ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh...
Transcript of ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh...
![Page 1: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Titleポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州における政府間対立, 1998-2004年(<特集>インドネシア政治への新たな視座)
Author(s) プラスティヤワン, ワフユ
Citation 東南アジア研究 (2007), 45(1): 120-136
Issue Date 2007-06-30
URL http://hdl.handle.net/2433/53875
Right
Type Departmental Bulletin Paper
Textversion publisher
Kyoto University
![Page 2: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
����������� ����������� ����� ������������
������� !"�#�
The Political Economy of Post Soeharto Indonesia:Intergovernmental Conflict in Riau, ���������
Wahyu PG6H:IN6L6C*
The present study focuses on changes in Indonesia after the fall of Soeharto in ����. Itexamines a dispute involving the central government, a provincial government, and CaltexPacific Indonesia $CPI%� a multinational company based in Riau, over an oil block calledCoastal Pekanbaru Plains $CPP%& After democratization and decentralization, a newpattern of Indonesian politics has been in the making, the characteristics of which enableprovincial politicians to create political networks with those who are powerful in Jakarta.Such political networks'initiated from the provincial level'did not exist within the NewOrder state. However, the CPP conflict illustrates their limits. The governor of Riau, SalehDjasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able to set upa political network with powerful local and national politicians. Without substantialpolitical backing, his challenge led to defeat and the dispute directly resulted in a climateinhospitable to foreign investors.
Keywords: Indonesian political economy, decentralization, institution, local politics, Riau������(#)*+�, ���� -./01� 23� -. �� ����
I � � �
456,789�:;1�-./01<=,(#)*+�, ���>/?@�ABC�D
EF89� ����+�GHIJ@�KL#M�NOPQ $CPP% RSTUVWPX
0>YZ�[R>\]@�AB^� ����F2_`9ab^CcVdefg,hi-.j
klmnopqcSr� �8*s��tGAulvwx>yz{YSR�AB>|@D
AA^R} �8*s��tGB9� ~� ��m�� u,���t��� (#��t���
���cS�rd���V���,�*G+�#>e��� C� ��G�tl�,�3u
� (#)*+������ $LSI%� Lembaga Survei Indonesia, Wisma Tugu Lt. ���, Jl. KH.Wahid Hasyim No. ���, Jakarta �����, Indonesiae-mail: wprasetyawan�gmail.com
��� ��� �¡ �¢ ���� �£
120
![Page 3: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
��������� ��������������������
�� !"#���$ %&'����&()*$ +,-�./�012.�3456�
�!+7�89��:;7�9<=��%. >?4$ CPI.@ /A�BC��DE�F
�� CPI./�C�B�G� � �� ���� �HA��I����JK��'%LM�
/��NO5���� ���P��Q�$ ���RS5/TUF���� Q�M�B'
%L�H/G����RV�W�5��X�Y�5ZJ�I/56��� A��M��
[����Z��\5]���I/�H���^S��F���
������/U���$ ���� ?_$ <=��%�`�U !BaP�bc$ [�Dd
/��������"X�e�Tf�Ug�B#�5U��F�/F�I/�6�� ���� �
%(%��hi$ $ ���� �8j!k%&'l(/[�m�)nS$ �RS5Yc$ ��op
!���qBrH����*��sJ�I/�f�U�����tuB+�G�F�� I��
��RS5NX�vw�[�<��k�%PxT6���Uc�y5ec$ ��z'*k�
���,-5 F��"��T� {Sakai ����; Aspinall and Fealy ����; Kingsbury and
Aveling ����|$����.}5 F��"��T�{Turner and Podger ����| U~T��
//0xG�P�� 1��$ �<�!9�'*�$ �2���z'*k��Bf�F���*
�B3�xG�TR�����4Q�F�/n5�$ [�67�f���HG��8[�T�
��x/�2���9���x567�ZJ�F� {Malley ����: ���|� I���vw�:�
��RSB�������c�;�5��G�vw�6�I/T6��$ ��5����r�
<5bQ����Aop!���/�c=xG�T�/�����B�F� ���$ ��5
���op!���q��BA�5����>�U����9�/��,-X�56��
��$ ()�!�/��7k�*�T`�U�?����bc$ I���A��NO�g@
5�GUQG��RSm�����T6��PUF� �����$ ���� �8j!k�RA�
m5�G 6�I�f�F����*5 F�$ '%LM5���6���"X��
Mop!���q�����()�!�/�B NO$ ()�!�/�����7k�*�
���5Y��¡¢xG�� £5MC¤B[�������7k�*�����FG����
�����U�� ¥�$ ����7k�*�BUQG��������F� [��J$ A�
/��BaP�¦§$ MC¤B()�!�5F���q��/�7k�*�����FG�
¨©*��sJ�I/B�P�� '%LMC¤�¦§$ ��ªD5bF�TMop!�TrH
����7k�*��«E�F¬�� ���op!���q��/�FNO��ce®�I
/5¯G��°Q�U�$ Mop!5bF��'%L�H��n5X� ±'%Lr7²I³ �
>�´3µ� �¶�6��1·¸9·1/T��¹¬�UHU�����6�� [�Dd$ M
C¤�A�/���5bF�GG���6��
����«J�?4�Kc�6�� �º�L �M/L �M�8j!k<�4�'%LM��
�:»�¼8k98j!k½5bQ�����
121
![Page 4: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
������� II�� � �������������������� !�"#���
�$%� III�� �&'(� IV� � )*�+,�������-.�/01234
562�7�89:�7;:�2<����$%�
� � �������� �
����= �> �?� ����@ABC, D���BEFGH 5IJ:� )�K�L�<�MN
:�O�� ����2P(5QR� S�,O�P(5TQ:�UV2 �� � WX2)�K
�L�,YZ[\��R�� ]M^_�`ab�,_4c���^<��d;,ef�!�
gMardjani ����: ��h O� ijk�l� mji��l� njoLp�l� ���qrsl<
�^t� ����=uv ��w��������OP,xy !� ����=�z(:�
����{|}2����� � ~2�;���� ������2����������i
�,���^�&�5����� ����=��������������2�|������
:� �e���[�d;,yR�!���2��� I����;E�� �������{�
����� ����=<� ����=��2�� ��i�21 ¡ ¢£ ����¤�����¥
��i� � ����{|}2¦§�¨©�� �����ª�«L¬2��®¯j°�®
+¥ ����=±�e�² ��¤� ����=±�e�² ��¤� ����=±�e�² ��¤� ����=±�e�²�¤� ����=±�e� ³´µ¶2 ����¤21 ¡���� gKompas ��/�/�h
�� � ����
·¸�¹�º» ��¼ �w
122
![Page 5: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
����������� �������� �Lutfi ����: ����� �������� !
�"�#�$%&%'���()��*+,!-./ 0,�12!3�4�$%&%(5
��!6�� �7�/ �����8�-6!�$%&%�� ���(�9 ���� ��:
1.��7��6 ��:��;�0�/<=!/�3>?�(�@AB,C�� �:��D
�ED�C1F�G�CHI/ 3�4��J3KL��M����!�C�2�0�7+/ N
O%L�� ����3>?��P ���QR/NO%L�STU!�"V#$�C0��
H72��
W�R/ NO%L�X�%Y�Z&�[2!��\]^'�(_�C���)*�`+�!
62��a bY��)*,c�-d!e./ �FbY�W�)*�fg��.�/eC� N
O%L�hi�$%&%��0)�C)*�,c� �Robinson �����/ j�/ k�.����
�0)�C)*,c���� NO%L��01��!i�0)l�_./ 2mn%�j3o
�Chi�45�+Y�pH+q/$%&%�rst6uv7 wDewan Pembinaa ��!t6
��xly�_C0�2mn%�j�x���(_�C0�(z� �Shiraishi �����
0F��i�$%&%�0)�<=!/ 8.����{��|�C ���9 �}8�~{
�C0�/ NO%L�:h����7�#$l���L�K%��� 0�8�/ ��vu
(;<����7�=��A�C(/ r�.����7�W��=��;�>7+�01�
12!#$B,/ �01�?#�@F�B,�� 0�1F��7�A^'�0)�C0�/
���A�L���;���.���:�NO%L��B�C0��H2��
W,�<=!/ NO%L�/ >��C(�D�EF��G2!W�b6�*�������
C�Hp��.I�C0�/ ��'����J,�0)��-6�� ��A���k��z
��!K�72�� I���A� ��:QI�>��C7+�=L���B��C��H6
M�e2� �Kuntjoro ������
0F����.�k�.)*(,cB,�(�=�/ NO%L�"V�;���.��N
B�C0�(z�� I�"V��2!���O$�NO%L�772!6�QI/ NO%
L�PQ�RF�7H72�� "V�;��D�S�TU�HgNO%L�TU� =/
j���.��NO%L�?#�@2�� W�!/ �����\].�l�VW�j�NO%
L�45������H2��
3�4�-6!�/ �����NO%L(¡¢£!X¤���S�S¥�¦K%�a�"V
,a YZ[�-6!� §)* winstitutiona¨ � §\�H©]��C�*�ªK«¬�®£K�¯Y!°��M���C����.I�+,�"±�©]¨ �^)�!-g �North ������
-a ��� �² ��_/ `¡¢£�³3´%Oj,� µa�Q��-.� ¶�Sbµ¤ w���a/ >µ¤ w���a/ scµ¤ w����a· ¸de¹)fi w��a/ giµ¤ w����a/ hiµ¤w����a/ heº»h w����a
£>U�¼NL�NO%L½�-*C��\]
123
![Page 6: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
�������������� ������� ������ �� ������������
������������ Rab ����a: �!� "#��$%�&����'()*���� �+
,-./�012�3456�� �����78� �+,-./.9 ���:#� ��'
��-�;<�=���56> loc. cit.!�
� � ���������� ����� CPI
�����?@A�BC��DEF�G�H>I�5J� K�����L��� �M��
�������56>��DEFNOPQRS��,T��U � VW��X� YCPS� �Z
[\�]�^_��]`�#��ab2�I�56>� VW��X�5���DEF'c@d
��e)� f�X��gh��5�\VW���&�[\&��bi� Bartlett � ���:
��!� � �� ?@A�/C�A��d��jkl>I�5� A�ghmn�op>�n�q
r`�#�����Usp�I�56>� �������Usp tq!�"h�u>�6
� �� �����v�'wxk-�;�# �H>I�'5���
CPI �� y���i>z{'�+,5|{�}p��� ������I�56>� f����
$?~��T��+S�D��%�A�/C�����' �����A�'%&bi )>
I��'����56>� I�'��Z[�� ~��T��+S�D��T%�A�/C��
���()*A�/C YNV Nederlandsche Pacific Petroleum Maatshapij� �G���� �
C� ������+����D���+����,��#�� -��.���}��� f�
� ���������5�p A�'/�bi�� P����+��>������0�1�2
�'�1�:�H> �����3�4��C�|{����� ������EF��5����6�
��� ���� CPI C' ����7$���& ¡�]��}����� ����3�4�
��56>� f� � �����3�8� �~�¢q£' CPI �{9X� YCOW� �3¤� ����
3�8������q£'PQRS��,T:)>��DEF��U CPI C�VW��X
��3¥2��
����q£� CPI C��¦�3¥i�X��� � ��DEF� CPI C�VW���
§8� �; ��<¨�� A�g=� �©' CPI C�ª«�5� ¬«� �© Y������
� ��®$��� ���~�D�>i>I��«� �n��+,��¯\ª«�'��
Colombijn ����!�
K[) � ����?°@±���+,-�qr'"��:�AB������>I��H
>�
.� ����� ��² ��C� D�����³´,�V¨i� �E�µ¶��«� ?�·¸�¹ Y�������F��¹ Y������ ?�G� Y����
DH+�+º» �¼ �½
124
![Page 7: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
II ��������� �����
������ �������� ��������������� ������
�� ��������������� ��� !�����"#$%����&&���
��'�����(����"�)(#*��*��(!��������� ��!� �+
,-� ./01�23��������4��� CPI5��6�7�� �������8%9�
&�� ��:��6��;�< ��=!�>& !� (&(���� �������"?�@#
(!ABCDEFG�� ��:�H���$ GIAJK��L%*��� MN���4
���O(P%&(�Q#*���"�< (R��L%S'�TU%9���& !��V �
"?���"W(X�)*�+,�Y%Z�#� �����[-��4\"$�����;
��"].^/�_>�01�2���! �����` J��&�� ��;�34�a
b��"�56$�c7LdPe0fgF�&�� ���5&�hi%j8� k'� ��
j8l �9+�� !� �"?�:%�m+� '� ��cXn!o��%&(!!i�� �
�` J6#p;��8q� �4���%(���(��<Z$&=�>orL9��#�
�& !�
Q!� ABCDEFG��4�s��gGtJuv+�*w?(!� @�x�/�A�
�yB#$%�#� x�/�A�Cz��4���{KJ|8�L%9��#�8}~D�#
$ !� (&(���� A�B#�E�@�� �4����.eIF�� �P8%R��
��rGn���& !�#$%� �����DE/����s�H�(�%IZ�J���
�KK�"�#KL�M�Li!FE�t0C��Gf#$ !�q#$%� (&(� FE�
t0�ABCDEFGf*$�Q����cX(!NO��^P�M�L%9���Q(!�
-#�P� ;��������"7����hi%�h�M��*�RL%9���& !�
;8#�Qq� ABCDEFG���0�&�T��P9��L%� @� �����&� ��
�Q#/0.��"?�Li!�S#$+� DE/����T��P�0�{� G���
a����W��UVL%��������������^/��W#*$ !� /0.�
�"?[-� ABCDEFG���:����X���PY��Z"���z�� DE/�
���0�{� G�Y��[�$�%9��\i!��V /0.��:�&���"?�
/V ABCDEFG� ��� �� �]� ���ID¡G#^Q8!� ¢£Q# ��¤K#¥���� ������¦§¨_^¥£ ©SecapaV �`¥(��S�a�bª«i!� ��������Xc�¥�d¬(!� ��#�E ���e�®XBf#¯°(!�� �����&� ����&-� ���/0.��"?���i� ���&� ����&-��±²³�� !�
0V 9�T������ ´µ¶ Forum Keadilan ·����/��/��: ��¸ ¹º�
t»¼�½�C������-%����
125
![Page 8: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
����������� ������������ ����������������
���� !"#���$%�& '(��)��*��������+�,�� �
��-�.�+/�0+1�'����23$%,�& �� � �����$�/�0�/
45����+���('�+1,�& �6�� � �78�9��$�/45��:;�
<�6+"�$%=� /454>� �?@=AB� CDE��F����6G��
1B1,�6?$%�& � CDE��F�H$�������I2JK3D���LMN
�O 1=+1�'�+!"P�#�QB� R�#%6?�S+$#���/T�<%=&
�1 &6� ,����U��VDWXY�+1Z[��6��������I2JK3D�
�<'P�\ ]^� ()� R��M_N `�aYb�<Dac�*+d"+,�-ef�
./�� ���������+�,��'(��� CDE����g0[+�$h1
& '���23ij+� *+��kl�VDWXY�+m �����������&n
�12$%=3o�&�p
�?+��������+�,�q,6 r,����4�9�ds$%�& 5t-+u=
�4v%<w6-���vx� y2z{�a�7�|�89� Dac/+m ��:4-�.
�+;,�& ����<}=>?@�w6�~A1B�$%,� ����<CB�$�� ����4
�Dac/$D�4���E,��� j� R��FG� �����$%,�& ������
����<CB�.��FGH ���+I��H ��,�'�+1=� R��9J��)��
S,�& D>4+1,������WXG �KL5t4$%=� ������F����& R
��� d"��4� M5MN4� �O4� ,�y��E���4<3 � �Kompas ����/�/
��& R�vx� Dac/+mo��9P):;��4H:;6?[�����4�Q���1
��RS+�,�& R�'�<vx���� ����4+�TmB��������<�
�1=+���U+V��Dac/�����(���+�66�? � /W��SGS1
�9P)S�k¡¢�'�-e(+���$%,�& £+� '(��:4-u=�Dac
/��9+¤X¥h¦'�� §w6Dac¨Y© ª� B'�+P�&
III � � � �
«$�� y2z{�a6?Dac��Z[&¬k� §w6Dac¨Y© @=¡¢�
®¯�F<��u(1\6$�Z[&¬k� S�� '�¨Y</��9+��u(+��
1p ��������</�0+1,�6?�������I2JK3D����:;"#�3o�]�� ����<+Dac�°±5²^&���h+��2�qC��³´�� ,�������I2JK3D���Nµ¶·¸o�'�6?�(6<j�& '�_+* �� Jawa Pos �����/�/��� ¹º&
`aa�a»¼ ��A �½
126
![Page 9: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
����������
�������� ����� ������������ ��������� �
���!���"�#����� $%&'(��)*+�� �,-.��/0����1�
234� ��")5���6��!7� 8/�9�����:;<= �>���� ?@
ABCA@��DC�EFD>G �����H IJ�7��� �� KFDJ����L
��!��� ����� ��M��"��N�O#�.P��QR�ST�U���0
V��
?@ABCA@��DC�EFD� ���� !"�#3�9�0� )*$9�%W�
� !"�&'�(XDY%CFZ[&�'\]�� ())*] ^() ��_ �*7+
�� `Albintani ����: ��a� (XDY%�b30��() ���,-.>c/�O� 01<
=>d=4>">����2�3�240�34e�O!�>�� ^������fg�5�h
60i7<=>d=4>">�� ()�>"$9�87>�"j9k��:l�m�<n�o
��0p�� q=q=�!"�b3 �>">�� ()�0r�s� >t>"u=�v ��
$9��!;<���V��"s_ `Jakarta Post ����/��/��a�
?@ABCA@��DC�EFD�(XDY%CFZ[&��wx�y��KFDJ��z
=�2"��{�y��jO�� (XDY%CFZ[&��|}T~>?�0�����@�
AB0V#� F�����z=��CD�>���<�KFDJ���E��0V��� ��
�� ?@ABCA@��DC�EFD�F.'G.>�[��A�%&�j1�
2"�� KFDJ����)*�u�M�HI�'� J�|.>�0K\� p�o��
"� KFDJ���L����L��1����� MNO���� �����|���P�
KFDJ�2��|.�#�p� ��'KC��BI��N�>�O!��#��"= �
��Q34�KFDJ� ����R>�������S��c/�{T�d�sd0>.�
��.�J�'I��U� �"��|�L��"�c/� >���0V� `Barr ����;
Peluso ����a� KFDJ���f� ���VW �¡X�¢£�o�0 ���¤d��
¥���Y¦��� ZX�$%&'(��)[\]� ��§ ¨ �© ����^ª�?ID« �j>
�J¬�_� ^)`�_�« ��a��� ���� u!��J¬�_�Rb�®¯X.[��
c�£q= p�[�0V��� )`���!X.{T�d�O� � ZX� �©ª�?ID
�[��d°e±�£![����²A%³I(´%c��fµ����« o!��gh�?
2« )`���!24�KFDJ���O�[�¶i�hj�<��j�0V�� ZX�)`��� k·<=��� V���k·<= �>�[��"1�� �2�� ��� W �lW ¸�~G�
3« ²A%³I(´%c��>=4� ��¹e<=�D²�u�m�no�p�q9ºr�£q=��
Y»¼�½KJCKFDJ��¤d��|��
127
![Page 10: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
����������� ���
���������������� ��������� � �!�"#$��%��&�'
�()*� �+�,��-."�/01234���3536��7�8*$��
6�)�9: �+� 6;$��<��: ,��-=�" >: ?@"A�B����
�"�C*$��D�C9� �$�*+ ��� �+"EFG: ,��-�����H
"�;$I�J6��K��J6 �$�� *: ,��-"�L"��9M�
��C�J6*+: ����N�O��PQ�R���8�: S�T��UV�6�)W
,��-X����Y�� ,��-Z �: ����N�O������ 6
�$��+�!�"��"#[\�]^"_$"�`*$JC*$�ab �C*$�� S
Fc%"&'C��: ����N�O��,��-=�: PQ()�*de ��G*f*:
��g"h�$iI�!�*++�jkF�J6� �$� lDerks ����: ���m�
,��-,-R: �������6������������N�O��n"of.!p&
�/�601�� 6fhb: ��� !�23�4q�6I"�: �+�5?6rs�tu
v���w3,�x0yz4�{-"���|}7�~8��� 9��f���� S�
��6: �+� 9�������6�8����9� ��6�):;��<!�A)
"Cf: �+���� ��������� 6�)W"=>�� ���������?��/
�����@$I�PQ�A�B"��� J����,��-"A��=��"�h�9
�: ������6"8��9�+!�=���!�C�a6D�kF��
*: J����E��FG��H"��I�C�%�$J�9�+�� ���tu
�{-���������&� �e �f: ����8���K!���C�La601
lAbdurrahman ����: ���m: ��,�3�"��9������� ��������� � ��
%�t�3�� a6�V�b�� lGamma ����/�/��: ��m� ���tu�{-� ����M�
N"O �� �����7� � ��¡!�J6�PV���: �u�¢0��£{¤���
9!����QR¥�¦SkF�601�*+JS �$�� *: �§"�����+
� 9!�����$TE�UU�¦SkF�J6 : �H�%�$J!��EC+`: ��
��$T�PV��`9C�V¨�W*+���tu�{-�X%YZ"�!�A:©9[$
�� �a: �§�6J(�: O �� �����7� � �j\e���ª��]5^����
}7��_��K��6��K`: ���$TE�UU����}7�8�«¬�b
��hb �C*$��
�����`�®J¯ ��������� �aI�V���$TE��!�J6�b�
°K���*c* �C�: ±(: �²³v�C 9�>�!�J6 V¨�W*+
����"#[\�~��Af5´do!�J6�°K��µY��¶�� *: V¨�
W�����"#[\�·�!�8¸C¹e�fkC�J6*+: ��������� �[\�
gh�t�º» ¼ �½
128
![Page 11: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
������������� �������������������������
�� � �! �������"#�������"$%���� &'�(�� )! ��
*�+,-�./012+34567� 89:;<�=���>?����@AB��
� 89:;<�! 89C����D"E�! � �4089�F���3G�H�����
�IJ�����KF�L�� ����8M�N*O��P"�Q��R��S3�����
T"�� ������U�$%�VWLX! � 89:;<�=����� ��Y��
������� ��Z?B�� 6 ! N*O���"[ ���\�39]�&����
^" _X�`� �� �7� �`Ba! N*O�!���bc"W�S3��dKF�>
?� ��($%7B�� ��L��� ����� �e��fg! h8#N*Oi�j ��
���k$�l�?B! N*O�m%�n� h8#N*Oi�j �k&o'�^?��p(�
������q N*O�m%����S3��r��)*�s����W! ��bc"��t�
L������W h+Vj � �67! �����,- ���� uN�v�&����
�.Ww^�� ��fg! �����x/����N*Om%Wfy�� ��p(����
���� *-0*z{-W�����|}~� �0� �W! �"�� ������&�
����� ����
����W12367�%� ��! �4���0����v����-��56���
7"�B���R�8%�������� �4���3����56� ������"x/ �
��W! �B�LU���N*O������399��"�������L��� ����
��! ����"��6! L���N*O�����k$"o'��K<"dH �6�
¡:"¢£a�7�6����L�� ¤¥��! �4���0����v�399�^��S
3��r¦G�§B��
IV �������
� �� �
¨��©ª����! ��0����vW ����;«��< �o hN*O�%<;j �¬"
®¯�^�6�� ���S3����r��°="±U7�¢�� �S3�67�! ��0
����v�<;"®¯��( )6N*O��!���Q�>²"³ ����´�¯
�7B���L�� N*O����QWw^� ��! �dµ]�¶������·¸�L�
��
��q *-0*z{-W�����??�� h8#N*Oi�j "@�� �����W! k&"o'�� ���^�6���
1.¹�º�v0�{-v»����39¼½
129
![Page 12: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
����� �������� ��� ��� �������������� �� ����
��������� !�"��#$%!&�'����(���)"�*+,� -��
������./��01�23�� &�45�� ��6��� ����� !23�)
"� 7Blackburn ����: ��8* ���3���)������ ��� ��� 9$:����
;;� �� <�9$�=��>��23���?@9$@�ABC!*��D ��E� FGHI
JKL��M� ���6N���)����� ���O�P�#Q!�"�132R� �ST
+UVW�2X0�� <�9$�YZ��![����\]X�* �9�� �(����3
���)�^���[�9$�+,_`abSc��)��d�0� ��M� ��6N��)
"�*
+,_`abSc��X0e�\]X���� ��� ��� �f!g\]!�����
"#hijklHIU�%![�\�(���mRnoC�[�\]X�* +,_`abS
c�� �����"#hijklHIU�%![��pq��%9X��� ���� �$
r%&��0=� !�'R%1�() ![��\�� �3 ![�\+,_`abSc
s�*t�u"![��\���\]!*�9��+,�+v��M ��6N�vw�(���
^��� ��%BR� ��6�MN�v�+x�0�� 7Jakarta Post ����/�/�8* �(���
y1�\�� CPIz�TJ�{|�%,}� !�H~�b������45�-�.��1
0�� CPIz��H~�b��FUc|U�/� !M� ��6@9$�13w�\]X�
7Bisnis Indonesia ����/��/��8* �(�������FGHIJKL����0�9?�0
�����$%9X��"� 1g������23�4��1X�* � -��X0�m�M
� ��6@��13���% ���<���5���C���(���+v���C!B�
��19%9X�* 9�1X0� +,_`abSc�������)��(����oQ!@
���Sc�U���(���ZX01%9X�* @9$[�� �(������23���
���6#Q![�����01X�*
� � ������ � � � ��
&�$����"�X0�����23������� !�"�� �(���7;��
8��X�* ;"�� �� �9$������ 9:;�¡¢�<=��[�\]R� 7
;"��� �>�]!b��£���h�?¤�¥¦��[�\]!* >@�§��� �
-9$��¡¢�;10�¨©�%9X��w99B$ª� �� 9:;�¡¢�<= !
�13�h��8����\]!* >@�§��X0�� A«¬UJ���B6�� �®¯
�FT�\��B6���°�01![�9$� #$%!��B6�)�pq�0±²�C
��D �³���_�´W µ�J_�³¶J�D·D ���H�V¸U� ����� � ��E� ¹GHIJ�0*
AF�`�º» �¼ �½
130
![Page 13: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
����������� ���� �������������� ��������
������� � !� �"#�$��� ���%&&'�(� ���) *+,�
�������-.��#��� /��-0�*+,�1���23����4-��-
�5���&�� 6Albintani ����: ���7� 8��� ��#�19��:����� � *+,
��� ;!��"8<��� =�� �$��%� *+,�&�����> �?���
#@A�� *+,� BC�#���� ���D#E&� ��� ���)�����
*+,� ��� �����$FG�� *+,���������� @EH%#��%�
E��� ���
*+,���IJK� LMNL� OPJP� Q*KP� *PR�$� �S�T���&�
U��VW� X�YZ[!�&\IJK����� IJK�'%](�^���� *+,
��� ��#�� �����YZ� )*_ ���&�+`��a b� ��� �
� cW,��V��� ����-�deJfL�ghi�����IJK� ���-�.j�
k����� ����-�� lPmno+� oPRpqe� rsqo+�t/ >�YZu0�
v�w1�����x"#� y23z�ko{|* }~o� PRpqe� rsqo+� ~{� |
�qe� lPmno+� ~*� +,�45�����%�� �E#lPmno+��x� *+
,��IJK�����G�� �8G�� �G� *+,YZ�X�67����'��
%��#��
oPRpqe��+���$�-�� *+,���YZ��.W80���>����
$��������oPRpqe�lP����9� ���*P�#�$��� �^���
� 6Yue ����: 7� XG��A�� oPRpqe&��$�-�� IJK*+,�V��T
��:����S����� oPRpqe&��:� }oPRpqe��;�V?�B��%
��� � IJK�V����:��<?��-�IJK��B���=��a��A� 6Yue
����: ��7� ��#�&�W���:�� IJK��>�� ����#�$�� ���>�
IJK� ¡��%� �W� ����-¢; ��£ ¤�#� �¥?me�@�:��¦-
�$� 6Royle ����: ��7�
*+,���� �8GG�YZ��A&�IJK�����%&&'�(� *+,�
�� � � �G�����YZ��UW ��$�$�TB�6 #�� @(� C�.
��� *+,��§D��=*+,��¨rM�9��>�©ª#�VW� *+,���
��#�� #�%YZ��UW ��$���� ���� @�� � #��#�%���
§D ��¥e«+��¬@W� X��=��j�.�%� ���E#�� 8��� *
+,��� ��#���8GG�� �����¥e«+�®¯/�� R¨&��§D�F°�±�
������²F��
��� �³´?µ��¶`�%��$�� ·¸�V$������ ¨rM�9���
¹�º�p¨M»¨¼eM½�V��19YZ
131
![Page 14: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
��������� ������������ ����������������
������������������ �� ��!�"�#$"%�&��' (Wee
����: ���)* +&�� ��������,- �.�/��0#"�#$"��&'*
1'� $21�34�����5%�6��� 7 �898'0��������:
;<��"�#$"��=�>?���'* � @ !A�� 7 B��A�"!&��
�� ��������C�����;��DE%�$"��F"�#����&�� �=
�G�C���HI&'* ���H��� ���;���G�C���J��K��LF
!&'���* $#��� ������M�N1&'*
� � ������ � � � �����
O ��P&'�#QR�S!�T"�"UVW��&'* XYZ[\]8�^����
����&�_`ab\cd#$��%��e�fT"�"UVW���'���* �^
�&�!��� e�fT� 7'������(g�N���� O ��e�fT �"
"UJ$"�_`ab\cd#$�h��%%i�jk�l�mn%o$"��F"�
#p!��&'*
����)�q��*� XYZ[\]8�^������r���� s+tuv�_`ab\cd
#$�w��� ��xyz{8|�e�fT,-%}~$"%6��.%��'*���
XYZ[\]8�^�� e�fT,-%��{8|�w���$"�_`ab\cd#$/
0%�1J4�2���"#"�'* e�fT�w��� O ��"&� �R�34��
"�~�2'�#��* 1�� ��������%5����$""� ��� � ���
�'%N�$"��* 1��<�R���� �6����#%��&����L$$"
%7�'��� e�fT,-�� �{8|��}J$"����S!��"����
�&'* _`ab\cd#$��%�e�fT����� ��e�fT,-�yz{8|��
}�!k2�� e�fT����89��1&�_`ab\cd#$�:��Y�;��}~
�2'�� ;�<��LF'�J�=����� O �"����#�'��f% >�
'&'���*
1'� O ��e�fT,-%}~'��� _`ab\cd#$/0�w¡� ���
�'%N�"�#? ��&'���* Z[\]8�^�e�fT,-%}~1@"
�� ¢£����¤¥"¦ "�#§A%B�'�� ¨©��e�fT,-%}~$"��
����'%ª�«¬��&'*
e�fT�r�� $�_`ab\cd#$/0%CDJ¤E"��� O ��[®
��� Z[\]8�^¯\°±²³�]�a®´������rµ¶²·¸e®¹��. (����/�/
��)*
FG�·�º» ��¼ �½
132
![Page 15: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
���������� ���� ���������������� �������
�� ����� � ��!"�#$�%&�'(&�)* � +,-.�$�� ��
����/.0*����� 12�3456���7�.� � ��89�(���)
�:;<��� ���=>*����?�=�%&���@AB�C�D���� �
����EF�B�C���:; G�H &IJK��L�� G� �H &IJK���M�� N
�O �� ��.�12�3456��P+�Q!RSTI&IJ%&<�F��
UVWX4Y�"#& ��$%:;�Z&�![*� \]��^�_`�12�3456
���$a�b'.cI*� ���D��� G� �H �B�C�� ���=�&IJ
d(�![�Me���T:F�� ���� \]��^�_`.)f�*g� N�/,�+
h.,$�iJ.#$����� ���NM�-,Se��)TjTg� ���� ��P+
��=�%&�,$�)f�UVWX4Y�"#.*F�����
.I*� ���12�3456���/Tj&k ��l��m�� � 0.1n=�%
&�23&�*� 56���P+�o4�iJ&��� N��$.� � �pq5rstV
uv�� ��w\xy z{|� BSPy� �67��� N�*� �� BSPy}� ��l�
89�� ~:� ����4� �;�=�&<>� �Bisnis Indonesia ��/�/�; ��/�/���
���= ��.� BSPy&����2<��w4�v�&��<12�3456���
�s=�x���� C�67=�%&.�O����� >=� ��.�!"?@� ��&=�%
&<k�O�� �Buletin Warta Pertamina ��/�/���
�:�� A�&BC��.8=� ���=D �E���RM�%&<� ���F��G
d5.H������ �������X� �0�A��BC���IJKL��M=�N
OP&�* GA��BC��IJKL�M(8H zBalaks� �Eg� w4�v�.9F*
Balaks��Gd5&TF����� CPIy&��G�QM� ��= ��� BSPy&w4�v��
x���� C� Balaks& �=��R�S��G�N�.TD��� %��G.ig� ��
�� Balaks���*12�3456��<��RM�A�� ��l���=�%&.Tg�
��� � �"�<��RM��RNU "�R�¡¢ .£¤RM� ��= ���¥/ G12�3456���� ��k�� NM��¦IH .�� �������&����§¨��!V� �������� ����= �� ��W� �R©M� ����=:; ��=.u�2�� �/�X$��&� � ��ªYD«Z¬� ����=:;�� �������� zMPR� ��X$������=���/�<�\]��^�_`.[M*I��
��� 12�3456���� ��B�C:;��/\]��^�_`�\f� �������]� ����/��/����
��� � ���/:;UVWX4Y�"#�\f� ����/��/������ w4�v�� BSPy^y��®)�� ������� zBSPyF��� W¯��\°C zw4�v�F�� ]� ����/�/���
��� A��IJKL&�� ±��_U� ²³� `ab�c´�o,�µ.�J7�� ³¶� R�©<�/Vd·�¸=�
�¹º�»�`���4`¼.c[��q�½
133
![Page 16: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
������������ ����� ������������������� !�
�"� �#� ����� �$�%��&'(�� )*+,-�����.! ����/0��12
3� 4Bisnis Indonesia ����/�/5� ����� �$ � 6789*:;��� CPI<=> BSP
<)*+,-�?8@A��B�CD23��
EF�=>>=�GH�� I�JK�L������M �N� �� K�L��O
���PQR��N� �S�!� ��������O���TU= �VW� �XI��
O���YZ[\A��]�������^���� ����_
V � �
�O��I�JK�������� ��L��`(��� ab���O��c=���
�����M ��� � �O���de������� ��������fg����
�� I�JK�����M �N� �� H �I�JK�����a��hi�� I�J
K�jIA[.!��ck���lm� I�JK�������K�Ln c�O�op
�!"��q�YZ[\A��#�r>s�(�=���k�� tu*[$%v�!k3
w� �Ox&�PQ(H��'>Fyz(�PQ!)s>3�`�� &���*����
�O���y{�+,���|}~-�.!k��� = � /��� ������� &
��0�������O��� K��� �x���c�(����1 H�������
�� ��� �=>�.c2"� ��������A�*�%3cR�23�(�(4�!
��`2>!k��� �H ���&���c&������5��F!�6���7�&
�8!�9 ������������:"������>/� �O�op�#�r>s��
qYZ[\A���] ��O��������; �!k��� �L�!��O��
����<�K��c�� �L�!k��c� ���=>�3wK���� =(���^
���� �L�!k��
� �
�>��?�k����� @�A ¡�¢£¤�¥¦�¥_� §¨©*xuJ ¡ªB�¥CD�«�£¤¬_� 6[I�x�®-A¯t ¡E_� °�F ¡E_ �G"�±²³�´�µ �� �¶·�H F¸µ��
��_ BSP<�¬!¹I�0(��µeº» �(�( 4Bisnis Indonesia ����/�/�5�
CD�«�£¤ ��¼ �½
134
![Page 17: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
� � � �
��������� � No. ����/ ��/MEM. M/ ����� ����� �� ������������������� !"�No. �/T. CPP. KS/X/SS�������#��$%&�'(� ����� ��� ����
���)*+!"� No. ��/Ekbang/ ����/� ����� ��� ����,�-./� BSP010234�� No. �/tcb/Riau/XII/ ����� �#��$%&� 5BSP06789� �:��;< 5,�-./6789 '(� ����� ��� ����
=>�?@Bisnis Indonesia
����/��/�� Pemda Riau Ngotot Minta ��A Saham CPP.
����/�/ Balaks Teken Kontrak Perdana bagi Hasil Blok CPP.
����/�/� Wawancara dengan Direktur Presiden Bumi Siak Pusako, Azaly Djohan.
����/�/� Bumi Siak Pusako Terlahir untuk Minyak.
����/�/� Kami Siap Operasikan Blok CPP.Buletin Warta Pertamina
����/�/�.Forum Keadilan
����/��/� Setumpuk Urusan buaat Gubernur Baru.Gamma
����/�/�� Geliat Provinsi Minyak: pp. �.Jakarta Post
����/��/�� Scholar Renew Independence for Riau.
����/�/� Riau Province to Jointly Own CPP’s Oil Block.Jawa Pos
����//� Gagal Rebut Ladang Minyak, Terjuni Bisnis Penerbangan.Kompas
����/�/� Prediksi Pemilu di Riau: Ramai-Ramai Menggoyang Beringin.
B��C�Abdurahman, Sukri. ����. Hubungan Pemerintah Pusat dan Daerah: Kasus Riau. In Krisis Masa Kini
dan Orde Baru, edited by Muhamad Hisyam. Jakarta: Yayasan Obor Indonesia.Aden, Jean. ����. Entrepreneurship and Protection in the Indonesian Oil Service Industry. In
Southeast Asian Capitalists, edited by Ruth McVey. Ithaca: SEAP Cornell University Press.Albintani, Muchid. ����. Dari Riau Merdeka Sampai Otonomi Nol. Pekanbaru: Unri Press.Aliansi Peduli Pelalawan 5Appel9� ����. Prahara Abadi? Buku Putih. Pekanbaru: Appel.Aspinall, Edward: and Fealy, Greg, eds. ����. Local Power and Politics in Indonesia: Decentralisation
and Democratisation. Singapore: ISEAS.Barr, Christopher. ����. Bob Hasan: The Rise of Apkindo and the Shifting Dynamics of Control in
Indonesia’s Timber Sector. Indonesia : ���.����. ����. Profit on Paper: The Political Economy of Fiber and Finance in Indonesia’s Pulp and
Paper Industries. In Banking on Sustainability: Structural Adjustment and Forestry Reform in PostSuharto Indonesia, edited by Christopher Barr. Bogor: CIFOR.
Bartlett III, Anderson. ����. Pertamina: Indonesian National Oil. Jakarta and Tulsa: Amerasian Ltd.Blackburn, Susan. ����. Riau. In Perspective from the Periphery, ACFOA Development Report.Colombijn, Fred. ����. A Peaceful Road to Freedom. Inside Indonesia � 5January-March9�Escobar, Arturo. ���. Encountering Development: The Making and Unmaking of the Third World.
Princeton: Princeton University Press.Derks, Will. ����. Malay Identity Work. Bidjragen Tot De Taal, Land en Volkenkunde ��: �����.Imparsial. ����. Regional Budget for TNI: A Threat for Civilian Control over the Military. In Catatan
DEF�GHI�H&�IJKLMNOPQR
135
![Page 18: ポスト・スハルト期における政治経済 : リアウ州に … governor of Riau, Saleh Djasit, in challenging a policy decided by the central government, proved less able](https://reader031.fdocument.pub/reader031/viewer/2022021916/5cdd51b988c9934c738dc89e/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
imparisial: Critical Analysis on Defense Policy���� March ����.Human Right Watch. ����. Without Remedy: Human Right Abuse and Indonesian’s Pulp and Paper
Industry. Washington: Human Right Watch.Kingsbury, Damien; and Aveling, Harry, eds. ����. Autonomy and Disintegration. London: Routledge
Curzon.Kuntjoro, Mudradjat. ����. Desentralisasi Fiskal di Indonesia. Prisma �����: ���.Lutfi, Muchtar, ed. ��. Sejarah Riau. Pekanbaru: Percetakan Riau.Mardjani, Ma’rifat. ����. Realisasi Propinsi Riau-Djambi. Jakarta: Pustaka Njiur Melambai.Malley, Michael. S. ����. New Rules, Old Structures, and the Limits of Indonesia’s Democratic
Decentralization. In Local Power and Politics in Indonesia: Decentralisation and Democratisation,edited by Edward Aspinall and Greg Fealy, pp. ������. Singapore: ISEAS.
North, Douglass. ����. The New Institutional Economics and Third World Development. In The NewInstitutional Economics and Third World Development, edited by John Harris, Janet Hunter andColin M Lewis, pp. ���. London: Routledge.
Peluso, Nancy. ����. Rich Forest, Poor People: Resource Control and Resistance in Java. California:University of California Press.
Pemerintah Daerah Riau. ����. Riau Makmur: Pelaksanaan Tugas Gubernur Kepala Tingkat I Riau H.Imam Munandar: Oktober 1980�Oktober1985. Pekan Baru: Pemerintah Daerah Riau.
Rab, Tabrani. ����a. Tempias: Kilas Balik Kritik Prof. Dr. H. Tabrani Rab 1998�2001. Bandung:Alumni.
����. ����b. Menuju Riau Berdaulat. Pekanbaru: Riau Cultural Institute.Robison, Richard. ����. Indonesia: Tension in State and Regime. In Southeast Asia in the 1990s:
Authoritarian, Democracy, and Capitalism, edited by Richard Robison, Kevin Hewison and GaryRodan, pp. ����. St. Leonard: Allen and Unwin.
Royle, Stephen. A. ���. Industrialisation in Indonesia: The Example of Batam Island. SingaporeJournal of Tropical Geography �����: �����.
Sakai, Minako. ����. The Privatisation of Padang Cement: Regional Identity and EconomicHegemony in the New Era of Decentralisation. In Local Power and Politics in Indonesia: Decentr-alisation and Democratisation, edited by Edward Aspinall and Greg Fealy, pp. ������. Singapore:ISEAS.
Shiraishi, Takashi. ����. Dukuh: A Golkar Village. In Approaching Suharto’s Indonesia from theMargin, edited by Takashi Shiraishi, pp. ����. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Turner, Mark; and Podger, Owen. ����. Decentralisation in Indonesia: Redesigning the State. Canber-ra : Asia Pacific Press at Australian National University.
Wee, Vivienne. ����. Ethno-nationalism in Process: Ethnicity, Atavism and Indigenism in Riau,Indonesia. The Pacific Review �����: �����.
Yue, Chia Siow. ���. The Sijori Growth Triangle: Challenges, Opportunities and StrategicResponse. In Growth Triangle in Southeast Asia, edited by Imran Lim, pp. ������. Kuala Lumpur:ISI Malaya.
����. ���. Singapore: Advanced Production Base and Smart Hub of the Electronic Industry. InMultinational and East Asian Integration, edited by Wendy Dobson and Chia Siow Yue, pp. ����.Canada: IDRC.
����� ��� ��
136