7/31/2019 2007 study notes

1/16

Hdgpjc @kui|`d|u?

uebkzi~b|dgkj? `kui|`d|d` pbitfbpu# `dctukigu# bjcctekgjpkigu# lkzj||d

ldbjqkit|' hi|d ejudu kg hjcdu' igudp fdgd|jcc{ kg pddgjfd {dj|u# u~kmd kg

vihdg jp hdgj~jtud'

< p{~du ia u{h~pihu?~iukpkqd u{h~pihu?

j u{h~pih ia uebkzi~b|dgkj dqk`dgp l{ kpu ~|dudged?

`dctukigu# ldckda pbjp ku ecdj|c{ eigp|j`kepi|{ pi |djckp{'

bjcctekgjpkigu "lipb qkutjc jg` jt`kpi|{'''hjkgc{ jt`kpi|{+

pbitfbp `kui|`d|u

Gdfjpkqd u{h~pihu?

j u{h~pih ebj|jepd|kzd` l{ pbd jludgud ia ldbjqkit|u eiguk`d|d` gi|hjc?

uiekjc vkpb`|jvjc

cjem ia jaadep jg` addckgfu ia bj~~{

|d`ted` hipkqjpkig

`i~jhkgd b{~ipbduku ai| uebkzi~b|dgkj?

utffdupu pbjp ~iukpkqd u{h~pihu "~|dudged ia u{h~pihu+ j|d ejtud` l{

iqd|jepkqkp{ ia u{gj~udu ldpvddg `i~jhkgd|fke gdt|igu ia pbd qdgp|jc

pdfhdgpjc j|dj jg` gdt|igu kg pbd gtecdtu jeethldgu jg` jh{`fjcj'

Ebci|~|ihjzkgd "Pbi|jzkgd+(j p{~kejc gdt|icd~pke# j `i~jhkgd |ded~pi| lciemd|' j eihhigc{ ~|due|kld`jgpkuebkzi~b|dgke |tf'

Ecizj~kgd " Eci~kgd+jg JP[^KEJC gdt|icd~pke# jg jgpk~u{ebipke `|tf pbjp lciemu @0 |ded~pi|u kg pbdgtecdtu jeethldgu''''CJUP \DUI\P****

`i~jhkgd pbdi|{ vju ut~~i|pd` l{ `ikgf j upt`{ vkpb jh~bdpu vbd|d pbd`i~jhkgd jhitgp |dcdjud` vju f|djpd| kg uebkzi~b|dgkru vkpb hi|d ~iukpkqdu{h~pihu'

ciuu ia hjuu kg l|jkg'

^iuuklcd ejtudu ia pbd l|jkg jlgi|hjckp{?

D~k`dhkicif{ "upt`{ ia pbd `kup|kltpkig jg` ejtudu ia `kudjudu+

\dudj|eb utffdupu udqd|jc dgqk|ighdgpjc ajepi|u?(udjuig ia lk|pb " li|g `t|kgf cjpd vkgpd| jg` dj|c{ u~|kgf hjmdu t hi|d ckmdc{+(qk|jc d~k`dhkeu(~i~tcjpkig `dgukp{ "hi|d kg ekp{ pbjg eitgp|{+(cjpkpt`d( bkfbd| cjpkpkt`d hi|d ckmdc{'''jg` at|pbd| a|ih pbd dtjpi| hi|d ckmdc{(~|dgjpjc hjcgtp|kpkig( kgect`kgf eigackepkgf lcii` p{~du

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

2/16

LTP PBD LKFFDUP AJEPI\ KU FDGDPKEU*** BD\KPJLKCKP[ PB\ITFB JFDGD*pbd{ bjqd k`dgpkakd` j fdgd pbjp hjmdu {it HI\D UTEED^PKLCD* `idugp hdjgpbjp {it vkcc fdp kp# otup pbjp {it j|d hi|d ckmdc{

Hjoi| jaadepkqd kui|`d|(J ud|kitu hii` `kui|`d|# kgect`du tgk~icj| `d~|duukig jg` lk~icj| `kuui|`d|

(hjoi| `d~|duukqd `kui|`d| "tgk~icj|(j ud|kitu hii` `kui|`d| pbjp eigukupu ia tg|dhkppkgf `d~|duukig ig

~d|ki`u ia `d~|duukig pbjp `i gip jcpd|gjpd vkpb ~d|ki`u ia hjgkj'

(lk~icj| `kui|`d|j ud|kitu hii` `kui|`d| ebj|jepd|kzd` l{ e{eckejc ~d|ki`u ia hjgkj jg`

`d~|duukig'

^U[EBICIFKEJC P\DJPHDGPU IA HJOI\ JAADEPKQD @KUI\@D\U?(P|ke{eckejc jgpk`d~|duujgpu

(j ecjuu ia `|tfu tud` pi p|djp `d~|duukig kgbklkpu pbd |dt~pjmd iagi|d~kd~b|kgd jg` ud|ipigkg gjhd` ai| pbd u~dekake hicdetcj| up|tept|d'

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

3/16

(u~dekake ud|ipigkg |dt~pjmd kgbklkpi "UU\K+(j `|tf pbjp kgbklkpu pbd |dt~pjmd ia ud|ipigkg vkpbitp jaadepkgf pbd

|dt~pjmd ia ipbd| gdt|ip|jguhkppd|u'

(higijhkgd b{~ipbduku?( j b{~ipbduku pbjp upjpdu pbjp `d~|duukig ku ejtud` l{ j civ cdqdc ia jepkqkp{ ia

igd i| hi|d higijhkgd|fke u{gj~udu'

(dqk`dged utffdup pbjp `d~|duukig ejg ld ejtud` l{ higijhkgd jgpjfigkupuuteb ju |dud|~kgd pbjp bju lddg tud` pi p|djp bkfb lcii` ~|duut|d'

ui pbd higijhkgd `dup|i{u pbd gdt|ip|jguhkppd|u ldai|d |dcdjud' kgbklkpkgfhigijhkgd hdjgu hi|d bj~~{ gdt|ip|jguhkppd|u ckmd ud|jpigkg'

\icd ia higijhkgdu?

4(BKJJ(j l|djm`ivg ~|i`tep ia pbd gdt|ip|jguhkppd| ud|ipigkg "4(BP+ `de|djud` EUA

cdqdcu aitg` kg ~jpkdgpu vkpb utkek`jc cdqdcu ia `d~|duukig'

P|~pi~bjg `d~cdpkig ~|ied`t|d?(j ~|ied`t|d kgqicqkgf j civ p|{~pi~bjg `kdp jg` j p|{~pi~bjg a|dd jhkgi jek`eiempjkc pbjp civd|u l|jkg p|{~pi~bjg jg eigudtdgpc{ `de|djudu pbd u{gpbdukuia 4(BP'

^b{ukicifkejc p|djphdgpu?Dcdep|ieigqtcuked pbd|j~{ "DEP+(j l|kd` dcdep|kejc ubiem j~~ckd` pi pbd bdj` pbjp |dtcpu kg jg dcdep|kejc udkzt|dtud` pbd|~dtpkejcc{ pi jccdqkjpd udqd| `d~|duukig'

ckpbkth(j ebdhkejc dcdhdgp# ckpbkth ej|ligjpd ku tud` pi p|djp lk~icj|'

dqk`dged ai| l|jkg jlgi|hjckpkdu kg hjoi| jaadepkqd kui|`d|u'ckmd pbd jh{f`jcj dqk`dged utffdupu pbd i|lkpia|igpjc ei|pdr ku fdgd|jcc{ hi|djepkqjpd` kg `d~|duud` ~jpkdgpu pbjg kg bdjcpb{ utlodepu'uddg pb|itfb ah|k

\ic` ia ek|ej`kjg |b{pbhu?\DH UCDD^ @D^\KQJPKIG( udcdepkqd `d~|kejpkig ia |dh ucdd~ pb|itfb DDF higkpi|kgf' kp ku igd ia pbdhiup daadepkqd jgpk`d~|duujgp p|djphdgpu# utffdupu j eciud |dcjpkigubk~ldpvddg \DH ucdd~ jg` hii`' pjmdu udqd|jc vddmu

Pipjc ucdd~ d~|kqjpkig?pipjc ucdd~ `d~|kqjpkig bju jgpk`d~|duujgp daadepu pbjp j|d khhd`kjpd bivdqd|

pbd ~|ied`t|d ku gip qd|{ ~|jepkejc

uihd kg`kqk`tjcu vkcc gip |du~ig` pi dkpbd| pipjc i| udcdepkqd `d~|kqjpkig'

\ICD IA _DKPFDLD\U?

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

4/16

Udjuigjc jaadepkqd kui|`d| " UJ@+(j hii` `kui|`d| ebj|jepd|kzd` l{ `d~|duukig# cdpbj|f{# ucdd~ `kupt|ljged jg`e|jqkgf ai| ej|lib{`|jpdu `t|kgf pbd vkgpd| higpbu

Uthhd| `d~|duukigj hii` `kui|`d| ebj|jepd|kzd` l{ `d~|duukig ucdd~ `kupt|ljgedu jg` j ciuu ia

j~~dpkpd'

^bipi pbd|j~{( p|djphdgp ia udjuigjc jaadepkqd `kui|`d| l{ `jkc{ dr~iut|d pil|kfbp ckfbp'

88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888

`|tfu?

~u{ebijepkqd jg` ~u{ebip|i~ke j|d pbd ujhd pbkgf( `|tfu pbjp e|iuu pbd lcii`l|jkg lj||kd| jg` jcpd| ldbjqkit|'

dg`ifdgitu edccu( ~|d drkupkgf edccu'

IC@U JG@ HKCGD\( |dkgai|ed` ~cdjut|d edgp|d ia hjhhkckjg l|jkg'

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

5/16

Wubivu pbjp japd| j ed|pjkg ~ikgp pbd jgjcfduke daadep ~djmu jg` pbdg pbd`d~|duukqd daadep eihdu kg " upi~u l|djpbkgf jg` vbjpgip+

jh~bdpu j|d jg jfigkup ai| gjpt|jcc{ ieet|kgf `i~jhkgd

^|kgek~cdu ia ~u{ebi~bj|hjeicif{?Daadepu ia |d~djpd` j`hkgkup|jpkig?(Picd|jged( `de|djud kg daadepkqdgduu ia j `|tf pbjp ku j`hkgkupd|d` |d~djpd`c{'(Udgukpkzjpkig( i~~iukpd ia pbd jliqd'

(Vkpb`|jvjc( pbd j~~dj|jged ia u{h~pihu i~~iukpd pi pbiud ~|i`ted` l{ j`|tf vbdg pbd `|tf ku j`hkgkupd|d` |d~djpd`c{ jg` pbdg ut``dgc{ gi cigfd|pjmdg' ATEMU [IT\ UBKP T^*

(^cjedli( jg kgd|p utlupjged fkqdg pi jg i|fjgkuh kg ckdt ia j ~b{ukicifkejcc{

jepkqd `|tf# tud` dr~d|khdgpjcc{ pi eigp|ic ai| pbd daadepu ia hd|dj`hkgkup|jpkig ia j `|tf'

Ukpdu ia `|tf j``kepkig?(Jgpjfigkup( j `|tf pbjp i~~iudu i| kgbklkpu pbd daadepu ia j ~j|pketcj|gdt|ip|jguhkppd| ig pbd ~iupu{gj~pke edcc' D'F'(^jkgmkccd|

(Jfigkup( j `|tf pbjp ajekckpjpdu pbd daadepu ia j ~j|pketcj| gdt|ip|jguhkppd| igpbd ~iupu{gj~pke edcc' D'F'( Eimd

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

6/16

ubivu biv `i~jhkgd ku u~kmd` `t|kgf gkeipkgd eiguth~pkig( cdj`kgf pi pbdaddckgfu ia j``kepkig'

UTlupjged jltud kui|`d|?

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

7/16

(utlupjged jltud ku ut~d| ud|kitu(pbd utlupjgedu pbjp j|d jltud` upkhtcjpd pbd l|jkg hdebjgkuhu pbjp j|d|du~iguklcd ai| ~iukpkqd |dkgai|edhdgp

Gdfjpkqd |dkgai|edhdgp?pbd |dhiqjc i| |d`tepkig ia jg jqd|ukqd upkhtctu pbjp ku eigpkgfdgp ig j

~j|pketcj| |du~igud vkpb jg jppdg`jgp kge|djud kg pbd a|dtdge{ ia pbjp|du~igud'''''k` `igp `i kp pbdg ubkp bt|pu

~iukpkqd |dkgai|edhdgp?pbd kh~iukpkig i| kge|djud ia j ~cdjujgp upkhtctu pbjp ku eigpkgfdgp ig j~j|pketcj| |du~igud vkpb jg jppdg`jgp kge|djud kg pbd a|dtge{ ia ppbjp|du~igud'''ubkp addcu fii` ka `i'

^jqciqkjg eig`kpkigkgf hj{ dr~cjkg `|tf piccd|jged?jp pbd upj|p uihdigd tudu pbd `|tf# ai| drjh~cd bd|ikg uddu gdd`cd jg` bjudaadepu# pbd|d ku gi eig`kpkigd` |du~igud a|ih uddkgf pbd gdd`cd jg`

`|tf''''ltp cjpd| ig pbd{ ldfkg pi juuiekjpd pbd ukfbp ia pbd gdd`cd jg` pbddaadepu ia pbd `|tf'''pbku hj{ vdjmdg pbd ~b{ukicifkejc daadepu ia pbd `|tf'

Picd|jged? pbd ajep pbjp kge|djukgfc{ cj|fd| iudu ia j `|tf htup ld pjmdg pijebdkgqd j ~j|pketcj| daadep# ejtud` l{ eih~dgujpi|{ hdebjgkuhu pbjp i~~iudpbd daadep ia pbd `|tf'

Vkpb`|jvjc u{h~pihu? pbd J^^DJ\JGED IA U[H^PIHU i~~iukpd pi pbiud~|i`ted` l{ j `|tf vbdg pbd `|tf ku ut``dgc{ gi cigfd| pjmdg'

Vkpb`|jvjc daadepu j|d CJ\FD\ vbdg vkpb`|jvjc bj~~dgu kg pbd ujhd ~cjedpbjp pbd `|tf vju j`hkupd|d` pbjp pbd{ j|d bjqkgf vkpb`|jvjc a|ih'

l|jkg p|kdu pi mdd~ bihdiupjuku' ejgp pdcc pbd `kaad|dged ldpvddg pbd gjpt|jcieet|kgf gdt|iebdhkejcu kg {it| u{updh jg` pbd `|tfu vbkeb hkhke kp' l|jkgpbdg |d`tedu pbd gjpt|jc jhitgpu ieet|kgf jg` kge|djudu pbd |d t~pjmd ukpdu#jg` |d`tedu udgukpkqkp{'E|iuu picid|jged( ka {it fdp piccd|jged kg igd pbdg hkfbp bjqd kg jgipbd|'

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

8/16

hdpbj`igd( `idu pbd ujhd pbkgf ju bd|ikg "lkg`u pi pbd ~iup u{gj~pke |ded~pi|ukpd+ ltp kp `idugp bjqd j hjuukqd daadep jg` kp lkg`u ai| cigfd|'''ui t fdp pbd~b{ukicifkejc daadepu upkcc otup vddgu {it iaa kp'

Gjcp|drigd( tud` pi p|djp jceibic j``kepkig''''|d`ted` pbd ckmdc{bii` ia |dcj~udjfjkgup j ~cjedli'

8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888

cdj|gkgf jg` hdhi|{

P[^DU IA CDJ\GKGF?(gig juuiekjpkqd cdj|gkgf?

( udgukpkzjpkig? d'f' cit` gikud bdj|` giv hi|d udgukpkqd pi cit` gikuduai| ubi|p pkhd'd'f' uhjcc dcdep|ke ubiem pi pbd |jg`ih udj ugjkc''''kpu fkccu ~tcc kg |dacdr'''pbdg~tp j ckppcd odp ia vjpd| igpi pbd pjkc# {it udd j ukhkcj| fkcc |du~igud'''`idu pbku

l{ ajekckpjpkgf ejcekth kig hilkckp{'

(bjlkptjpkig? d'f' ebjgfd ia ckfbp {it gipked up|jkfbp jvj{ ltp japd|ldkgf tud` pi kp {it ejg ptgd kp itp "jg` l|kgf kp kgpi eigekitugduu+d'f' |jg`ih udj uctf ,j~c{ukj, uddu j ckfbp acjub# |dp|jepu kpu fkccu kg |dacdr

|djepkig ltp japd| cipu ia dr~iut|d kp ejg vkpb`|jv kpu fkcc |dacdr' kp `idu pbku l{eigp|icckgf pbd ejcekth kigu |tubkgf kg' iqd| cigf pd|h bjlkptjpkig ejg cdj` piup|tept|jc ebjgfdu# ubivkgf pbjp hdhi|{ ejg bjqd j ~b{ukejc daadep'

(ecjuukejc eig`kpkigkgf?(^jqciqu `ifu' " bd tud` ldccu ltp ujhd ubkp+

j upkhtctu ejg cdjqd uihd ai|h ia |duk`tjc daadep ig j gdt|ig jccivkgf kp pi ldjepkqjpd` ajupd| pbd gdrp pkhd pbd upkhtctu ku ~|dudgp''''^JK\KGF J Eig`kpkigd` Upkhtctu VKPB J Tgeig`kpkgkigd` upkhtctuUP\DGFPBDGU U[GJ^UD(((\DHDHLD\ PBKU*

(kgup|thdgjc eig`kpkigkgf "i~d|jgp eig`kpkigkgf'''LA UMKGGD\+`i~jhkgd ejg jep ju j |dvj|` ai| i~d|jgp "kgup|thdgpjc+ eig`kpkigkgf' pii ckppcd`i~jhkgd kh~j|du akgd hipi| hiqdhdgp7~j|mkguigu'

atem t~ {it| bk~~iejh~tu jg` {it vkcc ciud pbd jlkckp{ pi ai|h gdv cigf pd|h`decj|jpkqd hdhi|kdu'''ltp {it vkcc |dhdhld| {it| ~|ded`t|jc hdhi|{'''uipbd{ ejg cdj|g biv pi `i gdv hiqdhdgpu ltp gip pbd |tcdu ai| pbd fjhd'`|jvkgf kg j hk||i| dqd|{pbkgf ku |dqd|ud`'''~di~cd cdj|g pi j`j~p iqd|pkhd''pbd{ |dpjkg pbdk| cdj|gp eigp|ic jg` hdhi|kdu ai| `ikgf pbd ~|ied`t|d'''''ka{it bj` uihdigd vbi bj` atemd` t~ pbdk| bk~~iejh~tu pbdg pbd{ vitc` `dg{pbjp pbd{ bj` dqd| `igd pbku pjum''''ltp pbd{ vitc` upkcc fdp ldppd| jp kp'ai|fdppkgf cigf pd|h hdhi|kdu ltp |dhdhld|kgf ~|ied`t|jc hdhi|kdu'

(cigf pd|h ~ipdgpkjpkig? CP^( j cigf pd|h kge|djud kg pbd dekpjlkckp{ ia j gdt|ig pi j ~j|pketcj| u{gj~pke

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

9/16

kg~tp ejtud` l{ |d~djpd` bkfb a|dtdge{ jepkqkp{ ia pbjp kg~tp# kge|djud kgjh~j |ded~pi|u''''''`ikgf uihdpbkgf cipu kge|djudu pbd up|dgfpb jg` u~dd` iau{gj~ud

cigf pd|h `d~|duukig( i~~iukpd

udeig` hduudgfd| u{updh ku pbd|d pi hi`ka{ pi u{gj~ud pi hjmd kphi|d |djepkqd'add`ljem u{updh' p{~d ia CP^'

U{gj~pke ebjgfdu pbjp hj{ tg`d|ckd CP^

U{gj~pke ebjgfdu pbjp hj{ tg`d|ckd CP^

WWWW^IUUKLCD ^B[UKEJC EBJGFDU pbjp eihd a|ih CP^''''jcc b{~ipbdpkejc ltpjcc up|dgfpbdg pbd u{gj~ud japd| cigf pd|h ~ipdgpkjpkig'''JCC J\D CIGFCJUPKGF'''~iuuklc{ hjg{ {dj|u'

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

10/16

Vi|mkgf hdhi|{

Vi|mkgf hdhi|{ mdd~u kg hkg` vbjp {it bjqd `igd |dedgpc{Ckmd |dp|kdqkgf aii` a|ih jg jccd{vj{

:' P|jkg j f|it~ ia |jpu pi mgiv vbkeb

j|hu ia pbd hjzd j|d gdqd| ljkpd`

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

11/16

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

12/16

(\DH ucdd~ j~~dj|u pi ~|ihipd l|jkg `dqdci~hdgp jg` cdj|gkgf# ltp biv kphkfbp `i ui ku gip {dp tg`d|upii`'

Atgepkigu ia uciv vjqd ucdd~?(ucdd~ ku j tgkqd|ujc ~bdgihdgig jhkgf qd|pdl|jpdu

(igc{ vj|h lcii`d` qd|pdl|jpdu drbklkp \DH ucdd~'

(ucdd~ j~~dj|u pi ld duudgpkjc pi ut|qkqjc

(igd ed|dl|jc bdhku~bd|d ucdd~u jp j pkhd kg pbd lippcdgiud `ic~bkg'

Daadepu ia ucdd~ d~|kqjpkig?(ucdd~ j~~dj|u pi ld j gdeduukp{ ia ckad'(|dupi|jpkqd daadepu ia ucdd~ j~~dj| pi ld hi|d kh~i|pjgp ai| pbd l|jkg jg` pbd|dup ia pbd li`{'(`d~|kejpkig `idu gip j~~dj| pi kgpd|ad|d vkpb pbd jlkckp{ pi ~d|ai|h ~b{ukejc

drd|ekud(pbd|d ku gi dqk`dged ia j ~b{ukicifkejc up|duu |du~igud pi ucdd~ `d~|kqjpkig'(upt`kdu bjqd |d~i|pd` eifgkpkqd jlkckpkdu jg` hdgpjc pjumu ejg ld jaadepd` l{ucdd~ `d~|kqjpkig(|dudj|eb utffdupu pbjp pbd l|jkg ku |dupkgf `t|kgf uciv vjqd ucdd~(hdgpjc jepkqkp{ `t|kgf pbd `j{ j~~dj|u pi upkhtcjpd kge|djud` uciv vjqd ucdd~jp gkfbp'

LKICIFKEJC ECIEMU(eigp|ic ia udjuigjc |b{pbhu? pbd ~kgdjc fcjg`(pbd ~kgdjc fcjg`? j fcjg` jppjebd` pi pbd `i|ujc pdepthc ~|i`tedu hdcjpigkg

jg` ~cj{u j |icd kg ek|ej`kjg jg` udjuigjc |b{pbhu'

(Ek|ej`kjg |b{pbhu?

(Hdcjpigkg? j bi|higd ude|dpd` `t|kgf pbd gkfbp l{ pbd ~kgdjc li`{= ~cj{u j|icd kg ek|ej`kjg jg` udjuigjc |b{pbhu'

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

13/16

Wubivu biv ckfbp cdqdcu ejg kgactdged ~b{ukicifkejc jepkqkp{ jtpihjpkejcc{vkpbkg pbd li`{'

( drpdg`u a|ih hd`tccj kgpi

ai|dl|jkg# eigp|icu eiguekitugduu

( eigp|kltpdu pi ei|pkejcj|itujc

( |dcdjudu gi|d~kgd~b|kgd# kg|du~igud pi hdjgkgfatc dqdgpu

qkfkcjged

ieet|u `t|kgf \DH ucdd~

Wpbdud pbkgfu vjmd t t~ jg` mdd~ t jucdd~

Gdt|jc eigp|ic ia uciv vjqd ucdd~?

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

14/16

Ljujc ai|dl|jkg)qdgp|icjpd|jc ~|di~pke j|dj "QC^J+Ku j f|it~ ia FJLJd|fke gdt|igu kg pbd ~|di~pke j|dj vbiud jepkqkp{ ut~~|duudujcd|pgduu jg` ldfjqkit|jc j|itujc jg` ~|ihipdu ucdd~'

(`dup|tepkig ia pbku j|dj bju lddg |d~i|pd` pi |dutcp kg pipjc kguihgkj#eihj#jg`

dqdgptjcc{ `djpb kg |jpu'

^FI vjqd?lt|upu ia ~bjuke dcdep|kejc jepkqkp{ i|kfkgjpkgf kg pbd ~igu aiccivd` l{ pbdjepkqkp{ kg pbd cjpd|jc fdgketcjpd gtecdtu jg` qkutjc ei|pdr# j ebj|jepd|kupke ia|dh ucdd~'

Kguihgkj?(|d~i|pd` pi jaadep j~~|iekhjpdc{

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

15/16

Jgihkj? `kaaketcp{ akg`kgf pbd j~~|i~|kjpd vi|` pi `due|kld jg` ilodep'u{h~pih ia j~bjukj'

Vd|gkemdu j~bjukj?kgjlkckp{ pi tg`d|upjg` i| ~|i`ted hdjgkgfatc cjgftjfd# ~|i`tepkig ia vi|`u kg

upkcc kgpjep'

^t|d vi|` `djagduu?pbd jlkckp{ pi bdj`# pi u~djm jg` tutjtcc{ pi |dj` jg` v|kpd vkpbitp ldkgf jlcdpi eih~|dbdg` pbd hdjgkgf ia u~ddeb' ejtud` l{ l|jkg `jhjfd pi pbd|vd|gkemd j|dj i| `ku|t~pkig ia jt`kpi|{ kg~tp pi pbku |dfkig'

P|jguei|pkejc udgui|{ j~bjukj?j u~ddeb `kui|`d| kg vbkeb j ~d|uig bju `kaaketcp{ eih~|dbdg`kgf u~ddeb jg`~|i`tekgf hdjgkgfatc u~igpjgditu u~ddeb ltp ejg |d~djp u~ddeb 'ejtud` l{`jhjfd pi pbd |dfkig ia pbd l|jkg ~iupd|ki| pi vdgkemdu j|dj' pbku ku hj`d~iuuklcd pb|itfb pbd j|etjpd ajueketctu( j eiggdepkig ldpvddg l|ieju jg`

vdgkemdu j|dj pbjp jccivu ~jpkdgpu pi |d~djp vi|`u ltp gip tg`d|upjg` pbdh'

eig`tepkig j~bjukj?jg j~bjukj ebj|epd|kzd` l{ pbd kgjlkckp{ pi |d~djp vi|`u pbjp j|d bdj|` ltp pbdjlkckp{ pi u~djm gi|hjcc{ jg` eih~|dbdg` u~ddeb ia ipbd|u'

8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888

Uejgu?LIPB AH\K JG@ ^DP UEJGU HDJUT\D EBJGFDU KG \DFKIGJC ED\DL\JCLCII@ ACIV' ltp kg `kaad|dgp vj{u'

AH\K(Pbd ~|ied`t|d ku ukhkcj| pi H\K ltp tudu pbd ebjgfd kg hjfgdpkzjpkigldpvddg ir{fdg(|keb jg` ir{fdg(~ii| lcii` ju kpu ljuke hdjut|d'

^DP( tudu uckfbpc{ |j`kjpd` vjpd|' `dpdepu kgpd|jepkigu vkpb l|jkg edccu " fkqd ia~bipiu pbjp j|d `dpdepd`+

8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888

|dj`kgf?jcdrkj( ciuu ia jlkckp{ pi |dj` ltp ejg upkcc v|kpd' ~|i`ted` l{ l|jkg `jhjfd'

7/31/2019 2007 study notes

16/16

@kui|`d|u ia \dj`kgf jg` V|kpkgf

Pivj|` jg tg`d|upjg`kgf ia |dj`kgf

Ut|ajed `{ucdrkj

J |dj`kgf `kui|`d| kg vbkeb j ~d|uig ejg |dj`vi|`u ~bigdpkejcc{ ltp bju `kaaketcp{ |dj`kgfk||dftcj|c{ u~dccd` vi|`u l{ vbicd(vi|` |dj`kgf'

^bigicifkejc `{ucdrkj

J |dj`kgf `kui|`d| kg vbkeb j ~d|uig ejg |dj`

ajhkckj| vi|`u ltp bju `kaaketcp{ |dj`kgftgajhkckj| vi|`u i| ~|igitgedjlcd gigvi|`u'

`k|dep `{ucdrkj? j cjgftjfd `kui|`d| ejtud` l{ l|jkg `jhjfd vbd|d j ~d|uigejg |dj` vi|`u jcit` vkpbitp tg`d|upjg`kgf pbdh'