0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'...

15
" #$%&'( )&*&') (%)&+%,& ,-#+& .-+ &/' (%)&+%,& -. +/-(' %)0*$( 1#*$ 0-2'+*3 '& *0 "#$%&'%(()* 456 &-7$ -. ,-8'$&+93 '& *03 +,(,&+$&')- ,6*6 $:6 ;<=">?) "#$#%"&%'() * (+,,-#.#%'&- .#./0&%"+. /$ -&1 2% (+,,/0' /$ ./'2/% $/0 (+..&03 4+"5.#%' %6 %$&+-(#,&%-$ -@ ABC >D3 >;;E3 FGH5 ,:IJF GKLM B GKBJH@N :@ (KOK@MB@F5P A:FH:@ O:J )IQQBJC 1IMNQK@F6 (IJH@N FGBF GKBJH@N3 FR: S>T H55IK5 RKJK JBH5KM FGBF RBJJB@F OIJFGKJ UJHKOH@N UC FGK VBJFHK56 .HJ5F3 BLFG:ING FGK ,:QVLBH@F H5 @:F WLKBJ3 VLBH@FHOO5P BFF:J@KC JKVJK5K@FKM MIJH@N FGK GKBJH@N FGBF VLBH@FHOO5 H@FK@MKM F: QBH@FBH@ B OKMKJBL WLBHQ BNBH@5F FGK &:R@ O:J OBHLIJK F: FJBH@ B@M 5IVKJ4H5K6 %@ BMMHFH:@3 MIJH@N FGK GKBJH@N3 VLBH@FHOO5P BFF:J@KC BJNIKM FGBF B OBWFIBL H55IK KXH5FKM B5 F: RGKFGKJ FGK W:BWG OKLF W:KJWKM H@F: W:@5K@FH@N F: FGK 5KBJWG UC FGK WJ:RM :O 5VKWFBF:J56 (KOK@MB@F5 GKJKUC 5IUQHF FGK H@5FB@F )IVVLKQK@FBL AKQ:JB@MIQ BMMJK55H@N U:FG FGK5K H55IK56 %%6 *+Y#A'$& &6 $&2-+0# '/ '0&2% &%" (+,#072(# *LFG:ING VLBH@FHOO M:K5 @:F 5VKWHOHWBLLC MKLH@KBFK B WBI5K :O BWFH:@ O:J OBHLIJK F: FJBH@ B@MZ:J 5IVKJ4H5K3 FGK *QK@MKM ,:QVLBH@F W:@FBH@5 FGK NK@KJBL OBWFIBL BLLKNBFH:@ FGBF FGK &:R@ B@M O:JQKJ ,GHKO -P+:IJ[K OBHLKM F: BMK\IBFKLC FJBH@ :J 5IVKJ4H5K FGK " &GK (KOK@MB@F5 BJK FGK O:IJ ,:4K@FJC 2:LHWK (KVBJFQK@F :OOHWKJ5 RG: JK5V:@MKM F: FGK H@WHMK@F S]K4H@ 26 /BJJH53 ]K4H@ ]K@@KMC3 (B4HM $KL5:@3 B@M )FKVGK@ *6 AHWGBHLHMK5T3 FGK &JKB5IJKJ :O FGK &:R@ S7BJJK@ 7K5FT3 O:JQKJ ,GHKO :O 2:LHWK O:J FGK &:R@ :O ,:4K@FJC3 ^JHB@ -P+:IJ[K B@M WIJJK@F ,GHKO :O 2:LHWK3+:@BLM '6 (B)HL4B6 Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 1 of 15 PageID #: 272

Transcript of 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'...

Page 1: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

#$%&'(!)&*&')!(%)&+%,&!,-#+&!.-+!&/'!(%)&+%,&!-.!+/-('!%)0*$(!

!1#*$!0-2'+*3!!'&!*0!! "#$%&'%(()*!!! 456!!&-7$!-.!,-8'$&+93!'&!*03!! +,(,&+$&')-!!

!!

,6*6!$:6!;<=">?)!!!!

!!

"#$#%"&%'()*!(+,,-#.#%'&-!.#./0&%"+.!/$!-&1!2%!(+,,/0'!/$!./'2/%!$/0!(+..&03!4+"5.#%'!

!%6! %$&+-(#,&%-$!

!! -@!ABC!>D3!>;;E3!FGH5!,:IJF!GKLM!B!GKBJH@N!:@!(KOK@MB@F5P!A:FH:@!O:J!)IQQBJC!

1IMNQK@F6!!(IJH@N!FGBF!GKBJH@N3!FR:!S>T!H55IK5!RKJK!JBH5KM!FGBF!RBJJB@F!OIJFGKJ!UJHKOH@N!

UC!FGK!VBJFHK56!!.HJ5F3!BLFG:ING!FGK!,:QVLBH@F!H5!@:F!WLKBJ3!VLBH@FHOO5P!BFF:J@KC!JKVJK5K@FKM!

MIJH@N!FGK!GKBJH@N!FGBF!VLBH@FHOO5!H@FK@MKM!F:!QBH@FBH@!B!OKMKJBL!WLBHQ!BNBH@5F!FGK!&:R@!

O:J!OBHLIJK!F:!FJBH@!B@M!5IVKJ4H5K6!!%@!BMMHFH:@3!MIJH@N!FGK!GKBJH@N3!VLBH@FHOO5P!BFF:J@KC!

BJNIKM!FGBF!B!OBWFIBL!H55IK!KXH5FKM!B5!F:!RGKFGKJ!FGK!W:BWG!OKLF!W:KJWKM!H@F:!W:@5K@FH@N!F:!

FGK!5KBJWG!UC!FGK!WJ:RM!:O!5VKWFBF:J56!!(KOK@MB@F5!GKJKUC!5IUQHF!FGK!H@5FB@F!

)IVVLKQK@FBL!AKQ:JB@MIQ!BMMJK55H@N!U:FG!FGK5K!H55IK56!!

%%6! *+Y#A'$&!

! &6! $&2-+0#!'/!'0&2%!&%"!(+,#072(#!

*LFG:ING!VLBH@FHOO!M:K5!@:F!5VKWHOHWBLLC!MKLH@KBFK!B!WBI5K!:O!BWFH:@!O:J!OBHLIJK!F:!

FJBH@!B@MZ:J!5IVKJ4H5K3!FGK!*QK@MKM!,:QVLBH@F!W:@FBH@5!FGK!NK@KJBL!OBWFIBL!BLLKNBFH:@!

FGBF!FGK!&:R@!B@M!O:JQKJ!,GHKO!-P+:IJ[K!OBHLKM!F:!BMK\IBFKLC!FJBH@!:J!5IVKJ4H5K!FGK!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"!&GK!(KOK@MB@F5!BJK!FGK!O:IJ!,:4K@FJC!2:LHWK!(KVBJFQK@F!:OOHWKJ5!RG:!JK5V:@MKM!F:!FGK!H@WHMK@F!S]K4H@!26!/BJJH53!]K4H@!]K@@KMC3!(B4HM!$KL5:@3!B@M!)FKVGK@!*6!AHWGBHLHMK5T3!FGK!&JKB5IJKJ!:O!FGK!&:R@!S7BJJK@!7K5FT3!O:JQKJ!,GHKO!:O!2:LHWK!O:J!FGK!&:R@!:O!,:4K@FJC3!^JHB@!-P+:IJ[K!B@M!WIJJK@F!,GHKO!:O!2:LHWK3+:@BLM!'6!(B)HL4B6!!!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 1 of 15 PageID #: 272

Page 2: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

#$%&'(!$))&'(*+!,*(%-.&/(!.$!#*$#(*!0-11(*!&1!23&'3!.$!'$145'.!+(-*'3(+!-14!+(&65*(+78!!

!"#$%#%&'(")*+,$-.&)+/+0/+)1&22&34(56"#$-&789:;&&95*&1:!.3(!;-<!"=>!"??@>!3(-*&1:>!

#%-&1.&))+A!-..$*1(<!*(#*(+(1.(4!.3-.!#%-&1.&))+!2(*(!+((B&1:!.$!0-&1.-&1!-!<($#**!'%-&0!

C-+(4!$1!.3(!-%%(:(4!)-&%5*(!.$!.*-&1!$*!+5#(*/&+(7!!9()(14-1.+!.35+!3(*(C<!0$/(!)$*!.3(!

(1.*<!$)!+500-*<!D54:0(1.!$1!#%-&1.&))+A!)(4(*-%!'%-&0!)$*!)-&%5*(!.$!.*-&1!$*!+5#(*/&+(7!

E3(!F5#*(0(!G$5*.!3-+!&0#$+(4!-!3&:3!C5*4(1!$1!#-*.&(+!+((B&1:!.$!*('$/(*!

-:-&1+.!-!051&'&#-%&.<!$*!+5#(*/&+$*<!#(*+$1-%!)$*!-1!-%%(:(4!)-&%5*(!.$!.*-&1!514(*!=&>?@27!!

H1!)-'.>!&1!',-A&(B&'+$-($&C;&D+//,E>!.3(!I1&.(4!F.-.(+!F5#*(0(!G$5*.!3(%4!.3-.!.3(*(!-*(!

$1%<!,%&0&.(4!'&*'50+.-1'(+!&1!23&'3!-1!-%%(:-.&$1!$)!-!J)-&%5*(!.$!.*-&1A!'-1!C(!.3(!C-+&+!

)$*!%&-C&%&.<!514(*!K!L@MN78!!9@?&F;G;&2H@.&2@H&3>?@?:;&

O)!'$5*+(>!&1!$*4(*!.$!0-&1.-&1!-!'%-&0!-:-&1+.!.3(!E$21!&.+(%)!514(*!=&>?@2.&!.3(!

#%-&1.&))!05+.!4(0$1+.*-.(!&1!.3(!)&*+.!&1+.-1'(!.3-.!&.!2-+!-1!51%-2)5%>!51'$1+.&.5.&$1-%!

#$%&'<>!#*-'.&'(!$*!'5+.$0!.3-.!%(-4!.$!.3(!'$1+.&.5.&$1-%!4(#*&/-.&$17!<($#**&C;&',-A&(B&

I#J&K(/L&4#)-;&(B&G(5;&G#/C,5#E.&92M&F;G;&MN@&3>?H@:7!!!H1!',-A&(B&'+$-($&C;&D+//,E!9@?&

F;G;&2H@.&2@H&3>?@?:.&.3(!F5#*(0(!G$5*.!'%-*&)&(4!.3(!+.-14-*4!-14!3(%4!.3-.!.3(!,#$%&'<8!

*(P5&*(0(1.!%&0&.&1:!051&'&#-%!%&-C&%&.<!&1!=&>?@2!'-+(+!514(*!<($#**!'-1!C(!+-.&+)&(4!&1!

051&'&#-%!,)-&%5*(!.$!.*-&18!'-+(+!$1%<!QLR!23(*(!(0#%$<((+!$)!-!%$'-%!:$/(*10(1.!

'$00&.!-!'$1+.&.5.&$1-%!/&$%-.&$1!Q"R!45(!.$!-!%-'B!$)!.*-&1&1:!C<!051&'&#-%!#$%&'<!0-B(*+!

QNR!23$!-*(!,4(%&C(*-.(%<!&14&))(*(1.8!.$!.3(!1((4!)$*!.3(!.*-&1&1:!-14!SR!&.!2-+!.3&+!%-'B!$)!

.*-&1&1:!.3-.!'-5+(4!.3(!'$1+.&.5.&$1-%!/&$%-.&$17!!

E3&+!+.-14-*4!.35+!)&*+.!*(P5&*(+!-!'$1+.&.5.&$1-%!(/(1.>!,;#;>!-1!514(*%<&1:!

'$1+.&.5.&$1-%!/&$%-.&$1!.3-.!.3(!)-&%5*(!.$!.*-&1!'-5+(+7!!T-4!)-'.+!$*!-!+&1:%(!$5.*-:($5+!

(/(1.!&+!&1+5))&'&(1.7!!!F$0(!B&14!$)!2*$1:!$)!'$1+.&.5.&$1-%!4&0(1+&$1!05+.!C(!#*(+(1.7!!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 2 of 15 PageID #: 273

Page 3: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!

)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

8/,';1;'<+,-,':110=,!%&'!7.1/%!$''4!$.%!/'*+&!%&'!())1'!.0!8&'%&'/!*!+.$)%(%1%(.$*2!

9(.2*%(.$!.++1//'4!($!./4'/!%.!0($4!%&*%!%&'!.00(+'/)!*/'!'$%(%2'4!%.!:1*2(0('4!(--1$(%3;!!#0!

%&'!7.1/%!8'/'!%.!$'9'/%&'2'))!/'*+&!%&()!())1'!*$4!4'+(4'!%&*%!%&'!1$4()<1%'4!0*+%)!0*(2'4!

%.!)1<<./%!*!0($4($5!.0!*!+.$)%(%1%(.$*2!9(.2*%(.$,!<2*($%(00)=!>!?@A"!+2*(-!*5*($)%!%&'!

-1$(+(<*2(%3!*$4!7&('0!8(22!2(B'8()'!0*(2;!!8>/?'"@'A"6'B#C$%$6'7,'D$%%$5&'(EF'+,-,'E0*&'

E00'<30;*=!<GH@'.'I$56"#'9.6'6J@@$5$K'#"'L"#6/>/J/>"#.%'>#MJ5?'./'/9$'9.#K6'"@'/9$'

>#K>7>KJ.%'I"%>L$'"@@>L$5&'/9$'@.L/'/9./'/9$'K$I.5/N$#/.%'5$CJ%./>"#6'N>C9/'9.7$'.J/9"5>O$K'

/9$'J6$'"@'L"#6/>/J/>"#.%%?'$PL$66>7$'@"5L$'>6'QJ>/$'R$6>K$'/9$'I">#/S=T'U7.#6'7,'B7$5?&'311'

V,)K'31))&'31)02(1'<36/'8>5,'300*=<W9$5$'>#K>7>KJ.%'"@@>L$56'K>K'7>"%./$'I%.>#/>@@X6'

L"#6/>/J/>"#.%'5>C9/6'>#'/9$'L"J56$'"@'.'9>C9'6I$$K'IJ56J>/&'/9$'8>/?'%>Y$W>6$'L"J%K'#"/'R$'

9$%K'%>.R%$'@"5'/9$'.%%$C$K'@.>%J5$'/"'N"#>/"5'I"%>L$'IJ56J>/6'.#K'/95"JC9'>/6'@.>%J5$'/"'

6JI$57>6$'I"%>L$'"@@>L$56'>#7"%7$K'>#'6JL9'IJ56J>/6=,!''

! C9'$!*++'<%($5,!.5CJ$#K",!%&'!</'-()'!%&*%!%&'!.00(+'/)=!*+%(.$)!*-.1$%'4!%.!*!

+.$)%(%1%(.$*2!4'</(9*%(.$!D'+*1)'!%&'!7.*+&!+.124!$.%!+.$)'$%!.$!D'&*20!.0!%&'!<2*($%(00)!

*$4E./!%&*%!%&'!<.2(+'!2*+B'4!</.D*D2'!+*1)'!%.!)'*/+&,!($!./4'/!%.!)1++''4!.$!%&'(/!0*(21/'!

%.!%/*($!+2*(-,!<2*($%(00)!-1)%!4'-.$)%/*%'!%&*%!%&'!F.8$!*$4!7&('0!8'/'!4'2(D'/*%'23!

($4(00'/'$%!($!%&'!0*(21/'!%.!%/*($!%&'!.00(+'/);!!#$!8>/?'"@'8.#/"#&'(;0'+,-,')E;&');E'

<30;0=&'%&'!<2*($%(00!&*4!*22'5'4!%&*%!41'!%.!%&'!($*4':1*+3!.0!<.2(+'!%/*($($5,!%&'!7(%3!.0!

7*$%.$!*$4!(%)!.00(+(*2)!9(.2*%'4!<2*($%(00=)!+.$)%(%1%(.$*2!/(5&%!%.!/'+'(9'!-'4(+*2!

*%%'$%(.$!8&(2'!($!<.2(+'!+1)%.43;!HK,'./');:;!G0%'/!%&'!61/3!/12'4!($!%&'!<2*($%(00=)!0*9./,!

%&'!+(%3!-*4'!*!-.%(.$!0./!6145-'$%!$.%8(%&)%*$4($5!%&'!9'/4(+%,!+2*(-($5!%&*%!*!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 3 of 15 PageID #: 274

Page 4: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

#$%&'&()*&+,!')%!-%*,!./!0-$%1!*&).*/!$%1/2!3!4567!89/2/!+9/!(-*&',!&%!(*)'/!&:!&+:/*0!

$%'-%:+&+$+&-%)*;!<%!2/=/'+&%>!+9/!'&+,?:!%)22-8!&%+/2(2/+)+&-%!-0!3!4567@!+9/!!"#$%#!'-$2+!

/:+).*&:9/1!+9/!0-**-8&%>!:+)%1)21!0-2!/A)*$)+&%>!A)*&1!(-*&'&/:!)**/>/1!+-!9)A/!.//%!

$%'-%:+&+$+&-%)**,!)((*&/1B!!

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

(-*&',!-0!&%)1/D$)+/!+2)&%&%>@!89/2/!I+9/!%//1!0-2!#-2/!-2!1&00/2/%+!+2)&%&%>!&:!:-!

-.A&-$:@!)%1!+9/!&%)1/D$)',!:-!*&J/*,!+-!2/:$*+!&%!+9/!A&-*)+&-%!-0!'-%:+&+$+&-%)*!2&>9+:@!

+9)+!+9/!(-*&',#)J/2:!-0!+9/!'&+,!')%!2/):-%).*,!./!:)&1!+-!9)A/!.//%!1/*&./2)+/*,!

&%1&00/2/%+!+-!+9/!%//1;K!!/&0,"$,14;;!!H*)&%+&00:!#$:+!)*:-!1/#-%:+2)+/!+9)+!)!#$%&'&()*&+,!

&'()*'+"$'(<!'9-:/!)%!&%)1/D$)+/!+2)&%&%>!(2->2)#;!/&0,"$,124;!!!

C9/!I1/*&./2)+/!&%1&00/2/%'/K!:+)%1)21!9):!.//%!.2-J/%!1-8%!&%+-!+92//!/*/#/%+:B!!!

L4M!+9)+!)!(-*&',#)J/2!-0!+9/!#$%&'&()*&+,!J%-8:!+-!)!#-2)*!'/2+)&%+,!+9)+!&+:!/#(*-,//:!8&**!'-%02-%+!)!>&A/%!:&+$)+&-%N!!!LOM!+9)+!+9/!:&+$)+&-%!/&+9/2!(2/:/%+:!+9/!/#(*-,//!8&+9!)!1&00&'$*+!'9-&'/!-0!+9/!:-2+!+9)+!+2)&%&%>!-2!:$(/2A&:&-%!8&**!#)J/!*/::!1&00&'$*+!-2!+9)+!+9/2/!&:!)!9&:+-2,!-0!/#(*-,//:!#&:9)%1*&%>!+9/!:&+$)+&-%N!)%1!!!L7M!+9)+!+9/!82-%>!'9-&'/!.,!+9/!/#(*-,//!8&**!02/D$/%+*,!')$:/!+9/!1/(2&A)+&-%!-0!)!'&+&P/%?:!'-%:+&+$+&-%)*!2&>9+:;!!!

=6)$8,>0,?%@#,%-,A0,B">'#C,D;;E,F0=0,G)9$0,HAI/=,JEJJ,5G0,!%##0,D;;E:,.)$)#K,

L).8%(9%#,>0,=.%77'$$"C,1JJ,M01&,NEJC,NOO,5D&,!)+0,D;;1:,5.)$"$)%#9,%6)$$'&:0,,

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 4 of 15 PageID #: 275

Page 5: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

#$%&'()!*(+!&,-./(0!-1!23'4/-5&!,*36!*3/&/(0!13-6!),/&!)3*/(/(0!2-7/8+9!-3!*(+!

'4/:'(8'!-1!:'7/%'3*)/-(!-(!),'!;:'1'(:*()&<=!2*3)9!27*/()/11!1*/7&!)-!:'6-(&)3*)'!*(!/&&5'!

-1!6*)'3/*7!1*8)!*&!)-!.,'),'3!),'!>'1'(:*()&!*8)5*77+!8,-&'!*!2-7/8+!./),!:'7/%'3*)'!

/(:/11'3'(8'!)-.*3:?!8-(&)/)5)/-(*7!3/0,)&!-1!/(:/4/:5*7&@!!!"#$"%&'(")*"+$",)-'./012"345"6$"

+788$"91"9:42"9:5";<$"=>$"944?@$!!

A(!),/&!&2'8/1/8!8-()'B)9!*!&,-./(0!-1!:'7/%'3*)'!/(:/11'3'(8'!0'('3*77+!3'C5/3'&!D*!&,-./(0!E-1!6-3'!),*(!*!&/(07'!/(&)*(8'!-1!),'!7*8F!-1!)3*/(/(0!-3!&52'34/&/-(!8*5&/(0!*!4/-7*)/-(!-1!8-(&)/)5)/-(*7!3/0,)&@ED!D;$=!27*/()/11!;65&)=!:'6-(&)3*)'!E*)!7'*&)!*!2*))'3(!-1!&/6/7*3!4/-7*)/-(&ED!*3/&/(0!13-6!)3*/(/(0!-3!&52'34/&/(0!D),*)!/&!&-!87'*37+!/(*:'C5*)'!*&!)-!%'!E-%4/-5&7+!7/F'7+!)-!3'&57)!/(!*!8-(&)/)5)/-(*7!4/-7*)/-(@ED!$!7/6/)':!'B8'2)/-(!1-3!&/(07'G/(8/:'()!7/*%/7/)+!'B/&)&!-(7+!D.,'3'!),'!1*8)&!0/4/(0!3/&'!)-!),'!4/-7*)/-(!*3'!&58,!),*)!/)!&,-57:!,*4'!%''(!*22*3'()!)-!),'!2-7/8+6*F'3!),*)!*!8-(&)/)5)/-(*7!4/-7*)/-(!.*&!),'!,/0,7+!23':/8)*%7'!8-(&'C5'(8'!-1!*!2*3)/857*3!2-7/8+!-3!1*/753'!)-!)3*/(@D!!

A-7B*&>.1"#$"C)..&0D2"EEF"6$G1"G992"G9:";E'H"%&-$"=&DD$"944I@";J&'/'&)0D")B&''>1@$!!! A(!),/&!8*&'9!:'1'(:*()&!&5%6/)!),*)!),'!5(:/&25)':!1*8)&!1*/7!)-!&522-3)!*!1/(:/(0!

-1!:'7/%'3*)'!/(:/11'3'(8'@!!A(!2*3)/857*39!),'3'!/&!(-!%*&/&!)-!&522-3)!),'!8-(875&/-(!/(!),'!

1/3&)!/(&)*(8'!),*)!*(+!,*36!,*:!3'&57)':!/(!),'!2*&)!13-6!),/&!*77'0':!:'1/8/'()!)3*/(/(0!-3!

#E*)!7'*&)!*!2*))'3(!-1!&/6/7*3!4/-7*)/-(&ED!*3/&/(0!13-6!)3*/(/(0!-3!&52'34/&/(0!D),*)!/&!&-!

87'*37+!/(*:'C5*)'!*&!)-!%'!E-%4/-5&7+!7/F'7+!)-!3'&57)!/(!*!8-(&)/)5)/-(*7!4/-7*)/-(@ED!!

A-7B*&>.12"EEF"6$G1"/'"G9:$"$%&'()!&58,!*77'0':!23/-3!,*36!-3!'4'(!*(!*77'0*)/-(!-1!&58,!

,*369!27*/()/11!8*((-)!6'')!/)&!%53:'(!-1!&,-./(0!),*)!),'!:'1'(:*()&!#*8)5*77+!8,-&'!*!

2-7/8+!./),!:'7/%'3*)'!/(:/11'3'(8'!)-.*3:!),'!8-(&)/)5)/-(*7!3/0,)&!-1!/(:/4/:5*7&@?!!!"#$"

%&'(")*"+$",)-'./012"345"6$"+788$"91"/'"9:5$!!

! H,'!I7'4'(),!J/385/)!,*&!*::3'&&':!*!&/6/7*3!87*/6!3'0*3:/(0!),'!('':!1-3!

*::/)/-(*7!)3*/(/(0!/(!),'!8-()'B)!-1!2-7/8'!-11/8'3&!/()'3*8)/-(!./),!&)5:'()&!*(:!

8-(875:':!#),*)!),'!('':!1-3!)3*/(/(0!3'0*3:/(0!),'!:')'()/-(!-1!&)5:'()&!&2'8/1/8*77+!/&!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 5 of 15 PageID #: 276

Page 6: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

#$%!$&'($)*!(#!%+,!-&*%.-/%!-#0!%+-%!-!1-/2!$3!*)/+!%.-(#(#4!(*!-!56$**(&1,!(76,.3,/%($#85!

&)%!#$%!-!541-.(#4!$7(**($#5!3.$7!-!%.-(#(#4!.,4(7,#9:!!"#$%&'%()*+,-.%/01%2'34%5670.%

5387%955+:%;,"'%<=#'%688>?'!!;#!%+-%!/-*,8!%+,!<6,/(-1!=,*$)./,!$33(/,.!-%!-!7(001,!*/+$$1!

%$$2!-!*%)0,#%!>+$!+-0!%+.,-%,#,0!%$!+(%!-!%,-/+,.!(#%$!%+,!+-11>-?!-#0!61-/,0!+-#0/)33*!

$#!+,.!%$!0,7$#*%.-%,!>+-%!(%!3,1%!1(2,!%$!4,%!-..,*%,09!!;#!-00.,**(#4!%+,!3-(1).,!%$!%.-(#!

-#0!*)6,.'(*,!/1-(7!-4-(#*%!%+,!<=@A*!*)6,.($.8!%+,!B$).%!#$%,0!%+-%!%+,!<=@!+-0!

.,/,(',0!%.-(#(#48!-%!&$%+!%+,!6$1(/,!-/-0,7?!-#0!%+,!<+,.(33C*!D,6-.%7,#%8!$#!%+,!6.$6,.!

)*,!$3!3$./,!-#0!%+,!6.(#/(61,*!$3!6.$&-&1,!/-)*,9!E+,!B$).%!%+)*!/$#/1)0,0!%+-%!FG%H+,!

3-(1).,!%$!6.$'(0,!*6,/(3(/!%.-(#(#4!.,4-.0(#4!%+,!0,%,#%($#!$3!*%)0,#%*8!(#!-00(%($#!

%$!4,#,.-1!%.-(#(#4!.,4-.0(#4!)*,!$3!3$./,!0).(#4!0,%,#%($#!-#0!II!J*(/K!-..,*%8!>-*!#$%!

5*$!1(2,1?5!%$!.,*)1%!(#!%+,!'($1-%($#!$3!*%)0,#%*C!L$).%+!M7,#07,#%!.(4+%*!%+-%!<+,.(33!

<,N%$#!.,-*$#-&1?!/-#!&,!*-(0!%$!+-',!&,,#!0,1(&,.-%,1?!(#0(33,.,#%!%$!%+,!#,,0!3$.!%+(*!

6-.%(/)1-.(O,0!%.-(#(#4!>(%+$)%!-#?!6.($.!#$%(/,9:!!@4'!-,+,AB%,A+C"%#=,#%;,+$%)D%;#A+)A.%/17%

E'F'%#+%378G76%9D,A4,AB%A)%)H&,)I*%ACC4%+)%+"#,A%J#,=%*IKC"&,*)"*%"CB#"4,AB%L:CA%+)%

K")&,4C%MC4,-#=%+"C#+MCA+%HC$)A4%D,"*+%#,4?'!!!

! P(2,>(*,8!(#!%+,!(#*%-#%!/-*,8!%+,.,!(*!#$%+(#4!%$!*)66$.%!%+,!3(#0(#4!%+-%!3-(1).,!%$!

6.$'(0,!-00(%($#-1!%.-(#(#4!&,?$#0!%+-%!.,/,(',0!&?!%+,!$33(/,.*!>$)10!*$!1(2,1?!.,*)1%!(#!

%+,!'($1-%($#!$3!*%)0,#%*A!/('(1!.(4+%*!%+-%!%+,!E$>#!$.!3$.7,.!B+(,3!/-#!&,!3$)#0!%$!+-',!

&,,#!0,1(&,.-%,1?!(#0(33,.,#%!%$!%+,!#,,0!3$.!%+,!-00(%($#-1!%.-(#(#49!!Q$.,$',.8!-*!%$!%+,!

E$>#!(%*,138!61-(#%(33*!/-##$%!6$(#%!%$!-#?!,'(0,#/,!%+-%!*)66$.%*!-!3(#0(#4!$3!-#!

)#/$#*%(%)%($#-1!6$1(/?!$.!6.-/%(/,!.,1-%(',!%$!3-(1).,!%$!6.$6,.1?!%.-(#!-#0!*)6,.'(*,!

$33(/,.*9!!N)AC==.%/3>%E'F'%>01'%%M&*,#%!*)/+!,'(0,#/,8!%+,!E$>#!-#0!3$.7,.!B+(,3!-.,!

,#%(%1,0!%$!*)77-.?!R)047,#%9!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 6 of 15 PageID #: 277

Page 7: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

! #$!%&&'(')$*!%+!,'(-!%..!/)$+('(0(')$%.!/.%'1+*!2.%'$('33!/%$!)$.4!+0//55&!)$!'(+!

3%'.065!()!(6%'$!/.%'1!0$&56!!"#$%&"'3!(-%(!3%'.065!'+!(-5!/%0+5!)6!(-5!71)8'$9!3)6/5:!

;5-'$&!(-5!0$&56.4'$9!/)$+('(0(')$%.!&526'8%(')$<!'((")*+,"-.")/0+-01"2%$"34'4"/+"&%%<!=!

9)856$15$(%.!5$('(4!7'+!)$.4!.'%;.5!,-5$!'(!/%$!;5!3%'6.4!+%'&!(-%(!(-5!/'(4!'(+5.3!'+!(-5!

,6)$9&)56<:"")-55*06"74")*+,"-."8/9:(9"8(*;<+61"=>&"34'4"##=1"#??""@34'4"#$$?A4!!>-5!

?026515!@)06(!-%+!512.)45&!%$!7%/(0%.!/%0+%(')$:!+(%$&%6&!'$!/.%'1+!%9%'$+(!%!

10$'/'2%.'(4!3)6!(-5!$59.'95$(!(6%'$'$9!%$&!+02568'+')$!)3!9)856$15$(!)33'/'%.+!0$&56!2?"

34'4)4"!"#$%&<!!)*+,"-.")/0+-01"2%$"34'4"/+"&$><!!>-%(!'+*!'$!)6&56!()!1%'$(%'$!%!!"#$%&!

/.%'1!%9%'$+(!%!10$'/'2%.'(4*!2.%'$('33!10+(!&51)$+(6%(5!(-%(!(-5!/.%'15&!&53'/'5$/4!

7%/(0%..4!/%0+5+!'$A064<:!!BC4!!>-5!?026515!@)06(!-%+!&5+/6';5&!(-'+!;06&5$!%+!65B0'6'$9!%!

+-),'$9!(-%(!7(-5!'&5$('3'5&!&53'/'5$/4!'$!%!/'(4C+!(6%'$'$9!26)96%1!<!<!<!D'+E!/.)+5.4!65.%(5&!

()!(-5!0.('1%(5!'$A064<!<!<!F)0.&!(-5!'$A064!-%85!;55$!%8)'&5&!-%&!(-5!512.)455!;55$!

(6%'$5&!0$&56!%!26)96%1!(-%(!,%+!$)(!&53'/'5$(!'$!(-5!'&5$('3'5&!65+25/(G:!!BC4"/+"&$#4!!!

>-5!&5(561'$%(')$!)3!,-5(-56!(-565!'+!%!/%0+%.!.'$H!-%+!;55$!/-%6%/(56'I5&!%+!%!

.59%.!/)$/.0+')$!6%(-56!(-%$!%!30$/(')$!)3!);A5/('85!3%/(<!!D9*++-0"74"E/5-0(,1"$>#"F4'GHH4"

222"@I4"E/66"#$$=A4"">-5!?026515!@)06(!-%+!306(-56!(0()65&!(-%(!'$!)6&56!()!&5(561'$5!'3!

%!2.%'$('33!-%+!15(!(-'+!76'9)6)0+!+(%$&%6&:!)3!/%0+%(')$*!(-5!@)06(!+-)0.&!65356!()!+(%(5!

()6(!26'$/'2.5+<!!J-C9*;G(KL)*9*5-"74"M/9N*/1")4O4"P-4"$QL#&>Q"@#6+")*941"RG0("?1"#$$SAT"

'-+-"74")/99/6UG*55-1"%S%"F4'GHH4"&?21"&&#"@I4"VG(9+-"J*N-"#$$=A<!!J$&56!K-)&5!#+.%$&C+!

/%0+%(')$!+(%$&%6&*!2.%'$('33+!10+(!&51)$+(6%(5!(-%(!7;0(!3)6:!(-5!%..595&!3%'.065!()!%/(*!

(-5!'$A064!,)0.&!$)(!-%85!)//0665&<!!M(5-6-"74"W(00,1"%#?"O4?C"%#21"%#%"@J4B4"?>>?A4!!#$!

(-'+!/%+5*!9'85$!(-5!/'6/01+(%$/5+!+066)0$&'$9!(-5!/)$+5$(!%$&!+5%6/-*!&535$&%$(+!+0;1'(!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 7 of 15 PageID #: 278

Page 8: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

#$%#!&#!'%(()#!*+!,%&-!#$%#!#$+!.%'/!)0!%--&#&)(%.!#1%&(&(2!34$%#+5+1!#$%#!#1%&(&(2!6%7!$%5+!

*++(8!4%,!#$+!-1&5&(2!0)1'+!*+$&(-!#$+!%..+2+-!')(,#&#9#&)(%.!-+:1&5%#&)(;!!!

<'')1-&(2.7=!-+0+(-%(#,!,9*6&#!#$%#!&(!#$+!&(,#%(#!'%,+=!%,!%!6%##+1!)0!.%4=!

:.%&(#&00,!%1+!9(%*.+!#)!:1)5+!#$%#!#$+!%..+2+-!0%&.91+!#)!#1%&(!&,!#$+!1+,9.#!)0!#$+!>)4(?,!)1!

@$&+0?,!A-+.&*+1%#+!&(-&00+1+('+B!)1=!&(!%(7!+5+(#=!#$%#!,9'$!0%&.91+!#)!#1%&(!'%9,+-!

:.%&(#&00!#)!,900+1!%!')(,#&#9#&)(%.!-+:1&5%#&)(;!!C966%17!D9-26+(#!,$)9.-!%'')1-&(2.7!

+(#+1!)(!*+$%.0!)0!-+0+(-%(#,;!

!"# $%&'()(*+#(,,%-(./#)01,#)&('%0*#.1#.0&(-#&-+#2%3*04(2*#

E#!&,!%.,)!()#+4)1#$7=!#$%#!#$+!0)16+1!@$&+0!F?G)91/+=!&(!%(7!+5+(#=!&,!+(#&#.+-!#)!

H9%.&0&+-!&669(&#7!01)6!#$+!0%&.91+!#)!#1%&(!%(-!,9:+15&,+!'.%&6!0)1!%..!#$+!,%6+!1+%,)(,!

#$%#!D9,#&07!#$+!21%(#&(2!)0!H9%.&0&+-!&669(&#7!0)1!#$+!)00&'+1,!%'#9%..7!&(5).5+-!&(!#$+!

&('&-+(#;!!I)1+!:1+'&,+.7=!&#!4%,!()#!'.+%1.7!+,#%*.&,$+-!#$%#!%!')%'$!&(!'9,#)-7!)0!

,#9-+(#,!)(!%!,'$)).!,:)(,)1+-!%#$.+#&'!+5+(#!.%'/+-!'%:%'&#7!#)!')(,+(#!)(!*+$%.0!)0!#$+!

,#9-+(#,!#)!%!:).&'+!,+%1'$;!!>$+!+5+(#!4%,!()#!)0!,9'$!(%#91+!#$%#!#$+!@$&+0!,$)9.-!$%5+!

/()4(!#$%#!0%&.91+!#)!:1)5&-+!%--&#&)(%.!#1%&(&(2!4)9.-!')(,#&#9#+!-+.&*+1%#+!&(-&00+1+('+!

#)!#$+!:.%&(#&00,?!1&2$#,;!!!""#$%"%##&'()*#+,-#.%/0#(1#2/34#5617"#8(9#9(:#;<1#=>8"('8)#

":1(?8$:7"0=#@<'#AB'A<:":#<@#CB(8$@$"0#$DDB;$1)#:B>7#17(1#(#'"(:<;(?8"#<@@$>$(8#$;#

!7"'$@@EF:G#%#%#%#:7<":#9<B80#7(H"#I;<9;#17(1#17"#@($8B'"#1<#A'<H$0"#:B>7#1'($;$;J#

><;:1$1B1"0#0"8$?"'(1"#$;0$@@"'";>"KLM#N$8")#H%#O"91<;*#4+#.%/0#P/Q*#P/R#52217#S$'%#244PL#

5><;>8B0$;J#17(1#:7"'$@@#9(:#";1$18"0#1<#CB(8$@$"0#$DDB;$1)#<;#@($8B'"T1<T1'($;#>8($D#97"'"#

A8($;1$@@:#@($8"0#1<#>$1"#>(:"#8(9#<'#><;:1$1B1$<;(8#A'<H$:$<;#'"CB$'$;J#:7"'$@@#1<#A'<H$0"#

1'($;$;J#<;#7<9#1<#B:"#U'D)#A"':<;;"8#(;0#'"V">1$;J#A8($;1$@@:W#('JBD";1#17(1#S$1)#<@#

S(;1<;W:#J";"'(8#:1(;0('0#<@#8$(?$8$1)#$;#@($8B'"#1<#1'($;#>(:":#>8"('8)#":1(?8$:7"0#17"#

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 8 of 15 PageID #: 279

Page 9: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "

!"#$%&'()*%%"+%,(-.(/$,!"00(10()!12*!3(4156%78(9:;(<,3.(=>>?.(;@@8(9AB(C;;%$(4"!.(<D*.(

9AAE&.!!#$%&'()'%*+,-!.'/'%.0%*&!&)123*!*40*!/$52'5!#43'/!678$)59'!3&!'%*3*+'.!*$!

()0+3/3'.!322)%3*,!/5$2!:+03%*3//&7!/03+)5'!*$!*503%!;+032!0%.!&)2205,!<).=2'%*!&4$)+.!

*4)&!'%*'5!3%!43&!/0>$5?!

!"! #$$%&%'()*%++,*%(-*./(!*.0'('.%+(%--%!1(2#$3'314(.-(!.5+%51(1.(+%#*!6(

(! @%$*4'5!3&&)'!503&'.!.)53%=!*4'!&)2205,!<).=2'%*!4'053%=!A0&!A4'*4'5!*4'!

;$0;47&!;$%&'%*!A0&!3%>0+3.!1';0)&'!4'!0++'='.+,!/'+*!;$'5;'.!1,!*4'!:5'&'%;'!$/!*4'!

;5$A.?!!B+03%*3//&!;+032!*40*!0!/0;*)0+!3&&)'!'C3&*&!0&!*$!A4'*4'5!*4'!;$0;4!/'+*!;$2:'++'.!

*$!;$%&'%*!*$!*4'!&'05;4!1';0)&'!$/!*4'!;5$A.!*40*!40.!=0*4'5'.!%'05!*4'!1)&?!!D'/'%.0%*&!

5'&:$%.!*40*-!0&!0!20**'5!$/!+0A-!*4'!0++'='.!$)*&3.'!3%/+)'%;'!1,!*4'!*435.!:05*3'&!.$'&!%$*!

3%>0+3.0*'!*4'!;$0;47&!;$%&'%*!0%.!*4)&!3&!355'+'>0%*!*$!:+03%*3//&7!;$%&*3*)*3$%0+!;+032&?!!

80*4'5-!)%.'5!A'++E&'**+'.!:5';'.'%*!3%!$5.'5!*$!3%>0+3.0*'!;$%&'%*-!*4'5'!2)&*!1'!;$'5;3>'!

0;*3$%!1,!*4'!$//3;'5&!*4'2&'+>'&?!!F%!*43&!;0&'-!:+03%*3//&!.$!%$*!0++'='!*40*!*4'!$//3;'5&!

;$'5;'.!#$0;4!G05;40%.!*$!;$%&'%*!*$!*4'!&'05;4?!!@%,!0++'='.!:5'&&)5'!/'+*!1,!#$0;4!

G05;40%.!1';0)&'!$/!*4'!;5$A.!3&!*4)&!355'+'>0%*!*$!*4'!.'*'523%0*3$%!$/!A4'*4'5!*4'!

$//3;'5&!05'!'%*3*+'.!*$!()0+3/3'.!322)%3*,?!!

! @&!%$*'.!3%!D'/'%.0%*&7!G'2$50%.)2!$/!H0A!3%!&)::$5*!$/!*4'35!G$*3$%!/$5!

I)2205,!J).=2'%*-!K$%'!$/!*4'!&:';3/3;0++,!'&*01+3&4'.!'C;':*3$%&!*$!*4'!LM$)5*4!

@2'%.2'%*N!5'()35'2'%*&!$/!1$*4!0!A0550%*!0%.!:5$101+'!;0)&'!3&!0!&'05;4!*40*!3&!

;$%.);*'.!:)5&)0%*!*$!;$%&'%*?K!!/F$6,FGD1%$(-.()5+%*H16%,8(I;9(J./.(9;E8(9;@(C;@KB&'(

J./.(-.(L"DF$,+MN*-*!!,%,8(O9B(<.B3(;8(;O(C;+%(4"!.(9AAE&.!!6/!;$)5&'-!3%!$5.'5!/$5!0!

;$%&'%*!*$!&'05;4!*$!1'!>0+3.-!3*!2)&*!1'!>$+)%*053+,!=3>'%?!!P3.(*%(9BO?!!O43&!5'()35'&!

+$$93%=!0*!*4'!*$*0+3*,!$/!*4'!;35;)2&*0%;'&?!!J./.(-.(Q,66"6#+8(I@;(<./5>>.(93(;AK98(;AK@(

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 9 of 15 PageID #: 280

Page 10: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "#

!"#$%&'$())*+,$!$%&'(')*!+,!'(-./-0+,1!02'!0%0-.+03!%4!02'!5+)5/670-,5'7!+,!02'!5%,0'80!

%4!/,9/'!+,4./',5'!%)!5%')5+%,*!:%/)07!2-('!-;;.+'9!02'!2%.9+,1!%4!-.&./'0.$1,$-.223&&45!

6*7$8,9,$:;*5$:*)$!8,9,$:7<=+!-,9!)'</+)'9!02-0!-!5%,7',0+,1!;-)03!&2%!-..'1'7!5%')5+%,!

9'6%,70)-0'!02-0!02'!5%')5+%,!'6-,-0'9!4)%6!02'!;%.+5'!%44+5')7!02'67'.('7!)-02')!02-,!

-,3!7/=>'50+('!%)!%/07+9'!+,4./',5'?!!@,!-.223&&4!02'!9'4',9-,0!5.-+6'9!02-0!2+7!

5%,4'77+%,!0%!02'!;%.+5'!&-7!+,(%./,0-)3!9/'!0%!2+7!6',0-.!5%,9+0+%,?!!@,!)'>'50+,1!02'!

;%7+0+%,!02-0!02'!70-0'6',07!72%/.9!='!7/;;)'77'9!/,9')!02'!A%/)02!B6',96',0!9/'!0%!02'!

9'4',9-,0C7!6',0-.!70-0'*!-7!%;;%7'9!0%!;%.+5'!6+75%,9/50!5%6;'..+,1!02'!5%,4'77+%,*!02'!

:%/)0!7/)('3'9!02'!5-7'7!%(')!02'!;-70!4+403!3'-)7!-,9!7/66-)+D'9E!!

B=7',0!;%.+5'!5%,9/50!5-/7-..3!)'.-0'9!0%!02'!5%,4'77+%,*!02')'!+7!7+6;.3!,%!=-7+7!

4%)!5%,5./9+,1!02-0!-,3!70-0'!-50%)!2-7!9';)+('9!-!5)+6+,-.!9'4',9-,0!%4!9/'!

;)%5'77!%4!.-&?!F'7;%,9',0!5%))'50.3!,%0'7!02-0!-7!+,0'))%1-0%)7!2-('!0/),'9!0%!

6%)'!7/=0.'!4%)67!%4!;7352%.%1+5-.!;')7/-7+%,*!5%/)07!2-('!4%/,9!02'!6',0-.!

5%,9+0+%,!%4!02'!9'4',9-,0!-!6%)'!7+1,+4+5-,0!4-50%)!+,!02'!G(%./,0-)+,'77G!

5-.5/./7?!!!H/0!02+7!4-50!9%'7!,%0!>/70+43!-!5%,5./7+%,!02-0!-!9'4',9-,0I7!6',0-.!

5%,9+0+%,*!=3!+07'.4!-,9!-;-)0!4)%6!+07!)'.-0+%,!0%!%44+5+-.!5%')5+%,*!72%/.9!'(')!

9+7;%7'!%4!02'!+,</+)3!+,0%!5%,70+0/0+%,-.!G(%./,0-)+,'77?G!

$>0,$'?$:=6!J5+0-0+%,!%6+00'9K?!L2'!M/;)'6'!:%/)0!02/7!)'>'50'9!02'!9'4',9-,0C7!5.-+6!02-0!

02'!:%/)0!6/70!N4+,9!-,!-00'6;0'9!&-+(')!+,(-.+9!&2','(')!02'!9'4',9-,0!4''.7!5%6;'..'9!

0%!&-+('!2+7!)+1207!=3!)'-7%,!%4!-,3!5%6;/.7+%,*!'(',!+4!02'!5%6;/.7+%,!9%'7!,%0!4.%&!

4)%6!02'!;%.+5'?O!!>0,$$'?$:*),$L2'!:%/)0!2'.9!02-0!02')'!6/70!='!-,!G'77',0+-.!.+,P!

='0&'',!5%')5+('!-50+(+03!%4!02'!M0-0'*!%,!02'!%,'!2-,9*!-,9!-!)'7/.0+,1!5%,4'77+%,!=3!-!

9'4',9-,0*!%,!02'!%02')?G!!>0,$'?$:=;$!3@AB'CDC$'0030+?!L2'!:%/)0!/,9')75%)'9!02'!G70-0'!

-50%)G!)'</+)'6',0!=3!70-0+,1E!!

L2'!6%70!%/0)-1'%/7!='2-(+%)!=3!-!;)+(-0'!;-)03!7''P+,1!0%!7'5/)'!'(+9',5'!

-1-+,70!-!9'4',9-,0!9%'7!,%0!6-P'!02-0!'(+9',5'!+,-96+77+=.'!/,9')!02'!Q/'!

R)%5'77!:.-/7'?!

!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 10 of 15 PageID #: 281

Page 11: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! ""

!"#$%&$'((#$$#$%&!'()%*+(,-!%&!.(&-/!*+!)$-!'-0*1+%)%*+!)$()!)$-!23-!4'*0-&&!0,(3&-!(+/!

*)$-'!0%5%,!'%1$)&!&6-0%7%0(,,8!6'*)-0)!0%)%9-+&!7'*:!.-%+1!/-6'%5-/!*7!)$-%'!'%1$)&!.8!;&)()-!

(0)*'&<=!!;>$-)$-'!(!?(%5-'!*7!)$-!@%7)$!A:-+/:-+)!6'%5%,-1-!%&!5*,3+)('8!/-6-+/&!*+!

B)$-!(.&-+0-!*7!6*,%0-!*5-''-(0$%+1C!+*)!*+!D7'--!0$*%0-D!%+!(+8!.'*(/-'!&-+&-!*7!)$-!

?*'/<B!!!"#$%&$')*#$$+,,$-#,#$.#+#$/#$012%3-145-%67$898$:#;"$)<7$(=$>'2&$?-3#$@#0#$8999A$

>BCD&E1FGE$H,D,I",64J%3K-%$E,32,DL$&,2&-L-,"$&E%&$2E,$L,D&$/,3M$2K%3,"$%I"$NEM2-K%DDM$-DD7$

&E,3,$O%2$I1$,/-",IK,$OE%&21,/,3$1L$NEM2-K%D$K1,3K-1I$13$-I&-P-"%&-1I7$I13$O%2$&E,3,$%IM$

-I"-K%&-1I$1L$K1I"FK&$QM$&E,$D%O$,IL13K,P,I&$%G,I&2$&E%&$O1FD"$%P1FI&$&1$N2MKE1D1G-K%D$

K1,3K-1I$13$-I&-P-"%&-1IRA#$$$

! A&!+*)-/C!?1II,DDM!$(&!.--+!(66,%-/!)*!0(&-&!0$(,,-+1%+1!)$-!5*,3+)('%+-&&!*7!

0*+&-+)!)*!&-('0$!3+/-'!)$-!@*3')--+)$!A:-+/:-+)<!!S,II-IG27$<='$:#+FNN#8"$%&$'9*T#$$

A,)$*31$!)$-!5*,3+)('%+-&&!&)(+/('/!3+/-'!)$-!@%7)$!(+/!@*3')--+)$!(:-+/:-+)&!%&!

&,%1$),8!/%77-'-+)C!!-"#8C!(!6(')8!0$(,,-+1%+1!)$-!5(,%/%)8!*7!(!0*+&-+)!)*!&-('0$!.(&-/!*+!

3+/3-!0*-'0%*+!:3&)!,%E-?%&-!/-:*+&)'()-!0*-'0%5-!(0)%*+!.8!)$-!1*5-'+:-+)(,!(1-+)!

'()$-'!)$(+!&3.F-0)%5-!6-'0-6)%*+!*7!0*-'0%*+<!!@*'!-G(:6,-C!%+!S,II-IG2C!)$-!/-7-+/(+)!

$(/!0,(%:-/!)$()!.-0(3&-!*7!$%&!:-+)(,!,%:%)()%*+&!$-!$(/!+*)!7'--,8!(+/!5*,3+)('%,8!

0*+&-+)-/!)*!)$-!&-('0$!*7!$%&!6-'&*+(,!.(1!.8!H<I<!4*&)(,!%+&6-0)*'&<!!A7)-'!0*+0,3/%+1!

)$()!?1II,DDM!(66,%-/!)*!(!/-)-':%+()%*+!*7!?$-)$-'!(!0*+&-+)!)*!&-('0$!?(&!0*-'0-/C!)$-!

J*3')!$-,/!)$()!;)$-'-!%&!+*!.(&%&!7*'!7%+/%+1!K-++%+1&L!0*+&-+)!)*!&-('0$!%+5*,3+)('8!

M(.&-+)!(+8!-5%/-+0-!*7!6&80$*,*1%0(,!*'!6$8&%0(,!0*-'0%*+!*+!)$-!6(')!*7!)$-!(1-+)&<L=!!

!"#$%&$'9T9#!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!N!#$-!/%&)%+0)%*+!%&!.(&-/!*+!)$-!7(0)!)$()!?$%,-!(!0*+&-+)!)*!&-('0$!:3&)!.-!5*,3+)('%,8!1%5-+C!%)!+--/!+*)!.-!E+*?%+1!(+/!%+)-,,%1-+)!(&!'-O3%'-/!3+/-'!)$-!?(%5-'!*7!H-3%I"%!'%1$)&<!!S,II-IG27$<='$:#+FNN#8"$%&$'9*=#!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 11 of 15 PageID #: 282

Page 12: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "#

! $%&!!"##$#%&''()*+!*&,-&.!)/(0!()*)'+)',-./01.2'34'5)67'8942'898':;;<='>$.)'5?-)'

;@@8A1!2%&*&!+%&!3,&4&0+%!'-*5)-+!*&6&5+&.!+%&!.&7&0.80+9:!5,8-;!+%8+!%-:!:+8+&;&0+:!+(!

<&5*&+!<&*4-5&!8=&0+:!80.!%-:!5(0:&0+!+(!:&8*5%1!>(+%!&?&5)+&.!2%-,&!%&!28:!)0.&*=(-0=!

/:@5%-8+*-5!+*&8+;&0+!7(*!:&4&*&!.&/*&::-(01!28:!-04(,)0+8*@A!!B,8-0+-77!5,8-;&.!+%8+!=-4&0!

%-:!:&4&*&!;&0+8,!.&/*&::-(0!80.!;&.-58+&.!:+8+&1!+%&!<&5*&+!<&*4-5&!C=&0+D:!/*(;-:&!+(!

/*(4-.&!%-;!%&,/!-0!(>+8-0-0=!;&0+8,!%&8,+%!+*&8+;&0+!28:!5(&*5-4&A!!$%&!3,&4&0+%!

'-*5)-+1!%(2&4&*1!0(+&.!+%&!8>:&05&!(7!E80@!&4-.&05&!(7!/:@5%(,(=-58,!(*!/%@:-58,!

5(&*5-(0!(0!+%&!/8*+!(7!+%&!8=&0+:AF!B7)''$%&*&7(*&1!-0!8//,@-0=!>0##"??C2'+%&!'()*+!%&,.!

+%8+!+%&*&!28:!0(!>8:-:!7(*!7-0.-0=!+%8+!+%&!.&7&0.80+9:!:+8+&;&0+:!80.!5(0:&0+!+(!:&8*5%!

2&*&!-04(,)0+8*@A!!B7)!!

! >0##"??C!28:!8,:(!8//,-&.!-0!()*)'+)'DE".C2'F44F'()*)'G$&<)'HIJB*';K@3L'

:*)G)M)N)'*"O<)'@2'F44FA!+(!.&7&8+!8!.&7&0.80+9:!5,8-;!+%8+!%&!28:!)0.),@!5(&*5&.!-0!

:-=0-0=!8!5(0:&0+!+(!:&8*5%A!!G0!+%8+!58:&1!+%&!.&7&0.80+!28:!(*-=-08,,@!7*(;!C7=%80-:+80A!

H&!5,8-;&.!+%8+!%&!:-=0&.!+%&!5(0:&0+!7(*;!>&58):&!(7!%-:!&?/&*-&05&!-0!C7=%80-:+80!80.!

%-:!>&,-&7!+%8+!-7!%&!78-,&.!+(!5((/&*8+&!%&!2(),.!>&!%&,.!-0!5):+(.@!80.!:)>6&5+&.!+(!8>):&!

>@!+%&!IJG!8=&0+:A!!$%&!'()*+!%&,.1!%(2&4&*1!+%8+!%-:!:)>6&5+-4&!>&,-&7:!2&*&!-**&,&480+!

E)0,&::!+%&*&!-:!80!8,,&=8+-(0!+%8+!8=&0+:!(7!+%&!K0-+&.!<+8+&:!&0=8=&.!-0!:(;&!+@/&!(7!

5(&*5-(0AL!!B7)!P$<$#%'()*)'+)'*-?-E"=2';8F'5)67'992';;3':F7'>$.)';@@9AA!!E$%&!.&7&0.80+!

%8:!78-,&.!+(!8,,&=&!80@!5(&*5-4&!85+-(0!(*!)0*&8:(08>,&!>&%84-(*!>@!+%&!=(4&*0;&0+8,!

8=&0+:!+(!-0.)5&!%-;!+(!28-4&!%-:!M-*80.8!*-=%+:!80.!;8N&!5&*+8-0!:+8+&;&0+:1!(*!+(!

5(0:&0+!+(!+%&!48*-():!:&8*5%&:A!$%&!.&7&0.80+D:!,-;-+&.!&.)58+-(01!5()/,&.!

2-+%!&?/&*-&05&:!-0!C7=%80-:+80!80.!%-:!/(:+O<&/+&;>&*!""+%!7&8*:!80.!8//*&%&0:-(0:1!

8*&!2%(,,@!)0*&,8+&.!+(!+%&!8=&0+:D!5(0.)5+AF!!B7)!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 12 of 15 PageID #: 283

Page 13: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "#

! $%&'!()'!)*'+!,%-!.+/.*0'&+/!+1!,%-!2-.+/3!4&5.0&,!,%-!.)'-!+1!!"#$%&'(&)*++(,&

-*./$&01&!21*$3,&456&7(89&:;8&<:$%&=#>(&)*++(&?;44@&<A+.ABC#D%*9&0.#+#0+@(!!$%-!6*)&/,&11!

&/!,%),!.)'-7!)/!0/3-5.+8-5!)9-/,!1+5!$-//-''--!:05-)0!+1!;/8-',&9),&+/7!<5+09%,!=!">?#!

.*)&@!)9)&/',!3-1-/3)/,'!1+5!)**-9-3!8&+*),&+/!+1!%&'!30-!65+.-''!5&9%,'A!!$%-!&/8-',&9),&/9!

+11&.-5'!%)3!'-)5.%-3!6*)&/,&11B'!65+6-5,C!1+5!',+*-/!65+6-5,C!)1,-5!5-.-&8&/9!%&'!.+/'-/,A!!

$%-!6*)&/,&117!%+(-8-57!@)&/,)&/-3!,%),!,%-!.+/'-/,!()'!.+-5.-3!<C!,%-!.&5.0@',)/.-'!

'055+0/3&/9!,%-!&/8-',&9),&/9!+11&.-5'B!5-D0-',!1+5!.+/'-/,!)/3!%&'!95)/,&/9!,%-!')@-A!!

E+(-8-57!,%-!4+05,!%-*3!,%),!FG,H%-!+/*C!)**-9-3!.+-5.&8-!6+*&.C!).,&8&,C!()'!,%-!

I),@+'6%-5-I!+1!,%-!'-)5.%!JG,%),!&'7!,%-!&/8-',&9),&/9!+11&.-5'H!9)&/-3!-/,5)/.-!,+!,%-!

%+0'-!(&,%+0,!3&'.*+'&/9!,%-!+11&.&)*!/),05-!+1!,%-&5!8&'&,K!)/3!,%-!5-*),&+/'%&6!+1!,%-!

6)5,&-'!J.+L(+5M-5'KAN!!E9(&&&O*)&/,&11!/-8-5,%-*-''!@)&/,)&/-3!,%),!%-!1-*,!%-!%)3!/+!.%+&.-!

<0,!,+!)95--!<-.)0'-!+1!%&'!-@6*+C@-/,!),!,%-!:05-)0!+1!;/8-',&9),&+/!)/3!%&'!<-*&-1!,%),!

%-!.+0*3!*+'-!%&'!P+<!&1!%-!5-10'-3A!!E+(-8-57!&/!5-.+9/&Q&/9!,%),!,%-!6*)&/,&11!*&M-(&'-!

)3@&,,-3!,%),!%-!M/-(!%-!.+0*3!5-10'-7!,%-!4+05,!%-*3!,%),!%&'!F'0<P-.,&8-!.+/.-5/!+8-5!

P-+6)53&Q&/9!%&'!P+<!3+-'!/+,!5&'-!,+!,%-!*-8-*!+1!.+-5.&+/7!.+@60*'&+/7!+5!1+5.-!5-'0*,&/9!

&/!)!.+/',&,0,&+/)*!8&+*),&+/AN!!E9(!!

! R'!,%-'-!.)'-'!@)M-!.*-)57!)/3!)'!)5,&.0*),-3!<C!,%-!S+05,%!4&5.0&,7!F)!.+05,T'!

-8)*0),&+/!+1!,%-!,+,)*&,C!+1!,%-!.&5.0@',)/.-'!&'!<)'-37!/+,!+/!,%-!6-5.-6,&+/'!+1!,%-!

&/3&8&30)*!'-)5.%-37!<0,!+/!,%-!.+-5.&8-/-''!+1!,%-!+11&.-5T'!.+/30.,!&/!+<,)&/&/9!,%-!

.+/'-/,A!!;/!+,%-5!(+53'7!,%-!5-*-8)/,!D0-',&+/!&'!/+,!(%-,%-5!,%-!6-5'+/!(%+'-!.+/'-/,!&'!

'+09%,!6-5.-&8-3!.+-5.&+/!<0,7!5),%-57!(%-,%-5!,%-5-!).,0)**C!()'!.+-5.&+/AN!!F(!(&'(&

GA*H292,&?;;?&F(!(&I..(&JKLE!&88M?8&<N$%&=#>(&?;;?@<A+.ABC#D%*9&.*>&OA>#2"&0.#+#0+@&

O#$#+P&=0++*CC3,&NM;&F(!(&2$&?:QR:M(&!!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 13 of 15 PageID #: 284

Page 14: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "#

! $%!&'()!*+),-!(&!()!.%/()0.&,/!&'+&!&',!122(*,3)!&114!%1!*1,3*(5,!+*&(1%!&1!*1%5(%*,!

&',!61+*'!&1!+73,,!&1!+!),+3*'!12!&',!)&./,%&)8!!9)!03,5(1.):;!%1&,/!(%!).0013&!12!

<,2,%/+%&)=!>1&(1%!213!?.@@+3;!A./7@,%&-!61+*'!>+3*'+%/!&,)&(2(,/!&'+&!1%,!12!

122(*,3)!+)4,/!(2!&',!61+*'!B1.:/!+::1B!&',!122(*,3)!&1!+:)1!*1%/.*&!+!),+3*'!+%/!&',!

61+*'!3,+/(:;!+73,,/!C,:(,5(%7!&'+&!(&!B+)!C,)&!&1!'+5,!'()!0:+;,3)!%+@,)!*:,+3,/8D!!

!"#$%"&'()#*+(",(-./-0*!!$%!2+*&-!+**13/(%7!&1!61+*'!>+3*'+%/-!&',!01:(*,!122(*,3)!B,3,!

*1.3&,1.)!+%/!0312,))(1%+:!E+&!+::!&(@,)F!+%/!3,0,+&,/:;!&1:/!&',!C;)&+%/,3)!&1!G.(,&!

/1B%8!!!"#$%"&'()#*+(",(-1+(-.("&'(2-*((9)!&',!+C15,!*+),)!@+4,!*:,+3-!+C),%&!+%;!

,5(/,%*,!12!*1,3*(5,!*1%/.*&!C;!&',!122(*,3)!&',@),:5,)-!0:+(%&(22)=!3,:(+%*,!1%!&',!

+::,7,/!03,)).3,!(@01),/!C;!&',!E*31B/F!()!(33,:,5+%&!&1!&',!/,&,3@(%+&(1%!12!B',&',3!&',!

*1%),%&!B+)!*1%)&(&.&(1%+:!2(3@!(%!&'+&!(&!B+)!51:.%&+3(:;!7(5,%8!!H'.)-!213!+::!&',!3,+)1%)!

1.&:(%,/!(%!<,2,%/+%&)=!03,5(1.):;!2(:,/!>1&(1%!213!?.@@+3;!A./7@,%&!+%/!13+:!

+37.@,%&)!@+/,!+&!',+3(%7-!/,2,%/+%&)!3,)0,*&2.::;!3,G.,)&!&'+&!).@@+3;!I./7@,%&!,%&,3!

(%!2+513!12!/,2,%/+%&)8!

!

! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!<,2,%/+%&)-!! J;!&',(3!+&&13%,;-!!!! 343(!"#$(56784,9! !! >+3*!<,?()&1!!!!!!!!!KLMNONP!! <Q?$?HR!S9T!! M""!9%7,::!?&3,,&!! U8R8!J1V!MOWD!! U315(/,%*,-!X$!YMZYW[MOWD!! U'1%,\!K#Y"P!MNM[###M!! ]+V\! K#Y"P!MNM[ZZDN!! Q@+(:\!@+3*^/,)()&1:+B8*1@!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!D!9:&'1.7'!%1&!@+&,3(+:!213!0.301),)!12!&',!(%)&+%&!@1&(1%-!&',!122(*,3)!&,)&(2(,/!&'+&!&',;!/(/!%1&!+)4!213!*1%),%&!&1!),+3*'8!!X+&',3-!(&!B+)!61+*'!>+3*'+%/!B'1!122,3,/!&1!+::1B!&',!122(*,3)!&1!),+3*'!&',!)&./,%&)8!!!8$%"8:8'64()#*+(",(;;*!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 14 of 15 PageID #: 285

Page 15: 0*$(!!"#$%%&'()*'+,-,'./'*01203,!!#$!%&'!($)%*$%!+*)',!*)!-./'!01223!*44/'))'4!41/($5!%&'!)1--*/3!6145-'$%!&'*/($5,!4'0'$4*$%)!-*($%*($!%&*%!1$4'/!4$.56"#'7,'8.%%.9.#&'3:0'-,'

! "#

!!!!

$%&'()($*'(+,!+)!-%&.($%!!

(!/01023!4015673!5/85!5/0!965/6:!;<4=>0:5!/8?!200:!0@0451<:648@@3!76@0;!965/!5/0!$<=15!<:!5/6?!A5/!;83!<7!B=:0C!DEEA!8:;!6?!8F86@82@0!7<1!F6096:G!8:;!;<9:@<8;6:G!71<>!5/0!%$)!?3?50>H!!-01F640!<:!5/0!4<=:?0@!<7!104<1;C!8?!@6?50;!20@<9C!96@@!20!077045=850;!23!0@0451<:64!>08:?H!!

!-50I/0:!JH!&<26:?<:C!%?KH! ?1<26:?<:L?>1<26:?<:@89H4<>!!.64M6!BH!N0/>8C!%?KH! F20O>8L?>1<26:?<:@89H4<>!!! "#"!$%&'!()*+#,-!! ! !! !!!!

Case 1:08-cv-00123-S-DLM Document 31 Filed 06/09/09 Page 15 of 15 PageID #: 286