สูง ต่ำ ไม่เท่ากัน:...

download สูง ต่ำ ไม่เท่ากัน: ทำไมระบบการศึกษาจึงสร้างความเหลื่อมล้ำ?

of 87

description

โดย แบ๊งค์ งามอรุณโชติ, ถิรภาพ ฟักทองพิมพ์ครั้งแรก ธันวาคม ๒๕๕๕สถานการณ์ความเหลื่อมล้ำทางการศึกษาในภาพรวม โดยเฉพาะอย่างยิ่ง “ระบบการศึกษา” ในฐานะสาเหตุหลักของความเหลื่อมล้ำ

Transcript of สูง ต่ำ ไม่เท่ากัน:...

  • ?

  • 3

    - : ?

    (Social Inequality Reduction Network: SIRNet) ISBN : xxxxxxxxxxx 2555

    113 10200

    0-2225-9536 9 0-2222-5188

    :

    :

    : , ,

    , ,

    :

    :

    : ,

    :

    :

    :

    :

    2 88/37 14 .

    . . 11000

    . 02-832-9127

    : www.ThaiSocialHealth.net

    : (SIRNet)

    :

    : 0-2225-9536 9

    0-2222-5188

    ?

    150

  • 2

    (Discourse on the Origin and Basis of Inequality Among Men)

  • 76 ?

    .. 2475

    68

    10

    12 (794,602 )

    2 6

    7,094

    150

    800,000

    600,000

    :

    ?

    -:

    19

    .. 2555

  • 98 ?

    (SIRNet

    Social Inequity Reduction Network)

    -

    (.)

  • 1110 ?

    3. 102

    /

    / 108

    112

    120

    126

    4. 138

    147

    1 153

    2 157

    3 161

    167

    15

    1. 20

    23

    24

    29

    32

    38

    45

    2. 50

    54

    ..2554 - 2555

    81

    96

  • 1514 ?

    (Huber, Ragin, & Stephens, 1993)

  • 1716 ?

    ,

    ,

  • 1918 ?

    (2554)

  • 2120 ?

    1

  • 2322 ?

    ,

    1

  • 2524 ?

    ,

    ,

    Thomas, Wang, Fan (2001)

    6

  • 2726 ?

    1

    ,

    Hanushek ,

    (2555)

    1

  • 2928 ?

    ,

  • 3130 ?

    2

    2

    ()

    ()

    , ,

    ,

    2 1

  • 3332 ?

    ( ,

    2553)

    /

    (2549)

    /

    4

  • 3534 ?

    [ =

    ]

    /

  • 3736 ?

    [=/ = ]

    /

    /

    /

  • 3938 ?

    21

    (1997)

    (1)

    (2)

    ?

  • 4140 ?

    ?

    ?

    ?

    (Parfit, 1997)

  • 4342 ?

  • 4544 ?

    3

    3

  • 4746 ?

    4

    4

    4 David Graeber, Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology, (Chicago: Prickly Paradigm Press, 2004), p. 77-94. ()

  • 4948 ?

  • 5150 ?

    2

  • 5352 ?

    ..2554-2555,

    2

  • 5554 ?

    ..2554 - 2555

    ,

    ..2554

  • 5756 ?

    1

    ..2554

    25

    ()

    1

    0-75

    Year

    of E

    duca

    tion

    15

    10

    5

    010 20 30 40 50 60 70

    Age

    StDevMean

    Formative)(year

    : SES (2011)

  • 5958 ?

    15-35

    2

    Year

    of E

    duca

    tion

    15

    10

    5

    010 20 30 40 50 60 70

    Age

    Formative)

    (year

    GenderMale

    Female

    : SES (2011)

  • 6160 ?

    3

    ,

    21-22

    3

    Year

    of E

    duca

    tion

    15

    10

    5

    010 20 30 40 50 60 70

    Age

    Formative)

    (year

    RegionBangkok

    NortheastSouth

    NorthCentral

    : SES (2011)

  • 6362 ?

    4

    4

    Year

    of E

    duca

    tion

    15

    10

    5

    010 20 30 40 50 60 70

    Age

    Formative)

    (year

    AreaMunicipalNon-municipal

    : SES (2011)

  • 6564 ?

    2

    5

    ()

    ()

    5

    5

    10

    20

    30

    15

    25

    35

    0

    5

    Secondary HigherPrimary

    : Psacharopoulos & Patrinos (2004)

    5

    ,

  • 6766 ?

    6 6

    6 54.8

    6

    1 .. 2541

    6 1 100% 1

    0

    100

    20

    120

    60

    80

    40

    ( )

    10089.5 85.6 79.6

    68.4

    54.8

    .1 .6 .1 .3 .4/.1 .6/.3

    : (, , , 2555)

  • 6968 ?

    7

    .. 2549 87

    ..

    2552

    -

    7

    ..2549

    7 8 ..2555 Ahuja, Chucherd, & Pootrakool (2006) .. 2548

    13,497 15,753 17,295 16,929 12,266 30,152 5,651

    10,000

    20,000

    30,000

    40,000

    50,000

    Pre-

    prim

    ary

    Prim

    ary

    Pre-

    prim

    ary

    Lowe

    r-se

    cond

    ary

    Uppe

    r-se

    cond

    ary

    & Vo

    catio

    nal I

    Voca

    tiona

    l II

    Terti

    ary

    : Ahuja, Chucherd, & Pootrakool (2006)

    ..2548

    .. 2549

  • 7170 ?

    8

    ..2552

    ( 9)

    8

    24,066.62

    34,419.42

    10,000

    20,000

    30,000

    40,000

    50,000

    0

    : (2552) (2555)

    8 , (2555)

  • 7372 ?

    9

    ..2554

    75

    25 ..

    2547 : 83 : 17

    ( ,

    , 2555)

    (%) (%)

    (2552)

    (2552)

    (2552)

    0 5 10 15 20 25

    : (, , , 2555)

  • 7574 ?

    (1)

    2554

    (2) :

    , ,

    (2555)

    (2554)

    10

    3

    10

    1 3

    98.59

    104.5

    101.29100.11

    96.85 95.99

    IQ < 100 IQ < 100 IQ < 100

    : (2554)

  • 7776 ?

    11

    11

    1 3

    IQ < 100 IQ < 100 IQ < 100

    90.00

    95.00

    100.00

    105.00

    110.00

    94.5096.26

    97.27 98.6899.38 100.59

    100.94 99.97 100.47

    1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3

    : (2554)

    3

    PISA, TIMSS O-NET

  • 7978 ?

    , , (2555)

    12 14

    12

    12

    13

    (.2) (.)

    2520 30 35420 470

    TIMSS 2007 O-NET-2552

    : , , (2555)

  • 8180 ?

    (. .)

    (.1)

    13

    PISA 2009 TIMSS 2007 O-Net 2553

    .1

    .2

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    :, , (2555)

  • 8382 ?

    ..2554

    Ahuja, Chucherd,

    Pootrakool(2006) ,

    , (2555)

    4 1

    1

    ( 4 )

    : Ahuja, Chucherd, Pootrakool(2006)

    Ahuja, Chucherd, Pootrakool (2006)

    2554 2

  • 8584 ?

    2

    20

    1

    3

    1

    3 4

  • 8786 ?

    1

    , ,

  • 8988 ?

    Ahuja,

    Chucherd, Pootrakool (2006)

    ,

    , (2555)

    Ahuja, Chucherd, Pootrakool(2006)

    (2003)

    3-4

    5 2

    2

    Ahuja, Chucherd, Pootrakool (2006)

    ()

    ()

  • 9190 ?

    : Ahuja, Chucherd, & Pootrakool (2006)

    Ahuja, Chucherd, & Pootrakool (2006)

    2

    1

  • 9392 ?

    , ,

    (2555)

    (2006)

    (2555)

    3

    , ,

    (2555) Ahuja

    (2006)

    : , , (2555)

    , ,

    (2555)

    3

  • 9594 ?

  • 9796 ?

    (2008)

    ..2554

    ,

    ,

    3

    ,

  • 9998 ?

    3

    3

    4 ,

    ,

    ,

    2

  • 101100 ?

  • 103102 ?

    3

    /

  • 105104 ?

    /

    /

    3

  • 107106 ?

    /

    /

    / /

    /

  • 109108 ?

    /

    (

    , 2555)

    /

  • 111110 ?

    ,

  • 113112 ?

    /

    /

    (.)

    1

    (2555)

    .

  • 115114 ?

    .

    /

    (.)

    9

    9 1

    1-2

  • 117116 ?

    ()

    ( ()

    4 10, 2554)

  • 119118 ?

    []

    (

    () 4 , 2555)

    10

    4 ( )

    (

    )

    3.00

    (

    , 2554)

  • 121120 ?

    Ahuja, Chucherd, &

    Pootrakool (2006)

  • 123122 ?

    ?

    (2552)

  • 125124 ?

    ,

    ?

  • 127126 ?

    4

    (

    , 2552)

  • 129128 ?

    ?

    11 .

    ,

    ( , 2549)

  • 131130 ?

    11

    12

    /

    12

  • 133132 ?

    3

    (

    Stanley

    Fish , 2549)

    ,

    ,

    ?

    /

    /

    (

    /

    , 2554 136)

  • 135134 ?

    13

    (2549)

    (2554)

    /

    13

  • 137136 ?

  • 139138 ?

    4

  • 141140 ?

    .. 2554-2555

    ,

    4

  • 143142 ?

    14

    ,

    /

    14

    ,

    /

    ,

  • 145144 ?

    ,

    /

  • 147146 ?

    Ashvin Ahuja, Thitima Chucherd, Kobsak Pootrakool.

    (2006). Human Capital Policy: Building a

    Comparative Workforce for 21th Century Thailand.

    Bank of Thailand.

    Derek Parfit. (1997). Equality and Priority.Ratio.

    Evelyne Huber, Charles Ragin, John D. Stephens.

    (1993). Social Democracy, Christian Democracy,

    Constitutional Structure, and the Welfare State.

    The American Journal of Sociology, 711-749.

  • 149148 ?

    Jean-Jacques Rousseau. (1754 translated in 1950).

    A Discourse on the Origin of Inequality. The

    Social Contract and Discourses (G. D. H. Cole,

    ). New York: Dutton: Everymans Library.

    George Psacharopoulos, Harry Anthony Patrinos.

    (2004). Return on Investment in Education: A

    Further Update.Education Economics.

    Vinod Thomas, Yan Wang, Xibo Fan. (2001).

    Measuring Education Inequality: Gini Coeficients

    of Education.World Bank.

    World Health Organization. (2008). Closing the Gap

    in a Generation: Health Equity Through Action on

    Social Determinants of Health.

    . (2554).

    2554. .

    . (2552).

    2552: .

    2555

    : http://203.146.15.234/eis/

    . (2552). (irony)

    .

    ,

    ( 57). : .

    . (2554). :

    . : .

    () 4

    . (24 2555).

    . (

    , )

    . (19 2555).

    .

  • 151150 ?

    , ,

    . (2555).

    .

    (TDRI).

    . (2555).

    ..2555. :

    .

    , ,

    . (2555). :

    .

    (TDRI).

    . (24

    2555).

    . ( , )

    . (2549). .

    : .

    . (2552).

    ? ,

    ( 5). : .

    . (2553).

    :

    . : .

  • 153152 ?

    1

  • 155154 ?

    (,

    )

    4

    A B

    1 10 15

    2 6 3 3 8 6

    4 9 10

    5 7 12

    8 9.2

    1.6 4.8

    A B

    1 5 A

    8 B

  • 157156 ?

    A (

    )

    B

    1 15

    2 3

    A B

    2

    5

    20 2554

    -0.105** -

    -0.129**

  • 159158 ?

    0.717** -

    ()

    -2.861**

    -

    -2.384**

    -

    -1.799**

    -0.595** -

    -1.286**

    -0.389**

    -1.14**

    -1.558**

    -0.29**

    -0.242**

    -0.071**

    -0.445**

    ()

    -4.083**

    /

    -4.409**

    -3.696**

    -4.21**

    -3.483**

    -2.752**

    -1.246**

    -1.38**

    :89,145

    (R2 ):0.495

    : ***,** * 1, 5, and 10% Ordinary Least Square (Standard Errors) heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors

  • 161160 ?

    3

    6

    2554

  • 163162 ?

    0* 0.0000064 0** ^2 0.0000042** 0.0000038** 0.0000062** -0.004** -0.003** -0.001**

    -0.008** -0.008** -0.014**

    -

    -0.003** -0.002** -0.001**

    -

    -0.002** -0.000055 -0.002**

    -0.024** -0.025** -0.01**

    ()

    -0.03** -0.032** 0.023**

    ()

    -

    -0.024** -0.025** 0.006**

    -

    -0.018** -0.018** 0.002**

    -0.008** -0.008** -0.004**

    -0.007** -0.007** -0.011**

    -0.007** -0.007** 0.012**

    -0.003** -0.003** 0.001**

    -0.01** -0.01** -0.002**

    -0.016** -0.016** -0.013**

    -0.014** -0.013** -0.012**

    -0.007** -0.007** 0.011**

  • 165164 ?

    ()

    -0.008** -0.007** -0.006**

    /

    -0.003** -0.002** -0.009**

    -0.018** -0.017** -0.04**

    -0.009** -0.009** 0

    -0.012** -0.011** -0.018**

    -0.014** -0.013** -0.015**

    -0.006** -0.005** -0.004**

    0.017** 0.014** 0.027**

    : 1,061 24,100 24,477

    (R2 ):

    0.310 .301 0.320

  • 167

    (Political Economics)

    (New Institutional Economics)

    :

    (),

    ()

    .. , Economic

    analysis of law and the efficiency of the justice system in

    relation to environmental lawsuits: Thailands experience (2013)

  • 169168 ?

    2551 2555

    ()

    1. Income Inequality and Growth under Thailands Public

    Investment in Human Capital, GSTF Business Review (GBR)

    Vol. 2 No. 1, 2012 (Print ISSN: 2010-4804, E-periodical:

    2251-2888)

    2. Convergence in Income Inequality and Growth under

    Public Investment in Human Capital: The Case of Thailand,

    Procedia Finance and Economics Vol. 2, 2012 (Print ISSN:

    2251-2012, E-Periodical ISSN: 2251-2020)

    3. Thailand A Labour Market Profile,

    International Labour Organization, 2012 (Print ISBN:

    9789-2212-6903-8, Web: 9789-2212-6904-5)

  • 171170 ?

  • 172?