ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , –...

24
, 30 , 1 , 2018 1439 77 , 30 , 1 , 77 100 , 2018 1439 : 7677 1658 1 11 01 1439 ; 15 04 1439 : , , 1437 , 2016 , , , , , 89.5 % , 75 % , 40.8 % , 33 % , 58.6 % , , : , , _________________________________________________________________________ ________ The Extent of Integrating Self-Learning Skills in the Chemistry Book for the Students of Third Secondary Grade who are on the System of Courses in Saudi Arabia Abdullah Awad Al Harbi (1) Majmaah University (Received 01/10/2017; accepted 02/01/2018) Abstract: The current research aimed at finding out the extent of integrating the self-learning skills in the chemistry book for the students of third secondary stage who are on the system of courses in Saudi Arabia where the analytical tool included the self-learning skills. The current research limited the study to the chemistry book for the students of third secondary grade who are on the system of courses, edition 1437 AH, 2016 AD. The results of the analysis showed that the degree of integrating the skills of evolving the chemical concepts, skills of biological applications, skills of communication and cooperation, and skills of sustainable development in the chemistry book of the third secondary grade who are on the system of courses were respectively 89.5%, 75%, 40.8%, and 33%. In general, the percentage of integrating the four mentioned skills in the chemistry book of the third secondary grade who are on the system of courses reached 58.6% whereas the skills which were not included in this book were as follows: the content contributes in attaining cooperation with others to achieve learning, the content contributes and aids in solving problems, and the content is tied to the applications of mathematics. Keywords: analyzing school books, self-learning skills, courses' system. __________________________ _______________________________________________ ________ 1 , , , , 66 , 11952 (1) Associate Professor of Science Education, College of Education, Majmaah University Majmaah, Saudi Arabia, P.O. Box (66) Postal Code (11952). : [email protected] e-mail:

Transcript of ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , –...

Page 1: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 77 –

�� �������� ���� ����� ,30 ����� ,�1�" " , 77 − 100 ,2018��1439� � �$�%:7677 −1658�

���� � ��� �� �� ������ ���� ������ ������� ���� � !���

"�#! ���$%&�'() *� '�+$ � '���&� �

,$-� )� . /+ 0� �1.214

��)��� ��$�* � + ,-�� ��.11�01�1439;� ,-�� 01.2 + 15�04�1439� �

&�5�6�*:3)45 6�$ �7��$ 89 :�;� <=1�� >� ?��@)@A�� B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ JK��� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� ,�����Q��� + H�%�I$ R$ 0@�=C�� S��T UN�A52E�F�� G��C��V B�CD WX :�;� <=1�� YC.�2?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON H�%��P�� ���1Z ,1437 ,�� 2016 ,�

�����Q�� G@��C�� S%�[2V H�I\T2H�%�I$ 3)45 6�CQ$ ]T 0@�=C�� ^_�CN��@)-5 `�K�5a� H�%��I$2 ,��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� H�%��I$2 ,��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ,�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$2 ,]2��C��2JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��:���C�� W�X d�� 89.5% ,75% ,40.8% ,33% ���X 0Af�2 ,

5 �1QN Ug� ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ��)C� h%i� H�%�I�� 3)4JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON H�%��P�� 58.6V% ?��@)@A�� B��CD �I-)4�C� j k�C�� H�%��I�� ]T2 JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON k H�%�P��lG��C��� m�@P=C� R��no� h$ ]2��C�� m@P=C 6�C=�� G �Q�p2 ,l� 0�; �D%�f��� + 6��C=�� G �Q��HqAf��p ,

2lH�@r����� G�X H�P@1bC 6�C=�� s15��pV

'�8��9&� �:��� :E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ ,�@t%��� uCA�� 0@�v , ��ON��H�%�P V _________________________________________________________________________________

The Extent of Integrating Self-Learning Skills in the Chemistry Book for the Students of

Third Secondary Grade who are on the System of Courses in Saudi Arabia Abdullah Awad Al Harbi(1)

Majmaah University

(Received 01/10/2017; accepted 02/01/2018) Abstract: The current research aimed at finding out the extent of integrating the self-learning skills in the chemistry book for the

students of third secondary stage who are on the system of courses in Saudi Arabia where the analytical tool included the self-learning skills.

The current research limited the study to the chemistry book for the students of third secondary grade who are on the system of courses,

edition 1437 AH, 2016 AD. The results of the analysis showed that the degree of integrating the skills of evolving the chemical concepts,

skills of biological applications, skills of communication and cooperation, and skills of sustainable development in the chemistry book of the

third secondary grade who are on the system of courses were respectively 89.5%, 75%, 40.8%, and 33%. In general, the percentage of

integrating the four mentioned skills in the chemistry book of the third secondary grade who are on the system of courses reached 58.6%

whereas the skills which were not included in this book were as follows: the content contributes in attaining cooperation with others to

achieve learning, the content contributes and aids in solving problems, and the content is tied to the applications of mathematics.

Keywords: analyzing school books, self-learning skills, courses' system. _________________________________________________________________________________

�1� w%�f�� ������ x�%�5 y�Z2 ^ �-�� z�CtT��)��� ��$�* ,�@�� �@�D ,V ������ ,�����Q�� �@���� �A�)�� ,"V B�66� M��{�� |$��� ,�11952V�

(1) Associate Professor of Science Education, College of Education,

Majmaah University

Majmaah, Saudi Arabia, P.O. Box (66) Postal Code (11952).

}2A�~� ��{��: [email protected] e-mail:

Page 2: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 78 –

'��%�:

R��=N <��@� ,H���$����� Y��X + ]o� �@���N � m7�C��2 +���� %��cNa� 6�T MF���2 ,0_��� E�$����

��PC�� 89k)���� m_��Z2 u@��tT %�I\2 G��C�� �)C�5 J@\�5 WXu��b�� H�%�I$2 H�%�. G��C��� m�@P=C�

B��b��V ]9 ��bC�� h���� �gC��2 +���� % + ���� MF���

���5 + GItT ��@�� �-��X W�X `�K;� H�2�T2 u@��tT�$����� ,���� ���P5 �f�2 ]�P�� �@�� �@-��� �@�2��� �-

�����2�T2 ���@5�$����� S%���L�� ]T 89 R�,�����2 M����;�+ ��O-�� S����X9 u��bC5 ��@*���-AC�� ������� ��$�O-��

��@5�$����� ��)Av 01PCQ�� Bq�b�� ��@� RA)� <@= �,h@% 2000� V �����5 H�t%�� k-1C a9 mP=C� a �F 2

%�� T�1$ WX �D�5 E�z 0Af� G��C�� �@�)�� Bqb�� �t ���T2 ,��@����� ����� ���C�� �2%� G T R$ �%�1CX� Y���� H��1�bC$ ��I@�9 U�X� k�C�� ������ H������ W�X H��DT �KK�C�� H��CA��2 H�@�i� ]T2 ,:�;�

6�� ��@��5 �@�T2 �)@.Bqb���t%��� G��n� ���)

(Mok & Cheng, 2001; Billett, 2010)V ��L��;� u@���ti� R$ ���� E�F�� G��C�� ]�7 �F� ,��@)@��C�� 0������ h@� + G��C�� H�@�)X + ��X�c��2

2 �@7 ]�A� u��b�� � �%���� s@�b�C�� RX `2�Q��2��� %�@Cn���I)��5 + u���� k�C�� ��@)���� S�� V R�$2

0����$ h�@� + ��P@1b5 �@N�A$9 B��ti� �F H�|@�G@��C��, �0D ,M��)��� ���CQ�$2 ��@�P��� ��5%�. uQ�

�� MF��2���c) �@)@��C�� H�Z�f-�� u��b�� �@7 �%�� , >��� i� ��=N ���I�C$ �n� ��fN 89 ��fN R$ 0PC-�2

%��P��2 ���= S��=�� �@)@��C�� ,�1t�-5 kC�� �X���2 ��-@�CQ��$ G������ H������%92 E�F���� G��PC���� ����z + �I@*�52�5 �,��@;� 2003�V

,��c�C��� j����� `2� + ��@��;� ^ �-�� �)C�52�@�t%�$ u�CD k�-15 W�X ��@���� `2��� �I-$2 � ���5

�@)t��� H�I�� ]T u��  %��� B�CA�� ]�7 ��F�2 , �� ��P �@�@5��t� ?��r + S%��� 04�7T + Bq�b�� �

j���� �=r�2; G� T �� B��CA�� ]T ��-7�X �z9 ����n��K$ Bq�b�� �1Q�-�� ��7����2 G��C��� %�}��)f���, 2010� V0��Q��D�$ ���DT2 �Maxwell, 1985 � W��X ]T

�¡���5 �@��t%��� u��CA������@)@��C�� ���@�)��� + 6����2 , ]%�[2T�Osborne, 2014� �@�t%��� ������� uCD ]T

]�7 :�C��2 ,���ti� ¢�Z2 �f.�-�� WX Bqb�� h�f5G��%�QcCt�2 GICf.�-$E�F��� G��C��� WX G �X�Q5 V

��A�)�� M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD ����2 ��@t2 �I7 ,�@t%��� uCA�� ��5 ��T �����Q�� �@����

�@)���� �7�PL�� 0PN2 G��C�� 0_�t2 R$ �$� V m��C� �@72E�F�� G��C�� ��Ic) ���)� j 3L��1��2 ?����� ]�7 WX

��C�� ��£ J���5 ���C G��c���5 H���5 �P7 ,E�F�� G

Page 3: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 79 –

Ha���� R$ ��� E�F�� G��C�� ]T �D ,����� �%���� U��X�-52 H�����5 �F��� ,M����� B�i� + ���L��;� �F�� �����5 h��*��2 ,������� H���@�i� + ���5�c���5

3L��1�� H� �¤� ���5 89 H�c���C��, `2�-5 R$ GI-)7 qX <�@� R�$ E�F��� G��C��� 0_��t��� ��C.��@)@��C��

<�@� R$ ��2�-5 R$ GI-$2 ,�L��;�u���b�� ��C.qX , <@� R$ ��2�-5 R$ GI-$22 �P_��Z ���5�1@��tTV

6����2 M2���-b��2 k-@,�����(2006 G��C���� ]T �� E�F�� ��I@7 ���P� k�C�� ��@)@��C�� u@���ti� ���T

¥1K��2 ,�7���� WX `�K;� + {Di� %2��� u��b��� �����gC$ W�X �b@Q���2 � %�£ V ¥@�r�5 R�A)�2

u���b�� � ��P� k)@��5 ��fN �N� E�F�� G��C�� ��Ic$ �� ,�Q�c- �Q�cN G���� u��b�� ]T MT ,�QcN ?�P�5 R$ ��X�)� `q�n R�$ ,��I�$�A52 �C@K��� ��@)-5 mP¦ ��)��5 ?��-¡T ��§ ��)� k�C�� �bfNi�2 �@)��C�� J.����

E�F��V ��Dz2 �@�Z� �2009� ��7��� T E�F��� G��C��� ]T �$�X �I-$ ,�)CQ��� G��C��� H����X2 H�%��I$ B�QCD�

G@���5 �@�2�Q�$ u��b�� 0)v2 ,E�F�� G��C�� ������ 3Qv2 ,S�@;� 6�$ �)CQ�� G��C�� m@Pv2 ,�Qc- �QcN h�$ B2���C��2 ,� ���¤2 ,%��)Ct� ���g��� H�%�I��

R��A� ,0��)��� y���t H����gC$�$���X �2005 � `2���-C� ���%T + � ���¦2 �n� %�O-$ R$ E�F�� G��C�� >�� T

k >�� T : ,E�F��� G��C��� s@b�C��� �b15�$ >�� T

,�Ic@\�52 H�$����� %��K$ ����Ct� m��C5 >�� T2 ���b15�$ >���� T2 ,E�F���� G@@PC���� ���b15�$ >���� T2

3)��C�� H� �¤�V E�F�� G��C�� �@�T R)A52 R�$ ���n�$ 0K� �

E�F��� G��C��� m_��Z ¨�-5 + GItT MF��2 ;k-P5 % ��b5 0�* �� �F 2 ,u��b�� 6��3L���1��]��$�P� ?��*�� �@)���� H�t�%���2 ��=1��,E�F�� G��C�� `�� + �P7

q�7 ,�����7 ���Q$ G��C�� ]T G��C�� H���ON H�DT �� ���CQ� ]T u��b���@5�F�� �5�%�.cC�� + �Q� ]T2 ,�A

,G��C��� k��@b1� "��c�� �7��� �� ,����c�� �CX© m72������c�� y2���c�� ����*qX ����P�2 �9%�-A��t2 ,M2�|���

1994 V� R$ �0D m7�22�,M2qCc�� 2004 ;,�$�X 2005� �� 0��5 �$%�-At� M2�|�2 1994)�� ]T E�F��� G��C�

�I-$ ;���|$ S�X k�X��� <�@= ,�����c�� y2�c�� S�X��$ ��@�)X `qn R$ Bqb�� ����c�� y2�c�� E�F�� G��C�� ,��c�Cª G���5 Ha���) ¥)Q�5 <�@� ,G@��C�� ���c5 ,��5�%�. m�72 ���qn R�$ �C�t�%� + u���b�� ��PC�2

G��C�� + �CX©2 ,�5�%�I$2 V R$ ]T �D����|$ F�n�� �NT �5�$�C �2 �5�%�.2 �5�1�%2 u��b�� H�*�� %�1CXa� +

PC� ��t�D �bfNi�2  �%��� ^I-�� ��@1Z �_�r + %� �*%� «.T 89 0@K=C�� WX ��X�Q� �NT2 ,�Cv ���b-��

�����c�� ��@)@��C�� ��5�*�� m���Z R�X �-A� �,RQ�� 1994�V

Page 4: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 80 –

R�$ k�C�� H�%��I�� R�$ �X�)� E�F�� G��C��2 ��DqC$� ]92 ,��@5�z G��C�� m@Pv u��b�� h@bCQ� ��qn

H�%�I�� �F� `���Z2 ,H�.2i� 0D + G��C�� R$ �-A¬ ��@�� >���� �$ � 2 ,�I*%�n2 �t%��� 0n�� �)���

�@�Z �DF�2 ,S�)CQ�� �2009 � ��$�X H�%��I$ w�- ]T H�%��I$ k� 2 ,��§ u���b�� ��2|5 u� E�F�� G��C�� S��cC�ta�2 ,E�F��� G��PC�� H�%�I$2 ,MT��� �D%�f��

S�7��C�� Hq@IQC�� R$ ����C�ta�2 ,��@�=�� ���@1�� + G��C�� V­���� ��¦ �D �1987 � H�%��I$ R�$ ��X�)�

��@_��P�� `��@�� k�)-5 kC�� ���®� E�F�� G��C��, k� 2 ��C7��$ m��Z RX ��z2 ,B�CA�� 89 `����� H�%�I$ ,�IQ��tT2 ,���I_��1$2 ,���t�Ic��2 J@-K��C�� m��_��b

a�2 ,B�CA�� ����Ct� H�%�I$2 ,� �_��72,�-$ S��cCt G@ ��c�� ��@)-5 H�%��I$ ��7��$ ��@�T 89 ��N��P� �F 2 H�%���I$2 ,���@5�@;� H���P@1bC�� H�%���I$2 ,���@_�@)@A�� B�CD + �$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$2 ,]2��C��2 `�K5a�

�����v ?�@)@A��V ���N�L�� �%���� ]T ������ R$2 l ���ONH�%�P��p��� ¯���1$ W�X |D�5 �����Q�� ,E�F��� G��C

N ����� ��z2 ���D�@ 2 �7�� � ,G@��C�� + �@X�N ��P ,�-@$�4��$2 �1@����tT2 <��@= °�Q��� ±��� ���@)-5 89

0L$ ,u��b�� �@5�@;� H�%�I�� : H�%��I$2 E�F�� G��C�� h��$ 0��X�cC��2 ,k��X��� 0��)���2 0�����C��2 ]2����C��

�Z9 + ,�no� MT��� `�1.2 �f.�-��2 %��;�2 R��no� %

RZ����2 h�)C�)�� ��@���� ¥��K��2 �Df�� G@P�� R$ �G@��C�� S%�[2�����Q�� , 1433V�

���ON �%���$ >��� T ���X ��2 ,m1t ��2 |�D�5 ��²T ¥4�5� ,�����Q�� + H�%�P��W�X ]2���C��

��)X ^�� ��DT ��D ,G��C��� ��@�)X `q�n �D%�f��2x.���2 k��Cc��2�2015 � �bf��NT 3)4��5 ���@�T W��X

6�� `�K5a� GX�5 H�%�1�� ���N�L�� ������ + ?�@)@A�� 2T ,G���� h$ 2T ,]��.i� 3 0���C�� m@P=C� ,Bqb��

h��)C��� h�$ R��) ����¦ ]T u���b�� h@bCQ��� <�@= ;,S�X�Q��� ���� �$�-X 3�CQ� ��7��$ 89 ��N��P� �F� 2 B��CD + H�%�I�� �F mPv?��@)@A�� JK��� <���L��

M�N�L�� N���O ,H�%��P�� ]T u�� m1�t ��$ ?��r +2 G��C��� ��$[q�� H�%��I�� G� T ?�@)@A�� B�CD R)4C�

E�F��; ��4��T2 ,��X 0Af �@_�@A�� G@ �c�� �@�i ���ON ��t�tT ���� ?�@)@A�� B�CD 6�C£ ]T m�b-$ R$ �Qc5 +

��t%��� 0�n�� u���b�� ��*��5 k�C�� �@)���� � ��O��� °�C�2 ,�I*%�n2 J�.��)�� ��C���$2 ��Q�c5 ]��A

G@ ���c)�� ���D�%�9 ]���A� ]T ��� a ,��=@=��� ���@)���� G@ ��c�� h$ �)I7 mcC� °C� ,��=@=� ��D�%�9 �@_�@)@A��

)@A��@?������� 6���� �����1P�� ���@)���� ���@_� V �F�� R��$2 H�%�I$ H�%�I���@)-5 R$ ���5 kI7 ,�@_�@)@A�� G@ �c��

<�@� ,?�@)@A�� x�%�5 >�� T m�P=C� �$��-X G��C��� h�$ ¥�r�2 0Af� S������ �7���� s� u��b�� ��P�

Page 5: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 81 –

0�1. R�$ ��q@L) ��� H�z ���4. 2T G@ �c$ �,�)f�. 2002� V ��1�b�� B�Q�D9 89 ?�@)@A�� x�%�5 °�Q� �F�

� ��O�� 2T ?�@�i� R$ �LD RX S���C$ �@_�@)@D G@ �c$ u�K�� R$ �NT �*22 ,�@c@\2 S%�K �@�@1b�� G��� ]T

��c�C��� G����� ¨2�7 + �@)���� G@ �c�� h@)� �1�b��; z9 ,� ���@P�52 �ICZ�Q�� ���*%� + H2���cC5 G@ ���c�� ]9

�J�r2 ���*2 ��X 2T S�A1$ ����$ + G@ �c�� w�%�9 ��b®� G�Ic�� �11�t ]�A� �. u��b�� �-X �P�b$ ��Ic$

(Birk & Kurts, 1999) V H��@P@1bC�� H�%��I$ ���5 �D;��@5�@ + �I-@)4�5 u�� k�C��2 ,��)I�� H�%��I�� R$

?�@)@A�� B�CD; �@t�ti� %�A7i�2 G@ �c�� m��C5 �²i ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ���N�L�� ������ Bqb�� �It%�� kC��

R��$ Bq��b�� ���I*��� ��� S³���1$ ���.qX ���� k��C��2 ]2���C�� H�%��I$ ]T ��D ,��@$�@�� G��@� + HqAf$

�K5a�2 �v ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ` H�{®� `��1C� ����7 mPBqb�� 3� ��)X ^��x.��2 ��)X ^�� k�Cc��2,

2015� ��@)-C�� H�%��I$ E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ R$2 , Y-�� �T �� %��T kC��2 ,�$��CQ���)£2 �2017� �²�

u��b�� H�%�I$2 >%��$ ���bC� °�Q5 kC�� �@)-C��V � G��C�� kO� m1t �� ��1D ��C � `�[�$2 E�F�

R$ �%�1CX� 3L��1�� R$T �����5 m�Pv kC�� G@��C�� ¨��N �F�� ,G��C��� + ��C1�%2 ,�@5�F�� G��C�� H�%�. h$ mcC� E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ H��t�%��� R�$ ���X U�2�-5

�t�%� �I-$2 ,?�@�i�2 ������ uCD + �-)4C�� H��@1Xk�1X|��2� 2005 �9 U7�� k�C�� H�%���I$ ?�K�PCt� 8

H�%���AC�� �LDT ]T 3152 ,������ uCD + E�F�� G��C�� `�� + UN�D E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I�RC�� ,�bf�Ni� G¡ ,

,��)C� �¡qL�� uCA�� + G��PC�� ���tT G¡U-@2 �t�%� ¥��c�� �2015 � �@5�@;� H�%�I�� R)4C5 ������ uCD ]T

]T �D ,�bt�C$ �*%� 0AD S%�I$ MT R)4C5 j uCA��H�F�� S%��9 H�%�I$ R$V ¥��c�� m7�22�2015 � ���@CN

-�2 �t�%��Winter, 2007� %�K�. 89 H%���T kC�� R��$ ]T ���-7�X �z9 ,�$��CQ���� ���@)-C�� m��@Pv + ^ ���-��

�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$ �@5�@;� H�%�I��V ��4�T2��|��2 G@���� �t�%� H|D% �2015 �X W

JK��� ?�@�i� B�CD + �-)4�� E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 0@�c5 6�$2 ,�����Q�� G@KP�� �Pb-) M�N�L�� `2i� 89 ^_�C-�� U���5 �.2 ,H�%�I�� ��C� ?�@�i� H���$ h�@)� M�N��L�� `2i� JK��� ?��@�i� B��CD R)45 H�*%��2 <�=1�� + S���=�� E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$

�c�Cª 3)45 G����� 0�@��2 ,u���b�� B�CD R$ 0D + S��c-$, m���C� �@�7 �t�%��� �F ^_�CN mcC52 ,��)C�2

,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ WX u�%�C�� 89 H����� �*�=�´i� �t�%� h$ �1997� kC�� 3�)���� ]T 89 H%���T

��*%�2 E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ WX B%�C�� 89 �*�=���@��X V�%� H���DT22 ]���4���� ���t k��1@�|��2 h��f����

Page 6: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 82 –

�2015 �2 ?��|@c�� uCD ]TT ���N�L�� ������ + G���� ��� ���4�P�� h�$ 0�$��C�� ��¦µ H�����%9 ��T R$ U�n

��@�)C��� �@)���� �S.S.I V�}���)��� ��t�%� U7�� 2 �2005 � u�CD + E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ WX JfA��

���N�L�� ����)�� H�@r�����, U���52 ]T 89 �t�%���0.T H�@�r����� u�CD + ���7���5 E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$

��)C� �qL��6�C=�� RC$ +V E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�) m��C� �@72

,?�@)@A�� B�CD +U7� ��t�%� ��r��� ��1X2 RQ�� �2016 �0��@�v 89 <����L�� JK���� ?���@)@A�� B���CD

st�C�� � ���P72 y����� +���4�P��@*���-AC��2 G�����

22 h��)C�������@1��� S.T.S.E� ]T ���t�%��� H���I\T2 , �1Q�- �$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� ���4�. R)45 ?�@)@A�� B�CD

%��P) �@N�C$ 22% ?��@)@A�� B�CD ]T �-7�X �z9 ���n , Bq�b�� �X�Q�5 �²T �c�� R$ �@�)X �bfNT R)4C�

MT���� ?��92 �D%�f��2 �P-�� WX�^��2 {���,��)X 2016� V �t�%� H%��T �D]�-�� �2006 � G@ �c�� ]T 89

h�$ u�t�-C5 a ?��@)@A�� B��CD + �-)4C�� �@_�@)@A�� |D% ?�@)@A�� B�CD ]T2 ,�L��;� H� �¤a�2 H�%�bC�� 0)f� a B�CA�� ]T2 ,WXT �1Q- �@_�@)@A�� m_�P;� WX

�Q@_��� �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� 0D Vm7��C5 �D ��t�%� ^_�CN ]�-�� �2006 �]��X�P�� ��t�%� ^_��CN h$ �2005 � k�C��

u�CD + S�%����� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� 0�@�v 89 U7�

G��P52 ,]�%i� + �bt�C��2 �@t�ti� ����)�� ������ ��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� 0@�v G5 �.2 ,�§ ���®� H������

c@-K�52 ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ���v <@� R$ ��@c@D2 �I µ���-X h��@� ]T 89 ���t�%��� U�����52 ,���I��[�5 W��X U�K��� ���t�%��� ���@-��� �@��t�%��� H��������

�)X ^� �t�%� H�DT �D ,�bt�C$ H����P5 �)X ^�x.�2 kCc��2 �2015 � ���X�� H���CQ��� 3� ][���C

�@N���2 �@����� + ?�K�PCta� H�%��I$ R�$ S%��I$ 0�A������ ?�@)@A�� uCD�����Q�� + ���N�L�� V

��r�X m1�t �� , H��t�%��� G�O�$ ]T ¥4�C�?��@)@A��2 ������� + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ WX H|D%

��X 0Af<��1�� �� j2 , − �)�X �2�� + − ��t�%� H�%�I� U.�b5�@)-5 H��P@1bC��2 ,��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c��

�$��CQ���� ���@)-C��2 ,]2����C��2 `�K��5a�2 ,���@5�@;� + B�CD?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P��

�����Q��V �<1� '��=�:

%��K$ G T R$ �@t%��� uCA�� ���5H��$����� ��I-$ �)CQ� <@� ;��|D��� ����� �)ONi� + �Q@_��� + G��%�. %�bC5 ��qn R$2 ,�@)���� GIC7�P¡ Bqb��

�P�� z��¶�2 `����2 k�)���� �AcC�� + �1�t�-�� H�%���@$�@�� G��@� �]���4�� ,]2��n�2 2015� , U��2T2

�-�2 �t�%��Winter, 2007� u�CA�� ����b5 S%2·

Page 7: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 83 –

,�@t%��� + H�@r�����2 ������ ���b5 ¨2,$ |D% �F� k�C�� �@t�ti� H�%�I�� u��b�� B�QD9 WX �����Q��

,�@-I��2 �@�)��� S�@;� H�1�bC$ wqC$� R$ �-A¬ m@Pv2 ~�2 RA)C�� 0*T R$ G@��C�� T�1$ H�%�I�� �@)-52 ,]�P5

0L$ ,u��b�� �@5�@;� : ]2���C�� H�%��I$2 E�F�� G��C�� R���no� h�$ 0�X�cC��2 ,k�X��� 0�)���2 0���C��2

�f�.�-��2 %��;�2 �G@���C�� S%�[2�����Q��� , 1433� VP5 j :��;� U�.��� + G@��C�� �)I$ ]T �D�� �F 2 Y�C

��@)-5 89 ���z °�b�C5 0 ,�@)@��C�� S���� 0@Kv WXH�$����� WX `�K;� ��qn R$ RA)� kC�� H�%�I��

��T ,��� 2011�V ]��-�� ��t�%� U��2T �D �2006 � u� kC�� �Q@_��� �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� �)_�. ���X9 �@��

?�@)@A�� B�CD + �I-@)45 V+ G@���C�� GQ�. �f�� ��D ���%��7�Florida Department of Education, 2017 �

H�%��I$ ������� ^ ��-$ R)4�C5 ]T �@�T 89 ]2���C�� `�K5a�2 V2T �@)���� H�t�%��� ±� H�DWX %�K.

E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I� ��X 0Af ������ uCD 3)45 �,¥��c��2015 ,]�-�� ; 2006� V 3)4�5 ��@�i ����ON2

G��C�� H�%�I$B�CD + E�F��?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� + ���t�tT ����5 �²T m�b-$ R$2 ,

,u���b�� ��*��5 kC�� �@_�@)@A�� �@)���� � ��O�� �Qc5GC�� �<��=1�� B���CA H�%���I�� ����5 3)4��5 6���)

?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��V

�<1� >��?@:

:�;� <=1�� >� 89 : 1 − <��L�� JK�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD S?��.M�N�L��

�@�@�v S?��. H�%�P�� ��ONV 2 − G��C��� H�%�I) �P��C$ �)_�. ���X9E�F���

B�CD + �I-@)45 RA)� kC��2?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��V 3 − H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �7��$G��C��� E�F��� �P��C�� �@)-Cc����@_�@)@A�� G@ � ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC��2

�$��CQ�� �@)-C��2 ]2��C��2 `�K5a�2 B�CD + ?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��V

�<1� '�AB@:

H��v ��Af$ <=1�� + `��Q�� ¹@_��� Eo� :�$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C�� E�F�� + B�CD ?�@)@A��

JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� + �A�)�� �@���� ?�����Q�� �.2 UPL1N� �-X ���ti� �@X�c�� �@5o�: 1 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� �@�7

m����C� ���@)-C G@ ���c�� ���@_�@)@A�� + B���CD ?���@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��

2 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� �@�7 m��C� H�P@1bC�� ��@5�@;� + B��CD ?��@)@A�� JK���

<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� 3 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C�� E�F��� �@�7

Page 8: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 84 –

m��C� `�K5a� ]2���C��2 + B��CD ?��@)@A�� JK��� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��

4 − �$ 6�$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� �@�7 m��C� �@)-C�� $��CQ��� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L��

M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� �<1� '�C@ :

­� �@7 �@�i� R)A5 : 1 − �7��<=1�� k�bb�� ���*�% ���Fg5 :�;�

<�@= ,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ `��) m��C� �@7 ^ �-�� B��CD %����9 S���X9 ��-X ���_�CN R$ S��cCta� RA)�

�L�� <��L�� JK�� ?�@)@A��H�%�P$ ��ON M�N V 2 − ?�@)@A�� k)��$ ��2|5 + <=1�� �F G �Q�

?��@)@A�� B��CD �I-)4�5 kC��2 ,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ R$ ��-A)C� kA� ,H�%�P$ ��ON M�N�L�� <��L�� JK�� :��C��2 ,G�§qb� %��P�� GIQ��%�5 ?��-¡T ��z S�X��$

GI)��5 3Qv V 3 − �@�T BqZ ���N�L�� ������ BqZ ���n2

B�Q�CDa ��*�= G� R�F��� ,M�N�L�� <��L�� JK�� �������� H���1�bC� ������C��t� ;E�F���� G��C���� H�%���I$

�@�$���V �<1� ��<�D��:

��� �� �� : � ��P� MF�� k)@��C�� ��f-�� � ��X�7�$ G��C�� �5�����C�t� ��@)-5 >��§ �@5�F�� �C1��

��1@�CQ$ �5�%�.2 �5�N�A$92 m�P¦ �� ��5�$�C �2 ����@� ���)C� h$ ¥*�-�� 0X�cC��2 ,�I�$�A52 �C@K�� �@)-5

��5�%�P ��PL��2 �Q�cN WX ��CXa� m��Z RX �,k�X�$ 1998�V >���5 �-@ E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$��²� ��X�)�

`��@�� k�)-5 k�C�� ����®� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ R$�@_��P�� �,­��� 1987�V

>���52 �F� + ���@_��*9 E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ �P��C�� H�%�I�� R$ �X�)� �²� <=1�� �@)-C G@ �c��

,]2���C��2 `�K�5a�2 ,�@5�@;� H�P@1bC��2 ,�@_�@)@A�� ���%�I$ ¨�)�2 ,�$��CQ�� �@)-C��221S%�I$ V

��E����EE����� ��EE� �EE��� � !�EE�� "�EE#!

���$%&� : ��@_��*9 >����2?�@)@A�� B�CD �N�3 G5 MF�� ������2 H�@r����� x�%�5 ���b5 ¨2,$ R)r �c@��5 ,`�K�7 �Q�» B��CA�� M��¦2 ,�����Q�� + �@�@1b��

k� : ,���@_�@)@A�� H����gC��2 ���.�b��2 ,S������ Ha���� ,k_���@)@A�� ]�|��5a�2 ,���@_�@)@A�� HqX���cC�� ���X©2

qX�c52 �@N��D2%�@�� H�1D��� H�PCf$2 ���1Z2 ,�� k B�CA��1437−2016�����Q�� ,G@��C�� S%�[2 ,V

���$E%&� "�#! : ��N� ���O-�� �F >����2 0�A@ �t%�� wf$ ^$�N� R$ ]�AC� M�N�L�� G@��C�� ���*

3K�K¶ R�%�Q�$ 89 ¨�cC�2 ,Bqb�� h@�; �����T u��b�� ��C� ,�@�@1b�� ������ �no�2 �@N�QN~� ������

�t�%��� ����� �I�A@ + �b®� �F °-1C52 ,����T +

Page 9: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 85 –

,�--P�� �@t�%��� H�X�Q�� ��ON �I�T R$ S���X uN��*2 ,­$���AC�� ^I-���� ����ON2 ,k��)D��� `������ ����ON2���PC�� H�2�T2 G��C���2 G@���C�� + ��@X�N u@���tTG� �G@��C�� S%�[2�����Q�� , 1433�V

�<1� F�G�:

:��;� <=1�� �)CX� ­@��=C�� kc����� ^I-���Content Analysis ,6�C=�� 0@�v B��tT `qn R$ ,

�@72� 0�@�=C�� `q�n R�$ S� �O�� ¼_�Kn Y� GC������ uQ-��2 H�%��AC�� B�Q= k)A��V

�<1� 'G�.H I��J: B��CD R�$ <�=1�� ��-@X2 h)C� 0L¬?��@)@A��

JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON ,H�%��P�� ���1Z 1437−2016`2�* 31�2 , 1 B��CD 6��C£ �2%�2 `�K�7

?�@)@A��JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��:

KH�L2 1 :4��� ������� ���� � �M NH�)H K �O ���� � !��� "�#! ���$%&�P

K �O

����� NH��� Q� G. ��<9��

`2i� ,�1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� ,Bz��C�� 6�. ,H�[�g���@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5 43-10 }�L�� M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�Q� ,��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� ,S%��;� ,�.�b�� 83-54

<��L�� 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ,0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$����� ,k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON 111-92

h���� ��� ]�|5a� ����]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� ,k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� ,kA@$�-� 153-120

x$�®� H��)@��1�� ,���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5 ,0@N��A�� H�1D�$ ,H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A�� ,0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@�� 193-162

�<1� R�)@ : �?���*9 R�$ m1�t �$ ?�r +2 <���1�� ���. H

G T ���=C ��z2 ,�@�2i� �ICg@K ���P5 �)_�. ���X� R��$ ���X�)� R)4��C5 ]T R��A)�� R��$ k��C�� Ha������ h�%i� + H�%��I�� H���v2 ,E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$

Ha�� :�@)-5 H�%�I$ H�%��I$2 ,��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ,]2����C��2 `�K��5a� H�%���I$2 ,���@5�@;� H���P@1bC��

�I$2�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%V

$(�%�� '�S�T ��1UH V�W : W�X �I�r�X G5 ���PC�� �)_�. y�� R$ �D�C�� y��Z2 ^ ��-�� + 3K�K�C�� 3�)A=�� R$ �X�)� ,G�q���52 G��O�q) ����T R�F��2 ,������ x�%�5 0����5 G�5 ;3)A=�� Hq���52 H�O�q$ h� ��2

H�?��*~�2 ,���PC�� �)_�.k ]�f�� �F + U¬ kC�� : S%�I$ >F� �@1��i� 6T%l h$ ut�-C� � G��C�� m@Pv

���� W�X G��C�$ 0D S%�.p S%��I$ ��F�D2 ,l GIQ��

Page 10: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 86 –

G��C�� 6�� �@�7���� S���[ WX 6�C=��p �²i ;− uQ� G½T%− 0� ,��@�v ����� 6�C=�� �P��C$ S%�I$ ��5 a

G�52 ,��5�z G��C��� �P��C$ k ��@1��T 6T%2 ,�I7F�� ��)�D `��1C�t� 0�L$ ,H�%�I�� ±� 0���5 3)A=��

lH�X�r���p�� l6�C=��p ����PC�� ��)_�. U�N�A52 , R$ Hq���C�� ��21 ,E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ R$ S%�I$

G.% `2��� ¥r�$ � �D 2V

KH�L2 2 :4���� � ��� �� �� ������ ������� ��� ���� �� !�� "�#! ���$%&�P

K�X&� " R���&� �����&� )�.

1 6�C=�� G �Q�+ �t%���@t�ti� G���� H�%�I$ V 2 ���Cc$ ���tT ¢�Z �@N�A$9 6�C=�� ¥@C�V 3 G �Q� 6�C=�� B��@Ct� G@ �c�� �@_�@)@A�� kC�� �7��C� �� J���5 k)�X 4 G �Q� 6�C=�� B��@Ct� G@ �c�� �@_�@)@A�� kC�� �7��C� �� J���5 �g��� ��|@��N~�V 5 R)4C� 6�C=�� ��L$T 2T R�%�¬ �X�Q5 WX �7��$ ��Ic�� k_�@)@A�� �����V

������ '�S������ ��?�9&� '��G�

6 R)4C� 6�C=�� ��Fg5 ��*�% `�� 6�CQ$ G��C��V

6

7 R)4C� 6�C=�� �a��� ��P$ HqAf� �@5�@� �@�.�2V 8 S�@;� R$ �@�.�2 ��L$T 6�C=�� R)4C�V 9 R)4C��@�2�Q�� 0)v H�%�I$ 6�C=�� V

'����-� ��%�1D�� ������

10 �@�.�2 �@_�@)@D HqAf� ��P$ a��� 6�C=�� R)4C�V

4

11 G��C�� 6�C=�� �X�Q� WX�5�z G@P� ]TV 12 G �Q� 6�C=�� m@P=C ]2��C�� h$ R��no� m@P=C� G��C��V 13 ���ti� ¢�Z 6�C=�� ¥@C�R��no� WX V

QH� ��H K���Y� ������

14 HqAf�� 0; �D%�f�� + 6�C=�� G �Q�V

4

15 k)���� ?�KPCta� WX 6�C=�� �X�Q�V 16 � 6�� J�4��2 S�P�� ��PN 6�C=�� [{�G��C�V 17 M�=C��2 <=1�� "�7 6�C=�� ¥@C�V 18 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC�%i� G�XV 19 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC?�@�i� G�XV 20 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC?��|@c�� G�XV

'����*&� '��G�� ������

21 6�C=�� s15�� H�P@1bC H�@r����� G�XV

7

Z �X&� 21

Page 11: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 87 –

�. 0@�=C�� H�1¡ R$ �D�C��2 ��CX�� <���1�� �� B���ti� ;����PC�� ��)_�. H��1¡ u@��tT R$ 3��tT B��CD <���1�� 0�� �@72 ,R$|�� {X H�1L�� � `2i�

0�@�=C�� R�$ h@�tT �¡q¡ �� 0@�=C�� ��XT2 ,?�@)@A�� �2�D �����$ ���Ct�2 ,`2i�Cooper 0$��$ B�Q;

H�1L��:

H�1L�� 0$��$ =3 y�c5a� H��$ ��X }�L��2 `2i� 0@�=C�� ×100 y�c5a� H��$ ��X +>qCna� H��$ ��X

{��X H���1L�� B�Q��� G��5 }���L�� B����ti� +2 ��n� ¼C�ª 0�1. R$ �QcN B�CA�� 0�� <@� ,���7i� Hq$��$ Á���Ct� G52 ,������ x�%�5 y�Z2 ^ �-)

X Ug� kC��2 ,������� xcN ����Ct� H�1L�� :��C�� W0.902 ,0.94V

'�S��EE8[� 'EE\� &� : :���;� <��=1�� ���C��t� H�%��I$ 3)45 6�$ �7��� ������ uQ-��2 H�%��AC��

?�@)@A�� B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L�� ��ON H�%�P��V

����$L] �<1�:

m@P=C� >� <=1�� 0�L)C��2 + ��7��$ 6��$ 3)45 H�%�I$ G��C�� F��E� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK��

<����L�� M�N���L�� ����ON H�%���P�� ���A�)�� ���@���� ;�����Q�� ��@P5 <=1�� s��4�� �@��C�� : 1 − ¨qZa� WX H�t�%��� �P�Q��� ���=1��2

H���@�i�2 ���@���� ���@1-*i�2 k��C�� U���2�-5 H�%���I$ G��C�� E�F�� + uCD ������ ?�@)@A��2V

2 − 0@�v B�CD �?�@)@A� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L��

��ON H�%��P�� >��§ ��7��$ 6��$ 3)4�5 H�%��I$ G��C�� E�F�� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L��

��ON H�%�P��V 3 − U�L¬ �-@X 0@�=C�� R�$ h�@� H�X��r��� �-)4C�� + B�CD ?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ���ON H�%�P�� ��1Z 1437−2016V 4 − ���)CX� <��=1�� S���Ac�� �¦Y���� S�����D

,0@�=C�� ��z2 <=1�� RX H�%�I$ G��C��� E�F��� + ¼-�� H�$�t���2 `�A��i�2 �bf�Ni�2 S���*��� +

B�CA��V 5 − 0)���� �0���@�=C�� ¼-����� H�$����t���2

`�A�i�2 �bfNi�2 S��*��� + B�CA��V 6 − j 0)f� �0�@�=C�� Ãm��q���,H�=�bK��� `2���2 M%2��� µ�-��� V� 7 − 0)X ¥Q$ B�CA� ?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L��

M�N�L�� ��ON ,H�%�P�� ��z2 �5?��P S?��. ,�@N�C$ G�52 S��X9 �5?��. S�$ 6�nTV

Page 12: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 88 –

���=T�G�H �<1� FS��!:

KH^� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:

��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �$+ ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� �@)-C?��@)@A�� B��CD JK���

<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ :�C�� `2��� 31� B���CD + ���@_�@)@A�� G@ ���c�� ���@)-C ���P��C�� E�F����

?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��:

KH�L2 3 :4��� �� �� ������ ���� ��� + '%� �&� '��G���?�9&� ������� ���� � '�S������ � !��� ���� ������$%&� "�#! P

a� ��$��%c a� ��$��%c

'G���� de 'G���� � R����

6

R����

5

R����

4

R����

3

R����

2

R����

1 ��. f &� g�9�

5 * * × * * * H�[�g��

5 * * × * * * � 6�.Bz��C�

5 * * × * * * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 4�16.7

20�83.3

5 * * × * * * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5

g�

9�KH

^�

5 * * × * * * �.�b��

5 * * × * * * S%��;�

6 * * * * * * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 2�8.3

22�91.7

6 * * * * * * + �gC�� B�Q�M%��;� 6�C=��

h���

g�9�

6 * * * * * * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON

6 * * * * * * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$����� 0�0 18�100

6 * * * * * * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. �

��� g

�9�

5 * * × * * * kA@$�-���� ]�|5a� ����

6 * * * * * * k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� 2�11.1 16�88.9

5 * * × * * * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$

� g�

9�

5 * * × * * * 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��

6 * * * * * * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��

5 * * × * * * 0@N��A�� H�1D�$

5 * * × * * * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5

4�13.3

26�86.7

5 * * × * * * H��)@��1��

i��j

� g�

9�

102c89.5 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�

12c10.5 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�

Page 13: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 89 –

R�$ ¥4C�`2���� 3 G��C��� H�%��I$ ���X ]T ��P��C�� E�F�� ��@)-C + �-)4�C�� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c��

B�CD?�@)@A�� M�N��L�� <��L�� JK�� H�%��P�� ���ON k 102 � %��. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ 89.5%, ���X �-�@

k �-)4C�� �� H�%�I��12� %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ %10.5V ]T 89 �-)4C�� H�%�I�� S�LD u1t ���� �%2

,?�@)@A�� G��5 + 0n��� k �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c��]T ��D ��C£6� ?���@)@A�� ���)C�� ����C��X� ��³���1$ W��X G@ ���c��

,�@_�@)@A�� :�C��2 ?�@)@A�� B�CD �I-)45 V ��D ¥4�C�R$ ?�@)@A�� B�CD `�K7 �LDT ]T �QcN `2��� JK��

<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P����� H�%��I� �-)4C�� C G�� ��P��C�� E�F�� ��@)-C 0K�c�� �� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c��

�L�� <�l��@_�@)@A�� HqX��cC�� �X©p R)4�5 <�@� ,�� H�%�I$C �1Q�- E�F�� G��100% + u1Q��� �����2 ,

MF��� ��@���� 0K�c�� �� <���L�� 0Kc�� ]T 89 ��z~� �g��� J���5 �7��5 R)45 H�=�bK$ 0A� ��|@��N

S����� �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c���@7V B��CD `�K�7 0�.T �-@ ��� H�%��P�� ���ON M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� ?�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ��@)-C ��P��C�� E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I� �-)4C��

@_�@)@A��i� 0K�c�� �� �`2 lS����� Ha���p <�@� , %��P) �@7 �-)4C�� �� H�%�I�� �1QN H?�*16.7V%

�DR�$ ¥4C�%��I$ ��LDT ]T �Q�cN `2���� H�)4�5 ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��@ + ��-

?�@)@A�� B�CDJK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� S%�I$ ;�@5o� H�%�I�� k l WX 6�C=�� G �Q��t%�� �@��t�ti� G������ H�%���I$p S%���I$2 ,l 6���C=�� ¥@��C����Cc$ ���tT ¢�Z �@N�A$9p S%�I$2 ,l 6��C=�� G �Q�

Ct� J����5 ��� �7���C� k�C�� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� B��@k��)�Xp S%���I$2 ,l 6���C=�� R)4��C� R�%���¬ 2T ����L$T

������ k_��@)@A�� ��Ic�� �7��$ WX �X�Q5p S%��I$2 ,l 6�C=�� R)4C�G��C��� 6�CQ$ `�� ��*�% ��Fg5p,

� %��. ����$ �1Q- S%�I$ 0D H?�* <@�100%, �-�@ S%�I$l6�C=�� G �Q� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� B��@C�t�

���|@��N~� ��g��� J����5 �� �7��C� kC��p + U-)4�5 ?�@)@A�� B�CDJK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P��

� %�. ����$ �1Q-36.8% �z9 ����n �@N�C$ �1QN k 2 , + GIC��t�%� ]��)A@��t R�F���� Bq��b�� ]T ���-7�X

@t �@1b��2 �@t�-��2 �@)���� H�KK�C�� �F ]�t%����|@��N~� �g��� �@_�@)@A�� H�=�bK�� V �F� m�cC52

G@����2 ��|�� �t�%� h$ ��@C-���2015 � H%���T k�C�� h�@)� M�N��L�� `2i� JK�� ?�@�i� B�CD R)45 89 H�*%��2 <�=1�� + S���=�� E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ G����� 0�@��2 ,u���b�� B�CD R$ 0D + �c�Cª 3)45

S��c-$��)C�2 ,V + ?��* ��$ WX 0@�=C�� ^_�CN �D�52 89 H%����T k��C��2 ,���t�%��� H���@�T G@ ���c�� ���@�T

)@A��@ ,�@_�2 ��t�tT ��5 �²T ��@)���� � ���O�� �Qc5 +

Page 14: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 90 –

�*��5 kC��u���b�� ��C���$2 ��Q�c5 ]��A� °�C�2 , ��=@=� �@)���� J.��)��V

h��� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:

$ 3)45 6�$ �$ ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I?��@)@A�� B��CD + �@5�@;� H�P@1bC�� JK��� <���L��

M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P�� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ :�C�� `2��� 31� ?��@)@A�� B��CD + ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� ��P��C�� E�F��

H�%�P�� ��ON M�N�L�� <��L�� JK��:

KH�L2 4 :4�� ���� ��� ������� ���� � '����-� ��%�1D��+ '%� �&� ��� �� �� ����� !��� ���� ������$%&� "�#! P

a� ��$��%c a� ��$��%c

'G���� de 'G���� � R����4 R����3 R����2 R����1 ��. f &� g�9�

4 * * * * H�[�g��

2 × * × * Bz��C�� 6�.

3 × * * * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 5�31.2

11�68.8

2 × × * * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5

g�

9�KH

^�

3 * × * * �.�b��

4 * * * * S%��;�

3 × * * * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 4�25 12�75

2 × × * * M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�Q�

h���

g�9�

4 * * * * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON

4 * * * * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$�����

2�16.7

10�83.3

2 × * × * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ���

� g�

9�

3 * × * * kA@$�-���� ]�|5a� ����

3 * × * * a� + S�¡��� 0$�����k_�@)@A�� ]�|5

2�16.7

10�83.3

4 * * * * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$

� g�

9�

2 × × * * 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��

3 × * * * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��

2 × × * * 0@N��A�� H�1D�$

4 * * * * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5

6�30

14�70

3 * × * * �1��H��)@�

i��j

� g�

9�

57c75 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�

19c25 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�

*'G����P ×'G���� de P

Page 15: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 91 –

R$ ¥4C�`2��� 4 E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ ��X ]T ?��@)@A�� B��CD + �-)4�C�� ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� �P��C��

M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� k� H�%��P�� ���ON 57 ,S%��I$ � %�. ����$ �1Q-75%, �-)4�C�� ��� H�%�I�� ��X �-@

k 19 � %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ 25 V% `2���� 3�1� ��D B�CD `�K7 �LDT ]T �QcN?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L��

��ON H�%�P�� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I� �-)4C�� <��L�� 0Kc�� � �@5�@;� H�P@1bC��l HqX��cC�� �X©

�@_�@)@A��p h���� 0Kc��2 ,lk_��@)@A�� ]�|5a�p�1Q�- , � %�. ����$83.3 %0K7 0A�V ]T �QcN `2��� 31� �D

��@5�@;� H��P@1bC�� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C�� H�%�I$ �LDT ?�@)@A�� B�CD + ��-@)45M�N��L�� <���L�� JK�� ���ON

$ ;�@5o� H�%�I�� k H�%�P�� S%��Il 6��C=�� R)4�C��@�.�2 �@5�@� HqAf� ��P$ �a���p H?��* <�@� ,

� %��. ����$ �1Q-100% ]T 89 ���z <���1�� 2|���2 , ?��@)@A�� B��CD + �@)���� H�X�r���JK��� <���L��

M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� S��@;� ��P��C$ H�X��r�$ k� H���1D���2 ���.�b��2 ,S������ Ha���� 0��L$ ,����X 0Af��

�@N��D2%�@�� V S%�I$ H?�*2l ���L$T 6��C=�� R)4C�S�@;� R$ �@�.�2p � %�. ����$ �1Q- 89.5% ��D�� �F 2 , H�X�r�$ ]T?��@)@A�� JK��� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON

H�%�P��S�@;� �P��C$ , S%�I$ ]T �c� �$ �F 2 l R)4C��@�.�2 �@5�@� HqAf� ��P$ �a��� 6�C=��p H?�* ,

1Q-� 100 V%`2����� ��-5?��. +2 4 ���N ¨��r�$ ]TlBz����C�� 6���.p ¨���r�$2 ,l 0��X�cC�� ���X© 3N����.

k_�@)@A��p �§ R)4C5 j S%�I$ lR)4C� 6��C=�� ���L$T ���@�.�2 R��$ S���@;�p V B���CD + ��-@)4��5 H�%���I�� 0��.T2

?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� S%��I$ k l���� 6��C=�� R)4C� ��@_�@)@D HqAf�� ���P$ �a

�@�.�2p � %��. ����$ �1Q- 3)4C�� 6�CQ$ ?�* <@� ,52.6% j ����1��P5 H�X���r��� JK��N ]T k��-�� �F�� 2 ,

�F� ��@�T <���1�� 6��� �-�@ ,�P�Q��� S%�I�� R)4C5 B�CD + R)4C5 ]T u� <@= S%�I��?�@)@A�� JK���

<��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��$ �1Q- ���n2 ,�@��X ����HqAf)�� ��P$ �a��� ��P5 �²T 0��� �� �@_�@)@A��

z G��C��� �t%��� 3 s��� + S%�I�� �F G �Q52 ,°-�$ G½�� �1�Z 0@ �5 + ��4�T G �Q5 <@= ,�@�.���� S�@;�2 ,G�§ s@�¦ MF��� h�.���� GI7 + �1t�-�� �@)���� S%�P��

��@bCQ� :�C��2]�P5 0�A� �=@=� �@)�X H��Qc5 G�G ��� �*��5 2T GII*��5 �@_�@)@D ��Af$ R�$ ]T ��D ,

±�� �@)-5 � M�N�L�� G@��C�� + H�%�P�� ��ON >�� T �@5�@;� H�%�I���,�����Q�� G@��C�� S%�[2 1433�V

���� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:

��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �$�K5a�?��@)@A�� B�CD + ]2��C��2 ` JK��� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��

Page 16: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 92 –

KH�L2 5 :4 ���� � QH� ��H K���Y�+ '%� �&� ��� �� �� ������ ���� ���������� ��� ���� � !��� "�#! ���$%&�P

��$�� a�%c ��$�� a�%c

'G���� de 'G���� � R����

4

R����

3

R����

2

R����

1 ��. f &� �9�g

2 × * × * H�[�g��

1 × × × * Bz��C�� 6�.

1 × × × * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 10�62.5 6�37.5

2 × * × * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5

g�

9�KH

^�

2 × * × * �.�b��

2 × * × * S%��;�

1 × × × * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 10�62.5 6�37.5

1 × × × * M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�Q�

h���

g�9�

2 × * × * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON

2 × * × * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$�����

7�58.3

5�41.7

1 × × × * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ���

� g�

9�

2 × * × * kA@$�-���� ]�|5a� ����

2 × * × * k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� 6�50

6�50

2 × * × * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$

� g�

9�

2 × * × * 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��

1 × × × * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��

1 × × × * 0@N��A�� H�1D�$

2 × * × * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5

12�60

8�40

2 × * × * H��)@��1��

i��j

� g�

9�

31c40.8 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�

45c59.2 '���� ����$��� c'( A&� '1*G�

*'G���� P ×'G���� deP

R�$ ¥4C�`2���� 5 G��C��� H�%��I$ ���X ]T

�P��C�� E�F�� B��CD + �-)4�C�� ]2���C��2 `�K�5a�?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%��P�� k� 31

� %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$40.8%, H�%��I�� ���X �-�@

k �-)4C�� ��45 � %��. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$ 59.2%, H�%���I$ 3)4��5 6�CQ��$ ]T ����X 0Af�� ���q�2

B����CD + ]2�����C��2 `�K���5a�����@)@A��? JK����� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��,s�t�C�� ]2� 3�1� ��D

Page 17: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 93 –

B��CD `�K�7 �LDT ]T �QcN `2���?��@)@A�� JK��� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� G��C��� H�%��I� �-)4C��

h����� 0K�c�� �� ]2���C��2 `�K�5a� �P��C�� E�F��lk_���@)@A�� ]�|��5a�p 3)4��5 6�CQ��$ d��� <��@� ,

H�%�I�� � %��. �����$ �1Q�- �@750% 0K�c�� ��@��2 , <����L��l���@_�@)@A�� HqX���cC�� ���X©p d��� <��@� ,

��@7 3)4C�� 6�CQ$41.7 V% + G@���C�� GQ�. �f��2���%��7 (Florida Department of Education, 2017)

]2���C�� H�%�I$ WX ������ ^ �-$ R)4C5 ]T �@�T 89`�K5a�2V

�DR�$ ¥4C�`2���� H�%��I$ ��LDT ]T �Q�cN + ��-@)4�5 ]2���C��2 `�K�5a� ��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��

B�CD?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� S%���I$ k�� l���5�z G@��P� ]T G��C���� 6���C=�� �X�Q���p ,

3)4C�� 6�CQ$ d� <@�100% ��z <��1�� 2|��2 , B���CD ]T 89?���@)@A�� JK���� <����L�� M�N���L�� N����O

H�%�P�� ��D ,���X 0Af 0Kc�� ��*��� ���tT R)45 ,B��CA�� `�K�7 R�$ 0K7 0A� �@)��P5 ���tT R)45 R�$ 0K7 0D ���² + R-P$ %�1Cn� WX ��4�T �_��C�a2 + G �Q�Ct ��c�C��� ���ti� �F ]T2 ,B�CA�� `�K7

G����2z G@��@P5 + ���1�b�� S�X�Q��$ V 6�CQ��$ d��� �-��@E%�I� 3)4C�� lQ�� h�$ ]2���C�� m@P=C 6�C=�� G

G��C�� m@P=C� R��no�p2 ,l �D%�f�� + 6�C=�� G �Q�

HqAf��� 0;p 00.0 % ]T ���z `���2 ,S%��I$ 0�A�2T ]2��C�� R$ ¨�N MT R)4C� j ?�@)@A�� B�CD �D%�f��

,G��C��� m�@P=C� GIQ�cNT �1�b�� 3 HqAf�� 0� +���5 W�X 3)_�P�� �X�� �F 2 J@B��CA���*��$ 89 ��C

G��C��� m�P=@� ;R��no� h$ ]2��C�� H�%�I� �-@)452 0�)��� |��|�5 + G �Q�� °�C�2 ,��1�b�� 3� }2��C�� ����@)���� H�f���.�-�� R���$ S��cC���ta�2 k���X���

i�2 G@ ��c�� G���5 ?��-¡T GC�5 k�C�� ����Ac�� H��2�Z °Q@X �D��2 ,�@)���� m_�P;�2 °Q�@X k�-2 S�1� �T2

�2016 �WX ��$2 ������� ^ ��-$ + ��O-�� S���X9 �@�T ��I_��C�� S%2· WX �@D�C��2 ;�@)�X S��$ R$ �-)4C5 �����Ac�� �D%�f���� ���t%�� ¥@��C5 k��C�� �bf��Ni� W��X

��)X ^�� m1�t �$ h$ mcC�2 ,?�KPCta�2 ��)X ^��x.�2 kCc��2� 2015 � ?��@)@A�� �bfNT 3)45 �@��

`�K5a� GX�5 H�%�1�� �����7 m�P=@� ,Bq�b�� 6��GI-@ H�{®� `��1C� V

I+�$� K�_*� `. '+�L[�:

��P��C�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$ �$?��@)@A�� B���CD + �$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� JK��� <����L��

M�N�L�� ��ON ?H�%�P��

Page 18: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 94 –

KH�L2 6 :4�*&� '��G��+ '%� �&� ��� �� �� ������ ���� ������$%&� "�#! � !��� ���� ��� ������� ���� � '���P

a� ��$��%c a� ��$��%c

'G���� de 'G���� � R����

7

R����

6

R����

5

R����

4

R����

3

R����

2

R����

1 ��. f &� g�9�

3 × × × × * * * H�[�g��

3 × × × × * * * 6�.Bz��C��

3 × × × × * * * �1�K�� �����2 ��_�Q�� ����� 14�50 14�50

5 × * × * * * * �@_��|@c�� ���;� H��g5

g�

9�KH

^�

3 × × × × * * * �.�b��

3 × × × × * * * S%��;�

4 × × * × * * * ��%��;� �@_�@)@A�� Ha����� 18�64.3 10�35.7

0 × × × × × × × Q�M%��;� 6�C=�� + �gC�� B�

h���

g�9�

3 × × × × * * * k_�@)@A�� 0X�cC�� �X©2 ���KC�� ���ON

3 × × × × * * * 0X�cC�� �X© + S�¡��� 0$����� 12�57.1 9�42.9

3 × × × × * * * 0X�cC�� �X© 3N��. ���

� g�

9�

1 × * × × × × × �-���� ]�|5a� ����kA@$

0 × × × × × × × k_�@)@A�� ]�|5a� + S�¡��� 0$����� 16�76.2 5�23.8

4 × × × * * * * ]�|5a� U��¡ `��Ct� I+�$

� g�

9�

0 × × × × × × × 0�%i� H��@�� 2 0@A�i� H��@��

3 × × × × * * * H�-@$i�2 H��L�~�2 Ha�=A��

0 × × × × × × × 0@N��A�� H�1D�$

3 × × × × * * * ���4��� H�1D�)�� 6�nT HqX�c5

29�82.9 6�17.1

0 × × × × × × × H��)@��1�� i

��j� g

�9�

44�33 �@�A�� H�%��AC�� ������� �1Q-�� 89�67 �@�A�� H�%��AC�� ������� �1Q-��

*'G���� P ×'G���� deP

R$ ¥4C�`2��� 6��X ]T H�%���A5 H�%��I$ C�� B�CD + �-)4C�� �$��CQ�� �@)-C�� �P��C�� E�F�� G��

?�@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%��P�� k� 44 � %��. �����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$33%, ���X �-�@ H�%���A5

k �-)4C�� �� H�%�I��89� %�. ����$ �1Q- ,S%�I$

67% H�%��I$ 3)45 6�CQ$ ]T ��X 0Af �q�2 ,���@)-C�� B���CD + �$��CQ���� ?���@)@A�� JK���� <����L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P��,st�C�� ]2� `2���� 3�1� �D

B��CD `�K�7 �LDT ]T �QcN?��@)@A�� JK��� <���L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I� �-)4C��

Page 19: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 95 –

`2i� 0K�c�� �� �$��CQ��� �@)-C�� �P��C��l Ha���S����p�$ d�� <�@� , 3)4�C�� 6�CQ50% 0�.T �-�@ ,

�� �$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� H�%��I� ��-@)45 B�CA�� `�K7 3)4�C�� 6�CQ�$ d�� <@� ,x$�®� 0Kc��17.1% ,

0K�c�� �F + 3)4C�� 6�CQ$ ��c�N� u1t ����2 ,���.qZ9 0K�c�� �F� �I-)4C� j H�%�I�� ±� ]T 89

S%�I$ k 2l 6�C=�� s15�� H��P@1bC%i� G��X�p , S%���I$2l 6���C=�� s15���� H���P@1bC?���@�i� G���Xp , S%���I$2l 6���C=�� s15���� H���P@1bC?����|@c�� G���Xp ,

S%�I$2 l 6�C=�� s15�� H��P@1bCH�@�r����� G��Xp , B��CD + x$��®� 0K�c�� 6��C£ ]T °-�)?��@)@A��

JK���� <����L�� M�N���L�� ����ON H�%���P�� y���bC� j k�� 2 ;6���ni� �������� H�K��K�C� ,�%i� G���X

��4���T �D%�f���2 ,H�@��r�����2 ,?����|@c��2 ,?���@�i�2 <��L�� 0Kc��l�@_�@)@A�� HqX�cC�� �X©p ,MF��2 j

� ��4�T R)4C��C��@)���� ����� V ^ ��-$ 89 `�����2 G�5 <�@= ,��@��;� ^ �-�� + �O-�� S��X9 �|�� ��$�AC$

3� +����� �� ��C£ + h)¤ �P��b �I)@)K5 G@ ��c$ �-7�X �z9 ���n ,H�@r�����2 �t�-��2 �@-PC��2 ������������� x�%��5 + ���I$ � �%2� u���5 ������� uCD ]T

�Lee, 2014 V� �DR�$ ¥4C� H�%��I$ ��LDT ]T �Q�cN `2����

B��CD + ��-@)45 �$��CQ�� �@)-C�� �P��C�� E�F�� G��C��

?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON ��H�%��P k� H�%�I��lk�)���� ?�K�PCta� W�X 6��C=�� �X�Q�p ,

2lG��C��� 6��� J�4���2 S��P�� ��PN 6�C=�� [{�p ,2lM�=C��2 <=1�� "�7 6�C=�� ¥@C�p H?�* <@� ,

3)45 �1Q- S%�I$ 0D68.4% u1t ]T <��1�� 6��2 , B�CD + H�%�I�� ��5 3)45?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L��

M�N�L�� ��ON �H�%�P� B�CD 6�C£ ]T 89 ���� ?�@)@A�� JK�� <���L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� M��¦ l �z��$HT���.?p <��=1��2 ?�K��PCta� W��X �X�Q��5 k��C��2 ,

�@5�F�� �5�%�. JfACQ� ]T u��b�� h@bCQ�2 ,M�=C��2 ����C�� R)4�C5 ��D ,¢2�b�� `Å�QC�� RX ��*~� +

¨�r�$ �@_�@)@A��l?�KPCta�p72 , S��A7 ¢��Z GC� �@�@)�X,m�)XT 0Af� �I@7 <=1�� u��b�� R$ u�b��2 V

�6�CQ��$ H�%���I�� ±��� U��g� �-��@4��c�-$ �� R��$ S%�I$ k 2 ,3)4C��l 6�C=�� s15�� H��P@1bC G��X

�%i�p S%���I$2 ,l 6���C=�� s15���� H���P@1bC G���X?����|@c��p 3)4��C�� 6�CQ��$ d��� <��@� ,10.5 % 0��A�

�1Q�N {C�52 ,S%�I$ S%��I$2 ,�4�c�-$ �����$l s15���6�C=�� H�P@1bC ?��@�i� G�Xp 6�CQ�$ d�� <�@� ,

3)4��C��5.3 V% B���CD R)4��C� j �����nT2?���@)@A�� JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P�� S%��I� ���.qZ9

l 6��C=�� s15�� H��P@1bCH�@�r����� G��Xp <�@� , 3)4C�� �1QN Ug�00.0%�T 89 ��z �X�� �� , ]T ��@

Page 20: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 96 –

�@r����� G@ �c�� %�1CXa� 3� Fn��5 B��CD J@��5 �-X�222 `[���CN�7 ����DT ���$ h��$ ����z m��7��C�2 ,?���@)@A��

(Vantassel & Wood, 2010) Áz���)N ���@�X�7 W��X �@t�%��� H������2 ^ �-�� G@)K5 + ��$�AC�� ^ �-��

���N�L�� ������ +V ��I$ 3)4�5 6�CQ$ ��c�N� m��C� �@72 H�%

Ug� kC��2 ,�$��CQ�� �@)-C��33% 2|��� <��1�� ]�7 ,JK��� ?�@)@A�� 6�C£ ]T 89 ��c�Na� ��z <���L��

M�N�L�� ��ON 6��� WX G��C�� mP=@� �c@��5 G5 H�%�P�� ?�@)@A�� B�CD 3)45 + ��[%� ��C a� RA� j2 ,�KP��

JK�� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON C�� H�%��I$ H�%�P�� ��@)- M���=C��2 <��=1��2 k��)���� ?�K��PCta� + �$��CQ���� 89 �f�� �F� 2 ,6��ni� �@)���� ������ ¨2�c �b%2

�@�t%��� u�CA�� ����b5 ��@�T�Winter, 2007���D , ¢��.� RQ��� ���r��� ���1X2�2016� 89 ���@�T w�³9

?��@)@A�� ^ ��-$ ���X9 ]�� + 3KC��� V ��qN ��D

��X 0Af�N >qC�n� H�%��I�� Ha��� 3)4�5 uQ �)X ^�2 {�� �5 ��F� ;?�@)@A�� B�CD + h%i�

�2016 � ?��@)@A�� B��CD + H�%��I�� h��[�5 �@�T WXM2�QC$ 0AfV

`2����� R�$ m1t ��2 32 ,42 ,52 ,6 ¥4�C� , ���P��C�� E�F���� G��C���� H�%���I$ 3)4��5 6�CQ��$ ]T

1bC��2 �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� �@)-C `�K5a�2 �@5�@;� H�P@ ?����@)@A�� B����CD + �$��CQ����� ����@)-C��2 ]2�����C��2

JK���� <����L�� M�N���L�� ����ON d��� H�%���P��58.6% , E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ 3)4�5 ���X 6�CQ$ d� �-@ ��@5�@;� H��P@1bC��2 ��@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� �@)-C �P��C��

+ �$��CQ�� �@)-C��2 ]2��C��2 `�K5a�2 ?�@)@A�� B�CD JK�� <��L�� M�N��L�� ���ON H�%��P��41.4% 3�1�2 ,

`2���7 H�%��I�� h@)� ��X 0Af 3)4C�� 6�CQ$ h%i�:

KH�L2 7 :4��� ������� ���� � ��� �� �� ������ ���� � �*� ���� � !��� "�#! ���$%&�P

'G���� 'G���� de �����&�

��$�� % �$��� %

�@)-5 H�%�I$ �@_�@)@A�� G@ �c�� 102 89.5 12 10.5

�@5�@;� H�P@1bC�� H�%�I$ 57 75 19 25 ]2��C��2 `�K5a� H�%�I$ 31 40.8 45 59,2

�$��CQ�� �@)-C�� H�%�I$ 44 33 89 67

�����&� I�m 234 58.6 165 41.4

Page 21: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 97 –

�<1� ��8n%�H ���W �:

­� � <=1�� Æ��: - � ]T <����L�� JK���� ?���@)@A�� B���CD R)4��C

��ON M�N�L�� ­�� ��$ W�X H�%�P�� : ���$�AC�� ^ ��-��STEMH�%�I$2 , �@)-C�� H�%�I$2 ,�$��CQ�� `�K5a�

E�F�� G��C�� �@�)X 3Q=C� ,]2��C��2V - ����@�T �7�����5 J������5 ����g��� �����|@��N~�

H�=�bK��)�� ���@_�@)@A�� + B���CD ?���@)@A�� JK���� <��L�� M�N�L�� ��ON H�%�P�� V - ?���@)@A�� B���CD 6���C£ G �Q���� ]T S%2·

]2���C�� m@Pv + H�%�P�� ��ON M�N�L�� <��L�� JK�� s15�� ]T2 ,HqAf�� 0; GI�$ �D%�f��2 R��no� h$ G���C��� m�P �¦ k�A� H�@r����� G�X H�P@1bC 6�C=��

E�F��V ���¡�� ��@)�X H��t�%� ?���*9 <�=1�� ¢P�2

������gC$ ]���A52 ,���@��;� ���t�%��� : ?���@)@A�� B���CD1,2,4,5 ?���@)@A�� B���CD2 ,H�%���P�� ����ON l ����O-��­Kc��pV

* * * H �)��&� '�S�TIL�$&�

oYH@ :'�+$ � IL�$&�:

�T ������)£ |���7 , �2011 V� ��@)-5 + ������ �bf�Ni� %2��@5�@;� H�%�I��V � ��$�P$ 0�)X ��.%2 �¬��)� M�-Q���

����®� �%���)�� <��L��: kX��b. 3� �D�,��� y��7�

"���®�2 ������� G@����C�� ,9-10�4�2011] ����X ,: S%�[2G@��C��2 �@��V

3�t�� ,��)£2 ;U��$ ,Y-�� �T�2017 V��$��CQ��� ��@)-C�� :���³�$2 � ���T2 �I$�Ic$ VS� �P�� : �@���� �X�)���

,-��2 u�%�C��V �n ,�´i��� �1997 V� G���)�� E�F��� G��C��� H����cD + �$�P$

�����V mf$� ��$�* ���, 13�1�, 32-20V 9��)£ ,M�2|�2 ;`�D ,%�-At �1994 V� ��@*���-AC�� + ��$�P$

�@)@��C��V]�X :h�[�C��2 ,-�� ¢qc�� �1CA$V 3Q�� U- ]�[�t ,�)X ^�2 ;�´T U- ����� ,{�� �2016 V�

cC�� H�%�I$ B��CD + �-)4�C�� �bf�Ni� + ��.�-�� ��A M�N��L�� }��L�� JK�� ?�@)@A��l��@�@�v ��t�%�pV ����

,G@KP�� ��$�* �@Qc-��2 ����� ������ 9�2�,458-421V ���)£ ��)£ ,��@;� �2003 V��5�@�@5��t�2 x�%��C�� m�_��Z V

S�=C�� �@���� H�%�$~� :k�$��� B�CA�� %��V ���t ,���)X ^���S����N ,x.���2 ;]�[����1X ,k��Cc��2 ; �2015 V�

i� + �@t�ti� ?�KPCta� H�t 3)45 6�CQ$ �bf�N����N�L�� ����)�� ?�@)@A�� uCD + �@�)���V ���� ���$�*

�� R��=1�� ,�@Qc-��2 ����� ����3�16�,516-487V ��1X2 ;��@1X �´T ,RQ� m�7�$ ,��r��� �2016 V� B��CD 0�@�v� JK�� ?�@)@A�� G����� ���4�. m�72 WX st�C�� <��L�

��@1��2 h)C���2 �@*���-AC��2 �S.T.S.E�V ���� ���$�* �� ���g,�@Qc-��2 ����� ��=151,458-436V

m��� �)£ ,RQ� �1994 V�Y��� H��gC$2 E�F�� G��C��V ����@��,�b. ��$�� 111�23� ,46-52V

`����N ,����|��2 ;�����n ,G@������ �2015� V H�����$ 0��@�c5 6���$ ?��@�i� B��CD + �-)4�� E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I� ?�@�i�

Page 22: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 98 –

G@K�P�� ��Pb-) M�N�L�� `2i� JK��V H��t�%� ����,xc-�� G�X2 �@�� + �@�X65�9�,188-159V

�´T ,h@% �@);��1X �2000 V��$�®� ?�-¡T G��)�� �@-I�� �@)-C��V Qc-��2 ����� ��=1�� ����@ �� [i� ���$�*,88,187-

155 V UcX ,M2�-b��2 ;M[�7 ,k-@,���2006 V��@)@��C�� Hq����� :

�@5�$����� YX + E�F�� G��C�� 0n�$ VS� ��P�� : |�D�$,-�� B�CA�� V

�@��t ,}��)f��� �2010 V� �@�t�ti� H�Q��� 3)4�5 6�CQ�$?�KPCtq�JK��� ?���|@c�� uCD + �@�)��� �bfNi� +

�����Q�� �@���� �A�)�� + M�N�L�� }�L��V ��@�2��� ���������� ��=�,31,151-122 V

��)£ ,k�1@�|��2 ;�I7 ,h��f��2 ;�´T ,]���4�� �2015 V� 6��$ �����Q��� �@���� �A�)�� + ?��|@c�� uCD 6�C£ 3)45

��§ 3�)���� k�X2 6�CQ$2 �@�)C��� �@)���� ���4P��V � ��� �@Q�c-��2 ������ ������−,R���=1��2�16�,197-

161V ��K��X ���)£ ,���@�Z �2009 V� G��C����2 G@����C�� H�@�@5���t�

`��c��. ��X] :h�[�C��2 ,-�� ?�©~� %��V >2Å���� ��1X y%��Z ,�$��X�2005 V�E�F��� G��C��� l��)@ �c$

2�QtT2 1@��tT�pVS� �P�� :h�[�C��2 ,-�� �@����� %����V X����1X `qZ ,k1X|��2 ;0)C� }� ,H��@1 �2005 V� H�%��I$

R�$ 82i� �qL�� >�cK�� ������ uCD + E�F�� G��C����I@)��$ ��ON ��*22 � ��C£ 0@�v `qn V ���$�* ����

���n ��������� ������ ,3�5�,92-6- V �� �1X �´T ,­��� �1987 V�bC��2 ����O-�� 3 E�F�� G��C��m�@1 V

U��A�� :0tqQ�� H�z H�%�f-$V

j��t ��)£ ,}��)��� �2005 V� u�CD + E�F��� G��C��� H�%��I$ �� ��C£ 0�@�v `q�n R�$ ���N�L�� ����)�� H�@r����� ��@���� ��A�)�� + w��15 ��Pb-) ��I@)��$ �ON �I*22

�����Q��V ,��5�$ ���$�* ,S%�f�-$ ��� �CQ*�$ ���t% i�]�%V

u��� ,°Q@X�T2 ;�)£ R GL�@ ,°Q�@X k�-2 ;���-�9 ,S��1��2016 V� WX 3)_�. 3@Q�%�5 3*z�)N ����Ct� �@���7

������� G���5 ��=N �1�b�� �@�7�� + k_�-1�� °=-��V ���� ,����. ]�b�Q��� ���$�* �@Q�c-��2 ����� H�t�%���

10�1�235-222V N�b�t ,¥��c���G�t�. U- �2015 V� u�CD 3)4�5 6��$ ����X

���ON ���I*2 R��$ ���@5�@;� H�%���I)�� �b��t�C�� ���������������� ���-��) �������� H�����$V ������� �������

,�KK�C�� 40�4� ,64-8V �@It ,M2qCc���G\��D RQ£ �2004 V� ����X9 + G@���C�� ����c5

M����� G���PC��2 ���@P�� + Áz��)NT G����� 0�@ �52 V]�X :y2,�� %��V -� ,]�X�P���)£ G@ ��9 ]� �2005 V� ��@_�@)@A�� G@ ��c�� 0�@�v

+ �b�t�C�� �@�t�ti� �����)�� ������ uCD + S�%����i� ��I*2 R$ �§ ���®� �@t�%��� H������ G��P52 ]�%

������ k)��$ �ONV ���$�* ,S%�f-$ �� �CQ*�$ ���t% �5�$]�%i� ,V

­X ,�)f. �2002 V�H�@�@5�t� ����Ct� �¡T)@ ��c�� �@gC�� k G@ ��c�� ±�1�� ���$��� ��1�Z H�%�K�5 ¥@=K�5 WX

?�@�i� + �@)����V ���$�* ,S%�f�-$ �� ��%�CD� ���t% ,x)� 3X�@���� Y$ ��%�I�.

�´T m@7�5 ,kX�$ �1998 V�G@��C�� ���c5 V ��X] :�Ac�� %��V

Page 23: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

�� �������� ���� , �����30 ����� ,�1� ������ ,�2018��1439� �

– 99 –

RQ� ]�@�t ,]�-�� �2006 V�@A�� G@ �c�� G��P52 0@�v + ��@_�@)]���Q�� ���N�L�� ������ ?�@)@A�� S��$ H�%�P$V ����t%

�������� ]���Q���� ����$�* ,S%�f��-$ ���� �CQ��*�$�@*���-AC��2V

G@����C�� S%�[2 �����Q���� �1433 V� ����ON M�N���L�� G@����C�� 0��@��H�%�P$V,x$��®� %����~� ������� : ����� ¨2,�$

@��C�� ���bC� |�|����1X R ���1X����� GV o��!�U :'�1GL^� IL�$&�:

Al-Ahmed, K. (1997). Introduction in the competencies of

self - learning for the Arab teacher. (in Arabic).

Journal of University of Damascus, 13(1), 20-32.

Al-Dalaan, A., & Al-Shayah, F. & Al-Zoghyby, M. (2015).

The extent of inclusion the content of physics books

in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia the social scientific

issues and the level of awareness about it with

teachers. (in Arabic). Journal of King Saud

University for Educational and Psychological

Sciences, 2(16), 161-197.

Al-dghaim, K. & Al-Zayd, N. (2015). The extent of

activation of the biology teachers of the self-

learning skills which included in the biology book

for the first grade secondary in Al- Qassiem region.

(in Arabic). Journal of Arab Studies in Education

and Psychology, 65(9), 159-188.

AL-Faleh, S. (2015). The extent of inclusion science books

which is taught in intermediate stage to life skills

from the point of view of science teachers in

Riyadh city. (in Arabic). Journal of Specialized

Educational, 40(4), 8-64. Al-Jabr, L., & Haj Omer, S. (2016). Critical Thinking Skills

in the Activities which included in the Book of

Chemistry for the Second Secondary Grade

"Analytical Study. (in Arabic). Journal of

Educational and Psychological Sciences Qassiem

University, 9(2), 421-458.

Al-Shamrani, S. (2010). The level of inclusion of the basic

features of the survey in practical activities in the

second grade secondary physics books in Saudi

Arabia. (in Arabic). The International Journal of

Educational Research, 31, 122 -151.

Billett, S. (2010). The Perils of Confusing Lifelong

Learning with Lifelong Education. International

Journal Of Lifelong Education, 29(4), 401-413.

Birk, J., & Kurtz, M. (1999). Effect of Experience on

Retention and Elimination of Misconceptions about

Molecular Structure and Bonding. Journal of

Chemical Education, 76(1), 124 - 128.

Essa, G., & Abou Libdah, E. & Beni Essa, H. (2016). The

effectiveness of using two instructional models

based on the constructivist approach in the student

motivation towards science learning. (in Arabic).

Journal of Educational and Psychological Studies

Sultan Qabous University, 10(1), 222-235.

Florida Department of Education. (2017, March 12).

Mathematics, Science & STEM Programs.

Retrieved from

http://www.fldoe.org/academics/standards/subject-

areas/math-science/stem.

Haj omer, S., Bucks, N., & ALmufti, A. (2015). The level

of inclusion of basic survey features in practical

activities in the books of chemistry for the

secondary stage. (in Arabic). Journal of the

University of Bahrain for Educational and

Psychological Sciences, 3(16), 487-516.

Hassan, A. & Abdu -Alreda, M. (2016). Analysis of the

book of chemistry for the third grade intermediate

according to the issues of science and technology.

society and the environment (S.T.S.E). (in Arabic).

Journal of Baghdad University for Educational and

Psychological Research, 51, 436-458.

Hassan, M. (1994). Self-learning and time variables. (in

Arabic). Journal of Education, University of Qatar,

111(23), 46-52.

Lee, Y. (2014). Comparative Analysis of the Presentation

of the Nature of Science in U.S. High school

Biology and Korea High school Science Textbooks.

National Teacher Education Journal, 7(2), 11-19.

Maxwell, J. (1985). The future of textbooks–Can they help

individualize education: A Bulletin Special.

National Association of Secondary School

Principals, 68–74.

Mok, C. & Cheng, C. (2001). Theory of Self Learning in a

Human and Technological Environment:

Implications for Education Reforms. International

Journal of Education Management, 15(4), 172-186.

Obaidat, H. & Al-Zouhby, T. (2005). Self-learning skills in

science books for the first three grades through

analyzing their content and the point of view of

their teachers. (in Arabic). Journal of King Khalid

University for Educational Sciences, 3(5), 6-92.

Osborne, J. (2014). Teaching critical thinking, New

directions in science education. Perspectives on the

science curriculum, 95(352), 53-62.

Rabiah, A. (2000). Professional development of the teacher

Page 24: ˇ ˆ˙ ˙˝ '() * '˙+$ '˝ & $%& # ! - KSU · 2018. 2. 9. · ˜ 1439 ˝ 2018 ˘ˇ , 1 , 30 , – 79 – ha˘ r$ ef g c ]t ™d , “% u˜˜x-52 h ˜˜ 5 f ˜˜ ,m˜˜ b i + ˜˜l

��;� ���X R �� �1X: B�CD + E�F�� G��C�� H�%�I$ 3)45 6�$?�@)@A�� VVV

– 100 –

during service. (in Arabic). Journal of Educational

and Psychological Research Al-Azhar University,

88, 155-187.

VanTassel, J. & Wood, S. (2010). The Integrated

Curriculum Model (ICM). Learning and Individual

Differences, 20(4), 345-357.

Winter, C. (2007). Edr-rcation for Sustainable Development

and the Secondary Curriculum in English schools:

rhetoric or reality. Cambridge Journal of

Education, 37(3), 317- 354.

* * *