01234 - LWW Journalsjournals.lww.com/anesthesia-analgesia/Documents..., #+,-./ -($)"#.!#/" ,0"#-($...
Transcript of 01234 - LWW Journalsjournals.lww.com/anesthesia-analgesia/Documents..., #+,-./ -($)"#.!#/" ,0"#-($...
!
!"#$%
"
&'(
!"#$$
)
$#
*
!
+,-
!"#!!!
!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234
!!"#$%&# '$()
!
*+
"
,$!-!$%./# !#$"%&
!
*+
!
01+
"
2&&3/43/) 5#-(%$%(
!
*+
"
01%6%77# *3&8$("#$)
!
*+
!
01+
"
9#(&
!
*($%# +#):3&8)
!
*+
"
+(& ;3&<$3%)
!
*+
!
01+
"
9#(& '/<6%#6:%&388%
!
*+
+#7($8#:#&8 -
"
=&#)81!)%# #8 -# >!(&%:(8%3& ?1%$/$<%@(6#
!
=))%)8(&@# 0/A6%./#
!
B
#
7%8(/C -# 0($%)
!
B
#
7%8(6 5%@1(8
!
?6(/-# 5#$&($-
!
0($%)
!
,$(&@#D
./
$
01
$
!!!""#"#$%$%#&&
!
!"## "$ %"&#%'"(#&)##
"
*+,
#
''()*()*+,
"
-.*/01+,
2$%*-3
$
!""4&./0*+,1-52678
!
-)./0 /.0)
"
12
#
9734)
"
:';<=4>*56.!
$
?7
"
8
@A9,BC/0D:;
%
E(
"
FG 12"$ *+, %()*()*+,
&
H<
"
FG!"" 12 *+,
$
23
$
)= 34 I
565J*5" 7 #*KL>+?F*,MNO
"
P?F-'!".Q
!
RS)@1
!
60.0)
!
8/.'0 5&9')0: ;&<)&0"/:
"
685;
#
A 6=')!
!
>)/?)/BJ1TU!"BC
$
/0 12D
"
#"#$' @A*()*V BCCD!E-*1W23 F.#) G/'D). 4XY5Z *+,
"
/07
%*()*()
$
"!".Q[ 12= *+,%()**()!\TU62!\]E^
!
! HC
%
C@
#$
45
$
()* *+,%*()
I = 12._`2!M
!
$ HC
%
3JK
"
! HC
%
CC@B
#"
F=!".Qa_`2!M
!
$ HC
%
LLC
"
! HC
%
CLCM
#"
Gb!".Q= 12H._
I `2!M
!
$ HC
%
3MB
"
! HC
%
CC43
#$
46
$
FG 12*26=$ *+,%*()*()262!
"
FG*!"$$, 12*26
$
!"#$%&'$
$
(!)*+,-./0
#
?3&46%@8%&< $#)/68) 1("# A##& $#73$8#- 3& 81# #44#@8 34 (&C%#8E 3& 81# 7$373436 -3)# $#
!
F ./%$#- 43$ %&-/@%&< 63)) 34 @3&)@%3/)&#))
$
;G?
%
D H1# 1#:3-E&(:%@ #44#@8) 34 (&C%#8E
!
%&@$#()#- 1#($8 $(8#
$
B>
%!
(&-
@($-%(@ 3/87/8 :(E (@@3/&8 43$ 81#)# -%)@$#7(&@%#)D I# 81#$#43$# -#)%<&#- 81%) )8/-E 83 (--$#))
!
4%$)8
!
81# #44#@8 34 7#$%37
!
#$(8%"# B> 3& 7$373436 -3)# $#./%$#- 43$ ;G? (&-
!
)#@3&-
!
81# #44#@8 34 7#$%37#$(8%"# (&C%#8E 3& B>D 1234-05
#
,3$8E
!
4%"# =!= 71E)%@(6 )8(8/) "
&
# 4#:(6# 7(8%#&8) /&-#$<3%&< <E&#@363<%@(6 )/$<#$E J#$# )8/-%#-D =&C%#8E J() ())#))#- %& 81#
37#$(8%&< $33: J%81 81# !8(8#
!
H$(%8 =&C%#8E K&"#&83$E
$
!H=K
% !
)8(8# !7%#6A#$<#$ )@(6#
$
)%8/(8%3&(6 (&C%#8E
%
D =48#$ B> $#
!
@3$-%&<
!
(&#)81#)%( J() %&-/@#- J%81 ( LMM
!
:6N1 OP 7$373436 %&4/)%3& J%81 81# 5()# 0$%:#(
%
7/:7
$
,$#)#&%/)
!
Q%(6
!
5$#R
!
%&)
!
,$(&@#
%
/&8%6 ;G?D H1# 7$373436 -3)# J() $#@3$-#- (8 81# 8%:# 34 ;G?D >#6(8%3&)1%7) A#8J##& !H=K
!
)8(8# (&- B> "#$
!
)/) 7$373436 -3)# (8 ;G? J#$# 8#)8#- J%81 81# !7#($:(& 8#)8 J%81 ( ! "(6/# 34 M
%
MOD ,25.635
#
= )%<&%4%@(&8 $#6(8%3&)1%7
F J() 3A)#$"#- A#8J##& B> (&- 7$373436 -3)# (8;G?
$
$ SM
%
TUV
!
! SM
%
MMOL
%
A/8 &38 A#8J##& !H=K
!
)8(8# (&- 7$373436
W -3)#
$
$ SM
%
XXM
!
! SM
%
MXMY
%
D B3J#"#$
!
( )%<&%4%@(&8 $#6(8%3&)1%7 J() 3A)#$"#- A#8J##&!H=K
!
)8(8# (&- B>
$
$ SM
%
TYL
W (&- ! SM
%
MMZT
%
D )-/)6.57-/5
#
K&@$#()#- 7#$%37#$(8%"# B> %) ())3@%(8#- J%81 %&@$#()#- 7$373436 -3)# $#./%$#- 43$
F ;G?D 0#$%37#$(8%"# (&C%#8E (@@3/&8) 43$ %&@$#()#- B>D
$
"#$%&' "#()* +,-,
"
--,
#
./
&
/0
%
!!!"#"$%&'(#$"
!
!)*%+
"$'!"
!
&,'()-.#*
&
+,/-01
!
"$2!!
!
3.4-.#*'$%/025
$
&'
(!6%12"78'$%9:
%
'
@
!
B
(
!
34;##
!6<5=)#)
'
L
(
&
(>782")"#!!?$%&="67@
$
!"## "$ %"&%'"(#&)##
!
*+,
%
A38&'('/0B
C9:;'()
'
@
!
B
(
!
<!=&>!=!!??@D
AB'()
&
!!EF3'CDEAFGGHCH
$
-)./0 /.0)
!
12
%
EC'?0
'
3
!
J
(
&
IJ-.#*KL
M?@DAB'NO,'G#I *+, A&'(.4
0
'
N
!
@B
(
!
3P$Q#!R-.#*#
!
12 G()&
'(' *+,/0
!
!!G() 12
&
S3$%;J
!
<KT'ULKM&(N=&R#*#'%$OV
M()WX
&
JY
!
$Q!*);Z78
#
[P
!
"# 12(
"$!!!!
!
!"#$%
"
&'(
!"#$$
)
$#
*
!
+,-
!!"#! !"#"#
!
"#
"
$%!$%! $%
#
.
!!
/
&'()& &''( * ) !+!' &''* * & !
"
"
, #+,-./-($)"#.!#/
"
,0"#-($
%*&!$$
"
+',1-%&23.4('
#
$%
01
*(5 0* 1 )2 )
$
343 6)7" 1#)
$
89
/0:1;$!*<,1%=2&'()
#
*+>
/2?
%
&'
"
,@3AB+3,4
"
-95 &0
678"
$
,!$C
$
,(%CB./DCE
"
@
&+FCE'5-BG9.H!$I/1
#
"%
2345
0:!$JK
!
;1#<I
&
4536
'
LM!$!N
O
(
07
)
#
&PQ=>230!!$?RST
"
U5$
%V5
(
0
!
7
"
08
)
#
)@@(% &' 'IA
#
BQ(C124W!.D
"
4!$JK
#
56
&E!)A
% *
2F,GH
+
B
*
27*I
+#
5+
')AX
"
,1JY85Z? 8 'X[8Q'29
%
QKLG
"
@K
"
MN
"
O\
#
:2]^3
"
P6
!$,1=O!$,1!!$JK!N6:_`Q
#
BR(C12-9!B;1<!!$
#
ST5
6
% *
2F,*a
+
B
*
2PQ=bH!c
+#
4E
"
&='UV;[8Q=29
%
WXY@
"
@W
"
A
\
"
B1^@Wd
#
()c#<3Z+(!,6-5 &' 1 *' 6[\
e
"
,6fg1Ihf!$
#
=!$JKN6iC
"
!$;1!6jGk+]^<_^<
#
@(I/l
,`Y 0' 6a=9.H
#
,1m$%n+5>,!4dBo144p5
W
"
JY8.H&@(I/
&
JKq;1
'#
!$J
KIY85;$r
"
st-b%4W-.
#
&%
67458!"9:
$%n+Gu,1st%5C
"
06;$rv
"
> &'9 Hcbwdx,1e;
"
/`.f5m!"
#!?y
#
78Hcyghzi{Z|}!"#y
g~�!��
#
{7$%6/^<.%! 4536 �
�
"
^Z5Qjk901/
&
:;.< $=>>?<
%
"
3<.@;/A
"
BC?/ D<;.<.?
"
EF
'
�/
"
��,1LM_:�ck
$
2 blI@AFmn2qN!;o
#
p,1.H!$JKIv
"
o�"I�=B9k
&
GHGA+I., JI++C K<?GG=<?
"
4:D
'"
�mI�=B9kj
:Y5mLQq6<
"
0=>! 7#o#!C:
#
st-b5 0L ! " #
&
3GA<;M?/?,;
"
%=?.I
!
E;IN;.G+/
"
O<;/,;
'
Z &''NIP- !��f� :;G?
D<.N?;
%
3?yr' !"#
#
!"#��7G9LMD+
st
#
G9D+st!ouP5!"#vw?yv
+ 02 4Zx\123,1!?E
"
yGuF4F�
z
#
r' !"#W
"
5{5w)@�
"
yPG6?7
Z8G�,1!�z
#
p|A1��,1 !"# W
"
5 %=>I++K
%
&
Q?N?C #+NK;/H
"
5?NG?
"
:?I>.=N
'
B
}`H>C
#
|A1f\.J 4536 !��^9:
"
&;B}0: 4,-/.,I?< pc
(
02
)
C��~����W
<3!"#��rIN
&
#?
'
�5M?y3
"
J��
5D2,1!*(
$
<�q�K6�
#
!"#!"
#qIN:.J+!CEr' !"#
"
�V5 %=>I++K
B}��5<3LX
&
-AAK
%
PPRRRS C?N?CS J?
'#
!"#v
"
+!?yMN7 #? <O+!?y
"
()L
�0��F
#
kv
"
� %=>I++KB}LM2P<6<
"
f��
x>C�� !"#
"
�",�o #?q!"#"#
#
'%
;<=>?
��XZX'jIh
&
G6'jdH
'#
>44
q;$r!!$;1qJK
"
I�qB9ki�:
= !"# W!"#B #? :����LM6i�*j
Q?
"
{7 2 'i�l!%j5mQo="#q #?
!i�<
"
0 ! T'
%
'0 J�7T@&<�(�
#
! T
U '
%
'2 i�!j:LxzI2R6<
"
6<V5!P
4A;AV.?R B}
&
434 I/GA.A=A?W ,;<H F#
'#
72��44q;$rXo,!!$JK:
"
2]V52 X.I,+Y+/ Q?
#
5i�*j�7#@=
:�d!=Sqi�<
#
! T'
%
'2 J�7T@&<�
U (�
#
4E&�6<L5 4A;AV.?R B}.H
#
�mE��!<3
"
2]52�<2R! �
"
{7^@^#-P>!!�#Qo^#
#
2]!�
YJTPR¡;$r! $%
&
" 8B�K^#
'
= !"#
U W!"#"#
&
# 8BO�K^#
'
�d@�Y�*
#
U 0: Q=K+/Aq DI=NN?<
(
0)
)
UA! �
"
<3W`Y
3V 4Q ! " ^#
&
I�
'
q # ^#
&
!"#"#
'"
U &�j:P&% &' S,1!()X",
(
6�7
&
(*
'
02
'
#P6q
&
00)
'
&2
'
N>
)"
�¢[8Q= 'q &
£¤�
&
6�7 '
%
'2 q '
%
&'
'"
�o
"
V;��Q=
" q # d¥9!2R*j
#
Z;@;N;
(
0(
)
f�()
"
5
U ¦W2]f\!jE�5��Ih!"#!-b"
#
"
",2i�*j:P>m '
%
8 = '
%
) �d
"
mP
!
!"#$%
"
&'(
!"#$$
)
$#
*
!
+,-
!"%!!!
!!"!"#$%
!
!&'#$"%"()*+
!
%
"
"
"!,##
!
#$ $%-&&'(
#
).'/*
0+1,2-(#$(
$
%
%&
&
"
.
!!
/
$" $%-!132$%
!
!!#4"./)5
6 % &
"
7 % $%-8+*#9:0%;<=>&?
$1@A6
"
0
$!
$" $%-#4"./
B'
#
(
$
#'
#
(" ) $*
'
(! ) &%
$
+C
#
+,
$
%&"
#
%&! ) %&'
'
%"! ) %**
$
2D
#
-.
$
&(
#
"" ) *$
'
$* ) %!!
$
/01
#
-.2,
(
$ (#
%
$
#
%'
%
& ) (&
%
&
'
%*
%
* ) #&
%
*
$
<=E%$1@A #'
#
## ) $(
'
(" ) "&
$
<=E%$13, $(
#
## ) "!
'
($ ) *#
$
<=>$1@A $(#
## ) $'
'
(! ) &3
$
4
<=> 5/6
#
,,7.
$
%(#
#
%%& ) %#&
'
%!! ) %'!
$
<=> 78
#
9:,
$
*3
#
&$ ) 33
'
"% ) %(&
$
$$
F
(
% $%-%;<=>&?$1@A4)G&
"
(!6H+&
-(
#
*I-('+
$
5;<1 = $1@A
!
3,-56
'
5/6 = .,6
'
78 =7J
4
<=E%#$1@A89K/(:0*
#
! = !
%
%$*3 ;L >?@+
!
A BCBD <=
'
4MNOP"( =!
%
3!**
$
>-$16QL3 # ?R
#
% ) " ?R
'
@A
(
!
%
" ) (( ?R
$
#ST
!
1U#<=>1B.#$1
@A-#C'D789
#
6 %
$"
EFG R
!
"#$#
E-+ %!*,.
#
'* ) %(3,.
'
@A
(
*' ) %3# ,.
$!
F
T# GH #+ $
%
3(.2,@
#
$
%
$ ) "
%
#(.2,@
'
@A
(
#
%
"
) &
%
*(.2,@
$"
=V#E%
!
$1@A1 EFG R"#$E-C
'WX$13,1"#$E-C'GD7Y/OP
N
#
6 (
$!
Z,#[\25 GH #
"
;<=>&
!
$1@A1 EFG R"#$E-C
'HD7Y/OPN
#
6 (
$!
Z,#[\25 GH #
"
[\9I
!
077J1 EFG R"#$E-'7]Y
OPN
!
J.,61"#$E-C'3D7]YO
PN
#
6 (
$!
Z,#[\25 GH #
"
$ EFGR<=
>&#$1@A^7J1"#$#E-^ GH #C'
_`a1"%I2
!
077JZE-^ GH #7Y/
OPN
#
"#$E-# ! = !
%
!!%%
!
GH ## ! =
A !
%
!!(%
$#
4 %
$"
<=>&#$1@A17J7]Y#
OPN
!
0$1@A1.,6C'D7OPN
#
4 (
$"
0
"!
; EFGR"#$E-^ GHIK1$1@A
)
$13,
)
7JWX.,6#C'#PLN
"#$E- "#$5M
#
GH
$
=VE%$13, ! =!
%
"'& ! =!
%
33&
$ =!
%
!3 $ =!
%
!((
=VE%$1@A ! =!
%
!#%* ! =!
%
!("%
$ =!
%
#($ $ =!
%
##3
<=>$1@A ! =!
%
!#!& ! =!
%
!(('
$ =!
%
##! $ =!
%
#$*
<=>.,6
#
,,7.
$
! =!
%
$%'% ! =!
%
"$3
$ =!
%
%(( $ =!
%
!'%
<=>7J
#
9:,
$
! =!
%
!!%( ! =!
%
!!!#
$ =!
%
$3* $ =!
%
"$(
$$
F
(
! I!
%
!% b7/(:0*
!!
1
$!
<=>&7J1"#$E-#P"
#
'N
'
$ = !
%
$3*
!
! =!
%
!!%(
$
WX<=>&7J10ON-5M'#P"
#
6N
'
$ =!
%
"$(
!
! =!
%
!!!#
$
F
(
(3%Pc '"
(
#Q7R'
2
!!
3
;!!4)#S-&
!
"!a1"%I2
!
"
#$8FV45# 78 c64dWF< EFG R"#
""!!!!
!
!"#$%
"
&'(
!"#$$
)
$#
*
!
+,-
!!
.
"!
!"#$!!%&"!'"!#()$
!
"%
"
$ !
"
%
#$#
#
! !"
%
%&'(
$
*+!"#$!!%&&'',()$
!
#%
"
$ !"
%
('%
#
! !"
%
""%(
$
-
%
#"!(. )*
(
()$*/
"(+&0 +,%
#
1'-./0,123
&
&
'
(45,6$
-
(
1.45789:;#/<(','$=%&
01>'?(()*@
!
2345,67/80 39:,;
#
<=>
$
A *"
8B2&'"+&3/CDE()$
(
4.
#
+F(45GH5#$!!IJ&'"
+&0 +,%(67
#
8,KL./9(M:
(
+F
N;!"#$(!!%&'',CO-P)$
#
Q
<=RS!!
#
',ST
(
U>?@<V
#
4.1
A)$GBCW#/<.%(45$(XCY
(
!
!.'',0'#D&ER(FGZ)H(
&
(
!
?
'
(
7
I
#
W!"#$[>C;('J#K
#
L'',0
'#D&(FGZ)
&
$
'
(
@,00 23
&
#$
'
9:!!0#
K\](M^NO(/%_*P/1ADQ`KR
(ST
(
4.
#
!!.Ua',ST(b$L.c
O
"
0D
)
&V>.bdBCWVef$W!(c
OLg67',(ST
(
C)Jhaef'X8!
!I&'"+&(67
#
ijN9( & (ef1)C
;;&'(45
&
#
!
&
'
(
-8/89,74 0 A839
&
#
'
(1)9
:
#
!"Y2(!!"!8H.!!%&' <=> %
W (" k '" 8(lm&'"+&C)H
(
7I
#
B.9C23
&
%
'
(1)n!"Y2FG(!!.ZoLA
*[pQ&98H. >DE= &9Yq)(
#
*'Zo
(34-*+k\ar]V^8(lm(&'"+&
Z)
(
Z0(
#
-./0,123
&
&
'
GBCN;s_`,$
!!%&"!*+354-t,W ("FC
*
GC
&
#
*
H
&
#
*+k IJ+ 8> <=> %+k *" 8I45C6-6
7
(
W1uef$
#
+FBCN;`,0!"#(
!!%&"!'+k IJ+ 8(&'"+&> +, %
/C)$
#
4.9:;!!_5.&'"+&(/
967cO
#
'',(STC)
(
>8
#
6ef(
Hav+FH5#$"p+w
#
cAI6xb(7
./01J!"#$','&'"+&()$
#
8
GBCW!kB8C()yQl
(
1.29cdA
3:JzC;7R<{
#
+F@ek(`,'!"
#$!!%&'&'"+&3/ ! %A "
%
"# k
K "
%
"*
(
$;',(67s
#
k+ef'X8(|}
fg_*P/ef$BC;(hi
#
cA!!ID
Q`KR>R'#D&(67_5~O|}�g(
Gf8j=
#
k8��;!!(+&hi
(
W1u
ef$
#
+F�� IJ+ MA'X
#
cA*Wef,
-��678�:YMA'X
&
#%
#
#*
#
#)
'
(
Vs
#
IJ
���l=m01
#
n<v:*./���
#
1I
J|}��C=y(op45
#
4.Z�-:>?
p��
#
v?45@Aq0
(
$;�JRA5
#
'
X0&'"4-t,(��_5g\]r&wh
(
cA IJ+/6s1tg��opq�
#
B*L��
x+&(&'"4�gB�wh(Fx
(
+F��
uvK74-*��wh
(
<5��L.w� <=>
%MA|}fg('X
#
8gxYL�bdCW(
wh
(
�y
#
<=> .*z�8/A &" L (* 1
&
%"
'
Zo
9{�DE7.?C(
#
B* IJ+ 8( <=> %�9
(|}fg_5Ha
#
B*W�yef$ IJ+ 8(
<=> (%|g2m
(
b�
#
<5W -8/89,74 0
A839
&
#
'
' -./0,123
&
&
'
(ef$
#
L.�( <=> %
MA'X
#
1'}L.CW(whC)
(
cA&'
"+&' <=> %3/()$_5H.(�
(
W!k
^~AAwh
#
+Fv:;L.Fwh�k�b(
��
%
:74-&'"
#
G� #* 1q�L� IJ+
(
+F(ef$G�`�D&'"Hg
&
%#
'
*+��
r&'#D&
#
1v?�*q�Y',FG>!!F
G8&'"+&~3FG(A5
(
I+;n
#
+F�
�k1�@�?C. 1�+&(FG'�¡0��
(STC)
(
V<(ef9:
#
DQ`KR%�
#
"
�.'#D&5JS&'"(2E&
&
) M #%
'
#
1.cA
','34=R('#D&3/C5-()$
#
8�
"!#''#D&
(
+F(45¢X
#
Y',FG
#
!
!"#$%
"
&'(
!"#$$
)
$#
*
!
+,-
!"&!!!
!"#!!"#"!"#$%
!
#$&!'""$%%
&
"
$$
#
$
#("!'()*)"+,-.*+&,-.
/!/0!"#01""23123
"
$%
#
$
&'()*+,-45
"
./
#
64*(567"8#
%
-9
%
:7;#<=89!"#$>" #,?@
$
A0%?
@:%;<'=B>?CD
!
@&E
!
FGHIJ
K"L3*A$%B,
$
MC&NGH"O&'6
7
!
PD'QRSTB>??@
"
$0
!
$/
#
"'E:(U
F*VGWHI$>
"
$1
#
"(J,-"
&
$223453*)
'
!
"# #, (K"XYZ:
!
L[#\GHI&N]M
!$89 #,"YZK
$
#(GHO*(N):GH
!
:%D'OJK
,-(J!"^P_"`*:LQ
$
CR
!
abE
S"! " #!"
&
67 8 .9%3:
'
$(K
&
%
%
/
)
1
%
6 (:534
'
T+Ucd"(J!"^,-(K*,V
(-W*^XY%Z[\R&e
$
#]&efM^
791
!
gh(Jij'=B>?"23
%
"<(
U&!'"'_A0,-kK%`RQ)
$
ghFGHIl%e"9D-h'(E"
&
!"
#!"
%
!"#(K
%
"<Vm
%
&E;.)a
'!
&Nben+*/V+
$
&N#o'(c+d06
7)pV+
!
L12#q+3ersmV(t"4
e5167$6"Vh"<0$f"<0
$
,1
!
gui&E$%'($%!"#" !"#!
"
!
Rgui"<$&E;!"#01""$%%&
$
!
!""
$
#
$
$%&
$
'
"
!
()*+ ,-. /
$
0
"
.
!
/
!
'
!
0