˜ 1437˛ 2015 ˘ˇ , 427 − 405 ! ! , 3 , 27
Transcript of ˜ 1437˛ 2015 ˘ˇ , 427 − 405 ! ! , 3 , 27
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 405 –
�� ��������� ��� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3�! ! , 405 − 427 ����� ,�2015��1437� �
������ ��� �� ���� ������� ������ ������ ���� � �!�"#$�� %&' � (�)�� ��)�*� �!������� �#+ � "*#,- �.�/�) 0� 1!-&��� 2��
3"4��5 6���4 7� 78����491;�'�� � <= 7� >!��� ,92; ��# $��� �%�&
� ' ()�� � *03�03�1436;� ()�� -.*/ ' 29�07�1436� �
��$A#�: 1�2%34�� �)5 ��678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� ����� �) % ' �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% G�H�I J % K5 L >� M:4�� NI �2��O� � M#� MH P �� QR D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� `� a� b�2* K5 � M#� MH P �� @S<H/ @3AB�� c�C��� G�H�d�� ��6)% -�< �*35 e/ @� Pf MgM4=�
-h% ,� M#� MH P �� : ]62��5 ��67 _1��� 12%34�� ]2�8 '/ ��5 -AB� ]2�4�� j�� ' klm� @��)#/ ,]2�4�� J�4?%/ ,n)o� p�V– Z��[�\� ����5q �rs�� ,�2��O� �r2t���/ , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMVuH 4��/ ` _�% ��V�A% �M)P2 M5 K5 Q5v =/ ,�w�x �V�.4#� ]2Cs8 :]8/ ,9rw��� y6)�� z�hF�.�� � {4#�
�304 �/ ]�%�301 � ' |�2D�s�FI ����� }/��R ��&/ � M#� MH P �� @�6tq @�V�2.�� -2�e �/ ,����� �) C� ���� ]2�4�� bH� % @~�%/ 9C�% _% �C�%S8 cC��� @�<�H�I ;W� XYMV Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1�� 12%34�� ]2�8 ' �Y��?�� @�lm�/ �2��O� ]��� �r2t// ,]2�4��� klm� @��)#/ n)o� p�V @�fg4� J
uH 4�� 9Y�8/ , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� `�4�� J�4?�� Pf MgM4 =% L34xE JS8 |�2D�sFI � ���� }/�R ��&/ � 5 _5 QrB< �6)A�/9C2 `
�!+��C � %0#'��:��H �� -2s�4�� ,G��?�� Z��[\� ` _________________________________________________________________________________
Behavioral Problems Associated with Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder Among
Students as Perceived by Elementary School Teachers in Riyadh
Abdulrahman Abdullah Abaoud(1), and Nabil Sharaf Almalki(2) King Saud University
(Received 25/12/2014; accepted 18/05/2015)
Abstract: This study was aimed at measuring the differences of elementary school teachers’ perceptions of behavioral problems that appear in pupils with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). The study focused on measuring any statistically significance
differences of some variables and their relationship to the extent of realization of teachers. These variables included gender, level of education, years of experience, teacher's current position, previous experience in teaching pupils with ADHD, and training. This research
applied the descriptive approach, using a questionnaire. The study sample included 304 male elementary school teachers and 301 female
elementary school teachers. The study found several results; no statistically significant differences at the 0.05 level or less regarding teachers’ perceptions of behavioral problems in pupils with ADHD and level of education. The study also showed statistically significant
differences between the perceptions of teachers and gender, years of experience, teacher's current position, previous experience in teaching
pupils with ADHD, and training.
Key words: Conduct Disorder, School Studying.
_________________________________________________________________________________
�1� ��4#q 5�?% ]?Y� ,�w�m� �2���� ,��# $��� �%�& ,�2���� �2�< ����� ,���?�� �2���� �A�C�� , Z !�92732� � l�� S%��� ,�11663�
(1) Assistant Professor, Department of Special Education,
College of Education, King Saud University.
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, P.O. Box (92732) , Postal Code: (11663)
�/�A��� l��: [email protected] e-mail:
�2� ��4#q 5�?% ]?Y� ,�w�m� �2���� ,��# $��� �%�& ,�2���� �2�< (2) Assistant Professor, Department of Special Education,
College of Education, King Saud University.
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 406 –
�-��- _% ��� �2#�H �� L�rs�� -x�� 12%34�� �&�� ?��48/ ,�2?�r)�� uV��o�� �6)% fh< �.8�8 ,@� �4�� _��AC �1���� 9<��?���� u��V�o� ' ����\�/ kH�s���
;W XYMV ' Z��[\E� -hC/ ;�47F3% T�B�)��/ U��.4VE�)% �� 94�� ]2�4�� @�*�% _% |�*�% D�S�� 9<�O� ��6
1�2%34�� _�% -�2�* f�� � �5(Zentall & Javorsky,
2007) ]��s��R -��x�� @� ��e z���6&�� �6..?���/ , �2��#�H ��(Graczyk, Atkins, Jackson, Letendre,
Kim-Cohen, Baumann, & McCoy, 2005); z� / �CD� �� ��rg�� � -AB�8 p�R �VE�/ �D�S�� T�B�)�� /q
,���2C2�4�� ���2�C�� ' @���*�% ���2Ye z/� j���e/ @���*��� U1�� T���.8HE |����7V/ ,�%���#��� L� �� �� ,1�2%34�� K�5 �2.�# H��� _% �62�5 u8� �%/ G��?��� ��s��� @����[�\� c�� |�5�2�� ��h<�� ����� Qr)w
�2?��r)�� (Anderson, Watt, Noble, & Shanley,
2012)` ]62��5 �67 12%34�� �E� zq $�� NI L�� % G��# ;] ��CV k��R j3x �t���% kH�s� Z�[�
]����2� ��% �2A4�� ' ���w -AB Z��[\E� �1 / ] ��4?�%/ ,]6<��# �.\ -<�B% �X2 MF X_ ;% ,�2#H ��
]���*��� ]64*35/ ,��H ��(DuPaul, & Weyandt,
2006) ` zq @���#�H �� a��� QrB��< ��*/� j���r�����.4VE� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� �67 _1�� T�B�)��/ U
,�:2 ;\ M�M�� @�2<��?�� ]62�5 �678 �% k��5 D�S�� 9<�O�-��h% : ,� ���4�� @����[��\�/ ,����Y��/ ,Z����4<E�
����6Y�� @�2<��?����/ �(Reid, Trout, & Schartz,
2005, p.361) z��6&�� @����[�\E� $��8 u.?�/ ,@3AB% $��� ���h%q _%/ ,�2#�H �� L�rs�� -x�� :
/q ,]6�2se �\ ��% v��VI /q ���I K5 ]�H * � 5 � H/ �� U1� / ,|3wq ]6)% Z��[% � �%/ �� z�r�A
9C���<�� ]�6D��q K�5 |�.�# nA)8 .Y4?���/ �¡� �Kos, Richdale, & Jackson, 2004�.
@3AB�� U1 _% ��8 94�� ��r�� ]�F �R��/ �H��Y4�� ��.48 K�5 z��hF�.�� !��F � H�B�4V� J %/
�� �.?V zq � &// ,�ss{4�� �2h�.�� S<���� _5 kH��s� H�B4V� ¢���� H Y8 11 % ]2��4�� 1�2%38 p��C� _%
��5 ¤r)�� u[�� �2A�%�� �2Co� ��Y8 u?�� ���� (2011) ` @�#�H �� fB8 n)o� u?�� �6r2)s8 )5/
_��% Z��[��\E�� �����w¥� ���\�5 ���h<q c��).�� zq NI� H� YC� ,@�).�� F�/ -��Y% ¦3 ` �1� W2{B8 ]4/
Z��[\E� − @�#�H �� u?�� − @��)?�� ' �2C��� ����F��� U1�� ' 1��2%34�� z� ;���#H �� _��% N/�� -�§ ��% �1� / ,���[R/ ���r� ]��2<��# z�#H~ ¨�\�/ -AB�� ��678 Z��[\3� �2#�#�� ���5��
-�h% ,k� �4% H��w -A�� K�5 �6)% z�V� _% )5 :H � �5/ ,]6 �.4V� �\/ ,] 5�YC� b��o� ]6�R
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 407 –
]62C�% @~2�4� ]65�.8��Kos et al., 2004� zq u§/ , ��)% ��� �1�� Z��[\E� �1 H�6t zq z�C��� GH @��4?�C�/ ,1�2%34�� c�� ��8/�r4% u?)� �67 12%34�� ,��#�4��/ ,�2rm� c� �% pv�4/ ,���� =�X2 MF X_ ;% �r�4©
w/ z�C��� z�A zq u�[4 �1 / @��4?�� K5q NI |E� z��A zq/ ,@�2<��?��� $�4� , |�7F3% }�q/ |�S2<�8 �h<q ������� u2��#��/ �64o�% }��/ �6\��5�� ���I ]^ � $���8 ¨��%3% ]62�5���67 _��% ���% -��%�4�� �.��#�)�� U1� ' ��H ��� �s��� -�x�� �:2;<�=� >?��� @����[\E�
���k���A.�� ����C�� ����F` (Martinussen, Tannock,
Chaban, McInnes, & Ferguson, 2006) ; GH�q ��*/ zq $���� _��%/ ���A.�� W2{B��4�� ���2ªq z�s��s{4��
n2?42��V�%/ 9<�8��l2<(Kypriotaki & Manolitsis,
2010) j��r�«� ��A.�� �B�A�� ��2ªq K�5 � <q z�1��� �.4VE� ' WYV ]^ � _1�� ,9�<�O� T�B�)�� ' k��v/ U
$��� z� ;@�2<��?��� $��8 ]62��5 �678 zq �*�4�� /q -�%�4�� u�#�)�� ������� Z��#�� H�24x� K5 5�?
�2#�H �� ]��sR -x�� ]6%` z��hF�.�� ��*/ �Y��?�� @�2���� �&��% �/ ���/v _% p�\���� Q2)5 94�� @�#�H �� _% � 5 K5
$�8 _%/ ,k� 4% �f%H��</ z�� /q ��#� MH;� @�#�H �� ,_��#/ f �?�2R/ u�.2 /(Ohan, Cormier, Hepp,
Visser, & Strain 2008) ��F��� 9C�% G�H�d� �Y�4��
9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W� XYMV Z��[\E �2D� 4�E�]���� �¬�/ ]��2<����# K��5 ��� ��q/ ��D�S�� ` QR �� /
f�����8 J ���% b����2* NI ���� M#� MH P �� ]���6<�H�I $�1���� |��<�H�I ��h<�� c� ;CP�=�� :zq NI Q��w�8/ ,Z��[\E� ]��� �¬�/ ]��2<��# ' �2��§I �h<q ��V�< Z��[\3� ���V ]6%��6r% K�5 $��� n�AV� */ ,12%34�� U�¬
��2��§I kH�s� ������/ �:2;<�=� >?�� @3x 4�� ` �B�</�� @� �¬�/ @�2<��# :zMq � M#� MH P �� |��<�H�I -*�� cC�
]6%��6r% $�1�</ ,1�2%34�� ���V �2.��# ��h<q QV�<������ �:2;<�=� >?�� @3x 4��`
��42��� J���&q// $��V��R/ zS��2&f8(sciutto,
terjesen & Bender-Frank, 2000) ����48 ���#� MH;� ;W XYMV Z��[\E �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% G�H�I J C�
�<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE������m� ]6C2 ��r%/ �D�S�� 9 ` $���4� ]��6<�H�I J�4?��% b���2* NI ��� M#� MH P �� QR �� / _�% Z��[\3� ����m� ]6C2 �r% e/ @�2<��?�� ���[.8�% ,�V�.4��#E� �64)C���8 @E���� ����3� j3��x ,������5��/ ,Z��[���\3� �2���#�#�� @����%�����
3��/ W2{B4��/ ` J�4?% zq NI � M#� MH P �� Q�w�8/�I U���.4VE� ;W�� XYMV Z��[��\� �����5� c��C��� G�H
K�5q �D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B)��/−®����% -AB��− _�%�2#�#�� �8�%��% e/ Z��[\E� 3� ]6<�H�I `
J�4?�% c�� |��2��§I |���.8H� G�) :zMq � M#� MH P �� @�6tq/
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 408 –
]^ �� _1��� �% ]6�%�8/ Z��[\3� cC��� G�H�I x @��)# c�/ $�� ]����r< J�4?%/ ]2�4��� ]64%
�28�1��` $��2R�</ H���V �����&q ���#� MH;� '/(Nur &
Kavakcı, 2010) 9�C�% @�� �¬� b��2* NI QR � U��.4VE� ;W� XYMV Z��[�\E ]6<�H�I/ �2D� 4�E� ��F��� _�% �� M#� MH P �� ��M)P2 M5 Q�V�A8/ , �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/
�87 � |~�% ` �� M#� MH P �� Q�w�8/ ,yD��4)�� _�% � �5 NI� v��q : G�H�I J�4?�% ' ®���% f� ��r{V� ��&/
����V ]���� �¬� j� ��45� ���% Z��[��\3� c��C��� c��� ������ ���*35 ����&/ NI �R���\��� ,Z��[��\E�
Z��[\3� ]6<�H�I J�4?% c�/ cC��� @� �¬�` z/�x�/ z�#H Vq zH�* */(Anderson et al.,
2012) ]64#�H� ' c��218 � ��2%�o� ���F���� |��.���/ ,]2�4�� j�� ' -C�� ]� �.#�109 � ��F���� Z3�
/ ,]2�4�� j�� ' klx z�A�C E �2%�o��127 � |~�% J �% ��R�% L �° ,������� z� �2�� ' z���C _± 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W� XYMV Z��[�\E ]6<�H�I
8 ' ]64.�H/ , D�S�� ;W� XYMV ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� nH9�<�O� T�B)�� ' k��v/ U�.4VE� ` b��2* NI �R��\���
G�H��� K��5 kl��m� ����q c���/ c��C��� c��� }/���r��G��?��� �1� ���V U��¬E� _�A8/ ` yD��4V @H���q/
_5 ����&q _1�� � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq �2� zq NI � M#� MH P ��
z�< �V�.4#E� Z��[�\� WD�s�{� �2& ����I ]^ �� }��� z�<H �/ , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV
�6&35 ` _1�� c2%�o� 12%34�� :zMq � M#� MH P �� @�6tq/ ]2��8 ' ��.�H ��h<q ]� ]2�4�� ' -C�� ]� �.? ² T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
D�S�� 9<�O� ' z���C z���S �% _1�� cC��� _% , z� 2�� ` ��V��< -�C�� ' _�C4?��� c� ;CP�=�� :zq Q):2�/
_��% 1�2%34�� �E�� ����V ]��2<���# ' ��2��§I ��h<q]2��4�� ' -�C�� ]� �.# _1�� c2%�o� ` QrB�</
�V�.4#E� -CA4#� _% �2� G�H�I @��4?% :zMq � M#� MH P ��E U��.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� u.?� ;L34x� �6)2� &�
D�v 9<�F T�BV ��&//` �° ��* �#� MH;� '/ z/��x�/ b�<(Kos et al.,
2004) z� ���2��� c�%������ c���C��� G�H�I ����VH�YC� Z��[�\� ���V z� 2��� z��C L�# _1�� cC���/
�D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV ` M5 Q�V�A8/ ��M)P2 _% � M#� MH P ���120 � ,��2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% _% |~�%
/�45 � ]64�F��% _�% f�x�� J�4?��� ' |����8 |�.����V�.4�#E� _�5 ]62� Z�&q */ ,�2%�o� ` QR � /
c��C��� WD�s��x c��� ���*3�� �� e NI ��� M#� MH P ��U��.4VE� ;W� XYMV Z��[�\E ]�6<�H�I J�4?%/ �r�4{��
D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ ` _% � 5 NI � M#� MH P �� Q�w�8/�� v��q ,yD�4)�� : c�%���� c�C��� G�H�I J�4?�% zq
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 409 –
c������ 1�2%34�� _�% K�5q �� M#� MH P �� ��AB� z� 2����%�o�� ` J�4?�% c�� ��*35 ���&/ _�5 QrB�< ~<
�D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� G�H�Ilx/ $�1�� c�C��� G�H�I J�4?�% zq/ ,nH �4�� k
]2�4�� j�� ' �2�C�� �#H~�� j3x _% S8 ���� ` -�A2� J��&q/�Bekle, 2004 � �°�B�% ��#� MH;�
' c�%��� cC��� @�H�s8/ G�H�I �VH�Y% NI QR Z��[�\� ��V ,�2%�o� ��F��� ' Z3� c�/ z� 2��
�B)��/ U�.4VE� �\ D�S�� 9<�O� T ` ��M)P2 M5 Q�V�A8/_% � M#� MH P �� �30 �/ ,]2�4�� ' z�% ³ |~�%�40 � |�.���
�2%�o� ��F��� ' ` ��V��< c ;CP�=�� :zq � M#� MH P �� QrB</ G�H�I _�% Z��[\3� ]��H�s8/ ]6<�H�I ' �*� �h<q 1�2%34�� u���q zq ��% ,] H ��s8/ c2%�o� 12%34��
�Y�8c�C��� _% K5q �.?)� @�.H 8 � ` QrB�< ��2F ¢��F zq yD�4)��95 % ��%q ,|�.H �8 ���Y�8 1�2%34�� _�%
J�# uH 4�� K5 ]6)% -s´ ]�R z�C���23 % _�%z� 2�� ' c�%��� cC��� ¢��I `
~���� / z���8� / H����28/ Q?��/ J���&q/ �West, Taylor, Houghton, & Hudyma 2005 �
MH;� c� �62R zH�* �253[4#� �#��256 � c�/ |~�%�92 � _�% �V�.4�#E� QV�A8/ ,H�%�� ��2�/q _%�67 �k��YR `
]�� ��Y4%/ ]����<�H�I @��4?��% b���2* NI QR �� / 9��<�O� T�B��)��/ U���.4VE� ;W�� XYMV Z��[��\� Z�.��#�
�&35/ �sD�sx/ , D�S�� ` zq NI � M#� MH P �� -w�8 */ H��%�� ��2�/q j��F c�C��� _�% K�5q G�H�I ]^ ��
_�5 yD��4)�� �r?�8 ²/ ,��4o�%/ Z��[�\E� Z�.#q Z��[�\E� WD�sm ]6<�H�I @��4?% ' @�R34x�
� M#� MH P �� ' � ��� ` @� �Y4�� zq yD��4)�� Q�\/q ~< _�% µ-�A� ���\�/ Q�V�< Z��[�\E� j��F ����m�
H�%�� ��2�/q/ cC���` � �/ D��� �#' -� �E :
��Y�4�� �2#�H �� @3ABC�� cC��� G�H�I zI T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��� c�C��� G���# K5 |���§I $�� nA) , D�S�� 9<�O� �������� u2����#�� H���24x� ' 5�?��/ ,]����6&�8/
�.#�)��(Kos, Richdale, & Hay, 2006) ` H�B4V� > /t �D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� k� �
-2s��4�� J�4?�% � �4� �62�5 j 4?�� ,12%34�� J � c�C��� J �� k��R ��&/ K5 |���% ,]^ � ��H �� -AB�� ��6% -�%�4�� ��2�I �4´ ~� ����� ' |�H�s*/
¶�§I ` z/�x�/ z�#H Vq H��q */(Anderson et al.,
2012)I �678 94�� @3ABC�� cC��� G�H�I � 5 zq N ��� z��A ,�2#�H �� ]��sR -x�� 12%34�� �E� )5
NI ��� $�� zq �6)%/ ,�2.�?�� � H��� : ]6%~4� � � 5 ��647F3% _�AC 94�� �.F�s�� -<�B��/ @�2<��?��� J �% G�H�I � �5 NI �R��\��� ,1�2%34�� �E�� K5
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 410 –
34�� �E��� ���&�F ] ��Y8 � ��5/ ,k 5�?��C�� 1��2% ��2�5�R _�5 ]����# �)5 ��*���%/ ��\�/ @�%��%
�2#�H �� ]��sR -x�� 12%34�� �2D�/ �� @�f��4�� ` ~< �6.42�# 9�4�� nH �4�� u2���#q K�5 ���2# $�� zq
z�C��� ~< ,]6?H 4� �.#�)�� @�2�28��#�� H�24x�/�� ] �� 4�#� J % K5 nA)2# $�� zq ' �<H�B�C
��4³ ��AB�� GH _% z� ;������ @3x 4�� 12r)8~6)�% µ-< �*�% ��4{2# ¢�4���/ ,�6<H E _% _5 `
z��C��� ��� �1�� ��2O� H/ �� �2ªq �BA �1 / ��Y8 ]62�R ,12%34�� �E�� ������ @�% m� ] Y8 ' ,��� H�6t j���F ' �����5�� _��5 ·3����� �2�/�?��% �S& 12r)8/ ,j����� @�H�s8 �\// kH�B�� ] Y8/ z~��� ��6C22Y8/ �:2;<�=� >?���/ ������� @3x �4�� _%
��H �� ]6F��V` � �E� �/ D��� <�F:
� ��7% K�5 L >�� M:4�� NI �� M#� MH P �� U1� QR _�% �D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�
' cw�s��{�� c��C��� ���7V ���6&/ ,��� M#� MH P �� U1�� K�5 c�C��� 5�?�8 @��F�Y%/ @�2w�4� /�m�/ -�%�4�� ��2r2< z��2� NI �R��\��� � ��7�� $�8 G�H�I
@� Pf� MgM4=�� a�� ���q b�2*/ ,�6%� J�4?�% ,n)�o� ,�2��O� ]��� �r2t/ ,]2�4�� ' klm� @��)# ,]2�4��
4?��� 1�2%34�� ]2�8 ' �Y��?�� @�lm� U1� ' cR 6
uH 4�� 9Y�8 ,� M#� MH P �� � Z��[�\� cC��� G�H�I K5 ' 1�2%34�� �)5 �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� WYV
�2D� 4�E� ��F���` � �E� �/ D��� �#GE5:
c���?���� _��5 �����&�� NI ��� M#� MH P �� Q��#�ª/ ,c?2D��� : �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% G�H�I J % �%
3ABC�� _1��� 1�2%34�� �)5 ��678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @ ? �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � 9�C�% G�H�I ' �2D�sFI ��E� @�� }/�R G�) - / ��678 9�4�� �:2;<�=� >?��� @3AB�� ��V �2D� 4�E� ��F��� U���.4VE� ;W�� XYMV =Z��[��\� ]^ ��� _1���� 1��2%34�� ��)5
��/-%��� JS8 D�S�� 9<�O� T�B) : J�4?�% ,n)o� ���2��O� ���r2t��� ,���2C2�4�� kl��m� @��)��# ,]2���4�� =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� ]2�8 j�� ' @�lm�/
?uH 4��/ D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV �!H5� �E� �/ D��� :
�#�H �� _% �65�\�% ' � M#� MH P �� U1 l48 @� =��X2 MF X_� ;% 9�6R ,��w�x �2ªq �6.?A8 ,�h O� �2���� ���2D� 4�E� ����F��� 9��C�% G�H�d��� ���[.8�% p���\��� _1��� 1�2%34�� �)5 ��678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC��
9�<�O� T�B�)�� k��v/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� ]^ � `� ¦������ -D�/q _% > 4R ���/�� =�X2 MF X_ ;% �%q ��2���
c�C��� �7V �6&/ _% p�\��� y��8 94�� − u?�F
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 411 –
chF��.�� ]��5 − |�r2��w�8 � �Y8 ����q $��� NI L���� ¹��Y8/ ,��6� :]�8 9�4�� @�V�2.�� NI |���)4#� ��ABC��
yD�4)�� �8�6tq �% u?�� |E��F ` ' �6)% k��R�� ]42#/ U��.4VE� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1��� 12%34�� �% x $��� -�< ,]62�C�% ��% x/ , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/
�C2�4�� �2�C�� ��[8 ' ��6#�� �2g�` � �E� �/ D��� %�I#�J-:
�#+ � "*#,-�K!�������Elementary school
teachers : ]2��8/ ��2��� z��� ��� !�{���� ]� j/�� �s�� _% �2D� 4�E� bH� ��� cY�4��� j�r���
b��?�� NI���� ]2�4�� ' ` ' ]6�2 �8/ ] �� 5I ]4/cC��� �� 5I �2�< /q �2���� @�2�<`
�L!��"M# N$K�� %&' � Behavioral problems : ]^ �� _1��� j��r��� )5 �678 94�� @�2<��?�� 9 � �< , �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\�
E�/ ,S2<��� K5 12%34�� kH * 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ p�R V -�x�� @�2<��?�� ' ]A�4�� K5 kH Y�� � 5/ ,T�r�� ,�2rs���� �[B��V�� ' �<H�B���� �����w -��h% �s����
]6)% ����[�� ��6�� ���I ���w/ ` ��K����� ��K���� ���K�� OP�K� 7)1K�� 1!-&���
�K����� �K�� �� ���� Students with Attention
deficit hyperactivity disorder : _1�� 12%34�� ] ]^ ����C4?�% ��CV _�% � �5 U��.4VE� /� /q T��R
p�R �VE�/ ,T�B�)�� �1��� H��A4 |�f�h< ' ,UH��6tºF3/ k��5 �h<q |k F �± z�A K5 J�4?% -��± _%
����R�� c����� j3�x k��R ��C)�� �(Rosenberg,
Westling, & McLeskey, 2008, p. 237)` +� �E� �/ D��� 3��:
���2V�A�� �/ ��O� :bH� ���� ���) C� ���2D� 4�E� ���?�� �2���� �A�C�� ,�����`
�2)%S�� �/ O� : ��H ��� ���� _% ��h�� -sr��1434�1435�� `
� �E� �/ D��� Q*�R: @~���%/ 9��C�% _��% ��� M#� MH P �� ���C4� z���A8
������ ��) % ' ��2D� 4�E� ��F��� `���.��/ ] � �5 » kH�v/ @�2D�s���FI u?���F����� ]2����4��/ ����2���� �
1432�1433�� − (13,845)�%/ |~�% C� (Ministry
of Education, 2013)` � �E� �/ D��� ���D! �4:
�M)P2 M5 H�24x� :]8 � M#� MH P �� �C4� ]�F p�?8E |��7V @����4�#� ¢��I »��/ ,� M#� MH P �� �C4�� ��h± �2ssF
� ���Rq �M)P2 M��605 � p�C� _%�850 � �6v�8 ]8 �V�.4#�bH� �� K5 ` ��#H % c?�¼ K�5 �� M#� MH P �� Q�Y.�/
-C� */ ,@�).��/ c).�� K5 �/�?4��� �5v�% �2D� 4�� ����� �) %� ��#/ ,}� ,Z��� ,Z��)& ,j~������� �) % `�
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 412 –
� �E� �/ D��� S.�-: {4#� � M#� MH P �� U1 L� q �2Y�4� z��hF�.�� ��
k��5 y6)�� �1 � {4?/ ; 2��4�� 9rw��� y6)�� − �% �� j3x _% k� �7�� �w/ NI L � 94�� @�#�H �� c��� ���*3�� f?��r8/ L�B��A4#�/ ���6�2�e/ @���V�2.��
�� M#� MH P �� @� Pf MgM4 =% �1999Bevins, � yD��4)� /��m�/ ,yD�4)�� _% �Yh.)�� @�2w�4�� ] Y8/ ,�2*�/`
� �E� �/ D��� T�35: @�/��� ��R�%/ �Y��?�� @�#�H �� �&��% � K�5 z��hF�.�� �Y ² ,�6R� q �2Y�4� �° QV�4#� 94�� - �8 ����&I z/� �� M#� MH P �� U1 K5 �6Y2.[8 _AC k��q ���* �1��/ ;�� M#� MH P �� L� � q ��% ��YR��4% ��6�§ �62�5
#�H �� k��q ]2Cs8/ ��[4� z�hF�.�� cDS�& _% �V�A% �j/�� �So� ,�2��O� � M#� MH P �� L� q nA8 : _�5 kH��.5
c<H�B��� WD�s{� �*3�� @�� @� Pf MgM4 =C�� ���#q �4# ,� M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M�� @��)�# ,]2��4�� J�4?�% ,n)�o� p�V
�Y��?��� @�l�m� ,�2��O� ]��� �r2t/ ,]2�4�� ' klm� 12%34�� ]2�8 ' U��.4VE� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1��
uH 4�� , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ `� ���h�� �S�o� z�A8/ ���F��� 9C�% G�H�I J�4?% Q?A5 ,k�YR _(5 _% 1�2%34�� �)5 �678 94�� �2<��?�� @3ABC�� �2D� 4�E� 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W� XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1��
4�#� j3�x _% , D�S�� @��A2� b��2Y� c<H�B��� ����
�~��m�(Likert scale) ����4��#3� k���D�� ���\/ l��5 n�¼ NI F�/ _% H 4��/ GH�B�� �7V �6&�� �YR��4��
@����4#��5 = ,k B� �R�/q1 =k B� �R�/q E� j���/ , �4�R�0.80 ������ �&H� K5 ]A��� ` _% QF/��8 94��/180� �YR���� � 5 ��r� -*q/ _%/ ,k B181 NI 260 ��r�
_%/ ,�YR���� � 5261 NI 340 _�%/ ,��2O� ��r� 341 NI 420 _%/ ,�YR���� ��r� 421k B� �YR���� ��r� �h<q/ `
� �E� �/ D��� T�35 %��U� V�W: � M#� MH P �� k��q } w _% �Y�4����V�.4�#E� � ���*
cs�s{4�� c�C �A��� _% ��Hq K5 �6\�� z�hF�.�� c�2)��/ ���# $���� ��%��� ��w�m� ��2���� ]?Y� T�B��)��/ U���.4VE� ;W�� XYMV Z��[��\� j���� ' ����.��� ¹��\/ J �% ' ]�6D�H� �� �I -&q _% ; D�S�� 9<�O� <�4��/ ,��g��� ��[x�� _% �64%3#/ �V�.4#E� @��YR
����.�� p���\�� ���64%�3% J ��% _��% ` ]2��Ae ���/�.�� J�&q z�2.4#E� 9�4�� @�R�\��/ @3 4�� z�hF
@���YR n�¼ K5 Q�C4�� 94��/ z�CA��� �° ¾/q ,�#��?���/ ,��2V�h�� kH�.�� 9 / ,z�2.4#E� @��YR _% k���� ���{4� ,k(��5 ���2V�h��/ ,k������/ ,���#�4��/
k��YR z/(5 ����YR � 5/ �2D�6)�� �64g2s� ` ��Y�4��/Z�?F ]8 � M#� MH P �� k��q @�.� _%@��.� -�%�C� k����
¿�.V/�< �r�q(Cronbach’s Alpha) »�� �1�� �0.982 � Àj�5 @�.h� ]?48 �V�.4#E� @��YR zq <q �±`
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 413 –
�!��J+X� �Y�, �: �� {4�#�� z��hF�.�� ���* � M#� MH P �� @�V�2� -2��4�
��25~4&E� ������ �2D�s�F�� ��%SO� y%�V��(SPSS) 2.�� �o�% ' � {4? �1�� ��{4�#�/ �2D�sF�� @�V�
@����4#E ,�H�2�� @�R���VE�/ ,�2��?O� @�[#�4�� @3AB�C�� ]��<�H�I J C� �[.8��� � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq =Z��[�\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� �2D� 4�E� ��F��� ' D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV
'����� �) % `@��.� Z�?F NI �R�\I ��#�H �� k��q¿�.V/�< �r�q -%�C� (Cronbach’s Alpha) _�% �Y�4��
�% {4?��� k���� @�.���V�.4�#E� `� ��2.[8 |���q :]�8/H���.4x� �@� (t-test) -��&q _��% � {4?�� b���2Y% ��� /
@��5�C� c�� }/��r�� ���E� @�� yD��4V NI j�w��� P ��� c<H�B���28¡� @� Pf MgM4=�� ' � M#� MH: � �r2t��� ,n)o�
uH ��4�� ����q ,���2��O� `� _���.4�� -��2�e H���.4x� :]��8 ~��< ���F��(One-way ANOVA) @�� yD�4V NI j�w���
��s��4�� @� Pf�� MgM4 =C�� ��� M#� MH P �� ���M)P2 M5 c��� }/���r�� ���E����,]2��4�� ' ��8lx @��)�#/ ,]���� ]2��8 J�4?%
=Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1�� 12%34�� ]2�8 ' �Y��?�� klm�/ ��D�S�� 9��<�O� T�B��)��/ U���.4VE� ;W�� XYMV `� ����* $�1��<
��[5d� c<H�B�� @����4#� -2�e/ j�x�I )5 z�hF�.�� �q�� ����&q _� ��rw �C2*� ��Á� -�2��4� ���r4<E�/
f���8 G��) z�A E Â4F ,J�x�� ��H�� @����4#E�
;��H�2�� @�R���VE�/ �2��?O� @�[#�4�� Z�?F K5 j��F �qH �� � z�A E * c<H�B�� a� z� $��/ J �% _�% |��%v�& n2�� /q ,�2<��?��� @3AB��� $��8
�4���4#� ' ��2O� NI ��4 �± ,�4YR��% ` S������ >!#Z� (4:
z�hF�.�� ��* �64o�%/ �6�2�e/ @�V�2.�� �� �� ���% v����q _��5 �B��A��/ ,�64B��*�)%/ yD���4)�� ����
K�5 $��� ���5/ ,�� M#� MH P �� U1� yD�4V �2�I Q�w�8á� ��)��:
O[/ \��]91 ^;_�Y� D̀ �a�� M- bc� � �E� �/ D��� ���D! �4 3�c5 Q)d"�^ _�Y� /�'��� ��$���
�<� 304 50.2% ÂhVq 301 49.8%
p�C��� 605 100%
/ �o� j3x _% ]�*H j�1 � H�<1��� zq ¨��4 z����hC�304 � �.?��)�50.2% ���M)P2 M5 �����Rq ¢����I _��%
:_�hC ¦�V�� zq/ ,� M#� MH P ���301 � �M)P2 M5 ���Rq ¢��I _% �.?)� � M#� MH P ��49.8 %� M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq`
O[/ \��]92 ^;$ � D̀ �a�� M- bc� � �E� �/ D��� ���D! �4 3�c5 Q)d"��*!#,��� e"�^ �*!#,��� e"�$ � /�'��� ��$���
9%�& 457 75.5% f4?&�% 86 14.2% U�H�4<� 6 1.0% J�xq 56 9.3%
p�C��� 605 100%
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 414 –
]*H j/ o� j3x _%�2 � zq ¨�4�457 � _�% � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rqz��hC 75.5 % ��M)P2 M5 ����Rq ¢���I _%
] ��4?�% ,� M#� MH P �� K�5 c5v��% ,9%��& 9�C2�4��á� ��)��� :86 � �4.?�)� f4?�&�%14.2 % ¢���I _�%
/ ,�� M#� MH P �� ��M)P2 M5 ���Rq�6 � �.?�)� U�H��4<�12.0 % _�%/ ,� M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq ¢��I�56 � K�5 z��5v�4 ]6)�%
�4.?)� J�xq �2C2�8 @��4?%9.3 % ����Rq ¢���I _�%� MH P �� �M)P2 M5� M#`
O[/ \��]93 ^; \�R f Tgh� %�"�E D̀ �a�� M- bc� � �E� �/ D��� ���D! �4 3�c5 Q)d"�
O!#,���^ Tgh� %�"�E /�'��� ��$���
_%0 � 5 @��)# 195 32.2% _%6� −10@��)# 140 23.1%
11�h<�R �)# 270 44.7% p�C��� 605 100%
]*H j/ o� j3x _%�3 � zq ¨�4�270 � _�%
z��hC � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq44.7 % ��M)P2 M5 ����Rq ¢��I _%]2��4�� j��� ' ]��l�x @��)# ,� M#� MH P ���11 � �)�#
zq/ ,�h<�R�195 � z��hC32.2 % ��M)P2 M5 ����Rq ¢��I _%_��% ]2���4�� j���� ' ]�l��x @��)��# ,��� M#� MH P ���5 �
/ ,-*q/ @��)#�140 �4.?�)� ]6)% �23.1 % ¢���I _�% ]2��4�� j��� ' ]�l�x @��)�# ,� M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq
_% c� ¹/��86 � 10@��)# `
O[/ \��]94 ^; f �K!��� �KC!i"�� D̀ K �a�� M- bKc� �K �E� �/ D��� ���D! �4 3�c5 Q)d"��E/� �^
�C!i"�� /�'��� ��$���
��H� �w ]�% 443 73.2% w�x �2��8 ]�%� 162 26.8%
p�C��� 605 100%
]��*H j/ ��o� j3��x _��%�4 � � ��5 zq ¨���4
»���� ��H� ���w 9��C�% �443 � �����Rq ¢����I _��% �.?�)� � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M573.2% ��2���� 9�C�% � �5 zq/ ,
»�� �w�m� �162 � �.?�)� �� M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq ¢��I _%26.8`%
O[/ \��]95 ^;c5 Q)d"� 1K!-&��� _)/�K� f �!��KEj� bKc� �K �E� �/ D��� �K��D! �4 3�
������ ��� �� ���� ������� k,� ����� OP�� 7)1��^ _)/���� /�'��� ��$���
]V 434 71.7% E 171 28.3%
p�C��� 605 100%
]*H j/ o� j3x _%�5 � zq ¨�4�434 � _�%
z��hC � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq �4.?�V ��%71.7 % ]�� �.�# ' k��v/ U�.4VE� �\ Z��[\� ]^ � 12%38 nH 8
zq/ ,9<�O� T�B)�� �171 � �.?)� �M)P2 M�� ���Rq ¢��I _%28.3 % Z��[�\� ]^ �� 12%38 nH 8 ]� �.? ² _%
D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� �\ `
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 415 –
O[/ \��]96 ^; �/ D��� ���D! �4 3�c5 Q)d"� \�KR f �K!�)/���� %�/� N��� bc� � �E� �-�h� l��U5 ������ ��� �� ���� ������� ���� �� �����
O!#,����
�L!�) �/�L��� %�/� N��� /�'��� ��$���
]V 85 14.0% E 520 86.0%
p�C��� 605 100%
]*H j/ o� j3x _%�6 � zq ¨�4�520 � _�%
�� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq ¢��I �.?)� � M#� MH P 86.0 % K�5 ���s�4 ² T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� j�� ' �2.H 8 @�H/�
zq/ ,]2��4�� ' ��% m� ���)�q D�S�� 9<�O��85 � _�% �.?)� �M)P2 M�� ���Rq14.0 % ' �2.H 8 @�H/� K5 ���se
�D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� j��m� ��)�q]2�4�� ' �% `
� �E� �/ D��� �#GEm� ��#,� � S������: j/�� j��?�� : ���F��� 9�C�% G�H�I J �% �%
1�2%34�� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� �2D� 4�E�
9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� ? D�S��
����F��� 9��C�% G�H�I J ��% K��5 L���4��� 4�E� 1�2%34�� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� �2D
9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� @��R���VE�/ ,�2��?�O� @�[#�4�� Z�?F ]8 , D�S�� K�5 � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ���Rq @����4#E ,u8���/ ,�H�2��
94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� K5 SA8�8 @�H�.5 �)5 �678 T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
D�S�� 9<�O� ` �2��?O� @�[#�4�� �C2* Z�?F ]8 ~<�R���VE�/@ �q��� ����&q _� �H�2�� � ��Á� ��C2Y<
,J�x�� ��H�� @����4#E� -2��4� ��r4<E�/ ��rw @�[��#�4�� Z�?��F K��5 f����8 G���) z���A E ��4F
��H�2�� @�R���VE�/ �2��?O� ` ~�< yD��4)�� @���&/á� j/ o� �6�\�:
O[/ \��]97 ^; �� ���� ������� ���� �� M����� OP�� 7)1�� 1!-&��� ��4 .n� ���� �L!��"M# N$�� %&' �� ��#,� � %�/��,�� o4 � �E� �/ D��� ���D! �4 3�c5 %���p�E�
���- ������ �����c�" � q�4 %��E"�- r$+ s�!�d��� ^
O[/ T/��,�� T/��,�� 3�4 ��!,�� tE"� � u�$�
<�I��� e/�!, �
�����
18 Q4B4 ]6 �.4V� ���6?� @�fhC�� �2&H�m� 94�� z�\�4 �� 472 2.02 1.303 1
10 ]^ � ���w ��Y.�� ' Y�� ��H �� k % ���� �VH�Y% ]6D3%S� 448 2.03 1.340 2
4 z/ § ���w ' �<H�B�� ' �[BV�� �2rs�� �/ ° 466 2.09 1.248 3
11 z/ § ���w ' H�74VE� Â4F -s ] H/� 464 2.10 1.309 4
5 ]^ � ���w ' ]27)8 Q*��� )5 ]6D��q ��6�� ����[�� ]6)% 448 2.14 1.258 5
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 416 –
Q��� O[/ \��]97;^
O[/ T/��,�� ��T/��, 3�4 ��!,�� tE"� � u�$�
<�I��� e/�!, �
�����
8 z/ § ���w ' S2<��� K5 ���q ��6�� �[BV��/ ����[�� ]6)% 442 2.14 1.270 6
19 /fh< z�2?)�� ��6C�� �[BV��/ 94�� z�%�Y �° |�2%� 443 2.14 1.291 7
13 z�� �4 -AB� T�r% �Y�[�/ f� �[.�)% 477 2.15 1.245 8
1 z�RÄ4 �25�R V�� k � |�VH�Y% ]6D3%S� 440 2.15 1.278 9
15 z/ § ���w ' S2<�8 ]6 �.4V� -2w�r4� ��2��� k� ��� ]� 520 2.17 1.217 10
3 z/�67 |��~Vq �2<��# f� ,���# -h% :��o� ' L/�t f� �.#�)% 496 2.17 1.235 11
7 z�5H�? ������& _5 ���#�� -.* ��64VE� _% �6\�5 476 2.18 1.295 12
12 /fh< -C�C4�� �5SVE�/ _% ��6�� �[BV��/ 94�� u�[8 ]6)% 476 2.18 1.337 13
2 z� =C ;?:4 M � � kH Y�� K5 p�.8� @~2�4�� ����[�� ]6)% 428 2.20 1.200 14
6 |�fh< �% z/ Yr ]6\���q ]��/�q/ ���2#H 459 2.20 1.285 15
17 |�fh< �% z���Y _�x¡� ' ]6h F z��x 4/ �2R 454 2.20 1.307 16
9 E z�gs /q z/ . �q �~4 � �% )5 ¦ �48 ]62�I k��.% 471 2.21 1.251 17
20 E z�=� P�r= ��2Y�� ��6��� �[BV��/ 94�� �S�4?8 |� 6& |�2�Y5 500 2.23 1.308 18
16 z� =C ;?:4 M � :�\�r��� j3x ]6D��q ��6C�� �[BV��/ ����[�� ]6)% 444 2.24 1.253 19
14 z��Br ' ���I ��6�� �[BV��/ ����[�� ]6)% 452 2.42 1.284 20
q�,�� tE"� � 2.26 1.045
���Rq zq ¨�4 U35q ��\��� yD�4)�� j3x _%
�C�% _�% � M#� MH P �� �M)P2 M5 ��) % ' ��2D� 4�E� ���F��� 9 )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� z�<H E ����� T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
�#�4C� D�S�� 9<�O��2.26_% 5� �Y �#�4% � / ,@��A2� b�2Y% _% �2V�h�� ��r�� ' (Likert scale)� _�%
1.81 NI 2.60 �4���?�¼ NI �F�/ _% H ` Åj�� �� / G�H�I U���¬ ���M)P2 M�� �����Rq nV���¬ � ��5 K��5 |�2D�s��FI ]^ ��� _1���� 1��2%34�� J ��� �:2;<�=� >?���� @3AB����
K�5/ , �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\�@3AB���� $���8 ����&/ ` @�[��#�4% Q��F/��8 ��*/
4�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� ]6<�H�I 1�2%34�� )5 �678 9 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1��
c� �% D�S���2.02NI 2.42 � ' ��Y8 @�[�#�4% 9� / @�A2� b�2Y% _% �2V�h�� ��r��(Likert scale) `
_�% �� M#� MH P �� ��M)P2 M5 ����Rq zq yD�4)�� _% ¨�4/�� �) % ' �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% cYR���% f� ���
�)5 ��678 9�4�� �:2;<�=� >?��� @3AB�� _% _(5 K5
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 417 –
T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� ]�*H @�H�.�� ' -hC48 , D�S�� 9<�O��18 ,10 ,4 ,11 ,
5 ,8 ,19 ,13 ,1 ,15 ,3 ,7 ,12 ,2 ,6 ,17 ,9 ,20 ,16 ,14� ,F |�2�v�)8 �6.28�M8 :]8/ ��M)P2 M5 �� M�XRMq �YMR�� =% � 5 �&H� u?
¢�4��< 9 / ,�62�5 � M#� MH P �� : ]�*H kH��.�� @��&�18 � /:� 94�� �2&H�m� @�fhC�� ���6?� ]6 �.4V� Q4B4
�� z�\�4� �#�4C� ,N/�� �.8��� ' �2.02_�% 5 `� ]*H kH�.�� @��&/�10 �9 / :� ���Y.�� ����w ]^ �
�� Y�� ']6D3%S� �VH�Y% ���� k % ��H � �.8��� ' �#�4C� ,�2V�h���2.03 _% 5 `� ]�*H kH��.�� @���& ]�
�4 �9�� / :� �[B��V�� ' �<H�B���� ' �����w z/ ��§�/ ° �2rs��� �#�4C� ,�h��h�� �.8��� ' �2.09 _% 5 `�
]*H kH�.�� @��& $�� ��11 �9 / : � z/ §Â4F H�74VE� ' ���w] H/� -s � ,������ �.8��� '
�#�4C��2.10 _% 5 `� ]*H kH�.�� @��&/�5 �9� / :� ����6�� ]��6D��q ��)5 Q��*��� ]2��7)8 ' �����w ]^ ���
]6)% ����[��� ��#�4C� ,�?�%�m� �.8��� ' �2.14 _�% 5 `� ]*H kH�.�� @��& $�� � ]��8 �9 / :� z/ �§
���6�� ���q K�5 S�2<��� ' ���w �����[�� �[B�V��/ ]6)%� �#�4C� �#��?�� �.8��� ' �2.14 _�% 5 `� _�%/
]�*H kH��.�� @���& ]��19 �9� / :� z�2?�)�� /f�h< |��2%� ��° z��%�Y 9�4�� �[B�V��/ ��6C��� ��.8��� '
�#�4C� ,���?���2.14 _% 5 `� ]�*H kH��.�� @��&/
�13 �9�� / :� f��� ���Y�[�/ T���r% -AB��� z�� ���4.���)%�[� ���#�4C� ���)%�h�� ���.8��� ' �2.15 _��% 5 `�
]�*H kH�.�� @��&/�1 �9� / :� ��25�R V�� z�R�4]6D3%S� |�VH�Y% k �� ��#�4C� ,��#�4�� ��.8��� '
�2.15 _�% 5 `� ]�*H kH��.�� @���& $��� ��/�15 �Â�� / :� -2��w�r4� ]6 ���.4V� S��2<�8 ' �����w z/ ��§
]� k� ��� ��2������� ' ��#�4C� ,k���� �.8�2.17 _%5 `�
]*H kH�.�� @��& ]��3 �9 / :� |��~Vq z/�67-h% ,� ��# f� �2<��# :�.�#�)% f� L/�t ' ��o��
�#�4C� ,k(5 ���O� �.8��� '�2.17 _% 5 `� @��&/ ]*H kH�.���7 �9 / :� ����#�� _5 ���&��� z�5H�?
�6��\�5 _��% ����64VE� -��.*�� ' ,k(��5 ���2V�h�� ���.8�� �#�4C��2.18 _% 5 `� ]�*H kH��.�� @���& $�� �
�12 �9�� / :� ����6�� _��% ���5SVE�/ -��C�C4�� /f��h<]6)�% u��[8 94�� �[BV��/� ,k(�5 ��h��h�� ��.8��� '
��#�4C��2.18 _��% 5 `� ]��*H kH���.�� @����& ]����2 �9�� / :� @~2���4�� p���.8� K��5 kH ��Y�� � ��� z� =C ;?��:4 M
�]6)% ����[�� ��#�4C� ,k(5 ������ �.8��� ' �2.20 _%5 `� ]*H kH�.�� @��&/�6 � 9 /� z/ Yr �% |�fh<
�2#H �� ]��/�q/ ]6\���q� ,k(�5 �?%�m� �.8��� ' ���#�4C��2.20 _��% 5 `� ]��*H kH���.�� @����&/�17 �
9�� / :� ]6h ��F ' _���x¡� z�����Y ���% |�f��h<
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 418 –
��2R z��x 4/�' ��#�4C� ,k(�5 �#��?��� ��.8��� �2.20 _% 5 `� ]�*H kH��.�� @��& $�� ��9 � 9� /� ]62��I ¦ ��48 �% �)5 �~4 � �q z/ . /q z�gs E
k��.%� ��#�4C� ,k(�5 ���?�� �.8��� ' �2.21 _�% 5 `� ]*H kH�.�� @��&/�20 � 9 /� ���2Y�� z�=� P�r= E
6& �S�4?8 94�� �[BV��/ ��6��� |�2�Y5 |� � �)%�h�� �.8���� �#�4C� ,k(5�2.23 _% 5 `� ]�*H kH��.�� @���& ]�
�16 � 9 /� ���6C�� ]�6D��q j3x ��\�r��� z� =C ;?:4 M]6)��% ������[�� �[B��V��/� ,k(��5 ���#�4�� ���.8��� '
�#�4C��2.24 _% 5 `� ]*H kH�.�� @��& |�fxq/�14 � 9 /���/ ��6�� ���I ' z��Br]6)�% �����[�� �[BV�
�#�4C� ,_(�� �.8��� '�2.42 _%5`�
����h�� j��?���� : ����E� @�� }/���R G���) -�� @3ABC�� �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% G�H�I ' �2D�sFI =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?��
? D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV �� V�C��_�Y� D̀ �a�� M- <&�v :
���E� @�� }/��R G�) z�< ��I �% K5 L�4��n)��o� Pf�� MgM4 =% L34x���� �2D�s��FI z���hF�.�� � {4��#�
H���.4x��@�� (Sample T-test c��� }/���r�� ���R�� �6��\� ~�< yD��4)�� @���&/ � M#� MH P �� ���Rq @���&I
¢�4�� j/ o�:
O[/ \��]98 ^; /���v� S����w%x_�Y� D̀ �a�� M- bc� � �E� �/ D��� ��D! �4 3�c5 %��E"�- y� V�C�� ����� : "!�!C� /���v�
� �E� �/ D��� /��z _�Y� 3�4��!,�� < �*![
�������!��J+X�
tE"� �u�$�
<�I���e/�!, �
% �*![ e"�$-������
�<� 298 2.486 1.125 �� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� ]^ � _1�� 12%34 D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\�` ÂhVq 299
37.682 0.000** 2.042 .907
−5.311 0.00**
** 2"�$- ��4 ���30.05 >[mc
���E� @�� }/��R ���&/ U3�5q j/ �o� �67
J�4?��% ��)5 �2D�s��FI0.05c��C��� G�H�I ' -��*�R 12%34�� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� @~���/ 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1��
n) ;o� Pf MgM4=;� |�YR/ D�S�� ` ��<�H�I ��h<q ¦�V�� zq Â)C�
H�<1�� _% 12%34�� �E� J � �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC��` �$ � D̀ �a�� M- <&�v�� V�C���*!#,��� e":
��E� @�� }/�R $��) QV�< ��I �% K5 L�4�� Pf MgM4 =% L34xE JS8 � M#� MH P �� ���Rq @���&I ' �2D�sFI
z���hF�.�� � {4��#� ,9��C2�4�� ��4?����� _���.4�� -��2�e
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 419 –
���F���� ANOVA � zI }/��r�� $��8 �R�% -&q _%¢�4�� j/ o� �6�\� ~< yD�4)�� @��&/ ,@ &/:
O[/ \��]99 ^; S����we3�+j� 7)����� >!#Zx�*!#,��� e"�$ � D̀ �a�� M- <&�v� s���| � �E� �/ D��� ��D! �4 3�c5 %���]} f V�C#� /"I � 7)����� /�J- %�,�- ~"*R �)� %�]/3 %�,� � tE"�- < �*![ ������ e"�$-
@�5�C��� c� 2.529 3 .843 @�5�C��� -x�� 648.762 593 1.094
��)5 ���678 9��4�� �:2;<�=� >?���� @3AB����34�� U��.4VE� ' ��\ ]^ �� _1�� 12%
9<�O� T�B)�� k��v/ p�C��� 651.290 596 .770 .511
`� 2"�$- ��4 ���30.05 >[mc
� �5 U3�5q ���\��� yD��4)�� j3x _% ¨�4 �)5 �2D�s�FI ���E� @�� }/��R ��&/ J�4?�% 0.05
94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� � M#� MH P �� ���Rq G�H�I ' ,-*�R U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� )5 �678 ��4?�� Pf MgM4 =% L34xE J MS X=8 , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/
9C2�4��`
O!#,��� \�R f Tgh� %�"�E D̀ �a�� M- <&�v�� V�C��: 4�� @�� }/��R $���) Q�V�< ��I ��% K�5 L�
JS�=8 �� M#� MH P �� ��M)P2 M5 ����Rq @���&I ' �2D�sFI ��E� � {4�#� ]2�4�� j�� ' klm� @��)# Pf MgM4 =% L34xE
z�hF�.������F�� _�.4�� -2�e � (ANOVA) ¨2\�4���E� ¢�4�� j/ ��� |�YR/ yD�4)�� @��&/ ,}/�r��:
O[/ \��]910 ^; S����we3�+j� 7)����� >!#Z xO!#,��� \�R f Tgh� %�"�E D̀ �a�� M- <&�v� s���| � �E� �/ D��� 3�c5 %���]} f V�C#�^
/"I � 7)����� /�J- %�,�- ~"*R �)� %�]/3 %�,� � tE"�- < �*![ ������ e"�$-
@�5�C��� c� 12.271 2 6.135 @�5�C��� -x�� 639.020 594 1.076
��)5 ���678 9��4�� �:2;<�=� >?���� @3AB������� 12%34�� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1
D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� p�C��� 651.290 596 5.703 .004**
** 2"�$- ��4 ���30.05 >[mc
��E� @�� }/�R ��&/ U35q j/ o� _% ¨�4
J�4?% )5 �2D�sFI0.05 ����Rq G�H�I J �% ' ,-*�R 1�2%34�� �)5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� � M#� MH P �� T�B�)�� k��v/ U�.4VE� ' �\ Z��[\� ]^ � _1��
j��� ' kl�m� @��)# Pf MgM4 =% L34xE JS=8 ,9<�O�]2�4�� ` @���R _�% c�4�R -�< c�� }/��r�� � �4�/
:]�8 k �F K5 klm� @��)# ,�2r2�� H��.4x� �� {4�#� ¢�4��< ��D�4V @��&/:
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 420 –
O[/ \��]911 ^;T�+ o4 Tgv ��Gc >� y� V�C�� 7- b�I�#� �!C!� /���v� S����^ Tgh� %�"�E
/"I � Tgh� %�"�E 3�4��!,��
tE"� �u�$� 5>[5� %�"�E 7-6 − 10%�"�E 11��mc q�4
5-*q/ @��)# 192 2.106 − ** _%6 − 10@��)# 138 2.371 −
�:2;<�=� >?��� @3AB�� �)5 ��678 9�4�� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� 11�h<�R ��5 267 2.420 − ** 2"�$- ��4 ���30.05>[mc
G�) zq U35q ��\��� j/ o� yD�4V _% ¨�4
@�� |�*/�R J�4?% )5 �2D�sFI ��E� 0.05 c�� -�*�R ]��lx _1�� cC��� G�H�I5 G�H�I/ ,-�*q/ @��)#
]��l�x _1��� cC���11 @3AB�C�� ,�h<��R |��%�5 Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� ¨��s� $��/ ;9<�O� T�B)�� k��v/ U�.4VE� ' �\
1�� cC��� ]��lx _11 @��6tq ��2F ,�h<��R |�%�5 @3AB���� U1�� ���*��� |���<�H�I =���h<q ]�� :�q ���#� MH P ��
] f� _%` �E/� � f �!��� �C!i"�� D̀ �a�� M- <&�v�� V�C�� :
���E� @�� }/�R G�) QV�< ��I �% K5 L�4�� ' ���2��O� ���r2t��� Pf�� MgM4 =% L34��xE JS��8 �2D�s��FI
� �#H �� H��.4x� z��hF�.�� � {4�#�@ � (Sample T-
test) @��&/ ,� M#� MH P �� ���Rq @���&I c� }/�r�� �R��¢�4�� j/ o� �6�\� ~< yD�4)�� :
O[/ \��]912 ^; /���v� S����w%x�E/� � f �!��� �C!i"�� D̀ �a�� M- bc� � �E� �/ D��� 3�c5 %��E"�- y� V�C�� ����� ^
"!�!C� /���v�
� /��z� �E� �/ D�� �C!i"�� 3�4��!,�� < �*![
�������!��J+X�
tE"� �u�$�
<�I���e/�!, �
% �*![ e"�$-������
��H� �w ]�% 437 2.428 1.104 ��)5 ���678 9��4�� �:2;<�=� >?���� @3AB���� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1��� 12%34��
D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� �w�x �2��8 ]�% 160 71.724 0.000**
1.816 .690
−6.558 0.00**
** 2"�$- ��4 ���30.05>[mc
}/��R ���&/ NI U3�5q ���\��� yD�4)�� fB8 J�4?�% �)5 �2D�sFI ��E� @��0.05 G�H�I ' -�*�R
��w�m� ��2���� 9�C�%/ �2�#�H �� L�rs��� 9C�% =� >?�� @3ABC�� _1��� 1�2%34�� �)5 ��678 94�� �:2;<�
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 421 –
; �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ ��w�m� �2���� 9C�% ¨��s� $��/ ` 9C�% zq Â)C�
����� L�rs�� 9C�% _% |�<�H�I �h<q �w�m� �2����` M���K�� OP�� 1!-&� _)/�� D̀ �a�� M- <&�v�� V�C��
��� ������������ ��� �� ���� ���� : ������ }/���R G���) Q��V�< ��I ���% K��5 L���4��
]^ �� 1�2%38 nH �8 Pf MgM4 =% L34xE J MS X=8 |�2D�sFI � {4#� D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�
H�.4x� z�hF�.���@ �T-test Sample) � }/��r�� �R�� MH P �� �)P2 M5 ���Rq @���&I c� ~�< yD��4)�� @���&/ ,�� M#�
¢�4�� j/ o� �6�\� :
O[/ \��]913 ^; /���v� S����w%x �K�� �� K���� ��K����� ��K�� �� ���K�� OP�� 1!-&� _)/�� D̀ �a�� M- bc� � �E� �/ D��� 3�c5 %��E"�- y� V�C�� �����
������
"!�!C� /���v� � �E� �/ D��� /��z _)/���� ��!,�� 3�4
< �*![ �!��J+X� ������
� tE"� u�$�
<�I���e/�!, �
% �*![ e"�$-������
]V 430 2.149 .990 �)5 ��678 9�4�� �:2;<�=� >?��� @3AB�� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� E 167 12.023 0.001
2.559 1.124
4.368 0.00**
** 2"�$- ��4 ���30.05 >[mc
}/��R ���&/ U35q ��\��� yD�4)�� _% ¨�4 J�4?�% �)5 �2D�sFI ��E� @��0.05 G�H�I ' -�*�R
Z��[�\� ]^ �� 12%38 �� =# :H M� zq �.# _1�� cC��� c�C��� G�H�I/ , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV
��# :H� Xzq �.?�� ² _1���� @3AB��C�� ,����r�� U1�� �� ¨��s� $��/ ;12%34�� �E� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� ,12%34�� �E� nH 8 ' ] lx ]^ � _1�� cC��� _�% �:2;<�=� >?��� 1�2%34�� -<�B� �<�H�I �h<q ��V�< �2F
��r�� U1 nH 8 ]� �.? ² _1�� cC���`
D̀ �a�� M- <&�v�� V�C�� f �K!�)/�� %�/�3 o4 \"J� �K����� �K�� �� K���� ��K����� ������ ����� \�R
O!#,��� f �-�h� l��U5: ���E� @�� }/�R G�) QV�< ��I �% K5 L�4�� @�H/� K�5 j�s�O� Pf� MgM4 =% L34xE JS X=8 �2D�sFI 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� j�� ' �2.H 8
�� z��hF�.�� � {4�#� ]2��4�� j��� ' �% m� ��)�q D�S H���.4x��@�� (Sample T-test c��� }/���r�� ���R��
� M#� MH P �� �)P2 M5 ���Rq @���&I ` ��\� ~< yD�4)�� @��&/á� j/ o�:
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 422 –
O[/ \��]914 ^; /���v� S����w%xbc� � �E� �/ D��� ��D! �4 3�c5 %��E"�- y� V�C�� ����� ��K����� ��K�� �� ����� \�R f �!�)/�� %�/�3 o4 \"J� D̀ �a�� M- O!#,��� f �-�h� l��U5 ������ ��� �� ����^
"!�!C� /���v� � �E� �/ D��� /��z r)/����
3�4��!,�� < �*![ �!��J+X� ������
tE"� �u�$�
<�I���e/�!, �
% �*![ e"�$-������
]V 84 1.785 .834 � 1�2%34�� �)5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�9<�O� T�B)�� k��v/ U�.4VE� ]^ � _1�� E 513
22.323 0.000** 2.342 1.056
4.602 0.00**
** J�4?% )5 ����0.05 -*�R
���&/ NI U35q j/ o� ' �) :C��� yD�4)�� fB8
FI ��E� @�� }/�R J�4?�% �)5 �2D�s0.05 ' -�*�R j��� ' ��2.H 8 @�H/� K�5 c�w�O� cC��� G�H�I ���)�q �D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� K�5 c��w�O� f�� cC��� G�H�I/ ]2�4�� ' �% m� _��% ¨��s��� $����/ ;�?��rV j������ ' ���2.H 8 @�H/�
j�� ' �ss{4% @�H/� K5 ���sF ;W XYMV Z��[\�]2�4�� ' �% m� ��)�q D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE�`
S������ � [��-: J % ' @�R34xE� b�2Y� � M#� MH P �� U1 QC4 � �)5 ��678 9�4�� �:2;<�=� >?��� @3ABC�� cC��� G�H�I T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
� ' D�S�� 9<�O� ��#� MH;� NI �R�\��� ,�2D� 4�E� ��F�� c�C��� G�H�I J �C� ��64*35/ @� Pf� MgM4=�� a�� ��q
1�2%34�� _�% ���r�� U1� �)5 �:2;<�=� >?��� @3ABC�� ` �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% :zMq � M#� MH P �� U1 yD�4V QrB</ �E�� �)5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� z�<H E
@�#�H �� U1 �% ��4Ç uV�o� �1 ' 9 / ;12%34�� (Ohan et al., Kos et al., 2004; Anderson el al., 2012)`
' ��� n)o� Pf MgM4 =% :zq �#� MH P �� U1 Q�\/q/ �:2;<�=� >?��� @3AB�C�� �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% G�H�I
E� ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1��� 1�2%34�� J � U��.4V ���F��� ' @~��� G�H�I zq/ , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ G�H�I _�% K�5q z��< �:2;<�=� >?��� @3ABC�� �2D� 4�E�
cC��� ` k��*/ -C�4�� K5 :_�H * NI $�� JS= */ |3��Ce ��h<q _��q/ ,j��r��� @�2<��?�� _64�7F3%
H�<1�� _% j�r�«� `�#� MH;� ��% ��r48 ���24)�� U1� / ��Nur & Kavakcı, 2010 � ¦��V�� zq NI Q�w�8 94��
J �� �:2;<�=� >?��� @3AB�C�� H�<1��� _�% |��<�H�I �h<q��2D� 4�E� ���F��� ' 1�2%34�� �E� ` yD��4V ��)h4�#��
�#� MH;��Rinn & Nelson, 2009� � 5 NI @H��q 94�� , @~����� G�H�I/ c��C��� G�H�I c��� }/���R ����&/
@3ABC��n)o� Pf MgM4=;� JS= �:2;<�=� >?�� ` ����&/ � ��5 NI |����q ��� M#� MH P �� Q���w�8/
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 423 –
@3AB��C�� �� M#� MH P �� ��M)P2 M5 ����Rq G�H�I ' @��R34x� ��4?��� Pf� MgM4=;� JS�= 1�2%34�� �E�� J � �:2;<�=� >?�� � 8/ ��AB�� �1 ��� F NI �� �%�� �1 / ;9C2�4��
J�4?% NI �R��\��� ,�6s�D�sx/ �� � �7C� 95��� W2{B�8/ ]2�2Y8 ' �% {4?��� @�2�28��#�� Z�2�
��2D� 4�E� ���F��� ���)�q 12%34�� �E� J � �6\��5q ` ��#� MH;� yD�4)� �YR��% ��24)�� U1 @��&/(Sciutto et
al., 2000) ` 9M4���#� MH;� yD����4V :zq _���% ]������� K���5(Stormont, Reinke, & Herman, 2011; Mahar &
Chalmers, 2007) Pf�� MgM4=;� f����8 ����&/ NI �8H����q ��* @3AB��C�� c��C��� G�H�I K��5 9��C2�4�� J�4?����
�:2;<�=� >?��` ����&/ NI ��� M#� MH P �� U1�� yD���4V @H����q ~��< @3AB��C�� ��� M#� MH P �� ���M)P2 M5 �����Rq G�H�I ' L34��x�
)5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34�� Pf�� MgM4=� JS��= ��D�S�� 9��<�O� T�B��)��/ U���.4VE� ;W�� XYMV
]2�4�� j�� ' klm� @��)# ` :zq ��#� MH P �� Q�)2� �*/ -<�B��� $��4� G�H��� J�4?�% ��v @��v ~��< klm�
_�5 ]�l�x -�Y8 E _1��� z�C���R ,�:2;<�=� >?���11 � ��V�< |�%�5 cC��� _% @3AB�� U1 �*��� |�<�H�I �h<q
@��)# n¼ v/��48 E ]��lx _1�� ` ���24)�� U1� / NI Q��w�8 94�� �Y��?�� @�#�H �� ' �H/ �% �% �r48 c��C��� G�H�I J�4?��% c��� ¶���§I T���.8H� ����&/ $��� ]^ �� _1��� 1�2%34�� �% -%�4��/ Z��[\3�
��� ]64% ��x @��)��#/ Z��[��\E� J�4?��%/ ]2�4�� �28�1�� ]���r<�Sciutto et al, 2000� ��#� MH;�/ ,(Kos
et al., 2004) �2?�H 4�� @�lm� �2ªq NI @H��q 94�� �67 _1�� 12%34�� J � �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� G�H�I '
�D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � `U1�� yD���4V |����q ����4Ç ~��< yD���4V ���% ��� M#� MH P ��
���#� MH;�(Daniel, 2011; Ghanizadeh, Fallahi, &
Akhondzadeh, 2009; Kleynhans, 2005; &
Martinussen, Tannock, & Chaban, 2011), 9�4�� ' ��� E ]2�4�� ' klm� @��)# Pf MgM4 =% zq NI Q�w�8
�:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� cC��� G�H�I` �w�8 ~< ' L34�x� ��&/ NI �#�H P �� U1 Q
9��C�%/ �2��#�H �� L�rs���� 9��C�% _��% µ-��< G�H�I �)5 ��678 9�4�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� ,�w�m� �2���� T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
D�S�� 9<�O� ` ��h<q �w�m� �2���� 9C�% zq @�6tq/3AB��� U1�� |��<�H�I /q ������ ]2��4�� 9�C�% _��% @
�2#�H �� L�rs�� ` j�s�F NI ���24)�� U1� JS�=8/ ���F�% ' �:2�#�H� @�H��Y% K5 �w�m� �2���� 9C�% �w�x �rs� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� ��%�� b�H���A.�� $���8 ]����/v ��*/ ,���%�5 �rs��� ���2���� j���� _��5/
�#�� _�% � �� �� {4#� �2r2A� @�H�Y�� @�2�28�� 1�2%34�� �E�� ��% -%�4�� �Y�[� �2C2�4��(Kos et
al., 2006)`
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 424 –
L34�x� ��&/ K5 � M#� MH P �� U1 yD�4V @ <q/ =Z��[�\� ]^ � 12%38 ��# :H� _1�� cC��� G�H�I ' c�C��� G�H�I/ �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV
�r�� U1 nH 8 ]� �.? ² _1��� ` _1��� z�C����R |���<�H�I ���h<q ��V���< ����r�� U1�� ����# :H M� zq ]��� �.��# ]�� �.?� ² _1��� c�C��� _% �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC��
��r�� U1 nH 8 ` �2�I @H��q �% �% ��24)�� U1 �r48/ ���#� MH ; < �Y��?���� @���#�H �� yD���4V a���(Perold,
Louw, & Kleynhans, 2010)�#� MH;�/ (Anderson, et
al., 2012) ' GH���� _��% ���2� zq NI Q���w�8 9��4�� U��.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� _5 �2& G�H�I ]^ � �V�.4#E� }���/ WD�s�m� ' ��w�x �D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/
3�� ` ��% a�� ��% ��2��O� �#�H �� ��24V ��4Ç/ 9��4��/ ,@���< =� 9��4�� @���#�H �� $���8 ���2�I Q���w�8
�� zq NI Q�w�8 ]�� �.?� ² _1��� c2%��o� 12%34 _1�� 12%34�� ]2�8 ' �.�H �h<q ]2�4�� j�� ' -C�� �D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ �
z� 2��� z��C _1�� cC��� _% ` $��� u.# JS=/ ��%�B��� @��%���� K�5 c2%�o� Z3[�� j�sF '
Z��[\E� �1 _5 @�H�YC�� �C4?�� � �4�� P-t ' Q)C��8 ~��H/ ,|��� �4�#�/ |3 �8/ �R�\I �2#�H �� ' ��.���� ] )5 ��/ Z3[�� Sr´ �% @�H�Y�� $�8
12%34�� �E� �% -C��`
���2ªq NI ���2��O� ��� M#� MH P �� yD���4V @H����q ~��< @�H/ > ��2.H 4��� :2�/ ,]2�4�� j�� ' �% m� ��)�q Q�)
j�� ' �2.H 8 @�H/� K5 c�w�O� cC��� G�H�I zq ���)�q �D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\� �E�� U��¬ ��2��§I ��h<q ��V��< ]2�4�� j�� ' �% m� ��2.H 8 @�H/� K5 c�w�O� f� cC��� _% 12%34��
�?rV j���� ' `� MH;� �% �r48 ��24)�� U1 /�#(Anderson
et al., 2012) ��#� MH;�/(Ghanizadeh et al., 2009) ,����r�� U1�� 9��C�% uH ��8 ���2ªq K��5 @S��<H 9��4��
]2��4�� ��2�C5 c?�e ' ]6?8 @�H/ > �� zq @�6tq/ ` ��#� MH;� yD��4V _�5 ���4Ç ��6)A��Bekle, 2004 � 9�4��
]��6<�H�I ' ���*� ���h<q ��V���< c�� ;CP�=�� :zq NI Q���w�8 K5 ,12%34�� H�s8/ G�H�I _% Z��[\3� ]��H�s8/ ��VH�Y% K�5q J�4?C� uH 4�� 12%34�� 9Y�8 _% ]����
cC��� klx J�4?% NI $�� JS=/ ;cC����` %�!W"���� ���h�:
���M)P2 M5 �����Rq :zMq ��� M#� MH P �� U1�� yD���4V Q���\/q C� �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% _% � M#� MH P �� E ����� �)
1�2%34�� �)5 ��678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� z�<H 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1��
�#�4C� D�S���2.26_% 5 � ���r�� ' ��Y �#�4% � / @��A2� b��2Y�� @���R _% �2V�h���_�% 1.81 NI 2.60 �
����Rq nV�¬ J % NI fB8 94�� ��r�� 9 / K�5 ��M)P2 M��
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 425 –
�:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� U1 ��&/ ` @�[�#�4% QF/��8/ )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3AB�� G�H�I K5 ]64YR��% T�B�)��/ U��.4VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 12%34��
c� �% D�S�� 9<�O��2.02NI 2.42 � @�[#�4% 9 / ,% @��R _% �2V�h�� ��r�� ' �Y8@�A2� b�2Y `
K5 ���8 94�� @�fg4�� :zMq � M#� MH P �� yD�4V Q)2�/ �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� @~���/ cC��� G�H�I J�4?% ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1�� 12%34�� )5 �678 94��
9� , �D�S�� 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4VE� : n)�o� Pf� MgM4 =%¦�V�� ¨��s� `lm� Pf MgM4 =%/ �S G�H��� :zq Q4.�q/ ,k
����S� ` @ <q/ ,]2�4�� j�� ' �2��O� �r2t��� Pf MgM4 =%/ _��% |���<�H�I ���h<q ���w�m� ���2� :��� 9��C�% :zq ���#� MH ; ��
L�rs���� 9��C�% ` Z��[��\� j���� ' kl��m� Pf�� MgM4 =%/ _% ��q �#� MH ; �� Q4.�q/ , D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE�
klx ]� E _± �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� |�<�H�I �h<q ] :�Mq/klx z�A�C ` Q��\/q/ ��:2. ;H :4�� @�H/ > ��� Pf MgM4 =%/
Z��[��\� j���� ' �s��s{4�� @�H/ ���� :zMq ��� M#� MH P �� J�4?�% K�5 |���q D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV
� ' @�H/� �� �Y�8 _1�� z�C���R ,G�H��� j����� �1 ² �1��� ]6D3%v _% |�<�H�I �h<q ]2�4�� ' �% m� ��)�q
�6?rV @�H =/ � �� ��Y�4` oK4 <"K["��� �KE� �/ D��� �1F %���!� >!#Z �,�� �"KK) ����$KK�� %�KKE�/���� �KK�� �KK�/��-� �KK.p����
���� ���+���� : • -�%���� j��F �2V� 2% @�#�H� ���&I�@��*��� �
� 5 _% � e 94�� ��2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% a� G�H�I �6P� MF f?28 ' ��6#�� -&q _% ,�:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC��
�64o�%/` • S�S8 -.�# j��F ��2R�/ �2�.Y4?% @�#�H � ��2Y��
�:2;<�=� >?��� @3AB�C�� �2D� 4�E� ��F��� 9C�% G�H�I ;W� XYMV =Z��[�\� ]^ �� _1�� 12%34�� )5 �678 94��
E� D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4V` • K5 �6C2C8 ��§ j���� �1° �w�x @�2��q H� wI
H��C4#�� �6h e �]4 zq K5 ,��r�� U1 9C�%` • ����F��� 9��C�% G�H�I ���*��� �H/� ]���Y8 �����&I
1�2%34�� )5 �678 94�� �:2;<�=� >?�� @3ABC�� �2D� 4�E�VE� ;W XYMV =Z��[\� ]^ � _1�� 9�<�O� T�B�)��/ U�.4
D�S��` • ��2C�5 @�/ �V/ ��2.H 8 @�H/�/ -C5 ÈH/ �%�*I
U1� 9�C�% �&��8 94�� @�2��A��� �-F ' �ss{4% ��7)�� uV�o�� ��4 �% ���# ,��r��� K�5 ]6)2 �% -<
�7F3��/ �BA�� �Y�� � 9�Y2.[4�� uV�o�� �:�4 �% �q C��/�% u#�)�� -%�4�� �Y����r�� U1 �`�
• ' ��2<1�� kS�6&��/ �h O� @�2)Y4�� _% k��r4#E� @�l�m� Z���wq/ �2)�� @�6o� �% -w��4�� �2�C5
�ss{4% É=q _�A8/ ,j���� �1 '`
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 426 –
�*��[� /3�J �Q]� � American Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic and
statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.,
TR.). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric
Association.
Anderson, D.; Watt, S., Noble, W. ; & Shanley, D. (2012).
Knowledge of attention deficit hyperactivity
disorder (ADHD) and attitudes toward teaching
children with ADHD: The role of teaching
experience. Psychology in the Schools, 49(6), 511–
525. doi: 10.1002/pits.21617
Bekle, B. (2004). Knowledge and attitudes about attention-
deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): A
comparison between practicing teachers and
undergraduate education students, Journal of
Attention Disorders, (7), 151-161.
Bevins, T. (1999, summer). Research Designs. Retrieved
February 13, 2014, from
http://ruby.fgcu.edu/courses/sbevins/50065/qtdesig
n.html
Daniel, E. (2011). Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder –
available training module for school teachers.
Journal of Educational Psychology and
Counseling, (2), 209-243.
DuPaul, G.; & Weyandt, L. (2006). School-based
intervention for children with attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder: Effects on academic, social,
and behavioural functioning. International Journal
of Disability, Development, and Education, 53(2),
161-176.
Ghanizadeh, A.; Fallahi, M.; & Akhondzadeh, S. (2009).
Disclosure of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity
Disorder and its Effect on Rejection of Students by
Teachers. Iranian Journal Of Medical
Sciences, 34(4), 259-264.
Graczyk, P.; Atkins, M.; Jackson, M., Letendre, J.; Kim-
Cohen, J.; Baumann, B. ; & McCoy, J. (2005).
Urban Educators' Perceptions of Interventions for
Students With Attention Deficit Hyperactivity
Disorder: A Preliminary Investigation. Behavioral
Disorders, 30(2), 95-104.
Kleynhans, S. (2005). Primary school teachers’ knowledge
and misperceptions of attention-
deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
(Unpublished master dissertation). Retrieved from
http://hdl.handle.net/10019.1/1612
Kos, J.; Richdale, A.; & Hay, D. (2006). Children with
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and their
teachers: A review of the literature. International
Journal of Disability, Development & Education,
53(2), 147-160. doi:10.1080/10349120600716125
Kos, J.; Richdale, A.; & Jackson, M. (2004). Knowledge
about attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: A
comparison of in-service and preservice teachers.
Psychology in the Schools, 41(5), 517-526.
Kypriotaki, M.; & Manolitsis, G. (2010). Teachers’
evaluations for the detection of primary-school
children with attention deficit hyperactivity
disorder. European Journal of Special Needs
Education, 25(3), 269-281.
doi:10.1080/08856257.2010.492940
Mahar, P.; & Chalmers, L. (2007). Teachers’ perceptions of
students diagnosed with ADHD. National Forum of
Applied Educational Research Journal, 20(3), 1-8.
Martinussen, R.; Tannock, R.; Chaban, P.; McInnes, A.; &
Ferguson, B. (2006). Increasing awareness and
understanding of attention deficit hyperactivity
disorder (ADHD) in education to promote better
academic outcomes for students with ADHD.
Exceptionality Education Canada, 16(3), 107-128.
Martinussen, R.; Tannock, R.; & Chaban, P. (2011).
Teachers’ reported use of instructional and behavior
management practices for students with behavior
problems: Relationship to role and level of training
in ADHD. Child & Youth Care Forum, 40(3), 193-
210. doi:10.1007/s10566-010-9130-6
Ministry of Education of Saudi Arabia. (2013, February).
Summary statistics on general education in K.S.A
academic year 2011/2012. Retrieved from
http://portal.moe.gov.sa/Pages/stat32-33.aspx Nur, N.; & Kavakcı, O. (2010). Elementary school
teachers’ knowledge and attitudes related to
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Journal of
Society for development in new net environment in
B&H, 4(2), 350-355.
Ohan, J.; Cormier, N.; Hepp, S. ; Visser, T.; & Strain, M.
(2008). Does knowledge about attention-
deficit/hyperactivity disorder impact teachers'
reported behaviors and perceptions? School
Psychology Quarterly, 23, 436-449.
Perold, M.; Louw, C.; & Kleynhans, S. (2010). Primary
school teachers’ knowledge and misperceptions of
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
South African Journal of Education, 30(3), 457-
473.
Reid, R.; Trout, A.; & Schartz, M. (2005). Self-regulation
interventions for children with attention
deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Exceptional
Children, 71(4), 361-377.
Rinn, A.; & Nelson, J. (2009). Preservice Teachers'
Perceptions of Behaviors Characteristic of ADHD
and Giftedness. Roeper Review, 31(1), 18-26.
doi:10.1080/02783190802527349
Rosenberg, M.; Westling, D.; & McLeskey, J. (2008).
Special education for today’s teachers: An
introduction. Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Merrill/Prentice Hall.
�� ����� ������� ���� ,27 � �� ,�3� ����� ,�2015��1437� �
– 427 –
Sciutto, M.; Terjesen, M.; & Bender Frank, A. (2000).
Teacher's knowledge and misperceptions of
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Psychology
in the Schools, (37), 115-122.
Stormont, M.;Reinke, W.; & Herman, K. (2011). Teachers’
characteristics and ratings for evidence-based
behavioral interventions. Behavioral Disorders,
37(1), 19-29.
West, J.; Taylor, M.; Houghton, S.; & Hudyma, S. (2005).
A comparison of teachers’ and parents’ knowledge
and beliefs about attention-deficit/hyperactivity
disorder (ADHD). School Psychology
International, 26(2), 192-208.
doi:10.1177/0143034305052913
Zentall, S.;& Javorsky, J. (2007). Professional development
for teachers of students with ADHD and
characteristics of ADHD. Behavioral Disorders,
32(2), 78-93.
* * *
9A���� L� -2.V/ ,��5��q �� .5 _���� .5: D�S�� 9<�O� T�B)��/ U�.4VE� ;W XYMV Z��[\�� �[.8��� �2<��?�� @3AB��```
– 428 –