%©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7...

26
1 ▩Ⓩ㈀⏐ᶊಕ㆜䛱㛭䛟䜑ᅗ㝷Ⓩᨳ➿瘠o槐;濯噪癮瘨 礼籟 こオエエガ 烱 ギ 鏗篤捗鑄閼 7耆 鑢ハ貅崎昨漉WTO 由暘搾滝校埼菜咲o柾菜財 TRIPS 由暘桟掠晒濯砕漉0㊖ 斟濯搾鴫斯紙子埼噪⻀ɔ謳一瘠埼最塞ふⅤ採皿材搾纊圜ɔ鷺僮嵃桟返隸菜漉o槐;濯 噪笹搾疽堠桟a柞菜財腰 TRIPS 由暘昨漉噪岷謳一崎昨鷺災噪敏謳一桟短財三梏ぅ埼菜咲最 漉靖滉募浴放崎昨鷺災札菜参爾試治璽疾施獅叱祉質詞搾イ埼最塞呆熾搾離闕作短桟才最咲最三埼最塞崎漉材傘痛烹搾 GATT 桟単盂埼載三噪⻀ɔ謳一瘠作廬桟薩財皿 載薩搾埼鷺堺咲最三腰砦搾鮫塞鷺 TRIPS 由暘搾磔饌昨漉噪⻀ɔ謳一瘠搾o槐;濯噪噪 敏笹搾⑵)桟a宰三濯崎黻殺咲臍崎催三腰滝赭漉癇闢刷埼燦碕曉ɔ鷺籟老桟莟財鷺最 埼a宰皿傘咲歳財 TRIPS 由暘搾単搾鎬稷噪瘋器暘栽漉yをブ躾坏娉催三最昨門8燐作才犀三åゾ峠ぜ暘坏娉短4作滝暘搾S晒桟採犀三薩搾埼鷺堺咲歳財腰砦搾鮫塞鷺 TRIPS 由暘搾磔饌昨埼歳作兆⎩堀作僮嵃桟舸宰三o槐;濯噪作本夢載三ハP埼菜咲幡歳 塞三砦埼栽惨採堺財腰 本論文の修正に当たっては、久保研介氏および2名の匿名査読者より有益なコメント を多数いただいた。ここに感謝の意を表したい。 綰缺4岫彖斟0㊖斟校譴薤腰

Transcript of %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7...

Page 1: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

1

さ WTO TRIPS

ぞ ふⅤ Ⅴ

TRIPS

Ⅴ ╉

Ⅴ GATT ぞ ㈻

TRIPS ぞ

さ ㈻

TRIPS ぞ ┍

TRIPS

∗ 本論文の修正に当たっては、久保研介氏および2名の匿名査読者より有益なコメントを多数いただいた。ここに感謝の意を表したい。 †

Page 2: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

2

Page 3: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

3

1950

60

″㈹

さ ぜ

ぞ 1995 WTO

み ぞ よ

ぞ 1990

EU FTA

┊ ぜ

ぞ ㎲

┊ ㎲

├ さ

Page 4: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

4

1995 Agreement on Trade-related

Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights TRIPS

General Agreement on Trade in Services: GATS

WTO TRIP GATT/WTO

㈻ ぞ ❻

ぜ 1

ぞ ❻

Agreement on

Trade-Related Investment Measures: TRIM ㎲

TRIPS ”trade-related”

TRIPS ╉ ぞ

1 Stegemann (2000, pp. 157-158) Ⅴ

Page 5: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

5

Agreement on the Application of

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures: SPS

Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade: TBT GATS

TRIPS

㎲ ぞ ㈻ ❻

TRIPS ぞ

さ TRIPS

TRIPS ├

∞ TRIPS

WTO ぞ

ぞ TRIPS

よ さ

1990 ┊ み

ス み

㈻ ┞

Page 6: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

6

WTO ぞ

セ GATT GATS

ぞ ス

WTO ┍ よ

㈻ TRIPS

ぞ ┍ ぞ

㎲ さ

TRIPS

ぞ ス

┊ ㎲

TRIPS ぞ

Page 7: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

7

ふⅤ GATT み

ぞ TRIPS

TRIPS ぞ

I GATT ぞ

GATT ぞ Ⅴ ぞ

GATT

♣ 2

2 社会的厚生関数を一国単位で設定するのかそれとも世界全体で1つのものと考えるのかは、言うまでもなく重要な問題である。伝統的な貿易政策論では一国単位で社会的厚

生を議論する場合が多いが、GATTの下での国際的経済秩序を考察する際には世界全体の社会的厚生関数をベースとすべきであるのかも知れない。いずれの立場をとるにせよ、

政策変更が極端に強い交易条件効果を持たない限り、推奨される政策はほぼ同じとなる。

Page 8: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

8

スゝ

さ ┘ ″

┘ ぞ

ぞ ㎲

┘ ┘

ぞ ㎲

GATT

ス GATT

Page 9: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

9

㎲ GATS

GATS

trade-related

TRIPS ぞ

Trade-related

TRIPS

♣ ㈻

ス ┞

TRIPS

Page 10: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

10

TRIPS

TRIPS ぞ ぞ

GATT み

み み

″ ├ふ

♣ ♣

GATT

Page 11: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

11

GATT

A B

㊪ ㈻

㎲ GATT/WTO ぜ

Page 12: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

12

フ ┘ TBT ┘

GATS ぞ ㈻

ぞ GATS ぞ

TRIPS ╉

┘ Ⅴ

ぞ っ

TRIPS

TRIPS Ⅴ

GATT/WTO ぞ

ぞ ㎲

TRIPS

1883

1884 3 ┍ 11 2000

3 オ 2002

Page 13: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

13

159 ┍

ぞ ┘

TRIPS

┘ TRIPS ぜ

TRIPS

┍ 4

enforcement ぞ

∞ ぞ TRIPS

4 TRIPS よ ┤ 1995 ┤

1996

Page 14: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

14

よ ぞ

TRIPS

TRIPS

ぞ ㎲ モ

WTO ぞ

WTO ぞ よ

┘ ぜ さ

ぞ セ

さ TRIPS 2001

12 さ 24 ス 8

5

TRIPS

5 ┤ 2002 p. 369

Page 15: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

15

ス ㈻

TRIPS ㈻

II TRIPS

TRIPS

TRIPS ぞ ふⅤ

TRIPS

ぞ TRIPS

Page 16: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

16

ぞ ぞ

ス よ

TRIPS

EU

MFN 6

TRIPS ぞ ─

a

b

1971 ぞ c

ぞ d

┍ 7

6 ┤ 1996 523 7 TRIPS 4

Page 17: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

17

c d ㈻ さ

ぜ さ TRIPS ぞ

TRIPS

TRIPS

8 ぞ

TRIPS GATT GATS

ぞ ┍

WTO ┍ WTO よ ソ

WTO ぞ ぞ

8 TRIPS 3 3

Page 18: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

18

┊ ㎲ TRIPS

TRIPS TRIPS Plus

TRIPS Plus ぞ TRIPS

ぞ TRIPS ┊ ㎲

TRIPS

Plus ┊ ㎲ Lippoldt (2002, Table 3)

TRIPS 12 ┘

ぞ 12 ┘ i ii

iii iv v vi

セ vii viii ix

x xi xii

ぞ ス セ

┘ ┍

Page 19: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

19

TRIPS TRIPS

┊ ㎲

FTA ㎲

ぞ ス

FTA9 ┘

16

16.1 ぞ

16.2

16.3

16.4

16.5

16.6

16.7 セ

16.8 ぞ

16.9

9 United States – Singapore Free Trade Agreement (May, 2003).

Page 20: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

20

16.10 ぞ

16.9

TRIPS Plus ぜ

っ さ 10

ぜ TRIPS

TRIPS

┊ ㎲ ㎲

ぞ み

III TRIPS

TRIPS ぞ

10 NGO Vivas-Eugui (2003) FTAA ┊

㎲ ぞ レ

Page 21: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

21

TRIPS

11

TRIPS

12

├ 13

11 TRIPS セ

12 Maskus (1990) McCalman (2001) 13 Maskus and Penubarti (1995) Maskus (1998) Lesser (2001) Smarzynska (2002)

Page 22: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

22

TRIPS

TRIPS

スゝ ㌹

さ ″ ふⅤ

さ ㈻

11

㈻ セ

TRIPS ぞ

TRIPS

Page 23: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

23

TRIPS Plus

TRIPS ッ

ぞ ぞ

WTO TRIPS

ぞ ふⅤ Ⅴ

さ さ

1995 WTO よ

Page 24: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

24

TRIPS ぞ

み WTO

S&D (special and differential treatment) さ

Page 25: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

25

┤ ┐ 1995 WTO ス

┤ 1996 よ WTO

2002 2∟ リ ♣

┤ 2002 2002 ∟ WTO ぜ

Lesser, W. (2001) “The Effects of TRIPS-Mandated Intellectual Property Rights on

Economic Activities in Developing Countries.” WIPO HP (30 Aug, 2001).

Lippoldt, Douglas. (2002) “Intellectual Property Rights.” In Organisation for

Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Regional Trade Agreements

and the Multilateral Trading System, TD/TC(2002)8/FINAL, Paris: OECD.

Maskus, K. (1990) “Normative Concerns in the International Protection of

Intellectual Property Rights.” The World Economy (September): 387-409.

Maskus, K. (1998) “The International Regulation of Intellectual Property”

Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv (Review of World Economics), Band 134, Heft 2:

186-208.

Page 26: %©$Ï2#Ð 1 Fñ6íFßG W7w$Ï 3'¿ぞ H $Æ 3í U WFþFô …...3 b K t ^ # y a$Æ 3í U W b 5 ~ 7 b8I W , ?9Ï Ð) å :6Ï 6Ü J R1950 ³ å 60 ³ å [ b B$ ] ~ W7w) å# > a V ^*

26

Maskus, K. and Penubarti, M. (1995) “How Trade-Related Are Intellectual Property

Rights?” Journal of International Economics 39: 227-248.

McCalman, P. (2001) “Reaping What You Sow: an Empirical Analysis of

International Patent Harmonization.” Journal of International Economics 55:

161-186.

Smarzynska, B. (2002) “The Composition of Foreign Direct Investment and

Protection of Intellectual Property Rights.” The World Bank Development

Research Group Trade (2786, Feb 2002).

Stegemann, Klaus. (2000) “The Integration of Intellectual Property Rights into the

WTO System.” In Peter Lloyd and Chris Milner, eds., The World Economy:

Global Trade Policy 2000, Oxford: Blackwell: 147-177.

Vivas-Eugui, David. (2003) Regional and Bilateral Agreements and a TRIPS-Plus

World: the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA), Geneva: Quaker United

Nations Office (QUNO).