.......................................................1 4 ........................6 12 26 .......................... .

........................

..........36 ..............43 ................................................55 32 6 2009 ..................................57

! LSM1 Bob and Gretchen Pas-santino Elliot Miller """" 2 "!"1. "" "" 1

2.

"" "" "" """"" " Herbert Worldwide Church of God "" 3 Transformed by Truth Ruth Tucker David Neff Azusa Pacific universityFuller "" SeminaryRegent College"" W.Armstrong

! """" Hank Hanegraaff

3

""Elliot Miller

Jesus movement """" """ !""!""! ""4 "" 4.

!"

"!"

"()"""

()"" """"( ) "" Christian Research "" 4 Counterfeits Project

""""""

Institute Spiritual

""5Cult

""6

""

5.

""(cultic) "" 6. Ronald Enroth The Lure of the Cults (Chappaqua NY Christian Herald Books 1979) SalemKirban Satan's Angels Exposed(Huntingdon Valley,PA Salem Kirban,Inc.,1980)Bob LarsonLarson's Book of Cults(Carol Stream,IL Tyndale House Publishers,1983) Jerram Barrs "Freedom and Discipleship (Downers GroveILInter Varsity Press,1983) 5

Watchman Nee Witness Lee 7 "" ""

"" 7.

6

"" 8"" "" 9

10 "" ""11"" 12

"" "" 8. 9. "( )"

http: //www.lordsrecovery.org/history/iv.himl 10. """ ?"(Afirmation and Critique13July 1996)3162 11. "()" http://www.lordsrecovery.org/history/iv.himl 12. ""http: //www.lordsrecovery.org/history/iv.himl 7

Walter Bob and Gretchen Passantino 0range country Register " "Bible Answer Man"" Martin Melodyland

"" "" ""

Thomas Nelson 8

The Jack Christian

Mind

Benders

Sparks

World Liberation Front Jim People's Temple The God-Men Neil TDuddy Schwengeler-Verlag Intervarsity Press Schwengeler-Verlag SchwengelerVerlag "" "" 13 13. 14

Jones

( 2 8) 14 ""

() 14. (1996) 9

15

Harvest House John AnkerbergJohn Weldon The Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions ECNR "" "" ECNR ""ECPA " " CBA " "ECCUCRI Fuller Theological Seminary 16 17

""

"" 15. (1989) 16. (FullertonCADCP Press2008)27-29 17. "Loose Cult Talk"editorialChristianity TodayMarch 200627 (http//www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2006/march/15.27.html)Ken Walker,"Former Local Church Critics Change Stance"CharismaJune 200920 (http//www.charismamag.com/index.php/news/20741-former-local-church-criticschange-stance) 10

18 ECalvin BeisnerJames BjornstadNorman L.Geisler HWayne HouseGordon RLewisRon RhodesJames RWhite

18.

"''" http//www.open-letter.org/pdf/OL_PressRelease.pdf. 11

" '' " " "" '''' 16 '' " 2001 2000 "" 19862002

" 12

" 1997 1997

"(( !" 19961979 " " www.cftfc.com/com_chinese/controversies/reading.asp title_no=2-06&chap_no=2-06-01

" " 2008 2008 41

"" United Pentecostal Church 13

19 20 21

"""""" "" !

"!

It's the EconomyStupid!"""economy""

Bill C1intonJames Carville "!" 19. abuGian"''"("The Teachings of Witness Lee of the'Local Church' (Church of Recovery)"(The Bereans Apologetics Research Ministry) http//www. thebereans. net/arm-wlee. shtml)" ''''"("To All Zealous'Witness Lee Teaching'Followers Regarding the Triune God'Doctrine",Biblocality http//www.telus.net/trbrooks/TeachingofLC3.htm)Calvin Beisner Colin Hansen"'"'("cult Watchers ReconsiderFormer Detractors of Nee and Lee Now Endorse ' Local Churches"Bold Bible Teaching,http://www.boldbibleteaching.net/watchmanneeandwitness.html) (19991998) 14

20. 21.

essential

Trinityontological

Trinity

immanent Trinity economic Trinity 22 23 ""Chronological ""functional "" "'''''' modalist"2422. 23. 24.

"" (19931999) 15

[ ] 25 Chris Wilde" "26 29 32 35 1820 28 2626 45 17 27

""

25. 26.

(1991) 4 ""(Presentation of Some of the teachings of Witness Lee concerning Several Key Doctrinal Issues)()2 27. (19961993) 16

28 7

910 1314 16 "" 18" " 17"[] " " " " " 28. (1990) 60

[" "] [""] 17

Irenaeus TertullianAugustine "" "" " " James D. G. Dunn The Christ and the Spirit,vol.1, Christology [Grand 18 Rapids,MI:W.B.Eerdmans,1998],164-165

W. H. Griffith Thomas The Holy Spirit [Grand Rapids,MI:Kregel,1986; reprint of The Holy Spirit of God,4th ed.MI:W.B.Eerdmans,1913],144, H. B. Swete "" The Holy Spirit in the New Testament, [LondonNew YorkMacmillan1912]30629

"" interpenetration

" " 2329 DCP(2009)18-21 " . " ( http://www.lctestimony.org/StatementOfTeachings.pdf) 19

30 "" "" Robert Govett"" 31 ""distinct ""separate "" American Heritage Dictionary 1""distinct "" 2""separate a.""b."" 32 """" 30. 31. (1999) 220-229 1 (Robett Govett)(The Twofoldness of Divine Truth,Haysville,NC:Schoettle Publishing Company, 2003) 32. Wayne GrudemSystematic Theology:An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine,Grand Rapids:Zondervan Publishing House,1995,248 (Phil Gons)"?" ("Are You a Practical Modalist?''PhilGons.com,Thoughts on Theology and Technology,January 19,2009,http://philgons.com/2008/01/are-you-apractical-modalist/ Rev.James Hastings,M.A.,ed,The Expository Times,vol.7;October 1895-Sptember 1896(Edinburgh:T.and T.Clark,n.d.),153 20

" "33 """" "" " "person ""person 34"'' '' Griffith ThomasThe Principles of Theology'"" '"3533. 34. (19931999) Karl Barth"" Carl FHHenryGod,Revelation ,and Authority Volume5:God Who Stands and Stays Part One (Wheaton,IL:Crossway Books,1982) 184 35. (1985) 21

" United Pentecostal Church 36

"

""one God in three Persons""three Persons in one nature Persons in one nature Phineas DakeJimmy Swaggart Kenneth CopelandBenny Hinn (Yahweh) 37 ""( )38 "" "" "" "" Cornelius Van Til Phil Gons"legalism antinomianism36. 37. 38. 22

"" John Frame "39

"" coinherence

existing within one another "39.

"

23

""" " immanence """"" """ AH strongSystematic Theology [Old Tappan, NJ: Revell, 1960,c1907]332-333 40

" "the entire Godheadthe Triune Godbecame flesh ""

40. DCP(2009)15-17 24

41

41.

25

""" " 1970 91 "''' '" 2008 44 " " 1990 " " "' ' "

26

"" ""New Age Worldwide Church of God " " pseudoChristian ""Word of Faith" "Latter Rain "" ontological economic Trinity Trinity

""Human deification

"" "" "" "" ""

42

, ,43

"" ""deification 44

45 42 . 43 . 44 . 45 . (1990) (1995) 137 (1997) 109 28

46

" " "" """" " "47

""48

46 . 47 .

(1996) 161 (1999) ( 2004) "The Crystallization:Union with the Triune God"Affirmation and 29 Critique1,3(July

48 .

"" ""deification d.373 ""de Incarn. 54.3" " "" " " "" 49

1996), 64 DCP(2009)33-34 49 . 30

"' '" """"

"" Dallas Theological Seminary "" Lewis Sperry Chafer "" " """" " 1 2

31

"" ""

33

50

"" 51 ""

"" "" "" "" "" """ "50. "" 51. ""www. contendingforthefaith. com/responses/booklets/beliefs" " 34

292 2021 1819 10 12 112023 3132 ""energies 52

52 .

Henry ScougalThe Life of God in the Soul of Man(Frearn,Ross-shire,Scotland:ChristianFocus Publications,1996); Ruth Paxson,Life on the Highest Plane(Grand Rabids:Kregal,1996);Mary E.Mcdonough,God's Plan of Redemption(Anaheim,LivingStream Books,1999);T.Austin-Spark,What is Man? (Cloverdale,IN:Ministry of Life,1939) 35

"" " " 18 41999 http://www.recoveryversion.com.tw/Style0A026/FunShow011.php B=40_16_18_0_4.

" " 8 3 1999

http://www.recoveryversion.com.tw/Style0A026/FunShow011.ph pB=66_3_8_0_3. " "

" 36

"2002 435

" !"2001

" "

""

"""" "" " "

""

37

53 Arminians Anabaptists

"" 54 53. 54. ( 15-17 12-13 21-22 ) 38

55 " "

55 .

(2000) 96-97 39

56

"" ""! " "5 ((" "(( "" 79 212 213

56 . 57 .

DC P200939-40 "''"()27 lctestimony.org/LongerResponse.html 40

Classica cessationists Evangelical Theological Society Evangelical Ministries to New Pentecostal

Religions ECPACBA """ """ " " " """"" 41

42

"" 18 "" ""

"" " "

1985Institute for the Study of American ReligionJGordon Melton" "An Open Letter Concerning Witness Lee and43

God-Man

Controversy""Spiritual

Counterfeits Project Witness Lee S. C. PNeil T. Duddy Brooks Alexander I.V.P

44

58

! propositional revelation 59 60 """ """ Leo GSeyranian 61 58 (1985) . 59 . http:// www.contendingforthefaith.com/libel-litigations-god-men/Open60 Ltr/open.html. . http://www.contendingforthefaith.com/libel-litigations/god61 men/decision/completeText.html. . 45

62 ""

" "

"""" 63

62 http://www. apologeticsindex.org/363-spiritual. 63. counterfeits-project ""(Statement of Decision -Lee vDuddyreThe God-Men by Neil Duddy and the SCP)(Alameda)(Leon Seyranian) 283 1 www.Contendingforthefaith.com/libel-litigations/godmen/decision/completeText.html 46

64

ECNR Ankerberg Harvest House

Weldon " " ECNR ECNR CHRISTIAN RESEARCH JOURNAL "" 64 . The New cults(Santa Ana,C AVision House,1980) 47

Oneness Pentecostalism 65 66 " "67 68"" "" " " " " "" Harvest " "69 ECNR"65. (EugeneHarvest House1999) ""(375) 66. 67 (Ken Walker)""(Charisma . (Kunt Van Gorden)"" 68 . 48 69 .

House

" ECNR "" ECNR """"" "" "" """" "" ""

"""""ECNR " 70 " " " "71 70. "" PSL0011-2 71. 49

ECNR " "72"" ECNR

ECNR 72. 50

18

73 Harvest House Harvest " " House

74Eric Christian Literature Crusade Christian HeraldBooks The Lure of the CultsRegal Books Salem Kirban InterVarsity73. 74. Douglas Le Blanc""303(2007)6844(www.equip.org/articles/local-church-wins-somne-allies-among-former-critics) 51

Pement

PressTyndale Press Moody r PressJim Moran Light of Truth Bereans Apologetics Research Ministry Daniel Azuma "" 1 2 3"" ""

4 JPUSA 75 Harvest House

75 .

()""JPUSA 53

Harvest House Harvest HouseHarvest "76 Ilouse

18 7 ""

76 .

"''" 2-323 54

"!" 1 2 3 "" 55

"" Elliot Miller

56

Christian Research InstituteCRI ""guru 19 ""esotericism

57

" " Hank Hanegraaff ""Bible Answer Man www.equip.org.

58