2 현대 일본사회의 요괴 붐 - s-space.snu.ac.krs-space.snu.ac.kr/bitstream/10371/139593/1/2....

37
박전열(朴銓烈) 중앙대학교 대학원 국문과를 거쳐, 일본 쓰쿠바( 筑波)대학 역사인류학연구과에서 문학박사학위를 취득했다. 한국민속학회 회장, 한국일본역사문화학회 회장을 역임했다. 중앙대학 교 일어일문학과 교수 정년퇴임 후, 현재 명예교수. 한일 민간의 놀이문화, 특히 연극과 다도( )의 현장의 퍼포먼스와 증답물에 관심을 가지고, 여기에 내재된 정신세계에 주목하고 있다. 『각 설이타령 연구』, 『걸립의 구조( 門付けの構造)』, 『봉산탈춤』, 『일본전통문화론』, 『이야기 일본연극 사』, 『남방록의 연구』 등 다수의 논저가 있다. 이 논문은 2008년 정부(교육과학기술부)의 재원으로 한국연구재단의 지원을 받아 연구되었음 ( NRF-2008-362-B00006). 2/ 박전열 무로마치 시대의 백귀야행 두루말이 그림(百鬼夜行絵巻)에는 밤이면 나타나 거리를 누빈다는 많은 종 류의 요괴가 등장한다. 궤짝에 갇힌 여러 요괴를 내려다보는 빨간 몸통의 외발 오니()는 현대사회에서도 빈번히 화제에 오르는 대표적인 요괴다. 중요문화재로 지정되어 교토 다이토쿠지(大徳寺) 신주안(真珠庵) 이 소장하고 있다. 현대 일본사회의 요괴 붐 https://doi.org/10.291514/ILBI.2018.18.068

Transcript of 2 현대 일본사회의 요괴 붐 - s-space.snu.ac.krs-space.snu.ac.kr/bitstream/10371/139593/1/2....

() , ()
. , .
, . , ( ) , .
, (), , ,
, .
2008 ()
(NRF-2008-362-B00006).
2/

()
. ()
. () ()
.
1.
‘’() ,1
‘’ . ‘
’ 2
.
.3
‘’ 1990
< 108 > .
<>
‘’

.

,
(, ) .
,
1 .
15, 148 7 .
‘’ .
.
.
,
.
2 58 . ‘ ’
. 1400 ‘ , , .
() , “ ?”
, . “ () .
” . .
.
3 ‘-: . . :
()’ ‘–: ’ .
,
.
.
,4
,5 ,6
,7 ,8
9
.
, , () , (
), , , ,
.
,
.
‘’
,
()
.
()
,

. ‘ ,
’ , , ‘’ ‘’
4 , , 9, , 1971, 93~114.
5 , , 19, , 1986, 431~476.
6 , , 11, , 1995, 105~130.
7 , : , 56, , 2008, 47~61.
8 , : , 16,
, 2009, 141~163.
9 , , , , 2014, 187~210.
71
. . ,

, , , ,
‘’ ‘’
< 1> .10
, ()
.
,
() .
,
.

.
‘’(
), ‘’(), ‘’() ‘’() ‘
10 , , , 2000, 44.
()

< 1> ·· ()
< 2> () () .
()
() .()

’() 11 .
,
.

,


.
‘ ’
.
2.

.
() ,
.
‘’() .

, .
,
, ‘, , ,
, , ’ .
.
11 ‘’ ‘’(. , )
, . ‘’
.
73
,
() .12
,
.

.

, 1960
, , , ,
. 1960 2018
‘ ’13 .

,
.
(, 1922~2015)
< >() 1968
, 1 .

() .
, .
12 (), ()
(), () (), ()
(), () () .
,
.
13 , , , 2015. 1. 8. https://style.nikkei.com/article/DGXMZO80491910U4A201C1000000(
2017. 12. 20)
74 18
,

. < > 1960

.
,
.

.
, 1980
2 . < >
,
() 14 ()
()
. () (
14 , , , 1987.
< 3> () < 4> < >
75
) () ,
‘’() , () ‘
’ ,
(),

() ,
‘’(),
,
,
.
2 ,
,
.
, ,
.
1987 () ‘
…’15 ,
. 1993 ‘
’ ,
()
.
.16 “
”17 .
15 , , 2, , 2000, 437.
16 1993 () ‘ ’, 2001
‘: (: )’, 2004 ()
‘ ’, 2013 () ‘ ’, 2016 ( ) ‘ - ’.
17 , , –, , 2013, 21.
76 18
‘ – ’18
4000
,
.

.

. ,


,
.
,
.
,
.
() 1988
< >()
.
,
,
.

‘ ’
.
77
3) 3
1990 3 , , ,

.

, , ,
, .19
20 ,
, .
,
.

,
.
.
1997 <>(
) , 1
. ‘’(), ()
() ,
, .
() 21
19 , , , 1998. 20 () () () .
, .
, ,
() .
, .
21 () ‘ - ,
,
78 18
()
, . “
()
, () ,
.
.”22 <
> , ,
,
.
3 2001
< >()
. (),
‘’
, .
,
, ,

. ,
,
.
.

() ’ . , , , , 1982, 510.
22 , , , , 1980, 12.
79
. ()
,
, () , .
() ‘
’23 5 ,
.
5 ,

.
< > :
, , 3 , :
, , :
, : , :
. 5
.
3
,
.
4) 4 IT
2014 IT
. 2014 24 ‘’ ,
(: ) , <>
<> .
2013
23 , , , 2004(1923), 13.
24 () 30 .
, , .
80 18
,

,
,
. 2016
‘’, (: 2
) < >, (: 3 )
‘ ’, < >(
), ‘AI’, ‘PSVR’ . ‘’, ‘
’ .
‘’
, ‘’ .

, 5 ‘
’25 . 2014 ‘’ , , ,
, 4
.
,
25 , ()
. VR(virtual reality)

.
81
.

.
5)
,
.
,
,

.
,
,
.
,
.
8 (, 1716~1745) ‘
() ’ .
.
() . , (
) , , . (
)
. .
()
,
. .
,
82 18
(, 1659~1777)
()
. () ,
() .
().
, ,
. 1715 1753

.
() () ()
.
27 ,

() ”28 .
‘’ .
, .
,
. ,

26 , , 38, 1989, 1.
27 , , , , 1992, 226. ‘’
,
, “ () () .
” .
.
28 , , , , 12.
83
< 6> ()
< 7> ()

‘’
. ,
. ‘’
, . ,

. ‘’
. . ‘’
.
,
.
18
, ,
.
,
29 , , 53, , 2016, 14.
84 18

“ ” ,
. 18
.
, ,
,
.
3.
1)
1 14
, ‘’
.
,
.
A ‘’

. ‘
’() ‘ ’()
‘’() ‘’()
.
.
30 2014 1 2
(, 1928~1989)
, .
‘ ’ ,
.
1) ‘ ’

.


,

.

,

.
.
,
()
.
3) ‘’
. ()
.

.
4) ‘’
.
.

,
< 8> 2017

.
,

.

,
.
,
.
2)
, ,

. ,

.

, ,
31
.
() 32 , ,

.
.
31 , , , , 2003, 99~103.
32 , , , JR
.
87
,
.
,
.
,
.
. 21 ,
.


‘ ’33
.
33 http://www.nichibun.ac.jp/youkaidb/index.html( 2017. 12. 20). () , , , , ,
.
< 9>
88 18

,
.

3 5
. ‘’,
, ‘
, , , , , ,
…’
.34


. , , , ,
, ‘
’ ‘ ’ .
4.
1)
, ‘ ’(
) .

34 , , , , 2009, 269~284.
89
.
, “
.”35
.
‘’() 2013
(3DS)
.
, , , ,
, .
,
, ‘ ’()
.36

.
35 , , , , 2000, 100.
36 !? ?, SPA!, 2014. 7. 23(
).
90 18

, () .
,
() .
‘’
.

.

.
RPG(Role Playing Game)
.
() 5
, ,
. ()
.
,
‘’ .
,
.


.
‘ ’ ,
.

.

91
,

,
. ,
.
2)
‘ 5’ .
‘ ’
.
.
,
, ‘’(quest) .
.
.
, .
.

,
.
‘’() .
.
,
.
.
,

92 18
’() .
‘’
.

. .
‘’() .
.
.

.
,

.
,
,

.

,
.
,
‘ ’
,

. ()
?
93
.
‘ ’
. <>
‘ ’ ‘ ’ ‘ ’
. , ‘
’ ‘ ’ ‘
’ ‘ ’ . ‘
’ .37
‘ ’
. ‘ ’
.
‘ ’(externalization)38 .
, () .
()
‘() , ’
. ,
, ‘
’ .
, .

.
.

.
37 , ?, , 2014, http://credo. asia/2014/12/26/yokai-watch-education/( : 2017. 12. 23).
38 .
, .
.
94 18
.
.
.
,

.
,

.

.
,
, .
,
.
, ,
, ,
.

.
‘ ’
.
95
, () .39
()
.
,
,
40 .
,
,
. ,
‘ ’() .
.
‘’() 41 ()
, ‘’( )
,
.

,
.
.

.”42

39 . “ ( ) , .
,
.”
40 , , , 2011. 41 , .
42 , , , , 2017, 305.
96 18
() ,
. 2001
‘’().
.
, ,
.
,

“ ”43
.
< >
, ‘’
, .

. ,
43 , , , 2006, 188.
< 12> ()
< 13> ()
97

.
, , .
5. : 3
, , , , , ,
.

.
,

.
,
.
“ ”44 .
‘’
, . ,
, , , ,
, .
,
,
. “
.”45
44 , , : , , 2015, 14.
45 , , 53, ,
98 18
, 3
. , ,
.
.
,
.

,
.
,
.
.
,
. ,
(variation) .
(), (), , ()
,
,
. ()
,
, ,
2016, 9.
. ,

.
290 18
, , , 2014.
, , , 2011.
, , , 2004(1923).
, , , 1998.
, , ,
, , , , 2009.
, , 53, 2016.
, , 2, , , 2000.
, , ,
, 2015.
, , , .
, , : , , 2013.
, , , , 2000.
, , , 1999.
, , , , 1992.
, , 38, 1989.
, , 53, 2016.
, , , 2006.
, , , 1987.
: () |
, : , 9, 2006.
, () , , 2017.
, () , 52, 2008.
, , , 2005, 2005.
, , , , 2016.
, , , , , 2012.
, , , 2015.
, , CAMPANA 11, 2004.
, , , 1985.
, , , 2004.
, , , 2004.
|
: 2017. 12. 29 | : 2018. 1. 6 | : 2018. 2. 8
(D. Graeber) 1980
- , 1) ‘ ’
, 2) ‘’ ()
1980
‘’ .
, , 1980
?
-
.
, ,

, 1980
.
1980
‘’
, 90
‘ ’
: , , , , , ,
|
: 2018. 1. 5 | : 2018. 1. 11 | : 2018. 2. 8
, 3 . ,
, .
.
,
.
.
,
.
,
295
.
.
.
,
. ,
. (), (), , ()
.
.
.
() , .
, , .
: , , , ,
: () |
: 2017. 11. 13 | : 2017. 12. 1 | : 2018. 2. 8
1990 .
() () 88 ()
. () 33
() .
(), (),
() () ()
() ()
. ()
, (), () () , ()
() , () , ()
.
, 2004 7 ‘ ’(
)
.
: , , , , ,
: |
: 2017. 12. 4 | : 2017. 12. 12 | : 2018. 2. 8
‘’ , ,
. 1980 2000
. 2009 .
.
, , ,
. , , , , ,
, ,
298 18

CONTEMPORARY JAPANESE SOCIETY AND RELIGION Japan’s 1980s Consumer Society and Girls’ Fetishism: Focusing on Girls’ Original Charms and Transmigration Girls Phenomena | KIM Hyojin On the basis of David Graeber’s discussion on fetishism as ‘social creativity’, I explore the possibility of interpreting Japanese girls’ magico-religious practices during the 1980s as their social creativity to find a way of living in burgeoning consumer society. Also, I analyze how older generation “translated” girls’ fetishism as their own subculture by rereading Otsuka Eiji’s Shjo Minzokugaku (Folklore of Young Girls) and his other works on 80’s girls’ culture, borrowing Sakai Naoki’s concept of translation.
In spite of the religious circumstances of Japan during the 1980s, which are characterized by the dominance of new academism, new age movements and new science, and the development of new-new religions, why did people pay attention to girls’ fetishism as the symbol of religion in 80s’ consumer society? In order to answer this question, I illuminate girls’ magico-religious practices and transmigration girls phenomena in the 1980s by analyzing girls’ occult magazines and girls’ comics specializing in those issues. Original charms and deviations, created by girls themselves, and the idea of transmigration were very popular among girls in the 1980s, and a variety of media, especially magazines and girls’ comics, allowed girls to share their ideas and communicate with each other within girls’ community. While girls’ fetishism had often interpreted in terms of Japanese nationalistic imagination, it should be emphasized that girls’ practices were rather byproducts of their efforts to interpret rapid consumerization of the Japanese society in which every social relationship could be expressed and converged on consumption, such as buying and presenting fancy goods.
Finally, I argue that Otsuka, who tried to read the essence of 1980s’ consumer society through the girls’ subculture and their fetishism as social creativity, was a “translator” who translated girls’ contemporary fetishism into academic discourses on prewar girls’ culture and mainstream society that sexualized girls. In this respect, Otsuka’s work can be evaluated as a creation of “continuity in discontinuity,” which eventually led to fetishism of girls and their sexuality in the 1990s.  • Keywords: fetishism, original charms, Otsuka Eiji, girl’s culture, consumer society,
transmigration girls, translation
Ykai Boom in Contemporary Japanese Society | PARK Jeon Yull Ykai refers to the naming of attributes of sound, phenomenon, fear and mystery that are often difficult to describe. When Ykai () is discussed in Japan, its detailed contents can be
Abstract
299
explained in three levels, Ykai as a phenomenon, as character in a story, and as a moulded and visualized figure.
While people speak about Ykai repeatedly, people will start to recognize Ykai as if they exist as real entities. As a result, Ykai and monster obtain names, and some Ykai even possess unique shapes and personalities, becoming subjects of creative illustrations and stories.
Ykai does not simply remain within the abstract world of stories. It sometimes reappears on ritual performances of festivals, which are designed to demonstrate its past dignity as an object of rites. In addition, it often is painted as characters of drawings or theater plays, or commercialized as toys and accessories. At this moment, Ykai is produced with a fixed image of strong personality, specific name, and concrete figure. Once its fixed image has determined, it maintains its image, but is reproduced into various forms. Traditional Ykai, such as Oni (), Tengu (), Kappa (), Tanuki (), has formed various characters today. In addition, Ykai nowadays is continuously recreated in various ways.
Ykai has become a huge boom as it has engaged with the cultural demand of contemporary Japanese society. Works an Ykai in contemporary society function as an important material for cultural production, and have become a subject of enjoyment and healing. In addition, Ykai has formed into a huge business world, using it as tourism resources and contents for local cultures. • Keywords: Ykai, Shosh Saiyakuki, Ykai watch, externalization
Pilgrimage and the Japanese: Focusing on Kumano Kod | PARK Kyutae  Multiple sacred sites for pilgrimage, such as Shikoku Henr, Saigoku Kannon Pilgrimage, and Seven Lucky Gods Pilgrimage, have widely developed in Japan. The purpose of this essay is to examine historical distinctions and especially religious meanings of Kumano Pilgrimage, which includes not only the so-called Three Grand Shrines of Kumano, consisting of Kumano-hongu-taisha, Kumano-hayatama-taisha, and Kumano-nachi-taisha, but also Seiganto- ji and Fudarakusan-ji. In so doing, I pay close attention to several points as follows: the deep relationship between Kumano and Shugend, passage to Fudaraku, which can be said as a distinctive form of ritual suicide, Yunomine hot spring and the story of Ogurihankan, episodes of Ippen and Izumi Shikibu, Hana-no-iwaya based on the myth of Izanami, the symbol of three-legged crow and so forth. In conclusion, I show that religious motifs as border, purification, death and rebirth were the original core of Kumano Pilgrimage and that nowadays it is newly reproduced by the ways of Spirituality boom or Power Spot boom since the registration of “Sacred Sites and Pilgrimage Routes in the Ki Mountain Range ( )” as UNESCO World Heritage Site in the year of 2004. • Keywords: sacred sites, pilgrimage, Kumano Kod, Three Grand Shrines of Kumano, purifi-
cation, death and rebirth