Post on 11-Aug-2015
!"#$%&'"()*$+,-$
!"#$%&'()$*%&'
./0,&1$.234"567$$80"9)$0&$+/':;23<&($8/22"))$=!
+%#,-.$/'0#$1"&2$)/)'3/1"&$/#/'
4'5.*%6"&'789:'
")/#;")$,#<=.%>?@/1"&$/#/'
Why publish in English?
! =(0"1(3<&(3:$:3(>/3>"$&?$3234"5;2)$
! @/;:4$3($;(0"1(3<&(3:$1"9/03<&($
! -"A":&9$;(0"1(3<&(3:$2&::3'&13<&()$
! BA"1)"3)$1")"312,$&99&10/(;<")$
CD E3(/)21;90$)01/20/1"$
FD .')01320)$3(4$<0:")$GD H31>"<(>$0,"$I&/1(3:$JD K#"2<A"$L1;<(>'
Today’s Presentation
CD !&/1(3:$)":"2<&($FD M&A"1$:"N"1)$GD +""1$1"A;"L$
1#++&'-!2! 1#++&'-!3!
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' IMRaD
" A62*&/.*'" =#*&%)B.,%#'" E"*C%)2$$
" %"2BG*2'" 3#)'" -$2.B22$%#'
JC"'6"<$##$#<
JC"'"#)
JC"'>$))G"
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' Introduction
O"("13:$;(01&4/2<&($
89"2;P2$3;5)$A$>2'
M/11"(0$)030"$&?$0,"$P":4$
+1&':"5$;($0,"$P":4$
8"2&(4316$;(01&4/2<&($
M/11"(0$)030"$&?$0,"$P":4$
+1&':"5$;($0,"$P":4$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"'
Introduction – flow of information
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
5#"'I%*"#,/G' *C"&/I"B,.' */&<"*' L%&' GB#<' ./#."&' $2' *C"'V#*' 2$<#/G$#<'I/*CD/M='JC"' ./#%#$./G'V#*' 2$<#/G$#<'I/*CD/M' $#'>/>>/G2' .%#2$2*2'%L' /' L/>$GM'%L'2".&"*")'G$I$)R>%)$-")'V#*'I&%*"$#'G$</#)2'*C/*'6$#)'*%'/'L/>$GM'%L'WRI/22'*&/#2>">6&/#"'X&$;;G")'YX;)Z'&"."I*%&2P'/2'&"1$"D")='[#'6&$"LP'$#'*C"'/62"#."'%L'G$</#)P'<GM.%<"#'2M#*C/2"'O$#/2"R:'Y\!]:ZP'$#'.%>IG"^'D$*C'/^$#'/#)'/)"#%>/*%B2'I%GMI%2$2'.%G$'YA+EZP'.%#2,*B,1"GM'IC%2IC%&MG/*"2'_R./*"#$#P'*C"'I&$>/&M'V#*'2$<#/G$#<'"`".*%&P'*/&<",#<'$*'L%&'B6$a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
A6"&&/#*'V#*'2$<#/G$#<')B"'*%'>B*/,%#2' $#'*+#,-.&%&'%&'/01')&$1"2')"&"<BG/*")'<&%D*C' $#'6%*C'L/>$G$/G'/#)'#%#RC"&")$*/&M'.%G%&".*/G'./#."&2='b%D"1"&P'#%#R2>/GG'."GG'GB#<'./#."&2'YU!EKEZP'*C"'>%2*'.%>>%#'*MI"'%L'GB#<'./#."&P'&/&"GM'C/&6%&'/01'%&'*+#,-.&%&'>B*/,%#2='c/*C"&P'/6"&&/#*'V#*'/.,1$*M'$#'GB#<'./#."&'$2'G$#O")'*%'$#.&"/2")'"^I&"22$%#'%L'BI2*&"/>'V#*'2$<#/G$#<'"`".*%&2'2B.C'/2'N1G'%&')".&"/2")'"^I&"22$%#'%L'V#*'/#*/<%#$2*2'2B.C'/2'V#*R$#C$6$*%&M'L/.*%&'9'YV$LR9Z=''
(`".,1"'IC/&>/.%G%<$./G'$#C$6$*%&2'%L'*C"'V#*'I/*CD/M'C/1"'%#GM'&"."#*GM'6".%>"'/1/$G/6G"='!.&""#2'L%&'2>/GGR>%G".BG"'/#*/<%#$2*2'%L'*C"'V#*'I/*CD/M'L%B#)'*D%'"#;M>"2'*%'6"'O"M'>")$/*%&2'%L'V#*'2$<#/G$#<='JC"2"'/&"'I%GMRAN+R&$6%2"'I%GM>"&/2"' Y+Ac+Z'"#;M>"2P' */#OM&/2"' YJU]!Z'9'/#)'JU]!7P'DC$.C'/d/.C'I%GMRAN+R&$6%2"'Y+AcZ'%#*%'2B62*&/*"'I&%*"$#2='JC"$&'&%G"2'$#'&"<BG/,#<'*"G%>"&/2"'LB#.,%#'/#)'>$*%,.'2I$#)G"'L%&>/,%#'/&"'O#%D#P'6B*'*C"$&'&%G"'$#'+Ac2MG/,#<' /^$#' 2%' /2' *%'>/$#*/$#' *C"' %I,>/G' G"1"G' L%&' ./#%#$./G'V#*' 2$<#/G$#<' C/2' %#GM' &"."#*GM' 6""#' &".%<#$;")=' JC"' .%>I%B#)2' $)"#,-")' $#' *C"2"'2.&""#2P'eAfg:gP'[VcR9'"^%P'/#)'[VcR9'"#)%P'/.*'6M'2I".$-./GGM'$#C$6$,#<'*C"'+Ac+'/.,1$*M'%L'JU]!9'/#)'JU]!7='[VcR"^%'$2'/'2*"&"%$2%>"&'%L'[VcR9'"#)%'D$*C'h94RL%G)'G%D"&'(EQ8='+Ac+'$#C$6$,%#'$2'/'*&/.*/6G"'IC/&>/.%G%<$./G'*/&<"*'%&'2%23P'/2'/#*/<%#$2*2'%L'%*C"&'+Ac+'C%>%G%<2'"^"&*'/#,#"%IG/2,.'&"2I%#2"2'$#'6&"/2*'/#)'%1/&$/#'./#."&P'/2'&"1$"D")=''
JC$2' 2*B)M'"^IG%&")' *C"'CMI%*C"2$2' *C/*' $#C$6$,%#'%L'JU]!'6M'IC/&>/.%G%<$./G'%&'<"#",.'>"/#2'D%BG)' $#C$6$*' GB#<'./#."&'<&%D*C$ %&'2%-43'/#)' %&'2%23' $#'.G$#$./GGMR&"G"1/#*'*&/#2<"#$.'>%B2"'>%)"G2'%L'GB#<'./#."&'*C/*'D"&"'I&"1$%B2GM')"1"G%I")P'/2'&"1$"D")='
O"("13:$;(01&4/2<&($
8"2&(4316$;(01&4/2<&($
B'I"2<A")$iB2.C'"*'/G='iHE'E/#."&='7897j'9:k'799='
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' Methods
Q&L$;0$L3)$4&("$
O"("13:$5"0,&4)$89"2;P2$0"2,(;R/")$S4;)2/))$2&(01&:)T$
-303$3(3:6);)$U/3(<P23<&($5"0,&4)$
803<)<23:$0")0)$
V,30$L3)$/)"4$
8359:")$&1$931<2;93(0)$E30"1;3:)$
Q&L$;0$L3)$3(3:6W"4$
1,+!897':'+!.#;#<5-!+,!:&+#='!#>6#.&8#-75$!
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' Results
CD =(;<3:$&')"1A3<&($FD M,31320"1;W3<&($GD .99:;23<&($
K32,$)/')"2<&($2&11")9&(4)$0&$$'-#!P>/1"$
V,30$6&/$?&/(4*$-'7$L,30$;0$5"3()!
X&>;23:$91")"(03<&($
8/')"2<&()$
Y320/3:$4")21;9<&($
?.#+#-7#!+,+!.#+,$75:'+!#-!,-!'.:#-!$@(&0'!
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' Discussion
8/55316$&?$P(4;(>)$
%":"A3(2"$&?$P(4;(>)$
=59:;23<&()$?&1$$0,"$P":4$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"'
' ' ' 'A22"22>"#*'%L'$)"#,*M')"1"G%I>"#*'/G&"/)M'$#'/)%G"2."#."'$2'$>I%&*/#*'*%'2*B)M')"1"G%I>"#*/G'I/*C2'$#'<"#"&/G'/#)'*%'"#/6G"'1/G$)'.%#.GB2$%#2'/6%B*'2I".$-.'I/*C%G%<$./G'&$2O2l'JC"'!D$22R\"&>/#RA>"&$./#'aB"2,%##/$&"'/5(/'I&%1$)"2'/'&"G$/6G"'/#)'1/G$)'/22"22>"#*'%L'*C"'.%>IG"^'.%#2*&B.*'mI/*C%G%<MR&"G/*")'$)"#,*M'$#*"<&/,%#'12='$)"#,*M')$`B2$%#n'$#'/)%G"2."#*2'6M'$#*"<&/,#<')$`"&"#*'*C"%&",./G'/II&%/.C"2'/#)'/'&"/2%#/6G"'2*&B.*B&"'%L'O#%D#'2B6.%#2*&B.*2='f/G$)'/22"22>"#*'*%%G2'>B2*'/G2%'>""*'*C"'&"aB$&">"#*2'%L'$#*"&#/,%#/G'B2/6$G$*M'$#'.&%22R.BG*B&/G'2*B)$"2'Y"=<='/2')"2.&$6")'6M'*C"' [#*"&#/,%#/G'J"2*'E%>>$22$%#ZP' *%'>%)"G')$`"&"#*'IC"#%*MI"2' $#')$`"&"#*' .BG*B&"2'/#)' *%'"#/6G"'1/G$)' .%>I/&$2%#2'%L' $)"#,*M')"1"G%I>"#*' $#')$`"&"#*'2%.$","2'6M'I&%1$)$#<'*&B"'"aB$1/G"#."'$#'.%#*"#*'%L'*C"'/22"22>"#*'*%%G='' ' ' ' ' JC"'!I/#$2C' .BG*B&"R/)/I*")' *&/#2G/,%#'%L'/5(/' 2C%D")'<%%)'I2M.C%>"*&$.'I&%I"&,"2' $#' *C"'H"^$./#' 2/>IG"P'D$*C' 2$>$G/&'I/d"' $#' &"2BG*2'.%>I/&")'*%'*C"'%&$<$#/G'1"&2$%#='V"'.%#.GB)"'*C/*'/GG'.%#2*&B.*2'/#)'2B6.%#2*&B.*2'.%#*/$#")'$#'*C"'A[NA'>%)"G'*%'.%#2,*B*"'m$)"#,*M')"1"G%I>"#*n'C/)'6""#'2B.."22LBGGM'*&/#2I%2")'$#*%'*C"'m!I/#$2CR2I"/O$#<'.BG*B&"n'D$*C'<%%)'.%#*"#*'"aB$1/G"#."=''
' ' ' ' 'E%>I/&")'*%'*C"'\"&>/#'$*">2'%L'/5(/P'*C"'!I/#$2C'$*">2'2"">")'*%'6"'m"/2$"&'*%'/#2D"&'$#'/'2M>I*%>/,.'D/MnP'$="='*%'2/M'mM"2n'.%)")'*%D/&)2'$)"#,*M')$`B2$%#'$#'*C"'H"^$./#'2.C%%G'2/>IG"='VC$G"'$#'*C"'\"&>/#'2/>IG"P'*C"'>"/#'I"&."#*/<"'%L'2M>I*%>/,.'/#2D"&2'YI$Z'D/2':8T'/#)'78'%L'*C"'Qo'$*">2'2C%D")'/'I"&."#*/<"'6"G%D'98TP'$#'*C"'H"^$./#'2/>IG"'*C"'>"/#'I$'D/2'48T'/#)'%#GM':'$*">2'2C%D")'/#'"^*&">"'1/GB"'L%&'m)$F.BG*M'*%'6"'/#2D"&")'D$*C'M"2n'D$*C'/'I$'6"G%D'98T='JC$2'>"/#2'*C/*'*C"'$*">2'D"&"'$#'<"#"&/G'>%&"')$F.BG*'*%'/#2D"&'D$*C'mM"2n'$#'*C"'\"&>/#'1"&2$%#'*C/#'$#'*C"'H"^$./#'1"&2$%#'%L'/5(/='JCB2P'2.%&"')$`"&"#."2'6"*D""#'H"^$./#'/#)'\"&>/#'/)%G"2."#*2'./##%*'6"' $#*"&I&"*")')$&".*GM'/2')$`"&"#*' G"1"G2'%L'$)"#,*M')$`B2$%#'6"./B2"'2.%&"'"aB$1/G"#."'./##%*'6"'/22B>")='JC"&"L%&"P'I%IBG/,%#'#%&>2P'"=<='JR1/GB"2'"^*&/.*")'L&%>'&"I&"2"#*/,1"'I%IBG/,%#2P'C/1"'*%'6"'B2")'L%&'1/G$)'.%>I/&$2%#2'%L'2/>IG"2'.%#."&#$#<'*C"$&'mG"1"G2'%L'$)"#,*M')"1"G%I>"#*n=''' ' ' ' 'AGG'!I/#$2C'A[NA'$*">2'>/*.C")'*C"'.&$*"&$%#'L%&'$*">'6$/2'/#)'I&%1")'*%'6"'m/<"'/#)'<"#)"&'L/$&n'$#'*C"'H"^$./#'2*B)M='JC$2'/<&""2'D"GG'D$*C'*C"'&"2BG*2' $#' *C"'\"&>/#' 2*B)M=' JC"' .G/22$./G' "^/>IG"' L%&' "^IG/$#$#<' m$*">' L/$&#"22n' $2' *C"' m2%.."&' $*">nk' $*'D%BG)'6"'B#L/$&' *%' @B)<"' *C"' L&"aB"#.M'%L'<"#"&/G'ICM2$./G'/.,1$*M'6M'/2O$#<'mb%D'%p"#')%'M%B'IG/M'2%.."&n'6"./B2"'<$&G2'B2B/GGM')%'#%*'G$O"'*C$2'</>"'/2'>B.C'/2'6%M2')%='\$&G2'D%BG)'I&%6/6GM'2/M'm#"1"&n'>%&"'%p"#P'/#)'*C"&"L%&"'D%BG)'6"' @B)<")'L/G2"GM'/2'mICM2$./GGM' $#/.,1"n' $#'.%#*&/2*' *%' *C"'6%M2='A2'/GG'A[NA' $*">2'./#'6"'&"</&)")'/2'<"#)"&'/#)'/<"'L/$&P')$`"&"#."2'%#'*C"'2.%&"'G"1"G'6"*D""#'<"#)"&'/#)'/<"'<&%BI2'./#'6"'$#*"&I&"*")'/2'*&B"')"1"G%I>"#*/G')$`"&"#."2='''''''A'G$>$*/,%#'%L'*C"'2*B)M'$2'*C"'G/.O'%L'I2M.C$/*&$.')$2%&)"&'/22"22>"#*'$#'*C"'2.C%%G'2/>IG"='i/2")'%#'"I$)">$%G%<$./G'2*B)$"2P'D"'/22B>")'*C/*'BI'*%'9QR78T'%L'*C$2'&"I&"2"#*/,1"'2/>IG"'%L'/)%G"2."#*2'>/M'"^C$6$*'>$#%&'*%'>/@%&'2$<#2'%L'>"#*/G'I&%6G">2='b%D"1"&P'D$*C%B*'"#&$.C>"#*'D$*C'/'.G$#$./G'2B62/>IG"' )$2IG/M$#<' "^*&">"&' G"1"G2' %L' $)"#,*M' )$`B2$%#P' *C"' C"*"&%<"#"$*M' %L' *C"' 2/>IG"' L%&' "1/GB/,#<' *C"' 6/2$.' I2M.C%>"*&$.' I&%I"&,"2' %L' *C"'!I/#$2C'/5(/' $2'#%*'%I,>/G='!$>$G/&GMP'/'*&B"'.G$#$./G'2/>IG"'%L'I/,"#*2'D$*C')"-#")')$/<#%2"2'D%BG)'6"'>%&"'$#L%&>/,1"'L%&'.%>I/&$#<'*C"$&'A[NA'2.%&"2'D$*C'*C%2"'%L'*C"'2.C%%G'2/>IG"'$#'%&)"&'*%'"1/GB/*"'.&$*"&$%#'1/G$)$*M='J%'"^*&/.*'I%IBG/,%#'#%&>2'L%&'H"^$.%P'/'&"I&"2"#*/,1"'2/>IG"'D$*C'/'C$<C"&'I/&,.$I/,%#'&/*"'$2'#"")")'D$*C'/)"aB/*"'2/>IG"'2$;"'$#'*C"')$`"&"#*'*/&<"*")'<&%BI2'L%&'<"#)"&'/#)'/<"=''
' ' ' ' 'JC"'!I/#$2C'1"&2$%#'%L'/5(/'2C%D")'<%%)'I2M.C%>"*&$.'I&%I"&,"2'$#'H"^$.%'/#)'./#'6"'B2")'*%'/22"22'*C"'.%#2*&B.*'mI/*C%G%<MR&"G/*")'$)"#,*M'$#*"<&/,%#'12=')$`B2$%#n'D$*C'&"G$/6$G$*MP'1/G$)$*MP'/#)'.%#*"#*'"aB$1/G"#."'$#'.%>I/&$2%#'D$*C'*C"'%&$<$#/G'A[NA'aB"2,%##/$&"='JC$2'-#)$#<'2BII%&*2'*C"'.&%22R.BG*B&/G'<"#"&/G$;/6$G$*M'%L'*C"'B#)"&GM$#<'.%#."I*'/#)'.%#-&>2'*C"'$>I%&*/#."'%L'.BG*B&"R2I".$-.'*"2*'/)/I,%#'$#'/))$,%#'*%'G$*"&/G'*&/#2G/,%#'%L'*C"'aB"2,%##/$&"='U"1"&*C"G"22P'2%>"'$*">2'2C%BG)'6"'$>I&%1")='JC"&"L%&"P'*C"'*"2*'1"&2$%#'%L'm/5(/'!I/#$2C'q'H"^$.%n'2C%BG)'6"'LB&*C"&'/)/I*")'/#)'2C%BG)'6"'*"2*")'$#'/'>%&"'C"*"&%<"#"%B2'I%IBG/,%#=''
]/22$#'"*'/G='EC$G)'A)%G"2.'+2M.C$/*&M'H"#*'b"/G*C'789:j'Wk7Q='
Discussion – flow of information
i/.O<&%B#)'M&(2:/);&($
+1&':"5$
c"G"1/#."'+1"A;&/)$)0/4;")$
X;5;03<&()$
[>IG$./,%#2' =59:;23<&()$M&(2:/);&($
Y/0/1"$4;1"2<&()$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' Linking your ideas
O"("13:$'32Z>1&/(4$
B'I"2<A")$
E"0,&4&:&>6$
%")/:0)$3(4$P>/1")$
8/55316$&?$P(4;(>)$
=59:;23<&()$?&1$0,"$P":4$
%":"A3(2"$&?$P(4;(>)$
[(&L:"4>"$>39)$
A-$50#!$@(&058#-7#!+,+!&:#5+!#-!+,!&-B#+C(50&@-!
M/11"(0$)030"$&?$0,"$P":4$=(01&4/2<&($
E"0,&4)$
%")/:0)$
-;)2/));&($
A62*&/.*2' Important points
Y;1)0$;591"));&($&?$6&/1$939"1$
=59&103(2"$&?$6&/1$1")/:0)$
\3:;4;06$&?$6&/1$2&(2:/);&()$
%":"A3(2"$&?$$6&/1$3;5)$
!/4>"$6&/1$L1;<(>$)06:"$
+1&'3':6$&(:6$9310$0,30$L;::$'"$1"34$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' Sections of an abstract
.;5)$
@32Z>1&/(4$
E"0,&4)$
%")/:0)$
M&(2:/);&($
V,6$0,"$)0/46$L3)$4&("$SF]^T$
_&/1$,69&0,");)$SC]^T$
H"2,(;R/")$SC]^T$
E&)0$;59&103(0$P(4;(>)$SJ]^T$
M&(2:/);&(`;59:;23<&()$SF]^T$
"'-0&+#!+,885.)!'E!)',.!.#+#5.0F!
A62*&/.*2' Unstructured abstract
5B&' B#)"&2*/#)$#<' %L' *C"'>".C/#$2>2' 6M'DC$.C' )B.*2' /#)' G%6BG"2' )"1"G%I' $2' )"&$1")' L&%>'>%)"G' %&</#$2>2' /#)' *C&""R)$>"#2$%#/G' Y:NZ' ."GG' .BG*B&"' >%)"G2' DC"&"$#' >/>>/G$/#'"I$*C"G$/G' ."GG2' B#)"&<%'>%&IC%<"#"2$2' *%' L%&>'>BG,."GGBG/&' 2IC"&"2'D$*C' /' C%GG%D' ."#*&/G'GB>"#=' b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q78'r>?C'/#)'*C"'2*&B.*B&"2'&%*/*")':S8s'"1"&M'4'C')B&$#<'*C"'"/&GM'IC/2"'%L'>%&IC%<"#"2$2='c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aB"'>".C/#%ICM2$./G'I&%."22'%62"&1")')B&$#<'#%&>/G':N'>%&IC%<"#"2$2'*C/*'&"<BG/*"2'G/>$#$#'>/*&$^'/22">6GM'/#)'$2'G%2*'$#'./#."&R)"&$1")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2='
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
A62*&/.*2' Unstructured abstract
M&(2:/);&($JCB2P'.%%&)$#/*")'&%*/,%#/G'>%1">"#*' $2'/'B#$aB"'>".C/#%ICM2$./G'I&%."22'%62"&1")')B&$#<'#%&>/G':N'>%&IC%<"#"2$2'*C/*'&"<BG/*"2'G/>$#$#'>/*&$^'/22">6GM'/#)'$2'G%2*'$#'./#."&R)"&$1")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2='
%")/:0)$
V"' &"I%&*' *C/*' $#' /))$,%#' *%' /.,1"GM' >/$#*/$#$#<' /I$.%6/2/G' I%G/&$*MP' *C"' 2*&B.*B&"2' B#)"&D"#*'&%*/,%#/G'>%,%#2'/*'&/*"2'%L'9Qq78'r>?C'/#)'*C"'2*&B.*B&"2'&%*/*")':S8s'"1"&M'4'C')B&$#<'*C"'"/&GM'IC/2"'%L'>%&IC%<"#"2$2='c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
E"0,&4)$V"'I"&L%&>")'>BG,)$>"#2$%#/G' G$1"R."GG' $>/<$#<'/#/GM2$2'*%'*&/.O'*C"'>%&IC%<"#",.'I&%."22'2*/&,#<'L&%>' /' 2$#<G"' ."GG' *%' *C"' )"1"G%I>"#*' %L' /' >BG,."GGBG/&P' 2IC"&$./G' 2*&B.*B&"' .%>I%2")' %L' I%G/&$;")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2'2B&&%B#)$#<'/'C%GG%D'GB>"#=''
@32Z>1&/(4$5B&' B#)"&2*/#)$#<' %L' *C"' >".C/#$2>2' 6M' DC$.C' )B.*2' /#)' G%6BG"2' )"1"G%I' $2' )"&$1")' L&%>' >%)"G'%&</#$2>2'/#)'*C&""R)$>"#2$%#/G'Y:NZ'."GG'.BG*B&"'>%)"G2'DC"&"$#'>/>>/G$/#'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2'B#)"&<%'>%&IC%<"#"2$2' *%' L%&>' >BG,."GGBG/&' 2IC"&"2' D$*C' /' C%GG%D' ."#*&/G' GB>"#=' b%D"1"&P' *C"'>".C/#%ICM2$./G'I&%I"&,"2'/22%.$/*")'D$*C'"I$*C"G$/G'>%&IC%<"#"2$2'/&"'I%%&GM'B#)"&2*%%)=''
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
K)21;'3$)/$1")"a3$$"($)"22;&(")$
A62*&/.*2' Writing your abstract
V"' &"I%&*' *C/*' $#' /))$,%#' *%' /.,1"GM' >/$#*/$#$#<' /I$.%6/2/G' I%G/&$*MP' *C"' 2*&B.*B&"2'B#)"&D"#*'&%*/,%#/G'>%,%#2'/*'&/*"2'%L'9Qq78'r>?C'/#)'*C"'2*&B.*B&"2'&%*/*")':S8s'"1"&M'4'C')B&$#<'*C"'"/&GM'IC/2"'%L'>%&IC%<"#"2$2='c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
V1;0"$0,"$1")/:0)$)"2<&($P1)0$
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
G'+!.#+,$75:'+!+'-!$'+!:#+0,%.&8&#-7'+!8H+!&86'.75-7#+!
A62*&/.*2' Writing your abstract
5B&'B#)"&2*/#)$#<'%L' *C"'>".C/#$2>2'6M'DC$.C')B.*2' /#)' G%6BG"2' )"1"G%I' $2' )"&$1")'L&%>' >%)"G' %&</#$2>2' /#)' *C&""R)$>"#2$%#/G' Y:NZ' ."GG' .BG*B&"' >%)"G2' DC"&"$#'>/>>/G$/#'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2'B#)"&<%'>%&IC%<"#"2$2'*%'L%&>'>BG,."GGBG/&'2IC"&"2'D$*C'/'C%GG%D' ."#*&/G' GB>"#=' b%D"1"&P' *C"' >".C/#%ICM2$./G' I&%I"&,"2' /22%.$/*")' D$*C'"I$*C"G$/G'>%&IC%<"#"2$2'/&"'I%%&GM'B#)"&2*%%)=''
V1;0"$0,"$'32Z>1&/(4$)"2<&($)"2&(4$
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
G'+!5-7#0#:#-7#+!#>6$&05-!6'.!I,9!+,!#+7,:&'!:#%#!F50#.+#'
+1&':"5$
A62*&/.*2' Writing your abstract
V"'I"&L%&>")'>BG,)$>"#2$%#/G' G$1"R."GG' $>/<$#<' /#/GM2$2' *%' *&/.O' *C"'>%&IC%<"#",.'I&%."22' 2*/&,#<' L&%>' /' 2$#<G"' ."GG' *%' *C"' )"1"G%I>"#*' %L' /' >BG,."GGBG/&P' 2IC"&$./G'2*&B.*B&"'.%>I%2")'%L'I%G/&$;")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2'2B&&%B#)$#<'/'C%GG%D'GB>"#=''
V1;0"$0,"$5"0,&4)$)"2<&($0,;14$
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
G'+!897':'+!+'-!$5+!790-&05+!(#-#.5$#+!
A62*&/.*2' Writing your abstract
JCB2P' .%%&)$#/*")' &%*/,%#/G' >%1">"#*' $2' /' B#$aB"' >".C/#%ICM2$./G' I&%."22'%62"&1")')B&$#<'#%&>/G':N'>%&IC%<"#"2$2' *C/*' &"<BG/*"2' G/>$#$#'>/*&$^' /22">6GM'/#)'$2'G%2*'$#'./#."&R)"&$1")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2='
V1;0"$0,"$2&(2:/);&($)"2<&($:3)0$
Q&L"A"1*$ 0,"$ 5"2,3(&9,6);23:$ 91&9"1<")$ 3))&2;30"4$ L;0,$"9;0,":;3:$5&19,&>"(");)$31"$9&&1:6$/(4"1)0&&4D$
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
G5!0'-0$,+&@-!:#%#!5%'.:5.!#$!6.'%$#85!
M&(2:/);&($
=59:;23<&()$
A62*&/.*2' Writing your abstract
JCB2P' .%%&)$#/*")' &%*/,%#/G' >%1">"#*' $2' /' B#$aB"' >".C/#%ICM2$./G' I&%."22' %62"&1")' )B&$#<'#%&>/G' :N' >%&IC%<"#"2$2' *C/*' &"<BG/*"2' G/>$#$#' >/*&$^' /22">6GM' /#)' $2' G%2*' $#' ./#."&R)"&$1")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2='
V"' &"I%&*' *C/*' $#' /))$,%#' *%' /.,1"GM' >/$#*/$#$#<' /I$.%6/2/G' I%G/&$*MP' *C"' 2*&B.*B&"2' B#)"&D"#*'&%*/,%#/G'>%,%#2'/*'&/*"2'%L'9Qq78'r>?C'/#)'*C"'2*&B.*B&"2'&%*/*")':S8s'"1"&M'4'C')B&$#<'*C"'"/&GM'IC/2"'%L'>%&IC%<"#"2$2='c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
V"' I"&L%&>")' >BG,)$>"#2$%#/G' G$1"R."GG' $>/<$#<' /#/GM2$2' *%' *&/.O' *C"' >%&IC%<"#",.' I&%."22'2*/&,#<' L&%>' /' 2$#<G"' ."GG' *%' *C"' )"1"G%I>"#*' %L' /'>BG,."GGBG/&P' 2IC"&$./G' 2*&B.*B&"' .%>I%2")' %L'I%G/&$;")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2'2B&&%B#)$#<'/'C%GG%D'GB>"#=''
5B&'B#)"&2*/#)$#<'%L' *C"'>".C/#$2>2'6M'DC$.C')B.*2' /#)' G%6BG"2')"1"G%I' $2')"&$1")' L&%>'>%)"G'%&</#$2>2' /#)' *C&""R)$>"#2$%#/G' Y:NZ' ."GG' .BG*B&"' >%)"G2' DC"&"$#' >/>>/G$/#' "I$*C"G$/G' ."GG2'B#)"&<%'>%&IC%<"#"2$2' *%' L%&>'>BG,."GGBG/&' 2IC"&"2'D$*C' /' C%GG%D' ."#*&/G' GB>"#=' b%D"1"&P' *C"'>".C/#%ICM2$./G'I&%I"&,"2'/22%.$/*")'D$*C'"I$*C"G$/G'>%&IC%<"#"2$2'/&"'I%%&GM'B#)"&2*%%)=''
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
A62*&/.*2' Writing your abstract
5B&'B#)"&2*/#)$#<'%L' *C"'>".C/#$2>2'6M'DC$.C')B.*2' /#)' G%6BG"2')"1"G%I' $2')"&$1")' L&%>'>%)"G'%&</#$2>2' /#)' *C&""R)$>"#2$%#/G' Y:NZ' ."GG' .BG*B&"' >%)"G2' DC"&"$#' >/>>/G$/#' "I$*C"G$/G' ."GG2'B#)"&<%'>%&IC%<"#"2$2' *%' L%&>'>BG,."GGBG/&' 2IC"&"2'D$*C' /' C%GG%D' ."#*&/G' GB>"#=' b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q78' r>?C' /#)' *C"'2*&B.*B&"2'&%*/*")':S8s'"1"&M'4'C')B&$#<'*C"'"/&GM'IC/2"'%L'>%&IC%<"#"2$2='c%*/,%#/G'>%,%#'D/2'$#)"I"#)"#*'%L'*C"'."GG'.M.G"P'6B*'D/2'6G%.O")'6M'G%22'%L'*C"'"I$*C"G$/G'I%G/&$*M'I&%*"$#2'!.&$66G"'%&'+/&):P' %&' 6M' $#C$6$,%#' %L' )M#"$#R6/2")'>$.&%*B6BG"'>%*%&2=' [#*"&"2,#<GMP' #%#"' %L' *C"' 2*&B.*B&"2')"&$1")'L&%>'CB>/#'./#."&'B#)"&D"#*'&%*/,%#/G'>%,%#='V"'L%B#)'/')$&".*'&"G/,%#2C$I'6"*D""#'&%*/,%#/G' >%,%#' /#)' /22">6GM' %L' "#)%<"#%B2' 6/2">"#*' >">6&/#"' >/*&$^' /&%B#)' *C"' :N'2*&B.*B&"2P' /#)' *C/*' 2*&B.*B&"2' *C/*' L/$G")' *%' &%*/*"'D"&"' )"L".,1"' $#'D"/1$#<' "^%<"#%B2' G/>$#$#'>/*&$^=' N$22%GB,%#' %L' 6/2">"#*' >">6&/#"' /&%B#)' >/*B&"P' #%#&%*/,#<' /.$#$' &"2*%&")' &%*/,%#/G'>%1">"#*'/#)'*C"'/6$G$*M'*%'/22">6G"'"^%<"#%B2'G/>$#$#='JCB2P'.%%&)$#/*")'&%*/,%#/G'>%1">"#*'$2'/'B#$aB"'>".C/#%ICM2$./G'I&%."22'%62"&1")')B&$#<'#%&>/G':N'>%&IC%<"#"2$2'*C/*'&"<BG/*"2'G/>$#$#'>/*&$^'/22">6GM'/#)'$2'G%2*'$#'./#."&R)"&$1")'"I$*C"G$/G'."GG2='M&(2:/);&()$
%")/:0)$
E"0,&4)$
@32Z>1&/(4$
V/#<'"*'/G='+UA!='789:j'998k'9S: 9So='
A62*&/.*2'
=59&103(0$9&;(0)$
8/5531;W"$Z"6$P(4;(>$M&(03;()$Z"6L&14)$X"))$0,3($F]$L&14)$
.A&;4$
U/")<&()$.''1"A;3<&()$
bc"Ld$&1$b(&A":d$
Effective titles
A$!J7,$'!:#%#!+#.!0'-0&+'!)!.#+,8&.!+,!F5$$5K('+!0$5B#!
EB2*%>"&'!"&1$."'J/&<"*'*C"'@%B&#/G'
ECG%&%ICMGG'$2'I&"2"#*'$#'>/#M'IG/#*'%&</#2P'$#.GB)$#<'$>>/*B&"'L&B$*'DC"&"'$*'$2'B2B/GGM')"<&/)")')B&$#<'&$I"#$#<='H/*B&"'<&""#'O$D$L&B$*' Y/#6&%7%,' 7.$%#%38,Z' /&"' /#' "^."I,%#P' D$*C' C$<C'.%#."#*&/,%#2' %L' .CG%&%ICMGG' &">/$#$#<' $#' *C"' L&B$*' t"2C=' [#'<%G)Rt"2C")' O$D$L&B$*' Y/9' #:%&.&8%8ZP' .CG%&%ICMGG' $2' )"<&/)")' *%'.%G%B&G"22' ./*/6%G$*"2' BI%#' L&B$*' &$I"#$#<P' G"/1$#<' M"GG%D'./&%*"#%$)2'1$2$6G"='V"'C/1"' $)"#,-")'./#)$)/*"'<"#"2' L%&' *C"'.%#*&%G'%L'.CG%&%ICMGG')"<&/)/,%#l'
+$GO$#<*%#'"*'/G='+G/#*/='7897j'7:Sk'9S9Qu9S7o='
H,"$2&(01&:$&?$2,:&1&9,6::$:"A":)$;($530/1;(>$Z;L;?1/;0$@1&34$;(0"1")0$
@1&34$;(0"1")0$
Broad focused journal
?$5-75!
EB2*%>"&'!"&1$."'J/&<"*'*C"'@%B&#/G'
J&/)$,%#/G'D"")'>/#/<">"#*P'2B.C'/2',GG/<"'/#)'$&&$</,%#P'C/2'G")'*%' /#' "#C/#.")' >/$#*"#/#."' %L' D"*G/#)' IG/#*' 2I".$"2' $#' L/GG%D'I/))M'-"G)2='c"."#*'C"&6$.$)"'B2/<"'/#)'$>I&%1">"#*2' $#' $&&$</,%#'/#)' )&/$#/<"' 2M2*">2' C%D"1"&' C/1"' ./B2")' C/6$*/*' G%22' %L' *C"2"'2I".$"2P'"2I".$/GGM'$#'-"G)2'%#'%I"#'G%DG/#)2l'
K#"20)$&?$<::3>"$3(4$;11;>3<&($&($0,"$&22/11"(2"$3(4$")03':;),5"(0$&?$(3<A"$L"0:3(4$9:3(0$)9"2;")$;($?3::&L$93446$P":4)$
Narrow focused journal
?5::)!5-:!L57#.!M#B#$'68#-7!
J/O/#%2"'"*'/G='+/))M'V/*"&'(#1$&%#='789:j'99k'9u4='
N#)O'.:+!E.'8!7F#!D&8+!5-:!10'6#!
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' High readability
_&/1$1"34"1$),&/:4e$
f(4"1)03(4$6&/1$:&>;2$;55"4;30":6$
c&0$,3A"$0&$1"34$):&L:6$
B(:6$,3A"$0&$1"34$&(2"$
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' 1. Short sentences
Q#5:&-(!'-0#R!J^$&?$1"34"1)$23($/(4"1)03(4$3$FghL&14$)"(0"(2"$gi^$&?$1"34"1)$23($/(4"1)03(4$3$CghL&14$)"(0"(2"$
+$##"&'/#)'+$##"&'Y9ggoZ'13!!;&%#,63&'<=%$$8'
f<:;2"$)j:&$/(3$;4"3$9&1$&132;&($CikF]$93:3'13)$
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' Short sentences
ST!O'.:+!
H,"$ :31>")0$ 2&593(6*$ 3$ M&:&5';3($ 2&19&13<&($ ?&/(4"4$ ;($ClCm$&/0);4"$&?$@&>30n$'6$E;>/":$Q"1(n(4"W*$L3)$2&();4"1"4$0&$ '"$ 3$ 5&4":$ ;($ 0,"$ 4"A":&95"(0$ &?$ 5&4"1($ "59:&6""$2&(4;<&()$'6$"2&(&5;)0)D$
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' Short sentences
ST!O'.:+!
H,"$ :31>")0$ 2&593(6*$ 3$ M&:&5';3($ 2&19&13<&($ ?&/(4"4$ ;($ClCm$&/0);4"$&?$@&>30n$'6$E;>/":$Q"1(n(4"W*$L3)$2&();4"1"4$0&$ '"$ 3$ 5&4":$ ;($ 0,"$ 4"A":&95"(0$ &?$ 5&4"1($ "59:&6""$2&(4;<&()$'6$"2&(&5;)0)D$
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' Short sentences
K2&(&5;)0)$ 2&();4"1"4$ 0,"$ :31>")0$ 2&593(6$ 0&$'"$ 3$5&4":$ ;($0,"$ 4"A":&95"(0$ &?$ 5&4"1($ "59:&6""$ 2&(4;<&()D$ H,;)$2&593(6$ L3)$ 3$ M&:&5';3($ 2&19&13<&($ ?&/(4"4$ ;($ ClCm$&/0);4"$&?$@&>30n$'6$E;>/":$Q"1(n(4"WD$
2U!O'.:+!
2V!O'.:+!W-#!&:#5!6#.!+#-7#-0#!
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' 2. Active voice
8"(0"(2")$L1;N"($;($0,"$32<A"$A&;2"$31"7$
+&86$#! :&.#07! 0$#5.! #5+)!7'!.#5:!
H,"$5"2,3(;)5)$1">/:3<(>$0/5&1$>1&L0,$L"1"$;(A")<>30"4D$
?5++&B#!
V"$;(A")<>30"4$0,"$5"2,3(;)5)$1">/:3<(>$0/5&1$>1&L0,D$D0CB#!
XC$&0#!$5!B'K!50CB5!65.5!+#.!8H+!:&.#07'+!
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' Active voice is preferred
m02"'*C"'50CB#!B'&0#!DC"#'$*'$2'G"22'D%&)M'/#)'>%&"')$&".*'*C/#'*C"'I/22$1"n='Y:&)'")=P'I<='47Z'
m02"'*C"'50CB#!B'&0#!&/*C"&'*C/#'*C"'I/22$1"'1%$."ln=''DDD=/I/2*MG"=%&<?G"/&#?L/a2?"`".,1"R1"&6RB2"=/2I^'
mA2'/'>/d"&'%L'2*MG"P'I/22$1"'1%$."'$2'*MI$./GGMP'6B*'#%*'/GD/M2P'$#L"&$%&'*%'50CB#!B'&0#n='Y9Q*C'")=P'I<='9WWZ'
m[#'<"#"&/GP'/B*C%&2'2C%BG)'B2"'*C"'50CB#!B'&0#ln='Y98*C'")=P'I<=':78Z'
D"1!17)$#!Y,&:#!
D?D!17)$#!!
"F&05('!17)$#!Y,&:#!
D4D!45-,5$!'E!17)$#!
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' 3. Stress position
G'+!$#07'.#+!+#!0#-7.5-!#-!#$!Z-5$!:#!$5!'.50&'-!65.5!&:#-CZ05.!$'!I,#!#+!&86'.75-7#!
CD _&/$4")"1A"$3$13;)"*$'/0$0,"$'/4>"0$;)$<>,0D$
V,;2,$)"(0"(2"$)/>>")0)$0,30$6&/$$O&$$$>"0$3$13;)"o$
FD H,"$'/4>"0$;)$<>,0*$'/0$6&/$4")"1A"$3$13;)"D$
CdIk??D&$,#<."#*"&=B#.=")B?C/#)%B*2?t%D?'
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' Stress position
H,"$'/4>"0$;)$<>,0*$'/0$6&/$4")"1A"$3$13;)"D$_&/1$)3:316$
L;::$;(21"3)"$30$0,"$'">;((;(>$&?$("p0$6"31D$
X3$9&);2;j($4"$0"();j($4"'"$;(01&4/2;1$$":$0"53$4"$:3$);>/;"(0"$&132;&$
CdIk??D&$,#<."#*"&=B#.=")B?C/#)%B*2?t%D?'
801"))$9&);<&($ H&9;2$9&);<&($
G5!6'+&0&@-!:#$!7#85!&:#-CZ05!:#!I,9!7.575!$5!'.50&@-!
(`".,1"'V&$,#<' 4. Topic position
*F#! 65C#-7! L"(0$ 0&$ 0,"$ ,&)9;03:$ 0&$ )""$ 3$(5+7.'#-7#.'$'(&+7D$*F#! :'07'.! 0,"($ 9"1?&15"4$ 3$ )"1;")$&?$ :&5(-'+C0! 7#+7+D$ *F#! .#+,$7+! ),&L"4$ 0,"$ 93<"(0$)/#"1"4$ ?1&5$ 3$ %507#.&5$! &-E#0C'-D! D-C%&'C0+! L"1"$91")21;'"4$ 0&$ 01"30$ 0,"$ ;(?"2<&($ '"?&1"$ 0,"$ 93<"(0$4"A":&9"4$3($,$0#.D$$
$)"/ $)"/$)"/$)"/
J%I$.'G$#O
2"#*"#."
FDi$<5")$5&1"$2&55&($;($K(>:;),$0,3($;($893(;),$
!$>I2%#'3H='3'!".%#)'K/#<'V&$*='7888j'gk'7g:q:8g='
(`".,1"'V&$,#<'
X/(>$ 23(2"1$ ;)$ 0,"$ :"34;(>$ 23/)"$ &?$ 23(2"1$ 5&103:;06$ ?&1$5"($ 3(4$ L&5"(D$ -")9;0"$ )5&Z;(>$ 91"A"(<&($ 3(4$2"))3<&($91&>135)e$ec"L$L36)$ 0&$ 01"30$&1$91"A"(0$ :/(>$23(2"1$31"$0,"1"?&1"$(""4"4D$
B("$9&0"(<3:$0,"139"/<2$031>"0$?&1$:/(>$23(2"1$;)$0,"$V(0$);>(3:;(>$930,L36D$H,"$23(&(;23:$V(0$);>(3:;(>$930,L36$;($53553:)$2&();)0)$&?$3e$
iB2.C'"*'/G='iHE'E/#."&='7897j'9:k'799='
H&9;2$)"(0"(2"$
H&9;2$)"(0"(2"$
801"))$)"(0"(2"$
f<:;2"$:3$9&);2;&($4"$$0"();j($6$0"53$$"($)/$")21;0&$4"$53("13$:j>;23$3:$91")"(031$:3$;(?&1532;j($
Manuscript structure
Thank you!
LLLD"43(W"4;<(>D2&5$
Any questions?
Y&::&L$/)$&($HL;N"1$q!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'
X;Z"$/)$&($Y32"'&&Z$?32"'&&ZD2&5`!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'
-&L(:&34$3(4$?/10,"1$1"34;(>$"43(W"4;<(>D2&5`/(;A3::"$
Thank you!
LLLD"43(W"4;<(>D2&5$
Any questions?
Y&::&L$/)$&($HL;N"1$q!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'
X;Z"$/)$&($Y32"'&&Z$?32"'&&ZD2&5`!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'
-&L(:&34$3(4$?/10,"1$1"34;(>$"43(W"4;<(>D2&5`I3A"1;3(3$
!"#$%&'"()*$+,-$
!"#$%&'()$*%&'
./0,&1$.234"567$$80"9)$0&$+/':;23<&($8/22"))$==!
0#$1"&2$)/)')"G'f/GG"'
7'5.*%6"&'789:'
")/#;")$,#<=.%>?B#$1/GG"'
!"#$%&'"()*$+,-$
!"#$%&'()$*%&'
./0,&1$.234"567$$80"9)$0&$+/':;23<&($8/22"))$==!
+%#,-.$/'0#$1"&2$)/)'3/1"&$/#/'
4'5.*%6"&'789:'
")/#;")$,#<=.%>?@/1"&$/#/'
CD E3(/)21;90$)01/20/1"$
FD .')01320)$3(4$<0:")$GD H31>"<(>$0,"$I&/1(3:$JD K#"2<A"$L1;<(>'
Today’s Presentation
CD !&/1(3:$)":"2<&($FD M&A"1$:"N"1)$GD +""1$1"A;"L$
1#++&'-!2! 1#++&'-!3!
Edanz survey results – Primary difficulty during manuscript preparation
&'v':::'IB6G$2C")'#%#R#/,1"'(#<G$2C'/B*C%&2'
EC%%2$#<'/'@%B&#/G'
(^I&"22$#<'*C%B<C*2'.G"/&GM'$#'(#<G$2C'
0#)"&2*/#)$#<'*C"'/B*C%&'<B$)"G$#"2'
X%&>/w#<'/..%&)$#<'*%'*C"'<B$)"G$#"2'
CCr$
gl$
gG$
mG$
GiDJ^$
FGDg^$
FCDl^$
CrDl^$
X&)$3/0&1")$<"("($4;P2/:034")$9313$":">;1$:3)$1"A;)03)$6$2&591"(4"1$:3)$4;1"201;2")$4"$:3)$$1"A;)03)$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Tenga en cuenta los diferentes factores de cada revista
.;5)$s$)2&9"$ %"34"1),;9$
B9"($322"))$ =(4"p;(>$
LF&0F!E507'.!&+!8'+7!&86'.75-7!7'!)',\!
+/':;23<&($?1"R/"(26$
=59320$?320&1$
]5.&#+!%)!Z#$:!
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Choosing a target journal
^'-#+758#-7#!#B5$,#!$5!&86'.75-0&5!!:#!+,!&-B#+C(50&@-!
8;>(;P23(2"$ .;5)$3(4$82&9"$=59320$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#'
c"L$P(4;(>)$
Evaluating significance: Novelty
E"4;/5$0&$,;>,$;59320$
X&L$0&$5"4;/5$;59320$
=(21"5"(03:$34A3(2")$
M&(2"90/3:$34A3(2")$
_`,#!75-!-,#B'+!+'-!7,+!.#+,$75:'+\!
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Evaluating significance: Relevance
_`,9!75-!.#$#B5-7#+!+'-!+,+!.#+,$75:'+!!#-!+,!0586'!,!'7.'+!0586'+\!
+&9/:3<&($)9"2;P2o$%")01;20"4$0&$>"&>139,;23:$:&23<&(o$Q&L$2&55&($;)$0,"$4;)"3)"o$
E"4;23:$
%":"A3(0$0&$'/);("))$&1$531Z"<(>o$Q3A"$;59320$&($>&A"1(5"(0$9&:;26o$
+)62,&:&>6$
Q&L$'1&34:6$399:;23':"$;)$0,"$4");>(o$$=)$;0$2&)0h"#"2<A"o$
K(>;(""1;(>$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Evaluating significance: Importance
.1"3$&?$9&9/:31$399"3:
80"5$2"::)*$<))/"$"(>;(""1;(>*$>:&'3:$L315;(>*$31<P2;3:$;(0"::;>"(2"
=59&103(0$1"3:hL&1:4$399:;23<&()
%;2"$1");)03(0$0&$,;>,$)3:0$2&(4;<&()*$),1;59$1");)03(0$0&$;(?"2<&(
_`,9!75-!&86'.75-7#+!+'-!$5+!56$&050&'-#+!!!#-!#$!8,-:'!.#5$\!
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Journal Selector
=()"10$6&/1$91&9&)"4$3')01320$
A$![',.-5$!1#$#07'.!5),:5!5!#$#(&.!!$5!6,%$&050&'-!8H+!5:#0,5:5!
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Journal Selector
%"2&55"(4"4$I&/1(3:)$
Y;:0"1$'67$=59320$?320&1$
+/':;),;(>$?1"R/"(26$B9"($322"))$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Journal Selector 8"53(<2$5302,;(>$0"15)$
!&/1(3:)$=Y*$.;5)$s$82&9"*$$3(4$Y1"R/"(26$
8;5;:31$9/':;),"4$31<2:")$
Q3A"$0,"6$9/':;),"4$);5;:31$31<2:")$.#0#-7$)o$Q3A"$6&/$0&7#:$)&5"$&?$0,")"$31<2:")o$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Tips to identify the most suitable journal
!'
=4"(<?6$0,"$;(0"1")0)$&?$0,"$<',.-5$!#:&7'.!
=4"(<?6$0,"$;(0"1")0)$&?$0,"$
.#5:#.+!
• K4;0&1;3:)$• %"A;"L$31<2:")$• 89"2;3:$;))/")$
• E&)0$A;"L"4$• E&)0$2;0"4$
a:#-CZ05!$'+!&-7#.#+#+!:#$!#:&7'.!:#!$5!.#B&+75!)!:#!$'+!$#07'.#+!#-!05:5!6,%$&050&'-!
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Author guidelines
bcUTT!O'.:+d!
a86'.75-7!6'&-7+!
.1<2:"$)01/20/1"$
V&14$:;5;0)$
%"?"1"(2")$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Author guidelines – article structure
+1"9313<&($&?$E3(/)21;90)$
@">;()$&($93>"$l$S&?$CgT$
H;0:"$93>"*$3')01320$["6L&14)$0&$$:&&Z$?&1o$
V,30$6&/$),&/:4$'"$:&&Z;(>$?&1$
• .1<2:"$069"$)9"2;P2)$• H;0:"$93>"$;(?&153<&($• .')01320*$>139,;23:$3')01320*$
Z"6L&14)*$3(4$,;>,:;>,0)$• E3;($0"p0$)"2<&()$• %"?"1"(2")$• Y;>/1")$3(4$Y;>/1"$X">"(4)$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Author guidelines – word limits
L'.:!$&8&7+!85)!566$)!7'e!
• H;0:")$• %/((;(>$<0:")$• Q;>,:;>,0)$• .')01320)$• E3;($0"p0$• Y;>/1"$:">"(4)$
3%B&#/G'2"G".,%#' Author guidelines – references
=(h0"p0$2;03<&()$\3(2&/A"1$7$x9y'%&'9'
Q31A3147$YU/>"P'M"/&Z'
%"?"1"(2"$:;)0$\3(2&/A"1$7$UB>"&$./G'
Q31A3147$AGIC/6",./G'
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2'
.')013207$Y;1)0$;591"));&($?&1$1"34"1)$
X3)$23103)$4"$91")"(032;j($)&($:3$91;5"13$;591");j($9313$":$"4;0&1$4"$/(3$1"A;)03$
8;>(;P23(2"$%":"A3(2"$
X"A":$&?$K(>:;),$=(0"1")<(>$0&$0,";1$1"34"1)o$
V,6$6&/1$L&1Z$;)$;59&103(0t$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
H/&.'K$II>/#P'HN'()$*%&R$#REC$"L'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'
:'!"I*">6"&'789:'
N"/&'N&'K$II>/#P'
+G"/2"' -#)' "#.G%2")' %B&' >/#B2.&$I*' "#,*G")' m(1/GB/,%#' %L' *C"'
\G/2<%D'I&%<#%2,.'2.%&"'$#'I/,"#*2'B#)"&<%$#<'.B&/,1"'&"2".,%#'
L%&'6&"/2*'./#."&' G$1"&'>"*/2*/2"2Pn'DC$.C'D"'D%BG)' G$O"'*%'2B6>$*'L%&'IB6G$./,%#'/2'/#'5&$<$#/G'A&,.G"'$#'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'
@4.,-!.&-=''
3%B&#/G'")$*%&z2'#/>"'
E3(/)21;90$<0:"$
+/':;23<&($069"$
a-:&I,#!#$!J7,$'!:#!+,!#+0.&7'!)!C6'!:#!6,%$&050&@-!
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
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
Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$;(A")<>32;j($4"'"1;3$4"$,32"1)"$
! ",..#-7!2*/*"'%L'*C"'-"G)'! ?.'%$#8'&"2"/&.C"&2'/&"'L/.$#<'
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
JC"' \G/2<%D' I&%<#%2,.' 2.%&"' Y\+!Z' $2' %L' 1/GB"' L%&' /' 1/&$"*M' %L'*B>%B&2=' !"1"&/G' 2*B)$"2' C/1"' $#1"2,</*")' *C"' I&%<#%2,.' 1/GB"' %L'*C"' \+!' $#' I/,"#*2' D$*C' >"*/2*/,.' 6&"/2*' ./#."&P' 6B*' L"D' 2*B)$"2'C/1"' I"&L%&>")' 2B.C' /#' $#1"2,</,%#' L%&' I/,"#*2' B#)"&<%$#<' G$1"&'&"2".,%#' L%&' G$1"&'>"*/2*/2"2=' XB&*C"&>%&"P' *C"&"' /&"' .B&&"#*GM' #%'2*B)$"2'*C/*'C/1"'"^/>$#")'*C"'I&%<#%2,.'1/GB"'%L'*C"'>%)$-")'\+!'Y>\+!Z' $#' *C"2"'I/,"#*2='JC"'I&"2"#*' 2*B)M'"1/GB/*")' *C"'>\+!' $#'*"&>2' %L' $*2' I&%<#%2,.' 1/GB"' L%&' I%2*%I"&/,1"' )"/*C' $#' I/,"#*2'B#)"&<%$#<'G$1"&'&"2".,%#'L%&'6&"/2*'./#."&'G$1"&'>"*/2*/2"2='
Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$;(A")<>32;j($4"'"1;3$4"$,32"1)"$
! ",..#-7!2*/*"'%L'*C"'-"G)'! ?.'%$#8'&"2"/&.C"&2'/&"'L/.$#<'
=(01&4/2<&($
+1&':"5$
B'I"2<A")$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
%")/53$)/)$2&(2:/);&(")$2:3A"$
! g.&#;)')"2.&$6"'M%B&'>"*C%)%G%<M'! 1,885.&K#'M%B&'O"M'-#)$#<2'
A' *%*/G' %L' :9o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
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
A' *%*/G' %L' :9o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
! g.&#;)')"2.&$6"'M%B&'>"*C%)%G%<M'! 1,885.&K#'M%B&'O"M'-#)$#<2'
E"0,&4)$
["6$1")/:0)$
%")/53$)/)$2&(2:/);&(")$2:3A"$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
JC$2'2*B)M'$2'*C"'-&2*'*%')">%#2*&/*"'*C/*'*C"'I&"%I"&/,1"'>\+!P'/'2$>IG"' .G$#$./G' *%%GP' $2' /' B2"LBG' I&%<#%2,.' L/.*%&' L%&' I%2*%I"&/,1"'2B&1$1/G' $#'6&"/2*'./#."&'I/,"#*2'B#)"&<%$#<'.B&/,1"'&"2".,%#'L%&'G$1"&' >"*/2*/2"2=' JC$2' $#L%&>/,%#' $2' $>>")$/*"GM' .G$#$./GGM'/IIG$./6G"' L%&' 2B&<"%#2' /#)' >")$./G' %#.%G%<$2*2' *&"/,#<' 2B.C'I/,"#*2='A2'/'I&">$"&'@%B&#/G'.%1"&$#<'6&"/2*'./#."&'*&"/*>"#*P'D"'6"G$"1"' *C/*'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:' ,&7' @4.,-!.&-' $2' *C"' I"&L".*'IG/{%&>'L&%>'DC$.C'*%'2C/&"'%B&'&"2BG*2'D$*C'/GG' *C%2"'.%#."&#")'D$*C'6&"/2*'./#."&='
Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$")21;0&$)"1v3$;(0"1")3(0"$9313$:&)$:"20&1")$4"$/(3$1"A;)03$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
JC$2'2*B)M'$2'*C"'-&2*'*%')">%#2*&/*"'*C/*'*C"'I&"%I"&/,1"'>\+!P'/'2$>IG"' .G$#$./G' *%%GP' $2' /' B2"LBG' I&%<#%2,.' L/.*%&' L%&' I%2*%I"&/,1"'2B&1$1/G' $#'6&"/2*'./#."&'I/,"#*2'B#)"&<%$#<'.B&/,1"'&"2".,%#'L%&'G$1"&' >"*/2*/2"2=' JC$2' $#L%&>/,%#' $2' $>>")$/*"GM' .G$#$./GGM'/IIG$./6G"' L%&' 2B&<"%#2' /#)' >")$./G' %#.%G%<$2*2' *&"/,#<' 2B.C'I/,"#*2='A2'/'I&">$"&'@%B&#/G'.%1"&$#<'6&"/2*'./#."&'*&"/*>"#*P'D"'6"G$"1"' *C/*'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:' ,&7' @4.,-!.&-' $2' *C"' I"&L".*'IG/{%&>'L&%>'DC$.C'*%'2C/&"'%B&'&"2BG*2'D$*C'/GG' *C%2"'.%#."&#")'D$*C'6&"/2*'./#."&='
Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$")21;0&$)"1v3$;(0"1")3(0"$9313$:&)$:"20&1")$4"$/(3$1"A;)03$
M&(2:/);&($
%":"A3(2"$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
JC$2'2*B)M'$2'*C"'-&2*'*%')">%#2*&/*"'*C/*'*C"'I&"%I"&/,1"'>\+!P'/'2$>IG"' .G$#$./G' *%%GP' $2' /' B2"LBG' I&%<#%2,.' L/.*%&' L%&' I%2*%I"&/,1"'2B&1$1/G' $#'6&"/2*'./#."&'I/,"#*2'B#)"&<%$#<'.B&/,1"'&"2".,%#'L%&'G$1"&' >"*/2*/2"2=' JC$2' $#L%&>/,%#' $2' $>>")$/*"GM' .G$#$./GGM'/IIG$./6G"' L%&' 2B&<"%#2' /#)' >")$./G' %#.%G%<$2*2' *&"/,#<' 2B.C'I/,"#*2='A2'/'I&">$"&'@%B&#/G'.%1"&$#<'6&"/2*'./#."&'*&"/*>"#*P'D"'6"G$"1"' *C/*'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:' ,&7' @4.,-!.&-' $2' *C"' I"&L".*'IG/{%&>'L&%>'DC$.C'*%'2C/&"'%B&'&"2BG*2'D$*C'/GG' *C%2"'.%#."&#")'D$*C'6&"/2*'./#."&='
f)"$93:3'13)$2:3A"$3$931<1$4"$:&)$&'I"<A&)$6$$":$3:23(2"$"($)/$23103$4"$91")"(032;j($
N#)O'.:+!E.'8!7F#!D&8+!5-:!10'6#!
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
V"'.%#-&>'*C/*'*C$2'>/#B2.&$I*'C/2'#%*'6""#'IB6G$2C")'"G2"DC"&"'/#)'$2'#%*'B#)"&'.%#2$)"&/,%#'6M'/#%*C"&'@%B&#/G='AGG'/B*C%&2'C/1"'/II&%1")' *C"' >/#B2.&$I*P' $#.GB)$#<' /B*C%&2C$I' /#)' %&)"&' %L'/B*C%&2C$IP' /#)' /<&""'D$*C' 2B6>$22$%#' *%'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:',&7' @4.,-!.&-=' JC$2' 2*B)M'D/2' LB#)")' 6M' *C"'H$#$2*&M' %L' b"/G*CP'K/6%B&' /#)'V"GL/&"=' JC"' /B*C%&2' C/1"' #%' .%#t$.*2' %L' $#*"&"2*' *%')".G/&"='
Kp9&(>3$1")9&()3';:;434$:">3:$)&'1"$u<23$4"$:3$;(A")<>32;j($6$:3$9/':;232;j($
! -;)2:3;5"1)$1":30"4$0&$6,%$&05C'-!#7F&0+!! 8&/12")$&?$h,-:&-(!! "'-;&07+!'E!&-7#.#+7!
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
V"'.%#-&>'*C/*'*C$2'>/#B2.&$I*'C/2'#%*'6""#'IB6G$2C")'"G2"DC"&"'/#)'$2'#%*'B#)"&'.%#2$)"&/,%#'6M'/#%*C"&'@%B&#/G='AGG'/B*C%&2'C/1"'/II&%1")' *C"' >/#B2.&$I*P' $#.GB)$#<' /B*C%&2C$I' /#)' %&)"&' %L'/B*C%&2C$IP' /#)' /<&""'D$*C' 2B6>$22$%#' *%'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:',&7' @4.,-!.&-=' JC$2' 2*B)M'D/2' LB#)")' 6M' *C"'H$#$2*&M' %L' b"/G*CP'K/6%B&' /#)'V"GL/&"=' JC"' /B*C%&2' C/1"' #%' .%#t$.*2' %L' $#*"&"2*' *%')".G/&"='
Kp9&(>3$1")9&()3';:;434$:">3:$)&'1"$u<23$4"$:3$;(A")<>32;j($6$:3$9/':;232;j($
! -;)2:3;5"1)$1":30"4$0&$6,%$&05C'-!#7F&0+!! 8&/12")$&?$h,-:&-(!! "'-;&07+!'E!&-7#.#+7!
Y/(4;(>$
K0,;2)$
M&(w;20)$&?$;(0"1")0$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
V"'D%BG)'G$O"'*%'&".%>>"#)'*C"'L%GG%D$#<'&"1$"D"&2'*%'"1/GB/*"'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*k''
9= c"1$"D"&'9'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'7= c"1$"D"&'7'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#':= c"1$"D"&':'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'4= c"1$"D"&'4'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'
+G"/2"'/))&"22'/GG'.%&&"2I%#)"#."'*%k'
! c".%>>"#)")'&"1$"D"&2'! AB*C%&z2'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'
B0,"1$;59&103(0$;(?&153<&(7$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Building your cover letter
V"'D%BG)'G$O"'*%'&".%>>"#)'*C"'L%GG%D$#<'&"1$"D"&2'*%'"1/GB/*"'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*k''
9= c"1$"D"&'9'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'7= c"1$"D"&'7'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#':= c"1$"D"&':'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'4= c"1$"D"&'4'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'
+G"/2"'/))&"22'/GG'.%&&"2I%#)"#."'*%k'
%"2&5;"(4"$1"A;)&1")$9313$)/$53(/)01;0&$
B0,"1$;59&103(0$;(?&153<&(7$
! c".%>>"#)")'&"1$"D"&2'! AB*C%&z2'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'H/#B2.&$I*'2*&B.*B&"' A good cover letter
H/&.'K$II>/#P'HN'()$*%&R$#REC$"L'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'
:'!"I*">6"&'789:'
N"/&'N&'K$II>/#P'
+G"/2"' -#)' "#.G%2")' %B&'>/#B2.&$I*' "#,*G")' m(1/GB/,%#' %L' *C"' \G/2<%D' I&%<#%2,.' 2.%&"' $#' I/,"#*2' B#)"&<%$#<' .B&/,1"' &"2".,%#' L%&' 6&"/2*' ./#."&' G$1"&'>"*/2*/2"2Pn' DC$.C'D"'D%BG)' G$O"' *%' 2B6>$*' L%&'IB6G$./,%#'/2'/#'5&$<$#/G'A&,.G"'$#'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-='=''
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
A'*%*/G'%L':9o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
JC$2'2*B)M'$2'*C"'-&2*'*%')">%#2*&/*"'*C/*'*C"'I&"%I"&/,1"'>\+!P'/'2$>IG"'.G$#$./G'*%%GP' $2'/'B2"LBG'I&%<#%2,.'L/.*%&'L%&'I%2*%I"&/,1"'2B&1$1/G' $#'6&"/2*'./#."&'I/,"#*2'B#)"&<%$#<'.B&/,1"'&"2".,%#'L%&' G$1"&'>"*/2*/2"2='JC$2'$#L%&>/,%#'$2'$>>")$/*"GM'.G$#$./GGM'/IIG$./6G"'L%&'2B&<"%#2'/#)'>")$./G'%#.%G%<$2*2'*&"/,#<'2B.C'I/,"#*2='A2'/'I&">$"&'@%B&#/G'.%1"&$#<'6&"/2*'./#."&'*&"/*>"#*P'D"'6"G$"1"'*C/*'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'$2'*C"'I"&L".*'IG/{%&>'L&%>'DC$.C'*%'2C/&"'%B&'&"2BG*2'D$*C'/GG'*C%2"'.%#."&#")'D$*C'6&"/2*'./#."&='
V"'.%#-&>'*C/*'*C$2'>/#B2.&$I*'C/2'#%*'6""#'IB6G$2C")'"G2"DC"&"'/#)'$2'#%*'B#)"&'.%#2$)"&/,%#'6M'/#%*C"&'@%B&#/G='AGG'/B*C%&2'C/1"'/II&%1")'*C"'>/#B2.&$I*P'$#.GB)$#<'/B*C%&2C$I'/#)'%&)"&'%L'/B*C%&2C$IP'/#)'/<&""'D$*C'2B6>$22$%#'*%'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-='JC$2'2*B)M'D/2'LB#)")'6M'*C"'H$#$2*&M'%L'b"/G*CP'K/6%B&'/#)'V"GL/&"='JC"'/B*C%&2'C/1"'#%'.%#t$.*2'%L'$#*"&"2*'*%')".G/&"='
V"'D%BG)'G$O"'*%'&".%>>"#)'*C"'L%GG%D$#<'&"1$"D"&2'*%'"1/GB/*"'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*k''
c"1$"D"&'9'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'c"1$"D"&'7'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'c"1$"D"&':'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'c"1$"D"&'4'/#)'.%#*/.*'$#L%&>/,%#'
+G"/2"'/))&"22'/GG'.%&&"2I%#)"#."'*%k'
V"'G%%O'L%&D/&)'*%'C"/&$#<'L&%>'M%B'/*'M%B&'"/&G$"2*'.%#1"#$"#."='
|%B&2'2$#."&"GMP'
E3(/)21;90$;(?&153<&($
@32Z>1&/(4$
["6$P(4;(>)$
%":"A3(2"$
-;)2:3;5"1)$
%"2&55"(4"4$1"A;"L"1)$
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Recommending
reviewers
mVC"#' 2B6>$w#<' M%B&' I/I"&P' M%B' >B2*' I&%1$)"' *C"'#/>"2P' /FG$/,%#2P' /#)' 1/G$)' "R>/$G' /))&"22"2' %L' -1"' YQZ'&"1$"D"&2=' [L' M%B' )%' #%*' )%' 2%P' M%B&' I/I"&' D$GG' 6"'&"*B&#")P'B#&"1$"D")=n'
mAB*C%&2' /&"' &"aB"2*")' *%' I&%1$)"' *C"' #/>"2' /#)' LBGG'/))&"22"2'Y$#.GB)$#<'"R>/$G'/))&"22Z'%L'BI'*%'L%B&'I%*"#,/G'&"L"&""2ln'
]#.&ZI,#!$5+!:&.#07.&0#+!:#!$5!.#B&+75!65.5!:#7#.8&-5.!0,H-7'+!.#B&+'.#+!+#!.#0'8&#-:5-!
E%1"&/<"'/#)'!*/F#<'+G/#'E%1"&'G"d"&2' Recommending
reviewers
V,"1"$0&$P(4$0,"5o$
Y1&5$6&/1$1"34;(>`1"?"1"(2")*$("0L&1Z;(>$30$2&(?"1"(2")$
Q&L$)"(;&1o$ .;5$?&1$5;4h:"A":$1")"312,"1)$
V,&$0&$3A&;4o$M&::3'&130&1)$S93)0$i$6"31)T*$
1")"312,"1)$?1&5$)35"$;()<0/<&($
a-7#.-5C'-5$!$&+7e$$C$&1$F$?1&5$.);3*$C$&1$F$?1&5$K/1&9"*$3(4$C$&1$F$?1&5$0,"$.5"1;23)$
Q#0'8&#-:#!&-B#+C(5:'.#+!:#!-&B#$!!8#:&'!:#!:&E#.#-7#+!65i+#+!
+""&'c"1$"D'Improves your manuscript
Y#7!&-B'$B#:!$#'*C"''
I""&'&"1$"D'I&%."22'
X3$1"A;);j($9&1$931")$")$/($91&2")&$$9&);<A&$R/"$5"I&131n$)/$53(/)2;0&$
+""&'c"1$"D' What reviewers are looking for
H,"$)2;"(2"$
H,"$53(/)21;90$
! %":"A3(0$,69&0,");)$! O&&4$"p9"1;5"(03:$4");>($! .991&91;30"$5"0,&4&:&>6$! O&&4$4303$3(3:6);)$! \3:;4$2&(2:/);&()$
! X&>;23:$w&L$&?$;(?&153<&($! E3(/)21;90$)01/20/1"$3(4$?&153x(>$! .991&91;30"$1"?"1"(2")$! Q;>,$1"343';:;06$
+""&'c"1$"D'
%")9&()"$:"N"1$
%")9&(43$2:3135"(0"$3$2343$$2&5"(031;&$4"$)/)$1"A;)&1")$
A5+)$0&$)""$2,3(>")$
%"?"1$0&$:;("$3(4$93>"$(/5'"1)$
f)"$3$4;#"1"(0$2&:&1$?&(0$
Q;>,:;>,0$0,"$0"p0$
Revision
+""&'c"1$"D'Writing a response letter
H/&.'K$II>/#P'HN'()$*%&R$#REC$"L'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'
:'!"I*">6"&'789:'
N"/&'N&'K$II>/#P'
c"k'c"2B6>$22$%#'%L'>/#B2.&$I*'&"L"&"#."'U%='V3!R8WRQW:g'
+G"/2"'-#)'/d/.C")'/'&"1$2")'1"&2$%#'%L'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*'%&$<$#/GGM'"#,*G")'m(1/GB/,%#'%L'*C"'\G/2<%D'I&%<#%2,.'2.%&"'$#'I/,"#*2'B#)"&<%$#<'.B&/,1"'&"2".,%#'L%&'6&"/2*'./#."&'G$1"&'>"*/2*/2"2Pn'DC$.C'D"'D%BG)'G$O"'*%'&"2B6>$*'L%&'.%#2$)"&/,%#'L%&'IB6G$./,%#'$#'*C"'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-9'
JC"'&"1$"D"&z2'.%>>"#*2'D"&"'C$<CGM'$#2$<C{BG'/#)'"#/6G")'B2'*%'<&"/*GM'$>I&%1"'*C"'aB/G$*M'%L'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*='[#'*C"'L%GG%D$#<'I/<"2'/&"'%B&'I%$#*R6MRI%$#*'&"2I%#2"2'*%'"/.C'%L'*C"'.%>>"#*2='
c"1$2$%#2'$#'*C"'>/#B2.&$I*'/&"'2C%D#'/2'B#)"&G$#")'*"^*='[#'/..%&)/#."'D$*C'*C"'-&2*'.%>>"#*P'*C"',*G"'C/2'6""#'&"1$2")'/#)'*C"'"#,&"'>/#B2.&$I*'C/2'B#)"&<%#"'2B62*/#,/G'(#<G$2C'")$,#<=''V"'C%I"'*C/*'*C"'&"1$2$%#2'$#'*C"'>/#B2.&$I*'/#)'%B&'/..%>I/#M$#<'&"2I%#2"2'D$GG'6"'2BF.$"#*'*%'>/O"'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*'2B$*/6G"'L%&'IB6G$./,%#'$#'*C"'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-='
.441"))$"4;0&1$9"1)&(3::6$
E3(/)21;90$=-$(/5'"1$
H,3(Z$1"A;"L"1)$
Q;>,:;>,0$53I&1$2,3(>")$
+""&'c"1$"D'Agreeing with reviewers
Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e! 5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;?&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J','8%!I$.'K,;88%,&'A;?&'B3;$7':,2.'8;L#.79'M34.32.4J'-:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3' #3!I,4.' -3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'
%")9&()"7' V"' /<&""' D$*C' *C"' &"1$"D"&z2' /22"22>"#*' %L' *C"'/#/GM2$2='5B&'*/$G%&")'LB#.,%#P'$#'$*2'.B&&"#*'L%&>P'>/O"2'$*')$F.BG*'*%' *"GG' *C/*' *C$2' >"/2B&">"#*' .%#2,*B*"2' /' 2$<#$-./#*'$>I&%1">"#*' %1"&' I&"1$%B2GM' &"I%&*")' 1/GB"2=' V"' )"2.&$6"' %B&'#"D'/#/GM2$2'B2$#<'/'\/B22$/#'-w#<'LB#.,%#'$#'%B&'&"1$2")'c"2BG*2'2".,%#'Y+/<"'SP'K$#"2'97q9oZ='
+""&'c"1$"D'
Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e! 5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;?&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J','8%!I$.'K,;88%,&'A;?&'B3;$7':,2.'8;L#.79'M34.32.4J'-:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3' #3!I,4.' -3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'
%")9&()"7' V"' /<&""' D$*C' *C"' &"1$"D"&z2' /22"22>"#*' %L' *C"'/#/GM2$2='5B&'*/$G%&")'LB#.,%#P'$#'$*2'.B&&"#*'L%&>P'>/O"2'$*')$F.BG*'*%' *"GG' *C/*' *C$2' >"/2B&">"#*' .%#2,*B*"2' /' 2$<#$-./#*'$>I&%1">"#*' %1"&' I&"1$%B2GM' &"I%&*")' 1/GB"2=' V"' )"2.&$6"' %B&'#"D'/#/GM2$2'B2$#<'/'\/B22$/#'-w#<'LB#.,%#'$#'%B&'&"1$2")'c"2BG*2'2".,%#'Y+/<"'SP'K$#"2'97q9oZ='
Agreeing with reviewers
.>1""5"(0$
%"A;);&()$X&23<&($
+""&'c"1$"D'
Disagreeing with reviewers
Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e!5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;?&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J' ,' 8%!I$.' K,;88%,&' A;?&' B3;$7' :,2.' 8;L#.79'M34.32.4J' -:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3'#3!I,4.'-3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'
%")9&()"7' AG*C%B<C' /' 2$>IG"' \/B22$/#' -*' D%BG)' L/.$G$*/*"'.%>I/&$2%#'D$*C'*C"'&"2BG*2'%L'%*C"&'2*B)$"2P'%B&'*/$G%&")'LB#.,%#'/GG%D2' L%&' *C"' /#/GM2$2' %L' *C"' )/*/' $#' *"&>2' %L' *C"' !>$*C'>%)"G'x!>$*C' "*' /G=P' 9ggoy=' V"' C/1"' #%D' "^IG/$#")' *C"' B2"' %L' *C$2'LB#.,%#' /#)' *C"' !>$*C' >%)"G' $#' %B&' &"1$2")' N$2.B22$%#' 2".,%#'Y+/<"'97P'K$#"2'7qSZ='
+""&'c"1$"D'
Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e!5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;?&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J' ,' 8%!I$.' K,;88%,&' A;?&' B3;$7' :,2.' 8;L#.79'M34.32.4J' -:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3'#3!I,4.'-3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'
%")9&()"7' AG*C%B<C' /' 2$>IG"' \/B22$/#' -*' D%BG)' L/.$G$*/*"'.%>I/&$2%#'D$*C'*C"'&"2BG*2'%L'%*C"&'2*B)$"2P'%B&'*/$G%&")'LB#.,%#'/GG%D2' L%&' *C"' /#/GM2$2' %L' *C"' )/*/' $#' *"&>2' %L' *C"' !>$*C'>%)"G'x!>$*C' "*' /G=P' 9ggoy=' V"' C/1"' #%D' "^IG/$#")' *C"' B2"' %L' *C$2'LB#.,%#' /#)' *C"' !>$*C' >%)"G' $#' %B&' &"1$2")' N$2.B22$%#' 2".,%#'Y+/<"'97P'K$#"2'7qSZ='
Disagreeing with reviewers
%"A;);&()$
X&23<&($
KA;4"(2"$
+""&'c"1$"D'
Q#B&#O#.!0'88#-7N'@:.',;-:348'$33=.7'A34'I3$"!34I:%8!8'%&'-:.'I43!3-.4' 4.F%3&'3A' -:.'F.&.O' :3B.2.4J' -:."'7%7&P-' .2,$;,-.' -:.';&-4,&8$,-.7' 4.F%3&89' @:,-' %8' 3&.' 3A' !"' #3&#.4&8' ,C3;-' -:%8'!.-:373$3F"9'
“Hidden” questions
Q#6F.5+#:! I,#+C'-N' Q:"' 7%7&R-' -:.' ,;-:348' .2,$;,-.'I3$"!34I:%8!8'%&'-:.';&-4,&8$,-.7'4.F%3&8'3A'-:.'F.&.S'
+""&'c"1$"D'
Q#B&#O#.!0'88#-7N'@:.',;-:348'$33=.7'A34'I3$"!34I:%8!8'%&'-:.'I43!3-.4' 4.F%3&'3A' -:.'F.&.O' :3B.2.4J' -:."'7%7&P-' .2,$;,-.' -:.';&-4,&8$,-.7' 4.F%3&89' @:,-' %8' 3&.' 3A' !"' #3&#.4&8' ,C3;-' -:%8'!.-:373$3F"9'
“Hidden” questions
%")9&()"k' [#' *C$2' 2*B)MP' D"' )".$)")' *%' L%.B2' %#' *C"' I&%>%*"&'&"<$%#'%L'*C$2'<"#"'6"./B2"'I&"1$%B2'2*B)$"2'x|/@$>/'"*'/G=P'7898j'3/.O2%#' "*' /G=P' 7899y' C/1"' 2C%D#' *C/*' $*2' *&/#2.&$I,%#' D/2'I/&,.BG/&GM' /`".*")=' JC$2' C/2' #%D' 6""#' .G/&$-")' $#' *C"'N$2.B22$%#'2".,%#'%L'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*'Y+/<"'9SP'K$#"'74q7oZ='
+""&'c"1$"D'
Q#B&#O#.!0'88#-7N'@:.',;-:348'$33=.7'A34'I3$"!34I:%8!8'%&'-:.'I43!3-.4' 4.F%3&'3A' -:.'F.&.O' :3B.2.4J' -:."'7%7&P-' .2,$;,-.' -:.';&-4,&8$,-.7' 4.F%3&89' @:,-' %8' 3&.' 3A' !"' #3&#.4&8' ,C3;-' -:%8'!.-:373$3F"9'
“Hidden” questions
%")9&()"k' [#' *C$2' 2*B)MP' D"' )".$)")' *%' L%.B2' %#' *C"' I&%>%*"&'&"<$%#'%L'*C$2'<"#"'6"./B2"'I&"1$%B2'2*B)$"2'x|/@$>/'"*'/G=P'7898j'3/.O2%#' "*' /G=P' 7899y' C/1"' 2C%D#' *C/*' $*2' *&/#2.&$I,%#' D/2'I/&,.BG/&GM' /`".*")=' JC$2' C/2' #%D' 6""#' .G/&$-")' $#' *C"'N$2.B22$%#'2".,%#'%L'%B&'>/#B2.&$I*'Y+/<"'9SP'K$#"'74q7oZ='
%"A;);&()$
X&23<&($
KA;4"(2"$
Summary 1#++&'-!2!
! X&>;23::6$91")"(<(>$;(?&153<&($;($6&/1$53(/)21;90$! V1;<(>$"#"2<A"$3')01320)$3(4$<0:")$! H31>"<(>$'1&34$A"1)/)$(311&L$?&2/)"4$I&/1(3:)$! M:"31:6$2&55/(;23<(>$6&/1$;4"3)$;($K(>:;),$
1#++&'-!3!
! M,&&);(>$0,"$5&)0$)/;03':"$I&/1(3:$! M&55/(;23<(>$L;0,$I&/1(3:$"4;0&1)$! c3A;>3<(>$9""1$1"A;"L$