Optical Networks (3-4)-Network Survivability

Instructor: Xiaohong JiangSchool of Information Science

大学院情報科学研究科姜 暁鴻 助教授

Lecture 3: Network Survivability

SurvivabilityProtectionOptical Networks EvolutionProtection for Point-to-Point LinksProtection for Ring NetworksProtection for Mesh Networks

3

4

Outline

SurvivabilityProtectionOptical Networks EvolutionProtection for Point-to-Point LinksProtection for Ring NetworksProtection for Mesh Networks

Survivability

DefinitionWhy Survivable Optical Networks

Survivability DefinitionSurvivability of a network can be defined as its ability to continue providing service in the presence of failure(s). A network is survivable if it has a certain degree of survivability.

A survivable network A non-survivable network

A

IPRouter

OADMB

SONET Terminal

C D

IPRouter

SONET Terminal

E

IPRouter F IP

Router

OLT

OXC

Lightpath λ1

λ1

λ2 λ2

λ2

λ1

A

IPRouter

OADMB

SONET Terminal

C D

IPRouter

SONET Terminal

E

IPRouter F IP

Router

OLT

OXC

Lightpath λ1

λ1

λ2 λ2

λ2

λ1

Why Survivable Optical Networks

Potential bandwidth of one optical fiber exceeds several tens Tbps (note that the bandwidth of copper cable is only a few Mbps). A single failure can disrupt millions of users and result in millions of dollars of lost revenue to users and operators of a network.Note: The most likely failure event is fiber cut (link failure) and the protection is the key technique used to ensure survivability.

Link failure(fiber cut)Switch

failure

Outline

SurvivabilityProtectionOptical Networks EvolutionProtection for Point-to-Point LinksProtection for Ring NetworksProtection for Mesh Networks

ProtectionProtection DefinitionWorking and Protection PathsDedicated and Shared ProtectionRevertive and Nonrevertive ProtectionUnidirectional and Bidirectional Protection SwitchingPath Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching

Protection DefinitionProtection is to provide some redundant capacity within a network and automatically reroute traffic around the failure using this redundant capacity.

ProtectionProtection DefinitionWorking and Protection PathsDedicated and Shared ProtectionRevertive and Nonrevertive ProtectionUnidirectional and Bidirectional Protection SwitchingPath Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching

Working and Protection PathsWorking paths carry traffic under normal operation;Protection paths provide alternate paths to carry the traffic in case of failure.

Working and protection paths are usually diversely routed (link-disjoint) so that both path are not lost in the case of a single failure.

Working path

Protect path

ProtectionProtection DefinitionWorking and Protection PathsDedicated and Shared ProtectionRevertive and Nonrevertive ProtectionUnidirectional and Bidirectional Protection SwitchingPath Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching

Dedicated and Shared ProtectionDedicated protection provides each working path its own dedicated protection path;Shared protection allows bandwidth sharing among the protection paths of connections if the working paths of these connections will not fail simultaneously (usually link-disjoint).

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Dedicated protection Shared protection

ProtectionProtection DefinitionWorking and Protection PathsDedicated and Shared ProtectionRevertive and Nonrevertive ProtectionUnidirectional and Bidirectional Protection SwitchingPath Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching

Revertive and NonrevertiveProtection

Revertive protection automatically switch the traffic back from protection path onto the working path once the working path is repaired.Nonrevertive protection allows the traffic remains on the the protection path after the working path is repaired.

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Dedicated protection(revertive or non revertive)

Shared protection(revertive )

ProtectionProtection DefinitionWorking and Protection PathsDedicated and Shared ProtectionRevertive and Nonrevertive ProtectionUnidirectional and Bidirectional Protection SwitchingPath Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching

Unidirectional and Bidirectional Protection Switching

Working

Protection

Protection switching can be unidirectional or bidirectional.Unidirectional protection switching: In the event of a single fiber cut, only one direction of traffic is switched over to the protection fiber and the other direction remains on the original working fiber. (Suitable for dedicated protection schemes)Bidirectional protection switching: In the event of a single fiber cut, both directions are switched over to the protection fibers(Suitable for shared protection schemes)

(a) Normal operation (b) Unidirectional protectionswitching

(c) Bidirectional protectionswitching

Working

Protection

×

Protection

Working

×

ProtectionProtection DefinitionWorking and Protection PathsDedicated and Shared ProtectionRevertive and Nonrevertive ProtectionUnidirectional and Bidirectional Protection SwitchingPath Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching

Path Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching

Path Switching, Span Switching, and Ring Switching involve how and where the traffic is rerouted in the event of a failure.Path switching: connection is rerouted end to end from its source to its destination along an alternate path.Span switching: connection is rerouted on a spare link between the nodes adjacent to the failure.Ring switching: connection is rerouted on a ring between the nodes adjacent to the failure.

Working path(a) Normal operation (b) Path switching (c) Span switching (d) Ring switching

Outline

SurvivabilityProtectionOptical Networks EvolutionProtection for Point-to-Point LinksProtection for Ring NetworksProtection for Mesh Networks

Optical Networks Evolution

::

λ3

λ2λ1

λ3λ1

λ2

λ3λ3

λ2λ1 λ2λ1

λ3λ1

λ2

Opt

ical

Pat

h C

ontr

olla

bilit

y

Stat

ic C

ontr

olD

ynam

ic C

ontr

ol

1990’s 2010’s

Point-to-point WDM transmission

OADM-based WDM Ring Network

OXC-based WDM Mesh Network

OADM

OXC

Time

Network Autonomously Controlled by IndividualPhotonic MPLS Routers

MPLS: Multi-Protocol Label SwitchingOADM:Optical Add/Drop Multiplexer OXC: Optical Cross-connect

Photonic MPLS Routers

Fast Optical Burst Data Switching Network

Outline

SurvivabilityProtectionOptical Networks EvolutionProtection for Point-to-Point LinksProtection for Ring NetworksProtection for Mesh Networks

Protection for Point-to-Point Links (Automatic Protection Switching )

1+1 protection 1:1 protection 1:N protection

1+1 Protection

SwitchSplitter

Source Destination

In 1+1 protection, traffic is transmitted simultaneously on two separate fibers (usually over disjoint routes) from source to the destination, and the destination simply selects one of the two fibers for reception. If that fiber is cut, the destination simply switches over to the other fiber and continues to receive data.1+1 protection is fast but requires high bandwidth redundancy.

1:1 Protection In 1:1 protection, there are still two fibers from source to the destination. However, traffic is transmitted over only one fiber at a time (working fiber). If that fiber is cut, the source and the destination both switch over to the other protection fiber.1:1 protection is not as quick as 1+1 protection in restoring traffic, but results in a better bandwidth utilization.

SwitchSwitch

Source Destination

Working fiber

Protection fiber

1:N Protection 1:N protection is a generalization of 1:1 protection, in which N working fibers share s single protection fiber. This scheme can handle the failure of any single working fiber. 1:N protection is very efficient in terms of bandwidth utilization.

SwitchSwitch

Source Destination

Protection fiber

SwitchSwitch

SwitchSwitch

Switch Switch

1

2

N

::

Low-priority data

Outline

SurvivabilityProtectionOptical Networks EvolutionProtection for Point-to-Point LinksProtection for Ring NetworksProtection for Mesh Networks

Protection for Ring Networks (Self-Healing Rings)

Ring networksUnidirectional Path-Switched RingBidirectional Line-Switched Ring (BLSR)BLSR-Span SwitchingBLSR-Ring SwitchingRing Interconnection-a simple wayRing Interconnection-dual homing

Ring Networks

2

1

4

3

fiber

A ring is the simplest topology that is 2-connected, that is, provide two separate paths between any pair of nodes. Ring networks are popular for carrier as well as enterprise networks.

Ring networksUnidirectional Path-Switched RingBidirectional Line-Switched Ring (BLSR)BLSR-Span SwitchingBLSR-Ring SwitchingRing Interconnection-a simple wayRing Interconnection-dual homing

Protection for Ring Networks

Unidirectional Path-Switched Ring (UPSR)In a UPSR, one fiber (a path) is used as working fiber and the other as the protection fiber. Traffic is transmitted simultaneously on the working fiber in the clockwise directionand on the protection fiber in the counterclockwise direction. A UPSR is essentially 1+1 protection.

Ring networksUnidirectional Path-Switched RingBidirectional Line-Switched Ring (BLSR)BLSR-Span SwitchingBLSR-Ring SwitchingRing Interconnection-a simple wayRing Interconnection-dual homing

Protection for Ring Networks

Bidirectional Line-Switched Rings (BLSR)In a four-fiber BLSR, two fibers (a line) are used as working fibers and, two are used for protection. Unlike a UPSR, working traffic in a BLSR can be carried on both directionsalong the ring (usually along shortest path between two nodes). A BLSR is essentially 1:1 protection. The BLSR employs two protection mechanisms: span switching and ring Switching.

Ring networksUnidirectional Path-Switched RingBidirectional Line-Switched Ring (BLSR)BLSR-Span SwitchingBLSR-Ring SwitchingRing Interconnection-a simple wayRing Interconnection-dual homing

Protection for Ring Networks

BLSR-Span SwitchingIn span switching, if a transmitter or receiver on a working fiber fails, the traffic is routed onto the protection fiber in the same span (Span switching can also be used to restore traffic in the event of fiber cut,provided the protection fibers on thatspan are routed separately from the working fibers. However, this is usually not the case. So ring switching is usually used to restore traffic in case of fiber or cable cut.)

Span switching

Ring networksUnidirectional Path-Switched RingBidirectional Line-Switched Ring (BLSR)BLSR-Span SwitchingBLSR-Ring SwitchingRing Interconnection-a simple wayRing Interconnection-dual homing

Protection for Ring Networks

BLSR-Ring SwitchingIn the ring switching, the traffic on the failed link is rerouted around the ring on the protection fibers between the nodes adjacent to the failure.Note: BLSRs (1:1 protection) are more efficient than UPSRs(1+1 protection), because BLSRs provide spatial reuse capabilities by allowing protection bandwidth to be shared between spatially separated connections.

Ring switching

Ring networksUnidirectional Path-Switched RingBidirectional Line-Switched Ring (BLSR)BLSR-Span SwitchingBLSR-Ring SwitchingRing Interconnection-a simple wayRing Interconnection-dual homing

Protection for Ring Networks

Ring Interconnection-a simple wayThe entire network typically consists of multiple rings interconnected with each other, and a connection may have to be routed through multiple rings to get t its destination.

The simplest way for rings interconnection is to connect the drop sides of two AMDs on different rings back to back. Note this interconnection is broken if one of the AMDs fails or there is a problem with the cabling between the two ADMs.

Ring networksUnidirectional Path-Switched RingBidirectional Line-Switched Ring (BLSR)BLSR-Span SwitchingBLSR-Ring SwitchingRing Interconnection-a simple wayRing Interconnection-dual homing

Protection for Ring Networks

Ring Interconnection-Dual homingDual homing makes use of two hub nodes to perform the interconnection.

In dual homing, each end node is connected to two hub nodes so as to be able to recover from the failure of a hub node or the failure of any interconnection between the hub nodes.

Outline

SurvivabilityProtectionOptical Networks EvolutionProtection for Point-to-Point LinksProtection for Ring NetworksProtection for Mesh Networks

Protection for Mesh NetworksThere are two main pre-designed protection techniques against single-link failure in WDM Mesh networks:•Link-based protection•Path-based protection

5

6

3

4

1

2

Working path

Link-based protection

Path-based protection

Link-based Protection for Mesh Networks

In link-based protection, a protection path is reserved for each link based on ring switching.

Dedicated link protection:A protection lightpath is dedicated to a particular link. If the protection paths of two links are overlapped, then different wavelengths must be used in the overlapped links.

Shared link protection : It allows different backup paths to share a wavelength on the overlapping links, if the corresponding working channels are on different links. It utilizes capacity more efficient than dedicated link protection

5

6

3

4

1

2

5

6

3

4

1

2

λ1 λ2

λ1

Path-based Protection for Mesh Networks

In path-based protection, a protection path is reserved for each working path.

Dedicated path protection: It provides each working path its own dedicated protection path;

Shared path protection: Itallows bandwidth sharing among the protection paths of connections if the working paths of these connections will not fail simultaneously (usually link-disjoint).

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path

Working path

Protect path