBf)5� OfV�

#Bf;B,� B� �a,� "Zs m0 ��/_ �/+#B;B� u�� Í B)� #B;B�, .+���, �f�� B,��)2� �� m0 ��/y <� #B;3 1−>f2V¬ Ëf)� �f�Zs m0 >f;�/_ �fD�[ �e Y��B)5e� "a� N� ±, -<fd7

n� o�p�ND&� ]�f :��W � E~ $5�s5&� =A3 �Z��) :d��kS&� :W� �E

n� o���NV&� r��A t�V9? yM#. d�k�5&� d3�&� :W ��E

Page 138: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�{ −

�J�a7 ���� Í O�/Ge� #B;B,�,�f&,0 "Zfs Tt�D� m0 ���� Í "A��/�� T%, , Z�,� �! Ë2s B)� �a,,>/$,� ��/_ Zs 3

f;−#B;B� #B;B,� �;�� N� ±,Ëf�&�: Ë?h; :�� B�� , Í .f�/5� Zfs "Zs m0 ����,�&,0 .�/5� "Zs O7 3

#−"Zs m0 .�/5� Zs #B;B,� N�[ �e , Í .f�/5� Y�f�B)5e� �f� "Zfs Of7 �&,0 ����,l,a[ #B;B,� �;�� N�[ �e� ,#B;B,� �;�� B� #B;B,� N�[ ,

m�%J � N� 42%7Ø– �J�a, #B;B,� �;�� –u�Le� #B;B,� B� , :�� B�� Úd� Ë?h;,Úd� Ë?h; :�� u�Le� #B;B,�� 3

f�−u�Le� #B;B,� N�[ �w0� ,#Bf;B,� �f;�� Bf� �a,�� , Ëf?h; f:�� Úd� ,#�.�� �/� �A2+ Å[ TB)57 P&, Nw0 B)�,�+Zf|[ ! �C+� ,

T�G�D�� #%J N�V�0 �&� P&, �D� t[±,6A�! NBV+ N� O&j/G+ �D� t[ =� "Z�, t�2��=� �&,0 �)�B]B7 >5] T�&c� -�CJ� Tt�D3

�−�f)���� Y�2Ve� >+#B;B� #.� N� ± ±,S#Bf;B� �fkB[ �� , Í S.f|V/�� �A�M�,uf�Le� #Bf;B,� m0 >]BCf² >��f60� >$GfD �I N� m0 X;.+ tD0 ±,

�J�a7 (?��,�, �<fRb� Aa%/+ >5�/² "B;� ! Y���6��� �G2,� l�J N�� ±�)/&��� !3N�� ±Å[ #B;Be� ,&?h; #B;B,� N�[ N0� =�&�&�: =�3

��af� >j] Y�$@� �c�9 �a,� O&,,� �a� A�V��� Y���� >]<� "a�#B;B,� S:� 3

�A�f� �f! "f%7 `f� �Af+ -�CD0� #.F/7 O&,,� �a� Í .��2,� �V,UB�%,�,-�CDb�� U%,� S.?�# �! �;�.�� 3 �f)2� �,pfJ Ë/,� �+���,� w0 ,� �a�c<R0 4c.J b O&,=�>&D��\,� m0 ,>f&,�� �F�� 4/: ³�$J b O7 , w0

¦+.d/,�� ��,� �)/+�s,f&%7 N�fV� �f� �&�,�7 (;.,�� , �af� >f+�s Of7

Page 139: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>&7�LM� �F�� �� NBV+ N� O&,,�3�&� >:#��,� >&,�/,� 1�$9¼, l,w� : ����:−�+Q,� &G,� ��w ,m�%J � ��A ,X&' N� m0 ± �f! �� Y��B)5e�

#B;B� NBV&, �&,0 ��t�D�7 #B;B,� m0 .�/5� #B;B,� TB)5�= ��3 Í lf� b� N��.7� O&,# m0 .�/5J `B!# #.µ "a� N�±, TBf)5� ��2|/f9� �f;B� B� t�

#Bf;B� NBfV&, �f&,0 (�2+ �� m0 ��&/:b� N�V�0 �� #B;B,�=�, �f7 Ëf2!�� �a,� Ë;A�M� .@*e�+� "Z@pJ u�%/ O&$f9 f! ��&f�E� Y��B)57 Ë;A�M

��&f�E� "af� #Bf;� uf�j/+ Ë;A�fM� NBfV,�� #�§b�, af�2&: �Cf//� ÒO%5,�7 S#B;B� NBVJ� #B;B,�73

�f��� Í ��&/:b�7 Y��B)5e� .?�9 U�j[ �,�: TB)5[ #B;B,� N� 42%7±"Zs m0 �A�M� Í, �f! Ë2�/G� �J�a, �$;�� #B;B,� �a� �V+ ¢ t� >f;���

"Zs Í Z@p/,� �, �V+ ¢ �&,0 Tt�Db�7 Z�,� m0 A��/�b��, Tt�fDb�7 l,w� �&,0 3

&G,� `B!�,m�%J � ��A ,�fV¬ B)� #B;B�, .+��� TB)5� O[ N� ± ±, b� �;�B7 �Ve� �� ��,�f;�B7 #B;B�, S.+��e� Y��B)5e� �� �� <� ,

�.� ! `B!,� "a� (/J tD0f$;�� #B;B,� NB[ =��fJ�a, , Xf2+ (CfM�� �fJ�a, �f;�� Åf[ 42%� B� �&: �� #B;B,� NB[, `B!f,� 8f! �fkE

�)&�! �ª�2/e�,�h; >F&/2,� O%§ �&V� = � ��O&,,� �� , f! SA#�C� �a� Ë5� 1B�Le�,$;�� #B;B,� NB[ �$|+ ¢ t� =� Y�f�B)5e� �f� "Zfs NB[ �$|+ ¢ �&,0 S.�/5�, l,w� �)&,0 ��t�D�73

�,B�7 %7 t&� "�B!�: "u�Le� #B;B,� B� �;�B,� NBV&� , �f! `.%e� �� ± � K�&,0 Tt�Db�� "Z�7 &&�/,�, Y�f&�t�, #B;B,� ��.! ABC/+ b �a� %�

>2Ve�"3 u?�f���� Y�f&��e� >f5�/² #�.f�� #B;� ��2/�� �.� ! (/J tD0

Page 140: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوج

− �{�� −

#B;B,� Y�a,,5D (/+ ¢ t� AB[ae� Ub/9b� (/+ ¢ l,w Ë, a�2&: �$|+ ¢� Ò>2Ve� Y�&�t�, #B;B,� ��.! ��2/��3

&Gf,� >&f��: �f� AB[afe� ¦2f,� f! �tf�%,� ~%$, Á��� Í ��; c��f,B�7 `B!f,� "a� ! ��z!� �&� �� +.F/,� ¥° ! �+Q,�: " �f&�

�j7, B� �a,� #B;B,� NB[ B� u$9 �� È/�� NE `.f%� �f;�B,� 8!± K�"Z�7 &&�/,� �!,�&,0 Tt�Db�� , f! #Bf;B,� ��.f! T! �2� Th�+ b�

�<Rb�, #B;B� �)�%7 u?���� >5�/² #�.�� #B;B,� >�&�� NBVJ N� ª�B� OC52� �J�a7,l,a[ P&, �)�%7� ,�f, .�i #.� Tt�D�7 ;B, ;� B, O7 � K K�,

f/y b #Bf;� Of[ N� �$@ B, (%D± (/f, �f&,0 (�f2+ �f� m0 �f/+#B;B� Í ���9,�"��F3

SZ�E� �JA�$! �� �+Q,� &G,� T<[ ! �z%e� ¢�%,� �a� #�.��" (%D �$@ B,3 33 »,�" .[a,� >�7�G,� �JA�$! ! ��z!b� " .+�f�� TBf)5� Of[ #B;B�,,<|� N�GD��[ =,#B;B,� �&,0 (�2+ ¢�� �Dx� 3 333 »,�"f&5J Ëf/,��

��[ #B;B,� U��2/&, TB%,�, �f&,0 (�f2+ N� �� 42|/G� ��[ #B;B,� NBV&� �"Zs,Y��B)5e� >&�7 -<d7 ,�fD�&7 Tf�J �� BjD ! 3 (fJ �w0 �fD� 4f2%7 ± ±

(/f, �f&,0 (�f2+ �f� m0 �f/+#B;B� Í ��f/_ Zs #B;� B� �� O[ N� �$@�±AB[ae� O&,,�,l,w �, 4D� �V, ± , O[ (�� (CM���<�%,�,�tf�%,�� Of7 ,

AD�� b0,l,a[ #B;B,� ~%7 Np7 NB�h§ ±, m0 �f/+#B;B� Í ��f/y b �� �&,0 (�2+ ��,�fJ�a, #B;B,� �;�� B�� , �af� m0 .f�/5+ .f�g� ~%$f,�� Tt�Db�3

n� o���XV&� $�f�2 ¡.�K : $I3)� \A3

Page 141: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�  −

.[af,� u7�9 &G,� Ub/9� "#�ª �&L� >c<%,� ~�D c�,�f,Bc Bf�� : " #B;B�, .+��� TB)5� O[,��[ <|� N�GD=, �f;B7 #B;B,� �&,0 (�2+ ¢�� �Dx�

#Bf;B� �fV+ ¢ .f�E� P5D Í "B;B,� ��=�f%Lc �f)&� =�3 33 »f,�" X2/e�f7 Ë?h��,?�ª ��! N�[ B, Ë?h�� X2/e� Nx� = ±�;�/_ N�V, =���f%� �DB[ Í =�� "Zs m0,Tf%,� �fV¬ B)� "Zs m0 ��/_ B� �� O[� ,�fV¬ �f� �� b�

X2/7 T%,�,X2/7 T%,� .+��+ �¬ �� b �D� t[ ±3Xf2/e� �af� N�[ �e� , T%,� �! SA�$! N�[ �a,�,&?h; =�&�&�: =�,&?h; T%,� N�[ =�&�&�: =�, N� Th�&�

Y�&��e� .?�9 Í T%,� u�j/+ b, m0 �/��f60 ��,� >&��%� 42%� NBV+� Ë?h�� X2/e� �a�,�+ b �� B�� Oc�! ��h/, 87 �.5J b >q$,� N�� �&[

�/&��%� 42%�� ��! Í X2/¬� X2/¬��F3 �+Q,� &G,� SA�$! ! #.+ �¬ �D� t[±,m�f%J � ��A ,�f,Bc Bf�� : " Of[

#Bf;B� �DB[ Í B)� #B;B�, .+��� TB)5�=� "Zfs m0 ��f/_ .f�E� Pf5D Í #B;B,� B� �a,�"3#B;B,� O%; �D� ±, Y�&�t�, �A�! Å[ TB)5� B��, b �A�M� Í �, u��,YbB�%e� Î�B@ Í %+� ± � K, Y�w �A�fM� Í SA.f�/� = �fJ�w �

Z@pJ,Y��af�, Z@pf/,� Np7 NB�h§ �<�%,� X&'� ,Y�#Bf;Be� �� , P&f,� Y�#B;B�,,�G527 TB�+ b #B;B,� NE ,"Z�7 TB�+ O7 , .@*fe� B� #B;Be�� ,�7 ���CJb#B;B,N�f&!E� Í �f, u�� b �a,� #B;B,� b , `f, TBf�%�� %&' �<�%,�=����/f�b� a�p� Y�$@�7 Nw*+ u/�e� Y�$@0 N� >��$,� (Vj7 ±,

PV%,� P&,�,#B;B,�7 >5C/� Y�w Y�$@0 Th�/G+ >+#B;Be� Y�$@x� Ò, t2f&7 >+#B;Be� Y�$@0 Th�/G+ b #B;B,� Y�$@0,�B)5� �DBV, =�&�[ =� N� h?�f�� ��

n� o ���c#& ���XV&� $�f�2 G#� �m�b 8�xk $�f�2}�n�X&� : $I3)� �\t3

Page 142: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

u?����� Y�&�t�, �.%+ b 3 B� �&: �� N�&!E� Í u�j/,�� Ë;A�M� #B;B,�7 �, U<�/9� b #B;B,��

�f&,0 >f;�/_ Y��B)5e� NBVJ 4/:,>f/$,� �� m0 ��f/y b Bf� t2f&7 , Of7 �H TB�&, Y�#B;Be� Y��w m0 ��/y ���� Í #B;B,�, �+Qf,� &G,� t2&7

E� PV! c.� ,#B;B,� m0 #B;Be� ��&/:�� A��/��7 �� , #Bf;Be� T�&c�#B;B,�7��F3

#Bf;B,� m0 #Bf;B,� Zs ��&/:� N� >59<5,� ��$c� �+Q,� &G,� `B!�±�)&�! N��.7 b `B!# �A�½,8d/,�� ¦+.d/,� #.µ b0 , #.fµ Ëf)�

�b*� �)&!+ `B!#,SA�½ f! N�f�.7� Of&,# (f�+ ¢ tf� Zfs ��f&/:� #Bf;� B� �&: �� #B;B,� NB[ ! Ub/9b� (/+ b #B;B,� m0 #B;B,�

.@*e� B� u�L�,Y��B)5e� �� "Zs m0 ��t�D�7 3 Y�f��: �f� >��: �2))� >Lc�9 ��ae� �a� O&,# >�G�9, .7�fV� b0 �2! -.L,� ~�+ b ¥#�c B��

O��; ��3 "#B;� Í .�/5� #B;B,� Zs N� u���±";BJ >�!� Y�w m0 �/+#B;B�� , b

#B;B,� m0, �J�6�.%�� "#�.�� Í A.�/&, #B;� B� �&: �� #B;B,� N0 O7 >j;.� Y�w� >�!�� >�! �� �, 7b3S;Be� Y�a,� m0 Nw0 >;���� , m0 b

#B;B,�3 �#�H��:−�+Q,� &G,� .[w ,m�%J � ��A ,#B;B� #B;B,� �;�� N� ±, B�� :��Ë�&�: Ë?h; ,"Zs m0 ���� Í .�/5� Zs ,�f&�! A�f$s b u: �a�� ,

>�L%e� S:<e� b0 �&� �ª�2+ b�, #B;B7 (&�G/,� �! NBV,� NB�L%+ �+a,�

n� o�Z�� :"&�-&�) "#-&�) aN-&� �I�. :�OW E

Page 143: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�!7�� ";�� u,��, Bf� �af� #Bf;B,� �f;�� N� f%7 t&f� "�Bf!# �fV, ±Ë�&�: Ë?h; :�� �Dp7 "�B!# X� u�Le� #B;B,�±,� �af� Of;E �af� Xf2/�

�B)5� NBV+ N� u�Le� #B;B,�=�&�[ =�#�.�� �/� �A2+ ,�+Z|[ ! �C+� , >); ! "Zs m0 Tt�Db�� ��.%,�� T�G�Db�� #%/,� �&�! X2/+ �D� t[

�/5C7 -B]Be� -�CJ�,1�BC,�� u�� �! %$,� >+�s &%7 T<[ , �D�µ %&' �<�%,� UB�! �A�µ Í Ëq7 B� �e=�, (fVj7 NB[A+ �<�%,� X&F�

u�Le� #B;B,� NB[ ��2/�� >q$,�, f:�� >��60� &c �p7 &�/,� �! `.%e� Úd�,Ë�&�: Ë?h;� , Ëf/,� Y�A�$/!b� �� �� �A�$/!� Å[ TB)5� �DE

�­�a7 TB�J b,�f7 TBf�+ �B6B�� O_ �� #B;B�, 7<� , #Bf;B,� N� tf[ ±bB�%e� Î�B@ Í #�%�Y,�A�M� Í �� �)?�ªx7 P&, Ë/,� , �f� �DBV, O7

m�E� YbB�%e� m0 2/G� B)� >&D�|,� YbB�%e�3 #Bf;B� �A�M� Í P&�� #B;� B�,N�GD0 #B;Be� O7 ,}.�� ,.F�� ,.F:� ,�f�Zs� , Thf�+ (f@

#B;� �, NBV+ N� #B;Be� l,w >&,B�%� ����F3 $R Å[ #B;B,� N� �<�%,� ��5J�$�±Ë%&, �fDB[ �f&: �f� Ëf%&$L,� ÅfV,��

&�[ 42%�=��A�M� Í �, #B;� b Å�! �A�$/!� .�� �, "#�.f�� Í "#Bf;� tD0� �A�M� Í >2&%/e�,#B;B,� Í >Cd�/e� u?���� Y��w Ë�� 3 P&, #B;B,��

#B;B7,<�� =#B;B,� �;�� NBV+ N� �! ,<�� = f! "Zf�7 "Z@pfJ �! �&,0 Tt�Db� >);,&G,� "AB] t[ ,m�%J � ��A 3

ABf�E� �f� #Bf;B,� TBf)5� N� ÔBV,�&Gf,� (&V��f$! >f�<%,� A.c c�±

n� o�Z�� :���XV&� G#� }�L5p4� ]�f :��W O��−O�� E $&>%D&� �SK G&� d3�fz� �.�N: �I)

�-%&� W�^� �N� R�2 ,G&�-: �� HD23E

Page 144: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>&!�h/Db�,��a,� �)!h/2+ Ë/,� , 42%� Ë� �&: �� �A�M� Í �I #B;� b� Å[, >&G�,� >,�9.,� ! �ª�.,� �+,� �Lc ¥° ! �/&��: Í .[w ��

�fCD ��: "�E� N0 �A�fM� Í >L&Gf7 Y�f+B� ·�d, �f)2� Of�%,� �hf/2+ AB�� Y�2+�$e�� Y�[A��e� �$2J �Gj7=�>f&�[ ,N� b0 ± �f­��w �f� �hf/2+ �f�

�h; 4G+= ± � K�&J�w� =�, �h/2+ ��� �2! �A�� .�� >�:<7 �2�4Gf+± � K&f6.! =�, ��,� �! >7B�Le� A�@g� �J.J >�:<7 �h/2+ �Dx� #B;B,�[×"��F3

�+.�� &5+ ¦2,� �a��; �A�fM� Í A.f�/� Zfs Å[ 42%� #B;B,� N� U�E� � ±B� �&: ��,m�E� YbBf�%e� �f� �h/2� N�@ UB�%� #B;B,� N� .�g�� ±,

m�E� YbBf�%e� �f! Åf�%,� ��A#�� Í� �A�fM�� Xc�B,� Í .�p/� B)�, >&;A�M� Y�+BI�� Y�2&%/,� Ë� Ë/,��, ! .�E� P&,� PV%,� , AB] t[ ± �

�+Q,� &G,�,Y�#B;Be� u�� N� �� ±, ¦Cf��� Y�f2&%/,� Ëf� Ëf/,�� #B;B�, >&?h��,#Bf;B,� �f! �A�M�� Xc�B,� Í S.�p/� , Tt�fD�7 lf,w�

�A�fM� Í Y�#Bf;B� �f)2� OCfj/&� >f,B�%e� �f­�&��� m0 #B;B,�3 �af� UB�%� B� �� -<� 3

�+Q,� &G,� UB�� �&�!�: "�B)5� #B;B,� NBV+ <� =�f&�[ =� " �,�f� �f¬ �<�%,� X&'� UB�%,� Ybb# �&�,#Bf;B,� Sf:B7 8�?�f�,� Zs , �f&V�

#B;B,� NBV+ N� ABC/+�,f&�[ 4f2%� �fDB[ �&: �� =�f��L� =�,fJ�w =� Sf:�� ¦d�/� Ë?h; #B;B7 �A�M� Í >2&%/�,[z�f� 4f2%� �DB[ X2+ �&[� = =�

7 �CJ� �� X&' 87#B;B,�3

n� o$&���&� G#� =b��&� R��&� 8xI ]�f G#� «�9&��%&� "�9M&���� $�f�2H�%Dc&� :��

W QOE

Page 145: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

T<fV,� �a� N0 U��� "a� &G,� SA�$! ! "#�ª �&L� >�<%,� �z!� c�; OV��=�, >,�: Í >[z�� Y�#B;Be� X&' Np7 >��7 (Vy :� O[ NE = ±

Y���f%e� >�' �! ª�/� �H,>f,��� lf�J >f�&�: b0 P&f, #Bf;B,� N�� ±, -�CDb� �! ��.� ��Zs �DB[ `B!#�, S.7�V�� ¸f5�7 f+A� N0 >fy¤

1.%,� >�, Í �, X6� �� #B;B,�, ��%/f9�� .f�i 4f2%� ! r�L]� N0� ª�µ=�,>&�5�,� >$9�2e� b0 T��e� �a� Í >,��e� "a� #�.+� �;� <� ��F3

�+Q,� &G,� ��w c�, 8f%,� >V: ¥° ! �/&��: Í m�%J � ��A ".Lf9 �� -<� m0 "�� �A�$� �d&�,�f2�, �f;�� N� ��f2� .f[w �f&: ±

uf�Le� #B;B,� B� P&, #B;B,�, f! Ë$J�fV,� 1�Bf; f! uf�! ��f2! ·�M� #B;B,� B� �;�B,� NB[ �� >59<5,� ��A ! #A�� ��z!�, ��

?�ª #B;B,� NBV+ N� Th�, ·�M� #B;B,� N�[ B, �D�= ±��f/&��� ! , �f2DBV, >��7 #B;B,� O�%D, O�%D b �22V, m�%J �/&���,�f�.+��J f! �af� Uf� ,

�,B�7 ��z!b� �! Ë$J�V,� 1�;p�: "UBf�%� "#Bf;� N� (�GfD b ±, Of7 #B;� B� �&: �� #B;B,� UB�%e�",�f,B�7 �+Q,� &G,� �&�! u�%� : "

Bf� UBf�%e� #B;B,� �� #�.e� N�[ �w0 Ë2%+ UB�%� "#B;� N� (�GD b �,Bc±� Nx� u�Le� #B;B,��bB�%� �DB[ 4!#=�2V,�7 ,l,af[ �Gf&, �fJ�w N� Xf� ±,

�f/�&�� u�Le� #B;B,� S.+��� Tª<,� `.�C,� (&�GJ 2%�,�f&� ��hfD <f� , bB�%� �DB[ `B!� ·�M� #B;B,� #�.e� N�[ N0�= �B2¬ �2V,�7 "� F3

u�Le� #B;B,� P&, m�%J �D� Í >y¤ �2� SA�$%,� "a��±, #Bf;B,� Bf� Of7

n� o}�n�X&� ���c&� ��%#& ���XV&� $�f�2 G#� �m�b 8�xk $�f�2 :$I3) :� �\AE

n� oR�-&� $D92 ]�f G#� }�n�X&� ���c&� $�f�2 :W��E

Page 146: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

M�·�,>59<5,� �&,0 ��w �� ! , "Zf�, ·�fM� #B;B,� �a� �.%+ <� u?����� Y��B)5e� ��,u�Le� #B;B,�7 P&, �D�� ±, �/&f��: Í ".[w �� !

f+.F/,� ¥° !, �f)2� OCfj/+ Y�f&�t�, �f6�.!� ��t�fD�7 �af,�� Y�#B;B�3

#B;B,� m�%J �DB[ >&���� "a� �� .�i X6B� Í .[w t[ �f� f! ·�fM� >59<5,� �&,0 ��w,U�c �&: : ">&��e� 8! �;�B,� Í 1B;B,� O&c ��, ,#B;B,� Ë� Ë/,�,·�M� #B;B,� 8! B� �2�c ? #B;B,� ! T�/+ �&V� ,

u�Le� #B;B,� ! T�/+�, A�a_ <� "��F3 "#B;� 87 �2� �.5�± � �,·�M� m�%J , �A�! Zs Úd�� Ë?h; B� �a,��

"Z�,,Y�&�t�, �A�%,� u�Le� #B;B,� 87� ,f&�[ 4f2%� �fDB[ �&: �� = =� [z��=�Y�#B;Be� 87 3

�2V,�7 ABC/,� Ëq7 #B;B,� u�L� N� >]<M��±, �� ! �C+ b B�� �G527 (?�c,SpR�B� �&�! Oy Np7 ,�Gf527 �f��&c Of�%+ b� , �f� Of[ Nxf�

�e� 42%� ABC/+,lj�,�� ,NB�,�� ,#�BG,�� , >fq7 (f�%+ l,w U�|��� �G527 (?�c �� ! �C+ N� O/y b �D�� F, TB�/� �� �A�M� Í P&��

lj�,�� �e� B� �&� u�j/�� �J�a7,NB�,�� ,l,w Zs� , Í uf�j/e� Of7 Y�5C,� "aH �C/J Y��w �A�M�, Ëf� �f&: �f� #Bf;B,� >5] �)�|��

>&�[ >%&$R3u�Le� #B;B,� Oj� �2� #.� ! ,<|f� �f�j[ = �f;�� f! #B;B,�f[ >f&�V,� �f%e� (&��f5� Ybbf, S.��� S.7�V� SpR�B� #B;B,�

n� oR�-&� $D92 ]�f G#� }�n�X&� ���c&� $�f�2 : W�� E�Z��) :W��E

n� od��kS&� : W� � – � �E

Page 147: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحد

− �{�� −

u�Le�,>��Le� (&��5e� �� "Zs� 3 >f&�V,� Î�%e� -��J N� rC+ b �D� tV� � ±�)2� #.� m0,U��+ N� O|� :+ª >&D�GD�� ,�.! �e� ,.V7 lj�,� �, 42%7 e� �:#�.�E� �b*� Í u?���� "a� �� ÅV,� TB)5, >f/$,� rC+ b l,a[

�2� #.� Í ÅV,� #B;B,� TB)5� �:,#Bf;B,� B� �;�B,� U��+ Np7 �, f! u�Le� #B;B,� �D�±,#�.�� �� �&�! �C+ �e �/�&�: Í �A�%,� 3 &G,� 1.s� c�,m�%J � ��A ,U�c t2&: 1�.s�� >+�s : "Be�� Å[ #B; ,

&?h; #B;B,� N�[ N0�= ��&�&�: =� "3.f�E� �+Qf,� PfV! fc �&[ .�D�� , &�[ Ë?h�� O%F�=�,&?h; ÅV,�� =�,5,�² =��<�%,� X&' �&�! X'� �� l,w Í 3

&?h; u�Le� #B;B,� ��%; Í P&,�=�Ëf?h�� #Bf;Be� �f�%; �f� 1.spf7 , #B;B,� >5C7 �C/e�,&�[ =�3

G�, �k0 ��`h&6 >,�+Q,� �)&� A[ ±,m�f%J � �f�A , Ybb# B5f] UBff�%,�,�?�ff�� �.ff! ��ff!�Bc� �ff)�?��: OffV7 1½� , b0 ��w �ff��

:�� #B;B,� NBV7 ��,� #B;B,� S:� ��ae �+�z�,=� b� �&� #%J b T�G�D� b� .|VJ 3

$R >fF&/D� Tªb (/: Å[ #B;Be� Np7 �+Q,� &G,� (V: N0± >f$Jz� >f&%&Ë?h;� :�� u�Le� #B;B,� Np7 UB�,� !±, 8f%e� #B;Be� NB[ X2+ B)�

&?h;=�, Sf:� f! u7�Gf,� �,b/f9�� �f�<[ Tf� �� l,w (�9 N0 �DE ± �#B;B,�,#B;B,� >5C7 ���CJ� Th�/G+ Ë?h�� #B;Be� NE , Th�/G+ a�2&:� Ò

&�&�: �.|VJ #B;B,� .|VJ=�, .f|V/7 l,w� >f&?h; u?�f�: Ëf� Ëf/,� "#�.f��#B;B,� >5C7 >5C/� 3

f:�� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� NB[ 45/D� �wx� %7�=�f&?h;� =� �f;�� #Bf;� Bf� #B;B,�,m�%J ,Ë%&$R Å[ TB)5� �D� �$@� ±, �&: �� �A�M� Í �, u�� b

Page 148: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ { −

B�,>&��%,� YbBje� �� �D�� ,YbBf�%e� Î�Bf@ Í #�%�� , �f� 4f5/D� &G,� �JAf:�� "A�f$/!�7 T�fV:� �f� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �a� ! =�f&?h; =�,

�+Z|[ ! �c] ��2/�� "�B![,SAB)�fe� ���Gfc� m0 �fJ�w Í ���Gf�D�� , "#%J�,"#�.�E �6�.!� ,�)�B]B� m0 >5C,� Tt�D� �)&,0 ��t�D�� 3

��&,# ! &G,� "#A�� �a,� ��z!b� ����,�,Bc B�� : "A#�f$/+ �af,� m0 >[Qf,� Xf2+ b TBf)5� �D� #B;B,� ¸5, �� ��a,�±,f&?h; NBfV+ �f&V� =�

&�&�:=� "�,B�7 �2! 1�;� (@ : "#B;B,� >�&�: Í T<V,� N0 ±, A#�f$/+ t&f� b ¸5�,� UB,� �� N��wE� �&,0,f&�[ NBfV+ N� ªB§ �Dx� =�f6A�!� =�f+A�$/!� =�

w : Í ��z�b� �! X2/e� Ë�&��� l,a,�J�, }�f&�,�7 �;�B,� TB)5[ �/�&�: m0"%5D �§ b �Dx� =�,�f7 O|� �a,� �;�B,� TB)5� NE ± �, �f� Bf�

&�[ �DB[ �&:=�&%&$R =� Í #�.f�E� f! �c] �&: �� �V, `B2%� �z�� �A�M�,S:�� Y�w ! b0 �C+ b ,#Bf;B,� �;�� B� , 4f2%� P&f,�

,� 1B;� >5C7 #B;B,� �;�� -�CJ��z�e� ÅV,� 42%e�7 ���CJ� #B;B, �A�M� Í "#�.�E �A�%,�,#Bf;B,� 1Bf;� B� P&, m�%J �D� 42%7 ±, ��

ÅV,� 42%e�,�&� ��z�<, O7��,� TB)5e�� ,�A�M� Í Y�w B� O7, �Cf/� #B;B,� 1B;B7,#B;B,� 1B;� B� P&,� , &Gf,� �f&,0 �f�w �� -<d7

,� TB)5e� O%; �&: �+Q,�u�Le� ÅV,Bf� Bf� �&: �� #B;B,� B�� , m�%J �;�B,� P5D3 87� .��� �.5,��Ð �,9�� }�&�,�� 3

d��H��:−�+Q,� &G,� X;A� ,m�f%J � ��A ,S���fe� >f+#B;B,� S.f|V,� , u�Le� #B;B,� Tt�D� m0 Y�2Ve� S.|[ Ë��, �f;�� 1Bf;� B� �a,��

#B;B,�,Úd� :�� B�� ,&��� m0 >2Ve� �)/, f! Tt�fDb� �a� P&,�

Page 149: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ � −

�/5C7 -B]Be� -�CJ� O&$9,f&&�J� >$GfD� >��f60 #.fµ Bf� O7 , Npf7 #Bf;B� OCfj&� f+ª m0 uf�Le� #B;B,� -��+,#Bf;� b , m0 -��f+�

.�i #B;B� OCj&� �.!,.�i #B;� b , OCfj&� }.f5,� m0 -��f+� ·BC² #B;B�,·BC² }.� B� ,}.� #B;� P&,� ,�� .f|V/J �afV

Y���6��� �G2,� u+.L7 Y�#B;Be�,>f�&��� u+.L7 P&,� , O&$f9 f! >&5]B,�,#B;B,� >5] �! >+.! Y�#B;B� Ë)� , �A�$/!� .�� .|V/,� �a�� ~_,O�%,� �)�j�+ >+A�$/!� AB�� Y���6��� �G2,� NE , Í �I #B;� b �A�M�3J�2,� #%/,� �a� Np7 &G,� ¥¤ �a� O;E ± ± �Gf2,� "a� S.|[ �� �

:�B,� #B;B�, Y���6��� ,uf�Le� #Bf;B,�, #f%/7 P&f, Y�f2Ve� m0 �&�:,(�B/� #%J B� O7 ,>f�&d/� S.f|[� ,Shf+t/� Y�#Bf;B� `��zfJ ,

l,a[ �G&, >�&����3 >f!B2/e� u?�f���� S���e� S.|V,� "a� N� 42%7±, 4��f2/J b #�fVJ Ëf/,��

�&�� 1�¿ b0 Ë���U,�I �: b Ë/,� Y��B/e� �� (&�! T�[A� 3 8f$+ ¢ ? Y�#B;Be� .|V/J �H Ë/,�� Y���6��� �G2,� "a� >�&�: �� �V,

�)/�&�: �+Q,� &G,�,<] � X&L/G+ �,� =l,w �! ��V+ N� , fc �fDE ¥¤± �,�y�J Í �#�] B�� , Y�f&&�/,�� Y���f6��� �Gf2,� lf�J N� ±

>&5&V,� >,B)µ,�)/&��� ! �<Rb� Aa%/&� 3 >�&��� �� �I ¸:b >+A�$/!� Y�&&�J� �GD� Y���60 #.µ Nw0 Ë� �aV�

�� Í Xc�B,��,���0 l,w� =� ��ae� �a� ¥¤ ��2$, – S:� ��a� Ë2!� #B;B,�–(�B,�� U�&M� ! (?��,� 3

&Gf,� �f2, 87 <�± �,m�f%J � �f�A ,f��%/,� lf�J >f�&�: Y���f6��� Y�Y�&&�/,�� �G2,��,�IBC: >&5&[� , Sf&�%,� "afI f�/%e� NBV+ 4/: –

Page 150: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ � −

S&�! �� �H (�!�� ,�J�5]� � Y�a7 �I�CJb,Y�2Ve�� , �a� >�&�:� #B;B,�–�)2� �A� >2&7 ! 3 >f,�)�� �f��&s Í �fH &Gf,� Ë�.+ N� ��� � ±

O&,,� �a� ! (V: B)� >+t%,��, ��� �/�.7 ��ae� �a� ! (@± �, >,�)��7 N<L$,��3>,�); ¾ABJ >,�); ! >,�:�� NE ±3OfF$� T��� ´�9 �&V� ,

YbB�%e�7 �D��ª Í ¢�%,� ¢�! ,X&2�,� pLM� �a� O|� �2! AC+ N��, ���,�� 8$e�,�D<L7 ! �<�%,� u5J� �a,� 3

m�f%J � �f�A �+Q,� X&L/G+ b, f%7 Sf:� ��af7 �fDt+0� �&�GfJ#B;B,�, O&$f9 f! Y�f��%J Ëf� Y���f6��� �Gf2,� lf�J N� (!h+ N� ±

Ë�&��� #�§��,#B;B,� �;�� SAc u�%J 42%7 ,:�B,� ,m�%J� �D�j$9 , Y�2Ve� "aH,#Bf;�� >f&�&�: S.f|[ �;B+ u�%/,� �a� O|� NE = ±�f&�&�: =� Y�#B;B�,, T�Gf�D� �f;BJ �fk� t[ UBf�%�� >f&�&�: >f�! m0 #Bf;B,�

Ë�&�:,#B;B,� >&2&2@� m0� ;�f2V¬� #Bf;B,� �;�� ,>f�&�: , b �f� Bf�� �+Q,� &G,� �&�J.+,m�%J � ��A 3

Y�f2Ve� Y�f&��� �]� ! ·.�� O[ ·.: �+Q,� &G,� FD �a,�)&,0 u�Le� #B;B,� Tt�D� %7,Y�#Bf;� �Gf&,� Y�#Bf;B� �kp7 , tf[

J�&,0 SA���� ���3 >5f] �f! `.f%� #Bf;B� Y�f$@0 rCf+ �f&[ �V, ± K�#B;B,�,#Bf;Be� Bf�� u/�fe� �$|D N� N��wE� Í rC+ �&[ �D� 42%7 �,

#B;B,� B�� ���/�b� a�p� Ë52D�,#Bf;� <7 #B;B� Y�$@0 rC+ O�� , <[i �$|+ �[ �D0= ±O[� >5] <7 ,&���� =��� >5] <7 , >5f] <f7 ~&7��

��&7,&�C�� =�S<] <7 ,t?�]� =T�&] <7 ,[.j/�� =�>f[.: <f7 ,=2[�f9� � NBV9 <7,�a� %7 UB�%,� Í �� (&�/G+ O)� 3

#Bf;B,� >fj?�A �f� �f� Y�#Bf;Be� "a� N� ! >%R�c >,b# U+ �a��±

Page 151: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{   −

c<R0=�,�+Q,� &G,� r+�/7 ,��afe� �af� m0 ��w �� O[ r+�/7� , O�2,� T�J t[()�%7 �!,ÍBC,� Ï.! �7�[ 3

S#Bf;B� �Gf&, Y�#Bf;Be� "a� N� ! >%R�c >,b# �+ �a,��, Zfs �� c<R0 #B;B,�7 >5C/�=�,f&?h; #B;B,� O%; Î�;.�� �+Q,� N� = ±�f&�&�: =�

t?�c=�J�a7 ,�7 Y�#B;Be� �C/J �&V� ,l,a[ B�� , f! >��%� Ë� O7 >�&���3T%,� >�&�: N� l,w ± �C/+ N� �Dp� �� t! Ë�&��� #B;B,� Ë$�9 #B;B,�7� &?h; #B;B,� N�[ �wx�=�&�&�: =�Cfd�� =�t?�fc� = �af� N�f[ �fJ�a7

7B�G� #B;B,�=�Y�2Ve� �! ,>f��%� >f2Ve� Y�#B;Be� NB[ Th�&� ��F3 #Bf;B,� Sf:� ��a� S.V�� >�&�: B� �a��, Ëf?h; #Bf;B,� N� �fe�L� ±

N� O&j/G&� Ë�&�:#%/+,"Z�, �.%+ N� O&j/G&� 3 4f2%e� �af� f&5+ �f� >&G�,� >,�9.,� ¥° ! �/&��: Í &G,� .[w c�

"[*+� ,8&?hf�� 8f7 �Gf2,� f! ��z!� ! "#A Í .[w �&:, #�f5� <f� N�c#�Cf/� N�f&?h; �fJ�V,� �af�� l:��f,� �a� O|� N� ��z!b�±

82+�$/� N�DBV+,�Dp7 &G,� 1�;p� f+ª l:��f,� �afH �&,0 A��e� N�[ N0 = �� <|�=,.! �J�V,� �aH� =�N�2+�$/� N�&?h; ��2)� , tfH �f&,0 A��fe� N�[ N0� +ª=�,<|� =,:�� Ë�&�: Ë?h; b0 ��2� P&�� ,f+ª Y�w B� , \f/!� �f2V,

lj�,�7 ���CJ� SA�J �%�,>7�/V,�7 ���CJ� `.��� , Ë?h�� #%/+ ¢ l,a7� �&���#%J Ë=�&�&�: =�,.+�f�J .+�f�/+ ¢� =�f&�&�: =�, .+�f�J� #f%J ��f2� Of7

A�$/!b� �Gj7,:�B,� Ë?h�� ! �D� B,� ± ±K,Y�A�$/!b�� Y�)�� �Gj7 ,

n� o�Z�� :b 8�xk $�f�2���XV&� ]�f G#� }�n�X&� $�f�2 G#� �m� : $I3)� �\AE

Page 152: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ � −

&�[ Ë�&��� Ë?h�� NBV+ N� Th, S#%/� Y�&?h;=���F3 &G,� 1�B; B� �a�,&G,� N� ¸j�D �22V, ±,m�f%J � �f�A ,b/f9� Í �,

&�[ Ë?h�� O%; c #B;B,� S:� ��a� !=�,U�c t2&: : " Åf[ #B;Be�� "&?h; ÅV,� O%; t[ =�,U�c t2&: : "�B)5� #B;B,� NBV+ <� =�&�[ =� �fV+

#�.�� �, NBV+ N�,Ëf�&�: Ë?h; �J�w : Í B� O7 3 33"3 fc �f&[ .�D�f� �+Q,� &G,� ��c,m�%J � ��A ,u?���� ,O;E ��ae� �a� �+�.J 3

S:� ��ae ".+.�J Í u7�G,� �CD m0 �a� &G,� ¦D �26 �� �w0 �jD�#B;B,�,uf�Le� #Bf;B,� B� #B;B,� �;�� NB[ �� , Ëf?h; f:�� Bf�� Ë�&�:,�A�M� Í Y�&��e� .|VJ N� �+A �� Zs �� �2, r�J� ±, �f)2! \%e��

Y�2Ve�7,#B;B,� �;�� Y�a, .|VJ B� , uf�Le� #B;B,� B� �a,��, �f� f&?h; �fDB[ �&:=�, Y�af,� Y�A�f$/!� �A�fM� Í >f2Ve� Y�f&��e� "af��

S:�B,�,:�B,� #B;B,� �a� >�:<� 2! ¸:<J , �� +ª Y�w >�:<[ S! Y�A�$/!�� "B;�,l:��f,� SA�J �/�:<[ ,�fJ�V,� SA�fJ� , SA�fJ�

��e�,�A�$/!b� u+.L7 +ª .|V/+ �aV�� �G2,�� Y, �A�fM� Í u�j/e�f� S:�� Y�w,f+ª Y�w Ëf� , Y�af, >f+A�$/!� �A�Bf! �A�Bf%,� lf�J�

S:��,J�w �kB[ Í ¥�J b =�>&?h; S:�� 3 t&f� �+Qf,� &G,� T<[ ! �6�z!� Í ÕBL,� �+,� �<! .[w c� t[

>&?h�� "aH OC/+,f�J Ëf/,� Ê�f5,E� Î�%� O&C� 1B�Le� N� ± T�fV:E� X�k<L7� T�V:E� >&�: 8$//, �)&�!, ¸f5, �� �+Q,� &G,� #�.� N�[ Nx�

" #B;Be� "�,Bc Í : " ¢ #Bf;B,� �f&,0 (�f2+ ¢�� #B;B�, .+��� TB)5� O[

n� o�Z�� :$�Nx�D&� ����N&� ���M: G#� }�n�X&� ���c&� ��%&� $�f�2 :W��E

Page 153: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ � −

#B;B� �V+=� " 3UB�%,� �)5J ��,>f�&�: #B;B,�f7 �C/e� Ë2%+ , b Bf)� �7 «.+,D� �� �7 ¥¤ �� "#�.� N�[ N0� ± ± �#B;B,� m0 >$GD �, �a,� ��,� �,

#Bf;B,� Í >f�&���7 ABC/+ b B)�, b0 Of�%J b �Gf5D m0 ��f,� >$GfD w0 A�$/!b� ~j7,#B;B� �D� N��\,�7 �$|+ �&V� ±,.�i 42%� N�[ N0� =, b

��w b� �a�,"#�G�� �/j] Í .�2+ 4/: �2&$&�� ��F3 �! �§ ¢ �+Q,� &G,� N� �&F%,��± f! Bf� "#A�� �af,� ��zf!b�

��&,#, �f7 T�fc �� #B;Be� ¸5, �� TB)5e� N� ��z!b� SAB] Í .[w �&: ±#B;B,�,()�<[ Í .)/�� t[ , 1�f;p� ? :� ��%+ b 42%7 ¯5+ �&V� =�,B�7: "�&,0 �#*+ ��� N��\,� B� X$/e� N�±, T�BfcE� >2Gf,� ! A�)/�b� b

T���E� �+B/7" 3 &G,� 1.­ �2� ¸j�D �jD�,m�%J � ��A ,1�B�� �! , Of|� f%+ O�� Ø � K

7�B; T<V,� �a�=��B�,� ��z!b� �a� �! ,SBf�,� >f+�s Í Bf� �a,� O7 , �9�9� �� ��ae� �a� S.V5, T#�I��3 ��zf!b� �! �§ ¢ >�&��� Í �D0 ±

>/$,�,fe� �afH NB�?��,� �2! �&§ N� X&L/G+ �,� fc<R� ��a=�, (fk� �fe�R #B;B,� S:B7 NB2++,Y�#Bf;Be� -�CfJ�7 �B�f9 N0 (k0 �, Ëf� Ëf/,��

Y�2Ve�,9�A ()$�a� �B�� >�&�: #B;B,�7 =�,�: NB2�*� B)� =� "af� Np7 l,a[ �)9� Y�2Ve�,m�%J � #B;� Ë� >�&��� Í �)2V, , (�fD� �af,�

�t�D� �)&,0=�f+A�$/!� =�,Bf] f! Y�f&&�J� Y���f6�� �GfD SA, Í �f2V, >�&��� �;� ! �)�?��: Í A�9 B� >�&���,&Gf,� �7 ¥¤ t[ ± �, � �f�A

m�%J,�,Bc Í r+�J ³�7� : "��c Nx� �:#Bf;B,� N� `.f+ �&� UB�J �w�� ±,

n� o�Z�� :d��kS&� :W�Ou−�OQE

Page 154: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ � −

�;�B,� 8! �DB[ X�,T�G�Db�� ¡hF/�, O7�c Zs� , O[�&� ! �G$D� c Y�#B;Be�, �)&� .)��,��&f�E� �f� �� �f2! Bf�� <f� , �f)2&! Bf� Of7 �)/�&�:�,>+A�$/!� Y�2&%J� Y�&&�/7 Y#%J� Yª�/�� tD0� , l,a, O|+� Ø � K

S.|V/e� ��B�E� AB] Í "AB)�� .j$,�7, .j$,� >�&�: b0 ��2� P&, �D� X� ���3 �w :Of�%,� ABfR ��A� ABfR �af� N� �f� T<f[ �f2� ��9 c±, b�

>&5�V,� Y����e�7 b0 �&,0 O]B/+,>&��%,� Y�.��2e� N�# , �fe ¯&� O[� �, u��"3

�af� Í S���fe� >f+#B;B,� S.f|V,� N� Í �f2� rf+¤ ¦fD SA�f$%,� "a)�±#B;B,�,�­��w S.|[ ! ,�)9�2;�� ,�)!�BD�� ,�)C?�C�� ,�­�5]� , tD0

m�%J � #B;� Ë�,��� ,9 b� A�&s� <� `B3 � m�%J ,�D�j$9 , Of[ �! ¦�D,>�i O[ �! "h2J� 3

�+Q,� &G,� �]� N0±,m�%J � ��A , O�%,� ABR �B� �Dp7 ��ae� �a� �2� r+¤ O&,# B�,�+� =�,��afe� �af� N<fL7 f! , N� �f�<[ 4f2%� w0 ±

O&,,� �a� ÖJ.+ b O�%,�,�fF+� "#.f+ Of7 ×, �<f�%,� Xf&' UBf�! NE ±XL�J,.�2,�� #�)/;<, �%� U�µ b t7 ,�!B2J� ".|VJ� #B;B,� #%/7 ��F3

&Gff,� ffFD �aff,,m�ff%J � �ff�A , -B�ffV,� ff! ��affe� �aff� U�ff:� Y����ffe��, �ffI »ff6.J Off?b# Y����ffe�� -B�ffV,� YA�ff] 4ff/��

}B52,�,1B��,� �)&,0 ��LJ� , ABf�� f&;�Be�� Y����e�� -B�V,� N0 ±

n� o �����? '�x?z� R� /�; H�� m�n�&� d�2) 8KS. R� =�p G5x^. 1s�z� |�f '�I>? "L%5�A 8KSD&� aKA t�MpAaN-&� 3�� ��3) H� ,$����X&� '��I4� R. H�#� 8:�� �D?) , /V&�

~ $?�V9. �K�X:" W�^5&� "���;) E "&�-&�) "#-&�) aN-&� �I�. :�OW ��E

Page 155: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ � −

<&,# %J b >&2R�7 >&c�w= × K��t�%,� ��5J�7 ,NBD�fc� �7�f6 �fI P&, �D� l,w ±, -</�b�� Y��5/,� >+�s Í Y����e�� -B�V,� N� TB�%��±, ��V2+ t�

u: �D� ! }�2,� �� +h,±,OfR�7 �D� ! }�2,� �� �.%, ��V2+ ±, (f[� ���Qf,� .��� �,�Æ >�R�7 `��!# �B!#� }�D�, f! }�f2�, ��B�fc� ± �

��V,� u$R3f!° .fV2J b �f¬ Y����fe�� -B�V,� N� �a� Í u��� = ±�, �Q,� .��B� �,�Æ b N� ¶Q7 �V,�, P&, B)� �Q,� �,�� ��[ OV�

Î��A ��V7,Î�L&� ��[ B� O7 , O�f&, �$:�] ��c Í N�L&�,� �$] ± ��7 � #�$! , � 1�7 �! ()��+� ,�2+#� 3

>2Gf,� Of�� 2! S���e�� ��V,��, �fc.R f:�� (f�%,� f&5+ N�f[ N0� S\/%e���F ,Å�2,�� Å�%,�� Ó�� O&,,� m0 >��60, >f&�7 �f! ª�f/+ �D� b0 ± ±

n� od�� '��IA G#� d�K�cD&�) $5f�9D&� ���-: ~ $�0�^&� C�3��� �5#Vk� , ��� R. "L�D0

��>? $5f�9D&�" "L5&� G#� �V%� �. ���? R�-&� =A3 H�>U ��-#& H�� �c9�0" E "LY-? R�)" 3�^?4�? ���-&� C�5f�9. , '�^:��? t�#N&� C�5f�9.)" E�Z�� :oD#&� :W� E R. "L�.)

�sg&� �L����>? �L0�� :""#-&�? $5f�9. ,"L5&�? $?�pz� y�NM: /K) ,'�M&�? $5f�9.) , /K)'�M&� dm��b $��3 y�NM: ,)) ��2�V&�? $5f�9.) d3�fz� $Mp y�NM: /K" E�Z�� : ~ �s.z�

���2z� C��9f� ,���2z� t�V9? yM#. :W�� E ��>? ���2z� H?�VU ~ /&�(,&� �L0�� �I) �DU" $.�.SD&� H:�5p R. HV�U(:) ���Lx: ��� 8#N&� ~ �LZ� 3�� , d��gU 3�.A 3��&� �&7 R. �c9��)

�K��D�A a�I R. oD%� ��U ,�-. �L& "K�V�0$MYV. ��; $#DX. } ,��7 7� JYVV0 , a^M: GV2H��M�� �� C�S? $�N�NM&� $0�-D&� ,C�.�V&� C��I��&� H:�5^?) ,H&�-0>?) EEE" ER��&� 1�#� ���2� :

��W �Q− � E ��>? =��cN&� ��� �L5��-: ��n)"����&� �-�? 8#N&� 3�Y2 , �SK ~ �NV5. ��;a�&�&� a.>: G&� $&�M&� ,�%&� 8#x:)a� ,8��&� /��)m R. ��XV%. �) , �-� R� t�XM. �)

8�,&�" E$���cN&� $&���&� :W�� , ��>? "�N&� R?� �L0��)"t�&� �Lh�M� 1�#� ,G&�-:) H��M�� ,��-&� 8#I ~ , ���; G#� G5_: 3�.A G#� �� H-#x�)" ER�9&�%&� �3��. :Wu�O E /#� �L0��) H�>? =3�N&�"c�0 8#N&� ~ �LZ� 3�� 8�,&� H? �K�" E"#-&� R�� ]�f :��W �P E ��%&� ���)

Page 156: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{ � −

H�>? �c9&� ���c&�"$���,&� }�-D&� R. t�XM&� ��3) �. G#� {s��� , $�N�NM&� $�5_&� 3�.4�)

�m�Lf) �m�jn)< <" EC�j5��-V&� :W�QO ,�jZ��) :��3�-V&� C�DL. G#� ��I�V&� :W��� E �� C�5��-V? d�K�cD&� ��0�� �I) �DUd , ��A �L�." $D� ��N? ��; R. yM&� 3�Y2 " E $&���&�

$���cN&� :W�� E ��A �L�.)"yM&�? d�K�c. ,��2�V&� a`��? ���f4� $��3 /K) , d�K�c.)yM#& ,���f4� ~ yM&� $��3 /K) ,yM&� d�K�c.) , t��:3� s? R�N�&� $N�N2 /K)" E ~ �s.z�

���2z� C��9f� ,2z� t�V9? yM#.��� :W�� , ��A �L�.)" �V? t�XM&� ��N� <" E 'b��.R��`�%&� :W��P E ��>? ���c&� ��%&� �L0��)"��2�V&� a`��? ���f4� $��3 , ��b�? y#x:)

�f ��; R. R�N�&� $N�N2 ,���f4� ~ yM&� $��3 ��b�? y#x:) ,H& =S&� Hn�&� �K �&7) ,G&�-: , �/f aU ~ HV��K�� 8%M?" E�5��-V&�C :W Q ,��3�-V&� C�DL. G#� ��I�V&� :W�P� E

8XM&� ��c9��) R�N�&�) "#-&� ~ e�IA) �fA) ":A �DL�A ~ ��5#Vk� �I) , |�cU "LY-�0":A d�K�cD&� �A e�� =)�L&� 1s�z� ,$5f�9D&� ��0 /K) E�Z�� :R��`�%&� 'b��. :W��P ,

�Z��) :R�9&�%&� �3��. :Wu�Q ,�L%&�) =��cN&� =A3 �K)=m3) ,�Y�A E�Z�� : $&���&�$���cN&� :W�� ,�3�-D&� �3��� ,���2z� t�V9? yM#. :W P� E�)�kT e��) , �^� /?>U

d�K�cD&�) $5f�9D&� �A ���%&� ,G�-D&� ~ R�?3�NV. ���U ��) ,G�-D&� ~ ":A �c9&� �A �� E �Z��oD#&� :W�� E

�L�. aU ~ C��n /V&� C�5��-V&� ��0 aU G#�)B ,0y�� �D� ,$?3�NV. ,$�0�^&� ��� �DKsU) , a?$�%&� aK A ���) ,}�#&� "#-&� R. ,�m��� t�#I ~ �� H�N#� =S&� "#-&� �&7 �K) , y`�N2 ��U3��0

+M?) �Z� R� � ���f4� E+��MV&� H�.) ,1�L&z�) ,$Im�^&� $�.��D&� e��&�) , �� R. /K /V&�)G&�-: E�L&z�) +��MV&� �V_� R9&1 ,1��D&� ~ � $ZN�&� ~ d�K�cD&�) $5f�9D&�) E

}�#&� "#-&� R. d�K�cD&�) $5f�9D&� "#-0 ,�f s? E�SK ~ �Z�� : 1s�z� $XM& $���#&� $&���&�/&�(,&� ,/&��-&� 3�^N&� a`��3 RD� :W����K�-? �.) ,=b��&� �_5#& ���9&� ��%5V&� :� �

W�P�−�P� E ��D#-&� y5:� �I R9&– C��K�cD&�) C�5f�9D&� $�NM? "�#%V&� �-? – 1�� d3)�� G#�

{�c&� �K��Z& ���5&�_. ,d3)�Y&�? R��&� R. 1�#-. �K �. $p�k E aU �A G#� ��-DnA �I �S&�M�Mp ����f �^� �&�_� �cU< < < ,�L�#� oDXD&� {�c&� 1�92A �&�_�) , �5cU �-� s0 H? �V-� �<

����D23 ��L&�< < , �cU �K a?}�x�f /%�#?� E

Page 157: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ن نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين م

− �{ � −

�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 oDX. :���W OOu ,a`���&� o.�n :� W QO�K�-? �.) , �3��.

R�9&�%&� :Wu� �K�-? �.) ,}�U�c#& /&�&� �xI ,�L�&� ��x&�) �� $��) t�VU RD� :W��P�K�-? �.) E

$�0�^&� $D`A R. }�3��&� '�I ,G&�-: �� HD23 :"N�NM&� �9�: �D?3 �L& �7T s0 �.�� R�-?3A /�#I $ $�%&�) t�V9&� R. R��K�c? �� /�#I ak�: �A" E

aL� '�I) ,G&�-: �� HD23 :" a���0 $�%&�) t�V9&� H& �Lc� � �n) aU B" E ���X&� '�I) :"y#_&� G#� dm)�%. �L#U ��x&� ,'���&� �hA G5VI� R. G#� �� , ds^&� H�#�

1s%&�)"E ,'�I) ,�A�Y :" $�%&�) t�V9&�? ��N. ��D#� " E '�I H�A =3��&� R�%M&� /?A R� ��n) :"�� o. /��� HV�A3 R. ,an) (� , �2 R� Hn�_: $&�2

H�?�N: s0 {�c&� "#� ,a�&m �L�#� '�� � $&�2 /��� HV�A3 R.) , HD��0 �K�� �52 �L& �Lc� �)H��m G#�" E

'�I H�A /xN%&� =�%&� R�) :" R. �&�; �L0 "92 �K�� qN�� "#� R��? G�m�"E b��_&� ��-� �?A '�I) ,G&�-: �� HD23 :" a��? �L0 �K�� H5&�_� R��? aU " E d3�LcD&� $�0�^&� ����I R.) :" $I��b /L0 $-��c&� �5&�k $N�N2 aU " E }s�X&� 3m�N&���� 1�.z� '�I ,��� �� r�I :"0 R���&� HN0��� � �K�� aU ���SK �L" E /&7�c&� R%M&� /?A 1�.z� R�) ,G&�-: �� HD23 ,��U H�A'�N� :" J�M^&� �5cU @3�� �7� ��c9&� {m) $�%&�) t�V9&�? aD��0 $�%&�) t�V9& ,�� �� �%5�& aI) ,G&�-: , $D^-&� /& RD�

$�%&�) t�V9&� ~ , 1�L&z�) �c9&� 8��n ~ /& �L�DY� "&)" E �X� R?� aN�)��%MV�z� a��� G#� H& �.sU /���c&� 1�.z� R� $�L&z� C�2�V5&� ~ $�< , R.

H&�I H�0 ��n �. $#Dn :">x_&� H�#� o�VD� RD? ���VI�� o. �N� �A ���#� 8n��&� , R� �N�)'�9f� H? ���VI�� ~ �L� �7� H�#� b�X� RD? ���VI�� , t�V9&� G#� $D`4� R� ��n �. @�-� a?

$�%&�),���#�I �s�I �D0 ,���U�: �s�N� "&�.) , $�0�^&� '��IA {��:� G#� a�&�&� ��& 1�I �7� ���#� �.)$�%&�) t�V9&� G#� �L��� �-? �� "L&�D�A) ,"Lk��f Gp) �&S?) , 82�p H? ��n �. �A)

$�%&�) t�V9&� G#� @�-� 1�L5&�) '��24�) 1�#-&� R. �)S&�) �n�&� ,�s�I ��0 , "& ��)�J^" E H?�VU ~ �)3b |�c&� �U7)" ��^V&� ����I "H&�I ,d���I :" R. H��9? �)�c. Hn�V&� ��p

yM&� ����� +�2 ,G&�-: , ����� �D?)" E'�I) ,�Y�A :" H�#� >x_&� ��5V�� 1�^-D& �� o�V. � " E

Page 158: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�{ −

H&�I =���XL&� R� ��%#9�� aN�) :"��5� $N�NM&� ��; R. $-��c&� , R. $N�NM&�) $-��c&� ��;

m�M&�" E '�? =���XL#& t�XMD&� �cU ~ ��n R9&" m�M&�) ��5� " $D#U "'�M." E �� $0�-. ~ r��&� �&�%. t�XMD&� �cU H?�VU ~ =���XL&� �U7 �I) ,G&�-: , "L�. �US0

�� $0�-. G&� �LN��� �A /��: $5`�� ,G&�-: , 1�L&z� �K–C��K�cD&�) ��c9&� =A −�� '�N0 '�M. a��%&� �SK ,yM&�) a���&� ��K�? $0�-D&� �4 , >x_&� G#� ��K�? 1�L&z� aK4 ��&)

t��^&�) ,�� �>? "L#. }� '�N� ��2�) �4< ,G&�-: ,��9. H& ��& ,�kT '�N�) : H& �>? "L#. /������9.< ,R�:m�YVD&� R�����&� R�:�K e�2� 8��n ~ yM&� ��9� �A $&�M. �) ,�DL�. aU) /��� 1�L&z� ,R����D&� R�SK tSU) ��p ��5�& (�D. $&�M. � 1(#�) ,a�&�&�? ��-� S`���)B E �A G&�'�I :���gU �SK ~ ��&�,� �.�I �A ����.b ~ ��A3 �I)< < ,m��-&� y��� G&� "L&�2 ���%��)� , o�DX&�)

$&s� G#� ,�sN-&� o�DX& �&�_. "L&�I) ,1�L&z� ����� R. d�c� �4� '��IA d�c-? ����� �2�) "92 ~ $YI��V. ,$#��? �L#U e)���&� ��9V0 E'�I �A G&� :$���K) d���) {�f $0�-D&� , �

1�L&� , $0�-D&� ~ 1�L&z� "92)– G&�-: �� $0�-. =A – ��n�&� a9? a��? " E =3�N&� /#� '�I) :"{�Dnz�) $�%&�) t�V9&�? '�p4� ~ �%DV&� , R� @���z�) @����

���� )A ���k , �K��; �)m $����&�) e�L&� R� �L.�^V��" E '�I) ,�Y�A :"a��? 1s90 "L&�2 "L�&� "#%� ���N5&� �� $#LX&� q-? '�I �.A) , 8n��&� a?

$��DMD&� $-��c&� G#� "L&�-0A) "L&��2A @�� ,$����&� $�%&�) t�V9&�) ,a�I �DLN0�) �D0 , �.)m3 �DL5&�k , m3) �DU" m3 �L0 H�. ��& �. �SK ���.A ~ ��2A R. " E'���&� $N��� �� $N��� s0 ,1s%&� H�#� ,HVN�N2 �� $N�N2 �) ,HV-��f �� $-��f �) , H:��N� �� d��N� �)" E

3�x��&� R��&� ��� '�I) :"���� H���?) ��K�� R9� "& �� $N�NM&� "&�� , R�� HVN�N2 ��9: �>?HV-��f ,��?)��K�� R�� H� , H? 3�9D.  `�b �L0"E

{�c&� G#� @�-: C��K�cD&�) ��c9&�) C�.�L&z� �A yM&�) ,$�%&�) t�V9&� G#� , �D0a�I �DLN0�) ,{�c&�? m��V��� ��U) ,]�� �DL5&�k �.) ,H? m��V�� �) ,{�c&�? m��V��� a? E

���X&� '�I ,G&�-: �� HD23 :" R� 1�N&� m��0� ��2�V&� ��M&�" E y�� �D�0 �Z�� :oD#&� :W��� ,$���cN&� $&���&� :WO�−O ,WO� ,WOu ,W OO ,

��#?� ���#: :W��u ,��^V&� R� y`�N2 :W��P ,}�?�&� JV5&� :W�O , ���&)4� C�N��RN#D&� R?� :W� � ,"DL&� ��N�� :� W O� −O�O ,"DL&� ��N�� ¡.�� $�L&z� C�2�V5&� :

��W Q� ,V&� ����I��^ :W� ,W � ,t�XMD&� �cU :WP�O��%� ��^V? , ]�f

Page 159: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

Î�;� Ëc�w .�� �Dp7 O?b,�,�$:�C7 ·�� ,u?<M� �&�! X�L+ b , �af, b B)�<&,# %+= Ø � K��Zs �� >&!Q,� TB�%,� Í ��B9 �\/%� , (�%,� �J#��0 �V,

�Q,� ·BCD .��B�, �/���B7 ¶�Q� >&2+,� >&!Q,� �+���,� Í, >]�� �B�%� �)2� N�[ ��=�SA�À,�7 �+,� �� ,m�f%J � >f&D�:� >,pGf� O|[ ,

���M �/2+�$��,�f)2� ��f, �/�@�¬ T!� ,¤ �f� f! ·BCf2,� �f7 �f:1�$,� �a� Í >�&5/Ge�,�f&�! �f�.��B� �f,#� , Sf:� ��af� f%+ �f¬ × � K

1�&JA� b� l� Zs �� �I T#�C� #B;B,�3 �Q,� .��� ! �.%+ ��V,� N� �t�%,� �&�! u5J� �a,� u���K � � K ±, ����� t�

�7 a��,�Q,� ·BC27 S\%,� N�[� ,¥.R� #A �5,�� ��� ± K,b� N�[� #�/!�Q,� ·BC27,��+� , �Qf,� ·BC2, �/5,�² b� �/���B� �$|+ ¢ �� ���� ±

�t�%,� �&� ��/�� �a,� �a)�, N� u��� ? b T� �$:�] `, (�%,� &5+ O� ±�$:�C, UB[B� �B2,� �a� .��,1aV+ b� �C+ b ± � K3c#�f] NBfV+ t7.�� =�

Xc�B�, %7 t&� �/�7�L7 �c] ��V2+, �� 7w�[ NBV+=��, �/�#�C� AB)�, 3 �B�fc� #Bf;B,� Sf:B7 NB�?�f�,� �!ª �a,� ��V,� Nx� U�: O[ !�± ± ±

SABLM� >+�s Í >&!° >+�! >&�c Ë� ��$R ! (��B!#, �f)&�! �Jz+� SZ|[ >&2+# O[���, �.f� ! >&��,� "aH .@p/J >&2+,� �+���,� X&' N0 O7 ±

�H (&�G/,� ,� b�m�%J � NB[ >&�c �,#B;B,� �;�� , #Bf;B,� �a� B� ��[,�?�h;� X&F7 ,�9�2;�� ,�!�BD�� ,"#�.��� ,�J�5f]� �Cf?�C�� , ��

�2! OC52� �, .+���,�, �+�$�� , O�/Gf�� h&/� ·�� #B;B7 �J�a7 #.5/�

"#-&� R�� :��W OQ ,��%#9�� ��cV%D#& 1s�z� ~ $�0�^&� :WQ� ,W�^5&� m3 :

W��� ,"�2�&� RD2�&� JV0 :W�P�E

Page 160: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

¢�%,� #B;� �!3SABLM� >+�s Í >,pG� �k� l� b� , O?�Ge� O]� Ë� O7 2+,�>+#��/!b� >&3 �f� �b*f� �f!ª �af,� ��V,� �a� �.! �;� �a,

#Bf;B,� �a� Í �A�G,� u�Le� #B;B,� B� #B;B,� �;�� NB[, �Gf$2e�� Y�#B;Be� O[�&� !,�)&� >�&��� >); ! .���� , �f� Bf�� b �f&j7

Y�#B;Be� �� �� "#B;�,�Q,� ·BCD ! ,f���B� N�[ N0 (�%2, =� �fI �² T�5,=� 3 Nbf+ tfk� �D;B, >2G,�� 1�/V,� �� �Q,� ·BCD �2%$/J B,�

#Bff;�� Y��w �ff! "#Bff;�� m�ff%J � Y�w U�Cff5D� ff! >ff%R�c >ff,b#Y�cB�de�,�)2! "ª�&/��� ,�fI �/2+�$�� ,f�,�� �fDB[ f!� =� >f); f! �fI

Z@p/,�� �&�!�5,�,t+c �DB[ �&: �� =��/� =�#B;B,� Í �)&�! ,� �fkB[ ��#B;B,� Í m�%J �2! S.�p/� >@#�:3m�f%J U�fc : " Bf�� �� �f�|[ P&f,

ZC$,� X&G,�"��F3 >&2&2@Â, Y�$@� �)&��,m�%J �J�w ,"Zs Y��w� ,>f�@te� Ëf5D rf] �fe b0� 3

�,Bc ��|��,�D�j$9 : " :� �B5[ �, �V+ ¢�� � = K � �� K K ± �K �"� F,U�fc� ,Of?�c �f� hf! : " ��� � � AB×2,�� Yt��,� O%;� �AE�� Y��tG,� u�� �a,� �Ø� � � � � ±� � � � � �� � �K � � ±× � � � � K"�OF, U�c�

�?�&�! Í }�J: " u��f7 b0 t)�2&7 ��� �AE�� Y��tG,� ��2��� ���Ð � � � � � ± �� �� �± � K � � � � � �� � � � "��F, U�c�: " E� u�� �a,�7 N�.5V/, (V±2?� Oc� �� � � ± � �� � �� K KK �� K� � �#�D� �, NB�%v� 8�B+ Í �A= K � � � �� � � K� � � � � � �� �

8e�%,� 1A l,w� � �� �� × � � �* �f)&� Afc� �f)&� �A�f7� �)cB� �� Õ��A �)&� O%;� � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � �� � �± � �� � � 8�?�G�, ��B9 T�+� >%7A� Í �­�Bc�� �� � �± � � �Ð � ± � � �Ò � � �� � *�# Ë�� �tG,� m0 `B/9� (@� K � �� � ± � ±� � � � K U��� N�� � � �

n� oe3�c&� d3�� , $�l���E

n� oWskz� d3�� , $�l��E

n  o1�-�4� d3�� , $�l� E

n� o�XM&� d3�� , $�l�uPE

Page 161: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�  −

8%?�R ��2&J� �/,�c ��.[ �� �!BR �&/?� �A¼,� �I� =� � � � �� � � �� � � � �� �� �� = � �� � � � � �* Y��tf9 X$9 ������Ò � � � ±� � � K � � � �f�5:� r&7�Cf7 �&Df,� �tGf,� �f±2+ª� ��.�� �t9 O[ Í 4:��� 8�B+ Í= � � � � � � ± � � � � � �� �� � ± � � � � � �� × � � � �Ð K � ��

h%,� .+�J l,w� � � K � �� �� �(&�%,� h+� � � � �"��FU�c� : " �af,� (fV7A ��f$!� }�f±2,� �fq� �f+� ± K � ×K ± K K �� K � � �NB�/J (V�%, (V�$c �� �+a,�� (V���� K � �± � � � �K K K± � ± �� � � �� � � � "� F3

U�%�E� Ê�5,p7 Y��; Ë/,�� Ni.�,� Í SZ|V,� Y�+g� �� ��Zs�, Of%5[ " u�M�" �� " O%�� " �� " .+BC/,� " �� " .+BV/,�" �� " >J����� ��&:�� ", ��" �ª.,� "3 333»,�, �)��f6�� Ni.f�,� �f)&,0 A��� Ë/,� U�%�E� "a� OV�

mBe�,<!� O; ,�J�w m0 ,>�&�: �7 ���c >&�&�: >&�%� Y�5] Ë� , Ëf�� UBf%5e�� Of!�5,� 87 S.+��e� �;BJ,�Bf�de�� u,�fM� 3 ^�f2/+ �f� Bf��

�,� ��ae� X� >:�¤#B;B,� S:B7 O?�3 uf$R f! �f7�7A� �f�c �af,�� ±��V,�3

�,Bc �+#�:E� ���,(�f9� �&�! � ] : " �f%� �� b� � N�f[ "�OF, >+��A Í�" "Zs �� b� " >|,�@� " ��$c �� b� " >f&2&2@� m0 Z�J �)�[� #B;B,�;%7 t&� �)��� Ë/,� ��&�E�� m�%J � 3

�+#�:E��; SZ|[ 1�$,� �a� Í=�, .f[w Í Y#A� Ë/,� �+#�:E� >]�� >&�%5,� m�%J � Y�5],u�M�f[ ,�ª.f,�� ,��f&:��� ,>fJ����� , Xf�.,��

~5M��,~$�,�� �G$,�� ,Ubw��� ª�h!��� ,3 33»,�, >f,b# UfJ �kx� UB%5�, O!�5,� S.+��� ! >%R�c,�B�d�, u,�M� 3

Ì�/9� �$�w B,� ! �A��,� ·BCD >,b# ! >2G,�� >7�/V,� X� >,#E�

n� o�#^0 d3�� , C��l�Q−� E

n� od�N�&� d3�� , $�l� �E

n  oHX��_: 1�N: , "I3 ¡.�K �Z���POEF

Page 162: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

#B;B,� >&2&2@�;#Bf;B,� �f;�� #Bf;� ,m�f%J � ,Y�fcB�de� #Bf;�� , Y�2Ve� ,OC5,� U�L, Y�#B;B,�� Y�#B;B,� h+�� !� O7, �f� Ë$Gj� �&,0 Y°�3

�,�f² �fDx� �Qf,� Of?b# .��Bf� ��afe� �a� >5,�² m0 >��6��$� �a�, ��+�,Of�%,� O?b# XR�B�, , Y�#Bf;B,� .+�f�/7 >&f6�c >&f6�c �fDB[ �f�

>�&�: ��.|VJ� Y�#B;Be��,�f�#B;� A.f�/� u?���� Y��w N�� ±, 4f2%7 �A�M� Í NBV,�,>�&�: ,A�$/!b� O&$9 ! b , �afH NB�?��,� �;�A �a,� K � ± �

��ae�3 6�z!� u7�G,� ��&,# Í &G,� #A�� �,=� �&�! �f2! 1�;� (@,�f,Bc Bf�� : "

#B;B� �DB[ Í ��/y B� �� O[ >�?��,� >��e� ! �F/+ (%D=� Bf)� "Zfs m0 �&L, X2� �V¬�;#B;B� �DB[ Í ��/je� N� B�� = ±�"Zfs m0 ,"f;B� Bf� ,

%Lc �V¬=�,#B;B� �DB[ Í ��/je� b =�"Zs m0 , "#Bf;� Bf� �af,� "3 (f@ �,B�7 �2! 1�;�: "+� u&c# .�27 X�2, m0 �f/+#B;B� Í ��f/:� �e �D� B�� ±

"Zs �� l,w #�5/9� �� "Zs,�B�%� A�]� =��BcB� �, =��&�! l,w Í , O[� �V¬ B)� l,a[ B� �� , �� "#Bf;� �f&�! -BfcBe� Zf�,� l,w Ë9 ��B9Ð K

";B�"3 �! �5,b� Ybb# �.� �&[ .�D� �+Q,� &G�, m�%J � .5s �f��Bj�

�, �%6� ���, Ëf?h; #Bf;B7 S#Bf;Be� Sf:�B,� Y�a,� �C&, �D0 4/: ±Ë�&�:,�;�B,� Y�w Ë�� ,m�%J ,u�Le� #B;B,� B� �a,�� , 1B;B7 SA�J #B;B,�,�f]B,� �afI uj/Ge� �DB[ �&: �� ,�f%� Zfs b A�f$/!�7 , b�

#B;B,� Í >&2&2@�,/!b� ".f|VJ �f&: �f� N�fV���7 `.f�� SA�fJ� �A�f$, "2! -B]Be��,>&|&�� "a� �� ,N�V���7 ,��&/:<, Th�/Ge� 3 Ofc�! �p�

Page 163: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�+B/,� �a� O|� �&�! Ë5�,�Dp[� ±,m�%J � ��A ,Y�f2Ve� #Bf;B7 .f�+ × � K, >�&��� >); !,Y�#Bf;Be� "af� ��&/:�7 "A�.c� , Y�.f|VJ Ëf� Ëf/,��

>+A�$/!�,u�Le� #B;B,� SÀ: m0 , �a,�� #B;B,� �;�� B�3 Xfc�B,� t2&7 ��&/:� b� N�V�0 b N� N�)�+ >�&�����,>f+Z$%J >f+ª�µ Ê�f5,� Ëf� tD0 ,

Î�%e� >sA��,O&C�� S?�� �)?�A� �� P&, , �af� >f�&�: ��f5�0 �)2� #�.+ ��ae�,#B;B,� �;�� N� B�� ±,m�%J � ,�f�[ #Bf;B,� �a� B� , Xf&F7

"#�.��� �?�h;�3 <)�± �<fF7 �f/�&�:� �fJ7ª� ��afe� �af� >f]<� �+Qf,� &G,� .[w

>�Be� Y�A�$%,� l�J U�|�� m0 �B� Zs �� ¥B6��3 S:�B,� Y�a,� NB�� �]� ��A� �� O&C�� S?�� �p�±, lf�J Ë� Ë/,��

Y���6��� �G2,�� Y�A�$/!b�,Y�2Ve�7 , �D�[ �w0 ¹' ¹' Y�a,� l�J S:�B,�,B� �a,�� #B;B,� �;�� ,u�Le� #B;B,�� 3

&G,� O&C5J N0±,m�%J � ��A ,l�Ge� �aH #B;B,� S:� ��ae ; l�G� Y���6��� �G2,�� Y�A�$/!b�7 S:�B,� Y�a,� .|VJ, l�Gfe� �f2&%7 Bf�

ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� �V�9 �a,�,uf�Le� #B;B,� .|VJ >�+.L, �D�&7 Í O$c �� , #B;B,�7 U�c t2&:&�e� #B;B,�� u�Le� ,�&,0 SA���� ���J t[ 3

Í Ï.! �7� -BCJ �]� t2&: 8%$9 �7� ÍBC,� -BG�&5,� �] �,�#B;B,� S:�,Y���6��� �G2,�� Y�A�$/!b�7 �,B�, ,>F® >5G�� �kp7 3

�/fD�� �®� #B;B,� Í B� �/5G�� Nx� (V�� �a� Í �c] X� �V,�±, �fDE ±B,� `.+>��Le� S:,A�f$/!b� uf+.L7 Bf,� Y�f2V¬ (f@ t� ± �, Í �� OfV�

>:�¤ #B;B,� 1B;B7 �]B+ #B;B,�,uf�Le� #B;B,� Y�2&%J �� �DE , #B;B,� �;�� B� �a,�3

Page 164: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

عدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودموقف الس

− �{�� −

�,Bc 2! �+Q,� &G,� T<[ ! "#�ª �&L� »&�,� �z!� c�: " �e �D0 ± �/+#B;B� Í ��/:�"3�,B�7 : "j7 �&� UBc� �, .�� >+#B;Be�7 #�A� N0 �DE �

#B;B,�7 -�CJb� Zs,-B]Be�7 ���&c� , �afH >+#B;Be� YB$|7 (�GD <� 42%e�, #Bf;B,� m0 �f);�&/:� NBf[ (�GD <� T�&�,�� -�CJb� �H #�A� N0� �h�/G�=� #B;Be� N�V�� "��F3

�&;� ��z!� B��,SB�,� >+�s Í� ,O$c �J.[w �� 42%7 B�� Of&�c 3 lf,w >�V, >&c �� �D�± ±" >f+#B;Be� " �Cf/e� #Bf;Be� �f� "#�.f� �fV+ ¢ N0 �?#B;B,� >5C7 ! <f� #Bf;B,� >5f] �� `.%� #B;Be� NB[ �7 42! N0 �Dx�± K� �

l,w �%52+,>+#B;Be� u�j/J ¢ �DE ±,a�2&: Ò, ABCf/+ b #Bf;� <7 #B;B� "#B;� O�%,�,c<R0 =�,�� ���J t[ �&,0 SA��3 >5Cf7 �C/e� �7 42! N0� �

��z!� �� .|[� �&�! Th, �� #B;B,�, "#�ª �f&L� »&�,� ".[w �� U�E� #Bf;B,� >2V¬ �kB[ Th�/G+ b �)&,0 #B;B,� Tt�D� m0 >&��e� ��&/:� N� ��±

�­�w Í,�A�fM� Í uf�j/� #B;B,� �;�� Nx� ±, Tt�fD� ¸f:<+ Of�%,�� 0 ·�fM� "#B;��f/&��� m,>f&��e� m0 #Bf;B,� Tt�fD� �f� Th�/Gf+ b� ,

#B;B,� m0 >&��e� ��&/:��,#B;Be� N�V�0 ,#B;B,� �;�� B� �a,�� 3 �� #B;B,� �;�B7 �2� ~�2,� r] 3 �.f� �f� Thf�+ �fD� .�g� ��z!b��±

m0 >f�&�: #Bf;B,� .f|VJ >f�&�: #B;B,�f7 �Cf/e� >+#B;Be�7 "#�.� NB[?�c Y�#B;�Y�#B;Be�7 >&�&�: >,�+Q,� &G,� �&�J.+ b�� B�� , ��A

m�%J �3 >�7�G,� �JA�$! Í �+Q,� &G,� UBc ����: " �V¬ B)� l,a[ B� �� O[� "

n� o���XV&� ]�f G#� }�n�X&� $�f�2 G#� �m�b 8�xk $�f�2 : $I3)� �\tE

Page 165: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>�! m0 S.�/5� u?��: �D�[ B, t&� Y�2Ve�7 Y�#B;Be� �]� rC+ tDx��­�&���� �­��w �! >�C52�,B,� 8! �k�� ��� ± � ��f;�, #Bf;B,� Bf� �af,��

u�Le�, N�fV��� 4f2%� �f! >f7A�%,� >&G/,� #.µ b0 �?�A� �� O&C� <� Ë�&���,¥<L]b� Í a�2&: >:��� b� Ò3

�+Q,� &G,� UBc ����±,m�%J � ��A : " 8f! #Bf;B,� NBf[ f+*+ �f¬� T%,� Í�2+ �J�w : Í #B;B,� N� �;�B,�±,B)5e� %7� B�� UBf$c �! Y��

T%,�"�f,B�7 "#�ª �f&L� »&�f,� �f&�! �zf!� f�� : " S�f��2e�7 #�A� N0 ���.%,� A�$/!�7 ,�,Bc �&�! U+ t[: " T%,� UB$c �! Y��B)5e� %7� B��

"3l,w (�GD <� 3�,Bc �� �&�! U/9� ��� : " �f! Xf2/+ b "�f! �f� NE ± T%,� UB$c"3��7 P&, ,N� Th�/G� �DE ��)�f&�27 >5f] Of[ �Cf/J b ,

�)&� O&,,� �a� N�+.�,<|� ��&$,� N� U���� = ±��&�27 �C/+ , N� rC+ w0 �~&7p7 P&, ��&$,� U��+3(�G� �C,� A�$/!�7 S���2e� �7 #�A� N0� , �V,�

%5D �§ b=�, :�� -B]B� Í �t/;b� Í S���2e� +A� N0 �a[� "��F3 »&�,� ��z!� 42%��f&��2� #B;B,� O%; �+Q,� &G,� N� "#�ª �&L�= ±�

T%�,, �f)2� "#�.f� NBV+ N� ��0 ? &G�, Y�#�.� ¾<@ O/� S���2e� "a�� ±��.%,� A�$/!�7 S���2e�,�Cf,� A�$/!�7 S���2e� ��0� ±,f|,�@ �f�0� =� Í S�f��2e�

:�� -B]B� Í �t/;b�3BC�� u�� b Ybt/:b� "a� X&'� &Gf,� #m�%J �;�B,� 8! #B;B,� N� ! u7�G,� ��&,# Ö� Í �+Q,�3 �fD� l,w ±

Zfs Tf%,�� #B;B,� 87 S���2e� "a� Nx� ��.%,� Í S���2e� S���2e�7 #�A� N0± �>�G�,c<R� =�,��f%� N�[ �e �.%+ #B;B,� N� ! �<�%,� ��5Jb = ±� �f�

n� o���XV&� ]�f G#� }�n�X&� $�f�2 G#� �m�b 8�xk $�f�2 : $I3)� �\t−� \AE

Page 166: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

u?����� Y��B)5e�, N� t[ ±�.%+ T%,�,�+� =�,#B;B� B� �e ,U��&� : fc ��,� #B;� T%D�,"#Bf;� U�ª �� 3 �Cf+ "#�ª �f&L� N� `.fD l,af, ±�,B�7 &G,� Ub/9�: "�fJ�a, Tf%,� UBf$c �f! X2/+ b "�! �� NE, Of7

#B;B,� >L9�B7"��7 P&, �Dp7 ,�f, >&c b �� , -�CfJ�7 �Bf�2� �fDE ±�)�?��27 Y�5C,�,.� �)&� O&,,� �a� N�+, �CD N� rC+ �D� (�%D �jD� � ±

��&�27 ��,�,#Bf;B,� >5] �9BJ T! X� ,<|f� U�f�&� =: P&f, ��f&$,� ~&7p73

�af� Nxf� �Cf,� A�f$/!�7 S�f��2e� Tf%,�� #B;B,� 87 S���2e�7 #�A� N0 ����± � ±�, (�G�± � K, �&�! �] �� B� P&, #B;B,� �&�! �] �� N� l,w ±T%,�, tf[

��� .+��� #B;B,� TB)5� N�= ±�T%,� TB)5e ,T�f%7 #Bf;Be� �� �� <� , #B;B7 T�%e� �� �� b�, Bf� #B;B,�f7 �C/e� �� �� b �D� 42%7 ±

T%,�7 �C/e� �2&%73 Xf52+ b Tf%,�� #B;B,� 87 S���2�, 42%e� �a� �V, ,� NB[ ! �,b/9� Í �+Q,� &G,��f;�B,� 8f! #Bf;B, �f��%J Tf%,

>/$,� �B6Be�7,�<f�%,� X&' ��5Jb ,�+Qf,� &Gf,� ()2f�� , �af� f! TBf)5e�� �f]�e� Í Tf%,�� #Bf;B,� 8f7 S���2e�� .+��/,�3 S.+�f�e� NE� ±T%,�7 #B;B,� �]� �] Th�/GJ �]�e� Í S���2e��, �f]� �f]�

#B;B,�7 T%,�,U��&� :� ;� � � KT�%e� �a,#B;Be� �a� T!� � K, Th�/Gf+ B�� Ë�&�: #B;B7 Y�#B;Be� -�CJ�,#B;B,� Í ��.|V/, Th�/Ge� , b�f� B��

�+Q,� &G,� �&�J.+3 -B]B� Í �t/;b� Í t)2&7 S���2e� T%,�� #B;B,� 87 S���2e�7 #�A� N0 ����±

�a� Nx� :��,��+� ,�, (�G� ,&�! u5/+ .�� B�� �<�%,� X&' �, Thf�, b0� ±:�B,� Ng� Í :�B,� ��,� Í 8�&�2,� �t/;� �2�3 ª�BF7 UB�+ :� <�

Page 167: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

S:�� Y�w Í T%,�� #B;B,� �t/;�,<|� +ª Y�a[ =, U�f�+ N� rCf+ <� ff+ª N0= ±�Ng� Pff5D Í Tff%,�7� #B;B,�ff7 �Cff/� , ���CffJ� Ni Pff5D ��

T%,�7 ���CJ� Ni B� #B;B,�7,�<�%,� ��5J�7 X2/¬ B� �¬ �a� Nx� ±3 Í �+Qf,� &Gf,� Xf52+ b Tf%,�� #Bf;B,� 8f7 S�f��2�, 42%e� �a� �V,

#B;B,� S:� ! u7�G,� �,b/9�, �f;�� 8! B� u�Le� #B;B,� NB[� #B;B,�,�B6Be� �aH ���%J T%, 3

�+Q,� &G,� T<[ ! .�i ��z!� �2)� N0 (@±,�Gf,� ".f[w u7, �f� Zfs "#�ª �&L� »&�,� "#A��,�+Q,� &G,� N� B�� ±,m�f%J � ��A , �.f5+

�A�fM� Í �DB[ u�j/� �#B;� .�� #B;B,� N�� ±, �fDp7 #Bf;B,� �Cf+ �af, T%�, -�2�Ò ,T%,� UB$c �! Y��B)5e� %7� �Dp7�±, Xf'� �af,� uf�� t2&7

�<�%,� X&' �&�! ,A���� ���J t[�&,0 S, .�� B� B� �&: �� #B;B,� N� ±�B2%� Å[,>f&��%,� YbBfje� �� ,YbBf�%e� Î�Bf@ Í S#�f%e� , <f�

.�� �DB[ �&: �� �]B+=�&�[ =���L� =�T%,� Í�2+ �Dp7 , Y��B)5e� %7� �D�� T%,� UB$c �!3>&|&�� "a� �� #B;B,� NE ±,.f�� �DB[ �&: �� �� =�f&�[ =�

��L�=�, �A�M� Í �, #B;� b,�, NB[ b �� ,~f_ Å�! Ë2�w .�� B� O7 , "#�.f�� uf�j/7 NBfV+ �A�fM� Í ����� "#B;� tD0�, Ëf/,� Ëf� "#�.f���

#Bf;B,� >5C7 �]BJ, �f­���27 �f­�#B;� �f]BJ Yf;� �w0 af�2&:� � K ÒT%�,3Y�#Bf;Be� .f|V/7 Y�#Bf;B,� .|VJ Th�/G+ �&�!� , .f|V/7 S.f|V/e� ?��:�­��B)5�� �)�,>&G2�� ,>f&!B2,�� ,>&Cfd�,�� 3 #�.f� NBfV+ N� b0 �

8f&��! 8�Bf)5� tkBf[ �f&: �f� S�f��2e� t)2f&7 S���2e�7 �+Q,� &G,���a,�� 42%e� Í �+.+��/�,�Dx� ,l,w �, (�G+ a�2&: Ò, SA�f��� ���J t[

�&,0,%5D l,w �+§ b �V, =�,a,� TB)5e� NBV7 (&�G/�, #B;� b Å�%,� Ë2�

Page 168: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�{ −

�A�M� Í �,,�+Q,� &G,� �&�J.+ b �� B�� 3 ����d�� ���N��G 7T2! 5�p ����#B;B,� �&$�J Ë�� ,f:�� �fDB[ �&: �� =�,

Y���6��� �G2,�� Y�A�$/!b�7 ".|VJ�,.j$,�7 ,f:�� �DB[ �&: �� =�, ��B�E�7 ".|VJ�,��� .j$,� >�&�: b0 ��2� P&, �D� X� ±, �&$�fJ #.fµ B)�

.+BCJ�,Xc�B,� �� �, &]A b 3Z|[ �&$�/,� �a�� =� NB�?�f�,� �f&,0 pfF�+ �� #B;B,� S:� ��a7,�f�|�� ,�f+� =�, f:�B�, �A�f$/!b� .f|V/,� �&$�fJ

Si.ff� �ff� .ff|[E >ff�7��e� Sff:�B,� Y�aff,�7, .ff%�/,�� ��B/ff9b� Í >ff5�/² 1j/,��,l,w Zs� , Í f:�B,� �&$�J �a[� S.f|V,� �&$�fJ� AB2,�f7 �fJ�w

AB2,� �)&�! ��G+ Ë/,� T�.;E�7 >+A�$/!b�, "ABfD Y�w �f� �f)&�! ~&f5&� :�B,�3

%5D �v b Y�)&$�J �)�[ "a)�=� ��w �� ! #B;B,� S:� ! >,b,� Í �7 NB�?��,� �&,0, .f|V/,� NBf[ f&5J �f)/�&�: Í Y�)&$�f/,� "af� N� lf,w ±

&�&�:=�,VJ P&,� .|=�+A�$/!� =�3:�� �J�w Í N�[ N0� .j$,�� =� �f;�B�� N� b0 ± ±�2! >�C52� Zs �2� Ë)� SZ|[ �D�[ N0�,SZ|V,� "W�h;� Ë�� , O[ .j$,��

SZ|[ ��h;� ! O/��,>%/Fe� �J�Aw Ë� ,OfV,� �af� �)2� OC: Ë/,�� , ��B�� SAB] ! "W�h;� Y.)� �a,�,�hf;� ! O/�� O[ �2))� �, t2f&7

<[ m�%J � NB[ `.+ b #B;B,� S:� ��a�=,"W�h;� Y�#B;Be�� , NE ±Y�#Bf;B,� .f|V/7 (&�Gf/,� Th�/Gf+ ��hf;E� #B;B7 (&�G/,�, U�Cf5D�7 w0

S#%/� Y�#B;�� Y�#B;B� U�C5Db� �aH OCj/+ �2! .j$,� ��h;�, �¬� OV�, .+��� �h�� N� A.�� B�3 �&�J.+ b �¬ �a�� #B;B,� S:B7 NB�?��,�3

�A�M� Í "#B;� u�j/� .j$,� N� !±, Í �f, #B;� b u�Le� #B;B,� t2&7 B� �&: �� �A�M�3

Page 169: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�+�.�, >�7��e� Y�a,� U�|� ��|��,>f&;A�M� u?�f��� f! �Gf$2e� AB2,�� , #B;B,� Í >&2&2@�� u�� N��h�/G+ tkx�;f%/e� �f+�.e�� S:�B,� Y�a,� S#,

AB2,� �&�! ���� �G$D� Ë/,� u?����� :�B,� AB2,��3 b �f¬ >&2&2@�� "a�� S:B,�7 NB�?��,� �)&�J.+,()$�a� O]� T­ �kE 3

�+Q,� &G,� O&,# UB: N�[ tD0 Y��c�2� �� u$9 c �� Nx� %7�, �f�A m�%J �,+.F/,� ¥° ! �/&��: Í "#A�� �a,� ,! Ub/9<, >jf]

#B;B,� S:� ��a�,Úd� :�� #B;B,� N� u&��� , �;�� #B;� B� #B;B,�,m�%J ,uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �2&%7 B� �D�� ±3 lf�J U<f� �f� N�f7 fc�

�5%6 ��&,, >�c�2e� ,�>&,�� >,#E� m0 4c.+ b �D�±,<�� = m0 4c.+ N� �! �>&D��\,� O?b,�,O&,f7 P&f, �D� .)� O7 ,f� Of7 Í �Vj/f9� >)$f� B

�+Q,� &G,� �)s�] Ë/,� SA�$%,� l�/7 ��Bs�] �)&�2/%� 1B�c, � �f�A m�%J,#.Fe� Ë�%,� �j$,�� O�%,� N�h&� Í >&c b� �I Nª� <� 3

��(' F1G Í �+Qf,� &Gf,� �f)5,� Ëf/,� >,�f9.,� lf�J `Bj� m0 Z�� N� �>&9A�5,� >��,�7 #B;B,� S:�,� �)'.J� >f&7.%,� >f��,� m0 �27, Yf!� tf[

O$c �w �� l,a7,��f2� �%f6B� Í >,�9.,� "a� ¦D #A�� ¢ tD0� , �f&: f+.F/,� ¥° f! �/&f��: �� �+Q,� &G,� SA�$! Y#A��, �f� .f|[E

�$9;b�� ��� = ±>,�f9.,� "af� UBfL�� , �af� Of��[ Of�|+ �f)�t/7 �f�#�.+0� �j$,�3&D�@ ���� =� �)&� �� N¼� �f�<[ �f! �f)$,�s Í �.Æ b Y��B�%� ��

"+.F/,� r+° ! �/&��: Í3f|,�@ ���� = ±� �f+�2@ Í T<f[ ��A#� �f)&� N¼f� ±�+Q,� &G,� T<[ �� P&, >,�9.,�,B� O7 ,.)�+ t[ , �f27� Y���f60 ��

(;ze�,"Zs �� 3 U�'�� O&$9 ! >,�9.,� "a� Í ��; �� .[w� �D� ���,:� (@ t&f� T<V,� u�

Page 170: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>&��60 N�%� �� �)&� #A�Ò, �/&f��: Í �f�<[ Í �+Qf,� &Gf,� ��.[a+ ¢ +.F/,� ¥° !3

�B6B� �� .|[� >,�9.,� "a� YB: �,, �afH uf�%/�� (f)� Bf� �f� �)2� �j$,�,()7 P&, �� �)2�� ,>f&�! >f&c �af7 �Gf&, Y�f+�V: � O7 3

>@<@ YB: >,�9.,� N� UB�,� �V+�>f)� Y�!B6B�,Ëf�� ; K�_`���b�S�>&)&$�J SAB] �+Q,� &G,� �&� .[w , #Bf;B,� �fJ�.� �$f� �f&: Ø �

#B;B,� �J�.� !� Y�$@0 m0 �I<� �� O]B/&, AB2,� �J�.7, NBf[ B�� �J�w B� ��,� #B;�,��ae� �aH U�c �� N�&7� ,>&�BC,�� >59<5,� (�� 3

�d�� K�`��� ! �&� U/9� #Bf;B,� S:� ��a� , � NBf[ �� ,m�f%J , UBf�%,� 1�f7A� 2! #B;B,� B�,>5f9<5,� (f�� ,f&:B/,� Of��� , (f��

>&�BC,�3 \��d�� K�`��� ��� f! T<fV,�� .�2,� 1�7A� ~%7 ��z!� �&� #A�� ��

��ae� �a�3 >,�9.,� "a� Y�!B6B� (�� � "a�3�)&� ��; �e >�c�2�� �.! �a�� 3

���b�S� K�`��� ±�T{G � �f)&,0 A��fe� >&)&$�/,� SABC,�7 u�%/+ �� B�� 5Di=��+Q,� &G,� Nx� ,m�%J � ��A , #Bf;B,� �fJ�.� f!� N�f&7 #C7

b�|� 1½ �)�°��=�$J�.�� AB2,�7 l,a, , >f&D�AB2,� ��&f�E� N� .[w �&: ±�J�.� >@<@ ! �)/&D�ABD Í; m�S� �/9;�� N� �#�5/G� ��,� ABD NBV+=� �f�

"Zs,�AE� �;� >+AB2[ ,�f��+0 �f/�7��� f2! P�,� ��%�7 �Ö� �Dx� , ��&f�� >@<@ >$J.e� "a� Ë5�;�AE� �f;� U�E� , Xfc�B,� �B�f,� Î�f|,��

�&�!,�)2� �B�,� ~&5/G+ �H Ë/,� >�7��e� �,�|,�� 3 N� f:� ! �$/�+ b� ±�/� >@<|,� ��&�E� "a�S.+�,�fV¬ �AE� �f;� �� �B�,� U��ª N�� ±, Of7

Page 171: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

قف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجودمو

− �{�  −

Xc��3 ��#�d�� �/9;���J�w È/�� "ABD NBV+ N� �, �f­�w NBVJ N� .+�J ! P�,�[

AB2�, >�h�/G�� >&�/��,N��&f� >f$J.e� "a� � ;P�f,� T.f; ��f:� , "�B6 �|,��,N�.+��/� ��� ,�h�/G� P�,� T.; N�[ �w0� =� ! AB2�, �f�

�2� �B�,� ��V5D� ªB§ <� �D.[w, ABCfJ ªBfF&� �f�.+��J m0 >$G2,�7 ���� t)[�V5D�3

�d��d�� �/9;���J�a7 "ABD NBV+ N� ,�J�w ! ?�ª AB27 b ,�B�,�[ , �Ö� �Dx� �J�a7,?�ª .�i AB27 b =��J�w ! 3>��7 P&, AB2,� N� Oc�! ! 45� b w0 ±,

DB[ Í ��/y b��&�� �=��&,0 .�i �� Tt�D� m0 3 �� �2)� >$J.e� "a� Í� :��,}�2,� 8!� ! �G527 .��� AB2,� B�� , A�f�7 �f7 �Ö� "�! ���

AB2�, �/&�7�c3 &G,� .[w (@,m�%J � ��A ,AB2,� U�j[ �$J�.� Í #B;B,� U�: N� ±, �f&:

�B2%� ABD #B;B,� N� 87± ± �,�J�.� N�� ±¾<@ Y�#B;Be� ; m�S� �_/9;�� N� #�5/G� ��,� #B;� NBV+=�Z�,� �� ,>f2Ve� Y�f&��e� U�f: B� t[ , Nxf� ±�f�Zs �� #�5/G� ��#B;�,��&f�� >f@<@ >f$J.e� "af� Ëf5� ; >f&��e� U�E�

>2Ve� ,��Zs �� #�5/G� B� �a,� ��#B;� Î�|,��, Zf�,� lf,w �f,�|,�� #B;B,� ���� �a,��)&�!, #Bf;Be� �a� �� #B;B,� ��V5D� N� Í l� b� ±h?�; �J�w m0 .�2,�7,Xc�� O7 3

��#�d�� �/9;�� #Bf;B,� ��V5D� NBV+ �;� ! "#B;B, >&�/�� �J�w NBVJ N� �b�_ �2!=,#B;B,� �;�� U�: �a�� ,8f�V/e� ABf)' ��af� f! 3 �

N��&� >$J.e� "a�;�;�B,� Y�w U�E� ,� "#B;� Î�|,�, #�5/Gf� Bf� �a,� �J�w ��,X2/¬ �J�w m0 .�2,�7 #B;Be� �a� �! #B;B,� ��V5D� N� 45� b� ±,

Page 172: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

#B;B,�� Y�a,� .+��J ! ��27 �V¬ ��V5Db� ABCJ �V,=3 �d��d�� �/9;���fJ�w 8! B� #B;B7 S#B;B� �J�w NBVJ N� �, .+�f�� #Bf;B7 b

�J�a, ,#B;B,� >�&�j[,b w0 �f! f%$,� >f+�s Í #B;B,� >�&�: N� Í >)$� ±T%,�,>��,� �� AB2,� %7 }�&�[ �2� ��%7 }�&c� , �fJ�a7 ABf2,� N� t[� ±Z2�,t��� NBV+ N� U�_� =,#B;B� �J�a7 #B;B,� l,a[ , NBfV+ N� U�f_�

��%�=�3�J�a7 #B;B� :�� �� >$J.e� "a� Í� , �Gj7 #B;B� "�! ��� &�7�c#B;B�, �/,�Gf527 .��f�� �Öf� AB2,� N� (�! t[� ± � � K, �f� "�f! �f��

�7 .��� ��&�E�3#B;B,�� Y�a,� 87 ��V5Db� ABCJ �V+ b �2)�� , ��f27 =��#��� !,�2&%7 #B;B,� � Y�a,� NE 3#B;B,� �;�� U�: �a�� , !

8��/e� ��af�–<9�� >59<5,� �+Q,� &G,� (H Ë2%+� 8&�– !� �+:Be� >&�BC,� ��a� 3 NB��/e� U�c >@ ���± �– NB&�<f9�� >59<5,� �� – #Bf;B,� �f;�� N0 ±

�j7 #B;�,N��&� �&� P&, �� ;Y�a,� U�E� ,#B;B,� �|,�� , B� �a,�� Y�a�, �A�!,#Bf;B,� 8f! �;�B,� O7 ,�f7 (?�fc Bf� �af,� 3 ��af��

Y�a,� #��� Í >&�BC,�AB)�� #B;B,��3 �a�� – 8f! �f;�B,� NBf[ �� #B;B,�–t)2&7 �&�! u5/e� �� ,>&�BCf,�� 8&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� 87 �� 3

�� �&�%,� >$J.e� Í NBV+ N� 7b #B;B,� �;�� Np7 >�ª�; O�%,� >��7 Nx�± ±Y�#B;Be� �J�.�, �f� `Bfc�� f!� >f+#B;Be� Í >f$J.� NBVJ b �&j7

�/$J.�, >f+#B;Be� Í �f;�B,� >f$J.� �� !� �J�.e� �� >$J.� �D�[ B, w0�;�B,�7 m�� >$J.e� l�J �D�V, 3 >f+#B;Be� Í �f&�%,� >f$J.e� N� (f�! c�± � � K

>|,�|,� >$J.e�,�2&! ��,� #B;� NBV+ N� �� , NBfV+ b �f;�B,� #B;B�

Page 173: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�2&! b0,�&�! ��5J� t[ ,>&�BC,�� >59<5,� �� ��F3 RAD"� M& ��:−

#Bf;B,� �+Q,� &G,� �)&� �$� Ë/,� >&)&$�/,� SABC,� "a� N� ¸j�D �jD± ±�$J�.�� AB2,�7 �$J�.��,8J�af,� ��f5J� m0 �fI<� �� O]B/&, , ABf2,� Y�w

t)$J�.� �� �&�%,� >$J.e� Í #B;B,� Y�w�,�fJ�w B� ��,� NB[ >$J.� B�� , "Zs m0 "A��/�� Zs ��,AB2,� �J�.� !p� ,�J�w AB2,� B� ,�J�w �B�,� �� ,

�+Q,� &G,� �2! \! t[± �,�fJ�w #Bf;B,� Bf� #Bf;B,� �fJ�.� !� �a[� , �J�w Zs m0 "#B;� Í "A��/�� T%,3m�%J �;�B,� NBV+ N� �;B� �&�!� ,

�G5D #B;B,� B�,Y�#B;Be� �J�.� !� �DBV, 3 �&$�f/,� �a� O|� N0 UBc� b%5D �+Q,� &G,� �§ =�#Bf;B,� Sf:� ��a� u&�� Í ,<�f� = �f!

".+BCJ,�;� �� .|[� �� l,w� ; ��� ���� � A.f�/� Ëf�&�: �� ABf2,� N¼� �A�M� Í "#B;�,Å[ .�p7 P&,� ,#B;B,�[ ,Åf[ TBf)5� Bf� �af,�� , b

�, u��,B� �&: �� ,�A�M� Í 3 �#�H ������fJ �af,� AB2,� N¼� K f! �R�Gf$D�� ��f&� >fF&/D ��&f�E� �f7 `.

#B;B,� Í >�&�: 85+��/� �+.�� #B;� Th�/G+ T�.;E�, #Bf;� Bf�� b� AB2,�,T�.;E� #B;�� ,#Bf;B,� >f&2&2@� Ö/�+ B�� , �&�fJ.+ b �f¬ Bf��

�+Q,� &G,�,��ae� �aH NB�?��,� b� 3 d��H ����� ��7 P&f, ".f�� >�&�: Í AB2,� N¼� ±�Öf, &Gf,� �f&,0 �f�w tf[ �+Q,� ,AB2,� >�&�: Í �2|j7 B, O7,�+�� (�%,� Í �$@ t[ , �D� �D;B,

n� o� d�2) ~ $&��3}�n�X&� ���c&� ��%#& m�n�& ,{�DX. RD� : $I3)���\A−t E �I)

��^: �)m /K �. G#� ���c&� ��%&� C�3��� Cm3)A ,d��%� o���. ~ ��E

Page 174: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>!¯,�� .�C,� >+�s Í Y�Aw,S#.Fe� 8%,�7 `.J b , (Gf�� �f� �f%$2J �Öe�,>�&�� Zs �­�w Í Ë� ,T�.;E� ! �)RB�G7 �V, , l�J �H �ÖJ T�.;E� 3� ! U#� b�±%/$� ���5,� m0 �.� �w0 �.e� N� �� �a= ±� T.f; �! �AE�,�));� ! P�,� �BL9 �c� ,�B�� -<�,� �A��� , F&f9

>V,�: >�� Í �G5D ,>�&�� ����� P�,� ;B,�,Z2/G� �AE� �;�� =� ��AB27,�AE� �;� ! �)2� >|%$2e� AB2,� Th: `.+ N� N�# �, (s.f,� f!

� Th: #B;� ��T<�,� b0 (@ t� ���5,� Í SQ/2e� �B�,± �, �/�&�: Í AB2,�� ��5M� >+�s Í� >����F3

�fJ�a7 #B;B� #B;B,� N� �+Q,� &G,� `B!# ����±,"Zf�7 b , f!� Bf�� #B;B,� �J�.�, �fk� �)%f6B� Í �)/�fc�2� u$f9 �� #B;B,� �;�� B��

�)&�! N��.7 b `B!# #.µ3 �� .)��fc<R0 Uf+ b �&$�f/,� �af� N� >�c�2e� "a�= ±� #Bf;B,� NBf[ f! ��j/�=��J�a7 ,Y�#B;Be� �J�.� !� �DE ,AB2,� NE ±,��|� ,�fJ�a7 u�j/� ,

"Zs m0 �/+ABD Í .�/5+ b,>+AB2,� �J�.� !� Í �DE ±3 Ã�d�� K�`��� �����+Qf,� &Gf,� Ub/f9�7 uf�%/+ t&f� B�� ,�f�A �

m�%J ,>59<5,� l�G7 #B;B,� S:� ��a� !, >&�BCf,� l�Gf7 (f@ #B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,�, NBf[ f! (Ib/f9� >5f9<5,� �f! O�D c �Dx�

� #B;�,m�%J ,�;�B,� ,�J�w 8! , Tf�J c �� O|7 �j$,� #B;B,� �D�� �%6B� Í ()2! O�2,�3>,�f9.,� "af� Í ()2f! Of�D �f&: ,fD� ± �f$@ fc �

#B;B,� �/�&�: �;�B,� N� (�2! N��\,�7±,(�! c� � � K,��+� , O�%,� >,b7

n� o"&�-&�) "#-&�) aN-&� �I�. :�OW ��− �uE

Page 175: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

#B;B,� �;�� �D�±,.�� NBV+ N� ªB§ b� =�&�[ =�,.�� �� =� >f&�V,� �f, �.%J TB%,��,.f�� N�[ B, �2&! B� �a,� #B;B,� NE = ±�f&�[ =� Í �f��� ABCf/+ ¢

8%/,� N�7 �A�M�, N� Th�&� $[.� �;�B,� NBV+=�8%/,�� ÅV,� .�E� �� , U�_ �;�B,� �[.J�,f&?h; �f;�B,� NBV+ N� �§ O7 =�f&�&�: =�f=2&%/�� �

�J�a7,�J�w 8! �2&%J NBV+ �� ,�fJ�w 8f! "#B;� N� t[ ±, ABCf/+ b 4f/: "B;B,� �� �;B7 �&� �[z,�� #%/,�3t?�c NBV+ N� �§� =�J�a7 , ¢ Bf, �DE

�c �V+t?=;�/_ NBV+ �J�a7 =�Z�,� m0 ,U�_ �;�&/:�� 3 #Bf;� N� A.f�J �w0� ±�2&! �;�B,�,#B;B,� NBV&� ,��+� ,�fJ�w f: Í �2&%/� ,f&?h;� =�f&�&�: =�,

t?�c�=�J�a7 ,#�.�E� �Gj7 #B;B,� >�&�: #%J NE ±, Y�f&�t�, �)6�.!� Yb�je� O&$c �� >2Ve�3f�e� "af� �f� u�� c� Bf� �f;�B,� N� Y��±

u�Le� #B;B,�36A�! NBV+ b N� �2)� u�Le�7 #�.e�� =�>f&�t�, , NBfV+ Of7 t?�c==2&%/�� ��J�a7 ,+A�!� =�"Z�7 &�/,� �! 3 #B;B,� �<R� N� �2)� (�! c� ± � � K

ª�µ �;�B,� Zs !,6A�! P&, #B;B,� NE = ±��h; b� =�f=2&! b� �"Zf�, , E� NB[ 42%��fJ�a7 (?�f�,� #Bf;B,� SÀf: m0 >$GD �I N� S#B;B� ��&�±,

#B;B,� SÀ: �� N��&� �)&�!�,�I �A�! #B;B,� N� b ±,�)&� O��# �� 3 .�2,� 1�7A� �&�! �� �a�,O�%,� A�V�p7 �&,0 �B��7� ��F3

8&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� Ub/f9b �f��27 uf�%/+ t&f� �a�, (�tf9 �+af,�� �� 8��je�78��/e�,.f�2,� 1�jf]� (f� �+af,� , Sf:� ��af� f!

#B;B,�3�/�c�2� Ôp/9� 3 >&�BC,� Ub/9b ���27 OC/+ t&� ����±,#Bf;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� , �+af,��

n� o}�n�X&� ���c#& m�n�&� d�2) ~ $&��3 ,{�DX. RD� : $I3)��� \ t– ��� \AE

Page 176: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�+:Be� �� 8��je� (�t9,�f�&��� ��afe� �a� .+.�J ! , #A�� f�� ABfR O�%,� ABR ��A� N0 �B,�c (k� ()2!= ±±�b Y����fe�7 b0 �f&,0 Of]B/+

>&5�V,�,>&��%,� Y�.��2e� N�# ,�[�A#0 �! h;�! O�%,�� , }�B�� hF%[ YbB�%e� ��A#0 �!,O�%,� Y�[A� Ë� Ë/,� 3 N� ABL,� l,w Í u�� c� ±

#B;B,� >�&�: ,�;�B,� 8! B� �a,�,&�[ P&, =�,&?h; b� =�,��! b� =�, b� ]��=�, �� u�L� B� O7 #B&�,� X&',�<R�� &c �! `.%�� ± K�,��+� , f!

Ë%&$L,� ÅV,� Í >&��%,� TB�%,� 1�7A� U�c �� }�&c, �f�v >f�&��� l�J� ± � �>2Ve� Y�&��e� Í Y.)��,#B;B,�7 >�B]Be� >&DBV,� .���e�� , b �&j7 ��&�E� �� �� �)2! B��,&,�� ��&�E� �� �� N�[ B, w0 =�fe �f)2! N�f[ �

5C/�=�#B;B,�7 3 >f�&��� lf�J Y�A�$/!� �+Q,� &G,� ()2! O�D (@,uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �� ,

<�D U���=>f%���� >f+:E�7 4GJ �<Rb� A�$/!�7 Y\/!� �w0 �k� ()2! ± � ±K, Y�af,� >f$J.� Í Y�2&%/,�� #B&�,� �� �)%� �� b N� A�$/!�7 Y\/!� �w0�,

fH ��f&&�J >�:<� X�Ëf52,� �a,>��f,� >f+:E�7 4GfJ ± � K, �f,h2J �w0� >ff+:�B,� SÀff��7 4GffJ Y�5Cff,�� �tff9E� >ff$J.� m0 U�E� ÅF/,�ff7± � K,

Y�5C,�� �t9E� SÀ:�,`.�� >$J.� m0 �,h2J �w0� , .��f�� Í ��v� Y�fcB�de� XD�C7 4GJ Y�a,� �+�.�� �t9E�± � K3 �f+�.e�� .��f�e� �fJ�.��

��5/�>J,8f%� �BfD� #! Í SABC_ �G&,� , A�f�7 �f)2� f:�� Of[� Y�5Cf,�� �t9E� �� >5]� (9b .)�� �/&�7�c3 �f�� N�GfD�� �BfD �f��� ±Y�5Cf,�� �tf9E� X&� >%���� >$J.e�� >&�7��,�,�f,Bc� , �f&�! � f]

(�9�: " �JAB] ! T#i � u�� "342%e� �a� m0 SA��0 , ���� �� .)��=� �J�5] X&�3

Page 177: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

Sf:�� >f�&�: Y�f$@x7 NBf,B�+ (fk0 (IBfc &Gf,� ()2! O�D N� m0, Ëf� u�Le� #B;B,�,>f+A�$/!� Y�f2&%J� #Bf&�7 S.f|V,� P$�� Í Y.)� , �afI�

T�Gf�D� b� #%J �­:� >�&�: m0 �.L/+ b �$G,�, �f$� �fDx� f:�B,�[ ±�)�]�� #�!E�,�.� X&' Í AB)�,� �,� #�!E� �J3 >�&�: m0 �.L/+ b� T�G�D� �J:�,%Lc =�,SZ|V,� #�!E� �J�.� X&' Í N� t[� ±,>&��2/� Z�,� ,

f:�B,� Zs �� P&,, Y�af,� b0 P&f, >f&DBV,� .��f�e� Xf&' Í l,af[ S:�B,�,Ybh2/,�� Y�&�F/,� A�$/!�7 b0 P&, .|V/,�� #%/,� (�B/� , �H w0

#B&�,� YA�]�)&,0 >�2� >+A�$/!b� Y�2&%/,�� 3 f� �+a,� 1�$,E�� .?�C$,� B,�� N� (IBc ()2! O�D (@K ± >f�,�7 >fVj7 �BC×

Í >f��j/� Zs >+A�$/!� S.|V,� l�J N� �B[A#�� ����� c 1�LM� OC��±.�E� P5D,>f&,�%/e� Sf:�B,� Y�af,� b0 >f�&�: #B;B� P&,� , (fk� tf[

B;� N� �B��:±U�_ A�)�,� :�B,� SZs X� A�&sE� #,OR�7 >+Z�,� (�BJ� , 8�A�%,� �� ��\V,� ~%7 U�c t[: U�fffff&� NBfffffV,� tfffffD0

>ffff�&��� Í uffff: Bffff��Þ �

�affff� (ffff)5+ �ffff� Offf[�

>fffff�+.L,� A�¿� ª�fffff:��F �+:Be� Ë��_ �! ���D t7 OC/+ t&� �a�,�+Q,� &G,� (�t9 t[ , �f�

b/9b���ae� �a� ! U3 �)� :

f! Ub/f9� �� "�.[w �¬ 8&�<9�� >59<5,� �! ���D t7 OC/+ t&� �����ae� �a�, T<f[� >5f9<5,� T<f[ 87 �+h� ()2! ���D �� N� `.D �j2� ±

n� o~ $&��3{�DX. RD� }�n�X&� ���c#& m�n�&� d�2) : $I3)���\ A–t E

Page 178: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�{ −

>&�BC,�,�+Q,� &G,� T<[ �� ()2! O�2,� �a� NB[ Í l�,� ¾AB+ �¬ 3 ��D >+�7 Í �D� l,w± #B;B,� �;�� NB[ ! AB)�e� (Ib/9� �.[w ()2! ��j$,� #B;B,� B�,�%f6B� Í ()2f! Of�2,� Tf�J c t7 , �/�fc�2� �f��

��2���F%2� l,w m0 �B$�w tD0 (k� �� =� >f&��e� �f� #B;B,� �;�� �[z, #B;B,��,#B;B,�� 8%/,� �� �� , 8f! "#Bf;� 8f! �f/&��� N� N�.+ ()� ±�2&%J, �j$,� ·�M� #B;B,� (�2! B)�,6A�! #B;B,� P&�� =� �� �f/&��e �h;=�%�# �)2� =��J�w Í �[z�, ,<�! B,� =3()2! O�2,� �$@ c ��[ �a�� 3

f! &Gf,� �f�#A�� Ëf/,� >��f6�� lf�J Ëf� ()2! O�2,� �$|+ ¢ �¬ �V,AB[ae� (Ib/9�,f:B,� O�� �� >&�BC,� UBc �)2&%7 Ë� Ë/,�� S, lf�J�

8&�<f9�� >59<5,� �! �$|J ¢ AB�� ¾<@ Í Y��; >��6��, N�f[ N0� �j$,� #B;B,� B� �;�B,� NB[ Í ()$�a� Tªb �)�%73

b�S� ;�S� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� Bf� #Bf;B,� �f;�� Np7 UB�,� ()&,0 29� �D� ± ±�,Bc ()2! �$|+ ¢ �¬ �a��,%,� r+�7 "�5D c �2&9 �7� N0 O7 ±SA�$, .f[w t[

�%6B� Í� F,()$�a� Tªb �a� N�[ N0� 3 Ã�d�� ;�S� ����� �f! �f� f! #Bf;B,� �<fR0 Npf7 UBf�,� ()&f,0 29� �D� ± ±

�;�B,�,m�%J ,ª�µ 3�f, >f�&�: b (�2! Y�2Ve� #B;� N� �a� 42%�� ±, (��� ���� 1a[ B� O7,NB&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� �7 O�+ ¢ �¬ �a�� , b�

()$/[ Í .LG� B�,= ���� �a� PV! NB,B�+ (� O7 �, Y�2Ve� N� N�.+ ()� ±�A�M� Í ��#B;� u�j/�,�)/&��� ! ?�ª ��#B;� N�� ±,�I �A�! 3

n� o�Z�� :WO� – Ou+M�&� R. E

n� o�Z�� :W��+M�&� R. E

Page 179: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

\��d�� ;�S� �������0� �D� =� ª�fµ �;�B,� �! �� #B;� N� �� ()2! ���D �e ±&�E� NB[ 42%� Np7 UB�,� ()&,0 29�± SÀf: m0 >$GfD �fI N� S#Bf;B� ��±

�J�a7 (?��,� #B;B,�,#B;B,� SÀ: �� N��&� �)&�! N�� ±3 �a��,�+� =�,8&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� �! ���D �$|+ ¢ �¬ , Í N�f� Bf� b� ()$/[ 3��� �a� �� PV%,� ! (� O7=�, �;�B,� Zs #B;� N� N�.+ �&: ±

! �DB[ A�$/!�7 �;�B,� �� /G�>�,�, TB�%� ¢�%,�� , �fDBV7 (&�Gf/,� X� #B;B,� �;��,(+c ,¾#�: #B;B,� �V¬ "�B9 ��� ,�f7 �;�� �� 3 (f)�

�)/&��� ! ?�ª Ë�&�: #B;� Y�2Ve� #B;� N� N�.+±, ��&f�E� u?��:� �A�M� Í,Y�2Ve� �� ,>f�&�: #Bf;B,� >5Cf7 >5Cf/� Y�#Bf;B� , N�� ±#B;B,�,� Å[ 42%� �a,�� �z�,�I �A�! 3 �f� ()2! &G,� "#A�� �� b

u�Le� #B;B,� SÀ: m0 >��60� >$GD #.µ �I Y�#B;Be� N�±, Bf� �af,�� �;�B,� #B;�,�­�w Í #B;� �I NBV+ N� N�# , 8f! Bf� T<V,� �a� Nx� ±

#B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� T<[ 3 Í 8&�<9�� >59<5,� �! &G,� �� O�2,� �a� O|� S:� ! (Ib/9�

#B;B,� �;��,SABC,� "aH , >,�f9.,� "a� S#�� X&' NB[ Í l�,� ¾AB+ �5&,pJ ��,�G527 ".LG+ ¢�� &G,� T<[ Í �A#� c NBV+ N� %$+ <� � � K3

�)&,0 A��e� >@<|,� ��Ag� "a� N�� >]��±, m0 �fH UBf�,� &Gf,� 29� Ë/,�� )&,0 ��2G+ ¢ >59<5,��c�Be� ! �:° O|� Í (, ¦Cd/� 1�/[ B�� Y�!B6Be� "a� O|� Í, >f&��e�� #Bf;B,� >,pGf� Ác�D �D� �� (s.,� ! ±

���ae�� �.5,� 2! 8%/,��, ¦fD ¥° ��f2! >59<5,� ��A ��2� .[w� �c�Be� 1�/[ ,�&� .[a+ (��=�c<R� �a� �� =�3 f! �/&��: O|� Í .[w b� +.F/,� ¥°,8f%,� >V: ¥° ! �/&��: b� , �f! Of�2,� �af� Of|�

Page 180: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>59<5,�,>,�9.,� "a� Í ���D �a,� , -�fJ �f� ��f2� N� ��,� ���+ �¬ ± � ± Ð � K>,�9.,� "a� S#t7,Y�#�+h,� "a� O|� �)&,0 -�6p� , �af� NBV+ N� %$+ b�

(;ze� �27� O%� ��3�f7� 8��/e�7 �+Q,� &G,� +.+ N� b� � �f� 8��je8&�<f9�� >5f9<5,� Zfs .�2,� 1�7A�, >&�BCf,� ���fc (fH f+.+ Npf[ .�2,� 1�7A� �� #B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,�,.�i .�� �a)� 3"#�.7 (�!� �� 3

Sf:� ��af� ! Ub/9� �� >&�BC,� Ë��_ �! ���D t7 OC/+ t&� ����#B;B,�,e� �a� N� N�.+ (k� ()2! O�D �� ±Of�%,� ABfR �B� ��a, �fD��

>&��%,� Y�.��2e� N�# >&5�V,� Y����e�7 �&,0 O]B/+, r&jf] O�D B�� ()2! �7�@,�%6B� Í ".[w T�J t[ 3r] (@ ,��+� , �f� ()2f! �f��D �f�

�;�B,� 8! B� #B;B,� >�&�: NB[3 ~c�2+ �� �a� %7 ()2! O�D c �2V, � Í ".[w u7�G,� �CD Í ()2! ���D ���%6B,�/�fc�2� �f� �af,�� , Bf�� +.F/,� ¥° ! �/&��: �� �CD, �af� N0 NBf,B�+ (fk� �f2� .f[w �&:

Ëf?hF7 b� ÅfV7 P&f, �f;�B,� 8f! Bf� �af,� #B;B,�,T�f%7 b� , b� ·�d7,#B&�,� X&' �� u�L� B� O7 ,�<Rb� &c �! 4/: `.%�� = �± K, f!

Í >&��%,� TB�%,� 1�7A� �,�c �� }�&cË%&$L,� ÅV,�3 l�J Í ��2� .[w t2&7 u�Le� #B;B,� N� >&����±,�f;�B,� #Bf;� �2&%7 B� �a,� ,m�f%J , f:��

Úd�,Ë�&�: Ë?h;� ,Y��B)5�, �A�! ÅV7 P&, , ¦d�/� B� O7 � Y�w Í 8%/��,m�%J ,#B;B,� �;�B,� ,&�[ N�[ N0� B)� =�&%&$R =�, �f�

��B)5� �&:,�� �D� b0 ±Ëf�&�: Ëf?h; B� �]�e� �&: , b0 �Cf+ b S:�� Y�w !Ò,��� ,#B;B,� �;�� Y�w Ë� , #Bf;B,� �f;�� TB)5[

�f]�e� �&: �� �V, �+Z|[ ! ��B)5� �C+ Å[ 42%� B� �&: ��=Úd� :�� B�,�;�B,� #B;� B� ,m�%J 3

Page 181: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

جودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الو

− �{�  −

#B;B,� �;�B�,u�Le� #B;B,� B� ,Úd� :�� u�Le� #B;B,�� Ëf?h; �;�B,� B�,m�%J 3 �f� �fD� Í l�,� ¾AB+ �¬ >,�9.,� "a� Í ¦2,� �a�� ±

�+Q,� &G,� T<[,m�%J � ��A ,�&,0 �+B2/,� T�J t[ 3 �+Qf,� &G,� #�.� NBV+ N� b0� Ø,m�f%J � �f�A , AB[afe� �<fRb� �f�

#B;B�, ,A�$/!b� �aH,>,�9.,� "a� Í ��; t[ ,.� B� #Bf;B�, 8%J<,� >$Ju�Le�,-BC/,� >?� 2! AB)�� B� t[ ,>f$J.e� "af� Ëf5� , �f)2! \f%e��

>��Le� S:B,� >$J.7,8%J<,� >$J.7� , Bf� �f&: �� #B;B,� �]B+ b �]� �p7 #B;�,&c �p7 &�+ b� ,&JB$@ N�[ ��B9 =�&$�9 �� =�, #.µ B� O7

�<R�� &c �! 4/:,Zs #B;� B)� ¶Qf7 b f&�� ,¶Qf7 b b� , b� b ¶Q7,b ¶Q7 b b� ,�j&6BJ Ôp&9 t[ 3 Í�f2J ��2� NBV+ <� �&�!�

8C2,� Í 8JA�$%,� 873 ¦2,� �a� N0−>&�BC,� ��a� B� �D� ! a�� �w0 , (f)�<[ Í .�2,� N�#

#B;B,� �J�.� Í, �D�&7 Ôg� –#Bf;B,� �;�� #B;� u�� Ë52+ ,$f9 �D�jm�%J�,Ëf?h; Úfd� ·�� #B;B7 �A�M� Í 8%/� Y�w B� �&: �� , �7 h&/�,"#B;� O%§ O7 ,m�%J ,�)G5D Y�#B;Be� #B;� 8! , Ëf� Ë/,��

�)/�&�: Í ,��+�,U�&�� (�� 3 #Bf;B,� Sf:� ��a� ! >:�¤ Nb+ 8C2,� <[ N� �� (s.,� !�±,

� &G,� �, �/D� �a,� ¦2,� ��B9f+.F/,� ¥° f! �/&f��: Í �+Q,, u�Le� #B;B,� N� ��±,�f;�B,� #B;� B� �a,�� ,m�f%J , Úfd� f:��

Ë?h;,Ë%&$R Å[ �D� �� ,>f&?h; b� >f&�V7 �f]B+ <� ,TBf! b� , b� ·BC�,&c O[ �! `.%� B)� ± K�,�<R�� &c �! 4/: , "af� Í ��f; t[ >,�9.,�,<[ NE = ±N� `.f+ t)2� ± Y���f6��7 NBfV+ tfD0 Y�#Bf;Be� .f|VJ

Page 182: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

Y�A�ff$/!b�� �Gff2,��,u?�ff��� Y�ff&��� >��ff6x7 lff,w� , �ff)2! \ff%e�� Y�2Ve�7,u�Le� #B;B,� �a� SÀ: m0 ,:�� N�[ ��B9 =�&Cd� =�&?h; =�, &�[ ��=�&%&$R =�,#B&�,� �! `.%� ± K�, NBfV+ b N� 8$�ae� O[ ! Th�+ a�2&:� Ò

��� "aI#B;�� u�� �� Y�2Ve�� u?�,Y�#Bf;Be �tf9� #.fµ Ë� �� , #B;B,� >5C7 >5C/� Zs �)2V,,�D�&7 T�J �� ! 3 �&Gf7 �A�� �2)� N� b0 ±

8$�ae� 87,~_ �A�$/!� �A�� B�� , <f[ ! #B;B,� S:� Í ¥�+ b 8$�ae�;f:�� uf�Le� #Bf;B,� NBfV7 Ñ�f�,� U�E� ��afe� N� lf,w =� &Cd�=�&?h; =� � NBV+ N� �&�! Th�+ ±,m�%J ,#Bf;B� ,"#Bf;�� , �af� Bf�

�2&%7 #B;B,�,�;�B,� #B;� B� ���e� #B;B,� �a)� ,f:�� #B;� B�� , >+A�$/!� S.|V,��,>&�&�: b ,U�&�� (�� #.µ Ë�� , #A� fc �¬ (s.,� !

; :�� u�Le� #B;B,� NB[ `B!# Í >:#�c Y�6�z!� ��Úfd� Ë?h, �%6B� Í .[w t[, #B;B,� B� �;�B,� NB[ #��� �a,�� Î�|,� ��ae� ���� ±

u�Le�,&c O[ �! `.%e� ± � K,�<R�� &c �! 4/: , #B;� Ë5D �2� Th�+ �Dx� �;�B,�,m�%J ,�A�M� Í SA.�/� Y�w B� �&: �� , Úd� :�� #B;B7 Ë?h;�,Ë%&$L,� ÅV,� NE ,Í �, u�� b N�&!E� , #.fFe� #Bf;B,� �af[�

&c O[ �! `.%e��,�<fRb� &c �! 4/: ,Xfc�B,� Í �f, #Bf;� b , Of7 "#�.�� Í "#B;�,�I �6�.%7 l,w� 3 �afH 8�?�f�,� �f! �f$@ fc �fD� Zs ±

NBV+ tD0 Y�#B;Be� .|VJ N� N�.+ (k� ��ae�,��+� , Y�A�f$/!b� u+.L7 Y���6��� �G2,��,6x7 l,w� Y�f&��� m0 ÅfV,� u�Le� #B;B,� �a� >��

#B;B,� >5C7 >5C/� Zs Y�#B;B� �)2� OCj//� Y�2Ve�, �f� BjD ! "�D� �D�&7 T�J c,>f&�! >+A�$/!� AB�� Y���6��� �G2,� N� l�b� ±,

�A�M� Í �I #B;� b3��ae� �a� ! Tª<,�� ,¦2f,� �af� �f� #�5/Ge� ,

Page 183: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�;�B,� #B;� Ë5D,m�%J ,·�f� Úfd� #B;B7 "#.5J �&: �� , �af[� Y�f2Ve� #B;� Ë5D,S.f|V/e� ¢�f%,� �af� u?�f�: Ëf� Ëf/,�� , �f�A�$/!�7

#B;B,�7 >5C/� Zs Y�#B;B�,AB�� �kBV, =�>&�! >+A�$/!� 3 #B;B,� �a)� (��� U�&�� T! ��.,� �a� !,�, >�&�: b 3

|j7 >,�9.,� "a� ���6� �,=�".[a+ ¢ ¥° f! �/&��: Í �+Q,� &G,� +.F/,�,>f2Ve� Y�f&��e� Í uf�Le� #Bf;B,� �af� Uhf2J >f�+.R Ë�� , Í

S! �J�.�; m�S� �/9;��>f%���� >f+:E� >f$J.� , >f�:<� >f$J.� Ëf�� #.µ �c<R� A�$/!�7 u�Le� #B;B,�=�A�$/!�� &c O[ �! 3 ��#�d�� �/9;�� >f$J.�

>��,� >+:E�, b N� >f�:<� A�$/!�7 u�Le� #B;B,� >�:<� >$J.� Ë�� Y�2&%/,�� #B&�,� �� �)%� ��, �afH uf�Le� #B;B,� �a� &&�J ¶�z�� X�

Ë52,� �aH A�$/!b�, �af� �f! Y�A�$/!b�� #B&�,� ��9 >�:<� ¶Q7 �� u�Le� #B;B,�3 �d��d�� �/9;��>+:�B,� >$J.� ,Y�5Cf,�� �tf9E� SÀ:� ,

Y�5C,�� �t9E� SÀ: Í ÅF/,�7 u�Le� #B;B,� Uh2J B��3 ��G�;�� �/9;�� Y�cB�de� XD�] >$J.�, �t9E� .���� Í ÅF/,�7 u�Le� #B;B,� Uh2J B��

Y�5C,��3Y�a,� �+�.� Ë� �t9E� .���� �J�.�� ,>J��5/� Ë�� , �Gf&, 8%� �BD� #! Í SABC_,>]BCf² >f&�7�c �f)2� OV,� Y�f&�v UBf$�,

�)&�! u�Le� #B;B,� 3 #Bf;B,� �fJ�.� f+� Í >,�f9.,� "a� Í ��.[w #A� Ë/,� �J�.e� "a� N0±

-BCf/,� >f?� �f)&,0 A��� c �J�6B&�� �Jbh2J� u�Le�, �f� (s.f,� f! �J�.e� "a� Í ()�</��,�f­���%/�� ��#�f!�� ��Wtf9� �&: �� , �fV, "a� O|� ()2! AB)�e�>,�9.,� l�J Í ��.[w ��; Ë/,� �J�.e�, �)j&6BJ�

�/,� Bj2,� !:

Page 184: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�H Uh2/J Uª�2�� �J�.� #B;B�, N� -BC/,� >?� `.+±,O5f9 m0 B�! �� , >�_ >&��! >+A�$/!� �J�.� Ë��, >f$J.,�7 �f)2&7 .�pf/,�� Tf�/,� N� 42%7 ±

O�%/,��,�A�M� Í b ,�fJ�.e� "a� 87 P&�� ,Ôg� �f�.[w ,Î�f�ª NBf7 , :�� �� Ë;A�M� #B;B,� Í Ë)�, N��ª P5D B� >$J.� U�� u�� N��ª�

��.�i u��3 m�S� �/9;��: >$J.� " >��Le� S:B,� ",4GJ� ,�+� =�, >$J.� " 8f%J<,� "

�"#B;B,�� X�� "� " X�� >+:� "� " uf�Le� �&�,� "� " �<fR��" �" �j$,� Y�a,� "� " Ëf5de� hf2V,� "� " u?�f��� >f�&�: "� " >f�&���

>+je�"3 >&I�� Y�a,� �]BJ b >$J.e� "a� �,�]� �p7 , u�� Y�w \/%J �2))�

�� ¶Q7 b,�� b ¶Q7 b� , m0 �f;�� Tf%,� m0 �f;� �f2� Y�a��� #B;B,�,#B;� b Ë)� ,T! b� , �f]� Of[ �f! "hf2� �f2� m�%J u��� �%D� ,(9A� (9��,(V:� ,(fV: �pf7 �f&�! (fVy N� rCf+ <f� , b�

S:� �� �� �� �&,0 -��+±,1B;� �� ,>&?h; b� >&�V7 b �]B+ b� , S.|[ b� S:� b�,&&�/,�� 8%/,� Ö/�+ l,w O[ NE ±, �<fR�� Í�f2+�

AB[ae�,&c O[ �! �<R�� >$J.e� "a)�� ,�<R�� &c �! 4/: , ��f9� 8%/,�3 >$J.7 &G,� ��t9 c� " >f%���� >+:E� ", ()�f%7 �)&Gf+� "

X�� >+:�"".[w T�J t[ 3 ��#�d�� �/9;��:U�E� 8%/,� >$J.� , >$J.� 4GJ� " >f+:E� ", >f$J.� Ëf��

�� b ¶Q7 Y�a,� A�$/!�,�<fR�� ¶Q7 �� 3 >f$J.e� "af� Í Y�af,�� �<Rb�7 S&��,/7 �� ÔB$@ &c O[ �! ��#.F, Ô�w fµ �f! SA�f$! Ë)�

�t9E� �� ��, P&,,�­�.@*e b� ,AB)� �)&� , �f! S#.µ Y�w �2)� tD0�

Page 185: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>&��M�� >&��� Y�A�$/!b�,uf�Le� Tf%,� >$J.� Ë)� 3 &Gf,� ��tf9 fc� ">��,� >+:E�"3>�7�Gf,� >f$J.e� �f! >$J.e� "a� Y.�pJ tD0� , >f$J.� " �>��Le� S:B,",&&�/,� ! >$J.,�7 T�� �<R�� NE , Yf&�J fc �2)��

�� b ¶Q7 �� �<R��7 Y�a,�, A�Cf,� �f&: �f� �f&$Jz,� N� Xf� >$J.� .�pJ Ö/�+">��Le� S:B,� " >$J.� �! " >+:E� " �ª\f,� �kBV,

Ëff/$J.� 8ff7 X��ff��" >ff+:E� ",uff�Le� Tff%,� >ff$J.� Ëff�� ,�� >ff$J." >+:�B,�"u�Le� #B;B,� >$J.� Ë�� ,��.[w Ôg�� 3

�d��d�� �/9;��:Î�|,� 8%/,� >$J.� , >$J.7 4Ge�� " >+:�B,� ", >f$J.� B�� Y���6��� �G2,�� #B&�,�7 Y�a,� A�$/!�,�� ¶Qf7 Y�af,� A�$/!� �� , &�e� #B;B,� Í Y�a,� Åv >$J.� B��,a� Í ÅF/,� �a�� N�f!BD >$J.e� ";

4G+ U�E� �B2,�" h8wS� x�E�� ", >+:�B,� >$J.� Í Y�a,� Åv B�� Y�2Ve� X&' AB] Í,SB�,�7 �)&� ��#B;� ABC/+ Ë/,� 3 Ëf$: Åfv Bf)�

>f&�%,� SÀf�� Í �­�#�%/f9�� ��&f�E� #B;B, �;B� Ô�w3 Åfv Bf)� Ë�!,�#B;� b 3

4G+ Î�|,� �B2,��"�� h81�� x�E",�#B;B,� ÅF/,�7 �2! \%+� , B�� Of%5,�7 Ë;A�fM� NBfV,� Í Y�#B;Be� AB)�, ~&f5,� Í �fD�[ N� f%7

SB�,�7 }cE�3>+#B;B,� Y���6��� �G2,�7 �2! \%e� B� ��AB)�� , t[ �%6B� Í �&,0 SA���� ���J3

}cE� ~&5,� ! �Jz� }�e� ~&5,��,� OC� U�E�$� >/7�|,� N�&!E(�%,� Í >&�]E� �­�#�%/9��, Xf� �A�fM� Í N�&!E� l�J OC� Î�|,�7�

�)%7�BJ� �)�ª�B,3 ~&f5,� #Bf;B,� Sf:� Í SAB[afe� �/,�f9A Í �+Qf,� &G,� 49 c�

Page 186: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

}cE�,U�E� ÅF/,� B�� ,Y�5Cf,�� �tf9E� >f$J.� m0 ÅF/f,� Bf�� , >$J.�">+:�B,� " >$J.�� " Y�5C,�� �t9E�",}�e� ~&5,� 49 t[ ,

Î�|,� ÅF/,� B��,Y�af,� �f+�.�� �tf9E� .���� Í ÅF/,� B�� , >f$J.� " Y�cB�de� XD�]"3f:�� 4f2%e� N�f[ �w0 Y�&G/,� "a� Í >:��� b� =�3

}fcE� ~&f5,� NBf[ �f� �fJ.[w �f� Bf� TBf�,� >2G,� ! AB)�e� �V,$/!� ��<[ }�e�� >$J.e �+A�">+:�B,�" , ÅF/f7 P&f, }f�e� ~&5,��

>+:�B,� >$J.� �! O�/G�3 �#B;B,� ÅF/,� �J�.e `.�� O&]�5J >&�BC�, N0 (@, ~&f5,� Bf� �a,�

()$/[ �� �)�&]�5J (�%J }�e���F3 �+Qff,� &Gff,� N0,m�ff%J � �ff�A , .[aff+ ¢ �� >&�BCff,� �b*ffI Off&,#

8ff��je� ,7 8�?�ff�,�#Bff;B,� Sff:B,�aff� (��!ff� ff! , >ff,#� .ff[w tff[ >59<5,�,()$�a� �.! t2&: ,()$�af� >f�&�: �.f%7 �f2� 4f5/[� O7 ,

�5Di �)&,0 A��e� �$J�.� .[w� ,>f+#B;B,� S.|V,� AB)� >&5&[ (@ ���, lf,w� Y���6��� �G2,�� Y�A�$/!b� u+.L7,Ëf�&��� .f|V/,� >f�+.R f! b ,

)$��=� .|V/7 ���+0 �)&� :�B,� N�+¯7 #�!E� �J�.�,#f! �f6.� t)� =�

n� o~ �L#�p�5:) m�n�#& $N?�%&� 8:��D&� �Z��:−

8&�x&� $�,? :WP��K�-? �.) ,"�2�&� RD2�&� JV0 t�VU yNM. $.�N. :W���K�-? �.) ,R��M�&� oDX. : W����K�-? �.) ,��4� ]��^. :W �P – �� ,W �Q�K�-? �.) ,

WO ��K�-? �.) ,WOO��K�-? �.) ,���NV&� r��A t�V9? yM#. d�k�5&� d3�&� :W ��− �u ,/.�X#& "9M&� W�^0 ]�f :WPO ,�m�b /&��& "9M&� W�^0 ]�f :W , ��cU

���5&� C�2sxp� :�OW �� � ,W���O ,}�n�X#& C�5��-V&� :W���−��� , C�N�#-:"9M&� W�^0 G#� /5�5� s-&� �?A :Wu −QE

Page 187: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

A.V� :�B,� b0 B� P&��=�,�,�: �a� #B;B,� �a[� 3 O&|/,� �a� �V,– #�!E�7 �� –%5D �+§ b =�, �fJ�.e� �fH 4f2! N0 �DE

�I #B;� b >&�! AB�� Ë)� �Gj� >&7�G�� >+#%,�, A.fVe� :�B,� 4/: Z�,� �)$J�.� Í>&��2/� ,>�B/� >&��! Y�A�$/!� �kE , �fJ�.� �fH 42! N0�

Xffc�B,� Í >ff&�&�: S.ff|V/� Ëff)� �A�ffM� Í >ff+#B;� u?�ff�� >ff+#!, b A�$/!b�7,#B;B,� S:� `B!# X� ^�2/+ �� B�� 3

#�!E� �J�.� .|V/7 ��.|VJ� >+#B;B,� S:B�, �+Q,� &G,� O&|/� �aI: ! a�� N0 :�B,�7�f! ���fe� #Bf;B,� �af� NBf[ Ö/�+ B)� �/�&�=�

���=�b�&�� =,>/$,� "#B;B, >�&�: b 3 f! �,b/f9� #�.fe� �a� [*+ �¬� �$�! "#A�� �a,� .%�,�7 a�pe� �a�, (��� U�&� NBV,� �a� N� &5+ �a,��

S���e� S.|V,� "a� �&: �� 3ÍBCf,� Ï.f! �f7b �� N�/&$,� N�a����F, ,���ae� �aH >�&��� ! �++ �a,�%6B� Í �&,0 SA���� ���J t[ 3

>,�f9.,� Í "#A�� �af,� �Bf$2,� �+�� ����,�f,Bc Bf�� , �f&�! � f] (�9�: " �JAB] ! T#i � u��" �b*f� �f7 lGf/9� �� (�!� �� B)�

()/+.f�D >j] ! S:B,�7 NB�?��,�,�� �Bf2,� N� A�f$/!�7 lf,w� Î�GfDu�� �&�� �&�! ��� µ (�!�, Y�5Cf,�� �tf9E� Xf&' f! �f?�B/:b

>&I��,>&I�� Y�a�, .)�� .)��� (J� B)� 3 �+f�� �af� �+.Æ T�J c� u�� ��ae� X� u5/+ t7 �)&;BJ� �B$2,�3

\��d�� K�`���G 7T2! 5�p ���, 1�f7A� �f� #A�B,� ��z!b�7 u�%/e� B��

n� o~ R�V��&� �Z�� :"9M&� W�^0 :W�PQ E '�? H�0 ��n �I)" �SK "L5� R. aU "H&�I :" =S&�)

�SK "L5�"E

Page 188: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

دة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظرية وح

− �{�{ −

�� .�2,���ae� �a� ! T<V,,�,Bc Í �JAB] Y��; :�� ��z!� B)� : " (k0– T<V,�� .�2,� O�� �� –�+f:Be� >&�BCf,� UBfc f! �B6z!� ,

�B,�c� :#Bf;B,� >&�&�: 8! #B;B,� �;�� N�[ N0, Xf&' Í �f�v Ëf�� (/�c �� ! ��&�E�,�)&� Y.)�� , #Bf;B,� >f�&�: T�Gf�D� lf,w �� Th�+

.|VJ���,>G&GM� ��&�¼, �)/G7<�� ,Y�A�w��,�� , �a� Oc�! ªB§ �&[� Ð � K l,w �! "h2e� �;�B,� >�&�: m0 >$G2,�7 .�E�" 3 �+Qf,� &Gf,� a�� (@

�,B�7 ��z!b� �a� �! (H�B; .[a7: " T�Gf�Db� T�hf, Npf7 �B7�;� (�� �B2¬ >L,�de�� .|V/,��,Bc� 8: P�,� ��%� N� `.J b� ± �f;� f! �!tGf�2� P&, �AE�=.f|V/�� =�,f%Lc =�, �f;B, Tªb .f|V/,�� T�Gf�Db� Of7

�AE�,"ff:� ��%�ff,� Y\ff/!� �w0 lffDx� , Offje� �ff! .ff�2,� XffLc Xff� �AE� �;� >�:<��,T�G�D� b� #%J �&� ABC/+ <� ,<f]� =3 1�Bf;�

>L,�de�,��+� ,U�|e� �a� �� (�%+ ,BD N� Oc�! ! 45� <� X�+ P�,� AAB2,� l,w PF2/+ b� >G&GM� ��&�E� !, >L9�B7 ¦�D �&,0 �.L/+ b�

Oje� >G�,>5+Q,� ��&�E� ! X�+ �D� t[ , -° >Lf9�B7 ��° +h+ b� Oje�,��°� �,�: ! 8,��� <[ Í AB2,� O7 3 -Qf,�� ¦�2f,� (�Bf/�

Oje� m0 X;�A,�&�E� ! "ABD X�+ ¢ B,� f��! ��f&� N�f[ �fe >G&GM� �=� <��[=, �Cc�D O7 "��F3

Sf:� ��af� ! 8�V/e� O$c �� &G,� "#A�� �a,� ��z!b� �a� N0�j$,� �+�2@ Í #A� N�� u$9 c #B;B,�,Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� ��A >�c�2� 2! , �+Qf,� &G,� >,#� >�c�2� 2! 4/:�,8�f� m0 (Gf�2+ ��zf!� Bf�� ;

n� o{�DX. RD� }�n�X&� ���c#& m�n�&� d�2) ~ $&��3 : $I3)��u \AE

Page 189: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

,� SAB] ¶�Gf$D� N� #Bf;B,� Sf:� ��af� ! ��z!b� �� U�E� u� Í� Of%5,�7 �f�.|VJ Th�/Gf+ S.f|V/e� ��&f�E� u?�f�: ! :�B,� #B;B,�

Xc�B,�,S:B,� Í�2+ �� B�� 3 P&Gf� Bf� �f� S.|V/e� u?���� �� N� ��z!b� �� .�g� u�,� SAB]�±

Aac� , �&�v� �)&�! #B;B,� �;�� #B;� ¶�G$D���I �/G7<� Th�/G+ �)&�, ���+0 �DB[� ,"�+0 �kB[�3#B;B,� �;�� Ut[ �� A.�� B� �� -<� B�� ,

<�� ¦?��2,� �! ��h2J�=P?�GM� �! 3 t)&,0 SA���� ��$9 c 86�z!b� �+a� O|��,5Di �&,0 ��BD t[ =�, �f��

#B;B,� S:� ��ae 8�L$� 86�z!� N�%+ uj7, +�� �V, ��; �a,�t)2! 1�B�� B� ¦2,� �a� �73 ABf2,� ¶�G$D� U�|7 N�[ 1�B�� .+.�J �V,

T�.;E� !,7�B; %+ b �/�&�: Í B)� =�&�! =� �&�! ���+ O&|� B� �� A�7 >&7�LM� 8��\,� X7�R, 8f7 >$9�2e� %7 X� SABC,� �+.�/, U�|� #.µ B)�

�7 �$�e�� �$�e�3�� ABC/+ <� ��afe ".+BCfJ Í "Z��afj7 U�f|e� �a� a#B;B,� S:�,�f;� �f� .|[E ; b�S�: SA.f�/� Y�w �f/�&�: Í ABf2,� N�

�A�M� Í ��#B;�,u�Le� #B;B,� -<d7 ,Åf�! Åf[ TBf)5� B� �a,�� , �A�M� Í >&|&�� "a� �� �, #B;� <�3

Ã�d��:��&f�E� u?�f�: ! �G$2+ N� �V+ b AB2,� N� lf�J �fD�[ �w0 b0 �A�M� Í NB[ �I� S#B;B� u?����,��&f�E� u?�f�: t2f&7 , 8�?�f�,� f2!

S:B,�7,�I #B;� b ,#B;B,� .|V/, b0� 3 \��d��:��&�E� u?��: ! AB2,� ¶�G$D� N� , >f�&�: u?���� "a� �D�[ B,� S:��,�AE� �;B[ , >f�&��� lf�J� ABf2,� 87 .+��/,� Th�/G+ Sf:�B,�,

N��&5,�� ¶�G$Db� ��w r] �e b0�3

Page 190: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�G�;��: u?�f�: �f� �&�! �LG$D� t7 .@p/J b �J�w� �/�&�: Np7 AB2,� .+BCJ Y��w�,>G&G� �� >5+° �D�[ ��B9 , m0 N�f%;.+ >GfM�� -Qf,� tD0�

AB2,� �&�! �G$D� Ë/,� u?���� Y��w, �R�Gf$D�7 #B;B,� U�: NBV+ �aV�� � �+° !�)G&G�� ��&�E,r&j] Zs .+BCJ , N� �f� �D�&7 u$9 c �e

�A�M� Í #B;B� Ë�&�: .�� AB2,�,.�Cf,� >f+�s Í Y�Aw �! SA�$! B�� , �)G5D Í >�&�� Zs,�ÖJ� �H .)�J ��&�E� �V,� , >f��|[ �G: ! O[

�F:� �DB,� �/&��5�� ��.;,Í .@*f+� T�.;� �� �&�! X�+ t7 .@p/+ AB2,�� �cB,� P5D3 u?�f�: �� �)&�! X�+ t7 �J�w� �/�&�: .@p/J b AB2,� N� �2�9

>G&G� �� >5+° �D�[ ��B9 Y��w�, ABf2,� Y�w NBf[ m0 X;.+ �a� �V, >&��e� Í u?���� l�J �! >�C52�,�AE� >&��e S.+��� AB2,� >&�t� , >&��e

��e�,.F�,� >&��e ,N�GD�� >&��e ,�&��e�� �)Cf?�C�� �)�?��j7 Sh+t/� Y�)��]���,~%$f,� �)�f%$7 .@p/J <� ,�/Gf�� Y�af,� -° �f&: �f� ,

>GFD Y�w �/G�b �� �w0 N�GD�� Y�w -Q[,�J�w Nx� ,Ëf� �&: �� , b >GFD Y�w m0 U$/J, �)/Gf�<e >f5+° Y�w m0 UBj/J >GF2,� Y�a,� b�

J�w=�>5+° ,N�GD��[ 3 S:� 1�j]� ��� >f&2&2@x7 NB,B�+ b (kx� #B;B,�, <��=S.|V,� �! ,P&G� �a�� �+° �a� U��+ 4/:,f:�� #B;B,� O7 ,

Y��c�2/e� X&' `B:,�J���6x7 Z|[ �J�a7 :�� B)� ,O&,w� h+h! B� t[ , X&6�� X&�A�,Z�f]� Z$[� ,P&Gf�� �f+°� ,"B,pf�� �f,0� , 1A�

1B7.��,°� Z�� ,.5[� Nt+0� ,�G:� r&f$c� ,�f&$�� �f&R� ,3 333»,�3

��z!b� �a� X�# �A�25,� �+,� P� U��: c�, "#A �.%� Í l,w� Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� !,��z!b� �a� O|7 �z!� t2&: , �A�f25,� 1�;p�

Page 191: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�  −

Y�2Ve� u?��� Í�6�� #B;B,� N�,>+#B;Be� 42%7 , m0 >f]�� >$GD �, u�� #B;B,�,� #B;B,� 8! b u�, �fJ�w Í ��f,� 1Bf;� �f� Thf�+ b�

·BC² �� m0 �7�G/D� 1B;�,Y�#Bf;Be� B� #%/e� N� 42%7 , Ç�fµ #B;B,� �GD,#B;B,� P5D b ��F3 �7�B; �a�, m0 lf,w Zs� >GM�� -Q,�� #%/,� U�:� �DE .��� "#�G��

Y���6��� �G2,�,Y�#B;Be� Ë� Ë/,� ,�J�w #B;B,� b , �a�� �f/�&�: Í�<�%,� ���%+ 1�BF7 P&,, �f� �f�+ Y�A�f$%7 UBf�%�, ��f�� �+B� O7

S?��� O&C� �)?�A�3 ? b T� #B;� �I O� �G2,�� Y���6�� "a� U��+ w0 �C?�C� Í "h+��� #B;B,� .|VJ �2� Th, #B;� �I N�[ Nx�, �fI �V+ ¢ N0�

StGfe�� Y�#Bf;Be� "a� #B;B, >�&�: <� #B;�Y���f6��� �Gf2,�7, #B;� <7 S#B;B� �k0 U��+ N� rC+ �&[ �V,,�� O u/�fe� Y�f$@0 O�%+

���/�b� a�p� Ë5D�3Y���f6��� �G2,� "a� NB[ �.� ! (@ , Ëf/,�� Y�#B;Be�7 �)2! \!,S#B;B� ,Sf:�B,� Y�af,� NB�f� �f)/�&�: Í Ë)� ,

>GM�7 SA�J� -Q,�7 �]BJ SA�J Ë/,�,�G��7 SA�J� r$�,�7 SA�J� , SA�fJ� N�V���7 SA�J� 1B;B,�7,1B7.e�7 SA�J� 1.,�7 SA�J� ,�aV�� , b0 (f@ t�

�;�B,� #B;�,u�Le� #B;B,� ,`B9 (@ ��� ,<]� =3 Y�A�f$/!b� Npf7 XfL�+ #Bf;B,� S:� ��a7 �++ �¬ >&�BC,� X&' w0

uf�� Y�w �� Ë� Y���6b�� �G2,��,m�f%J ,e� u?�f�: Ëf)� Y�f2V, >/7�|,� N�&!E� Ë� Ë/,��,#Bf;B,�� (f�%,� Ë&�µ Í , ~&f5,� Bf� U�E�f�

}cE�,}�e� ~&5,� B� .�g�� , >f$J.� �f� 8�f&5,�� 8&�Fe� <[�

n� o�Z�� :��4� ]��^. :W ��E

Page 192: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

u�� >+:��,u�Le� #B;B,� B� �a,� ,Ë� B�� B� Ë)� , �f+B/,� �a� (�� OR�$,� ��ae� �a� �+�z, 3 s� �&$�/,� �a� O|� Nx� �a, NB�?�f�,� �f)&,0 pfF�+ Ëf/,� Y�)&$�f/,� �f� "Z

�)2! Z$%/�, S:B,�7,��AB] ~%7 m0 SA���� ���J t[ , �f)&�! UJ b >&�7�L� SABC7,f%5D �v <� =�, �f+.�J� r&f6B/�, >f�|�� #.fµ Ëf� Of7

S.V5,�,.|[� b 3 S:� Í Î�;.�� �+Q,� >,�9A �D� �.! �� �s.� c NB[� �2� m0�

�#B;B,,�D� �)6.! U<� �� N�7 c� ,m�%J � ��A , ��afe� �aI �/2+ ¥B6� OV7,"�f+0 "#��/!� ! U+ �, "A�C/D�� ,�f7 �&�GfJ� , �f�/Æ b�

¥° f! �/&f��: Í �]BCfD Í �)2! "#A�� t! �)&� #B;B,� S:� S.V�+.F/,�,�)/�c�2� u$9 Ë/,�� ,ae� >&���� ·BCD Í �D� b0 #A�� fc SAB[

��ae� �a� >j] ! �/,#�3 �+Q,� &G,� N� 8$J �/,#�� ��<V, >�&5/Ge� >�c�2e� "a� %7�, � ��A

m�%J,�, 85,*e� �+a� U<� �� ��ae� �aH �++ , ¥° ! �/&��: ��� +.F/,�,#B;B,� S:� Í �)5,� Ë/,� �/,�9A� , f�D >f+�7 Í Tf�J c �V, ]BCD��ae� �a� #.J �c�Be� ¥° 1�/[ Í ·BCD �2! Y#A� c �D� �,

N�V7 >&�E� �� �k� b0 SZG+ Y�A��0 �D�[ N0 Ë��, T! ! UJ �kE ��ae� �aH "�6A,uf�� 1�2F7 u?b Zs B� �� m0 Ö5+ �DBV, , �D�j$f9

m�%J�3 AB[afe� ¥Qf,� �f� ·BCfD ¾<@ ��2� �, Y#A�� ��; Â8_��� (�Bf�

"�6A T!� "�6.,,Of�%,� ABfR �B� �Dp7 ��ae� �aI �5]� B�� , �f&: >��%,� AB�E� �� #B;B,� �:�$� Í U�c: " >f5,�d/� Y�#B;Be� u?��: N0

Page 193: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

SA�À,�7, b -�f]�E� �Gfj7 #%/J S:�� Y�w OV,� N� �� U��+ ��� �)&,0 �5/�+ b S.7�V� �D�%+ O�%,� ABL7 N�&�/e�� Zs"��F, N�C2,� ����

uf�� >fL,�² ���h�/f9b #B;B,� S:� S.V5, #A t)&5� N�.�g�, �D�j$f9 m�%J�,Y�2Ve� X&� ,Y�A�w��,� 4/: ,O&j/G� .�� >L,�de� "a� NE ,

hf&&� 4D#� �, ��� Oc�! �7 UB�,� ! ¡z§ b� F, Í ���f; N�Cf2,� �af�� Y�&I�� Í P��M� �cBe�,�.�p/� t)� u7�G,� ¦2,� �! N3

�D�Gfj/9�� "�6A �� 87�/V,� l2+w Í �$@ �� 87 �A�%J� ~c�2J �2))���ae� �aI,�&�! Ub/9b�� �2! ���,� O7 ,1�/V,� �a� Í �2! �$@ ��� ,

�c�Be� ¥° Ë2!�,"�f+0 ��f�A f! U+ �¬ , 8Cf2,� Í ��f; �f� >f]�� �+Z�E�,Y�f&I�� �cB� Í ��� ,J tf[ Tf�, �f! .�pf/� �fcB� Bf��

>��%,� AB�E� Í �j$,�,Î�f|,� �fcBe� Í B� �a,�� 3 �af,� 8+�.f,� �pf� �+Q,� &G,� �&�! .�/9�,m�%J � ��A 3�fj7 m0 ��f/� >,pGe� "a� N0 ,

#�)/;b� b0 �&� �2! P&,�,�D�&7 Ôp&9 t[ 3 6��D� 5� R>? ��"� �� Z �4)� `�a:−

N0 �f$/[ �f� .�pf/e�� Tf�/e� >f�.%� m0 ��f/y >,pGe� "a� Í .�2,� u&��SAB[ae� ¾<|,�,T�/�, »9�D T�V:E� �� .�p/e� NE 3

m0 Of]BJ� (�� "a� �$/[ �� .�p/e� �� T�/e� -.!� N� �,��: � u���>F&/D,�<Rb�� �j$,� S.|[ ! 3�f$/[ .f|[� ! �&J� �� , lf�J >f]��

>@<|,� �/V,�,+.F/,� ¥° ! �/&��: �H Ë2!�� , Í �f)5,� Ë/,� �/,�9A�

n� o&� ]�f�I��D :� W ��u ,W �Z��)u�+M�&� R. E

n� o�Z�� :�I��D&� ]�f :� W �u ,WO� ,�Z��) : Wu� – u +M�&� R. E

Page 194: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

#B;B,� S:�,�c�Be� ¥°� , X�J (�� ��.�i m0 �I�� �� �)&�! �&J� �� O&��,� Ë5�+ �� ! Ë2&!,O&�%,� ¡\+ �� 3 �fc� N� l,w �� Ñ.s N�[�

�2� SA��0 !,m�%J � ��A ,�J &5+ �� ! UJ f! �/V,� "a� ~%7 T`.�E�,<|� Z�+ Np[ =� m0 �c�Be� ¥° Í *8�7�Gf,� �f&5,, Í .[af+ ��

�c�Be� ¥° �7�/[ 85,*e� �+a� :�, T�/e� m0 Y�A���� "a� O|� U/� .�p/e� ��,�J�52Cf� �&,pfJ »+A�fJ &5+ �� `.�E� �$/[ Í .[a+ N� �� , ��

�)?t9� .[w 4/:,.5�� (�� ��[ l,w �� ��7 3 �f, �Bf'.J �+af,� 4/: O7 �f�.|[� �&,¹fJ »+A�BJ ��.[a+ ¢ �$/[ �t9� ��#¿�, �f2+.c �f/[ -<fd7

Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� ,�f5&,¹J .f|[� »+A�BfJ ��.[w �, 8'ze� Nx�, �[�f��� Of7 �)5&,pJ3

�2� ´�.5,� N�V�� »+A�J &5+ �� �c�Be� ¥° >+�k Í ��; c �D� Zs,� ��%,�G5D &G,� T<[ ��,U�c �&: : " �$Gf,� TBf+ �f5&,pJ �f� ´�.5,� Xc� c

�2&f] 2c.9 >9�.j7 >?tDt@� X$9 >29 U�B� O?��� �� �%,� �+.cY��g� �!"��F 3f+.F/,� ¥° f! �/&��: Í #.+ ¢ �V,, �/,�f9A Í b�

#B;B,� S:� Í �)5,� Ë/,�,�)2� ´�.5,� »+A�J ! U+ �� , �fc� ¢ Î� tf[ <�f� 85,*fe� �+af� m0 Z�+ �� �+ 87 Ë/,� `.�E� �$/[ Í= .f[w �f!

t)5&,pJ »+A�J3 Tf�/,�7 (fV�� Ç 42Gf/&, t)2f� ´�.f5,� Xc� 4/� �A#� <� ¾<|,� Y�5,*e� "a� 87 .�p/,��3

r&f;z, Öf5e� ��,� T%D <� ��h2�, XR��,� 8�&,� O&C� �2�! �w0 �V,

n� o�I��D&� ]�f :�uW ��� E ~ 3�USD&� ]�c&� R. ­�0 �I ���c&� ��%&� �A G#� �� RD.)���Z&� �cU ~ $5�#k /n�2 |�c&� |�3�V&� �SK ,&� �k R. |�3�V&� �SK �U7 �A �U7) ��%

H%5� ���c&� E���Z&� �cU �Z�� :� W �uQ�E

Page 195: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

رية وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظ

− �{�� −

1�BC,�,}B52,� �&,0 ��LJ �;� ! ,�BV�,� �7 U�hJ� 3 �f! �&,pf/,� Í S.�p/� �c�Be� ¥° 1�/[ N� ��,� ! �,��,� N0 UBcp�

85,*e� l2+w,.�p/� ��; �5&,pJ �� ´�.5,� N� l,w =�, O$c �5&,pJ �� ´.� �� Y�B29 XG/7 �J���,>29 8/9� X$9 >7�.c ��w0 .%,� �� �, �� 3�wx� �D�[

>29 �+Q,� &G,� S#b���{f� , >2f9 �J���� ���ff� , Í �fD� �f2�!� �+ª\e� ³7�B2,� �� N�[ "�$]� ".! O$/��, �f/[ fc NBfV+ N� f%$+ <f�

���.c Ë/,� �/V,� ! ��B:,S?�5,� O;E , f! �A/Gf+ �f�0 �)&� B�� �,*e�,<µ OC5+ �� = , ��/y S?��� >/VD ! �$2+ ���)&,0,U/Gf+ �� , �� �z%+,�f/V,� f! �t�%,� �)%�+ Ë/,� ��B�� ��.s� �� l,w Zs� 3 $,�s Ë��=�(�%,� ��R Y�+�7 Í NBVJ �� , �,��,� Í (�%,� �,�R ��&�+� �G52,3

(;.fJ �f� ~%7 ".[w �� "A�5�� >�B%D a2� TB�%,� Í "h&�� �sB$D ! U+ ! Y��&�%J� ��B: X6� �D� �,"�$f] Í >f&��V,� ¥° >&��B,� , �2f]�

$/[=�>&9A�5,�7 Bj2,� Í ,>&��2,�� >&��%,� TB�%,� Í (@ ��F3�+�� =� Í ��f; �f� �ª�.f,� f_ �+,� �Lc P�µ À: �7�$� Í �2�w cBJ S�, �D� �/'.J

X,�Le� ¥°� >&G�,� >,�9.�, �:° �&�! �.�&, S�.H, Í UB§ ".V� `�.� uL2e��\,� �B�[,"�� �A�$� "a&�J ! �,� ,�� Í (&�� B�� , O:.�

�2! a��� �&,0 �+Q,� &G,�, Öf�+ �f� �f2� "�f� �A�f$� »&�,� `�A c� $F!=�,�ª�.,� �+,� �L�, X,�Le� ¥° 1�/[ �&�! �.�&, &G,� ��ªb �� ,

5Di AB[ae�=�,�+Qf,� &G,� "�� �A�$� »&�,� XG� ,f�B+ =�>�f] , Bf��

n� o$�L�&� �`��5&� :W� PE

Page 196: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

>9Ae� Í �9�A# .[�a+,UB�+ B�� : �af[ ¥A��,� U�c – �+f,� �fLc �� �ª�.,�– �af[ w�/9b� U�c� – "�f� �A�f$� »&�f,� �� –�af[ UBfc� �fD�� 3

"�� �A�$� »&�,� �7 �F!p�,1.R t+� 1.R� , Sf� �f� ¦fcA �D0 4/: �7.R,+.+ �� O%5+� (�V/+� �.�+ N� �, Nw�� 3�: �+Q,� #B9 ��2�� >&f�

AB[ae� X,�Le� ¥°,7�� U�ª b B�� =�".! O$/�� Í ��F3 S� 4D#� Í TB�%,� O&C� �� ´.� �D� �/'.J Í ��; �� �a[�3 �, Y.; c�

Í �f��J� �sB$D ! UJ >+�V: .5�� �+,� ��F� "��,� ª�Z� ([�: X�.fV$� (�%,�=�, N� #�A� �fe �+Qf,� &Gf,� N� �f/'.J Í ��f; f�� -Qf/+

.VG%,� }�$, P$, AB[ae� "��,� >�ª<7,Î�ª�f/5/,� �+f,� %Gf, U�fc� , 7.�� N�[�=�"��,� P�µ m0 ,Ë�.,� Í .��� �+.s O;A Î0 , 4%GJ N� B;A�

�J�c<� Ç ¯&/&, N�L�G,� 2! Ë�: Í, 4f/: &Gf,� 4�f�� %G,� �[.� ��,� 1�7 m0 <]�,1�$,� ! %G,� �5c�p� ,! O�#� .[w� N�L�G,�

���]��,N�L�G,� �$�L� ,Ë�.,� Í l,t[ ÎA� �, U�c� ,�h; &G,� �.�p� =� �%$R �?�/D �� 852Ce� ! Y�6�z!� �&�,N�L�Gf,� "�L!�� , "af� U�fc�

Ë��)9,Ë/%2] "a�� ,�/$J.� ! N�L�G,� X�R�� ,��z:�� ��!� ±, �7.c� �G�µ ��,�5�,� A�# P+AJ �&,0 �B�� , f&5+ 82f9 Q! >7�.c �)&� O�� }A+�� F3 >?t%$9� 8%$9 >29 >+�V�� "a� ��C: n��{f� o N�f[ ��

&G,� .!,m�%J � ��A ,>29 8@<@ ��w w0 3 Bf�� �fD��ª �tf�!� �fD�.c� ! �+Q,� &G,� T�J ! UJ >+�V�� "a)�

n� o�Z�� :$�L�&� �`��5&� :W� � −� � ,W�O� −�O� ,$���D-�&� y`�Nc&� :WQ −QOE

n� o$�L�&� �`��5&� :W�O�E

Page 197: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

7�� U�ªb=�,c Ëf/,� �f/V,� f! ��B�� �/[ c �D�� �f)&�! Xf�R�� �f��..V$�=�,+*� ��0 �)&�! u�%� =�6z%� �� =�,:A�� �� =�,��_ �� =�b/G�� =, tf[

8�je� Np� B�3 �f­��.c f2! NBVJ �/V,� ! �t�%,� �)%�+ Ë/,� ��B�� N� �,��,� Ë5�

�)&�! �<Rb��3 f! �+Qf,� &Gf,� �)%f6� Ëf/,� ��Bf�� Np� �a�� �ff��.c Ëff/,� �ff/V,�,ff+.F/,� ¥° ff! �/&ff��: �ff)2�� , ¥° -<ffd7

�c�Be�,.�p/� �Dx� ,Y�B29 X�$7 �J��� O&$c &G,� �5,� �� ±, 1�f/[ Bf�� Z$[ ¥°� �,*�,>&��: #.µ P&,� 3

¥° O$c �)5,� �D� ��,� ! ���&� #B;B,� S:� Í �)5,� Ë/,� >,�9.,� ���SZC�,�7 �G&, Sz57 �c�Be�,�� N�[ �e 7=��h/�� =�-BCf/,� l�G� ,af�i =�

>+2$��2,� >�+.L,�7,�#�� =�f_ �7 _ �;�B� �d&� ��F,�+f,� �<f! , A�L%,�,�A�d$,� , >29 ÍB/e� n�{�f� o, �f)5,� c >,�9.,� l�J N�� >]��

>&9A�5,� >��,�7,f$/[ �7�$f�� "�$f] Í �f,� �fD� �f2! Of�2,� Tf�J c �DE =� >&9A�5,�7 O?�9A�3

,�&,0 O&�� �a,�� �a,�?�.�,� l�J m0 .�2,�7 , .�pf/� �fc�Be� ¥° �7�/[ N�

n� o =3�_�&� 3�x-&� R��&� �s�EEEEEE�− u� jK EF

�DM. R? �DM. ,R��&� �s� ,=3�_�&� ,&�/.b3��_ ,3�x-&� , r3��. ~ ��,p ~ "#-&� 8#�e3�_? ,1�#� d�� ~  ��) ,��^V&�) ��#%&� "#-& m�X:) ,H_�f R� ��^V&� SkA) , |�f

�DM. R? �DM. ���cN� R��&� ��� Hn��k $����cN�&� $N��x&� ,/%�)4� , $�� m�&�D&� =3�_�&����jK , $�� ~�VD&�)�Q�jK Ex-&� R��&� �s� ~�: $��I ~ 3�" �����,n "e3�_? '�D�A R. ,

R0m ��) E�Z�� :$�m3�&� y`��M&� :W����K�-? �.) E |�f =���cN�&� R��&� ��� $Dn�: �Z��)y?�%&� on�D&� ~ $����cN�&� $N��x&� :W� P�K�-? �.) E

Page 198: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�{ −

85,*e� l2+w �! �&,p/,� Í, �f/V,� �f� �fc�Be� ¥° �7�/[ N�� >]�� >2G,� O�� �t�! `, >,��/e�� S/%e�,}A�e� Í }A+ N�[� 3 �+Q,� &G,� N� r;.e� �� �a� !�,m�%J � ��A ,c �f�&� �! X;A

#B;B,� S:� ��a� m0,#B;B,� �;�� >L,�de Th�/Ge� ,m�%J� �D�j$9 , Y�A�w��,�� P?�Gd�,,Bf�! lf,w �f! � m�f%J =�Zf$[ =�, >fL,�de� "af�

Oc�! �H UB�,� ! �z§ b Ë/,� >G7<e��, �+Qf,� &Gf,� lf,w .f[w t[ �G5D3

Page 199: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

K���� KLA� �� #��� � b�D� 67!� !/!� �8� ���4�

�f7 8�?�f�,� .)��� ���Gc�� #B;B,� S:� ��a� �.! �� ´�.5,� %7�, �.f%/,� �f� 7b �)/�c�2�� �+%G,� ·BCD �.!�, O&$f9 f! Bf,�

U�'��,#Bf;B,� Sf:� >f+.�D �� (&�G,� O�%,�� (&V�� �A��,� �cBe , �)�#�CJ T� t)���BJ O�3j$e� �a� Í �D�&7 #�� �� �a� �3

O�� ���2� : !/!� �8� ���4� �� b�D� 67!� :− #B;B,� S:� ��a� >�&�: �2, 8$J N� %7, N� `.+ �a,� ��ae� B� �D��

�,m�%J ,#B;B,� �;�� ,�2&%7 ¢�%,� �a� B� , ".f)��� "<fµ �fD� A�$/!�7 �&� .)�� v �a,�,B� B�� , fµ� .f)��� SABf] Of[ 8f! m�%J B)� ,

=2G:�j&$c �� N�[ =�,$&R =�|&$� �� =�,�2, N�7 ,lf� �f� Zfs �f� , ��af� �fD� >�ff&5/Ge� >2Gff,�� 1�ff/V,� Ybb# .��Bff� �A�ff%+, 8ff7 �.ff5J Ëff/,�

Y�#B;Be�,u?����� N�&!E� 87 h&�� , �f­�&��� Í Y��af,� 8f7 OC5J� �)��V:�� �­�#B;��,/J �� YB%2,�� ¦?�CM� �� >&���� Y�w OV�� hf&

��Zs �! �H,>&!Q,� T�V:E� �$J.J �a� !� 3 �<fF7 �+�$/,�� h+t/,� �a� O|� �D;� >2G,�� 1�/V,� ·BCD Í �D.�D �wx�

¥B6��,&�; �a� .)�+ =���afe� �af� �f2/VJ Ëf/,� Sf9�5,� Tª�B�,� Í , Ôg� �;B,� ! >2G,�� 1�/V,� ·BCD Ybb# �7 OL$/�:−

����:ae� �a� N0 Y�w� 8! Í �k�&!� Í S.+��/e� >J��5/e� u?���� X§ ��S:��, u+.5/,� �� �Q,� ·BCD �&�! �,# Ë/,� .��B�,� N<L7 �2� Th�&�

�B�de�� u,�M� 87,1B7.e�� 1.,�� ,"B,pfe�� �,��� ,lf�5,�� lf�e�� , N�L&�,�� Ë$2,��,��*e�� ,.��V,�� ,©�%,�� X?�L,�� ,�� �G��� r&f$�,,

Page 200: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�&$M�� �&L,��,.[w �¬ �� 87 h+�� <� , Y��w 8f7 4f/: h+�f� b Of7 8cB�de�,�.! #B;� B� +ª #B;B� ,.V7 #B;� B� ,(+.f� #Bf;� B� ,

>§� #B;� B�,3 3333»,�,S:�� 8! �� OV,� w0 ,S:�B,� 8%,� B� O7 , ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� U�c t[,�]BCfD ���J t[ ,Í ��f; �f&: �)�f%7 : " &G,�� $%,� 87 P&,,1B7.e�� 1.,� b� , >�f6�5� �B�de�� u,�M� b�

"��F3T#i �! U�c� ,T<G,� �&�! : " uf�M� u�� B� "� F3 >f�A �f! U�fc� m�%J � �� N�2/�b�: " B� b0 (@ ��� �/�� �� %� "�OF3 �a� Í �]BCD�

f6Be� �af� Í Ì�� �� �� .|[� 1�$,�X3 ��afe� �af� N� #BCf�e�� �)2&7 �c.�� Y��a,� 87 Yh&� Ë/,� �Q,� Ybb# �,��, u+.5/,� >]��

� 87,m�%J ,#B;B,� �;�� ,u�M�� ,#B;B,� �V¬ B� �a,� 3 m�%J U�c: " �� ��|[ P&, "��F,m�%J U�c� : " ��.f�5,� (/D� }�2,� �q� �+ � m0,ff&�� Ëff2�,� Bff� �� "�PF ,U�ffc�: " �AE�� Y��tGff,� uff��u��7"��F,�Bf�de�� u,�fM� 8f7 hf&&/,� f! >,�,� Y�+g� �� ��Zs� ,

~%7 �! ()�%7 8cB�de� h+���3 ��ae� �a� ! S9�5,� Tª�B�,� �� N0 (@, 1�/V,� Ybb# �A�%J Ë/,��

Aa�/G�� �Õ� r$�/G� B� t7 m�%J ���CJ� T�h, >2G,��,t[ l,af7 ¥¤

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W �Q ,�Z��) :��W PE

n� o"9M&� W�^0 :WP�E

n  o9M&� W�^0" :W�POE

n� oe3�c&� d3�� : $�l���E

n� o���0 d3�� , $�l��PE

n� o"�K��?� d3�� , $�l��QE

Page 201: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�  −

�7 (�9� Ï.! �7�,�]BCD ���J t[ ,�,Bc �)2� : " �fJB5+ N� �V+ b – u�� ��–�)2� �%D ,�.! S#B_ �D�[ ��B9� =�<�!� =!°� =�, >�B�a� ��

�.!=�<�!� =!°� =�, � 4Gfe b0 l,w P&,� ,m�f%J , >f]�� "��F3 t2f&7 N��&�� �&$D >29� m�%J � 1�/[ N� FDm�%J P+�J� �+h2J B� t73 U�fc

�G5D �! m�%J: " \fV/e� A�f$�� hf+h%,� �&f)e� ��*fe� T<Gf,� }�f�,�NB[Q+ t! � N�j$9"� F3 �G5D �! m�%J U�c�: " TBD b� >29 "a�pJ b "�OF,U�c� : " � Xf9 f�,

��&2s� �jD� Z�� � N0 �B,�c �+a,� UBc"��F,U�c� : "¢ ,B+ ¢� �+ "�PF, U�c�,(�9� �&�! � ] : " T�2+ N� �, Ë�$2+ b� T�2+ b � N0 "��F3

#B;B,� �a� Í A#�] T<[� O%� O[ NB[ ��ae� �a� �� Th�+ �D�� t[,+� =� "AC� N�[,�/%&$R� , � T<[� O%� B� ,m�%J ,"Z�, #B;� b w0 , (@ ��� ± �

`B9,b N� �&�! Th�+� �&�! Sa��*e� �JzJ ,�f�<[� �f�%� �fDE ,m�f%J , N�GD0 �� l�� �� A] ��B9,N�L&� �� ,��*f� �� ,.��f[ �� ,Ëf�J �� , ��

.;��,��<[� ��%� l,w O[ 3Ï.f! �7� U�c : "uf�� >2Gf,� OfV,� , >f�R�D

n� o"9M&� W�^0 : W�QE

n� o�cM&� d3�� , $�l� OE

n  od�N�&� d3�� , $�l� PPE

n� o���D� 'T d3�� , $�l��u�E

n� oWskz� d3�� , $�l�OE

n� oHM�Mp ~ "#%. 1�.z� Hn�kA ,VU��D�z� t� ,1s%&� H�#� H&�I ~ t�? :"1��� � �� �� " : WQ� , ]� QO− ��QEF

Page 202: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

u�� ! ��2|,�7,333, �&�! 4�2|e�� Ë2|e� B)� � �K K�"��F,U�c� : Ë2&! Y.�D t�Zs m0 �f);� �ff�<[ -<ff� Îw� �%ff9 �ff��� F

U�c�:− 1�ff�w �ffI 8�ff��%,� 1Bff�c

"�.fffJ b �fff� Y��fff� Ëfff� �w0

�ff2&� ��&ff�E� �ffF!� �ff� �w�

"�.fffffD w0 "�.fffffD �fffff�� "�.fffffD �ff$! �ff&�A UBff�+ w0 Å&ff,#� � � � K

"�Bfff9 Ëfff��.,� tfff� �fffF%J <fff�

CffD Ni.ff�,� Í ��ff; ffc �aff[=�

Í .ffff�E"�ffff�# ffffc 8ffff2: �OF

U�c�: "4�A � �V,� �&�A w0 �&�A �� ,�7 �7 t7 (/d� , �.%f� �f&,�&� �9B,� ��,Ë5D 87 �9� �Dx� , �,Bc B�� " �&�A ��� "Y�$@0 87� , Bf��

�,Bc: " 4�A � �V,�",�,Bc B�� :�fD� � �fV, �fD� w0 �fD� �� 3 �af)� e�� .���,� Í �2�<[ Í �2,Bc 42%�.��f�,�f2&! �fD�� , ABf] -</f�� Xf�

.���e�"��F3m�%J �,Bc �! U�c� : " (@ (q+p7 1�/V,� NB$/V+ �+a�, O+B� � 2! �� �a� NB,B�+"�PF: ""2! �� �� B�� , �f;B,� Zfs �f� �V,�

NB!h+ �a,�"��F 3 � �f� Bf� #B;B,� �a� Í T<[� O%�� >2V9� >[.: O[ Í .�E� �aV��,

Jm�% , Y�2VGf,�� Y�f[.�� "af� �fH �f��c Ëf/,� ¢�%,� Y��w 8! B� w0

n� o"9M&� W�^0 :W�QE

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W �PQE

n  o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W OuQE

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W ���E

n� od�N�&� d3�� , $�l��QE

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W �� E

Page 203: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

U�BcE�� U�%�E��3 f2! �k� �&D,� S�&�� Í Y�5,�² �2� YA] �a,� Ë��,� Í Ï.! �7� UB�+

�2� �)K2G: .)�+ S.�g� Í u?���� -��VD�� K,�f)�[ Utf!E� Xf&' �G:� K K�, f��%,� N� TB&,� l,w �, ��V2+ �&: � Bf� �fI O,m�f%J ,"Zfs b , Ëf)�

�,t!�,m�%J ,r$c b� �)&� ¦�D b �G�� >���[ �)�[ �,t!�� ��F3 >&&J �7� .[w�,m�%J � ��A , N� Sf:B,�7 8�?��,� >&�BC,� �b*� 2! N�

;�G,�� X[�.,� B� �,X6�M�� ,7�%,�� ,(?�Cf,�� ,X?�f��� ,(?�f�,�� , (?�2,��,� B�� T��9E�� ��.�E� �$&CJ �a,,��f!E� �&�/$J� , �f7 /�fJ� ���¼,�,333»,�� F3

(�:� U�c: <%52fff� �j$fff]�="A�fff/Æ �fffe

Y�fff!�R �fff�[ Åfff%5� Ëfff2��OF

�&�V/,� N<L7 ��ae� �a� �� Th�&� �a� !�,�f�Ve� 8f! ��Ve� w0 Ð K ± K� �, ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� �aH ¥¤ t[��F3 >�' ��� �f,Bc 1�f$,� �a� Í ��<[: "

>f@#�: SAc (@ N� N�.+ <� � O�� �� NB�A�%,� ���,<f]� =, �f)2! NBfV+ �� O%� , Of_ Í ËI0 (9� ! ËI0 (9� �� 1�LM�� �&�V/,� Xc� tD0�Î�&[ $!,5�V� $%,� ËG� = �Ð K�5&�VJ 1�LM� l,w� =� "�PF3

¦�E� 42%e�7 Tªb Tª<,� �a��,7 f! Ub/f9b� m0 .f�/5+ b �D� 42%

n� o�Z�� :�$�9D&� C�2�V5& :�OW ��OE

n� o$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W �Q− P�E

n  o�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :���W �PE

n� o W �Z�� � ,u�+M�&� R. E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW ��OE

Page 204: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

T�h��, Tª<,� YB$@,��ae� �a� ABCJ #.F7 �Dx� , N�&!� N� m0 ���a,� 4f2%� N<L$7 �!a+� O�%,� (�G+ �J�2&%J� u�� Y�w Ë� >+#B;B,� u?����

�&�V/,�, 4D#E� Y�a,� m0 >$JA !E� Y�a,� �� Ë��BD� .���� B� �a,�� >ff$JA,ff� T�hff, Xff� 8J�aff,� h+�,�ff&�V/,� Ëff!��# uff��� , >!�L/ff9b�[

A�&/�b��,XD�Be� ��5/D�� 3 ? �a� �&�VJ �p� !? �/&c ��� !��Ve� 8! ��Ve� N�[ �w0Ð K ± K,Bf� B� �DE , `B9� Zs (@ ���3

Z|[ FD �a,=�lf/)/,�� NBfFe� ��af� m0 Of&+ ��afe� �aH �++ �¬ , f,� �&,�V/,�7 O%,� �.J�>&!Q,S<Cf,�[ ,TBCf,�� ,S�f[h,�� ,�f��� ,

Y�#�$%,� �� ��Zs�,>f&�[ �+f,�� >%+Qf,� �f� Ã<GDb� O7 , Ofy <f� b<:=,��.: T.y b� =�,S:�� 8! �� OV,� w0 3

�b*f� U�: �� 4V� c ¢�! �� ([�,()[B�f9 A�Bf! ��f[� , #�Gf�� (HQ�,`I� �! (I<6� ()��.jD�� 3

ÍBC,� �a)� �b*f� �f� >f5?�R �f� Aafy Å&f�� (+.V,�$! »&�,� Z$V,� >&�BC,� O[ �� �k� Ë!J± K,��9A� �7 ��*J b �I�: >�&�: Í �)2V, , b�

.�g� TB&,�7 ,>&!Q,� �&,�V/,�7 &�/J b�, �f$�c Í �� �&�J.+ b �;� ! Nt+�� �� SAw U��|�, ��V,� O�� �J�.� m0 O]� �� �&V� N�&%,����F3

#B;B,� S:� ��a7 .@pJ �! A�L&$,� �+,� ��H �a� O|� .[w�, Èf�p� >&!Q,� �&,�V/,� �.J m0 �7, � �° �! ��.!��� ,m�%J , ��� O:� ���

T.:,>c#�Dª ()� ,=2R�7 S.5[ �, � Of:� �� NB�y b (kE , �f� NBf�.y b�

n� o�Z�� :m�n�&� d�2) G�-. R. m�^ND&� ]�Y�� :W�u−�QE

Page 205: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

T.:,U�;,� �� O;#� ()� ,70 �f� �%,�� P&f�, }�f2�, N�.f)�+ (fkE � ���+�.e� 8j]�2,� SABC7, � m0 8�]Be� ,(k�f��+� T�Bf%,� ()2�p&� , �&� (kB;A/G+ NB,�h+ b�=��&�� =�>|&$M� >�.%e� l�J m0 (�B�]B+ 4/: ,

Y�f&)2e� Of%�� Y�AB�pfe� �.J ª�B; ()/L!� Ë/,�, �f&�V/,� N� #�f�/!�� �a� m0 O]�B,� �! �c�9T��e� ��F3

�f&� P&f, Ni.�,� N0 UB�+ N�[ �D� Î�G�/,� �&5%,� �! >&&J �7� O�D c�ff&:BJ,�° �ff�[ Ni.ff�,� Off7 ,>ff;�h,� 8ff7 �.ff5+ b �ffD�� ,>ff&$2;E�� , ��E��,:�� OV,� ,��.: NB7BFje� "�/!� tD0� =� ()&�! T�.: B� �2��� (�2!,T�.: (@ t� �D2! ���� ± �� F3 X�.���ae� �a� ! Tªb �)2� S?�5,� ��5/D�� �&,�V/,� 3 f&�J �f� 4f/:�

�H Th/,�� >&!Q,� �&,�V/,�7,�H a��� �Q,� Ybb# \/!�� , Of�+ �D� b0 ± �X?�Qf,� "af�� �&,�fV/,� "a� >&�: "�v ".�� �� SZ: Í, lf,w .f[w tf[

�A�25,� »&�,�,���� "!� =�#B_ =�(q, ,� O%; �&: uf&�� Y�f�<! �O%5,�� Y�a,� >+:�,#B;B,� Í Y�a,� S:� �� ,Of%5,� S:B, Ö/�e� ,

�)%�A XcB/+ b SZ: § �$:�] N�,�)&� l�+ b� ,�f)%�A �2V+ b� , NE >+:E� #B)� &5+ ��V,�,>df9�A >fV�� #B)�,� l,w A�] �wx� , Xf2/�� #%/,� T�V:� �� SZ�� X�A ,$%/,�7 �&�V/,�[�OF3

Of9.,� U�f9A0 N<fL7 #B;B,� S:� ��a� ! Th�+ t[, Í >f;�: <f� (I�9A0 ,�fH ����f; Ë/,� ()&,�%J� ()%?�° ��A� �� S?�� b�, Of9.e�� � K

n� o�Z�� :"�2�&� RD2�&� JV0 :�PuE

n�o �Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W ��− �P ,W �Z��)���−�� E

n  o�Z�� :��4� ]��^. :WP �E

Page 206: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

()&,0 O9.e� 8! B� O9.e� 8! B�� K,S:�� 8%,�� >,�9.,� NBVJ �� mx� 3 m�%J �,Bc �� �b*� 2! S?�� �p�: "�f9A� �fD0 f:BD �2=� AafD� N� �f�Bc m0 (&,� 1�a! ()&Jp+ N� O$c �� l�Bc"��F,�D�j$9 �,Bc� : " (���� #�! m0�

"Zs �,0 �� (V,�� � ��$!� TBc �+ U�c �#B�� F,�,Bc� ,Of?�c �f� hf! : " ���] (���� #B@ m0�,"Zfs �f,0 �f� (V,�f� � ��$!� TBc �+ U�c "�OF, |V,� Y�+g� �� ��Zs�(+.V,� Ni.�,� Í SZ,mBfe� �f)&� .[a+ Ë/,�� , Of;

<!�,()��Bc� m0 ��9A �|%7 ,�/%+Q7 �Q/,�� �J#�$%, 3 ��A� �� S?�� �p� S:�� 8%,� �D�[ �w0 O9.,� U�9A0, � Bf� ¢�%,� �a� N�[� ,m�f%J , Bf)�

u�M� 8!,()&,0 O9.e�� O9.,� 8! ,�J�C2�� �J�6B&�� �J�&�v (�� 3 u�M�7 .V� O9.,� SB!# >�&�: N� Ï.! �7� `.+ �a,, ()��D (kB�B+ (kE

� S#�$! m0 � Zs S#�$! ��,m�%J ,u�� �V, ,"2! , �f� U��/Db� �a� N� S#�f$! �f� U��/D� B� tD0 �+B!e�,m�f%J ,>]BCf² Ç�fµ� ABf] Í ,

��Zs� N�@�E�� T�2]E�[,] Í �J#�$! m0 `.f�� Ç�µ� AB, fFe� Í �� T�%,�,�J�w ¢�%,�� #B;B,� B� �DB[ �&: �� ,ABC,� X&' Í �� 3

Ï.! �7� U�c: " � m0 SB!,� ,m�%J ,B!e�7 .V� , >f+�$,� �� T! �� �DE � � �>+��,� m0 4!&�� � K �3 " � m0 �B!#� K � �".Ve� 8! �a)� 3 " SZCf7 ! " N� �f$2�

.�E���[ �, ,.V� "B7�;p� =� (��!# t[ "��F3 �&�! �:° Í Î����,� U�c: "�&,0 �2� SB!# � m0 SB!,� N� "�2%� , � NE

n� o]�� d3�� , $�l��E

n� om�K d3�� , $�l�P�E

n  o����4� d3�� , $�l��OE

n� o"9M&� W�^0 :W��−� E

Page 207: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

Ë!�,�� B!e� 8!,>+��,�� >+�$,�� , �� O[ 8! �DBV, "��F3 f&!B,�� f!B,� N<fL7 ��afe� �af� f! Th�+ t[,1�f�%,�� 1�Bf|,�� ,

�+#p/,� N<L7�, �f?�A� �f� Sf?�� b �¬ �a� OV�,f!B/e�� f!�B,� NE Ð, �c�%e�� �&|e��K,1#*e�� Ð,#B!Be� 8! B� ,!B/e�� ± � K,1�|e�� � K,�c�%e�� � � K,

1#*e��3 f! Sf:�B,� 8f%,� ��G/J Np7 N��wE�� UB�%,� Í �a� O|� rC+ �&[�

AB�E� l�/7 �­�w,���)2+� ��.�p&� ,�%+� K � ���f!B/+� �K ±,�f)$c�%+� �f)$&|+� , d&7BJ �H#*+�=�.+h%J� =�3

1�#g� "af� f! UfJ �f+#�:�� Y�f+i �� >2G,�� Ni.�,� Í ��; �� OV��)?�A� �� 4;.+ S?�� b >�R�7 X?�Q,��3

�+# O[ >&�: #B;B,� S:� ��a� ! Th�+ t[,S#�f$! O[� , f$! tf)� �� �/!�� Y�#B$%� �� N�GD��uf: !� �&C� B)� ?��!, OfV,� NE

"#B;�� u�� Y�w,�DB��� �J�2&%J� �&,�µ� ,A�f&s�� `Bf9 (@ t� ± �, P&f,� A�+# "Zs A�,� ͱ �3

�G527 �G52, 7�! B)�,u?�f��� N�&!� Í S.���,� ,�f)&�! "#Bf;� >f6��x7 3 Sf:� ��af7 Th�/Gf+ #Bf;B,� S:� ��a7 (&�G/,� N� �a� ¦&d�J�

+#E�N�,>�&��� Í S:�� N�+#E�� ,ABC,�� .���e� Í �!B2J N0� 3 ¯5+ Ï.! �7� FD �a," Èc "�,Bc Í ,m�%J : " ��f$%J b� lf7A Èc�

"�+0 b0"� F(Vj7 ,��� Ac� 3UBf�&� : " Afc .+f�,� (&f�%,� N�j$f9

n� o"9M&� W�^0 G#� }�f�N&� ]�f :W�� ,�Z��) :9M&� W�^0 G#� /.�X&� ]�f" :W�O� ,�m�b /&�? ]�f) : W�uE

n� o����z� d3�� , $�l� OE

Page 208: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوج

− �{�{ −

È��� (V:� Èc�,#B$%� O[ Í "�+0 b0 ��$%J b N� l7A Èc� ,� �+�Y�#Bf$%e� ABf] Í �f,B� �� 87�, NBf�%+ b }�f2,� .f|[� �fV,� "��F3 UB9.,� O�� ! Ï.! �7� �&%+�– >%+Qf,� �tf�! (fH Ë2%+� – (kBf[

��¯�" Èc " 42%7 " .�� "� F3 1�$,� �a� Í ".%� ���:

8��1) q��� = k�Ug� 81)�� n�812)� �� ��t 48(� �#�� U�c (@:�� �H F/+ SAB] O[ Í ��.%+ O��V,� -A�%,, Uh2+ SAB] O[ Í� �)&�,"f�/%� SAB] Í b0 ��.%+ b -A�%,� "Zs� , Í �f, fv �w0 ".fV2+� ��Zs�OF3

��<[ ���: "��.,� P5D B� �a,� �t%,� Í u�� OV,� K � � � � K, O[ ABC, O7��,� � `B9 ��,�G5D u�� u�� Í l,w #A� c� � � � �,�f)�[ UB�%,� �J#.� , Tf%,

l,w �� �))�, �G5D Í ABC/+ �D� � Í >,��� �:�] O[ Np7 Y.%� ��� .��=�"$%&� � B� �&� UB�+ �� ,"Zs b � B�� , b0 Oje� l,w Í ���� ��� �,333333 , �, N� bB,�– � �� –);� =� f! �G5D �]� �� �/%� O[ Í

,�7 ��9A >2G,� Y�#��/!b� AB] Í UBj/"��F3 N�A�f� �f&�� f! 49B� �D&9 �/! N� Ï.! �7� .[w �a� O;E, t)&f�!

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW P�u ,�Z��) :$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W O�u ,W��P ,�

W �u ,W��PW) PQ� ,W��� ,�OW �u ,��W �� ,W��� ,W�Q� , �� ,"9M&� W�^0 :W� ,�&4� t�VU ,$��24� t�VU �K) ,/?�� R?� a`��3 RD�:W OE

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W O�uE

n  o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :�OW �O E

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :��W �� – � E

Page 209: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

T<G,� ,OF%,� S#�$! ��Bc ! "A�VD0 �$G7 N�[, ()!+ N� �7 m�E� N�V� �D�$%+, � >+#B$! u�j/J 4/: ,m�%J ,SAB] O[ Í , `.+ �� -A�%,� NE �

�� O[ Í u��, "�.+ O7 �� O[ 8!��F3 ¥BD �D&9 TBc Í ".[w �a� O|��,T<Gf,� �f&�! ,#� (­#�f$! Í =�!�Bf9� =�

�¯D� �B%+� ¾B�+�, uf�� �f� �Bf�)� (­#�$! �B[.J B, (k0 U�c �&: �b*� �� �B[.J �� Ac !;f);� #Bf$%� Of[ Í ufj�, Nx� =�, �f� �f�.%+

��.%+,��)§ �� ��)§� � F3 &&J �7� O�D c�2I� m0 1��a,� +.+ N�[ �D� 8%$9 �7� �! >,U�fc �fD�� :

�%GfJ b T<9�� �A� N0;�� Of[ N�f$%+ NB[Qf� f2I� NE , 4f/: N�B&��� Y�$2,��OF3

��ae� �a� N� `.D �jD�– N�+#E� S:� Ë2!� – .��B�, ~c�2�� #��� .)Le� �Q,�,>2G,�� 1�/V,� Ybb, OL$�� ,�&� l� b t7 ,�]� �� , m�%J� �D�j$9,T�2]E� #�$! ± K,NB[Q� (kp7 ,NBe��� ,N�.��f[� , (fk�� A�2,� Í N��²3P;A �kp7 T�2]E� �]� t[ 3_ �D&9 N�� t[ =�, ] (�9� �&�! �,��&$DE� �� ��$c ��� � � �,��ZGVJ� T�2]E� (&Lj/, �B|%7 tD0 ,

>&2C,� >&2@B,� ! ����,��3 S#�f$!� >f&2@B,� �f+# uf�y ��ae� �a� t2&7 � `B9 ��� T�2]E�,m�%J 3

m�%J U�c: " N�@�E� �� P;.,� �B$2/;��� � �� � � � K �� � � �Ð �"��F3m�%J U�c� : " �+af,� �fq� �+� �� ± � × �

n� o�Z�� :"9M&� W�^0 :W�Q E

n� o�Z�� :"9M&� W�^0 :W� E

n  o�Z�� :$�D�: R?� e)�V0 {�DX. :� W ��uE

n� o�M&� d3�� , $�l�O�E

Page 210: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

f! �f� Pf;A TbªE�� 1�CfDE�� ¯f&e�� .fM� tD0 �BK2�i� Ð K K � � �� �� � � � K � � � � �� � � � K � �� � ± � � N�L&�f,� O� � � ± �NBj�5J (V�%, "B$2/;��� � �K � K K �� K �� K ± � � "��F3U�c� ,�D�j$9 : " �f7 �Q+ N� .5�+ b �Ø � N0� �� � � � K �� K � � ± �

t&�! t@0 ` �z�� �� �Ø �7 �Q+ ��� ���+ �e l,w N�# �� .5�+�= = � � � K� � � � �� �� � � � � �� � �� K � � K � �� � � � "� F3 _ �D&9�,��<9� � Y�B�] �&�! ,��� >V� O�# �e =� T�2f]E� (fL:

�&� �)2� u$+ ¢� ��¯[�=�,�­#�$! �! 4k� , \[E� �Q,� �� l,w O%;� O%�, �$je�,A�2,� Í �$:�] �de�� 3 �f�� T<f9�� �f+# (&�/G+ �&V�

_ �D&9 �7 ��;,(�9� �&�! � ] ,"#��f+� ��fc�2+ �f+# Xf� , �f+# � S#�$! ¥+ ��a��T�2f]E�� SA�F�,Y�fD�B&��� ,#�f$%,� ��f&,�E�� ,

l,w Zs�,�)2Gj/G+� , � m0 >7.c� S#�$! l,w %+� O7× K �,m�%J , ���.+ O7 "#B;�� � Y�w3

#B%G� �7 �$! `�A,U�c �D� �2! � ÑA :Ëf$2,� O�# , �f&�! � f] (�9�,>V� ,$CD NB/9� >?t@<@ >$%V,� UB:� =�Í� >+��A "t2] = ", O%F�

UB�+� "&7 N�[ #B%7 �)2%L+: " N�f[ OfR�$,� N0 OfR�$,� uf�ª� uf�� ��; cB�ª=� " ,UB�+�: " &%+ ��� OR�$,� ¡$+ ��� u�� ��; "�OF3

#Bf;B,� S:� ��a� N<L7 `.+ .)Le� �Q,�� �a,, Of|� m0 Öf5+ �fDE S9�5,� Tª�B�,� l�J,,� U�L70 Ë2%+ �7 UB�,�� f9�A >&I�� >%+Q=�, af�E��

9�A �,�L70� ��ae� �a� ~�A SA�À,�7 Ë2%+ >&I�� >%+Q,�7=�3

n� od�`�D&� d3�� , $�l�Q�E

n� o���%�&� d3� , $�l��uE

n  oHM�Mp ~ "#%. Hn�kA ,��%&�) m�LX&� t�VU ,$�-9&� '�2 R. 1��p4� $&�b� t�? :W�QP , ]�u� – ��u�EF

Page 211: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�  −

����� ���2� ����� ���2� ����� ���2� ����� ���2� :::: !/!� �8� ���4� �� #��� 67!� !/!� �8� ���4� �� #��� 67!� !/!� �8� ���4� �� #��� 67!� !/!� �8� ���4� �� #��� 67!� ::::−−−− >f&I�� X?�Q,� �cB� �! �BG,� (&�/Ge� r+�,� O�%,� �cB� ��/� b

�,�L70� ��ae� �a� ~�A Í >+�tG,�,Q,� N� l,w� tf7 ÔpfJ b >&I�� X?��j$�/GJ� UB�%,� ��&�,>j&jf] (&,�f%J �� �)&� �� OV� PV%,� ! O7 ,

>y�,� UB�%,� Ybb# u��BJ,N�f�5/+ UBf�%e� r+¤� UB�2e� r&jC� , N�6A�%/+ b�,N�5�/� �� , �/�L7�� ��ae� �a� >&I�� >%+Q,� Y#A �&j�

>+BG,� UB�%,� "#.J N� 7<�,,�� >&�G,� ��$L3 ��afe� �af� N<fL7 �� SZ|[ �;�� �+%G,� ·BCD Ä��D Í T�J c�

<�!=,��.[af7 T<V,� O+BLJ S#�!0 m0 >;�: <� , O&$f9 f! ��.[afD Of7 U�'��3

U1) c'"�� �"' �UOG qQ�� Pp�Ëf%&$L,� ÅfV,� TBf)5� uf�� `Bf!# , #B;B,�[ ,�A�M�� N�&!E� Í3%&' �<�%,�� =� ÅfV,� TB)5� N� ! NB�5/�

�A�ffM� Í� N�ff&!E� Í �ff, #Bff;� b Ëff%&$L,�,#�ff%� �ffDBV, =� Î�Bff@ Í YbB�%e�,�D�&7 T�J t[ ,�fJ�&?h;� "#�.�� �A�M� Í #B;Be� N� NB�5/��,

N�.7�V+ #B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� �b*� FD t2&7,f&?h; "! ! N��+� = �� �&�&�:3

qQ�� ��U_1) c'"�� �"' �UOG � >f+#B;B,� N�f&!E� S.f|[ ��f5/D� T�hf, S���e�,U�&�� 1�¿ #.µ �k�� , #f%/7 )�fJ �<f�%,� X&' UB�! t2&7

>+#B;B,� u?����,9�2;� =�,!�BD�� =�,f]�d��� =�, N� >,�j/f9� f! Xfv� f:�� S.f|V,� "a� #B;� NBV+=�,f=2&! NBfVJ N� >,�j/f9� f!� �Sf:�� ,

�B�de� Y�w 8! u,�M� Y�w �)&� NBV+�, Y�w 8f! �#�C,� Ë$2,� Y�w� 1w�V,� º$2/e�,P&f�7� Y�w 8! ,�f&$M� Y�w �f2&%7 Bf� �f&L,� Y�w� ,

Page 212: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

9�5,� Y�w �G5D B� r,�C,� Y�w� 333»,�3Oc�! ���%+ b �¬ �a)� ,<�f� = �7 "B5/+ N� �!3

U1) :8�E�� sD���� ��� ��ae� �a� ! �Bf�de�� u,�M� ��B/9�, >f�%,� UBff�%e��,�$Gffe�� �$Gff,� ,>ff,h2e�� >ff$J.,� Í ,Tff�,�� ,N�ffV���� , ¾����,l,w Zs� 3 (f9� OfV7 #Bf;B,� �f;�� �C/+ N� �2� Th�+ t[

�A�M� #B;B,� Í u�_ B� �¬ �5]�,Y�#B;Be� 8! B� w0 , N� �f2� Th�&� Y�5C,� �� r$�/G� B� t7 �C/+,2,�f[ TB,>f�5�,�� ,Of)��� ,(f��,�� ,

1aV,��3 333Oc�! �7 "B5/+ b �¬ �a�� »,�3 � >L,�² ��ae� �a� ! Th�+ t[,m�f%J ,#Bf;B,� �f;�� , Y�A�w�f��,

Y�9�F2,��,#B;B� O[ 8! �DE ,B�! NBe��,� UB�+ t! � m�%J =�Z$[ =�3 � O7,m�%J ,u�Le� UtV,� �, ,� Ut��� T�/,,��fH �cB� P&, �a,� ��)$,�� ,

>�i� ¦�D O[ �! "h2�,`BG,�� A�&sE� >|+�_ �! }�� , >L,�² �! �\� ¾#�B��,ZC$,� X&G,� B�� �� ��|[ P&, 3

= <�! #B_ B� �� N<L7 ��ae� �a� �� Th�+ t[�, ¥fe�� �+#p/,� N<L$[ Ta,�� ,1��%,�� 1�B|,��,&!B,�� !B,�� ,[ �af� N<fL7 Í �f�|� T�J t

!° ��ae�=�3Taf,�� ¥fe�7 �f2� #�.fe� N� t)2f&7 �A�f5,� �V, , 1�Bf|,�� 1��%,��,&!B,�� !B,�� ,Å�%,� ,Ë!Q,� ��2� �)2� #�.e� t2&7 3 �a� %�

<�! rC+ b ��ae�=ZC�J� O�� �� �2� Xc� �� ! ",B, ,�B,� �+#pJ , �/$c�%� b�,4/: b� AB�E� �� .�� �p7 �5&�VJ , �af,� �f�Ve� 8f! �DE

�5�[,u�� 8! B� O7 ,B�! NBe��,� UB�+ t! m�%J� �D�j$9 =�Z$[ =�3 �!�$J� S#�)�7 O�%,� ABR �B� ��ae� �a� N� u���, lf,w f! ¦fD tf[

�+Q,� &G,�,�G5D ,#Bf;B,� Sf:B7 8�?�f�,� T�f�0 �&�! ¦D t[� , �f7�

Page 213: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

ÍBC,� Ï.!��F3<�! �D<L7 ! �!�$J� )�+ ��a� �� l$G:� 3 #Bf;B,� ��af7 UBf�,� f! Thf�J Ë/,� S9�5,� >&��%,� Tª�B�,� (�� "a�3 �/5,�² u$9 t&� N�7 c t[ UB�%e� r+¤ �,�� ��ae� �a� N� �)2� .)�+�

UB�2e� r&jC,,�, >&c b� ��ae� �a� O|e A�$/!� <� a�2&j� Ò, b� &]AUB$�,� �� �,,Xc�B,� >�7�L�� u�� �� �, &]A b w0 , (?�fc ��af� B� O7

U�&M�� (�B,� !3

n� o$�9D&� C�2�V5&� :� W P OE

Page 214: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�c�d >&,�/,� �?�/2,� �<F/9� �V+ m�%J � j7 �j$,� �a� �� ´�.5,� %7�:

�−�AE� �� :�� X�] Í Ä�! c �+%G,� <[ N� ; N�f9�.� #<7 Í .)2,� ��A� ���, �f�A��; �f��,>&cQf,� >&�<f9�� N�f�$,� Ëf�� , �f&:

>&F%,� >&�<9�� l,te�,N�f�h,� P5D Í �+¤�%/� �D�[ tk�� t[ , �fD�� Y����, t)2&7 N�[,Y��c�2�� Y�A��_� ,t)%v >&�! O��_� 3tfk� t[ , �t�%,� ��5J�7�,�t�%,� ª.7� �� �D�[ ,��w0 ,>f&��%,� TBf�%,� Í ,� m0 >��f60

>&!Q,� TB�%,� Í t)/���0� t)��J3 �f� .f|[ Y�5,*�� Sa�<J �[.J tk�� ��%73

�−(+c ��a� #B;B,� S:� ��a� N� ,N�fDB&,� >5f9<� ~%7 �7 U�c , 1B%�,� ~%7 �7 �D�#�,#B2I�f[ ,>&�<f9�� N�f�$,� ~f%7 Í Qf/D�� ,

Ï.%,� 1.�e� #<$[,P,fDE�� ,(fF%,� #<f7� , ��A� �f�� }A�f� #<$f[ .)2,�,��A��; ��� 3��f$J�� #��A �f&� Qf/D� f�7 O[ Í �, N�[� , N�f[ N0�

A�z9b�� (/V/,� X7�R ()&�! ���+, >f+h�.,�� >f+B5%,� X7�R �&�! ���+� Y�A�����,ÍBCf,� Ï.! �7� ��; N� m0 � ABfR �f! �f;.�p� Óf,DE�

>+.)�� m0 Nt/V,�,� >+B5%,� X7�R� f&%�/,�� r+�/,� 1B�9� m0 >+h�.,�O&]p/,��,#Bf;B,� Sf:B7 8�?��,� T��0 B� uj7 N�V� , >f,�! "f%7 �f�� � � � � �

�&�!3 >f&�&�: Sf:� :�� #B;B,� N� A�$/!� ! TB�J ��ae� �a� S.V� N��, b

�)&� .|VJ,>/$,� , � #B;� B�� ,m�%J ,82�*e� ��A ! ,¢�%,� #B;� B�� , J�w�,�+j�e� ��A ! 3

Page 215: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحد

− �{�� −

8$�ae� <[ ! S.|V,� "a� N��;�+j�e� ��a�� 82�*e� ��a� , S.f|[ >�B/�,>�&d/� ,�I >�&�:b 3S:�� 8%,�� ,A�$/!b�7 .|V/,�� 3

 −1�$f9� Sf! m0 Xf;.+ #B;B,� S:B7 UB�,� p�2� N� , �$f9 N� �f)2� ��f25,� T��� u&�� m0 t7A X;.+ �7 UB�,�ÍBCf,�, #Bf;� Ëf5D m0 Öf5e�

`BG,�� A�&sE�,#��b�� UB��� >+.�27 (&�G/,� m0 X;.+ �� , S.fV� m0 �� �je� AB2,�, � N� Í 8&�<9�� >59<5,� ��.7 .@p/,� m0 �� ,m�%J , B� ·�M� #B;B,�, � NB[ `B!# m0 T<9�� Í �� ,m�%J ,N�fV� O[ Í , ��

#B;B�=� b >); Í,>2G,�� 1�/V,� .��B� Ybb# m0 �� , ~f%7 ��A f! >&�BC,�,��ae� �aH 8�?��,� 3

�−#Bf;B,� �;�� >2+�$� m0 Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� ��a+ ,m�f%J� �D�j$f9 , Í "#B;�� �/&���,Y�2Ve� Y�#B;�� Y�&���� Y��a, , #B;B7 h&/� B)�

Y�f2Ve� #B;B, .+��� O�/G�,B,� N�f[ N0� [z�f� uf�Le� T�f%,� #Bf;=� +B2%�=�Y�2Ve� #B;�� �;�B,� #B;� 87 , >&]BCf� Í ¥#�fc Zs B)�

#B;B� O[ #B;�,�;�B,� #B;� ��B9 ,m�%J ,Y�2Ve� #B;� �� 3 �−Y�#Bf;Be� .|V/7 Y�#B;B,� .|VJ `.+ Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� Nx� �a� !� ,

#B;B� OV�–� #B;B,� Í "Zs X� �z�� N0� �z�e� T�%,– �f! O�/G� "Zs #B;�,S.f|V/� >f]�M� Y�#B;B,�f� �a, ,�­�f6�.%� .f|V/, , Ëf��

>&;A�M� N�&!E�� Y�#B;Be�3 �−%G,� #A�� ,m�%J � ��A ,#Bf;B,� Sf:B7 8�?��,� �F: ,b�� =, (f@

&D�@ �)5+ª= ±�,��ae� �a� N<L7 ! �/,#� .[w (@ , Y�#B;Be� #%J 1B;�� Y�#B;B,��3

Page 216: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

�−:�� #B;B,� N� �$/[ ~%7 Í �+Q,� &G,� `.+ , �;�� #B;� B�� #B;B,�,u�Le� #B;B,� B� �D�� ,Y�#Bf;Be� Xf&' Í �A�Gf,� , �af� N��

u�Le� #B;B,�,Úd� :�� , �f;�� #Bf;� Bf� ·�f� #Bf;B7 h&/� �J�w #B;B,�3�� #Bf;B,� #f%J m0 �)&� Z�+ �, `.�� �/[ Í t2&7 >,�j/f9

�J:�3 �−�+Qf,� &G,� `.+ , Sf:� m0 �f&� ��af+ �af,� U�E� ��.f,� f!

#B;B,�,~f_ �A�f$/!� .f|VJ NBfV,� �af� Í Y�#B;Be� .|VJ N� , P&f, Ë�&�j7, m0 uf�Le� f:�B,� #Bf;B,� �af� >$GD� >��60 >F&/D O]�: B)�

Y�#B;Be� N�&!�,Y�f2V¬ 4GJ Ë/,�� ,Zfs Y�#Bf;B� �f)2� OCfj&� #B;B,� >5C7 >5C/�3

�−�aff� �ff$�a� ff! O?bff,� ~ff%7 �+Qff,� &Gff,� #A�� , �&�GffJ Xff� O�%,� ABR �B� ��ae� �a� Np7 �y�J�3 �/,�f9A U<� �� ".@pJ �7 c�

Y�#B;Be� �J�.e ".[w Í >&�BC,� ��A¹7 #B;B,� S:� Í 3 �{−�J�w #B;� S#�+ª >,pG� Ä��D U<� �� .)� ,m�%J , ! `f� �/&���

�)/7B%]� >,pGe� "a� �Bs,�f&s �! �)&� T<V,� NE , �f� N�f7 fc� #Bf;B,� �f;�� N0 (IBfc Í 8&�<f9�� >59<5,� ��a� �.! U<�,

m�%J,·�M� #B;B,� B� ,�j$,� ,#.µ =�>f&��e� �f! 4/: , m0 Öf5+ �fD� #B;B,� S:� ��a7 UB�,�, Ëf/,� m�E� S#�fe� Bf� t7A O7 �f)2� 4�/f9���ae� �a� S:B,�7 NB�?��,�,Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� l,w .[w t[ 3

��− "af� Í uf�� N� �+%Gf,� ��A >�fc�2�� �.f! U<f� �� N�7 �, Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� X� >,pGe�,m�%J � ��A ,"#B;� N� Í ,m�f%J , �f! �?�f7

Page 217: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �{�� −

Y�2Ve� #B;�,�D�� ,m�%J ,#B;B,� �;�� ,#B;B7 h&/� �f7 ·�� , tf[ �7 ·�� #B;B7 h&/� �)2� O[ Y�2Ve� N�,:�B7 P&,� .|V/� #B;B,�� ,

�<�=��+Q,� &G,� �&,0 ��w �e ,m�%J � ��A 3 ��−#Bf;B,� �f;�� #Bf;� 87 ��h+��� #B;B,� >&2&2@� ! U+ �a,�� , m�%J ,#B;B,� �V¬�, � `B9 �� B�� , N� �f� %Gf,� ".f[w �f� ± #Bf;B,�

�B2%e� ��z�b� u+.L7 "#�.�� ! UB��,>f&D�|,� YbB�%e� �� B)� , Ëf/,� �A�M� Í �I #B;� b,Ë� �&: �� ,"#�.f�� Í "#Bf;� O7 , �.f%+ Bf)� S.|V/e� �J�!B6Be,Y��a,�� N�&!E� Ë�� ,>f&�&�: S.|[ �)2� OCj&� , b

>+A�$/!�3.|V/7 SA�À,� (Vj7 XL�J UB�%,� N� ��� %$J Y�#B;B,� =� .|V/, Y�#B;Be�,S���e� S.|V,� "a� NBVJ N� O�%+ �&V� ,>9BGfje�� ,fJ�w =�

S:��,#B;�� =�:�� =�3".[w ��� ,��+� ,#B;B,� �;�� >G7<� T�h, �� , m�%J� �D�j$9,Y�9�F2,�� Y�A�w��,� ,:�� #B;B,� N�[ B, t&� =�, N�f[�

u�Le� #B;B,� B� #B;B,� �;�� ,,�N�&!E� X&' Í �A�G, f! �G$2e�� Y�#B;Be� O[�&�3%G,� ".[w ��� ,��+� , #B;B,� S:� ��a� >5,�² �� �Q,� Ybb,,>2G,�� 1�/V,� �� , U�fL70 m0 Öf5+ ��afe� �a� NBV, 9�A >%+Q,�=;�O9.,� U�9A0 �� S?�� b w0 ,�/V,� U�hD0� , �f� Sf?�� b� �&,�V/,�,B,�� !B,�� &!,�+#p/,�� ,1��%,�� 1�B|,�� ,Taf,�� ¥fe�� ,

S:�� 8%,� �D�[ �w0 l,w O[ �� S?�5,� �� w03 � −�+Q,� &G,� NBV+ N� r;.e� �� ,m�f%J � �f�A , �f! Xf;A fc

#B;B,� S:B7 UB�,�, Í �fc�Be� ¥° �f7�/[ .�pfJ f! >f,�,� �?�.f��, �&,p/,�,>&2&2@� m0 �&� Z�+ �a,�� #B;B,� , m�f%J � NBfV+ N� >,�j/f9b

Page 218: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{{ −

�/L,�² ���h�/9b Y�#B;Be� 8!,m�%J ,Y�f9�F2,�� Y�A�w���, , Ëf/,�� Oc�! �H UB�,� ! �z§ b3

��−<�! #B;B,� S:� ��a� N<L7 �$@ c =f!°� =�, �fF� UBf�%,� w0 ���.J� ,9�A ��L$J� ���2J >%+Q,� N� t[=�3

* * *

Page 219: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{� −

� ./ ��KLA (+.V,� Ni.�,�

\�(:��?!A$� :− e(f

�− �+ff+.e� 1�#i– �#A�.)Gff,� �+ff,� ��&ff6 �&,pffJ – �ffR uff&�� %ff9 -�W.,�ff$!– ¾�zff�, >ff+.�ªE� >ff$/Ve� °�ff2,� – Qff2�, S.ff+h��

X+ªB/,��– �� –>!�$L,� »+A�J .[w Zs �� 3 �− >�6�5,� >2+e� O�� ��Ai– Ï�A�5,� �D Ï� �&,pJ – Z$,� �&�! u�!

A#�D ��D– �Qe� A�# – >%7�.,� >%$L,� –Y�Z7 3  − Z���e�� ¥�jC,�� Z[�2e�� O&R�7E�– 8Gf�� �f$! ¸��fj�,

� Î�cAB�� (&��.70 �7– Ë?�B+.5,� ��.,�$! u&�%J� u&�� – SA�#0 °�f2,� >&5�G,� >%����7 ��/���� SB!,�� >&�<9�� ¾Bj$,�–}A�f27 – >f%$Le�

>&5�G,�– m�E� >%$L,� – >29 ��{  f�− ��� T 3 �− >R�D.s A�$�� Í >R�:��– �&LM� �7 �+,� N�G�, – _ u&��

N�2! �$!– ËFD�fM� >$/V� – S.��f�,� – >f&D�|,� >f%$L,� – � �  ff�− ��� T3 �−>+:E�, ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� O?�9A �6 – Ï.! �7 �+,� Ë&je –

�# >&Dt|%,� -A�%e� S.?– �[.f,� #�7� A&: – m�E� >f%$L,� – � �� ff�− Ï.%,� ¾�z,� ��&:0 A�# .+BCJ–Y�Z7 3

�− ËV,�fe� Ï.f%,� �f7� .fV7 ÏE Ni.�,� T�V:�– f_ Åf! uf&�� ���F$,�– .V5,� A�# – � �� f� − ����T3

Page 220: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{� −

�− �+,� TB�! ��&:0– Ç�h�,� T<9�� >F� – A�# .+BCfJ >f�.%e�– Y�Z7– ��{� f�− ����T 3

�− �<�� A�$��–U �j&jCJ� "Q27 Ë2! 3NB&29�� ,�13 }��.f[– (��,� >%$L� – P+A�7 – ª�Ab >$/V� – P+A�7 – >29 �� �T 3

�− ¢�%,� N�+#�– �&9 �/9 B� AB/[,� ABG��\,� �&,pJ – �f+.%J (/f9A %9 ��B:�– >f&���|,� ABGf�� A�# – �f�: –L,� m�E� >f%$–

���� f� − �{{�T 3 �{− `\V,� 2I� N�+#�– Ë$�f� f�� AB/[f,� �&,pfJ – >f$/V�

>+�e� >�)2,�– S.���,� – >G��M� >%$L,� – ����T 3 ��− S¤�ff%e� ���affe�� �.ff5,�� N�ff+#E� – AB/[ff,� �&,pffJ

�� >$&� A#��,�$!– SABf2e� >f2+e�7 >&�<f9�� >f%���� >f%$R –>2f9 � ��f� 3

��− �+f,� UBf]� Í 8f%7AE�– �ª�.f,� �+f,� .fd5, – Xf$R >&Dt|%,� -A�%e� SA�#0 P�µ >%$L7– �[,� #�7� A&: – m�E� >f%$L,� –

>29� � f� 3 � − 1.%,� 2! BL9A�– SAB�2� Zs ·BCD >9�A# – AB/[,�

��7 ��.,�$!– Y�!B$Le� >,�[� °�2,� – �+BV,� –|,� >f%$L,� >f&D�– >29����T 3

��− P+�/,� }�9� – �ª�.f,� .f! �f7 f_ �+f,� .fd5, – Ë$��� Ï�$,� 45LC� >%�$L�– S.���,� – � �� f�− �� �T3

��− Y�5C,�� �t9E�– Ë�)&$,� 8G�� �7 �� T��Â, – >%$L�

Page 221: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{  −

S#�%G,�– � �� f� −>&�%,� �/V,� A�# .+BCJ – Y�Zf7 – ��{�ff�−����T3 ��− Y�A���� Y�)&$2/,�� – �2&f9 �f7 Åf! Ï� P&?.�, – uf&��

�&D# Nt&�9 AB/[,�– -A�%e� A�# – �� – ����T3 ��− ff]��e� ¥° Í ff]��e� -°�– ff_ �ff7 ff�� T�ff�Â, Õ�2Ve�– >+ZM� >%$Le� – S.���,� – m�E� >%$L,� –»+A�J <7 3 ��− -BC/,� ! ��B6�– T�2s �%�R AB/[,� �&,pJ – °�f2,�

�/V,� ¢�!– S.���,� –»+A�J <7 3 ��− #��.,� O&$9 m0 >+�I�� #��/!b�– 8Gf�� �f7 �� T��Â, Ë�)&$,�– �J�V,� T�C! �� u&�� – S+�� ���g� A�# – m�E� >f%$L,�

– ��{� f� − ����T 3 �{− T<!E�– Å[Ah,� �+,� ZM – 8+<�, (�%,� A�# – Y�Z7

–$L,� >G��M� >%– ���{T 3 ��− �A�d$,� r&j] ¥° Í �+�� T<!� – Nt&�9 Ï� T��Â, Ï�LM�− #B%f9 Ui ��.,�f$! �7 %9 �7 _ AB/[,� >9�A#� u&�� –

T� >f%��F7 Ë�<f9�� ¾�z,� ��&:0� >&�%,� ¾Bj$,� )%� Y�AB�2� ��`.�,�− >�.Ve� >V� – m�E� >%$L,� ��{� f�− ���{T 3

��− 1.%,� 2! 8RB���– ��.,�f$! AB/[f,� �f, Tfc� ���: ��7– Y�!B$Le� >,�[� °�2,� – �+BV,� – >|,�|,� >%$L,� – ����T3 � − ��&:�� Yb�V�0 Í �<���– TBf�! ��f&:0 1�f/V7 uj�� �+,�– Ç�hf�,� T<f9�� >fF: T��Â, – >f�.%e� A�# .+BCfJ – Y�Zf7 –

Page 222: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{� −

��{� f� − ����T3

��− D0 .%,� ��27p7 .�,� ��$– Î<�Gf%,� .fF: �f7� ¸��fj�, – >&Dt|%,� -A�%e� S.?�# >%$R– �[,� #�7� A&: – m�E� >%$L,� � �� f�−

����T3 ��− -</f�b� �$;�� Ë/,� 1�$9E� ! �&$2/,� Í -�CD�� –

ÕB&�L$,� &G,� �7� T��Â,– >f+�,� N�Bf6A f_ AB/[f,� u&�� – A�# 5,� .V– u��# – m�E� >%$L,� – � �� f�− ����T 3

��− (�Gff,� Î�ff%� �ff� ()$ffe� ¥��ff+0 – ff�� »&�ff,� �&,pffJ �AB)2�,�– >&�%,� �/V,� ��&:0 A�# >%$L� –»+A�J <7 3 ��− #B;B,� S:� 42%� �� #BC�e� ¥��+0 – Ë2�,�f$! T��Â, Ó�7�2,�– ¥�/5,�$! &%9 u&�� – >&7.%,� ��f�g� A�# – >f&D�|,� >f%$L,� –

>29���� f� − �{{�T 3 ��− (fV�� ¥° Í (I� Ê��+0 – �f7 f_ �f7 f�� »&�f�, >$&F!– >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

egf ��− �&ffje� .ffj$,� nËR�ffD.�,� N�ff&: Ï� ZGff5Jo – �ff7 ff_ T�ff�Â,

�ff9B+, ËR�ffD.�,� N�ff&: Ï� – .ffV5,� A�# – Y�Zff7 – ��{  fff�− ��� T 3

 {− >+�)2,�� >+�$,�– Ë��f�,� Zf|[ �7� ¸��j�, – -A�f%e� >f$/V� – Y�Z7– ����>&D�|,� >%$L,� T3

 �− X7�G,� N.�,� %7 �� �9�j7 X,�L,� A$,�– Åf! �7 _ >�<%�,

Page 223: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{� −

Î�[B�,�– >�.%e� A�# –Y�Z7 3  �− -A�%,� 7– 8%$9 �7 u�� $%, – "ABf/[ �AB; AB/[,� u&�� –

P,DE� A�#– Y�Z7 – �2V,� A�# – Y�Zf7 – >2f9 m�E� >f%$L,� ����T 3

  − �fJ�.e� Y�&�V7 ÅF/,� �&J.J ! �,�L,� >&�7– f��Fe� Zf�¼, �.?�h�� A#��,�$!– Ç�f&V,� (&��.f70 (f]�! AB/[f,� uf&�� – A�#

>&�%,� �/V,�– Y�Z7 – m�E� >%$L,� – ���� f�− �{{�T 3  �− � >&�7 P,DE� O�� U�;A »+A�J Í P/�e– Ëf&y �f7 �� T��Â,

Ë$�,�– Ï.%,� 1�/V,� A�# – S.���,� – ����T 3

 �− S�fj2,�� 8+Bf��,� Y�f�$R Í S�f!B,� >&�7– �+f,� U<f; T�f�Â, ËRB&G,�– >�.%e� A�# °�2,� –Y�Z7 3

 �− �+Qf,� �+f�� #�A� 1�$f9� Í �+.%/,�� N�&$,� – ¾fj�, G,� Ë2&G�� Sh� �7�7 Z)�,� _ �7 (&��.70 &– �+,� �&9 ��2/!�7

�J�[− Ï.%,� 1�/V,� A�# – Y�Z7 – ��{� f�− ����T 3

e�f  �− U�E�� .�g� ª�.L,� .@¹� .��B; �� O�Ve� ��/,�– u+f] �&,pJ

N�� �G:– �+f,� -° (&V��f$! r&jCfJ – �+f,� -° QfD Ë$/V,�– ��$7 – >%$Le� >&7.%,� >+2I�– � �  f�− ��� T 3

 �− �#AB,� �7� »+A�J– �#ABf,� �7�7 Z)�,� .5�� �7 .! �+,� +h, – >+A&�� >%$Le� Y�AB�2� – �F2,� – >&D�|,� >%$L,� – � �� ff� −

����T 3

Page 224: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{� −

 �− T<9�� »+A�J– >2f9 Y�f&�B7 ·�fM� �hf�� � � – ��{ ff� − Ë$�a,� �� �7 _ T��Â,–u&�� # 3 �?<�ª� -�.%� #�B! A��7–

>,�9.,� >G9*�– m�E� >%$L,� – ��{� f�− ����T 3

�{− #�f�7 »+A�J – �#�f�$,� �f&LM� Åf! �f7 f�� ¸��fj�, – A�# Ï.%,� 1�/V,�–Y�Z7 3

��− N�.ff+0 Í >ff&,B�e� >ff,�,� »+A�ffJ– T<Gff,�$! AB/[ff,� �&,pffJ Ë)� h+h%,�$!– -A�%e� A�# >!�$R –�� – ����T 3

��− �\L,� »+A�J– �\fL,� .f+.; �7 _ .5%; Ï� T��Â, – uf&�� (&��.70 O�5,� B7� _– N�+B9 A�# – Y�Z7 – ����T 3

� − Ó,DE� .V5,� »+A�J– �f&|2,�7 �f,�|2; OfdDi �&,pJ – �f! �f��D PD*f� 8G: AB/[,� >&D�$9��– >+�fe� >�f)2,� >f$/V� – >f%$L,�

m�E�– ����T 3

��− T<9�� Í Ë5G�5,� .V5,� »+A�J– Bf7� Åf! f_ AB/[f,� �&,pJ N�+A– >&7.%,� >�)2,� A�# – Y�Z7 – >&D�|,� >%$L,� – ��� T 3

��− Ë5G�5,� .V5,� »+A�JnS.�p/e� }A�e�� BL9A�o – AB/[,� �&,pJ N�+A B7� Å! _– >&%���� >�.%e� A�# – >+A2V9�� – ���{T 3

��− »+A�J >f&D�DB&,� >5G�5,� – �f9B+ AB/[f,� �&,pfJ – (f��,� A�# – Y�Z7–»+A�J <7 3

��− P,DE� S��c »+A�J– Ë�,�e� Ë��$2,� �$! �7 �G�� ÏE – A�# S+�� ���g�– Y�Z7 – ��{{ f� − ���{T 3

��− �+,� UB]� Í >,#E� S�$J – f_ �f7 NBf&� 8%e� Ï� T��Â,

Page 225: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوج

− ��{� −

Ë5G2,�–�� >�<9 #B�[ u&– Q2,�� >!�$L�, Ï���� N�5�� >%$L� – m�E� >%$L,�– ���{T 3

��− (�E� 1A�v– �+BVG7 -�.%e� _ �7 �� Å! ÏE – ��f2/!�7 ª�A�i - f� r&jCJ�– Ë�<f9�� 1�/V,� A�# °�2,� – S.��f�,� –

»+A�J <73 �{− >&G�,� >,�9.,� ¥° >&�L2e� !�B�,� .+.�– #B_ �+,� �L�,

�ª�.,� _ �7– Ë$��� Ï�$,� 4G&! >%$L� – S.���,� – >&D�|,� >%$L,� � �� f�− ����T 3

��− >,�w.� �� O�%,� Í >,B$�� >,B�� �� 2)�, �� u&��– N�fy.,� ÏE Î�Z$,� �� �7 _– >&Dt|%,� -A�%e� S.?�# – �[f,� #�f7i A&: –

� �� f�− ����T 3

��− aJ ��&,�E� S.[– �AB7�Gf&2,� A�L%,� �+,� +.5, – uf&�%J� >f'.J h+h%,�$! Ë2&,� U�2� SAB/[#– 1�/V�, >��%,� >+�e� >�&I� – S.���,�

– m�E� >%$L,� – �{{�T 3

� − Ê�5�� S.[aJ– Ë$�a,� �� �7 _ �+,� P� T��Â, – uf&�� Ë�%e� ��.,�$!–t|%,� -A�f%e� S.?�# >f&D– �[f,� #�f7i Af&: –

2I�− � �� f�− Ï.%,� ¾�z,� ��&:0 A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3 ��− -BCff/,� Off�� ��affe -.ff%/,�– ff_ .ffV7 Ï� T<ff9�� ��ff/,

�w�7<V,�– >&�%,� �/V,� A�# – Y�Z7 ��{{ f�− ���{T 3

��− Y�5+.%/,�– Î�;.�� �+Q,� &G�, – N�f2$, >f$/V� – Y�Zf7 – ����T 3

Page 226: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{� −

��− %J (fV�� ·BCf� f! Ëf5&5! <%,� Ï� Y��&�– 1�f/V7 ufj�� Ï.! �7� (V�� ·BC�– Ï.f%,� 1�f/V,� A�# – Y�Zf7 – >f%$L,�

>&D�|,�– ��{{ f�− ���{T 3

��− Y�&I�� �� �5cB�� Î�ª�/5/,�– �f$! #�f!0 �f� "�AB/[# >,�9A <e� Å!– `.�,� T� >%��; – >�.Ve� >V� –,�� S&�%,� (Gc SB!3

��− ËR�D.�,� N�&: Ï� ZG5J− .�D� =�&je� .j$,�3 ��− �\L,� ZG5JnNi.f�,� �i Of+�pJ �f! N�f&$,� X��;o – Ï� T�f�Â,

�\fL,� .+.; �7 _ .5%;– Ëf$��� Ï�f$,� 45LCf� – S.��f�,� – >|,�|,� >%$L,�� �� f�− ����T3

�{− (+.V,� Ni.�,� ZG5J – ÍBCf,� Ï.f! �f7� �+f,� Ë&je – uf&�� �,�s 45LC� AB/[,�– Qf2,�� >f!�$L�, P,DE� A�# – Y�Zf7 –

>|,�|,� >%$L,�– ��{� f�− ����T 3

��− Ë$R.�,� ZG5J nNi.�,� T�V:E X����o – f�� �f7 f_ T�f�Â, Ë$R.�,� �A�CDE�– Ï.f%,� ¾�z,� ��&:0 A�# �%$R #�!� – Y�Zf7 –

����T 3

��− Z$V,� ZG5/,�–_ T��Â, �ª�.f,� �+f,� .fd� .f! �f7 f– A�# .V5,�– Y�Z7 ��{  f�− ��� T 3

� − >�C,� 1�/V, >�V/,�– �7�f7 -�.f%e� �f$! �f7 f_ >�<%�, A�7E�– Ä�.fI� T<Gf,�$! AB/[f,� uf&�� – >f!�$L�, .fV5,� A�# – ����− ����T 3

��− >��2,� Y�&�B, >�V/,� –f2e� (&�%,�f$! �+,� Ë[ª T��Â, �Aa–

Page 227: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��{� −

-�.f%� #�Bf! A��f7 AB/[,� u&��– >,�f9.,� >Gf9*� – Y�Zf7 – >&D�|,� >%$L,���{� f�− ����T 3

��− P&�70 P&$�J– �ªBf�� �f7 �.5,� Ï� �+,� U�' T��Â, – �f&2! >+Z2e� >!�$L,� SA�#0 "Q27– >&D�|,� >%$L,� – � ��f�3

��− Ï.f! �7� Z5VJ m0 Ë$�,� �&$2J– �+f,� N�f�\, .f! �f7 (&��.f7�Ë!��$,�− O&[B,� ��.,�$! u&�� – >+je� >2G,� >%$L� – �f� –

ª�$,� �� }�$! >$/V� .+BCJ– >�.Ve� >V� – ��{{f�3 ��− -�°��� �&$2/,�– �#B%Gfe� 8Gf�� �f7 Åf! �G�� ÏE – A�#

�%]– Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3 ��− 1.,� Y�5] Y�$@0� &:B/,�–¸���� T��Â, �f7 ��j9� �7 _

>+h�– }�.� O&�� _ �&�! u�!� �%;�A – ª�$,� A�# X+ªBJ – >V� >�.Ve�– � �� f�− ����T3

��− &:B/,�– "2� �7 ��j90 �7 _ ¸���� T��Â, – AB/[,� u&�� Ë$&�B,� �$! _, �Cf�,� h+h%,�f$! �f7 4f9B� AB/[,�� – A�#

�B$2,� `I�– �� –� A�# >�&�f5,– >+#B%Gf,� – >f&D�|,� >f%$L,� – �� �f�− �{�{T 3

�{− �+A�%/,� Yt)� ! �&cB/,�– -�W.,�f$! f_ >�<%,� �&,pJ ���2e�– >+�,� N�B6A _ u&�� – ¤�f%e� .V5,� A�# – Y�Zf7 –

.V5,� A�#– u��# – m�E� >%$L,� – ���{ f�− ���{T 3

��− O?�9.,� X��; – T<f9�� »&�, >f&&J �f7� �+f,� Ëf�J– uf&�� ¢�9 #��A _ AB/[,�– Îfe� >%$L� – S.��f�,� – m�E� >f%$L,� –

Page 228: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���{ −

��{� f�− ����T 3

��− ��f&,�E� Y���.[ X��;– Î�f)$2,� O&!tf9� �f7 �f9B+ �&,pfJ – �B! SBL! (&��.7� u&��– Ë$��� Ï�$,� 45LC� >%$L� – S.���,� –

>|,�|,� >%$L,�– ��{� f�− ����T 3

� − Ë�<9�� ZV5/,� �� ËI�� �D���– Ë)$,� _ AB/[,� �&,pJ – .V5,� A�#– Y�Z7 – >G��M� >%$L,� – � �� f�− ����T 3

��− }�f� >f2+� T<f!E� �� O: �� .[w Í }�$/cb� S�a;– T�f�Â, Õ�2Ve� Ñ��,� �7 �� Ñ��,�– >fc�AB,�� >f!�$L�, ABCf2e� A�# –

1.�e�−,� ¶�7.– m�E� >%$L,� – � �  f�− ��� T 3

��− P,DE� Sb� .[w Í P$/�e� S�a;– Ï� �f7 _ �&�� T��Â, �D– >'z,�� �&,p/�, >+�e� A�,� – ����T 3

��− >,<��n>,<�� 1�/[ o– ÍBCf,� Ï.f! �7� �+,� Ë&je – �f6 Ï.! �7� O?�9A >!Bµ– >&Dt|%,� -A�%e� S.?�# –�[,� #�7i A&: −

m�E� >%$L,�– � �� f�− Ï.%,� ¾�z,� ��&:0 A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3 ��− Í��,� r]�2,� P&DE�� Í�V,� r,�C,� P&���– ^�%e� �.5,� ÏE

Î��.)2,� �+.[ª �7–}�f$! N�Gf:0 AB/[,� u&�� , f_ AB/[f,�� ÇBM� Õ.�– �/V,� ¢�! –Y�Z7 3

ehf ��− ,� >&��: (�Gf,� �/f� f! �AB;�f$– f_ �f7 (&��.f7� »&�f�,

�AB;�$,�– >&7.%,� �/V,� ��&:0 A�# >%$L� – �� –»+A�J <7 3 ��− ËcB9,� >&��:nËcBf9,� _o »&�f�, 8f��\,� T� ¥° f!

Page 229: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

ÕB2G,� _–Q2,�� >!�$L�, .V5,� A�# 3 �{− ÔBV,�&G,� >&��:nÔBV,�&G,� (&V��$!o� �Lc ¥° ! �+f,

>&G�,� >,�9.,� ! �ª�.,�– �L�,� ¥° ! O/�� �Bµ �6 �&�! ��B: S!� �ª�.,�– >f+Z�E� >%$Le� – m�E� >f%$L,� – >2f9

� �  f�− ��{�T 3

��− ÔBV,�&Gf,� >&��: nÔBV,�&Gf,� (&V��f$! o �fc�Be� ¥° f! Î�;.�� �+Q�,– �c�Be� ¥° Á��H – S#�%G,� >%$L� – S.��f�,�

– m�E� >%$L,� – � �� f�− ��{�T 3

��− >&�L2e� !�B�,� .+.� ! Î�;.�� �+Q,� >&��:– .+.� Á��H �ª�.f,� �fL��, >&�L2e� !�B�,�– Ëf$��� Ï�f$,� 45LCf� >f%$L� –

>&D�|,� >%$L,�– � �� f�− ����T 3

� − _ �+,� P�, 8%,� >V: ¥° ! Î�;.�� �+Q,� >&��: "�� �A�$� �7– >29 N�hc S�$7 X$R � �� f�− ��{�T 3

��− N�$C,� >&��:nN�$C,� Å! _ o ÎB�E� _ �7 Å! ¥° ! l,�� �7� >&5,� !– Ï.%,� 1�/V,� ��&:0 A�# – Ë$��� Ï�$,� 4G&! –

S.���,�–»+A�J <7 3 ��− >Fje� N�&7 Í >F��– Î�)$f]�� >2Gf,� T�Bfc ¸��fj�, –� uf&�

Å�e� X&7A �7 _ >9�A#�, (&f:A B7� #B_ _� – >f+�.,� A�# – ��+.,�– m�E� >%$L,� – ���� f�− ���{T 3

��− >+2$��2,� �<;� u?��: Í >+#AB,� u?��� – �f7 &Fe�$! �&,pJ Î�M� _– Ï�A,� O&[B,�$! °�2,� – u��# – >f!�$L,� A�7 X$R

Page 230: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

S.��%,�– >29 � {�f�3 ��− -�.��n-�.�� 1�/[o – Ï�A�5,� �D ÏE – �)� �G_ u&��

– �Qe� A�# – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3 ��− S.��f�,�� �� »+A�J Í S½�je� �G: – �+f,� U<f; ¸��fj�,

ËRB&G,�– (&��.f70 O�f5,� Bf7� _ u&�� – Ï�f$,� 4Gf&! >f%$L� Ë$���– S.���,� – m�E� >%$L,� – � �� f�����T 3

��− X7�Gf,� N.f�,� #�f: m0 1.f�e�� P,fDE� Í ÍBCf,� AB��� �.FI�− Ëf/d$,� U<! U�' AB/[,� �&,pJ – >f���|,� >f$/V� °�f2,� >&2+,�− S.���,� – m�E� >%$L,� – ���� f�− �{{�T 3

�{− -BC/,� �! u?��:– 4Gf&! A#��,�f$! »&�f,� �&,pJ – Í Xf$R �z�FD�−D�|,� >%$L,� >&– � �{ f�− ���{T 3

��− ��&5]E� Y��$R� ��&,�E� >&�:– Î�)5f]�� (&f%D Ï� ¸��j�, – S#�%G,� >%$L�– �� – � �� f�− ����T 3

��− �ZG,� >���– Ó2�$,� �$! �7 _ A�7E� �7b – AB/[f,� u&�� PD*ff� 8Gff:– -A�ff%e� A�# >ff%$L� – S.��ff�,� – >ff&D�|,� >ff%$L,� –

����T 3# eif

� − Î�DB&,� .V5,� �+.� – ��f7 ��.,�$! AB/[,� �&,pJ – >f,�[� Y�ff!B$Le�– �ff+BV,� – (ff��,� A�# – Y�Zff7 – >Gff��M� >ff%$L,� –

����T 3 e f

Page 231: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���  −

��− >&�<9�� -A�%e� S.?�#– >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3

��− Î�/G$,� }.L7 -A�%� S.?�#– >�.%e� A�# –Y�Z7 3 ��− -BC/,� Í Y�9�A# Ë�<9��" ���af�� Y�&Cd� " – �&,pfJ

-° U<; _ AB/[,�– >&7.%,� >�)2,� A�# – S.���,� – ���{T 3

��− >2��|,� >?�e� N�&!� Í >2��V,� AA,� – Î<�Gf%,� .F: �7� ¸��j�, – >ff&Dt|%,� -A�ff%e� S.ff?�# – �[ff,� #�ff7i Aff&: – >2ff9 � �{ fff�−

.+BCJ− O&�� A�# –Y�Z7 3 ��− SA,� �tfV��� 8f�V/e�� >&�BCf,� ���af� uf&�� Í S.��5,�–

Ë��f�� ��.,�f$! <�,– T�f�Â, P+f�/,� }�f9� 1�f/V7 ufj�� �ª�.,�– Ë$��� Ï�$,� 45LC� >%$L� – � �� f�− �� �T 3

��− >5G�5,� »+A�J Í }�A#–AB[f� Ë�Bf&7 (&��.70 AB/[,� �&,pJ , T.[ �9B+ w�/9E��–Z�E� >%$Le� S.���,�7 >+– >29 ����T 3

�{{− Í�C,� O)2e� ! Í��,� O&,,�– �.f�J �f7 �f9B+ �+f,� Ut� `#.7− YB/�� _ (&)� u&�� – Ëf�%,� �j$,� h[.� Y�AB�2� –

`.�,� T� >%��;– >�.Ve� >V� – � �� f�− ����T 3

�{�− >+�,� Y�D�+,�– S.f�ª Bf7� f_ T��Â, – Ï.f%,� .fV5,� A�# – ��–»+A�J <7 3

�{�− ABCff%,� �ff�/² Í ff?��%,�� Y�D�+ff,�– ff�� w�/ff9E� �&,pffJ A�ffL! AB5�,�ff$!– m�E� >ff%$L,� − >ff�.Ve� >ffV� − ��{� fff�−

����T 3

�{ − ��ae� �t�! N�&!� >�.%� Í ��ae� ��$+,� – NBf:.� �7� T��Â,

Page 232: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

ة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحد

− ���� −

ËV,�e�– AB2,� B7� ��E� _ AB/[,� u&�� – ¾�zf,� A�# Xf$L�, Q2,��– S.���,� –»+A�J <7 3

�{�− �A�5,� �7� N�B+#– �A�f5,� �f7 .! ¦5: ÏE – A�f] A�# – Y�Z7 3

�{�− T<9�� N�B+#– �f7� ��.,�f$! �f7 f_ �+f,� Pf� T��Â, �h�,�– �Gf: ��¯f[ &f9 uf&�� – >f&�%,� �f/V,� A�# Xf$R – Y�Z7– m�E� >%$L,� ���� f�− ���{T 3

�{�− �� N�B+# �<– NB&2&f9�� P+Bf, �&�! u�!� Ï.%,� ¦2,� u�: – NB&2&9�� P+B, QD– P+A�7 >%$R ����T 3

�{�− SZ�a,� – ÕBL,� Å! �+,� �<! >�<%�, – S.f?�# >f%$L7 Xf$R >&���2,� -A�%e�– �[f,� #�f7i A&: – m�E� >f%$L,� – ¢�f! .+BCfJ

�/V,�– Y�Z7 – ����T 3

�{�− Ê�5�� S.[aJ O+w,e� Ê�f5�� Y�f�$R O+a7 Ê��E� ¸j�7 4G– ËfVe� f)� �f7 _ �+,� Ë�J T��Â,– >f�j�� UBf+w >f@<@ �f6

Ë$�a�, Ê�5�� S.[aJ 1�/V7– Ï.%,� ��&:0 A�# .+BCJ –»+A�J <7 3 �{�− \s �� \� Í \%,� ! O+a,�– �7 �� >!Aª Ï� �+,� Ç� T��Â,

Ëfc�.%,� �f7� (&:.,�$!– uf&�� }�f$! �f)� r,�f]– >Gf9*� >,�9.,�– Y�Z7 – m�E� >%$L,� ��{�f�−����T 3

e�f ��{− Î�DB&,� .V5,� X&7A– ��f7 ��.,�f$! AB/[f,� �&,pJ – °�f2,�

Y�!B$Le� >,�[�– �+BV,� – (��,� A�#� – Y�Z7 – >Gf��M� >%$L,�

Page 233: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

����T 3

���− >&)�� ! #.,�– Ë�A�,� &%9 �7 Nt|! ¸��j�, –6 1�f/[ � ��G,� ?��!–A��f2,� Ë��f9 Åf! ��2/!�7 , Ë$,�fL,� Ëf%' Atf!� ± �–

-A�%e� Sp�2� °�2,�– >+A2V9�� – >29 ����T 3

���− ·BC5,� #A, #B)�f,� >,h2�� #B;B,� >$J.� 4Ge� – Åf! T�f�Â, �A��,�– Z/G;�� >,�9A – <e� Å! �$! #�!0 – `.f�,� T� >f%��;

–S&�%,� (Gc SB!,�� –>�.Ve� >V� 3 �� − >9�&G,�� YB�<,� Í >,�9A– �ªB2&$f9� �&,pfJ – (+f�J� >f'.J

Ë52: �G: AB/[,�–�+.[ª #�*� AB/[,� >%;�.� 3 ���− �A�CDE� �+.[ª ¥° �%�� >+Z��,� >,�9.,�– (+.V,�f$! T�f�Â,

�Z��,� Nª�B� �7– r&$f] Å! _ >%$L7 X$R – S.��f�,� – <f7 »+A�J3

���− >&D�,� >,�9.,�– Ç�hf�,� T<f9�� >fF: T��Â, – >�Gf�9 �f6 Ç�hf�,� T�f��� O?�f9A �f� Ç�B%,� ABC�,�– U�E� �hf�� – ��f2/!�7

<%,� B7� 45LC� _ »&�,�– �f2�� >f$/V� – S.��f�,� – >f%$L,� >&D�|,�– � �{ f�− ���{T 3

���− Y�#�G,�� �t�%,� U�B:� Í Y�2�� Y�6�A–<%�, .c�f7 f_ >f� �A�GD�BM� �B9Be�– N�&�&!t9� � 9� u&�� – >+A&�� >%$Le� –

N�.)R– � �{ f�−Y�Z7 >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ 3 ePf

���− (V��� U�|�E� Í ([E� .�ª– ÕBf&,� �Gj�, – AB/[f,� uf&��

Page 234: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

ËF: _, Àf�E� f_ AB/[f,�� – >f���|,� A�# >f!�$R – A�f,� ���&$,�– 1.�e�– m�E� >%$L,� ��{� f� − ����T 3

e0f ���− �B�e� U�# >�.%e �B�G,�– �hf+.�e� Åf! �f7 f�� �+,� Ë�/, –

S#�+ª 45LC� _ u&��, AB��! ¥�/5,�$! &%9� – �&,pf/,� >f2� >'z,��– S.���,� – ���� T– ��� T3

���− `\V,� �2G,�– Ëf�)&$,� 8Gf�� �7 �� ¸���� T��Â, – >f%$L� >&Dt|%,� -A�%e� S.?�# P�µ– �[f,� #�f7i Af&: – m�E� >f%$L,� –

� �� f�− >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3 ��{− `\V,� �2G,�– Ë?�Gf2,� �&%f� �f7 �� ¸���� T��Â, – uf&��

�A�ff2$,� Nt&�ff9 A�5�,�ff$! AB/[f,�, �Gff: ��¯ff[ &ff9� – A�# >&�%,� �/V,�– Y�Z7 –� >%$L,� m�E– ��{�� f�����T 3

���− Y�#Bf;Be� ¡#�$7 ���e� >&De� >9�&G,�– Ï�A�f5,� �fD ÏE – A�FD �z� �ªB� u&��– >&V&,B@�V,� >%$Le� – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

���− �<$2,� T<!� Z9– Ë$�af,� �+f,� P� ¸���� T��Â, – -�°0 ¶�*DAE� �&%�– >,�9.,� >G9*� –Y�Z7 3

ejf �� − � >f&V,�e� Y�f�$R Í >&[h,� AB2,� S.F– f_ �f7 f_ »&�f�,

-B�²– .V5,� A�# .+BCJ – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

���− T<9�� Í >��c Y�&Cd�– AB/[f,� �f)'.J� �)2&7 �,� Y�9�A# ��7 ��.,�$!– Y�!B$Le� >,�[� °�2,� – �+BV,� – >|,�|,� >%$L,�

Page 235: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

– ����T 3

���− A�$�� Í ��a,� Y�Aa� ��w �� – #tf%,� �f7 Ë��f$! >�<%�, Å$2��– Ï.%,� ¾�z,� ��&:0 A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3

���− 42G�� �t9E� ¥°– �f7� ��.,�f$! �f7 T<G,�$! (V�� ÏE Å&$f��� Ëd�,� N�;.7± �– �f+he� f+.� f�� »&�f,� uf&�� – A�#

>&�%,� �/V,�– Y�Z7 – m�E� >%$L,� – �{�{T 3

���− f+.F/,� f! Î�)5f]�� ¥°, ¥° Í f!�B�,� +GfJ 4Gfe� f?��%,� +.v– Î�)5f]�� �+f,� Pf� T�f�Â, – uf&�%J� uf&��

Î��%,� #�� ,�� AB/[,�– Qf2�, ��&�f,� A�# >!�$R – �f+BV,� – m�E� >%$L,�– ��   f�− �{��T 3

���− uL2e� Í (�G,� ¥°,�� ()$e� ¥��+0 1�/V7 uj�� (�Gf,� Î�%� – �À�E� >�<%,� »&��, – >&7.%,� �/V,� ��&:0 A�# >%$L7 X$R –

S.���,�–»+A�J <7 3 ���− uL2e� Í (�G,� ¥°– �2�� (&:.,�$! w�/9¼, – >$/Ve� °�2,�

¾�z�, >+.�ªE�– S.���,� –»+A�J <7 3 � {− (�Gf� r&j] ¥° , ��f)2e�7 4Gfe� – -° �f7 Ëf&y T�f�Â, � ��Bff2,– Thff: �ff7� A�# >ff%$L� nff:�� ff�µo – m�E� >ff%$L,� –

�{{�T 3

� �− >&5Gf2,� ?��%,� ¥°– Î�ª�f/5/,� �+f,� %f9 >f�<%�, – uf&�� ��G,� �ª�F: �� AB/[,�– >f+.�ªE� Y�f&�V,� >$/V� – S.��f�,� –

m�E� >%$L,�− ��{� f�− ����T 3

Page 236: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

� �− (f��� �+ª� (�%,� 8! ¥°–� Åf! T�f�Â, �A�f�,– A�# .+BCfJ >�.%e�–Y�Z7 3

�  − >V�� NB&! ¥°– �ª�.f,� �+,� .d� T��Â, – AB/[f,� uf&�� ��G,� �ª�F: ��– >+�e� B�FDb� >$/V� – S.���,� – m�E� >%$L,�

– ��{{f�3 � �− (V�� ·BC� ¥°– Î����,� ��ª.,�$! »&��, – >%$L�� >$/V�

Ëff$��� Ï�ff$,� 45LCff�–.��ff�,� S– >ff&D�|,� >ff%$L,� – � �� fff�− ����T 3

� �− (ffV�� ·BCff� ¥°– Ë��ff�� ��.,�ff$! mBff�, – �jjff] Ç�f&V,� (&��.f70 (f]�! AB/[f,� �7 42/!��– >f&�%,� �f/V,� A�# –

Y�Z7– >&D�|,� >%$L,� – >29 �{{�T3 � �− (V�� ·BC� ¥°– Ëf52�� "#�ª Ç�7 Nt&�9 �7 45LC� �&,pJ –,� �&��B: �%6� �&CfD %9� �#�� »&�– >f&�%,� �f/V,� A�# –

Y�Z7– m�E� >%$L,� – ���� f��{{�T 3

� �− +.F/,� ! ËF�B�,� ¥°–�+,� �<! >�<%,� ¥° B�� , Åf! _ �7, ÕBL,� �+,� ZC2, #��/!b� +.v ! ËF�B,�7 Z)�,� –

�fc�Be� ¥° �f� Î�f|,� �hf�� Á��H �B$L�–,� A�# >f!�$R >f!�$L S.��%,�– �&[.J – m�E� >%$L,� – >29 � ��f�3

� �− A�@g� OV�� ¥°– ���fjL,� .f5%; Ï� T��Â, – »&�f,� uf&�� ¶�*ffDAE� �&%ff�– >,�ff9.,� >Gff9*� – Y�Zff7 – m�E� >ff%$L,�

���� f�− ����T 3

Page 237: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

� �− ¥�/5e� ¦&d�J ! UBLe� ¥Q,�– Î�ª�f/5/,� �+f,� %9 >�<%�, –� >&f��: �%�� �f&�! Î�f;.�� �+Qf,� &Gf,– >f&Dt|! >f%$L� –

Y#�%9A#− � �{f�3 ��{− T<V,� (�! Í ]��e� ¥°– Î�ª�/5/,� �+,� %9 >�<%�, – X$R

�B2G$,� �2�� T._ ���� >%$L� Í– m�E� >%$L,� – >29 � {�f�3 ���− >%+Q,�– �.;g� 8G�� �7 _ ¸���� T��Â, – AB/[,� u&��

�$! ËF&�f,� .f! �7 – �RBf,� A�# >f!�$R – ��f+.,� – >f%$L,� m�E�− ���� f�− ����T 3

���− Nt+�� �%�– Ë�)&$,� 8G�� �7 �� ¸���� T��Â, – Ï� uf&�� UB�sª ÎB&G7 &%G,� _ .;��– >f&�%,� �f/V,� A�# – Y�Zf7 –

m�E� >%$L,�– ���{ f�− ���{T 3

�� − �5�,�–P&?.,� �&,pJ �2&9 �7 Å! Ï� – SaJ�9E� �� >2� u&�� – Ë�B�,� #��A��� >���|,� SA�ª� QD–�� 3

���− O?�Gfe� �+a)/, O?�G,� �5�– �f7 f_ �f7 ��.,�f$! >f�<%�, N�ff��− Ë!BGff&,� "ff$! }B&R�ff2s� 1E� �ff&�! uff�! – >ff%$Le�

>&V&,B@�V,�–Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3 ���− ����,� O?�G� Í O&�%,� ��5� Of&�%/,�� >V��� A�,�� – T�f�Â,

�+,� P�,.V7 Ï� �7 _ , >f+ªB�� (&fc �7�f7 Z)�f,� – >f%$Le� >&2&G��– S.���,� – m�E� >%$L,� � � f�3

���− >f&Dt|%,� >,�,� �t�! Í >&Dt%2,� u?���,� – Ä�fR >f�<%,� �&,pfJ "#�ª �\[– Ï.%,� 1�/V,� A�# – Y�Z7 – ����T 3

Page 238: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���{ −

e[f

���− >&I�� �?�jC,� – �2c.Gf,� �+f,� P�, – AB/[f,� uf&�� �+Q,� ��.,�$! ��– ¥<f5,� >$/V� – �f+BV,� – m�E� >f%$L,�

��{�f�− ����T 3

���− N�$�7 �7� �&Jz7 N�&: �7� r&j]– �f7 Åf! �+f,� �<f! T��Â, ÕA�5,� N�$�7– ¶�*DAE� �&%� u&�� – >,�f9.,� >G9*� – >f%$L,�

|,� >&D����� f�− ��� T 3

���− �A�d$,� r&j]– �A�fd$,� O&!tf90 �f7 f_ >fF�� T��Â, – Thff: �ff7� A�# >ff!�$R– ff:�� ff�µ – m�E� >ff%$L,� – ���� fff�−

�{{  T–Y�Z7 3 ��{− (�G� r&j]– �AB7�Gf&2,� ��fF�� �f7 (�Gf� >fF�� T��Â, –

Thff: �ff7� A�# >ff!�$R– ff:�� ff�µ – m�E� >ff%$L,� – ��� fff� − �{{� T–Y�Z7 3

���− T<9�� Í >&�BC,�– NBGf�V&D AB/[,� �Q/Ge� �&,pJ – �f'.J >f$+° �+f,� ABD �&�! u�!�– ËFD�fM� >f$/V� °�f2,� – S.��f�,� –

>&D�|,� >%$L,�– ���� f�− �{{�T 3

ekf ���− X9�/,� N.�,� O�E X�<,� �B�,� – ��.,�f$! �f7 f_ T�f�Â,

���dG,�–A�# .+BCJ S�&�� >$/V� – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

elf �� − ��&,�E� Y��$R – ���e� �7� Å! �7 .! �+,� ��¯, – ABD u&��

Page 239: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

>$+° �+,�– >�.%e� A�# – Y�Z7 – ��{� f�− ����T 3

− >�7�2�� Y��$R – Åf%+ Ï� �f7 _ 8G�� Ï� Ñ���, – >2Gf,� >f%$L� >+je�– �� –%e� A�# .+BCJ >�.–Y�Z7 3

���− >&%���ff,� Y�ff�$R– �B2ff9E� (&:.,�ff$! �+ff,� Utff� – uff&�� �AB$�� �$!– Q2,�� >!�$L�, TB�%,� A�# – ��+.,� – ��{� f�−

����T 3

���− >&%���ff,� Y�ff�$R – >$)ff� Ñ�ffc �ff7� �+ff,� Ëff��/, – ��ff2/!�7 N�� (&�%,�$!– �/V,� ¢�! – Y�Z7 – ��{� f�����T 3

���− �,� Y��$R `\V,� >&%��– ËV$G,� Í�V,�$! �7 Å! �+,� Ë�/, – >&2&G�� >%$Le� X$R– � ��f�− >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3

���− >&�BCf,� Y��$R– Ë�Gf,� 8Gf�� �f7 f_ ��.,�f$! ÏE – >$+° �+,� ABD u&��– ËFD�M� >$/V� – S.���,� – >f|,�|,� >f%$L,� –

��{� f�− ����T 3

���− ��$L,� `\V,� Y– Î�.%�,� Å! �7 1��B,�$! T��Â, – .V5,� A�# – Y�Z7 – >+�e� >%$L,� �! – � ��f�3 ���− �+¯5e� Y��$R– �#��,� �+,� P� T��Â, – �� >2� >%;�.�

�t�%,�– >&�%,� �/V,� A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3 ebf

��{− \s �� \� Í \%,� – Ë$�af,� �+f,� P� ¸��j�, –uf&�� .;�f� Ï� UB�sª &%G,� _– >&�%,� �/V,� A�# – Y�Z7 – ��{� f�− ����T 3

���− Ë:Bf,� .?�Cf7� Qf$,� Y�f+.�D 87 Ë�<9�� N��.%,�– >f�<%�,

Page 240: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

ÕAe� Ë�J _– ´<$,� >G9*� – Y�Z7 – >f&D�|,� >f%$L,� ��{� f�− ����T 3

���− >�%,�– Î�)$]E� »&�,� Ï� ¸��j�, – ��6A u&�� f_ �7 � �AB5[A�$e� P+A#0– Q2�, >]�%,� A�# – ��+.,� – >&D�|,� >%$L,� –

���� f�− ����T 3

�� − N�f�h,� O�� »+A�J Í Nt�� �!" >2f9 (;�.fJ� ¾#�Bf: ���−���f�" – Ë2&%,� #B_ �+,� A7 T��Â, – _ _ AB/[,� u&�� 8��– 1�/V�, >��%,� >+�e� >�&I� –�,� S.��– ��{� f�− ����T 3

���− N�f�h,� O�� »+A�J Í Nt�� �!" >2f9 (;�.fJ� ¾#�Bf: ���−���f�" – 8f�� f_ f_ AB/[,� u&�� – >f��%,� >+�fe� >f�&I�

1�/V�,– S.���,� – >29 ��{� f�− ����T 3

���− 8f�E� �$,� »+A�J Í 8|,� �%,�– f�� �f7 f_ �+f,� Ëf�/, Õ�ff5,�−ff� uff&�� &Gff,� #�*, Ë:�ff2L,� .��ffR ff_� – S.��ff�,� – ����T 3

���− >f+�F$7 >%7�G,� >?�e� Í �t�%,� �� -.! �&� >+�A,� N�B2!– ÏE Ë2+\�,� �$! �7 �� }�$%,�– ~qBfD U#�! u&�� – ��f�g� A�#

S+��– Y�Z7 – ����T 3

���− -A�%e� -A�B!– �#A�.)Gf,� �+f,� 1�)f� T��Â, –ufj�� 1�f/[ Ç�h��, �+,� TB�! ��&:0– >�.%e� A�# – Y�Z7 – ��{� f�− ����T 3

emf ���− >f&|+�� `��/5,� – Ëf/&I� .fF: �f7� �+f,� 1�)�f, – >f%$L�

Page 241: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���  −

Ëff$��� Ï�ff$,� 45LCff�– S.��ff�,� – >ff&D�|,� >ff%$L,� – � �{ fff�− ���{T 3

���− �A�d$,� r&j] ¥Q7 �A�$,� r/� – Î<�Gf%,� .F: �7� ¸���� – >f&�%,� �/V,� A�# – Y�Zf7 – m�E� >f%$L,� – �{{ T−n >f@<@

��h;�o3 ��{− Î��.,� ~&5,�� Î�7.,� r/5,�– Î<&�� A#��,�$! T��Â, – .+BCJ

>�.%e� A�#– Y�Z7 – ��{� f�− ����T 3

���− Ï.! �7� (/M�� (+.V,�$! Å&�� �L�,� >,��7 (&:.,� ��.,� r/� �+,� Ë&_– �&,pJ A�L&$,� �G: �7 Ë2�,�$! �7 �+,� ��H– uf&��

�f+he� f+.� �� »&�,�– >f&7.%,� ��f�g� A�# >f%$L� – S.��f�,� – m�E� >%$L,�– �� � f�− �{�{T 3

���− ZG5/,� (�! �� >+�A,�� >+��.,� Ë2� 87 X���� .+�,� r/� n ZGf5JÎ�[B�,�o – Î�[B�,� _ �7 Å! �7 _ T��Â, – 45LCf� >%$L�

Ë$��� Ï�$,�– >&D�|,� >%$L,� S.���,� – � �  f�− ����T 3

�� − >&�]E� �:�$e� ¥° Í >&I�� Y�:B/5,�– f_ �7 �� »&��, >$&F! �7– (fV�� ¥° Í (fI� Ê�f�+0 1�/[ Á��H – A�# .+BCfJ >�.%e�– Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

���− >&Ve� Y�:B/5,�–.f! �f7� �+f,� Ëfje ÍBCf,� Ï– A�# >f%$L� A#�]−Y�Z7 3

���− >&�<V,� "W�Ai� �ª�.,� �+,� .d�– r,�f] f_ AB/[f,� �&,pJ N�[Ah,�– Q2,�� >!�$L�, .V5,� A�# – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

Page 242: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

���− �.5,� 87 �.5,�– �#��$,� .���,�$! T��Â, – �+f,� Ë&_ u&�� &��$!– >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3

���− � (V�� ·BC– Ï�A�5,� �D ÏE – ���fVe� (&:.,�f$! QD – �� >!�$R– >29 � �� f�− ��{�T 3

���− (V�� ·BC�– ÍBC,� Ï.! �7� �+,� Ë&je – Ï� u&�%J� u&�� Ëff5&5! <ff%,�– Ï.ff%,� 1�ff/V,� A�# – Y�Zff7 – >ff&D�|,� >ff%$L,� –

��{{f�− ���{T 3 ���− »+A�/,� Í "h[.�� Ï.%,� .V5,�– �Zf,�� Õb �# AB/[,� �&,pJ – A�L&$,� O&!t90 �&�! u�!� >&7.%,� m0 ���D – Î�f2$�,� 1�f/V,� A�# –

Y�Z7–»+A�J <7 3

��{− >+2I� Y�5G�5,�" >&:<]��� >&�<9��� >&[�2I� �­�!�Lc " – AB/[,� �&,pJ– AB%+ª Å! – Qf2,�� >!�$L�, P,DE� A�# – >f%$L,�

m�E����{T 3

���− >&�<9�� �­z�� �IB]� #B;B,� S:� >5G��– f�� >��D �&,pJ �AB$��– Ë$&�,� O��[ 45LC� AB/[,� -�°x7 – >f&&J �f7� >$/V�

– �.je� – �+.j$,� – m�E� >%$L,� – ��{�f� 3

���− ���a�� Y���� >&D�DB&,� >5G�5,�– A�C&7 _ AB/[,� �&,pJ – Î�2$�,� 1�/V,� A�#– Y�Z7 – ��� T 3

�� − �9.)5,�– (+2,� �7b – >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

���− >&52�� (;�.J Í >&)$,� ?�B5,�– �B2V�,� Ë��$! _ >�<%�, – Î�G%2,� �+,� A7 _ ��2/!�7– >f�.%e� A�# .+BCJ –Y�Zf7 , �f!

Page 243: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

>29 m�E� >%$L,�� ��f� 3

���− Y�&�B,� Y�B�–%�, Ë$/V,� .[�� �7 _ >�<– Ëf&_ _ u&�� &��$! �+,�– >�)2,� >$/V� –�� 3

���− Ë�<9�� -BC/,� Í–Ë%���,� �G: AB/[,� �&,pJ , AB/[f,�� ËF%,� +h&,� B7�– Qf2,�� >!�$L�, T<G,� A�# – S.��f�,� – >f%$L,�

m�E�– ���� f�− �{{�T 3

���− �C,� X���� ¥° .+�,� ~&� Z– ���f2e� -�W.,�$! >�<%�, – >�.%e� A�# .+BCJ–Y�Z7 3

enf ���− A�,� – Ï�f+.5,� f_ �7 .5%; .V7 Ï� ¸��j�, – �.f! uf&��

(&�ff9 (%2e�ff$!– Qff2,�� >ff!�$L�, Thff: �ff7� A�# – m�E� >ff%$L,� ���� f�− �{{{T 3

���− A�,�� ����,� – Ëf�)&$,� 8Gf�� �7 �� ¸���� T��Â, – uf&�� .��! Ui �$! �7 _– N�V&$%,� >$/V� >!�$R – ��f+.,� – >f%$L,�

>&D�|,����� f�− �{{�T 3

��{− ÇB,� �+: ! ÇB,� .Lc– Î�[B�,� Å! �7 _ T��Â, – �6 �)&,0 u+.L,�� � >+b� 1�/[– U<f� (&��.f70 (&��.70 AB/[�, – A�#

>|+�� �/V,�– S.���,� – >29 � �� f�− ����T 3

���− -BC/,� !�Bc– ��Aª �f7� �� �7 �� }�$%,� ÏE – �jjf] A�F2,� �.�ª _– Ås.� $%� Å! AB/[,� �%;�A – >f$/V� °�f2,� >+.�ªE� Y�&�V,�– S.���,� – >&D�|,� >%$L,� – � �� f�− ����T 3

Page 244: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

eCf ���− »+A�/,� Í O��V,�– �Ahf�� Z@E� �7� T��Â, –# >f!�$R A#�f] A�

Y�Z7 A�#�– >29 � �� f�− ����T 3

�� − NBf25,� Y�:<L]� -��[– �BD�f)/,� Ëc�A�f5,� Åf! fje – A#�f] A�# .+BCJ– Y�Zf7 – >2f9 m�E� >f%$L,� �f! ���� ff�−

����T 3

���− }�$,�� O+h�� �5M� ��[– ÎB�F%,� _ �7 O&!t90 »&��, – Ï.f%,� ¾�zf,� ��f&:0 A�# .+BCJ– Y�Zf7 – }f�,� >f%$R �f! –

S.���,�− >29 � ��f�3 ���− NBf25,�� �f/V,� Ë��f9� �f! NB2�,� ��[– 45LCf� Of6�5�,

>5&�� Ë;�j7 Z)�,� �$!– >|+�� TB�%,� A�# .+BCJ – Y�Zf7 – UB$D�/9� >%$R �!3

���− 1BFje� ��[– �.+BfFI� Ï<f�� Nt|! �7 Å! �G�� ÏE – SAB/[f,� uf&�%J� >f'.J� >9�A# O+f2c �#�I�f$! #�%f90 – Xf;�A

��7 &Fe�$! 8�� AB/[,� >'z,�– >f!�$L�, >&7.%,� >�)2,� A�# – Y�Z7– >29 ���{T 3

���− #��/!b� +.v ¥° Í #�.e� ��[– .f)Le� �7� �+,� U�' »&��, Å��– Y�!B$L�, Ë�!E� >G9*� X$R – Y�Z7 – m�E� >%$L,� – ��{� f�− ����T 3

���− 1��,E�� 42V,�– Ë�,� }�$! »&��, – ���B,� >G9*� – Y�Zf7 – >&D�|,� >%$L,� – ��{  f�− ��� T 3

Page 245: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

eJf ���− N�hf&e� N�G, – Î<�Gf%,� .fF: �f7� ¸��fj�, – -A�f%e� S.f?�#

>&Dt|%,�− �[,� #�7i A&: – >2f9 m�E� >f%$L,� � �� ff�− .+BCfJ Ë�!E� >G9*�– Y�Z7 – >29 ��{� f�− ����T 3

�{{− X�,�– ÕBfL,� ��¯f,� �D ÏE – (&���f$! AB/[f,� uf&�� #Bff_ , A�¿ Ëc�$,�ff$! �ffR�– >ff|+�� �ff/V,� A�# – �ff� – � �{f�− ���{T 3

eUf �{�− >&cQe� �:�$e�– �ª�.,� �+,� .d� T��Â, – (C/%e� _ u&��

�#��$,� �7– Ï.%,� 1�/V,� A�# >%$R –�E� >%$L,� m– ���{ f�− ���{T 3

�{�− .!��,�� �J�V,� 1#� Í .?�G,� O|e�– �fD �+,� ��&6 r/5,� ÏE _ �7 _ �7 �, Å]Be� Z@E� �7�7 -�.%e� – Ëf_ f_ u&�� &��$! �+,�– >+�%,� >$/Ve� – �&] – Y�Z7 – >29 ���� f�

���{T 3

�{ − 8C5,� ¥° Í �+.j$,� Xµ–<%�, Ë2&Gf�� �G�� �7 ¤�D >� Î<&V,�– Ë:A�f�� �µ u&�� – >f&�%,� �f/V,� A�# – Y�Zf7 –

m�E� >%$L,��{�{T 3

�{�− >f&&J �f7� �+,� Ë�J T<9�� »&� `��/� �Bµ– �f&J.J� Xf' _ �27�� �F2,� _ ��.,�$!– m�E� >f%$L,� � �� ff�− A�#

B%G,� >&7.%,� >V�e�7 ��/�b�>+#3

Page 246: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

�{�− O?�Ge�� O?�9.,� >!Bµ– >f&&J �f7� �+f,� Ë�/, – �f)&�! uf�! �tff�%,� �ff� >ff!�' �)jjff]�– >ff&�%,� �ff/V,� A�# – Y�Zff7 –

��{ f�− ��� T 3

�{�− 8%/GD ��+0� $%D ��+0 Uª�2� 87 8V,�G,� �A��– �+,� P�, .V7 Ï� �7 _, >f+ªB�� (&fc �7�f7 Z)�f,� –f_ uf&�%J� uf&��

�#��$,� �7 (C/%e�– Ï.f%,� 1�/V,� A�# >!�$R – Y�Zf7 – f�µ :��– m�E� >%$L,� ���� f�− �{{�T 3

�{�− Ë�<9�� -BC/,� m0 O��– Ëf&2�,� �f�B,� Bf7� AB/[,� �&,pJ Î�ª�/5/,�– >���|,� A�# – S.���,� – >|,�|,� >%$L,� – >29 ����T 3

�{�− Í N���&,� S\!� N�2�� Si.� N�f�h,� ¾#�Bf: �� \/%+ �� >�.%� – Ë%��&,� %9� �7 �$! T��Â,– ABCf2e� O&�� ��2/!�7 – �f/V,� A�#

>&�%,�– Y�Z7 – m�E� >%$L,� – ���� f�− ����T 3

�{�− -.�/Gf� �f� O[ Í -.L/Ge�– f�� �f7 f_ �+f,� 1�)�f, Ë)&�7��– >fj&c _ &5� AB/[,� u&�� –Zf�� >f%$L� – (fc –

«.ff,� �+Qff,� Y�A��ff/D� °�ff2,�– >ff&�%,� �ff/V,� A�# .+BCffJ – Y�Z7− >&D�|,� >%$L,� – ��{� f�����T 3

��{− 2Ge�– Î�$&�,� O$2: �7 �� T��Â, – >&2&e� >%$Le� – S.���,� – A#�] A�# .+BCJ–Y�Z7 3

���− A�BDE� S�V��– Ç�hf�,� T<f9�� >fF: T��Â, – >f!Bµ �f6 9A Ç�hf�,� T�f��� O?�f9A �f� Ç�Bf%,� ABC�,� O?�– Î�f|,� �hf�� –

�<%,� B7� 45LC� _ »&�,� ��2/!�7– �f2�� >f$/V� – S.��f�,� –

Page 247: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ���� −

>&D�|,� >%$L,�– � �{f�− ���{T 3

���− �D�&7� �+�� OV�� – �ABf� �f7� �Gf�� �f7 f_ ¸��fj�, – >&Dt|%,� -A�%e� S.?�# >%$L�– #�7i A&: –,� �[– � {�f�3

�� − #B)�e�� UB�%e� 87 PDE� ¥�$C�– Shf� �7 _ �+,� P�, �A�25,�– #B;B,�� X�� �&s ¥�/5� 1�/V7 uj�� – AB/[f,� u&��

Ç�&V,� (&��.70 (]�!– >&�%,� �/V,� A�# – Y�Z7 – m�E� >f%$L,� – >29 �{�{T 3

���− >&,�%,� �,�Le�–� .! �7 _ �+,� .d5, �ª�.,– AB/[,� u&�� ��G,� �ª�F: ��– Ï.f%,� 1�f/V,� A�# >f%$R – Y�Zf7 – >f%$L,�

>29 m�E�����T 3

���− >&�<9�� >5G�5,� ¢�%�– >f&2�� #�Bf; _ �&,pJ – (f��,� A�# – Y�Z7– >&D�|,� >%$L,� ��� T 3

���− 1.�e� A�$�� ¦&d�J Í �F%e�– �f[�.e� f:�B,� $%, – uf�! �&�!N�+.%,� &%9 _, Ë�%,� Ï.%,� _� – 1�/V,� A�# – A�f,�

���&$,�– >%7�G,� >%$L,� – ����T 3

���− N��$,� (F%�– �Bf�� �f$! �f7 YBc�f+ �+,� 1�)�, – A�# A#�], Y�Z7 A�# – >29 � ��f�− ����T 3

���− >5Gf�5,� Y�j�LCe O���,� (F%e�– (%2e�f$! AB/[f,� �&,pfJ Ë25��–� ÇB7� >$/V� °�2,– S.���,� – >|,�|,� >%$L,� – ���{ ff�− �{{{T 3

���− S.���,�7 >&7.%,� >��,� XFe Ë5G�5,� (F%e�– NB��f, >��%,� >�&I�

Page 248: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �� { −

>+Z�E� X7�Le�– S.���,� � �� f�− ����T 3

��{− Ë5Gf�5,� (fF%e�– �$&�f] Of&' �&,pfJ – Î�f2$�,� 1�f/V,� A�# – Y�Z7– ����T 3

���− (F%e� Ë5G�5,�– >f$�� #�.f� �&,pJ – >f!�$L�, >f|+�� ��f$c A�# Q2,��− S.���,� – >G��M� >%$L,� – �{{�T 3

���− Z$V,� (F%e�– Î�\fL,� f�� �f7 Nt&�f9 (f9��,� Ï� ¸��fj�, – Ë5�Gf,� &Fe�$! �� u&��– >f!�$L�, >f&7.%,� A�f,� – #�f�7 –

>&D�|,� >%$L,� 3

�� − 85,*e� (F%�–�&,pJ >,�j[ �6A .! – 4f2|e� >f$/V� °�f2,� – Y�Z7– Ï.%,� ¾�z,� ��&:0 A�# –Y�Z7 3

���− �f?�BL,�� �.f5,�� ���ae�� ?��%,�� Y�D�+�, Ë!B9Be� (F%e� ¢�%,� Í Oj2,��– A�[ª O&)9 AB/[,� �&,pJ – Ï.f%,� 1�/V,� A�# –

u��#– S.���,� – m�E� >%$L,� – ���� f�− ����T 3

���− � »+A�/,�� >�.%e– �BG$,� N�&59 �7 1B�%+ �9B+ ÏE – uf&�� �.ff%,� ��&ff6 T.ff[� AB/[ff,�– >,�ff9.,� >Gff9*� – >ff&D�|,� >ff%$L,�

��{�f�− ����T 3

���− S#�&G,� ¥�$C�� S#�%G,� ¥�/5�– "#�ª `\f[ Ä�L, – �f/V,� A�# >&�%,�– Y�Z7 – ��{� f�����T 3

���− T<V,� (�! Í ]��e�–+,� %G, Î�ª�f/5/,� .f! �7 #B%G� �– ]��e� ¥° Á��H– �B2Gf$,� �f2�� T.f_ ���� >%$L� Í X$R –

m�E� >%$L,�� {�f�3

Page 249: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

لوجودموقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة ا

− �� � −

���− >2Gf,E� f! S.)/�fe� �+#�:E� �� Z|[ N�&7 Í >2G�� ]��e�– ���dG,� �+,� P� ¸��j�,– u+Cf,� f_ �f$! r&jCJ –

ËFD�M� >$/V� °�2,�–��,� S.�3 ���− N��� �7� >���– N��� �7 ��.,�$! >�<%�, – �%�f,� A�# – �� –»+A�J <7 3 � {− Oj2,�� O�e� – Î�/9.)�f,� (+.V,�f$! �f7 _ T��Â, – uf&��

Î<&[ &9 _– Ëf$��� Ï�f$,� 45LCf� >%$L� >[° – S.��f�,� – � �� f�− ����T 3

� �− �+.?�G,� Uª�2�– �f$! T<9�� »&�, ��.fI� �A�CfDE� – A�# >&�%,� �/V,�– Y�Z7 – ��{� f�− ����T 3

� �− (�E�� �B�e� »+A�J Í (�/2e�– ��.,�f$! �.f5,� Ï� �+,� Ut� �ªB�� �7– >f&Dt|%,� -A�f%e� S.?�# – �[f,� #�f7i Af&: – >f%$L,�

m�E�– � ��f�3 �  − T<V,� (�! Í �c�Be�–��.,�$! �+,� �%7 ˧�� – .+BCfJ

�/V,� ¢�!– Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3 � �− >5G�5,� T<!� >!B9B�n�D�;E�� 1.%,� o– Î�A w�/f9E� #�!0

�5,� Å+0– OdD �AB; AB/[,� >%;�.� – >&�%,� �/V,� A�# – Y�Z7 – m�E� >%$L,� – ���� f�− ����T 3

� �− S¯&e� >&7.%,� >!B9Be�–U�7.s u&5� _ -�°x7 – A�# .+BCJ Ï.%,� ¾�z,� ��&:0–Y�Z7 3

� �− >5Gff�5,� >!Bff9B�– ��ff7 ��.,�ff$! AB/[ff,� �&,pffJ – Xff$R Q2,�� Y�9�A�, >&7.%,� >G9*e�– Y�Zf7 – m�E� >f%$L,� – >2f9

Page 250: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �� � −

����T 3

� �− S�/de� >&5G�5,� >!B9Be�– Of��[ #�*f� >f+h&�FD�� �f! �f)��D �#�] &�.,�$!� �Q%,� U<;�–A -�6�� �)&�! -°�� �)%;�

#B_ �&FD Ë[ª AB/[,� >&�<90 Y�&Cd�– (f��,� A�# – Y�Zf7 –»+A�J <7 3

� �− S¤�%e� 1�h:E�� ���ae�� N�+#E� Í S¯&e� >!B9Be�– -�°0 Ëf2)�� #�f� �f7 XD�� AB/[,�– >f!�$L�, >f&e�%,� S�f2,� A�# °�f2,�

Q2,��– >%7�.,� >%$L,� ���{f�3 � �− 8�f9.e� "#�f$!� 8e�f%,� 1A �f� ¢�f%,�� (�%,�� O�%,� �cB�–

�\f] 45LCf� T<9�� »&� �&,pJ– Ï.f%,� ¾�zf,� ��f&:0 A�# – Y�Z7��{� f�− ����T 3

��{− U�;.,� �D Í U�/!b� N�h&�− �� �7 _ �+,� P� ¸��j�, Ë$�a,�– ���fF$,� Å! _ u&�� –f&�%,� �f/V,� A�# .+BCfJ >– Y�Z7 3

e_f ���− S�ffF2,� – �2&ff9 �ff7 Åff! Ï� P&?.ff�, – Ëff$��� Ï�ff$,� 45LCff� –

S.���,�– >&D�|,� >%$L,� – � �� f��� �T 3

���− S.���,�� �� �B�� Í S.��h,� TBF2,�– �f7 �f9B+ �+f,� Ut� `#.7 �.�J– >f'z,�� �&,p/�, >��%,� >+�e� >G9*e� – � � ff�−

��� T 3

�� − �� }B52,� >�hD N��h,� »+A�BJ Í N�7E– #��# �f7 Åf! �f&Ld�, ÍZC,� �.�B��– �$: �G: AB/[,� u&�� – �/V,� A�# >%$L� –

Page 251: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− ��   −

��– ���{T 3

���− ��ABLJ� >&�BC,� >5G�5,� Sp�D– &��$! N��.! AB/[,� �&,pJ ¥�/�– Ë�<9�� �/Ve� – Y�Z7 – � �� f�− ����T 3

���− -BC/,� Y�j�LC� Í ·BC2,�– Ï�.f! �ª�fs f_ �&,pJ – >$&/c A�#– u��# – ����T 3

���− T<9�� �B6 Í >&�BC,� 2! U�CJb� >+.�D– �f27 SA�f9 �&,pJ #B%ff9 Ui �Gffje�$!– Qff2�, SA�ff2e� A�# – Sff; – m�E� >ff%$L,�

���� f�− ����T 3

���− N�&!E� N�&!� Í N�&�%,� (�D– ËRB&Gf,� �+f,� U<f; ¸��j�, – [,� .+.� 4/: �&�&� AB/– >&�%,� >$/Ve� .+BCJ –Y�Z7 3

eo&f ���− 8�A�%,� >+� "852Ce� A�@i� 85,*e� �t9� " – O&!tf90 »&�f�,

�#��$,� ���7– >f|+�� TBf�%,� A�# .+BCfJ – Y�Zf7 – >f%$R �f! UB$D�/9� 3

e�f ���− Y�&�B,�7 Í�B,� – �5C,� l$+� �7 O&�� �+,� ¥<C, – ��f2/!�7

Bff�� zff+A Y– .2+�/ff� hffD�.� Qff2,� A�# – N#�$Gff&� – ��{� fff�− ����T 3

��{− T<9�� U�# ! O+a,� Í T<V,� h&;�– �+f,� Pf� ¸��fj�, ���dGff,�−-�.ff%� #�Bff! A��ff7 AB/[ff,� uff&�� , }A�ff� T�Cff!� Î�/9.��, Ëf&LM� �� AB/[,�� – >,�f9.,� >Gf9*� – Y�Zf7 –

m�E� >%$L,�– ���� f�− ����T 3

Page 252: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �� � −

���− Ï.%,� .V5,� Í #B;B,� S:�– f��.,� _ �&,pJ – Y�AB�f2� 1.%,� 1�/V,� #���– ����T 3

���− N�&!E� Y�&��– N�V�� �7 �+,� P�, – N�G:0 AB/[,� u&�� }�$!– A#�] A�# – Y�Z7 –»+A�J <7 3

�����:��p!$q� : �− �� �+,� P� ¥° ! Î�;.�� �+Q,� &G,� >&��: Î�)5f]

ÕBL,� �+,� ZC2, T<V,� +.v !– >f$/V7 >�B5_ >&L� >dGD h+h%,�$! l�e�– SAB2e� >2+e� – �V: -A�! »&�,� >$/V� >!Bµ

– �&2CJ �� " ?��! " ¸5�� (cA n��� 3o �− ¥° f! Î�;.�� �+Q,� >&��: ! "#�ª �&L� »&�,� >&��:

v ! Î�)5]�� �+,� P� ÕBfL,� �+f,� ZCf2, T<fV,� f+.– SAB2e� >2+e� Í h+h%,�$! l�e� >$/V7 >�B5_ >&L� >dGD– >!Bµ

�V: -A�! »&�,� >$/V�– �&2CJ �� " ?��! " – ¸f5�� (fcA n��� 3o

 − #B;B,� S:� Í >,�9A– Î�;.�� �+Q,� &G�, – >f&L� >dGD 9.,� "a� ! �B/y �Bµ �6 >�B5_ �f7� Y�f5,*� Í >,�9A� >,�

ÍBC,� Ï.!– ��+.,� >%��; – >+h[.e� >$/Ve� –Y�RBLde� (Gc 3

�− ��5,� ¥�/5�nË%���,� ��5,� ��.� Í ¥�/5e�o – �+f,� %f9 �&,pJ Î�ª�/5/,� .! �7 #B%G�, �f7 #B%Gf� �f7 _ �7 Ë&y "&5: >/J�

Î�ª�/5/,� .!–8,.7 >$/V� Í >�B5_ >dGD , (cA �� n��{�o3 �− Ï.! �7� >'.J �! Ë$2e� UB�,�– ���dG,� �+,� P�, – >dGD

8,.7 >$/V� Í >�B5_ >&L�– �&D�e� – (cA �� n���� 3o

Page 253: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �� � −

��?!�!� 0�1% b!�!� rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr�L2-�

*���� EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEuuP *J�� KLA� : !/!� �8� G&MN� ���5��� 6���"� EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEuuu

m�E� S.�5,� :+.%/,��+%G,�7 �EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEuuu −m�E� >,pGe� :Î�ª�/5/,� �+,� %G7 �+.%/,�EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEuuQ −>&D�|,� >,pGe� :Î�;.�� �+Q,�7 �+.%/,�EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEuQ�

>&D�|,� S.�5,� :�7 8�?��,� .)��� #B;B,� S:� ��a7 �+.%/,�EEEEEEEEEEQ�� −#B;B,�� S:� ��a� T�Gc� EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEQ�� −��ae� �a� �t9� 333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333�{� −B;B,� S:B7 UB�,� p�2� #333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333�{  −��A�J 333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333�{�

*=���� KLA� :�&��� !/!� �8� Z ���5� [!-�EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEQ�� m�E� S.�5,� : #B;B,� S:� Í �+%G,� ·BCDEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEQ��

−b�� = : #B;B,� S:� Í Î�ª�/5/,� �+,� %9 ·BCD333333333333333333��� −�&D�@ = : #B;B,� S:� Í Î�;.�� �+Q,� ·BCD333333333333333333333���

>&D�|,� S.�5,� :,� ·BCD �D #B;B,� S:� Í �+%G33333333333333333333��� −b�� = :#B;B,� S:� ��a� UB: Î�ª�/5/,� %G,� ·BCD �D333333333���

u+.� O[ >,#�� �Ve�� �;�B,� Í >&��e� ! #B;B,� S#�+ª Í 8��e� ��Ai�   U�E� u+.5,� >,#� n��$,� 8G�� Ï�� �.%�E� �G�� Ï� o333333333333� �

.5,� >,#� �|,� u+n�� >59<5,�8&�<9 o333333333333333333333333333333333��� �,�|,� u+.5,� >,#�n/e� AB)'8�V o3333333333333333333333333333333333333��{

Page 254: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �� � −

8�?��,� S#�5/9�>59<5,� �! ()$�a� #B;B,� S:B733333333333333333333��� �/5/,� %G,� U�L70#B;B,� S:B7 8�?��,� �$�, Î�ª33333333333333333333333���

−�&D�@ = :+Q,� ·BCD �D#B;B,� S:� ��a� UB: Î�;.�� �3333333��� +Q,� &G,� ·BCD �D�/&��: Í t[ �+.F/,� ¥° ! 33333333333333��{

m�E� >,pGe� �D33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333��� >|,�|,�� >&D�|,� >,pGe� �D3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333���

>%7�.,� >,pGe� �D33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333��� >G��M� >,pGe� �D3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333��  >9#�G,� >,pGe� �D3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333��� >%7�G,� >,pGe� �Dn&,##B;B,� S:� ! �+Q,� &G,� Oo33333333333333��� >2��|,� >,pGe� �DnS:B7 #B;B,� S:� �&$�J.j$,� o3333333333333333333�{�{

#B;B,� S:� Í �/,�9A Í t[ �+Q,� &G,� ·BCD �D >,�9.,� Y�!B6B�33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333�{��

"�D� >,�9.�, U�E� �B6Be�nAB2,� �J�.7 #B;B,� �J�.� �&$�J o33333�{�  "�D� Î�|,� �B6Be�n5,� l�G7 &G,� Ub/9� Sf:� f! >&�BCf,�� >59<

#B;B,�o3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333�{�� BC,� 2! #B;B,� �J�.�>&�333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333�{�� "�D� �,�|,� �B6Be�n#B;B,� S:� ��a� ! 8�V/e� ��z!�o333�{�{

Í .�2,� u&���+Q,� &G,� �&�! .�/9� ��33333333333333333333333333333�{�� *K���� KLA� : !/!� �8� ���4� �� #��� � b�D� 67!�EEEEEEEEE����

m�E� S.�5,� : #B;B,� S:� >+.�D �� �Q,� �cB�3333333333333333333�{�{ >&D�|,� S.�5,� :�#B;B,� S:� >+.�D �� O�%,� �cB333333333333333333333�{��

Page 255: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

موقف السعدين من نظرية وحدة الوجود

− �� � −

*�c�d EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE��PO *./ �� EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE��� * ��?!�!� 0�1%EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE��O�

* * *

Page 256: 4˚ ˆ 5 67!ˆ · 2021. 1. 9. · دﻮﺟﻮ˛ا ةﺪﺣو ﺔ ﺮﻈﻧ ﻦﻣ ﻦﻳﺪﻌﺴ˛ا ﻒﻗﻮ! − − Í t)&f$%[ Bfˇ! m0 >˛ 60 , tk ª Í >&ˇ˘%, TBˇ%, Í mBL,

وحدة الوجودموقف السعدين من نظرية

− �� � −