3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat

6
Onepsa} ? Lhík lg phq}ehlslo Mne}es Mne}es tlsn sna nlsj}| jb snjqegc jb |ae} l e hegc( tnlon gjs jgh| eooapsac egc }apaosac phq}ehls| mqs oaham}esac phq}ehls| tlsn bqhh d}egcaq}' Phq}ehls| l }aehls| jb jq} slka egc l gjs jgh| lgcloeslra jb lkpj}segs clkagljg jb sna pjhlsloeh egc joleh }aehls|( mqs ehj lgslsqsljgehlva rehqa egc kj}eh( tnlon s}agdsnag sna eooapsegoa( elklhesljg( sjha}egoa( paeoabqh oja~lsagoa( }apaos bj} nqkeg }ldns( }apaos bj} ojkkqgls| }ldns( ojkklskags bj} clehjdqa egc paeoabqh kasnjc jb ojgbhlos }ajhqsljg egc cagjqgoa cjdkeslk _aklslk( rljhagoa( sa}}j} seoslo aso' Sna qgp}aoacagsac ecregoakags egc d}jtsn lg lgbj}kesljg egc ojkkqgloesljg saongjhjd| tlsn sna }eplc dhjmehlveslj g egc hlma}ehlvesljg }ela sna ojgoa}g bj} erlgd sna clbba}ags oqhsq}a egc s}eclsljg l sna nqkegls| qselgac lgoa ls lgoapsljg lg snal} }apaoslra e}ae' Sna mq } s lg aojgjklo ( bl gego le h( oqh sq}e h( pjh ls lo eh eos lr ls la tl sn sn a s} ag c jb  njkjdaglvesljg ehh jra} sna tj}hc l e ojgoa}g ehh jra} sna tj}hc( sna cakjo}eslo lgslsqsljg gaac phq}ehlslo lgslsqsljg sj s}agdsnag sna rjloa jb taeia} aosljg jb jolas| ehh jra} sna tj}hc' Ls l ekph| cakjgs}esac lg sna nlsj}| jb tj}hc snes e phq}ehlslo s}ec lsljg ag}lo na sna tj} hc oqhsq }a egc s}eclsljg' Mne }esl| e Kqehkeg kqs seia ojdglvegoa jb sna beos snes re}ljq ojkkqglsla lg Mne}es tlsn kqhslpha one} eosa}lslo( hegdqeda ( s}ec lsljg ( kjca jb tj} nlp ( bjjc neml s( kq lo egc cegoa( }lsqeh( l e }aehls|' Sna| nera sj hlra sjdasna} gj pq}pja tlhh ma jhrac sj ahlklgesa snaa ess}lmqsa' Sna| kqs eooaps snes snaa clra}a ess}lmqsa l o}aesljg jb Djc( egc sna| kqs gjs s}| sj ahlklgesa snaa ess}lmqsa lg sna geka jb pq}ls|' Sna}a e}a lgsegoa tna}a lg sna eqsnj}lsla keglbasac snal} esslsqca jb jb jpagga sjte}c jsna} Oqhsq}eh s}eclsljg lg hesa} oagsq}la' Cq}lgd sna }qha jb Emmelc oehlpn eh Kegq}( tnj }qhac lg mastaag 413441( e kjrakags bj} sna s}eghesljg jb sna Onepsa} ? Ojgbhlos jb Ojgsakpj}egals|6 E pa}paoslra m| Caragc}e _ne}ke Ecrjoesa carmne}ctev@njskelh'ojk 

Transcript of 3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat

Page 1: 3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat

 

Onepsa} ?

Lhík lg phq}ehlslo Mne}es

Mne}es tlsn sna nlsj}| jb snjqegc jb |ae} l e hegc( tnlon gjs jgh| eooapsac egc

}apaosac phq}ehls| mqs oaham}esac phq}ehls| tlsn bqhh d}egcaq}' Phq}ehls| l }aehls| jb jq} 

slka egc l gjs jgh| lgcloeslra jb lkpj}segs clkagljg jb sna pjhlsloeh egc joleh

}aehls|( mqs ehj lgslsqsljgehlva rehqa egc kj}eh( tnlon s}agdsnag sna eooapsegoa(

elklhesljg( sjha}egoa( paeoabqh oja~lsagoa( }apaos bj} nqkeg }ldns( }apaos bj} 

ojkkqgls| }ldns( ojkklskags bj} clehjdqa egc paeoabqh kasnjc jb ojgbhlos }ajhqsljg

egc cagjqgoa cjdkeslk _aklslk( rljhagoa( sa}}j} seoslo aso' Sna qgp}aoacagsac

ecregoakags egc d}jtsn lg lgbj}kesljg egc ojkkqgloesljg saongjhjd| tlsn sna }eplc

dhjmehlvesljg egc hlma}ehlvesljg }ela sna ojgoa}g bj} erlgd sna clbba}ags oqhsq}a egc

s}eclsljg l sna nqkegls| qselgac lgoa ls lgoapsljg lg snal} }apaoslra e}ae' Sna

mq}s lg aojgjklo( blgegoleh( oqhsq}eh( pjhlsloeh eoslrlsla tlsn sna s}agc jb 

njkjdaglvesljg ehh jra} sna tj}hc l e ojgoa}g ehh jra} sna tj}hc( sna cakjo}eslo

lgslsqsljg gaac phq}ehlslo lgslsqsljg sj s}agdsnag sna rjloa jb taeia} aosljg jb 

jolas| ehh jra} sna tj}hc' Ls l ekph| cakjgs}esac lg sna nlsj}| jb tj}hc snes e

phq}ehlslo s}eclsljg ag}lona sna tj}hc oqhsq}a egc s}eclsljg' Mne}esl|e Kqehkeg

kqs seia ojdglvegoa jb sna beos snes re}ljq ojkkqglsla lg Mne}es tlsn kqhslpha

one}eosa}lslo( hegdqeda( s}eclsljg( kjca jb tj}nlp( bjjc nemls( kqlo egc

cegoa( }lsqeh( l e }aehls|' Sna| nera sj hlra sjdasna} gj pq}pja tlhh ma jhrac sj

ahlklgesa snaa ess}lmqsa' Sna| kqs eooaps snes snaa clra}a ess}lmqsa l o}aesljg

jb Djc( egc sna| kqs gjs s}| sj ahlklgesa snaa ess}lmqsa lg sna geka jb pq}ls|'

Sna}a e}a lgsegoa tna}a lg sna eqsnj}lsla keglbasac snal} esslsqca jb jb jpagga

sjte}c jsna} Oqhsq}eh s}eclsljg lg hesa} oagsq}la' Cq}lgd sna }qha jb Emmelc oehlpn

eh Kegq}( tnj }qhac lg mastaag 413441( e kjrakags bj} sna s}eghesljg jb sna

Onepsa} ? Ojgbhlos jb Ojgsakpj}egals|6 E pa}paoslra m| Caragc}e

_ne}ke Ecrjoesa carmne}ctev@njskelh'ojk 

Page 2: 3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat

 

olagslblo( pnlhjjpnloeh( kacloeh( hlsa}esq}a( het( es}jhjd|( aso( jb Lgcle D}aaoa( egc

Ad|ps lgsj E}emlo hegdqeda Egc sna gjg+Kqhlk b}jk ehh jra} sna tj}hc ta}a lgrlsac

sj qgca}seia snl sei'

Ls l e daga}eh pa}oapsljg arag tlsnlg sna Kqhlk ojkkqgls|( snes Lhík l sedgegs

}ahldljg' Sna lgolcags( e}jqgc q( egc e }apj}sac lg sna kacle' Ehj agbj}oa snl

pa}oapsljg Mqs snl l gjs s}qa' Lheklo s}eclsljg apaolehh| sna hadeh s}eclsljg(

lgna}agsh| lgohqca kaoneglk( tnlon p}jrlca ekpha peoa egc ojpa sj oj}}ahesa sna

Lheklo snjqdns tlsn sna onegda lg sna joleh oqhsq}eh lkp}jrakags egc

carahjpkags' Sna}a e}a ara}eh kasnjc( e pa} Lheklo s}eclsljg( sj eooaps egc

lgoj}pj}esa sna onegda( tnlon e}a lgsa}tjrag tlsn onegdlgd slka j} ojqgs}|' Sna

stj kasnjcjhjdloeh p}lgolpha bj} sna lgsa}p}asesljg egc a~phegesljg jb Lheklo

s}eclsljg e}a egehjdloeh cacqosljg snes l ul|e( egc ojgagq ekjgd fq}ls egc

onjhe} snes l lfke' Kj}ajra}( sna}a l e }esljgeh egc olagslblo kasnjcjhjdloehh| bj} 

hadeh lggjresljg snes l lfslnec' Lfslnec oeg ma cablgac e eg Lheklo kasnjcjhjd| sj

hadlhesa jg gat lqa jg sna mel jb egehjdloeh cacqosljg egc ojgagq ekjgd

 fq}ls egc onjhe}' Ls l lgsa}aslgd sj gjsa na}a snes sna kqon+kehldgac sa}k9 beste l

gjsnlgd mqs hadeh jplgljg( tnag sna Kqhlk se}sac hlrlgd lg clbba}ags pe}s jb E}em egc

hesa} jg lg clbba}ags pe}s jb tj}hc' Sna gaac te bahs bj} sna epphloesljg jb Lheklo

p}lgolpha lg gata} lsqesljg' Snl l ehj lkpj}segs sj keia gjsa na}a snes sna

 fq}lclosljg jb snaa beste l hlklsac sj sna sa}}lsj}leh fq}lclosljg' Tlsn sna peeda jb 

slka( ara}eh clbba}ags onjjh jb fq}lp}qcagoa aka}dac' Snaa e}a onjjh jb 

 fq}lp}qcagoa ta}a gekac ebsa} aklgags Lheklo fq}ls( lgohqclgd neeg jb me}en(

etvel( eh seme}l( Emq snet}( egc jka jsna}' Kj}ajra}( sna cahlma}esljg }ade}clgd

clbba}ags aos snal} dagal egc snal} lgsa}p}asesljg egc pe}sleh eooapsegoa jb Uq}eg

lg sna hldns jb ojgs}jra}la ehh jra} sna tj}hc qghjoi sna s}agdsn jb ul|e egc lfke'

Ls l ra}| lkpj}segs bj} Mne}esl|e Kqehkeg sj asemhln sna }ahesljg lg snal} Lheklo

Onepsa} ? Ojgbhlos jb Ojgsakpj}egals|6 E pa}paoslra m| Caragc}e

_ne}ke Ecrjoesa carmne}ctev@njskelh'ojk 

Page 3: 3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat

 

mahlab egc qpa}s}qosq}a e}jqgc snak' Sna lkpj}segs pjlgs na}a l sna oja~lsagoa

egc eoojkkjcesljg egc lb pjlmha eoohlkeslvesljg jb clbba}ags lgsa}p}asesljg jb 

Lheklo s}eclsljg egc het tlsn sna qpa}s}qosq}a' _aojgch|( sna eooapsegoa jb hjoeh

p}eosloa( qa( s}eclsljg egc snl}c sjha}egoa egc eoojkkjcesljg jb cagjklgesljgeh

clbba}agoa tlsnlg sna ojkkqgls| egc jqslca sna ojkkqgls|'

Beha pa}oapsljg emjqs cjklgegoa jb e pe}sloqhe} aos egc cag|lgd peoa bj} 

ojgs}qoslra cahlma}esljg sj jsna} nqgc}ac jb aos tlsnlg sna Lheklo tj}hc j}ca} egc

jqslca sna Lheklo tj}hc l gjs jgh| ohjlsa}ac ls mqs clklglnac eooapsegoa jb gjs j

pjpqhe} mqs ra}| abbaoslra sjjh sj }asj}a c|geklk tlsnlg sna Lheklo tj}hc egc ls

lgsa} a }ahesljgnlp tlsn jsna} ojkkqglsla' Sna cahlma}esljg ke| lgohqca olagslblo

}aae}on ehj jg ao}aslra pa}ljc jb lgclslgd jb Uq}eg e sna}a e}a re}ljq snaj}la

bhjes e}jqgc emjqs ls eosqeh lgclslgd egc keglpqhesljg' Arag Lheklo tj}hc oeggjs

}abqsa j} ojgs}eclos a~lsagoa jb clbba}ags aos tlsnlg ls bjhc jka arag onehhagda

sesq jb Kjnekkec e hes kaagda} jb Ehhen'

Sna nlsj}| jb Lheklo s}eclsljg p}jra snes sna clbba}agoa oeg oja~ls tlsnjqs

o}aeslgd ojgbhlos egc nes}ac snjqdn lg klgloqha( oessa}ac egc qpp}aac sj keia ls

gjg+a~lsags' E aklgags Lheklo fq}ls( lmg eh ue||lk e|9$ sna mel jb Lheklo ne}le

l tlcjk egc tahbe}a jb sna pajpha lg snl tj}hc( egc na}aebsa} e ohelkac egc

pjsqhesac' Snl tahbe}a hla lg ojkphasa fqsloa( ka}o|( tahh+malgd( egc tlcjk'

Eg|snlgd snes cape}s b}jk fqsloa sj jpp}aljg( b}jk ka}o| sj ne}nga( b}jk

tahbe}a sj kla}| egc b}jk tlcjk sj bjhh| ne gjsnlgd sj cj tlsn sna ne}le' Ls l

}aehh| qgbj}sqgesa snes sna p}aags lgsahhaosqeh egc }apjglmha pajpha jb eg

pe}sloqhe} Lheklo s}eclsljg tlsnjqs eg| baahlgd jb }akj}a( lgsa}p}as( sna p}lgolpha jb 

ne}le( tnlon haec sj lgojgraglagoa kla}| jpp}aljg' Sna jmfaoslra jb sna

lgsa}p}asesljg njqhc ma sna d}aesa} djjc( egc sna ojgraglagoa jb pajpha lg sna hldns

jb ehlkags jb cakjo}eo| kjca}gls| egc phq}ehlk' Tnlha lgsa}p}aslgd sna _ne}les lg

Onepsa} ? Ojgbhlos jb Ojgsakpj}egals|6 E pa}paoslra m| Caragc}e

_ne}ke Ecrjoesa carmne}ctev@njskelh'ojk 

Page 4: 3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat

 

sna hldns jb ahakags jb cakjo}eo| kjca}gls| egc phq}ehlk ta njqhc gjs cjqms sna

njgas| tlcjk( lgsad}ls|( egc lgoa}ls| jb sna Lheklo }ahldljq haeca} egc jsna} 

lgsahhaosqeh' Sna Lheklo haeca} jb Mne}es kqs epp}aolesa sna onegda ehh jra} sna

tj}hc eooapsac m| sna Kqhlk lgsahhldagsle lg sna lgsa}as jb Mne}esl|e Kqhlk'

Lg }aba}agoa jb phq}ehlk( ls l lkpj}segs sj epph| sna p}lgolpha jb eeml||en ls kaeg

nahplgd jga$ jtg pajpha lg e kegga} snes l kj}ehh| t}jgd egc p}lgolpha jb 

eeml||en l cl}aosh| }ahesac sj sna cjos}lga jb fenlhl||en( egjsna} kaeglgd jb 

eeml||en l nahplgd jga$ ojkkqgls| lg kessa} jb lgfqsloa egc jpp}aljg' Lg jq} 

ojqgs}|( sna joleh ldglbloegoa egc bqgosljg jb eeml||en egc ls pjsagsleh lgbhqagoa

jg pjhlsloeh p}joaa njqhc ma qslhlvac bj} sna massa}kags jb Mne}esl|e Lhík' Sna

gadeslra egc kehbqgosljg lgbhqagoa egc }aqhs jb Kqhlk kagsehls| sj qppj}s snal} 

oj+}ahldljg M}asn}ag tlsnjqs djlgd lgsj e }esljgeh( hjdlo fqs jg sna mel jb }ahldljg

njqhc ma cagjqgoac e pa} sna cjos}lga jb eeml||en' Sna}a l gjsnlgd t}jgd lg

pjlslra ojgoljqga jb mahjgdlgd sj e oqhsq}eh( }ahldljq( hlgdqlslo egc eg| jsna} 

d}jqp' Ls l jga jb sna lkpj}segs lgs}qkags lg carahjplgd egc s}agdsnaglgd

jhlce}ls| egc m}jsna}njjc' Njtara}( eg| gadeslra ojggjsesljg njqhc ma

ojgcakgac9 sna cas}qoslra egc gadeslra rlat jb qon d}jqp njqhc ma }adqhesac

e ls q}ah| ne cas}qoslra lkphloesljg egc ojgauqagoa jg elklhesljg lg joleh

egc pjhlsloeh p}joaa' _joleh egc pjhlsloeh lgslsqsljg nerlgd belsn lg phq}ehlk kqs

eooaps clra}ls| lg Lheklo j}ca} egc nlsj}lols| egc bqgosljgehls| jb qon aos egc

snal} mahlab |sak snjqdn ls ke| ma ecra}e}leh sj oa}selg rljhags aos tnlon e}a

sn}aes sj phq}eh j}ca} jb Mne}esl|e jolas| lg pe}sloqhe} egc kqhsl+pjhe} phq}ehlslo tj}hc

j}ca}' Sna| kqs p}jrlca phesbj}k sj qon aos jb Lheklo j}ca} e sna| e}a qgca} 

d}aes sn}aes b}jk oa}selg rljhags aos tnlon e}a cas}j|lgd snal} oagsq}la jhc

s}eclsljg jkaslka jhca} sneg Lhek qgca} sna }elkags jb pq}lbloesljg' Ta ke| uqjsa

Kates }adljg jb ]efesneg tna}alg |sakeslo egglnlhesljg jb jhc p}eosloa tnlon

Onepsa} ? Ojgbhlos jb Ojgsakpj}egals|6 E pa}paoslra m| Caragc}e

_ne}ke Ecrjoesa carmne}ctev@njskelh'ojk 

Page 5: 3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat

 

p}acesa Lhek( ojgslgqa lg sna geka jb pq}lbloesljg m| semhaadn( fekees egc se}sac

p}joa jb dnassjlesljg snq o}aeslgd ojgbhlos( cls}qs( qploljg egc lgsjha}egoa'

Eoslrlsla jb qon gesq}a qmsegslesac m| ojgslgqjq rljhags s}lia Lheklo d}jqp ehh

jra} sna tj}hc lg ara}| pe}s jb tj}hc clsq}m b}edlha auqlhlm}lqk' Lb L ke| e| j(

phq}ehls| snjqdn kjs lkp}adgemha mqs cqa sj ls lkkaga oepeols| sj eoigjthacda(

qgca}segc egc eooaps clra}a ojgoaps jkaslka eos egc bqgosljg sj cas}j| lsahb'

Sna }jkegslolk jb phq}ehlk ke| dlra beha aga jb eslesljg egc ahb dhj}lbloesljg

mqs snl taeiag ls abbaoslraga sj ahlklgesa lcajhjdla pe}sloqhe}h| klhlse}|

lcajhjdla•''

Onepsa} ? Ojgbhlos jb Ojgsakpj}egals|6 E pa}paoslra m| Caragc}e

_ne}ke Ecrjoesa carmne}ctev@njskelh'ojk 

Page 6: 3.Islam in Pluralist Bharat